vpipi : v

v v pi

. v..: 907

piv piv piv

v

v pi

2

3

1 5

2 v pi v 72.1 v . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 72.2 v . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 72.3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9

2.3.1 v pi pi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 112.3.2 v . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13

3 193.1 v . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 193.2 v ? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 193.3 pipi v . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25

3.3.1 pi pi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 253.3.2 v pi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27

3.4 pi ; . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28

4 v pi 334.1 v . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 334.2 pi Thomas Nagel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 334.3 pi David Furley . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 364.4 pi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40

5 pi 45

6 46

4

1

pi v pi v "pi". pi pi v v "" " v". pi, pi pi, pi v . pi , , pi. pi , pi. pi ( ), vv pivv. v piv pi, v . pi v, v , v pipiv .

piv v, "". v pi pi pi v vpi pi. pipiv v v . v pi v v v , pi, pi v. vv pi, vv v pi, pi pi v . v,v pipi, , pi pi , v . pi, pivpi v , pi pi .

pi v vv pi v pi- v v. v, pi pi pi v . , pi pivpi v pi v . pi piv pi pi pi piv pi v . v v . vv, piv pivv v pi , pi v. v , pi -v piv, v vv pi . , pi pi v pi pi vpi, v v pi v, v .

v pi pi v . , pi v (37 ) v, pi pi v pi . pi v pi pi v v pi, v pi pi pi pi . pi, pi pi v pipiv ,v pi.

5

1

v pi piv pi pi pi piv pi pi: . v, v , pi , pi, . v piv v piv pi pi . v pi, v pi, v v v pi, v pi pi pi v v pi v pi v . piv, pivv v pi v pi pi . , v , v v pi pi pi , v pi pi pi v pi piv v. v pi, v pi " v ;". v pi v RobertSharples, James Warren, A.A. Long, pi pi pi piv, pi v v v v pi v. , v vpipivv pi v vv pi v Thomas Nagel, David Furley . vv v pi pi v v pi pi pi . pi pi pi , v pi pi pi v pivv v pi, pi pi pi v v v pi.

piv v pivpi pi v v pi v pi pi. v pi v v pi pi pi v v, pi pi v pi pi piv pipi pi Herculaneum. v, pi vv v v pi v- pi pi pi pivv .

, v v v pipi v , pi v v piv v piv pi v, piv piv v .

6

2 v piv

2.1 v

v v v pi. pi v pi v, v pipi pivpi pi pi pi pi v v pi. v, v pi pi piv pi v pi, pivpiv v v v , v v v . , vv v pi pi, piv v . v v vv v , pi v v v . , pi pi pi , vv pi pi pi v, pi pi pi piv.

2.2 v

piv v v piv pi ,pipi pi v v pi v, v pi - pi vv piv pi pi pi. v v pi v vpi v, pi pi, v pi , pi pi v v piv .

pi piv v pi pi v vv , vpi, vv, piv pi . vv pi :

I. [...]. (, pi , 32.14-15).1

1. , pi, , pi , , v/ 2009, v. 121

7

2 v pi v

pi pi pipi pi v v pi pi v v v. pi vv pi pi , vv, piv pi pi pi v pi pi pi v . v pi piv v 23:

II. v pi v, pi pi v pi , pi v . ( 23).2

v v, pi v vv (-) v (v) pi v v vv. pi, pi v pi v v v , vv v, pi v v v -v piv v. , v piv v vv v pipiv v. pi pi vv pi3 piv v v . pi -. A.A. Long, pipi v v, pi, pi piv v v v . v, v pi v , pi v pi. , v v v v pi , pi, pi pi , pi v pi. piv v pipiv v pi , v pi. pipiv, piv pi v v v v pi v , v pi .4

pi pipi pi pipi v vpi v v pi . pi vv pi , pi, pi pi . vv, v pi pipiv pi , pi pipipi, v pi v. v pi v .

v pi v piv - v pipipi pi , pi pi pi v v . , pi piv pi v v v ( ), pi -

2.pi., v. 2813 A.A. Long4A.A. Long, v v, ...., 2003, v. 49. , pi A.A. Long, pi pi, v .

8

2 v pi v

pi pi pipi. pi pi.

pi, v vv v , pi- v pi v pi v vv , v pi . , pi pi vv (pi, pi), v pi v v. , v pi pi v piv( ) v v pipi. v piv -, pi v piv pi pi pi, pi pi v v v pi.

2.3

pi , v v pi , pi pi pipi pi, pi , pi pipipi pi. v piv vv v pipi pi pi . "pipi" pi v v pi , pivv pi v v pi v vpi. vv A.A. Long pi. , Long "vv piv pi pi pi v piv pi piv pi pi piv pi".5 pipi, pi pipi, pi v v pi , pi . v, pi pi v v pi . , pi pi pi pi vpi piv v , pi pi pi pi pi pivv . , pipi v piv v , pi pi v , piv pi, v, pi pi pi pi. pi, pi v v,pi pi vv , pi pi , pi pi vv pi. piv pi pi pi pipi:

III. , pi, , v v v pi, pi pi. pi: pi , pi v pi pi pi. (piv pi 129, v. 12-14).6

IV. pi pipiv pi piv pi ,

5A.A. Long, v v, ...., 2003, v. 1116. , pi, , pi , , v/ 2009, v. 259

9

2 v pi v

pi pivv pi . , pi pi pi pi , pi . (piv pi 129,v. 7-10).7

vpi , pi, v (v) pi pi vv () pi.8 , v piv pi pi v vpi :

