27
!"#$% '( )'*+%*+, "#$#%&%'# "#$#%&%'# "#$#%&%'# "#$#%&%'# ()*& #+% ,$-. /*)0% 1* ()*& #+% ,$-. /*)0% 1* ()*& #+% ,$-. /*)0% 1* ()*& #+% ,$-. /*)0% 1*21+$3)- 1+$3)- 1+$3)- 1+$3)- 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 444444444444444444444444444 444444444444444444444444444 444444444444444444444444444 5 /*)%6*)7 /*)%6*)7 /*)%6*)7 /*)%6*)744444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 444444444444444 444444444444444 444444444444444 8 9'#)*7:0#3*' 9'#)*7:0#3*' 9'#)*7:0#3*' 9'#)*7:0#3*' 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444 4444444444 4444444444 ; /3'73'<- /3'73'<- /3'73'<- /3'73'<- 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444 44444444444444 44444444444444 => => => => /*0:- ?)%$- /*0:- ?)%$- /*0:- ?)%$- /*0:- ?)%$- 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444 44444444 44444444 =@ ?00*:'#$A3B3#C $'7 ,)$'-D$)%'0C 3' E:7<%#3'< $'7 /3'$'03$B F%D*)#3'< 44444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 =@ ?00*:'#$A3B3#C $'7 ,)$'-D$)%'0C F%0*&&%'7$#3*'- 44444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 =@ G$'$<3'< #+% 9&D$0# *( /%7%)$B H%(303# F%7:0#3*' 444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 =I F%0*&&%'7$#3*'- *' G$'$<3'< #+% 9&D$0# *( /%7%)$B H%(303# F%7:0#3*' 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 =I J'7%)(:'7%7 F%#3)%&%'# K)*&3-%- 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 =L 9'0)%$-3'< ,)$'-D*)#$#3*' 9'M%-#&%'# #* E%'%(3# #+% N0*'*&C44444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 =; 9&D)*M3'< #+% "#$#%O/%7%)$B K$)#'%)-+3D *( G%730$374444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 @= 1*'0B:-3*' *'0B:-3*' *'0B:-3*' *'0B:-3*' 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444 4444444444 4444444444 @P N'7'*#%- N'7'*#%- N'7'*#%- N'7'*#%-44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 44444444444444444444444444444444 444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 4444444444444 4444444444444 4444444444444 @8

2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

!

!"#$%&'(&)'*+%*+,&!

"#$#%&%'#"#$#%&%'#"#$#%&%'#"#$#%&%'#!!!!()*&!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!1*()*&!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!1*()*&!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!1*()*&!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!1*22221+$3)-1+$3)-1+$3)-1+$3)-!!!!4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444!!!!5555!!!!

/*)%6*)7/*)%6*)7/*)%6*)7/*)%6*)7!!!!44444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444!!!!8888!!!!

9'#)*7:0#3*'9'#)*7:0#3*'9'#)*7:0#3*'9'#)*7:0#3*'!!!!444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444!!!!;;;;!!!!

/3'73'<-/3'73'<-/3'73'<-/3'73'<-!!!!4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444!!!!=>=>=>=>!!!!

/*0:-!?)%$-/*0:-!?)%$-/*0:-!?)%$-/*0:-!?)%$-!!!!4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444!!!!====@@@@!!!!?00*:'#$A3B3#C!$'7!,)$'-D$)%'0C!3'!E:7<%#3'<!$'7!/3'$'03$B!F%D*)#3'<!44444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444!=@!?00*:'#$A3B3#C!$'7!,)$'-D$)%'0C!F%0*&&%'7$#3*'-!44444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444!=@!G$'$<3'<!#+%!9&D$0#!*(!/%7%)$B!H%(303#!F%7:0#3*'!444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444!=I!F%0*&&%'7$#3*'-!*'!G$'$<3'<!#+%!9&D$0#!*(!/%7%)$B!H%(303#!F%7:0#3*'!4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444!=I!J'7%)(:'7%7!F%#3)%&%'#!K)*&3-%-!4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444!=L!9'0)%$-3'<!,)$'-D*)#$#3*'!9'M%-#&%'#!#*!E%'%(3#!#+%!N0*'*&C!44444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444!=;!9&D)*M3'<!#+%!"#$#%O/%7%)$B!K$)#'%)-+3D!*(!G%730$37!4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444!@=!

1111*'0B:-3*'*'0B:-3*'*'0B:-3*'*'0B:-3*'!!!!444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444!!!!@@@@PPPP!!!!

N'7'*#%-N'7'*#%-N'7'*#%-N'7'*#%-!!!!444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444!!!!@@@@8888!!!

! &

Page 2: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

!!

&

Page 3: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&&&&&&/3'$B!F%D*)#!!

1+"+%:%*+&(/':&+0%&!",7&8'/9%&)';)0"6/,&!!!!

,+%!"#$#%!E:7<%#!1)3-3-!,$-.!/*)0%!6$-!0)%$#%7!3'!#+%!$(#%)&$#+!*(!#+%!<B*A$B!(3'$'03$B!0)3-3-!#*!%Q$&3'%!#+%!3'0)%$-3'<BC!D%)3B*:-!D*-3#3*'!*(!&$'C!-#$#%-4!9'!*:)!3'3#3$B!)%D*)#R!6%!:'$&A3<:*:-BC!0*'0B:7%7!#+$#R!S,+%!%Q3-#3'<!#)$T%0#*)C!*(!-#$#%!-D%'73'<R!#$Q$#3*'R!$'7!$7&3'3-#)$#3M%!D)$0#30%-!0$''*#!A%!-:-#$3'%74!,+%!A$-30!D)*AB%&!3-!'*#!0C0B30$B4!9#!3-!-#):0#:)$B4!,+%!#3&%!#*!$0#!3-!'*64U!

?!0*'(B:%'0%!*(!#)%'7-!$'7!03)0:&-#$'0%-!+$M%!DB$0%7!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-!3'!$!D*-3#3*'!*(!(3-0$B!3'-#$A3B3#C!$'7!:'7%)&3'%7!#+%!$A3B3#C!*(!#+%3)!%0*'*&3%-!#*!0*&D%#%!3'!#+%!<B*A$B!&$).%#DB$0%V!

! "#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!)%M%':%-!*'BC!D$)#3$BBC!)%0*M%)%7!-3'0%!#+%!)%0%--3*'!#+$#!A%<$'!3'!@>>;4!! F%7:0#3*'-!3'!(%7%)$B!-D%'73'<!+$M%!&$7%!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!(3'$'0%-!&*)%!0+$*#30!$'7!&*)%!73((30:B#!#*!&$'$<%4!! F%#3)%&%'#!$'7!+%$B#+!0$)%!%QD%'73#:)%-!0*'#3':%!#*!)3-%!$#!$!)$#%!($-#%)!#+$'!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!)%M%':%-R!$'7!&$'C!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-!+$M%!'*#!$77)%--%7!-%)3*:-!D%'-3*'!(:'73'<!-+*)#($BB-4!

! /%6!-#$#%-!+$M%!&*:'#%7!'%6!0$D3#$B!3'()$-#):0#:)%!3'M%-#&%'#!D)*<)$&-!#+$#!.%%D!D$0%!63#+!7%#%)3*)$#3*'!$'7!63BB!.%%D!#+%3)!3'()$-#):0#:)%!&*7%)'!$'7!0*&D%#3#3M%4!

! ,+%!'%$)2#*#$B!$A-%'0%!*(!-%)3*:-!0*'-:B#$#3*'!A%#6%%'!(%7%)$B!$'7!-#$#%!(3-0$B!D*B30C&$.%)-!+$-!*(#%'!*A-0:)%7!#+%!B*'<2#%)&!3&D$0#!*(!%QD%'73#:)%!0:#-!$'7!)%M%':%!)%7:0#3*'-4!

W%!$B-*!-#:73%7R!3'!7%#$3BR!#+%!(3'$'03$B!0*'73#3*'-!3'!%$0+!*(!-3Q!-#$#%-V!1$B3(*)'3$R!9BB3'*3-R!X%6!Y%)-%CR!X%6!Z*).R!,%Q$-!$'7![3)<3'3$!\6664-#$#%A:7<%#4*)<]4!W%!+%B7!73-0:--3*'-!63#+!D$)#'%)-!$'7!-#$.%+*B7%)-!#*!)%M3%6!*:)!(3'73'<-!3'!(*:)!*(!#+*-%!-#$#%-4!!

"*&%!*(!#+%!&*-#!-%)3*:-!D)*AB%&-!7%#%0#%7!6%)%V!!

! 1$-+2A$-%7!A:7<%#3'<R!6+30+!($03B3#$#%7!<3&&30.-!$'7!*A-0:)%7!-#$#%!(3-0$B!0*'73#3*'^!! ,+%!$A-%'0%!*(!&%$'3'<(:B!&:B#3C%$)!(3'$'03$B!DB$''3'<^!!! E:7<%#-!$'7!(3'$'03$B!)%D*)#-!#+$#!($3B%7!#*!-%#!*:#!#+%!(:#:)%!0*-#-!*(!(3'$'03$B!*AB3<$#3*'-!$B)%$7C!&$7%4!

9'!-:&R!63#+*:#!7%%D2-%$#%7!)%(*)&!3'!-#$#%!<*M%)'&%'#!(3-0$B!$(($3)-!*)!(%7%)$B!)%0*<'3#3*'!*(!#+%!-#)$3'-!*'!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!A:7<%#-R!#+%!(:#:)%!+%$B#+!*(!?&%)30$_-!0*&&:'3#3%-!$'7!3#-!%0*'*&C!$)%!$#!<)%$#!)3-.!*(!(:)#+%)!7%#%)3*)$#3*'4!!

`'%!0*'0%)'!)$3-%7!#+)*:<+*:#!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%_-!6*).!3-!#+$#!(3-0$B!-#)%--!):'-!7*6'+3BBR!&$.3'<!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-!#+%!0*BB%0#3'<!D*3'#!*(!#+%!<)%$#%-#!(3-0$B!-#)%--4!,+3-!$7M%)-%BC!$((%0#-!#+%!D:AB30!-:DD*)#!-C-#%&-!*'!6+30+!?&%)30$'-!7%D%'7!a!0*)%!-%)M30%-!(*)!6+30+!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-!$)%!D)3&$)3BC!)%-D*'-3AB%R!-:0+!$-!D*B30%!$'7!(3)%!D)*#%0#3*'R!-$(%!)*$7-R!0B%$'!6$#%)R!$'7!73-$-#%)!)%-D*'-%4!,+%!0*'0%'#)$#3*'!*(!7%#%)3*)$#3*'!3'!#+%-%!-C-#%&-!$#!#+%!B*0$B!B%M%B!3-!3'!$773#3*'!#*!%)*-3*'!*(!%7:0$#3*'$B!b:$B3#C!$'7!0$D3#$B!3'()$-#):0#:)%4!!

,+3-!<)3&!A:#!)%$B3-#30!$--%--&%'#!*(!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!(3-0$B!+%$B#+!-%#!#+%!0*'#%Q#!(*)!K+$-%!,6*!*(!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%_-!6*).R!6+30+!3'0B:7%7!X$#3*'$B!H3$B*<:%-!#*!%Q$&3'%!(*:)!+3<+2D)3*)3#C!$)%$-R!3'0B:73'<V!!

! 9&D)*M3'<!#+%!"#$#%O/%7%)$B!K$)#'%)-+3D!*(!G%730$37!!! G$'$<3'<!#+%!9&D$0#!*(!/%7%)$B!H%(303#!F%7:0#3*'^!!

Page 4: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

I!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&!/3'$B!F%D*)#!

! J'(:'7%7!K%'-3*'!K)*&3-%-^!$'7!! 9'0)%$-3'<!,)$'-D*)#$#3*'!/:'73'<!#*!E%'%(3#!#+%!N0*'*&C4!

9'!%$0+!*(!#+%-%!.%C!$)%$-R!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!D)%D$)%7!$!6+3#%!D$D%)=!$'7!A)*:<+#!#*<%#+%)!(*:)!X$#3*'$B!H3$B*<:%-R!6+30+!3'0B:7%7!3'73M37:$B-!63#+!%QD%)#3-%!3'!73((%)%'#!73&%'-3*'-!*(!#+%!$)%$-!:'7%)!%Q$&3'$#3*'4!,+%!<*$B!6$-!#*!(3'7!0*&&*'!<)*:'7!$'7!<%'%)$#%!M3$AB%!37%$-!#*!$77)%--!#+%!0+$BB%'<%-!3'!%$0+!$)%$4!,+*-%!D$)#303D$#3'<!3'0B:7%7!A:-3'%--!B%$7%)-R!%B%0#%7!*((303$B-R!:'3*'!*((303$B-R!D:AB30!D*B30C!%QD%)#-R!0*&&:'3#C!B%$7%)-R!$7M*0$#%-R!$'7!$0$7%&30-!a!$BB!63#+!$!)%-*BM%!#*!<%'%)$#%!D)*<)%--!#+)*:<+!0)%$#3M%!$'7!0*'-03%'#3*:-!<*M%)'3'<4!,+%-%!H3$B*<:%-!0)%$#%7!M$B:$AB%!(*):&-!#+$#!3'(*)&%7!#+3-!(3'$B!)%D*)#!$'7!-D:))%7!0*'#3':3'<!73-0:--3*'!$&*'<!#+%!D$)#3%-4!

"#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!-D%'73'<!+$-!A%%'!%Q#)%&%BC!3&D*)#$'#!#*!#+%!?&%)30$'!%0*'*&CR!%-D%03$BBC!3'!#+%!$)%$-!*(!%7:0$#3*'!$'7!3'()$-#):0#:)%4!,+%!,$-.!/*)0%!3-!'*#!3'!$!D*-3#3*'!#*!&$.%!-D%03(30!D)*D*-$B-!3'!D)*<)$&&$#30!D)3*)3#3%-R!%QD%'73#:)%!B%M%B-R!#$Q!)$#%-R!*)!-#):0#:)%-!#+$#!0*:B7!7%$B!63#+!A:7<%#$)C!D)*AB%&-4!c*6%M%)R!#+*-%!D*B3#30$B!$'7!D*B30C!73-0:--3*'-!&:-#!)%-#!*'!+*'%-#R!)%B3$AB%!A:7<%#!%-#3&$#%-!$'7!%$-3BC!$00%--3AB%!$'7!#)$'-D$)%'#!7$#$!*'!(3'$'03$B!$'7!D)*<)$&&$#30!)%-:B#-!3'!*)7%)!#*!A:3B7!#):-#!$'7!-:DD*)#!(*)!)%(*)&-4!J'7%)-#$'73'<!*(!A$-30R!0B%$)!7$#$!3-!%--%'#3$B!(*)!-*BM3'<!$'7!D)%M%'#3'<!(3'$'03$B!D)*AB%&-4!!

!"#!"#!"#!"#!!!!$%&#$%&#$%&#$%&#''''()*#&$+#!%,-#."/0+#()*#&$+#!%,-#."/0+#()*#&$+#!%,-#."/0+#()*#&$+#!%,-#."/0+#1111+0"2+0"2+0"2+0"22+(),#&$+#2+(),#&$+#2+(),#&$+#2+(),#&$+#...."33"45(67#"33"45(67#"33"45(67#"33"45(67#####G*73(3%7!?00):$B!E:7<%#3'<!AC!"#$#%-!$'7!d*0$B3#3%-4!G*73(3%7!?00):$B!E:7<%#3'<!AC!"#$#%-!$'7!d*0$B3#3%-4!G*73(3%7!?00):$B!E:7<%#3'<!AC!"#$#%-!$'7!d*0$B3#3%-4!G*73(3%7!?00):$B!E:7<%#3'<!AC!"#$#%-!$'7!d*0$B3#3%-4!,+%!D)$0#30%!*(!0$-+2A$-%7!A:7<%#3'<!($03B3#$#%-!<3&&30.-!$'7!-+*)#2#%)&!&%$-:)%-!#+$#!*A-0:)%!$0#:$B!(3'$'03$B!0*'73#3*'-4!W+%)%!$DD)*D)3$#%R!:-3'<!0*'-3-#%'#R!&*73(3%7!$00):$B2A$-%7!A:7<%#3'<!6*:B7!($03B3#$#%!0*&D$)3-*'!$'7!$M*37!A:7<%#-!A$-%7!*'!3'$00:)$#%!)%D)%-%'#$#3*'-!*(!(:#:)%!*AB3<$#3*'-!*)!)%M%':%-4!!!!

G:B#3G:B#3G:B#3G:B#3CCCC%$)!/3'$'03$B!KB$'-4%$)!/3'$'03$B!KB$'-4%$)!/3'$'03$B!KB$'-4%$)!/3'$'03$B!KB$'-4!!!!"#$#%-!-+*:B7!3'0B:7%!&%$'3'<(:BR!(*)6$)72B**.3'<!(3'$'03$B!DB$'-!$-!D$)#!*(!#+%3)!$'':$B!A:7<%#!-:A&3--3*'!$'7!$7*D#3*'!D)*0%--!$-!6%BB!$-!)%b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

F%-%)M%!/:'7-4F%-%)M%!/:'7-4F%-%)M%!/:'7-4F%-%)M%!/:'7-4!!!!F%-%)M%!(:'7-R!*(#%'!0$BB%7!)$3'C!7$C!(:'7-R!-+*:B7!A%!)%b:3)%7!$'7!-+*:B7!A%!$7%b:$#%!#*!&%%#!$'C!)%$-*'$ABC!$'#303D$#%7!%M%'#:$B3#C4!9#!3-!+%$)#%'3'<!#*!-%%!#+$#!&$'C!-#$#%-!+$M%!A%<:'R!3'!-&$BB!-#%D-R!#*!)%DB%'3-+!#+%-%!(:'7-4!!!!

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e%7!#+$#R!7:%!#*!-:77%'!)%M%':%!-+*)#($BB-R!0$-+!A$B$'0%-!$#!#3&%-!&$C!'%%7!#*!A%!A*B-#%)%7!63#+!#+%!D)*0%%7-!*(!-+*)#!#%)&!A*))*63'<R!#+$#!A*))*63'<!-+*:B7!'%M%)!A%!#)%$#%7!$-!$'!%B%&%'#!*(!)%M%':%!$'7!D)*M3-3*'!-+*:B7!A%!&$7%!(*)!3#-!)%D$C&%'#4!!!!

Page 5: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&&&&/3'$B!F%D*)#!

