35
2016 Tennessee High School Mock Trial Case Materials Copyright 2015, Tennessee Bar Association Young Lawyers Division 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL COMPETITION CASE MATERIALS IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR WESTON COUNTY, TENNESSEE AT SHRADERVILLE ASHTON STEPINGHUF, Plaintiff, Case No. 15cv0929 v. Jury Demanded THOROBERN APPLIANCES, INC., Defendant. EXHIBITS The following names are meant for identification purposes only. This list is not a stipulation, and teams still must rely on the rules of evidence to have any proposed exhibit admitted into evidence. EXHIBIT A Photographs of the Horse Trailer, postfire EXHIBIT B Photographs of the refrigerator removed from the Horse Trailer EXHIBIT C Letter from Thorobern Appliances, Inc. risk manager EXHIBIT D Notice of Recall sent from Thorobern Appliances, Inc. to National Highway Traffic Safety Administration EXHIBIT E Emails between Pat Xiulet and Sam Jones EXHIBIT F List of recall notices sent EXHIBIT G Text messages between Ashton Stepinghuf and Ryan Atwood EXHIBIT H Blaer Sondottir curriculum vitae EXHIBIT I Tommie Fehler curriculum vitae EXHIBIT J Thorobern Appliances Inc. internal investigation report

2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

2016 Tennessee High School Mock Trial Case Materials Copyright 2015, Tennessee Bar Association Young Lawyers Division  

2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL COMPETITION 

CASE MATERIALS  

 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR WESTON COUNTY, TENNESSEE 

AT SHRADERVILLE 

ASHTON STEPINGHUF,   

       Plaintiff,   

  Case No. 15‐cv‐0929 

v.  Jury Demanded 

   

THOROBERN APPLIANCES, INC.,   

       Defendant.   

 

 EXHIBITS 

 

   The following names are meant for identification purposes only. This list is not a stipulation, and teams still must rely on the rules of evidence to have any proposed exhibit admitted into evidence.  EXHIBIT A  Photographs of the Horse Trailer, post‐fire EXHIBIT B  Photographs of the refrigerator removed from the Horse Trailer EXHIBIT C  Letter from Thorobern Appliances, Inc. risk manager EXHIBIT D  Notice of Recall sent from Thorobern Appliances, Inc. to National Highway Traffic 

Safety Administration EXHIBIT E  Emails between Pat Xiulet and Sam Jones EXHIBIT F  List of recall notices sent EXHIBIT G  Text messages between Ashton Stepinghuf and Ryan Atwood EXHIBIT H  Blaer Sondottir curriculum vitae EXHIBIT I  Tommie Fehler curriculum vitae EXHIBIT J  Thorobern Appliances Inc. internal investigation report 

Page 2: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL
kristen.corn
Exhibit
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
A
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
Page 3: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
Area of fire origin on right side of trailer, in area of refrigerator
Page 4: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
View of condenser condition
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
Close-up view of ruptured refrigerant line located beneath condenser
kristen.corn
Exhibit
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
B
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
Page 5: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
View of burn patterns on side of refrigerator after removal from cabinet
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
Same as above photo, from opposite side
Page 6: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

THOROBERN APPLIANCES, INC. 1221 Liten Blvd.

Manning, Tennessee 38107

March 1, 2015

Ashton Stepinghuf 521 Stepinghuf Hollow Dobbsville, Tennessee 37139 RE: Claimant: Ashton Stepinghuf

Date of Loss: December 20, 2014 Product: Refrigerator, Model JNY, Serial NO. 8675E09 Dear Ashton Stepinghuf: I write today regarding the above-identified loss. Thorobern Appliances, Inc. has thoroughly investigated your fire loss that occurred on or about December 20, 2014, involving a Thorobern Refrigerator through personal investigation, interviews, and various experts. Our investigation is now complete.

The investigation revealed that Thorobern Appliances, Inc. manufactured the refrigerator in your horse trailer, Model JNY, Serial No. 8675E09. Your Thorobern refrigerator was subject to a voluntary recall. However, Thorobern Appliances, Inc. sent proper notice of the voluntary recall to all purchasers of the recalled models.

After careful review and investigation of your trailer and the Thorobern

refrigerator removed from your trailer, Thorobern Appliances, Inc. has concluded that the fire was not the result of a manufacturing defect. The investigation revealed that the fire resulted from an intentional alteration to the refrigerator. In fact, it appears that a deliberate puncture of the refrigerant piping caused a coolant to leak. The coolant, in turn, was ignited by the pilot light, thus causing the resulting fire. Based upon our investigation, we are unable to offer you any compensation for the loss of your Thorobern refrigerator or horse trailer as a result of the fire on or about December 20, 2014. Sincerely,

Cara Stylvis Thorobern Appliances, Inc.

Risk Management Department

kristen.corn
Exhibit
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
C
Page 7: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

THOROBERN APPLIANCES, INC. 1221 Liten Blvd

Manning, Tennessee 38107

December 1, 2011

VIA CERTIFIED MAIL, Ret. Rec. Req. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration ATTN: Recall Administration 1200 New Jersey Ave. SE Washington, D.C. 20590 RE: NHTSA RECALL # 08A-330 Dear Sir or Madam: Please find enclosed a Notification of Defect which Thorobern Recreational Appliances, Inc. is submitting pursuant to 49 C.F.R., Part 573.6. We are continuing preparations of media documents for your approval and are in the process of customer acquisition lists, as well as OEM and dealer records. Once these documents are completed, they will be submitted under seal and request for confidentiality to your lead counsel for approval. Once approval has been obtained, all end users and distributors will be alerted via Notice of Voluntary Recall. The remedy anticipated for this Recall will be replacement, at local distributors and retail outlets, of all affected product components, including but not limited to replacement of the entire cooling unit which necessarily includes replacement of the welded coolant coils. As previously noted, this is the first recall campaign initiated for the affected products class. In the event this recall campaign requires expansion, appropriate notification will be provided and approval requested. Thank you for your consideration. Respectfully,

Sam Jones Thorobern Appliances, Inc. Vice President and Director of Design and Product Safety /prx Enclosures: as stated   

kristen.corn
Exhibit
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
D
Page 8: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

POTENTIAL DEFECT NOTIFICATION Pursuant to 49 C.F.R.§573 

 Thorobern Recreational Appliances, Inc. (“Thorobern”) is a manufacturer and supplier of original equipment for recreational vehicles. Thorobern has determined that a potential defect may exist in the items of motor vehicle equipment listed below. Thorobern is submitting this notification of a potential safety related defect to the National Transportation Safety Administration in accordance with the applicable provisions of 49 CFR Part 573.  Thorobern is a Deleware Corporation with its principal place of business at 1221 Blue Suede Shoes Blvd in Memphis, Tennessee. The Thorobern products affected by this notice were manufactured by Thorobern at its manufacturing facilities in Sweden.   The Thorobern products which may contain a potential defect are two‐door refrigerators manufactured between March 1, 2007 and January 31, 2011. The potentially affected refrigerators all are gas powered JNY Model 8675E09.  The potential safety related defect is associated with the cooling unit of the refrigerator. A fractional percentage of potentially affected units have experienced a fatigue crack or rupture in the area of the welds in the coolant coils within the cooling unit. A fatigue crack or rupture may allow flammable coolant to escape the coolant coils and come into contact with the ignition pilot lite located within the unit, which could potentially create a risk of fire or explosion.   For the population of product with the model and serial ranges shown above, a potential inconsistent weld process may have contributed to the weld fatigue resulting in a crack or rupture to the welds along the coolant coils.   Increased market demand required a new production line with new state‐of‐the‐art technology during this affected time period. This improvement in technology and the streamlining of the production weld process significantly reduced the variability of the coolant seam welds and heating processes. This proprietary weld and heating process has now been phased out and all units in inventory left on hand have been destroyed or scrapped.  Thorobern estimates that the failure rate on the units undergoing the potentially problematic weld process is less than 7%. There have been no incidents involving death reported to date relative to this product safety risk.   This notice was prepared by and inquiries should be addressed to:  Sam Jones Vice President and Director of Design and Product Safety 1221 Liten Blvd. Manning, Tennessee 38107  

Page 9: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

  RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED:  THOROBERN APPLIANCES, INC.   Sam Jones Vice President and Director of Design and Product Safety 1221 Liten Blvd. Manning, Tennessee 38107  DATED:         

Page 10: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Pat Xiulet From: Sam Jones <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, January 24, 2011 11:21 AM To: Pat Xiulet Cc: Cara Stylvis Subject: Re: Notices As we already discussed, we are revisiting the method of delivery of the notices. As we also already discussed, I will keep you posted. Don’t call me, I’ll call you. Thanks. Sam

On Mon, Jan 24, 2011 at 10:12 AM, Pat Xiulet <[email protected]> wrote:

Sam, I only got thru the Hs on the list. Dont we have to do all of them? I still have a TON to do. Lmk. Thx.

PRX

On Thurs, Jan 20, 2011 at 04:15 PM, Pat Xiulet <[email protected]> wrote:

Sam, when can I get back to the list? Has the mailing acct been restarted? I tried to send a letter but there was no money in the postage acct. I just sent out up to H. Have a great weekend.

Pat

On Mon, Jan 17, 2011 at 03:17 PM, Sam Jones <[email protected]> wrote:

Pat, Until further notice, please suspend sending out the notices. We are looking into a more appropriate way to send the letters. Regards, Sam

Sam Jones Vice President and Director of Design and Product Safety Thorobern Appliances, Inc. 1221 Liten Blvd. Manning, Tennessee 37771 **Please consider the environment before printing this email**

kristen.corn
Exhibit
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
E
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
Page 11: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Mo

