!"#2 Š 8 6>5:

�*Vab*bn f\4qSZ\Ya,\Sf]`S,mh1V

Awake! (ISSN 0005-237X) Issue 4 August 2016 is published bimonthly by Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York, Inc.;L. Weaver, Jr., President; G. F. Simonis, Secretary-Treasurer; 1000 Red Mills Road, Wallkill, NY 12589-3299.� Druck und Verlag: Wachtturm Bibel- und Traktat-Gesellschaft, Selters/Ts., V. i. S. d. P. Ramon Templeton, Selters/Ts.� 2016 Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania. Printed in Germany

!"#2

Vol. 97, No. 4 / Bimonthly / RUSSIAN �S`*3 V*3/\-\ ,m]daV* , `*4Zmf e\`Y*b*fB 9; ;:5>>>D ˙\abd]1Z Z* 5>; q4mV*f

�1a]W*bZ\D 'b\ S4/*ZS1 P h*abn ,a1YS`Z\y +S+W1yaV\y ]`\a,1bSb1WnZ\y /1qb1WnZ\abSEV\b\`*q ]`\,\/Sbaq f`SabS*ZaVSYS �,S/1b1WqYS �1-\,m S ]\//1`3S,*1baq /\+`\,\WnZmYS]\31`b,\,*ZSqYSD ˚aWS ,m f\bSb1 a/1W*bn ]\31`b,\,*ZS1E ]\a1bSb1 a*yb www.jw.org/ru

˚aWS Z1 dV*4*Z\ SZ*h1E +S+W1yaVS1 gSb*bm ,4qbm S4 w�,qk1ZZ\-\ �Sa*ZSq P �1`1,\/* Z\,\-\ YS`*x

˝1W*1b1 WS ,m ]\WdhSbn +\Wnj1 SZe\`Y*OgSS SWS f\bSb1E hb\+m a ,*YS ]`\,\/SW\an+1a]W*bZ\1 /\Y*jZ11 S4dh1ZS1 �S+WSSH

�\a1bSb1 a*yb www.jw.org/ru SWS Z*]SjSb1]\ \/Z\Yd S4 dV*4*ZZmf ZS31 */`1a\,

�*V ,m /dY*1b1E ab\SbWS ]`SOW*-*bn daSWSqE hb\+m +\`\bnaqa ]W\fSYS ]`S,mhV*YSH

��S+WSS -\,\`SbaqB

w�\Z1g /1W* Wdhj1 1-\ Z*h*W*xL'VVW14S*ab ;B<MD

� obSf ab*bnqf \+ad3/*pbaq+S+W1yaVS1 ]`SZgS]mE V\b\`m1]\Y\-*pb +mbn f\4qSZ\Y a,\Sf]`S,mh1VD

7 �˚�� � ����˝

�*V ab*bn f\4qSZ\Ya,\Sf ]`S,mh1V

����•�˚ ���˝˚; �b\ , �S+WSS -\,\`Sbaq \ -\Y\a1Vad*WS4Y1H5> ����#& �˚�&˚

�*V \bZ\aSbnaq V S4Y1Z1ZSqY , 3S4ZS56 ���� % ���˙%

�\14/V* , �S`-S4Sp58 ���� ˛�˚ ) ���

S4Sh1aV*q ]`S,W1V*b1WnZ\abn5: �����• ���& � ˛��%�˚�H

˝S4Z1ZZmy gSVW ]1`S\/Sh1aVSf gSV*/

s ���˝˚ ���•�����&�

������ ��˙�˚�

�*V ]1`1ab*bn a]\`Sbn�d,ab,d1b1 WS ,mE hb\E `*4-\,*`S,*q a\a]dbZSV\Y 3S4ZSE ,m +d/b\ S/1b1 ]\ YSZZ\OYd ]\Wp S V*3/my Z1\ab\`\3Zmy j*- Y\31b,m4,*bn ,4`m, oY\gSy S ]1`1`*abS , 3*`OVSy a]\`H ˚aWS /*E b\ ob* ab*bnq /Wq ,*aD

L Y\b`Sb1 ,VW*/Vd ����˚• ��˚ ��˚��) ˛

������ � �˙��˚��M

�˙˚��˙����

�b\ -\,\`qb b,\S a,1`abZSVS�1`* , �\-*�\h1Yd `*4dYZ\ ,1`Sbn , a\b,\`1ZS1H

L Y\b`Sb1 ,VW*/Vd ����˚• ��˚ ��˚��) ˛

�˙� ���M

r

w

r

�`\+d/Sb1an! Š8 6>5: 7

�b\ \+k1-\ , /1yab,Sqf abSZ* S �\`SHa\4Z*pb \ZS ob\ SWS Z1bE Z\ \ZS \+* Z*f\/qbOaq ,\ ,W*abS Y\kZ\y aSWm P aSWm ]`S,mhVSD

� hb\ Y\3Z\ aV*4*bn \ ,*aH \b1WS +m,m `*4,Sbn V*VS1Ob\ ]\W14Zm1 ]`S,mhVSH\4Y\3Z\E ,m ]\ab*,SWS a1+1 g1Wn `1-dWq`Z\4*ZSY*bnaq a]\`b\YE `*Znj1 W\3Sbnaq a]*bnSWS +\Wnj1 ,`1Y1ZS ]`\,\/Sbn a +WS4VSYSWp/nYSD

�\ ,\4Y\3Z\E 1abn S b*VS1 ]`S,mhVSE \b V\Ob\`mf ,m `1jSWS S4+*,SbnaqD �*]`SY1`E ,mf\bSb1 +`\aSbn Vd`SbnE ]1`1ab*bn 1abn Z14/\O`\,dp ]Skd SWS Y1Znj1 ,`1Y1ZS b`*bSbnZ* SZb1`Z1bD

�*/\ ]`S4Z*bnE hb\ `*aab*,*bnaq a ]W\fSYS]`S,mhV*YS Z1 b*V W1-V\D �1/*`\Y -\,\`qbEhb\ ,`1/Z*q ]`S,mhV* V*V b1]W*q ]\ab1Wn, f\W\/Zmy /1ZnB 4*W14bn ]\/ \/1qW\ W1-V\E* ,mW14*bn aW\3Z\I

�*V 31 ab*bn f\4qSZ\Y a,\Sf ]`S,mh1VEhb\+m \ZS `*+\b*WS Z* Z*aE * Z1 ]`\bS, Z*aH�*aaY\b`SY b`S a\,1b*E V\b\`m1 \aZ\,*ZmZ* ]`SZgS]*f S4 �S+WSSD

�˚�� � ����˝

�*V ab*bn f\4qSZ\Y a,\Sf ]`S,mh1V

˛˚��� +d/SWnZSVD \bqabSZd ,a1 1k1 f\h1baqa]*bnE \Z a`*4d 31 ,ab*1bEZ*/1,*1b ]`S-\b\,W1ZZmya ,1h1`* a]\`bS,Zmy V\aObpY S ,mf\/Sb Z* ]`\+13OVdD abSZ +1-*1b ]\ db`*Yb`S `*4* , Z1/1Wp d31g1Wmy -\/D

�\`S b\WnV\ hb\ ]\aa\`SOW*an a Yd31YD `*aab`\1ZOZmf hd,ab,*f \Z* +13SbZ* VdfZpE /\ab*1b S4 jV*e*V\`\+Vd j\V\W*/Zmf V\Ze1bS al1/*1b Sf \/Zd 4* /`d-\yD�*V \Z* ]\abd]*1b V*3/my`*4E V\-/* Z1`,ZSh*1bD

\4Y\3Z\E ,m 4*f\bSb1 ]\Y1Zqbn , a,\1y3S4ZS ,a1 S a`*4dD m /dY*1b1B w�* ob\yZ1/1W1 +`\jd Vd`SbnE aV,1`Z\aW\,SbnEZ1 +d/d 4*aS3S,*bnaq /\]\4/Z*E Z*hZd4*ZSY*bnaq a]\`b\YE 1abn ]\W14Zdp ]SkdS ]\4,\Zp +*+djV1 a /1/djV\yxD /Z*V\E]mb*qan /\abShn \/Z\,`1Y1ZZ\ ,a1f a,\Sfg1W1yE ,mE aV\`11 ,a1-\E Z1 /\abS-ZSb1ZS \/Z\yI

���˚•�• �� ��B w�d/`\abn Pa\ aV`\YZmYSx L�`SbhS 55B6MD

�V`\YZm1 Wp/S `1*WSabShZmD ZS \a\4OZ*pbE hb\ Sf ,`1YqE aSWm S `1ad`am \-`*OZSh1ZZmD �\ob\YdE ,Y1ab\ b\-\ hb\+m Y1OZqbn ,a1 S a`*4dE b*VS1 Wp/S /1yab,dpb]\ob*]Z\D

