72
1 מכון ירושלים לחקר ישראל מיסודה של קרן ע׳רלס ה׳ רבסון העימות האלים הישראלי־פלסטיגי2004-2000 המעבר מיישוב סכסוך לניהול סכסוך01 כ- ׳׳׳*י«. ׳ יעקב בר־סימן אפרים לביא קובי מיכאל דניאל בר־טל ישראל לחקר ירושלים למכון שמורות הזכויות כל

העימות האלים הישראלי פלסטיני 2000-2004

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

1

0002-4002

. *- 10

!

I

00024002:

5002

, 101 .The JUS Studies Series, no 00024002:

:4002-0002 The Israeli-Palestinian Violent Conflict The Transition from Conflict Resolution to Conflict Management Yaacov Bar-Siman-Tov Ephraim Lavie Kobi Michael Daniel Bar-Tal

,

5002, 02, 68129

2005, The Jerusalem Institute for Israel Studies The Hay Elyachar House 20 Radak St., 92186 Jerusalem http://www.jiis.org.il

, 3002 4002. , , , , : , , , , , , , , , . : , , .

. 4791. 0002 1002 . , , , , . - . 51 . . , . , . - , , . , . , , , , , . -. . , -. . 09

. , , . , , , -.

9

31

39910002

91 72 72 33 04

.

: 54 55 75

0002 , , , , . , . , . . , . , , , . , . : . . . . , , . , . . , ) ( , . 9 .

, 3002 . , . : , , , , , , , , , , . 3 3002. , , , .

: ) , 1002(; , 0002, ;

1.

2.

3.

.

, , : , , , ; , ) (, , , , ,;

1.

2.

3.

01

) , , (; , , , . 5. 4.

:;

1. 2.

) 0002(. , .

11

j

39910002 , ) ,)intractabieConflict1

, )2891( )78913991(, . , , , . , , , , . , , , , ] ) ([. 2

:

1. .

Daniel Bar-Tal, "Societal Beliefs in Times of Intractabie Conflict: The Israeli Case", International ,Journal of Conflict Management ,)9991( ,)4(93 ,9 (1998), pp. 22-50. Also published in Megamot

1

.)pp. 443-491 (in Hebrew , , : )"? :("What Went Wrong in the Israeli-Palestinian Peace Process , 9991-1002: ): , 1002( ) ): , 5991( , , , , - 0002 ? ): , 3002( , ?): , , , 4002( , , - ): , 3002( , ): 2

31

2. . 3. , . 4. , : , 7691 242 833 491. , , . 5. , , , , . 6. , , , , . 7. .

, 8991( , , ): , 3002(; , , , 083183) 1002(, 42 92 , , , 383 ) 2002(, 21 51; , ) : , 0002(; , 0002-3002, , 393 ) 4002(, 6213; , - ): , 2002( )(, : - ): , , 3002(; , - ! ): , 2002(; , ): , 4002( , ): , 1002( , ! ? ): , , 3002(.

41

8. , . 9. . 01. , , . , . , . , . , , , , 6991, ; . , . , 0002 , 1002. , , , 4 3

, , , , . , . , , , . . , , - , : . , )5 4991( , , : , )92 6991(.4

3

1 5

, . , , 1002, . , 0002 , . . , , , , 6

5

, , .

. , , . , - \ 8 7

, , )02 0002( , , ... : , )62 0002(. Weymouth, Lally. "Stream of Life", interview with Ehud Barak, Newsweek (May 6, 2002); Ehud Barak, "Israel Needs a True Partner for Peace, New York Times (July 30, 2001); Ehud Barak. "More .)3002 ,21 an Actor Than a Leader", Newsweek (May , , )6 2002(. , , )41 1002( , , )6 2002(. ,"?Jeremy Pressman, "Visions in Collision - What Happened at Camp David and Taba International .34-5 .Security, vol. 28 (2003), pp , , , , , , )6 2002( , , )12 3002(; 0002 - ? - ) , 6181 3002( , , , , , , , . : , - 0002 .; , : 49911002): , 1002( , , , ; 8 7 6

5

61

. , . , . 01

9

.

11

, .

