132

10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

����������� ��������������������������� "!�����#%$'&����(���)�*�"+�-,.�)�*�/�10���23���45$'��23&�06�*���7�8

9":<;�=?>A@CBED

FHG*I�JLKNMOMQPSRTMQUVMQW*PYX�PSZ[]\�MOJLPS^_M`U]acbedfPhgSMO\OKfgi[]djbe^*k]Kl^*PSPh\OKf^*km[]^*RonpUqJmZ*G�MQPS\6FHghKfPh^*gSPUq^oro[is?tHuqv�t�wqwqx�v*Kf^yZ[]\�MOKz[]d{a|G*df}*dldlJmPh^_MpU]a~MOW*P

\OPS��G*Kl\�PhJmPh^_MQ�`a|Uq\�MQW�PYR�Phkq\�PhP�U]aro[]��MQPh\`U]a�be^*kqKf^*PhPS\OKl^�kmKf^�npUqJLZ�G�MQPS\�F�ghKlPS^*ghPY[]^�Robe^*kqKf^*PhPS\OKf^*k

$' ������2e4<�

���������������������������<�����c�������������S���E�� ¡������¢6�E�¡���£�e¤]��¥������E�c��¦��E���3���p�S���h�j��¦*�h�����������h�E�����S¥)�����S�6������ ��E�O§S��������¨i¤��©��E���� Y���E�p�����]���E�����S���E�i�S�ª�~�E�����3¥����«�S�����¬¦­ "�ª�©®������E�¡�£�����E�¡¢©�¯�|���E�ª¤��©����¢°�£ ©�£�E���¡��±(²°�����E�O�£���h�c�������E���i¢Y�E���¡��³S��E�����������p´z�������h�ª��µj����¦­���| ��������]���E�E�ª������¦�¢©�¯�|���E�ª¤��©����¢3����µS�����¬�����¡�_�������������©¢©��¥)�����S��¤i c�E�O¢©��¥��ª��µ��i���¡���e���h�E���E�S���h�E�ª����±²°�����i¢����������~����µS�����¬�����¡����{¶E·�¸?���©�����¡���¹��¨�������¢©������������©�E�S�������c��ºi�O¥��©�¹��¤��ª��¨h����¢¡�������ª i»��������j�E�O�|�<��º©��¥��©�E�ª�����¼ ���E�?¢© i�������ª¥Y���i�������ª���h�6¢©������¥)�����S��±½�����«�i���¡��� ¼ ����³L�ª�y���E����µm�¾�E����������� �����������`�ª�6�E�O¢©��¥���¢T¤]��¥������E��������E�O¥¹�����¯§h���~���E���i�¯¢©���{� ¼ ��¦­�����¡�<��¦H�S�E�E�ª�£������¥��S¿H�ª�����¡���<µS�����������E��¢`¤h ������e¢© i�������¯¥��ª�i�������ª���S��¢©������¥��E�ª����¦­�������E�~�ª��E����������������Àh����¢¡���E���S���{��¥�����������¨S�S�����S¥)���ª¥���¨hµ��������¹������¢p¦­�����Á�����<��º©�]����������¥�� ¼ ���E�6�E���~¶E·�¸������E���¡���E���¡���©¢©���]����¢�E���(³i��� ¼ �ª��¢©µS�e���(¤]��¢�¢©��¢Y���"�����3�����£���E�����E�(���£�O¢�¦­������º©��¥����E�ª����±�²°���E���£�~�S���j����¥¹�����¯§h���(�S�"�E���E���(¥��S�£�(�£�E��¢©���O��¿�E����Â*���E���¹�E���`ÃQ´z�����i¥����������©�E��������º�¥��ª���£�ª�������ªµ��������E����¨i�(�£�E������µ(¥���¥¹���ª��µ3�ª�����ª�������h�����E�ª���`��¦H�E��������¢��������S�E S¨h����¢Ä��������S�£�OÅ �jÂ��ºi�h�Æ����µS�����¬�����Ǧ­�S��¢©�ª�£�E���ª¤��©�E�O¢�¥������£�����£����±

¶È�p�E����¢����������S�������h������¢��ª�p�������p���h���������S����¦��S���*�p���E���©¢_¨ ¼ �j���ª�E�~�ª������������¢e�E�������h�S�ª��¦­�S��¦­���������i��������®�¥����E�ª�����¦q¶E·�¸y���©�����¡���¹�c����¢�¦­���Æ¢© i�������¯¥����i�������ª���h�¢����E�O¥)�����S��±*²«��¢©�O�E¥��E�ª¤]���c��� ¼ ���i¢����©¦­�S�{�£�]��¥��¬¦­ i�ª��µe¶E·�¸y���©�����¡���¹��ª�É�E����¶|����¤]���ª�����E������������������������Å �3�ª��µS�ª¥�¨�����¢m���������¡�������E������¢©���O�E����¦~���E�O¥¹�����¯§S���6¦­�S�p�S�����¬¦­ i�ª��µ��ª�i�Q���E�¯���h�¹�(�ª��E���ª�����i¢������ª�T�����Y¶|����¤]���ª���Y���E���S���O±Ê²«�Y¢����������S�T�����E���i¢��`¦­�S�6µ��������¹��������µV���E�i��¦N�¡��¦3¶E·S¸Ë���©�E�S�������¾¦­�S�`� ¼ ��E�����������Ì��������������¨������6Ä�����¥¹�ÉÂ{�E���S���e����¢¾¶|�E��¤������ª�Q·�Í�¸�Ä�±H²«���£��� ¼ ���������©¢��(¦­���(��º©��¥����E�ª��µ�¶E·�¸Î�����E���¡������¦­�S��E�O�|������µ�¨]¤h "�����ª� ¼ ����µ��E������º©��¥��©�E�ª���"��¦{�£�S�p�����©�����¡���¹�`¢©��®�����¢ ¼ ���E�Y�����ª�����¹����������¢"��º©�¯�|�����h�E�¯����§h�����h�E��®��������E�����¼ �������������i�ª�����E�ª "�����©´z��º©�O¥��©�¹��¤��ª��±�Ä��S�|���� S¨ ¼ ���������E���h�e�ª�p���E���S�������h���~����¢� h�������ª¥p�ª�i�Q���E�¯���h�e¢©������¥��E�ª���¾���°���¹¢©����E���¡��³S�����e�p�S�E����¥����¯��¤����(ÏÐ���°�����E�E�¯¥����ª����¨ ¼ ���E��� ¼ ��� ¼ �E�"��¥¹���ª���S�(��Ñ¡¥������h�c�ª��¥��E���p���h�����¢© i�������ª¥����i�������¯���h�¢©���E��¥��E�ª����¨ ¼ ���������E���3¢©���E�O¥)�E�ª�������h�S�_�ª���S���ª ����ª�ª� ¼ �O¢¡�E���¡��³S�c�����c���S�E�����S�����¬�¹�j�ª�����©����ºi�O¥��©�����S����±

Ò W*PS�OKl��FHG*Z{Ph\�Ó�Kl�OU]\hÔ(r�Kfg�W[]Phd�X¾Õ�be\�^*��MÒ KfMOdlP�ÔcÖ����OKl��M�[]^_M�×e\OU]a|PS�O�OU]\

Ò W*PS�OKl��FHG*Z{Ph\�Ó�Kl�OU]\hÔ(F�MOPhZ*W*PS^AØ�Õ{Ù�[]\Odl[]^*RÒ KfMOdlP�Ôe×e\OKl^�ghKlZ*[]djÚ`Ph�OPh[]\Og�WÊFHghKfPh^_MQKf��M

Ò W*PS�OKl��FHG*Z{Ph\�Ó�Kl�OU]\hÔ3Û�[�^*gSsyÖ«Õ�Üjs�^*g�WÒ KfMOdlP�Ôe×e\OU]a|PS�O�OU]\

u

Page 2: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

t

Page 3: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� �����������

� �� ������������������� �uqÕNu Ö�g ��^*U�!`dlPSR*kqJmPh^_MQ� Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ uqu

uqÕNuqÕfu Ø]U]Kl^_M"!pU]\#� Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ uqu

$ %&��')(*�,+�* .-/�0�*')1&-/ ��324-5��6879������ �� �):tHÕNu Ò W*PhU]\OPhJ Z�\OU©ÓqPS\O� Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u©xtHÕªt r�U�R*Phdjg�W*PSg �]PS\O� Õ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u�;tHÕ�x X�s�^[]JmKlg�Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M¡R�PSMQPSgSMOKlUq^ÐÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u�;tHÕ=< >@?BA [�G�MQUqJL[�MQ[ ÕYÕ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u�CtHÕED ×e\OUqkq\O[]J Z�\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKlPS� ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u�C

tHÕEDHÕfu FUq\@!�[�\ORy�OKfJ¾G*dz[�MQKlU]^ \OPSdz[�MOKlUq^ ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u�GtHÕEDHÕ¯t >)^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M6[]���OPh\�MQKfUq^ ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ t]wtHÕEDHÕªx ÜjKNÓqPh^�Ph�O� Õ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ t]wtHÕEDHÕH< A�MOW*Ph\`�Q[�a|PSM)sTZ*\�UqZ{Ph\�MOKlPS�AÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ tHu

tHÕHI Ò W*PJ>@A6Ö5dz[�^*kqG[]k]P ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ tHutHÕE; Ú6PSdz[�MOPhRK!�Uq\#� ÕYÕ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ tqt

tHÕE;HÕfu Ö�I*��MO\Q[]g�MQKfUq^ ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ tqttHÕE;HÕ¯t L3PS\OKNaÈsHKf^*kVZ[]\O[]JmPSMQPS\OKNMhPhRy��sH��MQPSJL�mÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ t]x

: OP'Q��R����.��(*�975S $9Tx�ÕNu FHZ{PhghKNaÈs�Kl^*kÉ[]dfkqUq\�KfMQW�JL�p[]�U>@?BA []GHMQUqJL[�M�[ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ tBDx�Õªt bWV�PSghG�MOKl^*kL[]G�MOUqJL[�M�[ Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ t�Ix�Õ�x X�s�^[]JmKlg�Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M¡R�PSMQPSgSMOKlUq^ÐÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ tB;x�Õ=< ×�[]Kf\OPSR?PXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^ Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ t�Cx�ÕED ×e\OU©Ó�Kl^*kÉZ*\�UqZÆPS\�MOKlPh� ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ t�G

x�ÕEDHÕfu ×e\�U�Ó�Kf^*kÉKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ� ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ t�Gx�ÕEDHÕ¯t ×e\�U�Ó�Kf^*km[m��KlJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^ \�Phdl[�MQKfUq^ Õ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ x�u

x�ÕHI Ö����OPh���OJmPh^_M ÕYÕYÕ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ xqx

Y Z&-51�'[1\�������*')1 :^]<*ÕNu ×~P�MQPh\��OUq^�J¾G�MOG[]d�PXV�gSdlG*��KlUq^�[]dfkqUq\OKNMQW*J Õ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ x_;

<*ÕNuqÕfu ×�PSMOPh\O��Uq^oKf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MO�¡R*PSMOPhg�MQPhR�I_syX"[]K`��Uq^ ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ xBC<*ÕNuqÕ¯t ×e\�U�Ó�Kf^*km×~PSMOPh\��OUq^�Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ� ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <_w

<*Õªt Ö�MQUqJmKlg�JLPSJLUq\�s a|Uq\¡R�Kl��MO\OKfI*G�MQPSRygi[]g�W*PS� Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <*u<*ÕªtHÕfu bWVHPhgSG�MQKf^*kÉMQW*P�gi[�g�W*P°[�G�MQUqJL[�MOUq^ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <*u

x

Page 4: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

<*ÕªtHÕ¯t >)^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MQ�`\�Ph��G*Kl\�PhR�[]^*RyR*P�MQPhg�MQPSR�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <�t<*ÕªtHÕªx Ò W�PY��KlJ¾G�dz[�MOKlUq^ \�Phdl[�MQKfUq^ Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <B<<*ÕªtHÕH< ×e\�U�Ó�Kf^*kVMQW*P��OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^ \OPSdz[�MOKlUq^ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <B<<*ÕªtHÕ D Ö��O��Ph�O��JLPS^_M ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <QD

<*Õ�x X�Kl��MQ\OKfI*G�MOPhR?npUq^*��Ph^*��G*� !`KNMQW?×�[�V�U]�¾Õ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <QD<*Õ�x�Õfu F�ZÆPSghKf}*gi[�MOKlUq^?[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^ ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <QD<*Õ�x�Õ¯t >)JmZ*dfPhJmPh^_M�[�MOKlUq^ []G�MQU]J [�MOUq^ ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <_I<*Õ�x�Õªx bWVHPhgSG�MQKf^*kÉMQW*P«Ù"dlUqI[�d�u"[]GHMQUqJL[�MQU]^'ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <_I<*Õ�x�ÕH< X�s�^[�JLKfg�Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M¡R*P�MQPhg�MQKfUq^�\�Ph��G*dfMO�ÁÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <_C<*Õ�x�Õ D ×~[]Kl\�PhRyP VHPSghG�MOKlUq^ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <_G<*Õ�x�ÕEI L3PS\OKNaÈsHKf^*kÉ[V�OKfJ¾G*dz[�MQKlU]^ \OPSdz[�MOKlUq^TKf^�Ü�× Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ DHu

T � � R���'����, .7�� -51\��� 1��B-5(*-�W(�' -5 �� �B�9�0��')��� ��S. �-/+�,� �* �/-/�0��-5 ^� �.'_��')�����*�� T9TDHÕNu >)^_MQ\OU�R*G*g�MQKfUq^1ÕYÕYÕ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ DBD

DHÕNuqÕfu Ò Ph\�JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ D�IDHÕNuqÕ¯t Û�[]KfÓ]P�[]dlk]Uq\OKNMQW*J ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ DB;DHÕNuqÕªx npU]\O\OPSgSMO^*Ph����Z*\�UqZÆPS\�MOKlPh� Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ DB;DHÕNuqÕH< ×�Ph\�a|Uq\OJL[]^*gSP«[�^[]dfs���Kl� ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ D�C

DHÕªt Ù�Uq[]d�Ô~PhdlKfJLKf^[�MOP�Kl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MQ�`[�^*RyR*Ph\�KfÓqPSR�Ó�[]\�Kz[]I*dfPh� Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ D�GDHÕªtHÕfu bedfKlJmKl^[�MOKlUq^ÉM)s�ZÆP�Ô���M�[�MOKlg�v*R�s�^[]JmKlg"^*PSk_[�MOKfÓqP�Uq\¡RHsH^*[]JLKfg"ZÆU]�OKfMOKfÓ]P Õ«ÕYÕ IqwDHÕªtHÕ¯t Ú`Ph��UqG*\�ghPh�6�Q[iÓ]PhRoKf^yPhdlKfJLKf^[�MOKlUq^�Ô�MQKfJLP�v���Z[]ghPYUq\¡Z*\�Kl^_MQKf^*k Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Iqw

DHÕ�x ×e\OPSÓ�KfUqG*�`UqZ�MOKlJmK`Mi[�MQKlU]^*�ÌÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ I�uDHÕ�x�Õfu �6KlPS\Q[]\�g�W�sT[]^*R �U�! ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ I�uDHÕ�x�Õ¯t Û6KlJmJLPS\��¬�pMQW�Ph�OKf�`Z[]��MOP]v*MOULI{P"PhR*KNMQPSR ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ I�uDHÕ�x�Õªx F�M�[]kqPSR�Kf^�a|Ph\�Ph^*gSP°ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ I�uDHÕ�x�ÕH< L([�\OKz[�I*dlP�U]\OR*PS\OKl^�k Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ I_tDHÕ�x�Õ D npU]^*�OPS��G�Ph^*gSPh��U]a�Ó�[]\OKl[]I*dfP�Uq\OR�Ph\OKf^*kÌÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ IqxDHÕ�x�ÕEI >)^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M��U�! Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ I�<DHÕ�x�Õ ; FH[]JLZ�dlP��U�! ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ I�<DHÕ�x�ÕEC ×~[�MQW�� ÕYÕ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ I_DDHÕ�x�ÕEG �6KlPS\Q[]\�g�W�s �OW[]Z{PÊÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ I_D

DHÕ=< ��[]^�R*dlKf^*kVPh��G[]dfKfM)s5Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ IBIDHÕ=<*Õfu npU]Z�s�Kf^*k [�^*RyKl^*��M�[]^_MQKl[�MQKfUq^TU]a~Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�ÇÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ IBCDHÕ=<*Õ¯t FH[]JLZ�dlP�gSUqG*^_MQ�«Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ;HuDHÕ=<*Õªx r?Kl�O��Kl^*kÉR[�M�[V�Q[]JmZ*dfPh�AÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ;qtDHÕ=<*ÕH< Û6UÉJLUq\�P"^*Uq^��¹Kl^*��M�[]^_MOKz[�MOKlUq^ U�a�Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MO�LÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ;qtDHÕ=<*Õ D ×�Uq��M6Z*\�UHgSPh���OKl^�k%ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ; <

DHÕED FHG*Z*Z�\OPh���OKfUq^�U]Z�MQKfJLKNMi[�MOKlUq^ÎÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ;BDDHÕEDHÕfu F�G*Z*Z*\�Ph�O��KlUq^ya£[]g�MQUq\�KlPh� ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ;�GDHÕEDHÕ¯t ��[]^*R*dfKl^*kV��G*Z*Z*\�Ph���OKlU]^oR*G*\�Kl^*kmX"[]KN�]Uq^����¡\�G*^ ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ;�GDHÕEDHÕªx F�G*Z*Z*\�Ph�O��Uq\O�6MQW[�M`R*UÉ^*U]M6W[iÓqP�MQW*PSKl\�Ó�[]dfG*Ph�¡��PSMÉÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ C�uDHÕEDHÕH< F�G*Z*Z*\�Ph�O��KlUq^?gSs�gSdlPh� ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ C�u

DHÕHI npUq^*R*KNMQKfUq^[]dÆKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M¡R*PSMOPhg�MQKlU]^ ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ C�uDHÕHI�Õfu >)^�gh\OPSJLPS^_M�[]djR*P�MQPSgSMQKfUq^?U]a�gSUq^*R*KNMQKfUq^[]dÆKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�?Õ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ C_t

<

Page 5: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

DHÕE; FG*^*gSMOKlUq^TZ*[]\Q[]JmPSMOPh\�� Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ C�<DHÕHC FG�MQG*\�P !pU]\#� ÕYÕYÕ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ C�<DHÕHG npUq^*gSdlG*��KlUq^½Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ C_D

� ��+����������, .7 ��R�' ��� ��� �*+ ��(�- ���9� �^]I�ÕNu FHKlJ°G*dz[�MOKl^*k«Z[]Kf\OPhR?[]GHMQUqJL[�M�[ ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ C_;I�Õªt ��[]^�R*dlKf^*kV��G[]^_MQKN}Ph\��6Kf^TMQW*P«FHKfJ¾G*dz[�MQUq\ËÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ CBC

I�ÕªtHÕfu F�UqG*^*R?P VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ CBCI�ÕªtHÕ¯t �6^*�OU]G*^*RoPXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^ ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ CBG

I�Õ�x npUq^*^*PSgSMOKl^*kÉMQUVMQW�P«X"[�K`�]U]^TKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M`R*PSMOPhgSMOUq\ Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ CBGI�Õ�x�Õfu Ò \Q[�^*�Odl[�MQKfUq^TU]a~J []ZyR[�M�[V��MO\OG*g�MQG*\�Ph� ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ GqwI�Õ�x�Õ¯t npU]^*R*KfMOKlUq^*[]d<��Z*dlKNMOMQKf^*k¾Kf^ >@A`Ö ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Gqw

] �� -5������+ - ��- �* ��1\- � ')(,(�'� ') �R.-5 ��_�, .7 ��R.' ��'�����')1�') ^��- ���*�� � � � �� -5������+ - ��- �* ��R.'������ �^'Q� �9:;HÕNu Ò W*P«r�G*PSdldlPS\¡JLU�R*PSdÌÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Gqx;HÕªt Ò W*P�^*P\! >)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP�JmUHR�Phd�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ G_;

;HÕªtHÕfu r?PSM�[VMQW�PhUq\�s a|Uq\�MQW�PY^�P\!P>@?BA []G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^TJmUHR�Phd ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u©w]w;HÕªtHÕ¯t F�KlJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^ \�Phdl[�MQKfUq^*�pÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u©wHu

;HÕ�x Ö����OPh���OJmPh^_M ÕYÕYÕ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u©w <� � �,1 �_��1 1 ���� ����T

C�ÕNu FG*\�MOW*Ph\¡\�Ph�OPh[]\Og�WÁÕ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u©wBDC�ÕNuqÕfu >)JmZ*\�U�Ó]PhR?R�s�^[]JmKlg"Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M¡R�PSMQPSgSMOKlUq^ ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u©wBDC�ÕNuqÕ¯t >)JmZ*\�U�Ó]PhR?Z*\OU�U]a~�OgS\OKlZHMQ�¡a|\OUqJ []G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^yghU�R*P ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u©wBDC�ÕNuqÕªx ×e\�Uqkq\Q[�JLJmKl^*k°Kl^ MQW�PYZ�\OU©ÓqPS\�dl[]^*kqG[�kqP Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u©wBDC�ÕNuqÕH< F~KldfMOPh\�Kl^*k¾Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MO� !`KfMOW?[]G�MQU]J [�MOPhRyW*PSG*\OKf��MQKfgh�¡a|Uq\¡Z*\�UHU�a|� ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u©w�I

C�Õªt npUq^*gSdlG*��KlUq^½Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u©wB;� � ���� ��� .' 1�1������8� �U� � �* � -/�0�*-5 �� + '_��R��8� �, ��1�-� ' (*(�' �����2 � R.' % -��8�^1 1 �*+ ��(�- ������ ��')(*- ���*�� ������8� � �, ��1�-� ' (*(�' ���)T

D

Page 6: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

I

Page 7: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� � � ��� � ����� �

t ��u Ö Z*\OU�U]a~U]a~��s�dldfUqkqKl��J�Kf^?Ü�×�Õ�ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u�Dt ��t Ö Z*\OU�U]a~U]a~��s�dldfUqkqKl��J�I_sygh[]�OPS��Kf^K>)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP]Õ ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ u�Ix ��u Ö�^?U©ÓqPh\�Ó�KlP\!�U]a�U]G*\¡JLP�MQW*U�R ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ t�Ix ��t Ö� �������TI*dfUHg � U�ac[¾a|Uq\@!�[]\�R���KlJ¾G�dz[�MOKlUq^L\OPhdl[�MQKfUq^�Õ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ x_Dx ��x F�[]JmZ*dlP�UqG�MQZ�G�M6U]a~MOW*P�Z*\OU�U]a�M�[]g�MQKfgh�¡kqPS^*Ph\O[�MQPSR�a|Uq\¡Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M¡Z�\OU�U]a|�¡Kl^ >)�Q[�IÆPSdldlP�Õ xBI< ��u F�M�[�MQP ��MQ\O[]^*�OKNMQKfUq^ R*Kl[]kq\Q[�J�a|Uq\¡Uq^�PYZ�\OU�ghPh���`Kl^TMQW*PY×�PSMQPS\O��Uq^Ê[]dfkqUq\�KfMQW�J�Õ Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ xBC< ��t Ò W*PY×~P�MQPh\��OUq^?M !pU �)Z*\�UHgSPh�O�6J¾G�MOG[]djPXV�gSdlG*��KlUq^?[]dfkqUq\�KfMQW�J�Kf^ >@A`Ö°Õ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ xBG< ��x Ò W*P��OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^?[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^�v �����<Õ¡Õ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <�t< � < F�MQ\�Uq^*kqdNs gh[]g�W*Kl^�kmKfJLZ�dlPhJmPh^_MQ[�MQKfUq^�v � �������*Õ?ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <_x< �@D Ò W*P��OKfJ¾G*dz[�MQKlU]^ \OPSdz[�MOKlUq^y[]^�R?PXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^Ê[]^*^�U]M�[�MOKlUq^���IÆP�M !pPSPh^�������[]^�R�� �������*Õ`Õ <B<< � I FHZ{PhghKN}gi[�MQKlU]^TU]acgSUq^*�OPS^*�OG���Kl^K>@A`Ö Õ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <_I< �@; Ö I[]dfdlU]M �)I[]��PhRTKfJLZ*dfPhJmPh^_M�[�MQKlU]^ U]a~ghUq^*��Ph^*��G*��Kf^ >@A6Ö ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ <Q;< � C FUq\ !p[]\ORy��KlJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^ \�Phdz[�MQKlU]^T[]^*R?��MOPhZogSUq\O\�Ph��ZÆUq^�R*Ph^*gSP"!# �������TI*dfUHg � $�a|\OU]J MQW*P

%�& �('�� &�) �OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^*!*F�KlkqG�\OP <�Õªx�ÕNu($eMQU°MOW*P+���(,.-«KlJmZ*dfPhJmPh^_M�[�MOKlUq^�!,F~KlkqG*\�P <�Õªx�ÕNu($�Õ D]wD ��u L([]\OKl[]I*dfPh��G��OPhR½Kl^�MQW*PV\�G*^*^*Kf^*k MQKfJLP°[]^*R �OZ[�ghPm[]^[]dNs��OPh�/!|�OPSPmFHPhg�MQKlU]^ D�ÕfuqÕ=< a|Uq\

R*PSMQ[]Kldf�0$�ÕcÖ�dfd<Ó�[]\OKl[]I*dlPS��P VHgSPhZ�M6a|Uq\2143�v6573�v�8¡v�[]^�R�8:9�[]\OPJ��^*U�!`^o��M�[�MOKlgi[�dldfs]Õ ÕYÕ D�CD ��t ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ I_tD ��x ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ I_tD � < ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ I_DD �@D Ò W*PY[]R�Ó�[]^_M�[�kqP�U]a�W*[]^*R*dfKl^*kVPS��G*[]dlKNM)s �OZ{PhgSKz[]dfdfs Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ IBID � I ;ËW*Ph^�<��OZ�dlKfMO�¡U>=Êa|\�UqJ�?�@�A0B�C°KNM`Kl�¡^*U]M6[�R*Ph��G[�MOPYMOUL��KlJmZ*dfsLghU]Z�sTMOW*P�Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�

a|\OUqJ/MOW*P UqdfR�dlPh[]R*PS\«MQU�MQW*PL^*P\!�Õ Ò W*PLM !pUAkq\O[isqPhR �)UqG�M¾Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�hvEDF!G@�A0<H$«[]^�RI !G@�A0<�AKJ.$��OW*U�! !`W[�MU!pU]G*dlR?IÆP�JmKl���OKl^�k*Õ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ IBC

D �@; FHUqdNÓHKf^*k`MQW*P�ghUqZ_s�Kl^*k�Z*\OUqI�dlPhJ5I_s&�]PhPSZ*Kl^�k�Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ��Uq^°MOW*Pp�O[]JLP(Ó�[]\OKl[]I*dlP�Õ�Ü�Kf^*Ph�ghUq^�^*Phg�MQKl^�kmKf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MO��MQUVÓ�[]\OKl[]I*dfPh�¡W[iÓqPYI{PhPh^?\OPSJLU©Ó]PhRya|Uq\¡ghdl[]\OKNM)sqÕÁÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ;]w

D � C npUqZ_s�Kl^*k U�a3Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�6G*�OKf^*k ghU]J¾I*Kl^*[�MQKfUq^*�U!`KfMQW�\OPSZÆP�MQKfMOKlUq^<v�!`W*PS\OPL@yKl�6MQW*P«UqdlRdlPh[]R*Ph\`[�^*R�<�Kl��MQW�PY^�P\!�dfPi[]R�Ph\hÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ;]w

D � G A�Z�MQKfJLKNMhKl^�k�MQW*P�ghUqZ_s�Kl^*k�[]^*R¾\�P �PXV�KNÓqP�Z�\OU�ghPh���hÕ(FHU]JLP(Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�.!`KfMOW°JmUq\OP3MQW[�^Uq^*P�Kl^���M�[�^*ghP"U]ac[¾Ó][�\OKz[�I*dlP�R�Um^�U]M6W[iÓqP"MQUmIÆP"Kf^*��MQ[]^_MQKl[�MQPSR�ÕAÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ;Hu

D ��uiw >¹M�Kf� !`\�Uq^*k*v�[]�p��W*U�!`^TW*Ph\�P]v�MOUV[]�O��G*JmP4MON MOPQ!R<S$(W*UqdlR���P�ÓqPh^TMOW*UqG*kqW"@ÉKf�pJmKl���OKl^�k*Õ>¹M`ghUqG�dlRyIÆP"MOW*P�gi[]��PYMOW[�MT<�Kf�¡^*U]M6PSÓ]Ph^�Õ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ;]x

D ��u]u >¹MeKl��!`\OUq^*k�v�[]�c�OW�U�!`^mW*PS\OP]vqMOU�[]�O��G*JmP2MON MOP:!G<H$�R*U�Ph�c^�U]M3W*UqdfR !`W*Ph^U@�Kl�cJmKl���OKl^�k*Õ>¹M`ghUqG�dlRyIÆP"MOW*P�gi[]��PYMOW[�MWVÊKl�¡P�ÓqPh^<Õ ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ; <

;

Page 8: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

D ��u©t Ò W*PÉ�OUqG�^*R !p[isAMQUTW[�^*R*dlPVJmKl���OKf^*k Ó�[]dlG*PS�hÔ ��PhPhZÁ[ M !pU � !�[is PS��G*[]dlKNM)sÊKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MIÆP�M !pPSPh^�@ []^*R�<�[]^*Ry��Z*dlKNM`U>=ÊMQW�PYPS��G[]dlKNM)s ��PSMQ�SÕ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ;BD

D ��uix Ò W*P Z�\OUqI*dfPhJ !`KNMQW�^*U�M°Kf^*��MQ[]^_MQKz[�MQKl^�k?Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MO�°[�^*R�\OPSdfs�Kl^�k�Uq^½MQW*PLR[�MQ[ �U�!W*KlPS\Q[]\�g�W_soÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«Õ�ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ;�I

D ��u�< A�^*P !p[is�MOUÊghUq\�\OPSgSM°MOW*P Z*\�UqI*dfPhJ/U]a`^*U]^��)Kf^*��MQ[]^_MQKz[�MQKlU]^�Ô«Kf^*��MQ[]^_MQKl[�MQPmKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�MQW[�M"!pUqG�dlR?W*UqdlRTU]^�PS��G*[]dlKNM)s dlPh[]R*PS\O�6[�M`PSÓ]Ph\�syZ*\OUqk]\Q[]J Z{UqKf^�MhÕ ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ;B;

D ��u�D�Ö�^*U�MQW*PS\ !�[is�MQUÊgSUq\O\�PhgSM°MQW*P Z�\OUqI*dfPhJ U]a`^*U]^��)Kf^*��MQ[]^_MQKz[�MQKlU]^�Ô¾ghU]Z�sÁ\OPSdlPSÓ�[]^_M°Kl^��Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ��a|\OU]J G*Z*Z{Ph\`Z*\�Uqkq\O[]J Z{UqKl^_MO�6G�ZÆUq^y��Z*dlKNMOMQKf^*k°MOW*P�Ph��G[]dfKfM)sT��PSMiÕ Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ ;�C

D ��u IÇFHG*Z*Z�\OPh���OKfUq^-Kf^Î[]gSMOKlUq^�a|Uq\¾MOW*PTdlU]kqKlgh[]dpKfJLZ*dfKlgh[�MQKfUq^*��������� ��� ����� []^�R������� �� ������� ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Cqw

; ��u Ò W*P��OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^?[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^�v �����yMO\Q[]^*��dz[�MOPhRTMQU >)�O[]IÆPSdldfP ÕYÕ�Õ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ GBG

C

Page 9: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� � ��� ��� �

� ��� ��� � � � � ���

Ö��4!�PTKl^�gh\OPh[]�OKf^*kqdNs \OPhdNsÁU]^ÇghUqJmZ*G�MOPh\O�VKf^�UqG*\°dlKfÓ]Ph�SvcMQW*P gSUq\O\�Phg�MQ^*PS�O�ÉU]a6�OU]aÈM !p[]\�PT��s���MOPhJm�VUq^MQW�Ph�OP�ghUqJmZ*G�MOPh\O�pIÆPSghUqJmPh��gh\OG�ghKz[�d�Õ Ò W�P�Z*\OU]I*dlPSJ U�ajR*PhJmUq^*��MQ\O[�MQKf^*k«MOW*P�gSUq\O\�PhgSMO^*Ph���¡U]a��OU�aÈM !�[]\�PKl� ��^*U�!`^½[]���� ������������������ ��� �����!�#"Õ"L3Ph\OKNaÈs�Kl^*kL�OU]aÈM !p[]\OP°Kl�6KlJmZÆUq\�M�[]^_M6I{Phgi[�G*�OP¾KNM�k]KfÓqPS��G*��ghUq^�}��R*PS^*ghP`MQW[�M�U]G*\e��s���MOPhJm��Z{Ph\�a|Uq\OJ []�3R*Ph��Klkq^*PSR [�^*RLR�U«^*U�M3IÆPSW[iÓqP6W[]\OJÉa|G*dfdfsqÕ Ò W*P6JLU]��M3R*K%$LgSG*dfM�OU�aÈM !�[]\�PA��s���MOPhJm�TMQU�ÓqPS\OKNaÈs []\�PAR*Kl��MQ\�KlI*G�MOPhR�v`Uq\ ghUq^*gSG*\O\�Ph^_Miv�Uq^*PS�hÔ�MOW*Ph��P ghUqJ¾I�Kl^*P?MQW*PAgSUqJ �Z*dfP VHKfM)s U]a~MO\Q[]R�KfMQKfUq^[]dEv�ghPh^_MO\Q[]dfK`MhPSRy�OU]aÈM !p[]\OP���sH��MQPSJL�U!`KfMOWyMOW*P"^*Uq^�R*PSMOPh\OJmKl^�Kl�OJ a|\OUqJ�Z*\OU�ghPS�O��Ph�Kl^_MOPh\OdfPi[iÓ�Kl^*k¾MOW*PhKf\¡P VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^*�SÕ

Ò W*Ph\�P°[�\OP"JL[]^_sTR*Ph��Kl\O[]I*dlP�[�MOMO\OKlI�G�MQPS�6Kf^T�OU]aÈM !p[]\�PYÓ]Ph\OKN}gi[�MQKlU]^ MQPhg�W�^*Kl��G*PS�hÕ Ò W�P�MOPhg�W*^�Kl��G*P �¬�ghU]\O\OPSgSMO^*Ph����kqG[�\Q[]^_MQPSP���W*UqG*dfR«I{P�[]��J [�MOW*PhJL[�MOKlgi[�dldfs`a|Uq\�J [�d_[]��ZÆUq���OKfI*dlP�v���U�MOW[�M�KfMO����M�[�MOPhJmPh^_M�U]aghU]\O\OPSgSMO^*Ph����Kf�cZ*\OPSghKf�OP6[]^*RVMQW�P6��s���MQPSJ gi[�^LI{P¡R*Kl��ghG*���OPSRLG*��Kl^*k"MOW*P¡��MQ[]^*R[]\�RmMOUHU]dl��U�a<JL[�MQW�PhJL[�M �KlgS�hÕ'&(P�Miv�MQW*P`ÓqPS\OKN}gi[�MOKlUq^m�OW�UqG*dlRL^*U]M(\OPS��G*Kl\�P�PXVHMO\OPSJLP�[]JLU]G*^_MQ�3U]a�PH=<U]\�M(a|\OUqJ MOW*P�Z�\OUqkq\O[]JmJLPS\hÕÒ W*P¡ÓqPS\OKN}gi[�MOKlUq^V��W*UqG*dfRm[]dl��U"Z*\OU©Ó�KlR*P¡Kf^_MQG*KNMQKlU]^¾\OPSk_[]\OR�Kl^*k !`W_s¾MOW*P`�OU]aÈM !p[]\OP`��sH��MQPSJ Kl�cKf^*ghUq\�\OPSgSMiÕÜ�[]��MOdfs]v�Ph\�\OUq\��°��W*UqG*dfR�IÆPLgi[]G�kqW_MV[]�«Pi[]\�dfs½[]�«ZÆUq���OKfI*dlPmKl^½MQW*PLR*Ph��Klkq^�Z*\OU�ghPS�O�¾Kf^ÁUq\�R*Ph\YMQUo�O[iÓqPZ*\�Uqkq\Q[�JLJmPh\pMOKlJmP"[]^*R?JmKl^*KfJLKNMhP6W[]\OJ�MQUVMQW*P�G*��Ph\�� !`W*Um\OPSdfs Uq^?MOW*P���s���MOPhJ?Õ

×e\OUqkq\O[]J [�^[]dfs���Kl�VJmPSMQW�UHR*�¾a|U]\°ÓqPS\OKf}*gi[�MOKlUq^�gi[�^ÎI{Pyghdl[]�O��Kf}PSRÎKf^_MQUÊM !�U�gh[�MQPSkqUq\OKfPh�SÔ ��MQ[�MQKfg[]^*RÎR�s�^[]JmKlg �¬ØqÚ6wqw �EÕ-F�M�[�MOKlg JmPSMOW*U�R*�m[]^[]dNs MSPy[½Z�\OUqkq\O[]J !`KNMQW*U]G�MÉP VHPhgSG�MQKf^*k½KfMiÕÁÖ ��UqG*^*R<vghU]^*�OPS\�Ó�[�MQKNÓqP6��MQ[�MQKfg6JmPSMOW*U�RLZ*\�UHR�G*ghPS��a|Uq\�J []d�kqG[]\O[]^_MQPhPS��I{Phgh[]G*��P�KfMO�3\OPh��G*dfMO��W�UqdlRVa|Uq\([]dfdP VHPhgSG��MQKfUq^*�SÕ ��U�!�PSÓqPS\hv�ÓqPh\�KfaÈs�Kl^�k«kqPS^*Ph\O[]d�ghUq\�\OPSgSMQ^�Ph�O��Z*\OU]ZÆPS\�MQKfPh�W!£KEÕ�P�Õfv_MOW*Uq�OP`MQW*[�M(kqU«I{PSs]Uq^*RL\OPhdl[�MQKNÓqPSdfs�OKfJLZ�dlPmZ*\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKfPh�°dfK`��PmM)s�Z{P ghUq\�\OPSgSMQ^�Ph�O� $«a|Uq\¾[�dld3P VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^*�VU]a¡[oZ*\OU]kq\Q[]J Kf�°G*^*R�PhghKfR[]I*dfP]Õ�Ö��MQ[�MQKfgVJLP�MQW*U�R MQW[�M«[�M�MQPSJLZ�MO��MQUyÓqPS\OKfaÈsÊ�OG*g�W�k]Ph^*PS\Q[]deZ*\�UqZ{Ph\�MOKlPS�YPSKfMOW*Ph\�\OPS��MO\OKlg�MQ��KfMO�OPSdfa(MQU?Z[]\ �MQKfghG*dl[]\¡ghdl[]�O��Ph��U]acZ*\�Uqkq\O[]JL�`Uq\6\OPS��G*Kl\�Ph��dl[]\Ok]P�[]JLU]G*^_MQ�6U]aeW�G*JL[]^�Kf^_MQPh\O[]gSMOKlUq^<Õ Ò W�G*�hv�ÓqPS\OKfaÈs�Kf^*kghU]\O\OPSgSMO^*Ph��� !`KfMOWo��MQ[�MQKfg«JmPSMOW*U�R*��Kf��[�^oP VHZ{Ph^*��KfÓ]P¾UqZ{Ph\Q[�MQKlU]^�Kf^?MOPh\OJm�6U]aeZ*\�Uqkq\Q[�JLJmPh\¡MQKfJLP�a|U]\[]^_sTgSUqJLZ�dlP V ��s���MOPhJ?Õ

>)^ogSUq^_MQ\Q[���MivRHsH^*[]JLKfg�[]^[]dNs��OKl�¡JmPSMOW*U�R*�"!pUq\ �TUqZ{Ph\Q[�MQKlU]^[]dldNs)( MQW[�M6Kf�hv*I_syP V�[]JmKl^�Kl^*kVPXV�P �ghGHMQKlU]^*�hÕWF�U]\�[�Z�\OUqkq\O[]JP!`KfMOW¾[�dl[]\OkqP(Uq\�Kl^�}*^*KfMOP���PSMeU]a�PXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^*�hv�[6R�s�^[]JmKlg�[�^[]dfs���Kl��P V�[]JmKl^*PS�Uq^*dNs [y�OG*I*��PSM°U]apMOW*PLPXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^*�hÕ Ò W*PÉMQPSg�W*^*Kf��G�P Kl��G*^��OUqG*^�R�Kfa�KfMY[�M�MQPSJLZ�MO�YMOU�k]Ph^*PS\Q[]dfK`MhP¾a|U]\[]dfd�PXV�PSghG�MOKlUq^��hÕ½Û�P�ÓqPh\�MQW*PSdlPS�O�hv�R�s�^[]JmKlg []^[]dNsH��Kl�«Kl�¾G*��PSa|G*d�IÆPSgi[]G��OPyKfM°\OPh��G*Kf\OPS�¾ghUqJmZ[]\O[�MQKNÓqPSdfsdlKNMOMOdlP�Z*\�Uqkq\O[]JLJmPh\cMOKlJmP]Õ Ò W*P�Z*\�Uqkq\O[]JLJmPh\eJmPh\�PhdNsV^*PhPSR*��MOU°PXV�PSghG�MOP�MOW*P�Z*\�Uqkq\O[]J Uq^L�OUqJmP¡MQPh��M�OG�KfMQP�v*[]^�R Z[]���pMQW*P�P VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^TR[�MQ[«MQU°MOW*P�R�s�^[�JLKfg�[]^*[]dfs��OKf�hÕ+*�Phgi[�G*�OP"U]ajMOW*Kl��dlU�! MQKfJLP6ghU]��MpMOUZ*\�Uqkq\Q[�JLJmPh\��hv_R�s�^[]JmKlg`[�^[]dfs���Ph�hv��OG�g�WT[]�eMQPS��MQKf^*k*v�W[iÓqP�Z*\OU©Ó]Ph^ G��OPSa|G�dÆKf^É}*^*R*Kl^�k«PS\O\OU]\O�(��G�Klg ��dfs[]^*R?Pi[�\Odfs Kl^yR*P�ÓqPhdfUqZ*JmPh^_MiÕ

G

Page 10: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ò W*P�Z*\OKfJ [�\�sÉZ*G*\�ZÆU]�OP"U]a�MQW�Kl�pMOW*Ph��Kl�¡Kl�(MQUVZ*\�Ph��Ph^_M�[¾JLP�MQW*U�R*UqdfUqk]sÉa|Uq\�Ó]Ph\�KfaÈs�Kl^*k¾MOW*P"ghU]\O\OPSgSM �^*PS�O�(U]a�R*Kf��MO\OKlI�G�MQPSRL[�dlkqUq\�KfMOW*JL�~MQW[�M(gSUqJ¾I*Kf^*Ph�cMOW*P���MQ\�Ph^*k]MOW*�(U]a���M�[�MOKlg`[]^*RmR�s�^[]JmKlg¡Ó]Ph\OKN}gi[�MQKlU]^MQPSg�W*^*Kf��G�Ph�hÕ&A�G*\�JLP�MQW*U�Ro\�PS}^*PS��[]^*RAKf^�MOPhkq\O[�MQPS��M !�U a|Uq\OJmPh\�dfsyR*Kf����UqKf^_M�I*GHM"G*�OP�a|G*d~MOPhg�W*^�Kl��G*Ph�SÕÒ W*PÊ}\���MTMOPhg�W*^*Kf��G*PÊa|Uq\OJL[]dfdfsÇJmUHR�Phdl�LR*Kl��MQ\�KlI*G�MOPhRË[]dfkqUq\�KfMQW�JL�m[]� >@?�AC[]GHMQUqJL[�M�[ �¬Ü Ò CBG �"[�^*RZ*\�U�Ó]Ph��MOW*PhJ ghUq\�\OPSgSM"G*��Kl^*k [ ��� � �#� ����� ���#������v<[ k]Ph^*PS\Q[]d �)Z*G*\�ZÆU]�OP°��M�[�MOKlgYÓqPh\�Kf}gh[�MQKfUq^�MOUHU]d�Õ Ò W*P�OPSghUq^�RoMQPSg�W*^*Kl��G*P�vÆgh[]dldfPhR��#" ��� �!�� " �#��������" ��� ��� � ��� �!�#" � b(n¡ÙYÛ�w�uiI �Ev�MQ[��]PS��Kf^�PXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^�MQ\O[]ghPS�U]a{[�Z*\�Uqkq\O[]J []^*RVghU]^ ��Phg�MQG*\�Ph�eZ{Uq�O��KlI*dfPpZ*\�UqZÆPS\�MOKlPh��[]I{UqG�McMOW*P�Z*\�Uqkq\Q[�J Kf^¾kqPS^*Ph\O[]d�ÕWA�G*\cJmPSMQW�UHR��UqdfUqk]s !pUq\ ����[]�¡a|UqdfdlU�!`�hÔuqÕ FUq\�J []dfdfs JLU�R*Phd�MQW�PV[]dlk]Uq\OKNMQW*J [���[]^[>@?BA []GHMQUqJL[�MQU]^�Õ Ò W�P >@?BA []G�MQU]J [�MOUq^oJmU�R*Phd�Kl��[JL[�MQW�PhJL[�MQKfgi[]d9!�[isTMOULR*PS�OgS\OKlI{P�R*Kl��MQ\�KlI*G�MOPhR�[]dlk]Uq\OKNMQW*Jm��[]�`��M�[�MOPYJL[]g�W*Kf^*Ph� !`W�Uq�OP«[]gSMOKlUq^��[]\�P"dz[]I{PhdfPhR�Õ

tHÕ *pG�KldlRy[¾MOPh��M`��G*KfMOP]v*MOPh��M¡MOW*PJ>@?BA [�G�MQUqJL[�MOUq^TI_sTP VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^�v�[]^�Ry} V?[]^_sTPh\�\OUq\���MQW[�M6[]\OKf�OP]Õx�Õ`Ö�^[]dfs)MSP�MQW�P�PXV�PSghG�MOKlUq^��cU©ÓqPh\�MQW*P(MQPS��Mc��G*KfMOP�G��OKl^�k�R�s�^[]JmKlg(Kl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M�R*PSMOPhg�MQKlU]^«MQU�Z*\OU�R*G*gSP[V�OP�M6U]acgh[]^*R*KfR[�MQP"Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MO��MQW[�M6[]\OP�dlKN�]PSdfsmMQUÉIÆP"MO\OG*P"a|Uq\�MOW*PY[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^�Õ

<*Õ6×e\OU©Ó]PYMOW*PY[]dlkqU]\OKfMOW*J+ghUq\�\OPSgSM�G*�OKf^*km[VMOW*PhU]\OPhJ Z�\OU©ÓqPS\hÕ Ò W*Kl�`Kf� !`W*Ph\�PYMOW*PY[]gSMOG[]djghU]\O\OPSgSM �^*PS�O�`Z*\�UHU]a�W[�Z*ZÆPS^*�hÕ Ò \Q[]R�KfMQKfUq^[]dfdfs]v�Z�\OUqkq\O[]JmJLPS\O��W[iÓ]P�a|U]G*^*R?[°MQW*PSUq\OPSJ Z*\�U�Ó]Ph\`R*K%$LgSG*dfMMOUTG*�OPÉI{Phgi[�G*�OPmKfM"Kf��^*U]MY[�G�MQUqJL[�MOKlg¾[�^*R \OPh��G*Kf\OPS�"W�G�J []^ Kf^*Z*G�MhÕ ;�PmJL[���PVG*�OKf^*ky[ MQW*P �Uq\�PhJ Z�\OU©ÓqPS\�Pi[��OKlPS\`I�syZ�\OU©Ó�KlR*Kf^*km[]G�MQU]J [�MOKlgh[]dldNs��¹kqPh^�Ph\Q[�MQPhR Kl^*Z*GHM¡MQUÉMQW*PYZ*\OU©Ó]Ph\`MQW[�M6gh[]^\�PhR*G*gSP°MQW�P°W�G*JL[]^oKf^*Z*G�M�\OPS��G�Kl\OPSR�Õ ;ÁP«R*U MOW*Kl�6Kl^yM !pU !p[is��hÕ F�Kl\���Miv5!�P¾R*P�ÓqPhdfUqZA[m�OPSM�U]aMQ[]gSMOKlgh�Sv�Uq\eZ*\OU�U]aÆ��MO\Q[�MOPhk]sÉZ*\�Uqkq\O[]JL�SvqMQW[�M3gi[]^mIÆP`G*��PhRLUq^ [�dld*��MQ\OG�gSMQG�\OPhRLKl^*R�G*gSMOKfÓqP`Z*\�UHU�a|�U]a�>@?BA []G�MOUqJ [�M�[�Õ3F�PhghU]^*R�v�OU]JLP"Uq\`[�dld<dfPhJmJ [���MQW*[�M6[]\OP"^�PhPhR�PhR�a|U]\¡Z*\OU�U]a|�¡[]\�P"Z*\OU©Ó�KlR�PhRI_sTR�s�^[�JLKfg"Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M¡R*PSMOPhg�MQKlU]^�\O[�MQW*PS\¡MQW[]^yI_sTMQW�PYZ�\OUqkq\O[]JmJLPS\hÕ

F�MQPSZ*�?uqv¡tA[]^*R <½\OPh��G*Kf\OPy�OU]JLPyW�G*JL[]^-Kf^_MQPh\O[]gSMOKlUq^<v !`W�KldlPy��MQPhZ-x Kl�m[]G�MOUqJ [�MQKlg�ÕÇ×�[�\�MmU]aJmKl^*KfJLKNMhKl^�k?Z�\OUqkq\O[]JmJLPS\°PS=ÆUq\�MVKl^�Ó]Ph\OKN}gi[�MQKlU]^ÇKl�¾\�PhR*G*gSKl^*kÊMOW*PTW�G*JL[]^�Kl^*Z*GHMVKl^�MOW*PTZ*\OU�ghPS�O�SÕ;�PoR*PS�Ogh\�KlI{PoMQW�PoMQ\O[]R*PoU�=<� !pPÊJL[���PoUq^.MOW*Kl�LKl���OG*P !`W*Ph^3!�PÊR*Ph��gh\�KlI{PoUqG*\LJLP�MQW*U�R*UqdfUqk]s�Kf^R*P�M�[]Kfd�Õ

;ÁP�R*U¾^*U]M�[�MOMOPhJmZ�M(ÓqPh\�KfaÈs []dld*M)s�Z{Ph�¡U]a�Z�\OUqkq\O[]J Z*\�UqZÆPS\�MOKlPh�Sv*[]^�R a|UHgSG*�pU]^ � ����ÉZ*\�UqZ{Ph\�MOKlPS�U]aeR�Kl��MO\OKfI*G�MQPSRo��sH��MQPSJL�SÕ"F�[�a|P�M)s?Z*\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKfPh�6Ph^*��G*\OP°MOW[�M�Kl^*gSUq\O\�Phg�M�Uq\6R[]JL[]kqKf^*kÉIÆPSW[iÓHKfUq\6^*PSÓ]Ph\U�ghghG�\O�hÕ:;�P¡a|UHgSG*�3Uq^É�Q[�a|P�M)sÉZ*\OU]ZÆPS\�MQKfPh�eI{Phgh[]G*�OP`MQW�PSsm[]\�P�MQW*P6JLU]��M3KlJmZ{Uq\�MQ[]^_McUq^*PS�(a|U]\ePh^*��G*\OKf^*kghU]\O\OPSgSMO^*Ph���hÕ

>)^�MOPh\OJm��U]apMOUHU]dl��MQUyKfJLZ*dfPhJmPh^_M�UqG*\�JmPSMOW*UHR<v.!�Pmgi[]^½ghG*\�\OPS^�MOdfs G*��PmM !�U�MOW*PhU]\OPhJ/Z�\OU©ÓqPS\O�[]^*RVU]^*PpR�s�^[�JLKfgpKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M~R*PSMOPhgSMOUq\hÕ A"G�\cJLP�MQW*U�R°Kf��^*U�Mca|G*^*R[�JLPS^�MQ[]dldNs�dlKfJLKNMQPhR"MOU�MQW*PS�OP�MOUHUqdf�hvI*G�MpMQW*PS�OPY[]\OP�MQW*P�U]^*Ph� !�P"W[iÓqP��OZ{Ph^_M`PH=<Uq\�M¡R*P�ÓqPhdfUqZ*Kf^*k¾Kl^TU]\OR*PS\pMQUV��G*Z*Z{Uq\�M�MOW*P"JmPSMQW�UHR�Õ Ò W*P>)�Q[�IÆPSdldlP ? � A"Ü MQW*PSUq\OPSJ Z*\OU©Ó]Ph\6Kl�`[É�OG*Z*Z{Uq\�MQPhRyMQU�Uqd�I{Phgh[]G*��P«U]a~MQW*P�I*\�Pi[]RHMQW?U]a�KNMQ�`W*KfkqW*Ph\¡U]\OR*PS\dlU]kqKlg�� ×�[�G5Gqx �EÕ Ò W*P�Ü�[�\Og�WL×3\�U©ÓqPh\ ��ÙYÙJG�u �{Kf�e�OG*Z*Z{Uq\�MQPhRLIÆPSgi[]G��OP�U�a�KfMO�3[]dl\�Pi[]RHs���MQKfkqW_M3Kl^_MQPSkq\Q[�MOKlUq^!`KfMOWTMQW*P >@?BA []G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^TJmUHR�Phd � *pUqkqwqw �EÕ A"^TMOW*P�R�s�^[]JmKlg���KlR*P�v*UqG*\¡JmPSMOW*UHRyG*��Ph�¡MQW�P«X"[�K`�]U]^MQU�Uqd � b(n¡ÙYÛ�w�uiI �ja|U]\¡R�s�^[]JmKlg"Kl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M¡R*P�MQPSgSMQKfUq^�Õ

Ò UVJmUq\�P�ghdfPi[]\�dfsmKl^_MO\OU�R*G*ghP�UqG*\pJmPSMOW*U�R*UqdlU]k]sqv_!�P�}\O��M¡Z*\OPS�OPS^�M6I[�g ��k]\OUqG*^�R?U]^ a|Uq\OJL[]d{JLU�R��PhdfKl^*kÁU]a°R�Kl��MO\OKfI*G�MQPSR'[]dlkqU]\OKfMOW*Jm� []^�RËMOW*PAKl���OG*PS�yU]a°��U]aÈM !p[]\OPAÓqPS\OKN}gi[�MOKlUq^<Õ Ò W�G*�hv"npW[]Z�MOPh\�tKl^_MO\OU�R*G*ghPS��MQW�P4>@?BA+[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^oJmU�R*Phd��ÆMQW�P°M !pUTJL[���Uq\6M)s�ZÆPS�"U]a3kqPh^�Ph\Q[�d �)Z�G*\OZ{Uq�OP°��M�[�MQKlgYÓqPS\OKf}��gi[�MQKlU]^LMQU�Uqdf�hv�JLU�R*Phd{g�W*PSg �]Ph\���[�^*R MQW�PhUq\�PhJ Z*\OU©ÓqPS\O�Sv�[]^*R MQW�PhKl\(gi[�Z[]I*KfdlKfMOKlPS����[°I[]��Klg�U©Ó]Ph\�Ó�KfP\!'U]a

u©w

Page 11: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

R�s�^[]JmKlgYKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M6R*PSMOPhg�MQKlU]^ ��[]^�RoMQW*PYM)s�ZÆPS��U]a3Z*\�Uqkq\Q[�J Z*\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKfPh��MOW[�M !pP°�OW[]dfd�[�MOMOPhJmZ�M�MOUÓqPS\OKNaÈsqÕ ;ËKfMQWyMQW�Kl�`I[]g ��kq\�UqG*^*R�v5!�P«R�Ph�OgS\OKfIÆPYUqG*\`JmPSMQW�UHR*U]dlUqk]sLKl^onpW[]ZHMQPh\�x�ÕpnpW[]Z�MOPh\U<m�OW*U�!`�UqG*\`JmPSMOW*UHR�Kl^yUqZ{Ph\O[�MQKfUq^�U]^?MOW*\OPSP°gi[��OPY��MQG�R*KlPS�hÔ¡×�PSMQPS\O��Uq^ �¬��M !�U �)Z*\�UHgSPh����J¾G�MOG[]djP VHgSdlG*��KlUq^o[]d �kqUq\�KfMOW*J�v�[���MO\OUq^�k°gi[�g�W*Kl^*k«KlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^_M�[�MOKlUq^¾U�aj�OW[�\OPhRLJLPSJLU]\�s ��[�^*R Ü�[]JmZÆU]\�M �¬�(×�[0VHUq�(Z*\�U]MQU�ghUqda|Uq\¡R*Kf��MO\OKlI�G�MQPSR?gSUq^*��Ph^*��G*�hÕ

>)^-U]\OR*PS\ÉMOU KlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^�M°UqG*\ÉJmPSMQW�UHR�v3KNM4!�[��L^*PSghPS�O�Q[�\�s�MQU Ph^�W[]^*gSP�Z*\�P �¹P VHKl��MQKl^�kÊMQU�Uqdl�°a|U]\ÓqPS\OKN}gi[�MOKlUq^ []^*R MOU¾R*PSÓ]PhdfUqZ !�[is���MQUVR�Ph�OgS\OKfIÆP�MOW*P�a|U]\OJL[]d�J [�MOW*PhJL[�MOKlgi[�d{JmU�R*Phdf� !�P�W[iÓqP"Kf^ MQW�Pdz[�^*kqG[]k]P"U]ae[mghUqJmZ*G�MOPh\¡MQW*PSUq\OPSJ Z*\OU©Ó]Ph\hÕ6npW*[]Z�MQPS\ DÉ�OW*U�!`��W*U�! R�s�^[]JmKlg�Kl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M`R*P�MQPhg�MQKfUq^gi[�^ IÆP?Ph^�W[]^*gSPhR MQU�J [ �]P?KfMLJLUq\�Py�Ogi[�dz[]I*dfP?a|U]\mdl[]\Ok]Ph\m[]^*R dfUq^*kqPS\ �¹\OG*^*^�Kl^*k Z*\�Uqkq\Q[�JL�SÕ Ò W*PZ*\�KlJL[]\�s�a|UHgSG*��Kl�"R*PS�Ogh\�KlI*Kf^*k�[]^ Kl^*gS\OPhJmPh^_MQ[]d3[]dlk]Uq\OKNMQW*JÐa|Uq\�[]^[�dfs)MhKf^*kyP VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^*� ( Uq^*PVMQW[�MR*U�Ph�V^*U�MVG*�OPyG*Z���Z[]ghPy[��¾MQW*PTPXV�PSghG�MOKlUq^�dfPh^*k]MOWÇKl^*gS\OPh[]�OPS�hÕÇnpW*[]Z�MQPS\ IÊ�OW*U�!`�ÉPh^*W*[]^*ghPSJLPS^_MQ�MQUyMQW�P >@A`Ö FHKfJ¾G*dl[�MQUq\L!£Kl^_MOPh\OZ�\OPSMOPh\ $�Kf^½MOUo[]dfdlU�! KfM�MQU?P VHPhgSG�MQPLJLU]\OPÉZ*\OU]kq\Q[]Jm�hv��OUyMQW*[�M«MOW*Ph��PZ*\�Uqkq\Q[�JL�¡gh[]^�I{PY[]^[]dNs)MhPhRyÓ�Kz[VR�s�^[]JmKlg�Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M¡R�PSMQPSgSMOKlUq^�ÕpnpW[]ZHMQPh\ ;VR*Ph��gh\�KlI{Ph�6W*U�! [É^*P\!JmUHR*PSd !p[]�eR*P�ÓqPhdfUqZ{PhRVa|Uq\ >@?BAË[]G�MOUqJL[�M�[�Kf^°MQW�P">)�Q[]I{PhdfdlPpMOW*PhUq\�PhJ Z*\OU©ÓqPS\��¬�3dz[]^*k]G[]kqP�v�MQU"Kf^*gh\�Pi[]��P[]G�MOUqJL[�MQKfUq^ Kl^TMOW*P"ÓqPh\�Kf}gh[�MQKfUq^yZ*\OU�ghPS�O�SvÆ[�^*R�\�PhR*G�ghPYW�G�J []^yKf^�Ó]UqdfÓ]PhJmPh^_MiÕ

F�Kl^*[]dldNsqv�npW[]Z�MOPh\ CÉ��G*kqkqPS��MO�6a|G*\�MQW*PS\`\OPh��Pi[]\�g�WÊ[]^�R�gSUq^*ghdfG*R*PS�hÕ

����� ����� ��������� ��� ������

> !�UqG*dfR°dlKN�]P3MQU6MQW[]^ �Yr�Klg�W[�PhdHb3\�^*��MhvqJ°s�Z*\�KlJL[]\�s�\OPh��Pi[]\�g�WV�OG*Z{Ph\�Ó�Kl�OU]\hv�a|U]\~kqG�KlR*Kf^*k`PSÓqPS\�s°[]�OZ{Phg�MU]a{J°s !pU]\#�¾U©ÓqPS\cMQW*P¡dl[]��M�M !pU"sqPh[]\O�Sv�[]^*RVa|Uq\cZ*\�U©ÓHKfR*Kl^�k�JLPpPh^*gSUqG*\Q[�kqPhJmPh^_M([]^*RÉKf^*�OZ*Kf\Q[�MOKlUq^«R*G*\ �Kl^�kYMOW*P�JmUq��M�R*K%$LgSG*dfM3MOKlJmPh�hÕW>W!pU]G*dlRT[�dl�OUYdlKN�]P¡MQUYMQW[�^/�LF�MQPSZ*W*Ph^?Ù�[]\�dz[]^*RÉa|Uq\(IÆPSKl^*k ��� ����UqG*\OgSPU]a�[]R�Ó�KfghPTUq^�a|Uq\�J [�d�JmUHR�PhdlKf^*koU�a >@?�A []GHMQUqJL[�M�[�Kl^�MQW�PhUq\�PhJ Z�\OU©ÓqPS\O�m[]^*R�Uq^ÇG*��Kl^*kÊMOW*PhU]\OPhJZ*\�U�Ó]Ph\���Kl^?kqPh^�Ph\Q[�d�Õ">¡[]J []df�OUmkq\Q[�MQPSa|G�d�MOU Û�[]^*gSs�Ü�s�^*g�WÊa|Uq\¡MQPh[]g�W*Kf^*k JmPYMOW*P«a|G�^*R[]JmPh^_M�[�dl�`U]aR*Kf��MQ\�KlI*GHMQPhR�[]dfkqUq\OKNMQW*Jm��[�^*R?a|U]\OJL[]d�JmPSMQW�UHR*�Sv�[]^*Rya|Uq\¡�OG�kqkqPh��MQKf^*kLPXV�[]JLZ�dlPh�6[]^�R !p[isH�6MQUmJLU©Ó]Pa|Uq\@!�[]\�R�Kf^TZ*\OU�U]a|�"!`KfMOWyW*Ph\`KlJmJmPh^*��P�P VHZ{Ph\OKfPh^*gSP !`KNMQWyMQW*P"}PSdlR�Õ

> !pUqG�dlRT[]df�OU¾dfK`��P�MQU«MQW[]^ � Ü�[]G*\O[¾X�Pi[�^�vØ]PS\OPhJ«s Û6KlJmJLPS\hvHØ]Uq�OW Ò []G*I{Ph\Sv[]^*RTr�Klg�W[�Phd Ò �O[]K�v!`W*UÁMQ[]G*kqW_M JLP�W*U�! MQU�gSUHR*P�PS=ÆPhg�MQKfÓ]PhdNs.Kf^ [½MOPi[]J []^*R.ghUq\�\OPhg�MQPSRË[]^*R Kf^*KfMOKz[�MOPhR�Uq\ \�PS}^�PhRJL[]^_sÊKlJmZ*dfPhJmPh^_M�[�MOKlUq^?KlR�Pi[]��Z�\OPh��Ph^_MQPSRÁKf^ÊMQW*Kf��MQW*PS�OKf�hÕ >�[]df�OU PXV�Z�\OPh���«J«sÊkq\O[�MQKNMQG*R*PYMQUyX�Kfdl�OG�^��� \�d ��� [is�^[]\(a|Uq\¡W*PhdfZ*Kl^�kVUq\Ok_[�^*K`MSP"UqG*\ ��UqKl^_M !�Uq\ �TUq^TMQW*Kf�¡JLP�MQW*U�R*UqdfUqk]sqÕ

"!# "!# $ �����p� ,Á���&%Ò W*P�KlJmZ*\�U�Ó]PhJmPh^_MQ��MQUÉR�s�^[]JmKlg�Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MpR*PSMOPhg�MQKlU]^ !�Ph\�P�KlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^�MOPhRT[�aÈMQPh\pP V�MQPS^*�OKNÓqPYR*Kl��ghG*� ��OKfUq^ !`KfMOWmr�Klg�W[�Phd�be\O^*��MiÕ(Ø]PS\OPhJ«sVÛ�KfJLJmPh\c[]^*RLr�Klg�W*[]Phdbe\�^*��M(R*P�ÓqPhdfUqZ{PhRLMOW*P¡KlR�Pi["U]a{W*KlPS\Q[]\�g�W*K �gi[�dldfs?Uq\�R*Ph\�Kl^*kTZ�\OUqkq\O[]J ZÆUqKf^_MQ��a|Uq\�R�s�^[]JmKlg¾Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M�R*PSMOPhgSMOKlUq^½[]^�R½KfJLZ�dlPhJmPh^_MOPhRoMOW*PVKl^*KNMQKl[]dKl^�gh\OPSJLPS^_M�[]dcÓ]Ph\O��KlUq^�U]a(MQW*PLX"[]K`��Uq^AMQU�Uqd�v8!`KNMQW*U]G�M�MQW*PÉUqZ�MOKlJmK`Mh[�MQKfUq^*��R�Kl�OgSG*�O��PhR�Kf^½MOW*Kl��MOW*Ph��Kl�SÕÛ�KfKjX�U�UHR*U�U¾Kf^*KfMOKz[]dfdfsVKfJLZ*dfPhJmPh^_MQPSR MQW*P�W[�^*R*dlKf^*kVU]a~ghUq^�R*KfMOKlUq^[�dÆKf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MO�¡Kl^ MQW�P«X"[�K`�]U]^yMOUHU]d�Õ

Ö�^*R�\OP � *�UqkqR[]^�U�ÓÎUq\�KlkqKf^[]dfdfs�R*PSÓ]PhdlU]ZÆPSR.MQW*P >@A6Ö MQ\Q[�^*�Odl[�MQUq\ÉMQU½MQW*PoÜ�[]\Og�W ×e\�U�Ó]Ph\SvU!`W�KldlPF�MOPhZ*W*PS^ÊÙ�[]\�dz[]^*R []^*R�npW*\�Kl�¡ÜjG*W*\��¡R*PSÓ]PhdfUqZÆPSRTMQW*P"Uq\�KlkqKf^[]d9>)�Q[�IÆPSdldlP6MQ\O[]^*�Odl[�MQU]\hÕ+*pU]kqR[]^*U©Ó []dl��U!`\OU�MQP"MQW*P�gSUHR*P"a|Uq\�MOW*P���MO\OUq^*kmgi[�g�W*Kl^*kÉJmPhJmUq\�s []G�MOUqJ [�M�[¾Kl^yUq^�P"U]a~MOW*P�gi[]��P«��MQG*R�KlPh�SÕ

Û�KfghUqdfP >)JmJLU]\OdlKfgi[ !p[]�T[ÁgSUqdldl[]IÆU]\Q[�MOUq\VKl^.MOW*PoZ�\OU�U]a"U]a"MOW*PA×�[�V�U]� Z*\OU�MQU�ghUqd6Kl^ÎMQW*PoÜ�[�\Og�W×e\OU©ÓqPS\hÕ`Ú`UqI{Ph\�MOU X�Ph×e\OKl��ghU*v�Û�[]^*g�s?Üjs�^*g�WÊ[]^*RoÖ�dlPXV�FHW_Ó�[]\�MO�OJL[]^�a|Uq\�J¾G*dl[�MQPSRyMOW*PYUq\OKfkqKl^[�d >@?BA[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^TgSUHR�P�a|U]\`×�[0VHUq�SÕ

uqu

Page 12: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ö�^_MQU]^*KlUÇÚ6[]JmKl\�P�M �)Ú6U]I*\OPSR*U½a|U]\OJ¾G*dl[�MQPSR-MOW*PoUq\�KlkqKf^[]d¡KfR*Pi[½U]a�W[iÓ�Kl^*kÇ[�^*^*U]MQ[�MQKfUq^*�ÉMQU>@A`ÖZ*\�Uqkq\Q[�JL�¡Kf^TUq\OR*PS\¡MQUÉR*Ph��gh\�KlI{P«gSUq\O\�Ph�OZ{Uq^*R�Ph^*gSPh��Kf^yP VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^�I{PSM !�PhPS^oM !�U []GHMQUqJL[�M�[HÕ

u�t

Page 13: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� � ��� ��� �

� ��� ��� � � � � � � � � � � ��� �� � � � �

Ò W*Kf� g�W[]ZHMQPh\LZ*\OPS�OPS^�MO�T[ÁI[�g ��k]\OUqG*^�R Uq^.��U]aÈM !p[]\OPoÓ]Ph\�Kf}gh[�MQKfUq^ []^�R-a|Uq\�J []d¡JmU�R*PhdfKl^*k U]a"R�Kl� �MQ\�KlI*GHMQPhR []dlkqU]\OKfMOW*Jm�mKf^ Uq\�R*Ph\ MOUÇIÆP�MOMOPh\ G*^�R*Ph\���M�[�^*RËUqG*\ JmPSMOW*U�R*UqdlU]k]sÇa|Uq\LÓ]Ph\�Kf}gh[�MQKfUq^�Õ ;�PR*Kf�OghG��O�`MQW*PY��MO\OPh^�k]MQW*��[]^*R !�Pi[���^*PS�O�OPS�"U]a�MOW*P"M !pULJ [�Kl^TkqPS^*Ph\O[]d���M�[�MQKlg�Ó]Ph\�Kf}gh[�MQKfUq^?MOPhg�W*^�Kl��G*Ph�SvJmUHR*PSd�g�W*Phg ��Kl^�kÉ[]^*RLMOW*PhU]\OPhJ+Z*\�U©ÓHKf^*k¾Kf^ FHPSgSMOKlUq^*��tHÕNu�[]^*RTtHÕ¯t�Õ >)^ P V�[]JmKl^�Kl^*kY[]^T[�^[]dfs���Kl�eMQPSg�W��^*Kf��G�P]v^!�PV[]\�P°Kf^�MOPh\�Ph��MOPhRAKf^�MQW�\OPhPYa|Pi[�MOG*\OPS�hÔ¡MQW�P¾R*Phk]\OPhP«U]a3KfMO��[�G�MQUqJL[�MOKlUq^�v*MOW*P¾PXV�Z�\OPh���OKNÓHKNM)soU]\dlKfJLKNMQ��U]a�KNMQ�¡dfUqkqKlg�v*[]^�R?MOW*PYÓ�[]\�KlP�M)s U]a�Z*\OUqk]\Q[]Jm�¡KfM¡gh[]^?P V�[]JmKl^*P�Õ ;�P�Kl^_MQ\�UHR�G*ghP"MQW�PYgSUq^*gSPhZ�M�U]aR�s�^[]JmKlg"Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�M�R*PSMOPhgSMOKlUq^?Kl^�FHPSgSMOKlUq^�tHÕ�x�Õ

>)^yFHPSgSMQKfUq^ tHÕH< !pP�Kl^_MQ\�UHR�G*ghP¡MQW�P >@?BAÌ[�G�MQUqJL[�MOUq^LJmU�R*Phd*a|Uq\3R*Kf��MO\OKlI�G�MQPSR ��s���MQPhJm�hv�MQW*P6JL[�MQW��PhJL[�MOKlgi[�d¡I[]�OKf�La|Uq\mUqG*\ !�Uq\#��v6[]^*RÎa|Uq\OJL[]dldNs�PXV�Z�\OPh���TUqG*\ÉÓqPS\OKf}*gi[�MOKlUq^-kqU_[]df�LKf^-MQW�Kl�mJLU�R*Phd`Kf^FHPSgSMQKfUq^�tHÕEDHÕQ;ÁP"R*PS�OgS\OKlI{P«[]dfMOPh\O^*[�MQKNÓqP]v�\OPhdl[�MQPSR?[]Z*Z*\�U_[]g�W*PS�6MOUÉÓ]Ph\�Kf}gh[�MQKfUq^yKl^�FHPhg�MQKfUq^�tHÕ ;�Õ

���� �� � �� ���� �� ������ �

ÖËMQW*PSUq\OPSJ Z�\OU©ÓqPS\pKl��[YMOUHU]d*MQW[�M�JL[]^*KlZ�G*dz[�MOPh�3JL[�MQW*PSJ [�MQKlgh[]d�a£[]g�MQ�(kqKfÓ]Ph^mMQU°KNM(Kl^ U]\OR*PS\(MOU°Z*\�U�Ó]PJmUq\OP�a£[]gSMO�hÕ�×3\�U©ÓqPh\���G*��P¾dlUqk]Klgh�`U]aeÓ�[]\�s�Kl^*kLP VHZ*\OPS�O��KfÓ�KfM)s]Õ FUq\6P V�[]JmZ*dlP�v{MOW*P¾Ü�[]\�g�W ×3\�U©ÓqPh\L!EÜ�× $G*��Ph�3J¾G*dNMQK �¹�OUq\�MQPSR !£KEÕ�P�Õfv]P VHZ*dlKfghKNMQdfsYR[�M�[�M)s�ZÆPSR6$~}\���M3Uq\�R*Ph\edfUqkqKlg�v0!`W�KldlP�MQW*P">)�O[]IÆPSdldfP�? � A�ÜT��sH��MQPSJG*��Ph�VW*KfkqW*Ph\«Uq\OR�Ph\°dfUqkqKfg !`KNMQW�roÜ ��sH^_MQ[0V�[]^�R�M)sHZ�Kl^*k*Õ >¹a�[]^Ç[]dfkqUq\OKNMQW*J []^*RÇKfMO�«gSUqJmZ*G�M�[�MQKlU]^JmUHR*PSd�gh[]^ÇI{P P VHZ*\�Ph�O��PhRÎKl^ÁMOW*P dfUqkqKlgmU]a6[ÊZ*\�U©ÓqPh\SvcMQW*PS^Î[oG*�OPS\Vgi[]^ÇG��OP MOW*P Z*\�U�Ó]Ph\¾MOUÊÓqPh\�KfaÈsZ*\�UqZÆPS\�MOKlPh�¡U�a�MQW�P«[�dlkqUq\�KfMOW*J�Õ

>)^ÇUq\OR�Ph\«MOUÊR*UoMOW*Kl�Sv~MOW*P G*��Ph\¾W[��«MQUoR*PS}^�P a|Uq\«MOW*P Z�\OU©ÓqPS\É[�JmUHR*PSd�U�a¡ghUqJmZ*G�MQ[�MQKfUq^�[�^*RMQW�P I{PhW[iÓ�KlUq\«U]a¡MQW�P []dfkqUq\OKNMQW*J?Õ Ò W*PS^ÇMQW*PLG*�OPS\¾��MQ[�MQPS�°MQW*PLZ*\OU�U]a¡k]U_[]dl�Sv�Uq\YdlU]kqKlgh[]deZ*\OPSR*Klgh[�MQPS�MQW*[�M�W*P !`Kl��W*Ph�"MQUy��W*U�!�Õ Ò W*PLZ�\OU©ÓqPS\�MOW*Ph^½�OU]G*^*R*dNsAJ [�^*KlZ*G�dz[�MOPh��JL[�MOW*PhJL[�MQKfgi[]d�a£[]g�MQ��KlJmZ*dlKfPhRI_s MQW*PmR*PS}*^*KfMOKlUq^*�YKl^½Uq\�R*Ph\�MQU?Z*\OU©Ó]P MQW*PmkqU_[�d�Õ Ò W�P JL[]^*KlZ�G*dz[�MOKlUq^��"[]\OPmgi[�dldlPSR � ������ � ����� ���#[]^*Rmgi[�^LI{P`g�W[]Kl^�PhRmKl^_MQU�W*KfkqW*Ph\edfPSÓ]Phd�J [�^*KlZ*G�dz[�MOKlUq^*�~gi[]dfdlPSR � � ���� �!� �����!� �Õ FUq\eP V�[]JmZ*dlP�v�[YZ�\OU�U]aJmPSMQW�UHR Kl^ >)�O[]IÆPSdldfP�?]Ü�×1Kf�"Z*\OU�U]a�I_s½[]�O��G*JLZHMQKlU]^9?�KlJmZ*dfKlgi[�MQKlU]^�Õ+;ËW*Ph^ MQW*PÉZ*\�UHU�apkqUq[]dcKl�"U�apMQW�Pa|Uq\�J ��� � v_MOW*P`Z*\OU©ÓqPS\pgh[]^LI{P6[]�#��PhR MOU°[��O�OG�JLP¡MQW*[�M �'W�UqdlR*�Sv�[]^*RÉMQUYdlPSM �5I{P`MOW*P6^*P\! Z�\OU�U]akqU_[�d�ÕJA�^*gSP � Kl��Z�\OU©ÓqPS^�vjMQW*P¾Z�\OU©ÓqPS\"ZÆUqZ��"KfMQ� � ������ ��!� ���A[�^*RA��MQ[�MQPS��MQW[�M ��� � Kl��MO\OG*P�Õ�Ö�OKfJLZ�dlP�Z�\OU�U]ajM�[]g�MQKfg�JLKfkqW_M���ZÆPSghKfaÈsmMQW*[�M¡MQW*P�KlJmZ*dlKfgi[�MOKlUq^ÉJmPSMQW�UHRTKf�¡[]Z*Z*dfKlPSR !`W*Ph^�PSÓqPS\ ��[]^*R �W[iÓqP«ghUqJmJmUq^Ta|\OPhP"Ó�[]\�Kz[]I*dfPh�SÕ Ò W*PYR*PSghKl��KlUq^yMQUL[]Z*Z�dfsTZ*\�UHU�a�JmPSMOW*UHR���[]^�R?MQ[]gSMOKlgh�`gh[]^oI{P�J []R�PJL[]^�G[]dldNsqv�[]G�MQU]J [�MOKlgh[]dldNsqv�Uq\¡I{U]MQW�v�R*PhZ{Ph^*R�Kl^*kmUq^yMQW*P�Z*\�U�Ó]Ph\SÕ

Ö5�OPh��G*PS^*ghP«U]a~Z*\OU�U]a~JLP�MQW*U�R*�6[]^*RTM�[�gSMQKfgh�¡MQW*[�M`Z*\OU©Ó]Ph��[VkqUq[]d�Kl�`[ � ������ ������ � ��Uq\¡��KlJmZ*dfs [

u©x

Page 14: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Z*\�UHU]a�Õ6Ö Z�\OU©ÓqPS\�MQW[�M��OG�Z*ZÆU]\�MQ��\OPh��G*Kf\OPS��P V�MOPh\O^*[]d�Kf^*Z*G�M�[�M�P�ÓqPS\�sÊ��MQPSZAKl����MQKfdldjG*��PSa|G*d�a|Uq\�KNM�gh[]^I{P"[°MQU�UqdÆa|U]\pR*P�ÓqPhdfUqZ*Kf^*kÉ[]^*RTg�W*PSg ��Kl^*kÉMQW*P"gSUq\O\�Phg�MQ^*PS�O�`U]a�[¾Z*\�UHU]a���gh\OKfZ�M¡kqPS^*Ph\O[�MQPSRyI�s W[]^*RTU]\I_sy[]^*U�MQW*PS\`MOUHU]d�Õ

FHKl^�ghPÉPSÓ]Ph^�}*\O��MYUq\�R*Ph\�dfUqkqKlg°Kl�"G*^*R�PhghKfR[]I*dfP]v�Z*\�U�Ó]Ph\��«\�PhZ{Uq\�M�a£[]KfdlG*\�P°I{U]MQW !`W*Ph^ MQW�Pmk]U_[]dcKf�G*^_MQ\�G*P]v�[]^�R4!`W*Ph^VMQW�PSs¾gh[]^*^*U�M3Z*\OU©ÓqP�MOW*P¡kqU_[�d�Õ�>¹a{MOW*P¡kqU_[�dHKf�cKl^*R�PhPhRVMO\OG*P¡[�McMQW*Kf�cZ{UqKl^_Miv]W�G�J []^��W[iÓqP«MQU ��MQPSZAKl^Ê[�^*RÊR*Kf\OPhg�M�MOW*P°Z*\�U©ÓqPh\��OUqJmPhW*U�!�Õ Ò W*Kl��Kl�U!`W_sqv<MO\Q[]R*KNMQKfUq^[]dfdfsqvHMQW*PSUq\OPSJ Z�\OU©ÓqPS\O�W[iÓqP¡I{PhPS^ÉghUq^*��KlR*PS\OPSRmR�K $mghG*dNM�MOU"G*�OP¡I_s¾P�ÓqPS\�s�R[isÉZ*\OU]kq\Q[]JmJmPh\O��a|Uq\���U]aÈM !p[]\OP�Ó]Ph\OKN}gi[�MQKlU]^�Ô�MOW*PSs[]\�PV^*U]MY[]G�MOUqJL[�MQKfg¾[]^*R \�Ph��G*Kl\�PÉW�G�J []^���MQUyZ*\OU©Ó�KlR�PVJ¾G*g�W½U]a3MQW*PÉKl^��OKlk]W�M�Kl^AZ*\�UHU]a|�SÕVbcÓqPS^�MQW�PJmUq��M6[]GHMQUqJL[�MQKfg�MQW�PhUq\�PhJ Z*\�U©ÓqPh\���U]^*dfs []G�MQU]J [�MOP"�OJL[]dldÆ��MOPhZ*�6G*�OKf^*kVM�[]g�MQKfgh�hÕ

>)^ MQW�Kl��MOW*Ph��Kl�Sv !�P�R*KfÓ�KfR*P6MOW*P�W�G*JL[]^LKl^*Z*GHM�Kl^_MOU«M !�U°Ó�[]\OKfPSMQKfPh�SÔ�dlPSJLJL[]�([]^*RLM�[]g�MQKlgS�hÕ Ò []gSMOKlgS�MQPSdldpMOW*P?Z*\OU©ÓqPS\mMOU�G��OP?Z*\OP �)P VHKf��MQKf^*kAa£[]gSMO� [�^*R-Z�\OU�U]a�JmPSMOW*U�R*�VMQU½J [���PyZ*\OUqk]\OPh���LU]^.[ Z*\OU�U]a�ÕbWV�[]JLZ�dlPh�jKf^*ghdfG*R*P�Ô��OKfJLZ*dfKf}gh[�MQKfUq^�vSgi[]��P�[�^[]dfs���Kl�hv�[��O�OG�JLZ�MOKlUq^5?�KlJmZ*dlKfgi[�MOKlUq^6[]^�RYKf^*R*G*g�MQKfUq^�Õ Ò W*PSs[]\�P°�OPh[]\Og�W�Ph��Uq^oa£[]g�MQ� ��^*U�!`^ÊMOU MQW*P°Z*\OU©ÓqPS\hvj[�ghghU]JLZ[�^*KlPSRÊI_sodfUqkqKlgh[]djG*^*KN}gi[�MQKlU]^oJmPhg�W[]^�Kl�OJm�hÕFHUqJmPpZ�\OU©ÓqPS\O�3W[iÓqP¡I*G�KldfM �)Kf^YMQ[]gSMOKlgh�~MQW[�Me[]G�MQU]J [�MOKlgh[]dldNs"[�M�MQPhJmZ�M~MQU�[]Z*Z�dfs�MQW*PSJL��PhdNÓqPh�eU]^VZ*\OU�U]a|�hÕ

ÜjPhJmJ []��[�R*R«^�P\!Áa£[�gSMQ�jMOU`MOW*P3Z*\OU©Ó]Ph\��¬�W��^*U�!`dfPhR*kqP3I[��OP]Õ *pPSa|U]\OP3Z*\OU©Ó�Kl^�k�[¡kqUq[]d�via|Uq\jPXV�[]JLZ�dlP]vKfM«JL[©s½I{P ^*PSghPh���Q[]\�s�MQUo��M�[�MQP [�^*RÇZ*\OU©Ó]PT[odlPSJLJL[�Õ FUq\«PXV�[]JLZ�dlP]v�dlPhJmJL[ � JL[is½IÆPL^*PhPSR*PhRMQU?Z*\�U�Ó]Pma£[�gSM�� Õ A�\hvjMQU?Z*\OU©Ó]P � � � v�KfM�JL[isÊI{PL^*PSghPS�O�Q[�\�s MQUy�OW�U�! � � � []^�R�� � � ÕÒ W*PY�OPh[]\Og�Wya|Uq\`[]^�[]Z*Z*\�UqZ*\�Kz[�MOP�� Kl�`[ÉdlPSJLJL[°Kl^�Z*G�MiÕ >)^oFHPSgSMQKfUq^�tHÕED !�P��OW*U�! W*U�!ÌdlPhJmJL[]�¡[]\�PG*��PhR�Kf^�Z*\�UHU�a|�YU�a¡R*Kl��MQ\�KlI*G�MOPhR�[]dlk]Uq\OKNMQW*Jm�hÕ F�Kl^�R*Kl^*kTMOW*PL\�KlkqW_MYdlPSJLJL[]�"Kf�YJ°G*g�W�JmUq\OPÉR*K%$LgSG*dfMa|Uq\�[ ghU]JLZ*GHMQPh\6MQW[�^o}^*R*Kf^*k MOW*P°\�KlkqW_M6M�[]g�MQKlgS�hv{a|Uq\�KNM�Kf��^*PSghPS�O�Q[�\�soMOU gh\�Pi[�MOP«a£[]g�MQ�6MQW[�M�R*U ^*U�MsqP�M6P VHKl��Miv*\O[�MQW*PS\pMQW*[]^yJLPS\OPhdNs ��Pi[]\�g�W�U]^ MQW*P"Z*\�U©ÓqPh\ ��� ��^*U�!`dlPSR*kqP"I[]��P]Õ Ò W*PSUq\OP�MQKlgh[]dldNsqvH[VZ*\OU©ÓqPS\ghU]G*dlR�[]df�OUÊ}^�RÎMOW*Ph��Pya£[�gSMQ�VI_sÇ��Pi[]\�g�W*Kl^�k½U]^-[�dldpZ{Uq���OKlI�dlP ��sH^_MQ[]gSMOKlgi[�d�ghUqJ°I*Kl^[�MQKlU]^*�hveI*GHMVMQW*Kf��OPh[]\Og�Wo�OZ[]gSP«Kf�`Ph^*Uq\�JLU]G*�hv{[]^*R?Pi[�g�WA[�MOMOPhJmZ�M�[�M6dlPSJLJL[ !pU]G*dlR?W[iÓqPYMQUmIÆP�ÓqPS\OKf}*PhRoI_s?[É�OPS\OKlPS�U]a�M�[]g�MQKfgh�hvU]\ !pUq\��OP�v{JmUq\�P"dlPhJmJL[]�hÕ

Ò W*P°��G*ghgSPh����U]a~G*�OKf^*k [ÉMQW*PSUq\OPSJ Z*\OU©Ó]Ph\6R*PhZ{Ph^*R���Uq^?W*U�! J¾G*g�W�U]a�MOW*P«[]IÆU©Ó]P«W�G*JL[]^?Kl^*Z*GHMgi[�^�I{P"PhdfKlJmKl^[�MOPhR�Õ Ò W*PJ�]P�sTMQUÉUqG*\¡JmPSMOW*UHR�UqdlUqk�s Kf^oF�PhgSMOKlUq^?xVKl��MOW*P�\OPSR*G*gSMOKlUq^yU]a�MQW�Kl�¡W�G*JL[]^Kl^�Z*G�MiÕ Ò W*PV^*P V�M�M !�UT�OPSgSMOKlUq^*�"R�Ph�OgS\OKfIÆP¾Kf^Êkq\�Pi[�MOPh\�R�PSM�[�Kld�MQW*P°M !�UyZ*\OU©Ó]Ph\O� !�PV�OW*[]dld�G*�OP°Kl^ÊUqG�\JmPSMQW�UHR�Õ

� R.'�� -/�0� R % ������'Q�Ò W*P�Ü�[]\Og�W ×3\�U©ÓqPh\ �¬Ù«ÙJG�u ��!£Ü�× $eKl�3[�^LKf^�MOPh\O[]gSMOKfÓqP`MQW�PhUq\�PhJ Z*\�U�Ó�Kf^*k«��s���MQPSJ a|Uq\c}\O��M �¹Uq\OR*PS\�dfUqkqKfg]Õ>¹ML[]R*JmKfMO�¾�OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^*�VU]a�MQW*PSUq\OKfPh�VKl^ÇMOW*P?Ü�[�\Og�W.FHW[]\�PhR-Ü�[�^*kqG[]k]P �¬Ù ��Ù�� Gqx � !EÜ�F�ÜE$�Õ >¹MÉKf���MO\OUq^�kqdfsAR*[�M�[ M)s�ZÆPSR�v�!`KNMQW R*PSghdz[�\OPhR M)s�ZÆPS�hv�[]^*R½KfMQ�"M)s�Z{PL��sH��MQPSJCZ{Ph\�JLKNMQ��Z{UqdNsHJmUq\�Z*W*Klg«M)sHZ{Ph�Sv�OG�g�Wy[]�������� �,����v[«��PSM�U]ajKf^�MOPhkqPS\O�SÕ >¹Mp��G*Z*Z{Uq\�MO�pJL[]^_sÉKl^_MQG*KNMQKNÓqP`Z*\OU�U]a<JLP�MQW*U�R*�hv��OG�g�Wy[]��Z�\OU�U]aI_s KlJmZ*dlKfgi[�MOKlUq^o[]^*R�ghUq^_MQ\O[]R*KfgSMQKfUq^�Õ ��U�!�PSÓ]Ph\hv�KfM�R*U�Ph�Y^*U]MY�OG�Z*ZÆU]\�MYMQW*PÉgh\�Pi[�MOKlUq^½U]ap^*P\! Z�\OU�U]aJmPSMQW�UHR*�Sv3Uq^*dfs�MQW*PTgS\OPh[�MQKfUq^�U]a6^*P\! dlPhJmJL[]�&!`W*Kfg�W-gh[]^�IÆP?[]Z�Z*dlKfPhR�G*��Kl^*kAMOW*PyI*G*KldNM �¹Kl^ÁZ�\OU�U]aJmPSMQW�UHR*�SÕ

Ö���[]^ÊP V�[]JmZ*dfP]v5!pP°�OW*U�! [ Z*\�UHU�acU]acMOW*P°��s�dldlU]kqKl��J \OG*dfP]v !G@ � <H$�� !R< � BS$ � !G@ � B $�vÆKf^Ü�×'Kf^[F�KfkqG*\OP¾t ��u]Õ4;ÁP¾R�Kl\OPSgSM�Ü�× MQUTZ{Ph\�a|Uq\OJ []^AP VHW[�G*��MOKfÓqPV��Pi[]\�g�W�U]^oMQW*P¾Ó�[]dfG*Ph��U]a @�[�^*R*<©vÓ�Kz[Vgi[��OPY[]^[]dNs��OKl�Sv[]^*R�Ü�×.�OG�ghghPSPhR*�SÕ

Ò W*P�G*^�R*Ph\�dfs�Kl^*k°R[�M�[«��MQ\�G*gSMOG*\OPS�¡U]ajMQW�P >@A6ÖÌdz[]^*k]G[]kqP !£R*PS�OgS\OKlI{PhRTKf^TFHPSgSMOKlUq^yt�ÕEI $([]\OP�I[]��PhRUq^ Ü�×1R*[�M�[TdlKfI*\Q[�\OKlPS�hv{�OUTMQ\O[]^*��dz[�MOKl^*k I{PSM !�PhPS^½MOW*P¾M !�U?R�UqJ [�Kl^*��Kf��\OPSdz[�MOKfÓ]Phdfs?��MQ\Q[�KlkqW_MOa|U]\ !p[]\OR�ÕFG*\�MOW*Ph\SvjMQW*Kf�"JLPh[]^*�"MQW[�MY[]^_sAR[�MQ[?��MQ\OG�gSMQG�\OPh�YG*��PhRÁKf^[>@A6Ö []df\OPi[�R�sAW[iÓqPmÜ�F�Ü.��ZÆPSghKN}gi[�MOKlUq^��

u <

Page 15: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

����������������� ������������������������������������������ ����������������� �"!$#�%�%&�

��'(��*)�%&�&����%����,+-�/.0�21 34+5�6. ��17. +-�8. ��1

��9&�%�%:*;���(�%�<!����=�������������?>�;��A@�BC�����������ED,'�>��F�$�ED"G��������

��H�9I�����J�K!�*L&����� �M��)=�M>&��)�%������A:&%���&�%�%:N���I�����������O���PQ�%��R�S������T!$����*L������N(��&��%�&(��J�����U!� >R�����L��J����V&���XWZY[W-Y[!\���� >R�����L��J����V&���XWZY[W^]�!`_2����Na&�?;��=�M>���)�%����A:&%b�&���c���������d!� +e���8.f�g1 3h+5�`. �J17. +?���i. ��1

��j&)����k�=:&%����%�Pl���Q�������������?>�;��A@�BC���������m�nD,'�>��F���nD"G��������

��H�9I�����J�K!�&�NL���&��� �?��)c�M>���)�%&�����o:&%���&�%&%:*���Q����������&��O���PC��%� �S�������F!��J��&�*L&�����N(�����%���(J�����J�p!�&� > ���L�����V����qW^]�W-Y2!$�J��&� > ���L�����V����qW^]�W^]K!`_R�J��&�Na��?;��=�S>&��)�%&���A:&%�c�&���c���������K!�&� �J�n34+e�J�r. �J1s. �

�&�*j&�����S;����R�?��)��&%��&�%����t������&�*ut�M>���)�%����A:&%=�������=Y*+S%�>&�l%�:*]�1

�&��j&���&���l(��&��%�&(��J�����o> ���L�����V&�&�XW^]�W-Yv�&%��(��t�S�J�M���?;wW

�&�*H&�������*ut�M>&��)�%����A:&%�I�������=Y*+S%�>&��%�:N]J1�&�yx{zb9��%�����b���b��%��;R������|���� ��%�TW

�&�*j&�����S;����R�?��)��&%��&�%����t������&�*ut�M>���)�%����A:&%=�������N]t+S%�>&�l%�:*]�1

�&��j&���&���l(��&��%�&(��J�����o> ���L�����V&�&�XW^]�W^]*�&%��(��t�S�J�M���?;wW

�&�*H&�������*ut�M>&��)�%����A:&%�I�������N]t+S%�>&��%�:N]J1�&�yx{zb9��%�����b���b��%��;R������|���� ��%�TW

�&�*H&�������*]t�M>&��)�%����A:&%�I�������=Y*+S%�>&��%�:N]J1�&�yx{zb9��%�����b���I���������m�TW

W&W�W

�&�NL�%��}����S�&>���A>�����~W^]�!�+k�/.0�21E3h+��`. ��1s. +-�/. ��1�&�yx{zb9��%�����b���I�����������KW

F�KfkqG*\OP"t ��uqÔeÖ Z�\OU�U]a�U�a���sHdfdlUqk]Kl�OJ Kl^?Ü�×~Õ

u�D

Page 16: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

��(���%��M;Q�����&�&%)R���Z;~!����\D-.f���A�nD-. � D-. �EDe. ���+��m)�%��&�Q+?��(���%��M;y+�S�J�&��%�) �&�Z;U1[�\YN�S>&��)�%&����1 !��&1+��=x� ������A�� � $���{zEDe. ���&1+�� Y[Wox�`���������E� ���^z De. ���&1

���������y+����������������1

+��m)�%��&�Q+?��(���%��M;y+�S�J�&��%�) �&�Z;U1[� ]=�S>&��)�%&�����J1g!���1+��=x� ������A�� � $���{zEDe. ���&1+�� Y[Wox�`���������E� ��$���^z D-. ����1+�� ]�Wox�`���������E� �� _t���{zED-. ����1

���������y+�����������M����1

+��m)�%��&�Q+?��(���%��M;y+�S�J�&��%�) �&�Z;U1[� u=�S>&��)�%&�����J1g!���1+��=x� ������A�� � $���{zEDe. ���&1+�� Y[Wox�`���������E� ��$�� ���^z D-. ���&1+�� ]�Wox�`���������E� ��$��/_b��� z D-. ���&1+�� u�Wox�`���������E� �� _t���{zED-. ����1

���������y+���-;J���&���&�J1

+��m)�%��&�Q+?��(���%��M;y+�S�J�&��%�) �&�Z;�1�1g!��&1+��=x� ������A�� � $���{zEDe. ���&1+��vO&%t�S>&��)�%&���������&1��%����

F�KfkqG*\�P�t ��t�ÔeÖ Z�\OU�U]a�U]a���s�dldlU]kqKl��J�I_sygi[��OPh�6Kl^ >)�O[]IÆPSdldfP]Õ

kqPS^*Ph\O[�MQPSR?a|Uq\�MOW*P�Z*\OU©Ó]Ph\hÕ

� R.' �\1�- � ')(*(*' �� � � 1\S.1\��')+Ò W*PU>)�Q[�IÆPSdldlP ? � A"Üy��s���MOPhJ � ×�[]G/Gqx�v�Ù"Uq\ C�G �Kf�e["ghUqJ¾I�Kl^[�MOKlUq^°U]a�M !pUYZ[]\�MQ�hÕ Ò W*PU>)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP���sH��MQPSJKl�m[]^-Kl^_MQPS\Q[]g�MQKNÓqPTMQW*PSUq\OPSJ Z*\OU©ÓqPS\LMOW[�MÉÓqPS\OKf}*Ph� dfUqkqKfgi[]d���M�[�MQPhJmPh^_MO� kqKNÓqPh^ÎMQU½KfMhÕ >)�Q[�IÆPSdldlPygh[]^UqZ{Ph\O[�MQP !`KNMQWÉ[]^_sVkqKNÓqPS^VdlUqkqKfg]v�!`W�Ph^VMQW*P`dfUqkqKlg(Kl�e��ZÆPSghKN}PhRÉKl^VKNMQ����JmPSMQ[ �)dl[]^*kqG*[]kqP ��Õ Ò W*P`dlUqkqKfg !�Pg�W*Uq��P¡MQU"G*��P�a|Uq\cUqG*\eJmPSMOW*U�R*UqdlU]k]sYKl� � A�Üev�Uq\cW*KfkqW*Ph\ �)Uq\�R*Ph\�dlUqkqKfg]Õ ��^�dlK`��P�}\O��M �¹Uq\OR*PS\cdlU]kqKlg�v � A"Ü[]dfdlU�!`��a|G*^*g�MQKfUq^*��MQUyI{P¾}\O��M �¹ghdz[��O��Ó�[]dlG�Ph� ( K�Õ¬P]ÕNv<Ó�[]dfG*Ph��MOW[�M�gi[�^½I{PÉZ[]���OPhR�[]�"Z[�\Q[]JmPSMOPh\O��MOUa|G*^*g�MQKfUq^*�c[�^*R¾\OP�MQG*\�^*PhR<Õ � A"Ü?[]dl��U�[]dfdlU�!`�~��G[�^�MOKf}gh[�MQKfUq^°U]^°a|G*^*g�MQKlU]^*�hÕ Ò W*P¡[]R�Ó�[]^_MQ[]kqP�U]a*G*�OKf^*kW*KfkqW*Ph\ �)Uq\�R*Ph\�dlUqkqKfg«Kf��M !�U]a|UqdlR<Õ F�Kf\O��Miv<MOW*PVZ*\OU©Ó]Ph\�gi[]^ I{P¾G*��PhR MQUTZ*\�U�Ó]PVa£[]gSMO��[]IÆU]G�M�a|G*^*g�MQKfUq^*�hÕFUq\¡P V�[]JmZ*dfP]v !�P�gi[]^?�OW*U�!�MOW[�M6[VkqKNÓqPh^?Z*\�PhR*Kfgi[�MOPYKf�`[]^yKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MiÕ3F�PhghU]^*R�v � A"Ü�gh[]^?IÆP�G*��PhRMQUVZ�\OU©ÓqP � ���!�"! ��� � �#� �v*Uq\pMOW*PhU]\�sT[�IÆUqGHM�Z*\�UHU]a�JmPSMOW*UHR��hÕ Ò W*Kf��Kl��G��OPSa|G�d<a|Uq\pÓ]Ph\OKN}gi[�MQKlU]^TIÆPSgi[]G*��PKfM`Z�\OU©ÓqPS�6MOW[�M¡MQW�PYJmPSMOW*U�R*�`G*�OPSR?MOUmÓ]Ph\OKNaÈsT��s���MQPhJm��[]\OP�MOW*PhJm�OPSdfÓqPS����UqG*^*R<Õ

>)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP ���L��s�^_M�[0V.Kl�L[]^ [�G*kqJmPh^_MQPSR.ÓqPS\O�OKfUq^ U]a«r�Ü3Õ�ÜjUqkqKfgi[]d�a|Uq\�J¾G*dl[]P?[]\OP���M�[�MQPhR.Kl^ r�Ü3vG*��Kl^*koMOW*PTdz[�^*kqG[]k]P �¬�«M)s�ZÆP ��s���MOPhJ !£[]^*RÇ��s�^_M�[�V�$�v3I*G�M¾MOW*P ��s�^_M�[�V�Kl�°[]G*kqJmPh^_MQPSR�MQUA[�dldlU�! a|U]\MQW�Pm��M�[�MOKl^*kTU�ap��G[]^_MOKf}PS\O�hÕ Ò W*PÉgSUqJLJL[]^*R���MQUyghUq^_MO\OUqdcMOW*PÉZ*\OU©ÓqPS\Y[]\OP !`\OKNMOMOPh^ Kl^AÓqPS\�sA��KlJmZ*dlP��s�^_M�[�V<Õ Ò W*PYroÜ dlU]kqKlgh[]da|Uq\OJ¾G�dz[]P�[]\OP !`\OKfM�MQPS^TKl^ ��G*U]MOPh�`[]�`[�\OkqG*JmPh^_MO�pMQU°MOW*Ph��P�ghUqJmJ [�^*R*�hÕ�ÖZ*\�UHU]a~U]a���s�dfdlUqkqKf�OJ Kl^ >)�Q[�IÆPSdldlP"Kf���OW�U�!`^�Kl^ F�KfkqG*\OP"t ��tHÕeÖ�M¡MOW*P�Ph^*R?U]a�MQW*P�Z*\�UHU�a�v !pP�Kf^�Ó]UB�]P�MQW�P-$# � � &�& Z�\OU�U]a~MQ[]gSMOKlg�v !`W*Klg�W?Kl^_Ó]UB�]PS��[ÉI*G*KfdfM �¹Kl^ ��KlJmZ*dlKN}Ph\SÕ

u�I

Page 17: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

>)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP ? � A"Ü��OG*Z*Z{Uq\�MQ�"MQW*Pm[]R�R*KfMOKlUq^ÊU�ap^*P ! Z*\�UHU�apJmPSMOW*UHR���[]^*RAM�[]g�MQKfgh�hvjI{U]MOW½Kf^ KfMQ��dz[]^��kqG[�kqPT[]^*RÇKf^ÎroÜev~MOW*PTKlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^_M�[�MOKlUq^½dz[]^�kqG[]kqPLU]a`MQW*P Z*\OU©ÓqPS\hÕ�>)^�MQW*PTdl[�MOMOPh\hvW>)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP gh[]^I{PLG*��PhR�[]�«[���M�[]^�R[]\ORÁZ*\OUqk]\Q[]JmJLKf^*kTdz[�^*kqG[]k]P]v��OU�MOW*PmG*�OPS\¾gi[]^�ZÆU�MQPh^_MOKz[]dfdfsÊgS\OPh[�MQPLZÆU�!�Ph\�a|G�dM�[�gSMQKfgh�SÕ

>)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP ? � A"ÜÁ[�dl�OUVW*[]�6[É\�Phdl[�MQKNÓqPhdNs dl[]\OkqP�G*�OPS\6gSUqJmJ¾G*^*KNM)sqv[]^�R�KNMQ�¡R[�MQ[VdlKlI�\Q[]\�KlPh�p[]\OP�JmUq\OPP V�MOPh^*��KfÓqP�Õ ��U�!�PSÓ]Ph\hv�MQW�P >)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP¾R[�M�[ ��MO\OG*g�MQG*\�PÉdlKlI�\Q[]\�KlPh�6R*Uy^*U]M�R*Kl\�PhgSMOdfs�J [�MQg�WÊMQW�PVUq^*Ph��Kf^>@A6Ö«v�OUL[]^_sK>@A6Ö5R[�M�[V��MO\OG*g�MQG*\�Ph��^�PhPhRyMQUÉI{P�J []^�G[�dldfsmMQ\O[]^*��dz[�MOPhRTa|Uq\">)�Q[�IÆPSdldlP�Õ

�� � � � ��� � � ���� �� �

r�U�R*Phd�g�W*PSg �]Ph\��°[�\OP¾[mZÆU]�O�OKfI*dlP°[]dfMOPh\�^[�MQKNÓqP�ÓqPS\OKf}*gi[�MOKlUq^�JLP�MQW*U�R�Õ�r�UHR�Phd�g�W�Phg �]PS\O��P V�[]JmKl^�P«MQW�PPh^_MOKl\OPY\OPh[]g�W[]I�dlPY��M�[�MQPY�OZ[]gSP°U]ae[mZ*\�Uqkq\O[]J MQUmR*PSMOPh\�JLKf^*P«KNae[ÉZ*\OU]ZÆPS\�M)s?W*UqdfR*�hÕ Ò W�PSs !pU]\#�yKl^�[Ó�[]\OKfPSM)smU]a�^*Uq^LMQPhJmZ{Uq\Q[]dÆ[]^*R Z*\OUqZ{Uq��KfMQKfUq^[]dMOPhJmZÆUq\O[]d{dlUqkqKfgh� ��n¡Ù�× GBG �<[]^*Ry[]\�P�a|G*dfdfsm[]G�MOUqJL[�MQPSRZ*\�U�Ó�KfR*PhR°MOW*PpG��OPh\���^*U�!`��MQW*P�Z*\OU]ZÆPS\�M)s�MQU6ÓqPh\�KfaÈs]Õ Ò W*PSKl\�J []Kf^«dfKlJmKfMjKf��MOW[�M~I_s«W*[©Ó�Kf^*k�MOU�P V�[]JmKl^�P[]dfd¡\OPi[�g�W[]I*dfPo��MQ[�MQPS�hv�MOW*PhKf\mZ{Ph\�a|Uq\OJL[]^*gSP�gh[]^ ��G�=<PS\ R*\O[]��MOKlgh[]dldNsÁa|Uq\m��s���MOPhJm� !`KfMOW-dl[]\Ok]P���M�[�MOP�OZ*[]ghPS�hv�[�^*R�MOW*PSs?R*UL^*U]M !pUq\ �Ta|Uq\`Kl^�}^�KfMQP���M�[�MOP°��s���MQPhJm��KNac��UqG*^*R*^�Ph�O��Kl�`MQUmIÆPYZ*\OPS�OPS\�ÓqPSR�Õ FUq\ghU]^*ghG*\�\OPS^�M~��s���MQPhJm�hv�JLU�R*PSdl�jg�W*PSg �]Ph\��cW[iÓqP3MQU6P V�[]JmKl^�P3[]dld�Kl^_MQPS\OdlPh[iÓHKf^*kq�jU]a�P VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^*�Svq[]^*R"MOW*PhKf\\OG�^�MOKlJmP¡Kl^*gS\OPh[]�OPS�(PXVHZÆUq^�Ph^_MQKl[]dldNs !`KfMOWVMQW*P`^�G*J¾I{Ph\3U]aÆZ*\OU�ghPS�O��Ph�pG�^*dlPS�O�3ghdfPSÓqPS\3UqZ�MQKfJLKNMi[�MOKlUq^��c[]\�PR*Uq^�P]Õ

r�U�R*Phd�g�W*PSg �]Ph\~R*Ph��Klkq^�Ph\O��W[iÓqP(ghU]JLP3G*ZJ!`KfMOWY��UqJmP !p[is��~MQU`U©ÓqPS\OgSUqJLP3MQW�P(dl[]\Ok]P�?�Kf^�}^*KNMQPc��M�[�MOP�OZ*[]ghP�Z*\OUqI�dlPhJ?Õ *(sÉG*�OKf^*k°gSdlPSÓ]Ph\(R[�MQ[«��MO\OG*g�MQG*\�Ph���OG*g�WT[���I*Kf^[]\�sÉR*PhgSKl�OKfUq^mR*Kz[]k]\Q[]Jm�hv_dl[]\OkqP`��M�[�MOP�OZ*[]ghPS�"gi[]^AI{P°g�W*PSg �]PSRÁ��G*Klg ��dNs !|dlUqkÉMQKfJLPO$¡a|Uq\�JLU]��M�Z�\OUqkq\O[]Jm��W�G*JL[]^*� !�UqG*dfR !`\OKNMQP �¬n¡Ù�× G�G ��Õ��U�!�PSÓ]Ph\hv�MQW�Ph\OPÉ[�\OPVZ*\�Uqkq\Q[�JL��a|U]\ !`W*Klg�WAMOW*Kl��MOPhg�W*^�Kl��G*PÉR*U�Ph�"^*U]M !pUq\ ��Õ FUq\�[]^ Kf^�}^*KNMQP¾��M�[�MOP��s���MQPhJ?v*JmUHR�Phd<g�W�Phg �]PS\O��[]\OP"G��OPhRTMOUVg�W*Phg � }*^*KfMOP���MQ[�MQP �������� � ��� �!�#" "U]a�MQW*P���s���MQPSJ�vI�G�M¡W�G*JL[]^!�Uq\#�mKl�(Kl^_ÓqU]dfÓqPSRTKl^ma|Uq\OJ¾G�dz[�MOKl^*kY[]^*R Z*\OU©Ó�Kl^*kYMQW*P�ghUq^*gS\OP�MQP�MOU¾[]I*��MQ\O[]gSM¡JL[]Z*Z�Kl^*k*ÕcFHPhg�MQKfUq^TtHÕE;HÕNuR*Kf�OghG��O�OPS�"MQPhg�W�^*Kl��G*PS�Y\�Phdl[�MQPSRÊMQU JmUHR�Phd�g�W�Phg ��Kl^*kyG*��Kl^*k MOW*Kl��[]I*��MQ\Q[�gSMQKfUq^ []^*RAW�U�! KNM�\OPSdz[�MOPh��MOUUqG*\ !�Uq\ �{Õ

