Market Impacts of Japanese Rice Policies With and Without ...€¦ ·...

Preview:

Citation preview

�� �� ��

������ ����������

����������

�!"#$�%&'(')$*�

+,-.� �/�0�1�2�

-�.� �34556� 7894:;<5�

�������

������ ��������������������

��������� �������

��������������� �

� !"#$%&'()*+,-./012&*+34156789:��31!

"#1()*+$6&';<=>?@ABCDE<FG*HIJKLMNO=E

<FPQHIJKLMN1R?S&TOUV.WVUXY9:()Z[\]^_

TO[`&O^_abc1��/0?de^_fge"hVi'&_jk;lm

$%&'-no$pqA?rsiCtu:Ti$v_5w1xyz{|1}7T

iV1#~1()*+?G��i_U��UO&���?��G�_f � ����������:F��������O�si_Njk;lm1ge1

����$%&')+��[��^_Ch1���$�^_u�?J B:()

$¡^_��1��$¢U�5£oX¤¥?¦§¨78_TO?©ªiCfT1

u�7,:«¬o­�$6&',®¯1lm$°±Vi'&_.11:²#,8

V³_´µ1¶·¸I¹[º»BXc',XVX&TO[Ah'&_fT1¼8

V³_´µ1¶·¸I¹½$,:¾¿ÀI:¶·Á�:ÂB'Ek<F#Zxy

Ã+N?ÄÅi_fT1¼8V³_´µ1½O&�ÆÇÈ?ÉÊ78_fÂiO

&�1.:T1ÆÇÈ,:¶·¸I¹1º»[ËÌÍ�:ÅC¾¿ÀI:¶·Á

�:ÂB'Ek<[¡ÎOB'&XUÏCTiÅ71jk;���?ÐѪi_

TO1ÎÒÓUV78_fÅCT1u�7,:�ÔÕ1Ö×$.OØ&'ÙÚ[

3ÛB:Ü�ÔÙÚv9.S�ÔÙÚ1�ÔÕ1Ý�Þßà[��c^_v�á

âØã'&_fT1TO.:�ÔÕ1Ö×7äå^_TO1XUÏCTiÅ71

jk;���1ÐÑ78_fBUBX?V:pB&u�1Þ7:²#,:5A1

¼æ�çèéê½ÙÚ$6&'S&�ÔÕ[ë�^_Ch:Ti[��ËÌUV

ìí^_TO?îhVi'&_fªV$:#ï��$6&',:u�ðñ1ðò

7,:óôEF��¡Î1#ï��uLMN$6&'ÙÚå1õö[÷ã:-.

xyøùoX´µ1#ï��[�à$��^_v�áâØã'&_fT1TO.:

#ï��[��^_Ch1ú�û�ü�ýOB'ÙÚå7Xcþ���1óôE

[�Ï'�CTiÅ71jk;���1.�561ÐÑ78_f � T1��$,�Þ1�61`&?8_fF�NpC$T�6ãC���u�[

�Å':��������qA?®¯1()�$� ^��$6&'3�^

_TOfF�N�#O���1()�$��^_��������1ï�$�

^_ National Milk Producers' FederationF��G�G*H��NO Dairy Farmers of

1 ��,�È7ñUiC�ð[}�() !7"#BC.178_f

13

Canada 1$%$6&'ÊË^_TOfTT7,Å�:F&$'(C)$OÏ'1N*+o¾¿OB'1G�1,-Øã:G�G*1&.:G�/t10&12

3oX4.:²#51#67891��X:&:();<�=¬1>9X�$

?@[uAÍX?V:B�C#$%&'()*+?D$vÏ'TiE�Å71

Fc\]ªi'�CG{$6&'HIBC&f��������1��$�^_

��13�7,:O9Aã#JK-F¶L�ÔN:#ï��0M:ÂB'NO�

PGK-F(QRG%vS¶·¸I¹N$?@[uAÍ:��1()�OTU

^_´7:�#O���1()�$6&'VW^_fÅCjk;���$.O

Ø&'¼PQHXY½Fconsumer financedN¶·¸I¹$6&'.@L7�_v�X¶·¸I¹Z�MF<E<N1L[\]$6&'Aá^_fT1<E<1^_

,:��������1���u�$.OØ�:jk;1t$%&'¶·¸I¹

$�^_v9`á1Aá[abo$cL^_Iã$X_f ���=>?@ABCDEF>�GHIJKLMNO�

PQRSTIUV�

� G�,bc1ÉÊXdef?ÄÅiC5g1¼h�½¾Ù78_Ch:B�C

#7,F&$'(C)$OÏ'N-.*+oX¾¿15678_OVVi'&

_FSpencer and BlanfordNfiÏ':B�C#7,:G�1jkX(Q[l\^_TO[ÚmBCfge1B�C#,(Q¦nv9.oBp(QqOO&��r

$stB'&_Ch:T�BCÚu[vw3$xJBCTO,WVU78_fª

':y$z{xyqA1Ch:#ï(Q1UX91zu?¶LÙ$-�{Vi

CO^_fÂ1rbOB'G�_G�1zQÕ1ÜÞ,:#Z$OÏ'-.*+

oU6ÉÊX¾¿156$6&'v3X(Q¬0[ë�^_O&�Úu[|}$

ªVBU±X&fiÏ'v3X(Q[ë�^_Ch$zQÕ[ë�^_TO?~

ÅB&�õ:bc1B�C#D,G�1v3X#ï(Q[l\^_Ch:\]

�áoU6IJoX�$�V�_[�XUÏCf WXWYGZ[�

� G�,:z�1ÅÅ7,Uªs9:ÅC�h'��B�^&Ch:Ti[��:

��^_Ch1/t$��$¶�BXc',XVX&fbc1)*�O,�X9:

G�,��G*ªi:�­o$,�AoXG*Êf1TÕ?S&Ch:��Ð|

$¡�B'G*[��^_Ch$UX91�5?UU_fT1Ch:()Z[\

]^_TO[`&O^_��0M?�t^_Å7:ÅCG�[TUo���$

·�^_TO[§�$^_v�X��? ¡ªi_Å7:¢~1()ZOB',:

G���+H?£©BC��[¤ãLi_U:G�[¥'_UO&��í$EO

¦�§¨©?XUÏCCh:��+HFG�1-ª10&1N1«$/t�¬9

?8ÏCf � ()1tu:G�1­ÊO(QO15$®¯oX¦°±?de^_TO.�r

[²³$B'&_f´�C#1tu:µ¶·®$G�G*¸?-�$X_¹¢?

14

8_5\:5£$º��1PQ¸?-.b&1?»®789:-.¼X&1?·

®78_f��7,½1TO?ò:G�(Q?·®$-.¼X&5\:­Ê,

-SÖ×$8_fªV$:G�?��B�^&TO?T�BC�r$¾¿[Uã

'&_fO&�1.:º��1tu:S(Q-Ü­Ê­$ÀÁB:¯$Ü(Q-S­Ê­$Â�^_TO?7�X&UV78_fÂ1õ:G�1(QO­Ê1zÃ

��Ä94?�h'Ü&¹¢$89:T1TO,(QÂB'ÅC,­Ê1A�U

XÐ|ª:��1UX9ÅÆXÐÇ[Ý�ÈT^TO[�É^_f(QO­Ê

1®¯oX¦°±$­ÊO(Q1��Ä94?�h'Ü&O&�&.?ÉX9:

��1��X®¯ÐÇ[Ý�ÈTB:/tÊË1ÌÍ[IÎ^_rb$XÏ'�

CfD$v_����0M1`&,:NO­$�ÏÙ[/tUVÐ�B:¦n

­$/t$�9Ñ^TO7T�BC®¯oX¦°±[Ò×|^_TO$8ÏCf

T�BC0M,ÓÔeÕ�ÛÖ1×�[B:��1®¯ÐÇ[ØAªÍ_ab

?8ÏCf WX\]G^_T`a�

� G�/t?23oXÙÚ[À'&_F^XA):�¿�1�91?b&1$

¡B:0&1?�h'¼X&NTO.G�/t1.�561�r789:T1T

O,:D$v_ÛL[Ü�|^_ÝÞOB'.5£o$îhVi'&_f)Z

1¼lm9½[Sh_TO[`&O^_]ß?0Aªi_Å7:ÅCG�[��

�Å7àáCh1âãoX¶���?¡x^_Å7:G�/t,�h'äåo7

89:Yæ1)Z1tu:G�1ãçoX0&1,EO¦�deBXUÏCfT

1Ch:)Z,FXU¦�c:èsµ®X�:/t$%&'NO�¿�?G�

_�­$N¼price takerF��¤�HN½789:G�1��[éêõÅÏCc�¬7�XUÏCfªV$G*qO­$X_O:bc1)Z,:Ø&��[¤ãL

i�_[�X&Óã7Xc:G�1�ë[$&Ó^TOªìíÓÏCf&$)

Z?��+H1£©^_��[¤ãLiXUÏCtu$T�BCîï$ð9�^

UÏCCh:Ti[ñ»^_TO?:�#$%&')ZÂB'ÅC,()q1G

���+H$¡^_lm9[Sh_TO[`&OB':�òOó1ô�ý�ü�

õèé�ö�÷���[÷ã_*�oXÝÞOXÏCf bcdefG#gIhi�

� #ï1RG��$êa4[�CÍ_Ch:²#D,:øíUVØ�X¶LÙ

?�¸$ùiúo1[ñ»^_Ch$¶Lz���ÔX�:ûVU1#JK-[

÷ãXc',XVXUÏCfüuoX��FGoý@$ ÏCtu:#JK-$

vÏ'#ï1/t��[Sh$ë�^_v9.:#JK-[÷ã�:)Z$¦n

þ&[��TO7Úu��O/t��O1�M[¸�^_\?�ÅB&fBUB

X?V�ÏÙ1tu:#ï1()Z$¦nþ&[��O�XY?É^�_Ch:

