33

stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    10

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

�������������� ������ ����� ����������� �����! "���#�$%�&�(')�*��+ � �,�-� /.+�����0 ��12���

3!4658789;:�<=78>$?98@BA�C*4EDF>+G�HBI89=4KJL>NMO<=78PRQ/<S78DTJLU�VW<=7�MEJXP*JL>KYZC8D\[

]!^#_a`�b�cedf`gihkj%lnmZo�p�qsr&tvuwjarxj�yElxjapzlxo{jarxlwq|h~}Nlxj�lnmZj�t�uwoK��}f��qs�sq�lT��p�qsrxlxunqs�L�Zlwq�oEyvr�of��%�sq|hk}Nlxj�rx�Zrxlxj�h

tvuwoKtXj%uwlwq�jar!��}frxjap�oEy�}�mvq�j%u�}Nun��mvqs�%}f�W�*}��fjarwqs}Ky�hko�pvja����g*l�lnmvj+�e}frxj+of��lnmZj2h�oZpvja������j�vrxj�rwq|h��v�s}Nlwq�oEyvr�of�#}��%�sq|hk}Nlxj\h�oZpvja�eq|y~��mvqs��m{lnmZj�oE�vlwte�Zlwr�pvjatXj�yvpkoEy{lnmZj&�%�sq|hk}NlxjWrx�Zrxlxj�htvuwoKtXj%uwlwq�jar�}Kyvp��%}Ky�}f�srxo\�Xj*��oEhkt�}Nunjap���q�lnm�oK��rxj%uw�N}Nlwq�oEyvr%���BmZj8pvj%�funj%j8lxo���mvqs��m�lnmZj$hko�pvja�oE�Zlwte�ZlwrB}Nuwj��x��oEyvrwqsrwlxj�yKlw ~�Bq�lnm�lnmZjWoK�erxj%uw�N}Nlwq�oEyvrBqsr��vrxjap�lxokoK��lw}fq|y�lnmZj\�sq�¡fja�sq|mZo�oZp��¢ofu$lnmZj�%�sq|hk}Nlxj�rx��rwlxj�hitvunoKtLj%unlwq�jar%�S£�j&pvj%¤Lyvj$lnmZjB�%�sq|h~}Nlxj�rx�Zrxlxj�hitvuwoKtXj%uwlwq�jar}fr�lnmZoKrxj�tvuwoKtXj%uwlwq�jarof�&lnmZj��%�sq|hk}Nlxj+h�oZpvja��lnmv}Nl{��oEyElxuwoK�BlnmZj��s}Nuw�fj�¥¦rw�%}f��j+uwjarntLoEy�rxj�of�&lnmZj��%�sq|hk}Nlxj�rx��rwlxj�h)lxoj�§�lxj%u�yv}f���¢ofun�%q|yZ�Kr%��¨©y2lnmvqsr�t�}ftXj%ua�=��jª�vrxj~lnmZjª«�¨F�R¬N­®�%�sq|h~}Nlxj!hko�pvja�$¯°«�¨©�B¬N­\±8«�²&lxotvuwo���qspvj�rwq|h��v�s}Nlwq�oEyvrSof�vo���ja}Ky³�Krn�Zuw��}f��j�}Kyvp��vt�tXj%u#}NlnhkoKrwtemZj%unqs�lxj�hktXj%un}Nln�Zunj�Xj�mv}a�Zq�ofuSo��fj%u´ oEyZjar8pvj%¤Lyvjapª�6�~�s}Nlwq�ln�vp�j\��}Kyvp�r%��¨xy{lnmZj\«-¨©�B¬N­\±8«µ��lnmvj&�%�sq|h~}Nlxj\rx�Zrxlxj�hRtvuwoKtXj%uwlwq�jar*�%}Ky�Xj�rxj%lB�Zqs}klnmvuwj%j�t�}Nu�}Kh�j%lxj%unr%¶$±*�sq|h~}Nlxj�rxj�yvrnq�lwq���q�lT�O¯¢lnmZj�ja·Z�vqs�sqs�vu�q|��h®rn�vuw�¢}f��j�lxj�hktXj%un}Nln�Zuwj��mv}Kyv�fj�q|y�unjarwtXoEyvrxjWlxo{}{pvoE�v���sq|yv��of��±$¸W¬���oEyv��j�yElxun}Nlwq�oEyvr%²w�Xlnmvj\un}Nlxj�of��pvj%jatv¥¹o���ja}KyzmZja}Nl�vtvlw}N¡fj�¯�}fr�rxj%l�6��lnmZjBp�q»º¼�vrwq�oEykof��lxj�hktXj%un}Nln�Zuwj$}KyvoEhk}f�sq�jarq|yElxo�lnmvjBpvj%jatZ¥¹oZ��ja}Ky~�Xja��o��"lnmZj�%�sq|hk}NlxoK��of�Kqs�%}f�=hkq»§Zjap{�s}��fj%u%²w�L}Kyvp�yZj%l8rxlxunj�yZ�flnm{of�#lnmZjW}KyElnmZuwoKtXof�fj�yvqs�&}Nj%uwoKrxoK���¢ofun�%q|yZ�Kr%�¨©ylnmvqsr���ofuw¡X�Z��jW�vrxj�oE�Zlwte�Zl��¢uwoEh½«�¨©�B¬N­\±8«¾��oE�vt���japª�Bq�lnmªmvqsrxlxofu�qs�%}f�Llxj�h~tXj%un}Nln�Zuwj$unja��ofunp�rlxo�h~}N¡fj�q|yZ�¢j%uwj�yv��j&}f�XoE�Zl�lnmZjarwj��%�sq|h~}Nlxj�rx�Zrxlxj�h¿tvuwoKtXj%uwlwq�jara��À�fj�yklnmvoE�Z�Emklnmvj�«�¨F�B¬N­\±8«qsr=�¢}Nu���jarwr���oEh~te�Zlw}Nlwq�oEyv}f�s����pvj�hk}Ky�p�q|yZ�Blnm�}Ky�}��°�v�s�ZÁN­��%�sq|h~}Nlxj$h�oZpvja���NlnmZj*lw}frx¡�of�Lu���y�yvq|yv�lnmZj{hko�pvja���¢ofu\ja}f��mµ��oEh���q|yv}Nlwq�oEy2of�*lnmZj~�%�sq|hk}Nlxjªt�}Nun}Khkj%lxj%unr\}KyvpOtvuwoZ��jarwrwq|yZ�-q�lwr�oE�Zlwte�Zlqsr���oEh~te�Zlw}Nlwq�oEyv}f�s���µp�j�hk}Kyvp�q|yv�v�{�Bm��vr%��}�rxlw}Nlwqsrwlwqs�%}f�*hko�p�ja��qsr�uwja·Z�vq�uwjapµlxo�}ft�t�uwoa§vq|hk}NlxjlnmZjWh�oZpvja�eoE�vlwte�Zl%��£�jWoK�vlw}fq|yªuwjarn����lwr�lnm�}Nl*}Nunj&��u�q�lwqs�%}f���Âofu$��yvp�j%unrxlw}Kyvp�q|yv����yv��j%unlw}fq|yKlT�{q|y���vln�Zuwj�%�sq|h~}Nlxj���mv}KyZ�fj*}Kyvp�t�uwo��Zqspvj�}Ky�q|yvpvjatXj�yvp�j�yKl#��mZja�w¡�lnmv}NlSlnmvj�q|yZ�¢ofu�hk}Nlwq�oEy���oEyElw}fq|yZjapq|y!uwja��j�yElB�%�sq|hk}Nlxj���mv}Kyv�fj�qsr8uwoK�e��rxl8lxo~rxlw}Nlwqsrxlwqs�%}f�Slxuwja}Nlnhkj�yKl%�à j%�ª��ofunper%¶h�oZpvja�³�%}f�sqs�vun}Nlwq�oEy³�L�%�sq|hk}Nlxj���mv}KyZ�fjf�X�%�sq|hk}Nlxj�rwj�yvrwq�lwq��Zq�l¦�f�L�*}��fjarwqs}Ky+h�j%lnmZoZp�r

ÄnÅ=ÆTÇKÈEÉ;ÊfË�ÈEÌ6ÍÉEÎ-ÏÌFÌTÉNÐnÑ»ËaÒTÓ�Ô¼ÆFÉaÕ|Ó�ÌFÌTÉ�Æ�Î!Ö�Ón×6ËaÆTÒTØ&ÓnÈÙÒ/ÉaÕ�Ï×K×KÚ»ÑÛÓ�Ü¿Ý�ËaÒTÞKÓ�ØWË%ÒTÑ�ÐnÌ/Ë�ÈEܽÊÙÒ©Ë%ÒFѻ̦ÒTÑ�ÐnÌ�Î�ß�ÈEÑÛà�ÓnÆTáÌTÑâÒ¹ã�É�Õ�ä=Ë�ÚÛÑÛÕ|É�ÆFÈKÑ�ËKÎ�å�å�æaçµèÑÛé�Þ�ÊNÒTÆFÓnÓwÒ�ÝkÊvê�ÊEë�ìSíKÎ\ÊfËaÈÙÒFËîäSÆFÇKïµä=Ï�á°ð�æañ�çaò6Î�ß$óôÊZó Ï$ó8õföÙ÷NøEùÙúNû�üeý³þÂ÷ZÿNýNÿ³þ�����÷vÎ����� þ¹û�üeý³þÂ÷ZÿNýNÿ³þ�����÷����õNöÙ÷�øEùEó³äSÞEÆTÑ�Ììó�KÉ�ÆTÓ�̹Ò�Î��Ó�̦Ó�ËaƩЩÞ�ÊfÐnÑÛÓ�ÈÙÒTÑ�̹Ò�Î ��É�Ñ»ÈÙÒÔ¼ÆFÉ�é�Æ©ËaØ É�È�ÒTÞKÓ�ÊfÐwÑ»ÓnÈEÐnÓBËaÈ6Ü�Ô�É�ÚÛÑ�ÐwãÉaÕ���Ú»É��EË�Ú=äSÞEËaÈEé�Ó�Î��ØRì¼òÙñ%á�òÙí���Ý����*Î�����Ý�Ë�ÌFÌnó�Ï�à�Ó�ó»Î³ä=Ë�Ø��KÆFÑ»ÜKé�Ó�Î�Ý�Ï ñ�íKå���ðKÎeßBó ÊZó Ï$óSÿ����Nù�ö��Eý��fú�ü! "��þ�����÷vÎ� ��õ�þ|ü! "��þ�����÷���#�$Ùù�õKû�$Kÿ&%Eû%ø'#'��� ����� �EÎ�Ö�ËaÈEÑÛÓ�Ú�(ZË�È�ÒFÓ�ÜfÓ�ÌTЩÞEÑÂÎ ��ÆFË�ÜfÇEË%ÒFÓBÊÙÒTÇ6ÜfÓnÈÙÒ�ÎvÖ�Ón×EË�ƦÒFØ&ÓnÈÙÒÉaÕ¼Ï×K×KÚ»ÑÛÓ�Ü~Ý�Ë%ÒFÞKÓwáØWË%ÒFÑ»Ð�Ì�Ë�ÈEÜkÊÙÒFËaÒTÑ�̹ÒFÑ»Ð�ÌnÎvßÈKÑÛà�ÓnƩ̦ÑÛÒ¹ã�ÉaÕSä=ËaÚ»ÑâÕ|É�ÆTÈEÑ»ËEÎLå�å�æaçWèÑÛé�Þ~ÊÙÒTÆFÓnÓnÒ*ÝkÊvêZÊEë�ì=ífÎvÊfËaÈÙÒ©Ë�äSÆTÇEï�ä=Ï�á°ð�æ�ñ�çaò6ÎEß$óôÊZó Ï$ó�fû�ø )�'$�*fúÙû�üeý³þ¢÷�ÿNýNÿ�þ�����÷vÎ ����� þ¹û�üeý³þ¢÷ZÿÙýNÿ³þ�����÷����+�fû%ø, ���$�*6ó

-

Page 2: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

� ��������� � ���������

������������� �"!#� $&%('*)�,+#� -.'"� -/�"0(%/�1��2&3�4/5,36�,78':9/3�;�2&$<���='*3�)?>@)�':3��A�B3C�*3�)?-/�D���=�*$&E�3�4D$&%F':9/3BG8� -/�?'*9H )?)*3C)*)*�D3C%('JI�3�!#� �?'��,7K':9/3JLM%('*3��?5 �1N 3��?%/�D3�%O'P�=2RQ"�,%.3�2#� %�SB2&$<���='*3�SB98�,%.5 3UTVLWQ�S6SYX.Z,[ [ \(]P^G_$<�?)?'`X':9.3�5,2<� +/�,2a�`N 3��*�,5 3��,%/%(-8�=2�':3��D!#3��*�=':-/�?3��=7�'*9/3�bc�=�?':9edf)g)*-/��7h�,;�3D98�=)i$&%/;��?3`�,)?3�4j+(>k�=)��l-/;P9m�=)[.^n\o4/3C5 �*3C3�)FSB3�2&)*$&-/)F)*$&%/;C3p':9/3�2<�=':3 -1q '*9r;�3C%O':-/��> ^tsu3�;C� %/4vX"���,)?'i�,7�':9.$<)i� +/)*3C�?N,3�4w�B�,�*�D$&%/5x$&)�='?':�*$&+/-.'*3�4k':�o9@-.���=%w$<%uy8-/3�%.;�3p�,%k'*9/3�;C2<$&���=':3�)?>@)?'*3��z)*$&%/;C3�':9.3�+#3�5 $&%/%/$&%/5t�,7B'*9/3�$&%/4/-.)?':�?${�=2�*3|N � 2&-.'*$<� % ��$}':9~�,%O'*9/�*� !#� 5 3C%/$&;l7h�,;C'*� �*)UTh!/�?$<���,�?$<2}>�$&%/;��?3`�,)?$<%.5�5 �*3C3�%/9/�,-/)*3D5O�,)J;�� %.;�3�%O'*�:�='*$<� %.)|]+#3�$&%/5�!8�,��':2}>k�*3�)?!K�,%/)*$&+/2&3p7V� ��':9/3����,�?�D$<%/5.^x�69/3��8�*)�'U!K�,$<%O'i$<)F+/�,)*3C4w� %w3|Nu$&4/3C%/;�3�$&%j'*9/3�� +u�)*3C�?N=�='*$<� %/�,2K�?3�;C� �*4/)B�,7R)*-.�?7h�,;C3J':3C�D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3C)B��$&'*9�)*$&�D$<2<�,�B3|N@$<4/3C%/;�3�7V�?� ��':3C�D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3C)�$<%p+K�,'*9':9.3�-.!/!K3C���M�=':�D� )?!/9/3��?3��,%/4k�u;C3`�,% ':3C�D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3D�*3C;�� �?4/)�+K3C5 $&%/%/$&%/5t$&%~':9/3 -1q � [,)�^l�69/3�)?3�;C� %/4!#� $<%O'�$&)�)?-/!/!#� �?'*3�4t+(>�'*9/3�2<$}':3C�:�='*-/�*3�� %o;�2&$&����':3g���@4/3C2R3|�u!K3C�*$&�D3�%O':)�$&%���9/$<;P9o':9/3�)?$<�i-/2{��':$&� %/)�,7c':9/3D9/$&)?'*� �*$&;`�=2�!K3C�*$&�u4�T�� -1�O� [p':��!/�*3C)*3C%('|]��=�*3D;�� �D!8�=�*3�4j�,5O�=$<%/)�'�':9/3D� +.)*3���N=�=':$&� %8�,2"�*3�;C� �*4e^LM%~)*9/�,�?'`XR'*9/3U9/$&)?':�,�*$&;`�,2�?3�;��,�*4~;`�,%.%/�,'g+K3U3��u!/2{�=$<%/3C4r+O>�%/�=':-/�*�,2�;C2<$&���=':3U7V� �?;�$&%/5 )�� ��-/%u7V� �*;C3�4;�2&$&����':3�N=�,�*$<�,+/$&2&$&'M>,^�69@-.)�X(� %/2}>F)?$<�i-/2{��':$&� %/)��$&'*9D+K�,'*9��,%O':9/�?� !K�,5 3�%/$&;��,%/4U%/�=':-/�*�,2.7V� �?;�$&%/5 );��,%+#3�)?'Y�*3C!/2<$&;`��':3l'*9/3l!8�=)?'�;P9/�,%/5 3C)Y$&%x':3C��!#3��*�=':-.�*3,^JG8-/�?'*9/3��?�D� �*3=Xe3|�u!#3��?$<�D3�%O'*)���$&'*9x':9/3C)*3F)*�,�D3�D�u4.3�2&)�!/�*3C4/$&;C'�3CN,3�%~2<�,�*5 3C�J�B�,�*�D$&%/5�$<%�'*9/3l7V-.'*-/�*3i$&7a'*9/3F;��,%/;�3C%('*�:�='*$<�,%/)��,7a5 �?3�3�%.9/� -/)?3U5O�,)*3C)�,�?3g%.�,'�)?':�,+/$&2<$&E�3C4x+O>��*3C4/-/;�$&%/5�3��D$&)*)*$&� %/)C^

�69/3c)*-/+u��3C;C'"�,7.'*9/$<)�!8�,!#3���$&)�'*�J-.)*3c;�2&$<���='*3�;P98�=%/5 3c� +/)*3C�?N=�='*$<� %.)_':��3��.!.2<� �?3�'*9/3a4/$<)�':�?$<+/-u':$&� %/)7V� �g!/�*�,!K3C�?':$&3�)l�,76':9/3�;�2&$<���='*3�)?>@)�':3���':98��'l;C� %O':�*�,2�':9.3p)*$&�l-.2{�='*$<�,%/)U�,7�7V-.'*-/�*3�;�2&$<���='*3�;P98�,%.5 3$&%m�*3�)?!K�,%/)*3�':�x3|�u!K3C;C'*3�4�;�2&$<���='*3�7V� �*;C$<%/5,)�^~�69/3�)?3�)*$&�l-/2<�='*$<� %.)�!.�*�1N@$<4/3�$&%.7V� �?���=':$&� %m� %m2&� %/5=�':3C�*��;�2&$&����':3F!/�?3�4/$&;C'*$<�,%/)��,%/4��,�*3i���=4/3F+O>o)*$&�l-/2<�=':$&%/5�'*9/3l7V-.'*-/�*3i)?'P��':3l�=7�':9/3l5 2<�,+8�,2�;�2&$<���='*3)?>@)�':3���-/)*$&%/5���;�2&$<���='*3l�D�u4.3�2h^ H 9/$<3C�:�,�?;P9O>��,7;C2<$&���=':3l���@4/3C2<)J3|�u$<)�':)�T�SB2{�,-.)*)*3C% 3C'��,2�^&XeZ,[ [OZ(]':9/�='�;�2<�,)*)?$&�/3�)�':9/3��:�=%/5 3��,7��D�u4.3�2R;��,��!.2<3��.$}':$&3�)J�,;C;�� �?4/$<%.5�'*�D'*9/3�)*$&�l-.2{�='*3�4t)*!8�='*${�=2v)*;��,2<3C)Y�=%/4;�2&$&����':3|���*3C2<3|N,�=%('g!/�?�u;C3�)?)*3�)C^ H )�4/$<)?;�-/)?)*3C4r$&%ksu3�;|':$&� % - [.^ � ^ - �,7BSB98�,!.'*3�� - [�$&%�':9/3ULWQcS6S H I��T��o3�3�9.2c3|'F�=2�^&X�Z,[ [O\O]PXR':9/3C)*3�;�2<�,)*)?3�)i�,7��D�@4/3�2&)l�=�*3D2<$&)?'*3�4m�=)ls@$<�D!/2&3�SB2&$&����':3p�t�u4.3�2&)�T�s.S6�t)|]:Xba�,�?'*9u�M)�>@)?':3C���t�@4/3�2&)a�,7#LM%('*3��?��3C4/$<�=':3YSB� �D!/2&3|�u$&'M>xThb��oL�SB)|]PXu�,%/4 H '*���,)*!/9/3C�*3�����;�3��,%���3�%/3C�:�,2SB$&�*;�-.2{�='*$<�,%��t�u4.3�2&)�T H ���gS6�t)|]:^~��3�!#3�%/4/$&%/5��,%r':9/3p)*;`�=2<3��?3��(-/$&�*3C4��,�i':9.3p0,3|>w!/�?�u;C3�)?)*3�)F'*�+#3�$<%.;�2&-/4/3�4eXJ� %.3x;`�=%�;P9/�u�,)*3 �r�D�@4/3�2�7V�*� � � %.3x�,7�'*9/3�)?3 ;�2<�,)*)?3�)�7V� �p�r5 $}N 3�%�!.�*�=��3C;C'`^�G8� �3|�.�,�D!/2&3,X�':�r)*$&�l-/2<�=':3�'*9/3x7V-/2&2Y)?!8�='*${�,2�4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.':$&� %��,7�;C2<$&���=':3xN=�,�?${�=+/2<3C)~Th3=^f5.^<X6':3C�D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3=X!/�?3�;�$&!/$}'P�='*$<�,%vX � �6��$<%/4.)|]PX ':9.�*3�3��M4/$&�D3�%/)?$<�,%8�,2 H �g�gS6�t)J�,�*3g�*3C�(-/$<�?3�4v^B�69/3�)?3l�D�u4.3�2&)J4/$&)*;C�*3|':$&E�3':9.3g3��,�?'*9vd¡)Y�='*�D� )*!/9.3��*3=X �u;C3`�,%/)CX#�,%/4o2{�,%.4t$&%O':�p5,�*$&4o+#�`�u3�)J'*98�='�98�`N,3F�F'M>@!/$<;��,2�)*$&E�3i�,7Z � [U0@�¢ Z � [t0(��^�£r3p%/�,':3�':98��'F���,%O>r;C2<$&���=':3��?3�2&3CN=�,%O'U!/9.3�%/� �D3C%8��98�`N@$<%/5~)?!8�=':$<�,2c)*;��,2<3C)U)*���,2&2<3C�':9/�,%~Z � [�0(�¤TV$<%�!/�,�?'*$<;C-/2{�=��;�2&� -/4/)�]��@;�;�-.�J��$}':9/$&%�':9/�,)*3F5 �?$<4x+K�`�u3�)��=%/4 �,�?3F�,;C;�� -/%O'*3�4 7V� ��+(>¥.¦,§?¦,¨p©|ªW©|§�«&¬1¦,ªh«�­�®.¯ ^SB98�=%/5 $&%/5l':9.3J!8�=�:�,�D3C'*3��?$<E��=':$&� %/)B��$&2&2K;P98�=%/5 3J'*9/3Y)?-/+u��5 �*$&4/)*;��,2&3Y3C°K3�;|':)6�=%/4;`�=%x�=°K3�;|'�':9/3�2<�,�*5 3��M)?;`�,2&3����@4/3C2R� -.':!.-.'�)*-/+.)?'P�=%('*${�=2<2}> ^c£r3���$&2<2R�?3C':-.�*%�':�U':9/$&)�$<)?)*-/3g2{��':3��C^

��%p':9/3J�,':9.3��B3��@':�*3C�D3,X/$}7R� %/2}>D':9/3J5 2&� +8�,2 � ��9/3��D$&)*!/9/3C�*$&;��D3`�,%p'*3��D!#3��:��':-/�?3�)6�,�?3J�?3��(-/$&�*3C4vX��s/S6�±;��,%~+K3U�=% �,!/!/�?� !/�?${�='*3F�D�u4.3�2"7V� �J)*$&�l-/2<�='*$<� %.)g!.�*�1N@$<4/3C4~4/3C':�,$<2&)�� %�)?���,2<2&3���)?;`�,2&3�)�;��,%+#3�4/$&)*�*3C5O�,�?4/3�4v^ LM%w'*9/$&)F;`�,)?3,X!/�?�u;C3�)?)*3�)U)?���,2<2&3��F'*98�,%w9.3��D$<)?!/9/3C�*$&;o)?;`�,2&3�)D�=�*3p!/�,�:�,�D3|':3��?$<EC3�4Th3=^f5.^<Xa�,2&2c��$²�u$<%.5 !/�*�@;�3C)*)*3C)F��$&'*9/$&%³�=%/4w+#3C'M��3�3�%m'*9/3��='*���,)*!/9/3C�*3�� �i�u;C3`�,%.)|]�)?-/;P9��,)F$&)l4/�,%/37V� �D!/�?�u;C3�)*)?3�)p��$}':9.$<%��=% H ���iS6� 5 �*$&4u��+K�`�K^��69/3�)?3x�D�@4/3�2&)��,�?3t3��@':�*3C�D3�2}>�;C� �D!/-.'P��':$&� %8�,2&2&>3C´�;C$<3C%('��,%/4 �,�?3i��3�2&2_)?-/$}':3�4�7V�,��'*3�)?'*$<%.5�;�2&$<���='*3l!#� 2<$&;C>o)?;�3�%/�,�*$&� )Y��9/3C%~��7V-/2&2 H �g�gS6�µ$&)Y%/�='�*3C�(-/$<�?3�4v^��69/3o4/$&):�,4uN,�=%(':�,5 3t$<)D':98��'p���,%O>�!/�*�@;�3C)*)?3�)��,�?3t9.$<5 9.2&>¶!8�=�:�,�D3C'*3��?$<EC3�4��,%.4�)*�j0,3|>7V3�3C4/+8�,;P0()i+K3|'M�B3C3�%w;C2<$&���=':3�)*-/+@�M)?>@)�':3��D)F���`> %/�='i+#3��,4/3C�@-/�=':3C2&>k�*3C!/�*3C)*3C%('*3�4w$&%k)*$&�l-/2<�=':$&� %/)C^

Z

Page 3: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

G8� ��3|�.�,�D!/2&3,XK'*9/3l)?� 2&-/+/$&2<$}'M>x�=7;`�,�?+K�,%x4/$&�`�.$&4/3F$&%x)?3`��������':3��Y$<)J9/$<5,9/2&>�'*3��D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3i4/3�!#3�%.4/3�%O'�,%/4¶)?�k9.3��D$<)?!/9/3C�*$&;x�D3`�,%m'*3��D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3C)���� -/2&4�%/�,'D4/$&)?'*$<%/5,-/$<)?9³+#3C'M��3�3C%�!#� 2<�,�D�,%/4m':�?� !/$&;`�,2�*3C5 $&� %/)p��9/3C�*3x'*3��D!#3��:��':-/�?3�)�4/3|':3��?�D$<%/3�'*9/3ty/-u� �=7iS6�gZk$<%O':�w'*9/3x�@;�3��,%v^ £�9.3�% ':9.3�!K�,2{�,��B�,�*�D$&%/5w$&)�Z�� � '*$<�D3�)�)?'*�*� %/5,3���'*98�,%�':9/3�':�?� !/$&;`�,2����=�*�D$<%.5/X�':9/$&)�!K� 2<�,���,�D!/2&$&�8;��=':$&� %���� -/2&4%/3C3�4t'*�D+K3�!8�,�*�,�D3C'*3��*$&E�3C4x$&%x�=%xs.S6�j^

�69/$&)J!/�?3CN@$&� -/)�3|�.�,�D!/2&3i9.$<5 9.2<$&5 9O':)6':9.3�%/3�3C4o7V� ��'*9/3�':9.$<�?4o;C2{�=)*)��,7�;�2&$<���='*3g�D�@4/3�2&)�X bc�tL�SB)C^bc�tL�SB)�98�`N 3U+#3�3C% 4/3CN,3�2&� !#3�4 ':��3��.!.2<� �?3F�*3C)*3��,�*;P9~�(-/3�)�':$&� %/)���9/3C�*3�s/S6�o)��,�*3g':�@��)*$&�D!/2<3D�=%/4H ���iS6�o)p�,�?3�':�@�~;�� �D!/-.':�=':$&� %8�=2<2}>m$&%/3C´�;�$&3�%O'�^��a>u!.$<;��,2<2}> X�b��oL�SB)�98�`N,3t9/$&5 9�2{��':$}':-/4/3��?3�)*���2&-.':$&� %³'*�r�?3�)*�,2&N,3x':9/3�':�?� !/$&;`�,26'*�r!#� 2{�=�D'*3��D!#3��:��':-/�?3x;P98�,%.5 3�)�+.-.'p�,%/2&>¶)?$<�D!/2&$}�83�4�2&� %/5 $}':-.4/3�*3C!/�*3C)*3C%(':�=':$&� %��=7"':9.3g2<�,%/4x�,%/4o�u;C3`�,%o4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.':$&� %/)C^��69/$&)Y$&%O':3��?�D3�4/$<�=':3i)*!8��':$<�,2R�*3C)*� 2&-.':$&� %t+K3��'M��3�3�%�s.S6�t)U�,%/4 H �g�gS6�t)i!/�*�1N@$<4.3�)U�o���,�*3p;C� �D!/-.':�=':$&� %8�,2&2}>j3|´�;�$&3�%O'D%(-/�D3��*$&;`�=2B)?'*�*-/;|':-/�?37V� �6)?$<�i-/2{��':$&%/5�'*9/3�;�2&$<���='*3g)�>@)?':3C��^�LM%�':9/$&)�!8�,!#3��CX/�B3g-/)*3g�,%obc�tL�S '*98�='�$&%/;�2&-/4/3C)J!8�=�:�,�D3C'*3��W�$&E`�='*$<� %.)F$<4.3�%O':$&;`�,2c':�o':9/� )?3�$&% H ���iS6�t)i��9/$<2&3�� %.2&>k)*$&�l-.2{�='*$<%.5�':9/3�EC� %8�,2²�M�D3��,%w)?':�=':3��,76':9.3;�2&$&����':3�� %t�D2<�='*$&'*-/4/3|��9/3�$&5 9O'J5 �*$&4v^c�t� �?3�4/3C':�,$<2&)���$<2&2R+K3�4/3C)*;C�*$&+K3C4x$&%�su3C;C'*$<� %xZu^

SB� �D�D� %g'*���,2<2=':9/3C)*3a;�2&$<���='*3a���@4/3C2<)��,�?3!/�*�,!K3C�?':$&3�)R'*98�='�4/3|':3��?�D$<%/3a':9.32{�,�?5 3|��)*;��,2<3a�?3�)*!#� %/)?3':�U;C2<$&���=':3J7V� �*;C$<%/5,)gTh3,^¡5/^&X.$&%/;��?3`�,)?$<%.5�;C� %/;C3�%O':�*�=':$&� %/)��,7�5 �?3�3C%/9/� -/)?3�5O�,)*3C)|]:^c�69.3�)*3��=�*3Y'M>@!/$&;`�,2&2}>;P98�,�*�,;C'*3��?$<EC3�4p+O>i'M�B�g!/�*�,!K3C�?':$&3�)��SB2&$<���='*3�)*3�%.)*$}':$}Nu$}'M>��,%/4U'*9/36�:�='*36�,7#9/3`��'a-/!.'P�=0,3�+O>l':9.364/3�3C!u��@;�3`�=%v^mSB2&$<���='*3�)*3�%.)*$}':$}Nu$}'M>�$<)U4.3C�8%/3C4��=)D'*9/3 ©����@«�²«��§|«�@¨ 5 2&� +8�,2²�M�D3`�=%³�=%/%(-8�,2²�M�D3`�,%¶)?-/�?7h�,;C3':3C�D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3U;P98�=%/5 3F$&% �*3C)*!#� %/)*3U'*����4/� -/+.2<$&%/5��,7�S6��Zp;��,%/;�3C%('*�:�='*$<�,%j�=%/4 $<)Y4/3�%/�=':3�4~+O> ��^�69/$&)�$&)U':9/3�'*3��D!#3��:��':-/�?3t�?3�)*!#� %/)?3x��7 ':3��D�=2<2B'*�:�,%.)*$&3�%O'p!.�*�@;�3�)?)*3C)�;C� �D3o$&%O':�k+8�,2<�,%/;C3,XB)?-/;P9 �=)�@;�3`�=%��,%/4�2<�,%/4p)?-/�?7h�=;�3,^�69.3J�*�=':3��,7v9.3`�='�-/!.':�,0,3�+O>�'*9/3�4/3�3C!u�M�@;�3��,%p$&)c'*9/3�;�� %O':�?� 2&2<$&%/5l!.�*�@;�3�)?)':9/�='D2<$&�D$&'*)F':9/3��*�=':3��=7Y)?-/�?7h�,;C3����=�*�D$<%.5r�,)U$}'��,!/!.�*�O�,;P9.3�)D3��(-/$&2<$&+/�?$<-/��^m�69/$&)D$<)U4.3C':3C�*�D$&%/3�4+O>o�,2&2R!/�*�@;�3C)*)*3C)J'*98�='��D$}�o3��.;C3�)?)Y9/3��='J7V�?� � '*9/3g)*-/��7h�,;�3g�u;C3`�,%o$&%('*��'*9/3g4/3�3C!K3C�J2<�`> 3��?)��,%.4t;��,%+#3�;P98�,�*�,;C'*3��*$&E�3C4¶+(>w�,%m3C°K3�;|':$}N 3�4/$}°K-/)*$&� %¶;��@3C´�;�$&3�%O'D4/3C%/�,'*3�4¶+O>����F^ ��� 5 3|':9/3C��X�':9.3�)*3�'M���!/�?� !K3C�?'*$<3C)�4/3C'*3��*�D$&%/3F':9.3l':�*�,%/)*$&3�%O'��?3�)*!#� %/)?3U�,7':9.3F;�2&$<���='*3U)?>@)?'*3�� ':��;P98�,%.5 3�)�$&%�2<�,�*5 3��M)?;`�,2&3�:�=4/${��':$}N 3�7V� �*;C$<%.5 )�^

