72
<유권자자유법> 토론회 2012 총·대선과 유권자 표현의 자유를 위한 선거법 개정방향 일시 일수 오전 장소 국회 의원회관 주최 민주통합당 김부겸 의원 유권자자유네트워크 준

[토론회] 2012 총·대선과 유권자 표현의 자유를 위한 선거법 개정방향

  • View
    220

  • Download
    4

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

지난 12월 15일, 현행 공직선거법의 주요 독소조항들에 대한 종합적 개정안(일명 ‘유권자자유법’)이 발의되었습니다(대표 발의자: 민주통합당 김부겸 의원). 은 유자넷과 김부겸 의원실의 정책 협의를 통해 발의되었으며, 최근 재보궐 선거에서 첨예한 문제로 나타난 SNS 규제 문제를 비롯해 지난 10여 년간 유권자의 참정권과 정치적 표현을 제약해왔던 제반 독소조항에 대한 개정 내용을 담고 있습니다. 유자넷과 민주통합당 김부겸 의원은 12/21(수), 국회 의원회관 130호에서 ‘ 2012년 총·대선과 유권자 표현의 자유를 위한 선거법 개정방향(부제 : 유권자 자유법 발의와 쟁점 토론)’을 진행했습니다.

Citation preview

  • 2012

    | 2011 12 21() 10 30 | 130 | , ()

  • 2

    2012

    / , / , / , - ( )

    / / /

  • 3

    2012

    / , - ( ) 4

    / 36 / 38 / 45

    - 2000-2010 ( . 2011/6/1)

  • 4

    - ( )

    / ,

    .

    1.

    , . . . .1) .2) . () .3)

    1) , (),(, 2004), 303.2) , , , 19(2008), 695.3) , , 9(, 2009), 144.

  • 5

    . , . , , , , , , . . , , , . . . , . .

    . . . .

    2.

    . 4) .

    4) , , , . : , , , 26 1, 35.

  • 6

    . . .

    . 58 1 . . , . , .5) . .

    , . . . . 21 , 24 , .6)

    5) , , 4 (, 2009), 1308.6) 1994. 7. 29. 934, 6()

  • 7

    .7)

    , . . .8) , , , , , .9)

    . UN 2011. 7. 28. 34 , .10) UN 93 180 , . 2010. 6. 2. 4 . , .

    7) 2004. 3. 25. 20017108) 1999. 11. 25. 98141( , )9) 2004. 4. 29. 2002467 10) 2, Human Rights Committee 102nd session, Geneva, 11-29 July 2011, General comment No.34.

  • 8

    , . , .

    3.

    , , , , . ' ' . 2002. 6. 27. 99480 11) 2010.12.28, 2008157 12) . .13) , , (representative democracy) .14)

    SNS 2.0 . 2.0 , , , . 1.0 , , 2.0

    11) , .12) ,

    .13) , : , , 24 1

    , 232.14) , (twitter) , , 35 (2010. 3. 15.)

  • 9

    . 1.0 , 2.0 .15) 2.0 SNS (, , ) , . SNS . , SNS . , ' ' . SNS .

    .

    . , , . . , . , , ,, , , 16)

    15) , 2.0 UCC -, , , 201(2009), 6416) 1995. 4. 20. 9229 , 2001. 12. 20. 200096, 200157()

  • 10

    . .

    , , . .17) (SNS) . , . .

    , , . (90), (93), (103), (107) . . , . .

    17) , , 2003. 8,16,, , 2011.4,37.

  • 11

    . 18)

    , . 93 1 , 180

    . , , , . 2007 UCC

    2010 , (4) . ,

    . , , , , . ,

    . , . , .

    18) // . ( 10. )

  • 12

    .

    . , , ( 581).

    . ( 59, 8241).

    . , ( 826).

    . , , 180 60 ( 901).

    . 180 , ( 931).

    . , ( 101).

    . , ( 1033).

  • 13

    . , ( 8242, 110, 251).

    . ( 1482).

    . 9 ( 1551, 2, 5).

    . ( 2301).

    . ( 2542).

  • 15

    .581 (49 602 ) , , 5 .5.

    593 , ( 211 . ) .60313 7 .8241 211 ( ) , , 2 .826 .901 180 60, , , 2 .931 .101 .1033 .1092 67 824123 6, .110 .

