13

University of California, Berkeley...CFOPS /G¾{Ct@ ð ¾ / 1ü/ Ç CF6t¿F1

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: University of California, Berkeley...CFOPS /G¾{Ct@ ð ¾ / 1ü/ Ç CF6t¿F1

������������ ������������������������������ �"!$#%��������&����' �����(���)�*�$�����+"�,!-�

.0/ 1325476�1987:,/ 1<;7=?>�@BA�/DCFE�/G1<;?HJIG4<1�K"@<AML7N7OP/DCQIDR�OTS�E

U(VXW�YJZJ[]\Q^5_ `bac\bde`Q\�fgachGacijacVXd<kl deachm\Q^]ijan[po"V�q9U-rtscanqPV�^]deaurGk<vw\Q^]xm\bsc\Qo

y o r�de`{ze\bd<kJ^{r�d}| oDkJx ZJ~ean[j^]VXd��t��`bib� ~�\Q^]xm\Qsu\FoD� \b|JZ

�����b�b���}�t�X�M� d�[]zJaci�Y}rtY�\F^�kG�(\gYJ^]VtY�VXij\�[]zJ\M�t�T�{�Q�F���P���t�����t�����]�]�Fker�|GoGdertW�ac``bVtdD[]\bdD[,|Jaci�[j^]ac~eZG[]auVtd�i�oGi�[]\bW�~JZeacsn[,VXd []VXY?Vtq¡r¢Y�\b\Q^j£¤[]Vt£¥Y�\b\Q^gsuVD`br�[]acVXd�ij\Q^j£h ac`b\X�G¦�\�YG^]\bij\bdD[0r�^]\bYJsuac`�rMYJsurt`b\bW�\Qd [¡YG^]Vt[]VD`bVtsB[]zer�[0~eZJausu|Gi-[]ze\g[j^]\b\g�¡zJausc\W�\b\F[]audJ§�¨�Vm_"rtde|¢ij\F^]hm\Q^¡`�r�Y}rt`Qac[po�`QVXdei�[j^{r�acd []ib�e©-ze\�dGZJW�~�\Q^(Vtqª^]\QYescac`�rti0rti�(\bscs¡rti�[]zJ\�|G\bsurbo�rtde|�~}rtde|G�¡au|G[]z�`QVXdeijZJW�YJ[]acVXd�qTVt^�ZeY7|er�[]\�YJ^]VXYert§Xr�[]acVXdr�^]\5ijac§XdJan«}`�r�d []sno�^]\�|JZJ`b\�|<�D_GacW�ZJsur�[]acVXd�^]\QijZesn[]i(ijzJV��3[]z}r�[w[]zJ\¡|Jacijij\bW�acd}r�[]acVXd[j^]\b\�z}rti¡`bscVtij\g[]V�[]ze\5VXYG[]auW�r�s7dGZJW�~�\Q^(Vtqª^]\QYescac`�rtibke§XVDV |�scVmrt|�|Gaui�[j^]ac~JZJ[]acVXd<kijW�r�susG|G\bsur�o�r�d}|,~}r�d}|G�¡au| []z�Y�\Qd}rtsn[]ac\biªqTVt^¬ZeY7|Jr�[]\wW�Zesn[]ac`�r�i�[�`bVXW�Yer�^]\�|g�¡an[]z[]zJ\�a­|G\�rts<`�r�ij\X®}i�[{r�[]au`g^]\QYescac`�rMYesurt`Q\bW�\bdD[¡VXd �°¯ W�Zesn[]ac`�rti�[��

± ²e³0´�µ7¶�·�¸�¹º´7»]¶0³

¼g476�6�½ S�OT6�1eC�;�OP¾{CF¿QO­N7L7CFOTIG1%IGÀ¬ÁÂ6tN?S�IG1eCF6t1JCg/ 1<;%¾]CQ¿F6X/ Ã)O­1<Ä¢Ã)6t;�OP/�OP¾5I À9ÄJ¿FIDR�OT17Ä�OTÃ"ÅÆ IJ¿{Cb/ 1<S�6G@ª¼g476�Sb4B/ ÇTÇ­6t17ÄG6"OT¾�CFI Æ ¿QIDÈ}OT;�6"S�IG1eCQ6�1eCM;7OT¾{CF¿QO­N<L�CFOTIG13CFI�S�ÇTO­6t1JCb¾�R�O­CF4ÉÄGI}I�;Ê�Ë<Ì ÍcÎ�Ï°ÐÒÑ]Ó�Ô�Õ�Ö�×XÎ¥ØbÕÒÙbÊ,ÑmÔJÚ R�4<O­ÇT6Û¿Q6�CQ/GO­1<O­17Ä ÕpÜÝØ�Î¥Õ�Þ<Ï / 1<;àß Ì Í­ÌDÞªØQÕbá ¿F6X¾{IJL7¿QS�6�S�IG17ž{L7Ã Æ CQO­IJ13IGÀ�CF476�L71<;�6t¿FÇT=}O­1<Ä O­17À¤¿Q/J¾]CQ¿FL<S�CFL7¿Q6G@¬256�1eCQ¿Q/GǬCFI?CF4<6t¾F6¢ÄGIe/ ÇP¾,OP¾,CQ476)S�/ ¿Q6�À¤L<ÇÆ ÇT/JS�6tÃ�6t1eCgIGÀ-;</DCQ/�¿Q6 Æ ÇTOPS�/G¾�/G1<;%CF476�;�OP¾Q¾{6tÃ�OT1</ CFOTIG1�I À-L Æ ;</DCF6X¾�@

â¡¿Q6�È}O­IJL<¾wR5IJ¿FãMIG1"¿F6 Æ ÇTOTSt/ Æ ÇP/GS�6�Ã)6�1eC�OT1eÈJIGÇTÈG6X¾¡ä ÏjÌDÏ°Î¥Ø Æ ÇT/JS�6tÃ�6t1eC(IGÀB¿Q6 Æ ÇTOTSt/G¾9å�/G¾{ž{L7Ã)OT17Ä�CF4</ C-S�Ç­OT6�1eCQ¾tæm;�OT¾{CF¿QOTN7L�CFOTIG1�/ 1<;"/GStS�6t¾Q¾ Æ /DC{CQ6�¿Q1<¾(/ ¿Q60ã}17IDR�1�OT1"/J;�ÈD/ 1<S�6Jç­èté78]ê ë°@¼g476t¾F6�CF6XSb4717OPìeL76t¾�O­ÄJ17IG¿Q6�¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿�St/ Æ /JS�O­C]=?S�IJ1<¾{CF¿b/ OT1JCb¾�/ 1<;�/J¾F¾FL7Ã)6�6�í Æ Ç­OPS�O­C�ã}17IDR�Ç­Å6t;�ÄJ6�IGÀwCQ476�ÄGÇTIGNB/ Ǫî]âï176�C]R�IG¿Qã)CFI Æ IJÇ­IJÄG=G@

ð S�CQL</ ÇgÁÉ6�NÝS�IJ1JCQ6�1eC�;7OT¾{CF¿QO­N<L�CFOTIG1ï¿F6XìeL7O­¿Q6t¾ áDÐDÞªÌDñ�봯 IG¿ ÑDÞBÍcÎ�ÞºÕ ¿Q6 Æ ÇTOPS�/ Æ ÇT/JS�6�ÅÃ�6t1eCt@ ò�Ie¾]C�S�L7¿Q¿Q6�1eC¡25IJ1eCF6�1eC�K�OP¾{CF¿QO­N7L7CFOTIG1)ó,6�C]R�IG¿Qã�¾5ô�2�K�ó�¾Qõ(LB¾{6gK�ó�öeÅ�N</G¾F6t;"¿F6X;�O­Å¿F6XS�CFOTIG1ÉCQI�¿FIJL�CF6 S�Ç­OT6�1eCQ¾t欿Q6tìeL76X¾]Cb¾�çuèJ8{÷<8�ètø78�èmùXë�@¬K�L76�CFI�CQ476 1</ CFL7¿Q6�I À�S�6t1eCF¿b/ ÇTO­Et6t;Ç­I�S�/ CFOTIG1Ò¾F6�¿QÈ}OTS�6t¾t8¬CQ476�2�K�óú1B/ Ã)6?¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿¢S�/G1717I C)/DûªIG¿b;üCFIÂãG6t6 Æ ¿Q6tS�IJ¿Q;<¾�À¤IG¿"CF4<6Ç­I�S�/ CFOTIG1<¾�I À56t/GSb43¿F6 Æ Ç­OPS�/<@º¼g4}L<¾�CQ476�2�K�ó�I À�CF6t1 Æ ÇT/JS�6t¾�Ã�/ 1}=�Ã)IG¿Q6¢¿Q6 Æ ÇTOTSt/G¾�CF4</G1176tS�6t¾Q¾F/G¿F= /G1<;?S�IG1<¾FL7Ã)6t¾gL<17176tS�6t¾Q¾F/G¿F= ¾{CFIJ¿Q/GÄG6�¿F6X¾{IJL7¿bS�6t¾�/ 1B;?L Æ ;7/ CF6�N</G1<;�R�OP;}CF49@

ý7IG¿gL Æ ;7/ CF6�;�OP¾F¾F6�Ã)OT1</DCQO­IJ1¬8�î]âÒÃ"L7Ç­CFOPS�/G¾{C�4</G¾5À¤L71B;7/ Ã)6�1eCb/ Ç Æ ¿QIGN7ÇT6�Ã�¾5À¤IG¿�îj1eCQ6�¿FÅ176�C�;�OP¾]CQ¿FOTN7L�CQO­IJ1þç ÿmë�@�ý7L7¿FCF476t¿t8ºCQ476�¿Q6)OT¾�17I�R�OT;76�ÇT=Û/mÈm/GO­ÇP/ N<Ç­6"O­1eCF6t¿{Åj;�IJÃ)/GO­13î]â Ã"L7ÇuÅCFOPS�/G¾{Ct@ ð ¾�/ 1ü/ Ç­CF6t¿F1</ CFOTÈG6J8 ð Æ7Æ ÇTOTSt/DCFOTIG1��¬6tÈG6tÇ¡ò�L7Ç­CFOPS�/G¾{C ô ð �9ò3õ�CF¿QOT6t¾�CFI�N7L<O­ÇP;Â/G16�½ S�OT6�1eC�176�C]R�IG¿Qã)I À9L<17OTSt/G¾{C,S�IG1<176tS�CFOTIG1<¾�/ 1<;%CFI)S�IJ1<¾{CF¿QL<S�C�;7/DCb/";7OT¾{CF¿QO­N<L�CFOTIG1?CF¿Q6�6X¾IG1�CFI Æ IGÀwCQ47OP¾ ÑD×DÕ�Ö�ÍTÌDÐ ¾{CF¿QL<S�CQL7¿F6�ç ÿ�8���8{é<8��78���è�ë�@7ò�Ie¾]C ð �9ò ¾{=�¾{CF6tÃ)¾g4B/mÈG6�¾FSt/ ÇP/ N7OTÇ­ÅOuC]= Æ ¿QIGN7ÇT6�Ã�¾t8B¾FO­1<S�6MCF476t=�L�CFOTÇ­OTE�6"/ S�6t1JCQ¿Q/GǬ17I�;�6�CQI Ã�/ OT1eCQ/ OT1Û¾{CQ/DCQ6�À¤IG¿�/ ÇTǬ6�í�OP¾]CQO­1<ÄSb47O­ÇP;�¿Q6�1 ç é78��78�èJèG8��Dë°8(IG¿¢CFIÂ4</ 1<;7Ç­6�/ ÇTÇ��]IGOT1 ��¿Q6tìeL76t¾{CQ¾�ç ��è�ë�@w:,6 Æ ÇTOTSt/DCQO­17Ä3CF476�¿QIeIGC

Page 2: University of California, Berkeley...CFOPS /G¾{Ct@ ð ¾ / 1ü/ Ç CF6t¿F1

����� ���}��� ^]`FzJac[]\Q`Q[]ZJ^]\gV�q¬rM|Gauijij\QW�auder�[]acVXd"[j^]\b\X�

OT¾MCQ476 S�IJÃ)Ã�IJ1ɾFIGÇTL�CQO­IJ1ïç �78���è�ë�8�N7L�C�CQ47OP¾�¾{L7ûº6t¿Q¾MÀ¤¿QIGà S�IG1B¾{OP¾]CQ6�1<S�= Æ ¿QIGN7ÇT6�Ã�¾�/G1<;S�IGÃ)Ã"L717OPS�/DCQO­IJ1?IDÈJ6�¿Q476t/J;�@

¼g476�¿Q6�/ ¿Q6�C]R�I�S�¿QL<S�OP/ Ǭ;�6X¾{OTÄG1�OP¾F¾FL76t¾�CQ4</DC,R�6�CF¿Q=�CFI /J;7;�¿Q6t¾Q¾�O­1�CF4<OT¾ Æ / Æ 6�¿

èG@�>,IDR�CQIï;7=e1B/ Ã)OTSt/ ÇTÇ­= Sb47I}Ie¾{63CF476ü1}L7âNº6�¿�/G1<; Æ ÇP/GS�6�Ã)6�1eC�I À¢¿Q6 Æ Ç­OPS�/J¾%R�47OTÇT6¾F/ CFOP¾]À¤=}OT17Ä���Ieö%¿F6XìeL7O­¿Q6�Ã)6t1JCb¾g/ 1<;�¾F6�¿QÈG6�¿�St/ Æ /JS�O­C]= S�IG1B¾]CQ¿Q/GO­1eCQ¾t@

��@�>,IDRÉCFI,;7OT¾Q¾{6tÃ)O­1</ CF6¡L Æ ;7/ CF6X¾�CFIgCQ476t¾F6¡¿Q6 Æ ÇTOPS�/G¾¬R�OuCQ4�¾{Ã�/ ÇTÇJ;76�ÇP/m=�/ 1B;�NB/ 1<;�R�OP;}CQ4S�IJ1<¾{L<Ã Æ CFOTIG1¬@

5IGCF4�Ã"L<¾]C5NB6�/G;7;�¿Q6t¾Q¾F6t;�R�OuCQ47IGL7C06�í Æ ÇTOTS�OuC5ãe1<IDR�Ç­6X;�ÄG6�IGÀºCQ476�ÄJÇ­IJN</ Ç<176�C]R�IG¿Qã�CFI Æ IJÇuÅIGÄG=J@7ý7L7¿FCF4<6�¿X8�R56MR�IGL7ÇP;�Ç­OTãG6�CFI�¾QS�/GÇ­6�CFI)Ã)OTÇ­ÇTO­IJ1<¾�IGÀ(IJN ]6tS�CQ¾t87S�ÇTO­6t1JCb¾�87/G1<;�¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿b¾�@

