17. Pasandan v Comelec

7/24/2019 17. Pasandan v Comelec

1/8

/---!e-library! 6.0 Philippines Copyright 2000 by Sony Valdez---\

[2002V62" #$%& P. P$S$'($)$'* petitioner* +s. C&,,SS&' &' )C&'S and

#$ S$)$,&'$ ). $S,* respondents.2002 1l 3n #an4%.5. 'o. 072( C S

& '

C$5P&* .8

$ petition 9or de4laration o9 9ail1re o9 ele4tion :1st spe4i;4ally allege the essential

gro1nds that er4ise o9 this e>traordinary re:edy. &ther


2/8

n Pre4in4t 'os. 6$-3$* 72$-7$ and 73$-7D$* Pasandalan 4lai:s that $s1:@s

s1pporters* ta?ing ad+antage o9 the ;st;ght bet


3/8

Pasandalan no< assails the Co:ele4@s dis:issal o9 his petition* raising the 9ollo


4/8

BAa the ele4tion in any polling pla4e has not been held on the date ;>ed on a44o1nt

o9 9or4e :a=e1re* +iolen4e* terroris:* 9ra1d or other analogo1s 4a1sesI

Ab the ele4tion in any polling pla4e has been s1spended be9ore the ho1r ;>ed by

la< 9or the 4losing o9 the +oting on a44o1nt o9 9or4e :a=e1re* +iolen4e* terroris:*

9ra1d or other analogo1s 4a1sesI or

A4 a9ter the +oting and d1ring the preparation and trans:ission o9 the ele4tion

ret1rns or in the 41stody or 4an+ass thereo9* s14h ele4tion res1lts in a 9ail1re to

ele4t on a44o1nt o9 9or4e :a=e1re* +iolen4e* terroris:* 9ra1d or other analogo1s

4a1ses.B[6"

Ehat is 4o::on in these three instan4es is the res1lting 9ail1re to ele4t.[F" n the

;rst instan4e* no ele4tion is held


5/8

o traordinary

re:edy.[6" he party


6/8

$ thoro1gh e>a:ination o9 the aGda+its re+eals that they s1er 9ro: both e>trinsi4

and intrinsi4 in+alidity. he 9or: and the 4ontents o9 the aGda+its


7/8

a li4ensed e>a:iner o9 K1estioned do41:ents* a:ined 4opies o9 the ele4tion

ret1rns o9 )a?as-'C(. n the present 4ase* Pasandalan 9ailed to atta4h independent

and ob=e4ti+e e+iden4e other than the sel9-ser+ing aGda+its o9 his o


8/8

;led a petition 9or the n1lli;4ation o9 ele4tion. he Co:ele4 r1led against a 9ail1re o9

ele4tion be4a1se a4t1al +oting had ta?en pla4e. Ho

Documents

17. Pasandan v Comelec