2009~

u J(jIi~ N~

()lyJo (JiYgtJt 1~0i7iS yl(j~Jt

JUiJUJ (JI4IJJI Jp (IJgtI Ij) Jy lijJ

iSj~ lijJ jcl iSh

1

u J(jIi~ N~

()lyJo (JiYgtJt 1~0i7iS yl(j~Jt

JUiJUJ (JI4IJJI Jp (IJgtI Ij) Jy lijJ

iSj~ lijJ jcl iSh

1

~------- --------------------------------

Y Uy 01 w1 ~~ ~ollol~J -rjol sjt ol4J 4~JJl yU ~Jw J= uy Jol s)sLJol slYj) ol ljJJ ~ JL uLjt Y~J4-Jol u~)W1 CgtIs~ sliIJol sJY J uU1-rw A)LI ltl ~JL jll= ~L

wljS~

LiuJJlJl Jil~ olJ t~J I~ Twu1ro ls ~ Ij 1JlJrS Li5 5JiJJ ylLiol 6SNJ JiJol J YJJIYrS olJ rcJ w~~r-lJijol ~~I)u JLJ yyraquo u1wJ ~ yl CrlLiu~lu ~r-wls tJLiJi Ij 5JiJJ r-JYb vol1J ~ ~ wi TIYt~ ~ TJlJlwr-~ ) r-JJol ycltl J)J ~Uol TJIJlJiulro YLJiwJ YJ Icr)b t~ ~r-y5j

I~ wi Jlu~Iraquo ~r-lJijol b~l)u JLJ YYraquo UwJ olJ yly ~wJLu IJolr-w WyIJJ uJ=J 5J~ )bols WJJLiw ol)IY6SIraquo Ij 1JlJrS uol~ls Jii1ts J 5loJi tbJ ulJlIol) yl 5JiJJ r-JYb YJJIYrS ~ 5UJ ~rshy~ o~)u ~ Ij 1JlJrS 51~ollu YLu IJ~ UwJ YYraquo ~ JiJl ~ Li ~oJ CrILiu~ Ij 5JiJyl J

51raquoullJlu ytJi r-JJol uJ=J Ij JiUkiLiw YLu I~ (Transparency International) J 1Jl1LiJ 1Jl1Jr-luos yl ~J~) olJ yJ ~ JJl

TwUI~ olJ ~uvu olJJ YCltl YI5IJWIIJlu~ J~ olJJO Ijr-Li~ olJ~ 5JiJJ I~Li olI~ Ji~ I~ Liu jr-LiJioI olJ IJlIJ 2008 olJ yJIYlJrS 0JjJLiu LS)Liu J ulJJrS ~ t~ ir-ol tw -tr- I~ 1Jl1twlJ ~s J (Vlcw Liu 5JiJyl vtw Ij Or- r-J-iljW I~ yl Cr-1Liw ULiJJr-uJrS5o Ij vJS OJ ~ 5JiJJ olJ yJlyJ JJUol tJlIJJLIys ol~lraquo ly)jJiol 0W Licr lu tLiw ~ YJol Ijr-LiJilw degr-~ulu ~ ~vol

uJ=yls ~JrS olJ Liu JJUol ~ t~J~ olJ t~lJ T~l~ I~JIC ~ lu J ~jlraquo uw1Licr lJijJ b~l)u 10( IN J bull olJ IJlIJ 2009 tJol 1JJLlys olJ~Iraquo lj vJS 5JJ Ivs J LS)Liu ~J Jiol

Liu )IYIJo CJS T~I~ yCrs vlJr-u~s JJlJol olJ ol1tJ 5JiJJ LibollJiw lJroJUO y)s lJiu1Lis JJLJ Jiit Li yYJ ULiJJ01s r-vJC yl Liu JJUJ J raquoJU r-bJy vol1J ~r-lJijol o~)u ~ JOyraquo U1wJ I~

~~o JJUoltJol 1JJLIys ol~lraquowJi Ij o~ ~Jcr0 ytJi Jiilts I~ JW 5JiJJ ~ wJ1Uol lu) ~ IJllLiJ Jjlpl J uol~ls 1~Ws ULij wtNr- ~ol

JJlJol tJl1JJLIys ol)IY6SIraquo Ij vJS ~~r- tw~l~ ~ yyraquo TJuol J ~ lJiwJLS ulJJS LS)Liu ~Jcr~lu YJUUrS 0JjJLiu 5JJ Ivs cr~Jraquo v 1yJ Li~JvJIJLi NolJlJLie YJLwIULis

~J J e~ulu JiULi~ YLu IJ~ (YJLwIULiI)bull 51~lu YLu I~ U1wJ J ~IJYJr-~ltsJ (Oberammergau) r-JYb UwJ I~U olI~ Ji~ I~ ~ r-vJ~ y u vs 3middot LiJ lu IJ JrS vs IJ 1s

vs JrS J JrS IJ Ir- s (r-Juwraquo)l ULij r-JJol ~JJO J)J ~~ I~

I NC3 UNODC OECD and DRMI (Monterey)

2

I(IIIU JJ~IJiS J sloltJl tlJ ~IJ ~ltJl ~(IiS Ij II~IJ ()ItIJol J ulIJJOiS JJiS Jlul J II (JoOIIuo JU1CiS J (iUIIiS I~

~LlJAiijols lUlts J 1~s 0) poundJJsl ~tiju ~ swJ ~Ll ylt~ ~lt ru t~~ w1rbJH Nyt J t)ijJIs Ji)oIijJ Wk5Iis ijl ys ~Uij ~ JJJ GWijw CIJIs jw~ rvffil yl tb))J YO)J Jltu rJ~)ij trJltisl --S10J ~ JoJ rvJuW ulJJ JlyJ twrJ Wij~ r~ 1J1ulw Ij JJs JI)JIJiojlw r~ww Uljrw ijUu Jljr1wels )J)ij~s ijl JJrwlw ylWJy uhNt

Jy

~b J) ytJ lUlts tb r)Jr J yo bJ ) --SJs rcyJYij ~INW I --S10J JIJo ~W I~ ylt~ uvIijJi Crij tr~ Ij rrJ)ijuls Ciil ~Jc JiJJ ijW J~t degrGWijw ylt~ --SrYJJ NYt J) ytJoIs tij) ~I~ J 1~1Js ~ JjJ J rs J1WJ Jlij) ytJoIs C--S~ I Wijj tij) r~) UIjJ ~Ll yjiJ J

I~JiU ij--S rJ I swJ ~ UIjJ

yo tWJIW ytJraquos Ij y)Wlro trJ rJiI~s WIJ J)Iybo yl web J1js lUlts --Sl) J) I~Is I~U Iyjlyls trJs yls --S--s yo rJJ J) d NW J~Is J --SloJ tb) uJb biro Jly wJIJoIs kJIJJIijs

y) I~UrJI)Jjij)rr~j I~ bull uJi)Jo YO)ijW IJJlr J)Iybo yllrijW J~Is J --SloJ tb) uULl J) ytJi lUlts

bull y)Wlro IrJjJs J)Iybo yl INW J~Is J --SloJ tb) ~IJ

bull )JwJ tJJ I)jijlys J~Is tJJ I)jijlys J1W1ijijol J ~Uols ~Ir J~Is J) ytJi lUlts ij~ Ij rlijo ols weLl J1js J) ijW

ytJI~ ijW r)JJiwlro ij--S Iyjl) ij~ I~I yo Jirl J) GWijw 1)jijIys yen swJ )JWJo1s rbJH ~J uJb ij~ Ij IJj1r JIWJWs yls oro CJiojw J J~Is WlwJ lUso swJI~JW ~J

