121
제주해군기지 조사보고서 당 제주해군기지 진상조사단 민주당 민주노동당 창조한국당 진보신당 국민참여당

제주해군기지 조사보고서 (2011. 8.)

  • View
    219

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

2011년 8월 4일 야5당 제주해군기지 진상조사단이 발표한 조사보고서 입니다. 제주해군기지건설 과정, 과정상에서 발생한 문제점, 기지건설의 타당성 검토 등 제기되고 있는 많은 문제들을 포괄적으로 다루고 있습니다.

Citation preview

  • 2011. 8.

    5 (, , , , )

  • - 1 -

    1. ----------------- 31. --------------------------------------------------------------- 52. ----------------------------------------------------------- 73. ---------------------------------------------------------------- 8

    2. ----------------------------- 91. --------------------------------------------------------------- 112. --------------------------------------------------------------- 123. --------------------------------------------------------------- 15

    3. ---------------------------- 251. ----------------------------------- 272. ---------------------- 293. -------------------------- 32

  • - 2 -

    4. ---------------------------- 351. -------------------------- 372. --------------------------------------------- 483. ----------------------------------------------------- 604. ------------------------------------ 805. ----------------------------------------- 89

    5. ---------------------------- 991. ----------------------------------------- 1012. -------------------- 1033. ------------------------------ 109

    6. ----------------------------------------------- 115

    7. ---------------------------------------------------------------- 119

  • - 3 -

    1.

    1. 2. 3.

  • - 4 -

  • - 5 -

    1.

    2007 6 4

    ,

    , , , 5

    5(, , , ,

  • - 6 -

    )1)

    2011 4 5 5 5

    2011 5 4 22 5 , 2011 6 (6 22 7 1 )

    1) ()

  • - 7 -

    (17)

    (2)

    (2)

    (1)

    2.

    5 2)

    2) () ()

  • - 8 -

    3.

    4.28() 5, 5. 2() , 5. 4() 1 * , (17), (2), (2), (1) 22 5.12() 2 5.13() 5.23() ( )5.27() , 6. 8() , (

    )6. 9() 3 6.22() 4

    ()6.23() 5 7.13() , 7.29() 6 8. 2() 7 8. 4() ()

  • - 9 -

    2.

    1. 2. 3.

  • - 10 -

  • - 11 -

    8 200720143)

    53(16.1) 4(1.2)49(14.9)- :29(8.7)- :20(6.2)

    1 304 534 9,770

    15 2

    2,400m 2,500m 20

    1.

    3) 2015 1

  • - 12 -

    534 9,770

    2006 - 2

    2007 - 20

    2008 - 174

    2009 15 326

    2010 115 641

    2011 - 1,516

    2012 103 1,825

    2013301

    2,454

    2014 2,812

    2.

    (1) 4)( : )

    * 2011 2010 * 9,770 1,372 ( 14%, 11.6.30 ), 100% ( 642)

    4)

  • - 13 -

    (2) 5)

    07. 6 , ()07. 6 ( )07.12 ( )

    , 08 174 08. 8 KDI, B/C 1.11.7

    08. 9 30 09. 4 (, , )09.11 10. 3 * 10.12

    11. 6 ()11.10 12. 1 (14.12 )

    5) : (11.6.15)

  • - 14 -

    : 29(8.7) : 522

    (10.7)

    ( 96%)-: 74-/:70/4

    (11.6 )

    : 29(8.7) : 3.2

    , (10.511.4)

    - 3.0(34%) - 2.4(28%)

    (11.6)

    - 2.4(28%) (11.69)/

    - 2,400m- 2,500m : 5,029

    - 1 (5.15)- 2

    (11.6 ) (11.6) (11.7)

    : 8(2.4) : 2,188

    (5.13)

    (11.712.9)

    (12.1015.6)

    : 616 : 877

    /(11.6) (12.813.4)

    (13.515.4)

    : 3.5 : 395

    (11.6)

    (11.612.9)

    (12.1014.9)

    : : 23.36

    ()

    /(11.6)/

  • - 15 -

    3.