F�������Oó[ìcNEO¦�1#?�Ôz��[÷ã(���í1

15

#~1�Ôz��,PQ¸1a�$�Vi'&_):�íÔÕ[�h'Sc÷AB'&_FÂ1��3?����[ _N2f � EO¦�1#7#J\][1FcB'&_G{,:�ÏÙ1#6789$��

X��?de^_Ch78_f�#:���:ÂB'EO¦�1BóC#1G*

H��,�������1��1E ��$x^_F�4���Nf��1G

*H��,:�������1��1E ��$x^_f÷æ���1(),:

�1#~O,�h'�XÏ'&_f�1#~1()?���¿O��1�\[*

�O^_#ï/t�¢1*+78_1$¡B:�������Oó1(),

`�X�ä*�$.OØ&C¶·�¢1��()789:G�1G*Q?�h'

Ü&fT1Ch:#J\][�AX&ö9:EO¦�1#1()Z,÷æ���

1)ZO78^_TO?7�X&f ��j�f�

� bc1()Z,:G���+H1/t�¬9$¡�^_1�OB'()q$�

B'&_f()q,:G�¶�ç�è 1uG|:®¯ÐÇ1Ò×|:G���

+H!1�¿�1ØA(Q:G�1º������¿�!1��PG:ÂB'/

t"�1£(X�:G�/t$bc1ÉÊX#�<�[�Ï'&_fÅCTiV

1�$,:()Z$% 6�1ê&['h:D!1;<�(Ç$.UX91

)*[z&'&_fT1Ch:()*+1tu:q+�u$v9�$ªi'&_

)Z1zu,:�1)+�,v9.S&fªV$:()��]ß[0A^_61

()q1¡ò9?��&Ch:D1/0[Y-'()q1>9?ªV$2|

ªi'&_fiÏ':=¬OB'1()Z$,5£$UX91>9?8_f � ªV$:.ä1.?ö/o789:�1´µ1)+$0ªX&äå7,:()

?1��918_251é+$X9?)78_fT�BCäå$%&':()?

XcX_O&�TO,:)314+¬?XcX_TO[�É^_Ch:TiV1

äåFès�#15�6�þó���1´ø7N1()[\�^_v�'h_

UX91>o89?de^_f´9�Có1()q?UX91>9[�&:

! [YqªÍC´9�Có()qA?()[\�^_Ch1]ß1�è78_f � B�C#D?()*+[1Fc\]B'&_gî$,:*+o¾¿10:X

(Q[l\BC&O&�*�oXÊ'$;Å9:<=oÊ>?UX9��&TO

,WVU78_fBUBX?V:pCX���qA1Þ7D1��()*+

Âiz¬?®¯��XÏ'&cU,TiÅ7E�Wl7,X&f?$T1�r$

6&'@9õßC&f ������ �����klG�����mno��� � ��������7,:����������$)+��[��^_Ch1�

��$6&'u�?J BCCh:xyøùoX()��[��^_v�'h_

2 A#,èí789:�ÏÙ$¡^_�ÔÕ,���BMf

16

89?®¯SÅ_TO$X_fCÓB:xyz{|$�^_���$6&'5A

1u�$xBC.11:qA1«¬oï�1bc$6&',:X%:^C'1

#~7lm^_DÊ?8_f�Þ1¯7,:��1()�OTUB66:´�

F�#O���N1()�[HI^_TO7:�����������u�?

()�$� ^��$6&'3�^_f?@OX_è�ü,#JK-F¶L�

ÔN:D/0:#ï��0M:NO�PGK-F^XA)#ï(QRGO¶·

¸I¹N78_f �

ABpbqDErstug�N�

� &$B�C#$%&':T1��$¡^_E,¼ë�7�_½O&�.17

8_fTiV1#~1tu:G�,Dʦ§FX¾¿78_Ch:²#1D,

¶LÙ$Gd^_TOXc:v3X#ï(Q[l\Bv�O^_Óp�fªV$:

EO¦�1#7()Z$UX91>9?89:BU.xy[z{|BCtu:

��������ó[ìc8V³_#~1()Z?HI[¤ã_TO$X_f

5£$)ZO&�.1,:qJ1�K?©B'&_gê�õ1LM[N_OV

_¹¢$8_Ch:T1TO,:()$��^_#JK-1�àX��$6&'

#6oXu�[�_TO[Å^Å^ìí$B'&_fÂ1rb:ge"hVi'

&_xylm$%&':�ÏÙ?èíOB'OAi_§�4?UX9S&f��

�u�7,:�ÔÕ$�-'ÙÚ[3ÛB:�ÔÕ1S&ÙÚ1Ý�Þßà[�

ÔÕ1Ü&ÙÚv9��c^_v�Ah'&_fBUBX?V:²#,:5�1

ÙÚ[æ�çèéêXÙÚ$mAB:Â�^_TO7®¯1&UX_��UV.

ìí^_TO?7�_Ch:bc1B�C#?T�BC\]7�ÏÙ[\]^_

§�4?8_f bvwtxyrstug�N�

� %ÂVc#J\][ë�7�_�õ:#ï��0M.ë�7�_TO$X_f

jk;7,����0M,P-Vi'&X&.11:#ï��uLMFóôEN

$v9/0ªi_Ch:Ti[��BXc',XVX&fg�1jk;���7

,:#ï��[��^_Ch1*×ROB'óôE1üM[�Ï'&_Ch:(

)$¡^_#ï��[��BX&3:�1*+34$¡^_#ï��[��^_

TO7QhuAÍis:()$¡^_óôE[��BX&7�Å^TO.7�_f

BUBX?V:pB&�����������u�1ðò7,:ÙÚRO$�·

$õö[÷ã:-.xyøùoX´µ1��[�à$��^_v�áâSã'&

_Ch:TiÅ71îï?Ð|^_TO$X_f�#����[ÄhCB�C#

$%&':()34?óôEM1UX91zu[3h'&_Ch:�·$¡^_

ÙÚå1õö/0[ê&BCtu$,:()34?��X��[¤ã_TO$X

_f � ()*+$6&',:bc1#~$bc1����0M?de^_f�#:�

��:ÂB'<T7.�&Vi'&_-.5£oXK-,:D1UABC��

Ö×7�ÏÙ[0&õß:�¿�1��V;�[÷A^_\]78_fD?0

17

&õß_1$Ê^_Q�,óôE1M$@Lªi_fBUBX?V:�#���

�$6&'óôE[L@^_tu:G�1üG*¸$6&'de^_#ï��O

#6��O1���?v3$VWªi'&X&fT1��#$6&'óôE[L

@^_6$#6��O#ï��O1���?v3$VWªi'&X&O&��r

[V_Ch$,:�:TiV1#~1()0M1*�oXX��$6&'H

I^_DÊ?8_f�Þ7,:��10MOTUB66:�#O���10M$

?@[uAÍ'Y-_f z8� {bGxy�

� �#7,:���¿����0MF>DEDN$.OØ&'D?�ÏÙ[0

&õß:Ti$v9�ÏÙ1/t��[5Zo$Þ�B'&_fT10&õß

��,:�Þ1@A[\$.OØ&'L@B'&_f |}~X��G���h�|���VXwt�h��VX������a'�~�

|�VX��������a�~� � �òô�ý�ü�õèé�ö�÷���F]ôô;N,:��+H?)Z$�

þAXc',XVX&���¿�Fý��^O_N1-Ü��[÷AB'&_f |�~���VXP��h�|X��\]�h���������a'�~�|�

VX��������a�~� � ÏÙ1/t��OÏÙ10&õß��O?`B&tu:F�N\OF�N\,

+-.1[дBCÓã$X_f]ôô;1-Ü��1ê61@A[\,:

F�N\v9.²³789:ý��^ÏÙFû�aNOý��_ÏÙF5��O

b�N1�#c5-Ü��,:÷AªiC�J3��$.OØ&'L@ªi_f

���¿�-Ü�þ&áâ��Fý��^ÅC,ý��_1&�iUS&\1�

�N$F��7Ë�,d��1NeFcountyNå$÷Aªi_º��fgô� Fý��h�MN[õiÍ^_TO7º��ÏÙFý��hN1-Ü�þ&áâ

��?eå$÷Aªi_fTiÅ7,:#ï1º��­Ê[jC^Ch$DÊX

¶�Q1��?ý��h�M[÷ã_ÝÞOªi'�CfG�1��kl,��

1]ôô;äå1Âimi$f��ªi:]ôô;äåRO$n5oX�ÉÒ°

��7)Z$�þ&?�Ai_f � ªV$:]ôô;0M1Þ7º����?���¿��$�ÇB'Þo^_1

[p¨^_Ch:´9�Có1�[¡ÎO^_F´9�CóqAO�si_Nº

��Fý��hN1.�561��V;�?�qqd�)+]$r9úÅiCf

�����)+],T10M[�#$s�B:Úu��Oê61��O1�M[

t����PQH1ãA9$D?�þ�TO$XÏC3fÅCÒ°B'�u�$

3 T1sZc,�þM,:v�þ�$%&']ôô;��?�d.q���[ÞpÏCtu1:�d.q���Ov�þ�1]ôô;ý��hº��-Ü��O1�M78_f]ôô;0M1Þ7,:

v�þ�1�d.q���$¡�^_��?��1^C'1e$6&'zÇo$L@7�:T1��O]ôô;��O1�M,^C'1e7+M$X_fiÏ':CÓ561ä@FT1tu$,

