View
1
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
I
yg eapiv
〔要
fpeyntwot so
fteh fereatesinrSs u,ha
dtu
t tess,
ih
sng
urpos
d
ep eoft ss
-maeE ht ti mma it si rSli yWr gt nLl( WL)o
h
hteacer
T
ftlesuhlteaiopnlte
ft
it
lesu
ltessu,
htll
flocoz
i :ont tuai
et ma yh gtor eter so
assroom s wi er so -
ihslng
i d tsavanages.d tvanageivlteatldegar
on
apanes
a
sng
apa
ro
I
iot
nJ nithsbeenal gt dt
nfm E lihtoJ er essofisr ea sord
-
verfuinnfsctageconhealookattes ds eo ree gon i -
-omrc
lransahrougllikindreates gs st ht
iko
lStrer
heitnseredt'ions obeami dbyt
d luaiivdnei
lufnivitos・ei
ytara
旨〕 本稿は英語教育において,目的基準準拠テス ト (
としての教師自作のクローズテス トの持つ可能性を検証したものである。この実験にお
いて,日本人大学生を対象として英語読解力を,和訳形式によるパラグラフ要約と2種
のクローズテス トによって測定した。その結果,両者の間にプラスの相関性がみられ
た。特に要約テス トと多肢選択肢形式のクローズテス トの間に,高い相関がみられた。
このことは,多肢選択肢形式のクローズテス トは読解テス トとして有効であるばかりで
なく,効果的な自学自習の方策として有効であることを示唆している。さらに,クロー
ズテス トは音読による読解練習とともに利用すれば,外国語学習の到達目標の一つであ
る予測文法を,学習者の中にはぐくむ一助となることを示しているものと言えよう。
ng nc,
)tesfreerence-iteronicr dt
OTAK
llikiasiean aswellashsb cs sofE
hinnceconhan(
xa
tenerio
i fons o,
t
tna
ic
tna
i invers
xa
lnng,
xa
itaona
tnranc
sc
tnranc
f
iv
eg
ti
its
tpe
tsag
ye ee mi re mp
en lu
eo ree Wh
Coll eE eE mi nC CEEC) dtes dsree gbyt
ites n,ptyive-tec et
-con
h
tne
tce,
lpp
iontna
l dt tsuen
xa
c
tnran
ig
ka
e
avhei tes,
nhh shoo sa ytoe
yh etot ee cee mi stwi
gteHomemaeT tessd-hinE l tvaua
xpmmar ofeeciolteatessc,i lngcoz,tir et orr
teioltealbilxporyistoe eaposs ecorr nb wee
dtuiht ss
ion!t(lI dtnro u.
teslnnsctrshTpe.yhiocC-ilpetl et e丘 ree gt
jbtesedbyano
-
tnaxaC tenehehiscalldte' rE mi
neaciodtrai ntot ha
hl We.
r[*-r J m mayw7l F] Su
pesyn
l
haragrap
hec
sadtwot
ytot
islnginnCS-lStr ree gE
' reahlnSla gtel me
galdouindrea
ioi tvat
itraccinl drareahroug
enc
t
eonr smo ntol
ho gp e?
dTkar a.ihiecnqueioT ltransa nt sdeh
lihps
dtuih
Eng
t ss
hei Ion,itronuncah ireensoo
icenc丘ro
diea nro
artes
ang
h
ion
ion
f tques
tues
hIty.
ht
itare
ivers
ich
itan
u
w
n i ntef hp yist
hall eq sontet emu
sav yo sr ingfm r gcmp ntop nt
-lransa
scihg
ic
apanes
h ireenso
h fereorl Toe.toran
ninwh ht
sanimp tr eJ eh hoo
f
es
py
l
ivj tec et ei
hcassislngti inversi Ees ve.ti l i iona unversta ninu yE
oindeailnlace
layapanes
h iaslnn
sng
csecon
roiot
dsree gemp sisp dma yonr gcmp
nfm E lihtoJ ep
bnivj tecbt tesssu, eadofpeytooprepareetobewell dfrb ht so
ivtite enotne
av
is
dt tsuen
hte
sh
yw htoe rcmp
2 天 理 大 学 学 報
-o
ver
h ireenson.
heacer
hiecnque
taf llp mi hrw t rt nt stotss gcmpoque
eE htlsteatt stsr ng
dl etwa
dh ana
sf ndh mioJ Holmtet et st ett apanesees weransa ,.