de

l JNY

86

75

E09

Re

call No

tices

Tho

rob

ern Se

rial #First

LastStre

etA

dd

ress

City

StateZip

Co

de

Date

 Sen

t

  82

1 8

03 8

6 1

01

2 6

53 2

Nan

cyA

barca

35

61 M

on

roe A

venu

eFo

rt Myers

FL3

39

01

1/5

/20

12

  75

1 5

F9 6

5 6

40

4 6

38 9

Lou

iseA

bell

45

03 R

ivend

ell Drive

Akro

nO

H4

43

07

1/5

/20

12

  27

3 5

85 6

9 6

34

1 6

89 7

Edd

ieA

costa

33

19 Tu

rnp

ike Drive

Hu

ntsville

AL

35

80

21

/5/2

01

2

  23

Y 1Y2

 98 9

75

2 1

74 8

Tho

mas

Ad

am1

20 Yo

rkie Lane

Saint M

arysG

A3

15

58

1/5

/20

12

  18

1 Y9

8 8

5 5

02

9 1

75 7

Do

roth

yA

dam

s3

77

9 K

imb

erly Way

Allen

dale

MI

49

40

11

/5/2

01

2

  95

3 9

59 8

7 6

92

8 3

02 8

Pau

lA

dam

s5

09 Q

uarry D

riveM

idlan

d C

ityA

L3

63

50

1/5

/20

12

  91

2 5

05 3

1 2

14

9 1

00 3

Ch

arlesA

dam

s3

71

6 D

avis Lane

Den

verC

O8

02

39

1/5

/20

12

  Y91 7

03 1

8 7

59

8 2

61 8

Mich

aelA

dam

s4

15

4 Ju

nip

er Drive

Brecken

ridge

MI

48

61

51

/5/2

01

2

  23

2 2

92 1

5 4

13

7 6

60 2

Mary

Ad

ams

42

57 V

alley View

 Drive

West R

oxb

ury

MA

02

13

21

/5/2

01

2

  03

0 7

52 0

0 5

23

2 4

89 1

Do

nn

aA

dam

s3

54 W

est StreetG

rand R

apid

sM

I4

95

03

1/5

/20

12

  15

9 7

22 0

5 0

85

4 4

40 9

Han

nah

Agu

irre1

27

9 Tree To

p Lan

eEasto

nP

A1

80

42

1/5

/20

12

  92

0 4

29 1

4 1

67

4 0

68 9

Lucy

Akers

95 C

olem

an A

venu

eO

ceansid

eC

A9

20

54

1/5

/20

12

  56

A 2

37 4

4 2

19

9 1

68 4

Ken

neth

Akin

35

1 R

ogu

ski Ro

adSh

revepo

rtLA

71

10

11

/5/2

01

2

  Y33 8

43 7

2 1

29

8 6

31 1

Ro

bin

Alb

recht

76

4 O

liverio D

riveW

ichita

KS

67

20

21

/5/2

01

2

  75

7 2

24 3

5 0

30

1 2

39 7

Ken

neth

Ald

ana

20

33 P

leasant H

ill Ro

adLake W

orth

FL3

34

63

1/5

/20

12

  78

5 0

75 3

9 7

22

0 3

64 5

Lorrain

eA

lday

32

02 R

oseb

ud A

venu

eW

ilmo

tA

R7

16

76

1/5

/20

12

  3F0 3

F9 7

9 4

88

3 2

01 0

Rach

elA

lexand

er4

26

7 P

heasan

t Rid

ge Ro

adPh

iladelp

hia

PA

19

10

31

/5/2

01

2

  58

7 9

5A 9

3 4

31

3 8

46 7

Leann

aA

lford

29

31 A

dam

sville Ro

adH

arlingen

TX7

85

50

1/5

/20

12

  62

7 F4

8 6

6 5

14

1 5

63 7

Leon

ardA

lford

28

00 R

osew

oo

d C

ou

rtR

och

esterM

N5

59

04

1/5

/20

12

  36

2 2

38 7

9 2

06

7 7

59 7

Raym

on

dA

llan4

07

9 Tim

bercrest R

oad

Eagle River

AK

99

57

71

/5/2

01

2

  53

2 9

44 6

3 0

13

0 8

06 5

Valerie

Allen

12

9 R

accoo

n R

un

SeattleW

A9

81

01

1/5

/20

12

  91

2 7

73 1

2 7

30

6 3

46 0

EllaA

llen4

61

8 Lib

erty Aven

ue

Santa A

na

CA

92

70

51

/5/2

01

2

  35

0 6

90 7

2 1

24

3 9

31 3

JessieA

llen1

88

6 P

eaceful Lan

eC

leveland

OH

44

11

31

/5/2

01

2

  02

7 6

78 1

9 8

60

6 6

95 0

LisaA

llen1

71

4 C

erullo

 Ro

adLo

uisville

KY

40

29

91

/5/2

01

2

  62

5 F3

6 0

4 8

17

4 9

93 1

Lorrain

eA

lon

zo4

2 Lo

st Creek R

oad

Kin

g Of P

russia

PA

19

40

61

/5/2

01

2

  77

9 5

Y2 0

7 0

07

3 9

63 0

Ro

nd

aA

ltamiran

o2

74

6 P

op

lar Aven

ue

San D

iegoC

A9

21

03

1/5

/20

12

  71

8 9

51 2

9 3

26

3 6

82 8

JerryA

nd

ers3

87 R

ichiso

n D

riveSh

eph

erdM

T5

90

79

1/5

/20

12

kristen.corn
Exhibit
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
F
Page 12: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Mo

