31

0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

���������������� ������������������������������������ ���"!#�%$�$�$�$��'&(���*),+.-�!,+.-0/2103��

465�7989:;8=<�> ?A@CB DFEHGI5�<J8K:L:M7K?HNPOPQRDSGPO <UTI5�89VWDFQUQX?Y:;8KDZ<X5�ODS:�<J8'[\5 VJ5]EH8K?HGPQ^`_ba�c=d0eMf�g�h�c9ikj\_bl(monU^;prq�s�itd0uwv�g�vxikl�y�cKzru�m�{�itd|its}h~g�ft_bl�cK�=m,�x��c=pre|s}h�itjFa���p�l�m��

��d0p�itl}f�g�h���l�u�a�c=d|��m��`itl�uY�Mz�c'��c=p��Fg���c'��e��|_��"�

�]cK��itd0e|j\c=l�e`_k�U�Js��"�|p�q=�Km(�}_bl�e�ikl�i�{�e�ike|c��Ml�p��bcKd0�|p�e��

^�g�v�g�vxikl�y�cKzruHitl�uA^�g�f�gbh�cKitj\_tl�m��]cK��itd0e|j\c=l�eX_t���Js��"�0p�qK�=m��}_bl�e�itl�iZ{�e�ike|c��Ml�p��bc=d|�|p�e��bm���_t KcKj\itl�m

�}¡£¢t¤�¥�¦#¥�§©¨bªt«b¬�g�­*cKj\itp�z.®Xq9ikl�y�cKzru�¯]��s��"�|p�q=�Kg�j\_tl�e�itl�i�g�cKu���m�zrc9itjH_bl�¯]��s��"�|prqK�=g,jH_bl�e�itl�i�g,c=u���°

{�g�hJg�ft_bl�c=�Km��]cK��itd2e�jHcKl�eM_t�J�Js��"�|p�q=�]itl�uw���2e�d0_bl�_bjF�tm���itd0e|j\_b��e�s}v�_bz�zrcK�bckm�±�itl�_#�tcKd=m(²M±³¬b¨b¥b¢b¢�g

­´c=j�ikp�zµ®U{�itd|its�g,h~g¶ft_bl�c=��¯]u�itd2e�jH_b��e|s�g,c=u���°

�·gth�itjFa���p�l�mt¸U����cKd0p�jHcKl�e�itz��Js����0p�q=�J�]cK��ikd0e�jHcKl�eKm��Ml�p��bc=d|�|p�e��Fv�_bz�zrcK�bc¹�]��a�zrp�l�mk�]��a�zrp�lº«�mb^`cK����a�z�prq

_t��»�d|c=z�itl�u(g;­´cKj\itprzµ®X�kcKp�e�s�z�itjSa���p�l�¯�s�_te�j\itp�z.g,q=_bj�°

��g"f�g�h���l�u�a�c=d|��m��]cK��ikd0e�jHcKl�e¼_t�(�Js��"�0p�qK�=m�¡�s�cM�Ml�pr�bc=d|�0pre��A_t�(��d|pr K_bl�i�m�¡���qK�|_tl�m��]½}ª�¢t¥b¾�¦bgx­´cKj\itprzµ®

z���l�u�a�cKd|��¯�c=j�ikp�zµg,itd0p� K_tl�i�g�cKu���°

�Fg��Zg���c'��e��|_���m�²Mike�pr_bl�itz�{�_bz�itd`¿]a��|c=d0�kike|_bd0�tm�{���l��0��_teKm�²]�Àªbªb¨t«�¤�g`­´c=j�itprzµ®Xit��c'��e��|_���¯]l��|_�g,c=u���°

n ¸~¸~^Á{"�"�0e|cKjH��ikeMº{�ÃÄv

� ��itd2e�jH_b��e|sÅv�_bz�zrcK�bc

� �;l�pr�tcKd|�0pre��}v�_bzrz�c=�bc��]��a�zrp�l

� ¡�s�cZ�Ml�pr�bc=d|�0pre��Æ_t����d0p� =_bl�i

� ²Mike�pr_bl�itz�{"_bz�itd�¿�a��|cKd2�kike�_bd2�

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 2: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

áIâ�ã ×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&��æèç�é=ê�ë#ì�ítê�î »�lÅe�s�pr��ï�_bd0�èï�cºd|c=z�ike|c�e�s�cºj�ik�bl�c=e|p�q�itl�uÅe|_b��_tz�_b�bprq9itz���itd|itjA§

c=e|cKd0�M_t��e�ï�c=zr�tcFp�l�e|cKd|��z�itl�c'e�itd2�Æj\it�bl�c'e�p�q�q=z�_b��u���e�_\it�|�0_�q=p�ike|cKuÅ�|_bz�itd`itq=e|pr�tcZd0c'§

�bpr_bl��Kg�ðñc����|cFiHq'�"z�p�l�u�d|prq9itzrzr�H�0�"jHj\c'e�d|prq�qK_bl��0e�ikl�e2§©òó�*_bd|q=c'§µ�*d|cKc�jH_�u�cKz�e�_Hu�c%§

d|p��bc�y�c=z�uÅz�p�l�c]e�ï`p��0eKm�e�_te�itz�qK��d0d|c=l�eKm�itl�uYe�_te�itz�j�ik�bl�c=e|p�q]ô��"�Y�*d|_bjõprl}�0pre|�}_ba"§

�|c=d0�kike|p�_bl��`_t�Xj�ik�bl�c=e|p�q�q=z�_b��u��Kg�ðñcZq=_bj\��itd|c�e�s�cK�|cZ��d|_t��c=d0e�prcK��ï`pre|sÅe|s�_b�0cZ_t�Äe�s�c

it�0�|_"qKp�i×e�cKuÅ�|_tz�itd`itq'e�p��bcºd|cK�tp�_bl��=m�ï`s�p�q�sÅï�cºp�l��*cKd��*d|_bjö�|_bz�itdx�bc=q=e�_tdMj\it�bl�c'e�_b�td�itjH�Kg

¿]��d`qK_bjH��itd0p��0_blY_t�Xô��"��c=�]itl�u}q=��d|d0cKl�e��Md|c=�tc9itzr�K®�­2¦�°xe|s�c�e�_te�itz�ô����Åd|ike�pr_b�;÷xø�ù�úb÷�û�ü

e�c=l�u}e|_\a�c�_t�U_td|u�c=d;��l�pre���ý�­µ¾b°�e|s�cºe|_te�ikz�qK��d0d|c=l�e�d�ike|p�_b��þKø�ù�úkþ=û�üPitd0cZ_bd0u�cKd0�M_k�

j\it�bl�p�e���u�c��0j�ikz�z�c=dKý�itl�uó­´¨�°�e�s�c=d|cºp��`iA�0e�ike�pr�0e�prq9itzrzr�\�|pr�bl�pry�q9itl�e;��d|_t��_bd2e�pr_bl�itzo§

pre��èa�c'e�ï�c=cKlwe|s�cKjÅg�¿]��dM�kc=�Æy�l�u�p�l��t�MprlÅq=_bjH��itd|prl��·e�_te�itz�e�ï`p��2e��MòXÿ ikd|ct®Ä­©¦#°�e�s�c

�kitz���cK�`_t�`­´òXÿ¼°0ø�ù itd0c�e��"��prq9itzrzr�èitlw_bd0u�cKd`_t�Xj�ik�bl�pre|��u�c��bd0c9ike|cKd�e�s�itlÅe|s�_b�0cZ_t�

­.ò�ÿ¼°2û�ü�ý�itl�u ­µ¾b°�e|s�cKd0cZpr�;l�_\�2e�ike|p��0e|p�qKitz�z����0p��bl�p�y�q9ikl�e`�0p��blÅ_bd;itjH��z�p�e���u�c]d|c=z�iק

e�pr_bl��0s�p��Ya�c=e�ï¹cKcKlIe|s�cKjÅg�¡�s�c=�|cZy�l�u�p�l��b�`qK_bjH��c=z����`e�_Ha�c=z�p�c'�bc�e�s�ike;j�it�tl�c=e|p�q

qKzr_b��u��;it�0�|_"qKp�ike�c=uÅï`p�e�s}itq=e|pr�bcºd|c=�bp�_tlÅc=d|����e�p�_tl���ikd|c��*_bd|jHcKuYa��Åj�ik�bl�c=e|p�q�d0c'§

qK_tl�l�cKq'e�pr_bl}a�c=e�ï¹cKc=lIe�s�c=�|cºd|c=�bp�_bl��Mikl�u}e|s�cKprd�z�itd0�bcKd©§��|qKitz�c��0��d|d0_b��l�u�p�l��b�=m�d�ike|s�cKd

e�s�itl}�0p�jH��z�c�c=d|����e�p�_tl}_t�X��d|c%§�c%��pr�0e|p�l��A�0e|d|��q'e���d0cK�Mp�lYe�s�cºqK_bd0_bl�iA_bd�q�s�d0_bj\_t�|��s�c=d|ckg

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 3: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&�� áIâ �� î�����ê�ë�����ítê� ����v�_bd0_bl�itzÄj�ik�|��c��0cKq'e�p�_tl��·­.v��w¸J��°�itd0cSitlIitz�jH_b�0e;u�ikp�zr�è_�q=qK��d0d|cKl�qKc·_blwe|s�cF�0��l�gM»�l�e|cKd0��z�itl"§

c=e�itd0� j�ikl�pr�*c=�0e�i×e�p�_tl��Z_k�]v��}¸~�A_t� e|cKlós�i9�tc}iw�tcKd2� u�pr�0e�prl�q=eSj�it�tl�c=e|p�q��2e�d0��q=e|��d|ckm¹l�ikj\c=zr�ñi

z�ikd|�bc%§��|qKitz�cºs�c=z�p���g�������������� �"!#�$��%'&o¦�¤tª�¦)(�u�cK�0qKd|pra�c=uIe�s�pr�]j\it�bl�c'e�p�qº�0e|d|��q'e���d0cAit��i+*|�wit�bl�c'e�prqv�z�_t��u�g-, ��q=qK_bd0u�p�l��ñe�_ ����d|z�it��i/.��Au�c=y�l�pre|p�_bl�m¹e�s�d0cKcw��d|_b��cKd2e�p�c=�èitd0cwd0c)0���p�d0cKu e|_ pru�cKl�e�p�� � i�0e|d|��q'e���d0cHit��iÆj�it�tl�c=e|p�qSq=z�_b��u(®A­212°�iè�tcKd0� zr_�ï³��d|_te|_blPe�cKjH��cKd�i×e���d0ctý¹­21312°]ièz�itd|�bckm��|jH_"_te�s�mjH_bl�_te|_bl�p�q`d0_te�ike|p�_blA_t�(e�s�c;y�cKzru�u�prd|cKq'e�pr_bl�ý"itl�u ­4131312°~c=l�s�itl�qKcKu�j�it�tl�c=e|p�q�y�cKzruè�0e|d|c=l��te�s(gJ¡�s�c�bc=l�cKd|itz�qKit�|c�_t��iM�|jH_�_te|s�mtjH_bl�_ke�_bl�prq¹d0_te�i×e�p�_tlF_t��e|s�cxy�cKzruSu�prd|cKq'e�pr_blFpr�Uq9itzrz�c=uSi�j\it�bl�c'e�prq¹ô����

d|_t��ckgU�xe�zrc9it�2e¼_bl�c'§µe�s�prd|u &�576�8"�913:;��m�¦�¤b¤b¬<(.m�itl�u(m�itq=qK_bd0u�p�l��ºe|_Z�0_bj\c`d0cK�|cKitd|q�s�cKd|�=&>�)%9��%�m@?A��B�B�13:;��$:�CD�E�"�FC$1HGJIK�"L)8JMON�m�¾t¬b¬b¬�ýQP �)R�Rbm�¾t¬b¬t¬<((q=_bl��0p�u�c=d�ita�z��èjH_bd|ckm�_k�Äe|s�c�p�l�e|cKd|��z�itl�c'e�itd2�Hj�itl�pr�*cK�2e�iקe�pr_bl���_t�Uv��w¸J�;_ba��|c=d0�tcKuTSVUXWYS[ZY\As�i��tcZj\it�bl�c=e�prq�ô����Åd0_b��cH­´z�ikd|�bc%§��|qKitz�c�s�cKzrp���°��0e|d|��q'e���d0ctg¡�s�c=d|cFc%��p��0e`e�ï¹_�a�ik�|p�qºp�u�c9it�;ita�_b��e`e�s�cZ�0_bz�itd�_td|p��tp�l���_t��e�s�c�e�_t��_bzr_b�t�\_t�Uj\it�bl�c=e�prq�qKzr_b��u��=g

{�_bjHcwprl��bcK�2e�pr��ike�_td|�]&^�)%9��%�m�_`�J6�6�M��"�"m¹¾t¬b¬b¬�ýba ���3�91����$:c�"!d�$��%�m�¾t¬b¬t¬<(`��prc=ï �|_tz�itdHcKd0����e�pr_bl���it�

�bzr_ba�itz.mUpµg�ctg�mJu�c=y�l�cKu a�� e�s�cÆ_��tcKd�ikz�zxu�pr��_tz�itdºj�ik�bl�c=e|p�q�y�cKz�uó_k�;e|s�cÅ{���l(g »�lóe�s�pr�F�"p�c=ï�mJe|s�c

y�c=z�uIzrp�l�c=�M_t�Xe�s�cZs�cKzrj\c'e��2e�d|cKitjHcKd�a�cKz�e�a�cKq=_bjHcZe�s�cS_b��e|cKd|jH_b�2e�q=_bp�zr�M_t�Xe�s�cZj�it�tl�c=e|p�qºqKz�_t��u

e�s�d|_b���ts d0cKq=_bl�l�c=q=e�pr_bl a�c=s�p�l�u e|s�c\v��w¸£it��p�e�z�p�� e��M_$ef&^�)%9��%�mQ576�8"�913:;��mU¦9¤b¤b¬�ýg_`�J6�6�M��"�h�"!E�$��%�m¦�¤b¤tª<(µgı;cKl�q=c¹e�s�c¼zrc9itu�p�l���y�c=z�u�u�p�d0cKq'e�p�_tlº_k��j\it�bl�c'e�p�qJq=z�_b��u���e�cKl�u��Äe|_��*_bz�zr_#ï e�s�ike�_t��e|s�c~z�itd0�bc'§�|qKitz�c¹�|_bz�itdÄu�p���_bz�ckmtd0c=�bc=d|�0p�l���ike��|_tz�itd�j�i×��prjS��jÅgÄ¿�lSe|s�c�_ke�s�c=dXs�itl�u�m�_te�s�cKdUik��e�s�_td|�X�2e���u���prl��

y�z�itj\c=l�eXc=d|����e|p�_bl���&^�)%9��%�mi�j6O!3I;kl�"�b�$:�CEmb��8"!'m�¦�¤b¤�¥"ý��E6O!nI;kl�"�Q�$:�CpoqGJI;rg�":K:Äm"¦9¤b¤bª<(��"p�c'ï e|s�cKjit�~z�_"q9ikz�c=�tcKl�e��=m�ï`pre|s\prl�e�cKd0��z�ikl�c=e�itd0�Fj�it�tl�c=e|p�qxy�c=z�uw­´»2�wÃJ°U_bd0p�c=l�e�ike�pr_bl��Uq=_bd|d0cKz�ike�prl���ï`pre�s·e|s�c

�|_tz�itdºu�p���_bzrc\_bl�zr� a�cKq9ik���|cèe|s�c\e|_bd|_bpru�itzJy�c=z�u��Zp�l y�z�itjHcKl�e��Zu�_I�|_�gP{���q�s i}z�_"q9itzJ�"p�c'ï`��_bprl�e

s�it�;itzr�|_·a�cKc=lÅe�it�tc=l}prlYe|s�cX*0a�d0c9it�k_b��eF,\jH_�u�cKz�_t�Xitq'e�pr�tc�d|c=�bp�_blÆc=d|����e�p�_tl���&tsE:K!�1H6�GJIK6�8�m�¦�¤b¤bª�ý

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 4: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

áIâvu ×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&��sE:K!�1H6�GJIK6�8��"!w�$��%�m�¦�¤b¤b¤<(.®�e|s�c�e|_b��_tz�_b�t�A_k��e�s�c�ikq=e�p��bc]d0cK�bpr_blèu�c'e�c=d|jHp�l�c=�¹e�s�ike�_t��e|s�c]j\it�bl�c'e�p�qqKzr_b��ux&y?zNO:{GJI]�"!g�$��%�m�¾t¬b¬�¾�(µg¡�s�c¼d|c=z�ike|p�_bl��0s�p���a�c=e�ï¹cKc=lSj�ik�bl�c=e|p�qJq=z�_b��u���ikl�uºe|s�cKprd��|_bz�itd���d|_t�bcKl�p�e�_bd0��j�i9��a�c¹jF��q�sZjH_bd0c

�0e|d�itpr�bs�e|�*_bd2ïxikd|uS�*_bdXy�z�itjHcKl�e���&|�j6O!3I;kl�"�#�$:�Cpmb��8"!%m�¦�¤b¤b¥�ýq_`�}6�6�M��"�"m�¾t¬b¬t¬<(�e|s�itlAitq'e�pr�tc�d|c=�bp�_bl��&y~#�"L�!38�6OL��$:�CX_��$:��Q�"��C(m�¾t¬b¬�¦bý@?��F�$kl6O:T�"!w�$��%�m�¾t¬b¬b¾O(µgU±M_�ï�c'�bc=dKm�iZz�itd|�tc;�*d|itq=e|p�_bl\_t�Äv��w¸J�`itd0cit�0�|_"qKp�i×e�cKu�ï`pre|sZ�0_bz�ikd�itq=e|pr�bc~d0cK�bpr_bl��Kg��M�0p�l��;p�j\it�bc=���*d|_bjCa�_te|sºe|s�c¼h���{�v�¿�&y�b���v�JGJMO:{�"���"!�$��%�m¦�¤b¤b¢O(Äitl�u}¸J»�¡�&|���"����R"6O�@C$13:K1<��"�}���"!Q�$��%�m�¦�¤b¤�¢O(�prl��0e|d|��jHcKl�e|�M_blYe�s�cS{�¿�±�¿³j\pr�|�0p�_blx&y��6OkD13:;�;6�"!��$��%�m�¦�¤b¤b¢O(µm;ov�@R)�Y�$kh�$:K1��$:��$:�Cp���"�}��&�¾t¬b¬�¦�(��*_b��l�uAe|s�ikeJ_k��e|s�c`¨�¾�v��w¸X§ d|cKz�ike�c=uSe�d|itl��|prcKl�e��Jprle�s�cKp�d`�2e���u��tm�«�¦�� ï¹cKd|cFit�|�0_�q=p�ike|cKuYï`pre|switq'e�p��bcºd|cK�tp�_bl���ï`p�e�s�_b��eM��d|_bjHp�l�c=l�qKc�c=d|����e|p�_bl��Km�«b«i�ï¹cKd|c�ik�|�|_"qKp�ike�c=uèï`pre|sècKd0����e�pr_bl��x_k����d|_bjHp�l�cKl�q=cK�xc=jSa�c=u�u�c=uÆp�lÆitq'e�p��bc]d0cK�bpr_bl��Km�itl�uÆ_bl�zr�Ŧ#¢��ï¹cKd|cSit�|�0_�q=p�ike|cKu}ï`p�e�s}cKd|����e�pr_bl��;_t�J��d0_bj\prl�cKl�qKcK�M_b��e|�|p�u�cFitq'e�p��bcFd0cK�bpr_bl��=g�¡�s�_b�|c·v��w¸J��e�s�i×e

u�pru}l�_ke`p�l��b_bz��bcº��d|_tj\prl�cKl�q=c�cKd|����e�pr_bl��`_bd|pr�bp�l�ike�c=uÆp�lÅitq=e|pr�tcZd0cK�bpr_bl���a�_te�sYï`pre|switl�uÅï`p�e�s�_b��e

��d0_bj\prl�cKl�qKcK�=g » eÅ�0cKcKjH�Åz�p��kcKz�� e�s�ike}i q=_bj\��d|cKs�cKl��0pr�bc ��l�u�cKd|�2e�itl�u�p�l�� _t�ºe�s�c d|c=z�ike|p�_bl��0s�p��

a�c=e�ï¹cKcKl prl�e|cKd0��z�itl�c=e�ikd0� u�pr�0e���d|a�itl�qKcK�Fitl�u e|s�cKprdZ��d|_b�bc=l�pre|_bd��|_bz�itdºd|cK�tp�_bl��º�|s�_b��z�uña�c\a�it�0cKu

_blóiÅa�d|_bitu �"p�c'ïÕe�s�ikeFqK_bl��|p�u�cKd|�ºe�s�c�j�it�tl�c=e|p�qA�0e|d|��q'e���d0cè_t�`a�_te�sñ��d|_bjHp�l�cKl�q=cK�Sikl�uóitq'e�pr�tc

d|c=�bp�_tl��KgJ±;_�ï�c'�bcKd=m��*d|_bjÕe|s�c]_ba��0cKd2�ti×e�p�_tl�itz���_tp�l�e�_k����prc=ï�m"e�s�c�i��kitprz�ita�z�c`u�ike�iSitl�uÆik�|�|_"qKp�ike�c=u

itl�ikzr�"�|pr�Ae|cKq�s�l�p^0���cK�èitd|cX0���pre|c}u�p�e(c=d|c=l�eH�*_bdAe�s�c=�|cÅe�ï�_ ��s�cKl�_tj\c=l�i�g »�l ��itd0e|p�qK��z�itd=m¹�bc=q=e|_bd

j\it�bl�c'e�p�q`y�c=z�uÆjHc9it�0��d|c=j\c=l�e|��itd0c�i9�tikp�z�ika�z�c`_bl�z��A�*_bdxitq'e�p��bc�d0cK�bpr_bl��=g~±McKl�qKctm�p�l�e|s�p��¼ï�_bd0�\ï¹c

s�i9�bcºq�s�_b�0cKlÅe�_AqK_bl�qKcKl�e|d�ike|cZ_blÅj\it�bl�c'e�p�q�qKz�_t��uYc=�bc=l�e��]ik�|�|_"qKp�ike�c=uÅï`p�e�sÅitq'e�pr�tc�d|cK�tp�_bl��=g

¡�s�pr�¹d0cK�|cKitd|q�s�p��~j\_ke�pr�kike|cKuAa��Hd|cK�0��zre|�¼e|s�ikeb?��iI;kh�$:K: �"!��$��%�&,¾k¬b¬�¾O(�s�i9�tc�_ba�e�itp�l�cKuH_bl�q=_bjA§a�prl�ike�pr_bl��º_t�;itq'e�pr�tcèd|c=�bp�_tlóitl�uóz�itd|�bcH�|qKitz�c\y�cKzru��Fe�s�ike·itd0cè�|c=l��|p�e�p��bc�e|_Pd|cKq=_bl�y��t��d�ike|p�_bl a��

cKd0����e|p�_bl�gZ¡�s�c=�IqK_bl�q=z���u�cSe�s�ike�v��w¸J�Z_"qKq=��d�p�lPq=_blO�0��l�q'e�pr_blIï`pre|sPqKcKd2e�itprl s�cKzrj\c'e��0e|d|c9ikj\c=dqK_tl�y��b��d|ike�pr_bl��Sï`s�c=d|cYe�s�cY�2e�d|cKitjHcKdAp��·�0cKl��0pre�p��bcÆe�_ e�s�cÅprl��b_bz��bcKu itq'e�pr�tcYd|cK�tp�_bl�mJï`s�prq�s s�it�

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 5: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&�� áIâ��l�_bl���_te|cKl�e�p�itz�q�s�ikd�itq'e�cKd=gU���Jï¹cKzrzµm�preUp��JjH_te�p��ti×e�cKuFp�l�u�c=��c=l�u�c=l�e|zr�·a��Ad0cK�|��zre��Ue|s�ikeJï¹c�&|?A�F�$kl6O:�"!��$��%�m�¾t¬b¬b¾O(�s�i9�tcº_ta�e�itprl�cKuÆ_tlYe|s�c�d|c=z�ike|p�_bl��|s�pr�èa�c'e�ï�c=cKlÅ�|_bz�itd�itl�uÅprl�e�cKd0��z�ikl�c=e�itd0�\��s�c=l�_bj·§cKl�i�m�u�p��0qK���0�|c=uña�cKzr_#ï�gºÃ�d|_tj e|s�cK�0c·�0e���u�p�c=�Km�ï¹cAitd|c·zrcKuwe|_Æc'����z�_td|cSe�s�cSp�l�e�c=d�itq'e�pr_blPa�c'e�ï�c=cKl

itq'e�pr�tc�d|c=�bp�_bl��`itl�uÆe�s�c�z�itd|�tc'§��0q9itzrc�y�c=z�uYit�;iF�´itq'e�_bd�prlÆ�|_bz�itdxcKd0����e|p�_bl��`ikl�uÆe�s�c��*_bd0j�ike|p�_bl\_t�

j\it�bl�c'e�p�q�qKz�_t��u��Kg

?A�F�$kl6O:��"!D�$��%7&,¾k¬b¬�¾O(`�2e���u�prcKu i �|c'eè_t��«�� �|_bz�itdAqK_bd0_bl�itz`cKd0����e|p�_bl��\it�0�|_"qKp�i×e�cKu ï`pre|s e|s�ccKd0����e|p�_blñ_t���M§ d�i9� �|p��tj\_bpru��Km�ï`s�prq�s itd|cH��l�_�ï`lóe�_wa�c���d|_"u���q=e|pr�tc�_t�`�0��q�sóc=�tcKl�e��X&n_��$:��Q�"��C�"!D�$��%�m;¦�¤b¤t¤<(µgà»�l e|s�cwz�itd|�bc%§��0q9itzrc}u�pr��_tz�cYj\_"u�c=z�&^�)%9��%�m�_`�J6�6�M��"�"m¹¾t¬b¬b¬�mxs�cKd�ÃXp��t��d|c��<(.gàe|s�c

itd0q9itu�c�_t��y�cKzruÆz�p�l�cK�¹ï`s�_b�|c�it��c'�èj�ikd|����e�s�c]a�it�0c�_t��e�s�c]s�cKz�pr_b�|��s�cKd0p�q]q=��d|d0cKl�e`�|s�c=c=e`a�cKq=_bj\c=�

e�s�cM_b��e�cKd0j\_t�0e¼qK_bprz�_t�(e|s�c;j�it�tl�c=e|p�q`qKzr_b��u�m"it�~u�pr�|qK���|�|c=uYita�_#�tctgJ»�l\qK_bl�e�d|it�0eKm�prl�ikq=e�p��bc%§�d|c=�bp�_tl

ô����Åd0_b��c�j\_"u�cKzr�xe�s�c�y�c=z�uÅz�prl�cK��_t��e�s�cZv��w¸X§�it�|�0_�q=p�ike|cKu}itq=e|pr�bc�d0cK�bpr_bl�m�itzrd|c9iku��è_t�Äô�����§ d|_b��c

�*_bd0jWa�c=�*_bd0cAe|s�cAcKd0����e�pr_bl �0e�itd0e|�KmÄitd|cHit�0�|��jHcKu e�_Yc%����itl�u prl iÅ�0cKz���§��|prj\prz�itd`j\itl�l�c=dKm��|_Æe|s�c

_b��e|cKd0j\_b�2eUy�c=z�uAz�prl�cK�U_k��e|s�cxô����·d|_b��cxa�cKqK_tj\cxe|s�c�z�cKitu�p�l��]cKu��tc;_k��e|s�c�j\it�bl�c'e�p�q�qKz�_t��uX&��A13!�6OL�$:�C�����"kl6O�;�913:�mĦ�¤b¤t¤�m�e�s�c=p�d�ÃXpr�b��d0cA¾O(.gl?��F�$kl6O:��"!j�$��%w&�¾t¬b¬�¾O(X�|s�_�ï¹cKu e|s�ike�prlIe�s�c=p�d�u�ike�it�|c'el�c=pre�s�cKd�e�s�cºz�ikd|�bc%§��|qKitz�c�u�p���_bz�c]jH_"u�cKz�l�_td`e|s�cZitq=e|pr�bc%§�d0cK�bpr_blÆô����Åd|_t��c�jH_�u�c=z�p��`�|pr�bl�p�y�q9itl�e|zr�

a�c=e|e|cKd`e�s�iklÅe|s�cºe|_b�|�;_t�UiHq=_bp�lÅp�lÅ��d|c=u�p�q'e�prl��·e�s�cºd|c=z�ike|p�_bl��0s�p��Ya�c=e�ï¹cKc=lIp�l�u�pr�"p�u���itz�j\it�bl�c'e�p�q

qKzr_b��u��;itl�uYe|s�cKprd���d|_t�bcKl�p�e�_bd��0_bz�ikdxj�ik�bl�c=e|p�q]y�c=z�u��=g

»�lP�|c=q=e|p�_blñ¾Hï¹cAu�cK�0qKd|pra�cF_b��d]u�i×e�iè�|_t��d|q=cK�ºitl�u itl�itzr�"�|pr�Me|cKq�s�l�pV0���cK���*_bd]j\it�bl�c=e�prqFq=z�_b��u��itl�u itq=e|pr�bc\d|c=�bp�_bl��KgÆð c\e�s�c=l qK_bjH��itd0c\_t��dF�0_bz�itdZitl�u p�l�e�c=d|��z�itl�c=e�itd0� d0cK�0��zre|�Fp�lñ�|c=q=e�pr_bló¨�m

�*_"qK���0p�l��Z�|cK��itd�ike|cKz��A_bl\ô��"��c=��itl�u\qK��d0d|c=l�e|�xp�l\�|c=q=e�pr_blè¨�gr¦�itl�u\y�cKz�u\z�prl�c�e�ï`p��0e¹p�l\�|c=q=e�pr_blè¨�g ¾�g

»�lÅ�|cKq'e�pr_bl}«·ï¹cZ�0s�_�ï£e�s�ike`a�_ke�sÅqK_bl��0p�u�c=d�ike|p�_bl���z�c9ikuÅ���`e|_�i·��prq=e|��d|c�p�lÆï`s�prq�s}d0cKq=_bl�l�c=q=e�pr_bl

_t�Äe�s�cºitq'e�p��bc�d|c=�bp�_blÆï`p�e�sYpre|���|��d0d|_b��l�u�p�l��t�;��z�i9�"�Mi·q=cKl�e�d|itz�d|_bzrctg

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 6: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

áIâ�� ×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&��� î��Aç�é)��ë���ì�ê� ����ÄéAì@�� �Æì�ê�ì æ¡��ìK¢n£�é� .éðñcw���0cwu�ike�iñ�*d|_tj e�s�cÅ�*_bz�zr_#ï`prl�� j\pr�|�0p�_bl��}¤ prl��0e|d|��jHcKl�e|�\�*_bdAe�s�pr�\�2e���u���® ¥¼_ts��t_bsK¤b{;�]¡&[�q8"��:{�"!H�+�"!��$��%�mx¦�¤t¤�¦)(.ý¹ðÍ»©²��p¤t�}�;¦&|?A��B�B�13:;���"!��$��%�mx¦�¤b¤�¢�(�itl�u {"ðภ­ e�s�c=d|j\itz���z�it�0j�i�°

&n§��$13�9L�1H���"!=�$��%�mJ¦�¤t¤�¢O(.ýJ{�¿�±]¿p¤b�}�]»d&9oqGJIK�"���}�"���"!j�$��%�m~¦�¤t¤�¢O(.ýXitl�uñe�s�c�±Mitz�cKit�×itz�iÅ{"e|_b�tc=�S��_קz�ikd|p�jHc=e|cKd;­.�}cKc=�;{�_bz�ikd�¿]a��0cKd2�ti×e�_bd2�bm�±Mi9ïxitp�¨¶p�°b&|a 1HGJM��"N�m�¦�¤tª�¢O(.gU¡�s�c�{�¿�±�¿p¤th���{�v�¿£qK_td|_bl�i#§

�bd|it��sX&y�b���v�JGJMO:{�"�7�"!��$��%�m�¦�¤b¤�¢�(�ï�it�~itzr�|_����|cKud0���itzrpre�ike�p��bcKz����*_bdXc'�bc=l�e¼pru�cKl�e�p�y�q9i×e�p�_tlF����d0��_t�|cK�=gðñc]z�prj\p�e~_b��d��0c9itd0q�sÆ�*_bd�c'�bcKl�e|�`e|_Fe�s�c]_��bcKd0z�it��a�c'e�ï�c=cKlYe�s�c7¥¼_ts��t_bsYikl�u�ðÍ»©²�� jHp��0�|p�_tl��Kg

¡�p�jHc�qK_��bc=d�it�tcZ_t�zS^UXWFSHZF\Au�ike�i·�*d|_tjR¿��w²M»�­*»2{�¸~¸X§©¨�¤A»2�w�X§©ª�°xa�c=�*_bd0cºe|s�p���e�prj\c�pr�`�|��_bd�itu�p�qtýï`s�prz�cSe�s�cKd|cHp���c=l�_b���bsñu�ike�iYe|_}pru�cKl�e�p�� �we|s�c\c%��p��0e|cKl�q=c�_t�xiÅq=z�_b��u�m��|�/©HqKprcKl�eSq=_��bcKd|it�bcA�*_bdºijS��z�e�po§���itd|itjHc=e�c=d�z�cKit�0e2§��F0���ikd|cK�Äy�eUpr�Xi;j\_td|c¼�0e�d0p�l��tcKl�eUu�c=j�ikl�uF_blZe�s�c¹u�ike�i�gÄðÍs�prz�c~ï�c¹u�_]l�_ke

d|c�0���p�d0cSu�ike�i\�*d|_bj e|s�cA{�¿�±]¿ jHp��0�|p�_tl�m�s�i��"prl��Æh���{�v�¿ itl�u �}�]»�u�ike�ièu�p�uwj\it�kcS�|c=z�cKq'e�pr_bl

itl�u�itl�itz��"�|p��JcKit�|prcKd=m�itl�uHe|s�c;y�l�itz�u�ike�it�|c'e�u�_"cK�¼�|s�_#ï iºa�p�it�Je�_�ï�itd|u��¼e�s�c;_��bc=d|z�ik��_t��itz�z�e|s�d|c=c

�|��itqKc=qKd�i×� e9g·ð cAl�c=cKu e�_Y��l�itjFa�p��b��_b���|z��Ipru�cKl�e�p�� �we|s�cA�|_bz�itd��|_b��d|qKcA_t�¹c9ikq�s j\it�bl�c'e�p�qFqKz�_t��u

e�_Aa�c�ita�zrc�e�_AqK_tj\��ikd|cj0���itl�e|pre�prcK���0��q�sIit��q=��d|d0cKl�e9m�ô����Åitl�uÆe�ï`pr�0e9gJ�M�;i·y�d|�0e�y�zre�c=dKm�ï¹c�z�_"_b�ike�e�s�c�h���{�v�¿öz�p��2e��*_bd�s�itzr_Å_tdº��itd0e|p�itzUs�itz�_wv��w¸J�F_"qKq=��d|d0p�l��ÅikeZita�_b��e�e�s�c\d0p��bs�e�e�prj\ckm�it�

q9ikz�qK��z�ike|cKu\e|s�c;qK_bl��2e�itl�ex�tcKzr_�q=pre��·e�d|itl��0pre¼e�p�jHcZ­2¦9«�¥ºjHp�z�zrp�_blF�"j u�p��"p�u�c=u�a��Ae�s�c�i��tcKd|it�bc]�0_bz�itd

ï`p�l�uH�0��c=cKu\_ba��|c=d0�tcKuèprlSe�s�c`p�l�e|cKd|��z�itl�c'e�itd2�Sc��0cKq=e�i�°'m"itl�u\c%��q=z���u�cMc'�bcKl�e|�¼ï`s�c=d|c`e�s�c=d|c;itd0c`e�ï¹_­´_tdxj\_td|c�°~��_t�|�|pra�z�c��|_b��d0qKc=�xe�s�ikexcKd|����e�c=uYï`p�e�s�prlèz�c=�|�xe|s�itlYiSu�i9�è_k��_bl�c�itl�_ke�s�c=dKgUðñc]�|cKitd|q�s

e�s�c�{i�]¡ ikd|q�s�p��bc·�*_bd]q=_bd|d0cK�|��_bl�u�p�l��Y�|pr�bl���_t�~ô�itd0p�l���m�a�d|pr�bs�e�cKl�p�l��Æ_bd�c=d|����e�p�_tlñikl�u p�u�c=l�e|pr� �

e�s�cSitq'e�pr�tcFd0cK�bpr_bl�m�pr�Uitl���ý�0���p�c'e0§��0��lIc'�bcKl�e|��itd|cZu�p��0q9itd0u�cKu�g�ðñcFu�c=z�c'e�cSikl��Åc'�bcKl�e|�]�*_bd;ï`s�p�q�se�s�cKd|c�pr��c=�"p�u�c=l�qKc�e�s�ike�v��w¸ p�l�e|cKd�ikq=e�pr_blY��z�i9�"�;i·d|_bzrch&�576JB/�$�y8"rw�$kDN��"!g�$��%�m�¾t¬b¬�¾�(µgÃXprl�itz�z��bm�ï�c·q�s�cKq��Ie�s�c·±]{��Êitd|q�s�pr�bcS�*_td��bc=q=e�_tdºj\it�bl�c=e�_t�bd�itjRu�i×e�i��*_bd]�|itp�uw�]^ l�cKitd�e|s�c

e�prj\c=�]_t�¼cKd0����e|p�_bl�m�itl�u u�p��0q9itd0u itl��Pc=�tcKl�e���ï`pre|s�_b��e]j�it�tl�c=e|_b�bd�ikj\�=gº¡�s�c·l�_bl�§ c'��p��2e�cKl�qKcA_t�

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 7: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&�� áIâ{ª±]{�� u�ike�iAïxik�;e|s�cFjH_b�0e;zrp�jHpre�prl��Zy�zre�c=d`p�lÅcKz�prj\prl�ike|p�l��S��_b�0�|p�a�z�c�c=�tcKl�e����*_td;�2e���u��bm(c=�|��cKq=p�itzrzr�

itd0_b��l�uñ�|_bz�itd�j�i#��prjS��jÅgè{"p�l�q=cHï¹c\��l�_�ïÕe|s�ikeFitq=e|pr�bcAd0cK�bpr_bl��Km�it�ZiÅï`s�_tz�ctmÄc=�t_bzr�tc\_tlñe�prj\c

�|qKitz�c=��_t�Uu�i9���=m�ï¹c·itq=qKcK��e�e�prj\c�u�p�e(c=d|c=l�qKc=�]_t�J���Åe�_�ita�_t��eMe�ï¹_Æu�i9�"�Kg`ðÍs�cKlIitz�z�p��;��ikp�uIikl�u

u�_bl�ctm�ï�cZs�i9�bcS_bl�zr� ¦#¾·c=�tcKl�e��]e|_��0e|��u��tgM±;_�ï�c'�bcKd=m�it�;ï�cZ�|s�itzrz��|s�_�ïÁa�cKz�_�ï�m�e�s�pr�`l"��jSa�c=d�pr�

�|��©\q=p�c=l�e;e�_·�"p�c=z�uÅi·�0e�ike�pr�0e�prq9itzrzr�H�|pr�bl�p�y�q9itl�e`d0cK�|��zre9g� î � îx�)��ê���ëO«�¢*ìK����ê�ì�ë�£¬�Æì�ê�ìñæ¡��ìK¢n£�é� .éSì@��®­��"é���¢*ê�éÃ�_bz�zr_�ï`p�l��¡?A��B�B�13:;� �"!#�$��%'& ¦�¤b¤t¬<(µm�ï�c·jH_"u�cKzÄj�ik�bl�c=e|p�qºqKzr_b��u��]���|p�l���e�s�cFqK_bl��2e�itl�e2§©ò �*_bd0qKc%§

�*d|c=c�y�c=z�uó�|_tz���e|p�_bl _k�j?z�;:�C�¯)�;1^8"!¡& ¦�¤�¢t¬<(.mXï`s�prq�s it�|�0��j\c=�·q=�"z�prl�u�d0p�q9ikz¼�2�"j\jHc=e|d0�bgñ{�prl�qKc\e�s�pr�ï¹_bd|�ñp��·itl c%����z�_bd|ike�pr_bl _t�`e�s�cèd|c=z�ike|p�_bl��0s�p�� _t�`e�s�cÆs�c=z�prqKpre�� _t�;j\it�bl�c'e�prq�qKzr_b��u��Se|_Ie�s�i×e·_t�

�|_tz�itd~itq'e�p��bc`d|c=�bp�_bl��Km�ï`s�p�q�s�itd|c`d0cK��d0cK�|c=l�e�cKu�a��Aq=_bl��2e�itl�e0§�òI�*_bd|q=c'§ �*d0cKc;j\_"u�c=z��#&y~#�"L�!38�6OL��"!'�$��%�m¦�¤b¤b¢O(µm�e�s�c��|prj\��z�c]q'��zrp�l�u�d|p�qKitz(q=_bl��2e�itl�e0§�ò �*_bd|q=c'§ �*d0cKc]ô��"�Åd|_b��c�j\_"u�c=z�p���pru�c9itz.g�]c=e�itp�zr�F_t�M_b��d·j\it�bl�c=e�prqèqKzr_b��uójH_�u�cKz�itl�u q=_�u�c}ikd|cÆu�c=�|qKd0p�a�cKu p�ló�M����c=l�u�po� �Fg �M�Hitl

æ�«�«'�;��� n°c'��itjH��zrc�_t��p�e��Fit����zrp�q9i×e�p�_tl�mÄÃXp��b��d|cŦè�|s�_�ï`�Aiwj\it�bl�c=e�prqAqKz�_t��u �*d|_tj �M���b���2eƦ#¾�±�¦�¨�mX¾t¬b¬b¬�m ² n³��Äë�� �d|c=�|��z�e�prl��è�*d|_bj iYv��w¸£ik�|�|_"qKp�ike�c=uIï`pre|s ��^ ¤�¦t¦9«Æ_blP�����b���0eº¤�gZ¡�s�c·�tcKd0e|p�qKitzUu�it�0s�cKu zrp�l�c=�

u�c=z�p�l�c9ike|cAe|s�cHqKz�_t��u a�_b��l�u�itd|prcK�Ký�p�l��0p�u�ckmÄe|s�cHd|_te�ike�pr_bl _t�xe�s�c\j\it�bl�c'e�prqSy�cKzruñ�*d|_tj l�_bd2e�sñe|_

�|_t��e�s�m~ï`pre|s iP�0e�cKitu��ócKit�0e�ï�itd0u��\q=_bjH��_bl�cKl�e9m~p��·cKit�|przr�ñ�|c=cKl�gó¡�s�cYl�_td0e�sóe|_Pc9it�2eHe|_P�|_b��e�s

d|_ke�ike|p�_bl p���prl�u�p�qKike�p��bcA_t�xi}d|pr�bs�e0§ s�itl�u�c=u ô����ñd|_b��ctgè¿]�tcKd0z�itpru itd0cHe|s�cHa�c=�0e0§µy�eZqK��d2�bcK�Z�*d|_bj

e�s�c�qK_bl��2e�itl�e2§©ò �*_bd0qKc'§µ�*d|c=c�y�cKzruYj\_"u�ctý"e�s�c�i#��pr��_t��e�s�c]ô����Æd0_b��c�pr�xp�l�qKz�prl�cKuèike�¦b¦�´�a�cKzr_#ïÍe|s�c

cKq=z�pr��e�prq]��z�ikl�ctm�ikl�u}pr�`ª�¾$´��*d|_bj e�s�cº¸~itd2e�s�§©{���lÅz�p�l�cA­21�%��)%�m���_bprl�e|p�l��·l�_teb0���pre|cºu���c�c9it�2e%°'g¡�ita�z�c�¦;�|s�_�ï`�~e�s�c;��d0_b��c=d0e|p�cK�~_t��e�s�c�¦#¾�j\it�bl�c'e�p�q�q=z�_b��uHc'�bc=l�e|�x_ba��0cKd2�bcKu�p�l·e�s�c;�|_tz�itdUï`prl�u µ ì�çz¢n� �

ikeº¦��`�Zgxv�_bz���jHl��;¢�±"¤A�0s�_�ï e�s�c�a�cK�2e0§ y�eM��itd�itjHc=e|cKd0�7¶�·�m�¸v·9m�¹E·9mvºE·�itl�u�» ik�;u�c=e�c=d|jHp�l�c=u

�*d|_tj _b��d·�]_�ï`l�s�p�zrz�§©{�p�jH��z�c%�Pq=_�u�ckg ¡�s�cèe�c=l�e|s qK_bzr��j\l p��·iIu�prj\c=l��|pr_bl�zrcK�|�Zj\cKit�|��d|cÆ_t��e|s�c

�b_"_�u�l�cK�0�2§�_k��§ y�eKm�e�s�cHj\prl�p�jF��j½¼ � cKd0d|_bd�_t�¼e�s�c\a�cK�2eºy�e9m�l�_bd0j�itzrp� =cKuPa��Pe�s�cHi×��p�itzUj\it�bl�c'e�p�qÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 8: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

áIâ�¾ ×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&��y�c=z�u�gg?A��B�B�13:;�l�"!w�$��%&o¦�¤t¤b¬<(��*_b��l�uèe|s�cKprd�a�cK�0e�y�exa��èjHp�l�prj\pr Kprl��=¼ � ý�p�l��0e�cKitu�m"ï�c�jHp�l�prj\pr Kc�¼ �itl�uSe|s�cKlH�|qKitz�c�a��Ze�s�cxy�eJ��itd|itj\c'e�c=d'¹E·�g�ðñcx�*_b��l�uAe|s�ikeJ���|p�l���?���B�B�13:;���"!��$��%^.,�JjHc=e|s�_�u·zrc9itu��e�_ ��l�u���cÅ�0e�i×e�p��2e�prq9itz¼ï�c=p��bs�eHa�c=p�l�� ��z�itqKc=u _bl y�l�u�p�l�� �0_bz���e�p�_tl��Fï`pre|s z�itd|�tc¡¹E·9m¼�*d|c)0���c=l�e�zr�qK_t����z�c=uàï`p�e�sÍd�iku�p�p]_k�S�|c'�bc=d�itz��`�Àitl�uàs�p��tsàprj\��itq=eY��ikd�itjHc=e|cKd|�=g ¡�s�cK�0c �|_tz���e|p�_bl��\ï�c=d|c

u�pr�|jHp��|�0cKu it�·q=z�cKitd|z��ñl�_te·��s��"�|prq9itzrzr�ñ�|cKl��|p�a�z�ctgñÃXprl�itz�z��bmÄï�cÆs�i9�tcYe|s�cÆqK��d|d|c=l�eAþ9ø�ùÍitl�u e|s�c

j\it�bl�c'e�p�qPô��"�C÷xø�ùUm�it�}u�c=y�l�c=u£a�cKz�_�ï�m�itl�uÊe�s�c �*_bd0qKc%§ �*d|c=cñ��itd�itjHc=e|cKd}ò¹m�ik�}u�c'y�l�c=u a��

c)0���i×e�p�_tl ­*��¾b°%g¡�s�c�e�_te�itz�q=��d|d0cKl�e;þ�ô�_�ï`p�l��AprlYe|s�c�ô����Yd0_b��cºqKitlYa�c�qKitz�q=��z�ike|cKu

þd¿ÁÀ¬Â¡Ã�Ä æ ¿cÀÆÅ ò�ÇÈ ·�É Ã�Ä æTÊ ­2¦�°

ðñc\j\i9� qK_bl��0p�u�c=dºe|s�cèi#��p�itz~itl�u it KprjS��e|s�itzJqK_tj\��_bl�c=l�e|�Z_k�xc)0���i×e�p�_tl ­2¦�°��0cK��itd|ike�c=zr� ­ �*d|_bj

c)0���i×e�p�_tl�­*�F¦#°%m9e�s�c=d|c~p��(l�_`d�itu�p�itztq=_bjH��_bl�cKl�e�_t��e�s�cJj\it�bl�c=e�prqXy�c=z�u�itl�u�e|s"���Äl�_;d|itu�p�itzkq=��d|d0cKl�eu�c=l��|p�e���°%g·¡�s�cHi×��p�itz�qK��d0d|c=l�eºu�c=��c=l�u���_bl�z��I_blPe|s�cAi×��p�itz�qK_bjH��_bl�cKl�e�_t�¼e�s�c·j�it�tl�c=e|p�qFy�c=z�u�m

