Центральная Азия и Кавказ 2007 №04(52)

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

1/176

4(52), 2007

1

CA&CC Press

20074(52)

-

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

2/176

4(52), 2007

2

/: (994 - 12) 497 12 22 E-mail: [email protected]

/: (46) 920 62016 E-mail: [email protected]

(, )/: (994 - 12) 499 11 73 E-mail: [email protected]

()/: (+7 - 701) 531 61 46 E-mail: [email protected]

().: (+996 - 312) 65-48-33 E-mail: [email protected]

().: (992 - 917) 72 81 79 E-mail: [email protected]


(): (+994 50) 3006694 E-mail: [email protected]



().: (972) 2 5882332 E-mail: [email protected]

().: (49 - 89) 3003132 E-mail: [email protected]

().: (86) 10-64039088 E-mail: [email protected]

(). (7 - 495) 3163146 E-mail: [email protected]

().: (380-44) 524 79 13 E-mail: [email protected]

: 620720-0459

: 22 339

: M-770

CA&CC Press.

: 556699-5964

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

3/176

4(52), 2007

3

, , ()

, ()

, ( )

, , ()

, , - () ()

, ()

, , , ()

, , . .. ,

( )

, , ()

, () , ()

, , () . ()

() ,

() , - ( )

,

() , , ()

, , ( ) , , () , , - , () ,

. c () , ()

, ,

()

, ,

:

CA&CC Press ABHubertusstigen 9. 97455 Lule

SWEDEN

: www.ca-c.org , 2007

CA&CC Press, 2007

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

4/176

4(52), 2007

4

-

4(52) 2007 .

. .

: ........................... 7

. . ................................................................. 18

. . : ........................ 27

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

5/176

4(52), 2007

5

:

. . : .......................................... 37

. . ..................................................... 51

. . ............................................................. 64

. . : ( 2007 .) ................................................ 72

. . : .................................................................. 82

. . -

(- ) ...................................... 91

. , :. .

........................ 103

. . :

.......................................... 115

. . 1991 ............................... 126

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

6/176

4(52), 2007

6

:

:

.

.

.

. . - ............................................................ 140

. . .................................. 152

. , , , :. . ......................................................... 166

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

7/176

4(52), 2007

7

:

,

(, )

, , , , , , , - , -

, . , , - . , 22 , - 1.

- (). , , 2 . 2010 - 90 , 52,5 . , 2015- 150 79,4 .

1 .: . - / . . .. . : , 2004. . 198.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

8/176

4(52), 2007

8

( ). 2006 65 , 27 . 2.

, - , - ( ) .

-. , -. , (19% ), -3. - . , 100% , , , , , . 2006 5,3 . , 2010- 15 . 4.

. , , , - , , 2020 - . , , , - , .

, ; . - . 13 , . , - , .

(

2006 . 91,5 , 2% ), 2227 , . - , , , , , . - 3035 5.

, , .

, . , - ( ) -.

, , ( ), - .

2 .: . : , 2006. . 225.3 .:

, 2002 .4 .: . . 225.5 .: [www.centran.ru],

[www.gazetasng.ru].

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

9/176

4(52), 2007

9

, , , -

, -. - , - . , - - .

* * *

- .

. , - ( 10%- ). . - , 20 , .

10 .

, - , , - . - -.

, - :

) ;

) ;

) ;

) .

, (). , -

. , - , , -

. ,

-. , 6:

6 .: . . .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

10/176

4(52), 2007

10

1. -

.

, , . , - --. , ( , ) - ( : -, ). - - .

2. -

.

- .

3. - -

.

- - , - , , - , , , .

-

, - , - () . - , , .

, , , - - .

,

, - , - , - , .

: 17 1991 () 17 1994 . -

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

11/176

4(52), 2007

11

- 7:

) , , ( , ) . ( ) ( , , -), .

) - .

,

. , , - , - .

- - , - .

, -- , - . -

- - - , :

1. -- ().

-, . - - . - -,

.2. ,

, - .

3. , -

.

7 .: , 2002 .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

12/176

4(52), 2007

12

n :

-

( ), - ;

, -, - .

n :

- , ;

.

n :

- , - - ( -);

- - - .

4. - - , .

- - .

- -, -2, - () . , - , 9- , ; - , - , .

, , , .

-.

n :

) - -, 2002 - .

, 86% - , , , - . , -

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

13/176

4(52), 2007

13

, ; - .

, - .

- , , - - .

) 1 2 , .

n : . - (-

), , -, (). -

, , , ..

5. . -

, - , , .

, -, , , -

, , . - . - 8.

, :

) ;

) ;

) ;

) .

.

-, - . , , 2006

8 .: , 2002 .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

14/176

4(52), 2007

14

110,6%, - 107%.

. 2004 107,1%, 2005- - 0,6% ( 99,4%). 2006 102,7% - . , - . , 2005 12% - , 2006- 10,2% ( 2005 .)9.

, , . . , - : -.

. ,

80%, - , . - .

, , , ( ), . - .

1990- ( - ). - ( 4% 8%, 2006- 107,3%) , 10.

, , , , , - , , - .

, , . , - .

(236 .) . 2003 , ,

11

. , 1997 , - , - , . -

9 [www.centran.ru],[www.gazetasng.ru].

10 .: .11 .: .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

15/176

4(52), 2007

15

. 90% , .

, -, . -. 3% , 2005 4% .

. , , , , , , ,100% . , , - .

, , -

. 1990- . 10%, 2006- 107%.

-; , , (630 . . ) - . 50% . - - . - , . - 10 . 12.

, , , -

. , - - , . , , , . -- . -. , , , . . , , - . - . , ( -) 12,5 (!) . -

. , 13.

- - . , , :

12 [www.undp.tj/documents/CPAP%20Rus.pdf], 12 2007.13 . [http://www.miningexpo.ru/news/714], 12 2007.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

16/176

4(52), 2007

16

1. , .

n , ; ; - .

n - ( ).

.

.

n :

) , , - ;

) .

2. .

n :

) , - , , ;

) ;) -

.

3. .

n , - , - , - .

n :

) ;) .

4. ( - ).

5. .

n , , - - - .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

17/176

4(52), 2007

17

n - . , -

:) ;

) -.

, , , .

6. .

n - . - - .

, , :) ;

) ;

) -;

) , - - ;

) - ;

) - ;

) , - ;

) -.

7. .

n :

) (- );

) -;

) , .

8. .

n () , - . -

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

18/176

4(52), 2007

18

, , , -

(, ), - . , , , .

* * *

, - . - - , , - .

, - - . , - . - , - , , - -

.

(, )

- . - ,

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

19/176

4(52), 2007

19

, - .

23 - , . 15,4% ( )1.

, , - , , , , . - .

, . , , 2007 , ( -) .

. -

. , , -, . - , -, - .

. , , (2007 .) - , - 16 , .

, -, . -

- . 2005 , , , .

. (, ), - -. , - .

, , , - - , .

: , , - . - , - , , - , . - , ,

1 .: China Statistical Yearbook. Beijing: China Statistics Press, 2006.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

20/176

4(52), 2007

20

, .

