-
BEPxoBHA PAAA yKPAiHl,tTHCTI4TyT 3AKOHOAABCTBA
04053, KHin. npor. Hecropiscsxaii, 4, rct.235 96 01. (raxc. 235
96 05. e-rnail:[email protected]
/- an ,JZ"a)'___:_ o-{, 2ot Z p.
[epruorvry 3acryrrH r{KyIo.nonu KorvrireryBepxonnoi Patu
Yrcpainu3 IIIITaHb 3aKOHOAaBTIO[Osa6esne.renHq
[paBooxopoHHoiAiqrsHocri
TIAJIAMAPqYKY M. TI.
Ilfanonnufi Murco.no flerponuuy!
Ha Baru rlucr eia 15 rllororo 2017 poKy }lb 04-1813-315
HaAcrrJraeMonpouo:uqii Ao npoerrin 3axonin: (peecrp.Ns 4346 nia 3
L03.2016), (peecrp. J\e 4358sia 01.04.2016), (peecrp.Ns 4396 sin
12.04.2016),
-
IIPOIIO3r4IIIi
Ao rrpoercry 3arcony Ynpai'nu (peecrp. Ilb 3768 nia 14.01 .2016)
,KuM uepe46aueHo roqaroKpo6oru aBToMarr{soeaHoi cucreMu He
upufinxro. Torvry anarig cKJIaAy[po[oHoBaHoro 3[orruHy e
[epeAqacHI,IM 3 ornrAy, 3oKpeMa, Ha HeBu3na.reHicrrcy6'ercrin fioro
Brrr{HeHHf,.
PasoN,r 3 rIr{M, Br.r3HatreHHr B rKocri cy6'exra 3noqI,IHy
cyAAi, ronoByloqorocyAAi, {K rle [pofloHyerbc, [poeKToM,
BI{KJILIKae 3ayBaxeHH{ B .racruHiroKJraAeHH, Ha cyAAro sAificHeHHs
nesracrusoi fior"ry $ynxqii uloAosa6esueqeHHfl BlrKoHaHH, cyAoBr{x
piurenr, ulo He rloBHoto rraiporo y3roAxyerbcfl 3
QyHrqion€rrrbHuM rpr.r3HaareHHsM cyAy - BLrKJrrorIHo sAificHeHHg
npaBocyAAs(cramr 124 Koncruryqii YrpaiHu).
Anropanau He AorpI{MaHo BHMor saroHoAas.roi rexuixn
.racruHicra6imsocri 3aKoHy i ro.rHocri repuiHonorii,
ocrimrzsa6egue.reHH.f, cra6ilrsocri 3aKoHy i ro.rHocri
repuiHonorii, ocrilrrz
ni4o6paxeHHf, y Aucrro3raqii Hoprrar{ BuqeplHoro uepelixy
cy6'exra 3noqI,IHy ysiAnosiAHocri Ao Hrr3Br{ nocaAu (uauamnur
sia.{iry AepxaBHoi sm(oHas.roiclyx6u), [pr{3BeAe Ao Heo6xiAnocri
BHeceHHf, grraiH y BI{[aAKy, HanplaKna4, stuiunHa3Bkr opraHy, a6o
uoca.qu. 3aramHo upzfiHflTvrr y rpnrvriHarlbHoMy saroHi
eBXr.rBaHHf, y3ararrbHrororrofo rroH.f,TT.f, "cryx6ona oco6a, f,Ka
Mae [paBo AocTylyao qiei cucreMu".
2. But
-
npaBun po6oru 3 TaKoro clrcTeMoro, f,Krrlo qe crtpuquHuJro
MafiHoBy IIrKoAy y3HarrHoMy po3Mipi.
Tax, siAuosiAanrnicrr 3a HeB[KoHaHHt a6o HeH€IrIexHe
BI,IKoHaHHIcnyx6onoro oco6oro csoix cnyx6onnx o6os'sgxia uepes
HecyurinHe craBJIeHHtAo Hux, qo 3aBAaJro icrorHoi urcogr,r
oxopoHrcBaHuM 3aKoHoM [paBaM, cso6oAaN,Ira iurepecaM oKpeMr{x
rpoMaprflH, AepxaBHIaM qI{ lpoMaAcbruu iurepecana a6oinrepecarvr
oKpeMLIx rcpLIAI,ItrHI,Ix oci6 nepe,q6aueno cr.367
(Clyx6onane.q6anicm) i aoaarronoi pernaMeHraqii ne norpe6ye.
3. /{ononnennr Kpr.rMlHurnbHoro 3aKoHoAaBcrBa HoBoIo
HopMoIoo6on'sgxoBo rrepeA6a'aae nupiureunfl rrr{TaHHf, rrloAo
uiAcniAHocri npouoHoBaHLlx
-tJ. ,{ononneunr rpuuiHarbHoro
4o rpuvrinarisarlii 4ixHr, a orxe BHeceHH.rI siAuosiAHrEx sN,IiH
4o KplarvrinalrHororpoqecyirJrbHoro KoAeKcy Yrpainu. Biauosi.{ni
sNIiHu rlpoeKroM He rlepeA6a.IeHi.
