20
160000765 I-I'; l Ill 'I['j I llf jl! O 0 CI Z Z g I II I%I ;= =la I I rg ~ IU 'iI lIR, ',Iilig I I I,l It!a II II II !jlD I ~ Im i iej( e al rrr C 0 IO c 0 LL tL'g O o E O. 0 0 e c E E 0 e I O O C (a .0 0 m N g 'C ar Om al I IL X UI CO wD Z I CII Cl Z CD e rrr ta IA e IOI Ia p 0 ID 0 0 V Z 0 V O CO K D p 0 O Z Z 0 C 0 C 2 m e al I ta 'P IO e ta e tD 0 al CL e 0 0 J3 E Z C 0 nl 0 al '0 0 CO R III IO E Z 9 o. m 0 al 'e Crt 0 CO z I- I O 0 0 C Clf E E D I- 0 CD C I C C 0 CO C 0 N C CO 0 C 0 V C K. E 0 O I 0 X Z O IO I- Z V CL D. '0 al 0 c e C y O Eoo CD 0 m c g rrf oCLe 0 ID CD '0 Crl ego= 00 IEZ. la 0 rto ID C nl O 1D 0= e e OP CL> C> Om ta c c rn rQ e III al m CO c ~ .C o m IN p c IE Crl 0 ) eCO Ci E lcf e ee 1-c e+ Cr E c Crt W .D 0 0 0 0 ID eomCO m- e mm Q E C C e trr CD Pcm) 0 8 0 Z I CI Q Y IL ~C III O mL O X Z CI 0 te C IO I'0 Z 5 IO III ILI 0 O 0 C ID E 0 rto '0 e ID CI CO CD CD ih IO CI 0 8 IC Io CD 0\ Cl 1V al 0 e IC III 0 Ol 0 e g CO O. e a! Ol CL Ol IO 0 ID E m 0 IR '0 Ol tD CI CO Of Ol Of Cl C 0 'Cl ID 13 0 0 CI CO CD r CD Cl e 0 m CLI e at Ol ta 0 O. CL CO 4 0 Z Ol E Tl 0 0 CQ e al Cl CO 8 C D 1I 'E 8 IC CO C7 Ol Ca Cl X e III ID 0 O c ro CO Ia ID

160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

160000765

I-I';

l Ill'I['j

I

llf

jl! O

0CIZ

Z

g I II I%I

;==laI I rg ~ IU

'iI

lIR,

',Iilig I

I I,lIt!aII II

II

!jlD I ~Im i iej(

eal

rrr C0 IOc 0

LLtL'g

O

o E

O.0 0ec EE 0e I

O

O C(a .00 m

N

g 'C

ar

Omal

IIL XUI CO

wD

Z

I

CII

ClZ

CDerrr

ta

IAeIOIIa

p

0ID00V

Z0VOCO

KD

p

0O

ZZ

0

C0C

2mealIta'P

IO

etaetD0alCL

e0

0J3EZC0nl0

al'0 0

CORIIIIOEZ9

o. m0

al 'e

Crt

0CO

zI-IO00

CClf

EEDI-0CDCICC

0CO

C0

NC

CO

0

C0

V

CK.E0OI0XZO

IOI-ZV

CLD.

'0al 0c eC y OEoo

CD —0mc g rrf

oCLe0 ID CD'0 Crl

ego=00 IEZ.

la0rto IDC —nlO 1D0= e eOP CL>C> Omta c crn

rQ e IIIal

m CO c ~.C o m INp c IE Crl

0) eCO

Ci Elcf e ee1-c e+Cr E cCrt W .D0

00 0 ID

eomCOm-e mm

Q EC

C e trrCD

Pcm)

0

80Z

I

CI

QYIL~CIII

O

mL

O

XZCI

0te

C

IO

I'0

Z5

IO IIIILI0 O

0

CID

E

0rto'0eID

CI

COCDCD

ih

IOCI

0

8IC

IoCD0\

Cl1Val

0eIC

III

0Ol0 eg CO

O. ea!Ol

CL

Ol IO

0

IDE

m

0IR'0OltD

CICOOfOl

OfClC0

'ClID1300CI

COCD

r

CDCl

e0

m CLI

e atOlta—0O.

CL

CO 4

0ZOl

E

Tl

00CQ

eal

ClCO

8

CD1I'E

8IC

CO

C7Ol

CaCl

XeIII

ID0Oc

ro COIa ID

Page 2: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

0Z

dlE2IgC

0CD

ClQt0

8

C0

P8

CL

o

CDCl'0SClSX

lU

Ql

0C0

CD

tgDICD

=:8Do0

I

CtCDO

0ZCSE

00CO

0ID

«C

ClCtlC«I

DlCt

0D

E8

CU

Cl

0Ot

4lESaa

ID

I

ClCtCt«C

0ZCtgE

0

00CU

ClID0CI

ClCV

DlCtC0OS

lg0\IID

CL'l

CE

04!COl

EWaO.