, - - ( ).

, -. - ,, . - , . , , - . , , - , , - . - , , - , .

, - - -. , - , , - . ( ) - , , - -.

. , , - , . 2010 80%. , , - . 2.

, , , . -, : - , -. -, , - .

- - , . , , , - - . - , - - . 2003 .

2 .: .. [www.iimes.ru/rus/stat/2004/22-09-04.html], 12 2007.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

21/176

4(52), 2007

21

- . , 2122 2006 , -

-. - , .

-.

n .

- () - , , ( ) , .

,

2020 68 . , 30 . , 38 . 3. ,

, . -, - () - -11. , -- , - - ( 1999 .) - () -. , - . -

. - ( 40 . 30 ) (45 . ) - 4.

n .

; , , , .

. - - . -

, .

- . -

3 .: . , // ,23 2006; itch: [www.aksnews.ru/m/100357/fitch:_rezultaty_energodialoga_rf_i_knr_neodnoznachny.html], 12 2007.

4 .: .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

22/176

4(52), 2007

22

, , - .

- . ; - . - 2007 .

n .

, -- -: ( ).

- - - ( ) - , .

- 2020 , , .

- 21 2006 . - :

2008 , 600720 ,

3,64,3 /; 2010 , 300 ,

18 /;

2015 , 640 , 38,4 /.5

- .

. , - .

n .

, -, . . , 2005 - : (2300 ) (2600 ).

5 (. [www.raoes.ru], 12 2007).

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

23/176

4(52), 2007

23

n .

, ,

(, -) .

, - : . , - 2006 , - - , .

n .

- -

. ; - , , , - .

- -- . 2005 () 6 . . . , - , - . - , .

, .

, , - ( -), , , - .

- , ,

, , . - , - - - . - , - .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

24/176

4(52), 2007

24

- . -

, , , .

. , - .

, - (23 2004 .) - . .

-

: , - 67 2005 . - , , . . , -, , , - - .

, - . - ( , 1517 2006 ., -).

(15 2006 .) -

- , . : - . - 6.

- , 15 - 2006 , - . , - . . - - .

- (

) . - 2007 - , - .

, - , : , . ,

6 .. , 15 2006 . [www.kremlin.ru].

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

25/176

4(52), 2007

25

. , - , , -

- . -

, , - , -, -. , .

, -, , , , , , - , , - .

,

. , , , -. - .

- , , , ..

( - ) , . ,

- , - . , , - , . , , , .

, , , . .

, . , ,

. , ( , -). 510 , , .

, -, . ( - ), .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

26/176

4(52), 2007

26

, , , -

. , , . 2001 - (), 15 ( , -). , 40% -, 80%. , 7.

( ) - : , . - -

. , - ( ) , , , , .

, 2006 Sonatrach - , . , - .

. , . . , -, , -

; -, .

, . (, , , ), , , . - , - .

, , - - , -

, . .

2002 ( ) - , , -- .

7 .: // , 14 2007.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

27/176

4(52), 2007

27

. , - -,

2007 , . , - , . -

- , , . , , - , , -. - -: , , . - 60% .

, , - , , ( -), ( ), -

., -, .

, - , , - , , - , , .

, , -, , , .

:

, ,

(, )

, -. -.

- (, , ,), -

- - () .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

28/176

4(52), 2007

28

. - , - ; - , .

, . - , , , , . ,

(, , .). . 1, -, (), (- ) (, 64,1% 80,8%) - . 6,4 ( ..), 2,6 ..

1

1

( ) - , .

(. . 1).

1 .

80,8%

11,5%

7,7%

64,1%

25,0%

10,9%

()2,6 ..

()6,4 ..

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

29/176

4(52), 2007

29

, , , . 65,8 . , 9,3 . . : 49,7 . ( 75,5% ), 16,1 . (24,5%).

( 4 000 ) - , - (50 ) - ( ). -

26 600 59 747 . 0,85 /. . . , 12,6 . . . ( ) 8,2 . 3.

13 600 - - .

, 319, 15,63 , 135,8 -. 208 - 14,78 , 111 , 851 . (5,4% ).

228,5 -, - 26,1 . . -

3,27 - : 5,06 -, 1,73 -. , 164,8 - ( 72,1%) 63,7 -(27,9%) .

, , 135,8 -, 60% - (. . 2).

1

2

-

() 2006

() , %

438,3

110,9

0,06

0,05

2 355

430

0,005

0,001

135,8

68,5

5,3

7,8

2 .: . ., 19621964, .3 .: () .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

30/176

4(52), 2007

30

136 -, 68 -. , 32 -.

: 2006 5 322 - (7,8% ). - .

. -

2

() 4

% -

:

(, )

100,0

40,5

59,5

228,5

92,7

135,8

26,08

10,46

15,62

3

5

- %

31,3

23,4

7,8

0,9

7,8

4,7

9,4

3,4

10,0

1,3

100,0

4 .5 .

10,0

7,5

2,5

0,3

2,5

1,5

3,0

1,1

3,2

0,4

32,0

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

31/176

4(52), 2007

31

, 100 3,9 -. -

, , 150 17,5 -, 45 18,4 -. , . ( ) .

. , 40% - (, , , , , , ). 16,6% . - . , . (. . 3).

, 1990- . - , , , .

, .

- , , - , , .

XIX . , , , , - . 1930- .

( ) . -, . - 1948 .

, - : - , . .

1 2006 , - - 78,8%, 16,6%, 4,6% (. . 4).

, , . , , -

.

. - ( ) 46% 7 5007 800 , 1020% 5 5006 500 , 3040% 3 5004 500 , 2030% 5 5006 500 . : 30% 5 500 , 30,5% 5 300 6.

6 .: . . . V. ., 1963.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

32/176

4(52), 2007

32

. 2 750 , 40%. , 1987 .

, - - ; . , , - ( 20 45 . ), ( - ), ( 2226 ).

, , ., , (1 5001 700 ). , , .

- 1 . -

, . -, . ., - , . - 8.

. - 813,2 . . . - ( - ). , , ( ) . - : 1 34 . 9.

, -. , - - . 20012006 56 . , 3 (, 1958 .).

4

( )7

1

++1

2

,

:

13,7

3,7

1,6

8,4

54,7

49,8

0,5

4,4

429,9

339,0

19,6

71,3

210,1

164,9

13,5

31,7

216,0

170,3

6,1

39,6

3,8

3,8

7 .8 .: . . . V. ., 1963. . 90.9 . . 252.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

33/176

4(52), 2007

33

1868 . . . - , 1877-. 1881- . ; 10.

19291930 , , . - 1947 , . 1984 , . ( 1 2007 .) - 16 : , -, , --, , - .. : , , , . - + 180 , 11,0 . 2006 63,5 . .

, ( ), , , - -, 0,53 .

. -(, -, ) . , .

: , .

- , , - 4,5%, . - .

, - ; .

, , ; - .

, . .. , , - . , -, - , .

, , , . 19541963 , 1967 : 2 712 . 11 - 11.

, .

