Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
Weiguo Li
Institute of High Energy Physics
2002 年 6 月 5 日
BEPCII/BESIII PROJECTBESIII Collaboration Meeting
June 5-6, Beijing
2
Goals of this collaboration meeting• Inform the overall BEPCII/BESII preliminary design and
the project status
• Discuss the status of BESIII preliminary design,
consensus on detector design choices
• Discuss the possible participations from other countries,
from other institutes in China
• Future plan for detector design, R&D, detector
manufacture, schedule and cost
• BESIII collaboration, organization
3
Introduction
BEPCII Design
BESIII Design
BESIII Collaboration
Summary
4
Korea (3)
Korea University Seoul National University
Chonbuk National University
Japan (5)
Nikow UniversityTokyo Institute of Technology
Miyazaki UniversityKEK
U. Tokyo
USA (4)
University of HawaiiUniversity of Texas at Dallas
Colorado State University Stanford Linear Accelerator Center
UK (1)Queen Mary University
China (15)IHEP of CAS
Univ. of Sci. and Tech. of ChinaShandong Univ., Zhejiang Univ.
Huazhong Normal Univ. Shanghai Jiaotong Univ.
Peking Univ., CCAST Wuhan Univ., Nankai Univ.
Henan Normal Univ.Hunan Univ., Liaoning Univ.
Tsinghua Univ., Sichuan Univ.
U. Tokyo, Central Univ.,Guangxi normal Univ., Guangxi Univ.
5
Data Collected with BESI and BESII Ecm (GeV)
Physics BES Data Other Lab.
3.10 J/ 7.8106 8.6106
3.69 (2S) 3.9106 1.8106
4.03 1.0105 LEP
4.03 DS, D 22.3 pb-1 CLEO
3.55 m scan m 5 pb-1
2-5 R scan R value,
QED, (g-2) 6+85 points 2, MarkI
Crystal Ball Pluto……
3.1 3.69 3.78
J/ (2S) (3S)
5.8107
1.46107
~7 pb-1
BES Current StatusBES Current Status
6
BESII Detector BESII Detector ((1995-1997 upgrade1995-1997 upgrade))
VC: xy = 100 m TOF: T = 180 ps counter: r= 3 cm MDC: xy = 250 m BSC: E/E= 22 % z = 5.5 cm dE/dx= 8.4 % = 7.9 mr B field: 0.4 T p/p=1.8(1+p2) z = 2.3 cm Dead time/event: 〈 10 ms
7
BESBES Main Physics Results
Precise Mass Measurement of lepton.
2-5 GeV R measurement.
Systematic study of decays.
Systematic study of J/ decays.
Obtain fDs from Ds pure leptonic decay.
Measure Br(DS ) in model independent way.
BES has 116 entries in PDG.
BES has 74 invited talk ， published 216 papers ， 48 pa
pers in world-class journals.
8
Physics Window for BEPC Two major directions in world HEP:
– High Energy Frontier ： Search for Higgs particle and beyond STM
particles and phenomena.
– High precision frontier ： high statistics and high precision ， check
STM ， search for phenomena beyond STM.
Considering the new developments of world HEP, the main physics window
for BEPC is precise measurement of charm and charmonium physics, and s
earch for new phenomena.
Advantages: huge cross section at J/ 和′ resonance
simple topology and low background at threshold
Important area to study QCD ， perturbative and non-perturbative QCD ，can search for new physics.
9
BEPC II Physic Goals
• Precise measurements of J/、 、 (3S) Decays
• Precise measurement of CKM parameters
• Light quark hadron spectroscopy
• Excited baryon spectroscopy
• Other D and Ds physics: – precise measurement of D and Ds decays
– measurement of fD, fDs – D0 –D0 mixing
• Check VDM, NRQCD, PQCD, study puzzle
10
BEPC II Physics Goals （ 2 ）
• Mechanism of hadron production ， low energy QCD ：
precise R measurement• physics ： charged current ， m and m
• Search for new particles: 1P1、 c、 glueballs 、quark-gluon hybrid 、 exotic states…
• Search for new phenomena: – rare decays;– lepton number violation; – CP violation in J/ 和 decays;
11
BEPC Future Development: BEPCII
• Precise measurements need:– High statistics → high luminosity machine – Small systematic error→ high performance detector
• BEPC will run at J/ and ， with huge cross-section,
also at ”
• Need to have major upgrade for machine and detector
(BEPCII / BESIII) ， to increase machine luminosity by
more than one order of magnitude with relatively small b
udget and in a relatively short time.