��� ��˝ � ��˚˙�� )�&

�b*,nb1 `1*WSabShZm1 g1WSD \b hb\ ,*Y]\Y\31bB

�b\+m +mab`11 /\abShn da]1f*E 4*Y1ZSOb1 ]W\fS1 ]`S,mhVS f\`\jSYSD �`1/]\W\O3SYE , ,*j1Y a]SaV1 ]W\fSf ]`S,mh1V ab\OSb ]dZVb w�WSjV\Y YZ\-\ aY\b`p b1W1,SO4\`xE * , a]SaV1 f\`\jSf ]`S,mh1V Pw�*/\ +\Wnj1 \+k*bnaq a +WS4VSYS Wp/nOYSxD �\-/* ]\]`\+dyb1 aW1/dpk11B ,Y1ab\b\-\ hb\+mE ]`S/q /\Y\yE a`*4d 31 ,VWpOh*bn b1W1,S4\`E ]\\+k*yb1an a /`d-\Y SWS`\/ab,1ZZSV\Y S d4Z*yb1E V*V d Z1-\ /1W*D

1 �d/nb1 `1*WSabShZm

���˚˛ %˚ �� ��% ˛ ��� w�b\+m ,m d/\ab\,1`qWSan , b\YEhb\ +\W11 ,*3Z\x L�SWS]]Syg*Y 5B5>MD

w�\Z1g /1W* Wdhj1 1-\ Z*h*W*xL'VVW14S*ab ;B<MD

�mb*qan /\abShn \/Z\O,`1Y1ZZ\ ,a1f a,\Sfg1W1yE ,mE aV\`11 ,a1-\EZ1 /\abS-ZSb1 ZS \/Z\yI

5 �\4/*yb1 /,* a]SaV*B , ]1`,my ,]SOjSb1 f\`\jS1 ]`S,mhVSE V\b\`m1 ,*Yf\b1W\an +m `*4,SbnE * ,\ ,b\`\y P]W\fS1 ]`S,mhVSE \b V\b\`mf ,*YZd3Z\ S4+*,SbnaqD �1 \-`*ZShS,*yOb1an \/ZSYO/,dYq ]dZVb*YSD ˛*]SjSb1,a1E hb\ ]`Sf\/Sb Z* dYD

6 �`\ZdY1`dyb1 ]dZVbm , ]\`q/V1,*3Z\abSD

7 m+1`Sb1 \/SZ SWS /,* ]dZVb*S4 V*3/\-\ a]SaV* S ]\`*+\b*yb1Z*/ ZSYSD �\aW1 ob\-\ ,\4nYSb1an4* aW1/dpkS1 ]dZVbmD

�`\+d/Sb1an! Š8 6>5: 9

˙ m Z*ab`\SWSan ]`*,SWnZ\ ]Sb*bnaqEZ\ ob\b +`SV1b Y\`\31Z\-\ ,m-Wq/Sbb*V *]]1bSbZ\I

˙ m `1jSWS +`\aSbn Vd`SbnE Z\ ,*j /`d-aZ\,* ]`1/W*-*1b ,*Y aS-*`1bdE f\bqS 4Z*1bE hb\ ,m ab*`*1b1an ]\`,*bna ob\y ,`1/Z\y ]`S,mhV\yD

˙ m 4*]W*ZS`\,*WS Z* a1-\/Zq 4*ZqbSqa]\`b\YE Z\ ,*Y ]W\f\ d31 \b \/Z\y YmaOWSE hb\ ]`S/1baq ]1`1`mbn ,1an jV*e, ]\SaV*f V`\aa\,\VI

S/Sb1 WS ,m hb\Ob\ \+k11 , obSf b`1faWdh*qfH �*V ]\V*4m,*1b \]mbE Wp/SE a V\Ob\`mYS Ym ]`\,\/SY ,`1YqE S aSbd*gSSEV\b\`m1 Ym a1+1 a\4/*1YE ,WSqpb Z* b\E]`S\+`1b1Y WS Ym ]\W14Zm1 ]`S,mhVS SS4+*,SYaq WS \b ,`1/ZmfD

���˚•�• �� ��B w�`1/daY\b`SOb1WnZmy ,S/Sb +1/ab,S1 S dV`m,*1baqE* Z1\]mbZm1 S/db ,]1`1/ S Z*V*4m,*Opbaqx L�`SbhS 66B7MD

�S+WSq a\,1bd1b Z*Y /dY*bn Z*]1`1/D�*V*q ]`1/daY\b`Sb1WnZ\abn ]\Y\31b Z*YS4+1-*bn aSbd*gSyE V\b\`m1 Y1j*pb /\aObS31ZSp Z*jSf g1W1yD �W*-\/*`q ob\Yd Ym\V*31Yaq , +\W11 ,mS-`mjZ\Y ]\W\31ZSSL6 �SY\e1p 6B66MD �\`\bV\ -\,\`qE Zd3Z\d]`*,Wqbn a,\1y 3S4ZnpD

��� ��˝ � ��˚˙�� )�&˙ �/1W*yb1 b*VE hb\+m +mW\ aW\3Z11 ]\yObS Z* ]\,\/d d ]W\f\y ]`S,mhVSD �*]`SOY1`E 1aWS ,m f\bSb1 ]1`1ybS Z* 4/\`\,\1]Sb*ZS1E Z1 /1`3Sb1 /\Y* ]`\/dVbmE V\Ob\`m1E V*V ,m 4Z*1b1E ,`1/Zm /Wq ,*j1-\4/\`\,nqD �\-/*E 1aWS ,\4ZSVZ1b 31W*ZS1al1abn hb\OZS+d/n ,`1/Z\1E ]\//*bnaqSaVdj1ZSp +d/1b aW\3Z11E h1Y a]`*O,Sbnaq a ZSYD

˙ �/1W*yb1 b*VE hb\+m aW1/\,*bn f\`\j1y]`S,mhV1 ab*W\ ]`\k1D �*]`SY1`E 1aWS,m 4*]W*ZS`\,*WS a a*Y\-\ db`* ]\4*ZSOY*bnaq a]\`b\YE ]`S-\b\,nb1 a]\`bS,ZmyV\abpY a ,1h1`* S ]\W\3Sb1 1-\ `q/\Ya V`\,*bnpD �1Y W1-h1 +d/1b ]`Sabd]SbnV b`1ZS`\,V1E b1Y +\Wnj1 ,1`\qbZ\abnEhb\ ,m \adk1ab,Sb1 a,\S ]W*ZmD

˙ ZSY*b1WnZ\ \bZ1aSb1an V ,m+\`d /`dO41yD �m ab*Z\,SYaq ]\f\3S Z* Wp/1yEa V\b\`mYS ]`\,\/SY ,`1Yq L5 �\`SZeqOZ*Y 59B77MD �\ob\Yd \-`*ZShnb1 \+k1ZS1a b1YSE Vb\ ]\\k`q1b ]`S,mhVSE a V\b\O`mYS ,m +\`1b1anE S ]`\,\/Sb1 ,`1Yqa b1YSE Vb\ ]\+d3/*1b ,*a V f\`\j1YdD

2 �]`*,Wqyb1 a,\1y 3S4Znp

���˚˛ %˚ �� ��% ˛ ��� w�b\ f\/Sb a Yd/`mYSE ab*Z1b Yd/`mYxL�`SbhS 57B6>MD

w�W*Zm ]`SW13Z\-\ ]`S,\/qb V da]1fdxL�`SbhS 65B9MD

�/1W*yb1 b*VE hb\+maW1/\,*bn ]W\f\y]`S,mhV1 ab*W\ aW\3Z11E* f\`\j1y P ]`\k1

�mbd1b YZ1ZS1E hb\ `*4,Sbn Z\,dp ]`S,mhOVd Y\3Z\ 4* 65 /1ZnD /Z*V\E V*V ]\V*4mO,*pb SaaW1/\,*ZSqE ,a1 \h1Zn SZ/S,SO/d*WnZ\B \/ZSY Wp/qY Z* ob\ b`1+d1baqY1Znj1 ,`1Y1ZSE /`d-SY +\Wnj1D ˙\W3Z\WS ob\ ,*a `*aab`*S,*bnH

˙\]dabSYE ,m `1jSWS 4*ZSY*bnaqa]\`b\Y b`S `*4* , Z1/1WpD

˙ ]1`,dp Z1/1Wp ,m /\abS-WS a,\1yg1WSD

˙ \ ,b\`dp Z1/1Wp ,m ]`\]dabSWS \/Z\4*ZqbS1D

˙ b`1bnp Z1/1Wp ,m aZ\,* aW1/d1b1a,\1Yd ]W*ZdD

˙ h1b,1`bdp Z1/1Wp ,m ]`*VbSh1aVSZ1 4*ZSY*WSanD

˙ ]qbdp Z1/1Wp ,m aZ\,* /\abS-WSa,\1y g1WS S a b1f ]\` d31 Z1 ]`\]daOV*1b1 b`1ZS`\,\VD