10 .: . ., 1972. . 193.11 .: .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

34/176

4(52), 2007

34

1 2007 : , . -

8 317 . , 1 2 513 . - 2 5 804 . . , 2006

21,4 . . . 2007 1,8 . , 66,7% , 33,3% (. . 2).

2

2007

,

-- . , , .

: 1987 17,6 . . ( ) - . , () 1990- , 112 484 . /-, 22 630, 6 110

1 83 744.

, , 651000. - . - , - (0,222,9 /), .

. (450 .. 450 ..).

200 250 . . , . .

, - : 1950

66,7%

33,3%

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

35/176

4(52), 2007

35

, 1951- . 1957- 17 , (43%). -

, 1950- , . - - () , .

. - - , :

28 - ;

- ;

;

.

( .. ) - , , -, , .. (15 ). - . , . . .

- . - , .

1,3 - , , (4,1 /) 4,5 -. 0,5 0,9 /., 1,5 /.

1980- - - - . - - . 12.

- . 2004 . . - . - , , - (25 ) , . -

12 .: . . . ., 1987.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

36/176

4(52), 2007

36

, Risf - 13.

:

(-, ..);

.

, , - , - 120 14 . . - .

-, , . - 3,24,7 -. 260 . .

, , - . - . 1990- - . .

, , - . - :

1) , , - , - , ;

2) . - - , 15.

, - . - , - .

- , - .

13 . ., 2004.14 .: . ., 2006

( . .).15 .: . ., 2004. . 183.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

37/176

4(52), 2007

37

:

:

(, )

:

- , . , - , - .

:

- . , - , -. XIX - ,

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

38/176

4(52), 2007

38

.

: - , - , - . - , - . , .

1990- -

-. - , , -, , , - -, - , 10 .

- ,

. - - - - - - . ,, , , - , , - 3.

- . (1993 .). -, -

, - ,

- 1. XX , - , , - -, . , -

. - , - . .

, , . , , ( ), - - 2,

, - 1953 . ( .) , 1979 , -

1 1901 -, . - 19041905 . - -

, , -, - - .

2 1953 , - , - . , . 1951 - - , .

3 .: Jaffe A. US Policy Towards the CaspianRegion: Can the Wish-list Be Realized? // The Securityof the Caspian Region: SIPRI, 6 January 2000. P. 1.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

39/176

4(52), 2007

39

, , , - , , - . , , -, , , .

, -

, , , . - , .

, . - , , . , .

, -

- ., , , : , , - - . - ,

. . - , -, -, - - , 4.

, -

, , - - . - , , - , 1991 5, - , , -

- 1992 6.

4Cohen A. US Policy in the Caucasus and CentralAsia: Building a New Silk Road to Economic

Prosperity // Background paper 1132, the Heritageoundation, 24 July 1997.

5 , - 1993 , - , , , - -.

6 .: Jaffe A. Op. cit. P. 12.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

40/176

4(52), 2007

40

, - -

, , - . , - - , , , .

, 30 - , - 7.

- . -, . , , -

, , - - , - . -: , - . , , - 8. , - : , , . , : 9.

, - , -, . . ( ) , NIOC - , 10.

11 2001 - , , - - . - , - , -

. , - - , . - -

7Jaffe A. Op. cit. P. 3.8Cohen A. Op. cit.9 Ibidem.10 .: Hays .W. US Congress and the Caspian [http://www.ourworld.compusrve.com/

HOMEPAGES/USAZERB/333.htm].

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

41/176

4(52), 2007

41

, , 11, .

, , - - - , -, , - , , - 12. : 2001 . , , - , . -

, - , - , , , , , , - 13.

11 2001 . - , - , . - , , , - .

- - -: - , - , . , , , , , - , , -, - . , . , - , - , , 14.

- : - , , -, -, () -

11 1988 - .12 .: Hays .W. Op. cit.13 Opening Statement of Hon. Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, Chair, Subcommittee on the Middle East and Central

Asia Hearing: U.S. Security Concerns in Central Asia, 26 October 2005.14 Ibidem.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

42/176

4(52), 2007

42

, - . ,

, , , , - -, , , , . , -- - 15.

16, -, , - , . - , -.

2001 . -, - , : , ( ) () , - . - , , - , . , , , . , -; , - , 17.

18, - 19 .

15 State Department Advisory, 29 April 2005.16 , (. . 17).

, - - , . - 1744 ( - 1517 ). , , - .

17 airbanks Ch.H., Jr. Ten Years after the Soviet Breakup: Disillusionment in the Caucasus and CentralAsia // Journal of Democracy, 2001, Vol. 12, No. 4.

18

-: - , , , , . - - - . 1990- , ... , 2004 . - , , - .

19 .: [www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/cabs/caspenv.html].

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

43/176

4(52), 2007

43

, : -

, , - , 20. , - , - , - .

1998 - : - ; - ; - ; - , - ; - 21.

. , , : - , - , 22 . , , - , - .

, . -, - . , , , , - 23. . :

. , - .

. , .

. , - .

20 Shaffer B. U.S. Policy Toward the Caspian Region: Recommendations for the Bush Administration[www.ksg.edu/bcsia/sdi]. .: Kazakhstan News Bulletin, September 2001, Vol. 3, No. 2, 3.

21 US Congress, 105th Congress, Second Session, Committee on International Relations, Hearing, USInterests in the Central Asian Republics, 12 ebruary 1998 [http:/commdocs.house.gov/committees/intlrel/hfa48119.00/hfa48119_0.HTM].

22 Ibidem.23 .: Ibidem.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

44/176

4(52), 2007

44

. , , -24.

, - , , . - - , . - , - , - , - , 25.

, , - , , ,

. - 26. - - , , - .

, , , , , . . , , . - - : - . . - 27.

- , , , -, - (. ).

- ? : - . -

, -, XIXXX . , -

24 Testimony by Richard L. Morningstar, Special Advisor to the President and Secretary of State for CaspianBasins Energy Diplomacy, before the Senate Subcommittee on International Economic Policy, Exports and TradePromotion, 3 March 1999 [http://www.treemedia.com/efrlibrary/library/morningstar.html].

25 Ibidem.26 Ibidem; Statement of Robert W. Gee, Assistant Secretary of State for Policy and International Affairs,

Department of Energy.27 Ibidem.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

45/176

4(52), 2007

45

, , - . , -

. - , , - . , , . -, , -

. , -, , - ( . ..). , , . - , 28.

, - , , , - . . , - -, ( ) . 11 - 2001 - - . , - , .

1999 -

, . , - , . -, , , . 29.

11 2001 - . - , , - . ,

30

-31.

28Cohen A. Op. cit.29Klare M.T. The New Geography of Conflict // oreign Affairs, May-June 2001, Vol. 80, No. 3.30 ,

2005 .31

. , 2005 : : (.: [www.eurasianet.org/departments/insight/articles/eav091205ru.shtml]).

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

46/176

4(52), 2007

46

:

, ,

, , , . , , . , . , , .

, , - , - , , - . - 1979 . - , 1995 , . , - . 1996 , . 1997 -

, . , - , , 32. 2001 . 33.