CD

CQl

E

W

0ID0CtCl0

CA

Q

0«7S

8

IA

Ct

oCt

84«

IUC«I

Cl'00C4tECl

CI

CD

WCDlg

fLIA

CIC«l

0Z

COl

E

VlC

00NOOtIDCI

IA

Cl

OlCdCt

C00S

IA

CICIo

T7Ol

CJOlX

lU

IDDl

4lO CD

0 OlCg0 m0

Egt IA4) «0 O

OD 44W 0I5 Z

C

gl

00CD'0ClCl0

ID

OAloCO

Al

C0OIP

00ID

Ck

IA

OCll

ClS OO O

CC0 sCg0 m

Cl 0

OD C«I

.W 00Z

CCl

E

WC

00ID

QtQl0

IA

C't

Ctt

C00Qt

IA

oCD

0Ql

0QlIC

lU

SOp O0 S

DlC Ww aE

CIO C«l

lgCI Z

IU0I0Z

0

S

E

0D.W

C0 C

0 O.'00 Ot

C 0SId

Ol .—0Cl

C lm

C0 S'Cl

Ct '0) 'llE

0W

ct U00 I-Ol Cl

0—0 44Cg

IO

E 5<S0

ID

8)ldIP

0

0Cd

I-0S

Zi4!0

dllddl

Cg

EE

C0Cl

OI

S

D 0OI W

IDa df

C C

4t W

W

c ttlW CE m0

o aaa

0IgS

S0N C

AI

td

IA

OQl

«C

ECtl

CCD'7 0gC Cf

g DlIA dl

W0

Cg 'DC1V 5 C

CP

E

80 O W

Id 0 CIQ

E '00 Cl

Cl

CP S0ld

Qt .. IQ

CD

C Z0 0

Z O.

E

C4«I

D

Page 3: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

3.60000765I"> Z 0 1 Q ttI a 6 Ii 0 a e N

W '0

CL IU

'0I5tlt

N

Q

~o 5«ZaO o- 055 f C>r ca r

(5 O ca

g gIA I0 0cc r

AIN

0N

ca af af0 r(0 l«f CaN or N0 0 0

IA NID ID

CCI0 00 0

LeE

cF oC0 0 00 0 00 0 00 0 0

>o @a0 ci0 00 CI0 O

0CCl

Cl

1lW gof E

7 Po

CCCl Cil

DtL Wf15 C(f(5 I

V ta0 N.CL ((ffC5L 00 NN C0W

pE cLol Cf

260 0e D.

ma e$ +Cl

p8

5IC(5—E 0e CECa 0m 00 ~m c5.--

0 Ja

e mUJ(5 (5OD (5

5I Cl 13o eW cmec oI- C

Cl 'D D

0'jCLCL

«C

e

0CCC

0

Qe

0'O

W

Cl

Q00N

CICl

000

QCl

CeC(ft5

eCll

CDf

Cl'D

W0ta ~CC

Ia

0m

0

ClV

N I0—~

m«5

Cl

I- g0

CWgEaCI

V 0(5(5 130 I5eNea~af l5C 0ma

c cEec e(5 C

eCICCl '(50

al0

0

E EI- E0p I-CIC Y

Crf 0crr

QcCC 0

N

2~Cl D

me 0

C9 emQ

1fNC CfIC 'Cl

Ec5 E

Ct.NCI

IF0 e

NI5mc e0 CC—c 0«Ccc

(5 eN Y

Cl E fo~i e m'P D

«C tA Q laN' —NNONE LN

. DCLWtci a 0.15

Oar «IN>Dt(ft. rn L o.

l508D >e

e O mcCoeeeOC15 O

WCQo) Cl ocCl 0 Ce4--~

Cfl 0 (5Cl CL E

«5O(om~~ cocc >, E.co.c e

me D.BN-tc E e a

0WO>o00 eN ICCE

O,X C CWZ aEOD reNmtc m

c . em ci:2 cf

Je(5

Ot50Cl

0lo

ECt

E

tt!"0e

NCl(E0(5N

Cl

Cl

'OexeCCI

CC

«5'(5I-Iat5

eCl

5(

5OCl 5ct e

Cl

m Dt5

CW

(II IC

CC

0Cl (5ew 0EolCC molCt

2 CO"C

ta

Cf

LC1 Dt5

Cl

00 c(5 (A

CL EQ E(5 0c I-(5

ol (0(5 C—0> cn0 m0 0

Tle (5

L

< l3NNmEN E 0

mCt5

ca~ 15ot xe

tlf CC Ce C

IC

IU0 IU

OO-" "