V. v pipi piv piv v v v ,pi v pi vpi . (piv pi 128, v. 1-4).9

v v pipiv v . pi pi, v vv pi, piv v pi, pi pi pi. pi pi, vv piv pi, pi pi pi pi . pi v v v v v pipi.

pi pi, pi pipi pi pi pi v v. pi pi v v pi v pi v pi. v, vpi v pi v pi, v . pi v v pi pi. pi pi v piv pi :

VI. pi v pi pi v . pi v pi, piv. , pi pi , v .(piv pi 127, v. 9-13).10

, pi pi v pi v pi pi v. pi pi . pi pi, pi v v pi, pi pi v pi.v v pi pi , pi pi, vpi piv . , pi pivv

7.pi., v. 2598Robert Sharples, , pi pi, v v v v, -, v/ 2002, v. 1479. , pi, , pi , , v/ 2009, v. 25710.pi., v. 257

10

2 v pi v

v v. pi pi v pipi, pi v pi pi , , v pi pi v, pi pi v v pi pi piv v. pipi piv , pi Sharples, pi v v , pi v pi v pi v pi v v piv pi , pi v.11 v pipi, v pi v pi.

2.3.1 v pi pi

v pi

v pi pi pi v pi, pi pi v pi v piv v. pi pi pi, pi v. v . pi pi, piv pi piv pi v. v, v v v pi, , pi pi piv pi. , pi pi pi. piv pi piv v, pi pi, vv. piv pi pi pi pi piv pi pi piv v v pi, piv v pi :

VII. ... pi , pivv pi v pi . (piv pi 131, v.1-3).12

pi pipi pi piv v pi pi- pi . pipi, pi v v, v vv pi pi pi-, piv v piv , pi,pi pi, . , pi, -pipi v pi, vv pi v .

v pi

pi pi v piv pi. pi pi v

11Robert Sharples, , pi pi, v v v v, -, v/ 2002, v. 15012. , pi, , pi , , v/ 2009, v. 261

11

2 v pi v

v v vv pi. pi pi v , pi , piv pi. pi pi v ,pi v pi pi v : pi, v pi v vv.pipi pi v vv. v v pi piv (vv )pi v . pi v pi. pi pi

VIII. ... pi , piv v piv . (piv pi 130, v. 11-12).13

pi pi v . pi pi piv. , pi Sharples, v pi v , pi.14 pi pipi pi v :

IX. pi. pi piv v v piv, pi pi pi pi pi pi . ( 3).15

X. pi pi pi v , v v pi pi. ( 18).16

pi pi piv v pi- pi pi v pipiv. pi pi v, v pi . pi pipiv pi v, v pipiv, pivpi piv v pi pipi . pi pi, pi v 129 vpiv pi (. IV, v. 9), pipi piv pi pivv pi.

v pi

v v pi. pi pi piv , pi pi. pi pi, pi v . v piv v pi pi v pi (pi.. pi), piv v pi pi pi. pi pi pi

13,pi., v. 26114Robert Sharples, , pi pi, v v v v, -, v/ 2002, v. 14715.pi., v. 26916.pi., v. 277

12

2 v pi v

pi v pi "". piv v pi , pi v pi. v pi piv piv pi , pi pi, pi pi.

piv pi pi pi pi vv "v". pi pi, pi pi pi pi pi, pi pi pi v v pipi vpipi vpi pi pi pi . pipi pi pi v vpi, v v pi. piv, pi, v , v piv , pi vpi piv(. IX, v. 12)

pipi, pi pi pipi, vpi pi- piv v pi (. V, v. 10). pi vpi, v pi v v pi. v pi v pi. pi, pi pipi pi piv v v v pi, v pi pi v v pi pi pi pi pi pipiv pi. pi, pi pipi , v v ,v pipiv , v, pipi pi. pipi v, pi v v pi v pi v v.

2.3.2 v

pi v, pi pi . pi-, piv v v v. pi pi pi pi, v pi-vpi pi . pi pi, v pi pi v v. pi Tim O'Keefe,pi , , pipi vv v v vv v v vv .17 , pi pi v ,v pi v O'Keefe, vpi , v v , v -v pi v v v . pi pi, pi v

17Tim O'Keefe, Epicureanism, Acumen, Durham U.K. 2010, v. 117

13

2 v pi v

, pi pi,pi pi pi v .18 piv, piv piv pi v v , pi vv pi pi vv -v pi pipi v v . pi pi pi pi pi v . , piv pi pi pi v v v , pi piv v , v pi vv.

pi, pi piv, pi v pi piv pi, pi pi pivvv. v v vv vv pi pi v v vv. pi pipi -vv v v piv v v pi pi v v vv vpi pi pi v pi. pipi. pivpiv pi pi ,pi pipi:

XI. v , v pipiv: " pi v . pi v vv v. pi pi v piv vv ..."( , pi , 22.1-8).19

v piv pi pi pi , , pi v vv. piv pi v pi piv pivv pi pi v, v piv pi v v v pi pi v pi v pi.

v, O'Keefe pi vv , vv pi v pi pi, v v pi v v . vv v. pi pi pi vv pi v v . piv pi v vv pi , v pi pi v pi pi . pi pi v vv pi pi v pi piv pi v pi.