�b*VE Z* e\`YS`\,*ZS1 Z\,\y ]`S,mhVSd ,*a djW\ ]qbn Z1/1WnD �\31b ]\V*4*bnaqEhb\ ob\ \h1Zn /\W-Sy a`\VE Z\E /\abS-Zd,a,\1y g1WSE ,m ]\hd,ab,d1b1 `*/\abn \bb\O-\E hb\ ]`S\+`1WS ]\W14Zdp ]`S,mhVdD

���˚•�• �� ��B w�`*,1/ZmyY\31b d]*abn S a1Yn `*4E Z\ ,a1 `*,Z\,ab*Z1bx L�`SbhS 68B5:MD

�S+WSq ]\+d3/*1b Z*a 4*]*abSan b1`]1OZS1YD V\Z1hZ\Y ah1b1 ,*3Z\ Z1 b\E aV\WnV\`*4 Ym ]*/*1YE * b\E aV\WnV\ `*4 Ym ,ab*1YD

��� ��˝ � ��˚˙�� )�&˙ �1 /dY*yb1E hb\ 1aWS ,m , V*V\yOb\Y\Y1Zb /*WS a1+1 aW*+SZdE b\ ,m 4*V\ZOh1ZZmy Z1d/*hZSVD �*ab`\yb1anE hb\Z* ]dbS V \adk1ab,W1ZSp a,\1y g1WSd ,*a SZ\-/* +d/db aWdh*bnaq a`m,mD

˙ �\a`1/\b\hS,*yb1an Z* a,\Sf da]1f*fD�*]`SY1`E 1aWS ,m f\bSb1 S4Y1ZSbnY*Z1`d \+k1ZSq a\ a,\SYS /1bnYSEa]`\aSb1 a1+qB w�b\ ]\Y\-W\ YZ1 ,]`\jWmy `*4 a/1`3*bnaq S Z1 ]\,maSbn-\W\a Z* `1+1ZV*H �\-d WS q , aW1/dpOkSy `*4 ]\abd]Sbn b*V 31Hx �\/\+Zm1,\]`\am ]\Y\-db ,*Y 4*V`1]Sbn ,*jda]1fE ,Y1ab\ b\-\ hb\+m 4*gSVWS,*bnaqZ* Z1d/*h*fD

�4Z*yb1E V*V +S+W1yaVS1 ]`SZgS]m Y\O-db ]\Y\hn ,*Y S , /`d-Sf ae1`*f 3S4ZSEZ*]`SY1` a]`*,Wqbnaq a +1a]\V\yab,*YSEa\/1yab,\,*bn +W*-\]\WdhSp , a1Yn1 S \+O`1abS Z*ab\qk11 ah*abn1D ˙Wq ob\-\ \+`*ObSb1an V �,S/1b1WqY �1-\,m SWS ]\a1bSb1Z*j a*yb jw.orgD ˛

3 ˛*]*aSb1an b1`]1ZS1Y

���˚˛ %˚ �� ��% ˛ ��� w�dabn b,\S -W*4* aY\b`qb ]`qY\x L�`SbhS 8B69MD

w˛*+m,*q b\E hb\ ]\4*/SE S ]`\abS`*qan V b\YdEhb\ ,]1`1/SE q ab`1YWpan V g1WSxL�SWS]]Syg*Y 7B57E 58MD

V\Z1hZ\Y ah1b1 ,*3Z\Z1 b\E aV\WnV\ `*4 Ym]*/*1YE * b\E aV\WnV\ `*4Ym ,ab*1Y

�`\+d/Sb1an! Š8 6>5: ;

���� ab`*Z*f \/Z\]\Wm1 +`*VS/\ aSf ]\` \ab*pbaq ]`1/Y1b\Y a]\`\,D�\-/* , 6>59 -\/d 1`f\,Zmy ad/ �"�d4*V\ZSW b*VS1 +`*VS Z* ,a1y b1``Sb\O`SS ab`*ZmE ob\ ab*W\ \/Z\y S4 a*Ymf\+ad3/*1Ymf b1Y , SZb1`Z1b1D /SZ S4h*ab\ 4*/*,*1Ymf ,\]`\a\, 4,dh*W b*VBw�b\ , �S+WSS -\,\`Sbaq \ -\Y\a1Vad*WnOZmf +`*V*fHx

�S+WSS Z1 \+ad3/*1baq ,\]`\a \ b\YESY1pb WS /,* h1W\,1V* \/Z\-\ ]\W* 4*V\ZO

Z\1 ]`*,\ ,abd]*bn , +`*VD ˚abn +\W11adk1ab,1ZZmy ,\]`\aB w�*V\,\ \bZ\j1ZS1�S+WSS V -\Y\a1Vad*WS4YdHx

�1 ]`\,1/q bk*b1WnZ\-\ SaaW1/\,*ZSq�S+WSSE YZ\-S1 Wp/S d,1`1ZmE hb\ 4Z*pb\b,1bEP Z\ ]`S ob\Y Sf YZ1ZSq `*af\/qbaqI�*VE Z1V\b\`m1 -\,\`qbE hb\ �S+WSq \/Z\O4Z*hZ\ ,mabd]*1b ]`\bS, -11,D ˙`d-S1 4*Oq,WqpbE hb\ +S+W1yaV\1 ]\,1W1ZS1 wWp+S+WS3Z1-\x \]`*,/m,*1b Wp+m1 e\`Yma1Vad*WnZmf \bZ\j1ZSy L�SYWqZ*Y 57B=MD

��� ������ ���)H

�*V\1 S4 obSf db,1`3/1ZSyE]\O,*j1YdE ,1`Z\H

5D �S+WSq \ad3/*1b -\Y\a1Vad*WS4YD

6D �S+WSq Z1 \ad3/*1b -\Y\a1Vad*WS4YD

7D �S+WSq ]\\k`q1b -\Y\e\+SpLZ1Z*,Sabn S ]`1/d+13/1ZZ\1\bZ\j1ZS1 V -\Y\a1Vad*WSab*YMD

���˚�%B

5D �˚� �D �S+WSS aV*4*Z\B w�\Y\a1VOad*WSabmDDD ZSV\Yd S4 ZSf Z1 ]\WdhSbnZ*aW1/Sq , �*`ab,1 �\-*x L5 �\`SZOeqZ*Y :B=E 5>E �\,`1Y1ZZmy `daaVSy]1`1,\/MD 'bS aW\,* \bZ\aqbaq V*VV Yd3hSZ*YE b*V S V 31ZkSZ*Y L�SYOWqZ*Y 5B6:MD

6D ˚�˚� �D �S+WSq dhSbE hb\ a1Vad*WnOZm1 \bZ\j1ZSq /\]dabSYm b\WnV\Y13/d Yd3hSZ\y S 31ZkSZ\yE a\1/SOZ1ZZmYS d4*YS +`*V* L�mbS1 5B6;E 6<C�`SbhS 9B5<E 5=MD

7D ˚�˚� �D \bq �S+WSq \ad3/*1b -\Y\Oa1Vad*WS4YE \Z* Z1 ]\\k`q1b ]`1/O,4qb\1 \bZ\j1ZS1 V -\Y\a1Vad*WSOab*YE *Vbm Z*aSWSq S /`d-S1 /1yab,SqEZ*]`*,W1ZZm1 ]`\bS, ZSf L�SYWqZ*Y56B5<M�5�D

�b\ , �S+WSS-\,\`Sbaq \-\Y\a1Vad*WS4Y1H

*V\,* ]\4SgSq �,S/1b1W1y 1-\,mH

�,S/1b1WS �1-\,m ,1`qbE hb\ �S+WSq Pa*Ymy WdhjSy Y\`*WnZmy V\/1VaE S ab*`*Opbaq ]\ Z1Yd 3Sbn L�a*Sq 8<B5;M�6�D �\ob\OYd /Wq ZSf Z1]`S1YW1Y\ Wp+\1 +14Z`*,Oab,1ZZ\1 ]\,1/1ZS1E , b\Y hSaW1 -\Y\a1VOad*WS4Y L5 �\`SZeqZ*Y :B5<M�7�D �,S/1b1WSf\bqb 3Sbn ]\ +S+W1yaVSY Z\`Y*YE S ob\ Sf4*V\ZZ\1 ]`*,\D

b\ 31 ,`1Yq �,S/1b1WS �1-\,m ab`1OYqbaq wV YS`d a\ ,a1YSx L˚,`1qY 56B58MD \bq �,S/1b1WS ahSb*pbE hb\ -\Y\a1Vad*OWS4Y Z1]`S1YW1YE \ZS Z1 Z*,q4m,*pb a,\S,4-Wq/m /`d-SYE Z1 a\,1`j*pb S Z1 \/\O+`qpb Z*aSWnab,1ZZmf /1yab,Sy ]`\bS,-\Y\a1Vad*WSab\,D �,S/1b1WS �1-\,m ]\Oabd]*pb , a\-W*aSS a 4\W\bmY ]`*,SW\YB\ZS \bZ\aqbaq V /`d-SY b*VE V*V f\bqbE hb\O+m \bZ\aSWSan V ZSY L�*be1q ;B56MD