f lglSntSOe Sc tisdgt ttncuya m. oma na
hho Ob rh edttt gt nt eme er eo
is
n
in
ne ybemaeadami yc m t tt nisah yt
dea
h
ome es
tn
i itna
t
io
dan ar,
eac
ltransa
he
i
h
lec
lia
I
dt tuen
tesso,
io
he
he
ltransa
i dTtnsere.
h
idnea
in
av
free
t tonsruc
iv
d
a
tec
tex
j
it
ditu
n
as
tu.
h
d
heacer
h
ro
hroug
o
l
e
tenec
anguag
ias
asur
hparagrap
sconn
n
r
no
Thi
ca
t
ure
tess.ivj tecbu et
tuer.oerocliast tess,ivtec et obee yp essdbycmp
-
itproprae
ionlta
asivj tecbo eme
fe.iliahiesngoeseenoneedfrE lihint rd yl
-ini lcuffi tadtme
-n
-
-lracooursteasonahtaecree
h tou
icenc
t
n
islng
iotucaf
d tnersan
itnsr
lb
hT
bea etou dE hwi
eMi yoEd nadS ed st tl ec eino mmu
わrit tsracorkashetatitisr re ytomae3d sf
it tsracorthtatpens a4hd
as
ihg
h ias
ieno
l
ver
c
n
ig
llik
ieno
io
n
i tnca
iuno
ora
el
n
islng
leveop
I)
h
gt tfrTOEFL.nE hcasssinj rads rh hshoosemp sh♭
bee do ed fo lc de rhnt tonp me mmu ns sa yslace
esin
e 'l Be ro,
t
xa
are
k Fers o.
omlgtOP ea h t yaee ytos eascmp dwihscor
eses saer do et tma re mp wnsmlh
as
tr
r
iequre
he
r
houglt
killl
repar
d berad C ies ons,
nconsu
B ies
ts o,hats,ilkrasicqurl dt tsuencigleavhtaani
hoo
hTtec. sme st weh etoh ph hshoo sa eo ll ti
sc
j
-
-rans
tnranceti inversivtite eu ye
-ow
rahrougm o gcmp nt st h tnStesh ireensooindrerea,hei F tng ur.heac
-oncen
sichit tuaoiirucllilkora sf sins had es ninw ha
psochooea
ritponsoi l ionavewd tuca
etodoist
0or000,0
eu
lte
arg
iproxp
i
lo
丘irocenc
Ever ea.
St tes.
nlays
lings
h
i
ig id
d kt trauaesa
ic
h
ms no ht wh hp oreo
eCEECE mi nme steE hp yoral enmbroru
one
asure
l dt tsuenhoo satatme yy ra ma y4
eh hoo dg et sann
sc
r
itnao
i lcuous
l dt tsuen
tur
xa
c
tou a
ig
h
r
T
h s oietmo sa
tu it tsracor.df
Ites n.freerence-orm dt
iteiihtrouargrsucapereshrtome eads etet tp so hal eg pwi nalmidtmecornasurdore
span
sidTOEIC(tiL an,
leveo
)T,tes
in
icenc
krl
丘ro
tenrhteht tever a,
hP yT OEF
yaecurr ywo gtod pas it-ivj tecbu ewr
reoi itsennhteiverne, rl gcmp
ap氏etver
st ss nintha
dIar.nimb e4hd rcme yh yo nhbs
it tuao
o
iih
it tsraco
i tcae
t
lexp
h
)6
ttu
991nBrow
te
(
a
buiequrea'ioni tnca sar ds
lihitnaoxa
ol
h
ihg
tese
inn
r
c
llik
econ
io
h
i tncaloraco
teseri
h ienso or
i ll女olta
nn mmu ns saet donteCEECE mi nw et
ns saet dontes dsree gofh ycmp
CoO lraoursl teasontkathasl dt tsuen ot ea ec ein` mmu
lebinllilkrasiasini l tncucaf gb co samo
ioni tnca
ihgiunoearnemstobel dinj rh
li bonatuesituitl icqure,l dt ttsuenscig♭hrf hshoo oa sq eq eh
h lta oracol dG tnsove rane.oellitiscrepancihi Tons.tna sd ys sg sonu dt mmu
apanese.iniknht ginJ
All et shavheacerhtlls.ik
islngicaP trackestmeo eEi n( lEhtr
l dt tsuen.cigverkaebtsioi tnca nmu et nbye yh hshoo Howe
gsindrea'dt tuens
dg sofhihgroupiefispec
jbdopusnoc ebttoa tohioc
htoe ow,gtoninit tneres
Ot traneari
miexa
klls s evⅣ lmp
eihert
ievseav
i
urposes,
deionsheo
bl tocauar e
わ htaeveis
leop
lng
l
ias
idea
ra
n
dr
eac
er
h
av
lra uenc o
わi lequre eveop
d i tror esgnae
itounr nar
i,
te
0
hle
l
io
tver
ever,
t tra
fe
Sc
whhe lf me yo tw ec het ndcro yc sr rn nw rt mea
nr dfrted meto
w as10w saed dasb cv yi
hoosinac ywh eo yp
Ne ess fweh etot ho lE hfrw rp weh etod
siihT
easwellase
s
fp
nlea
ihOs n.