L

"#)%'<#+%'%7!"#$#%!`M%)-3<+#!*(!d*0$B!/3'$'03$B!F%D*)#3'<!$'7!"#)%'<#+%'%7!"#$#%!`M%)-3<+#!*(!d*0$B!/3'$'03$B!F%D*)#3'<!$'7!"#)%'<#+%'%7!"#$#%!`M%)-3<+#!*(!d*0$B!/3'$'03$B!F%D*)#3'<!$'7!"#)%'<#+%'%7!"#$#%!`M%)-3<+#!*(!d*0$B!/3'$'03$B!F%D*)#3'<!$'7!1*&&:'30$#1*&&:'30$#1*&&:'30$#1*&&:'30$#3'<!K)*-D%0#-43'<!K)*-D%0#-43'<!K)*-D%0#-43'<!K)*-D%0#-4!F%0%'#!7%M%B*D&%'#-!3'!-%M%)$B!-#$#%-!7%&*'-#)$#%!#+%!'%%7!(*)!-#$#:#*)C!&%0+$'3-&-!#+$#!$BB*6!-#$#%-!#*!D)*M37%!-#)*'<!*M%)-3<+#!*(!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-!3'!$7M$'0%!*(!(3'$'03$B!%&%)<%'03%-4!K%)3*730!)%D*)#3'<!AC!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-!$'7!#3&%BC!)%M3%6!*(!(3'$'03$B!7$#$!AC!-#$#%!<*M%)'&%'#-!3-!%--%'#3$B!#*!$'#303D$#3'<!$'7!7%$B3'<!63#+!#+%!#+)%$#-!#*!D:AB30!-%)M30%-4!"#$#%-!-+*:B7!+$M%!-#$#:#*)C!D)*0%--%-!(*)!3&D*-3'<!0*))%0#3M%!$0#3*'-!*'!B*0$B3#3%-!6+*-%!(3'$'03$B!D*-3#3*'-!3'730$#%!$!+3<+!)3-.!*(!#+%3)!$A3B3#C!#*!&%%#!#+%3)!*AB3<$#3*'-!#*!#+%!D:AB304!!!!

E:7<%#!"#$'7$)7-4!E:7<%#!"#$'7$)7-4!E:7<%#!"#$'7$)7-4!E:7<%#!"#$'7$)7-4!E:7<%#3'<!-#$'7$)7-!-+*:B7!3'0B:7%!7%(3'3#3*'!*(!#+%!'$#:)%!*(!)%M%':%-R!B3&3#$#3*'-!*'!#+%!:-%!*(!'*')%0:))3'<!3#%&-R!&:B#3C%$)!DB$''3'<R!($3)!D)%-%'#$#3*'!*(!D%'-3*'!$'7!*#+%)!A%'%(3#!B3$A3B3#3%-R!$'7!#+%!-3e%!$'7!D$0%!*(!(:'73'<!*(!)%-%)M%!(:'7-4!E:7<%#-!-+*:B7!'*#!A%!*'!$!0$-+!A$-3-4!!!!!

N$-3BC!J'7%)-#$'7$AB%!/3'$'03$B!F%D*)#-4!N$-3BC!J'7%)-#$'7$AB%!/3'$'03$B!F%D*)#-4!N$-3BC!J'7%)-#$'7$AB%!/3'$'03$B!F%D*)#-4!N$-3BC!J'7%)-#$'7$AB%!/3'$'03$B!F%D*)#-4!"3&3B$)BCR!-#$'7$)72-%##3'<!A*73%-!-+*:B7!6*).!63#+!$--*03$#3*'-!*(!-#$#%-!#*!7%M%B*D!):B%-!(*)!#+%!0)%$#3*'!*(!0*'03-%R!#3&%BC!$'7!)%$7$AB%!(3'$'03$B!)%D*)#-4!,+%!0*'M*B:#%7R!-D)$6B3'<!'$#:)%!*(!-#$#%!(3'$'03$B!-#$#%&%'#-!&$.%!#+%&!*(!B3&3#%7!:-%!(*)!$BB!A:#!3'73M37:$B-!63#+!%Q#%'-3M%!#)$3'3'<4!E*#+!A:7<%#$)C!$'7!$--%#2A$-%7!3'(*)&$#3*'!(*)!$BB!-D%03$B!(:'7-!-+*:B7!A%!%$-3BC!$00%--3AB%4!":0+!7$#$!-+*:B7!A%!:-%7!3'!73-0B*-:)%!-#$#%&%'#-!(*)!A*))*63'<!3'!#+%!-$&%!(*)&$#4!!!!

9&DB30$#3*'-!(*)!#+%!/%7%)$B!f*M%)'&%'#9&DB30$#3*'-!(*)!#+%!/%7%)$B!f*M%)'&%'#9&DB30$#3*'-!(*)!#+%!/%7%)$B!f*M%)'&%'#9&DB30$#3*'-!(*)!#+%!/%7%)$B!f*M%)'&%'#4!,+%)%!3-!B3##B%!%M37%'0%!#*7$C!#+$#!#+%!1*'<)%--!$'7!NQ%0:#3M%!E)$'0+!0*'-37%)!#+%!3&D$0#!*(!3#-!7%03-3*'-!*'!#+%!*#+%)!B%M%B-!*(!<*M%)'&%'#!3'!-%##3'<!D*B30C!$'7!-D%'73'<!B%M%B-!(*)!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#4!,+%!)%$B3#C!3-!#+$#!$BB!#+)%%!B%M%B-!*(!<*M%)'&%'#!-%)M%!#+%!-$&%!D%*DB%!$'7!+$M%!$!)%-D*'-3A3B3#C!#*!%'-:)%!#+$#!#+%!:'3'#%'7%7!0*'-%b:%'0%-!*(!#+%3)!(3-0$B!$0#3*'-!7*!'*#!&:B#3DBC!#+%!0*'#)$730#3*'-R!+$)&R!*)!73-):D#3*'!%QD%)3%'0%7!AC!#+%!03#3e%'-!6+*!&:-#!$7T:-#!#*!#+%!3&D$0#!*(!$BB!#+)%%!B%M%B-!*(!<*M%)'&%'#!3'!#+%3)!B3M%-4!,+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!'%%7-!#*!A%!&*)%!0*<'3e$'#!*(!#+%!%((%0#-!3#-!$0#3*'-!+$M%!*'!#+%!(3-0$B!0*'73#3*'!*(!#+%!-#$#%-!$'7!B*0$B3#3%-4!!!!!

K)*T%0#3*'-!*(!#+%!9&D$0#!*'!"#$#%!$'7!d*0$B!/3'$'0%-!$'7!"%)M30%-!*(!/%7%)$B!?0#3*'-!$'7!K*B303%-!K)*T%0#3*'-!*(!#+%!9&D$0#!*'!"#$#%!$'7!d*0$B!/3'$'0%-!$'7!"%)M30%-!*(!/%7%)$B!?0#3*'-!$'7!K*B303%-!K)*T%0#3*'-!*(!#+%!9&D$0#!*'!"#$#%!$'7!d*0$B!/3'$'0%-!$'7!"%)M30%-!*(!/%7%)$B!?0#3*'-!$'7!K*B303%-!K)*T%0#3*'-!*(!#+%!9&D$0#!*'!"#$#%!$'7!d*0$B!/3'$'0%-!$'7!"%)M30%-!*(!/%7%)$B!?0#3*'-!$'7!K*B303%-!""""+*:B7!A%!F%b:3)%74!+*:B7!A%!F%b:3)%74!+*:B7!A%!F%b:3)%74!+*:B7!A%!F%b:3)%74!,+%!,$-.!/*)0%_-!$'$BC-3-!(*:'7!#+$#!'*!&%0+$'3-&!'*6!%Q3-#-!(*)!7%#%)&3'3'<R!$--%--3'<R!$'7!0*&&:'30$#3'<!#+%!(3-0$B!3&D$0#!*(!(%7%)$B!$0#3*'-!*'!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-4!!!!

?7%b:$#%!H3-0B*-:)%!*(!,%)&-R!1*'73#3*'-?7%b:$#%!H3-0B*-:)%!*(!,%)&-R!1*'73#3*'-?7%b:$#%!H3-0B*-:)%!*(!,%)&-R!1*'73#3*'-?7%b:$#%!H3-0B*-:)%!*(!,%)&-R!1*'73#3*'-RRRR!!!!$'7!F3-.-!*(!G:'303D$B!/3'$'0%-$'7!F3-.-!*(!G:'303D$B!/3'$'0%-$'7!F3-.-!*(!G:'303D$B!/3'$'0%-$'7!F3-.-!*(!G:'303D$B!/3'$'0%-4!4!4!4!,+%!0:))%'#!T:)3-730#3*'!*(!#+%!J4"4!"%0:)3#C!1*&&3--3*'!\"N1]!63#+!)%-D%0#!#*!&:'303D$B!(3'$'0%!3--:%)-!3-!'$))*6BC!B3&3#%7!#*!()$:7!7:%!#*!#+%!-*20$BB%7!S,*6%)!?&%'7&%'#RU!$'7!'*!*#+%)!A*7C!+$-!#+%!$((3)&$#3M%!*AB3<$#3*'!*)!$:#+*)3#C!#*!)%b:3)%!(:BB!#)$'-D$)%'0C!$'7!73-0B*-:)%!*(!)3-.4!,+%!,*6%)!?&%'7&%'#!-+*:B7!A%!)%M3-3#%7!-*!#+$#!#+%!"N1!0$'!)%b:3)%!3--:%)-!#*!0*&DBC!63#+!-%'-3AB%!73-0B*-:)%!)%b:3)%&%'#-!$-!6%BB!$-!63#+!)*A:-#!$00*:'#3'<!-#$'7$)7-4!

,+%!)%0*&&%'7$#3*'-!$A*M%!$'7!#+%!0*&&%'#$)C!3'0B:7%7!3'!#+3-!/3'$B!F%D*)#!*(!#+%!"#$#%!E:7<%#!1)3-3-!,$-.!/*)0%!$)%!#+%!)%-:B#!*(!#+)%%!C%$)-!*(!)%-%$)0+R!$'$BC-3-R!$'7!7%A$#%4!,+%!,$-.!/*)0%!?7M3-*)C!E*$)7!+$-!%'7*)-%7!#+%-%!)%0*&&%'7$#3*'-!$'7!+*D%-!#+$#!#+%!+3<+BC!)%<$)7%7!D$)#303D$'#-!3'!%$0+!*(!*:)!X$#3*'$B!H3$B*<:%-!63BB!+%BD!#*!73--%&3'$#%!$'7!D)*&*#%!#+%&!3'!#+%3)!7$C2#*27$C!0*'#$0#!63#+!D*B30C&$.%)-!3'!#+%3)!)%-D%0#3M%!(3%B7-!*(!$7M*0$0C!$'7!%QD%)#3-%4!!

X$#3*'$B!3'$##%'#3*'!#*!#+%!(3'$'03$B!D)%--:)%!A%$)3'<!7*6'!*'!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#!0$'!'*!B*'<%)!A%!#*B%)$#%74!W+$#!3-!$#!-#$.%!3-!#+%!-#)%'<#+!*(!*:)!%7:0$#3*'$B!3'-#3#:#3*'-R!*(!*:)!3'()$-#):0#:)%!$'7!D:AB30!-C-#%&-R!*(!*:)!+%$B#+!0$)%!$'7!

Page 6: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

P!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&!/3'$B!F%D*)#!

T:7303$B!-C-#%&-R!$'7!*(!#+%!-$(%#C!$'7!-%0:)3#C!*(!#+%!?&%)30$'!-*03%#C4!W+$#!3-!)%b:3)%7!3-!)%0*<'3#3*'!*(!#+%!0*BB%0#3M%!)%-D*'-3A3B3#C!*(!*:)!(%7%)$B!$'7!-#$#%!<*M%)'&%'#-!(*)!$0#3*'4!!

9#!3-R!$(#%)!$BBR!*:)!0+3B7)%'!$'7!<)$'70+3B7)%'!6+*!63BB!D$C!#+%!D)30%!*(!($3B:)%R!$'7!6+*!63BB!+$M%!#*!0*D%!63#+!#+%!73&3'3-+%7!-#)%'<#+!$'7!0*&D%#3#3M%'%--!*(!#+%!?&%)30$'!)%D:AB304!!

"3'0%)%BCR!

!

!

F30+$)7!F$M3#0+!!! ! ! ! K$:B![*B0.%)!1*21+$3)!! ! ! ! ! 1*21+$3)!

! &

Page 7: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&&&&/3'$B!F%D*)#!

8

8'/%<'/4&/*)&%)!X%6!Z*).!d3%:#%'$'#!f*M%)'*)!F30+$)7!F$M3#0+!$'7!(*)&%)!/%7%)$B!F%-%)M%!E*$)7!1+$3)!K$:B!?4![*B0.%)!0)%$#%7!#+%!"#$#%!E:7<%#!1)3-3-!,$-.!/*)0%!A%0$:-%!*(!#+%3)!<)*63'<!0*'0%)'!$A*:#!#+%! B*'<2#%)&!(3-0$B!-:-#$3'$A3B3#C!*(!#+%!-#$#%-!$'7!#+%!D%)-3-#%'#!-#):0#:)$B!3&A$B$'0%!3'!-#$#%!A:7<%#-R!6+30+!6$-!$00%B%)$#%7!AC!#+%!(3'$'03$B!0*BB$D-%!*(!@>>;4!

?(#%)!%Q#%'-3M%!DB$''3'<!$'7!(:'7)$3-3'<!3'!@>=>!$'7!%$)BC!@>==R!G%--)-4!F$M3#0+!$'7![*B0.%)!6%)%!T*3'%7!AC $!A*$)7!*(!3'73M37:$B-!63#+!%Q#%'-3M%!$'7!M$)3%7!0$)%%)-!3'!D:AB30!-%)M30%!$'7!D:AB30!D*B30C4!,+%!,$-.!/*)0%!6$-!*((303$BBC!B$:'0+%7!3'!?D)3B!@>==4!

9'!$773#3*'!#*!#+%!0*20+$3)-R!#+%!A*$)7!*(!#+%!"#$#%!E:7<%#!1)3-3-!,$-.!/*)0%!3'0B:7%-!#+%-%!&%&A%)-V!

!"#$%&'()*+),-'./) 0%(12$)3+)4'&"5'6%7)0-+)8$"&&"2)9+)4&'/) :';".)4-'61)81<1-)=%&.>'-?) @"#$'-.)8+)!'<$'6)3&"#1)A+)@";&"6) A'-#)B+)C$'D)=1%-E1)8+)C$F&<G)

?!0*)%!#%$&!*(!%QD%)#-!63#+!A:7<%#!$'7!(3'$'03$B!DB$''3'<!%QD%)3%'0%!$#!#+%!'$#3*'$BR!-#$#%R!$'7!B*0$B!B%M%B-!$'7!D)$0#30$B!%QD%)3%'0%!7%)3M%7!()*&!#+%!&$'$<%&%'#!*(!D)%M3*:-!(3-0$B!0)3-%-!D:AB3-+%7!#+%!F%D*)#!*(!,+%!"#$#%!E:7<%#!1)3-3-!,$-.!/*)0%!3'!Y:BC!@>=@4!!"3'0%!3#!6$-!'*#!(%$-3AB%!#*!-#:7C!%$0+!*(!#+%!(3(#C!-#$#%-!3'!7%D#+R!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!#$)<%#%7!-3Q!-#$#%-!a!1$B3(*)'3$R!9BB3'*3-R!X%6!Y%)-%CR!X%6!Z*).R!,%Q$-R!$'7![3)<3'3$!a!(*)!3'27%D#+R!*'2-3#%!$'$BC-3-4!9'!%$0+!-#$#%R!#+%!0*)%!#%$&!6*).%7!0B*-%BC!63#+!%QD%)#-!6+*!6%)%!7%%DBC!($&3B3$)!63#+!#+%!-:A-#$'0%R!-#):0#:)%R!D)*0%7:)%-R!7*0:&%'#-R!$'7!D*B3#30-!*(!#+%!-#$#%_-!A:7<%#4!!

,+%!,$-.!/*)0%!F%D*)#!7)%6!'$#3*'$B!$##%'#3*'!#*!#+%!%)*73'<!(3-0$B!0*'73#3*'!*(!-#$#%-4!,+%!F%D*)#!D:#!$!-D*#B3<+#!*'!-%M%)$B!.%C!7)3M%)-!0*&D)*&3-3'<!-#$#%-_!(3-0$B!-#$A3B3#CV!

! G%730$37!"D%'73'<!f)*6#+!9-!1)*673'<!`:#!`#+%)!X%%7-^!! /%7%)$B!H%(303#!F%7:0#3*'!,+)%$#%'-!"#$#%!N0*'*&3%-!$'7!E:7<%#-^!! J'7%)(:'7%7!F%#3)%&%'#!K)*&3-%-!1)%$#%!F3-.-!(*)!/:#:)%!E:7<%#-^!! X$))*6R!N)*73'<!,$Q!E$-%-!$'7![*B$#3B%!,$Q!F%M%':%-!J'7%)&3'%!"#$#%!/3'$'0%-^!! d*0$B!f*M%)'&%'#!/3-0$B!"#)%--!K*-%-!1+$BB%'<%-!(*)!"#$#%-^!! "#$#%!E:7<%#!d$6-!$'7!K)$0#30%-!c3'7%)!/3-0$B!"#$A3B3#C!$'7!G$-.!9&A$B$'0%-4!

,*!$77)%--!#+%!7%0B3'3'<!(3-0$B!0*'73#3*'!*(!-#$#%-R!3'!@>=5!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!+*-#%7!(*:)!X$#3*'$B!H3$B*<:%-!(*0:-3'<!*'!#+%!&*-#!:)<%'#!$)%$-!*(!0*'0%)'R!3'0B:73'<V!9'()$-#):0#:)%R!J'7%)(:'7%7!F%#3)%&%'#!K)*&3-%-R!G%730$37R!$'7!G$'$<3'<!#+%!9&D$0#!*(!/%7%)$B!H%(303#!F%7:0#3*'4!H:)3'<!%$0+!7$CB*'<!H3$B*<:%R!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!<$#+%)%7!%QD%)#-!#*!73-0:--!*D#3*'-!(*)!'%6!*)<$'3e$#3*'$B!-#):0#:)%-R!0*'-:B#$#3M%!D)*0%--%-R!*)!B%<3-B$#3M%!&%0+$'3-&-!#+$#!0$'!D)*&*#%!$!0**D%)$#3M%!$DD)*$0+!A%#6%%'!#+%!(%7%)$B!$'7!-#$#%!<*M%)'&%'#-!#*!-*BM3'<!#+%-%!0+$BB%'<%-4!,+%!3'D:#!*(!D$)#303D$'#-!*(!%$0+!X$#3*'$B!H3$B*<:%!3'(*)&%7!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!)%0*&&%'7$#3*'-!*:#B3'%7!3'!#+3-!(3'$B!)%D*)#4!

,+%!'$&%-!*(!#+%!(:BB!D)*T%0#!#%$&!0$'!A%!(*:'7!*'!#+%!?0.'*6B%7<&%'#-!D$<%!$#!#+%!%'7!*(!#+3-!)%D*)#4!!

!

Page 8: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

;!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&!/3'$B!F%D*)#!

=*+/'439+6'*&!9'!#+%!Y:BC!@>=@!F%D*)#!*(!"#$#%!E:7<%#!1)3-3-!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!\,$-.!/*)0%!F%D*)#]R!,$-.!/*)0%!1*21+$3)-!K$:B![*B0.%)!$'7!F30+$)7!F$M3#0+!-$37V!

