Kant Wittgenstein:

.

2012

Kant Wittgenstein: .

: 12 , 2012.

:

: .

: .

:

.

: .

: .

: .

[3]

...

Kant Wittgenstein: .

ISBN

(. 5343/1932, 202, 2).

[4]

[5]

In the beginning was the Word, in the end world without end

Ulysses, James Joyce

[6]

[7]

,

, . ,

Kant Wittgenstein, .

.

. ,

.

. ,

, , Kant

Wittgenstein. . ,

.

,

,

- .

.

.

. , ,

( ).

, ,

, , ,

, , 5 ,

(!), , , ( )

, .

... 2007.

2007 2008 , ,

2012.

.

, , , ,

, 2005 - 2012.

[8]

[9]

.

.

: .

- Kant Wittgenstein.

1. - Kant.

1.1.

.

1.2. - :

, .

1.3. .

1.4. .

1.5. 1770:

.

2. Wittgenstein.

2.1.

Wittgenstein.

2. 2. .

2.3. , :

.

2.4. :

.

: .

1. .

2.

9-10

11 - 39

41 - 53

53 - 61

61 - 65

65 - 70

70 - 75

75 - 93

94 - 95

95 - 114

114 - 124

124 - 139

140 - 149

151 - 164

[10]

Kant Wittgenstein.

2.1. Kant .

2.2. Wittgenstein .

3. : ,

.

3.1. : .

3.2. , .

3.3. Kant Wittgenstein.

4. : Kant Wittgenstein.

: .

1. Kant Wittgenstein.

2. :

.

3. .

3.1.

.

3.2. : , ,

, .

4. .

.

.

164 - 165

165 - 171

171 - 180

180 - 183

183 - 187

187 - 192

193 - 212

213 - 226

226 - 248

248 - 271

272 - 282

282 - 293

293 - 307

309 - 323

325 - 341

[11]

,

,

, *

+

.

[Wittgenstein, Notes on Logic, 1998:84].1

Wittgenstein Kant

,

, 20 .2 , ,

- Wittgenstein

Kant, , ,

,

, (Kant) (Wittgenstein).3

, , Wittgenstein

Kant

(Glock, 1997).

(Cavell, 1996), (M. Williams, 1999)

, , ,

, Wittgenstein,

, Wittgenstein

,

, Wittgenstein (Fromm, 1979).

,

Wittgenstein a priori .4

1 Kant Wittgenstein . . 2 1960

Eric Stenius, (1960:214-226). Wittgenstein Kant Maslow 1933. Maslow, 1997 (1961). 3 : Hacker, (1972). Schwyzer, (1973), Pears, (1987), Garver, (1994, 1996:139-170),

Cavell, (1996: 261-295). 4 a priori . .: Stenius,

1960, Specht, 1969:149, 153, 171, Cavell, 1972:67-93, : 86 Cavell a priori . a priori : .. : . Garver, 1967:423, Garver, 1994, Baker Hacker, 2009 (1985):261.. a priori

[12]

,

( Wittgenstein ,

,

)

5 - ,

, ,

(Apel, 1973). , ,

.6

, , , ,

Apel ( , ,

).

, , , ,

, Meredith Williams (1999).

()7 , ,

, ( a priori )

( / ). Kant ,

. Wittgenstein, ,

( ) , ,

, ,

, Rush Rhees

.

a priori , , , , , Husserl a priori a priori Kant (. . Harald Delius, 1963: 19-20). Husserl . . Michael Dummett, 1996 (1994). 5 , ,

Strawson, 1959 1966. Strawson , , Husserl, . . Natterer, (2003:296-7). , . . Aschenberg, (1982). , . . Stern, 2003. 6 : Engel, (1970: 483-513), Stegmller, (1972), Heinrich, (1977), Bachmaier, (1978), Hofmann, (2000). 7 :

* -/ -+ , .

[13]

Wittgenstein, / ,

, ! ,

,

.

Wittgenstein. Wittgenstein

Stonborough-Wittgenstein Haus

Paul Engelmann

Wittgenstein, Margaret Stonborough-Wittgenstein. ,

(Monk, 1990),

.8

, ,

Kant ()

Wittgenstein.9 , Wittgenstein, -

.

. . (

) * 112 46:14.10.1913 (MS)].

Wittgenstein. :

*

, MS 109 200:5.11.1930]. , ,

,

.

, ,

Wittgenstein,

, * ,

115 ()+,

, (

8 Wittgenstein . . Nana Last, (2008). Last Wittgenstein . , Last, Wittgenstein, Wittgenstein *.. Introduction+. . . Bernhard (2000). 9 ()

, , , , 2008 (, 1963). Wittgenstein Wittgenstein Wittgenstein .

[14]

). , ,

. , ,

, , (

). ,

, *MS 156a 25r:ca.

1932-4]. , ,

*MS 126

15r:2810.1942], , ,

, ,

.10

,

. Wittgenstein

() , , ,

: ,

.

, , ,

, *282-3]. ,

. ,

, .

, Wittgenstein

Tractatus Logico Philosophicus (TLP).11

,

*Zettel141 ()+, *Z145/6], ,

10 Wittgenstein Darstellung : TLP . , . , , Wittgenstein , . (Vorstellbarkeit) : (Darstellbarkeit) (Mittel der Darstellung) *+ *397+. . - ; 2

3

.

, Kant , . 11

TLP . . . , (2007:24). TLP *+.

[15]

, ,

: *+

,

:

.

(

, 79-80).

, Wittgenstein, ,

. ,

,

, , .

; ;

, ,

, ; *+

; )

)

*+ *

125 ()].

;

() ()

, :

, ,

, :

() , ,

() , a priori,

, .

,

*195/156+ , ,

*832/860+. , ..

a priori

*833/861, ].

Kant Wittgenstein.

Kant

.

[16]

Wittgenstein,

.

, ,

,

, ,

Wittgenstein.

, Wittgenstein

,

,

, ,

. , , ,

, .

( )

[, 9. , Wittgenstein, 1988:396].

12

:

*79+.

. Kant

,

, :

, (

), ,

a priori

12 , Kant Wittgenstein: , , ( / Kant) (Wittgenstein), . *. . 301+, , . , , , , , . Wittgenstein , (Mitteln der Darstellung). , , , , , . , 3

, , . , , : , . .