18.pi., v. 11819. , pi, , pi , , v/ 2009, v. 105

14

2 v pi v

v, , v pi pi pi , v , pi pi. pi , pi v v piv pi pi vv pi, pi pi, pi pi , v v pi pi piv vv. pipi pi pi O'Keefe v pi piv pi v pi, vv v v , pi v, vvpi vv vv pi, , pi v pi v v pi. v, vpi v pi v pipi pi v v .20

v pi pi v v piv v pi v pi v pi pi piv pi v. piv pi v , v v pipiv pi pi pi pi v pi vvv pi piv piv pi pipiv pi v v pi v . pi pi v piv pi , pivpiv pi pipi, pipiv pi v pi pi v v.

pi piv pi pi O'Keefe pi v pi v v vv v.21 pi, pi v O'Keefe, pi pi piv pi pipi pi piv, v, v v pi piv pi pi piv piv v piv v , v piv pipiv pi v., v pi v pipiv v. pi v pipiv vpipiv pi.22 v v v pi v vv pi v pipiv piv pi v v vv, pi piv vv v vv. pi, v, pi pi v pi, pi v pi v pi v. pi pi, vv, pi v pi v v vv.

20Tim O'Keefe, Epicureanism, Acumen, Durham U.K. 2010, v. 119

21.pi., v. 11922.pi., v. 119

15

2 v pi v

pi, v v, pi pi , v v pi pi v .

v

v pi v pi v vv v . v pipi v pi . , v , v vv v . v piv v pi, v piv pi. pi, pi pi, v pi , pi pi pi, pi piv . v v , pi, v , pi vv (v pipiv v, pi vv v). , , pi v v v pi v v v v pi. v.

pi pi v, pi pi piv pi v pi v vv pi pi piv pi, v pi. vv pi vv pi pipi, , pi v . v pi vv pi pi pi v. pi vv pi pi piv vv, pi piv v pi (. IX, v. 12). v,v pi v , v pi pi piv v pi pi pi, , v pipi , v pi pi piv pipi v pi .

pi pi pi - vv v . pi pi pi v v pi pi . pi pi- pi . pi v v pi , piv . pipiv pi, v pi vv v vv pi pi pi .

pi, v pi pi , pi pi v v vv, pi pipi piv v. pipiv, pi v piv pi v v vv. piv. pi John M. Cooper v pi v pi23, pipi v piv

23John M. Cooper, pi v pi, pi . , pi

16

2 v pi v

pi vv pi pi v pi v vv. pi pi Cooper pi " v pi v pi pipi, piv pi pi ".24 pipi, pi piv piv pi pi v , pi pi pi (. X, v. 12).

v pi, piv v pi, pi, , v v . v v pi pi v v pi, pi pi , pi, v vv , (vv pi) pipiv v pi .

pi v v v pi pi. pi pi pi pi . v v v pi pi -v v pi v v. pi v pi . pipi pi, pi v v v piv piv pivv, pi .

pi piv pi pipi pi pi pi- v pi pi pi, v pi, v pi piv v,

XII. pi v piv piv, pipi . ( 15).25

v pi, piv pi v pi v , piv , pi pi vv pi. pi , v v piv pi , v pi piv . pipi pipi pi v pi v. v v v v pi. pipi, v v piv , pi v , v pi pi, piv vv pi pi pi vv v . pi pi pipi pi v piv pi :

XIII. v , vpipi , pi, pi, v

v, , , v/ 2012, v. 12624.pi., v. 12625. , pi, , pi , , v/ 2009, v. 277

17

2 v pi v

v , piv v pi pi - pi v pi , v. (piv pi 130, v.5-11).26

v pipi pi " v pi , v". pi v v pi . pi pi v v pi, vvv pi pi . v pivpi piv v pivv , pi pi pi piv v .

26.pi., v. 257

18

3

3.1 v

v , v pi pivv pi v v . v pi pi, pipi pi v, v pi v , pi pi v vv . , pivv pi pi, pi pi v , pi pi pipi v , piv v piv vv pi.

3.2 v ?

v v pi , pipi piv vpi " v ;". v pi v pi- v piv v pi, v pi v. pi v v, pi piv pi (. 2.3, v. 9), , pi pi pipi pi, pi , pi pi pipi pi. v pi, vv piv pi, v . pi, pi pi, pi pi, , pi pi pi pi piv v. pi v , - pi pi, v pi, .

, pi, pi v v . pi pi vv vv v v, v . v, v v pi.

pi piv pi pi -v, pi pi pivv v . piv pi 123 :

XIV. , pi, v . pi piv pi, v

19

3

pi v . (piv pi 123, v.10-12).1

pi piv , pi pipi pi pi pi- pi , pi, pi pi, v pipi pi . pi v pi. , pi pi. , v pi pipi, v ( ). , pi piv pi, pi pi pi -v v v pi v. pi piv Robert Sharples, pi v v v pi pi .2 pi v v pi (. 2.2, v.7-9), pi v pi pi v pi pi pi . v v pipiv, v v . v pipi,v piv pi 124 :

XV. pi pi (. pi), v pi v v . (piv pi 124, v. 1-5).3

pivpiv pi pi , (pi). pi-v, pipi v v , vv v v. pi pi pi, pi v v . v piv pi pi pi vvvv pi-vv pi pi. pi pi pipi v pi pi pi v.4 pi pi, pi v v ( pi, 7.211-216).5 pi, pi pi, pi pi , , pi v pi, pi : pivpi pi pi , pivpi v, .6 vpi, pi v pi pivpi .

pi piv pi pi , pi pi ,

1. , pi, , pi , , v/ 2009, v. 2512Robert Sharples, , pi pi, v v v v, -, v/ 2002, v. 1613. , pi, , pi , , v/ 2009, v. 2514. , pi, , v/ 2000, v. 855.pi., v. 616.pi., v. 61