. -, , . , ,

32 : ,

( ) - . - . . , - , , , (.: Hearing on US Interests in the Central Asian Republics.House of Representatives, Subcommittee on Asia and the Pacific, Committee on International Relations, Washington,DC [http://commdocs.house.gov/committees/intlrel/hfa 48119.000/hfa48119_0f.ht]).

33 .: Congressional Research Service. The Library of Congress CRS Issue Brief for Congress, Order CodeIB93033. Iran: Current Developments and US Policy. Updated 25 July 2003, Kenneth Katzman oreign Affairs,Defense, and Trade Division.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

47/176

4(52), 2007

47

. c , : ,

: , , . , . 34.

: - . -, . , , , , 35.

- - . - -

- , .

- . , , , , - , , . , - , - - , , , , - , -36. ,

- , , - , . , - - , - 37.

, - .

34 Statement of rederick Starr, Chairman of Central Asia-Caucasus Institute, Paul H. Nitze School ofAdvanced International Studies of Johns Hopkins University, before the Senate Subcommittee on InternationalEconomic Policy, Exports and Trade Promotion, 3 March 1999 [commdocs.house.gov/committees/intlrel/hfa48119.000/hfa48119_0.HTM].

35 Ibidem.36Berman I. US oreign Policy Challenges Posed by Iran. Briefing before the House International Relations

Committee Subcommittee on the Middle East and Central Asia, 18 October 2005.37 Ibidem.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

48/176

4(52), 2007

48

-, ,

, . 15 , , , , , , -, - 38.

-, , , , - .

, , - , . ,

, - . - , ( ) - . , , - , , , - . ( ) , - .

11 , . - - , . - , , , . 39 : . -: , , . , - , , - , 40.

, - , - , 41.

38 Sestanovich St., einstein L. Russias Wrong Direction: What the United States Can and Should Do.Report of an Independent Task orce, Council on oreign Relations (CR), 2006.

39 Ibidem.40 Ibidem.41 Ibidem.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

49/176

4(52), 2007

49

, - , . , -

, , - !. , : , , . - . , , , - , , , , -. , - . : -

, , . , . -, 42.

, , , .

,

- . , , - - , .

- 2001 - . , - . - , 11 2001 . , - , , . .

, : , - 43.

42 Prepared Statement, Subcommittee on Europe and Emerging Threats, Hearing on Developments in US-Russia Relations, 9 March 2005, by Eugene B. Rumer, Senior ellow, Institute for National Strategic Studies,National Defense University [http://wwwc.house.gov/international_relations/109/rum030905.htm].

43 , - 1 2002 (.: [www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2002/06/20020601-3.html]).

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

50/176

4(52), 2007

50

, -, -

, , , -. -

, - . , , , , , . - : - ; , - ,

. , - , , - , - .

- , - , - 44.

, - , . , -

, , 2005 45, , - .

, - -, , . , - ( ) , -, .

44 .: [www.state.gov/p/sca/rls/rm/2006/65292.htm].

45 , . - 187 , , , .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

51/176

4(52), 2007

51

,

(, )

- -

, - ( ), (, , ), - ( ).

, ., - - -, ,

- .

, , -, - -, - , - - . - - , - - . - -, ( ) -

,

-

, . - - . - , , --, . - ( ) .

- -: (, , -, - ), . , - . - , - , - , - , -, , .

, - . , -

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

52/176

4(52), 2007

52

, -

. , 1990- (, 19911996 .), , - . :-, ; -, , - , , - ; , -, - -, .

(19962001 .)

. , , , (). 1997 - . . , , , . - .

, - , . -, -

. (), . , .

(20012005 .) 11 - 2001 . , -

, - , -

- . -

. , - , - - -

, ( -

-). , 2001 - - - , , ,: 2001 - - .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

53/176

4(52), 2007

53

- . ,

- . , 2001 - - .

, . - , - , . , - , , - (, ) , , .

- . -

, . - - . - , - , . , - () - .

( ), 20032005 - , . ( - . ) ( ) 2005 , . - . - .

2005 (). , -- , , -

, . 2005 -

, ( ) . ( .. - .. ). , 2006 - , .

.-, : -

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

54/176

4(52), 2007

54

, , ;

(, ) ; -; ; .. -

. 2005 , , -, . , - - , .

. 2004 , ( 2005 .) -. ( ). -

- - , 2005 . , - .

-. , . , - - - .

. - . 1992 , 15 . , - , , , , - -. - , - .

- . ( 1997 .) -. , - , , , - , -

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

55/176

4(52), 2007

55

. .

, ( -) XIX , - . - ( 1999 .), . . -, , (-, ), - .

. , 2001 , - . - . 11 - -

; , , . - 2001 , - . 2000 . , , -- , .

- : 1) , - , - , ; 2) ( ) --, , .

, 2004 .

2003 - , - , . - , , , - . 2004 . - ( ) -. .

2005 , ,

. . 18 , , - , , , 1. , .

1 .: President Attends International Republican Institute Dinner [http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2005/05/20050518-2.html].

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

56/176

4(52), 2007

56

20042005 , , ().

, . , , - - , ( ).

. . . , -, - . , ,

, , - . .

, 2005 -. ( ) - . (2004 .) , - , (2005 .) - . :

1) -, ;

2) .

, - . 18 2005 , . , , , . , . , - , -

, . -

, , - , 2005 . - . 2005 , - , .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

57/176

4(52), 2007

57

. - , , - . - - - , 2004 .

- . -

. -, . , - , .

, - : , , . - , - . - .

-. , , . , , -, , .

- . , - - . , - 2.

2004

, . , - . . - , - .

2 .: Davis J.K., Sweeny M.J. Central Asia on U.S. Strategy and Operational Planning: Where Do We Gorom Here? Washington, D.C.: IRA, 2004.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

58/176

4(52), 2007

58

, .

( ) - , - . , , , - .

, (, ) . , - , , - - ,

. , , -

, , - - , . , , - , .

, - . , , 2001 -

, , , . -, 2002 .

, -, , , , - . , - , - . - , , -

, . - , .

, , - . , ( 2004 .) . . . - - -

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

59/176

4(52), 2007

59

. - .

2005 - , ; - . -, , 2005 . .

, 2006 , : -, . - - . 27 2005 . , , -, .

. , , , , - , . .

. , . , , - . - . , , - , , -

, , , .

. ( 2005 .), , - , . , 2005 : - laisser faire ( , ). .

(NCAP), - , , - , -

. 2005 NCAP . , think-tank. -, NCAP , - . - , . - , -, -

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

60/176

4(52), 2007

60

. 2006 NCAP 3.

2005 , - , - , , - ( , 2005 .)4.

- : . - , , .

, , , - .

- , ( )5.

- ( ) . , - . - ( ).

, . , , ( ), - .

, - , ; -

-

3 .:Rywkin M. Stability in Central Asia: Engaging Kazakhstan. A Report (with Policy Recommendations)on U.S. Interests in Central Asia and U.S.-Kazakhstan Relations. N.Y.: NCAP, 2005; Schwab G.D., Rywkin M.Security and Stability in Central Asia: Differing Interests and Perspectives. N.Y.: NCAP, 2006.