, , , , . , , : )1( 7691, ,

): , 4002(, 3354. Hussein Agha and Robert Malley, "Capip David: The Tragedy of Errors", New York Review of Books (August 9, 2001); Arie Kacowitz, "Rashomon in Jerusalem; Mapping the Israeli Position in the Israeli-Palestinian Peace Process 1993-2001", Paper presented at the conference "Assessing the Israeli-Palestinian Negotiations 1993-2001" (The Davis Institute for International Relations, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, 2004); Acram Hannieh, "The Camp David Papers", Journal of Palestine Studies, vol. 30 (2001), pp. 75-97; Dennis Ross, "Camp David: An Exchange", New York Review of Books (September 20,2001); Charles Enderlin, The Shattered Dreams: The Failure of the .)3002 ,Peace Process in the Middle East 1995-2002 (New York: Other Press , ,- , , 822532 , , 1 1002(; , , )12 4002(. ) Khalil Shikaki, "New Thinking about Jerusalem", Presentation at the Conference in Washington ."D.C., www. centerpeace.org. (September 5, 2000); Pressman, "Visions in Collision; 9

, , , , 9384 , : , , , 7273 , )5 2002( , , )92 2002(; , , )31 1002(.; ;

0 1

, , , )92 1 0002(; 0 , , )9 1002( , , )02 1002(. Tracy Wilkinson, "Blame for Camp David Talks' Failure Takes a Twist", Los Angeles Times, (July .)1002 ,92 1 7

1 1

;)2( ) (;)3( 21

491.

, , . , , . 7691, 84919491. , , . , : , , , . , , , 7691 .31

, 91, 8891. , , 614; , ), , 574, 794(. . , , 04 , , )32 4002(. 8491 9491 . , , , , . , , , , 7691 . , , , , 84919491 , .31

21

81

, 0002 , . , ) 1002(, , . , , , , , . , . . , . , 51 41

- .

. , , , . , .

, , , ) 1002(, 08. , , 923033, 063, 624. , , .51

4 1

91

, , 61

.

71

, .

, , . , , , . , , 81

, .

, , . 91

, , , .

, )0002(: ? - )6181 3002(. , , 813913 , - , )6 2002(; , , )31 2002( , , 943 , , 652752 , , .; ; 71

6 1

, , , , , , . , , . , , ) , / , , 1 0002(; 6 , , 12 0002, ) , ( , . : , : , )22 0002( , ) 1002(, 6; , )01,11 4002(; , )11 4002(; , , )31 4002( , , )51 4002(; , , )61 4002( , )32 4002(; , , )03 4002(. , , )6 2002(.91

81

02

, , 0002 , . , , , , , . 0002, , 7891 . 0002 , , 02

.

82 0002 , - , . , . , , 003 . .' , . ,

, : , . , . , . . . , , , , )61 4002( , , : . , , )(, , 11 , , , )03 4002(, 0002 ; : ... , ... , , , , )11 4002( , , : )81 3002(, )92 4002(, )12 4002(.

0 2

12

, . : 141 005 , 0002, 681 -045 ; 22 12

1002 28 007 .

, . , . . , , 4 1002. 0002 11 ) ( 0002 13 48; 32

1002 82 89 .;

0002, . , . , , , , . . , , , , . , . , . ,

, , 913: , , . .www.palestinercs.org Palestine Red Crescent Society , 921 , 071 , 1002 76 . , : ) : , 4002(, 104. : www.mfa.gov.il3 2 2 2

1 2

22

. . , .52

42

, .

, ) 1002(, . , , . , . , , . )491, 242, 833(, . , , , . , , . , , , . , 62

, , 863 , , 123913 , , ) 123(. 57 , . . , , )6 2002( , )31 2002( , , )03 4002(. . , , )03 4002(.;

4 2

, , )6 2002( , )31 2002( , , 913223 , , 82. , , , . , , )11 4002(.; 6 2

5 2

, , ) , , 3 ) 0002( 3.

32

, 72

.

, , . : / . A ) (. , . , . . , , 82

.

. , . , 92

.