!"#$%&'%()*+&'$&,$-"#$!.*/$0&1%#$+*$)'.23+4)&)*5$!"#$#6+*-+'4$-1.7#%-&18$&,$*-.-#$*9#':+'4;$-.6.-+&'$.':$.:2+'+*-1.-+<#$91.%-+%#$%.''&-$3#$*)*-.+'#:5$!"#$3.*+%$91&3(#2$+*$'&-$%8%(+%.(5$=-$+*$*-1)%-)1.(5$

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

?!#+%&%!*(!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!F%D*)#!$'7!#+%!3'73M37:$B!"#$#%!F%D*)#-!3-!#+$#!(3-0$B!-#)%--!):'-!7*6'+3BB!$'7!#+$#!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-!$)%!#+%!0*BB%0#3'<!D*3'#4!,+3-!$7M%)-%BC!$((%0#-!#+%!7%B3M%)C!*(!D:AB30!-%)M30%-!$'7!&$.%-!3'M%-#&%'#!&*-#!73((30:B#!$#!#+%!D*3'#!6+%)%!3#!3-!'%%7%7!&*-#4!,+%!@>=5!1+$D#%)!g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

"3'0%!#+%!Y:BC!@>=@!,$-.!/*)0%!F%D*)#!$'7!#+%!3--:$'0%!*(!-3Q!"#$#%!F%D*)#-R@!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!+$-!(*0:-%7!*'!(3M%!-:AT%0#!$)%$-V!

! ?00*:'#$A3B3#C!$'7!,)$'-D$)%'0C!3'!E:7<%#3'<!$'7!/3'$'03$B!F%D*)#3'<^!! J'7%)(:'7%7!F%#3)%&%'#!K)*&3-%-^!! ,)$'-D*)#$#3*'!9'M%-#&%'#^!! ,+%!"#$#%O/%7%)$B!G%730$37!K$)#'%)-+3D^!$'7!! ,+%!9&D$0#!*(!/%7%)$B!H%(303#!F%7:0#3*'4!

,+%!,$-.!/*)0%!0*'M%'%7!(*:)!X$#3*'$B!H3$B*<:%-!*'!#+%!#*D30-!$A*M%4!,+%-%!H3$B*<:%-!0)%$#%7!M$B:$AB%!(*):&-!#+$#!3'(*)&%7!#+3-!(3'$B!)%D*)#!$'7!-D:))%7!0*'#3':3'<!73-0:--3*'!$&*'<!#+%!D$)#303D$#3'<!D$)#3%-45!,+3-!)%D*)#!-:&&$)3e%-!#+%!

Page 9: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&&&&/3'$B!F%D*)#!

g

6+3#%!D$D%)-!D)%D$)%7!(*)R!$'7!#+%!3'-3<+#-!7)$6'!()*&R!#+%!X$#3*'$B!H3$B*<:%-4!W+%)%!$DD)*D)3$#%R!)%0*&&%'7$#3*'-!$)%!&$7%4

Page 10: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

=>!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&!/3'$B!F%D*)#!

86*46*5,&,+%!*AT%0#3M%!*(!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!3-!#*!3'(*)&!#+%!D:AB30!*(!#+%!0+$)$0#%)!$'7!<)$M3#C!*(!#+%!(3-0$B!3--:%-!0*'()*'#3'<!#+%!-#$#%-!$'7!#+%!0*'-%b:%'0%-!*(!7%(%))3'<!0*))%0#3M%!$0#3*'-4!,+3-!/3'$B!F%D*)#!*(!#+%!"#$#%!E:7<%#!1)3-3-!,$-.!/*)0%!0:B&3'$#%-!#+)%%!C%$)-!*(!)%-%$)0+R!$'$BC-3-R!$'7!7%A$#%4!,+%!,$-.!/*)0%!%'0*:)$<%-!<*M%)'&%'#-!$#!$BB!B%M%B-!#*!0*'-37%)!3#-!D)*0%--!)%0*&&%'7$#3*'-!$'7!3&DB%&%'#!D*B303%-!$'7!D)*<)$&-!#+$#!63BB!B%$7!#*!B*'<2#%)&!-#):0#:)$B!$7T:-#&%'#-4!?!-:&&$)C!*(!#+%!(3'73'<-!3-!D)%-%'#%7!A%B*64!

89356%&5"(,#89356%&5"(,#89356%&5"(,#89356%&5"(,#::::/+#/+#/+#/+#11115,5(6#5,5(6#5,5(6#5,5(6#....%,&+/#%,&+/#%,&+/#%,&+/#!!!!$%(#$%(#$%(#$%(#;;;;&%&+,<#&%&+,<#&%&+,<#&%&+,<#::::9535&=#&"#9535&=#&"#9535&=#&"#9535&=#&"#>>>>++&#++&#++&#++&#!!!!$+2$+2$+2$+2####,+%!F*0.%(%BB%)!9'-#3#:#%!?D)3B!@>=5!>-.-#$?#<#')#$?#9&1-!-#$#%-V$

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email protected]%"@&1:5I$!

!$+#15,5(6#?",&,#"@#A(@B()+)#C+(,5"(,#?"(&5(B+#&"#C/+,,B/+#;&%&+#DB)6+&,#%()#D%3%(0+#;$++&,!$+#15,5(6#?",&,#"@#A(@B()+)#C+(,5"(,#?"(&5(B+#&"#C/+,,B/+#;&%&+#DB)6+&,#%()#D%3%(0+#;$++&,!$+#15,5(6#?",&,#"@#A(@B()+)#C+(,5"(,#?"(&5(B+#&"#C/+,,B/+#;&%&+#DB)6+&,#%()#D%3%(0+#;$++&,!$+#15,5(6#?",&,#"@#A(@B()+)#C+(,5"(,#?"(&5(B+#&"#C/+,,B/+#;&%&+#DB)6+&,#%()#D%3%(0+#;$++&,####"3'0%!@>>;R!(*)#C2#+)%%!-#$#%-!+$M%!%'$0#%7!D%'-3*'!)%(*)&-R!$)%!$##%&D#3'<!)%(*)&-R!*)!$)%!0*'#%&DB$#3'<!#+%&4!G*-#!)%(*)&-!+$M%!A%%'!3'!)%-D%0#!#*!'%6!+3)%-!$'7!+$M%!+$7!&3'3&$B!%((%0#!*'!:'(:'7%7!B3$A3B3#3%-4L!9'!&$'C!-#$#%-!#+%)%!+$-!A%%'!-#)*'<!D*B3#30$B!)%-3-#$'0%!#*!)%(*)&4!K%''-CBM$'3$R!(*)!%Q$&DB%R!+$-!'*#!A%%'!$AB%!#*!$0+3%M%!B%<3-B$#3M%!0+$'<%!$'7!($0%-!-%M%)%!D%'-3*'!:'7%)(:'73'<!0*'-%b:%'0%-4!9BB3'*3-_!)%(*)&-!&$C!A%!#**!B3##B%R!#**!B$#%4!,+%!0*-#-!*(!D%'-3*'-!$'7!*#+%)!D*-#%&DB*C&%'#!A%'%(3#-!<%'%)$BBC!$)%!<)*63'<!($-#%)!#+$'!)%M%':%-!$'7!0*'#3':%!#*!0)*67!*:#!*#+%)!'%0%--$)C!A:7<%#!3#%&-4!c%$B#+!0$)%R!%7:0$#3*'R!$'7!3'()$-#):0#:)%!(:'73'<!$)%!M30#3&3e%7R!$-!3-!$37!#*!#+%!M:B'%)$AB%4!9'!@>=@R!-#$#%!(:'73'<!(*)!D)%2h!D)*<)$&-!%QD%)3%'0%7!3#-!B$)<%-#!*'%!C%$)!7)*D!%M%)R!#*!6%BB!A%B*6!#+%!3'(B$#3*'!$7T:-#%7!$M%)$<%!*(!@>>@^!#+%!'$#3*'_-!C*:'<%-#!B%$)'%)-!$)%!A%$)3'<!$!73-D)*D*)#3*'$#%!-+$)%!*(!A:7<%#!0:#-4!

!$+#'@@+0&#"(#&$+#;&%&+,#"@#.+)+/%3#E+@505&#1+)B0&5"(#5,#A(-("4(#%()#8@&+(#A(0"(,5)+/+)!$+#'@@+0&#"(#&$+#;&%&+,#"@#.+)+/%3#E+@505&#1+)B0&5"(#5,#A(-("4(#%()#8@&+(#A(0"(,5)+/+)!$+#'@@+0&#"(#&$+#;&%&+,#"@#.+)+/%3#E+@505&#1+)B0&5"(#5,#A(-("4(#%()#8@&+(#A(0"(,5)+/+)!$+#'@@+0&#"(#&$+#;&%&+,#"@#.+)+/%3#E+@505&#1+)B0&5"(#5,#A(-("4(#%()#8@&+(#A(0"(,5)+/+)####/%7%)$B!7%(303#!)%7:0#3*'!D)%-%'#-!'%6!73((30:B#3%-!(*)!#+%!-#$#%-4!"#$#%-!$B)%$7C!+$M%!(%B#!#+%!3&D$0#!*(!-%b:%-#)$#3*'4!G*)%!#+$'!iL!A3BB3*'!*(!0:#-!3'!@>=5!7:%!#*!-%b:%-#)$#3*'!+$M%!A%%'!B%M3%7!$<$3'-#!-#$#%-4!H3-0)%#3*'$)C!D)*<)$&-!6%)%!+$)7%-#!+3#R!6+3B%!-*&%!&$'7$#*)C!D)*<)$&-!B3.%!G%730$37!6%)%!B$)<%BC!%Q%&D#4!1:#-!#*!":DDB%&%'#$B!X:#)3#3*'!?--3-#$'0%!

Page 11: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&&&&/3'$B!F%D*)#!

==

D)*<)$&-R!d*6!9'0*&%!c%$#3'<!?--3-#$'0%R!"D%03$B!N7:0$#3*'R!c%$7-#$)#R!G%$B-!*'!W+%%B-R!K:AB30!c%$B#+!(:'73'<!#+)*:<+!#+%!G%'#$B!c%$B#+!EB*0.!f)$'#!K)*<)$&R!$'7!J4"4!N'M3)*'&%'#$B!K)*#%0#3*'!?<%'0C!\NK?]!<)$'#-!$BB!73)%0#BC!3&D$0#!-#$#%-4!

?-!1*'<)%--!0*'-37%)-!'%6!-D%'73'<!DB$'-R!3#!3-!:'0B%$)!3(!-%b:%-#)$#3*'!63BB!0*'#3':%!*)!A%!)%DB$0%7!AC!'%6!0:#-4!"#$#%-!0$''*#!$'#303D$#%!A:7<%#$)C!)%B3%(!()*&!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!$'7!$)%!+*D3'<!#+$#!1*'<)%--!63BB!'*#!3&D*-%!3'0)%$-%7!(%7%)$B!0:#-R!(:)#+%)!3&D$0#3'<!0):03$B!-%)M30%-4!,+%)%!3-!B3##B%!0*'-37%)$#3*'!*(!#+%!3&D$0#!*'!-#$#%-!AC!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!$-!3#!0)%$#%-!3#-!*6'!(3-0$B!DB$'-!3'!$!M%)C!0*'#%'#3*:-!%'M3)*'&%'#4!

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e$#3*'-!$'7!3'-#3#:#3*'-!#+$#!$##%&D#!#*!b:$'#3(C!-D%'73'<!'%%7-R!?&%)30$!3-!3'M%-#3'<!3'$7%b:$#%BC!3'!*:)!D:AB30!3'()$-#):0#:)%4!?!)%0%'#!1%'#%)!(*)!?&%)30$'!K)*<)%--!)%D*)#!*'!?&%)30$_-!3'()$-#):0#:)%!(:'73'<!<$D!%-#3&$#%7!#+$#!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!3-!:'7%)3'M%-#3'<!3'!3'()$-#):0#:)%!AC!$DD)*Q3&$#%BC!iI;!A3BB3*'!D%)!C%$)R!$--:&3'<!$!<*$B!*(!$7%b:$#%BC!&$3'#$3'3'<!%Q3-#3'<!3'()$-#):0#:)%!$'7!D)%D$)3'<!(*)!D)*T%0#%7!%0*'*&30!$'7!D*D:B$#3*'!<)*6#+4P!,+%)%!$)%!+:'7)%7-!*(!#+*:-$'7-!*(!+3<+6$C!&3B%-!$'7!#%'-!*(!#+*:-$'7-!*(!A)37<%-!$0)*--!?&%)30$!#+$#!+$M%!A%%'!0B$--3(3%7!$-!7%(303%'#R!$'7!0*'#3':%!#*!7%#%)3*)$#%!3'!-D3#%!*(!%M37%'0%!#+$#!#+%!D)*AB%&!3'0)%$-%-!7)$&$#30$BBC!$-!0)3#30$B!3'M%-#&%'#!3-!7%B$C%74!!

!$+#:@@"/)%93+#?%/+#:0&<,#F2H%0&#5,#A(0+/&%5(!$+#:@@"/)%93+#?%/+#:0&<,#F2H%0&#5,#A(0+/&%5(!$+#:@@"/)%93+#?%/+#:0&<,#F2H%0&#5,#A(0+/&%5(!$+#:@@"/)%93+#?%/+#:0&<,#F2H%0&#5,#A(0+/&%5(####"#$#%-!$)%!#)C3'<!#*!7%#%)&3'%!#+%!3&D$0#!*(!#+%!?((*)7$AB%!1$)%!?0#!$'7!6+%#+%)!#*!D$)#303D$#%!3'!3#-!G%730$37!%QD$'-3*'$)C!D)*M3-3*'-4!?-!*(!`0#*A%)!@>=5R!$00*)73'<!#*!#+%!h$3-%)!/$&3BC!/*:'7$#3*'R!#6%'#C2#6*!-#$#%-!+$M%!*D#%7!*:#!*(!#+%!?0#_-!G%730$37!%QD$'-3*'4!,+%!?0#!)%&$3'-!:'7%)!$--$:B#!AC!F%D:AB30$'-!$'7!3#-!0B:&-C!3'3#3$B!3&DB%&%'#$#3*'!+$-!0)%$#%7!'%6!-.%D#303-&4!

,+%!0%)#$3'#C!*(!)3-3'<!)%#3)%&%'#!0*-#-R!0*:DB%7!63#+!#+%!:'0%)#$3'#C!$--*03$#%7!63#+!)%M%':%!#)%'7-R!(%7%)$B!A:7<%#!$0#3*'-R!#)$'-D*)#$#3*'!(:'73'<!$'7!#+%!3&DB%&%'#$#3*'!*(!#+%!?((*)7$AB%!1$)%!?0#R!$BB!&$.%!#+%!0)%$#3*'!*(!#):BC!A$B$'0%7!-#$#%!A:7<%#-!$!73((30:B#!#$-.4!?-!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!F%D*)#!%&D+$-3e%7R!(*)#C2'3'%!-#$#%-!+$M%!$!A$B$'0%7!A:7<%#!)%b:3)%&%'#!%3#+%)!AC!0*'-#3#:#3*'!*)!-#$#:#%R!A:#!#+%C!7*!'*#!7%(3'%!)%M%':%!a!$'7!#+:-!&$'C!-#$#%-!:-%!#+%!D)*0%%7-!*(!A*))*63'<!$'7!$--%#!-$B%-!$-!)%M%':%-!(*)!A:7<%#3'<!D:)D*-%-R!D$)#30:B$)BC!3'!0+$BB%'<3'<!#3&%-4!,+3-!3-!$!D)$0#30%!#+$#!$00*&DB3-+%-!B3##B%!3'!#+%!-+*)#!#%)&!$'7!*((%)-!*'BC!3'0)%$-%7!D$3'!$'7!+$M*0!3'!#+%!B*'<!):'4!! !

Page 12: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

=@!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&!/3'$B!F%D*)#!

8'93,&>/%",&!!!!"##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!*&!3%-42'*&4!(&-!5*&(&#*(+!"##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!*&!3%-42'*&4!(&-!5*&(&#*(+!"##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!*&!3%-42'*&4!(&-!5*&(&#*(+!"##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!*&!3%-42'*&4!(&-!5*&(&#*(+!621$/'*&4621$/'*&4621$/'*&4621$/'*&4!!!!

K:AB30!#):-#!3'!<*M%)'&%'#!3-!$#!*)!'%$)!$BB2#3&%!B*6-4!?00*)73'<!#*!#+%!K%6!F%-%$)0+!1%'#%)R!I5!D%)0%'#!*(!#+%!D:AB30!73-#):-#-!#+%3)!-#$#%!<*M%)'&%'#4!c*'%-#R!)%B3$AB%!A:7<%#!%-#3&$#%-!$'7!0B%$)R!$00%--3AB%!7$#$!*'!(3'$'03$B!$'7!D)*<)$&&$#30!)%-:B#-!&3<+#!3'0)%$-%!#):-#R!6+30+!3-!'%0%--$)C!#*!A:3B7!-:DD*)#!(*)!-#):0#:)$B!)%(*)&-4!Nb:$BBC!-3<'3(30$'#R!0B%$)!7$#$!$)%!%--%'#3$B!(*)!-*BM3'<!$'7!D)%M%'#3'<!(3'$'03$B!D)*AB%&-4!!

,+%!(3'$'03$B!0)3-3-R!6+30+!A%<$'!3'!@>>;R!$'7!#+%!$##%'#3*'!3#!-D$6'%7R!737!'*#!0)%$#%!#+%!-#):0#:)$B!A:7<%#!D)*AB%&-!*(!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-4!F$#+%)R!3#!)%M%$B%7!#+%&4!,+3-!-:<<%-#-!#+$#!+$7!<*M%)'&%'#R!#+%!&%73$R!#$QD$C%)-R!$'7!#+%!%B%0#*)$#%!A%%'!$6$)%!*(!#+%!D**)!(3-0$B!0*'73#3*'!*(!-#$#%!<*M%)'&%'#-!$'7!#+%!:'7%)BC3'<!#)%'7-!$'7!0$:-%-!*(!#+*-%!0*'73#3*'-R!#+%C!&$C!+$M%!A%%'!$AB%!#*!3&DB%&%'#!D)%M%'#3M%!$'7!$&%B3*)$#3M%!-#%D-4!!

?#!#+%3)!+%$)#R!#+%!%0*'*&30!%M%'#-!A%<3''3'<!3'!@>>;!<%'%)$#%7!$!-%M%)%!)%M%':%!0)3-3-4!d$0.!*(!#)$'-D$)%'0C!$'7!$00*:'#$A3B3#C!0*'-#3#:#%-!A$7!(3'$'03$BR!<*M%)'&%'#R!$'7!D*B3#30$B!D)$0#30%4!"%B(27%0%D#3*'R!%3#+%)!7%B3A%)$#%!*)!:'63##3'<R!0$:-%-!3'$0#3*'!$'7!3<'*)$'0%4!,+:-R!'*#!*'BC!3-!#)$'-D$)%'0C!3'!A:7<%#$)C!$'7!(3-0$B!)%D*)#3'<!7%-3)$AB%R!#+%!$A-%'0%!*(!3#!0$'!A%!$!&$T*)!0$:-%!*(!<*M%)'&%'#!(3-0$B!D)*AB%&-4!!