¼9I�Cb/GSbã}ÇT6�CF476X¾{6�Sb4</ ÇTÇT6�17ÄJ6t¾t8<R�6 Æ ¿QI Æ IJ¾F6�/ 176tR ÁÂ6tN3S�IJ1eCF6�1eCM;�OT¾{CF¿QOTN7L�CFOTIG1¾{=�¾{ÅCF6�Ã� áDÎ äbä Õ�ñ�Î�ÞºÌ Ïp봄 ÞþÏ°ÖFÕbÕ ô¤OT1 ¾{4<IG¿FCt8 á��jÏpÖFÕbÕ õ�@9ý(OTÄGL7¿Q6�è)O­ÇTÇTL<¾]CQ¿Q/ CF6X¾�/�;}Å°CF¿Q6�6�¾{=�¾{CF6tÃ�@¼g476�¿Q6"/G¿F6�CQ47¿Q6�6¢ã}OT1<;7¾�I À0;7/ CQ/%O­1�CQ476)¾{=�¾{CF6�Ã�wä ÑDË�ÖFØbÕ ä�� ÖFÕ��ºÍcÎ¥ØbÌ ä�8¬/G1<; ØbÌGØ��7Õ ä�@ª¼g4<6;}ÅpCQ¿F6t6�CQ/G¿FÄJ6�Cb¾,;�=}1</ Ã)OPSMÁÂ6tN3S�IJ1eCF6�1eC�;7OT¾{CF¿QO­N<L�CFOTIG1��B476�1BS�6�CQ476�¿Q6�OP¾�/ ¾FO­1<ÄGÇT6�¾{IJL7¿QS�6IG1"CF476gÁÉ6�N)¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿X@ ð ¿Q6 Æ ÇTOTSt/�OP¾�/�S�I Æ =�IGÀº¾FIGL7¿bS�6�;7/DCb/,CQ4</DC�OP¾�¾]CQIG¿Q6t;�IJ1¢CQ476gIDÈG6t¿FÇP/m=¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿g/ 1<;?OT¾g/GÇ­Rg/m=�¾0ãJ6 Æ C�L Æ Å°CFIGÅ�;</DCF6J8}R�47O­ÇT6�/"St/GSb476�OP¾�¾]CQIG¿Q6t; IJ1?S�Ç­OT6�1eCQ¾�/G1<;?Ã)/m=NB6¢¾{CQ/GÇ­6J@<¼g476X¾{6�S�IGÃ Æ IJ176�1eCb¾,¾{6tÇuÀ�Å�IG¿QÄJ/G17OTE�6�O­1eCFI /�;�ÅpCQ¿F6t6�/ 1<;�L<¾F6¢/ Æ<Æ Ç­OPS�/ CFOTIG1�Å�ÇT6�ÈG6tÇâL7Ç­CFOPS�/J¾]C�CQIÛ;�OT¾Q¾F6�Ã)O­1B/DCF6%L Æ ;</DCF6X¾MÀ¤¿QIGà ¾FIGL<¿QS�6"CQI�¿F6 Æ ÇTOTSt/G¾t@(25IG476t¿F6t1<S�6)IGÀgSt/GSb476X¾OT¾�Ã�/GO­1eCQ/GO­1<6t;�;�=}1</ Ã)OPS�/GÇ­ÇT= CQ47¿FIJL7ÄG4�/ Æ<Æ ¿FIe/GSb476X¾g¾{L<Sb4�/J¾�çuèmÿmë�@�ÁÂ6"/G¾Q¾{L7Ã)6MCQ4</DC�;}ÅCF¿Q6�6M¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿b¾0/ ¿Q6 Æ ÇT/JS�6t;%O­1?îj1eCF6�¿Q176�CgK�/DCb/)256t1JCQ6�¿b¾�ô¥î]KM2gõ�IGÀ9Ã�/ ]IJ¿0î{ö�â5¾5R�O­CF4�ÄGI}I�;S�IG1<176tS�CFOTÈeO­C]=�CQI�CF4<6,N</GSbã}NºIG176J@G¼g476X¾{6,¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿Q¾(À¤IJ¿FÃ�/ Æ 6t6�¿FÅpCQI Å Æ 6t6�¿�IDÈJ6�¿QÇT/m=�176�C]R5IJ¿FãS�/ ÇTÇT6t;�� Ì��<Õ ä Ï°Ö�Ð ç � ø ë°8BCFI��<1<;3176t/G¿FN}=�¿F6 Æ ÇTOTSt/G¾�À¤IJ¿�CF476)S�ÇTO­6t1eCQ¾t@ªó�I CQ6¢CQ4</DC�¼w/ Æ 6X¾]CQ¿F=OT¾M¾F4</ ¿Q6t;Â/GS�¿QIJ¾Q¾,IJN ]6tS�CQ¾t8ªR�47O­ÇT6)6t/JSb43IGN ]6tS�C�À¤IG¿�;�OP¾Q¾{6tÃ�OT1</ CFOTIG134B/G¾M/%4<O­6t¿Q/G¿QSb47OPS�/GÇ;}ÅpCQ¿F6t6G@

ÁÂ6�Ã�/ ãJ6�CQ476MÀ¤IGÇTÇTIDR�O­17Ä�S�IG1eCF¿QO­N<L�CFOTIG1<¾gOT1?CF476 Æ / Æ 6t¿�

� ÁÂ6 Æ ¿QI Æ IJ¾F601<IDÈG6�Ç�/GÇ­ÄJIG¿QOuCQ47Ã�¾¬CQI�;�=}1</GÃ)OTSt/ ÇTÇ­= Æ ÇP/GS�6�S�Ç­Ie¾{65CFI�Ã)O­1<O­Ã"L7Ãà1}L7âNº6�¿I À-¿F6 Æ ÇTOTSt/G¾�R�47OTÇ­6�Ã)6�6�CFOT17Ä)CF4<6�S�ÇTO­6t1JCb¾�æ���I}ö%/G1<;�¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿b¾�æ�S�/ Æ /GS�OuC]= S�IG1<¾{CF¿b/ OT1eCQ¾t@

Page 3: University of California, Berkeley...CFOPS /G¾{Ct@ ð ¾ / 1ü/ Ç CF6t¿F1

� ÁÂ6�¾{6tÇuÀ�Å�IG¿QÄJ/G17OTE�6MCF4<6t¾F6¢¿Q6 Æ ÇTOTSt/G¾�OT1eCFI�/ 1Û/ Æ<Æ Ç­OPS�/ CFOTIG1�Å�ÇT6�ÈG6tǬâL<ÇuCQOTSt/G¾{C�CF¿Q6�6¢R�OuCQ4¾{Ã�/GǭǬ;�6tÇT/m=?/ 1<;�N</G1<;�R�OP;}CF4�S�IJ1<¾FL7Ã Æ CFOTIG1?À¤IG¿�L Æ ;7/ CF6�;�OP¾F¾F6�Ã)OT1</DCQO­IJ1¬@

� ÁÂ6üÇT6�ÈJ6�¿b/ ÄG6¼w/ Æ 6X¾]CQ¿F=ïCFIïOTÃ Æ ¿FIDÈJ6¾QS�/ ÇP/ N<O­ÇTOuC]=J@�¼(/ Æ 6t¾{CF¿Q= Æ 6�¿QÃ�O­CQ¾�S�Ç­OT6�1eCQ¾?CQIÇ­I�St/DCF6�1<6t/ ¿QN}= ¿Q6 Æ ÇTOTSt/ ¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿b¾�R�OuCQ47IGL�C%S�IG1eCQ/JS�CQO­17Ä /ü¿QI}I C�¡/G¾ /ü¿Q6t¾FL7Ç­Ct8¡6X/GSb417I�;�6�OT1�/);}Å°CF¿Q6�6MÃ�/ OT1eCQ/GO­1<¾�¾{CQ/ CF6MIG1<Ç­=%À¤IG¿�O­CQ¾ Æ /G¿F6t1JC,/G1<;�;�O­¿Q6tS�C,Sb47O­ÇP;�¿Q6�1¬@

ó,I CQ6MCF4</ C�/ ÇTÇ�CF4<6t¾F6�/ ¿Q6�/JSb47O­6tÈG6X;%R�O­CF4�ÇTO­Ã)O­CF6t;�ÇTI�S�/GÇ�176�C]R�IG¿Qã�CFI Æ IJÇ­IJÄG=�ã}17IDR�ÇT6t;�ÄJ6IG17ÇT=G@

¼g476,¿Q6t¾{C0I À�CQ476 Æ / Æ 6t¿0OP¾0IJ¿FÄe/ 17OTE�6X;"/J¾�À¤IGÇTÇTIDR,¾ JÁÂ6�À¤IG¿QâL7ÇP/DCQ6gCF476�¿F6 Æ Ç­OPS�/ Æ ÇT/JS�6�ÅÃ�6t1eC Æ ¿FIJN7Ç­6tà OT1 ö�6tS @ �?/ 1B;3OT1eCF¿QI};7L<S�6�¼(/ Æ 6t¾{CF¿Q=ÛO­1 ö}6XS @¬é7@9ö�6tS @�÷�;�6X¾FS�¿FOTNº6t¾�CF4<6Æ ¿FIGCFI�S�IJÇT¾(À¤IJ¿�N7L7OTÇT;7O­17Ä�/G1<;�Ã�/ OT1JCb/ OT17OT17Ä�/�;}ÅpCQ¿F6t6G@��0ÈD/ ÇTL</DCQO­IJ1�/G1<;¢¿Q6t¾FL7Ç­CQ¾¡/G¿F6gÄJO­ÈJ6�1O­1Ûö}6XS @Bÿ787/ 1<;��<1</GÇ­ÇT=?S�IG1<S�Ç­L<¾FOTIG1<¾g/ 1B;%À¤L7CFL7¿Q6�R5IJ¿Fã�OT1Ûö}6tSG@��7@

� �µ7¶����� ��¶¡µ� à¸���w´7»{¶0³

¼g476�¿Q6�OP¾g/�N7OTÄ);�6t¾FO­ÄJ1?¾ Æ /GS�6,À¤IJ¿�Ã)I�;�6tÇ­OT17Ä�ÁÂ6tN%¿Q6 Æ ÇTOTSt/ Æ ÇT/JS�6�Ã)6t1JCg/G¾g/ 1?I Æ CQO­Ã)OTEt/ ÅCFOTIG1 Æ ¿QIGN7ÇT6�à / 1B; R56?;�6t¾QS�¿QO­Nº6 O­C"/G¾�À¤IGÇTÇ­IDR,¾t@-25IJ1<¾FOT;�6t¿¢/ Æ I Æ L<ÇT/G¿¢ÁÉ6�N ¾FOuCQ6%IG¿"/2�K�ó 47Ie¾]CQO­17Ä�¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿X8GR�47OPSb4?/GO­Ã�¾5CFI�OTÃ Æ ¿FIDÈJ6,OuCb¾ Æ 6t¿{À¤IJ¿FÃ�/ 1BS�6�N}= Æ LB¾{47OT17Ä�OuCb¾gS�IG17ÅCF6�1eC�CQI ¾{IJÃ�6M47Ie¾]CQO­1<Ä)¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿g17I�;�6t¾t@7¼g476 Æ ¿QIGN7ÇT6�ÃúOT¾�CQI ;�=}1</ Ã)OPS�/ ÇTÇT=%;�6tS�OT;76�R�476�¿Q6S�IG1eCQ6�1eC�OT¾�CQI�Nº6�¿Q6 Æ ÇTOTSt/DCQ6t;%¾FI�CF4</ C,¾{IJÃ�6MIJN ]6tS�CFOTÈG6�À¤L71<S�CQO­IJ1�OT¾gI Æ CFOTÃ)O­Et6t;?L71<;�6t¿,/;�=}1</ Ã)OPS�CF¿b/D½ S Æ /DCFCF6�¿Q1?/G1<; ¾F6�CgI À9S�Ç­OT6�1eCQ¾tæ ��Ieö�/G1<;��mIJ¿0¿Q6t¾FIGL7¿bS�6�S�IG1B¾]CQ¿Q/GO­1eCQ¾t@J¼g4<6IGN ]6XS�CFOTÈG6,À¤L71<S�CQO­IJ1 S�/G1�6�O­CF476t¿5Ã)OT17O­Ã)OTE�6�S�Ç­OT6�1eCb¾�æ ��Ieö"Ã)6�CQ¿FOPS�¾t8J¾FL<Sb4 /G¾0ÇT/ CF6t1<S�=J8GÇTIJ¾Q¾¿Q/ CF6G8XCQ47¿FIJL7ÄG4 Æ L�Ct8m6�CQS @T8mIG¿-Ã)O­1<O­Ã)OTE�6�CF476�¿Q6 Æ ÇTOTSt/DCQO­IJ1"S�Ie¾]C(I À¬2�K�óݾF6�¿QÈeOPS�6 Æ ¿QIDÈeOP;�6t¿Q¾t86G@ Ä<@T8�176�C]R�IG¿Qã N</G1<;�R�OP;}CF4�S�IJ1<¾FL7Ã Æ CFOTIG1¬8<IG¿�/ 1�IDÈG6t¿Q/GǭǪS�Ie¾]C�À¤L<1<S�CQO­IJ1�O­À-6t/GSb4�ÇTO­17ã?OT¾/G¾Q¾{I�S�OP/DCQ6t;�R�O­CF43/�S�IJ¾{Ct@Bý<IG¿�ÁÂ6tNÛS�IG1eCQ6�1eC�;�6tÇ­OTÈG6t¿F=J87CF4<6�Ã�/ ]IG¿�¿F6X¾{IJL7¿QS�6�S�IJ1<¾{L<Ã Æ ÅCFOTIG13OT1É¿F6 Æ Ç­OPS�/ CFOTIG13S�IJ¾{C�OP¾�CF476)176�C]R5IJ¿Fã�/JS�S�6X¾F¾�N</G1<;�R�OP;}CF4É/DC�6t/JSb4Ûîj1eCF6�¿Q176�CMK�/DCb/256�1eCF6t¿�ô¤î]K�2gõ-CQI�CF476�N</GSbã}NºIG176�1<6�C]R�IG¿Qãº@ ¼g4}L<¾0R�476�1�ÄJO­ÈJ6�1�/�ÁÉ6�N�IJN ]6tS�Ct8 CQ476�S�IJ¾{COT¾�ÇTOT176t/G¿FÇT= Æ ¿QI Æ IG¿FCFOTIG1</GÇBCQI)CF476�1}L7Ã"NB6t¿�I À(¿F6 Æ Ç­OPS�/J¾�@