Incruryr 3aKoHoAaBcrBaBepxonuoi Pagu Yrpaihn
-
IIPOIIO3r,ilUiAo rrpoeKTy 3arcoHy Vrcpai'ulr ttlpo BHeceHHfl
crvtiH 4o Kpurrina.nrnoro
Ko4excy Yrcpain u ruoAo BcraHoBJreH Hq ni4noniAaJr bHocri sa
nocepeAHIrIITBoy niqrcyni"
(peecmp. lW 4358 eid 01.04.2016 p.)
3aronoupoeKr poepo6neHo 3 Meroro sano6iraHnx i uporu.qii
ropyuqii yuy6niunifi i upnnarHifi c$epax cycuirbHux siAHocun
IIrJIrxoM 3arpoBaAxeHH,siAuoniAaJlrHocri 3a rIocepeAHI,IIIrBo y
ui4ryui.
floAin.srcun cryp6onaHicu anropin 3aKoHorrpoeKTy IrIoAo
3aKoHoAaBrlorosa6esneqeHHfl peanieaqii npnrulzny neni4nopornocti
rcpuuiHalrnoisiAuoni.{anrnocri 3a rcopyuqifini Ais:n:as, BBaxaeMo
3a goqinrue sayBunr4Tr4HacTyrrHe.
l.3axononpoeKToM [porroHyerbc, AorroBlaurkr KK Yrpainu crarrerc
368-5,rqo nepe46auae siAuoeiAamnicru 3a rIocepeAHI,IIITBo y
ui4ryni, "to6torocepeAHurlrBo y [porloHyBauHi, o6iqxnni, [epeAaHHi
ra o4epxanniHerlpaBoMipHoi nuro.qu".
@axrzqHo Soprraorc [ocepeAHuIITBa y "uponouynanni, o6iqaHui,
uepe4auuiTa oAepxauni nenpanouipuoi sr4rvrorra" e nracHe
rrporro3l{Ilis, o6iIIsHKa, flepeAaqaHe[paBoMipnoi BuroALr,
siAnosiAanruicu sa sri Bxe uepe46auena .ITIHHTIMxpnrr,rinanbHr,rM
3aKoHoM.
3orpeua, cr. 354. fliaryu npaqinHnr
-
po3cniAyBaHHro Qamia ui4xyuy, a raKox cyAy, ocKirbKu npoua4ia
3rorruHHocrissarari i ropynqii, 3oKpeMa, norpe6ye cucreMHoro
ui4xo4y, rroeAHaHH,upo{inarcruqHlrx, [paBooxopoHHux ra pelpecuBHlrx
aaxo4in, .rirxo Bu3HarreHI,Ixupiopzrerin ra if HarrexHoro
sa6esue.reHHf,
(rca4pono-upoQecifiHoro,inQoprvrarlifiHo-aHarirn.rHoro,
HayKoBo-MeroAr,rtrHoro, rvrarepianbHo-TexHiqnororoqo ).
Orpirra roro, 3ayBaxprMo, rr1o uporu4ix ropyuqii Br,rKJrrorrHo
rpzuin€LrrbHo-rrpaBoBr{Mra MeroAaMn BuflBkrrrcr uee@eKTprBHoro,
aAxe [pr{rrr,rHu rlboro trBurqaMaK)Tb sAe6irsruoro
coqiaJrbHo-eKonoNaiqHzfi xaparrep, i ToMy, rpuuinzursHo-upanoni
uosnqii AepxaBr{ He 6y.{yu cupuftuarucr f,K cnpane4nuni,
arpnrraiuanbHo-upaBoni upuuucu He 6y4yru Br.rKoHyBarr4cs.
Incruryr 3aKoHoAaBcrBaBepxonHoi PaAn Yrcpaihn
-
IIPOrO3r4rIri,,IIpo BHeceHHfl sIlriH 4o Kpurvrina.nrHoro KoAeKcy
Vrcpaihr (rqogo
BcraHoBJreHHfl nianonilamnocri 3a HeBnKoHaHHfl piuHoro
QinanconororrJraHy AepxaBHoro uign pr{eMcrBa, [opy[reH Hfl
rropflArcy fi oro
3 arBepAlr(en nqln o ro.qxe n nn)>>(peecrp. J\b 4396 sit
12.04.2016 p.)
3axonoupoeKT pospo6neHo 3 Meroro BcraHoBJreHHs rrepeAyMoB
BprKoHaHH,pi.trvx $inaHconux nranis AepxaBHr{x ui4npueMcrB,
ni4noueHnr eSexrunnocriyupanninnr AepxaBHr.rMr{ ni4upnerracrBaMr4,
sa6esne.reHHf,4iurnocri raxnx ui4upueucrB ra siAuosiAHo
s6inrrueHHfl o6crry,,{epxannoro 6ro4xery Yrpainu 3a pe3ynbraraMr.r
rocrroAapcrrcoi 4irlrHocriAepxaBHr,rx ui4upueMcrB.