de

l JNY

86

75

E09

Re

call No

tices

Tho

rob

ern Se

rial #First

LastStre

etA

dd

ress

City

StateZip

Co

de

Date

 Sen

t

  99

F 64

1 7

9 9

62

4 6

48 3

Tod

dA

nd

erson

44

96 Su

mn

er StreetG

arden

aC

A9

02

48

1/5

/20

12

  08

8 0

49 5

7 3

94

0 8

30 3

Rita

An

dreas

46

82 B

yrd Lan

eA

lbu

qu

erqu

eN

M8

71

02

1/5

/20

12

  33

3 8

62 0

8 2

00

3 1

96 8

Od

essaA

ngelo

30

46 Ech

o Lan

eK

alamazo

oM

I4

90

07

1/5

/20

12

  58

1 F6

5 0

0 1

51

8 6

75 9

Margaret

Arago

n1

18 Farn

um R

oad

New

 York

NY

10

00

71

/5/2

01

2

  26

1 V

82 4

7 4

03

3 0

18 2

Josep

hA

rdis

46

27 B

row

n Street

Waln

ut C

reekC

A9

45

96

1/5

/20

12

  24

4 7

V4 1

2 2

29

6 6

73 5

Ken

neth

Arm

stron

g2

61

1 M

yra StreetN

orth

 Kin

gstow

nR

I0

28

52

1/5

/20

12

  01

7 Y6

5 4

5 6

12

2 9

59 4

Josh

ua

Arm

stron

g4

03

9 B

righto

n C

ircle Ro

adSain

t Clo

ud

MN

56

30

31

/5/2

01

2

  29

3 6

47 3

1 0

95

4 2

69 2

Helen

Arn

old

35

11 Fo

rmu

la Lane

Dallas

TX7

52

07

1/5

/20

12

  9W

8 2

Y9 4

3 3

48

9 4

85 6

Julie

Atkin

son

32

58 Felo

sa Drive

Ab

ilene

TX7

96

02

1/5

/20

12

  97

6 0

A7 9

0 4

89

5 4

01 4

JeanA

twell

24

29 Elkview

 Drive

Jup

iterFL

33

47

81

/5/2

01

2

  20

5 1

79 6

6 5

71

3 1

08 9

Nath

aniel

Au

gustu

s1

66

7 R

om

ines M

ill Ro

adA

rlingto

nTX

76

01

11

/5/2

01

2

  89

9 6

16 2

8 2

92

9 3

39 9

TerrellA

ustin

11

26 H

arter StreetLim

aO

H4

58

01

1/5

/20

12

  F52 6

56 5

7 1

18

4 9

96 1

Marla

Avilla

37

83 W

oo

drid

ge Lane

Mem

ph

isTN

38

11

61

/5/2

01

2

  Y73 V

12 1

7 8

55

2 9

26 3

Ch

risB

abb

42

16 U

nio

n Street

SeattleW

A9

81

18

1/5

/20

12

  87

7 3

30 7

8 3

94

7 7

03 7

Carl

Bain

24

38 R

eeves StreetA

pp

leton

WI

54

91

11

/5/2

01

2

  91

2 8

2F 4

7 1

14

6 7

84 2

Caro

lB

aird4

00

3 C

hu

rch Street

Flush

ing

NY

11

35

41

/5/2

01

2

  67

1 A

67 0

2 3

37

6 0

75 3

Herm

anB

aker4

38

9 M

assachu

setts Aven

Ad

elph

iD

C2

07

83

1/5

/20

12

  76

1 8

52 8

9 5

22

1 7

96 9

Geo

rgeB

aker2

02

0 B

aker Aven

ue

Dallas

TX7

52

01

1/5

/20

12

  92

4 0

49 9

5 2

88

3 2

79 9

Jacob

Baker

46

04 B

riarhill Lan

eM

edin

aO

H4

42

56

1/5

/20

12

  80

9 1

99 8

7 1

42

9 6

73 3

Kristy

Baker

22

48 D

eer Rid

ge Drive

Mo

ntclair

NJ

07

04

21

/5/2

01

2

  85

6 1

05 6

1 3

82

6 7

64 7

Belin

da

Balke

37

03 C

oven

try Co

urt

Gu

lfpo

rtM

S3

95

01

1/5

/20

12

  90

3 3

91 5

7 4

61

8 8

13 4

Mich

elleB

allard2

19

5 Lyn

n A

venu

eScan

din

aviaW

I5

49

77

1/5

/20

12

  A2

5 3

37 0

2 7

84

6 1

50 0

SteveB

allentin

e2

97

6 Flo

rence Street

TylerTX

75

70

21

/5/2

01

2

  4V

6 3

A8 2

1 7

11

6 4

75 6

Lind

aB

and

y4

52 A

tha D

riveB

utto

nw

illow

CA

93

20

61

/5/2

01

2

  94

8 1

E1 8

3 6

65

2 5

85 5

SaraB

anks

14

09 C

linto

n Street

Ph

iladelp

hia

PA

19

10

81

/5/2

01

2

  A3

7 3

37 4

9 7

88

6 2

90 8

Dan

iB

arbo

ur

46

08 H

ickory R

idge D

riveLas V

egasN

V8

91

09

1/5

/20

12

  46

8 8

37 1

6 6

33

9 9

20 4

SteveB

arker1

85

8 H

all Valley D

riveElkin

sW

V2

62

41

1/5

/20

12

  99

8 2

27 9

5 7

13

0 6

67 8

Steph

enB

arnette

95

5 H

ickory Lan

eW

ashin

gton

DC

20

00

51

/5/2

01

2

Page 13: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Mo

de

l JNY

86

75

E09

Re

call No

tices

Tho

rob

ern Se

rial #First

LastStre

etA

dd

ress

City

StateZip

Co

de

Date

 Sen

t

  Y93 5

A5 3

6 2

06

9 1

00 9

SarahB

arrera4

72

8 Sh

ort Street

Au

stinTX

78

72

91

/5/2

01

2

  34

5 9

45 6

9 9

74

4 8

45 8

Cyn

thia

Bartelt

46

95 C

and

lelight D

riveB

aytow

nTX

77

52

01

/5/2

01

2

  F04 9

V3 7

1 4

59

2 2

35 5

Harley

Barth

45

52 Stu

tler Lane

ErieP

A1

65

01

1/5

/20

12

  99

E 76

F 39 4

28

0 3

49 4

Tabith

aB

arthel

91 P

enn

sylvania A

venu

eLakew

oo

dN

J0

87

01

1/5

/20

12

  57

7 1

58 4

1 7

62

9 2

79 9

Carrie

Barto

n3

09

9 Tim

ber R

idge R

oad

Citru

s Heigh

tsC

A9

56

10

1/5

/20

12

  W3

3 1

15 7

7 6

40

2 5

14 8

Lawren

ceB

atey2

89 P

allet StreetYo

nkers

NY

10

70

11

/5/2

01

2

  E77 Y5

3 8

8 5

42

6 2

40 1

Brian

Batiste

68

8 R

ockw

ell Lane

Elizabeth

 City

NC

27

90

91

/5/2

01

2

  8Y1

 04

0 6

2 1

42

5 9

42 1

David

Beach

46

95 Skin

ner H

ollo

w R

oadB

utte Falls

OR

97

52

21

/5/2

01

2

  07

8 V

12 5

5 1

99

6 0

23 3

Lavon

aB

edgo

od

37

54 A

shcraft C

ou

rtSan

 Diego

CA

92

11

11

/5/2

01

2

  88

6 E5

4 2

6 2

30

3 7

24 6

Jorge

Beeb

e3

69

0 Terry Lan

eM

elbo

urn

eFL

32

93

51

/5/2

01

2

  83

4 7

9E 8

2 5

47

9 5

23 7

Mary

Belch

er2

20

4 C

han

dler H

ollo

w R

oaG

lensh

awP

A1

51

16

1/5

/20

12

  29

4 8

7E 8

6 4

81

5 0

96 3

An

drew

Bell

16

81 A

rrow

oo

d D

riveJackso

nville

FL3

22

02

1/5

/20

12

  68

7 1

51 1

7 5

50

9 6

54 9

Willie

Bell

31

20 C

amb

ridge D

riveP

ho

enix

AZ

85

02

91

/5/2

01

2

  8E7

 F20 3

0 8

34

2 6

88 7

Tho

mas

Bell

36

12 P

arrill Co

urt

Sou

th B

end

IN4

66

25

1/5

/20

12

  89

0 2

91 5

0 8

49

0 4

75 5

David

Ben

der

45

19 So

uth

side Lan

eLo

s An

gelesC

A9

00

29

1/5

/20

12

  20

5 3

83 6

4 7

55

5 4

23 2

Ho

llyB

enjam

in3

45

7 A

ngie D

riveSan

ta An

aC

A9

27

04

1/5

/20

12

  85

6 7

51 6

2 7

51

7 1

05 5

Kristin

Berg

46

27 B

raxton Street

Vern

on H

illsIL

60

06

11

/5/2

01

2

  04

2 V

53 8

1 4

59

6 1

71 6

Joh

nB

erry1

99

9 R

ed H

awk R

oad

Freepo

rtM

N5

63

31

1/5

/20

12

  36

4 F1

4 5

2 5

28

2 7

72 4

Walter

Bian

co2

46

0 B

uen

a Vista A

venu

eR

oseb

urg

OR

97

47

01

/5/2

01

2

  70

4 5

40 6

8 8

49

5 7

56 6

Ricard

oB

isho

p2

00

2 Fo

rt StreetSeattle

WA

98

10

91

/5/2

01

2

  82

3 5

4A 3

1 9

79

5 0

57 2

Thelm

aB

issett1

43

5 D

riftwo

od R

oad

Oaklan

dC

A9

46

12

1/5

/20

12

  Y02 2

37 1

0 1

33

3 9

37 3

Elizabeth

Blake

10

65 Sp

irit Drive

Po

rt Oran

geFL

32

01

91

/5/2

01

2

  7Y5

 02

0 1

4 7

86

4 8

46 9

Joh

nB

levins

30

70 D

uff A

venu

eSo

uth B

urlin

gton

VT

05

40

31

/5/2

01

2

  9W

5 2

13 7

9 6

62

6 6

30 9

Brian

Blevin

s1

17

7 M

cKin

ley Aven

ue

Byers

CO

80

10

31

/5/2

01

2

  03

W 7

13 3

1 0

35

9 4

79 1

Melissa

Blizzard

25

10 Lau

rel LeeK

ansas C

ityM

O6

41

06

1/5

/20

12

  W5

3 8

82 1

8 9

79

0 5

58 7

Joan

nB

od

dy

40

9 Sh

erwo

od C

ircleLafayette

LA7

05

83

1/5

/20

12

  20

6 9

68 5

7 7

55

3 0

85 4

Reb

eccaB

oggs

30

07 Fo

rmu

la Lane

Dallas

TX7

52

47

1/5

/20

12

  46

4 1

V0 6

9 3

60

6 0

45 3

Tho

mas

Bo

ldu

c3

19

7 Elm

wo

od A

venu

eSco

ttsdale

AZ

85

25

11

/5/2

01

2

Page 14: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Mo

de

l JNY

86

75

E09

Re

call No

tices

Tho

rob

ern Se

rial #First

LastStre

etA

dd

ress

City

StateZip

Co

de

Date

 Sen

t

  4F3 5

70 3

7 1

73

9 2

13 8

JillB

ollin

g2

96

6 Jerry To

th D

riveElm

end

orf

AK

99

50

61

/5/2

01

2

  67

4 6

F8 0

0 6

69

4 9

81 0

Timo

thy

Bo

nd

s1

20

4 A

rchw

oo

d A

venu

eG

lend

oW

Y8

22

13

1/5

/20

12

  68

5 0

32 4

1 2

02

1 6

43 7

Do

risB

on

ner

17

95 Flyn

n Street

Stron

gsvilleO

H4

41

36

1/5

/20

12

  10

0 5

94 8

4 7

16

5 6

96 1

An

ton

iaB

oo

ker2

58

2 W

alnu

t StreetJackso

nM

S3

92

01

1/5

/20

12

  07

2 5

07 1

5 1

06

5 9

13 6

Julie

Bo

oker

47

40 W

alnu

t Hill D

riveC

incin

nati

OH

45

23

61

/5/2

01

2

  43

4 9

02 9

2 6

67

4 1

68 5

JeffB

ou

dreau

55

6 O

ral Lake Ro

adN

avarreM

N5

53

92

1/5

/20

12

  34

5 7

00 2

6 6

92

1 2

50 0

Am

yB

ou

ton

41

15 P

ickens W

ayD

eniso

nTX

75

02

01

/5/2

01

2

  56

A 7

11 2

4 7

10

7 7

91 9

Peter

Bo

wles

19

71 Lo

wn

des H

ill Park R

oBakersfield

CA

93

30

11

/5/2

01

2

  66

8 2

F3 8

2 2

40

7 8

49 4

Carlo

sB

oyes

16

63 Lyn

n O

gden

 Lane

Galvesto

nTX

77

55

01

/5/2

01

2

  77

8 7

09 4

1 7

60

8 4

62 1

JillB

racey4

97

4 B

urto

n A

venu

eM

emp

his

TN3

81

17

1/5

/20

12

  91

4 9

66 5

7 1

91

6 8

84 7

Vau

ghn

Bracy

11

88 D

awso

n D

riveC

abo

tA

R7

20

23

1/5

/20

12

  A6

4 6

05 9

3 9

88

3 6

73 5

Mary

Bragg

97

6 A

nd

y StreetSio

ux Falls

SD5

71

02

1/5

/20

12

  5F0 0

01 3

8 5

61

0 5

34 7

Alexan

der

Bran

ch1

48

7 Tro

user Leg R

oad

Sprin

gfieldM

A0

11

03

1/5

/20

12

  38

5 7

6E 5

2 3

45

0 8

87 8

Maria

Braxto

n4

81

7 W

ilkinso

n C

ou

rtN

orth

 Nap

lesFL

33

96

31

/5/2

01

2

  82

V 7

17 2

9 0

46

6 7

37 9