: , 2 3002, 6121=http:llwww.memri.0rg.illmemrilL0adArticlePage.asp?lang1mge=Hebrew&enttype=4&entid /, : , , ; , ; , : , )22 4002(. , , % 9 , 8 . , . , , 93. , : ... , 204. : , 864. ,David Matz, "Why DidTaba End?", Palestine-hraelJournal 501-69 .vol. 10 (2003), issue 3, pp9 2 82

72

42

, ) (, . . , 13 03

.

, , . , , , . , , , , . , .

."and issue 4, pp. 92-104; Pressman, "Visions in Collision , , , )41 2002(. , , )6 2002( , , 614 , , 773, 544, 744, 554-654, .364674. Daniel Bar-Tal, and Keren Sharvit, "Psychological Foundations of the Israeli Jews' Reactions to Al Aqsa Intifada: The Role of the Threatening Transitional Context", Invited paper presented at the conference "Why Neighbours Kill: Explaining the Breakdown of Ethic Relations" (University .)4002 ,6-3 of Western Ontario, Canada, June1 3 0 3

52

j

I

!I

, 1002, 3002 ) (, . , . . , , , 11 1002 :23

, .

, , , , . , . , 1002 . , , , . , , . , . , , , 53 43 33

.

, , 82. , 1, 783983, 954. , , , )4 4991(. , , 783983, 954; , , 893; , ,

2 3

3 3

4 3

53

72

63

.

73

:

, , . , , . , , , . , . , . , , 2002.

763, , , )6 2002( , , )31 2002(. , , , )51 1002(. : , , , 4002, . , . , , , : . , . , . , )31 4002(. , : , ,- , , , , 2002 3002.7 3 6 3

82

, , , 83

_.

, , , . , : , , . , . : , 7691, , 14 04 93

.

, , . , , . , , )11 4002(. , : , )92 3991(; , , )22 3991( , )92 8991(; , , )91 3991(; , , )4 4991(; , , )92 0002(; . , : ): , 9991( , ): , 5991(. .)0002 ,51 J. Bennet, "Sharon's Wars", New York Times (August , ) , , (; , )01,11 4002(; , )11 4002( , , )51 4002(; , , )4 2002(; , )92 2002(. , : , 3343. 921 4 0 4 9 3

8 3

. - . , 34 24

, .

. , , . , 54 44

, .

, . . , , , , 71 , , 4

!

, . ) (, , 74

.2 4

, , , 383 ) 2002(, 6152 , , )92 2002( , , )51 4002(.;

, . .

3 4

4 4

, : , 23 , , , 23) 3002(, 3132. , , )4 2002( , , )(, , 0212 , , )51 4002(.; 6 4

5 4

, , )92 2002(.

7 4

03

, - . , . . * , , . , . , , , . , , 05 94 8

.

, ; : , , )5 1002(; , , )6 3002(; , , )52 4002( , , , )2 4002(; , , )41 4002(; , , )13 4002(; , /http://www.ynet.co.il , ,)7 3002(, , , .(2002'1,7340,L-1579249fl0.html , , , . , - , 9304, 44. , 93, 14, 44; , )32 3002(. : : . ... , , . )( )( . .0 5 9 4

8

13

, , , . , 15

.

, , , . , , . , . , , . , , 7691 8491 9491 . 35 25

, )03 4002( : ... ... , . , ; : 75, )03 4002(; , , 11( . ynet.co.il 4002( , , )03 4002(; , , )41 4002(. , , )6 3002(, , 2002(. ,4.0,2951-html(htp:/w.ynecoil/arts,7340L2 5

1 5

, : )0002(: )6181 3002(; : ) , 12 4002(. , , . : , , , , , )1002( , ): , 3002( , ; , ?, )(, , 3354 , , , )(, , 6465 , , )(, , 7586; , 75, )03 4002( , , )31 2002(; , , , )(, - 0002 < ) : , 3002(, 6136.; ;

3 5

23

, ) ( . ) 1002(. , 7691 , , . , , . , 45

, .

, , . , , , . , . , ) ( , . 55

, , , )11 4002(. . , 003 , . : , , )92 4002( , , )02 4002(. , , )92 0002( , , )92 2002( , , )4 2002( , , )31 1002( , , )31 4002(.5 5

4 5

33

, . 65

, .

, : , , , , . . . , . . . . , , . , . , , . , , . , 95 85 75

.