4 .: Starr .S.E. A Greater Central Asia: Partnership for Afghanistan and Its Neighbors. The CentralAsia-Caucasus Institute and Silk Road Studies Program. Washington, DC: Joint Transatlantic Research and PolicyCenter, 2005.

5 . : . , // , 2005, . 3, 4. . 8893; . // , 2005, . 3, 4. . 7287.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

61/176

4(52), 2007

61

, ; - ;

( .. - ). -

, - - . , . - , - . - ().

, 20052006 . -

- , . , ( ) , , .

2005 - . , . 2006 - - .

-

, - . , - . , , .

2004 , , . - , - . , . , -, . . - . , -

, -. , - .

, 2005 , . (, ) , -

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

62/176

4(52), 2007

62

, . -

, - , . -- , - .

. , , - . , 2005 - . - . . . ( - ),

. , . ( 2004 .) . , : , - . , - .

: ? , , -

, . . ,

- . . , - -, . , -.

. 2006 , - - . 2005 - , . -

, . - ,

( ): -- , . , - . , , , , . -

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

63/176

4(52), 2007

63

, , ,

, - ( ). , -

- 180 . - , , - , -. 2006 , . , . .

2001 - : 11 - , , , , , - . - 2002 , - 2006-.

- : - , , - - .

, , , .

- . . - - . , , , - .

- -, I , - - , . - , - .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

64/176

4(52), 2007

64

(, )

1,

10 - . , , 1990- 2002 - - - , - - 11 2001 , - : -, , - 2. - 11 -, - - , - - .

, . - -

, , 2000- . , -

-, , , - , , , , - - , -, .

:

1) ;

2) ;

3) -

.

- , - - , , -, .

1 .: .. : // -,2002, 9.

2 . . 55.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

65/176

4(52), 2007

65

, , , , - . - , - - , . - , , - , - .

, -, - , .

-, , . -, . , . ( , . ) , . , . ., , , , . , - - 3. - , -- . , . - 31 2006 : , , , , , , , , , , . , , -

, , - . , , , , , , -. , - 4.

3 ., : Starr S.. A Partnership for Central Asia // oreign Affairs, Jul/Aug 2005, Vol. 84, No. 4.P. 164; Macfarlane S.N. The United States and Regionalism in Central Asia // International Affairs, May 2004,Vol. 80, No. 3. P. 447.

4 [http://www.edinros.ru/news.html?id=110500], 8 2007.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

66/176

4(52), 2007

66

, , , -

. -- - , - , - , - . -.5

, 6 7 ( ), , , . , - - .

, - . , - -, . -, - . - , , , - .

- , -

: , . , , - , - , , , . , , -, - . - , , , . ( ) -, , - - , ,

5 .: act Sheet: President Bush Calls for a orward Strategy of reedom to Promote Democracy inthe Middle East. Todays Presidential Action. or Immediate Release. Office of the Press Secretary. 6 November2003.

6 .: . : . [http://www.centrasia.ru/newsA.php4?st=1120804020], 8 2007.

7 .: . -, [http://www.kreml.org/interview/94878025], 8 2007.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

67/176

4(52), 2007

67

, -. -

- , - . , , -, , - .

- (, ), , , - . - , , , -.

, , , - , - . - (, , ).

-, - , - , .

1994 -

. , - , -, . , ,: , - , -, - , 8.

1997 - - -, . , , . . -, , - 9. -, - , , .

, - - , .

. - , :

8Lake A. Confronting Backlash States // oreign Affairs, March/April 1994. P. 45.9 [http://secretary.state.gov/www/statements/9770930], 22 May 2006.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

68/176

4(52), 2007

68

, , , , -

, - 10. - , - : . -, -, .

- - , - , -, , -, . , , -

. , - , , . , , - , - . : - , - , - . - , ,

, - 11.

, , - . . -., . : , , , , , - . - . , , - 12.

, - -. , -

10Lake A. Op. cit. P. 46.11Eizenstat S., Porter J.E., Weinstein J. Rebuilding Weak States // oreign Affairs, Jan/eb 2005, Vol. 84.

P. 134.12 Clinton B. State of the Union Address, 25 January 1994 [http://www.thisnation.com/library/sotu/1994

bc.html], 10 June 2007.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

69/176

4(52), 2007

69

, . -, -

, , . -, - , , - , , - -, . -, , , , . -, - , - , - .

, , -

( -) . : -, . , , ( ). -. - .

- , . -

, - . - , , , -, , . , , -, - .

.

n -, -

- , , . - , .

n -, - . - , - , - .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

70/176

4(52), 2007

70

n , -- ,

, , - . , , - - -- . - , .

, . -

- . , -, -. , , , , .

, - .

, - -. , - . ( ) : , , , - . - : - , ; ; - .

, 13.

13 ., : Cohen A. U.S. Interests and Central Asia Energy Security // Backgrounder #1984,Heritage oundation, 15 November 2006.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

71/176

4(52), 2007

71

. .

. , , . , , - . 1990- - , , 14. , , , , - 2015 4 , 45 15 . , . , - . 2007 , -

, , , - .

- , . , , - . -, . - , - , : -, , , - , , - .

, - , , , , , -

. , - , , . ( , ). ,

14 .: . // , 2002, 2 (20).

15 .: U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Information Administration, Country Analysis Briefs: CaspianSea Region, September 2005 [www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/cabs/Caspian/Oil.html], 15 November 2006.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

72/176

4(52), 2007

72

, - , , ,

. - , - -.

, - . , - 2009 .

:

( 2007 .)

, (, )

1.

- 2001 .

- - 11 2001 , - -, , -, . , - .

, - . - 18 - 1961 . .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

73/176

4(52), 2007

73

, , , -

, , , . - , , . .

- , , , . - - .

, , , - , -

() E-3 Sentry, . . 2005 - - : : , 1.

2004 - , .

- -. . , 2005 . ( .. -

) . . - 2. - , - - .

2.

2007 - ( -

) , . - - 2001 . , , 2001 , .

1 [http://www.analitik.kg/politics/2005/08/01/895.htm], 28 2006.2 .: [http://www.lenta.ru/news/2005/10/12/base/], 13 2005.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

74/176

4(52), 2007

74

: 2 -

, - . - - 3.

, -, - . - : , - , - 4.

(8 ) , . . - (10 ) -, , , .

, , - ( ,17 ). 23 , , ( 23 ).

- ,

.

3.

. , .

. () , , - - . (6 2006 .) , - . . : , - -

3 .: , 2 2007.4 : -

[http://www.pr.kg/n/detail.php?id=16874], 11 2007.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

75/176

4(52), 2007

75

, . , -

5

. -, - 5 2005 , - .

() . - 6. - , , , .

. -

. . -

, - . , , . - , , , - , -.

20 640 . - , -. , 2003 2005 12 , 345 .

- . - , , - , .

. -, , , -

, , - . - -

- , ,

5 , , -- , , press, 24kg .