Mario

Brazell

23

78 M

usgrave Street

Atlan

taG

A3

03

03

1/5

/20

12

  V3

1 4

21 2

5 5

57

7 8

60 3

Maria

Breau

x1

92

0 Sp

irit Drive

Po

rt Oran

geFL

32

01

91

/5/2

01

2

  47

4 E1

8 1

5 9

55

6 7

63 5

EarlB

renn

an3

45

3 B

ingam

on R

oad

Euclid

OH

44

13

21

/5/2

01

2

  34

6 5

02 1

8 6

79

8 9

08 8

Deb

orah

Brew

er2

41 G

eneva Street

Bellero

seN

Y1

14

26

1/5

/20

12

  01

5 4

1Y 9

9 8

78

9 9

63 1

Mich

aelB

rock

25

5 P

arkway D

riveSierra V

istaA

Z8

56

35

1/5

/20

12

  99

1 2

42 8

9 9

20

2 8

64 0

Ro

gerB

rogd

on

13

62 H

arper Street

Kevil

KY

42

05

31

/5/2

01

2

  26

F A4

4 6

5 0

44

8 2

79 6

Dian

aB

roo

ks1

47

0 Fraggle D

riveD

ow

ners G

rove

IL6

05

15

1/5

/20

12

  7F4 7

16 0

3 7

72

5 0

97 0

Justin

Bro

wn

31

53 Ju

nip

er Drive

Ash

leyM

I4

88

06

1/5

/20

12

  23

0 0

58 5

1 5

11

1 4

06 3

Lou

isB

row

n4

24

2 R

yder A

venu

eB

oth

ellW

A9

80

11

1/5

/20

12

  98

A 7

55 4

2 5

94

8 6

84 0

Jeann

etteB

row

n3

40

9 Tree To

p Lan

eG

leno

lden

PA

19

03

61

/5/2

01

2

  27

2 8

2E 2

0 8

92

4 9

70 3

Do

lores

Bro

wn

25

60 R

ockfo

rd R

oad

Ren

oN

V8

95

01

1/5

/20

12

  F94 9

57 4

8 5

21

9 9

89 5

Mary

Bro

wn

35

45 B

ridge A

venu

eLafayette

LA7

05

03

1/5

/20

12

  61

E 43

7 7

8 3

94

6 1

21 1

Barb

araB

row

n2

06

7 Tail En

ds R

oad

Milw

aukee

WI

53

20

21

/5/2

01

2

  43

1 8

56 4

5 6

21

9 7

44 8

Sop

hia

Bro

wn

36

48 G

lenw

oo

d A

venu

eG

arfield H

eights

OH

44

12

51

/5/2

01

2

Page 15: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Mo

de

l JNY

86

75

E09

Re

call No

tices

Tho

rob

ern Se

rial #First

LastStre

etA

dd

ress

City

StateZip

Co

de

Date

 Sen

t

  53

F 35

2 5

6 8

86

0 7

36 3

An

gieB

row

n1

57

3 C

edar Lan

eEast B

osto

nM

A0

21

28

1/5

/20

12

  51

3 1

9W 1

1 8

12

3 1

87 2

Patricia

Bro

wn

19

67 A

rmo

ry Ro

adLillin

gton

NC

27

54

61

/5/2

01

2

  24

7 6

09 6

6 6

82

9 2

92 8

Ro

gerB

ryant

72

2 O

rph

an R

oad

Rad

isson

WI

54

86

71

/5/2

01

2

  83

A 2

70 6

1 8

30

0 6

92 7

JerryB

uck

34

05 Lu

ke Lane

Enid

OK

73

70

11

/5/2

01

2

  37

2 0

W4 4

7 5

29

4 2

55 2

Karla

Bu

ggs3

32

3 A

spen

 Co

urt

Bo

ston

MA

02

10

91

/5/2

01

2

  29

E 87

7 2

0 1

30

7 8

63 2

Kevin

Bu

nch

30

69 M

illbro

ok R

oad

Schau

mb

urg

IL6

01

73

1/5

/20

12

  16

A 9

62 5

2 7

24

0 0

71 0

Joh

nB

urch

14

82 H

ill Haven

 Drive

Waco

TX7

67

01

1/5

/20

12

  91

5 8

26 2

5 5

16

0 8

15 2

Joan

Bu

rgin2

60 C

olem

an A

venu

eP

alm D

esertC

A9

22

60

1/5

/20

12

  W1

0 1

44 9

7 7

06

7 2

89 6

Do

nald

Bu

rgos

49

64 C

enter A

venu

eFresn

oC

A9

37

06

1/5

/20

12

  Y42 3

A6 2

8 8

56

9 2

50 4

Maria

Bu

rns

20

56 C

alico D

riveC

olville

WA

99

11

41

/5/2

01

2

  66

7 Y7

4 8

2 4

83

4 2

86 5

James

Bu

rns

28

16 B

riarwo

od R

oad

Sprin

gfieldM

O6

58

06

1/5

/20

12

  89

6 7

87 0

2 0

45

9 5

05 5

Alfred

Bu

rns

26

09 P

oo

h B

ear Lane

Green

villeSC

29

60

11

/5/2

01

2

  A5

3 Y1

3 3

3 8

08

5 9

56 1

Ch

erylB

urto

n1

86

9 O

len Th

om

as Drive

Gain

esvilleTX

76

24

01

/5/2

01

2

  11

8 7

33 8

2 9

23

3 2

71 1

Mich

aelB

ush

15

74 C

harack R

oad

Blo

om

ingto

nIN

47

40

81

/5/2

01

2

  60

1 E6

4 9

4 2

48

9 1

95 4

Francis

Bu

ss3

51

7 Lyn

n O

gden

 Lane

Beau

mo

nt

TX7

77

05

1/5

/20

12

  52

A 4

67 1

2 2

37

6 6

76 3

Erma

Byers

47

25 M

aple Lan

eC

rossville

AL

35

96

01

/5/2

01

2

  71

8 4

96 9

9 1

23

3 5

02 5

An

na

Byrd

67

7 B

oggess Street

Eno

nO

H4

53

23

1/5

/20

12

  7W

8 6

32 7

0 7

47

9 7

50 9

Barry

Byrd

21

11 P

oo

h B

ear Lane

Green

villeSC

29

60

71

/5/2

01

2

  26

9 9

79 8

2 0

23

2 3

99 9

An

itraB

yrum

46

12 M

oo

nligh

t Drive

Prin

ceton

NJ

08

54

01

/5/2

01

2

  8Y0

 73

1 4

0 9

26

5 2

34 9

Juan

itaC

ado

gan2

45

5 W

oo

d D

uck D

riveM

arqu

etteM

I4

98

55

1/5

/20

12

  71

5 2

3E 5

8 2

54

4 0

82 9

Jane

Caffey

48

82 Elk Street

Los A

ngeles

CA

90

01

71

/5/2

01

2

  86

6 8

A4 4

2 6

81

8 3

84 0

Santiago

Calab

rese4

83

1 G

rove A

venu

eO

klaho

ma C

ityO

K7

31

02

1/5

/20

12

  E23 7

72 2

5 9

07

8 0

85 5

Am

yC

aldw

ell4

22

4 Farlan

d A

venu

eG

ranite Sh

oals

TX7

86

54

1/5

/20

12

  W6

4 9

65 4

0 4

10

2 9

13 9

Lauren

ceC

ales3

72

0 V

illage View

 Drive

Fort M

yersFL

33

90

11

/5/2

01

2

  58

8 7

64 2

9 5

51

4 8

10 1

JerryC

alho

un

15

46 O

akridge Lan

eA

rlingto

nTX

76

01

11

/5/2

01

2

  8V

1 9

77 1

6 1

50

3 3

11 9

Bo

bb

yC

arey2

48

7 A

rthu

r Aven

ue

Prin

ceton

IL6

13

56

1/5

/20

12

  89

0 2

91 6

6 3

24

2 4

38 2

Ro

semary

Carlso

n2

97

9 R

idge R

oad

Hu

tchin

son

KS

67

50

11

/5/2

01

2

  47

8 5

A0 5

1 1

31

9 3

97 5

Julie

Carp

enter

46

74 B

road

 StreetB

irmin

gham

AL

35

22

21

/5/2

01

2

Page 16: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Mo

de

l JNY

86

75

E09

Re

call No

tices

Tho

rob

ern Se

rial #First

LastStre

etA

dd

ress

City

StateZip

Co

de

Date

 Sen

t

  V4

4 0

92 8

4 0

07

3 6

28 5

Karen

Carp

enter

33

19 Fran

k Aven

ue

Glen

shaw

PA

15

11

61

/6/2

01

2

  00

9 5

14 1

5 4

40

5 5

75 7

Ch

ristop

her

Carro

ll1

49

6 Ju

nkin

s Aven

ue

Vald

osta

GA

31

60

11

/6/2

01

2

  04

4 1

57 2

0 2

96

5 5

56 5

James

Carro

ll4

31

5 Fo

ley StreetTam

aracFL

33

32

11

/6/2

01

2

  W7

4 A

56 4

7 3

54

6 8

65 4

Ro

bert

Carter

24

1 R

edb

ud D

riveN

ew Yo

rkN

Y1

00

11

1/6

/20

12

  88

8 7

E2 2

0 7

29

8 7

51 8

Rich

ardC

arter9

01 G

old

ie Lane

Mid

dleto

wn

OH

45

04

41

/6/2

01

2

  05

3 7

66 2

2 6

89

5 9

51 2

Joh

nC

arter2

27

7 C

row

field R

oad

Ph

oen

ixA

Z8

50

32

1/6

/20

12

  5W

3 7

10 5

6 2

05

8 7

60 0

Lois

Castro

15

73 H

all StreetLas V

egasN

V8

91

01

1/6

/20

12

  49

Y 44

8 7

8 9

31

4 2

07 6

Ton

yaC

atlin2

55

9 O

live StreetTo

ledo

OH

43

61

41

/6/2

01

2

  98

W 4

40 6

7 8

39

1 8

59 7

Gerard

Cato

41

03 Sm

all StreetN

ew Yo

rkN

Y1

00

38

1/6

/20

12

  44

4 8

17 1

1 9

84

4 9

82 4

Can

dace

Cavin

21

61 K

imb

erly Way

Gran

d R

apid

sM

I4

95

46

1/6

/20

12

  17

2 E5

5 3

9 7

67

5 7

99 7

Brad

leyC

avins

38

59 M

y Drive

Gard

en C

ityN

Y1

15

30

1/6

/20

12

  66

W 5

72 2

4 3

38

5 2

52 5

Mich

aelC

han

ce3

54

3 H

ickory Street

Salt Lake City

UT

84

11

11

/6/2

01

2

  28

Y 72

5 5

4 1

15

7 2

50 2

Janice

Ch

esson

40

17 W

ashin

gton A

venu

eB

ogalu

saM

S7

04

27

1/6

/20

12

  45

0 4

68 7

8 9

53

5 1

63 3

David

Ch

ristop

her

14

50 B

erkley StreetN

ewark

PA

19

71

41

/6/2

01

2

  02

2 9

V7 7

5 0

71

7 5

74 2

Mich

aelC

hu

te1

98

5 H

ighlan

d V

iew D

riveElk G

rove

CA

95

62

41

/6/2

01

2

  9V

0 8

Y6 1

6 9

57

7 7

03 2

Emm

aC

lark2

03

7 C

ost A

venu

eB

ethesd

aM

D2

08

17

1/6

/20

12

  22

F 31

5 4

5 5

83

5 6

30 1

Ethel

Clark

38

22 Jarvis Street

Bu

ffaloN

Y1

42

02

1/6

/20

12

  34

5 4

58 1

4 1

41

4 8

82 4

Lind

aC

lark2

15 H

anifan

 Lane

No

rcross

GA

30

07

11

/6/2

01

2

  30

2 1

E7 3

9 4

68

9 4

14 8

Do

roth

yC

layton

38

06 K

ildeer D

riveN

orfo

lkV

A2

35

02

1/6

/20

12

  V7

4 0

00 7

7 2

11

8 5

93 2

Ad

riene

Co

le4

03

5 G

rayston

e LakesM

illedgeville

GA

31

06

11

/6/2

01

2

  81

9 F7

1 7

6 1

99

5 9

52 1

Kyle

Co

le1

72

9 Lo

gan Lan

eD

enver

CO

80

22

01

/6/2

01

2

  61

7 3

0A 0

1 0

69

9 8

38 1

Lauren

Co

leman

58 B

oo

ne Street

Co

rpu

s Ch

ristiTX

78

40

11

/6/2

01

2

  12

1 6

56 0

1 3

74

0 1

11 5

Steph

enC

ollin

s1

10

2 C

alvin Street

Baltim

ore

MD

21

20

21

/6/2

01

2

  95

9 0

16 3

9 7

30

6 2

05 6

Marjo

rieC

olo

n3

35

6 H

um

min

gbird

 Way

Du

xbu

ryM

A0

23

32

1/6

/20

12

  15

5 7

25 1

7 6

14

2 8

99 2

Nath

aniel

Co

mp

ton

15

12 G

arrett StreetN

ewark

PA

19

71

41

/6/2

01

2

  24

5 0

42 7

9 5

56

0 1

42 9

Vicki

Co

nkle

51

6 W

alnu

t Aven

ue

Jersey City

NJ

07

30

41

/6/2

01

2

  59

W 2

55 4

2 8

05

7 4

41 1

Rich

ardC

on

ner

32

59 Sto

ckert Ho

llow R

oa

Bellevu

eW

A9

80

07

1/6

/20

12

  W0

8 8

09 3

1 0

99

4 8

28 2

Clara

Co

nn

olly

45

87 Lin

den

 Aven

ue

Orlan

do

FL3

28

01

1/6

/20

12

Page 17: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Mo

de

l JNY

86

75

E09

Re

call No

tices

Tho

rob

ern Se

rial #First

LastStre

etA

dd

ress

City

StateZip

Co

de

Date

 Sen

t

  F96 9

58 9

3 3