[17]

* + *135/175+. Kant

, a priori , a priori

. :

, , ,

,

*+ *222+.

,

,

;

- Wittgenstein.

Wittgenstein

, , :

, ,

*. +

[ , 44]. Kant ,

, ,

.

Kant :

, .

,

,

*.

+. .

:

.

*#4881, 18:018, 1776-8].13

Kant Wittgenstein ,

- .

,

, Kant, ,

, / a priori [TLP, 5.634],

*132+:

. ,

13 Kant Kant : www.korpora.org/Kant/. : Immanuel Kant, The Cambridge Companion of the Works of Immanuel Kant, General Editors: Paul Guyer and Allen W. Wood, Cambridge University Press.

[18]

. Kant

, /

:

*841/869+. ;

:

*. +

*..+. ,

;

, Kant

, ,

:

*20:260+

:

: ( )

() *20:292/3+.

. Kant,

,

.14

,

, , .

.

Kant , ,

: , ,

* 840/868+.

.

,

, *..+.

14

Ameriks (2000, (1982)) Kant . Kant , , . ant [Metaphysik Mrongovius (1783/4) Vigilantius (1794/5)] * 29, 1983+ Cambridge [Lectures on Metaphysics, 1997] Ameriks, (Ameriks, 2001:19-36). Ameriks .

[19]

Kant,

, , , ,

Kant ,

, , :

*851/879+.

, ,

*07:119+,

*..+,

[07:324/5, . (Patrick Kain, 2003:93)].

,

, . , ,

,

- .

, ,

. , ,

, .

, ,

,

, ,

, ; ,

, ;

, .

() , .

,

. Kant *27+.

: ,

, *.

+ *28/14+. , ,

,

, ,

*26+. , ,

;

, , /

.

,

[20]

,

,

;

,

*642/670+. , ,

( ) ,

,

.

, ,

: :

(Standpunkt) *. +

,

*. +.

,

, ..

-

( ),

().

, ..,

, ,

, ,

, , , ,

, , *658-6/686-7].

Kant,

, . 15

,

,

. , ,

,

, - -

15

Stephen Palmquist , , / : , Palmquist, (. . Stephen Palmquist, Kants Sytem of Perspectives, 17/5/2012: http://www.hkbu.edu.hk/~ppp/ksp1/KSP3.html). Kant . Conant Nietzsche, , Nietzsche ( ), (Conant, 2005:48).

[21]

, .

,

,

*662/690+.

. ,

, .

: , ,

()

*665/693+.

-

, , ,

.

,

.

, .

,

,

, .

Kant:

, , ,

,

, .

, Kant

,

*+ *667/695+.

: ()

,

. ,

,

() .

- :

- Wittgenstein

[593+.

Kant

, Wittgenstein:

[22]

,

.

,

*402+

:

. ,

*55+. , Wittgenstein

-

, ,

,

.

.

, ,

, , ,

(Kant) (Wittgenstein).

Wittgenstein,

, , ,

.

Wittgenstein

,

() .

Kant, ,

,

.

,

(), ()

().

.

,

.

.

,

, .

[23]

; [08:131-147]

, Stegmaier (2007:131-2): :

;. ,

, , ,

,

,

.16

, ,

:

,

, , .

: *+ ,

, , .

( ;)

:

, ,

*18+.

/

.

*203+.

. Graham Bird Kant Wittgenstein

(2006:611) /

, , .

Kant Wittgenstein

,

. ,

: Kant

,

, ,

Wittgenstein

16

Ludwig Wittgenstein, Item 109, Band V, Bemerkungen, p.135 [1998].

[24]

, -

.

, Wittgenstein,

.

. ,

,

.

, *

2 ()+. :

,

*

, VII15 ()].

, ,

, ,

,

. Wittgenstein

, ..

Kant , , ,

,

Kant

.

, , ,

.17

,

Kant,

19 20 .

Kant

:

. ,

17

/ : *37 46+, *68/93+ Kant , ..., . , , . , , Wittgenstein: , , . : , , , , .

[25]

.

. ,

,

Kant ,

Wittgenstein .

:

,

,

.

Kant

Wittgenstein 20 .

, , :

.

, ,

(Kant)

(Wittgenstein) - , .

,

, ,

(Kant), (Wittgenstein).

,

. ,

, , , .

, ,

Kant Wittgenstein,

.18

(Kant)

(Wittgenstein), ,

,

Kant

Wittgenstein.

.

18

Kant 1760-1770 , : , : *. + , , . , , , *+ *#3709, 17:246-250 1762-1763].

[26]

, , -

Kant Wittgenstein. -

Kant , Wittgenstein

, -

1 . Kant Wittgenstein

(Kant)

(Wittgenstein), 19 (Kant)

(Wittgenstein)

. - Kant

Wittgenstein, ,

.

- Kant

Wittgenstein,

, .

.

: ,

.

*835/863+,

*118]. , ,

; Kant: , ,

, ,

,

*. + , ,

(

a priori ) *738/766+. ,

,

,

19

: - - ( ) . , - , 35 (1747-1781) . , , , , , , , .

[27]

*707/735+.20

*118+,

*727/755+ ,

*..+.

. :

*96+.

. ,

, , .

Kant Wittgenstein.

Wittgenstein :

Haus Wittgenstein ()21

Kant *502/474+.

,

, ,

, , ,

*. + *835/863+.

,

,

() .

20

Kant : . 21

http://www.fotopedia.com/albums/-B5ojqwpKQ 11 2012.

[28]

, ,

*127+.

, , ,

() .

,

, , , ,

, . ,

.

, , , ,

,

,

.

(Kant), , (Wittgenstein)

,

,

,

,

.22

,

,

. ,

, , , ,

22 Kant Wittgenstein: Fromm (1972) .. , Kant Wittgenstein. Fromm () . Kant (perceptio) *320/377+ Fromm . , Kant, . . , a priori. . / . ( / ...) . Fromm (1972) , . Davidson, , , , *. . 820/848+. (Davidson, 1974:15..).

[29]

, - ; -

(TLP).

Kant ,

,

,

. Kant

Marcus Herz, 21 1772, :

*. :

+, ,

,

, , ,

,

, ,

. :

; *10:1301+.