Iloginxro.rz cryp6osaHicrr aBropa 3aKoHorrpoeKry rrloAo
3arpoBaAxeHH,eSexrunuoro ynpaaninHxenyrpiurrboro
eroHol,ri.rHororracrKoro AoAanoi naprocri, r
1. 3aroHoupoeKroM rlpoloHyerbcr 3arrpoBaAr{rr{
rpuuinanrnyni4uoni4a;rrnicm 3a HeBr{KoHaHHs pi.ruoro Qiuaucoaoro
lnaHy AepxaBHoroui4nplaelacrBa, [opy[reHH, rroprAry fioro
3arBepAxeHns/uoroAxeHH.f, rlr.f,xoMAorroBHeHnx KpnvriHtrJrbHoro
KoAeKcy HoBoro HopMorc cr.2l0- I .
Anropou He Aorpt4MaHo BI{Morr{ 3aKoHoAas.roi rexHiru s .racruHi
roqnocrireprurinonorii. 3orpeMa, BHKoprIcraHH{ reprrainy "uoca4ona
oco6a" ne siAuosiAaesuicry yxLIBaHoMy y rpnvriuanbHoMy saroHi
rroH.rrrrs "clyx6ona oco6a", qo eHerrpulycruMrrM s uosuqifi
oAHaKoBoro 3acrocyBaHHr 3aKoHy.
2.3 ortsAy Ha re, IIIo KpuMinamna siAuosiAamnicru e
naficyropiururvrBI,IAoM IopI,IAI,IrIHoi siAnosiAamsocri ocnoeHoro
uiAcraBoro KpuMinanisarlii AisnrBIl3HaqeHo ik cycnimna
ne6esue.*ricrr. Y uo.scHrosanrHifi sauucqi aBropoM HeHaBeAeHo
rcpurepii cycninrHoi He6esueKra ropyrreHHfl xepinnurou
roprAKy3arBepAxenns/uoroAxeHH, pi.rHoro Sinanconoro rnaHy
AepxaBHorouigupueucrBa, a raKox fioro HeBuKoHaHH.rr.
Harouicm, TBepAxeHHs rtpo re, rqo "nigcyrHicu
rcpnvrinanrnoiniAnoni4anrnocri 3a HeBr{KoHaHHr pi.ruoro Qiuauconoro
rrJraHy AepxaBHorouigupzenacrBa, [opyrueHH, nopf,Axy fioro
3arBepAxeuHs/noroAxeHH{ po6urr saMoxJIHBe yHLIKHeHH, si4
riAnoniAanrnocri uee$errnBHrrx naeuegxepinAepxaBHr,rx
ui4npuenacrn>> He Moxe BBaxarucb Aocraruiu
apryMeHToMo6lpyHrosaHocri ueo6xiAHocri upzfiHrrrf,
3aKoHorpoeKTy.
flpouonosaHi uoroxeHH, rr,ricrgrr safiny geraniaaqiro i uo cyri
onucyrorbgir.ttut, BquHeHHf, ;lKux e uiAcranoro rrprrr.f,rHeHHs
oco6u Ao .qucq[uninapnoini4uoni4anrsocri.
upu6yrxoaoiHaAxoAxeHb Ao
AepxaBHprMu ui4upueucrBaMu, ni4nonlennxpr,rHKy, s6imureHH.f,
eKcrropry roBapin s serzxorc
s6imueHux o6cxry HaAxoAxeHb Ao ,{epxannoro6ro4xery YrpaiHn
BBaxaeMo sa AorlinrHe 3ayBaxuTu HacryrrHe.
-
3. .{ouonHeHnx rcpzuiHanbHoro 3aKoHoAaBcrBa HoBoro
HopMoroo6os'sgxoBo rrepeA6aqae nnpiurennfl. rrr4TanHf, rrloAo
niAcriAnocri uponoHoBaHrlx4o xpnuiHarisaqii 4ixnr, a orxe BHeceHH,
niAuosiAnzx svriH go KpnrraiHarlrnororpoqecyarbHoro KoAeKcy
Yrpainu. Biauosiani sNaiHu aBropoM HenporroHyrcTbcr.
Incrnryr 3aKoHoAaBcrBaBepxonnol Paln Vxpainu
-
IIPOrO3rrrIriAo rlpoenTy 3arcouy Yxpainu,,IIpo BHeceHHfl cruiH
qo Kpumina.nrnoroKoAeKcy Yrcpainu (qoqo uiAsrqeHns siAnosiAarrHocri
sa neqi.uroneBrlKoplrcraHufl 6roAxerrurx Korurin, s.qifi cneHHfl
suAarxin 6ro4xery .ln
HaAaHHfl rcpe4urin s 6ro4xcery 6es ncraHoBJreHrrx 6roAxerHrrx
[prr3HarreHba6o s ix uepenuulennnrr)>>
(peecmp. Ns 4407 eid 13.0a.2016 p.)