'0 tlrCl

m —e) ~~CA

W (5 eCL Ee w

(5

0IUI-«I.'L'

UI

IU

0 .CLeW LEe tav e

C5I Q

CL(5

o Ee0EIL Q

Ol

Qaf 5P9 C)

0(5I-

Cl

I—L

IDQ

CCl

EWl

ClN0Cl

Cl«5

VIoClal CIaC(5

V

OQ I—

5E

I-

Cl0ca

(«I

eOlCC

C3

e

l5

«L'5

I-

NN

C

C0

ccN

0

0CA

EEI-

r53

N r«C (tf

ZI—C

Dm0 C0- 0

CAca

0C

IUcnOla

O(5

'E ce C

6 v

C5 OI CAO

ca t«f caN or N0 0 0

laIA Ca

caO 00 0

CI0 DI0 NIA

CACI

CaCD

cc c0

NCf Ctf

m '02

ICIN

CDe NOl Nm 0

X Co Ia

Cl 0III Y NO O

> mE

I- Ia O

Q 0 0

Page 4: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

CI

CIIA

o

C2ItlCUl8T)X'

tttl«OOeIO Ia0nl 0m al80

tsCC

I- Y

S

0,UcIO

C«0OO

0OI

Ll.0 cZI

I

ra 0

0 00C80-0 IV

RZ0 st0I alOl

OI 0Ic4OI

mC Ol0C Ol400 ~

~ cU,Vfce ~'2 IIIOI

s ccC Ite Ia

m

CO

OlIO

«cN

'U

OO US

0t S0 Iglil '00 eCC

IOl'0I0'000OlIOIO

IO

0ILS0

O0SIO

0

CSCc e

IO

ol0

UP. e

0OD

IO

C0 0IO

IO,'0.y t4B osV cm e

ILI

e cI- 0

z0Ol

0Z00

0IaIO

I-T7COl

T7ID

Ol

Ol

Ol

cm

e

CmID

e

0tDIll

ItlC0

04IO

IO

'aCIO

OI

Ol

0tD

0'D

tD

-0OI IIIa%

IIIeop

4

to 00 m

s vcsm=ES Ecepm c

00ts CS Isa3'

Io0 ILSc>o0 S U

LE cs eC ce

C'ccm Olttl t

c cm U

IOI «OI

0 g0 cp«Z

0 lJ0 0 ol 0o 4Lco~PEels 40'0

DL g-m ol 0IO0 e m o.IO5 IDO.0

C mls

4 s eCL 4Cmass

IOcc oc

>U 0

SCI Ol

m 0 SOCC

0 0acmQ op"c.ts OI Ol

V Ol

0 Uma ace EDLR5 K~Ko o.m

Page 5: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

'"? 0 I F P~'j570."I160000765

DONE AND EXECUTED this 11 day of April, 2016 by a majority of the Virginia Gas and OilBoard.

Chait man, Bradley C. Lambert

DONE AND PERFORMED this 11 day of April, 2016 by Order of the Virginia Gas and Oil Board.

Rick CooperPrincipal Executive to thestaff, Virginia Gas and Oil Board

COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF RUSSELL

My Commission expires: Juiy 31, 2017

Acknowledged onthis JJ - dayof M',20 4 personally before mesnotarypubllcI-Ik ,

(

in and for the Commonwealth of Virgihia, appeared Bradley C. Lambert, being duly sworn diddepose and say that he is the Chairman of the Virginia Gas and Oil Board and appeared RickCooper, being duly sworn did depose and say that he is Principal Executive to the staff of theVirginia Gas and Oil Board, that they executed the same and was authorized to do so.

".,Gg'+.

'QTAriY '

qr: PUBLICRFG. tr26294IlVT CC",,'. GSi„n

SF'. TIi DtIllttlllint

'age

Number 5.

Page 6: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

PETITIONER: CNX Gas Company LLC DIVISION OF GAS AND OIL

DOCKET NO: VGOB 98-0324-0835-04

RELIEF SOUGHT: (1) DISBURSEMENT FROM ESCROW REGARDING TRACT(S) 4A, 4D (2) ANDAUTHORIZATION FOR DfRECT PAYMENT OF ROYALTIES (3) AND DISMISSAL OF COAL OWNERSPURSUANT TO CODE OF VIRGINIA SECTION 45.1-361.22:2.

HEARING DATE: On June 16, 2015, the Virginia Gas and Oil Board, cn its own motion, granted the Director ofthe Division of Gas and Oil the authority to process coal owner dismissal disbursements thathave no pending denciencies or issues. Code of Virginia Section 45.1-361.22:2. Etfectivedate: July1,2015.