12
High Energy Physics 1 ） BEPC future development BEPC II:
- BEPC / BES major upgrade, increase luminosity by more than one order of magnitude;
- Main physics goal: J/ , ′and D/DS physics;
2 ） Strength non-accelerator experiments: Cosmic ray,
astro-physics experiments, neutrino experiment…;
3 ） International Collaboration
Chinese Academy of Sciences ：The strategy for Chinese HEP and Advanced Accelerator technology
13
Science-education Leading Group of State Council, the 7th meeting (2000.7.27), discussed the report by CAS about HEP Conclusions ：（ 1 ） Approval in principle of 《 Report about the future development of Chinese HEP and advanced accelerator technology 》 by CAS. Meanwhile, CAS should consult further with experts in China and abroad ， strength and attract more international collaboration. （ 2 ） In view of the success of BEPC, approval of major upgrade of BEPC, with a budget of 400 M RMB.With relatively small invest, continue to obtain high-level achievements. (At that time, it was meant single-ring)
14
Competition in tau-charm physics• CESR, USA runs at 10GeV for B physics, because it can hardl
y compete with two B factories ， on the other hand, there are
important and interesting physics at tau-charm energy region
as demonstrated at BEPC, plans to reduce the collision energy
by installing a series of SC wigglers, expected lum. （ 1.5 – 3)x
1032cm-2s-1 。• VEPP-4M, Novosibirsk, Russia, has a similar plan.
• BEPC/BES can not enjoy the advantage of unique e+e- collider
in this energy region any more ， strong competition.
• BEPC II single ring design can not ensure competitive edge in
the race.
15
BEPC II Double ring DesignBEPC II Double ring Design• In the existing BEPC tunnel, add another ring, cross over at south a
nd north points, two equal rings for electrons and positrons. Advanced double-ring collision technology.
• 93 bunches ， total current > 0.9A in each ring. Collision spacing ： 8 ns.• In south, collision with large cross-angle （ ±11 mr ） .• Calculated luminosity ： 1033 cm-2 s-1 @ 3.78GeV.
• In north cross point, connecting SR beam between two outer rings, in south cross point, use dipole magnet to bend the beam back to out
er ring.• SR run ： 250mA @ 2.5 GeV.• Major detector upgrade ： BES III.
Luminosity of BEPCII is a factor of 3-7 of that of CESRc, more potential, and technically less challenge. Budget increased by 50 ％ .
16
BEPC Upgrade: BEPC II BEPC Upgrade: BEPC II — — double ring double ring
e -
RFRF SR
e+
IP
17
BEPCIIBEPCII Design GoalsDesign Goals
Beam energy 1 – 2 GeV
Optimal energy 1.89 GeV
Luminosity 1 x 10 33 cm-2s-1 @ 1.89 GeV
Linac requirements Full energy injection: 1.55 1.89 GeV Positron injection rate > 50 mA/min
Dedicated SR 250 mA @ 2.5 GeV
Increase beam current ， reduce beam size
18
Wood Model Space Study for Double Ring
19
Luminosity Increase
)(
)()()1(1017.2)s(cm
*341-2-
cm
AIkGeVERL
y
bby
Micro-:y*=5cm 1.5 cm
Super-conducting magnetImpedance red. and SC RF cavity
z=5cm <1.5cm
D.R.: multi bunches h~400, kb=1 93
(LBEPCII/ LBEPC) D.R.=(5.5/1.5) 93 9.8/35=96
LBEPC=1.010 31 cm-2s-1 LBEPCII =110 33 cm-2s-1
Ib=9.8mA, y=0.04
20
Means of lum. incerase (E = 1.89 GeV)
parameter unit BEPC BEPCII
y* cm 5.0 ～ 1.5
Bunch number kb 1 93
y 0.04 0.04
Beam current Ib mA 35 9.8
factor for lum. increase
1 ～ 100
BEPCII cross-angle collision ： 2 x 11mr
21
BEPCII/BEPC/CESRc Comparison
22
BEPCII BEPCII Key Technologies and ChallengesKey Technologies and Challenges
Linac Injection rate: 5 mA/min.
50 mA/min.