18

x^_v�þ�äå1º��X¢ãÕ[�#1^C'1e$0�BCfT1ý�

�hX¢ãÕ[�#o$0�BCtu:}w�õ�äåX�1º��X¢ãÕ1

Ü&äå78Ï'.:V;x�X�1º��X¢ãÕ1S&äåO+-yz[¤

ãVi_Ch:T�BCäå$OÏ'{9o78_fT10M7,:D$v_

XY[��þ;��^_Ch:�)Z?�5$¤ã@_¡Î$7�_G�¸$ö

M[÷ã'&_f � Ê^_$:�#D,:�$>DEDO]ôô;[Y-'��[/0B'&_f

OTp?:]ôô;$%ã_º���O���¿��,:ge1óôE1.O7

,#ï��O#6��O1���[L@^_1$�����78_O$Xªi

'&X&fTi$¡^_561|W,:]ôô;7,:�ÏÙ1/t��$.O

Ø�:�¿�t���?�þAXc',XVX&-Ü��[÷AB'&_$q�

X&O&�TO78_f^XA):÷�5�÷���fgô� $6&',()

qO��+HO1lm$v9UAªi'&_Ch:t���UV)Z$ê6$�

þAi'&_��,Yæ:-Ü��[õpÏ'&_f�#D,ge:]ôô;

-Ü��(���}��~�u.�d��C9�������)O#6����FË�.�d��N1�M7,Xc:>DED����Fq.q���NO#6����O1�M[óôE1@A*×OB'Â�B'&_f�#1@A\\$is:ó

ôE$@A^C�#ï��O#6��O1��?��1Ö×v9.�ªcX_f �8� ���GX���xy�

� ���D,:5��O��b�1F����O�si_N0&õß��[÷

AB:TiO+�$�Þ1@A[\[�&:Ti$¡�B't���?)Z$�

þ&§�X���¿��[L@^_f |�~��������w�M=�Gug�� ��¡¢£X¤¥X��¦|� 

�Gwt�h��VX������ ��a�~�|¡¢£Xwt�h��V

X�����£X�a�~§¨|�a'�~� � ���1tu:�#1tuO�X9:5��O��b�1D����,E

�æo$5��O��b�1ê61����O`B&fÂ1G{,:���7,:

�#OTC:����Ö×[­Q°±��Ö×v9.,_U$Sc÷AB'&_

Ch78_f����Ö×?�h'S&.11:NO�?G-X&v�:G�1

(Q¸[��$RGB'&_Ch:5��O��b�1D0&õ߸,¼X&f � ²ó1G*Hô�ý�ü�õèé�ö�v��Fôô�NOt���O,:5

��O��b�$6&'D1@ABC�¿��[@Ý$��TO7u�B'&

_fªV$:�1�ÏÙ$�Ai_F%vÂ�u1G�X¢ãý��1N�¿�

$6&'.:5��O��b�$6&'D?@ABC�¿��$TèB'zÇ

o$��?´Jªi_f�ÅU$òÏ':T1TO,:D1@ABC��?

v�þ�N[�Ï'�#1^C'1e[/A^_TO?7�_fªV$&s:T1ç�è ,:

�d.q���UVv�þ�1ý��h�M[Ý&CMO��5�1ê61ý��h �5�(ý��^O_1S&\)O1�(1�u�)[¸�^_TO$�r^_f

19

��õ�^is:)ZOt���O157@ݪi_:8V³_ý��1��?

��õ�^_TO[�É^_f��ªiC0&õß��,ê61��OE `B

&Ch:5£$t���,¡�^_�¿��[�þ&:Â1��þ[��+H$

��^_4f � �#1tuO+�:���1��.óôE$v3$���þªi'&X&fT

i$6&',�61|W?VVi_f�5$:��[ÚoO^_�L��OT

i$¡�^_t���1�¿���[D?L@B'&_TO,éê78_.1

1:Ti,)Z1ôô�Ot���O?@Ý^_61¼����½$q�X&T

O78_fT1��[��v�D?)Z�t���$20^_TO,UB'X

c:)ZOt���,D1@ABC��[z3C)1@Ý��OB'¼z�o

$½�Ï'&_$q�X&f�w$óôE1.O7#ï��O#6��O1��

�[L@^_1$�Ai'&_ge1#6����[��TO$F�#X�:�

1#~1tuO+�N���.�¡B'&_TO78_fB�C#1��$vi

s:÷æ���1()ÙÚ?�1#~O8Å9$.�X_Ch:÷æ���1¶

·��[#6����OB'�&:�1#~1#ï��OTU^_TO,ìí7

8_f ©8� ª«GX���xy�

� �#:���:ÂB'<T1tuO,�X9:��1tu$,:�q�q��

�#ï�ÏÙ1D0&õß0M?ê.o$XcXÏCfªV$��7,:óô

EM[��$��^_Ch5:F�N�Ê�ÏÙ1ØAmu��:F�N)Z[¡

ÎO^_���¿�1\���F�DN:ÂB'F�Nt���[¡ÎO^_*

×@Ý��FEDN[Äh:�����$,5:1D/0��[º»BCfÂ

iÅ7�D,:)Z1G*Q$.OØ&'L@ªi:ED$6&',F�#O�

��$%ã_`\F�N%vSF�N$ÛÖ^_@A[\[�&N�ÏÙ1/t

��OÏÚ�Q$.OØ�:t���1�þ§���OB'L@ªi'&CfÂ

T7:�DOED1�M?¦nþ&OB')Z$�þAi'&Cf � p0M7,:�0M$%ã_G� kg�C9Ë���1¦nþ&M1�?�A�þ&MOB'�ªiCfT1�A�þ&M1Ö×$6&',:­QîïO)Z1

G*Q[VWB:��$sB[�Ï'&_f��7,ge:���¿��?/t

7UAªi'&_f/t��1Ö×$UUAV�:)Z,/t��$�A�þ&

M[õiÍBCM[¤ã@_f

4 �������Å7:)Z$¡^_sZ�þ&?�Ai'&Cf���D,T10M[��o$º»B:sZ�þ&M[�MB:�¿�1D��0&õß��OTi$¡�^_t���1

�þ&§���[Ý�õßCft���,��þ1��3[��+H$��B:��+H,G�

O�ÏÙ1����[Ý�õßCfiÏ':sZ�þ&[º»B'.:)Z1¤@M,�V�:

PQH1�þ&M?�_rb$XÏCf 5 ��7,:����0M?jk;���1Þ7P-Vi'%9:Ti[��^_Óã7,�ªiX&OVC17,X&UO�Ai_f

20

� .�561K-,:���7Â�ªi'&_0M$ÖC5g1kL\}0M7

8_f���¿�1/t��?qJ��51Ò°R[ÞpÏCtu:)Z,:

DO)Zz�7�÷BC*¹UVÂ1�M1��%[¤ã@_TO?7�_f«¬o$,:���¿��kg �C9�.��[)Z?Þ·B:D?���¿��kg�C9�.��[¸IB'&_f � ��7,.,����[�Ï'&X&Ch:#ï��O#6��O1���

,��1óôE7,���þªi'&X&f�#����7.T�BC���[

óôE7v3$���þB'&X&.11:�#O���$,ÅÓ aX���

�0M?de^_Ch:Â1G{,Ý�o$�X_fBUBX?V:�����

���7,:#ïRG��O#6����1Aá$6&'TiÅ7v9.¡Ïú

¦ÓY![�&:T�BC���[óôE1L@$�to$Äh_v�$^_§

�4.8_f WXG¬­r@G®M�¯°Ip±²³o�N�

� ge"hVi'&_jk;lm?u�$xBC¯.()$��^_#JK-�

5A1#ï��[ë�7�_O^is:��[­Q°±��[õp_Ö×$Ý�

õß_TO?7�_fBUBX?V:(Q���[ê&BX&ö9:­Q°±

��[ _Ö×1��,:G�1G*qO[Ý�ÈT^f#ï(Q¸[��^

_Ch$,:�$(QRGO¶·¸I¹1�61\]?8_f z8� ´µ¶³�

� ge1jk;���7,(QRGK-$6&'/0B'&X&f�#7,:�

��¿�1����[va�.Uã'¢~$��B'%9:£¤1Y9:���

�,ge:TUoÜ&Ö×$8_f/t��?ge:����[õp_Ö×7Ð

ÇB'&_Ch:ÅÆXNO��r,G-'&X&fiÏ':�#$,ge:(

QRG0M?deBX&6f � ��$,:()Z1�#�$F}�() !¥ ¦>=N$v9�$ªiC¼z�oX½(QRG0M?de^_fBUBX?V:D?���¿�1\���

[¢~$Ý�Þß'�CF£¤1Y9:\���,�����$º»ªiCNT

O?�>7:G�1G*¸?§¨o$�¼B'�CCh:qJu�5:G*Úu

1õö$G*¸?©xBX&îï?¨&'&_f

6 �#7,�q���ã$����?�à$Ý�õßViCCh:()*+,G�1ª4oXqO$stBCf�#7,T1�r$¡P^_Ch:«���$v_wgÛ1(QRG0M[cLB

CfÂ156?�q���1G��{L¬Fô>DN789:.�56?�q�u�1()º+

L¬F>kDN78ÏCfô>D1*�oXï�O,:�q�������UV�q�u���

���Å71G�1G*¸[­A1*×­5v9.�V^®:¯Ë$°±BC)Z$g¹[�þ

�O&�.1ÓÏCfÅC>kD$��BC)Z?²³�¬[´µ^_U¶·BCtu:¸¶¹

?�þAiCfªV$:��H,:zV?()G*$iéÍ�:ÅC&÷[()G*$Â�BX

&TO$+�BXc',XVXUÏCfT10M1·¸$6&', Suzuki and Kaiser (1994) [$vf

21

� ��.�q���ã¹$ª4oXG*qO$stB:��D,¦nþ&$v

_�XY[�V^Ch:\���1¡ÎOX_G�1¸[0ö^_TO$BCf

öMa¸1��X0�$¡�B:}�() !,öMa¸[ _NO�?¡G

BX&v�:zVG*z�[ê&BCf()q?zVcLBCO&��É$%&

':��1(QRG0M,z�oX.1ÓÏC?:z�[ q^_G�[G*B

C)Z$��Xz� qº»[¼BCO&�@7:T10M,¼20oX½4�

[À'&CfTi,:Âimi1)Z$6&':8_�$G*¸?z�¸[

Ctu: q3Óã½�1z�¸[�V^O&�.1ÓÏCf6Å9��7,:

]�$GdÍ�$20oXG*z�[ê&7�C178_fTi,�$:D?