    (1)

    ()93.12 (156 )95.12 19972001 97.10 ()9901. * : , , , , ,

    * :

    02. 5 ()02. 6 , 2

    02. 7 () / 02.10 , * 25%, 58%

    02.12 , 04. 9 20062010

    20054 ,

  • - 16 -

    5 6 , 1 8 , 10 *

    11 , 12 *

    ,

    20064 , 20062010

    ( ) , 5 7 2006 (/ 5.97)7 2 , 8 , 20072011 ( )9 , 10 (ENG)

  • - 17 -

    * , 11 (ENG)12 , 07 (20) * 20 ,

    2007 3 2,

    * , 1/2, , , , 8

    1, 4 , (4.11)* 07.5

    , ( 600) (4.12) (4.26) (4.27) , (4.30)* (), (), () 3

    , 5 , 5.111

  • - 18 -

    1 (5.34)2 (5.1112) , (5.14) (5.18) * : : 6 , (6.5)

    , (6.8) , (6.22)7

    , (7.4) , (7.19)8

    () (8.20)* 725 , 680, 35, 911 , (11.8)* ( 2), ( 1)12 ,

    , 08 174 (12.28)

  • - 19 -

    20081 , (1.30)48 KDI, 4 , ()

    (3.115.9) , (4.16)79 , 9 (6 )10 ()

    , 08 174 (10.13)12 / * 78 (09.1.21)

    20091 , 23 * 4 , , (4.24)

    --, (4.27)5 (5.14)6 (6.4)

  • - 20 -

    7 , /(7.8) * 8 () (8.20)

    (8.26)*

    (8.27)9 (9.23)

    (9.26)12

    (12.17) (12.22), (975)

    20102 1 3 , (3.3)

    (3.17)4 , (4.6)6 8 , ()

    , , 9 , /, 1

  • - 21 -

    10 1, /, , (10.31)12 , (12.22)* 87, 6, 12, 1

    20111 , 3 , () (3.15)4 2

    (4.29)*

    5 5 , (5.13) (5.17)* ,

  • - 22 -

    (2)

    09. 1 , 9 , 12 ,

    , 10. 3 , 4 , / 7 , 12 , 11. 1 ,

  • - 23 -

    (3)

    449

    (09.4.20) : 1(10.7.15) (11.6.16) : * (09.1.21) , (10.3.17)

    19 (10.1.25)

    : 1(10.12.15) (11.5.18) : * ( )

    378

    ( 10.4.29, 11.2.28) : (11.3.29) 11.8.19 3

  • - 24 -

  • - 25 -

    3.

    1. 2. 3.

  • - 26 -

  • - 27 -

    1.

    () , ( )( )

    6) (2011 7 22 ) 1,916, 717

    400 2007 4 4

    ( ) , ( )

    2007 4

    6) , , 2007.11.

  • - 28 -

    4

    , , ,

    5 12

    2009 9 2 11 , 75.5% 43.9% 8.1% 5.4

  • - 29 -

    2.

    , , ,

    , , , 2008 9 , 7)

    7 76 ,

    , ,

    7) KBS, 2009 1 29

  • - 30 -

    2007 134( 4, 130) , , ( )

    44, 29 73 , ,,

    2011 6 20

    6 22

  • - 31 -

    6 22 24 3 , ,

    , ,

  • - 32 -

    3.

    ( ), , , , ,

    ()

    8) 9) , ,

    8) 2011 6 21 ...,

    9) 2011 6 2

    ....,

  • - 33 -

    10) () 11)

    , , , , -/-/-

    10) 16 () ( "" ) .17 ( ) 19 1, . ( "" ) .

    11) 2011 7 22 , , 2, 2,

  • - 34 -

  • - 35 -

    4.

    1. 2. 3. 4. 5.

  • - 36 -

  • - 37 -

    1.

    (1) ?

    () , ,- , , , ,- ,

    , ,

    (, , )

  • - 38 -

    - -

    2 12 , - 89 ( 199m) ,- 150m 10m

    , 3

  • - 39 -

    (2) ?

    , ,

    , ,

    ,

    , ,

    ,

  • - 40 -

    , ,-

    , , - - - ,

  • - 41 -

    2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2009 2010

    469(1) 370(1) 370(1) 445(2) 329(1) 276 239(4) 263 410 455

    262(1) 170 170 189(1) 173(1) 122 88(2) 80 69 118

    93 52(1) 52(1) 87(1) 32 36 53 30 30 28

    39 65 65 72 45 25 29 21 37 23

    , ,- ,- , - , , , , , ,

  • - 42 -

    68 78 78 93 73 80 61(2) 120 266 286

    7 5 5 4 6 13 8 12 8 0

    : , (2009, )2009 2010

  • - 43 -

    (3) ?

    , , () , ,

    '06'07 8 , ,, ,

    ('07.4.26),

    , , ('07.5) , ('07.5) ('07.5),

    ('07.6)

  • - 44 -

    ,

    , - , , , , - , - , 15m

  • - 45 -

    , , 1 , - , , , 8, 9, 8, 8 8 - , / 2, 1, 2 - , - ,

  • - 46 -

    / (3) (3) (3) (2) (1) (1) (1) (2)

    (2) (3) (1) (1) (3) (1) (1) (2)

    (1) (1) (2) (2) (1) (2) (1) (2)

    (2) (2) (2) (3) (2) (2) (2) (2)

    2 1 4 3 5 7 8 6

    12)

    ) (3) : (), (2) : , (1) : ()

    - 120 ,- 10 1 12 ,- ,

    12) , , 2009.2.