  • 16

    1482 5 , , ., (

    ) 5 .1551 6( 8) 9 , 2 4 9 , 5 6( 8) 9 .1762 6( 8) 9 .23011 .251 .2542 , , , , , .25525 1 , 2 2 .26111 33 .

    .

  • 17

    58( )

    .

    , 1

    .

    58( ) ----------

    ----------------------

    (49 602

    )

    -------------

    ----------------------

    -------. ----------------

    --------------------------

    ----------------------.

    1.4. ( ) 1.4. ( )

    5.

    ( ) ( )

    59()

    . ,

    .

    59() -------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    ------.--------------------

    --------------------------

    ---------------------.

    1.2. ( ) 1.2. ( )

  • 18

    3. ,

    3. (

    21

    1

    . )

    ---------

    603(

    )

    .

    603(

    ) ----------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    --------.

    1.2. ( ) 1.2. ( )

    3. (

    .

    )

    4.6. ( ) 4.6. ( )

    7. (

    .

    )

  • 19

    .

    (

    )

    5

    .

    ( ) ( )

    824(

    )

    211

    (

    )

    .

    824(

    ) ----------

    ------------------

    -----

    ----------------.

    1.

    2.

  • 20

    3. (

    )

    .

    ,

    5

    .

    (

    ),

    ,

    . ,

  • 21

    .

    ( ) ( )

    826(

    )

    (

    )

    24

    (

    )

    .

    ,

    445

  • 22

    .

    1

    .

    1 2

    ,

    .

    1

  • 23

    .

    .

    .

    6

    .

    90( )

    180

    (

    )

    90( )

    ---------60-------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

  • 24

    . (

    )

    (

    .

    )

    .

    ----------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    ----------.

    1.3. ( ) 1.3. ( )

    1

    .

    1.

    37

    2

    2.

  • 25

    93(

    )

    180

    (

    )

    (

    . )

    (

    .

    )

    , , ,

    ,

    93(

    )

  • 26

    .

    ,

    .

    1. ,

    6032

    ( 2

    ,

    ) 60

    312

    2.

    37

    2

    ( ) ( )

    101( )

    101( )

    --------------------

    ----------------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

  • 27

    .

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    -.

    103( )

    ( )

    103( )

    ( )

    ,

    .

    ---------------------

    ------------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    -----------------.

    ( ) ( )

    109(

    ) (

    )

    109(

    ) (

    )

    603167

    82412

    3

    ( 11

    6

    ) .

    --------------------6

    ----------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------.

    ( ) ( )

    110( )

  • 28

    (

    .

    ),

    ,

    . ,

    .

    148( )

    ( )

    148( )

    ( )

    .

    ------------------------

    --------------

    5

    --

    --------------------------

    -------

    . ,

  • 29

    (

    )

    5

    .

    ( ) ( )

    155()

    6

    6(

    8) .

    ,

    .

    155() --------

    --------------------------

    ---9-------. ----------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    ----.

  • 30

    148(

    )

    10

    4 . 1

    .

    ------------------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    9-------. -------------

    --------------------------

    -----------------.

    ( ) ( )

    6(

    8)

    .

    ------------------------

    -9------------------

    --------------------------

    -.

    176( )

    ( )

    176( )

    ( )

    6

    (

    8)

    .

    ------------------------

    -----------------------9

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    ------------------.

    230( )

    5

    1

    230( )

    ------------------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

  • 31

    . ------------.

    1.

    (

    .

    )

    ( )

    (7912

    81182

    1 8221

    2

    .

    )

    (

    .

    1.

    -----------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

  • 32

    )

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------

    2.5. ( ) 2.5. ( )

    ( ) ( )

    251()

    (

    ),

    3

    500

    . ,

    .

    254() 254()

  • 33

    ( ) ( )

    ,

    , ,

    ,

    , ,

    ,

    ,

    2

    400

    .

    ------------------

    ---------------------

    -----------------------

    -----------------------

    -----------------------

    -----------------------

    -----------

    ,

    -----------

    -----------------------

    -----------------------

    ---------.

    255()

    ( )

    255()

    ( )

    2

    400

    .

    ------------------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    ------------.

    1.4. ( ) 1.4. ( )

    5. 93(

    )1

    5. ------------------------

    ------------------------

    -----2------------

    ------------------------

  • 34

    , 2

    3

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ------------------------

    ---------------

    6.8. ( ) 6.8. ( )

    ( ) ( )

    261( )

    1

    .

    261( )

    -----------------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    ----------.