. Kant

. ,

- ,

*02:74+,

, ,

*320+. , ,

: , ,

. Apel (1995:xii-xiv)

, ,

. vorstellen

,

*+, Wittgenstein [TLP, 5.556]:

. /

( / ),

.

Peirce, Peirce Apel23 (1995),

23

Peirce Apel Apel Peirce Morris, Peirce, , , , (Morris, 1938). Morris, Apel, . Apel Morris

[30]

Peirce, , , Kant

Wittgenstein

: , ,

,

()

, , , ,

, .

,

.

Kant

: [ +

,

*153-4+. Wittgenstein

:

. , ,

. *+.

: .

.

, ,

. *401+.

;

,

. ,

,

, Wittgenstein:

, . ,

Peirce (Apel, 155-6). , . , , Peirce, . Apel Peirce , Peirce . ( Peirce Apel . . Abrams, 2004). , Apel Peirce, Peirce, Morris, .

[31]

, , ,

, ,

, ,

: *+

*+ *125+, , ,

,

, *132+.

. 3

.

,

,

.

, ,

Kant Wittgenstein. ,

, ,

.

Wittgenstein. Kant

,

Kant *. .

+. Kant

,

, ,

.24 Wittgenstein, , -

, .

, ,

. Kant Wittgenstein

-

,

.

24

, , Kant, , , . . .

[32]

,

.. , ,

, , ,

,

. : ()

,

. ,

. () Kant

Wittgenstein ,

- .

Kant:

.

.

,

.

.

, ,

.

.

Kant:

. ,

, , ,

.

. , , ,

, . ,

a priori

, , ,

, : .

.

a priori

*#5116, 1776-8, 18:095-6].

Wittgenstein , ,

:

[33]

(

)

.

:

*22+.

- Kant Wittgenstein

1 :

(

) Kant Wittgenstein. Kant Wittgenstein

, ,

,

, .

- Kant

Wittgenstein :

- Kant -

. - Kant

. Wittgenstein

Frege Russell,

. Wittgenstein, ,

: Wittgenstein ,

,

. - Kant

Wittgenstein

: , , .

, ,

.

Kant 1770.

Kant

, ,

.

,

. Wittgenstein

, ,

.

[34]

:

- .

() .

, , ,

, ,

, .

, ,

.

- .

,

. :

(

), , ,

.

TLP zeigen

sich zeigen *6.522+,

- ,

/

, , ,

TLP (Stegmller, 19653).

, - Kant Wittgenstein,

, , ,

.

, .

-

Kant Wittgenstein

1 . Kant,

Wittgenstein,

,

, , ,

( Kant) (

Wittgenstein).

- , ,

, .

,

, .

[35]

,

.

,

Kant

*30+

. :

*+

*+ *33+. :

, 4.5: :

.

.

[114+. , ,

:

( ). Wittgenstein:

.

, ,

, , ,

,

.

,

.

, Kant Wittgenstein

25 .

, Kant Wittgenstein

, ,

.

()

Kant Wittgenstein.

25 Palmquist Kant (Perspektiv) (. . http://staffweb.hkbu.edu.hk/ppp/ksp1/KSP2.html). Palmquist , , . : Gesichtspunkt, Standpunkt, Absicht.

[36]

.

Wittgenstein:

, ,

*6.342+. :

[152+. , ,

,

.26

, , , .

:

,

, .

,

,

Kant ,

Wittgenstein :

;. ,

.

, ,

, :

,

*57+

*124+.27

26 , , , . Michael Friedman: *+ , . *+ *+ *+ . *+ ( ) *+ ( ) *+ (Friedman, 2001:23/4). 27 Meredith Williams : . Williams Kant Wittgenstein. . . Williams Meredith, (1999:.60-81). , , , Wittgenstein

[37]

.

Wittgenstein

, Kant

Wittgenstein

Kant.

(Kant)

(Wittgenstein).

, ,

,

,

.

.

, , Kant

:

,

, Wittgenstein, .

Kant Wittgenstein

.

Kant .

.

. , , ,

.

. ,

. Wittgenstein , , , . : , , , (Baker, 2004). Wittgenstein , , Wittgenstein .

[38]

,

.28

,

. - Kant

Wittgenstein,

- ,

, Kant,

, , :

:

; *#313, 1764-1770, 15:122+.

Wittgenstein, , :

. ,

*115+. , ,

,

.

Kant -

,

.

Wittgenstein ,29 -,30 ,31

,32 33 . , ,

28 Cavell (1999 (1979):78, 2010:93) . , , , , , . , 43, . Cavell . , , [116+, . 29 Stenius, (1960). Stenius: Visser, 1981 Leinfellner, (1981). 30 Wittgenstein , . ., Haller, 1981 (1980): 32-42, Werner, (1982:13-27). 31

Wittgenstein: . . Bernstein, 2010:21-2. Wittgenstein -: . . Hilary Putnam, 1995:27-32. 32

Glock: . , () Tractatus *+. . (125/6). Glock, , Wittgenstein (126) Wittgenstein .

[39]

, .

Kant Wittgenstein , ,

.34

Allan Janik

(2001) :

, Janik

,

/ Wittgenstein.

: 1)

2)

3)

4)

() 5)

.

Kant . . . Redding, (2010). 33 . . Karl Otto Apel, (1973). , , Paul Natterer Apel : (1) . (2) () , . , , . (3) . a priori : / / / / / / / / / , (Natterer, 2003:456..). 34 corpus Wittgenstein Bergen, [Wittgensteins Nachlass, The Bergen Electronic Edition, Oxford University Press, University of Bergen, the Wittgenstein Trustees, 2000+ Kant ( a priori ) 9 . Wittgenstein : Kant , Wittgenstein . Kuusela (2001) .. Wittgenstein , . .

[40]

[41]

.

: -

Kant Wittgenstein.

- Kant

Wittgenstein.

- , Wittgenstein,

, . Kant

: ,

, , *+

.

,

.

.

*02:367-8]

, Kant

.

Wittgenstein, ,

,

.

. , ,

Wittgenstein 1915,

,

Wittgenstein - *22.1.1915+.

,

, , Wittgenstein,

:

*4.8.1916+.

Wittgenstein

TLP.

- Kant

Wittgenstein,

: - Kant, 1762,

- Kant

.