ï`s�prq�s��kitd|prcK�xik�¼e|s�c] Kc=d|_te|s�§�_td|u�c=d���c=�|�0cKz(�*��l�q=e�pr_bl�gXðÍp�e�s\q=�"z�prl�u�d|prq9itz��2�"j\jHc=e|d0�ËÄ�ÌÁ¿Ê¾OÍÎzÄiÎitl�uÅ�|prj\��z�c]prl�e|cK�bd|ike�pr_blèe�s�cKlÅ�bpr�tcK�

þ9ø�ùX¿£¾Oͼ­´¬ Ê ¢�¦�¤�¦#¢t° È ·JÏ n ¹E·JºE· ­µ¾t°

ï`s�c=d|c·e�s�cAl���jHcKd0p�q9ikz��´itq'e�_bd=m�d|cK�0��zre|p�l��è�*d0_bj e|s�c·z�prj\p�e��;_t�¹p�l�e�c=�bd�ike|p�_bl(m(p���Ð n ­µ¾ Ê «�¬t«bª�°'gZ²M_te|ce�s�ike�e�s�c�q=��d|d0cKl�e�pr��p�l�u�p�d|c=q=e|zr�\u�cK��cKl�u�cKl�e]_blÅò¼g

�¹�Yi·�0p�jHp�z�ikd�p�l�e|cK�bd|itz(e�_Ac�0"��ike�pr_blñ­2¦#°%m�e�s�c�j\it�bl�c'e�prq]ô����}÷Íp�lÆe�s�c�ô��"�Yd|_b��c�p��=®

÷xø�ù�¿£¾Oͼ­´¬ Ê ¾"¦#¢tªbª�°2¹E·}º �· Ê ­.¨b°

¡�s�cÆi9�tcKd�ik�bcÆd�itu�p����Z_t��e�s�cw¦#¾}qKzr_b��u��Zp�l ¡�ita�zrcw¦èpr�·¾k« Ê ¨wjHp�zrz�pr_blP��j}mU_tdS¬�g�¦��w�`�ºgP¡�s�ci9�bc=d�it�bcèe�ï`pr�0e·��cKdZ��l�p�eSz�c=l��te|sfѵò`Ò�¿À¦ Ê ¾k«XÓ ¦�¬ Ï n · j Ï n mJ_bd�¦�ª}�`� Ï n gP¡�s�cYi9�bc=d�it�tcÆi×��p�itzj\it�bl�c'e�p�q¼y�cKzruA�0e�d0cKl��ke�sAp���¦�ª]l�¡�g�v�_bjSa�prl�p�l���e�s�cxy�cKz�uA�2e�d|c=l��te|s\ikl�uAd�itu�pr���Ua��·c�0"��ike�pr_bl��;­µ¾t°ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 9: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&�� áIâ�Ôitl�u ­.¨�°��bp��bcK��Ñ.þKø�ùÒQ¿ ¦ Ê ¦�¨dÓ ¦9¬$ÕM�Zm(ikl�u+Ñ ÷xø�ùqÒQ¿ ¦�� Ê ¦�Óó¦�¬ n´� ðÍa�g�»�lÅe�s�cZqK�b�;�0�"�0e|cKj _t�

��l�p�e��=m¼¦�ðÍaÖ¿ ¦�¬$×��Y�(g·¡�s�cAj\cKitl qKz�_t��u i×��p���z�prcK�]prl e|s�cAcKq=z�p���e�p�qF��z�itl�cÅ­FÑH¶�·�Ò=¿���´'Øàª�´%°'mitl�uHe�s�c;jHc9itl\ita��0_bz���e|c`cKz�c'�kike�pr_blH�*d0_bj e|s�cMc=qKzrp���e|p�q���z�itl�c;p��¹¾b¾ ´ gX¡�s�c�i9�tcKd�ik�bc]it =p�jS��e�sA�*d|_bje�s�cAÂZ{�¸ Ù�§ u�p�d0cKq=e|p�_blwp��F¦���¾$´Ký�s�_#ï¹c=�tcKd=m�p��Uï�cSe�it�tcSe|s�cSu�prd|c=q=e�pr_blIjH_�u���z�_}¦�ªb¬P­*p��bl�_td|p�l��He|s�cu�prd|cKq'e�pr_blÆ_t�U��_bprl�e|p�l���°'m�e�s�cºi9�bc=d�it�bcZit =p�jS��e|sÆz�prcK��qKzr_b�|c�e|_Hd0p��bs�e`ikl��bz�c=��e�_·e�s�c�cKitd0e|s�§��0��l}zrp�l�c

ike�¦�¬b¨�´�Ø ¦#¾<´KgJ¡�s�c�ita�_��bc]d0cK�0��zre|�xitd0c�p�l��bcKl�c=d�itz�it�bd0cKc=j\c=l�e¹ï`pre|sè��d|c'�"p�_b���¹ï�_bd0���xq9ike�itz�_t�bp�l��j\it�bl�c'e�p�qHqKzr_b��u��¡&>�)%9��%�m'?A��B�B�13:;���"!=�$��%�m¹¦�¤t¤b¬�ý'?���B�B�13:;�x�"!p�$��%�m¹¦�¤b¤�¥"ý'a �;�3�91����$: �"!p�$��%�m¼¦�¤b¤tª<(µg������c=l�u�p���� u�p��0qK���0�|cK��u�p��0qKd|c=��itl�q=p�c=��a�c=e�ï¹cKcKlÆ�kitd0p�_b���¼it��e�s�_bd0�).�y�e��~e�_Z_bl�cM��itd0e|p�q=��z�itd0zr�Zï�c=z�z�§itl�ikzr�" Kc=u}j\it�bl�c'e�prq]qKzr_b��uYc=�tcKl�e9m�p�lÅiD0���itl�e�p�e�ike|pr�bc�j\itl�l�cKdKg� î � î�Úq��¢*ì�ë��Æì�ê9ì æ¡��ìK¢3£�é� ´éSìK��®­��"é���¢ ê#éðñcÅ�0cKc=� e�_ qK_tj\��ikd|cèe�s�cY�kitzr��cK�·_k�Me|_te�itz�qK��d0d|cKl�eKm¼e|_te�itz¹ô�����mxitl�u _��tcKd�ikz�z�e�ï`pr�0eHu�cKl��|pre��

­´jHc9ik�|��d0cKu a�� e�s�cÆ�*_bd0qKc%§ �*d|c=c'§µy�cKzruó��itd�ikj\c'e�cKdAòX°Zp�lój\it�bl�c=e�prqèqKzr_b��u��Se|_Ie�s�cÆ�kitzr��cK�·_t�`e|s�c

��ikj\cw0���itl�e�p�e�p�c=��prl��*cKd0d|c=uZ�*d|_tjC�bc=q=e�_tdXj\it�bl�c'e�_b�bd|itjH�Ä_k��e�s�cKp�d�it�0�|_"qKp�i×e�cKuZ�|_bz�itdÄitq=e|pr�tc¹d0cK�bpr_bl��Kg

¡�ita�z�cº¾F�0��jHj�itd0p� =cK�x_b��d��|_bz�itd�itq'e�pr�tc�d|c=�bp�_blÆu�ike�iAitl�uYd0cK�|��zre��=g¼v�_bz���j\l��;¾Sikl�uŨAu�c=y�l�c�e|s�c µ ì�çz¢n� �u�ike|c itl�uÊe|p�jHcI_t�Ze�s�c cKd0����e�p��bc c=�tcKl�e ­*c'��qKc=��e}ï`s�cKd|cñ_ba�cKz�pr�|c=u�mM�*d0_bj ¥¼_bs��k_bsv¤b{i�]¡;°}ikl�uqK_tz���jHl « e|s�cY�0e�ikd0eAe�prj\cÆ_t�Me�s�cÆ�tcKq=e|_bdHj�it�tl�c=e|_b�bd�ikj6�|qKitl�g ²M_te|cYe|s�ikeA�*_bd·�0_bj\cYc'�bcKl�e|�Km

ï¹c\s�i9�tcHjF��zre|p���zrcSj�ik�bl�c=e|_b�bd|itj\�=m(�*d|c�0���cKl�e�z��Pa�c=�*_bd0c\ikl�u i×� e�cKd]e|s�cAcKd0����e�pr_bl�gA�;l�i9�b_bpru�ita�zrc��l�q=cKd2e�itprl�e��\p��¹��d|c=�|c=l�e`prl�e�s�c]itl�ikzr�"�|pr�¹�*_bd¼e�s�_b�0c�qKit�|c=��p�l�ï`s�prq�s�e�s�c]j�ik�bl�c=e|_b�bd|itj e�prj\c=�xitd0c

jH_bd|c]e|s�itlÅiHu�i��è_bdxe�ï�_H�*d|_bj e�s�c�c=d|����e|p�_blÆe|p�jHcK�Kg

¡�s�cF±]{�� d0_b��e�prl�cKz��èj\it�tc=��ikq=e�p��bcºd|c=�bp�_blY�bc=q=e|_bd�j\it�bl�c'e�_b�td�itjH�x���0p�l��He�s�cF{"e�_t�tcK�M��d|_ky�z�c=�

_t��e|s�c�½(cKcKj\itl�§ �|c=l��|p�e�pr�tc�Ã�c;»wÛ�Ûv�b¨b¬�¦bg ¢"m��t¨b¬�¾�g¶¢#Ü�Íu�_b��a�z�c=eKm�d�it�2e�cKd0p�l��Z_��bcKd�iZd0cKq=e�itl��b��z�itd¹itd|cKi

e�s�ike�p��Me�����p�q9ikz�zr�}iè�*c=ï itd0qSj\prl���e�c=�]_bl c9itq�s �0p�u�cÅ­.¾�g¶ªÆikd|qSjHp�l���e|cK�]prlIe�s�c·c%��ikj\��zrcSp�l Ã�p��k§

��d0cè¾b°%gÆ�xeFcKitq�s d|it�0e|cKdº��_bprl�eºe|s�c��2e�d0cKl��te|s _t��e�s�cHz�_bl��bpre|��u�p�l�itz�­�¹EÝ�°�itl�uñe�d�ikl��0�tcKd|�0c ­Þ¹bß(° ² n³��Äë�� �ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 10: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

áIâAàYá ×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&��qK_tj\��_bl�c=l�e|��_t��e|s�cMy�cKz�uI­´d0cKz�i×e�pr�tc;e|_Fe�s�c�z�prl�c`_t���|pr�bs�e%°%m�itl�u�e�s�c�it KprjS��e|s¡¸Æ_t��e�s�cMe�d|itl��2�bcKd0�|cy�c=z�u�m�itd0cS�|s�_#ï`l e�s�d|_b���ts e|s�c·���0c·_t�¼qK_bl�e�_t��d|�ºitl�u zrp�l�cZ�|cK�tj\c=l�e|�KgS¡�s�cK�|c·�kitzr��cK��itd0cSu�c'e�cKd©§

jHp�l�c=u �*d0_bjWe�s�cÆ{"e|_b�tc=�F��d0_ty�z�c=�Z���|p�l��Åe|s�c\l�_bl�§�zrp�l�cKitd�z�cKit�0e2§��Y0"��itd|c=�Fp�l��tcKd|�0p�_bl e�c=q�s�l�p^0���c\_t�o@MO�;kh�$:K1HGJId�$:�Cp?�13!��J8�& ¦�¤bª�¥O(.mkï`s�p�q�s·e�it�kcK�Jprl�e|_�itq=qK_b��l�eJj\it�bl�c=e�_ק�_b��e|p�q¼c�e�cKq'e��;­J�)%9��%�mbÃ�ikd�itu�i9�d|_ke�ike|p�_bl�°�itl�uIj�ik�bl�c=e|p�q�y�z�zrp�l��A�´itq'e�_bd=g;ðñcFd0cK�|_tzr�bcZe�s�c\¦�ªb¬�´]ikjSa�p��t��pre��Yprl]¸ itl�uIe�d|itl��2�*_bd|je�s�c]j�ik�bl�c=e|_b�bd|itj e�_Fs�cKzrp�_b�bd|it��s�prq`qK_"_bd|u�prl�ike|cK�Km"p�lHï`s�p�q�sèe|s�c]j\it�bl�c'e�prq`y�cKz�u�p���u�cK�|q=d|pra�c=uÆa��

e�s�cS�bcKd2e�prq9itzUq=_bjH��_bl�cKl�e�¹EâZitl�u s�_bd0p� K_tl�e�itzXq=_bjH��_bl�cKl�e���¹7ã\itl�uÖ¹7ä×gZ¡�s�c·�bcKd2e�prq9itzUq=��d|d0cKl�eu�c=l��|p�e��]Ð�âMpr�xe�s�c=l}u�cKd|p��bc=u}���0p�l��H��jH�qåc=d|c$.��;h�i�ï�m

«$Íæ Ð�âg¿ ­ÞçèÓ]Ç·°zÃ�éê ¿ìë ¹#äë Ùîí ë ¹7ãëKï Ê ­´«�°

_��$:��Q�"��C��"!g�$��%�& ¦�¤b¤t¨<(�c'����z�itp�lèe|s�cK�0cZ��d|_"qKcKu���d|c=�MprlÅu�c=e�ikp�zµgðñcZy�d0�0eMp�u�c=l�e|pr� �tm�prl}e|s�cº�tcKq'e�_bdMj�it�tl�c=e|_b�bd�ikj}m�e|s�cZa�_b��l�u�itd|prcK�;_t�Ue|s�cSitd0c9iAe�s�ikeMqK_tl�e�itp�l��

e�s�c¼��s�_te�_t�|��s�c=d|prqU�*_�_te|��_tp�l�e���_k��e|s�c¼itq=e|pr�bcJd0cK�bpr_bl�ô������2�"�0e�c=j}m;1�%��)%�m�e�s�_t�|c~j�ik�bl�c=e|_b�bd|itjÊ��p���cKzr�

e�s�ikexzrp�c;ike�e|s�cM�*_"_te|��_bprl�e��¼_t��e�s�c]qK_bd0_bl�itz�itq'e�p��bc�d0cK�bpr_bl�zr_�_t���¹�0cKc=lÅa��d¥¼_bs��k_bsY{;��¡�g�Ã�_bd~e�s�pr�����d0��_t�|cSï¹cH���|c·c9ik�|p�z��wq=_k§�d0cK�bpr�0e|cKd|c=uP_��bcKd0z�i9�"��_t��{;�]¡ p�j\it�bc=�]itl�uñ�w�]»;j\it�bl�c'e�_b�bd|itjH�Km�it�

p�l e�s�c\c%��ikj\��zrc\�0s�_�ï`l p�l e�s�c�z�c'� eº��itl�c=z¼_k�`ÃXp��t��d|cH¾�gèðñcH���|cHe�s�c=�|c�_��tcKd|z�i9���ºe�_}u�d�i9ï e|s�c

ô����Å�2�"�0e�c=jRa�_b��l�u�itd2�Æ_blYe�s�cºqK_bd0d|c=�|��_bl�u�prl���±�{�� j\it�bl�c'e�_b�bd|itj ­*d|pr�bs�e`��itl�c=z °'gJðñcZu�_\l�_ke

l�c=cKu e�_}qK_k§ d|c=�bp��2e�cKd�e�s�cÆ�w�]»�itl�u ±]{�� j\it�bl�c'e�_b�td�itjH�Ký�preZp��Zi}�|prj\��z�cAc'��cKd0qKpr�|cèprl ��ike0e�c=d|l

d|c=qK_b�tl�pre|p�_blºe�_]���0c�e�s�c�¹EݺqK_bl�e�_t��d|�JprlFa�_te�sFe|s�cxzrc=� eJikl�uSd|pr�bs�eU��ikl�cKzr�X_t��ÃXpr�b��d0cx¾;e|_]u�d|i�ï e|s�cô����Æ�0�"�0e|cKjRa�_t��l�u�itd2�Æ_blÆe�s�c��tcKq'e�_bd;j�ik�bl�c=e|_b�bd|itj}gU�}_bd0cK_��bc=dKm�pre`pr��l�_te`l�c=qKcK�0��itd2�Ye�_Au�d�i9ï

e�s�p���a�_b��l�u�itd0�\��d0cKqKpr�|c=zr��ý�a�cKqKit���|c�p�e¹�´ikz�z��¼_b��e|�|pru�cMe|s�c]�0e|d|_bl��k§ ô��"�Æitd0c9iF_k��e�s�c]j\it�bl�c=e�_t�bd�itjÅm

e�s�c]u�cKd0pr�tcKuÆe�_te�itz�qK��d0d|cKl�e|�`itl�uèô�����c=�Mikd|c�prl��|c=l��|p�e�p��bc�e|_·��z�it���|p�a�z�c`�tikd|p�i×e�p�_tl��¹prlèpre|��zr_�qKike�pr_bl�g

¡�s�c¹a�_b��l�u�itd2��p������|c=uZ�*_bd�e�ï¹_�����d0��_t�|cK�=gXðñc¹���0c¼e|s�c¼d|cK�tp�_blº_b��e|�|p�u�c¹p�e�e�_;u�c=e|cKd|jHp�l�c¼e|s�c¹l�_bp��0c

z�c'�bc=z��ºa�� q=_bjH����e�prl��Æe�s�cH�0e�itl�u�ikd|u u�c=�"p�ike|p�_bl���ðJ­Þ¹EÝ�°�itl�u�ðJ­Þ¹#ß(°]_t�¹e�s�cHs�p��2e�_b�td�itjH��_t��¹7ÝÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 11: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&�� áIâ�à�àitl�ud¹bß��kitzr��cK�=gX¡�s�c`i9�bc=d�it�tc`�kitzr��c�_k��ðJ­Þ¹EÝ�°�p�lSe|s�cx�bc=q=e|_bdJj�ik�bl�c=e|_b�bd|itj\�����|c=uAp�lFe|s�p��U�2e���u��p���¾t¬·Â itl�u�e�s�c�i9�bcKd|it�bc��kitzr��c;_t�Að~­Þ¹bß(°¼p���¥t¬FÂAg�ð cM���|cMe�s�cMd|cK�tp�_bl\p�l��0p�u�c`e�s�c�a�_b��l�u�itd2�He|_u�c'e�cKd0j\prl�c�e�s�c��kitz���cK�`_t�Uþ=û�ü itl�uw÷�û�üP�bp��bc=lwp�lYq=_bz���jHl��#�Hitl�uw¥A_t�X¡Xika�z�cZ¾�g¼þKû�ü ikl�uP÷�û�üitd0cSe�s�cSe|_te�itz���l��0p��bl�c=u qK��d0d|cKl�eZitl�u j\it�bl�c'e�prqFô����Id|cK�0��c=q=e|pr�bc=zr�tmw1�%��)%�m�þ=û�üx¿�ñ¡òKótÐ�â×­�ô °�óöõ/÷�úb¾itl�uC÷�û�üÆ¿ ñ�òKó ¹Eâ#­�ô °�óøõ/÷×úb¾ _��tcKd}itz�z���po��cKz��Yprl��|pru�cIe�s�c a�_b��l�u�ikd0�bm]ï`s�cKd|c�õ/÷ pr�Æe�s�cñ±]{��j\it�bl�c'e�_b�bd|itj ��p���cKz�ikd|c9i�g

��c=q9it���0cI_t�]e|s�cÅp�l�ô���cKl�q=cw_t��l�_bp��0ctmxþ=û�üàitl�uÍ÷�û�üÊitd0c}������c=d�zrp�jHpre��Ze�_ ��z�it���0p�a�zrcÆ�tikz���c=�

ï`pre|s�p�lPe|s�cHitq=e|pr�bcHd|c=�bp�_tl a�_b��l�u�itd|prcK�=gAðñcHu�cKd0pr�bcHqK_td|d|c=�|��_bl�u�prl��Yz�_�ï¹cKdºz�p�jHpre|��a��Pprl�qKzr��u�p�l��

p�lèe|s�c��|��jH��_bl�z��\e|s�_b�0cº��p���cKzr��ï`s�_b�0c�¹#ß}�kitz���cK�xc%��q=cKc=uI¨b¬b¬HÂ�it���0�KgJ¡~����p�q9ikz�zr�He�s�cK�|c��kitz���cK�Kms�c=d|c9i×� e�cKdºu�c=l�_te�c=u þ � ·�·û�ü itl�uó÷ � ·�·û�ü mXikd|cAd|_b���bs�zr�Is�itzr�¹e�s�cH������cKdºz�prj\p�e��=g·¡�s�cK�0c��kitz���c=��_t��e|s�c������cKd;itl�u}zr_#ï¹cKd`zrp�jHpre��¼u�c'y�l�c�e�s�c�d�ikl��bcK�`�bp��bc=l}prlÅq=_bz���j\l��Q�\itl�uw¥·_t��¡Xika�z�cº¾�gJ¡�s�c=�Æ�kitd0�ï`p�u�cKzr�tm�a���eFe|s�c�i9�tcKd�ik�bcK�Y­Þù ¨b¬ í ¢t¬Å¡xðÍa d|c=�|��cKq=e|pr�tcKzr��°ºitd|cH�|_bjHc=ï`s�ikeF�td|c9i×e�cKd�e�s�itlñe|s�c

jHcKu�p�itlè�kitz���cH­ÞùÁ¾b¢S¡xðÍa�°x_t��e|s�c�u�p��2e�d0p�a���e|p�_blÆ�tpr�bc=lYa��Tú�6Orw�$�YCx& ¦�¤bªt¤<(µgðñcèu�c=e|cKd0j\prl�cÆiwu�pr��_tz�cHz�cKl��te�s �0q9itzrcËû\�*_bdFcKitq�s itq=e|pr�bc�d|cK�tp�_blña�� u�c=e|cKd0j\prl�p�l��Åe�s�c\ô�����§

ï¹cKp��ts�e|cKuÅqKc=l�e|d|_bpru���_t��itzrz(��_b�|p�e�pr�tc�itl�uYl�c=��ike|pr�bc]ô�����g~ðñc�p�l�qKz���u�c]p�lèe|s�ike`u�c'e�c=d|jHp�l�ike|p�_blèitz�z

��po��c=z��Jprl��|pru�c�e�s�c;a�_b��l�u�itd0�Ze�s�i×e~j\c=c=eJe�s�c;q=d|p�e�cKd0p�_blSe|s�ikew¹EÝ �;ü ¹#ß �Eý «�­3ð � ­�¹EÝ�° ü ð � ­Þ¹bß(°|°'g¡�s�cÅ�tikz���c=�\_t�#û}it����c9itdHp�l qK_tz���jHl ª _t��¡�ita�zrcw¾"g ¡�s�c}e|p�zreA_k��e�s�cwz�prl�cÆa�c=e�ï¹cKcKl e|s�cÅe�ï¹_

qKc=l�e�d|_tp�u���ï`pre|sYd|cK�0��c=q=e;e�_·e�s�cº�0_bz�ikd�c)0���ike|_bd`p����bp��bcKlÅp�lÆe|s�c�z�it�2e�qK_bzr��jHlÅ_k��e|s�p��xe�ita�z�ckgðñc�jHc9it�0��d|c;e�s�cM_#�tcKd|itz�z�e�ï`p��2ex_t�(e�s�c�itq=e|pr�bc;d|c=�bp�_tl�j\it�bl�c'e�p�q�y�c=z�uH�*_bz�zr_#ï`prl���~b�"L�!n8�6OLD�"!��$��%& ¦�¤b¤�¢O(.m�ï`s�_Hp�l�e|d|_"u���qKc=uÅòAþ�ÿ�� � m�e�s�c��kitzr��c]_t�Xò �*_bd`i·z�prl�c9itd¹�*_bd|q=c'§ �*d0cKc�y�c=z�u�çèÓTÇ ¿àòzÇÕe�s�i×e

�bp��bcK�xe|s�c�a�cK�0e;zrc9it�2e0§��Y0���itd|c=�xy�e�e�_Se|s�c�_ba��0cKd0�tcKu�¹7ãZitl�uX¹7äMy�cKzruÆp�lYiS�bc=q=e�_td;j\it�bl�c=e�_t�bd�itjÅmqK_tl��0e|d�itprl�cKu\a��Ae|s�c�_ba��|cKd2�bc=u�¹Eâxu�pr�0e�d0p�a���e�p�_tl�g�?A�JM$��& ¦�¤b¤b¤<(�itl�uX�b�;��:{�"!Þ!����"!'�$��%{&�¾t¬b¬t«$(��*_b��l�ue�s�ike�e�s�pr��j\cKit�|��d|c�p���0���ikl�e|pre�ike�p��bcKz��èd0_ba����2e�ï`s�cKl}��d|_b��cKd`i×e|e�c=l�e�p�_tlÅpr�x��itpruÆe�_Al�_bpr�|ctg��¼ikz���c=�ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 12: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