~b UljrwJJ KJ (UNCAC) I r~I--S)Jo IWJ rCJ1s --SWJI~JW J) Iybo yl ~uls JJ --SlrJl )~ I~ we1Jo1s lUlts ~ JIWJ Ij ijW JwJ J) ~o --S--s yls INW 0rlo~s -AW Jjlp

lUlt J Wij)yls (JJc JIW yl ijW swJIWUijJW JuIJo --SWWJ

~Jr~lro JIkJylwe I~ blyJ b)jlJtrWo y)s yl~ llJ1tl rc)( Ij poundJJyl tJloJ ~ JJJI ylJ J rijijW 0) ~Co Ij r~os JW I yl)Jo Y0Js rwlUY I~s wJ1Ws --SWJ

3

I(IIIU JJ~IJiS J sloltJl tlJ ~IJ ~ltJl ~(IiS Ij II~IJ ()ItIJol J ulIJJOiS JJiS Jlul J II (JoOIIuo JU1CiS J (iUIIiS I~

~LlJAiijols lUlts J 1~s 0) poundJJsl ~tiju ~ swJ ~Ll ylt~ ~lt ru t~~ w1rbJH Nyt J t)ijJIs Ji)oIijJ Wk5Iis ijl ys ~Uij ~ JJJ GWijw CIJIs jw~ rvffil yl tb))J YO)J Jltu rJ~)ij trJltisl --S10J ~ JoJ rvJuW ulJJ JlyJ twrJ Wij~ r~ 1J1ulw Ij JJs JI)JIJiojlw r~ww Uljrw ijUu Jljr1wels )J)ij~s ijl JJrwlw ylWJy uhNt

Jy

~b J) ytJ lUlts tb r)Jr J yo bJ ) --SJs rcyJYij ~INW I --S10J JIJo ~W I~ ylt~ uvIijJi Crij tr~ Ij rrJ)ijuls Ciil ~Jc JiJJ ijW J~t degrGWijw ylt~ --SrYJJ NYt J) ytJoIs tij) ~I~ J 1~1Js ~ JjJ J rs J1WJ Jlij) ytJoIs C--S~ I Wijj tij) r~) UIjJ ~Ll yjiJ J

I~JiU ij--S rJ I swJ ~ UIjJ

yo tWJIW ytJraquos Ij y)Wlro trJ rJiI~s WIJ J)Iybo yl web J1js lUlts --Sl) J) I~Is I~U Iyjlyls trJs yls --S--s yo rJJ J) d NW J~Is J --SloJ tb) uJb biro Jly wJIJoIs kJIJJIijs

y) I~UrJI)Jjij)rr~j I~ bull uJi)Jo YO)ijW IJJlr J)Iybo yllrijW J~Is J --SloJ tb) uULl J) ytJi lUlts

bull y)Wlro IrJjJs J)Iybo yl INW J~Is J --SloJ tb) ~IJ

bull )JwJ tJJ I)jijlys J~Is tJJ I)jijlys J1W1ijijol J ~Uols ~Ir J~Is J) ytJi lUlts ij~ Ij rlijo ols weLl J1js J) ijW

ytJI~ ijW r)JJiwlro ij--S Iyjl) ij~ I~I yo Jirl J) GWijw 1)jijIys yen swJ )JWJo1s rbJH ~J uJb ij~ Ij IJj1r JIWJWs yls oro CJiojw J J~Is WlwJ lUso swJI~JW ~J

~b UljrwJJ KJ (UNCAC) I r~I--S)Jo IWJ rCJ1s --SWJI~JW J) Iybo yl ~uls JJ --SlrJl )~ I~ we1Jo1s lUlts ~ JIWJ Ij ijW JwJ J) ~o --S--s yls INW 0rlo~s -AW Jjlp

lUlt J Wij)yls (JJc JIW yl ijW swJIWUijJW JuIJo --SWWJ

~Jr~lro JIkJylwe I~ blyJ b)jlJtrWo y)s yl~ llJ1tl rc)( Ij poundJJyl tJloJ ~ JJJI ylJ J rijijW 0) ~Co Ij r~os JW I yl)Jo Y0Js rwlUY I~s wJ1Ws --SWJ

3

bull )) rtw ~~J~ (I (S Jtiij( JI)o 1ij0 ~ (JlJ( I~I (wJ=J) (I 101~s 0r-o

Uij~r-ols 10 ~ )~ sl) (S ~ - JJo) Yij)JW sJu ~ 0(S s0) J 0r-o Uij~r-ols (t~s JI)osJu ) (S ()Ij) J 10) ()) (I ~ (S )1)) (JlJ( YJ)o ~ )) ~ sl) (S

~ bull )) (tw )t~ J ItJ1Js ))~Iraquo 10 I~so sl) JoIu1iJo J JoltN(liJo 10lt1())0 ulj Ij

0byl~

)) 1ij0 J(jIJo ~ (I Ij )~Iraquo Cyi (S j0ij( (wJ=J) (I ~0ij01~ bull ijs Ii J~I)~ l(Jws sraquo ) yl )Iij~ J Jooll~ 10lt1( (S )ool J 10 ) ~ ~1ij10

(S J(j10ol

bull ijs mJ J~ 10 l~s bJ ) ~JYw) y)Jl J yolJiJ I0J6t ol) Uij~(Ss (j 10 I~ j))~)ol

bull ijs (JoiI1Jt-IuJ~ 10 I~s sl))) 10 yl C(JkJ)os )Iij~ J wI ~1ij1010lt1( )J) ylJiJ

lwso yl~ sl) ijl (0lyt ~ (jIJoJ 0 b1Nj ijl tij) JobjliJo 10C)u oll)o )J)

)J 4SiyU Ji J~ ~ At -r ~0~ Wl1s)J 4S liA) -r 4j)1 I) 0~ Jy~) ~)Li ilA)s wilol lo) oj4o14S (~y~) )JssY jlJJoitigtp ~ Y Jc 1 ~1 )~)~ -r o)lAiu101jl LJ1fi1

J ollJI~ ~ ~ y~ sJLgtp J solI s)oly 0gt+1 ~fo~ wljyl1 ~ JJoitigtp r~ ~ )oliJJol li)l5 s sY jl4S llS -r lji1 I) s)i) lI 1 o~ 4j1) olU jI ~1 UiyU 0IiSY)) J~ oollJ jY 4AJt

li ltu I tJ ~ It J ~ It) j I lo 4S J If bull It ltlL bull bull ols) ) ~ ugt- ~ y u y y ~ ~ u ) ~ -r lt-J)- ~)

(2002 01iS~ ~) ~4)l1 0 y~ d ~4S -ru jl OJlAiu1 Y 01) jl

)) C1ws wtl~ ~)) vraquo 0ijj JltJ) Jly ~~ (I w10 (S )oJs CWs)) JoJJW Ujoll0

WfJiiu ~~Iraquo Ij (Y( (S )lwJs ~b ~ij~ y)s (~IJ ol) swJI~JiJ ~ol0b ()13(10

~~J s W(lw 0 1r-o I~s Yij0 lJ~ J))ybo yl lijw (J~Jt I~ wtJiiu )()(S Ij u()b I)cso

w)o I~ ol) t~ 101w Wf1Jiiu ~~ Ij IJJoU ijs s1J(0ol t1r-o I)cso s))o l()l

(~Jt r-o(~raquos ylijol)Jw)y J(JJ IWJ1t It~s Ij 0 b )) yt) JUts I~ WJIYijraquos ~ ~J) (yl)jo yl tb)w IWtl~ (S )JJ 3(IW (~) tJlowJ YJJs J~ JJ(jWs Ij (~ ols tlJo (ltgtLSJo

s )~y ) 1ij(ly (S swJ J(Jol ollu yl~ 1ij0 ~J(j)0Ir-o ~ ~0ijw J~ s~ (S swol

---------------- 4

1 UlIC~~ IJj~III($ JI I] NI~I~ I~lllo l~ 1I~1Nl ~I) ror l~~ Yyxs Jjlp J 0)1gtIrS ~ Ij -U cy 1)xkIrS CIltJ~ r(S ~ )JUJ CJJ 1)x1--U JJi)oslxs 1 yYxs (S ~ yJ

lr) y))raquogtrS1 iJIJ) ~ J J) U rJ)JbJxs ~ JIJr I~ y Jx) J u)rlUJo 0)1gtIrS ru-Jc lt10 ltJJU- YJigtJ 5rS Ij rlrlltJ t~J yJ lt10 tUJU rv(nJ 1)xI--U ltJtu Jy