Wittgenstein

[42]

,

, . Wittgenstein Frege

Russell

.

- Kant

Wittgenstein

,

, .

, ,

Kant Wittgenstein:

Wittgenstein, *. + ,

*4.115+. ,

- Kant ,

Wittgenstein .

, , , (-

Kant) ( Wittgenstein).35

Kant (Unbegreiflichkeit)

, , , , ,

( ).

. Kant, 1762,

/ ,

: , -

Kant 1770, ,

, ,

, - Kant

.

Kant, ,

, ,

, .

a priori ,

,

35

, , , Wittgenstein * TLP+, - , , , , , Wittgenstein *. . , [6.52], [6.521]].

[43]

, , , (

1770 *. . #2835, 16:536+)

, .36

Wittgenstein

,

: , ,

*18.3.1915+.37

, .

a priori

/ . ;

.

-

, *. . 6.1223+, , ,

, , .

Kant Wittgenstein

-

: Kant ,

,

, Wittgenstein ,

. , ,

(Kant) (Wittgenstein),

.

Wittgenstein: .

, *6.522+.38

36 - Kant, , , *. . #3922, 17:346+. 37 . 38

TLP *6.53+ *6.522+: . *6.54+ Wittgenstein, TLP : *6.53+ . *6.54+ . TLP Cora Diamond (1995), : . *6.54+, Wittgenstein , Diamond , ,

[44]

Kant.

21 1772 Marcus Herz:

*. 1770+

,

.

, ,

() .

, ,

: -

Kant ,

Wittgenstein.

- Kant

1762 - ,

Wittgenstein,

, , ,

: ,

, Wittgenstein [4.112].

,

, : .

- Kant

Wittgenstein

, ,

.39

Wittgenstein. : . . , . *6.54+ , , *6.54+ , - : , , *7+ Wittgenstein. *7+ *6.54+: *6.54+ TLP. - . , . 39 . . Kant Wittgenstein : Pirmin Stekeler, (2004: 285-304) TLP : Kant, () *. + *6.371+

[45]

- 1762,

Kant :

, (1747-1759),

.

,

, ,

. Kant

.40 Kant

, ,

- 1762,

.

,

,

. ,

:

. ,

/ ( / )

- a posteriori -,

. - Kant

,

. , ,

,

. Kant:

,

. ..:

. :

, *02:72/3+.41

TLP *. . 6.372 / 6.52+, . 40

Kant 1760-1770, Kant , , . Verstand , (2012). . 41 Kant: : , , , :

[46]

, ,

, , ,

, .

Wittgenstein TLP:

Wittgenstein

TLP,

,

. , ,

, .

..

.

, ,

:

.

. ,

, , -

TLP , , - Carnap,

(2003 (1937): 284/5, 74): *.

+

(

) ,

, ,

, , .

Wittgenstein, Carnap,

.

, , , , . , : , , *#3706, 17:242, 1760-1764 [?] (1753-1759?), 1773-1777 [?] (LBl Kuffner, I, ppi-iv) - . . Immanuel Kant, The Cambridge Companion of the Works of Immanuel Kant, Notes and Fragments, Cambridge University Press, 2005:74-76]. Kant 1762/3 , 1755 : . : . , , Kant .

[47]

, , - Kant

Wittgenstein , ,

Kant

Wittgenstein -

. - Kant 1762

Wittgenstein

,

Wittgenstein,

*. . 6.53+42.

.

(Kant) (Wittgenstein)

, .

(Kant)43

(Wittgenstein), , ,

.44 , ,

, .

, ,

, ,

, ,

.

- Kant Wittgenstein, ,

, ,

- .

42 - Kant , , Kant , *. . #3942, 17:357, 1764-1769]. 43

. . 8, 02:395: , . , , ( ). : , , , , . . , , . 44

Wittgenstein , , , , , , , . *. . Michael Potter, 2008:284, B71]. TLP: . : . *6.1231 : 6.1232+.

[48]

, Kant

Wittgenstein :

(

) :

; *197/242+.

Wittgenstein:

, .

, , ,

, ,

, , ,

[22.11.1914].

Kant Wittgenstein

(Kant)

(Wittgenstein). -, , ,

Wittgenstein,

.

,

Wittgenstein , ,

, , .

- Kant :

,

, , ,

, .

, , :

, , ,

.

, , Wittgenstein TLP:

,

. , , , ,

, , , ,

.

, .

-

[49]

.

, .

- Kant

Wittgenstein ,

(Kant) (Wittgenstein).

,

.

- Kant Wittgenstein

*. . #3922, 17:346+ *6.1223+

, , :

*..+.

, ,

, , !

.

, ,

,

: Kant 1770

*02:396+,

Wittgenstein [6.45],

,

, -.

,

.

, , ,

.

(Kant).

Wittgenstein .

*2.1+ *4.031+

, ,

*1.12+. , ,

- .

.

,

(Wittgenstein), , ,

[50]

, .45

, Kant 1770,

,

/ *19, 02:408+.

Wittgenstein: .

,

, *+ *6.41+.

- Kant

,

.

.

()

, ,

,

Wittgenstein.

Kant 1770: ,

. ,

*+.

*02:408].46

45 Glock (1997:296) TLP, , . Glock TLP . , TLP , , , TLP *..:293+. , , . , , , . 46

Kant virtus , , , , . virtual . : , , . : .

[51]

*6.432+: ,

*. + *..+.

(Kant) (Wittgenstein)

: ,

.

, ,

, , :

. ,

, . ,

, ,

, , ,

(Kant)

(Wittgenstein) , , . ,

, , ,

() .

-

Kant Wittgenstein.

. ,

( , ,

, .), ,

, , .

,

,

, ,

. Kant,

Wittgenstein, :

, Kant Wittgenstein , ,

,

.

Kant , 1762/3,

.

: ,

: , - Kant - , , , : , , , , , , . .

[52]

1770, , ,

. 1770 Kant

,

. Wittgenstein

, , ,

.

, , , , ,

.

,

. , .

.

Wittgenstein,

,

, , ,

*, 4.115].

.

Kant, ,

1770 *02:389, 13..+,

, . ,

,

1770,

, ,

, /

. Kant ,

,

,

. ,

, ,

, Wittgenstein.

*3.1-3.11+

, ,

.

- Kant

Wittgenstein,

.

