View
230
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
1/53
UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS IN
MEASUREMENT(Review of Stat ist ical Aspects in Engineering Measurement)
Prof. Dr. Ir. Harinaldi, M.EngDepartment of Mechanical Engineering
Faculty of Engineering, University of Indonesia
App l ied Flow Measurement and Visual izat ion Lecture Module
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
2/53
PART 1
Introduction
and Under lying Concepts
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
3/53
Uncertainty Analysis What it is
There is no such thing as a perfect
measurements. All measurements of a variablecontain inaccuracies.
The analysis of the uncertainties in
experimental measurements and results is a
powerful tool, particularly when it is used inthe planning and design of experiments
Although it may be possible to decrease an
uncertainty by improved experimental method
or the careful use of statistical technique to
reduce the uncertainty, it can never be
eliminated
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
4/53
Issues of Analysis
Systematic and Random Uncertainties
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
5/53
Issues of Analysis
Systematic Uncertainties
Offset uncertainty
Clearly there is a problem here:
the boiling point of water should be very close to 100.0o
C while the melting point should be very close to 0.0o
C There is an offset uncertainty with the temperature
measuring system of about 7.5 oC
Possible causes are inherent to measurement device
(such as low battery, malfunctioning digital meter,
incorrect type of thermocouple, etc)
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
6/53
Issues of Analysis
Systematic Uncertainties
Gain uncertainty
(mb - mc) versus mc
0.00
0.20
0.40
0.60
0.80
1.00
1.20
1.40
1.60
0.00 20.00 40.00 60.00 80.00 100.00 120.00
mc (g)
mb-m
c
(g)
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
7/53
Issues of Analysis
Random Uncertainties
Random uncertainties produce scatter in observedvalues.
The cause :
o limitation in the scale of the instrument
resolution uncertainty due to rounding up of
measured valueo reading uncertainty
o random uncertainty due to environmental factor
(electrical interference, vibration, power supply
fluctuation, Brownian motion of air molecule,background radiation, noise, etc)
Use statistical technique to get an estimate of the
probable uncertainty and to allow us to calculate the
effect of combining uncertainties
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
8/53
Issues of Analysis
True Value, Accuracy and Precision
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
9/53
Statistical Basics on Uncertainty
Data
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
10/53
Statistical Basics on Uncertainty
Sample and Population
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
11/53
Statistical Basics on Uncertainty
Frequency Distribution
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
12/53
Statistical Basics on Uncertainty
Histogram and Probability Distribution
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
13/53
Statistical Basics on Uncertainty
Mean and Standard Deviation
Sample Population
Mean
Standard
Deviation
Variance = (Standard Deviation)2
Variance
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
14/53
Statistical Basics on Uncertainty
Standard Error (of the Mean)
If standard deviation of population (x)of is known :
In a sampling with nrepeated measurement (sampling
size = n), the standard error is determined as:
StandardError =
If standard deviation of population of is unknown, thenit is estimated from standard deviation of sample (sx)
for infinite population
For finite population
with size of N
Standard
Error = or
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
15/53
Statistical Basics on Uncertainty
Gaussian (Normal) Distribution Function
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
16/53
Statistical Basics on Uncertainty
Probability of Gaussian Distribution
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
17/53
Statistical Basics on Uncertainty
Standard Gaussian Distribution
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
18/53
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
19/53
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
20/53
PART 2
Determining Measurement
Uncertainty
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
21/53
Data Handling Rejection of Outliers
Rejection of outliers is more acceptable in areas of
practice where the underlying model of the process
being measured and the usual distribution of
measurement error are confidently known
You want some way to identify what observations in
your data set need closer study. It's not appropriate to
simply throw away or delete an observation; you must
keep it around to look at later. The picture is as follows.