��3�!#3�%/4.$<%/5�� %t'*9/3g;�2&$<���='*3l�D�u4.3�2�+K3C$<%.5�-/)?3�4vX#':9/3C)*3g'M�B��!/�*� !#3���':$&3�)�;`�,%t3�$}':9/3C�Y+#3i4.$<�?3�;C'*2&>)*3|'YN@$<��!8�,�*�,�D3C'*3��*)J$<%t':9/3g�D�u4/3C2_�,��+#3l3C)?'*$<���='*3�4x7V�?� � )*$&�l-/2<�='*$<� %.)�-/)*$&%/5p'*9/3�7V-/2<2�)?>@)�':3���^�LM%':9.3�2{�='?':3C�F;`�,)?3,X':9.3�;�� �i+/$<%/�=':$&� %¶�,7�4/$}°e3C�*3�%O'D!8�=�:�,�D3C'*3��?$<E��=':$&� %/)tT��=%/4w':9/3C$<�l$<%O':3C�*%8�=26!8�,�:�=�U�3C'*3���)*3|'*'*$<%/5,)|]Y-/2&'*$<���='*3�2}>k4/3C'*3��*�D$&%/3�)g':9/3C)*3�;�2&$<���='*3�)�>@)?':3C� !/�*�,!K3C�?':$&3�)i�,%/4k)*��':9.3�4.>@%8�=��$&;`�=2�*3C)*!#� %/)?3F�,7�'*9/3i�D�@4/3�2�;`�=%/%/�,'Y+K3g3�)�':$&����':3�4 ¦i¥#§�«�­�§�« ^�LM%t':9.$<)J;`�,)?3,XK'*9/3��?3l���`>o+K3i���=%(>o;C� �F�+/$&%8�='*$<� %.)J�,7"!8�,�*�,�D3C':3C�*)�':98�='�2&3`�,4o':�D':9/3g):�=��3g;�2&$&����':3l)�>@)?':3C��!/�*� !#3���':$&3�)Y�,%/4o)*���U':9.� �*� -.5 9)*3��,�*;P9x�,7�':9.3i!8�=�:�,�D3C'*3��J)*!8�,;C3i��� -/2&4�+#3i�?3��(-/$&�*3�4t7V� �J;��,2&$<+/�*�=':$&� %t!/-/�*!#� )?3�)�^�LM%o':9/$&)Y!8�=!K3C����3;��,%/)*$&4/3��i�,%jbc�tL�SA;�2&$&����':3D�D�u4/3C27V� ����9/$&;P9j':9.3�;C2<$&���=':3�)?>@)�':3�� !.�*� !#3���':$&3�)g;`�,%k+K3��,4���-/)?'*3�4N@${�D)*$&%/5 2&3�!8�,�*�,�D3C':3C�*)C^��69/$&)���$<2&2R+K3�4/$&)*;C-/)*)?3�4�$&%xsu3�;|':$&� %�Z@^

H %��,4.4/$&'*$<�,%8�,2#�*3��(-/$&�*3C�D3�%O'�$<)�':�F$&%/;�2&-/4/3J':9/3�-.%/;�3C�?'P�=$<%O'M>�$&%p'*9/3�3|�@'*3��*%/�,2e�*�,4/$<�=':$}N 3Y7V�,�*;�$&%/5/^G8� �B'*9/3�;`�,2&$&+/�:�='*$<�,%o�=7"�F;C2<$&���=':3��D�@4/3�2e'*�F':9/3��,+/)*3C�?N 3C4t'*3��D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3��?3�;��,�*4vX.��3��l-/)�'�$<%/;C2<-.4/3':9.3�-/%/;�3C�?':�,$<%O'M>m$&%w':9.3�7V� �*;C$<%/5 �1N,3��F':9.3�):�,�D3�'*$<�D3�!#3��*$&�@4v^~�69/$<)U7V� �?;�$&%/5 -/%/;C3���'P�,$&%O'M>¶�,�*$&)*3C)���,$&%/2&>�7V�?� � ':9.3j!#�u�,�o0(%/�1��2&3�4/5,3w�,7l'*9/3k9/$<)�':� �?$<;��,2��*3C;�� �?4 7V� �t�,3��?� )*�,2<)C^ H 3C�*� )?� 2<)x�,�*3~':9.3)*-.)*!#3�%/4/3C4w!8�,��':$&;�-/2<�='*3����='?':3���$&%k'*9/3��=':�D� )?!/9/3C�*3D':98�='g98�`N,3p��)*9.� �?'i2<$}7V3|��':$&�D3xTh�,!/!/�?�`�e^�48�`>@)':�U�D� %O'*9/)|]B�,%/4�;��,%��*3|y83�;|'�� �6�,+/)?� �*+�)?� 2{�=���,%/4�$&%.7V�:�,�?3�4��:�=4/${��':$&� %kTh)?3�3gG8� �*)�':3��B3C'��,2h^RT�Z,[ [O\(]:^}]H �?3�;��,�*4 �,7'*9/3F;��,%/;�3C%('*�:�='*$<�,%/)�7V� ���=3��*�,)*� 2&)�4/�@3�)�%.�,'�3|�u$&)?'�TV-/%/2&$<0=3D5 �*3C3�%/9/�,-/)*3U5O�=)*3�)�]��,%/4 )?���3i�?3�2}>�� %�':9/3�3��D$&)*)?$<� %.)Y�*3C;�� �?4o7V�,��':9/3�N=�,�*$&� -/)�)?!K3C;�$&3�)J'*�D3�)?'*$<���='*3g'*9/3��:�,4.${�='*$&N,3g7V�,�*;�$&%/5/^ H ))*-.;P9¶��3��?3C7V3��g':�x'*9/3p-.%/;�3C�?'P�=$<%O'M>m$&%r':9.3p%/3|'D�,%O':9/�?� !#� 5 3�%.$<;��=3��*�,)*� 2a7V� �*;C$<%.5/X"���*$}'*'*3�%m9/3C�*3��=)

Page 4: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

��������^p�69/$&)i!.�*$&���=�*$&2&>~�?3�!/�?3�)*3C%O':)l'*9/3�-.%/;�3C�?'P�=$<%O'M>k$<%r�,2&2a�,3��?� )*� 2&)g+/-.'i�,2&)*�o;`�,%j�*3�!.�*3�)?3�%O'U�=%(>-/%/�D�@4/3�2&3�4�3��u'*3��?%8�,2K7V�,�*;�$&%/5 )C^�_�,5 3C'*9/3��B��$}':9 � �=%/4 ���UXu'*9/3�)?3��,�?3J':9.�*3�3Y!8�,�:�=��3|':3C�*)�':9/�='�;��,%+#3F;`�,2&$&+/�:�='*3�4k�,5O�=$<%/)�'�':9.3U9/$<)�':� �?$<;��,2��?3�;��,�*4 �,7c� +/)?3���N 3�4~':3C�D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3C)�^ H )��,2&2<-.4/3�4 ':��+#3C7V�,�*3,X� -/�Y5 �O�,2_$<)�'*�o!.�*�1N@$<4/3D��7V-/2&2"�(-8�=%('*$&�/;`�='*$<� %k�,7a':9.3U!/�*� +/�,+/$&2<$&)?'*$<;D-/%/;C3���'P�,$&%O':$&3�)�7V� �Y'*9/3�)?3D'*9/�*3C3!8�,�*�,�D3C'*3��*)-.)*$&%/5�� -.'*!/-.'�7V�?� � ':9/3��oLM� Z,� ;C2<$&���=':3B���@4/3C2RT�s@� 0,� 2&�1NU�,%.4�s@':� %.3�T -1q,q � �@]��=G8� �?3�)�'3C'J�,2h^�T�Z,[ [@]?]YT��tLM��Z=��S6�~]PX89/$&)?'*� �*$&;`�=2��?3�;C� �*4/)CX#�iS6� )*$&�l-.2{�='*$<�,%/)Y�=%/4t3��u!K3C�?'a��-/4/5 �D3�%O'�^

�69/3l�tLM��Z,��S6��!.�*�1N@$<4/3C)Y)?$<�i-/2{��':$&� %/)Y�=7��@;�3`�=%vX8)*-/��7h�,;�3i�,%/4o-/!/!#3��J�='*���,)*!/9/3C�*$&;g'*3��D!#3��:���':-.�*3l+#3�9/�1N@$&� ��^J�69/3F�D�@4/3�2�-/)*3C)��p)�>u)�':3C���,7a2<�='*$&'*-/4/3F�=%/4�9/3C$<5 9O'�;C�u�,�*4/$&%8�='*3�)J'*�p)?$<�i-/2{��':3F':9.3�`N 3C�:�,5 3D)�'P�='*3��=7c'*9/3D;�2&$<���='*3D��N,3���E��,%/3�)�4/3|�8%/3�4j+O> 2{��':$}':-/4/3U+/�,%/4/)C^D��3C'P�=$<2&)��,7a':9/3D)?'*�*-/;|':-/�?3�,7�'*9/3p�D�@4/3�2��,�?3�!/�?3�)?3�%O':3C4�$&%ms@3�;C'*$<�,%�Zu^��69/3��tLM��Z=��S6� �1N,3��*�,5 3�)i�1N 3��l2<� %.5 $&'*-/4/3=X�+/-.'i$&'*)� -.'*!/-.'D���='*;P9/3�)D;�2&$&����':3�� +/)?3���N,��':$&� %/)D�,%/4¶!/�?�u4.-/;�3C)U)*$&��$&2<�,�D!/�*3C4/$<;|':$&� %/)��,)l'*9/� )?3��,7�7V-/2<2 � ��='*���,)*!/9/3C�*3��M�@;�3`�=% 5 3�%/3C�:�,2�;�$&�*;C-/2<�=':$&� %��D�@4/3�2&)DT��gS6�~]:^#�69.3F;�� �D!/-u':3��Y3C°K� �?'J$<%ON,� 2&N,3�4~$&%��*-/%@�%/$&%/5�':9.3��tLM��Z,��S6� $&)�J7V�*�,;C'*$<� %U�=78':98�='"�,7#�J7V-/2&2 � � ���@4/3C2�^�su�/X $}'$&)��*3C2{�='*$&N,3�2}>F3��,)?>i':��3��.!.2<� �?34/$}°e3C�*3C%('�N=�,2&-/3�)�7V�,�Y':9/3U;C2<$&���=':3D)�>u)�':3C� !/�*�,!K3C�?':$&3�)CXR':98�='��,�*3U�?3�!/�?3�)*3C%O':3�4j+O>�2&���A4/$&�D3�%/)?$<� %/�,2!8�,�*�,�D3C'*3��*)C^

�c>@!/$&;`�=2J� -u':!/-.'D7V�?� � �~�*-/%��,7�':9/3x�tLM��Z,��S6� ;�� %/)?$<)�':)��,7J'*3��D!#3��:��':-/�?3�)���'D��k4.$&°K3��?3�%O'2<�=':$}':-/4.3�)�XK��$&'*9 - - N 3C�?':$&;`�=2�2{�`>,3��*)�7V�,�J':9.3 -1� [�� -1q q � !#3��?$<�@4vXv3|N 3���> � [���$&%(-.':3C)�^gLM%�':9/$&)�!8�=!K3C���3U;�� %/)?$<4.3���':9/�?3�3U)?-/�D���=�*$&3�)g�,7c)*-/;P9k� -.'*!/-.'�'*98�='���3D�*3C7V3C��':���,) �?4/$<�,5 %/� )�':$&;�)�� � H N 3C;C'*� ���,7Z � � ;C� �D!K�,%/3�%O':)CX(;�� %/)?$<)�':$&%/5g�,7 ':9/36-/!.!K3C�a�,$<�_':3��D!#3��*�=':-/�?36;P98�,%/5,3�)a+K3|'M�B3C3�%�':9/3 -1q,� �� -`q qO� �=%/4-1q - � -1q,� [�!K3C�*$&�u4.)B�=' � �2<�=':$}':-.4/3�)B�,%/4 � 2&3CN,3�2&)�� su-.�?7h�,;C3�'*3��D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3�;P98�,%.5 3,X@;�� %.)*$&)?':$&%/5F�=7e':9.34/$}°e3C�*3C%/;�3g+K3|'M�B3C3�%x'*9/3g4/3�;��,48�,2��`N 3C�:�,5,3g'*3��D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3C)�7V�,� -1q ���� -1q qO� !#3��?$<�@4/)��,%/4�':9.3i�`N,3��:�=5 3':3C�D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3��,7 -1q [��� -1q,qO� �='a��4/$}°K3��*3C%O'B3C�@-/�,2}�M�,�*3���E�� %8�=2/+8�,%/4.)�X(�*3C)*-/2}':$&%/5g$<%��gZ,[�4/$&�D3�%/)?$<� %/�,2N 3C;C'*� ���"�,%/4~4/3�3C!j�@;�3��,% ':3C��!#3��*�=':-.�*3U':�?3�%/4vX�;��,2<;C-/2<�=':3C4k7V� ��'*9/3 -1qO� Z�� -1q,qO� !#3��*$&�@4v^��J$&)?'*� �*$&;`�=2� +/)?3���N,��':$&� %/)��,%/4x�iS6� � -u':!/-.'J�,�?3�� +.':�,$<%.3�4o$<%o;�� �?�*3C)*!#� %/4/3C%/;�3�':�U':9.3�'*9/�*3C3�4/${�=5 %/� )�':$&;�)�^a£j3%/�,'*$<;C3�':98��'�$<%o�,2&2e':9.�*3�3�;��,)*3C)6�B3g�`N � $&4o-/)*$&%/5��,+/)?� 2<-u':3�':3C��!#3��*�=':-.�*3�N=�,2&-/3�)��,%/4�;C� %/)*$&4/3C��)?� �D3�D3`�,)?-/�*3J�,7e'*3��D!#3��:��':-/�?3Y;P98�,%.5 3,^�69/$&)B$&)���;��,���D� %p!/�:�,;|':$&;�3J�,�D� %/5i;�2&$<���='*� 2<�,5 $<)�':)c':�i�,;�;C� -/%O'7V� ��)?>@)?'*3����=':$&;�+/$<�,)*3C)6$<%�'*9/3Y�D�@4/3�2K� -.'*!/-.'`^cs@3�3�3���3�+/�,2<4.$v�,%/4�s.�,%/)���oT�Z,[ [ \(]"7V�,���,%�$&2&2<-/)�':�*�=':$&� %�,7�':9/$&)67h�,;C'*)�^

G"$&5 -/�*3 - )*9/�1��)�)?-/�D���,�*$&3�)��,7�'*9/3l'*9/�*3C3F4/$<�,5 %/� )�':$&;�)��,+.'P�,$&%/3C4�7V�*� � ':9.3D�tLM��Z,��S6�±)?$<�i-u�2<�=':$&� %/)�!#3���7V� �*�D3�4~� %k�p'*9/�*3C3�4.$<�D3�%.)*$&� %8�,25 �?$<4~�,7c�(Z��!K� $&%O':)�7V� ������T�� ������������������]P^FG8� �;��,��!/�,�*$&)*� %t!/-/�?!K� )?3�)��B3g)*-.!K3C�*$&��!#� )?3l3`�=;P9x4/$<�,5 %/�,)?':$&;,X ;��,2<;C-/2<�=':3C4t7V�*�,� 9/$&)?'*� �*$&;`�,2��?3�;��,�*4/)CX '*�':9.3��D�@4/3�2a�*3C)*-/2}':)C^�LM%r3�)?)*3C%/;�3��,-/�i!.�*� +/2&3�� $&)�':�t�/%/4j'*9/3�N=�,2&-/3C)l�,7 �¶':9/�='l���,0=3�'*9/3p�D�@4/3�2� -.'*!/-.'��,)�)?$<�D$&2{�=��':�g':9/3J9/$&)?':�,�*$&;`�,2#�*3C;�� �?4/)��,)�!K�,)*)*$&+/2&3,^��t� �?3Y!/�?3�;C$<)?3�2}> X.7V� ���i5,$&N,3�%�4/$<�,5 %.� )?'*$<;=X4/3C%/�,':3"!t':9/3Y� +/)*3C�?N=�='*$<� %��=%/4$#�T%��]"'*9/3�� -u':!/-.'B�,7R':9.3Y�D�u4.3�2K7V�,�B�l5,$&N,3�%&�_^ H 2<$&0,3C2<$&9/�@�u4�7V� �'�$&)��,+.'P�,$&%/3C4t+O>��,)?)*-/�D$&%/5D':98�='6'*9/3�4/$}°e3C�*3�%.;�3g$<)J���,-/)*)?${�=%v^)(J)*$&%/5�!/�*$&� �6$&%.7V� �?����':$&� %�� %�':9/3�;�2&$²����=':3�!/�?� !K3C�?'*$<3C)B7V�*� �A':9/3J2<$}':3C�:�='*-/�*3=Xu��3Y� +.':�,$&%��i!#� )�':3��?$<�,�c7V� �*�_^+(�%.7V� ��':-/%8��':3�2}> Xu� -.'*!/-.'c7V�*� �':9.3l�oLM��Z,��S6�z$&)��`N,�=$<2<�,+/2&3�� %/2}>��='��F7V3C� 9(-/%/4/�?3�4/)J!/�*3��M)?!K3C;�$}�83�4t!K� $&%O':)6� %t�,%�$&�*�*3C5 -/2<�,�65 �?$<4v^H 2&)*�.XK�?-/%/%/$&%/5��,%.4x!#� )?'��M!/�?�u;C3�)*)?$<%.5�':$&��3C)Y%/3C3�4/3C4�':��;`�,2&;�-/2<�='*3�#�T%��]�!/�*3|N 3�%O'*)�-/)J7V�?� � 3��i+K3C4u�4/$&%/5g$&'*)c3|N=�,2<-/�=':$&� %D��$&'*9/$<%p�,%�$&'*3��:��':$}N 3���3|':9/�@4v^as@�/XO':��7V-/2&2&>D3��.!.2<� �?3�'*9/3�!K�,)?':3C�*$&� �a4/$&)?':�?$<+.-.':$&� %�,7+�~��3l;��?3`�='*3F�,%t�,-u�u$&2<$<�,��>t)�'P�='*$<)�':$&;`�,2��D�u4.3�2R':98��'J!.�*�1N@$<4/3C)��,%x�,!/!/�?�1�u$&���=':$&� %t'*�,#�^BG8� �6':9/$&)!/-/�?!K�,)*3Y��3�-/)?3��U���,-/)*)?${�=%�!/�*�@;�3C)*)�^a�69/$&)�$&)_��-/)�':$}�83�4vXu7V�*� � �.-B�1>,3�)?${�,%�N@$&3C��!#� $<%O'�X/+O>p':9.3J7h�,;|'':9/�='�7V� ����5 $&N,3�%��w'*9/3UN=�,2<-.3��=7'#�$<)�-/%.0@%.����%eX_)?�o��3����`> ;C� %/)*$&4/3C�i$}'i�,)g���*�,%/4/�,� !/�*�@;�3C)*)C^�69/3J)*3C'?':$&%/5F�,7e� -/�c!/�*�,+/2<3C� $<)a':98��'B�,7e;`�,2&$&+/�:�='*$<�,%p�,7R;C� �D!/-.'*3��B�D�@4/3�2 !8�=�:�,�D3C'*3��?)��,)c4/3�)?;��?$<+#3�4$&%0/�3C%/%/3�4u>~�,%/4j�Fd1�J�,5O�,%�T�Z,[ [ - ]P^g�69/3F7V�u;C-/)�$&)�%/�,'�� %~!/�?3�4/$&;C'*$<� %~� ��4/�='P���,)?)*$&�D$<2<�=':$&� %vX�+/-u'

Page 5: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

0 100 200 300 400

0.000

0.001

0.002

0.003

0.004

Model run index

Degree

s Cent

igrades

/Year

*****

*

****

*

*****

*

**

*

**

*********

*

****

**

****

*

*

*

*** **

*******

*

****

**

**

**

*

*

*

***

*

**

**

*

******

******

***

**

*********

*****

**

**

***

**

********

****

*

**

** **

*

*

**

******

****

*

*******

*

**

****

*

*

**

*******

*

***********

*

*

*

*************

**

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

****

*

*

*

*

*

**

*******

*

*

**

*

*

***

*****

*

*

*

*

*

**

*

**

*

**

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

**

*

*

*

*

****

*

*

**

*

*

*

*

*

*

**

**

*

*

**

*

*

*

**

*

*

**

*

**

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

***

*

**

−0.5

0.00.5

1.01.5

latitude

Degree

s Celci

us

48.6

14.5

−14.5

−48.6 48.6

14.5

−14.5

−48.6 48.6

14.5

−14.5

−48.6 48.6

14.5

−14.5

−48.6 48.6

14.5

−14.5

−48.6

X

X

X X

XX

X

X XX X

XX X

X

XX

X XX

−1.5

−1.0

−0.5

0.00.5

1.01.5

2.0

pressure

Degree

s Celci

us

50 100 150 200 300 500 700 850

X

XX

X

X

X

X

XX

XX

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

XX

XXX

X

XX

XX

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

XX

X

XXX

XXX

X

XX

X

X

XX

X

X

XXX

X

X

X

XXX

X

X

X

XXX

X

X

X

X

X

X

XX

X

X

X

X

XXX

X

X

X

X

XXXXX

XXXX

X

X

X

X

XX

XX

X

X

X

X

XXX

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

XX

XX

XX

X

XX

X

X

X

XX

X

XX

X

X

XX

X

XX

X

XXXX

XXX

X

XXXX

XX

XXXX

X

X

XX

XX

XXXX

X

XXX

XXXX

XXXX

XXXX

X

XX

X

XXXX

X

X

X

XX

XX

X

XX

XXX

XXXXXX

X

X

G"$&5 -/�?3 - � �SoKt³¶W­�j%jat2oZ��ja}Ky+lxj�hktXj%un}Nln�Zunj�lxunj�yvp�rWp�qs}N�EyZoKrwlwqs�N�k�BmZj�q|yvpvj�§+��ofuwuwjarwtXoEyvp+lxo�lnmZj�oE�vlwte�Zl�¢ofu\lnmZj��E¬���peq»ºXj%uwj�yEl���oEh���q|yv}Nlwq�oEy�r\of��lnmZj~�%�sq|hk}Nlxj{t�}Nun}Kh�j%lxj%u�r%�k�BmZj~mZofu�q ´ oEyKlw}f���sq|yZj~��ofuwuwjarntLoEy�p�r&lxolnmZj�oK��rwj%uw�Ù}Nlwq�oEy³��±�j�yElxj%ua¶��v�vuw�¢}f��j�lxj�h~tLj%u�}Nln�Zuwj�p�qs}N�EyZoKrxlwqs�N���BmZj��Xoa§vt���oflwr\��ofunuwjarwtXoEyvpzlxo�lnmZj~h�oZpvja�oE�Zlwte�vl��¢ofu\lnmZj�¤e�fjkpvja�%}fpvjar\}Kyvp2�ÂoE�Zu\�s}Nlwq�ln��pvj~��}Kyvper%���Bmvjk��uwoKrwrxjar\��ofunuwjarwtXoEyvp+lxo�lnmZj�oK��rwj%uw�Ù}Nlwq�oEy�r%���oflxlxoEh�¶���t�tXj%u*}fq�u8lxj�hktXj%un}Nln�Zuwj&p�qs}N�EyZoKrwlwqs�%r%��BmZj&�Xoa§vt���oflwr8��ofuwuwjarntLoEy�p{lxo�lnmZj\hko�pvja�LoE�Zlwte�vl��¢ofu8lnmZjp�q»º�j%uwj�yElB�s}Nlwq�ln�vpvjar�}Kyvp-tvuwjarnrn�ZuwjW��}Kyvper%���BmZjWoK��rxj%un�Ù}Nlwq�oEyvr�}Nuwj�h~}Nuw¡fjap!�Bq�lnm-��unoKrwrxjar%�

Page 6: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

� %w$&%.7V3C�*3�%.;�3�7V� �g':9/3�!/�,�:�,�D3|':3��?)l':9/�='F;C� %O':�*�,2c'*9/3�;��,��!.-.':3C�F�D�u4/3C2��,%.4w':98�='l98�`N 3��t!/�*3C;�$&)*3!/9O>@)*$&;`�,2_�D3`�,%/$&%/5/^JG8� �6'M�B�p�,7�':9.3l4/$<�,5 %/�,)?':$&;�)�':9/3i� -.'*!/-.'J$<)J�l-/2}':$}N=�,�*$<�=':3=^�s@��':9.3l;`�=2<$&+/�:��':$&� %!/�?�u;C3�4/-/�?3F98�,)�':��$<%/;C� �*!#� �*�=':3i$<%.7V�,�*���=':$&� %x�,+K�,-.'���;��1N=�,�*$<�,%/;C3F���=':�?$}�K^�£r3i-/)*3U�iS6�µ�,-.':!/-u'':�D3C2<$&;�$}'��U!/�?$<�,�64/$<)�':�?$<+/-u':$&� %t7V� �6)?-/;P9x���='*�*$&;�3C)�^

LM%�':9/3g7V� 2&2<�1��$&%/5�)*3C;C'*$<� %���3F!/�?�1Nu$&4/3l'*9/3F)?;�$&3�%O':$}�8;U+8�,;P0(5 �?� -/%/4�7V�,��'*9/3D�tLM��Z,��S6�±�,-.':!/-u'':9/�='R�B3a-/)?3$<%�':9.$<)R!8�=!K3C��^"��-.�R)?'P��':$&)?':$&;`�=2(�,%8�,2}>@)*$&)�+.-/$<2&4/)�� %�!/�?3CN@$<�,-/)R�B� �?0��,$&�D3�4i�='R3�)�':$&���=':$&%/5':9.3i!#� )?'*3��?$<� �J4/$&)?':�?$<+.-.':$&� %/)J�,7;�2&$&����':3l)�>@)?':3C��!.�*� !#3���':$&3�)�^��69/$&)Y$&)Y$&)�4/3�)?;��*$&+#3�4 $&% su3C;C':$&� %~Z@^f�/^�69/3�)?':�=':$&)?'*$<;��,2v�D�@4/3�2v��3�;�� %.)*$&4/3���$<%�'*9/$<)���� �?0��,!/!/2&$&3�)6':9/3��D3|':9/�@4/)6!/�?� !K�,)*3�4o$&%xsu�,%/) ��D3|'��,2�^T�Z=[ [O\(]:Xe��9/$&;P9r�,�?3U4/3�)?;��?$<+#3�4k$<%jsu3C;C'*$<� % � ^ H )�7V� ���D� )�'g;`�,2&$<+.�:�='*$<� % !.�*� +/2&3��D)CX���3U3|�u!#3�;C'g':9.3!/�?$<� ��$&%.7V� �?����':$&� %x� % �~'*��+#3�;��?-/;�$<�,2�7V� �6':9/3�3�)�':$&���=':$&� %��,7_':9/3g;�2&$&����':3g)?>@)?'*3���!/�*�,!K3C�?':$&3�)C^6LM%':9.$<)�!8�,!#3�����3J7V�@;�-.)B� %�':9/3J3�)?'*$<���='*$<%.5l':9/3�':9/3Y�,�D� -/%O'��=7R$<%u7V� �*���='*$<� %�':98��'B$&)B!/�?�1Nu$&4/3C4�+(>�':9.348�=':�.^�£r3l4/��)*��+O>��(-8�=%('*$&7 >@$&%/5�':9/3F�1N,3��*2<�,!~+#3C'M��3�3�%k!/�?$<� ���,%/4 !#� )?'*3��*$&� ��4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.'*$<� %.)�-/)*$&%/5-B98��'*'P�=;P98�,�?>(> ��4/$&)?':�,%/;C3�)�X8��9/$&;P9��=�*3�4/3|�8%/3�4o$&%xs@3�;C'*$<�,% � ^nZu^c��-/�6�?3�)*-.2&'*)�7V�,�63`�,;P9��,7�':9/3�'*9/�*3C34/$<�,5 %/�,)?':$&;�)J�,�?3�!/�*3C)*3�%O'*3�4�$&%�s@3�;C'*$<�,%t�/^���-/�6;C� %/;�2&-/)?$<� %.)��,�?3�!/�*3C)*3�%O'*3�4�$&%o'*9/3�2{�=)?'�)*3C;C':$&� %v^

� ���J�����������k����l�� ���a��� �

�69/3�4.3�)*;C�*$&!.':$&� %��,7e':9/3J5 3�%/3C�:�='*$<�,%��,7R':9.3��tLM��Z,� 4/�='P��7V� 2<2&�1��)��l)?3��?$<3C)��,7R!8�=!K3C�*)�^�69.3�;�2&$<���='*3�D�u4.3�2B�B�,)D$<%.$&'*${�,2&2}>m4/3�)?;��?$<+#3�4³$<%³su� 0=� 2&��Nm�,%/4�s@':� %.3kT -1q q,� �@]���$}':9��,%¶-/!#48�='*3�'*��':9/3��@;�3��,%�D�u4.3�2Y4.3�)*;C�*$&+K3C4 $&%�G8� �*3C)?'�3|'��,2h^�T�Z,[ [@]:^ �69/3 4/3C)*;��?$<!u':$&� %��,7�':9/3x7V�,�*;�$&%/5 )��,!/!/2&$<3C4�7V� �p':9.3-1� ,[�� -1q,qO� !#3��*$&�@4k$&)�5 $}N 3C%j$&%k'*9/3U)*-.!/!/2&3��D3�%O'P�=2c���='*3��?${�,2�7V�?� ��G �,�*3�)�'�3C'i�,2h^T�Z,[ [@]:^.��3��*3U��3!/�?��N@$&4/3J��+.�*$&3C7v4.3�)*;C�*$&!.':$&� %��,7e'*9/3����@4/3C2�XO':9.3�9.$<)�':� �?$<;��,2/7V� �*;C$<%.5 )�XO':9.3�3��u!K3C�*$&��3C%O'P�,2#4/3�)?$<5,%vX.�=%/4��4/$&)*;�-.)*)*$&� %w�=7B�,'*9/3����D3C'*9/�@4/)�-/)*3C4j7V� ��3C)?'*$<���='*$<%/5o':9/3D!/�?� +8�,+.$<2&$&'M>�4/$<)�':�?$<+/-u':$&� %/)�7V� ��;�2&$<���='*3)*3C%/)*$}':$}N@$&'M>,^

����� �������������! "��#�$%#�&(' )+* �,� -/.���0213 ��4' #657�8.�69/3��tLM� Z,� ;�2&$<���='*3D���@4/3C2�;�� %.)*$&)?':)��,7���E��,%8�,2&2&>O�W�`N,3��:�=5 3�4j�=':�D� )?!/9/3C�*$&;p�gS6�¤;�� -.!/2<3C4k'*����D$}�u3C4u�M2<�`> 3��:9J��y8-@� �@;�3`�=%k�D�@4/3�2hXv��$}':9k9/3`�='g�=%/� ���,2&$<3C)�4/$&°K-/)?3�4r+#3�2&�1�A'*9/3D�D$}�u3�4@�M2<�1>,3��C^U�69/3�D�u4.3�2Y4.3C'P�=$<2&)�;`�=% +K3t7V� -/%/4 $&%�su�,0,� 2&�1N��,%/4�s@':� %.3¶T -1q,q � +K]:^ �69/3��=':�D� )?!/9/3��?$<; �D�@4/3�2�$&)��E��,%8�,2&2&>��`N 3C�:�,5,3�4�N,3��?)*$&� %��,7#':9/3Y���u4/4/�,�*4DLM%/)�':$}':-.'*3�7V� ��su!/�,;�3Ys@':-.4/$<3C)�T���L�s.s ]��t�u4.3�28L*L"5 3�%/3C�:�,2;�$&�*;C-/2<�=':$&� %��D�@4/3�2gT��Y�,%.)*3�%³3C'p�,2h^<X -1q,� � ]���$}':9�!8�,�:�=��3|':3C�*$&E`�='*$<� %.)p�,7�':9/3o3�4.4.>m':�*�,%/)*!#� ��':)D�,7�D� �D3�%O':-.�oXY9/3`�='�XY�=%/4����,$<)�':-/�?3 +(> +8�,�*�@;�2&$&%/$<; 3C4/4/$&3�)jT�s(':� %/3~�=%/4<;��,�/X -`q � \uX -1q q [@]:^��69/3�D�u4.3�2/N 3C�*)?$<� %��B3�-/)?3J98�=)c��2<�='*$&'*-/4/3�+8�,%/4/)CXO7V� �a�g�?3�)?� 2<-u':$&� %p�,7K�>=�X@�,%.4 - - N,3��?'*$<;��,2 2{�`>,3��*)a��$}':9�D2{�`>,3��*)Y�,+#��N,3�':9/3�':�?� !#� !8�,-/)?3�T��,+#�1N 3iZ,[ [U98Q_�@]P^