2 ~I~s utltgtd 110 eWIW ~()MtsJJ tJl IJj~III($ ue~~W ~Jl JIJr I~ ltJI ltJiJb 5 UU) ~JjltJ I~ulro V J) ~r 51JuiJU J yJ0lro y)~orS ytJrS 1 lt10 JJJ JI~ yJJ

3 ~s ~JJo ISIJ($ 1~~Il ~Jl ~ j oro ytJorS Jjlp 0r1~ 5u J 01raquo 0~ ~ ulu ltJrr ~ lt10 u 51) ~)~ yJuJ ~ JJr I~ oro ru1yt lt10 Jr~ 0)JrS 0xs 1r5lu lltJ 11JrS JiJ1J J

(sIltJ JrW ~iJ J rJ)J ltJJU- JJ ~J0J ~)1gt 5xs 1)~lro 1 ~NJ 5)Jo lt10 JuylJ u yl or rJIltJ (S50LJ ltJI ~jI)J v J) ltJr ~ or51u lt10 Yyxs u lltJJ1 rJ)J y))raquogtrS )1) JoUJ

4 J()M~1~0 uSNJ ~Jl lt10 l~y CJJ sJJ) ~u (S ~)J~ 1JigtJuro I ltJI (O CJJJrS ~J 5LJ lt10 tUJU r~IJ lulu (S ltJJlwJ YCJo1rS rt~ 1)VJuro1 bJ ) (J~liJb lt10 IJI)ltJ rH) J)

Jjlp ~~J I (S ltJJ1wJsJ lu1 lt10 0) ytJ ~~ ltJI J)I~ yl 0) I~ ~Y 01rS rt~ JJilultJ 5w J lulu Or(UIU (S ltJJI0LJ l~uro1 lt10 ~)1gt0rS CIJ( Ij c5JrltJ Ij ~J

iJIJrliJblrS t) c5~ (NGOs) lt10 iJblJolrS tJ(S I)VIJ ~ ltJI v~loolrS ru~ JJiIUltJ 5wJ 111Jt01 ylJ ~51 JJ ~ wJ Ij rJIIltJ lt10 u1ltJJ y)VJ ~~ltJ ltJINu rcJNltJ I~ulro ~J JJo lt10 JJJ CJJ 5JJY~ ~r ~J J y))raquogtrS 51JuiJiJb lt10 Yyxs ulltJJ UJlt kJ I yl

(Jluy iJJ(S J) Nlu UCJloJ ~~~

5 ()M~lwlo($ ~ICIIO olIlJI($ ~~~ sIJ~Wl()MIW wlJl 110 J0IIJ($ wl~J Iu vll) JJ ltJIIJO )Jj I l) y) CJOJ~~JJrJ lJYUJ)Jo IrS 1j(~ltJCJloJYJl JIJr I~ltJ ~ICltIOol J)vJc ~I ylJI

iJJP ~)J ltJI yltJJlulllJtoi lt10 I~ulro 1 IJ)J YC~ 1) lIJ J) clJrS ~ ltJtu ~ICltlO J~ulj ~ICltJ CJJ 5JJYI~ lt10 bJ)sJrS J) 5 sJJ) ~UJ) ~Iu)Jo olrS 4 ltJl 5 tw Ij~JN ltJI ~)JIJ 1 J) y) (S ~)J ~ICltlO JJ~IU ylJ Or Ij 51~Iu ~ J Or Ij UiJ)lu I~

uliol(S ylJuJ Jil ltJ~o (S Jy ltJI 5 sJJ) riJICltlO 01 1 lt10 iJ) ~)1gtol Ij ~J It~lrS IIA1u iJIJrliJblrS tc5JrltJrS JVliJb olrS ~)1gtrS I iJb1Jo1rS td(S ~~raquo JoJ J) Iu iJJP ~

(vo yj~ J~5 (S ltJJlul (IY r~xs y) 1rS ltJylJJo v~loolrS ~UJt ylJJ (lt10 r~IJ LSIul) (sIltJ x) r1(to50l)

6 I~)($ ~ J$ JJ ~ J)JA uul J 4j11 li)1 ltJ1i ~l rS)S oJ JX JJ ~4 ~ JlUJgtI lli ~ ~ JAI~I J$ JJ )UJ J ~ dlAJJjJli1 ~ ltJ1jJ rSyA) ~ )y=lyl uul rS~$

Jh I+ rS~ J ISJY 011)J Jlji yU rSyA) ~ 4j1~)S IS)Y Jlil r-fJ Yw

7 lll~o sIJ($ 5 y)u1ro ltIOiJIjrSbc50l ltJI ~jIraquo ~-Ixs JJo ~~Jwol ltJINu JJJ (~ olrS Ij Iu IJlrlltJ rrsu I~ J) 1rS IIrS i 1IrS J 1IrS I i) 1IrS (IPAP and PARP) yljltJlylyJ

8 ~1))JUJ lt10 tUJ1U ytJrS Ij 5 JJY r~ yl J) ulio)Jl~ iJI) N5I0jrolrS ~ Y-iu J5 J ulltJJ IusJU JlJo (S JJJ (0u JJY ol-1rS (S ltJJIUJ iJ1J1iJb -II JJ iJIJ ~ y) ylJJ

tr(jJ(jJtS - ~ Jlo luollje mol -0()1jtS

It is recommended that nations make full use of NATO resources and partnership tools in developing the follow up to this effort Nations are also encouraged to take advantage of expertise of civil society organisations from within their own country Such an approach will help strengthen the outputs of this

process and build trust with the public

01 I~~ H Il V~I~~~rlfVV Iltr(f~_~ll~~~jf~_~ mil1n5~~r~1g

(

-( Ishy C-t pound r ~Lb ~1 ~

11

~ ~cent [ rf ~ ~~ ~ ~CC ~c~ 1

L deg [ I- L L rt _~ V L I-gttgt~ ~ c

( ~v E-[rFnmiddot no o

~ ~I shy)i ~ ~ ~ b ~bull cmiddot

~ tpound ~ ~v t~ ~ c ~ r- c ~(t L (i ~

11

c lti- [ rT (( r- ~ ~ ( c 4A L- ((

v

~f [ ~ ~ tmiddot t~c Gcmiddot C L e ~ c~ ~v~ tJ ~1

( I t

~ I-~~ pound~ C -[L E nmiddotmiddot ~ I- ~(( -~ 1 cmiddot ec~ ~[ e ~crnmiddot I- L ~ L ~ tI fA ~I 0 I

L [i11 ~ 1- cmiddot~ g~ tt to

~~

~~c~v) ~ ~~ ) ~ [ ~L ~ ~~ - -( [ ~ c- fC ~ ~ ~ ~ c - [L -[ -( - 4[ ( L ~~ ~

~ E G - L - N Fi c- 1- 1- ~ ct ~ $ c

-[ 0-

f~ ~ poundt [) t ~ ~~ n - ~ l- e 0-

[ c ~ 0- I- shy~~ ~ t~~it -[ L [ r I shy

~ ~~[c e ft = fA LLt ~ ~pound t- ~ c-

gttgt

L [ f-c~ )-()v L ~ L [ ((-~~- - ~ L ltL ~ i -t ~~ ~ Emiddotn - L~ gttgt lshyI 0 1 (( L

gttgt -[ C F~ ~ -nmiddot shy ~ I shy-C 11 ~ L el-C c -( v tI rt E rlf =shy~ [ c L t