Filtering Process (Selection and Rejection of Data)
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
22/53
Data Handling Rejection of Outliers
Filtering Process (Selection and Rejection of Data)A sensitive subject and one that can bring out
strong feeling amongst experimenters:o One argue : All data are equal no
circumstances in which the rejection of
data can be justified
o Another argue : there as those that know
that a set of data is spurious and reject it
without a second thought
Expert judgment confidence levelStatistical test :
o Chauvenets criterion P = 11/(2n)
o Peirces criterion
o - riterion = 2, 3,
http://localhost/var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/chauvenetscriterion.pdfhttp://localhost/var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/chauvenetscriterion.pdf8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
23/53
Data Handling Rejection of Outliers
Chauvenets criterion
Wide acceptance method which defines an acceptable
scatter around the mean value from a given sample of
n readings from the same parent population
All points should be retained that fall within a band
around the mean value that corresponds to a
probability of 11/(2n)
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
24/53
Data Handling Rejection of Outliers
Chauvenets criterion
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
25/53
Dealing with Uncertainty
Quoting the Uncertainty
After making repeated measurement of aquantity, there are four important steps to take in
quoting the value of the quantity:
1. Calculate the mean of the measured values2. Calculate the uncertainty in the quantity,
making clear the method used. Round the
uncertainty to one significant figure (or two if
the first figure is a 1)3. Quote the mean and uncertainty to the
appropriate number of figures
4. State the units of the quantity
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
26/53
Dealing with Uncertainty
Uncertainty statement
Absolute uncertainty
o With unit of the quantity
)of(unit XUX x
Fractional uncertaintyo no unit
X
UXyuncertaintfractional
Percentage uncertainty
o no unit
%100yuncertaintpercentage
X
UX
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
27/53
Determining Uncertainty Single
Measurement
If only one measurement is made, the uncertainty
is generally determined from the instrument
resolution of reading scale (resolution
uncertainty)
Uncertainty = half of the smallest resolution of reading
Example :
A length of a stick is measured with a rule with resolutionof reading scale 1 mm. The reading is 361 mm, then the
length should be quoted as:
L = (361.0 0.5) (mm)
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
28/53
Determining Uncertainty Repeated
Measurement of Single Quantity
Simple Method - 1
n
XX minmax
tmeasuremenofnumber
rangemeaninyuncertaint
Example:
)/(8.341mean smc
(m/s)75.3385.345range cR
(m/s)875.08/7yuncertaint cU
(m/s)100.0093.418
(m/s)9.08.341
2
c
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
29/53
Determining Uncertainty Repeated
Measurement of Single Quantity
Simple Method - 2
Example:
)/(8.341mean smc
4.11
8.3417.342...8.3414.3428.3415.341deviationTotal
cci
425.18/4.11deviationMeanyUncertaint
(m/s)100.0143.418
(m/s)4.18.341
2
c
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
30/53
Determining Uncertainty Repeated
Measurement of Single Quantity
Statistical Approach to variability in data
meantheoferrortandardmeaninyuncertaint s
n
sxx xxxx kUU limitsconfidence
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
31/53
Determining Uncertainty Repeated
Measurement of Single Quantity
(s)006.050
043.0mean,theoferrorStandard
(s)043.0deviation,Standard
(s)604.0Mean,
t
ts
t
With 95 % level of confidence : (s)012.02 ttU
Then : (s)012.0604.0 t
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
32/53
Combining Uncertainty Uncertainty
Propagation
An experiment may require the determination of several
quantities which are later to be inserted into an equation.
The uncertainties in the measured quantities combine to
give an uncertainty of the calculated value
The combination of these uncertainties is sometimes called
the propagation of uncertainty or error propagation
V
m
measured quantity
with uncertainty
measured quantity
with uncertainty
calculated quantity
with propagation ofuncertainty
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
33/53
Combining Uncertainty Simple Method
Most straightforward method and requires only simple
arithmetic.
Each quantity in the formula is modified by an amount equalto the uncertainty in the quantity to produce the largest
value and the smallest value
Example :
In an electrical experiment, the current through a resistor wasfound to be (2.5 0.1) mA and the voltage across the resistor
(5.5 0.3) V. Determine the resistance of the resistor Rand the
uncertainty UR !