6 .: ., . [http://www.ng.ru/cis/2007-05-23/1_bishkek.html?sublist], 11 2007.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

76/176

4(52), 2007

76

- -

. : ( - ) . , , , , 7. - , - , , , - 8.

. - . : - ; - , ; - , - . ; , . . , , - . - , - .

, . ( ) , - , . , , -, ( ).

, . , . , .

- , , , , .

. - 9. : , - - ,

7 : [http://www.press-uz.info/ru/content.scm?topicId=2803&contentId=67504],11 2007.

8 : [http://www.kyrgyznews.kg/news/real/3196], 11 2007.

9 .: [http://www.24news.ru], 14 2007.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

77/176

4(52), 2007

77

, , , - 10.

. , 3 - - . , - , , - . , .

:

1. , - , , - .

2.

( ).3. , , , . - - .

4.

-

, -, , , , , . . , -, C-17 III.

- , , - , , - . . , 150 ., - 2006 , -. , - , , .

. , - , : ; , -

10 , 25 2007.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

78/176

4(52), 2007

78

, . .

, . , , . , - . - . , . . -, . , - . - , . - (55 . .).

5.

- , , - . ; , . , - - . - , - .

: - , , - , -.

:

- ;

;

- , ;

, .

- - .

: ,

, ?

, . - . - , , , , , .

, -, , -

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

79/176

4(52), 2007

79

(1998 .), (2000 .). , , - , .

-, - . .-,

, . , , . -, .

, , - .

, , . , , .

1 500 , -3, , 2 000 . -, - , 11.

. ( , ) , , , , . - [] 12.

. . , . , , 24 , , , 10% 76%13.

, .

6.

.

n 1. -

.

11 - [http://www.cnews.ru/news/line/index.shtml?2006/03/31/198886],12 2007.

12 , 15 2007.13 .: // , 25 2007.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

80/176

4(52), 2007

80

:

-

; ,

, , , -;

, 2007 , - ;

- , ;

, - ;

- -.

n 2. .

:

-, , , - ;

, -

- ;

;

- .

n 3.

.

- . :

, - ;

- ;

- ;

.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

81/176

4(52), 2007

81

-

. ( -) . , , , - .

, - , , , , , .

-, ,

-. , , - .

- , , - , . .

. .

, -

. - . , , . , 40 - .

. , . . -, .

, , - : , -

. :

. - , . .

- -

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

82/176

4(52), 2007

82

, . - , ( -

) . -- , , .

, , . - , .

:

(, )

1

, - . - , ( -

), , - - , , .

( - ) -, -- . - , .

, - , , , ( ) ( -). , , -

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

83/176

4(52), 2007

83

, , - .

, - . , , - , -, , -, . - . , - .

2 ,

. - - , , - : , - . , 1990 . .

, 1992 , - . , . - ; - ; - , -. - . . , , . . ,

. 1992 , XVI

, - - ( ), . - , , , . .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

84/176

4(52), 2007

84

3

, , , . , - - . - - , , - . , ( ) .

, - , - . 1990- , - ( ) . . - . -, . , ( ) , , ,

. , , -, . .

. - - , - . - , , , , , .

, ( ) . 1993 , - . - , . - - .

().

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

85/176

4(52), 2007

85

- : . ( ),

( ). , , , - -, . , -, , - .

, - , . , -, ,

, -. , .. - , ( ) . - ( ) , - . , 1990- , - .

, . , - , , , .. , , , , , , ,, . , - , ; , , , - , .. , , , , .

4

, - , 1999 () 2000

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

86/176

4(52), 2007

86

, (). , -

- - - . - , , ( ). - - .

, , , 11 2001 .

, - - . 10 ,

, , - (, , ), , , , , - , . , , - , . . , , - .

. -

-: - . , . , - .

, . -, , - ( . - ),

. ,

( ), - , , - , - .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

87/176

4(52), 2007

87

. , -, -

; -, , ; -, - , , , - ; -, , - ( ).

-. , , , -

. , , - . , , ( ) -, , . -, ( -) , , - ( , ).

- ( ) . - . - .

, ; , 2002. -- . - ,

, , -. . , - -. , - .

. ,

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

88/176

4(52), 2007

88

( 2004 .) - , , , 201- -

201- , - .. - , -, .

- - . 2004 - . 2005- - , 14 - , () . 19 - -

. , ( ) - - , - .

5

2005 . - - , () ,

, . , - 14 .

- , , . ( ), 13 - 2005 , . , , -. , , -

, , -, . . . : - , , - .

, , 25 , - : -

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

89/176

4(52), 2007

89

. . , -

. 2005 , 1991 , , - . - , . - , - - .

- . - , , , , . - - ; , , , . - -. , ,

.

, 2005 - , - , , . 2006 . , 1990- , , , , . , - .

- -, , -

. , . - . . - . , . -, ( ) -, ,

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

90/176

4(52), 2007

90

, , .

( -) , - - . - , , - , , - .

. , - , , , , ( 100 . .),

, - , - . - , , - .

, - . - , , - , , -, - . - , , . , ,

- .

, - , , , , - , . , .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

91/176

4(52), 2007

91

-

(- )

, ,

(, )

1. - ( )

. - ,

, , - , 1. , - , .

1 .: .., .. : - . .: , 1986. . 4849; ..

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

92/176

4(52), 2007

92

- - () , -

. , -- - 2.

.. .. , - - - ( ) , - (), - . , - . - -, , , .. ( , -, - ) - 3.

- , -- , . , - , , - . - , , - 4.

- , , - - - .

2.

- , , - - 1921 (1940 .), - . -. , - - .

, -

(), - . 3. , , , , -

: // -, , ,2002. , 12. . 9394, 102103.

2 .: ... .. . . . 4748.3 . . 5658.4 .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

93/176

4(52), 2007

93

5. -: , . , -

., . 3, .

/ ( -. ..) , - (. 8 . 3)6.

. 6. . 3. , - [ , , / 7]. . , , . -

. , - [ ], [ ] ( )8. [ ]9.

, . - , , - - , .

2003 . - . 5 , .

, 5.1. , 10. - - 11.

5.3. , , . 6 , . ,

.

5 . // -.

6 .7 .8 .9 .10 .

// .11 .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

94/176

4(52), 2007

94

5.4. :

12

. - , . , , - , -, , .

() . ( ). (Caspian Guard ) ( ) , - .

-

, ( , , ). - (. 10.1).

, - - (7 2003 .) , - . , , - - . , ( 9)13.

, - . , - .

10. , , : ... - 14. ? , , - - ?

, , , , .

, 5 . , , -

15.

, - , ?

12 .13 7 2003 . // -

.14 .15 .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

95/176

4(52), 2007

95

- - --

, , -- , .

3. -

, , - .

- , . - , - .

-- . , 23 2001 -3 . , -3 - (). -- -3 - . . -.

, .

, , -, , - , 16.

, . - , , .

., 29 2004 - , -

(- ), - - . . , . -, 17.

16 .: [http://rambler.ru/news/economy/10344/1798413.html?print=1].