�\\k`q1b WS �S+WSq ]`1/,4qb\1\bZ\j1ZS1H

�1V\b\`m1 db,1`3/*pbE hb\ �S+WSq a11b]`1/d+13/1ZS1 ]\ \bZ\j1ZSp V -\Y\a1VOad*WSab*Y S hb\ b1E Vb\ aW1/dpb 11 Z\`Y*YE]`\q,Wqpb Z1b1`]SY\abnD w�S+WSq ]Sa*OW*an , b1 ,`1Y1Z*E V\-/* Wp/S YmaWSWS d4OV\ S +mWS ]\WZm ]`1/`*aad/V\,EP -\,\`qbab\`\ZZSVS b*V\-\ ,4-Wq/*DP Z*j1 ,`1Yq\+k1ab,\ ]`S4Z*1b ]`1/ab*,Sb1W1y Wp+\y`*amE Z*gS\Z*WnZ\abS S a1Vad*WnZ\y \`SO1Zb*gSSxD �\-W*aZ\ b*V\Yd YZ1ZSpE \ad3O/*bn -\Y\a1Vad*WS4Y P ,a1 `*,Z\ hb\ \bO,1`-*bn Wp/1y a /`d-SY g,1b\Y V\3SD �\dY1abZ\ WS b*V\1 a`*,Z1ZS1H �1bD �\h1YdH

�\b\Yd hb\ 1abn +\Wnj*q `*4ZSg* Y13O/d b1YE hb\+m \ad3/*bn -\Y\a1Vad*WnZ\1]\,1/1ZS1E S b1YE hb\+m \b,1`-*bn Wp/1yEV\b\`m1 ,1/db -\Y\a1Vad*WnZmy \+`*43S4ZSD �S+WSq ]\+d3/*1b f`SabS*Z d,*O3*bn ,a1f Wp/1y L5 �1b`* 6B5;M�8�D �\ ob\Z1 4Z*hSbE hb\ f`SabS*Z1 /\W3Zm \/\+`qbnWp+\1 ]\,1/1ZS1D

�*aaY\b`SY ]`SY1`D �`1/]\W\3SYE ,mahSb*1b1 Vd`1ZS1 ,`1/Z\y S /*31 \b,`*bSO

b1WnZ\y ]`S,mhV\yE * ,*j a\b`d/ZSV ]\`*+\b1 Vd`SbD �d/db WS ,*a ahSb*bn \-`*ZSOh1ZZmY S4O4* b\-\E hb\ ,m ]\O/`d-\Yd \bZ\OaSb1an V Vd`1ZSpH �\3Z\ WS db,1`3/*bnEhb\ `*4 ,m Z1 Vd`Sb1E b\ d ,*a ]`1/d+13/1OZS1 V Vd`qkSYH � 1aWS a\b`d/ZSV ,/`d-ab*W +m Z*ab*S,*bnE hb\+m ,m S4Y1ZSWSa,\1 \bZ\j1ZS1 V Vd`1ZSpE `*4,1 ob\ Z1-\,\`SW\ +m \ b\YE hb\ \Z a*Y YmaWSb d4V\S ]`\q,Wq1b Z1b1`]SY\abnH

�,S/1b1WS �1-\,m ]`S/1`3S,*pbaq Y\O`*WnZmf ]`SZgS]\, S4 �S+WSSD ZS Z1\/\+`qpb /1W*E V\b\`m1 �S+WSq \ad3/*1bD/Z*V\ \ZS Z1 ,maY1S,*pb Wp/1yE V\b\O`m1 ,1/db /`d-\y \+`*4 3S4ZSE S Z1 \bZ\Oaqbaq V ZSY a ]`1Z1+`131ZS1YD

1 aWSjV\Y WS �S+WSq ab`\-*H

� hb\ Y\3Z\ aV*4*bn \ Wp/qf a -\Y\a1VOad*WnZmYS Z*VW\ZZ\abqYSH ),Wqpbaq WSobS Z*VW\ZZ\abS ,`\3/1ZZmYSH ˚aWS /*E`*4,1 Z1 31ab\V\ \ad3/*bn Wp/1y 4* b\Ehb\ \ZS ]`\ab\ aW1/dpb a,\SY 1ab1ab,1ZOZmY 31W*ZSqYH

�S+WSS ZSh1-\ Z1 aV*4*Z\ \ +S\W\-SOh1aV\y ]`S`\/1 -\Y\a1Vad*WS4Y*D b\ 31,`1Yq \Z* ]`S4Z*1bE hb\ d h1W\,1V* Y\-db+mbn -Wd+\V\ dV\`1ZS,jS1aq h1`bm f*`*VOb1`*D �\ , Z1y -\,\`SbaqE hb\E 1aWS Ym f\ObSY `*/\,*bn �\-*E Ym /\W3Zm S4+1-*bn\]`1/1W1ZZ\-\ ]\,1/1ZSqE , b\Y hSaW1 -\OY\a1Vad*WS4Y* L6 �\`SZeqZ*Y 5>B8E 9MD

�b\Ob\ aV*31bE hb\�S+WSq aWSjV\Yab`\O-*D �\ b*V\y ,4-Wq/ ]`1/]\W*-*1bE hb\ Ym/\W3Zm aW1/\,*bn a,\SY a1Vad*WnZmY 31OW*ZSqYE V\b\`m1Z*ab\WnV\,*3ZmEhb\Sf Z1Zd3Z\ S /*31 Z1,\4Y\3Z\ V\Zb`\WS`\,*bnD/Z*V\ �S+WSq ,\4,mj*1b h1W\,1V*E -\,\O`qE hb\ \ZY\31b ]`\bS,\ab\qbn a,\SY31W*OZSqYD \bWShS1 \b 3S,\bZmfE V\b\`m1 `dV\O,\/ab,dpbaq SZabSZVb*YSE Wp/SY\-db a/1`O3S,*bn a,\S ]\`m,m L�\W\aaqZ*Y7B9M�9�D�1V\b\`m1 a]1gS*WSabm ahSb*pbE hb\

\]`1/1W1ZZm1 h1`bm f*`*Vb1`*E Z*]`SY1`*-`1aaS,Z\abnE Y\-db SY1bn +S\W\-Sh1O

�`\+d/Sb1an! Š8 6>5: =

aVdp ]`S`\/dD \bq �S+WSq Z1 a\/1`3SbZ*dhZmf \+lqaZ1ZSy ]\ ob\Yd ]\,\/dE \Z*]`S4Z*1bE hb\ Z1V\b\`m1 Wp/S Y\-db +mbn,a]mWnhS,mYS S aVW\ZZmYS -\`qhSbnaqL�`SbhS 66B68C 6=B66MD �1Y Z1 Y1Z11 \Z*]`S4m,*1bB wab*,n -Z1, S \b,1`-ZSq`\abnx L�a*W\Y 7;B<C 'e1aqZ*Y 8B75MD

`q/ WS Vb\Ob\ aV*31bE hb\ /*,*bn b*V\ya\,1b h1W\,1VdE aVW\ZZ\Yd V *-`1aaSSE 31Oab\V\D ˙*31 dh1Zm1E V\b\`m1 d+13/1ZmEhb\ *-`1aaS,Z\abn 4*W\31Z* , -1Z*fE Skdba]\a\+m ]\Y\hn Wp/qY V\Zb`\WS`\,*bna,\y -Z1,D

�,S/1b1WS �1-\,m 4*ZSY*pb b*Vdp 31]\4SgSp ]\ \bZ\j1ZSp V Wp+\Yd ]\,1/1OZSpE V\b\`\1 ]`\bS,\`1hSb +S+W1yaVSYZ\`Y*YE , b\Y hSaW1 V SZbSYZmY \bZ\j1ZSOqY Y13/d Yd3hSZ\y S 31ZkSZ\yE V\b\`m1Z1 a\ab\qb /`d- a /`d-\Y , +`*V1D �S+WSqa\,1bd1b ,a1Y dY1bn w,W*ab,\,*bn Z*/ a,\OSY b1W\Y a\ a,qb\abnp S /\ab\SZab,\YxE* Z1 S/bS wZ* ]\,\/d a,\Sf ZS4Y1ZZmfab`*ab1yx L5 �1aa*W\ZSVSyg*Y 8B8E 9E�\,my `daaVSy ]1`1,\/MD

w 1V\b\`m1S4 ,*a SY1ZZ\ b*VSYS S+mWSx I ,1V1 f`SabS*Z*YS ab*Z\,SWSan a*Ym1

`*4Zm1 Wp/SE S V\YdOb\ S4 ZSf Zd3Z\ +mW\, V\`Z1 S4Y1ZSbn a,\y \+`*43S4ZSD �*]`SOY1`E , 5 �\`SZeqZ*Y :B=P55 d]\YSZ*pbaq`*4,`*bZSVSE S/\W\]\VW\ZZSVSE wZ*`djSOb1WS ad]`d31aV\y ,1`Z\abSE ]*aaS,Zm1 S*VbS,Zm1 -\Y\a1Vad*WSabmOYd3hSZmx S -\O,\`SbaqB wA Z1V\b\`m1 S4 ,*a SY1ZZ\ b*VSOYS S +mWSx L�YmaW\,\y ]1`1,\/MD