�qdd�$¦nþ&0M[cLBC6$:5¾$56Óãq+�u[mAB:

D?T1�u(mA=¬)$¸Q¹[�þ�v�$BCCh78_fÂ1rb:)Z?¸Q¹[¤ã@_Ch$,T�BCmA=¬$�L^_BUXc:Â1r

b:�()Z1qu%?TiV1mA=¬$�L^_TO$XÏCfT1Ch:}�() !,/t!1G�1(Q[��þ;��^_9[�_TO$XÏCf

ÅC}�() !,z�[��BC&O¿~^_)Z$bh$¬3^_TO7:

T10M[8_BMÄ9o$à�^_v�À9BCf � G�(Q?Á/7-.��$RGªi'&_#,8_&,���U.BiX&f

���1tu$,:²ó1ôô�[Yª�$G�[��^_TO?]�$v9P

-Vi'&_fÂ1rb:���%1()Z?ôô�$�LB'&_f�òD%vSóD,���¿�Oº��1�\1��¸[0ö^_���[Ah (Romain and Sumner):T1z�[¢~1()Z$¬3B'&_fi�:²()Z,:���¿�Oº��1���[å~$\ B'&C?:ge,Â1�\?5

61���$ÅOhVi'&_fT1z��7,¸[�AÍ�:Âimi1)Z

1/tçÂ�?5A$\Ci_Ch:¼/tçÂ��ýÃ��FôEÄN½O�

si_fès:f��äå1º��X¢ãÕ?��%789:���¿����?�%�¼B:óï1º����?�%�¼BCtu:²)Z1z��,�.d%F���¿�z��7�.�%:º��z��7�.�%N�¼^_TO$X_fz� qG*?P»ªi'&_Aã7,X&.11:z� qG*UV¤ã@_

TO17�_��,�h'Ü&Fès:�����UV�����1÷��x

÷ó1º���?Ò°B'���xÅþ��C9d�.�u�����78ÏC1$¡B'�q.�������NCh:T1TO? qG*[�»^_Æ>OXÏ'%9:NO�,¼X&f���1)Z1¢ÇåG*�,:Â1óï7@Ý^_

TO?7�_f �·�¸¹º»¼�

� ¶·¸I¹,NO�[P3^_Ch$�Ai_.�561ÉÊX1�78_f

T1�����������u�7,:¶·¸I¹1º»$¢ã'��c��·

BCf«¬oX­ö,®¯1lm$°±Vi'&_.11:u�7,:8V³_

´µ1¶·¸I¹[º»^_O¤C'&_fT1u�7,:¾¿ÀI:¶·Á�:

#ZxyÃ+FEk<N[Äh:8V³_´µ1¶·¸I¹[¡ÎOB'&_f

22

�#1�ÏÙ¶·ÈÉL¬O<T1¶·¸I¹,D$v_WlX¶·¸I¹

78_Ch:®7.jk;1º»ËÌ1¡ÎOB'���þªi'&_fBUB

X?V:&c6U1#~7,:)*�1¶·[Ê$ÈÉ^_v�X�11�?�

Ai'&_fTi$,ès:#ZxyÃ+FEk<N$3Ûªi_=>=F�

��()°Ë N?ê&B'&_���1��´J0M?8_f���7,:¶

·ÏÙ1��¢ã1G�$6&'�ÌçÍ��ý��[÷ã:Ti$Ü&��[

÷AB'&_f^XA)¶·¢ã1��kL[Tiv9.��1S&#ï¢ã�

�kLOO.$f��B:Â1�ÉÒ°[()Z$�þÏ'&_f � �Þ1cÎX6Ï�[�&:Ek<$v_¶·[Y-'ê.o$¶·¸I[�

�t��a $6&'|W^_TO?7�_fy$8_Ek<$Â1#7��ª

i_G�[@9O�Ð3Ñ?8_.1O^_fCO#ï7,T1Ek<$Ð3

Ñ?8ÏCOB'.:¶L?0öªiX&ö9:T1Ek<,øí178Z1O

178[Y-'��¤�H1 t$-Ui_Ch:D�B.Ð3o�¬9[�6

Aã7,X&fFTT7,:ûVU1¶L0öK-?8_Ch:Â1Ek<?#

6��[õp_#ï��[´J^_TO?7�_.1OyA^_NfT1Ek<

1%z,:)ZUVÒ�BCÓÙ1°Ô��+HOB':#ï1ÓÙ1(Q¸[

#ï/tO¶·/tO$¬3B:ü��kL[-�|ªÍ_TO$8_fTi[

êg^_Ch$,:#ï/tO#6/t$��BCtu1ö/kL?`BcXã

is,XVX&fT1Ek<,:#ï/tO¶·/t$%ã_ÙÚ1����1

�ÉÒ°��[)Z$�þ�TO7kl[)Z$ÕÖ^_f)Z,��¤�H7

8_OyA^_Ch:ö/G*Q?×V1¤ã@_f����$`BcX_v�

$G*^_f¶·��,:#6/t1ü(Q¸Oü­Ê¸?`BcX_��78

_fT1Ek<,:#6/t7,��¤�H78_OyA^_f � �õ1yA$.OØ�:Ø�7,T1/tîï[^_o$|WB'&_fTT

7 Pd ,#ï��789:Qd ,#ï(Q¸789:Qs ,ü(Q¸789:Pb ,f����789:QRd ,øí­Ê789:QRs ,øí(Q78_fØ�FÙ«N1#ï��1ö/kLùÚO­Û1 Pw Ö×(¶·��1ÖÒXö/kLsÚ) O1l@F@=N,#ï��O¶·��$v9$úÅi_ö/kL?°±^_@78

_f@=,a�o$?1v�$Ü^TO?7�_f Pd + (�Pd/�Qd)�Qd = Pw, ÝÞß ÅC, Pd(1-�/E) = Pw, Ýàß TT7 � (0 � � � 1) ,/t�¬9�a789:E ,#ï­Ê1��Ä941á¡R6Å9 -(�Qd/�Pd)(Pd/Qd) 78_f`\�ÝÞß�1âã,:#ï��$v_ö/kL78_f#ï/t$%&'Ek<,��÷AH78_Ch:²#ï��¸?�c,

��^_O#ï��, (�Pd/�Qd)� Þo^_O$úÅi_fiÏ':#ï��$v_ükL1�¼M, (�Pd/�Qd)�Qd OX_f6Å9:#ï��¸1�c,1��$v9$úÅi_kL1��M, `\ÝÞß 7©ªi_Y9 Pd+(�Pd/�Qd)�Qd $X_f`\�ÝÞß 1Ùã,¶·��$v9$úÅi_ö/kL78_fT16Ï�7,:Ek<?¶·/t$%&'��¤�H?8_OyAB'&_Ch:T1M,:¶

·¸1Ð|$UUAV�5A78_.1O$úÅi_f� 1R,:#J\]1M

23

u&$��ªi_f¶L[P-Ctu:Ek<$, Pd(1-1/E) = Pw 7©^TO17�_v�X/t�¬9[�6TO?7�_5\:#J\]?X&tu:Ek<,

#ï/t$%&'��¤�HOX_ (^XA) Pd = Pw) f � Ek<,#ï��¸[T1Ö× (Qd) Å7��B:Â1tu:#ï��,:­ÊùÚOäåõ1 Qd O1l@F@óN7UAªi_fÂ15\:#ïG*¸,:(QùÚOf����ùÚ1l@F@<N7UAªi_fT1f����ùÚ,

a�o$�Þ1v�$Ü^TO?7�_f Pb = [PdQd + Pw(Qs – Qd)]/Qs Ýæß ­Û1#6�� (Pw) 7°±?xJªiCtu:Ø�FÙ«N1Ek<1¶·¸

(Qs-Qd) ,Ø�Fâ«N$©BC#6/t1¶L¸ (QRd-QRs) O`BcX_f#ï/tO#6/t1�\?h�781tu:� = 0 789:Ø�1 Pw*?h�78Ö×$8_TO[©B'&_Ch:`\�ÝÞß�,�Pd = Pw (=Pb) OX_fEk<?���å[�Ï'&_ge1#6�� Pwv9.78oX#6�� Pw*?ScX_@$ç�BXc',XVX&fEk<,:#ï��[0öB:#ï��[Ý�õß:

¶·¸[��^Ch:#6°±��[Ý�Þß_f G*H,f���� Pb[¤ã@9:¶·�� Pw ? Pbv9.Ü&Ch:Ø�

FÙ«N1Î\´�=><1tè7©ªi_¹M?¸I¹OX_fT1X��7

,:PQH?¸I¹1�M[XYB:Ø�1�=><1tèO PdPbBA 1tè?`BcX_fjk;1.O7/0ªi'&_Yæ1¶·¸I¹1tu:DÅC

,éÔH?�=><1tè[XY^_fiÏ': PdPbBA ÅC,�=><1tè,:¼PQHXY½¶·¸I¹Z�MF<E<N78_OAá^_TO?7�_

(Schluep, 1999)fT1tu: ESE=Qe(Pb-Pw)=Qd(Pd-Pb), Ýêß

789:TT7 Qe=Qs-Qd78_f ��FG1ý@$ ÏCtu:¼PQHXY½¶·¸I¹$,Yæ1¸I¹v

9.�r?8_§�4?8_ (Alston and Gray)fØ�$%&':Yæ1¶·¸I¹$v9G*H�� Pb?xJªiCtu:¶·¸,]<OX9:¶·��, Pw'OX9:D�·,Î\´]�ë<OX_fT1tu:h�781z{/tOTU

BCtu1FG;�,�61ìí91îï´1tè1ðOX9:Ti,�61ñ

ò1ó´1ð7ܪi_¼PQHXY½¶·¸I¹1tu1;�v9.�ª&êf�

Ýàß�%vS�Ýêß\�UV�Vi_ ESE = (�PdQdQe)/(E Qs) Ýôß

UV©ªi_Y9:�1ÊË[5AO^is:� 1R?��cX_$6i'¼PQHXY½<E<1M.�_fiÏ':� .<E<1��ª1mu$X_f �#1]ôô;7.º��O���¿�O15$���[÷ã:f����[

)Z$�þÏ'&_Ch:õ¤OÛÖ^_&Ò[À'&_fº��1��[/

0^_TO7:º���[Ý�õß:���¿��[Ý�Þß_TO?7�_C

7 TT7,:ÒÔ��þ$6&'VX&f

24

h:NO�[¶·^_TO?�y$X_f6Å9:�ÏÙ1¶·[ÈÉ^_Ch:

�#7.���7.ÛÖ10M[Â�B'&_f � óO�������.ÛÖ1�[õ�B'&_f£ö16Ï�7,#ï

��O¶·��O1���UV<E<$6&'|WB'&_?:Ti[¶·/t

51���å$6&'|W^_Ch$Â�^_TO.7�_føí1PQH.<

E<[XY^_v�Xtu[cL^_TO$vÏ'6Ï�[�y$s�^_TO

?7�_fØ�7,:�61#[�ÏC&c6U1éè$6&'©B'&_fé

èF÷N1tu:#ïPQH,:�61øí/t1<E<[XYB'&_f

FøN7,:#ï1PQHOí#�1PQH?í#�1<E<[XYB'&_f

FùN7,:í#�1PQH?í#�1<E<[XYB:#ïG*H$,øí�

�1�ÉÒ°��?�þAi'&_fÂB'FúN7,:í#�1PQH?#ï

/tOí#�1<E<[XYB'&_f^C'1éè$%&':ìcíÏCûå

?ñò1ûå[¸IB'&_fiÏ':¼PQHXY½<E<[5£o$?1v

�$Aá^_TO?7�_f ESE=��Pj� Pb�Qj/2 (9),

TT7 Pj , j üÚ1#UV¤ã@ÏC��UV¶�Q[�BÝ&CM789:Pb ,f����789:Qj , j üÚ1#7��BCa¸78_fT1[\[��TO7:���1X��Óã7Xc:ó��������1�ÏÙ¶·\\[

.Äh:8V³_¼PQHXY½<E<$6&'L@^_TO?7�_fbc1

#~?�ÏÙ¶·[ÈÉ^_Ch$ûVU1gÛ1Êý1¸I¹[�Ï'%9:

<E<$�^_+-[\[�Ï'Â1^C'[L[^_TO?7�_f���1

�ÏÙ[�ÏC<E<1L@è[Ü�©BCf#RO1¶·a¸���?8is:

T1<E<1L@[&UX_éè$.s�^_TO?7�_f � £¤1Y9:�����������u�7,:¾¿ÀI�¶·Á�[Y-C

.1Óã7Xc:¶·[��Ek<[Y-C¼PQHXY½¸I¹[Äh:8V

³_´µ1¶·¸I¹[º»^_O¤C'&_fT�BCÊþUV:TiÅ71

jk;���1Þ7/0ªiXUÏC¼�iC½¶·¸I¹1GYoXAáOê

�oX[A\]?DÊ$X_TO,WVU78_f��7£�B'&_<E<,: ¼PQHXY½¶·¸I¹1aboXL[\]OXp�f � ¶·¸I¹$6&'ªV$.�56m�B'%�C&@?8_fTiÅ71j

k;���1Þ7:¶·¸I¹$¡^_��ËÌ,#ï�$¡^_.1v9.

��ÓÏCf5�1è7,:¦nþ&?ê6$,#ï��7,Xc¶·¸I¹7

8_O�X^C�78ÏCtu7.:Ti[#ï��$3Û^_TO7Ü&��

Õ?0�ªiCf®¯T�BC¦�u[p¨^_Ch:8_�[¶·¸I¹$

3Û^_U:#ï���$3Û^_U[��^_Ch1WlXAá?DÊ78

_f��������1���u�7,:xyøùoX#ï��[�à$��^

_O¤C'&_fTi$v9:#ï�O¶·¸I¹O1äå$vÏ'Ý�ÈT

ªi'&_��Õ1¦°±[Óð^_TO?§�$X_U.BiX&f

25

������r½¾�{b����G¿À� � T1��1�91�37,:�#O���?��������$6&'��$

'&_U[©^f�#1tu:�#1()q[ãÜ^_}�oX�$78_��

G�G*H��FôD]N$()Z1�$?�ªi'&_.1OV_f�

#$%&':ôD],()Z1�[ã�^_}�oX� �XVS$;<�

(Ç�$15678_fÅC���1tu$,:Dairy Farmers of CanadaF>]=N$��������$�^_Â1#1�$?�ªi'&_.1OV_f Á{WXWYÂÃÄG¿À� ���u�J �£1ôD]1$% � T1 7,:��������7�AiClm$�^_ôD]1$%$6&

'ÊË^_f^XA):����������$���u�$x^_Å71ô

D]1$%$6&'HI^_fT1$%,:ôD]1 Î?�����u��

q�$�#! 7�ÏC�ò$.OØcf � xy1z{|�£$¡^_��G�G*H��FôD]N1$%O,:Ê^

_$:()*+1/0[�#?5\o$Óð^C�7,X&O&�.178_f

��$vis:ôD]OB',:�ÏÙ1v9z{X#6xy[��^_O+

�$:v9[ÜX#6xy.��B'&_fôD],:¶L$¡B'�#/t

[ �^_£$:�1#~�äåFès<T����N?¸I¹��Ô[�à

$��BXc',XVX&O��B'&_fôD]7,:�1�ÊC#¶äå

?()/t[ �B'&X&$.UUAV�:�#?z#1()/t[ �B'

&_TO?�h'��ÓOB'&_f � ôD]OB',:xy[z{|^_Ch$TiÅ7�Ai'�C@9��1

}7��������?-.ÉÊ78_OÁ-'&_f×V$vis�����

�����M$,:¸IªiC<TUV1¶·?�ÏÙ1#6xy1�u�[3

hCf��:<T:���:ê��:ÂB'A#X�1�ÊX/t,SÕ1�

íÔÕ[���Ôz��71Fc\]ªi'&_fôD],:TiO,¡�o

$�#?¶·¸I¹$ÂiE��V�:�ÔÕ.TT7Ý�u&$·B'&_

#~v9.UX9Ü&O��B'&_f � ôD],:�#?�����$��������7�ÏC)+£�[29$

��B'&_f×V1��$vis:�ÏÙ1#6xy[z{|^_õ7:T1

£�,��oU6[ÜX.1ÓÏCfT1£�,:xyøùo#ï���1�

àX��Óã7Xc:¶·¸I¹1h�Xº»[��^_.1ÓÏCfT1£�

7,:SÕ1�ÔE�Ý�Þßà[��c^_v�áâØã_¼�ðoX½@A

[\[Y-'�ÔÕ1�àXÝ�Þß[Ê'^_.1ÓÏCfôD]$OÏ'

-.ÉÊX@,:T1£�$%&'�ÏÙ[PQ^_�ÊX/t1+� �[Ê

'B'&CTOÓÏCfBUBX?V:�#?�����$�ÏC£�,�1q

26

�a1#~$v9�Uªi:lm$�CÏ'&_�#1ãÜH,�q^_BUX

UÏCf � ôD]7,:�#/t?:�$<TUV11Fc\�ªiCNO�ÏÙ1

¼º�t½(dumping ground)$XÏ'&_OÁ-'&_f×V1$%7,:��������lm1/t�ýæ�$��^_«t$-.�Y1Nä?8_O&�f