4A r~)it

~ -~n ~- cmiddotmiddot~t -~ ~~~ ([ - ~ L e

1 cu -JIxJIIU) olJ ()llp yJ uollol lUlt --raquo Ji1J s1~Jolslu lUlt ()l1Jw J ~WJi1j tolllw l~yl)W-s J r0JJ01 sJl olJ Jjlp lUlt wJ~C lool

IJ~Jtlw y) YJ~

bull IJWolIJ -JIxJIIU olJ)ybo yl ~ lUlt J wIYNI~J(5 olJ vJJC ylJI

bull ~u lUlt t~Jw IYJICul J CIIw wt~ bull I(ILSJ 1JYb --raquo Uu-Il J ol~lJ(5 olJ UOIllUlt (~I olJ vJJC ~I~ J ()l1~ JI Ij (J(5

sIJl0olIUIJss)

2 olJ yly (IJ ytJioI lUlt olJ sJiJJ wlu w~C lool Ij ~J ~1JollJs 0Jyl JI~ ~JJ(5 tolllw I~tyl)w J JJI (JCol 11 Iu ytJioI 0j Ji1~ suwxJ J ~Ji -JIxJIIU

o(W0ol~ Iu s1J (~JUO IYJJw ~ ~Jol~ lulu olJ Y)YJss olJ CsJlw -JI~~J o(wuol~ (o)ybo I yl Jjlp lUlt ollJ0ol~

IJ~Jtlw y) YJ~

bull I(LSJo )I (1~lu Iuu olJ Iu 0Jyl

bull I~IJ 1 Jj()~ Iu 0Jyl bull J)Jollllu tlYJ~ ()l1~ -)ybo lulu yl Jjlp lUlt suwxJ J ~Ji urlJul J

J~~ --raquo C(lylw lulu

1~1rlolIIlSfi1 ~ ~ji d ~ JollJ ~I J tlol ~ J uWJ~ ~ J J~Js -lo tlol 3 fil ~ ~Ip- ~ ~ ~Iy ~I 4 WJ ~L ullol~JljS 1jigt11J rloltS ~Jolll Y~I ylji1 o~

~ll 0~1 ul jlloly Jlly ~ 4 rlol

IJ~Jtlw y) YJ~ bull JJI0u olJ )ybo yl l(wJ~ --raquo laJlt lw lUlt

bull 1~lu ol~JJ tl~ --raquo I(ull ~l

4 )ybo Jjlp lUlt ) yl lltololUs --raquo Ji1J JJluo 01 ~Jy J (1~luol tJ CsJlW-s (Iu IJ) wJ~C lool (~JUO yl UUIJiJY IYJP ~ ~JollolJ JIUI(ILSJ tllY lUlt J)J ~ ~J0ol J

(uol JJW s ylJ~

IJ~Jtlw y) YJ~ bull ~~Io llto lolUs olJ yly olJJusIJ(5 olJ uolllUlt

bull ~~Io J(luo 01 ~Jy olJ yly ol~lJ(5 olJ uolllUlt

bull (IJ ~~Iool tlJ~ olJ yly uolllUlt (I~ II~)

7

1 cu -JIxJIIU) olJ ()llp yJ uollol lUlt --raquo Ji1J s1~Jolslu lUlt ()l1Jw J ~WJi1j tolllw l~yl)W-s J r0JJ01 sJl olJ Jjlp lUlt wJ~C lool

IJ~Jtlw y) YJ~

bull IJWolIJ -JIxJIIU olJ)ybo yl ~ lUlt J wIYNI~J(5 olJ vJJC ylJI

bull ~u lUlt t~Jw IYJICul J CIIw wt~ bull I(ILSJ 1JYb --raquo Uu-Il J ol~lJ(5 olJ UOIllUlt (~I olJ vJJC ~I~ J ()l1~ JI Ij (J(5

sIJl0olIUIJss)

2 olJ yly (IJ ytJioI lUlt olJ sJiJJ wlu w~C lool Ij ~J ~1JollJs 0Jyl JI~ ~JJ(5 tolllw I~tyl)w J JJI (JCol 11 Iu ytJioI 0j Ji1~ suwxJ J ~Ji -JIxJIIU

o(W0ol~ Iu s1J (~JUO IYJJw ~ ~Jol~ lulu olJ Y)YJss olJ CsJlw -JI~~J o(wuol~ (o)ybo I yl Jjlp lUlt ollJ0ol~

IJ~Jtlw y) YJ~

bull I(LSJo )I (1~lu Iuu olJ Iu 0Jyl

bull I~IJ 1 Jj()~ Iu 0Jyl bull J)Jollllu tlYJ~ ()l1~ -)ybo lulu yl Jjlp lUlt suwxJ J ~Ji urlJul J

J~~ --raquo C(lylw lulu

1~1rlolIIlSfi1 ~ ~ji d ~ JollJ ~I J tlol ~ J uWJ~ ~ J J~Js -lo tlol 3 fil ~ ~Ip- ~ ~ ~Iy ~I 4 WJ ~L ullol~JljS 1jigt11J rloltS ~Jolll Y~I ylji1 o~

~ll 0~1 ul jlloly Jlly ~ 4 rlol

IJ~Jtlw y) YJ~ bull JJI0u olJ )ybo yl l(wJ~ --raquo laJlt lw lUlt

bull 1~lu ol~JJ tl~ --raquo I(ull ~l

4 )ybo Jjlp lUlt ) yl lltololUs --raquo Ji1J JJluo 01 ~Jy J (1~luol tJ CsJlW-s (Iu IJ) wJ~C lool (~JUO yl UUIJiJY IYJP ~ ~JollolJ JIUI(ILSJ tllY lUlt J)J ~ ~J0ol J

(uol JJW s ylJ~

IJ~Jtlw y) YJ~ bull ~~Io llto lolUs olJ yly olJJusIJ(5 olJ uolllUlt

bull ~~Io J(luo 01 ~Jy olJ yly ol~lJ(5 olJ uolllUlt

bull (IJ ~~Iool tlJ~ olJ yly uolllUlt (I~ II~)

7

L Ij Iyjl) ~wI~~~I y)s (YI)jo tJo raquoF J ~Ill) ltSJiJ) )1 (~J0o 1~Ilo IS )Jl

IJ~Jtw y)s y)xgtIS

bull 1tlollu J WII0oIs ~W IJ~~ ~Il (Ij J~J sWJIWUlt$JW~l ~Il iJ1~IW ~ ~l swJ1WUlt$JW u-1j1W o~l)S lJUvlJs J I~U (OECD) l) yy Iyl)jo yl raquoF u-U1Wi Ij

u-raquo s1JNllw tiJ0I11S t 1J(s bull ~IWj~ls ()l1)u Ij ~J 1)~I~ols ~)JO lJJ~l ~I (GRECO) )J)s I)HI

bull JltWdegIS (JW sww0 10IJ~wJw -J1()-S eol()s -J) JltW uJIIl1 JltW 1l)ltS

~Il JIIJrw JU~w ~w JrdJ

1~JtI y)s y)xgtIS

bull ~~ Iu-U)ujs ~~I JJ1WW 0oIlo J l)jlJt~I bull 1l1)u~l ~Il J IJ) tJ1w J1Clo1s ~) ~)JOols 0~1)S J tiY