3axoHonpoeKT pospo6leuo 3 Meroro e BcraHoBJreHHq
rrepeAyMoBHeAorryIqeHHf, Ta [olepe.(xeHHf, neqinronoro
BuKopvcran:afl.6roAxersnx rorulin,sAificHeHHq nu4arxin 6ro4xery qtr
HaAaHHs xpe4rarin s 6ro4xery 6egBcraHoBJIeHLIx 6ro4xenrux
[pLI3HarIeHb a6o s ix [epeBr.rqeHHsM IuJI{xoM[oclrJreHHx canrcqifi
xprErvrinanbHo-[paBoBux HopM.
floAinqrc.{u cryp6onanicm aBropa 3aKoHorpoeKry rrloAo
sa6esue.reHHflueni4aopotnocri rpuuiuamsoi niAuoeigamuocri sa
sro.rrurHi rrocrraHHx y cQepiAepxaBHoro ceKTopy eKoHoMiru seaxaeMo
3a Aorlinrne 3ayBaxr,rrr,r HacryrrHe.
l.3axonoupoeKroM nponoHyerbcfl rrocvrrkrrur canrrlii cr. 210 KK
rrrJrrxoMBUKJIIoTIeHHx 3 rI.1 anrrepnarr,rBHl4x nugin rroKapaHb y
nu4i urrpaQy , o6ueNenuxnoli, BI{[paBHrx po6it i saupona4xeHH.rrM
6esanrrepHaruBHoro rroKapaHnr y nugiuos6aereuns nori Ha crpoK Ao
n'grrz porin, g o6os's:KoBr.rM uos6asleHHrM [paBao6ifiuatu nenni
[ocaALI .ru gafiNdarr,rcfl rreBHoro Aismsicrro Ha crpoK Ao
rpboxporir.
BiguosiaHo Ao q. 1 cr. 65 KK Yxpainn cyA Mae rpu3Haqarr{
rroKapaHHrr,BpaxoByrcqu cryuiur rsxxocri Brrr{HeHoro 3Jroqr{Hy,
oco6y BuHHoro rao6crasuHtr, rr1o nou' xxuryrorb ra o6rxNyrorb
rroKapaHH.rr.
flpufiuxrra 3aKoHorrpoeKry naguipHo o6iuexurr clA npr.r
po3rna.qi cnpannpo 3JIoqI{HI{, uepe46a.reni crarrero 2I0 KK,
ocrimru HaxsHicrs6esanrrepHarr{BHoro rroKapaHHfl 3a nexnani0iKosaHe
4ixuua (.r.1) cy[epeqr.rrb3acaAHuqoMy tIpkTHIII{ry 4IrQepenqiarlii
(inprniayanisaqii) xpuuiuanrnoinignoni4anrnocri ra rroKapaHHr.
BcraHosreHHq 6esanrrepHarr.rBHr{x canxqifi 3a
Brrr,rHeHHf,cynepequrb cr. 61 Koncruryuii Yxpainra, sriAHo 3
,KorosiAnoniAanrnicru oco6u Mae inruanilyanruufi xapaKrep,
rzKoucruryqifinoro Cyay Yrpainu J.lb15-pn/2004 si1 2 rrr4crorraAa
2004 poKy,si.quoeiAHo Ao sKoro "cyA inguui4yanisye norapannfl,
neo6xiAne i 4ocrarHe AJrsBI,IlpaBneHH{ 3acyAxeHux; saranrHi 3acaplr
npu3HarreHHr rroKapaHHf, ue uicrsrrsuHsrris qoAo HeBpaxyBaHHs
cryleH, rqxxocri; Kepyrcqucb 3ararrbHlrMu3acaAaMI,I [pI'I3HaqeHHfl
tIOKapAHHfl, CyA Mae [pLr3HaqarLr rroKapaHHf, KoHKpernifioco6i 3a
rourperHufi 3JIorrI4H, MaKcHMirJrbHo iH4unigyani:yro.rn
[oKapaHH{;sriAHo 3 npuHIII,IrIoM in4uni4yarisarlii ropra4uuuoi
nignoniga-urnocri rpu[pI,I3HarIeHHi uorapaHH{ cyA Mae BpaxoByBaua
o6craBuHr{ clpanu". 3asHa.reHi
3noquHyIOpI{AI,IqHa
piurennro
-
rIoJIoxeHHf, 3aKpilneHi i B MixHapoAHr{x AoroBopax, 3roAa Ha
o6os'ssrcosicrrflKlrx HaAaHa Bepxoanorc Pa4oro YrpaiHn.
3a sldicror'r BVMor cr. 50KK rroKapaHH, 6ygyuu 3axoAoM rpuMycy,
qo3acrocoByerbc, nig iueni AepxaBV 3a Br4poKoM cyAy Ao oco6u,
Br43HaHoi nuHuoroy BquHeHni sloqzHy, i rloJlf,rae n uepe46ar{eHoMy
3aKoHoM o6uexeHni upaa icno6og 3acyAxeHoro, Mae Ha ueri ne rinrru
Kapy, a fi nurtpaBJreHHf, 3acyAxeHzx,a raKox sauo6iraHHf,
B.TLIHeHHIo HoBI{x 3JrorruHis sr 3acyAxeHvrMn, rar i
iurunuuoco6auu.