ôD]1$\O,:*�o$,:<T:���:ÂB'��UVX¦V�É1

8_l{ÊË[¤ã@_TOXc:�#?z#1/t[5\o$ �B'&_O

&�.178_f�õ?:×V?Ìu\\7,Xc:ª­1xylm7.8_B

M��ªi'&C�ðoX�ÔÕ��[\[��TO$��^_ÝÞ$XÏ'&

_f � iÏ'��$vis:ôD],���u�1J Å7:z{xylm$6&

'�Þ1v�X t[OÏ'&Cf � ��� z��ï:z��í:ÂB'z��¡Îí1ÙÚ$6&'�#$¡`X

�ýæ�[îhX&ö9:�#!1�ýæ�1z��1Ti�õ1s�$5

:�¡^_fÅC:<T?�#!1�ýæ�1��$v_yz[¤ã_tu:

&A1#?�#1�ÏÙ$¡^_z�[��^TO7Ti[¸�C�78_f � ��� �ÏÙ1¼¶L1��½$v_¼���BÞß½ab$À_Ch:

¼æ�V���½[Â�^_TO[��^_fôD],:�ÏÙ¶L1

¼��½OTi$v_��1�BÞßab[ñ»^_Ch:�#!1�ÏÙ

¶L$¡^_¶L0ö[2|^_TO$*�o$, JB'&Cf � ��� øí$\]ªi'&_/t?de^_ö9:T�BC/t$z��ï%

vSz��í1�ÏÙ$¡^_�ýæ�[ªV$`ß_TO$�¡^_f^

XA):ôD],:�#1()*+[78õ¦Â$^_v�X&UX_K

-$.�¡B'&Cf � Âi7,:��������lm1t7:xy1z{|[!"^_Ch$ô

D]?¤ãLi'."&OV'&C1,�1v�Xï�78p�Uf��$v

is:ôD],:<T?5:1¶·¸I¹[º»^_TO[ÊËOB':�Ï

Ù¶·ÈÉL¬F><#DN[º»^_TO[��B'&Cf><#D0M,:

�#7�Ai'&_251sZoX¶·¸I0M789:Â1/$,1Fc\]

ªi'&_<T1¶·v9.UX9�ª&fiÏ':><#D[º»^_1OÝ

�{$<T1¶·¸I[^C'º»7�is:�#$OÏ' ÂX@Ý78_f

�#F%vS�1#~N[ãÜB'lmB'&_Ç~,T1@$6&'<T$U

X9189[�Cf � T1��1%&7m�BCO%9:#ZxyÃ+FEk<N.åX´1¶·¸

I¹78_fBUBX?V:ôD],:�#7�Ai'&_Ek<FÓÙ¹'

[(¥ ===N$,�¡B'&X&f×VOB',:¶·O¶L$6&')�o &Ñ[ÛVi:xy[øùB'&_OôD]?Á-_v�X¼Ð3oX½E

k<$�¡B'&_178_f��$vis:ôD],:#ï1G��¬[�

27

�þ;��^_)�oÑÂ�#6/t$¶·^_)�oÑÂ[Ek<$îh_C

�7,X&O¤C'&_fT�B'�_O:ôD],:�#1===$,�r

?X&5\:5:1Ð3oXEk<[º»^C�ÓO��B'&_v�$$_f � #ï��$6&':ôD],#ï1()G*H[��^_�[§¨o$*

AB'&_fôD],+1�O,1�[h�$º»^_TO$29$�¡

B'&_fBUBX?V:+1�$.OØ&C¸I¹[��^_TO$6&'

,HIB'%9:ÅC-1�$6&',:�1#~1G*H$ê&ªi'&_

ö9:�#1G*H$.ê&^C�78_OV'&_fôD]7,:��6

�./�ç0�qB$v_¶·¸I¹1���/t!11zoX�ýæ�1s�

O+�$"h_tu$ö9:�#.#ï��1��[¤ãLi'.v&O��^

_f � ôD],�#1���¿����0MF>DEDN[§¨^_TO[2]B:

T10M?jk;$v9¦�$3�ªi'&_O4-'&_�'78_f×V,:

jk;?>DED$v_G*H��[wÉ$���þB'%9:Ti$vÏ'ø

ùoab?Ö�Bªi'&_O��^_f����?ÜUÏCCh:T10M,

�qqq�Å7#ï/t��$EO¦���[� ªXUÏCfBUBX?V:

jk;7,:T10M$¡^_�XY?E /;ÓÏC�­$6&'.:��

�þ$�:>DED$v_��Q�[�57�u5��OKAB'&_fªV

$:ôD]7,:<T1��0M?�#1>DEDv9.,_U$xyøùo

78_OÁ-'&_f½$<T7,:TiO,�X_L@\]$.OØ�:�#

v9.�à$¼X&¹M[��B'&_f � Ê^_$:ôD],:qA?[Ü:[Ò:U6��oX.178_ö9:x

y1z{|$ J78_O¤C'&_fxy1z{|$�^_ôD]1$%$

,��1¼6½?8_f�5$:¶·¸I¹,º»^_DÊ?8_f�w$:�

#Óã7Xc:�ÏÙ[PQ^_�ÊX/t:^XA)<T:��:ÂB'��

�$%ã_/t�ýæ�[s�BXc',XVX&f-¯$:#ï1()�,1

(9[ë�^_Ch:ôD]7,#ï���[ë�^_TO$ JB'&_f ������G �����Åo�Æ]�

� ôD],:��������1���u�$UX9jnB'&_f�Þ7,:

���u�?J B'UV�75¯$ôD]?�ÏC�7¡Ü$.OØ�:

ôD]1$%$6&'ÊË^_f � ôD]7,:®¯1���?¼�#1()G*H:��+H:ÂB'¶·+

H$OÏ'W_&8~½[Û_OÁ-'&_fôD]1 Î9-S��:«

H,:¼Ti,��������$OÏ'�ªX5;$q�X&.11:lm[

h<B:Á/xy1�=%OB'1jk;1Á�[Sh_O&��>oX8~$

 's��X?@78_½O�òBCfôD]7,:Ti?�h'£¢�X�

5;78_O4-'&_.11:T1��1£1¯7HIBC�ÏÙxy$�^

_×V1��[êg^_Ch$,:X%&ÏÂ�1À9?DÊ78_OÁ-'&

_f

28

� ��������1���u�$%&':¼XcO.Aõ7,:¶·¸I¹[

h�$º»^_TO7u�BCfôD]7,:T1rb$�h'jnB'%9:

Ti$v9:�ÏÙ1Ch$¶·¸I¹[BÖ1v�$�Ï'&_Bó�u$v

_¶·$¡B:�#1�ÏÙ?TiÅ7v9.z�X´7787�_O��^_f � ÅCôD]7,:��������1���u�$%&'<T:�.�:�

�:ÂB'���X�1ÉÊX/t[\]B'�CSÕX�Ô[Ý�Þß_TO

?r9úÅiCTO$.jnB'&_fôD]$v_-â1�7¡Ü$vis:

¼T�BC/A$v9:�#?/t�ýæ�[z{|^_1OÝ�{$:�1

bc1�ÊX�ÏÙ/t$%&'.�#[õp_/t�ýæ�1z{|[l\7

�_§�4?G-CfTi$v9:�#?z#1()$¡^_uGoXÖ×1�

Ô\][ë�B66:øí1¶·CD?Ý�ÞßVi_TO.8&ÅÏ':�#

1�ÏÙ¶·1789[Sh_TO?7�_½f � ÅCôD]7,:���u�$%&'5AÖ×1#ï)+��1§¨[îh

_5\:�1#~7Â�B'&_SÖ×1��[�#1)+�,7ê&ªi'&

_v�XÜÖ×1��O�ðªÍ_v�áâØã'&_TO$��oÓÏCfT

1rb,:�������$u�$x^_�£1ôD]1jk;$�^_$%

$.5EB'&_f ���G���G¿Ç�

ÈÉÊ�Ëo�ÌÍTI¿Ç�

� ���7,:SÖ×1#ïG*H��[��^_Ch$��X(QRG0M[

Â�B'&_fT1(QRG0M,:�qd��ã��:���1()�1Ý

F[XB'�CfT1Ch:jk;lm$Go���1 t,:æ$z#1(Q

RG0M[\]^_TOUV;ÅÏ'&Cf#ï1G*¸O­Ê[°±ªÍ_T

O[ÚoO^_0M,:Âi?&U$��$à�ªiv�O.:��:��X¶

LRG$Gd�_[�X&f���$%&'(QRG0M?�h'abo$H

�B:Ti[º»^_v�'h_&UX_z{xyqA.�c¤ãLiViX&

O^_1? Dairy Farmers of CanadaF>]=N1$%78_f � iÏ'���1ãÜC),:(QRG0M1º»['h_v�X&UX_£�

$.�¡^Ccl�C_µM[I&Cféê:(QRG0M1de^_���1

u61ÙÚ1G*H=¬^C'?:&UX_ã¶[þÏ'.z#1(QRG0M

[\]^_v����1ãÜC)$n5B'�SUã_Ch:¼Eô�u½O�

si_;<�=¬[rJBCf>]=1tu:()341(QRG0M[ë�^

_ÚoÓã7Xc:���7(QRG?ê&ªi'&_�1�61*Ù$6&'