áIâAà|ã ×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&��_t�xòÄû�ü u�c=e�c=d|jHp�l�c=u prl e|s�p���j\itl�l�c=dKmÄ���|prl��w_tl�zr�P��p���cKzr��ï`s�_b�|cHj\cKit�|��d|cKu ¹#ß �kitzr��cK�ºc'��qKc=cKu¨b¬b¬HÂõ­*_��bcKd�e|s�d|c=cºe|p�jHcK��e|s�c�l�_bp��0c�z�c=�tcKz�°xitd|c��bp��bcKlYprlYe|s�c���c=l���zre|p�j\ike�c]q=_bz���j\lÆ_t�X¡Xika�z�cº¾�g

� î �� ´é9í���éKé� �������Úq��¢*ì�ë�{�)��ê��"ë�«�¢´ì@����ê�ì�ë�£��� ��«�ì�ë< ´é)���Äé�M�0p�l���e|s�c~j\c'e�s�_"u���u�p��0qK���0�|c=uSita�_��bctm#ï¹c¹s�i9�tc�itl�itzr�" Kc=u�a�_te|sZprl�e�cKd0��z�ikl�c=e�itd0�]itl�u��|_bz�itd�u�ike�i

e�_�u�c=e|cKd|jHp�l�c¹�kitz���cK�X_k��e�_te�itz�qK��d0d|cKl�eKmbe�_te�itz�j\it�bl�c=e�prq¼ô�����m�itl�uSe|s�c¹�*_bd0qKc%§ �*d|c=c'§µy�cKzruS��itd|itj\c'e�c=d

ò p�lHj�it�tl�c=e|p�q;qKz�_t��u��¹itl�uèik�|�|_"qKp�ike�c=uÆitq'e�pr�tcMd0cK�bpr_bl��=gXð cMqK_bl��|p�u�cKd~e�s�cMd|cKz�ike�pr_bl��0s�p��Ha�c'e�ï�c=cKl

e�s�cK�|c]0���ikl�e|pre|p�cK��p�l e�c=d|jH�è_t��ï`s�i×eÆï�cPa�cKzrp�c=�tcwe�_óa�cPi �kitzrp�u y�d|�0eÅik����d|_9��p�j\ike|p�_bl e�_ e|s�c

c'����ikl��|pr_blP_t�~p�l�e|cKd|��z�itl�c'e�itd2�Yj�ik�bl�c=e|p�qºqKzr_b��u��=®`e|s�cS�0��a�§��Mzr� �tcKl�prqFs��"u�d|_bj\it�bl�c=e�prqFc%����itl��|pr_bl

_t�~iH�*_bd|q=c'§ �*d0cKcZs�p��bs�zr��§�pr_bl�p� =cKuÅ��z�ik�|j\i�g`»�lwe�s�pr�]it����d|_9��p�j\ike�pr_bl�m�a�_te�s}e�s�cºe�_te�itz�ô����Iitl�uwe|s�c

e�_ke�itz�q=��d|d0cKl�eMp�lÅitlÅc'����itl�u�p�l��HqKzr_b��uÅitd|c�q=_bl��|c=d0�tcKuT0���itl�e|pre�prcK�=m��|prl�qKc�e�s�cZq=��d|d0cKl�e;u�cKl��0pre��Ypr��|prj\��zr�\��d|_b��_bd2e�p�_tl�itz�e|_h¹�m�itl�uYe�s�c�j\it�bl�c'e�prq�y�cKzruYp��x�*d|_t KcKlÅp�l�e|_Ae|s�c���z�ik�|j\i�g� î � î ² ¢Þ�°�"é·ìK������ë#ëO�;��ê�é¡�s�c=d|cYitd0cÆ�|c=�tcKd|itzxl�_te|c=ï¹_bd0e|s�� �*c9ike|��d|c=�·p�l e|s�cèd|c=z�ike|p�_bl��|s�pr� a�c=e�ï¹cKcKl j�ik�bl�c=e|p�qHô���� ikl�u

cKzrcKq'e�d|prq�q=��d|d0cKl�eU�kitz���cK�Uprl·�Iv��~itl�u·�]^`�Kmtï`s�prq�sAitd|c¹�|s�_�ï`lAp�lºe�s�c��|p��"e|sAitl�uS�0c=�bc=l�e�sHqK_bzr��j\l��

_t�~¡�ita�zrc·¨�g]¡�s�c=�|c·�*c9i×e���d0cK�]qKitlPa�cFu�p��0qK���0�|cKu p�l}e�s�cF�*d|itjHc=ï¹_bd|�Y_t�~e�s�d|cKcFs�p��bs�zr�Å�|prj\��zrpry�c=u�m µ ì�çz¢n� �a���eSqK_bl�q=cK��e|��itzrzr�ñ���|c'�*��zµm~jH_�u�c=z��Z_t��e�s�cÆ�0_bz�ikdF�bc=l�cK�0p��·_t�;j\it�bl�c'e�p�q\qKzr_b��u��=g ¡�s�cK�|cYjH_�u�cKz��

itd0cYe|s�ikeAe�s�cYô���� p�lóe�s�c}j\it�bl�c'e�prqèqKzr_b��u _bd|pr�bp�l�i×e�cK�Fp�l�®ñ­2¦�°Ze�s�c}itq=e|pr�tcÅd0cK�bpr_bl itz�_tl�c ­*e|s�c

�]^ÕjH_�u�cKz °%ý�­.¾b°�e|s�c�_��tcKd|z��"p�l��}z�itd0�bc'§ �|q9ikz�c·u�pr��_bzrcHitz�_bl�cw­ e�s�c�hÄ{��öjH_�u�c=z °%ý�­.¨b°ºiÅd|cK�tp�_bl _t�

d|c=qK_bl�l�cKq'e�p�_tl _k�;e|s�cÅitq=e|pr�tcèd|c=�bp�_bl ikl�uóe�s�cÆz�itd|�bc%§��0q9itzrc�u�pr��_bzrcP­ e�s�cÆ��^�§�h�{��Rd0cKq=_bl�l�c=q=e�pr_bl

jH_�u�c=z °%g

ÃXprd|�0eKmke|s�c�ô����Sd�ike|p�_b�U÷xø�ù�úb÷�û�ü\�|c=cKlAp�lF¡Xita�z�c�¨Me|cKl�uSe|_�a�c�z�itd0�bctgÄ»�lSe�s�d0cKcxc'�bc=l�e|�M­.²M_t�KgJ¨�m

¤�m"itl�u}¦b¦#°Uz�pr�0e|cKuHp�lH¡Xita�z�c;¨�m�_ba��0cKd0�tcKuè�kitzr��cK�~_t��e|s�c`ô����Hd�i×e�p�_��bd0c9ike|cKd~e�s�iklw¦�¬b¬�� itd|c`zrp��0e|cKu�m

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 13: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&�� áIâ�à �a���e¼_bl�zr�Sc'�bc=l�e�²M_�gJ¨�c'��qKc=cKu��M¦�¬b¬��Á_t��e|s�c�ô����·�kitzr��c�a�c=�*_bd0cxe�s�c`cKd0����e|p�_bl�gX¡�s�p��Jz�ike|e|cKdJc=�tcKl�e

p��]e|s�����p�l�q=_bl��|pr�0e|cKl�e�ï`pre�sPe|s�cA�]^ jH_�u�cKzµm(a���eºqK_bl��|p��2e�c=l�e�ï`p�e�sPe�s�cHhÄ{�� j\_"u�c=zµm(ï`s�prq�sñs�it�

l�_Y������cKd�zrp�jHpreM_blPe�s�c·d|ike�pr_�m�itl�u e|s�cA�]^x§©hÄ{��Õd|c=qK_bl�l�cKq'e�p�_tl jH_"u�cKz.m(ï`s�_b�0cH������c=d�z�p�jHpre;pr�

¾t¬b¬��Æg¹¡�s�p��;p��`a���e]iH�|p�l��bz�c�qKit�|ckm��0_\ï¹cFqK_tl�qKzr��u�c�e�s�ike;e�s�cZz�itd|�bc]ô����}d�ike|p�_b��u�_\l�_teM��_t�|cZitl_ba��"p�_b���;��d|_ba�zrcKjÅg

{"e|��u�p�c=�xa��fP �)R�RD�"!��$��%&,¾k¬b¬b¬ta/(�itl�u ?A��B�B�13:;�¡�"!w�$��%A& ¦�¤b¤�¥�((s�i9�tcº���|cKuÅiSu�p�e(c=d|c=l�e�it����d0_�itq�s�*d|_tj _b��d0�Km"p�l·ï`s�p�q�s\�|��cKq=pry�q;a�_t��l�u�itd0p�c=�¼_k�(e�s�cM�0_bz�itdJ�0_b��d0qKc�d0cK�bpr_blHitd|c;p�l��*cKd|d0cKuA�*d|_bj p�j\it�bcK�

­.¸J»�¡�mX{;�]¡�mıMòU°'g��M� e�c=dZpru�cKl�e|pr� �"p�l��Yu�prj\jHp�l��Æd|cK�tp�_bl���_bd���z�it���0p�a�zrcS�*_�_te|��_tp�l�e���_t��cKd|����e�prl��y�z�itj\c=l�e��xik��e�s�c��|_bz�itd��0_b��d|q=c�d|c=�bp�_bl��Km�e|s�c=�\���0cº�w�]»~j�it�tl�c=e|_b�bd�ikj\�~e�_Sprl��*cKd¹e�s�c�ik�|�|_"qKp�ike�c=u

ô����º÷������`m×it��u�p��2e�prl�q=e��*d0_bjà_b��dÄ÷�û�üÄm�ï`s�p�q�s�jHc9it�0��d|c=��e|s�cUô�����_t��e�s�cUï`s�_tz�c~itq'e�pr�tcJd|c=�bp�_bl�ikl�u

l�_bl�c�_t��l�cKitd|a��Ë0���p�c'e�itd0c9it�=ghPT�)R�R��"!w�$��%q&�¾t¬b¬b¬ta�((c=�0e�prj�i×e�cKuè÷������ it�0�|_"qKp�i×e�cKu\ï`pre�sHe�s�cMï�c=z�z�§_ba��0cKd2�bcKuI�wi9�I¦�¤t¤�¥Fc=�tcKl�eM�*d0_bj e�s�c�u�prj\jHp�l��Fd|c=�bp�_tl��x_t��itlŸJ»�¡³¦9¤�¢#Ü�£prj�it�tctgU¡�s�c=p�d��0_b��d|q=c

d|c=�bp�_tl p�l�qKz���u�cKu jF��q�só_t��e�s�c\ô���� _t��e|s�cÆitq'e�pr�tc�d0cK�bpr_bl�mUa���eSu�pru l�_teFc'�"e�c=l�u �|��a��2e�itl�e|p�itzrzr�

a�c=�b_tl�u p�e9g ¡�s�c'�óu�c=e|cKd0j\prl�cKu ÷xø�ù�út÷������³e|_Pa�cÆ¥t¨��èg�?A��B�B�13:;���"!��$��%#& ¦�¤b¤b¥O(��2e���u�p�cKuóe|s�cd|c=z�ike|p�_bl��|s�pr� _k��÷xø�ù e�_Ye�s�c�÷������ ���0p�l��}¸J»�¡�m�{;�]¡�m�itl�uñ±�ò _ba��0cKd2�ti×e�p�_tl��Kg\¡�s�c=� �0e|��u�prcKu

e�s�d|cKc·u�p���ik����cKitd|prl��k§µy�z�itjHcKl�eMc=�tcKl�e��=m�ï`s�prq�sñik����cKitd�e|_Åprl��b_bz��bc·jS��q�s jH_bd|cZô���� _b��e��|pru�cFe|s�c

d|c=z�ike|cKu}itq=e|pr�tcZd0cK�bpr_bl���e�s�ikl}e�s�cºc'�bc=l�e]�0e���u�p�c=uwa���PT�)R�RË�"!Q�$��%z&�¾t¬b¬b¬ta�(µm�itl�uwqK_tl�qKzr��u�cKuÅe�s�i×e÷xø�ù�úb÷������cù ¾b¢t¬��èg·�¹cKq9ik���|c�÷������Êp��]q=_bl�qKc=��e���itz�z��Iu�p�e(c=d|cKl�e��*d|_tjW_b��dº÷�û�ü�m�_b��d�d|cK�0��zre|�

itl�uÅe�s�c=p�d0�MqKitl�l�_te�a�cºqK_tj\��ikd|cKu}u�p�d0cKq'e�zr�tg`±M_�ï¹c=�bc=dKm(e|s�cKprdMd0cK�0��zre|�M�0cKcKj qK_tl��|pr�0e�c=l�e�ï`pre|sw_b��d

y�l�u�p�l��·e�s�ike`e�s�c�ô����Æd�ike|p�_b�`÷xø�ù�út÷�û�üwe�c=l�uYe�_Ha�c�z�itd|�bckg

{�c=qK_bl�u(m¹e�s�cÅq=��d|d0cKl�e\d�ike|p�_b�·þKø�ù�úkþKû�ü �|c=cKl prló¡Xika�z�cŨIe�c=l�u e|_ña�cÆ_bd0u�cKd0�\_t�Mj\it�bl�p�e���u�c

z�c=�|�`e�s�ikl}e�s�cºô��"�Åd�ike|p�_b�;÷xø�ù�úb÷�û�ü�g¹¡�s�p��;j�ik�tcK�;�|c=l��|cZ_bl�z��Æp�lYe�s�cºqK_tl�e|c'�"e]_k�Xe�s�cZ��^ ikl�u

�]^x§©hÄ{�� d0cKq=_bl�l�c=q=e�pr_blAj\_"u�c=z��Kmkpr��e|s�cKd0c�p��Ul�_��0p��bl�pry�qKitl�eJqK��d0d|c=l�e~��d|cK�0cKl�e¼_b��e|�|p�u�c�e�s�c�q=_bd|c=�J_t�

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 14: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

áIâAà2u ×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&��itq'e�pr�tc�d|c=�bp�_bl��KgJ��z�e�s�_t���bsÆe�s�pr�x�"p�c=ïÊp���d0c9it�0_bl�ita�z�ctm�pre`p���s�itd|uYe�_Au�c'�*cKl�u(m��|p�l�qKcºit�`i·��d�ikq=e�prq9itz

j\ike|e|cKd��bcKq'e�_bdZj�ik�bl�c=e|_b�bd|it��s��ºz�itq�� �0�/©HqKp�c=l�eS�|c=l��|p�e�p���p�e�� e�_wjHc9ik�|��d0c\q=��d|d0cKl�e��·a�c=�t_bl�u e|s�c�0e|d|_bl��k§ y�c=z�uPikd|c9ik��_t�¼itq=e|pr�tcSd|c=�bp�_bl��Kg�» e�d|c=j�ikp�l��M��_b�0�|pra�z�cºe�s�ike�e�s�c=d|c·c'��pr�0e�_blIe|s�cH{���lI�tcKd2�

c'�"e|cKl�u�c=u d|cK�tp�_bl��º_b��e|�|pru�c���^;��ï`pre|s qK��d0d|c=l�eSu�cKl��0pre�� e�s�ikeSpr�Zzr_#ï�m�a���eFl�c=�tcKd0e|s�cKzrcK�0�·l�_teZ�|_

z�_�ïàe�s�i×e�e�s�c=p�d`qK_bl�e|d|p�a���e�pr_blèe�_·e�s�c�e|_te�ikz�qK��d0d|c=l�eM_t�U�Iv��;p���l�c=�bz�pr�bp�a�zrctg

¡�s�cÅe�s�prd|u �*cKike���d|cw_k��e�s�cwd|c=�|��z�e��\p�l ¡Xita�z�cI¨ p��·e�s�ike�e|s�cKd0cwp��Hi �0e�i×e�p��2e�prq9itzrzr� �0p��bl�pry�qKitl�e

��d0_b��_td0e�pr_bl�itzrpre���a�c'e�ï�c=cKlIe�s�cFô����}d�i×e�p�_t�]÷xø�ù�út÷�û�ü itl�uwe|s�cFq=��d|d0cKl�e�d�i×e�p�_t�;þKø�ù�úkþ=û�ü�g`¡�s�pr�

d|c=�|��z�e¼p��~c'����d0cK�|�0cKuèprl\�td�it��s�p�q9ikz��*_bd|j p�lHÃXp��t��d|c`¨�m�ï`s�prq�s\�0s�_�ï`�¹e|s�ike¹it�Je�s�c`ô����·d�ike|p�_��bd|_�ï`�=m ² n³��Äë�� ��|_ºu�_"cK�~e�s�c;qK��d|d|c=l�e�d|ike�pr_�g�¡�s�p��¼p��~c'����d0cK�|�0cKuÆprlAe|s�c`y��b��d0cMik�¹zrp�l�cKitdXe�d0cKl�u(m"ï`s�prq�s�s�ik�¹i��|zr_b��c

_t�¼¦ Ê ¦#¢gØ ¬ Ê ¦���ÓP¦�¬ � gUðÍs�c=e|s�cKd`_bd�l�_texe|s�c�d|c=z�ike|p�_bl��0s�p��\p��xzrp�l�cKitdKm"pre�p��xu�cKjH_bl��0e|d�ita�zr�\d|c9ikzµm�it�

c=�"pru�cKl�q=cKuÆa��\iS{���c9ikd|j\itl\d|itl��b§�_td|u�c=d�qK_td|d|c=z�ike|p�_blAq=_�c"©\q=p�c=l�e�_t��¬�g,ª�¦b¦tm�ï`p�e�s\qK_bl�y�u�cKl�q=c]z�c'�bc=z¤b¤�g,ª��ègI¡�s�pr�Fe�d0cKl�uóqKitlójH_b�0eFc9it�0p�zr� a�cèc'����z�itp�l�cKu prl e�c=d|jH�F_t�`e�s�cè�]^x§©hÄ{��öd0cKq=_bl�l�c=q=e�pr_bl

jH_�u�c=zµmkp�lFï`s�prq�sAs�itzr��_k��e|s�cxô����S_t��e�s�c;�Iv _td|p��tp�l�ike|cK��p�lFe|s�c�_b��e|cKdU�0s�cKzrz�_t��e�s�c`itq=e|pr�bc�d|cK�tp�_bl�m

itl�uHit�~jH_bd|c�_k��e|s�c`�]^ ô����A�b_"cK�~p�l�e|_]e�s�cM�Iv�m��0_Zu�_"cK�Je|s�c`it�|�0_�q=p�ike|cKuA�]^ q=��d|d0cKl�e9gJ¡�s�cKd|c`pr�

l�_�d|cKit�|_tlHï`s�i×e��|_"c=�tcKdJe�_�c%����cKq'e¹e|s�p��Ue|d|c=l�uAp�l·e�s�c`hÄ{��ÍjH_�u�c=zµgÄ»�l·e�s�c`�]^ j\_"u�cKz.mb_bl�c�jHp��ts�e

e�s�p�l��Æe�s�ike�pre;ï¹_b��z�u ikd|p��0cFp��J�]^`��ï`pre|sPj\_td|cºqK��d0d|cKl�e�prlI��d|_t��_bd2e�pr_bl}e|_�e�s�c=p�d;ô���� ­*z�itd0�bcKdMò¹m

jH_bd|c��*d|c=cZc=l�cKd0�t��°;e�c=l�u�cKu}e�_�a�cFjH_bd0cºc=d|����e�pr�tctgM±M_�ï¹c=�bc=dKm(e|s�cFq=_bjSa�prl�ike|p�_blY_t�JþKø�ù�� þKû�ü

itl�u ÷xø�ù®ùR÷�û�ü itd|�b��cK�Zit��itprl��0e�e�s�p��ºj\_"u�cKz.m��0p�l�q=c\_tl�c�qKitl�l�_teZ��z�it���|pra�zr�we�it�kc�cK�0�|c=l�e|p�itzrzr�

itzrz~e|s�c\ô���� _k�`itlóitq'e�p��bc�d0cK�bpr_blñï`p�e�s�_t��eZe�it��p�l��Åï`pre|s preZj\_td|cAe�s�itl iÅe�prl�� �*d|itq=e|p�_blñ_t�xe|s�c

qK��d|d|c=l�e9g

� î � î µ�� ´é=ê{�prl�qKcAò pr��ièe�ï`p��0e�u�cKl��0pre��bm�e|s�cA��d|_"u���q'eºòXÿÊpr��iÆj\cKit�|��d|c·_t�¼e�s�c·_��tcKd�ikz�zXe�ï`pr�0eºqK_bl�e�itp�l�c=u

p�l z�c=l��te�s ÿ�gÍ¡�_ u�c=e�c=d|jHp�l�c}òXÿ �*_td�itq'e�p��bcÅd|cK�tp�_bl��=m�ï¹cIs�i9�bc}p�l��*c=d|d|c=u ÿ �kitz���cK�A�*d|_bj e|s�c

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 15: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&�� áIâ�à}��bc=q=e|_bd�j\it�bl�c'e�_b�td�itjH�`a��}itu�_b��e�prl��Ae�s�cZit����d0_9��prj�i×e�p�_tlYe|s�ike;e�s�cºqK_td|_bl�ikzÄ��^£y�cKzruwz�prl�cK�Mitd0c

�|c=j\prqKprd|qK��z�itd=mÄ�0_Pÿ ¿ÆÍ{û9úb¾�gYÃ�_bdºj�it�tl�c=e|p�qHqKz�_t��u��Km�_bl e|s�c�_te|s�cKdºs�itl�u�mJÿ p���e�s�c\z�c=l��te�sñ_t�

e�s�c\i#��pr��_t��e|s�c·ô���� d|_t��cHitd0qKp�l��Y�*d0_bjWe|s�cAa�it�|cH_t�¹e�s�cAqK_td|_bl�iÆe�_ ¦H�`� ikl�uña�itq���g�¡Ä_Åe|s�c

a�cK�0e�_t��_b��d¹��l�_�ï`z�c=u��bckm�e�s�cM_bl�zr�·ï¹_bd|�·e�_Zu�p�d0cKq'e�zr�AjHc9ik�|��d0c;e|s�p��¼z�c=l��te�s�itl�u\l"��jSa�c=d�_t�(e���d0l��

� ������� �¼p�l}itl}prl�e�cKd0��z�ikl�c=e�itd0�Æô��"�Åd|_b��cZpr�j?�$�}8�6O:��"!Q�$��%z& ¦�¤b¤�¥O(.m�ï`s�_\���|c=uI�|_bz�itd�ô�itd0cZc=z�cKq'e�d0_ble�prj\c%§�_t��§µô�p��ts�eUitd|�t��j\c=l�e��~e�_º�|s�_�ï e�s�ike~e�s�c�¿]q=e�_ta�c=dM¦�ª�±�¾t¬�m�¦�¤t¤�¢�c'�bc=l�e�s�itu\«ºe|��d|l��¹a�c'e�ï�c=cKle�s�cºô�ikd|c��|p�e�cºitl�uñ¦Z�`�ºg�¡�s�pr�M��l�p^0���cº_ba��|c=d0�kike|p�_bl}itz�zr_�ï`�����;e|_He|cK�2e�_b��d;jHc=e|s�_"u����*_bd`���|prl��òXÿ e|_FcK�2e�prj�ike|c � �!�"�!� �0gg?q�$�J8�6O:]�"!��$��%q& ¦�¤b¤b¥O(�u�c=e|cKd|jHp�l�cKu�e|s�ike¼e�s�c]q=z�_b��uq.,�¼d�iku�p����¹p��¹¬�g�¦9«F�`�ºm�|_Iò�# ¦�¥·�`�pÏ n mJitl�uñe�s�c=p�dºq9itzrqK��z�ike�c=u z�c=l��te|s _t�`i}y�cKz�u z�p�l�cHq=z�_b�0c\e|_we�s�c\qKzr_b��uói×��pr�Zï�it�¾�g¶¢F�`�Zg�¡�s����$� �!����� ��¿Cò�ÿ¹ú�­µ¾OÍÄ°'¿f� Ê ª�m�p�lÆd0c9it�0_bl�ita�z�c�it�td|cKc=j\c=l�e�ï`pre�sèe|s�cKprdx_ba��0cKd2�bcKuY�kitz���c_t�Xª�g