, ,

[53]

, ,

.

Wittgenstein

TLP,

, , TLP. TLP

Wittgenstein : TLP

, (Das

erlsende Wort)47 .

1. Kant: - Kant.

1.1. .

*1747-1755], , Kant, ,

, ,

1762, ,

.

Kant

. 48 1756

,

:

*. +

, ,

,

,

. ,

,

*+ *01:475+.

1762:

47

, Wittgenstein James Klagee. . . James Klagee, 2010:245-256. 48

Kant Martin Schnfeld, 2000:184..): Knigsberg. , Kant .

[54]

. , ,

Kant

.

1763

:

.

.

,

: ,

, .., ,

,

*02:66].

,

Kant -

:

,

*..].

, ,

:

, , . Kant,

, , ,

, ,

.

, : Kant , ,

. ,

,

. Kant

: ,

() , .

, , 1762/3,

:

, ,

. -

Kant ,

[55]

,

, , ,

,

,

- Kant

, ,

. ,

- , Kant

,

.

, :

Immanuel Kant (1762)

(1763)

,

1763

( 1764) ,

(1766)

- .

- Kant

1747-175649 -

49 , , Kant 1 *. . AIX-XII]. Kant : () , () () . Kant Kant. : Fischer, (1860). Paulsen, (1875). Boehm, (1906). Vaihinger, (1970). De Vleeschauwer, (1962), Hinske, (1970), Henrich, (1967:9-38). Schnfeld, (2000)). 1747 ( Kant) 1756/7, , , . , , 1762-1766 , Kant . , , , 1770 () Kant. Kant - . , , : 1770 1772 Kant Marcus Herz 21 1772. , 1770 1768 Kant - , , , , . . Eduard von Hartmann (1894 / 1910), Kant 1772 1770 1780.

[56]

(

).

, Henrich,

, 1762/3-1766,

(1967:9-10),

Kant

. , Henrich,

.

() , , ()

.

.

,

. ,

,

.

,

.

,

, .

, ,

.

,

, Kant, ,

. : ,

,

. , ,

, , . , ,

.

, , .

, Kant,

, ,

*02:283/4].50

50 . . 02:070.. . *02:167/8+, - Kant: :

[57]

:

Kant,

.

: ,

. ,

,

, . ,

, , ,

,

, , .

, , .51

1763

,

1763, Kant

, :

, ,

:

,

*02:276+.

Kant , , :

. :

,

*..+.

,

.

,

. ,

, , , ,

, . , ,

[. . Immanuel Kant, Metaphysical Foundations of Natural Science, Cambridge University Press, 2004]. 51

Kant 1763: . *02:290+.

[58]

,

,

*02:227+.

,

, , ,

: ,

. , ,

*in concreto+

*02:278:2 / in abstracto+.

, ,

,

,

, ,

*02:278+.

, , ,

:52 *. +

, ,

. , ,

*. +

,

, *.

+*..+ ,

: *02:278/9].

() ,

, , ,

: *02:280+.

, , :

.

52 , . , , .

[59]

Kant: ,

,

* Kant

, +,

,

.

*+

, *+

*02:58/9+.

, .

, ,

. , , ,

,

,

, .

-

, .

. , ,

:

-

.

:

, ,

.

.

, .

Kant

.

,

1762/3-1766

.

, ,

[60]

.53 , , .

. ()

, , ,

,

.

, , 1770.

, ,

, . , ,

, , ,

, , , ,

*. . 02:72/3+.54

, ()

, , .

Kant :

,

53 1763/4 Kant *. . 01:100, 2 +. , *..+ , . , , . : . () , , , , (Eduard von Hartmann, 1979 (1894):14 Friedrich Paulsen, 1875:88..). 54 *. + Kant : *#3942, 17:357, 1764-1768?, 1769?+. , , : . - Kant, 1762-1766, a posteriori , ( ) *. #3717+. a priori . . , , , , a posteriori [##3716 -7,17:259.., 1762-3 / #3738, 17:278../#3914, 3917..+. a priori, a posteriori a priori 1772-1776 *. #4634, 17:616..+.

[61]

.55

, , ,

. , ,

, .

1.2. - : ,

.

Kant 1762-1766 ,

, - .

, ,

.

.

Kant,

, ,

() .

.

-

Hume Kant.56 Kant Hume,

/ - ,

.57

55 - 1755. , , (ratio essendi vel fiendi ratio cognoscendi) ( ) ( ): *. + , *. + *01:392+. 1763/4 , . : : Kant : *02:073..+. 56 Kant Hume . , , , , , Kant Hume. - : , , , , , , ( Kant Hume . .: Beck, 1969:118, Kuehn, 2005: 98-137, : Forster, 2010)). 57 Kuno Fischer (1860) - Kant Hume, , , , Kant .

[62]

Kant Hume,

Kant .58 , ,

,

.

, , ,

:

Kant 1776-8,

, , ,

:

*. + *#5015,

1776/8, 18:60..+.59 ,

, ,

1762/3-1766. Kant

, , Hume.

.

.

,

.

, , , .

:

Kant. :

.

,

Kant 20

. . (2004). 58 Kant - . . Waxman (2005). Kant Hume Manfred Kuehn, Kant Kant Hume , , (. . Kuehn, (2001)). 59

: - . , , , - ( Adickes ). , , - , Kant. .

[63]

,

*04:262+.

, ,

, , .

Manfred Kuehn Kant:

Kant *. +

,

,

.

.

. ,

- [meaningless+

*insignificant+ *2005: 121+.60

, , , ,

,

,

,

, () ,

. ,

-

Kant . ,

.

,

, , : !

, *424/452].

Kant.

1776-1778:

, *.

+.

60

. . (Forster, 2010). O Forster Kuehn , , Kant Hume. Forster , , : Kant , , , . . Forster Kuehn . , , , Kuehn Hume.

[64]

,

. *...+.

: 1769 - *#5037, 18:069, M XXXVI,

1776 1778+.61

,

, :

,

.

:

,

*+

.

,

, , ,

.

Kant:

, *.

+: *434+. ,

, ,

61 Kant, Hume , Hume . , , . Christian Garve Kant . *10:342+ 7 1783 : *. + , . : , , , , . *+ , , . , 21

1798

*12:257-8], : , , , , 4 *sic+: , : , *12:258+. David Hume, , Kant, , , *04:260+.