New positron source
Stability and reliability
Einj= 1.55-1.89 GeV
500MHz SC RF System
SC RF Technology
Power source and low level
Cryogenics…
Injection
Magnets
Power supplies
Vacuum system
SC Q magnet and IP
Beam instrumentation
Control system
23
Linac UpgradeRequirements: Positron injection rate 5mA/min. 50 mA/min.; Energy 1.3 GeV 1.55 ~ 1.89 GeV;
Use 45MW Klystron,upgrade RF source, replace 8 aged acceleration tubes ；Bombarding energy for positron 150 MeV 240 MeV;
Electron gun beam intensity 5A10A ； Produce new positron source, improving efficiency ； Improve focus and orbit-correction system ； Repetition rate 12.5 Hz 50 Hz ； Pulse duration 2.5ns1ns ； Possibility of double pulse injection (fRF/fLinac=7/40);
24
means and factors for increase injection rate
25
SC RF System
Requirements ： Sufficient voltage Sufficient power reducing coupling instability stability, reliabilit
y
Measures: collaborate with SSRF, Cornell and KEK ， using existing technology.
26
Super-conducting Cavity CESR-type Cavity (ACCEL) KEKB-type Cavity (Mitsubishi )
IHEP/SSRF collaborating group will optimize the cavity design, follow the manufacture process and technology, master the required techniques for operating and repairing the cavities.
27
Interaction point and SC Q magnet 磁场强度 有效长度(m)
四极线圈 16.7 T/m 0.4
斜四极线圈 0.2 T/m 0.4
SR 偏转线圈 0.645 0.4
反抵螺线管 2.6 0.5
屏蔽螺线管 ~1.2 ~0.4
水平校正线圈 0.0528 0.4
垂直校正线圈 0.0528 0.4
28
Beam Feedback System Challenge ： How to insure collision?
Beam-beam bending and scanning techniques ：Beam-beam bending ： accelerator physicsBending measurement ： beam instrumentationScan feedback ： automatic control
IP_Bump
Orbit data SteeringBeam-BeamDeflection
IP-BPM 二极校正铁IP Orbit Feedback
29
BES III Expected Event Rates
Particle Energy Single Ring （ 1.2fb
-1 ）Double Ring (4
fb-1)
D0 7.0106 2.3107
D+ 5.0106 1.7107
Ds 4.14GeV 2.0106 4106
+- 3.57GeV3.67GeV
0.6106
2.91060.2107
0.96107
J/ 3-4109 6-10109
0.6109 2109
30
BESIII Design Goals
• High event rate ： lum. :1033cm-2 s-1 and bunch spacing 8ns ， hardware trigger rate: 4000 Hz ， putting on mass medium: 3000 Hz.
• Improve detector resolutions , especially for photons
• Improve particle identification
• Enlarge detector solid angle acceptance
• Design interaction region to fit sc Q magnets
31BESIII BESIII DetectorDetector
32
BESIII Main Sub-systems• CsI EM Calorimeter: E/E < 3%• MDC: small cell, Al field wire and He-based gas
P/P (1GeV) = 1.25 %@0.4T, 0.5 %@1T, dE/dx = 6 %
• Time of Flight: T: barrel 80 ps ； endcap 100 ps counter(RPC): readout strip width ： ~4 cm
• Luminosity Monitor(LM) L/ L = 3 %• SC Solenoid ： 1 Tesla, I.D. 1.32 m, Length 3.8 m• New Trigger and Online system for multi-bunch and h
igh lum. Operation, 4000Hz, 3000Hz to mass storage• New Electronics ： pipeline operation
• Offline computing: PC farm, mass storage
33
Item
time measurement Charge measurementCount rateper channel
Information provided to trigger
Number of channel
σtINL Ran
ge
Cross-talk
Number
ofcha
nnels
σQ
INL
Dynamic
range
Cross-talk
Type Quant.