,{ocxrHenH, 3aBAaHb rpuuinaluroi eiAnoni4a-uruocri ra Merra
[oKapaHH,rpr{Hrlr4rry cninpo:rraipnocri rsxrocri
rroKapaHH{uepe46a.rae 3acrocyBaHHf,
cycuinruifi ne6esne.IHocri 3JIot{r{Hy, sxuit y AaHoMy BHlaAKy
6yla [opyrreHo.3 ornf,Ay Ha Br{KnaAeHe e uiAcrasu BBaxarH, rqo
uepe46a.reui
3aKoHorlpoeKroM sluiHu yHeMoxJII,IBJIlororb .rrK peanieaqiro
npaBa sacygxeuoioco6u na uou'sKllreHHf, rIoKapaHH{, TaK i
N4oxrzsicrr 4lx cyAy BpaxyBaru rrptrlpr{3Haqeuni uorapaHHf,
o6crasuHu, rrxi fioro uou'xrur;ruorr (cr. 66 KK).
2.BurcnuKae 3arlepeqeHHf, npono3raqir rqo4o 3arrpoBaAxeHHf, y
caHxqii u. 2cr. 210 KK ulJlbrepHaruBHoro rloKapaHHx y nu4i
4oni.uroro nos6asJreHHfl soni.BianoniaHo Ao svricry cr. 63, cr. 64
KK qe noKapaHHs BcraHoBJrroerbc, 3aBTIIIIHOHH, oco6ruIso rrxKLIx
sro.runis i sacrocoByerbct Jr[rue y BIduaAKax, KoJII,IcyA He BBaxae
3a MoxJIuBe 3acrocoByBarr{ uos6asreHHx sori Ha [eBHr.rfi crporc
irloJlf,rae s i:oflxllii:acy4xeHoro ta norraiulenHi fioro 4o
rpzrr,riHzurbHo-BuroHae.roiycraHoBr,r 3aKpr4Toro rrrny
4oni.ruo.
3anpona.qxeHH.f, goniuuoro nos6asJreHHfl aoni uoprA 3
rrJrbrepHaruBHr,rMunog6asneHHrM eoni sia 12 Ao 15 porin craBlrrb
Heqilrone BlrKopucrauHfl.6roANerHnx roruriB Ha oAr{H rqa6enr 3
TaKHM 3roquHaMv\ flK yMr{cHe n6uncrao,BrII{HeHe 3a o6uNytovl.Ix
o6ctasuu (c.2 cr. 115 KK Yrpainra), ropyrueHHflsaxoHis
nifiHu,saxoHis ra esz.rain nifiHu, uoeAsani 3 yMr.rcHr4r{
s6zecrnorra (u.2 cr. 438 KKYxpaiHv), 3acrocyBaHHfl :6poi MacoBoro
3HHrrIeHHs, trKrrlo BoHo crpuqrHr{nosaru6em nrcgefi .ru iHrui tsxxi
Hacrigru (t.2 cr.439 KK YxpairuE), reHoqu4 (u.1cr. 442 KK Yrpainu)
ra iH.
floai6na 3aKoHoAaBrIa rporloeuqir He y3roAxyerbc, ig
saranrHoBlr3HaHr{My.{oKTpI{ui rpr,rrrain€IJlbHoro npaBa
[pr{Hrlr4rroM, 3a:uicrou {Koro rroKapaHHf, Maeni.{noniAaru pinuro
cycninrHoi ne6eaueKr{ 3nor{r.rHy, 3a sxuit BcraHoBJrroerbc,
rlenoKapaHH.f,.
3. Ha niActasi BI4KJIaAeHoro He AoBoAurbcx no4irxrr.r AyMKy
aBTopa npo re,qo upIEfiHrrrf, Ilboro 3aKoHorlpoeKTy (a cal,re
[oclrJreHHs saxoAin rcpurraina-nrnoipeupecii) neo6xi4ne"grfl
3aupoBaAxeHH, eSerrunnoro yilpasriHHs
AepxaBHLrMr.ruiAnpueucrBaMl,I, eigHonnenus ix
rrJraroclporr,roxuocri, KoHKypeHros4aurocri,upu6yrrconocri,
siAHonleHHfl BHyrpiutmoro eroHorr,ri.rHoro puHKy,
g6ilrureHnseKclopry ronapin 3 BeJIuKorc qacrKoro AoAaHoi naprocri,
s6inrureHHs o6cxryHaAxoAxeHb Ao .{epxannoro 6rc4xery Yxpaiuu".
-
flpaxrrara 3anpoBaAxeHH, Ha4laipruEx saxoAis
xpurraiHamno-upanonoipeupecii 6es 3acrocyBaHH, opranisaqifinux,
coqianruo-eKoHoMiuuux,iAeorori.rH[x 3axo4ir e xu6noro y flporuAii
sro.ruHHocri 3ar€rnoM ra uoAorannixopyuqii, 3oKpeMa.
Iucrnryr 3aKoHoAaBcrBaBepxonuol Patn Yrcpainn
-
IPOfro314rIriAo rrpoeKTy 3aKoHy Yrcpainu
-
IIPOIIO3r4rlriAo rpoer$y 3ar> (uoao igeurusirca uii
no.rriqefi crrcux)>>
(peecmp. lW 5700 eid 23.01.2017 p.)