DRILLING UNIT: AA38

BUCHANAN, TAZEWELL COUNTY, VIRGINIA

PETITION FOR ORDER OF DISBURSEMENT OF ESCROW FUNDS

1.Petitioner and its counsel

Petitioner is CNX Gas Company LLC, 627 Cleypool Hill Mall Road, Cedar Bluff, VA 24609, (276)596-5075. Petitioner's counsel is Mark A. Swarlz, Hillard 6 Swartz, LLP, 122 Capital Street, Suite201, Charleston, WV 25301.

2. Regef Sought

(1) the disbursement of escrowed funds heretofore deposited with the Board's Escrow Agent(s)attributable to of Tract(s) 4A 8 4D as depicted upon the annexed Table; and (2) authorization tobegin paying royalties directly to Glenward Jason Shorlt, Tommy Shortt, and Kenneth Wingo

3.Legal Authority

Va. Code Ann. g 45.1-361.1et seq., 4 VAC 25-160-140.,and relevant Virginia Gas and OilBoard Orders ("Board ) heretofore promulgated pursuant to law.

4. Type of Well(s)

Coalbed Methane

5.Factual basis for relief requested

Page Number 6.

Page 7: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

a. Glenward Jason Shortt, Tommy Shorlt, and Kenneth Wingo is the gas claimant in Tracts 4A 84D. As such Glenward Jason Shortt, Tommy Shortt, and Kenneth Wingo are entitled to 100'Ya ofthe CBM royalties now in escrow and as may be hereafter payable. See Va. Code Ann. () 45.1-361.22:2.A.b. That CNX Gas Company LLC has given the notice(s) mquired by () 45.1-361.22.2.Ato allconflicting claimants identified in the above referenced pooling Order and any supplementalOrdem pertaining thereto.c. That none of the conffiofing claimants noticed have provided, within 45 days of the notice(s)given as provided in b. above, Ihe Board, its designated agent the Director of the Division of Gasand Oil, the Operator and/or the Applicant evidence of either an agreement regarding theescrowed funds/royalties or a proceeding regarding same.d. Thai a detailed accounting in accordance with the applicable provisions of tJ 45.1-361.22issubmitted herewith and identified as Exhibit J.e. That an Exhibil identified as Table 1 is annexed hereto, and it specifies how the disbursement(s) is to be calculated and paid by the escrow agent.f. That Va. Code Ann. t) 45.1-361.22:2.A.further provides that the Operator shall pay suchroyalties as may hereafter be payable directly to Ihe gas claimant Glenward Jason Shortt, TommyShortt, and Kenneth Winqo and not escrow same. See Exhibit EE annexed hereto.

6. Attestation

The foregoing Petition to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief is true and cormct.

Page Number 7.

Page 8: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

ett tteu eA «I tw ~cy ee ee~ueetu, Net

~t~ It~eu ~l t atftu ~

wygaae e e lt ee tee eeetIt sa eeattit teL

,e ertAlt~c ceceoroot

r ~'

EXHI8IT AOAKlf008 F IELQ

I%IT AA88FOACE FQQLTItC

VG08-88 W M4 ~8~MC GOB~ LLC sell Wooe oef guest — ~™

troat oe De@et lon autocracy jtFW~ JCMTA

Ccenty 4lelaeecilagaL OIetrlot ~<Qge SPgla0$ goocec CV4tule Olot le o oee Olot ~ l le ed Olet

eev< 1/9'!L >oeruuro orat alcoor or Lieu@ceo Loco sLe4gp~

~~ONAL

Page Number g.

Page 9: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

CNX 6ag Cagftyaxg ILLtRT Ak-BS

CocucocncraalSc ftcai Company, $bact g $fohu fk Ferrp $65 Acue Sbso$ -AZ $GnarsleRecerra Cord~~-Bahur trabcage Cent leanedXnozGceehthed Gorporsthm hbourlhnbrsgeCoalfccaerdGlGf Gsa ~ILQ -QiL Gae and CRhf leaned$7.76accus $4700$bt

m~~~~,~6~~67~+ ~-CoalRasrrca Coal pcopsr5ae Gaapeccr Bebnr Ihubnga Gnd lensedEuoa Greoh Ooal Carpoceiion —hhore hrafnage Coal LuucrdOBX Gsa~LLC-GBtf LeasedBorbt Bettykfdfeon -Surface sed Ah $Srtss& agaspt GoalCNX Gas Gocapenp LLO-fBL Gaa asd ISBNLeered0,0$ scoee 0.fl$$%

Ccascuoncruahh Coal Cocapscq',Tuetg IPLB.~ggttggdcau%taod AB~ eaeopcCifRenure Coal~Qocupenp-Betucr ~fiscal LeeredBauer Crack Coul ~tbuc -Ahura Itrsbeege Cost LcserdCttZ Oae Compare LLC -Gee end CSbf LearntaM sores $4$7$0at