[65]

,

.62

, , ,

, -

, , ,

, , ,

.

,

. -

,

.

, ,

, .

1.3. .

, , - Kant, , ,

.

, . Kant:

.

62 Norbert Hinske (1966) , *104..+. : (1) . (2) (3) *. . 102+. - , , 1768-9, Kant , *. #5037, 18:069, M XXXVI, 1776 1778], *1770+ [1781]. 18 , [. . Kant: http://www.manchester.edu/kant/lectures/lecturesListDiscipline.htm, : 22.12.2011 Kant , +, , , , , , , .

[66]

. ,

*02:291+.

, ,

, , , () ,

, ,

. , ,

,

,

, .

, ,

() ;

,

,

, , ,

.

, ,

:

, Kant,

,

*02:74+.

, , ,

. .

, Kant,

. , ,

, , , .

, :

, ,

, .

, ,

[67]

.63

,

Kant, : , , ,

, ( ) ...

. , ,

,

, , :

.

Kant:

.

,

*02:74+. , ,

,

,

, .

, ,

,

.

.

, Kant,

; * Kant+ *02:202+

: ,

,

, ,

,

63 Cohen - (Cohen, (1873)). : Dasein *. Kant+, , . (respectus logicus) [Sein] Dasein . Dasein , , , , = . [Wirkende] , *33+. , , , 1770 Kant. : Kant , , / . , , .

[68]

*+

*02:203+. , ,

, , ,

.

() ().

, , ,

.

.

, Kant,

. ,

, , . *+

, ,

.

,

*02:322/3+.

, ,

. ,

() .

, , .

(

) ,

( ), ,

, .

,

, , ,

*. . 02:280+.

-

,

,

, .

, ,

[69]

, , , ,

.64

-

:

, Kant, .

. , -

.

, ,

, -

, , .

1763

:

*. +

,

, ;

. ,

,

, *02:200+.

.

: * +

(.. )

*+ *#3716, 17:255, 1764-1768+. 1766

Kant

: *+ ,

, , ,

.

, , ,

.

*02:370 / ].

64

: , .

[70]

, ,

. 65

, ,

, ,

, . , , a posteriori,

: a priori

Kant a posteriori

a priori .66

, Kant, ,

. ,

, .

1.4. .

, ,

,

. #3942

1764-1769: *+ 65 , , . a posteriori , *. + *+*#3716, 17:256/9, 1764-1768]. Kant 1766 , : . , . . , , , . , , : . , , *+ *02:367/8+. 66 , , , , , , a posteriori: , , *+ : , , . : , *#3716, 17:257-9, 1764-1768+. a priori *1768+ *1770+ . , , . a priori . , - , , , , a posteriori.

[71]

, .

, *+

*+.

. *+ :

. *+ ,

*17:357+.

, , [willkrlich]

, ,

. ,

.

, ,

.

1766:

,

, :

*+ *02:370+.

,

.. .67 , -

,

: *.

+ , ,

. , , ,

*+ *#3709, 17:246-250 1762-1763+.

, ,

*02:280+.

,

, ,

: ,

.

, .

, , , , ,

67 . . , *. ].

[72]

, ,

.

, , -

1769 -

Kant

-

. 1769:

*+ ,

, ,

*. +

*#3922, 17:346-7, 1769+. ,

, ,

: - Kant

.

, , . Kant

.

/ , ,

, ,

, . Kant

, ,

, .

:

. ,

, .

, ,

,

, ,

( ).

:

( ) (

) * Kant 597/625+.

- :

, ,

,

,

.

, , ,

[73]

.

, ,

. , ,

,

, ,

.

- Kant, ,

,

,

! ,

- , , ,

1770

. , ,

.

, ,

.

- Kant

1762.

. :

. ,

. ,

, .

- Kant

(1766), a priori68

68 a priori a priori a priori . , a priori , Kant , , Leibniz Wolff. a priori : / , , , , / 1768 Kant : . : , Kant, , , , . , , ,

[74]

.

.

, :

, .

,

, , ,

( ),

.

1770

:

, , ,

, ,

. , ,

, , .

,

( ),

:

*02:393/4+

,

, ,

,

-

1766. 1766, , Kant

,

,

. , Kant

/

.

1770 :

.

, Kant

*.. / #3958, 17:366, 1769, #3974, 17:371, 1769, #3976, 17:372, 1769..+.

[75]

:

,

*4.114-4.115].

1.5. 1770:

.

-

,

:

-

.

Kant 1766.69

- Kant

, ,

, ,

.

Kant ,

(), , ,

,

.

-

.

:

-

, .

, .70 71

69 , . *. . Immanuel Kant, The Cambridge Edition of the Works of Immanuel Kant: Lectures on Logic, Bloomberg Logic, 167, Cambridge, 1992:167]. 70

, , : , , . ( ) , , *05:351, 59+. ( ).

[76]

.

-

, ,

.

-

,

.

, ,

Jsche Logik: , Kant *84

+,

:

,

. , , ,

.72

, ,

Kant o Jsche Logik

, .73

*. +,

Kant *58+

, ,

,

*04:357+.74

*90+ ,

:

, , ,

,

* 05:352+. , , 1770 . 71 Kaulbach (1982:77) . 72

Immanuel Kant, The Cambridge Edition of the Works of Immanuel Kant: Lectures on Logic, Cambridge University Press, 1992:626. 73

. *224+. : , ( ) *+ *..+. 74

. . *05:464+ Kant: ( ) ( ) *+ *, 2002: 429].

[77]

,

*05:463 / +.

.

, ,

.

, , ,

- , , .

- :

() .

, ,

/

. 1762/3.

- Kant

. Kant

, , - Kant,

,

( ).

,

- .

-

, , ,

-

- .

: , ,

( ), *+

: ,

, ,

, ,

*05:352, , 59, .295+.

- :

. , ,

, :

[78]

, *02:339+.

-

,

, ,

, ,

,

*. . 665/693+.

, ,

,

, ( )

*05:70/1, , 2004:107].

, , :

. - :

,

(),

.

Kant 1770: ( )

*+.

,

, . ,

, ,

. ,

,

.

.

. ,

. ,

, , ,

, , ,

() *-2:396-7, 10+.