ð ¾ ��O­L Õ�Ï,ÌDÍ�� CF¿QOT6t;�CQI%Ã)O­1<O­Ã)OTE�6"CF476¢CFI Cb/ Ç(¿F6X¾ Æ IG1B¾{6�ÇP/DCQ6�1<S�=�I À0/ ÇTÇwCF476�S�ÇTO­6t1JCb¾�æ¿F6XìJL<6t¾{CQ¾�R�OuCQ4ïCF476�1}L7âNº6�¿�IGÀ�¿Q6 Æ ÇTOPS�/G¾)/J¾�S�IG1<¾{CF¿b/ OT1eC�ç­èté ë°8-R�6�CQ/GSbã}ÇT6%CQ476�¿Q6 Æ ÇTOTSt/Æ ÇT/JS�6tÃ�6t1eC Æ ¿QIGN<Ç­6tÃ*À¤¿FIJà / 17IGCF476t¿M/G17ÄGÇT6 ªÃ)OT17O­Ã)OTE�6�CF4<6�1}L7Ã"NB6t¿MI À0¿Q6 Æ ÇTOPS�/G¾�R�476t1Ã�6t6�CQO­17ÄÂS�ÇTO­6t1JCb¾�æ9ÇT/ CF6�1BS�=üS�IG1B¾]CQ¿Q/GO­1eCQ¾�/G1<;ü¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿b¾�æ¬St/ Æ /JS�O­C]=ÂS�IG1<¾{CF¿b/ OT1eCQ¾t@¬>,6�¿Q6�R�6/G¾Q¾{L7Ã)6"CF4</ CMS�Ç­OT6�1eCb¾MÄGOTÈG6¢¿Q6t/J¾{IJ1</ N<Ç­6�ÇP/DCQ6�1<S�=ÛS�IJ1<¾]CQ¿Q/GO­1eCb¾�/J¾�O­C�S�/G13Nº6�1<6�ÄGIGCFOP/DCQ6t;CF47¿QIGL7ÄJ4�/�¾F6�¿QÈ}OTS�6�Å�Ç­6tÈG6�ÇJ/ ÄG¿Q6�6tÃ)6�1eC5ôpö � ð õ9Nº6�C]R�6�6�1"S�ÇTO­6t1JCb¾w/G1<;"2�K�óÒÈJ6�1<;7IG¿b¾�@�¼g4}L<¾R56"À¤IG¿QâL7ÇP/DCQ6¢CQ476)ÁÂ6tN S�IG1eCQ6�1eC Æ ÇT/JS�6�Ã)6t1JC Æ ¿QIGN<Ç­6tà /G¾�À¤IGÇTÇ­IDR,¾t@���O­ÈJ6�1É/%176�C]R5IJ¿Fã� R�O­CF4��ÂS�ÇTOT6�1eCQ¾�/G1<; Ô ¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿51<I};76t¾t8�6t/GSb4�S�ÇTOT6�1eC����-4</G¾gO­CQ¾ ÍTÌDÏjÕ�ÞªØ�Ð%ØbÑDÞ ä ÏpÖFÌ Î�Þ<Ï�� �{8/ 1<;ü6X/GSb4 ¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿! �"�4</G¾¢OuCb¾�Ç­Ie/G;��DN</ 1B;�R�OT;�CF4#� ¾]CQIG¿b/ ÄG6 ØbÌ��<ÌGØ�Î�ÏpÐüØbÑDÞ ä Ï°ÖFÌDÎ�ÞBÏ%$ "G@w¼g4<6Æ ¿FIJN7ÇT6�Ã�OP¾�CQI �<1<; /3¾{Ã�/ ÇTÇT6t¾{C"¾{6�C�I À,¾F6�¿QÈG6�¿b¾'&)(5¾{L<Sb4üCQ4</DC¢CF476%;7OT¾{CQ/G1<S�6 Nº6�C]R�6�6t1/ 1}=�S�ÇTO­6t1JC*����/ 1<;�O­CQ¾ � Æ / ¿Q6�1eC �%¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿ ,+.-0/1&)((OP¾�NºIGL<1<;�6t;3N}= � �F@ºò�IJ¿F6¢À¤IG¿QÃ�/ ÇTÇ­=J8�<1<;�CQ476�Ã�OT17OTâL7Ã32¢8}¾FL<Sb4 CQ4</DC�CF476t¿F6�OT¾g/"¾{6�C4&)(65 Ô R�OuCQ487 &)(97;:<2 /G1<;>= Ø /?�-8@ + /A&)(�¾FL<Sb4�CQ4</DC,;�OP¾]Cb/ 1<S�6JôB�D8� + õC � + @�ò�6X/ 1}R�47OTÇ­6J8JCQ476t¾F6MS�ÇTO­6t1JCb¾4D / 1<;?¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿b¾&)(-¾{6tÇuÀ�Å�IG¿QÄJ/G17O­Et6�OT1JCQI�/G1Â/ Æ7Æ ÇTOTSt/DCFOTIG17Å°ÇT6�ÈJ6�Ç9Ã"L7Ç­CFOPS�/G¾{C�CF¿Q6�6�R�OuCQ4ED /J¾�ÇT6t/mÈJ6t¾�/ 1<;F= � /G&)(p87O­CQ¾gÀ¥/G1�Å°IJL�C,;�6�ÄJ¿F6t6�ô¤O°@ 6J@­871}L7Ã"NB6t¿�I À�;�OT¿F6XS�C,Sb47OTÇT;�¿Q6�1ºõ5¾Q/DCQOT¾ �<6X¾�H-ôB � õIC $ � @

Page 4: University of California, Berkeley...CFOPS /G¾{Ct@ ð ¾ / 1ü/ Ç CF6t¿F1

3598

2218

0325

B4F8

9098

4432

9598

Gateway of client

3A40

L4

L4

CE42

L1

L1 L2

L1 L1L1

L2

Root

Replica−2

L1Replica−1

L4

L3

L2

L1

L1

L2L2

1212

4432

45984432

75980128

1010

����� ���<� ©-ze\¡©ºrtY�\bi�[j^jo � dGqT^{r�i�[j^]Ze`Q[]ZG^]\X®������D�F�-�j���G�p�¡�¥�,�}���D�F�0�t�7�0�t���t�P�º�t�ª�,���P������ ����� ����������������� � ������� � ��� �!� � ��� #"%$'&��)(Q���5�t�]�����{�F�(Q�¤���p�]� *¬�P�,+��.-G�t�{���/(0�21c�t�43¤�j�����65������D�7 � �� � � ����8 :97�F�6;t�F�F�)YeZe~JscauijzÒ�]�<-=1 �>({���?$0@%�Q�F���t�P�������F�]�F��D�F���¥��*w�t�����j���t�>A�1u�j��;��P���B$]��(6C�D-G���P�e�p�F�{� 7 �m�t���p�j�)�t�{�j��*¬� 8 .E#1 �¥�F�J���g�j��� �p�����P�]�)(Q�/1 @��¥���j�<-=1 �/(]�t�F$0@��Q�F�����P�G�¢���F�]�Q�H�D�F���¥��*w�t�j������t�I� �e���'1ª�F�J({���G�J�p�F�F�T�G�)��-G�t�P�e�p�F� 7 � ��K�� ���� �L�������M�N��� �� 8

O � ���¬µ=Pt´�¶IP�Q0���¬µSR�¶�¹ �(´�»{¶0³UT �¬µKV�»F¹ �XWZY%´K[��!\ �IQ0�XWJ´�µ=]²e³�^bµ��_WJ´}µB¸�¹º´7¸,µ��

ó,6�C]R�IG¿Qã}O­1<Ä�¿Q6t¾F6t/G¿QSb4<6�¿b¾�4</mÈJ6�NB6tÄGL71ÉCQIÛ6�í Æ ÇTIG¿Q6�;�6tS�6�1eCF¿b/ ÇTO­Et6t; Æ 6�6�¿FÅ°CFI Å Æ 6�6�¿�ÇTI�S�/ ÅCFOTIG1 ¾F6�¿QÈeOPS�6X¾ ç � ø78�è�÷<8�ètê78�è �Dë�@wö}LBSb4Ò¾{6t¿FÈ}OPS�6X¾MI ûª6�¿"/3;�OT¾{CF¿QOTN7L�CF6X;üO­17À¤¿Q/J¾]CQ¿FL<S�CFL7¿Q6�À¤IJ¿Ç­I�S�/ CFOT17Ä%IJN ]6tS�CQ¾�ìeL7OTSbã}ÇT=G8ºR�OuCQ43ÄJL</ ¿b/ 1eCF6t6t;�¾FL<S�S�6t¾Q¾�/G1<;�ÇTI}St/ ÇTOuC]=J@º:�/DCF4<6�¿�CF4</G13;�6�ÅÆ 6t1<;�OT17Ä?IJ1Â/�¾{OT17ÄJÇ­6�¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿,CQI?ÇTI�S�/ CF6)/ 1ÛIJN ]6tS�Ct8�/?ìeL76t¿F=�OT1ÛCQ47OT¾MÃ)I�;�6tÇ(OP¾ Æ /G¾Q¾F6t;/ ¿QIGL71<;3CF4<6 176�C]R�IG¿QãÛL71eCQO­Ç5OuC¢¿Q6t/JSb476t¾M/�17I�;�6 CF4</ C�ãe1<IDR,¾�CF476 ÇTI�S�/ CFOTIG1üI À�CF476%¿F6�ÅìJL<6t¾{CF6t;)IJN ]6tS�Ct@=`�L7¿0;�OP¾F¾F6�Ã)OT1</DCQO­IJ1)CF¿Q6�6,OP¾¡N<L7O­Ç­C0IJ1)CFI Æ IGÀ¬¼w/ Æ 6X¾]CQ¿F=�ç �GøDëB/G1<;�CQ/GãG6X¾/G;�ÈD/ 1eCb/ ÄG6�I À(C]R�I¢À¤6X/DCFL<¿F6X¾ á Î ä ÏpÖ�Î ß Ë�Ï�Õbá Í­ÑtØbÌ ÏpÎ¥Ñ Þ ä Õ�Ö�×XÎ¥ØbÕ ä�/ 1B;Ûä ÕbÌDÖFØ��ba�Î�Ï ��Í­ÑtØbÌ ÍcÎ�ÏpÐ @

¼w/ Æ 6X¾]CQ¿F=?OT¾,/G1�î]âÝIDÈG6t¿FÇP/m=�176�C]R�IG¿Qã�CQ4</DC�L<¾{6X¾,/�;�OP¾]CQ¿FOTN7L�CQ6t;�8<À¥/ L7Ç­C{Å°CFIJÇ­6t¿Q/G1eC�/ ¿FÅSb47OuCQ6tS�CFL7¿Q6�CFI3CF¿b/GSbã3CF476?Ç­I�S�/ CFOTIG1 IGÀgIJN ]6tS�CQ¾¢O­1 CQ476%1<6�C]R�IG¿Qãº@9îj1 IGL7¿�/ ¿bSb47OuCQ6tS�CFL7¿Q6ô¥ý(O­ÄJL7¿Q6�èmõ�8}CQ476�;}ÅpCQ¿F6t6�¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿b¾�ô¥Op@ 6G@T8º2�K�ó 6t;�ÄJ6�¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿Q¾bõ¡/G1<;%Ã"L7Ç­CFOPS�/G¾{C,¿QIeIGCg¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿ô¤O°@ 6J@­8�ÁÂ6tN ¾{IJL7¿bS�6Û¾F6�¿QÈG6�¿�õ)/ ¿Q6Û¼(/ Æ 6t¾{CF¿Q=þ17I�;�6X¾�@ �0/JSb4ÝS�Ç­OT6�1eC Cb/ ÇTã�¾�CFIÒOuCb¾ 176X/ ¿QNe=¼w/ Æ 6X¾]CQ¿F=Û1<I};76Ûô Ï �7ÕMceÌDÏjÕ�a0ÌDÐ õ�CQIÛ¾{6t1<;3IJN ]6tS�C�¿F6XìeL76t¾{CQ¾t@ªîj1 Æ ¿Q/JS�CFOPS�6J8ªCF476�Äe/DCQ6�Rg/m=17I�;�6�S�/G1?Nº6�Ç­I�St/DCF6X; CQ47¿QIGL7ÄJ4�S�6�¿FCQ/ OT1�NBI}I Cb¾]CQ¿Q/ Æ Ã)6XSb4</ 17OP¾FÃ)¾t@

d#e<f g:h=i.jJk�l�m�nporqtsul�v<wuxzy{jJk�|ýwOTÄGL<¿F6 ��¾F47IDR,¾�/ Æ IG¿FCFOTIG1)IGÀ�¼(/ Æ 6t¾{CF¿Q=G@'�5/GSb4�17I�;�6 ]IJO­1<¾5¼w/ Æ 6X¾]CQ¿F="O­1 /¢;�OT¾{CF¿QOTN7L�CF6X;À¥/G¾F47O­IJ1ÛCQ47¿FIJL7ÄG43176t/G¿FN}=�¾{L<¿F¿QIGÄe/DCF6"¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿b¾�/ 1B;3¾F6�CML Æ ÞªÕ�Î�c � ß ÑDÖ�Î�ÞJc ÇTOT17ã�¾�À¤IJ¿�S�IG17Å176tS�CFOTIG1�CQI%I CQ476�¿M¼(/ Æ 6t¾{CF¿Q=�1<I};76t¾�ç �GøDë�@B¼g476�176�OTÄG4}NºIG¿QO­1<Ä Ç­OT17ã�¾�/ ¿Q6¢¾{4<IDR�13/G¾�¾{IJÇ­OP;/ ¿Q¿FIDR,¾t@Bö}L<Sb4Â176�OTÄG4}NºIG¿QO­1<Ä Ç­OT17ã�¾ Æ ¿FIDÈ}OP;�6"/%¿FIJL�CF6¢À¤¿FIJÃ*6�ÈG6t¿F=�17I�;�6"CFI?6�ÈG6t¿F=�IGCF476t¿17I�;�6 �wCF476%¿FIJL�CFOT17Ä Æ ¿QI�S�6X¾F¾¢¿F6X¾{IJÇ­ÈJ6t¾�CF4<6?;�6X¾]CQO­1</ CFOTIG1 /J;7;�¿Q6t¾Q¾�IG176?;�O­ÄJOuC)/DC"/�CFOTÃ�6

Page 5: University of California, Berkeley...CFOPS /G¾{Ct@ ð ¾ / 1ü/ Ç CF6t¿F1

ô¤6G@ Ä<@T8������ ê :������ �Gê :���� ÿ �Gê :�� ÷eÿ �Gê78�R�4<6�¿Q6��}æ ¾�¿Q6 Æ ¿Q6t¾F6�1eC�R�OTÇT;<S�/ ¿b;7¾bõ�@(¼g47OT¾¿FIJL�CFOT17ľQSb476tÃ�6?OT¾�N</J¾{6X; IG1 CF476�4</G¾F476X;}Å�¾FL�½)í ¿FIJL�CFOT17Äɾ]CQ¿FL<S�CFL7¿Q6%IJ¿FOTÄGOT1</GÇ­ÇT= Æ ¿F6�ž{6t1JCQ6t;?N}=?â¡ÇP/Dí}CQIG1¬8�:,/ {/ ¿b/ Ã�/ 1¬8�/G1<;?:,OTSb4</�ç­è �Dë°@

d#e g:h=i.jJk�l�m�n�� v k�l�m�v� Isul�j����.q���h=l�v<qtw��Xj m��#v��2j¼w/ Æ 6X¾]CQ¿F="6�Ã Æ ÇTID=}¾�CF47OP¾0OT1�À¤¿b/G¾{CF¿QL<S�CQL7¿Q6gÀ¤IG¿0;7/ CQ/�ÇTI�S�/ CFOTIG1¬@��5/GSb4)IGN ]6tS�C¡OP¾0/J¾F¾FI�S�OP/DCQ6t;R�OuCQ4þ/ � Ì��<Õ ä Ï°Ö�ÐÉÍ­ÑtØbÌ ÏpÎ¥Ñ Þ ÖFÑtÑ Ï CQ47¿QIGL7ÄJ4Ò/3;�6�CF6t¿FÃ)OT17OT¾{CFOPS?Ã)/ Æ7Æ OT17ÄÛÀ¤L<1<S�CQO­IJ1¬@�¼g47OT¾¿FI}I C�OT¾5À¤IJ¿5ÇTI�S�/DCQO­IJ1 Æ L7¿ Æ IJ¾F6t¾5IG17ÇT= / 1<; 4</G¾�17IGCF47OT17Ä�CQI�;7I¢R�O­CF4?CF476�âL7Ç­CFOPS�/J¾]Cg¿QIeIGC¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿�ô¥¾FL<Sb4)/G¾(CF4<6�ÁÉ6�N�S�IG1eCF6t1JC¡¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿(OT1)ýwOTÄGL<¿F6MèXõ�@G¼wIM/J;�ÈG6t¿{CQOT¾F6g/ 1�IGN ]6XS�C��}8DCF4<6¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿� ,¾{CFIJ¿FOT17Ä�CF476�IJN ]6tS�C0¾{6t1<;7¾�/ Æ L<N7Ç­OP¾F4�Ã)6X¾F¾Q/ ÄJ65CQIDR�/G¿Q;�CF476,¼(/ Æ 6t¾{CF¿Q=¢ÇTI�S�/ CFOTIG1¿FI}I CgÀ¤IJ¿gCF4</ C�IGN ]6XS�CX87;�6 Æ IJ¾FOuCQO­1<Ä Í­ÑtØbÌ ÏpÎ¥Ñ Þ �<ÑDÎ�ÞBÏ�Õ�Ö ä�O­1�CF4<6MÀ¤IG¿QÃúI À���`�N ]6XS�C{Å�î]K�ô�� õ�8ö}6�¿QÈG6t¿{Å�î]K"ô9 mõ���/DC¢6X/GSb4ü47I Æ @w¼g476X¾{6 Ã�/ Æ7Æ OT17ÄJ¾�/G¿F6 ¾FOTÃ Æ Ç­= Æ IJO­1eCQ6�¿b¾�CFI�CQ476?¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿ %R�4<6�¿Q6 ��OP¾¢Nº6�OT17Äü¾]CQIG¿Q6t;�8-/ 1B; 17I C)/3S�I Æ =üI À�CF4<6?IJN ]6tS�C"O­CQ¾F6�Ç­À]@ ð 17I�;�6 ?CF4</ CãG6�6 Æ ¾�ÇTI�S�/DCQO­IJ1?Ã�/ Æ7Æ OT17ÄJ¾gÀ¤IJ¿,âL<ÇuCQO Æ ÇT6�¿Q6 Æ ÇTOPS�/G¾gãJ6�6 Æ ¾gCF4<6�Ã*¾{IJ¿{CQ6t;�O­1�CQ476�IG¿b;�6t¿�I À;�OT¾{CQ/G1<S�6�À¤¿QIGà G@