3 iss Ij IJ1)l raquoF il uiJI)sol) ~ iJIJ ~ l) ltSJiJ) )11 IJ)l W~)l J1wJWs J)) ~~ Iu-U 01)0 y cjIs ~iiw)lo y)s 1w ItiJ) ~C loil

8

1 iS)lr yt~l~ JjljW )iIlt J lvJW 0)JI~ r~ )) sJ) Jir -JJilj 0f)) rt)~ t1)gtgt~ ~ILls J Uu-b J)I) ))) (-JO b)Jlw ~IJ )JiJul~ iS-RiS rtl)~ ~)OI lvlJkJ i)O)1 Jl-il

Uov~ lj JJ rJ)) t~ UO iS0)

r~Jtlw -J)~ -J))(($

bull ~~JWo -Jt~I~ )so)) rt~ ~JwJ-iW t1) J)I) )JJ) wtW ~ ~)I bull ~~JWo t1)gtgt~ J uiJII)) ~ wJW)) IW yt~ iSloJ )bl ~l~raquo)so Or LSwJJ)) ~

I~)II~ w~c )0)

bull ~o wtj)~ -J)~ lvJW)) -fo) ~~~I~ wi)) IJ-gtJjW IJ-gtr )I~w)) Iw N rJY )Ji~ J Uu-b y) wlw ~J JJ)

2 wto) -JO r-J1)jo tJo Uu-b)) ))JW JjljW )iIlt degr1wlaJraquoso lj iJIIraquo Jj) )iIlt J J~ )~j ItJlr J)o )) ~o uJc~ J)I) )1))1

rJ~Jtlwy)~ -J))(($

bull 1 Jj) )iIlt J J~ )~j sl) )) yl)O fliUJo )vU-SIraquo CJ-A ~ jww)1 ~) r~ JW) wJ~C )0)

bull ~Io~ )) yl)O )~Iraquo J t1)w Uu-I))) ))JW JjljW )iIlt J iJII)iJII) 0)JII~ fiJJc )) ~o uJac~ J)) )I))Y

bull ~~ WrJWo lj 1~lrl~ ) ~Iw iS0)so )))~ -JI )~Iraquo J t1) Uu-I) )) ))JW J) )iIlt J 0)JII~ fiJJc 1~lrJi)o l~

3 wJ~C )o)so 0Nw swJW ~o w)I~raquo y)~ -J)~ fliUJo )~Iraquo J Uu-b)) ))JW J)jW )iIlt J 0)JII~ ~ )) ~I~)~ J ~o I~ICI~ -J)~ cJ Iw r()(gtJo )gtgt ~I~ Jl-il

Uo~ lj Of w)I~) Iwtl~Ji)o I)~o iS0)

r~Jtlw -J)~ y))(($ bull IiS)lr bl)O 1 U)) tl~ fIiUJJ I~)b )) Iw )~ liJwY

bull rJltJJ-iw lw ~iJllwY

5 ~o iJob ol~ ~y )I))so o)il lj w wiNw )~Iraquo J ryl)jo yl Uu-)I ~JAraquo lj lw )) ytJ )iIlt~ yl~Y tJ-iw )~IJ))o1 ) wJ~C )0)

rJ~JtIw -J)~ -J)~ bull ~~ O) J wiIJoi)E 4S~ w~ ~b J JJYr wL) yl ~I J-IJ)1u9 ~ wl)Jt

Y~))

bull Y~I ~ ~ )) A)4-i ~ wll)IJl ltblU J ~)I$A bull ooll Jl wl~ - Y))) )-J ~~~A)4-i)L Y4SLJj ~)) )Lic1 ~u ~Iy ~)Ya-- ~

) JlJI ~ 4~Jlto)1u9 foJ)Y ~)WI ~ JL ~I)j jl wlgtoLJjTransparency Internationals Global Corruption Barometer))) J) ~~)) (

6 JJI oIJ1)jIJtrJoIif~) W~C )o)so rJlrlw )iIt~ (Itr lj -fol~ J~) J lvJW 0)JII~ riJJc ) Jb) -JO ~jlraquo r)lp Uu-b ~ iJlj)

r~Jtlw -J)~ -J)~ bull 1 iS1)fw)lw Jjl )iIlt J lvJW 0)JII~ ~ 0J-iJ ~ JJW) wi trJs~I~Ji-JOO INj)1

~jlraquo )ow) U) ~Jiraquo ~~JWo

9

bull Tijl Cb It~J()ltO ~UJ0 y)s lbJlt Jo0~10 ~JllIJl wI ijl~ ~Is J010) Ij raquoJw CJraquo ijl ~Il ~jIJJO Jo0l~

bull (~ ~IWj~Iijs y)s C(Iijw Ij lbJlt Jo0~10 ~JllIJl u sll( Tij(I~ 1ij0 NsIW~1 (~J IUw J u (~ ClJls -6YijJ ~ JOJ0l~ T~~s Ij bJjIJtrJoI wI (~ cls I~~

bull 0JJO JUI~ ~Is ~JyslJ UJOIs (JIJl ~~ JO ~Il (ij~~

10

1 ~Jl~ ~1x (Code of Conduct) ) ~ -lJUJuJ JjIJw ~lt (u1gtI((oS IJS-s t1lIIU J sIJ1Ullu

tJ u1gtI((oS) ~ lt-10 Jtlw iu o~ul wJ~C~l J yJJil ~ sl11 ytJiollj t1J ~1l iJl~ lu ~JI~ I~ Jl-i11Iiu llIJYb) ~N~ ~l

IJ~Jtw y)-s YJ~ bull [0 IJJ)W-s lJ )~ lt-10 raquoJw Wcu J ~IU UJx w~1l1 IUUt utkul-s ltU Ij ~lI-s

J ty ~Jl lly~

bull ~JI~ ~Ix [~JUO ~iJ ((oS iJJl~ bull i1 NJ)w yl ~Jl~ ltJ1J-s 1 1Jw CIIw ((oS iJJul~ I~J ((oS iJJul [~JUO lt-10 Ulo-s ~~)u

J1i1U-ilo ((oS iJJl J Wc~1 ((oS Iyul~ bull [0 YUIJloI-s y)-s WJJiw ~JI~ ~Ix J WlJiu1u J~Jl l1Jl~

bull i1 uJJ-s Y-u -lJIiJuJ u1gt11-S J tJ u1gt11-S ~Jl l1Jl 1 JJltls Iilu yJ o~ IUJ1t s1JNllU ~J ((oS iJJl~

bull [0 wJ~o Jijo l-s lt-10 ~1U-s ~ lJ NIw CIiIIi J)J l1J0l lt-10 tlJ ((oS ll lt-10 tUJUI0IJ ~IU-s ~lJ t)-ill)-iol-S lltJIlt-s1 llly 1Jsw~l~ s1J ((oS suul~

2 yl ~l5lw w~C lol ~ yl wtJu Ij ~JI~ JUwlx [~JUO J Ij Iiraquos-s yJCJJl ((oS iJJl igtO

IJJl1j wtJulw) ~ lJlJ IiJ tJlJ ~JJ ~I UiJI iJlo Iiw lt-10 t~lJ iJJC lol

3 JJUllJjIY-s -lJUJuJ lt-10 iJ1~ wulJltJ ~jl~l JJUl yIJtJIliwJlSuiJ J Iu ~ y 111i(J

lJ~Ix iJt~ J urJul-s Ii-i~ [~JUO yJCJJl ((oS iJJl lt-10 ltw~lJ w~C lol

IJ~Jtw y)-s YJ~ bull NJ)-iofluw~lylw yJ -llo 10Jw - Yi)ou1-S tlJs [~JUO tJu ((oS iJJul~ i1 1~lu JluJo

ylx J 10IJ 1u ~Jl l1Jl~ bull 11 lt-10 sIJlUlIu l1((oS 1IJjiJIu1gt1 ~l ~1l lllo ((oS iJJl~

bull WU1JYlJ lJY olioS IIIJ)-iwlJ N111w CIiIIi [~JUO 1~~ bull s1Jlullu WiJuo1l1w ~IIUJlj1uo iJ~ul) [~JUO ltJ11 ((oS suul (lt-10 iJ1~ ~yl 1i~JN0I