1020.2A102.5
V5.5 33-I
V
R
1042.2A102.4
V8.5 33-max
R
1000.2A102.6
V2.5 33-min
R
10210.02
3minmax RR
102.02.2 3R
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
34/53
Combining Uncertainty Partial
Differentiation
Based on differentiation of
function of several variables
b
b
Va
a
VV
baVV
),(
baV Ub
VU
a
VU
bbVa
aVV
Uncertainty propagation:
Properties:
baVbaV
baVbaV
b
b
a
a
V
VabV
b
b
a
a
V
VbaV
/
Sum:
Difference:
Product:
Quotient:
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
35/53
Combining Uncertainty Partial
Differentiation
Example :
The temperature of (3.0 0.2) x 10-1kg of water is raised by (5.50.5) oC by heating element placed in the water. Calculate the
amount of heat transferred to the water to cause this
temperature rise !
J1088.4
)(0.5)(0.3)(4186)(0.02)(4186)(5.5
and
J6907)5.5)()(4186(0.3
mcUUcU
mcQcmQ
UQ
Um
QU
mcQ
mQ
mQ
The value of c = 4186 J kg-1oC-1
is assumed to be constant(neglecting its uncertainty)
J101.19.6 3Q
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
36/53
Combining Uncertainty Statistical
Approach
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
),(
baV
baV
b
V
a
V
b
V
a
V
baVV
Taking uncertainty of the mean to relate to standard error of
the mean and partial differential principle
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
37/53
Uncertainty in Linear Fitting of X Y Data
Least Square Method in Linear Fitting
22ii
iiii
xxn
yxyxnm
22
2
ii
iiiii
xxn
yxxyxc
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
38/53
Uncertainty in Linear Fitting of X Y Data
In reality for each value of x, the corresponding y
has some uncertainty
contribute to the uncertainty of m and c
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
39/53
Uncertainty in Linear Fitting of X Y Data
Uncertainty of m
22
ii
m
xxn
n
Uncertainty of c
22
2
ii
i
m
xxn
x
where
2
2
1
cmxy
n ii
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
40/53
PART 3
More on Measurement Uncertainty
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
41/53
General Uncertainty Analysis
Consider a general case in which an experimental result, r, is
a function of Jmeasured variable Xi
JXXXrr ,...,, 21
Then, the uncertainty in the result is given by :
2
1
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
1
2 ...21 i
J
i i
X
J
XXr UX
rU
X
rU
X
rU
X
rU
J
iX
i
i
XUX
r
ivariablemeasuredin theyuncertaint
tcoefficienysensitivitabsolute
Note : all absolute uncertainties (UX) should be expressed with
the same level of confidence
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
42/53
General Uncertainty Analysis
Nondimensionalized forms:
222
2
2
2
2
2
1
2
1
12
2
...21
j
X
j
jXXr
X
U
Xr
r
X
X
U
Xr
rX
X
U
Xr
rX
rU j
Note :factorionmagnificatyuncertaint
i
i
i UMFX
r
r
X
oncontributipercentageyuncertaint12
22
UPC
rU
X
U
X
r
r
X
r
i
X
j
i i
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
43/53
General Uncertainty Analysis
Example:
A pressurized air tank is nominally at ambient temperature (25 oC).
Using ideal gas law, how accurately can the density be determinedif the temperature is measured with an uncertainty of 2 oC and the
tank pressure is measured with a relative uncertainty of 1%?
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
44/53
General Uncertainty Analysis
Uncertainty analysis:
222
2222
2
2
22
22222
zeroisthatassuming
1
1
1
,,
T
U
p
UU
UT
U
R
U
p
UU
RT
p
RT
pT
T
T
RT
p
TR
pR
R
R
RT
p
p
p
T
U
T
T
R
U
R
R
p
U
p
pU
TRpRTp
Tp
RTRp
TRp
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
45/53
General Uncertainty Analysis
Uncertainty analysis:
%2.1012.0)298/2(01.0
01.0
298
2
2982732522
22
2
UU
pU
T
U
KTKCU
p
T
o
T
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
46/53
Detailed Uncertainty Analysis
X1
B1,P1
X2
B2,P2
Xj
Bj,Pj
1 2 j.