¡�s�cIjHc9ik�|��d0cKjHcKl�eÆ_t��?q�$�}8�6O:c�"!D�$��%=& ¦�¤b¤�¥O(Mp��\��l�pV0"��ctm`a���e\ï�cIqKitl ���0cI�0e|d�itpr�bs�e|�*_bd2ïxitd0u

it�0�|��jH��e�pr_bl���e�_��0���2e�p�� �P���|cH_t�¼e�s�c=p�d��kitz���c·_t��ÿÁ¿ ¾ Ê ¢Æ�`� ik�Fièy�d0�0eFit����d0_���prj�ike|p�_bl}�*_bdºitz�z

qKzr_b��u��=g]» �¼i�j\it�bl�c'e�prqZq=z�_b��u}ï�c=d|cFe|_èa�cSi���c=d0�*c=q=e]e|_bd|_bpruwc%��e|cKl�u�p�l����*d0_bjW{���lwe|_Ƹ~itd0e|sPa��

e�s�c�e�prj\cHpreZcKl�q=_b��l�e�c=d|�Hiw�0��itqKc=qKd|ik� e·qKzr_b�|cHe�_P¸~itd2e�s�mJp�eZï¹_b��zruós�i9�bcÆÿ ¿ ¨ Ê ¦K«I�`�ZýXikeFe|s�c_te|s�cKd]c%�"e�d|c=j\ckm�i�*0l�c=cKu�zrc),Æj\it�bl�c'e�p�qZqKzr_b��u ­´s�_#ï¹c=�tcKdºp�jH��z�ik���|pra�z�c9°xï¹_b��zruPs�i9�bcAÿ ¿Õ¾��`�ºg

{���zrpre0e�p�l��Ze�s�c�u�pVe�cKd0cKl�q=c�ï¹c�s�i9�bc�e�s�c�?�$�}8�6O:x�"!��$��%¼ÿ+¿C¾ Ê ¢S�`�£d|c=�|��z�e9m�ï`s�prq�sÆï�c�s�i9�bc����0cKu

p�lYq=_bj\����e�prl��Se�s�c�j\it�bl�c'e�prq]qKzr_b��u ­.òXÿ¼°2ø�ùP�kitzr��cK��prlYqK_bzr��j\lŤ�g

¡�s�cF�kitzr��cK�M_t�M­.ò�ÿ¼°2û�üñitl�u ­´òXÿ¼°0ø�ù �tpr�bc=lIp�l}e�s�cZz�it�2e�e�ï¹_ÆqK_bzr��j\l���_t�J¡�ita�zrcS¨��0s�_�ï³e�ï¹_

l�_te|c=ï¹_bd0e|s��P��d|_t��c=d0e�prcK�=gSÃXprd|�0eKm(e�s�cS�tikz���c=�]_t�]­.òXÿ¼°2ø�ùóitd|cSe��"��prq9itzrzr�}itl _bd|u�cKd�_t�¼j\it�bl�p�e���u�c

�bd0c9ike|cKd�e�s�itl�e�s�_b�0c~_t��­´òXÿ¼°2û�üÄgX{�c=qK_bl�u(m×e|s�cKd0c¼pr��l�_`�0�"�0e|cKj\ike�prqJ�|pr�bl�_bd�itjH��z�p�e���u�cUd|c=z�ike|p�_bl��0s�p��

a�c=e�ï¹cKcKlÅe�s�c=j}g~»�lY_bl�z��ƪ·_t�¹¦#¾Sc=�tcKl�e��;u�_·e�s�c��0p��bl��`ik�bd|c=ctý�prexp��xe�s����`s�ikd|u�z��è�|��d|��d0p��|prl��·e�s�i×e

ï¹c\y�l�u e�s�c�{���c9itd0j�ikl d�ikl��b§�_bd0u�cKd�qK_td|d|c=z�ike|p�_bl q=_�c"©\q=p�c=l�eFp��º¬�g,¬t«}itl�uñe|s�cHqK_bl�y�u�cKl�q=cèz�c'�bc=zÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 16: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

áIâAàY� ×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&��p��`_bl�zr�I¦9¬��èm�1�%��)%�m�e|s�cKd0cZpr��l�_H�0e�i×e�p��2e�prq9itzrzr�\�|p��tl�pry�qKitl�e;d|cKz�ike�pr_bl��0s�p���gJ¡�s�p��;z�itq��è_k�Xq=_bd|d0cKz�i×e�p�_tlp��Mp�lPik�bd|c=cKjHcKl�e]ï`pre|sx?A�F�$kl6O:��"!��$��%w&�¾t¬b¬b¾O(µm�ï`s�_Æ�0s�_�ï�c=u e|s�ike�i\j�it�tl�c=e|p�qFq=z�_b��uIqK_b��z�uIl�_ke�|prj\��zr� a�c ió�|pr�bjH_bp�u c%����itl�u�prl�� _b��eY_t��e�s�c �0_bz�ikdÆike�jH_b�0��s�cKd0ctm]s�_#ï¹c=�tcKdÅ�|��q�sÊ�0e|d|��q'e���d0cK�

itd0cÅc%����z�itprl�cKu(g » eHp��Hitzr�|_ p�l it�bd0cKcKjHcKl�eAï`pre|s _t��d·y�l�u�prl�� e|s�ikeAe�s�cI{���c9ikd|j\itl d|itl��b§�_td|u�c=d

qK_td|d|c=z�ike|p�_bl qK_"c�©Hq=p�cKl�eFa�c'e�ï�c=cKlóe�s�cHe�przreº_t�`itq'e�p��bc�d0cK�bpr_bl��Fitl�u e|s�c�z�ike�p�e���u�c}­ e�p�z�e�ï�g,d=g�eKgÄe|s�ccKq=z�pr��e�prq�°¼_k��e|s�c�qKzr_b��uÅi×��cK�`p�� í ¬ Ê ¾b¢b¢"m�a���e�e|s�c�qK_bl�y�u�cKl�q=cZzrc=�tcKz�_t��p���_bl�zr�Æ¥t¨��èm�prj\��z��"p�l��Zl�_d|cKitz��0e�ike�pr�0e|p�q9ikz(�|pr�bl�p�y�q9itl�qKctg

¡�s�c=�|c·e�ï�_Æ��d|_b��cKd2e�p�c=�&% e�s�ike�e�s�cF�kitzr��cK��_t�M­.ò�ÿ¹°2ø�ùóitd|cZe�����p�q9ikz�zr�}itlw_bd|u�c=d]_t�¼j\it�bl�p�e���u�c�bd0c9ike|cKd·e�s�ikl e|s�_b�|cÅ_t�·­.òXÿ¼°©û�ü�mxitl�u e�s�ikeAe�s�c=d|cÅp��·l�_ �0�"�0e|cKj\ike�prq}�0p��bl _bdHitjH��zrpre���u�cèd|c=z�iק

e�pr_bl��0s�p��Ya�c=e�ï¹cKcKlÅe�s�c=j'% q9itlÅitzr�|_A���0c=�*��zrzr�èa�c�u�p��0qK���0�|c=uIp�lÆe�s�cºq=_bl�e�c%��eM_t�Äe�s�c�e|s�d|c=cº�0p�jH��z�cjH_�u�c=z���prl�e|d|_"u���q=cKuSi×eÄe|s�c~�0e�itd0e�_t���|cKq'e�pr_blS¨�g�¦bgXv�z�cKitd|z���e�s�c¼�´itq'e�e�s�ike�e|s�c¼�kitzr��cK��_t��­.ò�ÿ¹°©û�üAitd0c

itlÅ_bd|u�cKd`_t��j�it�tl�pre|��u�c�z�c=�|��e�s�itlÅe|s�_b�0cZ_t�x­.ò�ÿ¼°0ø�ù p�jHj\c=u�p�ike|cKz��\d0��z�c=�`_b��e`jH_�u�c=z���prlYï`s�p�q�s

i�j�it�tl�c=e|p�qxq=z�_b��uApr�~�*_td|jHcKuAa��Hi�q=_bd|_tl�itz��0e|d|��q'e���d0cM�0p�jH��zr�Zz�p�� e�prl��]_$eÆprl�e�_��|��ikqKctm"l�itjHcKz��Fe|s�c�]^ jH_�u�cKzµg�{�prj\prz�itd0zr�bm"pre`d0��z�c=�M_t��e�jH_"u�cKzr��p�lYï`s�p�q�sÅe�s�cºj�ik�bl�c=e|p�q�qKzr_b��uÅp����*_bd0j\c=uÅï`p�e�s�_b��e

d|c=qK_bl�l�cKq'e�p�_tlY�*d0_bj e�s�c�z�itd|�bc%§��0q9itzrc�qK_td|_bl�i�m��*_bd�ï`s�prq�sÆe�s�c=d|c�p���l�_Ac=�"p�u�c=l�qKc�_t�Äs�pr�bs�z��He�ï`pr�0e|cKu

y�c=z�u��=gXð c;itd0c�qK_bjH��cKz�zrcKuFe|_�a�c=z�p�c'�bcxe|s�ike~_bl�z��SjH_�u�cKz���e�s�ike~prl��b_b�kc;j\it�bl�c=e�prqxd|c=qK_bl�l�cKq'e�p�_tlHprl

e�s�cMc=d|����e|pr�tcM��d0_�q=cK�0��q9ikl���d0_�u���qKc;�|_Fj\itl��·e���d|l��~ï`pre|s�p�lAe�s�c;d|c=�|��z�e�prl���j�it�tl�c=e|p�q`qKzr_b��u�g�» e�pr�

l�_te|c=ï¹_bd0e|s��Se�s�i×e~�|��q�sHd|c=qK_bl�l�cKq=e|p�_blAjH_�u�cKz��Xq9itlAitzr�|_�d0c9itu�przr�Zc'����z�itp�lSe|s�c�z�itq��º_t��d|c=z�ike|p�_bl��0s�p��

a�c=e�ï¹cKcKlà­´òXÿ¼°2û�üóitl�u ­.òXÿ¼°2ø�ùXg)(qI/�$:;�T�$:�CX?A6Or½&�¾t¬b¬t¨<(J�|s�_#ïÕe|s�ikeºj\it�bl�c'e�p�q·d0cKq=_bl�l�c=q=e�pr_bl

q9iklèd|cKitu�p�z��Ad|c'�bcKd0�|c]e|s�c�e�ï`p��2exu�prd|c=q=e�pr_bl�_k��iZô�����d|_t��cMcKjHcKd|�tp�l��ºp�l�e�_F��d|c%§�c'��pr�0e�prl��Zy�cKz�u��Km�u���c

e�_ prl�e|cKd0��z�i9� a�c=e�ï¹cKc=l e|s�cÆp�l�e�c=d|l�ikzxj�ik�bl�c=e|p�qès�cKz�prqKp�e�p�c=�F_t�;e�s�cYe�ï¹_Pô���� �2�"�0e�c=j\�\itl�uóe|s�cKprd

jS��e|��itz�j\it�bl�c=e�prq�s�cKzrp�q=pre��bg

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 17: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&�� áIâ�àJª* î�Úq�+�,� ì�ë�£»�l·e�s�c`��d0cKq=cKu�prl����|cKq'e�pr_bl·ï�c`s�i9�bc`u�pr�|q=���|�0cKu�_t��dJd|c=�|��z�e��Jp�lSe|cKd0j\�J_t��e|s�d|c=c;�0p�jH��z�c¹j\_"u�c=z��&%

e�s�ike·ô���� prlój�it�tl�c=e|p�qèq=z�_b��u��H_td|p��tp�l�ike|cK�Sprl�® ­©¦#°Sitq=e|pr�tcÅd0cK�bpr_bl��Å­ e�s�cY�]^ j\_"u�cKz�°'ý]­µ¾b°Ze|s�c

_��bc=d|zr�"prl��Pz�itd0�bc'§ �|qKitz�cèu�p���_bz�cI­*e�s�cYh�{��RjH_"u�cKz�°'ý�­.¨�°FiPd0cK�bpr_bl e�s�i×e·s�it�·c%����cKd0p�c=l�qKc=u d|c=qK_bl"§

l�c=q=e�pr_blè_t��e|s�c�itq'e�p��bc�d0cK�bpr_blÆitl�u�e�s�c�z�itd0�bc'§ �|q9ikz�c;u�p���_bz�cZ­ e�s�c]��^�§�hÄ{��Cd|c=qK_bl�l�cKq'e�p�_tlÆj\_"u�cKz�°'g

¡�s�cº�����0s�_teM_t�X_t��d`qK_bl��0p�u�c=d�ike|p�_blÅ_t�Äe�s�cºz�ikd|�bc]ô��"�Åd�ike|p�_b�;÷xø�ù�út÷�û�ü�m�e|s�c��´itq=e�e|s�ike`e�s�c�ô����

d�i×e�p�_t�S÷xø�ù�út÷�û�ü e|cKl�uñe�_Ia�c�jS��q�sóz�itd0�bcKd�e�s�itl e�s�cèqK��d0d|c=l�eSd�ike|p�_b��þ9ø�ù�úkþKû�ü itl�uñe�s�c\�0e�i#§

e�pr�0e|p�q9ikz�zr�ñ�|pr�bl�p�y�q9itl�eA��d0_b��_bd0e|p�_bl�ikz�pre��ña�c=e�ï¹cKcKl e�s�cYô���� d|ike�pr_b�\÷xø�ù�úb÷�û�üÍitl�u e�s�cÅq=��d|d0cKl�e

d�i×e�p�_t�;þKø�ù�úkþ=û�üPp��`e�s�i×eM_tl�zr�Æe|s�cZd0cKq=_bl�l�c=q=e�pr_blIjH_�u�cKz¼­.¨b°�c=j\c=d|�bc=����l��|q9i×e�s�c=u�g`���Mï¹cKzrzµm�e|s�c

d|c=qK_bl�l�cKq'e�p�_tlIj\_"u�c=z�p��`e�s�cº_bl�z��Y_bl�c�e�s�ikeMq9iklwc'����z�itp�lYe�s�ikeMe|s�cZ�kitzr��cK�;_t��­.òXÿ¼°2ø�ù itd0cºe��"��po§

q9ikz�zr�Hiklè_bd|u�cKdx_t��j\it�bl�pre���u�cM�td|c9i×e�cKd¼e�s�ikl�e�s�_t�|c]_t�¹­´òXÿ¼°2û�üwitl�u�e�s�i×e�e�s�cKd|c�p���l�_S�0�"�0e|cKj\ike�prq

�|pr�bl _bdZitjH��z�p�e���u�cHd0cKz�ike�pr_bl��|s�p�� a�c'e�ï�c=cKl e�s�c=j}g}±Mc=l�qKckm~ï¹cÆitd0c�q=_bj\��cKzrz�c=u e|_Ia�c=z�prc=�bcHe�s�i×e

_bl�z�� jH_"u�cKzr�ºe|s�ike·prl��t_b�tcÆj\it�bl�c=e�prq�d0cKqK_tl�l�cKq'e�pr_bl a�c'e�ï�c=cKl itq=e|pr�bc�d|cK�tp�_bl��Sitl�u e�s�cKp�dZz�itd0�bc'§

�|qKitz�c·_��tcKd|z��"p�l��èy�c=z�u���prlIe�s�c·c=d|����e�pr�tcA��d|_"qKc=�|��q9itl c%����z�itprlIe�s�c·d0cKz�i×e�p�_tl��|s�pr����a�c=e�ï¹cKc=lñe|_te�itz

ô�����m�e�_te�itz�qK��d|d|c=l�e9m�itl�uèik�|�|_"qKp�ike�c=uHe�ï`pr�0e¼_t�(j�it�tl�c=e|p�qxy�c=z�u��¼_t��ikq=e�p��bc`d|c=�bp�_tl��¼itl�uèik�|�|_"qKp�ike�c=u

j\it�bl�c'e�p�q�qKz�_t��u��`d|c'�bc9ikz�cKuÅp�lÆe|s�p����2e���u��tg

æ�«�«'����� n° æ-�,. ì@³��A��ê� .í-�¢�����/.��A��¢ðñc~�*_tz�z�_�ï�?A��B�B�13:;���"!�$��%;&o¦�¤t¤b¬<(.mk���0p�l���e|s�c¹q=_bl��2e�itl�e0§�òè�*_bd|q=c'§ �*d0cKcJy�c=z�u��|_bzr��e�pr_bl�_t�v?z�;:�C�¯)�;1^8"!& ¦�¤�¢t¬<(Æitl�u q=�"z�prl�u�d0p�q9ikzè�bcK_tj\c'e�d0�tg Ã�_bd qK_tl��0e�itl�e ò¼mXç Ó Ç ¿ òzÇ ¿ È ·} a�cKq=_bj\c=�

ç � Çè¿ í ò � Çèm��|prl�qKc�ÇRpr��u�p��bc=d|�bc=l�qKc%§ �*d|c=ctg�¡�s�cF�|_bzr��e�pr_bl���prlwq'��zrp�l�u�d|p�qKitzÄqK_"_bd|u�prl�ike|cK�;�bpr�tcKl

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 18: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

áIâAàY¾ ×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&��a�� ?���:�C�¯)�;1^8"!�& ¦�¤�¢t¬<(�itd|ck® ¹�û ¿¦¹E·�Ð�·×­.ò�Îb°

¹#ß ¿¦»T¹7·)Ð n ­´ò�Ît°¹]ü ¿L¬ Ê0 111112111113

­´�F¦�°

ï`s�c=d|c ¹Mû�m=¹bß itl�u�¹]üÁitd|ckm�d|c=�|��cKq=e|pr�tcKzr�tm]e�s�cñi×��p�ikzµm`e�itl��tcKl�e�p�itzH­.it =p�jS��e�s�itz�°�itl�uÊd�itu�p�itz

qK_tj\��_bl�c=l�e|�A_t�Me|s�cÅj�it�tl�c=e|p�q�y�c=z�u�ýb¹7·\pr�Se�s�cÆy�c=z�u �0e�d0cKl��ke�s _bl e|s�cÅi×��p��·_t�Me�s�cYq'��zrp�l�u�cKdKý» ¿cØ·¦Mpr�~e|s�c;s�itl�u�c=u�l�c=�|��_k�(e�s�c;ô��"�Hd|_b��cZ­ ü ¦;�*_td¼d0p��bs�e2§�s�itl�u�cKu�m í ¦;�*_td¼zrc=� e2§�s�itl�u�cKu�°%ý�ikl�ue�s�cXÐ54Åikd|cAe�s�c76�e|s _bd0u�cKdZ��cK�0�|c=z¼�*��l�q=e�pr_bl��=g�¡�s�cH�*_bd|q=c'§ �*d0cKcH��itd|itj\c'e�c=dZò pr�ºd0cKz�ike�c=u e|_Åe|s�c

�|pr Kc�_t�Äe�s�c�q=z�_b��uYa��

ò ¿£¾ Ê «�¬t«bª�ú$ºE·98 ­´��¾t°

ï`s�c=d|c�e�s�c�l���jHcKd|prq9itz��´itq=e|_bd�p��xe|s�c�z�_"q9ike|p�_blè_k��e|s�c�y�d|�2e� =cKd|_A_t��Ð�·9g�M� e|cKd�d|_ke�ike|p�l����*d|_tjCqKzr_b��u�§ qKc=l�e|cKd0cKuSq=_�_bd0u�p�l�ike�c=��e�_`e�s�c¹Âº{�¸IqK_"_bd|u�p�l�ike|cJ�0�"�0e|cKjÅmke|s�c~j\_"u�cKz

­ÞÇ ø °�p��xe�s�cºzrc9it�2e0§ �F0���itd0cK�;a�c=�0e`y�e�e�_Ae�s�cº_ta��|c=d0�bc=uwu�i×e�iÅ­ÞÇA°%m�j\prl�p�jHp� =p�l��¼ � ¿ ¦

¨5�;: < ­Þ¹7ã í ¹ øã ° � ü ­Þ¹#ä í ¹ øä ° � ü ­Þ¹Eâ í ¹ øâ ° �>= ­´�]¨b°

a��ójHc9itl��A_t�;e�s�cÅu�_#ï`l�s�p�zrz�§��0p�jH��z�c%�ñj\c'e�s�_"u _t��?��"��C;�"�X�$:�C]aÖ�F��CÁ& ¦�¤��b¢O(µgó¡�s�cY�´ikq=e�_tdA¨5�cKl�e|cKd|�¹�*d|_bj e|s�c�¨ºj�ik�bl�c=e|p�q�y�c=z�u�q=_bjH��_bl�cKl�e��¼�*_bd~c9itq�sè_k�@� s�_t��d|z��Ai9�bcKd|it�bc=uÆ_ba��|c=d0�tcKuÆu�ike�i

��_bp�l�e��;���0cKu�g;ð cº���|cZe�s�cZd|_b��e|p�l�c * Ï×ß A5B�C�Ï ,Æit�M�bpr�tcKlIprl}�0cKq'e�p�_tl ¦�¬�g�«�_t��~g�}�J8J8d�"!b�$��%`& ¦�¤b¤b¾O(µg¡�s�c;z�cKit�0e2§��F0���ikd|cK�¼itl�itzr�"�|pr�~d|c=e|��d|l��~e|s�c`�*_bz�zr_#ï`prl��]��ikd�itjHc=e|cKd|�=m"it�J�tikd|p�ika�z�c=�Up�l·e�s�c;jH_"u�cKz.®x­412°¶�·;itl�u�¸�·Km�e�s�c�z�ike|pre���u�c]itl�uÅzr_bl��bp�e���u�ctm"d|cK�0��c=q=e|pr�bc=zr�tm�_t��e�s�c�q=z�_b��u{.,��i#��pr�Ký�­41312°gºE·9m�e�s�c�d|itu�p����_t�Äe�s�cºqKzr_b��u�ýÄ­4131312°�D�·Km�e�s�c�p�jH��itq'e`��itd|itj\c'e�c=dKm�_bd�u�pr�0e�itl�qKc�_t��e�s�c��0��itqKc=qKd|ik� eM�*d0_bjöe|s�c�qKz�_t��u

i×��p��ZikeZqKzr_b�|c=�0e·ik����d|_bitq�s�gÅ�Ml�zrp��kc\��d0c=�"p�_t���FjH_�u�cKz���_t�xj�it�tl�c=e|p�qAqKzr_b��u��=m�ï¹c�u�_Il�_teZy�eZe|s�c

qKzr_b��uÆs�ikl�u�cKu�l�cK�0�7» ¿ÁØ·¦bgJ»�l��2e�cKitu�m�e�s�c�s�itl�u�c=u�l�c=�|�`p��xu�c=e�c=d|jHp�l�c=uè�*d|_bj �"p��0��itz(prl��|��cKq'e�pr_bl

_t�Äe�s�c�e|p�jHc'§��0cKd0p�cK��u�ike�iAitl�uYc=l�e|cKd0cKuIprl�e|_Se�s�c�jH_�u�cKz�it�;iSy���cKu}��itd|itj\c'e�c=dKg

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 19: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&�� áIâ�àFÔ���`e�s�cZu�_�ï`l�s�p�z�zo§��0p�jH��z�c%�èjHc=e|s�_�uÅq9iklwqK_tl��tcKd0�bcF_bl}z�_"q9itz�jHp�l�p�j\i�m�d|ike�s�cKd`e�s�itlÅe�s�cº�bzr_ba�itz

jHp�l�prjS��jÅm�ï¹cÅ�2�"�0e�c=j�i×e�p�qKitz�z�� ���|cY�|c'�bcKd|itz`�|c'e��A_t�;p�l�p�e�p�itz¹��itd�itjHc=e|cKd0�·p�ló_bd0u�cKdSe|_ _ta�e�itprl i