1~1JU J ty)

FJb ~tS 1J ~tA o~ jl ~ cb ~ J~l ~ji IJ l1)I-stAlo1JlJL J wlla UiIly -s4-0Jl~ 4 yenS wI) (SiL w~)UI ~ J-11jb I 01gt l~ IS olyJ1S ~ u-yL J 4li -Sly

u-JY -s Iy w~ yoY

bull IJ ul -s~Ily u1J1 y1 J IIt ~l Jb ~lllS IS ltIiYJl IJ ~IlytS 1Slli J ~ Jjyy ll~ y1

~lllS IS ltIiYJl ~Y ~ J ~Jl ~ bull ~lJ IS ~~WJ~ JlISlli J ~ ua -Sly ~Ily u1raquoo y1

bull ~l~ IS Uilly ~Y ~ J ~Jl ~ 1Slli J ~ -slcAj wlla y1

bull ~~ Il- ~liL) o~j jl ~1ly o~j y1

5 JJUl wt~y J1UJU-s IJ lJl ~1l J wllY-J lU~YU-slJ Y)YJ -lJUJuJ wJU-iuJJI l1J J~ J

iJ~ul-s IjIlo suuloJl wJ~C lol

11

bull IiW )JW ltJI (O wrlwo I ueIJlwo I~

bull WJJi iCkSr iJl=1- ) iW )JWl (iiJltJ J i iW iCLSi --lO )JiS tiro ylj ~

6 CJ~ IWJW-s i IJlrlltJ ltJs t~o -J)IgtJWJ Ult J W-i)y r~ )s ) ~ iJIJ Iti)) ltSJiJ) JOr rysyraquo~ iJltJIW-s i 0l Jo w yl ~j(iIltJ Iw ltJJ~C 5W-i li ~~ 0 ickSr

tJW-s YJo I~ U) YJo [JWOf

7 ~j(iIltJ iHb --lO ~ltJ ltJt~Y JIWJW-s usul Ult )) ~ iJIJ ~~ ) ltSJiJ) tu )ILSo~

8 ltJJ~C ois l1)ltJ ~~u il~ 0l [~JWO 1jb)jIJtrJoI) )JW wol Ult 5JJ) JOrI iJl=1P I- 5w

9 U) JJIW-iw I~ltJ rJs 1~ly I-os) iJIY- ~~Jlw ueIJ))ybo yl 0l~JiJU u [0 b)jIJtrJoIi y) w~i0 [W-iw 111- yli ~IJ u

12

1 )JUJ 7Jlu-Sjlxs JJlySk~ poundJJ) CJiJ lt-lO JI~ wUIJY ~1Us J 7JigtJuJ J Jtylw s~~ JtJ )I lt-lO Icw(l) wJu4ic J

2 Itlyl s~~ y)l WJlySlw Jltilt J) poundJJ) CJiJ)I wJu4ic J (lt-lO tUJ1U 10IJ

U-$1~uJol t~lWs rUs U-$IjIU~ol u1wJ 1Aj1 wsu~Jxs J ty)

3 )JUJ I)tsoYJ~o Jltilt lt-lO 71JJIIU lt-lO JIJJ IJI)JsJ~~-J J Itlyl qu Iu I(I-J ) wJu4ic J 11 J) Iu)~ J) 71)JIIU Yco (JP I- J)Jlt 11 YJJlto Jltilt 0) (IIJo lt-lO uJ) I-

)(IJlt

4 t) Ij wt~(O csJiw 0lyt tl JJ) J) IIJ Jlti1t ~~lt lt-lO tUJ1U ~IJ u)JJ J(iltsJ lu-olu lJSul J (II) JI)ol

5 )JUJ yco tlJi- J) yly YJJlto Jjlp Jlti1t J) poundJJ) JII ~JJ0o I~ J 11JigtI0o 01 J)y 6J) 101gt1 J) Iu)~ J)JJ I- uJlt

6 11 I(I-J J1-t Jjlp J) (IIJJ~ lt-lO uJ) )U-$ I~lt IJ) lt-lO uJ) ~ wi ~o c J yl ltj(1w YJ I~lt 11 Itl~1 I(I-J JIJt ylJlw) Ij YJJlto I~lt 11 J) lt)($Iu (IIJ Ij I(I-J JjlJJ

JI I- JJJlt IJ) I- JJJ ~uJ JJWs yl)r

7 )JUJ c(llyJigt lt-lO I(I-J J))w Jlti1t) wJu4ic J lt-lO JI~ wUIJY c(lly~ uJ) uWllt lu 01gt1)w Ij (Iraquo 71JJllu1 (II) 0011 11 7)JY 01 tl ltJIJl0o c(llyJigt1- JJ0Jlt IJ) ~ JJ0J

w Ju4ic sU-$J ~)

8 )Jul JJ) )($Js WC)($y J ltIy JI)ol) 01)0 yl wLb JP J u-otu U-$~roI)y~ w~c sU-$J

IJu-oJtlw y) y)~ bull 6))JtIJoI J) )~ yl JI)tsol lt-lO JIJJ J(IltsJ lJSu (IIIU ysly Jty

bull 6)jIJtIJ Jlw Jjlxs J bly u)JJ ~u lu-olu J WJlyxs so y) wlNu J)~Ixs J) luJ~ I- JJJ

bull 11 J)IJ Ij u)JJ ~ul 0) (IIJo J) c(llylw Jjlp IUJI I- JJJlt sJ1 bly J)II ) J)($Uw

1 suJ J lt-lO ~o ~Jxs Ij 001I~I I- JJJlt

13

1 )JUJ 7Jlu-Sjlxs JJlySk~ poundJJ) CJiJ lt-lO JI~ wUIJY ~1Us J 7JigtJuJ J Jtylw s~~ JtJ )I lt-lO Icw(l) wJu4ic J

2 Itlyl s~~ y)l WJlySlw Jltilt J) poundJJ) CJiJ)I wJu4ic J (lt-lO tUJ1U 10IJ

U-$1~uJol t~lWs rUs U-$IjIU~ol u1wJ 1Aj1 wsu~Jxs J ty)

3 )JUJ I)tsoYJ~o Jltilt lt-lO 71JJIIU lt-lO JIJJ IJI)JsJ~~-J J Itlyl qu Iu I(I-J ) wJu4ic J 11 J) Iu)~ J) 71)JIIU Yco (JP I- J)Jlt 11 YJJlto Jltilt 0) (IIJo lt-lO uJ) I-

)(IJlt

4 t) Ij wt~(O csJiw 0lyt tl JJ) J) IIJ Jlti1t ~~lt lt-lO tUJ1U ~IJ u)JJ J(iltsJ lu-olu lJSul J (II) JI)ol

5 )JUJ yco tlJi- J) yly YJJlto Jjlp Jlti1t J) poundJJ) JII ~JJ0o I~ J 11JigtI0o 01 J)y 6J) 101gt1 J) Iu)~ J)JJ I- uJlt

6 11 I(I-J J1-t Jjlp J) (IIJJ~ lt-lO uJ) )U-$ I~lt IJ) lt-lO uJ) ~ wi ~o c J yl ltj(1w YJ I~lt 11 Itl~1 I(I-J JIJt ylJlw) Ij YJJlto I~lt 11 J) lt)($Iu (IIJ Ij I(I-J JjlJJ