70

0 4

79 1

Den

isC

oo

k4

28 Lakelan

d Terrace

Sou

thfield

MI

48

23

51

/6/2

01

2

  30

9 V

11 5

8 1

30

0 7

32 3

Bo

nn

ieC

oo

n1

66

2 P

arkway Street

Los A

ngeles

CA

90

01

71

/6/2

01

2

  48

5 1

95 8

7 4

08

0 3

24 2

Alliso

nC

oo

per

91

6 Su

nset D

riveStar C

ityA

R7

16

67

1/6

/20

12

  1F0 F2

2 8

0 7

48

8 6

89 0

Mario

nC

oo

per

47

2 Jen

nifer Lan

eD

urh

amN

C2

77

07

1/6

/20

12

  22

0 1

57 3

8 0

51

2 8

33 7

LisaC

oo

per

10

38 W

orth

ingto

n D

riveG

rand P

rairieTX

75

05

11

/6/2

01

2

  63

9 7

E3 0

1 7

18

0 9

01 0

James

Co

op

er3

04

9 Flem

ing Street

Mo

ntgo

mery

AL

36

10

41

/6/2

01

2

  E46 1

90 2

1 9

49

0 8

17 8

Timo

thy

Co

over

40

22 B

urn

ing M

emo

ry LanPh

iladelp

hia

PA

19

12

51

/6/2

01

2

  18

3 0

05 3

9 9

14

5 5

51 8

Bessie

Co

ron

a2

59

2 W

ashin

gton A

venu

eJackso

nM

S3

92

11

1/6

/20

12

  82

8 2

41 3

1 3

62

2 6

03 4

Virgin

iaC

ortez

33

02 W

akefield Street

Ph

iladelp

hia

PA

19

10

81

/6/2

01

2

  43

0 0

8Y 6

1 2

48

0 7

83 4

An

itaC

ou

rtney

13

5 C

olu

mb

ia Min

e Ro

adR

ipley

WV

25

27

11

/6/2

01

2

  75

7 A

00 9

8 8

56

8 1

54 7

Cassan

dra

Co

vingto

n1

87

6 M

ud

lick Ro

adSp

okan

eW

A9

92

18

1/6

/20

12

  Y55 6

98 4

8 6

70

7 3

15 7

Du

ane

Co

wles

32

65 Steve H

un

t Ro

adM

iami

FL3

31

38

1/6

/20

12

  14

3 8

E8 2

2 9

03

0 3

18 0

David

Co

x4

88

9 C

arter StreetB

lufo

rdIL

62

81

41

/6/2

01

2

  98

0 2

A1 5

9 1

35

8 2

89 1

Lauren

ceC

raig3

45 G

old

cliff Circle

Wash

ingto

nD

C2

00

05

1/6

/20

12

  75

3 1

14 7

2 1

67

9 0

71 9

Mel

Crass

30

90 W

ilkinso

n C

ou

rtFo

rt Myers

FL3

39

01

1/6

/20

12

  38

4 8

42 0

7 4

29

8 5

60 9

Ralp

hC

rawfo

rd1

38

7 Jo

ann

e Lane

Low

ellM

A0

18

52

1/6

/20

12

  V7

9 5

76 2

2 6

93

1 4

87 7

Ram

on

Craw

ford

29

04 H

ano

ver StreetN

ew Yo

rkN

Y1

00

38

1/6

/20

12

  04

2 7

V6 1

8 3

39

3 6

28 2

Clay

Craw

ford

31

62 C

ou

nty Lin

e Ro

adTam

pa

FL3

36

02

1/6

/20

12

  78

5 0

24 0

8 6

02

3 1

24 4

Qu

intin

Craw

ford

48

9 Lake Flo

yd C

ircleG

aithersb

urg

MD

20

87

71

/6/2

01

2

  6F9 2

7F 7

0 9

07

0 0

13 7

Mary

Craw

ford

10

22 M

arie StreetB

altimo

reM

D2

12

06

1/6

/20

12

  3A

0 0

07 7

2 3

95

2 4

21 3

Gw

end

olyn

Creger

44

62 P

leasant H

ill Ro

adM

iami

FL3

31

69

1/6

/20

12

  F85 2

46 9

6 5

88

0 5

23 1

Gab

rielC

remean

s4

95

4 Sh

ort Street

Au

stinTX

78

74

11

/6/2

01

2

  14

8 1

89 4

9 5

10

5 7

90 2

Lanette

Cresp

o2

94

3 H

orn

or A

venu

eTu

lsaO

K7

41

31

1/6

/20

12

  Y11 1

F6 2

7 1

03

5 4

87 8

Du

ane

Cu

mm

ings

18

75 M

arietta StreetSan

 Francisco

CA

94

10

71

/6/2

01

2

  46

V 5

56 6

2 1

55

3 4

60 3

Dan

iellaC

utlip

34

77 Lu

netta Street

Po

rt Ch

arlotte

FL3

39

54

1/6

/20

12

  53

2 0

95 5

4 0

84

4 7

37 1

Margaret

Dacu

s4

85 C

and

lelight D

riveB

aytow

nTX

77

52

01

/6/2

01

2

  52

9 9

42 0

5 8

69

7 9

91 8

JessicaD

aigle3

61

7 D

esert Bro

om C

ou

rtN

ewark

NJ

07

10

21

/6/2

01

2

  98

5 9

72 8

0 7

09

4 9

31 2

Jose

Daigre

45

39 Sn

ider Street

Pu

eblo

CO

81

00

31

/6/2

01

2

Page 18: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Mo

de

l JNY

86

75

E09

Re

call No

tices

Tho

rob

ern Se

rial #First

LastStre

etA

dd

ress

City

StateZip

Co

de

Date

 Sen

t

  57

9 5

29 0

3 6

60

8 7

76 0

Dian

eD

alke2

05

1 C

edar Street

Blyth

evilleA

R7

23

15

1/6

/20

12

  83

3 V

97 6

1 4

21

7 5

33 0

Kera

Dan

iels3

82

5 R

ainy D

ay Drive

Waterto

wn

MA

02

17

21

/6/2

01

2

  V5

9 2

1V 4

4 7

84

9 7

18 8

SylviaD

aniels

32

88 Freed

om Lan

eSto

ckton

CA

95

20

41

/6/2

01

2

  26

6 A

49 1

0 7

64

6 3

98 7

Ernesto

Darb

y8

14 R

ainb

ow R

oad

Alh

amb

raC

A9

18

01

1/6

/20

12

  37

A 8

A3 6

2 1

35

2 8

32 5

Shirley

Dau

gherty

13

63 B

urke Street

Read

ing

MA

01

86

71

/6/2

01

2

  12

E 89

Y 57 6

94

7 0

90 9

Willie

Daven

po

rt4

52

7 A

viation W

ayLo

s An

gelesC

A9

00

17

1/6

/20

12

  1W

8 0

61 8

6 1

74

9 9

70 0

Ro

bert

Daven

po

rt4

36

9 K

inch

eloe R

oad

Po

rtland

OR

97

23

21

/6/2

01

2

  76

0 1

7F 5

9 8

66

1 1

64 0

Oscar

Daven

po

rt4

99

0 Sm

all StreetN

ew Yo

rkN

Y1

00

36

1/6

/20

12

  V9

0 2

15 3

1 4

82

1 7

78 4

Emily

David

son

30 Sp

adafo

re Drive

Kn

ox

PA

16

23

21

/6/2

01

2

  08

8 7

99 5

3 8

61

3 7

61 8

Joh

nD

avis3

36

1 C

lay StreetIn

dian

apo

lisIN

46

26

81

/9/2

01

2

  57

A 7

81 2

9 2

76

3 6

32 5

Mike

Davis

47

08 H

all Valley D

riveW

heelin

gW

V2

60

03

1/9

/20

12

  08

E 14

4 3

9 7

68

1 9

70 3

EvaD

avis4

83

9 D

iane Street

Tho

usan

d O

aksC

A9

13

62

1/9

/20

12

  09

8 2

11 3

3 0

18

9 6

11 8

Co

urtn

eyD

avis1

16 Sycam

ore Fo

rk Ro

adFo

rt Laud

erdale

FL3

33

01

1/9

/20

12

  4W

8 1

49 0

1 4

53

2 2

29 5

Lind

aD

avis4

96

8 P

inch

elon

e StreetN

orfo

lkV

A2

35

02

1/9

/20

12

  1E2

 59

3 9

7 8

54

5 6

57 1

Aliso

nD

avis4

40

5 N

orth

west B

ou

levarJersey C

ityN

J0

73

04

1/9

/20

12

  7Y8

 V7

4 0

8 0

27

5 0

65 0

Betty

Daviso

n3

06

0 V

esta Drive

Ch

icagoIL

60

62

01

/9/2

01

2

  16

3 2

93 3

5 2

80

3 7

52 0

Dio

nD

awso

n4

35

4 V

alley StreetC

amd

enN

J0

81

02

  53

0 3

79 6

8 3

57

8 7

08 3

Timo

thy

Dayto

n7

43 Zap

pia D

riveW

inch

esterK

Y4

03

91

  19

8 V

49 9

8 9

41

1 7

13 3

Marvin

Deckard

76

9 B

artlett Aven

ue

Sou

thfield

MI

48

07

5

  W9

8 Y8

2 5

4 5

69

9 0

41 6

Joh

nD

ecker1

41

4 P

retty View

 Lane

Santa R

osa

CA

95

40

1

  86

1 7

96 4

8 4

02

7 0

89 7

Santo

sD

eclue

68

3 Earn

hard

t Drive

Lou

isvilleK

Y4

02

42

  58

7 9

78 5

1 0

55

3 9

17 1

Susan

Dejo

hn

36

00 Ligh

tho

use D

riveSp

ringfield

MO

65

80

2

  87

8 1

62 0

5 1

62

3 6

79 2

An

tho

ny

Dem

arco2

13

3 Sch

oo

l StreetW

ashin

gton

DC

20

00

7

  95

2 6

13 9

3 1

61

7 4

23 2

Marilyn

Devin

e4

44

9 Statio

n Street

Oaklan

dC

A9

46

12

  Y79 V

75 6

0 8

54

4 4

84 1

Dan

aD

evito2

36

9 G

rand A

venu

eO

rland

oFL

32

80

5

  49

5 8

77 4

6 3

25

0 7

80 5

Mark

Dew

itt3

68

1 Seltice W

ayTw

in Falls

ID8

33

01

  21

4 0

79 4

6 7

30

2 8

78 1

Dam

on

Diaz

26

25 G

iraffe Hill D

riveD

allasTX

75

20

7

  38

5 2

64 1

7 4

88

2 8

10 8

Nick

Do

ak1

04

5 R

oan

e Aven

ue

Ho

usto

nTX

77

09

9

Page 19: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Mo

de

l JNY

86

75

E09

Re

call No

tices

Tho

rob

ern Se

rial #First

LastStre

etA

dd

ress

City

StateZip

Co

de

Date

 Sen

t

  86

0 5

91 7

9 5

96

2 3

70 8

Hu

goD

olan

23

30 B

ell StreetN

ew Yo

rkN

Y1

00

19

  91

6 6

95 3

9 8

47

7 6

92 8

Shelley

Do

men

ech5

47 W

ines Lan

eH

ou

ston

TX7

70

06

  60

1 9

10 2

9 4

89

6 0

17 3

No

elD

on

lon

29

23 B

astin D

riveN

orristo

wn

PA

19

40

3

  33

6 3

50 3

2 5

67

8 7

32 3

JesseD

on

nelly

34

45 C

amb

ridge D

riveP

eoria

AZ

85

38

2

  21

1 Y6

0 3

2 9

42

8 8

57 9

Janie

Do

rgan1

28

7 Taylo

r StreetScarsd

aleN

Y1

05

83

  61

5 1

F3 2

3 8

95

9 2

60 0

Tamm

yD

orsey

62

7 B

un

galow R

oad

Arlin

gton

NE

68

00

2

  99

2 9

35 0

2 5

58

2 4

26 6

Mark

Do

uglas

11

39 B

uck D

riveK

earns

UT

84

11

8

  07

Y 47

8 4

6 3

01

3 1

80 2

Ro

nald

Do

uglas

17

45 Lo

dgeville R

oad

Min

neap

olis

MN

55

41

1

  8E3

 94

8 3

6 0

23

7 3

75 6

Ton

yaD

ow

10

82 V

iking D

riveC

hillico

the

OH

45

60

1

  41

0 6

44 5

0 9

26

7 8

97 9

StevenD

ow

27

78 U

niversity D

riveB

urr R

idge

IL6

12

57

  4A

3 8

V6 1

1 4

22

3 4

35 5

Savann

ahD

ow

nard

44

80 Jo

dy R

oad

Ph

iladelp

hia

PA

19

10

3

  A0

7 F9

7 3

5 4

60

1 8

50 6

Millard

Do

yle3

23

9 A

dam

s Aven

ue

Frederick

MD

21

70

1

  90

6 0

10 7

6 7

99

8 3

83 0

James

Drau

ghn

35

31 D

rum

mo

nd Street

New

arkN

J0

71

02

  51

8 2

13 2

6 5

58

9 2

01 1

Leon

ardD

ub

ose

44

73 Q

ueen

s Lane

Lynch

bu

rgV

A2

45

02

  53

2 5

39 0

7 0

36

6 2

20 8

Kim

berly

Du

dek

20

22 Tree Fro

g Lane

Ro

send

aleM

O6

44

83

  60

W 2

87 4

6 1

32

1 3

62 2

Luz

Du

dley

40

67 P

erry StreetSo

uth

fieldM

I4

80

34

  E02 5

F8 1

3 3

94

7 4

22 9

Janet

Du

ffy4

08

7 A

rbo

r Co

urt

Ch

eyenn

eW

Y8

20

03

  59

5 4

96 9

4 6

96

2 3

82 3

Bo

ydD

uke

39

63 Sp

ring Street

Matto

on

IL6

19

38

  46

V 4

87 4

4 6

60

1 3

22 8

Ph

ilipD

yer7

05 M

esa Drive

Las Vegas

NV

89

10

1

  00

9 W

36 3

8 6