Heiner Bielefeldt (2003)

,

. , ,

Kant, , ,

[79]

, .

.

.

, , Kant

, , :

, ,

, , , .

1770 ,

, , ,

, .

Kant / ,

,

.

,

.

.

,

, ,

.

. 1762:

.

1762 , ,

, , ,

.

, .

:

, , ,

,

. , , ,

, , ,

, , , . ,

.

[80]

1756

,

/ :

, ,

.

, , , ,

, .

*. +

, .

,

*01:223+.

- Kant:

.

:

.

Kant

,

.

,

, .

, . , ,

, Kant.

,

,

() .

,

*. 01:100+. ,

, ,

, ,

. 1763/4 Kant

*. . 01:100, 2

+.

,

*..+.

[81]

,

,

. ,

, ,

.

,

. ,

, .

Kant ,

,

,

, Kant,

.

: , ,

.

.

. *. +

* +

.

*02:85+.

. Kant , ,

.

,

, ,

, *.

. 01:394+.75

Kant , , ,

, , ,

, , . , ,

, ,

. 1763

1764 -

75 1755 . , .

[82]

,

1763:

, ,

.

,

,

, , .

*. +

*. + *02:297+.

,

.

1766 [

]

- Kant: , Kant

,

.

. Kant , ,

. ,

, .

, 1766, ,

( )

:

, ,

.

: Swedenborg,

,

, Kant

,

. Swedenborg Kant

.

Kant :

:

,

.

, ,

[83]

* +,

, , ,

*02:342/3+.

, , ,

,

.

, :

.

Kant

*02:350+ *02:351+,

*..+. , ,

Kant *02:350+. , ,

*. . 02:367/8].

Swedenborg

. ,

. , ,

: , ,

(,

Kant), , , , ,

.

, , ,

,

:

,

Kant.

Kant ,

,

76

76 Kant Swedenborg. : , , , . : ,

[84]

, ,

:

,

, .

, ,

*02:346, 1992:451, 37+. Kant - , , *. . Versuch ber die Krankheiten des Kopfes (AK 2:257-71), 1764]. Falkenstein (2004) : , , . Falkenstein (2004:11) , , , . Falkenstein , , (2004:13) *145+ *. : Longuenesse, (1997:211..), Allison, (2004)+. Falkenstein 1770 (. . 2004:68.. 1770 Lambert *10:103 105..+ Kant , , Kant Lambert ( (. . 2004:74). , , Falkenstein ( (2004:14) : . * Falkenstein (2004:25). , , *. . 18/9 +. ( Falkenstein , (2004:28..) . . . Strawson, (2005 (1966):15). Strawson: *. , Kant+ *. + *. +. , *. + . Kant Locke Kant *. . AIX] - , 1773: , , , , *An Herz Gegen Ende die Jahre 1773, 10:145].

[85]

, ,

:

*+ :

, ,

, - ,

, .

Kant: *. +

*02:364+

* +

, , ,

*02:339+. , ,

, *02:362+

, ,

:

: , ,

... *02:339+.

,

:

.

.

.

, ,

. ,

1770,

.

,

,

.

() (

) ()

.

.

[86]

1762/3 *. . #3709, 17:246-250,

1762-3+ 1770 : .

Kant

.

, : ,

,

, .

, ,

, .

*02:370+.

,

: .

:

*.

+ , , .

,

*+ *#3709, 17:246-250 1762-1763].

, ,

:

, ,

, *. . 01:394+.

, ,

:

. ,

, ,

, . ,

, , ;

Kant 1770

,

, :

,

[87]

,

,

, , *02:387+.

, *. .

02:388+ : .

- -

,

. Kant

:

*111+.

Kant ,

,

:

(

) ,

.77

, ,

.

,

.

Kant 1768.

, ,

Kant 1760 -1770

.

1768

, Kant

,

, ,

1770, .

:

. , *+,

*. +

,

. ,

:

77

. . , *40 48+ .

[88]

,

*02:383+.

, , ,

,

: ,

.

(

1768

).

1768:

,

,

. *+

, *+,

,

.

.

*..+.

, ,

( ),

(

1760 1770).

-

,

, ,

, ,

, , :

, .

, ,

.

- Kant ,

Kant,

[89]

, .

, 1768

a priori

.

, 1770,

, Kant

.

, *. .

+ ,

, ,

,

.

2 1770, Kant

. , ,

*3+ ,

, *. . + ,

, [Verstand]. :

, Kant

*4.+:

,

,

*02:392/3+.

, , Kant

: ,

, , ,

, .

, , ,

, .

,

( ),

:

*02:393/4+. , , :

;

:

- Kant

, .

[90]

, , ,

,

, :

,

:

, Kant *02:396+

: ,

, , ,

*..+.

Kant 1770 ,

.

Swedenborg

. , ,

: .

, .

.

.

,

,

, :

: , , .

, ,

,

,

.78

Kant: ,

,

,

, .

( ).

78 , , : . . , , .

[91]

, ,

*02:396, 9+. /

.79

, , Kant ,

, : . *+

, ,

*02:410+ .

, ,

,

*02:409/410+. Kant

1770

1756,80 . 1762

/ ,

-

.

.

:

,

,

, ,

: ( )

, ,

, , ,

. *+ *04:363/4

Rolf Peter Horstmann (1998:540..)+.

79

Ameriks (2011:29-54) . 80 , , Kant *01:475+. . 1770 *02:396, 9+.

[92]

Kant

. - 1770

.

Wittgenstein Wittgenstein Schopenhauer,

,

, .

sub specie aeternitatis,

, ,

.

Wittgenstein ,

.

, .

- Kant

,

Wittgenstein :

, ,

.

,

.

, , :

Kant, , ,

, .

Stokhof (2002:236-7) , ,

, , , ,

. , , : TLP

*6.13+

, . ,

, ,

, .

:

*2.012+ ,

. (

[93]

) *+ *2.0123+

*2.014+

,

*3.42+

*4.064+

, *5.524+ .

, ,

. , , Wittgenstein

,

, -

Kant. Wittgenstein

- Kant: Kant

,

Wittgenstein .

Wittgenstein, ,

, ,

, Kant.

, ,

*5.621+, ,

, , ,

*5.641+. ,

*6.41+.