20

3

pi . pi A.A. Long, v pivv piv pi, v pi v pi piv pi piv v .7 pi v pi piv. pi Sharples, v piv pi v v piv pi . pi pi v v pi;8 piv, pi pipi, Sharples piv pi v , v . pi vpi Long, , , pi v v piv pi .9 v , pi, v . v, v pi pi pi v vv , , pi .

pi pi v piv pi pi pi, pi v v v , pi . pi pi, pi v v pi v , v v piv pi . , pi Long, pi piv v, v , pipi v v pi pi , v. ,v pipi, pi . pi pi pi Long (pi. . 63 , DRNIII v. 176 ..)10, pi pi pi pi v v piv . pi vpi pi pi v, pi , pi v, piv., v pipi, v v.

pi pi , pi, -v piv pi pi . pi v pi (. 2.3.1, v. 11 ..), pi v pi pi v v , v v pi, pi vv v v pi . pi piv , piv pi. v pi, pi, pipi pi pi pi. pi v -, pi pi , pi v

7A.A. Long, v v, ...., 2003, v. 90

8Robert Sharples, , pi pi, v v v v, -, v/ 2002, v. 161

9A.A. Long, v v, ...., 2003, v. 91

10.pi., v. 93

21

3

pi . pi pi v piv , pi pi pi, pi piv v pi. v, piv, pi v v piv pi pi pi pi, v pi pi piv pivv pi. v, , v pi, v v pi pi piv pi . pi vpi pi v pi v v , pi vpi . pi, pi , pi pi v pi.

pi pi pi piv-v pi. v pi pi - pi v pi pi v,piv , , piv pivv . v, v 19 20 :

XVI. pi pipiv pi v , pi v . ( 19).11

XVII. v, , v pi pi pi. , , v vpi v v pi , v pi pi . pi vv , , pivv v pi , pi v pi . ( 20).12

pi vpi pi pi pi. pi Sharples, pi , vv, pi , piv.13 pi v , piv pi, v pipi v , . vv , pi pipi pi.pi , pi v pi pi v vpi , pi v pi v, v pipi,pi pi pivv . , piv pi v , pipi vv . pi piv pi, piv v piv vv. , pi. v pivpiv pi , v v piv pi , pi pi vv:

11. , pi, , pi , , v/ 2009, v. 27912.pi., v. 27913Robert Sharples, , pi pi, v v v v, -, v/ 2002, v. 164

22

3

XVIII. pi, v, pipi v , pi vv v v pi . , , pi : ,

, v pi . /

piv , pi ; v , v. , v pipi v. (piv pi 126, v. 6 - 127 v. 4).14

pi v v piv pi. , pi -v vv v v v ,v pi, pi pi pi .pi, vv pi . vpi pi pi v ,pipi pi . , pi . v , pi. pi v vv , , . v, v pi , pi pi v.pi pi.

pi pipiv pi pi piv v -: pipiv pi pi pi pi , pipivpi pi . pi pipiv, piv vv pi pi , pipiv pipi , pi pi pi pi v v v,v piv pi v . JamesWarren, pi pi v pi, pi vv pi piv pi v pi .15 pi, pi pi , pi Warren pi. Warren piv pi v pi pi pi pi pi pi v pi pi pi v.16

piv, pi pi v-, pi vv v pipiv pi pi v , pi pipi . pi pi , v pi v . v vv pi

14. , pi, , pi , , v/ 2009, v. 25515James Warren, Facing Death - Epicurus and his critics, Clarendon Press, Oxford 2004, v. 205

16.pi., v. 206

23

3

pi pi vv pi v pi pi pi v , v pi vv. v, v vv, pi pi pi. v , pi pi , v v , pi piv. pi v pivpipi pi pi v pi piv pi vv pi piv, v v .

pipiv pi pi : vv , pi , . pi pi v 20 pi v , pi . v pi vv . pi, pi v , pi. pi pi pi pi pi Warren.17 v pi piv piv vpi pi v . pi , v . pi pi v. pi v pi vpi pi vv -v . piv pi pi vvpi pi. v pi pi pivv v pi v, v pi piv, v v , pi v vv pi v . piv pi Warren pipiv , pi -pi 31 pi pi v pi.18 pi Warren, pi , v v pi v pi . pi v pi v pi pi vv v v piv v vv, pi ,pi v pi, v, -v vpiv v vv v pi pi , v pi. piv Warren vv, pipi v pi vv pi v pi, pi v v.

pi v pipiv pi pipi-v pi . , pi v pipiv pi, pipiv pivpi, pi pi pi v, ,pi pipi, vpi v vv pi v v v v vv. vv pi Warren v v pi vpi pi pi pivpi, piv

17.pi., v. 20718.pi., v. 207

24

3

pi pi pi pi.19 pi pi pi piv v pi pi vpi . vv, pi pi pi vv v, pi, pi pi v pi pi pi pi - v . v , v , . pi , piv pi.20

3.3 pipi v

pi , pi pi v pi pi. pi, v piv pi , pi pi, -piv pi pi v v pi pi . pipi pi v v piv v pi v pi. pi v v pi. pi pivpi pi pi pi pi pipi v .