4Z*h*pb WS aW\,* w* Z1V\b\`m1 S4 ,*aSY1ZZ\ b*VSYS S +mWSxE hb\ b1E Vb\ ]1`1Oab*W dh*ab,\,*bn , -\Y\a1Vad*WnZmf\bZ\j1ZSqfE Z*,a1-/* \a,\+\/SWSan \bZ1hSabmf 31W*ZSyH `q/ WSE ,1/n �S+WSq]\+d3/*1bB w�\abd]*yb1 ]\ /dfdE S ,m

Z1 +d/1b1 Sa]\WZqbn ZSV*VSf ]W\baVSf 31OW*ZSyx L�*W*b*Y 9B5:MD

˛*Y1bnb1E , �S+WSS Z1 aV*4*Z\E hb\ f`SOabS*ZSZ ]1`1ab*Z1b Sa]mbm,*bn -\Y\a1VadO*WnZm1 31W*ZSqD Z1y -\,\`SbaqE hb\ aWdO3Sb1Wn �\-* Z1 +d/1b Sf Sa]\WZqbnD `SabSO*Z1 dh*baq V\Zb`\WS`\,*bn b*VS1 31W*ZSqE,Y1ab\ b\-\ hb\+m `*4,S,*bn Sf S S/bSd ZSf Z* ]\,\/d L�*V\,* 5B58E 59M�:�D�*VSY \+`*4\YE �S+WSq ]`\,\/Sb h1bV\1

`*4WShS1 Y13/d Z*VW\ZZ\abqYS S ]\,1/1OZS1Y L�SYWqZ*Y ;B5:P69MD �1W\,1V a -\Y\Oa1Vad*WnZmYS Z*VW\ZZ\abqYS Y\31b V\ZOb`\WS`\,*bn a,\S Z1hSabm1 31W*ZSqE b*V31 V*V \Z a]\a\+1Z V\Zb`\WS`\,*bn WpO+m1 /`d-S1 Z1]`*,SWnZm1 31W*ZSqE Z*]`SOY1` 31W*ZS1 ,a]mWSbnE S4Y1ZSbn a]dbZSVd3S4ZS SWS hb\Ob\ dV`*abn L5 �\`SZeqZ*Y=B6;C 6 �1b`* 6B58E 59MD

�,S/1b1WS �1-\,m ]`S/1`3S,*pbaq +S+OW1yaVSf Z`*,ab,1ZZmf Z\`YE Z\ ]`S ob\Y\ZS Z1 Z*,q4m,*pb a,\S ,4-Wq/m \V`d3*pOkSYD �*V31 \ZS Z1 /\+S,*pbaq \bY1Zm 4*OV\Z\,E 4*kSk*pkSf ]`*,* b1fE h1y \+`*43S4ZS \bWSh*1baq \b Sf Z\`Y ]\,1/1ZSqD1abnE V\b\`dp Z1adb �,S/1b1WS �1-\,mE]\W\3Sb1WnZ\ ,WSq1b Z* Wp/1yD �,S/1b1WSa `*/\abnp /1Wqbaq 1y a\ ,a1YSE Vb\ -\b\,Sf aWdj*bn L˙1qZSq 6>B6>MD ˛

�,S/1b1WS �1-\,m ]\abd]*pb , a\-W*aSS a 4\W\bmY ]`*,SW\YB\ZS \bZ\aqbaq V /`d-SY b*VE V*V f\bqbE hb\+m \bZ\aSWSan V ZSY

����˚����)B5D �SYWqZ*Y 56B5<B w�d/nb1 , YS`1 a\ ,a1YS Wp/nYSxD6D �a*Sq 8<B5;B w)E �1-\,*EP b,\y �\-E V\b\`my dhSbb1+q ]\W14Z\YdxD

7D 5 �\`SZeqZ*Y :B5<B w�1-Sb1 \b `*4,`*b*Ix L�\,`1OY1ZZmy `daaVSy ]1`1,\/MD

8D 5 �1b`* 6B5;B w�\hSb*yb1 Wp/1y ,aqV\-\ `\/*xD9D �\W\aaqZ*Y 7B9B w�\ob\Yd dY1`b,Sb1 , a1+1 ,a1 b\Ehb\ , ,*a \b 41YZ\y ]`S`\/mB `*a]dbab,\E +14Z`*,abO,1ZZ\abnE ab`*abSx L�\,`1Y1ZZmy `daaVSy ]1`1,\/MD

:D �*V\,* 5B58E 59B w�*3/my Sa]mbm,*1baqE d,W1V*qanS a\+W*4Zqqan a\+ab,1ZZmY 31W*ZS1YD ˛*b1Y 31W*OZS1E 4*h*,E `\3/*1b -`1fxD

���˙ ���&

� �*]* ]\WdhSW Z\,dp `*+\bdES ,*j* a1Ynq /\W3Z* ]1`1O1f*bnD

� �,\y WdhjSy /`d- d143*1bD

� �b*`jSy +`*b SWS a1ab`*,abd]*1b , +`*V S +d/1b3Sbn \b/1WnZ\D

�*aV\WnV\ W1-V\ b1+1 ]`Sa]\Oa\+Sbnaq V obSY S4Y1Z1ZSqYH

˚aWS /1`1,\ -Z1baq \b ,1b`*EaV\`11 ,a1-\E \Z\ Z1 aW\Y*1baq,\ ,`1Yq +d`SD �\/\+Z\ b*V\Yd/1`1,dE bm Y\31jn dhSbnaq+mbn -S+VSY S ]\/ab`*S,*bnaq]\/ \+ab\qb1Wnab,*E V\b\`m1b1+1 ]\hbS SWS a\,a1Y Z1]\/O,W*abZmD �`13/1 h1Y d4Z*bnEV*V ob\ /1W*bnE /*,*y ]\-\,\O`SY \ a*YSf S4Y1Z1ZSqfD

��� �˝ � ˛ ��&

4Y1Z1ZSq Z1S4+13ZmD �S+WSS \h1Zn b\hZ\ aV*4*Z\Bw˙Wq ,a1f ,`1Yq S aWdh*yx L'VVW14S*ab =B55MD �*Z\ SWS]\4/Z\ bm d+1/Sjnaq , SabSZZ\abS obSf aW\,D �\Z1hZ\Ew,`1Yq S aWdh*yx Z1 ,a1-/* ]`SZ\aqb hb\Ob\ ]W\f\1D �\O`\y S4Y1Z1ZSqE V\b\`m1 V*3dbaq Z1]`SqbZmYSE Y\-db\+1`Zdbnaq V Wdhj1YdD � ,a1 31 S4Y1Z1ZSq P V*V f\`\jS1Eb*V S ]W\fS1 P YZ\-Sf ,m+S,*pb S4 V\W1SD

4Y1Z1ZSq \a\+1ZZ\ b`d/Zm /Wq ]\/`\abV\,D �\h1YdH\b hb\ -\,\`Sb �W1Va�B w�Zdb`S b1+q S b*V d31 ]`\Saf\O/qb S4Y1Z1ZSqE * bdb 1k1 S ]1`1Y1Zm S4,Z1I 'b\ b\WnV\/\+*,Wq1b ab`1aaxD

˚abn 1k1 \/Z* ]`ShSZ*D �\-/* , 3S4ZS ,4`\aW\-\ h1W\,1V*]`\Saf\/qb ]1`1Y1ZmE a]`*,Sbnaq a ZSYS 1Yd ]\Y\-*1b3S4Z1ZZmy \]mbD �\ d ]\/`\abV\, b*V\-\ \]mb* ]\hbS Z1bD

