20
東南アジア研究 48 3 号 2010 12 314 1930‒40 代の金永鍵とベトナム研* ユン・デヨン(尹大栄** Kim Yung-kun’s Course of Life and Vietnamese Studies in the 1930s and the 1940s YOUN Daeyeong** Abstract Who was Kim Yung-kun? What made him devote himself to so many things for which he worked in the 1930s and the 1940s? And how should we comprehend the significance of his efforts to blaze a trail in the field of Vietnamese research? These three inquiries are pursued serially in this study. Born in 1910 and graduating in 1927 from Gyeongseong Second Superior School, Kim Yung-kun came to Hanoi in 1931 as an assistant librarian, an experience that would give him a deeper understanding of Vietnamese history and culture with which he might be unfamiliar. Ten years later, he left Indochina and returned to Korea in order not to be involved in the Japanese military occupation of Vietnam. Back in his country , Kim Yung-kun tried to apply himself to Korean studies, strongly influenced by Mun Il-pyeong and some other Koreanologists. However, after joining in with other leftists, his desire arose for a more active social and political engagement in order to deal with acute national problems. Since t that time Kim Yung-kun endeavored to integrate academic work with concrete social and political engage- ment, leading to a number of action research studies covering Korean history, tendency literature, criticism of arts and so forth. These academic interests and militant engagement have originated from Kim Yung- t kun’s experiences in Vietnam. Having devoted a part of his life to Hanoi earned Kim Yung-kun the reputa- tion of being an expert on Vietnamese studies and won him the enduring friendship of Lê Dư. In the early 1940s, the Korean Vietnamologist also published in a book his earlier works on Japanese relations with Vietnam, Champa and Cambodia, which he had been continuously writing since about 1936. Years later, he met with numerous difficulties when carrying out a study of Vietnam as he was deeply involved in various political movements. And so, his vision of Southeast Asia turned out to be incomplete. Keywords: Kim Yung-kun, Kim Vĩ V V nh Ki n, Kin Eiken, Lê Dư, Vietnam, Vietnamese studies ーワード:金永鍵レ・ズベトナムベトナム* 本稿は『東南アジア研究아연The Southeast Asian Review韓国東南アジア学会)19 3 号(2009 10 )に発表した論考を再検討のうえ補完したものである** 学韓国学研究所;Center for Korean Studies, Inha University , 253 Yonghyun-dong, Nam-gu, Incheon, 402–751, Republic of Korea e-mail: vinhsinh98@hotmail.com 和訳:イ・ミジ李美智

1930‒40年代の金永鍵とベトナム研究* 仁荷大学韓国学研究所;Center for Korean Studies, Inha University, 253 Yonghyun-dong, Nam-gu, Incheon, 402–751, Republic

  • Upload
    dokhue

  • View
    227

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 48 32010 12

    314

    193040*

    **

    Kim Yung-kuns Course of Life and Vietnamese Studiesin the 1930s and the 1940s

    YOUN Daeyeong**

    Abstract

    Who was Kim Yung-kun? What made him devote himself to so many things for which he worked in the

    1930s and the 1940s? And how should we comprehend the significance of his efforts to blaze a trail in the

    field of Vietnamese research? These three inquiries are pursued serially in this study. Born in 1910 and

    graduating in 1927 from Gyeongseong Second Superior School, Kim Yung-kun came to Hanoi in 1931 as

    an assistant librarian, an experience that would give him a deeper understanding of Vietnamese history

    and culture with which he might be unfamiliar. Ten years later, he left Indochina and returned to Korea in

    order not to be involved in the Japanese military occupation of Vietnam.

    Back in his country, Kim Yung-kun tried to apply himself to Korean studies, strongly influenced by

    Mun Il-pyeong and some other Koreanologists. However, after joining in with other leftists, his desire

    arose for a more active social and political engagement in order to deal with acute national problems. Since t

    that time Kim Yung-kun endeavored to integrate academic work with concrete social and political engage-

    ment, leading to a number of action research studies covering Korean history, tendency literature, criticism

    of arts and so forth. These academic interests and militant engagement have originated from Kim Yung-t

    kuns experiences in Vietnam. Having devoted a part of his life to Hanoi earned Kim Yung-kun the reputa-

    tion of being an expert on Vietnamese studies and won him the enduring friendship of L D. In the early 1940s, the Korean Vietnamologist also published in a book his earlier works on Japanese relations

    with Vietnam, Champa and Cambodia, which he had been continuously writing since about 1936. Years

    later, he met with numerous difficulties when carrying out a study of Vietnam as he was deeply involved

    in various political movements. And so, his vision of Southeast Asia turned out to be incomplete.