,6*!-D%03(30-!3BB:-#)$#%!+*6!#+%!B$0.!*(!#)$'-D$)%'0C!0$'!0*'#)3A:#%!#*!(3-0$B!D)*AB%&-V!

9'!)%-D%0#!*(!D%'-3*'-R!$0#:$)3%-!+$M%!0$B0:B$#%7!$!<*M%)'&%'#_-!$'':$B!)%b:3)%7!0*'#)3A:#3*'!#*!#+%!<*M%)'&%'#_-!D%'-3*'!(:'7-4!J-:$BBCR!#+%-%!0$B0:B$#3*'-!$)%!'*#!&$7%!D:AB30!0*'#%&D*)$'%*:-!63#+!#+%!0$B0:B$#3*'4!,+%C!-+*:B7!A%4!`#+%)63-%R!3#!3-!#**!%$-C!(*)!#+%!NQ%0:#3M%!$'7!#+%!B%<3-B$#:)%!#*!3<'*)%!#+%!0$B0:B$#3*'!$'7!:'7%)(:'7!#+%!D%'-3*'!-C-#%&-4!

?:73#%7!(3'$'03$B!-#$#%&%'#-!*(!<*M%)'&%'#-!<%'%)$BBC!$)%!-B*6!#*!A%!D)%D$)%7R!*M%)BC!0*&DB%QR!$'7!$)%!D:AB3-+%7!#**!B$#%!#*!A%!$-!&%$'3'<(:B!$-!#+%C!0*:B7!A%4!f*M%)'&%'#-!-+*:B7!%-#$AB3-+!-#$#:#*)C!D)*M3-3*'-!#+$#!)%b:3)%!#+%!#3&%BC!D:AB30$#3*'!*(!0B%$)R!)%$7$AB%R!$:73#%7!(3'$'03$B!-#$#%&%'#-!-*!#+$#!(3-0$B!7%03-3*'&$.3'<!0$'!A%!A%##%)!3'(*)&%74!

"##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!62#$772&-('*$&0"##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!62#$772&-('*$&0"##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!62#$772&-('*$&0"##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!62#$772&-('*$&0$$$$

!$+#!%,-#."/0+#!$+#!%,-#."/0+#!$+#!%,-#."/0+#!$+#!%,-#."/0+#1111+0"22+(),#&$+#+0"22+(),#&$+#+0"22+(),#&$+#+0"22+(),#&$+#...."33"45(67"33"45(67"33"45(67"33"45(67!!!!####G*73(3%7!?00):$B!E:7<%#3'<!AC!"#$#%-!$'7!d*0$B3#3%-4!G*73(3%7!?00):$B!E:7<%#3'<!AC!"#$#%-!$'7!d*0$B3#3%-4!G*73(3%7!?00):$B!E:7<%#3'<!AC!"#$#%-!$'7!d*0$B3#3%-4!G*73(3%7!?00):$B!E:7<%#3'<!AC!"#$#%-!$'7!d*0$B3#3%-4!,+%!D)$0#30%!*(!0$-+2A$-%7!A:7<%#3'<!($03B3#$#%-!<3&&30.-!$'7!-+*)#2#%)&!&%$-:)%-!#+$#!*A-0:)%!$0#:$B!(3'$'03$B!0*'73#3*'-4!W+%)%!$DD)*D)3$#%R!:-3'<!0*'-3-#%'#R!&*73(3%7!$00):$B2A$-%7!A:7<%#3'<!6*:B7!($03B3#$#%!0*&D$)3-*'!$'7!$M*37!A:7<%#-!A$-%7!*'!3'$00:)$#%!)%D)%-%'#$#3*'-!*(!(:#:)%!*AB3<$#3*'-!*)!)%M%':%-4!!!!!

G:B#3G:B#3G:B#3G:B#3CCCC%$)!%$)!%$)!%$)!/3'$'03$B!KB$'-4!/3'$'03$B!KB$'-4!/3'$'03$B!KB$'-4!/3'$'03$B!KB$'-4!"#$#%-!-+*:B7!3'0B:7%!&%$'3'<(:BR!(*)6$)72B**.3'<!(3'$'03$B!DB$'-!$-!D$)#!*(!#+%3)!$'':$B!A:7<%#!-:A&3--3*'!$'7!$7*D#3*'!D)*0%--!$'7!)%b:3)%!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-!3'!#+%3)!T:)3-730#3*'-!#*!7*!#+%!-$&%4!?!0*&D)%+%'-3M%!$'':$B!A:7<%#!D)%-%'#%7!AC!#+%!<*M%)'*)!$'7!)%M3%6%7!$'7!$DD)*M%7!AC!#+%!B%<3-B$#:)%!-+*:B7!-%)M%!$-!#+%!(3)-#!C%$)!*(!#+%!(*)6$)72B**.3'<!&:B#3C%$)!DB$'4!,+%-%!DB$'-!-+*:B7!%'0*&D$--!A*#+!*D%)$#3'<!$'7!0$D3#$B!%QD%'73#:)%-!$'7!-+*:B7!-%#!*:#!

Page 13: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&&&&/3'$B!F%D*)#!

=5

#+%!A$-30!$--:&D#3*'-!)%<$)73'<!)%M%':%!$'7!%QD%'73#:)%-R!-+*63'<!0B%$)BC!6+%'!(:#:)%!0*-#-!*(!D)*&3-%-R!-:0+!$-!7%A#!-%)M30%!$'7!B%$-3'<!A$BB**'!D$C&%'#-R!$)%!7:%4!,+%!0$D3#$B!DB$'!-+*:B7!$B-*!3'730$#%!#+%!-*:)0%!*(!(3'$'03'<!#*!A%!:-%7!(*)!D)*T%0#-4!!

F%-%)M%!/:'7-4!F%-%)M%!/:'7-4!F%-%)M%!/:'7-4!F%-%)M%!/:'7-4!F%-%)M%!(:'7-R!*(#%'!0$BB%7!)$3'C!7$C!(:'7-R!-+*:B7!A%!)%b:3)%7!$'7!-+*:B7!A%!$7%b:$#%!#*!&%%#!$'C!)%$-*'$ABC!$'#303D$#%7!%M%'#:$B3#C4!9#!3-!+%$)#%'3'<!#*!-%%!#+$#!&$'C!-#$#%-!+$M%!A%<:'R!3'!-&$BB!-#%D-R!#*!)%DB%'3-+!#+%-%!(:'7-4!!!!

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e%7!#+$#R!A%0$:-%!*(!-:77%'!)%M%':%!-+*)#($BB-R!0$-+!A$B$'0%-!$#!#3&%-!&$C!'%%7!#*!A%!A*B-#%)%7!63#+!#+%!D)*0%%7-!*(!-+*)#!#%)&!A*))*63'<R!#+$#!A*))*63'<!-+*:B7!'%M%)!A%!#)%$#%7!$-!$'!%B%&%'#!*(!)%M%':%R!$'7!D)*M3-3*'!-+*:B7!A%!&$7%!(*)!3#-!)%D$C&%'#4!!!!!

"#)%'<#+%'%7!"#$#%!`M%)-3<+#!*(!d*0$B!/3'$'03$B!F%D*)#3'<!$'7"#)%'<#+%'%7!"#$#%!`M%)-3<+#!*(!d*0$B!/3'$'03$B!F%D*)#3'<!$'7"#)%'<#+%'%7!"#$#%!`M%)-3<+#!*(!d*0$B!/3'$'03$B!F%D*)#3'<!$'7"#)%'<#+%'%7!"#$#%!`M%)-3<+#!*(!d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

E:7<%#!"#$'7$)7-4!E:7<%#!"#$'7$)7-4!E:7<%#!"#$'7$)7-4!E:7<%#!"#$'7$)7-4!E:7<%#3'<!-#$'7$)7-!-+*:B7!A%!7%M%B*D%7!#*!3'0B:7%!7%(3'3#3*'!*(!#+%!'$#:)%!*(!)%M%':%-R!B3&3#$#3*'-!*'!#+%!:-%!*(!'*')%0:))3'<!3#%&-R!&:B#3C%$)!DB$''3'<R!($3)!D)%-%'#$#3*'!*(!D%'-3*'!$'7!*#+%)!A%'%(3#!B3$A3B3#3%-R!$'7!#+%!-3e%!$'7!D$0%!*(!(:'73'<!*(!)%-%)M%!(:'7-4!W+%'!(%$-3AB%R!A:7<%#!D)%-%'#$#3*'-!-+*:B7!A%!*'!#+%!A$-3-!*(!$00):$B!)$#+%)!#+$'!0$-+!$00*:'#3'<4!E:7<%#-!-+*:B7!'*#!A%!*'!$!0$-+!A$-3-4!!!!!

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

9&DB30$#3*'-!(*)!#+%!/%7%)$B!f*M%)'&%'#9&DB30$#3*'-!(*)!#+%!/%7%)$B!f*M%)'&%'#9&DB30$#3*'-!(*)!#+%!/%7%)$B!f*M%)'&%'#9&DB30$#3*'-!(*)!#+%!/%7%)$B!f*M%)'&%'#4!,+%)%!3-!B3##B%!%M37%'0%!#*7$C!#+$#!#+%!1*'<)%--!$'7!NQ%0:#3M%!E)$'0+!0*'-37%)!#+%!3&D$0#!*(!3#-!7%03-3*'-!*'!#+%!*#+%)!B%M%B-!*(!<*M%)'&%'#!3'!-%##3'<!D*B30C!$'7!-D%'73'<!B%M%B-!(*)!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#4!,+%!)%$B3#C!3-!#+$#!$BB!#+)%%!B%M%B-!*(!<*M%)'&%'#!-%)M%!#+%!-$&%!D%*DB%!$'7!+$M%!$!)%-D*'-3A3B3#C!#*!%'-:)%!#+$#!#+%!:'3'#%'7%7!0*'-%b:%'0%-!*(!#+%3)!(3-0$B!$0#3*'-!7*!'*#!&:B#3DBC!#+%!0*'#)$730#3*'-R!+$)&R!*)!73-):D#3*'!%QD%)3%'0%7!AC!#+%!03#3e%'-!6+*!&:-#!$7T:-#!#*!#+%!3&D$0#!*(!$BB!#+)%%!B%M%B-!*(!<*M%)'&%'#!3'!#+%3)!B3M%-4!,+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!'%%7-!#*!A%!&*)%!0*<'3e$'#!*(!#+%!%((%0#-!3#-!$0#3*'-!+$M%!*'!#+%!(3-0$B!0*'73#3*'!*(!#+%!-#$#%-!$'7!B*0$B3#3%-4!!!!!

K)*T%0#3*'-!*(!#+%!9&D$0#!*'!"#$#%!$'7!d*0$B!/3'$'0%-!$'7!"%)M30%-!*(!/%7%)$B!?0#3*'-!$'7!K*B303%-!K)*T%0#3*'-!*(!#+%!9&D$0#!*'!"#$#%!$'7!d*0$B!/3'$'0%-!$'7!"%)M30%-!*(!/%7%)$B!?0#3*'-!$'7!K*B303%-!K)*T%0#3*'-!*(!#+%!9&D$0#!*'!"#$#%!$'7!d*0$B!/3'$'0%-!$'7!"%)M30%-!*(!/%7%)$B!?0#3*'-!$'7!K*B303%-!K)*T%0#3*'-!*(!#+%!9&D$0#!*'!"#$#%!$'7!d*0$B!/3'$'0%-!$'7!"%)M30%-!*(!/%7%)$B!?0#3*'-!$'7!K*B303%-!""""+*:B7!A%!F%b:3)%74!+*:B7!A%!F%b:3)%74!+*:B7!A%!F%b:3)%74!+*:B7!A%!F%b:3)%74!,+%!,$-.!/*)0%_-!$'$BC-3-!(*:'7!#+$#!'*!&%0+$'3-&!'*6!%Q3-#-!(*)!7%#%)&3'3'<R!$--%--3'<R!$'7!0*&&:'30$#3'<!#+%!(3-0$B!3&D$0#!*(!(%7%)$B!$0#3*'-!*'!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-4!!!!!

Page 14: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

=I!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&!/3'$B!F%D*)#!

?7%b:$#%!H3-0B*-:)%!*(!,%)&-R!1*'73#3*'-?7%b:$#%!H3-0B*-:)%!*(!,%)&-R!1*'73#3*'-?7%b:$#%!H3-0B*-:)%!*(!,%)&-R!1*'73#3*'-?7%b:$#%!H3-0B*-:)%!*(!,%)&-R!1*'73#3*'-RRRR!!!!$'7!F3-.-!*(!G:'303D$B!/3'$'0%-$'7!F3-.-!*(!G:'303D$B!/3'$'0%-$'7!F3-.-!*(!G:'303D$B!/3'$'0%-$'7!F3-.-!*(!G:'303D$B!/3'$'0%-4!4!4!4!,+%!"N1_-!0:))%'#!T:)3-730#3*'!63#+!)%-D%0#!#*!&:'303D$B!(3'$'0%!3--:%)-!3-!'$))*6BC!B3&3#%7!#*!()$:7!7:%!#*!#+%!-*20$BB%7!S,*6%)!?&%'7&%'#RU!$'7!'*!*#+%)!A*7C!+$-!#+%!$((3)&$#3M%!*AB3<$#3*'!*)!$:#+*)3#C!#*!)%b:3)%!(:BB!#)$'-D$)%'0C!$'7!73-0B*-:)%!*(!)3-.4!,+%!,*6%)!?&%'7&%'#!-+*:B7!A%!)%M3-3#%7!#*!-%%!3(!#+%!"N1!-+*:B7!A%!<3M%'!#+%!-$&%!T:)3-730#3*'!*M%)!#+%!3--:$'0%!*(!&:'303D$B!-%0:)3#3%-!$-!3#!+$-!*M%)!3--:$'0%!*(!0*)D*)$#%!-%0:)3#3%-4!!

8(&(4*&4!'92!:71(#'!$;!52-2/(+!<2;*#*'!62-%#'*$&8(&(4*&4!'92!:71(#'!$;!52-2/(+!<2;*#*'!62-%#'*$&8(&(4*&4!'92!:71(#'!$;!52-2/(+!<2;*#*'!62-%#'*$&8(&(4*&4!'92!:71(#'!$;!52-2/(+!<2;*#*'!62-%#'*$&!!!!

,+%!,$-.!/*)0%!F%D*)#!-#$#%-V!!

!"#1#$.1#$'&$*-.':+'4$*-1)%-)1#*$.':$91&%#:)1#*$@+-"+'$-"#$,#:#1.($4&<#1'2#'-$,&1$.'.(8Q+'4$-"#$+29.%-*$&'$*-.-#*$.':$(&%.(+-+#*$&,$1#:)%#:$,#:#1.($*9#':+'4$&1$,#:#1.($-.6$%".'4#*;$.':$-"#1#$+*$(+--(#$:+.(&4)#$.3&)-$-"#*#$+**)#*$3#-@##'$-"#$,#:#1.($4&<#1'2#'-$.':$*-.-#$.':$(&%.($4&<#1'2#'-*5$

9'!($0#R!#+%)%!0$'!A%!$'!$B$)&3'<!73-0*''%0#!A%#6%%'!(%7%)$B!$'7!-#$#%!D*B30C&$.%)-4!c3<+BC!)%D*)#%7!)%0*&&%'7$#3*'-!()*&!#+%!"3&D-*'2E*6B%-!1*&&3--3*'!*'!#+%!/%7%)$B!E:7<%#!H%(303#!$'7!#+%!D)*D*-%7!A:7<%#!D)%D$)%7!AC!#+%!c*:-%!E:7<%#!1*&&3##%%!1+$3)!K$:B!FC$'!3BB:-#)$#%!#+%!73-0*''%0#4!E*#+!#+%!1*&&3--3*'!$'7!G)4!FC$'!D)*D*-%7!)$3-3'<!#+%!G%730$)%!%B3<3A3B3#C!$<%!#*!P84!"3'0%!&*-#!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-!D)*M37%!($&3BC!&%730$B!A%'%(3#-!#*!#+%3)!%B3<3AB%!)%#3)%%-!$'7!%&DB*C%%-!:'#3B!#+%C!$<%!b:$B3(C!(*)!G%730$)%R!#+%!3&D$0#!*'!#+%!-#$#%-!*(!$'!3'0)%$-%!#*!$<%!-3Q#C2-%M%'!6*:B7!A%!M%)C!0*-#BC4!,+%)%!3-!'*!$DD$)%'#!%M37%'0%!#+$#!#+%!1*&&3--3*'!*)!#+%!1*'<)%--!0*'-37%)%7!#+3-!0*'-%b:%'0%4!!

G%&A%)-!*(!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!A%B3%M%!#+$#!#+%)%!-+*:B7!A%!$!0%'#)$B3e%7!%'#3#C!63#+3'!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!0+$)<%7!#*!&%$-:)%!$'7!)%D*)#!D:AB30BC!*'!#+%!3&D$0#!*(!(%7%)$B!3'3#3$#3M%-!*'!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-4!,+%)%!-+*:B7!A%!$7+%)%'0%!#*!#+%!D)3'03DB%!#+$#!#+%!NQ%0:#3M%!$'7!d%<3-B$#3M%!A)$'0+%-!*(!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!-+*:B7!A%!)%-D*'-3AB%!(*)!$BB!*(!#+%!0*'-%b:%'0%-!*(!6+$#!#+%C!7*R!'*#!T:-#!(*)!#+%!0*'-%b:%'0%-!#+$#!#+%C!3'#%'74!!

,+%!,$-.!/*)0%!W+3#%!K$D%)!*'!G$'$<3'<!#+%!9&D$0#!*(!/%7%)$B!H%(303#!F%7:0#3*'!%QDB*)%-!#+3-!D+%'*&%'*'V!

! W+3B%!#+%)%!3-!'*!$<)%%&%'#!*'!#+%!%B%&%'#-!*(!(%7%)$B!(3-0$B!)%(*)&R!6+$#%M%)!$0#3*'-!$)%!#$.%'!a!B*6%)!%QD%'73#:)%-R!3'0)%$-%7!)%M%':%-R!*)!A*#+!a!63BB!+$M%!$!-3<'3(30$'#!3&D$0#!*'!-#$#%-4!c*6%M%)R!#+%)%!+$-!A%%'!B3##B%!-%)3*:-!$'$BC-3-!*(!D*#%'#3$B!3&D$0#-!$'7!B3##B%!73$B*<:%!A%#6%%'!#+%!-#$#%-!$'7!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!$A*:#!#+%!'$#:)%!*(!6+$#!0*:B7!*00:)4!?'!%b:$BBC!#)*:AB3'<!)%$B3#C!3-!#+$#!#+%)%!3-!'*!*)<$'3e%7!&%0+$'3-&!#*!+$M%!0*'#3':3'<!73-0:--3*'-!*'!#+%-%!$'7!*#+%)!0)3#30$B!3--:%-!0*'0%)'3'<!A*#+!#+%!(%7%)$B!$'7!-#$#%!<*M%)'&%'#-4!