Ilpoerr 3aroHy YrpaiHra pospo6leuo 3Merolo yAocKoHaJreHHq
cl{creMr{ nepcoH€Lnuroi i4enru$ixarlii noniqeficbKr{x, aTaKox
ni4nulqenux pinnx 4oeipz HaceJreHHfl Ao noliqii,
BAocKoH€rJreHH.[3aKoHoAaBcrBa YxpaiHIz y cQepi rpaBooxoponnoi
4ixlrnocri, uigerarqeHurnposopocri HaAaHHq noniqeficbKI4x IIocJryr,
BcraHoBJreHH{ AeMoKparv.glHuxupunqunie 4ilnrnocri noniqii,
3MeHrxeHH{ xinrxocri euua4rin 3JroBxr,rBaHH,BJIaAoro,
[epeBkIIr{eHH{ BnaAI{ Ta cnyx6onoi ne46anocri
noniqeficbKr4Mr4,:6inrureHuq eSerrueHocri 3axr,rcry csoix rpaB
rpoMaAf,HaMr4. Kpivr rlboro,peanisaqia HopM 3aKoHorlpoeKry
cnpu.sruMe ni6epaniaaqii 3aKoHoAaBcrBa raiHrerpaqifiHonay rocryny
Vxpaiun ao eC.
3axououpoeKToM 3arlponoHoBaHo BrrKJrrorrr4Tpr qacruuy 2 cl:arri
l7 3arcony,saxpiuuru Aaui uonoxeHH, crar, i 17 n pos4ini III crarri
l7-l n uacrraHi, rqocrocyerbc.f, clyx6onoro nocni4uenux ra
inazeiayanbHoro HoMepynoniqeficbKoro. 3 oux4y Ha rle cri4
uacroBrrrr,r raxi rraipryBaHHfl.
1.y BI4naAKy BLIKopI,ICTaHH, noniqeficbKr4M :aco6ie
in4rani4ya-rbHoro3axl{cry Ao HLIX xpinuEcr HaIxI4BKa s
iHIuniAy€urbHt4M HoMepoM, txuit3a3Har{aerbcf Ha naruunqi TaKI,IM
rII4HoM, u4o6 sa6e3neHumu uocrcLtueicma ilozoposnisuaeaHHfl ua
eidcmaui i $irccat1ii' sa donouozoto mexuiuuux sqco6ie. flauaHopMa,
Ha HaIrI rIorJIf,A, Mae oqiHouni roHflTT-rr B .racruHi
sa6e:ne.{eHH-sMoxJlrrBocri po:ui3HaBaHHq na ni4craui i Qixcaqii :a
AonoMororo rexniqnuxsaco6is iH4zni4yanbHoro HoMepy xeToHa. V
upoerri saxoHy He 3a3Harr aerbcfl, Haxrifi ni4crani uoxJII4Be raKe
po3nigHaraHHx 3a AonoMororo rexui.ruux gaco6ie qu6es ix
AonoMorr4.
2. Cratrro 20 3axony nponoHyerbc, AorroBHr4Tr4 HoBoro qacrr4Horo
6, ae6ya. 3a3HarreHo, ruo >. TaritrpurlJ4cv uonuuHi
y3foAxyBartrcfl Ta eiAuosiAaua [onoxeHH.rrM[zcqnulinapnoro craryry
HaqioHanrnoi noniqii Yxpaiuz. IIp, rlboMy cni4BpaxoByBarrl
roJroxeHHq npoeKry 3axoHy Vr
-
rrPofro3IIIIIIAo rrpoercTy 3arcony Vrcpailnu
,IIpo BHeceHHfl sruiu .qo KpuvrinamHoro rpoqecyaJrbHoro KoAeKcy
YrpaihuIrIoAo BperyJrloBaHufl oKpeM rlx n Irra Hb
uiac.niaHogti"
(peecrp. Ns 5720 r;it 26.01.2017 p.)
Meroro 3aKOHOrrpOeKTy AeKJIapOBaHO ,,[pI4BeAeHHfl
[OJIOXeHbrpoqecyirlrbHoro KoAeKcy Yrcpainrn y siAuoniAHicrr
AoKpurvrinanbHoro
KoHqenqii p erp oprrayB aHH, xpuvriHanrnoi ro cruqii
YrpaiHu".
Y sn'xsry 3 III{M, rlporloHylorrcs sNaiHu Ao cr.cr. 3, 38,
216,232,246, 575K[IK, f,Kr{Mra Br{Krroqarorbc{ rroJroxeHHs, Iqo
HaAalorb [paBo opraHaM.{epxaenoi rpuuinanbHo-BuKonas.roi cnyx6ra
YrcpaiHI,r (aani-[GC)sAificHrosaru AocyAone cri4crno.