Bscntr $7. Iccbcgrr-Surdcco aacl CRJcn Bd Geej et'us-Suctbcn ond GifJoseph %crbrf IILet uz —Burgun aacl OilBISvd, cbddiaos, atua Qenw)-Sake nerd OSctcdbart Sbsrtl, ot ax —Surdcce aud OffOercdd K Shrub et ua- Burgun aud Oil~+am -a@a and<bi%aura I Cbgdcoee -Surface uccf Oct

lRBf dchBeon. et us Gfcrs) -Su%en snd MOceu~ afVkgfuts -Seafare and CilBrian~et ua -'ucdcca unct Oit

Cucammnwdth~~,~ p&,Shortgpdgdu Ttmctt-maBeoercu Coal~~-Sobrcr Grcgsatp Cosl LraercfKnee Gresb Coal Cocpcncprcac-dhore Bratnuge Ocrl LasercfCSXOaa Comyaccf ILC —fgtM LousedWalter Shod et sl -Surface and AB BSssccde accept CrudGboc hfap god Psrcal 6th$36 accus $,$600%

Cccucoonuucdch Coal Compaccf, Tcaot 7 Ok Short $6.$$ Acre Tma) -CoalReaeree Ccaf Proportion ~. lhciow had@sip Coal LrscedXucu Greeh Coal Curfccratfus - itboce Orainsge Oerl LeasedCHEOcn~LLC - GSbf faececfBoburt Base, etus m Tenn Siuut Heirs —cbS kEucrah cccceca OoaiRobert Rose, ot ua- Sue fcun

(ftccwepg4$ Pcuuelgk0.57aaccn 0.71$gtt

Page Number 9.

Page 10: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

JJ66tl j i6000026G

QNX Oae ComPanyLAA'%T

AA.SSTract tdmrtgtcsctmm

deb ~wealth Coal Ccmyany. Tract 7(b1.StmrtSbgghem Trectt CoatBaaarvs Cmd oterrttm~-Below DrswmgaCoal Lrseodterms Cme k Cred ~Ibm -Above~Coal LeasedCtCK Css Comyant LLC - Cttw LamedRchart Rase, aa nn erTnm Shcet Eetrr -Alt BRncrnh mesyt CoalCcmmcmweattb ed Vlqgnh-Snrdrcectmi beati etch. 3?most W

tbanmtmweatth Coal~,Tract y Short BtlAg Ame Trmed Coalttaccrve Coal esyerctee ~-Bskiw Ocrcdnege Ccwl LamedEmrr Creek Coat Cmyoaetcnn -Above tcrstmam Cmt Less«iCttX CmCemymcr LXC .CBbl LeasedWetter Sberb at nl -AB Mttosrste eaaaya CoalCammormwatth et'Rehh - ttsetbmytbshtay SCA yaresl Wltee smrm tt82coct

Commmtw~ Cmd Cementer. Trace tg &Shorte Acrat -AB~Resmva Cord eypyttat s Comysny - Below Drstnada Coat ter«mdKmm Crash Cmd Corporation - Above tretseee Cast LeasedCtCt Csa~LLC —C!l, ttaa sod CBtia Le«estUsksaem Surtbes Owmw

fn Meettca ~gttt3@isermr tA'/t4cc

cbso~tb Cosl Cemycmv. skeet g tt. taL HiU dt.ee Aem Tract} GsdRecarva Coal yrcgisrttm Cceetmnr Bebrw~Coat Lmaadttrs«Crash Gml Corcmrccbm -Above ttrstsscs Cml LsaeadCMXCta«Comtsmti LLC CBbtLeamdRobert Bore, et oe «r Tom Shore ttetre -AE XSnmah eseets CoalBeberattem, ates -Soetaeoe Bbg? Sth ya lea.Nts o,tttetcc

tbsmnmrwasRh Coal Corayaajy, Tmct tt tB25 Acre TcecC-ABtdbaerrdaRea Ad~~ Below 5?rntnnen CaelLcmmdKnrrc Creak Coal Cortroeatbm

.Ah«ra BradeatB Cbcd LancedCtCc ttsa Cemtsocc LLC- thl, Oae asd tBttrt Leasedtcctc asm SAtltc

ybbraacr tl., BQ10

Page Number 10,

Page 11: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

.' 0 IO,"-i:",)6 '.'