�69/3D�D�u4/3C2a�,2&)*��3��D!/2&�1>u)�':9.3�Zu^ � �?9J��y8-u� �@;�3��,%~�D$}�u3�4j2{�`>,3����D�u4/3C2"��$}':9k� = � � = 2{�='*$&'*-/4/3��2&� %/5 $}':-/4.3F5 �*$&4 ;�3C2<2&)��,%/4x4/$&°K-/)?$<� %~�,7a9.3`�='��=%/� ���,2&$<3C)�$<%O'*��':9/3F4.3�3�!@�M�@;�3`�=%k+#3�2&�1��':9/3F;C2<$&���=':���2&� 5 $&;`�,2/�D$²�u3�4p2<�`> 3C��^ H 2&2&����$&%/5�7V� �;P98�,%.5 $<%.5g)?3`����$<;C3J$&%D�l-/2}':$&!/2&3J5,�*$&4�;C3�2&2<)CX@'*9/$&)c!.�*�1N@$<4/3C)�)?�D�u�,'*9�D3�2}':$&%/5 ':�*�,%/)*$}':$&� %/)��,)l;�� �D!8�,�?3�4¶':�~��)?$<%/5,2<3�E��,%8�,2²�M�D3`�,%m�@;�3��,%¶5 �*$&4u��;�3�2&2h^r�69/$&)U�u;C3`�,%¶;C� �F�!#� %/3�%O'��D�@4/3�2_$<)�4.3�)*;C�*$&+K3C4~+(> �Y�,%.)*3�%~3|'��,2h^T -`q � � ]:^��69/3U�='*�D� )*!/9.3��*$&;U�D�u4.3�2"-.)*3�)�'*9/3D��L�s/s�:�=4/${��':$}N 3B'*�:�,%/)�7V3��_;��@4/3B��9/$&;P9U;�� %O':�,$<%.)�,2&2u�*�,4/$<�=':$}N 3C2&>l$<�D!#� �?':�,%O'"':�*�,;�3�5O�,)?3�)�,)��B3C2<2.�,)��=3��*�,)*� 2&)�,%/4U'*9/3�$&�3C°K3�;|'��,%��*�,4/$<�=':$}N 36'*�:�,%/)�7V3��C^"�69/3�)*-.�?7h�,;C3J�=�*3`���,7#3��,;P9�2<�='*$&'*-/4/36+8�,%.4�$&)a4/$}Nu$&4/3C4�$&%O':�g�!#3��*;C3�%O'P�=5 3��,7"2<�,%/4eX/�u;C3`�,%eX/2{�=%/4u�M$&;�3=X �,%/4�)*3����M$&;�3���$}':9�':9/3�)?-/�?7h�=;�3�y8-u�u3�)�;C� �D!/-.':3C4x)?3�!8�,�*�=':3C2&>7V� ��3��,;P9�)*-/��7h�,;�3�'M>@!#3,^a�69/$&)��,2<2&�1��)67V� �6�,!/!.�*� !/�?${��':3Y'*�*3`��':�D3�%O'��,7��:�,4.${�='*$&N,3�7V� �*;C$<%.5 )64/3�!#3�%.4/3�%O'

Page 7: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

� %�-.%/4/3��?2&>@$&%/5�)*-.�?7h�,;C3l'M>@!K3F)?-/;P9~�,)Y�,%O':9/�?� !K�,5 3�%/$&;F�=3��*�,)*� 2&)�^J�69/3U�='*���,)*!/9/3C�*$&;U;�� �D!#� %/3C%('Y�,7':9.3��D�@4/3�2hX�'*9/3��?3C7V� �?3,X_!/�*�1N@$<4.3�)l�D� )�'l$&�D!K�,�?'P�=%('g%/�,%/2<$&%/3��,�i$&%O':3C�:�,;|':$&� %/)l+#3C'M��3�3C%w;��,��!#� %/3C%O':)�,7�':9/3g�='*�D� )*!/9.3��*$&;g)?>@)?'*3���^

H )o4/$&)*;�-.)*)*3C4 !/�*3|N@$<� -.)*2}> X�':9/3r�tLM�zZ,�z�D�u4.3�2�98�,)�'M�B�³!8�,�*�,�D3C':3C�*)�':98��'t4.3C':3C�*�D$&%/3r':9.3':$&�D3�)?;`�,2&3Y�=%/4����,5,%/$&'*-/4/3��,7#':9/3�4/3C;`�,48�=2/':�g;�3�%O'*-/�?>U'*$<�D3�)?;`�,2&3��*3�)?!K�,%/)*3�':�i�,%D3|�@':3C�*%8�=2 7V�,�*;�$&%/5/^�69/3C)*3U�,�?3g'*9/3g3��(-/$&2<$&+/�*$&-/� ;�2&$<���='*3l)?3�%/)?$&'*$&N@$}'M>¶T � ]�':�p��4/�,-/+/2&$<%/5��,7cS6���Y;C� %/;C3�%O':�*�=':$&� %/)��=%/4':9.3F5 2&� +8�,2²�M�D3`�=%xN 3C�?':$&;`�=2_':9.3��*���,2_4/$}°e-/)?$&N@$}'M>¶T � �i]�7V� ��':9/3l��$²�u$<%.5��,7':9/3C�*���,2"�,%/� ���,2&$<3C)�$&%('*�':9.3�4/3�3C!³�@;�3��,%v^j£j3�%/�,'*3�':98��' ��$<)D)?3C'D+O>m�,4���-/)?'*$<%/5j��;�2&� -/4m7V3C3�4/+8�=;P0m!8�,�:�=��3|':3C��X��KX':98��'�,4=��-.)?':)i':9/3�;�2&� -/4w7V�:�=;C':$&� %/)i-/)*3C4m$<%j':9/3��*�,4/$<�=':$}N 3�':�:�=%/)?7V3C�l;`�=2<;C-/2{��':$&� %/)�^ su!K3C;�$}�8;`�=2<2}> X���3�)*3|'':9.3U�,4=��-/)�':3C4 ;�2&� -/4/$&%/3�)?)�X���� Xv+O>t�l-/2}':$&!/2}>u$&%/5�':9.3F�D�u4/3C2";��,2<;C-/2<�=':3C4k;C2<�,-/4/$&%/3�)?)�X���Xe+(>x��'*3��*�!/�?� !K�,�?':$&� %8�=2e':�U':9.3g5,2<� +/�,2v�D3`�,%o)*-.�?7h�,;C3�'*3��D!#3��:��':-/�?3,X��� ':�D� +u'P�,$&% ���������1T -�� ���� �]P^aLM%':9.$<)����,%/%/3C��X��B3UN=�,��>�� '*�o�,4=��-/)�' � �=%/4j9/�1N,3p��� %.3|��'*�=�M�,%/3U���,!/!/$&%/5�7V� ��)*!#3�;C$&7 >@$&%/5 ��^U£j3�,2&)*�~%/�,'*3�':98��'U':9/3�N,3��?'*$<;��,2�':9.3��*���,264.$&°K-/)*$}N@$&'M>m7V�,�F9/3`��'p�=%/� ���,2&$<3C)U98�,)���2{��':$}':-/4/3��M2&� %/5 $}':-.4/34/3C!K3C%/4/3�%.;�3D':98�='�$&)�)*;��,2&3�4k+(>x':9/3U5 2&� +8�=2}����3��,% ���YN=�,2&-/3,^F�69.$<)�$&��!.2<$&3�)�':9/�='g�,4=��-/)�':�D3�%O'*)�7V�,�4/$}°e3C�*3C%('��*3�2<�='*$&N,3��:�='*3�)��,7R9/3��='B-.!.'P�,0=3�$&%�4/$}°e3C�*3�%O'6�?3�5 $&� %/)B�,�*3�%/�,'B!K3C�*�D$}'*':3C4p��$}':9�':9.$<)�4/3�)?$<5 %e^LM%p)?3�%/)?$&'*$&N@$}'M>�'*3�)�':)a':�g;P98�,%/5 3C)B$&%�'*9/$<)c!8�='?':3C�*%p�=7e4/3C3�!u���u;C3`�,%p9/3`�='c-/!u'P�,0=3,Xu��3�7V� -/%/4D':9/3�5 2&� +8�,2�D3`�,%o;P98�,%.5 3�)�$<%o�@;�3`�=%o'*3��D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3C)���3��?3�$<%/)?3�%/)?$&'*$&N,3l':�D)?-/;P9x;P98�=%/5 3�)C^

��� � * �802�:��� 13 �� � � -�� 1 $���� � � 1�� $ # � "� ���H )J�D3�%O':$&� %/3C4 $<%x'*9/3l$&%O':�?�u4/-.;C':$&� %vX#�B3i98�`N 3F3C2<3C;C'*3�4�':��-/)*3i':9/�?3�3l;C2<$&���=':3i;P98�,%/5,3F4/$<�,5 %/� )�':$&;�)CX��9/$&;P9x�=�*3J'*9/3�):�=��3��=)�-/)*3C4�$<%�G8� �?3�)?'�3C'��,2h^RT�Z,[ [OZO]P^��69/$&)��,2&2<�1��)6-/)�'*�F$&)*� 2<�=':3�'*9/3�3|°e3C;C'��,7�':9.3�,4/4.$&'*$<� %/�,2c7V�,�*;�$&%/5 )g� %r'*9/3�!K� )�':3C�*$&� �l4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.'*$<� %.)�^x�69.3p;�2&$&����':3p;P9/�,%/5 3�4.${�,5,%/� )?'*$<;C)l-/)?3�4m$&%G8� �*3C)?'�3C'��=2�^�T�Z,[ [OZ(]��B3C�*3 �

����� � !�"$#&%'� (�)+*,�.-/!��102(�*43�02�1576 '*�*3�%.4 $&% 5,2<� +/�,2}���D3`�,% [28 � 0(� 4/3�3C! 2<�1>,3����,7i!K3C%O'P�,48�=2�`N 3C�:�,5,3�)�7V�*� � -1qO� Z48 -1q q � ^gsu� -/�?;�3U�,7c� +.)*3���N=�=':$&� %8�,2"�*3�;C� �*4.)���9R3CN@$}':-/)�3|'g�,2�^�T�Z,[,[ � ]P^�£j3��$&2<2R�?3C7V3C��'*�U':9/$&)�4/${�=5 %/� )�':$&;l�,)����F^

�;:<3�02=>(?%'�@*,�.-/!��102(�*43�02�1576 �p3��(-8�=2}�M�,�*3���2<�=':$}':-/4.3l�`N 3C�:�,5,3�)Y7V� ��3��,;P9��,7_�/N 3F4.3�;`�=4/3�)�7V�*� �-1q ��28 -1q,qO� �*3|7V3��*3C%/;�3C4p':� -1q [ � � -1q,qO� ;�2&$&����':� 2&� 5,>,^csu� -/�?;�3��,7e�,+/)*3C�?N=�=':$&� %8�=2#�?3�;C� �*4/)���A,� %/3C)3|'Y�=2�^�T -1q q q ]P^�£j3���$&2&2R�*3C7V3C�6':�U':9/$&)�4/$<�,5 %/� )�':$&;g�,)Jsu��^

��B�!�!��10,"$(�CD0�*4�1-E!�� 0F(.*23�02�1576 ��$&°K3��?3�%/;C3Y+#3C'M��3�3C% -1q � 28 -1q qO� �,%/4 -1q - 8 -1q � [��`N 3C�:�,5,3�)���'3C$<5 9O'_)?':�,%/48�,�?4i!.�*3�)?)*-/�?3B2&3CN,3�2&)_7V�*�,� �O� [�� � [�98Q_�J� % � 4.3�5 �?3�3c5 �*$&4v^"su� -/�?;�3c�,7/� +.)*3���N=�=':$&� %8�,2�?3�;��,�*4/)�Q"�=�*0,3C�J3|'J�,2�^�T -1q q \O]P^"£j3���$<2&2R�*3|7V3��6':�U':9.$<)�4/$<�,5 %/� )�':$&;g�,) ( H ^

��+/)*3C�?N=�='*$<� %.)Y7V� �J'*9/3l-.!/!K3C���,$&�Y4/$<�,5 %.� )?'*$<;U�=�*3l�D$&)*)?$<%/5�7V�,���p%(-/�i+K3C���,7a2<�=':$}':-/4.3|�M9.3�$&5 9O'�;��@� ���4/$&%8�='*3�)�XR�D� )�':2}>x$&%�':9.3�su� -.'*9/3��?% �J3��D$&)*!/9.3��*3=^l�69/$&)��*3C4/-/;C3�)�':9.3F4/$&��3C%/)*$&� %k�,7':9.3F4/$<�,5 %/� )�':$&;7V�*�,� Z � � '*��Z Z=[.^ H 4/4.$&'*$<� %/�,2<2}> XK+O>x2&�u�,0@$&%/5p�='J'*9/3l+#�,'?':� � !8�=%/3�2��,7aG"$&5 -/�?3 - �B3l� +/)*3C�?N,3l':98��'$&%r':9/3p)?':�*�=':�,)*!/9/3C�*$&;�2<�1>,3��?)oT � [��WZ,[ [�98Q"�(]PX�':9.3p4/$<�,5 %/�,)?':$&;�!/�?�1Nu$&4/3C)U2<$}'*'*2<3�$<%.7V�,�*���=':$&� %vX��,)l':9.3�D�u4.3�2&3�4¶':3��D!#3��*�=':-/�?3�)��,�?3�$<%.)*3�%.)*$}':$}N 3t'*� � �,)U)*9.����%�+O>w':9.3�)*���,2&2<3C�U�:�,%/5,3��,7�':3��D!#3��*�=':-/�?3;P98�,%.5 3�)��='':9.3�)*3�2&3CN 3C2<)C^a�69/36�B3��,0U4/3�!#3�%.4/3�%/;C3Y� % � $&)c;C� %/)?$<)�':3�%O'c��$&'*9�'*9/3�2<�@;`�=2/;��@� 2&$<%/5g+#3�$&%/54/�?$&N,3�%�+O>m'*9/3�4/3�;C�*3`�=)*3o$<%�)?'*�:�='*� )*!/9.3��*$&;o� E�� %.3o;C� %/;C3�%O':�*�=':$&� %/)xTh%/�='�'*9/3�;P98�,%/5,3�)�$<%�S6��Z �,��,'*9/3��i5 �*3C3�%/9/�,-/)*3�5 �,)l;C� %/;�3C%O':�:��':$&� %/)|]:^ I�3�;`�=2<2&$<%.5x':98��'F4/$}°e3C�*3C%('lN,�=2<-/3C)F�,7 � �,�?3p���,$&%/2}>j4.-/3

\

Page 8: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

':�r4/$&°K3��?3�%O'�;C2<� -.4�7V3�3C4/+8�,;P0()�$&%�':9/3t':�*�,!K� )?!/9/3C�*3,X�)�':�:��':� )?!/9/3��?$<;t':3��D!#3��*�=':-/�?3�)p��$&2&2Y%/�,'�N=�,�?>)*$&5 %/$}�8;��,%O':2}>��,) ��$&)JN=�,�*$&3�4e^ H )�)*-/;P9vX#':9/3i�D�u4/3C2<3C4x':3C�D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3C)Y4/��%/�,'�N,�=�?>�)*$&5 %/$}�8;��,%O':2}>x$&%� -/�J3�%/)?3��i+/2<3��,%.4x�B3F�,�*3F%.�,'�5O�=$<%/$&%/5��=%(>t�*3C2<3|N=�,%O'�$<%u7V� �*���='*$<� %t7V� �J'*9/3l2&$<0=3�2&$<9.�u�@4 3�)�':$&����':3�)C^�69/3C�*3U�,�?3l�D7V3C� �B�`>u)�'*���,4.4/�*3C)*)Y'*9/$<)C^�LM%x':9/$&)Y!/�,!K3C��X �B3l�*3�)�':�?$<;|'�� -/�?)*3C2&N,3�)�':��-/)*$&%/5�� %.2&>�':9.37V� -/��2<�`> 3��?)J'*98�='J;�� �?�*3�)?!K�,%/4t'*� � [48.Z,[ [D98Q"��!/�*3C)*)?-/�*3i2<3|N 3�2&)DTV� ���,2&'*$&'*-/4/3C)J7V�*�,� �,+#� -.' - - ':�pZ,[0(��]P^��69/$&)U�,�D� -/%O'*)g'*�x�*3C�(-/$<�?$<%.5x':98��'i��3p5 3|'i'*9/3�)?':�*�=':�,)*!/9/3C�*$&;�;��@� 2&$<%.5t;C� �*�?3�;C'F�,%/4j%/3�5 2&3�;|'':9.3���3`�=0�':�*�,!K� )?!/9/3C�*$&;��B�,�?��$&%/5/^

����� � �70?0 1 ��� #�&�� �7�7.�� ��5 -/.���0213 ���� # � ����$�����69/3t;�-/�?�*3�%O'p)*3C'p�,7�)?$<�i-/2<�=':$&� %/)�-.)*3�)p�j)?3C'��,7�9/$&)?'*� �*$&;`�,2�;C2<$&���=':3o7V� �*;C$<%/5,)�4/-.�*$&%/5r':9.3t!#3��?$<�@4-1� ,[�� -1q,qO� ^��69/3 3|�@'*3��*%/�,2J7V� �?;�$&%/5 )��=�*3x;P9/�,%/5 3C)�$<% �~5 �?3�3C%/9/� -/)?3 5O�,)�;�� %/;C3�%O':�*�=':$&� %/) �J�,%/)?3�%�,%/4 Z Z��,'*9/3��?)DT�Z,[,[OZ(]PX#)*-.2&7h�='*3U�,3C�*� )?� 2"2&�O�,4/$&%/5 )Y)*;`�=2<3C4 +(>�s/��Z�3C��$&)*)?$<�,%/)isu�D$&'*9 3C'��,2h^"T�Z,[ [ � ]PX':�?� !#� )*!/9.3��*$&;F�=%/4x)�':�:��':� )?!/9/3��?$<;i� E��,%/3l;C� %/;�3C%O':�:��':$&� %/)1T��Y�,%.)*3�%~�=%/4~Z ZU�,':9.3��*)CXvZ=[ [OZ(]:X82{�,%.4u�M-/)?3N 3C5 3C':�=':$&� %m;P98�=%/5 3�)oThIJ�=���=%/0(-.'*'M>r�,%/4¶G8� 2&3C>#X -1q q q ]:X")?� 2{�=�F$<�?�:�,4.${�,%.;�3�;P98�=%/5 3�)�T 9R3`�,%eXZ,[ [,[@]PX�,%/4³)?'*�:�='*� )*!/9.3��*$&;t�,3��?� )*� 2&)�7V�?� �±N,� 2<;��,%/$&;x3C�*-/!.'*$<�,%/)�T�s.�='*�j3|'��,2h^&X -1q q � X -/!K4/�=':3C4³':�rZ,[ [ - ]P^�gs/��9_s�$<)6':9.3g)?9/� ��':98�,%.4x%/�,':�=':$&� %�7V� ��'*9/$<)�)?3C'��,7"7V�,�*;�$&%/5 )C^

����� � ���!� # � ��� � "��0 13 "��#�$�� #����su3C;C':$&� % q ^1k$<%�SB9/�,!.':3C� q �,7�':9.3xLWQcS6S H I���T%��3�5 3C�*2�3C'p�,2h^<XBZ,[ [O\O]l!.�*�1N@$<4/3C)��r)?-/�D���=�?>��,73�)�':$&���=':3C)��,7v!.�*� +8�=+/$<2&$}'M>�4.$<)�':�*$&+/-.'*$<�,%/)�7V� �c;�2&$&����':3�)*3�%.)*$}':$}Nu$}'M>p':�,0,3C%p7V�*�,��':9/3��*3C;�3�%O'B2<$}':3C�:�='*-/�*3=^su3C;C':$&� % - [.^ � $&% SB9/�,!.':3C� - [w�,7�':9.3�LWQcS6S H I�� T��o3�3�9.2�3C'o�,2h^<X�Z,[ [O\O]F7V-/��':9/3C��4/$<)?;�-/)?)*3C)t':9.3-/%/;C3���'P�,$&%O':$&3�)�$<% �(-8�=%('*$&7 >@$&%/5o;�2&$<���='*3U;P98�,%/5 3U!.�*�=��3C;C':$&� %/)�+O>��,;�;C� -/%O':$&%/5�7V� ���=4/4/$}':$&� %8�,2��D�@4/3�2-/%/;C3���'P�,$&%O':$&3�)�^�LM%�'*9/$<)�!8�,!#3��CXc��3t�,�*3��*3C)?'*�*$&;C':$&%/5k':9/3o4/$&)*;�-.)*)*$&� %�'*�k'*9/� )?3o�D3|':9/�@4/)D':98�='�-/)?3':9.3lZ=[=':9�;�3C%O':-/��>�$<%/)�':�?-/�D3�%O'P�,2��?3�;��,�*4�':�D3�)�':$&����':3�':9/3�4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.'*$<� %t�,7_;�2&$<���='*3g)?3�%/)?$&'*$&N@$}'M> ^�su$}�5 �?� -/!/)�98�`N 3�!/-/+/2&$&)*9/3C4w�*3C)*-/2}':)i$<%~':9/$&)g;`�='*3�5 � ��>³T H %/4/�*�,%/�1N,�o�,%/4rsu;P9/2&3�)?$<%.5 3��CXZ,[ [ - �����*3�5,� �?>3C'g�=2�^&X�Z,[ [ Z � /�%(-.'*'*$�3C'g�=2�^&X�Z,[ [ � �vG8� �?3�)?'�3|'g�,2h^<X�Z=[ [ �eG �*�,�D3U3C'g�,2h^&X�Z,[ [ � ]P^pT��J�=':3F��3�3��u;�2&-/4/3G8� �*)�':3C�F�,%/4����*3C5 � ��> T�Z,[ [(]�+#3�;��,-/)*3p$&'U4.�u3C)l%/�,'F-/)*3p'*9/3��?3�;��,�*4w+8�=;P0j':�x+K3C5 $<%.%/$<%.5 �,7�Z,[='*9;�3C%O':-/��> ^²]p�69.3i-/%.4/3��?2&>@$&%/5��D3C'*9/�u4.)Y$&%x�,2&2��,7"'*9/3�)?3l�=�*3�N 3���>o)*$&��$&2<�,��'*��'*9/3g+8�,)*$&;l�D3|':9/�@4/� 2&� 5,>-/)?3�4U$&%i':9.$<)_!8�,!#3���^��Y�,�D3C2&>,XO�J)?3C'��=78;�2&$<���='*3�)*$&�l-.2{�='*$<�,%/)"��3��*3����,4/3���$}':9F�J;�2&$&����':3��D�@4/3�2O��$}':9N=�,�*$&� -/)g)*3|'*'*$<%/5,)g7V� ����^�LM%r3`�=;P9r;`�=)*3,X�':9/3�)*$&�l-.2{�='*$<�,%/)i��3��?3p;��,��!/�,�*3C4w�,5O�=$<%/)�'�':9/3�� +/)?3��?N,3�4':3C�D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3t�*3�;C� �*4 �,%/4��,)?)*$&5 %/3C4��j2&$<0=3�2&$<9/�@�@4�':98��'�$}'p$&)p;C� %/)*$&)?'*3�%O'���$}':9�'*9/3x� +.)*3���N=�=':$&� %/)C^G8�*� ��':9/3�)?3C'��,7_)*$&�l-/2<�=':$&� %/)CX#�D4.$<)�':�*$&+/-.'*$<�,%vX���T � ]:X/$<)�3C)?':$&���=':3C4v^Bsu3CN,3��:�=2�;P9.� $<;C3�)J�,�*3����,4/3�$&%3`�=;P9x�D3C'*9/�u4 �a£�9/�='�;�2&$<���='*3i�D�@4/3�2R$&)�-/)*3C4t'*��!#3���7V� �*� ':9/3�)*$&�l-.2{�='*$<�,%/)��x£�98�='�� +.)*3���N=�=':$&� %8�,24/$<�,5 %/�,)?':$&;�$&)6-/)*3C4����,%/4�£�98��'6%/� $&)*3��D�@4/3�2v$&)6�*3C�(-/$<�?3�4�':�F4.3C':3C�*�D$&%/3�;�� %/)?$<)�':3C%/;C>�+#3C'M��3�3C%t':9.3)*$&�l-.2{�='*$<�,%��,%/4�� +/)?3���N,��':$&� %/)���LM%p�=2<28;��,)*3C)�3��.;C3�!.'BG8� �*3C)?'c3C'��,2h^#T�Z=[ [@]��=%/4pG8�*�,�D363C'��,2h^#T�Z,[ [ � ]PX5 2&� +8�,2#�D3`�,%�':3��D!#3��*�=':-/�?3�$&)�-/)*3C4��,)�'*9/3�4/$<�,5 %.� )?'*$<;�N,�=�*$<�,+/2&3��,%/4�)?�F� %/2}>�-/%/$}N,�=�*$<�=':3J)?'P��':$&)?':$&;`�=2�D3C'*9/�u4.)J�=�*3��*3C�@-.$<�?3�4v^��

G8� �*3C)?'c3C'��,2h^#T�Z,[,[OZ(]�!/�?3�)*3C%O':3�4��,%�3C)?'*$<���='*3J�,7#':9.3a��� $&%O'a!/�*�,+8�,+/$&2<$}'M>D4/3C%/)*$}'M>D7V-/%/;C'*$<�,% T�Qa��Gc]7V� �g-/%/;C3��?':�,$&%m;�2&$<���='*3p)?>@)�':3��µ!/�*�,!K3C�?':$&3�)C^��Y'*9/3��i5 �*� -.!/)�T H %/4/�?� %/�1N=���,%/4msu;P9/2&3�)*$&%/5 3C��XaZ=[ [ - � ��ÆTÓ�é�É�ÆTã$ÓnÒ=Ë�ÚÂó"!¢íañ�ñ�í$#XÜKÉ$ØWË&%�Ó�Ç6̦Ó�É�ÕZÒTÞKÓ�É�×fÒTÑ»ØWËaÚ"'EÈKé�Ó�ÆT×EÆTÑ»ÈÙÒ#ÜfÓwÒFÓ�ÐxÒFÑÛÉ�ÈWÆTÓ�̦ÇEÚâҩ̳ÒTÉBÓ�̦ÒTÑ»Ø&ËaÒTÓ�ÒFÞKÓÈKÓnÒSËaÓ�ÆTÉÙ̦É�Ú

Õ|É�Æ©ÐwÑ»ÈKé�Õ|ÆFÉ�Ø ÒTÓ�Ø&×6Ó�ÆFËaÒTÇKÆFÓ{ЩÞEË�ÈKé�Ó�×6Ë%Ò¦ÒFÓnÆFÈEÌ �EÇfÒ�ÒFÞKÓnȵÉ�ÈKÚ»ãzÐnÉ�ÈEÌTÑ�ÜfÓnÆ�é�Ú»É��EË�ÚØ&Ó�Ë�È+ÒTÓnØ&×�ÓnÆ©Ë%ÒFÇKÆTÓ{ÆTÓ�̦×�É�È6̦Ó�ÒFÉÓ�̦ÒTÑ»ØWË%ÒFÓ)(/ó ��ÒË�×K×�Ó�ËaÆ©ÌSÒTÞEËaÒ�ÒTÞKÑ�Ì�Ë�Ø�É�ÇKÈÙÒFÌ=ÒFÉ&ÜKÉ�Ç��KÚ»Ó8ÇEÌTÓ*ÉaÕXÒTÞKÓ$ÌTÇKÆTÕ Ë�ÐwÓ�ÒTÓ�Ø&×6Ó�ÆFËaÒTÇKÆFÓ8ÆTÓ�ÐwÉ�ÆFÜvó

Page 9: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

���*3�5,� �?>p3C'J�,2h^<X Z=[ [OZ � /�%(-.'?':$R3C'��=2�^&X#Z,[ [ � �/G8� �*3C)?'�3C'J�,2h^&X Z,[ [ �8G8�:�,�D3�3C'��=2�^&X#Z,[ [ � �8G8� �*)�':3����=%/4���*3�5,� �?>#X@Z,[ [�@]�98�`N 3J3�)?'*$<���='*3�4�)*$&��$&2<�,�BQa��G")c�,2}':9.� -/5 9�3`�,;P9�-/)*3C)B4/$}°K3��*3C%O'B�D3C'*9/�@4/)B�=%/4�4/�='P�.^�J�1��3CN,3����,2&2v�,�?3�+8�,)?3�4�� %�3�)�':$&���=':$&%/5U':9/3Y4/3�5 �?3�3�'*�l��9/$&;P9x�l;C2<$&���=':3��D�@4/3�2K;`�,%��?3�!/�?�u4/-.;�3�':9.39/$&)?'*� �*$&;`�,2K;�2&$<���='*3��*3C;�� �?4v^aQ"�,�*�,�D3C'*3��*)���$}':9.$<%�3`�=;P9����@4/3C2v�,�?3�!K3C�?'*-/�*+#3�4�'*�D�,2&'*3��c':9/3��?3�)*!#� %/)?3':�m;C2<$&���=':3�7V�,�*;�$&%/5 )��,%/4��w)?':�=':$&)?'*$<;��,2�;C� �D!8�,�*$&)*�,% $&)�-/)?3�4�':�m�?3���3�;|'�;��,�l+/$&%8�='*$<� %.)o�=7i�D�@4/3�2!8�,�*�,�D3C'*3��*)C^

�69/3���3|':9/�@4�$<)c+8�,)?3�4�� %�'*9/3�� !.'*$<���,2/�8%.5 3��?!/�*$&%O'B4/3|':3C;C':$&� %�':3�;P9.%/$<�(-/3�7V� �;��,��!/�,�*$&%/5l�D�@4/3�2�,%/4³� +/)?3��?N=�='*$<�,%8�,2�48�=':�.^��69/$&)�':3C;P9/%/$&�(-/3�;��,%/)*$&)?'*)��,7��?-/%/%/$&%/5m�k;�2&$<���='*3t�D�@4/3�2�-/%/4.3����~)*3|'�,7"!/�*3C)*;��?$<+#3�4�7V�,�*;�$&%/5 )J�,%/4o-/)?$<%/5p;�2&$<���='*3i;P98�=%/5 3l4.3C':3C;C'*$<� %t4/$<�,5 %/� )�':$&;�)�':��4/3C'*3��*�D$&%/3l��9/3|':9/3C�':9.3U)*$&�l-/2<�=':3C4j;C2<$&���=':3D;P98�=%/5 3U$&)�� +/)*3C�?N,3�4r$&%�':9.3U;�2&$<���='*3��?3�;C� �*4k�,%/4 $&)�4/$&)?':$&%/5 -.$<)?98�,+/2&3U7V�*� �-/%.7V�,�*;�3C4 N=�,�*$<�,+/$&2<$}'M>³�,7�':9.3�;�2&$<���='*3�)?>@)�':3�� Th)?3�3~�t$}':;P9.3�2&2�3C'��,2�^YT�Z=[ [ - ]l� �pLM%O'*3��*%/�=':$&� %8�,2 ¦��� ­�� ��3|':3�;|':$&� %m�,%.4 H '*'*�*$&+/-.'*$<� %m���?� -/!�T�Z,[ [ � ]Y�,%/4r�?3C7V3C�*3�%.;�3�)F'*9/3��?3�$&%K]P^�LM%j)?'P��':$&)?':$&;`�=2c'*3��*�D)CX2&3C'*'*$<%.5 �����+#3i'*9/3l9/$&)?'*� �*$&;`�=2"�*3C;�� �?4/)�X� lT(]�':9.3F�D�u4/3C2_�,-.':!/-u'Y':9/�='Y4.3�!#3�%/4/)Y� %�!8�,�*�,�D3C'*3��*)��,%/4 � ��':9/3g;��1N=�,�?${�,%.;�3g����':�*$²�KX#��2&$<0=3�2&$<9.�u�@4x7V-/%/;|':$&� %o$<)�� +.':�,$<%.3�4t7V�?� � '*9/3i)�'P�='*$<)�':$&;�)FTD lTO]�� ����P] � ��� �� TD lTO]�� �����]P^"L�'B$&)B%/�='B!#� )*)?$<+.2<3Y'*�i3C)?'*$<���='*3Y':9/3�':�?-/3Y;C2<$&���=':3J)?>@)?'*3�� N=�,�*$<�,+/$&2<$}'M> X�� ��X� %k;�3C%('*-/�?>~'*$<�D3|��)*;��,2<3C)i7V�?� � � +/)?3���N,��':$&� %/)i�,%/4~':9/3C�*3C7V�,�*3,X�;�2&$&����':3����@4/3C2<)i�,�*3��*-.%k��$}':9k�.�u3�4+#� -/%/48�=�?>�;C� %/4/$}':$&� %/)�7V� ��':9.� -/):�=%/4/)��,7�> 3`�=�*)�':��� +.'P�=$<%�3�)�':$&���=':3C)J�,7�':9.3g;C2<$&���=':3�N=�,�*$<�,+/$&2&$&'M>,^