���� ��� � � �� ��� �� �� � � � ��� �����

Ò W*PoX"[]K`��Uq^.Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MmR*P�MQPhg�MQUq\ �¬b(n¡Ù�Û�w�ui[ �6Z*\OUqZ{Uq��Ph� Z*\�UqZ{Ph\�MOKlPS�mMOW[�M []\OP�dlK`��PhdNs�MQU�IÆP?MQ\OG�PMQW�\OUqG*k]W*UqG�M�[ÉZ*\OUqk]\Q[]J ���`PXV�PSghG�MOKlUq^<Õ�X"[]KN�]Uq^yUqZ{Ph\O[�MQPS��R�s�^[�JLKfgi[]dfdfsLI�syPXV�[]JLKf^*Kl^�kÉÓ�[]dfG*Ph�`gSUqJ �Z*G�MOPhR R*G�\OKl^�k�P VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^Ë[]^*R k]Ph^*PS\Q[]dfK`MhKf^*kÁU©Ó]Ph\ MOW*Uq�OP�Ó][�dlG*PS�hÕP>¹MQ� UqG�MQZ�G�M Kf� Kl^-MQW*Poa|U]\OJ U]aKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MQ�¡U©Ó]Ph\6[mk]\Q[]JmJ [�\pUq^TMQW�PYZ�\OUqkq\O[]J ����Ó�[]\�Kz[]I*dfPh�SÕ >)^*KfMOKz[]dfdfs]v�X"[]KN�]Uq^TgSUq^ ��PSgSMQG�\OPh�6MQW[�M6[]dldZ*\�UqZÆPS\�MOKlPh�YKl^½KfMO��kq\Q[]JmJL[]\"[]\�PmMO\OG*PmUq^�MOW*PmZ*\OUqk]\Q[]J?Õ Ò W*PS^ÇX"[]KN�]Uq^ P V�[]JmKl^�Ph��MQW*PmP VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^R[�MQ[�[]^*RVR�PhdlP�MQPS�3[]^_s°Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MO�~MQW*[�M3[]\�P�ghUq^_MO\Q[]R*KfgSMOPhRVI_s°MOW*P�R[�MQ[�Õ F~Kl^[]dfdfs]v�X"[�K`�]U]^¾G*�OPS�e��MQ[�MQKfg[]^[�dfs��OKf��[�^*Ro��M�[�MOKl��MOKlgh[]d�MQPS��MQ�6MQUL\OPhR�G*ghPYMQW*P«^�G�J¾IÆPS\�U�aca£[]dl��P�ZÆUq��KfMOKfÓqPS��I_s?PhdfKlJmKl^[�MQKl^�k¾�OUqJmP�U]aMQW�P \OPSJ [�Kl^*Kf^*kyKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ� �¬b(n¡Ù�Û�wqw ��Õ ;ËW*PS^�G*�OPSR�Kl^�ghUq^���G*^*gSMOKlUq^ !`KfMOW�MQW�P >@A6Ö Kl^_MOPh\OZ�\OPSMOPh\SvX"[]KN�]Uq^VPXV�Z�\OPh���OPS��MQW�Kl�ca|Uq\�J []dH�OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^VKl^ >@A6ÖË[��3[]^ÉKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MeU]a{MQW*P¡PXV�PSghG�MOPhR []G�MQU]J [�MOUq^�Õ

X�s�^[]JmKlg�R*PSMOPhg�MQKlU]^oU]a�Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�`Kl�`G*^*��UqG*^*R<vÆI{Phgh[]G*�OPYMQW*PS\OP«Kl�`^*UmkqG[]\O[]^_MQPhPYMQW[�M6MOW*P�MQPh��M�OG�KfMQPTG��OPhR�MQU kqPS^*Ph\O[�MQPyPXV�PSghG�MOKlUq^ÇMO\Q[]gSPh�Va|G*dldNsÁg�W*[]\Q[]g�MQPS\OK`MSPh�VMQW�P?PXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^ÎPS^_ÓHKf\OUq^�JLPS^�MhÕ >)^Z*\O[]gSMOKlghP�v_MQW*P6\OPSZÆUq\�MQPSR Z*\�UqZÆPS\�MOKlPh��[]\�P6G��OG[]dfdfs¾MO\OG*P�[]^*RL[]\�P�kqPS^*Ph\O[]dldNsVW*PSdlZ�a|G*dKf^LPXVHZ*dlKfgi[�MOKl^*k"MQW�P��s���MQPhJCG*^*R�Ph\�MQPh��MV[]^�R9?�Uq\�KfMO�YMOPh��M°��G*KfMOP]ÕKFG*\�MQW*PS\OJmUq\OP�v�MOW*PLJmPSMOW*U�RÁR*PS�Ogh\�KlI{PhR�Kl^ MQW*Kf�«Z[�ZÆPS\

u�;

Page 18: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

R*U�Ph�¡^*U�M¡\OPSdfsLUq^TG*^*Z*\�U©ÓqPh^�dlPSJLJL[]����\Q[�MQW*PS\hv�KNM¡G*��Ph�`X"[]KN�]Uq^ MOUV�OG*kqk]Ph��M`dfPhJmJ [���[]^*Ry[°MOW*PhU]\OPhJZ*\�U�Ó]Ph\6MQU Z�\OU©ÓqP !`W�Klg�W*P�ÓqPh\�U]acMQW�Ph�OP«dlPSJLJL[]�`KfM6gi[�^Ê[]^*R�MQW*PS^�MQULG*�OPYMQW*U]�OP°dfPhJmJ [��6Kf^o[mdz[]\�kqPh\Z*\�UHU]a�Õ

X"[]K`��Uq^yZ*\OU�R*G*gSPh�`UqG�MOZ*G�M`Kf^yMOW*P�a|Uq\�J U]a�[¾a|Uq\OJL[]d<��ZÆPSghKN}gi[�MOKlUq^TMOW[�M`U]aÈMOPh^yJ [�MQg�W*PS�U!`W*[�M6[W�G*JL[]^ !pUqG�dlRÉW[iÓqP"!`\OKNMOMOPh^ �¬b(n¡Ù�Û�wqwHv_Û�b3w_t�I ��ÕebcÓ]Ph^ !`W�Ph^LX"[]K`��Uq^4!�[��(k]KfÓqPS^ÉKl^[]R�Ph��G[�MOP�MQPh��M�OG�KfMQPS��Kl^oUq\OR*PS\�MQUy[�\�MQKN}ghKl[]dldNs R*PSkq\Q[�R*P¾KfMO��UqG�MOZ*G�Mhv�KfM���MOKldld�KlJmZ*\�U�Ó]PhRÊZ�\OUqkq\O[]JmJLPS\�Z{Ph\�a|Uq\OJL[]^*gSP!|MOUm[É��M�[�MOKl��MQKlgh[]dldNs ��Klkq^�Kf}gh[]^_M¡R*Phk]\OPhPO$`U]^�[ÉZ*\�Uqkq\Q[�J�ÓqPS\OKN}gi[�MOKlUq^TMQ[]�#� � Û�b3w_t�g ��Õ

Û�KfJLJmPh\`[]^�Robe\O^���M �¬Û�b(wqt�I ��W[iÓqP°[]dl��UmG��OPhRoR�s�^[]JmKlg�[]^[�dfs��OKf�`a|\�UqJ X"[]KN�]Uq^TMOULW*PSdlZ?��MQ[�MQKfg[]^[�dfs��OKf��Kf^?MOW*P¾b(F*n"?qØq[iÓ�[LMOUHUqdEÕ Ò W*PSKl\6Z*\OKfJ []\�sTkqU_[�d.!p[]�6MQU PXV�MQ\Q[�gSM"[�^*R�Ó]Ph\OKNaÈsoØq[©Ó�[mZ*\OUqk]\Q[]J�OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^*�V\O[�MQW*PS\¾MQW[�^�Ó]Ph\�KfaÈs�Kl^*kA�O[�a|PSM)s�Z*\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKfPh�VKl^�}*\O��MmUq\�R*Ph\VdfUqkqKfg []I{UqG�MVR�Kl��MO\OKfI*G�MQPSR[]dfkqUq\OKNMQW*Jm�hÕ Ù"\OU�ghPAPSM�[]dEÕ �¬Ù�\�U_w_t ��[]\OP½[�M�MQPSJLZ�MOKl^*k�MOU�G*�OP JmUHR*PSd�g�W*PSg �]Ph\��ÊUq^ËZ*\�Uqkq\Q[�JL� MOUkqPS^*Ph\O[�MQP MQPS��M?UqG�MOZ*G�Mya|Uq\yR�s�^[]JmKlgAKf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MyR*P�MQPSgSMQKfUq^ !`KfMQW MOW*PÁX"[�K`�]U]^ËMOUHU]d�v6\Q[�MOW*Ph\TMQW*[]^P VHPSghG�MOKl^*kÉMQW*P�Z*\�Uqkq\O[]JL��MOW*PhJm�OPSdfÓ]Ph�hÕ

���� ����� ��� � ��� � � �

>@?BA [�G�MQUqJL[�MQ[ �¬Ü Ò CBG �`W[iÓqP?I{PhPh^ÎG*��PhR-MOU�JmU�R*Phd¡[ÊÓ�[]\�KlPSM)s�U]a�R�Kl��MO\OKfI*G�MQPSR-��s���MQPSJL� �¬ÙYÜ�wqwq[ ��Õ>@?BA []G�MQU]J [�MQ[T[]\OP�!|ZÆUq���OKfI*dfsoKl^�}^�KfMQP�vj^*Uq^*R�PSMQPS\OJmKl^*Kf��MOKlg�$6��M�[�MQPÉJ [�g�W*Kl^*PS�"Kl^[!`W*Kfg�W½MO\Q[]^*��KfMOKlUq^*�I{PSM !�PhPh^.��M�[�MQPh�m[]\�P?[]�O��UHgSKz[�MOPhR !`KfMOWÎ^*[]JLPSR � �����!�#" �Õ�Ö�gSMQKfUq^*�m[]\�PTghdz[��O�OKN}PhR-[]�ÉPhKNMQW*PS\ � "�� ���� � � �EveU]\ � " ������" ��� Õ Ò W*PTKl^*Z�G�MQ�°[]^*RÇUqG�MOZ*G�MO�V[]\OPLP V�MQPS\O^[�d¡[]gSMOKlUq^��°G*��PhR�a|Uq\«ghUqJmJ¾G*^*Kfgi[�MOKlUq^!`KfMOW MQW*P�[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^ �¬�pPS^�Ó�Kf\OUq^*JmPh^_M��*Kl^_MQPS\O^[�d�[]g�MQKlU]^*�¡[]\�P�Ó�Kl�OKfI*dlP�Uq^*dNsmMOU¾MQW*P�[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^ KNMQ�OPSdfa�ÕÖ�^.[]G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^ÇgSUq^_MQ\OU]dl� !`W*Klg�WÎUqG�MOZ*G�M []^*RÎKl^_MQPS\O^[]d`[�gSMQKfUq^*�ÉKfMÉZ{Ph\�a|Uq\OJm�hv�I*G�MLKl^*Z�G�Mm[]gSMOKlUq^��[]\�PV^*U]M"G*^�R*Ph\"KNMQ��gSUq^_MQ\OU]d�ÕYÖ�gSMOKlUq^���gi[]^ I{PVZ[]\O[]JLP�MQ\�K`MhPSR�Õ�Ö�^ >@?BA+[]G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^ÊgSUq^*��Kl��MO�"U]a(KfMO������" ���� ����vW!`W*Kfg�WÇdlKf��MQ�«KfMO�¾[]g�MQKlU]^*���([o��PSMÉU]a ��!����� �v��OUqJmP U]a"!`W*Kfg�W�[]\OPLR*Kl��MQKf^*kqG*Kf�OW*PSRÇ[]�¾��M�[]\�M��MQ[�MQPS���([ ��!��� � ! � � ��" �� ���!�#" � ���%�����!�#"v�!`W�Klg�W�gSUq^_M�[]Kf^*�YMO\OKfZ*dlPS�YU�a�MQW*Pma|Uq\OJ !|��MQ[�MQP�vc[]g�MQKlU]^�v~��M�[�MOP�$ �[]^*R�[]^yUqZ�MOKlUq^*[]d��OP�M6U]a �!�#����Õ

Ö�g�MQKlU]^��ÊKf� ��" ����� � �ÉKl^L��M�[�MQP���Kfa<MOW*Ph\�P�Kf�p[Y��M�[�MQP����H�OG*g�W MOW[�M4!�� A��QA���� $eKl��[YMQ\O[]^*��KfMQKfUq^mU]a�MQW�P[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^<Õ >)^�Z*G�MY[]g�MQKlU]^*�"[]\�P¾Ph^[�I*dlPSRAKl^APSÓ]Ph\�sA��MQ[�MQP�Õ Ò W*PVUqZ{Ph\O[�MQKfUq^ÊU]a�[]^[>@?�A []GHMQUqJL[�MQU]^Kl��R*PS�OgS\OKlI{PhRÁI�s½[�^ÁP VHPSghG�MOKlUq^��! "��#OA0@%$ A���$0A�&�&�&Nv�!`W�Klg�WÁKf�Y[]^�[]dNMQPS\O^[�MOKl^*ky��Ph��G*Ph^�ghPh�VU�a���MQ[�MQPS�[]^*Ro[]gSMOKlUq^��`MOW[�M�Kl�`Ó�[]dlKfR !`KNMQW?\OPS�OZ{PhgSM�MQUmMQW*P«[]G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^ �¬�¡MQ\O[]^*�OKNMQKfUq^*�hÕ Ò W*P°PXV�PSghG�MOKlUq^���U]ac[]^[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^½[]\�P¾MQW*Pm�OP�MYU]a¡[]dfdc�OG�g�WÁ�OPS��G*Ph^*gSPh�SÕTÖ+MO\Q[]gSP('ÁU]ap[]^½P VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^)�ÎKf�YKNMQ�"Z*\�U ��Phg�MQKfUq^�OG�g�W MOW[�M"��M�[�MOPh��[]^�RAKl^_MQPS\O^[]d~[]g�MQKlU]^*�"[]\�P¾\OPSJLU©ÓqPSR�Õ Ò W*P¾MQ\O[]ghPS�"U]a([]^ []GHMQUqJL[�MQU]^oR*P�MQPh\�JLKf^*P]vMQW�Ph\OP�a|Uq\OP�vKfMO�¡P V�MQPS\O^[]d�I{PhW[iÓ�KlU]\hÕ

×e\OUqkq\O[]J Z�\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKlPS�cUq\c��ZÆPSghKN}gi[�MOKlUq^��3[]\OP�R�Ph�OgS\OKfIÆPSRma|Uq\�J [�dldfs�Kf^°MQPS\OJm�eU]aÆ[]G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^°MO\Q[]gSPh�SÕÖ Z*\�UqZÆPS\�M)sTKf��R*P�}^*PhR�I_s MQW*P"��PSM6U]a�MQ\O[]ghPS�`KfM`[]R�JLKNMQ�hÕ F�U]\�P V�[]JmZ*dlP�v*Z*\�UqZÆPS\�M)s+* JLKfkqW_M¡\OPS��G*Kl\�P[]^o[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^TMQULUq^*dfsT}*\OP«[LZ[]\�MQKfghG*dl[]\`[]gSMOKlUq^�@ !RP $"!`W*PS\OP P�Kf��[]^�PSÓ]Ph^ÊKf^�MOPhkqPS\hÕ">)^?MQW*Kf��gh[]�OP�v*5Kl�3MQW*P���PSM¡U�a�[]dldMQ\O[]ghPS��ghU]^�MQ[]Kl^�Kl^*k«Uq^*dfsmP�ÓqPh^yKf^�Ó]UHgh[�MQKfUq^*�(U]aE@ÕeÖ�^y[]GHMQUqJL[�MQU]^ UqI{PSs��¡[°k]KfÓqPS^Z*\�UqZÆPS\�M)s+* Kfa~KfMQ��MO\Q[]gSPh�6[]\�P«[V��G*I*�OP�M�U�a,*ÉÕ

��.- /� ����� � � �� ���� �� ������

bcÓqPS\�sÉZ*\�UqZÆPS\�M)s°U]aÆ[�Z*\OUqk]\Q[]J MQ\Q[�ghP¡gi[�^mI{P !`\�KfMOMOPh^m[]�3[]^VKf^_MQPh\��OPSgSMQKfUq^ÉU]aÆ[��Q[�a|P�M)sÉ[]^*Rm[�dfKfÓqPS^*Ph���Z*\�UqZÆPS\�M)s � Ö"F C_; �EÕ4>)^�a|Uq\�J []dfdfs]v<[T�Q[�a|PSM)sAZ*\�UqZ{Ph\�M)sÊKl��Uq^�P !`W�Ph\OP���^�U]MQW*Kf^*kTI[]R W[�Z*ZÆPS^*� ��v.!`W�KldlP

u�C

Page 19: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

[odfKfÓqPS^*Ph���¾Z*\�UqZÆPS\�M)s�Kl�YUq^*P !`W�Ph\OP ���OUqJmPSMOW*Kl^�kokqU�UHR�PSÓ]Ph^_MQG[�dldfs½W[�Z*ZÆPS^*� ��vePh^*��G*\OKf^*kÊMQW[�M°MQW�PZ*\�Uqkq\Q[�J JL[��]PS�6Z�\OUqkq\�Ph����R*G�\OKl^�kmKNMQ�¡PXV�PSghG�MOKlUq^<Õ

FUq\OJL[]dldNsqv�[¾MQ\O[]ghP"Z*\�UqZ{Ph\�M)s !E[V�OP�M`U]a�MQ\Q[�ghPh�SvUq\¡[]dNMQPS\O^[�MOKfÓ]Phdfs]v*[¾Z*\�PhR*Kfgi[�MOP"Uq^TMQ\O[]ghPS�0$ * Kf�¡[�Q[�a|PSM)syZ*\�UqZÆPS\�M)sTKNa�Ô

� * gSUq^_M�[]Kf^*��MQW�PYPSJLZHM)sTMQ\Q[�ghP]v*[]^*R

� >¹a���Kl�¡Kf^+*mvHMQW*PS^Ê[]^_s }^�KfMQP"Z�\OPS} V�� ������Kl�¡Kl^ *ÉÕ

>¹a3[mMO\Q[]gSP«R�UHPS��^*U�M��O[�MQKf��aÈs?[L�O[�a|PSM)s?Z*\�UqZ{Ph\�M)s]v{MOW*Ph^ !pP«gi[]^?}^*RoMOW*PYP V�[]gSM�Z*dz[�ghP !`W*Ph\�P°MQW�PZ*\�UqZÆPS\�M)s !p[]�`Ó�KlUqdl[�MQPSR !`KfMQWTMOW*PY[]IÆU©Ó]P«R*P�}^*KNMQKlU]^�Õ

FUq\OJL[]dldNsqv * Kl�`[VdfKfÓqPS^*Ph���`Z*\OUqZ{Ph\�M)syKfa�Ô

� FUq\`[]^_s��½MQW*PS\OP�P VHKf��MQ��[]^yP V�MOPh^*��KlUq^� ��U�a���OG*g�W?MQW[�M�� ��Kl�¡Kf^?×~Õ

>)^VUqG*\�Ó]Ph\�Kf}gh[�MQKfUq^¾JmPSMQW�UHR*U]dlUqk]s]v0!�P�R*U"^�U]Me[�M�MQPSJLZ�M~ÓqPS\OKfaÈs°[]dfd�M)s�Z{Ph�eU]a�Z*\�Uqkq\O[]J5Z*\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKfPh�hvI*G�M a|UHgSG*� Uq^ �O[�a|PSM)s-Z*\OU]ZÆPS\�MQKfPh� U�a�R*Kl��MQ\OKfI*G�MOPhRË[]dfkqUq\OKNMQW*Jm�VMQW[�M gi[�^ IÆPÊR�Ph�OgS\OKfIÆPSR PhKfMOW*Ph\ I�s� " �#��������" �)�# ��������!�#" ÊU]\LI_s � �#������� � ����( �%��� �!�#" �����%�����!�#" �Õ ;�PoR�UÁMQW*Kf�LI{Phgh[]G*��PÊUqG*\ÉMQU�Uqdl�[]dfdlU�!ÌMOW*Ph��P°M !pU R*PhJmUq^*��MQ\Q[�MQKlU]^*��U�ae�Q[�a|P�M)s�MOU I{P«Ó]Ph\OKN}PhR<v�[]^*R�IÆPSgi[]G��OP¾dfKfÓqPS^*Ph����Z*\�UqZ{Ph\�MOKlPS��[]\�P^*U]M6[��6KfJLZ{Uq\�M�[]^_M�a|Uq\`[�dlkqUq\�KfMOW*J+ghUq\�\OPhg�MQ^*PS�O�SÕ

Ò W*PY^*P V�M`M !pUL�OPSgSMQKfUq^*�`�OW�U�!ÌW*U�! �Q[�a|PSM)sTZ*\�UqZ{Ph\�MOKlPS��[�Z*Z*dfsLMQU >@?BA [�G�MQUqJL[�MQ[�Õ

� !� !# � �(�*,�2e�#/�*�� !"&�2��*�����/��~&�2��*�����

Ò W*PVZ*G�\OZ{Uq�OPVU]a([ a|U]\ !p[]\ORA��KlJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^?\OPhdl[�MQKfUq^oKf��MQU \OPhdl[�MQP«M !pUy[]GHMQUqJL[�M�[Hv�[ � � ��� ��� �����!�#" ��$!� � � �����#"'[]^*R-[]^ ��� �� ��� ��" � �����!�#" �� ��� � ��� �#"v¡[]^�RÎMOUÁ�OW�U�! MQW[�MmMQW�P�dl[�MOMOPh\VKlJmZ*dfPhJmPh^_MQ�VMQW�PI{PhW[iÓ�KlUq\YU]a�MOW*PÉa|Uq\OJmPh\SÕ >¹a¡MQW*Pm�OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^�[�G�MQUqJL[�MOUq^�Kf�J��^�U�!`^�MOUoI{PhW[iÓ]P �Q[�a|Phdfs]v~MOW*Ph^���U!`KldfdÆMOW*P�KlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^�MQ[�MQKfUq^T[]GHMQUqJL[�MQU]^�v*[]^�R?MOW*P�KlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^�MQ[�MQKfUq^ !`KfdldÆIÆP"ÓqPS\OKN}PhR�Õ

FUq\OJL[]dldNsqv°[]^ []GHMQUqJL[�MQU]^ � Kl� R*P�}^*PSR MQU'KlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^_M½['��ZÆPSghKf}*gi[�MOKlUq^ []G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^ � KNa��� @ BHM ��! �4$�� ��� @ BHM ��! �L$�Õ3ÖÌa|Uq\ !p[]\�RT�OKlJ°G*dz[�MOKlUq^L\OPSdz[�MOKlUq^ �¬Ü�L G_D�I �<Kl����G $mghKlPS^_M !£I*G�M`^�U]M¡^*PSghPh� ��Q[�\�s�$¡MOU ��W*U�! MQW*Kf�6KfJLZ�dlPhJmPh^_MQ[�MQKfUq^�Õ3Ö a|Uq\ !p[]\OR��OKfJ¾G*dz[�MQKlU]^T\OPhdl[�MQKfUq^�V U]^�MQW�P«��M�[�MOPh��U�a � [�^*R�5�Q[�MOKl��}Ph�¡MQW�P�M !�UÉa|UqdldfU�!`Kf^*k°M !�ULgSUq^*R*KNMQKfUq^*�hÔ

� FUq\`[]dfd ��� � � @ ��� ��! �+$�v*MQW*PS\OP�P VHKf��MQ��� � � � @ ��� ��! �L$p��G*g�W�MOW[�M V:!�� A��.$�Õ� FUq\�[]dfd ! � A @6A���� $�� ��� @ P ��! �4$"[]^*R a|Uq\�[]dld����OG�g�W�MQW*[�M V:!�� A��.$�v�MQW*PS\OPÉP VHKl��MQ�«[]^ P VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^� � M J M�B���! �L$"!`KNMQWT}^[�dj��M�[�MQP�� ���OG*g�W?MQW[�MhÔ ��� @�BHM�!���$ ��� @�BSM�!R@ $¡[]^�R V:! ���#A�� � $�Õ

FUq\cPi[�g�WmPXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^��oU�a �«vqMQW*P`[�IÆU©ÓqP¡\�Ph��G*Kf\OPhJmPh^_M([]dfdlU�!`��G��3MOU"g�W*U�Uq�OP`[]^ÉPXV�PSghG�MOKlUq^��?U]a �MQW*[�M6��M�[�\�MQ��[]^*R?MQ\O[]^*�OKNMQKfUq^*�¡Z*\�UqZÆPS\OdNsqÕ Ò W*P � � � � �� ��� ��� � " ��� ��" ��JmPSMQW�UHR?G*�OPS��J¾G�dfMQKfZ*dlP�dlPSÓ]Phdf�U]a�[]G�MOUqJL[�M�[Ê[�\OP G*��PhR�MQUA��W*U�! MQW*[�MÉ[ÊghU]^*gh\�PSMQPyKfJLZ*dfPhJmPh^_M�[�MQKlU]^�KfJLZ*dfPhJmPh^_MQ�°[Ê�OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^<Õ

u�G

Page 20: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� !� !�� � ���e2e����23�p� 2e���������*�����

Ö�^yKf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M`[��O�OPS\�MOKlUq^yKl�p�OKlJmZ*dNs [¾��M�[�MOPhJmPh^_M`MQW[�M¡MOW*P"\OPh[]g�W[]I�dlP"��MQ[�MQPS�`U]ac[�^ >@?�A []GHMQUqJL[�MQU]^UqI{PSs�[ kqKNÓqPS^oZ*\�PhR*Kfgi[�MOP]Õ Ò W*Ph��PÉ[]�O��Ph\�MOKlUq^���[]Z*Z�dfsTMQU ��M�[�MQPh��[]^*RÊ^�U]M�MOU []g�MQKlU]^*�hÕ Ò U Z*\OU©Ó]P°MQW[�M[]^?[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^yUqI{PSs��6[]^?Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M 3�v*KfM`Kf�¡^*PhgSPh���Q[]\�s?MOUÉ�OW*U�!�M !�UmMOW*Kl^�kq�hÔ

� FUq\`[]dfd ��� � � @ ��� ��! �+$�v�3.!��($�Õ� FUq\`[]dfdQ! � A @6A���� $ � ��� @ P � ! �+$�v�3.!��($ � 3.!���� $�Õ>)^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MO��[]\OPVG��OPhR Kf^ÊMQW*\�PhP4!p[©s��SÕ F�Kl\���Mhv�KfM�Kl����UqJLP�MQKfJLPS��ghUq^_Ó]Ph^*KfPh^_M�MQUT�OZ{PhgSKfaÈsoZ*\OUqk]\Q[]J

Z*\�UqZÆPS\�MOKlPh�(G*��Kl^*kV[�^ Kl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M(\Q[�MOW*Ph\(MQW[�^ [«��ZÆPSghKN}gi[�MOKlUq^ []G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^�ÕcFHPhgSUq^*R�v�Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�3J [isI{P«^*PSPhR*PSRoMQUm�OW�U�! [m��KlJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^T\OPSdz[�MOKlUq^ ( Kf^?MOW*P«��KlJ¾G�dz[�MOKlUq^TZ*\�UHU�a�v�MQW*PYKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M`Kl�`G*��PhRA[��[VdlPSJLJL[�Õ Ò W*Kf\OR�v�Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�¡JL[©s IÆP�^*PSPhR*PSR�MOUmZ�\OU©ÓqPYU]MQW�Ph\`Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�SÕ

;ÁPLgi[]^�a|Uq\OJL[]dlKNMhPÉ[]^�R�Z*\OU©Ó]P J [�^�s½�O[�a|PSM)s�Z*\OU]ZÆPS\�MQKfPh�«[]�°KfJLZ�dlPhJmPh^_MQ[�MQKfUq^ \OPhdl[�MQKfUq^*��Uq\YKl^��Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�SÕ >)^ÁMOW*P ^�P V�M¾M !�UA�OPhg�MQKfUq^*�hv�!pP PXV�[]JLKf^*PmZÆUq���OKfI*dlPLJLP�MQW*U�R*��MQUoÓ]Ph\OKNaÈs½U]MQW*PS\°Z*\�UqZ{Ph\�M)sM)s�ZÆPS�hÕ

� !� !�� � �����������H�

ÜjKfÓ]Ph^*PS�O�`Z*\OU]ZÆPS\�MQKfPh�`[]\�P�G*��PhRyMQUV�OW�U�!1MQW[�M`[¾��s���MOPhJ JL[��]PS�¡PSÓ]Ph^_MQG[�djZ*\OUqk]\OPh���¡MQU�!�[�\OR*�`[¾kqUq[]d�ÕÖ dfKfÓqPS^*Ph����Z*\�UqZÆPS\�M)soKl��PSKfMOW*Ph\���M�[�MQPhR PXV�Z�dlKlgSKfMOdfsTKf^oMQPSJLZ{Uq\Q[�d~dfUqkqKlg�vÆU]\�\OPSdlKfPh��U]^oMQW*P°G*^*R*PS\Odfs�Kf^*kJmUHR*PSd(MOUÊZ*\�U�Ó�KfR*PLMOW*P MQPSJLZ{Uq\O[]dea|\Q[]JmP\!�Uq\#�½[]^�RÇKl�Y�OZ{PhghKN}PhR�Kf^�MQPS\OJm�°U]a¡MOW*P JmUHR�Phd�Õ FUq\«[]^P V�[]JmZ*dfPVU]a�MOW*PÉdz[�M�MQPS\hv�MQW�P >@?�A�[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^Êa|\O[]JmP\!�Uq\#�A[�dldlU�!`��a|U]\�[y��PSMYU]a � �#�� � ������� � �!�#" �vjU]\�OP�MQ��U]a�[]g�MQKlU]^*���OG�g�W½MOW[�MY[ Z[]\�MQKfghG*dl[]\���PSMYU]a3}\OKf^*kq��R�PSMQPS\OJmKl^*PÉ[� ��� �LP VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^�Õ F\�UqJ MOW*Ph��Pa£[]Kf\�P VHPSghG�MOKlUq^*�Sv�!`W*Klg�W�[]\OP°�OKlJmZ*dfP°dlKNÓqPS^*Ph���YZ�\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKlPS�hv�MOW*PVR*Ph��Klkq^�Ph\"gi[�^�[�\OkqG*P°JLUq\�P¾ghU]JLZ*dfP VdlKNÓqPS^*Ph���6Z�\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKlPS�hÕ

ÜjKfÓqP >@?BA�[]G�MQU]J [�MQ[ ��F�Ù«FHÖ�Ü.GBC �([]\�PL[TJmUq\OPÉkqPS^*Ph\O[]d !p[©sAMOU���ZÆPSghKNaÈsAdlKNÓqPh^�Ph�O�SÕ Ò W�PSs�[]dldfU�![]\�I*KfMO\Q[]\�s MQPSJLZ{Uq\Q[�d�a|U]\OJ¾G*dl[]PU!£��ZÆPSghKf}*PhRA[]��[L��PSM�U]a3[]gSghPhZHM�[]I*dfP«MO\Q[]gSPh�0$¡a|Uq\6dlKfÓ]Ph^*PS�O��Z*\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKfPh�hv!`KfMOWLMOW*P�Uq^�dfsÉ\OPS��MO\OKlg�MQKfUq^ I{PhKf^*k«MOW[�M(MQW*P�Z*\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKfPh�(\OPhJL[]Kf^ �Q[�MQKl��}�[]I*dfP¡a|Uq\�[]dfdKl^*Z�G�MQ�SÕ ��^�a|Uq\�MQG��^[�MOPhdNsqv]MO\Q[]R*KNMQKfUq^[]d_��KlJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^�\OPSdz[�MOKlUq^*�Sv !`W*Kfg�WV�OW*U�!�MQW*[�McUq^�P¡[]G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^«KlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^�MO��[�^*U]MQW�Ph\hvR*Uy^*U]M !�Uq\ �Êa|Uq\"dlKNÓqP4>@?BA []G�MOUqJ [�M�[�Õ Ò W�Kl�"Kl�"I{Phgh[]G*��P [T�OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^o\�Phdz[�MQKlU]^A�OW*U�!`��MQW[�M�Ph[]g�WU]acMOW*P°KfJLZ�dlPhJmPh^_MQ[�MQKfUq^?[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^ �¬�¡MQ\Q[�ghPh��[]\OP°[L�OG�I*�OP�M"U]a �����cMOW*P«MO\Q[]gSPh��U�acMQW*P«�OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^<v !`W*KldfP MQW*PTdfKfÓqPS^*Ph���É\OPh��G*Kf\OPSJLPS^�MO�É\OPh��MQ\�KlgSMÉMOW*PTghUq\�\OPSgSMÉMQ\O[]ghPS�mU�a�MOW*PT�OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^ MOUm[m��ZÆPSghKf}*gY��G*I*��PSMiÕ

��U�!�PSÓqPS\hvHÖ�MOMQKfP � Ö�M�M GBG �W[]�3[ !p[©s¾U]a<��ZÆPSghKNaÈsHKf^*k�dlKNÓqPh^�Ph�O�cMOW[�M3dfPh^*R*�3KNMQ�OPSdfa�MQU�a|U]\OJL[]dHÓ]Ph\OKN}gi[ �MQKfUq^ I_sm�OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^É\OPhdl[�MQKfUq^�Õ�>)^�MOG*KfMOKfÓ]Phdfs]v�MOW*P�dfKfÓ]P6MO\Q[]gSPh��U]aj[]^ KlJmZ*dfPhJmPh^_M�[�MOKlUq^4!`Kfdld�I{P�[«��G*I*��PSMU]ajMOW*P�dfKfÓqP`MQ\O[]ghPS��U]a�MOW*P���ZÆPSghKf}*gi[�MOKlUq^�ÕW>)^ W*Kl��JLP�MQW*U�R�v�dlKNÓqPh^�Ph�O�pZ*\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKfPh�pJ°G*��MpIÆP��OZ{PhghKN}PhRy[��Z[]Kf\O�¡U]a~Z*\�PhR*Kfgi[�MOPh��� � A ����Uq^?MOW*PY[]G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^T��M�[�MOP]v�OG�g�W�MQW*[�M¡MQW*P"a|UqdfdlU�!`Kl^�k°MQPSJLZ{Uq\Q[�d�W*UqdfR*�hÔ

� ! ��� �� �L$Ò W*Kl�"\�Pi[]R�� ��Kl^�}*^*KfMOPhdfs?U]aÈMOPh^�v<KfM�Kf��MQ\�G*P¾MQW*[�M�[]^AU�ghgSG*\O\�Ph^*gSPmU�a(MOW*P¾Z*\�UqZ{Ph\�M)sÊÖ dlPh[]R*��MOUy[]^

Kl^H}^*KfMOPhdNs«U�aÈMQPh^VU�ghgSG*\O\�Ph^*gSP¡U]aMQW�P¡Z*\OUqZ{Ph\�M)s)*��*Õ Ò W�G*�Sv�MOW*P�MQPSJLZ{Uq\O[]d�a|\O[]JmP\!�Uq\#�YKl�~Ph^*gh[]Z*�OG�dz[�MOPhRPh^_MOKl\OPSdfs�Kl^ÁMOW*P JmUHR�Phd�vc[]^*R�MQW�P R*Ph��Klkq^�Ph\VUq^*dNs½W[]�¾MQU !pUq\ ��!`KNMQW�MQW�P }\O��MÉUq\OR�Ph\¾dfUqkqKlgmU]a`MQW�PZ*\�PhR*Kfgi[�MOPh�hÕE;ËKfMOW�MOW*Kl�j��ZÆPSghKl[]dqa|Uq\OJ1U]aHdlKfÓ]Ph^*PS�O�Sv]Ö�MOMOKlPeW[���R�PSÓqPSdlUqZ{PhR«[¡a|Uq\OJL[]d�MOW*PhU]\�s"U]a���dfKfÓqPS^*Ph���Z*\�Ph�OPS\�Ó�Kl^�kL��KlJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^ \�Phdz[�MQKlU]^*� �*v�[]^?P V�MQPS^*�OKfUq^�U�a~a|Uq\@!�[�\OR?�OKlJ°G*dz[�MOKlUq^L\OPSdz[�MOKlUq^*��a|U]\¡dlKfÓ]Ph^*PS�O�SÕ

t]w

Page 21: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� !� !�� � ������ ��2������q0�������°����������

A�G*\�JmPSMOW*UHRo\OPh��G*Kf\OPS�"�Q[�a|P�M)sÊZ*\�UqZÆPS\�MOKlPh��MQUTPhKNMQW*PS\�I{PVKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M�[��O�OPS\�MOKlUq^*�"U]\�\OP�}^*PSJLPS^�M�JL[]Z��Z*Kf^*kq�hv��OU�KfM�JL[isAdlPh[©Ó]PLU]G�M¾[Ta|P\! �Q[�a|P�M)s�Z�\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKlPS�hv�Ph��ZÆPSghKz[�dldfs�MQW*PmUq^*PS�«\�Phdl[�MQKf^*kTMQU�[]R �O[]gSPh^_M�OP�MQ�`U]a~��MQ[�MQPS�hÕ FUq\¡P V�[]JmZ*dlP�v*^*PSKfMQW�Ph\¡Kl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MQ�p^*Uq\¡�OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^ \�Phdz[�MQKlU]^*��gi[�^?R�Kl\OPSgSMOdfs �O[is MQW[�M[]^ []gSMOKlUq^ ��$cKl�(^*PSÓ]Ph\(a|UqdldfU�!�PhRmI_sL[]^*U]MOW*Ph\�[]gSMOKlUq^ ��©Õ ��U�!�PSÓqPS\hv�MOW*Ph\�P�[]\�P�Ph[]��s !p[isH�(MQU«\OP\!`\�KfMOP[]dfd��OG�g�WÁ�Q[�a|PSM)sAR*P�}^*KNMQKlU]^*�"Kl^_MQUTPSKfMOW*Ph\"Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M�[��O�OPS\�MOKlUq^*��Uq\�\OPS}*^*PhJmPh^_MQ�Sv�!`KNMQWAMQW�PL[�R*R*KfMOKlUq^U]a�W*Kl��MQUq\�sT��MQ[�MQP"Ó�[]\OKl[]I*dfPh� � Ü�L G_D][ ��Õ >)^?MOW*PYgi[]��P«U]a�MQW�Kl�`P V�[]JmZ*dlP�v�[ �[]kLgSUqG*dfR?I{PY�OPSMU!`W*PS^*PSÓ]Ph\�,$�Kf�¡P VHPhgSG�MQPSR�v<[�^*R?MOW*P�Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M¡ghU]G*dlRyI{P � ��`Kl�`^*P�ÓqPS\�PS^[]I*dfPhRyKfa:V�� @ D Kl�¡U]^ �*Õ

��� �� � ��� � ��� � �� ���

Ò W*P&>@A6Ö dl[]^*kqG*[]kqP ��Ù�Ü�wqwq[ ��Z*\�U©ÓHKfR*Ph��^*U]MQ[�MQKfUq^*�¡a|Uq\6R*Ph��gh\OKfI*Kl^�k >@?BA []GHMQUqJL[�M�[m[]^*R?a|Uq\6��M�[�MQKl^�kMQW�PhKl\6Z*\�UqZÆPS\�MOKlPh� ��KfM6G*��Ph��Ü�[]\�g�W FHW[]\�PhR Ü�[]^*k]G[]kqP ��Ù ��Ù��8Gqx ����ZÆPSghKN}gi[�MOKlUq^���MQU [0VHKlUqJL[�MQKNMhP"MQW�P�OPSJ [�^�MOKlgS�jU]a >@?�A-[]G�MOUqJL[�M�[¡[]^�R�MOW*P3R[�MQ[pM)sHZ{Ph��G*��PhR�MQU`R*Ph��gh\�KlI{P�[�dlkqUq\�KfMOW*JL�SÕ8>)^ >@A6Ö°viMO\Q[]^��OKfMOKlUq^\OPSdz[�MOKlUq^���[]\OPÉR*P�}^*PhRÁKl^AMQPS\OJm�YU�a�Z*\�PhghU]^*R*KfMOKlUq^��«[�^*R�PH=<PSgSMO�hÕ Ò W*PS�OPLgi[]^½IÆP !`\OKNMOMOPh^½PhKfMOW*Ph\�Kf^[]^½KlJmZÆPS\Q[�MOKfÓ]PV��M)s�dlP�!E[��«[y�OPS��G*Ph^*gSP U]a�[]�O��Klkq^*JmPh^_Mhv�gSUq^*R*KNMQKfUq^[]dEvj[]^*R½dlU�UqZ ��MQ[�MQPSJLPS^�MO�0$�v~Uq\�Kf^R*PSghdz[�\Q[�MOKfÓqP���M)s�dlP7!£[]�c[�Z�\OPhR�Klgi[�MQP�\�Phdz[�MQKl^�k���MQ[�MQP�Ó][�\OKz[�I*dlPS�~Kf^°MQW*PpZ*\OP ��[]^*RVZ{Uq��M �)��M�[�MOPh�hvqMO\Q[]^��OKfMOKlUq^Z[]\O[]JmPSMQPS\O�Sv<[]^�RÊU]MQW�Ph\�^�Uq^*R*P�MQPh\�JLKf^*Kl��MQKfgi[]dfdfs g�W�Uq�OPS^AZ[]\Q[�JLP�MQPh\��0$�Õ >¹M�Kl��[]dl��U Z{Uq�O��KlI*dfPYMOU G*��PV[ghU]J¾I*Kl^*[�MQKfUq^ U]a~MQW*PS�OP"M !pUL��M)s�dlPS�hÕ

Û�Uq^�R*PSMOPh\OJmKl^�Kl�OJ []Z*Z{Pi[�\O�eKl^ >@A`Ö Kl^¾M !�U !�[is��hÔ ��� �� �!��� ��� �v_Kl^¾MQW�P�a|Uq\OJ U]a ��� ��� ->�«ghU]^*��MO\OG*g�MQ�Kl^ ��M�[�MQP�Ó�[]\�Kz[]I*dfP`Kl^*KNMQKz[�dlK`Mh[�MQKfUq^*�e[�^*R MQW�P�PS=ÆPhg�MQ�¡U]ajMOW*P�MQ\O[]^*��KfMQKfUq^mR*PS}^�KfMQKfUq^*�Sv*[]^*R ��� �� �!��� � � �v�Kf^MQW�Ppa|Uq\OJ U]a{[]g�MQKfUq^¾�Og�W�PhR*G*dfKl^*k"G�^*ghPS\�M�[�Kl^_M)sqÕeÛ6Uq^*R*P�MQPS\OJmKl^*Kf�OJ []dldfU�!`����s���MQPhJm�cMQU"I{P�R*PS�OgS\OKlI{PhRÉKf^MQW�PhKl\¡JmUq��M`kqPh^*PS\Q[]dÆa|Uq\OJm�`[]^*RyMQUÉI{P�ÓqPh\�Kf}PSR�gSUq^*��KlR*PS\OKl^�kL[�dld<Z{Uq���OKlI�dlP"I{PhW[iÓ�KlUq\��"!`KfMQW�UqG�M`I{PhKl^�kMQKfPhRTMQUm[ÉZ[]\�MQKlgSG*dz[�\pKlJmZ*dfPhJmPh^_M�[�MOKlUq^ U]ac[V��sH��MQPSJ R�Ph�OKfkq^�Õ

Ò U�Uqdf��Kl^ >@A6Ö Kf^*ghdfG*R*P¾[ g�W�Phg �]PS\Ya|U]\ !�Phdld �¹a|Uq\�JLPSR*^*PS�O��U�a([]G�MQU]J [�MQ[ !£P�Õ�k�ÕfvÆKl^*Z*GHM�[]gSMOKlUq^���[]\�P[]d !�[is��TPh^[�I*dlPSR6$�v6[�FHKfJ¾G*dz[�MQUq\�!£Kf^_MQPh\�Z*\OP�MQPS\0$ � � n�X � w_t ��v6[]^�R1[½MQ\Q[�^*�Odl[�MQUq\ma|\OUqJ >@A6Ö MQU�MQW�PMQW�PhUq\�PhJ Z*\�U©ÓHKf^*kmdz[]^*k]G[]kqP�U�a~MOW*PYÜ�[�\Og�W�×3\�U©ÓqPh\ � *¡ÙYÜ�w_t ��Õ

;ÁP¡G��OP¡MQW*P">@?�A'[]GHMQUqJL[�MQU]^¾JLU�R*PSd*[]^*RVMOW*P">@A6Ö dl[]^*kqG[�kqP�a|Uq\�UqG*\cÓqPS\OKN}gi[�MOKlUq^VJmPSMOW*U�R*UqdlU]k]sa|Uq\"JL[]^_sA\OPh[]�OU]^*�hÕ F�Kl\���Mhv�MOW*PÉJLU�R*PSdcW[]�YZ*\OU©Ó]Ph^ÁG��OPSa|G�d(Kf^ R*Ph��gh\OKfI*Kl^�k?JL[]^_sAPXV�Kf��MOKl^*ky��s���MQPhJm�[]^*Ro[]dlk]Uq\OKNMQW*Jm���¬ÙYÜ�wqwq[ ��Õ6F�PhghU]^*R�v9!pP«gi[]^�G*�OPYMQW*PYP VHKl��MQKf^*kLMOUHUqd�MOW[�M6MQ\O[]^*�Odl[�MQPS�U>@A6Ö � *pU]k_wqw �Kl^_MOUÎMOW*P½}*\O��M�Uq\�R*Ph\ydz[�^*kqG[]k]P½U�a°MQW�P½MOW*PhUq\�PhJ Z*\�U©ÓqPh\�Ü�×~v6[]^*RÌ[]R[]ZHM�KNMyMQUÎkqPh^*PS\Q[�MOP�Z�\OU�U]aM�[�gSMQKfgh�SÕ ;�P gh[]^Ç[]df�OU?\OP�M�[]\�kqPSM«MQW*PmMQU�UqdcMQUÊk]Ph^*PS\Q[�MOP []^*R½MQW*PLU]MQW�Ph\°Z�\OU©ÓqPS\O�hÕÊro[]^_s½Z*\OU�U]a|�YU]aR*Kf��MQ\�KlI*GHMQPhRË[�dlkqUq\�KfMOW*JL�ÉW[iÓ]P []dl\�Pi[]R�s-I{PhPh^ R�Uq^*P !`KfMOW Ü�× � *¡Ù�Ü�wqt �EÕ Ò W�Ph\OPAKf� []df�OUÇ[�dl\OPh[]R�s[�JmU�R*Phd�a|Uq\ÉMQW�P���PhJL[]^_MQKlgS� U]a >@?BA []G�MOUqJL[�M�[ Kl^ >)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP �¬r��G*d GBC ��[]^*R ÜjG*W�\O� W*[]�LgS\OPh[�MQPSR [R*PS�OKlk]^ a|Uq\¡[°MQU�Uqd�MQU¾MO\Q[]^*��dz[�MOP >@A6Ö�MOU >)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP �¬ÜjG*Wwqt ��Õ Ò W�Kl\OR<v*[]^ >@A6ÖÌZ*\OUqk]\Q[]J Kl��PXVHPhghGHM�[]I*dfP[�aÈMOPh\¡�OU]JLP"JmUHR�Kf}gh[�MQKfUq^*��[�^*RTMQW*P"PXV�PSghG�MOKlUq^���gh[]^yIÆP"G*��PhR�Kl^TR�s�^[]JmKlg�[�^[]dfs���Kl�hÕ�;ËKfMQWTÓ�[]\�KlUqG*�Ph^�W[]^*gSPhJmPh^_MQ�Sv`MOW*P >@A6Ö/F�KlJ¾G*dl[�MQU]\¾gi[]^.Z*\OU�R*G*gSP�R[�M�[½MOW*P?Kl�mG*�OP�a|G*d6a|U]\mMOW*PoX"[�K`�]U]^ÎMOUHUqd�MOUP V�[]JmKl^�P �¬Û�b(wqt][ �EÕ

tHu

Page 22: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

���� � � ��� � ��� � �� �

>)^ÉMQW*P¡^*PXV�M�M !�U«��Phg�MQKlU]^*�hv_!�P6R�Kl�OgSG*�O�(JmPSMQW�UHR*�eR�PSÓqPSdlUqZ{PhRÉMQU�KfJLZ*\�U©ÓqP�MQW�P6\O[]^*kqP¡U�a<��sH��MQPSJL�3MQW[�Mgi[�^½I{P¾ÓqPS\OKN}PhR½I_s [ JLU�R*PSd�g�W*PSg �]Ph\SÕ Ò W*PV}\O��M«Kf�"[]I*��MQ\O[]gSMOKlUq^�v�[yJmPi[�^*��MQUTJL[]Z [Tdz[]\�kqP¾��M�[�MOP�OZ*[]ghP�Kl^_MOUV[¾�OJL[]dldfPh\���M�[�MQP"�OZ*[]ghP�a|Uq\pJLU�R*PhdÆg�W*Phg ��Kf^*k*Õ Ò W*P��OPSghUq^*R?Kl��[°ÓqPh\�Kf}gh[�MQKfUq^TJmPSMQW�UHR a|U]\[V\OPS��MQ\�Klg�MQPhR?ghdl[]�O�`U]a~��s���MQPhJm�6gi[]dfdlPhRyZ[�\Q[]JmPSMO\OK`MSPhRT��sH��MQPSJL�SÕ

� !�� !# $1 ����*�2e4<�*���p�

Ö�I���MQ\O[]gSMOKlUq^ ��n¡n";�;][ ��W[]��I{PhPS^¾Kl^�gh\OPh[]�OKf^*kqdNs"G*�OPSRVI_sYMOW*PpJmU�R*Phd�g�W*PSg ��Kf^*k"ghU]JLJ¾G�^*KfM)s � ×~U�Rwqx ��Kf^Uq\�R*Ph\�MQU�R*Ph[]dQ!`KfMQW°IÆU]MOW°MQW�P+!|}*^*KfMOP�$���M�[�MOPp��Z[]ghPpP VHZ*dlU]�OKlU]^V[]^*R°MOW*PpKf^�}^*KNMQP(��MQ[�MQP���Z[]gSP�Z*\OU]I*dlPSJ�Õ>)^LMOW*Kl�(�OPSgSMOKlUq^�vQ!�P�P V�[]JmKl^�P`MOW*P6ZÆUq���OKfI*dlP�[]Z*Z*\�U_[]g�W*PS��[]^�R dlKfJLKNM�[�MOKlUq^���MOU°G*��Kl^*k°[]I*��MO\Q[]g�MQKfUq^ [�^*RJmUHR*PSdg�W*Phg ��Kf^*k°a|Uq\eMQW�P >@?BA1[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^ÉJLU�R*PSd�Õ ;ÁP�[]dl��U«R�Ph�OgS\OKfIÆP6UqG*\ !�Uq\#�ÉKl^VMOW*P6MOPh\�JLKf^*UqdlU]k]sU]a�[]I*��MQ\Q[�gSM6Kl^_MQPS\OZ*\�PSMQ[�MQKfUq^Ta|Uq\¡ghUqJmZ[]\�Kl��Uq^�Õ

Ö�I*��MQ\O[]gSMOKlUq^1Kl�yJ [�Z*Z*Kl^�k-[�ghU]^*gh\�PSMQP���MQ[�MQP½�OZ[�ghP MQU-[]^�[]I���MQ\O[]gSM���MQ[�MQP½�OZ*[]ghP�v�[ !p[©s MOUa|Uq\�J []dfK`MSPÊ[]^*RËJL[��]PA��UqG*^*RËMQW�P�[�Z*Z*\OU VHKlJL[�MOKlUq^ U�a°[ÇJmUHR�Phd�Õ JLU�R*PSd�MQW[�MyJ [is.s�KfPhdlR G��OPSa|G�dKl^Ha|Uq\OJL[�MQKfUq^�Õ Ò W*Kf��J []Z�Z*Kl^*kyKf�YJmUq��M«G��OPSa|G�d !`W�Ph^�KNM�Kl�"a|\OUqJ Kl^�}^�KfMQPVMOU?}^�KfMQPÉ��Z[]ghP�vc[]^�R�MQW�PJmUHR*PSdeg�W*Phg ��Kf^*kÊUq^ MQW*PL[]I*��MQ\O[]gSM«�OZ[�ghP Z�\OU�R*G*ghPSR�Ó]Ph\OKN}Ph�YMQW*PmghU]^*gh\�PSMQPL�OZ[�ghP]ÕTÙ�KNÓqPh^Á[y}*^*KfMOPZ*\�UqZÆPS\�M)s]v�MOW*Ph\�PmPXVHKl��MO�°[�^�[�I*��MO\Q[]g�MQKlU]^½MOW[�M�JL[]Z*��[]^½Kl^�}*^*KfMOPV��M�[�MQPÉ�OZ[�ghPÉMQU?[y}*^*KfMOPVUq^*PVMQW[�M\OPSZ*\OPS�OPS^�MO��MQW*P�Z*\OU]ZÆPS\�M)sqÕ �6U�!�PSÓ]Ph\Sv*KfM�Kl�(G*^*R*PSghKfR[]I*dfP�MQU¾[]gSMOG[]dldNsVR*PSR*G*ghP�MQW*P�\�KlkqW_M�[]I*��MQ\O[]gSMOKlUq^�v[]^*RyMQW�P�}*^*KfMOP"�OZ[]gSP«JmKlk]W�M���MQKfdldÆIÆP"MQU�UVdz[�\OkqP�Õ

Ö Z*\�PhR*Kfgi[�MOP�[]I*��MO\Q[]g�MQKfUq^�Kl�Ê[ Z[]\�MOKlgSG*dz[]\�[]I*��MQ\O[]gSMOKlUq^ JL[]Z*Z*Kf^*k.gSUq^*gS\OPSMOP���M�[�MQP���Z[]ghP�MOUI{UHUqdfPi[]^ Ó�[]\�Kz[]I�dlPh�SÕ >¹M`Kl�¡PS��G�KfÓ�[]dlPS^_M6MOUm[]^�Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MhÕ Ò W*P�JL[]Z*Z*Kf^*k¾a|G*^*g�MQKlU]^�Kf��MQW�G*�`Z*\OPSR*Klgh[�MQPS�Uq^�ghUq^*gS\OP�MQP Ó�[]\�Kz[]I*dfPh�Sv~dfK`�]P J����{ÕK>)^ÁMQW*PSUq\�s]v�a|Uq\«[]^_s½Z*\OUqZ{Ph\�M)sqv�MOW*Ph\�P PXV�Kf��MO�¾[]^Ç[�I*��MO\Q[]g�MQKlU]^�OG�g�W�MOW[�M¾[]^_s�JmU�R*Phd(gi[]^ÁIÆP JL[]Z*Z{PhR�MQU�M !�UA��MQ[�MQPS�( KEÕ�P�Õfvc[�Z*\�PhR*Kfgi[�MOPT[]I*��MQ\Q[�gSMQKfUq^Ágh[]^ÇI{P�OG $LgSKlPS^�M�a|Uq\"JmU�R*Phdcg�W�Phg ��Kl^*k�v�!`W*PS\OPÉUq^*PÉ��M�[�MOPVKl� ��kqU�U�R �y[]^*R½[]^*U�MQW*PS\"Kl� ��I[�R �?[]^*R[!pP ��G*��M�OW�U�!.MQW[�M ��I[]R ��Kl�3^*U�M3\OPi[�g�W[]I*dfP`a|\�UqJ MOW*P`��MQ[]\�M(��MQ[�MQPS��U�a�[]^m[]GHMQUqJL[�MQU]^�Õ�Ö�dld�MO\Q[]^*��KfMOKlUq^*�~a|\OUqJ��kqU�U�R �«^�PSÓqPS\�kqUYMQU���I[]R �*vH[]^*RLMQW*Kf��Kf��Ph[]��sÉMQU°g�W*Phg �mIÆPSgi[]G��OP�MOW*P�[]I���MQ\O[]gSMOKlUq^LW[]��R*Uq^*P�[]dldMQW�P!�Uq\#� � ×~U�Rwqx ��Õ

��U�!�PSÓqPS\hv�}^*R*Kf^*k�MQW*P½\OKfkqW_MyZ*\OPSR*Klgh[�MQP�[]I*��MQ\Q[�gSMQKfUq^'Kl�?[]dl��U�G*^*R*PSghKlR*[]I*dlP½[]^�RÌR*K%$LgSG*dfMTa|U]\W�G*JL[]^*�cMQU"R�U*Õ�Ö Z*\�PhR*Kfgi[�MOP 3«U]^¾MQW*P¡gSUq^*gh\�PSMOP6��M�[�MOP �6J¾G���MeW[iÓ]P`MOW*P�a|UqdfdlU�!`Kl^*k6MQW*\�PhP¡Z*\�UqZ{Ph\�MOKlPS�MQUÉI{P�G*�OP�a|G*dja|Uq\�ÓqPS\OKf}*gi[�MOKlUq^�Ô

��� 9� 9�� 3F! � � @ � M($ � D������.! � � @ � M($�ÕQ3 KfJLZ*dfKlPS��MQW�PYZ�\OUqZ{Ph\�M)s MQUmIÆP"Z�\OU©ÓqPSR�Õ��� 9� 9���� � 9� �� 9R3.!�� � @ � M($�Õ 3 W�UqdlR*�¡U]^yMOW*P���MQ[]\�MhÕ��� 9� 9���� � 9� 9���� ! 3.!�� � @ � M($ � ��� @ P � � ��(PQ!�� � @ � M A.� � @ � M�� $ � 3.!�� � @ � M�� $�ÕQ3LKl� ��Kl^*R*G�gSMQKNÓqP �*Õ Ò W[�M`Kf�hv�KNa

!�P ��^*U�! MQW*[�M+3?W*UqdlR���Uq^ [ Z*\�PV��M�[�MQP]vÆMQW*PS^ 3?Kl���OG $mghKfPh^_M�MQU Z�\OU©ÓqPVMQW*[�M+3?W*UqdlR���G*^*R*PS\[]^_s MO\Q[]^��OKfMOKlUq^ MOUm[mZ{Uq��M`��M�[�MOP]Õ

Ò W*P4��PSs?MQU ��G*ghgSPh����a|G*d�Ó]Ph\�Kf}gh[�MQKfUq^ !`KNMQWÊ[�I*��MO\Q[]g�MQKlU]^�Kf�6MOU R*Kf�OghU©Ó]Ph\�MOW*P°Kf^*R*G*g�MQKfÓ]P«Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�M3�ÕÊÛ6U]MQP MOW[�M 3½Kf�«G��OG[]dfdfs�[ogSUq^ ��G*^*g�MQKfUq^�U]a`JL[]^_s½Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�hÕor�P�MQW*U�R*�¾Kf^*ghdfG*R*P � !`KlR*PS^*Kl^*k"�!`W*PS\OP�3ÇKf� !�Pi[ �]Ph^�PhR'[�MmPSÓ]Ph\�s-��MOPhZ G�^�MOKld`KfMmKf�LKf^*R*G*g�MQKfÓ]P �¬n¡n G_t �Ev�Uq\mW*PhG�\OKl��MQKfgh�m�OG*g�W [�� []I����MO\Q[]g�MQKfUq^*�"I_s ��U�gSM�[�kqUq^*� �T�Q[is�Kl^*kyMQW[�M"MQW*PVÓ�[]dlG�Ph�"U]a JÇ[]^�R��o[]\OP !`KfMOW*Kl^ [�^½U�gSMQ[]kqUq^*[]dc\OPSkqKlU]^

tqt

Page 23: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

!`W*PS^?k]\Q[]Z*W�PhR ��r?Kl^w�u ��Õ >)^TMOW*Kl����Ph^*��P]vUqG�\�JLP�MQW*U�R*UqdfUqk]s]v)!`W*Kfg�W?[]dl��UV[�MOMOPhJmZ�MQ��MQU¾}^*Ry��G*KfMQ[]I*dlPKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MQ��a|Uq\pÓqPS\OKN}gi[�MOKlUq^<v�Kl�p^*U]M�MOW[�M`R*K =<PS\OPh^_M�a|\�UqJ�MOW*P"PS=ÆUq\�MQ��U]a�\�Ph�OPh[]\Og�W�Ph\O�6U]a~[]I*��MQ\O[]gSMOKlUq^�Õ

��U�!�PSÓqPS\hvUqG�\ !�Uq\#�ÉR*K =<PS\O�(Kl^mMQW*P !�[is !pP�R*Kl��ghU©ÓqPS\�MQW�Ph�OP�Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�([]^*R W�U�!3!�P�Ó]Ph\�KfaÈsÉMQW[�MMQW�PSs�KfJLZ�dfsÊMOW*P ��kqU�U�R �ÊZ*\�UqZÆPS\�M)s]Õ ;ÁP R�Kl�OgSU©ÓqPh\VKf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MO�«MOW*\OUqG�kqW�P VHPSghG�MOKlUq^�\Q[�MQW*PS\°MQW[�^Ç[��MQ[�MQKfg¾JmPSMQW�UHR*U]dlUqk]s?dfK`�]P !`KlR*PS^*Kl^�k*Õ Ò W�PVkq\Q[]JmJL[]\�U�a�U]G*\"Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ��Kl�"[]df�OU !`KfR*Ph\SÕ¾×e\OPS�OPS^�MOdfs]vMQW�Uq�OP !`W*UÊ[]\�PLZ�\Q[]g�MQKlgSKl^*k?[]GHMQUqJL[�MQKfgi[]dfdfs?kqPS^*Ph\O[�MQKf^*kÊ[]I���MQ\O[]gSMOKlUq^���a|U]\YÓ]Ph\OKN}gi[�MQKlU]^���PhPhJ/MOUoI{P\OPS��MO\OKlg�MQKf^*kYMOW*PhJm�OPSdfÓ]Ph��MOU°[�\OKfMOW*JmPSMQKfg¡Uq^ Kf^_MQPhk]Ph\O� � ×~U�Rwqx �Æ[]^*RL�Q[isÉ^*U]MOW*Kl^�k*v_a|Uq\3P V�[]JmZ*dlP�vH[�IÆUqGHM�OG�I*�OP�MeKl^*gSdlG*��KlUq^YUq^¾G�^�I{UqG*^�R*PhRV��PSMQ�SÕ >)^¾��UqJLP�gi[]��Ph�SvqMQW*P�G*�OP�a|G*d*[]I���MQ\O[]gSMOKlUq^��~J¾G���McI{Ppk]Ph^*PS\Q[�MOPhRI_sYW[]^*R�ÕcFHKl^�ghP3UqG*\�JLP�MQW*U�RYG*�OPS�e[`MOW*PhU]\OPhJ5Z*\�U©ÓqPh\~\Q[�MOW*Ph\jMOW[]^¾[6JLU�R*PSd_g�W*Phg ��Ph\hv_KNM�J [is�\OPS��G*Kl\�PJmUq\OP6J [�^�G*[]dÆKf^_MQPh\�ÓqPS^�MOKlUq^LMQU°Ó]Ph\OKNaÈsÉMQW[�M�[]^ Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M 3ÉUqI{PSs��pMQW�P�MQW�\OPhP�Z*\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKfPh�hÕ �6U�!pP�ÓqPh\Sv!�PÊgi[]^ JL[���PoZ*\�Uqkq\OPS�O� !`W�Ph^ MQW�PÊKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MmKl� ^�U]M ��G*KNMQPo��G $mghKfPh^_M a|Uq\mÓqPh\�Kf}gh[�MQKfUq^ Z*\�PhgSKl�OPSdfsI{Phgi[�G*�OPYU]a�MQW*PY[]I*KfdlKNM)sLMOUmJL[]^�G[]dfdfsmKl^_MOPh\�Ó]Ph^*P�Õ

� !�� !�� � ����� ��0������ ��2e�23 �����������j��#C�H06������ �

Ö Z[]\Q[�JLP�MQ\OKNMhPSRÁ��s���MQPhJCKl�«[]^�G*^�IÆUqG�^*R*PhR�[�\O\Q[is½U]a�}^*KfMOP ��M�[�MOP []GHMQUqJL[�M�[TMQW*[�M°U]^*dfs Z{Ph\�a|Uq\OJghU]JLJ¾G�^*Klgh[�MQKfUq^4!`KfMOWLMQW�PhKl\3^*PSKlkqW�I{Uq\O�SÕcÖ'Z[]\Q[�JLP�MQ\OKNMhPSRm��s���MQPSJ�Kf�3��MQKfdld�[]^mKl^H}^*KfMOP`��M�[�MQP6��s���MOPhJ?vI*G�M6KNMQ�¡Kl^H}^*KfM)s Kl�¡Uq^�dfs Kf^TMQW*P�^�G*J¾I{Ph\`U]a~Z[]\�MQKlgSKlZ[�MQKl^�k¾Z*\OU�ghPS�O��Ph�hÕ

A�^*PÇZ[]\�MQKlgSG*dz[�\oJmUHR*PSd¾g�W*PSg ��Kf^*kËMQPhg�W�^*Kl��G*P�vVgi[]dfdlPhR ��Kl^_Ó�Kl��KlI*dfPÁKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MQ� � I_s5×e^�G�PhdlKEv°P�M[]dEÕ �¬×3Ú���w�u �Ev¡[]dfdlU�!`�É[�\�Ph��MO\OKfgSMQPSR.gSdz[]���LU]a�Z[]\O[]JLP�MQ\�K`MhPSR-��s���MQPSJL�LMQU½IÆP?JLU�R*PSd¡g�W*Phg ��PhR a|Uq\m[ghPS\�MQ[]Kl^ÊgSdz[]����U]a3Z*\�UqZ{Ph\�MOKlPS�hÕ *�s�JmUHR*PSd�g�W*Phg ��Kl^�k�[LghPh\�M�[]Kf^ !£gSUqJLZ�G�M�[]I�dlP�$¡^�G*J¾I{Ph\�U�aeMQW*PS�OPÉ[]G��MQU]J [�MQ[�vÆMOW*PV\OPS�OG*dNM�W*UqdfR*��a|Uq\"[]dfd�MOW*Pm[]G�MOUqJ [�M�[�Õ FUq\�PXV*[�JLZ*dfP]v<MOW*PSsÊJLU�R*Phd~g�W*Phg � DT[]GHMQUqJL[�M�[Kl^Ê[ �OUqdfG�MQKfUq^�MOU MQW*P¾X�Kl^*Kf^*k ×eW*KfdlUq��UqZ*W*PS\��¬��Ö�dfkqUq\�KfMQW�J MQU ��W*U�! MOW[�M�MOW*P¾��UqdlG�MOKlUq^oW*UqdlR���a|Uq\�[]^G*^�I{UqG*^*R*PSRo��sH��MQPSJ�Õ

>)^_MQG*KNMQKfÓ]PhdNsqv�MQW*P�JmPSMOW*U�R \OPS��MQ\�Klg�MQ�pKNMQ��Phdfa<MQU¾Z*\�UqZ{Ph\�MOKlPS��MQW*[�M¡[]\�P�dfUHgh[]d ( \�Phdz[�MQPhRLMQUV[°W*[]^*R�a|G*dU]a�[]G�MQU]J [�MQ[AKl^_MQPS\Q[]g�MQKl^�k½^�P V�MLMOU�Ph[]g�W.U�MQW*PS\hvp\O[�MQW�Ph\ÉMQW[]^�MQW�P�kqdfUqI[]dp��s���MOPhJ?Õ FG*\�MOW*Ph\SvpMQW�PKl^�R*KfÓ�KlR�G[]d�[]G�MQU]J [�MQ[Ê^*U]MÉUq^�dfs�W[iÓqPyMQU IÆP }*^*KfMOPT��M�[�MQP]v(I*G�MÉdfKlJmKfMOPhRÁKf^Ça|G*^*gSMOKlUq^<Õ Ò W*PyP V�[]g�MdlKfJLKNM�W[��«^*U�MYs]PSM°IÆPSPh^�a|U]\OJL[]dlKNMhPhR<ÕmÖ�^ÁPXV*[�JLZ*dfPÉJ [is Z*\�U�Ó�KfR*PÉ�OUqJmPLKf^_MQG*KNMQKlU]^�vjW*U�!pP�ÓqPS\hÔ¾MQW�PKl^�R*KfÓ�KlR�G[]dc[�G�MQUqJL[�MQ[ gi[]^*^�U]M«[]gSMY[]��gSPhdldf�"Uq^�[ Ò G*\�Kl^*kyJL[]g�W*Kl^�P¾M�[]Z{P]v�!`W*PS\OPhI_s MQW�PSsA��KlJ¾G*dl[�MQPMQW�P Ò G*\�Kl^*kÉJL[]g�W*Kf^*P�I_sTZ[]���OKf^*kÉJLPS�O�Q[�kqPh�`I[]g � []^*RTa|Uq\�MOW�Õ A�MQW*PS\ !`Kf�OP]v*[VÓ]Ph\�Kf}gh[�MQKfUq^TU]a~�OG*g�W�[Z[]\O[]JmPSMQ\�K`MSPhRy��s���MOPhJ !�UqG*dfR�I{PY[]I*dlP�MQUÉMQPhdfd�Kfa�MOW*P Ò G*\�Kl^*kÉJL[]g�W*Kf^*P"W[]dNMQ�hÕ

FG*\�MOW*Ph\Sv(JL[]^_s�R�Kl��MO\OKfI*G�MQPSR�[]dlk]Uq\OKNMQW*Jm�«W*[©Ó]PT��MQ[�MQP Ó�[]\�Kz[]I*dfPh�°MOW[�MÉ[�\OP G*^�I{UqG*^*R�PhR�v�Kl^�[]R��R*KNMQKlU]^ÁMQUAW[iÓ�Kl^�k []^ÇG*^�IÆU]G*^*R*PSR-^�G*J¾I{Ph\°U]a6Z*\OU�ghPS�O�OPS�hÕ FUq\«P V�[]JmZ*dlP�v(Ü�[�JLZ{Uq\�M�����*�[���Ph\�sÇ[]d �kqUq\�KfMOW*J � Ü�[]J ;0< �`\OPS��G*Kl\�Ph�ÉPi[]g�W-Z*\OU�ghPS�O�ÉMQU½W[iÓqP�[]^ÎG*^�IÆUqG�^*R*PhR-Kl^_MQPSkqPh\ÉgSUqG*^_MQPS\hÕ FUq\¾MOW*Ph��P��s���MQPhJm�hv{JmUHR*PSdjg�W*Phg ��Kf^*k W[]�6^*UL[]^*�@!pPS\��OUÉa£[]\SÕ Ò W�G*� !�P�a|UHgSG*��U]G*\"!pUq\ �yUq^?MOW*PhU]\OPhJ Z�\OU©ÓqPS\O�[]dfUq^*P"Kl^TMOPh\OJm�¡U]a~��MQ[�MQKfg�ÓqPh\�Kf}gh[�MQKfUq^TMQU�Uqdl�SÕ

t]x

Page 24: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

t <

Page 25: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� � ��� ��� �

� � � ��� � ��� ���

Ò W*Kf�L��PhgSMOKlUq^-R*Ph��gh\�KlI{Ph� Kf^-R�PSM�[�Kld`UqG*\ÉKl^_MOPh^*R*PSR JmPSMQW�UHR�a|Uq\ÉÓqPh\�KfaÈs�Kl^�k�R*Kf��MO\OKlI�G�MQPSR []dfkqUq\OKNMQW*Jm�G*��Kl^*k«[YgSUqJ¾I*Kf^[�MOKlUq^VU]aÆa|Uq\OJL[]d*JmU�R*PhdfKl^*k*v�R�s�^[]JmKlg6[]^[�dfs��OKf�3[]^*RLMOW*PhU]\OPhJ Z�\OU©Ó�Kl^*k*ÕcÚ6PSgi[]dfd�MQW[�MZ*\�UqZÆPS\�MOKlPh��a|Uq\ >@?BA+[]G�MOUqJL[�M�[mgi[]^AI{P¾��MQ[�MQPSR PhKfMOW*Ph\�[]��Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M�[]�O��Ph\�MOKlUq^���Uq\�[����OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^[]G�MOUqJL[�M�[�Õ*;�PTG*�OP?[Ê�OdfKlkqW_MOdfs½R*K =ÆPh\�Ph^_Mm[]Z*Z�\OU_[]g�W�a|Uq\¾Z�\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKlPS�¾��MQ[�MQPSR.[��VKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�°Ó]Ph\O��G*�Z*\�UqZÆPS\�MOKlPh�(��MQ[�MQPSR Ó�Kz[��OZ{PhghKN}gi[�MQKlU]^ []G�MOUqJL[�M�[�v�I*GHMpMQW�P�}\���MpMOW*\OPSP���MQPhZ��¡[]\OP6MQW*P6�Q[�JLP�Õ F�G�\�MQW�Ph\hv^*U]MOP�MQW*[�M�Ph[]g�WyKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_Mp^*PSPhR*PSRTa|Uq\�Ó]Ph\OKN}gi[�MQKlU]^ I_s ��KlJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^m\OPhdl[�MQKfUq^ gh[]^TG*��P�MQW*P�ÓqPh\��OKfUq^TU]aUqG*\¡JmPSMOW*U�Rya|U]\¡Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�hÕ

A�G*\`JLP�MQW*U�R�v*UqGHMQdlKf^*PhRTKf^ F�KlkqG�\OP�x �Quqv�Kf�¡�OG*JmJ [�\OK`MSPhRyI_s a|UqG*\`��MQPhZ��hÔuqÕ�r�U�R*PSd�MQW*PY[]dfkqUq\OKNMQW*J []�6[]^ >@?BA []G�MQU]J [�MOUq^�Õ

tHÕ6Ú`Ph^*R�Ph\pMOW*P"^*Uq^*R�PSMQPS\OJmKl^*Kf��MOKlg�[]^*RTR*PSghdz[�\Q[�MOKfÓqPSdfsm�OZ{PhgSKf}PSRK>@?BA5[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^ Kf^_MQU4>@A`Ö Z*\OU �kq\O[]Jm��MQW[�M6[�\OP�KlJmZÆPS\Q[�MOKfÓ]PhdfsLP VHPSghG�MQ[]I*dlP�Õ >)^yMQW�PYgh[]�OP�U]a~ÓqPS\OKf}*gi[�MOKlUq^yI_sT�OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^ \OPSdz[ �MOKlUq^�v)!pPYUq^*dNs ^�PhPhR?MQUV\�P\!`\OKNMQP"MQW�P"KlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^�MQ[�MQKfUq^ [�G�MQUqJL[�MOUq^�ÕebWVHPhgSG�MQPYMQW*P�[]GHMQUqJL[�MQU]^!£[]G�MQU]J [�MQ[ $�G*��Kl^*kL[V�OKfJLZ*dfP�MQPS��M6��MO\Q[�MOPhk]s]vÆ[�^*R?} V�[]^_sTPh\�\OUq\��6MOW[�M`JL[©sT[]\OKf�OP]vG�^�MOKld8!`W[�MMOW*P�Z*\OUqk]\Q[]JmJLPS\�I{PhdlKfPSÓ]Ph�6[]\OP"gSUq\O\�Phg�M�PXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^*��[�\OP�Z*\OU�R*G*gSPhR�Õ

x�Õ`Ö�^[]dfs)MSP3MOW*P3P VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^*��G*�OKf^*k`R�s�^[]JmKlg3Kl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MjR*P�MQPSgSMQKfUq^�MQU`Z*\OU�R*G*gSPp[¡��PSM~U]a�Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MO�hÕ<*Õ Ò \Q[]^��Odz[�MQP [�dld([]G�MOUqJ [�M�[�Kf^_MQUoMOW*P dl[]^*kqG[�kqPLU�a6[�MQW*PSUq\OPSJ%Z�\OU©ÓqPS\hv([]^*RÁÓ]Ph\�KfaÈs½MQW*P �O[�a|PSM)sZ*\�UqZ{Ph\�MOKlPS�hv8!`KfMOW½[]�O��Kl��MQ[]^*gSPÉa|\�UqJ?Ô�MQW�PÉX"[]K`��Uq^ Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�"[]�"dfPhJmJ [�����M�[�gSMQKfgh��[]^�R½Z�\OU�U]a��MQ\OG�gSMQG�\OP�a|\OUqJ MQW*P"MQ\O[]^*��dz[�MOKlUq^ MOUHUqdEÕ

� ��� � � ��� �� � � � � ���� � � � � � � ����� � � � ��� � ���

Ò W*P¡}\���M(��MOPhZ Kf^VG*�OKf^*k�UqG*\3JmPSMQW�UHRVa|Uq\�Ó]Ph\�KfaÈs�Kl^*kY[���s���MOPhJ Kf�cMQU�R*PS}*^*P�KNM3[]�([]^ >@?BA'[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^�ÕÒ W*Kf�YJmPi[�^*�"MQW[�M«[]^½[]dfkqUq\�KfMQW�J ��W*UqG*dfR�I{PÉghUq^_ÓqPS\�MOPhR�Kf^�MOU?[?��M�[�MOPmJL[]g�W*Kf^*P4!`KfMOW�Ph[]g�W�[�MQUqJmKlg��MOPhZ�I{PhKf^*kÊ[yMQ\O[]^*�OKNMQKfUq^�Õ?ro[]^_s�[]dfkqUq\OKNMQW*Jm�"W[iÓqP IÆPSPh^�JmUHR�PhdlPSRÁ[�� >@?BA []GHMQUqJL[�M�[ � ×(×(Ù � GBI�vFHÖ6ÙYÙ � Gqxq[HvHÙ�Ü�wqw]I �Æ[]^*R !pP�R*U°^*U�MpR*PSdfÓ]P�R*PSPhZ{Ph\pKf^_MQU°W�U�! MOW*P�gSUq^_ÓqPS\O�OKfUq^ W[�Z*ZÆPS^*�hÕ Ò W*P6}^[]d\OPS�OG*dNM6Kl�`[]^ >@?BA []G�MQU]J [�MOUq^TMQW[�M`Kl�`[VJ [�MQW*PSJ [�MOKlgh[]d<��ZÆPSghKf}*gi[�MOKlUq^Ta|Uq\`[]^?[]dfkqUq\�KfMQW�J�Õ

Û�U�!�v�MQW�PVR*PS}^�KfMQKfUq^ÊU]a(�O[�a|PSM)soZ*\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKfPh��gh[]^AIÆPVR�Uq^*P¾Kf^ÊM !pUK!p[©s��SÕ A�aÈMQPS^�v�KfM�Kl����G $mghKfPh^_MMQUÇ��KlJmZ*dfs-��MQ[�MQP [�^ Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M Uq^ËI{PhW[iÓ�KlUq\Sv���G*g�W1[]� !`KfMOW MQW*P ×�PSMQPS\O��Uq^1gh[]�OP ��MQG*R�s G*�OPSR1Kf^

tBD

Page 26: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

F�KfkqG*\OPÊx ��uqÔÁÖ�^'U�Ó]Ph\�ÓHKfP\! U]a°U]G*\TJLP�MQW*U�R�Õ ;�PAÓqPS\OKfaÈs.Z*\OU]kq\Q[]J Z*\OU]ZÆPS\�MQKfPh� !`KNMQWËW*PhdfZ a|\OUqJR�s�^[]JmKlg"Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�M�R*PSMOPhgSMOKlUq^�[]^*RyZ*\�UHU�a���gh\OKfZ�MQ�`kqPS^*Ph\O[�MQPSRoI_sTUqG�\">@A6Ö MQUmZ*\OU©Ó]Ph\¡MQ\O[]^*�Odl[�MQU]\O�hÕ

npW[]ZHMQPh\ <�ÕfuqÕ L3Ph\OKN}gi[�MQKlU]^�I_sÁKf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MO�°Kl�°�OG*Z*Z{Uq\�MQPhRÇI_sÁUqG*\¾JmPSMOW*UHR<Õ A�MQW*PS\ !`Kl��P]veMQW�P G*�OPS\JL[©soZ*\OP�a|Ph\"MQUT��M�[�MOPÉ�Q[�a|P�M)sAZ*\OU]ZÆPS\�MQKfPh��[]�Y[]^�U]MQW*PS\ >@?BA�[�G�MQUqJL[�MOUq^ �¬Ü�L G_D][ ��Õ >)^AMQW�Kl�"gi[��OP]v�MQW�PG*��Ph\��OW*UqG�dlR°��ZÆPSghKNaÈs"MQW*P3ghU]\O\OPSgSM�IÆPSW[iÓHKfUq\�Kl^"MQPS\OJm�~U�a[`�OZ{PhghKN}gi[�MQKlU]^°[]GHMQUqJL[�MQU]^«[�^*R«Ó]Ph\OKN}gi[�MQKlU]^�OW*[]dld�W[]Z�ZÆPS^ I_sma|U]\ !p[]\ORL�OKlJ°G*dz[�MOKlUq^<v�!`W*Klg�W Kl��[]^*U]MOW*Ph\(JLP�MQW*U�R !�P���G*Z*Z{Uq\�MhÕ Ò W*P�G��OPh\p[]dl��U°W[��MQUÉ��ZÆPSghKfaÈs MQW*P"a|Uq\@!�[]\�R���KlJ¾G�dz[�MOKlUq^ \�Phdl[�MQKfUq^�Õ

� � ��� ��� � � � � � � � � � � ���

Ò W*P��OPSghUq^�R?��MQPSZ�Kf^TG*�OKf^*kVUqG*\�JmPSMOW*U�R MQUVÓqPS\OKfaÈs []^?[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^ Kl�pMOU¾MQPh��M6KfMQ�pIÆPSW[iÓHKfUq\pMOW*\OUqG�kqWP VHPSghG�MOKlUq^�Õ Ò W*PK>@A`Ö FHKlJ¾G�dz[�MOUq\«��KlJ¾G�dz[�MOPh� !|Uq^�[Ê�OKf^*kqdfP ghU]JLZ*GHMQPh\ $«P VHPSghG�MOKlUq^�U]a6[]^ >@?BAÐ[]G��MQU]J [�MOUq^�v�[]dfdlU�!`Kl^*k MOW*PmG*�OPS\YMOU�W*PSdlZ��OPhdfPhg�M«MOW*PLPXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^*�°[�^*R�MOU�Z*\�UqZ{Uq�OPmKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�"a|Uq\"MQW�PKl^_MOPh\OZ�\OPSMOPh\¡MQUÉg�W*PSg ��Õ

npUq^_ÓqPS\�MQKf^*kK>@?BA []G�MOUqJL[�M�[ÉKl^_MQU P VHPhgSG�M�[]I�dlP4>@A`Ö ghU�R*P«Kl^_ÓqUqdNÓqPS��M !pUT��MQPSZ*�hÔU!`\OKNMQKl^�kmMOW*PV[]G��MQU]J [�MQ[LKf^ÊMQW*P4>@A`Ö dz[�^*kqG[]k]P]v�[�^*RA\OPS�OUqdNÓHKf^*k ^*U]^*R*PSMOPh\�JLKf^*Kl��J I_so�Og�W*PSR*G*dlKf^*k*Õ�Ö�aÈMOPh\@!�[]\�R�v�MQW�P>@A6ÖÌFHKfJ¾G*dz[�MQUq\ePXV�PSghG�MOPh��MOW*P�Z�\OUqkq\O[]J+[]^*R !`\OKNMQPh�(P VHPSghG�MOKlUq^ R*[�M�[ !|MQW�P�gSUq^*gh\�PSMOP�\OPSZ*\OPS�OPS^�MQ[�MQKfUq^U]a~Kl^_MQPS\OdfPi[iÓqPSR���M�[�MOPh��[]^*R?[]gSMOKlUq^��0$�MQUL[¾}dlP�Õ

Ò W*Pya|Uq\OJmPh\VKf�V^*PhgSPh�O�O[]\�s-[]^�R-\�Phdz[�MQKfÓ]PhdNs�MO\OKfÓ�Kl[]d�ÔmMQW*P >@A6Ö Ò UHU]d`��KfMV��G*Z*Z{Uq\�MO� [AG*��PSa|G*d`I*GHMdlKfJLKNMQPSRÇ�OPSMLU]a�R[�M�[AM)s�ZÆP?dlKfI*\Q[�\OKlPS�4!`\OKNMOMQPS^-Kf^.Ü�F�Üev3[]^�R-MQW�P���ZÆPSghKf}*PhR >@?�A []G�MQU]J [�MOUq^�J¾G*��MI{P !`\�KfM�MQPh^'Kl^ MOPh\OJm�yU]a°MOW*Ph��P�dfKlI*\O[]\OKfPh�SÕ A�MOW*Ph\TMOUHUqdf�TdlKN�]PÊMQW�P�>@A`Ö npU]JLZ{Uq�OPS\yZ*\OU©Ó�KlR*P MQW�PghU]^�Ó]Ph^*KfPh^*gSP U]a�W[iÓ�Kl^*kÁMOU !`\OKNMQPÊU]^*dfsÎUq^*PÊ[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^ [�^*R I{PhKl^�kÇ[]I*dfP�MQU�a|Uq\OJ [Á��s���MQPhJ U]aKl^_MOPh\OgSUq^*^*PSgSMOPhRÊ[�G�MQUqJL[�MQ[¾G*�OKf^*kVMQW*Kf�`[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^?[]�`[VMQPhJmZ*dl[�MQP�Õ

Ò W*P�dl[�MOMOPh\3\OPS��G*Kl\�Ph� !pUq\ ��Ô !pP�J¾G*��M !`\OKNMQP � ��� ����� � " ���� ��npW*P�GBC*v�Ú�Ú6wqw �{MOW[�M(g�W*U�Uq�OP�IÆP�M !pPSPh^^*Uq^�R*PSMOPh\OJmKl^�Kl��MOKlg"��MQPhZ��"[]^�[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^?gi[]^?M�[���P]Õ ;ËW*PS^oÓqPS\OKfaÈs�Kf^*kLI_s?�OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^T\OPSdz[�MOKlUq^�vHMQW*Kf�Kl�`Uq^�dfsy^*PSghPh���Q[]\�s�a|U]\6KfJLZ�dlPhJmPh^_MQ[�MQKfUq^y[]G�MOUqJ [�M�[�Õ Ò W*P«Z�\OKlJL[]\�sTZ*dz[�ghP�a|Uq\¡MQW*Kf�6Kf��Kf^���g�W*PhR�G*dlKf^*k!`W*Kfg�W�MQ\O[]^*��KfMQKfUq^Ê}\�Ph�Y^*P V�M°[]JLU]^*kTMQW*Uq��PVMQW[�M«[]\�PÉPh^[]I�dlPhR<Õ Ò W*P >@A6Ö dz[�^*kqG[]k]PÉ[]dldfU�!`�"G���MOU[]Z*Z{Ph^�RÁ[T�OJL[]dfdcZ*\OU]kq\Q[]J?v�gh[]dldfPhR½[ - ��������� & �oI*dfUHg ��v�[�M"MOW*PÉPh^*R�U]a�MOW*Pm[]G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^AR*P�}^*KNMQKlU]^MQU�ZÆPS\�a|Uq\�J MQW*Kf�°��g�W*PhR*G�dlKl^�k*Õ Ò W*P�-���������� & �½I*dfUHg �A^�U]M°U]^*dfs ��PhdlPSgSMO�&!`W*Kfg�WÁMQ\O[]^*�OKNMQKfUq^½MOUoZ{Ph\ �a|Uq\�J G��OKl^�kT[ dz[�^*kqG[]k]PYÓ]Ph\�s��OKfJLKfdz[]\�MOU >@A6Ö $ I*G�M�[]dl��U �OPSdlPhg�MQ� !`W�Klg�WAZ[]\O[]JmPSMQPS\O�6MQU ��G*Z*Z*dNs?MOU� ¶z���ª�������£���S���ª�����ª ��E���3�E���p�e�E���¡���h���ª¥��j���<�E��� �e:Z: ¥��©¢©�c��¦*¶E¸�(¨©��º�¥����©�j�¬���S���� ����ª��� ¼ �<�ª�����������E�ª���e¥��©¢©�S±

t�I

Page 27: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

MQW�P¾MQ\Q[�^*�OKNMQKlU]^�Õ�Ö�R*R*KNMQKfUq^[]dfdfsqv9!`W*PS\OPVMQW*P >@A`Ö dz[]^�kqG[]kqP¾[]dldfU�!`��^*Uq^*R�PSMQPS\OJmKl^*Kf��MOKlg°g�W�UqKlgSPVG*�OKf^*k���6� � ->�°MQPS\OJm� !`KNMQW*Kf^"� ���VI*dlU�g ���hv�R*PSMOPh\�JLKf^*Ph\���W[iÓ]P�MQU«IÆP6�OG�Z*Z*dlKfPhRÉMQU«g�W*UHU]�OP�[«�OZ{PhgSKf}g6g�W*UqKfghP�Õ>¹M`Kl�¡^�U]M`^*PhgSPh���Q[]\�s?MOW[�M6[V�Og�W�PhR*G*dfPhR >@A6Ö5Z*\OU]kq\Q[]J�Kl��Z�G*\OPSdfsTR*P�MQPS\OJmKl^*Kf��MQKfg �2-���������� & � I*dlU�g ���gi[�^�G*��P�P VHZ*dlKfghKNM`gi[]dfdl�pMOUm\O[]^*R*U]JLKNMi[�MOKlUq^ a|G�^*gSMOKlUq^*�SÕ

*pPhgh[]G*��PyMO\Q[]^��OKfMOKlUq^��«W[iÓ]PTZ[]\Q[�JLP�MQPh\��V[]^*RÇI{Phgh[]G*��P MQW*PSKl\¾Z*\�PhgSUq^*R*KNMQKlU]^*�¾[]\�P Kl^�}\O��M �)U]\OR*PS\dlU]kqKlg�vjKfM�Kl��kqPS^*Ph\O[]dldNsÊG*^�R*PhgSKlR[]I�dlPVMQU�[]G�MOUqJ [�MQKlgh[]dldNs?�Og�W*PSR*G*dlPÉMQ\O[]^*��KfMQKfUq^*�SÕ �6U�!pP�ÓqPh\SvcKfMYKf�"��MQKfdldG*��PSa|G*d�MQU�R*P�ÓqPSdlUqZVJmPSMOW*UHR��~MQW*[�McPSKfMQW�Ph\c[�G�MQUqJL[�MOKlgi[�dldfs��Og�W�PhR*G*dfP�a|Uq\���UqJmP�M)s�ZÆPS�cU]aMO\Q[]^*��KfMOKlUq^*�Sv�U]\!p[©s���MQU"!`\OKNMQP -���������� & ��I*dlU�g ����MQW[�M~[]Z�Z*\OU VHKlJL[�MQP~a£[]Kl\ !|Uq\jU]MOW*Ph\�R*PS�OKl\�PhR6$<��g�W*PhR�G*dlKf^*k6MOPhg�W*^�Kl��G*Ph�SÕÖÌgSUqJmJLUq^L�Og�W*PSR*G*dfP�MQPhg�W�^*Kl��G*P"G*��PhRTKf^ UqG*\pgi[]��P���MOG*R*KlPS��Kl��[]�pa|U]dldlU�!`�SÔ�Z*Kfg �L[«^*UHR�P"[�M�\O[]^*R*U]J�v}^*R !`W�Klg�WT[]g�MQKfUq^*��MOW*P�^�UHR*P�gi[]^LM�[���P"[]^*R Z{Ph\�a|Uq\OJ+Uq^�P�U]ajMOW*Ph��P"[]gSMOKlUq^��hÕ �6�OG[]dfdfs]v�[°Z*[]\�MOKlghG�dz[]\^*U�R*P �¬�`g�W*UqKfghP�U]a�[]gSMOKlUq^*�¡Kf�`dlKlJmKfMOPhRmMQUÉUq^*P�Õ

>¹M¡Kl��KlJmZÆU]\�M�[�^�M3MOUV^*U]MQP !`W_s !�P !�[]^_M`[«�Og�W*PSR*G*dlP�MOW[�M¡PXVHW*KlI*KNMQ�p[]dldMQW�P�Kl^_MQPS\OPS��MQKf^*k¾I{PhW[iÓ�KlU]\U]a�[°Z�\OUqkq\O[]J?Ô�P VHPSghG�MOKlUq^*�`[�\OP�MOW*P��OU]G*\OgSP�U]a�R[�MQ[«a|Uq\�R�s�^[]JmKlg�Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�M�R*P�MQPhg�MQKfUq^ MQU¾PXV�[]JLKf^*P]ÕÖ�dNMQW*U]G*kqWm^*U]M�[]dldZ{Uq���OKlI�dlP¡P VHPSghG�MOKlUq^*��W[iÓqP6MQUYIÆP6�OPSPh^*!ÈMQW*Kf� !�UqG*dfR [�JLUqG�^�M3MOU°[�ÓqPh\�sm�OdlU�!-a|Uq\OJU]a�JLU�R*Phdjg�W�Phg ��Kl^*k $�v{KfM6Kl�`R*PS�OKl\O[]I*dfP�MOULgS\OPh[�MQP«\OPhZ�\OPh��Ph^_M�[�MQKfÓ]P«MO\Q[]^*��KfMOKlUq^y��MOPhZ*�SÕ Ò W*P ��PSs?Kl^��OKlk]W�MW*PS\OP"Kl��MQW[�M¡MOW*P -���������� & �LI*dlU�g � gh[]^yIÆP��OPhPS^o[��`[°MQPh��M6�OG*KNMQP�a|\�UqJ�MOW*P"ZÆPS\O��ZÆPSgSMQKNÓqP�U]a�R�s�^[]JmKlg[]^[�dfs��OKf�hÕ

� ��� ��� � � �� ��� �� �� � � � ��� �����

L3Ph\�KfaÈs�Kl^�kT�Q[�a|P�M)sAZ*\OU]ZÆPS\�MQKfPh�"U]aÈMOPh^ R*PSZÆPS^*R*��Uq^ Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�"[�^*R Uq^½[]G VHKldfKz[]\�s�dfPhJmJ [��hÕ°ro[]g�W*Kf^*PÓqPS\OKN}gi[�MOKlUq^�\�Ph��G*Kl\�Ph�ÉMQW[�MÉ�OG*g�W-dlPhJmJL[]�¾I{P?��M�[�MOPhR-[]^*RÎZ*\OU©Ó]PhR.PXVHZ*dlKfghKfMOdfs]vePSÓqPS^.KNa�MOW*PSs���PhPhJdlKN�]P I{U�UB�Q�]PhPSZ*Kl^�k�R*P�M�[]Kfdl�°MOUAMQW*PyG*��Ph\hÕ �6Ph^*gSP]v(MQW*PTMQW�Kl\ORÇ��MQPSZ.Kl^ÇU]G*\VJLP�MQW*U�R�Kl�°MOU kqPh^*PS\Q[�MOPgi[�^*R*KlR*[�MQPAKf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MO�y[]^*RËdlPSJLJL[]�T[]GHMQUqJL[�MQKfgi[]dfdfs�I_s G*��Kl^*k�R�s�^[�JLKfgAKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MTR*PSMOPhg�MQKlU]^ËMOU[]^[�dfs)MhP�P VHPSghG�MOKlUq^?R[�MQ[Va|\�UqJ�MOW*PJ>@A6Ö FHKfJ¾G*dz[�MQUq\SÕ

Ö�aÈMOPh\�P VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^ R[�MQ[yKf�"kqPh^�Ph\Q[�MQPhR a|\OU]J MOW*PLFHKlJ¾G�dz[�MOUq\hvÆKfM"Kf��kqKfÓ]Ph^ MQU MOW*PmX"[]K`��Uq^ÊMQU�Uqd~MOUZ{Ph\�a|U]\OJ MOW*Kl�eR�s�^[�JLKfg¡Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MeR*PSMOPhg�MQKlU]^�Õ Ò UHUqd��OG*Z*Z{Uq\�M(a|U]\cMQW*Kf�(R*[�M�["ghU]^�Ó]Ph\��OKlU]^ !p[]�3Kl^*KNMQKz[�dldfsR*P�ÓqPhdfUqZ{PhR°I_sYX�Ph[]^°[�^*R¾FH[]^_MQUq� �¬X�Ph[qwqw�v�Û�F�w�u ��[�^*RYa|G�\�MQW�Ph\�P V�MQPS^*�OKfUq^*�~[]\OP3�OW�U�!`^°Kl^«FHPhg�MQKfUq^ IHÕªx�ÕX"[]KN�]Uq^�kqPh^*PS\Q[�MOPh��gSUq^ ��PSgSMQG�\OPh�L!£Kl^?}\O��M �¹Uq\OR*PS\�dfUqkqKlgO$�MQW[�M"[]\�P«Ó�[]dlKfR >@A6Ö ��sH^_MQ[0VÊKf^�MOW*P«a|Uq\�J U]aKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MQ�SÕ Ò W�Ph�OP«Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�`[]\�PY[]Z*Z{Ph^*R*PSRoMQUVMOW*P°[�G�MQUqJL[�MOUq^�v�MOULI{P«G��OPhR�Kl^TMQW�P«^*PXV�M���MQPhZ�U]aUqG*\¡JmPSMOW*U�R�Õ

>¹ac[�^�s G*^�G*�OG[�djIÆPSW[iÓHKfUq\�Kf�¡�OPhPS^�I_syX"[�K`�]U]^y[�M�MQW�Kl�¡Z{UqKl^_Miv�[]� !`KfMOW MQW*PY×�PSMQPS\O��Uq^�gh[]�OP���MQG*R�sKl^�FHPSgSMOKlUq^ <*ÕNuqvKfM¡Kf�6[]^�Ph[]\OdNs UqZ�ZÆUq\�MQG*^�KfM)s MOUÉ} VyMQW*PY[]dfkqUq\OKNMQW*J Uq\¡KNMQ�`KlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^_M�[�MOKlUq^LKl^ >@A6Ö«ÕÒ W*Kf�`a|PSPhR*I*[]g �ydlU�UqZTU]a�!`\OKfMOKl^*kÉU]a~ghU�R*PY[]^*R?R�s�^[]JmKlgY[]^*[]dfs��OKf�hv*U�aÈMQPh^?Kl^�ghdlG�R*Kl^*k¾MOW*PY[]R*R*KNMQKfUq^TU]aJmUq\OP`MQPS��M���G*KfMOPh�Sv�gi[�^ W[]Z*Z{Ph^TG�^�MOKldMQW�P�G*�OPS\pKf���O[�MQKf��}PSR MQW[�M !`W[�MpKl��\OPhZ{Uq\�MQPhR I�sÉMOW*P�R�s�^[]JmKlgKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M¡R*P�MQPSgSMQU]\�Kf�¡^*U]M`G*^*PXVHZÆPSgSMQPSRÊI{PhW[iÓ�KlUq\SÕ

Ò W*\OPSPLZ{U]MOPh^_MQKl[]d�Z*\�UqI*dfPhJm� !`KfMQWAMOW*Kl��MOW*Kl\�RA��MQPSZÁ[�\OPVMQW[�M"MQW*PÉdlPSJLJL[]��KfM"Z*\�UHR�G*ghPS�«JL[isÊI{PG*^*��UqG*^*R<v�Kl^*gSUqJmZ*dlP�MQP]veU]\m^�U]MVÓqPS\�sÎG*�OP�a|G*d�ÕÎX�PS�OZ*KNMQP MQW�Ph�OP?Z{U]MQPS^�MOKz[]dpZ*KfM�a£[]dldf�hvcMQW�Kl�V��MOPhZÎMQPh^�R*�MQU?Z{Ph\�a|U]\OJ !�PhdldeKf^�Z�\Q[]g�MQKlgSPm[]�«��W*U�!`^�I_s UqG*\Ygi[]��PL��MQG*R�KlPh�«[]^*R�U]MQW�Ph\O� � Û�b3w_t�I�v�Û�b(wqt�g �EÕ ;�PR*Kf�OghG��O�6W*U�!ÌMQUÉgSUqZÆP !`KNMQWTMQW*P"MOW*\OPSP«Z{U]MQPS^_MQKz[�d�Z*\OU]I*dlPSJL�SÕ

� �^�� ��� .')1 1 X�s�^[]JmKlg¡Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�M3R�PSMQPSgSMOKlUq^LKl�3G*^*��UqG*^*R�Ô�\OPhZ{Uq\�MQPhRLZ*\OU]ZÆPS\�MQKfPh�([]\�P`MO\OG*P6U©ÓqPS\�MQW�PMQPS��M �OG*KNMQP]vpI*G�MmMQW*PS\OPoKf�L^�UÁkqG[�\Q[]^_MQPSP�MOW[�MmMQW*PyMQPS��M ��G*KfMOP�a|G*dfdfsÁg�W[]\Q[�gSMQPS\OKNMhPh�LMQW*P?P VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^

tB;

Page 28: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ph^_Ó�Kl\�Uq^*JmPh^_MVU]a`MOW*PTZ*\OU]kq\Q[]J?Õ Ò W*Kf�VR*U�Ph�¾^*U�MVW*Kl^�R*Ph\¾G��hvea|Uq\°M !�UA\OPh[]�OUq^��hÕ�F�Kl\���Miv !�PTG*��Py[]dldU]a¡MOW*P R�s�^[]JmKlgh[]dldNsAR*P�MQPhg�MQPSRÎKf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MO�«MOUÊW*PhdfZ�Kl^ÁZ*\OUqZ{Uq��Kl^*k*v�G*^*R*PS\O��MQ[]^*R*Kf^*k*v3[]^�RÁÓqPS\OKfaÈs�Kf^*kZ*\�Uqkq\Q[�J Z*\OU]ZÆPS\�MQKfPh�Sv�I�G�M !pP6G*�OP�["MQW*PSUq\OPSJ Z*\OU©ÓqPS\�MOUYPS^*�OG�\OP�MOW[�M3MQW�P6dfPhJmJ [�� !pP6G*�OP6Kl^ÉZ*\�UHU�a|�[]\�P��OUqG�^*R�Õ�FHPhgSUq^*R�v�JLUq��M�U]a�MOW*P�UqG�MOZ*G�M¡Kf^TUqG*\�gi[]��P"��MQG�R*KlPS� !pPS\OP"ghU]\O\OPSgSMhv[]^*R MOW*Uq�OP�MOW[�M !�Ph\�P^*U]M !�Ph\�P�Ph[]�OKfdfs«ghUq\�\OPSgSMQPSR [�\�MQKNa£[]gSMO�eU]a{MQW*P�MOPh��M(��G*KfMOP7!£P VHPSghG�MOKlUq^m�Og�W*PSR*G*dfKl^*k�$�Õ >)^mkqPh^*PS\Q[]dEvq�OKfJLZ�dfsghU©Ó]Ph\OKf^*kmPSÓqPS\�syKf^�MOPh\�Ph��MOKl^*kL[]��ZÆPSgSM6U]a~Pi[]g�Wo[]gSMOKlUq^T��PhPhJm�`MQUÉIÆPY[]R�Ph��G[�MOP]Õ

Z&��+ �W(�'_��') �')1 1 X�s�^[]JmKlg°Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M�R*PSMOPhgSMOKlUq^½Kl�"Kf^*ghU]JLZ*dfPSMOP]Ô�MQW�PmZ�\OUqZ{Uq�OPSR�Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MO�"J [isI{P(Kf^*�OG $LgSKlPS^�M�a|Uq\�Ó]Ph\OKN}gi[�MQKlU]^�v�IÆPSgi[]G*��Pp��UqJLPeMO\OG*P3Kl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MQ��[�\OP3^*U]M�\OPSZÆU]\�MQPSR�Õ~X"[]K`��Uq^�\OPh��MQ\�KlgSMO�MQW�P¾�OP�M"U]a3Kl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MQ��KfM�g�W*Phg ���"a|Uq\�M !�UT\OPh[]�OU]^*�hÔ6MQU gSUq^*�OPS\�Ó]Pm\�G*^_MQKfJLP°[]^*R�vÆJLUq\�P°KfJLZ{Uq\�MQ[]^_MQdNsqvMQU�\OPSR*G*ghPLMQW*PL^�G�J¾IÆPS\°U]apa£[]dl��PLZ{Uq�OKNMQKNÓqPh��MQW*[�M¾KNM«\�PhZ{Uq\�MO� !ÈMQW*PLJLUq\�PLZ�\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKlPS�«KNMYg�W*Phg ���hv3MQW�Pdz[�\OkqPS\pMQW*P�^�G*J¾I{Ph\`U]a�a£[]df�OP"Uq\`^*Uq^ �)G*��PSa|G*djZ*\�UqZ{Ph\�MOKlPS�6KNM !`Kldfd<\�PhZ{Uq\�M0$�Õ

FHUqJmPSMOKlJmPh�hv][]�cKf^¾UqG*\e×~[0VHUq�egi[��OP¡��MOG*R�s]v_R�s�^[]JmKlg�Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M~R*PSMOPhg�MQKlU]^VJ [is«\OPhZ{Uq\�Me[]^VKf^�Ó�[]\�K �[]^_M(MQW[�M(Kf�(^�U]MpZ�\OU©Ó�[]I*dlP`Kf^LKf�OUqdl[�MQKfUq^ ( []^*U]MOW*Ph\(Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M3J [isÉI{P�^�PhghPS�O�O[]\�sLI*G�M�^*U]M(R*P�MQPhg�MQPSR�Õ>)^oU�MQW*PS\ !�Uq\OR*�SvÆRHsH^*[]JLKfg«Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�M`R�PSMQPSgSMOKlUq^�gi[]^ÊZ{Uq��MQG*dl[�MQPY[LG��OPSa|G�d~Z*\�UqZ{Ph\�M)s !`W*U]�OP°Z�\OU�U]acKf�ghU]JLZ*dfKlgh[�MQPSR�Õ Ò W*Kl�Y[]I*KfdlKNM)s�MOU�R*PSghUqJmZ{Uq�OPL[?Z�\OU�U]apKf^_MQUyZ[]\�MQ�YR*PhJmUq^*��MQ\Q[�MQPh�«[T��MO\OPh^�k]MQW�U]a�UqG�\MQPSg�W*^*Kf��G�P]Ô�KNM�Kf��Pi[]��soMOU g�W*Phg �oZ*\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKfPh��R�s�^[�JLKfgi[]dfdfsqv{PSÓ]Ph^ KfaeMOW*PSsoW[iÓqPVgSUqJLZ�dlKlgh[�MQPSRoZ*\�UHU�a|�MQW*[�M6[]\OP�I{PSs]Uq^*R�MOW*P�gi[]Z*[]I*KldfKfMOKlPh��U]a~ghUqJmZ*dlP�MQPSdfs []G�MQU]J [�MOKlg���M�[�MOKlg�MOUHUqdf�hÕ

� 1�'�� ��(, .')1 1 Ò W*Kf\OR�vp�OUqJmPo\�PhZ{Uq\�MOPhR Z*\�UqZ{Ph\�MOKlPS� JL[©sÎI{P�MO\OG*P�I*G�M ^�U]M G*��PSa|G*dEÕ�X"[]KN�]Uq^ÎG*��Ph�W*PSG*\OKf��MQKfgh�YMQUoZ�\OG*^*P G*�OPSdlPh���°a£[]g�MQ�hv~a|Uq\«Kf^*��MQ[]^*gSP]vcI_s½dlKfJLKNMQKl^�k UqG�MOZ*G�M¾I*[]�OPSRÇUq^ÁÓ�[]\OKl[]I*dfP¾M)sHZ{Ph�SÕ��U�!�PSÓ]Ph\hv�KfMVKf�¾KlJmZ{Uq�O��KlI*dfPma|Uq\¾[AMOUHU]d(MOU ��^*U�! !`W[�Mm[AW�G*JL[]^!`Kldfd(}^�R-R*PS�OKf\Q[]I*dfP Kl^�[ k]KfÓqPS^�OKNMQG[�MQKlU]^�Õ�>)^ÉZ*\O[]gSMOKlgSP]v_!pP¡}^�RÉMOW[�M3KNMeKl�cPh[]��sVa|U]\cW�G*J [�^*�cMQU��OPSdlPSgSM3MQW*P¡G��OPSa|G�dKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�e[]^�RÉMOUZ[]���3U�Ó]Ph\3MQW*P`G*^�Kl^_MQPS\OPh��MQKf^*k«U]^*Ph� ( []^*RmP V�[]JmKl^*Kf^*k�MQW*PSJ W*PhdfZÆPSRÉG*�3�OUqdfKlR*KNaÈs°UqG�\eG*^*R*PS\O��MQ[]^*R*Kf^*kU]a�MQW*PL[]dlk]Uq\OKNMQW*J []^*R½MQW*PmKlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^_M�[�MOKlUq^�Õ Ò W�G*�Svc[?JLU�R*Ph\O[�MQPÉ[�JLUqG�^�MYU]apP V�MQ\O[�Kf^�a|Uq\OJL[�MOKlUq^R*U�Ph�`^*U]M`R�Kl��MO\Q[]g�M6Uq\¡R*Kl�O[]I*dfP"G*�OPS\O�hÕ

FHKlJmKldl[]\OdNsqvqMOW*P"\OPSZÆUq\�MQPSR?Z�\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKlPS��JL[©sLI{P"JLUq\�P�MQW*[]^y[]\OP"\�Pi[]dfdfsm^*PSPhR*PSR�Ôp[¾Z�\OU�U]a�[]ghgSPhZ�MOPhRI_sÎ[ÊMQW*PSUq\OPSJ Z*\OU©ÓqPS\LJL[is�G*��P�JmUq\�PTKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�¾MQW*[]^.[�\OPy��MO\OKlg�MQdNs�^*PSghPh���Q[]\�sqvpMOW�G*�LU]I*�OgSG*\OKf^*kMQW�P Ph���OPS^�MOKz[]d�[]\�kqG*JmPh^_MiÕ";�P I{PhdfKlPSÓ]PLKNMYKl�YIÆP�MOMQPS\YMOU�}\���M°UqI�M�[�Kl^�[ !�Uq\#��Kl^�k*v�JL[]g�W*Kf^*P ��ÓqPh\�Kf}PSRZ*\�UHU]a�vH[]^*RLMQW*PS^ MQU°��KlJmZ*dlKNaÈsVKfMhÕe×~U]�O�OKfI*dfsL[]GHMQUqJL[�MQKf^*k�MQW*Kf�(MQ[]�#��!|a|UqdfdlU�!`Kl^�k«Ú`Kl^_MQ[]^*Ph^��¬Ú`Kl^w]w �ÆI�sKfMOPh\O[�MQKf^*kLG�^�MOUy[ JmKl^*KfJ []dÆ} V��)Z{UqKl^_M�U�a3Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�0$¡Kl��Z*\OPS�OPS^�MOPhR�[]��a|GHMQG*\�P !pU]\#�?Kl^ FHPSgSMOKlUq^[CHÕfuqÕ;�PVR*KlRÊ^�U]M"W[iÓqPVMOUTZÆPS\�a|Uq\�J ��G*g�WÁ[ \�PhR*G�gSMQKfUq^AKl^oUqG*\�gh[]�OPV��MQG*R�s]Õ Ò W*Kf��}^*R�Kl^*ky[]gSghUq\�R*� !`KfMOWU]MOW*Ph\¾G��OPh\V��MQG*R�KlPh�VU�a�\�G*^_MQKfJLP []^[]dNsH��Kl� � Û�b3w_t�g �Ev !`W�Ph\OP MOW*PTUqG�MOZ*G�M¾a|\�UqJCR�s�^[]JmKlg Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MR*P�MQPhg�MQKfUq^ !p[]�6[]I*dfP�MQUÉW*PSdlZyÓqPh\�KfaÈs MOW*PY[]I*��Ph^*gSP«U]a~ghPS\�MQ[]Kl^y\OG�^�MOKlJmP"Ph\�\OUq\��hÕ