! `M%)!#+%!D$-#!#6*!C%$)-R!,$-.!/*)0%!&%&A%)-!6+*!+$M%!73-0:--%7!63#+!&%&A%)-!*(!1*'<)%--!$'7!#+%3)!-#$((-!#+%!3&D$0#!*(!(%7%)$B!B%<3-B$#3*'!*'!-#$#%-R!D$)#30:B$)BC!A:7<%#!3#%&-!$'7!#$Q!0+$'<%-R!)%D*)#!#+$#!M%)C!(%6!-%%&!(*0:-%7!*'!3#4!!

62#$772&-('*$&0!$&!8(&(4*&62#$772&-('*$&0!$&!8(&(4*&62#$772&-('*$&0!$&!8(&(4*&62#$772&-('*$&0!$&!8(&(4*&4!'92!:71(#'!$;!52-2/(+!<2;*#*'!62-%#'*$&4!'92!:71(#'!$;!52-2/(+!<2;*#*'!62-%#'*$&4!'92!:71(#'!$;!52-2/(+!<2;*#*'!62-%#'*$&4!'92!:71(#'!$;!52-2/(+!<2;*#*'!62-%#'*$&####

!$+#!%,-#."/0+#!$+#!%,-#."/0+#!$+#!%,-#."/0+#!$+#!%,-#."/0+#1111+0"22+(),#&$+#+0"22+(),#&$+#+0"22+(),#&$+#+0"22+(),#&$+#...."33"45(67"33"45(67"33"45(67"33"45(67####! 1)%$#%!$!0%'#)$B3e%7R!3'7%D%'7%'#!&%0+$'3-&!(*)!3&D)*M%7!)%D*)#3'<!$'7!$'$BC-3-!*(!-#$#%!(3'$'03$B!7$#$41)%$#%!$!0%'#)$B3e%7R!3'7%D%'7%'#!&%0+$'3-&!(*)!3&D)*M%7!)%D*)#3'<!$'7!$'$BC-3-!*(!-#$#%!(3'$'03$B!7$#$41)%$#%!$!0%'#)$B3e%7R!3'7%D%'7%'#!&%0+$'3-&!(*)!3&D)*M%7!)%D*)#3'<!$'7!$'$BC-3-!*(!-#$#%!(3'$'03$B!7$#$41)%$#%!$!0%'#)$B3e%7R!3'7%D%'7%'#!&%0+$'3-&!(*)!3&D)*M%7!)%D*)#3'<!$'7!$'$BC-3-!*(!-#$#%!(3'$'03$B!7$#$4!,+3-!&%0+$'3-&!0*:B7!A%!+*:-%7!3'!$!(%7%)$B!7%D$)#&%'#!*)!$<%'0C!*)!63#+!#+%!1*'<)%--3*'$B!E:7<%#!`((30%!$'7!6*:B7!+$M%!0*&D)%+%'-3M%!)%-D*'-3A3B3#C!(*)!7$#$!0*BB%0#3*'!$'7!$'$BC-3-4!!

Page 15: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&&&&/3'$B!F%D*)#!

=L

! N'0*:)$<%!7%M%B*D&%'#!*(!&%0+$'3-&-!(*)!A%##%)!0**)73'$#3*'!A%#6%%'!-#$#%!$'7!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#-4N'0*:)$<%!7%M%B*D&%'#!*(!&%0+$'3-&-!(*)!A%##%)!0**)73'$#3*'!A%#6%%'!-#$#%!$'7!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#-4N'0*:)$<%!7%M%B*D&%'#!*(!&%0+$'3-&-!(*)!A%##%)!0**)73'$#3*'!A%#6%%'!-#$#%!$'7!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#-4N'0*:)$<%!7%M%B*D&%'#!*(!&%0+$'3-&-!(*)!A%##%)!0**)73'$#3*'!A%#6%%'!-#$#%!$'7!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#-4!?!K)%-37%'#3$B!NQ%0:#3M%!`)7%)!-+*:B7!A%!3--:%7!#+$#!6*:B7!)%b:3)%!0$A3'%#!$<%'03%-!#*!0**)73'$#%!63#+!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-!6+%'!#$.3'<!&$T*)!$0#3*'-!#+$#!6*:B7!$((%0#!#+%&4!!9'(*)&$#3*'!$A*:#!#+%-%!$0#3*'-!-+*:B7!$B-*!A%!-+$)%7!63#+!1*'<)%--!#*!3'(*)&!#+%&!$A*:#!#+%!3&D$0#!*(!D*#%'#3$B!7%03-3*'-!!

! 9'!0**D%)$#3*'!63#+!#+%!-#$#%-R!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!-+*:B7!%'<$<%!3'!$!&$T*)!)%M3%6!*(!D*B303%-!$((%0#3'<!-#$#%!9'!0**D%)$#3*'!63#+!#+%!-#$#%-R!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!-+*:B7!%'<$<%!3'!$!&$T*)!)%M3%6!*(!D*B303%-!$((%0#3'<!-#$#%!9'!0**D%)$#3*'!63#+!#+%!-#$#%-R!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!-+*:B7!%'<$<%!3'!$!&$T*)!)%M3%6!*(!D*B303%-!$((%0#3'<!-#$#%!9'!0**D%)$#3*'!63#+!#+%!-#$#%-R!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!-+*:B7!%'<$<%!3'!$!&$T*)!)%M3%6!*(!D*B303%-!$((%0#3'<!-#$#%!<*M%)'&%'#-4!<*M%)'&%'#-4!<*M%)'&%'#-4!<*M%)'&%'#-4!,6*!*(!#+%!D)*D*-$B-!#+$#!0*:B7!A%!0*'-37%)%7!$)%V!\=]!$!S-*)#3'<U!D)*0%--!-3&3B$)!#*!*'%!:'7%)#$.%'!7:)3'<!#+%!F%$<$'!$7&3'3-#)$#3*'!#+$#!6*:B7!37%'#3(C!&$T*)!(%7%)$B!D)*<)$&-!$'7!$'$BCe%!6+%)%!#+%3)!(:'0#3*'-!6*:B7!A%!D%)(*)&%7!A%-#!$'7!\@]!T*3'#!7%M%B*D&%'#!*(!$'!$'$BC#30!&*7%B!#+$#!6*:B7!($03B3#$#%!A)*$7!$--%--&%'#!*(!#+%!3&D$0#!*(!M$)3*:-!#$Q!)%(*)&!D)*D*-$B-4!!

=&-2/;%&-2-!62'*/272&'!>/$7*020=&-2/;%&-2-!62'*/272&'!>/$7*020=&-2/;%&-2-!62'*/272&'!>/$7*020=&-2/;%&-2-!62'*/272&'!>/$7*020!!!!

9'!&$'C!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-!$!-3<'3(30$'#!0$:-%!*(!(3-0$B!73-#)%--!3-!#+%!3'0)%$-%!3'!D%'-3*'!0*'#)3A:#3*'-!#+$#!&:-#!A%!&$7%!#*!-:DD*)#!D$-#!D)*&3-%-!#*!D$C!(*)!6*).!D%)(*)&%7!AC!%&DB*C%%-!3'!D)%M3*:-!C%$)-4!,+%-%!D$C&%'#-!+$M%!#+%!3'0)%$-3'<!%((%0#!*(!0)*673'<!*:#!'%%7%7!0:))%'#!-%)M30%-!63#+3'!%Q3-#3'<!)%M%':%!-#):0#:)%-4!!

,+%!,$-.!/*)0%!0*&&3--3*'%7!$!-#$((!6+3#%!D$D%)!*'!J'7%)(:'7%7!F%#3)%&%'#!K)*&3-%-!$'7!+%B7!$!X$#3*'$B!H3$B*<:%!*'!J'7%)(:'7%7!F%#3)%&%'#!K)*&3-%-!*'!?D)3B!=gR!@>=5R!$#!#+%!X%6!Z*).!/%7%)$B!F%-%)M%!E$'.4!NQ0%)D#-!()*&!#+%!6+3#%!D$D%)!3'0B:7%V!!

! "#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#!)%#3)%&%'#!-C-#%&-!0*M%)!&*)%!#+$'!'3'%#%%'!&3BB3*'!6*).%)-!\$A*:#!$!-3Q#+!*(!#+%!J4"4!6*).(*)0%]!$'7!&*)%!#+$'!%3<+#!&3BB3*'!A%'%(303$)3%-4!?A*:#!$!b:$)#%)!*(!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#!6*).%)-!$)%!'*#!0*M%)%7!AC!"*03$B!"%0:)3#CR!$'7!&$'C!6*).%)-R!A%'%(303$)3%-R!$'7!#+%3)!($&3B3%-!)%BC!D)3&$)3BC!*'!#+%3)!D:AB30!D%'-3*'-!(*)!)%#3)%&%'#!-%0:)3#C4!F%#3)%&%'#!A%'%(3#-!+$M%!DB$C%7!$'!3&D*)#$'#!)*B%!3'!$##)$0#3'<!$'7!)%#$3'3'<!6*).%)-!(*)!#+%!0):03$B!-%)M30%-!#+$#!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-!7%B3M%)4!

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

! f*M%)'&%'#-!+$M%!A%%'!&$.3'<!637%-D)%$7!0+$'<%-!3'!)%-D*'-%!#*!)3-3'<!D%'-3*'!0*'#)3A:#3*'-4!"*&%!0+$'<%-!$((%0#!A*#+!0:))%'#!6*).%)-!$'7!)%#3)%%-!#+)*:<+!0+$'<%-!3'!0*'#)3A:#3*'-R!$<%!*(!)%#3)%&%'#R!$'7!A%'%(3#-4!`#+%)!0+$'<%-!$((%0#!-#$.%+*B7%)-!3'!<*M%)'&%'#-!&*)%!<%'%)$BBC!#+)*:<+!0:#-!3'!-%)M30%-R!3'0)%$-%-!3'!#$Q%-R!$'7!(3-0$B!B%<%)7%&$3'!7%-3<'%7!#*!D*-#D*'%!-%)M30%!0:#-!*)!#$Q!3'0)%$-%-!AC!D)*M%)A3$BBC!.30.3'<!#+%!0$'!7*6'!#+%!)*$74!

! 1+$'<%-!-+*:B7!A%!&$7%!3'!#+%!0*'#%Q#!*(!+*'*)3'<!D)*&3-%-!&$7%!#*!D:AB30!-%0#*)!%&DB*C%%-!$'7!)%#3)%%-R!D)%-%)M3'<!D:AB30!-%)M30%-R!$'7!0)%$#3'<!)%$-*'$AB%!A:)7%'-!*'!#$QD$C%)-!$'7!(%%D$C%)-4!W%!%QD%0#!$BB!-#$.%+*B7%)-!-+$)%!#+%-%!D)3'03DB%-!$'7!<*$B-!7%-D3#%!-+$)D!73-$<)%%&%'#-!$A*:#!#+%!$DD)*D)3$#%!73-#)3A:#3*'!*(!#+%!A:)7%'4!

Page 16: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

=P!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&!/3'$B!F%D*)#!

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b:3)%7!AC!B$6!#*!A%!D$374!,+%!D*)#3*'!*(!B3$A3B3#C!'*#!0*M%)%7!AC!$0#:$)3$B!$--%#-!3-!)%(%))%7!#*!$-!#+%!:'(:'7%7!$0#:$)3$B!$00):%7!B3$A3B3#C4!

N0*'*&3-#-!$'7!(3'$'03$B!$'$BC-#-!<%'%)$BBC!73-0*:'#!(:#:)%!D$C&%'#-!:-3'<!)$#%-!#+$#!)%(B%0#!#+%!)3-.!$--*03$#%7!63#+!#+%!D)*&3-%7!D$C&%'#-R!)%B$#3M%!#*!#+%!A)*$7%)!&$).%#4!"3'0%!&*-#!D:AB30!D%'-3*'!A%'%(3#-!+$M%!-#)*'<!B%<$B!D)*#%0#3*'-R!#+%!$DD)*D)3$#%!73-0*:'#!)$#%-!-+*:B7!A%!0*&D$)$AB%!#*!*#+%)!B*6!)3-.!$--%#-4!`(!0*:)-%!#+*-%!B%<$B!D)*#%0#3*'-!$)%!3'!T%*D$)7C!3'!$'C!T:)3-730#3*'-!#+$#!0$'!:-%!#+%!(%7%)$B!A$'.):D#0C!0*7%R!6+30+!63BB!D)%%&D#!$'C!B*0$B!*)!-#$#%!D)*#%0#3*'-4!":0+!)$#%-!$)%!<%'%)$BBC!&:0+!B*6%)!#+$'!#+*-%!0+*-%'!3'!$0#:$)3$B!M$B:$#3*'-R!6+30+!0:))%'#BC!$M%)$<%!$A*:#!848L!D%)0%'#4!W+%'!-#$#%-!:-%!+3<+%)!73-0*:'#!)$#%-R!#+%C!$)%!$AB%!#*!&$.%!B*6%)!$'7!*(#%'!3'$7%b:$#%!0*'#)3A:#3*'-R!:B#3&$#%BC!)%-:B#3'<!3'!+3<+%)!:'(:'7%7!B3$A3B3#3%-4!/*)!#+%!'$#3*'!$-!$!6+*B%R!-#$#%!$'7!B*0$B!D%'-3*'!-C-#%&-!+$7!-%B(2)%D*)#%7!B%M%B-!*(!$DD)*Q3&$#%BC!8P!D%)0%'#!(:'7%7!*'!$'!$0#:$)3$B!A$-3-!$#!#+%!%'7!*(!#+%3)!@>==!(3-0$B!C%$)-R!B%$M3'<!#+%&!$0#:$)3$BBC!:'7%)(:'7%7!AC!$DD)*Q3&$#%BC!i=!#)3BB3*'4!

F%#3)%&%'#!-C-#%&-!M$)C!<)%$#BC!3'!#+%3)!%-#3&$#%7!:'7%)(:'73'<4!,+%)%!$)%!'*!)%<:B$)BC!)%D*)#%7!%-#3&$#%-!*(!:'7%)(:'73'<!A$-%7!:D*'!B*6%)2)3-.!73-0*:'#!)$#%-R!-*!6%!&:-#!0*&D$)%!:-3'<!$0#:$)3$B!%-#3&$#%-!A$-%7!*'!$--:&%7!)$#%-!*(!)%#:)'4!`(!#+%!=@P!&$T*)!DB$'-!3'!#+%!K:AB30!/:'7!":)M%C!&$3'#$3'%7!AC!#+%!X$#3*'$B!?--*03$#3*'!*(!"#$#%!F%#3)%&%'#!?7&3'3-#)$#*)-R!#6%'#C!+$7!$0#:$)3$B!(:'7%7!)$#3*-!*(!$DD)*Q3&$#%BC!g>!D%)0%'#!*)!+3<+%)!$#!#+%!%'7!*(!#+%!@>==!(3-0$B!C%$)4!,+%-%!3'0B:7%7!#6*!*(!#+%!B$)<%-#!)%#3)%&%'#!-C-#%&-!3'!#+%!'$#3*'V!#+%!X%6!Z*).!"#$#%!$'7!d*0$B!N&DB*C%%!F%#3)%&%'#!"C-#%&!$'7!#+%!X%6!Z*).!"#$#%!,%$0+%)-!F%#3)%&%'#!"C-#%&4!"%M%'#%%'!DB$'-!+$7!$0#:$)3$B!(:'73'<!)$#3*-!A%B*6!P>!D%)0%'#4!9(!%-#3&$#%-!*(!(:'7%7!)$#3*-!A$-%7!*'!B*62)3-.!73-0*:'#!)$#%-!6%)%!$M$3B$AB%R!#+%!(:'7%7!-#$#:-!*(!M3)#:$BBC!%M%)C!DB$'!6*:B7!B**.!'*#$ABC!6*)-%4!!

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

?'*#+%)!0$:-%!*(!:'7%)(:'73'<!+$-!A%%'!)%#)*$0#3M%!A%'%(3#!3'0)%$-%-4!,+%!&*-#!-3<'3(30$'#!%Q$&DB%!*(!#+3-!3-!1$B3(*)'3$4!J'7%)(:'73'<!0$'!A%!6*)-%!6+%'!#+%!7C'$&30-!*(!'%6!):B%-!$)%!'*#!#*#$BBC!:'7%)-#**7!$'7!0$'!B%$7!#*!6*).%)!$0#3*'-!#+$#!%QD$'7!#+%!M$B:%-!*(!D%'-3*'-!63#+!%QD$'7%7!A$-%!-$B$)C!#+)*:<+!*M%)#3&%4!

Page 17: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&&&&/3'$B!F%D*)#!

=8

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`'%R!"%0#3*'!=>R!*(!#+%!J4"4!1*'-#3#:#3*'R!6+30+!D)*M37%-R!3'!D$)#R!#+$#!'*!-#$#%!&$C!D$--!$'C!B$6!#+$#!73&3'3-+%-!*)!3&D$3)-!$!0*'#)$0#4!,+%!A)%$7#+!*(!#+3-!J4"4!0*'-#3#:#3*'$B!D)*#%0#3*'!7%D%'7-!*'!#+%!#%)&-!*(!#+%!0*'#)$0#!$'7!#+%!&$#%)3$B3#C!$'7!03)0:&-#$'0%-!*(!#+%!B%<3-B$#3M%BC!%'$0#%7!&*73(30$#3*'-4!

/*)#C2#6*!-#$#%-!$7+%)%!#*!#+%!#+%*)C!#+$#!$!D%'-3*'!0*'#)$0#!3-!0)%$#%7!AC!M3)#:%!*(!D:AB30!-%)M30%!%&DB*C&%'#4!,+%-%!-#$#%-!)%<$)7!D%'-3*'-!$-!7%(%))%7!0*&D%'-$#3*'4!?!0*'#)$0#!&$C!A%!7%0B$)%7!3'!#+%!:'7%)BC3'<!B%<3-B$#3*'R!D)%-0)3A%7!AC!%QDB303#!-#$#%!0*'-#3#:#3*'$B!B$'<:$<%R!*)!(*:'7!*)!3&DB3%7!$'7!-*!7%#%)&3'%7!AC!#+%!-#$#%!0*:)#-4!W+%'%M%)!$!-#$#%!0*'-#3#:#3*'!%QDB303#BC!D)%-0)3A%-!#+$#!$!0*'#)$0#!%Q3-#-R!#+%!-#$#%!0*'-#3#:#3*'!*)!-#$#%!B$6!:-:$BBC!$B-*!D)*M37%-!#+$#!#+%!A%'%(3#-!*(!#+%!0*'#)$0#!0$''*#!A%!73&3'3-+%7!*)!3&D$3)%74!!