S4Y1Z1ZSqY Zd3Z\ dhSbnaq ]`Sa]\a*+WS,*bnaqD �]\Oa\+Z\abn +mab`\ ,\aab*Z*,WS,*bnaq ]\aW1 ab`1aa\,\y aSObd*gSS S dY1ZS1 ]`Sa]\a*+WS,*bnaq V S4Y1Z1ZSqY Z*4m,*O1baq ]aSf\W\-Sh1aV\y dab\yhS,\abnpD �*V*q dab\yhS,\abn]\Y\-*1b Z1 ]`\ab\ ]1`13Sbn aSbd*gSpE Z\ S d,S/1bn 4*V*3dkSYSaq ]`1]qbab,SqYS Z\,m1 ,\4Y\3Z\abSD �\/`\abOVSE V\b\`m1 Z*dhSWSan ]`Sa]\a*+WS,*bnaq V S4Y1Z1ZSqYE`131 ]`S+1-*pb V Z*`V\bSV*Y SWS *WV\-\Wp , b`d/Zmy /Wqa1+q ]1`S\/ 3S4ZSD

� �1V\b\`m1 SY1Z* , ob\y ab*bn1 S4Y1Z1ZmD

����#& �˚�&˚ � ��˙˚˝&

�*V \bZ\aSbnaqV S4Y1Z1ZSqY, 3S4ZS

r ˙`d-S1 ab*bnS , ]\Y\kn a1YnqY Y\3Z\ Z*ybS Z* a*yb1 jw.org

�`\+d/Sb1an! Š8 6>5: 55

��� ��˝ � ��˚˙�� )�&

�`SYS `1*WnZ\abnD �\Z1hZ\E b1+1 f\b1W\an +m V\Zb`\OWS`\,*bn ,a1 , a,\1y 3S4ZSE Z\ ob\ Z1,\4Y\3Z\D ˙`d4nqY\-db d1f*bn , /`d-\y -\`\/ SWS ,abd]Sbn , +`*VC +`*b Sa1ab`* ,m`*abdb S ]\VSZdb `\/Z\y /\YC \+ab\qb1Wnab,*Y\-db ,mZd/Sbn ,*jd a1Ynp ]1`11f*bnE S4O4* h1-\ ]`S/1bOaq \ab*,Sbn /`d41y S ]`S,mhZdp \+ab*Z\,VdD �\ob\Yd WdhOj1 ]`SZqbn `1*WnZ\abnE h1Y ]\4,\WSbn Z1-*bS,ZmY YmaWqY4*,W*/1bn b\+\yD L�S+W1yaVSy ]`SZgS]B 'VVW14S*ab ;B5>DM

�Y\b`S ,]1`1/D˝Sbn ]`\jWmY P ,a1 `*,Z\ hb\ aY\b`1bnb\WnV\ , 41`V*W\ 4*/Z1-\ ,S/*E V\-/* ,1/1jn *,b\Y\+SWnD�\Z1hZ\E ,`1Yq \b ,`1Y1ZS ob\ /1W*bn Z1\+f\/SY\E Z\-W*,ZmY \+`*4\Y Zd3Z\ a\a`1/\b\hSbnaq Z* /\`\-1 ,]1O`1/SD 'b\b 31 ]`SZgS] ]`SY1ZSY S V ]1`1Y1Z*Y , 3S4ZSD�b*`*yaq aY\b`1bn , +d/dk11 L�`SbhS 8B69MD �\/dY*yE Z*O]`SY1`E V*VS1 g1WS bm Y\- +m ]\ab*,Sbn Z* +WS3*yjSyY1aqg SWS ]\W-\/*D

�\a`1/\b\hS,*yaq Z* ]\W\3Sb1WnZ\YD w�Y1ZS1 ]`Sa]\Oa*+WS,*bnaq V S4Y1Z1ZSqYP ob\ ,\]`\a Z*ab`\qEP -\,\`Sb/1,djV* ]\SY1ZS �\`*DP�kS ]\W\3Sb1WnZ\1 , a,\1y aSbdO*gSSxD �\ab*`*yaq d,S/1bn f\bq+m\/SZ ]Wpa, a,\Sf Z\,mf\+ab\qb1Wnab,*fD L�S+W1yaVSy ]`SZgS]B 'VVW14S*ab :B=DM

˙1,djV* ]\ SY1ZS SVb\`Sq ,a]\YSZ*1bE hb\E V\-/* \Z*+mW* ]\/`\abV\YE ,a1 11 +WS4VS1 /`d4nq `*4l1f*WSan Vb\Vd/*D w�Z1 +mW\ b*V \/SZ\V\I \b1W\anE hb\+m ,a1 \ab*O,*W\an V*V ]`13/1EP -\,\`Sb \Z*DP �\ a1yh*a q ]\ZSY*pEhb\ SY1ZZ\ b\-/* q Z*h*W* ,4`\aW1bnD ) \a\4Z*W*E hb\ +14S4Y1Z1ZSy Z1 ]\,4`\aW11jnD �`\Y1 b\-\E q d,S/1W*E hb\,\V`d- Y1Zq 1abn b1E a V1Y Y\3Z\ ]\/`d3SbnaqxD L�S+W1yOaVSy ]`SZgS]B �`SbhS 6;B5>DM

�\Y\-*y /`d-SYD �S+WSS -\,\`SbaqE hb\ Ym /\W3Zm4*+\bSbnaq wZ1 b\WnV\ \ a,\Sf SZb1`1a*fE Z\ S \+ SZb1`1Oa*f /`d-Sfx L�SWS]]Syg*Y 6B8MD �1`1Z\aSbn a\+ab,1ZZm1b`d/Z\abS +d/1b W1-h1E 1aWS ]\Y\-*bn \V`d3*pkSYD �ZZ*EV\b\`\y 5; W1bE /1WSbaqB w�\ ,`1Y1Z1Y q ]\ZqW*E hb\E V\-/*]\Y\-*1jn b1YE Vb\ \V*4*Waq , ]\/\+Z\y SWS /*31 fd/j1yaSbd*gSSE ob\ ]`SZ\aSb ]\Wn4d b1+1 a*Y\yxD ˛

�(�˚�%˚���˚•�˚ ���

w�1 -\,\`SB t�\h1Yd ]`13ZS1/ZS +mWS Wdhj1 ZmZ1jZSfHrxL'VVW14S*ab ;B5>MD

w�dhj1 `*/\,*bnaq b\YdEhb\ SY11jnE h1Y 31W*bn b\-\Ehb\ Z1 SY11jnx L'VVW14S*ab :B=E�YmaW\,\y ]1`1,\/MD

w�dhj1 a\a1/ ,+WS4SE h1Y +`*b,/*WSx L�`SbhS 6;B5>MD

���

w�b\+m dhSbnaq ]`Sa]\a*+WS,*bnOaq V ]1`1Y1Z*YE Zd3Z\ *Z*WSO4S`\,*bn aSbd*gSpE , V\b\`\y\V*4*WaqE S \a\4Z*bnE hb\ S4Y1Z1OZSq P ob\ h*abn 3S4ZSD �1Y +mabO`11 ]`SY1jn `1*WnZ\abnE b1Y W1-Oh1 b1+1 +d/1b ]`Sa]\a\+SbnaqD�*Z\ SWS ]\4/Z\ ,a1 Z*W*/SbaqxD

�����

w�1`13S, hb\Ob\ Z1]`SqbZ\1Eq ab*`*pan Z1 4*gSVWS,*bnaqZ* ob\YE * 3Sbn /*Wnj1D ˙dY*pEhb\+m dY1bn ]`Sa]\a*+WS,*bnaqV Z\,mY \+ab\qb1Wnab,*YE Zd3Z\aY\b`1bn ,]1`1/E * Z1 Z*4*/xD

˝Sbn ]`\jWmY P ,a1 `*,Z\ hb\ aY\b`1bnb\WnV\ , 41`V*W\ 4*/Z1-\ ,S/*E V\-/*,1/1jn *,b\Y\+SWn

��˝˚ �) ,ma\VSYS 4*aZ131ZZmYS ,1`jSOZ*YS �S`-S4Sq Z*f\/Sbaq , �`1/Z1y �4SS S

-`*ZShSb a �*4*fab*Z\YE �4+1VSab*Z\YE �*/3SVSab*OZ\Y S �Sb*1YD �\hbS => ]`\g1Zb\, b1``Sb\`SS ab`*OZm 4*ZSY*pb -\`mD �S`-S4SS Z*f\/Sbaq a*Y*q ,mOa\V*q b\hV* -\`Z\y aSab1Ym �qZnO"*ZnC 11 ,ma\b* P;87= Y1b`\, Z*/ d`\,Z1Y Y\`qD V\W\ 8 ]`\g1Zb\,]W\k*/S ob\y ab`*Zm ]\V`mb\ W1a*YSD �Y1ZZ\ 4/1an`*a]\W*-*pbaq V`d]Z1yjS1 Z* ]W*Z1b1 W1a* -`1gV\O-\ \`1f*D

�S`-S4m S4,1abZm a,\SY -\ab1]`SSYab,\Y S d,*O31ZS1Y V Wp/qYD � b1YE Vb\ ab*`j1E 4/1an \+`*k*Opbaq Z* w,mxE dabd]*pb SY Y1ab\ , \+k1ab,1ZZ\Yb`*Za]\`b1 S ]`1/W*-*pb a*Ym1 ]\h1bZm1 Y1ab*4* ab\W\YD