� ��� / � ���� � � ��� � � � Ò W*P«�OPhgSUq^*RA��MQPhZAKf^�U]G*\�JmPSMOW*UHR<v{PXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^�v<Kf��[]df�OU []Z*Z*\�UqZ*\OKl[�MQP !`W*PS^ [�MOMOPhJmZ�MQKf^*kÉMQULÓ]Ph\�KfaÈs�[�OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^°\�Phdz[�MQKlU]^�Õ~Ö��3^*U]MQPSRLKf^mFHPhg�MQKfUq^mx�Õ¯t�vqMQW*PU>@A6ÖË��KlJ¾G*dl[�MQU]\�gi[�^mW�PhdlZmG*��Ph\O�ea|Uq\�J¾G*dl[�MQP¡[�^*RMQPS��M�MQW*P`Ó�[]dlKfR*KfM)s°U]a�["a|Uq\ !p[]\ORL�OKfJ¾G*dz[�MQKlU]^V\OPhdl[�MQKfUq^�v_Z*\�KlUq\eMOU°�OG�g�WT[YÓ]Ph\OKN}gi[�MQKlU]^�Õ >)^LMOW*Kl�(�OPSgSMOKlUq^�v!�PTR*Kl��ghG*���mW�U�! [o��g�W*PhR*G�dlP?[]^*RÇU]MOW*Ph\VKf^�a|Uq\�J [�MOKlUq^½gi[�^ÇW*PhdfZÇKl^ÇP VHPSghG�MOKl^*k Z[]Kf\OPSRÇ[]G�MOUqJ [�M�[�v!`W*KfdlP¾MQW�P >@A`Ö���KlJ¾G�dz[�MOUq\�MOPh��MO�YMOW*PÉghUq^�R*KfMOKlUq^*�"U�apMQW�Pm\�Phdl[�MQKfUq^�Õ Ò W*Kf���Og�W*PSR*G*dlKf^*k !`Kldld�dz[�MOPh\"I{PG*��PSa|G*d�Kl^Tk]G*KlR*Kf^*k¾ÓqPS\OKN}gi[�MOKlUq^<Õ

t�C

Page 29: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ö a|Uq\ !p[]\�R1��KlJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^.\�Phdl[�MQKfUq^ Kl� [�Z�\OPhR�Klgi[�MQPÊMQW*[�My\OPSdz[�MOPh� MQW�PA��M�[�MQPh�yU]aYM !�U.[]GHMQUqJL[�M�[!£��PhP?MQW*P?R*PS}*^*KfMOKlUq^ÎKl^ FHPhg�MQKlU]^ tHÕEDHÕNu($�Õ ×~[]Kl\�PhR-P VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^.\�Ph��G*Kl\�Ph�L�OG*g�W [½ghUq\�\OPS�OZ{Uq^*R*PS^*ghPoMOU\OPS�OUqdNÓqP�^*Uq^�R*PSMOPh\OJmKl^�Kl�OJ?Õ �6�OG[]dfdfs]vHMQW�PYR�Ph�OKfkq^*PS\¡U]ac[�^?KfJLZ�dlPhJmPh^_MQ[�MQKfUq^ W[��`[]^yKlR*Ph[ÉU�a�MOW*P���MOPhZghU]\O\OPS�OZ{Uq^*R*PS^*ghP�Õ Ò W*P >@A6ÖÐMQU�Uqd`��KfMV[]dldfU�!`�¾MOW*P?R*Ph��Klkq^*PS\mMOU½[]^*^*U]MQ[�MQPyMQW�P?Z�\OUqkq\O[]J !`KNMQW�MQW*Kf�ghU]\O\OPS�OZ{Uq^*R*PS^*ghP�Õ

Ò W*P�����������I*dlU�g �yKl^ F�KlkqG�\OP¾x ��tmR�Ph�OgS\OKfIÆPS��[ ��MOPhZAghU]\O\OPS�OZ{Uq^*R*PS^*ghPVa|Uq\6G*��PVKl^�MOPh��MQKl^�ky[ �OKfJ �G*dl[�MQKfUq^�\�Phdl[�MQKfUq^�Õ Ò W*PTghU�R*P Kf�«a|\�UqJ/MQW*PT×~[0VHUq�Vgi[��OP ��MQG*R�sÁKl^�FHPhg�MQKlU]^ <*ÕªxHÕEI?I*G�M4!�P P V�[]JmKl^�PUq^*dNsoMOW*PÉ��s�^_M�[0V�W*PS\OP]ÕL;ËKNMQW�[��������¡I*dlU�g ��vjMQW*PÉZ[]Kf\OPSR���KlJ¾G*dl[�MQU]\�gi[�^�PXV�PSghG�MOPLMOW*PÉ�OZ{PhghKN}gi[ �MQKfUq^�[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^yKl^?dlU�g ����MQPSZ !`KfMOW?MOW*P°KfJLZ�dlPhJmPh^_MQ[�MQKfUq^T[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^<Õ Ò W*P ���������3I*dlU�g �TghU]^�MQ[]Kl^��M !�UL��G*I��)I�dlU�g ���SvghUq\�\OPS�OZ{Uq^*R*Kf^*k¾MQUVMQW�P�M !pUmghUq^�R*KfMOKlUq^*�p\OPh��G*Kf\OPSRya|U]\`[¾�OKlJ°G*dz[�MOKlUq^ \OPhdl[�MQKfUq^*!EFHPhg �MQKfUq^ÁtHÕ D�Õfu($�Õ Ò W*PL}*\O��M°�OG*I �)I*dfUHg ��v���M�[]\�MQPSR�I_s�������������������v���W*U�!`�¾W*U�! MQU���M�[�\�MYMQW*Pm�OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^<Õ � Ò W*P��OPSghUq^*R��OG*I �)I*dfUHg � gSUq^_M�[]Kf^*�`[]^?Ph^_MQ\�sTa|Uq\¡Pi[�g�Wo[]g�MQKfUq^yU]a~MOW*P�KlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^_M�[�MOKlUq^[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^ �pMQW*Kf�ÉPh^_MQ\�s�Z*\OU©Ó�KlR*PS� [�^.[]dfkqUq\�KfMQW�JCa|Uq\ÉZ*\�UHR�G*ghKf^*k½[]^-PXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^-a|\Q[�kqJLPS^_MLU�a�MQW�P�OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^y[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^<Õ3F�s�^_M�[]g�MQKlgh[]dldNsqvHPi[]g�W?Ph^_MQ\�s G*��Ph�������V��M�[�MOPhJmPh^_MQ��MOUVMQPhdfdÆMOW*P"�OKfJ¾G*dz[�MQUq\MQUV}\�P"�OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^y[]gSMOKlUq^��hÕeÖ�����������I*dlU�g � JL[isT[]df�OUVghU]^�MQ[]Kl^y[¾MOW*Kl\�RT�OG*I��¹I*dlU�g �LMOW[�M¡R�Phghdl[]\OPS�[]G VHKfdlKz[�\�sÉÓ�[]\OKl[]I*dlPS�¡G*�OPSR�I_sTMOW*P���MQPSZ�gSUq\O\�Ph��ZÆUq^�R*Ph^*gSP]Õ

� �.- /� ���� � �� ���� �� � ���

Ò W*P¡dl[]��Me��MQPSZmKf^¾UqG*\�JLP�MQW*U�RVKl��MQU"Z*\�U�Ó]P¡MQW*P���KlJ¾G�dz[�MOKlUq^«\OPhdl[�MQKfUq^ !|Uq\cKf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M0$�G*��Kl^*k�[�MOW*PhU]\OPhJZ*\�U�Ó]Ph\SÕ Ò W*Kl��kqG*[]\Q[]^_MOPhPh��MQW�P���UqG*^*R*^�Ph�O�~U]a*U]G*\jMQPhg�W�^*Kl��G*P�ÕcÖ���R*PS�Ogh\�KlI{PhR°[]IÆU©Ó]P]v�MOW*PhU]\OPhJ Z�\OU©ÓqPS\O�kqPS^*Ph\O[]dldNsÊ\OPS��G*Kl\�PLW�G*JL[]^½Kl^*Z*GHM�Kl^ MQW*PVa|Uq\�J U]a�dfPhJmJ [��"[]^*R½Z*\OU�U]a(M�[]g�MQKfgh�hÕ ��PS\OP !pPmR*PS�Ogh\�KlI{PW*U�! MQW*P \�Ph��G*dfMO�VU]a�FHPhg�MQKfUq^*�Éx�Õ�xA[]^*R�x�Õ=<Agi[�^ÇIÆP G��OPhR�MQUokqPh^*PS\Q[�MOP MQW*Kf�¾Kl^�Z*G�MV[�G�MQUqJL[�MOKlgi[�dldfs]ÕF�Kf\O��Mhv<MQW�P¾Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ����G*kqkqPS��MOPhR½I�soR�s�^[]JmKlg¾Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�M�R*PSMOPhg�MQKlU]^AIÆPSghUqJmPVgi[]^�R*KlR[�MQPh�"dfPhJmJ [��hvMQW�Ph\OPSI_so�O[©Ó�Kf^*kmMOW*P°G��OPh\6MQKfJLP"Kf^?}^�R*Kl^*k []G VHKldfKz[]\�s Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MO�`^*PhPSR*PhRÊa|Uq\¡Ó]Ph\OKN}gi[�MQKlU]^�Õ`FHPSghUq^*R<vMQW�P«[�^*^*U]MQ[�MQKfUq^*�pa|Uq\¡Z*[]Kl\�PhRTP VHPSghG�MOKlUq^?Z*\OU©Ó�KlR�P«[VZ*\�UHU�a~U]G�MQdfKl^*P"[�^*R?MQ[]gSMOKlgS�hÕ >)^TMQW*Kf�¡�OPSgSMQKfUq^�v/!�P�OW�U�!�W*U�!ÌMQUÉkqPS^*Ph\O[�MQP"MOW*P�dz[�M�MQPh\SÕ

Ò W*P�UqG�MOdlKl^�P�[]^*R MQ[]gSMOKlgS�¡[]\OP"k]Ph^*PS\Q[�MOPhRTa|\OUqJ JmUHR*KN}PhRLÓqPh\��OKfUq^*�`U]a�MQW*P�Z*\OU�U]a�MQ\O[]^*�Odl[�MQU]\O��a|U]\Ü�× []^*R >)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP�Õ Ò W*P�MQ\O[]^*��dz[�MOUq\O�`G*��PYMOW*P«��MQ\�G*gSMOG*\OPYU]a�MOW*PYZ*\OUqk]\Q[]J ��MQW�P°[]^�^*U]M�[�MQKlU]^*� !`\OKNMOMQPS^I_sAMQW*PÉG*��Ph\"a|Uq\�P VHPSghG�MOKlUq^ ��[]^*R½UqG*\ ��^*U�!`dlPSR*kqPmU]a�ghUqJmJLU]^[]dlKNMQKfPh�6Kl^ Z*\OU�U]a|��U]a >@?BA []GHMQUqJL[�M�[MQUAk]Ph^*PS\Q[�MOPTZ*\OU�U]a6�OgS\OKlZHMQ�hÕ�>)^�Z*\Q[]g�MQKfghP]v !�PyW[iÓqPTa|UqG*^*R�MOW[�MVMOW*Ph��PTZ*\OU�U]a6�OgS\OKlZHMQ�VW[iÓqPy�O[©Ó]PhRÓqPS\OKN}gi[�MOKlUq^TMOKlJmP�I_s?[]G�MQU]J [�MOKl^*k°J []^_sT��MQPSZ*�`U]ae[VZ*\�UHU]a�Õ

� !� !# ������������������e2e����23�p�*�

×e\OU�U]a|�¡U]a~Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�¡Kf^�[¾MOW*PhUq\�PhJ Z*\�U©ÓqPh\¡a|UqdfdlU�!1[V��MQ\�G*gSMOG*\OPSRoJmPSMOW*UHR�UqdlUqk�sÆÔ

� ×e\OU©Ó]PYMOW*P���M�[�\�M`ghU]^*R*KfMOKlUq^<Õ

� ×e\OU©Ó]P¾MQW*PYMQ\Q[�^*�OKNMQKlU]^oghU]^*R*KfMOKlUq^�I_so��MQ\OG�gSMQG�\Q[]dcKf^*R*G*g�MQKfUq^oUq^�MQW*P¾R*[�M�[LM)s�Z{P¾U]aeMOW*PV[]g�MQKlU]^[]^�R�KNMQ�¡Z[]\O[]JmPSMQPS\O�SÕ

� �������£������¦��ª��µh���<�|�¹���E���|�¹����������¦j�E�����E���O¥���®�¥����E�ª���m���©�E�S�����E�S�V�ª�p¢©���������������O¢V¤i °�E��� � �!�"�!� �"¤��ª�©¥¹³¾���É�����¥��©¢©�SÀ��E��� ����������������� ¤��ª�©¥¹³ �E���ª��¥������V�����E�E�¯¥����ª�����£�����E���£�����E��¨ ¼ ���ª¥¹�y�¡�Q  ¢©���]����¢T��� �����°�£�����£���|�¹���E�Y��¦e�E����ª�p�������p���h���������S�"���©�����¡��������±

t�G

Page 30: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ò W*Ph\�PA[]\�P�M !�UÁMQU�Uqdl�ÉMQW*[�MLMO\Q[]^��Odz[�MQP >@A6Ö MOUÁZ*\�U©ÓqPh\ dz[]^*k]G[]kqPS� []^�R �OUqJmP\!`W*[�MT[]GHMQUqJL[�MQPZ*\�U�Ó�KfR*Kl^*kyMQW�Kl� ��Kf^*RÁU�a`[]�O��Kl��M�[]^*gSP]Õ Ò W*P # � ��� & - & MQU�Uqd � *¡ÙYÜ�w_t �pgSUq^_ÓqPS\�MQ� >@A6Ö Z*\OUqk]\Q[]Jm�°[�^*R[]���OPh\�MQPSRoKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MQ�¡Kf^_MQUÉÜ�F�Üev�[]^?Kl^*Z*GHM`dz[]^*k]G[]kqP�a|U]\`Ü�×�ÕÖ�^?P V�[]JmZ*dlP"U�a�KNMQ�¡UqG�MOZ*G�M6Kl�SÔ

�&�%������k�&�d+Z�J1 3 ���a������ +k�U� �d�E����1 . �k�&�K+k���?1

Ò W*P # � ��� �->��'�� & & � �¬ÜjG*W*w_t �_MQU�Uqd_Z*\�U©ÓHKfR*Ph���OKfJLKfdz[]\<[]�O��Kl��M�[]^*gSP(a|U]\�\�Pi[]��Uq^*Kf^*k�[�IÆUqGHM�>@A`Ö�G*�OKf^*k>)�Q[�IÆPSdldlP �¬Û�F G�<*v�r��G*d GBC �EÕ7;�PVW[iÓqPÉG*��PhR½[ MQW*Kf��MQU�Uqd��OG*gSghPh����a|G*dfdfsAKf^Agi[]��PV��MOG*R*KlPS�hÕ«Ö�^AP V�[]JmZ*dfPU]a~KfMO�¡UqG�MQZ�G�M6Kl�hÔ

��M;�;����"���S�����<!��"�M�������l���S�yW

++Z������S(��������*��>&�=�S�������21 3+�N�M�������21 3+?���J�������M;R����� ��%&:���>��=�M�������l���M�[11���2+M��:&:�������� �&%�:*��>��=�M�������c���M�21$�

Û�U�! !�PLR*PS�OgS\OKlI{PLMOW*PÉM�[]g�MQKlgS�"MQW[�MYMQW�P >)�O[]IÆPSdldfPÉMO\Q[]^��Odz[�MQUq\�UqG�MOZ*G�MO�Ya|Uq\Y[]���OKf��MQKf^*k?Z*\OU�U]a|��U]aKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MQ�SÕ Ò W*PmÜ�×1MQ\O[]^*��dz[�MOUq\�UqG�MOZ*G�MO�Y\�Phdl[�MQKNÓqPhdNsoJmKl^�KlJL[]d�MQ[]gSMOKlgS��a|Uq\"Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ��I{Phgh[]G*��P !�PW[iÓqP¡dfPh���cghUq^_MO\OUqd�U©ÓqPh\cMOW*P�Z*\�U©ÓqPh\~MQW[]^4!�P�R*U�a|U]\�>)�O[]IÆPSdldfP]Õ F~KlkqG*\�Ppx ��x���W*U�!`�cMQW*P�dfKl^*PS�~k]Ph^*PS\Q[�MOPhRI_s�MOW*P >)�O[]I{PhdldfPmMOUHU]d3a|U]\«Uq^�P Kl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MYU]a�MOW*P ��W[]\OPSRÇJLPSJLU]\�s gi[��OP ��MQG*RHs�a|\�UqJ%npW[]Z�MOPh\ <�Õ¯tHÕÖ�kq[]Kl^�vcMOW*PyZ[]\�MQKlgSG*dz[�\¾[]dfkqUq\OKNMQW*J/Kf�V^*U]MÉKfJLZ{Uq\�MQ[]^_MiÕ Ò W*PykqPS^*Ph\O[]d�JmPSMQW�UHR*U]dlUqk]s !�PTG*�OPyKl�É[��a|UqdfdlU�!`�hÔuqÕ6×e\OU©Ó]PÉMOW*PÉ��MQ[]\�M�gSUq^*R*KNMQKlU]^AI�sÊghKfMOKl^*k �OZ{PhghKN}gVM�[]g�MQKfgh�hÕ Ò W*Kl�"Kf��\OPSdz[�MOKfÓqPSdfs���MO\Q[]KfkqW_MOa|Uq\@!�[]\�R[]^�R���UÉMOW*P"M�[]g�MQKfg�a|Uq\�MQW*Kf�`Kl�¡UqJmKfM�MQPhR a|\�UqJ�MOW*P"}kqG*\�P]Õ

tHÕ�FHZ�dlKfM°G*Z�MQW*PTZ*\�UHU�a�U�a�MOW*PTKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MVKl^_MOUA�OPhZ*[]\Q[�MOPydlPhJmJL[]�«a|Uq\°Pi[]g�W�MQ\O[]^*�OKNMQKfUq^�Õ�×3\�U©ÓqPPh[]g�W dlPSJLJL["I_sLgSKfMOKl^*kY[«��ZÆPSghKN}g���Ph��G*Ph^�ghP"U]aÆMQW*PSUq\OPSJL�p[]IÆU]G�M3MQW*P�[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^m[]�pdfPhJmJ [��hÕ>)^ MQW*P¾}*kqG*\OP�vjMQW*PV}\���MYZ[]\O[]kq\Q[�Z*W �OW*U�!`��MQW*PVZ*\�UHU�a�a|Uq\�Uq^*PVMQ\O[]^*�OKNMQKfUq^�v � ��-� �(, ��v�!`W�Klg�W[]���OG*JmPh� -�� ��������Kl�É\OPh[]g�W[]I�dlP?[]^*R ����-�6�(, ��Kf�VPh^[]I�dlPhR<Õ Ò W*P?ghU�R*P�[�MOMOPhJmZ�MQ�VMQU½Z*\�U�Ó]PMOW[�M"MQW�PVKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M O,� oW*UqdfR*��a|Uq\�MQW�PVZÆUq��M �¹��M�[�MQP]Õ Ò W*PVM�[]g�MQKlgS�"kqPh^�Ph\Q[�MQUq\"gSKfMQPS��MQW*P¾MOW*\OPSPZ*\�PhJmKl��Ph�hv ���� ) v¡[�^*R ��*Õ Ò W*PS^ KfMmG*��Ph�LMOW*P -$# � -[]^*R � ������ >)�Q[]I{PhdfdlPTM�[�gSMQKfgh� !`KfMOW��ZÆPSghKf}*gL[�\OkqG*JmPh^_MO�"\OPhdl[�MQKf^*k MOUyMOW*PÉ[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^AR�PS}^*KNMQKfUq^�v !`W*Kfg�W !�Ph\�PÉR*Kl��ghU©ÓqPS\OPhR½MQUyI{PPH=<PSgSMQKNÓqPYKl^TZ*\�UHU�a|�hÕ

x�Õ Ò \�sLMQU¾Z*\�U©ÓqP"MQW*P�Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M���MOPhZyghU]^*R*KfMOKlUq^ I�s Kl^*R�G*gSMOKlUq^ U]^ MQW*P�[]g�MQKfUq^ R[�MQ[°M)s�ZÆP�[]^�RTI�sgSKfMQKf^*k MQW�PLdfPhJmJ []��a|Uq\"Pi[]g�W½MQ\O[]^*�OKNMQKfUq^�Õ Ò W*Kf�«Kf�"�OW*U�!`^�Kf^ MOW*PÉ�OPSghUq^*R�Z[]\O[]kq\Q[�Z*W�U�apMQW�P}k]G*\OP�Õ

<*Õ6×e\OU©Ó]P¾MQW*PVKf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^�ghP°U�aeMQW*P¾Z�\OPhR�Klgi[�MQP¾KNMQ�OPSdfa3I_sÊgSKfMOKl^*kmMQW*P¾��MQPSZ½gSUq^*R*KNMQKfUq^A[]^*RÊMOW*P¾��M�[]\�MgSUq^*R*KNMQKlU]^ dlPSJLJL[]�hÕ Ò W*Ph^?Z*\�U�Ó]P�MQW[�M6[]�¡[¾ghU]^*�OPS��G�Ph^*gSP°U]a�MQW�P"Z*\OPSR*Klgh[�MQP�I{PhKf^*kÉ[]^TKf^�Ó�[]\�K �[]^_Mhv<MQW*P°Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M�W*UqdfR*��Uq^Ê[]dld�\OPh[]g�W[]I*dfPV��MQ[�MQPS�hÕ Ò W*Kl��dz[]��M"Z[]\�M�Kl��G*�OP�a|G*dc�OU MOW[�M"U�MQW*PS\Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M¡Z�\OU�U]a|�¡gi[]^yM�[ �]PY[]R�Ó�[]^_M�[�kqP�U]a~MOW*P�ghG*\�\OPS^�M6Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M¡W�UqdlR*Kf^*kV�OW�UqG*dlR�[V��MQ[�MQP�I{P\�Pi[]g�W[�I*dlP�Õ

FUq\cJL[]^_s°��KlJmZ*dlP�Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�hv�dlKN�]P�Kf^°MQW*P¡JmPhJmUq\�s«gh[]�OP¡��MQG*RHsqv_MQW*PS�OP`[]GHMQUqJL[�MQKfgi[]dfdfs"k]Ph^*PS\Q[�MOPhRM�[�gSMQKfgh�¡\�Ph��G*Kl\�P�^*ULW�G*JL[]^?[]G*k]JLPS^�MQ[�MQKfUq^�Õ

xqw

Page 31: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� !� !�� ������������ 2+�*�� !"&�2�����p�/���&�2�����p�

Ú`Phgi[�dld<a|\�UqJ FHPSgSMOKlUq^�tHÕEDHÕNu�MQW[�M¡Ó]Ph\�KfaÈs�Kl^*km[V�OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^ \�Phdz[�MQKlU]^ \OPS��G�Kl\OPS�¡ÓqPh\�KfaÈs�Kl^�kmI{U]MOW�[V��M�[]\�MghU]^*R*KfMOKlUq^¾[]^*RÉ[���MQPhZÉgSUq^*R*KNMQKlU]^�Õ Ò \Q[�^*�Odl[�MQKfUq^°MQU�Uqdf�~Kf^¾MQW*P >@A`Ö.MQU�UqdN��KNM�G��OP�MQW�P ����������I�dlU�g �Ya|Uq\�[�OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^°\�Phdz[�MQKlU]^°MQU"kqPS^*Ph\O[�MQP¡Z�\OU�U]a�M�[]g�MQKlgS�ca|Uq\cPh[]g�WÉghUq^*R�KfMQKfUq^�Õ Ò W*P �������¾I*dfUHg �«gi[]^ÉI{P¡�OPSPh^[]��[ MOPh��MY��G*KfMOP°MQW[�MY[]dl��UTghUq^_M�[�Kl^*��MOW*PÉZ*\OU]kq\Q[]JmJmPh\��¬� ��^*U�!`dfPhR*kqPm[]I{UqG�M�W*U�! MOW*PV�OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^ Kl����G*Z*Z{Uq�OPSR?MOUVIÆPSW[iÓqP ( MQW�Kl��Kf� !`W_sTKfMpKl��G*��PSa|G*djKf^T[°a|Uq\�J []d{Z*\�UHU]a�vHUq^*gSP"Z*\OUqZ{Ph\�dfsMQ\O[]^*��dz[�MOPhR�Õ Ò W�P ��� ����I*dfUHg ��a|\�UqJ MQW*P�×�[�V�U]� gi[��OPo��MQG*RHs-Kf^ F~KlkqG*\�P?x ��t !`Kldfd¡IÆP?G*�OPSR []�L[\OG�^*^*Kl^�kmPXV�[]JLZ�dlP]Õ

� ��-/��� �B�^ ����������� Ò W*PÉ��MQ[]\�M�ghUq^*R�KfMQKfUq^Ê\�Ph��G*Kl\�Ph�"}^*R�Kl^*ky[ !`KfMO^*Ph���"��MQ[]\�M���M�[�MOP <«U]a3MQW�PV�OZ{PhghKN}gi[�MQKlU]^ []G�MQU]J [�MOUq^�Õ>)^�Ü�×�v*MQW*P�Z*\�UHU�a~U]I*dlKfk_[�MQKfUq^ Kf�

�M������T+5�d!-a���������Fx^j�z�1s.��A� !ea����������Tx #�z=+�M����&�T+ �g1 3lGK+5�d���211

MQW�PY\�G*dlPS�6[]\OP"��KlJmKldz[�\(a|Uq\">)�O[]I{PhdldfP]v*I�G�MU!`\Q[]Z*Z{PhR�G*ZyKl^?[ÉZ*\OPSR*Klgh[�MQP�Ô��(���%��M;cG�L��J�M(���]����M; ���S���&��!

������G�P���aJ�Z; ���S����&�lL&���?(������?;tG�L��J�M(���]����M;��!`W*PS\OP�MQW*P�Z*\�PhR*Kfgi[�MOPYKf�h��%��R�S������:����&�SG�P���a��-; ���S���&�4!&!

�J+ � ����� ��%��jd� � �S��������jU1*�S%��/. + � ����� ��%�&#F� � �S��������#�1��S%�� .+����M��������j�. ���S��������# . ��%�%&�R17.��%&%&� �

������G�P���aJ�Z; ���S����&�l��>&��jt��>&��#NG D&D+ �c� W ���Q�S������� �&%�:N��>&��j � +���� Wn+e� �I������&��� ��%&:N��>&�# 1 3

+�GN�o�R111

�Ò W*PTR*P�}^*KfMOKlUq^�U]a¡MQW�P Z*\�PhR*Kfgi[�MOP ghUqJmPh�«Kl^ÁM !�UAZ*KfPhghPS�hÕ[F~Kl\O��MivW!�P R*P�}^*P MOW*P R[�M�[�M)s�Z{P U]a

# -�� � � # � - �� � {v`MOW*Ph^ !�PoR�PS}^*PoKfMQ�LJLPh[]^*Kf^*k*Õ Ò W*PÊR*[�M�[ M)sHZ{PÊ�O[©s�� MOW[�M #�-�� � ��# � - �� � M�[ �]Ph�°Kl^ MQW*\�PhPT[]\�kqG*JmPh^_MQ�SÔ°M !�UA[]G�MOUqJ [�M�[ !£Z[]\O[]JmPSMQ\�K`MSPhRÁI_s MQW�PhKl\«[]g�MQKlU]^½M)s�Z{P]v3[]�YP VHZ*dl[]Kl^*PSRKl^ÇFHPhg�MQKlU]^ ; $°[]^�RÇ[Ê\OPSdz[�MOKlUq^�Uq^ÁMQW�PhKl\«��MQ[�MQPS�hv([]^*RÇ\�PSMQG�\O^*�V[ÊI{U�UqdlPh[]^�Õ Ò W�PTR*PS}^�KfMQKfUq^ÁKf�°MQW�P��MQ[]^*R[�\OR?��M�[�\�M6ghUq^�R*KfMOKlUq^ a|Uq\¡��KlJ¾G�dz[�MOKlUq^L\OPhdl[�MQKfUq^*�SÕ

Ò W*PmZ*\OU�U]a(MQ\Q[�^*�Odl[�MQUq\�MOUHU]dl�"P V�MO\Q[]g�MYMOW*P !`KfMQ^�Ph�O� <«a|\�UqJ MQW�PmKfJLZ{Ph\O[�MQKNÓqP¾��M�[�MOPhJmPh^_MQ�YKl^ MQW�P�����������������Á�OPSgSMQKfUq^½U]a�[���������¡I�dlU�g �{v.!`W*Kfg�W�R*P�}^*PmKl^*KNMQKl[]d�Ó�[]dfG*Ph�"a|Uq\�MOW*Pm��M�[�MQPVÓ�[]\OKl[]I*dlPS��Kl^ MQW�P�OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^Ç[]GHMQUqJL[�MQU]^�Kf^ÁMQPS\OJm�°U]a¡MOW*P Kf^*KfMOKz[]dcÓ�[]dfG*Ph�Ya|Uq\YMOW*P ��M�[�MOP Ó�[]\OKl[]I*dlPS��Kl^ÁMOW*P KfJLZ*dfP �JmPh^_M�[�MOKlUq^Á[]G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^�Õ >)^�MQW*P ×�[0VHUq�Vgh[]�OP ��MQG*RHsqveMQW*P Z*\OU�U]a¡��gh\OKfZ�MVkqPS^*Ph\O[�MQU]\«MQ\O[]^*��dz[�MOPhR�MQW�P�����������������o�OPSgSMQKfUq^yU]a F~KlkqG*\�P"x ��tVKf^_MQUVMQW*P"a|UqdfdlU�!`Kl^�k°ghU]JLJL[]^*R*��a|U]\`Ü�סÔ

�����������*%��J�����%�ba������ ������!Ea����������Fx����&%��J����YMz � a���������Tx�L&%�����z���&������Ca����&������� +5�K!Za����������Tx����&%�������YSzJ1 Dx^�KWS�?�R�S� ������&�K�$�KW5���%��%J�����F����� �\�dWe���J���������K� �FW5:&��������z

�&�%����I�M�����T+5�d!-a����������Fx����&%��J����YSzJ17.�A��!ea����������Tx�L&%�� ��zt+��M������T+ �g1 3lG�+e�K���g11

����?>�;��o@�B�.����?>�;��o@�B,�M�J���������J�S| �?��)A�����"a������ �����g+Z����1

x�u

Page 32: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

��PS\OP�vqMQW*P�M !�U���\�Ph��G*JLP¡I_s �qgSUqJLJL[]^*R���R*Kf\OPhg�M3Ü�×½MOU�IÆPSkqKl^¾MOW*P�Z*\�UHU�aÆI_s°G*�OKf^*k"KfMO��I*G*KfdfM �)Kl^«KlJmZ*dlK �gi[�MQKlU]^yMQ[]gSMOKlg�v !`W*Klg�W�[]���OG*JmPh�¡MQW�PYW_s�Z{U]MQW*PS�OKf��[]^�R�\�PhZ*dl[]ghPS�`MOW*P�G*^*KNÓqPh\��Q[]dfdfs ��G*[]^_MQKf}*PhRyÓ][�\OKz[�I*dlP� I_sÎ[ } VHPSR ghUq^���M�[�^�M ��� v�[]^�RÎMOW*Ph^-G*�OKf^*k���� �� ����� �� ����� []�VMQW�P !`KNMQ^*PS�O�Éa|Uq\VMQW*P?P VHKl��MQPS^�MOKz[]d��G[]^_MQKN}Ph\����Õ >)^ MQW�P�gi[��OP���MQG*RHsqvHMOW*Ph��P�ghU]JLJL[]^*R*��[]\�P���G $mghKlPS^_MpMQU°ghUqJmZ*dlP�MQP¡MQW�P�Z*\�UHU]a�U]a�MQW�P��MQ[]\�M6gSUq^*R*KNMQKlU]^�Õ

Ò W*PYghUqJmJ [�^*R*�`[]\�P"�OKlJmKldl[]\�a|U]\">)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP]Ô���S����� ����������%��J��� YM]�L�%��R�c� ���&%��J����Y D&DL�%� � ���S�������W ;������"+���&%�������Y[W?�M�R�S� �������&�c� ����%����� Y�1

+ ���&%�������Y[W ���%��%�����t� ���&%��J����Y1���+ ���&%�������Y[W5�������S���&�c� ����%������Y�1+ ���&%�������Y[W5:��������"� ���&%��J����Y&1$�

��(���%��M;cG ���&%�������YS]�L�%� � ���S������!������G�P���aJ�Z; ���S����&� ���&%�������Y L�%����*G�����%����� YM]&L�%��R� �

W&W�W�M(�%�P ��+��S���&�����������&%��J����YS]�L�%�� � � ����%��J��� Y�1 �I������&��� ��%&: L&%����n3

G�����%��J��� YM]�L�%��R� � ���&%��J����Y�+������&� ����������%������YM]&L�%� � � ���&%�������Y�1$����������y+�&�e;��t�����! ������&� ����������%������YM]&L�%� � �����&: L�%�� � �����:

L�%��R� ��������&� �����&: G�����%��J��� YM]�L�%��R� �����:L�%��R� ������������W^;R����� �����:J1

Ò W*P }\O��ModfKl^*PAR*P�}^*PS� - �� � ���� & Õ Ò W*P���PhgSUq^*RÌdfKl^*PAZ�\OU©ÓqPS��MQW*[�M*- �� � ���� & �Q[�MQKl��}Ph�yMQW�P��MQ[]\�M�\OPh��G*Kf\OPSJLPS^�M"MOW*\OU]G*kqWÊMQW�PVG*�OPVU]a3MOW*P -$# � ÊM�[]g�MQKlg�Õ Ò W*Pm[]\Ok]G*JLPS^_MQ��MOU MQW*P¾MQ[]gSMOKlg¾[�\OP¾MQW�PR*P�}^*KfMOKlUq^��"U]apZ*[]\�MO�"U]a�MOW*PVM !pU?[]GHMQUqJL[�M�[HÕ Ò W*P�s[!pPS\OPmg�W*Uq�OPS^�a|\�UqJ UqG�\"P VHZÆPS\OKfPh^*gSP !`KNMQW >@?BA[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^�Z*\OU�U]a|�°[]^*R�MQW�Ph^ÇghU�R*PSRÇKl^_MQU?MQW*P >)�O[]I{PhdldfPLMO\Q[]^*��dz[�MOUq\�MQU�Uqd(MOUÊI{P UqG�MOZ*G�M°a|U]\°PSÓ]Ph\�s[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^<Õ

� ��'�� �B�^ ����������� Ò W*P"��MQPhZTgSUq^*R*KNMQKfUq^ \�Ph��G*Kl\�Ph��}^�R*Kl^*k¾[ !`KfMQ^�Ph�O�pP VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^ �½U�ajMQW*P���ZÆPSghKN}gi[�MOKlUq^ []G�MQU]J [�MOUq^La|U]\Pi[�g�WÉMO\Q[]^��OKfMOKlUq^°U]aMQW*P¡KfJLZ�dlPhJmPh^_MQ[�MQKfUq^°[�G�MQUqJL[�MOUq^�Õ Ò W*P¡Z*\OU�U]a���gh\OKfZ�MekqPS^*Ph\O[�MQU]\�a|Uq\OJ°G*dz[�MOPh��MQW*Kf�Z*\�UHU]a~UqI*dfKlk_[�MQKlU]^La|Uq\`Ü�× []�¡a|UqdfdlU�!`�hÔ

�&�%����G�+5�F!ea���������Tx j�zU� � !ea���������Tx{#Jz�1

3,�M�����T+e�K�\�&�S��(��q! j���� ��%� �px^jJzU� � ��!-a����������Tx{jJzJ17.�*�������F!�j �S�R��%��Ja&���Fx #�z=+���������G&���)U+ ��� ������21 3bGd+5� ���\����M�d+��F�$�������21�1E3

��������d+e�������[1�D,���������+M�&�S��(��g11

Ö �OKfJLKfdz[]\3a|Uq\OJ°G*dz[�MOKlUq^LKl��k]Ph^*PS\Q[�MOPhR?Kl^K>)�Q[�IÆPSdldlP�v !`W*Kfg�W�gh[]^yIÆP�a|U]G*^*RyKl^TÖ�Z*ZÆPS^*R*K V *�Õ *pU]MOWMQU�Uqdf�«[�dl�OU?kqPS^*Ph\O[�MQPLZ*\OU�U]a���gh\�KlZ�MO�«MQW*[�M°R�KfÓ�KlR*PVMOW*P Z*\�UHU�a�Kl^_MOU�gh[]�OPS�¾I[]��PhR�Uq^½MQW*P ��Kl^*R�U]a�MQW�P[]g�MQKlU]^ � Õ >)^TÜ�×~v_MQW*Kf�p��gh\OKfZ�M�G*�OPS�pMQW*P�ghUqJmJL[]^*R ������� �"! �$#&%�'(� � ��#()�%*)�% � vQ!`W*Kfg�W R*Kl\�Phg�MQ��Ü�×MQUyZ{Ph\�a|Uq\OJ ��MO\OG*g�MQG*\O[]deKl^*R�G*gSMOKlUq^AUq^AMOW*PVR[�MQ[�M)s�ZÆPVU]a � v8!`W�KldlP°Kl^[>)�Q[�IÆPSdldlP�v<MQW�PV�Ogh\�KlZ�M�G��OPh��MQW�P#O, ��� � TM�[�gSMQKfg]Õ Ò W*P"MOUHUqdf��kqPS^*Ph\O[�MQP�dlPSJLJL[]�pMOUÉW[]^*R*dfP�MQW*P�R*P�M�[]Kfdl��U�a~MOW*P�Kl^*R*KNÓ�KlR*G[�d<gi[��OPh�SÕ FUq\P V�[]JmZ*dfP]v�MQW*PVÜ�× MQ\O[]^*�Odl[�MQU]\�kqPS^*Ph\O[�MQPS��MQW�P°a|UqdldfU�!`Kl^*kÉdlPSJLJL[m[]^*RÊZ*\�UHU�a3�Ogh\�KlZ�M�a|\OUqJ MOW*P ��������I*dfUHg �ma|Uq\�MQW*P+#&%,#-�m[�gSMQKfUq^yKl^ MOW*PY×�[0VHUq�6gi[]��P«��MQG*RHsqÕ

�&�%����G�+5�F!ea���������Tx�����%��J��� YMzU� � !ea����������Tx�L&%�� �&z�1

3,�M�����T+e�K� �k� �?�d+?� � �21[� � ��1 .�*�������F!�j �S�R��%��Ja&���Fx�L&%�� ��z

x_t

Page 33: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

+k��������G&���)U+��T� �������[1E3G�+e� �J�\����M�F+ ���$�������[1�1 3��������K+e������[1�D,��������d+k�&�S��(��211

WW����?>�;��o@�B .����?>�;��o@�B,�M�J���������J�S| �?��)N��������� �y�?� �?�F+S���p�$���R1 � � �

Ò W*P?Kl^_MQPSdldlKfkqPh^�ghP U]a6MQW�Kl�VM�[]g�MQKfgTdlKlPS�VKl^ÇMQW�P?dfKl^*PLMQW[�Mm�O[©s��/� ��- � ��� '�� -����� #�� & #��#O,��������QÕ;ËW*Kfg�W�I{PSMQ[VMOUÉ�OZ{PhghKl[]dlKNMhP�MOUÉKl�¡R*PS\OKfÓ]PhRya|\OUqJ�MQW*P �����>�TI�dlU�g � �¬�2� #�� �L��M�[�MOPhJmPh^_MQ�6Kl^ MOW*P�ghUq\�\OP ��OZ{Uq^*R�Kl^*k ����� I*dlU�g ���hÕ3Ö�^�[]^[�dlUqkqU]G*���OgS\OKfZ�M6Kl�¡kqPS^*Ph\O[�MQPSR?a|Uq\U>)�O[]IÆPSdldfP]Õ

;ËW*Ph^ ���������cI�dlU�g ���6[]\�P�JLUq\�P�ghU]JLZ*dfKlgh[�MQPSR MQW[]^yMQW�Uq�OP�Kl^ MOW*PY×�[0VHUq�6gi[��OP���MOG*R�sqv*MOW*P���UqIyU]aMQW�P"Z*\OU�U]a��OgS\OKlZHM`kqPh^*PS\Q[�MOUq\¡Kl�pghUq\�\OPh��ZÆU]^*R*Kl^�kqdfsLJLU]\OP"ghU]JLZ*dfKlgh[�MQPSR�Õ FUq\�PXV�[]JLZ�dlP]vHMQW*P"kqPS^*Ph\O[�MQU]\J¾G*��M�P VHZ[]^*R°[ � ���3PS^�MO\�s�Kf^YMOW*P ����������I*dlU�g ��MOW[�M�ghU]^�MQ[]Kl^��~[`�OPS��G*Ph^*gSP�U]aHghUq^�R*KfMOKlUq^[�dq��MQ[�MQPSJLPS^�MO��OG�g�WÊ[]�

� 9 Y � ����� ��� �y�JY�������� ��� �,�] �� 9&] � ����� ��� �y�u�������� ��� �,��� �

Kl^_MOUmU]^*P"MQW[�M`gSUq^_M�[]Kf^*�`^*Ph��MQPSRoghU]^*R*KfMOKlUq^*[]dl���OG*g�Wo[]�� 9 Y � ������ 9&] � ����� �� �y�JY ��� �y�u�������� ��� �y�JY ��� � ��� �

�������� 9&] � ����� �� �y�] ��� �y�u�������� ��� �y�] ��� � ��� �

Kl^yUq\�R*Ph\¡MOUmk]Ph^*PS\Q[�MOP�MOW*PY[]Z*Z*\�UqZ*\�Kz[�MOP"gi[]��PY��Z*dlKNMQ�¡Kf^yMOW*P�Z*\OU�U]a��OgS\OKfZ�MiÕA�G*\LMOPhg�W*^*Kf��G*Ph�TR*U�^*U]M ghUqJmZ*dlP�MQPSdfs�PhdfKlJmKl^[�MQP MQW�Po^*PSPhR a|Uq\mW�G*J [�^ kqG*KfR[]^*gSP�Kf^.Z*\�U�Ó�Kf^*k

Kl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MQ� []^*RË�OKfJ¾G*dz[�MQKlU]^.\OPSdz[�MOKlUq^��hÕ FHUqJmPÊMQ\O[]^*�OKNMQKfUq^*�LMOW[�MyW[iÓ]P½gSUqJmZ*dlPXV ��PhJL[]^_MQKlgS�TJ [is^*PSPhRTMQW*P�ghKfMQ[�MQKfUq^ U�a~��ZÆPSghKN}g�Kl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MQ�4!|MOW[�M¡W[iÓ]P�[]dl\�Pi[]R�smI{PhPS^?Z�\OU©ÓqPSR6$�ÕQ;�P�R*UV^*U]MpsqPSM`W*[©Ó]P[oJmPSMOW*UHR�UqdlUqk�sÊa|Uq\°g�W�UHUq��Kl^*k !`W*Klg�WÇKf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MO�YMOUÊghKNMQP�Õ Ò W*PS\OP JL[is�[]dl��UoI{P U]MQW�Ph\°gh[]�OP �OZ*dfKfMQ�MQW*[�M6[]\OP�^*U�M`JLPS^�MOKlUq^�PhR?Kl^ MQW�P+ �������TI*dlU�g ��Õ ;�P�R*UÉ^*U]M¡s]PSM�ghUq^*��KlR*PS\¡MQW*PS�OPY�OZ*dfKfMQ�SÕ

��� \Od � v©P�M�[�d�Õ � � n�X � w_t ��W[iÓqP�[�dl�OU`JL[]^�G[]dfdfs�Z{Ph\�a|Uq\OJmPhR�MQW�Pp[]I{U©ÓqP(Z*\OU�ghPS�O�~Kl^YÜ�×ÊUq^°X�K � ����MQ\O[�¬�J¾G�MOG[]djPXV�gSdlG*��KlUq^o[]dlk]Uq\OKNMQW*J?Õ Ò W*P°R*K =<PS\OPS^*ghPJ!`KfMOWoUqG*\`JmPSMOW*UHR�Kl�¡MQW*[�M6UqG*\`MQU�Uqdl�`^*U�! Z{Ph\�a|Uq\OJMQW�P�MO\Q[]^��Odz[�MQKlU]^y[]G�MQU]J [�MOKlgh[]dldNsVa|\OUqJ MQW*P4 ��� ���TI*dfUHg ��Õ

� �� ��� � � � � � ����

Ò W*P½J [�Kl^ËR*\Q[ !`I[�g �'U�a¾UqG*\yJmPSMOW*UHR'Kl� MOW[�M?W�G*JL[]^ÌKf^�MOPh\�ÓqPh^_MOKlUq^'Kl�y��MOKldfd�^*PhgSPh���Q[]\�sÌKf^ËM !�UKlJmZ{Uq\�MQ[]^_MjZ*dz[�ghPh�SÕ F�Kf\O��Miv�MQW*P3\OKfkqW_M�Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�j^*PSPhR°MOU�I{P3�OPhdfPhg�MQPhR«MQU6G*�OP(Kl^�ÓqPS\OKf}*gi[�MOKlUq^�Õ�FHPSghUq^*R<v!`W*PS^�MQW�PYZ�\OU©ÓqPS\6gh[]^*^*U�M�JL[���PYZ�\OU�ghPh���hvMQW�PYG��OPh\`W[��`MOULPS^_MQPh\¡MQ[]gSMOKlgh�¡MOUmgSUqJmZ*dlP�MQP"Z*\�UHU]a|�SÕ

Û�P�ÓqPh\�MQW*PSdlPS�O�hv�UqG�\�JmPSMQW�UHR*U]dlUqk]s��Q[�MOKl��}*Ph�~}�ÓqP¡R*PS�OKl\O[]I*dfP�Z*\�UqZ{Ph\�MOKlPS��a|Uq\�[6Ó]Ph\OKN}gi[�MQKlU]^°JmPSMQW�UHR�Ô

� �0R���'��.�, .7- � ���0+ -/( �����8� � � � �B�9���0')���� .')1 1 A"G�\�JmPSMOW*UHR�G*�OPS� >@?BA []GHMQUqJL[�M�[Va|Uq\`a|Uq\OJL[]dJmUHR*PSdlKf^*kV[]^*R�[¾MQW*PSUq\OPSJ Z*\OU©Ó]Ph\hv5!`W*U]�OPYUqG�MQZ�G�M6Kl�`[VdlUqk]Klgi[�dldfsVÓ]Ph\�Kf}�[]I�dlP�Z*\OU�U]a�Õ Ò W*P�JmPSMOW*UHRyKf�MQW�G*�6�OU]G*^*R�Õ

xqx

Page 34: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Z&- ���0R��* .73')�����9�01��8���,��6�( S A"G�\YJmPSMOW*U�R�PXV�PSghG�MOPh�V[�^*R�MOPh��MO�«MOW*PLZ�\OUqkq\O[]J I{PSa|Uq\�PmMOW*PmZ*\OU �kq\O[]JLJmPh\�W[]�eMQU�Kl^_Ó]Ph��M3MOKlJmP�Kl^Va|Uq\�J []d�ÓqPS\OKf}*gi[�MOKlUq^�Õ�bWV�PSghG�MOKlUq^mKl�ca£[���M([]^*R<v�gSUqJmZ[]\OPSRVMQU"a|Uq\OJL[]dÓqPS\OKN}gi[�MOKlUq^<vHPh[]��sLa|Uq\�MOW*P�Z*\�Uqkq\Q[�JLJmPh\3MQU¾Z{Ph\�a|Uq\OJ?Õ Ò Ph��MQ�¡gh[]^T\OP�ÓqPi[�d�R*PSÓ�Kl[�MQKfUq^*��a|\�UqJ+P VHZ{PhgSMOPhRI{PhW[iÓ�KlUq\SÕ3X�s�^[]JmKlg�Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M`R*P�MQPSgSMQKfUq^ygi[]^�[]df�OUÉ\OP�ÓqPi[�d���G*g�WoPS\O\�Uq^*PhU]G*�`IÆPSW[iÓHKfUq\hÕ

� ����6��* .7 �� -5(*( ���,1\� � � ���.��')� -5(*79�9�0����R�+1 Ò W*P >@?BA [�G�MQUqJL[�MOUq^TJLU�R*PSdjgi[]^?IÆP�G*��PhR?a|Uq\`[dz[�\OkqP�Ó�[]\�KlPSM)s¾U]aj[]��s�^*g�W*\OU]^*UqG*����s���MOPhJm� �¬Ù�Uqd`Gqwq[�v�Ü�sH^/GBI ��Õ *�sV\OPh[]�OU]^*Kl^*kYUq^mJ [�MQW*PSJ [�MOKlgh[]d�a£[]g�MQ�hvMQW�PhUq\�PhJ Z�\OU©ÓqPS\O�?gi[]^ËW[]^�R*dlPÊKf^�}^*KNMQPÊ��M�[�MOP]v�^*Uq^*R*P�MQPS\OJmKl^*Kf��MQKfgo��sH��MQPSJL�SÕ X�s�^[]JmKlgoKf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MR*P�MQPhg�MQKfUq^Tgi[]^?[]df�OU¾W*[]^*R*dfP"�OG*g�Wy��s���MQPhJm�hÕ Ò W�G*�"!`KfMOWTUqG*\pMOUHUqdf�hvQ!pP�gh[]^ ÓqPS\OKfaÈs []^_s ��sH��MQPSJ MQW[�Mgi[�^�I{P�JLU�R*PhdfPhRy[]�6[]^ >@?BA []G�MQU]J [�MOUq^�Õ

� ')�����_�* �7 ��R.' �����979��-5++ 'Q�K'�� �9���K�, � �9�0+ -5(���')�0��� �B- ���*�� Ö���[ gSUq^*��Ph��G*Ph^�ghPÉU]acMOW*PhKf\kqPS^*Ph\O[]dlKNM)sqv�MOW*PhUq\�PhJ%Z*\OU©ÓqPS\O�ÉW[iÓqP MO\Q[]R�KfMQKfUq^[]dfdfsA\�Ph��G*Kf\OPhRÇ��Klkq^�Kf}gh[]^_M¾W�G*JL[]^ÇKl^_MQPS\Q[]g�MQKfUq^ !£KEÕ�P�ÕfvZ*\�Uqkq\Q[�JLJmPh\ PH=<U]\�M?Kl^ËÓqPS\OKf}*gi[�MOKlUq^6$�Õ A�G*\yJmPSMOW*UHRË\�PhR*G*gSPh�?MQW*Kf�?W�G*JL[]^'PS=ÆUq\�M?Kf^1G*��Kl^*k�MQW�PZ*\�U�Ó]Ph\`MQW*\�UqG*kqW?[]���OKf��M�[�^*ghPJ!`KfMOW?dfPhJmJ [��¡[]^*RTM�[�gSMQKfgh�SÕ

% �0� �.�*���* �7 �, �1 ��7�R^� � �9���R�' �����97���-5+ + 'Q�� FHUqJmPTU]a6MQW*PyKl^��OKlk]W�M¾��MQPSJL�Va|\�UqJ MQW�P?\�Ph��G*dfMO�U]a�R�s�^[]JmKlg�Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M�R*P�MQPhg�MQKfUq^�v !`W*Kfg�WyJ [isLUqG�MQZ�G�M`G*�OP�a|G*djZ*\�UqZÆPS\�MOKlPh��MQW[�M¡[]\OP"^*U�M¡^*PhgSPh���Q[]\�KldfsG*��PhRÉKl^°[�Z[]\�MOKlgSG*dz[]\�gSUq\O\�PhgSMO^*Ph���3Z*\OU�U]a�Õ�r�Uq\OPpKl^*��KlkqW_McKf�c[]g�W�KlPSÓ]PhRÉI{Phgi[�G*�OP¡UqG�\�JmPSMQW�UHR¾Z�\OU�R*G*ghPS�[V�OP�M�U]a�a£[]g�MQ�6[]^*RTMQW�PhKl\¡Z�\OU�U]a|�hÕ

x�<

Page 35: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� ��������� � ��� � � � ��� � � � ����%������Y � �CL&%�����!L&%����KWM�?�[�M� ��������ED ����%��J��� Y[WM�?�[�M�R���������3L&%����KW ���%��%J����� D ����%��J��� Y[W����%��J%����&�n3L&%����KW5�������S����� D ����%��J��� Y[W5���J���S����� 3L&%����KW5:&�������� D ����%��J��� Y[W5:&�������� 3�b�F!�����S>��"+e� �bL&%����UWM�?(�%������ �

�A�T! #��&���%��4+5� � ���&%��J����Y2W?�M>R�&����������� 3 ����%��J��� Y[W����&�dx{�Jz D �?;�����F+ �g1v1&1� � � � � � �� � � BL�%�����WM�?�[�M� ��������T!$a���� x O�%�&��zC! D ���&%�������Y[WS�?�R�S� ������&� L�%�����W����%���%J���&�d! a���Tx�����S>��JzC! D ���&%�������Y[W5���%��%J����� L�%�����W?�?(�%������~!$a����x�����S>��Jz ! D � � L�%�����We���J���S�����F!$a���� x O�%�&��z ! D ���&%�������Y[W5�������S���&� L�%�����We:&��������X!$a����x O�%��&��z ! D ���&%�������Y[W5:��������

� � � � � � � � �v�S������T+eaF!$a&����x O�%�&�JzU��#q!$a���� x #��&�&�%��2zJ1*�?)��%��� � � � � � �l�k� �M�d+?��! O�%�&�F� ��!���&�S>��g1 � � ��� � � � � �c�k� �?�d+k�p� �[1 � � � � � � � ��:&�����U+?��! O�%�&�[1 � � ��� � � � � �*:&�����p+?��1 � � � � � � � � � �v�&���&�M���F+k��! O�%���F� ��!�����S>��21 � � ��� � � � � � � �v�����&�M�&�T+k�p���21 � � � � � � � � � � �E; ������#J���&�&%�U+�� ! #��&�&�%��p1N�?)��%��� � � � � � � � � � ��� �������?�U+M�p! O�%�&�F��# ! a����Tx�#��&���%�[zJ1N�?)��%��� � � � � � � � � � ��%����K+k��! O�%���F��� ! #��&���%��U1*�?)��%��� � � � � � � � � � ���&���M)&������g+ �q! #��&���%��<� �T!���&�S>��g1 � � _�+ � � ����%��J��� Y[Wk�M>R�&�����������R1 � � � ��?)��%��

� � ��� �o� ! #��&�&�%��h+�� � ����%������Y[W?�S> �����&�&���&�n3 ���&%�������Y[W �����dx{�Jz��DQ�R���J1� � � � �?)���%���

���������� � � � � � � � �m�S(�%�%���������g+��R1

� � � � � � � � � � � �A�?�����&��������J���S���U+ �q! #��&����%��p1 � � +5� � ����%������Y[W?�S> �����&�&���&� 1 � ������?)��%��

� � ��� +����%������Y[W������Kx ��zEDQ� ���R1 � � � ��?)��%��

� � ��� �o� ! #��&�&�%��h+�� � ����%������Y[W?�S> �����&�&���&�n3 ���&%�������Y[W �����dx{�Jz��DQ�R���J1� � � � �?)���%���

���������� � � � � � � � �m�S(�%�%���������g+ ���&%��J����Y2W ���&�dx{��z�W����&��1

� � �

F�Klk]G*\OP�x ��tHÔeÖ� ��� ���TI*dfUHg �LU]ae[¾a|Uq\@!�[�\OR?�OKlJ°G*dz[�MOKlUq^L\OPSdz[�MOKlUq^�Õ

x_D

Page 36: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

+����S�����&���� ���M�R��%�� �&1��(���%��M; �?��� ������� � ���J�M��%���T!� � � � � ������ !��&������M(J������� L&���?(��I�SL&���?(�� ��������RYU!����?�&�=��L&���?(������������]�!���������J�&�M; �������%�: L����?(��I�SL����?(���++k��J�M�J%����m�*21�1 �

�M(�%�P�� � �k�&�,+S��:&:�������� �&%�: L&���M(��I�SL&���M(��T++Z����S��%����o��g1&1�1 ����������y+��k������&�l�����RY���]R1���������y+���-;J���&���&�*�����! �?���������: L��J�M(��������: L��J�M(J� �������J���S; ���� �����&:

L��J�M(������&:&:��J�S������&: L��J�M(J� �����������KW ; ����� ������:�1���������y+S��>&��%���1

��%����

+��v'(�� ��� � � � � �=�M�����"��%�����S� ��%��=�?�����&��: �&1��(���%��M; �?��� ������� � !� � � � � ������ !��&������M(J������� L&���?(��I�SL&���?(�� ��������RYU! � �k�&�I�SL&���M(�� ���������]�!���������J�&�M; �������%�: L����?(��I�SL����?(��t��L&���?(����

�M(�%�P�� � �k�&�,+S��:&:�������� �&%�: L&���M(��I�SL&���M(��t�L&���?(��g1$����������y+��k������&�l�����RY���]R1���������y+��������� �L&���M(��21���������y+�&�e;��t�����! �?��� ������� � �J�?����%�����1���������y+�&�e;��t�����! �?��� ������� � ���J�M��%���[1���������y+�&�e;��t�����! �?��� ������� � �������R1���������y+�&�e;��t�����! �?��� ������� � ��P�R�M��� 1���������y+�&�e;��t�����! �?��� ������� � ����%���[1���������y+�&�e;��t�����! �?��� ������� � �����%��21

��%����

+��oj�> � �������&�����%�%:�� �&1��(���%��M; �?��� ���M����� �������F!

� ��� � �� � � � L&���M(����k�&� ����������y+?>���I�?������ ������ �&1���������y+���-;J���&���&�*�����! �?������������� �?������������R��1

��%����

��(���%��M; �?��� ����&�J�M(���J�&�K!��������S(�������� L&���M(��I�SL&���M(��nD-. �k�&�I�SL&���?(�� ����������y+��k������&� �M�������?������ ������R1���������y+S��>&��%I�k�&�&�% !n�M����� ������� �������S(�������� 1

��%���������

F�KfkqG*\OP�x ��x�Ô3FH[]JLZ�dlP"UqG�MOZ*G�M6U]a�MQW*P�Z*\�UHU�a�MQ[]gSMOKlgS�6k]Ph^*PS\Q[�MOPhRya|Uq\¡Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M¡Z*\�UHU]a|�`Kf^K>)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP]Õ

xBI

Page 37: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� � ��� ��� �

� � � � � � � �

Ò W*Kf� g�W[]ZHMQPh\ R*Ph��gh\OKfIÆPS� MQW�\OPhP�gi[]��PÊ��MOG*R*KfPh� MOW[�M !pPS\OPAG*��PhR MQU½MQPS��MTUqG�\LJmPSMOW*UHR�UqdlUqk�sÇU]a�G*� �Kl^�k R�s�^[]JmKlgYKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M�R*PSMOPhgSMOKlUq^Ê[]^*RÊJmUHR�Phd �¹�OZ{PhgSKf}g�Kl^��OKlk]W�MO��MOU JmUq\OPYP $mghKfPh^_MQdNsoZ�\OU©ÓqP¾�O[�a|PSM)sZ*\�UqZÆPS\�MOKlPh�¡Kf^?[ÉMOW*PhUq\�PhJ Z�\OU©ÓqPS\hÕ

� ×�PSMQPS\O��Uq^ �¬�cJ¾G�MOG[]d_P VHgSdlG*��KlUq^«[]dlk]Uq\OKNMQW*J?Õ Ò W*Kl��Kf�~[6dlU�g �]UqGHM �¹a|\�PhP3KlJmZ*dfPhJmPh^_M�[�MOKlUq^�U]a*J¾GHMQG[]dPXV�gSdlG*��KlUq^Ta|Uq\�M !�U Z�\OU�ghPh���OPS��G*��Kl^*km�OW*[]\OPSR�JmPhJmUq\�s]v*Z*\�U�Ó]Ph^�I�s Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_M`[]�O��Ph\�MQKlU]^*�hÕ

� Ö�^ []dfkqUq\OKNMQW*JCMQW[�M KfJLZ*dfPhJmPh^_MQ�m[�MOUqJmKlgy�OW[�\OPhR.JLPSJLUq\�s�MQW�\OUqG*k]W.R*Kf��MQ\�KlI*GHMQPhR-gi[]g�W�Kl^*k*vR*\O[ !`^°a|\OUqJ *pU]kqR[]^*U©Ó �¬�3r�Õ�b3^�k*Õ~MOW*Ph��Kl� � *pUqkqwqw �EÕ Ò W*P�KlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^�MQ[�MQKfUq^�U]a��W[]\OPSRVJLPSJLU]\�sKf�¡Z*\OU©ÓqPS^ogSUq\O\�PhgSM6I_sy�OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^ \�Phdz[�MQKlU]^�Õ

� Ü�[]JmZÆU]\�M �¬��×~[0VHUq��Z*\OU�MQU�ghUqdEv�[]� !`\�KfM�MQPh^AKf^[>@A6Ö I_sAX�P¾×3\�Kl��ghU*v�P�MY[]d�Õ � X"×(Ü�F � w_t �EÕ°×~[0VHUq�KfJLZ*dfPhJmPh^_MQ�ÉgSUq^*�OPS^*�OG��TG*�OKf^*k�[½I[]dldfU]Mm[]^*R.��G�Uq\OG*J ��sH��MQPSJ�v6[]^*R-Kl�mZ*\OU©Ó]PhR ghU]\O\OPSgSM I�s��G*ghgSPh�O��KfÓ]P°\OP�}^*PSJLPS^�MhÕ

� ��� / � � �� � �� � � �,�� � � � � ��� ����� � ����� � � �

Ò W*Pm×~P�MQPS\O�OU]^�M !�U �)Z*\�UHgSPh���«J¾GHMQG[]d~P VHghdfG*�OKfUq^�[]dlkqU]\OKfMOW*J��¬×�PSM C�u �3[]g�W�KlPSÓ]Ph�YdlU�g �]UqGHM �¹a|\�PhPVJ¾GHMQG[]dP VHgSdlG*��KlUq^-G*�OKf^*kÁJ¾G�dfMQK � !`\�KfMQPS\hv3J¾G*dNMQK �)\OPh[]R*PS\hv(\OPi[�R�� !`\�KfMQPy��W[]\OPSR JmPhJmUq\�s]Õ Ò W*PÊ[�dlkqUq\�KfMOW*J !�PZ*\�Ph�OPS^_MyW*Ph\�PÊKl�LR*Ph��Klkq^*PSR a|Uq\LM !�UÇZ*\�UHgSPh�O��Ph�Sv�I*GHM MQW*PÊ[]dlkqU]\OKfMOW*J gh[]^ I{PÊ��MQ[]kqPhR.Kl^ [ !|�OKf^*kqdlPPhdfKlJmKl^[�MQKlU]^6$�MQUqG*\�^[]JmPh^_M`MQUÉ�OG�Z*ZÆU]\�M6JLU]\OP"Z*\�UHgSPh�O��Ph�SÕ

Ò W*Ph\�PÊ[]\�PTMQW*\�PhPTÓ�[]\OKl[]I*dlPS�VKl^ÇMQW�Po[]dfkqUq\�KfMQW�J�Ô��� ��� # v��� ��� $ [�^*R �(� %Õ F�Klk]G*\OPK< �Quy�OW*U�!`�MQW�P°��MQ[�MQP �¹MO\Q[]^*��KfMOKlUq^?R*Kz[�kq\Q[]J�a|Uq\�[m�OKf^*kqdlP�Z*\�UHgSPh���hÕ Ò W�P¾[]dfkqUq\OKNMQW*J UqZÆPS\Q[�MOPh��[]�6a|U]dldlU�!`�SÕ`beÓ]Ph\�sZ*\�UHgSPh�O�2��OPSMO� � & � ���G �yMQULMO\OG*P�v{MOW*Ph^o�OPSMO� �� � ,�MOU KNMQ�OPSdfa�Õ"F\�UqJ MQW�Ph^ÊUq^<vÆPh[]g�WÊZ*\�UHgSPh�O��g�W*Phg ���MQW�PmU�MQW*PS\��¬�7� & � � []^*R ���� ,ÆÕ >¹a�PSKfMQW�Ph\�MQW�PmU�MQW*PS\YZ�\OU�ghPh�����¬� � & � �ÊKl�"U>= ! ��������� � & � � $�v~Uq\"Kfa(MQW�PMQG�\O^ Ó�[]\OKl[]I*dfP�Z{UqKl^_MQ�(MQU¾MOW*P�U]MOW*Ph\�Z�\OU�ghPh��� ! ������������ � ,�$�v*MQW*P�}\���M¡Z�\OU�ghPh���`Kl��[�dldlU�!�PhR MOUVkqUVKl^_MOUMQW�P¾gh\�KfMQKfgi[]dj��Phg�MQKlU]^�Õ Ò W*P¾gS\OKNMQKlgh[]dj\OPSkqKlU]^ÊghUq^��OKl��MQ��U]aeMQW*P°��M�[�MQPh��Kl^ !`W�Klg�WÊMQW�P°Z*\�Uqkq\Q[�J gSUqG*^_MQPS\W[]�¡MOW*P"Ó][�dlG*P ��� # # �>� & �TU]\4��� # # � � &�) Õ

F�Klk]G*\OPK< ��tokqKfÓ]Ph�VMQW�P >@A`ÖÐghU�R*PTa|Uq\¾MQW*Kf�É[]dlk]Uq\OKNMQW*J?vW!`W*Kfg�W !�P�Z�\OU©ÓqPSR.ghU]\O\OPSgSM !`KfMOW�IÆU]MOWÜ�× [�^*R>)�Q[�IÆPSdldlPLG*�OKf^*kÊUq^�dfs½Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�YR*Kl��ghU©ÓqPS\OPSRÎI_s�X"[]K`��Uq^�ÕÊX"[�K`�]U]^ÁR*P�MQPhg�MQPSR�MOW*P J¾GHMQG[]dP VHgSdlG*��KlUq^?Z*\OU]ZÆPS\�M)s MOW[�M"!p[]�6MOW*P"}^[]djk]U_[]d�v�[]dlU]^*k4!`KfMOWyM !�UmKl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�¡\OPS��G*Kl\�PhRya|Uq\¡KfMO�¡Z*\OU�U]a�Õ

x_;

Page 38: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

F�KlkqG�\OP < �QuqÔ3F�MQ[�MQP �¹MQ\O[]^*��KfMQKfUq^TR*Kl[]kq\Q[�J a|Uq\¡U]^*P�Z*\OU�ghPS�O�6Kl^TMQW*PY×�PSMQPS\O��Uq^Ê[]dfkqUq\�KfMQW�J�Õ

Ò W*P«×~PSMOPh\��OUq^ >@A6Ö5Z*\�Uqkq\Q[�J !p[]�`�Og�W*PSR*G*dlPSR�a|Uq\¡PXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^�G*��Kl^*kÉ\O[]^*R*UqJ��Og�W*PSR*G*dfKl^*k*Õ Ò W[�MKl�Sv�MOW*Pm�Og�W*PSR*G*dlPS\¾�OPSdlPSgSMQPSR�Uq^*PmU]a�MQW*PmM !pU�Z*\OU�ghPS�O�OPS�V[�M«\Q[]^�R*UqJ []^*RÁ[]R�Ó�[]^*gSPhR�KNMQ����MQ[�MQP�v�KNa�KfM!p[]��Z{Uq���OKlI�dlP]Õ Ò W*P&>@A`Ö5Z*\OUqk]\Q[]J !�[]�6\OG�^ya|U]\ D]wqwqw¾MQ\O[]^*��KfMQKfUq^*�SÕ

Ò W*Kl�eKf�c[�kqU�U�R¾�OG*I ��PhgSM3a|Uq\c[�gi[]��P¡��MQG�R�s¾I{Phgh[]G*�OP`J¾GHMQG[]d�P VHgSdlG*��KlUq^m[]dfkqUq\OKNMQW*Jm��gi[]^VI{P¡�OG�I�MQdfP[]^*RyMQPS��MOKl^*kVMQW�PhJ Kf�¡\Q[]\�Phdfs �OG $mgSKlPh^_MhÕ >)^ >@A6Ö«vJ¾G�MQG*[]d�P VHgSdlG*��KlUq^yKl�¡PXVHZ*\OPS�O�OPSR []��MQW�PYKf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�MMQW*[�M !`W*PS^ÊUq^*P°[]G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^�Kl�6Kl^�MOW*P°��PSM"U�ae��MQ[�MQPS��R*Ph��Klkq^*[�MQPSRA[]��MOW*P°gS\OKNMQKlgh[]dj\OPSkqKlU]^�v{MOW*P°U�MQW*PS\[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^TKf�¡^*U]MhÕ

� !# "!# �o��������H�p� �����e2e����23�p��� #"���*��4<����#% �0 �Ì23� %(�p�;�PY^�U�!ÌR*Ph��gh\�KlI{P«X"[�K`�]U]^ ���`UqGHMQZ*G�M"!`W�Ph^ok]KfÓqPS^?MOW*PY×~P�MQPh\��OUq^�P VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^*�SÕ

A�^¾[]^«Kl^*KNMQKz[�d]\OG�^°U©ÓqPS\~MQW�Pp×�PSMQPS\O��Uq^VP VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^*�Sv_X"[]K`��Uq^�\OPSZÆUq\�MQPSR°MQW[�M�MOW*P(J¾G�MQG*[]d�P VHghdfG*�OKfUq^Z*\�UqZÆPS\�M)s R�KlRË^*U]M?[]g�MQG[�dldfs-W*UqdfR�v`a|Uq\ !�P�W[�R'JL[]R*P [�^'PS\O\�Uq\TKl^3!`\OKNMQKf^*kÁMQW�P >@A`Ö ghU�R*P]ÔÇKf^UqG*\YKl^�KfMQKl[]d�KfJLZ�dlPhJmPh^_MQ[�MQKfUq^�v�Ph[]g�W�Z*\�UHgSPh�O�«�OP�M¾KfMO� � � ,½Ó�[]\OKl[]I*dlPV}\���Mhv~MQW�Ph^ÁKNMQ�7� & � �AÓ�[]\OKl[]I*dfP]ÕÚ`G*^*^*Kf^*kÁX"[�K`�]U]^-KfJLJmPhR*Kl[�MQPSdfs½\OP�ÓqPh[]dlPSR-MQW�Kl�mPh\O\�Uq\hÕ ;ÁP?ghU]G*dlR-[]dl��U�W*[©Ó]PoR*P�MQPSgSMQPSR.MQW�P�PS\O\OU]\R*G*\�Kl^*k¾MOW*PhU]\OPhJ�Z*\OU©Ó�Kl^�k*v*I*G�M6[�k_[]Kl^<vHKNM !�[���a£[]��MOPh\hv�Pi[]��KlPh\Sv[]^*RyJmUq\OP�ghUq^_Ó]Ph^*KfPh^_M�MOUV^*U]MOKlghP�KfM¡Kf^X"[]KN�]Uq^ �¬�¡�OG�JLJL[]\OKNMi[�MOKlUq^ U]a~MOW*P�\OG*^_MOKlJmP"Z*\OUqZ{Ph\�MQKfPh�hÕ

Ö�aÈMOPh\¡ghU]\O\OPSgSMOKl^*k°MOW*P"Z*\�UqI*dlPSJ�vQ!�PY\�Ph\O[]^ MQW*P >@A`Ö5FHKfJ¾G*dz[�MQUq\�[]^*RyX"[]KN�]Uq^<ÕeX"[]K`��Uq^T\OPSZÆU]\�MQPSRMQW�PYJ°G�MQG[�d<P VHgSdlG*��KlUq^?Z*\OU]ZÆPS\�M)sqv^*[]JLPSdfs]vHMQW*[�M`^*UVM !pUmZ*\�UHgSPh�O��Ph�6J [is �OKlJ°G*dfMQ[]^*PhU]G*�OdNs I{P"Kl^TMQW�Pgh\�KfMOKlgi[�d<\OPSkqKlU]^�Õ3bWV�Z�\OPh���OPSRÊKl^?Ü�×.��s�^_M�[�V<vMOW*Kl�¡Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M¡Kf�

�M������>������d!�J�Kx5��� �M��������zJ1 D4�� �M�R������ ��3C�����?���������D ���%���(��� �M�������6.�J��x-����%���(J� �M�������Jz �Df�SR�M�R��������Y

�J�Kx5��� �M��������zJ1 D4�� �M�R������ ��3C�����?���������D ���%���(��� �M�������6.�J��x-��� �M��������z��DQ�J�Kxe���%�&(��� �?��������z

�J�Kx5��� �M��������zJ1 D4�� �M�R�������Y 3C�����?���������D ���%���(��� �M�������6.�J��x-����%���(J� �M�������Jz �Df�SR�M�R������� �

�J�Kx5��� �M��������zJ1 D4�� �M�R�������Y 3C�����?���������D ���%���(��� �M�������6.�J��x-��� �M��������z��DQ�J�Kxe���%�&(��� �?��������z

X"[]K`��Uq^?[]dl��UÉ\OPhZ{Uq\�MQPhRyM !�ULdfPhJmJ []�p^*PhPSR*PhR?MQUÉZ*\OU©Ó]PYMOW*Kl�¡Z*\�UqZ{Ph\�M)s{Ô�k����jT!���"+e�J�Kx{�JzED"��&� �M��)2Y��c�J��x{�JzED,�&&�R�?��)�]

�c�J��x{�JzEDf�S �S� �&����� ���c�J��x{��z Df�SR�M� �&������Y

xBC

Page 39: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

��'�(�����l����*�P�%N���%�����&���� �$���?;����N���������*�RYgW�5B � �b9&�%��S'����J� D ��� � � � ��� � ��� � ���F� �RY�A9�LI�M���������N:&%�����%)&��M;"��%�>������dW�5B � �b9&L'�������D ��� � � � ��� � ��� � P����M�R�?��) �U� ��&�R�?��) ��� �&&�R�?��)[Y �

�&&�R�?��)�]U���S �S� �&����� ��� �SR�M� �&������Y

� � � � � � � ���,9��������%��� �� � � � � � �� � � � � � ������k��)�+ ��!59&�%��S'����J��1 � � � � � � ���������&GJ���)�+ �T!e9&�%J�S'������ 1[� �����'�>����+ ��!�9��%���'&�&��� 1R�

�M(��J����G�����)U+ � !�9&�%���'&���J�R1[���S(���� �&'&>���K+ � !�9&�%J�S'������J1� � � � � ���S �S� �&����� + � !�9&�%J�S'������R1[�E������&�J��� + �T!59��%J�S'&�&����1

� � � ��� ��ojN���%)���S;Q��%>&�����������*�J%&%����&���:���)b:&%l�����?(l���%J���J�&�o���� ��������l�Z�t����������%�:N��������j������qx jd� # zU�$P�( ���?(=����I�?�����������o��� �����J�*%�:N�&�����ojb�����=��%�����J�?�R�������M;R�������o%�:�������A#�W�J�"! j������Xx 9��%J�S'&�&���K� 9&L'&����RzQ! D �%�� ��������U+ePJ�J�M�R�?��) � 1R�:�����)f! j������qx�9��%J�S'&�&�����$#�%�%&�JzQ! D �%�� ��������U+Z:&�������21R��>�� ! 9&�%J�S'������

� ��� � � � � � �� � � � � � ������k��)�+ �[1� � �N�J��x{��z D"P����M� �M��) �� � �J��x{� zQ! D"��&� �M��) �

� � � � � � �o�����G��&�)p+��R1� � �N�J��x{��z D,�&�� �?��) �� � �J��x{� zQ! D"��&� �M��)2Y :�����)qx � zQ! D"�&>��

� � � � � � �o�����'�>���U+��R1� � �N�J��x{��z D,�&�� �?��)[Y� � �J��x{� zQ! D"��&� �M��)�] $�>��f! D=�

� � � � � � �o�M(��J����'�>�&��+ �21� � �N�J��x{��z D,�&�� �?��)�]� � ��>&� �D=� � � � �,�J��x{� zQ! D �� �M�R������ �

� � � � � � �o�M(��J����G�����)U+ �21� � �N�J��x{��z D,�&�� �?��)�]� � _g:����)y+ � �nDC��� � �����C�RY �������l���R1 � �����"�J�Kx � zQ! Df�S �S� �&����� � �

� � � � � ���S �S� �&�����=+5�R1� � �N�J��x{��z Df�SR�M� �&����� �� � �J��x{� zQ! Df�� �S� ������ Y

� � � � � � ����&�&�J���=+��21� � �N�J��x{��z Df�SR�M� �&������Y� � �J��x{� zQ! D"PJ�J�S� �?��) � :����) x �JzQ! Dy:&�&�����

F�KfkqG*\OPJ< ��tHÔ Ò W*P°×�PSMOPh\O��Uq^ÊM !�U �)Z*\�UHgSPh����J¾G�MOG[]d�P VHgSdlG*��KlUq^�[]dlk]Uq\OKNMQW*J�Kl^ >@A6Ö°ÕUFUq\`I*\�PSÓ�KfM)s]vMQW*Kf�}kqG�\OP�UqJmKfMQ��MQW*P��Og�W�PhR*G*dfKl^*kmghU�R*P"MQW*[�M`g�W*U�Uq�OPS��[]JmUq^*kVZ{Uq���OKlI�dlP"P VHPSghG�MOKlUq^*��[�M`\�G*^_MQKlJmP]Õ

xBG

Page 40: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

. :����)qx ��z�1

�k���#�!���"+e�J�Kx{�JzED"��&� �M��)�]r. �J��x �>�� z Dy�&�� �M��)�]J1

X"[]KN�]Uq^�P VHZ*\OPS�O��PhR MQW*PS�OP¾dfPhJmJ []��[]��[ �OP�M"U]ae��PhZ[]\O[�MQP«MQPh\�JL��I[]��PhRAUq^ÊPS^[]I*dfPhJmPh^_M�U�aeMQW*P«ghUq\ �\OPS�OZ{Uq^*R*Kf^*km[]gSMOKlUq^��hÔ

�����J���&� +������&GJ���)�+ � 1�17. :�����)qx ��z�����J���&� +������&'&>���K+ � 1�17. :�����)qx ��z�����J���&� +��M(J��� �&G��&�)U+��g1�17. :�����)qx ��z�����J���&� +��M(J��� �&'�>����+��g1�17. :�����)qx ��z�����J���&� +��SR�M�R�������g+ � 1&1s. :�����)qx ��z�����J���&� +Z������������p+ � 1�17. :�����)qx ��z

�����J���&� +��M(J��� �&G��&�)U+��g1�17. �J�Kx �>&� zED"��&�R�?��)�]�����J���&� +��M(J��� �&'�>����+��g1�17. �J�Kx �>&� zED"��&�R�?��)�]

Ò W*P6}\O��MpgSdz[]G*��P��O[isH�(MQW[�M !`W*PS^*PSÓ]Ph\pMOW*P ��� � ����� ��� MQ\O[]^*�OKNMQKfUq^ÉKl�3Ph^[�I*dlPSR Kl^L[«Z�\OU�ghPh���hvHKfMQ� �� ���Kl�¡MO\OG*P�Õ Ò W*Ph��P¾�OKfJLZ�dlP"ghU]^*R*KfMOKlUq^��`[]\OPY^*U]M6��MQ[�MQPSRÊKl^yMQW�P«gSUHR*P�v�I*G�M��OUqJmP�U]a�MOW*PhJ []\�P«[�Z*Z[]\�Ph^_Ma|\OU]J ��MQ[�MQKfg?Kf^*�OZ{Phg�MQKfUq^�Õ X"[�K`�]U]^.[]df�OU \OPSZÆU]\�MQPSR.��UqJLPyKf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MO�ÉMOW[�M !�Ph\OP�^*U]MmG*��PhR.a|Uq\ÉUqG�\Z*\�UHU]a�v�I*G�M6JLKfkqW_M¡I{PYG��OPSa|G�d�a|Uq\¡U]MQW�Ph\`Z*\OU�U]a|�SÕ A"^�PYPXV�[]JLZ�dlP"Kl�SÔ

�����J���&� +Z������������p+ � 1�17. :����) x �>&��z

FHPSgSMQKfUq^ C�ÕNu«R*Kf�OgSG*�O��Ph�6ZÆUq���OKfI*dlP�a|G�MOG*\OP�JmPSMOW*UHR��`MOUV}^*R?�OG*g�W?MQ\OG�PYI�G�M6^*U]M`G*��PSa|G*d�Kl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MQ�SÕ

� !# "!�� ������������ �o��������H�p� �����e2e����23�p���

;�P"G*�OPSR���%��¾[]^*R��&%��� °MOUVZ*\OU©Ó]P�MOW*P"J¾G�MOG[]d�PXVHghdlG��OKlU]^TZ*\OUqZ{Ph\�M)s��&%������������ !`KNMQWTI{U]MQW?Ü�×.[�^*R>)�Q[�IÆPSdldlP�Õ

;ËKfMOW >)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP]v_U]G*\cZ*\�U]MQU]M)s�Z{P`[]G�MOUqJ [�MQKlgh[]dldNs�kqPh^�Ph\Q[�MQPhRVMQ[]gSMOKlgh�cMOW[�M !�Ph\�P`�OG $mghKfPh^_M3MQU�Z*\�U�Ó]P�&%��� HÕ Ò W*PTMQ[]gSMOKlgh�°Z*\OU©ÓqPSR���%��oa|Uq\V[�dld(I*G�MVUq^�P MQ\Q[�^*�OKNMQKlU]^ ! ��� � ����� ��� $�Õ FUq\YMQW*Kf�°MQ\O[]^*��KfMQKfUq^�v!�P¾W[]RÊMOU �OG*Z�Z*dfs��OUqJmP°Z�\OU�ghPhR�G*\Q[]d~��MOPhZ*�"I_s�W[]^*R�vÆ\OPh[]�OUq^�Kl^*k I_sogi[]��PV[]^[]dNs��OKl�6R*PSZÆPS^*R*Kl^�kTUq^!`W*P�MQW*PS\eUq\c^*U]M � %��&%�' �������Õ FUq\��&%�������������v�MQW*P��O[]JmP !�[���MQ\�G*P�a|Uq\~M !�U�MQ\O[]^*��KfMQKfUq^*�Sv ��� � ����� ���[]^*R ��� � ����� � %HÕ*pPhgh[]G*��P�Ü�×Ádz[�g ���3Z*\�Uqkq\O[]JLJL[]I*dfPpM�[�gSMQKfgh�SvQ!�P6W[]RÉMQU��OG*Z�Z*dfsm[]dfd*Z*\�UHgSPhR*G*\O[]dKl^�Z*G�M(J [�^�G*[]dldNsqÕÒ W[�M6Z*\�UHU�a�v�MQU�U*v !�Ph^_M�MQW*\�UqG*kqWK!`KfMOW*UqG�M`R�K $mghG*dNM)sqÕ

Ö�^�Pi[]\�dlKlPS\`Z*\OU�U]acU�a�MQW�P¾[]dfkqUq\OKNMQW*J?v*[�dlUq^*k !`KNMQW >@A`Ö �¹��M)s�dlPYZ*�OPSG*R*U�ghU�R*P]v<[]Z*Z{Pi[]\���Kf^oÜ�s�^*g�W �¬�I{UHUB� � Ü�sH^/GBI �EÕ4;ÁP¾R�KlRÊ^*U�M�P V�[]JmKl^�P«MQW�P¾Z*�OPSG*R*U�ghU�R*PVUq\6MQW*P¾Z�\OU�U]a3G*^_MQKfd�[�aÈMOPh\�gSUqJmZ*dlP�MQKl^�kLUqG�\U�!`^ KlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^�MQ[�MQKfUq^?[]^*R Z*\�UHU]a�Õ Ò W*Kl�"Z*\�UHU�a([]dl��U G*�OPSRAM !pUTKf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MO�hÕ Ò W*P¾}\���M�Kf��UqG*\��&%�� �ÕÒ W*PY�OPSghUq^*RoKl�`dlKN�]P��&%���ÉI*GHM�PXV�Z�dlKlgSKfMOdfs JmPh^_MOKlUq^*��MOW*PYU]MQW*PS\�Z�\OU�ghPh����[�^*RoKf� !`\OKfM�MQPS^oKl^TMOPh\OJm�`U]aZ*\�Uqkq\Q[�J ghU]G*^_MQPh\��hÔ

�k���&LF!��� �N� ��+ � �D=� � 3

+5�J�Kx ��z Df�SR�M�R������� � �l�J�Kx ��zED4�� �M�R�������Y&1 3+5�J�Kx � � zED"��&�R�?��)�] �c�J�Kx{� � zED4�� �M�R������ �

�l�J�Kx{� �ZzED4�� �M�R�������Y1. �>&���DI� ��11

<_w

Page 41: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

>)^ÊUq\�R*Ph\`MQUmghUqJmZ[]\�PYMOW*P�M !pULZ[]Kl\���U�acKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MQ�Sv5!pP«ZÆPS\�a|Uq\�JLPSRo[É�OPSghUq^*R Ü�× Z*\�UHU�a�vG*�OKf^*k�&%����"Kl^���MQPh[]R U�a �&%���*Õ Ò W�Kl�(Z*\OU�U]a8!p[]�p��G*KNMQP6R*K =ÆPh\�Ph^_Miv�I*G�M !�[���[]I{UqG�M3MQW�P��Q[�JLP6dlPS^*k]MQWLKl^ÉMQPS\OJm�U]a�Ü�×ÇghUqJmJL[]^*R*�SÕ+*pU]MOWyÜ�×ÇZ*\�UHU�a|��MQU�UB�m[]I{UqG�M�MQW*P��O[]JmP�PS=ÆUq\�Miv�I�G�M�R*P�ÓqPSdlUqZ*JmPh^_M¡U�ajMQW*P�Z�\OU�U]aI[]��PhR�Uq^��&%���°W[]RyMQW�P«[�R�Ó�[]^_M�[]kqP�U]a~UqG*\`[�R*R*KfMOKlUq^*[]d<PXV�Z{Ph\�KlPS^*ghP�Õ

Ò W*P?Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MVZ*\OU]ZÆUq��PhRÎI_s�X"[]K`��Uq^�W[]�É�OP�ÓqPS\Q[]d6[]R�Ó�[]^_MQ[]kqPh�SÕ F�Kl\���Miv3KNM4!�[��LZ*\�U©ÓHKfR*PhR-[]G��MQU]J [�MOKlgh[]dldNsqve\OPS��G*Kl\�Kl^*k ^*U½G*�OPS\ PH=<Uq\�MmIÆP�sqUq^*R.Z*\OU©Ó�KlR*Kf^*kAMQPS��MLgi[]��Ph�hÕ'F�PhghU]^*R�v�KNM !�[]�L�OKfJLZ*dfPh\[]^*RÁPi[]��KlPh\�MQUoG*^*R*PS\O��MQ[]^*R�MOW[]^ÁMOW*P PXV�Z{Ph\�M �¹Z*\OU©Ó�KlR*PSR�Kl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MiÕ Ò W*Kf\OR�v~KfM«G*^*PXV�Z{Phg�MQPSR*dfsÁZ*\OU �Ó�KlR*PSRÊKl^��OKlk]W�MhvÆ\�PSÓ]Pi[]dfKl^*k Kf^_MQPh\�Ph��MQKl^�k Kl^Ha|Uq\OJL[�MQKfUq^?[]I{UqG�M�MOW*P¾\�Phdz[�MQKlU]^*�OW*KfZ�I{PSM !�PhPS^ �?[]^*R ��� %vKl^Ha|Uq\OJL[�MQKfUq^LMOW[�MU!�PYZ�G�M`MQUÉkqU�UHRyG*��PYKf^yUqG*\`Z*\OU�U]a�Õ

� � � � ��� � � � � � �� � �� � � � �� � � ��� � � � � ���

;�PT\OPhZ{Uq\�MVUq^�[]^*U�MQW*PS\¾gi[]��PT��MOG*R�sqv�[Ê��MO\OUq^�kAgi[]g�W*PTa|Uq\¾[�MQUqJmKlgm�OW*[]\OPSRÎJmPhJmUq\�sqv !`W*PS\OPTPSÓ]Ph\�sZ*\�UHgSPh�O��Uq\�W[��¡[°gi[�g�W*P"[]^*RLMQW*PS\OP�Kf��[°gSPh^_MQ\O[]d<��MQUq\�P]Õ3b3[]g�WTgi[�g�W*P"gi[]^ W[iÓqP�[«Ó�[]dfG*P�U]\pI{P�PhJmZ�M)s]ÕÒ W*PÉghU�R*P¾a|Uq\�MOW*Kl��[]dlkqU]\OKfMOW*JÐKl��I*[]�OPSR�Uq^ *pU]kqR[]^*U©Ó � *¡Ù�Ü�w_t �EvjI*G�M !�Pm[]^[]dNs MSP¾MQW*PÉ[�dlkqUq\�KfMOW*JR*K =<PS\OPh^_MOdfs a|\�UqJ W*Kf�¡Z*\OU�U]a�Õ

Ò W*P Z*\�UHU�a¡a|Uq\YMOW*Kl�°[]dlk]Uq\OKNMQW*J G��OPh�É[?a|Uq\ !p[]\ORÁ�OKlJ°G*dz[�MOKlUq^ \�Phdz[�MQKlU]^�Õ Ò W�P �OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^Ç[]G��MQU]J [�MOUq^�v������ !,F�KfkqG*\OP < ��x $�v�Z*\�U©ÓHKfR*Ph�¡MOW*P"R*PS}*^*KfMOKlUq^ a|Uq\�[�MQUqJmKlg��OW[�\OPhR?JmPhJmUq\�s]Õ Ò W*P���� &�& � ���R[�MQ[¾M)sHZ{PYgh\OPh[�MQPS��[ÉZ{UqKl^_MQPSRyR*UqJL[]Kl^ a|Uq\6[VkqKNÓqPh^?R[�MQ[¾M)sHZ{P �T�OUÉMQW[�M���M�[�MOP"Ó][�\OKz[�I*dlPS�¡gi[]^?W*UqdfR, # & Ó�[]dfG*Ph�SÕ Ò W*P ��� '����yUqZ{Ph\O[�MQUq\`M�[ �]Ph��[]^oPSdlPhJmPh^_M�U]acM)s�Z{P �?[]^*RÊgS\OPh[�MQPS��[]^ÊPSdlPSJLPS^�M�U]acM)s�Z{P��� & & � ��� !`W*KldfP�MQW*P � �� & UqZÆPS\Q[�MOUq\¡R*U�Ph�¡MQW�PY\�PSÓ]Ph\O��P]Õ

b3[]g�WÊ^*U�R*P°gh[]^�MQ[��]P«Kl^o[]^oKf^�Ó]UHgh[�MQKfUq^yÓHKl[mKNMQ��#O,� ������?[�gSMQKfUq^�v�[]^�RA[]Z*Z*dNsTMQW*PYKl^_Ó]UHgh[�MQKfUq^?MOUMQW�P�gSPh^_MQ\O[]dÆJmPhJmUq\�sVKl^ÉMQW*P �� �����É[]gSMOKlUq^�Õ Ò W*P�gSPh^_MQ\O[]d{JLPSJLUq\�s7��������� �mKl�3G*Z{R[�MOPhRT[]gSghUq\�R*Kl^�kMQUÎ�OU]JLP a|G*^*g�MQKlU]^ �� �������>� !`W*KldfP�[�\OPS�OZ{Uq^*��PÁKl�?gi[�dlghG�dz[�MOPhRËI_s'MOW*P a|G*^*gSMOKlUq^ � ��- � & {Õ Ò W*P^*U�R*Po\�Ph��ZÆUq^�R*�LMOU�KfMO�LG*��Ph\ !`KfMQWÎMQW*P�\OPS�OZ{Uq^*�OP�Õ Ò W*Po[]G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^ÎKlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^_MQ�m[�MQU]JLKfg?��W[]\�PhRJmPhJmUq\�sVI{Phgh[]G*��P]Ô¡u($�MQW�P�Kf^�Ó]UHgh[�MQKfUq^*��[]\OP6[]dfd�OPS\OKz[�dlK`MSPhRmUq^ÉMQW*P��OW[]\�PhRmÓ][�\OKz[�I*dlP ����� []^*RTt>$ePh[]g�WKl^_Ó]UHgh[�MQKfUq^ �¬�¾MQKlJmP Kf^_MQPh\�Ó�[]d�ghU]^�MQ[]Kl^��¾MQW*PyP V�[]g�MmZÆUqKf^_MVU]a��OPh\�Kz[]dfK`Mh[�MQKfUq^ÁUq^ÇMOW*Py�OW[]\�PhRÎJLPSJLU]\�sÓ�[]\OKl[]I*dfP]Õ

Ò W*P½[]G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^ � �������-KlJmZ*dfPhJmPh^_MQ�mMQW*PÊgh[]g�W*Kf^*kÎ[]dlkqU]\OKfMOW*J?Õ Ò W*P #O, �� ���.[�^*R � ��-�6�(, �[]g�MQKlU]^*�6[]\OP"MQW�PY�O[]JmP]Õ ;ËW*Ph^�ZÆPS\�a|Uq\�JLKf^*kÉ[ !`\�KfMOP�MOUL��W[]\�PhRoJmPhJmUq\�sqv[ÉZ*\OU�ghPS�O��Uq\�G�ZÆR[�MQPh�`MQW�PghPS^_MQ\Q[�d{JmPhJmUq\�sVdlU�gi[�MOKlUq^É[�^*RLgSdlPh[]\O�eMQW�P�gh[]g�W*Ph��U]a�U�MQW*PS\�Z*\�UHgSPh���OUq\��4!|Kl^mUq^*P`��s�^*g�W*\�Uq^*UqG�����MOPhZ6$�Õ×e\OU�ghPS�O�OU]\O�¾gh[]^Ç[]\�I*KfMO\Q[]\�Kldfs�ghU]Z�s½a|\OU]J MQW*PLghPh^_MO\Q[]d(JLPSJLU]\�s dlU�gi[�MQKlU]^ MOU�MOW*PhKf\«gh[]g�W*Ph�¾[]^*R�gh[]^R*PSdlPSMOP�MQW*PSKl\¡gh[]g�W*PhR?Ó�[]dlG*PS�hÕ:;ËW*PS^�Z{Ph\�a|Uq\OJmKl^�kV[V\OPi[�R�v�[VZ*\OU�ghPS�O�OU]\6PSKfMOW*Ph\¡\�Pi[]R*�¡a|\�UqJ KNMQ�¡gi[�g�W*PUq\ !p[]KfMO�¡a|Uq\�MQW*P�gh[]g�W*P�MQUÉIÆP"}dfdlPSR�Õ

A�G*\�kqU_[]deKf��MOU�Z�\OU©ÓqPÉMQW*PmP VHKf��MQPS^*ghPmU]a�[ya|Uq\@!�[�\OR½�OKlJ°G*dz[�MOKlUq^A\�Phdl[�MQKfUq^AIÆP�M !pPSPh^ � ������� [�^*R�����?G*�OKf^*kmUqG*\¡JmPSMQW�UHR*U]dlUqk]s]Õ

� !�� !# � ��4�!������� �*���54j2e4{��� 23!����� 2����p�

Ö �Og�W�PhR*G*dfP !p[]� !`\OKNMOMOPh^Aa|Uq\�MQW�Pmgh[]g�W*Pm[]dfkqUq\OKNMQW*JÐKf^½U]\OR*PS\�MQUyP VHPhgSG�MQPmKfM"MOUTZÆPS\�a|Uq\�J R�s�^[]JmKlgKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M�R�PSMQPSgSMOKlUq^�ÕeÖ�� !`KfMOW MQW*P�×~PSMOPh\��OUq^?gi[]��P"��MOG*R�sqvHMQW*P"��g�W*PhR*G�dlP"�OPSdlPSgSMQ�`[¾^�UHR*P�[�M¡\Q[�^*R*UqJ[]^*R'[�M�MQPSJLZ�MO� MQU�JmU©ÓqPAKfMLa|Uq\ !p[]\�R'Kf^ MQW*P [�dlkqUq\�KfMOW*J [�M !`W[�MOPSÓ]Ph\y��MQ[�MQPÊMOW*P ^*UHR�PÊKl�SÕ Ò W*Kf�\Q[�^*R*UqJmK`MSPhRÉ�Og�W*PSR*G*dfP !p[]��\�G*^La|U]\ D]wqw���MQPSZ*�hÕ3Û6U«��Klkq^�Kf}gh[]^_M�g�W*[]^*kqPS�p^*PSPhR*PSRLMQUYI{P�JL[]R*P¡MQU�MQW�P

<*u

Page 42: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� � � � � � � ��� ���?;� �� � � � � � �� � � � � ���k�&��%����F+ �q! O�%��&�F� �T! j��M���S%��K1[�E����S��%���p+ � !$O�%�&�F� ! ���J�M��%� ���1 � � � � � � �n>����&�����F+ �q! O�%��� 1

� � � � � �;��?; ���~! ��&�S>�� ! DC� �d� �*�S�=�&�R�S�&���&�N����:���>J��N�����S>�����M�q! j�&����qx O�%�&�F� O>����Tx jJ�M� �S%��gz�zC! D ��%��R�S��������+e� ��� 1R�J�?�X! j�&����qx O�%�&�F� O>����Tx ���J�M�J%�� ���z�zC! D ��%��R�S��������+��R���J1

� ��� � � � � � �

� � � � � ���k�&��%����F+ ���$�J1� � ����M� x ��zEDQ� ���

� ����M� x � zQ! D �?;������F+5�J1

� � � � � � �n>����&�����F+ �� � ��� � � �d!�jJ�M����%��p1� � �J�?�qx ��zEDQ� ���n3Q���M� x ��z Dy�?;�����F+5� 1

� �J�?�qx � zQ! D �?;������F+-����?>�����+5�d��;��M; ����1�1 ;��M; ���0! D"�����:�%��;F+-�K� ;��?; ���p1

� � � � � � ����S��%���p+��F� [1� � �J�?�qx ��zEDy�M;�����d+5 1

� �J�?�qx � zQ! DC� ��� ���M� x � zQ! DC� ���

F�KlkqG�\OP < �)x�Ô Ò W*PY�OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^?[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^�v������<Õ

[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^�ghU�R*P°KNMQ��Phdfa~MQU \�Ph^*R�Ph\�KNM�PXV�PSghG�MQ[]I*dfP( W�U�!�PSÓ]Ph\Sv�a|Uq\�Z*\O[]gSMOKlgh[]d�\OPi[��OUq^*� !pP¾g�W�Uq�OP°MOUKlJmZ*dfPhJmPh^_M¡Pi[�g�W�^*U�R*P�KlR?[]�`[�^�Kf^�MOPhkqPS\¡\Q[�MOW*Ph\¡MOW[]^�[]^?[]I*��MO\Q[]g�M6R[�M�[¾M)s�Z{P]Õ

� !�� !�� � ���e2e����23�p��� ����6!"�����#/23��#/#"���*��4<����#

A�^*P`Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_McKf�ePh^*UqG�kqWmMOU"�OW*U�! MOW[�MeMOW*Kl�c��MQ\�Uq^*kYgi[]g�W*Kf^*kY[]dlk]Uq\OKNMQW*J5KlJmZ*dfPhJmPh^_MQ�c��W[]\�PhRmJLPSJ �Uq\�sÆÔ !`W�Ph^y[¾Z*\�UHgSPh�O��Uq\��¬�¡gi[�g�W*P"Kl��^*U]M�PSJLZHM)sqv*KNMQ��Ó�[]dfG*P�Kf�pPS��G*[]dÆMOU¾MQW*P�gSPh^_MQ\O[]d<JmPhJmUq\�s�¬��Ó�[]dfG*P]ÕÒ W*Kf�6Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�M !�[]�`R*P�MQPSgSMQPSRÊI_syX"[]KN�]Uq^?[]�SÔ

���h! O�%���Q+�����?(��Tx �Jz �DC� ���/. �����?(�� x{��z�W5���&�S>�� D=; �?; ���p1

Ö��"!`\OKNMOMOPh^?Kl^ *pUqkqR*[]^*U©Ó � *¡ÙYÜ�w_t ��vHMQW*Kf�6Kf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�M�Kl�hÔ���h! O�%���Q+�����?(��Tx �Jz DC� ��� �,�����?(�� x{��z D �?;�����F+ ; �?; ���U11

Ò W*PÉ\OPS�OG*dNMQ�Y[]\OPVdfUqkqKfgi[]dfdfsTPS��G�KfÓ�[]dlPS^_M�I*G�M���s�^_M�[�gSMQKfgi[]dfdfs�R*K =ÆPh\�Ph^_M�I{Phgi[�G*�OPLX"[]K`��Uq^AR*U�Ph�"^*U�MR*P�MQPhg�M�Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MO��U©ÓqPS\�R*Kf����G*^�gSMQKfUq^*�SvÆI*GHM�\Q[�MQW*PS\�Z*Kfg �]PSRAUqG�M6MQW*PYÓ][�dlG*PS��Kf^ogi[�g�W*P«MOW[�M !pPS\OP¾^*U�M%,#( �[]^*Rm�Q[ !-MQW[�MeMOW*P¡Ó�[]dlG*PS� !pPS\OP`Ph��G[�d*MQU � � ��� �� Õ Ò W[�M(Kl�Sv�X"[]K`��Uq^É[]\�\OKfÓ]PhRm[�MeMOW*P`�Q[]JmP¡\OPS�OG*dNM[]�6[VW�G*J [�^�R*KfR�v*I*GHM¡ÓHKl[É[mR*K =<PS\OPS^�M`JmPSMOW*U�R�Õ

<�t

Page 43: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� � � � � � � ���,L&���M(��� �� � � � � � �� � � � � ���k�&��%����F+ �q! O�%��&�F� �T! j��M���S%��K1[�E����S��%���p+ � !$O�%�&�F� ! ���J�M��%� ���1 � � � � � � � �����d+ �q! O�%��&�21[�$P���?���d+ � !$O�%�&�[1[� ��%��&�d+���! O�%�&�21[�E��%��T+ �q! O�%�&� 1

� � � � � �; �?; ���~!���&��>��h! DC� �K����S��!$j������Xx O�%�&�F� O>J���dx5jJ�M���S%��2z�z"! D �%�� ��������U+5� ��� 1R�J�M� !$j������Xx O�%�&�F� O>J���dx������S��%� ����z�zQ! Df��%� ���������U+e� ��� 1R������?(�� !$j������Xx O�%�&�F�$O>��&�Fx���&�S>�� z�zC! D ��%��R�S��������+e� ����1

� ��� � � � � � �� � � � � ���k�&��%����F+ ���$�J1� � ����S�Tx �Jz DQ� ���

� ����S�Tx �Jz"! D �?;�����d+5� 1

� � � � � � � �����d+ �� � ��� � �\� ! jJ�M����%��p1� � ��?;�����F+5�R1 D,���S��x{�Jz����������F+-� 1 J�M��x �Jz DQ� ��� �����?(�� x ��z��DQ� ���

� �J�M��x �Jz"! D �?;�����d+Z����?>J���T+e�K�n�����?(�� x ��z�W������R11

� � � � � � �nP&��?���K+��� � ��� � �\� ! j��M���S%�� 1� � ��?;�����F+5�R1 D,���S��x{�Jz��&���� �M��� +5�R1 J�M��x �Jz DQ� ���

� �J�M��x �Jz"! D �?;�����d+Z����?>J���T+e�K� ; �?; ���U1�1 ; �?; ��� ! D"�����:�%�;T+5�d��;��?; ���p1 �����?(��h! D ��%��R�S��������+��R���J1

� � � � � � �v��%��&�F+ �21� ������?(�� x � zQ! D �?;������F+ ;��?; �� 1

� � � � � � �n���%��T+ �21� ������?(�� x � zQ! DC� ���

� � � � � � ����S��%���p+��F� [1� � �J�M��x �Jz Dy�M;�����F+� 1

� �J�M��x �Jz"! DC� ��� ���S�Tx �Jz"! DC� ���

� � � � � � ���k�&� � L&���?(���!�N�4!$O�%���"+������M(���x ��z DC� ��� �y�����?(��Tx �Jz D �?;������F+ ;��?; ��p11

F�Klk]G*\OP < � <*Ô3F�MO\OUq^�kqdfs gi[]g�W*Kf^*kmKlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^�MQ[�MQKfUq^�v � ���(���*Õ<_x

Page 44: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� ��������� � ��� � � � ��� � � � L&���?(�� � � ���?;q!���M;XW ;��M; ���vD,L����?(��TW^;��M; ����3 ���M;qWe���M� DyL&���?(���We���M�v3 ���M;XW�J�M� DyL&���M(���W J�?�

� � � � �S���������M;XW5���M�h! D,L����?(���W5���M�����M;XW J�?�4! D,L����?(���W J�?� ���M;XW ;��M; ���0! DyL&���?(���W ;��?; ��

� � � � � � � � �v��%��&�F+ �4! O�%�&�[1*�M)��%���

� � � � � � � � �n���%��T+ �4! O�%�&�[1*�M)��%���

� � � � � � � � �\P���?���d+ �f!$O�%���F� � ! jJ�M���S%���1 � � � � � ��� � � � �n>����&����y+5�T�$��1

� �

� � � � � � � � � �����d+ �4! O�%�&�F�$�y! jJ�S���S%���1 � � � � � ��� � � � �n>����&����y+5�T�$��1

� �

� � � � � � � � ����S��%���p+ �f!$O�%���F��4! ���J�M��%� ��J1 � � � � � � � � � � ��J�M�J%����Q+ ��� R1

� �

� � � � � � � ���k�&��%����,+5�f!$O�%���F� � ! jJ�M���S%���1 � � � � � � � � � ���k�&��%����,+5��� ��1

� �

F~KlkqG*\�P < � DHÔ Ò W*P��OKfJ¾G*dz[�MQKlU]^ \OPSdz[�MOKlUq^y[]^�R?PXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^Ê[]^*^�U]M�[�MOKlUq^���IÆP�M !pPSPh^�������[]^�R�� �������*Õ

� !�� !�� ����� �*�� !"&�2��*�����C���&�2�������

Ò W*P¾��KlJ¾G�dz[�MOKlUq^?\OPSdz[�MOKlUq^?IÆP�M !pPSPh^AMQW�P°M !pUy[�G�MQUqJL[�MQ[LKl���OW*U�!`^AKf^[F�Klk]G*\OP < �@D�Õ Ò W*P¾��KlJ¾G�dz[�MOKlUq^\OPSdz[�MOKlUq^T�O[isH�¡MOW[�M`MQW*P�[�dld<MOW*P���M�[�MQP�Ó�[]\OKl[]I*dfPh��JL[]ZTÓ�Kz[¾MQW*P�KfR*Ph^_MQKNM)s \�Phdz[�MQKlU]^�v�[�^*R��O[isH�6^*U]MOW*Kl^�k[]I{UqG�M¡MOW*P �>�������LÓ�[]\OKl[]I*dfP�Kl^ MOW*P7� ������� []G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^ !ÈMQW*Kf�¡Kl� !`W_s MOW*PY[]IÆU©Ó]PYKf^_Ó][�\OKz[�^�M�Kl�¡^*PSghPh� ��Q[�\�s�$�Õ°Û�U]MOKlghPYMQW*PVPXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^�[�^*^*U]MQ[�MQKfUq^*��a|Uq\�Pi[]g�WAMQ\O[]^*��KfMQKfUq^�v�!`W*Klg�W[!`Kldfd~I{P¾G*��PhR�[ MQPSJLZ*dl[�MQPa|Uq\¡kqPS^*Ph\O[�MQKf^*kVMQW*P�Z*\�UHU�a�I_s MOW*PYÜ�×.[]^*R >)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP�MO\Q[]^*��dz[�MOKlUq^ MOUHU]dl�hÕ

� !�� !�� ������������ ���� �*�� !"&�2��*�����/��~&�2��*�����

����Kl^*k"MOW*P`Z*\OU�U]a{MQ\Q[�^*�Odl[�MQUq\~MQU�Uqdl�SvB!pP¡MQ\O[]^*��dz[�MOPhRVMQW*P¡M !�U¾[]GHMQUqJL[�M�[�[]^*RÉMQW*P`�OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^¾\OPSdz[�MOKlUq^Kl^_MOUÎKf^*Z*G�Mya|Uq\TI{U]MOWÌÜ�× []^�R >)�O[]IÆPSdldfP]Õ Ò W*P }\O��Mo��MQPhZ !pP½g�W*Uq��P½MOU-R�U-I{PSa|Uq\�P Z*\OU©Ó�Kl^*k�MQW�P�OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^ \OPSdz[�MOKlUq^ !�[]�`MQUÉZ*\�U©ÓqP�MQW*P�gh\�G*ghKl[]d�Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MhÕ

Ò W*P?Z*\OU�U]a��Ogh\�KlZ�MO� !pPykqPS^*Ph\O[�MQPSR !�Ph\OP?��G*KfMOPT�OG*gSghPS�O��a|G�d�Õ >)^-Ü�×~v�MOW*P?Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MVW[]RÇMQU½I{PR*Uq^�P I_s½W[]^*R�v�[]�&!�P R�UÊ^*U]M«kqPh^�Ph\Q[�MQP Z�\OU�U]a���gh\OKfZ�MQ�SÕ >)^>)�Q[]I{PhdfdlP�v�MOW*P gS\OG*gSKz[]d3Kl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_Miv.!p[]�[]G�MOUqJL[�MQKfgi[]dfdfs«Z*\OU©ÓqPSR ��G*��M�a|\OUqJ MOW*P�Z*\�UHU]a��Ogh\�KlZ�MhÕ Ò W�G*��^*Ph[]\OdNs MhPh\�U¾W�G*JL[]^ !�Uq\#� !�[��pKl^_Ó]UqdfÓ]PhRKl^yZ*\�U©ÓHKf^*kVMQW*Kf�`Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MiÕ3npW[�Z�MQPS\ ;VR*PS�Ogh\�KlI{Ph�¡MQW�P&>)�O[]IÆPSdldfP�JLU�R*PSd<a|Uq\¡MQW*PY[]GHMQUqJL[�M�[¾Kf^yR*PSMQ[]Kld[]^*RyMQW�PYJmPSMOW*U�R*UqdlU]k]sLa|U]\¡kqPh^*PS\Q[�MOKl^*kÉZ*\�UHU�a~��gh\�KlZ�MO�`a|U]\¡Kl^_Ó�[]\OKl[]^_MQ�hÕ