ýwOTÄGL<¿F6 ��¾F47IDR,¾�C]R5I�¿Q6 Æ ÇTOPS�/G¾�/G1<;ÂCF476 ¼(/ Æ 6t¾{CF¿Q=Û¿QI}I C�À¤IG¿�/G1üIGN ]6XS�Ct@ �¬I�S�/ CFOTIG1Æ IJO­1eCF6t¿Q¾0/ ¿Q6,¾{47IDR�1�/J¾¡;�I CFCF6X;�/ ¿Q¿FIDR,¾wCF4B/DC Æ IGOT1eC¡N</GSbã¢CFI�¿Q6 Æ ÇTOPS�/�¾F6�¿QÈG6�¿b¾t@m¼wI�ÇTI}St/DCQ6/ 1%IJN ]6tS�Ct8�/�S�ÇTO­6t1JC,¾F6�1<;<¾�/"Ã)6t¾Q¾F/GÄG6�CFIDRg/ ¿b;�CF476MIGN ]6tS�CXæ ¾�¿QI}I Ct@}Á 476t1%CQ476�Ã�6X¾F¾Q/ ÄJ66�1<S�IGL71eCF6t¿Q¾5/ Æ IGOT1eCF6�¿X8GO­Cg¿FIJL�CF6X¾0;�OT¿F6XS�CQÇ­=�CFI¢CF476�IGN ]6XS�CX@Jî�C�OT¾�¾{4<IDR�1 O­1Âçuè �më<CQ4</DC�CF4<6/mÈG6�¿b/ ÄJ6�;7OT¾{CQ/G1<S�6�CQ¿Q/mÈJ6�ÇT6t;ÂO­1 ÇTI�S�/ CFOT17ÄÛ/ 1 IJN ]6tS�C�OT¾ �ºÖFÑ��7Ñ Ö�ÏpÎ¥Ñ ÞºÌDÍ CQI�CF4<6%;�OP¾]Cb/ 1<S�6À¤¿FIJà CF4</ C)IJN ]6tS�C�OT1þCF6�¿QÃ�¾�I À,CQ476�1eL<âNº6�¿)I À�4<I Æ ¾"CF¿b/mÈG6t¿Q¾F6t;¬@9îj1Ý/G;7;�O­CFOTIG198(O­C�OT¾Æ ¿FIDÈJ6t;MCQ4</DC-À¤IJ¿-/G1}=�17I�;�64�¡CQ4</DC�¿Q6tìeL76t¾{CQ¾(IJN ]6tS�C��}8 ¼(/ Æ 6t¾{CF¿Q=�S�/G1¢¿QIGL�CQ65CQ476g¿F6XìeL76t¾{CCFIÉCF476�/J¾{=}Ã Æ CFIGCFOPS�/GÇ­ÇT= I Æ CQO­Ã�/GÇ�17I�;�6 ô¤OT1ÒCQ6�¿QÃ�¾)I À�CQ476�¾{4<IG¿FCF6t¾{C Æ /DCQ4þ176�C]R5IJ¿Fã;�OT¾{CQ/G1<S�6mõ5CF4</ C�S�IJ1JCb/ OT1<¾g/�¿F6 Æ Ç­OPS�/�IGÀ���çuè �më�@

! " » WJW �6 »F³��(´7»]¶0³ \�µ���� �3µ7¶�´�¶�¹ª¶% W

#Xe<f orj�i�$ v��2h&%'$ h(��j*) j w l?hKw+� g.m�jJj&, qZwuk�l�m�s+�Gl�v<qtwîj1)CF47OP¾0¾F6tS�CFOTIG1¬8JR56 Æ ¿F6X¾{6t1JC0/G1 / ÇTÄGIJ¿FO­CF47à CF4</ C5;�=}1</GÃ�OPS�/GÇ­ÇT= Æ ÇT/JS�6t¾0¿F6 Æ ÇTOTSt/G¾�/ 1B;)IG¿FÅÄJ/ 1<O­Et6t¾�CQ476�à OT1eCFI�/ 1¢/ Æ7Æ ÇTOTSt/DCFOTIG17Å°ÇT6�ÈJ6�ÇGÃ"L7Ç­CFOPS�/G¾{C9CQ¿F6t60R�O­CF4�IJ17ÇT=�ÇTOTÃ�O­CF6X;�ã}17IDR�ÇT6t;�ÄJ6I ÀªCF476�176�C]R�IG¿Qã�CQI Æ IGÇTIGÄJ=G@G¼g47OP¾0/GÇ­ÄJIG¿QOuCQ47Ã�/DC{CQ6�Ã Æ Cb¾�CFI�¾F/ CFOP¾ �B6t¾�NºI CQ4%S�ÇTO­6t1eC0ÇT/ CF6t1<S�=/ 1<; ¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿¢S�/ Æ /GS�OuC]=üS�IJ1<¾{CF¿b/ OT1JCb¾�@_`�L7¿�ÄGIJ/GÇ¡OP¾�CQI3Ã)O­1<O­Ã)OTE�6?CF476�1}L7âNº6�¿"I À�¿Q6 Æ ÇTO­ÅS�/G¾�;�6 Æ Ç­ID=J6t;�/ 1<;�CFI%¾F6�Ç­À�Å°IJ¿FÄe/ 17OTE�6MCQ476¢¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿Q¾�R�O­CF43¿F6 Æ Ç­OPS�/J¾�OT1JCQI?/�ÇTIJ/J;}Å�N</ ÇP/ 1<S�6t;CF¿Q6�6G@9ÁÂ6 S�IG1eCF¿b/G¾{CM¾{CQ/ CFOPS�¾{IJÇ­L7CFOTIG1<¾�CQ4</DC¢/J¾F¾FL7Ã)6)ÄGÇTIGN</GÇ�ãe1<IDR�Ç­6X;�ÄG6)I ÀgS�ÇTO­6t1eCQ¾�/G1<;CFI Æ IGÇTIGÄJ=G@

� n#w h() v�� o j i�$ v��2h-%'$ h.�2j�) jJw l ÁÉ6�S�IG1<¾FOT;76�¿,C]R�I%/GÇ­ÄJIG¿QOuCQ47Ã�¾ ÞºÌDÎ�×DÕ �ªÍ­ÌGØbÕ�ñ)Õ�Þ<Ï/ 1<; ä ñ)Ì Ö�Ï �ªÍ­ÌGØbÕ�ñ)Õ�Þ<Ï 8¡À¤IJ¿%S�IJÃ Æ / ¿QOT¾FIG19@�ÁÂ63;76t¾QS�¿QO­Nº6�CF4<6t¾F6Û/G¾ Æ ¿QI�S�6X;�L7¿Q6t¾�À¤IG¿?/176�R S�ÇTO­6t1eC Ø CFI ]IGOT1?CF476MCQ¿F6t6�IGÀ(IJN ]6tS�C Ñ 8 Æ IJ¾Q¾{OTN7ÇT=%ÄJ6�176t¿Q/ CFOT17Ä"1<6�R ¿Q6 Æ Ç­OPS�/J¾gO­1�CF4<6Æ ¿FI�S�6t¾Q¾�@<ý<IGÇTÇ­IDR�OT17Ä�CQ476�17IGCQ/ CFOTIG1<¾�O­1Âö�6tS @ ��8<CF476"ÇT/ CF6�1BS�=�S�IG1B¾]CQ¿Q/GO­1eC,I À Ø OT¾ � + /G1<;CF476�S�/ Æ /GS�O­C]="S�IG1<¾{CF¿b/ OT1eC0I À� �OP¾ $�/ @eÁÂ6�;�6 �<1<6,CF4<6,À¤IGÇTÇTIDR�O­17Ä�1<I CQ/ CFOTIG1<¾�JS�L7¿Q¿F6t1JC5Ç­Ie/G;I À $ � / ��¿F6tÃ)/GO­1<O­17Ä�S�/ Æ /GS�OuC]=�IGÀ 10,� / : $�/ Å $ � / ��IDÈJ6�¿QÇT/m=�;�OP¾]Cb/ 1<S�6"IJ1ɼ(/ Æ 6t¾{CF¿Q= ��2 43656798;:6<>=9?�/ 1<; î]âÒ;�OP¾]Cb/ 1<S�6 ��2 43;@BAg@ ð ¾ Æ 6t¿FOTI�;�OPS�/ ÇTÇT="CQ476�¿Q6�/G¿F6 �{¿Q6�À¤¿Q6t¾F4 ��Ã)6t¾Q¾Q/ ÄG6X¾

Page 6: University of California, Berkeley...CFOPS /G¾{Ct@ ð ¾ / 1ü/ Ç CF6t¿F1

� ���<�������B��� f�oGd}r�W�au`5\bYJscau`br ¯ s­r�`b\bW�\bdD[ �gr�achm\ ���tk����� ��ij\bde|Ji,r�����Vtaud���^]\��DZe\Qi�[g[]V?�¡�¡an[]zü�,[]zJ^]VXZJ§Xz�©ªrtY�\bi�[j^joDk7YJac§X§toG~ert`{xGig[]zJ\ �°¯ rt|G£| ^]\bijij\bibk������! #"%$&('*) +�,����.-/�!01�-rtde|32.�4(5�kJqTVt^5\�rt`{z)ij\Q^]hX\Q^6�!0ºVXd"[]ze\gYer�[]z

7 �98 2�� 4;:=< ��>?��@A �18 ����� ("%$/&('*) +�, 7 ��A?� 8CB ��D ��>?��@ �g~�\b`bVXW�\QiE��F i0Yer�^]\bdD[�k �HG � � �

��IT�!�J ��YJacde§XiK��[]V�§X\Q[E����� ML%NO�P�XkQ�!�R �18 ���#� L/N 7 ibk}` 8SB � D ��>?��@ �g~�\b`bVtW�\biT�.F i0Y}r�^]\Qd [�k �HG � � �

��@?���@��UWV ^]VXW []zJ\�`bscVXij\bi�[5VXdJ\�[]V;�tk 8 �e��� �e�.> �Q�F�6;t�F�X� 0 ���%�,+J�%-G�t�,+ �?�

ij\�r�^]`{z�qPV�^6 w[]z}r�[¡i]r�[]aci�«}\biE2��!Y : � �Q@�� ����� ("%$&('*) +�,��Z /-M��� B ��D��@��

[ �gYJZJ[]i¡r�^]\bYJscau`brMVXd\ �rtd}|¢~�\b`bVtW�\bi¡ac[]i¡Yer�^]\bdD[�kH �~�\b`bVtW�\biT�.F i0Y}r�^]\bdD[] (YeZJ~escacijze\biK��aud)©ªrtY�\bi�[j^joDk �HG � � �^ 8 �}�_� �}��> -G�t�,+)�b�F�6;t�F�`��a * +J�t�Q�E2�� 4 -b:c< �d� �_a¬YeacdJ§XiK��[]VM§t\Q[E���#� (L/Ne�P��a�kQ�!���f �5`FzJVDVXij\biK -�¡zJau`{z�zerti�[]ze\�ijW�r�scsu\Qi�[6����� ML%Ne�Z -#��� B ��D��� _GrtW�\�rti0i�[]\bYei � r�d}| � �

g $<xtqtm�v/l�|+) f?h K�=}1</ Ã)OPS�:�6 Æ Ç­OPS�/)â¡ÇP/GS�6�Ã)6�1eC�ô¥ó�/ OTÈG6mõ