3.3.1 pi pi

pi pi pi pi v v pi pi v piv pi , v 124-125:

XIX. vv pi v v vv, vv vv. v pi pi piv , piv pi v , pi pi v.

, pi, pi v pi pi pi v , pi pi v . pi, pi pi pi , pi pi v v . pi pi, pi pi . pi pi , , pi -v piv pi, pi pi pi , pi . , pi

19.pi., v. 20920.pi., v. 209

25

3

pi -v pi pi, pi pi.21

pi pi (pi. . 124, v. 8-10) v v v v v vv. v pi v v pi pi v, pi pi pi v. v, pi vpi pi , pipi v pi -v . pi vv vv. v pi, pi. , pi ( v vv) pi v pi v , vv pi. , pi . v, pi pi v v piv vv pi v :

) pi piv vv

1. v v vv ( pi -v).

2. v vv vv.

3. , pi 1 2, , v pi, pi.

4. , pi 3, vv pi pi pi v v pi .

vpiv pi vv , , . vpiv piv vpi v pi pi v pi . pi , v v pi . , pi pi v, , pi pi, vv v vv () pipi vv (vv ).

pi (pi. . 125, v. 6-11) v v pipi v pipi v v vv. pi pi v , v pi pi, pi pi . , pi pi v v v pi v v:

) pi v

1. , v pi, pi.

2. pi, pi.

21. , pi, , pi , , v/ 2009, v. 253

26

3

3. , pi 1 2, pi ( pi) , .

pi pi, pi piv James Warren22, pi ) (-piv pi 124) v v v pi v v: pi. vv vpi pi v v vv, vpi , pipi v. pipi, pi ) v piv pi 125 v v pi vv, pipi pi pi pi v. , pi. v, -pi pi pi v piv pi ., v v v vpi. v vpi piv vv . v , : pi v pi piv vv pi v ; pi pi , pipi piv vv (pi) v , pi piv pi piv v v . pi v , pi v pi pi v pi, v , pi, pi, v.

, 2 vpi pivv pipi pi:

XX. pi . pi piv v pi v pi . ( 2).23

v pi pi pipi v v. pi piv pi piv pi, , pi pipi, pi piv , , pi v, pi piv v pi v. pipi, pivpi pi v v pi pi v pi. v, piv, pi pi vv.

3.3.2 v pi

v pi pi v pi De Rerum Natura( v pi), v v 832-841 pi III:

XXI. pi v pi v pi, ... v, pi, piv v pi pi pi, pi pi pi v vv .24

22James Warren, Facing Death - Epicurus and his critics, Clarendon Press, Oxford 2004, v. 2023. , pi, , pi , , v/ 2009, v. 26924, v pi, , v/ 2005, v. 241

27

3

pi pi pi -v v pi pi v . pi pi , vv . pi piv v v pi : pi pi, pi pi pi - v pi. pipi, pi pi v pi v. v v , pi-v v pi, v pi pi piv vv . , pi pi pi. pi vv v pipi v pi v v pi v vpi. pipiv, v pi pi vv pivpi .

pi , pi pi v pi v pipi v . vv, pi pi, pi v pi pi . vv pi James Warren, David Furley, Thomas Nagel piv , , . v pi v pi v pi v pi , pi pi . pi pivv v .

3.4 pi ;

piv v v , v pi pi pi v v . pi pi v v . Warren, pi "v " pi v. pi pipi piv v vv pi pi . pi Warren.

, pi vv v : - pi pi; , v, pi pi vv . pi, pi v v pi pi, v vv pi pi pi. Warren v vv- , pi vv . , :

1. pi pi ;

2. pi pi pi pi;

28

3

3. pi pi pi vv;

4. pi pi piv v piv pi vv v ;25

, pi pi, vv . , 1 vv . , 2 pi pi pi, v , 3 v pi . , 4 v .26 vv pi , pi pi . pi, pi pi pi vv pi pi. pi , v pi , pi vv . pi, pi pi vv , pi pi pi. , pi pi v piv vv . vv .

pi, pi Warren, vv ( pi pipi pi 1) pi ( pi pipi pi 2). pi pi v pi pi pi pi .27 v, pi pi v pi vpiv pi pi De Rerum Natura pi v vv .

pi pipi, 2 pi vpi v pi pi v piv pi , v v pi pi v pi , pi v v piv pi . pi v pi pi pi v. v, pi pipi v v pi vv pi , pi v pi . pivpiv v pi pipi. pivpiv pi :

XXII. pi piv pi v. (, IV.7.4).28

pi pivpiv pi pi v pi pi v pi piv v v,

25James Warren, Facing Death - Epicurus and his critics, Clarendon Press, Oxford 2004, v. 3

26.pi., v. 427.pi., v. 628. , pi, , pi , , v/ 2009, v. 477

29

3

pi pi , pi pi v. pivpiv pi pivv v pipi pi piv v:

XXIII. pi piv pi v , pi . , pipi. vpi, v pi vv, pi pi pi v piv pi, pi . (pipi, piv vI.22.5).29

pivpiv pi pi v v . pi pi v v 2 pi pi pi pi piv ( v) v, pi v . pipi, pi v piv pi v v pi , v pi , vv pi v pi , pi v pi pi v , pi pipi, pi . v vv . pi v vv v pi pi pi v pi.

piv v pi pi pi pi pipi v v . , pi , pi pi pi pi, pi v . v, pi pi pi v v pi pi vv pi , v v pi pi v pi. , pi pi v vv . pi pi, pi pi pi pi pi Warren. vv pi: v pi piv , pi piv, v v pipi pi, pi .

v , , piv piv pi pi v piv pi :

XXIV. v, pi, pi , piv .(piv pi 126 v. 1-3).30

pi , v pi v . vv v piv pi. pi pi

29.pi., v. 47730.pi., v. 253 - 255

30

3

v v , pi, vv v . , pi v , pi pi pi pi, pi v , vpi piv . v , pipi pi pi. , pi , v pi. v, vv v , vpi pipi pi v Warren.