.
r=r(X1,X2, , Xj)
r
Br,Pr
Elemental error sources
Individual measurement system
Measurement of individual
variables
Equation of result
Experimental result
B = b ias (systemat ic uncerta inty)
P = precis ion (random) u ncerta inty
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
47/53
Detailed Uncertainty Analysis
The uncertainty in the result is:
222
rrr PBU
Systematic (bias) uncertainty:
1
1 11
222 2J
i
J
ik
ikki
J
i
iir BBB
J
i
iir PP
1
222
Precision (random) uncertainty:
Correlated systematic
uncertainty
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
48/53
Systematic Uncertainty
Systematic error can be determined and eliminated by
calibration on ly to a certain degree(A certain bias will
remain in the output of the instrument that is calibrated) In the design phase of an experiment, estimate of systematic
uncertainty may be based on manufacturers specifications,
analytical estimates and previous experience
As the experiment progress, the estimate can be updated by
considering the sources of elemental error:o Calibration error: some bias always remains as a result
of calibration since no standard is perfect and no
calibration process is perfect
o Data acquisition error: there are potential biases due to
environmental and installation effects on the transduceras well as the biases in the system that acquires,
conditions and stores the output of the transducer
o Data reduction errors: biases arise due to replacing data
with a curve fit, computational resolution and so on
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
49/53
Random Uncertainty Analysis
Random uncertainty can be determined with various ways
depending on particular experiment:
o Previous experience of others using the same/similartype of apparatus/instrument
o Previous measurement results using the same
apparatus/instrument
o Make repeated measurement
When making repeated measurement, care should be takento the time frame that required to make the measurement:
o Data sets should be acquired over a time period that is
large relative to the time scale of the factors that have a
significant influence on the data and that contribute to
the random errorso Be careful of using a data acquisition system
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
50/53
Random Uncertainty Analysis
t
Time, t
Y
Failure to determine random
uncertainty due to inappropriate
data acquisition
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
51/53
Some Detail Approach/Guidelines
Abernethy approach (1970-1980):
o Adapted in SAE, ISA, JANNAF, NRC, USAF, NATO
estimateconfidence99%for
estimateconfidence95%for2/1
22
rrADD
rrRSS
tSBU
tSBU
Coleman and Steele approach (1989 renewed 1998):
o Adapted in AIAA, AGARD, ANSI/ASME222
rrr PBU
1
1 11
222 2J
i
J
ik
kiikki
J
i
iir BBBB
1
1 11
222 2J
i
J
ik
kiSikki
J
i
iir PPPP
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
52/53
Some Detail Approach/Guidelines
ISO Guide approach (1993):
o Adapted by BIPM, IEC, IFCC, IUPAC, IUPAP, IOLM
oUsing a standard uncertaintyo Instead of categorizing uncertainty as systematic and
random, the standard uncertaintyvalues are divided
into type A standard uncertainty and type B standard
uncertainty
o Type A uncertainties are those evaluated by thestatistical analysis of series of observations
o Type B uncertainties are those evaluated by means
other than the statistical analysis of series of
observations
NIST Approach (1994):o Use expanded uncertainty Uto report of all NIST
measurement other than those for which Uchas
traditionally been employed
o The value of k= 2 should be used. The values of kother
than 2 are only to be used for specific application
8/11/2019 LM01-Aspek Statistik Pengukuran-Analisis Ketidakpastian
53/53
References
[1] Montgomery, D.C., & Runger, G.C, Appl ied Statistics and Probabil i ty for Engineers 3rd
Ed., John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York, (2003)
[2] Harinaldi, Prinsip-pr insip Statistik Untuk Tekni k dan Sains, Erlangga, (2005)
[3] Kirkup, L, Experimental Method: An I ntroduction to the Analysis and Presentation of
Data, John Wiley and Sons, Australia, Ltd., Queensland, (1994)
[4] Coleman, H.W and Steele, W.G., Exper imentation and Uncertainty Analysis for Engineer
2ndEd., John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York, (1999)
[5] Doebelin, E.O, Engineer ing Experimentation, Plann ing Execution, Reporting, McGraw-
Hill Book Co., New York, (1995)
Recommended