9(!$!D%'-3*'!0*'#)$0#!3-!7%%&%7!#*!%Q3-#R!#+%!&*-#!3&D*)#$'#!b:%-#3*'-!#*!A%!$-.%7!3'!$--%--3'<!#+%!$&*:'#!*(!0*'-#3#:#3*'$B!D)*#%0#3*'!$M$3B$AB%!#*!#+$#!D%'-3*'!0*'#)$0#!$)%V!W+%'!6$-!#+%!0*'#)$0#!0)%$#%7j!?'7R!6+$#!$)%!3#-!#%)&-j!":A-%b:%'#BC!3&D*)#$'#!b:%-#3*'-!$)%V!W+$#!3-!#+%!0*)%!D)*&3-%!*(!#+%!0*'#)$0#j!?'7R!3-!#+%)%!0B%$)R!:'$&A3<:*:-!B%<3-B$#3M%!3'#%'#!#*!%-#$AB3-+!$!0*'#)$0#R!#*!A3'7!(:#:)%!B%<3-B$#:)%-!#*!#+%!0*'#)$0#_-!#%)&-R!$'7R!#+%)%ACR!)%B3'b:3-+!#+%!-*M%)%3<'#C!*(!#+%!-#$#%!#*!&$.%!(:#:)%!0+$'<%-j!

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

K$50$#K$50$#K$50$#K$50$#1111+@"/2,#+@"/2,#+@"/2,#+@"/2,#KKKK"B3)#"B3)#"B3)#"B3)#LLLL%M+#%M+#%M+#%M+#&$+#N&$+#N&$+#N&$+#N/+%&+,&#/+%&+,&#/+%&+,&#/+%&+,&#FFFF2H%0&O2H%0&O2H%0&O2H%0&O####f*M%)'&%'#-!0$'!0+$'<%!D%'-3*'!A%'%(3#-!(*)!'%6!+3)%-!63#+*:#!B%<$B!)%-#)30#3*'-R!$B#+*:<+!#+%C!&$C!)$3-%!0*'0%)'-!$A*:#!$##)$0#3M%'%--!$-!%&DB*C%)-!$'7!$A*:#!)%#3)%&%'#!-%0:)3#C4!9#!+$-!A%%'!0*&&*'!(*)!<*M%)'&%'#-!#*!$77!'%6!#3%)-!63#+!)%7:0%7!A%'%(3#-!(*)!'%6!6*).%)-4!9#!3-!3&D*)#$'#!#*!'*#%!#+$#!-:0+!0+$'<%-!+$M%!$A-*B:#%BC!'*!3&D$0#!*'!:'(:'7%7!B3$A3B3#3%-R!A:#!0$'!-B*6!<)*6#+!3'!(:#:)%!B3$A3B3#3%-!$'7!M%)C!<)$7:$BBC!$((%0#!0*'#)3A:#3*'-!)%b:3)%7!AC!<*M%)'&%'#-4!

f*M%)'&%'#-!$)%!)%B:0#$'#!#*!)%7:0%!A%'%(3#-!(*)!)%#3)%%-R!$-!#+3-!3'M*BM%-!)%7:03'<!3'0*&%-!$#!$!D*3'#!3'!D%*DB%_-!B3M%-!6+%)%!#+%C!+$M%!$!B3&3#%7!$A3B3#C!#*!)%0*M%)4!F%#3)%%!A%'%(3#-!$B-*!#CD30$BBC!+$M%!)%B$#3M%BC!-#)*'<!B%<$B!D)*#%0#3*'-4!"*&%!0*:)#-!+$M%!$BB*6%7!0+$'<%-!#*!0*-#!*(!B3M3'<!$7T:-#&%'#-!\1`d?-]R!A:#!-%M%)$B!-#$#%!0*:)#-!+$M%!(*:'7!1`d?_-!$)%!%'#3#B%7!#*!#+%!-$&%!B%M%B!*(!D)*#%0#3*'!$-!A$-%!A%'%(3#-4!

,+%!3'2A%#6%%'!$)%$!3-!'*'$00):%7!A%'%(3#-!(*)!0:))%'#!6*).%)-R!6+%)%!#+%)%!3-!$!73-#3'0#3*'!A%#6%%'!A%'%(3#-!D)%M3*:-BC!%$)'%7!$'7!A%'%(3#-!C%#!#*!A%!%$)'%7!$##)3A:#$AB%!#*!(:#:)%!-%)M30%4!,+%)%!+$M%!A%%'!)%B$#3M%BC!(%6!%((*)#-!#*!)%7:0%!A%'%(3#-!D)%M3*:-BC!%$)'%74!N$)'%7!A%'%(3#-!+$M%!-#)*'<!B%<$B!D)*#%0#3*'-!$'7!#+%!+*B7%)-!*(!#+%&!+$M%!B3##B%!3'0%'#3M%!#*!'%<*#3$#%!3'!)%-D%0#!*(!#+%&4!

Page 18: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

=;!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&!/3'$B!F%D*)#!

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`'%!D$)#303D$'#!*A-%)M%7V!$

!"#1#$*"&)(:$3#$'&$2&1.($:+*-+'%-+&'$3#-@##'$.$%&22+-2#'-$-&$9.8$+'-#1#*-$-&$*&2#&'#$@"&$(#':*$8&)$2&'#8$-".'$.$%&22+-2#'-$-&$9.8$*&2#&'#$@"&$@&1/*$,&1$8&)5$TU+'#-##'V$2+((+&'$9#&9(#$@&1/$,&1$*-.-#$.':$(&%.($4&<#1'2#'-*W$+-X*$%1.Q8$-".-$@#$@&)(:'X-$@.'-$-&$,+':[email protected]$-&$,+6$-"+*$91&3(#2$*&$@#$%.'$%&'-+')#$-&$.--1.%-$-"#$3#*-$9#&9(#$-&$4&<#1'2#'-$*#1<+%#5$$

H3-0:--3*'!$B-*!0%'#%)%7!*'!#+%!'%%7!#*!0)%$#%!$'7!3'0%'#3M3e%!(*):&-!-*!#+$#!-#$.%+*B7%)-!\:'3*'-R!&$'$<%&%'#R!A*'7+*B7%)-R!$'7!*#+%)-!3'!73-#)%--%7!03#3%-]!0*:B7!D$)#303D$#%!3'!$!0*BB$A*)$#3M%!D)*0%--!#+$#!6*:B7!A%<3'!6%BB!A%(*)%!$'C#+3'<!)%-%&AB3'<!#+%!($3B:)%!*(!0*BB$A*)$#3*'!#+$#!3-!&:'303D$B!A$'.):D#0C4!!

?"(&5(B5(6#C+(,5"(#:(%3=,5,?"(&5(B5(6#C+(,5"(#:(%3=,5,?"(&5(B5(6#C+(,5"(#:(%3=,5,?"(&5(B5(6#C+(,5"(#:(%3=,5,####,+%!,$-.!/*)0%!<%'%)$BBC!%'7*)-%-!#+%!$'$BC-%-!$'7!-:<<%-#3*'-!0*'#$3'%7!3'!>-1#'4-"#'+'4$-"#$>#%)1+-8$&,$M)3(+%$>#%-&1$Y#,+'#:$E#'#,+-$M(.'*R!D:AB3-+%7!AC!#+%!F*0.%(%BB%)!9'-#3#:#%!$'7!$:#+*)%7!AC!(*)&%)!,$-.!/*)0%!-#$((!&%&A%)-!H*'!E*C7!$'7!K%#%)!h3%)'$'!\(*)#+0*&3'<4]!G)4!E*C7!$'7!G)4!h3%)'$'!$B-*!$:#+*)%7!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%_-!K%'-3*'!W+3#%!K$D%)4!

:&#/2(0*&4!./(&01$/'('*$&!:&?20'72&'!'$!32&2;*'!'92!@#$&$7,:&#/2(0*&4!./(&01$/'('*$&!:&?20'72&'!'$!32&2;*'!'92!@#$&$7,:&#/2(0*&4!./(&01$/'('*$&!:&?20'72&'!'$!32&2;*'!'92!@#$&$7,:&#/2(0*&4!./(&01$/'('*$&!:&?20'72&'!'$!32&2;*'!'92!@#$&$7,!!!!

,+%!0*'73#3*'!*(!*:)!#)$'-D*)#$#3*'!3'()$-#):0#:)%!+$-!A%%'!0+$)$0#%)3e%7!AC!'%$)!($3B3'<!<)$7%-!()*&!&$'C!-*:)0%-R!3'0B:73'<!#+%!?&%)30$'!"*03%#C!*(!13M3B!N'<3'%%)-!\?"1N]48!9'!3#-!@>=5!F%D*)#!1$)7R!#+%!?"1N!<$M%!#+%!0*'73#3*'!*(!#+%!'$#3*'_-!3'()$-#):0#:)%!$!<)$7%!*(!Hk!-$C3'<R!RZ"+(#$-"#$2&:#*-$91&41#**$+*$#'%&)1.4+'4;$+-$+*$%(#.1$-".-$@#$".<#$.$*+4'+,+%.'-$3.%/(&4$&,$&<#1:)#$2.+'-#'.'%#$.%1&**$&)1$+',1.*-1)%-)1#$*8*-#2*;$.$91#**+'4$'##:$,&1$2&:#1'+Q.-+&';$.':$.'$+22#'*#$&99&1-)'+-8$-&$%1#.-#$1#(+.3(#;$(&'4A-#12$,)':+'4$*&)1%#*$-&$.<&+:$@+9+'4$&)-$&)1$1#%#'-$4.+'*5S!

9'!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!F%D*)#R!#+%!<%'%)$B!(*0:-!6$-!*'!3'()$-#):0#:)%!-D%'73'<!$'7!#+%!D)%--:)%!#+$#!6$-!A%3'<!D:#!*'!$M$3B$AB%!(:'7-!()*&!D*#%'#3$B!(%7%)$B!0:#A$0.-!$'7!()*&!0*&D%#3'<!'%%7-!$#!#+%!-#$#%!B%M%B4!,*!D)*M37%!0*'#%Q#!(*)!3'()$-#):0#:)%!-D%'73'<R!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!-#$#%7V!$

>-.-#*$.':$-"#+1$(&%.(+-+#*$,+'.'%#$'#.1(8$-"1##AH).1-#1*$&,$.(($9)3(+%$+',1.*-1)%-)1#*$[$*%"&&(*;$"+4"@.8*$.':$-1.'*+-$*8*-#2*;$:1+'/+'[email protected]#1;$.':$&-"#1$91&7#%-*$%1)%+.($-&$#%&'&2+%$41&@-"$.':$9)3(+%$"#.(-"$.':$*.,#-85$$

,+%!0$))*#!*(!(%7%)$B!&*'%CR!D$)#30:B$)BC!3'!#)$'-D*)#$#3*'R!0$'!7)3M%!3'()$-#):0#:)%!3'M%-#&%'#4!G*)%!#+$'!ig>!A3BB3*'!(B*6-!$'':$BBC!()*&!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!#*!-#$#%-!(*)!3'()$-#):0#:)%4!?-!D)*T%0#%7!AC!#+%!1*'<)%--3*'$B!E:7<%#!`((30%!\1E`]!#+3-!63BB!7%0)%$-%!AC!&*)%!#+$'!5L!D%)0%'#!3'!#+%!D%)3*7!()*&!@>=@!#*!@>@@!$-!$!)%-:B#!*(!#+%!'%%7!#*!7%0)%$-%!*M%)$BB!(%7%)$B!-D%'73'<!$-!D$)#!*(!%((*)#-!#*!)%7:0%!#+%!(%7%)$B!7%(303#4!!

9#!3-!)%$-*'$AB%!#*!$--:&%!#+$#!#+%)%!63BB!A%!'%6!)%-#)$3'#-!*'!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!-D%'73'<R!D)%--:)%!#*!0:#!<)$'#-23'2$37!#*!-#$#%-R!0:#-!3'!(%7%)$B!D)*0:)%&%'#R!$'7!:'0%)#$3'#C!$A*:#!(%7%)$B!#$Q!0+$'<%-!#+$#!&3<+#!&*73(C!#+%!#$Q2()%%!0+$)$0#%)3-#30!

Page 19: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&&&&/3'$B!F%D*)#!

=g

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`R!(*:)!*(!#+%!-#:7C!-#$#%-!A%'%(3#!&*)%!()*&!#+%!#$Q2()%%!3'0*&%!*(!&:'303D$B!A*'7-!#+$'!#+%!'$#3*'!$-!$!6+*B%4!!

E%B*6!$)%!*A-%)M$#3*'-!()*&!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!-#$((!W+3#%!K$D%)!*'!9'0)%$-3'<!,)$'-D*)#$#3*'!9'M%-#&%'#!#*!E%'%(3#!#+%!N0*'*&CV!!

! c3-#*)30$BBCR!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!$'7!-#$#%-!+$M%!-+$)%7!#+%!D)3&$)C!(:'73'<!)%-D*'-3A3B3#C!(*)!)*$7-R!+3<+6$C-R!A)37<%-R!$'7!#)$'-3#4!c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

! ,+%!3&D*)#$'0%!*(!#+%!#)$'-D*)#$#3*'!-C-#%&!$-!$!6+*B%!3-!637%BC!:'7%)-#**7!AC!A*#+!#+%!D:AB30!$'7!D)3M$#%!-%0#*)-4!,+%!3'#%)0*''%0#%7!D$)#'%)-+3D!$&*'<!#+%!&*7%-!#*!&*M%!<**7-!()*&!D*)#-!*)!$3)D*)#-!#*!)$3B!*)!)*$7-!3-!#+%!D)3&$)C!3'<)%73%'#!(*)!T:-#23'2#3&%!7%B3M%)C!$'7!#+%!&*M%&%'#!*(!A:B.!0$)<*4!W+3B%!#+%!3&D*)#$'0%!*(!$'!3'#%)0*''%0#%7!-C-#%&!#*!0*&&%)0%!$'7!-#$#%!%0*'*&3%-!3-!0B%$)BC!-:A-#$'#3$BR!#+%!A%'%(3#-!+$M%!A%%'!73((30:B#!#*!b:$'#3(C4!!

! f3M%'!0:))%'#!(:'73'<!D)*T%0#3*'-R!#+%!?&%)30$'!"*03%#C!*(!13M3B!N'<3'%%)-!\?"1N]!%-#3&$#%-!#+$#!()*&!@>=5!#+)*:<+!@>@>R!#+%!'$#3*'$B!%0*'*&C!63BB!(%%B!$!'%<$#3M%!3&D$0#!*(!$B&*-#!ig>>!A3BB3*'!3'!B*-#!fHK!7:%!#*!7%#%)3*)$#3'<!-:)($0%!#)$'-D*)#$#3*'!3'()$-#):0#:)%!0*'73#3*'-4!W+%'!#+3-!#3&%!D%)3*7!3-!%Q#%'7%7!#*!@>I>R!#+%!3&D$0#!3'0)%$-%-!#*!$DD)*Q3&$#%BC!i54=!#)3BB3*'4!?"1N!%-#3&$#%-!#+$#!igI!A3BB3*'!D%)!C%$)!3-!'%%7%7!3'!$773#3*'$B!(:'73'<!(*)!-:)($0%!#)$'-D*)#$#3*'4!?773#3*'$BBCR!$3)D*)#-!($0%!$!(:'73'<!<$D!*(!i5g!A3BB3*'!#+)*:<+!@>@>R!$'7!igL!A3BB3*'!#+)*:<+!@>I>4!1)3#30$B!#*!0*&&%)0%R!#+%!'$#3*'_-!D*)#-!$'7!3'B$'7!6$#%)6$C-!$)%!%-#3&$#%7!#*!+$M%!$!(:'73'<!<$D!*(!i=P!A3BB3*'!AC!@>@>R!6+30+!63BB!<)*6!#*!iIP!A3BB3*'!AC!@>I>4!!

/%7%)$B!(:'73'<!(*)!-:)($0%!#)$'-D*)#$#3*'!6$-!&*-#!)%0%'#BC!)%$:#+*)3e%7!(*)!#6*!(3-0$B!C%$)-!AC!B%<3-B$#3*'!'$&%7!G*M3'<!?+%$7!(*)!K)*<)%--!3'!#+%!@=-#!1%'#:)C!\G?K2@=]4!,+3-!B%$M%-!$!(:'73'<!<$D!(*)!-:)($0%!#)$'-D*)#$#3*'!*(!&*)%!#+$'!i54P!#)3BB3*'!#+)*:<+!@>I>4!!

/:'73'<!(*)!$BB!$-D%0#-!*(!$M3$#3*'!+$-!A%%'!7%0B3'3'<!-3'0%!@>>g!6+%'!$DD)*D)3$#%7!B%M%B-!6%)%!*M%)!i=8!A3BB3*'4!9'!@>=@R!$:#+*)3e$#3*'!*(!#+%!:-%!*(!/%7%)$B!?M3$#3*'!?7&3'3-#)$#3*'!\/??]!)%M%':%-!6$-!-%M%)$B!C%$)-!3'!#+%!&$.3'<4!!?!#3&%BCR!(:'7$&%'#$B!)%M3%6!*(!$M3$#3*'!(3'$'0%-!AC!1*'<)%--!3-!:'B3.%BC4!!

F%$:#+*)3e$#3*'!*(!#+%!W$#%)!F%-*:)0%-!H%M%B*D&%'#!?0#!*(!=g;P!3-!A%(*)%!#+%!1*'<)%--!63#+!(3'$B!$0#3*'!D)*T%0#%7!(*)!@>=I4!,+%!&$0)*!b:%-#3*'!$0)*--!$BB!*(!#+%!&*7%-!3-R!Sc*6!-+*:B7!)%-D*'-3A3B3#C!A%!73M37%7!A%#6%%'!-#$#%-R!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#R!$'7!#+%!D)3M$#%!-%0#*)!(*)!7%03-3*'!&$.3'<!$'7!(:'73'<!$0)*--!#+%!&*7%-jU!

Page 20: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

@>!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&!/3'$B!F%D*)#!

W3#+!%Q#)%&%BC!B3&3#%7!)%-*:)0%-R!&$Q3&3e3'<!#+%!%((%0#3M%'%--!*(!#)$'-D*)#$#3*'!D)*T%0#-!3-!3&D*)#$'#4!,+%!?&%)30$'!D%*DB%!)%b:3)%!0*'(37%'0%!#+$#!#+%3)!&*'%C!3-!A%3'<!6%BB!-D%'#!3'!*)7%)!#*!%-#$AB3-+!D:AB30!-:DD*)#!(*)!'%6!(:'73'<4!c3-#*)30$BBCR!#+%!:-%!*(!%$)&$).-!$'7!*#+%)!(:'73'<!7%M30%-!D)*7:0%7!#**!&$'C!D)*T%0#-!#+$#!0*:B7!A%!0+$)$0#%)3e%7!$-!SA)37<%-!#*!'*6+%)%4U!,+%-%!D)*T%0#-!-*&%#3&%-!A%'%(3#!B3&3#%7!0*'-#3#:%'03%-R!$'7!$)%!*(#%'!M%)C!%QD%'-3M%!(*)!#+%!A%'%(3#-!#+$#!#+%C!D)*M37%R!(:)#+%)!%)*73'<!D:AB30!#):-#4!