ÄGIGOT17Ä�À¤¿FIJÃà/�Sb4<O­ÇP;¢¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿9CQI�O­CQ¾ Æ /G¿F6t1eCwÀ¤IJ¿(¾FI À�C¡¾{CQ/DCQ65Ã�/G1</ ÄJ6�Ã)6�1eCt8mR�6�/J¾F¾FL7Ã)65CF4</ C6t/GSb4 Æ /G¿F6t1JC,¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿5ã}17IDR,¾�CQ476�S�L7¿Q¿Q6�1eC�¿F6tÃ)/GO­1<O­17Ä)S�/ Æ /GS�OuC]=%I Àw6X/GSb4�Sb47OTÇT;�¾F6�¿QÈG6�¿X@i hKv��Zj i+$<h(�2j�) jJw l ¡25ÇTO­6t1JC �%¾F6�1B;7¾�CQ476�¿F6XìeL76t¾{C¢À¤IJ¿"IJN ]6tS�C ��CQ47¿QIGL7ÄJ4Ò¼w/ Æ 6X¾]CQ¿F=/ 1<;ÂOT¾M¿QIGL7CF6t;ÛCFI�¾F6�¿QÈG6�¿0 J@¬ý7IJ¿�CQ476)1</ OTÈG6)/ Æ<Æ ¿FIe/GSb4¬8wä�IJ17Ç­=ÂS�IG1B¾{OP;�6�¿b¾�OuCb¾{6tÇuÀ�CFI�Nº6�Dæ ¾ Æ / ¿Q6�1eC)¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿t8-O°@ 6J@­8�R�4<6�CF4<6�¿ 0 � / �úøü/ 1<; ��2 43;@BA�ôB �j ��õ C � + / ¿Q6�¾F/ CFOP¾ �<6X;�@�î�ÀL71<¾Q/DCFOP¾ �<6t;�8(O­C"R�OTÇ­Ç5CF¿Q=3CQI Æ ÇP/GS�6%/�¿Q6 Æ ÇTOPS�/�IJ1üCF476?IDÈG6�¿QÇP/m= Æ /DCQ4Ò¾F6�¿QÈG6�¿�CF4</ C"OP¾"/J¾Ø�Í­Ñ ä Õ CFI ��/G¾ Æ IJ¾Q¾{OTN7ÇT6�ô¥¾F6�6 ð ÇTÄGIJ¿FO­CF4<à èXõ�@7ó,I CQ6MCF4</ C,ÄGOTÈG6t1 CF4<6�Ç­OTÃ)OuCQ6t;�¾F6t/ ¿bSb4¬8eCF4<61</ OTÈG6¢/ Æ7Æ ¿QIJ/JSb4�Ã�/m=�17IGC�/ ÇTRg/m=}¾ �<1<;�CQ476"¾FL7O­CQ/ N<Ç­6 Æ / ¿Q6�1eC�¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿�À¤IG¿�6�ÈJ6�¿Q=�S�Ç­OT6�1eCt86�ÈG6t1?R�4<6�1�¾{LBSb4�/ Æ /G¿F6t1JC�6�í}OP¾{CQ¾t@��) hKm�l i+$<h(�2j�) jJw l �5¾F¾F6�1eCQOT/GÇ­ÇT=G8eCF4<6M¾FÃ�/ ¿FCg/ Æ7Æ ¿QIJ/JSb43ô ð Ç­ÄJIG¿QOuCQ47à �Gõ�/ C{CF6tÃ Æ CQ¾�CQII Æ CQO­Ã)OTE�6�CF476 �{Nº6t¾{C � Æ /G¿F6t1JC�¾F6�ÇT6tS�CQO­IJ1 À¤IJ¿ ��O­1�/"ÇT/G¿FÄJ6�¿5¾F6�C�O­1BS�ÇTL<;�OT17Ä G8}O­CQ¾ �<ÌDÖFÕ�Þ<Ï �ä Î ß ÍcÎ�ÞJc ä5/G1<; O­CQ¾ Ñ Ï �<Õ�Ö ä Õ�Ö�×DÕ�Ö�Ø��}Î�ÍTáDÖFÕ�Þ @ ð Ã�IJ17Ä)ìJLB/ ÇTO �<6X;%St/ 1<;�OP;7/ CF6t¾t8 ��Sb47I}IJ¾F6t¾0CF4<6IG176)R�O­CF4ÉCF476)ÇTO­ÄJ4eCF6t¾{C�Ç­Ie/G;É/G¾ Æ /G¿F6t1JCX@�î�À517IJ176)I À5CF476tÃ�Ã)6�6�C�CF476�S�ÇTOT6�1eCtæ ¾MÇT/ CF6t1<S�=/ 1<;ü¾F6�¿QÈG6�¿Xæ ¾�ÇTIJ/J;üS�IG1B¾]CQ¿Q/GO­1eCQ¾t8� �R�OTÇTÇ¡CF¿Q=ÛCQI Æ ÇP/GS�6�/�¿Q6 Æ ÇTOPS�/�IG1ÉCQ476�IDÈG6t¿FÇP/m= Æ /DCQ4¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿¡CQ4</DC�OT¾�/G¾ Ó�ÌDÖ À¤¿FIJà ��/G¾ Æ Ie¾F¾FO­N<Ç­6J@JÁÉ6�St/ ÇTÇBO­C Í­Ì.k�Ð �ºÍ­ÌJØQÕ�ñ�Õ�ÞBÏ @ ð ÇTǺCF476X¾{6�¾]CQ6 Æ ¾/ OTÃ�CFIÛ;�OP¾{CF¿QO­N7L7CF6)CF4<6�Ç­Ie/G;ÛR�O­CF4üCQ476)ÄG¿Q6�6X;�=3/ ÇTÄGIJ¿FO­CF4<Ã*CFI�¿Q6t;�L<S�6�CF476�1}L7Ã"NB6t¿�I À¿F6 Æ Ç­OPS�/J¾g176�6X;�6t;?R�47OTÇ­6�¾Q/DCQOT¾{À¤=}O­1<Ä"CQ476�S�IJ1<¾{CF¿b/ OT1JCb¾�@

ó,I CQ6¡CQ4</DC-R560CF¿Q=�CFI�LB¾{60CF476�IDÈG6t¿FÇP/m=�ÇP/DCQ6�1<S�=�CQI�6X¾]CQO­Ã�/DCQ60CQ476�î]âÛÇP/DCF6t1<S�=MOT1�IG¿b;�6t¿CFI%¾Q/mÈG6 � Æ O­1<Ä �)Ã)6t¾Q¾F/GÄG6X¾�@<>�6�¿Q6�CF4<6"S�ÇTOT6�1eC�S�/G1Û¾]Cb/ ¿FC�/ ;7/G6�Ã)IG1 Æ ¿FIJÄG¿b/ Ã Æ ¿QIDÈ}OT;76t;Ne=%OuCb¾�2�K�ó ¾F6�¿QÈ}OTS�6 Æ ¿FIDÈ}OP;�6�¿gR�476t1�ÇT/GL71<Sb47OT17Ä"CF476�N7¿QIDR,¾F6�¿�¾{I�CQ4</DC,O­C�S�/G1�/JS�CFOTÈG6tÇ­=Æ / ¿FCFOPS�O Æ /DCQ6�O­1)CQ476 Æ ¿QI CQI�S�IGÇP¾t@ ¼g476�Ç­I�St/ ÇTOuC]= Æ ¿FI Æ 6t¿{C]=¢I À¬¼w/ Æ 6X¾]CQ¿F="1</DCQL7¿b/ ÇTÇ­=�ÇT6t/J;7¾-CQICF476�Ç­I�St/ ÇTOuC]=)I À9;�ÅpCQ¿F6t6G8}Op@ 6G@T8JCF476 Æ / ¿Q6�1eCg/ 1<;?Sb47O­ÇP;�¿Q6�1�CQ6�1<; CFI"NB6�S�ÇTIJ¾F6�CQI"6X/GSb4 IGCF476t¿O­1?CF6t¿FÃ�¾�I À¬CQ476M1}L7âNº6�¿gI À(î]âÒ4<I Æ ¾�Nº6�C]R�6�6�1%CF476tÃ�@7¼g47OT¾ Æ ¿FIDÈ}OP;�6t¾5ÄGI}I�;%;�6tÇT/m=�/G1<;âL7Ç­CFOPS�/J¾]C,N</G1<;�R�OP;}CF4�S�IG1<¾FL7Ã Æ CFOTIG1�R�476t1�;7OT¾Q¾{6tÃ)O­1</ CFOT17Ä)L Æ ;7/DCQ6t¾t8</G¾gÃ)6t/J¾{L<¿F6X;%OT1

Page 7: University of California, Berkeley...CFOPS /G¾{Ct@ ð ¾ / 1ü/ Ç CF6t¿F1

� ���<�������B��� f�oGd}r�W�au`5\bYJscau`br ¯ s­r�`b\bW�\bdD[ _GW�r�^j[_���tk����� (-ij\Qd}|Ji0r ����Vtaud��M^]\��DZe\bi�[¡[]V��¬�¡an[]z���[]zG^]VXZe§tz�©ªr�Y�\bi�[j^jo7 �wij\bde|Ji�(F i �°¯ rt|e| ^]\biji�[]VMan[]i0Yer�^]\bdD[%-�r�d}|�V�[]ze\Q^¡ij\Q^]hX\Q^0`FzJausu| ^]\bd�� ( �18 2�� 4 D : �A -�qPVt^j�-r�^{|Gi5[]ze\5^]\��DZe\bi�[�[]V��*F i0ijau~JscaudJ§Xi,�]� �18 2.� 4(4C: �J �Xk � k �_�,r�d}|3����ij\bd}|r(¡an[]iK2�� �18 an[]iK2�� : �R �98 (:�D�F�����t� @��j�<-=1 @ ��>?��@U (-`FzJVDVXij\bi�[]ze\5Y}r�^]\bdD[e w�¡zJac`Fz"z}rti-[]zJ\�~Jau§t§X\bi�[E2���r�d}| ���#� (L/NO�Z /-M��� B ��D�k �HG � � ���IP�!�

[ (wij\bde|Ji-r,W�\biji]r�§X\¡[]V¢�ª[]zG^]VXZJ§Xz¢©ªrtY�\Qi�[j^jo�rt§Xrtacd�r�d}|M[]ze\¡W�\biji]r�§X\5Yeac§X§�oJ~ert`{x i[]ze\ �°¯ rX|J|G^]\bijij\Qibk ����� ("%$&('*) +�,�����-%� 0 ��rtde|\2��!4(5�qPV�^�\brt`{z)ij\Q^]hm\Q^6� 0 VXd�[]zJ\gY}r�[]z

] V ^]VXW []zJ\g`bscVXij\bi�[5VXdJ\g[]V �Xk 8 �}�_� �}��> �Q�F� ;t�F� � 0 �t� �,+e�.-G���,+ �d�ij\�r�^]`{z�qPV�^K -[]z}r�[¡i]r�[]aci�«}\biE2�� Y : � �Q@�� ����� ("%$&('*) +�,��Z /-(��� B � D

��@?�^ _JrtW�\grti¡i�[]\bYei � k � r�d}| � aud � �_�<�������º�_� f�oGdertW�ac`!0\bYescac`�r ¯ surt`b\QW�\bdD[ ��rtachm\X���f �g`FzJVDVXij\biK (�¡zJac`Fz)zerti�[]ze\�~eac§X§t\bi�[`����� L%N �Z -#��� B � D��� _JrtW�\grti¡i�[]\bY�����acd � �_�<�������º�_� f�oGdertW�ac`!0\bYescac`�r ¯ surt`b\QW�\bdD[ ��rtachm\X�

��@��g $<xtqtm�v/l�| ) h K�=}1</GÃ)OTS�:�6 Æ ÇTOTSt/�â0ÇT/JS�6tÃ�6t1eC�ô°ö}Ã�/ ¿FCbõ

ö}6tSG@ºÿ�@º¼g476�CQ¿Q/J;�6�IGû3Nº6�C]R�6�6�1�CQ476"¾FÃ�/ ¿FC�/ 1B;�1</ OTÈG6�/ Æ7Æ ¿QIJ/GSb4<6t¾gOP¾�CF4B/DC�CQ476"¾FÃ�/ ¿FCIG176�S�IJ1<¾FL7Ã)6t¾(Ã)IG¿Q6 ��]IGOT1 ��CF¿b/D½ S5CFI�S�IJ1<¾]CQ¿FLBS�C¡/�CF¿Q6�6gR�OuCQ4¢À¤6tR56t¿�¿F6 Æ ÇTOTSt/G¾t8mS�IDÈG6t¿FOT17ÄÃ�IJ¿F6gS�ÇTOT6�1eCQ¾t8DR�OuCQ4)Ç­6X¾F¾-;�6tÇT/m=�/G1<;¢Ã"L7Ç­CFOPS�/G¾{C�N</ 1B;�R�OT;�CF4)S�IG1B¾{L7Ã Æ CQO­IJ1¬@DÁÉ6�6tÈD/ ÇTL</DCQ6CF47OP¾gCF¿b/G;76�I ûÛOT1Ûö}6tSG@<ÿ�@

� l�h=l�v�� o j i�$ v���h %'$ h(��j�) jJw l ¼g476 ¿Q6 Æ ÇTOTSt/ Æ ÇP/GS�6tÃ)6�1eC�Ã)6�CF4<I};<¾�ÄGOTÈG6t1 / NºIDÈG6�/ ¿Q6L717ÇTO­ãJ6�ÇT=�CFI�NB6MI Æ CFOTÃ�/ Ç�OT1%CQ6�¿QÃ)¾gIGÀ¬CF4<6�1eL<âNº6�¿gI À(¿F6 Æ Ç­OPS�/J¾g;�6 Æ ÇTID=G6X;�8�¾{OT1<S�6�S�Ç­OT6�1eCQ¾/ ¿Q6¢/G;7;76t;�¾F6tìeL76�1eCQOT/GÇ­ÇT=�/G1<;�R�O­CF4ÛÇTOTÃ�O­CF6X;Ûã}17IDR�ÇT6t;�ÄJ6�I À�CQ476¢176�C]R5IJ¿Fã%CFI Æ IJÇ­IJÄG=G@Bîj1CF476�¾{CQ/DCQOTS�/ Æ<Æ ¿FIe/GSb4¬8GCF476�¿QIeIGCg¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿04</J¾gS�IGÃ Æ ÇT6�CQ6�ã}17IDR�ÇT6t;7ÄG6�IGÀ¬CF4<6�176�C]R5IJ¿Fã�/G1<;Æ ÇT/JS�6X¾)¿F6 Æ Ç­OPS�/J¾ Ì]ÓbÏjÕ�Ö ÄG6�C{CFOT17Äü/ ÇTÇgCF476�¿Q6tìeL76X¾]Cb¾"À¤¿FIJÃ�CF476ÛS�Ç­OT6�1eCb¾�@�îj1þCF47OP¾�¾QSb476�Ã)6G8L Æ ;</DCF6X¾ / ¿Q6�;�OP¾F¾F6�Ã)OT1</DCQ6t;þCF47¿QIGL<ÄG4ïî]â�âL7Ç­CFOPS�/J¾]CX@5öeCQ/ CFOPS Æ ÇP/GS�6tÃ)6�1eC�OT¾�1<I C ÈG6t¿F=¿F6X/ ÇTOT¾{CFOPS 8}N7L�C,Ã�/m= Æ ¿QIDÈ}OT;76�Nº6�CFCF6�¿ Æ 6t¿{À¤IJ¿FÃ�/ 1BS�6M¾{OT1<S�6MO­C�6�í Æ ÇTIGO­CQ¾gã}17IDR�ÇT6t;�ÄJ6�IGÀ9CF4<6S�ÇTO­6t1JC�;7OT¾{CF¿QO­N<L�CFOTIG1�/ 1<;�ÄJÇ­IJN</ Ǫ176�C]R5IJ¿Fã�CQI Æ IGÇTIGÄJ=G@

¼g476 Æ ¿QIGN<Ç­6tà À¤IJ¿FÃ"L7ÇP/DCF6X;�OT1Âö}6tSG@ � S�/G1ÛNº6�S�IG1}ÈG6t¿{CQ6t;?CFI�/%¾ Æ 6XS�OP/ Ç-S�/J¾{6�IGÀ¡CF4<6S�/ Æ /GS�O­CQ/ CF6X;%À¥/JS�OTÇ­O­C]=�Ç­I�St/DCFOTIG1 Æ ¿QIGN<Ç­6tÃ$çnùXë-;�6 �<1<6t;Û/J¾gÀ¤IGÇTÇ­IDR,¾t@#��OTÈG6t1Û/�¾{6�C�IGÀ-ÇTI�S�/ ÅCFOTIG1<¾ Î /DC¢R�47OPSb4üÀ¥/GS�O­ÇTO­CFOT6t¾�Ã�/m=ÂNB6?N7L7OTÇuCX8wN7L<O­ÇP;�OT17Ä3/�À¥/JS�OTÇ­O­C]=É/ C¢ÇTI}St/DCQO­IJ1 Î OT1<S�L7¿Q¾/�S�IJ¾{C�I À�H � @6�0/JSb4ÉS�Ç­OT6�1eC��MâLB¾]C�Nº6%/G¾Q¾FO­ÄJ176t;3CFI�IJ176)À¥/GS�O­ÇTOuC]=J8¬OT1<S�L7¿Q¿QO­17Ä�/�S�IJ¾{C�I À� " ��� ""R�476t¿F6 � ");�6�17IGCF6X¾�CQ476);�6�Ã�/ 1B;�I À¡CQ476�17I�;�6���8¬/G1<; ��� "�;�6t17I CQ6t¾�CF476);�OP¾]Cb/ 1<S�6NB6�C]R56t6�1 Î / 1<;���@6�5/GSb4ÂÀ¥/GS�O­ÇTOuC]=ÉS�/G1ü¾F6�¿QÈG6)/DC"Ã�Ie¾]C $ ��S�Ç­OT6�1eCb¾�@9¼g4<6 IGN ]6XS�CQO­ÈJ6�OP¾MCQI�<1<;�CF4<6,1}L7âNº6�¿¡IGÀªÀ¥/GS�OTÇTOuCQO­6X¾¡/ 1<;�CQ476�OT¿¡ÇTI�S�/DCQO­IJ1<¾�=}OT6�ÇP;�O­1<ÄMCF476,Ã)OT17OTâL7Ã�CFIGCQ/ ÇBS�IJ¾{Ct@