    Keywords: Kim Yung-kun, Kim VVV nh Ki n, Kin Eiken, L D, Vietnam, Vietnamese studies

    * The Southeast Asian Review19 32009 10

    ** Center for Korean Studies, Inha University, 253 Yonghyun-dong, Nam-gu, Incheon,402751, Republic of Korea

    e-mail: [email protected]

  • 315

    193040

    19#

    201905

    :

    1910

    1920

    1930

    : , 1930

    1943

    1943a

    1990

    10

    1930

    1940K 1947: 3##

    #

    ## KC

  • 48 3

    316

    I BEFEO

    193040

    10 1939

    2007

    1927 3 2

    2007: 52

    1910 3 18

    1868?

    1923

    19101914,

    19161921, 1924; 19131917; n.d.: 98;

    2008: 29

    1920H Nicole Franaise

    dExtrme-Orient , Vin ng Bc C Hc Vin,

    1999: 9798

    1927 2 2 1931

    1 4 K

    1948: 10211111928121929X

    : 112

    1930

    1936: 6667; 2004: 285286;

    1999: 98; 2007: 69

    1

  • 317

    193040

    Bulletin de lcole

    Franaise dExtrme-OrientBEFEO

    1931 4 13 2

    14

    1931

    BEFEO tome 312

    Trn Vn Gip1931

    1942: 4; BEFEO 1931:

    5265281931George Cds

    C 1939: 164

    1932

    Nguyn Vn TNguyn Vn Khoan

    Trn Vn Gipassistant

    1932 5 1

    2pisodes du Heik Monogatari, traduits par S. Goto et M. Prunier, Paris, 1930, 148 p.

    1 :1931 4 13 2

  • 48 3

    318

    L Dbibliothcaire-adjoint

    1936 4 J 1932: 125;

    BEFEO 1933: 416417; J 1943a: 12

    1931 1939 72

    52 11 9

    BEFEO 1931; 19331937; 1939: 1937

    BEFEO 1937: 560, 568569, 584

    18881943

    K 1937: 464

    Paul Pelliot 1904BEFEO Deux itinraires de Chine en Inde la fin du

    VIIIe sicleGutman 1976

    1933 9Hi An

    1937 9

    secrtaire bibliothcaire gnralPaul

    Mus1617

    Nol Peri Nng

    BEFEO 1933: 1049; J 1943a: 11936

    1936

    K 1947:

    823

    319362007: 69

  • 319

    193040

    1932

    zen-sekyeng-zene

    yeBEFEO 1933: 447, 457, 458; 1939: 286, 288, 305, 311

    1936Zosnb b

    Choi Hynbaiy

    BEFEO 1936: 543

    iBEFEO

    1939: 286, 288, 305

    1931

    Trn Vn Gip

    BEFEO 1932: 526528

    Bibliographie bouddhiquePrzyluski et al. 1931

    1931192930

    BEFEO 1932: 546550

    1932 1934 : , 1930

    : , 1934

    BEFEO 1933: 10331034; 1934: 704707 1938

    1937

    Kim 1938: 306308

    1937 4

    K 1937: 4644654 1936

    4 1936 12 29

  • 48 3

    320

    1937 2

    Louis Bezacier

    Victor GoloubewMadeleine ColaniPierre Dupont

    Jean Manikus Paul LvyClmentin-Ojha and

    Manguin 2007: 180181

    II1940

    Nguyn Thiu Lu

    1939 12 23

    Nguyn Thiu Lu 1997: 29

    19401940 1941

    1940K 1947: 3

    1940 10

    Hi Phng

    J

    1943a: 2

    Cds 1947: 150

    1941 5 28

    5 6

    J 1941a: 425433; 2004: 285; 1943: 437439

    1941 10 1-49 2

    5 1 91943 9

    5

    5 7 41942 6 10 1-561943 1 3 28

  • 321

    193040

    1941 96

    1946 9 ,

    1940

    K 1947: 3

    2 81941 9 3

    81942 8

    8 10

    1942 10 10 11944 1

    1863

    1886 6 1887 5

    18881936

    1934 5

    K 1947: 34

    1945 8 16

    1947: 15310 29

    61 21946 65 1 120

  • 48 3

    322

    1945 11 9

    1949

    7

    1947 8

    ,

    K 1948: 319424423 1

    : 12, 30

    : 46

    ,

    : 21 ,

    7 1949

  • 323

    193040

    : 3435

    : 21

    : 5758 1945 7

    K 1945a: 37

    K 1947: 4

    1945 9 17

    2002: 231945 10 22

    1945

    10 22

    12 13

    1945

    12 25

    1946

    1946 3 25

    2005: 27

    K 1948: 14, 27, 62

  • 48 3

    324

    1947

    2 1985: 4673 17

    1947 3 19

    1948

    38

    1948 2 13

    1985: 467468

    1990: 241

    19401945

    1948

    2

    1947 9 :