<B<

Page 45: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ö��Va|Uq\¾MOW*Py�OKlJ°G*dz[�MOKlUq^�\OPSdz[�MOKlUq^�veI{U]MOWÎZ�\OU©ÓqPS\mMO\Q[]^*��dz[�MOUq\O�°kqPh^*PS\Q[�MOPhR-Z*\OU�U]a6�OgS\OKlZHMQ�Va|Uq\¾MQW�P[]G�MOUqJL[�M�[oa|UqdfdlU�!`Kl^�koMQW*PyJmPSMOW*UHR�UqdlUqk�sÁZ*\�Ph��Ph^_MQPSR Kl^-npW[]ZHMQPh\mx�Õ >)^ÎI{U]MQWÎZ*\OU©Ó]Ph\O�SvpMQW�P?Z�\OU�U]a�OgS\OKfZ�MQ��Z*\OU©ÓqPSRy[]R*PS��G*[�MQP�MOUV[]G�MOUqJL[�MQKfgi[]dfdfs«Z*\OU©ÓqP�[]dldMQ\O[]^*��KfMQKfUq^*�3P VHgSPhZ�M¡a|Uq\(Uq^*P�vHMOW*P � �����mMO\Q[]^���OKNMQKfUq^�Õ ��PS\OP]vq[6a|P\!�dlKl^�Ph��U]a*W�G*JL[]^��¹kqPh^*PS\Q[�MOPhR¾gSUqJmJ []^�R*��!pPS\OP�^*PSghPS�O�Q[�\�sYMQU�dfPSÓ]Ph\Q[�kqP�MOW*P�gS\OG*gSKz[]dKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_MiÔ&!`W*Ph^�\OPh[]R*Kf^*k�a|\�UqJ gi[]g�W*P�vcMQW*P gi[]g�W*P ���¾Ó�[]dfG*PmghUq^_M�[�Kl^*�YMQW*P Ó�[]dfG*P U�a ��������� ��Õ A"G�\ghU]JLZ*GHMQPh\ �)kqPS^*Ph\O[�MQPSR�Z�\OU�U]a�!p[]�`^*Ph[]\OdNsTKlR*PS^_MQKlgh[]dÆMOU *�UqkqR[]^�U�Ó �¬�`Z*\OU�U]a � *¡Ù�Ü�w_t �ja|U]\`Ü�×�Õ

� !�� !� $'�H�������� ���p�

FUq\¾MQW�P�JmPhJmUq\�sÁgi[]��P���MQG*RHsqv�dfKfMOMOdlP W�G*JL[]^ÎKl^_MQPS\�Ó]Ph^_MQKfUq^ !p[]�m\OPh��G*Kf\OPSR�Õ Ò W*P?��MOPhZ*�mKl^_Ó]UqdfÓ�Kl^�kMQW�PmJmUq��M�W�G�J []^ W*PSdlZ[!�Ph\OP�ÔLu�$��OPhdfPhg�MQKl^�kyMOW*PVKl^_Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M�MOW[�MYJLKfkqW_M"I{PVG*�OP�a|G*dea|Uq\�MQW�Pm��KlJ¾G�dz[ �MQKfUq^ \OPSdz[�MOKlUq^AZ*\�UHU�a �ct $"t>$"k]KfÓ�Kl^*ky[Ta|P\! ghUqJmJL[]^*R*��MOU?MOW*PÉZ*\OU©ÓqPS\ !`W�Ph^ÁKNM�W[]dNMQPhR<Õ Ò W�G*�Sv�UqG�\JmPSMQW�UHR*U]dlUqk]s !p[]�`��G�KfMQP���G*ghgSPh�O��a|G*d�W*Ph\�P]Õ

� ��� � � �� � � � ��� � �� � �� �,� � � � � / � � ���Ü�[]JmZÆUq\�M �¬�m×�[0VHUq� Z�\OU]MOUHgSUqd��¬Ü�[]J GBC ��KfJLZ*dfPhJmPh^_MQ�VR�Kl��MO\OKfI*G�MQPSR.gSUq^*�OPS^*�OG��TKl^ [�^ []��sH^�g�W*\OUq^�UqG*���s���MQPhJCKl^ !`W*Klg�W�Kl^*R�KfÓ�KlR*G*[]deZ*\OU�ghPS�O��Ph�¾gh[]^�a£[]Kfd�Õ/;ÁPLR*PS}^�P R*Kf��MQ\�KlI*GHMQPhR�ghUq^��OPh^��OG*�É[]��a|UqdfdlU�!`�hÕFHG*Z�ZÆUq��P�MQW[�M 3LKf�¡[°}^*KNMQP���PSM`U]a�^*U�R*PS�¡\OPhZ�\OPh��Ph^_MQKf^*kVMQW*P"Z�\OU�ghPh���OPS�6Kf^ MQW*P���s���MOPhJÐ[]^*R�� Kf�pMQW�P�OP�M¾U]a�ZÆUq���OKfI*dlPmghUq^��OPh^��OG*�¾Ó�[]dfG*Ph�SÕ�×e\�UHgSPh�O��Ph�VKf^ 3AJL[©s Z�\OUqZ{Uq�OPmÓ�[]dlG*PS�°Kf^��LÕ Ò W*PLghUq^��OPh^��OG*��OPS\�Ó�KlgSP"Kl�p[]dldfU�!�PhRmMQUV\�PSMQG�\O^TR*PSghKl��KlUq^���MQU°Z*\OU�ghPS�O�OPS�¡MQW[�MpW[iÓqP"Z*\�UqZ{Uq�OPSR Ó][�dlG*PS�hÕ >¹M�J°G*��M¡�O[�MQKf��aÈsM !�U�gSUq^*R*KNMQKlU]^*�hÔ�[]dfdc^*U�R*Ph��J¾G���MY\OPSghPhKNÓqPÉMQW*PÉ�O[]JLP¾Ó�[]dfG*P ! ��[]kq\OPSPhJmPh^_M � $�[�^*RAMQW[�M�Ó�[]dfG*PVJ¾G*��MW[iÓqPYI{PhPh^?Z*\�UqZÆU]�OPhR?I_sy�OUqJmP"Z*\�UHgSPh�O� ! ��Ó][�dlKlR�KfM)s$��$�Õ

×�[0VHUq�pKlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^�MO�3ghUq^*��Ph^*��G*�¡MQW*\�UqG*kqWmMQW*P�G*�OP�U]aj��G*Uq\�G*JL�p[]^*R I*[]dldfU]M3ÓqU]MOKl^*k°[]^*R !�P�Z*\�U�Ó]PMQW�P¾KlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^_M�[�MOKlUq^ MOW*\OUqG�kqWÊ�OG�ghghPS�O��KfÓqPÉ\�PS}^*PSJLPS^_M"U]a3J¾G*dNMQKfZ*dlP��OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^y\OPhdl[�MQKfUq^*�SÕT;�P°G*��PghU�R*PYa|\OUqJ [ gh[]�OP¾��MQG*RHs � X"×3Ü~F � w_t ��MQW*[�M�R*P�}^*PS��[ W*KlPS\Q[]\�g�W_s�U�a([]G�MQU]J [�MQ[�Õ Ò W*P¾W*KfkqW*PS��M �¹dlP�ÓqPhd[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^<v���)�%,�]v�Z*\OU©Ó�KlR�Ph��[Y�OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^La|Uq\3gSUq^*�OPS^*�OG��hÕ Ò W*P�dfU�!�Ph��M �¹dlPSÓ]Phd<[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^�v�� � ��)��]vZ*\�U�Ó�KfR*Ph�(["R*Kl��MQ\�KlI*G�MOPhRÉKlJmZ*dfPhJmPh^_M�[�MOKlUq^<Õ�Ö�^ÉKl^_MQPS\OJmPhR*Kl[�MQP �)dlP�ÓqPSd*[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^<v��� �)-� � �©v�[]dfMOW*UqG*k]W^*Uq^ �)R*Kf��MQ\�KlI*GHMQPhR<v6gh[]Z�MOG*\OPS�yMOW*PÊJL[]Kl^.KlR*Ph[�U]a«×�[0VHUq�Sv�MQW*[�MTU]aYG*��Kl^*kÇI[�dldlU�MQ�L[]^*RË��G*Uq\OG�JL� MOU[]g�W*KfPSÓ]P«gSUq^*�OPS^*�OG��hÕ�Ö5ghU]\O\OPSgSMO^*Ph����Z*\�UHU]a�Kl^_ÓqU]dfÓqPS�`�OW*U�!`Kl^�kLMQW�PYPXVHKl��MOPh^*gSP«U�ae[É�OPh\�KlPS�6U�a�a|Uq\@!�[]\�R�OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^ \OPhdl[�MQKfUq^*��I{PSM !�PhPh^���G*ghgSPh�O��KfÓ]PTdlPSÓ]Phdf�°Kl^½MQW*PLW*KlPS\Q[]\�g�W_sqÕ >)^ÁMQW*Kf�«��Phg�MQKlU]^�vW!�P R*Kl��ghG*���MQW�PÉa|U]\ !p[]\OR �OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKfUq^oI{PSM !�PhPS^ � )-% �É[�^*R�� �)-� � ��©Õ Ò W*Kl�"Kf�"I[]��PhR½Uq^AMQW*P !�Uq\#�ÊI_s Û6P ;ËKl^�vPSMhÕ([]d�ÕcKf^ �¬Û�b�Ù � wqx ��Õ

� !�� !# � �°��4��� �4j2��*���p� 23!����p+2����p�

Ò W*Pm�OKfkq^[�MOG*\OPÉU]a�MQW*Pm�OZ{PhgSKf}gh[�MQKfUq^Á[�G�MQUqJL[�MOUq^ � )�%,��!,F�KfkqG*\�P <*ÕªxHÕfu($�gSUq^_M�[]Kf^*�°[�^�Kf^*Z*G�M«[]g�MQKlU]^# % #-� � #�� � � v�\OPhZ�\OPh��Ph^_MQKf^*k�MOW*P(Z*\OUqZ{Uq�O[]d_U]a�Ó�[]dfG*P �6I�sYZ*\�UHgSPh��� #qv][]^YKl^_MOPh\O^*[]d�[]gSMOKlUq^ ��� ) )���� � � �� � � v\OPSZ*\OPS�OPS^�MOKl^*kTMOW*PVg�W*UqKfghP¾U]a([ gSUq^*��Ph^*��G*�YÓ�[]dfG*P���vj[]^AUqGHMQZ*G�M"[]gSMOKlUq^ ' � � #�'�� � #�� � � v<\OPhZ�\OPh��Ph^_MQKf^*kMQW�P�\�PhZ{Uq\�M(U]a{MQW*P6ghU]^*�OPS^*�OG*�(Ó�[]dlG*P¡MOU«Z*\�UHgSPh��� #qvH[�^*R [�^LKf^*Z*G�M�[]g�MQKlU]^ � � #( � # � v�\�PhZ*\�Ph��Ph^_MQKf^*k°MQW�Pa£[]KfdlG*\�P(U�a�Z*\OU�ghPS�O� #]Õ Ò W*P�[]G�MQU]J [�MOUq^°Z�\OU©Ó�KlR*PS�~MQW�Pp\OPS��G*Kl\�PhRÉ[]kq\�PhPSJLPS^�Mc[]^*R°Ó�[]dfKlR*KNM)s"kqG[�\Q[]^_MQPSPh�SÔUq^*dNs [���Kl^*k]dlPÊgSUq^*�OPS^*�OG��?Ó�[]dfG*PÊgi[�^'I{PAg�W*Uq��Ph^�v�[]^*R MQW*[�MTÓ�[]dlG*PoJ¾G*��MyW*[©Ó]P IÆPSPh^ËZ*\OP�Ó�KlUqG*��dfsZ*\�UqZÆU]�OPhR<Õ

<QD

Page 46: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

�5B � ��O�%�&� D � � � � � � �&%������ ��%�� ! �k�&��5B � � ��&�S>�� D � � � � � � ���&�S>��q! �k�&�

� � � � � � � ���,L&%�� �� �� � � � � � � � � � ��:&�����U+?��! O�%�&�g1[���k� �M�d+?��! O�%�&�F� ��!���&�S>��[1� � � � � �v�&���&�M���F+k��! O�%��&�F��� !���&�S>��R1 � � � � � � �o�M(�%�%��� ����g+5�T!���&�S>��R1

� � � � � ��M�R�S� �������&�F!$a����x O�%��&�JzQ! D ���p� ���%���%J���&�d! a���Tx�����S>��JzC! D � � ��M(�%������w! a�����x���&��>��Jz ! D ���p� ���J���S�����F!$a���� x O�%�&��z ! D � � �:��������<! a�����x O�%�&��z ! D ���

� ��� � � � � � � � � � �l�k� �M�d+?�p���[1� ��� _�+?� �l:��������p1 3�_ +k� �C�?�[�M� ��������R1 � � � �

�?�R�S� ������&�"! D0�?�R�S� ������&��� � � � ���%��%J�����,! D"���%��J%����&��� �&� �

� � � � � � � �o�M(�%�%��� ����g+5� 1� � �N� �����%��J%����&��3,�?(�%������mD ���� � �?(�%������ ! D �&� �

� � � � � �v�&���&�M���F+k�p� � 1� � �=� �Q�?�[�M�R�������� 3�_�+?� �l�������S���&��1 3

_�+?� �l:��������p1 3l� �Q�?(�%������� � �����������&�"! D,�����������&��� �����

� � � ��:&�����U+?��1� � :&�J�����4! Dy:&���������� � � �

F�KfkqG*\�P < � IHÔ(FHZÆPSghKN}gi[�MOKlUq^yU]a~ghU]^*�OPS^*�OG*��Kl^ >@A6Ö

� !�� !�� � �"&��� ���p��2�����p� 23!����p+2��*���

Ò W*P`[]GHMQUqJL[�MQU]^ �� �)-� � �W!,F�KfkqG*\OP <*ÕªxHÕfu($��OZ{PhghKN}Ph�3[�^L[�dlkqUq\�KfMOW*J�MQW[�MeKlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^_MQ��gSUq^*��Ph^*��G*��Kf^É[^*Uq^ �)R*Kf��MQ\�KlI*GHMQPhRT��PSM�MQKl^�k*Õ Ò W*Kl�6[]GHMQUqJL[�MQU]^ G*�OPS��[°MOU]M�[�dldfsLUq\�R*Ph\�PhRy�OP�M�U�a�I[�dldlU�MQ��a|U]\�Ó][�dlG*PS�hv*Uq^�PU]a !`W*Kfg�WAJ [is?PSÓ]Ph^_MQG*[]dldNsoI{P¾g�W*Uq��Ph^½[]�6MQW*P¾gSUq^*��Ph^*��G*�"Ó][�dlG*P«Kfae��G $mghKlPS^_MY[]Z*Z*\�U�Ó�[]d~Kl�6ghUqdfdlPSgSMQPSRa|\OU]J�MQW�PYZ�\OU�ghPh���OPS��Kl^TMOW*P���s���MOPhJ?Õ

>)^ []R*R*KNMQKfUq^oMQULMQW*P¾PXV�MQPh\�^[]de[�gSMQKfUq^*��U�aeMQW*PV[�G�MQUqJL[�MOUq^ � )-% ��vÆMOW*P¾�OKfkq^[�MOG*\OP°U]a �� �)�� � ��Kl^��ghdfG*R*PS��Kl^_MOPh\O^*[]d�[�gSMQKfUq^*��a|Uq\�J [���Kf^*k�I*[]dldfU]MQ�Sv][]���OKfkq^*Kl^�k6MOW*PhJ Ó�[]dlG�Ph�hv][]^*R°Ó]U]MQKf^*k�a|U]\~Uq\~[]I*��M�[]Kf^*Kl^�ka|\OU]J I[]dfdlU]MO�hÕ Ò W�P«[�G�MQUqJL[�MOUq^ �� �)�� � �6R*PSMOPh\OJmKl^�Ph��MQW�P�a£[�MQP"U]a�[VI[]dldfU]M�I_sTgSUq^*��KlR*PS\OKl^�kÉMOW*P�[]g �MQKfUq^*��U]ap��G�Uq\OG*Jm�hv�!`W*Klg�WÁ[]\OPV}^�KfMQPm�OG�I*�OP�MQ�°U�a 3�v~U]^�MQW*[�MYI[]dldfU]MiÕ �� �)�� � ��V[]dldfU�!`�Y[yI[]dfdlU]M�MOU�OG�ghghPSPhRÊU]^*dfs Kfa�PSÓ]Ph\�s?^*U�R*P"Kf^�[É��G*Uq\�G*J W[]�¡Ó]U]MQPSR?a|Uq\`KNMiÕ

� !�� !�� � ��4�!������� �*�����Ì&��� �23& 23!��*��+2��*���

Ò W*PA��PhghU]^*R1��MQPSZ'Kf^ G*��Kl^*kÇUqG�\ JLP�MQW*U�R.MOU�ÓqPh\�KfaÈs []^Ë[]G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^-Kl� MOU�MQPh��MyKfMO� I{PhW[iÓ�KlUq\ I�s�OKfJ¾G*dl[�MQKf^*k�P VHPSghG�MOKlUq^�Õ Ò W*P���KlJ¾G�dz[�MOUq\�\�Ph��G*Kl\�Ph�3MQW[�M >@A6ÖËZ*\OU]kq\Q[]Jm�eI{P`MO\Q[]^���a|Uq\�JLPSRmKf^_MQUY[�a|Uq\OJ�OG�KfM�[�I*dlPea|Uq\�P VHPhgSG�MQKfUq^�ÕWF�U]\~PXV*[�JLZ*dfP]v�MQW*P��OKfJ¾G*dz[�MQUq\j\�Ph��G*Kl\�Ph����G*Uq\OG�JL�~Kl^«×�[0VHUq��MOU�I{PpKf^*KfMOKz[]dfK`MSPhRUqZ{Ph\O[�MQKfUq^[]dfdfsqv !`W�Ph\OPh[]�~MOW*PSsJ!�Ph\�P��OZ{PhgSKf}PSR¾R*PhgSdz[]\O[�MQKNÓqPSdfs"Kf^YMOW*P�U]\OKlk]Kl^[]d�>@?BA []G�MOUqJ [�MQUq^�JmUHR*PSd�Õ

<_I

Page 47: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

�5B � ��#��&����%�� D � � � � � � %������ �M��)F! �k�&�

� � � � � � � ��� ����%��J��� Y� �� � � � � � � � � � ��:&�����U+?��! O�%�&�g1[���k� �M�d+?��! O�%�&�F� ��!���&�S>��[1� � � � � �v�&���&�M���F+k��! O�%��&�F��� !���&�S>��R1 � � � � � � �o�M������F+Z�&(���O�%������U! a�����x O�%�&� zJ1[�$; ������#J���&�&%�U+�� ! #��&�&�%��p1R�

��� �������?��+?�U!$O�%�&�F��#q!$a���� x #��&���%�[zJ12����&���M)&������g+���!$#��&���%�q� �F!�����S>��21R���%����K+k��! O�%��&�F� �q! #��&���%���1[� �?�����&��������J���S���U+ �q! #��&����%�� 1

� � � � � ��M�R�S� �������&�F!$a����x O�%��&�JzQ! D ���p� ���%���%J���&�d! a���Tx�����S>��Jz ! D ���p��������S���&�F!$a&����x O�%�&��z ! D ���p� :&��������<!$a����x O�%��&��z ! D ���p��J������%� �U!$a&����x #��&���%��2zQ! D ���p� �M>R�&�����������T!$a���� x #��&���%�[zQ! D ���p������d!$j������Xx #��&���%��<�$O>��&�Fx���&�S>�� z�z ! D4�%��R�S������U+e�R��� 1R���%�����q!$j������Xx O�%�&�F� a���� x #��&�&�%��2z�z ! D4�%��R�S������F+�����1[��� �����J�M���&�F! j&�����Xx O�%��&�F� a���� x #��&����%��gz�zQ! D4�%��R�S������F+�����1��>�%��>�;g�U!$a&����x O�%�&��zp������� !$a���� x #��&�&�%��2zQ! D � �

� ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � �o�M������F+Z�&(���O�%������&1� � ��>�%&>�;g�=! D,�&��������q+�xeY?zU�n��(J�O�%&���J��1

� � ��! O�%�&� � �&(��O�%������ � �b��%�����qxe�zC! D ��� ��� �������?���&�Fxe��zQ! D ��� � �

� � � �l�k� �M�d+?�p���[1� � ��j����Z�cL&%����=+?G��?)>&��IY�1

� � � ��:&�����C+M��1� � :&�J�����4! Dy:&���������� � � �

� � � � � � �E; ������#J���&�&%�K+ �R1� � �m_4+5� ���J������%� ��1 � � �J���&�&%� �=! DC�J���&�&%� � � �� �

� � � � � � � ���&���M)&������g+��F� � 1� � ��� �b��������%���� 3=���&�dx{�JzEDQ� ����3l� �b���%��J%����&�

3 �N����! #��&����%��h+5� ��W-%����� �?��) � ��W-%����� �?��) .���&�Fx � �ZzEDy�M;�����d+5�R1 �������l�&����[1

� ���&�dx{� zQ! Dy�?;�����F+ �R1 � � � � � � � ��%����K+k�p���R1� � �=� �Q�?�[�M�R�������� 3�_�+?� �l:��������p1 3

� �������&�&%���\3�_�+�� �c�� �����J�M���&�Fx5�z�1� � ��%���� xe�zQ! D,��%�����qxe�z�� ��� �

� � � � � � � ��� �������?��+?� ��#R1� � �=� �Q�?�[�M�R�������� 3�_�+?� �l:��������p1 3=��%������qx5�z��b#nD ���� � �� �S���J�M�����Tx5�zC! D ��� �������?���&�dx-��z ��#�

� � ��#J������%�F!�#��&����%�� �,# � � �t��O�%�&��!�O�%���Q+S��O�%��� � �>�%��>;2�7.

�#����&��%�� � �� �����J�M���&�Fx5��O�%��&�Jz�1� �����h�&���� ! Df�?��������4+M�#�������%��K� �&�&��21

� � �

� � � � � � �A�?�����&��������J���S���U+ �[1� � �*� �������&�&%���\3 �l}K!�O�%�&�C+Z} � ��>�%&>�;g�s. � ����%�����qx }�z�1� � �S> �&��&�&�����,! D4�S> �&��&�&����� � ��� �

� � � � � �v�&���&�M���F+k�p� � 1� � �=� �Q�?�[�M�R�������� 3�_�+?� �l�������S���&��1 3 _ +?� �c:&��������g1

3 �A��! #��&���%��4+ � �Q�M>R�&��&������� 3I�M;�����F+��[1�D"���&�Kx ��z�1� � �����������&�"! D,�����������&��� �����

F�KfkqG*\OP < �@;HÔeÖ I*[]dldfU]M �¹I[]�OPSRTKlJmZ*dlPSJLPS^_M�[�MOKlUq^ U�a�gSUq^*�OPS^*�OG���Kl^ >@A`Ö

<Q;

Page 48: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ö���KlR*Pya|\OU]J ��G*g�W I{UHU��)��PhPSZ*Kl^*kÁKl�O��G*Ph�Sv�MQW*P�gh\�G*ghKl[]d`Z*\OUqI�dlPhJ Kf�L\�Ph��UqdfÓ�Kl^�k�^*U]^*R*PSMOPh\�JLKf^*Kl��J I�s�OZ{PhgSKfaÈs�Kl^�kL[V��g�W*PhR*G�dlP]Õ(Ö�^?P V�[]JmZ*dfP"�Og�W*PSR*G*dlPYKl�SÔ

� � � � � � � �� � � ��� ��&(��O�%�������!$a���� x O�%�&��zC! D �k�������<+�x �zU�o�?��������X+�xeY?zU�o�k�������~+Jx ]�z�� � ��1�1&1��

�k�������<+�x uzU�o�?��������X+�x ��zU�o�k�������~+Jx���z�� � ��1�1&1� �

�� � � � � � � � �o�M������T+-�&(���O�%�������1 �� � � � � �c�k�R�?� +�x ��zK�Ax-YMz�1 �� � � � � �c�k�R�?� +�x-Y?zK�Ax^]&z�1 �� � � � � �*:&�J���F+�x��zJ1 �� � � � � � � � �\; ������#J������%�F+�x �zJ1

gi[�G*�OKf^*kVMQW*PJ>@A6Ö5��KlJ¾G*dl[�MQU]\pMQUÉP VHPSghG�MOP«}*Ó]P«[�gSMQKfUq^*�SÕ Ò W*P«U]G�MQZ*GHM�Kf�hÔ

���������� ������������ �������������������� ��!��"����$#��!��%���&�&'��(�*)��+,����+��.-���+�/����0� 1�����2�)�3��4����������15.������&6��.�*)��+,����+��.-���+�/����0�"1�����2�)�3��4����������15.�� ���&6��.�*)��+,����+��.-���+�/����0�#7�����2�)�(8������9����%���&(��(�*)��+,����+���-���+�/����0�%1�������� ������:,��*;���<�������+*���������&=��'�*)��+,����+��.-���+�/����0�

FUq\°UqG�\°gi[��OP ��MQG*R�s]v !pP !`\OU]MOP �Og�W*PSR*G*dfPh�¾MQUoP VHPhgSG�MQP �� �)�� � �� !`KNMQW�R�K =ÆPh\OPS^_MVKl^_MQPS\OdfPi[iÓ�Kl^*kq�U]a�[]gSMOKlUq^*�Sv~��UqJmPLU]a !`W*Klg�W�gi[]G��OP ^�UHR*PS�«MOU?a£[]KfdcUq\�MQU�[]I*��M�[]Kf^½a|\�UqJ [?I*[]dldfU]MiÕ ;ÁPmR*KfR�^*U�M°G*��P��MO\OG*g�MQG*\�PhRËMQPS��MykqPS^*Ph\O[�MQKfUq^ JLP�MQW*U�R*� MOUÇZ*\OU�R*G*gSPÊMQW*PA��g�W*PhR*G�dlPh�Sv�^*Uq\TR�KlR !�PAPSÓ�[]dlG*[�MQPoMOW*PhJ[]gSghUq\�R*Kl^*k?MQU��OZ{PhghKN}g gS\OKfMOPh\�Kz[ !£P]Õ¬k*ÕNvcghU�R*PmghU©ÓqPS\Q[]k]P�$�Õ >)^*��MOPi[]R�v�!pP ��KlJmZ*dfsÊ�OPhdfPhg�MQPhRÇPXVHPhghGHMQKlU]^*�MQW*[�M`KldfdlG*��MQ\Q[�MQPh� !`W[�MU!pP�a|PhdNM"!�[��6MOW*P�^*Uq\OJL[]dÆIÆPSW[iÓHKfUq\`U]a�MQW*PY[]G�MOUqJL[�MQUq^ !£[]^*RyMQW[�M`P VHPh\�ghKl��PhRPSÓ]Ph\�sV[]g�MQKlU]^6$�Õ.>)^¾UqG�\�P VHZ{Ph\�KlPh^�ghP]v_G��OKl^�k��OKfJLZ�dlP3�Og�W*PSR*G*dfPh�edlKN�]P3MQW*PS�OP�Kf��[�R*Ph��G[�MOPpa|Uq\�MQW*P�Z*G*\�ZÆUq��PU]a~R�s�^[]JmKlg"Kf^�Ó�[]\�Kz[]^_M¡R�PSMQPSgSMOKlUq^�Õ

� !�� !�� >@?(A�BDCFE�GHE�AJIKBKLME�BDA:NPO=QRNSQTGUNVE�WXAYLVQTZS[=\�NSZ]V^`_ba�cedf^`g�hjilknmocj_0ipcjkrqbsut�q�twv�q�il^`k3x6iyq�z|{=cji�}o^`k�~u_�^�su�uv�tws��j�6i�krmocj_0ipcjkrq�g�he��^j�u_T^j�Sx6zuilv4z�xXtw_0t:zut���~S���u�i�k�q�zut�g�i��|�u�pcoq�i�^`k�_�tw��coq�il^`k�~u_0^f^o��ilk���twv�q�i�^`k��u���S���S�K��zut���^`�u_JxXtw_0tj�

�k���RYU! �I�����?�������F!�O�%�&�C+����M|&��+-��%�����qx-��� �M��������z �C��� �������?���&�dxe�� �?��������zJ1 D ��1�k����]�! ���&�dW����&�S>����FW����&�p+-��%��O&>J�&�J1��I���%��J%����&��k����u�!\�&�M|��U+��S> �����&�&���&� �I�&����21 D ��k���f��! �S> �&��&�&�������I��������%����

��� t�zVc�m`t�cjsusut�s�q�zut�kVcj�!twg �&%��j� ��^`_�v�^`krm`t�kui�t�kuvwt3i�k�q�zSi�g6~u_�t�g�t�knq�coq�il^`k����  ���u���r~u_0^f^o�S^j�fq�zut¡a¢cedf^`g¢g0i��£�S�pcoq�i�^`k=_0tw�pceq�i�^jk=_�tw¤n�uil_�t�s�g0iyd�ilknmocj_0ipcjkrq�gw��¥umjtX��^`_�q�zutXg0i��£�S�pcoq�i�^`k

_�t��pcoq�i�^`k�~S_�^`~¦tw_�hVcjkus�^`kut��!^`_�t���^`_�^jkut�^j�¢q�zut�i�krmocj_�i�cjkrq�g��§��zut�q�x:^!��ilg�g0i�ku¨©ilknmocj_0ipcjkrq�gJx:t�_�tj��k�����q! �N��! #��&����%�� �N����! #��&���%��4+Z���&�dx{�Jz��DQ� ����3b��� � �`.

���&�Fx � �-z DC�����dx ��z ��� � �l�&����d+?�� �����J�M���&��11�k���fª�! �N��! #��&����%��h+5� �I�S> �����&�&���&�8.

� �F!ea����Tx O�%�&��z ���T!�O�%���+�� �bP �>J%&>�;2�\3+�� � � . � �b��%�����qx{� zJ1�1�1

�r«

Page 49: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

��zutwg0t!q�xX^�i�krmocj_�i�cjkrq�g=cj_0t�^`�Sq�g0i�sut�{=coi�}j^jk���g.¨`_�cj�!��cj_wh�g0^�ilq=kut�ilq�zutw_=v4zut�v4}jt�s ku^`_=_�t�~ ^j_0q�t�sq�zStw���K{=cji�}o^`k©su^�twgDku^jq¡_0tw~¦^`_0qDilknmocj_0ipcjkrq�g§x6ilq�z�t9dSilg0q�twkrq�i�cj�u¤n�Vcjkrq�iy¥Vtw_0gwh�ku^`_Ksu^�twgDiyqD_�tw~¦^`_�qKq�zu^`g0tx6ilq�z �!^`_�t�q�zVcjkPc ¨`ilmjtwk�k��S��� t�_�^o�=g����fq�tw_0��g�� ��zui�g!i�g!ku^jq�c ���ukusVcj�!twkrq�cj�6��i��!ilq�coq�il^`k�h��u�fqc�sutwg0i�¨`k�v4zu^`i�v�t©q�zVcoq3_0twsu�uv�twg©{=coi�}j^jk���g�v�^`��~S�Sq4coq�i�^`kucj��_0tw¤n�ui�_0tw�!twkrq�g|cjkus�hb�!^`_�t©il��~¦^`_0q�cjkrq����`hq�zSt�kn�u���¦tw_£^j��� co��g�t�~ ^jg�ilq�ilmjtwg|^j_|�ukuzStw��~f���u�:ilknmocj_0ipcjkrq�g3q�zVcoq©{=coi�}j^jk x:^j�u��s ^oq�zut�_0x6i�g0t�_�t�~ ^j_0q���ft�v�q�il^`k��sSi�g�v��ug�g0twg'~ ^oq�twkrq�ipcj�Ux:c��g.^j�¢i��!~u_�^1m�i�kS¨|q�zuilg�¨`_�co����cj_w�

��k ^j�u_�v�cjg0t�g0q��Ss��`hM{=cjil}j^`k�~S_�^`~¦^`g�t�s���^j�u_�^j�Tq�zut�g0iyd�_0tw¤n�uil_�tws�ilknmocj_0ipcjkrq�gw�K��zuilg�_�twsS�uvwt�s q�zStcj�!^`�ukrqD^j�Uz��S��cjk!t� ^`_�q�� ~Vcj_�q�ilvw�u��cj_����|ku^jk���il��cj¨ji�kVcoq�ilmjtXt� U^`_�q�� _�tw¤n�uil_�t�s���^`_§q�zut(v�^`_�_0twv�q�kut�g�g~u_0^f^j��hSt�m`t�k q�zu^`�u¨`z�ilqJsui�s�ku^jq't���i��!i�kucoq�t(cj���Ug��uv4z z��S��cjk�t� U^`_�q��

��q3i�g=ku^jq�c��u�lt£q�zVcoq ��%��� hbcj�yq�zu^`�S¨`z q�_0�ut!cjkus kutwv�twg0g�cj_�� ��^j_�q�zut�~u_0^f^j��h�x:cjg�ku^jq3~u_0^1mjc��u��t©ilki�g0^`�pceq�i�^jk��:t�g0q4c��u��ilg�zuilku¨�iyq�_�t�¤n�ui�_0tws �ug0t£^j� �&%���� ����k ^jq�zutw_(x:^`_0sugwhUs���kVcj�!i�v|ilkrmjco_�ipcoknq(sut�q�twv�q�il^`k~¦^`g0q��u�pcoq�tws c��ug0t����u��g�i��!~u�lt|~u_0^`~ t�_0q�� � # %���� �'x6zu^`g0t©~u_�^�^j�¡i�g.vw^`�!~u��ilv�coq�tws � �¦twv�co�ug�t�ilq._�t�¤��Si�_�t�g�&%���� ���¢��zui�g�c��ui��lilq���q�^.sut�vw^`�!~¦^`g�t�c(~u_�^�^j�Vilknq�^.~Vco_0q�g¢sutw�!^`kug�q�_�coq�t�gKc(g�q�_�t�ku¨jq�z©^j�M^`�u_Tq�t�v4zukui�¤n�uto�ilq�ilg�t�cjg�� q�^ v4zutwv4} ~u_0^`~ t�_0q�i�twg�s���kVco��ilv�cj�l���`hDt�m`twk�il�'q�zut�� zVc�m`t vw^`�!~u��ilv�coq�tws ~u_0^f^o��g�q�zVcoq�cj_0t�¦t��`^jkus q�zut�v�cj~Vc��ui��lilq�iltwgX^j��v�^`�!~u��t�q�tw����co�Sq�^`��coq�i�v�g�q4coq�i�v�q�^�^`�lgw�

� !�� !� ��BDE�LVQTO Q (QTGT[(NVE�WXA

��zut¡��^`�u_0q�z�g�q�t�~|i�k3^`�u_b�!t�q�zS^fs3i�gbcj~u~S_�^`~u_0ipcoq�tKx6zutwk|coq�q�tw�!~Sq�ilku¨�q�^(mjtw_0il���3c6g�i��|�u�pcoq�i�^`k=_0tw��coq�il^`k��  g'ku^jq�tws i�k��ftwv�q�i�^jk��u���S���Shuq�zut���   g�il�£�u�pceq�^`_Jvwcjk�zStw��~ �ug�t�_�g'��^`_��£�S�pcoq�t�cjkus�q�twg�q.q�zut3mocj�li�suiyq��^j�¢c|��^`_�xJcj_0s�g�i��|�u�pcoq�i�^`k!_�t��pcoq�i�^`kUhf~u_0i�^`_¡q�^©g0�uv4z�c|mjtw_0il¥Vvwcoq�il^`k�����k�q�zSi�gJg0twv�q�i�^`kUhSx:t�suilg�v��ug�g�zu^1xc�g0v4zutwsS�u��t�cjkus ^oq�zut�_�ilkS��^`_���coq�i�^`k vwcjkPzut���~ i�k t�dftwv��Sq�ilku¨ ~Vcoi�_�t�s co�Sq�^`��coq�cSh¡x6zSi���t�q�zut!��  g�il�£�u��coq�^`_Dq�t�g0q�gJq�zut=v�^`kusuiyq�i�^jkug:^j�Tq�zut�_�t��pcoq�i�^`kU����zuilg�g�v4zut�su�u��ilku¨£x6i��l� ��coq�t�_"�¦t��ug0t����u��ilk�¨`�uilsui�ku¨m`t�_�iy¥Vv�coq�i�^`kU�

��k�]�i�¨`�S_�t�����«Shfq�zut=g�il�£�u��coq�il^`k�_0tw��coq�il^`k�i�gXq�zut=ilsutwkrq�iyq���^`k�co���Ug�q4coq�t�mocj_�i�c��u��t�g:^j� ��)�% � t�dfvwt�~Sq��� )��-��% hUx6zuilv4z i�g.kS^jq=c�g�q4coq�t|mocj_�i�c��u�lt�^j� �� �)-� � �� �=��zut£g�il�£�u��coq�il^`k _0tw��coq�il^`k�sut�¥Vkut�g ��� )����-% ilk� )-% � q�^ v�^`krq4cjilk c�mocj���ut � iy�'cjkus ^`ku��� il�Jq�zutw_0t�i�g£c g��uv�vwtwg0g0���u�#�Vco����^oq�ilk �� �)�� � � x6ilq�z mocj���ut� �6��zut ��������� �u��^�v4}�i�g'g0q�_�cji�¨jznq0��^`_0x:cj_0s ��^`_6q�zut�g0q�cj_0q.g0q4ceq�t£cokus���^`_6q�zut�t�d�q�t�_�kVco�§cjv�q�i�^jkugw�Jtwcjv4zt�d�q�tw_�kucj�¡cjv�q�i�^`k i�k q�zut�il��~S��tw�!twkrq�coq�il^`k cj�fq�^`��coq�^jk ilg���coq�v4zutws$��� q�zut!cjv�q�il^`k x6ilq�z q�zSt!g�cj�!tkVcj�!t�ilk�q�zut�g�~¦twv�il¥Vvwcoq�il^`k�cj�Sq�^`��coq�^`kU�§��zut�i�krq�t�_�kVco��cjv�q�i�^jkug � � �( � h � � � �� � �)�� h � �,� � � # % hVcokus��)(��� co_�t���ceq�v4zut�s����cjk�tw�!~Sq���t9dftwvw�fq�i�^jk g0tw¤n�utwkSvwt£^j�bq�zSt3g0~ t�vwiy¥Vv�coq�i�^`k�cj�fq�^`��coq�^jk��

��k|^`�S_¢vwcjg�t¡g0q��us��`heq�zut%��   g�il�£�u��coq�^`_Rvwcjk3_�t�mjt�cj�nq�xX^.~u_0^��u��t���gRx6iyq�z�c(�!^`_�tKkVcoilm`tDq�_0t�coq���t�krq � � � � � � � � � �J�&���S)�� ���� + �q! #��&�&�%��<��� !�����S>��21*�M)��%��� � � � � � � � � �A�M��������J�����������S����+ �q! #��&���%��p1

� � ��� � � ��� � � � �o�M(J%&%��� ���� +�����%����� Y[W ���&�Fx{�Jz�W5������1 � �

i�k q�zut ��������� �S��^�v4}���^`_(q�zut©ilknq�tw_0kVcj�§cov�q�il^`kug � � ��# � % � � cjkSs #&%���� % � &�� � #�' � �|]¢i�_�g�q�h�¨jilm`t�kc�g�v4zut�su�u��t�q�zVcoq't9dSt�vw�Sq�twg #&%���� % � &�� � #�' � q�x6i�v�t|ilk �� �)�� � �� hVq�zut�g0i��£�S�pcoq�^`_�sui�g0vw^1m`t�_�g'q�zVcoq'q�zSt~u_0twvw^jkusuilq�i�^`k ��^`_ ��� ) )���� � � � cjil��g6q�zut|g�twv�^`kus q�il��t3ilq.i�g(t�dftwv��Sq�t�s�ilk�q�zut|��^�v4}�g�q�t�~ t�dftwv��Sq�il^`k ^j�� )-% � ���ft�vw^`kSs�h � � ��# � % � � kutwt�sug(q�^!¥u_�t ��� )�)��-� � � il��c'�Vcj���l^jq6zVcjg#�¦twt�k sutwv�i�sut�s�ilknq�tw_0kVcj�����(�u�fqsu^�twg¡ku^jq)�`t�qJzVc�mjt�c=mjco���ut'cjg0g�i�¨jkutws�*�zut�kuvwt'x:t(�£�ug0qD¥V_0t ��� )�)���� � � x6zutwk�¥V_�ilku¨ � � ��# � % � � h��u�fq^`ku����iy��ku^!^jq�zutw_#�Vcj�l��^jqJi�k �� �)�� � �,+ ��� ��� � ��'���' zVcjg'c�ku^`k���kui��Umocj�l�utj�.- ^jg0q(^j�¢q�zui�g6vwcjg�t�cjkVcj����g�i�gi�g�kStwvwt�g�g�cj_/�� t�v�cj�Sg�t �� �)-� � � cj�l��^1x6g0�Vco����^oq�gJq�^'�¦t=m`^jq�tws�^jk � cjkus�q�^�g��uv�vwt�twsM�#� t���^`_�t=q�zSt���cj_0tcjg0g�i�¨jkutws�mocj���ut�gw�

��1

Page 50: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� ��������� � ��� � � � ��� � � � ����%������Y � �CL&%�����!L&%����KWM�?�[�M� ��������ED ����%��J��� Y[WM�?�[�M�R���������3L&%����KW ���%��%J����� D ����%��J��� Y[W����%��J%����&�n3L&%����KW5�������S����� D ����%��J��� Y[W5���J���S����� 3L&%����KW5:&�������� D ����%��J��� Y[W5:&�������� 3�b�F!�����S>��"+e� �bL&%����UWM�?(�%������ �

�A�T! #��&���%��4+5� � ���&%��J����Y2W?�M>R�&����������� 3 ����%��J��� Y[W����&�dx{�Jz D �?;�����F+ �g1v1&1� � � � � � �� � � BL�%�����WM�?�[�M� ��������T!$a���� x O�%�&��zC! D ���&%�������Y[WS�?�R�S� ������&� L�%�����W����%���%J���&�d! a���Tx�����S>��JzC! D ���&%�������Y[W5���%��%J����� L�%�����W?�?(�%������~!$a����x�����S>��Jz ! D � � L�%�����We���J���S�����F!$a���� x O�%�&��z ! D ���&%�������Y[W5�������S���&� L�%�����We:&��������X!$a����x O�%��&��z ! D ���&%�������Y[W5:��������

� � � � � � � � �v�S������T+eaF!$a&����x O�%�&�JzU��#q!$a���� x #��&�&�%��2zJ1*�?)��%��� � � � � � �l�k� �M�d+?��! O�%�&�F� ��!���&�S>��g1 � � ��� � � � � �c�k� �?�d+k�p� �[1 � � � � � � � ��:&�����U+?��! O�%�&�[1 � � ��� � � � � �*:&�����p+?��1 � � � � � � � � � �v�&���&�M���F+k��! O�%���F� ��!�����S>��21 � � ��� � � � � � � �v�����&�M�&�T+k�p���21 � � � � � � � � � � �E; ������#J���&�&%�U+�� ! #��&�&�%��p1N�?)��%��� � � � � � � � � � ��� �������?�U+M�p! O�%�&�F��# ! a����Tx�#��&���%�[zJ1N�?)��%��� � � � � � � � � � ��%����K+k��! O�%���F��� ! #��&���%��U1*�?)��%��� � � � � � � � � � ���&���M)&������g+ �q! #��&���%��<� �T!���&�S>��g1 � � _�+ � � ����%��J��� Y[Wk�M>R�&�����������R1 � � � ��?)��%��

� � ��� �o� ! #��&�&�%��h+�� � ����%������Y[W?�S> �����&�&���&�n3 ���&%�������Y[W �����dx{�Jz��DQ�R���J1� � � � �?)���%���

���������� � � � � � � � �m�S(�%�%���������g+��R1

� � � � � � � � � � � �A�?�����&��������J���S���U+ �q! #��&����%��p1 � � +5� � ����%������Y[W?�S> �����&�&���&� 1 � ������?)��%��

� � ��� +����%������Y[W������Kx ��zEDQ� ���R1 � � � ��?)��%��

� � ��� �o� ! #��&�&�%��h+�� � ����%������Y[W?�S> �����&�&���&�n3 ���&%�������Y[W �����dx{�Jz��DQ�R���J1� � � � �?)���%���

���������� � � � � � � � �m�S(�%�%���������g+ ���&%��J����Y2W ���&�dx{��z�W����&��1

� � �

]�il¨`�u_�t�����«S��]V^`_0x:cj_�s g0i��£�u��coq�il^`k _0tw��coq�il^`k cjkus g�q�tw~ v�^`_�_0twg�~¦^`kusStwkuv�t ����������� �u�l^fv4}f����_�^j� q�zSt� ���� �� g�~¦twv�il¥Vvwcoq�il^`k � ]�il¨`�u_�t=�S���S���7�Xq�^�q�zut�� ����� il��~u�ltw�!twkrq4ceq�i�^jk � ]¢i�¨`�u_0t=�u���S���1���

���

Page 51: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

��zui�g'ku^`kSsut�q�tw_��!i�kSi�g�� ��co}jtwg6q�zSt|cj�l¨`^`_0ilq�zS� �!^`_�t=¨jtwkut�_�cj��h �u�Sq'ilq6v�^`��~S��i�vwcoq�t�gJq�zut3vw^j_�_�t�v�q��kut�g�g|~S_�^�^j�����'twkuv�t�iyq=xJcjg�zutw�l~S���u�§q�^ �ug0t�~ucji�_0tws g�i��|�u�pcoq�i�^`k q�^ sSt �u�u¨�q�zut!sut�q4cjil��g=^j�Xq�zut!g0q�tw~vw^j_�_�t�g�~¦^`kusut�kuvwt|cjkus�cj_0_�ilmjt3coq�q�zut=��^`_0�£�u��coq�il^`k�g�zS^7x6k i�k�]�il¨`�u_0t=����«S�

��������� � QbLME � ?(E0A��FB ZuE�C [=\�B�NVE�WXA LVQb\�B�NVE�W:A E�A � �

��zut���cjg0qKg�q�t�~!ilk£^`�u_���t�q�zu^�s©i�gbq�^=~u_0^7mjt�q�zutJg0i��£�S�pcoq�i�^`k�_�tw��coq�il^`k � ^`_§ilknmocj_0ipcjkrq4�T�ug0i�ku¨�c.q�zutw^j_�tw�~u_0^7mjtw_���'tw_0t.x:t=sStwg�v�_�i�� t�zS^7x q�zSt�_�t�g��u�yq�gJ^j�¢��twv�q�i�^`kSgJ�u���S���£cjkus��u���S� ��v�cjk �¦t��ug0tws�q�^|¨`twkut�_�coq�tq�zSi�g�ilku~u�Sq�cj�Sq�^`��ceq�i�vwcj�����`� ]�il_�g�q�hJq�zSt i�krmocj_�i�cjkrq�g!g��u¨j¨`twg�q�tws ����s���kVcj�!i�v�ilkrmjco_�ipcoknq�sut�q�twv�q�il^`k�¦twvw^j��t v�cjkSsui�sVceq�twg��ltw�!��cjg�h(q�zutw_0t ��� g�c�m�i�ku¨ q�zut �ug�t�_�q�i��!t i�k ¥Vkusuilku¨�cj�fdfi��lipcj_��Pi�krmocj_0ipcjkrq�gkut�twsut�s���^`_§mjtw_�iy¥Vv�ceq�i�^jk��K�ft�vw^`kSs�hrq�zut'cjkukS^jq4coq�i�^`kSg���^`_K~Vcjil_�t�s©t�dftwv��Sq�il^`k�~S_�^1m�i�sut'c=~u_�^�^j�¦^`�Sq���ilkutj�

't�v�cj�l�K��_�^`� �ft�v�q�i�^`k ��� �f����q�zVcoq3m`t�_�il����ilku¨ c�g�i��|�u�pcoq�i�^`k _0tw��coq�il^`k�_0tw¤n�uil_�twg3m`t�_�il����ilku¨!�¦^jq�z cg0q�cj_0q�v�^`kusuiyq�il^`k cjkus c g0q�tw~ vw^`kusSilq�il^`k����¢_�cjkug���coq�il^`k q�^f^`�lg£i�k q�zut ��   q�^�^`�l}�iyq£�ug0t�q�zut ���������u�l^fv4}!��^`_6c!g0i��£�S�pcoq�i�^`k�_�tw��coq�il^`k�q�^�¨`t�kutw_�coq�t3~u_0^f^j�Tq�cjv�q�i�vwg���^`_�twcjv4z�vw^`kusSilq�il^`k��

� ����������� ���������������zut6g0q�cj_0q§vw^`kusSilq�il^`k£_0tw¤n�ui�_0twgK¥VkusSi�ku¨�c.x6iyq�kut�g�gDg0q�cj_0qKg�q4coq�t��X^j�Mq�zut�g�~¦twv�il¥Vvwcoq�il^`k!cj�Sq�^j��coq�^`k�� ��kq�zSt6a�cedf^`gDv�cog�t6g0q��us��`hrq�zut6~u_�^�^j�¦g�v�_�i�~fqD¨`twkut�_�coq�^`_§q�_�cjkug0�pcoq�tws£q�zSt ����������������� g0twv�q�i�^jk!^o�U]¢i�¨`�u_0tJ����«i�krq�^�q�zut=��^`���l^1x6i�ku¨£v�^`�!��cjkSsugJ��^`_��Ta��

"!�#%$%&('�!*)�+,!('�&(-")%'/.%-"&('0- � !0$213.�-0&�-"!"465 � $7)�8,&0$:9<; � .�-0&(-0!"4=5?>7)�@:4�;&"474A!�'%-B.(-"&%'7- � !0$DCE&F1G.�-0&�-0!�4=5 � $7)�8�&"$:9H;,IKJ 5 � �ML ����L � �ML ����L � � ;+7'")�N0!O4<-0&('%-=CE&P1Q.�-0&�-"!"465 � $7)�8,&0$:9H;,ISR � 8=1Q.(-0&�-0!"465?>0)A@:40;TC%4<-0&�'7-PC?8UIWV/XFCY& L 8ZI(I'0!�4�[A\:!^]"_`R'0!�4�[A\:!^]"_a4<+,!�#"bA&0$,bHc�b�@0de8 ��� .%-"&('0- � !0$fCG&0#�I

�(t�_�tohSq�zut'q�x:^ ������� � ! � v�^`�!��cjkSsug:suil_�t�v�q��Ta q�^ � t�¨`i�k�q�zut�~u_0^f^o� �����ug0i�ku¨|ilq�g.�u�uil�lq/��i�k!i��!~u��i �v�ceq�i�^jk�q�cjv�q�i�vohSx6zui�v4z cjg0g��u�!twg�q�zSt3z���~¦^jq�zut�g�ilg.cjkSs _0tw~u��cjvwt�g6q�zut��ukuiym`tw_0g�cj�l����¤��ucjkrq�il¥utws�mjco_�ipc��u��t� ��� c ¥Sdft�sPvw^`kSg0q4coknq ��� hJcjkSs q�zutwk��ug�ilku¨ ��� �� ����� �� ����� cjg©q�zSt�x6iyq�kut�g�g���^`_©q�zut�t�dfi�g�q�t�knq�ipcj�¤n�Vcjkrq�iy¥Vtw_ ��� � ��k�q�zSt.v�cog�t.g�q��us��`hfq�zutwg0t�vw^j����cjkusugXcj_0t(g0�"g!vwi�t�krq:q�^|vw^`�!~u��t�q�t�q�zSt.~u_0^f^j��^j��q�zStg0q�cj_0q'v�^`kusuiyq�i�^jk��

� ��h%ij��� ���������������zut=g�q�tw~�v�^`kusuiyq�il^`k�_0tw¤n�ui�_0twgJ¥VkSsui�ku¨£c|x6ilq�kStwg�g:t�dftwv��Sq�il^`klk ^o�Rq�zut�g0~ t�vwiy¥Vv�coq�i�^`k�cj�Sq�^j��coq�^`k���^j_t�cov4z�q�_�cjkSg�ilq�i�^`k|^j�Vq�zut�il��~S��tw�!twkrq�coq�il^`k|co�Sq�^`��coq�^`k��b��zut�~u_�^�^j�Mg0vw_�il~SqK¨`t�kutw_�coq�^j_���^`_��|�u�pcoq�twgbq�zuilg~u_0^f^j�¢^��u�li�¨rceq�i�^jk���^`_��TaPcjg���^`�l��^1x6gw�

+7'")�N0!X2CE&61Y.�-0&(-0!"4=5nm:; L 8o1Y.�-0&(-0!"4=5qp,;�I

Va4<-0!A+=CY& L &7$H+%r"&s1tm:#A-�bA)(@�4�5um,; L & � 1Q.�-0&�-"!"4=5qm,;,ISR� 8"!�-"&61?m�#H- bA)�@,.7! � 5vp:;wCA! � !�#AX7'"&%dMCx8 L 8"!(-0&UIyV/XPCE& �:L $(&"4<-PC?8 L 8�!�-0&UI%I3V

-%'0&"#�!PCY8"!�-0&ZI`Jz-%'"&"#A!PC�&7$H+7r"&UI(I

��q¢cj��g0^6¨`twkut�_�coq�twg¢c�~u_�^�^j�fg�vw_0i�~SqTq�zVcoqTsuiymfilsutwgRq�zutD~u_�^�^j�fi�krq�^6v�cog�twg �Vcjg0tws�^`k=q�zut¡}ni�kus�^j�fq�zut¡cjv�q�i�^jk� � �ug�ilku¨�q�zSt©vw^`�!��cokus ���&�(� ��! � # %%{�� � � #()-%*)-% � hUx6zuilv4z sui�_0twv�q�g|�Ta q�^�~¦tw_0��^j_�� g0q�_0�uv�q��u_�co�i�kSsu�uv�q�i�^`k�^`k|q�zutJsVcoq�coq���~ t:^j� � �bcjkus©¨`t�kutw_�coq�ilku¨.�ltw�!��cogbq�^.zVcjkSsu��t¡q�zutJsSt�q4coi���gb^j�Vq�zutJi�kSsuilm�i�sS�Vcj�

� �

Page 52: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

v�cog�twg��:]V^`_�t9dScj��~S��tjhSilq6¨`t�kutw_�coq�t�g6q�zut=��^`���l^1x6i�ku¨£�ltw�!��c©cokus�~u_�^�^j�¢g�vw_0i�~Sq6��_0^`� q�zut ��������� �u�l^fv4}��^`_Jq�zut # %,# � cjv�q�i�^jk�ilk�q�zut3a�c7dS^jg(vwcjg�t�g0q��us��j�

+7'")�N0!X2CE&61Y.�-0&(-0!"4=5 � $%)�8,&0$�9<; L 8o1Y.�-0&�-"!"4=5?>7)A@�47;�I

Va4<-0!A+=CY& L b�@�b�-PC�b L NUI L & � I R� 8"!�-"&61?m�#H- bA)�@,.7! � 5?>7)A@�47;wCH! � !,#HX7'�&(dMC 8 L 8"!�-0&ZI3V/XFCY& �:L $(&�4<-FC?8 L 8"!�-0&fI%IWV

-%'"&"#A!PCY8"!�-"&ZI Ja-%'0&"#A!PC�&0$H+%r"&UI(I���'0!�4�[A\:!^]"_KR'0!�4�[A\:!^]"_a4<+,!�#"bA&0$,bHc�b�@0d 8"!�-0& � � b�@�b�-6CHb�# L N�# I�� � �

�Ta ¥Vkuilg�zut�g(q�zSt�~u_0^f^o�§^j�§q�zui�g6�ltw�!��c�cj�Sq�^`��coq�ilv�cj�l���`hScjg'ilq(cj��g0^�su^ft�g(��^`_�q�zut � � #( h � � � �� � � �)�� h� �,� � � # % hMcjkSs ��)���� cjv�q�i�^`kug��

��zut ~S_�^�^j�|g0vw_0i�~Sq�g���^`_�q�zut ��tw�!��cjg���^`_�q�zSt � � ��# � % � � cjkus # %���� % � &�� � #�{ � cov�q�il^`kug�cj_0tq�zStw�!g�tw�ym`t�g!sSilm�i�sut�s i�krq�^ vwcjg�t�gwh:ilk cjvwv�^`_�sucjkuvwt�x6ilq�z q�zut � ��� g�q4coq�tw�!twkrq�g©��^`_|q�zu^`g0t cov�q�il^`kug©ilkq�zSt ��������� �u�l^fv4}M�D]V^`_Jt9duco��~u�ltjh�q�zut=~u_0^f^o�¢g0vw_0i�~Sq6¨`t�kutw_�coq�^j_�~u_�^�su�uv�twg�q�zut���^j����^1x6ilku¨|�ltw�!��c£cokusg�v�_�il~Sq6��^`_Jq�zut #&%���� % � &�� � #�{�� cjv�q�il^`k��

+7'")�N0!X2CE&61Y.�-0&(-0!"4=5 � $%)�8,&0$�9<; L 8o1Y.�-0&�-"!"4=5?>7)A@�47;�I

Vz4H-0!A+=CE& L b<@0-�!('%@,&0$��"!�#"bH "!�Cx8o1 p"&7$7$()�- L & � ISR� 8"!�-"&61?m�#H- bA)�@,.7! � 5?>7)A@�47;wCH! � !,#HX7'�&(dMC 8 L 8"!�-0&ZI3V/XFCY& �:L $(&�4<-FC?8 L 8"!�-0&fI%IWV

-%'"&"#A!PCY8"!�-"&ZI Ja-%'0&"#A!PC�&0$H+%r"&UI(I���'0!�4�[A\:!^]"_KR'0!�4�[A\:!^]"_z#A&"4A!�4e8,# � &0# � 4H[�#0#�!7!7 0!7 ��� '([�!T#�&"4A!'0!�4�[A\:!^]"_a4<+,!�#"bA&0$,bHc�b�@0d*8"!�-0& � � ���� $"4A!�b�� #A&�4A!'0!�4�[A\:!^]"_z#A&"4A!�4 &0# � N0&7$65q8,#7;3J @ bA$��� '([�! #A&�4A!'0!�4�[A\:!^]"_z4<+,!�#0b�&0$,bHc:b<@0d 8"!�-0& � � ����� $04�!�b��B#A&�4A!'0!�4�[A\:!^]"_B#A&"4A!"4 � 8=1?p�&7$%$()�- C?8 � &0# � 4H[�#0#�!7!7 0!7 Vw&0# � N0&7$65n8,#7; �JB@�bA$:I� � '(["!w#A&�4A!'0!"4<[A\:!^]0_ 4<+,!�#0b�&0$,bHc:b<@0d 8"!�-0& � � ���� X0&7$"4A!w#A&"4A!'0!"4<[A\:!^]0_ 4<+,!�#0b�&0$,bHc:b<@0d 8"!�-0& � � #Hr�)0)�4�! &"$fCG&0# � N0&0$F5u8,#7; � N0&7$ZI�� ���

�Ta kut�twsug£���S_0q�zStw_�cjg0g�i�g�q4cjkSvwt�q�^ ¥ukui�g0z q�zut�~u_0^f^o�(^o�'q�zui�g|��tw�!��cSh¢x6zuilv4z �ug�t�g!ilkrmjco_�ipcoknq�g ��%� �q�zS_�^`�u¨jz ��%��� � ��krmocj_�i�cjkrq �&%��� ilgR�ug�t�s3x6zut�k ��� )�)��-� � � ilgUq�zut§x6iyq�kut�g�gTt�dft�vw�Sq�i�^`k=��^`_ #&%���� % � &�� � #�{ �q�^�g0zu^1x q�zVceq=q�zut£mocj�l�ut � t�i�ku¨�v4zu^jg�twk � t���^`kS¨`g�q�^ � )-% � + � ) ��)��-�H{ �©��zut�^jq�zutw_=��^`�u_=ilkrmjco_�ipcoknq�gwhx6zuilv4z g0zu^1x q�zVcoq�cj��� �Vcj�l��^jq�g.ku^jq.i�k �� �)�� � ��,+ {�� � { zVc�m`t�i�sut�krq�i�vwcj�b^`_.kuil�¢mocj�l�utwg�h�zutw�l~ twg�q4c��S��i�g0zq�zucoq6v4zVcjku¨jtwg6q�^ �� �)-� � � + ��� ��� � �<{��<{ cjkus �� �)�� � � + � � ~S_�twg0tw_�m`t�q�zut�g�il�£�u��coq�il^`k�_�t��pcoq�i�^`kU�

� zutwk ��������� �S��^�v4}�g'cj_0t���^`_0t�vw^j��~u�li�vwcoq�t�s�q�zVcjk�q�zS^`g�t�i�k�q�zut3a�cedf^`g'v�cog�t�g0q��us��`huq�zut��0^���^j�q�zSt=~u_�^�^j�bg�v�_�i�~fq6¨`twkut�_�coq�^`_�i�g:vw^`_0_�twg0~ ^jkusui�kS¨`������^j_�t=vw^j��~u�li�vwcoq�t�s��§]V^`_Jt9dScj��~S��tjhfq�zut=¨`t�kutw_�coq�^j_�£�ug�q3t�df~Vcjkus�c � ��� twkrq�_�� i�k q�zSt �������� �u��^�v4}�v�^`krq4cjilkug3c�g�tw¤n�ut�kuvwt�^j�Xvw^`kusSilq�il^`kVcj�¢g0q�coq�t���t�knq�gg��Sv4z cjg

��� 9 � ����� ��� � &,9 ������� ��� � &�� ���� � � ����� ��� � &�� ������� ��� � & � �

i�krq�^!^jkut=q�zVcoq6v�^`krq4cjilkug6kutwg�q�t�s�vw^jkusuilq�i�^`kucj��gXg��uv4z�cjg

�`�

Page 53: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

��� 9 � �������� � � ����� �� � &,9 ��� � &�� ������� ��� � &,9 ��� � & � �

���������� � � ����� �� � &�� ��� � &�� ������� ��� � &�� ��� � & � �

i�k�^`_0sutw_�q�^!¨jtwkut�_�coq�t�q�zut3cj~u~u_0^`~u_0ipcoq�t=v�cjg0t3g0~u��iyq�g�ilk�q�zut�~u_�^�^j�bg�v�_�il~Sq�� .�Xv�^`�u_0g�tjhRq�zut©i�krmocj_�i�cjkrq�g(�ug�t�s q�^�twg0q�c��u�li�g�z c�g0i��£�S�pcoq�i�^`k _�tw��coq�il^`k��|�ug0q �¦t|m`t�_�iy¥Vtws q�zut��'�

g�t��lmjtwgw� �(t�_�t�q�^f^ShMq�zut|g0i��£�S�pcoq�^`_6cjkus ilkrmjco_�ipcoknq'sut�q�t�v�q�^j_.~u_0^7m�ilsut|zut���~��']�il_�g�q�hMi�krmocj_�i�cjkrq�g'g�^`�!t��q�il��t�gD_�tw¤n�uil_�t'^jq�zStw_:ilkrmjco_�ipcoknq�gDi�k�q�zut�i�_D~u_�^�^j��g�� ��k�q�zSt(vwcjg�t(g0q��Ss��`hf^`ku��� ��%��� _0tw¤n�uil_�tws�cj�fdfi��lipcj_��i�krmocj_0ipcjkrq�g � ��%� � cokus �&%���� ��ho^`kut:^o�ux6zui�v4z�xJcjg§{=cji�}o^`k|sut�q�t�v�q�t�s��D�ft�vw^`kSs�h`q�zutXg0q�coq�t���t�knq�^j�Vv�^`�'�~u�li�v�ceq�tws�i�krmocj_�i�cjkrq�gDg��Sv4z cog �&%���� v�cok(� t'q�t�g0q�t�s�m�ipc�g0i��£�S�pcoq�tws!t�dftwv��Sq�il^`k�*u^`kSvwt.g�q4coq�tws�~S_�^`~¦tw_0���`hq�zSt3~S_�^�^j��^o�¢q�zui�g�ilknmocj_0ipcjkrqJx:cjg'_�coq�zutw_�g0i��!~u��to�

��u_�q�twv4zukuil¤n�utwg�su^�ku^jq�vw^`�!~u��t�q�t���� tw�li��!i�kVceq�t�q�zSt�kut�twsP��^`_!zn�u��cokP¨`�uilsVcjkuv�t ilk ~u_0^7m�ilku¨i�krmocj_0ipcjkrq�g(cjkus�g�i��|�u�pcoq�i�^`k�_�t��pcoq�i�^`kSgw�6��zut���v�cjk cj�Sq�^j��coq�i�vwcj������suilg�vw^1mjtw_wh�cjkus ~u_0^1m`t£x6ilq�z��lilq�q���tzn�u��cjk�cjg�g0i�g�q4cjkuv�tjhuilkrmjco_�ipcoknq�g:g0�uv4z�cog �&%�� � h �&%�� � hVcjkus ��%��� �K��zut���vwcjkuku^jq �jt�q6suilg�v�^7mjtw_�ilknmocj_0i��cjkrq�gDg0�uv4z�cjg ��%� � cjkus �&%���� hnt�m`t�k�q�zu^`�u¨`z©q�zutwil_§~u_�^�^j��gDcj_0t6g�i��!~u�ltj�   kus!cj�yq�zu^`�S¨`z©q�zut��©sui�g0vw^1m`t�_i�krmocj_0ipcjkrq �&%��� hjx6zui�v4z|i�g�g0i��!~u��toheq�zut:~S_�^�^j�M^j�uq�zui�g¢i�krmocj_�i�cjkrq¢�Sg�i�kS¨|�Ta _0tw¤n�uil_�twg���^�sutw_�coq�t¡zn�u��cjk¨`�uilsVcjkuv�tj�

�j�

Page 54: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

�o�

Page 55: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� � ��� ����

� � � ���� �� � ��������� � � ������� ��� ��� � �! �"�#� � ��%$ � ��& � ��'�����( ��)�'� � ����� � �" �

*,+.- /1032547698;:;<=2�>?6@0  s���kVcj�!i�v ilkrmjco_�ipcoknq�sut�q�twv�q�i�^`k q�^f^`�.^��ug�t�_0mjtwg�~u_�^`¨j_�cj� t�dftwv��Sq�il^`kug cjkus ^`�Sq�~u�Sq�g�~u_0^`~¦tw_0q�i�t�g� �l^`¨`ilv�cj�V��^`_0�£�u�pcot1�§q�zVcoqJcj_�t(q�_��St�^j�Rq�zSt�t�dftwv��Sq�il^`kug6cjkSs�cj_�t(��i�}otw���!q�^��¦t.q�_0�ut�^j�Rq�zut�~u_0^`¨`_�co� ilk¨`t�kutw_�cj�*�|]M^j_�t�dScj�!~u��tohTcjk i�krmocj_�i�cjkrq=sut�q�twv�q�^`_=�!i�¨jznq�_�tw~¦^`_�q=q�zVcoq3ceq=twkrq�_�� q�^�~u_0^fv�twsu�S_�t��BADCBCfhE3FGHJIJKLKNMPOQG ESR K TBHVUNWYX *rq�zucoq¡coq¡t�dfilqK��_0^`� ~S_�^�vwtwsS�u_�t[Z]\.^uhN_V` G _badc � x6zut�_�tb_�i�g§q�zut�mocj_�i�c��u��t���gmocj���St�ceq�t�krq�_/��cjkSs�_ ` i�g�q�zut�mocj���ut!coq3t9dSiyq9� *�^`_�q�zVceq|ceq3��_0^`� q�zSt�~¦^`i�krq�^j�Xm�i�t�x ^j��cjk�� vw�li�t�knq^j�6v��pcjg0gfefh�g R Ofh g R _f����zut�_0tw~¦^`_0q�tws ~S_�^`~¦tw_�q�i�t�gwh�x6zSi�v4z cj_0t�g/��krq4cov�q�ilv�cj�l��� ilsutwkrq�ilv�cj�Dq�^���^`_���cj�g�~¦twv�il¥Vvwcoq�il^`kug�hMcj_�t�cj�lg�^�}nku^1x6k cjg6�li�}jt�����i�krmocj_�i�cjkrq�g��

��krmjco_�ipcoknq�sut�q�twv�q�i�^jk zVcjg�cj~u~u�li�vwcoq�il^`kug©q�^�~u_�^`¨j_�cj� t�m`^`�l�Sq�il^`kjilknm=oqp ����sr�h�g0q�coq�ilv�mjtw_�iy¥Vv�c �q�il^`ktiupvk � �`hwp(i�� �r�jcnh�pxk �r����hwpvk �`�ovjh�yDr�h�~u_0^`¨`_�cj� _�t�� cjv�q�^`_�ilku¨ziu{Qknoqp ���|r�h§cj�fq�^`��coq�t�s q�zutw^ �_�t�� ~u_0^1mfilku¨�iupvk �r�jcSh}pxknoq~ �`�Sh�yNr*h�q�twg0q�i�ku¨�i�yVhU�.cj_ �r��h�yuh�yBr*hRg0^j�q�xJco_�t��u~u¨`_�cjsut�g�i�yDr�hTcjku^j��cj���sut�q�twv�q�il^`k�i �{3���r�Vr�hK� cj�u�yq©sut�q�twv�q�i�^jk�i {={|�1k �r��hK{�^�s �r�rhP��� �`�fhnyNr*hDtw_0_�^`_©ilg�^`��coq�il^`k�i�yVhnyDr�hXcokustw_0_�^`_�~S_�t�mjtwkrq�il^`k"i�yDr�hMcj�!^`ku¨©^jq�zutw_0gw�

  kucjilmjt�il��~u�ltw�!twkrq4ceq�i�^jk ^j�Js��fkucj��ilv�i�krmocj_�i�cjkrq�sut�q�twv�q�i�^`k�i�g�ku^jq3sui g!vw�u�yq�� � t!~u_�t�g�twkrq£cjkc��ug�q�_�cjv�q�co��¨`^`_0ilq�zu� i�k ��twv�q�i�^`k �����`���f�H{�^`ilku¨ iyq�v�^`_�_0twv�q���� cjkus tEg�v�i�t�knq����jh'zS^7xXt�mjtw_�h�_�t�¤��Si�_�t�gg�^j��t q�zu^`�u¨`zrqw� ��zut q�x:^ vw^j_�_�t�v�q�kutwg0g ~u_0^`~¦tw_0q�i�t�g�x:t x6i�g0z q�^ ~u_�t�g�t�_0m`t x6zui��lt ^`~Sq�i��!i���i�ku¨ cjki�krmocj_0ipcjkrq(i�kS��t�_�twkSvwt£co��¨`^`_0ilq�zu� cj_0t��.�������N�}�Y�Y�©cjkSs��Y���x�����������}�Y�Y��� � t���^`_0��co������sut�¥ukut£q�zut�g�t©cogi�k �ftwv�q�i�^jk$�f���j���Sh¦x6ilq�zui�k�q�zut£v�^`krq�t�d�q3^j�¡c9�N���N�����N�9hU^`_'q�zut©g0t�q=^o�¡��^j_��£�u��cjt�cjk cj��¨j^`_�iyq�zu� vwcjk^`�Sq�~u�Sqw�

  k tYg!v�i�twkrq3i�kf��tw_�t�kuvwilku¨�cj�l¨`^`_0ilq�zS� ilg�sut�g�i�_�c��u�ltjh�ilk q�tw_0��g.^j�Dq�i��!t©cjkSs g�~Vcjv�t�kutwt�sutws��|��zut~u_0i���cj_/��tYg!vwiltwkuv���vw^`kuv�tw_0k�h t�ilq�zutw_�x6zut�k cjsusSi�ku¨�^jq�zutw_6^`~Sq�i��!i��wcoq�il^`kug:^j_'t9df~Vcjkusuilku¨�q�zut3¨`_�co�'���cj_whrilg§q�^�}jt�tw~�q�zut'cj��¨j^`_�iyq�zu�����}��� �������¡�¢�N���   k!i�kuv�_�t���t�knq�cj�Vcj�l¨`^`_0ilq�zS� t9dfzui �uiyq�gKq�xX^�~u_0^`~¦tw_0q�i�t�gq�zucoq£co_�t�sS�Vcj�Kq�^ t�cjv4z ^oq�zut�_w��]�i�_0g0qwh�ilq3v�^`kug��S��t�g|ku^ t9d�q�_�c g�~Vcjv�t�x6iyq�z _0twg0~ t�v�q£q�^ q�zSt��ltwku¨jq�z^j�Jq�zut�t9dftwvw�fq�i�^jkug|q�zucoq£co_�t�¨jilm`t�k�h§cokus ilq3_0�ukug|�li�kutwcj_���� i�k q�il��to���ftwv�^`kus�h§iyq3v�cjk _0�uk����¡£¤�¥���}��hcj�l^`ku¨`g0i�sut:q�zut6~u_�^j¨`_�cj� q�^ �¦t�t�dScj�!i�kut�s�hn_�twv�twiymfilku¨=mocj���ut�gDcjgKq�zut���cj_0t�¨`twkut�_�coq�tws�cjkus!sui�g0v�cj_0sui�kS¨q�zStw� co�q�t�_0x:cj_�s��D]V^`_Xt�dScj�!~u��tohScok�i�kuv�_�tw�!twkrq�cj�Uco��¨`^`_0ilq�zu� v�cok���^`kSilq�^j_Xc3x:t���g0tw_�m`tw_�^1mjtw_�sVc��g^`_|xXtwt�}ngwhDx6ilq�zS^`�Sq©zVc�m�i�kS¨ q�^ g0q�^`_�t�q�zut�_0twv�^`_�s ^j�'t�cov4z q�_�cjkSg�cjv�q�i�^jk�� ��zui�g|i�g£il��~¦^`_0q�cjkrq£cog©cxXtwtw},� g�q�_�cjkug�cjv�q�i�^`kSg=��c� ku^jq�t�mjtwk ¥uq�^`k sui�g0}M�   k i�kuv�_�t���t�knq�cj�Kcj�l¨`^`_0ilq�zS� ilg=cj�lg�^�c�^`kut ��~Vcjg0g

���

Page 56: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

cj�l¨`^`_�iyq�zu��� �kuvwt�i�kuv�_�tw�!twkrq�cj��iyq�� i�g3cjv4zSi�t�mjtws�hbq�zut�_�t�cj_�t!g�t�vw^`kSsVcj_/� tEg�v�i�t�kuv�� vw^jkuvwt�_�kug�� ��q�ilg|co��g�^�il�'�

~¦^`_0q�cjkrq�q�^�g�c�mjt�g�~Vcjv�t�cjkSs q�il��t!cjg|c����ukuv�q�il^`k ^j�:q�zut�g�i���t�^j�:q�zut�~u_�^`¨j_�cj��h¢�!t�cog��u_0tws ilk�q�zStkn�u���¦tw_=^j�¡mocj_�i�c��u�ltwgw� � t!^j~Sq�il��i �wt£co��^`ku¨�q�zuilg=��i�kSt ��� q4co}�ilku¨�cjsSmocjkrq�cj¨`t©^j�X^`kut©¨`t�kutw_�cj�§ilsut�cS�i�krmocj_0ipcjkrq�g6^j�q�twk il��~S����twcjv4z ^jq�zutw_��6��zut|g0~Vcjvwt£cjkus � ^j_6q�i��!t�_�twg0^`�u_0vwtwg.�ug�t�s q�^�v4zStwv4}�g��uv4z il�'�~u�li�tws i�krmocj_�i�cjkrq�g'v�cjk�^j�q�t�k � t£c1mj^`i�sStws�� � t�~u_�t�g�twkrq=q�zu_�t�t£^`~Sq�i��!i���ceq�i�^jkug �Vcjg0tws ^`k�q�zut|ilsut�c!^j�i��!~u�li�tws�i�krmocj_�i�cjkrq�gJilk�q�zui�g6v4zVco~Sq�t�_w�

��zui�gXv4zVcj~Sq�tw_JilgX^j_�¨rcjkSi��wt�s�cjg¡��^`���l^1x6gw�K��twv�q�i�^`k �f���j�$��sutwg0vw_�i�� t�g�c�kucjilmjt.i�krmocj_0ipcjkrqXi�kS��t�_�twkSvwi�kS¨cj�l¨`^`_�iyq�zu� cog�c �¦twkuv4zu��cj_0}�q�^|vw^`�!~Vcj_0t�cj¨rcoi�kug�q��D�ft�v�q�i�^`k �f���`� �£sut�g�vw_0i �¦twgJq�zut�sui� Ut�_�twkrq�~ucj_�cj�!t��q�t�_�gJq�zVcoq'c� twv�q�_�t�g�^`�u_0vwt�vw^jkug��u�!~Sq�i�^`k�cjkSs�q�zut=sVcoq�c£g0q�_��uv�q��u_0t3g0~Vcjv�t3^1mjtw_�x6zui�v4z�cjk�co��¨`^`_0ilq�zu�xX^`�u��s ^`~¦tw_�coq�to�!�ftwv�q�i�^jk �f���f����vw�pcog�g�iy¥Vtwg=q�zut�sui� tw_0twkrq3��t�q�zu^�sug ��� x6zui�v4z ^`~Sq�i��!i��wcoq�il^`kug'vw^`�u�ls�¦t�~ t�_0��^`_0��t�s��K�ft�v�q�i�^`kug.�f���S��� � ��cj_�¨jtw�����¦^`_�_0^1x:t�s���_0^`� p'i��!��t�_=ilp(il� �r� ��r�h �u�SqD_�t�~ twcoq�t�s�zStw_�tJ��^j_vw��cj_�iyq��©^j�Rt9df~ ^`g0ilq�i�^`kM�9h��f���ShScjkSs �f� ��g�zS^7x ��c �0^`_¡^`~Sq�i��!i��wcoq�il^`kug�q�zVcoqX��t�cos�q�^ � t�q�q�tw_:�Sg�t�^j��g�~Vcjv�tcjkus q�i��!t ����t���~u�l^ �filku¨�q�zut�� cov�q.q�zVcoq(g�^`�!t|ilkrmjco_�ipcoknq�g(il��~S����twcjv4z ^jq�zStw_.ilk�g0^`��t3xJc�j�.��zut�g�t^`~Sq�i��!i��wcoq�il^`kugbcj_�t�~¦tw_���^`_��!tws©^jk£q�zut6{=cjil}j^`k©ilkrmjco_�ipcoknq�sut�q�twv�q�^`_�ilknm=oqp ����sr�hnc�¨`twkStw_�co�u~u�u_0~ ^`g0tq�^�^`�§x6iyq�z�c�x6i�sSt�cjkSs �ug0t����u�¡¨`_�co����cj_w���ft�v�q�il^`k �f����g�zu^1x6g�t�d�q�t�kug�il^`kug�q�^ {=cjil}j^`k ��g�¨`_�cj����cj_q�^���cj}ot|iyq��!^`_�t3�ug�t����u�KcjkSs cj���l^1x ilq'q�^�t9d�q�_�cov�q=�!^`_�t�i�kS��^j_���coq�il^`k���_�^`� cjk�� ¨`ilmjtwk t9dSt�vw�Sq�i�^`kU��ft�v�q�il^`k�f��«!~u_0twg0twkrq�g6���Sq��S_�t=x:^j_�}�cjkus �ft�v�q�i�^`k!�f� 1�v�^`kuv����usut�gw�

�s���=��� ��� �������X\��=����(t�_�t=xXt�sut�¥Vkut�q�t�_��!i�ku^`�l^`¨��jh�q�^!¨jilm`t3c£��^`�ukSsVcoq�il^`k���^`_Jq�zut�_�twg�q.^o�¢q�zui�g�v4zVco~Sq�t�_w�

  ��� � �N� �N���¡�����¡�3i�g|g0��il¨`zrq���� �!^`_�t�¨`twkStw_�co�:q�zVcok �0�ug0q!c g0~ t�vwil¥uv���^�v�coq�i�^`k�i�k q�zut�~u_0^`¨`_�co� ���kug�q�t�cos�hDilq©_0tw~u_0twg�t�krq�g!c g�~¦twv�il¥Vv�g0vw^`~¦t � g0t�q�^j��mocj_0ipc��u�ltwg���cjkus iyq�g£cog�g�^�vwi�coq�t�s g�t���cjkrq�i�vwg�� ]V^`_t�dScj�!~u�ltjh�v�^`kug�ilsutw_�c�~S_�^`¨`_�cj� ~ ^`ilkrq�cjg�g0^fv�ipcoq�tws x6ilq�z q�zut©~S_�t���g0q�coq�t©^j�Xc��!t�q�zu^fsU� ��q�g=g�vw^j~ t©ilgcj�l�b¥Vt���sug=^o�¡q�zut©vw��cjg�g�cokus cjk�� cj_0¨`�u�!twkrq�g�q�^�q�zut©�!t�q�zu^�s�� ��q�g=g�t���cjkrq�i�vwg�cj_�t£q�zVcoq=t�m`tw_�� q�il��tq�zSt3�!t�q�zu^�s�i�g�v�co����t�s�hVc©g�kucj~ug�zS^jq'^j�§co���U~S_�t���g0q�coq�t=x6ilq�zui�k�g0vw^`~¦t�i�gJq�cj}jt�k��¡]M^j_6c�~S_�^`¨`_�cj� ~¦^`ilknqcjg0g�^�vwipceq�tws x6iyq�z q�zut�^�� �0twv�q�ilkrmjco_�ipcoknq�g|^j�'c vw�pcog�gwhKiyq�g£g0vw^`~¦t�ilg£cj�l�¡¥Vt���sug|^j��q�zut�v��pcjg0gwhDcjkSs ilq�gg�t���coknq�i�v�g:cj_0t'q�zVcoqXt�mjtw_/��q�i��!t6q�zut(cjk���~S���u��ilv6��t�q�zu^�s�ilgDv�cj�l��twsUh�g0kVcj~ug0zu^jq�g:^j�Tco���V~u_0t���g�q4coq�t.cokus~¦^`g0q���g0q�coq�t=x6iyq�zuilk�g�vw^j~ t�i�g�q�cj}jt�k��

  �|�N�x������i�gJq�zut�g�kVcj~Sg�zu^jq'^j��~u_�^j¨`_�cj� g0q�coq�t=q4co}jtwk���^`_6c�g�~¦twv�il¥Vv�~u_0^`¨`_�co� ~¦^`i�krq��  k"���]�Y���]� � ��� i�g6c©g0tw¤n�utwkSvwt|^o��g�cj��~S��twg�q�cj}jt�k ^1m`t�_'q�zut�_��uk�^j��c©~u_�^`¨j_�cj� ^7mjtw_6q�il��to� �� �N��� ���|����i�g!cjk t�df~u_�t�g�g0i�^`k cjg�g0^fv�ipcoq�tws x6ilq�z c ¨`iym`twk g�v�^`~¦t � c ~S_�^`¨`_�cj� ~¦^`i�krq4��� ��q!��c�

�¦t©c�g�il��~u�lt3¥utw��s _0t���t�_�twkSvwt � g0�uv4z cjg���� �"! +$# ��h¦��c� i�krm`^`�ym`t©co_�_�c� i�kusSt�dfi�ku¨�^`_�g��li�v�i�ku¨ � g��Sv4z�cog�%�&�"! +('*),+ ^B^S\ ).- ��� �"! +$# +�+ ��� �/! +0)"1 ��hu^`_=��c� ilknmj^`�lmjt©^jq�zStw_=vw^j��~¦^`�ukus t9df~u_�t�g�g�il^`kug��   ��� ������� � � �� �N� � ���|��� ilg�^`kut x6zu^`g�t mocj�l�ut�ilg�~u_�^1m�i�sStws i�k c�g�cj�!~u��to� ��zut�\ +,-2#/1 ^`~¦tw_�coq�^`_�sutwku^oq�twg�co_�_�c�g����ug�v�_�i�~fq�i�kS¨�cog6m�i�c@m ^`_43`c�moc!g��fkrq�ced �

  ����� � � � � � �N� � ���|���|i�g=c�mocj_0ipc��u�lt3x6zS^`g�t£mocj�l�ut£i�g(ku^jq=~S_�^1m�i�sut�s ilk c�g�co��~u�ltjh �u�Sq=ilg�i�kug�q�twcjsvw^j��~u�fq�tws cjg�c ���ukSv�q�il^`k ^j��^jq�zStw_�mocj_�i�c��u�ltwg�ce�q�tw_�q�zut � cjv�q�� ]V^`_�t9dScj��~S��tjh(cj_0_�c�Pg0��i�v�twg��li�}jt�%�&�"! +('*),+ ^B^S\ ).- ��� �"! +$# +�+ ��� �/! +0)"1 cj_0t=sutw_0ilmjtws���_�^`� q�zut=���u���Ucj_�_�c�5�%�&�"! +6'*),+ ^N^J\ ).-21 ¨`ilmjtwk�i�k�q�zStg�co��~u�ltj�

  k���� � �N� � �N�¡���,�27 �Y���©i�g�c�sVceq4c�g�q�_0�uv�q��u_�t�q�zVcoq�_�t��pcoq�twg�mjco_�ipc��u��t�g�ceq�c ~u_�^`¨j_�cj� ~¦^`i�krqw� ��q_�t�~u_�t�g�t�knq�g�c �¦^f^`�lt�cjk���^`_��£�S�pc�q�zucoq©x6i��l�"�¦t�v4zutwv4}otws cj¨`cji�kug�q�sVcoq�c���_�^`� g�cj�!~u��t�g©i�k s���kVcj�!i�vi�krmocj_0ipcjkrq�sut�q�twv�q�i�^`kU� ]V^`_ �u_0t�m�ilq��jh�x:t x6il���6^j�q�t�k _�t���tw_�q�^ cjkPilknmocj_0ipcjkrq�^�� �0t�v�q�g0i��!~u��� cjg�cjk

�j�

Page 57: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

i�krmocj_0ipcjkrq�h��u�Sq6xXt�su^�ku^oq(�!t�cok�q�zVcoq6iyq6i�gJq�_0�ut�^1m`tw_'cj�l��_��Skug6^j�§c�~u_0^`¨`_�co� �  �N���N�����N�(ilg�q�zut�g0t�q¡^j� �¦^f^`�lt�cjk���^`_��£�S�pcjtX^7mjtw_§x6zuilv4z�s���kVcj�!i�vJilknmocj_0ipcjkrq�sut�q�twv�q�i�^`k�^�vwv��u_�g��

��qKilgKcj��g0^.q�zn�ug§q�zutJg0t�qDsui� Ut�_�twkrqKilkrmjco_�ipcoknq�^�� �0t�v�qKq���~ t�gw�K]V^`_¢t�dScj�!~u��tohrc�¨`_�cj����cj_b��il¨`zrq�v�^`krq4cjilkq�zSt3t�¤n�Vcj��iyq���cjkSs �ltwg�g�q�zVcjk�^`~¦tw_�ceq�^`_0g'^jk�ilkrq�tw¨jtw_�g��

��zutw_0t|co_�t3cj��g0^©g�^`�!t=q�t�_��!g�g�~¦twvwiy¥Vv�q�^©q�zut3{=cjil}j^`k�s��fkucj��ilv=i�krmocj_�i�cjkrq�sut�q�twv�q�il^`k g���g0q�t�� � �� �Y���¡�¤������i�g�c£q�^�^`�Uq�zVcoq6t9dSt�vw�Sq�twg.c�~S_�^`¨`_�cj��hSi�krq�tw_�~S_�t�q�g6_��ukrq�il��t(mjco���ut�g6cjkus�^`�Sq�~S�Sq�g�q�zSt

mocj���Stwgbi�krq�^(c6��^j_���coqb�ukusut�_�g0q�cjkusVc��u��t%���3q�zutX{=cji�}o^`k5�Y�����Q�����jh7x6zui�v4z|cjkVcj�����wtwgbq�zut¡sVcoq�c'g�cj�!~u��t�gi�k q�t�_��!g|^j��ilkrmjco_�ipcoknq�gw��]V^`_3t�dScj�!~u��toh¢q�zSt ��   �fi��£�S�pcoq�^`_=i�g�q�zut ��   ��_�^`krq£t�kus ��^`_�{=cji�}o^`k�hcjkus q�zSt�{=coi�}j^jk ]M_0^`krq�t�kus ��^j_ 3`c1moc � sf��t ����i�kug�q�_0�u��t�krq�g 3`c�mjc�~u_0^`¨`_�cj��g�q�^�^`�Sq�~S�Sq�mjco���ut�g�q�^�c¥V�lt'_0t�cjsuc��u��t ���!{=cji�}o^`k��§��zSt.{=cjil}j^`k �Vcjv4}�t�kus�ilg¡_0twg0~ ^`kSg�i �S��t6��^`_Dvw^`�!~u�Sq�i�ku¨3sutw_0ilmjtws�mocj_0ipc��S��twg��_�^j� ~u_0i��!ilq�iym`t.mocj_0ipc��S��twg:¨`ilmjtwk�i�k�sVcoq�c!g�cj�!~u��t�gw�

�s���=��� ����� ��� �q� � ����� �������o������������� �"!#�%$�� &'!(� �)�+*��,�����,��-.&�&��,/�-.&0�21��j�l��/3&�-./4��&0�2!5�,16!5�7!8�21�¨.&��j���9� & �2���:��� &��;��-��<$=!5-`�5���2�,*���>&�?��)��!��@�j�'�6��!51>1����A�2!#-.��¨.!8$.�,1;�9����!#$.�B�j��¨ -.&�!8�2�u�C�������D� ����!#�,$.�,1E�2���:�.¨.-.�j�*�   1E��- ����* �5���2�,&>!#��F�,�,�2!#-.��f���`���3G��2��!#1��j��¨.- &�!#���u�H&�?��31���-F-I10�5-KJ6���9�2- ���;/�&�� �,��!5���j�*�

�`�#����!8�2!5�j�����.G=� 1�1'?u�@�L�j���4/�&�- /��,&'�2!#��16!#�M�2���=¨ &2�j�!�M��&N�2- �4�E�2&'?��j�����31'�����%��!(�����L� �7!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�:�O- &��� ���P/�&'-./4��&'���Q� ��*P�,-`����!#������!5-.�R-o�+$�� &�!5���u�#��1w�IS�-.&;�UT3�j�9/S�5� GV!y�N�����M��$�� !l�(���u�#�B/�&'-./4��&'��!5�,1� &'�IWFX)XY� ��* G GZ� ��*[�2���I$�� &�!5���u�#��1L� &'� E G]\%G^� �3*P_ G`!5�31'�����%��!(�����IWFX)X � E ��GZW=X)X � \o��G`WFX)X � _1�AGE G \%G E G _.G�� ��*[\ G _j�

a ��S�-.&b��� ���c1��j�9/S�5� Gd�����,��ef��� ���c��� ��*�!#*������7!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�@� 1�1'-F�,!(������*gJ�!#�2�h�����i1��j�@�7/�&�-`¨ &2�j�/4-.!5�)�j� 1;�����91��j�@/u�5�I� �3*k���5!��@!5�����2� � �l�j�51'!l���S�D� ���Q�������m� &��I�,-.�)�2&2��*�!5�A�2��*$���Q�2���@12�o�9/u�#�j�S�-.&b�UT��o�9/u�#� G �2���"1��j�9/S�5�onqp3r���r�p)sm���5!l�9!#�����2�,1B�2�3�t!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1bWFX)X � \o�UG E G \%G+� ��*�\ G _�O&'-`�u�����j����-K$ ���#!51'�w�

pS� ���/4-.&'�6�����L!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21<��������&����M��!5�"�o�v����&��j����12�j�@/u�#��16����$.���4�����t/�&'-F�,��1�1'��*��

�s���=��w x � �Vyz� ���V{F{�|� �+| � 3� � �`{�6��!#1>��}�¨.-.&'!#����~H��� 16��J+-@*��,1�!5&�����}#�;/�&�-./4��&0�2!#��1�G�1'-.?���*3����1'1E� ��*"�,-.~9/3}5�,�������,1�1��

�Z�������M�Dh=���   � �"!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��&'��/4-.&'����* ���"�@1'-.?���*t!5�)$�� &'!(� �)��*��A�2���A�2!#-.�Y��}�¨.-.&'!#����~H��-.}5*31��O- &�� }5}12��~9/�}#��16!#�"�����L!5��/3?3�m�O��������!51,G�!5�������;�2��10�D�UTF����?F�2!5- ��14�U�

��!5e �M- �2���,&B*��=����~9!#�9�2�,������!l¤=?3��1I1�?����g��1B�2�,1'�2!#�u¨�G�!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�m*��A�2���A�2!#-.�h!51m?���1�- ?���*g-K$.��&�� }5}/4-.1�1'! ��}#�d�UTF����?F�2!5- ��1^- ����/3&�-`¨.&�� ~t�`�6�3�+-���1'��&0$.��*B�ATF���,?3�2!#-.��1���&�� ��- �¢¨.?�� &�� �)�2�,��*m��->����� &2� �A�2�,&�!��,�� }#}+/4-.1�1'! ��}#���ATF���,?3�2!#-.�g���)$=!5&'-.��~@���)�21b- �������"/�&�-`¨ &2� ~t� ;?3&�*���¥���!#��!5-.�h!#1B�O-.&�1'-.?���*��3��1�1IJ�!#���&��,1�/4���A�>��-@-���1��,&'$.�,*R�ATF�,��?3��!5-.��1,�

� �4�yi^��h(��h7��h=��� � ��-.~@/�}#�,�2�@� }#�.-.&'!#�2�3~�&��,/�- &'�21m� �)�o/�&�- /��,&'���[�2���:��� �K�L!#1j�UTF/�&��,1�1�!#��}5�9!5�o!#��1�.&�� ~9~9� &,G3� �3* a �+�3-.}5*�16�O-.&���}5}z1�� ~@/�}5�,16!5�7�2���L!#��/�?3���m+-.~@/�}5�A�2���3��1�1�J�!8�2��&'��1'/��,�,����-Q� }5} /4-.1�1'!5��}#�M/�&'-./4��&'��!5�,1B!51m/�- 1�1�!#��}5�9!5�P������- &'� iLm=m �"�:�sr<��?F�?����:������!5��� �3}5�B!#�R/�&�� �,��!5����� � �Q!5�F����!#���B�%?�~��4��&;-��d�O- &�~�?�}5� �m� &��B��&�?��b-��d� �)�R1��A�L- �d�ATF���,?3�2!#-.��1,G

� �

Page 58: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

�Z�,&���/3&�-.�.&�� ~ ��/4-.!5�)�<$�� &'!(� ��}#��1,�� �%?�~��4��&�- �Z/�&�!#~9!8�2!#$ �>$�� &'!(� ��}#��1������b/�&'-.�.&�� ~C/4-.!5�)�� �%?�~��4��&�- �Z12� ~@/�}5�,1<�O-.&��b/�&�- �.&2� ~C/�-.!#�)�� �%?�~��4��&�- �Z!5��10��� �)�2!5���2�,*"!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�216���>�b/�&'-.�.&2��~C/4-.!5�)� G�� �����A�

� �%?�~��4��&�- �Z&���/4-.&0�2��*t!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21<���>�I/3&�-.�.&�� ~C/4-.!#�%� G�� ���3� *�!5�"�,-.~9~@-.�7��� 1���G G�� � � � �� �%?�~��4��&�- �`�l� }51'!#���,*7!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21������I/�&�- �.&2� ~u/�- !5�)� G�� ���F�

�Z-���� }d�O1�?�~ -���� }#} /�&'-.�.&2��~C/4-.!5�)�212�N$�� &�!5� ��}5�,1��� �%?�~��4��&�- �Z/�&�-.� &2� ~u/�-.!#�)�21��� �2- �2� } �%?�~��4��&�- �Z!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21 G�� �������F���� �2- �2� } �UT3�,��?3��!5-.�t}5�,��� ���P���'�ATF/�}#-F*3��*��%� G�� �������d�

D�2���,&�$�� &'!(� �3}5��1,�� �%?�~��4��&�- �Z!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�<�2�,~9/�}5���2�,1j�l�.&�� ~@~M� &2�

S^!#�.?�&�� � � �.���d� &'!(� ��}#��1b?�1'��* !5�h�2���t&�?3����!5�3�o��!5~@�7� ��* 1�/�� �,�Y����� }#�=1'��1Y�l1��,���=���,��!5-.� � ���.�! [�O- &*��A��� !#}51��U� � }#}z$�� &�!5� ��}#��1<�UT3�,��/3�>�O-.&"� G# ��4G���G ����*$����� &��;e%��-KJ��Y10������!5��� }5}8�.�

� ��*7~9� �)�9- ���2���,~ � &'�E�4�,�.- ��*7�2���E1'��-./4�;- �`� �)�91'�2���2!#�E-.&+*F�F��� ~9!#�;� ����}#�=1�!#1��) E?�&<*3�,����!8�2!#-.�M!#1��- ~9/�}#�,�������,1�16J�!#���i&'��1�/4���A���2-9�I� &2� ~@~M��&+- �Z/�&�- /��,&'�2!#��1,�oL!8$.�,�P�2���,1��7*��A����!8�2!5- ��1�G^�����M��� !#$ �7� }5� -.&�!8�2��~ !#1m1'-.?���*h�4����� ?�1'�7�,$.�,&'�P!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�B!#1m�2�,1'����*� �)��!5��10�m�A$.�,&'�o&��,}5�,$�� �)�m12� ~@/�}#�@!#�%�%�2��/ a �'&��m!51L��-.~@/�}#�,�2�I�4����� ?�1��M� }5}]/4-.1'1�!5�3}5�I!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21j� &'�!5�31'�����%��!(������*"!5�(�=����/ �.�)&���!516!#����&'��~@���)��� }z���,��� ?�1'�m!8��&�?��31�!#�"-.���L/�� 1'1��

�>-KJN�,$.�,&�G)�2�3�+� }#�.-.&'!#�2�3~ � ����!#�,$ ��1^������1'�+�2��&'���d�.-)� }#1`������}(� &'�.�]�2!#~9�d� ��*m1�/������<�,-.1'��G.� 1Z1���-KJ��!5���F���A�2!5- � � ���.�! ��)*d��!5�31'�����%��!(����!5���B� }5}4!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21,G3~9� �)�M&'��*�?3��*�� �)��!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21<� &��E!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2�,*� ��*"�2�,1'����* �dS�-.&6�AT3� ~@/�}#� G�!8��+ G�, � ��*.-0/1/4��+F�+�3-.}5*�1,G��2���,�$-0/2/4� , �N��-.}#*�1��

�s���=��3 � ��#4 � �H���Ey �����E� � ��{ �{�6��!#1�1'���A�2!5- �i����� }#���,��16�2���;��!5~@�L� ��*"1�/������j/��,&'�O-.&'~M� �3���;- �`�2���L����!#$.�L*��A�2�,�,�2!#-.�i� }5�.- &�!#����~t�

5 �D����6��G� �87"���<� ��9Z��hF�S^!#�.?�&�� ��: �;}5!#1'��1<�2���;$�� &�!5� ��}#��1+��������!5�<;�?����3���j/��,&'�O-.&'~M� �3��� �

� *3����- ����1L�2���I�%?�~��4��&j- �N/�&�!#~9!8�2!8$.�B$�� &'!(� ��}#��1L���j�"/�&'-.�.&2��~ /�- !5�)���@m+-.���,��/3��?�� }#}#�.G�����!51;!#1�2�3���%?�~B���,&]- ��$�� &'!(� �3}5��1^!5�I1��,-./�����&��@/�&2� �A�2!#��� G)!8�]!51��������%?�~��4��&]- �4$�� &�!5� ��}5�,1^�2�����d� &��6~@����1�?�&'��*�)�k�i�O&�-.�)������* �t�6���9/�&2� �A�2!#��� }]$�� }5?3�9~9���k�4�@}5��1'1B!8�<�2���@�O&�-.�)������*�- ~9!8�21L���,&'����!5�k$�� &'!(� �3}5��1,GZ- &~9�K�t�4�B~@-.&��m!#�]!8�D�3&�����e=1;- ?3�E- ��1���- /��"�v�O-.&D�UT3� ~9/3}5� G��)�Y1�� ~9/3}5!5�3�9/�&'!#$������j���,}5*�1D- � ��}5� 1�1'��1E!#�-.� �'�,�,��-.&'!5���)����*t/�&�-.� &2� ~@1��U�

�c*��,��- �2�,1������L�%?�~��4��&�- �Z12� ~@/�}5�,1����>�b/�&�-.� &2� ~u/�-.!#�)���� *��,��- �2�,1t�����[�%?�~��4��&"- ��!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2�,* !#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1"���t�g/�&�-.� &2� ~ /�-.!#�)���=� J�!5}5}>����$.�k�

/4-.1�!8�2!#$ � G:1�?�/4��&'}5!#����� &V��>z�,�,��- �?� G��O- &V��JN-E&'��� 1'-.��1��^S^!5&'1'��G�!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1`-��v�2���m!5�)$.- }#$.�d~@-.&��]�2��� �B-.�3�$�� &�!5� ��}#� �ZS - &��AT3� ~@/�}5��G �2�3��&���� &'�"@I���?A��^/�� !5&0J�!51'�<�CB%?�� }#!#���m!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21,�)�F�,��-.��*zG%�����6�.&�� ~9~9� &`- ��B�2-=-.}�}5!5e��D;� !#e -.��J�!#}5}4��&'��������������� � � �M$�� &'!(� ��}#��1d�2�����<&���/3&���1'���)�>����-.~@/�?3�2���2!#-.��-.�������;-.&'!5�.!#��� }$�� &�!5� ��}#��1���S - &+�AT3� ~@/�}#� G�!8�FE�!516��1'�CB%?����3��� G4� �3*.G^!516� �"!#�%�����.�,&�G=�2���;*��,&�!8$.��*7$�� &'!(� ��}#�HEfiIG r�~M���

�KJ

Page 59: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

�4��!5�)�2�,&��,1'�2!#����G �A$.�,�k!8� !#�E!#1D��-��;~9�,�)�2!5- ����*Q!#�Y�2���b/3&�-.�.&�� ~ �2�UTF���?&��Q� �����,&2� } G !#�]�������.&�� ~9~9� &1�?3/�/�- &'�21�� : J+���g*���&'!#$.�,* $�� &'!(� ��}#��1,G�� : J<���g!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1�GN� ��* � *�! >���&'���)�@!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�b���F/4��1,G+�2�3����2�3��&��L�,-.?�}5*7�4�L� 1�~9� �)�7� 1 � G @I� � �������+!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21,��&��"�2���;��� 1��L- � D;� !5e�-.� G�� G a � ��*� G p3G�=!5�,}5*�!#�����2���L*��A����!8�2!5- �7- � �M�.!#$ ���t!5���2�3�L���.?�&����

�R� �3* �� Gz�2�3�b&���/4-.&0�2��*o� �3*[�l��}51�!8����*Q!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�D��-.?3�%��1�GV&��,1�/4���A�2!#$ ��}8�.G`� &��B?�1��,*o��-t�4�,�'�2�,&��}#?���!#*������D��- ~9~@-.�M��� 1��L����� }#�=1'��1+J����,&��E�����E&��,/�- &'�2�,*7!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21+� &��;�m~9!#�=?31���?3}5�D1'?���1'�,��- �V�2�3��.&�� ~9~9� &� 1<��� ��*�!#*������;1��,���

�@G��2�����%?�~B���,&E- �d/�&�- �.&2� ~ /4-.!5�)�21,Gz1'��� }#��1EJ�!#���R/�&'-.�.&2��~ 1'!������ � }51'-�G������ �0��- ����} �9$�� }#?���1H���� ��*(���^*3����- ���j�����L/�&�-=*�?��A��- � � � ��*"�2���,!5&61'?���1��,&�!#/3� : }5��1'1���-.?��)����&�/�� &'���

� ����7�h iPh%�� ��:�:�y�,����h�`-D1'��?�*3�L�2�3�+/4��&'�O- &�~9� �����d- �F�2���N��� !#$ �+��}5�.-.&'!#����~iG�JN�+�,-.~@/�?3�2�d!#��1V1�/�� �,�<� �3*B�2!#~9�]/4��&0�O-.&�~9� ���,��4- �2� !5� �����iJN-.&'1'�7����*c�,-.~9~@-.�f��� 1'� ���P�i~9��� 1�?3&��Y1'/�� �,��� �)� �����Y~9�:TF!5~B?�~ �%?�~��4��&@- �!5�31'�����%��!(������*9!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21�GF� ��*9�2!5~@��� �)�@�2���>�%?�~��4��&<- � ��������e%1�-.�MJ����A�2���,&6� ��!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�N��-.}#*�1D�

�6���b��� !8$.�b��}5�.-.&'!#����~ /4��&'�O- &�~@1HB%?�!#����/4-F-.&'}#� � �F!#�����j�2���b��}5�.-.&'!#����~ !5��10��� �)��!(������1D�A$.�,&'�R/4-.1 :1�!#��}5�;!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�L�l!5�"10�2��/ � �AG3!#�216~9�:TF!5~B?�~C1'/�� ���j?�1�� �.�L!51 � �����O�A� �6��!51�!#1<�2���L12��~9�;�O-.&6�4- �2�"�2�3���- ~9~@-.�"� ��*"JN-.&�10�>��� 1��,1�G4� ��*t~9� e �,1������j� }5� -.&�!8�2��~ !5���,&��,~9�,�%�2� }q�

� G�� �����l� G�� �������F��P- &�1'� : ��� 1��o�2!5~@�Q-=����?3&�1"J���������}5}E!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1i��&��o��������e���* � �)��!5��10�Y��}5}E1�� ~9/3}5��17�O-.&7������!#&

/�&'-.�.&2��~C/4-.!5�)���F�2��!#16��� /�/4����1�J����,�Y��-I!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21���&��E�l� }#1�!#����* �� G�� ��� ����� � G�� ����� ���d� G�� ����� � ���d�m+-.~@~9-.� : ����1����2!5~@��-F�,��?�&'1+J����,�M�l� }51'!#���,*M!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1+� &'���l��}51�!8����* B%?�!5��e%}#� GF1'-B�2�����+������&'�E� &'�

$�� ��!#1���!#���.}#�@�O�,J ��������e%1D� �)� !#��1'�6�l� }#1�!8����*7!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1��� G�� �����=��� ����a �� � � ��� �'��� G � ��� ��� ���d�1a � ��� �� �?� � ���K����6���<��&'1'�]�2�,&�~�!51^�O- &Z�2�3�<?�1��A�O?�}�!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1Z�2����� � &'�6� �,��?�� }#}#�L�2&'?��<-.�������</�&'-.�.&2��~iG:J���!5���@� &'�

� }8J<���=1���������e���* G J���!5}#�E�2���L1'����- ��*t����&'~ !51<�O-.&+!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21<�2������� &��;?3�%��&�?��m� ��*zG�!5�7�2�3�;��-.~@~9- �����1�� G B%?�!#��e=}8���l� }#1�!#����* �

� !#����!5�[�2���9��-.�31'�2&�� !5�)��1B- �+1�-.?��3*�����1'1�G ��- ~9/�}#�,�������,1�1�����*k�����M!#����&'��~@���)��� } &'�CB%?�!5&'��~@���)��G^�~9� �'-.&�J+�K�b��-L12��$.�>1�/�� �,�D����* � -.&���!5~@� G)��1dJN��}#} � 1]�2-L&��,*�?�������}#?3������&]�O-.&�������?�1��,&�G=!51��2-j��}#!5~@!5���:�2�1�- ~9�i*���&'!#$.�,*c$�� &�!5� ��}#��19� ��* !#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1�� �6����&'�R!51@��-PJ+��� ��-���$.- !5* �UT���~9!#��!5���k� }#}6/�&�-.� &2� ~/4-.!5�)�21�����*i�A$.�,&'�"�ATF�,��?3��!5-.�i12� ~@/�}5�D!#�Z1�-.?��3*�����1'1D!#1<�2-I���L/�&'��1'��&'$ ��* �

�V� 1'��}#�.G !8�>!#1>!#~9/4-.&0��� �)�6�2-9��- ���j���������2���m� 1'�=~@/3�2-��2!5�L��-�������!5-.�t��!5*3��1�-.���j!5~@/�-.&0��� �)��*��A��� !#}q�!#�7�2� e �,1i1'-.~@�[� ~9- ?��)�"- �B��!5~@�Y�2-g�����,��e !8���h1�� ~9/3}5�Q��- �%��&2� *3!5�,��1t� � !#�)$ ��&�!(���%��� &�� D;��!5e - ���- ?�}5*7*�!#1��,��&����������6�3-b12� ~@/�}5�>~M���9�,$ ��&<�l� }#1�!#�v�9���,��&'�2� !5�M!5�)$�� &�!5� �)��G=!#�<�,-.?�}#*7-.~9!8�+���3����e%!5���I�2�3�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)��GF}5��� *�!5�3���2-I1�!#�.��!#����� �)��!5~@/�&'- $ ��~@���)��!5�7�2�3�m��1'�=~9/F�2- ��!5�E�,-.��1'�2� �)�21,�

*,+�� � 6����! #"$� >&% > 0'� 2(" > 0*)+�f47>&�f032-,.�f0;8 8'" 47>�)/" 8 )+�f47>&�10��&"$,� 1�~@���)�2!#-.���,*7!5�(�F���A�2!#-.� � �2� � �G=�2���[email protected]'�</�&�-.~@!51'!5���mJ<������-@- /3�2!#~9! ���D!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�<!5�3�O�,&����3���L!51+��-��}#!5~@!5���:�2�j1�-.~@��*��,&�!#$ ��*[$�� &�!5� ��}5�,1E� �3*o!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1D�2�����L� &'�b?���!5�)����&��,1'��!5���7-.&D}5-.�.!#��� }#}#�"!#~9/�}#!5�,* ��6��!#1>��}51�-b�3��}5/31���-I&���*3?����j��}#?3������&6�O-.&<�2�3�j?31���&,�

� �����o�AT3� ~@!5�3!5���MJ��3!5���o!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21;� �3*o*3��&�!8$.�,*o$�� &'!(� ��}#��1D��-7��}#!5~@!5������� G �2���,&��@� &'����J+-t-.& :�2�3-.�.-.����}��,-.�����,&���1,� �6���D��&'1'�6!#1NJ����A�2���,&<�2���>��}5!#~9!#������!5-.�I!51d1'�2���2!#�D-.&N*3�=��� ~@!5��G3� �3*��2���E1'���,-.��*

��3

Page 60: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

!516�3- J ~�?����t!#��1��K$ ��1>!5�7&��,1�-.?3&����,1��

��������� �R���������E�^� � � � �"�>| ���R{=�3�^� �y������ �E��� �y ���d�^� �� � � ���� �E��� �y | �d{ ���� �� �

�6���D��&�1'�<��-.���,��&'�"�O- &+��}#!5~@!5���:�2!5�3�;!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21<����*7*���&'!#$ ��*�$�� &�!5� ��}#��1d!51NJ��3�,�2�3��&<�2�3�E/�&�-=���,1�16��� ��4�b*�-.���b10������!5����}5}#�t-.&D~�?�1'�L�4�b*�-.�3�b*3�=��� ~@!5����}5}#� � DD�F��� ~9!#����}#!5~@!5���:�2!5- �t��� �[�����O?3&'�2�3��&;1�/3}5!#�!5�)��-I��JN-@��� 1'��1��d���,�)���2!8$.�j� ��*"/4-.1�!8�2!8$.� �

� 1'���:�2!5�6�,}5!#~9!#�����2!#-.�B!#1]-.���6�2����� ��� �@�4��*3-.���6J�!#����-.?3� �UT3�,��?3��!5-.�I�2&�� ����*��:���3� � �@�AT3� ~@/�}5�6!#1E�i G r�$E�i rqG%J���!5���@!51d� }8J<���=1 �2&�?3� � � 1'�2���2!#����}5!#~9!#������!5-.�m!51 � *3$�� �)�2� �.��- ?�1�GF� 1 !#� ��� �9�4��*�-.�����,$ ����4�,�O-.&'�m*��:���I!51�1��,��� � &��i��-.�)��&2� 10��G4�@*F�F��� ~9!#�L��}5!#~9!#������!5-.�9�����,*�1D�UT3�,��?3��!5-.�i*����2�3�+�6���j�AT3� ~@/�}#�J����,&��Y��� G�� ��� -0/1/4�����D��}5!#~9!#��������1-0/2/4� � �>!51L�7*3�=��� ~@!5�b�,}5!#~9!#�����2!#-.� G �O-.&EJN�9��� ����- �L�4�I1�?�&'��2������� G�� ?��)�2!5}z1�-.~@�;*����2�@!#161����,� � � !#�2�3!5�7*3�=��� ~@!5�;�,}5!#~9!#�����2!#-.� G.������&'�B� &'�E��J+-@����1���1,�

� ���`�Qh7�Z�Q� ������� � h �:�"��� 7�h h=� � �W� �D�"����� � !51VJ����,&��+- ���+1�� ~9/3}5� ��� �m�O-.&��A$.��&Z&��,~9-K$.�+� �B!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�-.&V*��,&�!#$ ��*j$ ��&�!(����}5���VS - &��AT3� ~@/�}5��G�!8�3�A$.��&� h E R������! "$# G �2���,� E�i �¡r=!51���- ��1��,��1�!#��� } �Z�6��!#1Z!#1���� }#}5�,*���,�)���2!8$.�j��}#!5~@!5������!5-.�7�4����� ?�1'�B�AT3� ~@/�}#��1��O-.&>�,}5!#~9!#�����2!#-.�7� &'�B�,-.�)�2&2��*�!5�A�2-.&0�7�2-9�����j!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�>- &*��,&�!#$ ��*"$�� &�!5� ��}5���

% �yi^� ��h0�&�('��4�G� ����7�hf���DiMi���h=���G��� � !#1�J�����&'�t� � !#�)$ ��&�!(���%��-.&b*���&'!#$ ��*g$ ��&�!(����}5��!#1b��}#!5~@!5��������*-.��}8�E�2�3&�-.?�� �B�4��!5�3��!#~9/3}5!5�,*;�)�m1'-.~@�d-��2���,&Z!#�%$�� &'!(� �)���ZS�-.&V�UT���~9/�}#� G3��� G)� �*� -0/2/������ M -0/2/4� � �A�+>�,&���G)�>/4-.1�!8�2!8$.�d1'���:�2��~@���)�^!51^�4��!#����~M� *3�<� �4-.?3�`�2���N��}#!5~@!5��������*L!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�`�)�m�����N��JN-E!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21-.�[�2���@}5�A�v����p>-t-.���I1�� ~9/3}5�b!51L�,��-.?��.�z�jJN�9��� ����-��m�4�I1�?�&'�9-��+�2�3�9�,}5!5~@!5�����2!#-.�i?3�%��!5} � }#}�*����2���� 16�4���,�"1����,� G�1�!#�����,� G)� -.& -0/1/4�����d��- ?�}5*7�4�E�l� }51'!#���,* ���6�%?�16JN�;?�1��;�2�3�D�2�,&�~ �01�?�/�/3&���1'1�!#-.����4������?�1��j!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21�� &'�;���,$ ��&���-.~@/�}#�,�2�,}#�M��}5!#~9!#��������* �

��������� - �V{&�/.��y �`{c{3�� ������ �`����� ���E�^� ��� �0�k� ��� �/�j{�|E�]y � � |� ���+� ���,�6���<1'���,-.��*I��-.�3����&'���O-.&^�,}5!#~9!#�����2!#-.�;!51`J������]&'��1'-.?�&��,��1]!8��12��$ ��1�� � �^���,1'��G)!#�`J�!5}5}%1��K$ �61�/������ G)1���$.��2!#~9�j� �3*R}5�A�>�����B!#�3�O��&'�����,!5���M� }5�.- &�!#����~ ��$ -.!5*R/3&�!5�)��!5���@-.?3�D�AT=�2&��M!5�3�O- &�~9���2!#-.���2���:�E!51�-.�)$=!5-.?31-.&�?���!#�)�2��&'��10�2!5�3�9�2-I�2�3�m?�1'��&,� � �>JN-.&�10��G4!#��J�!5}#} -.��}8�7&��,*�?��,�B/�&'!5�)�2!#����G���?3�>����$.�j�2���j12��~9�;�2!#~9�� ��*t1�/�� ���L��- 1'�21,�

�Z-M��$.-.!#*i/�&'!5�)�2!#���I�AT=�2&��9!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��16!51�&��,}(����!#$.�,}#�M1�!5~@/�}#� � &��%$�� &'!(� �)��!5�F�O��&��,�����j�����Y�4�j&'?��R��1�4�,�O-.&'� � � �����Y!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21>� &��L�2-9���m-.?3�2/3?3��G�� �Y!#�)$ ��&�!(���%���������E!#1>}#-.�.!#��� }#}#�@!5~@/�}5!#��*"�)�"�2���m&���10������i�4�L��}5!#~9!#��������* GF� ��*7�2�3!51�/�&�-=���,1�1������i�4�L&���/4���:�2��*z�

�Z-P12��$.�R1'/�� �,� G6!#�9!51@���,����1'12� &0� ��-�� �A�2?���}5}#�g*3��}5�A�2�t!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21@-.&@���,$ ��&�!#��1'�2� �)�2!(�:�2�7�2���,~i�+>-KJN�,$ ��&�G=1�- ?�*����,1�1N� ��*@��-.~@/�}5�A�2�,����1'1]�����,*@��-j�4�6/�&'��1��,&'$ ��* �dS�-.&��UT���~9/�}#� G)!8�1� G)� � -0/2/4����� M-0/1/4� � �UGz�2���,�P*��,}5�A�2!5�3� - /2/4� � �>~@!5�.�)�L�4�9�7�.-=-=*o!#*����F�2+>-KJ+�A$.�,&�G^����!51;����!#$.�I*��,}5�A�2!5- �o/3&�-=*�?����,1� �[!5�3��-.~@/�}5�A�2�I� }#�.-.&'!#�2�3~i��1���- ?�}5*[}(�:�2��&,� FG3� G � �,� - /2/4� � ��&'��~9� !5�Q��&�?���GV�����I?�1��,&;J�!5}5}Z��- �j�4�� ��}#�E�2-@*���*3?����?- /2/4� � �d�O&'-.~ -0/2/������A� �6���j��-.&'&��,�,��1�-.}#?3�2!#-.� GF!#� - /2/4� � �N!51<��-9�4�L��}#!5~@!5��������* G=!51<��-/�&'��1��,&'$ �b1�-.~@�m~@������� ��!51'~ �O-.&�&���� �����,&2����!5��� - /2/4� � �+1���- ?�}5*4� FG5�76 !q� � �8G�1'��-.?�}#*i�2�3�B*3�=��� ~@!5�1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'!5-.�i��-I}5-.��� ��&�� /�/3}#�.�

�Z-912��$.�j�2!#~9��G�!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�216��� �Y�4�L&���~@-K$.�,*Q� 16J�!#���t�O-.&�1'/�� ����� � }8�2�,&�������!#$ ��}#� G�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21���� ��4�B~9� &�e���*Q1�-9�2���A�R� &'�B��-��E�����,��e ��*z�m�6���,1��b!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1�JN-.?�}#*Y��� e���?�/R1'/�� �,� G ��?F�E�2���A�iJN-.?�}#*

8:9

Page 61: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

��- �m���,��*k��-Y�4�9���3����e �,*f� �)� !#��1'�L*��:���3�7S�-.&L�,-.~9/3}5�ATQ!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21L}5!#e ����� EfiIG r�� � �����,��e=!#���R��� �����e �L?�/i�@1'!5�.��!8�������%�6� ~9- ?��)��- �^��!5~@� �

&��7�2���D�O- }5}5-KJ�!#���B1'���,��!5-.�31�G3JN�;*�-b��- �<*�!51'��?�1'1�� �)��1'�2���2!#�E��}#!5~@!5���:�2!5- �I���������3! B%?���16�O-.&N�2���,&��E!#1� }#&�����*3�t� *���B=?����2�m}5!#����&����2?�&'�L-.�R1'�2� ��*���&�*Y10������!5�m� ��� }8�=1�!51 ium=m �"����G o m 3 8 rq� �F!#~9!#}(� &'}#� G3*3�=��� ~@!5����,�)���2!8$.�o��}#!5~@!5������!5-.� !51t� }#1�-g&��,}(����!#$.�,}#��10�2&�� !5�.�)�'�O-.&'J+� &�*z�f1'!5~@/�}#�c1'��-./ e�����/3!5���f�2&2����e -��B�2�3�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)� J������7!8�+!#1N�3-�}5-.�3�.��&d!5�)�2�,&��,1'�2!#������&��31'�2��� * G=J+�E*3��1��,&�!#�����2��&'���D����������! B%?���1+�O- &+*3�=��� ~@!5�/4-.1�!8�2!#$ �;1�?�/3/�&��,1�1�!#-.� �

*,+�� � 4 " ) >?6@:�, 6�2�>�% >����q2�>|6�0�,*+�A�O-.&��;�2�3!51<JN-.&�e G��2��&'���L-./3��!5~@!������2!#-.��1 J+�,&��m� }5&'��� *3�M/��,&'�O-.&'~9�,*i- �"����� D;� !5e�-.�"1'�=1'����~t�

S^!5&'1'��G �2���I��- �����,/3�j- �+!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�� � �:�J���¡�����tJ<��1B� *3*���* �IS�-.&L�71'��&�!#��1L- �N!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21E1'?�������1� h a r � h �.r$� h 9 �2���:��!5~@/�}#�9��� ���i- �2�3��&6!5�t���2-���� } - &�*��,&�G�!#��!#16-.��}8�����,����1'12� &0�"�2-Ie �,��/i��&2� ��e- �^-.���L- �^������~tG � ��*� � �:�J���Y��������!5�)$�� &�!5� �)��� 16�l� �,��1>�,-.~@�j!#� � � !#���t����� h !#�)$ ��&�!(���%��G3JN�m10��� &0�J�!#���4� h������ ����� �>�6�����,-.&�&'���,�E� ~@-.?��)�E- �^J+��� e �,��!5���7��� 1>��-����m*�-.������!#�bi � r J r��.r a rZ� &'�B1'�����zG�2�3���"�2���;������}�!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�6~�?�10�>�4��� h �.�]�6�3!51�����1'?�&��,1>1'-.?���*3����1'1E� ��*t��- ~9/�}#�,�������,1�1��

�F���,-.��* GN�Y$.�,&�1'!5-.� ��� a �m- � D;� !#e -.�g�:���2�,~9/F�2��*���-Q��}#!5~@!5�������91'-.~@��!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21,G]��?3�I��� *���-~9� e �j~�?�}8�2!5/3}5�;/�� 1'1��,1E-K$.��&>�2���j*����2�@�2-9*�-M1'-���S�-.&>�UT3� ~9/3}5� G D;� !#e -.� � a *�!5*Y�9/���1�1>��-M�,-.}5}#���,�J���!#���I$�� &'!(� �3}5��1`J+�,&����CB%?���}3�2-L�������@-��2���,&]���A�O-.&��6���%�B- �2�3��&]!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21ZJ+�,&��6�.�,����&����2�,* �)&�� � G���2�3����-.�3}#��������]JN-.?�}#*M�4�>!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2�,*9-.�@�2����1��,��-.�3*�/�� 1'1��]�6�%?�1 � a ��}#!5~@!5���:�2��*b~9� �)�I-.�)$=!5-.?31!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21N� ��*M��$.-.!#*���*��UT3� ~9!#��!5�3�m�UTF��&2� �3��-.?�1+*������F���6��!51N12��$.�,*��2!#~9�����d�2���>�ATF/4����1'�;- ��1�/�� �����!#�6��-F- eM?�/t1�/������L!5�"~@��~@-.&'�9�2�����6J+� 1�}5!#����� &+-.��� ����*7J<� 1���- ��!#����&'��~@���)����}q�

�6��!5&'* G)�2�����,-.�����,/3�<-�� �L*����2�L�3!5��&�� &����)�bJ+� 1d!5�)�2&'-F*�?3����*zG%��-m&'��}5���2�<$�� &'!(� ��}#��1 � �,&�-.1'1 /�&�-.� &2� ~/4-.!5�)�21,�-�P�L*��,1��,&�!5�4�;�2��!#1���!5�,&2� &'���%��!5�7�2���L���UT=�>1'���A�2!5- � �

����w���� � ������ �y4� �����,� � �"!