¼9IÂÃ)/ Æ CQ476�À¥/GS�OTÇTOuC]= ÇTI�S�/DCQO­IJ1 Æ ¿QIGN<Ç­6tà CQIÂIJL7¿b¾�8(R56�¾F6�C H �M/ ÇTR�/m=�¾ èJ8�/ 1<;þ¾{6�C��� "�ø�OuÀ�Ç­I�S�/ CFOTIG1 2 S�/G1ÒS�IDÈJ6�¿¢S�Ç­OT6�1eC�3IJ¿� I CQ476�¿QR�OP¾{6J@w¼g476?NB6X¾]C�/ Æ7Æ ¿FImí�OTÃ)/ CFOTIG1/ ÇTÄGIG¿QO­CF47à ã}17IDR�1%CFI�;7/m=�L<¾F6t¾�CQ476 Æ ¿FOTÃ�/ Ç­Å�;7L</ Ç�¾QSb476�Ã�/�/ 1<; �9/ ÄJ¿Q/G17ÄGOP/ 1%¿F6tÇT/ í�/ CFOTIG1CFI�/JSb47O­6tÈG60/,ÄGL</G¿Q/G1JCQ6�6X;�À¥/JS�CQIG¿9IGÀ�÷¢ç ùmë°@m>,IDR�6�ÈJ6�¿X8bCF47OP¾(/ ÇTÄGIG¿QO­CF47à OT¾¬CFI}I�S�IGÃ Æ ÇTOTSt/DCF6X;À¤IG¿ Æ ¿b/GS�CFOPS�/GÇ�L<¾{6J@Gîj1<¾{CF6X/G;�8GR56,;�6X¾{OTÄG1<6t;)/MÄG¿Q6�6X;�=¢/ ÇTÄGIJ¿FO­CF4<ÃàCF4B/DC¡4</J¾¡/MÇ­IJÄJ/G¿FO­CF47Ã)OPS/ Æ7Æ ¿QImí�O­Ã�/ CFOTIG1%¿b/DCQO­IB@

Page 8: University of California, Berkeley...CFOPS /G¾{Ct@ ð ¾ / 1ü/ Ç CF6t¿F1

56X¾{OP;�6X¾�CF476 Æ ¿F6tÈeOTIGLB¾g17I Cb/DCFOTIG1B¾�8�R�6�;�6 �B176MCF476�À¤IGÇTÇ­IDR�OT17Ä)ÈD/ ¿QOT/GN7Ç­6X¾ 7¾F6�C,IGÀ-S�IDÈeÅ6�¿Q6t;ÉS�ÇTO­6t1JCb¾�Ne=8 �D / 8�D /�� D / 1<; =G� /�D / 8 ��2 43;@ A�ôB�D8� mõ C � + �¬¾F6�C�IGÀ Æ IJ¾Q¾{OTN7ÇT6¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿ Æ / ¿Q6�1eCb¾0À¤IJ¿,S�ÇTO­6t1eC����& + 8 & + � &þ/ 1<; =A >/G& + 8 ��2 43;@BA�ô �D8# XõC � + @

� ���<�������B��� 5\QYescac`�r ¯ surt`b\bW�\Qd [ �5^]\b\�| o fgaci�[��BVXrX|Jv-rtsurtdJ`bacde§�����k�� �� @ � �º� ®�_ \Q[¡Vtq¬`Qsuac\bdD[]i�[]VM~�\g`QV�hX\Q^]\�|<®��kG[]Vt[{rtsBij\Q[0Vtq�ij\F^]hm\Q^]ib®�� �º� � �º� ®�_ \Q[¡Vtq¬ij\F^]hm\Q^]i¡`FzJVXij\bd"qPVt^¡^]\bYJscau`brMYesurt`b\QW�\bdD[�®��0 > � I1� EÂ�T�g���t���F�:-}�>@ �d�

U(zeVDVXij\`��� ���¡zeac`Fz�z}rti�[]zJ\�s­r�^]§X\bi�[(hXr�scZe\�Vtq7W�acdd��`�r�^{|Gaudertscan[°o�� � 4 � kX^]\bW�r�acdeacde§`�rtYert`ban[°o\2�� 4 �� 0�� � 0�� y ���� � ��£ y ����18 � � 4 � B 2�� 4 ��>?��@ � � �Ý£�� 4��IT�!�

_GVt^j[¡\brt`{z)\bsc\bW�\bdD[K����� 4 acd)acde`F^]\�rtijacde§�V�^{|J\Q^0V�q�� � D �U(zeVDVXij\�[]zJ\�«e^]i�[K2�� 4 `Qsuac\bdD[]i0acd � 4 r�i�� 4���� " 4 &��� � �þ£�� 4���� " 4 &��

��@?�^]\b`bVXW�YJZJ[]\ � D¡qPVt^�! �"�#�

��@��^]\F[]ZJ^]d ��0¤�

g $<xtqtm�v/l�| )Ud h öeCQ/ CFOPSM:�6 Æ ÇTOPS�/�â¡ÇP/GS�6�Ã)6�1eC�R�O­CF4�K�OP¾{CF¿QO­N7L7CF6t; �9IJ/G; g/ ÇP/ 1<S�O­1<Ä

ÁÂ6�S�IG1B¾{OP;�6�¿"C]R�IÛC]= Æ 6X¾¢IGÀ�¾{CQ/DCQOTS%¿F6 Æ ÇTOTSt/ Æ ÇP/GS�6�Ã)6�1eC�(R�O­CF4ÒIJ17ÇT=ÉIDÈJ6�¿QÇT/m= Æ /DCQ4CFI Æ IGÇTIGÄJ=?È�¾t@<R�O­CF4ÂÄGÇTIGN</GÇ9î]âÝCQI Æ IGÇTIGÄG=J@Bý<IG¿�CF476¢À¤IG¿QÃ�6t¿t8<CFI?6t/GSb4ÛS�Ç­OT6�1eC Ø 8BCF476�¿QIeIGCIG17ÇT=¢ã}17IDR,¾(CQ476�¾F6�¿QÈG6�¿b¾(IG1�CF4<6,¼w/ Æ 6X¾]CQ¿F= Æ /DCQ4"À¤¿QIGÃ Ø CQI�¿FI}I C�R�47OPSb4 S�/G1�S�IDÈG6t¿-CF4</ CS�ÇTO­6t1JC¢ô¥O­1�î]â ;7OT¾{CQ/G1<S�6mõ�@Z`�1�CF4<6�I CF4<6�¿,4</G1<;�8�CQ476�ÇP/DCFCF6�¿,/J¾F¾FL7Ã)6t¾�CF476�ã}17IDR�ÇT6t;�ÄJ6MI ÀÄGÇTIGN</GǺî]âïCQI Æ IGÇTIGÄJ= / 1<;?ÄGOTÈG6X¾�S�ÇTIJ¾F6�Å°CFI Å�I Æ CFOTÃ)/GÇBNºIGL<1<;�IG1�CF476�1}L7Ã"NB6t¿�I À-¿F6 Æ ÇTOTSt/G¾t@

#Xe �Xq�$ l � l�h=l�j g.m�jJjby{h v w l�jJw hKw+�2j¼g476�Ç­OTÈG6t176t¾Q¾-I ÀºCF4<6gCF¿Q6�6�OP¾-Ã)/GO­1eCb/ OT176t;�L<¾FO­1<Ä�/�¾FI À�CFÅ�¾{CQ/ CF6gÃ)6tSb4</G17OP¾{Ã�@Gâ-6t¿FOTI�;�OTSt/ ÇTÇ­=J8R56�¾F6�1<; �{476X/ ¿FCFNº6t/DC��¢Ã)6X¾F¾Q/ ÄJ6t¾0À¤¿FIJÃ�CF476�¿QI}I C�;�IDR�1 CQI�6X/GSb4?Ã�6tâNº6�¿X@}ÁÂ6�/J¾F¾FL7Ã)6CF4</ C�/GǭǪCQ476M17I�;�6t¾g/G¿F6�Ç­I}Ie¾{6tÇ­= ¾F=}1<Sb47¿QIG17OTE�6X;)CF47¿QIGL<ÄG4 CQ476�ó,6�C]R5IJ¿Fã ¼gOTÃ)6Mâ0¿FIGCFI�S�IJÇô¥ó�¼�â�õ�ç � ë°@5¼g4eLB¾)OuÀ�/ 1}= Ã)6�Ã"NB6t¿3ô¤6�í7S�6 Æ C�CF476�¿QI}I Cbõ"ÄJ6�CQ¾�CF476�Ã)6t¾Q¾Q/ ÄG6�R�O­CF47OT1 /S�6�¿FCQ/GO­1?CF4<¿F6X¾{47IJÇT;¬87OuC,R�OTÇTǬã}17IDR CQ4</DC,O­C,OP¾,¾]CQO­ÇTÇ9/GÇ­OTÈG6�IJ1%CQ476�CF¿Q6�6J@t`�CF476t¿FR�OP¾F6�O­C�R�OTÇ­ÇCFOTÃ�6MIJL�Cg/G1<;%¾{CQ/G¿{Cg¿Q6 ]IGOT17OT17Ä"CF476�CF¿Q6�6J@}òÛ6t/ 1}R�47OTÇT6G8}6t/JSb4%Ã)6�Ã"NB6t¿�R�OTÇTÇ Æ 6t¿FOTI�;�OTSt/ ÇTÇ­=¾{6t1<;MIGL�C(/ �{¿Q6�À¤¿Q6t¾F4 ��Ã)6t¾Q¾F/GÄG6-CFI�OuCb¾ Æ /G¿F6t1JCX@�î�À�CF4<6 Æ / ¿Q6�1eCw;7Ie6X¾�17IGCwÄG6�C�CF476�{¿Q6�À¤¿Q6t¾F4 �Ã�6X¾F¾Q/ ÄJ6�R�O­CF4<O­1Û/)S�6t¿{Cb/ OT1%CQ47¿Q6t¾F47IGÇP;�8�O­C,R�O­ÇTǬã}OTSbã%IGL�CgCF4<6�Sb47O­ÇP;�æ ¾�6�1eCQ¿F=J@

% & V � F¸��(´7»]¶0³

îj1üCF47OP¾¢¾F6tS�CFOTIG1¬8wR56�6tÈm/GÇ­LB/DCF6)CQ476 Æ 6�¿FÀ¤IG¿QÃ�/ 1<S�6)I À�IGL7¿";}ÅpCQ¿F6t6 / ÇTÄGIJ¿FO­CF47Ã�¾t@¬ÁÉ6 L<¾F6CF476!�M¼�Å�î]¼�ò CQ¿Q/G1<¾FOuCFÅ�¾{CFL7N�Ã)I�;�6�Ç�CQI)ÄG6�1<6�¿b/DCF6 �<ÈJ6�ÿ øGøJøDÅ�17I�;�6,CQI Æ IGÇTIGÄJO­6X¾�ç­è � ë°@7¼g4<6

Page 9: University of California, Berkeley...CFOPS /G¾{Ct@ ð ¾ / 1ü/ Ç CF6t¿F1

����� ���<� �:� � ${�F�����%�]�<-J1 �/(]�t�?�D�<-=1c��@m�j� 7 �¥� - 8 �t��� 1c���m�ü�t�P�]���{�/$0� ���¤�t�Ý�t�ï�Q�01u�)(Q�p�j�É�b�F�6;t�F�{�7 $]�t���¥�t� 8 7�� < < ��D¥���j�{���Q�F�6;t�F�F� 8

¿F6X¾{L7Ç­CQ¾g/G¿F6M/mÈG6t¿Q/GÄG6t;)IDÈJ6�¿5CF476�6�í Æ 6t¿FOTÃ)6�1eCQ¾�IG1?CF4<6 �BÈG6�CFI Æ IGÇTIGÄJO­6X¾�@ ð Æ /JSbãG6�CFÅ°ÇT6�ÈJ6�Ç°8Æ ¿FOTIG¿QO­C]=JÅjìeL76�L<6ÛN</G¾F6t; 6�ÈG6t1eC�Ã�/ 1B/ ÄG6t¿%OP¾�O­Ã Æ ÇT6�Ã)6�1eCQ6t; CQIï¾FOTâL7ÇP/DCQ6ÛCF4<6Â176�C]R5IJ¿FãÇT/ CF6�1BS�=G@

ÁÂ6ÛL7CFOTÇ­OTE�63C]R5I ¾{CF¿b/DCQ6�ÄGOT6t¾�À¤IG¿ Æ ÇP/GS�O­1<ÄÒ;}Å°CF¿Q6�6Û¾F6�¿QÈG6�¿b¾t@ `�1763¾F6�ÇT6tS�Cb¾%/GÇ­Ç�;}ÅpCQ¿F6t6¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿b¾�/ CÛ¿Q/G1<;�IJà ô¤ÇP/ Nº6�ÇT6t; ÖFÌ ÞºáGÑ ñ á��jÏpÖFÕbÕ õ�@�¼g4<6 I CF4<6�¿ Æ ¿Q6�À¤6t¿F6t1eCFOP/ ÇTÇ­= Sb47I}Ie¾{6X¾CF¿b/ 1<¾FOuC�/G1<;�ÄJ/ CF6�Rg/m= 17I�;�6X¾�ô¤ÇP/ Nº6�ÇT6t; ß ÌJØ�� ß ÑDÞºÕ)á��jÏpÖFÕbÕ õ�@º¼g47OT¾�/ Æ7Æ ¿QIJ/JSb4?Ã)OTÃ)OTSt¾�CF4<6¾]CQ¿Q/ CF6�ÄJ=�I À Æ ÇP/GS�OT17Ä�;}Å°CF¿Q6�6�¾F6�¿QÈG6�¿b¾�¾]CQ¿Q/ CF6�ÄJOTSt/ ÇTÇ­=�OT1�CF476�1<6�C]R�IG¿Qãº@