, 5991, 6991, . )Low intensity Conflict

, , )92 2002(; , , )4 2002( , , 5718. , , )92 2002(; , , 3. , , 84. , , 62.85 95

65

75

43

,(Lie . . ) 6991( ) 51 0002(, , . , , . , , )06

( - .

: . . , , , , . , 36 26 16

.

, , , 4282 , , )92 2002( , , 1323. . , , . , ) - , 42 3002(, . : , , , )92 2002(. : . , . . , , )52 4002(. , 3 6 2 6 1 6

0 6

53

, .

, , , , . , . , , , : , ... .... . , . : ; 46

; , . ; , : , , , , . . , : , : , .

, , ) 4002(. , , . , . . . , ) , , , , 1 4002(. : ), 03 4002(, . , . ) (, . , . , . , , 03.4 6

63

, . , , , . , . , , . , , - , , . , . , , . , . , , . , . . . , . - . . , . , . , , , .

73

. , , . , , . , 56

.

, . , ) , , ( . , . , . , . , , , , ) , , (, . , , , , , , 76 66

.

, , 4233.

56

)(, ), 1002(, 44: , . . , , 2151.76

66

83

. , )(, , , . , . , . 96 86

:

, . ) (, . 07

.

- . 2002 , . .

, , )92 2002(.

8 6

, , ) , 61 3002(. , , . 7 4002, , , , , . ) , 7 4002(. ) (: , . . ), 41 3002(.0 7

9 6

93

, : , , , , , . , .

, , . : ) 0002 1002( , )1002(; ) 2002(; ) 2002(; ) 2002 3002( ) 3002 (. , ) (, , , 11 1002 . , 0002 1002, , 1002. , , . , . , A 27 17

, .

, , : . , 1002, ,

, , 7282. , , )11 4002(.

17

2 7

04

. , , . ) ( ) ( . , , , , , . , . , . . , , ), (. , 1002, : )1( , 581 ) 1002( 61 1002. . )53 61 1002( )2( ; 47 37

;)3( 11 1002 . , , : . , , . , 1002 , 57

, , 8292.

3 7

, . , .5 7

7

14

. , . ) (, ,A , . . 2002, : 371 . 273 . 82 11. , 77

67

, : , )91 1002(. .)2002,1 Lee Hockstader, "Palestinian Authority Described As 'Terrorist'", Hearld Tribune (March , 1002 , . , , , , , . : , , 22 , )4 1002(; , : , )4 1002(; , , )81 1002(; , : , )02 1002(; , : , )42 1002(. , 1002, . , . : , , )51 1002( , , )32 1002(. 61 1002 , . , . , , , . , : ) ( , , . : , : , , )71 1002(; , : , )1 2002(. : , , )61 2002(; , , )02 2002( , , )12 2002( , , 561881.; 7 7

6 7

24

, ) 92 (. . , , , ; : . , , . , , . . ) 2002( ) ( 031) 173 (. 71 12. , , . ) 2002 - 3002( , , . , . 3002 , . , 2002. 2002 4002 94 343. , , . , : , , 18 08 97 87

, , 03. . .

8 7

9 7

0 8

, , -,www.idf.il , , )11 4002(; , 04 5: , )8 4002(.

1 8

34

. , , . , . , , , , . . , , . , , , . , 28

, .

, , , )2 4002(.

44

: , 0002. , , , . , . , , . , , . )39911002( . , , , , . ) : 1002( , , , . , , , - . , , . , .38

, , 813913.

38

54

, 1002, , . , , , . , 48

, .

, . , , . : , , . , , . , , , . , . : ) ,)Mutual Hurtingstalemate . .58

, , )11 4002(. , , : ... . : , .5 8

4 8

William I. Zartman, "Ripeness: The Hurting Stalemate and Beyond", in Paul C. Stern and Daniel Druckman (eds.), International Conflict Resolution After the Cold War (Washington: National .052-522 .Academy Press, 2000), pp

64

11 1002 , , ) (. , ) 2002( . , , . : 91 4002 ) ( 989 )496 592 ( 907,6 )117,4 899,1 ( 604,22 , . 05 . , . , . , . . , 710,1 895,5 , )82 4002(. .www.idf.il7 8 6 8