s
lng
el
r
indea
eaapanes
hi iecnqueslozsdit te s,expistd iproceures,
ywaso gJ el mesofE eo oss
ec ouec et nr gcasssa niga well
leas,fes orexa,luagalachavdroceureslllcozievces.it tesnas gd Wi ep eap einln g ecass mp
tahievceivff tecl iearnn'dt tuens gase ed s?W
ine.lishgt
ncreas
err
tll
hfttso
tes
lesu
tt s?Wi yi heshe et
her ewit lonalfft tnaeorsiexpermes'
n
t
ieve
is
hac
of
me
ollws
3 T tessgt Homemade-heinE l tvaua
S5temi yTnarilre2P.
lozetesangt dacintir
ion.
no ov heh he me da asmmaywrubove,itn oneisstpoybtr
itnsere
ier
miea
t
d
drer
er
I
t tesw tnaxat-erdt030u ys sa hermi m e miditftparo.sdt tuenti iinvers
tetaragrap4E hp dtec t1p hwih15ims
ed no timswasntmaeasmei l lcuous
tes
t
lozeh
d
an
o
haragraps
te
is
tres
lng
iolteehdl dTteee.
roomlolibcalpap
ms
efrt asshec
-
tes
as
o
h
is
l he a,
lng
icorn
t
er
ecaus
r
ver
xa
dr
tonsr
l
lte
fo,
aragrap
1,
btepa
iprox
te
dorssuc,
dt tuen
htr
p
lteee
telteee
in
t
dltree
t trucure
tf hes
F tary unc.
apanes
f
o
b ter
tenenc
dt tuen
dFoa o.
i
ec
tClu
ewl ktel y8hortoo yo ga ma ye rsme
ido haef st omo un nw nn ess nw sp
dmo ed yfrJ tE hsstnp es oc uc
ht Ⅳ lessl ll r15d di 9wost yc ms sw ep
h
s9hw dd hbnt etetme go es es so ep
mihth eb ntood sihed di dcrt ms re mp
flr
iexca
dacc dsewo gw
h
o
ha
i
Clu
dor
os
tei
idnepen
flir
ar
io
te
tc
hh tus,
ee
dl faso,
he
or
av
r
houg
i Ton.
t
f
t tua
itsse
lcesan,
tence
g
i
is
t
-on
-en
-
ddeirov
eiolteaivitos ecorr nb
-
-oror
-ii tonsar,tirepos
dnilaloufwltsei dbev da
diltoye
rel dnvove.llikhtaevelloikindrea'dt tuens gs rw rs si me
deirov
ustolierdt tuenswtttasi trswtl :urefias hef hahes esmpyn acc
hacわit tsracorindirov g4d sfre
ysuhayasinw tisu all
-
avelou
9w sallt ofllte15b si dort rp
l k dh rbet etan w ema sw, dt tuenhecausiase
tnsea
c
l kan
esh
h
d
i
av
htoge e
louic
dor
h hw et tmuhe es dh
1
b
haragrap
es
nln
in
ha
k
irh
tue
h
tonr
T.te
ga
r
dt ib hetsa oma essv
to4ims et dwast to yoep
hi inc dt gt tl
dn
nav
haragrap
ltwou
r
heTtes.