ÁÂ6�S�IJL Æ ÇT6)CF476�¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿ Æ ÇT/JS�6�Ã)6t1JC�R�O­CF4ÉÀ¤IGL<¿�;�Ouûª6�¿Q6�1eC�¿Q6 Æ ÇTOPS�/ Æ ÇT/JS�6tÃ�6t1eC�CQ6tSb4�Å17OTìeL76X¾ �IDÈG6t¿FÇP/m= ;�=}1</ Ã)OPSü1</ OTÈG6 Æ ÇT/JS�6�Ã)6t1JCïô ÑXá ÞªÌDÎ�×DÕ õ�8�IDÈJ6�¿QÇT/m= ;�=}1</GÃ)OTS ¾FÃ�/ ¿FCÆ ÇT/JS�6tÃ�6t1eC�ô Ñtá ä ñ�ÌDÖ�Ï õ�8DIDÈG6t¿FÇP/m=�¾]Cb/DCQOTS Æ ÇP/GS�6�Ã)6�1eC,ô Ñ ×mÕ�Ö�Í­ÌDÐ ä{õ�8G/G1<;"¾{CQ/ CFOPS Æ ÇT/JS�6tÃ�6t1eCIG1)î]âÉ176�C]R�IG¿Qã%ô��� ä{õ�@}ÿ øJø�17I�;�6X¾¡/ ¿Q6�Sb47IJ¾F6�1"CFI�Nº6�;}Å°CF¿Q6�6�¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿Q¾(R�O­CF4�6�O­CF4<6�¿ �F¿Q/G1�Å;�IGà �"IG¿ �{N</JSbã}NBIJ176 �"/ Æ7Æ ¿QIJ/JSb4¬@J¼g4<6�¿Q6t¾{CgI Àw1<I};76t¾g/ ¿Q6�S�Ç­OT6�1eCb¾�/G1<; ]IGOT1%CQ476�;}ÅpCQ¿F6t6O­1�/�¿Q/G1<;�IJà IG¿b;�6�¿X@}ÁÂ6�¿b/ 1B;�IGÃ)ÇT=%Sb47I}IJ¾F6�IJ176M17IG17ÅpCQ¿Q/G1<¾{O­C,;}Å°CF¿Q6�6�¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿�CFI�Nº6MCF4<6âL7Ç­CFOPS�/J¾]C�¾FIGL<¿QS�6M/G1<;�¾{6�C�/G¾�ÿ øGA CF476¢¾FOTE�6�I À¡;7/ CQ/�CQI NB6¢¿F6 Æ Ç­OPS�/ CF6X;�@<ý7L<¿{CQ476�¿X87R�6/G¾Q¾{L7Ã)65CF476�ÇP/DCF6t1<S�=�S�IG1<¾{CF¿b/ OT1eCwOP¾�ÿ ø Ã�¾(/ 1<;�CF476gÇTIJ/J;�S�/ Æ /GS�OuC]=�OP¾ � øGø�S�ÇTO­6t1JCb¾ � ¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿X@

îj1%CQ476MÀ¤IGÇTÇ­IDR�OT17ÄB8�R56�S�IJ1<¾FOT;�6t¿gCF47¿Q6�6MÃ)6�CQ¿FOPS�¾�

�� s h($ v lHn q $%o j i�$ v��2h %'$<h(�2j�) jJw l îj1<S�ÇTL<;�6X¾¡1}L7Ã"NB6t¿¡I À¬;�6 Æ Ç­ID=J6t;�¿Q6 Æ ÇTOTSt/G¾�/G1<;;�6�ÄJ¿F6t6�IGÀ9ÇTIJ/G;?;�OP¾]CQ¿FOTN7L�CQO­IJ1¬8}Ã�6X/G¾FL7¿Q6t; N}=)CQ476M¿Q/ CFOTI¢I À9CF476�¾{CQ/ 1B;7/ ¿b;%;�6tÈ}OT/ CFOTIG1È�¾�@�CF476¡Ã)6X/ 1�I À}CQ47601}L7Ã"NB6t¿¬I À7S�ÇTOT6�1eC(Sb47OTÇP;�¿F6t1�À¤IG¿96X/GSb4M¿Q6 Æ ÇTOTSt/�¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿X@ ð ¾FÃ�/ ÇTÇ­6t¿¿Q/ CFOTI)O­Ã Æ ÇTO­6X¾�Nº6�C{CQ6�¿,ÇTIJ/J;%;�OP¾{CF¿QO­N7L7CFOTIG1¬@

Page 10: University of California, Berkeley...CFOPS /G¾{Ct@ ð ¾ / 1ü/ Ç CF6t¿F1

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Cum

ulat

ive

Per

cent

age

of S

ourc

e to

Mem

ber

pairs

RDP

od_naive, 500 random serversod_smart, 500 random servers

od_naive, 500 backbone serversod_smart, 500 backbone servers

� � � ���º� E � � �21c�t���';t�¢�t�P�]���F�>$0�G�����t�ü��������� *¬�P�,+B;����F�¤���G�¢�6-�-}�j����(6+e�F� 7�� < < ��D¤���]�]��b�F�6;t�F�{� 8

� � � ��<�� �t����*9���t�,+r(]�t�e� � �:-e���¤�t�B* +e�F�?� �21 ���/(]�t�]� ��� � -G�m���p���X�t�¥� 7�� < < ��D¤���]�]��b�F�6;t�F�{� 8

� y{s+$/l�v��2hKk�lzi.j m $ qtm ) hKw+�2j -ÁÂ6�Ã)6X/G¾FL7¿F6%CF476�¿Q6�ÇP/DCQO­ÈJ6?;�6tÇT/m= Æ 6t1</ Ç­C]= ô¥:,K�â5õ/ 1<;¢CF4<65N</G1<;�R�OP;}CF4�S�IG1<¾FL7Ã Æ CFOTIG1"R�47OPSb4¢OP¾�S�IGÃ Æ L7CF6t;"N}=�¾{L<Ã�Ã)OT17Ä�CF476g1}L7âNº6�¿I À(Ne=eCQ6t¾gâL<ÇuCQO Æ ÇTOT6t;�N}=�CF476�CQ¿Q/G1<¾{Ã)OP¾F¾FOTIG1 CQO­Ã)6MIDÈG6t¿g6�ÈG6t¿F=)ÇTO­1<ã%OT1%CQ476M176�C]R�IG¿Qãª@

� g.m�jJj �2qZwuk�l�m�s+�Gl�v qZw l�m�h�� � h ÁÉ6�S�IGL71eC�NBIGCF4 CQ476�1}L7Ã"NB6t¿5IGÀw/ Æ<Æ Ç­OPS�/ CFOTIG1�Å�ÇT6�ÈG6tÇÃ)6t¾Q¾F/GÄG6t¾g¾F6�1eC�/ 1B; CQ476�N</ 1B;�R�OT;�CF4�S�IJ1<¾{L<Ã Æ CFOTIG1?À¤IG¿,S�IJ1<¾{CF¿QL<S�CQO­17Ä�CQ476�;}Å°CF¿Q6�6G@ýwOTÄGL<¿F6�é�¾{4<IDR,¾�CF476 1}L7Ã"NB6t¿�I Àg¿F6 Æ ÇTOTSt/G¾ Æ ÇP/GS�6t;ü/ 1<;ÂCQ476�Ç­Ie/G;É;�OP¾]CQ¿FOTN7L�CQO­IJ1ÉIJ1

CF476X¾{6�¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿b¾�@�� á ä ñ�ÌDÖ�Ï / Æ7Æ ¿FIe/GSb4 L<¾F6t¾"IG1<Ç­= /GNBIJL�C)éJø���CQI8�Jø���I À,CQ476�¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿b¾L<¾{6X;%N}= ÑXá ÞºÌDÎ�×DÕ 87OT¾g6tÈG6t1%Nº6�C{CQ6�¿gCQ4</ 1 ÑD×DÕ�Ö�ÍTÌDÐ äb87/G1<; OP¾gÈG6t¿F= S�Ç­Ie¾{6�CFI�CQ476MI Æ CQO­Ã�/ ÇS�/G¾F6 �� ä�@ ð ÇT¾FI�17I CQ6�CF4</ C Ñtá ä ñ)Ì Ö�Ï 4</J¾MNB6�C{CF6t¿�ÇTIJ/G;ü;�OP¾{CF¿QO­N7L7CFOTIG1ÉCF4</G1 Ñtá ÞºÌ Î�×mÕ/ 1<; ÑD×DÕ�Ö�ÍTÌDÐ äb87S�Ç­Ie¾{6�CQI � ä0À¤IG¿�NºI CF4 ÖFÌ ÞºáJÑDñ /G1<;üß ÌJØ�� ß ÑDÞªÕ�á��jÏpÖQÕQÕ @

îj1Âý(O­ÄJL7¿Q6�÷B8 Ñtá ä ñ)Ì Ö�Ï 4</G¾�Nº6�C{CQ6�¿�:,K�â CF4</G1 ÑXá ÞºÌDÎ�×DÕ 89/ 1<;ÂêJÿ�� I À ÑXá ä ñ�ÌDÖ�Ï:,K�â5¾)NB6�C]R56t6�1Ý/ 1}= Ã)6�Ã"NB6t¿ ¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿)/ 1<;ÒCF4<6�¿FI}I C Æ /GO­¿b¾�/ ¿Q6?R�O­CF4<O­1Ý÷<@¡ý(OTÄGL7¿Q6�ÿ

Page 11: University of California, Berkeley...CFOPS /G¾{Ct@ ð ¾ / 1ü/ Ç CF6t¿F1

� � � ���<� � � ��$F�F�¢���"� -�-=1 �/(]�t���¤�t� D<1u� ;t�019���F�]�F��D�F� 7 �¥� - 8 �t�}� �¥�t�¥��1_$]�t����*¬�¤���,+ (]�t�JD�6� ���]� 7 $]�t���¥�t� 8 �b������D¥���j�]� (]�t�e�]���6� (Q�����t� 7�� < < ��D¤���]�]���Q�F� ;t�F�{� 8

S�IG1eCQ¿Q/J¾]Cb¾�CF476�NB/ 1<;�R�OP;}CQ4ÛS�IG1B¾{L7Ã Æ CQO­IJ1�I À-Èm/G¿FOTIGLB¾,;}Å°CF¿Q6�6�S�IJ1<¾{CF¿QL<S�CQO­IJ1%CQ6tSb4717OPìeL76t¾R�OuCQ4þI Æ CFOTÃ�/ Çgî]â Æ ÇT/JS�6�Ã)6t1JCX@�¼g476?¿Q6t¾FL7Ç­CQ¾)/ ¿Q6%ÈJ6�¿Q=ü6�1<S�IGL7¿b/ ÄJO­17Ä�¬CQ476?NB/ 1<;�R�OP;}CQ4S�IG1B¾{L7Ã Æ CQO­IJ1)I À Ñtá ä ñ)Ì Ö�Ï OP¾0ìeL7O­CF6,S�Ç­Ie¾{6gCQI�CF476�I Æ CQO­Ã�/ Ç � ä�/ 1B;)OT¾�Ã"L<Sb4�ÇT6t¾Q¾-CF4</G1CF4</ C,I À ÑXá ÞºÌ Î�×mÕ @

¼g476 Æ 6�¿FÀ¤IG¿QÃ)/G1<S�6,/GNBIDÈJ6,OP¾0/GSb4<O­6tÈG6t;)/ C0CF4<6�S�Ie¾]C0IGÀ9;}Å°CF¿Q6�6�S�IG1<¾{CF¿QL<S�CQO­IJ1�ô¥ý(O­ÄJL7¿Q6�Jõ�@7>�IDR56tÈG6t¿t8JÀ¤IG¿gNºI CF4 ÖFÌ ÞºáJÑDñ / 1B;Éß ÌGØ � ß Ñ ÞºÕ�á��jÏ°ÖFÕbÕ 8 ÑXá ä ñ�ÌDÖ�Ï / Æ7Æ ¿QIJ/JSb4 Æ ¿QI};7L<S�6X¾Ç­6X¾F¾5CF4B/ 1?CF47¿Q6�6�CFOTÃ)6t¾gI À9CF476MÃ)6t¾Q¾F/GÄG6X¾0IGÀ Ñtá ÞºÌ Î�×mÕ / 1<;%Ç­6X¾F¾5CF4B/ 1?¾FO­í CFOTÃ)6t¾�I ÀwCF4</ CÀ¤IG¿ I Æ CFOTÃ�/ Ç�St/G¾F6 � ä�@0ò�6t/G1}R�47O­ÇT6G8 Ñtá ÞºÌ Î�×mÕ L<¾{6X¾ / ÇTÃ)IJ¾{C)CF4763¾Q/ Ã)6�/ Ã)IJL71eC I ÀN</ 1<;7R�OT;}CQ4�/G¾ � ä5R�47OTÇT6 ÑXá ä ñ)Ì Ö�Ï L<¾{6X¾�/ NºIGL�C�CQ47¿Q6�6�CFI �<ÈJ6�CFOTÃ�6X¾gCF4B/DC,I À � äb@

îj1�¾F47IG¿FCt8XCQ476,¾{Ã�/G¿{C�;�=}1</ Ã)OPS�¿F6 Æ Ç­OPS�/ Æ ÇP/GS�6�Ã)6�1eC�4</J¾(/MS�Ç­Ie¾{6�ÅpCQI Å�I Æ CQO­Ã�/ Çe1}L7âNº6�¿I À�¿F6 Æ ÇTOTSt/G¾t80Nº6�C{CQ6�¿�Ç­Ie/G;Ý;�OP¾]CQ¿FOTN7L�CQO­IJ1¬8g/ 1<;ÝÇT6t¾Q¾%;�6tÇT/m=Ý/ 1B;ÝâL7Ç­CFOPS�/J¾]C%NB/ 1<;�R�OP;}CQ4S�IG1B¾{L7Ã Æ CQO­IJ1�CF4</G1¢CQ476,1</GO­ÈJ6g/ Æ7Æ ¿QIJ/JSb4¬8D/DC-CF476 Æ ¿FOPS�6�IGÀ<CF4<¿F6t6gCFI �<ÈJ65CQO­Ã)6X¾¡/G¾-Ã"L<Sb4CF¿Q6�60S�IG1<¾{CF¿QL<S�CQO­IJ1�CF¿b/D½ S @���¾{LB/ ÇTÇ­=J8�CF¿Q6�60¿F6XS�IG1B¾]CQ¿FL<S�CFOTIG1�OT¾w/�âLBSb4�ÇT6t¾Q¾�À¤¿Q6tìeL76t1eC96�ÈJ6�1eCCF4</G1%ÁÉ6�N?;</DCQ/�/GStS�6X¾F¾5/ 1<;%L Æ ;</DCF6J@�ý7L7¿FCF476t¿t8}O­CQ¾ Æ 6�¿FÀ¤IG¿QÃ)/G1<S�6�OT¾gìeL7O­CF6MS�ÇTIJ¾F6,CFI"CF4<6OT;�6X/ Ç,St/G¾F6 �¾]Cb/DCQOTS Æ ÇP/GS�6�Ã)6�1eC�IG1þî]â�Ã"L7Ç­CFOPS�/G¾{Ct@¡>�6�1<S�6G8-CQ476 �F¾FÃ�/ ¿FC�/ Æ<Æ ¿FIe/GSb4 �3OT¾Ã�IJ¿F6�/J;�ÈD/ 1eCQ/GÄG6�IJL<¾t@

K�L76 CFI�CQ476%ÇTO­Ã)O­CF6X; 1}L7âNº6�¿�/ 1<;��DIG¿¢;7OT¾{CF¿QO­N<L�CFOTIG1 IGÀ�¾F6�¿QÈG6t¿Q¾t8�CQ476�¿Q6 Ã�/m=36�í}OP¾{C¾{IJÃ�6�S�Ç­OT6�1eCb¾�R�47I S�/G1717IGC,NB6¢S�IDÈG6t¿F6X; R�476t1�À¥/GS�OT17Ä)CQ476 ��Ieö�/ 1B;�St/ Æ /JS�O­C]= ¿Q6tìeL7OT¿F6�ÅÃ�6t1eCQ¾t@¡îj1ïCF47OP¾%St/G¾F6G8�IGL<¿ / ÇTÄGIG¿QO­CF47à St/ 1 Æ ¿QIDÈ}OT;�6�47OT1eCQ¾ /J¾�R�476t¿F6�CFI Æ ÇT/JS�6�Ã)IG¿Q6¾{6t¿FÈJ6�¿b¾�@ ð 1B;ÉCF476�6�í Æ 6�¿QOTÃ�6t1eCQ¾�¾F47IDRàCQ4</DC�CQ476�1</GO­ÈJ6)¾QSb476tÃ�6�4B/G¾MÃ�/ 1}=3Ã)IJ¿F6)L71�ÅS�IDÈG6t¿F6X;%S�Ç­OT6�1eCQ¾�CQ4</ 1�CQ476�¾{Ã�/G¿{C�IG1<6G87;�L76MCQI�CF476�1</ CFL7¿Q6�I À(OuCb¾�L71}N</GÇT/G1<S�6X;%ÇTIJ/J;�@