ru(BC B rpurraiHanbHoMy upoqeci BLTKoHyBaJIa poJlb opraHy
AisHaHH.f,(ni4uoni4Ho Ao npuuucin KIIK 1960 p. HaarzurblnuKvr
BurrpaBHo-rpyAoBl{x ycraHoB,criA.rux isonmopin,
rircynarbHo-rpyAoBr.rx upo0inaxropiia i
suxostrorpyAoBrlxupoQilaxropiia, nisuiue - Harr€rJrbHrrKr4 ycraHoB
BlrKoHaHHrI [oKapaHb, cligvrExisonxropiB - y c[paBax rpo 3norruHu
rrporlr BcraHoBJIeHoro noprAKy HeceHH.f,ctyx6u, s.rrureHi
upaqinHuKaMr4 rlr{x ycraHoB, a raKox y cflpaBax rtpo
3rorIHHI{,nquneni B po3TarrrysaHHi 3a3HarreHux ycraHoB Harrex€IJIIT
Ao oci6, qo npoBaAf,TbAisHaHHs y c[paBax rrloAo sroquHie
HeBeJr]rKoi rqxrocri). @yHrqii .qocyaoBorocJnAcTBa Ha TaKl opraHr{
He [oKnaAarlrcb.
3a upnuucaMr.r KIIK 2012 p. xoqa i sanuruuJlacb raKa Qoprr,ra
Aocy.(oBoroposcni4ynaHtfl sr AisHaHnx (u. 4 cr. 3), nona ua6yra
sosciN,I inruoro rrvricry.3riAHo s n. 8 q. 2 cr. 18 3axony ,,llpo
,{epxanHy rprarvriu€IrlbHo-BllKoHaBrrycnyx6y Yrpainu" ra a6s. 9 ,q.
1 cr. 5 3arony ,,fIPo otreparl4BHo-po3llryKoByAirlrnicrb" [oca4osi
i cnyx6oni oco6u opranin i ycraHon B]IKoHaHHf, noKapaHbTa cliAqux
isolrropin s.(ificHronanu nr{[re oreparnBHo-posuryroni 3axoAl{
ylopflAKy, nepeg6aueHoMy 3aKoHoAaBcrBoM Vrcpainn. 3 npufinxrrsM
3arony,,flpoBraury paAy rpaBocyAAs" opraHrr AKBC naAireni
rIoBHoBaxeHHtMLI opraHinAocyAoBoro poscniAyBaHH,
Pagol,r 3 Tr,rM, ni4Heceuu-n Ao ix t
-
Koro, xro flpuqerlavrit,4o uo,4ifi yuparruqi" (cupana ,,,[asuaoB
racJryrrrHr,rMu uponosuqii uloAo
crrpani; cri.q.{i Marorb 6yru He3arIexHLtMr4 Hairruri uporz
Yr
-
IIPOIIO3r{IIIIAo rrpoeKry 3arcony Yrcpaiuu
,rllpo BHeceHHfl ruin Ao AeflKrIx 3aKoHoAaBrI[x arrin Yrcpaiuu
ruoAoBperyJr IoBaH Hfl oKpeMrlx rr I{TaH b uilc.nhnoctit'
(peecrp. Nb 5720-t sia 10.02.2017 p.)
Meroro 3aKoHolpoeKTy AeKJIapoBaHo ,,HeAorryu{eHHf,
po3lxl4peHHf,rroBHoBaxeHb opranin ,{epxanHoi
rpuvriHirllbHo-Braronas.roi cnyx6u YrcpainnrrrJrflxoM
BkTKJrrorreHH, opranin ,{epNanHoi rpnuiHarbHo-BlaKoHanqoi
cryx6nYrpainn ie uepenixy opranin AocyAoBoro porcni4yr;auur/'.
y ss'xsry 3 rlraM, rrporroHyerbc{ BLrKJIroqurI{ opI'aHIa
,{epxanuoirpurr,rinarbHo-BuKonas.roi clyx6n Yxpainz is uepenixy
opranin AocyAoBoroposcni4ynaltfl; cKacyBaru rroBHoBaxeHH.,I opranin
,,{epxarHoi xpuuinalrno-BlrKoHaBqoi cnyx6u Yrpainr{ B rracruHi
poscri.4ynauux sro.ruHis, BquHeHux Harepzropii a6o B upzruiqeHHf,x
lepxannoi rcpuruiHzulbHo-BuKonasqoi clyN6uYrpainu (tari-ff(Bc).
II(BC B rpnrraiualbHoMy npoqeci BuKoHyB€uIa ponb opraHy
AisHaHH.fl(siauosi.{Ho Ao npuuzcin KIIK 1960 p. Haq€ulbHuKu
BI{rpaBHo-rpyAoBkIx ycraHoB,criA.rrx isonxropin,
nixyrarbHo-rpyAoBLrx npo0inarropiin i
suxoaHorpyAoBlrxupoQinarropiin, uisHime - HarrzrrrbHuKr4 ycraHoB
BTIKoHaHHfl rloKapaHr, cni,4unxisonxropiB - y c[paBax rtpo
3rorruHr{ rpor}I BcraHoBJIeHoro Iropf,AKy HeceHH.ttcryx6u, s.ruHeni
upaqinnuKaM[ rlux ycraHoB, a raKox y cnpaBax [po
3rlorlrlHt4,s.runeHi B po3TarrrysaHHi 3a3HarreHr{x ycraHoB
HaIIexaJII,I Ao oci6, rrlo [poBaAflTb
AisHaHHx y crpaBax rrloAo sno.ruHis HeBeJruKoi tsxrocri).