����w���� � ����� � $#O{ �����V{ �{�|E�]{=�&���L�&�&% � �� ��� ���6��!#1m1'���,��!5-.�k!5�)�2&'-F*3?����,1��7�2�����3��! B%?��M��-i/4��&0�O-.&�~ *F�F��� ~9!#�I/�-.1'!#��!#$.�@1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'!5-.�P�O- &j!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�*��A�2���A�2!#-.�9�)���2� e%!5���j� *F$ ���%�2� �.��- ��!5~@/�}5!#������!5-.�j&��,}(����!5-.�31���!#/�1]���A��J+�,���9*�! >���&'���)�d/�&�-.� &2� ~ /�-.!#�)�21�G� ��*t-.&'�)� ��! ��!5�3��/�&�- �.&2� ~u/�- !5�)�21�!5�)��-I�@}5������!5�����

����w���w '6��� �� ���4 �� � �Ey �&��R�I/�&'�,$=!5-.?31�$ ��&�1'!5-.�����F�,�,�2!#-.� � � p)�AG������ D;��!5e - �t10�=1'�2�,~ - /��,&2������*t!5�t~�?�}#��!5/�}#�E/�� 1'1��,1D-K$.�,&>�2�3�12��~9/�}#��1@�2-�!#�3�O��&9!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21�� �6���R~�?3}#�2!#/�}5�"/���1�1��,17/��,&�~@!#����*c- /3�2!#~9! ������!5-.��1I�4����� ?�1��Y����&0��� !#�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21N� &'�D� }8J<���=1+��&�?��>-.&d�l��}51���GF- &N�,��&'�2� !5�9*���&'!#$ ��*�$�� &�!5� ��}#��1d� &��>?���*��A�����,* � *N�I�2��10�2!#���B�2�3�1'��&�-.�3�.��10�>!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1<!5�7��� &�}#!5�,&</�� 1'1���1,G��2���EJN��� e���&�!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21<- &6����&0��� !#�"*���&'!#$.�,*7$ ��&�!(����}5�,1<~M�����- �N���,��*M��-B�4�D/�&'-F�,��1�1'��*"���+� }#}q�ZS - &N�UT���~9/�}#� G%!#� O G)( � }8J<���=1+��- }5*�1d-K$.��&+� ����� &�}#!5��&]/�� 1�1,GF�2�3���Ofh*( !#1;�����,��1�1�� &�!#}#�Q��&�?��@� ��*o���,��*P�3- �j���I!5�31'�����%��!(������* G ����10�2��*zG^-.&;&'��/4-.&'����*P- �k�"}(�:�2��&;/�� 1�1,��F!#~9!#}(� &'}#�.G)?3��}5�,1�1<�2�3�j!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�,+�- WYXVT/.1020 E _ R K T�HVUNWYX ��- }5*�1,GF�2�3�;*���&'!#$.�,*t$�� &'!(� �3}5� WYXVT�.3020 E _si4+ rV~M����4�j�3-.� : 1'����1'!5��� }q�

8 �

Page 62: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

��� Z��"�������N\ !/! +� ��� Z��"�������N\ !/!� ���� Z��"��� ! �J\��*��� � ������� � ^ ���S\���� ���"� # �� ^*���J\�����"Z�� ��� Z������ ����� ' ����� ���� Z��"��� ���"� '�� �\V^� � � !

!

S^!5� ?�&�� ��:0a �#"%$�&('*)�+-,/.�,�01+2&�34&�576-8�9;:#<=8(3>5@?A8B:76C'*)�+C,EDF&�G�&H01+C&(:7:7,�:1I

B.m2:::EXITreturnorig(this) orig(this.x) this.xthis

A:::CLASSA.n

A:::OBJECTthis.b this.b.x A.nthis

A.m:::ENTERarg arg.x this.b this.b.x A.nthis

B.m2:::ENTERthis.xthis

A.m:::EXITarg arg.x return this.b this.b.x A.norig(this)orig(arg) orig(arg.x) orig(this.b) orig(this.b.x) orig(A.n) this

B:::OBJECTthis.xthis

S^!#�.?�&�� ��: pF�KJL+-8 ?M34,�+C&�576-8�9;:7N�6-)POQ,15R?�,1,�9SG�&�346C&�O�+C,�:T<=8(3E57N�,U0V8�.�,*:7N�8 ?T9W629WJL6-X�Y;37,UZ�[@\�I^]�N;&(.;,�.W&�34,�&(:9;&('*,^57N�,*)�378(X(34&('_)Q8�6C9�51`a?TN;6C+-,KY;9;:7N;&(.;,�.bOQ8 $�,�:E37,1)�37,�:c,�9�5dG�&�346C&�O�+-,�:E&�5/57N;&�5/);378(X(34&('_)Q8�6C9�51Ifeg6C9�,�::7N�8�?h57N�,�)�&�375762&(+�8(34.�,1346C9;XKikjl.�,�:70V3m6-OQ,�.K629*]�,�0V576-8�9HZ�Ion�Iqp�`�?k6-57N^&/9�Y;OU&�5%57N�,>+-,�:7:c,13%,�9�.^8(<�57N�,�37,�+2&�576-8�9rIstJ�8(3>6C9�:c57&(9;0V,(`S\.^� ui j C�^*�( � \V^� � 6C9H57N;,d+-8�?A,13#+-,1<=5A0V8(3m9�,13�IwvKx>,�+2&�576-8�9;:�6C'*)�+C6C,�.*O�yH5c34&(9;:76-576CG�6-5@y^8(<z57N�,)�&�375762&(+Q8(34.�,13k&�37,{9�8(5#,V$�)�+C6C016-57+-y|.�34&�?T9rI

� ��!5}#�7-./4��&2�:�2!5�3�o!#� ~B?�}#��!5/�}#�M/�� 1'1��,1�G"D;� !#e -.�f� }#1�-Q�2&'��������*c��� ���c/3&�-.�.&�� ~ /4-.!5�)�I!#��*���/4��� :*��,�%��}#� �;�6����&'�,�O-.&'� G *��:���M�O&�- ~ - ����/�&'-.�.&2��~ /4-.!#�%�D~M���t�4��*�!51'��� &'*���*Q�4�,�O- &��B������- ������&>/�-.!#�)�21&*����2�b!516/�&'-F�,��1�1'��* �

����w���3 }o� �0� %;� � � � �� ���,~ ���+~9���'-.&�J+���j��-D!#~9/�&'-K$.�d/��,&'�O-.&'~M� �3��� �O-.&V*3�=��� ~@!5�d!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�Z*3�,�2�,�,��!5-.�m!51V�O-.&V/�&�-.� &2� ~�/4-.!5�)��1�2-L��-L}#-.���.�,&����6/3&�-=����1'1��,*M!5�3*���/4����*3���)�2}8�.�)&���10�2����* G)�2����*3�=��� ~@!5�+!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�]*��,�����A�2!5- �9��}5�.-.&'!#����~&��,}(������1<$�� &'!(� ��}#��1<�O&'-.~ � }#} /�&'-.�.&2��~C/4-.!5�)�216!#�t�I/�� &'��!(� }�-.&�*��,&��

�6���E&'��}(�:�2!5- ��1���!#/@�������N*��,������1+�����D/�� &'��!(� } -.&'*���&{� j !#18�01����,16� 1N~�?�����*��:���B��1 ���)&�� $�� &'!(� �3}5��1� ����*b�B12����!51'�v� � � j �3G)�2���,�"� }5} *����2�m1'�����"�:�d�m~�?�1'�<� }51'-B�4�D1'�����"�:� � 6 � 1����,1�� 1+~B?�����*����2�

8)a

Page 63: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� 1#��� � 1d�;��-.�31��CB%?��,������GF������!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21��2����� ��-.}#*b- $ ��& � � &����;1'?���1��A�+-�������-.1��6������� ��-.}#*I- $ ��&#��G1�!#�����m� �)�t*����2�I�������>��-.�)�2&�� *�!#�,�21>� �i!5�)$�� &�!5� �)��- $ ��&f�M~�?31'�D� }51'-9�,-.�)�2&2��*�!5�A�������B1�� ~@�j!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�-K$.�,& � �

S^!5� ?�&�� ��: pt1���-KJ�1b�2���9/�� &0�2!(��}N-.&'*���&j�O-.&�~@��*P�%� � j �O- &m�2�3���AT3� ~@/�}5�9��}5� 1�1'��1�- ��SZ!5�.?�&'� ��:a � m+-.��1�!#*���&m�2���9&���}5���2!#-.��1'��!5/o���A��J+�,��� ������� ���Je�t����*� � '�� ����� ����������"S^!5&'1'��G^&��,��� }#}d��������� }5}*����2�Y�O&�-.~ ~9�A�2��-=*h���)��&�!5�,1I~�?�1'�b� }51'-[� /�/�}8�P�2-R�����7-.���'�,�,�@!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21,� ��&��g- �2���,&�J+- &�*�1,G+-.� :�'���A�;!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21>~�?�10�L� }#J+���=1E��-.}#*R?�/4-.�Q~9�A�2��-=*R�,�%��&'� � �R�6���,&��,�O- &�� G JN�b����$.����������������� ��� �"! #"$P� j�����%����& '�()����� !�*�$�!"+�����*,������� R.- ������� ��� �"! #"$^� j ������� R/- ��& '�()����� !�*�$�!"+K���6����12� ~@����-.}5*31 ��&�?����O-.&]~@�,����-F*@�ATF!8�21�������%��������� ��� �"! #"$ � j ���0������& '�()����� !�1�23$ �DSZ!5��� }#}#� G���- �2�j�2���:�4�����%����& '�()����� !�*�$�!"+ � j65�7 �98��3������� � ������� !�1�23$ Gz1'!5���,�� �)�7/�&'� : 1'���:�2�L*����2�@��1�1�-=��!5���2�,*tJ�!8�2�t�b~9�A�2��-=*"�ATF!#��~�?31'������$.�j�4�����i1��,���Y- �t�,�)�2&'� �

S�-.&>&'��� 1'-.��1�1�!#~9!#}(� &+��-M-.�3��1>��������&��,}(�����;: 1>$�� &'!(� ��}#��1�� �,&�-.1'1D/�&'-.�.&�� ~ /�- !5�)�21,G �����j&���}5���2!#-.� :1��3!5/�16�2��������-.�)��&�!5�3?3�2�;�2-b�����L/�� &'��!(� }z-.&�*��,&�� &��j� 16�O-.}#}5-KJ�1��

<>=�? @BADC9AFEG@HE C�^*�( � ��I�d� &'!(� �3}5��1�-.�J��������7/4-.!5�)��1E� &'� � j ��������- &�&��,1�/4-.��*�!#���9C�^*�( � � $ ��&�!(����}5�,1E���E� }5}K� �ML 7����*� � e���N� L � �B/�&�- �.&2� ~u/�- !5�)�21,�

O 90P =MQ�CRAF@ 7TS�U A S @GC �WV E �FXYS C � =�C V E X 9 E � @ XKS�U AF= � I&���10��� �3���B$�� &'!(� ��}#��16�O&�- ~ ����� � ���Je�@/�&'-.�.&�� ~ /�- !5�)�E��&��W� j �����B�,-.&�&'��1�/4-.��*3!5����!#��1'�2� ���,�$�� &'!(� ��}#��1<- �Y� }#}����������GM� ��L �G�����*Z� � e9��N� L � ��/�&'-.�.&2��~C/4-.!5�)�21,�

O 90P =MQ�CRAF@ 7TS�U A S @GC �WV E �FX E U[S�� � AF@ � C S @BQ\= � E ]S C 6_^ = I&���10��� �3���9$�� &'!(� �3}5��1E�O&'-.~������, ������� M�`�De�7/�&'-.�.&�� ~ /4-.!5�)�m� &�� � j �2�3�9�,-.&�&'��1�/4-.��*3!5���t!5� :10��� ���,�t$�� &'!(� �3}5��1B-.� !#��1'��&�?�~@���)����* � &��.?3~9�,�%��1@� ��*g����}#*�1I- �>���=/4�Z3��� S�-.&b�UT3� ~9/3}5� Gd1��,�a 7 8Mb & 'c����� !�*�$�!"+ � ��*>������� R�d R b ����� ��� �"! #"$>!5�tS^!5� ?�&�� ��: p3� �

e � 9 Q �3S���� Af@ �g^BU = � = U�7 = � E 90P =MQ�CRAF@ 7�STU A S @�C � I&���10��� �3���;$�� &�!5� ��}5�,1N�O&'-.~u�����h ������� ���Je�m/�&'-.�.&2��~u/4-.!5�)����&��u� j �����;12��~9�;!#��1'�2� �����E$�� &'! :� �3}5��16- �i1'?����,}(� 1'1��,1>-.&6�3-.� : 10������!5�;!#������&6�,}(� 1'1��,1>- �B��

O 7 = U9U A X Af@ �k� =�C V E XZ�I�gS 6 E�@ � 6ji = S�k =M@lC V = �^ =MQ�A3?mQ S C9A3EG@ I� &��.?�~@���)�K�l1��E�2-Y�i~@�,����-F* ' ��&�� � j ��&��.?�~@���)�K�l1��;- �6~@�,����-=*�1j�������m-K$.��&'&�!#*��M-.&L!#~9/�}#� :~@���)� ' G��)�������L���,����$=!5-.&�� } 1�?3�3���=/�!5���9/�&�!#����!#/�}5���

����w�� � x � �E{&�Kn .�� �Ey �V{ � 4"�� �0� %;� � � � �� ���,� 161'��-KJ��i!#���2���;/3&��,$=!#-.?�161��,�,��!5-.� GF�2���;/���&'�2!5� }4-.&�*��,&�!#���b- �V$�� &�!5� ��}5�,1<!5~@/�}#!5��1 �2�����<J����,�i!#�%$�� &'! :� �)�21V��- }5*;�2&'?�� - $ ��&�$�� &�!5� ��}#��1����`�,��&'�2� !5�L/�&'-.�.&�� ~ /4-.!5�)��1�GK�2��- 1�� !5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21V� }#1�-6~�?31'�`��-.}#*E�2&�?3�N�:�}5-KJN��&>� ��1d*3&2��J��9!#�MSZ!5�.?�&'� ��: p)�^/�&�- �.&2� ~ /�- !5�)�21,�]S�-.&]!5��10��� �3��� G%!8��JN�>���K$ �]������� R.- ������� ��� �"! #"$ h ( G�2�3���"J+�L� }#1�-be%��-KJ ������� a 7 8 R.- b & 'c����� !�*�$�!"+ h ( �-�k�;����}5}�����!51<�����po�� �����N� �qoMr9/�&'-./4��&'����- �`/�&�-.� &2� ~/4-.!5�)�21,�

DD�=��� ~@!5�R!#�%$�� &'!(� �)�M*��,�����,��!5-.� ��� � ���Q-./F�2!5~@!��,��* �)� �2� e%!5���g��*3$�� �)��� �.�Y- �m����!51M��!5�,&2� &'���%�/�&'-./��,&'��� � ~ ���tJ<���g�2-k*�-k����!51,G+J���!#��� JN�R����$.�i!5~@/�}5�,~9�,�%����*f!5�g�2���$D;� !5e�-.�f1'�=1'����~tG6!51@�%�!5�31'�����%��!(����!5���3G]��������e%!5�3��G6� ��*g&'��/4-.&'��!5���[!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21I�:�b�2���"[email protected]'�I�.�,����&�� }6/�}5� ���7�2�3�,�h�,-.?�}5*f�4�

8 p

Page 64: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

1'�2���2�,* �<S�-.&6!#��1'�2� ���,� G !#�^� �t!5�)$�� &�!5� �)��� }#J+���=1>��- }5*�1�-K$.�,&D� �t-.���'�,�,�& 1�����}#*�1�G !8�6J+-.?3}5*t-.��}#���ATF!510����>�2��� � ���Je�@/�&'-.�.&�� ~ /�-.!#�)�I�l!#��1'����� *Y- � ��� ���Q~@�,����-=* 1]���������� ��*J� ��L M/4-.!5�)��1��AGz� ��*YJN-.?�}#*-.��}8�����,��*t�2-I���;����1'����*t-.���,�m/4��&61�� ~9/3}5� �

S�-.&E/�&'!5�)�2!#���7!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21��O-.&E�2���b?31���&,G��2���I� }#�.-.&'!#�2�3~ ��-.?�}#*[}5-=��������� }#}^!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21D- $ ��&j��1��A�- ��$�� &�!5� ��}5�,1 � ���@�Q/�&'-.�.&2��~ /4-.!5�)� � �)���O- &�~@!5���Y�����"��}#-.1�?�&'�"- �H� �:� ��?�1�!#���Q�2���7/�� &'��!(� }-.&'*���&'!5����Gz� ��*R�2� e%!5���M������?��3!5-.�g�O��-.���'?����,��!5-.���>- �]�2�3��!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21>/�&��,1����)�j���E��� ���[/4-.!5�)�>!5�R�2�3���}#-.1�?3&�� �

+>-KJN�,$.�,&�G��O-.& �2�3!51N���������3! B%?��E- �V~@!5�3!5~9� }3!#�%$�� &'!(� �)�N!5��10��� �)��!(����!5-.�b�2-mJ+-.&'e G3�4- �2�M�����D1�� ~@/�}5�,1� ��*7�����;!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21<~B?�1'� ;�-KJ �2��&'-.?��.�7�����;/�� &0�2!(��}z-.&'*���&6!#�"��1�/4����!8���;J<��� G � 16�ATF/�}5� !5���,*7!5�7�2�3����UTF����JN-M1'���,��!5-.�31��

����w���� � �<]� �0���+� � � !�6���>��� !#$ �D��}5�.-.&'!#����~ !#��1'�2� �)�2!(�:�2��1d� }#}�/�- 1�1�!#��}5��!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1D�O~9-=*�?�}#-;���F/4�D�,-.��10�2&2��!5�)�212�d���+� }#}�/�&�- :�.&�� ~ /�-.!#�)�21���p>-KJg�2���+��!5�,&2� &'���%�m/�&'-./��,&'���m*���1'��&'!5�4��*I� �4-K$.�<}#��� *�1Z�2-E���AJf&�?�}#��1Z�O- &^!5�31'�����%��!(����!5���!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21�����*7�O-.&<J��������2-I*�-IJ����,�Y�����,��e=!#���M!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��16� �)��!5��10��*������F�

%c@ � C S @�C9A S C9A3EG@ DE?�&'!5���P�����R1'�,�2?3/ /3��� 1��Q/3&�!5- &@��-h1����,!5���h*������3G�!#��1'�2� �)�2!(�:�2�Y!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��19- ��}#�J����,&����2�3�,�PJN-.?�}#*h��- �b�4�7!5�F�O��&�&�� ��}#�@�O&'-.~ �R�,-.&�&'��1'/�-.�3*�!5���R$ ��&'1�!5- �f�3!5�.���,&B!#���2�����3!5��&�� &����)� �S�-.&��UT���~9/�}#� G]�2�3�"� }5�.- &�!#����~ J+- ?�}5*g��- �I!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2� a 7 8 R.- b & 'c����� !�*�$�!"+ h ( 1'!5���,�"!#��JN-.?�}#*f���K$ �!5�31'�����%��!(������* a 7 8 R/- b & 'c����� ��� �"! #"$ h ( �O-.&b�2���t�CB%?�!8$�� }5�,�%�9!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�@���9�[��!5�.�3��&@/�&�-.� &2� ~ /4-.!#�%���A�S�-.&�~9� }#}#�.G !5��10��� �)�2!5���2!#-.�@!51+- ��}#�@� }#}5-KJN��*9J��3���"-.���>-.&+~@-.&���- � �����D$�� &'!(� ��}#��1d- �V� �M!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�+����1��-t/�&��,*����,��1'1�-.&�!#�Q�2��� � j /�� &0�2!5� }�-.&'*���&,�M�6�����m!51,G`�t1'�,�8� -�� � $�� &�!5� ��}5�,1;1���- ?�}5*o���@?�1'��*k��-!5�31'�����%��!(�����L� � � : � &'�7!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�<-.��}#�M!#����� � � �1�R�:� F� j �4�

�pV =MQ k AF@ � � �����7���M!5�)$�� &'!(� �)� !51 �l� }#1�!#����*@-.&]J+��� e �,����*t���+�j/3&�-.�.&�� ~ /4-.!5�)�d*�?�&'!5���j!5�3�O�,&��,������G��- /%�R!#� �0*�-KJ����7�2-7�2���b!#~9~@��*3!(�����m����!#}5*Q/�&'-.�.&�� ~ /4-.!#�%��1��?*N�Q����!#}5*R/3&�-.�.&�� ~�/4-.!#�%��GzJN�b~9��� �/�&'-.�.&2��~ /4-.!5�)�K�l1��6J�����&'�b�,$ ��&'�Y$ ��&�!(����}5�j?�1��,*[�%�i�2���B!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�E!51>}5�,1�1E!#�R�2����/�� &'��!(� }`-.&�*3��&�!#�����*N�I����� &��,1'�dJ+��~@��� �I�2���:�d������&'�>~B?�1'�d�4���3-m!#�%����&'~9�,*�!(�����6/�&�- �.&2� ~ /�-.!#�)�21���S - &]�AT3� ~@/�}5��G%J��3���a 7 8 R/- b & 'c����� ��� �"! #"$ h ( !51��l� }#1�!8����* G>!#�"!#17��-./�!#��* *�-KJ�� ��- + � ' ����� ��������g� 1 a 7 8 R/- b & 'c����� !�*�$�!"+ h ( �S�-.&�~9� }#}#�.G��6�l��}51�!8����*L!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��-K$ ��&Z��1'�,�Z- �F1�-.?�&'��� $�� &�!5� ��}5�,1 Eg1���- ?�}5*j��� �,-./�!5�,*;�2->��*3��1'��!5���:�2!5- �1��A��CJ������o� }#}`$�� &'!(� �3}5��1>!5�� � &'�b���E������1�� ~9�B/�&�-.� &2� ~ /�- !5�)�;� �3*[J��3��� � + � E ��� �0��� ���+b� j �A� �k�����(�Q�2+ � j � � j �A�A�

~ ���D/4-.1�!8�2!8$.����-.�31��CB%?��,�����;-��z�2�3!51d� /�/�&'-)� ����!#1]�2�����N~@�,�2�3-F*�1 *��A�����,*7!5�@!5�)�2�,&'�l� �,��1 J�!5}5}����K$ �!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�219&��,/�-.&0�2�,*�- $ ��&�������!#&7� &�� ?�~9�,�)�21�G��A$.��� �2�3-.?��.����-h1�� ~@/�}5�,1M����� �A$.�,&7���Y�2� e �,� -.�!5�)����&'�l������1;*3!5&��,�,��}#�.�LS�-.&>�AT3� ~@/�}5��Gz!8� �,$.�,&'�Q!#~9/3}5��~@���)�2���2!#-.�i-��+���Q!5�)�2�,&'�l� �,�� 1E~9�A�2��-=*Q!51>��� }#}5�,*J�!#���M�;��- � : �%?�}#} � &��.?3~9�,�%��G2D;� !5e�-.�bJ�!5}#}�&��,/�-.&0� �2��!#1]/�&�-./4��&0���@� 1d�j&'�CB%?�!#&���~@���)�d- �4�2����!5�)����&'�l����� G!5�31'�2��� *t- ����1��@&'�CB%?�!5&'��~@���)��- �Z��� ���t!5~@/�}5�,~9�,�)������!5-.� �

����w���� '����u|;� � � � !&��h�2���M!5�)$�� &�!5� �)� ;�-KJC� }5�.- &�!#����~tG^!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21 ;�-KJC*3- J�� � 1B�����,��� &����l��}51�!8����*z�o�6�3!51�/�&'-./4��&'���1�?3�.�.��10�21>�b��-.&'&���1'/�- ��*�!5�3� ;�-KJ � }5�.- &�!#����~ �2-@/�&�-=���,1�1�12��~9/�}#��1,�

8

Page 65: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

A.m:::ENTERthis.b.x A.n

A:::OBJECTthis.b.x A.n

A.m:::EXITthis.b.x A.norig(this.b.x) orig(A.n)

1 10 0

S^!#�.?�&�� ��: �� " $�&('U)�+-,|629;.;6C01&�576C9;Xu57N�,B9;,1,�.l<=8(3K)�&�57N�6C9�<=8(34'U&�576-8�9l6C9 :7&('U)�+-,|&(9�.l6C9�G�&�346C&(9�5��;8�? ` &(:.�,�:70V3m6-OQ,�.W629l]�,�0V576-8�9 Z�Ion�I���I�� )a8(34576-8�9 8(<#J�6CX�Y�37,HZ�[@nu6C: 37,1);378�.;Y;0V,�.r`z&(+C8�9�X ?k6-57NS& )a8(5c,�9�576C&(+ :4&('*)�+-,s���`��;`�F`��vmI�E6-G(,�9f8�9;+-yd57N;&�5g:4&('*)�+-,(`�57N�, 6C9�G�&�346C&(9�5 ����� ������� ����������&�5 + ������� ��`�De�k:7N�8�Y�+C./N�8�+C.rI �k8�?A,1G(,13 `6-</57N�,W:7&('*)�+C,!�;8�?k:|&(: 6C9�.;6C01&�5c,�.hO�yh57N�,WOQ8�+C.h+C629#"�:H8(</57N�,W)�&�37576C&(+k8(34.�,13�`>57N;,b6C9�G�&�3m6C&(9F5|?A8�Y�+C.�OQ,6C9;0V8(3437,�0V57+-yB<=&(+C:46�$;,�.rI&%>N�,137,1<=8(37,(`;57N;,/)�&�57Nu57&'"(,�9W6C:#6C'*)Q8(3757&(9�51I

�.�"&�*��,�)�2!#�v�M�2���L�AT3� �A��/�&�-.� &2� ~ /4-.!#�%�+J�����&'�j�����L12� ~@/�}5�EJ+� 1�*�&��KJ��t�O&�-.~t�

a ��S�-.&'~��2���9��}#-.1�?�&'�9-��6/�&�- �.&2� ~�/�-.!#�)�21L�2�����m����$.�M� �)�[$ ��&�!(����}5����}#}5�,*k!#�k�)�[�O-.}5}#-KJ�!5���7�2�3�&'��}(�:�2!5- ��1<?�/)J+� &�*i!5�7�2���L/���&'�2!5� }z- &�*��,&��

p3��S����,*Q�2���b1�� ~9/3}5�B��-7��� ���o- � �2���,1��I/�&'-.�.&2��~ /4-.!5�)��1;!5�Q���2- /�-.}#-.�.!#��� }V-.&'*���&,� � 12��~9/�}#�B!#1�O�,*��2-b��/4-.!5�)�+���v�2�,&<!#�+��� 1<�4���,���O��*���-b� }5}4/4-.!5�)�21dJ�����&'�L�B$�� &�!5� ��}5��!51N�.&������2�,&��]�6���,&��A�O-.&���G� �)�9�l� }51'!#���,*�!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21+� &��;��}#J+�K�=16�,-./�!5�,*��2-b}#- JN��&+/�&�-.� &2� ~ /�- !5�)�21N���A�O-.&��E�����E12��~9/�}#�D!#1�O�,*t������&'�L��-b�l� }51'!#�v�@�2���,~i�

����w��)( *Y�^���E{S�-.&M�4- ����!5�)$�� &�!5� �)��� �3*�12� ~@/�}5�(;�-KJLG������R/������ ��� e������2�3&�-.?�� � �2���R/�� &'��!(� }�-.&�*3��&�!#1M!5~@/4-.& :�����%���YS�-.&j�AT3� ~@/�}#� G��,-.��1�!#*���&BS^!5� ?�&�� ��: 3��o;!#$ ����- ��}#�Q����!51m*������FG�D;� !#e -.�k1���-.?3}5*�&'��/4-.&'�j�2���:�WYX +,+ R \ R OqG�. R H ��� + ������� ��`�De�3�*+�-KJ+�A$.��&,G.1�!#������JN� ����$.� �����%� R�d R.- b ����� ��� �"! #"$d� j 5�7 �98��3������� R d R/- � b & 'c����� !�1�23$� ��* � R,- b ����� ��� �"! #"$P� j � R,- b & 'c����� !�1�23$�G �2����$�� }#?���1E�O-.& C�^ �� � �%� �,! ��Z � #�� � ��* + � �"J+- ?�}5*Q�l� }#1�!#�v�"�����b!5� :$�� &�!5� �)���E�6�3�b/�&�-.�3}5��~ !#1>�2�����E�2�3�B��J+-"/��:�2��1D����&�- ?��.�R�2�3��/�� &0�2!(��}`- &�*��,&;� &��B*�! >���&'���)� 6 �����,��2&���$.��&'1��j*�! >���&'���)��/�&�- �.&2� ~u/�- !5�)�21,�

�Z-I��*�*�&��,1�1+����!51N/�&�- ��}5�,~iG%J+�L������- �2���2�>��� ���7�,*��.�E!#�M�2���>/�� &0�2!(��}�-.&'*���&dJ�!#����1�-.~@�D�3-.������� �/�� !#&+- ��$�� &'!(� �3}5��1/. + � 0 +��21 !51d�2-.� �,�2�3��&+&'��}5���2�,*��2-3.(4� 0 ��1 �)�@�2���E/�� &'��!(� } -.&'*���&<!8���2���D/����2�9�O&�-.~+ �E��-b4�E�O-.}#}5-KJ�16�2���j12��~9�j��-.���,��1D� 1>�����m/����2�t�O&�-.~ +\� ��-b � �<�6���m��-.���,��1>~�?�1'�>�4�m����- 1����Q1'-�2�����E1'�,�21;-��d$�� &'!(� �3}5��1��O&�- ~ ��JN-"/�&�- �.&2� ~ /4-.!5�)��1>�2�����L� &'�B&��,}(������*Q*�?3�B�2-M������1�� ~9�B!#�2�,~ �O&�-.~�2�3��}5!#1'�>1'����&'�2!#���M- �R/�� �.� 8 p9~�?31'�;1'��� &��m�2����1�� ~@�B��-.�3��� �H&��R�2��&'~91>- �dS^!#�.?�&�� ��: pFG�/���&2� }#}5��}�- &����� &�}8� : /�� &�� }5}#��}4}5!5�3��1<�O&�- ~C-.���L/�&'-.�.&�� ~C/4-.!5�)�6��-9����- �2�3��&6J�!5}#}z����$.�L�2�3�j1�� ~@�j�3-.�������

����w��)5 � ������ �y4� ��{3�E� | �� �Y!5~@/�-.&0��� �)��/�&'-./��,&'���i- �]�2�3�B��!#��&2��&����)�Y/3&�-./4��&0���Y/�&'��1'���)�2�,*o1'-M�l� &�!51��2�����>�2���j$�� &�!5� ��}5�,1D����*/�&'-.�.&2��~ /�-.!#�)�21b�O-.&�~ �[�2&'���t?���*��,&9�2�3��� j &��,}(����!5-.�31���!#/g�O- &M� �)�f-.���t&���� 1�- � �2�����9$�� &'!(� �3}5��1

8)�

Page 66: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

S^!#�.?�&�� ��:0� �`�6�3��� *3$�� �)��� � �6- � ��� ��*3}5!5�3�E�CB%?�� }#!#���m1�/4���,!(� }#}#�.� � !8�2��-.?F�]�CB%?�� }#!#���m��� ��*3}5!5�3�b� ����-K$.����2�3��&��+� &�� E!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21V1��K�=!#��� +�G �KG , � ��* /;��&��+�A$.�,� ���6���,&��6� &'� 8 !#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1V12���=!5���D�����N$�� &'!(� �3}5��1� &'�B�CB%?���}q��� !8�2�i�CB%?�� }#!#���t��� ��*3}5!5�3�M� }#}��2������B%?�� }5!8���t!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21���-.}#}(� /�1'�m!#�)�2-M- ���B��B=?�� }5!8���i1'�,��GJ���!#}5�;�,$ ���i!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21�� &'�;&���/3&���1'���)�2�,*R�)� � � ��� ��+=�<-.�7�2�3�j}#��� *3��&6- �Z�2���L1��A���

&��,}(����� G�1'?����f� 1�~@�,����-F*P!5��10��� ���,�M$�� &�!5� ��}#��1L�2-R-.�;�'���,��!5��10��� ���,�M$�� &�!5� ��}#��1��i�6����$�� &�!5� ��}#��1j- ���/�&'-.�.&2��~CJ+- ?�}5*"�2�%?�1��O-.&�~ �b�O-.&'��1'�>?���*3��&��2���j/�� &0�2!(��} -.&�*3��&�� +>-KJN�,$.�,&�G4J������i~�?�}#��!5/�}#�E&���� 1�- ��1� &'�9�,-.~���!#����* G`$�� &�!5� ��}5�,1j� &��@��-R}#-.���.�,&m��}#J+�K�=1m&���}5���2�,*��"�2&��,� 6 �2�3�,�k��� �k���,��-.~@�M�i�.�����,&2� }*�!#&����A�2�,*Y� �A�=��}5!#�;�.&2��/�� �

S�-.&��AT3� ~@/�}#� G J�!8�2�b~�?�}8�2!#/�}5�d!5���3��&�!8��� �3���L�O*�?��<�2-L!#�%����&0�l� ���,1��AG%�E~@�,����-=* 1^1�/4����!8�����:�2!5- �b��-.?�}#*�4�Y�.-K$.�,&����,* �%�f~�?3}#�2!#/�}5�"!#�%����&0�l� ���,1�G61�-P!#�21M� &�� ?�~9�,�)�219JN-.?�}#* ����$.�Y~�?�}#��!5/�}#�7/�� &'���)�21�!#�c�2�3�/�� &0�2!5� }z-.&'*���&,�

�6�%?�1NJN�D��� �9�3-B}5- ���.��&]1����b�2����� �����9!#�%$�� &'!(� �)� -.�3}#�I� /3/���� &�1N��� �2�������}����� ���Y��J����,&��D!8� ~M����4��~9- 1'�b�.�,����&�� }5}8�o1'���:�2��* ��� &��31'�2��� * G]JN�t&'�,JN-.&�* �'- ����/�}5� �����R�2-#�����¡�����N�n�¡�]� �����9� � ��� ���Y�Y�A�� �7!#~9/3}5��~@���)�2���2!#-.�bJ+-.?3}5*�����$ �E�2-B�2� e �E!#�)�2-�������- ?��)�<�2���D��-.� : �2&��,�E������?�&��>- ���2�3�E/�� &0�2!(��}4- &�*��,&J����,�(;�-KJ�!5�3�@1�� ~@/�}5�,1�� ��*"$ ��&�!(����}5�,1��

*,+�� � � 0;8�� > 0�� "��,:'�1� >?2��~ ���D*F�F��� ~9!#�>/4-.1'!#�2!8$.����}#!5~@!5���:�2!5- ���2�����3��! B%?��>!51 �2-�������*�}5���CB%?���}5!#���I1'/��,��!5� }5}8�.�^�6�3!51d12��$.�,161�/�� �,�� ��*Q��!5~@�B!5�R��JN-7J<���=1���oL!8$.����"$�� &�!5� ��}5�,1>�������j� &'�b� }#J+���=1;�CB%?�� } 6 ! � ���#Gz���,}5-.������-��2���b1�� ~@��CB%?���}5!#���L1'�,��� � � �k�+����$.�+-.���+��B%?�� }5!8���L!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�V�O-.&`�����+1'�,�^&2��������&V�2����� @I� �2AU� ��J+- : J<���m�CB%?�� }#!#���!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21,� a � �k�M����$.�7!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1m- ��}#�[-.�P-.����~@��~��4��&j- ����� ���h�CB%?�� }#!#���[1'�,�b&����2���,&m����� � �!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21N�O-.&+��� ���i~@��~B���,&�� � !#�2�7!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1<- �`~@-.&����2��� �"-.�3�E$ ��&�!(����}5��G=�����;12��$=!5��� 1<�O-.&+�2�3�}(�:���2�,&6��� �"�4�L����-.&'~9- ?�1��

� 1<1'���,�7!5�7S^!#�.?�&'� ��:� G)}5�A�<?�1<1������B/3&�-.�.&�� ~ /4-.!5�)�<��� 1N�O-.?3&N$�� &�!5� ��}#��1�G1+�r �Kr , r /I� ��*M�����,�M� &'�� }#}���B=?�� }q�]�6���,&��;!#1<� �7!#�%$�� &'!(� �)� �i�2���:�6��� �"��/�/�}#�@-K$.�,&�� �)��-.�3�E- �V�2���,~i�5p>-.&'~M� }#}#�4G)J+�EJN-.?�}#*���,��* 8 ��B=?�� }5!8����!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21<��-I�ATF/�&��,1�1��2���L�CB%?���}5!#���4�

+ G �Kr + G�, r + G /�r � G�, r � G /�r ,=G /� ��*. I!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21<��-@1'��-KJ �R����}#*"-.�i��� ��� �����+=�Ur ��� �A�Ur ��� , �Ar�����/=�� !#���@�����D?�1'�>-�� �CB%?���}5!#���I1'�,��1�G%J+�>����$.�D- ���>*������L1'��&�?��A�2?�&'�>�2�����+e����,/�1+�2&�� ��eb- ���2�����CB%?�� }#!#���

&��,}(����!5-.�31���!#/ G.� �3*b-.��}#�m��&'�������6-.���6�,-./)��- � �9�O-.&]�E��� ��-.�3!5����}3~@��~��4��&,G.-.&[��� �J������- � �2���61'�,��G�����+=�A��6���I}5��� *��,&;!51;����-.1'���P� &���!8�2&�� &�!#}#�"�O&�-.~ �2���b1'�,���@�6�3!51L12��$.�,1m1'/�� �,�@�4����� ?�1'�@JN�I*�-i�3- �L�����,*o��-

8:8

Page 67: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

e �,��/t�2&2����eM- �Z- �2�3��&6!5�31'���������,16- � �Y- &6�CB%?�� }#!#���9!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21�� S�?�&0�2���,&�G3����!51+12��$.�,1���!5~@� G3�,1�/4���,!(� }#}#�J����,�Y�����,��e=!#��� �R!#16��-.~@/�?3�2���2!#-.��� }#}#�I�ATF/4����1'!#$ � �

�6��!51 !#1 �L*F�F��� ~9!#� G)/4-.1�!8�2!8$.�6��}#!5~@!5���:�2!5- � �$��� �,��!#1]1�?�/�/3&���1'1��,*��)�����+=�]� ��* + G � G=� �3*@1'��-.?�}#*�2�3�;}(���'�2��&+���D�l��}51�!8����*zG ��� �,�NJ�!#}5}4����$.�;�2-b�4�;��&'��������*i� 16� �"!#�%$�� &'!(� �)�N�2-b�4�;��������e���* � �k�;*�-b��-������$.�L�2-@1�/4���,!(� }#}#�9��� ��*3}5� ����+=�<�4��!5�3�I�l��}51�!8����*zG�1�!#�����m� 1�}5-.�3�9��1 + G �E����}#* G���� �,�+JN-.?�}#*Y� }#1�-I�4��l� }#1�!#����* �

�6���B��B%?�� }5!8���7-./3��!5~@!������2!#-.�M�2-I�2�3� D;� !#e -.�"�2-=-.} !#1�1�?�~@~M��&�!��,��*t���,}5-KJLG � 1>� �i� ?��.~@���)���:�2!5- ��2-b�����L�����2!8$.�j� }#�.-.&�!8�2��~t�

%c@ ADC9A S�� A�� S C9A3EG@ *+�,�O- &��o&�?����3!5���h�2�3�k&'��1'�t- �m�2���o� }#�.-.&'!#�2�3~iG�� }#}E��-.~@/�� &�� ��}#�R$ ��&�!(����}5�,1"���t�/�&'-.�.&2��~u/4-.!5�)����&��;/�}5� ���,*t!#�)�2-��2�3�;12� ~@�;�CB%?�� }#!#���91��A���l��*����2��1'�2&'?��,��?�&����A� k � ���i��B%?�� }5!8���M1'�,��!#1�.!8$.���9� �@� &'��!#��&2� &0�B}#��� *��,&]�O&�-.~�J�!#�2�3!5���2�3��1'�,���(� �����@�2������- &�~9� }�� }#�.-.&'!#�2�3~�!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2�,1��l��-.� :�CB%?���}5!#���3� !5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21�G=J+�E� }5}#- J !#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2!#-.�9- ��}#�I�O-.&<!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1dJ��3-.1��E$�� &'!(� ��}#��1+� &��E}#��� *3��&�1N- ��2�3��!5&6��B%?�� }5!8����1'�,�21,�

< �BU AF@ � Q V =MQ k AF@ � � �<�A$.�,&'�9*������m12� ~@/�}5��*�?3&�!5�3�B�����,��e=!#����G���� ������B=?�� }5!8���I1��,�<!51 ��&�10�<�����,��e ��*�2-t1��,�9!8�+!8�21;~@��~��4��&'1j� &��I1'��!5}#}��CB%?�� } � &��N��- ��G`�����I�CB%?�� }#!#���Q1'�,�m!51;1'/�}5!8�L!5�)�2-"���AJ 1��A�21�GZ1�-"�2���:�$�� &�!5� ��}#��1ZJ�!8�2�I12��~9�+$�� }#?���1 ��&��6/�}5� ���,*b!5�)�2-E�����612� ~@�61��A�����6�3��!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1^- �4�2�3�6-.}5*�1'�,�& 1 }5��� *��,&� &'�D��- /�!5�,*M�2-m��� ���7- �������D�3�,J }5��� *���&'1�� � �v�2��&d�2��!#1�GF� }5} - ������&N!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21D�l1'-.~9�>- � J���!#���7~M���@�4����AJ�}#�7�,-./�!5�,* �6� &��;���3����e �,*[� 1�?�1�?�� }q�

' E � C ^ U E_Q\= ��� Af@ � �6���D�CB%?�� }#!#���I1��A�21N��� � GF���d�2���>����*M- � �2�3�D&�?3�9�2�3&�-.?�� �M�2�����ATF�,��?3��!5-.��*������3G�4�8�'*3�,$.- }#$.�,*��E������e;!5�)�2-�&��,�.?�}(��&V��JN- : J<���j�CB%?�� }#!#���L!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1�� +>-KJh�2�3!51V!51V*�-.�3�+*��,/��,��*�1^- �m�2�3�?�1'��&& 1+/3&��,�O�,&��,�����,1�� *N�I*��,�l��?�}#��G%����!51 /4-.1'�N/�&'-F�,��1�1'!5���m1'�2� �.����&������2�,1N��JN- : J+���@�CB%?�� }#!#���I!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21�4�,��JN�����Q������}5��� *��,&D- �]��� ���Q�CB%?���}5!#���t1'�,�L� �3*R!#��1D~@��~��4��&'1�G4&2��������&D����� �R�4�,��JN���,�o� }5}V~@��~��4��&'1- �^� �t�CB%?�� }#!#����1'�,���p>- ��!5�,���2�����L�����I*3�=��� ~@!5����}5}#�t1'?�/�/�&'��1�1'��*h!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1�G�1�?3����� 1 ��� �A�AG`� &��Ie���/3�m!5~@/�}5!#��!8�2}#���%��2�3�6�CB%?�� }#!#����~@������� ��!51'~i�VJ����,� �+�3-;}5-.��� ��&���B=?�� }51 +�G.J+��1'!5~@/�}#�m��-./)��9�O&'-.~ +����6�3��1'/�� �,�>����*�2!#~9��12��$=!5�3�.1<*��,/��,��*"-.����-KJ ~M���%�9!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21N� &'�E�CB%?�� }�*�?�&'!5�������3����e%!5���3�d�6�3�E~9- &��>$�� &'!(� �3}5��1�2������� &��L��B=?�� } �O-.&��I}5-.��� ��&6� ~@-.?��)��- �`�2!#~9��G3�2�3�j~@-.&'�E�2���L12��$=!5�3�.1��

�6���<����-K$.�+1�?�~@~M��&'�;�.!8$.�,1�� �m- $ ��&0$F!#�,Jf- �3��-KJf�>��� !8$.�N!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�V!5�3�O�,&����3���<��}5�.-.&'!#����~ ��� ���4�� }8�2��&'��*7�O-.&<1���$F!#���b�2!#~9�;����*"1�/�� �,�L?�1�!#���I�CB%?�� }#!#���.�)&���!#16-.��� : /�� 1'16���,��� ?31��j!#�61'!5~@/�}#�9� *�*31�1'-.~@�1'����/�1L�2-"�2�3�9��}5�.-.&'!#����~ �4�,�O- &��b!5�3!#�2!5� }5! ������!5-.�i� ��*o�4�,�O-.&'�@��� ���o12� ~@/�}5�b!#1L/�&�-=���,1�1��,* � +�-KJ+�A$.��&,G���31�?�&'!5���@1�-.?3��*����,1�1E����*"��-.~@/�}5�A�2�,����1'1>&'�CB%?�!5&'��1���� �3*�}5!#������$.�j!51'1�?��,1��

� m+-./)�=!5�3�L� ��*�!#��1'�2� �)�2!(�:�2!5�3�D��-.� : �CB%?���}5!#���j!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1^�4�,��JN�����I~@��~��4��&'1�- �������<12��~9�<��B%?�� } :!8����1��A���

� m+-.?3�%��!5���b�����L�=?3~����,&�- �^*������I12� ~@/�}#��161��,���

� m+-.?3�%��!5���b�����L�=?3~����,&�- �^~@!51'1�!#���b*����2�I1�� ~@/�}5�,1�1'���,�

� � ���,�i!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1�� &��L��-���!5��10��� �)�2!5���2�,*7J�!#�2�"&'��1�/4���A�>��-I*������8;�-KJ

� ~ �2�3��&�/�- 1'��/�&'-F�,��1�1'!5���@!51'1�?��,1�P�L*�!#1��,?�1�1���� ���i- �`�2���,1��j!5���2�3�j1'���A�2!5- ��1��������6�O-.}#}5-KJL�

8 �

Page 68: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

S^!#�.?�&�� ��: 8 ��� �3��� �b1�/3}5!#��1m- >f�O&'-.~��0+�r ,�� !#�m!51j��- �B� *���B%?����2�@�2-i1�!5~@/�}8�Q��-./)�[�2�3�M!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21�O&�- ~��2���I-.}#*[}5����*���&;�2-7�����9�3�,JL�@�6���@��JN-Y� &2���.�,* : -.?F�m!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1�G ��+�r �A�E� ��* # ��+�r �Kr ���;1���-KJJ�������JN-.?�}#*t�4�L~9!#1�1'!5�����

����3 ��� x �N| � ���, ���,�����E{%�����+� �0�^� � � ��� 4 ���6�� �0���+�3{

� ���,�Q� �t�CB%?�� }#!#���71'�,�E!#1�1�/�}#!#��*�?�&'!5���@!5�F�O��&��,������Gz���%�"!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��16�O&�-.~C�����j}5����*���&�- �������j-.}5*"1��A�� &'�t�,-./�!#��*g-.�)�2-[�2���"}#��� *��,&�1b- �>�2���"���AJ 1'�,�21,� �6�3!51I!51b���,���,1�12��&'�g�2-[&��,/�&��,1��,�%�9�2���7�l� �A�b�2���:�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21B~M����&'��~9� !5�k�2&�?3�7-.�h�2���7���AJ 1'�,�21I��?F�b�l� }51'!#���,*h-.�h�2���7-.}#*h1��A�21�� +>-KJ+�A$.�,&�G<~@��&'���- /%�=!#���9!#16��- ��� *3�CB%?������ �k � ���P- � �����I���,J }5����*���&'1m����*Q�2���I-.}#*Q}5����*���&;~@!5�.�)�;���K$ �9-��2���,&;!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21E�4�,��JN���,�P�2���,~ :1��,}#$ ��1�� �6���Q�AT3� ~@/�}#�R!5� S^!#�.?�&'� ��: 8 *���~@-.��10�2&����2�,1��2��!#1����6���R�2-./�/�� &'�71'��-KJ�17�2���Q10�������R- �!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�;!#�3�O��&'�����,�@�4�,�O- &��I�7���,&'����!5�[12� ~@/�}#�b!51;1��,��� GVJ���!#}5�B�����I��- �'�2-.~ 1���-KJ�1L�2���b10�������@���v�2�,&�2�3��12� ~@/�}#� � *+�A�O-.&���G +o!#1B�2���M}5����*���&m- ���2������B%?�� }5!8���P1'�,�b-����0+�r �Kr ,�� � � �v����&,G��@1'/�}5!8�21B- > !5�)��-!#��1B-KJ��g�CB%?�� }#!#���k1��A��� �f!51b�i$�� &'!(� �3}5�9�������mJ<� 1b�3- �b!5�k�2����- &�!5� !5��� } ��B=?�� }5!8���P1'�,� +�r �Kr , �[�6���!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�L�2�,~9/�}5���2�,1j� &�� � �l?3��� &'�3�UG �O��!5����&'�3�j����* # �O����&'��� &'�3�U� � 1�1'?�~9�@�2���9!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21j� &'���- ~9~�?F������!#$.�E�O- &<�2���,!5&<$�� &�!5� ��}#��1L�O!q� � �8G ��+�r �A��� � �Kr +=�'�A� ~ &�!#�.!5����}5}#� G)�2���L!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21<� &��������+=�Ur �������Ur ��+�r ���U�&��NJN�I1�!#~9/�}8�Y�,-./�!#��*Q-K$.�,&L�����I!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21E-��d�����b-.}#*Q}5����*���&;-.�)��-"����-.1'�b- �N�����b���AJ }5��� *��,&�1�G

JN�jJN-.?�}#*i��*�*�!#��!5-.��� }5}8�I����$.� ���� �A�Ur � �Kr ����6��!51�*�-=��1���-��>�,-K$.��&>� }#}z/4-.1�1'!5��!#}5!#��!5�,1�G%�O-.&<J+�j� &'�L~9!#1�1�!#����� ��+�r �A�Ar # ��+ r � r$���� 161��3- J��"�.&����.��*"!#���2���D���.?�&���� � /�- 1�1�!#��}5� �������6�,-.?�}#*���-.}#*"���+����!51</4-.!#�%��GF�O-.&N�AT3� ~@/�}5��G3!#1

��+�r �A�+�2+ h �K�~ ���EJ<������-b����$.�;�2�3��1��L!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1<!51+��-b!5��10��� �)��!(�����D�2���,~ ���+�2���E��!5~@�E- �V�2���;��B%?�� }5!8���M1'/�}5!8���

� �3- �2���,&E!51��2-�!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2�j�2���,~ *�?3&�!5�3��!5��!8�2!5� }5! ������!5-.� � �P�B��&�1'�E�ATF/�}(��!5�YJ��)�Y�����B��&'1'�;~@�,����-=*

8 J

Page 69: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

!516?3��1�-.?3��* G4� ��*"�2���,�i*3��1��,&�!#���;�2�3�j1'���,-.��*Y~@�,����-=* �

� =�C V E X���� %c@ � C S @�C9A S C9AF@ � AF@ 7�STU A S @�C � S C,C V =ZC9A � = E >�^^� ADC� �Y� }5� -.&�!8�2��~u��-.?�}#*i!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2�L���AJ !5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21������2���L�2!#~9�L- �^1�/�}#!#����!5���@� 1��O-.}#}5-KJ�1������,��� �4��2�3�j1'�,�>- �Z���,J�}#��� *3��&�1,G -B�4�L�����L-.}5*"}#��� *��,&�G � �3* �4�L�����L}5��� *���&'1�-.?3�21'!5*��L- �`�2�3�m-.}#*7�CB%?�� }#!#���1��A���]�6���D!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21 �2-B!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2�>� &��D� }5}������D!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1N-.� �0- � a��a��~9!#�=?31N�2�3�D!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21�2�����6J+�,&��j��-./3!5��*zG�~9!#�=?31<�2���L!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21<����������- }5*"-.� � }5-.�3� �]�6��!#1�/3&����,!51'��}#����-K$.�,&�1��2���L1��A�

��+�r �A�Ar # ��+ r � r$���61'��-KJ��Y�.&����.��*t!5�tS^!#�.?�&'� ��: 8 ��6���@/�&�-.�3}5��~ J�!#�2�[�2�3!51L!5~@/�}5�,~9�,�)������!5-.�i!51;�2���:�m1'-.~@�@-��N�����9!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2�,*o!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1;~M���

����$.�B���,���Y�l� }#1�!8����*t�)�i*������9���>����!51�/4-.!5�)����m+}#��� &'}#� G �O- &D� �i!5�)$�� &�!5� �)��}5!5e�� ��+�r �A�>� + - �D�2��!#1>!#1����1'�R��-t*3�,�2�,&�~@!5�����0+>-KJN�,$ ��&�G`�2���,&��@� &'�b1�-.~@�b!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21E�O-.&>J���!5���o�CB%?�� }#!#���Y!5~@/�}5!#��1D�3- �2��!#�����S�-.&+�UT3� ~9/3}5� GF��-.�31�!5*3��&<�2�3�E!5�)$�� &�!5� �)� ��+�r �A�+�2+ba � G ��7{;��-KJ�!5���B��������G�?��)�2!#}���-KJLG + G �>�.!8$.�,1��-t!5�3�O- &�~9���2!#-.�R-.�[J����,������& + a � G i����1m�4���,�k�2&'?�� �'�F��-.&0�j- �6� �A�2?���}5}#�Y1'��-.&�!#���t� }5}�1�� ~@/�}5�,1- � +t� ��*���vJ���!5���RJN-.?�}#*Q~M��e �b����- � : !#����&'��~@���)��� }^� }5� -.&�!8�2��~M�AG��2�3��&��b!#1D��-�J+���R�2-M*��,����&�~@!5�3�!#� ��+�r �A�B���,}5*h�O-.&I�[�.�����,&2� }<�O- &�~�?�}5�3���6�%?�1@!5��10��� �)��!(����!5���R!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1I���b�2�3�t��!5~@��- �>1�/�}#!#�b!#1?���1'-.?���*zG4�4����� ?�1'�jJN�L*�-9�3- ��e%��-KJ J���!5���t!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21<��-I!5��10��� �)�2!5���2���

� =�C V E X���� %c@ � C S @�C9A S C9AF@ � AF@ 7�STU A S @�C �,X`�KU AF@ � AF@ ADC9A S�� A�� S C9A3EG@� J+�K�Y�2-7e%��-KJ !8� ��+�r �A�D����}#*Q/�&��A$F!#-.?�1'}#�R!#1D�2-t� �A�2?���}5}#�t!#��1'�2� �)�2!(�:�2� ��+�r �A�D�:�E�2���b�4��� !5����!#������6��!#1�J+���.G������j!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�>!8�21'��}#�Z!51������,��e ��*o� �.� !5��10���2���m12� ~@/�}5�,1����A�O-.&��L�2���j�2!#~9�;- �^�2���j�CB%?�� }#!#���1�/3}5!#��� +>-KJN�,$ ��&�G�JN�;*�-��3- �+J+� �)�6�2-�!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2� ��+�r �A�d1�!#�������2��!#1+JN-.?�}5*M-.�)$F!5���2�>�2���E�4���3�,����1<- ��CB%?���}5!#���"- /3�2!#~9! ������!5-.� �/+>-KJN�,$ ��&�G4J+�Be=�3- J��������H+ G �E�4�,�O-.&'�j�����B1'/�}5!8��G�1'-MJ+�9� �N�[!5��10��� �)�2!5���2� ��+�r +=�E!5��10�2��� *k�O-.&L�4- �2� ��+�r �A�;� ��* ��+ r , �U� �k�9��� }5}�������1'�M���AJ ���F/4��1m- �6!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1�� ���b���D� � �!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21,� � �3��� � 1�/�}#!#�21Z-K>@�O&�-.~ +�G.�4- �2�B�����<&'��;��UT3!8$.��� �3*���-.��&'��;��UTF!#$.�6!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1�� &'�+�,-./�!5�,*-.�)�2- �KGV?�1�!#���7�2���I1�� ~9�b~@������� ��!51'~i�B�6��!51L� /3/�&�-)�����k��� �k�4�b1��,���k~9-.&'���.�,����&�� }5}8�R!5�R��JN-t���,J&�?3}5��1,G�-.���;�O-.&6!#��!#��!(� }#!����:�2!5- �9����*"-.���;�O-.&6*�?�&'!5���I�,-./)�F!#�����

%c@ ADC9A S�� A�� S C9A3EG@ � �����M!5��10��� �)�2!5���2!#���9�l��- � : ��B=?�� }5!8������!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1d*3?�&�!#���m!#��!#��!(� }#!������2!#-.� G }5�A�d������&'��4���I�CB%?�� }#!#���t1��A�21E!#��!#��!(� }#}#� � &��Y�����B1'?�~9~9� &0�"*���1'��&�!#/3�2!#-.� -�� �CB%?�� }#!#���"-./3��!5~@!������2!#-.� G3�O-.&��,$ ��&0�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�6-.��M$�� &�!5� ��}#��1�G=�2���L��}5�.-.&'!#����~ J+-.?3}5*"!5��10��� �)��!(��������� � !#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1��]�6��!#16!516�4����� ?�1��;JN�J+� �)�2��*"��}5}���- ~���!5�����2!#-.��1]- � �b$�� &�!5� ��}5�,1]-.���L��B=?�� }5!8���I}5����*���&'1���p�- J������E��}5�.-.&'!#����~ !#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2�,1� }#} � : J<���"��- ~���!5�����2!#-.��1 ����Do � �¤�¡��� ��� � �����]�6��!51�� }#}5-KJ�1<��� 1��,1>}#!5e � ��+ r +F�<����* # ��+�r +�r /=�A�

&����2���9�AT3� ~@/�}5�9� �4-K$.� G������M!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1j�������mJ+-.?3}5*��UT3!#1'�B���A�O-.&��@�2���9�CB%?�� }#!#���o1��A��1�/3}5!#�B� &'�1��3- J��i!5�tS^!#�.?�&�� ��: �=�����+=�Ur �������Ur ��+�r ���Ur ��+�r +=�Ar # ��+ r + r +F�Ur # ��+�r +�r ���Ur # ��+�r �Vr ���Ur # ���Vr �Vr ���

� E ^ 6 AF@ � XZ�KU Af@ � S �^Z� ADC � ����� � �c�CB%?�� }#!#��� 1��,��!51M1'/�}5!8��-K>ZG6!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21M� &��Y-.��}#�f�,-./�!5�,*�l�3-7!5��10��� �)�2!5���2!#-.� �UG���?F�;�2��!#1E��-./)�=!5�3�7!51E��-7}#-.���.�,&;��*�!#&����A�;1�?3��1'��!#�2?F�2!5- �Q- �d���,J }5��� *���&>�O-.&E-.}#*}5��� *��,&��1�k�I� �)� !#�Q?�1��b�����I��-.~��3!5������!5-.�31>J�!#���[&���/4�,��!#��!5-.�Y���������3! B%?�� �����,���M���������I�=?3~����,&;- ����AJ ��B=?�� }5!8���91'�,��1<�O&�-.~ -.���E��B%?�� }5!8���@1��,���dS - &+�������t!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�N��- �%�2� !5�3!5�����M!#��1'�2� ���,��1<- �V�����E-.}#*}5��� *��,&�GzJN�I��-./)�Y�����b!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�E�O-.&D��� ��� � : J<���R�,-.~���!#������!5-.�YJ�!8�2�Q&'��/4�,�2!8�2!#-.�R-.�Q�2�3���M}5��� *��,&�1��S^!#�.?�&�� ��: J 1'��-KJ�1m��-KJ ��� ���o- �d�2���b!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1E!5�Q�2�3�b�AT3� ~@/�}5��JN-.?�}#*o�4�b��- /�!5�,*[J��3���k�����b1��A�J�!#���.+�� 1�}5��� *���&61'/�}5!8�216-K>Z�

8 3

Page 70: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

S^!#�.?�&�� ��: �F� �F- }#$=!5���I�2�3�B��- /%�=!#����/�&'-.��}5�,~ �)�Ye�����/3!5����!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1�-.�Y�2�3�B12��~9�L$�� &�!5� ��}5��� ��!5���,1��- �������A�2!#���9!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1+�2-I$�� &�!5� ��}#��1<����$ �m�4���,�i&'��~@- $ ��*t�O-.&6��}5� &�!8���.�

~ &�!#�.!5����}�!#�%$�� &'!(� �)� &���10��� ���,��1>- �^}#��� *3��& m+-./�!5�,*i!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1����+F� � ��� �A�

������� 9 ��+�r ��� � � �Kr ���

��+�r +=� a ��+�r �A�AG � �Kr �A�

# ��+�r +�r +=� p # ��+�r +�r �A�AG # ��+�r �Kr �A�AG # � �Kr �Kr �A�

# ��+�r +�r ��� a # ��+�r �Kr ���AG # � �Kr �Kr ���

# ��+�r �Vr ��� � # � �Kr �Vr ���

# ���Vr �Vr$��� 9S^!#�.?�&�� ��: J � m+- /%�=!#���[- �D!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1b?�1�!#���[��-.~B��!5���:�2!5- ��1BJ�!#���g&���/4�,��!#��!5-.� G]J����,&��.+P!#1��2���"-.}#*}5��� *��,&�� ��* �D!51<�����L���,J�}#��� *3��&��

� 9

Page 71: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

S^!#�.?�&�� ��: 3 � ~ /3�2!#~9! ��!5�3�I�����B�,-./)�=!5���"� �3*R&���;��ATF!#$ ��/�&'-F�,��1�1,� �F-.~@�B!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1�J�!8�2�Y~@-.&'�m�2��� �-.���L!#��1'�2� �����L- �^��$�� &�!5� ��}5�D*�-I��- ������$.�L�2-I�4�j!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2�,* �

�6��!516~@�,����-=*7���%?�~@��&2�:�2��1����<}5����1'�<�����;!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21+�������<JN-.?�}#*"���;!#��1'�2� �)�2!(�:�2��*M!5�7~@�,�2�3-F*��.G� ��*t��� 1���*��CB%?������m!#�3�O-.&'~M����!5-.�@�O&�-.~ue �,��/�!#���M��&�-.?��3*i!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1+J�!#����!5�7�2�3�j1�� ~@�;�CB%?�� }#!#����1'�,����k�7?�1��7�,-.~���!#�����2!#-.��1LJ�!#���h&���/4�,��!#��!5-.��&����2�3��&B����� ���2�3-.1���J�!8�2��-.?F�b���,��� ?31��7- ������&0J�!51�� ��+ r +F�JN-.?�}5*[��-��L� /�/4��� &,���k�b?�1��b�,-.~���!#������!5-.��1>&2��������&E����� �[/4��&�~B?3������!5-.�31E���,��� ?31��bJ+�I��1�1�?3~9�b�2�3�*����2�b1'�2&'?��,��?�&��,1��O- &6!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21�� &'�;*���1'!5�.���,*i1'-@������� J�!5}5}4J+- &�e�&'���)� &'*�}5�,1�1�- �`�2���L-.&'*���&�- �`�2�3�$�� &�!5� ��}#��1L�O!q� � �8G ��&2� ��e%1���- ��� ��+�r �A�<� ��* � �Kr +=�+!#�Z�����,*���* G4� 16����� D;� !5e�-.�71'�=1'����~ *�-=��12�A�

&��V~9!#�.�)�V� /�/4����&V��� ��&'1'�V�2���:� �2��!#1�~9�A�2��-=*;!5�31'�����%��!(������1V� �;?3�������,��1'12� &0�m�%?�~B���,&�- �3!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1��+>-KJN�,$ ��&�G>J+�Q/4��&0�O-.&�~ �2�3�R�O-.}5}#- J�!#���o-./3�2!#~9! ������!5-.�z�Y!#�j�P$�� &'!(� �3}5�t-F�,��?�&'1 � �2!#~9�,19J�!#����!5� � �!5�)$�� &'!(� �)��G.�����>$�� &'!(� �3}5�� 1 �CB%?�� }#!#���b1'�,�+~�?�1'�N����$.�D���N}5����1'� �@~@��~��4��&'1�� ~ �2�3��&'J�!#1���G=�����>!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�!51D��-7}5-.�3�.��&>!5�)�2�,&���10�2!#���"� ��*Q!#1E*���10�2&'- � ��*c�l*�?3&�!5�3��&�?����A�j�6��!51E!#1E1��3- J��[!#�[S^!5�.?3&�� ��: 3 � &��Q�2�3��AT3� ~@/�}#� G !#� �9!#1��2���"-.��}8��~@��~��4��&b-��D!8�21���B=?�� }5!8����1��A��Gd�2���,�f�����"!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21 � �Kr �A�UG # � �Kr �Kr �A�UG# � �Kr �Kr , �AG # � �Kr �Kr /=����&��j*���10�2&�-K� ��* ���6�%?�1>�����B�%?�~��4��&�- �]!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1�!51���- ?���*��,*R�)�t�����B�%?�~B���,&- �Z!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21<J�!8�2��-.?F���CB%?�� }#!#����- /3�2!#~9! ������!5-.� �����3 ��� '����u|;� � y � . �+�3{S�-.&@1'���:�2!510�2!#��� }6�2�,1'��1�G�!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�9!#�3�O��&'�����,�R1'�=10�2��~@17}5!#e �(D;� !5e�-.� ��&2� ��eg�2�3�R�%?�~��4��&M-��L12� ~@/�}5�$�� }5?3��1+1'���,���O-.&+�L$�� &�!5� ��}5����S�-.&d��� ���9$ ��&�!(����}5��GF�:�+��� ���712� ~@/�}#�>*��:���m/4-.!#�%��G)�2���,&��E!#1N-.�3�D- � ����&��,�/�!#�����,16- �Z!5�3�O-.&'~M�:�2!5- � ���2�����6�����;*����2��!51 �K�+/�&��,1����)�>� ��*7J+� 1�� 1'1�!5� ����*7�2-b1'!5���,�;!#�<J+� 1�}(��1'�61'����� �

� �

Page 72: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

a �N/3&���1'���)����?3�6?3��~9-=*�!8����* �3p)�N~@!51'1�!5�3���)D;���2�B��� �7�4�;~@!51�1'!5���m�O-.&+&'��� 1'-.��1�*�!51'��?�1'1��,*i!#� �F���A�2!#-.�� �! �� p3�]�6���;��- ?��)��- �V�2���;�%?�~��4��&6-��Z~@-=*�!#���,*7� ��*"?��3~9-=*�!#����*�1�� ~9/3}5��1+!51<?�1'��*"�2-b}5���2�,&+��}5� 1�1'!#�v�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21���1A�'?�1'��!#���,*i-.&6�3- �B�O�2�3��&��L!#16��-9�3����*"�2-b��&2� ��e7~@!51'1�!5�3�b12� ~@/�}5�,1��U�

�i-=*�!#���,* � ?��3~9-=*�!#����* � ~@!51'1�!#���m*�������!#1<� }#1�-��,-.?��)�2�,*"�O- &+�������t� &�-.?�/M- �(�@$�� &�!5� ��}5�,1N�������6����1!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21>�.���3��&2�:�2��*z�BS�-.&D� � : ��?�/�}#� G !8� � �)�Y$�� &'!(� ��}#�m!#1E~@!51�1'!5���3G4�������Q�2�3�B�2?�/3}5��!#1D��- ��1�!#*���&'��*~@!51�1'!5���3� ~ �2���,&'J�!51'� G�!8�^���%�M$ ��&�!(����}5�E!#1<~@-F*�!8����*zG3�2���,�7�2���;�2?3/�}5�;!#16��-.��1'!5*��,&��,*i~@-F*3!#���,* ���6�%?�1�������i!#�%$�� &'!(� �)����� �"/��,&'�O-.&'~ �b~9-.&'�L� ���,?�&2�:�2�L1'�2���2!#1'�2!#��� }��2��10���

S�-.&N10������!510�2!5��� }��2�,1'�21N�2-B�,-.�)�2!#�=?3�>�2-m�F!#��}#*@�����E12��~9��&��,1�?�}8�21+?3��*���&+�CB%?�� }#!#���I-./3��!5~@!������2!#-.� G JN�~�?�10� /�&�-K$=!5*3�+�2���6&'!5�.�)�]1�� ~@/�}5�<*������D��-E$ ��&�!(����}5�,1�� ��*I!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1�G.�A$.���I�2�3-.?��.�b�2�3�<$ ��&�!(����}5�,1�� &'���- ~���!5�3��*Y!#�)�2-@�CB%?�� }#!#���"1��A�21E1'-M��-��E� }#}�!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21�� &'�B!5�31'�����%��!(������*"�2-9e ���,/R�2&�� ��e"- �]*����2�3���k�?�1'�>�2�3�>�O-.}#}5-KJ�!5���L�,-.��1��,&'$�����!#$.�>~9�,����� ��!#1�~t��!#� � �)�@- � �2�3�>$�� }5?3��1d!5�����M�CB%?���}5!#���I1'�,�+!51d~9-=*�!#����* G�2�3�����2�3�M�CB%?���}5!#���o1'�,�� 1�}#��� *��,&m!#1B�,-.��1�!#*���&'��*h~@-F*3!#���,* �tS ?3&'�2�3��&�GZJ������h!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1B� &'�M�,-./�!5�,*�l*3?��;�2-I�CB%?�� }#!#���71'�,��1�1'/�}5!8����!5���%�UG31�� ~9/3}5�E�,-.?��)�21>� &��j� }#1�-b�,-./�!5�,* �

�i!51'1�!#���b$ ��}5?��,1����K$ �j��-I���L��� �3*�}5�,*t1'/��,��!5� }5}8�.G���1��UTF/�}(� !#����*"!#�"�����L���AT=�>1��,�,�2!#-.� �

����3 ��w � �{3{&���, �;�^���H{F���u|;� �V{�F-.~@�,��!5~@��1,G4�UTF����?F�2!5- �R*����2�I�O-.&�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)��!5�3�O�,&��,�����m��-.�)����!5��1q�����Y�������"1�� ~@/�}5�,1��6�6��!#1D�����Y��� / :/4��� G �O-.&b�AT3� ~@/�}#� G �O-.&B$�� &�!5� ��}#��1��2�����@� &��7�3-.��1��,��1�!#��� }6!#�g1�-.~@�7��� 1'��1,G<1�?���� � 1�� R +oJ��������t!#1�%?�}5} ��&��M�����E��� !8$.�E!#~9/3}5��~@���)�2���2!#-.�I- �`!5�3�O�,&����3��� GF!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21N!5�.��- &���~9!#1�1�!#���B*������B1�� ~@/�}5�,1��]�6��!#1!51�1�- ?���*Y�O-.&��2���m��� !8$.�j!5~@/�}5�,~9�,�%�2���2!#-.�"���,��� ?31��b�@~9!#1�1�!#���@12� ~@/�}5�j~@��� ��1��2�3��&��B!51�!5��� *3�CB%?������!5�F�O-.&�~9���2!#-.���2-B��-.�)�2&�� *�!#�,�+� ��!5�)$�� &'!(� �)����+>-KJN�,$.�,&�G3J�!8�2����B%?�� }5!8���I-./3��!5~@!����:�2!5- � G.��!8�2���,&N!#�.��-.&'!5���~@!51�1'!5���b1�� ~@/�}5�,16-.&6��� ��*3}5!5�3�b~9!#1�1�!#���b12��~9/�}#��16}#!5e �;~@-=*�!#���,* � ?��3~9-=*�!#����*�$�� }5?3��16!516?3��1�-.?3��* �

S^!5� ?�&��,1 ��: � 9 � ��* ��: ���m�UT3/3}(� !#�t����!51,�=m+-.��1'!5*��,&D�I/�&'-.�.&2��~ /�- !5�)��J�!#�2�"��JN-9$�� &�!5� ��}#��1�G +7����*�KG�� ��*"��?3��� &'�9!5�)$�� &'!(� �)� �`��&���!#��!(� }#}#� G<+@� ��* ��� &'�E�CB%?�� } G#+I!51N�����;}5��� *��,&�G�����*�����+=�N�3-.}5*�1,��p>-KJ�i1�� ~@/�}5�@� &'&�!#$ ��1j�2�����m��� 1?+Q~9!#1�1'!5����GV��?F����- �%�2� !5�31B�"$ ��}5?��b�O-.& ���2�����m��- �%��&2� *3!5�,��1��^� �A�A� �k���������- �N�l� }51'!#�v� ����+F� ���,��� ?31�� �i~@!5�.�)�N��-.}#*9�O-.& +i�l� ��*�J����,� +@!#1+~@!51'1�!5�3��G)�2��!#1+!51N1'��!5}5}���&�?����A� �k���������- ��~9� !5�)����!5� ����+=�<� ��*t12�����2�3!51�!5~@/�}5!#��1 ��� �A�+�4������?�1��LJ+�j����$.�j1��,���Y�b�l��}51�!8�v�=!5����1�� ~@/�}5���

�6����1'-.?���*R1'-.}5?F�2!5- �Y!51��2-91�/�}#!#���2���m�CB%?�� }#!#���"1'�,� �0+�r � � � �3*R!5��10��� �)��!(�����B�I��J+- : J<���i�CB%?�� }#!#���!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�����A��J+�,��� +t� ��* �KG ��1D1��3- J��Q!#�RS^!#�.?�&'� ��: � a &��R�l� �,��G4J����,�R��J+- : J+�K�i�CB%?���}5!#���t!#�%$�� &'! :� �)�21���&��;?�1'��*"*�?�&'!5���b!#��!#��!(� }#!����:�2!5- � G������;!5��10��� �)��!(����!5-.�9!51<?��3�����,��1�1�� &'�4�d�2���;�,-./)�F!#���I~9�,����� ��!#1�~/�&'-F*�?3����1;�����I&�!5� �%�E&���1'?�}#��1��b�6���I�.�,����&�� }]&�?3}5� G �������zG`!#1D�2-"1'/�}5!8�;-K>g� }#}Z$�� &'!(� ��}#��1DJ�!8�2�[~@!51�1'!5���$�� }5?3��1D�O&'-.~ �2����- }5*R��B=?�� }5!8���i1'�,�;!#�)�2-7�����AJ��CB%?�� }#!#���i1��,�;� ��*R�2-M?�1�����������- /%�=!#���7~9�,����� ��!#1�~� 16?�1'?�� } G3J���!5}#�D!#����}#?�*�!5�3�B��J+- : J+�K�"��B%?�� }5!8���M!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1<!5�������;-.���,16!5��10��� �)��!(������*7*�?�&'!5���b!#��!#��!(� } :!������2!#-.� ��p>- �N!5���,}5?�*3!5���j��J+- : J<���9�CB%?�� }#!#���@!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21]JN-.?�}#*����>?���1'-.?���* G�� 1N�����E!5�)$�� &'!(� �)� + G �JN-.?�}5*t1'��!5}#}z��-.}#*"!5���2�3�j�UT3� ~9/3}5�;1�!#����� +9J+� 1�~9!#1�1'!5�����

����3 ��3 � � � � � ��� � �,���E{%�����+� �0�^� � � � � 4 ���<]� �0���+�3{~ ����*�&2��J���� ��eI- �z�CB%?�� }#!#���I-./F�2!5~@!������2!#-.��!#1 �������N�m/4��&0�O-.&�~9� ���,��-./3�2!#~9! ������!5-.�B*�-.����!5�@*����2��;�-KJ!51]�3-j}#-.���.�,&���- &�&��,�,�>�O!#�]!#1]!5���,-.~9/3}5�,���K�U� D;���2�H;�-KJ *�-=��1]�3- � !5��10��� �)��!(�����<!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21�!#�@�E/�&�-.� &2� ~/4-.!5�)��!8� �E��!#�.����&Z/�&�- �.&2� ~ /4-.!5�)�^1�?���1'?�~@��1��2�3�<!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21,�&+>-KJN�,$ ��&�G)�����<�AT3� ~@/�}#�+!5�m���.?�&'� ��: ��p1��3- J�1B��-KJ �2��!#1m!#1m�3- J !5���,-.~9/3}5�,��� ���6�3�M?�/�/4��&m/�&�- �.&2� ~�/�-.!#�)�B�,-.�)��� !#��1j$�� &'!(� �3}5� +������ �B����*�2�3�B}5-KJN��&>��-.�)����!5��1�$ ��&�!(����}5�,1H+��� ��� �E� �3*4�V�>�6�3�B��J+- +)1D� &��m��-.���3���,����*Q�)�.;�-KJLG�J���!#}5�j!5��!8�2!(��}5}#�

� a

Page 73: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

S^!#�.?�&�� ��: � 9 � &��D!#1�J�&'-.����G�� 1>1���-KJ��R���,&���G4��-�� 1'1�?�~@� � � ��� � �A����-.}#*�1��,$.�,�Y�2�3-.?��.� +�!#1�~9!#1�1�!#�����&�����-.?3}5*"���;�����L��� 1'�L������� �D!#16��- ���,$ ��� �

� GqG +�� �� ��J�!#��� +�� �� �E� 1D}#��� *��,&�� &��]�2���m1'������*�� &'*Q*������ ;�-KJ���-.� : !5��10��� �)�2!5���2!#-.�t!51�?�1��,* Gz�2�3���JN�E!5��!8�2!5� }5}8��-.��}8�@!5��10��� �)�2!5���2��!5�)$�� &'!(� �)� ����+���� � ���U� ����+ �� �� �2�N!51d��- �6!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2�,*M*�?��E��-�*����2� ;�-KJ-./3��!5~@!������2!#-.� G)J���!5}#� �������+!#16��- ��!5�31'�����%��!(������*"�4������?�1�� �R!#16��- �6�2�3�j}#��� *3��&��

�3���i�912��~9/�}#�j��&�1'�E� &�&'!#$ ��1��2�����D1���-KJ�1 �R!51���- �>�CB%?�� }`�2-'+��� ��� ��G �O-.}#}5-KJ+�,*i�)�Y�91�� ~9/3}5�;�2���:��l� }#1�!#����1 �o-.�R�2���8+%1D��?3�;��-��;-.� �V� � �Q�UT3� ~9/3}5�B-��]�2��!#1E��-.?3}5*R�4��!#�1�o~9��� ��1 �'�A$.�,���t� ��*R�2�3�12��~9/�}#��1�1��,���Q��&��9� a r a �AG`� a r %�<� �3*h� pFr %�A� �F!#����� +�� �� ������1>��-@!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21,G�J������t�2���j!5�3�CB%?�� }#!#���12��~9/�}#�m!#1>1'���,� G!�[!#1>1'/�}5!8�D-K>o��?F�E��-9!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21>� &��j��-./3!5��*z�>�6���,�RJ�������+���� � �>��� 1 �[�l� }#1�!#����* G�$;�-KJ�16�2- +�� �� ��G3J�����&'�m!8�6!51���}51�-��l��}51�!8����*z� +>-KJN�,$.�,&�G �R���A$.�,&>�.�A�21,�ZG�1'-I��-KJ �2�3�j- ?3�2/�?F�6�O&�-.~D;� !#e -.�[!51>J�&�-.���P�l! � ���#G�!#����- ~9/�}#�,���K�A�fp>- ���I�������L!8� ��!#1E�l� }51'!#���,*o�4�,�O- &����2�3�@!#���CB%?���}5!#���Y!51;1'�����zG�2�3���Q��- &�&��,�,������1'1;!51�/�&��,1���&0$.�,* G�1�!#����� �^��+�� �� �2��!#1���&�1'�E��&������2�,* G ����*Y�2�3���Q��- /�!5�,*Q� 1 �^������J��3���!5�3�CB%?�� }#!#������� /�/4����1,�

~ ���7J<���h�2-Q�3T��2��!#1b*������0;�-KJC/�&'-.��}#��~ !#1��2-[~M��e ���2�3�t�3-.� : !#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2!#-.��&�?3}5�7��-[}5- ���.��&� /�/3}#�.���6���:�E!51,Gz��}5}�}5��� *��,&�1E�:�E� }#}V/�&�-.� &2� ~ /4-.!5�)��1>��-KJ !#��1'�2� �)�2!(�:�2�j!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21�G �A$.���Q!8� � ��-��2���,&/�&'-.�.&2��~ /4-.!#�%�NJ+- ?�}5*7�A$.���)��?�� }5}8� ;�- J �����E!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�N*�-KJ�� � &����2���;����-K$.�;�,-.?��)�2�,&��UT���~9/�}#� G=�2��!#1� /�/3&�-)� ���M!51+1'-.?���*M���,��� ?�1'� ����+���� � ���N� �3* ����+��� ��� ���]�4- �2���UTF!51'��G31'-BJ������������D?3���CB%?�� }�12� ~@/�}#�>!#11��,��� G �������<��� �"�4�j�,-./�!#��* �

�6��!51d�3T@!5�3��&���� 1��,1N�����D1'/�� ���>?�1��,*M�O-.&d!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21,G)��?3�<*3-F�,1N��-��<� *3*M~�?����9�2-m�������2!5~@� G%1'!5���,�

� p

Page 74: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

S^!#�.?�&�� ��: ���.� &��6!#1NJ�&'-.����G3� 1<1��3- J��t���,&�� GF�2-b� 1'1�?�~@� � � ��� � �A�+*�-F�,1<��- �+��-.}#*MJ������.+I!51N~9!#1�1�!#�����&�����-.?3}5*"���;�����L��� 1'�L���������Q!516�A$.���z�

1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'!5-.�b-./F�2!5~@!������2!#-.�I���F���A�2!5- � � � � ��/�&��A$.���)��1��2���,~ �O&'-.~��4��!5�3�>�����,��e �,* � �P�+� }51'->�,}(� !#~ �2���:��2�3�6�=?3~����,&]- �4!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21��,}5!#~9!#�����2�,*B�)�������6�CB%?�� }#!#���m-./3��!5~@!����:�2!5- �m*�- ~9!#�����2�,1^�2�3�6�=?3~����,&��2���:�JN-.?�}5*@�4���,}5!#~9!#�����2�,*��)�b*����2��;�- JLG%�,1�/4����!5� }5}8��1'!5���,�>���%�I!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�^�2�����]JN����e ���31<��� �3��- �d?�1����2�3�*����2�8;�-KJ ~@������� �3!51�~t�

� �Q��}#�2�,&����:�2!#$ �;J<���t�2-9�FT"�2��!#1>/�&'-.��}#��~ !51��2-91���� &����R�O-.&�� }#}V!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�216�2���:�E� &'�m- �i�2�3�B-.}#*}5��� *��,&6!5�t� }5}4�2���L/���&����)��/�&'-.�.&2��~C/4-.!5�)�21,G�� ��*7��-@�,-./)���2�3�j!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��16-.�)�2-b�2�3�j�3�,J }#��� *3��&�1,G#&���2�3�E�AT3� ~@/�}5�D!5�M�����D���.?3&�� G(�tJN-.?�}#*7����$.� �i�,-./�!#��*��2-b!8�NJ��3��� �Y!#1+1'/�}5!8�+�O&�- ~ +��]�6��!#1<!51+1���-KJ��!5�tS^!#�.?�&'� ��: � � �

����3 � � * �d{=��|� ��y �V{F{ ���,�6���"��� 1'!5�"1'����/f!5�g/4-.1'�@/�&'-F�,��1�1'!5���[J+� 1I*���1'��&�!#���,* !#�h�2���"-K$.�,&'$=!5�AJ - �>�CB%?�� }#!#����- /3�2!#~9! ������!5-.�!5�[�2�3�910��� &0�B- � �F���A�2!#-.� � � 6 ��B%?�� }5!8���Q1��A�21B� &��@��-.�)$ ��&'����*�!#�)�2-"��J+- : J<���o�CB%?���}5!#���[!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1��+>-KJN�,$ ��&�G�!8��!51�- �v�2�,�Y�2���m��� 1'�B�2�����D1'-.~@�m$�� &�!5� ��}#��1�� &��m��- �D!5�)�2�,&���10�2!#���9�O-.&�/�&'!5�)�2!#����G4� ��*Y������1'�$�� &�!5� ��}#��1L~M���[�4�9�����M}#��� *��,&�1j- �6��B=?�� }5!8���[1��,��1�G]!#�oJ���!#��������1�����- ���M- �+�2���@!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21j-.�����%�- ���2����$�� &'!(� �3}5��1mJ�!5}5}N���"/�&'!5�)�2�,* �gS�-.&��UT���~9/�}#� G + GQG � GN� ��* +o!51��2�3�t}#��� *3��&�G ��?F� +o!51b��-��!5�)����&��,1'��!5����� &��i�2�����>����1�� G - /2/4��+=�+J�!5}#}���- �>���m/�&�!#�)�2��*��O����!51�!51���-.&'&��,�,�U����?3�>����!8�2���,&�J�!#}5}F-0/2/�� �A��O����!51L!#1jJ�&'-.���%�U���6�%?�1�G��4�,�O- &��I�2���9/�-.10�B/3&�-=����1'1�!#���Y�,-.�)$.��&'1�!#-.��1'�2� �.��G^1�- ~9�I�CB%?���}5!#���[1'�,��1�� &'���� � ���¤� � � &��]�2���m}5����*���&�- � � �i�CB%?�� }#!#���"1'�,�DJN-.?�}#*R��- �>�4�B/�&'!5�)�2�,* G4�����B}#��� *3��&�!51�1'J�!#��������*R��-M-.�3�

Page 75: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

S^!#�.?�&�� ��: � a �I�6����1'-.?���*�J+���P�2-Y��� ��*�}#��~@!51�1'!5���"$�� }5?3��1��@e �,��/f�i��JN- : J+������B=?�� }5!8���k!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��4�,��JN������+M� ��* �E� �3*i1'/�}5!8�6-K>R�����L�CB%?�� }#!#����1'�,��1��

�2����� J+-.?3}5*M�4�B�l!#�z� �)�@�ATF!510�212�A�]�6����!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21d���'��� �����,*M�2-L�2�3���O-.&'~9�,& }5����*���&d� &'�>10J�!#�2���3��*�-K$.�,&�2-b�����L���,J�}#��� *3��&��

*,+ * � : ;4 "$,(,5>|6�0 6 �25>�% >/� � 25>|6�0� � !5�)$�� &'!(� �)�7!#1����V�J��� �Y�Y�.� �R!#�j!#�"!#17!5~@/�}5!#��* �%� 1'-.~@�Q1��,�t- �m- ������&"!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21,� �F?�/3/�&��,1�1�!#-.�-./3��!5~@!������2!#-.�����'�2��~@/3��1t��- 1��K$ �P�2!#~9�Q�)� ��- �i�����,��e=!#��� 1'?�/�/�&'��1�1'��*�!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1�� &��i/��,&'�O-.&'~91*3�=��� ~@!5��G)/�- 1�!#��!#$ �6��}5!#~9!#������!5-.�m-.��}#� G)��?3�d!51]� �����,&2� } ���3-.?��.�I�2-;JN-.&�e��O-.& ��}5}�}#-.�.!5��� }3!#~9/3}5!5�����2!#-.��1,��F?�/3/�&��,1�1�!#-.�g� ��*P�CB%?�� }#!#���o-./3��!5~@!����:�2!5- �[� &��@�2����- ��}#�Q�O-.&'~91j- ��*3�=����~9!#�91'?�/�/�&'��1�1'!5-.�g?�1'��*h!#��2�3�?D;��!5e - ���2-=-.}q� �=?�/�/�&'��1�1'!5-.�i12��$.�,1���!5~@��1�� �3*t&'��*�?3����1���}#?3������&6�O&�- ~C/�&'!5�)�2!#����G3�3?3��!#�6*�-=��1���-��12��$ �t1'/�� �,� �"&��,��� }#}N�2�����b�O-.&�/4-.1�!8�2!8$.���,}5!5~@!5�����2!#-.� G`!#�b!#1���- �I/4-.1�1'!5��}#�M�2-[�,�%��!5&'��}#�k��}#!5~@!5���:�2�9� �!5~@/�}#!5��*i!5�)$�� &�!5� �)��� � !8�2�Q�CB%?���}5!#���i-./3��!5~@!������2!#-.� G�J+�be����,/o��&2� ��ei- �d!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21E!#~9/�}#!5�,!#�2}8�.G�1'!5���,��2�3�]��-./)�=!5����~@����������!51'~ !51V��*��CB%?������]�O-.& &�� : �,&����:�2!5�3�6!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21�� � !8�2�;1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'!5-.�j-./3��!5~@!����:�2!5- � G1�!#�����j!#�6JN-.&'e=1��O-.&�� }5}z!5~@/�}5!#������!5-.��1N!5�"�.�,����&�� }qG�!8�>!#1������,��1�1�� &'�"��-M� �A�2?���}5}#�Me �,��/Y�����m1'?�/�/�&'��1'1���*!5�)$�� &'!(� �)���

� ���V�J��� �Y�Y��� ���(�¥���3���,-.�����,�,�21@� �g!#�%$�� &'!(� �)�I����*g!#�21b1'?�/�/�&'��1'1�-.&'1����>1'!5���[1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'!5-.� }5!5�3e=1���)�2� !5}#1I��JN-�~9���'-.&I����� �3�.��1M��-o�����Y!#�3�O��&'�����,!5���k� }#�.-.&�!8�2��~ �OJN�YJ�!5}#}6� 1'1�?�~@�iJN�R� &'�i����� ���.!#���!#�b���v�2�,&��CB%?�� }#!#���P-./3�2!#~9! ������!5-.�o��� 1b�4���,�c��*�*���*��A��SZ!5&�10��G �������f!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��!51��.!8$.�,�����.�J��� �Y�Y��� ���� �����¤����� �Y���2�����N*��,1���&'!5�4�>J����:�<e%!5��*M- ��}5- �.!5��� }���- ��*�!#��!5-.�31N��� ��1�?3/�/�&��,1�16!8���)�=����- ��* GF�����D!#�)$ ��&�!(���%������,��e=!#���M~@������� ��!51'~ !516~@-=*�!#���,*��2-I12��$ �m�2!#~9�D�%��?�1�!#���91'?�/�/�&'��1'1�!5- �i}#!5��e%1��

� �

Page 76: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

S^!#�.?�&�� ��: �KpF�7�6���"/�&�-.�3}5��~ J�!#��� ��-��I!5��10��� �)�2!5���2!#���R!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1I� ��*g&��,}#�=!5���[-.�h�����"*�������;�-KJ��!#��&2��&����)�.���]&�- ��}5�,~ J�!8�2�R��- � : !#��1'�2� �)�2!(�:�2!5- �i- � !#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1���1�!#����� ��� �A��!#1D���A$.�,&;!5��10��� �)�2!5���2�,* Gz!8��R1'/�}5!8�21�-K>R�O&'-.~ +M!#�� ~ �!k�� �4�,�O- &�� �R*�&�-./31��O&'-.~ �H� �7k��jG�������� �RJ�!5}#}z���A$.�,&D����$.���[� 1�� �!5�)$�� &'!(� �)���

� 8

Page 77: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

S^!#�.?�&�� ��: �C �� ~ �3�+J<���m�2-E�,-.&�&'���,�^�2���</3&�-.��}#��~�- � ��-.� : !5�31'�����%��!(����!5-.�z��!5��10��� �)�2!5���2�d!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21`�2���:�JN-.?�}5*t��-.}#*7-.�t�CB%?�� }#!#����}#��� *3��&�1������A$.�,&'�"/�&'-.�.&2��~ /�- !5�)���

�"�

Page 78: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

S^!#�.?�&�� ��: � � � � ��-��2���,&<J<���7�2-b�,-.&�&'���A�������;/�&'-.��}5�,~C- �`��- � : !#��1'�2� �)�2!(�:�2!5- � �^�,-./)�7&��,}5�,$�� �)��!#�%$�� &'! :� �)�216�O&'-.~ ?�/�/4��&�/�&'-.�.&�� ~C/4-.!5�)��16?�/�- �i1'/�}5!8���2!#���B�����L�CB%?�� }#!#����1'�,���

� J

Page 79: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� �����i� �7!#�%$�� &'!(� �)�6!#1<��- /�!5�,*7- $ ��&6�2-I���3�,J ��B%?�� }5!8���M1'�,��G�J+�;*�-I��-��6��-./)�7-K$ ��&�1�?�/3/�&��,1�1�!#-.�}5!#��e%1���&��31'�2��� * G=J+�E&'� : ��������~@/3�+1'?�/�/�&'��1'1�!5- ��-.�M�����D�,-./�!5�,*�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)��G%��1+1��3- J��7!#���F�,�,��!5-.� � � � � a �

��� ����� ' .;|;|� �V{3{ � � � 4U�]yz� � ���V{�6���t��-.�3*�!#��!5-.��1b�O-.&I1'?�/�/�&'��1�1'!5-.� � &��"*��,/��,��*����)�M-.� �����t���=/4�i-��E!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�@� ��*f�2���t1'��&�?��A�2?�&'�- �E�����Y$�� &'!(� ��}#��1I1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'!5-.� JN-.&�e%17-.�z� S�-.&@�AT3� ~@/�}5��G E�i G r � � !#19!#~9/�}#!5�,*f�)� E � � 6�2�3!51�1�?�/�/3&���1'1�!#-.�Q*���/4���3*�1;��-��2�Y- �Y�2���j�l� �,���2�����D�����B1'?�/�/�&'��1�1'��*[!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�>!51>� � �'�,}5�,~9�,�%�D- � �!5�)$�� &'!(� �)��� �3*t��������-.���L- �`�2�3�L$�� &'!(� �3}5��1+!51��b}5-=������!5-.��!#�t� �t� &�&��K� �

�F?�/�/3&���1'1�!#-.�Y�l� �A�2-.&'!5��1�� &'�B�:������������*Y��-@�����B!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�6�����,�t~@!5�.�)��1'?�/�/�&'��1�1,G 1�!#�����j�������R1�?�/ :/�&'��1�1'!5-.�[}#!5��e7��� �[��-.���3���,�;��-7~�?�}8�2!5/3}5�L1�?�/3/�&��,1�1�- &�1j��?3�;-.�3}#�i-.����1'?�/�/�&'��1�1'�����1� �����o� 1'e �,*[��-���'�2��~@/3� 1'?�/�/�&'��1�1'!5-.�9-.�@� �@!5�)$�� &�!5� �)��G)�;1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'!5-.�@�l� �,��-.&'�B�.�����,&2������1N� ���V�J��� �Y�Y��� ���3�¤���x��� �N���A�� 1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'!5-.�Q�2�,~9/3}(��������-.�31�!510�21;- �N��}#!51'�D- �d!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21;����*R$�� &�!5� ��}5�,1E-.�R������1'�@!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1���&���2�3��&����ATF!#1'�21d�2���,1��>!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21 -.�9������$ ��&�!(����}5�,1�G.�2�3���M�����>1'?�/�/�&'��1'1�!5- �M�2�,~9/�}5���2��!#1��7����� � G=� �3*9�2�3�1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'!5-.�"�l� �,��-.&'�M!51�� }#}5-KJN��*��2-I1'?�/�/�&'��1�1��2�3�j1'?�/�/�&'��1'1������+�6���L1'?�/�/�&'��1�1'!5-.�"�2�,~9/3}(�����D�O-.&<�2�3�� �4-K$.�@�AT3� ~@/�}5��JN-.?�}#*k�4� i#n��mrVi EBr � rvs�rqG`��-.�31�!510�2!#���"- �+- ���I!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�L� ��*[$�� &�!5� ��}5�B�.&�-.?3/ �I�6�����- ��*�!#��!5-.�31<�O-.&61�?�/3/�&��,1�1�!#-.�R��&��;- ������&�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21,G�!5�3��}5?3*�!5���B�CB%?�� }#!#���71'�,�21,�

�6���<[email protected]'�`!#~9/4-.&'�2� �)�`��-.~@/�}5!#������!5-.�E��->��}#}5!#�����>1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'!5-.������~@/�}(����� !51V�2�����Z1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'!5-.�b��� ���� /3/��,�P� �,&�-.1'1;/�&�- �.&2� ~ /�- !5�)�21E$=!(�M������!#&E*����2�';�-KJ ��- �������A�2!#-.��1�� ���,��� }#}^�2���:�;�,$ ��&'�[!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��2��������- }5*�1j-.�h�Y/�� &��,�%�B/�&�- �.&2� ~ /4-.!5�)�m��-.}#*�1B-.�o�2���M����!5}#* �i�6�%?�1,G�J+��� }51'-iJ+� �)���2-i1������g� }5}�2�3�M� �3����10�2-.&j/�&'-.�.&2��~ /�-.!#�)�21L- �6���P!5�)$�� &'!(� �)��GV!#�k��*�*�!#��!5-.�Q��-i�2�3�9!#�%$�� &'!(� �)�& 1;/�&'-.�.&�� ~ /�- !5�)��GJ����,�R}5-=-.e%!5�����O- &�1'?�/�/�&'��1'1�-.&'1�G�J��3!5}5�L&'��~9� /�/�!#���b�2���L$�� &�!5� ��}5�,16$F!5���2���,!5& ;�-KJ ��-.�3�����A�2!5- ��1�� � �!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�6*�-=��1���-��>���K$ �j��-I����$.�m� }5}�!#�2161'?�/�/�&'��1'1�-.&'1D!5�7�����L12� ~@�;/�&�- �.&2� ~C/�-.!#�)����V� 1'��}#�.G%JN�E� }#1�-j?�1��>1�?�/�/3&���1'1�!#-.���2-m��!5*���!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21 !#~9/�}#!5�,*b�%�@*��:��� ;�- J��������d�2���>*����2��;�-KJ

~@������� �3!51�~C��� ���3- ����������� � � !#���t��B%?�� }5!8���.G3JN�L��� �t��-I}5- ���.��&+}5����$ �j!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1<?���!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2�,*t!8�/�� &'���)� /�&'-.�.&2��~ /4-.!5�)��1�����$.�6�2�3��~t�&+>-KJN�,$ ��&�G%JN�6��� �I?�1'�61�?�/�/3&���1'1�!#-.�@��-;12��$.�6��!5~@�+-.�I�����,��e=!#����2�3��1��N!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21,G:1'!5���,�dJ��3������B=?�� }5!8���;1��A�21^1'/�}5!8��G !5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21`� &'�N�,}5-.�3��*j��?3�Z��- �`�2���,!5&V1�?�/3/�&��,1�1�!#-.��l� �A�2-.&'!5��1,�

��� ����� �����,�L�����, { .;|;|� �V{3{&��� � � .� ���,�� ����� � � #O{ . �*+�,}5-KJ !51<�m*���1'��&�!#/3�2!#-.�7- �V��-KJ 1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'!5-.�"!51N!5�)�2�,�.&2�:�2��*7!#�)�2- D;� !#e -.� 1N!5�3�O�,&����3��!5�3��}5-=-./ ��k]$ ����2�3-.?��.�"1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'!5-.�"}5!#��e%1<~9�K�M��-.�3�����A��� ��&'-.1�16/�&'-.�.&�� ~C/4-.!5�)��1�G31'?�/�/�&'��1'1�!5- �i!8�21��,}#�V!#1<�AT3� ~@!5���,*!5�7�����L��-.�)�2�UT=�D- �Z-.���L/�&'-.�.&�� ~C/4-.!5�)���]S�-.&��b/�&�-.� &2� ~ /4-.!#�%���

�.� � ���,� !5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21���&��Y!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2�,* G���������~@/3�M��-h1�?�/�/3&���1'17�2���,~i� � ��!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�M!#1�1�?�/ :/�&'��1'1���*7J����,�t� �)�M1'?�/�/�&'��1�1'!5-.�"}#!5��eI���������D��&������2�,*7�O-.&+!8��G=��?3�+JN�;-.��}8�@e ���,/7�2&2����eM- �V-.�3�1'?�/�/�&'��1�1'!5-.�i}5!#��e �

a � DE?�&'!5���b!#�3�O��&'�����,!5���3G���������e"-.�3}#�M�����L!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21<��������� &'�j�3- ��1�?�/3/�&��,1�1��,*YJ�!#���t$�� }#?���1,�

p3� � ���,�t� �7!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�+!#1+�l� }#1�!#����* G=��-.}#}5�,�,�6��}5}4!#�21N1�?�/3/�&��,1�1��,��1,Gz� �3*7&���~@-K$.�E������!#&<1�?�/3/�&��,1�1�!#-.�}#!5��e%1�� &��z�������l��}51�!8����*I!#�%$�� &'!(� �)�]J+� 1d1�?�/�/3&���1'1�!#���b� �@!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�]J�!#���9����- �2�3��&d!5�)$�� &�!5� �)��G.�2�3�1'?�/�/�&'��1�1'!5-.�I}#!5��e;!#1^1'��!5}#}=&'��~@-K$.��*I1'!5���,�<!#�Z!51`�2���<�,-.�F�'?��3�,�2!#-.�B�������]!#~9/�}#!5�,1V�����<1'?�/�/�&'��1�1'!5-.�z��Z� e �9� }#}��2���b�O-.&'~9�,&�}#�Y1�?�/3/�&��,1�1��,*h!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21,GZ����*P�:���2�,~9/F�j��-i&'� : 1�?�/�/3&���1'1m������~ �O?�1�!#���

� 3

Page 80: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

S^!#�.?�&�� ��: � 8 �$�F?�/�/3&���1'1�!#-.� !5� � �A�2!5- �f�O-.&b�����i}#-.�.!#��� }<!#~9/3}5!5�����2!#-.��1?E � � M EfiIG r2� � ����*E � � M E�i �Dr� �

?��F�l� }51'!#���,*t!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1��U�]S�-.&�� �)�7?���1'?�/�/�&'��1'1���*Q!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1+�2������&��,~M� !#� G3���3����e7�2���,~CJ�!#���$�� }#?���1L!#�d�2�3�@!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�;J+� 1j!5�[�2���I1�� ~9�I/�&'-.�.&�� ~ /4-.!5�)�j� 1L�2���b�O-.&'~9�,&;1�?�/3/�&��,1�1�- &��*�k�*�-t��- �j�����,��ek!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1;!5�o*�! >���&'���)�j/�&�- �.&2� ~�/�-.!#�)�21L���,��� ?31��9�����,�[���K$ �9��-i�4�I!5�o����!5}#*/�&'-.�.&�� ~C/4-.!5�)��1�� ��*"J�!5}5}����L�����,��e �,*RJ������"$�� }5?��,1�� &�&'!#$.���

�� *+�A�O-.&��9!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21j� &'�9/�&'!5�)�2�,* �l! � ���#GZ*�?�&'!5���t/�- 1'��/3&�-=����1'1�!#���%�m�:���2�,~9/F�j��-Y1'?�/�/�&'��1�1b��� ���!#�%$�� &'!(� �)�����)� !5�z�

�6���m� ��-K$ �m��}5�.-.&'!#����~u�,��1�?3&���1��2�3�L�O- }5}5-KJ�!#����/�&'-./��,&'���4�

� V =%E U = � � I � I � I ��� e �B^B^BU = ��� AFEG@ @K= 7 = U� "S�� �l��� ��� 1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'��*�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�"��������A$.�,& ;�-KJ �2-@�@}#-KJ+�,&6/�&�-.� &2� ~ /4-.!#�%���

S^!5� ?�&�� ��: � 8 1'��-KJ�1�1'?�/�/�&'��1'1�!5- �Y!5�"���,�2!#-.� ���6�3�L$�� &'!(� �3}5��1<� &��E�����L� &�&����F1 +9� ��* �KG�!5�)�2�,�.��&'1"G� ��*��@� ��*7*3��&�!8$.�,*"$�� &'!(� �3}5��1 +�iIG r�� ��* +�i �Drq� &���!8�2!(��}5}#� G E � �MG31'-��2��!#1<!5~@/�}5!#��1 �2���:� E�i G r � � ����*E�i �Dr�� � ����$.�m��-M��- }5* � � 1'?�/�/�&'��1�1'!5-.�Y!51���1'�2� ��}#!51��3��*t��-.���3���,��1E � � ��-@�����m��JN-M1'?�/�/�&'��1'1���*

J:9

Page 81: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21,�8�=��-.?�}#*k���%�R12� ~@/�}5�,1;� &'&�!#$ ���2���:�;/�&��,1��,&'$.� E � �MG �2�3�I��JN-"1�?�/3/�&��,1�1��,*�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21J�!5}#}z��-��>�4�;�����,��e ��*z�

� ���B}5���2�,&N�2!#~9��G3�m12� ~@/�}5�>!51N1����,�7�2�����N�l� }51'!#���,1 E � � �l� ��*�E�i G r� �b�A�]�6���E��JN-b!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21�2�����bJ+�,&��t1�?�/3/�&��,1�1��,* ��-KJ �4���,-.~9�7&'���.?3}(� &b!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1����6���A�f� &��7���3����e �,* � �)� !#��1'�B�2���"*����2�12��~9/�}#� G�����* E�i G r � �H!51<�l� }#1�!#����* G=J���!5}#� E�i �Jr� � !#16/�&��,1���&0$.�,* �

��� ����w ' .;|;|� �V{3{&� �{h���E�^� � � ���]���E�� � ����� �� �� �$.��V{c{ � �� �3- �2���,&D!#1�1�?3�j�������D� &�!#1���1�J�!#���Y1'?�/�/�&'��1�1'!5-.�Q!#16�2�����>1�- ~9�j1�?�/3/�&��,1�1�- &�1;~9�K�"�4�j!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�216�2���:�1��A���2�3��!5&j/�� &�� ~@�,�2�,&�1m-.��}#�k���v����&B�t�O�,J 1�� ~9/3}5��1m����$.���4���,�h&���� * �RS�-.&j�AT3� ~@/�}#� G�!#�P!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21- �N�2���@�O-.&�~t� �;G + �3a ��G�+Q� ��* �b� &��@��- �m1��A��?��)��!5} ���m}5��� 1'� a 1�� ~@/�}5�,1m- �;���Vr � �E����$.�9���,���-.��1'��&0$.��*z� �P�Le%��-KJ ������� � G ��a @��� �t1�?�/3/�&��,1�1 � � �R��?3�>!#��!#16!5���,-.&�&'���A����-b�O-.}5}#- J ��!8�2���,&6- ��2�3�L�O- }5}5-KJ�!#���b� /�/3&�-)� ���3��1��

� m+-.�3�����A� ��G � a 9��- � �)�Y$F!5�91'?�/�/�&'��1�1'!5-.�Y}5!5�3e=1>�����2�3�B�4���.!#����!5�3���<�6��!#1>!#1>!#����-.&'&��,�,��G� 1jJ+�M��-.?�}#*P�,����-.?3�%����&{�'?�10��-.�3�9$�� }5?3�9�O-.&M���Vr � �AG<���.r&� �;�������B*�-F�,1B��-���1��A� +[� ��* �@��?F��,-.�)�2&2��*�!5�A�21 � � �V� �6��!#16J+-.?3}5*"���L?��31�-.?��3* �

� p�- �6��- �������A� ��G �Qa ��2- � � �t$=!5�B1�?�/3/�&��,1�1�!#-.�"}5!#��e%1��)&����2�3!51+��� 1���G��2���D��-.���3���,��!5-.��J�!#}5}���A$.�,&N�O-.&'~iG.�A$.�,�MJ������ + G �>� ��* � G ����F!5�3����!#� !51]������1�?�/�/3&���1'1�-.&d�2���:�N!#1 ����� ���.!#����G)�2�3�/4- �2�,�)�2!(��}�1�?�/�/3&���1'1��,�BJ�!5}#}���- ��e%��-KJ�J������t�2-M}#-F- e9�O-.&6�2�3�m���������.� G�� 1��2���L��JN-M!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21� &'�;��- ����- �������A�2�,* �

�6���E-.�3}#�bJ+�K�I��-B����$.�>�2���>1�?�/�/3&���1'1�!#-.�7}5!#��eB�O-.&'~H���N�����D&'!5�.�)� �2!#~9��!#1d��-B�����,��eM-=������1�!5- ��� }5}8�J����A�2���,&&� � � !51`1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'��* � ~ ���<1'?����bJ<���j�2-E*�->�2��!#1^!51`�2-E�UT3� �,��}#�m}5-=-.eE�O-.&ZJ��3���I� ��!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�- �������D�O-.&'~ �fG +:�Qa �����������.��1,G���?3�+�2��!#1NJN-.?�}5*M&��CB%?�!#&��;��*�*�!5�3�B1�/4���,!(� }4����1��;��� �3*�}5�,&�1N��-��,$ ��&0�1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'-.&��2���:�B���������.��1,�$&���10�2��� * G�!8�B!#1m��� 1�!#��&m��-Y&'?��h�i� �����,&2� }d1�?�/3/�&��,1�1�!#-.�h�����,��e�� ��1m*�- ���*�?�&'!5���"!#��!#��!(� }#!����:�2!5- � �</��,&�!5-=*�!#��� }#}#�.�?&��+�����91'?�/�/�&'��1'1�!5- �P�����,��ek!#1;*�-.���@?�1�!#���"�ATF/4-.�����)��!(� } ��� ��e-K> �O�,$.�,&'� � 9 G � 9:9 G�� 9:9:9 G+�,��� � 1�� ~@/�}5�,1��B�2���,� �����t��!5~@�7��-.10�M!#1I~9!#��!5~9� }qG ��1@[email protected]�9����� ���.!#���!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�216���K$ �j������!#&6/�� &�� ~9�A�2�,&�161��A����� &'}#�.�

��� ����3 ' .;|;|� �V{3{ � � ��y ��yV���V{�V� 1'��}#� G`������&'�M!51j�.B=?3��1'��!5-.�k- �<J����A�2���,&B1'?�/�/�&'��1�1'��*h!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1j��� ��1'?�/�/�&'��1�1B- �2���,&m!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1���6���Y� *3$�� �)��� � �t-��;� }#}5-KJ�!5���R����!51@!51I�.&'��������&I1�?3/�/�&��,1�1'!5-.� G<�����t*�� ���.�,&@�����t/�&��,1����3���R- �D�,�=��}#��1,�&��E������&'�R!51@�P�A�F�,}5��G<�2���,���k1'�,��-��;!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21@~M���g���A$.�,&����"�l� }#1�!#����* � �k�R� }#}5-KJ 1'?�/�/�&'��1'1���*!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21 �2-m���D1�?�/�/3&���1'1�-.&'1�G���?F�<�����,��eQ� �:�+*��,1�!#�.�M�2!#~9���]�������+� }5}������D1'?�/�/�&'��1�1'!5-.�7�l� �A�2-.&'!5�,1dJN�����$.�j��- �%�2� !5�"��-@}5- �.!5��� }��A�=��}5�,1��

*,+�� � 6�0;8;>?2�>?6@0'�1�t> 0*)+�f47>&� 032 8'"x2(" <b25>|6�0��������}5}3�������]�2�3��� &2� ~@~M��&^- �z� �)�b*3�=��� ~@!5�+!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�]*��,�����A�2!5- �910�F10�2�,~ ~�?�1'�d�4�6}5!#~9!8�2��*B���,��� ?�1'��2�3��&��i� &'�Y� �f!5�F����!#���"�=?3~����,&9-��E!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21��������9� &'�t��&�?��t- �;�[/�&'-.�.&2��~i� S�-.&I�AT3� ~@/�}5��GN�2�3�D;� !#e -.��10�=1'�2�,~ }5!#~9!8�21d!#��1���}8� �2-b!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1N�������6�,-.�)��� !#�"���[email protected]'��pB$�� &'!(� �3}5��1N� 1<�����;����-.~91+- �V!#��1

J �

Page 82: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

�.&�� ~9~9� &,�d�6�3!51�}5!5~@!#�2���2!#-.�@!51��@��&2� *��,-K>[�4�,��JN�����i�2���j�.���3��&2��}`?31��,�O?3}5���,1�1D-��^�2�3�m!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1>����*�2�3�j�UT=�2&2�b�2!#~9�b�l�4- �2�"��- ~9/�?F�2��&�� �3*i?�1'��&2�6!#�)$.-.}8$.��*t!5�"/�&'-F�,��1'1�!5�3�@������~t�

+>-KJN�,$.�,&�G=1��A���2!#���;�E����&�*b}5!#~9!8�V}5!#e �<p�$ ��&�!(����}5�,1^!51Z��- �^1�?��@��!#���)�]�O-.&�1'-.~@�<� /�/3}5!5�����2!#-.��1,�`�6�%?�1,G�2�3� D;� !5e�-.� 10�F10�2�,~ 1�?3/�/�- &'�21"�k}5!5~@!#����*f�AT=�2�,��1�!#-.��- �L!8�21M� &2� ~@~M��&9�)�c� }5}#- J�!#���[�O-.&M�4-F- }5�������- ~���!5�����2!#-.��1D-��<����-.~@!5�B!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�E?���!#��1��BS - &;� �)�R��JN-t�4-=-.}5��� �R$�� }5?��,1�G ������&'�@��� �[��� a�� G � 8*�! >z�,&����)����!#��� &0�9�O?��3�,�2!#-.��1,G���?3��!8�<!51+��- �6?�1'�,�O?�} ��-b����$.�j� }#}��2�3��1��E�O?3���,��!5-.��1,� D;� !5e�-.�"� }#}5-KJ�1+�2�3������,��e=!#���t- �]��J+-"1'/��,��!#�����O-.&�~@1�iID D �1k 9.a r �HE M � � ��* ��E M �M�L�6����1'�@� &���?31��,�O?3}]���,��� ?�1'�!5~@/�}#!5���:�2!5- ��1M��&��Q��- ~9~@-.��}8�c?�1'��* �2-g*���1'��&'!5�4�o/3&�-.�.&�� ~ �4�����K$=!#-.&�G>��1�/4���,!(� }#}#�c!5���ATF�,��/3��!5-.����}����1���1,�

&�� ����&�~@1I- �D����&'~9!#��-.}5- � �.G�JN�i1'��� }#}6��� }#}+�2���t}5�A�v�I��� ��* 1�!#*��7�2���"�Y�����N��� � ��� � ��* �����7J���-.}#�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�����Y�����N��� � �����N� ��� � �N� � �N�¡� �

+>-KJN�,$.�,&�G��A$.���QJ�!8�2�R/4- �2�,�)�2!(��}5}#��?�1��A�O?�}^!#~9/�}#!5�����2!#-.��1�G�� *�*�!#���H�'?�10�E-.���j���=/���-�� ��-=-.}5��� �Y�UT :/�� �31�!5- �Q��-.?�}#*R�ATF/�����*Q�2����� &2� ~@~M��&>�)�R1 B%?�� &�!#���M�����b�%?�~��4��&E- � !#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1��Qp�- �;� }#}Z-��d������1'�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21�JN-.?�}5*i���m?�1��A�O?�}q� D;� !#e -.�t�2�%?�1E*��,��!#*���1>-.�YJ���!#���R!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�>���2-.~@1��2-M���3-F-.1'�b� 1>}5�,�v���� �3*Q1�!5*3��1�� ~ �3��~9�,����� ��!#1�~ �O-.&>*����,!5*�!#���M�2�3!51D!#1>��-�}5�A�>������?�1'��&E1'/��,��!#�v� � ~ �2���,&D~@������� �3!51�~@1�G1�?3��� ��1B�AT3� ~@!5�3!5���i��-=-.}5��� �o/�&��,*�!5�����2�,1�!5�P�����M/3&�-.�.&�� ~ 1'�=�)���:Th� ��*�*������Y�,}5?�10�2�,&�!5�3�Q� ��� }8�=1�!51����$.�b�4���,�[��������~@/3�2�,*(i!D D �1k 9)a rq�E�6�3!51E1'���,��!5-.�Q1'��-KJ�1;��-KJ �2-����9�,!5�,�%��}#�i&�?��Q*F�F��� ~9!#�B!#�%$�� &'! :� �)�j*��,�����A�2!5- � GV*���1'/�!#���I�����@1����,~9!#���"�ATF/�}#-.1�!#-.�[!5�Q�2���I�%?�~��4��&L- �N!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21E�������j!5~@/�}#!5���:�2!5- ��1!5�)��&�-=*�?������

�6���M~9� !#�o!#1�1'?��9!#�[*��,�����,��!5���(E M � !51;�2���IJ+� 1'���M- �+��-.~@/�?3�2���2!#-.�[!#� Eu-.&� � &��@� }8J<���=1�2&'?�� � �>1'!5���;����-.� : !5���,&��,~9�,�%�2� }qG:~�?�}8�2!#/�}5� /�� 1'1]� /�/3&�-)� ���m�2-D����!51`/�&�- ��}5�,~�!#1Z��� 1'�4�^���v�2�,&^*3�=��� ~@!5�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)� *��A�2���A�2!#-.�9!#1]&�?��@�2���6��&'1'�d�2!#~9�+�O- &N�:�2-.~@!5�<!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1�G.JN�>- ��}#�B!5��10��� �)�2!5���2���,-.��*�!8�2!5- ��� }!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�FE M � !#�<Ec����* � � &�� ��- �Z!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21 ������~@1��,}#$ ��1�� &��8D;� !#e -.��� a G �2�3!51V!51V!5~@/�}#��~@���)�2�,*$=!(���Y�����N��� � �����N� ��� � �N� �N� �¡�����¡���AG�$=!5&0�2?�� }`/�&'-.�.&2��~ /4-.!#�%��1D�2�����E����$ �b���,���Q��&'��������*Q�2-M&���/3&���1'���)�� }#}������Y/4-.1'1�!5�3}5�Y!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��19- �c�2���i&�!#�.�)�M������*�1�!#*��Y- �D�2���R!#~9/3}5!5�����2!#-.�g� 1'1�?�~@!5��� E�!#1@��&�?����m+-.��*3!#�2!#-.��� }^/�&�-.� &2� ~ /4-.!#�%��1L� &��@/�� 1'1��,*P!5�[�2�3�@&'!5�.�)�j1�?3��1��A�B- �N�2���@*����2�"�O- &E�2���,!5&L��-.�3*�!#��!5-.��1�l! � ���#G3� }5}4�2���;1�� ~@/�}5�,1+J�����&'��E�!51+��&�?����<� ��*7�2���,�"��� ���"!5�)$�� &'!(� �)� � !#���2���;�,-.��*�!8�2!5- ��� }4/�&�-.� &2� ~/4-.!5�)��!516?31���*Y� 16�4�,�O-.&'� �

��������� � �Ey � ��� �+��� � � � � �Vyz� ��� � � 4"y � �,� ��� ��� �E� � ���<]� ����<�3{&��[� �R!#����&'��~@���)����}�� /�/3&�-)� ���R��-�*3�=��� ~@!5�j!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�E*3�,�2�,�,��!5-.� G���&'������!5�����,-.��*�!8�2!#-.��� }V!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21-.&E�,-.��*�!8�2!#-.��� }V/�&'-.�.&2��~ /4-.!#�%��1E��������- �;�4��*�- ���I���v�2�,&D*��:����12��~9/�}#��1>����$.�b�4�����[&'��� * � � ��� !#$ �!5�3��&��,~9�,�)��� };��/�/�&�-.� ��� JN-.?�}#* ���Q�2-g1'!5~@/�}#� !5��10��� �)��!(�����Q� }5}D��-.��*3!#�2!#-.��� }�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21,GD��?F�7�2��!#1JN-.?�}5*m&��,1�?�}8�^!#�m�2�3�+&��,1�-.?3&����N��-.�31�?�~@/3�2!#-.�B/3&���1'���)�2�,*@� ��-K$ � � � ��-./3��!5~@!��,!5����� /3/�&�-)�����B!51V�2-���� e��� *3$�� �)�2� �.�E- �������E-./F�2!5~@!������2!#-.��1��������6��&��;� }#&���� *3�@?�1��,*7!5�M����� D;� !#e -.�M1'�=1'����~t�]�6���;e �A��!5�31�!5� �%����,&��t!51I�2�����I�����i�3!5��&�� &����)�f��10��� �3}5!51'����*f�4�,��JN������/3&�-.�.&�� ~ /4-.!5�)��1M� }#1�-QJN-.&�e%19�O- &9�,-.��*�!8�2!5- ��� }/�&'-.�.&2��~C/4-.!5�)�21,�

� �D�����m10��� &0�E- �^!5�)$�� &�!5� �)��*��,�����,��!5-.�zG4J����,�Y�2�3�B/�&'-.�.&2��~ /�- !5�)�D�3!5��&�� &����)�t!51��,&����:�2��*zGz��- ��*�! :�2!#-.��� }]/3&�-.�.&�� ~ /4-.!5�)�21m� &'�9�,&����:�2��* �'?�1'�m}5!#e �@&���� ?�}(� &L/�&'-.�.&�� ~ /�- !5�)�21,�9kd��������-.�3*�!#��!5-.����}]/�&�- :�.&�� ~ /4-.!#�%�8��� " �?- � / �<!#1B�,-.�����,�,�2�,*f��-Y��JN-o� &�-.?�/31�- ��/�&�- �.&2� ~ /4-.!5�)��1B$=!(�i������� j &���}5���2!#-.� :1��3!5/ �$� �6�2���B&���� ?�}(� &�/�&'-.�.&2��~ /�-.!#�)�DJ�!#����-.?3���2�3����-.�3*�!#��!5-.�(��� " � � a �<�2�3����-.�3*�!#��!5-.����}�/�&�-.� &2� ~/4-.!5�)�21 ��� " �?- � / � �O-.&bJ���!#���c�2�3�i�,-.&�&'��1�/4-.��*3!5���k&���� ?�}(� &I/�&'-.�.&�� ~ /�- !5�)�219� &��t!5�g�2�3�Y&��,}(����!5-.���� " � � j ��� " � �

J)a

Page 83: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

�6��!51@��- �������A�2!#-.� !#1I/�&��,��!51'��}8�g!5� � ���,-.&�*��������"J�!#���f����� � j &'��}5���2!#-.� � ��� " �?- � / �u� j ��� " ��4������?�1��B� �)�t� �)�i*������I12� ~@/�}#��1�1��,���R?��3*���&D�@�,-.��*�!8�2!5- �t1'��-.?�}#*Y�4�m1'���,�R�)�7�2���m/�&�-.� &2� ~ /4-.!#�%��2�����L1�?��31�?�~@��1m� }5}Z12� ~@/�}#��1�� ��� " �/� j ��� " � M ��� " � - � / �/� j ��� " � - � / � !51E��&�?��I�4����� ?�1��I�2�3�?�/�/4��&>/�&�- �.&2� ~ /4-.!#�%�H��� " � ��}(��!5~@1���-M1'���b� }#}�12� ~@/�}#��1>���D�����B}#- JN��&�/�&'-.�.&2��~ /4-.!#�%� ��� " �����6��!#1���AJ�&�?�}#�L!51�� }51'-I�����,��1�1�� &'�i�4������?�1��m!#��!51���-��������L��� 1'�m������� ��� " �A� j ��� " � - � / � � �2���L�,-.��*�!8�2!5- �~9�K�M��- �6�4�E�2&'?��j���"��� " ��� �=!5���,�E�2���u� j -.&�*��,&�!#���b��� e���16�2���E��&2� �31�!#��!#$ �E��}#-.1�?�&'�;- �`�2���;&'?�}5�,1�G3JN�� &'�b1�?�&'���2����� ��� " � - � / �d� j ��� " � �m�6�3��1��I��JN-t�3�,J &�?�}#��1E�2- �.�,������&;�,1'������}5!#1��[��}(�:���2!#�����l&2�:�2���,&�2��� � �Q�2&'���K���O-.&I*����2� ;�- J�!#���o?�/ �O&'-.~ �k/�� &'��!5��?3}(� &�1�� ~@/�}5�"?���*3��&9�k��- ��*�!#��!5-.�zGd�3?3�9����!51I!#1� }#&�����*3��������*�}5�,*i�)�������L��!5�,&2� &'���)�.�

~ �����[�2���o��!#��&2��&����)� !51"��10��� �3}5!51'����*zGE!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21t� &'�o!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2�,* � �3* �����,��e �,*�?���*��,&i�2�3�12��~9�;&'?�}5�,1�� 1����A�O-.&���� DE?�&�!#���b��������e%!#����G -.�"��-.&'&��,1�/4-.��*�!#���b$ ��&�!(����}5�,1<���A��J+�,���i&���}5���2�,*"/�&�-.� &2� ~/4-.!5�)�21,G.�2����?�/3/��,&]!5�)$�� &�!5� �)��J�!5}#}31���� *�-KJc������}5-KJ+�,&]-.�������6�%?�1 !#����!#1]� }8J<���=1]�2&�?3� G)�2���6!#�)$ ��&�!(���%�E M �HJ�!#}5} �3- �����j��������e���* � E M � J�!5}#} ���j�����,��e ��*Q/3&����,!51'��}#�7J��3���Y!8�������,*�1>��-9�4� � J����,� �!516*3��1'��&�-K�.�,*Q���6�����L?�/�/4��&�/�&�- �.&2� ~u/�- !5�)���

�6����&'��!51�-.���m~9!#��-.&������ �3�.�B�2-@�2���m-./4��&2�:�2!5- �i- �^�2���m1'�=1'����~�*3?�&�!#���M�����,��e%!5������1�� ~9/3}5��1>� &'���-[}5- ���.��&�� }#J+���F1I!#��1��,&'�2�,*c�:�I�AT3� �,��}#�P-.���"/�&�- �.&2� ~ /�- !5�)���M�O- &���� ��� &��,�.?�}(��&�/�&�- �.&2� ~ /�- !5�)��G~9� �)�9�,-.��*�!8�2!#-.��1d��-.?�}#*���-.}#* � +�- JN�,$ ��&,G�/��,&'�O-.&'~9!#���m~B?�}#��!5/�}#��!#��1��,&'��!5-.��1N!51N��- �6�m/�&�-.�3}5��~H1'!5���,��2�3�b1'�=1'����~ !#1;� }5&'��� *F�R����/�� ��}#��- �d��� ��*3}5!5�3��~�?�}8�2!5/3}5�j12� ~@/�}5� ;�-KJ�1;�2-7-.���b/3&�-.�.&�� ~ /�-.!#�)��� � ��������Y!5�31���&0�2!#-.� G�~@��~@-.!������2!#-.����� �Y�4�L?�1��,*i�2-@~9� e �L1�?3&��L�2�����>�I12� ~@/�}#�;!51���- ��/�&'-F�,��1�1'��*Y� �)� !#������I/�&�- �.&2� ~u/�- !5�)���

~ ���;~9- &��D- /3�2!#~9! ������!5-.�@��� �7�4�E*�- ���E�2-������E1'�=10�2��~u�2-b� �@�,!5���)��}#�9��� ��*�}#�D�2�3�;��� 1'�EJ�����&'� E!51L��}#J+�K�=1;�2&'?�� � � ��!#}5� EH&��,~M��!5��1D��&�?���GZ!8�;!51;�3- �j�����,��1�1�� &'�[��-te����,/k�2�3�@�,-.��*�!8�2!#-.��� }Z/�&�-.� &2� ~/4-.!5�)�21L�O-.&?��� " �t�6�%?�1,G^�2�3�M��&'������!5-.�k- �<�����M��!#��&�� &����)�o��-.?3}5*P�4�M*3-.���M*F�F��� ~9!#��� }#}#� G`- ����� Eu!#1�l� }#1�!#����* ���6�3�m&'?�}5�,1�JN-.?�}#*"�����

� S�-.&���� " � - � / EBG��2���Q�,-.��*�!8�2!5- ��� }�/�&�-.� &2� ~ /�- !5�)��J����,&�� E ��-.}#*�1�G���-./)���3-f!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1�G1'!5���,�D�2���D!5�)$�� &�!5� �)�21+!#�M�2�3�D��J+-b/3&�-.�.&�� ~H/�- !5�)�21N~�?�1'�<���E!#*����)��!5����}z���N�2���D~9-.~@���)�+- �FE1 1�l� }#1�!8��������!5-.�P� ��* ��� " � - � /2E � j ��� " �o�6�3�7��-.��*3!#�2!#-.��~�?31'�b�4�7��������e���*f��&�10�b��-KJ+�A$.�,&�G�4����� ?�1��mJ+�jJ<� �)�E��-M�,-./)�t�����B!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1��������>�ATF!510� ��� � ��� �j�2���j�l� }51'!#�v�=!5�3�@*������@12� ~@/�}5�L!#11'�����z�

� S�-.&"��� " � - � /2E ` G3�����L��-.�3*�!#��!5-.�"/�&'-.�.&2��~C/4-.!5�)�6J����,&�� E�!51<�l� }#1�� G�!#��1'�2� �)�2!5���2�E�UT3� �,��}#�7�2�3�!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1B��- �B!5� ��� " � �F!#�����M?��)�2!5}N��-KJLG)E ��� 1b�3�,$.�,&b���,�����l� }#1���G]�,$.�,&'�%�2�3!5���[~�?�10�b�4���&�?��Y���'��� " � - � / E ` �)+�- JN�,$ ��&,G�JN�R*�-k��- ���3����* �2-P�,-./)� �����Y!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��19!#� ��� " 1'!5���,���� " � - � /2E�`z� j ��� " �

�6����1'�L&�?�}#��1+1'-.?���*3}#�M� ��*7!5�3��&��,~9�,�)��� }#}#�I/4��&'�O- &�~@1+��- ��*�!#��!5-.��� } !5�)$�� &�!5� �)�+*��A�2�,�,�2!#-.�MJ�!8�2���2�3�12��~9�N-./3�2!#~9! ������!5-.�31V� 1�!5� D;� !5e�-.�?� a � &�� Ec!51Z� }#J+���F1Z�2&�?3� G �������������<��- ��*�!#��!5-.��� })/�&�- �.&2� ~ /4-.!5�)��1� &'�;���,$ ��&���&'��������* � &��7�l� �,��GF�����;&�?�}#��1�� &'�L� *3$�� �)�����.��-.?316- $ ��&���~�?�}8�2!#/�}5��/�� 1'1�� /�/�&'-)� ��� � &2�:�2���,&�2��� �7!5��10��� �)��!(����!5���L�2���;�,-.��*�!8�2!#-.��� } /�&'-.�.&2��~ /4-.!#�%�N�O-.& E�����* ��E ��� &'}#�@-.� GFJ������7�2�3��&��>J�!5}5}4�4�~9� �)�Q- �2�3��&;!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21E������&'�@� &��b�2&'?�� G������I!5���,&���~@���)�2� }]-./3��!5~@!����:�2!5- ��1>�,&������2�b�2�3�9�,-.��*�!8�2!5- ��� }/�&'-.�.&2��~C/4-.!5�)��-.��}8�MJ����,�Y���,��*��,* �

J p

Page 84: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

*,+ � � :;0;<b25>|6�0 '� 4 ��% "x2(" 4 ,DE?�&'!5���o�2���i!5~@/�}5�,~9�,�%�2���2!#-.�g- �L*3�=��� ~@!5�t!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�9*��,�����,��!5-.� �O-.&9�����$& ~ � }(� �3�.?�� �.��G<!#�@J+� 1*�!#1���-K$ ��&��,*b�2�����Z~9� �)�m!#�)$ ��&�!(���%��1`JN��&'�6-.�)$=!5-.?�1Z���,��� ?31��+�����+$�� &�!5� ��}#��1V!5�)$.- }#$.�,*�J+�,&��</�� &2� ~@�,����&'1�2-;��&2� ��1'!#��!5-.��1,�Z�`-L&��,*�?�������}#?3������&��O-.&Z�2����?�1'��&�G)JN��*��,$ ��}5- /��,*M�;~@������� �3!51�~��2-L��}#!5~@!5���:�2�d����&0��� !#�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21d-.��/�� &2� ~@�,����& $�� &�!5� ��}5�,1�GF� ��*�/4-.&0�2��*9�2��!#1d����������! B%?��E�2-j�2���E1'��~9� �)�2!#��1+-�� 3.�K$��m� ��* m�O?����A�2!#-.�"/�� &2��~9�A�2��&'1��

� �2&�� ��1�!8�2!#-.��/�� &�� ~@�,�2�,&<!5� & ~ � !51+!5~@~�?3������}5���^�6��!#1<~9��� ��1<�������<�����E$�� }5?��,1<- �V�2�3�E$ ��&�!(����}5��4�,�O-.&'�[� ��* ���v����&��2�3�R�2&2����1�!8�2!5- � �l��� }5}#��*c�����Q/�&�� : � ��*�/4-.1'� : $�� }5?��,1��@J�!#}5}����Q��B%?�� }L� ��* ���%�!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�N-.���2���D/�-.10�<$�� &�!5� ��}#�>!#1<?���!#�%����&'��1'��!5���B���,��� ?�1'�L!#�dJ�!5}5}4�4�E/�&��,1��,�%��- ���2���E/3&��E$�� &�!5� ��}#� ��6���j12� ~@�;!51<��&�?��;�O-.&����%��*���&'!#$.�,*i$�� &'!(� ��}#�D- �Z�2���L/4-.1'�6$�� &'!(� �3}5� �

&�� 3.��$��L� ��*�mDG%�O?3���,��!5-.�I/�� &�� ~@�,�2�,&�1d� &'��~B?3��� �3}5� G)�3?3�d1�-.~@�6J<���=1N-�� ����� �3�.!5���;������~ &'����*��,&�2�3��~ ?���!#�%����&'��1'��!5���3� m+-.��1'!5*��,&E�@*������91'�2&'?��,��?�&�� �mJ�!#�2�i����}#* � R +�G�/�� 1�1'��*Q!#�%��-9�O?��3�,�2!#-.� �^�q�A� &���2�3�>$�� }5?3�b�l-�� �2���>/�- !5�)�2�,&�� �D!#1+���������.��*zGF�2�3��&��E� &�����J+-���� 1��,1���� � �E!51+1'�,�N�2-b�j���,J 1'��&�?��A�2?�&'��� a ��m!#161��,����-M� �"�UT3!#1'��!5���@*����2�I10�2&'?��,��?�&����[m<� 1'��� � �+��������- ���4�j1'���,�Y�)�7�2���L��� }5}#��&�GF?���}#��1�1 �m!#1�� }51'-!5�i�2����&'�,��?�&��[- �1�ZGz!5�YJ���!#���Q��� 1'���2���B&��,��?�&��Q$�� }#?��mJ�!#}5}V����$.�b�2�3��&��,}5�,$�� �)�;!#�3�O-.&'~M����!5-.�z� m<� 1'�� a �N~M���M���;1'�����t�)���2�3�;��� }#}5��&,G3��?F�6�2���;!#�3�O-.&�~9����!5-.�9!516?�1'��}5�,1�1�?���}#��1'1<�2���L���AJ $�� }#?��;- � � - � " � � �!51L!#�k�"*����2�71'�2&'?��,��?�&��@$=!51�!#��}5�m�2-"�2���@��� }#}5�,&�� &��+����!51L!#1E�2���@��� 1'� GV�2���,�k�����I*������"1'��&�?��A�2?�&'�@J�!#}5}��- �%�2� !5�t� }#}z�2�3�j�3�����,1�1�� &'�t!5�F�O-.&�~9���2!#-.� � �F-b�O-.&6�4- �2�t��� 1'��1,G �#- � " ��� �+!#16��- ��!5�)�2�,&��,1'�2!#�����

&����2����$�� }5?���- � �D!#1N�3- �+����� ���.�,* G3��?F�+�2�3�>$�� }5?3�>- � � R +b!51d����� ��� ��* G=�2��!#1N��>z�,�,�<~9���@����$=!51�!#��}5��2-b�����L��� }#}5��&,��&��"�2��!#16��� 1'� G � - � " � � R +=�<!516!#�%����&'��1'��!5���3G��,$ ���i����-.?�� � � - � " ��� �+!516�3- ���

&��Q!5~@/�}5�,~9�,�)������!5-.� G�}5� ���.?�� �.�m�O&'-.�)�E�,��*�1L� &'�B&��,1�/4-.��1'!5��}#�B�O-.&D}5� �4��}5!#���I$ ��&�!(����}5�,1D� 1D/�� &2��~ :�,����&'1�� � �)�i/�� &2� ~@�,����&>� ��*R*3��&�!8$����2!#-.�i*3-.���B�)�$D;� !5e�-.�t- �d�9/���&2� ~@�,����&�!51��2&������2�,*R}5!#e ��� - � " � � �� �4-K$.��� ��*I!51]�3- � !5�)�2�,&��,1'�2!#����� � �)��$�� &�!5� ��}#�+!51'1�?��,*9�)���O&'-.�)� ����*31d������� !51^&���}5���2�,*b�2-j�E/�� &�� ~9�A�2�,&$�� &�!5� ��}#�m!#1D}(�����,}5��*Y� 1E�91����,-.��*���&'�g�O-.&>�O&'-.�)� : ����*Q*��,&�!8$.��*��>/�� &�� ~9�A�2�,&��&��Y�������UT���~9/�}#��� �4-K$.��G�2�3!51L!51E��&�?��I�O-.& � R + 6 �����b�O&�-.�)�j���3*P*�-=��1j��- �j}(�����,}�!#�j� 1j�"/�� &�� ~9�A�2�,&�GV��?3�?D;� !#e -.�[}(�����,}51;!#�� 1I�Q1��,��-.�3*�� &'��/�� &2��~9�A�2��&,�%�`-.1'�I10��������1I- ��1��,��-.��*�� &'�g/���&2� ~@�,����&�1�� &��7!#�%����&'��1'��!5���[!8�6�2���"/�� :&2��~9�A�2��&6$�� &'!(� ��}#�D�2�3�,�t� &'�j&'��}5���2�,*t��-9����$ �m��-��>����� ���.�,* � �F!#�����L/���&2� ~@�,����&�1�!#�(& ~ � ��&��L*����,/�}#�!5~@~�?3�2� ��}#� G%�2����& ~ � �O&'-.�)�>�,��*t}(� �4��}#16� }5}z1����,-.��*���&'�"/�� &�� ~@�,�2�,&�1�� 1�/�&'!5~9� &'�9/�� &�� ~@�,�2�,&�1,�

�F!5�3����*��,����&�~@!5�3!5���LJ����,������&N1��,��-.��*�� &'�@/�� &�� ~@�,�2�,&�1N� &���!5�)����&��,1'��!5���m*���/4����*31+-.�@�2�����CB%?�� }#!#����4�,��JN�����R�����j/�&�� : � �3*R/�- 1'� : $�� &'!(� ��}#��1�- �Z�2���m��-.&'&���1'/�- ��*�!5�3�M/�&'!5~9� &'�M/�� &2��~9�A�2��&'1�G41�?�/3/�&��,1�1�!#���!5�)$�� &'!(� �)�21L�2�������,-.�)��� !#��1��,��-.��*�� &'�P/�� &2��~9�A�2��&'1B!#1��Y*3�=����~9!#�91'?�/�/�&'��1�1'!5-.�z� &��h��-.�)�2&�� 1'��G]1�?�/ :/�&'��1�1'!5���"!#�%$�� &'!(� �)��1DJ�!#���o/3&�!5~9� &0�Y/���&2� ~@�,����&�1D��� �o���b*3-.���b1'�2���2!#��� }#}#� � +�- JN�,$ ��&,G`�����b�CB%?�� }#!#���1��A�"���A��J+�,��� �2���Q/�&'� : ����* /�-.10� : $�� &'!(� �3}5��19��� �3��- �"�4�R��}#!5~@!5��������* G61'!5���,�Q!#�9J�!5}5}��4�Q?�1��,* �O- &*��A�2��&'~9!#��!5�3�b!#�`1��,��-.��*�� &'�"/���&2� ~@�,����&�1�� &'�L!5�)�2�,&���10�2!#�����

*,+�� � :�2�:;4 "��)6�4��� ?3��-.~9���2!#��� }#}#�I�.�,����&����2�9�l- &6��������eF��1'?�/�/�&'��1'1�-.&'1

�l*�-@~@-.&��L� ~B��!#��!5-.?�1N�ATF/4��&�!#~9�,�)�21�?�1�!#��� �;p 1���� /�����!5}#!#�2!#��12�!5~@/�}5�,~9�,�)�6-.��}#!5���

J

Page 85: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

*,+�� � 6�0;<��|:�,5>|6�0

J)�

Page 86: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

J:8

Page 87: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� � ��� ����

� � � ����� ��� � ��� � ��� � � � � � � �������

� �"!$#&%'�)(+*-,/.102%43657.408#2!:9;*"08365<.19=.1>?,/#@,/�)(+,@AB.40C.D9E(+F".G,/3H,/�".=IKJML�NO!:9QP-RS(+,83<0T#83U,/�)(+,V!W,VAB3<P"R$FX . X .1,C,/.40;#8P-!$,/.1FZY[370;.]\O.4%4PO,/!:>-^�IKJML�*"0837^<0/(79;#4_`.4#C*a.1%4!:(7R:RWb�!:>Z08.1RS(+,8!:3<>�,83�F-bc>)(+9=!$%d!$>?57(+08!S(+>e,F".f,/.4%f,/!$3<>hg�ij.@F".1#8%108! X .k,/�"0C.4.@9=(mlC3<0 !:9;*"0C3m57.49;.4>?,/#1nohprqtsvuxw-y6prz|{~}vw)p[���c��w)s�y6��qjw-y6w � 36A�,/�-.=#C.49=(7>?,/!:%1#&3+Y *)(7!$08.4F�#8!$9QP"R:(+,/!$3<> A�(+#2%'�)(7>-^<.4Fj,839=(7�7.&!$,�!:F".1>e,8!:%4(7Rv,83E,/�-.2#8.19E(+>e,8!:%1#T!:>d,/�".Q*-083c37Y�,'(+%1,/!$%4#M,/�)(+,T(708.&^<.4>-.40/(�,/.4F X bU,/�".V,/0/(+>"#8R:(+,/3<0,/3c3<R$#4g� w"z��vurpxz|{��hs|w)zaymp����c��� � 36A�,/�".@IKJML�#C!:9QP"R:(+,/370��)(7>"F-R:.4#��eP)(7>?,8!$�).108#�!:>�,/�-.VR:(7>"^<P"(7^<.7g�&��z�z|�c�7ymprz|{�y6�dym�|�H�Hw"px����zjy6�h��u � 36A�,/�".MIKJML NO!:92P"RS(+,83<0�*)(7#C#8.1#¡F)(+,/(V,83V,8�".T¢k(7!$�73<>£,/3c3<R#8P-%'�U,/�"(+,�F)(+,/(;#K,/08P-%1,/P-08.4#M!:>HIKJ�L X .4%13<9;.kF)(+,'(G#K,/08P-%1,/P-08.4#�P">"F".108#K,'(7>"F"( X R:. X bd¢k(7!$�73<>hg

¤H¥6¦ §H¨4© ª¬«1­&®�¨4¯ ° ± ­Q¨³²�´kµ ­2ª�®�¶;© ­&®·­� �".�¸O¹"ºeº7» X R:3c%'�Z37Y@,/�".¬IKJ�L¼RS(7>-^<P)(7^<.U#Cbc>?,'(�\�#8*�.4%4!W�).4#��-3mA�,/�-. IKJML½NO!$9QP"R:(+,/3<0£.]\-.1%4P-,8.4#(U#C*a.1%4!W�)%³(+,8!:3<>j(7P-,83<9E(�,/3<>�^<!$57.4>�(+>j!:9;*"R$.49;.4>?,'(+,8!:3<>t(+P-,/3<9=(+,83<>h¾¿#V,80/(7>"#C!$,8!:3<>hg�IÀ>j(U*"0C.15c!:37P"#5<.108#C!:3<>d37Yv,/�".VIKJMLÁNO!$9QP"RS(�,/3<01_O#C!:9QP"R:(+,/!$3<>D37Y�*)(7!$08.1FU(+P-,/3<9=(+,/(2A�(7#M!:9;*"R$.49;.4>?,/.1F�#83£,/�)(+,�37>"R$b,/�-.E*�3<#C,KÂÀ#C,/(+,/.=37Y�,8�".D!:9;*"R$.49;.4>?,'(+,8!:3<>t(+P-,/3<9=(+,83<>�A¡(7#&5c!$#8! X R:.£,/3U,8�".=¸O¹"ºeº7» X R$3O%'��gUÃ�P-0C,/�-.404_A�!$,8�E.4(7%'��»�Ä�¹OÅQ#C,/(+,/.19=.1>?,�!:>;,/�".�.f\O.4%1P-,/!$3<>h_c,/�".�#8*�.4%4!W�)%³(�,/!:37>D(7P-,83<9=(+,/3<>£AB3<P"R:FE%'�)(7>"^<.�#C,/(+,/.+_#83k,8�)(+,`(7>?b�Äm»Q#K,'(+,8.49;.4>?,/#�,/�"(+,Æ.f\-(79;!:>".1FG,/�".�#C,/(+,/. 3+Ya,8�".�#8*�.4%4!W�)%³(�,/!:37>£(7P-,/379E(+,83<>£(+Y�,8.40CA¡(70CF"#AB3<P"R:F X .�F-3<!:>"^�#83T37>2,/�".¡#C,'(�,/. (+Y�,8.40v,/�".B»�Äm¹OÅ"g�� �"!$#�9E(+F".`,8�".�#C.49=(7>?,/!:%1#·37Y),8�".�IKJ�L�NO!$9QP"RS(�,/3<0F"!WÇÈ.108.4>?,�Y[083<9É,/�-.2.f\O.1%4P-,8!:3<> ^7!$5<.1> X bU,8�".2*-083c37Y�,/08(7>"#CRS(+,83<0M,83O37R:#4g�� �".2*"083c37Y�,80/(7>"#CRS(+,83<0 ,/3c3<R:#(7#C#8P"9;.�,/�)(�,`(7>?bQ.f\-(79;!:>"(+,/!$3<>Q37Y�,/�-. #C,'(�,/. 37Y�.4!W,/�".10Æ(7P-,83<9E(�,/3<>2AB3<P"R$F X .�,8�". *"08.]ÂÀ#K,'(+,8. 37Y X 37,8�(7P-,83<9=(+,'(-g�Ã�370 .f\-(79;*"R:.+_"!:>�,/�-.&Ê�(�\O3<#�%³(7#C.&#K,/P"FOb<_�3<>".k37Y�,/�".T¸O¹"ºeº7»D(7%1,8!:3<>"# A¡(7#4nË/Ì�ÍÏÎKÐ�Ñ+Ò-Í?зÓ�Ô�Õ"ÖcÖ-×�ØcÙOÚ-Õ-Û�Ü/Ý�Þtß"ÕcÛeÛ?à<á�âtã`ÞjÚOÕcÛ+ä-å�æèç-ÌÎ4ËZé¡Ü/Ýëê�ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�íÈîmÖ+ä�ïOï<åcåcðOåcð�æñÑfò�Ò7Ð×�Ø?Ù-à<óOåÒhÔfôOÒÈÎ1Ëöõ Ý`Þ'ß"ÕcÛeÛ?à<á¼ÜfÝ ê�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhîmÖ�äaïcï<åOåeð-åeðñ÷øì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íÈî]ãOÕcÛ�ùKÝ)úöûü Ù�×7Ûaæ~Ñfò�Ò7Ð×�Ø?Ù-à<óOåÒ�Ô/ô?ÒË4Î/Í)ÒýÎCÐvÑ7ÒOÍ?зÓ�Ô�ï�þ)àcà"Ö?å?Ú"ÕOÛ|Ü]ã�æ

ÿ��

Page 88: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ë6Î Ì7ç� �".tÄm»j#C,/(+,/.19=.1>?,/#QAB3<P"R:F�,8.4#C,G,8�".�*�3<#C,KÂÀ#C,/(+,/.E37Y����eº�������d0/(+,8�".40Q,8�)(7>�,/�".�*-08.f #C,/(+,/.+_B(+#F".1#8!:0C.4F�!:>¬,/�".;*"0C3O37Y g£L�>"F�(+Y�,8.40k,/�-.;»�Äm¹OÅ�#C,/(+,/.19=.1>e,4_�-º��� H!$,/#C.4RWYBAB3<P"R$F X .£%'�)(7>"^<.1Fh_·#C3�(+>eb#8P X #8.1�cP-.4>?,�Äm»k#C,'(�,/.49;.4>?,8#�AB3<P"R:F&%'�".4%'�&(�F"!$Ça.40C.4>?,·#K,'(+,8.7gviö!$,/�@,/�-!:#v#8.49=(7>?,/!$%Æ9=!$#89=(+,/%'�h_m*)(+!:08.1F.f\O.1%4P-,8!:3<>"#�%4(7>">"3+,H>"37,�9=(+,/%'��#C!:9QP-RS(+,8!:3<>Z08.1RS(+,8!:3<> *"083c37Y[#4_M#83�37P"0E5<.108!W�)%³(+,8!:3<>�9;.1,8�"3cF"3<R:37^7b%³(+>">"37, X .tP"#8.1FhgøÃ�P-0C,/�-.404_�P"#8.108#H37YV,/�".tIKJ�L¼,/3c3<R:#D#C�"3<P"R$F X .�( X R$.�,/3è.]\-*�.4%f, (�%13<>"#8!$#C,8.4>?,�)(7>-F"R:!$>"^G37Y|¸-¹"ºeº+» X R:3c%'�e#4g

J ,/�".10&,/�"(7>j,/�-.D#8.19E(7>?,8!:%;9=!$#89=(+,/%'�h_·(7>"37,8�".40&R:!$9=!W,'(+,8!:3<> 3+Y�,/�"!$#&F-.4#8!$^<>�!$#&,/�-.ERS(+%'��3+Y !:>OÂY[3<0C9E(+,8!:3<>UY[3<0T,/�".Q¸O¹"ºeº7» X R:3c%'� %43cF".+gG� �".40C.=!$#k>"3�A�(³b¬,/�-.;%13OF-.G%³(7>t,/.1R:R·A��)(�,V,8�".£*"08.]ÂÀ#K,'(+,8.!:#1_È#C!:>"%1.Q,/�".108.Q%13<P"R:F X .Q9QP-R$,/!$*"R:.@*"0C.f #C,'(�,/.4#T,8�)(+, 9E(7*U,/3D,/�-.Q#/(79;.Q*�3<#C,KÂÀ#K,'(+,8.7g��¡�"3c3<#8!$>"^D,/�-.%4370808.1%1,��j.]\O.4%4PO,/!:37>�9;!:^<�?, F".1*a.1>"Fd3<>d,8�".@*"08.]ÂÀ#K,'(+,8.7g

� �eP"#4_�,8�".HIKJML NO!:9QP-RS(+,83<02A¡(7#E(+R$,/.108.1F #CP"%'� ,8�)(+,;!$,8#;*"(7!:0C.4FZ.f\O.4%1P-,/!$3<>~#C.49=(7>?,/!:%1#£9E(+,8%'�A��)(+,@,8�".£*"083c37Y`,/0/(+>"#8R:(+,/3<0T,83O37R:#TAB3<P"R:Ft3<PO,/*"P-,4g=L�R:R�0C.1Y[.108.4>-%4.4#V,/3U(7P-,83<9E(�,/3<>¬#K,'(+,8.£5+(70C!S( X R:.4#>"36A¼0C.1Y[.10H,83�,/�".t*"0C.f #C,'(�,/.t37YV,/�".t(7PO,/3<9=(+,/37>hg � �".tF"08(6A X (7%'��!:#D,8�)(+,�AB.�%4(7>">"3+,UF-!:08.1%1,8R$b3 X #C.40K5<.@,/�".@*�3<#C,KÂÀ#C,/(+,/.+g � 36A¡.f5<.104_�!$, %4(7> X .kF".1F"P"%4.1F�Y[08379 ,/�-.&(+%1,/!$3<>D,/�"(+,M�)(7# X .1.4>H�)08.1F�(+>"F!$,8#k*)(708(79=.f,/.108#4g;I Y¡,8�".40C.£!:#V(7>?b¬.f\O*"R$!:%1!$,@>"3<>-F".1,8.4089;!:>-!:#89 !:>¬,/�-.;*�3<#K,CÂÀ#K,'(+,8.7_v!$,@!$#k%³(7*-,8P"08.1Fj!$>,/�-.MR$3O%4(7RO5+(70C!S( X R:.4#1g·IÀF".4(7R:RWb<_7AB.�A¡3<P-R:FGA�(+>e,Æ,83 X .M( X R$.�,/[email protected][.40�,/3 X 37,/�G,/�-.M*-08.M(7>"F£*�3<#C,KÂÀ#C,/(+,/.1#!:>�,8�".@IKJMLÁNO!:92P"RS(+,83<04_ X P-,�,8�".@IKJML�RS(7>-^<P)(7^<. !$,/#C.4RWY·F"3c.4#�>"3+,�*a.1089;!$,�,8�"!:# F"P"(7R�08.fY[.408.1>"%4.+g

¤H¥�� � ­2¯¬µ¬«³¨³¯ ° ��ª ­Q¯D®�¨��t´k²�� ¨4¯ ®�� ´ §H¨³© ª¬«4­&®·¶;²I ,M!:# ^<.1>".408(7R:RWbDP">-F".4%1!:F)( X R:.kY[3<0 ,/�".@IKJ�L�Nc!:9QP"R:(+,/370¡,/3£F".f,/.40C9=!$>".@%4.10C,'(+!:>H*"08.1F"!:%4(+,/.1#4_�#8!$>"%4.@,/�-.IKJML�RS(7>"^7P)(7^<.&(7R:R$36A�#��eP)(7>?,8!$�).108#T3<>¬!$>-�)>"!W,/.VF)(+,/(=,Àbc*a.1#T,/3 X .2P"#C.4F��[,8�"3<P"^7��,/�".fb (+08.QP"#CP)(7R$R$bP"#C.4FG!:>2*"08.1%43<>"F-!$,/!$3<>"#v3<0 �"!�ºeº# <Å X R:3c%'�e#%$]g�Ã)3<0·.]\-(79=*-R:.7_�,/�".BIKJMLñ�v3c3<R:�e!$,�(7R$R:36A�#|,/�".�P-#8.�37Y�92P"RWÂ,/!$*"R:!$%³(+,8!:3<>V(7>-FG(7F"F"!W,/!$3<>2!$>Q�eP)(7>?,/!W�).4FG.]\-*-08.4#C#8!$3<>"#�365<.10�,/�".B!:>?,/.1^<.40C#4g�&�5<.1>GA�!$,/�-3<P-,��eP)(+>e,8!$�).108#1_!$Y�(=,/08(7>"#8!W,/!$3<>�%13<>?,'(7!$>"#T(ER$3O%4(7R�5+(708!:( X R:.+_�,8�".QR$3O%4(7R�57(+08!S( X R:.@!:#�!:9;*"R:!$%4!W,/R$b'�x.]\O!:#C,8.4>?,/!:(7R:RWb($��eP)(7>cÂ,/!W�).4FÈg�>".f5<.10C,/�-.4R:.1#8#1_hA¡.Q#K,/!$R:RhA¡(7>?,T,/3 X .2( X R:.V,/3=#8!:92P"RS(+,8.@9=3<#K,TIKJ�L�*"0C3<^<0/(+9=#1g�i�.&,8�".40C.1Y[3<0C.A�!:#C�d,83£F".157.4R:37*d,ÀAB3;A¡(³bc# 37Y��)(7>"F-R:!:>-^G�cP"(7>?,/!$�".408#1gBJk>-.V!$# #83<P->"F (7>-FH,8�".@37,/�-.40�P">"#C3<P">"Fhg

)+*-,.*0/ 1�24365,�87:9�7<;<3�=�>?2 5L >?bd.f\O*"0C.4#C#8!:37>�A�!$,8�"3<P-,�(=�eP)(+>e,8!$�).10@�[3<0 A�!$,8� (£�cP"(7>?,/!$�".40M3m57.40 (;�)>"!W,/.@F)(+,/(;,Àbc*�."$ !:#MF".1�)>-.4F(7#BA0C�A%DFE#GIHKJMLNAfgQ� �-.;#C3<P">"F�9=.f,/�"3cF¬08.1R:!$.4#k3<>¬,/�-.£Yx(+%1,k,/�"(+,V%4.40K,'(7!$>t�cP"(7>?,/!$�".4F�.f\O*"08.1#8#C!:3<>"#&(70C.F".1%4!:F"( X R:.&,/�"0C3<P"^<�¬!W,/.408(+,/!$3<>�37> ,/�".G*�3<#8#C! X R$.&5+(7R$P".4# ,8�)(+,T,8�".Q�eP)(7>?,8!$�).1Ft5+(70C!S( X R:.2%4(7> ,'(+�7.7gVI YO !$#�(£�">"!$,8.k#8.1,�(7>-FQP�!$# .f\O.4%1P-,'( X R:.+_�,8�".kY[3<R:R$36A�!:>"^2,ÀAB3;.f\O*"08.1#8#C!:3<>"#�(70C.V.]\O.4%4PO,'( X R$.7n

RTS �VU�W OYX PZ�[U�$0$\(S �VU�W O^] PZ�[U�$_$� �".�.f\O*"0C.4#C#8!:37>"#£(708.=.f\O.4%1P-,'( X R:. X .4%4(7P"#8.E!$,/.10/(+,8!:>"^d,/�"0C3<P"^<��,/�".D#C.1, O !$#2#8P�`=%1!:.1>e,G,83 F".]Â

,/.1089;!:>".d,/�".U,/08PO,/�ñ37Yk,8�". �eP)(7>?,8!$�).1F�.f\O*"08.1#8#C!:3<>hg�I YV(j*-083<^<08(79 %43<>?,/(7!:>"#E3<>"R$bZ#CP"%'�öR:!:9;!$,8.4F#Cbc>?,'(+%1,/!$%³(7R�Y[3<0C9=#1_h,/�".1>�,8�".£IKJML NO!:92P"RS(+,83<0T%4(7>�.]\O.4%4PO,/.=,8�".49dg£IÀ>�*-0/(7%f,/!:%1.7_|,/�".1#8.£Y[3<089;#@(70C.P"#C.4F£�eP"!$,8.�37Y�,/.1>h_ X .4%4(7P"#8.�,8�".�*"0C3<^<08(79=9;.40v37Y�,8.4>G9;.³(7>"#v,/3k#8(6b&,/�)(�,�.157.40KbG3 X lC.1%1,�!$>G(T#8.f,�3 X .1bc#(G^<!$57.4>d*"0837*a.10C,Àb<_)370�,8�)(+, ,8�".40C.V.]\O!:#C,8# (+>d3 X lC.4%f,�!$>d(£#C.1,M,/�)(�,�3 X .fbc# (G^<!W5<.4>d*"0C3<*a.10C,Àb7g

a�37,8.M,8�)(+,Æ,/�-.M,ÀAB32Y[3<0C9QP"RS(+.�( X 3657. (70C.M(7%1,8P)(7R:RWbG!:>-#C,'(+>"%4.1#B37Yh(V9;3<0C.M^7.4>".10/(7R�#8.f,¡3+YÈ,ÀAB3+Â A¡(³bX 3O3<R$.³(7>�.]\O*"08.1#8#8!$3<>"#M37Y·,8�".kY[3<089dn

ÿ<ÿ

Page 89: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

����$�����ºm¸ ����$���� A��".40C.£ºm¸H!$#M.1!$,8�".40� 3<0 ] _��!:#�U W O (7>"F��ø!$# .f\O.4%1P-,'( X R:.7gB� �".40C.2(+08. �Y[3<0C9=# 37Y·.³(7%'�U.f\O*"0C.4#8#C!:3<>UY[3<0�.³(7%'�U3<*a.10/(+,83<04_�(+>"Fd,8�eP"# ÿ ,/3+,'(7Rrg¡JT>"RWbD,/�-.V,ÀAB3E*"0C.4#C.4>?,/.1F¬( X 3m57.(70C.V.]\O.4%4PO,'( X R$.7g

� �".40C.£9E(³b X .G9;3<0C.2#8P-%'��#C3<P">"F"RWb�.]\O.4%4PO,'( X R$.G.f\O*"0C.4#8#C!:3<>-#@,8�)(+,@(+08.2AB3<0C,8�tF"!:#C%4365<.108!:>-^"g@I ,9=(6b X .£>".1%4.1#8#/(+0Cbt,/3d#Cbc>?,'(7%f,/!$%³(7R$R$b�,80/(7>-#CY[3<0C9 #8379=.£.f\O.1%4P-,/( X R:.£.]\-*-08.4#C#8!$3<>"#2#C3d,8�)(+,k,8�".1bt%4(7>X .V0C.4%13<^<>"!��4.4F X bD,/�-.VIKJ�LÁNO!:9QP-RS(+,83<0�(7#�.]\-.1%4P-,/( X R$.7g

)+*-,.*-, � 5���24365,� 7 9�7<;<3�=> 2 5� �".&P">"#837P">"F�9;.1,8�"3cF�!$,8.408(+,/.1#�,8�"0837P"^<��#C3<9;.VR:(708^7.@5+(7R$P".4#�37Y�,/�".&!:>-�">"!$,8.kF)(+,'(�,ÀbO*�.Q(+>"FU�-3<*a.1#,/�"(+,V#8.4.1!:>"^H,/�-.4#8.;!:#k.1>"3<P"^7��,/3HF".f,/.1089;!:>".G,/�-.£,808P-,8��5+(7R$P".£37Y`,/�".£�eP)(7>?,/!W�).401g=� �-.=9;.1,8�"3OFt!$##837P">"F�A��".1>t(=*�3<#8!W,/!W5<.V08.4#CP"R$, !:#�Y[3<P">"FUY[3<0 (+>�.f\O!$#C,/.1>?,/!S(+R��eP)(7>?,8!$�).10 3<0�(E>".1^?(+,/!W5<.&08.4#CP"R$,MY[3<0�(P">"!W5<.108#/(+RÈ�eP)(7>?,/!W�).401_ X PO,�P">"#C3<P">"F�!$>E^<.1>".408(7R g�Ã�370B!$>"#C,/(7>"%4.+_-!W,BAB3<P"R$F X .�F"! `;%1P"R$,`,/3&F".1,8.4089;!:>-.,/�-.@5+(7R$P".4# 3+Y�\a_"bH(7>"F��k,/3£%'�".1%'��Y[3<0�,/�".kY[3<R$R:36A�!:>-^Q.f\O*"0C.4#8#C!:3<>Èn

\���� ��� �������! �"$#&%(')#+*-,.#� �". F-!:#/(+F-5+(7>?,'(7^<.�37YÈP"#8!$>"^@,/�".MP">"#C3<P">"F=9=.f,/�"3cF=!$#�,/�)(+,`!W,B!$#�*a37#8#8! X R:. ,83&�)(³57.T(7>;.f\O.4%1P-,/!$3<>

!:>H,/�-.2IKJML�NO!$9QP"RS(�,/3<0�,8�)(+,MA¡3<P-R:F�>-37, X .&(;5+(7R:!$FH.f\O.4%1P-,/!$3<>¬(7%1%43<0CF"!:>"^£,/3;,/�".V%43cF".+g � 36A¡.f5<.401_AB.&#K,/!:R$RÈ*�.40C9=!W, P">"#C3<P">"FU.f\O.4%1P-,/!$3<>U!$>H3<08F".10�,/3=(7R:R$36A Y[370 *"083<^70/(79ø,/.4#K,/!$>"^"g

IÀ>�*"0/(+%1,/!$%4.MA�!$,/�EIKJML *-083<^<08(79;#4_eA¡.T�"(657. Y[3<P">-FD,/�)(+,B,/�".��eP)(7>?,/!W�).40C#�P"#8.1FH(708.�3<>�(2#C*a.1%4!W�)%F)(+,/(&#C.1,`,/�)(+,B!:#Æ�)>"!W,/.0/21 G43)1�5 G�3A D7685G-A0C G96!: H<;(H.=�G>1 DFE#L H.=�A0C�A%DFE#G>1�685)g·Ã)3<0B.]\-(79=*-R:.7_e!$>;,8�".TÊ�(�\O3<#%³(+#8.�#K,/P"FOb<_�AB.�#8*�.³(+�Z3+YT�eP)(7>?,/!W�).40C#E3<>~(7R:R X (7R:R$37,/#1g � 36AB.157.404_ AB.��e>"36A .f\-(7%f,/RWbè�"36A 9E(7>?bX (7R$R:37,8#£(708.d%4P-0808.1>?,/R$bZ!$> .]\-!$#C,8.4>"%1.7gö� �eP"#D!$,;!$#;#CP(`;%4!$.4>?,E,83j#8!$9=*-R$b�%'�-.4%'� X (7R:R$37,£�eP)(7>?,/!W�).40C#3<>¬,/�-.4#8. X (7R$R:37,8#4g&� �".£#83<P">-F�9;.1,8�"3OFtP"#C.4Fj( X 3657.;!$#k>"37,@#CP(`;%4!:.1>?,VY[370T,/�".;Ê·(m\-37#V%4(7#8.;#C,8P"F-b7_Y[3<0T,8�".40C.=!$#V>-3dF"(+,'(H#C,808P"%f,/P"0C.;,8�)(+,V�7.1.4*"#V,/0/(+%'�¬37Y�(+R:R·,8�".£.f\O!:#K,/!:>-^ X (+R:R:3+,/#4_È!:>"%1R:P"F"!$>"^DY[P-,8P"08.+_b<.f,C ,/3+ X .]ÂÀ%40C.³(+,8.4Fd3<>".1#4g

¤H¥7? @ø¶;¯¬¯ ´BA ®�¨³¯ ° ®�¶ ®�� ´ C ­Q¨�DG¶;¯ ¨³¯FEV­Q²Æ¨4­2¯�®¼µ ´ ®�´�A�®·¶=²� �"!$#Q#8.1%1,/!$3<>�F"!$#8%4P-#8#8.1#GA��)(+,£%'�)(7>-^<.4#QAB.40C.d9=(7F".;,/3 ,8�".DIKJML�Nc!:9QP"R:(+,/370V!$>�3<08F-.402,83¬�)(³5<.�!$,3<P-,8*"P-,2P"#8.fY[P"RBF"(+,'(�!$>�,8�".E!$>"*"P-,VY[3<0C9E(+,V37Y ,8�".=¢k(7!:�+3<>�,83O3<Rrg�� �".E�+.1b�*"083 X R:.19½�-.408.=!:#@,/�)(�,,/�-.QF)(+,/(D#C,/0CP"%1,8P"08.1#k!:> IKJ�L F"3�>"3+,T9=(+,/%'� ,8�".QF)(+,/(E#C,808P"%f,/P"0C.4#@!:>U,/�".G¢k(+!:�737>�,/3c3<R gTNO!:>-%4.2AB.P"#C.d,8�".�¢k(+!:�737>Z,83O3<R�,83j(+>)(7R$b)�1.dIKJ�L .]\O.4%4PO,/!:37>"#4_�AB.U>-.4.4F ,/3 X .f,8,/.10=%13<>">".1%1,;,/�".H,ÀAB3jF)(+,/(08.1*"08.1#8.1>e,/(+,/!$3<>"#1g

L ^7.4>".10/(7Re*"0C3 X R:.19ë!:>VR:!$>"�e!:>"^�#8*�.4%1!$�)%4(+,/!$3<>"#v(7>"F2(7P-,83<9E(�,/.4F@,/3c3<R$#v!$#�,/�)(+,�#8*�.4%1!$�)%4(+,/!$3<>"#�,/.1>"F,/3d�)(³5<.;^<0C.³(+,8.40@>"37,/(+,/!$3<>)(7R�%13<9;*"R:.]\-!W,Àb�,8�)(7>�!:9;*"R:.19=.1>e,/(+,/!$3<>"#T370V.]\O.4%4PO,/!:37>"#4g;iö�".40C.³(7#@,/3c3<R:#(70C. X .1#C,�(+, 0C.4*�3<0C,8!:>"^2#8!:9;*"R$. *"0C3<*a.10C,8!:.4#¡37Yv#8!:9;*"R$. F)(+,/(Q#C,808P"%f,/P"0C.4#4_�#C*a.1%4!$�"%³(+,8!:3<>"#¡9E(³bD.]\O*"08.1#8##837*"�"!:#K,/!$%³(+,8.4FQ*"0C3<*�.40C,8!:.1#·37Y�%13<9=*-R:!:%4(+,/.1F&F-3<9E(+!:>O #8*�.4%4!W�)%`F)(+,'(M#C,808P"%f,/P"0C.4#4g�i�.¡,8�".40C.1Y[3<0C.¡.f\c,8.4>"F¢k(7!$�73<>h¾¿#�^<0/(+9=9=(70¡Y[3<0�%'�".1%'�7.1F�!$>?57(+08!S(+>e,8# ,/3;!:>"%1R:P"F".@*"0C3<*�.40C,8!:.1#�(+>"F�F)(�,'(£#C,/0CP"%1,8P"08.1# 0C.4R:.f5+(7>?,,/3£IKJ�L#C*a.1%4!W�)%³(+,8!:3<>-#4g

� �".k¢k(7!$�73<>=!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,`F".1,8.4%1,83<0�3<*�.408(+,/.1#¡365<.10 X (7#C!:%�F)(+,'(�,ÀbO*�.4#1n�!:>?,/.1^<.40C#6�[#8%³(+RS(70C#�(7>"FE�)(7#8�cÂ%43cF".1#%$f_a#C,808!:>-^<#4_a(7>"F #C.4�eP".1>"%4.1#4g@� �"!:#��7.1.4*"#k!W,/#M!:9;*"R:.19=.1>e,/(+,/!$3<>�#8!$9=*-R:.7_)Yx(7#K,³_È(7>"F *�3<0C,/( X R$.@,839=(7>?bTF"!WÇÈ.108.4>?,v*"0C3<^<0/(+9=9;!:>"^¡RS(7>"^7P)(7^<.1#4g|IKJMLè#8*�.4%1!$�)%4(+,/!$3<>"#�P"#C.B9;3<0C.�#83<*"�-!:#C,8!:%4(+,/.1FVF"(+,'(+,Àbc*�.4#1_#8P-%'� (7#�#8.f,/#1_�,8P"*"R$.4#4_�(+>"FH9E(7*-# X .f,ÀA¡.1.4>¬(70 X !$,80/(70KbE,Àbc*�.4#4g

ÿHG

Page 90: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

IÀ>=37P"0�,/0/(+>"#8R:(+,/!$3<> X .1,ÀAB.4.4>=,/�". ,ÀAB3V,83O3<R$#4_<AB. (+R$,/.10·,/�-.MIKJ�L�NO!:9QP-RS(+,83<0·#C3V,8�)(+,`%43<9;*"R$!:%³(�,/.4FF)(+,/(D#C,808P"%f,/P"0C.4#&(708.G0C.4*"0C.4#8.1>?,/.4F�P"#8!$>"^H#8%4(7RS(70C#@(7>"Ft#8.1�eP".4>"%1.4#1g=Ã)3<0 .f\-(79;*"R:.+_�#8.1,8# X .1%43<9;.G#8.]Â�eP".4>-%4.4#1gBNO!:>"%1. ¢k(+!:�737>;3708F"!$>)(708!$R$bV,/.1#C,/#B#8.1�cP-.4>"%1.4#¡Y[3<0ÆF"P-*"R:!$%³(+,8.4#`(7>"F;3<08F-.40K 08.1RS(+,8.4F;*"083<*�.40K,/!$.4#4_A��"!$%'�t(708.Q!$080C.4R:.f5+(7>?, Y[3<0�#8.1,8#4_hAB.Q.f\c,8.4>"F�¢k(7!:�+3<>U,83�08.1%43<^<>-! �4.&A��".4>�(E#C.4�eP".4>-%4.£!:#T9=(70C�7.4Ft(+#08.1*"08.1#8.1>e,8!:>"^E(G#8.1,�(7>-F�¢k(7!$�73<>d(³5<37!:F"#�,8�".4#C.V,8.4#C,8#4g

� �".T>".]\c,¡,ÀAB3Q#8P X #8.4%f,/!$3<>"#�*"0C.4#C.4>?,�,/�-. 9;3<#C,B!:9;*a370C,'(+>e,ÆF"(+,'(@,/0/(+>"#8R:(+,/!$3<>"#ÆF"3<>". X b=,8�". IKJ�LNO!$9QP"RS(�,/3<01g�Ã�!:08#K,³_7AB. R:3c3<�&(+,��"36A IKJML�9=(7*"#1_<3<0·Y[P">-%1,/!$3<>"#�Y[0C3<9�(TF-3<9E(+!:>QF)(�,'( ,Àbc*a. ,83@(T0/(7>"^7.F)(+,/(E,Àbc*a.+_�(708.&,/0/(+>"#8R:(+,/.1F¬!:>?,/3�¢k(+!:�737> F)(+,/(E#C,808P"%f,/P"0C.4#4gQNO.4%13<>"Fh_hAB.GR:3c3<�H(+,T�"36A�%13<>"F"!W,/!:37>)(7R!:>?5+(70C!S(7>?, F".f,/.1%1,/!$3<>h_�(7#�F".1#8%108! X .4Fd!:>UNO.1%1,8!:3<> � g��-_)%³(+> X .@!:9;*"R:.19=.1>?,/.4FDY[370 IKJML�*"0837^<0/(79;#4g

)+*��+*0/ ����5���� =�>?2 5 2������� �� =� � =�� 3 ; =�3��7 ���(7* F)(+,/(�,Àbc*a.1#4_ #CP"%'�ö(7#;L 0808(³bZ(7>"F��U(7*�(70C.UP"#C.4Fñ!$> 9=(7>?bèIKJML *"0837^<0/(79;#4g L 9=(7*Z!:#;(Y[P">"%f,/!$3<>¬,/�)(+,V%13<>">".1%1,/#&(HF"3<9=(7!:>¬F)(�,'(D,Àbc*a.£,/3d(H0/(7>"^7.GF)(+,'(�,Àbc*a.+gDJ Y�,8.4>h_�,/�-.;F-3<9E(+!:>¬F)(+,/(,Àbc*a.@!$#M>-37, ,/37,/(7R:RWbE3708F".108.4FÈ_)#83£,/�".@9=(7*H%³(7>">-37, X .@*"0C.4#C.4>?,/.1F¬(7#M(G#8!:9;*"R$.k(70808(³bD,/3;¢k(7!$�73<>hg

� �".HIKJML�NO!$9QP"R:(+,/3<0V9=(7*�F)(+,/(�,ÀbO*�.4#;!:>�,ÀA¡3tA�(³bc#4g�÷!:0C#C,³_�!W,GR:!$>".³(+08! �1.4#2,8�".�0/(+>"^<.D37YM,/�-.9=(7*h_�(7>"Fj0C.4*�3<0C,8#&,8�".=5+(7R$P".4#@,/�)(�,Q(70C.=*-08.4#C.4>?,³gUÃ)3<0V(7>�(70C0/(³b��È_�,8�".�NO!$9QP"R:(+,/3<0�,/�eP"#Q0C.4*�3<0C,8#���������! "Å( #"�$E(7#¡(+>D(70C0/(³b£,/3Q¢k(+!:�737>hg�NO.1%43<>-Fh_O,8�".kNO!$9QP"R:(+,/3<0·#/(79;*"R:.1#B�+.1b7_-5+(7R:P".�*)(+!:08#`37Y|(V9E(+*% P"#8!$>"^&,ÀAB3GF"!:#K,/!$>"%1,`0/(+>"F"3<9 �7.fbc# >)(79;.4F H.5'& 5)(#A0C�(7>"F H.5 6 G�3A�=*&�5)(#A0C<g�� �".T3<P-,8*"P-,B,/3Q¢k(+!:�737>!:#G,ÀAB3jF".108!W5<.4FZ5+(708!:( X R:.1# �x#C.4.�NO.4%f,/!:37> � g,+<g,+�$ %.- H.5'&�5)(#A0C0/U(7>"F %.- H.5 6 G43A�=*& 5)(#A0C0/]g�ij.H.f\c,8.4>"F¢k(7!$�73<>;,/3G08.1*a370C,�!$>?57(+08!S(+>e,8#B!W,�F".f,/.1%1,/#¡!:>?5<3<RW5c!:>"^Q#CP"%'��#Cbc>?,/�-.1,/!$%T5+(708!:( X R:.1#¡(+# X .1!:>"^2P">"!$57.40C#/(7R$R$b�eP)(7>?,/!W�).4F;3<>G,/�-.�57(+08!S( X R:.1#4g�Ã)3<0�(7>?bG9E(+*Q,/�)(+,Æ�"(7#Æ(k0/(7>"^7.�A�!$,/�;(k>eP"R:R-.4R:.19=.1>?,��x! g¿.7gW_?(k*�3<!:>?,/.1F0/(+>"^<.GF)(+,/(E,Àbc*a. $f_�A¡.£!$>e,8083cF"P"%1.£(7>"37,8�".40k#KbO>?,8�".1,8!:%G5+(708!:( X R:.V,/3�0C.4*"0C.4#8.1>?,&,8�".G.4R$.49;.4>?,/#k37Y`,/�-.9=(7*�,/�)(+,M(+08.@>"37,�>eP"R$R g

ij.�P"#8.1F�9=.1%'�)(7>"!$#89;#E#8P-%'�ö(7#E,/�-.4#8.�!:>~37P"0E%4(7#8. #K,/P"FObñ!:>?573<R$5c!:>-^�,8�".¬Ê·(m\-37#�(7R:^73<08!W,/�"9d_A��"!$%'� P-#8.4#H(�9=(7*1�)º32-Å54 Y[08379 *)(+0C,/!$%4!$*)(+,/!$>"^�>"3OF-.4#D,/3�#C.1,8#�37Y X (7R:R$37,/#1g iö!$,8�"3<P-,E.4>"�"(7>"%4.]Â9;.4>?,³_�¢k(7!:�+3<>t08.1*a3<0K,/#kY[.1A !:>?,/.108.4#K,/!$>"^U*-083<*�.40K,/!:.1#@37YB,8�"!:#@F)(�,'(H#C,/0CP"%1,8P"08.+_�A��"!$%'��!$#@!:>"�".108.1>e,8R$b,ÀAB3+ÂÀF"!$9=.1>"#8!$3<>)(7R-(7>"F;!:>?5<37R$5<.1#Æ#8.1,8#Æ37YÈ>-3OF".1#`(7>"F X (7R:R$37,/#�08.1*"08.1#8.4>?,8.4F�(7#Æ#C.4�eP".4>-%4.4#1g`iö!W,/�£!:>OY[3<0KÂ9=(+,/!$3<>D( X 3<P-,¡,/�". ,Àbc*�.k37Y|,/�"!$#�F)(+,/(2#C,808P"%f,/P"0C.7_�(7>-FDA�!$,/��#Kbc>e,8�".1,8!:%T5+(70C!S( X R$.4#6��º32-Å54�"?� �87 �94-Å5:;$(7>"F���º32-Å54�"?� ��º32K!)Å<¹<7 �94-Å5:;$�_È¢k(+!:�737>E!:#B( X R$.M,83QF".f,/.4%f, (7>-FD08.1*a3<0K,�*"0C3<*�.40C,8!:.1#BP"#C.1Y[P"R�Y[3<0`*"083c37Y[#4_#8P-%'� (7#1n=øÕ?Ù8>�Ù-ðOå;?�ÞA@Oà?ðOå�Ü?Öc×3Bcå·Ü³ãOà?áOå?ð¡ù1Õ<ÙC>mÙ"ðOåD?-úFEÏÕ<ÝaÖ+á"Õ)×mÙ)åeð`ùfÕ<Ù8>�Ù-ð-åD?"ú)æ üHG æ)+*��+*-, I 2 5,� >I=> 245��� �����?>-=#=�>05�J >?5LK�MONL #29=.1>e,8!:3<>-.4F�!:>�NO.4%f,/!:37> � gP�O_�¢k(7!:�+3<>�!$#2%³(+*)( X R$.D37Y�F".f,/.4%f,/!$>"^¬%43<>-F"!$,8!:3<>)(+RB!$>e5+(70C!S(7>?,8#4_�3<0&!:>OÂ5+(708!:(7>?,/#kA�!$,8�j!$9=*"R$!:%4(+,/!$3<>"#4g � 3mAB.157.401_�%'�"3O37#8!:>-^UA��"!$%'�j%437>"F"!$,8!:3<>"(7R�!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,k,/3U#8.³(+08%'�jY[3<0@!$#F"! `=%1P"R$,B,/3GF"3QA�!W,/�"37P-,�365<.108RWbD.f\O*)(+>"F"!:>-^£¢k(7!:�+3<>h¾¿#�#8.4(708%'�H#8*"(7%4.+gB¢k(+!:�737>�R:.³(³57.4# !$,¡P"*D,/3G3+,/�".10,/3c3<R$#2,/3t%'�"3c3<#8.�,8�".H%43<>"F-!$,/!$3<>h_�3<0GR$.1Y�,G�"(7>"Fè#8!$F".7_`37Y�!:9;*"R:!$%³(+,8!:3<>"#1gt� �"!:#G#C.4%1,8!:3<>è#C�"36A�#=�"36A%437>"F"!$,8!:3<>-#�(708.k%'�"37#8.4>U!:>HIKJML&g

Lý#8!$9=*"R$.�#KbO>?,/(7%1,8!:%t(7>)(+R$bc#8!$#D#8P(`;%1.4#4g�� �-.jNc!:9QP"R:(+,/370=P"#C.4#H.³(+%'� %1RS(7P-#8. �x%13<>�lCP">-%1,�$E!$>ö(*"0C.4%437>"F"!$,8!:3<>�(7#2(U%437>"F"!$,8!:3<>�*"0C.4F"!$%³(+,8.7gDi�.E08.1*"RS(+%4.£,/0/(+>"#8!W,/!:37>�*)(+0/(79;.1,8.408#1_�A��"!$%'��(7*"*�.³(+0&!$>*"0C.4%437>"F"!$,8!:3<>-# X P-,�(708.@>"3+,�!$>H#8%437*a.&(+, ,/�-.&(+P-,/3<9=(+,83<>HR:.157.4Rr_ X bH#8*�.4%4!:(7Rh,/�-.@5+(70C!S( X R:. � �87 ��4OÅ5:�g� �".&�cP"(7>?,/!$�"%³(+,8!:3<>d,/.4%'�->"!:�eP".&F"!:#C%4P"#C#8.4Ft( X 365<.&.4>"#CP"08.&,/�)(+,M,/�-.&0C.4#8P-R$,/!$>"^;.f\O*"08.1#8#C!:3<>"#T(708.V#8.1>OÂ#8! X R:.+g�Ã)3<0¡.]\-(79=*-R:.7_c!:>=,/�".kÊv.1,8.408#C3<>H%³(7#C.k#C,8P"F-b �x÷!:^7P"08. �+ Q $f_e,/�". �"!"Å(�!R9S�� �5TVU ¸8WG*"0C.4%13<>"F"!W,/!:37>

G5X

Page 91: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

X .4%4379=.1#=,/�-. %43<>-F"!$,8!:3<>�¸��#" � �87 ��4OÅ5:;$�� 2c¹���Ä"�9T��"g � �"!$#E%437>"F"!$,8!:3<>Z!:#=P"#8.1F�!:>Z,/�".�Ê�.1,8.40C#83<>!:>?5+(70C!S(7>?,³n=��ÉÜ��)ï�ù�)ú ü ácó�a×mÙ-Ø �����)ï·ù'áeäcó?Ù�ú ü áOó��×�ÙOØ��"æ� �eP"#4_a¢k(7!:�+3<>H!:#�( X R:.k,/3£08.1*a370C,M!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,/#�,8�)(+,M!:>"F-!:%³(�,/.k*"0C3<*a.10C,8!:.4#�37Y�*)(70K,/!$%4P"R:(70�*�3<!:>?,/#�!$>,/�-.V%13OF-.VF-.4#8*-!$,/.@*�.40KY[3<089;!:>"^G!$>?57(+08!S(+>e,�F".1,8.4%1,8!:3<>d3<>�,/�-.V#Kbc#C,/.19�(7#�(£A��-3<R:.+g

G +

Page 92: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

G Q

Page 93: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� � ��� ����

�j� � � ���� ����� ��� ��� ��� � ��� ��� ��� � �� ����� ���� � ���� ��� � ������������� � ��� ����� � � ���� ����� ������ � � ��� ����

&�5<.10Cb�,8�".43708.49 *"0C365<.40 08.4�eP"!$08.1#k( ; =�6"! A�= % 6 (#AFL�!:>U!$,/#�RS(7>-^<P)(7^<.kY[3<0�,/�-.Q#Cbc#C,8.49�9=3cF".1Rv!W, !$#M,835<.108!WY�b<g�Ã)3<0�.]\"(+9=*"R$.7_$#@(708R:(7>"F£(7>"F;37,8�".40C#`F-.15<.1R:3<*�.4F;,/�".�9;3OF-.4R-Y[3<0�I&%7J (7P-,83<9E(�,'(T!:>G,8�".('v(+08%'�Ê�08365<.10*) NOL(#+#-, G/. X10 g�L�*-08365<.10�9=3cF".4RO#8*�.4%1!$�).1#Æ,8�". #8.19E(+>e,8!:%1#�37Y�,/�". #KbO#K,/.19 9=3cF".1R-!:>Q,8�". R:37^<!:%37Yv,/�".@*"0C365<.401g

� �".M3<08!$^<!:>)(+R-*"0C3m57.40`9=3cF".1R-Y[3<0ÆI&%<J�(+P-,/3<9=(+,/(@!$>£IÀ#/( X .4R$R:.�A¡(7#BF-.4#8!$^<>".1F X b��UP".1R:R$.40() �32P"R G<ÿ 0 gI ,/#Æ9=(7!:>£*"P-08*�3<#8. A¡(7#`,83&*-08365<.�,/�".�9;.1,/(k,8�".4370Cb;( X 3<P-,ÆIKJ (+P-,/3<9=(+,/(-_<#8P-%'��(7#�,/�".�#C3<P">"F">-.4#8#B37YY[3<0KA�(70CF@#8!:92P"RS(+,8!:3<>�08.1RS(+,8!:3<>T*-083c37Y[#4g|I ,v(7R$#83 *�.4089;!$,C,/.1Fk*"083c37Y[#h37YO*"0C3<*a.10C,8!:.4#�3+YO#C*a.1%4!W�)%Æ(7P-,83<9E(�,'(-g'�P"�"0C#T(7>"F4#@(708R:(7>"F�)5'�P"� X Q 0 P"#8.1F�,/�"!$#�9=3cF".4Rh,83EF".1#8!$^<> (7>-F�*)(70K,/!:(7R:RWbE!$9=*"R$.49;.4>?,M(G,/0/(+>"#8R:(+,/3<0Y[08379ýIKJML ,/3dIÀ#/( X .4R$R:.7g � 36A¡.f5<.104_·,8�".E9;3OF-.4RÆ(7>"F�,/08(7>"#8R:(+,/!$3<>¬A¡.108.+_·!:>�*"08(7%1,8!:%4.+_·!$>"%43<>?57.4>"!$.4>?,Y[3<0 F".1#8!$^<>"!:>-^=(+P-,/3<9=(+,/( X R:.�*"083c37Y[#�37Y�#8*�.4%1!$�)%V(7P-,83<9=(+,'(-g�ij.@F".1#8%40C! X .kA��eb X .4R$36A@g

Ã)3<0@3<P"0kA¡3708��_vAB.E%'�-3<#8.£,/3d%'�)(7>"^7.;,8�".=IÀ#8( X .4R:R$.G#Cbc#C,8.49 9;3OF".1R�,/3 X .£9;3<08.£#C!:9;!:RS(+0�,/3H,/�-.3<>".=%40C.³(+,8.4F X b�6¡37^<F)(7>"365tY[3<0&�"!:#VA¡3<0C��A�!W,/�j,8�".7'|(70C%'�èÊ�08365<.108)569#-' X Q 0 g�� �-!:#Q9=(7F".;,'(7%f,/!:%A�08!W,/!$>"^D.³(+#8!:.104g � .40C.7_hAB.£F".4#C%408! X .Q,8�".G9;3OF"!W�)%³(�,/!:37>"#T(7>-FtY[37089=(7R:RWb�#8*�.4%1!$Y�b ,8�".G*"083657.40k9;3OF".1R gi�.DP"#8.=,/�".=9=.19=3<0Kb�%³(7#C.D#C,8P"F-b�Y[083<9 NO.1%1,/!$3<> �"gPQd,83 #8�"36A ,/�-.DF"!$Ça.40C.4>"%1.4# X .1,ÀAB.4.1>Z,8�".=,ÀAB3*"0C3m57.40M9=3cF".1R:#4g

: ¥6¦ ; � ´ < ª ´k«³«1´k²ý© ¶Hµ ´k«IÀ>U,8�". �UP".4R$R:.10M*-08365<.10 9;3OF".1R _�(7>dIKJ (7P-,83<9=(+,/3<>H!$# (G,/0C!:*"R$.k%43<>"#C!:#K,/!:>-^=37Y�(7>�(+%1,/!$3<>d#8!:^7>)(+,/P-08.7_(2#C.1,�37Y|#K,'(70K, #C,/(+,/.1#4_)(7>-F�(Q#8.f, 37Y�,/08(7>"#C!$,/!$3<>"#1g�� �"!:#¡!:#B,8�".T#8(79=. (7#¡,8�".T!:>?,8P"!$,8!:3<>;Y[3<0B,8�".k(7%f,/P)(7R#Cbc#K,/.49ý9;3cF".4R�3+Y�(7>tI&%<Jø(7P-,83<9E(�,/3<>¬F".1#8%108! X .4F�!:>�NO.1%1,8!:3<> QOg �"g � 3mAB.157.401_�,/�-. �dP".4R$R:.40k9;3cF".4R(7R$#83H!:>"%1R:P"F-.4#V(7>"%1!:R:R:(70CbUF)(+,/(dF-.1�)>"!W,/!$3<>"#TY[3<0k,/�-.=*"0C365<.40@,/3dP">"F-.408#K,'(7>-F�,/�-.=9;3OF-.4R gG� �eP"#1_·,/�-.A��"3<R$.k*"083657.&9;3OF-.4Rh!$# 08.4*-08.4#C.4>?,/.1F X b�,/�".kY[3<R$R:36A�!:>-^"n= ¢k(+,/(2,Àbc*a.VF".4%1RS(708(+,/!$3<>�F".1#8%40C! X !$>"^G,/�".@#K,'(+,8.V#C*)(7%1.&37Yv,/�-.&(+P-,/3<9=(+,83<>hg= ¢k(+,/(2,Àbc*a.VF".4%1RS(708(+,/!$3<>�F".1#8%40C! X !$>"^G,/�".V(7%f,/!$3<>�,ÀbO*�.@37Yv,/�".V(7P-,83<9=(+,/3<>Èg

G/.

Page 94: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

= �¡R:(7#8#C!$�)%4(+,/!$3<>@37YO,8�".B(7%1,8!:3<>"#|(+#�!$>"*"P-,4_�37P-,/*"PO,·3<0�!$>?,/.40C>)(7Rrg�� �".1#8.`*"08.1F"!:%4(+,/.1#·(+08.Æ%43<9 X !:>".1F!$>e,83G,/�".V(7%f,/!:37>�#8!:^7>)(+,/P-08.7g= ¢T.f�)>"!$,8!:3<>�3+Y�,8�".@#8.1,M37Y�#C,/(70C,M#K,'(+,8.4#4g= ¢T.f�)>"!$,8!:3<>Z37YT,8�".U5+(7R$!:Fè,/08(7>"#8!W,/!$3<>"#;08.4R:(+,/!$>"^�(j*"0C.fÂÀ#K,'(+,8.7_�(7%f,/!$3<>ñ(7>-Fñ*a37#C,C #C,/(+,/.d37Yk,/�-.(7PO,/3<9=(+,/37>hg� �".V>".f\c,M#8.1%1,/!$3<>"#MF".4#C%40C! X .V.4(7%'�d%43<9;*a37>".4>?,M!:>H9;3<08.TF-.1,'(+!:R g

oay6w-y6���4}�w"�<�O�Nc,/(+,/.@#8*"(7%4.1# (70C.kF".4%1RS(70C.4FU(7#�08.1%43<0CF"#�3+Y�,8�".V(7P-,/379E(+,83<>�#C,/(+,/.k5+(70C!S( X R$.4#1nó-å-ï7à<ócð��-å����-Ö7á-Õeá-å ü��å��"ÚOÕ<ó ÞcÞ��eÚ-ÕcÛ+ä-å�Õ-ï+á ÞeÞ��Ü!@-à?ðcåÆâ���ï�á�×+à7Ù�@eä"ÛeÛaæ �eócóOÕ ��ó)Ö �½ÞeÞ��Ü!@-à?ðcåÆâ��"å"Ö �"à<ÙaÖ<å @eä"ÛeÛaæ �eócóOÕ ��� �".T%13<9=9=(7>"F;%40C.³(+,8.4#¡(7>DIÀ#/( X .1R:R:.�F)(�,'(V,Àbc*�.7_">-37,�(VF)(+,/(V5+(7R:P-.7g � (65c!$>"^Q(V08.4%13<08FE08.4*-08.4#C.4>?,,/�-.�F)(+,'(�,Àbc*�.�!:#2,8�".�%4370808.1%1,;(7*-*"083?(+%'�h_ X .4%4(7P"#C.d#K,'(+,8.D#8*"(7%4.1#=(+08.�%³(+0C,/.1#8!:(7>�*"083cF"P"%f,/#£37Y�,/�-.P">"F-.408RWbc!:>"^G5+(708!:( X R$.4#4g���7ymp[��z~�|w-y6wty��h}��L %f,/!$3<>"#�(70C.VF-.4%4R:(708.1F�(+# � '�,Àbc*a.V%437>"#C,808P"%f,/3<0C#4nðOÕ?á"Õ?á���"å���å����eÕ)ï+áa×7à<Ù ü×mÙcãOà��Oå Ù-à?ðcå Õ-ï�á�×+à7Ù �ó"å"Ö �"à<Ù"ð Ù-à?ðOåó-å-Ömä"Û7á��ä��OðcÕ<áOå Ù-à?ðcå� �"!:#d%40C.³(+,8.4#U(�9QP-,/P"(7R:RWbñ.f\O%1R:P"#C!$5<.�#8.f,�3+Y2%13<>"#C,808P"%f,/3<0C# X .4%4(7P"#C.�(7P-,83<9=(+,/3<>ö(+%1,/!$3<>"#d(70C.9QP-,8P)(7R$R$bd.f\O%4R$P"#8!W5<.+gG� �".£*)(70/(+9=.f,/.40C#T,/3�,/�-.Q,ÀbO*�.£%43<>-#C,/0CP"%1,83<0@%43<0C08.1#8*�3<>"Ft,/3�,/�".G*"(70/(79;.1,8.40C#37Y�,/�".V(7%f,/!:37>hg`i�.VP"#8.&(;F-!$Ça.408.1>?,�9;.³(+>"#�3+Y·%13<>"#C,808P"%f,/!$>"^=,8�".V(7%1,8!:3<>dF)(+,/(£,Àbc*�.VY[0C3<9�,/�-.&#K,'(+,8.F)(+,/(E,Àbc*a. X .4%4(7P"#8.G,8�".£(7P-,83<9E(�,/3<> #K,'(+,8.G!:#k(D%4(70C,8.4#C!S(7>¬*"0C3OF-P"%1,@37Y`.4(7%'�t#C,'(�,/.Q5+(708!:( X R$.7_aA��-!:R:.,/�-.&(+%1,/!$3<>"#�(70C.@9QP-,/P"(7R:RWbE.]\-%1R:P"#C!$57.7g�2uxw"�³�³p����<w-y6px��z ���Mw)�7ymp[��z��i�.V%1RS(7#C#8!WY�bE,/�-.&(+%1,/!$3<>"# !$>e,83G,/�"0C.4.@#8.f,/#4_�!$>"*"P-,4_"3<P-,8*"P-,�(7>"Fd!:>?,/.108>)(+R n�-å����"×�Ù��cä-á¼ÞeÞ����-å����cÕ"ï+áa×7à?Ù Ö7å<á��-å����"×�Ù��cä-á üOü�� ÕÆî��?Ó"ômÒ Õ Ì�ËÜ7×6ÙcãOà �OåëÙÁÕ�æ �"!OÕOÛOÖ7å#�Ü4ó-å)Ö �"à?Ù-ð Ù�óhæ ��!OÕcÛOÖ7å$�Ü1ä��OðcÕ?áOåëÙ�æ �"!OÕOÛOÖ7å

%&�

�-å����eà?äOá��OäOá¼ÞeÞ�'�"å����eÕ"ï7á�×<à<Ù Ö7å?á(��-å����eà?äOá��OäOá)�?ðOå+*ÆÞ

�,�"å����eà<ä-á��OäOá üOü-� ÕÆî��?Ó-ô�Ò Õ�ÌaËÜ7×6ÙcãOà �OåëÙÁÕ�æ �".eóeä-å/�Ü4ó-å)Ö �"à?Ù-ð Ù�óhæ ��.eó?ä-å/�Ü1ä��OðcÕ?áOåëÙ�æ �"!OÕOÛOÖ7åG �

Page 95: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

%&�

�-å����"×�ÙOá-åeóeÙ)ÕOÛ ÞeÞ��+�"å����eÕ"ï7á�×<à<Ù Ö7å?á(��-å����"×�ÙOá-åeóeÙ)ÕOÛ+�eðOå+*ÆÞ

�,�"å����"×mÙ-á-åeóeÙ"Õ-Û ücü�� Õ�î��?Ó-ô�Ò�Õ ÌaËÜ7×6ÙcãOà �OåëÙÁÕ�æ �"!OÕOÛOÖ7å#�Ü4ó-å)Ö �"à?Ù-ð Ù�óhæ ��!OÕcÛOÖ7å$�Ü1ä��OðcÕ?áOåëÙ�æ �".eóeä-å%&�6BbH%437>e57.4>?,/!$3<>h_)AB.VP-#8.@,/�".@%437R:R:.1%1,�3<*�.408(+,/370����1g�� $2,/3;F".1�">".V,8�".@#8.f,/#4g`� �".V%43<R$R:.1%1,�3<*�.408(+,/3<0

�)R$R:#T(D#C.1,@A�!$,8�t(7R:R|5+(7R:P-.4# ,8�)(+,@#/(�,/!:#KY�b�!W,/#T*-08.4F-!:%³(�,/.7g � 36AB.157.404_|,/�-.1b %13<P"R$F X .GF".f�)>".1F X b¬(+>eb37,8�".40�#8.f,M3<*a.10/(+,83<08# 370 X b�.]\O*"R:!$%4!$,8R$b=.4>eP"9;.408(+,/!$>"^G,/�".k5+(7R:P-.4#4g

� �".Q(+%1,/!$3<>�#C!:^<>"(+,/P"0C.@F"3O.1# >"3+, R$!:#C,�,8�".V,Àbc*�.237Y�(7%1,8!:3<>"# ��Y[3<0M,8�"!:#M!:#M(7R$08.4(7F-bHF"3<>-.2!:>U(7%f,/!:37>,/�-.VF"(+,'(Q,Àbc*a. $ X P-,�#8!$9=*"RWbD^<0C3<P"*"#�,8�".V( X 3m57.V,8�"08.1.@#8.1,8#4g`I ,M!:#�(7> �4'�,808!$*"R:.+n�-å����eÕ)ÖO×�Ø)�?ð-å'* Þ����-å����cÕ"ÖO×+Ø ü-ü Ü��-å����)×mÙ��OäOá�â �"å����eà<ä-á��OäOáÆâ �"å����"×mÙ-á-åeóeÙ"Õ-Û�æ+�� �|�¬�1y³w"�6yE�fy6w-y6�� �".V#C,/(70C,�#K,'(+,8.V!$#�(G#8P X #C.1, 37Y�,8�".@#C,/(+,/.1#4_�(7R$#83£F".1�">".4FUP"#8!$>"^G,/�".@%437R:R:.1%1,�3<*�.408(+,/3704n4OÅ<» � Å ���( !2(�?¹D2��54OÅ?»� � Å3���( !2(�<¹;2����� � Å3� �UK¹ 6¸ � Å3� � U��?º �� !2(� �92 �aÄ �9W;W��U_�(�!2 � Å3� � U��?º �� !2(� �92 �aÄ �9W;W��U��)Å3���(�<¹ � Å ��� ����W� �

� �mw)zv�³p�ympx��zv�L�,/08(7>"#8!W,/!$3<>G37YÈ(7>;(7P-,/379E(+,83<>G!:#`(7>��4'd,/08!$*"R:.¡37Yh(@*"0C.fÂÀ#K,'(+,8.7_c(7>;(7%f,/!:37>h_e(7>"F=(k*a3<#K,C #C,'(�,/.7g·� �".#8.f,M37Y�,80/(7>-#8!$,8!:3<>-# !:#�(7R$#83£F".1�">".4Fd5O!:(2,/�".@%13<R:R$.4%1,�37*a.10/(+,83<04ná� �-å-ÖÜ��1Õ·â��mÖOæeáOó-Õ<ÙaÖO×+á�×7à?Ù ü �)Ü��mÖ����1Õ����6Ö)æ+��-å����<áOó-Õ<ÙaÖ ÞcÞ���Ü �-å����cÕ"ï+áa×7à?ÙÆâ �-å����"Ö+á-Õeá-å�æ ácó"Õ<ÙaÖO×�áa×7à?Ù Ö7å<á��-å����<áOó-Õ<ÙaÖO×+á�×7à?Ù�Ö ü � � á?ó î� å<á Ö ü *"Ö�áá?óÕ-ï+á ü ÖmÙOð�á?óÖ�� ü ÛOÖ�áá?óÎÀÐ�?Ó-ô�Ò Õ-ï�á Ì�ËÜ7×mÙcãOà��Oå�ÙÁÕ�æ �Ü ��å��"ÚOÕ<ó Ö��7æ ü Ü ��å��"Ú-Õ<óøÖ)æ ÷Ü6Õ-ï+á Ö��7æ ü Ü�Õ"ÖeÖc×mØ?ÙýÜmÕ-ï�á Ö"æ Ù Ü�å��-Ý-å?ð�ÕÈæeæ ÷Ü4ó)Ö ��Ö��7æ ü ܳó)Ö ��ÖOæÜ4ó"å"Ö �"à<Ù"ðöÙ�óhæ �Ü ��å��"ÚOÕ<ó Ö��7æ ü Ü ��å��"Ú-Õ<óøÖ)æ ÷Ü6Õ-ï+á Ö��7æ ü Ü�Õ"ÖeÖc×mØ?ÙýÜmÕ-ï�á Ö"æ ÙÙ�×7Û�æ ÷

GD�

Page 96: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ü4ó)Ö ��Ö � æ ü Ü�Õ"ÖeÖc×mØ?Ùýܳó)Ö ��Ö"æ ÙÙ�×7Û�æÜ1ä��OðcÕ<áOå�Ù�æ �õ�Õ î~Ü<Ö�äeÝ Õ-ï+áëÙÈæ ü Ümå��-Ý"å?ðÁÕaæ ÷� å?áÕ ü���� ���ÁÕ`î~Ü7ÖmäeÝ Õ-ï�á Ùhæ ü Ü�å��-Ý-å?ð�Õaæ�ÎÀÐÜ ��å��"ÚOÕ<ó Ö��7æ ü Ü �"åeó�*Oàeó ��Õ Ü ��å��"Ú-Õ<óøÖ�æcæ ÷Ü6Õ-ï+á Ö��7æ ü ÜmÕ-ï+á Ö"æ ÷Ü4ó)Ö ��Ö��7æ ü Ü�Õ"ÖeÖc×mØ?Ùýܳó)Ö ��Ö"æ Ù Ü�å��-Ý-å?ð Ü6óOå-Ö�ä"Û7á�Õ Ü ��å��"ÚOÕ?óøÖ�æeæcæeæ

%&� � �".�,/!$%'�7.1F;5+(70C!S( X R$.4#.�x.7g¿^"gW_��% $�(708.�F"(+,'( ,Àbc*�.�57(+08!S( X R:.1#·!:> �4'�_<� �". #C,/(70�3<*�.408(+,/370 ��� $�9=(7�7.1#(=,8P"*"R:.+g i�.QP"#8.&,/�".1#8.G3<*�.408(+,/3<0C# �".108.Q,83�( X"X 0C.15c!S(�,/.&,8�".Q9;.³(7>-!:>"^=37Y`(E,/08(7>"#8!W,/!$3<>�(+#k(=,/0C!:*"R$.7g� �".T,80/(7>"#C!$,8!:3<>;F".1�">"!$,8!:3<>D*�.40C9=!W,/#B(7>?bD>eP"9 X .40¡37Y|*a37#C,C #C,/(+,/.1#¡,/3Q9=(+,8%'��(Q*)(70K,/!:%1P"RS(+0`*-08.f #C,/(+,/.+_(7%f,/!:37> *)(7!$0 ,8�"!:#�!:# (EY[3<089 37YÆ>"37>"F".1,8.40C9=!$>"!:#C9UgT� �-.Q.f\O!:#K,/.1>e,8!S(7R��eP)(7>?,/!W�).40k(+>"F��OÅ52U#Cbc>?,'(m\�)(7>-F"R:.Q,8�".£R:3c%³(7Rv57(+08!S( X R:.@�)_�Y[3<06�U!:#T>-37,@*)(70K,@37YB,8�".;(7%1,8!:3<>Ⱦ #TY[3<0C9E(+R�*)(+0/(79;.1,8.408# X PO,@!:#kP"#C.4F!:>d,/�".V,/08(7>"#8!W,/!$3<>dY[370 e¸94��52-Å �x#C.4.2,8�".Q(7PO,/3<9=(+,/37>U%13OF".&!:> NO.4%f,/!:37> �"gPQ $fg�� �".Q*-08.4%13<>"F"!W,/!$3<>dY[370 e¸94(� 2-ÅV!$#�A�0C!$,8,8.4>GP"#C!:>"^T(7>G.f\O!:#K,/.1>e,8!S(7RO�eP)(7>?,/!W�).401_?(7>"FQ,8�".4> �k!:#�08.1Y[.1080C.4FG,/3T!$>2,/�-.�.1Ça.4%f,Æ#8.4%f,/!$3<>P"#C!:>"^;( �-Å 2H(+>"F�(���� ��� 3<*�.40/(�,/3<01g�� �". �H3<*�.408(+,/370 %43<0C08.4#C*a37>"F"#�,/3;(70808(³b�#8P X #8%40C!:*-,8!:>"^-g���?��zvprz|{�y6�v� w"s|y6��qjwOy6��z'|(7#C,8R$b7_-,/�".V(7PO,/3<9=(+,/37>�!$,/#C.4RWY·!$# F".1�)>-.4Fhn�-å�� ÞeÞ ��Ü��-å����eÕ)ï+áa×7à<Ù`â �-å����-Ö7á-Õeá-å)æ×+àeÕ ��-å����?ð-å'*·Þ

�Oå�� ücü Ü �"å����cÕ"Ö-×�Ø�â�-å����-Ö7á-ÕeócáÆâ��-å����?ácó-Õ?Ù�Ö-×�á�×<à<ÙaÖOæ� �".`F)(+,'(�,ÀbO*�.`37Y � Å3�&!:#v(7>;Ä<º �)_mA��"!$%'�2!:#|(�*"0C.fÂÀF-.1�)>".1FQF)(+,/(�,/08!$*"R:.+g|� �".`Y[37R:R:36A�!$>"^�F".f�)>"!$,8!:3<>-#(70C.@,808P".kY[3<0�(+R:Rh(+P-,/3<9=(+,/(-_-#C!:>"%1.@,8�".1bd(+08. X P"!$R$, !$>?,/3;(G�".4R$*a.10��"R:.k!:>HIÀ#8( X .1R:R$.7n

U��0�����% 'W 2c¹(� �� cÄ 2aÄ<º�� � � U��% ����0������ 'W �U��0�����% 'WeÄ<ºK� � � �0� OÄ!T ��� 2; O¹OÅ����� 7Å52�� U��0������ 'W 2c¹�� �� cÄ 2�Ä?º�� 7Å52 �� �".&(7P-,/379E(+,83<>��)(7#M(QY[.1A 37,/�-.40��".4R$*a.10 *"083c%4.1F"P"0C.4#4n

�( cÄ3T��Oº+»��D4OÅ<» � �( cÄ3T��Oº+» � '2 ���HUK»�Äm¹ !2 � '2)W � !2(�?¹D2 �Oº7»��54OÅ<» � !2(�?¹D2 �Oº7» ���HU� <Å(�?º��94 � 92)W �2c¹�� �� �Oº+»��54OÅ<» � 2c¹�� �� �Oº+» � '2 ���HU 2 !aÄm¹;4 � '2)W �

� �³�³s|�O���=p[y6�Zym�|����sv�cuxux�e�=qj���|�cu � �������e��p[�·�<w-ymp[��z� �".108.�(70C.E,ÀAB3¬*"083 X R:.49;#@A�!$,/��,/�"!$#29;3OF".1R`Y[370&P"#C.�!:>�*"083c37Y[#23+Y�#8*�.4%4!W�)%�(7PO,/3<9=(+,'(O_�.1!$,/�-.40&Y[370�eP"9=(7>"#�3<0 9=(7%'�"!:>-.4#4n= � �".E.4>)( X R:.49;.4>?,&37YM(U*"(70C,8!:%4P-RS(70k,/08(7>"#C!$,/!$3<>�!:#2�-!:F"F".1>�!:>�,/�".;,/08(7>"#8!W,/!$3<>�F-.1�)>"!W,/!$3<>h_�(+>"F0C.4�eP"!:0C.4# (7> .f\O!$#C,/.1>?,/!S(+R��eP)(7>?,8!$�).10�,/3E#8*�.4%4!WY�b<gM� �eP"#4_È,83E#8(6bd,/�"(+, ��!:#M.4>"( X R:.1F !:>U#C,/(+,/."!?_!W, !:#�>".1%4.4#C#/(70Kb�,/3;#/(³b�nÜmå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcåeð�Õ7äOá Ö�Õ�æ üOü õ�Ö ��î~Ü+Ö�â�Õ�â�Ö��<æøÞñÜ�ácó-Õ?Ù�Ö'�eà'*ÁÕ7äcáÈæ� �"!$#D!:#EP">-Y[3<0K,/P">)(�,/.7_�(7#�.]\-!$#C,8.4>?,/!:(7R �eP)(7>?,8!$�).108#�%³(+> 37>"R$b X .�*"08365<.1F�!$>ñ,/�".�*"08365<.10 X b(7%f,/P)(+R:R$bU*"0C3m5c!$F"!:>"^=A�!$,/>-.4#8#k5+(70C!S( X R$.4#1g2� �eP"#k,/3H#/(³b ,8�)(+,V(7>�(7%f,/!$3<>¬!:#T.1>)( X R$.4Fh_�,8�".GP"#8.109QP-#C,B*"08365c!:F".�(VA�!W,/>".1#8#1_-.157.4>D,8�"3<P"^<�;,/�".MIKJML�%43cF".M!$,/#C.4RWYh9=(7F". ,/�".�.4>)( X R:.19=.1>e,B3 X 5c!:3<P-#!$>H,8�".k,/08(7>"#8!W,/!$3<>h¾¿#�*"08.1%43<>-F"!$,8!:3<>hg

G �

Page 97: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

= L�> .f\O.1%4P-,8!:3<> Y[0/(7^<9;.4>?,d!:#d>"37,dF".f,/.1089;!:>".1FèlCP"#K, X b ( ^7!$5<.1> #C.4�eP".4>-%4.�37YQ(7%1,8!:3<>-# X PO,0C.4�eP"!:0C.4#G,/�-.d*�3<#K,CÂÀ#K,'(+,8.4#£37YM.³(+%'�~37YM,/�".H(+%1,/!$3<>"#1g���3t#8�-3mA�,/�)(+,;(+> (+%1,/!$3<>�#8.1�eP".4>"%1.�!$#5+(7R$!:Fh_c,/�".@P"#C.40�9QP"#K,�*-08365c!:F".@9QP"RW,/!$*"R:.�.f\O!:#K,/.4>?,8!S(7RÈA�!W,/>".1#8#C.4#�,83£F".4#C%408! X .k,8�".@*a3<#K,C #C,'(�,/.4#1g

� �".@�)08#K,�#C�"3<0K,/%4379=!$>"^£!:# R:.1#8#�37Y·(;*-083 X R$.49 X .1%³(7P"#C.V,8�".@#C,/(7>"F)(70CFU!$>?57(+08!S(+>e,�*-083c37Y|,/.4>-F"#M,83X .&(Q,8�".43<0C.49Ï!$>�,/�".kY[3<0C9Unáeþ"åOà?ó"å�� �"å����>mÙ-ã&�-Ö7á-å �`ÞܳÖ�â�Õ�â�Ö �<æ�ÞñÜ+ácó"Õ<ÙaÖ �eà+* �Oå���æ�÷ ÜD>6Ùcã Ö"æ ü � ÜD>6Ùcã Ö��+æ

� �eP"#4_<,8�".�*�3<#C,KÂÀ#C,/(+,/.B!:#v.f\O*"R$!:%4!W,/RWbk*"08365c!:F-.4Fhg � 36A¡.f5<.104_?,/�".B#8.1%43<>"F£#C�"3<0C,8%43<9;!:>-^�!$#�(�*-083 X R$.49X .4%³(+P"#8.2A��-.4>�AB.2A¡(7>?, ,/3=#8�"36Aë,8�)(+, ,8�".40C.2.]\-!$#C,8#T(;A�!W,/>".1#8#�.f\O.4%1P-,/!$3<>'�Æ_�AB.2�"(657.2,/3=*"08365c!:F-.(7R$Rc,8�". !:>?,/.1089;.4F"!:(+,/.B#C,/(+,/.1#Æ(7R:#C3"g�� �-!:#�!:#�,/.4F-!:3<P"#�Y[3<0·,/�-.�P"#8.104_c(7>"FG%1R:P-,C,/.108#�%4379=*"PO,/.40 ÂÀ^<.1>".408(+,/.1F*"0C3O37Y[#1g

: ¥�� ; � ´ ¯ ´�� �<�·­���´k«³«4´ © ¶Hµ ´T«� �".@Y[P">"F)(+9=.1>e,/(7R|*"083 X R:.19�Y[3<0 *"08(7%1,8!:%³(+R�P"#8.V37Y·,8�". �UP".4R$R:.10M9;3cF".4Rh!$# ,/�)(+,M!W,M(7R:R$3mA�#�>"37>"F".1,8.40 Â9;!:>"!$#89 !:>�,8�".G*�3<#C,KÂÀ#C,/(+,/.&Y[3<0T.³(+%'��(+%1,/!$3<>h_a#83�,/�)(�,@(D*"083c37YÆ!$#T08.1�cP-!:08.1F¬,/3�%'�"3c3<#8.£(D*"(70C,8!:%4P-RS(70*�3<#C,KÂÀ#C,/(+,/.+g�� �"!$#�(70C!:#8.1#DY[083<9 (�F"!:0C.4%f,D,/08(7>"#8R:(+,/!$3<>ñ37YVI&%<J½(7P-,83<9E(�,'(-_�A��"!$%'� (708. X b�>)(�,/P"0C.>"3<>-F".1,8.4089;!:>-!:#C,8!:% Y[370 .³(7%'�U#C,'(�,/.7_)!$> X 3+,/�H,/�".@>".]\O,�(7%f,/!$3<>d(7>"FH,/�".@*�3<#C,KÂÀ#C,/(+,/.k^7!$5<.1>�(+>U(+%1,/!$3<>hg

IÀ>¬*"0/(+%1,/!$%4.+_ÈA��".4>¬AB.2A�08!W,/.QI&%7J (+P-,/3<9=(+,/(-_�,8�".Q9=(7!:>U#83<P-08%4.G3+YÆ>"3<>"F".f,/.1089;!:>"!$#89 !:#T!$>�,/�-.H#DFG 1�685�,/�)(�,2!$#@,/(7�7.1>h_�>"3+,2!$>�,/�-.=*�3<#C,KÂÀ#K,'(+,8.7gdÃ)P"0C,8�".401_�A��".1>j,/�".108.=!:#V>"3<>"F".f,/.1089;!:>"!$#89¼!$>�,/�-.*�3<#C,KÂÀ#C,/(+,/.+_<!:>£(+>Q365<.40KA��".4R$9=!$>"^k9=(mlC3<08!W,Àb@37Y�%³(7#C.4#1_e,8�".�>"37>"F".1,8.40C9=!$>"!:#C9!$#�9=(7F".¡.]\O*"R:!$%4!$, X b2,/�-.P"#C.E37Y��cº#� ���d57(+08!S( X R:.1#4_�A��"!:%'��.4>"%4(7*"#CP"RS(+,8.=,8�".=>-3<>"F".f,/.40C9=!$>"!:#C9Ug � (+>"F"R:!$>"^d>"3<>"F".f,/.1089;!:>"!$#89!:>�,/�".E(7%1,8!:3<>�!:#V.³(7#C!:.104_�#C!:>"%1.=AB.D%³(7>j*a.10CY[3<0C9½#K,/0CP"%1,8P"0/(7R`!:>-F"P"%1,8!:3<>�3<>j,8�".D(7%f,/!$3<>jF)(�,'(d,Àbc*�.(7>"F~%4365<.10�(7R:R *�3<#C#8! X !:R:!W,/!$.4#4g~I ,D!:#;>"37,E*a37#8#8! X R:.H,/3�F"3�,8�". #8(79=.d3<>~,8�".�*�3<#K,CÂÀ#K,'(+,8.U#C!:>"%1.�,/�-.>"3<>-F".1,8.4089;!:>-!:#89 !$# 9;!W\O.4F !$>UA�!W,/��,8�".G(7%f,/P)(7R�#C,/(+,/.25+(70C!S( X R:.4#1g � �".108.Q!$#�,8�cP-#@(7>¬(7F-5+(7>?,/(7^<.Q!$>*"P"#C�"!:>-^&(+R:Rc>"3<>"F".f,/.1089;!:>"!$#89!:>?,/3T,8�".�(7%1,8!:3<>Q(7>"F£9E(+�c!$>"^ ,8�". *a37#C,C #C,/(+,/. F".f,/.1089;!:>"!$#C,/!$%B37>"%4. ,/�-.*"0C.fÂÀ#K,'(+,8.Q(7>-Ft(7%1,8!:3<>�(708.&�c>-3mA�>ÈgT� �"!:#MA�(+# 6¡3<^<F"(7>"365�¾ #T!$>"#8!$^<�?, ) 6¡3<^ X5X 0 Y[3<0M,8�". '|(70C%'��,/�".13<0Cb37Y�I&%<JÁ(+P-,/3<9=(+,/(-_)(7>d(7*"*-083?(7%'�HAB.&%1R:3<#C.4R$b=Y[3<R:R$36A�!$>D,/�".@>".fAë9;3OF".1R g

� �". ^7.4>".10/(7R�08P"R$.�!:#Æ,/�)(+,B.157.40Kb^�"!�ºeº� 7Å25+(708!:( X R$. X .1%43<9;.4#¡( �eº#� ���&*)(708(79;.1,/.10`,83V,8�".T(+%1,/!$3<>hg� �".�(7%f,/!:37> F"(+,'(+,Àbc*�.t!$,/#C.4RWY&!$#�>"36A¼9;3OF-!$�).1Fñ,/3è!:>"%1R:P"F-. ,/�".tR:3c%³(+R�5+(708!:( X R$.¬(7#H(�*)(708(79=.f,/.10,/3¬.4(7%'� (7%1,8!:3<>hg�L >?b�%13<>"#K,/0/(+!:>?,/#G3<> �eº#� �(�t(7>"F �"!�ºeº# 7Å�5+(708!:( X R$.4# X .4%13<9;.�*"08.1%43<>"F-!$,/!$3<>"#2,83,/08(7>"#C!$,/!$3<>"#��fg�� �".T*�3<#C,KÂÀ#K,'(+,8.T!:#¡(2F".1,8.40C9=!$>"!:#K,/!:%�Y[P">"%f,/!$3<>D37Y�,8�".T*"0C.fÂÀ#K,'(+,8.k(7>"FD,8�".T>".fA (+%1,/!$3<>hgNO!$>"%4.¬AB.�%'�"(7>"^<.¬,/�-.�(+%1,/!$3<>�F)(+,/(+,Àbc*a.+_ AB.�>".1.4Fö,/3Z(7R$#83è%'�)(7>"^7.��-3mA¼(7%1,8!:3<>-# X .f,ÀA¡.1.4>�,ÀAB3(7P-,83<9=(+,'(Q%13<080C.4#8*�3<>"FÈgÆi�[email protected]\O*"R:(7!:>�,/�-!:# RS(�,/.40 !$>UNO.4%f,/!:37> � g QOgPQOg

L >E(7P-,/379E(+,83<>£!:#Æ>"36Aö( �+ ,8P"*"R$.7_?%437>"#8!$#C,/!$>"^@37Y�(+>D(7%f,/!:37>;#C!:^<>"(+,/P"0C.7_e#C,/(70C,`#K,'(+,8.4#4_O(7>=.4>)( X R:.fÂ9;.4>?,&Y[P->"%1,8!:3<>�(7>"F�(7>j.fÇÈ.1%1,VY[P">"%f,/!:37>hg=i�.=*-08.4#C.40K5<.E,8�".=9;.1,8�"3cF�37Y¡F".1�">"!:>"^H,/�-.E(7PO,/3<9=(+,/37>#8!$^<>)(+,8P"08. (7>"FH(7%f,/!$3<>�(7>"FE#C,'(�,/.TF)(�,'(+,Àbc*�.4#4g 6Bb=#8.1*)(708(+,/!$>"^2,/�-.T.4>)( X R:.19=.1>e,¡Y[083<9�,/�-.T.1Ça.4%f,³_-AB.%³(+>E#/(³b£A��".1>H(7>D(7%f,/!$3<>=!$#B.1>)( X R$.4F;A�!$,/�-3<P-,`�)(³5c!:>"^V,/32�eP)(+>e,8!$Y�bG,8�". *�3<#C,KÂÀ#K,'(+,8.7g�Ã)3<0`!:9;*"R:.19=.1>OÂ,'(�,/!:37>�%437>e57.4>"!$.4>"%1.7_v(7>¬(+P-,/3<9=(+,83<> !:#�>"3DR$3<>"^<.10T(=,8P"*"R:.+_ X PO,k!:>"#K,/.4(7F¬%43<>-#C,/0CP"%1,8.4F X b�,8�". �4',Àbc*a.@%13<>"#C,808P"%f,/3<0VÄ<º �)n

��� ����������������������� �"!#�$%����&('�����'���)�)*�+�,!-&('��.� ï/þ�à4à�Öfå �����/�0��1�$��.!2��)�)*�.� �-����!#�0��� *³à1ó $%3 ),!+465��7��6�� ���� � �.8�)��(� ��/�+89�.��:;� '��0!(�+�%� '��+�"4

G��

Page 98: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

ðOÕ?á"Õ?á���"å Ü � Õ-ï�á�×+à<Ù â � Ö�áOÕ<áOå�æ�×+àeÕ ü> � � � ��Õ-ï�á�×7à7Ù�ô+Î���Ð�Ó"Ñ��|Í<Ò � Ü�� � ×�ØcÙ"ÕeáeäOó"å �Oæ� � Ö�áOÕ<áOåøÖ7å?á�� Ü�� � áOÕ<óeá)Ö �cæ�)Ü��mÕ-ï+á�×+à7Ù�â��7Ö�áOÕ<á-åhæ å?Ù"Õ<Ý�Ûeå���å<Ù-á(� Ü�� �eÙ"Õ?Ý)Ûcå���å?ÙOá �cæ�)Ü��mÕ-ï+á�×+à7Ù�â��7Ö�áOÕ<á-åhæ�å *'*Oå-ï�á � Ü�� � *+*-å"ï+á�Ö��cæIÀ#/( X .4R$R:.=(7P-,83<9E(�,/!:%4(7R:RWb�F-.1�)>".1#G(7%1%4.4#C#83<0&Y[P">"%1,8!:3<>-#VA��".1>�A¡.=P"#8.;,/�"!$#29;.³(7>-#&37Y�F".1�)>-!$,/!$3<>hg

i�.V>-3mA F".1�">".V,8�".@9=.19=370Cb�(+P-,/3<9=(+,83<>�!:>�,/�-!:# *"0C3m57.40M9=3cF".1R n�-å�� ücü Ü5> � � �-å����eÕ)ÖO×�Ø �"å����"Ö+á"Õ?ócá �"å����cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá �-å����eå+*+*Oå)ï+áÈæ+�A��".40C.V,8�".@F)(+,/(G,Àbc*�.4# Å �� � �<Å3��Å �'2U(7>"F�Å<»c»OÅ(�!2d(708.@F".f�)>".1F X b�ná� �-å-ÖÜ��mÕ-ï�á�×7à7Ù�â �7Ö+áOÕ<áOåhæ å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá ü ���7Ö�áOÕ?áOå � �mÕ-ï+á�×+à7Ù � Ý-àcàcÛ��Ü��mÕ-ï�á�×7à7Ù�â �7Ö+áOÕ<áOåhæ å *'*cå"ï�á ü ���7Ö�áOÕ<á-å � ��Õ-ï�á�×+à7Ù � �7Ö+áOÕ<áOå�� �eP"#Q(7>t.1>)( X R$.49;.4>?,@Y[P">"%1,8!:3<>¬,8.4R:R$#TA��".1,8�".40&(�*)(70K,/!:%1P"RS(+0k(7%1,8!:3<>t!$#k.4>)( X R:.4FtY[08379¼(�#C,/(+,/.+_A��"!$R:.@,/�".Q.fÇÈ.1%1,�Y[P">"%1,8!:3<>�F".1,8.4089;!:>-.4#�,8�".Q>".fA�#C,/(+,/.+gT� �".Q.fÇÈ.1%1,TY[P">-%1,/!$3<>�!$# P">-#8*�.4%4!W�).4F A��-.4>,/�-.k(7%1,8!:3<>E!:#¡>-37,�.1>)( X R$.4Fhg�aM3mA !W,�!:#B*a37#8#8! X R:.M,/3Q�"(657.@(2�eP)(7>?,/!W�).40  Y[0C.4.T*"0C.4F"!$%³(+,8. ,/32F".1,8.4089;!:>-.A��".f,/�".10�(7>E(7%1,8!:3<>;!:#Æ.4>"( X R:.1Fh_O(7#BR$3<>"^V(7#Æ,/�".M*"0C.4%437>"F"!$,8!:3<>;!$,8#8.1R$YhF-3O.1#B>"3+,¡%13<>?,'(7!$>E(@�eP)(7>?,/!W�).401gÃ)3<0|,/�".`#8�)(+08.4F29=.19=3<0Kb@%³(7#C.¡#K,/P"F-b&!:>VIÀ#/( X .1R:R:.+_�,8�".¡>-.1A�,/08(7>"#CRS(+,8!:3<>V08.1#8P"RW,/#·!$>V,8�".¡#C*a.1%4!W�)%³(+,8!:3<>-##8�-3mA�>U!:>d÷!$^<P"08. �  +kY[3<0�,8�". � Å3�U(+P-,/3<9=(+,83<>hg

iö!$,8�dF-.1,/.1089;!:>"!$#89 !:>d(7%1,8!:3<>-#4_)(7>d.f\O.1%4P-,8!:3<>HY[0/(7^79=.1>e,�!$#�lCP"#C,�(GR:!$#C, 3+Y�(7%f,/!$3<>"#4nÑ����hÒ Ü � Õ-ï�á�×7à7Ù�æ åD?-å)ï�ä-á�×7à?Ù ü � � Õ-ï�á�×+à7Ù�Û-×?Ö+á�,/�-. �".³(7F;37Y�,/�". R$!:#K,�%43<>?,/(7!:>"#�,8�".6L H��FG�(7%f,/!$3<>h_<#C3@,8�)(+,�AB.�%³(7>£08.1%4P"0C#8!W5<.4RWb �x370�!:>"F"P-%1,/!W5<.1R$b($·F".1�">".,/�-.V.]\O.4%4PO,/!:37>�(7#�#C�"36A�> X .4R:36A@g

�#C!:>"^k,/�-!:#�.f\O.1%4P-,8!:3<>£Y[3<089=(+,�0C.4�eP"!$08.4#Æ#C3<9=. �-.4R:*�.40�Y[P->"%1,8!:3<>"#1g·� �".6� �( 32 �<»2Y[P">-%1,/!$3<>£08.f,/P"0C>"#,/�-.2#C,/(+,/.&,/�)(+,�!:#M,/�".&08.1#8P"RW,T37Y�.]\O.4%4PO,/!:>-^H(=*)(70K,/!$%4P"R:(70�.f\O.4%1P-,/!$3<> Y[0/(7^79=.1>e,�P"*�3<>¬(;#C,'(�,/.Q37Y�(7>(7P-,83<9=(+,/3<>È_OY[08379É(G^<!$57.4>d#C,'(�,/.7nï<à7Ù�Ö�á)Ö Û?Õ-Ö�á � * ÞeÞ��Ü ��Õ-ï�á�×7à7Ù â �7Ö�áOÕ<á-åhæë×+àeÕ �

�7Ö�á-Õ<áOå �Ü � Õ-ï�á�×7à7Ù�æ�å;?-å)ï�äOáa×7à?Ù ��7Ö�á-Õ<áOå�

�Oó�× �)ó"å"ïÛeÕ"Ö7á � * �?ð-å'*�Þ�eÛ?Õ-Ö�á � *øÕ7äcá Ö ùCú ü Ö&�ÛeÕ"Ö7á � * �?ð-å'* �·Þ�eÛ?Õ-Ö�á � *øÕ7äcá Ö Ü�cà<Ù�ÖëÕ"ï�áÁó-å-Ö�á�æ üå'*�*Oå)ï+á�Ö'�eà+*Õ7äcáÉÜ+Û?Õ"Ö�á � * Õ7äOá Ö óOå"Ö�á�æ Õ-ï�á�a�37,8.7nT,8�".Q¸-¹�Ä �-¹OÅ��d(+R:R:36A�# ,8�".£F".1�">"!$,8!:3<>¬37Y¡(�*)(70K,/!S(+R:R$bd#C*a.1%4!$�".4FtY[P">"%1,8!:3<>t!$> ,/�".£IÀ#/( X .1R:R:.

RS(+>"^<P)(7^7.=P"#C!:>"^ � 'ö*"(+,8,8.408>�9=(+,8%'�"!:>"^-g � �". ÄK � :-Å(� '2�Ä?º���Y[P->"%1,8!:3<>�F-.1,/.1089;!:>".1#2A��".f,/�".10£(7>.4>?,8!:08.@.]\-.1%4P-,8!:3<>HY[0/(+^<9=.1>?,�!:#�5+(7R:!$Fhnï<à7Ù�Ö�á)Ö×eÖ �9?-å)ï�äOáa×7à?ÙýÞeÞ��Ü ��Õ-ï�á�×7à7Ù â �7Ö�áOÕ<á-åhæë×+àeÕ �

�7Ö�á-Õ<áOå �Ü ��Õ-ï�á�×7à7Ù�æ�å;?-å)ï�äOáa×7à?Ù �Ý-àeàcÛ���Oó�× �)ó"å"ï×eÖ �9?-å)ï�äOáa×7à?Ù)�?ð-å'*`Þ

�"×eÖ �'?"å"ï�ä-á�×<à<Ù�Õ7äOá Ö�ùKú ü ÜG<ÿ

Page 99: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

ó-å-ï7à<ócð��-å����-Ö7á-Õeá-å ü��å��"ÚOÕ<ó ÞcÞ��eÚ-ÕcÛ+ä-å�Õ-ï+á ÞeÞ��Ü!@-à?ðcå`âñÜ��)ï�á�×7à7Ù�æ @eä"ÛeÛaæ �eócóOÕ ��ó)Ö �½ÞeÞ��Ü!@-à?ðcå`âñÜ��-å)Ö �"à?Ù�Ö?å�æ�@?ä)ÛeÛÈæ �eócóOÕ �ðOÕ?á"Õ?á���"å �-å����eÕ)ï+áa×7à<Ù ü×mÙcãOà��Oå �5@Oà?ðOå �,�'��ï�á�×+à7Ù � � ó-å)Ö �"à?Ù-ð �D@Oà?ðOå� � �"å"Ö �)à<ÙaÖ<å�� � ä��OðcÕ<á-å��5@Oàeðcå �,�+�)ï�á�×+à<Ù �ðOå *"Ö�-å����"Ö+á-Õeócá)�?ðOå+*ÆÞ�,�"å����-Ö+á"Õ?óOá üOü � Ö��-å�� îÜ4ó)Ö � Ö��Oå�� ü Ü<ï?à<ÙaÖ+á-Õ?ÙOá Ù�×<Ûaæeæ�÷Ü6Õ-ï+á Ö��Oå�� ü Ü<ï?à<ÙaÖ+á-Õ?ÙOá Ù�×<Ûaæeæ�÷Ü ��å��"ÚOÕ<ó Ö��Oå�� ü ã G æ%&�

ðOå *"Ö�"å����cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�?ð-å'*`Þ�,�"å����eå<Ù)Õ<Ý�Ûeå��aå<Ù-á Ö��Oå�� Õ �Oå�� ü-ü �?Ó"ômÒ Õ��Oå�� Ì�ËÜ7×6ÙcãOà �OåëÙÁÕaæ �Ü?Ü+ÖmäeÝ�ÜmÕ"ï�áøÖ��Oå��·æ ÙÈæ ü Ù�×<Ûaæ � Ö��Oå���î1Õ-ï�á¡ù Ù�ú ü Ù�×7Û�ܳó-å)Ö �)à<Ù-ð Ùëóhæ �Ü?Ü+ÖmäeÝ�ܳó�Ö � Ö��Oå��·æ ÙÈæ ü Ümå��-Ý-åeð�ó�æeæ�� Ö��Oå���î]ó)Ö ��ù Ù�ú ü å��-Ý-åeðÆÜ'óÈæ�Ü1ä��OðcÕ?áOåëÙÁÕaæ � ��Ö��Oå���î'ó)Ö �¡ùKÙ)ú ü Ùcä"Û~÷ÉÖ��-å��Mî1Õ-ï�á`ùCÙ)ú ü å��-Ý-åeðÆÜfÕ)æÜeÜcÜ+ÖmäeÝ Ü³ó)Ö ��Ö��Oå��·æ Ù�æ ü Ù�×7Û�æj÷½ÜeÜ+ÖmäeÝ�ÜmÕ-ï+áøÖ��-å��·æZÙ�æ ü Ü+å��-Ý-åeðÕÈæeæeæ�ðOå *"Ö

�-å����cå'*+*-å"ï7á&�?ð-å'*`Þ�,�"å����eå'*�*Oå)ï+á Ö��Oå�� Õ��Oå�� üOü �?Ó"ômÒ Õ��Oå��ÉÌ�ËÜ7×6ÙcãOà �OåëÙÁÕaæ �

�"å����-Ö+á"Õ?á"å·î ��Õ��OåÜ ��å��"ÚOÕ<óÉÖ��Oå���æÜ6Õ-ÖcÖc×mØ?ÙýÜmÕ-ï�áøÖ��Oå��·æ~Ù Ümå��-Ý-åeðÁÕaæ?æÜ1ó)Ö ��Ö��Oå��·æ��ܳó-å)Ö �)à<Ù-ð Ùëóhæ ��"å����-Ö+á"Õ?á"å·î ��Õ��OåÜ ��å��"ÚOÕ<óÉÖ��Oå���æÜ6Õ-ÖcÖc×mØ?ÙýÜmÕ-ï�áøÖ��Oå��·æ~Ù�Ù�×<Û)æÜ6Õ-ÖcÖc×mØ?Ùýܳó)Ö � Ö��Oå��·æ~Ù�Ù�×<Ûaæ��Ü1ä��OðcÕ?áOåëÙÁÕaæ ��"å����-Ö+á"Õ?á"å·î ��Õ��OåÜ��)å?ó�*-à?ó���Õ�Ü���å��"ÚOÕ<óÏÖ��Oå��·æ?æܳÕ-ï�á Ö��Oå��væÜ6Õ-ÖcÖc×mØ?Ùýܳó)Ö � Ö��Oå��·æ~Ù Ümå��-Ý-åeð�Ü6óOå"Ömä"Û7á�Õ Ü ��å��"Ú-Õ<óÏÖ��Oå��Ææeæeæeæ

�ðOå *"Ö�-å����eðOå'*�Þ� �Oå�� ü-ü Ü5> � � �"å����eÕ"Ö-×�Ø �-å����"Ö+á-Õeócá �"å����cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá �"å����eå'*�*Oå)ï+áÈæ+�

÷!$^<P"08. �  +<nk� �".;#8*�.4%1!$�)%4(+,/!$3<>�(7P-,/379E(+,83<>h_ � Å3�t,/08(7>"#CRS(+,8.4Ft,/3dIÀ#/( X .4R$R:.7g aM37,/!$%4.G�"36A ,8�".£R:3c%³(7R5+(708!:( X R$.@�D!:>U,/�". c¸94�� 2-ÅH,/08(7>"#C!$,/!$3<>�!$# >"36A(=Y[P-R:Rv*)(70/(+9=.f,/.401g � �"!$#T08.1�eP"!:0C.4#k(E%'�"(7>"^<.Q!$>��"36AAB.&9=(+,/%'��,80/(7%1.4# Y[3<0 #8!$9QP"R:(+,/!$3<>D08.1RS(+,8!:3<>-#4g GHG

Page 100: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

.eó?ä-åæ+�×eÖ �9?-å)ï�äOáa×7à?Ù)�?ð-å'* ��Þ�"×eÖ �'?"å"ï�ä-á�×<à<Ù�Õ7äOá Ö�ÜmÕ"ï�á��"ó-å-Ö�á�æ ü ÜÜmå?Ù"Õ?Ý)Ûeå���å?ÙOá&�cà'*�Õ7äcá Ü�Û?Õ-Ö+á � *øÕ7äOá Ö�óOå-Ö+á�æ Õ-ï�áhæ�÷Ü<×cÖ �9?-å"ï+äOáa×7à<Ù Õ7äcá Ö óOå-Ö�áÈææ+�a�36A,/�)(+,kAB.G�)(³5<.G,8�". X (7#C!:%G!:>OY[0/(7#K,/08P-%1,/P-08.7_h,8�".40C.£(708.&,/�"0C.4.£P"#8.fY[P"R�(7#C*a.1%1,8#V3+Y`,8�"!:#k9;3cF".4R

,/3;F"!$#8%4P-#8#4g�Ã�!:08#K,M!:# ,/�".V*"08(7%1,8!:%³(+Rh5O!$.1Aë3+Y�P"#C!:>"^;,/�"!$#M9;3cF".4RhY[3<0�*"0C3O3+Y[#4g¡� �-!:#M�)(7#�(7R:0C.³(7F-b X .1.4>*"0C.4#8.1>?,/.4F !:>ZNO.1%1,8!:3<> . g � gPQOgj� �".H9=(7!:> X .4>-.1�",GAB.H^<.1,£!$#Q,/�)(+,4_ÆR:!:�+.E,/�-. '|Ê�,/0/(+>"#8R:(+,/!$3<>h_�,/�-.,/08(7>"#C!$,/!$3<>D#C.49=(7>?,/!:%1#�!:#¡Y[[email protected]\O!:#K,/.1>e,8!S(7R��eP)(+>e,8!$�).108#1g¡Nc.4%437>"FU!$#�,/�".kP-#8.@37Yv,/�"!$#�9=3cF".1RÈY[3<0�,/�-.,/�-.43<0Kbt37Y¡I&%7J�(7P-,83<9E(�,'(D!:>t^<.1>".408(7R g£� �"!$#@!:#V(dP-#8.1Y[P-R`F-!:#8%1P"#8#C!:3<> X .4%³(+P"#8.£A¡.£A¡(7>?,&,83d.1>"#8P-08.,/�"(+,�,/�".@9;3OF".1Rh%³(+>UF"3;9;.1,'(m ,/�-.43<0C.1,/!$%T*"0C3O37Y[#1_�(7>"F�,/�"(+,M!$,�!:# #C3<P">"FÈgB� �"!$08FH!:#��"36A�,/�"!$#M9;3cF".4R08.1RS(+,8.4#�,83=#C!:9QP"R:(+,/!$3<>E0C.4R:(+,/!$3<>"#4g

� *-,.*0/ � 7 =� =�� 7<26��� ��26� =�� 7 5 7� K�6M �3�=�2��� =�2 5 � 2 �67 �IÀ>�,8�"!:#@#C.4%1,8!:3<>È_�AB.=F".1#8%108! X .E�-3mA�,/�".;!:>-Y[08(7#C,808P"%f,/P"0C.;AB.E�"(657.EF".f5<.1R:3<*�.4F�!:#@#C,8!:R:RÆ(+F".4�eP)(+,8.;Y[3709;.1,'(m ,/�-.43<0C.1,/!$%�*"0C3O37Y[#Æ(+#�F"3<>". X b �UP".1R:R$.404g�÷!:0C#C,�AB.�F".1�)>-.M,ÀAB3VY[P->"%1,8!:3<>"#�37>=(+P-,/3<9=(+,/(-n�0C.³(7%'�cÂ( X !$R:!W,ÀbD(7>-FU!$>e5+(70C!S(7>-%4.7gÆi�.@,8�".4>U*"083657.V,8�)(+,�,/�".V#C,/(7>"F)(+08Fd9=.f,/�"3cFU3+Y·*"0C365O!$>"^;IKJML!:>?5+(708!:(7>"%4.�x#K,'(70K,M%43<>"F-!$,/!$3<>��O#C,/.1*U%13<>"F"!W,/!$3<> $B!$#�(;#C3<P">"FHA�(³b�,83;#C�"36Aë!:>?5+(70C!S(7>"%1.k(7#�F".f�)>".4FU�".40C.7gIÀ>D3<0CF".40Æ,/3&F".1�)>-. 08.4(7%'�)( X !:R:!W,Àb<_?AB.��)0C#C,�F-.1�)>". (&�".1R:*�.401_O¹OÅ �(��!�� � �<Å� aÄ 2K!DA��"!$%'�D#/(³bc#B,8�)(+,¡(

*)(70K,/!$%4P"R:(70Æ#C,'(�,/. @!$#B0C.³(7%'�"( X R:.MY[083<9 (&*)(70C,8!:%1P"RS(70�#K,'(+,8. �QP"#8!$>"^Q(&*)(70C,8!:%1P"RS(70�.]\O.4%4PO,/!:37> �(�m¸ !��"nï<à<ÙaÖ+á-ðOå'*�Öó-åcÕ)ï�þ)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��È×�áeþ½ÞeÞ���Ü��mÕ-ï�á�×+à<Ù�â �7Ö�á-Õ<áOåÈæ"×+àeÕ ��7Ö�á-Õ<áOå �� Ö�á-Õ<áOå ��mÕ-ï+á�×+à7Ù�å;?-å)ï�äOáa×7à?Ù �Ý-àeàcÛ��

�<ó-åOÕ"ï+þ"Õ<Ý�Ûeå��a×�ácþ Õ7äOá Ö�Ö G ÕOÛ �eþ-Õ ücü ÜÜ�Ö G ÞñÖ+á"Õ?ócá�Ö �cà'*�Õ7äcáhæ�÷Ü<×cÖ �9?-å"ï+äOáa×7à<Ù Õ7äcá Ö G ÕcÛ �cþ-Õhæ�÷Ü�ÛeÕ-Ö�á � * Õ<äcá�Ö G ÕcÛ �eþ"Õ ü Ö-ææ+�a�36Aø,/�"!$#Q�".4R$*a.10Q*"0C.4F"!$%³(+,8.D!:#QP-#8.4F X bj,8�".�F".f�)>"!$,8!:3<>j37Y�¹OÅ#�(�"!�� ���<Åj!$>�#/(³bc!:>"^ ,8�)(+,Q,8�".40C.

.f\O!$#C,/#;(t#C,/(70C,£#K,'(+,8. �j(+>"F~(+>Z.]\O.4%4PO,/!:37> ���m¸#!���,8�)(+,;#/(�,/!:#K�).4#£¹OÅ �(��!�� � �<Å� aÄ 2K!a_�Y[370£(t^7!$5<.1>#C,/(+,/. cnï<à<ÙaÖ+á-ðOå'*�Öó"åcÕ)ï�þ"Õ?Ý)Ûcå ÞeÞ���Ü ��Õ-ï�á�×7à7Ù¡â��7Ö+áOÕ<áOåaæ)×+àeÕ � �7Ö+áOÕ<áOå � Ý-àeàOÛ �

�<ó-åOÕ"ï+þ"Õ<Ý�ÛeåëÕ7äOá�Ö ücüÜ]õ Ö G î~Ü4õ�ÕOÛ �eþ-Õýîjó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)Ûeå��a×+áeþ Õ<äcá Ö�Ö G ÕcÛ �eþ"Õhæ?æ� #@!W5<.1>E,/�"!$#¡F".f�)>"!W,/!:37>E37Y�0C.³(7%'�"( X !:R$!$,Àb7_eAB.T%4(7>�>"36AöF".1�">". A��)(+,�!$,B9=.4(7>"#BY[370¡(7>E!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,`,83

�"3<R$FH3<>d(7>�(+P-,/3<9=(+,83<>hg�L�>U!$>e5+(70C!S(7>?, !$#�(G*"08.1F"!:%4(+,/.@3<>�,/�-.V#K,'(+,8.4#M37Y·(7>�(+P-,/3<9=(+,83<>hg�� �eP"#1nï<à<ÙaÖ+á-ðOå'*�ÖÎ Ð���Ó"Í<Î Ó)Ð|Ñ ÞeÞ �hù+Ü �mÕ-ï�á�×+à7Ù�â �7Ö�áOÕ<á-å�æ)×7àeÕ�â �7Ö�á-Õ<áOå �MÝ-àeàOÛ-ú�� Ý-àeàcÛ���cÎ Ð���Ó"Í<Î Ó)Ð|Ñ Õ7äcá�� ü-ü Ü =øÖ·î�ó-åOÕ"ï+þ"Õ<Ý�Ûeå�Õ<äcá Ö����·ÜmÖ"æcæ��L >=!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,��G!:#`(7>=!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,Æ3<>E(+P-,/3<9=(+,83<>Z� '2£!WYaY[3<0`(7R$R"08.4(7%'�)( X R:.M#C,'(�,/.4# k,/�-.M!$>?57(+08!S(+>e,�"3<R$F"#4gQi�.£>"36A #C�"36A�,/�"(+,@,/�".£IKJML�9;.1,8�"3cFtY[370k*"08365c!:>"^H!$>e5+(70C!S(7>?,8#k!:#k#837P">"FhgGi�.;F-.1�)>".£,/�-.

+ X5X

Page 101: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

#C,/(70C,�(7>-Fd#K,/.1*�%437>"F"!$,8!:3<>-#��"3<R$F"!:>"^£(+#�Y[37R:R:36A�#1nï<à<ÙaÖ+á-ðOå'*�Ö×mÙOã"Õ?óa×7Õ<Ù-á&�"Ö+á-Õeócá½ÞcÞ��|ù7Ü��mÕ-ï�á�×+à7Ù�â��7Ö�áOÕ<áOåÈæ"×+àcÕÆâ �7Ö�á-Õ<áOå � Ý-àeàcÛ-ú � Ý-àeàcÛ���"×mÙ-ã-Õeó�×7Õ?ÙOá)�-Ö+á"Õ?óOá�Õ7äcá > ü-ü=ÉÖ�áOÕ<á-åýî~ÜeÖ�áOÕ?áOå¼Þ~ÜcÖ7á-Õ?óOá�Ö'�eà'*ÁÕ7äcáhæ � >Ö�áOÕ<á-åhæ+�ï<à<ÙaÖ+á-ðOå'*�Ö×mÙOã"Õ?óa×7Õ<Ù-á&�?ácó-Õ?Ù�Ö ÞcÞ��|ù7Ü��mÕ-ï�á�×+à7Ù�â��7Ö�áOÕ<áOåÈæ"×+àcÕÆâ �7Ö�á-Õ<áOå � Ý-àeàcÛ-ú � Ý-àeàcÛ���"×mÙ-ã-Õeó�×7Õ?ÙOá)�<ácó"Õ<ÙaÖ Õ7äcá > ü-ü=ÉÖ�áOÕ<á-å�Õ"ï�á�îÜ?ܳó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)ÛeåÕ7äcá Ö�áOÕ<áOå�æj÷Ü3>�Ö�áOÕ?áOåhæ�÷Ü�å?Ù"Õ?Ý)Ûeå���å?ÙOá&�cà'*Õ<äcáøÖ+áOÕ<áOå Õ-ï�áÈææ �

>�Ümå'*�*Oå"ï7á�Ö'�eà'*ÁÕ7äcá Ö�áOÕ<áOå Õ-ï+áÈæ+�� �".4#C.�#8!$9=*-R$b�(+08.t,/�".�#C,/(7>"F)(70CF�A¡(³b AB.j*-08365<.�!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,/#H!:> IKJML&g�i�.t,/�".1> *"083657.�,/�-.Y[3<R$R:36A�!:>"^29E(7!$>D,/�".13<08.19Unáeþ"åOà?ó"å��Ï×�ÙOã-Õeó�×<Õ<ÙOá8>|ÞÓ?ôfô�� � Ò+ô � G Þ �a×mÙOã"Õ?óa×7Õ<Ù-á&�"Ö+á-Õeócá Õ7äcá > �Õ7ÙOð��aí�Þ �a×mÙOã"Õ?óa×7Õ<Ù-á&�?ácó-Õ?Ù�ÖëÕ7äcá > �Ömþ-à���Ö �OÎKÐ���Ó"Í7ÎKÓ)Ð|Ñ�Õ<äcá >&�� �"!:#k!$#k(�Q X5X R$!:>".&*"083c37Y`#8�"36A�>�!:>¬L�*"*a.1>"F"! \¬L2g&� �".£08.4(7#83<>¬A��?b ,8�".Q,ÀA¡3H%13<>"F"!W,/!:37>"#k(70C.#8P�`=%1!:.1>e,V,/3d*"0C3m57.E!$>e5+(70C!S(7>-%4.G!:#k,8�".=.]\O*a.1%1,/.1F�3<>".+n2(H#C,/(+,/.;!:#@0C.³(7%'�)( X R:.£!$YB!$,@!$#V(d#K,'(70K,2#K,'(+,8.3<0Q%4(7> X .�0C.³(7%'�-.4FèY[083<9 (�5+(7R:!$F�.f\O.4%1P-,/!$3<>hg�I YM,8�".�#C,/(+,/.�!$#G(¬#C,/(70C,G#K,'(+,8.7_�Ä �'���<¹�Ä � �92 !2(�<¹;2�)(7>-F"R:.1#¡,/�"!$#¡%4(7#8.+g`I Yv(Q#K,'(+,8.T!:#B08.4(7%'�)( X R$.TF"P".�,/3£(&5+(7R$!:FE.]\O.4%4PO,/!:37>h_hÄ �'���<¹�Ä � �92 2c¹�� �� Q�)(7>-F"R:.1#,/�-!:#G%³(+#8.7g�� �-.d#C.4%13<>"F~%4(7#8.H!$#£( X !$,G!$>e,808!$%³(+,8.7_`(7#QAB.U�)(³57.H,83t#8�"36AÏ,8�)(+,G,/�-.�!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,G#C,8.4*%437>"F"!$,8!:3<>;�"3<R$F"!:>-^&!$#`#CP(`;%4!$.4>?,�,/3&#8�"36Aö,/�"(+,B,8�".M!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,B�-3<R:F"#ÆY[3<0Æ,/�".�.4>?,/!$08.M57(+R:!:F£.]\-.1%4P-,8!:3<>Ègi�.VF-3£,8�"!:# X b�#K,/08P-%1,/P-0/(7R|!:>-F"P"%1,8!:3<>�37>d,8�".k57(+R:!:FE.f\O.4%1P-,/!$3<>�#C.4�eP".4>-%4. �[%³(7#C. �ÈÄ �O_�%³(7#C.�"º��� $fg

� �eP"#4_-AB. �"(657.T*"0C3m57.4>h_OP"#8!$>"^237>"R$b£3<P-0BIÀ#8( X .1R:R$.M,8�".43<0Kb;37YhI&%<J (+P-,/3<9=(+,/(-_?,/�)(+,B3<P"0`9;.1,/�-3OFOÂ3<R$3<^7bQY[3<0`*"0C3m5c!$>"^2!$>e5+(70C!S(7>?,8#`!$#B#C3<P">"FÈg�� �"!:#B^<!$57.4#�(V%43<>-%408.f,/.�9E(+,8�".49=(+,8!:%³(+R-Y[3<P">"F"(+,/!$3<>=Y[3<0Æ,/�-.,/�-.43<0C.49Ï*"0C365<.40�,'(+%1,/!$%4# AB.VP-#8.V3<>H3<P"0�9=3cF".1R g

� *-,.*-, 1�>*� 3�� =�> 245 �7 � =�> 245��� �". 9;3OF-.4Rc!:#�(7R$#83k(+F".4�eP)(+,8.�Y[3<0·�"(7>"F"R$!:>"^T#C!:9QP-RS(+,8!:3<>V08.1RS(+,8!:3<>"#1gvi�.��)(³57. >"37,�b7.1,Æ*�.40CY[37089;.4FQ,/�-.9;.1,'(m ,/�-.43<0C.1,/!$%�*"0C3O37Y[#Æ#C�"36A�!:>"^@,/�)(�,�,/�".�IKJMLö9;.1,8�"3OFGY[3<0�#C�"36A�!:>"^V#8!$9QP"R:(+,/!$3<>Q08.1RS(+,8!:3<>-#�!:9;*"R:!$.4#,/08(7%4. !:>"%1R:P"#C!:3<>Q�r(7#¡!:#`*"08365<.1> X b=�)(7>-F�!:>7'hbc>"%'�h¾¿# X 3c3<�8) 'hbO> G � 0 (+>"F X b �dP".4R$R:.40B!:>D�-!:#¡9;3cF".4R $fgi�.D#8!$9=*"RWb�*"08.1#8.4>?,;�".108.E,8�".DY[P">"%f,/!:37>"#2Y[3<0&F".1�)>-!:>"^ ,8�)(+,£(�*-08.4F-!:%³(�,/.D!$#Q!:>"F-.4.4Fè( #C!:9QP-RS(+,8!:3<>08.1RS(+,8!:3<>Èg

� �". (7%f,/P)(+Rc9=(7*"*-!:>"^M37Y",8�".¡#K,'(+,8.4# X .1,ÀAB.4.1>Q,/�".B!:9;*"R:.19=.1>?,'(+,8!:3<>@(7>-FQ#8*�.4%1!$�)%4(+,/!$3<>Q(7PO,/3<9=(+,'(Y[3<0@(�#8!$9QP"R:(+,/!$3<>�0C.4RS(�,/!:37> !:#T,808!$5c!:(7R n�A¡.;#8!$9=*-R$bUP"#8.;(7>?b Sd,/�)(+,k,/(7�7.1#&!$> ,/�".£0C!:^<�?,@(7PO,/3<9=(+,/37>#C,/(+,/.1#4g`Ã)3<0�,/�-.V9=(7*"*-!:>"^QY[0C3<9�,/�-. #�(�"!"ÅE(7P-,83<9E(�,/3<>�,/3G,8�". � Å3�U(+P-,/3<9=(+,83<>h_O,8�"!:#�!$# #8!:9;*"RWbanï<à7Ù�Ö�á)Ö

! OÕ)ï�þ)å�� �"å�� ÞeÞ�� -Õ"ï+þ"å��"Ö+á"Õ?á-å � �-å����-Ö7á-Õeá-å � Ý-àcàcÛ��ðOå *"Ö! OÕ)ï�þ)å�� �"å����?ðOå+*ÆÞ

��! -Õ"ï+þ"å��'�-å��ÏÖ cÕ"ïmþ-å Ö��Oå�� ücüÜeÜcÜeÜ �Oå���î ��å��)ÚOÕ<óÉÖ��-å��·æ ü Ü OÕ-ïmþ-å`î ��å��"ÚOÕ<óÉÖ cÕ-ïmþ-åvæeæ�÷Ü?Ü �Oå���îfÕ-ï�á Ö��Oå��·æ ü Ü cÕ-ï�þ-å`î1Õ-ï�á Ö cÕ-ïmþ"å|æeæcæ�÷Ü?Ü �Oå���î'ó)Ö ��Ö��Oå��·æ ü Ü cÕ-ï�þ-å`î]ó)Ö ��Ö cÕ-ïmþ"å|æeæcæ��+ X +

Page 102: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� �".MF"! `;%4P-R$,ÀbG!$#�#8�"36A�!:>-^V,8�)(+,�,/�-.�%13<080C.4#8*�3<>"F-!:>"^@.f\O.1%4P-,8!:3<>"#`.f\O�"! X !$,�,8�".�#/(79;. ,/08(7%4.1#4g�� �"!$#!:# X .4%³(+P"#8.=37Y�,ÀAB3 08.4(7#83<>-#4gU÷!:0C#C,³_|,/�-.E(7%f,/!$3<>jF)(�,'(d,Àbc*�.4#&37Y�,/�-.=,ÀAB3¬(7P-,83<9E(�,'(H(708.=F"!$Ça.40C.4>?,³_(7%1%43<0CF"!:>"^Q,83Q,/�".@9;3OF-.4R g�� �eP"#4_)AB.k%³(7>">-37,�#8!$9=*"RWbE.1�eP)(+,/.T,8�".k,ÀA¡3;(7%f,/!$3<>"#�!$>H(£#K,/0C3<>"^<RWb=,Àbc*�.4FRS(+>"^<P)(7^7.kR:!:�+.@IÀ#/( X .4R$R:.k3<0('|Ê�gaNO.1%43<>"FÈ_�AB.&%'�-3<#8.V,/3;08.4#C3<R$57.V,8�".V>"3<>"F".f,/.1089;!:>"!$#89Ï37Y�*�3<#C,KÂÀ#C,/(+,/.1#X bE!$>"%4R$P"F"!$>"^2.]\O,80/(2*"(70/(79;.1,8.40C#�!:>;,/�".k(+%1,/!$3<>hg�aM36A ,8�".4#C.T*)(708(79;.1,/.108#�9=(³b;>"37,�9=(+,8%'� X .f,ÀA¡.1.4>,/�-.&(+P-,/3<9=(+,/( �x.7g¿^"gÆ3<>".@(+P-,/3<9=(+,83<>H�)(7#�>"3<>"F-.1,/.1089;!:>"!$#89d_O,8�".@37,/�".10 F"3c.4#�>"37,%$fg

ij.k0C.4#C3<R$57. X 37,8��37Y|,/�".1#8.@*"0C3 X R:.19=#BP"#8!$>"^£(2,/.1%'�">"!$�cP-.&(+R:9;3<#C,¡!:F".1>e,8!:%4(7R�,83Q,/�".k37>".kP"#8.1F X b6¡3<^7F)(7>"365&!:>&,8�".9'|ʬ,/0/(+>"#8R:(+,/3<01gvi�.¡F-.1�)>".�(�>".1A~(7%1,8!:3<>V,Àbc*a.¡,8�)(+,·08.4*-08.4#C.4>?,/#�,8�". (7%f,/!:37>"#·%13<9£Â9;3<>E,/3 X 37,8�H(7P-,83<9E(�,'(-_c(7>"FD,ÀAB3£(7%f,/!:37>D9E(+*"*"!:>-^&Y[P">"%f,/!$3<>"#¡,8�)(+,�9=(7*EY[0C3<9 .³(7%'�d(7PO,/3<9=(+,/37>h¾ #(7%f,/!:37>H,Àbc*�.k,/3G,/�".@%13<9=9;3<>�,Àbc*a.+g�iö!$,/��,8�".@9=.19=3<0KbD.]\"(+9=*"R$.7_-,8�"!:# !$#4nðOÕ?á"Õ?á���"å OÕ)ï�þ"å�� �"å����cÕ"ï7á�×7à?Ù ü×mÙcãOà��Oå @Oà?ðcå �)ï�á�×+à7Ù �ó"å"Ö �"à<Ù"ð @Oà?ðOå �"å"Ö �"à<ÙaÖ<å �ð?ä �'��ï<à7Ù�Ö�á)Ö�aÕ � OÕ"ï+þ"å ÞeÞ� OÕ"ï+þ"å �eÕ"ï7á�×<à<Ù � -Õ"ï+þ"å��'�-å����eÕ)ï+áa×7à<Ù ���Õ �+�Oå�� ÞcÞ����-å����eÕ)ï+á�×<à<Ù � OÕ"ï+þ"å�� �-å����cÕ"ï+áa×7à?Ù�

ðOå *"Ö��Õ � OÕ)ï�þ"å �?ð-å'*�Þ

����Õ � -Õ"ï�þ)å�Õ cÕ"ïmþ-å ücü �?Ó-ô�Ò Õ cÕ"ïmþ-å Ì�ËÜ<×mÙcãOà��Oå�ÙÕaæ � Ü?×6ÙOãOà��Oå�ÙÁÕaæ��ܳó"å"Ö �"à<Ù"ðöÙ�óÈæ � Ümó-å)Ö �"à?Ù-ð ÙëóÈæ �Ü4óOåcÕ?ð ÙÁÕ�æ � ð<ä �'� $�Ü �có�×máOå ÙÁÕaæ � ð<ä��'����Ü+ï7à ��ëÙ�æ � ð<ä �+��$�ܳð?ó-à ��Ù�æ � ð<ä �+�� �ðOå *"Ö��Õ � �-å����?ð-å'*�Þ

� ��Õ �+�-å�� Õ��Oå�� üOü �?Ó"ômÒøÕ��Oå��ÉÌ�ËÜ<×mÙcãOà��Oå�ÙÕaæ � Ü?×6ÙOãOà��Oå�ÙÁÕaæ��ܳó"å"Ö �"à<Ù"ðöÙ�óÈæ � Ümó-å)Ö �"à?Ù-ð ÙëóÈæ �Ü4ä��OðcÕ<áOå�ÙÕaæ � ð<ä �'� �a�37,8!:%1.¡,/�)(�,�,/�". !$>?,/.40C>)(7Rc,/0/(+>"#8!W,/!:37>"#�(70C.�9=(7*"*�.4FQ,/3�45 D�;� �2,/3k!$>"F"!:%4(+,/.`,/�)(�,�,/�".108. !$#�>"3k>".1.4F

,/3U%43<9;*)(70C.;,80/(7%1.4# X .f,ÀA¡.1.4>�,/�".19Ug M>-Y[3<0K,/P">)(�,/.4RWb<_v,/�".=9=.19=3<0Kbt.f\-(79;*"R:.£F"3c.4#&>"37,2�)(³5<.D(+>eb.f\c,8.408>"(7R�(7%f,/!:37>"# A�!$,8� R:3c%³(+R�*)(+0/(79;.1,8.408#1g � (7F� e¸94��52-Å X .4.1>�(7>¬.f\c,/.108>)(+R�(7%1,8!:3<>È_a,/�-.Q9E(+*"*"!:>-^AB3<P"R:Fd�)(³5<. X .4.1>hnðOÕ?á"Õ?á���"å OÕ)ï�þ"å�� �"å����cÕ"ï7á�×7à?Ù ü×mÙcãOà��Oå @Oà?ðcå �)ï�á�×+à7Ù �ó"å"Ö �"à<Ù"ð @Oà?ðOå �"å"Ö �"à<ÙaÖ<å �ä��OðcÕ<áOå @Oà?ðOåîcîeîðOå *"Ö��Õ � �-å����?ð-å'*�Þ

� ��Õ �+�-å�� Õ��Oå�� üOü �?Ó"ômÒøÕ��Oå��ÉÌ�ËÜ<×mÙcãOà��Oå�ÙÕaæ � Ü?×6ÙOãOà��Oå�ÙÁÕaæ��ܳó"å"Ö �"à<Ù"ðöÙ�óÈæ � Ümó-å)Ö �"à?Ù-ð ÙëóÈæ �Ü4ä��OðcÕ<áOå�ÙÕaæ � ܳä��-ðcÕ<áOå�Ù�æ+�+ X Q

Page 103: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

#@!W5<.1>H,8�"!:# 9=(7*"*-!:>"^QY[P">-%1,/!$3<>h_cA¡.@%³(+>U>"36A Y[P"R:RWbE#C*a.1%4!WY�bDA��)(+,�!W, 9=.4(7>"# !$>�IÀ#/( X .4R$R:.TY[3<0¡,ÀAB3(7P-,83<9=(+,'(2,83;�"(657.2(QY[3<0KA�(+08Fd#8!:92P"RS(+,8!:3<>E08.4R:(+,/!$3<>hg

LëY[3<0CA¡(708Fd#8!$9QP"R:(+,/!$3<> X .1,ÀAB.4.1>�,ÀA¡3=(7P-,83<9=(+,'(Q!$# F".1�)>-.4F (+#�Y[37R:R:36A�#1nï<à<ÙaÖ+á-ðOå'*�ÖÁ×cÖ�! �"ð � × � ÞeÞ��Ü��mÕ"ï7á�×<à<Ù � â �7Ö�áOÕ<áOå � æ�×+àcÕ � Ü��mÕ"ï7á�×<à<Ù � â �7Ö�áOÕ<áOå � æë×+àeÕ �Ü��7Ö�áOÕ?áOå � � �7Ö�áOÕ<áOå � � Ý-àeàcÛaæ �Ü��mÕ"ï7á�×<à<Ù � � �mÕ-ï�á�×+à7Ù�æ �Ü��mÕ"ï7á�×<à<Ù � � �mÕ-ï�á�×+à7Ù�æ �Ý-àeàOÛ���"×eÖ ! �"ð � × � Õ7äcá � Õ7äOá � ó-åOÛcÕ?áa×7à<Ù ��Õ � � ��Õ � � üOüÜ<×eÖ ! �-ð � × ���-Ö7á-Õeócá�Õ7äcá � Õ7äcá � ó"åOÛeÕeá�×<à<Ùaæ÷ Üe×eÖ ! �-ð � × ���<áOó-Õ?Ù�Ö�Õ7äcá � Õ7äcá � ó"åOÛeÕeá�×<à<Ù ��Õ � � ��Õ � � æ�� �".DÄK 3S��94 �"Ä �t*"0C.4F"!$%³(+,8.&,/(7�7.1#T!:>d,ÀA¡3H(7PO,/3<9=(+,'(O_�,8�".Q(+%1,/P"(7R�#C!:9QP-RS(+,8!:3<>H08.1RS(+,8!:3<>È_a(+>"F�,/�-.

,ÀAB3;9=(7*"*-!:>"^VY[P">"%1,8!:3<>-# (7>"FH#/(³bc#�,/�"(+,�,ÀAB3;%13<>"F"!W,/!$3<>"#¡�"(657.T,/3G�"37R:Fhn·,8�".k#C,/(70C, (7>"F�#C,8.4*H%437>"F"!WÂ,/!$3<>"#1g�� �".@#C,'(+0C,M%43<>-F"!$,8!:3<>�!$# F".1�)>-.4F (+#M.]\O*a.1%1,/.1Fhnï<à<ÙaÖ+á-ðOå'*�ÖÁ×cÖ�! �"ð � × ���"Ö+á"Õ?ócá¼ÞcÞ

�)Ü � Õ"ï7á�×7à?Ù � â � Ö+áOÕ<áOå � æ�×+àeÕ � Ü � Õ"ï7á�×7à?Ù � â � Ö+áOÕ<áOå � æë×+àeÕ �Ü��7Ö�áOÕ<á-å � � �7Ö+áOÕ<áOå � � Ý"àeàcÛaæ �Ý-àcàcÛ���"×eÖ ! �"ð � × ���"Ö+á-Õeócá Õ7äcá � Õ7äcá � ó"åOÛcÕ?á�×<à<Ù ücüÜ*=ÏÖ G î�Ö G ÞZÖ+á"Õ?óOá�Ö �cà'*Õ<äcá � � Ü1õëä G îñܳä G Þ~Ö7á-Õeócá�Ö'�eà+*Õ7äcá � æ�÷Ü4ó"åOÛeÕeá�×<à<Ù�Ö G ä G ææ?æ�� �"!:#E!:#D*"0C.4%1!:#8.1R$bZ,/�".�F".1�)>-!$,/!$3<>~AB.¬P"#8.�!:> '|Ê 3<0D3<>�*)(+*a.104ntY[3<0D(7R$R�#K,'(70K,D#K,'(+,8.4#�37Y@,/�-.

!:9;*"R$.49;.4>?,'(+,8!:3<>j(7P-,83<9E(�,/3<>h_�,/�".108.H.f\O!:#K,/#£(¬#C,/(70C,£#K,'(+,8.�37Y�,/�".H#C*a.1%4!$�"%³(+,8!:3<>è(7PO,/3<9=(+,/37>j,/�)(�,#/(�,/!:#K�).4# ,8�"[email protected]:(+,/!$3<>hg

� �".V#C,/.1*U%13<>"F"!W,/!$3<>�!:#M(7R$#83£(7#�.f\O*�.4%f,/.4FÈnï<à<ÙaÖ+á-ðOå'*�ÖÁ×cÖ�! �"ð � × ���?ácó"Õ<Ù�ÖÉÞcÞ�)Ü��mÕ"ï7á�×7à?Ù � â �7Ö+áOÕ<áOå � æ�×+àeÕ � Ü��mÕ"ï7á�×7à?Ù � â �7Ö+áOÕ<áOå � æë×+àeÕ �Ü��7Ö�áOÕ<á-å � � �7Ö+áOÕ<áOå � � Ý"àeàcÛaæ �Ü��mÕ"ï7á�×7à?Ù � â �mÕ"ï�á�×+à7Ù·æ Õ)ï+á�×<à<Ù �-Õ � �Ü��mÕ"ï7á�×7à?Ù � â �mÕ"ï�á�×+à7Ù·æ Õ)ï+á�×<à<Ù �-Õ � �Ý-àcàcÛ���"×eÖ ! �"ð � × ���?ácó-Õ?Ù�ÖëÕ7äcá � Õ7äcá � ó"åOÛcÕ?á�×<à<Ù ��Õ � � ��Õ � � üOüÜ*= Ö Õ-ï�á ä�î~Ü7å<Ù)Õ<Ý�Ûeå��aå<Ù-á&�eà+*ÁÕ7äOá � Ö Õ"ï�áhæj÷ܳó"åOÛcÕ?á�×<à<Ù�Ö�ä�æj÷ܳó"åcÕ)ï�þ"Õ?Ý)Ûcå�Õ7äcá � Ö"æ �Ü]õÝ-å?áOÕ î~ï<à?óOó-å)Ö � �9?-å)ï Õ7äcá � Õ7äOá � ó-åOÛcÕ?áa×7à<Ù ��Õ � � ��Õ � � Öñä¼ùfÕ"ï�á�ú Ý-å<áOÕææ�Ã)3<0�(7R$Re!:9;*"R:.19=.1>e,/(+,/!$3<>@(7%f,/!:37>"#��(�!2�_7,/�".108.�.]\O!:#C,8#�(7>Q.]\O.4%4PO,/!:37> �)Å 2(�k37Y",/�-.�#8*�.4%1!$�)%4(+,/!$3<>G(7POÂ

,/379E(+,83<>£#8P"%'�=,/�)(+,4�(�!2;(7>"F �)Å 2(�Q(70C.M%13<080C.4#C*a3<>-F"!:>"^&.f\O.4%1P-,/!$3<>"#1g�� �".�%13<080C.4#C*a3<>-F".4>"%1.T08.1RS(+,8!:3<>!:# ^7!$5<.1> X b�nï<à<ÙaÖ+á-ðOå'*�Öï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ïÏÞeÞ

�)Ü��mÕ"ï7á�×7à?Ù � â �7Ö+áOÕ<áOå � æ�×+àeÕ � Ü��mÕ"ï7á�×7à?Ù � â �7Ö+áOÕ<áOå � æë×+àeÕ �Ü��7Ö�áOÕ<á-å � � �7Ö+áOÕ<áOå � � Ý"àeàcÛaæ �Ü��mÕ"ï7á�×7à?Ù � â �mÕ"ï�á�×+à7Ù·æ Õ)ï+á�×<à<Ù �-Õ � �+ X/.

Page 104: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ü � Õ"ï7á�×7à?Ù � â � Õ"ï�á�×+à7Ù·æ Õ)ï+á�×<à<Ù �-Õ � ��<Ö+áOÕ<áOå � � �<Ö�áOÕ?áOå � �Ü��mÕ"ï7á�×7à?Ù � åD?-å)ï�ä-á�×7à?Ùaæ � Ü��mÕ)ï+áa×7à<Ù � å;?-å"ï+äOáa×7à<ÙÈæ �Ý-àcàcÛ��

�-ï<àeócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï Õ<äcá � Õ7äcá � ó-å-ÛeÕeá�×7à?Ù ��Õ � � ��Õ � � Öñä ÕcÛ �eþ-ÕÝ-å?áOÕ ücüÜ ��Õ � ��Õ � � Ümácó"Õ"ï<å � *Õ<äcá � Ý-å<áOÕhæcæ ü Ü ��Õ � ��Õ � � Ü6ácó"Õ"ï?å � *ÁÕ7äcá � ÕcÛ �cþ-Õhæ?æ÷ Üe×eÖ �'?-å)ï�ä-á�×7à?Ù Õ7äOá � äÝ"å<áOÕ�æ÷ Ümó-å-ÛeÕ?áa×7à?ÙÏÜ+ÛeÕ-Ö�á � * Õ<äcá � Ö�ÕcÛ �eþ"ÕhæÁÜ+ÛeÕ-Ö�á � * Õ7äcá � äÁÝ-å<áOÕÈæ?æ� � �"!:# ^<!$57.4# ,8�".Q,/�"0C.4.Q0C.4�eP"!$08.49;.4>?,8#k37Y�,/�".2#C,/.1*t%43<>"F-!$,/!$3<>hn�,80/(7%1.Q.4�eP)(7R$!$,Àb7_a5+(7R:!$F�.]\-.1%4P-,8!:3<>È_(7>"F�,8�)(+,£,/�".�R:(7#C,£#K,'(+,8.4#£08.1RS(+,8.7g�� �-. ��+¸�Y[P">-%1,/!$3<>è!:#Q,8�".H#C,'(+>"F)(70CF 9=(7*"*"!$>"^�Y[P">-%1,/!$3<>�,/�)(�,(7*"*-R:!:.1# !W,/#��"08#C,k(708^<P-9=.1>e,T3<>?,/3D.f5<.40Kb¬.4R$.49;.4>?,T3+YÆ!$,/# #8.4%13<>"F�(70C^<P"9;.4>?,³gTIÀ> ,8�"!:# %³(7#C.7_ÈAB.G9E(+*,/�-.&(+%1,/!$3<>H9E(+*"*"!:>-^QY[P">"%1,8!:3<>H3<>?,83£,8�".V(7P-,83<9E(�,/3<>D,80/(7%1.7_"A��"!$%'�U!$#�(GR$!:#C,�37Y�(+%1,/!$3<>"#1g

: ¥7? � ���·´ ����© ´k¯D®Ã)083<9ý37P-,Q%4(7#8.D#K,/P"F-!:.4#1_·AB.D�)(³5<.D#C.4.1>è,8�)(+,V,/�".E>".1A *"0C365<.40G9;3cF".4R�Y[3<0VI&%<JÉ(7P-,83<9E(�,'(-_ X (7#C.4F3<>�6¡3<^<F"(7>"365�¾ #@A¡3708��_·!$#&(+F".4�eP)(+,8.=!$>-Y[0/(+#C,/0CP"%1,8P"08.£Y[3<0k.1>)(7%1,8!:>"^d*"08(7%1,8!:%³(+R�*"083c37Y[#@37Y�#C!:9QP-RS(+,8!:3<>08.1RS(+,8!:3<>-# !:>¬IÀ#8( X .4R:R$.7g@ij.£�)(³57.=(+R:#83E#8.4.1>j!$> �¡�)(7*-,8.40 . ,/�"(+,k,/�".GF-.1�)>"!W,/!$3<>"#T�)(³57. X .4.1>�P-#8.1Y[P-RY[3<0�^<.4>".10/(+,8!:>"^E*"083c37Y�,'(+%1,/!$%4#1gk� �".GP"#8.fY[P"R:>-.4#8#k3+Y�,/�"!$#T9=3cF".1RvY[3<0�*"083c37Y[#�#C,/.19=#�Y[083<9�08.1#C,/0C!:%f,/!:>-^>"3<>-F".1,8.4089;!:>-!:#89�,83Q,/�".k(+%1,/!$3<>"#B37Y�(&,/08(7>"#8!W,/!$3<>h_c0/(+,8�".40¡,8�)(7>H(7R$R:36A�!:>-^&!W, (7R$#83Q!$>E,/�". *a3<#K,C #C,'(�,/.7g

IÀ>Q,/�".`Y[P-,/P-08.7_7!$,vA¡3<P-R:F X .¡�".1R:*-Y[P-Rc,83 *"0C3m57.¡,/�-.�#83<P->"F">".1#8#�37Y)*-08365c!:>"^T#C!:9QP-RS(+,8!:3<>@08.1RS(+,8!:3<>-#�!$>IÀ#/( X .1R:R:.+n|#8�"36A�!:>-^ ,/�)(�,�,8�".�#8!$9QP"R:(+,/!$3<>k08.1RS(+,8!:3<>V#C,/(70C,�(7>"FQ#K,/.4*G%13<>"F"!W,/!$3<>"#|!:9;*"R$b ,/0/(+%4.¡!$>"%4R$P"#8!$3<>hg� �"!$#¡!:#¡(29;.1,'(m ,/�-.43<0C.1,/!$%�*-083c37Y g�I , !$#¡R:!$�7.1R$bG,/�"(+,¡,8�".T9=(7*"*"!$>"^VY[P->"%1,8!:3<>EA�!$R:R�>".1.4F�,/3 X . P-#8.4FH!$>,/�-.VF-.1�)>"!W,/!$3<>H37Y�,80/(7%1.@!:>"%1R:P"#C!:3<>hg

+ X �

Page 105: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� � ��� ���� �

� � � � � ��� �����

�H¥6¦ �Hª¬²�®�� ´k² ²Æ´ �·´T­Q² A �� �".108.T(+08.M(+,`R:.4(7#C,ÆY[3<P"0�A¡(³bO#`,/3V.f\c,/.1>"FE,8�"!:#Æ08.1#8.4(708%'�hn�!$9=*-08365c!:>"^kF-bc>)(+9=!$%M!$>?57(+08!S(+>e,ÆF-.1,/.1%1,8!:3<>h_^<.1>".408(+,/!$>"^ X .1,C,/.10�*"0C3O3+Y�,/(7%1,8!:%4#1_�*"083<^70/(79;9=!$>"^G!:>H,/�-.V*-08365<.104_h(+>"FU#C.4R$.4%1,8!:>"^;!:>?5+(70C!S(7>?,/# Y[3<0�P"#C.!:>H*"0C3O3+Y[#4g

�+*0/ *0/ K;� ���2��47� � ��5��� >?; >?5�VV� > �54= �67:=(7<; => 2 5� �".�¢k(7!:�+3<>;F-bc>)(79;!:% !:>?5+(70C!S(7>?,ÆF".f,/.4%f,/3<0B%43<P-R:F X .M!:9;*"0C3m57.4Fh_e!$>=3<0CF".40�,83V�)>-FE9;3<08.�R:.19=9=(7#·Y[370*"0C3O37Y[#�(7>"F&!:>"%108.4(7#8.B�cP-9E(7>&!:>"#C!:^<�?,v08.1^?(70CF"!:>"^M*"0C3<^<0/(+9 X .1�)(³5O!$3<04gvLZ9E(mlC370v*-083 X R$.49ë!$>2F-bc>)(79;!:%!:>?5+(70C!S(7>?,�F".1,8.4%1,8!:3<>¬!$# %'�"3c3<#C!:>"^H(E^70/(79;9E(+0�37YÆ!$>?57(+08!S(+>e,8#�,8�)(+,T!$# P"#C.1Y[P"R�Y[3<0 *"0C3<^<08(79=9;.40C# X PO,F"3c.4#�>"37,�^<.4>".10/(+,8.Q(7>U.f\O%4.1#8#C!$5<.;(79;3<P">?,M37Y�37P-,/*"PO,³g�JT>".&A¡(³bU,83E%'�"3c3<#8.2(=^<08(79;9E(70�AB3<P"R$F X .,/3D,/(7�7. X 3c3<R:.4(7> .]\-*-08.4#C#8!$3<>"#V(7*"*�.³(70C!:>"^E!:> IKJ�L *"0837^<0/(79�%43cF".G(+# ,/.19=*"R:(+,/.1#T!:>U,/�".Q^70/(79;9E(+04gNO!$>"%4.Q,8�".4#C.£,8.49;*"RS(�,/.4#k%13<9;.2Y[083<9�,/�".G#C.49=(7>?,/!$%4#k37Y`,/�".G*-083<^<08(79d_È,/�".fb¬9=(6b X .GR:!:�+.4R$!:.40M,/3 X .P"#C.1Y[P"R�!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,/#1g�Ã)3<0Æ.f\-(79;*"R:.+_e!:>£,/�".�Ê·(�\O3<#B%³(7#C. #K,/P"F-bQ�rNO.4%f,/!:37> �"g . $]_)7 �'��£%4R:37#8.4RWbG08.1#8.19 X R:.1#,/�-.V*-08.4%13<>"F"!W,/!$3<>�Y[3<0�,/�". �( cÄ3T � �(���=,80/(7>-#8!$,8!:3<>Èg

�+*0/ *-, K;� ���2��47� ���2 26� ��; � >*��= �1�A�2�� �3�=(2�� =(245 ;:2 �67Nc,/(+,/!$%=(+>)(7R$bc#C!:#@37Y I&%<J (7P-,/379E(+,/(d%13<P"R$F�^<.1>".408(+,/.=9=3708.£F".1,/(7!:R$.4F�*"083c37Y¡#8%40C!:*-,8#&#C3U,8�)(+,&*"08365<.10%³(+> F"3�9;3<08.@A¡3708�HA�!$,/�-3<P-,T�eP"9=(7> !$>?,/.40K5<.1>e,8!:3<>ÈgkÃ)3<0�.]\-(79=*-R:.7_a!:>U*a.10CY[3<0C9=!$>"^E%4(7#8.Q#C*"R:!W,/#1_�AB.%4P-0808.1>?,/R$bH.]\-(79=!$>".GÄm»D#C,/(+,/.19=.1>?,/#M!:>�,/�".&(7>">-37,'(+,8!:3<>-#�Y[3<0 *)(7!$08.4Fd.f\O.1%4P-,8!:3<>h_ X P-,�A¡.V%43<P-R:FU(7R:#C3R:3c3<�=(+,VÄm»D#C,/(+,/.19=.1>e,8# A�!$,/�-!:>�,/�"[email protected]ÇÈ.1%1,/#M%43cF".k37Y�,/�".V(7PO,/3<9=(+,/37>�!$,/#C.4RWY g

�+*0/ *�� � �26J6��� � >05�J >05 =�� 7 ���2 � 7 � � �5�J 3�VJ 7i�.Q%³(7> Y[P-0C,/�-.40T.]\O,8.4>"Ft3<P-0�,/3c3<R$#�,/3EP"#8.Q,8�".QIÀ#/( X .1R:R:. % � J '�R$3<^<!:%V#Cbc#K,/.49¼(7>"F�,8�".43<0C.49 *"08365<.10) Ê·(7P G . _�#@3<0 ÿHG 0 gDIÀ#8( X .1R:R$.;!$#V(d*"0C3<^<08(79=9=( X R$.Q*"0C3m57.401_�#83dA¡.=%43<P"R$F�P-#8.E!W,/#@*"0C3<^<0/(+9=9;!:>"^ERS(7>OÂ^<P)(+^<.7_ �4'�_4,83MF-.408!W5<. X .1,8,8.40h,/(7%1,8!:%4#1g·Ê�0C.4#8.1>?,/R$b7_�AB.`�)(³5<.�,/�".�IKJ�L�,/0/(+>"#8R:(+,/3<0�,/3�IÀ#/( X .1R:R:.·^<.4>".10/(+,8.,/�-.M*-083c37Y�#8%40C!:*-, P"#8!$>"^ �4'U,/3kF-08!$57. ,/�". *"0C3O3+Ya9=(³b X .�9=3<0C.�*"0C3OF"P-%1,/!W5<.+gÆNO!:>-%4. IÀ#/( X .1R:R:. �"(7#Æ(

+ XD�

Page 106: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

RS(+08^<.10�P"#8.10`%13<9;9QP">"!W,ÀbG(7>"F=(k9=3708. .f\c,8.4>"#C!$5<.�#8.f,B3+YhR:! X 0/(+08!:.1#4_�,/�"!$#`9=(³bQ9=(7�7.�3<P-0`9;.1,8�"3cF"3<R:37^7b(7%1%4.4#C#8! X R:.k,/3£9;3<08.k*�.437*"R:.+g

�+*0/ *�� � >*�I=(7 � >?5�J >?5�VV� > �5.= � � >-=��L�3�=(2 �� =�7� � 7 3�� > � => ; �1��26� ���2�26� �JT>".�37Y ,8�".�#C,/(7^<.4#G!$>�3<P"029=.f,/�"3cF�,/�)(�,G!:>?5<37R$5<.1#G�eP"9E(+>�!:>?,/.10C5<.1>?,/!:37>�!:#Q�)(³5c!:>-^ ,/3¬9=(7>eP)(7R:RWb#8.1R:.1%1,@!:>?5+(70C!S(7>?,/#M,/3�P"#C.G!:>t(D*"0C3O3+Y g@i�.G(70C.G!:> #C.³(70C%'��3+Y`,808P".Q(7>"FtP"#8.fY[P"R�!$>e5+(70C!S(7>?,8#�A��".1>�AB.*�.40CY[37089Ï,/�-!:#M9E(7>eP)(+R�#8.4R$.4%f,/!:37>hg � .108.VA¡.&#8P"^<^7.4#C,T(;A¡(³bd,83E(+P-,/3<9=(+,8.@,8�"!:#M*"0C3O%1.4#8#1g�IÀ>e5+(70C!S(7>?,8#3<P-,8*"P-, X b�F-bc>)(79;!:%k!$>?57(+08!S(+>e,�F".1,8.4%1,8!:3<>d%³(+> X .@%4RS(+#8#8!W�).4Fd(7# Y[3<R$R:36A�#4n= �v08P".;(7>-F�P-#8.1Y[P-R g2� �-.4#8.=(70C.GRS(+,8.40TP"#C.4F�!:> 57.408!W�)%³(�,/!:37>�!$> ,/�".13<08.19¼*"0C3m57.40C#4gG� �".108.£9E(³bX .Q9;3<08.2,8�)(7>¬3<>-.GP"#8.fY[P"R�#8.f,@37Y`!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,/#M,/�)(+,k(708.GP"#C.4Ft!:> 57.40C!$�)%4(+,/!$3<>hgkij.&A�(7>?,�lCP"#K,3<>-.V#CP"%'��#C.1,4g= �v08P".£(+>"Ft>"37,@P"#C.1Y[P"RrgQ� �".4#C.£9E(³b X .GP"#C.1Y[P"R�Y[3<0 37,/�".108#1_ X P-,V(708.G>-37,@P"#8.1Fj(+#kR:.49;9=(7# !$>3<P-0�5<.40C!$�)%4(+,/!$3<>H*"083c37Y g= Ã�(7R$#8.7g� 36AB.15<.104_-,8�"!:#`%4R:(7#8#C!$�)%4(+,/!$3<>£!:#Æ^<.1>".408(7R:RWbGP">"F".1%4!$F)( X R$.7g·i�. .]\-*�.4%f,¡,83&0C.4R$b£37>D(@%43<9 X !:>)(+,8!:3<>

37Yv�eP"9=(7>H%4RS(+#8#8!W�)%³(�,/!:37>�(7>"Fd(7P-,83<9=(+,/!$% !:>?5+(70C!S(7>?,��)RW,/.108!:>-^G(7R:^73<08!W,/�"9;#`,83£%43<9;*a.1>"#/(�,/.7g � P"9=(7>%4R:(7#8#C!$�)%4(+,/!$3<>G!:#�#K,/!$R:R-�eP"9=(7>;!:>?,/.10C57.4>?,/!$3<>h_ X P-,Æ,/�-.M!$>?,/.40K5<.1>e,8!:3<>;!:#�^708.³(�,/R$b208.1F"P"%4.1FE%13<9=*"(708.1F£,83P"#C!:>"^�,/�".`*"0C3m57.40·(7R:3<>-.7_ X .1%³(7P"#C.B,8�".B*-083<^<08(79;9=.10�>"3 R$3<>"^<.10v�"(7#v,83�%13<9;.`P-*&A�!$,8�&,8�".B!$>?57(+08!S(+>e,8#4g

IÀ>Q*"0C3m5c!$>"^�!$>?57(+08!S(+>e,8#v,808P".ÆA�!$,8�&,8�".B*-08365<.104_7,8�".¡9=(7!:>@F"! `;%4P"RW,Àb@!:#�,/�".BF".4*�.4>-F".4>"%1!:.1# X .f,ÀA¡.1.4>F"!WÇÈ.108.4>?,;!:>?5+(70C!S(7>?,/#1gèI ,=%13<P"R$F X .�,/�)(�,=!$>?57(+08!S(+>e,�����!:#G,808P".+_ X P-,;%4(7>">"37, X .H*"08365<.1F A�!W,/�"3<PO,(7>"3+,/�".10¡!:>?5+(70C!S(7>?,��� !$>=,/�-. !:>-F"P"%1,8!$57. (7#C#8P"9;*-,8!:3<>hg·I ,�%437P"R:FE(7R:#C3 X .�,8�)(+,���d!:#ÆYx(7R:#C.7_ X P-,¡�"3<R:F-#,/0CP".���Z!:#T,808P".+g2ij.£#CP"^<^<.1#C,&(7>�(7R:^73<08!W,/�"9 X (7#C.4F�3<>t3<>". X b ��!:>?,'(+>".4>3)��M!$> X5X 0 ,/�)(+,@0C.4R$!:.4# 3<>(70C08!$5c!$>"^£(+, �-\H*�3<!$>e,8#4n

Nc,/(70C,=A�!$,8�ñ#83<9;.�#C.1, 7 �'� 37Y@!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,/#£,/3j�"R$,/.10D(7>-Fñ%'�".4%'�ZY[3<0=,808P-,8�hg �¡�".1%'�~!WY!$>e5+(70C!S(7>?,8#v!$>�7 �'�V�"3<R$F&3<>V,/�".B#C,/(70C,�#C,/(+,/.`37Y",8�".¡(+P-,/3<9=(+,83<>hg��M.19=365<.B(7>?bV!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,/#!$> 7"�'� ,/�)(+,EYx(7!:RrgL�#8#CP"9=. ,8�".¬!:>?5+(70C!S(7>?,/#E!:> 7 �'���"3<R$FñY[3<0D#C3<9=.�#C,'(�,/. �Z!$>ñ,/�".(7PO,/3<9=(+,/37>hgEÃ)3<0V(7R$R�.4>"( X R:.1F�(7%f,/!$3<>"#kY[083<9 �U,/3Q� �]_�*"08365<.;,/�)(�,V,8�".1b��"37R:F¬Y[3<0 ���fg��.49;365<.=(7>?bt!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,/#@!:> 7 �9�¬,8�)(+,@Yx(7!$R g��M.1*a.4(+,V,/�"!$#V*-083c%4.4#C#&A�!W,/�t,/�".;>".1A 7"�'�P">?,8!:R|,/�".Q9;.49 X .108# 3+Y 7"�'�U>"3DR$3<>"^<.10 %'�)(7>-^<.7gkL�,�,/�"!$# �-\�*a3<!$>?,³_a(7R:R�,/�-.Q!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,/#!$> 7 �'�H(70C.k,/08P-.7g

JT>"%4.MA¡.��)(³5<.k(V#8.1,B37Yh,808P".M!:>?5+(70C!S(7>?,/#1_?,/�".fb=%4(7> X .�.4(7#8!$R$bG%'�-.4%'�7.1Fd,83&#C.4. A��-!:%'�D(+08.M>".4.1F".4F,/3£*"0C365<.&(£#C!:9QP-RS(+,8!:3<>D0C.4R:(+,/!$3<> �x3<0�(+>ebD37,/�".10�*"083<*�.40K,Àb($fn

L�#8#8P-9=.Q,8�".G#8!$9QP"RS(�,/!:37>U0C.4RS(�,/!:37>�SVU_� � �CW;�"3<R$F"#4g@L�R:#83H(+#8#8P-9=. 7;�"3<R$F"# Y[3<0 �"g@L�,CÂ,8.49;*-, ,83E*"0C3m57.Q,/�".&#8!$9QP"RS(�,/!:37>d0C.4R:(+,/!$3<>��"37R:F"#�Y[3<0T(=08.³(+%'�)( X R$.2#C,/(+,/. � � Y[0C3<9 � X b#C�"36A�!:>"^Q,8�".T#C,/(7>"F)(+08FDA�!$,8>".4#C#+�¬Y[083<9 �E,83 � �]g���.19=*�3<0/(+08!:RWb£08.19=365<. 3<>".T!$>e5+(70C!S(7>?,Ä=!:> 7 �'�t(7>"F¬,/.1#C,V!$Y�,8�".£#8!$9QP"RS(�,/!:37>�08.1RS(+,8!:3<>�%³(7>t#C,8!:R$R X .G*"08365<.1Fj#C3<9=.1�"36A@gQI YB#83"_*�.40C9E(7>-.4>?,/RWb&0C.49;365<.TÄ�Y[083<9�7 �'��g�L�,8,8.49;*-,�,/�-!:#·0C.49;3657(+RO*"0C3O%1.4#C#�3<>Q.³(+%'�G!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,³g

+ X �

Page 107: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� �".k#8.f,�7 �'�=,8�)(+, 0C.49=(7!:>"#`!:#`,/0CP".7_"#C!:>"%1. AB.T#C,/(70C,8.4FDA�!$,8�H(&,/0CP".T#C.1,³g�I ,�!:# �K9=!$>"!:9=(7R �k!$>E,/�-.#8.1>"#8.£,/�"(+,V>"3H#8P X #C.1,&37YB!$,kA�!:R$R·0C.4#8P-R$,V!:>t(H*"083c37Y _�P"#C!:>"^d(�*"0C3m57.40@A�!$,8�t,8�".£#/(79;.G%³(+*)( X !$R:!$,8!:.1#4g� �".108.@9E(³b X .@(7>d(7RW,/.108>)(+,8!$57.T#8.f,�3+Y�!$>?57(+08!S(+>e,8#¡,/�"(+,�!:#�3+Y�(Q#C9E(7R$R:.10¡#8!��4.+_ X P-, AB.&(+08.k!:>?,8.408.1#C,8.4F!:> 3<>"RWb��)>"F"!$>"^�#8379=.d9=!$>"!:9=(7R�#C.1,4g Ã)P"0K,/�".104_ #8379=.U*"08365<.108#D9=(³b X .�( X R:.H,/3�!:F".1>?,/!$Y�b�A��-!:%'�!:>?5+(70C!S(7>?,/#�AB.40C.&P-#8.4Fd!:>d(G*"0C3O37Y _-#83£,/�".@#8.1%43<>-F (7R$^<3<08!W,/�"9 9=(³b�>"37, X .@>".4%1.4#8#8(70Cb7g

ij.`%437P"R:FV!:9;*"R:.19=.1>?, X 3+,/�&(7R:^<3708!$,8�"9;#È*"0C.4#8.1>?,/.4F2�".40C.BP"#C!:>"^M9;3<08.`(7P-,83<9=(+,/.1FV*-08365c!:>"^M9=.f,/�OÂ3cF"# X P"!:RW, !:>?,83;IÀ#8( X .4R:R$.7g

�H¥�� @ø¶;¯ A�«4ª ��¨4¶;¯� �".=*"P"08*�3<#C.=37Y¡#837Y�,ÀA¡(70C.=5<.108!W�)%³(+,8!:3<>�!:#k,83�.4>-#8P"0C.E*"0C3<^<0/(+9=9;.40C#@(7>"FjP-#8.40C#&,8�)(+,@,/�".;#Cbc#K,/.49;#,/�-.1bdF".157.4R$3<*¬(7>"FU.49;*"R:36b X .4�"(657.Q%4370808.1%1,8R$b<g IÀ>d,/�"!$#M,8�".4#C!:#1_�AB.&,/(7%'�eR:.4Fd,/�".&*"083 X R:.19Ï37Y�57.408!WY�b?Â!:>-^dF-!:#C,808! X P-,/.1Ft3<0@%43<>"%1P"080C.4>?,&#Cbc#C,8.49;#4_�A��-!:%'��(708.£37Y�,8.4>�!:>-�)>-!$,/.G#K,'(+,8.;(7>"F�>"3<>"F".f,/.1089;!:>"!$#C,/!$%7g� �".13<08.19ø*-08365<.108#�%4(7> X .�P-#8.4F;,/3&08.³(+#83<>=#83<P">-F"R$b;( X 3<P-,`,/�-.�%13<080C.4%1,8>".4#C#�37YÈ#8P"%'�D#Kbc#C,/.19=#1gBNOP"%'�9=(7%'�"!:>-.fÂÀ%'�-.4%'�7.1F�*-083c37Y[#T*"0C3m5c!$F".Q9;3<08.2(7#8#CP"0/(7>-%4.£37YÆ%4370808.1%1,8>".4#C#@,8�)(7>¬�)(+>"F¬*"083c37Y[#1_ X P-,k!$>"%4P-0(G%43<#K,�!:>�,/.1089;# 37Y��cP-9E(7>H!$>e,8.408(7%1,8!:3<>hg·� �".@9=.f,/�"3cF"3<R$3<^7b;*"08.1#8.1>e,8.4F !$>D,/�"!$#�,/�".1#8!$#M0C.4F"P-%4.4#�,/�-.�eP"9=(7>è.1Ça3<0C,G0C.4�eP"!$08.4Fè!$>�,/�".�,/�-.43<0C.49 *-08365<.10£Y[37025<.108!$Y�bc!$>"^t#/(+Y[.f,Àb�*"0C3<*a.10C,8!:.4#G3+Y�F-!:#C,808! X P-,/.1F(7R$^<3<08!W,/�"9;#¡9;3cF".4R$.4FDY[3<0C9E(7R$R$b=(7#�I&%<J(7P-,/379E(+,/(-g

JTP"0U9;.1,8�"3cF"3<R:37^7b~!$>?,/.4^70/(+,8.4#H,/.4#K,�.]\O.4%4PO,/!:37> �08P">->"!:>"^~(ZF-!:#C,808! X P-,/.1F (+R:^<3<0C!$,8�"9 A�!W,/��(,/.1#C,G#CP"!$,8.D3<>�(UP">"!:*-083c%4.4#C#83<0� A�!$,8��,/�".13<08.19 *"0C365O!$>"^"g &·\O*"R$3<0/(+,83<0Cbj(7>)(+R$bc#8!$# X (7#C.4F�3<>j#8P"%'�.f\O.1%4P-,8!:3<>"#�!:#�(MAB.4R$RWÂÀ�e>"36A�>2,8.4%'�">-!:�eP".¡Y[3<0 X P-!:R:F-!:>"^�!:>?,8P"!$,8!:3<>V(7>"F2*a.10CY[3<0C9=!$>"^�!:>".]\-*�.4>-#8!$57.�#/(+>"!$,Àb%'�".1%'�c#1g JTP"0�9;.1,/�-3OF"37R:3<^7b=.f\c,8.4>"F"#�,/�-.VP-#8.V37Y·0CP">O ,/!:9;. ,8.4%'�">"!$�eP".4#M!:>�,ÀAB3;A¡(³bO#1g

÷!:0C#C,4_�A¡.�P"#C.H(�F-bc>)(79;!:%E!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,2F".f,/.1%1,/370Q,/3 ^<.1>".408(7R:!��4.D3657.40G3 X #C.40K5<.4FZ.f\O.1%4P-,8!:3<>"#£(+>"F08.1*a370C,MR:3<^7!:%³(+Rh*"0837*a.10C,/!$.4#�,/�)(�, (+08.VR:!:�+.4RWbE,/3 X .k,808P".V37Y�,8�".&*-083<^<08(79dgB� �"!$#M,8.4%'�">-!:�eP".2*-083<*�3<#8.1#*"0C3<*a.10C,8!:.4#V,/�)(�,2AB3<P"R:Fj37,/�".10CA�!$#8.E�"(657.E,/3 X .=#Cbc>?,/�".1#8! �1.4F X b�(d*a.108#837>hgtNOP"%'��*-083<*�.40K,/!:.1#2%4(7>08.f5<.4(7R¡P">-.f\O*a.1%1,8.4F�*"0C3<*a.10C,8!:.4#V37Y�(d*"0837^<0/(79d_�(7>"F�,8�".1b�%³(+> X P-,C,/0C.4#8#2P">"F".108#C,/(7>"F"!$>"^ 9;3<08.£.fYSÂY[.4%f,/!W5<.4RWbj,8�)(7>�%³(+> X .�F"3<>-.D9=.108.1R$b�.f\-(79;!:>"!$>"^ .f\O.1%4P-,8!:3<>�,/08(7%4.1#4gO�U3<#C,£!$9=*�3<0K,'(7>?,/RWb¬Y[3<0Q3<P-09;.1,/�-3OF"37R:3<^7b7_|#8P"%'��*"0C3<*�.40C,8!:.1#&%4(7>�*"0C3m5c!$F".E!$>e5+(70C!S(7>?,8#&(+>"FjR$.49;9E(7#k,8�)(+,&#8!:9;*"R$!$Y�b *-083c37Y[#2(+>"F08.1F"P"%1.V,8�".43<0C.49Ï*-08365c!:>"^;.1Ça3<0C,4g

NO.4%13<>"Fh_+A¡.`R:.f5<.408(7^<.Æ,/�".`.1Ça3<0K,�P-#8.4F&,/3 X P"!:R$F@^<3O3cFk,/.1#C,�#8P"!W,/.4#|,/3M*"0C3OF"P-%4.`#8%40C!:*-,8#vY[370|,8�".43708.49*"0C3m57.40C#4_�A��"!$%'��9=!$0808370@,8�".=Y[37089 37Y�,8�".E#C%408!$*-,/#&Y[3<0&F-08!$5c!$>"^U*"(7!:0C.4F�.]\-.1%4P-,8!:3<>-#4g�� �-.4#8.D,/(7%1,8!:%1#%4379 X !:>-.TA�!$,/��37P"0 �e>"36A�R:.4F-^<.@37Y·*-083c37Y[# 37Y�(7R:RaI&%<JÁ(+P-,/3<9=(+,/(&,/3£*"0C3m5c!$F".k,/�".k*"0C3O3+Y�37P-,/R$!:>".T!$>H(*"0C3m57.401g

ij.d�)(³5<.d!:R$R:P"#K,/08(+,/.1F�,/�".HP"#C.U37YM,/�-.U9;.1,8�"3OF-3<R:3<^+b<_Æ(7>"FZ37Y�,/�".�,/3c3<R$#8.1,G,8�)(+,;#8P-*"*a370C,/#£,/�-.9;.1,/�-3OF"37R:3<^7b7_ X bH9=.4(7>"#�37Y�,/�"0C.4.@%³(7#C.&#K,/P"F-!:.4#1n '|(79;*a370C,³¾¿#�Ê·(m\-37#�*"0C37,/3c%437R _"F"!$#C,808! X P-,/.1FU#K,/0837>"^%³(+%'�"!:>"^;9;.49;3<0Cb7_"(7>"FUÊ�.f,/.108#837>h¾ #�QmÂÀ*-083c%4.4#C#�9QP-,/P"(7Rh.f\O%1R:P"#C!:3<>U(7R:^73<08!W,/�"9dg

IÀ> 3<0CF".40M,/3D.F`=%1!:.1>e,8R$bd!:9;*"R$.49;.4>?,M3<P"0M9=.f,/�"3cF"3<R$3<^7b<_�!W,�A¡(7# >-.4%4.1#8#8(70CbU,/3D.]\O,8.4>"F ,8�".&,8�"08.1.,/3c3<R$#M.19=*-R:36b<.1Fhg ij.&9=3cF"!$�".4FH,/�".&IKJML�NO!:9QP-RS(+,83<0�,/3E(7R:R$3mA�Y[3<0M#8!:92P"RS(+,8!:3<>�3+Y�#83<9;.V�cP"(7>?,/!$�".4F.f\O*"0C.4#C#8!:37>"#4_ (+>"F #C3�,8�)(+,£!$,8#£#8.49=(7>?,/!$%4#£9=(+,/%'�".1FZ,8�)(+,;37YM,/�".H,/3c3<R$#2,/�)(�,;,80/(7>-#8RS(�,/.�IKJML�!:>?,83*"0C3m57.40�RS(7>"^7P)(7^<.1#4g�i�.VY[3<0C9E(+R:! �1.4F�,/�-.&%13<080C.4%1,8>".4#C#T*"0C3<*a.10C,8!:.4#M37Y�FObO>"(79=!$%@!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,�F-.1,/.1%1,8!:3<>h_(7>"Fj9=3cF"!$�".4Ft,/�".E¢k(7!:�+3<>�,83O3<R�,83�9=(7�7.=!$,&9=3<0C.=#C%³(7R:( X R$.;5c!S(H,ÀA¡3�3<*-,/!$9=!��³(+,8!:3<>-#4g '|(7#K,/R$b7_�AB.F".f5<.4R$3<*�.4F (è>".fAý*"083657.40�9;3cF".4R Y[370dI&%7J (7P-,83<9E(�,'(�!:>ö,/�-.�IÀ#8( X .1R:R$. % � J-'#Cbc#C,8.49 X (7#C.4F�3<>6¡3<^7F)(7>"365�¾ #MA¡3708��A�!$,8�4'|Ê�(7>"FU*"083657.4F ,/�-.&#C3<P">"F">-.4#8# 37Y�3<P"0M!:>?5+(70C!S(7>?,�*"0C3m5c!$>"^E9;.1,8�"3OF-3<R:3<^+b<g� �".V*"083657.40�9=3cF".1RÈYx(7%4!$R:!W,'(+,8.4#¡^7.4>".10/(+,8!:3<>H37Y�*"083c37Yv,'(7%f,/!$%4#�!:>�3<P-0M9;.1,8�"3cF"3<R:37^7b<g

+ X��

Page 108: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

+ X<ÿ

Page 109: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� � � � � � ��� �

� � � � � � � ��� � ��� ��� ��� � ��� ��� � � � � � ��� ���

� � ��� ��� � ��� �

� �".�Y[3<R$R:36A�!:>"^U!:#QIÀ#8( X .4R:R$.D%43cF".�#C�"36A�!:>"^¬,/�"(+,£!:>�,8�".�IÀ#/( X .4R$R:.D*-08365<.10;9;3cF".4Rr_�3<P"0Q9;.1,8�"3OF�Y[370*"0C3m5c!$>"^k!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,/#�!$#�#837P">"Fhg·i�. #8�-3mA ,/�)(�,�*"08365c!:>-^T,/�". #K,'(70K,�%43<>-F"!$,8!:3<>G(+>"FG,/�". #K,/.4*£%13<>"F"!W,/!:37>Y[3<0D!$>?57(+08!S(+>e,8#4_@Ä �'���<¹�Ä � �92 !2(�<¹D2�(7>"F�Ä �'�(�?¹�Ä � �'2 2O¹�� �� jY[3<0D(7>ö(7P-,83<9E(�,/3<>ñ!$#D#8P�`=%1!:.1>e,�,83*"0C3m57.k!:>?5+(708!:(7>"%1.@�x(7#�F".f�)>".4FH!$>EIÀ#/( X .1R:R:. $fg�IÀ>?5+(70C!S(7>"%1.T!:#BF".1�">".4F�Y[3<0¡(2*"08.1F"!:%4(+,/. X bD#/(³bc!:>-^2,/�)(�,,/�-.V*-08.4F-!:%³(�,/.@�"3<R$F"# 3<>d(7R:RÈ08.³(+%'�)( X R$.V#K,'(+,8.4#1g`L�R:3<>-^£,8�".kA�(³b7_"A¡.VF".1�">".2(QY[.fA �".1R:*�.40�R:.19=9=(7#4gï<à<ÙaÖ+á-ðOå'*�Ö×mÙOã"Õ?óa×7Õ<Ù-á&�"Ö+á-Õeócá½ÞcÞ��|ù7Ü��mÕ-ï�á�×+à7Ù�â��7Ö�áOÕ<áOåÈæ"×+àcÕÆâ �7Ö�á-Õ<áOå ��Ý-àeàcÛ)ú�� Ý-àeàcÛ��

�"×mÙ-ã-Õeó�×7Õ?ÙOá)�-Ö+á"Õ?óOá�Õ7äcá > ü-ü=ÉÖ�áOÕ<á-åýî~ÜeÖ�áOÕ?áOå¼Þ~ÜcÖ7á-Õ?óOá�Ö'�eà'*ÁÕ7äcáhæ�� � >�Ö�á-Õ<áOåhæ+�ï<à<ÙaÖ+á-ðOå'*�Ö×mÙOã"Õ?óa×7Õ<Ù-á&�?ácó-Õ?Ù�Ö ÞcÞ��|ù7Ü � Õ-ï�á�×+à7Ù�â � Ö�áOÕ<áOåÈæ"×+àcÕÆâ � Ö�á-Õ<áOå ��Ý-àeàcÛ)ú�� Ý-àeàcÛ��

�"×mÙ-ã-Õeó�×7Õ?ÙOá)�<ácó"Õ<ÙaÖ Õ7äcá > ü-ü=ÉÖ�áOÕ<á-å�Õ"ï�á�îÜ?ܳó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)ÛeåÕ7äcá Ö�áOÕ<áOå�æj÷Ü3>�Ö�áOÕ?áOåhæ�÷Ü�å?Ù"Õ?Ý)Ûeå���å?ÙOá&�cà'*Õ<äcáøÖ+áOÕ<áOå Õ-ï�áÈææ�� �>�Ümå'*�*Oå"ï7á�Ö'�eà'*ÁÕ7äcá Ö�áOÕ<áOå Õ-ï+áÈæ+�

áeþ"åOà?ó"å��øå;?-å)ï�äOáa×7à?Ù � á"å �BÞÓ?ô1ô�� � Ò7ô Õ G Þ ��×eÖ �'?"å"ï�ä-á�×<à<Ù Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó+Ñ'Ì?Ð Ö�ÕcÛ �cþ-Õ(�Õ7ÙOðÁÕ)í�Þ�� å?Ù"Õ?Ý)Ûeå���å?ÙOá&�cà'* Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó�Ñ'Ì?нÜ7Û?Õ-Ö�á � *�Ó �"Ñ/Ì � Ó+Ñ/Ì?Ð�Ö�ÕcÛ �eþ-Õ�æ Õ-ï�á�Ömþ"à���Ö ��×eÖ �9?-å)ï�äOáa×7à?Ù Ó �"Ñ/Ì � Ó+Ñ/Ì?Ð�ÖøÜ6Õ-ï�á���ÕcÛ �eþ"Õhæ+�Õ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ ×cÖ �9?-å"ï+äOáa×7à<Ù��?ð-å'*����cóOå��ÈÖ�æðOà7Ù-åáeþ"åOà?ó"å��øÛcÕ"Ö+á � * � á-å �`Þ�eÛeÕ-Ö�á � *Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó�Ñ'Ì?Ð�Ö�ÜmÕ"ï�á���ÕOÛ �eþ-Õhæ üå'*+*-å"ï7á�Ö �cà'*öÓ �"Ñ'Ì � Ó+Ñ'Ì?Ð Ü7Û?Õ-Ö�á � *�Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó�Ñ'Ì?Ð�Ö ÕcÛ �eþ-Õhæ�Õ"ï�á��Õ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�ÛcÕ"Ö7á � *&�?ð-å'*)æðOà7Ù-åáeþ"åOà?ó"å���ó"åcÕ)ï�þ"Õ?Ý)Ûcå � á"å �BÞ�Èù��

+ XHG

Page 110: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

ó-åOÕ"ï+þ"Õ<Ý�Ûeå�Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó+Ñ'Ì?Ð Ö��å<Ù)Õ<Ý�Ûeå��aå<Ù-á&�eà+* Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó+Ñ'Ì?Ð�Ö Õ-ï�á�Cú ü �ó-åOÕ"ï+þ"Õ<Ý�Ûeå�Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó+Ñ'Ì?Ð Ü+å'*+*-å"ï7á�Ö �cà'*�Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó�Ñ'Ì?Ð�Ö Õ-ï�áhæ+�Õ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�ó"åcÕ)ï�þ"Õ?Ý)Ûcå��?ð-å'*�æ

��Í+Ì)Ì)Ë �Õ"ÖeÖmä ��åÕ G Þ �7õ�Ö G î �D? Ü6ó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)Ûeå��a×+áeþëÓ �"Ñ'Ì � Ó�Ñ'Ì?Ð�Ö�Ö G æ+�Õ7ÙOð�Õ)í�Þ �"å<Ù"Õ?Ý)Ûcå���å?ÙOá)�eà'*�Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó�Ñ'Ì?Ð�Ö Õ-ï+á(�ðcå'*�Ö Gèücü � � � ��� Ö G î �D? Ü6ó-åOÕ"ï+þ"Õ<Ý�Ûeå��a×�ácþ Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó+Ñ'Ì?Ð ÖÖ G æ+�þ"Õ<ãOåëá G Þ�� �D?ÉÜ�ó-åOÕ"ï+þ"Õ<Ý�Ûeå��a×�ácþ Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó+Ñ'Ì?Ð�ÖÖ G æ+�Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡ÞèÖ G �<ðcå *�Õ G åD?a×eÖ7á-å<Ùaï<å � à��aå)æÕ ���"Û Ü³óeä"Û?å�åD?a×eÖ7á-å<Ùaï<å � à��aå)æÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ�Õ G æðOà7Ù-åþ"Õ<ãOåëá�í�Þ��+õ ä¡î�ó"åcÕ)ï�þ"Õ?Ý)Ûcå��a×+áeþëÓ �"Ñ'Ì � Ó�Ñ'Ì?Ð�Ö�Ö G ä �Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ¬á G æðOà7Ù-åðcå'*�ÕcÛ �eþ-Õ üOü � ��� ����ä î�ó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)Ûeå��a×+áeþ Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó+Ñ'Ì?Ð ÖÖ G ä(�þ"Õ<ãOåëá��BÞ��eó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)Ûeå��a×+áeþ Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó+Ñ'Ì?Ð ÖÖ G ÕOÛ �eþ-Õ(�Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡ÞjÕ-Û �cþ)Õ��eðOå'* á�ícæðOà7Ù-åþ"Õ<ãOåÕ �BÞ��OÖ G Þ Ö7á-Õeócá�Ö'�eà+*öÓ �"Ñ'Ì � Ó�Ñ'Ì?Ð �Õ7ÙOðÁÕ��BÞ���×cÖ �'?"å"ï+äOá�×<à<Ù Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó�Ñ'Ì?Ð Ö G ÕcÛ �eþ-Õ(�Õ7ÙOðÁÕ���Þ��OÛ?Õ-Ö+á � *�Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó+Ñ'Ì?Ð Ö G ÕcÛ �eþ-Õ ü Ö)�Õ ���"Û Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá�á���æÕ ���"Û Ü?ÖO× � �)�cÕOÛcÛ�Õ?ðeðBÞ�ó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)Ûeå��a×+áeþ)�eðOå+*�æðOà7Ù-åÖ�þ-à����+õ�Ö G î �D?ÉÜ�ó-åOÕ"ï+þ"Õ<Ý�Ûeå��a×�ácþ Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó+Ñ'Ì?Ð Ü�å+*+*-å"ï+á�Ö �cà'* Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó+Ñ'Ì?Ð ÖëÕ-ï�áhæ Ö G æ+���Í+Ì)Ì)ˠܳóeä"Û?å�å5?<>)æ��Ö�þ-à����eó"åcÕ)ï�þ"Õ?Ý)Ûcå��a×+áeþ Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó�Ñ'Ì?Ð Ü+å'*�*Oå"ï7á�Ö'�eà'*�Ó �"Ñ'Ì � Ó�Ñ'Ì?Ð�Ö Õ-ï+áÈæ Ö G ÜmÕ-ï+á���ÕcÛ �eþ-Õhæ+�Õ ���"Û Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá�á��ÁÕ)íeæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ�ó"åcÕ)ï�þ"Õ?Ý)Ûcå��a×+áeþ��?ðOå+*�æðOà7Ù-å

� åeð� å?ðáeþ"åOà?ó"å��øå;?-å)ï�äOáa×7à?Ù � á"å ���7Ý"Õ)ï��BÞ�"×eÖ �'?"å"ï�ä-á�×<à<Ù�Õ7äOá Ö G ÜmÕ-ï�á���ÕcÛ �eþ"Õ�æ�� � ×eÖ �9?-å)ï�äOáa×7à?Ù�Õ7äcáøÖ G ÕcÛ �eþ-Õ�Õ ���"Û �Ü+Õ7äcáOà�æðOà7Ù-åáeþ"åOà?ó"å��Ï×�ÙOã-Õeó�×<Õ<ÙOá8> ��ÞÓ?ôfô�� � Ò+ô � G Þ �a×mÙOã"Õ?óa×7Õ<Ù-á&�"Ö+á-Õeócá Õ7äcá > �Õ7ÙOð��aí�Þ �a×mÙOã"Õ?óa×7Õ<Ù-á&�?ácó-Õ?Ù�ÖëÕ7äcá > �Õ7ÙOð����BÞ �-Ö G ÞñÜ?Ö7á-Õ?óOá�Ö'�eà'*ÁÕ7äcáhæ+�Ömþ-à���Ö

�"×cÖ �9?-å"ï+äOáa×7à<Ù Õ7äcá�Ö G ÕcÛ �cþ-Õ � � > Ü7Û?Õ-Ö�á � * Õ7äcá�Ö G ÕcÛ �cþ-Õhæ+���Í+Ì)Ì)Ë Üe×6ÙOð<ä�ï�á ÕcÛ �cþ-Õaæþ"Õ<ãOå *�í�Þ �'>�Ö G ���Í+Ì)Ì)Ë �þ"Õ<ãOå *�í��)í·Þ � =ÉÖ�áOÕ<á-å�î ÜeÖ�áOÕ<áOå¼Þ~Ö7á-Õeócá�Ö'�eà+*�Õ7äcá � � >ÁÖ�áOÕ?áOåhæ+�

� Ü?×6Ù�Ö7å<óeá � G â Öc× � ��ÕeðeðBÞ ×mÙ-ã-Õeó�×7Õ?ÙOá)�-Ö+á"Õ?óOá&�?ð-å'*Èæ

+5+ X

Page 111: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ö�þ-à�� ���)á?þ-å-Öc×eÖ�� � Ü?×6Ù�Ö7å<óeá�*aí��)í|âZÖc× ����Õ?ðcð¡Þ ����æ

� å?ð� �?Ó"ômÒ @�×7ÛÖ�þ-à�� ��� �?Ó"ômÒ � � Ü<Öc× � ��ÕeðeðBÞ�ÛeÕ)Ö+á � * �eðOå+* *�íeæ

%� �?Ó"ômÒ cà<Ù�ÖÖ�þ-à�� ��� �?Ó"ômÒ �

��Í+Ì)Ì)Ë Ü?Ö7Õ *cå�æÕ"ÖeÖmä ��å�Õ G Þ ��×eÖ �'?"å"ï�ä-á�×<à<Ù�Õ7äOá Ö G Ü6Õ'� ��Û"×?Ö�á �Èæ+�Ö�þ-à����9> Ü7Û?Õ-Ö�á � * Õ7äcá�Ö G ÜmÕ'� ��Û-×?Ö�á&�Èæeæ����Í+Ì)Ì)Ë �þ"Õ<ãOå Õ)í�Þ �-å<Ù"Õ?Ý)Ûcå���å?ÙOá)�eà'*�Õ7äcá Ü+ÛeÕ-Ö�á � * Õ<äcá�Ö G Û-×?Ö�á&�ÈæöÕ'� �Õ7Ù-ðÁÕ �BÞ ��×eÖ �9?-å)ï�äOáa×7à?Ù Õ7äcá Ö G Û-×eÖ�á �(�Õ ���"Û Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá�Õ G æÕ ���"Û ÜmÕ<äcáOàaæðOà7Ù-åþ"Õ<ãOå *��BÞ��'>�Ü+ÛeÕ-Ö�á � * Õ<äcá Ö G Û-×?Ö�á&�Èæ+�Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ cà7Ù�ÖëÕ ��æðOà7Ù-åþ"Õ<ãOå * �BÞ��?ó-åOÕ"ï+þ"Õ<Ý�Ûeå�Õ<äcá Ü+Û?Õ-Ö+á � * Õ7äcá Ö G Û"×?Ö�á �Èæ+�Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ�ó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)Ûeå �?ð-å'*aæÕ ���"Û Ü³óeä"Û?å�å5?<>�â�ó?ä"ÛeåÁå5?)>Oæ

��Í+Ì)Ì)Ë �Ömþ"à�� �?ó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)Ûeå��a×+áeþ Õ<äcáÏÜ7Û?Õ-Ö�á � * Õ7äcáøÖ G Û-×eÖ�á �Èæ Ö G Û-×?Ö�á&�(�Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�ó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)Ûeå��a×+áeþ)�eðOå+*aæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ ���Õ)í�Õ ��æðcà<Ù-å� åeðþ"Õ<ãOå * ��Þ��?ó-åOÕ"ï+þ"Õ<Ý�Ûeå�Õ<äcá Ü+Û?Õ-Ö+á � * Õ7äcá Ö G Ü�Õ'� � Û-×eÖ�á �Èæeæ �Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ�ó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)Ûeå �?ð-å'*aæÕ ���"Û Ü³óeä"Û?å�å5?<>�â�ó?ä"ÛeåÁå5?)>Oæ

��Í+Ì)Ì)Ë �Ömþ"à�� �?ó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)Ûeå��a×+áeþ Õ<äcáÜmå+*+*Oå)ï+á�Ö �eà+*�Õ7äcá Ü+ÛeÕ-Ö�á � * Õ<äcá Ö G Û-×?Ö�á&�Èæ Õ'�)æÖ G Ü6Õ'� � Û-×?Ö�á �hæ+�Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�ó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)Ûeå��a×+áeþ)�eðOå+*aæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ ���Õ)í�Õ ��æðcà<Ù-å� åeðþ"Õ<ãOå *���Þ������ñÖ+áOÕ<áOå Õ-ï�áBîù)�8ó-åOÕ"ï+þ"Õ<Ý�Ûeå�Õ<äcáøÖ+áOÕ<áOåö÷

>Ö+áOÕ<áOåö÷Ïå?Ù"Õ<Ý�Ûeå���å<Ù-á&�cà'*ÁÕ<äcáøÖ+áOÕ<áOå Õ-ï�á � úü � >�Ü�å+*+*-å"ï+á�Ö �cà'*Õ7äOáøÖ�á-Õ<áOå Õ-ï�á�æ+�Õ ���"Û Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá �aícæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ ×�ÙOã"Õ?ó�×<Õ<Ù-á&�<áOó-Õ?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*aæðOà7Ù-åÖ�þ-à�� ���)á?þ-å-Öc×eÖ��Õ ���"Û ÜmÕ<äcáOàaæÕ ���"Û Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá *�� * � *��ÁÕ)íeæÕ ���"Û ÜmÕ<äcáOà�æ Ü�� ß"àOà -åOÕ<þÆâ�Û?å<á �6ÖÖ<åeå�Ö<à���åäcÙÈ×�*�×cï<Õeá�×7à?Ù�� �cæ

+5+5+

Page 112: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

ðOà7Ù-å� åeð� åeð

%� å?ðáeþ"åOà?ó"å��Ï×�ÙOã-Õeó�×<Õ<ÙOá8>-í�ÞÓ?ôfô�� � Ò+ô � G Þ �a×mÙOã"Õ?óa×7Õ<Ù-á&�"Ö+á-Õeócá Õ7äcá > �Õ7ÙOð��aí�Þ �a×mÙOã"Õ?óa×7Õ<Ù-á&�?ácó-Õ?Ù�ÖëÕ7äcá > �Õ7ÙOð����BÞ �-Ö G ÞñÜ?Ö7á-Õ?óOá�Ö'�eà'*ÁÕ7äcáhæ+�Õ7ÙOð�� �BÞ �a×eÖ �9?-å)ï�äOáa×7à?Ù�Õ7äcá�Ö G ÕcÛ �eþ-Õ(�Ömþ-à���Ö

�;> Ü7Û?Õ-Ö�á � * Õ7äcá Ö G ÕcÛ �cþ-Õhæ+�Õ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ ×�ÙOã"Õ?ó�×<Õ<Ù-á)> � � G �aí ��� � ��æðOà7Ù-å

áeþ"åOà?ó"å��Ï×�ÙOã-Õeó�×<Õ<ÙOá8>|ÞÓ?ôfô�� � Ò+ô � G Þ �a×mÙOã"Õ?óa×7Õ<Ù-á&�"Ö+á-Õeócá Õ7äcá > �Õ7ÙOð��aí�Þ �a×mÙOã"Õ?óa×7Õ<Ù-á&�?ácó-Õ?Ù�ÖëÕ7äcá > �Ömþ-à���Ö �OÎKÐ���Ó"Í7ÎKÓ)Ð|Ñ�Õ<äcá >&�Õ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ ×�ÙOã"Õ?ó�×<Õ<Ù-á&�?ð-å'*�æÕ ���"Û �Ü+Õ7äcáOà�æ��Í+Ì)Ì)Ë �*)×3? ÖÖ�þ-à����?ó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)ÛeåÕ7äcá Ö ü � > Ö �Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ�ó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)Ûeå �?ð-å'*aæ��Í+Ì)Ì)Ë �Õ"ÖeÖmä ��å�Õ G Þ �7õ Ö G î �D? Ümó-åcÕ)ï�þ)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��È×�áeþ�Õ7äcá Ö�Ö G æ+�Ö�þ-à�� ���)á?þ-å-Öc×eÖ����Í+Ì)Ì)Ë �ðcå'*�Ö Gèücü � � � ��� Ö G î �D? Ü6ó-åOÕ"ï+þ"Õ<Ý�Ûeå��a×�ácþ Õ7äOá Ö�Ö G æ+�þ"Õ<ãOåëá G Þ�� �D?ÉÜ�ó-åOÕ"ï+þ"Õ<Ý�Ûeå��a×�ácþ Õ7äOá Ö�Ö G æ+�Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡ÞèÖ G �<ðcå *�Õ G åD?a×eÖ7á-å<Ùaï<å � à��aå)æÕ ���"Û Ü³óeä"Û?å�åD?a×eÖ7á-å<Ùaï<å � à��aå)æÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ�Õ G æðOà7Ù-åþ"Õ<ãOåëá�í�Þ��+õ ä¡î�ó"åcÕ)ï�þ"Õ?Ý)Ûcå��a×+áeþ�Õ7äcá Ö�Ö G ä�Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ¬á G æðOà7Ù-åðcå'*�ÕcÛ �eþ-Õ üOü � ��� ����ä î�ó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)Ûeå��a×+áeþ�Õ7äOá Ö�Ö G ä(�þ"Õ<ãOå *�í�Þ��eó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)Ûeå��a×+áeþ�Õ7äOá ÖÖ G ÕcÛ �eþ-Õ�Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡ÞjÕ-Û �cþ)Õ��eðOå'* á�ícæðOà7Ù-åþ"Õ<ãOå *��BÞ��OÖ G Þ Ö7á-Õeócá�Ö'�eà+*Õ7äcá(�Õ7ÙOð * �BÞ���×cÖ �'?"å"ï+äOá�×<à<Ù�Õ<äcá�Ö G ÕcÛ �eþ"Õ��Õ7ÙOð * ��Þ��OÛ?Õ-Ö+á � * Õ7äcáøÖ G ÕOÛ �eþ-Õ ü Ö&�Õ ���"Û Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá *�ícæÕ ���"Û Ü?ÖO× � �)�cÕOÛcÛ�Õ?ðeðBÞ�ó"åcÕ"ï+þ"Õ?Ý)Ûeå��a×+áeþ)�eðOå+*�æðOà7Ù-åÖ�þ-à����9>�Ö��Õ ���"Û Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá * �ÈæÕ ���"Û ÜmÕ<äcáOàaæ

+5+!Q

Page 113: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Õ ���"Û Ü³óeä"Û?å�×mÙ-ã-Õeó�×7Õ?ÙOá8>-í?æÕ ���"Û Ü?ÖO× � �)�cÕOÛcÛ�Õ?ðeðBÞ *�� * � * ��� G �aícæðOà7Ù-å� åeð� åeð

� å?ð

+5+ .