  • - 47 -

    (4)

    , ,

    ,

    , MD() , , ,

  • - 48 -

    2.

    , , 07. 5 13)

    13) (2011. 6. 10)

  • - 49 -

    (1)

    1999 2001 , , , , , 6 ,

    1997 2002 2005

    2007 5 2 2007 3 ,

    2007 3 , , , , , , (/), 8 , 9, 8, 7, / 6, 5

  • - 50 -

    14)

    , , , 4 , (00 )

    14) , , 2009.2.

  • - 51 -

    (2)

    2007 4 26 27

    1,900 87 15), , 16)

    4 12 , 17 , 20 , 23 , 25 26 , 17) 51 (87 )

    15) 9() 2 7

    16)

    17) 11( ) 1 51 2 31, 3 31 .12( ) .

  • - 52 -

    2007 4 28 , ,4 26

    2007 8 20 18) , 725 1,050 725 ( 69%) 94% 680 ( 35, 9)

    , 695

    18)

  • - 53 -

    11%, 48% 94%

    ,

    15(2007 4 1226) , 19) , , 19) 2007 5 1

  • - 54 -

    ,

    (3)

    2007 5 , 6

    , , , , 5 20)

  • - 55 -

    ,

    ( )

    , 2007 4

    ,

    20) , , 2006.12.

  • - 56 -

    2007 5 1 3

    4.11 , 5 4.26 , 4.27 4.30 , 5. 3 4 1 5.1112 2 5.14 ,

    1

    , 40% 21)

    21) . 2007 9 11 (MBC) 49.8%, 44.0%

  • - 57 -

    : 54.3%, 38.2%() : 56%, 34.4%() : 36.1%, 53.9%() : 42.2%, 49%

    5

  • - 58 -

    22)

    23) 3 3 , , ,

    24)

    20 199 , 79

    22)

    23)

    24) KBS, 2007.7.24

  • - 59 -

    25) 26) 27)

    5 1 11 2, 2, 1, 1, 5/6/7 1, 1 10

    2007

    25) 1 5 34, 2 5 1112

    26) , , , 4

    27) , 2007.6.

  • - 60 -

    3.

    , , , , , , ,

    2

    ( 00 )

    1

  • - 61 -

    (1)

    ( )28) 2009 1 , 2010 3

    , 1(2010 7) (2011 6) 2009 , 2010

    , 1

    28) 4 ( ) . . , . 1 , .

  • - 62 -

    (2)

    ( 442, 2004 ) 29)

    , , , * : , , 2007.

    29) 35() ( . ) . .1. ( ) [ ] 2. ( ) 3. 4. , ,

  • - 63 -

    2008 7 2009 9

    (, ), ( 4 ,6 ), ( )

    * 07.7.13 08.7.21 (5)08.7.22 1 08.7.31 ()08.8. 1 2 08. 8. 8 ()08.10.29 08.11.24 08.11.26 3 08.12.12 ()'09. 2. 93.20 '09. 3.26 ()'09. 6.26 09. 9.23 09. 9.28

  • - 64 -

    2011 2 8 (11 35) , 30)

    , 2011 5 25 6 9 , 6 20

    (11.6.9)

    30)

  • - 65 -

    (11.6.20)

    ,

    , 31)

    31) 37

  • - 66 -

    (3)

    '07. 8.~'08. 8. - ( ) 4 '08. 4.11~ 5. 9 - (20) ('08.4.18)'08. 6.11~ 8.10 1, 2, 3

    '08.10.31 -

    '09. 1.14 ( : )- , '09. 2. 9 ~ 25 - ('09. 3.26, )

    '09. 4. 7 ()

  • - 67 -

    '09. 4.14 ~ 5.13 ('09. 4.24)

    '09. 6.24

    '09. 7. 8 ~ 9.11 1, 2

    '09. 9.26

    '09.12.17 4 4, 2( 1) 6

    (100m )

    , , 10 8

    , , ,

  • - 68 -

    (09.2.92.25)

    , (09.4.3)

    (09.4.3) ()( ) 09.6 ,

    9 6

    ,

  • - 69 -

    ( 822 )

    * 2007 7 4 , 2008 1 2007 78 , 132 92 , 66

    3 (, , ) 1 ( 3942)

  • - 70 -

    ( 332333, 129, 736, 3 413) , ,

    , , ,

    ,

    , , , , ( 32, 332333) , ,

    ,

  • - 71 -

    2 ,

  • - 72 -

    ?