28

1 5

12 1

Cletu

sEasley

31

47 C

lou

sson R

oad

Sergeant B

luff

IA5

10

54

  13

3 7

F0 5

1 1

98

7 8

57 5

Glen

East1

27

2 C

on

federate D

riveSackets H

arbo

rN

Y1

36

85

  01

0 2

13 6

4 7

99

2 3

93 8

Pat

Echo

ls2

91

2 W

alnu

t StreetJackso

nM

S3

92

13

  21

7 3

52 2

8 6

98

7 7

10 8

Theresa

Edw

ards

38

66 Lau

rel LeeC

ottage G

rove

MN

55

01

6

  10

7 0

Y6 7

3 2

92

9 5

02 5

David

Edw

ards

28

0 Ten

mile R

oad

Cam

brid

geM

A0

21

41

  23

4 3

4V 4

2 8

39

2 5

37 0

Steph

anEd

ward

s4

84

7 B

road

 StreetB

irmin

gham

AL

35

22

2

  44

9 7

V0 8

6 4

86

6 4

96 5

Brid

getEd

ward

s6

06 Tw

in H

ou

se Lane

Neo

sho

MO

64

85

0

  30

E 33

3 6

9 1

72

3 7

06 2

Patricia

Eiland

35

20 Eva P

earl StreetB

aton R

ou

geLA

70

81

4

  16

A 6

51 2

3 6

96

5 7

24 1

Letha

Ellis2

84

7 C

herry R

idge D

riveB

uffalo

NY

14

20

4

Page 20: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Mo

de

l JNY

86

75

E09

Re

call No

tices

Tho

rob

ern Se

rial #First

LastStre

etA

dd

ress

City

StateZip

Co

de

Date

 Sen

t

  20

2 2

W8 8

3 2

08

0 9

64 6

Jenn

iferEllis

45

31 Eagle D

riveTem

peran

ceM

I4

81

82

  A8

0 A

14 9

9 0

91

8 0

26 9

Lori

Ellis1

53

2 B

lane Street

Saint Lo

uis

MO

63

10

1

  58

0 4

19 2

7 8

28

7 0

50 8

Pau

lEllis

18

87 W

ilson Street

Riversid

eC

A9

25

01

  78

0 4

94 0

7 7

04

4 0

60 9

Tho

mas

Enger

43

63 B

rann

on Street

Irvine

CA

92

61

4

  40

5 4

Y6 5

2 9

00

8 0

13 5

Nan

cyEn

och

38

33 Lyn

n Street

Cam

brid

geM

A0

21

41

  94

0 3

47 0

1 8

48

6 8

65 4

Kath

erine

Enrigh

t3

12

9 K

imb

erly Way

Gran

d R

apid

sM

I4

95

46

  96

2 9

44 2

6 4

51

3 6

25 2

Melissa

Esparza

56

4 W

est Drive

Ch

icagoIL

60

60

6

  1F0 9

38 7

5 2

69

5 2

56 2

Mark

Espin

al3

31

2 M

aple Lan

eB

irmin

gham

AL

35

20

9

  88

2 0

85 2

7 2

88

8 6

15 2

Joh

nEsp

ino

za2

30

2 Tavern

 Place

Westo

nW

V2

64

52

  39

W 6

11 6

9 7

48

3 6

52 2

Geo

rgeEu

ban

ks4

34 Lyo

n A

venu

eN

orth

 Framin

gham

MA

01

70

1

  8Y8

 07

E 17 6

17

3 4

81 6

Wen

dell

Evans

35

8 C

and

lelight D

riveH

um

ble

TX7

73

38

  72

8 1

96 2

1 7

22

2 2

58 6

TimEvan

s2

95

8 Sh

ort Street

Au

stinTX

78

72

3

  17

6 3

49 8

4 5

23

6 7

92 1

Leroy

Ewald

41

0 Lib

erty Aven

ue

Irvine

CA

92

66

4

  34

6 5

78 7

5 9

91

8 7

50 8

Lind

aEw

ing

46

61 B

ridge A

venu

eC

row

leyLA

70

52

6

  75

3 6

1A 7

0 2

36

9 8

19 5

Kelly

Fair1

37

7 A

irplan

e Aven

ue

Hartfo

rdC

T0

61

82

  Y26 1

79 8

1 6

05

6 2

84 2

Maxin

eFarley

17

77 A

ugu

sta Park

Barb

ou

rsvilleW

V2

55

04

  04

0 7

89 2

3 3

48

3 2

00 0

Ro

land

Farrar4

14

5 C

oal R

oad

Nesq

ueh

on

ing

PA

18

24

0

  35

V 4

37 7

2 6

85

7 2

26 2

ElsieFarris

47

60 R

itter Aven

ue

Ro

sevilleM

I4

80

66

  W0

3 8

97 9

0 1

51

2 4

00 4

Gh

islaine

Favela6

48 A

rmo

ry Ro

adFayetteville

NC

28

30

1

  81

7 2

87 0

7 0

50

1 1

65 8

Ton

iFergu

son

40

23 O

akmo

un

d D

riveC

hicago

IL6

06

44

  3A

0 0

2E 7

3 1

09

6 5

54 2

Elizabeth

Fernan

dez

42

83 Ed

ward

s StreetB

ethel

NC

27

81

2

  73

7 2

E2 4

6 1

11

2 8

25 2

Rayn

aFerrell

38

09 W

oo

dlan

d A

venu

eD

estrehan

LA7

00

47

  38

9 W

09 8

4 5

66

2 3

39 6

James

Ferron

31

50 P

op

lar Lane

Miam

iFL

33

13

9

  90

E 19

8 9

4 6

60

5 5

41 6

Ro

bert

Feuerstein

41

22 C

oo

lidge Street

Maitlan

dFL

32

75

1

  71

6 5

60 5

2 4

52

8 5

14 9

Tom

asaFitzgerald

60 M

ulb

erry Lane

Jup

iterFL

33

45

8

  Y11 7

68 9

7 1

22

1 2

22 3

Thelm

aFitzp

atrick3

28

2 A

gricultu

re Lane

Hialeah

FL3

30

12

  F42 9

40 4

2 2

94

6 0

42 9

William

Fletcher

10

66 H

enry Fo

rd A

venu

eB

ig Cab

inO

K7

43

32

  93

4 6

59 5

1 1

26

5 0

58 0

LeeFlo

rian1

49

3 N

eup

ort Lan

eD

ulu

thG

A3

00

97

Page 21: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Mo

de

l JNY

86

75

E09

Re

call No

tices

Tho

rob

ern Se

rial #First

LastStre

etA

dd

ress

City

StateZip

Co

de

Date

 Sen

t

  79

3 5

E8 9

7 3

45

8 4

68 5

Wern

erFlyn

n4

37

8 Leverto

n C

ove R

oad

Sprin

gfieldM

A0

11

03

  35

7 8

83 2

2 8

83

2 5

44 6

Lori

Follm

er7

56 P

atterson Fo

rk Ro

adC

hicago

IL6

06

05

  V2

7 0

46 5

6 1

58

2 8

65 7

Bru

ceFo

ntes

15

3 G

reen A

cres Ro

adR

ocky M

ou

nt

NC

27

80

1

  8V

4 7

83 0

4 9

28

2 7

82 9

Edd

ieFo

os

43

19 R

yder A

venu

eSeattle

WA

98

10

6

  5A

7 0

75 8

3 0

82

7 0

72 3

Alice

Forb

es7

9 N

eup

ort Lan

eD

un

wo

od

yG

A3

03

38

  43

5 4

16 5

3 6

61

6 7

16 5

Josep

hFo

rd2

09

8 M

ayo Street

Win

chester

KY

40

39

1

  23

W 8

65 3

2 4

33

8 9

83 8

Arth

ur

Fow

ler1

85

1 O

rph

an R

oad

Wash

bu

rnW

I5

48

91

  92

7 7

F5 0

3 3

81

1 7

63 0

Ricky

Francis

30

81 Lyn

n Street

Bo

ston

MA

02

10

7

  98

4 9

81 9

4 8

80

8 5

84 6

Arth

ur

Franklin

20

36 Sto

ne Lan

eW

ayne

PA

19

08

8

  14

0 0

06 2

1 9

19

0 5

60 6

Glen

nFricks

25

07 Eagle D

riveD

etroit

MI

48

22

6

  34

7 9

F2 2

2 1

83

6 0

66 4

Tho

mas

Frierson

19

44 O

ld D

ear Lane

Pearl R

iverN

Y1

09

65

  38

4 0

9Y 7

7 6

73

0 5

23 9

Cam

illeFrierso

n3

14

7 N

icho

las StreetSalin

aK

S6

74

01

  E16 4

1W 9

6 6

11

1 7

37 3

Joh

ann

aFrye

45

17 D

awso

n D

riveLittle R

ock

AR

72

20

1

  53

8 1

1F 9

5 6

55

2 2

61 6

Janie

Gage

98

2 B

ingam

on B

ranch R

oaElk G

rove V

illageIL

60

00

7

  33

0 6

76 1

6 2

08

6 1

29 8

Ch

arlesG

alind

o1

82

7 A

nd

ell Ro

adC

anal W

inch

esterO

H4

31

10

  43

9 0

20 9

7 0

28

0 8

67 9

Nesto

rG

arcia3

28 P

ike StreetD

el Mar

CA

92

01

4

  V5

7 6

70 4

7 2

68

3 6

82 5

Lloyd

Garcia

26

24 C

hen

ow

eth D

riveN

ashville

TN3

72

10

  08

2 1

32 3

0 4

40

0 1

48 5

Helen

Garcia

32

07 H

idd

enview

 Drive

New

tow

nP

A1

89

40

  6Y8

 4E7

 88 0

60

3 3

44 8

Do

nn

aG

arcia3

05

9 C

harla Lan

eB

ristol

TX7

51

25

  W0

8 1

62 2

7 9

33

7 1

03 1

Scott

Garn

er2

50

9 N

ixon A

venu

eM

idd

le Po

int

OH

45

86

3

  24

8 3

91 4

7 6

09

9 0

44 1

William

Garza

88

1 C

lover D

riveC

olo

rado Sp

rings

CO

80

92

0

  79

5 5

2W 1

7 0

82

7 0

21 2

Frances

Gaskin

32

7 B

urn

side A

venu

eP

ark City

UT

84

06

0

  35

W 1

02 4

2 0

83

5 1

00 4

Justin

Gau

lke2

76

2 D

ane Street

Ch

arlestow

nM

A0

21

29

  68

7 6

79 5

3 0

28

0 8

69 3

Patricia

Gavin

25

12 C

edarsto

ne D

riveM

aum

eeO

H4

35

37

  70

1 3

82 4

9 7

06

5 8

21 5

Billy

Gay

33

02 M

etz Lane

Cam

den

NJ

08

10

2

  67

6 9

3V 1

0 9

01

8 5

31 9

Ch

erylG

emm

ill3

60

0 A

lexand

er Aven

ue

Fremo

nt

CA

94

53

9

  68

3 6

F0 0

5 4

52

3 5

74 6

JerryG

entry

86 Tw

in W

illow Lan

eFayetteville

NC

28

30

1

  26

9 8

19 1

0 2

60

4 1

45 5

Lawren

ceG

eorge

22

05 H

enry Fo

rd A

venu

eP

rue

OK

74

06

0

Page 22: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Mo

de

l JNY

86

75

E09

Re

call No

tices

Tho

rob

ern Se

rial #First

LastStre

etA

dd

ress

City

StateZip

Co

de

Date

 Sen

t

  60

1 9

9A 8

1 9

93

9 9

83 3

William

Gib

bs

55

4 R

idge R

oad

Wich

itaK

S6

72

02

  04

0 3

A3 8

3 0

47

8 8

78 4

Ro

derick

Giro

ux

37

62 Sarah

 Drive

LafayetteLA

70

50

1

  V1

3 V

62 5

1 3

02

6 0

15 1

Ro

bert

Glen

n2

91

6 D Street

Blo

om

field To

wn

ship

MI

48

30

2

  00

0 1

08 8

4 9

80

9 3

62 8

Britn

iG

lover

95

1 C

om

fort C

ou

rtM

adiso

nW

I5

37

04

  2A

7 6

47 2

5 1

84

3 3

48 9

James

Go

do

y3

27

0 H

art Rid

ge Ro

adSagin

awM

I4

86

07

  94

1 3

E5 6

6 8

09

8 0

16 8

Bern

iceG

oin

s3

99

8 M

ulb

erry Lane

West P

alm B

eachFL

33

40

1

  74

8 W

28 9

7 2

65

0 9

35 3

Melissa

Go

ldb

erg1

63

4 Essex C

ou

rtR

ichm

on

dV

T0

54

77

  60

5 W

72 3

2 9

03

2 3

74 2

Ash

leyG

om

ez3

89 R

epp

ert Co

al Ro

adW

arrenM

I4

80

93

  29

4 3

19 0

9 9

83

9 3

70 1

Do

nn

aG

om

ez3

56 W

hite R

iver Way

Salt Lake City

UT

84

10

6

  33

4 5

69 9

8 9

53

2 1

30 0

JeanG

om

ez1

99

4 P

rimro

se Lane

Mad

ison

WI

53

70

4

  64

9 1

56 8

0 4

68

9 3

95 8

Julio

Go

nzales

40

86 B

eech Street

An

tioch

CA

94

50

9

  39

E E17 4

3 3

77

3 2

40 9

Tho

mas

Go

nzales

17

84 Fin

cham

 Ro

adW

interh

avenC

A9

22

83

  W3

5 5

19 6

1 9

19

4 9

07 6

Ro

scoe

Go

nzalez

32

25 H

orn

er StreetTw

insb

urg

OH

44

08

7

  10

9 A

13 3

0 3

21

4 9

99 7

Rich

ardG

oo

d3

14

8 D

uck C

reek Ro

adO

akland

CA

94

61

2

  11

2 8

04 9

7 8

56

3 0

02 6

An

na