Exhibit EUnit ASS

Docket I/GOB 984i3244t63544List of Respondents that require escrow

160000/65

Net Acresin Unit

interest in

Unit

Tract «4B=0.$7 acres

Escrow Due to Tftfe Conff/ct

COAL OWftERSft(P

(1) Commonwealth Coal Company, Tr. 7(h/. Short 29.23 Acre Tract)P.O. Box 1269Bristol, VA 24203

0.57 acres 0 7125%

OIL & GAS~W~ERS)(IP

(1) Robert Rose, et ux1G08 Shortls RoadRaven, VA 24639

0.57 acres 0.7125%

OR

(1) Tom Short Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a) Tommy ShortBox 1228Richlands, VA 24641

0.57 acres

0.052 acres1/11 of 0.57 acres

G.7125%

0.0648%

(b) Walter ShortPO Box 1210Cedar BtuÃ, VA 24609

0.052 acres1/11 of 0.57 acres

0.0648%

(c) Harold ShortPO Box 1818Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

0.052 acres1/11 of 0.57 acres

0.0648%

(d) Glenward Jason Short128 And St.Pounding Mill, VA 24637

0.052 acres1/11 af 0.57 acres

0.0648%

(e) Bsllard C. Short3417 View Ave.Roanoke, VA 24018

0.052 acres'l/11 of 0.57 acres

0.0648%

(f) Dorothy Keene279 Townview DriveLebanon, VA 24286

Page 1 of 6

0.052 acres1/11 of 0.57 acres

3/24/2016

Page Number 1 l.

Page 12: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

Exhibit EUnit ASS

Docket ¹VGOB 984)3244I83544List of Respondents that require escrow

i60000;6;

Net Acresin Unit

Interest inUnit

(g) Maudie Bronson Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(g.1) Kenneth W. Wingo1509 E. Brow RdSignal Mtn, Thl 37377

0.052 acres1/11 of 0 57 acres

0.0648%

(h) Efge Shortc/o Gamic ThomasPO box 745Doran, VA 24612

(i) Garnie ThomasPO box 745Dorsn, VA 24612

(j) Otis ShortPQ Box 1015Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

0.052 acres1/1 1 of 0 57 acres

0 052 acres1/11 of 0.57 acres

0.052 acres'I/11 of 0.57 acres

0.06481e

0.0648%

0.064S%

(k) Raymond B.Short Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(k.1) Norene ShortPO Box 197

Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

0.052 acres1/11 of 0.57 acres

Tract ¹4C. 0.28 acres

Total tract acresTotal tract percent

0.570.7125'Ye

Escrow Due Io T/tfe ConNct

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Commonwealth Coal Company, Tr. 7(//. Short 29.23 Acre Tract)P.O. Box 1269Bristol, VA 24203

0.26 acres 0.3250%

OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP

(1) Robert Rose, et ux

1008 Shortie Road Page 2 of 8

0.26 acres 0.3250'Yo

3/24/2016

Page Number 12.

Page 13: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

Exhibit EUnit AA-38

Docket ¹VGOB 984)3244635<4List of Respondents that require escrow

1600/.)(! f65

Net Acresin Unit

interest inUnit

Raven, VA 24639

OR

(1) Tom Short Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

0.26 acres 0.3250%

(a) Tommy ShortBox 1228Richlands, VA 24641

(b) Walter ShortPO Box 1210Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

0.024 acres1/11 of 0.26 acres

0.024 acres1/11 of 0.26 acres

0.0295%

0.0295%

(c) Harold ShortPO Box 1818Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

0.024 acres1/11 of 0.26 acres

0.0295%

(d) Glenward Jason Short128 And St.Pounding Mill, VA 24637

(e) Ballard C. Short3417 View Ave.Roanoke, VA 24018

0.024 acres1/11 of 0.26 acres

0.024 acres1/11 of 0.26 acres

0.0295%

0.0295%

(f) Dorothy Keene2?9 Townview DriveLebanon, VA 24266

0.024 acres1/11 of 0.26 acres

0.0295'yo

(g) Maudie Bronson Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(g.1) Kenneth W. Wingo1509 E. Brow RdSignal Mtn, TN 373?7

0.024 acres1/11 of 0.26 acres

0.0295%

(h) Effie Shortc/o Gamic ThomasPO box 745Doran, VA 24612

(i) Garnie ThomasPO box 745Doran, VA 24612

Page 3 of6

0.024 acres1/11 of 0.26 acres

0.024 acres1/11 of 0.26 acres

0.0295%

0 0295'i

3/24/2016

Page Number 13.