�|_tz���e|p�_blYï`s�p�q�s}p��;_ba��"p�_b���0zr�Æe|s�cZz�ike|e|cKd=g`¿��Ue�s�c��Hy�eM��itd|itjHc=e�c=d|�;��z����;e|s�cZs�cKz�prqKp�e���» ¿ ØA¦tm�*_b��d�itd|cw��_b�0pre|pr�bc}u�c=y�l�pre|ct®FE4·Km`e|s�cIe�prj\cÅ_t��q=z�_b�0cK�0eÅik����d|_bitq�s�ýpºE·9m�e|s�cPqKzr_b��u d|itu�p����Ký=¹E·�me�s�cZi#��p�itz(y�c=z�uY�0e|d|c=l��te�s(ý�ikl�u�¸�·9m�e|s�cºit KprjS��e�sY_t�Äe�s�cºq=z�_b��u}i#��pr�º­*ï`s�prz�c�l�_ke`�0e�d0p�q'e�zr����_t�|pre|pr�tcu�c'y�l�pre|ctm×ï�cxq�s�_�_b�0c¹e|_�u�c'y�l�c�p�eÄp�lZe|s�c�d|itl��bc¹¬�´HG®¸-G ¨$�b¬�´Kmkd�ike|s�cKd�e�s�ikl í ¦�ªb¬�´HG ¸IG£¦�ªt¬�´�°'gÃ���d0e|s�cKd0j\_td|ctm�ï¹cZy�l�u}e�s�ikeMe|s�cFprl�pre|p�itz��b��c=�|�|c=���*_bd�e�s�cK�|cZe�s�c=�|cF��itd�itjHc=e|cKd0�Ms�i9�tcFz�p�e|e|z�c�c�e�cKq'e_blwe|s�cFd0c=e|��d|l�c=uP�|_bzr��e�pr_bl�g`±;cKl�q=ctm(ï¹cS���0cZe�s�cS��itjHcºp�l�p�e�p�ikz(�kitz���c=�M�*_bd`e�s�cKjR�*_bd;y�e|e�prl���cKitq�s

qKzr_b��u�®�E4·g¿ n�KJ ø�ùXmvºE·g¿£¾DÓ ¦�¬5L`��j}m@¹E·Q¿C¾t¬·l�¡�m�itl�u ¸�·g¿ ¦�¨b¢$´Kgæ�«�«'����� n° Ç ��� ��«�ì�ë< ´é)�����NMO.Áì/³��A��ê� ´íP�¢n���� ² ê#éQM[��ë�êSRA� Ç ì�é=ê� �¢Þ¢n�X�Yì�£ �UT TNTWV ������ê¡�ita�z�c·«Æ�0s�_�ï`�ºe|s�cSy�e���ikd�itjHc=e|cKd|�=m�qK��d0d|c=l�eZitl�u ô����P�*_bd�e|s�cA�xit�2e�prz�z�cF��i9� ¾t¬b¬t¬ècKd|����e�pr_bl µ ì�çz¢n� *

­.¸U�tcKl�e]¤SprlÆ¡Xika�z�c=��¦bm�¾·itl�uŨ�°¹�*_bd�_b��dxï¹_bd|��itl�uÆ�*_bdxe�s�d|cKc�_ke�s�c=d�����a�zrp��|s�cKuÆï�_td|����&|?A��B�B�13:;��"!��$��%�mJ¾k¬b¬�¦bý�aT�;�3�91����$:f�"!��$��%�mU¾t¬b¬�¦9a(ýw?�N<:{GJI¬�"!��$��%�mJ¾t¬t¬b¨<(.gñh�pr�tcÆ_b��dF��d|c=�|cKl�eAï¹_bd|��m�?zNO:{GJI�"!��$��%~�*_bzrz�_�ïàh�cK����p�l��@.��`h���l�u@0���pr�0e2§��|_tz���e|p�_blèjH_"u�cKz.g�aT�;�3�91����$:Ö�"!g�$��%�m�_tlYe|s�c�_te|s�cKdxs�itl�u�m����0ci·l�_bl�§µ�*_bd|q=c'§µ�*d|cKc�q'��zrp�l�u�d|p�qKitz(jH_"u�cKz.g

¡�s�cèy�d0�0e·y��tcÆd|_�ï`�·_t�;¡�ita�z�c�«I�|s�_�ï e�s�c�y�e·��itd|itj\c'e�c=d|�D¶�·�m�¸�·Km�¹E·�m�ºE·Hitl�uXD�ú$ºE·9mUe|s�cl�_bd0j�ikz�p� =cKu prj\��itq=eÆ��itd�itjHc=e|cKd=g ¡�s�c z�ik�0eèe�ï¹_ d0_�ï`�ÆqK_bl�e�ikp�l e�s�cPu�cKd|p��bc=uÊ��ikd�itjHc=e|cKd|�è�*_td

qK��d|d|c=l�e�ikl�uóô�����m¹qKitz�q=��z�i×e�cKuó�*d0_bj c�0���ike�pr_bl��}­µ¾t°Fitl�uÊ­.¨b°'m~d|c=�|��cKq=e|pr�tcKzr�tm¹�*_bdZe�s�cè�*_bd0qKc%§ �*d|c=c

jH_�u�c=z��=gwa ���3�91����$:]�"!w�$��%q&�¾t¬b¬�¦9a�(�u�_Fl�_teg0���_te�c�iº�kitzr��c;�*_td¼e|s�c�q=��d|d0cKl�e9gQ?A��B�B�13:;�Ë�"!��$��%q&�¾t¬b¬b¨<(d|c=qKc=l�e|zr�º����a�z�p��0s�cKuº��l�q=cKd2e�itprl�e|p�c=�Äe|_;e|s�cKprd�_bd0p��bprl�itz@&|?A��B�B�13:;���"!A�$��%�m×¾t¬b¬�¦)(�y�e���itd�ikj\c'e�cKd0�Ký×e�s�c=�|citd0c�0���_ke�cKuÅp�lÆe|s�c�d|cKzrc=�kitl�e`qK_tz���jHl�g

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 20: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

áIâ�ã�á ×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&��ðñc��|c=c�e�s�ike¹e|s�cKd0c�pr�¹�0p��bl�p�y�q9ikl�e¹�|��d|c9ikuèp�lHe�s�cM_bd|prcKl�e�ike|p�_blH��itd|itjHc=e�c=d|��­Þ¶�·�m/¸�·�ikl�uYDxú<ºE·%°'g

±M_�ï¹c=�tcKdKmke�s�c~��l�q=cKd2e�itprl�e|p�c=��ik�|�|_"qKp�ike�c=uºï`p�e�s�e�s�c~�kitd0p�_b����j\_"u�cKzr��itd|c¼itzr�|_b0���pre|cJz�itd0�bctg'?A��B�B�13:;��"!7�$��%�&�¾t¬b¬t¨<(Uc%����cKq'e�e�s�ike�D�ú$ºE·�ï`p�zrzX���0��itzrzr�}a�c·e�s�c·j\_b�2e���_"_bd0zr�ÅcK�2e�p�j\ike|cKu 0���itl�e�p�e��bm�it��prep��·s�cKd|cký�e�s�cÅh�cK����p�l�� �"!��$��%Jy�eAe|_ e|s�cÅ�xit�2e�p�zrz�c���i�� ¾t¬b¬b¬Pc=�tcKl�e\s�it�Hi ¦'§�ðÍ��l�q=cKd0e�itp�l�e��óprl

Dxú<ºE·�_t�¹¬�g¶¨t¬�m�_bd�¨b¬��ÆgSÂ�p��bc=l e|s�p�����l�qKc=d0e�itp�l�z��we|s�c·c'�"e�d0cKjHc·�tikz���c=�]_t�b?zNO:{GJI �"!7�$��%Æ­.¬�g¶¬b¬b°itl�u+a ���3�91����$:¬�"!E�$��%I­´¬�g,«�¾b°]itd|cAl�_ke��|p��tl�pry�qKitl�e�z��Iu�p�e(c=d|cKl�eKg�¿]l e�s�cA_te|s�cKd�s�ikl�u�mÄ_b��d]�kitz���c_t��¶�·º­2¦�´%°¹u�pVe�cKd0���*d|_tj e|s�cH­´s�p��bs�z��Hp�l�q=z�p�l�cKu�°~i9�bcKd|it�bc�i×��pr���*d|_bj e�s�c]_te�s�cKd�e|s�d|c=c��0e���u�p�c=��a��è¨

�0e�itl�u�ikd|uÅu�c=�"p�i×e�p�_tl��Kg

¡�s�c=d|cAp���jS��q�sñzrcK�|���0��d|cKitu prlIe�s�cAq=��d|d0cKl�eZitl�uPô����P�kitzr��cK�=gËa ���3�91����$:¬�"!E�$��%�&,¾k¬b¬�¦9a/(Xy�l�u�kitz���cK�¼_t��d|itu�p����Km�i×��p�itz�y�c=z�u\�0e�d0cKl��ke�sèikl�u�prj\��ikq=e¼��itd|itj\c'e�c=d~e|s�ike�itd|cMitzrz��|p��tl�pry�qKitl�e�z��·z�itd0�bcKd

e�s�itlÆe�s�c�_te|s�cKd�jH_"u�cKzr�KgUðñc�ike|e|d|p�a���e�c�e|s�p���d0cK�0��zre�e|_Se�s�c��´itq'exe�s�i×e�e�s�pr��qKz�_t��uÆp�����ikd0e�prqK��z�itd|z��

ï¹cKz�z�y�e�a�� iP�*_bd0qKc'§µ�*d|c=cwjH_�u�c=zµg ¡�s�ikeÆikz�z�qKzr_b��u��\itd0cÅ�*_bd0qKcY�*d|c=cwp��Hitl it�|�0��jH��e�pr_bl�mxa���e�pr�

0���pre|c]d|cKit�|_tl�ita�zrc�p�l�z�_�ïÍ��z�ik�|j\i[Z c=�tcKl�e��`�|��q�s}ik�¹e�s�c��xit�2e�p�zrz�c;��i9��c'�bc=l�eZ­YÑ\Z�Ò�G ¬ Ê ¬�¦#°'gX¡�s�c�0e�itl�u�ikd|u u�c=�"p�i×e�p�_tl _k�Me|s�cÆe�_te�itzxqK��d|d|c=l�e\�kitzr��cK�·prl e|s�cÆe�s�d0cKcÆ�*_bd0qKc'§µ�*d|c=cÅjH_"u�cKzr�·p��Ʀ#¾��À_t�

e�s�cºjHc9ikl�m�itl�uYe�s�cº�0e�itl�u�ikd|uÅu�c=�"p�i×e�p�_tlÅ_k�Xe�s�c�e|_te�ikz(ô����Y�kitzr��cK�`p��M¾b¾$� _t�Äe�s�c�jHc9itl�g¼¡�s�c=�|c

��l�q=cKd2e�itprl�e|p�c=�Aitd|cÆ�0j�itzrz¹prlóqK_bjH��itd0p��0_bl e�_Ie|s�_b�|cY_t�`e|s�cÆqK��d0d|c=l�e\itl�u ô����ó�kitz���cK�S�*d|_tj e|s�c

�bc=q=e|_bd`j�it�tl�c=e|_b�bd�ikj\�=m�itl�uYs�c=l�qKcZitd0c�p��bl�_td|cKuÆprlÅÃXp��b��d|c�¨�g~Ã���d2e�s�c=dKm��0p�l�q=c�qK��d0d|cKl�e�itl�uÆô����

itd0cS�*��l�q=e|p�_bl��º_tl�zr�w_t�Q¹Ritl�u�ºSm�e|s�cAa�c=�0e0§ qK_bl��0e�d|itp�l�cKu y�e���itd|itj\c'e�c=d|�KmÄitl�uñprl�u�cK��cKl�u�cKl�eº_t�_bd0p�cKl�e�ike�pr_bl�mbp�eJp��Jl�_ke~�|��d0��d|pr�|p�l���e|s�ikeJe|s�cKd0c;pr�JqKzr_b�|c`it�td|cKc=j\c=l�e¹a�c=e�ï¹cKc=l�e�s�cx�tikz���c=�¼_k��q=��d|d0cKl�e

itl�uYô����è�*d|_bj e�s�d0cKc��*_bd|q=c'§ �*d0cKc�jH_�u�cKz��=g

ÃXprl�itz�z��bm�ï¹cFl�_te�c�e�s�i×e�l�_ke]itzrz�c=�bc=l�e��]s�i9�tcS�|��q�swz�itd0�bc���l�qKc=d0e�itp�l�e�prcK�=gMÃ�_bd`prl��0e�itl�qKckm�prl}_tl�c

_te|s�cKd¹c=�bc=l�e`jS��q�sÆ�0e|��u�prcKuèprl\e�s�c]z�p�e�cKd|ike���d|ctm�e|s�c�fbitl���ikd0�}¦�¤b¤�¥�c=�bc=l�e9m�e|s�c�i9�bc=d�it�bc�u�c=�"p�i×e�p�_tl

a�c=e�ï¹cKcKl i×��p���u�prd|cKq'e�pr_bl���a�c=e�ï¹cKcKlñ���Km`�b�;��������� �"!E�$��%�& ¦�¤b¤bªO(Jitl�u+mb��])kh�$1^MO13:��"!7�$��%w&,¾t¬t¬b¨<(Jpr�ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 21: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&�� áIâ(ã�à_bl�z�� ¦9« Ê ¢ ´ gI¡�s�i×e·c=�tcKl�e·ïxik�·l�_teSprl�qKzr��u�c=u p�l e|s�cè��d0cK�0cKl�eA�0e|��u��óik�FpreZïxik�Sl�_teAik�|�|_"qKp�ike�c=uï`pre|sÅiAl���jFa�c=d|cKuwitq=e|pr�tcºd0cK�bpr_bl�g

æÆíS^��� � ¢��;A³_�x����ê#étî »�l�e�c=d|��z�itl�c=e�itd0�ËS^UlWFS[ZY\Fu�ike�iZï¹cKd|c���d|_��"p�u�c=uÆa��\e�s�c�»2{�¡`�X§2vx�`�ÄðñcKaitl�uè²]{�{���v ¿º�}²M» ðñcKaÆu�ike�ita�it�0cK�=g¼¡�s�c�_bl�zrp�l�cMv��w¸ q9i×e�itzr_b�Zpr�¹�tcKl�c=d�ike|cKuÆitl�u�j\itp�l�e�ikp�l�c=u

a��S²;��{�� itl�u·¡�s�c`vxi×e�s�_bzrp�q¹�Ml�p��bc=d|�|p�e��S_t���Mj\c=d|prq9iMprlSqK_"_b��cKd|ike�pr_blZï`p�e�sFe|s�c�²�i9�kitz�^;c=�|cKitd|q�s

h�ita�_bd�ike|_bd0�tg {�¿�±]¿ p��FiI��d|_��0cKq=eA_k�`p�l�e�c=d|l�ike|p�_bl�itz~qK_"_b��c=d�ike|p�_bl a�c'e�ï�c=cKl ¸¹{"� itl�u ²;��{��Zg

¥¼_bs��k_bsÍp���i j\pr�|�|pr_bl _k��»2{���{ p�l fbit��itl�ý]e|s�c {;��¡ prl��0e|d|��jHcKl�e�p��Æi q=_bz�z�ita�_bd�ike|p�_bl _t��e|s�c

�Ml�pr�bc=d|�0pre��è_k��¡�_b���t_�m�e�s�c�²�ike|p�_bl�itz��M�0e|d|_bl�_tj\prq9itz(¿]a��|c=d0�kike�_td0�\_t�Xfbit��itl�m�itl�uèe|s�c�h�_�q���s�c=cKu

�witd2e�prlw{"_bz�itdxitl�u���0e|d|_b��s��"�0p�qK�Mh�ita�_bd�ike|_bd0�tg

Ã���l�u�prl�� �*_bd}e�s�pr�}ï¹_bd|�àïxit�P��d|_��"p�u�c=u a��C�]ÃÄ¿�{�^ ��l�u�cKdP�bd|itl�ePl���jSa�cKdPÃ�«�¤���¾t¬#§©¬b¬×§�¦=§¬�¦#¾kª ikl�u e|s�c}�w��^`»F�td�itl�eAe�_Pe�s�c}�;l�pr�tcKd0�|pre�� _k��vxitzrpr�*_bd0l�p�i�mJ��cKd0�tc=z�c=�tm�itl�u ²M�]{��R��l�u�c=d

{�^$`�¡ �bd�itl�e�²M�;Âp�ק4��¦b¦�¬�gU{�g¶hJg¶f�gx�·g,h~g"itl�uÆ��g¶f�g¶hJg"��itd0e|p�q=p���ike|cKuHp�lHe�s�pr�¹��d0_O�0cKq'e�e|s�d|_b���bs\e|s�c^`cK�|cKitd|q�s ¸U����cKd0p�cKl�qKc\�*_tdZ�;l�u�c=d|�bd|itu���ike|cK��­.^;¸~�]°��~d0_b�bd|itj ikeS�}_bl�e�ikl�iw{�e�ike|c��;l�pr�tcKd|�0pre��tm

ï`s�prq�s}pr���|������_bd2e�cKu}a��èe�s�cº²Mike�pr_bl�itz�{�qKprcKl�q=cFÃ�_b��l�u�ike�pr_blÆ��l�u�cKdMÂ�d|itl�eM²M_�g~¬�¾×«�¨b¤�¾t¨�g

­��aM[��ë��;��í��"é��l�e|p�_"q�s�_b�Km"{�gb�·grm�¡�s�c�j�it�tl�c=e|p�q¹e|_b��_bz�_b�k�Z_k���0_bz�ikdXcKd0����e|p�_bl��=m;sj8"!��}6JBKI;N�8)%Nb@%�m cedgfXmbhJ¦�ª�¦"±�¦�ªt«�m¦�¤b¤tª�g

��l�e|p�_"q�s�_b�Kmx{�g~�·grm�v�g~^�g~�]c9�~_bd0ctm¹itl�u f�gJ�Fg~��z�prj\q�s�����m¼� jH_"u�cKz��*_td·�|_bz�itd·qK_bd0_bl�itz�j\it�0�

c4�0c=q=e|p�_bl��=m�sj8"!��}6JBKI;N�8)%+b/%�mhcjied�m�«�ª�¢�m(¦�¤b¤b¤�g��_te|s�jHcKdKmk�FgrmÄitl�uñ�Sg��ñg�^;���0e9m�¡�s�c·y�c=z�u qK_tl�y��b��d|ike�pr_blP_t�¹j�ik�bl�c=e|p�qSq=z�_b��u��ºitl�uPe�s�cA�0_bz�itdq=�"q=z�ctm�prl�_�6O�}6O:��$��a]�O8J8ml n��JG"!Þ1H6O:/8bm�cKu�p�e�c=uÅa��Y²ºg��Zg�v�d|_"_b�tc=dKm�f�g §��Fg�ft_b�|c=zr�"l�m�itl�uIf�g�Ã�c'��l"§j\itl�m��b_bz.gX¤b¤Å_t�d57�J6JBKI;N�8"1HGF�$�zax6O:{6F�$�Y�"BKIÖoq�"��1H�J8�mÄ��g¼¦�¨b¤�m���jHcKd|prq9itl Â�cK_b��s��"�|prq9itz¹�Ml�p�_bl�m

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 22: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

áIâ�ã'ã ×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&��ð it�|s�prl��te|_bl�m��Sg¶v�grm�¦9¤b¤�¥�g

��_te|s�jHcKdKm_�Sg�m�itl�u ^�g�{�q�s�ï¹cKl�l(m�¡�s�c·�2e�d0��q=e|��d|cAitl�uP_bd|pr�bp�l}_t�¼j�it�tl�c=e|p�qFq=z�_b��u��]p�l}e�s�c·�0_bz�itdï`p�l�u�m�sE:K:�%g57�J6JBKI;N�8)%�m@ieo�m�¦bm(¦�¤b¤bª�g

��d0��cKq���l�c=dKm¹ÂAg�¸�grmJc'e·itz.grm�¡�s�cÆh�itd0�bc��Ml��bz�cè{���cKq=e|d|_b�0qK_b��p�qYv�_bd0_bl�it�td�it��s ­.h���{�v�¿�°%mwoq6O���$�~�I;N�8)%�mhieogfXm�¨�¢b¥"m�¦�¤b¤�¢"g

����d0z�it�bi�m;h~g�Ã�g�m�¸�g�v�g�{�pre0e�z�c=dKm;Ã�gx�witd|p�itl�p.m`itl�uÍ^�g`{�q�s�ï�c=l�l�m��}it�bl�c'e�p�qPzr_�_t� a�cKs�prl�uàitl

p�l�e|cKd|��z�itl�c'e�itd2� �0s�_"q���®p�~_��bit�bcKd=m�±;cKzrp�_b�·ikl�u »2�w�~ª _ta��|c=d0�kike�pr_bl��=mHb/%�57�J6JBKI;N�8)%�mb�J8)%�mHqro�m����¥k¨�m�¦�¤bª�¦bg

����d0z�it�bi�m(hJg(Ã�grm(c=e�itz.grm�� j\it�bl�c'e�prqFqKzr_b��uPq=_bl�e�itprl�p�l��\��d|_tj\prl�cKl�q=cSj\ike�c=d|p�ikzµ®`fbitl���ikd0�ñ¦�¤b¤�¥�m

b/%Q57�J6JBKI;N�8)%�mb�J8)%�m@ied�s�m�¾b¥b¥"m�¦�¤b¤bª�g����d0l�c=e0e�ckmU�Fg�mX^�g�v�gUvxikl�y�cKzru�mUikl�u �ZgÄ�ZgÄ��c=��e|�|_���m~�~s�_te�_b�0��s�c=d|p�q�itl�uñqK_bd0_bl�itz~qK��d|d|c=l�e��Fprl

�|_tz�itd`itq'e�p��bc�d|c=�bp�_tl��Km�sE8"!Þ�}6JBKI;N�8)%+b/%�mq13:lB��}�J8J8�m�¾t¬t¬t«�gvxitl�y�cKz�u(m(^�g�v�grm�f�g�Ã�g��]cFh�i\��c9it���|itd|u�prcKd0ctm@¥·g�Ã�itl�m��·g��Sg�h�c=�ki�m��Zg�²Zg(�}q�v�z���jH_bl�e9m�¡�g�^ºg�}c'e�q9ikzr�©mÄ�Sg�hJgÄ�}p�q��kc=��m~f�g §©��g�ðñ��c=z��|c=dKm�itl�uñ��g�ðÁg�h�pre�c=�KmÄ¡�s�cHj\_bd0��s�_bzr_b�t�}_t��ô�itd|cA��s�c%§

l�_bjHcKl�i�mUj\it�bl�c'e�p�qAy�c=z�u��=m~itl�u c=z�cKq'e�d0p�q�q=��d|d0cKl�e��·prlóitq'e�pr�tc�d0cK�bpr_bl��KgÄ»]§]»�l�e|d|_"u���q=e|p�_bl ikl�u

jHc=e�s�_�u��=m�sj8"!��}6JBKI;N�8)%+b/%�m�t ijiÄm�¨���¾�±"¨��b¤�m�¦�¤b¤b¨�gvxitl�y�cKz�u(m�^ºg�v�g�m�±Zg�{�g�±;��u��|_tl�m�itl�u}�Sg�¸`g��Åq9��cKl� =p�ckm({"p��bjH_bp�u�itz(jH_bd|��s�_bz�_t�t�èikl�u}c=d|����e�pr�tc

�|_tz�itd`itq'e�p���p�e��bm'57�J6JBKI;N�8)%Amb�J8)%�?A�"!Þ!H%�mufvo�mK�b¾b¥�m�¦�¤t¤b¤�gv�d|_"_b�kcKdKmIJºgrmÄf�g�¡�g�Â�_b�0z�prl���m�ikl�uñ{�g(ðÁg���its�zrcKdKm��wit�bl�c'e�prq·qKz�_t��u���ike��0cKq'e�_bd�a�_b��l�u�ikd|p�c=�Km�b/%57�J6JBKI;N�8)%�m#�J8)%�muied�sXm�¨b¬�¦�±�¨b¬���m�¦�¤b¤bª�g

v�d|_"_b�kcKdKm�²ZgJ�ºgrmx{�_bz�itd·itl�u s�c=z�pr_b�|��s�cKd|prqÆ�bcK_"c�e�cKq'e�p��bcYu�p��2e���d0a�itl�q=cK�=mOb/%QsE!�kl6�8)%j�$:�C oq6O���$�xw���"����%A~�I;N�8)%�myogfUm(¦�¬b¥�¦bm�¾t¬t¬b¬�g

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 23: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&�� áIâ(ã ��]cKz�ita�_b��u�prl�pHåc=d|ctm�f�g §©�Ägrm�c=e]itzµg�m�¸~»�¡�®(¸X��e|d|c=j\c%§©�Mz�e�d|i��"pr_bz�c'eM»�j\it�bprl��H¡�c=z�cK�0qK_b��cF�*_bd`e�s�cA{�¿�±]¿�}pr�|�|pr_bl�m{oq6O���$�E~�I;N�8)%�mhieogfUm�¾t¤�¦"±�¨�¦#¾"m(¦�¤b¤b¢�g

�]_bjHp�l��t_�me�Fgrm���g�ÃXzrcKq���m�itl�uY�Zg�»�g���_bz�itl�u�m�¡�s�cº{�¿�±]¿Áj\pr�|�|pr_bl�®U�MlY_#�tcKd2��prc=ï�moq6O���$�E~�I;N�8)%�mieogfUm�¦�±�¨�¥�m�¦�¤b¤�¢�g

