Ирина Разумова Консорциум НЭИКОН [email protected] Science Online в Крыму, июнь 2009

  • Upload
    ormand

  • View
    39

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Международные и национальные рейтинги университетов как механизм оценки научной деятельности: альтернатива или дополнение к индексам цитирования?. Ирина Разумова Консорциум НЭИКОН [email protected] Science Online в Крыму, июнь 2009. Рейтинги университетов. Что это? Зачем они? - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Citation preview

  • [email protected] Online , 2009 : ?

    , 2009

  • [email protected]

    , , 2009 . ? ? ?

    , 2009

  • ? , 2008 .

    5 2008 . 583 ( - ), http://www.kpmo.ru/kpmo/info/nsotdocs.html

    , 2009

  • ? . ...

    !!! , 1 2008

    , 2009

  • 2008 .

    .

    - Science Citation Index Expanded Social Sciences Citation Index, Web of Science (WoS).

    , 2009

  • . (, ). .

    , 2009

  • .

    , , ?

    , 2009

  • ....

    : . , : Web of Science, Scopus, Google Scholar

    , 2009

  • , , ?

    , 2009

  • . , , :

    , 2009

  • . ?

    , . , , , , , . ,

    , 2009

  • , , . ? . , STRF.ruhttp://www.strf.ru/organization.aspx?CatalogId=221&d_no=20373

    , top-50, top-10.

    IHEP (www.ihep.org) .

    , 2009

  • IHEP ( , full profs) - $1020 . .

    , 2009

  • IHEP . - . . - . .

    , 2009

  • . . http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/

    , 2009

  • UK: Times, Guardian The Independent , US News and World Report Ecole des Mines , ,

    , 2009

  • 22 (scientific impact), . (Third European Report on Science & Technology Indicators) (Directorate General for Science and Research of the European Commission), 2003 ( 2004).

    , 2009

  • EuropeEuropean UnionFranceGermanyIrelandItalySwitzerlandUKUkraine

    AsiaChinaPakistanIndiaPhilippines

    North AmericaCanadaUSA

    , 2009

  • Wikipedia: College and University Rankings

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/College_and_university_rankings

    , 2009

  • (, ). .

    , 2009

  • . 1. Times Higher Education Supplement (THES) QS World University Rankings (QS-Quacquarelli Symonds),

    , 2009

  • Times Higher Education Supplement (THES) 6 (Peer Review, 40%); (Recruitment Review, 10%); (International Students, 5%); (International Faculty, 5%); (Faculty / Student, 20%); (Citation/Faculty, 20%).

    , 2009

  • Top 300 Universities in ( ):Arts and HumanitiesLife Sciences & BiomedicineNatural SciencesSocial SciencesTechnologies

    , 2009

  • Top 100 2007 THES37 19 8 6 4 3 , , 2 , 1 , , , , , ., , , 0!!!!!!!

    , 2009

  • Moscow State UniversityWorld University Rankings 2008/2007 THES

    Area Rank Overall 183/231(96 2006; 79 2005)Natural Sciences 29Technology - 104Social Science - 207Life Sciences & Biomedicine -132Arts and Humanities - 166

    , 2009

  • St. Petersburg State UniversityWorld University Rankings 2008/2007

    RankOverall 224/239 (2006 -164; 2005 -218)Natural Sciences 81Arts and Humanities - 191Life Sciences & Biomedicine -237

    , 2009

  • THES 2008 Top 200 Top 300 Top 500 : 256 Technology 172 Natural Science) THES

    , 2009

  • (Peer Review, 40%; Recruitment Review, 10%); . 30 . ? . . , 2006 1% (1600 190 000). , Times (?) . , . 200: Fudan (China): 72 - 195 RIFT (Australia): 55 - 146, Emory (USA):173 - 56, Perdue (USA): 59 - 127

    , 2009

  • . 2.

    Academic Ranking of World Universities, ARWU,

    Shanghai Jiao Tong University, 2003.

    www.arwu.org

    , 2009

  • ARWU

    , (, , ) () (Alumni,10 %) , (, , ) () (Award, 20%); , 21 (HiCi, 20%);

    , 2009

  • ARWU

    , Nature Science (N&S, 20%); , Web of Science (SCIE, SSCI AHCI) (SCI, 20%); (FTE) (Size, 10%).

    , 2009

  • Nobel Prize winners. http://nobelprize.org/

    Fields Medals. http://www.mathunion.org/medals/

    Highly cited researchers. http://www.isihighlycited.com

    Articles published in Nature and Science. http://www.isiknowledge.com

    Articles indexed in Science Citation Index-Expanded and Social Science Citation Index. http://www.isiknowledge.com.

    FTE. : National Ministry of Education, National Bureau of Statistics, National Association of Universities and Colleges, National Rector's Conference.

    , 2009

  • Top 500 World Universities 2007/2008 ARWU

    , 2009

  • World Rank 2008Institution*RegionRegional Rank 2008CountryNational Rank 20081Harvard UnivAmericas1USA12Stanford UnivAmericas2USA23Univ California - BerkeleyAmericas3USA34Univ CambridgeEurope1UK15Massachusetts Inst Tech (MIT)Americas4USA46California Inst TechAmericas5USA57Columbia UnivAmericas6USA68Princeton UnivAmericas7USA79Univ ChicagoAmericas8USA810Univ OxfordEurope2UK211Yale UnivAmericas9USA912Cornell UnivAmericas10USA1013Univ California - Los AngelesAmericas11USA1114Univ California - San DiegoAmericas12USA1215Univ PennsylvaniaAmericas13USA1316Univ Washington - SeattleAmericas14USA1417Univ Wisconsin - MadisonAmericas15USA1518Univ California - San FranciscoAmericas16USA1619Tokyo UnivAsia/Pac1Japan120Johns Hopkins UnivAmericas17USA17

    , 2009

  • Nature, Science Nobel Prize Winners, Fields Medalists 2007 Scientometric ARWU . , , .Irreproducability of the results of the Shanghai academic ranking of world universities, Razvan V. Florian. Scientometrics, 2007, V. 72, #1

    , 2009

  • Newsweek: 100 Global Universities50% ARWU: , 21 (HiCi); , Nature Science (N&S); , Web of Science (SCIE, SSCI AHCI) (SCI); : 50/3 %

    , 2009

  • Newsweek: 100 Global Universities40 % THES 10 %: (International Students); (International Faculty); (Faculty / Student); (Citation/Faculty).10%

    , 2009

  • , 2009

  • . 5. GUR

    Global University Ranking, GUR

    , 2009

  • . 5. GUR

    , , ? 10

    , 2009

  • 2009 430 http://www.globaluniversitiesranking.org/ Top 100 3 ( 5 , . 55 , 84 )

    , 2009

  • , . . . , . . . , () . , ? ? . . - ?

    , 2009

  • ,

    , . : . . . .

    , 2009

  • - ()

    (WoS, Scopus, .., ?) , . (Evaluation) (Scientific Output): , WoS WoS, , . . - .

    , 2009

  • , .

    !

    , 2009

  • - , , . , 2001

    , 2009

  • , 2001 () , , , , 2001 ( , .), , 2001

    , 2009

  • .-. () (, , ..) 2007/2008 ? , , , % , . ( )

    , 2009

  • , , , , , , . - , . , Tflops

    , 2009

  • , : , , , , , ( 100 . .), (, .), .?

    , 2009

  • , , () ,

    , 2009

  • , / ; , ( ? ?)

    , 2009

  • , 2009

  • , 2009

  • , 2009

  • , 2009

    Top 500 , , 20- 2008 : 17 , 2 , 1 .