Go

od

e6

04 Sh

ingleto

n R

oad

New

 Bu

ffaloM

I4

91

17

  22

7 7

47 1

3 3

54

2 6

68 3

Vicki

Go

od

rich6

27 Lo

wlan

d D

riveO

glesby

IL6

13

48

  2F2 1

F3 6

8 3

32

4 9

76 4

TerryG

ord

on

47

90 Elm

 Drive

Elmsfo

rdN

Y1

05

23

  48

2 5

24 1

6 5

97

8 6

36 5

James

Go

rney

22

28 P

atterson Fo

rk Ro

adLo

mb

ardIL

60

14

8

  88

2 2

26 6

1 0

95

3 6

07 1

JeanG

racey3

21

7 M

assachu

setts Aven

Wash

ingto

nD

C2

00

09

  86

8 6

70 1

8 9

96

1 2

47 3

David

Grah

am2

56

6 Lero

y Lane

Alcester

SD5

70

01

  3A

4 5

F2 8

9 8

80

4 5

30 6

Lucin

da

Gran

ger1

06

2 Su

garfoo

t Lane

LafayetteIN

47

90

6

  73

6 2

62 5

7 8

72

5 7

72 2

JesseG

rant

40

24 Sp

adafo

re Drive

ErieP

A1

65

01

  90

F 01

2 2

8 1

44

0 8

40 7

James

Gran

t1

45

3 To

dd

s Lane

San A

nto

nio

TX7

82

38

  38

2 7

07 6

7 9

14

0 5

84 9

Jose

Gray

34

84 Lo

st Creek R

oad

Ph

iladelp

hia

PA

19

12

3

  67

2 W

60 5

4 6

83

6 8

85 1

Jeremy

Gray

48

31 Sim

pso

n Sq

uare

Alfalfa

OK

73

03

3

  1E5

 3W

4 2

1 6

55

6 2

74 0

Steph

anie

Gray

46

93 K

uh

l Aven

ue

Atlan

taG

A3

03

03

  95

0 6

11 0

2 0

25

3 0

91 5

Kath

leenG

rayson

37

73 C

atherin

e Drive

Pekin

ND

58

36

1

  54

9 5

32 3

8 4

97

7 7

35 6

James

Green

27

19 W

illison Street

Min

neap

olis

MN

55

41

1

Page 23: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Mo

de

l JNY

86

75

E09

Re

call No

tices

Tho

rob

ern Se

rial #First

LastStre

etA

dd

ress

City

StateZip

Co

de

Date

 Sen

t

  11

0 A

33 8

5 4

37

2 0

06 4

No

raG

reen4

58

1 B

icetow

n R

oad

New

 York

NY

10

01

1

  98

6 0

08 5

9 6

84

0 5

34 0

Mari

Griffin

35

54 R

om

ines M

ill Ro

adA

rlingto

nTX

76

01

1

  30

4 5

99 3

0 0

48

0 3

19 7

Laurie

Griffith

48

69 C

row

field R

oad

Gilb

ertA

Z8

52

33

  6Y1

 23

5 7

5 0

23

0 9

09 1

Am

and

aG

rimes

16

16 C

harla Lan

eD

allasTX

75

20

4

  20

4 0

51 4

3 5

90

2 3

04 5

Sharo

nG

rimes

31

2 B

lane Street

Saint Lo

uis

MO

63

12

3

  F02 8

78 1

7 8

74

0 7

18 2

Rita

Gru

bb

26

18 B

un

galow R

oad

Om

aha

NE

68

16

4

  30

1 9

76 9

3 5

84

1 8

41 8

Ad

rienn

eG

run

ewald

73

9 W

ashin

gton A

venu

eJackso

nM

S3

92

11

  Y13 3

01 5

3 3

19

1 3

55 3

Edw

ardG

uess

45

96 Trad

ers Alley

Kan

sas City

MO

64

10

5

  54

7 2

17 8

0 0

83

7 1

19 5

Julie

Gu

nn

88

6 C

lay Lick Ro

adC

astle Ro

ckC

O8

01

04

  8V

2 1

W5 1

7 6

57

0 6

77 8

Vin

ceG

urn

ey2

49

6 R

ollin

s Ro

adB

row

nlee

NE

69

12

6

  Y73 6

E4 3

9 2

71

5 7

03 1

Ken

neth

Gu

thrie

31

69 B

etter StreetK

ansas C

ityK

S6

61

01

  77

0 9

W7 1

4 8

32

2 0

72 2

Wesley

Had

lock

25

13 R

and

olp

h Street

Cam

brid

geM

A0

21

41

  87

6 4

87 1

9 7

62

8 7

65 5

Wern

erH

aley2

07

4 Jo

hn C

alvin D

riveB

urr R

idge

IL6

12

57

  53

9 2

15 4

0 4

13

2 9

73 8

Lance

Ham

mett

42

03 B

road

way Street

Geo

rgetow

nSC

29

44

0

  29

Y 75

2 3

6 8

02

4 2

66 6

Beverly

Han

sen3

53

3 Jerry To

th D

riveC

learA

K9

97

04

  4A

1 1

55 3

1 7

54

7 1

88 8

Dean

Harley

41

3 Lin

coln Street

Ho

pew

ell  Mercer

NJ

08

52

5

  84

4 A

44 7

3 6

12

1 3

78 4

LarryH

arringto

n1

13

1 D

ark Ho

llow R

oad

Pleasan

tvilleN

J0

82

32

  20

4 3

7Y 4

1 0

69

2 4

90 5

Do

nald

Harris

28

94 Ed

en D

riveSim

i Valley

CA

93

06

5

  42

6 1

41 1

7 5

69

7 0

92 0

Mich

elleH

arris3

44

8 R

ockw

ell Lane

Ro

cky Mo

un

tN

C2

78

01

  97

A 5

31 8

3 0

13

0 8

86 8

Ch

arlotte

Harriso

n3

39 Settlers Lan

eSyo

ssetN

Y1

17

91

  W0

4 9

Y4 1

4 8

34

8 3

66 6

Do

roth

yH

artsock

11

10 C

harack R

oad

Evansville

IN4

77

08

  3V

6 E2

3 2

5 1

41

7 4

66 7

Brad

leyH

askins

30

56 M

yra StreetW

arwick

RI

02

88

7

  3V

5 4

41 2

7 5

31

6 5

96 9

Mari

Haskin

s1

07

0 P

assaic StreetW

ashin

gton

DC

20

00

5

  81

A V

69 2

7 4

32

5 5

55 2

Matth

ewH

auck

30

83 P

rovid

ence Lan

eA

nah

eimC

A9

28

01

  97

6 0

38 7

4 8

45

5 0

18 6

Mich

aelH

ausm

ann

20

71 C

om

merce B

ou

levarOm

aha

NE

68

10

2

  92

1 9

A6 6

2 4

02

0 2

38 8

Alb

ertH

awkin

s2

25

7 H

ill Cro

ft Farm R

oad

Ch

icoC

A9

59

26

  F76 0

F1 1

9 5

57

3 6

38 4

StevenH

awkin

s2

44

4 M

elod

y Lane

Rich

mo

nd

VA

23

22

4

  43

9 0

68 0

5 1

81

8 7

11 5

Nin

aH

awth

orn

e9

93 R

iden

ou

r StreetM

iami

FL3

31

79

Page 24: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Mo

de

l JNY

86

75

E09

Re

call No

tices

Tho

rob

ern Se

rial #First

LastStre

etA

dd

ress

City

StateZip

Co

de

Date

 Sen

t

  4W

1 3

90 7

4 3

60

4 6

41 9

Willa

Hayes

35

34 In

gram R

oad

Green

sbo

roN

C2

74

06

  36

5 Y6

0 0

1 1

93

1 4

11 5

James

Hays

35

12 Star R

ou

teW

oo

d D

aleIL

60

19

1

  55

0 7

0F 8

7 9

43

3 8

00 9

Darren

Head

rick4

95

4 H

urry Street

Ch

ristiansb

urg

VA

24

07

3

  7W

3 4

12 1

1 1

39

5 6

73 3

Do

risH

end

erson

38

96 P

ratt Aven

ue

Pu

get Island

WA

98

61

2

  A9

8 7

7W 2

3 6

28

3 7

72 4

Elizabeth

Hen

derso

n4

33

1 P

inew

oo

d D

riveB

urr R

idge

IL6

12

57

  83

V 5

93 9

5 9

27

1 6

12 7

Kyle

Hen

derso

n4

92

4 O

akwo

od A

venu

eN

ew Yo

rkN

Y1

00

04

  Y62 A

90 5

5 4

81

3 4

82 4

Logan

Hen

ry4

48

0 C

liffside D

riveB

ingh

amto

nN

Y1

39

04

  73

0 0

20 9

3 5

38

7 0

17 4

Justin

Hered

ia1

94

0 H

idd

enview

 Drive

Tullyto

wn

PA

19

00

7

  74

0 8

W3 5

1 8

56

0 2

88 8

Do

nald

Hern

and

ez3

14

9 H

awks N

est Lane

Stlou

isM

O6

31

01

  56

W 5

78 7

4 9

93

7 4

88 9

Tom

Hern

and

ez3

56

5 H

og C

amp R

oad

Bu

rr Rid

geIL

60

52

7

  10

2 9

71 4

1 9

12

6 1

12 1

Do

nn

aH

ernan

dez

10

52 Sco

tt StreetP

ou

ghkeep

sieN

Y1

26

01

  29

4 1

0V 6

5 5

74

2 2

18 4

Ch

ristieH

esse4

67

1 W

exford W

ayLan

casterSC

29

72

0

  63

5 2

15 0

8 0

99

7 9

33 5

Victo

riaH

ewitt

83

8 B

yers Lane

Marysville

CA

95

90

1

  9W

1 4

63 3

3 9

67

2 3

76 0

Ph

illipH

ill2

98

9 Farlan

d A

venu

eV

ictoria

TX7

79

01

  08

6 7

A2 0

5 1

97

9 2

82 5

Bren

da

Hill

35

53 O

akdale A

venu

eTam

pa

FL3

36

10

  1E4

 65

7 0

0 1

38

1 8

05 5

Joh

nH

ill4

41

2 K

uh

l Aven

ue

Smyrn

aG

A3

00

82

  80

8 9

76 6

9 2

44

9 2

64 4

An

gelicaH

inkle

46

89 D

ou

glas Dairy R

oad

Joh

nso

n C

ityV

A3

76

15

  3Y4

 A3

9 6

9 1

74

4 0

92 6

Caro

lH

od

ge2

62

2 Jett Lan

eEl Segu

nd

oC

A9

02

45

  95

4 2

4E 2

2 2

23

5 0

75 7

Kath

erine

Ho

err2

20

1 Terra C

otta Street

Breezy P

oin

tM

N5

64

72

  30

7 6

01 9

6 2

10

2 2

49 8

Nath

anH

olco

mb

12

78 P

arker Drive

Clevelan

dO

H4

41

15

  E17 5

45 4

4 1

18

2 1

10 7

Ro

saH

old

er4

37

5 Jad

ewo

od D

riveG

aryIN

46

40

4

  4A

7 5

69 5

8 7

11

5 8

97 7

Bo

nn

ieH

ollid

ay3

03

2 A

dam

s Drive

San A

ngelo

TX7

69

03

  04

3 0

6E 4

4 7

69

7 5

19 3

Betty

Ho

ltzman

46

7 Fro

nt Street

Carso

nville

MI

48

41

9

  2A

3 8

15 1

7 3

46

4 1

04 1

Barb

araH

oo

ks4

3 P

rosp

ect Valley R

oad

Bu

rban

kC

A9

15

05

  67

5 2

25 1

5 5

99

6 8

36 7

Caro

leH

oo

ley1

92 B

erkley StreetP

ottsto

wn

PA

19

46

4

  74

9 4

34 9

3 7

66

6 1

51 1

Brian

Ho

op

s4

79

1 Jail D

riveM

anito

IL6

15

46

  3W

6 1

48 5

7 3

85

7 3

25 3

Bryan

Ho

pe

20

82 R

iver Ro

adC

olo

rado Sp

rings

CO

80

91

1

  70

6 3

V3 9

0 9

53

3 9

12 7

Rich

ardH

op

kins

38

77 R

ub

aiyat Ro

adEllsw

orth

MI

49

72

9

Page 25: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Mo

de

l JNY

86

75

E09

Re

call No

tices

Tho

rob

ern Se

rial #First

LastStre

etA

dd

ress

City

StateZip

Co

de

Date

 Sen

t

  15

6 4

V5 1

8 1

58

2 1

15 3

James

Ho

pp

er3

41

3 H

orn

er StreetYo

un

gstow

nO

H4

45

03

  56

4 7

17 4

7 3

54

8 6

55 9

Mary

Ho

pso

n3

86

6 H

idd

en P

on

d R

oad

Nash

villeTN

37

21

9

  60

8 3

W0 8

4 1

05

2 1

41 4

Ch

erylH

orak

48

47 Flyn

n Street

Westlake

OH

44

14

5

  W8

7 3

05 9

2 5

42

1 1

44 2

Am

yH

orn

28

28 N

uzu

m C

ou

rtB

uffalo

NY

14

20

2

  74

6 2

63 1

3 4

90

6 1

74 5

Nath

anH

orstm

an2

54

6 A

lfred D

riveSteelto

nP

A1

71

13

  92

4 3

F5 0

1 2

33

3 4

81 2

James

Ho

use

45

74 Sh

eila Lane

Imlay

NV

89

41

8

Page 26: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

•••◦◦ Horizon 7G 1:31 PM 1%

< Messages Ashton Details

Fri, Feb 14, 2014 11:36 AM

Fri, Feb 14, 2014 12:14 PM

Fri, Feb 14, 2014 12:52 PM

Woody, this trailer is jacked….i found beastmode asleep standing up against Clyde. The carnage is epicly bad.