68

78

88

)3002(, , 301http://www.herzliyaconference.orgll&CategoryID_071= ?=ArticleslArticle.asp ArticleID , "It Is Important to Be a Dove, But It Is As Important to Know Why Do People D Become Doves", Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the International Society of Political .)2002 ,Psychology (Berlin: July )(, : -! ): , 1002(; , , , )8 3002( , , 7 )13 3002( , , )9 4002(; , , )52 4002(; , ) 3002(; , , )5 3002(; 72 , )82 3002( , , , )32 4002(; , , )5 3002(; , , )41 3002( , , )42 3002(; , )61 3002(; .. , , )82 2002(; , ,88

74

, ) (. , , . , , . , . , , . , . . , , . 09 98

, .

, , . , , . . , ,

)3 2002( , , )5 2002( , , )6 2002(. , , )72 4002(. : , , , , . , , . . 06 2002 62 3002, 31 4002 ) 1 4002(. 254 2002 412 3002, 79 4002 ) 1 4002(. , , , , , )1 4002(.0 9 9 8

84

. , , , , , 19

.

) ( . , . , . , . , , , ) (. , . , , . , , , , . , : ) 2002(, . . , . , , , .

04 ) 4002( : 027,2 000,52 , , 04 5: , )8 4002(. 1002 002,6 . 049 )%51( , , , 1 4002(. )

1 9

94

. , . , , . , , , , . , . ): / , ( - , 7691 ), ( - 39

29

.

, , , . , , . . . .49

, , )72 4002(.

2 9

, , )81 1002(: , 7691. , ....4 9

39

, , , )13 3002(; , ):

05

. , 11 1002 ) (. . ) (. , . ) , , (. , ) 2002(, . : 491 ; ; , . :79 69 59

, .

, ) (, , , ,

, 32 3002(; ,"Lavie, Ephraim. "The Road Map: Political Resolution Instead of National Narrative Confrontation Palestine-Israel .19-38 .Journal, vol. 10 (2003), issue 4 pp 61 1002 . 41 , . 87 . , , )31 4002( , , )5 3002(. , ; , 3002.7 9 6 9 5 9

15

. . ) ,(reassurance ) ,(conditional reciprocity ).(Graduated Reciprocation In Tension Reduction ) (, . , , . . , , , ) (. ) (GRIT , , , . , , ) (. , . 89

, , .

, . . , , . , , .

: Alexander K. George, "The Need for Influence Theory and Actor - Specific Behavioral Models of Adversaries" in Barry R. Schneider and Jerrold M. Post (eds.), Know the Enemy: Profiles of Adversary Leaders and Their Strategic Cultures (Alabama: United States Air Force Counter-Proliferation .013-172 .Center, 2002), pp

8 9

25

. , , , , . , ." , . , . , , : 001

,

. . , , .

Daniel Bar-Tal, "Psychological Obstacles to Peace Making in the Middle East and Proposals to ,Overcome Them", Invited address presented at the annual conference of Peace Psychology (Marburg Germany: June 15-18, 2004). See also, Search For Common Ground, The potential for nonviolent .Intifada, www.sfcg.org/documents/SFCGpoll.pdf .)3002 ,01 (December , ): , 0991(, 555.0 0 1

9 9

35

I

I

- , . , , . , . . 101

.

, , , . , . , , . , , . , , , , , . , . ) (, , . , , : ,

, , , )1 4002(.

101

55

, , . , , . , , . , , , , . , , : . , . , , . , , . , , .

65

Agha, Hussein and Robert Malley, "Camp David; The Tragedy of Errors", New of Books (August 9, 2001). Barak, Ehud, "Israel Needs a True Partner for Peace, New York Times (July 30, 2001). Barak, Ehud, "More an Actor Than a Leader", Newsweek (May 12, 2003). YorkReview

Bar-Tal, Daniel, "It Is Important to Be a Dove, But It Is As Important to Know Why Do People Become Doves", Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the International Society of Political Psychology (Berlin: July, 2002). Bar-Tal, Daniel, "Psychological Obstacles to Peace Making in the Middle East and Proposals to Overcome Them", Invited address presented at the annual conference of Peace Psychology (Marburg, Germany: June 15-18, 2004). Bar-Tal, Daniel, "Societal Beliefs in Times of Intractable Conflict: The Israeli Case", I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l of Conflict published in Megamot, M a n a g e m e n t , 9 (1998), pp. 22-50. Also 39(4), (1999), pp. 443-491 (in Hebrew).