.;<�(Ç[�Ï'&_f

29

� T1(QRG0M[ë�^_Ch:���7,:jk;$6&'�Þ1 t[

OÏ'&C8f � ��� �Ôz�[JdF��������£N1Ö×$ë�^_TOf���

$%ã_ge1#ï1­Q5���[\�^_Ch$,Â�^_DÊ?8Ï

Cf¶L?��BCtu:)Z$OÏ':ge1/t��71°±?KUª

i_TO$X_f>]=7,:¼T1�f;�û1Â@$6&'îL½BC

õ7DOB'1[\Xxy�[õ�^_v����D$!B'&Cf � ��� Âimi1¾¿Ù$6&':/t�ýæ�[/t$%ã_PQ¸1u�

$s�^C�78_f�ÔÕ[Ý�Þß_v9.:�Ôz�[Y-'/t�

ýæ�[u�s�^_\?¼abo½78_fT1/t�ýæ�1u�1s

�,�ÔÕ1Ý�Þßv9.(QRG0MO� B�^&f � ��� /t!1ô�ü ��ýæ�[Fès²M:�ÏÙ:NM:�O:�

OX�NÙÚö��få$÷AB:Â1zu[Âimi1ö��fï1^C

'1ÙÚ$0�^_f � ��� �ýæ��ï1¶L$0�^_�ÔÕ[/;$^_f/t�ýæ�[ê

.o$0ö^_v�XcÎX�Ô$6&',�Ôz�OO.$��^_f�

��1tu:>]=,:5��1�Ôz�1Ð3oXRG�¬OB'1Ñö

[���()°Ë $Û_TO$��o78_f � u�� �Ôz�RG���$%&':ËÌBC�ýæ�1Ö×$OÏ'Ek<

?CMOXVX&ö9:�Ôz�1RGÑö[Ek<$îh_C�78_f � d�� D����X�1G*H��´Jt��a 1¼Ü�4½$6&'î

L^C�78_f���1Ç~,:T�BC��´J0M?[ÒU6[Ü7

89:/t�¢1�v9.~ÅB&OÁ-'&_f � ��� >]=7,:#ï��uLMFóôEN[Â�^_TO$�¡B'%9:

#RO1xyøùÖ×[L[^_Ch11�OB'Ülª$Fã_TO[�

1jk;��#$©^v����1ãÜC)$'h'&_f>]=7,:&

$���1v�$D1P��·[�AX&��´Jç�è [ ^_#$

6&',óôE,¦0:78_O��^_f � ��� >]=7,:���?z#1��0M$QR$)¹[(Q^_z{[l

\^_Ch:#ï��1Mu&1üuoXL[[§¨^_TO[��B'&

_f � q�� >]=,:óôE1Â�$�¡B'&_.11:óôE[@A^_1$

�Ï'&_a¸[���()°Ë ?ê6$÷ABCÏÙ1a¸$öA^_

v����D$'h'&_f

8 TiV1S�,:Dairy Farmers of Canada?�����$TJBCðñ$.OØ&'%9:Â1ï�,+=¬1U� Ì�$öVªi'&_f

30

� ���>]=,-1�[º»^_TO¿~B'%9:+1�$6&',-

�ö1�OB'10�ìí[ë�^_CcÀ9^_v����D$'h

'&_f � ����#1 tO+�:>]=.�ÏÙ$¡^_�XY$v_5:1¶·

¸I¹1º»$ JB'&_fÅCû?¶·¸I¹[ÙJ^_U1WlXA

á.DÊ78_f#6¾¿ÀI:¶·Á�:ÂB'¶·ÈÉL¬1Â�[/

�^_Ch:v9��U6[ÜXjk;���?DÊ78_f ������ �����Ëo�¿À�

� ��������1���u�[hWÏ'���$OÏ'ÉÊÓÏC@,:j

k;1.O7(QRGK-?/0ªiX&TO78_fiÏ'>]=OB',T

1rb$jnB'&'.¦�!7,X&f � ���u�$¡^_>]=1X�,f��.ü.��7.Xc:�)VUO&

s:¼��Å&} ½O.�áC�.178_fT1=¬7,:���u�?

lm­5}1��v9.lU$Yi'&_OV'&_.11:>]=OB',:

#ï��:¶·78:ÂB'/t�ýæ�$É�X��[Z&'&_f � >]=7,:z� q�Ô120oX��$�¡BC���1ãÜC)1[¥

[X�B'&_fz� q�Ô[ë�^_TO?¼���$%&'(QRG[§

¨^_õ7UAo$Éʽ78_O^_1?>]=1[\$%78_f � \H(Kaiser),:���u�$¡^_��[]_Ch:>]=1S^Ot_BCf×1`$vis:g�@$%&',���,v3$`&.178_Ch:���

OB',z#1 t[��B¨ã_TO?§�78_fO,&:bc1@$%

&':ÂiE��r?%UBCO,VViX&fªV$:���$OÏ'¦Ø

a¿OXÏ'&_bc1�r$6&'TiUVlmBXc',XVX&fTi,:

F�N/t�ýæ�$�^_ÊbOF�N#ï��$�^_Êb$�',Å_f � /t�ýæ�$�^_Êb$6&':���,:z�� q�Ô1Ti�õ1

&UX_20oX��$.�¡^_ t[c�B'&_fT1�r$,ÅÓUd

?6&'%V�:��X_UAUVX&O&�1?Â1S^1�$ÓÏCf×,:

���u�$:���?8_BMQR$¡�^_Nä?8_O4-'&Cf×,

¼e�½1^_$6&':�61�X_@A[\?!Yªi'&_OÈÏCf�

�£�$!YªiC-ª1[\,:�Ô[��^_Ch1�w\\789:è

s�Ô1��Úu?u��78_tu:Â1#?ÚuUVe�B'&_E�:Â

1#$OÏ'1ô�ü ��ýæ�[`ß_TO$X_fe�$�^_�6Ú1

\\,:Â1#?z#$OÏ'¼æ�çèéê½78_O�X^ÙÚ1a$.O

Ø&C.17:èsæ�çèéêXÙÚ1a?b&E�:ô�ü ��ýæ�

[`ß_TO$X_f���,:e�$�^_¯H1^_[��B'&_f � >]=7,:æ�çèéêXÙÚ$�^_���u�1Êb$jnB'&_f

���?(QRG[ë�^_Ch$,:#J\]?DÊ78_f>]=$vis:

æ�çèéêXÙÚ[\�B:Ti[èío$O_TO, Â78_fBUB

31

X?V:«¬oXï�$6&',TiUVlm^_DÊ?89:>]=?T1q

A[��^_U:Ti$�¡^_U,-no$,®¯1�q$âÙªi_f � #ï/t[hW_�r$6&':f?`BCS^,:��1�¬Ö×,�#$

OÏ'.<T$OÏ'.ÂiE�ÉÊ7,X&O4-'&_OÈÏCfÅC��

1�¬Ö×,:���$OÏ'.ÂiE�ÉÊ7,X&f«¬oXï�[ghh:

z#$��$6&'���?HI^_1,lm1?1��1TO78_f�

�$õö/0[÷ãCtu:Âi?&UX_.178i���O�#$��[�

^f Î� � Ï� � ªÅ�ÅXG{UV:bc1#~$%&':()�,,-./012&*+�

,15678ÏCf�5$:G�,<=o$:&$'(C)$OÏ'*+o¾¿

78_OVVi'�CTOf�w$:§¨oXG*:SMX��4:­Q1®

¯oX¦°±:ÂB'�M$Ü&­Q1��Ä94X�1@7&iXÙÚ789:

T�BC&4?:5�oX��ÐÇ�/t�¬9X�:/t$%ã_ïeoX¦

ØA41�>OXÏ'�CTOf�î$:G�/t?jno$äåoU623o

X4.[À'&CCh:T1TO?G�10&11/t�¬9[()Zv9.

,_U$2hCTOf�k$:÷æ���C#OB�C#O157G�G*1T

UY,$�h'��X��?89:B�C#?#ï��[#6��v9.Scë

�^_Ch$,#JK-[ê&BXc',XVXUÏCTOf-¯$:()q?:

#ï1()Z[\]^_Ch1]ß��1´J[�h'abo$KB"hCT

OfiÏ':�ÏÙ1#JK-[�à$��^_TO$6&',&UX_.17

8i#6oXu�[�_TO?ìíX§�4?8_fÂ1rb:®¯1jk;l

m$%&'.�ÏÙ?èío$OAi_§�4?S&f � �����������u�$,T�BCîï?$9úÅi'&_v�$$

_f���u�1Þ7,:�ÔÕ1Ö×$�-'ÙÚ[3ÛB:ÔÕ1Ü&ÙÚ

v9.S&ÙÚ1Ý�Þßà[��cBXc',XVX&fBUBX?V:²#

,:5A1ÙÚ$6&'¼æ�çèéêX½ÙÚ$mAB:Ti[�¯1lm1

¡ÎUVìí^_TO?7�_fbc1#~?:T1/A[�&:�ÏÙ[ìí

^_§¨[^_§�4?8_f � BUBX?V:pCX�����������u�7,:�·$6&'ÙÚå

1õö/0[÷ã:-.xyøùoX´µ1K-[�à$��^_v�'h'&

_fTi,:#ï��[��^_Ch1*×ROB'#ï��uLM1üM[�

Ï'&CTiÅ71jk;���[ÐÑ^_TO$X_f5�1#~7,ge 

aX����0M[ê&B'%9:TiÅ71jk;���7,Ti[v3$ó

ôE$@LB'&XUÏCf�#%vS���[Äh:B�C#7,:()�,

?óôEM1UX91zu[3h'&_Ch:ÙÚå1�·1õö/0[ê&B

Ctu:()�,$-.ÅÆX��?�áf#ï1���O#6����1A

32

á$6&'·¸$$sB:�#O���1óôE[@A^_6$T�BC0M[

v3$���þ^_C�78_f � ªV$:T1u�7,:¶·Á�0M�#ZxyÃ+FEk<N[Äh:8V

³_´µ1¶·¸I¹[º»^_v�Ah'&_fT1TO,:²#?z#1N

O�ÏÙ[øí1/t7P3^_H [0ö^_fge:bc1#~$%&':