h
loz
b
h
haragrap repare
わtr
i dtnsere.dya
repare
n
tcu
es
ave
loz
are
h lsou
o
o
te
l
repare
iba
lteee
ln
le
do
sp df hec ta
ha
wa
an
r
rt et
dr eascmp dto4p sp df∫teSWL Moep sa
moed dims dh beenp df ec et ni dh ebee
ea all mi
dila
ecuredrereparertesiie
hTtess.
fe
lozht
dn,
ftiliibale
ninmi astomodfdt sweep dino rtos
yo ec et er dof2
tolue
in
ac
ltee
te
ra
o
h
in
ha
or
d
laspure
i l lcuousyg,
i tpropra
a
t
p
ic
uc
trson
lteee
lan
r
h
ac
to
n
o
r
dlteee
it
t
it tsracor
o
sever,
t
deirov
t
tpe,y
loz
Ive
hdoox
secon
lte
t
ms dadte丘 ew yo
yt hati ynh wodwasd dme iv gnoc satall
tthea ew dfre hb
dc ep d4d sfre hb kwh hw smaebyd ga
ma ye Y8hor9horsmemesl hwodins hawayt ttei
hel kTan.
-iproxp
boj'dt tuens
em tobed
tei l 1gorousy,rtdo ge ynhwodr 5iverindlteef
teseino oma hetrt etkdredtui
il Iure.iaateswloztbtutes
tItes.
h ireenso
h
dtec et waloz
o
asur
easar gcmp nt hec et saf tddn
h
idnea
ar ed atome etesta
l
ibla
iba
le
lre
tCluflrirdedltonihtatas ya dmoed ytop
ich tentuna
nl kanhistofllteb sadtaeidan
rewasnop
medt eag ec et
ed dr rwihl
It tes nsea.
ta
loz
t
ienun
heta
bo
lteee
lica
erw
itonssetesiefid dt sc
rasposs eclbihe
eSWLc doritonssehT
incouragnoafthet sw snte gateser tolesuhT
tesShatit tcerafles nt WLt
hh ten,Ttenence.hingitintes es
intlesu gmo
nroorwet ig dfm amoherht
econt:fltsees
f teasonsor
loz
et hihreer
medthec ti hes dwot et
wer
to
ihghsytochooeter uont eo
uhindtot ko
nhhatne nteo
weenSWLant
iol tec
l
fe
ibaler
t
amoer eo
Wih t srhi
teaeac;hparagraps
thev dr
hhd25i
ntidila ya
adt tuenhl k Tans.htllif eb es sh
allt toge
d dtaope.
-
-
drecenhitcalup
ih
o
ha
lu
ln
u
lteedwo dntd eteoep
waso yt
assmedt tt smu
s
dn
tl k Ian.
iasees
lte
hk
o
lure
it tsracor
loulozpyhicoc-ilpetl
gd stocmp etheb wa
et ec ew ds ymaetet te ra
irfduredbyt no moheb mecauselbaor'dt tuenses
enacl dIou.indeabtexearlboyaj etol het ga nfttn t yr heess
hitevalu
ten
t
in
i
k
hati
h bere
i flanngu
i ton,tza
me nt wo dall et
yma gi
sochoo
Sthe
heto et ewr risc stob das eo yint
softet tl et maet sh eap mayf
f d dreunanc
rir
ens
av
liu
tesd
i dionvnce,
h 一eacerh
tei
Tanguage.
ht tess,
arge
flcoz
h
ilapar
dt tsuen
t
天 理 大 学 学 報
heyti ;ontunc
ioni tvat
yioi tvat
hie
dt tuens
dc ib etoacc gtes gade gt rmo
rt nme gt ra micp m a gtes mo nb
h inancn
h
nn
Riince asn.feror
hin
dcae
l teera
hieiasurn
tutonr
ha
h lsou
htra e
ry
tess
da
hosen
u
loz
oz
♭
t
l
Bto.
ih
repare
l kan
r
TheEx ime
oz
ht
tn
6J eu ys
4E lihp
hl aragrapng
d2p nf s(Cl ndB) hceAatet eteswr ga sweec rc
l tue
4d sf hb shre wa
leb obett uwo ms ec
Asap ef mi 4E hp sweep dfrsmma
per
is
lozo
d25b kimsadC eAg enoc satall ill eb sw eCl eBhof
dt tuens
3.
ion,
hose
av
t
r
loz
i invers
tnai lnaexa
s
lan
n
apanes
ng
haragrap
ac
htor
te
o
2t:ecs
tar
n
lan
it tsracor
jSbu
itni
ha
duc
rolouozdt tCl dpha eBw -
it.