�69/3���� �*0w!.�*3�)?3�%O':3C4³9.3��*3�$&)U+8�,)?3�4¶� %m� +u'P�,$&%/$&%/5~��2<$&0,3C2<$&9/�@�u4m7V� �g':9/3�;C2<$&���=':3�)?3�%/)?$&'*$&N@$}'M>T � ]:X�'*9/3��:�='*3��=7�9/3��='l-.!.'P�,0=3�+O>~':9.3�4/3C3�!j�u;C3`�,% T����i]:X"�,%.4k'*9/3�%.3C'l�,3��?� )*� 27V� �?;�$&%/5rT ��������]�,%/4x�,%8�,2}>@E�3g':9/3i-/%/;�3C�?':�,$<%O'M>t$<%t)*-/;P9 !/�,�:�,�D3|':3��?)Y-/)?$<%.5���!#� )�':3��?$<�,�J4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.'*$<� %eXv�=7 '*3���':9/3g$<%@�;��,�*!#� �:�='*$<�,%k�=7�3|�u!#3���'l!/�?$<�,�g0(%/�1��2&3�4/5,3,^p�69.$<)g$<)�':9.3�)*�,�D3�7V�*�,�D3C��� �*0 �=76G8� �*3C)?'g3C'i�,2h^cT�Z=[ [ - XZ,[ [ Z(]P^��69.3Y-/%/;C3���'P�,$&%�!8�,�*�,�D3C':3C�*)B�,%/4p'*9/3Y;C2<$&���=':3��D�@4/3�2#48�=':�g7V�?� ��':9/3��tLM��Z,��S6� �,�?3Y$&4/3�%@�':$&;`�=2�':��':9/�,)*3D$<%jG8� �*3C)?'�3|'l�=2�^aT�Z,[ [(]P^F�69/3��D3C'*9/�u4~-/)?3�4j$<%jG8� �*3C)?'�3C'i�,2h^aT�Z,[ [@]�$&)�+8�,)?3�4k� %3CN=�,2&-8�='*$<%.5o'*9/3�2&$&0,3�2&$&9/�u�@4r�,%/2&>k��'l��)*3|'l�=7�!/�?3|�M)?!K3C;�$}�83�4r;�� �i+/$<%/�=':$&� %/)g�,7B'*9/3�;�2&$<���='*3�)�>u)�':3C�!/�?� !K3C�?'*$<3C)�^ H 2&)*�/X@':9/3�3C)?'*$<���='*$<� %��=7���� �� $&)�4/� %.3�-/)*$&%/5D�,%�3C$<5 3C%ON 3�;|':� ��4/3C;�� �D!#� )*$}':$&� %��,7"�gS6��*-.%/)�X�!.�*$&� �i'*�t7V� �?��$&%/5x'*9/3p2&$&0,3�2&$&9/�u�@4v^ H )l!/�,�?'l�,76� %/5,� $<%.5x$&%(N,3�)�':$&5O�=':$&� %/)U$&%O':�x'*9/$&)l�D3C'*9/�u4eXSB-/�?�?>�3C'Y�,2h^�T�Z,[,[ � ]c;��,%/)*$&4/3��?3�4x'*9/3g$<�D!8�,;|'Y�=7"-/)?$<%.5p4/$}°e3C�*3C%('J':�?-/%/;`��':$&� %t%(-/�i+K3C�*)J$<%o':9/3g3�)�':$²����=':3��=7_'*9/3�%/� $&)*3�;��1N=�,�*$<�,%/;C3�$<%ON 3C�*)?3,^c�69/$<)�':�?-/%/;��=':$&� %��*3C!/�*3C)*3�%O'*)J':9.3�%@-.�l+#3����,7�3�$&5 3�%ON 3C;C'*� �*)�*3|'P�,$&%/3C4x$&%t':9.3i$&%ON 3��?)*3F3C)?'*$<���='*3F�,%/4�N=�,�*$&� -/)�$&%.7V� �*���='*$<�,%t;C�*$}':3��?${�D�B3C�*3i-/)*3C4x':��4/3C'*3��?��$&%/3l�,%�,!/!.�*� !/�?${��':3�':�?-/%/;��=':$&� %¶N,�=2<-/3�7V� �i':9/3��l-.2&'*$&N=�,�?${�='*3�4/${�=5 %/� )�':$&;�)�^m�69.3o�D3|':9/�@4/)�4/3CN,3�2&� !K3C4�$&%s.�,%.) ���3|'��,2h^_T�Z,[,[O\(]B�,%/4�-.)*3�4x$<%x'*9/$&)Y!8�,!#3���$&%('*3��?!K� 2<�='*3l�1N 3C�J':9.3l)*!/�,;�3i�,7;�2&$&����':3l!/�,�:�,�D3|':3��?)�,%/4 �,;�;C� -/%O'�7V� ���D� )?'p3�)?'*$<���='*$<�,%�-/%/;�3C�?':�,$<%O'*$<3C)�X�$<% !/�,�?'*$<;C-/2{�=��':9.� )*3�4.-/3t'*�r':9/3t;��1N=�,�*$<�,%/;C3���=':�?$}�K^ H 4.4/$&'*$<�,%8�,2R4/3|'P�,$&2<)��,�?3�!/�*3C)*3�%O'*3�4�$&%�s@3�;C'*$<�,% � ^

� ��� �g�����_���`�!����� �� ���

£j3l;��,%/)*$&4/3����p)?':�=':$&)?'*$<;��,2_�D�@4/3�2_�,2&� %/5p'*9/3l2&$&%/3�)��=7�':98��'Y4/3|N 3C2<� !#3�4~$&%~s.�,%.) ���3|'��,2h^�T�Z,[ [O\O]P^�LM%��98�='l7V� 2<2&�1��)FN 3C;C':�,�*)U��$<2&2�+#3�4/3C%/�,':3C4¶$<%¶+#� 2<4w7h�=;�3��,%.4����='*�*$&;�3C)F��$<2&2�;��,�*�*3C)*!#� %/4m':� ;��,!/$}'P�,22&3C'*'*3��?)�^�I�3�;��,2&2<$&%/5p'*9/3l%/�='P�='*$<� %t$<%t':9/3i$<%O':�?�u4.-/;C'*$<� %eXe2&3C'�!�� �"!t;��,�*�*3C)*!#� %/4�'*����)?-/�D���,�?>t�,7':9.3�9/$&)?':�,�*$&;`�,2�48�='P��;C� 2&2<3C;C':3C4��,�*� -.%/4w':9/3��B� �?2<4m�1N,3��U)*3|N 3C�:�,2�4.3�;`�=4/3�)C^j�69(-/)�# � - 7V� �U���FX# ��Z,[�7V� �gsu�A�,%/4 # � - [ q 7V� � ( H Th�,2}':9/� -.5 9~� -/��$&%/$&'*${�=2 ( H �,%8�=2&>@)*$&)����,)�!#3���7V� �*�D3�4~��$}':9# � Z Z,[(]P^��69/3��D�@4/3�2��*-/%/)l�,�*3�4/3�%.�,':3C4¶�,)%$�&'�(� ! ��)0� - ��*�*�* � �R^t�69/3�)?3��,�?3��x;C� 2<2&3�;|':$&� %�,7 �+# �M4/$&�D3�%/)?$<�,%8�,2�N 3�;|':� �?)�X � %/3�7V� ��3��,;P9x;C� �l+/$&%8�='*$<�,%x�,7�':9/3�;C2<$&���=':3g!8�,�*�,�D3C':3C�*)C^�£j3g4.3�%/�,'*3':9.$<)i�,)-,.�/� !1032 ^�G8� �gsu���,%/40( H Xv��3�;�� %/)?$<4.3��i�,4/4/$}':$&� %8�,2$&%.7V� �?���=':$&� %k!/�*�1N@$<4.3�4r+O>jS6���

q

Page 10: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

;��,%('*�*� 2��*-.%/)�Xv;C� %/)?$<)�':$&%/5��,7�� # �M4/$&�D3�%/)?$<�,%8�,2_N,3�;|':� �?) � &1Xv�,%.4�2<3|'�� � � !10��p+K3g':9/3i����':�*$²�t�,7)*-.;P9x;��,%('*�*� 2R�?-/%/)C^ H 2<)?�/X/7V� ��su� �=%/4&( H X83��,;P9x;C� �D!K�,%/3�%O'J�,7_'*9/3 #~4/$<�D3C%/)*$&� %8�,2�48��'P�FN 3C;C':�,�*)$&)�$<%/4.3|�u3�4~+O> �p'M����4/$<�D3C%/)*$&� %8�,22&�@;`�='*$<� %��� ��*� - ��*�*3*�� #_^�� �$&%/4/$&;`��':3�)�2<�='*$&'*-/4/3D�,%/4 4.3�;`�=4/37V� �lsu� �,%/4j2{��':$}':-/4/3p�,%/4r�,2&'*$&'*-/4/3�7V� � ( H ^��69/3�N,�=2<-/3C)l�,7B':9/3�;�2&$<���='*3p!8�,�*�,�D3C'*3��*)g��9/3��?3p':9.3�tLM��Z,��S6� $&)F3CN=�,2&-8�='*3�4m��$&2<2�+K3�4.3�%/�,'*3�4��,)�� �±T � ���.������� � �%��] � ����)?��':98�='i':9/3��D�@4/3�2� -.'*!/-.'o�='�2&�@;`�='*$<� %����,%/4 !8�,�*�,�D3C':3C��N=�,2<-.3�)���$&)�4/3�%/�=':3�4 �,) #�T�� ���1]P^ H )?-/�D���,�?>��,7g':9.3%/�,':�=':$&� %�$&)�!.�*3�)?3�%O':3C4�$&%t�_�,+/2&3 - ^

c�,�*$<�,+/2&3 �J�,':�=':$&� % su$&E�3 ��$&��3C%/)*$&� %9R�u;��=':$&� %/) � � ��*�*�* ��� ! # � - ��Z,[ � - [ q � � �+� ��J$&)?'*� �*$&;`�,2R�?3�;C� �*4/) � � ��*�*�* ��� ! # � - ��Z,[ � - [ q ������� �SB2<$&���=':3�!8�=�:�,�D3C'*3��?) � � ��*�*3* ��� 2 �$� �(Z� � &��+���su-/��7h�,;�3�4/$<�,5 %/�,)?':$&;�) $ � ��*�*3* � $ 2 �$� �(Z� $�& � � !SB� %O':�?� 2R�*-/%.) � � �3*�*�*�� � � � � q - � - Z �:�O[ ��� �+� !

�_�,+/2&3 - �csu-/�D���,�?>��=7_'*9/3g�1N=�,$&2<�,+/2&3g$&%.7V� �?���=':$&� %v^

£r3�4/3C%/�,'*3t�=)��_T��B]�'*9/3�':�*-.3,Xc-/%/� +/)?3���N 3�4eX64/${�=5 %/� )�':$&;t��'D2<�@;`�='*$<�,%��6^w£j3�%/�,':3�'*98�='D':9.3':9.�*3�3D4/$<�,5 %.� )?'*$<;C)g�?3C7V3C��':��2<$&%/3��,��7V-/%/;|':$&� %8�,2&)�X�� �Y�82}':3C�*)CX��=7�'*9/3U':3��D!#3��*�=':-/�?3,^l£j3D4/3�%.�,':3 ���T � � ,� � � ]��=)i':9.3! ¡':�*-.3,d_N=�,2&-/3��,7�':9.3�;�2&$<���='*3�)?>@)�':3���!/�?� !K3C�?'*$<3C)�T � � ����������������]P^t�69/3�%w��3�,)?)*-/�D3�':98�='

��� �"�_T�� ��] �$# � � #6T�� � � ��] �%# �& � - ��*3*�*�� # * T - ]�69/$&)��D3`�,%.)J':9/�='Y'*9/3l� +.)*3���N=�=':$&� %/)J4/3CN@$<�=':3l7V�?� � ':9/3g':�?-/3iN=�,2&-/3l�=7�':9/3i4/$<�,5 %/� )�':$&;l+O>x�,%x3C�*�*�,�# ��^ # �J�*3�!.�*3�)?3�%O':)��,+/)*3C�?N=�=':$&� % 3C�*�?� �*)CX6$<%/;C2<-.4/$<%.5w3��?�*� �?)p� %³)*!8�='*${�=2Y�,%.4�':3C��!#� �*�,2�)*;`�=2<3C)p':98��'�,�?3g)?���,2<2&3���':98�=%o'*9/3i5,�*$&4x;�3C2<2�)?$<EC3l�,%.4t':9/�='J�,�*3g$<%O'*�*�@4/-/;�3C4x+O>�':9/3��82}':3C��^�LM%o':9/3i�='*���,)*!/9/3C�*$&;)*;C$<3C%/;�3B2<$}':3C�:�='*-/�*3=X=':9.$<)_$<)�0(%/�1��%U�,)��*3�!.�*3�)?3�%O'P��':$}N 3�%.3�)*)a3C�*�*�,��^��$}N 3�%g':9/3�5 2&� +8�,2O)?;`�,2&3B�,7u':9/3c48�=':�-/)?3�4o$<%�':9.$<)��,!/!.2<$&;`�='*$<�,%vX.��3��/%/4�$&'�4/$}´�;�-/2}'�':�D)*3C!8�,�*�=':3��?3�!/�?3�)*3C%O'P�='*$&N,3�%/3C)*)��,%/4�� +.)*3���N=�=':$&� %8�,23��?�*� �?)�^�£j3F�,)?)*-/�D3g':98�='('&� T # � ��*�*3*�� # ! ] � �*) ! T�[ ��+

�-, ]PX ��9/3��?3 , $&)��D;��1N=�,�*$<�,%/;C3l���='*�*$²���=%/4+ � $&)D��)*;`�=2<3�!8�=�:�,�D3C'*3��C^rG8� �l'*9/3�-/%/$}N=�,�*$<�='*3�4/$<�,5 %/� )�':$&; # � - �,%/4w��3o�,)*)?-/�D3�':98�=' , $&)D�)*;��,2<�,�63��(-8�,2v'*�D� %/3,^ ���,':3�'*98�='�b�(-8�='*$<� %jT - ]c4/�@3�)6%/�,'�$&%/;C� �*!#� �:��':3�!#� )*)?$<+/2&3g�,4/4/$}':$}N 3�+/$<�,)?3�)��,7':9.3p;��,��!.-.':3C�l;��@4/3=X")*$&%/;C3,Xa�,)g�D3�%O':$&� %/3C4m3`�,�?2<$&3��CX"':9/3C)*3�)*9/� -.2<4w+#3��=;�;��,-/%O':3�4w7V�,�g+O>~':9.3�7h�,;|'':9/�='Y'*9/3F4/$<�,5 %/�,)?':$&;�)��D3��,)*-/�?3F':3C��!#3��*�=':-.�*3F;P98�=%/5 3,^g�o-/2&'*$<!.2<$&;`�='*$&N,3D+/${�=)*3�)��=�*3F%/�='�;��,%/)*$&4/3��?3�43�$}':9.3���X8)?$<%.;�3�':9/3C)*3i�,�*3�4/$}´�;�-/2}'�':�D3�)�':$&����':3g$<%t�U;`�,2&$<+.�:�='*$<� %�!/�?� +/2&3�� 2&$<0=3�':9/3�� %/3���3i;C� %/)?$<4/3C�$&%o'*9/$<)6��� �*0 ^

�69/3FN=�,2&-/3U�,7 #�T�� � ��]6$&)�-/%/0(%/�1��%~7V� �Y5,3�%/3C�:�,2�T #'� ��]:Xe)?���B3F'*�*3`��'�$&'��,)����:�=%/4/� � !/�*�@;�3C)*)C^�t� �?3J)?!K3C;�$}�8;`�=2<2}> X.��3��=)*)*-.��3J':98�=' #�T�� ��.&]�;��,�*�*3C)*!#� %/4/)c':�l�F���,-/)*)?${�=%p!/�?�u;C3�)*)C^£r3��D�u4/3C2 )*-/;P9!/�?�u;C3�)*)l+(>k)?!K3C;�$}7 >u$&%/5~�o��3��,%m�,%.4w�t)�'P�='*$<�,%8�,�?>k;C��N=�,�?${�=%/;�3�7V-/%/;C'*$<�,%v^t�69.$<)i$<)g':9/3�)?'P��':$&)?':$&;`�=23��(-/$}N=�,2&3�%O'B�D�@4/3�2/'*98�='��,2&2<�1��)7V� ��7h�,)�'��,!/!/�?�1�u$&���=':$&� %/)':��':9.3�%(-/�D3C�*$&;`�,2 )*$&�l-.2{�='*� ��^_£r3��,)?)*-/�D3':9/�='(/�T #�T�� ���1]*] �"0JT�� ���1]>�21�X/��9/3��?3�0��,%/4�1 �,�*3431�M4.$<�D3�%.)*$&� %8�,2vN,3�;C'*� �*)C^��69.3C>�4/3|�8%/3i�U2<$&%/3`�=�;��,�l+/$&%8�='*$<� %¶�,7�3|°e3C;C':)U4.-/3�':� 2&�u;��=':$&� %/)F�,%/4¶!8�,�*�,�D3C':3C�lN=�,2&-/3�)C^r�69/3�;C��N=�,�?${�=%/;�3�7V-/%.;C':$&� %m$&)5 $}N 3C%x+O>

;C�1NRT #�T�� �%���1] ��#�T�� & ��� � ]*] �"5.T6� ��� � ]7+ ��8 � , � & � T�ZO]7V� ��)*� �D3�;C� �*�?3�2<�=':$&� % 7V-/%/;|':$&� %95.T:. �;.&]:^ �69(-/)�X���3 �,�*3��,)*)?-/�D$<%/5m)?3�!8�=�:�,+/$&2&$&'M>�+K3|'M�B3C3�%"���=%/4��^tsu$<%.;�3�'*9/3��?3��,�?3��OZ�t4/$}°K3��*3C%O'F!#� $<%O'*)��D':9/3D7V-/2&2�;C�1N,�=�*$<�,%/;�3����=':�?$}�~7V� �lsu� $&)l�,7B4/$&��3C%/)*$&� %

- [

Page 11: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

� � � Z,[ ¢ � � � Z=[��=%/4t�=7�4/$&�D3�%/)?$<� %x�� �:� � � ¢ �� �:� � �D7V�,� ( H X )?�/X8)*3C!8�,�:�=+/$<2&$}'M>t$&)�0,3C>�'*��+.-/$<2&4/$&%/5�t�D�@4/3�2a':9/�='F;��,%r+#3��/'?':3C4r��$&'*9m�,%w$}':3C�:�='*$&N,3�!/�?�u;C3�4/-/�?3,^tG8� �Fs@� �,%/4 ( H XR�B3��,)*)?-/�D3p':98��'� &�� ) ! T � � , ]P^a�69/$&)�>u$&3�2&4/)�':9/3�!/�?$<�,�64/$<)�':�?$<+/-u':$&� %t7V� � , X

��T , ]�� 3|�u!�� � � Z '*�1T , � ��� ]�� , � � � � ���9/3C�*3 � � -�� ��� �&�� ��� & � �& ^ �J�=':3Y'*98�='���T , ]a$&)6!/�*�,!K3C�B7V� � ��� Z # � - ^aG8� ��su���B3���$&2<2K-/)*3�'M���;��,%('*�*� 2 �?-/%/)�Xu� %/3�;�� �?�*3C)*!#� %/4/)B'*��� � - Zg�,%.4�':9.3Y�,'*9/3��a':��� � q - ^asu�i$<%�+K�=':9p;��,)*3C)B':9.3J!/�?$<�,�$&)�!/�*�,!K3C��^aG8� � ( H ��3�-/)?3��l;�� %O'*�*� 2K�*-/%p��$}':9 � � �O[uXu$&�D!/2&>@$&%/5U':98��'���T , ]a$<)B%/�,'�!.�*� !#3��C^ �J�,'*3':9/�='��B3��,�*3��,)?)*-/�D$&%/5t'*98�='�':9.3�;C�1N,�=�*$<�,%/;�3C)l�,7c':9.3�� +.)*3���N=�=':$&� %/)i�,%/4~':9/3D;C2<$&���=':3��D�u4/3C2<)i�,�?3!/�?� !K�,�?':$&� %8�=2�^��69(-/)CX.':9.3�4/3�!#3�%.4/3�%/;C3�)?'*�*-/;|':-/�?3�$<%�':9/3Y'*3��D!#3��:��':-/�?3�4/$<�,5 %/� )�':$&;�)�$&)B;��,!.'*-/�*3C4�+(>�,2&2�'*9/�*3C3F)*�,-/�*;C3�)��,7$&%.7V� �?���=':$&� %v^�G8� �?3�)�'�3C'��,2h^�T�Z,[ [@]�$<�D!/2&$&;�$}':2}>x���,0=3F':9/3i):�,�D3U�,)?)*-/�D!.'*$<�,%v^�69/$&)U$<)l-/)*-8�=2<2}>w�?3C7V3��?�*3C4¶'*��$&%w':9/3�;C2<$&���=':3�2&$}':3��*�=':-.�*3��,)F-.%.7V� �*;C3�4m� �l%8�=':-.�:�,2aN=�,�*$<�,+/$&2<$}'M>m�=%/4;`�=%/%/�,'B+K3�3C)?'*$<���='*3�4�7V�*� � '*9/3Y� +.)*3���N=�=':$&� %8�,2K48�=':�F�,2&� %/3Y+#3�;��,-/)?3�':9/3��?3�;C� �*4/)��,�*3�':�@�F)*9/�,�?'B7V�,�':9.3 � [�� - [ [���> 3��,�6':$&��3C)*;��,2<3C)��,7$&%O':3��?3�)�'`^ H %�$<�D!#� �?':�,%O'Y�,-.':!/-u'��,7�,-/�Y�D�@4/3�2�$<)Y�,%�3C)?':$&���=':3i�,7':9.3g-.%.7V� �*;C3�4�N=�,�*$<�,+/$&2<$}'M> X +8�=)*3�4o� %t�,2&2e':9/�?3�3g�`N=�,$<2<�,+/2&3�'M>@!K3C)J�,7"48�=':�.^

��3C�8%.3��6���='*�*$²��� �+� 2 032�)*-/;P9g':98�='��(� & ��5.T�� �-� � � &��f]:^�9�3|' �_T ��] ��T65/T!� � � �"�"�1��*�*�* ��5/T!� � 2 ��"�f]*] � ^ 9R3C'�#mT7.&]'�%$ 0�T�� � ��.&] �3*�*�* �-0JT�� ! ��.&]'& ���"( 0 !eXR�,%/4~2&3C'�# �%$)#mT � � ] ��*�*3*��!#mT � 2 ]'& � ��� ! 2 0*(,X':9.3�%o-/)*$&%/5�3��(-8�='*$<� %.)FT - ]��,%/4rT�Z(]:X+ !N 3�;@T ,D]�, � ) !.- �0/ 221 +3+ #mT%��]>�# , 1"��+ � + T -�� 8 � ] , 8 � �_T �R]>�*4 ,

8 � �_T%��]54 , 8 � �64 , ,7, � T � ]

��9/3C�*3DN 3�;@T7.&]J4/3C%/�,':3C)g'*9/3D� !#3��:��':$&� %j�=7�)?':�,;P0($<%.5t':9.3�;C� 2<-.��%.)l�,7����=':�?$}�k$&%O':�t��N,3�;C'*� �i�,%/4844/3C%/�,':3C)�'*9/3 /��*� %/3C;P0,3C�J!/�?�u4.-/;C'�^

�69/3��?3U$<)J%/��%8��':-/�*�,2_4.$<)�'P�,%/;C3F$&%x':9/3l)*!8�,;C3F�,7;C2<$&���=':3l!8�,�:�=��3|':3C�*)Y'*98�='Y��$&2&2_9/3C2<! -.)�4/3C�/%/3�U;�� �?�*3C2{�='*$<�,%o7V-/%.;C':$&� %vX8)?����3g;�� %/)?$<4.3���3`�,;P9t;�� �D!#� %/3C%('J)*3C!8�,�*�=':3C2&>��=%/4t2&3C'

5.T6� ��� � ]+� 5 � T:9 � �;9 ����< � ] 5 ��T:9 �"�=9 � � ��< �C] 5 � T:9 � �;9 � � ��< � ] �

��9/3C�*3�5 �WT:9 � ��9 �� ]"� 3��u!?>1� -�� < �� 9 � �69 �� A@(^$��3��*3B< ���D3`�,)?-/�*3C)i'*9/3p;C� �*�?3�2<�=':$&� %k�:�,%/5,3�$&%j'*9/3�)*�,�D3-/%/$}':)F�,)C9 �M^xsu�/X"2{�,�?5 3�N=�,2&-/3C)F�,7D< �B$<�D!/2}>k':98�='i':9/3�;�� �?�*3C2{�='*$<�,%w��$<2&2�+#3�)?���=2<2c� %/2}>j7V�,�i!#� $&%('*)':9/�='D�,�?3�N 3C�?>w7h�=�F�,!8�=�?'`^ �69.3�)*3C!8�,�:�=+/$<2&$}'M>¶�,)*)?-/�D!.':$&� %¶$&)lN 3C�?>w;C� �D�D� %¶$<%w'*9/3�2&$&'*3��:��':-/�?3��,7)?':�=':$&)?'*$<;��,2��D�@4/3�2&$<%.5��,7c;�� �D!/-.'*3���� -u':!/-.'�Xv)*3C3,Xv7V� �J3|�.�,�D!/2&3,X�Q"�=-/2<�kT�Z,[ [ � ]PXK��9.��4/$<)?;�-/)?)*3C)i':9.3;P9/� $&;�3��,7�4/3|7h�,-/2}'�!/�*$&� �?)�7V�,�B':9/3�!/�,�:�,�D3|':3��?)��,7_�F)*3�!/�,�:�,+.2<3�;��,�*�*3C2{��':$&� %�7V-/%/;C'*$<�,%o$&%�':9/3g�t�='E3C�*%;�2<�,)?)�^

� ��� ��� # � 5 � � �����F��! � # $ �S��,2&$<+.�:�='*$<� %l!/�*� +.2<3C��)��,�*3�0@%.����%F'*��+#3B$&2<2@!K�,)*3�4l$<%F'*9/3B)?3�%/)?3B':98��'��,7 '*3�%l'*$<�D3�)"4/$&°K3��?3�%O';C� %.�85 -@��:��':$&� %/)R�,7u!8�,�*�,�D3C':3C�vN=�,2<-.3�)�!/�*�@4/-/;C3a)*$&��$&2<�,�R�*3C)*-/2}':)C^G8� �?'*-/%8�='*3�2}>�$&%�'*9/$&)_�=!/!/2&$<;��=':$&� %�0(%/�1��2<3C4/5 3�,+#� -.'i2<$&0,3C2&>jN=�,2<-.3�)F�,7B':9/3�;�2&$<���='*3�!8�,�*�,�D3C':3C�*)F$&)F�`N=�,$&2{�=+/2<3=^ su�t�B3�;��,%w)?!K3C;�$}7 >r)?;�$&3�%O':$}�8;`�=2<2}>)*�,-/%/4o!/�*$&� �*)67V� �6)?-/;P9x!/�,�:�,�D3|':3��?)�^

�69/3D!/�*$&� ��7V� � � � � � � ;C� �*�?3�)?!K� %.4/)�':�o��+K3|'P��4/$&)?':�?$<+.-.':$&� %~��$&'*9k)?-/!/!#� �?'g� %³Th[ � @]��=%/4!8�,�*�,�D3C'*3��*)pT � * � ��@]P^D�69/3�!/�*$&� ��7V� � ,��� � $<)g)*!#3�;C$&�83C4m�,)g��+K3|'P��4/$<)�':�?$<+/-u':$&� %j��$}':9j)*-/!/!#� ��'

- -

Page 12: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

� %�Th[ � -�� ]U�,%.4 !8�,�*�,�D3C':3C�*)~T�Z * �O� � - �@]P^��69/3�!/�?$<�,��7V� � � � ��������$<)p�r+K3|'P�r4.$<)�':�*$&+/-.'*$<�,%�� %T � - * � ��* � ]c��$&'*9x!8�=�:�,�D3C'*3��?)UTh� �:�u]P^a£�$}':9t'*9/3g3|�u;�3C!.':$&� % �,7_':9/3g!/�*$&� ��� %+,� � � X/�B3i+8�,)*3C4x':9.34/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.':$&� %/)D7V� � � ��� �=%/4 � � �%� !8�,��':2}>m� %m':9/3�!.�*3CN@$&� -/)D�B�,�*0w$&%�G �,�*3�)�'D3C'��,2h^�T�Z=[ [OZ(]g�=%/4G8� �*3C)?'�3C'Y�,2h^�T�Z,[,[@]P^��69/3���$<4.'*9/)J��3��?3l;P9/�,)*3�%t':��3|�@':3C%/4x��3�2&2��,-.':)?$<4/3g':9/3g�:�=%/5 3�)*-/5,5 3�)�':3�4x+(>2&$<0=3�2&$<9/�@�@4/)�7V�*� ��G8� �*3C)?'�3|'��,2h^T�Z,[ [@]B��9/$&2<3F'*9/3F)*9/�,!K3C)��B3C�*3U4/3C)*$&5 %/3C4k'*��+K3U�*�=':9.3���4/$}°K-/)*3U$&%':9.3�$&%O':3��?$<�,��TV$�^¡3,^&X�'*9/3�;�-/�i-/2{��':$}N 3�4/3C%/)*$}'M>~7V-/%/;|':$&� %w�,!.!/�*�`�u$<���='*3�2}>k2<$&%/3`�=��^²]��69/3�)?3p�:�=%/5 3�)i�,�?3�,2&)*��)*-/!/!#� ��':3�4t+O>�':9/3g2<�@;`��':$&� %/)��,7"'*9/3i)�'P�='*3|���,7 ��'*9/3|�M�,�?' � � �iS6�o)���3�2&2���$}':9.$<%o':9/3g!8�,�*�,�D3C':3C�)*!/�,;�3pT�su�,0,� 2&�1N�3C'J�,2h^<X#Z=[ [ � ]:^��69/3g2<$&0,3C2<$&9/�@�u4/)��,7"�U���@4/3C2R� -.':)?$<4.3g'*9/3�)?3i�?3�5 $&� %/)��,�?3g%.3`�,�6EC3��*�.^G8� ��':9/3�!.�*$&� �l� % �AX_�B3�-.)*3p'*9/3p£j3�+/)�':3��F�,%/4�su� 0=� 2&��N T�Z=[ [ [@]Y3�)�':$&����':3��,)l+8�,)*3C4m� %w3��.!#3���'3�2&$&;�$}'P�='*$<� %l)?':-.4.>l�=7#�t� �?5O�,%U�,%.4�/�3�$}':9�T -1q qO� ]:^_�69.3�)*3B�*3�)?-/2}':)"��3��?3�+8�,)?3�4U� %g':9/3�-/%/4/3C�*)?':�,%/4/$&%/5�,7B;�2&$<���='*3�)?;�$&3�%/;C3�3|�u!#3��?'*)l$&%j'*9/3�3��,�*2}> -1q q [.df)���9/�o�B�,-/2<4r98�`N 3�;�� %/)?$<4.3��*3C4m�D�u4/3C2a�*3�)?-/2}':)F�=)��3�2&2 �,);P98�,%/5,3�)a4/-/�?$<%/5�'*9/3�Z,[�����;�3C%O':-/��>��,%/4U':9/365,2{�,;C${�=2}��$<%O':3C�*5 2<�,;C${�,2.�*3�;C� �*4.)�7V� ��,+#� -.''*9/36!8�,)�'� [ [uXn[ [,[l> 3`�=�*)�^