#ï��[Scë�B66:NO�[��.Bc,P3^_K-?cLªi'&

_fjk;���$v9/0ªi'&X&(QRG,®¯.Â�^_TO?7�

_fjk;���1Þ7WnX¶·¸I¹,0öªi'&_.11:bc1#~

?¼PQHXY½¶·¸I¹Z�MF<E<NOB'Aá7�_:¦oWX�Ï

Ù¶·ÈÉK-[Â�B'&_f�����������u�7,8V³_´µ

1¶·¸I¹[¡Î$Äh'&_Ch:¼PQHXY½<E<.º»^C�78

_fiÏ':TiÅ71jk;���1Þ7/0ªiXUÏCTiV1¼�i

C½¶·¸I¹[GYo$WVU$B:ê�o$L[^_DÊ?8_f��7A

áB'&_<E<,:��������?-noXu�$x^_1$DÊOªi

_¼PQHXY½¶·¸I¹[L[^_Ch1 �X1�OX_f � ��������7,:#ï��0M�¶·¸I¹?��ö�.�����v

9.�à$��ªi_.11:¼æ�çèéêX½ÙÚ[�Ô��ËÌ1¡ÎU

Vìí7�_Ch:��������¯1xy?&ÏÂ�z{|ªiCÁ/$%

&'5�1#~1()�,?G��_Iã$X_fTiV1#~$OÏ'1ÉÊ

Xp_,:��������1Þ7NO�P3K-.+�$0öªi_TO78

_fNO�[øí1/t7º�^_TO?ìí$X_Ch:#J\]�#ï1S

��[§¨B'&_#~,:®¯,#ï(QRG0M$�V�_[�X&f � ������u�$¡^_�#1 t$6&':ôD]7,:u�?[Ü:

[Ò:U6��oX.178_ö9:xy1&ÏÂ�1z{|[��^_O¤C

'&_fz{xy$�^_×V1$%$,��1¼6½?8_f�5$:¶·¸

I¹,º»^_DÊ?8_f�w$:�#Óã7Xc:�ÏÙ[PQ^_�ÊX

/t:^XA)<T:��:ÂB'���$%ã_/t�ýæ�[s�BXc'

,XVX&f-¯$:#ï1()�,1(9[ë�^_Ch:ôD]7,#ï

���[ë�^_TO$ JB'&_f � ôD],:��������1���u�$UX9jnB'&_fôD]

7,:Ti?�h'£¢�X�5;78_O4-'&_.11:T1��1£1

¯7HIBC�ÏÙxy$�^_×V1��[êg^_Ch$,X%&ÏÂ�1

À9?DÊ78_OÁ-'&_fôD]7,:T1���$v9¶·¸I¹?

h�$º»ªi_TO$�h'jnB'%9:Ti$v9:�ÏÙ1Ch$¶·

¸I¹[BÖ1v�$�Ï'&_Bó�u$v_¶·$¡B:�#1�ÏÙ?T

iÅ7v9.z�X´7787�_O��^_fÅCôD]7,:�����

���1���u�$%&':<T:�.�:��:ÂB'���X�1ÉÊX

/t[\]B'�CSÕX�Ô[Ý�Þß_TO?r9úÅiCTO$.jnB

'&_fÅCôD]7,:���u�$%&'5A1Ö×1#ï)+��1§

¨[îh_5\:�1#~7Â�B'&_SÖ×1��[�#1)+�,7ê&

33

ªi'&_v�XÜÖ×1��O�ðªÍ_v�áâØã'&_TO$��oÓ

ÏCf � ������u�$�^_���1�",} o789:+#7,-.ÉÊX

lm?TiUVÓOV'&_f>]=7,:���u�?lm­5}1��v

9.lU$Yi'&_OV'&_.11:>]=OB',:#ï��:¶·7

8:ÂB'/t�ýæ�$É�X��[Z&'&_f>]=7,:g�@$%&

',���u�,v3$`&.178_Ch:���OB',z#1 t[��

B¨ã_TO?§�78_OÁ-'&_fO,&:bc1@$%&':ÂiE

��r?%UBCO,VViX&fªV$:���$OÏ'¦Øa¿OXÏ'

&_bc1�r$6&'TiUVlmBXc',XVX&fTi,:F�N/t

�ýæ�$�^_ÊbOF�N#ï��$�^_Êb$�',Å_f

34

ÐÑÒÓ� Alston J.M., and R. Gray, “State Trading versus Export Subsidies: The Case of Canadian

Wheat,” Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, Vol.25, 2000, pp.51-67. Dairy Farmers of Ontario, 2003 DFO Annual Report, January 2004. Erba, E.M., and A.M. Novakovic, The Evolution of Milk Pricing and Government

Intervention in Dairy Markets, Cornell University Extension Bulletin No. E.B. 95-05, 1995.

FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations) (2000). FAOSTAT Statistics Database, [online], URL: http://apps.fao.org [��.

Kawaguchi, T., N. Suzuki, and H. M. Kaiser, “Evaluating Class I Differentials in the New Federal Milk Marketing Order SyEk<m,” Agribusiness: An International Journal, Vol.17, 2001, pp.527-538.

Romain R.F., and D.A. Sumner, “Dairy Economic and Policy Issues between Canada and the United States,” Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 49, 2001, pp. 479-492.

Roningen, V.O., and P.M. Dixit, Economic Implications of Agricultural Policy Reforms in Industrial Market Economies, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Economic Research Service, Staff Paper No. AGES 89-36, 1989.

Schluep, Isabelle, The Law and Economics of “Consumer Only” Financed Export Subsidies: A Context for the WTO Panel on Canadian Dairy Pricing Policy, MS thesis, Cornell University, 1999.

�4qr���sܼ�Ô[cLBC#6xyt5°±6Ï�18 -23/t1tu-½:uv�)�wxy� 54z 1{2|:1999�:pp.85-96f.

Spencer, L., and C.J.Blanford, An Economic History of Milk Marketing and Pricing: 1800-1933, Volume 1, Grid Inc., 1977.

Suzuki, N. and H.M. Kaiser “Basic Mechanisms of Japanese Dairy Policy and Milk Market Models: A Comparison with US Dairy Policy,” Journal of Dairy Science, Vol. 77, 1994, pp.1746-1754.

Suzuki, N., J. Kinoshita, and H.M. Kaiser, “Measuring the Degree of Market Distortion through Price Discrimination for Hidden Export Subsidies Generated by State Trading Enterprises,” Japan International Agricultural Council, Report on Economic Analysis and Investigation of State Trading Enterprises, 2001. F������Þ}'¼¶·#ZxyH�$v_/tøù41L[1]1 ¡-¼�iC½¶·¸I¹$Z�^_���å$v_øùM1L[-½:u)+/t~�y� 10z 1|:2001�:pp.21-29Nf

35

��

������� ���������

(ESE

)����

�����

(199

8)���

(199

8)���

(199

8)���

(199

8)f������!"�� #

$%

(&�'

)()*+$,

-�����

���

���

1 ./

�01

ESE

(t)(t)

(.23

/t)(.23

/t)(.23

/t)(45.23

)(.23

/t)Q

sQ

ePd

PwPb

E�=

E(1-

Pw/P

d)ES

E=(

Pb-P

w)Q

eES

E/Q

e

678

90,6

0012

,077

3,70

02,

145

3,49

30.

700.

2916

.28

1,32

59:;�

69,7

0034

,352

3,06

31,

442

2,26

40.

500.

2628

.24

815

<8=

351,

620

29,3

064,

922

3,44

64,

799

0.72

0.22

39.6

51,

365

0>?@��� A

CD

CBC� DEFGF�HI8J� A

Pb=(

PdKQ

d+PwKQ

e)/Q

s �G��?0L�MN�H

OP

� K-�A

FA

OST

AT Q87R8S@#$%A

USD

A S

WO

PSIM

TQJ�U�H

Q87

��'

V

36

H

O

Qs-

Qd

( �W�

) (���

)Q

Rd-

QR

s=Q

s-Q

d

D

Qs

���

Pw

G

QR

s

X�

��������

(YZ[TQJ

)

��\]�

���

^_`a

I8J� `a

Pw*

Pw’

EB

F

QR

d

( �W�

)

Qd

bcdW`a

C

I8J�

Pb

!"`a

!"`a

�e()

��()

A

^_`a

���

Pd

37

��

f�

1f�

2��

f�

1f�

2

ÔÔ

Ô(a

) bvÕ�Â�Ö×

Ô(b

) bv�ØbGÕ�Â�Ö×

���

Pd

ghi3�

Pb

��

f�

1f�

2f�

1f�

2

ÔÔ

Ô(c

) ØbGÕ�Â�Ö×

Ô(d

) ØbGÕ�Â�Ö×

ÔÔÔÔÔ

( bv�h

= Ù�"�h

)ÔÔÔÔ

( bv�h

< Ù�"�h

)

ghi3�

Pb

P2

Qd

Q2

P2

Qd

Q1

��

���

Pd

P1 P2

P1

���

Pd

ghi3�

Pb

���

Pd

ghi3�

Pb

XY

jk�7lI���������

Qd

Q1

Q2

P1P1

Q1

Q2

P2

Q2

Qd

Q1

38

=

Recommended