JI I- JJJlt IJ) I- JJJ ~uJ JJWs yl)r

7 )JUJ c(llyJigt lt-lO I(I-J J))w Jlti1t) wJu4ic J lt-lO JI~ wUIJY c(lly~ uJ) uWllt lu 01gt1)w Ij (Iraquo 71JJllu1 (II) 0011 11 7)JY 01 tl ltJIJl0o c(llyJigt1- JJ0Jlt IJ) ~ JJ0J

w Ju4ic sU-$J ~)

8 )Jul JJ) )($Js WC)($y J ltIy JI)ol) 01)0 yl wLb JP J u-otu U-$~roI)y~ w~c sU-$J

IJu-oJtlw y) y)~ bull 6))JtIJoI J) )~ yl JI)tsol lt-lO JIJJ J(IltsJ lJSu (IIIU ysly Jty

bull 6)jIJtIJ Jlw Jjlxs J bly u)JJ ~u lu-olu J WJlyxs so y) wlNu J)~Ixs J) luJ~ I- JJJ

bull 11 J)IJ Ij u)JJ ~ul 0) (IIJo J) c(llylw Jjlp IUJI I- JJJlt sJ1 bly J)II ) J)($Uw

1 suJ J lt-lO ~o ~Jxs Ij 001I~I I- JJJlt

13

6 e~il~

is1Y 1Y wky- bull ~ljl OJl Jj c~ ltla 1l ulAljL) 4

bull uj 41 ~lj)l lp-J ~L -IL 1llL ~ Y w)li ltIi 1l 4S (-rJj uL1 yl ~ jl) ~ l1)1 41 ~~ l11 ~ J ljl OJl Jj1

2 11 u1IIUlolul1 o~ vJJlt yo cJy 1 llwlsol1 01 IIYUJ)1 U1J yl (O 11Y1tJs 1j ulYll1J YO1J cJ1oUl Jl~

IJ~Jtlw y) Y1~ bull 11 l1 vJc IlYw)wXs Y0Jl l1)ybo yl Iu I~Jt IJCJl IlYw~

bull l1 vJc 1Y1craquo 11 y) lY1y1j1u (~ ItwJU J 1ltJs) J IJIlk~ 1ltJs (YO JIJ -IJIY JJO Ju1t0 J csJllw IltJ) Y0Jl 1JJ~ l1 )ybo yl ~I1 JlyJ JyJ JCJl lI1l~

bull 11 NsIU~I y) ~I1w JCJl lI1l~ bull 11 bJlt01 (modules) IIJj~ l1 l~)IY I~~

3 Cb1 ~1ll1 WlI~IW lYJt J 1Jjluo (yo JIJJ J)1lIlo1 J CJlIJol 1ltJs) l1 J)b i~ (~JUO s10J ~ Iyl~

IJ~Jtlw y) y1~ bull 11 l1 )ybo yllu IJ~Jt slll I~JI YUIJl JCJl lI1l~

bull l1 vJc IYICJ 11 Y0Jl 1JJ~ l1 )ybo yl ~I1 JlyJ JyJ y) lY1y1j1u JCJl lI1l~ bull 11 NsIUj~I y) ~I1w IJCJlI~~

bull 11bJltIgtI (modules) IIJj~ l1 ~)IY I~~

5 11 slll lltSwJJu ~1~l1)ybo yl (~J~ yJCJ1l yl ~Il 01l1 vJc 1~1k~Xs y) uJIlUlolU IIIJJul J 01 l1 1Y1c0 JCJl lI1l~

IJ~Jtlw y) Y1~ bull 11 uJIlUlolU 11Jl IIJJJ llo lul~ 11 U)l ~ 1j JyJ ClYly )IYlu ~I~so JIl1 yo

~I1w y1 Cb1 ~1ll1 1Y1c0 yIWlJCJl lI1ul~ 11 lulu IIJjJ~lo lul~ 11l1 ~IUOI tlJlW C~J1 lulu W~~~ JJl~

6 11 b1jlJtIJoI y) CJlIJol lYJt l1 J)b i~ JCJl lI1l~ 1~1 JCJl lI1l 11 lUOI Ij ~~Io Cb1 ~Il Y1~ Jlo lul~

14

tJiJ1Ji 01 - JI~jIJ($ 1 JAxju-s)slJ 5JJJ J(I --JO 1JJ tl- --JO wlI~k~ lUlt J 1(Lxjw 1yyU ~ ~Jl UoJUw

JIJ wJ~C lIgtIjl

2 OJ ~J0o l~ullJ IJJI( J tl(IW) s Ij JJILxju t(JI txllxol (tU I~ (0()0 yl (ubJ lu) --JO

Itw-IJ (Jt- 5Lxjl

3 --JO It~IJ ~Jljljls (O 0lJ JjJw lUlt J LxjJyl IVJc (ULS~ txllxol~ IIjI txllraquo Ij UJ-s 1j5 Illy (~raquo ul=alp ~ JJl Ijl --JO 1JJ (lI~I0o Ij UJ 1lI)wt~lJ LxjJyl

(UJc J Jjlp lUlt

4 lJY ~(J txllraquo lUlt ) bull Ij IJJijly Lxjlyl wi I() JJIJlIl (--JO J(~ ~lplljslJ)Jraquo yl Jjpl J Jtylw tl- JlyJ I() IUw) 0()0 yl 0Ju J~ J u-ltotu Iu U1j~( wJ~C lIgtIjl

(JU-ltOJtlw y) YJ~ bull lJ)Jraquo yl lJY 01 (1(JxwlJ (JI(lw CUIU (O Jltllgt I J(Jl lIJl

bull (O ~ullj lJ )Jraquo yl ItJI( l1)ljljol J WcIIjU s tJly YJ 7Jlltul tll J --JO 0JJ J~lIgt --JO l~ ~ IIjl J(Jl lIJl

bull (O ~ullj y) ItJI( w-Il( (uUt (J(Jl I~ - lljl Ilju ~~ul YJ o~ J~ 01 JlyJ I()I~

bull iljl I() txllxol ~(~ YJJVljol lJY I Ijl w-I~ y) l~Iraquo J I-~ ItJIJ IUw

(JU-ltOJt lw y) YJ~

bull JUtw Cal UJlyJ J Lxjlj y) Iu bull ~ICljul 51raquo WJ1j IUWClI( J Lxjlyl (Jw y) ItU-ltOI oljtsw (ul~

bull (JJ)w J U-ltOJlyb ~Iraquo y) Itu-ltol oljtsw (uIJ~ 0()0 yl 0Ju JJw J u-ltotu 1001

7 1J jlJtrJol y) 0JJ o~ 7Jl0ol wlI~lwtxlIraquo (0( 1CJrI0o J 0( tljJ (CJ(I0o)) wJ~C lIgtIjl J N5ILxj~I Wtljlju ~t-Iw J()lltsJmiddot --JO J(~ JJullgtl w-N( ~Ijraquo ) --JO Itw-IJ ~t- 5Lxjl

(Ju-ltoJtIw y) YJ~ bull (O wulUy Ij txllxol ylJJy lUlt Ij lIj~lo 5Nw Ijl IJjJi tJu-s I~

bull lljl ~JJl wCxJ WJ J 51(w Ij OJ (JJl (ul~ J wE1j1j)w ytl (JJ-s 5ltj Ijl --JO -JP IJ5wJ~5) ~llraquo ~ JJl