Page 14: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

Exhibit EUnit AAQ8

Docket N/GOB 984t3244I63$414List of Respondents that require escrow

160000/'65

Met Acresin Unit

Intetarst inUnit

(i) Olis ShortPO Box 1015Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

(k) Raymond B.Short Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(k.1) Norene ShortPO Box 197

Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

0.024 acres1/1 1 of 0.26 acres

0.024 acres1/11 of 0.26 acres

0.0295%

0.0295%

Tract f/6- 0.09acres

Total tract acresTotal tract percent

0.260.3250%

Escrow Due to T/f/e Conff/ct

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Commonwealth Coal Company, Tr. 6(J.M. Hi/i 67.45 Acre Tract)

P.O. Box 1269Bristol, VA 24203

0.09 acres 0.1125'Yo

OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP

(1) Robert Rose, et ux

1006 Shortie RoadRaven, VA 24639

0.09 acres 0.1125%

(1} Tom Short Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(s) Tommy ShortlBox 1228Richlands, VA 24641

(b) Walter ShortPO Box 1210Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

0.09 acres

0.006 acres1/11 of 0.09 acres

0.008 acres1/11 of 0.09 acres

0 1125%

0.0102%

0.0102%

(c) Harold Short Page 4 of 6 o.ooe ac s 3/24)8$ P%o

Page Number 14,

Page 15: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

Exhibit EUnit AA.38

Docket ffVGOB 984)3244)6354)4List of Respondents that require escrow

Net Acresin Unit

160000;GS

interest in

Unit

PO Bcx 1818Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

1/11 ofOOQacres

(d) Glenward Jason Shorli128 And St.Pounding Mill, VA 24637

0.008 acres1/11 of 0.09 acres

0.0102%o

(e) Ballard C. Short3417 View Ave.Roanoke, VA 24018

(f) Dorothy Keene279 Townview DriveLebanon, VA 24266

0 008 acres1/11 of 0.09 acres

0.008 acres1/11 of 0.09 acres

0.0102%%uo

0.0102%

(g) Maudie Bronson Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(g.1) Kenneth W. Wingo1509 E. Brow RdSignal Mtn, TN 37377

(h) Effie Shortc/o Garnie ThomasPO box 745Dorsn, VA 24612

0.008 acres1/11 of 0.09 acres

0.008 acres1/11 of 0.09 acres

0.0'i 02%o

0.0102%

(i) Gamic ThomasPO box 745Doran, VA 24612

(j) Oiis ShortPO Box 1015Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

0.008 acres1/11 of 0.09 acres

0.008 acres1/11 of 0.09 acres

0.0102%

0.0'i 02%

(k) Raymond B. Short Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(k.1) hlorene ShortPO Box 197

Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

0.008 acres1/11 of 0.09 acres

0.0102%

Total tract acresTotal tract percent

0.090.1125%

Page5of6 3/24/2016

Page Number 15.

Page 16: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

Exhibit EUnit AA-38

Docket Nf GOB 984324<636~List of Respondents that require escrow

Nst Acresin Unit

Interest inUnit

Total Acreage in UnitTotal percentage in Unit

0.92001.1500%

Page 6 of 6 3/24/2016

Page Number I6.

Page 17: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

Exhibit EEi/nit AA-38

Docket IIVGOB 98%324%6354k(List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements/Court Orders/HB2658

160000~65

Net Acresin t/nit

Interest in

llnltPercent

af Escrow

Tract 02 - 0.09scree

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Commonwealth Coal Company, Tr. 3(Newel/ Short 87,/3 Acre Tract)P.O. Box 1269Bristol, VA 24203

0.09 acres 0.1125% n/a

OIL 6 GAS OWNERSHIP

Affidavit from Commanwesith Coal Corporation, dated September 30, 2015stsang they make no c/aim to the CB4!due to the current state of lawThe ownsm listed below are piantiffsin case no: fr10-cv65

(1) Doris 6elty Addison1305Tenace CourtSykssville, MD 21784

0.09 acres 0.1125% n/s

Tract tfdA- 3.16 acme

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Conuhonwesllh Coal Company, Tr. 7(/V. Short 29.23Acre Tract)P.O. Box 1269Brislol, VA 24203

3.16 acres 3.9500% rs'a

OIL 6 GAS OWNERSHIP

(1) Walter Short, et al

(a.ks. - Tom Short t/errs, Oevisees,Successors or Assigns)

(a) Tommy ShorttBox 1228Rich/ands, YA 24641

3.16 acres

0287 acres1/11 of 3.16acres

0.3591% 13.7814%HB2058

(b) Walter ShartPO Box 1210Cedar Bluff, YA 24609

0.287 acres1/1 1 of 3.16acres

0.3591% nra

(c) Herald ShorlPO Box 1818Cedar Blulf, VA 24609

0.431 acres3/22 of 3.16acres

0.5386% n/a

(d) Glenward Jason Shartt128 And St.Paunding Mill, VA 24637

0.431 acres3/22 of 3.16acme

0.5386% 20.6721'YoHB2058

(e) Ballard C. Short Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

Page 1 af 3 3/24/2016

Page Number 17.