17 [http://www.irna.ir/ru/20040929191800.txt.html].

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

96/176

4(52), 2007

96

2002 : -

. . . , , , - , 4- ; 10 . , 60 , 30 . , - 18.

, , - , , 2002 , 1998-, -

(- -- ) . - ; , 19.

, - . - , , , - ( , ). , , , - . , 2002 -3.

20042005 . -

, - , .

, - - .

2005 - , - . , 120 . -

, . , . 130 . - ( ) , , - .

18 .: . // , 25 2005.19 .: .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

97/176

4(52), 2007

97

- 20. , 2004

, , . -, , - , . -, - , . - 21.

, . , , ,

. , ,

- (). - . - , , , , - .

. ? , - , , ,

, . - , .

- , , , -, , , - , . - .

. - , - , 2003 .

, . ( 2006 .) . - . , . - , , .

20 .: . [http://www.apn-kz.ru/?charter_name=printadvert&data_id=283&do_view_single].

21 .: .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

98/176

4(52), 2007

98

, .

- . , :

n (- );

n ( );

n ( );

n ;

n ( );

n 22.

, , 19 . -- (. II), (. IV), - (. V), , , , (. VIVIII). , . IX ( ), . XI ( ) . XV ( )23.

, , - - .

. , - . 24. , , , , , . - - , - 25.

24 2005 . - : , , ,

26

.

22 .: - . // .

23 .: .24 .: -

[http://www.iran.ru/rus/print_news.php?news_id=34694&PHPSESSID=80ccca8e9f4a...].25 .: [http://www.politmonitor.ru/

index3.php?&mess=1130316047].26 -

.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

99/176

4(52), 2007

99

. - -

. -, - , . - . , 27.

. , . - - 28. , , . , , , - .

- : ; -

, .

, , .

XX - , 14 2006 , . , 29 . , - -: - . , . , - . 30. , - 31.

, -, , - . - , , . -. , 32.

, , , , ,

, .

27 : - [http://www.regnum.ru/news/577908.html].

28 .: . - ? [http://www.centrasia.ru/newsA.php4?st=1139219580].

29 .: . [http://vesti70.ru/news/full/?id=1125].

30 .31 .: .32 .: .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

100/176

4(52), 2007

100

, .

: - , 33.

. , , . , , , . , - , , .

. , , , , 34.

. , , - , , - . . 35. , - , . , -

- , - 36.

: 1990- - , ( - ).

.. , , , . ,

- , - , , -

33 - [http://www.interfax.kz/?lang=rus&act=print&int_id=10&news_id=585].

34 .: . , . 5 [http://www.iran.ru/index.shtml?ch=1& lang=ru&view=story&id=3718].

35 .: .36 .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

101/176

4(52), 2007

101

, ... , -

- ( , ..), 37.

, - -. , - , , - , - ( , ). - . 38. , , -

. , , , . .

, , - . , - ( , -, ) -. . .

, , . ( 20% , , ) . - . , 14% .

, , , - . - , . -: , -

. .

XX . , , , -.

37 .: .. . . . 100102.38 . . 108111, 120122.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

102/176

4(52), 2007

102

, . -

. , , . , - , 39.

2005 ( ) - , . , - 40.

. ? -, . , ,

, . , , . - , . , .

. - , (.. ). , -

. ( - ) . - - , -.

, -, - , . - , ; , . ,

, .

39 . . .40 .: .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

103/176

4(52), 2007

103

:

,

( , )

,

(, , )

- , - () .

- . , - .

- , , , . - - 2.

- - . - - : -

2006 , -

, 16 1. - - -, , - . - - -, - , -

1 .: Socor V. Tbilisi Claims Russian Navy Hold-ing Exercises ff Georgian Coast // Eurasia DailyMonitor, 20 October 2006, Vol. III, Issue 194, TheJamestown oundation [http://www.jamestown.org/publications_details.php?volume_id=414&issue_id=3895&article_id=2371563]. 2 Ibidem.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

104/176

4(52), 2007

104

- , , . - , () (AIP). - ,

. 4

. , ( , ) , , , 5. - - ,

. - , , - .

- - , . -- , , - - . - - . - , . - - -, , - , 2017 3.

- .

- , - . - - . , - -

. - , -.

3 -

(.: ., . : - // ,18 2005 [http://www.kommersant. ru/doc.aspx?DocsID=570863]).

4 .: Zimmerman S. Submarine Technology for the 21st Century, Trafford Publishing, 2006. P. 35.5 .: riedman N. Submarine Design and Development, Naval Institute Press, 1984. P. 81.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

105/176

4(52), 2007

105

6. , -

, . , -

. -, , - . - -, . , , , - - . , - , .

-, . , - . - , , - , , - - . , , - , - . , - , - - , -. , , - .

-, - , . , . - ( ) , , . , -

. , . , ( ) 7. - .

6 .: The Canadian Submarine Acquisition Project. A Report of the Standing Committee on NationalDefense, Issue No. 41. Ottawa, Canada: The House of Commons, August 1988. P. 33.

7 - . 1980- .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

106/176

4(52), 2007

106

19921993 , . , 1993 ,

, - , . - .

. , - . , , , . - , , - , , . , , - . .

- - , - . , , , -. , , .

, , , - . , - - ( ) . -

, , 2007 . , : , , - . , , , - .

, - . - . , , -, . - - . , -, . ,

. , , , 8.

8 , , , - , -. - , -: , , ,

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

107/176

4(52), 2007

107

, . , -

.

?

- . - , - , , . - - , , - , - , - , , - , , , , , - , - , , - , , , - , , - , - , , - , , 9.

-. , , - (, , ). : , , . -, , : . , - ( ), , , . , , - 10.

, - 11.

. - - , . , , , , .

9Booth K. Navies and oreign Policy. N.Y.: Holmes & Meier Publishers, Inc. 1979. P. 47.10 .: riedman N. Op. cit. P. 158.11 Commodore Denis Rouleau. Keynote Speech to the 23rd Annual Political Studies Students Conference.

Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada: The University of Manitoba, 31 January 2007.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

108/176

4(52), 2007

108

, . , , ,

, . - / , - - , , 12.

. - , , , . - . , : - 12 ( , ). , , . -- (

) 13

. , , - . - , - . - , - . - , - - 2006 .

- . - .

- . - . - , , - , . , -, , -.

, - , , . , , -

. , . -, , , - , -, . , , 1981 . -

12 Interview with Commodore Rouleau. Winnipeg, MB, 31 January 2007.13 .: Zimmerman S. Op. cit. P. 3.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

109/176

4(52), 2007

109

( ) - . ,

, -: , 14. , - - , , . - , 1990- . , 1996- RIMPAC -; 1999- JTEX/TMDI99 , - , , , - ( -). XXI , - , 15.

- ( ) . 1982 - () , - - , - . ( ) -16.

(AIP). , , - . , - 212a, - - . -, ( - ). 214 212a : , , , - . 300350 . 214 , - . , .