NM%'!6+%'!D)*T%0#-!+$M%!A)*$7!A%'%(3#-!#+$#!$)%!%$-3BC!)%0*<'3e$AB%R!#+%C!)%b:3)%!$!-3<'3(30$'#!3'M%-#&%'#4!,+%!1E`!'*#%-R!S,+%!)$#3*!*(!A%'%(3#-!#*!0*-#-!(*)!%0*'*&30$BBC!T:-#3(3$AB%!D)*T%0#-!M$)3%-!637%BC!()*&!D)*T%0#!#*!D)*T%0#4l!1$)%(:BBC!)$'.3'<!$'7!(:'73'<!D)*T%0#-!-*!#+$#!*'BC!#+*-%!63#+!#+%!+3<+%-#!'%#!A%'%(3#-!$)%!3&DB%&%'#%7!0*:B7!C3%B7!$!B$)<%!-+$)%!*(!#+%!#*#$B!D*--3AB%!A%'%(3#-!$#!$!()$0#3*'!*(!#+%!0*-#4U!E%'%(3#-!$'7!0*-#-!$)%!73((30:B#!#*!&%$-:)%R!A:#!%-#3&$#3'<!$'7!%M$B:$#3'<!#+%&!3-!$'!3&D*)#$'#!%B%&%'#!*(!-%B%0#3'<!-*:'7!D)*T%0#-4!

,+%!'%%7!#*!$--:)%!#+%!#3&%BC!3&DB%&%'#$#3*'!*(!#+%-%!D)*T%0#-!3-!M3#$B4!?-!'*#%7!AC!/*)&%)!J'7%)!"%0)%#$)C!*(!,)$'-D*)#$#3*'!F*C!h%'3#eV!!

!"#$.2&)'-$&,$-+2#$+-$-./#*$2.'8$+',1.*-1)%-)1#$91&7#%-*$-&$2&<#$,1&2$+'+-+.($+:#.$-&$,+'.($%&'*-1)%-+&'$,1)*-1.-#*$#<#18&'#$,1&2$-"#$9&(+%82./#1*$-&$-"#$9)3(+%5$\+4"-$-&$-#'$8#.1*$&,$-&-.($#(.9*#:$-+2#$&1$2&1#$+*$'&-$)'%&22&'$,&1$(.14#;$%&29(#6$91&7#%-*5$].'8$3#'#,+-*$@&)(:$)':&)3-#:(8$,(&@$,1&2$1#:)%+'4$-"+*$-+2#W$.%%&29(+*"+'4$-"+*$1#H)+1#*$)*$,+1*-$-&$)':#1*-.':$@"8$-"#$91&%#**$-./#*$*&$(&'4$-&:.85$

89,+/M%&5"(,#@/"2#&$+89,+/M%&5"(,#@/"2#&$+89,+/M%&5"(,#@/"2#&$+89,+/M%&5"(,#@/"2#&$+####P%&5"(%3#E5%3"6B+#"(P%&5"(%3#E5%3"6B+#"(P%&5"(%3#E5%3"6B+#"(P%&5"(%3#E5%3"6B+#"(####!/%(,H"/&%&5"(#!/%(,H"/&%&5"(#!/%(,H"/&%&5"(#!/%(,H"/&%&5"(#F(@/%,&/B0&B/+#F(@/%,&/B0&B/+#F(@/%,&/B0&B/+#F(@/%,&/B0&B/+#####,+%!X$#3*'$B!H3$B*<:%!*'!,)$'-D*)#$#3*'!9'()$-#):0#:)%!6$-!D)%-%'#%7!3'!D$)#'%)-+3D!63#+!#+%!?/d219`!$'7!#+%!J4"4!1+$&A%)!*(!1*&&%)0%4!K$)#303D$'#-!$<)%%7!#+$#!)%#3)%&%'#!$'7!+%$B#+!0$)%!%QD%'-%-!$)%!<)*63'<!$#!$!)$#%!7)$&$#30$BBC!($-#%)!#+$'!)%M%':%-!$'7R!3'!$773#3*'!#*!%7:0$#3*'!(:'73'<R!#+%!A3<<%-#!M30#3&!*(!#+$#!<)*6#+!3-!&$3'#%'$'0%!$'7!&*7%)'3e$#3*'!*(!*:)!'$#3*'_-!3'()$-#):0#:)%4!!

,+%!&$<'3#:7%!*(!#+%!3'()$-#):0#:)%!0*-#!3-!%'*)&*:-!$'7!<)*63'<4!,+%)%!3-!$'!3'%Q+$:-#3AB%!7%&$'7!(*)!3'()$-#):0#:)%!(:'73'<4!,+%!<)*:D!0*'-37%)%7!*D#3*'-!(*)!$7%b:$#%!)%M%':%!#*!#$0.B%!#+%!-%%&3'<BC!%'7B%--!B3-#!*(!'%0%--$)C!D)*T%0#-4!!

,$-.!/*)0%!1*21+$3)!K$:B![*B0.%)!-:<<%-#%7!#+$#!D)*<)%--!6*:B7!0*'#3':%!$#!$'!$AC-&$B!)$#%!3(!'*!0B%$)!M3-3*'!3-!*:#B3'%7V!$

!"+*$+*$.3&)-$%&22)'+-8$+'<#*-2#'-;$.':$%1#.-+'4$.$<+*+&'$,&1$"&@$-"&*#$%&22)'+-+#*$%&((#%-+<#(8$&9#1.-#$+'$.$*.,#$.':$#,,+%+#'-$2.''#15$Z+-"&)-$.$%(#.1$<+*+&'$,&1$+'<#*-+'4$+'$+',1.*-1)%-)1#;$+'%():+'4$.$:#:+%.-#:$1#<#')#$*&)1%#;$@#$%.''&-$%&29#-#5$

/3'$BBCR!#+%!H3$B*<:%!(*0:-%7!*'!D)*T%0#!-%B%0#3*'!$'7!3&DB%&%'#$#3*'4!,+%!:')%$-*'$ABC!B*'<!<%-#$#3*'!D%)3*7!(*)!3'()$-#):0#:)%!D)*T%0#-R!0*&A3'%7!63#+!#+%!73((30:B#C!3'!D)*M3'<!+*6!7%#%)3*)$#%7!$'!3'()$-#):0#:)%!3-!A%(*)%!-$(%#C!A%0*&%-!#+%!D)*D%BB$'#!(*)!$0#3*'R!0*&&$'7-!-%)3*:-!$##%'#3*'4!!

/*)&%)!K%''-CBM$'3$!f*M%)'*)!N7!F%'7%BB!'*#%7!#+%!B$)<%-#!3&D%73&%'#!#*!D)*<)%--!3-!#+%!%B%0#*)$#%_-!<%'%)$B!$M%)-3*'!#*!)$3-3'<!)%M%':%4!,+%!<*M%)'*)!*A-%)M%7V!!

!"#$.'*@#1$-&$4#'#1.-+'4$9&(+-+%.($@+(($+*$7)*-$:&$+-5$Z"#'$=$@.*$4&<#1'&1;$@#$9.**#:$-"#$*#%&':$3+44#*-$-.6$+'%1#.*#$+'$M#''*8(<.'+.$"+*-&185$M#&9(#$".-#:$-"#$'&-+&'$-".-$-.6#*$@#1#$3#+'4$1.+*#:;$3)-$-"#'$-"#8$@#'-$

Page 21: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&&&&/3'$B!F%D*)#!

@=

.3&)-$-"#+1$3)*+'#**$.':$-"#8$*.@$-"+'4*$%".'4+'4;$.':$-"#+1$.'4#1$:+**+9.-#:5$!"#8$*.@$-"#$#%&'&28$3&&2+'45$\1+#$D.'.(;$-1.'*.-(.'-+%$1.+(1&.:;$.':$+'-#1*-.-#$"+4"@.8^$.(($%.2#$.3&)-$-".'/*$-&$M1#*+:#'-+.($(#.:#1*"+95$Z#$'##:$91#*+:#'-+.($(#.:#1*"+95$!"#$T*(&@V$1.-#$.-$@"+%"$91&7#%-*$.1#$%&29(#-#:$+*$%.)*+'4$)*$-&$,.(($1.9+:(8$3#"+':5$!"#$2.+'$H)#*-+&'$+*$RP&@$%.'$@#$%&'<+'%#$D&'41#**$-&$/##9$)*$,1&2$,.((+'4$3#"+':$.-$.$1.9+:(8$:#%(+'+'4$1.-#_S$

d3.%!%7:0$#3*'R!#+%!-#$#%!*(!3'()$-#):0#:)%!3'!#+%!J'3#%7!"#$#%-!3&D$0#-!*:)!$A3B3#C!#*!0*&D%#%!$A)*$74!,+%!b:$B3#C!*(!*:)!3'()$-#):0#:)%!3-!$--*03$#%7!63#+!*:)!0*&D%#3#3M%'%--4!!

;B22%/=#"(#F(@/%,&/B0&B/+;B22%/=#"(#F(@/%,&/B0&B/+;B22%/=#"(#F(@/%,&/B0&B/+;B22%/=#"(#F(@/%,&/B0&B/+####,+%!&%&A%)-!*(!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!$<)%%7!#+$#!3#!6*:B7!'*#!A%!$DD)*D)3$#%!#*!*((%)!)%0*&&%'7$#3*'-!3'!)%-D%0#!#*!#+%!-D%03(30!B%M%B-!*(!)%b:3)%7!#)$'-D*)#$#3*'!3'M%-#&%'#!(:'73'<4!,+%!'%%7!(*)!$773#3*'$B!#)$'-D*)#$#3*'!3'M%-#&%'#!$#!$BB!B%M%B-!*(!<*M%)'&%'#!3-!*M%)6+%B&3'<R!&$.3'<!%'*)&*:-!7%&$'7-!*'!<*M%)'&%'#!)%M%':%-!$'7!#+%!$A3B3#C!*(!<*M%)'&%'#!#*!(3'$'0%!$'7R!#+:-R!3&D*-%!A:)7%'-!*'!-:A-%b:%'#!<%'%)$#3*'-!#*!D$C!(*)!D)*T%0#-!()*&!6+30+!#+%C!&$C!$'7!-+*:B7!A%'%(3#R!A:#!&$C!+$M%!'*!)*B%!3'!0+**-3'<4!,+%!M$-#!7%&$'7!(*)!#)$'-D*)#$#3*'!3'()$-#):0#:)%!)%b:3)%-!#+%!-%##3'<!*(!D)3*)3#3%-!$'7!-%B%0#3*'-!*(!D$##%)'-!*(!%0*'*&30!7%M%B*D&%'#4!,+%-%!$)%!73((30:B#!D*B3#30$B!$'7!-:A-#$'#3M%!0+*30%-!#+$#!'%0%--$)3BC!&:-#!A%!&$7%!AC!%B%0#%7!$'7!$DD*3'#%7!*((303$B-!3'!$!7%&*0)$#30$BBC!$00*:'#$AB%!&$''%)!#+$#!3-!)%(B%0#3M%!*(!*:)!M$B:%-!$'7!D*B3#30-4!

?00*)73'<BCR!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!7%#%)&3'%7!#*!0*'(3'%!3#-%B(!#*!&$.%!)%0*&&%'7$#3*'-!*'BC!63#+!)%-D%0#!#*!&$##%)-!*(!D)*0%--R!$7&3'3-#)$#3*'R!$'7!<*M%)'$'0%!-:0+!$-!A:7<%#!#)$'-D$)%'0CR!A:7<%#!&$.3'<R!(3'$'03$B!)%D*)#3'<R!#+%!&%#)30-!*(!D%'-3*'!(:'73'<R!$'7!(%7%)$B2-#$#%!)%B$#3*'-4!

:71/$?*&4!'92!A'('2B52-2/(+!>(/'&2/09*1!$;!82-*#(*-:71/$?*&4!'92!A'('2B52-2/(+!>(/'&2/09*1!$;!82-*#(*-:71/$?*&4!'92!A'('2B52-2/(+!>(/'&2/09*1!$;!82-*#(*-:71/$?*&4!'92!A'('2B52-2/(+!>(/'&2/09*1!$;!82-*#(*-####

E%B*6!$)%!*A-%)M$#3*'-!()*&!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!W+3#%!K$D%)!*'!9&D)*M3'<!"#$#%O/%7%)$B!K$)#'%)-+3D!*(!G%730$374!!

]#:+%.+:$1#%#'-(8$*)19.**#:$`AKI$#:)%.-+&'$.*$-"#$(.14#*-$.1#.$&,$*-.-#$*9#':+'4$@"#'$.(($,)':*;$+'%():+'4$,#:#1.($,)':*;$.1#$%&'*+:#1#:5$

Page 22: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

@@!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&!/3'$B!F%D*)#!

!

!! 9'!@>==R!0*&A3'%7!(%7%)$B!$'7!-#$#%!G%730$37!-D%'73'<!#*DD%7!iI5@!A3BB3*'R!63#+!-3<'3(30$'#!3&DB30$#3*'-!(*)!A*#+!(%7%)$B!$'7!-#$#%!A:7<%#-4!,+%!1*'<)%--3*'$B!E:7<%#!`((30%!A$-%B3'%!D)*T%0#3*'-!(*)!(%7%)$B!G%730$37!-D%'73'<!-+*6!$!)3-%!()*&!i@L;!A3BB3*'!3'!@>=@!#*!iP@@!A3BB3*'!3'!@>@@4!,+%!(%7%)$B!%QD%'73#:)%!#)%'7!3-!7)3M%'!3'!B$)<%!&%$-:)%!AC!#+%!?((*)7$AB%!1$)%!?0#_-!D)*M3-3*'!#+$#!(:'7-!#+%!D)*<)$&_-!%QD$'-3*'!#*!&*)%!B*623'0*&%!$7:B#-4!NQ0%D#!(*)!#+%!-*20$BB%7!S6**76*).U!%((%0#!#+$#!-*&%!-#$#%-!\%4<4R!1$B3(*)'3$]!#+3'.!63BB!0)%$#%!$!)3-%!3'!-#$#%!G%730$37!(:'73'<R!#+%!-#$#%!%QD%'73#:)%!#)%'7!B3'%!63BB!)3-%!&*)%!-B*6BC!-3'0%!-#$#%!G%730$37!D)*<)$&-!$)%!%QD%0#%7!#*!-+*:B7%)!$!-&$BB!()$0#3*'!*(!#+%!0*-#!*(!#+%!%QD$'7%7!$00%--!#*!+%$B#+!0$)%4!

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

! W+%'!B**.3'<!$#!-D%'73'<!-:DD*)#%7!63#+!-#$#%!)%M%':%-!$0)*--!$BB!-#$#%-R!G%730$37!$00*:'#%7!(*)!i=5@!A3BB3*'!3'!-#$#%!-D%'73'<!3'!@>=@4!9#!$00*:'#%7!(*)!$DD)*Q3&$#%BC!=P!D%)0%'#!*(!-#$#%!<%'%)$B!%QD%'73#:)%-4!`'!#+3-!A$-3-R!G%730$37!-D%'73'<!)$'.-!-%0*'7!A%+3'7!-#$#%!-D%'73'<!*'!%7:0$#3*'4!!

Page 23: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&&&&/3'$B!F%D*)#!

@5

! G%730$37!3-!'*#!3&&:'%!()*&!-C-#%&2637%!+%$B#+!0$)%!0*-#!D)%--:)%-4!E*#+!+%$B#+!0$)%!0*-#-!$'7!:#3B3e$#3*'!+$M%!3'0)%$-%7!-3<'3(30$'#BC!*M%)!#+%!B$-#!#+)%%!7%0$7%-!7:%!#*!#+%!:-%!*(!%QD%'-3M%!$'7!B3(%-$M3'<!#%0+'*B*<C!$'7!3&D)*M%7!B3(%!%QD%0#$'0C4!9'!-D3#%!*(!#+%-%!-C-#%&2637%!0*-#!D)%--:)%-R!G%730$37!+$-!A%%'!$AB%!#*!0*'#$3'!D%)2%')*BB%%!+%$B#+!0$)%!0*-#!3'0)%$-%-!&*)%!%((%0#3M%BC!#+$'!%3#+%)!D)3M$#%!&$).%#!3'-:)$'0%!*)!G%730$)%4!!

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g48!D%)0%'#!3'!@>==!#*!@!D%)0%'#!3'!@>=@4!!

! ?00*)73'<!#*!#+%!h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

! ?<$3'-#!#+3-!A$0.7)*D!*(!G%730$37!0*-#!<)*6#+R!#+%!G%730$37!%QD$'-3*'!D)*M3-3*'-!*(!#+%!?((*)7$AB%!1$)%!?0#R!6+30+!$)%!%-#3&$#%7!#*!%'$AB%!&*)%!#+$'!@=!&3BB3*'!$7:B#-!#*!A%0*&%!3'-:)%7R!$)%!A%3'<!7%A$#%7!$#!#+%!-#$#%!B%M%B4!,+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!63BB!D$C!=>>!D%)0%'#!*(!#+%!0*-#!*(!0*M%)3'<!#+%!'%6BC!%B3<3AB%!%')*BB%%-!A%<3''3'<!3'!@>=IR!D+$-3'<!7*6'!#*!g>!D%)0%'#!3'!@>=g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

! ,+%!)%0%'#!)%0%--3*'!+$-!(*)0%7!&*)%!?&%)30$'-!#*!#:)'!#*!G%730$37R!3'0)%$-3'<!#+%!D)*<)$&_-!*M%)$BB!0*-#4!c*6%M%)R!G%730$37_-!D%)2%')*BB%%!0*-#-!(*)!#+%!#CD30$B!6*).3'<!$<%!$7:B#!$'7!#+%3)!0+3B7)%'!3-!&*7%-#4!,+%!D)*<)$&_-!D%)2%')*BB%%!0*-#!<)*6#+!3-!<)%$#%-#!(*)!#+%!73-$AB%7R!#+%!7:$BBC!%B3<3AB%!$7:B#-!6+*!$)%!%3#+%)!73-$AB%7!*)!%B7%)BCR!$7:B#-!63#+!A%+$M3*)$B2A$-%7!3BB'%--%-R!$'7!B*623'0*&%!G%730$)%!)%03D3%'#-!6+*!'%%7!B*'<2#%)&!0$)%4!W+3B%!#+%!D%)2%')*BB%%!0*-#-!*(!#+%!-D%03$B!D*D:B$#3*'-!$)%!)%B$#3M%BC!%QD%'-3M%R!6%)%!3#!'*#!(*)!G%730$37R!&$'C!*(!#+%-%!3'73M37:$B-!6*:B7!+$M%!B3##B%!*)!'*!$00%--!#*!+%$B#+!*)!B*'<2#%)&!0$)%!-%)M30%-4!,+%!$A-%'0%!*(!-:0+!0$)%!6*:B7!$BB*6!#+%!+:&$'!0*-#-!*(!+$)7-+3D!$'7!D$3'!$'7R!3'!-*&%!0$-%-R!D)%&$#:)%!7%$#+4!9'!$773#3*'R!63#+*:#!G%730$37!$-!#+%!3'-:)%)!*(!B$-#!)%-*)#R!D)3M$#%!3'-:)$'0%!)$#%-!6*:B7!+$M%!#*!A%!+3<+%)!#*!0*M%)!#+%!0+$)3#C!*)!:'0*&D%'-$#%7!0$)%!D)*M37%7!(*)!#+%!$7:B#-!6+*!%'7!:D!3'!+*-D3#$B-!*)!':)-3'<!+*&%-!63#+*:#!3'-:)$'0%4!!