MDC 90000.5-1 ns
≤0.5%
0-400ns
9000 5fc
≤2%
15 fc -1800fc
1%
30 k/s hit
TOF
+ CCT
352+104
≤25ps
0- 60ns
456 12bits(ENOB)
≤2%
20mv –4v
2-4 k/s hit 456
EMCBAR
8064+1800
0.16 fc 200KeV
1 %
0.5fc -1500fc
0.3 %
1 k/s
SummationOf analog
EMC(End)
1800
0.16fc 1 %
0.5fc -1500fc
0.3 %
1 k/s
SummationOf analog
Mu
Chan ~10000
Spec
Considering multiple hit time measurement
34
Sub-system BES III BESII
XY (m) = 130 250
MDC P/P (0/0) = 0.5 %(1 GeV) SC
1.25 %(1 GeV) Normal
1.7% √2 (1 GeV)
dE/dx (0/0) = 6-7 % 8.5%
EM Calorimeter E/√E(0/0) = 2.5 %(1 GeV)
z(cm) = 0.5cm/√E
20% (1 GeV) 3 cm /√E
Time of Flight T (ps) = 80 ps barrel 100 ps endcap
180 ps barrel
350 ps endcap
Counters 9- 10 layers 3 layers
Magnet 1.0 tesla Option 1 0.4 tesla Option 2
0.4 tesla
Comparisons between BESIII and BESII
35BESIII detector with existing magnet
36
Expected physics reaches and background study by MC simulation, D, Ds, J/, (2S) will be covered by
Dr. Wang Yifang
Most of the main detector sub-systems will be covered by other speakers, I will say a few words about these sub-systems which are not presented separately today.
Interaction region
Mechanical preliminary design
Slow Control
37
Interaction RegionIt is very compact at IR, very close cooperation is needed in the designs of detector and machine components at IR
• Understand the space sharing, the support, vacuum tight
• Understand the backgrounds from machine and how to reduce them,
- Beam loss calculation (masks)
- Synchrotron radiation (masks)
- Heating effect (cooling if necessary)
• Understand the effects of the fringe field from SCQ to the detector
performances, the preliminary study shows that, field uniformity
should be better than 5% in most of the MDC volume
• Center of beam pipe will be a double-wall Be pipe
38
BESIII Mechanical design and Detector HallDetector on two rail pads to move in south-northIron Yoke Barrel~ 240 tons; endcap ~254 tons.
at both sides between barrel and endcap, there should be a slot of 1100x 80mm for each side of octagon on every terminal surface of the barrel of yoke, for cable space.
39View from the side of endcap yoke is closed
40
M24 Bolt
M16 Bolt
Assembled Structure, test assembling at factory
41
From upper
From bottom Support of SC dewar
42 Support of inner detector components
43
Movable endcap yoke; reposition for field stability
endcap EMC supporting and moving design, removing and recollecting cables should not change the gain.
44 Arrangements of electronic crates, moving with detector
45Arrangements for cooling water, gas, cables
1. Temperature measurement: EMC CsI , 600 ; MDC 16;
, 150; electronics crates, 300; cable rack, 100; environment, 100;
2. Humidity measurement: CsI, 200 ; MDC, 8; electronics, 20; environment, 30;
3. Low HV of VME crates: 500.
4. MDC gas ： 8.
5. Voltage of power supply: several.
6. Other measurements? Magnetic field; parameters in SC magnet and cryogenics; HV parameters for detectors; radiation dose; He leakage; flammable gas;others.
Slow control system
Required measurements from detector and electronics
ONE WIRE BUS can be used to read these signals out
Probe/master, doing R&D
64 bit W. A. O （ unique code worldwide), 12 bit DATE
Temperature probe: DS18B20, 22 RMB/probe
humidity probe: LTM8802, ~150 RMB/probe
1. Humidity range: 1~99% ， typical precision: 3%.
2. Temperature range: -30 ~60℃ ℃， accuracy 0.5 ℃
D . C voltage probe: DS2438/ LTM8805, several dozens of RMB/probe
analog voltage:0 ～ 10V （ resolution ： 0.01V ）
Light-decoupling between PC and master to reduce noise
pickup, LTM － 4850/2 dual-port RS － 485 card
48
BESIII Key Technology and Challenge• Control background (with machine people), take good quality data
at high luminosity. Small ring is more problematic with background
and radiation dose!