, - . , , . . , , -

14 .: Williscroft R.G. Is The Nuclear Submarine Really Invincible? [http://www.sftt.org/cgi_bin/csNews/csNews. cgi?database=DefenseWatch%202004.db&command=viewone&op=t&id=331&rnd=954.9177124505652].

15 .: Ibidem.16 .: The Canadian Submarine Acquisition Project. P. 34.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

110/176

4(52), 2007

110

17; , ,

. T-96, - , - . , , 100 .18 - , , , , 19. T-96, , , , - - .

- - MESMA( ). -

(), , , , -, 20. MESMA , , ( ). - 500 . , , - 21.

- . , . - . . ,

, - , .

, - . - , , , - .. . , - . - , , - .

17 .: Whitman E.C. AIP Technology Creates a New Undersea Threat [http://www.chinfo.navy.mil/navpalib/cno/n87/usw/issue_13/propulsion.htm].

18 .: Walsh D. The AIP Alternative: An Idea Whose Time Has Come? [http://www.navyleague.org/seapower/aip_alternative.htm].

19 .: riedman N. Op. cit. P. 131.20 .: Walsh D. Op. cit.21 .: Zimmerman S. Op. cit.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

111/176

4(52), 2007

111

, , 22. , -

, - .

. , - . - . , , , 2008. , , - , , .

, , ,

- . - - ( ) . , , , , . , , , .

-, . - , - , - .

2008 .

-2008 - . , , -, , , . , , , , . , -, , .

. - , , (31 2006 .) - , - . (CSNMG), . , 1936 , (,) 23.

22 - - . (.: Zimmerman S. Op. cit.).

23 .: Montreux Convention. Naval Treaty Implementation Program [http://www.ntip.navy.mil/montreux_convention.shtml].

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

112/176

4(52), 2007

112

, () 1936 , -, , , , , , , ,

. ( - ), , , . -, , , - , , - 24. , , , , - , 1936 - . , - , - , -25.

-

, , - . 2006 - 26. , , - - . - - . , 27. , - 2006 . , . . , - ,

, , , , [ ] 28.

, , . , , . , . (, , . . , - 19201921 , - .)29

24 . o - [John Daly] Oil, Guns, and Empire: Russia, Turkey, Caspian New Oil and the Montreaux Convention [http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homepages/usazerb/325.htm].

25 Ibiem.26 .: Cohen A., Irwin C. U.S. Strategy in the Black Sea Region // Backgrounder #1990, The Heritage oun-

dation [http://www.heritage.org/Research/RussiaandEurasia/bg1990.cfm].27 .: Ibidem.28Hill ., Taspinar O. Turkey and Russia: Axis of the Excluded? // Survival, Spring 2006, Vol. 48, No. 1 [http://

www.brookings.edu/views/articles/fhill/2006_survival.pdf].29Jackson B.P. The Soft War for Europes East: Russia and the West Square Off // Policy Review, Hoover

Institution [http://www.hoover.org/publications/policyreview/3202956.html].

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

113/176

4(52), 2007

113

, -, .

, XXI , 1936 , - 30.

- , , . , , , . - - -

31

. -, , . 21 , , . 2001 ( 2005 .) 17 32. 2005 . - PINR , , - , , 33. , - -

. 2007 , - , . , - , 34. , , - , . -, , . -, , ,

30Jackson B.P. Op. cit.31 2007 . -

, - (.: : - // , 5 2007 [http://www.vremya.ru/2007/96/5/179687.html]).

32 .: 6th leet Competes Black Sea Port Visits. Office of the Special Assistant for Military Deployments[deploymentlink.osd.mil/news/aug01/news_82901_001.shtml].

33 .: Intelligence Brief: U.S. Military Bases in the Black Sea Region // PINR, 19 November 2005 [http://www.pinr.com/report.php?ac=view_report&report_id=401&language_id=1].

34 .: Dorschner J. Black Sea Security Taking the Helm // Janes Defense Weekly, 18 May 2007 [http://www.janes.com/security/international_security/news/jdw/jdw070518_1_n.shtml].

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

114/176

4(52), 2007

114

- .

, - . - , . , - , . - , , . , .

, - 35. , , 2002, - .

, -, , - . , - . - , -

. , ( ) - , . . , 1936 - : , - .

35 .: . // , 5 2007. . 5.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

115/176

4(52), 2007

115

:

,

(, )

, :

, . -

, -

-

. - - , , , - -, , . -

,

1 -. , -- -- . - - - , .

1 - - - - : 2020 6 2006 .

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

116/176

4(52), 2007

116

(TAC) 1991 - -

( 1 ), () - .

1990- - , ; : -, , , . - , , - .

2001 . 11 2001 , -, ( 2004 2007 .) -

, (2006 .). ( ) : --, , , -- .

( ) . , - , , . , -- .

- , - : ,

. , ( ) - . - ( , - ), - . , .

- -- . , , () .

, - ( 15 ) , , - - 2.

2Wegener H. Central Asia: At Last Europe May Be Getting its Act Together // Europes World, Spring 2007,No. 5. P. 16.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

117/176

4(52), 2007

117

:

20072013 ( 20072013), 2007 ( ), - , 2007-3.

20072013 , . , ,, -, , - , . - :

1) ( -; ; , - ; , - );

2) ;

3) -.

, 2003 , - 4. , - - , , ,

. , - , , , - . -, - .

-, . - ( ), , (, - , , - ).

- . -

3 .: European Community Regional Strategy Paper for Assistance to Central Asia for the period 20072013[http://ec.europa.eu/external_relations/ceeca/c_asia/index.htm], 14 May 2007; Joint EUSR-General Secretariat. JointDiscussion Paper on the Strategy for Central Asia (Project) [http://www.kub.kz/article.php?sid=17234], 28 April2007.

4 A Secure Europe in a Better World. European Security Strategy, December 2003 [http://www.iss-eu.org/solana/solanae.pdf ], 23 March 2007.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

118/176

4(52), 2007

118

.

- . 20072013

, , , - 2007 , . , -, , - , , , .

, - . , , ; - . - 5. - , - , - , , - .

, - ,

. , 2007 , - , , . , , - 6. - , , - , , . -, .

. ( ) . , - 30 ( 2009 .).

7. , , . -

, ,

5 .: Milov V. Russian Energy Policy: Challenges and Implications. Roundtable discussion meeting.Chatham House, 20 September 2006 [http://www.chathamhouse.org.uk/viewdocument.php?documentid=7916],15 April 2007.

6 .: . // , 2127 2007, 19.7 .: Xuanli Liao. Central Asia and Chinas Energy Security // China and Eurasia orum Quarterly, 2006,

Vol. 4, No. 4. P. 6567.

7/30/2019 2007 04(52)

119/176

4(52), 2007

119

; , , .

. , , . - , . , , .

.-, , - . -, - ( - ). - .

, - , , - .

:

- : .

, - - ( ) . , -

2007 , ., 8.

. , - , - , - , . , - .

, , , -,

9

. , , - . , -, , .

, , ,

8 EU Institute for Security Studies. Paris, 23 April 2007 [http://www.i

Documents

Центральная Азия и Кавказ 2007 №04(52)