I�3C5O�,�?4/$<%.5g'*9/3J�=':9/3C�c!/�,�:�,�D3|':3��?)�$&%D':9/3��D�u4.3�2hX@��3J9/�1N,3Y�=2<�?3`�,4.>D4.$<)?;�-/)?)*3�4�'*9/3�!/�*$&� ���3J-/)?37V� � , X���9/$<;P9j$<)g+8�,)?3�4j� %w�gS6� )*$&�l-/2<�=':$&� %/)C^�G8� ��':9/3D�?3�5 �?3�)*)?$<�,%w!8�,�*�,�D3C':3C�*)�����3��,)?)*-/�D3��y �='c!/�?$<�,� ��T61Y]�� - ^�G �,��':9/3�)*;��,2&3J!8�=�:�,�D3C'*3��?)�+ � �,%.4 8 � �B3�%/�,'*$<;C3�7V�?� ��b�(-8�='*$<� %�T � ]�'*98�='a':9.3!/�?�u4/-.;C' 8 � + � ;`�,%o+#3�7h�,;C'*� �*$&E�3C4�7V�?� � '*9/�*3C3��,7_'*9/3�7V� -/�6+.2<�@;P0()�$&%�':9/3�;C��N=�,�?${�=%/;�3����=':�?$}�K^a�69/$&)$&��!.2<$&3�)�':98�='�':9.3�'M���Y!8�,�*�,�D3C'*3��*)"�,�*3c%/3��,�*2}>g-/%u�M$&4/3C%('*$&�8�,+/2&3,^�LM%i!/�:�,;|':$&;�3=X )*3C!8�,�:��':3B3C)?'*$<���='*$<� %i�,7+ � �=%/4 8 � $<)B!K� )?)*$&+/2&3�� %/2}>p+O>�-/)*$&%/5lN,3���>�$&%.7V� �*���='*$&N,3�!/�?$<� �?)�^LM%�'*9/$<)B�,!/!/2&$&;`�='*$<� %���3Y�.� 8 � � -�,%/4t2<3|' ��T�+ � ] � -�� + � ^��69/3l!.�*$&� �*)�7V� �6':9/3g�:�=%/5 3�!8�,�*�,�D3C':3C�*)7< �_�,�*3 ��T0< ��] � -�� < �%�� � - ��*�*�* � � ^-B3C�*5 3C�F3C'D�=2�^BT�Z,[,[ - ]�)?9/�1�B3C4m':98�='l!K�,)?':3C�*$&� �F$&�D!/�*� !.�*$&3C'M>w;C� -/2&4m�*3C)*-/2}'U7V�*� � '*9/3�;P9/� $&;�3��=7��,%$&��!.�*� !#3���!/�*$&� �67V� �6':9.3i�*�,%/5 3g!8�,�*�,�D3C':3C�J�=7�,%o$<)?�,':�?� !/$&;F���,-/)?)*$<�,%t�/3�2&4v^��69/3i�*3�)?-/2}':)Y$&%tQ"�,-/2&�T�Z=[ [ � ]i)*9.����'*98�='�$<�D!/�?� !/�*$&3C'M>��,7Y':9/3t!K� )�':3C�*$&� ��$&)p%.�,'��k!/�*�,+/2<3C� ��9/3�%�)?3�!8�,�*�,+/$&2<$}'M>³�,7�':9.3;��,�*�*3C2{��':$&� %o7V-.%/;C'*$<� %o$&)J�=)*)*-.��3C4v^

� � � � � 13 �1 ��� 1 ��� ��125 ���+ "1 $ �����H 'M>@!/$<;��,2(7V3`�='*-/�*3c�,7/;��,2&$<+/�*�=':$&� %g!/�*�,+/2<3C�D)_7V� ��;��,��!.-.':3C�_�D�@4/3�2&)"$&)R':98�='_!/�?$<� ��$&%.7V� �?����':$&� %i�,%i':9.3!8�,�*�,�D3C'*3��*)�':�U+#3Y;`�=2<$&+/�:��':3�4�$&)�-/)?-8�,2&2&>�7h�,$&�*2}>�$&%.y8-.3�%O':$<�,2v� %�'*9/3Y!#� )�':3��?$<�,���*3C)*-/2}':)C^ 9�-8�=%('*$&7 >@$&%/5':9.3��1N,3��*2<�,!�+K3|'M�B3C3�%�!/�?$<�,�a�,%/4�!K� )�':3C�*$&� �a4/$<)�':�?$<+/-u':$&� %/)a7V� ��':9/3�;`�=2<$&+/�:��':$&� %�!/�,�:�,�D3|':3��?)a!/�*�1N@$<4.3�)�U�D3`�,)?-/�*3g�,7�':9/3�$&%.7V� �*���='*$<�,%t$&%�':9/3g48�=':���=%/4�':9/3��D�u4.3�2��,+#� -.'�)?-/;P9x!8�=�:�,�D3C'*3��?)�^

H �D3`�,)?-/�*36�=78':9/3��1N,3��*2<�,!D+#3C'M��3�3�%D'M����!/�*� +/�,+/$&2<$}'M>F4/3C%/)*$}':$&3�)a$&)�5 $}N 3C%�+O>i':9/3 -�98�='*':�,;P98�,��>(>O�4/$&)?':�,%/;�3=^��69.$<)�$<)�4/3|�8%/3C4vX87V� ��'M�B��4/3C%/)*$}':$&3�)�� � Tv]��=%/4��2��T�v]B�,)

�T�� � ���F�C] ����� � � T�v]��2��T�v]��� ��� � � Tv]�F��Tv] �2��T�v]��� ��� �F��Tv]� � Tv] � � T�v]��� *SB2&3`�,�?2&>� �T�� � ���F�C]&� �T��F� ��� � ]PX� �T�� � ���2��] �¤[m�=%/4vX�+(> A,3�%/)?3�%vd¡)o$<%/3C�(-8�,2&$&'M>,X� �T�� � ���2��]! - ^�t� �?3��1N 3C�" �T�� � ���F�C] � - $&7"�,%/4�� %.2&>p$&7#� � ���F���,%.4$ �T�� � ���F�C] � [F$&7"�,%/4�� %.2&>�$}7%� � �,%/4&�2��9/�1N,3%/���1N 3C�*2<�,!v^psu�' �T�� � ���F�C]J!/�?�1Nu$&4/3C)l��+#� -/%/4/3C4j)�>@���D3|':�*$&;p�D3��,)*-/�?3��=7�'*9/3D)*$&��$&2<�,�*$}'M>~+K3|'M�B3C3�%'M���F4/$&)?':�?$<+.-.':$&� %/)C^)(e9.� -��,%/4�s.�,%/)����T�Z=[ [O\(]"-/)*3J$&'�'M�B�l;�� �D!8�,�?3J'*9/3Y� -u':!/-.'*)B�,7R�,%��='*���,)*!/9/3C�*$&;':�*�,%/)?!K� ��'F�D�@4/3�2��*-/%w-.%/4/3��i'M�B� 4/$}°K3��*3C%O'D+K� -.%/48�,��>j;C� %/4/$}':$&� %/)C^ �69/3C>j7V� -/%/4j':98�='* �T�� � ���F�|]!/�?��N@$&4/3�)")*$&��$&2<�,��$&%.7V� �*���='*$<�,%i':��':9/3�!K3C�*;C3�%O'P�,5,3��,78�1N 3C�*2<�,!U+#3C'M��3�3�%F'*9/3B9.$<5 9.3�)?'�4/3�%/)?$&'M>i$&%('*3���N,�=2;��,�*�*3C)*!#� %/4/$&%/5�':�'� � �,%.4~'*98�='�;C� �*�?3�)?!K� %.4/$<%.5o'*�+�2��7V� ����5 $}N 3�%k!/�?� +8�,+/$&2&$&'M>,^UG8� ���l-.2&'*$&N=�,�?${�='*3)*3|'*'*$<%/5,)�X, �T�� � ���2��]c$<)�3`�=)*$&3���':�D;`�,2&;�-.2{�='*3�':98�,%o$&%('*3���N,�=2R��N,3��?2{�,!.)�^

- Z

Page 13: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

LM%�� -/�Y�,!/!/2&$&;`�='*$<� % � ��;C� �*�?3�)?!K� %.4�':�p3C$&'*9/3��Y!/�*$&� ��� �Y!#� )?'*3��?$<� ��4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.':$&� %/)��=7�':9/3i;�2&$<���='*3!8�,�*�,�D3C'*3��*)C^ �69/3k2<�='*'*3��o�,�*3 0(%/�1��% �,%/2&> -/! '*�³�¶!/�?� !K�,�?':$&� %8�=2<$}'M>�;��,%/)?':�,%O'`^ 9R3|'�� �WTv] �3 �MT�v] � � � �� � - ��Z@X.':9/3C%

�T�� � ���2�C] � + � � � � T�v] �F��T�v]����� � � � T�v]��2��T�v] �� , �0� � ��/���� 3 � T��j]

3 ��T��j]� �� � /�� 3 ��T��j]

3 � T��j]� �� �� �0�

��

�/���� 3 � T��j]

3 ��T��j] /�� 3 ��T��j]3 � T��j]� �0� � �

��9/3C�*34/�����4/3�%.�,':3C)B':9/3J3|�u!#3�;C':�=':$&� %���$}':9��?3�)*!#3�;|'�':�i':9/3J4/3�%/)?$&'M> � �M^su�/X.$}'�$&)B!#� )?)*$&+/2<3J':�F� +u'P�,$&%�,%j�,!/!/�?�`�.$&���=':$&� %r'*�+ �T�� � ���F�C]J7V�*�,� ):�,�D!/2&3�)i�,7 � � �,%.4 �2�1X_-/)?$<%.5t':9.3�2<�`� �,7�2<�,�?5 3D%@-.�l+#3��*)C^£�9/3C%�� � T����-�A]:X@)?�l':9/�='���;�� %/)?$<)�':)6�,7e'M�B�U+/2&�@;P0��=7��:�,%/4.� ��N=�,�*$<�,+/2&3�)CX.':9/3J���,�*5 $&%8�,2&) � �WT��@];`�=%t+#3�;`�,%�+#3g;��,2&;�-/2<�=':3C4��,)

� �MT��@]+� � � �WT�� �g]�� �WT��g]������ -� �� & � � �"T�� � - & 1 ]��9/3C�*3�� - & 1 � � �M^ �J�=':3�':98��'�� ��T�� ��]a��$<2&2R-/)*-/�,2<2}>�+#3�'*9/3�7V-/2&2v;�� %.4/$&'*$<�,%8�,2R�,7 �.^

� ��� )+0?�7. �802�8$ �13 � # $�69/3�4/3|'P�,$&2&)F�,76':9.3�$<�D!/2&3��D3C%(':�=':$&� %¶�,76'*9/3�)?':�=':$&)?'*$<;��,2��D�@4/3�2c7V� 2<2&�1� �,2<�,%/5x':9.3�2<$&%/3C)F�,7Ys.�,%/)���3C'��,2h^�T�Z,[ [O\(]:^�£r3��?-/%��r)?$<�D$&2{�=����S6��S ':�j):�,�D!/2&3x7V�?� � ':9/3�!#� )�':3��?$<�,�p4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.':$&� %��,7��,2<2!8�,�*�,�D3C'*3��*)p$<% '*9/3��D�u4.3�2hX�7V�,�p3`�=;P9 �,%/3x�,7�'*9/3�4/$<�,5 %.� )?'*$<;C)�)*3�!/�,�:�='*3�2}> ^ LM%�� �?4/3���':�w� +u'P�,$&%':9.3�!K�,)?':3C�*$&� �l4.$<)�':�*$&+/-.'*$<�,%��=7 x+8�,)?3�4m� %j':9/3�$&%.7V� �?���=':$&� %w� %r���,�*3p'*98�,%w� %.3�4/$<�,5 %/� )�':$&;,X���3�,)?)*-/�D3r;C� %/4/$}':$&� %8�=2g$&%/4/3C!K3C%/4/3C%/;�3=^ �69(-/)CXi-.)*$&%/5 �¶)*-/!#3��W�M$&%/4/3�� � %.3k�,�o'M���³'*�³4/3C%/�,'*3j':9.3�(-8�,%O':$}':$&3�)i':98�='l4/3C�/%/3p':9.3p)?':�=':$&)?'*$<;��,2c���@4/3C2c7V� ��'M����4/$}°e3C�*3�%O'U4.${�,5,%/� )?'*$<;C)�X���3p98�`N,3p':98��'l':9.3��� $&%O'a2<$&0,3C2<$&9/�@�u4 ��T%! � ��� � � ! � ��� � �� � �� �C]�$&)�7h�,;|':� �?$<EC3�4��,)':9/36!.�*�@4/-/;C'a�=7 � � T�� � �!� � �� � ]_�=%/4�F��T�! � ��� � �� �C]:X.��9/3��?3� ��4/3�%/�=':3�)��,2&2e'*9/3�!8�,�*�,�D3C':3C�*)��,'*9/3���'*98�,% F-/)*3C4t$&%�':9/3��D�@4/3�2e7V�,��4/$²��,5 %.� )?'*$<;�?^m��$&N,3�%³��!/�*$&� � ��T �� � �! �C] � ��TO] ��T� � ] ��T� �C]g$}'D$<)U!#� )*)?$<+.2<3�':� �?-/%��k��S6��S '*�� +.':�,$&%t)*�,�D!/2<3C)J7V�?� � ��T �� � �� �. ! � ��� � � ! � ��� � ]:^B�69/$&)J�,!/!/�?�O�,;P9x$&)�;�� �D!/-.':�=':$&� %8�=2<2}>�4/3����,%.4u�$&%/5��,%.4l2&$<0=3�2}>i)?2<�1�m'*�Y;��,%(N,3��?5 3,^ H 4/4/$}':$&� %8�,2&2}> X,��3B�=�*3c$<%O':3C�*3C)?':3C4U$<%i� +/)?3��?N@$&%/5�9/�1�m'*9/3�!#� )�':3��?$<�,�4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.':$&� %t;�� %/4.$&'*$<� %/�,2R� %&! � ��� ��$&)�;P98�,%/5,3�4x+O>�'*9/3�-/)*3��,7�':9/3�4/$<�,5 %.� )?'*$<; ! � ��� � ^

£r3o)?':�,�?'�+O>¶�*-/%.%/$<%.5w�j��S6��S ':�k5 3|'p)*�,�D!/2<3C)p�,7 ��T ! � ��� � ]:^³£j3o'*9/3�%³�*-/%��k)?3�;C� %/4��S6��S 7V� � ��T ! � ��� � � ! � �!� � ]:^ LM%�':9/$&)�;`�=)*3�':9.3x7V-/2&2Y;��,%/4/$}':$&� %8�,2�7V� � r$&)�!/�?� !#� �?'*$<� %/�,2�'*���T " � � ! � ��� �P]��2��T%! � �!� � �� �C]:^tsu�/X_'*��� +.':�,$&%w�t)*�,�D!/2&3��,7 ��B3�;`�,%w!#3���7V� �*�z���t3C'*�*� !#� 2&$<)W��Y�=)?':$&%/5k)?'*3�! �=%/4³4.�:�`���~!/�*� !#� )?3�4�):�,�D!/2&3,X�)*�`> $#`Xa7V�*� � ��T � � ! � �!� � ]:^��69.3x�,;C;�3C!.'P�,%.;�3�:��':$&�j��$&2<2J+K3t5 $&N,3�%�+O>�':9/3t2<$&0,3C2<$&9/�@�u4 �*�=':$&� �2��T%! � �!� � $#��� �|] � �2��T%! � ��� � �� �C]:^ £j3�-/)?3x':9.3�,!/!.�*�`�u$<���='*$<� % ��T " � � ! � ��� � ]�� ��T ! � ��� � ]��,%/4~-/)*3U'*9/3U):�,�D!/2&3�)�7V�?� ��'*9/3F�8�*)�'i��S6��S �=)!/�?� !K�,):�,2&)67V� ��':9/3�)?3�;��,%/4x� %.3,^

% & ����� �C� �

£j36;�� %/)?$<4.3��*3C4�'M���i4.$<)�':�*$&+/-.'*$<�,%/)c7V�,�"':9/36;C2<$&���=':3�)�>u)�':3C� !/�*� !#3���':$&3�)C^c��%.3,X ':9/�='��$<2&28+#36�*3C7V3C�*�?3�4':���,)l':9.3�-/%/$}7V� �*��!/�*$&� �CX�;�� %.)*$&)?'D�,7�':9.3�!/�*�@4/-/;|'U�,76'*9/�*3C3�4/3�%/)?$&'*$<3C)U-/%/$}7V� �*���1N 3C�F':9/3��*�,%/5 3C)

- �

Page 14: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

� ��� � ���������� [.^ � � [u^ \ � � - ^f[ �

LM%u7V� �*���='*$&N,3iQ�?$<� � � [ � Zu^ -�� Z@^ � � �M[.^ �qO��� � ^n\ � � ^n[ � [.^f[ ���� [.^ � [u^ \ � � - ^¡�

(�%/$}7V� �*� Q�?$<� � � [ � � ^f[ \@^ �,q �M[.^ �qO��� � ^n\ - �/^ Z � [.^¡�

�_�,+/2&3iZ �csu-/�D���,��>��,7_'*9/3�!/�*$&� ��4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.':$&� %/)��,7�':9/3�;C2<$&���=':3�)?>@)�':3���!/�?� !#3��?'*$<3C)�^

0 1 2 3 4 5 6

02

46

8

Kv

S

0 1 2 3 4 5 6

−1.5

−1.0

−0.5

0.0

0.5

Kv

F aer

0 2 4 6 8

−1.5

−1.0

−0.5

0.0

0.5

S

F aer

G"$&5 -/�?3lZ � �*q��N}Nunqs}Nlxj�t�unq�ofuBp�qsrxlxu�qs�e�Zlwq�oEyvr8�¢ofu$lnmZj\�%�sq|h~}Nlxj�rx�Zrxlxj�h t�uwoKtXj%uwlwq�jar%�

T�[ � @] �1T�[ � -1� ]g�,%/4 T � - * � ��* � ]P^³�69/3t)?3�;C� %/4 $&)�'*9/3o� %/3o4/3�)?;��*$&+#3�4 $&%�su3C;C'*$<� % � ^ - X��,%.4³��$&2<2�+#3�*3|7V3��?�*3�4w'*� �,)g':9/3�$&%.7V� �?���=':$}N 3�!.�*$&� ��^ �J�,'*$<;C3p':98��'`X�$&%m+K�=':9w;��,)*3C)�X���3��,�*3��x!/�*$&� �?$B�,)?)*-/�D$&%/5':9/�='B'*9/3Y':9.�*3�3�!/�,�:�,�D3|':3��?)6�,�?3�$<%.4/3�!#3�%/4.3�%O'`^Bsu� �D3��(-8�,%O'*$<2&3�)�'*98�='64/3C)*;C�*$&+K3�'*9/3�;P98�,�*�,;C'*3��?$<)�':$&;�)�,7a+#�,':9 4.$<)�':�*$&+/-.'*$<�,%/)��,�*3l�*3�!#� ��':3�4 $&% �_�,+/2&3�Zu^��69/3U;��,%('*� -/�?)��,7a':9/3l+/$&N=�,�?${��':3F!/�?$<�,��4/3�%.)*$}':$&3�)�,�?3g!.�*3�)?3�%O':3C4x$&%xG_$<5 -.�*3iZu^

�!��� �����8�%#6����1 $ ��80?�:��� 13 ?� � � �� �8$ 5 �������£j3F)?':�,�?'*3�4 +O>�;C� %/)*$&4/3C�*$&%/5�':9/3U����4/$<�,5 %.� )?'*$<;=Xe':9/3i':�*3C%/4 $&% 4/3�3C!u�M�@;�3��,%�':3C��!#3��*�=':-.�*3�)C^ �J3��?3�A$&)D$<�?�*3C2<3|N,�=%('xT ':9/3�4/$<�,5 %.� )?'*$<;�$&)�� )?;`�,2<�,�|]:X�)?� �B3�2&3C'�0JT�� ���1]�� 0�T6�1]�� T - � 9 � ��9 � ��9 � ]>� X��$}':93 ���/^ H !K� )�':3C�*$&� �*$"��3D� +/)?3��?N,3U':98�='�'*9/3�Zu^ ��� �,%/4 ':9/3 q \u^ ��� �(-8�,%O'*$<2&3�)��,7a':9.3U4/$<)�':�?$<+/-u':$&� %/)�,7 � � ��.� - ��*�*3*��:�k�,�?3t�=2<2�!#� )?$&'*$&N,3o7V� �F'*9/3�$<%u7V� �*���='*$&N,3o!.�*$&� ��^¶�69/$&)D$<)��,2&)*�~':9/3�;��,)*3�7V� �F':9.3Zu^ ��� �,%.4�'*9/3 q \u^ ��� !#� )?'*3��*$&� �a�(-8�,%O':$&2&3�)B$&%D':9/3�-/%/$}7V� �?��!/�*$&� �a;`�=)*3,X(��$}':9p3��u;�3�!u':$&� %p�,7K':9/3JZu^ ����(-8�,%O':$&2&3t�,7�� � X��9/$&;P9�$&)D3��(-8�,2�'*� ���� - [ �� ^j£r3�%/�,'*3�':98��'U':9/$&)D$<�D!/2&$<3C)U':98�=' � � $&)��=2<�D� )�')*$&5 %/$}�8;��,%O':2}>¶!K� )?$&'*$&N,3,X�+.-.'�%/�,'D�(-/$}':3t�,%/4m':98��'U':9/$&)�$&)U':9/3�� %.2&>m4.${�,5,%/� )?'*$<;���9/3C�*3 ����98�,)��!#� )*$}':$}N 3�;��@3C´�;�$&3�%O'�^�su�/XR7V� ��+#�,'*9j!/�?$<�,�*)�X�':9.3�!#� )�':3��?$<�,�g;��,�*�?$<3C)i)?-/+/)�'P�,%O':$<�,2a3CN@$&4/3�%.;�3�'*98�='�':9.3+8�,)?3�2&$<%.3B7V� ������$<)_!K�,)*$}':$}N 3��=%/4F$&%/;��?3`�,)?$<%/5��,%O>i�=7/':9/3c':9/�?3�3�;�2&$<���='*3B)?>@)�':3�� !/�?� !K3C�?'*$<3C)"$&%/;��?3`�,)?3�)���F^

�_��;P9/3�;P0�'*9/3l�=+/$<2&$}'M>��,7"'*9/3i�D�@4/3�2v'*��!.�*3�4.$<;|'J'*9/3gN=�,2&-/3C)J�,7���� ��3i;P9/�,)*3l� � ;C� �l+/$&%8�='*$<�,%/)�,7B;�2&$<���='*3�!8�=�:�,�D3C'*3��?)F�='g�:�=%/4/� ��^�£j3�3|�u;�2&-/4/3C4w':9/� )?3�4/�='P��7V�*� � '*9/3�3�)?'*$<���='*$<�,%r!/�?�u;C3�4/-/�?3�,%/4~':9.3�%r�,+.'P�,$&%/3C4r):�=��!.2<3C)i7V�*�,� ':9/3C$<�6��� $&%O'l!#� )?'*3��?$<� ��!/�?3�4/$&;C'*$<�,%w4/$&)?':�?$<+.-.':$&� %/)C^��69/3p�?3�)?-/2&'*)�,�?3t)?9/�1��%�$<%�G_$<5 -.�*3 � ^��69/3C>��,�*3o+8�,)?3�4 �,% - [ [~):�,�D!/2&3�)�7V�*� �¤'*9/3x!/�?3�4/$&;C'*$&N,3 4/$&)?':�?$<+.-.':$&� %'P�=0,3�%�7V�*� � - [.Xf[ [ [�$}':3��*�=':$&� %/)��,7v'*9/3��xS6��S���$}':9��i2<�,5l�,7 - [ [.X(-/)?$<%/5F�,)B)�'P�,��':$&%/5iN=�,2&-/3J'*9/3Y2<�,)�'$}':3��*�=':3C)��,7���;P9/�,$<%k�,7 - [ [.Xf[ [ [�$}':3C�:�='*$<�,%/)�^l£j3D� +/)?3��?N,3�'*98�='�$&%k�,2<2"+/-.'�'M���t;��,)*3C)�TV%/� )�^ � �=%/4�(Z(]�'*9/3�!/�*3C4/$<;|':$}N 3�$&%O':3C�?N=�,28;��,%(':�,$&%/)�'*9/3�� +/)*3C�?N=�='*$<� %p�,%/4D':98��'c'*9/3���$<4.'*9/)c�,7v�D� )�'B$&%O':3���N=�,2<)��,�?3

- �

Page 15: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

0 10 20 30 40

0.000

0.001

0.002

0.003

0.004

Index

Degre

es Ce

ntigra

des/Ye

ar

G"$&5 -/�?3 � ��� uwjapeqs��lwq��fj\p�qsrxlxunqs�e�vlwq�oEy~�¢ofu$­\¸ }Nl �EÁ�u�}KyvpvoEhk���{rxja��ja��lxjap-��oEh���q|yv}Nlwq�oEyvr*of�SlnmZj&�%�sq|hk}Nlxj\rx�Zr©¥lxj�hRt�}Nun}Khkj%lxj%unr%���BmZj&q|yElxj%uw�Ù}f�sr8}Nunj��Kq��fj�y!�6�klnmZj\¬������¿}Kyvp����6�����R·Z�v}KyKlwqs��jara�Bq��EmEl$mv}Kyvp+¯����s}f�w¡L²}Kyvp��j%�¢l�mv}Kyvp-¯¢unjap�²Sq|yElxj%uw�Ù}f�sr��¢ofu�q|yZ�¢ofu�hk}Nlwq��fj�}Kyvp{��y�q��Âofu�h;t�unq�ofunr�uwjarntLja��lwq��fja���f���BmZjBrnh~}f�s�vpvoflwr��ofunuwjarwtXoEyvplxoklnmZj�tvuwjap�qs��lwq��fj�hkja}Ky�}Kyvp!lnmZj��s}Nuw�fj%u�pvoflwr$lxo~lnmZj�«�¨F��¬N­W±$«,oE�vlwte�Zl%�

)*���,2&2R;��,��!/�,�*3C4t':�U'*9/3�N,�=�*$<�,+/$&2<$}'M>�$&%o'*9/3�48�='P�u^H )*-/�D���,�?> �,7i':9/3~!#� )?'*3��?$<� ��4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.'*$<� % �,7l'*9/3k;�2&$<���='*3k)�>@)?':3C� !.�*� !#3���':$&3�)�7V� ������$&)

!/�?3�)*3C%O':3�4~$&%�':9/3i�8�*)�'Y':9.�*3�3l;�� 2&-/�D%/)��,7a�_�,+/2&3 � ^�£r3F)?3�3F)?-/+/)�'P�,%O':$<�,2�4.$&°K3��?3�%/;C3�)�+#3C'M��3�3�%~':9.3!#� )?'*3��*$&� �?)c�,+.'P�,$&%/3C4p-/%/4.3��':9/3�$&%.7V� �?����':$}N 3J�,%/4D':9/3�-/%/$}7V� �?��!/�*$&� �?)�X(3�)?!K3C;�$<�,2<2}>D7V� � � �,%/4 � � �%��^LM%U':9/3C)*3�'M����;`�,)?3�)':9/36���,�?5 $&%8�,2.!#� )�':3��?$<�,��4/3�%.)*$}':$&3�)c;�� �?�*3�)?!K�,%/4/$&%/5�':��':9.3�$<%u7V� �*���='*$&N,3�!.�*$&� ��,�?3;��,%/;�3C%('*�:�='*3�4o�,�?� -/%/4�)?���,2<2&3���N,�=2<-/3C)�':98�=%p':9/3Y� %/3�)B� +.'P�=$<%/3C4�7V� �a':9/3�-.%/$&7V�,�*��!/�*$&� ��^_£�9/3�%�':9.3N=�,2&-/3�)�$&% �"�=+/2<3 � �=�*3F;C� �D!8�,�*3C4 ':��':9.� )*3U$&% �"�=+/2<3�Z���3U� +/)?3���N 3U':98��'�':9/3U!#� )�':3��?$<�,��4/3�%.)*$}':$&3�)7V� 2&2<�1� '*9/3�+K3C98�`N@$<� �J�,7�':9/3g!/�*$&� �?)�^ H +#3C'*'*3���!/$&;C':-.�*3g�,7"'*9/$<)�)*$}':-/�=':$&� %x$&)�!/�*�1N@$<4.3�4x+O>�':9.3i!/2&�,'*)$&%xG"$&5 -/�?3��/^ �J3C�*3�':9/3�!#� )?'*3��?$<� ��4/3C%/)*$}':$&3�)J;�� �?�*3C)*!#� %/4/$&%/5�'*�����A�,�?3g!.2<�,'?':3C4o��$}':9o4/�,'?':3�4o;C> �,%2&$<%/3C)�^UG8� �J':9/3D$&%.7V� �*���='*$&N,3U!/�*$&� ����3D� +/)*3C�?N,3�'*98�='�'*9/3U!K�,)?':3C�*$&� ��4/3C%/)*$}':$&3�)g�,7 � �����,%/4 � �,�?3N 3C�?>i;�2&� )*3�':�J'*9/3B!.�*$&� �*)C^"�69/$&)"$&)"%/�='"':9.3B;`�=)*3�7V�,� ��������X,��9/3C�*3�'*9/3B!#� )�':3��?$<�,�")*9.����)")*-/+/)�'P�,%O'*${�,2&2}>2<�,�*5 3C�_':�,$<2&)�^"G8� ��'*9/3B-.%/$&7V�,�*��!/�*$&� �CX �,2&2@'*9/�*3C3B!#� )?'*3��?$<� �_4/3�%.)*$}':$&3�)a�,�?3B!/�?3C'*'M>�y ��'`^�YN,3��:�=2<2@�B3c�8%/4':9/�='�':9/3D2&$<0=3�2&$<9/�@�@4j� +/�='P�,$&%/3C4k7V�?� � ����;��,�*�?$<3C)i2&$}'*':2&3D$<%u7V� �*���='*$<� %j�,+#� -.'�'*9/3D;�2&$<���='*3�)�>u)�':3C�!/�?� !K3C�?'*$<3C)�^x£j3p� +.)*3���N 3�'*98�='`X_7V� � ��'*9/3�!#� )?'*3��*$&� �i4/3�%/)?$&'M>r)*9/�1��)U)?� �D3�$<�?�*3C5 -/2<�,�*$}':$&3�)CX�':9/$&)l$&)�t;C� %/)?3��(-/3�%.;�3��,7�'*9/3�7h�,;|'i'*98�='i':9/3�):�,�D!/2&3�)F�=7 ,�l':3C%/4/3C4w':�ty/-/;C'*-8�=':3p�,�*�,-/%/4r'*9/3�N=�,2&-/3�)i�,7��-/)?3�4x$&%�':9/3�4/3C)*$&5 %o7V�,��'*9/3��*-/%.)��=7_'*9/3i�tLM��Z,��S6�j^

�69/3D+/$}N,�=�*$<�=':3F!#� )�':3��?$<�,��4/$<)�':�?$<+/-u':$&� %/)�7V� �Y'*9/3U$<%u7V� �*���='*$&N,3U!/�*$&� ���,�?3F!/�*3C)*3C%('*3�4j$<% ':9.3l�8�*)�'�*�1���,7�G"$<5,-/�*3 � ^��69/3�)?3�;`�,%�+K3t;�� �D!8�,�?3�4���$}':9³':9/3t!/2<�=':)p$&%�G"$&5 -/�?3 Zu^�£j3x� +.)*3���N 3�)?� �D33�2&� %/5 �=':$&� %��,7"':9/3F;C� %O':� -.�*)Y�=7':9/3i!K� )�':3C�*$&� �Y4/3C%/)*$}'M>��=7",���,%/4 � XK�*3|y83�;|':$&%/5�':9/3g7h�,;C'J':98��'Y':9.3'P�=$<2&)��,7�'*9/3D!K�,)?':3C�*$&� ���,7 � �,�?3D2{�,�?5 3���'*98�,%~':9/�,)*3D�,7c':9/3D!/�?$<� �C^�G"$<5,-/�*3 �)*9/�1��)�':9/3D;C� %O':� -/�?)�,7'*9/3F+/$}N=�,�*$<�=':3l!K� )�':3C�*$&� �Y4/3C%/)*$}':$&3�)�-/%.4/3���'*9/3l-/%.$&7V� �?��!.�*$&� ��^ H �@-/�,%O':$}'P�='*$&N,3��D3��,)*-/�?3F�,7a':9.3)*$&�D$<2<�,�?$&'M>j+K3|'M�B3C3�%w'*9/3����,$<%O'i!/�*$&� �*)i�,%/4j!K�,)?':3C�*$&� �*)i$<)i5 $}N 3�%r+(>~'*9/3,-�98�='*':�,;P98�,��>(>O�x4/$&)?':�,%/;C3�)