Page 18: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

Exhibit EEUnit AAa8

Docket ¹VGOB 98<3244NI35<4List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreemente/Court Orders/HB2058

16O000 q65

Net Acresin Urrit

Interest inUnit

Percentof Escrow

(e.1) Earlean Shortt3417 View Ave.

Roanoke, VA 24018

0.287 acres1/11 of 3.16acres

0.3591%

(f) Dorothy Keene279 Townview Ddive

Lebanon, VA 24286

0.287 acres1/11 of 3.16acres

0.3591v%%d n/a

(g) Iltsudie Bronson Heirs, Devisees,Suctxwsors or Assigns

(g.f) Kenneth W. Wlngo1509 E. Brow Rd

Signal Min, TN 37377

G287 acres1/11 of 3.16acres

0.3591% 13 7814%%d

HB2050

(h) Efne Short0/o Gamis ThomasPO box 745Doran, VA 24612

0.287 acres1/11 of 3.18acres

0.359'l% me

5) Oas ShorPO Box 1D15Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

0.287 acres1/11 of 3.16acres

D 3591% n/a

(k) Raymond B.Short Heirs, Devisees,Successom or Assigns

(k.1) Norene ShortPO Box 197

Cedar Blot/, VA 246D9

0.287 acres1/11 of 3.16acres

0.3591% n/s

Total tract acresTotal tract percent

3.163.9500%

Tract ¹4D- 0.50 scree

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Commonwealth Coal Company. Tr. 7/iv Short 29.23Acre Tmc/)P.O. Box 1269Bristol, VA 24203

0.50 acres 0.6250%

OIL 6 GAS OWNERSHIP

(1) Walter Short, et al

(s./r.e. - Tom Short Heirs, Devisees,Successors ur Assigns)

0.50 acres 0.625D%

(a) Tommy ShortlBox 1228Richlands, VA 24641

0.045 acres1/11 of 0.50 acies

D.G568% 2.1806yoH 82058

Page 2 of 3 3/24/2016

Page Number 18.

Page 19: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

-: ~ Z 0 I 6 i','') 3 b / i / Exhibit EEUnit AA-38

Docket 8VGOB 984)3244163504Ust of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements/Court Orders/HB2058

160000>SS

Nst Acresin Unit

Interest inUnit

Percentof Escrow

(b) Walter ShortPO Box 1210Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

(c) Harold ShortPO Box 1818Cedar Blu/f, YA 24609

0.045 acres1/11 of 0.50 acres

0.068 acres3/22 of 0.50 acres

0.0568%

0.0852%, n/a

(d) Glenward Jason Shorli128 And Si.Pounding Mill, VA 24637

0.068 acres3/22 of 0.50 acres

0.0852'Ya 3.270%toHB2058

(e) Ballard C. Short Heirs, Devissea,Successors or Assigns

(e.1) Earlean Shor»3417 View Ave

Roanoke, VA 24018

(/) Dorothy Keene279 Townvisw DriveLebanon, VA 24266

0.045 acres1/11 of 0.50 acres

0.045 acres1/11 of 0.50 acres

0.0568%, n/a

0.0568% n/a

(g) Maudie Bronson Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(g.1) Kenneth W. Wingo1509 E. Brow RdSigna! Min, TN 3737T

0.045 acres1/11 of 0.50 acres

0.0568% 2H806yoHB2058

(h) E/5e Shortc/o Gamic ThomasPO box 745Doran, VA 24612

0.045 acres1/11 of 0.50 acres

0.0568% n/a

(i) Ogs ShortPO Box 1015Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

(k) Raymond B.Short Heirs, Dev<ssea,Successors or Assigns

(k.1) Norane ShortPO Box 197

Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

1/11 ofnxn INHTPO/IE ) f)JBL/OO123~RKU)IRi IN THE CLER)('8 OFFICE OF

TAzEb)ELL COL)NTY ON

NAY 3r 6 AT 21 OPN

TANHY 8. ALLISON CLER)(RECOROEPM NLi ~.

1/11 of 0.50 acres

Total tract acres 0,50Total tract percent 0.6250ye

Total Acreage ResolvedTotal Percentage Resolved

3.T5004.6875%

Page 3of3 3/24/2016

Page Number 19.

Page 20: 160000765...4t E Cl CI CD W CD lg fL IA CI C«l 0 Z C Ol E VlC 00 N O Ot ID CI IA Cl Ol Cd Ct C0 0S C ICIo T7 Ol CJ OlX lU ID Dl O4l CD 0 Ol 0 Cg 0m E ... t5 e CllC Df 'DCl W0 ta ~

IV< TR! INiFNT lll60000'?65RECCPDED IN THE CLERi('S UFFICF PF

BiCCNA!NAN CRNTY ON

NAY ~~ '016 AT 04:2SPi~i

BEVEPLY S. I:LLER~CLERl'ECURDFDBY: BLP