• Design and operate SC magnet
• Stable operation of MDC(>30000 wires), obtaining better resolution
• Obtain best possible EMC energy resolution, by quality
control in detector construction and good calibration systems
• Obtain best possible TOF resolution, all factors controlled
• Build a trigger and DAQ system, with required data transfer rate
and good performance (specifications, reliability)
49
Some preliminary design issues, such as TOF readout electronics, EMC support structure etc are not decided
Decision on the offline system should be taken ASAP, so people can start to work on the software
Determination of some of main design options
• Magnet? super-conducting/existing normal
• Particle ID? (TOF/ Ĉerenkov based)
Cost and schedule concern
• Cost for EMC, SC magnet and electronics is most crucial;
• MDC, EMC and SC magnet (including iron structure) on critical path;
50
BESIII will be competitive in producing good physics results after its completion; can help to master advanced technology related to detector design and construction, fast electronics, DAQ and data analyses, help to catch up with world level or close the gap.
But, construction of BESIII and obtaining world class results, are big challenge to Chinese HEP experimentalists, need to master new techniques, such as super-conducting, low-Z small cell MDC; high precision EM calorimeter; pipeline fast electronics, fast data acquisition, huge data storage and processing; Need international collaboration （ Japan, US, Korea) 。
51
• Conceptual design started in 1999.
• Feasibility study started in the summer of 2000 ， complete
d in Aug. of 2001.
• Preliminary design started in the summer of 2001 ：– Machine finished physics design, requirements for sub-systems are
determined;
– Sub-system designs are progressing well
– Detector design is progressing well
– Expected to finish preliminary design in the summer of 2002
• Upgrade of Linac started.
• R&D for key technologies started ： SC cavity, Q magnet
Project Status
52
Feasibility Study/Design Review• BEPC II feasibility international review ( 01. 4. 2 – 6, Beijing)
26 experts reviewed the feasibility of machine and detector
• BEPC II machine feasibility review ( 01. 7. 29 - 30 Beijing)
21 domestic experts reviewed machine feasibility and preliminary
design.
• BESIII International Workshop (01.10.13 – 15 Beijing)
• International technical review of machine preliminary
design at SLAC, May, 2002
BESIII preliminary design review, plan to be in Sep. of 2002
53
Project Schedule and Budget• Done Feasibility Study Report submitted. End of June of 2002 Preliminary Technical Design Report June 2003 R&D and prototype May 2004 BEPC run• July 2002 June 2006 Construction• May 2004 Nov. 2004 BESII dismounting and Linac upgrade • Nov. 2004 Jan. 2005 Linac commissioning• Jan. 2005 Apr. 2005 SR run• Apr. 2005 Jan. 2006 Storage ring assembling• Jan. 2006 June 2006 Commissioning of storage ring• June 2006 Sep. 2006 BESIII detector moved to beam-line• Sep. 2006 Commissioning machine and detector
54
BESIII Schedule
2001.1~2002.6 Preliminary design
2001.7~2003.6 R&D of critical parts
2002.7~2005.9 Construction of detector components
2003.1~2004.6 Construction of return yoke
2002.3~2004.12 Design of super-conducting magnet
2004.7~2004.11 BESII disassembling
2004.12~2005.3 BESIII iron yoke assembling (with magnet)
2005.4 Commissioning of cryogenics
2005.5~2005.8 Magnet field measurement （ with SCQ ） 2005.9~2006.1 Assembling of other detector components
2006.2~2006.6 Commissioning of BESIII detector
2006.7~2006.8 BESIII moved to beam-line
2006.9~2006.12 Commissioning of BEPCII+BESIII
55
BEPCII Team and Administration
• BEPC II project leaders and headquarter are established;
• 4 Major systems, Linac; Ring; Detector; Technical support( cryogenics).
• Most of responsible persons for sub-systems are appointed.
• Some procedures are established, quality control; budget control; technical review; etc.
56
BEPC Budget (M RMB)Ⅱ
* Expected contribution from abroad
System Budget Percentage
1 、 Linac 46 7.2%
2 、 Storage Ring 239.2 37.4%
3 、 Detector 219 （ 40* ） 34.2%
4 、 Technical support systems 90 14.0%
5 、 Infrastructure 5.5 0.9%
6 、 Others 10.3 1.6%
7 、 Contingency 30 4.7%
Total 640(40*)
57
BEPCII Domestic Collaboration
Welcome participation from other Institutes and Universities,
in charge of one sub-system or collaboration with IHEP• Shanghai Synchrotron Light Source
– 500 MHz RF system
• Shanghai Institute of Ceramics ： CsI crystals
• Beijing University ： RF system, detector
• Qinghua University ： Accelerator technique, detector
• University of Science and Technology of China ： Detector,
Readout electronics
58
BESIII Domestic Collaboration
Design, MC simulation
Sub-detectors R&D and construction
Electronics R&D and manufacture
Online/Offline software
Software package
Reconstructions
Calibration
Physics study
In Charge of some sub-system or send people to IHEP
59
BEPCII International Collaboration International collaboration played an important roll in B
EPC/BES project ， Expect to play major roll in the desi
gn and construction of BEPCII / BESIII ：– BNL of US: SC Q magnet;– SLAC of US: Key machine technology, design– KEK of Japan: SC cavity and SC solenoid… reviews; – Improve technical excellency and research capability Advice and help in design and construction in various systems; Technical review and follow-up in detector design, construction and commissioning. BESIII international review, sometime in September.