Â�_b��itzr�0ï�itjF��mIJZg�mX{�g{¥¹it�|s�prd|_�mÄ·g��}prq�s�itzrcK��mU� g�h~g��ºikp��|c=dKmÄ^�g��Fg�±;_#ï�itd0u�mX�Sgk�Fg�^;cKitjHcK�Km^�g�h�c=�|�kctm�itl�uH¡�g��t_bl\^;_b�0cKl��"p�l��tctm"»�l�e|cKd|itq=e|p�l��ºqK_bd0_bl�itz�j\it�0�Jc4�0cKq'e�pr_bl��¼itl�uH�|_bz�itdJcKl�cKd|�tc=e�prq��itd2e�prqKz�c=�KmvsE8"!��J6JBKI;N�8)%+b/%�mhc�zKfUm�hJ¦�¬t¨�±�hJ¦�¬�¥�m�¾t¬b¬�¾"g

Â�_b�|zrp�l���mÄf�g�¡�g�mXv�_bd|_bl�itzJj�ik�|��c4�0c=q=e�pr_bl��Zitl�u j�ik�bl�c=e|p�qSô��"� d|_b��cK��p�l p�l�e|cKd|��z�itl�c'e�itd2�I�0��itqKckmp�l�~wI;N�8"1HGJ8X6&{ha]���$:{�"!Þ1HG7|��9��}]mb6JBK�J8bmUcKu�p�e�c=uóa�� v�gX¡�gX^;���|�|c=z�z.m~¸`gX^ºg��Jd|prcK�0eKm~itl�u hJgXv�gh�cKckm¹�b_tzµg~¢tªP_t�l57�J6JBKI;N�8"1HGF�$��ax6O:{6F�$�Y�"BKI�oq�"�"1H�J8bm¹�(g~¨t«�¨�m~��jHcKd0p�qKitl Â�c=_b��s��"�|p�qKitz`�Ml�p�_bl�mð it�|s�prl��te|_bl�m��Sg¶v�grm�¦9¤b¤b¬�g

±M_�ï�itd|u(m�^ºg¼Ã�g�m�¡�s�c}j\it�bl�c'e�prqYy�cKz�u��H_k��itq'e�pr�tc}d0cK�bpr_bl��=gJ»Z§F��ike�i itl�u y�d|�2e�d0cK�0��zre|�KmEoq6O���$�~�I;N�8)%�mhi�fas�m�¾b¥�¦�±�¾tªt«�m�¦�¤bªb¤�g

h�itd|�0_bl�mX�Sg�¸�g�mUc=eSitzµg�mÄ¡�d|itqKprl��}e|s�c\e|_b��_tz�_b�t�I_t�xe�s�cÆ¿]q=e|_ba�c=d�¦�ª#§2¾t¬�m~¦�¤t¤�¢�mXj\it�bl�c=e�prqAqKz�_t��u

ï`pre|s�ù£¬ Ê ¦�±�¦�¬ � �tc~� c=z�c=q=e�d0_bl��=m�57�J6JBKI;N�8)%�mb�J8)%A?A�"!�![%�m@f�txm�¦�¤�¦b¦bm(¦�¤b¤�¥�gh�c9itjH_bl�m¼^�g~f�g�m�^�g~v�g~vxitl�y�cKzru�m�ikl�u �ZgU�FgU��c=��e|�|_���m��Jd|_b��cKd2e�p�c=�A_t�;j�it�tl�c=e|p�qèq=z�_b��u��\ikl�u

�bc=_bj�ik�bl�c=e|p�qÅ�0e|_bd|jH�èit�0�|_"qKp�ike�c=u ï`pre|s cKd0����e�pr_bl _t�]qK_bd0_bl�itzM�|p��tj\_bpru��Km$b/%h57�J6JBKI;N�8)%7m#�J8)%�miedrz(m�¦�¾t¨t«�m�u�_bpµ®�¦�¬�g�¦�¬�¾k¤�¤b¾t¬b¬�¦#ft�]¬b¬t¬b¨�¦�¨�m�¾t¬t¬�¾�g

h�cK�×i�m��·g��Sg�m�¿]l·e�s�cx�kitzr��cx_t��ò�û�ü��*d|_tj��~c=q=e�_td¼�wit�bl�c'e�_b�td�it��sAu�i×e�iM§�»0»�g�{���ike|p�itz�^;c=�|_bzr��e�pr_bl�mÃXprcKz�uÆ_k�+��p�c=ï�m�ikl�uY�¼itz�pru�pre���m�oq6O���$�E~�I;N�8)%�mhi5qjqXm�¾"¦"±"«�¬�m(¦�¤b¤b¤�g

h�cK����p�l���m(^ºg���g�m�ikl�u �Sg(�Mg(��c=d|u�prq�s�c=�"�0���tm�»�l�e|cKd0��z�itl�c=e�ikd0�}j�it�tl�c=e|p�qºqKz�_t��u��K®M{�_t��d|q=cK�Km(��d|_b�"§

cKd2e�prcK�Km�j\_"u�c=z�p�l��}ikl�u �bc=_bj\it�bl�c'e�p�qAd0cKz�i×e�p�_tl��|s�pr��m`mb�JGJ�":K!#mb�J8)%����"L$�"��%j57�J6JBKI;N�8"1HGJ8bm�sXmX¥b¥�m¾t¬b¬t¬�g

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 24: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

áIâ�ãJu ×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&��h�cK����p�l���m�^ºg���g�m�f�g"�Fg�ft_bl�cK�=m�itl�uYhJg�Ã�g��¹��d|z�it��i�m��wit�tl�c=e|p�q�y�c=z�uè�2e�d0��q=e|��d|c�_t��prl�e�cKd0��z�ikl�c=e�itd0�

j\it�bl�c'e�p�q�qKz�_t��u��Kmkb/%Q57�J6JBKI;N�8)%�mb�J8)%�m@�jc�m�¦b¦�¤b¢b¥�m(¦9¤b¤b¬�gh�cK����p�l���m�^�g��Ägrm�c=e]itzµg�m�¡�s�cFðÍ»©²��³j�it�tl�c=e|p�q�y�cKzruwp�l��tcK�0e|p���i×e�p�_tl�mo�B/�;GJ��oqG"1�%�mb�"LO%�mu� � m(¾t¬�¥�m¦�¤b¤b¢�g

h�cK����p�l���m¹^�grm¼�Fg~{" 9ita�_�m�v�g~�]c9Ã�_bd|c=�0eKm�itl�u �Mg¼f�gJ¡�s�_bjH���|_bl(mx�wik�bl�c=e|p�qYÃXzr���óprl �}_�u�cKz�c=u

�wit�tl�c=e|p�qFv�z�_b��u���ikeZ¦F�`�³itl�uI{�_bjHcS{���cKq=pry�qSv�_bjH��itd|pr�|_bl��;e|_����0�|_"qKp�ike�c=uI�Js�_te|_b�|��s�cKd|prq

ô�����m�p�l�~��}6�G)%�saiO8"!�lwo@?qsE� ovN<kEBK6�8"13�;k����2_�6O�"�}�"���$!��FC�~�IK�":{6Okl�":����$!h!nIK� ov�;:v�¡13:�!3IK�ú��"�91H6�8�BKIK�"�J�����$:�Cd13:�57�J6�8�B/�;GJ�a���ylwo'�klE_+�y?�6�6O�YC$r'1 n}M��E�qIK�O?��"!3IK�"�����$:�CO8���fjfjw�fecdoq��B�!��"khR"�"�ij�j��zp�\lwo�s o@~�w�t ijc~��m�����g�¦��t¨�±�¦#¥t¬�m(¦�¤b¤b¥�g

h�cK����p�l���mb^ºgk��g�mbc=eUitzµg�mt¡�s�c��xit�2e�p�zrz�c¼��i9�ºj�it�tl�c=e|p�q¼qKz�_t��u��Jitl�uS�����2e�d|cKitj �|s�_"q����K®J²;c9itd©§©¸~itd0e|s

p�l�e|cKd|��z�itl�c'e�itd2�è_ba��|cKd2�kike�pr_bl��Kmqoq6O���$�E~�I;N�8)%�mufvd~txm�¾kª�¥�m�¾t¬t¬�¦bgh�cK����p�l���m~^�g���g�m~�SgU��gX��cKd0u�p�q�s�c'�"�|���bm¹itl�uó¡�gUf�gUÃ�cKd0�b���|_tl�m¼¸~�2e�prj�ike|cKu c=d|d0_bd|�Sprl j\it�bl�c'e�p�q

qKzr_b��uAjH_�u�c=z�y�e~��itd�itjHc=e|cKd0�Uï`pre�sS�*_td|qKc%§ �*d0cKc`q=�"z�prl�u�d0p�q9ikz�zr���2�"j\jHc=e|d|p�qxit�|�0��j\��e�p�_tl��Km�b/%`57�J6gwBKI;N�8)%�m#�J8)%�muied�qXm(¦�¨b¢$��m�u�_tpµ®�¦�¬�g�¦�¬�¾t¤�¤t¾t¬b¬�¾bft��¬b¬b¤��b¢b¥�m"¾t¬b¬t¨�g

h���s�j\itl�l�m�f�g�·grmv¥·g(h�p.m�v�g���d0�bctm{�Fg�§���g�½(s�it_�mK¥·g(h�pr��m�¿Sg(v�g�{"eKg�v¹�"dKm�itl�u ²Zg(^;prq�s�m��;�|prl����_te�c=l�e|p�itz"y�cKzruAj\_"u�cKzr��e|_ºzrc9itd0lAita�_b��e¼v��w¸ñqK_bd0_bl�itz�q=_bl�e�c%��e¹itl�uHq=_bl��0c)0���cKl�qKcK�=mvsEkl�"��1HGF�$:sE8"!Þ�}6O:{6OkD1HGF�$�{oq6�G"1H�"!�NdaÖ�J�"!�13:;��mkfvdjd�m�¾k¬b¬�¾�g

h���l�u@0���pr�0eKm�{�grm��}it�bl�c'e�_bs��"u�d|_t�0e�i×e�p�q�y�c=z�u��=m�sE�}M$%h|�N�8)%�m � m�¨$��¦bm�¦�¤b¢t¬�gh��"l�q�s�m���g�f�g�m��Äg�f�g��wikq9²Mc=p�q=ctm�{�g��·gb��l�e|p�_"q�s�_b�Km�¡�g�±ºg�½(��d0a���q�s�c=l�m�ikl�uHh~g��Zg�ÃXpr�|��m���d|cKit�t_t��e

jH_�u�c=zz¨,d|c9ikz�p��0j�.�®U� q=_bj\��itd|pr�|_blÆe�_A_ba��|cKd2�kike�pr_bl��Km{�#�$:K�Áo@ú���?$l�aÖ�J�"!Þ13:;��m�¾t¬b¬�¾"gh��"l�q�s�mI�Mg�f�g�mÅ¡�g\±ºg\½(��d|a���q�s�cKl�mwhJgH�ZgAÃXp��0��mwitl�u {�gA�·gA��l�e�pr_�q�s�_b�KmÅ»�l�e�cKd0l�itzY�0e|d|��q%§

e���d|c _t�Åj\it�bl�c'e�p�q qKzr_b��u��=®õ�Jz�it�0j�i ikl�uÕqK_bjH��_b�|p�e�p�_tl�m�b/% 57�J6JBKI;N�8)%lmb�J8)%�m�ied�qXm}¦#¾t¨b¤�mu�_bp.®r¦9¬�gr¦9¬�¾t¤�¤b¾k¬b¬�¾bft��¬b¬b¤�¢t¤�¦bm"¾t¬b¬b¨�g

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 25: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

×�"�äx���A�"åF�"!�)~����k�����rå�������ä¹� ����"å����S��t����&�� áIâ(ã���}prq��tc=��m��Sg�hJg�m�¡�s�cF±Mitz�cKit�×itz�iS{"e�_b�kcK�M��_bz�itd|prj\c'e�c=dKm�oq6O���$�E~�I;N�8)%�mh��z(m�¾b¾k¨�±�¾t¨bª�m(¦�¤bªb¢�g�}��zrz�pr��itl�m�¡�g�m�v�g�¡�g�^`���0�|cKzrzµm�itl�uÅf�g�·g�h���s�j�itl�l�m�{�_bz�itd�q'�"qKz�c�c=�b_tz���e|p�_blÆ_t��e|s�c��0e|d|��q'e���d0c�_t�

j\it�bl�c'e�p�q�qKz�_t��u��`p�lÆe�s�cºprl�l�c=d�s�cKzrp�_b�0��s�cKd0ctm�57�J6JBKI;N�8)%Amb�J8)%�?A�"!Þ!H%�mufec�m�¾t¤b¢t¤�m�¦�¤t¤bª�g�}��zrz�pr��itl�m"¡�grm�v�g�¡�g�^;���0�|c=z�zµm�itl�u}f�g�·g�h���s�j\itl�l�m�»�l�e|cKd|��z�itl�c'e�itd2�Æj\it�bl�c'e�p�qMqKzr_b��u��=®�{�e�ike|p��2§

e�prq9itz(��ike|e|cKd0l��;itl�uÅd�itu�p�itz��kitd0p�ike|p�_bl��KmKs#C$LO%�o�B/�;GJ�jmb�J8)%�mkfvo�m�ªb¬�¦"±�ªt¬���m�¾k¬b¬b¬�g�}��zrz�pr��itl�m�¡�grm�v�g�¡�g�^`���|�0cKzrzµm���g�f�g(�Ml�u�cKd0�|_bl(m�itl�u �ñg�±ºg(�MqK�h�l�i�m��}��zre|p���zrcZ�0��itq=cKqKd|ik� e�ô����d|_t��cxjH_"u�cKzrp�l��M_t��e�s�c���it�0e|p�z�zrcx��i9�Zj�it�tl�c=e|p�q�q=z�_b��u�m57�J6JBKI;N�8)%vmb�J8)%v?A�"!Þ!H%�mUfaqXmb«b«�¦#¥�m�¾k¬b¬�¦9a�g

²Mc=z�u�c=dKm�f�g��Zgrm�ikl�uP^�g��}cKitu�m��³�|prj\��zrc'�ÅjHc=e|s�_�u}�*_bdM�*��l�q=e�pr_blwjHp�l�p�jHp���i×e�p�_tl�m'_�6OkEB��;!4�"��b@%�m��m�¨b¬bª�m(¦�¤���¢�g

¿]�bp�z��"p�ctm×�·g�ðÁgrmtc=eXitzµg�m�{"ðà¸�mkiMq=_bj\��d|cKs�cKl��0pr�bc���z�it�0j�i`p�l��0e�d0��jHcKl�e��*_tdÄe|s�c¹ðÍ»©²M� �|��itq=cKq=d�ik� eKm

o�B/�;GJ�=oqG"1�%Amb�"LO%�m�� � m�¢b¢�m(¦�¤b¤�¢�g��c'��e��|_���m;�Fg¼�Fg�m`itl�u ^�g¹v�gxvxitl�y�cKzru�m;{�_bz�itdAj�it�tl�c=e|p�qYy�cKzru��èitl�u �bc=_bj�ik�bl�c=e|p�qÅc=�tcKl�e��=m�b/%57�J6JBKI;N�8)%�m#�J8)%�muiedjo�m�¾b¢�¦�¤�¦"±�¾b¢�¦�¤b¥�m�¾k¬b¬�¦bg

��c'��e��|_���mx�ZgJ�Fg�m�^�g~v�g~vxitl�y�cKzru�m�ikl�u ¡�gU^ºg¼�}c'e�qKitzr�©m¼h�ike�p�e���u�p�l�itz~�kitd|p�ike�pr_bl _t�Ms�c=z�p�q=pre��ñ_t�

��s�_ke�_b�0��s�cKd0p�q�j\it�bl�c'e�p�qMy�cKzru��Km�sE8"!Þ�}6JBKI;N�8)%+b/%�?��"!�!H%�mUtjt�d�m�¦�¬b¤�m�¦�¤b¤�¢"g�Jd|c=�|�Km�ðÁg(±ºgrm�{�g��Zg(¡ÄcK���k_bz��0���bm(ðÁg�¡�g_�~c'e|e�c=d|zrp�l���m�itl�uP��g���g�ÃXz�itl�l�cKd2�bmh?E�;kl�"�"1HGF�$�qmb�JG"1yBK�J813:I|Q§�m=�qmQsm?�zjz(m�¾kl�uÅcKu�g�m�vxitjSa�d0p�u��tc��Ml�p���g��Jd0cK�|�=m�²Mc=ïf¥¼_bd|��m�¦�¤t¤�¾�g

^`�� Kj\itp���prl�m �Zgrmà{�g �witd2e�prl�m itl�u��Sgñ±;��mà{�pr�bl��Á_t� j\it�bl�c'e�prqÕs�cKzrp�qKp�e�� p�l p�l�e|cKd|��z�itl�§

c=e�itd0� j\it�|�Êc4�0cKq'e�pr_bl�� itl�u it�|�0_�q=p�ike|cKu ��d|_bjHp�l�c=l�qKc=�Km�b/% 57�J6JBKI;N�8)%Ömb�J8)%�m�ied�qXm ¦�¬b¤���mu�_bp.®r¦9¬�gr¦9¬�¾t¤�¤b¾k¬b¬�¾bft��¬b¬b¤�¢tªtª�m"¾t¬b¬b¨�g

{�q�s�c=d|d0cKdKmÄ�Äg�±Zg�m�c=eºikzµg�m(¡�s�c\{�_bz�itd�¿]�0qKp�zrz�ike|p�_bl��;»�l��tcK�0e|p���i×e�p�_tlw§M�}p�q�s�cKz��0_bl �]_b����zrcKdM»�j�it�tcKdKm

oq6O���$�E~�I;N�8)%�mhieogfXm(¦#¾t¤�±�¦�ªbª�m(¦�¤b¤�¢�g

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎbÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ"ÓÕÔ×ÖUØIÙ"Ú�ÚbÛ~ØPܼݩÚ"ÙkÞ�ß ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 26: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

áIâ�ã"� k���ä����H�"åF��!�)~����×���"��å�������ä�� �����å����S�"b����&(�{�����j�ikl�p�q�s�mJ�ZgrmUitl�u ��g�ðÁgUh�pre|cK�=m~{"e�_t�tcK�·��d|_ty�zrcèitl�itzr�"�|pr�Sitl�u �bc=q=e�_td·j�it�tl�c=e|p�qAy�cKzru��Kg�p~§

p�l��bc=d|�|pr_blÅ_t�X��s�_te�_t�|��s�c=d|prqºzrp�l�c=�KmvsE8"!��J6JBKI;N�8)%+b/%�m@s5fjfUm�«�¥t¨�±"«�ªb¾�m(¦�¤tª�¥�g{���a�d|itj�ikl�p�itl(m��Ägrm�itl�uè�Ag"�Äg��]c=d|ctm�{�_b��d|qKcMd|c=�bp�_bl��¹_t��qK_bd0_bl�itz�j\it�|�¼c4�0c=q=e�pr_bl��=mKsE8"!Þ�}6JBKI;N�8)%ub/%�mceo�i�m�¨�¥b¾�±�¨b¤�¢�m�¾t¬b¬�¦tg

¡�pre�_���mr�Fg�{�grm�itl�uÆ�Äg��)�c=j\_b��z�p�l(m��xit�|prqMe|_b��_tz�_b�t�A_k��e�ï`p��2e�cKuÆj\it�bl�c=e�prqMq=_bl�y��t��d�ike|p�_bl���p�l\�|_bz�itdô�itd|c=�Km�sE8"!Þ�}6O:�%sE8"!Þ�}6JBKI;N�8)%�m@sacji�m�¥t¬b¥�m�¦�¤b¤t¤�g

¡��|��l�c'e�i�m�{�g�m�c'e¹itzµg�mb¡�s�c�{�_t� e��M§ d�i9�·¡ÄcKzrcK�|q=_b��c;�*_bdUe|s�cM{�¿�h��]^x§��Íj\pr�|�0p�_bl�m�oq6O���$��~�I;N�8)%�m_i5sro�m¨�¥�±���¥"m�¦�¤b¤�¦tg

ð c=a�a�m��Sg�Ã�g�m�v�_bd0_bl�itz�j�it�0��c��0cKq=e|p�_bl��K®¼¿]d|pr�bp�l��=m�c'�b_bzr��e�pr_blèikl�uÆd|_bzrc�prlè�|��ikqKc]ï¹c9ike|s�cKd=mN��l�l�l�@�Y�$:/8)%A~����O8"kh�hoqG"1�%�mkfaqXm(¦#¥t¤�¢�m�¾t¬b¬b¬�g

ð c=a�a�m��Sg�Ã�g�m�^ºg���g�h�cK����p�l���m�hJg�Ã�g�����d|z�it��i�m�v�g�¸�g(�]cKÃX_bd|c=�0eKm(�Sg�¸�g�hÄikd|�|_tl�m�{�g�Ã�g��wikd0e�prl�m

{�g��Äg��Jzr��l��tc'e|eKm�itl�u��Sg��ñg�^`���2e9m�¡�s�c�_bd0p��bprl\ikl�uèu�c'�bcKzr_b��jHcKl�ex_k��e�s�c]�wi9�w¦9¤b¤�¥�j�it�tl�c=e|p�q

qKz�_t��u�m�b/%Q57�J6JBKI;N�8)%�m#�J8)%�muied�c�m�¾b¥J¾b¢"¦bm�¾t¬b¬t¬ta�g½(s�itl���m(�ñg�m�itl�uI��g�v�g(h�_#ï�m��wit�bl�c=e�prqZô��"�Ic=j\c=d|�bc=l�qKcSprl�e�_\e|s�cS�0_bz�itd;qK_td|_bl�i�g�»0»|»�g�¡�s�cSd|_tz�c

_t�Xj\it�bl�c=e�prq�s�cKzrp�q=pre��\qK_bl��0cKd2�ti×e�p�_tl�m�sj8"!��}6JBKI;N�8)%+b/%�m@c5qKt�m�«�¥t¤�m�¾t¬b¬b¨�g

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎtÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ�Ó Ô#ÖUØ Ù�Ú�Ú�Û~ØwܹݩÚ�ÙkÞ�ß ÇCÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 27: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

k���ä����H�"åF��!�)~����×���"��å��\���]ä�� �����å����S�"b����&(� áIâ�ã�ª

010

20

3040

|B|

-90-45

0

4590

Θ

090

180

270360

Φ

01020304050

v th

500600700800

Vsw

05

10152025

n p

Aug 12 Aug 13 Aug 14Date, 2000

-200

-100

0

Dst

² �³���ëO� � î {���jHj�itd2� ��z�_teè_t�ºqKz�_t��uÍc=�bc=l�ew²;_�gö¦�¾�mM�0s�_�ï`p�l�� i jH_�u�cKzMy�eY_t��e�����p�q9ikzj0���itz�p�e��­�¼ � ú$¹ �· ¿ ¬ Ê ¬�¾k«�°�e�_èj\it�bl�c=e�prqZy�c=z�uPj\it�bl�p�e���u�cè­Jóø¹�ó °'m(u�p�d|c=q=e|p�_bl ­\�Sm�÷�°]itl�uIe|s�cSq=_bl��0e�itl�e0§�ò �*_bd|q=c'§�*d|cKc�y�c=z�uÅy�eF­´�|jH_"_te�sYqK��d0�bc=��°%g�¡�s�cZzr_�ï�c=dM«H��itl�c=z��;itd0ctm�d|c=�|��cKq'e�pr�tcKz��bm���d|_te|_blYe�s�c=d|j\itz��|��cKc=u�m�d|itu�p�itz

�|_bz�itd�ï`prl�uSqK_tj\��_bl�c=l�eKm���d|_ke�_blSu�cKl��0pre��·ikl�u��������bc=_bj�ik�bl�c=e|p�q¹�0e�_td|j p�l�u�c%��gy �UDWFSHZF\]u�i×e�i]it�X_ba��|c=d0�tcKua���ðÍp�l�u}ike�¦��`�Zg��~c=d0e�prq9itz(u�it�|s�cKuwzrp�l�c=��u�cKzrp�l�cKike�c]e|s�c�qKzr_b��uYa�_t��l�u�itd0p�c=�Kg

ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ ÎtÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ�Ó Ô#ÖUØPÙ�Ú�ÚbÛ¼ØIܹݩÚ�ÙkÞ�ß ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ

Page 28: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

áIâ�ã"¾ k���ä����H�"åF��!�)~����×���"��å�������ä�� �����å����S�"b����&(�

-500 -450 -400 -350 -300 -250 -200X (arcsecs)

-500

-450

-400

-350

-300

-250

-200

Y (

arcs

ecs)

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 10 20 30 40 50 600

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 10 20 30 40 50 600

10

20

30

40

50

60

² �³���ëO� � î {�itjH��zrc�¥¼_bs��k_bsó{;��¡ �Mzµg�¦Hprj�ik�bc·itl�u �w�]»Mj�it�tl�c=e|_b�bd�ikj _��bc=d|z�i�� ­*z�c'� e���itl�c=z °�itl�u

itl�l�_te�ike�c=u ±�{��C�bc=q=e|_bdZj\it�bl�c=e�_t�bd�itj ­´d0p��bs�e���itl�cKz °M�*_td�e|s�cHitl�itz��"�|p���_t�¹c=�tcKl�e·²;_�gH«�gHh�c'� eº��itl�c=zµ®

Â�d0cKcKlK¤ka�z���cÆqK_bl�e�_t��d|��%Í��_b�|p�e�pr�tc�¤kl�cK��ike|pr�tcèj�ik�bl�c=e|p�qHô�����g {�_bz�itdS²;_bd0e|só����m~ð c=�0eAd0p��bs�e9ý�� itl�u ¥d|cKz�ike�p��bcJe�_Mu�p��0��qKc=l�e|cKd=mb��l�p�e��Ä�|cKq=_bl�u��X_t��itd0qtg�^;pr�bs�e���itl�cKz.®�Â�d0cKcKlK¤ka�z���c¹q=_bl�e�_b��d0�&% ��_b�0pre|pr�bc�¤kl�c=��ike�p��bcj�it�tl�c=e|p�qèô�����g ^`cKuK¤k����d0��z�cYqK_tl�e|_b��d0�&%Ía�_b��l�u�itd|prcK�·�*_bd·e�s�c}qKitz�q=��z�ike|p�_bló_k��q=cKl�e�c=d|�è_t�;ô���� ikl�u�ûkg��z�itq�� qK_bl�e�_t��dK® a�_b��l�u�ikd0� �*_bdÆqKitz�q=��z�i×e�p�_tl _t�hÐ�â�g ¸~itd0e|sC²;_bd0e|sÊ���(m�ð c=�0eÅd|pr�bs�e9ý��|qKitlCd0_�ï itl�u

qK_bzr��j\lYl���jSa�cKd0�`p�lY��l�p�e���_t��j�ik�bl�c=e|_b�bd|itjö��po��cKz��º­.¾ Ê ªb¨�¡ ¡ °'g

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎtÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ�Ó Ô#ÖUØ Ù�Ú�Ú�Û~ØwܹݩÚ�ÙkÞ�ß ÇCÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 29: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

k���ä����H�"åF��!�)~����×���"��å��\���]ä�� �����å����S�"b����&(� áIâ�ã�Ô

0.00 0.25 0.50 0.75 1.00 1.25MC/AR current ratio [ x 103 ]

0.00

0.25

0.50

0.75

1.00

MC

/AR

flux

rat

io

² �³���ëO� � î ÃXzr��� d�i×e�p�_Y�bc=d|�0���·qK��d0d|c=l�eSd�ike|p�_�gÆ¡�s�c\z�_�ï¹cKdSikl�u ������cKdZcKl�u��S_t�xe|s�c�_bd0u�p�l�ike�cHcKd0d|_bd

a�itd|�Mitd0cS÷ � ·�·û�ü itl�uP÷�û�üÄm�d0cK�0��c=q=e�p��bc=zr�bm�itl�uÅe�s�cZ��z�_ke|e�c=u}a���z�zrc=e;p���e�s�cKp�d;jHc9itl�ý��0p�jHp�z�ikd|zr�Ae|s�cSita��|qKpr�|�|iu�ike�i·��_bp�l�e|�Mikl�u}c=d|d0_bd`a�itd|�;itd0c��*d|_bjõþ � ·�·û�ü itl�uÅþKû�üÄg¼Ã�_tz�z�_�ï`prl��S������c=l�u�p��}�Mm�ï�cºp��bl�_bd|c]e|s�c��|j\itz�zrcKd��l�qKc=d0e�itp�l�e��Æ_t�U�IvÊq=��d|d0cKl�e�itl�uÆô����Y�kitzr��cK�=g

ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ ÎtÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ�Ó Ô#ÖUØPÙ�Ú�ÚbÛ¼ØIܹݩÚ�ÙkÞ�ß ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ

Page 30: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

áIâ � á k���ä����H�"åF��!�)~����×���"��å�������ä�� �����å����S�"b����&(�

µ ì�ç�¢n� � î �wit�bl�c=e�prq�qKz�_t��uYc=�bc=l�e��&% y�e]��itd�itjHc=e|cKd0�`itl�uÅp�l��*c=d|d|c=u�0"��itl�e�pre|p�c=�Kg²M_�g�¥¼cKitd v�z�_t��uY¡�p�jHcK�K® ¶�· ¸v· ¹E· ºE· ± ¼ � ú<¹ �· þ9ø�ù ÷xø�ù òÄø�ù

{"e�itd0e ¸Jl�u ­*u�cK��°Õ­*u�cK��°Õ­´l�¡;°Õ­.Â�j�° ­µÂ���° ­*¡xðÍa�°Õ­µÂ�j Ï n °¦ ¦9¤b¤�¢ Ã�c=aw¬bªA¬b¨ks Ã�cKaŬbªH¾b¾ks í ¦�ª ª�¦ ¦#¾"g ¥ ¦���gy� í ¬�g¶¬�¦�� ¬�g¶¢b¢ «�g¶¥k« ¬�g�¦#¢¾ ± �witd;¬t«Y¦b¦Ks �}itd`¬�¢·¬t«bs í ¢b¢ ¦#¢×« ¦b¦tg¶ª ¦9«�g ¾ í ¬�g¶¬b¨b¢ ¬�g�«b« ¨�g¶¾$� ¬�g�¦#¥¨ ± �]cKqA¦��A¬�¢×s �]c=q·¦��H¾b¾ks ¨b¤ ¢k¬ ¦b¦tgy� ¨t«�g ¾ í ¬�g¶¬�¾k¨ ¦bg,¬b¨ ¦�ª�g¶¢ ¬�g,¬�¥« ¦9¤b¤bª Ã�c=añ¦#¥è¦�¬ks Ã�cKa ¦�ªÆ¦�ªts í ¢ ¨�¦9¬ ¦#¥"gy� ¦�¤�g¶¬ ü ¬�g¶¬b¨b¾ ¬�g,ª�¥ ª�gt�b¤ ¬�g�¦�¨¢ ± �wi9�Ŭ�¾è¦#¾×s �wi9�Y¬b¨Æ¦#¥ks í ¤ ¨�¢t¥ ¦�¬�g ¢ ¨b¨�gy� ü ¬�g¶¬b¨b¢ ¬�g,¤�¦ ¦���g,¬ ¬�g,¬�¥�À¦9¤b¤b¤ Ã�c=añ¦�ªÆ¦9«ts Ã�cKa ¦�¤Æ¦#¾ks «�¦ ¢kª ¦���g¶ª ¨�¢"g,« í ¬�g¶¬�¦t¦ ¦bg¶¢k« ¾tª�gt� ¬�g,¬�¥¥ ± ������¬b¤Æ¦�¬ks �M���Y¦�¬Æ¦��ts ¢t¤ ¾b¥k¬ ¦#¾"g¶ª ¾t¨�g ¢ í ¬�g¶¬�¾k¨ ¬�g¶¥tª ¤�g¶¢t¤ ¬�g�¦�¬ª ± {�c=�P¾�¦Z¾�¦Ks {�cK�w¾b¾·¬�¢ks � ¤t¬ ¦9«�g ¥ ¥�g,¬bª í ¬�g¶¬�¦t¦ ¬�g¶¾b¥ ¬�g,¤b¤ ¬�g,¨t«¤ ¾k¬b¬b¬ ft��zJ¦#¢è¦�¤ks ft��zJ¦��A¬b¤ts ¦ �b¾ «�ª�gr¦ ¾$��g,« í ¬�g¶¬�¦�¢ ¨�g¶¾t¤ «�¢�g¶¢ ¬�g,¬b¤¦�¬ ± ft��zľtªH¾�¦Ks ft��zľt¤Æ¦b¦9s ¢ ¨�¦9¤ ¦9«�gy� ¦���g,« í ¬�g¶¬�¾<� ¬�gt��¾ ¢�g,¨b¨ ¬�g�¦#¢¦b¦ ± ������¬�¦º¬b¬ks �M���H¬�¦A¦��ts ¦�ª ¦b¦9ª ¦#¾"g¶¨ «�¬�g¶¤ í ¬�g¶¬�¦�¾ ¦bg,¨�¦ ¾b¥�g,¤ ¬�g,¬��¦#¾ ± �����}¦#¾·¬��ks �M���Y¦�¨A¬�¢ks í ¦b¦ ªb¾ ¾t¤�gr¦ ¾b¢"gr¦ ü ¬�g¶¬�¾×« ¦bg,¤b¬ ¾k«�g,¤ ¬�g�¦�¬

µ ì�ç�¢n� � î {�_bz�itd�_ba��0cKd0�kike|p�_bl��`itl�uÅp�l��*c=d|d|c=u�0"��itl�e�pre|p�c=�Kg²M_�g�¥¼cKitd ¸U�tcKl�e]¡�prj\c=�K® �]^ þ=û�ü ÷�û�ü û òÄû�ü6�]^£¡�przre

¸Jd|����e�pr_bl �wit�bl�c=e�_t�bd�itj ­´¡Ä��° ­´¡xðÍa�°Õ­.�}jè° ­µÂ�j Ï n ° ­Þ´�°¦ ¦9¤b¤�¢ Ã�c=aw¬k«Å¦�¢�® ¢<� Ã�c=aŬt«H¬�¦b®¶¢�¦ ¥tªb¨t«õ¬�g¶¤b¥�±�¾�g¶¾tª ¦#¾�g,ª�±�¾t¬�g¶¾ «�¾�g¶¾ í ¢ Ê ¦ í ¨t¬¾ ± Ã�c=aI¾kªH¬tª�®,«�� Ã�c=a}¾b¥è¦#¥�®�¦#¥ ¥tªt«�� ¦bg ¾<��±�¨�g,ª�¾ ¦�ª�g,¬�±�¨�¦bg¶¥ «�¬�g¶¥ í ¬ Ê ¥ «�¢± ± ± Ã�c=a}¾tªÆ¦�¤�®�«�¢ ± ¦bg¶¤�¦"±�¨�g,¨b¤ ¾t¤�g¶¾�±�¨b¤�g�« ��¦bg,¨ í ¤ Ê « í �¨ ± �]c=qH¦t¦Z¬t¨�®¶¨�¦ �]c=qA¦�¬Æ¦#¥�®¶¾b¾ ¥t¤b¨b¬ö¬�gy�t¨�±�¾�g,¨�� ��gy�k«O±�¦#¾�g�¦ ¨�¢�g¶¢ ¨t« Ê ª í ¦�¥± ± ± �]c=qA¦b¦A¦#¥�®�¦#¢ ±W¬�g,«bª�±�¦bg¶¢$� ¥�g ¾t¢�±�¦�¨�g,ª ¨t«�g,¬ ¾k« Ê « í ¨t¨« ¦9¤b¤bª Ã�c=añ¦K«\¬b¾�® ¾k¤ Ã�c=a ¦#¾è¦#¥�®,¨b¨ ª�¦#¢$� ¦bg¶¨k«O±�¾�g¶¾tª ¾t¤�g�«O±�¨���g,¤ «b«�g�¦ í ¦#¾ Ê ¨ í ¢¢ ± ����d�¾k¤Y¦���® ¢kª5¢Ê�M��dM¾tªÆ¦���®,¨bª ª�¾�¦�¬ö¬�g¶ªb¢�±�¨�g�¦9« ¾t¨�g¶¥�±�¨�¥�g,ª �b¬�g¶¥ ¦#¥�g¶¾ ¥t¤± ± ± �M��dM¾t¤Æ¦���®,¨b¤ ± ¦bg¶¬b¾�±�¾�g¶¾b¢ ¾k«�g¶¥�±�¨�¥�g�¦ ¾t¤�g,¤ ¾b¥�g,¬ í ¾k¬�À¦9¤b¤b¤ Ã�c=añ¦K«Å¦t¦b®r¦�� Ã�c=a ¦b¦A¦�¤�®¶¾$� ªt«�¢b¥ ¦bg¶¨t¤�±�¾�g,¤�¾ ¨�¾�g,ª�±�¢t¨�g,ª ��¾�g,¨ í « Ê ¥ ¾t¤¥ ± �M����¬k«\¬k«�®r¦t¦ �M���\¬�¾è¦���®,¨�� ª���¢�¦ ��gr¦9¬�±�¦�¬�g¶¢ ¦9«bª�g¶¬�±�¦�¤�¦bg,¬ ¤b¬�g¶¾ í ¥ Ê ¢ í ¾k¤ª ± {"cK� ¦�¥H¾t¾�® ¾kª {"cK�w¾t¬Æ¦#¥�®,¬b¬ ª�¥t¬b¬ö¬�gr¦�¢�±�¾�g�¦#¾ ¨�g ¢"¦"±�¾t¤�g,¨ ¥t¬�g�¦ í ¢ Ê « í ¦�¢¤ ¾k¬b¬b¬ ft��zJ¦K«\¬t¤�® ¾t¥ ft��zJ¦b¦A¦���®¶¢b¾õ¤b¬�¥b¥ «�g ¥k¨�±�¢�g�«�¨ ����g¶¢�±�¥b¾�gt� ¦9¬�¾�g¶¢ í «�ª Ê « ¬± ± ± ft��zJ¦9«Y¦���®,¨b¤ ± ¢�g¶¬t¨�±�¢�g¶¥t¤ «�¥�gt��±�ªb¬�g�« ��¢�gt� í ¢b¾ Ê ¤ ¦�¬± ± ± ft��zJ¦#¥è¦���®,¨�¾ ±W¬�g ¥k¨�±�¦bgt��� ¦�¤�g,¬�±�¨b¬�gt� ¨t«�g,¤ í ¾t¤ Ê ¾ í ¥t¢¦�¬ ± ft��zľt¢A¬b¾�®,«bª ft��zľ�¦Z¾t¬�®¶¾tª ¤b¬b¤�¥ «�g,«b¬�±"«�g¶¥b¢ ªt«�g,¨�±�ªbª�g�« ¢b¥�g,ª í ¦#¢ Ê � ¦#¥¦b¦ ± ft��zľt¥H¾t¾�®r¦9ª ft��zľ$�Ʀ���®,¨b¨ ¤b¬b¤�¥ö¾�gy�k«O±�¢�g,¬b¬ ¾$��g,¬�±�¢t¬�g�¦ ¢t¨�g,¨ ¦���g,¤ ¾t¤± ± ± ft��zľtªÆ¦���®�«�¬ ±W¬�g ¢"¦"±�¦bg,¨b¤ ¦�¬�g,¤�±�¾�¦bg,¬ «�¦bg�« í ¦#¥ Ê ¢ �b¨¦#¾ ± �M����¬t¤Y¦���®¶¨t¬ ¢ �M���\¬bªÆ¦���®,¨�¥õ¤�¦b¦9«W¦bg,«�¾�±�¾�g¶¢�¦ ¨�¾�gt��±"«�¦bg,¨ ª�¢�g,¨ í ¦#¾ Ê ¥ í ¦�¥± ± ± �M���Ŧb¦A¦���®¶¢tª ± ¦bg¶ªtª�±�¾�g,¤t« «�¾�g�¦"±�¢b¾�g�« ¥b¥�g,¤ í ¤ Ê ª ªb¨

¢Í¡�prj\cM�*d|_bjR{"_�±]¿p¤th���{�v�¿·ý��bit�Yp�l�¥¼_bs��k_bsÅe|cKjH��_td�itz�q=_��bcKd|it�bckg

ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ ÎtÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ�Ó Ô#ÖUØ Ù�Ú�Ú�Û~ØwܹݩÚ�ÙkÞ�ß ÇCÈCÉÊËàÌ

Page 31: 0/2103solar.physics.montana.edu/canfield/papers/mc_ar_ms.pdf · "!# %$$$$ '&( *),+.- !,+.-0/2103 465 7989:;8=< >?A@CB DFEHGI5

k���ä����H�"åF��!�)~����×���"��å��\���]ä�� �����å����S�"b����&(� áIâ � ൠì�çz¢n� � î v�_bjH��itd|pr�|_blY_t�Äô�����m�q=��d|d0cKl�e9m�itl�uYe�ï`p��2e��kitz���c=�`p�lY�]^`�;itl�u}�Iv��Kg²M_�g�¥¼c9itd ¸U�tcKl�e�¡�prj\c=�K® �]^ þKø�ù�úkþ=û�üL÷xø�ù�út÷�û�ü ­.ò�ÿ¼°2û�ü ­.òXÿ¼°2ø�ù�£

¸Jd|����e�pr_bl �wit�bl�c=e�_t�bd�itj Ó`¦�¬ Ï � �¦ ¦�¤b¤�¢ Ã�c=aŬt«Y¦#¢�®¶¢$� Ã�cKa}¬t«H¬�¦b®¶¢�¦ ¥tªb¨k«R¬�gr¦�¢�±�¬�g¶¢t¨ ¾t¬�±�¨bª í ¬ Ê ¨t« í ¢t¨ Ê ¾¾ ± Ã�c=a}¾tªA¬bª�®�«�� Ã�cKaw¾b¥·¬�¥�®�¦#¥õ¥tªt«�� ¬�g¶¬b¢�±�¬�g,¨b¬ ª�±�¦�ª í ¬ Ê ¬�¦ í ��¾ Ê ¾± ± ± Ã�cKaw¾tªÆ¦�¤�®�«�¢ ±W¬�gr¦�¾�±�¬�g¶¾tª ª�±�¦#¾ í ¬ Ê ¤�¦ ±¨ ± �]c=q·¦b¦º¬b¨�®,¨�¦ �]c=qA¦�¬Æ¦#¥�®¶¾b¾õ¥t¤b¨t¬ ¬�gr¦9¨�±�¦bg¶¾b¢ ¦b¦#¢�±�¾t¥t¤ ¦ Ê ¤k« í ¾b¢ Ê ª± ± ± �]c=qA¦b¦A¦#¥�®�¦#¢ ±W¬�g ¢kª�±"«�g,¬�¾ ¦#¾b¾�±�¨�¦9« ¦ Ê ¨t¬ ±« ¦�¤b¤bª Ã�c=a ¦9«H¬�¾�®¶¾t¤ Ã�cKa ¦#¾è¦#¥�®,¨b¨õª�¦#¢<� ¬�g¶¨t¬�±�¬�gt��� ¾b¾#§�¨b¬ í ¬ Ê ª�¢ ü «�¨�g�¦¢ ± ����d;¾t¤Æ¦���®¶¢tª �M��dM¾tªÆ¦���®,¨bªõª�¾�¦9¬ ¬�g¶¬t¤�±�¬�g,ªb¨ ¨�¢�±��b¤ ¦ Ê �k« ü ¾$��g,¨± ± ± �M��dM¾t¤Æ¦���®,¨b¤ ±W¬�g¶¨$��±�¦bg�¦�¤ «�¬�±�¥b¾ ¦ Ê ¾t¥ ±� ¦�¤b¤b¤ Ã�c=a ¦9«Y¦b¦b®�¦�� Ã�cKa ¦b¦A¦�¤�®¶¾$�õªt«�¢t¥õ¬�g¶¨$��±�¦bg,¬�¥ «�¨�±�ªb¤ í ¬ Ê «�� í ¾b¢ Ê ¬¥ ± �M���H¬t«H¬t«�®�¦b¦ �M���\¬�¾è¦���®,¨��õª���¢"¦ ¬�g¶¬$��±�¬�g�¦�¨ ¢�±�¥ í ¦ Ê ¬�� í ¨�¥ Ê �ª ± {"cK� ¦#¥A¾b¾�®¶¾tª {�cK�I¾t¬Æ¦#¥�®,¬b¬õª�¥t¬t¬ ¬�±�¬�g¶¢t¨ ¬�±�¦�¨ í ¬ Ê ¢t¤ í ¦�¾k« Ê ª¤R¾t¬b¬b¬ ft��zJ¦9«H¬b¤�®¶¾b¥ ft��zJ¦b¦A¦���®¶¢b¾ö¤b¬�¥t¥õ¬�g ¢kª�±�¬�g¶¥�¦ ��¦�±��b¤ í ¥ Ê ¥t¤ í ¨b¨ Ê ¢± ± ± ft��zJ¦9«Y¦���®,¨b¤ ±W¬�g ¢t¢�±�¬�gt�bª ¢b¾�±�¦t¦#¾ í ¢ Ê «�¢ ±± ± ± ft��zJ¦#¥è¦���®,¨�¾ ± ¦bg ¥kª�±���g�¦#¾ ¦�¨bª�±�¾t¥k« í ¦ Ê �b¬ ±¦9¬ ± ft��zľb¢·¬�¾�®�«�ª ft��zľ�¦Z¾t¬�®¶¾tªõ¤b¬b¤b¥õ¬�gr¦9¨�±�¬�g�¦9« ��g,¬�±���g�« í ¦ Ê «�¾ í ¢t¨ Ê ¤¦t¦ ± ft��zľb¥A¾b¾�®�¦�ª ft��zľ$�Ʀ���®,¨b¨õ¤b¬b¤b¥õ¬�gr¦9¤�±�¬�g�«�¤ «�¬�±�¦9¬�� ¦ Ê «�¾ í ¾�¦ Ê �± ± ± ft��zľtªÆ¦���®�«�¬ ±W¬�g¶ªt¨�±"«�g,¬b¬ ¦#¾�¦"±�¨�¦#¥ í ¦ Ê ¦9« ±¦�¾ ± �M���H¬b¤Æ¦���®,¨b¬ �M���\¬bªÆ¦���®,¨�¥ö¤�¦b¦K«R¬�g ¢k¤�±�¦bg,¨�¢ ¢$��±�¥t¤ í ¦ Ê ¥t¬ ü ¨�¢�g¶¾± ± ± �M���Ŧb¦A¦���®¶¢tª ±W¬�gy�t¬�±�¦bg�¦9« «���±���¾ í ¦ Ê ¦�¤ ±£ ���|�0��jHp�l��Hÿ�¿C¾ Ê ¢S�`�Zg

µ ì�çz¢n� * î v�_bjH��itd|pr�|_blY_t�Äy�e`��ikd�itjHc=e|cKd|�=®¼�xit�0e|p�zrz�c]��i9�žk¬b¬b¬Sc=�tcKl�e9gÃXpre`��itd�ikj\c'e�cKd �Jd0cK�|c=l�e�?A��B�B�13:;���"!g�$��%x?�N<:{GJI]�"!g�$��%xaT�;�3�91����$:��"!Q�$��%

ð _bd0� &,¾k¬b¬�¦bm�¾k¬b¬b¨<( &,¾k¬b¬b¨<( &�¾t¬b¬�¦Ka/(¶�· & u�c=�$( ¦ ¢b¢�Ø·¦�¨ ¾kª «�¬¸v· & u�c=�$( ��¾ «���Ø�¨�¾ �k« ªb¨¹E· & l�¡Q( «bª�gr¦ «���g¶ª�Ø�¨�g,¨ «b«�g,¨ ¥b¥ºE· & ¦�¬�¤;��jh( ¾<��g,« ¾b¥"g¶ª�Ø·¦bgt� ¾t¨�g¶¢ ¨�¢"g¶¨Dxú$ºE· ¬�g¶¬b¤ ¬�g�¦���Ø�¬�g¶¨t¬ ¬�g¶¬t¬ ¬�g�«�¾þKø�ù & ¦�¬ Õ �7( ¨�g¶¨ ¨�g�« ¾�g¶¥ ±÷xø�ù & ¦�¬ n´� ðÍa/( «�� ¢b¾ ¨t¨ ¤�¢

ÇÊÈCÉÊËàÌ ÎtÏkÐ�Ñ�ÏbÒ�Ó Ô#ÖUØPÙ�Ú�ÚbÛ¼ØIܹݩÚ�ÙkÞ�ß ÇCÈÊÉCËÍÌ