@ynrqii aocyaoBorocniAcrsa na raxi opraHla He rroKJlaAieururcb.
3a upunucaMu KIIK 20L2 p. xoqa i sanllruuJlacb raKa $opua
AocyAoBoroposcni4ynalHs, sr AisHaHHx (u. 4 cr. 3), roua :aafyta
soeciN,I inruoro :rraicry.3riAHo s u. 8 q. 2 cr. 18 3arouy ,,flpo
,{epxanny rpurrainulJlbHo-Bl{KoHaBqycnyx6y Yrpaihn" ra a6s. 9 .r. 1
cr. 5 3arcouy ,,lIPo oreparl{BHo-po3llryKoBy4ixlrnicrtr" uoca4osi i
cnyx6ori oco6u oprauin i ycranon BI,IKoHaHH.fl rloKapaHbTa criA.rux
isolaropin sAificHroeanu Jrrrlre oreparl{Buo-posluyroni 3axoAu
ynopflAKy, uepe46aueHoMy 3aKoHoAaBcrBoM Yrpainn. 3 npufinxrrf,M
3arony,,fIPoBrEury pap;y rpaBocyAAfl" opraHlr ru(BC naAireni
rIoBHoBaxeHHrMu oprauinAocyAoBoro poscniAyBaHH.f,
Pasol,r 3 Tr{M, siAHeceHH, Ao ix ronauereuqii 6yAr-mnx
elouuuin,BrrlrHeHlrx Ha repuropii a6o B upurvriuleHH.flx 4(BC,
craHoBI{Tb pvr3krKvt3JroBxuBaHb, ocrilrxll, 3 oAHoro 6ory,
nos6asrse 3acyAxeHux (sarpnrvraHnx)npaBa Ha He3aJrexHe
poscri4yBaHH, 4puruinarbHoro rlpaBoropylxeHH, (oco6orc,f,Ka He
uepe6ynae B cucrenri [tBC), a s iuruoro - yrpyAHloe rp]IrrrHeHlrf,
Aorpuuiuanruoi siAnosiAanrHocti uocaAoBux oci6 cucreura ffiBC.
3a raruu uiAxoAou 3aKoHoAaBrIr, crrpilotll/Icb Ha cr. 104 KIIK
1960 p.,MoxHa Ao opraHin 4ocy,qoBoro criAcrsa riAnecru fi inrui
4epxanni cnyx6u, IqogAiftcnrosaru AisHaHHa (: naAssu.rafiHr{x
curyaIlifi, [prlKopAonny, SiHaHcoBororvrouiropnHry, roulo).
-
Bpaxonyroqu no3l{uiro enponeficrroro cyAy 3 rpaB JrroAr4Hu rrpo
re, rqo,,oco6u, xxi upoao,qf,Tb uepenipru, i ri, xro npoBoAr4Tb
po:cni4yBaHHr, uosuHHi6yru He3uIrIexHr4MLr 3a iepapxiuHuM Ta
siAorvr.rur\d ni.4uoprgKyBaHHrM nia 6yar-Koro, xro [puqerlauit.qo
no.qifi y cupani; cni.qqi Marorb 6yru He3arrexHuMyr Haupaxruqi"
(crpana ,,,,!anuaoB ra inrui nporu Yxpainu" (2010 p.)),
nnaxaeMocJIyIUHLIMu upouoszqii qoAo Br{KJrroqeHHfl [oJroxeHb
rpzuinalbHorolpoqecyanbHoro 3aKoHy, srci HaAarorb rrpaBo opraHaM
ro(BC s4ificnronaruAocyAoBe cniAcrso (:anuurato.ru ird
[pl{H€Inexuicrr Ao oleparrrBHo-po3rrryKoBr{xui4pos4inin).
Bnecenns svriH Ao cr. 9-l 3arony ,,rlpo
oleparuBHo-po3rrryKoBy4irlrnicm" BuAaerbcs. HeAorlinrHr.rM,
ocxilrxu AIGC 3a csoiN,r rrpaBoBLrMcrarycoM i san4anruMrl Moxe
sAificHrosarrr oleparuBHo-po3rrryKoBy 4irlruicm,runa 6insrue, rrlo
srvrin Ao cr. 5 qroro 3arony He rrpoloHyerbcr.
Tarox, ocximrcu HasBa 3aKoHorrpoeKTy rrpo BHeceHHs sr\aiH i
AoloBHeHb AorIIdHHoro 3aKoHoAaBcrBa IroBuHHa nigo6paxarz cyrxicrr
ra sl,ricr raKrrxnpoflo3ullifi, ro BuAaerbcx 4oqinrnnrra ii
yrorrHeHHl, ocrcilrKr,r [poeKT crocyerbc,He JILIue sMiHu
ni.qcniAnocri s rpurvrinarbHoMy rrpoBaAxenui, a Ai.f,rsHocri !$BC,K
Oprarry AocyAoBofo po3cJrlAyBaHHs.
IHcruryr 3aKoHoAaBcrBaBepxonnoi Palu Vrcpaiuu