(~Jtlw y) YJ~

bull Y)JJl J IJwIy (ul~ 01 bull It1l J)JlIl

15

bull N5IjjJrgtIcS V lj J))~b bull ItJI~~I~~yIJJJb(0Ut U)~vraquo~~~

bull b)jlJt~~IcS ClgtlyxgtltS

bull JrW ~ tllti~lltideg -lObJ) t(o lj I)gtgt yJ~ yJCJyl) yl~~ 11 ~I~ b)jIJt~J TJyau ~~IJcSIsuw~ -ltJ~ ~I)~ J1-i ~~C ~~

bull G0 ~)(o~ lj J))~I~I j tllti~JcS I~)~ ~I~~ 5U~ J Ij G0 b)jIJt~w y)cS

tllti~JcS ~)J0ij5I~~ ~ JJ~

9 N5jjj~VcS) ~ y)cS ~u 5~~ su~ ~UIgt t~~ tllti~IJcS ~ -lO 5) y~~ Jy ltJ~C 5jj~ J -lO It~) YijU 5jj~ ~ ~) (oJ tJbcS ~) ~t(ol~ Ij G0 b)jIJt~IcS

I~I~~JJ~

10 ~) yly I~I~ Ij I~UU J ~IJIU~) )J~ tllti~Illti0 ltJJ~C ~~ (raquo Ij ~~IJcS lulu

uNUIU CI(oJ ~ JJ~ J wu J~ J tu GjjU )Jii5)~ ) -lO lt~) YijIU ~~

~JJtIltJ y)cS Y)xgtltS

bull b)jIJt~1 y)cS ul1 ~J Y) ~0U1 bull ~~ ~) )yk yl I~)b ~UIIgtY ~) I~I~ Ij 1~0UI

~JJtl~ y)cS y)xgtltS

bull G~ ~u ~)b tJ~JcS~) 5JJ ) ~~I bull Y)JY J 1)~IYcS W~00blltJ t~~JcS ~) ~lltiU (01Jv-

bull 1)~IYcS J ul1 y) t~ ~llti0l TIgt lj tblcS J))~b bull ~~IYij) t 1(ocS ) ltJJ~C 5jj~ ~ o~ Ij lu 5loJ tb) ~b ~) t~ ~llti0 y~

12 ltJJ~C 5jj~ ~ Graquo ~cS ~JU ~tu 5)~ ~5 tllti~IJcS Y~ ~)cS oNltJ t~I~ J

~~ JIC~ y~~ J~) (o~ (~~ J I)~) o)s)~) ~JIvraquo yl )J0~ tllti~lltidegIcS ~t~m uJu ~~

~JJtkJ y)lcS y)xgtltS

bull ~5Ijjj~lcS ~-N~ ~JcS bull G0 ~) (o~ Ij tllti~llti0cS ~ltcS sJJ) ~~I ~) clJ C I) lj ~0Yt JIC~ -lO ~~ I~ (JJI~

(oJ ~~y) bull G0 ltJ~IYijJcS ~) ~ I~) ~ltJI ~ ~JIU~ ~JJb ~~ ~ ltJ005 uo ~ y)cS

jjJru~o -ltJ~ ~)~

bull JJjju~~J~~ bull 1 Ij ~~ Igtij~~ (0Jv- JJ~ ~)J0 00b ~~~ ~J~

16

1 N5Irjjj~IcI5 wJ~C 5rjjs Jjlpl J iJIJr~115 ~ (-JC tuaJU- 0r1cU~oll5 txIu) Y15 -=-trJ yl uli~115 ~I~ J -l)ltw -lJ -JC lU1U 1iJltUlJo (Ssw wlb w J v=tu

b)jlJt~J -JC Itwual) --Vu ~

2 wJl~IcI5 w~C~s Jjlp Ult rJ) Y))iJ15 ) IJo I~ wi orSu uliSul) ylJI y)J0 rtclyll5 ~Iu J ryl)jo tJce ~I ) o~ txIxol ~Jy 5u

3 c1 JIJr I~ ltJl uliSull5 N~ c5 y)ul~ tJI~ I~ y1uliu wI yWJlw) rUI~ 01 1~lr uliJ0f ltJ~C~s ~ob)jIJtrJ J ~IrjjJrI5)ybo yl uliSulcl5s ()wJI00J

rtclyl ~NJ 5UU c1 ~ 1raquo r~J liJw

r~JtlltJ y15 Y)JiJI5 bull c1 ltUI~ --VU ~I) yl uliSull5 Itw J t~15 )ybo yluaJ tJI~ J jUt -JC to

~J I)f

bull ~~~15 1)JcIYI$ yl ItltJyl) y Ju c5 SltJ bull 1~IJo Ij b)jIJt~Ic15 Ij --VJ Jc~ iJcjle rrUJtcw c1 -=-tJc J IcUs ~e ~ UlSJ

I~ J ~c i~I~

4 Ij ~o b)jIJt~ y15 r-bJt iJltwu ~I ) yly txIxotl5 xy IJJJt ) syJ) ~I 1~IJo (S Jf

r~JtltJ y15 y))iJI5 bull W()IJy ~I~jlxol J txIxol J 1iJ01Jf5 s Ij lu I~IJo (S J

bull ltUI~I) b)jIJtrJ ty) 1J0 -JC Sull5 Itw ) r-1ciJO yl~-s tl~l5

bull 5 ~Irjj~ Jb)jIJt~IcI5)1 w~ Jocs) syJ) ~I ~I 1) (S iJ1j ltJI tJco iJJcent

I~iw cltJrw ) iJcj~r txIxolysl~ 500J -JC ~J 0rraquo 01c151j ys1clw ~~ J w rJo115 bl

17

---------------

10 ytJi wI JAxssos j sJiJ)ol tJll)jly l)~raquo I (~ JiJl~l ylJ tJlol (10l ~~so yo yyraquo 01wJ tJll)jy l)0wsraquo I by ~ s0l 0 ytJi I l) 0(0 o~(

W(~l tJol sy

--------shy

18

Y As I1JltlltJ ~~ ylygt JU tJ 1JiI--S ~raquo Jb-tl yl rl(t l~ ~IU ~lp Susan Pond

Director Partnership for Peace NATO International Staff Email spondhqnatoint

MarkPyman Director Defence Against Corruption programme Transparency International

Email mark pymantransparencyorguk

y)s rtJJrlltJ yij~ ylygt rJ~ ultJJ y)s ~ J JJIs rJI~s ijJJJ- IltJJI~ Jb-tl i-IO U1ijuls IUltJ~ Jj r(to sW

httpwwwnatointlissuespfpindexhtml httpwww nato jntlissueseapc

y)s rtJJrltJ ~~ ylygt yUIF ytJ wlts uk-ikiij~ ~u IJrJJ J 1(ltJJki JU-itltJ lu Jb-tl U1ijltJ lultJu~ J-i1 rJIltlo sw

httpwwwdefenceagainstcorruptionorg httpwwwtransparencyorg

Version control Version 7 January 30 2009 ~J ~o ~o 7 30 (UJraquo 2009

19

Y As I1JltlltJ ~~ ylygt JU tJ 1JiI--S ~raquo Jb-tl yl rl(t l~ ~IU ~lp Susan Pond

Director Partnership for Peace NATO International Staff Email spondhqnatoint

MarkPyman Director Defence Against Corruption programme Transparency International

Email mark pymantransparencyorguk

y)s rtJJrlltJ yij~ ylygt rJ~ ultJJ y)s ~ J JJIs rJI~s ijJJJ- IltJJI~ Jb-tl i-IO U1ijuls IUltJ~ Jj r(to sW

httpwwwnatointlissuespfpindexhtml httpwww nato jntlissueseapc

y)s rtJJrltJ ~~ ylygt yUIF ytJ wlts uk-ikiij~ ~u IJrJJ J 1(ltJJki JU-itltJ lu Jb-tl U1ijltJ lultJu~ J-i1 rJIltlo sw

httpwwwdefenceagainstcorruptionorg httpwwwtransparencyorg

Version control Version 7 January 30 2009 ~J ~o ~o 7 30 (UJraquo 2009

19