tessh f laragrapsorcozWLad2p etnSforharagraps
lan-'dt tuens
o-ioltacos 汀e nc
-e6.iolteatatosurrecausozentespec
ee
oztew
n
io
WLadCleBr
ltrea
S
nS dCl 0rnb f0WLa Ab ewhewea ac noen orr
-
-
-
ozo
h
d tope
l tvaua
ha
lu
ec
icorn
iscusson
m f hb kt nC eA Acc ds dfrCl eAre ew gwasa
ilteran tvenu
or
n
n
l
t
btepa
tlsu
ro
.loz
4.
wasftt tt swo dc yp moeade allye etes
TheRe sa dDi
lan
ih
ac
ha
fro o
le
guag
'
paperisht
nte100.<p6( )b wee
orhboutiinfeinhtny gd ea ttec
snitanebiolteaigucoznnSWLadCl eBs hahh corr nwaso daditi
ionltea
Fromheteharetacors
g
languag
ih
f
a
0
lxpor
har
he
r
tur
hert
in
hta
lta
tans
itsmu gtof re ewhtt smihts
me eaemoet n8% o euef ss db weent m.
ivtipos ecorr
nteioltaollbenoc汀e nb wee
tesspyozhah iesztpoy et tCl eBt et
asthitecnquesome
htadeionseelurpnsnsnos gmattrWhnwec rw
hel tvaua
i
pyozSt tess.fpeytoasuretilib yisme nb ht so ndCl eBt ee etdi WLa
w atatme ishT.
hte
umhde∫.wassmall allyten
)2(
htaereeh ltsouits,lesugr dbermemb dt
'
fitsecono
teifangedgiveasmallrr eo
:msterilcaitstta
nSpearioltaohert ewasac汀e n( ma
9.haan,
a
oz
tasbll・Iti lvey
dCl eA dt tof0
wi etooh ytosya
lof
tesiolt transai lonatidtra nt
gc et wi ed ussdinmoed nteltaerhiliteareiscblltesslozinkta
h ieszetpoy
nilear'dt tuens
ihgihTtges.ug sh
ahetra;b d danone
rnullh
rwecnh
-iscourseran,
gra
f blryvocaua gra,deggkn owl eo mma dd
mma "f troexpecancy.
tIorktochooefm.s
nnSWLa
tincnCl eAs eiozhta
htahsotesshtfo et wedt
herhah iestpoy st tt ewi
rtnsatnslibalres ei mme sSWLo
h
isn
fte
ro
uht
dtn prouce
)1(i :onstta
dp mi
enmbro
te100. )b wee
uha
h ireenso
a
ldoncu
o
oz
a
idnea
n
b
iht
S
ll
ur
swecnc et to
WLadCl eBcnbea
wi ea
er gcmp ns ihllT.ik si
" a
m a:tforT tes
<p6.o)f0 0(Bi tcenfe
ta
ixper
inkor
ea
w'
d tespons
h heeoug
languag
dt tsuens
A
corr owh
lt h t me
tslresuer
ty.iivtrea
bteB tans u.allyme wee
tyiliibal
sc)3791(erOll all
telteeeleas
i
t
i flanngu
av
kaers
h ltessou
es
ttan
loz
ites
lly,ua
ht
a
f
.
t
o
lresu
ha
las
tes
is
r
i
h
te
n
w
ha
av
h lsou
lteee
ixper
dre
t tes
ber
h
h
t
i
t
sh etolmi et tt
dbemoet nloi et sme obeme ns
ed dims osmallUs ac et dh ea t50d dims
no rt ttet scnbes
ee me Ne
lteresu s
Re
h
41..