Bar-Tal, Daniel and Keren Sharvit, "Psychological Foundations of the Israeli Jews' Reactions to Al Aqsa Intifada: The Role of the Threatening Transitional Context", Invited paper presented at the conference "Why Neighbours Kill: Explaining the Breakdown of Ethic Relations" (University of Western Ontario, Canada, June 3-6, 2004). Bennet, James, "Sharon's Wars", New York Times (August 15, 2000). Enderlin, Charles, The Shattered East 1995-2002 D r e a m s : The Failure of the Peace Process in the Middle

(New York: Other Press, 2003).

George, Alexander K., "The Need for Influence Theory and Actor - Specific Behavioral Models of Adversaries" in Barry R. Schneider and Jerrold M. Post (eds.), Know the Enemy: 271-310. 57 Profiles of A d v e r s a r y L e a d e r s and Their Strategic Cultures (Alabama: United States Air Force Counter-Proliferation Center, 2002), pp.

Hockstader, Lee, "Palestinian Authority Described As 'Terrorist'", Herald 1, 2002). Hannieh, Acram, "The Camp David Papers", Journal pp. 75-97.

Tribune

(March

of P a l e s t i n e Studies, vol. 30 (2001),

Kacowitz, Arie, "Rashomon in Jerusalem; Mapping the Israeli Position in the IsraeliPalestinian Peace Process 1993-2001", Paper presented at the conference "Assessing the Israeli-Palestinian Negotiations 1993-2001" (The Davis Institute for International Relations, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, 2004). Lavie, Ephraim, "The Road Map: Political Resolution Instead of National Narrative J o u r n a l , vol. 10 (2003), issue 4 pp. 83-91. J o u r n a l , v o l . 10 (2003), issue 3 pp.

Confrontation", Palestine-Israel

Matz, David, "Why DidTabaEnd?", Palestine-Israel 96-105 and issue 4 pp. 92-104.

Palestine Red Crescent Society- www.palestinercs.org Pressman, Jeremy, "Visions in Collision - What Happened at Camp David and Taba?", International Security, vol. 28 (2003), pp. 5-43. of Books (September 20,

Ross, Dennis, "Camp David: An Exchange", New York Review 2001).

Search For Common Ground, The Potential for Nonviolent Intifada, www.sfcg.org/ documents/SFCGpoll.pdf. (December 10, 2003). Shikaki, Khalil, "New Thinking about Jerusalem", Presentation at the conference in Washington D.C., www. Centerpeace.org. (September 5, 2000). Weymouth, Lally, "Stream of life", interview with Ehud Barak, Newsweek (May 6,2002). Angeles

Wilkinson, Tracy, "Blame for Camp David Talks' Failure Takes a Twist", L o s Times (July 29, 2001).

Zartman, I. William, "Ripeness: The Hurting Stalemate and Beyond", in Paul C. Stern and Daniel Druckman (eds.), International Conflict R e s o l u t i o n After the Cold War (Washington: National Academy Press, 2000), pp. 225-250.

58

, , )9 1002(. , . ? ? ): , 3002(. , , ,9429751-0437,1/o o . h t m l,ht p:/ www.ynet.co.il/artides )42 2002(. - ): , , )(, : 1002(. , . )03 4002(. , , : , )4 1002(. , , , - : )(, ): ,

, 3002(, 521. , , , , )11 4002(. , , )01,11 4002(. , , , )9 4002(. , , , , )41 2002(. , , : , )02 1002(. , , : , )22 0002(. )81 1002(. , ,

, , )32 4002(. , , ): , 1002(. , , , )6 3002(. , , : , )91 1002(. , , , )1 1002(.

95

, , : . , )5 4991(. , , , : , )92 6991(. , , 75, )03 4002(. , , , )7 3002(. , , , )42 3002(. , , , )3 2002(. , , ): , 4002(. , , , )5 3002(. , , ? ): , 2002(.

, , , )91 3991(. , , , )41 4002(. , , , )92 0002(. - : , )(,