    1. 8261

    2. ( ) 2. ( )

    ( ) ( )

    30

    0

    .

    ------------------------

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    -----.

    1.2. ( ) 1.2. ( )

  • 35

    3. 8266

    ( ) ( )

  • 36

    1

    /

    1.

    ( )

    , -

    -

  • 37

    2.

    ,

    - -

    , QR 2012 ,

    ( ) ,

    3.

    , , ( 58 1)

    , , , , ,

  • 38

    2

    1)

    /

    1.

    .

    , , , .

    , 1 1 .

    .

    , .

    1) .

  • 39

    , , , , .

    . , .

    2.

    .

    , .

    ,

    .

    , , .

    .

    .

  • 40

    .

    ucc, sns (, ) .

    - 8241 - 60316 - 109 ,

    - 2010 (62%), (21%) .- .

    .

    .

    - (445) , , 10 .

  • 41

    .

    , ,

    931 .

    931 - 931 sns , .- , 931 .

    .

    .

    .

    .

  • 42

    .

    - , , .- ,- .- , .- .

    .

    5 ,

    9 .

    ,

    .

    , 2010 15 , 69.1% 89.7% ,

  • 43

    .

    ,

    .

    .

    .

    , , .

    .

    .

    .

  • 44

    .

    . ,

    .

    , , , 2).

    , .

    3.

    .

    , , , .

    , , , , .

    2) .

  • 45

    3

    /

    .

    211 , Access . , , , , , . , , , .1)

    2), () . , , , .3)

    1) 1998. 2. 27. 962, 2000. 3. 30. 97108, 2002. 4. 25. 200127 .2) , 1995. 7. 21. 92177, 199.

  • 46

    .

    .

    1.

    , 1910 , 1925 , 1939 (Hatch Political Activities Act 1939), 1947 (Taft-Hartly Act 1947) . , , , , , , , PC , , , , , .4)

    2. , ,

    , , , , , .

    3. .

    , , , .

    4. ,

    3) , 1995. 4. 20. 9229.4) , , , 2001, 33.

  • 47

    . 2007 UCC . UCC SNS .5)

    . 93 1

    . , . 90 1, 93 1, 107, 254 2 59 , SNS 93 1, 82 6 .

    1. 93 1(90 1) ,

    90 93 .6)

    . .

    5) , , 2009 55(2009. 12), 88.6) , 2007. 6. 15. 2007175, 2009. 5. 28. 200811857 ; 2001. 8. 30. 9992,200039, 2000167168199205280 .

  • 48

    , , , , , . , , , , , .7) .

    2. 93 1

    93 1 UCC() ( 2009. 7. 30. 2009718) ( 2009. 5. 28. 200724) . 9 4, 5 6 () .

    . . , , .8) , UCC, SNS .

    7) , , 2011, , 198,8) , , 202.

  • 49

    3. 93 1 180 .

    . 86 2

    1. 1997 15

    2000 16 . 2002 16 , 2004 17 .2005. 8. 4.

    (826), 2007. 1. 26. 30 20 () (445), 2007 7 .

    2. 9)

    OECD . , , PC .10)

    .(EU)

    9) , , 2008.10.1710) (2008.7)

  • 50

    , .

    , .

    .

    3. (86 2)

    ., .

    , (), remailing service .,

    . 18 , .,

    ., ,

    .11)

    . 1995 (McIntyre v. Ohio ElectionsCommission)

    11) , , , 2011, 42

  • 51

    , .

    , . , .

    , , , , , . 12) . ,

    , .13)

    .

    12) , 2007, - -, , 15 2, ,13) , 2003, , CLIS Monthly 2003-5/6, ;

  • 2011 6 1 . 2010

    , FTA , SNS SNS .

    2011. 06. 01 | 2011-07

    2000-2010

  • . 2000 , 2002 , 2004 , 2007 , 2008 , 2010 .

    , , , , , UCC , , SNS .

    , 90(), 93( ), 103( ), 105( ), 107( ),251(), 254() . 33 180 , , UCC 93 1.

    10 , . , . , .

    (

  • ), ( , , ), ( ) .

  • ; ? ?

    1 ? ? ? ? . 2010 62 ( ) 108( ) . . . 2004 100 . . , . . . . . , , . 20 . . . . . 10 . . . .

  • . . , . . , .

    , 2000 16 ~ 2010 62 33. .

    33 6 , 33 12 .