T
-ver
fioi tcalep no
.ericaitstta lt ms
ensihi flIanngu.icitstta allyme nt ss er
Canlfi ign tinskdreiteravtisimp eino rtomaeits
4
5
orpymu et efhiocC-ilpetl
gteHomemaeT tessd-hinE l tvaua
ess ewr ri do eu esso et soit sc
dl mlgp
ftesflcozflseunhtfionvnce
urposes.n
e
ea
ht,hlet
ion,tna
ty.iivj tec
fI.
tnasureivj tec eme me
ish
he
tes.
asur
indea
s
ilatnois
tme etmu
tge Ot ei av dr gth ierwslse.inhto
Tapan.ioltransahrouggcmp nhso nbeenme dt ht ninJasure氏eah ireensooinR dea
heitcaodnlibalellbear ei roft
inhto gless
darienihourseitioltransaytou dtet st nslln sadd shhuTtex.hd tnersantilib
-liibaledr
-
m
dt tuens.
l
roupiifpeciteraolbtaiuylonm - dt sadntawass efrc ns cg sofstes
ti he rcassroo
freerence
ts,ha
no
T
ievce.intes
dweh eadsa
lt t tsances ransa,
oq na
fseulacaintir
tiin
u
fe
io
av
io
tuesn
n
ginLlh lt gdnorsmmaywr sap easau
d ten -
ive
r
xa
tespyivj tecb
eCEECE mi
ete t saeall
-
tesivt tne agrhesearcersasa etn i
ircumhesdeieve.hcivj tec etoa Un rt ec
i itnanheacehooi lcuotsodiff tajbfrtet rtoma
j tecbivtlia og eO
-her
2Va
et scnbeme nt yaeaccmp db
yissmpywhtt yp ttome
ianeorhehe
urpor
i flannguw
heal
ates
itidi
Languag
laVty.
4.
i
bi iltnannliaperesnttos emayt tp swhema gOcori lcuffi
ntidilayv ya
de
itnse
t
dnkiasec
obema
llbemuhe rtomaeadami ra
oetilibl iexil Fteras. yisakyt
scorehtfecurelllastiliibale ywi obes di es ri
-nlasurn059 sasame gl
tu0or40s
nrgmoeadninhtasureno,
).379esng
lar
kpeaer
hi
iv
layor
taoage
d leveope
rostilidbeaa
dbyT ntee y1
yofp epass sfrn es sofE lih(011r1
toindea'dt tuen h i isr gcmpreenson,
bi iltnanntCluflrdfrted yinma gOihoiiczetir
dF teare ur.susitisu allyf
ioeh st tt nwiltransahah iestpoy
omindeaivj techi becnqueo, er gc
teserslleiknsdu dt willf
hion
hes
tna
ha
xa
er
uc
toe
ilicave
dtnrouce
s
no rtod wiht scit w or
tC I.
nt sh ebeeni dins he mi sast
ih
Ei OEF dTOEI mutben dh et tt eo
tlea
av
L an,
ions.
tes
dre
l tevaua
h ipreenso
k Ten,
I
3say, ,lindeaf dt tsuenenutleaWed wihasmall mbro sinar gcassion,it tsua
uItess.freerence- dt no
illdl nf tietas sn
bo
rbllilterastex
tenence
itac,
htasoere
h Ieacer.
ltransae
e
lcorn
anguag
h ltsou
e
iitv
ire,
k
tecj
db dtmb wi edmetme ma emomo er
yins gt ds
tCluflri
tss2:oitrit ten al iporn5.
ing.t tes
Ex gthePo l Me sofCl eTe
fidnipecahoshahtefo mt nt es lk soma
iolt transaf nt
tessorSWLt sa
nat tneres
tt tonras
nro
s
te
iicenc
tes
inc
fro
loz
9
h
anguag
h
n
Oiirgn
h ien,
ioreg
tsr
T
o
allytec et wa
umetofr
nte1 Siti dag wlgi mogr
ff nl ep ylnc Od
t tespurporslozhassui ewhttec et
ewitutn anasurePiton-i tscree me me dq eaf
Ity n.iliibalrellas
ieronrlibalenilabtoymayn ev dadr eascit
stidiltsvaei yawe
et tisme ttome etes
ytocmp dtet dn
h
texan
asur
h
an
hreenot
es
il
ht
bia
iltonroversahasti beenac
nievced eaivj tecbu
bn1eaing-heacet mlgO
ns dee tisd
rall nisas
di,
iolt transa,
Iconng n.