-��

Page 16: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

0 1 2 3 4 5 6

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

Kv

Den

sity

priorsurf.doua

0 1 2 3 4 5 6

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

Kv

Den

sity

priorsurf.doua

0 5 10 15

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

0.30

S

Den

sity

priorsurf.doua

0 5 10 15

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

S

Den

sity

priorsurf.doua

−1.5 −1.0 −0.5 0.0 0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

Faer

Den

sity

priorsurf.doua

−1.5 −1.0 −0.5 0.0 0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

Faer

Den

sity

priorsurf.doua

G"$&5 -/�?3J� � «�}Nuw�Kq|yv}f�XtXoKrxlxj%unq�ofu8p�qsrxlxu�qs�e�Zlwq�oEyvrof�¼lnmZj��%�sq|h~}Nlxj�te}Nun}Kh�j%lxj%unr��¢ofu�ja}f��mªof�³lnmZj�lnmvuwj%j�p�qs}N�EyvoKr©¥lwqs�%r%�\�Bmvj���j%�¢l&��oK�|�eh~y���ofuwuwjarwtXoEyvp�r�lxo!q|yZ�Âofu�hk}Nlwq��fj�tvunq�ofunra�LlnmZj�unq��EmElW��oK�|��h~y���ofuwuwjarwtXoEyvper$lxo-��yvq��¢ofu�htvunq�ofu����BmZj�mvqsrxlxof�fu�}Khkr$q|y�pe}frnmZjap��sq|yZjar���ofuwuwjarwtXoEyvp!lxoklnmvj�tXoKq|yKlwr$q|y�lnmZj\j�§vtLj%u�q|h�j�yElw}f�³pvjarwq��Ey��

-

Page 17: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

��3C3�!o�u;C3`�,% s@-/�?7h�,;C3�':3��D!#3��*�=':-/�?3 (J!/!#3����,$&�� � � � ������� � ��� � � � �%� � ��� � �������

��� [u^ � � [.^ q Z �W[.^ q q [.^ � Z - ^ \ � �W[u^ \ - - ^ � � Zu^ Z,\ �W[.^n\ qLM%u7W^ � [ � Z@^ - � Zu^ � - �W[.^ � � - ^ q,q � ^ Z - �W[u^ � q Zu^ �,q � ^ \ q �W[.^nZ \

qO��� � ^ \ - �/^ � � �M[.^f[ [ � � ^n[ � � ^1 � �W[.^f[ �!- �/^ -�� .^n[ � [u^ - \��� [u^ Z=� [.^n\ � � - ^ � \ [.^ -`q Z@^ Z� �W[u^ � Z - ^ �,� Zu^ q!- � - ^ � �

(�%.7V��^ � [ � Z@^1 � .^n\ - �W[.^ � [ Zu^n[ � \@^ Z � �W[u^f� q �/^ -1� .^ � Z �W[.^ � ZqO��� � ^1 - - �/^ - - [u^ Z - � ^n[ \ - �.^n[ � �W[u^n[ � � ^ � � - � ^f[ [u^ � \

�"�,+.2<3 � �csu-/�D���,��>��,7_'*9/3�!K�,)?':3C�*$&� �64/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.':$&� %/)��,7_':9/3�;�2&$&����':3�)?>@)?'*3���!/�?� !K3C�?'*$<3C)�^��� ����(J%.$�^ su� su� (�%/$h^±��� � su� ( H ( H (J%/$h^

Qa�?$<�,� ������� ������� ���� � ������ ������ ���� �� ���� ����� - [u^f� � [.^ O\ [u^ � � [.^n\� [.^ � [ [.^ - [��� (�%/$�^ - [.^ � [ [u^ � � [.^¡� � [.^ Z� [.^ � Zsu� - [u^ � � [.^ q q [.^1 � [.^ - -su� (�%/$ - [.^ � � [.^ �,� [.^ Z=[��� � s@� - [.^ \ � [.^ - [( H - [.^ � [

�_�,+/2&36� ��G"$&�*)�'�*�1�³$<%D+#� 2&4D7h�=;�3 � -B98��'*'P�=;P98�,�?>(> �g4/$&)?':�,%/;C3�)c+K3|'M�B3C3�%D':9/3�!/�?$<� ���,%/4U':9/36!#� )�':3��?$<�,�4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.':$&� %/)t;�� �?�*3C)*!#� %/4/$&%/5³'*��'*9/3k4/$&°K3��?3�%O't4/${�=5 %/� )�':$&;�)�^ H 2&2��,':9/3C�t�?�1��)�� -�98�='*':�,;P98�,��>(>O�4/$&)?':�,%/;�3C)J+#3C'M��3�3C%x':9.3g!#� )�':3��?$<�,��4.$<)�':�*$&+/-.'*$<�,%/)�7V�,�64/$&°K3��?3�%O'J4/${�=5 %/� )�':$&;�)��,%/4o!/�*$&� �?)�^

�*3C!K�,�?':3C4�$&%�'*9/36�8�*)�'�'M���l3C%O':�*$&3�)c�,7K':9/36�8�?)?'��*�1� �,7e�"�=+/2<3��/^"£j3�� +/)?3��?N,3J'*98�='a':9/36'M���l%(-/�i+K3C�*)�,�?3�;�2&� )*3�'*� - X�)*�w'*98�='�X�3C)*!#3�;C${�,2&2}>�$<% '*9/3�;��,)*3��=7g'*9/3�$&%.7V� �?����':$}N 3 !/�?$<� �CX6':9/3�4/�='P�w�=�*3�%/�=';P98�,%.5 $<%.5�'*9/3�!/�*$&� ��$<%u7V� �*���='*$<� %�)?-/+/)?':�,%O':$<�,2&2&>,^

�!� � � � � & 1 ��� ��80?� �8� 13 ?� � � � � 1 $�� �LM%�� �*4.3��p'*��4.3C�8%/3 0 7V� �p'*9/3~�,%8�,2}>@)*$&)��,7lsu��XB��3k;C� %/)?$<4/3C�*3C4 0�T6� ���B] � T - � 9 � ��9 � ��9 � � � � ��]PX��9/3C�*3 � $&)U2<�=':$}':-/4.3t�=%/4 ��$&)U':9/3�4.3�;`�=4/3,^w£j3�-/)*3C4 � � - OZx;C� %O':�?� 2��*-.%/)D� +.'P�=$<%/3C4m7V�*� �':9.3w�gS6� 4/3|N 3C2<� !#3�4���'o'*9/3��J�,4/2&3C> SB3C%('*�*3=X�-B�*�,;P0(%/3�2&2hX (�/UX�;C�u4.3|�M%/�,�D3�4 �J�,4 S6��Z@^ �69/3!#� )?'*3��*$&� �c4/$&)?':�?$<+.-.':$&� %/)��=7 1�)*9.����'*98�='c':9/3J+8�,)?3�2&$<%/3J7V� �c'*9/3Y)?-/�?7h�=;�3J'*3��D!#3��:��':-/�?3Y;P98�,%.5 3Y$&)B%/�=')*$&5 %/$}�8;��,%O':2}>r4/$}°K3��*3C%O'l7V�*�,� E�3C�*�/^�LM%/;C�*3��,)*$&%/5 � � � 98�,)l�o4.3�;��?3`�,)?$<%.5 3C°K3�;C'i� %wsu��XR��9/$<2&3�7V�,�� �,%/4&� � �%�6'*9/3g3C°K3�;C'J$&)J!#� )*$}':$}N 3=^ 9��=':$}':-.4/3�4/�u3C)J%.�,'�)*3�3C� ':��98�`N 3i��)?$<5 %.$&�8;��,%O'�3|°e3C;C'J� %�s@��^LM%o;�� %O':�*�,)?'�X/':9/3�4/3C;`�,4.3�)�98�`N 3i��)?$<5 %.$&�8;��,%O'Y!#� )?$&'*$&N,3g3|°e3C;C'�^

£r3B!K3C�?7V� �?��3C4D�Y!/�?3�4/$&;C'*$&N,3J�=)*)*3C)*)?��3C%O'�)?$<�D$&2{�=�"':�Y'*9/3�� %.3�!/�*3C)*3C%('*3�4U7V� �"���U^�LM%UG"$&5 -/�?3�\���3!/�?3�)*3C%O'�'*9/3�!/�?3�4/$&;C'*$&N,3i$&%O':3���N=�,2<)67V� �B)*$²��;�� �i+/$&%8�=':$&� %/)��,7�'*9/3�;�2&$<���='*3�!8�,�:�=��3|':3C�*)6�,7�':9/3�� � 2<3|7 '� -.'��,7K':9/3J$<%.7V3C�*3C%/;�3=^a£j3�� +/)*3C�?N,3Y':98��'��D� )�'��,7K':9/3��tLM��Z S6���,-.':!/-u'��,�?3���$}':9.$<%p'*9/3Y!.�*3�4.$<;|':$}N 3$&%('*3���N,�=2<)C^�69/3�)?3�9/�1N,3Y�Y'M>@!/$&;`�=2/��$<4.'*9��=7_^nZ�4/3�5,�*3�3C)�^ H 2<)?��'*9/362<�=':$}':-/4.$<%8�=2 �,%/4D4/3�;��,48�,2.!8�='*'*3��?%/)�,7�':9/3��D�@4/3�2R)?$<�i-/2{��':$&� %/)J�,�*3���3�2&2�;��,!.'*-/�*3C4t+O>�':9.3g!.�*3�4.$<;|':$&� %/)�^

su� �D3D�(-8�,%O':$&2<3C)l�,7�!#� )?'*3��*$&� ��4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.':$&� %/)g�,7c':9/3D;C2<$&���=':3�!8�,�*�,�D3C':3C�*)g�,�?3��?3�!#� �?'*3�4k$<%~':9.37V� -/��':9vX(�/7 '*9��,%/4�)?$}�@':9�;C� 2&-/�D%/)��,7��_�,+/2&3 � ^�£�9.3�%�;��,��!/�,�*3C4p':�l'*9/3�!/�?$<�,���(-8�,%O'*$<2&3�)6$&%��"�=+/2<3�Z

- \

Page 18: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

1 2 3 4 5

24

68

Kv

S

1 2 3 4 5−

1.0

−0.

50.

0Kv

Fae

r2 4 6 8

−1.

0−

0.5

0.0

S

Fae

r0 1 2 3 4 5

24

68

Kv

S

0 1 2 3 4 5

−1.

0−

0.6

−0.

20.

2

Kv

Fae

r

2 4 6 8−

1.0

−0.

6−

0.2

0.2

S

Fae

r

1 2 3 4 5

02

46

8

Kv

S

1 2 3 4 5

−1.

0−

0.5

0.0

Kv

Fae

r

0 2 4 6 8

−1.

0−

0.5

0.0

S

Fae

r

G"$&5 -/�?3 � � «�}Nun�Kq|yv}f���q��N}Nunqs}Nlxj~tXoKrxlxj%u�q�ofu�p�qsrxlxu�qs�e�Zlwq�oEyvrWof�*lnmZj{�%�sq|hk}Nlxj~t�}Nu�}Kh�j%lxj%unr���rwq|yZ��ja}f��mµof�*lnmZjlnmZuwj%j�p�qs}N�EyZoKrwlwqs�%r&�Bq�lnm�}Kyzq|yZ�¢ofu�h~}Nlwq��fj�tvu�q�ofua�B�BmZj�tvunq�ofu�rB}KyvpztXoKrxlxj%unq�ofunr&}Nuwj�rnmZo���y��6�-lnmZj�lnmvq|yz}Kyvplnmvqs�n¡+�sq|yvjar%�#uwjarntLja��lwq��fja���f������q�unrxl\uwo��\¶\­�j%jat2oZ��ja}Ky�����ja��oEyvp�uno��\¶��v�vuw�¢}f��j�lxj�h~tXj%un}Nln�Zuwj��=�Bmvq�unp+uwo��\¶��t�tXj%u$}fq�ua�

-1�

Page 19: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

0 2 4 6

05

1015

Kv

S

0 1 2 3 4 5 6−

1.5

−0.

50.

00.

5

Kv

Fae

r0 5 10 15

−1.

5−

0.5

0.5

S

Fae

r0 2 4 6

05

1015

Kv

S

0 1 2 3 4 5 6

−1.

5−

0.5

0.0

0.5

Kv

Fae

r

0 5 10 15−

1.5

−0.

50.

5S

Fae

r

0 2 4 6

24

68

1014

Kv

S

0 1 2 3 4 5 6

−1.

5−

0.5

0.0

0.5

Kv

Fae

r

5 10 15

−1.

5−

0.5

0.5

S

Fae

r

G"$&5 -/�?3 � «�}Nun�Kq|yv}f���q��N}Nunqs}Nlxj~tXoKrxlxj%u�q�ofu�p�qsrxlxu�qs�e�Zlwq�oEyvrWof�*lnmZj{�%�sq|hk}Nlxj~t�}Nu�}Kh�j%lxj%unr���rwq|yZ��ja}f��mµof�*lnmZjlnmZuwj%j�p�qs}N�EyZoKrxlwqs�%r��Bq�lnm�}{�eyvq��Âofu�h tvunq�ofua� ��q�unrwlBuwo��\¶�­�j%jatzoZ��ja}Ky�� �Zja��oEyvp�uno��\¶ �v�Zuw��}f��j�lxj�h~tXj%un}Nln�Zuwj���Bmvq�u�p!uwo��\¶ ��t�tXj%u$}fq�ua�

-1q

Page 20: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

_

__

__

__

_

_

__

_

__

_

_

__

_

_

−0.3 −0.1 0.1

latitude

Degrees Celcius

__

_

__

__

_

_

_

_

_

_

_

__

_

_

__

xx

x

xx

xx

x

x

x

xx

x

x

xx

xx

x

x

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

Kv

=5, S

=0.5, F

aer =−

1.5

__

__

__

__

__

__

__

__

_

_

_

_

−0.1 0.1 0.3

latitude

Degrees Celcius

__

_

__

_

__

__

__

__

__

__

__

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

x

x

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

Kv

=2, S

=3, F

aer =0

_

__

_

_

__

__

__

_

__

__

__

_

_

−0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4

latitude

Degrees Celcius

__

_

__

__

__

__

__

_

__

__

__

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

Kv

=2, S

=8, F

aer =−

0.5

__

__

__

__

__

__

__

_

_

__

_

_−0.1 0.1 0.3

latitude

Degrees Celcius

__

_

_

__

__

__

__

__

__

__

__

xx

x

x

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

x

x

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

Kv

=0.26, S

=3, F

aer =−

0.25

__

__

_

_

__

_

__

_

_

__

_

_

_

_

_

−0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3

latitude

Degrees Celcius

_

__

_

__

__

__

_

_

__

__

__

__

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

x

xx

x

x

xx

x

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

Kv

=3, S

=1.5, F

aer =0

_

__

_

__

__

__

__

_

_

__

__

_

_

−0.1 0.1 0.2 0.3

latitude

Degrees Celcius

__

_

_

__

__

_

_

__

_

_

__

__

_

_

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

xx

x

xx

x

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

48.614.5

−14.5−48.6

Kv

=0, S

=1.5, F

aer =−

0.75

G"$&5 -/�?3�\��uwjap�qs��lwq��fjWp�qsrxlxunqs�L�Zlwq�oEy��¢ofu

�v�"}Nl*rwq»§~��oEh���q|yv}Nlwq�oEyvr�of�³lnmZj��%�sq|hk}Nlxj&rx��rwlxj�hitvunoKtLj%unlwq�jar%���BmZj

��uwoKrwrwjar8��ofuwuwjarwtXoEyvpªlxo�lnmZj\«-¨©�B¬N­\±8«rwq|h��v�s}Nlwq�oEyvr%����mZj�j�§Zlxuwj�hkjar*of�Sq|yElxj%uw�Ù}f�sr8}NunjW�Kq��fj�y!�E�{lnmZj\¬�����

}Kyvp���6����

�®tXoKrxlxj%unq�ofu�·Z�v}KyElwqs��jar%��¸&tXj�y!�%q�un�%��jar���ofuwuwjarntLoEy�p!lxo~tvuwjap�qs��lwq��fj�h�ja}Kyvra�

Z,[

Page 21: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

� � � � ���������� [u^ � � - ^¡� � �W[.^n\ q� [ � - ^ q \ Zu^ � �W[.^¡��qO��� � ^ -�� � ^f[,� �W[.^f[ �

�"�=+/2<3 � �aQ�� )?'*3��?$<� ���(-8�,%O':$&2&3�)��,7_'*9/3�;�2&$<���='*3i)�>@)?':3C� !/�*�,!K3C�?':$&3�)�-/)?$<%/5����A�=%/4�s@��^

��3l)*3C3F$&��!#� ��'P�,%O'J4/$&°K3��?3�%/;C3�)�+#�,'*9t7V� ��':9/3g$&%.7V� �*���='*$&N,3F�,%.4x':9/3g-/%/$}7V� �?� !.�*$&� ��^6�69/3i���,�*5 $&%8�,2!#� )?'*3��*$&� �a4/3C%/)*$}':$&3�)c$<%D':9.3��/�*)?'a;C� 2&-/�D%p�,7eG"$&5 -/�*36��)?9/�1� ':98��'':9/3�!#� )?'*3��*$&� ��7V� �*� ��� $&)a)*2&$<5,9('*2&>)*9.$&7 '*3�4�':�i':9/3J�*$&5 9O'B��$}':9��*3C)*!#3�;|'�':�g':9/3�!.�*$&� ��^��69.3�!K�,)?':3C�*$&� ��7V�,� � $&)B)*9.$&7 '*3�4�':�i':9/3J2<3|7 '`Xu��9.$<2&3':9.3�!K� )�':3C�*$&� �B7V� �*��� �%��$&)6�l-/;P9��D� �*3�;C� %/;C3�%O':�*�=':3C4x�,�?� -/%/4�'*9/3��D3�4.${�,%�'*98�,%�':9/3Y!/�*$&� ��^�69.$<)6$&)$&%o)?98�,�?!o;C� %O':�*�,)?'6'*�F':9/3�+#3�98�`N@$&� �6�,7�':9/3�!#� )�':3��?$<�,�6+8�,)*3C4�� %����FXu��9/$&;P9t9/�,)6�l-/;P9o2<�,�*5 3C��'P�,$&2&)':9/�,%k'*9/3D!/�*$&� �C^ULM%k'*9/3D)*3�;C� %/4j;�� 2&-/�D%r�,7BG"$&5 -/�?3U�o��3D!/�*3C)*3�%O'g':9/3�!#� )?'*3��*$&� ��4/3C%/)*$}':$&3�)i+8�,)?3�4� % ��-.%/$&7V�,�*� !/�*$&� ��^ H )Y7V� ��':9/3F��� 4.${�,5,%/� )?'*$<;i�B3U� +.)*3���N 3F'*98�='Y'*9/3F4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.'*$<� %.)�':3�%.4~'*��+#34/$}°e-.)*3��,%/4~)?'*�*� %.5 2&>�$<%.y/-/3�%/;C3�4j+(>x':9/3D2&�u;��=':$&� %~�,7a':9/3D4/3C)*$&5 %k!K� $&%O':)C^U�69/3D!K� )�':3C�*$&� ��4/3�%.)*$}'M>�,7 � � �%��$&)l��%/�,'*� �*$&� -/)g3|�u;�3C!.':$&� %v^�LM%k7h�,;C'g':9/$&)g2<�@� 0()i)?$<�D$&2{�=�i':��':9.3�!#� )?'*3��?$<� �g� +.':�,$&%/3�4j-/)*$&%/5':9.3l$&%.7V� �*���='*$&N,3l!/�?$<�,��^��69/3iN=�,2&-/3C)Y�,7�'*9/3l!#� )�':3��?$<�,�J�(-8�,%O'*$<2&3�)�$&%/4/$&;`��':3l'*98�='�':9/3i-/%/$}7V� �*� !/�?$<�,�+8�,)?3�4j!K� )�':3C�*$&� ��$<)�)?9/$&7 '*3�4k':��':9/3D2&3C7 '���$}':9k�*3�)?!K3C;C'g':��':9.3�$&%.7V� �?���=':$}N 3�!/�*$&� ��+8�=)*3�4j!K�,)?':3C�*$&� ��^�69/3C)*3g�*3�)?-/2}':)�$<%/4.$<;��=':3�':98��'6':9/3isu� 4/${�=5 %/� )�':$&;i;C� %O'P�,$&%/)�-/)*3|7V-/2�$<%u7V� �*���='*$<� %��?3�5O�,�?4/$&%/5 ��� �%��^

G8�*� ��':9/3�!/2&�,':)6�=7_'*9/3�+/$&N=�,�?${��':3�4/3C%/)*$}':$&3�)�$<%tG"$&5 -/�?3�) � �,%/4&.X/��3�� +/)*3C�?N,3i)?� �D3g4.$&°K3��?3�%/;C3�)+#3C'M��3�3�%t':9/3�4/3C%/)*$}':$&3�)�7V�*� � ���A�,%/4�':9.� )*3�7V�*�,��su��^8LM%�':9/3g$<%u7V� �*���='*$&N,3g;��,)*3���3i� +.)*3���N 3�':98��'':9.3U���,$<%O'��,7 � ��� �=%/4 ��7V�,������98�,)��~2<�1��3���;�3�%O'*3��p�=7Y���,)?)�'*98�,%¶':98�='D7V� ��suIg^�69/3U��� $&%O'�,7 � �=%/4 �������67V� �psu� $&)�':$&2}':3�4³4/�1��%O���,�?4��,%/4³$<)�2<3C)*)p;C� %/;C3�%O':�*�=':3C4 ��9/3�% ;C� �D!8�,�?3�4�'*�j':9.3� %/3�7V� �D���F^aG �,�U�D� �?3o4.�:�,���='*$<;�4/$}°e3C�*3C%/;�3C)��,�?3o�,+/)*3C�?N 3C4 $&%�'*9/3�-/%/$}7V� �*�¤!.�*$&� �D;`�,)?3,^ �J3��?3$}'�$<)Y;�2&3`�,�Y'*98�='�'*9/3F4/3C%/)*$}':$&3�)�� +u'P�,$&%/3�4~-/)?$<%.5osu�A9/�1N,3D�p�:�=%/5 3F�,7 �������67h�,�Y�D� �?3F;��,%/;�3C%('*�:�='*3�4�,�?� -/%/4o':9/3g�D3�4/$<�,% �,%.4����*�,%/5 3g�,7 ��9.$<5 9.3��J'*98�,%o':9/� )?3i�=7�':9/3g4/3C%/)*$}':$&3�)��,+.'P�,$&%/3C4�-/)*$&%/5����F^�69/3�N=�,2<-.3�)��,7Y'*9/3 -�98�='*':�,;P98�,��>(>O�r4/$&)?':�,%/;C3�)p+#3C'M��3�3C%�':9.3t!/�?$<�,�*)��,%/4¶':9/3o!K�,)?':3C�*$&� �*)D7V� �U':9.3su� 4.${�,5,%/� )?'*$<;=X �*3�!#� ��':3�4o$&%x�_�,+/2&3i�/X �=�*3�)*���,2&2<3C��'*98�,%o':9/� )?3i;C� �D!/-.'*3�4t7V�,��'*9/3isu� 4/$<�,5 %.� )?'*$<;=^�69/$&)Y;C� %.�8�?��)�':9/3l�,%8�,2}>@)*$&)Y�,7_':9/3i�(-8�,%O':$&2<3C)��,%.4x':9/3g5 �*�,!/9/$&;�)J�,7"'*9/3i-.%/$&N=�,�?${��':3F�=%/4x+/$}N=�,�*$<�='*3!#� )?'*3��*$&� ��4/3C%/)*$}':$&3�)C^

£r3l;�� %/)?$<4.3��*3C4k'M�����D� �*3i!K�,)?':3C�*$&� ��4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.'*$<� %.)�� +.'P�=$<%/3C4 -/)*$&%/5osu��^v��%/3F$&)Y':9/3l�*3�)?-/2}'��,7�*3C):�,�D!/2&$&%/5x':9.3�!#� )?'*3��?$<� �g4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.':$&� %r7V�?� � ���FXv7V� 2&2<�1��$&%/5t'*9/3���3|':9/�@4w4/3C)*;C�*$&+K3C4w$<%wsu3�;|':$&� %� ^ � ^p�69.3p�*3C)*-/2}':$&%/5t-/%/$}N,�=�*$<�=':3�!K�,)?':3C�*$&� �g4/3�%/)?$&'*$<3C)F�,�?3�!.�*3�)?3�%O':3C4m$<%rG"$&5 -/�*3 � ^pG8� � � ��� �=%/4��':9.36!K� )�':3C�*$&� �"7V� 2&2<�1��)�N,3��?>F;�2&� )*3C2&>F'*9/3�� %.36� +.'P�=$<%/3C4U-/)*$&%/5�� %/2}>Ds@��^ �69/36!#� )?'*3��*$&� ��4.3�%/)?$&'M>F7V�,���������$<)�)?� �D3C��98��'6$<%uy8-/3�%.;�3�4�+O>�':9/3���� �?3�)?-/2&'*)�^cG8� ���i%@-.��3C�*$&;`�,2K;�� �D!8�=�*$&)*� %���3��*3C!K�,�?'�)?� �D3�,7K':9/3��(-8�,%O':$&2<3C)��,7K':9/3C)*3Y4.3�%/)?$&'*$<3C)�$<%��"�=+/2<3 � ^ H 4/4/$}':$&� %8�,2&2}>���3Y%.�,':$&;�3�':98��'�'*9/3 -�98�='*':�,;P98�,��>(>O�4/$&)?':�,%/;�3x+K3|'M�B3C3�%�':9/3D��� $&%('�!#� )?'*3��*$&� ��4/$<)�':�?$<+/-u':$&� %��,%/4�':9/3t$<%.7V�,�*���=':$}N 3x!/�*$&� ��$<)��=2<�D� )�'p':9.3):�=��3x�,)�'*9/3x4.$<)�'P�,%/;C3x+#3C'M��3�3C%�'*9/3 s@� !K� )�':3C�*$&� �p�=%/4�':9.3t$&%.7V� �?����':$}N 3�!/�?$<�,��^�G8-/�?'*9/3��?�D� �*3=X':9.3�4/$&)?':�,%/;C3�)F+#3C'M��3�3C%r':9/3�':9/�,)*3D'M�B�t!K� )�':3C�*$&� �*)i$<)�N 3C�?>k;�2&� )*3�':�o� %/3=^��69/3��=+K�1N 3�4/$&)*;�-.)*)*$&� %!/�?��N@$&4/3�)�3CN@$&4/3�%.;�3i'*98�='�':9.3g!#� )�':3��?$<�,�64/$<)�':�?$<+/-u':$&� %x$&)�4/� �D$<%/�=':3C4t+O>�':9.3ls@� 4/$<�,5 %/�,)?':$&;,^

G"$&%8�,2&2&>,X#��3i;C� %/)?$<4/3C�J'*9/3i$&)*)?-/3F�,7"-/)*$&%/5p��4/$}°K3��*3C%O'�!/�?$<� ��7V� � , +8�=)*3�4x� %x��4/$}°e3C�*3�%O'��iS6�j^£j3g-.)*3 � � q!- �?3�!/2&$&;`�='*3�)��,7 � &Y+8�,)?3�4o� %���G���9 ��$&'*9t'*9/3�$<%.7V�,�*���=':$}N 3g!/�?$<� ��7V�,� ��^c�69.3i!/2&�,'*)�,7 ':9.36-/%/$}N,�=�*$<�=':36!#� )?'*3��?$<� �"4/$<)�':�?$<+/-u':$&� %/)a�,7 � ���FX � �=%/4�� � �%��)?9/�1� �D$<%.$<���,2/4.$&°K3��?3�%/;C3�)':��':9.3!#� )?'*3��*$&� �?)6� +.'P�=$<%/3C4�-/)*$&%/5U':9.3�;�� %O'*�*� 2v�?-/%/)�7V�?� � �Y�,4 S6�xZu^���%�'*9/3��,'*9/3���9/�,%/4���3�3|�u!K3C;C'�':9.3

Z -

Page 22: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

0 1 2 3 4 5 6

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

Kv

Den

sity

priorstdost resmpl.

0 5 10 150.

00.

10.

20.

3

S

Den

sity

priorstdost resmpl.

−1.5 −1.0 −0.5 0.0 0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

Faer

Den

sity

priorstdost resmpl.