piv, piv pi v , pi v pi piv pi v pi, pipi v. v v 4:

XXV. pi v v : piv pi v , pi pi v pi . [...]. ( 4).31

pi pivpiv pi vpi pi pi -pi pi v v, pi , v pi v v v, pi v v v pi pi . vv, vv pi. pivv pi piv, pi piv v. , pipi v pi v v, piv pi pipi v pi v pi . pi v pi pi vpi. pipi, pi v pi v v pi, pi pi v, pi vv pi v.

pi pi v piv pi , pi vv pi , pi pi pi:

XXVI. v , v pipiv: " pi v . pi v vv v. pi pi v piv vv ..."( , pi , 22.1-8).32

pi pivpiv pi vpi pi piv v- pi pi v pi vpi piv vvv pi . pi, pi pi, pi pi . , pi v, piv pi v v v. piv, pi vpi- pi pi pi v.

31.pi., v. 27132.pi., v. 105

31

3

v pi pi v pi-, v piv . vv pi Warren pi pivpiv v v piv pi v pi pi, piv pi pi v pivpiv v, pi v pi pi . pi pivpiv pi pi , pi pi .33 , v Warren, pi v vpi v v .

pi pi pi pipi pi v Warren (. 3.4, v. 28): pipi pi v v; , , pi , ; pi v pi vv pi , pi v pi, v v pi pi v pi pi .

33James Warren, Facing Death - Epicurus and his critics, Clarendon Press, Oxford 2004, v. 10

32

4 v pi

4.1 v

pi v v vv pi v- , v v v pi pipiv vvv pi v James Warren v Facing Death - Epi-curus and his critics. pi pi v pi pi v pi vv , v vv , v pi v v . pi pi pi v pi pi pi pi v v, piv v pi .

pivv pi v vv pi v pi v : Thomas Nagel, pi Death, David Furley pi pi ;, pi . vv pi pi v v pi , pi v pi v pi v , pi pi pi v.

4.2 pi Thomas Nagel

Death1 Thomas Nagel pi pi pipi pi , pi vpi pi , v pi v pi. v vpi v pivv pi . vv pi.

, Nagel pi pi. pi ,pi pi pi : pi , pi pi ( ) . v, Nagel , , piv

1Thomas Nagel, v , pi, 2007, . , v. 19 ..

33

4 v pi

pi. piv pi Nagel pi , v v pi pi pi pi v ,pi , pi, v v. v , pi pi v. , pi pi pi, Nagel, .

pi, pipi v pi pi . Nagel vv . , piv: ) v piv ) , pi v pivv ,v pivv , v . v, , , pi v , v pi, v pi pi., pi pi . pi pi pi pi pi pi pi vv pi v . , Nagel, pi pi pi piv v pi v v pi. , , pi pi vpi. , pi Nagel, pi v pi pi pi pi pi v pi: ) pi vpiv pi pi pi , ) pi pi pi pi v .

pi v Nagel, pi , pipi v v. pi v , pi pi. piv , pi Nagel, pi:) vv, pi pi v pi , pi pi. pi pi v pi , pipi v v pipiv pi pi v pi,pi pi v pipi v. pi, pipi piv pi , v pi v . vv, pi pipiv . ) pi piv vpi pi v pi pi v . v pi , pi, pi, pi pi pi pi v pi. ) pi pi piv vv pi () piv vv pi (pi.. pi ) ;

pi Nagel, pi piv v v pipi pi, : pi pi piv pi v pi pi vvv v v. vv pi pi piv . piv, pi pi piv v v

34

4 v pi

v , v pipi v.2 pi, pi pipipi v vv . vv , . , vv , , pi Nagel, piv v pi pi pi . vv, pipi v v pi piv . pi v vv v pi pipiv v. " pi", v Nagel, " pi pi pi pi pi pi pi. , pipi pi , pi piv v v pi, pipi piv."3

pipi, pivv Nagel piv v v pi pi v pi . pi v pi (. 3.3.2, v. 27), v pi pi piv v pi vv, pipi , piv pi. pi Nagel pipi, vv, , pi v pi pi pi, , pi vv, v pi pi v , v pi.

v pi, Nagel, pi pi pi pi , pi pipiv pi vv pi v pi pi pi. Nagel, pipi v piv pi pi pi v pi pi pipiv. v pi, pi v pi v . v pi . pi, Nagel, pi v . v pi v pi pi, vv piv pi v pi,v pi, pi. pi pi , pipi pi pi. pi v pi pi pi pivv.4

2.pi., v. 243.pi., v. 264.pi., v. 30

35

4 v pi

4.3 pi David Furley

David Furley v pi ;5 pi pi pi pi , v v pi v pi . v vv pi pipi pi James Warren, pi pi Furley v v , , v pi pi pi. v, pi pi- Furley pivv pi . pi pivv vv .

Furley pi pi pi . pi pi piv :

1. pi pi, pi pi v ( pi).

2. v pi.

3. , pi pi pi .

4. , vv ( ) pi pi .

5. pi, pi , v pipipi pi, piv.

6. pi, vv .6

pipi, Furley piv v pi pi v De Rerum Natura . 832-841. vv pi vv pi pi pi v v vpiv 3 pi pipi 5, pi piv pi pi vv.7 v, Furley pi pi v v pi v v , v v pi pi v. pi v pi v v pi v , , pi v v . , pi piv Furley, v vv pi vvv piv pipi piv pi v v. pi pi piv pi pi v piv pi v pi v . vv , . pi Furley vv,

5David Furley, pi ;, pi . , pi v, -, , v/ 2012, v. 189 ..