VS`-S4aVSf a1Ynqf , a`1/Z1Y b`\1 SWS +\W11/1b1yD �W*/jSy amZ /*31 ]\aW1 ,abd]W1ZSq , +`*V\+mhZ\ 3S,1b a `\/Sb1WqYS S 4*+\bSbaq \ ZSfD

���� % ���˙% � �����˛�)

�\14/V* , S`-S4Sp

��˛� ����

�˛�˚������

��˙˝�������

����•

��"�˚�

� � � � � ˛ � )�*jO�*+*b

�RobertPreston/agefotostock

�`\+d/Sb1an! Š8 6>5: 57

˙1,\h1V a a*Y\-\ /1bab,* dh*b ,1abS f\4qyab,\Ehb\E Z1a\YZ1ZZ\E ]`S-\/Sbaq SY , +d/dk1YD ]\/O`\abV\,\Y ,\4`*ab1 \ZS d31 ]\WZ\abnp ]\/-\b\,W1OZm V a*Y\ab\qb1WnZ\y 3S4ZSD ˙Wq +d/dk1y Z1,1abma\+S`*1baq ]`S/*Z\1B ,a1,\4Y\3Z\1 ]\ab1WnZ\1 +1OWn1E Z*`q/m S V\,1` `dhZ\y `*+\bmD ˝1ZSf ]W*bSbV*WmYE SWS ,mVd] 4* Z1,1abdE /1Zn-*YS S 3S,\bZmYSS4 ab*/*D

\ ,`1Yq ]`*4/ZSV\, SWS ]\f\`\Z ]\ b`*/SgSS`13db W\j*/n SWS +*`*Z*D �djd /1Wqb Z* h*abSE SV*3/*q h*abn ]`1/Z*4Z*h*1baq V\ZV`1bZ\Yd h1W\O,1VdD �\abn ]\Wdh*1b ]\`gSp , 4*,SaSY\abS \b a,\1O-\ ,\4`*ab* S ]\W\31ZSq , \+k1ab,1D �Wph1,dp`\Wn , ob\y b`*/SgSS S-`*1b d,*31ZS1D ˛*b1Y ]\O/*1baq Z*gS\Z*WnZ\1 VS`-S4aV\1 +Wp/\ +1j+*`Y*VEV\b\`\1 ]`SZqb\ 1abn `dV*YSD ˛

���˚ ��˚˙˚ )

*a1W1ZS1B 9 ;;:>>>

�b\WSg*B �SjV1V

)4mVB VS`-S4aVSyE `daaVSy

�aZ\,Zm1 b\,*`m oVa]\`b*BfW\]\VE j1`abnE 4\W\b\E `bdbnEd`*Z

�1WS-SqB SaW*Y L<> ]`\g1Zb\,Z*a1W1ZSqM

�S`-S4SS +W*-\/*`q]\Y\kS �,S/1b1W1y �1-\,mbmaqhS h1W\,1V 4Z*V\Yqbaqa +S+W1yaV\y SabSZ\y

�\Yd4 P Z*`\/ZmyYd4mV*WnZmy SZab`dY1Zb

�dYma P Z*]Sb\VS4 ]1`1+`\/S,j1-\V\+mWn1-\ Y\W\V*

% (`bm , /\WSZ1 �*jO�*+*b

�ZS-* w�1Yd Z* a*Y\Y/1W1 dhSb �S+WSqHxZ* VS`-S4aV\Y q4mV1/\abd]Z* Z* a*yb1jw.org

���� ˛�˚ ) ��� � ��˛��˚���) ����˚���˚�&���&

��˛��˚���) ����˚���˚�&���&�*j1 \bZ\j1ZS1 V eS4Sh1aV\y V`*a\b1 Y\31b a/1W*bn Z*a WS+\ ah*abWS,mYSEWS+\ Z1ah*abZmYSD

�\h1Yd Wp/S g1Zqb V`*a\bdH

�\E V*V h1W\,1h1aVSy Y\4- ,\a]`SZSY*1bV`*a\bdE /\ aSf ]\` \ab*1baq 4*-*/V\yD �S+OWSq Z1 \+lqaZq1bE V*VS1 ]`S ob\Y ]`\Saf\O/qb ]`\g1aamE Z\ , Z1y -\,\`SbaqE \bVd/*, Z*a hd,ab,\ ]`1V`*aZ\-\D ˙1W\ , b\YE hb\�\- Z*/1WSW Z*a b*VSYS 31 hd,ab,*YSE V*Vd Z1-\ L�mbS1 5B6;C 'VVW14S*ab 7B55MD �`\Y1b\-\E \Z a\4/*W Z1,1`\qbZ\ aW\3Z\1 S V`*OaS,\1 h1W\,1h1aV\1 b1W\E \+W*/*pk11 ]\O`*4Sb1WnZmYS ,\4Y\3Z\abqYSD �1aWdh*yZ\\/SZ h1W\,1VE 3S,jSy , /`1,Z\abSE aV*4*W\ �\-1B w�d/d f,*WSbn b1+qE ]\b\Yd hb\ q a\O4/*Z d/S,Sb1WnZ\ S ob\ ,Zdj*1b +W*-\-\,1OZS1x L�a*W\Y 57=B58MD

/Z*V\ a1-\/Zq YZ\-S1 ]`S/*pb aWSjV\Y+\Wnj\1 4Z*h1ZS1 V`*a\b1 S ,Z1jZ1Yd ,SO/dE h1Yd ,\ YZ\-\Y a]\a\+ab,dpb SZ/dab`SqY\/m S a`1/ab,* Y*aa\,\y SZe\`Y*gSSD�\-W*aZ\ \/Z\y VZS-1E SaaW1/\,*ZSqE ]`\O,1/1ZZm1 , 4*]*/Zmf ab`*Z*fE ]\V*4m,*pbEhb\ weS4Sh1aV*q ]`S,W1V*b1WnZ\abn ab*W*Z*S,*3Z1yjSY e*Vb\`\YE ,WSqpkSY Z* a*OY\\g1ZVd h1W\,1V*x LBody ImageMD �\ ]`S

b*V\Y d4V\Y ,4-Wq/1 Z1`1/V\ d]daV*1baq b\Ehb\ Z*YZ\-\ ,*3Z11 eS4Sh1aV\y V`*a\bmEP,Zdb`1ZZSy YS` h1W\,1V* L5 �*YdSW* 5:B;MD

�1Y +\Wnj1 /1W*1baq *Vg1Zb Z* ,Z1jOZ\abSE b1Y aSWnZ11 ]\/h1`VS,*1baq a1VadO*WnZ\abnE \a\+1ZZ\ 31ZaV*qD \bh1b1 �Y1O`SV*ZaV\y *aa\gS*gSS ]aSf\W\-\, L���M4* 6>>; -\/ -\,\`SW\anB w�`*VbSh1aVS ,a1`*aaY\b`1ZZm1 Sab\hZSVS SZe\`Y*gSS q,OZ\ dV*4m,*pb Z* a1Vad*WS4*gSp 31ZkSZxD�1aWdh*yZ\ �S+WSq Z*ab\yhS,\ ]`S4m,*1bZ*a ]`\bS,\ab\qbn ]\/\+Z\y b1Z/1ZgSSL�\W\aaqZ*Y 7B9E :MD

w�dabn ,*a dV`*j*1b Z1 hb\Ob\ ,Z1jOZ11DDD Z\ b\E hb\ aV`mb\ , a1`/g1h1W\,1V*EP Z1bW1ZZmy Z*`q/ a]\V\yOZ\-\ S V`\bV\-\ /df*E V\b\`my \h1Zng1Z1Z , -W*4*f �\-*x L5 �1b`* 7B7E 8MD

�\h1Yd ,*3Z\ SY1bn 4/`*,my ,4-Wq/ Z* V`*a\bdH

�1V\b\`m1 -\,\`qbB w�Y1y oee1VbZ\ ,m/1OWSbn b\E h1Y Z*-`*/SW* b1+q ]`S`\/*Ix�*V a\\+k*1baq , \bh1b1 ���E , VdWnbdO`*fE -/1 b*V\y ,4-Wq/ P Z\`Y*E Y\W\/m1 /1O,djVS S /*31 /1,\hVS Z*hSZ*pb ,\a]`SZSO