! G%730$37!-D%'73'<!*'!B*'<2#%)&!0$)%!-%)M30%-!(*)!$BB!%')*BB%%-!$00*:'#%7!(*)!5=4L!D%)0%'#!*(!$BB!D)*<)$&!-D%'73'<!(*)!-%)M30%!3'!@>=>R!$00*)73'<!#*!#+%!h$3-%)!1*&&3--3*'!*'!G%730$37!$'7!#+%!J'3'-:)%74!,+%!1%'#%)!(*)!G%730$)%!m!G%730$37!"%)M30%-!\1G"]!?0#:$)C!D*3'#-!*:#!#+$#R!S?-!#+%!':&A%)!*(!D%*DB%!$<%!-3Q#C2(3M%!*)!*B7%)!3'0)%$-%-!a!$'7!%-D%03$BBC!#+%!':&A%)!*(!#+*-%!*M%)!$<%!%3<+#C2(3M%!a!#+%)%!3-!$!0*))%-D*'73'<!D)*T%0#%7!3'0)%$-%!3'!#+%!$&*:'#!*(!B*'<2#%)&!0$)%!-D%'73'<R!-3'0%!%B7%)BC!A%'%(303$)3%-!#%'7!#*!:-%!&*)%!B*'<2#%)&!0$)%!#+$'!C*:'<%)!A%'%(303$)3%-4U!!

Page 24: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

@I!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&!/3'$B!F%D*)#!

! G$'C!-#$#%-!+$M%!3'-#3#:#%7!7%B3M%)C!-C-#%&!)%(*)&-!#+$#!)%7:0%!B*'<2#%)&!0$)%!0*-#-!AC!3'0)%$-3'<!#+%!-+$)%!*(!73-$AB%7!$'7!$<3'<!$7:B#-!0$)%7!(*)!3'!#+%3)!+*&%-R!)$#+%)!#+$'!':)-3'<!+*&%-4!,+%-%!)%(*)&-!+$M%!7)$&$#30$BBC!-B*6%7!#+%!$'':$B!0*-#!3'0)%$-%-!$--*03$#%7!63#+!B*'<2#%)&!0$)%4!c*6%M%)R!$-!#+%!D*D:B$#3*'!$<%-R!#+%!0*-#!3&DB30$#3*'-!(*)!#+%!G%730$37!D)*<)$&!(*)!B*'<2#%)&!0$)%!-%)M30%-!-:<<%-#!#+$#!-:A-#$'#3$B!0+$'<%-!$)%!'%%7%7!A*#+!#*!%'-:)%!$00%--!#*!#+%-%!0)3#30$B!0$)%!-%)M30%-!$'7!%'-:)%!#+%!-:-#$3'$A3B3#C!*(!#+%!G%730$37!D)*<)$&4!

! F%(*)&-!#*!#+%!G%730$37!D)*<)$&!$)%!'%0%--$)C!#*!%'-:)%!#+%!D)*<)$&_-!(3'$'03$B!-:-#$3'$A3B3#C4!,+%!0+$BB%'<%!3-!#*!37%'#3(C!)%(*)&-!#+$#!7*!'*#!:'7%)&3'%!#+%!+%$B#+!*:#0*&%-!*(!D**)R!$<3'<R!*)!73-$AB%7!?&%)30$'-4!9'!$773#3*'R!)%(*)&-!&:-#!D)*#%0#!$<$3'-#!-3<'3(30$'#!0*-#-!A%3'<!-+3(#%7!*'#*!D)3M$#%!D$C%)-4!`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e%'-R!#+%!)3-.!#+$#!)%(*)&-!&$C!D*-%!*'!*#+%)!D$C%)-R!$'7!#+%!%0*'*&30!3&D$0#!)%(*)&-!63BB!+$M%!*'!#+%!+%$B#+!0$)%!-C-#%&!*(!#+%!'$#3*'4!!

! G%730$37!3-!?&%)30$_-!-$(%#C!'%#!+%$B#+!0$)%!-C-#%&4!f3M%'!#+%!)%$0+!*(!#+%!D)*<)$&R!G%730$37!0$'!+$M%!$'!%'*)&*:-!3'(B:%'0%!*'!#+%!$DD)*$0+!$'7!D$0%!*(!+%$B#+!0$)%!7%B3M%)C!)%(*)&-!#+$#!D)*&*#%!6%BB'%--R!73-%$-%!D)%M%'#3*'R!$'7!0+)*'30!0$)%!&$'$<%&%'#4!c*6%M%)R!6+3B%!#+%!D)*<)$&!+$-!-:A-#$'#3$B!&$).%#!-+$)%R!3#!3-!'*#!#+%!7*&3'$'#!D$C%)^!#+%)%(*)%R!3#!3-!A*:'7!AC!#+%!'*)&-!*(!#+%!+%$B#+!0$)%!7%B3M%)C!-C-#%&!6)3#!B$)<%4!/%7%)$B!D*B30C!0+$'<%-!#+$#!$00%B%)$#%!#+%!D$0%!*(!)%(*)&-!3'!#+%!+%$B#+!0$)%!7%B3M%)C!&$).%#DB$0%!$((%0#3'<!D)3M$#%!D$C%)-!$-!6%BB!$-!G%730$)%!0$'!A%'%(3#!#+%!G%730$37!D)*<)$&4!!

89,+/M%&5"(,#@/"2#&$+89,+/M%&5"(,#@/"2#&$+89,+/M%&5"(,#@/"2#&$+89,+/M%&5"(,#@/"2#&$+####P%&5"(%3P%&5"(%3P%&5"(%3P%&5"(%3####E5%3"6B+E5%3"6B+E5%3"6B+E5%3"6B+####"(#>+)50%5)"(#>+)50%5)"(#>+)50%5)"(#>+)50%5)####,+%!,$-.!/*)0%!D$)#'%)%7!63#+!#+%!?BB3$'0%!(*)!c%$B#+!F%(*)&!$'7!#+%!"1?X!(*:'7$#3*'!#*!D)%-%'#!#+%!X$#3*'$B!H3$B*<:%!*'!G%730$37!$#!#+%!E$)A$)$!Y*)7$'!1*'(%)%'0%!1%'#%)!*(!#+%!h$3-%)!/$&3BC!/*:'7$#3*'4!?7M3-*)C!E*$)7!&%&A%)!Y*-%D+!1$B3($'*!6$-!#+%!0*'M%'%)4!"%0)%#$)C!1$B3($'*R!6+*!6*).%7!*'!#+%!*)3<3'$B!#%$&!3'!#+%!Y*+'-*'!$7&3'3-#)$#3*'!)%-D*'-3AB%!(*)!0)%$#3'<!G%730$37R!$--%--%7!#+%!-#$#%!*(!+%$B#+!0$)%!3'!?&%)30$V!@>!D%)0%'#!*(!?&%)30$'-!$)%!3'-:)%7!#+)*:<+!G%730$37R!63#+!-D%'73'<!$'7!%')*BB&%'#!3'0)%$-3'<!AC!5P>!D%)0%'#!$'7!5>>!D%)0%'#R!)%-D%0#3M%BCR!-3'0%!=g8L4!,+%!-%0)%#$)C!6$)'%7V!

Z+-"&)-$H)#*-+&'$]#:+%.+:$".*$+291&<#:$-"#$(+,#$#69#%-.'%8$.':$H).(+-8$&,$(+,#$&,$<)('#1.3(#$B2#1+%.'*$,&1$:#%.:#*;$.':$@+-"&)-$*&2#$*)3*-.'-+<#$%".'4#*$-&$"&@$-"#$91&41.2$+*$,)':#:;$+-*$1#.%"$.':$+29.%-$%&)(:$3#$)':#12+'#:5$

"%0)%#$)C!1$B3($'*!73)%0#%7!#+%!73-0:--3*'!#+)*:<+!#+)%%!D*#%'#3$B!-*B:#3*'-V!!

! c%$B#+!1$)%!H%B3M%)C!F%(*)&-^!! /:'73'<!F%(*)&-^!$'7!!! ?7&3'3-#)$#3M%!F%(*)&-4!!

H%A$#%!(*0:-%7!*'!*D#3*'-!(*)!+*6!#+%!(%7%)$B!<*M%)'&%'#!0$'!$00%B%)$#%!0*-#!-$M3'<!D)$0#30%-!#+$#!D)*&*#%!3&D)*M%7!+%$B#+!0$)%!b:$B3#C!$'7!+%$B#+!*:#0*&%-R!*D#3*'-!(*)!#+%!(%7%)$B!$'7!-#$#%!(*0:-!$'7!$0#3*'!#*!$77)%--!#+%!0*-#!7)3M%)-!*(!#+%!&*-#!%QD%'-3M%!%')*BB%%-!6+3B%!3&D)*M3'<!#+%3)!+%$B#+!*:#0*&%-4!

Page 25: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&&&&/3'$B!F%D*)#!

@L

c%$B#+!0$)%!-D%'73'<!$-!$!-+$)%!*(!<)*--!7*&%-#30!D)*7:0#!\fHK]!+$-!<)*6'!()*&!$A*:#!P!D%)0%'#!3'!=gPP!#*!$A*:#!=;!D%)0%'#!3'!@>=>4!G%730$37!3'!#+$#!-$&%!D%)3*7!$00*:'#-!(*)!$!)3-%!()*&!B%--!#+$'!=!D%)0%'#!3'!=gPP!#*!@48!D%)0%'#!*(!fHK!3'!@>=>4!

I"(6I"(6I"(6I"(6QQQQ!+/2#;+/M50+,#%()#;BHH"/&,!+/2#;+/M50+,#%()#;BHH"/&,!+/2#;+/M50+,#%()#;BHH"/&,!+/2#;+/M50+,#%()#;BHH"/&,####,+%!J4"4!"%'$#%!1*&&3--3*'!*'!d*'<2,%)&!1$)%R!0+$3)%7!AC!H)4!E):0%!1+%)'*(R!0+3%(!%Q%0:#3M%!*((30%)!*(!#+%!"1?X!/*:'7$#3*'R!3--:%7!3#-!(3'$B!)%D*)#!*'!"%D#%&A%)!5>R!@>=54!!

,+%!M3-3*'!*(!#+%!1*&&3--3*'!3'!)%<$)7!#*!-%)M30%!7%B3M%)C!3-R!S?!&*)%!)%-D*'-3M%R!3'#%<)$#%7R!D%)-*'20%'#%)%7R!$'7!(3-0$BBC!-:-#$3'$AB%!B*'<2#%)&!-%)M30%-!$'7!-:DD*)#-!\d,""]!7%B3M%)C!-C-#%&!#+$#!%'-:)%-!D%*DB%!0$'!$00%--!b:$B3#C!-%)M30%-!3'!-%##3'<-!#+%C!0+**-%4U!!

W3#+!)%<$)7!#*!G%730$37R!#+%!1*&&3--3*'!(*:'7!#+$#R!SG%730$37!3-!$!0)3#30$B!-$(%#C!'%#!D)*<)$&R!A:#!3#!3-!'*#!7%-3<'%7!#*!&%%#!#+%!d,""!'%%7-!*(!$!73M%)-%!D*D:B$#3*'4U!,+%!1*&&3--3*'!6$-!'*#!$AB%!#*!$<)%%!*'!$!-3'<B%!)%0*&&%'7$#3*'!(*)!(:#:)%!(3'$'03'<!*(!d,""R!A:#!D)*M37%7!#6*!$B#%)'$#3M%!D$#+-4!W+3B%!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!7*%-!'*#!%'7*)-%!#+%!)%0*&&%'7$#3*'-!*(!#+%!1*&&3--3*'R!3#!A%B3%M%-!#+$#!#+%3)!#+*:<+#(:B!$DD)*$0+!#*!$'$BCe3'<!#+%!3'0)%$-3'<BC!%QD%'-3M%!d,""!3--:%-R!%-D%03$BBC!3'!)%<$)7!#*!-#$#%!G%730$37!*AB3<$#3*'-R!6$))$'#-!-%)3*:-!0*'-37%)$#3*'!AC!1*'<)%--!$'7!#+%!$7&3'3-#)$#3*'4!

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

! !

Page 26: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

@P!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&!/3'$B!F%D*)#!

)'*9$3,6'*&!,+%!,$-.!/*)0%!)%0*<'3e%-!#+%!73((30:B#3%-!3'+%)%'#!3'!<*M%)'&%'#!0+$'<%4!9#!$B-*!)%0*<'3e%-!#+%!:)<%'0C!(*)!0+$'<%4!,+%!D)3&$)C!)%$-*'!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%!6$-!0)%$#%7!3-!#+$#!3'-:((303%'#!$##%'#3*'!3-!73)%0#%7!#*!#+%!(3-0$B!3&D%)$#3M%-!*(!#+%!-#$#%-4!"#$#%-R!$'7!#+%!B*0$B!<*M%)'&%'#-!#+%C!0)%$#%R!$)%!0+$)<%7!63#+!D)*M373'<!#+%!&*-#!3&D*)#$'#!7*&%-#30!<*M%)'&%'#!-%)M30%-4!Z%#!3&D*)#$'#!7%03-3*'-!*'!#+%!'$#3*'$B!B%M%B!*(#%'!7*!'*#!0*'-37%)!#+%!3&D$0#!*(!#+*-%!7%03-3*'-!*'!#+%3)!$A3B3#C!#*!7%B3M%)!#+*-%!-%)M30%-4!

X%M%)#+%B%--R!-#$#%-!0$'!3&D)*M%!#+%3)!$A3B3#C!#*!D)*M37%!-%)M30%-!$'7!%'+$'0%!#+%3)!(3'$'03$B!$'7!(3-0$B!7%03-3*'&$.3'<4!"#)3M3'<!(*)!-#):0#:)$BBC!A$B$'0%7R!$00):$B!A$-%7!A:7<%#-!6+%'!$DD)*D)3$#%!$'7!D)*M373'<!0B%$)!$'$BC-%-!*(!#+%!(3-0$B!3--:%-!#+%C!0*'()*'#!0$'!D%)&3#!-#$#%-!#*!:'7%)-#$'7!$'7!)%0*<'3e%!#+%!0+$BB%'<%-!#+%C!&:-#!-*BM%4!,+%!,$-.!/*)0%!*:#B3'%-!#+*-%!0+$BB%'<%-!$'7!&$.%-!)%0*&&%'7$#3*'-!#*!$77)%--!#+%&4;!

!

! !

Page 27: 2014-01-06 Final Report Draftgraphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/20140115... · 2018-01-26 · 2014-01-06 Final Report Draft ... 8!;!!

!!

-%.'/+,&'(&+0%&1+"+%&2345%+&)/6,6,&!",7&8'/9%&&&&&&&/3'$B!F%D*)#!

@8

?*4*'+%,&&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!=!! K$D%)-!$)%!$M$3B$AB%!*'!#+%!,$-.!/*)0%_-!W%A!-3#%V!6664-#$#%A:7<%#0)3-3-4*)<4!

@!! 6664-#$#%A:7<%#0)3-3-4*)<!!

5!! ?00*:'#$A3B3#C!$'7!,)$'-D$)%'0C!3'!E:7<%#3'<!$'7!/3'$'03$B!F%D*)#3'<!+$7!A%%'!0*M%)%7!%Q#%'-3M%BC!3'!#+%!Y:BC!@>=@!F%D*)#!*(!#+%!"#$#%!E:7<%#!1)3-3-!,$-.!/*)0%!$'7!3#!6$-!$<)%%7!#+$#!$!H3$B*<:%!6$-!'*#!'%%7%7!3'!#+3-!$)%$4!

I!! d:0C!H$7$C$'!$'7!H*'$B7!Y4!E*C7R!>-.-#*$B1#$U&-$a)-$&,$-"#$Z&&:*$Y#*9+-#$>-1&'4$?#<#')#$b.+'*$+'$-"#$0&)1-"$c).1-#1R!"#$#%!F%M%':%!F%D*)#!ng=!\?BA$'CR!XZV!,+%!X%B-*'!?4!F*0.%(%BB%)!9'-#3#:#%!*(!f*M%)'&%'#]R!+##DVOO)*0.3'-#4*)<O'%6-)**&O)%M%':%o)%D*)#-O@>=5O@>=52>I2@I2"FFog=4D7(4!!!

L!! "%%!C':#1,)':#:$M#'*+&'$M1&2+*#*R!W+3#%!K$D%)!D)%D$)%7!AC!-#$((!*(!#+%!"#$#%!E:7<%#!1)3-3-!,$-.!/*)0%!(*)!#+%!H3$B*<:%!*'!J'7%)(:'7%7!K%'-3*'!K)*&3-%-R!+%B7!$#!#+%!/%7%)$B!F%-%)M%!E$'.!*(!X%6!Z*).!*'!?D)3B!=gR!@>=54!

P!! H*''$!1**D%)R!]##-+'4$-"#$=',1.*-1)%-)1#$=29#1.-+<#^$B'$B,,&1:.3(#$M(.'$-&$M)-$B2#1+%.'*$E.%/$-&$Z&1/$?#3)+(:+'4$a)1$U.-+&'X*$=',1.*-1)%-)1#!\W$-+3'<#*'R!H1V!1%'#%)!(*)!?&%)30$'!K)*<)%--R!/%A):$)C!@>=@]R!+##DVOO6664$&%)30$'D)*<)%--4*)<O3--:%-O#%0+'*B*<CO)%D*)#O@>=@O>@O=PO==>P;O&%%#3'<2#+%23'()$-#):0#:)%23&D%)$#3M%O4!

8!! ,+%!?&%)30$'!"*03%#C!*(!13M3B!N'<3'%%)-R!IJKL$?#9&1-$D.1:$,&1$B2#1+%.X*$=',1.*-1)%-)1#!\F%-#*'R![?V!,+%!?&%)30$'!"*03%#C!*(!13M3B!N'<3'%%)-R!G$)0+!@>=5]R!+##DVOO66643'()$-#):0#:)%)%D*)#0$)74*)<O4!

;!! ,$-.!/*)0%!?7M3-*)C!E*$)7!&%&A%)!Y*-%D+!?4!1$B3($'*R!Y)4R!6*:B7!$77!#+3-!#+*:<+#!#*!#+%!0*'0B:-3*'V!S9'!$00*&&*7$#3'<!#+%3)!(3'$'03$B!73((30:B#3%-!#+%!-#$#%-!-+*:B7!A%!D$)#30:B$)BC!$##%'#3M%!#*!#+%!'%%7-!*(!#+%!&*-#!M:B'%)$AB%!3'!*:)!-*03%#C!$'7!#*!)%7:03'<!#+%!M$-#!3'0*&%!3'%b:$B3#C!#+$#!+$-!<)*6'!B3.%!Y$0.p-!A%$'-#$B.!*M%)!#+%!D$-#!#6*!*)!#+)%%!7%0$7%-4U!

!