    . , .

  • 20 0 0

    16

    7

    16 15 66 ,

    50 ( 1 2 5 )

    *90( )91( ) , 93( ) 95( ) 101( )105( ) ,107(

    2000 413 2010 62 , , .2000 16 2010 62 , 500 2000 , 2002 16 () , 2004 , 2007 17 , 2008 2010 62 . , .

    2000~2010

  • )254( )20 0 2

    16

    1

    100, 80

    90( )93( ) 107( )2 0 0 4

    17

    150

    93( )

    20 0 7

    17

    MB

    2007 6 ... ..

    50

    93( )

    20 0 8

    18

    2008 1

    100

    93( )

    20 1 0

    ,

    1 200 (2 )

    90( ) 107( )254( )

    *

  • 2000 2000 3 . . , , . . .

    2002 2002 40 . , . 90 . , , 90 ' ' . 90 .

    2004 2007 MB 2004 , , . , , , .

  • , (www.auction.co.kr) . (vote2004.nec.go.kr) , . 93 1 . 20 , , , . MB 1 3 , , . . 93 1 . .

    2008 . , , 27 ,

  • . , . . . .

    2010 . 2010 , 4 4 .10 , , , . . , , . , .

  • .

  • , 1

    52004 4

    70 ~ 1 5 0

    103( )

    2010 5 " , 2 1 ", " , . . "

    50

    90( )

    1

    2010 5 4 "1 , 6 2 "

    300

    93( )

    6 33 12 . 12 , 1 , UCC , , , , , , , , . .

    2002

    80

    254()

    2004 , i 3,127

    70

    95( )

  • 2010 4

    1 50 (2 )

    254()

    2010 , , 4 , 62 1

    50

    90( )

    4 , ,

    1 80 (2 )

    90( )107( )

    1 90(

    14 " " . PC ,

    100

    93( )

    2002 - , , , '

    50

    93( )

    , UCC (1~5)

    80

    93( ) 254()

    150

    93( )

    MB

    2007 6 ... ..

    50

    93( )

  • ,

    200 (2 )

    ) 107( )254()

    2003 11 .

    70

    93( ) 251()

    2004 4 " " " , ~!"

    100

    93( )

    2004 3

    250*

    93( )250()

    2007 6 , ,

    30

    93( )

    2007 10 , '

    42 '

    50

    251()

    2007 9 , , , , ?? ~~~

    50

    93( )

    2007 50 (Extreme Dirt Mr. Lee !! )

    30

    93 ( )

  • 251() 2007 1 ,

    108

    100

    251()254()

    2008 1

    100

    93( )

    * 612 931 250 250

    2007 11

    , 14? ? !

    100

    93( ) 251()

    2007 ""

    90

    93( )

    2007 12 , , ,

    80

    93( ) 251()

    2004 ,

    100

    108( ) ,

  • 2007 105

    600

    824( ) ,

    2007

    500

    826( )

    []

    !

    10

    93( )

    7

    16 15 66 ,

    50 ( 1 2 5 )

    *90( )91( ) ,93( ) 95( )101( )105( ), 107(

    (),(), () 21

    20 20

    230( )

  • )254()

    1

    1 0 0 ,80

    90( )93( ) 107( )

    12 ~

    .14) . .

    1 UCC 2007 17 UCC . . , . , 2007 87,812 , .

    14) 824( ) , .

  • .

    24 , . , , , , , .

    , , , . 251( ) , . , , .

  • 33 15, 824( ), 826( ), 90(), 91( ), 93( ), 95( ), 101(), 103( ), 105( ), 107(),108( ), 230( ), 250(), 251(), 2542() . 93 1 33 19 . .

    UCC (931) 2007 UCC 93 115) , UCC . , . 93 " UCC . , . . .

    15) 93( ) 180( ) ( . ) ( . ) , , , , .

  • .

    931 . 90116) , . . 10317), 10718) . . 4 , 103 107 .

    (251) , . 16) 90( ) 180(

    ) . ( ) ( . ) .1. , 2. 3. 17) 103( )

    , .18) 107( )

    .

  • . (25119)) . . .

    (230) 2010 62 4 230 . , . 230( )20) , .

    19) 251() ( ), 3 500 . , .20) 230( ) 5 1

    . 1. ( . ) ( ) (7912 811821 82212 . ) ( . )

  • . . , . . . 1 . . . . ( , ( , , ), ( ) . , , , .