Whoopsie

Ugh…my head is killing me. I feel like my well‐meaning parents were right about the dangers of substance abuse.

Yup.

Rly? One night love affair‐no question

Inneresting. I would have chosen cuts like aknife

TRYIN TO MAKE LIKE WE DON’T CARE

While you’re reaching out for something new, would you mind coming over here and grabbing a mop.

Srsly…this mess isn’t getting any better. I found Ryan written in what appears to be blood on the bedroom wall. What in the actual hell? Did you write your name in blood? Why,how,when? So many ?s

kristen.corn
Exhibit
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
G
Page 27: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

•••◦◦ Horizon 7G 1:31 PM 1%

< Messages Ashton Details

Fri, Feb 14, 2014 1:31 PM

How are you not responding to this text

message. Are you dead?

Tell you what is dead, the origin of the stench in this trailer. It is stank AF.

COME.OVER.HERE. I’ve got your scissors. Did you remember that the axle broke last night? Also, did you cut Clyde’s mane with your scissors

En route

Where you at? I just walked in, and it does, indeed, stink. You can stay in my room tonight, if you would like

I went to the store to get more garbage bags. I called to see how much an axel would be…more than a grand.

Pass on staying over

I’ll sell you Clyde for $1500. His mane is looking ferocious. Good horse. In other news, are you planning an events that could use a believable Tammy Wynette? $1500 on time booking fee.

No sorry. If only you could pull off a convincing Pam Tillis…

Page 28: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

•••◦◦ Horizon 7G 1:31 PM 1%

< Messages Ashton Details

Mon, Nov 17, 2014 9:59 PM

Mon, Nov 17, 2014, 11:11 PM

Fri, Oct 23 7:15 PM

Another thing…your breath is routinely bad. Like, medically bad. Its like your rotten soul is seeping out of your mouth 1 breath at a time

J/k Or am I?

You remember what we did on National Receptionist Day? Cause I don’t. I just remember your dragon breath.

Don’t be so “Huf”‐y lolololololollolo

I get that you’re mad. We can make this work tho. Come over. You are parked just next door. We can hang out…I just got the box sets of Pretty Little Liars and Dave’s World

You up?

No.

“‘Bout to start looking for a new trailer…money won’t be a barrier to my burning desires...

K

Hello. It’s me.

Page 29: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

BLAER SONDÓTTIR

Page 1 of 2  

1792 Reims Ways, Bedford, Tennessee [email protected]

EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND Doctor of Philosophy in Mechanical Engineering Université de Malesherbes, 1993 Dissertation: “Under the Bridge: The Use of Chemically Altered Traditional Metals in Welding Projects” Winner of the Lesane-Parish Fellowship Master of Engineering, très bien avec félicitations du jury Université de Malesherbes, 1988 Bachelor of Science, Mechanical Engineering, assez bien École de Varennes, 1987 PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE L.XVI, Corp., Lead Mechanical Engineer 1994–1996 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia Dean-Paradise, L.P., Mechanical Engineer 1996–1999 Dubai, UAE Nikoláyevich General, Lead Piping Engineer 2000–2001 Moscow, Russian Federation Whittabago Industries, Inc., Director of Mechanical Interior Design 2001–2004 Forest City, Iowa & Middlebury, Indiana Tennessee Technology University, Henry Wotton Distinguished Professor of Mechanical Engineering 2002–2008 Cookeville, Tennessee Breezy Consulting, LLC 2008–Present Bedford, Tennessee EXPERT TESTIMONY SINCE 2011 Caderousse v. Dantés, L.P., 2011 Saint-Mèran v. D’avrigny, P.L.L.C., 2011 Château-Renaud v. Blaine, Inc., 2011

kristen.corn
Exhibit
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
H
Page 30: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

BLAER SONDÓTTIR

Page 2 of 2  

1792 Reims Ways, Bedford, Tennessee [email protected]

Wentworth v. Guermanetes Group, 2012 Caulfield v. Andervilliers, LLP, 2012 Toole v. Capote, LLC, 2012 Hoyt v. Diver, Inc., 2012 Barban, ex. rel. Barban v. Diver, Inc., 2012 Gregorovius, et al. v. Diver, Inc., 2012 Glass-Coutell, Inc. v. Manufacturer, 2013 Grey v. Manufacturer, 2013 Mingott v. Manufacturer, 2013 Welland, LLC v. Manufacturer, 2014 Allen v. Halberstram Welding Services, Ltd., 2014 PROFESSIONAL MEMBERSHIPS The National Society of Mechanical Engineers, 2001–Present American Society of Professional Engineers, 2003–Present President, 2008–2009 European Association of National Engineering Associations, 1986–2001 Affiliate Member via the Conseil National des Ingenieurs de France PARTIAL PUBLICATIONS LIST (FULL LIST AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST) Hot in Here: Emerging Trends in Welding, The Journal of Mechanical Engineers who Weld, 2002. Dirty Side Up: How to Reuse Compromised Materials in Commercial Developments, MechEng

Magazine, 2006. Where Does that Ladder Go? Optimizing Appliance Installation in Recreational Vehicles, MechEng

Magazine, 2008. PERSONAL INTERESTS I am an avid participant in a local rhythm gymnastics troupe. I also love photography, and I have traveled to more than 15 abandoned theme parks—photographing them with abandon. I am also a dedicated Phan.

Page 31: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

TOMMIE FEHLER, PE 115 Statics Drive, Manning, TN 37205 – (615) 555-8955 Licensed Professional Engineer, with strategic and operational achievement in Engineering, production and quality management roles; Excellent track record in blue chip international organization and in-vehicle appliance technologies; Refrigerator expert extraordinaire

______________________________________________________________________________

EDUCATION Bachelor of Science in Mechanical Engineering (1984) Big Orange Institute of Technology Master of Science in Mechanical Engineering (1985) Big Orange Institute of Technology Doctorate of Mechanical Engineering (1989) Big Orange University Doctorate of Chemical Engineering (1989) Big Orange University ______________________________________________________________________________

KEY STRENGTHS Increased efficiencies, reduced waste and downtime, leading to $150,000/year cost savings Hands-on, results orientated, proactive team leader Focused on customer and business needs, rather than functional needs Worked across all departments to resolve issues and identify practical solutions Initiated and managed strategic change through to successful local level implementation Specialist skills in continuous improvement and world class manufacturing Project management skills to deliver and commission projects on time & on budget Saving money for my employer however possible ______________________________________________________________________________

CERTIFICATIONS FE – Fundamentals of Engineering Licensure (1985) PE – Principles and Practice of Engineering (1989) Tennessee License # 8685309 Geometric Dimensioning & Tolerancing Certification (1992) Forensic Engineering Specialty Certification (1995) Mechanics of Welding and Zincing Certification (1999) Master of Cuneiform Translation Certification (2000) ______________________________________________________________________________

kristen.corn
Exhibit
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
I
Page 32: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

______________________________________________________________________________ MEMBERSHIPS National Academy of Forensic Engineers

- Member since 1995

National Society of Cuneiform Readers Sanskrit Comic Book Translation Club of America

- President since 2000

______________________________________________________________________________

EMPLOYMENT Generic Electrifying Corporation (1985-1989)

- Staff Engineer - Left for new job opportunity at Stratt & Whitney

Stratt & Whitney (1989-1995)

- Structural Forensic Engineer - Left due to corporate politics

Thorobern Appliances, Inc. (1995-Current Time)

- Chief of Engineering - VP of Engineering

Fehler’s Consulting (2000-Current Time)

______________________________________________________________________________ RESEARCH PROJECTS, PODCASTS, LECTURES "A Computer Program for Simulating Sanskrit Writings" Master's Project, Department of Mechanical Engineering, BOIT, 1985. "Review of Methods for Crush Analysis of Automobile Appliances" Research Paper, Special Topics in Finite Element Analysis, BOIT, 1985. "Mechanical Refrigerant Accident Analysis Overview" Podcast Presentation, 2014-2015. Lecture Presentation, Case Studies and Computer Animation Demonstrations, Santa Barbara Trial Lawyers, Santa Barbara, CA, May 2011. ______________________________________________________________________________

Page 33: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

______________________________________________________________________________ EXPERT TESTIMONY Testimony at Jury Trial DirecTIONALITY v. Smye Refrigerants, et. al. (mechanical failure of air conditioner), U.S. District Court for South Carolina, 22 Jan 2004 Smithington v. Stratt and Whitney (mechanical failure of auto engine), U.S. District Court for Colorado, 28 Jun 2004 ______________________________________________________________________________

Page 34: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

CONFIDENTIAL

THOROBERN APPLIANCES, INC.

 

Investigative Report Tommie Fehler, P.E.

January 21, 2015

kristen.corn
Exhibit
kristen.corn
Typewritten Text
J
Page 35: 2016 TENNESSEE STATE HIGH SCHOOL MOCK TRIAL

Background Around January 5, 2015, VP Sam Jones directed William N. Iye and me to visit the site of a

loss claim in Dobbsville, Tennessee. We met the property owner, Ashton Stepinghuf, who took us to a damaged horse trailer. Stepinghuf explained that it appeared that the refrigerator in the trailer had caught fire. Site Visit

Mr. Iye and I entered the door on the aft end of the trailer as it had been the least damaged.

The burn pattern was pronounced above and behind the refrigerator. We removed the refrigerator away from the wall to inspect. The model stamp was visible and read JNY8675E09.

The source piping for the refrigerant ran from the back casing of the refrigerator through the

cabinetry beneath the sink where the storage tank was mounted. The conduit inside the paneling of the cabinetry had been relocated several inches above the rubber grommet from the force of the explosion. There was a visible piece of the piping which had a very small hole that was approximately 1 mm at its widest. The metal was slightly bent inward at the site of the breach.

To be able to get a better look, we requested the property owner’s permission to remove the refrigerator and take it back to Thorobern headquarters. Upon removal of the refrigerator and associated coolant piping, the coolant piping broke in to three pieces. All pieces were labeled according to the flow pathway and photographic documentation was taken.

Analysis

On January 6, 2015, Mr. Iye and I examined the unit in the lab. The entire refrigerator and tank were covered in alkane hydrocarbon residue. This was no surprise as it is a byproduct of isobutane combustion. The piping was inspected under a microscope. New piping from the Thorobern tanks to our refrigerators is cast in either copper or aluminum. These metals enjoy much higher failure tolerances to pressure and heat than traditional metal alloys used for air or water ducting. This particular unit had an older copper casting. Thorobern’s piping is also galvanized to prevent rusting and to reduce the possibility of the metal creating a static discharge. This is done by coating the pipe in zinc. Under magnification, the zinc on the piping will show the direction of force from the explosion emanating from the pipe. This is important to determine whether the explosion began in the isobutane storage tank or was created by backpressure from the refrigerator itself. Neither situation was present in this case. Upon close examination of the piping from Stepinghuf ’s unit, it was apparent that the zinc striations were all focused inward, towards the center of the pipe. A typical explosion would send the metal outward. Conclusion

It appears from the investigation of the Stepinghuf unit that some blunt force hit the exterior

of the coolant pipe and broke the piping. This explains why the piping had a strange bending pattern when inspected inside the trailer at the property. There is no way this explosion could have possibly been caused by any manufacturing defect. The hole in the piping was not in any of the locations where the coolant piping broke while removing the unit.