Page 12: University of California, Berkeley...CFOPS /G¾{Ct@ ð ¾ / 1ü/ Ç CF6t¿F1

� �¶5³�¹ {¸�W}»]¶0³�WG��³�· �,¸,´�¸�µ���� ¶¡µ��

îj13CQ47OT¾ Æ / Æ 6�¿X8�R56�6�í Æ ÇTIG¿Q6¢CQ6tSb471<OTìeL76X¾�À¤IG¿MN7L7OTÇT;7O­17Ä�CQ476 ;�OP¾F¾F6�Ã)OT1</DCQO­IJ1ÛCF¿Q6�6J8¬/?;7=JÅ1</ Ã)OPSÒS�IJ1eCF6�1eCÂ;7OT¾{CF¿QO­N<L�CFOTIG1à1<6�C]R�IG¿Qãº@�ý(O­¿b¾]CX8�R�6 Æ ¿FI Æ Ie¾{6 /G1<;àS�IJÃ Æ / ¿Q6Ò¾F6�ÈG6t¿Q/GÇ¿F6 Æ Ç­OPS�/ Æ ÇP/GS�6�Ã)6�1eC�/ ÇTÄGIG¿QO­CF47Ã�¾5R�47OTSb4�¿Q6t;�L<S�6�CQ476M1}L7âNº6�¿gI À(¿F6 Æ ÇTOTSt/G¾g;�6 Æ Ç­ID=J6t; /G1<;¾{6tÇuÀ�Å�IG¿QÄJ/G17O­Et6�CF4<6�à OT1JCQI�/�N</ ÇP/ 1BS�6t;¢;�OT¾Q¾F6�Ã)O­1B/DCFOTIG1�CF¿Q6�6G@ ö}6XS�IJ1<;�8XR56�L<¾F65¼(/ Æ 6t¾{CF¿Q=G8m/Æ 6t6�¿FÅpCQI Å Æ 6t6�¿�ÇTI}St/DCQO­IJ1 ¾{6t¿FÈ}OPS�6G8mÀ¤IJ¿0Nº6�CFCF6�¿�¾FSt/ ÇP/ N7OTÇTOuC]=¢/G1<;)ÇTI}St/ ÇTOuC]=J@ îj1)CF4<6�À¤L�CFL<¿F6J8GR�6R5IJL7ÇT;ÂÇTO­ãJ6¢CQIÛS�IG1eCQO­1}L76�6�ÈD/ ÇTL</ CFOTIG1ÉR�OuCQ4ÂÃ)IG¿Q6�;�OTÈG6�¿b¾F6¢CQI Æ IGÇTIGÄGOT6t¾�/ 1B;3R�IG¿Qã}Ç­Ie/G;7¾t8/G;7; ;7=e1B/ Ã)OTS%¿F6 Æ ÇTOTSt/Û;�6�ÇT6�CQO­IJ1 CFIÉ;}Å°CF¿Q6�6G8-/ 1B; O­1}ÈJ6t¾{CFOTÄJ/DCQ6 47IDR CFIÂN7L7OTÇT;þ/ÛNº6�CFCF6�¿2�K�ó R�O­CF4�I CQ476�¿ Æ 6�6t¿{Å°CFIGÅ Æ 6�6t¿gCF6XSb4717OPìJL<6t¾t@

� � ¹��g³�¶�� �9·�% �9³5´=W

ÁÂ6�ÄG¿b/GS�O­IJL<¾{ÇT=�/JSbã}17IDR�Ç­6X;�ÄG65¾ Æ IG1<¾FIG¿b¾F47O Æ /G1<;�ÄJ¿Q/G1eCQ¾�À¤¿QIGà K ð :,â ð ô¤ÄG¿b/ 1eCwó���Jø��7è�Å� �DÅ �mÅjê �<ètéeõ�8B2�/ ÇTO­À¤IG¿Q17OT/?ò�OPS�¿QI ��¿b/ 1eC �"ø<è�Åjø ÷ �78 �¡¿QOPS�¾Q¾{IJ1¬8Bó�IGã}OT/<8¬ö}O­6tÃ)6�1<¾t8¬ö Æ ¿QO­1eCt8ó�¼�¼�K�I}25IJòÛIM/G1<;)>�: ��ÇP/ NºIG¿b/DCQIG¿QO­6X¾�@mÁÉ6gCF4</G17ã">�/ I¢25476t1¬8GòÛ/ C{CF4<6�R 2�/ 6t¾Q/ ¿�/G1<;25476�1�Å�176t6�254}L</G4 À¤IG¿g¿Q6�È}OT6�R�OT17Ä¢CQ476M;�¿Q/ À�C�I À¬CQ476 Æ / Æ 6�¿�/ 1B;�CF4B/ 17ã�CQ476�/ 17IJ1}=eÃ)IJL<¾¿F6tÈeOT6�R�6�¿b¾5À¤IG¿gCQ476�OT¿�ÈD/ ÇTL</ N7ÇT6�¾FL7ÄGÄJ6t¾{CFOTIG1<¾t@

� �X^ �9µ��9³�¹ �uW

�X� � xXr�W�rta7©º\Q`FzJdeVXscVt§Xac\bi � de`X�¬zD[j[]Y<® ����������� rtxtrtW�r�a�� `QVXW)�� �����GU(z}rb�-r�[]ze\tk}_�����`�U-r�dede\tker�d}| ���ev9^]\Q�-\Q^��?�����®�0\bsca­r�~esc\gW�Zesn[]ac`�rti�[wqPVt^-ze\Q[]\Q^]Vt§X\Q£

dJ\bVXZJi�de\Q[p�-V�^]xGib� � d �-�j�({�]�]���P�G�t��� ����������)���%":E_" � k �������G� G�����GU(z ZBkJ_����r�VJkJrtde|! ���"�z}r�de§J� � `�rtij\0qPVt^¡\Qd}|�i�oGi�[]\bW W�Zesn[]ac`�rti�[�� � d �-�j�({�]�j�t�P�G�t��� �# E � 9$�&% ���(' �)��E 9Jk+*XZedJ\F�������G�

� ��f�au§tan[{rts � ijsurtd}| � dJ`X�¬zD[j[]YB® �,��������� |Gac§Xan[{rtscacijsurtd}|7� `bVXW)�� � ¯ � V ^{rtde`Qauib�-�(Vta­|7®��wVXZJ^?V��¡d acdD[]\Q^]dJ\Q[�|Gaui�[j^]ac~JZJ[]acVXd<��©º\b`{zedJac`�rtsM^]\bY�V�^j[�k � U � � k

zD[j[]Y<® ����������� rt`Qac^]a�� Vt^]§.��oDVtau|<k � YG^]aus�kJ�������G�/ �0*G�ef����ZJo []Vtd)rtde|1�?� V ��_ `FzD��r�^j[32X���54GY�\Q^]ac\bdJ`b\bi¡�¡an[]z�r�ijZJ^]hX\Qo�[]VDVXsBqTVt^5|Jacij`bV�hm\F^]audJ§

dJ\Q[°�(Vt^]x�[]acW�\gYJ^]V�[]VD`bVXsBij\Q^]hm\Q^]ib� � d �-�j�( ¬� �76t98� �)��9�k � ����� �� �(:M�;*mrtacdür�d}|=<��5<wr�^]an^{r�dea�� � YJYJ^]V>4GauW�r�[]acVXdÛrtsc§tVt^]an[]zeW�iMqTVt^�W�\Q[j^]ac`�q�r�`bacsuan[poÂscVD`�r�[]acVXd

r�d}|@?D£pW�\b|Jaurtd%YJ^]Vt~esc\bW�i�ZJijacde§"[]zJ\�YG^]acW�rtsn£p|JZ}r�s�ij`FzJ\bW�r¢rtd}|�surt§�^{rtdJ§Xaurtd�^]\Qs­rA4Jr�[]acVXd<�� d �-�j�( ¬� �)�%" E 9Jk � ����� �

� ��_���*mrtW�acd<k}U5�+*Xacd<k � ��:�ZJ^]`Xk f���5r�2XkJr�d}|!���J_Gzer�hGan[j[���U(VXdei�[j^{r�acde\�|¢W�ac^j^]V�^¡Yesurt`Q\bW�\bdD[Vtd"[]zJ\�audD[]\Q^]dJ\Q[�� � d �����({�{�j�t�T�G�t��� �B��������{� �b�(]�t��k ����� �t�

� �0*G�C*XrtdedJVt[j[]a¡\Q[�r�s���D�hm\F^]`�rti�[�® 0\bsca­r�~esc\)W�Zesn[]ac`�rti�[]acde§%�¡an[]zÉr�dÉV�hm\Q^]surboÛde\Q[p�-V�^]x7� � d�-�j�({�]�j�t�P���t��� � " 9 �B�{k ������� �

�H�G����an^j^]V�^ � W�rt§X\ � dD[]\Q^]de\F[ � dJ`X�¬zD[j[]YB® �,��������� W�an^j^]V�^j£pacW�r�§X\X� `bVtW)����X��f�� ¯ \bde|er�^{r�x auibk�_7��_Gzea�kef��E<9\Q^]W�rGkertde|1�?�}¦�rtsu|JhmVt§X\bs�� � �F� � ® � d r�YeYJsuac`�r�[]acVXd sc\bhm\bs

W�Zesn[]ac`�rti�[¡acdGqT^{rti�[j^]ZJ`Q[]ZJ^]\t� � d �-�j�({�]�j�t�P�G�t��� �(GX���H6 9���' 9Jk=����� �X��� ��U5� ��� ¯ s­rA4 []VXdBk�,�H�r��jr�^{rtW�r�dBkJrtde| � �D¦Ý��5ac`{z}rG� � `b`Q\bijijacde§�dJ\�r�^]~Do�`QVXYeac\bi¡V�qº^]\bYJsuan£

`br�[]\�|¢VX~H��\b`Q[]i0acd�rM|Gaui�[j^]ac~JZJ[]\�|¢\bd hGan^]VtdeW�\bdD[�� � d �-�j�( ¬� �g�,+e��9tE �p9 � #�# k � ����� ��H G� �¬�9¨�acZBk;<�� ��� ¯ rX|JW�r�d}r�~ez}r�dBk¬r�d}| ���;<9VD\bscxm\Q^��=D�d�[]ze\¢Yesurt`b\QW�\bdD[MVtq0�-\Q~3ij\F^]hm\Q^

^]\QYescac`�rtib� � d �����({�{�j�t�T�G�t��� ����������{� �b�(]�t��kJ����� �X�� � ��_���5r�[]d}r�i]rtW�oDk ¯ � V ^{r�de`bacibk��?�A gr�d}|Gsu\FoDk!,�>:,r�^]Y<k�rtde|�_���_GzJ\bdexX\Q^�� � ij`brtsurt~Jsu\(`bVXdD[]\bdD[j£

rt|e| ^]\biji]rt~Jsu\�dJ\Q[°�(Vt^]x�� � d �����(F�]�j�t�P���t��� � # E ��9$�&% E_" � ��kJ����� �X�

Page 13: University of California, Berkeley...CFOPS /G¾{Ct@ ð ¾ / 1ü/ Ç CF6t¿F1

�� � ¯ � 0V |G^]ac§XZJ\ 2)r�d}|3_7�w_ ac~}rts��3_ YJ^]\�rt|<®w_ `�rtsc\�r�~esc\)Yesur�[jqPVt^]W qPVt^�^]\bsca­r�~esc\�r�d}|Û\���`bac\bdD[r�ZJ[]VtW�r�[]\�|"|Jaci�[j^]ac~eZJ[]acVtdB� � d �����({�{�j�t�T�G�t��� �������¢kJ�������G�

� / � � �?0V��¡i�[j^]VXd3rtde| ¯ �ªf�^]ZJij`FzJ\bs�� ¯ rti�[j^jo7®¬_ `�rtsur�~esc\Xk¬|Gaui�[j^]ac~JZJ[]\�|�Vt~��°\b`Q[MscVD`�r�[]acVXd3rtde|^]VtZJ[]acde§�qPVt^0sur�^]§t\Q£¥ij`�rtsc\�Y�\b\Q^j£¤[]Vt£¥Y�\b\F^¡i�oJi�[]\QW�ib� � d �-�j�( ¬� � � �¤�X��1u� *w�t�]��� < < ���

� � ��_ Y�\b\�|G\Q^{r � de`X�¬zD[j[]YB® ����������� ijY�\b\�|G\Q^{rG� `bVtW)�� � � � VXd�_ []VXac`�r k�0VX~�\Q^j[ ��V�^j^]acibk�f�r�h a­| :,r�^]§t\Q^�k5�?� V ^{rtdJi0:,rXrtijzJVD\bx�k�r�d}| �r�^]awv-rtsur�x ^j£

acijzJd}rtd<�ºU(zeVt^{|7® � ij`�rtsur�~esc\gY�\b\Q^j£¤[]V�£pY�\Q\Q^(scVDVtxGZJY�ij\Q^]h au`Q\5qPV�^ � dD[]\Q^]dJ\Q[(rtYeYJscau`br�[]acVXdJib� � d�-�j�({�]�j�t�P���t��� � # E � 9$�&% E_" � � k ����� �t�

� � �0��� "�\b§XZG^{rGk�:M�<U-rtschm\F^j[�kºr�d}|%_7�<vwz}r�[j[{r�`Fzer�^��°\b\X�� �V��Ý[]V¢W�V |J\bsªrtd%audD[]\Q^]dJ\Q[°�(Vt^]x�� � d�-�j�({�]�j�t�P���t��� ���������)�)�_" E_" � k � ��� / �

���G�,v0�����+"7zertVGk *G�+:�ZJ~eaur�[]V��¡ac` 2XkJr�d}| � �+*XVXij\QYezB�ª©ªrtY�\Qi�[j^jo<® � d"acdJq­^{rti�[j^]ZJ`Q[]ZJ^]\0qPVt^¡qPrtZesn[j£[]Vtsc\Q^{rtdD[¡�¡au|J\Q£pr�^]\brMsuVD`br�[]acVXd r�d}|¢^]VtZJ[]acde§G� l U-v ©º\b`{zB��0\bY�Vt^j[ l U-v �XU�_ f�£<� �Q£ ��� � �t�

� �X��_��(¨�� "�z Z}rtdJ§Jkwv5�����C"7zertVGk � �9f��C*XVtij\bYez<kO,�C ��:,r�[32Xk(rtde| *J�wf��C:�ZJ~eaur�[]V��¡ac` 2X�v(r�om\bZ+47® � d�r�^]`FzJan[]\b`Q[]ZJ^]\gqTVt^5ij`�rtsur�~esc\�r�d}|"qPrtZJsc[j£¤[]Vtsu\F^{rtdD[5�¡au|G\Q£pr�^]\�r�|Jr�[{rM|Gauijij\QW�auder�£[]acVtdB� � d �����({�{�j�t�T�G�t��� � # E � ��"I9�9 � # kK����� �t