6.pi., v. 1907.pi., v. 190

36

4 v pi

, pivpi , v pi pi pi vpiv pi pipi, 3 5 (. 3.3.2,v. 27).

, Furley pi v pi pi pivv , pi pi v v -pi . pi pi piv pi pi , v v James Warren pi pipi (. 3.4, v. 28). Furley, v pi pi pi pi -pi, pi pi v vv pi v pi . pi pi, v , pipi pi pi, pi v , pi pi.

pi pi pi Furley pi v v, pi piv pi, v v. , pi Furley,pipi pivv pi vpi pi .

v pi pi v . Furley pi 34 35:

XXVII. . pi pi v pi pi v pi pi v pi. ( 34).8

XXVIII. pi pi pi pi v pi pi , - . pi. ( 35).9

pipi v pi pi pi pi vv pi v v pi v v pi v pi . pi , -, pi v v, piv pi v pi pi pi v pi pi . v pi pi pi , pi pi, pi pi pi (. 2.3.2, v. 14-15). pi pipi Furley vpi pi piv pi v v v v pi, v - , pi pi 35, v pipiv v pi v. v, v vv pi v v v v pipiv(. 3.2, v. 21-22).

8. , pi, , pi , , v/ 2009, v. 2879.pi., v. 289

37

4 v pi

, pi pi piv v. v Furley v pi v vv . pi. pipiv pi pi v pi,pi pi vv vv . "" (. ) pi v vv.

Furley pi pi v : ) pi vv pi pi ) pi , vv . pi pi piv pi pi pi pi, pi pi , v pi (pi v vvv v pi). v , pipi piv pi v pi, v v , pipi pi pi, pi pi . Furley .10 piv piv pi pi pi , pivv pi .

, pi v Furley v , pipi pi piv pi pi v v vv, v v pi v. , pi pi, pi: pi, , . pi pi pi v, pi pi.pi pi pi pi v, pi v . , pi pi , v ,v vpi . pi piv Thomas Nagel v Death, pi pipi. Nagel pi pi pi v v v v , vv v pi pi v. , pi pi pi pi pi v . Nagelpiv pi pivv v pipi pi v , vv .

vv Furley : piv pi pi v pi .pi pi pi pi vpi pi. pi v , v pi pi; pipi, pipi v pi pi ; pi pi , piv pi pi- piv v v, v .

10David Furley, pi ;, pi . , pi v, -, , v/ 2012, v. 202

38

4 v pi

v, pi v pi v, v. , v , pi vv , pi piv v . pi Furley pipi vv pi , v v pi v v pi (. 2.3.1, v. 11 ..).

v Furley v Bernard Williams pi The Makropoulos case

11, pi v pi piv -pi pi pipi pi , pi pi pipi v pi. v, Williams, v pi pi pi pipi pi v , , v , v pi.12 v pi Williams Furley pi pi. piv Williams piv , -v v , " pi" ( pi pi Furley Williams)13, pipi pi pivvpi pi , pi, v.

v pipi piv piv pi v pi v pi Furley. pivv v pi pi, pi pi pi, - pi pi pi, pi, pi pi pi pi, pi piv .14

pi v , Furley piv pi pivv v, pi pi pi. pi Williams pi pi pi pi vv . , Furley piv pi pivv v, pi pi pi pipi pi .

Furley vv v pi Nagel pipi vpi pi ( v) ( ) pi pi v piv v . , pi pi pivpi pi v v pi pi . pi pi pi

11Bernard Williams, The Macropoulos case: reections on the tedium of immortality , pi : Problems of the Self, Cambridge 1973, v. 84-85. pi . pi v, , , v/ 2012, v. 213

12David Furley, pi ;, pi . , pi v, -, , v/ 2012, v. 207

13.pi., v. 20814http://pages.pomona.edu/~mjg14747/001-2006/WilliamsDeath.shtml

39

4 v pi

piv v. pi " pi pi pi , pi pi pi pi, pi pi vv ."15 piv, pipi pi v pi piv pi v pi v pi. , pi pi pi pi pi pi , pi, pi Furley, v v pi vpi, piv v v pi v piv pi .

4.4 pi

16 pi pi pi piv . v, pi pi pi pi pi pi v piv v pi "pi v v vv". v pi pi v v , v pi v piv pi . pi :pi pi, pi v vvv. , pi pi, pi v . pi v pi pipi pi . pipi, pi v pi . pi pi, pi pi v, pi pi pi , pi pi v, v pipiv pi . pi, pi pi pi piv, pi v , pi pipiv pi . , pi v pi v vpipiv .

v pi pi , v pi pi piv v pi, v pi pi pi piv , v pi pi v pi pi , pi pi vv v. pi pipiv, v v pi, pi v pipiv v. pi , pipiv pi v, piv v , pi pi v

15David Furley, pi ;, pi . , pi v, -, , v/ 2012, v. 210

16 , , v, 17, , 2008, v. 94 ..

40

4 v pi

v. , vpi pi vv vv pipiv , v .

v , piv pi vv Nagelv v pi pi pipi. Nagel pi pi vv pi pi , pi v, pipiv pipi pi . piv pi, pi , piv pipiv pi pi v vv , , pi vv. pi piv piv pi pi pi v , pi pi pi pi v .

piv Nagel, pi pipi, pi pi pi piv pi v pipiv piv pi . , v Nagel, pi pivv pipi, pi " pi pi piv pi v , pipiv pi vv v v" " pi pi pivv pi v v , v pi pi v". , pi v pipipi pi pi, pi pi pi v vv . , pi v Nagel, v pi .