fte
i
A
ntidilt tesvab tou yadr
eisb dont
wheithso nbeenc
hase
fte
sa
a
'
hitecnqu
dt tsuen
li
Itess.ivj tecb et twi
ganinhteac
t
toutes
tese
io
f
n
lt transa
itn
s
oadt dwiho
nt
uccessul
07
tyidil
nxad trerd tonuce
tnsixper
hav
bto
tns
loregon
:asure
iexper
hest
t
me ebeenc dino oe mi
ef ge me
ome hp
eisherT
hesearctresenehavts ebeenp dbyr -
iveff teecneslozhieivitos ev w oftec et tasa
lesuesearcitegavnivitos eadn er hr
avordencivlaanch
tnsr
tner
it tesn
sad'eb eofe ef sap
gi ume toaasureteslozhthtagener)I.19 tisg allyareedt ec et me sn9Ftoo('tn s1
6 天 理 大 学 学 報
yehwasrerrdtobfeichtyw,ilibrl es llbtani el eaanguagivt tnegrauikanguagi lcuatpar
on
dr.
liaallyd ndne yc
hlpup
ngageow di
ns ytewo
he
hte "s
-
ios-
anguage
Sl,
irs'ne
l na
ritiso sf tl
dn
loze
hange
d dtnersan
ve
n
ow
tes
ir
ex
is
a
a
n
n
tes
l
h
k
lep
b
io
d
ls
h lou
ea
a
i tscre
drouc
f一e
he
ear
ha
n
a
h
ng.
hiecnque
Ttes.
ea
bov
ion
ac grma ts
e
he
ife
t
i
ra nO et el nercnmaeh nc
or
h Baragrap.
itera
sa mebya nd nadcnc
k ir,
f sd da ndt ohti obt ta stexpecancnerag ro gapmma ya ne ea
iel dbet rtot etearnnga rs ea ou
iht ko dt dtet tt rt et toonw ro sa nr ra
ei od gh sdnt ytew sayp ep ys ecnp easma sah
du el risc nofhsorhrl ml m eSl maet scnbec
ltransa
e
lac
earne
h
in
n
ho
franse
lga
t
dor
ldoncu
ra
hrougex
lear
iv
h
ove
t tes
h
isre
t
t
t
hesint
i dngan,
Hed Sag mmarO yaf texpecanc
i dngrea,i kngspea,
ra
i d dtngunersan,
lerne
iknhtorllsi
-e
-or
lta
i 一onscous
ta
iitex,
r
learnn
ht
ea
f
h
da sl tl ml etso nasn ess no sav
Ites.
fheh td sl SWhet otsa
ecaus
i
io
inconscouhTay.
i lnconscous
ex
ea O l d tng rareprouc,
ka
taen
on
a
ih
tca
Tary,
ltse
b taou.
ec
loz
es
ec et nbed eu yb etel mesc
h
ht
i
essi tt ti st en su gl
氏trece e
bou
l sall Hedtetesozec
d ftproucoby-
m
ht ion.i tza
ks
ay.
tex
versltnised tverhes
e
cr
u
o
av
l dou.
her
indea
apal
ea
yinJ nt eh ebeenanmbro ht booR tecen
el nedbyr ga Wecmea osst ea me samote yd
as
n
Ies.
lear
av
l
f
anguag
hiecnqu
anguage
honore
ncourage
-
ioreg
iis
erse
lou
r
I.
h
indea
r
leop
he
e
n
iero
ic
failrca
j
i isguse
hanguagesw
i
o
h
ac
ob
ih
t
T scmme
isnc
co
leg
eteMeiP dw nr ga dwase dinl ecass th
meb kd dinanwdess nf atme dt eo nigf
nl hmayp ew oaev dinf nl smayh ee
dehavears0harsertresen whtesdembarrass ep itra moet n10y epass
-or
-ixper
0
tnsrn1eaing-hteacfleruow mlgi u-
0harわrounnoa氏eionit tarnhmedtotes gp ta rr miga dfrmoet n1
R tegensi HceP tren:ersey all
-ibtus
ngea
es
ye
anguagi1 se ew eg ya el
wa ap essofb
af nl
f texpecanc
Co l incuson
iropn
si ndl mlyt rogo mmara
女
lil l xpanscear
ni gfnt ersoeo rp sg
h
6.
tf
is
he
in
h
t
kor
T3).
h
1
anguage.
h
1:
e
3
l
71
roc
(''
ireg
ii 9r ng
txac
わ
t
i
y,
w
T
or
laeslozdthatt et mpnthec ti
i :encyClror As
・ih kose
'
toivd tnprouclehavtnooes etoryonu er ememor
islngわtnised taverf me sfrE
ittessnlozeC).2
6.33-313p.)p,3(1L L i 4age eangu arnng.i ?ons
fterarh t eoig wodr w,o
Fasur
Ne.