TLP

. TLP , ,

Kant

1766 . , ,

, , TLP,

, ,

.

[94]

2. 81 Wittgenstein.

*. Wittgenstein+: ; ;

, .

Bertrand Russell, Autobiography, (1998:2330)

Wittgenstein

, , , ,

Wittgenstein . Wittgenstein

(Frege Russell),

. ,

, ,

( )

, Wittgenstein, .

Wittgenstein,

, , -

.

Wittgenstein Frege Russell

.82

81 Wittgenstein Wittgenstein. Wittgenstein TLP Wittgenstein TLP Wittgenstein 1929 Wittgenstein . Wittgenstein . Wittgenstein . Wittgenstein (. . Danile Moyal Sharrock, The Third Wittgenstein: The Post-Investigations Works, Ashgate Publishing Ltd., 2004). , Wittgenstein , , , Wittgenstein . , Diamond Conant, TLP (Cora Diamond & James Conant, 2004:35). (. . Kuusela, 2008). , , Stern, , : Wittgenstein, (Stern, 2006:205-206). 82

. . Marion (2006). Wittgenstein , Marion, , Wittgenstein.

[95]

, ,

, , ,

. , ,

.

,

.

/

, , ,

,

. ,

,

, ,

,

!

, -

, /

.

,

.

. , , ,

,

:

.

: TLP

TLP

Kant 1766 . ,

/ Wittgenstein

1929.

2.1. Wittgenstein.

, ,

Wittgenstein, :

1913 * : ],

Moore 1914 * : +

1914-1917 [+.

[96]

, , TLP83

,

.84

,

.

Wittgenstein

85 Wittgenstein

Frege Russell

. , , ,

, ,

,

.

: ,

(decompositional analysis / : )

,

(transformative

analysis / : ).

.

.

.

/

,

83

TLP: . . Rupert Read Mathew A. Lavery (ed.), 2011. 84 TLP TLP, , , , , TLP, TLP, - , TLP *. . , 2007:165..+. 85

Frege . (1984:74): Frege : (, ), (, ) , ( ) *+.

[97]

.

Wittgenstein :

,

, , .

;

:

Wittgenstein

- , ,

, , .

Wittgenstein.

,

Wittgenstein

Wittgenstein.86 , Wittgenstein ,

,

.

Wittgenstein ,

-

, , ( ).

, *+

, (, 1998:74),

, Wittgenstein *20.6.1915+.

, , , , :

.

,

86 : Wittgenstein, , - a priori / *. . 2.225 2.223+. , , *11.10.1914+. : . , , *3.1431+. *3.11+. TLP . , , , , .

[98]

( / )

.

Michael Beany (2007:3-4):

Frege Russell ,

.

;

; *+ ,

, ,

, , ,

;

;

a priori , ;

;. :

;

,

Beany,

Wittgenstein ,

, ,

,

,

, .

, , .

, ,

() .

Wittgenstein ,

, .

, :

, ,

. .

,

,

*+ *9.5.1915+

.

,

[99]

.

:

.

, ,

: , 1914 Wittgenstein,

; , .., :

;

.

. ; *+ :

; ;

Russell

( Russell : ! !). :

, , ,

() *3.9.1914+.

-

,

, .

: ,

, , ,

. , ,

, ,

,87 88 ,

.

, ,

,

Wittgenstein TLP.

, ,

- ,

87

TLP: , *5.5562+. 88

* + : *2, 2008:276+.

[100]

-

, , . ,

, - ,

! Wittgenstein

,

- ,

.

:

,

. , ,

,

.

, , TLP

Kant

1766.

,

, , .

Kant Wittgenstein

, ,

. , ,

,

, . ,

, , ,

, , , ,

.

Kant 1766

, Swedenborg.

Kant

.

Kant, Mendelssohn

Kant - Kant

.89 ,

89

Vaihinger Mendelssohn 1766 Kant. Laywine 1993:12, 101.. 148: *. Mendelssohn+

[101]

, .

, Kant

, , Swedenborg,

, ,

.90

TLP,

- ,

- TLP -

. - Kant 1766

Wittgenstein TLP : Kant

Swedenborg

, .

Swedenborg

, , Kant

.

, ,

.

, ,

, , ,

,

.

, , ,

, .

Kant Swedenborg, , ,

, , ,

,

Kant . 1990 TLP Cora Diamond Wittgenstein, , Kant 1766, Wittgenstein ( ) , , - ( ). 90

. Kant , , : 1766 , , , Hume , , .

[102]

, , , ,

Kant!91 Kant:

, ,

, , ,

*. + ,

, ,

,

, , *02:348+.

, ,

Swedenborg: , Kant

*+.

TLP.

Kant

, ,

Wittgenstein. TLP

,

Kant,

. ,

-

(Conant, 2004:167-192).

TLP

TLP

, .

TLP

Wittgenstein, Kant .

Cora Diamond

Wittgenstein , , [6.54],

91

. .: *. + , .. , Wolff , Crusius : : *02:341+.

[103]

, -

.

*6.54+:

: -

, , , , . ( ,

, ).

*6.54+ Kant ,

. Kant

1776-8, , , ,

: *.

+ *#5015, 1776/8, 18:60..+.

, ,

,

, , -. TLP *7+

. TLP.

, , TLP

, ,

,

:

. TLP ,

;

,

.

.

Wittgenstein TLP.

TLP , ,

TLP,

Wittgenstein.

, , TLP

Wittgenstein: Wittgenstein

.

. TLP , ,

[104]

, Wittgenstein!

,

.

:

,

. ,

,

.

:

. ,

, : *+

Wittgenstein

*2008:279, 24+ ,

.

, , , ,

,

92

, , ,

.

, ,

.

, Wittgenstein,

. , ,

.

,

. , ,

, ,

, .

, ,

*2008:276, 9+.

92

- - . . Wittgenstein : * + *+ *2008:276, 2+. : *+ *80+. . , , , , , , : , *25.10.1914+. , Wittgenstein, , *2008:288, C37+ .

[105]

,

,

:

( )

*. +,

,

. :

(Sinn) *Wittgenstein, 1998 (1961):80/1].93

: ,

, *2008:48,

282+. , , ;

. , ,

, ,

- ,

(

, 95 ).

, ,

Wittgenstein:

: ,

*15.11.1914+.

, ,

,

,