, pi , vv v v . pi pi v pipiv pi pi v vv. , v v pi pipiv pivv pi. piv,pi pi v . , pi , piv pi v v pivv , v pi Nagel. , pivv Nagel piv v pi , v pi. v pi , pivv pi pi , Nagel piv , v pi v . v pi pi, pi pi piv pi Nagel pi. , Nagel piv ) pi v, vv pi piv pi, ) pi pi pi pi v v pi . pi pi v pi piv. vv,pi pi vv , pi v pi pi piv v pi v pi

41

4 v pi

Nagel pi pi .17

v , v pi Nagel,pi v v pi pi pi , v v v piv . , v vv pi pi :

1. pi , pi, pi vvpi, v , pipi vv.

2. pi , v v pi, pi, v. ( vv v pi.)

3. pi pipiv pi pi pipi v. ( vv v pi.)

v piv v vv pi v v , pipiv pi pi v.

pi pi 34 35 (. v. 37, XXVII XXVIII) pi v (. 2.3.2, v. 14-15), pi pi piv pi pi pi vpi piv pi pi v piv pi piv pi v pi (). v, , pipi, v pi pivpi pi v, pipi ) pi v , ) v pi ) piv . pi, pi , piv pi piv , v piv .

pi , vpi pi pi pi - pipiv pi . pi pi v v pi. v : " pivv pi pi piv, pi pi, pi pi ,piv piv v v v pi pi v. vv, pivv pi: v pi v, pi vv vv."18 pi v: v pi pi pi .

v , pi pi : pi- piv pi . vv pi : v pi pivv pi-pi vv, vpi vv v

17.pi., v. 10118.pi., v. 104

42

4 v pi

piv pi. pi pipiv v pi : ) pi ( vv ) ) v ( pi). pi , v pi pipiv, v pi pi pi pi. . pi v v . , pipiv v v, piv pi v . vv, piv pi v, pi pi pi pi .

vv, pi pi "vv" pi v v vv. , pi, pi , pipi v pi pivv piv pi, pi piv pi pi v pi v. pi , pi pi pi piv v, pi pi pi v pi, pi v . v v pi piv pi. pi, pi pi pi piv , pi , pi piv pi v v pi vv pi. v pi v vv v, pi pi, pi v, pi pipi pi piv piv pi. pi v , " pi, pi, pi pi pi pi pi: pi v v pi v v pi pi. piv , piv piv v , , pi pi pi pi v v."19 , , pipi v pi v.

v pi pipiv. v , pi pipi pi pi v piv pi pipiv. pi pi v . pi v pi , v , pipi pi v , pi v pi . vv pi piv v v v pi pi v , pi pi piv. pipi pi vpi v. pi v v v v v v, v pi pi, v pi , pi pi pi v , pi vv piv. v, v

19.pi., v. 107

43

4 v pi

, v pi . v pi pi v pi v, v pi pi v. pi v v, v v, v v pi pi v. , pi v , pi vv pi, pipi, v v pi . , pi pi pi pi pi v v vv v pi v v .

pivv pipi piv pi pi . pi , pi pi v pi v pi pi , v pi pi pipi. , v . v pipi, pi vv pi pi pi v .

v pi piv v pi pi v v pi v, pi vv pi v pi pi . v , pi pi vv pi v pipi vv pi pi pi.20 , , pi , pi pi . , pi piv pipi v , pi vv . pipi v v pi v pi, pivpi, v piv pi, vpi. vv piv pi vv v pivv pi , pi , pi , pi vpiv. pi pi v pi pi v, pi v vv pi. , , v pi pi pi pi.

20.pi., v. 113

44

5 pi

pi v pi pi, v pi pi , pi v pi pi pivpi pi pi pi. v pi Nagel, Furley -, pi v pi , vpi pi, v pi pi, pi v pi. , v v pi . pi - , pi v pi piv pi pi pi , vv . piv pi pi vpi v, pi pi piv pi . -pi, vv v v , pi v pi piv pi pi v pi, pi pi- v v vv . vv, v v v, v .

v pi pi v v Warren, , v , v . pi piv v pi v , piv pi pi v pi pi . pi v, pi v. v pi v pi pi v v v. piv pi, pi pi v pi v, v pi pipi pi pipi pivpi. piv, v v , pi pi, pi piv v pi v v pi, pi pi pi v. vv, , v, pi pi v v 4 (. XXV, v. 31).

pi pi vv pi, v , pi pi, v v piv pi pi pi "", pi pi pi, pi v. pivpi pi pi v, pi pi pi .

45

6

1. , . pi. vv: 2000

2. , . . v [17]. : 2008

3. , . pi v, . vv: - 2012

4. , . pi, , pi . vv: 2009

5. . v pi. vv: 2005

6. Long, Anthony Arthur. v v. : .... 2003

7. Nagel, Thomas (. , ). v . : pi2007

8. O'Keefe, Tim. Epicureanism. Durham U.K.: Acumen 2010

9. Sharples, Robert. , pi pi, v v -v v. vv: 2002

10. Warren, James. Facing Death - Epicurus and his critics. Oxford: Clarendon Press

2004

11. http://pages.pomona.edu/~mjg14747/001-2006/WilliamsDeath.shtml ( -piv 17/09/2012)

46