ivt tnegra
Panguage rogra
atesasloz).1991(.
ginL ms wJ
nleC et ni eme eofELp
heheg rof texpecancra hgt tmma yw eindliu
wirtninlteeyd gaynhwodathsolitraribr
earhts,hati el nei Tes.iitvtc
eusuhtaww
h iaszedbeemph lou
htorrepareallylnO obep dftdrerr
titac
Tk Tk) oyo oy..hkougoG ia- oS
1sontcorenan,htaTen o,owJD lona."Jr dB nT Di dVi W.Ma ( 79
K itaseuγTodihh haushhuga).6991h (uso. Ch oG uS oY 0(
tnatenranceexalloegeaysoforttue ess nc mi
)asa" mmaro "f texpecancy.gra3791Oll (
me mu gthd linerynh icans
er
ifehc
・Whitversaon
et
ferences
neegta
teu
tnos
av
loz
lli,it
dence.
Syears.
ttn,
Weh er
ti tooletobina wwihanwp
me hec et
Re
h dan,ttesa
6991D (s .me inT) tes,
htlitn
r
B Jrown a,
F SndaStoos a,
Jher on, .
Momb
Oll W.
As
乙earnngLe anguag.feroritnav-ondn ep nc ・ma eL 22
asure.tt ymehe
nivN: tse ame ea
haiicencyafroanguagfseconteslozC). et so dl ep ndw
itenahia an,
5.1
T
-
hs
1p.)p,
Jher on, ,
Eng
1(
li , dV
Oll W. 3791J (r, .
7
-
eHomemaeT
w:s
611
)( Iss sinL eT gR Mass ett Nehacusley,
tess
h Researc ow.
d-
intesanguag
18.
ue).3819
hgtinE l tvaua
01p.)p.(13iL L 2anguage earnng.
uaru. ′
-
-h Tou o,k iause
-
e-guagS) econ.9819my( d血n eR
dnhonsotKie(n. hJ na
yO
TihkasuaTkt :en oyo.ji
ionar
ia
racintesL) anguag.6919r( eT ginP
kacforics.i itngusdL 0Ⅹ d:BlielpApf-
tesuengnG oT oSisseJ).
).rti iversfor:fdorgadD gU I eT 0Ⅹ 0Ⅹ dUn yPesstess.languagルsel ieueopnnD i iesgnni:cet
りihsackkougia oRi Ma)G.100
n. manL ndAd nS lmePa.iraF a.lyeB hac(Tihkasuak :yo
hhoaan
)
rHe tW.ndEl aS
hMe 0Ⅹ 0Ⅹ dUn yPessr
a
ti ivers
brer
for
ige
:
Sle
fdor
Tihk (asuan.
hdos.t
Tk :oyo
searc
0002dR hH r( )(trans..h hraseT.dlanopianjen
oK uDkiyoukkoug)Gia,9919)(trans..
DitcicE l d) ncycope.
Mo Ho M. dK Nano,an,i,hsAta,.,iri Tya,.,T hsuc 2)(trams.(.
xpenAp di
C oZe B
24
24
23
23
22
22
22
21
WL CleA 2
3
oz
2
13
2
0
7
2
9
9
U8
8
8
8
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
6
5
5
5
5
10
S
Q
1
2
3
21
20
2
6
2
1 19
18
18
18
17
7
6
3
7
4
9
2
1
17
17
15
15
14
14
14
02
8
4
4
14
14
10
3 1
1
1
3
6
7
4
1
1
1
1
)( 8919des.
1
14
3
2
0
0
6
6
5
5
3
2
2
1
8
7
7
1
0
ih )sers.lPbu
Oll Ed
汀yHo
Ok Hi o(
HenJ n(
ell
mo
.
use.
honso
Jh J (er on r, , .
de
le
K,
bu
w
a,
toO
1
5
9
8
4
5
taaDP lersona
j tecSbu
6
7
8
0
9
1
1
2
3
4
5
1
1
1
1
1 61
1 7
8
9
0
1
2
1
1
2
2
2 32
0
8
3
5
4
2
4
5 6
2
2
2 8
天 理 大 学 学 報
No :
ema mums rSfcoreo
tes
ixhT WLwaslOandfO ,andBwerAlozeCor e25a 5rnd2 i lveytespec
Recommended