Page 114: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

+5+��

Page 115: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� � � � � � ��� �

� � � � � � � � � � � � ��������� ��� � ��������� � ��� � �� � ��� ��� � ��� �

� �".HY[3<R:R$36A�!:>"^ !$#Q,/�".U(7P-,83<9=(+,/!$%³(7R$R$bt^<.1>".408(+,/.1F~*"0C3O37Y�3<P-,8R:!$>".�(7>"Fè,'(+%1,/!$%4#GY[3<0Q,8�".U#C!:9QP-RS(+,8!:3<>08.1RS(+,8!:3<>�*-083c37Y|Y[083<9�,8�".��(�cº��������&,/3 -º �� ;(7PO,/3<9=(+,/37>�!:>�,/�".VÊ�(�\O3<#�%4(7#8.@#K,/P"F-b7gÜ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �-æÜ � � � � × �)ä)ÛeÕeá�×<à<Ù *?ó-à���ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í~ácà cà7Ù�Ö �OæÜ � � � �eæáeþ-åeà<ó��ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ü ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � cà<Ù�Ö�ÞðOÕ?á"Õ?á���"åì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö'�eÕ"ï7á�×<à<Ù ü×mÙ�×má @Oà?ðcåÁÚOÕcÛ7ä-å#�

*OÕ"×7Û @Oà?ðcå/�ðOå-ïc×�ðcå @Oà?ðcåÁÚOÕcÛ7ä-å#�ð?ä �'��ï<à7Ù�Ö�á)Ö��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í ÞeÞ��Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í��cÕ"ï+áa×7à?Ù � ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �cÕ"ï+áa×7à?Ù��aÕ � Oà<ÙaÖÉÞeÞ�� Oà?Ù�Ö'�eÕ"ï7á�×<à<Ù � ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö �cÕ"ï7á�×7à?Ù��!Oì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<Ù�Ö�ÞeÞ��-ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å � -à<Ù�Ö'�-Ö7á-Õ?á"å � Ý-àeàOÛ �

ðOå *"Ö��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �?ðOå+*ÆÞ

����Õ �-ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Õeì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í üOü �?Ó-ô�ÒøÕeì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í ÌaËÜ7×6Ùa×má ×�ãÈæ � Ü<×6Ùa×má ×�ãÈæ �Ü *cÕ)×7Û�×"æ � Ü�*OÕ"×7ÛÁ×"æ �Ü6ðOå-ïc×�ðcåø×ñãhæ � Ümðcå"ïc×�ðcåø×�ãhæ��Ü �aÕ �"å<ß"Õ-ÛcÛcà?á Ý�æ � ð<ä �'����ÜmÕ?Ý�Ö7á-Õ)×�Ù�×ñßhæ � ð<ä��'��$�ÜmÕ)ÖcÖ-×�ØeÙ-Ú-Õ-Û�Ýëãhæ � ð<ä��'��$�Ü4ãOà?áOå ×ñÝhæ � ð<ä �'� $�Ü<×�ÙOá"å?óeÙ)ÕOÛ��-å"ï-×+ð-å�Ýhæ � ð<ä �'�� �ðOå *"Ö��Õ � Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*�Þ

����Õ � -à<Ù�Ö Õ cà7Ù�Ö ücü �?Ó"ômÒøÕ cà<Ù�Ö�ÌaËÜ7×6Ùa×má ×�ãÈæ � Ü<×6Ùa×má ×�ãÈæ �Ü *cÕ)×7Û�×"æ � Ü�*OÕ"×7ÛÁ×"æ �

+5+ �

Page 116: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ü6ðOå-ïc×�ðcåø×ñãhæ � Ümðcå"ïc×�ðcåø×�ãhæ��Ü7ï+þ"àOà"Ö<åeÚ-Õ-ÛöãÈæ � ð<ä��'����ðOå *"Ö!Oì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<Ù�Ö'�?ð-å'*BÞ

��!Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖÁÖ<ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö ücü ÜOÜcÜOÜcÜcÜOÜ cà7Ù�Ö·î�×�Ùa×�áa×7Õeá-åeð Ö cà7Ù�Ö�æ üÜ6ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íaî+×mÙa×+á�×<Õ?á-åcð�Ö<ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�íOæcæ��ÏÜOÜ cà7Ù�Ö·î �-ó-à �"à"Ö?åeð Ö cà7Ù�ÖÈæ üÜ6ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íaî �Oó-à �"à)Ö<åeð Ö7ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�ícæOæcæ���ÜcÜ cà7Ù�Ö·îfð-å"ï-×+ðOåcð Ö cà<Ù�Ö�æ üÜ6ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íaî4ðOå"ï-×+ð-åeð�Ö<ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íOæcæOæ��ÉÜcÜ cà7Ù�Ö·î *cÕ"×<Û?å?ðÏÖ Oà7Ù�Ö�æ üÜ6ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íaî *cÕ"×7Û?åeðÏÖ7ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í-æcæcæ��ÉÜA=Áã¡ÞeÞ�Ú-ÕcÛ+ä-å îñÜeܳõ Ý�ÞeÞ�ß-ÕcÛeÛeà<á î~ÜeÜ1ÝêÉÜ�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî�Ö�ä�ïOï<åOåeðOåcð�Ö<ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�íOæcæ���ÜcÜ?ÖmäeÝ�Ümì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íÈî'ãOÕcÛ�Ö7ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íeæ Ý�æ üÜ6å��-Ý-åeð�ã|æeæcæeæ � � Ü1ã ê Ü�Oà7Ù�Ö�î6ïmþ-à-Ö<å7Ù Ö cà<Ù�ÖÈæOæcæOæcæ��ÉÜA=Áã�ÞeÞ�ÚOÕOÛ+ä-å½î~ÜeÜ4ãêÉÜ cà7Ù�Ö�îmïmþ"à-Ö7å7ÙÉÖ Oà7Ù�Öhæeæ � � Ü4õ Ý�ÞeÞ�ß-ÕcÛeÛ?à?á î~ÜeÜ1Ýëê Ümì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhîmÖ�äaïcï<åOåeð-åeðÖ<ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í-æOæ��ÏÜOÜ<ÖmäcÝÉÜ�ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî]ãOÕOÛ Ö<ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�ícæZÝhæ ü Ümå��-Ý-å?ðã|æcæOæcæcæOæcæ&�ï<à<ÙaÖ+á-ðOå'*�ÖÖ+á-Õeócá��-åOÛeì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö¼ÞeÞ� ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��"Ö+á"Õ?á-å � -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å��

�-Ö+á"Õ?óOá+�-å-Û?ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ�Ö7ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í ücü Oà<ÙaÖ �"Ö+á-Õeá-å�î ��Õ��OåÏÜmì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íÈî�×�Ùa×�áa×7Õeá-åeð Ö7ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í<æÜ6ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íÈî �Oó"à �)à"Ö<åcð�Ö<ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�íOæ � % Ü+ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî1ð-å"ï-×+ðOåcð Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íeæ�Ümì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhî *cÕ"×7Ûeå?ðÏÖ7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íeæáeþ"åOà?ó"å�� !-ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö'�-Ö+á"Õ?óOáBÞ

�"×eÖ ! �"ð � × ���"Ö+á-Õeócá ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í Oà7Ù�Ö !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ&�Õ ���"Û �Ümó?ä"Û?å�×cÖ�! �"ð � × ���"Ö+á"Õ?ócá��eä�Ûeå�æ��Í+Ì)Ì)ËÜ � æ*)×3? Ö7ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íÕ"ÖeÖmä ��å�Õ G Þ���Ö<ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í|ÞèÖ+á"Õ?óOá�Ö �cà'* ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �Ö�þ-à����+õ Ö cà7Ù�Ö î Ö cà7Ù�Ö`ÞZÖ+á"Õ?óOá�Ö �cà'* cà7Ù�Ö�� !-ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö�Ö7ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö����Í+Ì)Ì)Ë Ümó?ä"Û?å å5?)>OæÖ�þ-à�� ��ÜeÖ+á"Õ?ócá��-å-Û?ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<Ù�Ö Ö7ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íeæ ê Ö7á-Õeócá�Ö'�eà+* cà<Ù�Ö��

!Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ Ö7ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íÁÜ?Ö7á-Õeócá+�"åOÛeì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö Ö<ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íeæ+�Õ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞZÖ7á-Õeócá+�"åOÛeì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+* -à<Ù�Ö'�?ð-å'*-à<Ù�Ö'�-Ö7á-Õ?óOá&�eðOå'* !Oì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<Ù�Ö'�?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æÕ ���"Û �Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócáøÕ G æÕ ���"Û �Ü+Õ7äcáOàÁæÕ ���"Û �Ü?ÖO× � �)�cÕOÛcÛ�Õ?ðeðBÞ ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��eðOå+* ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��"Ö+á"Õ?ócá)�?ð-å'*ÈæðOà7Ù-å

� å?ð� å?ð

Ü � !Oà<ó å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcåeð Ü�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈîm×mÙ�×má ×ñã�æ �cæáeþ"åOà?ó"å�� !-ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö'�<ácó"Õ<ÙaÖ �"×�Ùa×+á�ÞÓ?ôfô � � Ò7ô� G Þ �-å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�eà+*Áì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íÁÜ ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhîm×6Ù�×má�×�ãhæ+�Õ7Ù-ð �aí�Þ���!-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö�Ö7ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö��Õ7Ù-ð ���BÞ �có-åcÕ)ï�þ)Õ<Ý)Ûcå�ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í'�Ö�þ-à���Ö �+õ Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö�î ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í ��Õ � Oà?Ù�Ö�Ö<ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í Ö Oà7Ù�Öýù Üñì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhîm×6Ù�×má�×�ã�æ�ú�Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ �

��Í+Ì)Ì)ËÁÜ � æÜ � �eóOàeà'* å7Ùcáeó�øÕeã-Õ�×<ÛeÕ?Ý)Ûcå �OæðOå * Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ üOü �hù+Ü cà7Ù�Ö·îm×mÙ�×má ×ñã|æ�ú ÞeÞ -à<ÙaÖ �eÕ)ï+áa×7à<Ù Û-×?Ö�á �Ö�þ-à��-���)á?þ-å-ÖO×?Ö����Í+Ì)Ì)Ë Ümó?ä"Û?å�å5?<>-æ

+5+ �

Page 117: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ö�þ-à����"ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �-ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í�aÕ � -à<ÙaÖÖ7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í Ö cà<Ù�Ö ùñÜ~ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�íÈîm×6Ùa×má ×�ãhæ�úëÝ)å?á"Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �Õ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞZï?à?óOó-å"Ö � �9?-å"ï'�?ð-å'*aæÕ ���"Û �Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá � G �aícæÕ ���"Û �Ü+Õ7äcáOàÁæ

Ü���!Oà<ó�áeóOÕ-ï7å�å � ä)ÕOÛ"×+á�BÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �?ðOå+* -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'* !Oì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<Ù�Ö'�?ð-å'*��cóOå��ÈÖ � å?á)�?ðOå+*Õ"Ö-×�Ø&�)×mÙ-á-å?ócÙ"Õ-Û-Ö �eðOå+*�ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��cÕ"Ö-×�Ø&�eðOå+* -à<ÙaÖ �eÕ)ÖO×+Ø&�?ð-å'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �"×mÙ-á-åeóeÙ"Õ-Û+�eðOå'* Oà<ÙaÖ �)×mÙOá"å?ócÙ"ÕOÛ��?ð-å'* ��Õ �-ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'* ��Õ � Oà?Ù�Ö'�?ðOå+*)æÜ���!Oà<ó å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá¡Þ �cæ�Õ ���"Û �Ü<Öc× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aíÝ"å?á"Õ -à<Ù�Ö'�?ð-å'*�ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��eðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö'�?ðOå+* !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*��OóOå��ÈÖì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�?ð-å'* -à<Ù�Ö'�eå?Ù"Õ<Ý�Ûeå���å<Ù-á&�eðOå'*�ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í��cå'*+*-å"ï7á&�?ð-å'*Oà<ÙaÖ �cå'*+*-å"ï7á&�?ð-å'* ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �-Ö7á-Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å�î ��Õ �"å��eðOå'*�æÜ���!Oà<ó �"à)Ö+á-å+*+*-å"ï+áÁó-å-ÛeÕ?áa×7à?Ù¡Þ �cæ�Õ ���"Û Ü7Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞjácó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå+* � G �aíÝ"å?á"Õ -à<Ù�Ö'�?ð-å'*�ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��eðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö'�?ðOå+* !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*��OóOå��ÈÖì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'* -à<ÙaÖ �eå+*+*-å"ï+á)�?ð-å'*�ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��"Ö+á"Õ?á-åÆî ��Õ'�-å �?ðOå+*Oà<ÙaÖ �"Ö+á-Õeá-å·î ��Õ �"å��eðOå'*�æ ðcà7Ù"å � åeð � å?ð

Ü � !Oà<ó å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcåeð Ü�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî�*OÕ"×7Û�×)æ �Oæáeþ"åOà?ó"å�� !-ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö'�<ácó"Õ<ÙaÖ � *-Õ)×?Û`ÞÓ?ôfô � � Ò7ô� G Þ �-å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�eà+*Áì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íÁÜ ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhî�*cÕ"×7ÛÁ×"æ+�Õ7Ù-ð �aí�Þ���!-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö�Ö7ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö��Õ7Ù-ð ���BÞ �có-åcÕ)ï�þ)Õ<Ý)Ûcå�ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í'�Ö�þ-à���Ö �+õ Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö�î ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í�aÕ � Oà<ÙaÖÖ<ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í Ö Oà7Ù�Ö¼ù~Ü~ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî�*OÕ"×7Û�×)æ�ú�Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ �

��Í+Ì)Ì)ËÁÜ � æÜ � �eóOàeà'* å7Ùcáeó�øÕeã-Õ�×<ÛeÕ?Ý)Ûcå �OæðOå * Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ üOü �hù+Ü cà7Ù�Ö·î�*OÕ"×7Û�×)æ�ú ÞeÞ Oà<ÙaÖ �cÕ"ï+áa×7à?Ù Û-×?Ö�á �Ö�þ-à��-���)á?þ-å-ÖO×?Ö����Í+Ì)Ì)Ë Ümó?ä"Û?å�å5?<>-æÖ�þ-à����"ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �-ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í ��Õ � Oà?Ù�ÖÖ<ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í Ö Oà7Ù�Öýù Üñì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhî�*cÕ"×7Û�×"æ�ú�Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ �Õ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞZï?à?óOó-å"Ö � �9?-å"ï'�?ð-å'*aæÕ ���"Û �Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá � G �aícæÕ ���"Û �Ü+Õ7äcáOàÁæÜ���!Oà<ó�áeóOÕ-ï7å�å � ä)ÕOÛ"×+á�BÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �?ðOå+* -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'* !Oì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<Ù�Ö'�?ð-å'*��cóOå��ÈÖ � å?á)�?ðOå+*Õ"Ö-×�Ø&�)×mÙ-á-å?ócÙ"Õ-Û-Ö �eðOå+*�ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��cÕ"Ö-×�Ø&�eðOå+* -à<ÙaÖ �eÕ)ÖO×+Ø&�?ð-å'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �"×mÙ-á-åeóeÙ"Õ-Û+�eðOå'* Oà<ÙaÖ �)×mÙOá"å?ócÙ"ÕOÛ��?ð-å'* ��Õ �-ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'* ��Õ � Oà?Ù�Ö'�?ðOå+*)æÜ���!Oà<ó å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOáBÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*

Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå?Ù"Õ<Ý�Ûeå���å<Ù-á&�eðOå'*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æ

+5+ �

Page 118: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ü���!Oà<ó �"à)Ö+á-å+*+*-å"ï+áÁó-å-ÛeÕ?áa×7à?Ù`Þ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'* Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*!Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'*��cóOå��hÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �eå'*�*Oå)ï+á&�eðOå+* Oà<ÙaÖ �cå'*+*-å"ï7á&�?ð-å'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æðOà7Ù-å

� å?ð� å?ð

Ü � !Oà<ó å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcåeð Ü�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈîfðOå-ïc×�ðcåø×�ã Ý|æ �cæáeþ"åOà?ó"å�� !-ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö'�<ácó"Õ<ÙaÖ �?ð-å"ï-×+ðOå�ÞÓ?ôfô � � Ò7ô� G Þ �-å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�eà+*Áì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íÁÜ ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhîfðcå-ïc×�ðOå ×�ã Ý�æ+�Õ7Ù-ð �aí�Þ���!-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö�Ö7ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö��Õ7Ù-ð ���BÞ �có-åcÕ)ï�þ)Õ<Ý)Ûcå�ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í'�Ö�þ-à���Ö �+õ Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö�î ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í

��Õ � Oà?Ù�ÖÖ<ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö¼ù~Ü~ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhîfðcå-ïc×�ðOå ×�ã Ý�æ�ú�Ý"å?á"Õ -à<Ù�Ö&���Í+Ì)Ì)ËÁÜ � æÜ � �eóOàeà'* å7Ùcáeó�øÕeã-Õ�×<ÛeÕ?Ý)Ûcå �OæðOå * Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ üOü �hù+Ü cà7Ù�Ö·îfðOå-ïc×�ðcåø×�ã�æ�ú�ÞeÞ -à<ÙaÖ �eÕ)ï+áa×7à<Ù Û-×?Ö�á�Ö�þ-à��-���)á?þ-å-ÖO×?Ö��

��Í+Ì)Ì)Ë Ümó?ä"Û?å�å5?<>-æÖ�þ-à����"ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �-ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í ��Õ � Oà?Ù�ÖÖ<ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í Ö Oà7Ù�Öýù Üñì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhîfðcå-ïc×�ðOå ×�ã Ý|æ�ú�Ý"å?á"Õ -à<Ù�Ö&�Õ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞZï?à?óOó-å"Ö � �9?-å"ï'�?ð-å'*aæÕ ���"Û �Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá � G �aícæÕ ���"Û �Ü+Õ7äcáOàÁæÜ���!Oà<ó�áeóOÕ-ï7å�å � ä)ÕOÛ"×+á�BÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �?ðOå+* -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'* !Oì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<Ù�Ö'�?ð-å'*��cóOå��ÈÖ � å?á)�?ðOå+*Õ"Ö-×�Ø&�)×mÙ-á-å?ócÙ"Õ-Û-Ö �eðOå+*�ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��cÕ"Ö-×�Ø&�eðOå+* -à<ÙaÖ �eÕ)ÖO×+Ø&�?ð-å'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �"×mÙ-á-åeóeÙ"Õ-Û+�eðOå'* Oà<ÙaÖ �)×mÙOá"å?ócÙ"ÕOÛ��?ð-å'* ��Õ �-ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'* ��Õ � Oà?Ù�Ö'�?ðOå+*)æÜ���!Oà<ó å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOáBÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*

Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå?Ù"Õ<Ý�Ûeå���å<Ù-á&�eðOå'*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æ

Ü���!Oà<ó �"à)Ö+á-å+*+*-å"ï+áÁó-å-ÛeÕ?áa×7à?Ù`Þ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'* Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*!Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'*��cóOå��hÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �eå'*�*Oå)ï+á&�eðOå+* Oà<ÙaÖ �cå'*+*-å"ï7á&�?ð-å'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æðOà7Ù-å

� å?ð� å?ð

Ü � !Oà<ó å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcåeð Ü�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî ��Õ �"å<ß)ÕOÛcÛcà?á Ý|æ �cæáeþ"åOà?ó"å�� !-ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö'�<ácó"Õ<ÙaÖ ���aÕ �"å<ß"Õ-ÛcÛcà?á�ÞÓ?ôfô � � Ò7ô

+5+ ÿ

Page 119: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� G Þ �-å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�eà+*Áì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íÁÜ ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhî ��Õ'�-å<ß)ÕOÛOÛeà?á�Ý�æ+�Õ7Ù-ð �aí�Þ���!-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö�Ö7ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö��Õ7Ù-ð ���BÞ �có-åcÕ)ï�þ)Õ<Ý)Ûcå�ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í'�Ö�þ-à���Ö �+õ Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö�î ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í��Õ � Oà?Ù�ÖÖ<ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö¼ù~Ü~ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhî ��Õ'�-å<ß)ÕOÛOÛeà?á Ý�æ�ú�Ý"å?á"Õ -à<Ù�Ö&�

��Í+Ì)Ì)ËÁÜ � æÜ � �eóOàeà'* å7Ùcáeó�øÕeã-Õ�×<ÛeÕ?Ý)Ûcå �OæðOå * Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ üOü �|ùCúÏÞOÞ -à<Ù�Ö'�eÕ)ï+á�×<à<Ù Û"×?Ö�á �Ö�þ-à��-���)á?þ-å-ÖO×?Ö����Í+Ì)Ì)Ë Ümó?ä"Û?å�å5?<>-æÖ�þ-à����"ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �-ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í ��Õ � Oà?Ù�Ö�Ö<ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÖ Oà7Ù�Ö¼ù~Ü~ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî ��Õ �"å<ß)ÕOÛcÛcà?á Ý�æ�úëÝ)å?á"Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �Õ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞZï?à?óOó-å"Ö � �9?-å"ï'�?ð-å'*aæÕ ���"Û �Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá � G �aícæÕ ���"Û �Ü+Õ7äcáOàÁæÜ���!Oà<ó�áeóOÕ-ï7å�å � ä)ÕOÛ"×+á�BÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �?ðOå+* -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'* !Oì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<Ù�Ö'�?ð-å'*��cóOå��ÈÖ � å?á)�?ðOå+*Õ"Ö-×�Ø&�)×mÙ-á-å?ócÙ"Õ-Û-Ö �eðOå+*�ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��cÕ"Ö-×�Ø&�eðOå+* -à<ÙaÖ �eÕ)ÖO×+Ø&�?ð-å'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �"×mÙ-á-åeóeÙ"Õ-Û+�eðOå'* Oà<ÙaÖ �)×mÙOá"å?ócÙ"ÕOÛ��?ð-å'* ��Õ �-ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'* ��Õ � Oà?Ù�Ö'�?ðOå+*)æÜ���!Oà<ó å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOáBÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*

Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå?Ù"Õ<Ý�Ûeå���å<Ù-á&�eðOå'*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æ

Ü���!Oà<ó �"à)Ö+á-å+*+*-å"ï+áÁó-å-ÛeÕ?áa×7à?Ù`Þ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'* Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*!Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'*��cóOå��hÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �eå'*�*Oå)ï+á&�eðOå+* Oà<ÙaÖ �cå'*+*-å"ï7á&�?ð-å'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æðOà7Ù-å

� å?ð� å?ð

Ü � !Oà<ó å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcåeð Ü�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî³Õ<Ý�Ö7á-Õ�×mÙ × ß|æ �cæáeþ"åOà?ó"å�� !-ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö'�<ácó"Õ<ÙaÖ �eÕ?Ý�Ö7á-Õ)×�Ù�ÞÓ?ôfô � � Ò7ô� G Þ �-å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�eà+*Áì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íÁÜ ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhî1Õ<Ý�Ö7á-Õ�×mÙ ×ñßhæ+�Õ7Ù-ð �aí�Þ���!-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö�Ö7ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö��Õ7Ù-ð ���BÞ �có-åcÕ)ï�þ)Õ<Ý)Ûcå�ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í'�Ö�þ-à���Ö �+õ Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö�î ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í

��Õ � Oà?Ù�ÖÖ<ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö¼ù~Ü~ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhî4Õ<ÝaÖ+á-Õ�×mÙ ×~ß|æ�úëÝ)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö ���Í+Ì)Ì)ËÁÜ � æÜ � �eóOàeà'* å7Ùcáeó�øÕeã-Õ�×<ÛeÕ?Ý)Ûcå �OæðOå * Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ üOü �|ùCúÏÞOÞ -à<Ù�Ö'�eÕ)ï+á�×<à<Ù Û"×?Ö�á �Ö�þ-à��-���)á?þ-å-ÖO×?Ö��

��Í+Ì)Ì)Ë Ümó?ä"Û?å�å5?<>-æÖ�þ-à����"ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �-ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í ��Õ � Oà?Ù�ÖÖ<ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í Ö Oà7Ù�Öýù Üñì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhî1Õ<Ý�Ö7á-Õ�×mÙ ×ñß|æ�úëÝ)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �Õ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞZï?à?óOó-å"Ö � �9?-å"ï'�?ð-å'*aæ

+5+ G

Page 120: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Õ ���"Û �Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá � G �aícæÕ ���"Û �Ü+Õ7äcáOàÁæÜ���!Oà<ó�áeóOÕ-ï7å�å � ä)ÕOÛ"×+á�BÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �?ðOå+* -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'* !Oì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<Ù�Ö'�?ð-å'*��cóOå��ÈÖ � å?á)�?ðOå+*Õ"Ö-×�Ø&�)×mÙ-á-å?ócÙ"Õ-Û-Ö �eðOå+*�ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��cÕ"Ö-×�Ø&�eðOå+* -à<ÙaÖ �eÕ)ÖO×+Ø&�?ð-å'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �"×mÙ-á-åeóeÙ"Õ-Û+�eðOå'* Oà<ÙaÖ �)×mÙOá"å?ócÙ"ÕOÛ��?ð-å'* ��Õ �-ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'* ��Õ � Oà?Ù�Ö'�?ðOå+*)æÜ���!Oà<ó å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOáBÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*

Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå?Ù"Õ<Ý�Ûeå���å<Ù-á&�eðOå'*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æ

Ü���!Oà<ó �"à)Ö+á-å+*+*-å"ï+áÁó-å-ÛeÕ?áa×7à?Ù`Þ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'* Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*!Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'*��cóOå��hÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �eå'*�*Oå)ï+á&�eðOå+* Oà<ÙaÖ �cå'*+*-å"ï7á&�?ð-å'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æðOà7Ù-å

� å?ð� å?ð

Ü � !Oà<ó å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcåeð Ü�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî³Õ"ÖcÖ-×�ØcÙOÚ-Õ-ÛñÝ�ã�æ �cæáeþ"åOà?ó"å�� !-ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö'�<ácó"Õ<ÙaÖ �eÕ)ÖcÖ-×�ØeÙ-Ú-Õ-Û¡ÞÓ?ôfô � � Ò7ô� G Þ �-å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�eà+*Áì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íÁÜ ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhî1Õ"ÖcÖ-×�ØcÙOÚ-Õ-ÛöÝ�ãaæ+�Õ7Ù-ð �aí�Þ���!-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö�Ö7ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö��Õ7Ù-ð ���BÞ �có-åcÕ)ï�þ)Õ<Ý)Ûcå�ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í'�Ö�þ-à���Ö �+õ Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö�î ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í

��Õ � Oà?Ù�ÖÖ<ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö¼ù~Ü~ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhî4Õ"ÖOÖO×�ØcÙOÚ"ÕOÛ�Ý�ãÈæ+ú�Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö ���Í+Ì)Ì)ËÁÜ � æÜ � �eóOàeà'* å7Ùcáeó�øÕeã-Õ�×<ÛeÕ?Ý)Ûcå �OæÖ�þ-à��-���)á?þ-å-ÖO×?Ö����Í+Ì)Ì)Ë Ü<ï7Õ-Ö7å-Ö �)ÜKé�Ü/Ýëê Ümì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íaîmÖ�äaïcï<åOåeð-åeð�Ö<ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íOæeæeæ �<æ� Ü���.eó?ä-å �?Ó"ômÒ��cæ

�?Ó"ômÒ .eó?ä-åðcå'* Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ üOü �|ùCúÏÞOÞ Oà?Ù�Ö'�eÕ"ï7á�×<à<Ù�Û"×?Ö�á�Ö�þ-à�� ���)á?þ-å-Öc×eÖ����Í+Ì)Ì)ˠܳóeä"Û?å�å5?<>-æÖmþ"à�� �"ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í ��Õ � Oà?Ù�ÖÖ<ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í Ö Oà7Ù�Ö¼ù~Ü~ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî³Õ"ÖcÖ-×�ØcÙOÚ-Õ-ÛöÝ ã�æ+úëÝ"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡ÞZï?à?óOó-å"Ö � �9?-å"ï'�?ð-å'*�æÕ ���"Û Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá � G �aíeæÕ ���"Û ÜmÕ<äcáOà�æÜ���!Oà<ó�áeóOÕ-ï7å�å � ä)ÕOÛ"×+á�`Þ �eæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'*

!Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'*��cóOå��hÖ � å?á)�?ð-å'*ÁÕ)ÖO×+Ø&�"×�ÙOá"å?óeÙ)ÕOÛ"Ö �?ð-å'*�ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í��eÕ)ÖO×+Ø&�?ð-å'*Oà<ÙaÖ �cÕ"ÖO×+Ø&�eðOå'* ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í��"×�ÙOá"å?óeÙ)ÕOÛ��?ðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö �)×mÙ-á-å?ócÙ"Õ-Û+�?ð-å'* �aÕ �-ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í��eðOå'* ��Õ � -à<Ù�Ö

+!Q X

Page 121: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ü���!Oà<ó�å<Ù"Õ?Ý)Ûcå���å?ÙOáBÞ �eæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'* �cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå?Ù"Õ<Ý�Ûeå���å<Ù-á&�eðOå'*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+* Oà<ÙaÖ �cå'*+*-å"ï7á&�?ð-å'*ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��"Ö+á"Õ?á-åÆî ��Õ'�-å �?ðOå+* -à<Ù�Ö'�-Ö7á-Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'*)æ

Ü���!Oà<ó �"à"Ö7á-å+*+*Oå)ï+áÁó-åOÛcÕ?áa×7à<Ù¡Þ �eæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'*!Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'*��cóOå��hÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �eå'*�*Oå)ï+á&�eðOå+* Oà<ÙaÖ �cå'*+*-å"ï7á&�?ð-å'*ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��"Ö+á"Õ?á-åÆî ��Õ'�-å �?ðOå+* -à<Ù�Ö'�-Ö7á-Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'*)æðOà7Ù-å

� åeð%� Ü����-ÛOÖ7å)×�* �?Ó"ômÒ �cæ

�?Ó"ômÒ !OÕcÛOÖ7åÖ�þ-à�� ���)á?þ-å-Öc×eÖ����Í+Ì)Ì)Ë Ü?ï7Õ-Ö7å-Ö �)Üfõ�Ý ÞeÞ�ß-ÕcÛeÛ?à?á î�ÜeÜ1Ýëê Ümì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhî6Ö�ä�ïOï<åOåeðOåcð�Ö<ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�íOæeæ��Ü é Ü?Ü+ÖmäeÝ�Ümì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íÈî'ãOÕcÛ Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í?æ Ý�æ ü Ù�×7ÛÈæeæcæeæ��<æ� Ü���.eó?ä-å �?Ó"ômÒ �cæ

�?Ó"ômÒ .eó?ä-åðcå'* Ý"å?á"Õ -à<Ù�Ö ü-ü ��ù8úÏÞcÞ Oà?Ù�Ö'�eÕ"ï7á�×<à<Ù Û-×eÖ�á �Ömþ"à��-���)á?þ-å-Öc×eÖ����Í�Ì)Ì)Ëëܳóeä"Û?å�å5?<>-æÖmþ"à����)ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í ��Õ � Oà?Ù�ÖÖ7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í Ö Oà7Ù�Ö¼ù~Ü~ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî³Õ"ÖcÖ-×�ØcÙOÚ-Õ-ÛñÝ�ãhæ�ú�Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ �Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞZï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï'�?ðOå+*�æÕ ���"Û Ü<×mÙ�Ö7å<óeá � G �aíeæÕ ���"Û ÜmÕ<äcáOàÁæÜ�� !-à<óÁácóOÕ-ï7å å � ä)ÕOÛ"×+á�`Þ �eæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*

Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖ � åeá&�?ð-å'*�Õ"ÖO×+Ø&�)×mÙOá"å?ócÙ"ÕOÛ"Ö �eðOå'*ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í��eÕ)ÖO×+Ø&�?ð-å'* Oà?Ù�Ö'�eÕ"Ö-×�Ø)�?ðOå+* ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��)×mÙ-á-å?ócÙ"Õ-Û+�?ð-å'*-à<Ù�Ö'�"×�ÙOá-åeóeÙ)ÕOÛ+�eðOå+* ��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �?ðOå+* �aÕ � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�æ

Ü�� !-à<ó å<Ù"Õ?Ý)Ûcå���å?ÙOáBÞ �eæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå?Ù"Õ<Ý�Ûeå���å<Ù-á&�eðOå'*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æ

Ü�� !-à<ó �"à"Ö7á-å+*+*Oå)ï+áÁó-åOÛcÕ?áa×7à<Ù¡Þ �eæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æðcà<Ù-å

� åeð%� Ü���!OÕcÛOÖ7å �?Ó-ô�Ò �cæ

�?Ó"ômÒ !OÕcÛOÖ7å

+!Q9+

Page 122: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

ðcå'* Ý"å?á"Õ -à<Ù�Ö ü-ü �hù+Ü cà7Ù�Ö�îmï+þ"àOà"Ö<åeÚ-Õ-Ûöã�æ+úÉÞeÞ Oà?Ù�Ö �cÕ"ï7á�×7à?Ù Û-×?Ö+á�Ömþ"à��-���)á?þ-å-Öc×eÖ����Í�Ì)Ì)Ëëܳóeä"Û?å�å5?<>-æÖmþ"à����)ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í ��Õ � Oà?Ù�ÖÖ7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í Ö Oà7Ù�Ö¼ù~Ü~ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî³Õ"ÖcÖ-×�ØcÙOÚ-Õ-ÛñÝ�ãhæ�ú�Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ �Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞZï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï'�?ðOå+*�æÕ ���"Û Ü<×mÙ�Ö7å<óeá � G �aíeæÕ ���"Û ÜmÕ<äcáOàÁæÜ�� !-à<óÁácóOÕ-ï7å å � ä)ÕOÛ"×+á�`Þ �eæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*

Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖ � åeá&�?ð-å'*�Õ"ÖO×+Ø&�)×mÙOá"å?ócÙ"ÕOÛ"Ö �eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �eÕ"Ö-×�Ø)�?ðOå+* Oà<ÙaÖ �cÕ"ÖO×+Ø&�eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �"×�ÙOá-åeóeÙ)ÕOÛ+�eðOå+*Oà?Ù�Ö �)×mÙ-á-å?ócÙ"Õ-Û+�?ð-å'* ��Õ �-ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í��?ð-å'* ��Õ � -à<Ù�Ö'�?ð-å'*)æ

Ü�� !-à<ó å<Ù"Õ?Ý)Ûcå���å?ÙOáBÞ �eæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå?Ù"Õ<Ý�Ûeå���å<Ù-á&�eðOå'*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æ

Ü�� !-à<ó �"à"Ö7á-å+*+*Oå)ï+áÁó-åOÛcÕ?áa×7à<Ù¡Þ �eæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'* ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í��-Ö7á-Õeá-å�î ��Õ �"å��eðOå'* Oà?Ù�Ö �"Ö+á"Õ?á-å�î ��Õ'�-å��eðOå+*)æðcà<Ù-å

� åeð%� åeð

%� å?ð� å?ð

Ü � !Oà<ó å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcåeð Ü�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî]ã-à<áOå ×~Ý|æ �cæáeþ"åOà?ó"å�� !-ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö'�<ácó"Õ<ÙaÖ �<ã"à?á"åBÞÓ?ôfô � � Ò7ô� G Þ �-å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�eà+*Áì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íÁÜ ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhî]ãOà<áOå�×ñÝ�æ+�Õ7Ù-ð �aí�Þ���!-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö�Ö7ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö��Õ7Ù-ð ���BÞ �có-åcÕ)ï�þ)Õ<Ý)Ûcå�ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í'�Ö�þ-à���Ö �+õ Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö�î ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í

��Õ � Oà?Ù�Ö�Ö<ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íëÖ cà7Ù�Ö¼ù~Ü~ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íÈî]ãOà<áOå�× Ý|æ+úëÝ"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ ���Í+Ì)Ì)ËÁÜ � æÜ � �eóOàeà'* å7Ùcáeó�øÕeã-Õ�×<ÛeÕ?Ý)Ûcå �OæðOå * Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ üOü �|ùCúÏÞOÞ -à<Ù�Ö'�eÕ)ï+á�×<à<Ù Û"×?Ö�á �Ö�þ-à��-���)á?þ-å-ÖO×?Ö��

��Í+Ì)Ì)Ë Ümó?ä"Û?å�å5?<>-æÖ�þ-à����"ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �-ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í�aÕ � -à<ÙaÖÖ7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í Ö cà<Ù�Ö ùñÜ~ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî]ãOà?áOå ×ñÝ�æ�úëÝ)å?á"Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �Õ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞZï?à?óOó-å"Ö � �9?-å"ï'�?ð-å'*aæÕ ���"Û �Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá � G �aícæÕ ���"Û �Ü+Õ7äcáOàÁæ

+!Q5Q

Page 123: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ü���!Oà<ó�áeóOÕ-ï7å�å � ä)ÕOÛ"×+á�BÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �?ðOå+*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖ � åeá&�?ð-å'*Õ"Ö-×�Ø&�)×mÙ-á-å?ócÙ"Õ-Û-Ö �eðOå+*�ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í��cÕ"Ö-×�Ø&�eðOå+* -à<ÙaÖ �eÕ)ÖO×+Ø&�?ð-å'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �"×mÙ-á-åeóeÙ"Õ-Û+�eðOå'* Oà<ÙaÖ �)×mÙOá"å?ócÙ"ÕOÛ��?ð-å'* ��Õ �-ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'* ��Õ � Oà?Ù�Ö'�?ðOå+*)æ

Ü���!Oà<ó å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOáBÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå?Ù"Õ<Ý�Ûeå���å<Ù-á&�eðOå'*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æ

Ü���!Oà<ó �"à)Ö+á-å+*+*-å"ï+áÁó-å-ÛeÕ?áa×7à?Ù`Þ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü?Öc× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ)ï<å � * �eðOå'* � G �aí Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �eðOå+*ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'* ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í��-Ö7á-Õeá-å�î ��Õ �"å��eðOå'* Oà?Ù�Ö �"Ö+á"Õ?á-å�î ��Õ'�-å��eðOå+*)æðOà7Ù-å

� å?ð� å?ð

Ü � !Oà<ó å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcåeð Ü�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî+×mÙOá"å?ócÙ"ÕOÛ��-å)ïO×+ð-å�Ý|æ �cæáeþ"åOà?ó"å�� !-ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö'�<ácó"Õ<ÙaÖ �"×�ÙOá"å?óeÙ)ÕOÛ��-å"ï-×+ð-å ÞÓ?ôfô � � Ò7ô� G Þ �-å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�eà+*Áì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íÁÜ ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhî�×mÙ-á-å?ócÙ"Õ-Û �-å)ïO×7ðOå Ý�æ+�Õ7Ù-ð �aí�Þ���!-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö�Ö7ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö��Õ7Ù-ð ���BÞ �có-åcÕ)ï�þ)Õ<Ý)Ûcå�ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í'�Ö�þ-à���Ö �+õ Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö�î ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í

�aÕ � -à<ÙaÖÖ7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í Ö cà<Ù�Ö ùñÜ~ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî�×�ÙOá"å?óeÙ)ÕOÛ��-å"ï-×+ð-å�Ýhæ+ú�Ý)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö ���Í+Ì)Ì)ËÁÜ � æÜ � �eóOàeà'* å7Ùcáeó�øÕeã-Õ�×<ÛeÕ?Ý)Ûcå �OæÖ�þ-à��-���)á?þ-å-ÖO×?Ö����Í+Ì)Ì)Ë Ü<ï7Õ-Ö7å-Ö �)Ü'Ýëê Ümì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íÈîmÖ�äaïcï?åcåeð-åeð Ö7ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�ícæeæ��?æ� Ü���.eó?ä-å �?Ó"ômÒ��cæ

�?Ó"ômÒ .eó?ä-åðcå'* Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ üOü �|ùCúÏÞOÞ Oà?Ù�Ö'�eÕ"ï7á�×<à<Ù�Û"×?Ö�á�Ö�þ-à�� ���)á?þ-å-Öc×eÖ����Í+Ì)Ì)ˠܳóeä"Û?å�å5?<>-æÖmþ"à�� �"ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í ��Õ � Oà?Ù�ÖÖ<ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í Ö Oà7Ù�Ö¼ù~Ü~ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî+×mÙOá"å?ócÙ"ÕOÛ��-å)ïO×+ð-å�Ý|æ�úëÝ)å?á"Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡ÞZï?à?óOó-å"Ö � �9?-å"ï'�?ð-å'*�æÕ ���"Û Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá � G �aíeæÕ ���"Û ÜmÕ<äcáOà�æÜ���!Oà<ó�áeóOÕ-ï7å�å � ä)ÕOÛ"×+á�`Þ �eæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*

Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖ � åeá&�?ð-å'*�Õ"ÖO×+Ø&�)×mÙOá"å?ócÙ"ÕOÛ"Ö �eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �eÕ"Ö-×�Ø)�?ðOå+* Oà<ÙaÖ �cÕ"ÖO×+Ø&�eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �"×�ÙOá-åeóeÙ)ÕOÛ+�eðOå+*Oà?Ù�Ö �)×mÙ-á-å?ócÙ"Õ-Û+�?ð-å'* ��Õ �-ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í��?ð-å'* ��Õ � -à<Ù�Ö'�?ð-å'*)æ

Ü���!Oà<ó�å<Ù"Õ?Ý)Ûcå���å?ÙOáBÞ �eæ

+!Q .

Page 124: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå?Ù"Õ<Ý�Ûeå���å<Ù-á&�eðOå'*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æ

Ü���!Oà<ó �"à"Ö7á-å+*+*Oå)ï+áÁó-åOÛcÕ?áa×7à<Ù¡Þ �eæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeð¡Þ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'* ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í��-Ö7á-Õeá-å�î ��Õ �"å��eðOå'* Oà?Ù�Ö �"Ö+á"Õ?á-å�î ��Õ'�-å��eðOå+*)æðOà7Ù-å

� åeð%� Ü����-ÛOÖ7å)×�* �?Ó"ômÒ �cæ

�?Ó"ômÒ !OÕcÛOÖ7åÖ�þ-à�� ���)á?þ-å-Öc×eÖ����Í+Ì)Ì)Ë Ü?ï7Õ-Ö7å-Ö ��ÜeÜ+ÖmäeÝ�Ü�ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî'ãOÕcÛ Ö<ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í?æ Ý�æ ü Ù�×7Ûaæ��?æ� Ü���.eó?ä-å �?Ó"ômÒ �cæ

�?Ó"ômÒ .eó?ä-åðcå'* Ý"å?á"Õ -à<Ù�Ö ü-ü ��ù8úÏÞcÞ Oà?Ù�Ö'�eÕ"ï7á�×<à<Ù Û-×eÖ�á �Ömþ"à��-���)á?þ-å-Öc×eÖ����Í�Ì)Ì)Ëëܳóeä"Û?å�å5?<>-æÖmþ"à����)ï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö ��Õ �"ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í

��Õ � -à<Ù�ÖÁÖ7ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö ùñÜ ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íÈî�×�ÙOá-åeóeÙ)ÕOÛ �"å"ï-×+ðOå�Ý|æ+úëÝ"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �Õ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞZï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï'�?ðOå+*�æÕ ���"Û Ü<×mÙ�Ö7å<óeá � G �aíeæÕ ���"Û ÜmÕ<äcáOàÁæÜ�� !-à<óÁácóOÕ-ï7å å � ä)ÕOÛ"×+á�`Þ �eæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*

Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖ � åeá&�?ð-å'*�Õ"ÖO×+Ø&�)×mÙOá"å?ócÙ"ÕOÛ"Ö �eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �eÕ"Ö-×�Ø)�?ðOå+* Oà<ÙaÖ �cÕ"ÖO×+Ø&�eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �"×�ÙOá-åeóeÙ)ÕOÛ+�eðOå+*Oà?Ù�Ö �)×mÙ-á-å?ócÙ"Õ-Û+�?ð-å'* ��Õ �-ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í��?ð-å'* ��Õ � -à<Ù�Ö'�?ð-å'*)æ

Ü�� !-à<ó å<Ù"Õ?Ý)Ûcå���å?ÙOáBÞ �eæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå?Ù"Õ<Ý�Ûeå���å<Ù-á&�eðOå'*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æ

Ü�� !-à<ó �"à"Ö7á-å+*+*Oå)ï+áÁó-åOÛcÕ?áa×7à<Ù¡Þ �eæÕ ���"Û Ü7ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �?ð-å'*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'* ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í��-Ö7á-Õeá-å�î ��Õ �"å��eðOå'* Oà?Ù�Ö �"Ö+á"Õ?á-å�î ��Õ'�-å��eðOå+*)æðcà<Ù-å

� åeð%� Ü����-ÛOÖ7å)×�* �?Ó"ômÒ��cæ

�?Ó"ômÒ !OÕcÛOÖ7åÖmþ"à��-���)á?þ-å-Öc×eÖ����Í+Ì)Ì)Ë Ü?ï7Õ-Ö7å-Ö �)Ü1õ Ý ÞeÞtß"ÕcÛeÛ?à<á î�ÜeÜ1Ý êÉÜ�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî�Ö�ä�ïOï<åOåeðOåcð�Ö<ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�íOæeæ��

+!Q �

Page 125: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Ü?Ü+ÖmäeÝ�Ü�ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�íaî]ãOÕcÛ�Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íeæ Ý�æèûü Ù�×7Ûaæeæcæ��<æ� Ü�� .eó?ä-å �?Ó"ômÒ��cæ

�?Ó"ômÒ .có?ä-åðcå * Ý"å?á"Õ -à<Ù�Ö ücü ��ù8úÏÞcÞ Oà?Ù�Ö �cÕ"ï7á�×7à?Ù�Û-×eÖ�á �Ömþ"à��-���-áeþ-å-Öc×?Ö(���Í�Ì)Ì)Ë Ü6óeä"Û?å�å5?<>cæÖmþ-à � �"ï<àeócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ,�aÕ �"ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í �aÕ � Oà<ÙaÖÖ7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í Ö cà<Ù�Öýù Üñì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�íÈî+×mÙOá"å?ócÙ"ÕOÛ��-å)ïO×+ð-å Ý|æ�úëÝ)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�Ö �Õ ���"Û �Ü<ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞZï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï'�?ðOå+*�æÕ ���"Û �Ü?×mÙ�Ö7å<óeá � G �aícæÕ ���"Û �Ü�Õ<äcáOàÁæÜ�� !-à<óÁácóOÕ-ï7å�å � ä"Õ-Û"×+á�BÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü<ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �?ðOå+*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖ � åeá&�?ð-å'*�Õ"ÖO×+Ø&�)×mÙOá"å?ócÙ"ÕOÛ"Ö �eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �eÕ"Ö-×�Ø)�?ðOå+* Oà<ÙaÖ �cÕ"ÖO×+Ø&�eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �"×�ÙOá-åeóeÙ)ÕOÛ+�eðOå+*Oà?Ù�Ö �)×mÙ-á-å?ócÙ"Õ-Û+�?ð-å'* ��Õ �-ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í��?ð-å'* ��Õ � -à<Ù�Ö'�?ð-å'*)æÜ�� !-à<ó å?Ù"Õ?Ý)Ûeå���å?ÙOáBÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü<ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �?ðOå+*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå?Ù"Õ<Ý�Ûeå���å<Ù-á&�eðOå'*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æÜ�� !-à<ó��)à"Ö7á-å'*�*Oå)ï+á�ó-åOÛcÕ?áa×7à<ÙBÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü<ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �?ðOå+*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æðcà<Ù-å

� å?ð%� Ü�� !OÕcÛOÖ7å �?Ó"ômÒ��cæ

�?Ó"ômÒ !OÕcÛOÖ7åðcå * Ý"å?á"Õ -à<Ù�Ö ücü �hù+Ü cà7Ù�Ö�îmï+þ"àOà"Ö<åeÚ-Õ-Û Ü³ãOÕOÛøÜ7Ö�äeÝ�Ümì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íhî/ã-ÕcÛ Ö<ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�ícæZÝ�æcæcæ7úÏÞcÞ Ömþ"à��-���-áeþ-å-Öc×?Ö(���Í�Ì)Ì)Ë Ü6óeä"Û?å�å5?<>cæÖmþ-à � �"ï<àeócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ,�aÕ �"ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í

��Õ � -à<Ù�ÖÖ7ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�íëÖ cà7Ù�Ö ùñÜ ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íÈî�×�ÙOá-åeóeÙ)ÕOÛ �"å"ï-×+ðOå�Ý�æ�ú�Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ �Õ ���"Û �Ü<ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞZï?à?ócó"å"Ö � �'?"å"ï'�?ðOå+*�æÕ ���"Û �Ü?×mÙ�Ö7å<óeá � G �aícæÕ ���"Û �Ü�Õ<äcáOàÁæÜ�� !-à<óÁácóOÕ-ï7å�å � ä"Õ-Û"×+á�BÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü<ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �?ðOå+*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖ � åeá&�?ð-å'*�Õ"ÖO×+Ø&�)×mÙOá"å?ócÙ"ÕOÛ"Ö �eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �eÕ"Ö-×�Ø)�?ðOå+* Oà<ÙaÖ �cÕ"ÖO×+Ø&�eðOå'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �"×�ÙOá-åeóeÙ)ÕOÛ+�eðOå+*Oà?Ù�Ö �)×mÙ-á-å?ócÙ"Õ-Û+�?ð-å'* ��Õ �-ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í��?ð-å'* ��Õ � -à<Ù�Ö'�?ð-å'*)æÜ�� !-à<ó å?Ù"Õ?Ý)Ûeå���å?ÙOáBÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü<ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �?ðOå+*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå?Ù"Õ<Ý�Ûeå���å<Ù-á&�eðOå'*

+!Q �

Page 126: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

Oà?Ù�Ö �cå<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+* Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'*ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �-Ö+á"Õ?á"å�î �aÕ �-å �?ð-å'* -à<ÙaÖ �-Ö7á-Õeá-å·î �aÕ �"å��?ð-å'*)æÜ�� !-à<ó��)à"Ö7á-å'*�*Oå)ï+á�ó-åOÛcÕ?áa×7à<ÙBÞ �eæÕ ���"Û �Ü<ÖO× � � Õ?ðeðBÞ�áOó-Õ"ï?å � * �?ð-å'* � G �aí Ý"åeá-Õ -à<ÙaÖ �?ð-å'*�ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í �?ðOå+*Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'* !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ �eðOå'*��cóOå��ÈÖÁì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í �eå+*+*Oå)ï+á)�?ðOå+*Oà?Ù�Ö �cå'*�*Oå"ï7á&�eðOå'* ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í��-Ö7á-Õeá-å�î ��Õ �"å��eðOå'* Oà?Ù�Ö �"Ö+á"Õ?á-å�î ��Õ'�-å��eðOå+*)æðcà<Ù-å

� å?ð%� åeð

%� åeð

%� å?ð� å?ðáeþ"åOà?ó"å�� !-ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö'�<ácó"Õ<ÙaÖ·Þ

�"×eÖ ! �"ð � × ���?ácó-Õ?Ù�Öëì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í Oà7Ù�Ö !Oì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í � Oà<ÙaÖ,�aÕ �"ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í �aÕ � Oà<ÙaÖ����Í+Ì)Ì)Ë Ü6ó?ä"Û?å�×cÖ�! �"ð � × ���?ácó"Õ<Ù�Ö �eä�Ûeå�æ*�×!? Ö7ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Õeì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í Ö cà<Ù�ÖÕ"ÖeÖmä ��å� G Þ �-å<Ù)Õ<Ý)Ûcå��aå<ÙOá)�eà+*Áì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�íöÕeì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í'�Õ7Ù-ð �aí�Þ���!-ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö�Ö7ì-Ûcà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö cà7Ù�Ö��Õ7Ù-ð ���BÞ �có-åcÕ)ï�þ)Õ<Ý)Ûcå�ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í'�Ö�þ-à����+õÝ)å?á-Õ Oà?Ù�ÖÏî ï?à?óOó-å"Ö � �9?-å"ï ì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í cà7Ù�Ö !-ì-Ûcà<Ý"Õ-Û�í � Oà?Ù�Ö

�aÕ �"ì-Ûeà?Ý"Õ-Û�í �aÕ � Oà<ÙaÖ�Ö7ì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í Ö Oà7Ù�Ö ù�Õeì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�ímú�Ý"å?á"Õ -à<Ù�Ö&�Õ ���"Û �Ü?ï7Õ-Ö7å-Ö Õeì"Ûeà?Ý"ÕOÛ�í<æÕ ���"Û �Üe×6Ù�Ö7å<ócá �cóOå��hÖ�æÕ ���"Û �Ü?ÖO× � �)�cÕOÛcÛ�Õ?ðeðBÞ !Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ �<áOó-Õ?Ù�Ö �)×mÙÈ×�á�æÕ ���"Û �Ü?ÖO× � �)�cÕOÛcÛ�Õ?ðeðBÞ !Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ �<áOó-Õ?Ù�Ö �'*OÕ�×<ÛaæÕ ���"Û �Ü?ÖO× � �)�cÕOÛcÛ�Õ?ðeðBÞ !Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ �<áOó-Õ?Ù�Ö �eðOå)ïO×+ð-åhæÕ ���"Û �Ü?ÖO× � �)�cÕOÛcÛ�Õ?ðeðBÞ !Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ �<áOó-Õ?Ù�Ö ����Õ'�-å<ß)ÕOÛOÛeà?á�æÕ ���"Û �Ü?ÖO× � �)�cÕOÛcÛ�Õ?ðeðBÞ !Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ �<áOó-Õ?Ù�Ö �cÕ<ÝaÖ+á-Õ�×mÙvæÕ ���"Û �Ü?ÖO× � �)�cÕOÛcÛ�Õ?ðeðBÞ !Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ �<áOó-Õ?Ù�Ö �cÕ"ÖOÖO×�ØcÙOÚ"ÕOÛÈæÕ ���"Û �Ü?ÖO× � �)�cÕOÛcÛ�Õ?ðeðBÞ !Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ �<áOó-Õ?Ù�Ö �?ã-àeá-åÈæÕ ���"Û �Ü?ÖO× � �)�cÕOÛcÛ�Õ?ðeðBÞ !Oì"Ûeà<Ý)ÕOÛ�í � -à<ÙaÖ �<áOó-Õ?Ù�Ö �)×mÙ-á-å?ócÙ"Õ-Û �-å)ïO×7ðOåvæðOà7Ù-å� å?ð

+!Q �

Page 127: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

� � � � ����������� ���

) LkN ÿ�� 0 6¡36A¡.1>�L�R:*�.408>d(7>-FUÃ)0C.4F".108!:%'�DNO%'�">".1!:F".104g���.4%437^<>"! �1!:>"^G#8(+Y[.1,Àb�(7>"FHR:!W5<.4>-.4#8#1g�� 1 ���G>= 1VJME#G A0(�+6 % ;�E#G>1�5�7_-*)(7^<.1#.+ + � � +!Q �-_C+ G7ÿ�� g

) L�,8, G.G 0 Ê·(7P-R�� g�L�,8,8!:.+g9'�!$5<.1>".4#C# *"0C.4#C.40C5c!$>"^E#C!:9QP"R:(+,/!$3<>�08.1RS(+,8!:3<>-#4g¡IÀ>��+=76"D%A%A0(.1�5��� 6!: G�3A� ������� % ;6���1 E % 685�� 1 �FG =�1VJME#G-A0(��+6 % ;�E�G 1�5����������� ��_-L�,8RS(7>?,/(-_ #kL2_ + GHG.G g

) 69#+' X Q 0 L >"F-08. l86¡3<^<F)(+>"365a_kNc,/.1*"�".4>"!-g(#V(70CRS(7>-Fh_ (+>"F a�(7>"%fböL2g 'hbc>"%'�hg �d.4%'�)(7>-!:%³(+R,/08(7>"#8R:(+,/!$3<>Q37YaI&%<Jö(7P-,83<9E(�,/3<>G#C*a.1%4!$�"%³(+,8!:3<>"#·!:>?,/3T�)0C#C,KÂÀ3<0CF".40�R$3<^<!:%+g"IÀ>$#%# 5)(�&'& &'�(*)�+-,/.�&�5G-A�=�5�H G 1�685�H L0�+685�: A�=%A�5 D%A�6851& 68= % H L32TA%D73)5154MEA �:�68=76 AFG / 68=98KA0( H.5)(� 1 �FG =�1VJME#G-A0(:��� �FG-A % �f_ � 3<P-#C,/37>h_)��;Q_ aM3m57.49 X .40 Q X X QOg

) 6¡3<^ X5X 0 L >"F-08. l 6¡37^<F)(7>"365�g@Ã)3<089=(7R�5<.108!W�)%³(+,8!:3<>�37YÆ#8!$9QP"RS(�,/!:37>"# X .f,ÀA¡.1.4>tI&%<J�(7P-,83<9E(�,'(-g��(7#K,/.40t37Y=.4>-^<!:>".1.40C!:>"^ñ,8�".4#C!:#4_ �U(7#8#8(7%'�eP"#8.f,8,/#�IÀ>"#C,8!$,8P-,/.è37Y;�v.4%'�">"37R:3<^7b7_ ��(7# Â#/(7%'�eP"#C.1,C,/#�IÀ>"#K,/!W,/P-,8.B37Y-��.1%'�">"3<R$3<^7b7_K��(79 X 08!:F-^<.6��(7#C#/(7%'�eP"#C.1,8,8#4_ONO.1*-,/.19 X .10#Q X5X5X g

) �+� � � ( 0 Ê·(+,808!$%'�Q�¡37P"#837, (7>"F �M(7F"�"!:( �¡3<P-#837,4g�L X #K,/08(7%1,�!:>?,/.108*"0C.1,/(+,/!$3<>hn`(=P">-!$�).1FUR:(+,8,8!:%4.9=3cF".1RTY[3<0�#C,/(+,/!$%�(+>)(7R$bc#C!:#�37Y2*"083<^70/(79;# X bö%43<>"#K,/0CP"%1,8!:3<> 3<0d(7*"*"0C3³\-!$9E(�,/!:37>ñ37Y�-\O*a37!:>?,/#1ghIÀ>$�+=�6"D%A%A0(.1�5���B6!: G�3A<& 6 E)=FG�3 � 55E(H L � ���=��� % ;6���1 E % 6857�+= 1�5 D�1 ;�LNA �6!:>�+=76?.=0H % % 1�5�A@ H.5� E(H #A �f_-*)(+^<.4# Q .<ÿB� Q � QO_ '|37# L >"^<.1R:.1#4_��¡L2_ + G�� � g

) �+� � � X 0 Ê·(+,808!$%'� ��g��¡3<P-#837,;(7>-F �M(7F"�-!S( �¡3<P"#C37,³gjL P-,83<9E(�,/!:%=#Cbc>?,/�".1#8!$#=37YM3<*O,/!:9=(7R`!:>OÂ5+(708!:(7>?,d(7#8#C.40C,8!:3<>-#4nF��(+,8�".49=(+,/!$%³(7RMY[3<P">"F"(+,/!$3<>"#4g�IÀ>"�+=�6"D%A%A0(.1�5��� 6!:QG43A � ������ % ;6���1 E % 685 � =FG 1 C.D�1VH LV& 5G AFL L 1D#A�5 D%A H.5)(�+=�6?.=0H % % 1�5��@ H.5� E(H #A �f_Æ*)(7^<.1# + �+!QO_ ��3O%'�-.4#C,8.401_ aFEG_)L�P"^<P"#K,.+ G�� � g

) �+� G Q 0 Ê�g��¡3<P-#837,�(7>"F �@g �¡3<P"#C37,³g �¡3<9;*)(70C!:>"^ñ,8�".3#V(7R$3<!:#U%43<>->".4%f,/!:37>�(7>-F�A�!$F".4>cÂ!:>"^ %+>)(70C0836A�!:>"^D(7*"*"0C3?(7%'�".1#@,83H( X #K,/0/(+%1,@!:>?,8.408*-08.1,/(+,/!$3<>hgkIÀ> ��g 6B08P-bc>"3c3<^<�".£(+>"F��g�iö!:0C#8!:>-^"_B.1F"!$,83<08#1_F�+=�6"D%A%A0(.1�5��� 6!: G�3AG& 6 E�=�G�3 &�5G-A�= 5�H G>1�685�H LH��� % ;6���1 E % 685�+=76?.=0H % % 1�5�I@ H.5� E�H #A & % ;�LNA % A�5G H G 1�685 H.5)(J@ 6?.1 D$�+=76?.=0H % % 1�5�7_ *)(+^<.4#�Q � G� Q GD� _ '�.4P-57.4>h_ 6¡.4R$^<!:P-9U_)+ GHG Qcg '<a � N � . +<_�Nc*"08!$>"^<.40 ÂLKÆ.108RS(+^"g

) �9#VÊ GHG 0 & g���g(�¡R:(708�+.7_-JT08>)( #@0CP"9 X .40C^"_c(7>"F=¢T3<083<>=Ê�.1R:.1Fhg�� 6 (#AFL�� 3A%D'881�5�7gC�UIÀ��Ê�0C.4#8#1_+ GHGHG g

) �¡�". G<ÿ 0 L >">"( & g��¡�".1Y�,8.404g�LÉ#8!$9QP"R:(+,/3<0kY[3<0&,/�".�IKJ�LÏRS(7>-^<P)(7^<.+_���(³b + GHG<ÿ g ��(+#C,/.10G37Y&�>"^<!:>-.4.40C!:>"^�(7>"F 6�(7%'�-.4R:370E37Y&NO%1!:.1>"%4. !$> �¡3<9;*"P-,8.40HNc%4!:.1>"%4. (7>"F &�>"^<!$>".4.108!:>-^� �".4#C!:#1g

+!Q �

Page 128: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

) ¢k¢ ' & X Q 0 a�!$!"¢T3cF"3O3-_+L�RS(7>G¢T37>"3657(+>h_ '�.4. '�!:>È_<(7>"F �d!:%'�)(7.1R"¢Qg &Æ0C>"#C,4g�NO.4R$.4%f,/!:>-^T*"08.1F"!:%4(+,/.1#Y[3<0 !:9;*"R$!:%³(�,/!:37>"#B!$>H*"083<^70/(79�(7>)(7RWbO#C!:#1_<��(70C%'� + �-_Q X5X QOg

) ¢T.³( X5X 0 '|(7P"0/(4#£g|¢T.4(7>hg=IÀ9=*"0C365<.4Fj#8!:92P"RS(+,8!:3<>¬3+Y�I&%<JÏ(7PO,/3<9=(+,'(Og ��(+#C,/.10&3+Y�.4>-^<!:>".1.40 Â!:>"^H,/�-.4#8!$#4_#��(7#8#8(7%'�eP"#8.f,8,8#QIÀ>"#C,8!$,8P-,/.;37Y��v.4%'�->"3<R:37^7b<_#��(7#8#8(7%'�eP"#8.f,8,8#GIÀ>"#C,8!$,/PO,/.£37Y��.1%'�">"3<R$3<^7b7_ ��(+9 X 08!$F"^<. �U(7#8#8(7%'�eP"#8.f,8,/#1_�NO.1*-,/.19 X .40 Q X5X5X g

) ¢T3OF X Q 0 a�!$!h¢T3cF"3O3-g�NO.1R:.1%1,/!$>"^G*"0C.4F"!$%³(+,8.4#�Y[3<0�%13<>"F"!W,/!$3<>)(7R�!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,�F".f,/.1%1,/!$3<>�P"#C!:>"^G%1R:P"# Â,/.10@(7>)(7RWbO#C!:#1g ��(7#K,/.104¾¿#@,8�".4#C!:#1_ �UIÀ� ¢T.1*)(70C,89=.1>?,k37Y4&ÆR$.4%f,/08!$%³(7R &�>"^<!:>-.4.40C!:>"^H(+>"F�¡3<9;*"P-,/.10�NO%4!$.4>"%1.7_T��(79 X 0C!:F"^7.7_<�UL&_)Q X5X Qcg

) ¢kÊ 'vN , X Q 0 �M3 X .10C,/3�¢T.dÊ�08!:#C%43"_ a (+>"%1b 'hbc>"%'�h_ L�R:.f\ZNO�?57(+0C,/#C9E(+>h_.aM!:%437R:.DIÀ9;9=3708R:!$%³(-_Æ(+>"F��37� a�.;iö!:>hg � & 68= % H L>2 = A_H G % A�5G 6!: @:H % ;68=�G � � �.H C�6�� � L )68= 1 G�3 % _VQ X X QOgHIÀ>*"0837^<08.1#8#4g

) & �9# a X X 0 �U!:%'�"(7.4R ¢Qg�&Æ0C>"#C,4_ÆL F)(79 � �4.1!:#8R$.401_Æiö!$R:R$!S(79 #Gg #k08!$#CAB3<R:FÈ_Æ(7>"Fè¢k(³5c!:F a�3+,/�e!:>hg� P"!:%'�eR$bUF".f,/.4%f,/!$>"^D08.1R:.f57(+>e,T*"083<^70/(79 !:>?5+(70C!S(7>?,/#1g IÀ> & � ���"#������� � =�6"D%A%A0(.1�5��� 6!:G43AG#%# 5)(�&�5G-A�= 5�H G>1�685�H L��+685�: A�= A�5 D%A�6851� 6!:�G>/ H.= A�+5�.1�5 A%A�= 1�5�7_Æ*)(7^<.1# �H� GB� � �7ÿ _'�!:9;.408!$%'��_"IÀ08.1RS(7>"FÈ_�!7P">". � ��G _Q X5X5X g

) & �9# a X +6( 0 �U!:%'�"(7.4R &�08>"#K,³_ !<(7�+.B�¡37�c0C.4R$R _|iö!:R:R$!S(79�#Gg #k08!$#CAB3<08R$Fh_v(7>"Fj¢k(65c!$FYaM37,/�e!:>Èg�¢ b?Â>)(79;!:%4(7R:RWbGF"!:#C%4365<.108!$>"^QR:!$�7.1R$b;*"0837^<0/(79 !$>e5+(70C!S(7>?,8#`,83Q#8P"*-*a3<0K, *"0C3<^<0/(+9ø.f5<3<R$P-,/!$3<>hg&������ 2 =0H.5 �MH#DFG>1�685 � 685�� 6!:�G>/ H.= A �+5�.1�5 A%A�= 1�5�7_Q � ��Q $]n + � Q � _�Q X5X +<g

) & �9# a X + X 0 �U!:%'�"(7.4R�¢QgK&�0C>"#C,4_ !<(7�+.��¡3O%'�e08.1R:Rr_<iö!:R:R$!S(79#Gg #k08!$#CAB3<R:Fh_<(7>"F;¢k(³5O!$F a�37,8�c!$>hg�¢ b?Â>)(79;!:%4(7R:RWbGF"!:#C%4365<.108!$>"^QR:!$�7.1R$b;*"0837^<0/(79 !$>e5+(70C!S(7>?,8#`,83Q#8P"*-*a3<0K, *"0C3<^<0/(+9ø.f5<3<R$P-,/!$3<>hg&������ 2 =0H.5 �MH#DFG 1�685 ��6851� 6!:�G>/ H.= A��+5�.1�5 A%A�= 1�5�7_6Q � � Q $fn,+ � Q � _ÆÃ�. X 08P"(70Cb Q X5X +<g�L*"08.f5c!:3<P"#T57.40C#8!:37>�(+*"*a.4(708.1Ft!:> & � ��� � ��� ���+=�6"D%A%A0(.1�5��� 6!: G43AA#�.��FG6& 5G A�= 5�H G 1�685�H L�+685�: A�= A�5 D%A 685*� 6!:�G>/ H.= A��+5�.1�5 A%A�= 1�5�7_È*"(7^<.4#.Q'+ .B� Q5Q8�"_ '�3<#kL�>"^<.1R:.4#1_ �¡L2_ TNOL&_��(³b + GB� Q'+<_C+ G.GHG g

)5# � G � 0 #@.10/(7R$F^� g #V(7>->"3OFd(7>-F46¡.f,8,Àb � g � gT�¡�".1>"^"gBNc,8083<>"^7.4#C,M*�3<#C,8%43<>-F"!$,8!:3<>H#8.19E(+>e,8!:%1#(7#£,/�".�Y[3<0C9E(7R X (7#C!:#GY[3<0£08.f5<.40C#8.U.4>"^<!$>".4.108!$>"^"g��6 E�= 5�H L6!: � E�G 6 % H G A0(I� 6!:�G / H.= A�+5�.1�5 A%A�=�1�5�7_ . � + % Q $fn,+ .HGB� + �.�"_ !7P">". + GHG �-g

)5# # G + 0 Nc,/.1*"�".1> #V(70CRS(7>-F&(+>"F !73<�-> #kP-,8,/(7^"g � E)1 (#A.G 60@ ��� G43A @ H.=%D73 �+=�6"! A�=fge�v.4%'�">-!:%³(+R08.1*a3<0K,³_¡¢6& ��Ncbc#C,/.19=# �M.1#8.4(708%'� �¡.4>?,/.104_�+ GHG +<g M*aF"(+,/.1F 5<.108#C!:3<> (³57(+R:!S( X R:.�(�, �(' !'2;2e¸ ������;�T �0�#�# � �ÈÄ 2 � Å545 �� ���<¹ ��!�� ���ag

)5# � #+, G/. 0 !73<�">�KQg1#kP-,8,/(7^"_ !<(79;.4#�!-g � 3<0C>"!:>-^"_cNag !-g1#V(+08RS(+>"Fh_��Gge¢Qg�!73<>".1#4_cL2g'�U3cF".1,4_-(+>"F!-g8��g"iö!:>"^-gF@ H.= D73��<@ H.5� E�H #A � H.5)(I2 6�6 L �2:�68=>& 68= % H L �H;A%D�1 C.D_H G 1�685)g���.]\c,/#T(+>"F�U3<>"37^<0/(7*-�"#�!:>^�¡3<9;*"P-,/.10�NO%4!$.4>"%1.7g�NO*"0C!:>"^7.40K KÆ.40CRS(7^"_(a�.fA E`3<08��_ + GHG/. g

)5#+' X5X ( 0 Nc,/.1*"�".1>�!-g #V(70CRS(7>-F�(7>"F a�(7>"%1bEL2g '�bc>"%'�Èg �#8!$>"^QI&%<J�(7P-,83<9=(+,'(&Y[370¡F".f5<.4R$3<*"!$>"^F"!:#K,/0C! X P-,8.4F£#Cbc#K,/.49;#4gaIÀ> #V(70Kb2�kg '�.4(657.4>"#B(7>"F��UP-0/(7R$!)NO!W,'(708(79E(+>h_7.1F"!$,83<08#1_ & 6 E)5 �(KH G>1�685 � 6!:��+6 % ;685 A�5G�����H��"A0( �����FG-A % �f_�*)(7^<.1# Q ÿD� �$. +!QOg ��(79 X 08!$F"^<. M>"!$57.40C#8!$,ÀbÊ�08.4#C#4_CQ X5X5X g

+!Q ÿ

Page 129: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

)5#+' X5X X$0 Nc,/.1*"�".1>�!-g #V(70CRS(7>-F�(7>"F a�(7>"%1bEL2g '�bc>"%'�Èg �#8!$>"^QI&%<J�(7P-,83<9=(+,'(&Y[370¡F".f5<.4R$3<*"!$>"^F"!:#K,/0C! X P-,8.4F£#Cbc#K,/.49;#4gaIÀ> #V(70Kb2�kg '�.4(657.4>"#B(7>"F��UP-0/(7R$!)NO!W,'(708(79E(+>h_7.1F"!$,83<08#1_ & 6 E)5 �(KH G>1�685 � 6!::�+6 % ;685 A�5G�����H��"A0(:��� �FG-A % �f_a%'�"(7*-,/.10 + . _�*)(7^7.4#�Q ÿD� �$. + QOgT��(79 X 0C!:F"^<.�>"!W5<.108#8!W,ÀbdÊ�08.4#C#4_ TNcL2_)Q X5X X g

)5#@3<R G5X ( 0 �k.4>">".f,/�1!-g #@3<R$F"9=(7>hg�� 1 �FG = 1VJME�G-A0( � L )68=�1 G�3 % �$1 % E�L H G 1�685 E ��1�5� & 5.;�E�G����.E�G ;�E#G� E�G 6 % H G H7g=Ê��)¢�,/�-.4#8!$#4_v¢T.4*"(70C,89=.1>e,V37Y4&�R:.1%1,/0C!:%4(7R�&�>"^<!$>".4.108!$>"^d(7>"FY�¡3<9=*-P-,/.10NO%4!$.4>"%1.7_ ��(7#C#/(7%'�eP"#C.1,8,8#EIÀ>"#K,/!W,/P-,8.D37YM��.1%'�">"3<R$3<^7b7_.��(79 X 08!$F"^<.7_6�dL2_ !7P"RWb1+ GHG5X gL R$#83"_ ) #k3<R G5X X 0 g

)5#@3<R G5X X 0 �k.4>">".f,/� !-g"#@3<R$F"9=(7>hg<¢T!$#C,808! X P-,/.1F&(+R:^<3<0C!$,8�"9ö#8!:92P"RS(+,8!:3<> P"#8!$>"^�!$>"*"P-, %+3<P-,8*"P-,�(7POÂ,/3<9=(+,/(-g��v.4%'�">"!$%³(7R ��.4*�3<0K, �UIÀ�(% ' � N %+� �� � G X _<�UIÀ� '|( X 3<08(+,/3<0Kb=Y[370��¡3<9=*-P-,/.10NO%4!$.4>"%1.7_T��(79 X 08!:F-^<.7_<�dL2_�NO.1*-,/.19 X .10 + GHG5X g�L�R:#C3"_)Ê��)¢Á� �-.4#8!$# ) #k3<R G X ( 0 g

)5#@3<0 ÿHG 0 ��g !-g � g #k3<0CF"3<>hg � J '�naLÁ*"083c37Y�^7.4>".10/(+,8!:>"^D#Kbc#C,/.19 Y[3<0M�"!$^<�".40�3<08F-.40 R$3<^<!$%7g�IÀ>#£g 6B!:0C,ÀA�!$#C,8R:.k(7>-F�Êvg�L&g�NOP X 08(7�"9=(7>?b?(79d_).4F-!$,/3708#4_ ��E�= = A�5G32 =%A�5)(���1�5�� H.=*(./ H.= A��A�= 1 C.D_H G>1�685 H.5)( � E#G!6 % H G-A0(I2 3A768= A % �+=�6"!�1�5�7_)*)(7^<.1# � . � +!Q ÿ g)NO*"08!$>"^<.10KÂLKÆ.108R:(7^"_+ G<ÿHG g

)5#@0C3 X Q 0 L R$.f\ #k083c%4.+gÆÊ�.40C#83<>"(7R|%43<0C08.4#C*a37>"F)(7>"%1.7gBÊ�.108#837>)(7R|%43<0C08.1#8*�3<>"F)(7>-%4.7_8Q X X QOg) � (70 X Q 0 �U!:%'�"(7.4R � (+08F".104g�IÀ9;*"08365c!:>-^;,8.4#C,�#8P-!$,/.1#M5c!:(;^<.1>".408(+,/.1F�#C*a.1%4!$�"%³(+,8!:3<>"#1g¡�v.4%'�">-!:%³(+R

�M.1*a370C, ÿ � ÿ _�UIÀ� '|( X 3<0/(+,83<0Cb=Y[3<0��¡3<9;*"P-,8.40MNO%1!:.4>-%4.7_T��(79 X 08!$F"^<.7_�UL2_ !7P">". �"_Q X5X Qcg �M.f5O!$#8!$3<>H37Y�(+P-,/�"3704¾¿# �U(7#C,8.404¾¿#�,/�".1#8!:#1g

) � ' X Q 0 NOP"F"�-.4.4>-F"0/( � (7>"^?(7RM(7>-F��U3<>-!:%³(jNag '|(79Ug~��08(7%'�e!:>"^�F"36A�>ñ#837Y�,ÀA¡(70C. X P"^7#EP"# Â!:>"^E(7P-,83<9E(�,/!:%V(7>-3<9E(+R$bHF".f,/.4%f,/!$3<>hgMIÀ> & � ��� � � # � � =�6"D%A%A0(.1�5��� 6!: G43A #��G43 & 5G A�= �5�H G>1�685�H L<�+685�: A�= A�5 D%AF685 � 6!:�G / H.=%A �+5�.1�5 A%A�= 1�5�7_�Jk0CRS(7>-F"3"_�÷R:3<0C!:F)(O_ �U(6b Q5Q � Q �"_Q X5X Qcg

) ! � X5X 0 ¢k(7>"!$.4R !<(7%'�e#C3<>�(7>"F ��(+0C,/!$> ��!:>"(708FhgG� �-.£Y[PO,/P"0C.=37YB#83+Y�,ÀA�(70C.E(+>)(7R$bc#C!:#4gGIÀ> 2 3A& E#GVE�= A 6!: � 6!:�G / H.=%A � 5�.1�5 A%A�= 1�5�7_ '�!$9=.108!:%'��_OIÀ08.4R:(7>"Fh_Q X5X5X g

) � ��¢ , X Q 0 ¢T!:R$#8P">��@!$08R$! _mL >">"( �¡�".1Y�,8.404_ '|(7P-0/(T¢T.4(7>h_eNc,8.4*"�-.4>:!-g/#@(70CRS(7>"FÈ_ a (+>"%1b&L2g 'hbO>-%'�h_��37� aM.�iö!$>h_T(7>-F�L�>e,83<>"!$3 �M(79;!:0C. �f �M3 X 08.1F"3"g NO!$9QP"R:(+,/!$>"^�>"3<>-F".1,8.4089;!:>-!:#C,8!:%#Cbc#C,8.49;#G(+,V9QP"RW,/!$*"R:.GR$.15<.1R:#V37Y ( X #C,80/(7%f,/!:37>hgDIÀ>1�+=�6"D%A%A0(.1�5��� 6!:2 6�6 L � � H-��#���� #?_*)(7^<.1#B�H� ��� G _ 6B08>"3"_ � �4.1%'� ��.4*"P X R:!$%7_�L P"^<P-#C, Q X5X QOg L�R:#83D(65+(7!$RS( X R:.V(7# ��(+#/(70KbO��>"!W5<.108#8!W,ÀbH��.1%'�">"!$%³(7R ��.4*�3<0C,�÷I �  ��Ne Q X X Qm X5� g

) ��& # a X + 0 E`3<#8�-!:3 �@(+,'(737�+(O_ �U!:%'�"(7.4R�¢Qg &Æ0C>"#C,4_�iö!:R:R$!S(79 #£g #k08!$#CAB3<R:FÈ_�(7>"F�¢k(³5c!:F a�3+,/�e!:>hgL P-,83<9=(+,/.1F #8P"*-*a3<0K,TY[3<0�*"083<^70/(79 08.fYx(7%1,83<08!$>"^EP-#8!:>-^D!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,/#1g�IÀ> & � � � #����-. ��+=76"D%A%A0(.1�5��� 6!: G43A & 5G A�= 5�H G 1�685�H L �+685�: A�= A�5 D%A 685 � 6!:�G / H.= A � H.1�5G-A�5�H.5 D%Af_�*)(7^<.1#� . � � � � . _-÷R:3<0C.4>"%1.7_)I ,/(7R$b7_a�365<.19 X .40 � � + X _<Q X5X +7g

) 'v(+9 � � 0 '�.4#8R$!:. '|(79=*�3<0K,³geL >-.1AZ#83<R$P-,/!$3<>V37Y)F"! lC�c#K,/08(-¾ #�%43<>-%4P"0C08.4>?,�*-083<^<08(79;9=!$>"^ *"083 X R:.19UgIÀ> �+6 % % E)51 D_H G 1�685 � 6!:6G�3A � ��� _ + G � �"g

+!Q G

Page 130: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

) 'v(+9 G<ÿ 0 '�.4#8R$!:. 'v(+9=*�3<0C,4g�� �-.Q*)(70K,C ,8!:9;.@*)(708R$!S(79;.4>?,4g � ��� 2 =0H.5 �MH#DFG>1�685 � 685 �+6 % ;�E#G A�=��� �FG-A % �f_ + �� Q $fn,+ ./. � + � G _���(³b + GHG7ÿ g

) 'O� ÿHG 0 a (7>-%1btL2g '�bc>"%'��(7>"F ��(70C� �@g���PO,8,/R$.7g&L >�!:>?,/0C3OF"P-%1,/!$3<> ,/3HIÀ>"*-P-, %<JTP-,8*"P-,&(7POÂ,/3<9=(+,/(-g � ( &����.E(H.=FG-A�=�L �+_)Q(� . $]n Q9+ GB� Q �D�O_"NO.1*-,/.19 X .40.+ G<ÿHG g

) '|P-� X Q 0 �¡�"08!$#C,83<*"�".10 '�P"�"0C#4g��v0/(+>"#8R:(+,/!$>"^GY[083<9ÏIKJ�L,83=IÀ#8( X .4R:R$.7g�!'2'2?¸ ���� � � � � �hÄ 2 � Å54D ��¸"Å-ºm¸ �<Å ���K�! !O¹ ��OÄ �94-Å5:��[!'2D�T�O_�L P"^7P"#C,�Q X5X Qcg

) '-K GD� ( 0 a (7>-%1b+'hbc>"%'�2(+>"F2Ã)0C!$,/# K`(<(7>"F"08(7^<.104g<Ã)3<0KA�(+08FV(7>"F X (7%'�?A¡(708F&#8!$9QP"RS(�,/!:37>"# ÊÆ(70K,I'n M>e,8!:9;.4FU#Cbc#C,8.49;#4g.&�5�:�68= % H G 1�685 H.5)(*�+6 % ;�E#G H G>1�685)_ +!Q9+ � Q $fnPQ9+�� � Q ./. _�Nc.4*-,8.49GÂX .10 + GHGD� g

) '-K GD� X$0 a (7>-%1b£L2g 'hbc>"%'��(+>"FEÃ)0C!$,/#�i�g K`(7(7>"F"08(7^<.401ghÃ)3<0KA�(70CFE(+>"F X (7%'�?A�(70CFE#C!:9QP"R:(+,/!$3<>"#� *)(+0C,;I'n �>?,/!$9=.1F #KbO#K,/.19=#1g &�5�:�68= % H G 1�685 H.5)( �+6 % ;�E#GIH G 1�685)_ + Q9+ ��Q $fnPQ9+�� � Q ./. _NO.4*O,/.49 X .10 + G.GD� g

) '�bc> G � 0 a (7>-%1b 'hbc>"%'�hg �B1 �FG>= 1VJME#G A0( � L )68= 1 G�3 % �fg �U3708^?(7> �@(7P-Y[9=(7>">È_cN-(7>;Ã)0/(7>"%1!:#C%43"_#�¡L&_+ GHG �Og

) �U!:> X + 0 L >?,/37!:>". �U!$>".7g�� �-.d3c%1,/(7^<3<>Z( X #C,/08(7%1,£F-3<9E(+!:>hg�IÀ> �+=�6"D%A%A0(.1�5��� 6!: G43A� 1D83#G�3( 68=9881�5� �+685�: A�= A�5 D%A<685���A ! A�= �"A �+5�.1�5 A%A�= 1�5�7�B(���� � � �-.���_?NOP-,8,8^?(70K,³_1#k.4089=(7>?b<_JT%1,/3 X .10 Q X5X +<g

) �32P"R G<ÿ 0 JTRS(+Y��32P"R:R$.401g � ��A�= 1 C.D_H G 1�685 �+5 !�1�=7685 % A�5G :�68=�& ��� � E�G 6 % H G H ��H��"A0( 685 & 68= �% H L 1�� A0(:� AFG H-� 2 3A768= �+g�Ê��)¢�,/�".1#8!$#4_È�v.4%'�->"!:#C%'�". �>"!W5<.108#8!W, 2(+,��32P">"%'�".1>h_ �dP">"!:%'�È_#@.1089=(7>?b<_ + G.G<ÿ g

) a & X + 0 !7.40C.492bdi�g aM!:9;9=.10�(+>"F �U!$%'�)(7.4R·¢Qg &�0C>"#C,4g@Nc,'(�,/!:%@5<.108!W�)%³(+,8!:3<>U37YÆF-bc>)(79;!:%4(7R:RWbF".1,8.4%f,/.4F�*"0C3<^<0/(+9 !$>e5+(70C!S(7>?,8#4nMIÀ>e,8.4^<08(+,/!$>"^H¢k(7!$�73<>¬(+>"F &`N��9% !<(³5+(-g&IÀ>J�+=�6"D%A%A0(-�1�5���6!:�� � � �-. � & 1�= �FG ( 68=98��7367;�685�� E)5G>1 % A ��A�= 1 C.D_H G 1�685)_7Ê�(708!$#4_<Ã)08(7>"%4.+_%!7P"RWb.Q . _Q X5X +7g

) a & X Q7( 0 ��37� a�. iö!$>D(7>-F �U!:%'�"(7.4RT&�08>"#K,³g KÆ.408!WY�bc!:>"^VF"!:#K,/0C! X P-,8.4FE(7R:^<3708!$,8�"9;#Æ5c!:(&F-bc>)(79;!:%(7>)(7RWbc#8!:#H(+>"F ,8�".43708.49 *"08365c!:>"^-g���.1%'�">"!:%4(7R ��.4*�3<0C, ÿ ��+<_��UIÀ�k_ ��(+#8#/(+%'�cP-#8.1,C,/#IÀ>"#C,8!$,8P-,/.@37Y���.1%'�">"3<R$3<^7b7_���(79 X 0C!:F"^<.+_<��(7#C#/(7%'�eP"#C.1,C,/#4_ ��(³b Q � _<Q X5X QOg

) a & X Q X 0 !7.40C.492bHi�g�a�!$9=9;.40 (+>"F �U!$%'�)(7.1R�¢Qg &�0C>"#C,4g�L P-,83<9=(+,/!$%k^<.4>".10/(+,8!:3<>d37Y·*"083<^70/(79#8*�.4%1!$�)%4(+,/!$3<>"#4g IÀ> �+=�6"D%A%A0(.1�5��� 6!: G�3A�&�5G-A�= 5�H G>1�685�H L<��� % ;6���1 E % 685 � 6!:�G / H.= A2TA �FG 1�5�BH.5)( � 5�H L ����1 �f_"*)(7^7.4# Q . Q � Q8�;QO_ ��3<9;.7_OI ,'(7RWb<_�Q5QO_<Q X X QOg

) a & X Q+% 0 !7.40C.492bQi�g aM!:9;9=.10�(7>-F �U!$%'�)(7.1R)¢QgK&�08>"#K,³gaIÀ>e5+(70C!S(7>?,Æ!$>-Y[.40C.4>"%1.�Y[370�#C,/(+,/!$% %'�".4%'�<Â!:>"^-n�L > .49;*"!:0C!:%³(+R .15+(7R$P)(+,8!:3<>hg�IÀ> �+=�6"D%A%A0(.1�5��� 6!:QG43A � ��� �9& )H� ��& 2 . � G�3&�5G-A�= 5�H G>1�685�H L ��� % ;6���1 E % 685�G43A & 6 E)5)(KH G>1�685 � 6!: � 6!:�G / H.=%A �+5�.1�5 A%A�=�1�5�1��& ���#���� # ��_ �¡�)(70CR:.1#C,/37>h_�N�� _ a�3657.49 X .40 Q XB� Q QO_Q X X QOg

+ .5X

Page 131: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

) a & # , X/. 0 ��37�'a�.Viö!:>h_)�d!:%'�)(7.1Rv¢QgT&�0C>"#C,4_ÈNe,/.4*-�".4>*!-g #@(708R:(7>"Fh_�¢T!$R:#CP"> ���$08R�� _"(+>"F'a�(7>"%1b'hbO>-%'�hg M#8!:>-^2#8!$9QP"R:(+,/.1FE.f\O.1%4P-,8!:3<>�!$>=5<.108!WY�bO!$>"^2F-!:#C,808! X P-,/.1F�(7R$^<3<08!W,/�"9;#4gaIÀ> � ���� � & � ��� � & 6 E)=�G43 &�5G-A�= 5�H G>1�685�H L �+685�: A�= A�5 D%AB685 ��A�= 1 C.D_H G 1�685�� � 6 (#AFL � 3A%D'881�5� H.5)(� J��FG>=0H#DFG &�5G-A�= ; =%AFG H G 1�685)_ a�.1A E`3<08��_ aM.1A E`3708��_ !<(7>eP)(70Kb GB� +5+7_<Q X5X/. g

) a�!:9 X Q7( 0 !7.40C.492bZi�g4aM!:9;9=.104göL PO,/3<9=(+,/!$%H^<.4>".10/(+,8!:3<>ñ(7>"Fñ%'�".1%'�e!:>"^�37Y@*-083<^<08(79 #8*�.4%]Â!$�)%4(+,/!$3<>"#1g���(7#K,/.401¾ #H,/�-.4#8!$#4_ �dIÀ�ý¢T.4*)(+0C,/9;.4>?,H37Y &�R:.1%1,/0C!:%4(7R6&�>"^<!$>".4.108!:>-^ (+>"F�¡3<9;*"P-,/.10�NO%4!$.4>"%1.7_T��(79 X 0C!:F"^7.7_<�UL&_)��(³b�Q X5X QOg

) a�!:9 X Q X$0 !7.40C.492b¬i�g<aM!:9;9=.104g2L�P-,/379E(+,8!:%Q^7.4>".10/(+,8!:3<>�(7>"F�%'�".1%'�c!$>"^�3+Y¡*"0C3<^<08(79 #C*a.1%4!$�OÂ%³(+,8!:3<>-#4g���.1%'�">"!$%³(7R��M.1*a370C, ÿD� QO_C�UIÀ� '|( X 3<0/(+,83<0Cb�Y[370 �¡3<9;*"P-,8.40 NO%4!$.4>"%1.7_ ��(79£ÂX 08!$F"^<.+_)�UL2_ !7P">-. + X _<Q X5X QOg �M.f5c!:#8!$3<>H37Y·(7P-,/�-3<04¾¿# ��(7#C,8.401¾ # ,/�-.4#8!$#4g

) aTN G � 0 ��3 X !S(7# aM!:*"�+3mA�(7>"F �@37>"0/(7F=NOR$!:>"FÈgaI&%<J (7P-,83<9E(�,'(k!:>£IÀ#/( X .1R:R:. % � J '�g�IÀ> �+=�6"D%A%A0(-�1�5��� 6!: G�3A.&�5G-A�= 5�H G>1�685�H L0( 68=98��7367; 685 2 �7;A �9:�68= �+=�6�6!: � H.5)(7�+=76?.=0H % �f_�*)(7^<.1#+ X + � +5+ G _ 6��(7#C,/(7Fh_�NcAB.4F-.4>h_ + GHG �-g

) aTN X + 0 ��37� aM.¬iö!:>ö(7>"F #kP"#K,'(³5<3~N-(7>?,/37#4g�� �-.�IKJ�LMÂÀ¢k(7!:�+3<>ñ%437>">".4%f,/!$3<>hn &�>)( X R:!:>-^F-bc>)(79;!:% !$>?57(+08!S(+>e,EF"!:#C%4365<.10Cb�!$>�IKJML¼*-083<^<08(79;#4g 2K!)ÅOº+¹����_�#� � �hÄ 2 � Å54D ��32'4 ��¸��7¸"Å<¹ ����)º�! �a_�NO.1*-,/.19 X .10 Q X5X +<g

) Ê·(7P G . 0 '|(6A�0C.4>"%1.B� g|Ê�(7P"R$#83<>hg2� �".=IÀ#8( X .4R:R$.Q08.fY[.40C.4>"%1.=9=(7>eP)(7Rrg2�v.4%'�">"!$%³(7R ��.4*�3<0K, Q ÿ/. _�>"!W5<.108#8!W,ÀbH37Y���(79 X 0C!:F"^<.+_ �¡3<9;*"P-,8.40 '|( X 3<0/(+,83<0Cb7_ + GHG . g

) Ê�.1, ÿ + 0 #V(+0Cb '�g|Ê�.f,/.108#837>hg �dbe,/�-#2( X 3<P-,@,8�".£9QP-,/P"(7R�.f\O%4R$P"#8!$3<>�*"083 X R:.49dg &�5�:�68= % H G 1�685�+=76"D%A � ��1�5� @ AFGVG-A�= �f_ + Q�� . $]n + + � � +5+ �-_ !7P">-. + G<ÿ +<g

) Ê�3cF X/. 0 L >"F-08.³(+#GÊ�3cF".4R$#8�e! g�NO37Y�,ÀA¡(708.=9=3cF".4RÆ%'�".1%'�e!:>"^�A�!W,/�j( X #C,80/(7%f,/!$3<>j0C.1�)>".19=.1>?,³gHIÀ>� �J� � & � ��� � & 6 E�=�G�3 &�5G-A�=�5�H G 1�685�H L �+685�: A�= A�5 D%A 685 ��A�= 1 C.D_H G 1�685�� � 6 (#AFL � 3A%D'881�5�H.5)( � J��FG>=0H#DFG &�5G-A�= ; =%AFG H G 1�685)_a�.fA E`3<0C��_ aM.1A E`3708��_�!<(7>eP)(70Kb GB� +5+7_Q X5X . g

) Ê`Ê #-, G � 0 � #C57.1,/379=!$0�ÊvgmÊ�.f,/08365�_7L�>">)(�Ê�37^<3<#Cb<(7>?,/#1_eNc,/.1*"�".1> !-g #@(708R:(7>"Fh_ K !:%f,/3<0 '�P"%'�)(+>"^<%43-_(7>"F a (7>-%1b�L2g '�bc>"%'�Èg �¡3<9;*"P-,8.40  (7#C#8!:#K,/.1F57.408!W�)%³(�,/!:37>3+YD(7>(7R$^<3<0C!$,/�-9 Y[370%43<>-%4P"0C08.4>?,ö,/!$9=.1#C,/(79=*-#4g IÀ> �M.1!:>"�)(+08F #k37,��1�".4!$>É(7>"F !<(+> 6¡08.1F".40C.4�7.+_�.1F"!WÂ,/3<0C#4_ & 68= % H L �@A �"D�= 1 ;�G>1�685=2�A%D73)5154ME A � &��� 2 3A768= �� � ; ;�L 1 D_H G 1�685 ��� H.5)( 2 6�6 L ��rÃvJ �·� & %7Ê`NO��KQ¾ G �-n !73<!$>?,¬IÀ>?,/.40C>)(+,8!:3<>)(+R �¡3<>-Y[.108.4>-%4.Z3<>Ã�37089=(7R2¢T.1#8%108!:*O,/!:37>��.1%'�">"!$�cP-.4#�Y[3<0�¢T!:#C,808! X P-,/.1FGNcbc#K,/.49;#Æ(7>"F �¡3<9=92P">"!:%4(+,/!$3<>&ÊÆ0C37,/3c%437R:#4_+(7>"F£Ê�0C37,/3+Â%43<RhNO*�.4%4!W�)%³(�,/!:37>h_-�v.4#K,/!:>-^"_"(7>-F KÆ.408!W�)%³(�,/!:37>h_��@(7!$#8.108#8R:(7P-,8.408>È_ #k.4089=(7>?b<_"JT%1,/3 X .10+ GHG � $f_"*)(+^<.4# Q GB� �H�"g �¡�)(+*"9E(+>� � (7R$R _8+ GHG �-g

) Ê�� � X + 0 L 9;!:0�Ê�>cP-.4R:!r_hNc!$,85+(7>-!$, �MP"(7�h_a(7>"F '�.4>-3<08.��ÈP"%'��g L PO,/3<9=(+,/!$%&F-.4F"P"%f,/!W5<.257.408!W�)%³(mÂ,/!$3<>�A�!W,/��!$>e5c!$#8! X R:.£!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,/#1gUIÀ> 2 6�6 L � H.5)( � L )68= 1 G�3 % � :�68= G�3A � 5�H L ����1 �BH.5)(�+685 �FG>=�EDFG>1�685 6!:H�����FG A % � � 2 � � � � ��_6573<R:P"9;. Q X . +¡37Y @<A%DFGVE�= A�606 G A � 1�5��+6 % ;�E#G A�=� D�1 A�5 D%Af_"*)(7^7.4# ÿ Q ��G � _ #k.4>"365+(-_)I ,/(7R$b7_"L *"0C!:R Q � �-_<Q X X +<g

)��M!$> X5X 0 !7P"#8#C! �M!$>e,/(7>".1>hg�L >è!$,8.408(+,/!W5<.H(7R$^<3<08!W,/�"9ýY[3<0G#Kbc>e,8�".4#C! �1!:>"^�!:>?5+(708!:(7>?,/#4g�IÀ> �+=�6 �D%A%A0(.1�5��� 6!:6G�3A � A ! A�5G A%A�5G�3 66H G>1�685�H L �+685�: A�=%A�5 D%A 685 � =�G>1 C.D�1VH L)& 5G AFL L 1D#A�5 D%A H.5)(

+ . +

Page 132: 10 23 45$' 23& 06 * - Research | MIT CSAILgroups.csail.mit.edu/pag/pubs/thmprove-newin-mengthesis.pdf · Ph\ JLKf^*UqdfUqk]s ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕ Õ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ«ÕYÕYÕ«ÕYÕ

2 /4AFL :�G43��+685�: A�= A�5 D%AB685�&�55 6"! H G 1 ! A � ; ;�L 1 D_H G 1�685 � 6!: � =FG 1 C.D�1VH L9&�5G-AFL L 1D#A�5 D%Af_?*)(7^<.1#ÿ5X � �cÿ +5+<_OL P"#K,/!:>È_)��;Q_ !7P"RWb .5XB� L�P"^<P"#K, . _)Q X5X X g

)�� �VN X Q 0 JT08>)( ��(.�+_�Ê��"!:R$!:* �k3O3<*-9E(7>È_)(7>"F ��(70CbUNc�)(³A@g NO.19E(7>?,8!:%V(7>"3<9=(7RWbDF".f,/.4%f,/!$3<>�!$>3<>"R$!:>".GF)(�,'(H#83<P"0C%4.1#4gEIÀ>O& � ��� � � # � �+=�6"D%A%A0(.1�5��� 6!: G�3A�#��G43�& 5G A�= 5�H G 1�685�H L �+685 �: A�= A�5 D%A 685�� 6!:�G>/ H.= A �+5�.1�5 A%A�= 1�5�7_�JT08R:(7>"F"3-_"÷R$3<08!$F)(-_���(³b Q5Q � Q �-_Q X5X QOg

)�� � X5X 0 !-g�L >?,/3<>-!:3 ��(79 �:0C. �] ��3 X 08.1F"3"gÆÊ�(7!:0C.4F�#C!:9QP-RS(+,8!:3<>D3+Y�I&%<J�(+P-,/3<9=(+,/(-_�NO.1*-,/.19 X .10Q X5X5X g ��(7#K,/.10B37Y &�>"^<!$>".4.108!:>-^2(7>-F 6�(+%'�".4R$3<0Æ37Y�Nc%4!:.1>"%4.M!:> �¡3<9;*"P-,8.40BNO%4!$.4>"%1. (+>"F&�>"^<!:>-.4.40C!:>"^£� �".1#8!$#4_8��(7#C#/(7%'�eP"#C.1,8,8#TIÀ>"#K,/!$,8P-,/.@37Y��v.4%'�">"37R:3<^7b7_���(79 X 0C!:F"^7.7_<�UL&g

)¿NOL(# #-, G/. ( 0 ! � 08^7.4> ÃBg�N � ^?(<(+08FO L >"F".108#C.4>h_aNc,8.4*"�".1>!-g #@(708R:(7>"Fh_ !73<�"> K2g #@PO,8,'(+^"_ a (7>-%1bHL2g'hbO>-%'�h_"(7>-F=L�>">)(2Êv3<^<3<#Kb?(7>?,8#4g �¡3<9;*"P-,8.40KÂÀ(7#8#C!:#K,/.4F;#8!$9QP"R:(+,/!$3<>G*"083c37Y[#1gÈIÀ> �¡3<#C,/(7#�¡3<P"0C%43<P X .1,8!:#1_a.1F"!$,83<04_ �+6 % ;�E#G A�= � � 1 (#A0( ��A�= 1 C.D_H G>1�685 � � ,/�UIÀ>?,/.40C>)(+,8!:3<>)(+R �¡37>-Y[.40 Â.4>"%1.7_(�¡L K2¾ G . _ &�R:3<P">-F)(-_1#k08.4.1%4.+_ !7P->". % !7P-R$b + GHG/. $]_75<3<R$P"9;.�� G�� 37Y @<A%DFG[E)= A 6 6 G-A �1�5 �+6 % ;�E�G-A�= � D�1 A�5 D%Af_-*)(+^<.4# .5XD� �$. + G g"NO*"0C!:>"^<.10K KÆ.408R:(7^"_8+ GHG/. g

)¿NOL(# #-, G/. X 0 ! � 08^7.4>Uág�N � ^?(7(708FO L >"F-.408#C3<>h_�Nc,8.4*"�-.4>!-g #V(70CRS(7>-Fh_�!73<�">GK2g #@P-,C,'(7^-_a (7>-%1bHL2g'hbO>-%'�h_"(7>-F=L�>">)(2Êv3<^<3<#Kb?(7>?,8#4g �¡3<9;*"P-,8.40KÂÀ(7#8#C!:#K,/.4F;#8!$9QP"R:(+,/!$3<>G*"083c37Y[#1gÈIÀ> �¡3<#C,/(7#�¡3<P"0C%43<P X .1,8!:#1_-.4F-!$,/3704_ & 1 :�G�3�+685�: A�= A�5 D%AB685I�+6 % ;�E�G-A�= � � 1 (#A0( ��A�=�1 C.D_H G 1�685)_e*)(7^<.1#.5XD� �1. + G _ � .10/(7�eR:!$3<>h_(�¡08.f,/.7_ !7P->". + GHG . g"Nc*"08!$>"^<.40 ÂLKÆ.108RS(+^ '�.4%f,/P"0C. a�37,8.4# !:> �¡3<9£Â*"P-,8.40 NO%4!$.4>"%1. � G�� g

)¿N #&NcL ' G<ÿ 0 �M3 X .10C,/3VNc.4^?(7R:(-_ �M(7!:>-.40 #@(³A�R:!:%'��_ ! � 08^<.1>EN � ^?(<(70CFOÂÀL�>"F".108#8.1>h_e(7>"F a�(7>"%1b 'hbO>-%'�hg'�!$5<.1>".4#C#~!$> ,8!:9;.4Fø(7>"FøP">?,/!$9=.1F #Cbc#C,8.49;#4g &�5�:�68= % H G>1�685 H.5)( �+6 % ;�E�G H G>1�685)_+���+ � Q $fn,+5+ G � + � +<_���(70C%'� + G.G<ÿ g

+ . Q