Y*bn a1+q V*V w\+l1Vb a1Vad*WnZmf 31W*OZSyE Z* V\b\`my /`d-S1 +d/db aY\b`1bn\g1ZS,*pk1xD �*V\1 YmjW1ZS1 \h1Zn \]*aOZ\D �\ adbSE a1-\/Zq ob\ ab*W\ \/Z\y S4-W*,Zmf a\gS*WnZmf ]`\+W1Y S d-`\4\y

r b,1bm Z* /`d-S1 +S+W1yaVS1 ,\]`\am Y\3Z\ Z*ybS Z* a*yb1 jw.org

4/\`\,npE hb\E a\-W*aZ\ \bh1bd ���E Y\31bwV`*yZ1 Z1-*bS,Z\ aV*4m,*bnaq Z* oY\gS\OZ*WnZ\Y a\ab\qZSSxD 'b\ Y\31b ,m4m,*bnb*VS1 Z131W*b1WnZm1 ]\aW1/ab,SqE V*V b`1O,\3Z\abn S w/*31 \b,`*k1ZS1 V a1+1D �DDD�DDD�*aab`\yab,* ]Sb*ZSqE ZS4V*q a*Y\\g1ZOV*E /1]`1aaSq SWS ]\/*,W1ZZ\abnxD

w�/*Wqy ]1h*Wn \b a,\1-\ a1`/g* S\b,`*k*y +1/d \b a,\1y ]W\bSE ,1/npZ\abn S `*aa,1b 3S4ZS P ad1b*xL'VVW14S*ab 55B5>MD

�b\ 4Z*hSb ]`\q,Wqbn 4/`*,\YmaWS1H

�S+WSq a,q4m,*1b 4/`*,\YmaWS1 a\ aV`\YOZ\abnp L5 �SY\e1p 6B=MD �V`\YZmf Wp/1yZ1 ab\Sb ahSb*bn ]dabmYS S ]\,1`fZ\abZmOYSC \ZS a\f`*Zqpb d`*,Z\,1j1ZZmy ,4-Wq/Z* a1+q S Z1 4*gSVW1Zm Z* a,\1y ,Z1jZ\OabSD �V`\YZm1 Wp/S dhSbm,*pb hd,ab,*/`d-SfE hb\ ,m4m,*1b d,*31ZS1D �\W11 b\-\Eb*VSf Wp/1y \/\+`q1b �\- L�Sf1y :B<MD �YW1-h1 Z*ybS Z*ab\qkSf /`d41yE * b*V31a]dbZSV* 3S4ZSE /Wq V\b\`\-\ ,*3Zm ]`\hOZm1E ah*abWS,m1 \bZ\j1ZSqE * Z1 b\WnV\eS4Sh1aV*q ]`S,W1V*b1WnZ\abnD

˚abn YZ\-\ ]`ShSZE ]\h1Yd �S+WSq ]\+d3O/*1b Z*a \+`*k*bn ,ZSY*ZS1 -W*,ZmY \+`*O4\Y Z* ,Zdb`1ZZpp V`*a\bd P wb\E hb\aV`mb\ , a1`/g1 h1W\,1V*x L5 �1b`* 7B7E 8MD

�*V*q V`*a\b* Z1 ]\/,W*abZ* ,`1Y1ZSD �\/mS/db 1y b\WnV\ Z* ]\Wn4dI w�1/SZ* P ,1Z1gV`*a\bmE 1aWS \Z* Z*f\/Sbaq Z* ]dbS ]`*O,1/Z\abSxEP aV*4*Z\ , �`Sbh*f 5:B75D �*OVSY \+`*4\YE ]`\,1`1ZZm1 ,`1Y1Z1Y a\,1Obm S4 �S+WSS ]\Y\-*pb V*V Y\W\/mYE b*V S]\3SWmY Z*ybS a1V`1b ]\/WSZZ\y V`*a\bmE* b*V31 \+`1abS a*Y\d,*31ZS1 S d/\,W1bO,\`1ZS1 , 3S4ZSD ˛

w�`S,W1V*b1WnZ\abn +m,*1b \+Y*ZOhS,\yE S V`*a\b* P ]dab\yE Z\31ZkSZ*E V\b\`*q +\Sbaq �1-\,dE4*aWd3S,*1b f,*Wmx L�`SbhS 75B7>MD

\ YZ\-Sf VdWnbd`*f aWSjV\Y+\Wnj\1 4Z*h1ZS1 ]`S/*1baqa1Vad*WnZ\abS S V`*a\b1

�`\+d/Sb1an! Š8 6>5: 59

g1

6.4

-U1

60

42

8s�1a]W*bZ\ aV*h*yb1ob\b S ]`1/m/dkS1,m]daVS

�Sb*yb1 �S+WSp\ZW*yZ ]`SY1`Z\ Z*57> q4mV*f

˛*y/Sb1 Z* a*ybwww.jw.org/ru SWS\baV*ZS`dyb1 V\/

no

p

��˙%PZ*a1V\Ym1E ]\f\3S1 Z* a*`*ZhdE\+Sb*pb Z* ,a1f V\ZbSZ1Zb*fE V`\Y1 �ZO

b*`VbS/mD/Z*V\ \a\+my SZb1`1a /Wq+S\W\O-\, ]`1/ab*,Wq1b ]1`S\/Sh1aV*qE SWS wa1YOZ*/g*bSW1bZqqxE gSV*/*E V\b\`*q ,ab`1h*1baqb\WnV\ , ,\ab\hZ\y h*abS �1,1`Z\y �Y1`SVSD�+`*bSb1 ,ZSY*ZS1D�SWWS\Zm ]1`S\/Sh1O

aVSf gSV*/ ]\q,Wqpbaq ,1aZ\y ]\hbS \/Z\,`1OY1ZZ\ S 3S,db ,a1-\ WSjn Z1aV\WnV\ Z1/1WnD b1h1ZS1 V\`\bV\-\ ,`1Y1ZSE V\b\`\1 gSV*/m]`\,\/qb Z* a,1bdE \ZS a+`*am,*pb a,\p,Z1jZpp\+\W\hVdE \-WdjSb1WnZ\ ab`1V\hdbEW1b*pbE `*4YZ\3*pbaq S 4*b1Y dYS`*pbD �/SO,Sb1WnZ\E Z\ aW1/dpk11 ]\V\W1ZS1 ]\q,Wq1bOaq b\WnV\ a]dabq 57 SWS 5; W1bE , 4*,SaSY\OabS \b `*4Z\,S/Z\abSD�b\31 ]`\Saf\/Sb a gSOV*/*YS , b1h1ZS1 ob\-\ ,`1Y1ZSH�b\+m \b,1bSbn Z* ob\b ,\]`\aE /*,*yb1

+\Wnj1 d4Z*1Y\+ dZSV*WnZ\Y3S4Z1ZZ\Y gSVOW1 obSf Z*a1V\YmfD �`S+WS4Sb1WnZ\ h1`14Z1/1Wp ]\aW1 a,\1-\ ]\q,W1ZSq Z*a1V\Ym1a]*`S,*pbaq S a*YV* \bVW*/m,*1b , V\`1 ,1bO,1y \b 8>> /\ :>> qSgD aV\`1 ]\aW1 ob\-\,4`\aWm1 \a\+S dYS`*pbD�1`14 Z1aV\WnV\ Z1O/1Wn S4 qSg ]\q,Wqpbaq WShSZVSD ZS ]*/*pbZ* 41YWpS 4*`m,*pbaq , ]\h,dE -/1 Z*hSZ*1bOaq Sf ]\/41YZ*q3S4ZnD b1h1ZS1 ob\-\ ,`1Y1OZS WShSZVS ]Sb*pbaq a\V\Y V\`Z1y /1`1,n1,S Vdab*`ZSV\,D�1`14 57 SWS 5;W1b ]\q,Wq1baqZ\,\1 ]\V\W1ZS1 ,4`\aWmf gSV*/E -\b\,\1 ]\O,b\`Sbn ob\b d/S,Sb1WnZmy3S4Z1ZZmy gSVWD�\-W*aZ\ ab*bn1 , 3d`Z*W1 w�1yh1`xE b*V\y

aW\3Zmy ]`\g1aa `*4,SbSq ]1`S\/Sh1aVSf gSOV*/ d31 w,1V*YS ]`S,\/Sb dh1Zmf , 4*Y1j*Ob1Wnab,\xD�*Y b*V31 \bY1h*1baqB w'Zb\Y\W\O

-S /\ aSf ]\` ab*`*pbaq ]\ZqbnE V*V]\q,SWaqZ1\+mhZmy gSVW 3S4ZS obSf Z*a1V\YmfxD/OZ*V\ ob\ \ab*1baq \/Z\y Sfa*Ymf Z1\+lqaZSOYmf 4*-*/\V 3S,\bZ\-\YS`*D�b\,m /dY*1b1H�\q,SWSan WS ]1`S\/Sh1O

aVS1 gSV*/m a Sf Z1]\,b\`SYmY 3S4Z1ZZmYgSVW\Y , `14dWnb*b1 o,\WpgSSH �WS 31 ob\/1W\`dV`*4dYZ\-\ �,\`g*H˛

�����• ���& � ˛��%�˚�H

˝S4Z1ZZmy gSVW]1`S\/Sh1aVSfgSV*/

�Doug

Wechsler/agefotostock