    6 ,

    , ()

    ,

  • - 73 -

    (3 )

    2009 9 23 3 , 9 26 ( )

    (6)

    4 7 9 26 6

  • - 74 -

    9 26 3 23 26

    , ,

  • - 75 -

    (4)

    , , , , , , , 32)

    10% 188 (2010 7 28 ), 105,295m2 2004 10 27

    ( 292 3)

    2009 9 22 , 2009 9 25 2009 12 23 (),

    32) 292 3

  • - 76 -

    , , () 1 ,

    1 , ,

    (1991. 12. 31. 4485 ) 33)

    2011 5 12 5 33) , , 1992, 49

  • - 77 -

  • - 78 -

    (5)

    2009 12 22

    ( ), ()

    1

  • - 79 -

    (6)

    (, 1, 2) 2011 7

    34)

    , , 35)

    34) 8 1 3 35) 142

  • - 80 -

    4.

    (1)

    2002 (UN Education, Scienceand Culture Organization: ) (Biosphere Reserve), 2006 (World Natural heritage) 2010 (Geopark)

    , 7

  • - 81 -

    2002 2006

    () () ( )

    (incrusting animals)

    , ,

  • - 82 -

    , ,

    , 2 , , ,

  • - 83 -

    36)

    ,

    6 , ,

    36) (, bioregional management, Biosphere Reserve) , , , , , , , 3 ( : )

  • - 84 -

    , ( ), ( ) , ( - )

    (2)

    - ( )

    10m

    ( , )

    ( )

  • - 85 -

    ,

    2012 ( ) ,

    2008 10 29 ! 2008 9 22 1

    2011 7 13 12 (N 33131552, E 126291096)

  • - 86 -

    1

  • - 87 -

    ()

    2

  • - 88 -

    2002 , , ,

  • - 89 -

    5.

    (1) 2008

    2008 324 150 174

  • - 90 -

    (2)

    (KDI) 2008 48 , 2008 79

    , , 37)

    2008 9 30 , 174

    2011 7 3 (20112020) 38)

    37)

    38)

  • - 91 -

  • - 92 -

    (3)

    () , ,

    , ,

    2007 11 13 269 4

  • - 93 -

    ,

    , 2007 12 28 270 () 1

    39),

    , 39) , ,2008.1.8.; , , 2008.1.7.

  • - 94 -

    40), 41) , 42)

    ,

    , , () 40) , - KDI , 2008.4.23.

    41) , , 2008.4.24.

    42) 2008 11 27

  • - 95 -

    T/F

    T/F

    ,

    2008 2010 3

    ()

  • - 96 -

    2008 9 11

    534, 9,770 18

    14% 43)

    43) ( ) 10 , 1 2014 12

  • - 97 -

    , , , , ,

    , ,

  • - 98 -

  • - 99 -

    5.

    1. 2. 3.

  • - 100 -

  • - 101 -

    4

    08 12

    ,

    ,

    ,

    ,

    ,

    1

    06 6

    ,

    , , ,

    , ,

    ,

    07 12

    ,

    ()

    05

    ,

    ,

    ,

    2009

    03

    ,

    , , ,

    , ,

    07 2 , 09 3

    ,

    08

    , , (), ()

    (, , )

    -

    11 5

    ,

    ()

    03 7

    ,

    , , ,

    , , / ,

    ,

    , , ,

    1.

  • - 102 -

    ()

    01 8

    ,

    , , ,

    , ,

    ,

    94

    ,

    , , , , ,

    , / /

    04 1 08

    02

    ,

    , , ,

    ,

    , 2005

    , ,

    01 1

    ,

    , , (, , , )

    , ,

    2009 5

    ,

  • - 103 -

    2.

    (1)

    , 4 , ,

    ,

    ,

  • - 104 -

    (2)

    ,

  • - 105 -

    (3)

    , ,

    ,

    2003 7 , ,

  • - 106 -

    (4)

    ,

    2 ,

    ,

  • - 107 -

    (5)

    ,

    ,

  • - 108 -

    (6)

    , ,

    , , ,

  • - 109 -

    3.

    ,

    , ,

    , , , 3 (fact finding), , ,

  • - 110 -

    (1)

    , , ( ) , , ()

    , ,

    , , () ,

    , ,

    ,

  • - 111 -

    (2)

    , ,

    ()

    ,

    4 , () ' , 1 , 1

  • - 112 -

    (3)

    , ,

    ()

    () , () , ,

  • - 113 -

    (4)

    ,

    ,

    (fact finding) 3

  • - 114 -

  • - 115 -

    6.

  • - 116 -

  • - 117 -

    1.

    2.

    3. ,

    4.

    5. , ,

  • - 118 -

    , ,

    (1) (2)

    , (3)

    , ,

    ,

  • - 119 -

    7.