G"$&5 -/�?3 � � «�}Nuw�Kq|y�}f�8tLoKrwlxj%unq�ofu�p�qsrxlxunqs�e�vlwq�oEyvr�of�BlnmZj!�%�sq|hk}Nlxj-t�}Nu�}Kh�j%lxj%unr��vrwq|yZ�zlnmZj�pvj%jat oZ��ja}Kyî}KyvplnmZj�rn�Zuw��}f��j�lxj�hktXj%un}Nln�Zuwj�p�qs}N�EyZoKrxlwqs�%r � oKq|yKlw���z}Kyvpz��oEhkt�}NunqsrwoEy-�Bq�lnm�lnmZj�uwjarn�v��lwrW�vrnq|yZ�~lnmZj�p�qs}N�EyZoKrwlwqs�%rrxjat�}Nu�}Nlxja���f�

Z Z

Page 23: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

!#� )?'*3��*$&� �c�,7 , '*�i+#3J�=°e3C;C'*3�4�+O>U':9.3Y-/)?3J�,7v4/$&°K3��?3�%O'�;C� %O':�?� 2 �*-/%/)C^LM%�G"$&5 -/�?3 - [���3Y!/�?3�)?3�%O'�':9.3!#� )?'*3��*$&� �c4/3�%.)*$}':$&3�)B�=7e':9.3J2&� 5=��3�$&5 3�%ON=�,2&-/3�)��,7 , �=)a��3�2&2K�,)�+#�`�u!/2<�=':)a7V� �':9/3�!K�,)?':3C�*$&� �a):�,�D!/2&3�)��,7':9.3g3C$<5,3�%ON 3C;C':�,�Y;��,�*�*3C)*!#� %/4/$&%/5�':�U':9/3�2<�,�*5,3�)?'�3C$<5 3C%ON,�=2<-/3C)�^B£j3�� +/)?3��?N,3g'*98�='�$&%t+#�,':9�;��,)*3C)J':9.3�8�?)?'�3C$<5,3�%ON=�,2<-.3U98�,)Y2<�,�?5 3iN=�,�?${�,+.$<2&$&'M>,Xe)?2<$&5 9O':2}>�2<�,�*5,3��Y$&%x'*9/3.�J��S6�±;`�,)?3,^�G8� ��':9.3F3�$&5 3�%ON,3�;C'*� ���3��,+/)*3C�?N 3J���D� �*36�?3�5 -.2{�,�!/�='*'*3��*%D$&%�'*9/3���G���9�;`�,)?3�'*98�,%D$&%D'*9/3 �Y��S6� � %/3=^�LM%D!8�,��':$&;�-/2<�,�$}'$&)�%/�=':$&;�3`�=+/2<3�':9/�='`X(7V� ��':9.3���G���9t;��,)*3=X@'*9/3�;��@3C´�;�$&3�%O':)��,�*3�$&%/;��?3`�,)?$<%/5F�,)c�g7V-/%/;|':$&� %��,7v2<�=':$}':-.4/37V� �':9.3��8�?)?'�'M�B�i4/3�;��,4/3�)CX/�,%.4p4/3C;��*3��,)*$&%/5l7V�,�c'*9/3J2<�,)�'�'M���l� %.3�)�^ H 2&'*9/� -/5,9�':9.3J�1N 3C�:�,2&2#!8�='*'*3��?%/))*9.���³���=�*�D$<%.5g7V� �3��,;P9�2{�='*$&'*-/4/3=X('*9/3��*3C2{�='*$&N,36���,�?�D$<%/5g�:��':3�)a4/$}°K3���7V� ��'*9/3�2<3��,4/$&%/5�3�$&5 3�%/�D�@4/3�)C^

�!��� � �7�:��� 1 � �< "�802�:��� 13 �� � � ��� 1 $����H )l��3C%O':$&� %/3�4¶$&%�su3�;|':$&� %�Zu^nZuX"��3��*3C)?'*�*$&;C'D� -/�l�,%8�,2}>@)*$&)F':�x'*9/3p�8�?)?'F7V�,-/�l2<�`> 3��?)U�,76':9.3��=':�D�=�)*!.9/3��?3,^kLM%¶G"$<5,-/�*3 - �B3�� +.)*3���N 3�':9/�='`X"7V�,�l':9/3��8�*)�'F7V� -/�F2<�`> 3C�*)�X'*9/3��tLM��Z,��S6� )?$<�i-/2{��':$&� %/);`�=%�98�`N 3�)?$<5 %.$&�8;��,%O'�4/3�!/�,�?'*-/�*3C)p7V�*� � '*9/3�� +/)?3���N,��':$&� %/)�^ LM%�;�� %O':�*�,)?'p':�r'*9/3~su��Xc7V� ����9.$<;P9�D� )?'D)?$<�i-/2<�=':3C4�N=�,2&-/3�)U4.$&°K3��F�,%/3�� �l'M��� ':3�%O'*9/)U�,7J��4/3�5,�*3�3oSB3C2<)?$<-.)D7V�?� �z':9/3�� +.)*3���N=�=':$&� %/)CX':9.3.( H )*$&�l-.2{�='*$<�,%/)�;`�=%x+#3i�D� �?3i':9/�,%x� %.3l4/3C5 �*3C3F�`���`>�7V�*�,� ':9/3i� +/)*3C�?N=�='*$<� %.)�X#3�)*!#3�;C${�=2<2}>���'2<�=':$}':-/4.3�)F�`�B�`>j7V�?� � ':9/3�!K�,2<3C)�^o�69/$<)l$<�D!/2&$<3C)l':9/�='.( H $&)l2&$<0=3�2}>j'*�x!/�?�1Nu$&4/3��,%/2&>~��3`�,0k$&%.7V� ������=':$&� % �=+K� -u'J'*9/3F�D� )?'Y2<$&0,3C2&>tN=�,2<-.3�)��,7 �_^ H )Y$&%x':9/3i!/�*3|N@$<� -.)�'M�B��;��,)*3C)��B3l;�� %/)?$<4.3��*3C4 0 �=)�t2&$&%/3`�,�i7V-/%/;C'*$<�,%w�,7 � � ,�F�,%/4� � ^tG8� ��( H '*9/3p!#� )*$}':$&� %rN=�,�?${�=+/2<3�� $<)g'M�B� 4/$&�D3�%/)?$<�,%8�,2��=%/4;��,�*�*3C)*!#� %/4/)�'*��2{��':$}':-/4/3=X � XR�,%.4j�=2&'*$&'*-/4/3,X �1^ls@���B3F�/'?':3C4 � -/���D�@4/3�2"��$}':9 0�T�� ���1]�3��(-8�,2"'*�T - ��9 � ��9 � � 9 � �:;�� )`T�Z ��� �!-1� [@]��:2&� 5 ��� ��]P^�69/3�!#� )?'*3��?$<� �64.$<)�':�*$&+/-.'*$<�,%t�,7 1 )*9/�1��)6':9/�='6':9/3�+/�,)*3C2<$&%/37V� ��'*9/3i-.!/!K3C���,$<�6'*3��D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3g;P98�,%.5 3i$&)�%/3�5 �=':$}N 3=^ H )�7V� ��'*9/3Fs@��X8$<%/;C�*3��,)*$&%/5 � � � 98�=)J�D4/3��;��?3`�,)?$<%.5F3C°K3�;|'B� %�su��X(��9/$<2&3J7V�,� � �=%/4 ��������':9/3�3C°K3�;|'�$&)�!#� )*$}':$}N 3=^a�69/3J;C�u3|´�;�$&3�%O'�7V� �':9.3�'*3��*�;��,)�T�Z ��� �!-1� [(]Y$&)�)*$&5 %/$}�8;`�=%('*2&>j!#� )*$}':$}N 3=X"$&��!.2&>@$&%/5 ��!K� )?$&'*$&N,3p3|°e3C;C'l�='�':9/3�3��(-8�='*� �i�,%/4k%/3�5O���':$}N 3l3C°K3�;C'*)��='�':9.3l!#� 2<3C)�^��69/3l;C�u3|´�;�$&3�%O'�7V� �J�,2}':$}':-/4/3i$<)Y�,2&)*�p!#� )?$&'*$&N,3,Xv$&�D!/2&>@$&%/5��,%x$<%/;C�*3��,)*$&%/5':3C�D!K3C�:�='*-/�*3�;P98�,%.5 3g��$}':9o$&%/;��?3`�,)?$<%/5p�,2}':$}':-/4/3=^

�_�~�=)*)*3C)*)U':9.3�!/�*3C4/$<;|':$}N 3�;`�=!8�,+/$&2<$}'M>w�=7�'*9/3��D�@4/3�2B��3�4/$&4¶�,%¶�,%8�=2&>@)*$&)D)*$&�D$<2<�,�F':�t':9/3�� %.3!/�?3�)*3C%O':3�4�7V�,�J�����=%/4 su��^ LM%o':9/$&)Y;��,)*3=X#��3l� +.)*3���N 3C4�':98�='�'*9/3l!/�?3�4/$&;C'*$&N,3F$&%('*3���N,�=2<)J;`�,2&;�-/2<�='*3�47V�*�,��)*�,�D!/2<3C)��,7a':9/3U!/�?3�4/$&;C'*$&N,3D4/$<)�':�?$<+/-u':$&� %/)��B3C�*3D3|�@'*�*3��D3C2&>���$&4/3=^lLM%kG"$&5 -/�*3 - - �B3U!.�*3�)?3�%O'':9.3U!/�*3C4/$<;|':$}N 3���3��,%/)�7V� ��)?$}� ;�� �i+/$<%/�=':$&� %/)��,7c':9/3U;C2<$&���=':3D!8�=�:�,�D3C'*3��?)�^F£j3U� +/)*3C�?N,3�'*98�='�':9.3!/�?3�4/$&;C'*$&N,3r�D3`�,%.)o'*�:�,;P0 '*9/3~)*$&�l-/2<�=':$&� %/)oN 3C�?>���3�2&2�^�£r3j�,2&)*��� +/)*3C�?N,3j':9/�='�':9/3C�*3j�,�*3~2<�,�*5,34/$}°e3C�*3C%/;�3C)�+K3|'M�B3C3�%�':9.3l)*$&�l-.2{�='*$<�,%/)��,%/4t':9/3g� +/)?3��?N=�='*$<�,%/)�^YSB2<3��,�*2}>o':9/3C)*3F4/$}°K3��*3C%/;�3C)�98�`N 3l%/�3C°K3�;|'�� %o'*9/3�!/�*3C4/$&;C':$}N 3i�D3`�,%o+/-.'�':9.3C>�!/�?�u4.-/;�3�N 3C�?>�2<�,�*5,3g!.�*3�4.$<;|':$}N 3iN=�,�?${�=%/;�3C)�^

�69/3�2<�,)?'g':9.�*3�3p;�� 2&-/�D%/)l�=76�"�=+/2<3 � �*3C!K�,�?'i)*� �D3p�=7�':9/3��(-8�,%O':$&2<3C)F�,7�'*9/3p!#� )�':3��?$<�,�l4/$&)?'*�*$²�+/-.'*$<�,%/)g7V�,� ( H �,+.'P�,$&%/3C4j��$}':9j'*9/3�$<%.7V�,�*���=':$}N 3��,%/4k':9/3�-/%/$}7V� �?� !/�*$&� �C^�G8� ��':9/3�$&%.7V� �*���='*$&N,3!/�?$<� �CXO':9/3��(-8�,%O':$&2<3C)6�,)a�B3C2<2#�,)a':9.3J!/2&�,'*)��,7K':9/3�-/%/$}N=�,�*$<�='*3J!#� )?'*3��?$<� �c4/3C%/)*$}'M>p$&%�G_$<5 -.�*3��i)?9/�1� �':3C%/4/3C%/;C>�'*�U;�� %.;�3�%O'*�:�='*3����,�*3�N=�,2&-/3�)��,�?� -/%/4�2<�,�?5 3YN=�,2&-/3�)6�,7 � � � ':98�,%�'*9/3�!/�?$<� �C^ H )*$&�D$<2<�,�CX+/-.'D�i-/;P9�2<3C)*)D!/�*�,%/� -/%/;C3�4¶!/9/3C%/� �D3�%.� %³$&)U� +/)?3���N 3�4�7V� � � �,%.4 ��� �%��^rLM%m)?!/$}':3��,7�':9/$&)�Xa':9.3+/$}N=�,�*$<�=':3�4/$&)?'*�*$&+/-.':$&� %/)�$<%pG"$&5 -/�*3 � )*9/�1��':9/�='a':9/3��� $&%('�4/3C%/)*$}'M>p�=7 � �,%/4 � ���UX(� +.':�,$&%/3�4�7V�*� �( H X"98�=)F':9/3�)?���,2<2&3�)�'D�D�u4/3C2BN=�,2&-/3�)l7V�,� ��X���9/3�%¶;C� �D!8�,�*3C4m':��':9.3�;�� �?�*3C)*!#� %/4/$&%/5~4/3�%.)*$}':$&3�)� +.':�,$&%/3�4�7V�*� � ���A�,%.4�su��^

�69/3c!K� )�':3C�*$&� �R4/$&)?':�?$<+.-.':$&� %/)�7V�*� � ( H -/)*$&%/5J�6-/%/$}7V� �*� !.�*$&� ���,�*3a)?9/�1��%l$&%�'*9/3a)*3C;�� %/4i;�� 2&-/�D%�,7JG"$&5 -/�?3��j�=%/4�G"$<5,-/�*3 .^j�69/3�)?3,Xc':� 5 3|':9/3C�F��$&'*9m':9/3�!#� )?'*3��*$&� �U�(-8�,%O'*$<2&3�)D$&%/4/$&;`�='*3�'*98�=' ( H!/�?�u4/-.;�3�)B�gN,3��?>�)?'*�*� %.5l)*9.$&7 'B�,7v!/�?� +8�,+.$<2&$&'M>D'*���B�,�?4/)�2<�,�*5 3�N=�,2&-/3�)��,7v':9.3J!8�=�:�,�D3C'*3��?)�X.3C)*!#3�;C${�,2&2}>

Z �

Page 24: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

0 1 2 3 4 5 6

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

Kv

Den

sity

priorsurf. HDCMsurf. GFDL

0 5 10 150.

00.

10.

20.

3

S

Den

sity

priorsurf. HDCMsurf. GFDL

−1.5 −1.0 −0.5 0.0 0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

Faer

Den

sity

priorsurf. HDCMsurf. GFDL

G"$&5 -/�?3 q � «�}Nuw�Kq|yv}f�tLoKrwlxj%unq�ofu�p�qsrxlxu�qs�e�Zlwq�oEyvr&of��lnmZjk�%�sq|hk}Nlxj{t�}Nun}Kh�j%lxj%u�r\�vrwq|yZ��lnmZjkp�j%jat+o���ja}Kyµp�qs}N�N¥yZoKrxlwqs�k�Bq�lnm+l¦��o�peq»ºXj%uwj�yEl�tvu�q�ofu\rwtXja�%q�¤e�%}Nlwq�oEyvr\�¢ofu\lnmZj{��o��N}Nunqs}Kyv��jªh~}Nlxunqs��jar��e}frxjap�oEy�p�q»º�j%uwj�yEl��\±8«h�oZpvja�XoE�Zlwte�vlwr%�

Z=�

Page 25: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

PDF of the Log Eigenvalues (HADCM)

−8 −7 −6 −5 −4 −3 −2

Log−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−Eigenvalues

**

*

**

*

******

**

* **

**

**

*

* *

*

* *

*

*

*********

*

*

****

*

****

****

* ***

*

** **

*

***

−0

.40

.00

.4

Distribution of Eigenvector 1 (HADCM)

latitude

Eig

en

ve

cto

rs

48

.6

14

.5

−1

4.5

−4

8.6

48

.6

14

.5

−1

4.5

−4

8.6

48

.6

14

.5

−1

4.5

−4

8.6

48

.6

14

.5

−1

4.5

−4

8.6

48

.6

14

.5

−1

4.5

−4

8.6

PDF of the Log Eigenvalues (GFDL)

−8 −7 −6 −5 −4 −3 −2

Log−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−EigenvaluesLog−Eigenvalues

**

*

**

* *

*

* ****

***

*

** ****** *******

*

*

***

* *

**

*

* **

−0

.40

.00

.4

Distribution of Eigenvector 1 (HADCM)

latitude

Eig

en

ve

cto

rs

48

.6

14

.5

−1

4.5

−4

8.6

48

.6

14

.5

−1

4.5

−4

8.6

48

.6

14

.5

−1

4.5

−4

8.6

48

.6

14

.5

−1

4.5

−4

8.6

48

.6

14

.5

−1

4.5

−4

8.6

G"$&5 -/�?3 - [ � � oKrwlxj%unq�ofu�pvj�y�rwq�l¦��of��lnmvj2��of�N¥¹jaq��fj�yK�N}f�|�Zjar+�¢ofu�lnmZj������������� �� ��������������������������������� !��"#��$&%��� !�'��%� (��")�+*,$-�. 0/������#�1��$#�#�2�$&345����%6�2$7$&8����� (�9�� ��:��5 ;$�'<=�2$&�>�+*,$����&���?3!%�@�AB�C ��:������%� ;�� ;�?% ���D��E8��������?%����3;�?�F%2$��� ����G��3!3H ��?D��E�� ��I%��&�J�I ��? ;"# #�A4KG !%2�25 !8.���� ;$#��%4�L$�4�� ��I��$#����$#�����&��%C$��M�� ��IN��%2��? ;"����#D��?���2$��%J<�8O$��2�2$#�P���&���?3!%�@�A

Q�R

Page 26: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

−1.

0−

0.5

0.0

pressure

Deg

rees

Cen

tigra

des

50 100 150 200

x

xx

x

x

x

x

xxxx

xxx

xxxxxx

xxxxxxxxxxx

xx

x

x

x

x

x

x

xxxxxx

xxxxxxxx

xx

xxxxxx

x

x

xxxxxxxxx

xxxxxxxxx

xx

xxxx

xx

x

x

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx++++

++++++++++++++++++++++++

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++

++++++++

+++++++++++++++++++++++++

+++++++++++++++++++++

Kv = 5, S = 0.5, Faer = − 1.5

−1.

0−

0.5

0.0

0.5

pressure

Deg

rees

Cen

tigra

des

50 100 150 200

x

xx

x

x

x

x

xxxx

xxx

xxxxxx

xxxxxxxxxxx

xx

x

x

x

x

x

x

xxxxxx

xxxxxxxx

xxxxxxxx

x

x

xxxxxxxxx

xxxxxxxxx

xx

xxxx

xx

x

x

xxxxxxxxx

xxxxxxxxx

+++++++++

++++++++++++++++++++++

++++++++++++++++++++++++

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

+++++++++

+++++++++++++++++

Kv = 2, S = 3, Faer = 0

−1.

0−

0.5

0.0

0.5

pressure

Deg

rees

Cen

tigra

des

50 100 150 200

x

xx

x

x

x

x

xxxx

xxx

xxxxxx

xxxxxxxxxxx

xx

x

x

x

x

x

x

xxxxxx

xxxxxxxx

xxxxxxxx

x

x

xxxxxxxxx

xxxxxxxxx

xx

xxxx

xx

x

x

xxxxxxxxx

xxxxxxxxx

+++++++++

++++++++++++++++++++++

++++++++++++++++++++++++

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

+++++++++

+++++++++++++++++

Kv = 2, S = 8, Faer = − 0.5

−1.

0−

0.5

0.0

0.5

pressure

Deg

rees

Cen

tigra

des

50 100 150 200

x

xx

x

x

x

x

xxxx

xxx

xxxxxx

xxxxxxxxxxx

xx

x

x

x

x

x

xxxxxxxxxx

xxxxx

xxxxxxxx

x

x

xxxxxxxxx

xxxxxxxxx

xx

xxxx

xx

x

x

xxxxxxxxx

xxxxxxxxx

+++++++++

+++++++++++++++++++

++++++

+++++++++++++++++++++

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

+++++++++

+++++++++++++++++

Kv = 0.26, S = 3, Faer = − 0.25

−1.

0−

0.5

0.0

pressure

Deg

rees

Cen

tigra

des

50 100 150 200

x

xx

x

x

x

x

xxxx

xxx

xxxxxx

xxxxxxxxxxx

xx

x

x

x

x

x

x

xxxxxx

xxxxxxxx

xx

xxxxxx

x

x

xxxxxxxxx

xxxxxxxxx

xx

xxxx

xx

x

x

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

++++++++

++++++++++++++++++++

++++++

+++++++++++++++++++++

++++++++++

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++

+++++++++++++++++

Kv = 3, S = 1.5, Faer = 0

−1.

0−

0.5

0.0

pressure

Deg

rees

Cen

tigra

des

50 100 150 200

x

xx

x

x

x

x

xxxx

xxx

xxxxxx

xxxxxxxxxxx

xx

x

x

x

x

x

x

xxxxxx

xxxxxxxx

xx

xxxxxx

x

x

xxxxxxxxx

xxxxxxxxx

xx

xxxx

xx

x

x

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

+++++++++

++++++++++++++++++++++

++++++++++++++++++++++++

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

+++++++++

+++++++++++++++++

Kv = 0, S = 1.5, Faer = − 0.75

�������������� � ��?�� !���� ;D��1�J�?�&��%G�L$����� ���I%� ��F��$#�E8� (������ ;$#��% $��,�� ��6�3! (�6���2�6%���%2�2��� ���$&������ ;�?%AJK $���%��$����?%��O$#��� �2$��� ������ ����K���� %� (�E��3!���� ;$#��%A��� "!���$����?%���$#�����2$��� �� ����?�. !���� ;D��I�J�?�&��%?A#�$�%!.��$����?%���$#����2$6�� �� $&8�%2��D����� ;$#��%A

Q'&

Page 27: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

��� ��� ����� �������������������������! ���#" ��%$&�'� "(" ��)*�'�'��+,+-�.���/ " �� ) 0 1) � � �0 (2 � �%�3�� "4�5" ��6�3�� ""87&� ) � � � 9: ��� �;��< � >=?�'� " �%> @9A���3��0 "B��� ���/� " ��C���/ " �� ) 0 ��02 � � " 0�D�;�����3 �/ ���/)E� " 0 " �'� "F" �%2 � " � � � �����/ " � �/<�� " � � G � < " �'�/�!� � � � 9IH�JK�'�E�' " �����E�� " ��9 � � "L���M� �� �@�N��2 7 � " � � " �� � " �%2��� � �@ � �C��-+ ���O" ���2 � " �� � �( C2�� � ��� ) 0� 7 � " � " �� ��" �% � "87B� ���3�'�P � " �/)0 !�&Q8 " � ! " �3����/+�R " �� � 09: "4� < � � < " �� " �N��� � �' �(�3��2S< "87 0 " ���2 � " �� � ��< �� !� � TH>J 7 � " � " ����/ ��� �(9A� " �/�'2��� � �C�� � " ��L2 � " � � � � � < " �'�3%0� � � � 9ULVW2 ��� YXZ���

[ \^]E_a`>bc_a_a]0dAe fgech ijdAec`�kEbc_;]0dAec_

�����/ l2'��2 �>2�� � � �/��0 l�� �G)0) ! ( � � �#�/9A2G� !9�! " � " � � ��� �6$#�E+'0 �3��m9 � �%0� ��� � " ��?)E�����3<%�4� " � � ���" �%�2'�'�4��9� " �( ��3 " ��>n5Q8� Q ULo�n��Pp ��'�E���rqG2G� � �0� " ���2 � " �� � �s�%�3 " � �/<�� " � � ���t" ���)0���39A� " @+u " 09j2�� � 2 � " � ! &<'�� 0� � 6���wv � ! " �G9A9A�'�� ! ��� )0���39A� " Y�'� " ���� �6)!� �/9A� " � �/9 � �3� " � � x�MV �%�9 � �%0� �3 B��< �� "4� < � ! ���/ ��� �(9A� " � � � � � 9j�%�/v �0 " � ���() 0 0R%�3 )!� �G���3%�����3 "4� ��3)0��� � 0) � �(�G 0Rty�o�n� � " 2�� " RDn5Q8� Q ULo�n � � " 2�� " �� � rqG2 � "lz �{7 ��0����g<'�� !� � " ��? () ��0 " �/|')g� � " �4� " ��� ��>J��3� " �%���'� �3��<��/��� " + � � � 9}2'�'�(��9 " ��! " �39A� " � � �3 &��)!) � � " 0� ��� ���/ " �� �0 � � " 0�&X �L" ��>2��0 ! " ��'���w+u �/ 2�� � � �/��0 &��A�� @ 0 @ (9 0 "���� � �~7 2 � " � � � �F���/ " ��3<%� " � � M���wv � � � � 9 " � � ��3 � � � ! " " �����t� Q��P��&u�7 ��!� � )*����� � �3��<��/� � " + �3 �) � G �/�� �0�D����0 �G� " ��� � " �%�2 � �/ " 0 " �/9A� " ! ���&" ��A)0���39A� " 6 �+Z " !92�� � 2 � " � ! ?� � : �/9 �3�3�'� "4��" �%���'���w+Z �3 �/ � � �0 " " �����M� Q��P�'&u� R �/�2'�'� " �3) � �3�'� ��� �l���� �m�Y�����L�� ��� � " �%0��0 ( !R 7 � < �@��� �G< " �� " �3�������/v �0 ) 0 �3 " ��L @�'��2 0 ���;" ��L2 � " � � � �����/ " � �/<�� " � � !�o � �3 " ! "g7 � " � � � � ! " " �����&� Q��P�'&u� R 7 A|'G� " � � " Xu� �3 " �%�9 � " �/ ��� �@9�� " �w�� ���B" �� " ��� ���3�'�P � " �/)0 !R 7 ���/)*� �/ 7 �� � " � ��� " 0��/�� ���;" ������/ " ��3<%� " � � � )0) ���( �9 � " �lX �/9 �3�3�'�@�/+�R " �%?��E�� "�/ ��� �(9A� " � � ��3 ��/ " ��LH>J����3�'�P � " �/) 7 �� � 7 � �� 7 �/��0��/�� ����" �%����3 " ��3<�� " � � 0�F����L9 � "� � <�� "�� E� " ��� �3 " �� �0 � � " L�'� " ��? " � � ��6) � " �(�'�3 " � .���@��� 7 �� � " ��?2 � " � � � � �/ "�/ ��r�2 0 ��! "l���a" �� " ��?2�� � � �( !�#p � < ����0���' ��+. @9����3�����wv � ! ) ! �3 " ���2 � " � � � �>���3 " ��3<�� " � � � < " �'�/�0� � �/��A���wv � 0 " y?o�n � �G 0�

V"��� ���4��2 ���/)E���#�0 � � " ��� 7 0�/�F�� " ��� � 9 � �/)E���a��������0 ���F" ��:$B�'� "@" ��)*�%�@+,+-�����/ " �� ) ! ��� �" �%�2 � " � � � �#���/ " � �/<�� " � � � < " �'�/�0� 7 � " � �/ ��� �(9A� " �/�'�2�� � � �@ � (� �{7 �1 � < " �� " �N��� � �' �(�3��2 7 � " �" �%Y2��� � �!�s� � �� ( 0 " ��l ���P��w|')0�� ) ����" ������wv � 0G) 0 �< "87 !�2�� � � �#�� �%2 � " � � � � ��� �B������ �� 7 �) � �/�� � " ��C���/ " ��3<%� " � � ����"87B��� �'�� " � " ��0 !R �0�3� " !� "(�L" ��0 �)!� �/9A� " C2�� � 2 � " � ! 0R � !� "(�)*�'�'�(��) " ��3� 1)0���39A� " g9 � ��0�/ l2��0���/) " � � G 0�>����0 ��'� " ���� �4�� � ! " oB� �/9A� " 1��! (2 � %���>o#� ��� ��X 0��� !�'0�>���3 ���XG��� � ���% "(�m" �� �@9A�����qZ2'�� � � D�����%!+��'� �! " �39A� " 0��<-+�)0���3) � �3� " �/��" �%�)!� �/9A� " L �+Z " !9 �0 @2 � G "4� �: " �� �'�'�@���3� 0� ��� �() �3%�� @) 0 �'� � � ���6��� �;� �~�:��+'E�'���/ ) �E�� �/o�V Q ) � ) 0 " �(� " � � � �� � " � z �3%� " ��:)*�'����' �/ " 09:2 �(� " �������>o#� � �� �� E��� � ���!�Y��XG��� � � "" �% " �39 ��� o�V Q � � � < ���/�����+�0�'�l¡ �u� �Mp � ? (��9:2 � ! � � � 9¢���wv � ! " ���/ " ��3<%� " � � ��� ������ �� "4� ! " �39A� " " ������/ " � �/<�� " � � ��� �>o#�K�� ��XG�����£���� � ! � � " ��� � " �� �/ ��� �@9A� " �w���2��� � �0R " �%XZ���� � " ��>Xu�>¤LULV¥<'�� 0�A2 � " � � � �( M�'�� (� �{7 ��3���������� � Q �#� � �s< ��" � � � �� " � " ��0 7 � < ���� ���P��w|')0�� " )*�'����'0 �/ " �% ���B���/ " � �/<�� " � � 7 ��0 " ��Y2��� � � ����¦ �3 �� 2��'� " !� 7 �/� � " �� �CXZ� � �BXZ�¤§ULV1�

�� �-�'�@���3%� " �%1H�JW���3�'�P � " �/)�R 7 ��� � � " �'� " � " �/ " ��g9 � " ) � 9:2 ���q��� �.�%�/¨A) �G� "�� � "(�� ��lQ8 � ��) "Y7 12 � ��� �(9 0� " ��� 1 !2'�'�4� " ��� ���/+u 0 "�/-� � �w� �3�� � 2G2 ���'��� " !9:2 �4� " ��� 1)*� �������V"���L| �( " � "@" 09:2 " ) � G �/ " !� ��� � �3%� " �� � � �/� Q�Q�� ���/9 0 � � '���B�%�N�'�� � " �3)�Ra) � � � ! (2 � ���/�� "(�" �% ���P� " 2��0 @ �����N�E+� �( !�Fp " ��0���'���w+Z� 0� " ���| �@ "&��� ���#�� � " �%Y�3�� "#��� ���&�3�E+� �( � !2'�'�(� " !�/+��V � ���3� " ��� C)E�� 0 M) � �3�% � !�DR " �� � � " �'� " ) � � �0 (2 � �G "(�L" �� R�� "4� Q���� �'©;�L�N�E+' �( !R �/ " �� � %2�� � � �/���/�� " ���9 � " �3 ��� �(9A� " � � D�;JY B9 ! " � � �0���/�X !) " � � �= �«ªGR " ���2�� !���/) " �w������ � �3�� ) �3 " ���/

Q ¡

Page 28: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

p(TCR): prior (thin), ST (thick), ST+DO (dash)

0 1 2 3 4 5TCR (K)

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

p(SLR): prior (thin), ST (thick), ST+DO (dash)

0 10 20 30 40 50Sea level rise (cm)

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

��������� � Q � ��� ��3!���� ;D��E�� !%2�2� !8.���� ;$#��� �������� ;$#��%C�L$� ����� <=�2$&� @,�&��������� <�8�$��2�2$#� @ ��%� (��"���� � �1�=�$#��� �� ��5 ;$� �� !%2�2� !8.���� ;$#� $���� � �&����� <=�� � (��3! (����@���� �� ��$&%2�2�� ;$�C�� !%��2� !8.���� ;$#� $&8����� (���?�:��%� (��"���� <=�� � !���O@�&������ �� �O$&%��2�� ;$�4�� !%��2� !8.���� ;$#����%� (��"���� K�� <��.��%� ��?� @�A

)E�� �3 ��' �@+��3�'����� � � � " �� � � �3��H>J����3�'�P � " �/) � " �/ ����!.�3�'� �� �0��� � � " ���H�J ���3�'�P � " �/)L<'�� 0�� " ��:ª �P� "(��� R�� �'© � " ���9 �wq �/�� ���F" ��An.o�n�o 7 �� l�� �@+c2 �u� �0R 7 � " �m9 � "L���s" ��� (��9:2 ��0 ) � � � ! (2 � ���/�� "4� ��0 � ��52 � �/ " Y�� �����' ��+5� �{7 ��)!) !2 " ��G) �4� " � � �

� � � " ��AH>JgR 7 ��'�E�'6����� 0���G+m) � 9:9�! " 0� � " ��:���/ () � 02 �� ) ��0 g< "87 0 " ���n5Q8� Q ULo�n �/9 �G�N� " � � L�� � " ��1���/ "(� � �/)E��� ��������0 !R 7 ���/)*� " 0 � "4� 2�� � �%� ) 1�3�'���g2��0���/) " �/�'���� � �3�� ) ! 0�lJ� ��) � � ��0G) " ��g " � " �3 " �/)E��� 09 � �3� "4� ��2 � ��� �@9: �2 �Z� �(�w+ ��� �C2 � �/ " > ��" �3 " �� � �� ���/'������! ���P����3�D�sJ����� �%� " � � ���x2�� � < ��09 ����" �%�H�J �/ " �'� " � " )0�'� �� ! #� � "(" � �3 ��� �(9A� " � � ���< � � "B" �%l)0���39A� " @+u " 09 2%� � 2 � " ��0 �/�9 � "����F" ����3�E+� �@ 0�1p ��'�E�� �qZ)!� � �%0����,+ � < �@��� " � � ���# �� � �@ �3 � �%�9 � �%0���%p �� � " � � + " �%�3 � " �� �'� � � G� " �'� " �'� " �5 � ���() 0 ��'�A�' ��+��% " � � �'0� � � ���G� � " �/ �/9A2%�4��) " �/)E��� "(�lz 02 " �(��) z?��� ���3�Z2 � ( �/< ��� � �%�() ! ���t� < �@��� " � � '���% � � � �0�aV� " �� ��" �� �;�'�� � " �%� < ����� " � � 7 � g�'� " �� � ! � � " ��� �E�� �(�'���/��6�3�'���� � 9g< �@ ��� �'� " �GR' ��" �% � <G ����� " � � '������'� �3��<��/��� " +� @� � � �/�.< ��' ��+� (9A���/���#Q8 " �%g� " 9 � (2 �% � � < �@��� " � � Y� � L< ��" �� ()E� �() g�� �� � �/ @+�R0 @2 !) �3���/�/+��/�) � 9A2 �'� �/ � "(�1" ��Y�'� " � � !� ��� �#ULV��� ��XZ���'X � �/ )0��� ���/��A������ �%� " � � ���x � ���() ��� � � � � ��� � " �����'���w+Z �3 ���s" ��1H�J �/ ��� �q " ! � � "4� < g) � �/�� � 0�x��� �6� ��� " �� �l) � 9A2G� �/)E� " " �%�3 �2��/) " ��� �R 7 z �{7 " �'� "l" ��:H�J}�'� " �%�'�E��A� z �{7 �) � �/��<%�N�� �/ " ���� �{7 �L " �(� "4� (2 �� � �/)� ��� � �� R�� � Q��P� �'© � � �3 " ��A© �'� z � " �����s� � ���P¡ � �'� " �� " �� 6n E�'�@ " �����s� Q��P�'&u�(� ���;� z �/��" �%�3 ��/ "4� ��)0) � � " <-+ � �3%�A9 � � � !) 0 " �'� " �1 " � �G)*�.�� ������ Js� Q ����� � �(� " �����3R Q��P��R,� 9A�{+0���/9��/'� " " ���/ ><%�N�� C<�� " 2 �@�'��2 C ��" �39:2 ��� � + " �� �/ ( �%0 0�

�����) ���� 0 ":��� �@9 ���>" �� 09 � �3� "4� � �/ :2���� !�/+T " � " �3 " �/)E����R#�� �T � 2G�,+u �3)0���C) � �3�% �4� " � � �'�E���< ! �3 ) � �(2 � �(� " !� �3 "4� � " ��Vl����2 2�� � ��)*� "4� �/ ) � �(2 � �4� " �/��m��9 � � �E�����/ " �/)� " � � ) " ���7&� � �/��< "(� � .�� �/9A2G� 0� � ��+T<'���N��G) .9 � ��0�?���M$#n � � � � � " ��� �%� � ��) .��G���� 02 � ) 0��

Q �

Page 29: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

" !9:2 �4� " ��� ! 0RD�� �F$�n^)E���< ?) � G " �� ) " 0� 7 � " �� !�' �4���;�3� " � " � �%g� � �0 ��� �c�� � ) E���9 � ��0� �/9 �3�3�'� "4�L" �% � ��� �Zq:9 � q%!�6�3�E+� �M9 � �%0� � 0���3 " ���n5Q8� Q U�)!� �/9A� " C9 � ��0���ap C)0���) � �3�� �" �% 0% � ��+.<'���N��G) � � � " � � ��� ��� ���w��!c�N� " � " � ��?� � %��� ��������� � �� ���� ��&�� ���� 7 �� ���� �3 " ��5��E� " )E��2 ��) � " +�2 � � �� " 9A�� @ 0R������ �/ " �� " �39 �(� " ��� )*�'����� ����" �� " 09:2 �(� " ����� � 9����/+�RZ� �/ " ��>� � )E��� �4�����3� " �/�' ��� �@) �/�� R � !�N� " 0� "4� �Y�����LR�� �/ ��0�3� " !� "(� �WRu�� ���&��� ���'� " �%�� � " �3)0���M�� � � � � �/� � " ���s��E� " � �uq%! � � "?���&" ����3� " � " � ��A� � ��R �0�3� " !� "(� ���1�A����A�� " �'�/�3 ��� �G)*�5�19 � ��0�D�'� l< !+ � � " �%l () � 2 ���O" ���/ #2'��2 �C��� " � � ���P��Xu)*� � �/�� �1� � ��� Q,� 2�� � � �/��0 C� � �u� ��/ " � � ��� ) " � � "4�." �����0 � �� ��� � )*�T9 � ��!�3 !� � � � " ����G2 2 ���8�'� � " !9A2 �(� " �%� ����3�'�P � " �/)0 !RB�� ����� 0���G+����/ () �G ( !�DR 7 1� !� "4� ) � �3�% �� �/9:2 ��� � + �/�� " ��?���3�'�P � " �/) "(� )E��2 " ��� " �%g�3�'� ��r�8 @)E����< 0�'�E� � � �0���F+u2��3)0���/�/+�RC�� �F$�n � � ! : ��" �3 )!� �G�� " ����� � " �/)E��� " !9:2 �4� " ��� � " � � ) " ��� �/ " �%� " 9 � (2 �� � ��� � �5" �% � !�N� " � � �< "87 0� ��� � ��) %�� � � 2G2 ��� � � � " 09:2 �(� " ���6)*�'�����0 ?� !� ��� �%� " � � ���G) � �/�� �4� " � � x�����wq !�:�' � " �/)E��� " 09:2 �4� " ���>�%02 0 ��! ) ��/ s ��" �%0 ��� !� �/A�l " �� �'�'�@��F$�n < !)E�'� " �� �3 " �4��) " � � >< "87 05)0� � � � !R 7 � " �C����2 � �!R " !9:2 �4� " ��� ��� � 7 �/ � >� 0��� "(����wv � ! ":� 0� <'��) z !��Q " 9A�E+�< �2 � ( �/< �� "4� ���G��� ! ( " ��! ��� � " �3)0��� " !9:2 �4� " ��� ���!2 ! ��0G) �/ ( �%0 �<-+5���3� �{7 �3%�%) � !¨A) ��0 " �3 " ����F$�n "4� ���'��+���)0) � �(���/��P�w+P�ln5Q8� Q U )!� �/9A� " g9 � ��!� )0��2�� � � �/��� �G¨A) ��0 "Y� � �� " � " ��0 ��� � � " � "4� rqG2G� � �g��� " �( � " �w����F$�n " �� ) " ��� ! Y �G)*���� " ��0 ��

Q8 " ���/ g2 ��2 � 7 %�'�E�� " ��) z ��0�S�5)0��� �/<��(� " � � �2�� � < ��09 7 � " �T�59 � � " �3�%�39 0G � � '�����0 (2 � ���'� �3��< ����F�����/ ��3-� � �/�'0 " �� 0 " �39A� " � � ����� R 7 ���3)*� �3 >�� �/9A2 � � " �� " <-+,� 2�� � ��� ) "Y��� " �����'���w+-� �/ 0Ru �/ ) � " 2�� � � �3�%0 ��/ ��� �@9A� " � � ���< � � "s" ��C 0) � � � �@�� �F2�� � 2 � " � ! ����" �%>)!� �/9A� " C���'� �3��<��/��� " +��� � � �qG��9:2 ���R 7 ��'�E�' ! " �/9A� " ! ���&" �� ����0Z� ��0) � 9:2 � � " � � 7 ���/)*� @� �{7 ��)0��E�'�L���/ " �3 ) " � � < "87 0 ����0G (2 0) " � � 9 � � � 9}y �aU����� � �Y���'o�n Q 9 � ��!�3 !�F� �u�Pz �/���� "s" ��#|��( "F"87&� � �'0-��!)��"4� �( ��/ 0��)*��)E�� 7 Y|' � " �'� "&" ���+6�%�/v ���3 " �� ���B2 � "(" �(G ��� �3� " � " �G��Y��!2 ! ��! ) �R'<�� " ��" �/" � � ��� ��0)0���'���'�%02 0 ��! ) ��F���� " �� z1��� 0 " �39A� " �3%� � �3 F) � 9A2G� �/)E� " 0� 7 ��0 " ��C���3�'�P � " �3)��/ ��� �3�'� �'l���/9�! � � '��� � " +��� � " �� �"�/ 7 0� z 2%� � � � �/ ��� �(9A� " � � ��E��� �3�3��< ���R ��� z �/ " ��l)0�� ��� H�Jg�JY���� " �('� " �/�' 7&� � �/�A< "4� ) � �/�� �&��2'�'�(��9 " ��3)C " � �G) " �%� ��� � � RZ< �� !� � ��l����� �/�A (2'��) Y�� �" �/9 �) � ��� � �3�� ) � � ) " � � D��Q8 ���G��� " � � "4� 2�� � � �/���/��.��0 @ �� rq%�/<��/� � " +PR " ���/ ?��2 2�� � ��)*� ) � � �/� �� �/ "(�1" �� z �{7 �2�� � < � !9 " �'� " ) � ���'��N�� ) �2'� �4��9 " �@ �)E���< l���w¨�) � � "�"4� 0 " �/9A� " ��MJ��%�/v �0 "���/9 0 � � � !��� ) " � � .��2 2�� � ��)*� �3 " �'� "C����" �� )0� " �/�� " ��� � 9?< � ��� � �'0-����� �%0 ��� � �FQ8 � ��) " R" �%g2 � " � � � �>���/ " ��3<%� " � � ���!� �3 �%�3)0� " ! " �'� "Y� G�/+ " ��?| �@ "�� 7 ����!,��������! ��'� � ���P��w|')0�� " �w+�3�'� ���Rs � !� �/9 �3 � " �/�� " � � %9 � ��0 ��� ��� � �3��<��/� � " + 7 � " ���' �@+ (9A���/�#��9:2 ��� " � ��! �3 " ��%�'� " � �/ ��� z 0�w+ "4� < !v 0) " �/�'���p :�'� �) ��� �0 " �w+ 7B� � z �3%� �/�� � � �3�w+m$#�E+'0 �3�� �39:2 ��09 ! " � " � � ���F" ���/ ��2 2%� � ��)*�x�

" #^`%$�e�d'&Ik)(�h+*-, (�e/.s_

����M�'� " � � �@ 7 � F2'�'� " �3���3�w+l � 2 2 � � " 0�L<-+ " �%F�Y� " � � ���,XZ) � ! ) � � � � � " � � ���4�� " �lX%�O� y � 9A� " �� =��{¡P¡ R ªG�

0 (213(24!(lec`5(�_

JYG��� � � ���GRC���&y:�M�� ��XZ)*� ��0 �3��' �0RYn�� ���Y� Q��P� � � Vl< � !) " �w�� 0 " �39A� " � � ���l" ��.2�� � <'��<%�3��� " +�%0 � " + � � G) " � � ��� ��)0���/9�� " � 0G � " �w� � " +P�7698;:=<�>�?@9ACB)8ED�<�B)8NREFHGJIDR Q�Q R &P��RLKOQ�Q R & � Q �

Q �

Page 30: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

$� � �� �0R��G�3RMU"�Vl� �w�� � �(�GR��1�s��G��XZ�� ��� R&$��C� Q���� � � Vl< � !) " �w��5$#�E+�! �3�����'���w+Z �3 ��� @2'� " �3���/�/+) � � �0�3� " !�5� � " �G��6�>���� ��� >���� @<�����<������������������� B�� ������� �7B�BL>!������� ��>�'R�"JIDR �Eª & � K �Eª-¡�= �

oB�3�'� ( 0DR;n��/R n�+u 4� z R �F�xJg�/R�p E�E�' �0ROJg�#�G�3R o�� �G) �w|Gq£Ran��/R ���/)*�� � " R����3RO� � � " � �ROn��3R�p 0< �!RX��&�s�/R#JY�/)E��9 � R$�G�3RBJY���q ��£R%�g�MJ?�3R#$� ��� �!R#Jg�/RCo#��� � �£RC�L�/RCy���'��2 � �3 z ��R#J?�3R�y �u� ( �R ���3R� � �G9���DRay��/Ra� � z � " R �B�/Rsn �Pz � � �£R;Q*�OQ*�/Ra© "(� � z � � ��R&�1�/RsX "(� ��R;© � �� ��p���%� R&';�&� Q��P��Q,��F�'� " � �+Z " !9 9 � ��!�3 ��� �3 " �(9 0�%�N� " m) � 9:2 ���q � " + SoB� � �3�� " �� �-��2 �/ " �%c (2 0) " � � 9 ���)!� �/9A� " L �+Z " !9 9 � ��0�/ 0�)(&�*�+�-8-, A.J8NR F/DR R ¡� K�R � & �;ULVlQ � � � � ��� ¡P�� �P� ª � Q � �P� ��� ��Q���� � �P�

o�����@+PR-oY�3RPXG�� 0�� RP$Y����G� � � � ! " R-oY�G� Q��P��R,� Q8 � �0 ) ��� �O)0���39A� " & �+u " !9§2%� � 2 � " ��0 0�21 <3��@�89D�<�? 8��� B�46575�8�9�:.;PRuJY2G2 � ��0��n.� " ��09A� " �3)! Y��G��X " � " �/ " �3)! 0R�H�%�/�' �( � " + ��� o#����� ��� �(��3�6XZ�� " �Ao�� � ���

� � � ! " RaoY� ���3ROJY�/� !DRsn��;�L�3R;X �Pz�� � � ��R Jg�O© �O�� ��X "4� ��R;© � �?�&� Q��P� � � o � G " �(�'�/ " �3%��)0���39A� " 9 � ��0�C2�� � 2 � " � ! �G �/�� � 2 " �/9����C| ��� �@2�� �/ " �� " !) " � � �9� " � � � !�<(&�*�+�=����<>, A. ���?����B�R=F/�RQ ¡P¡ K�Q � R �

� � � ! " RAoY���C�/R�X "4� ��R:©O���?�L�� � X �Pz�� � � ��RAJg�L©O�A� Q��P�'&u� �s " �39A� " 0�K2�� � ��� )0���39A� " � �+Z �" 09 2�� � 2 � " ��0 ��/ )0��� ���/��S'� " ���4���Y�� ���� " �%� � 2 � ��!��3) ��� �() �/��P !� :=<�>�?@9ALB)87D5<�B)8A@E<���8NR�B�B�R� � � �� � ��� ��Q �-� Q��P��R y�� ��Q ª��-¡P¡Z�

� � � ! " RGoY� ���/R X "(� ��RZ©O� �?�/R X ��z�� � � �£RuJg�,©O�u�� �6J��3��0xR n��,�L�£� Q�����Q,� � �'�� " � � + �3%� � ) � " �'�/ " ��0 �/ )!� �/9A� " 6 @+u " 09 2%� � 2 � " ��0 7 � " � " �� �G ��� � !) 0 " )!� �/9A� " � < �@��� " � � G 0�C�D����<�E��<�RGF�"�H�R�'�{ª K ���{¡Z�

� � �( " �0RO© �/RO����9A�� 7 ��9?+PRI�1�/R�J � " ��q � RO© �/RO$� �@ " !DR;���/R;$� "(" 0RO�L�3R �t�����+PR U1�3R ���{+ 7&�Z� �DRJ�G�3R� 0��DR �G�/R'� �~7 �R�U1�/Rtn�+u����Rxy:�/R'� �P����-�GR��G�3Rt© � �/ DRt�L�/Rt���'�P�GRty��3RtXu)*� �G�3��RDn��t�� ��U � �(�3�� �DR�L�-�1��� Q��P� ¡ � oB�'�����0 �/T� " 9 � (2 �� � �/)�) � G " � " �%0 " A�� � �/ �4�����N� " �w�� ��� �@) �/�� �cQ8K(&�*�+�=����<( @6��ML <N46575PORQ?1 @<�S @9ALB��������6�D����<�E��<NTU� B�� B)8J(%>��� ����VW�� ��>� >��YX+>��[Z��+ML/:N� >��L?>\%��>)� @<N] >����� @�7B�BL<�B�B���<��� D5<�?>���� >��)� @<�\[���<���L >�^ <������<���_��� S%�� <���>�`(&�*�+�=����<Y( @6��ML <6� !� 0�£X£�£X � � � 9 � DRU1� � �/DRGn��un.��G��3%� R0';�uoB�%0DRGn��Zn.�'� � �%�3 !R0a��-J��' �@+ " R'n�� ��� �� � �&�� � �?�un �/�3�� � � R � Q � KOQ ª�= �o#��9g<���3���'?H>��w�� �@ � " +�© �0 ( !R£o#��9g<���3�%���R�H�a§�� �5� 7cbM� � z R'� b RtHYXZJg�

� � �( " �0R�©O�Bn����B�F�� � y � � � �@+�R$�G�&n���� Q�����&u� ����.)!� �/9A� " 5 ! � " �w� � " +��� � � " A) � 9A2 � �! " �%�N�'�� � !� � � � 9 0�'� " � �(�����3� " � � �<�� �%�� " �'� " �G��698N(&�*�+�=����<�R FP"DRtª�� K�R�Q �

� �4��9 �R#U1�2�G�/R�$ �u��" �DRB$Y�M$Y�F$Y�/R%a "@" ��0< � � � �%�P�DR%�G�FJ?�3RCX " �'�/ ��� � " �DRBU1�sJg�/RCy � � � �@+PRN�G�Mn��/Ro � �3���3G 0R�n��3RB�� �SJY�/� !DR�n��F�L�C� Q��P��R,� o � " �4�'�/��/���)!� �/9A� " ��� �0)E�� " ����� � � �� ��� 2��� � ��� ( �G9A2 " � � 0��:=<�>�?@9ALB)8ED�<�B)8I@ <���8NR B�FDR � � � � � � � ��Q �-� Q��P� =,yL� ��Q�Q�Q =%�P�

y � � � �@+�R$�G�3R�X "4� �Zv �0R��L�3R#����2 �!R�X£�/R>X "(��"(" R#© �&�� �����E+u� �0RC�?��� Q��P��Q,� J� � < ����� " � � '���/�/+< �� !� ! " �/9A� " ���O" ��L)!� �/9A� " L ! � " �w� � " +��2698N(&�*�+�=����<�R FH�Rtª ���~¡ K ª � Q �P�

�Y�� !DR-�G�£�� � Q�Q ��" �� �( �� Q��P��Q-� oB���39A� " ��� �() �3%�P �/�yLQ�XGX�XZQ Q��P��� �/9 � �3� " � � G 0��6985:=<�>�?@9ALB)8D�<�B)8NR FHGEd£RtULVlQ � � � � ��Q �-� Q���� �R�PU �P� �'�E=-ªG�

�Y�� !DRI�G�3RD��� @ !�3��ROy:�/R����3G�DR�U1�/R�X "(� ��RD© �/R��O��) �/ 0RDJ?�3R�� !< !��!v ROX£�/R����%0�G+�R����£�� �m� �4�E� �3 !R�s�a� � � � ª � �a¨A) ��0 "L" �%� r�8���/9 0 � � '��� �P� � <'��� 9 � ��!�3 ��� �l)0���/9�� " � " � ����0 Ln � ��0�/ �Q>�� �cQ(Q*�e >�J8AX <���� @�8 D�<�^ 8NR F F F'R &P� � K &�&�Q �

ª �

Page 31: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

� �� �@��R;y��3R ' 7 �� �( !R#�B�£p �3R $��4��) � ��" R © �/R y �/�3�� "@" R �?�/RO� � � R b �3R V"�( �3%��R&�G�On��3R � �/)*� � �/�/ 0Ra���3R© 0 % �0R6�G�u�� �6X "4��"(" Ru©O�x� Q��P� ¡ � H� �� �( " �� �%�3��g�� �6� "(" � �/<�� " �/���)0���39A� " �)*� �������DQ8 (&�*�+�=����<( @6��ML <N46575PORQ?1 @<�S @9ALB��������6�D����<�E��<NTU� B�� B)8J(%>��� ����VW�� ��>� >��YX+>��[Z��+ML/:N� >��L?>\%��>)� @<N] >����� @�7B�BL<�B�B���<��� D5<�?>���� >��)� @<�\[���<���L >�^ <������<���_��� S%�� <���>�`(&�*�+�=����<Y( @6��ML <6� !� 0�£X£�£X � � � 9 � DRU1� � �/DRGn��un.��G��3%� R0';�uoB�%0DRGn��Zn.�'� � �%�3 !R0a��-J��' �@+ " R'n�� ��� �� � �&�� � �?�un �/�3�� � � R &�& ª K ¡�= & �o#��9g<���3���'?H>��w�� �@ � " +�© �0 ( !R£o#��9g<���3�%���R�H�a§�� �5� 7cbM� � z R'� b RtHYXZJg�

Q8 " �('� " � � '����� � @>!��U" " 0) " � � ��� ��J "@" � �/<�� " � � .y � � � 2DR'oY��� Q��P��R,� U" " 0) " �/��A�� ��� "@" ��3<�� " �/��rq " �@'���#�/�� �%0 ) 0 � " ���)!� �/9A� " : @+u " 09 LJ � �� � 7K��� � !) 0 " ���G����G) 0 !� 698�(&�*�+�=����<�R F/�R� Q �%� K �Eª%�E= �

Q ©Mo�o}� Q���� ¡ � (&�*�+�=����<Y( @6��ML <)46575PO�� 1 @<�S!@9ALB��������D�D����<�E��<�T � B�� B)8�(%>��������VW�P����>� >�� X+>��[Z��+ML:N� >��L? \���> � @<�] >����� @A�7B�BL<�B�B���<��� D�<�?>���� >��2� @<2\ S�(%(a�,X � � � 9 � DR�X£� " �����u� !� 0� � RPo#��9g<���3�%��H>��w�� �@ � " +5©��0 @ 0� ��� & 2 2D�

� � �! 0Rt©O�3RG� 7 R�n��3R'© �'� z �!RtU1�3R n.�'� " �3xRtX£�'��G������� � �!RGQ*��� � ����� � X ��� � ��) L�'��� " 09:2 �4� " ��� L�� �� " C)*�'�����0 � �� � " ��L2'�� " � R�� +�E� �( 0� D�<�^!��<�� B >���:=<�>�?@9ALB�����B�R�B d£R �~¡�ª K � ���G�

a 0 %0�G+�Rxn���oY�t�� �.V�� �Y� �-��DR J?�O� Q���� � � $#�E+'0 �3���)0�����3<��(� " � � ��� ) � 9:2�� " �>9 � �%0�/ 0�56�>��P�� ���>��A� @< D�> A����D���_����� B�� �������D� >!����<�� A��&� <�����<�BATCRJI�BDR = Q�RLK = & = �

a� � "(" ��RM�L�3RMX "(� ) z �!R&��� �&�3R2� �u� 0R �B�;�� �T©s�3� "(" � �!RBy���� Q��P� ª � © � � < ��<��/� �/ " �3)�)0���/9�� " �)*�'��%��2%� � � !) " � � �� �3%�6� ���4����% "87&� � z 0� (&�*�+�-8-, A�J8NR�F F'R Q�R ¡ KOQ ¡ Q �

� E��xR �G�L� Q��P�P�u� �a� � � � " � � ����" ��m � � 5 @2 !) " �(��� ��� �4�����N�� ) � �/ ) " �%�9A�'�G �� ��9 �/��39 � 9��:=<�>�?@9ALB)8ED�<�B)8I@E<�� ��8NR F d£R Q = Q � KOQ = Q = �

� !� � " � !RaX£�/R�JY "4� � �£R �G���� � $ � +' �!RO����©O�M� Q�����R,� p �'�(9 �/�� ���M" �� 7&� �(�/� � ) E��DR�� � R�RLK�Q���� ªG�:=<�>�?@9ALB)8ED�<�B)8I@E<���8NR B�FDR � � � �� � ��� ��Q �P� Q��P� =-y�� ��Q � R � Q �

n 0�'�( !RFoY�3R�� � � ! " RaoY�3RsXZ2 ! ) �0Rs�L�/R � � �Ra�L� �� ����!+u � �3� !Rs�L�B� Q��P��&,� p¥� � " �/ � �%� � G�� � � " ��G���3%� ���£" ��>) � " � �/<�� " � � �9������<-+ � < ����� " � � '��� � �F9 " � � � � � � ���3)0��� � ) � " �'�/ " � ! "(�?" �%2%� !� � � � @�/+ �02 � � " 0���� � " �/)E�������/v �0 ) 0 ��3 " 09:2 �4� " ��� " � 0G� ��Q8 1 <��7?<�� �����P� < 16� <� � B��+� @<)@ >���<������ ��>LB�?@<�� <WQ)����<�?BN� >��� I � <�� B����� � �+ML��� � D5<3��>�E���+�*�+ML , � �2<�� <�E��<�B�� !� 0�D���x���aL�'�@��RsX£�G�G� �Y�� @ � ��R&oY�aU1�;n �3�/�� �:�� ��p �;�s�sn ����4�E+ � � J ��!2 � � " <-+ " ���oB���39A� " �oB�'��%��Xu) ��0 ) g© � � ���4��9�� � " ��?X �G<£) � 9:9�� "(" � .yL� � <'����oB�'��������0 E�'�@)*�DR'p��� @���/�� "4� DRtULoY�

n 0� ��RCy��3RBX "4� ) z �0R#���/RCo � �/���3 !RBp �/R � � ��0� ���/��P " �/DR�©O�3R#y��E+��RBJ?�3R#y � � � ��+PR��G�3R�a � "(� �DRBJ?�3Ra� � "@" ��R����/ROn ���@2 �-+PRI�G�/R�� � �'�GRDJ?�3RD����2 �!ROX£�/Rxp�� "(" �( � DR�Q*�/RDp 0�{�' �!ROJ?�D��G� 'x� � � R#';� ��oY�� Q��P� ¡ � yL� � <'����)0���39A� " �2%� � � !) " � � !�BQ8 (&�*�+�=����< ( @6��ML < 46575PORQY1 @<AS!@9ACB��������D�D����<�E��<�T � B�� B)8(%>��������VW�P����>� >��=X >��[Z��+ML/:N� >��C? \N��>)� @<�] >����� @ �7B�BL<�B�B���<��� D�<�?>�����>��$� @<N\3���<���L >�^ <������<��9�����SN�� <��>��(&�*�+�=����< ( @6��ML <l� 0� !�-X£��X � � � 9 � DR-U1� � �/DR,n��Pn.�� ��/�� R7';��oB�%0DRun��Pn.�'� � �%�3 !Ra���J>�� ��+ " RFn�� �����P � �?�� � �?� n �/�3�� � � Rs¡�=,¡ K � = & ��o#��9?<�� �/����6H���w�� �( � " +�© �0 ( !RFo#��9?<�� �/�����RH a ��G�.�� 7 bM� � z Rt� b RtHlXZJ?�

n � " )*��!�3��R �G� �B�x$Y�/R#aL�'� � �w+PRxU1�#�G�/R � �� �@��ROy��xoY�3RI' 7 �� �@ 0R �B�tp �3R�J��3��0xR�n����L�D��G��n.�'� !�� � R�G�x� Q��P� � � U" " 0) " � � ��� )0���39A� " l)*�'��%����� �%� "(" � �/<�� " � � ��� )E�'� 0 !�aQ8 (&�*�+�=����<?( @6��ML <�465757:�Q

ª%�

Page 32: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

1 @< �D����<��� � �N� T � B�� B.� !� 0� �G����� � � �%�P� "4� DR b ��U"�3��GR U1�#�G�Oy �� ���� 0R n���� � ���� �!R;©O�I�G�D�����% �F� �3G��0DR��g�-U��'��RMa:�-n.�� z 0�/�t�� �6oY�PJg�7� � � � � R & � RLK ¡�ª � �Po#��9?<�� �/�����H�%�/�' �( � " +A© �0 ( !Ro#��9g<���3���'�R�H�a§�� �5� 7 bM� � z Rt� b RtHlXuJg�

n � ��-��DRun��uy:�-�� �=a � " �DRuU1��p �t� � ��� R,� X � < � !) " �w�� � � ����!9 0 " M<-+:)0���39A� " �rqZ2 � " !��� �^!�+� >�J8�D��� 8$1 <3��@ >�� 8NR�F�"DR = & � J K =-¡ & Jg�

©;� � z �0RtU1� ���3Rty � �@� � DR n��3R'o�� �3��� 9�R'U1�G© � ���3R'X �q "4� DR'U1�'n�� �?�/R � � �/�N�� �DR'oY�6a�� �� ���>�E+u� �!R���t� � ���-¡ � J % 7 ��� � < ��������3� �%0���4����� � � �� " !9:2 �4� " ��� C�'� " �l<'�� ��� � �0) 0 "F" 09:2 �(� " ���" � ! � 0�':=<�>�?@9ALB�������� D�<�BL<����[��@ @E<�� ��<�� B�R F���R �E=���� K � R���Q �

©;� � � � RP�L�u� Q��P��R,� U" � �'�G� " 2��� � �@ ��� �Oy��'�G ( �3��?2�� � ) ! ( ! 0�21 @<J��� ��� B5>���������� � B�������B�R�B BDR R�R'&CKOR � Q ��>��9A�� z � "(" +�Rx������ � � � ��!+�RD�G�tJ?�;� � ����� � �s " �/9�� " �/��%���/ "(� � �/)E����)*�'�����0 �3 �P� � <'�����3�� �.) � �� � ) � � 2G�N��G� � � � 9 �~¡ �P� "4� � �� Q � :N� >�V3��� T$��> L <�>!��@<��?�������J(�AM��� <�B�R FPBDR ��-¡ K � ��Q ¡Z�

XG��G ��� RM$Y�/R�� � � ! " RMoY�a�� � 'D�� " !��0 @)*����RBU1�#� Q��P� ¡ � X " � " �/ " �3)0���B)0�����3<��(� " � � ��� )!� �/9A� " � �+Z " !92%� � 2 � " ��0 0� 1 <3��@�8;D�<�? 8���� B�46575PO 9�5���RsJY2 2 ����0�¥n.� " ��!9�� " �/)0 ��� � X " � " �3 " �/)0 0R#H���w�� �( � " + ���o#��� � ��� �(%�N�AXG�� " �6o��� ���

XG� "(� Rxn��3R��Y��G 0xR#�G� �C�/R�n�){o � �@9��/) z ROn��£© �£�� �c© � �3�3��) z R-�G�£$Y�;� � ����ª � X " �4� "4� @2 �� ��3)1�' � � � �� 2 " �/)E���x��02 " � 0�=698;:=<�>�?@9ACB)8 D�<�B)8NR�"�/DR Q�Q � � ¡ K�Q Q ����= �

XZ)*� % �/�� �!RxX�� �?��� � ��� Q-� Q8 " � � ��� ) " � � "4� )!� �/9A� " L9 � �%0���3��G�aQ8 (&�*�+�=����<�� ALB���<�� e > � <��*�+ML�� 0�x�a�� ���'� � !u< � " � � R�ª K�Q'& �'o#��9g<���3�%��gH>��w�� �@ � " +5©��0 @ 0R�� 7cbM� � z R'� b �

XZ9 � " �DR:X����G�/RgJYG��� ! 0R��L�3R1o � ) 02 " � � xR ���l�� � � ���@��R �G�1� Q���� ª � ���3 "4� ��3)0���1 � � � �%�c��� � q �/��!9 �3 @ � � �� � R�� � Q����P� �G1 <3��@�8 D�<�? 8R��� ?EQ���� LP����� 8 �P� � 8 < � ���B�B��?�+� @������ B�� �� N4 � �?� B�B���>��B���RP©;��) �w|')� � � " � 7 ! " �Y� " � � ��������< � �4� "(� �@+�R�� � �/ " y�� � < ����oB�'��%��g��0 E�'�@)*�.Q8 " � " � " �R � = �P� $#��� " �39 � �J>��! �%�R£o � �/� ��g© �'� z R�n.� �@+u�N�� � Q�� ¡�= � �

X �Pz�� � � ��R&Jg�s©O�3R�� � � ! " R&oY� ���s��G��X "4� ��RB©O� �?�C� Q��P� ª � o � 9:2'�'��3�� � ) E����3)��%E� " � 2 " � z �/� � �P)09 " �(�� ��0 " )0���39A� " L)*�'����� �qZ2 ��39 0 " 0�2698N(&�*�+�=����<�R F9IDR � R ¡�ª K � R � Q �

X �Pz�� � � ��R�J?��©O�C�� � X "4� ��RL©O���?�?� � �� � � � J � rq%�/< �� )!� �/9A� " �9 � ��!� ��� � � �/ �/ " �'�4� " 0��� ( ! ( @9�! " 0� (&�*�+�-8-, A�J8NREF��OR Q �%� K ª � ªG�

� � � ��� � < � J � �q �/< � A)0���/9�� " A9 � ��!� ��� � � ��/ �3 " ���4� " 0���� @ 0 @ (9 0 " 0� (&�*�+�=����< , A. ���?����B�RF���R Q � � K ª � ªZ�

X "(� ��R�© � �?�B�� � b � � R�n�� ��X£�l� � � � ¡ � U"���!� � 2G9�! "5��� � "87B� � ���/9�! � � '����� � '���3�w+ �E�� �4�'�'0� " � " �3 " �/)E��� �8�Z+Z ��9 �3)0���Y9 � ��0���&2 �'� " � � " �� � � �� ��� 0� �Z+�9 � 9 0 " � 9 � �uq%! �/ " �� ��0� �4���) � �@) � �3� " � � 5�� � " �% ���>2 �'�4��9 " � �/�E� " � � D��698#��� ��>LB)8 �D��� 8NR�����R'ªP¡ & � K ªP¡ � & �

� � � ��� �,� U"!�'0� � 2 9 0 "���� � "87&� �8�%�39 0G � � '���s� � '���/�/+��E�� �(�'��!�� " � " �3 " �/)E��� �8�Z+Z ��9 �3)0���a9 � �%0���2 �'� " ��� � " ���2'�'�(��9 " � �/�E� " � � ����" ���!� �G+ � �uq%! ��� �%E� " �� �:9 � �/ " ��� ���698&(&�*�+�-8NRMBDRu¡ Q'&CK ¡�= � �

ª Q

Page 33: stat.cmu.edustat.cmu.edu/bayesworkshop/2007/Sanso.pdf0( - - [ --[ -(^ 7v * , - , \

� 0<'���/����R�oY�t�� �.XG�� 0�� R'$Y�O� Q��P� ¡ � � � �/ " 2�� � � 0) " � � ���O" !9A2 �(� " �%� ��� ��2�� !) �/2�� " � " � � �)*�'��%��� � � 9 9 � � " �/2 ���)!� �/9A� " �9 � ��0�/ �J��� �4�'�@)*���/)E����<'�E+'0 ���2 2�� � ��)*�D�K1 <3��@�8�D�<�? 8���� B�46575PO 9�:�4-RJ�2 2 ��� !��n5� " ��!9A� " �/)0 ��� �.X " � " �/ " �/)0 !R�H���w�� �( � " + ��� o#��� � ��� �@��N��XG�� " �6o��� ���

��� � �@��R�©O�tp �/Rt©;� � z �0R£U1� ���3Rt� "@" R£X£� �B�t$Y�/R � � �! 0R£© �tU1�/R�n5){o#� � " �-+�RDn��/R�o � ��09A��DR �?�t�� �$�� � �'��DRs© ��� Q��P��R,� ��!� �/ � " �/�� �4���%� � � ����G2 2 ���'��� " !9:2 �4� " ��� ! � � � 9 � � R ��"4� Q�����Q � 698:=<�>�?@9ALB)8ED�<�B)8NR F FHG�R'� � � � � � � ��Q �-� Q���� =M�PU �P��R ¡ R ªG�

p 0< " �!R�n��FU1�a�� ��X �Pz�� � � ��RBJ?�s© �>� Q��P�P�u� J 9 " � � � � � � ��+ ��� � � � �� " � � + �/�� � ) � " �'�/ " + �/)!� �/9A� " L2�� � � 0) " � � !� (&�*�+�=�������=( @6��ML <�R�� IDR'=��~¡ K =P= & �

'x� � �xRGp � ��G�.XZ�� ��� R'$Y��� Q��P� ¡ � X " � " �/ " �/)E��� �3 � � ! ) ��� ��� " 9 � (2G�� ��3) " �(�� @2 � � " 9 � �%0�/ �� �/��2%� � ) 0 @ C) � -� � � � " � � 0� ���^!�+� >����<���������B�R ULVlQ � � � � �P��Q � !-�£� � R � �sQ8.© � ! ( !�

ªPª