60
BEPCII / BESIII can attract international participation, especially in detector and physics; Share cost ， improve detector performancesJoin BESIII collaboration and be in charge of some sub-systems U. Hawaii, U. Washington and other US Institutes,KEK and U. of Tokyoare participating in the project, will play important roll. More Institutes from US and Japan may joinKorea has interest in participating
Should form BESIII international collaboration according to international standard:Institution board; Executive board; Spokesperson; etc.
International review/Documentation/video conferencing
61
Summary BEPC/BES meet opportunity and challenge in the field of tau-cha
rm physics.
BEPCII double-ring design luminosity 1033 cm-2s-1at 1.89 GeV ，with major upgrade of BES ， can insure an important roll in world HEP, especially in tau-charm physics.
BEPCII/BESIII is technically feasible, should be started as soon as possible.
BESIII has a baseline design, optimization is needed
Strength domestic collaboration ， stimulate developments of relevant technologies in China.
International collaboration in BEPCII/BESIII construction.
BESIII Collaboration should follow international standard.
62
Hope this collaboration meeting is very successful
Thanks
谢谢
63
Item cost(10K RMB)
Number Total(10KRMB)
Total(10KRMB)
1 Beam-pipe and masks 120
2 MDC 1800
2-1 End-plates 900
2-2 Feed-through and wires 340
2-3 Other mechanical and wire stringing 395
2-3 HV cards and cables 90
2-5 Cosmic ray test 30
2-6 Others 45
3 EM Calorimeter 9650
3-1 CsI Crystals ~10000 7850
3-2 Si Pin Diode ~20000 600
3-3 Crystal measuring devices 200
3-4 Calibration systems 200
3-5 Support structure, assembling tool 400
3-6 Assembling 200
3-7 Others 200
BESIII Budget
64
4 Time of Flight 940
4-1 Scintillator 280 块 160
4-2 PMT R5924 456 只 600
4-3 New HV system 60
4-4 PMT Base 30
4-5 Machining and assembling 50
4-6 R&D 40
5 μcounters 300
5-1 RPC 250
5-2 R&D 50
6 Luminosity 50
65
7 Super-conducting magnet 4000*
8 FED electronics 3680
8-1 MDC 9000T+Q 1800
8-2 TOF 512 130
8-3 EMC 10000 1500
8-4 Muon 10000 250
9 Trigger and DAQ 1150
10 Old end-door modification 50
11 Gas,environment and monitor 100
12 others 60
Grand total 21900(4000*)
66
Infrastructure BEPCII needs some building construction: halls for Cryogenic system and additional magnet power supplier; improving shielding of some buildings, etc. Major systems:
– New cryogenic system: capacity of 1kW/4.5K– BEPCII power consumption to be doubled
• 110kV transformer: 6300kVA 12500kVA• New electric crates and apparatus
– Increase capacity of air-conditioning– Improve water circulation system– Improve pure water system
67
Sub-system BES III CLEOc
XY (m) = 130 110-130
MDC P/P (0/0) = 0.5 %(1 GeV) SC
1.25 %(1 GeV) normal
0.5 %(1 GeV)
dE/dx (0/0) = 6-7 % 6%
EMC E/√E(0/0) = 2.5 %(1 GeV)
z(cm) = 0.5cm/√E
2.3 %(1 GeV)0.5 cm /√E
TOF T (ps) = 80 ps Barrel 100 ps endcap
RICH
counter 9- 10 layers 3layers
magnet 1.0 tesla option 1 0.4 tesla option 2
1.0 tesla
Comparison Between BESIII and CLEOc