    1948 3

    194867

    1949 1

    193040

    III

    2001: 49

  • 325

    193040

    Kin Ei-KenKim Yung-kun

    81910

    Seoul

    1932 7

    1934 10

    J 1932: 125135;K 1934: 1719

    1936 7 1 127

    1 2

    Monosyllabic

    Nm ,

    ba

    quc ng,

    Phm Qunh, Nam Phong

    Nguyn Vn VVV nh,

    L D,

    1936 7 3579

    8 10 15Kim Yeung-KeunKim Young-Kun

  • 48 3

    326

    18

    10

    1112

    Champa19

    Hu

    1937 2 14 19

    5

    9

    1936 11 2 1

    1815 4Si Gn

    ng Hu Bi,

    Nguyn Duy Bo,

    1828Trng ng Qu,

    8

    1936: 6667

    1937 8

    Gustave Dumoutier 1895

    Bulletin de gographie historique et descriptiveParis, vol. 10Les comptoirs hollandais

    de Ph-hien ou Ph-khach, prs de Hng-yen (Tonkin) au XVIIe sicle

    Vn n,

    1 1938 7

    10 11931 5

    16

    16

    9 J 1943a: 2

  • 327

    193040

    J 1939a

    16 17

    Ty Sn,

    17 J

    1938Hng Yn

    J 1939b

    1938 5 17

    1933Ph

    Potalaka Potaraka

    1925ASalletLa Montagne de luniversel

    escarpementSallet 1925: 9, 130

    16 17

    J 1940

    1940

    K 1941a: 4; J 1941b

    J 1943b; 1943c

    1942 1943 3

    1931 1933

    1942

    1943

    1942: 12; J 1943a: 1

    17

    OudongPonhea-lu

    L Long Tng

    1927 2 22

    1927 2 22 1936

  • 48 3

    328

    1942

    Nh

    hc-chnh ng-PhpTi i hc

    Cnh ng nh quSi Gn v Ch L n

    ng Nguyn KimNam Phong

    Nht Linho n

    TuytNguyn DuKim Vn Kiu

    1946 11

    Nam Phng

    K 1948: 29, 33

    1945 11 15

    K 1945b

    1946 12

    K 1946a

    1946 2

  • 329

    193040

    K 1946b

    1947 5

    15

    1941 5

    K 1941b; Cds 1947: 150

    17

    625

    1949: 280; 1994: 21, 91

    1920

    1931

    10

    1930

  • 48 3

    330

    1945

    2001: 15161946

    K 1947: 34

    1948

    10

    L Long Tng, 1942

    1959

    Phan Huy L

    12

    193040

    1960

    1010

    10

  • 331

    193040

    1927 2 22 21161931413 1946 12 31 !

    1945 10 22

    1945 11 91945 12 25

    1947 3 19

    1941 7 7

    J19324(1): 125135193817(1): 77871939a9(7)1943a1781861939b18(1): 7710919404: 3573701941a : 7 71941b7(3): 4254331941c7(3): 35836219421943a1943b 1(2): 47501943c3n.d.

    1960 1990 1943200809193040

  • 48 3

    332

    ; 1942

    191014, 191621, 19241913191719437(3): 43743919362(1): 6669

    1990 : 2008

    2001 5(1): 4767

    Cds, George194715: 134150

    20072007 2007 :

    2004,272286 :

    1999 : 19394: 1991994 : K19341(1): 17241937 44(5-4): 4644651941a : 7 71941b7(5): 42491941c2(8):58631941d3(8):13013119428(10):116117194410(1): 77791945a : 1(2):

    36371945b1988.

    106107 : 1946a : ! 12 311946b1(2): 4141947 :1948 : :1985

    2449492 : 2002 : 2001 1946116 :19461(2): 165166194916: 280194715: 151154194916: 1771802005 1 : 2007 6880 : ; :

  • 333

    193040

    BEFEOBulletin de l'cole Franaise d'Extrme-Orient tomes 3139. 19311939.Goto, S.; and Prunier, M. 1930. pisodes du Heik Monogatari, traduits par. Avant-propos de M. Sylvain Lvi.

    Paris: Ernest Lereoux.Kim, Yung Kun. 1938. Note sur la nouvelle romanisation officielle du japonais. BEFEO 38: 306308.Przyluski, M. J. et al. 1931. Bibliographie bouddhique. Paris: Geuthner.Sallet, A. 1925. Les Montagnes de Marbe (Ngu-hanh son). Bulletin des Amis du Vieux Hue IIe anne (1924) n 1

    (janvier-mars): 8131.

    Clmentin-Ojha, Catherine; and Manguin, Pierre-Yves. 2007. A Century in Asia: The History of the cole Franaise

    dExtrme-Orient, 18982006. Singapore: Editions Didier Millet.Gutman, Pamela. 1976. Ancient Arakan. Ph.D. Dissertation. Canberra: The Australian National University.

    Nguyn Thiu Lu. 1997. ng Ch S : ng Phng Bc C Hc Vin. XXX a v Nay 40: 2930.

    C1939a10: 154158