Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 947
5. Index generalis
Alcune notizie sulla vita e sulle opere di Francesco Rossida Appignano O. Min.........................................................................................5
Tavole sinottiche...............................................................................................................131. Confronto tra le redazioni e le edizioni delle Quaestionespraeambulae...........13
2. Confronto tra le redazioni del Commento al I libro delle Sentenze................ 14
Abbreviazioni.............................................................................................................16
Opere di Francesco della Marca edite da Nazareno Mariani....................................17
Editio textus.............................................................................................................19
Quaestiones praeambulae................................................................................ 21
Quaestio praeambula I: Utrum ens simpliciter simplex possitESSE SUBIECTUM ALICUIUS SCIENTIAE IN INTELLECTU VIATORIS ..............23
Positio quaestionis [1-4]................................................................................................23
Status quaestionis [5] .....................................................................................................24
Articulus I. Quid vocatur ens simpliciter simplex............................... 24
Definitio [6]....................................................................................................................24
Duo corollaria [7-11].....................................................................................................24
Articulus II. Tale simplex compatitur secum aliquam nonIDENTITATEM SECUNDUM QUID ET HOC EST EX NATURA REI .................25
Introductio [12-14] ....................................................................................................... 25
Sed dicunt aliqui quod non [15] ................................................................................. 25
Iste modus est proprius unitati [16-22].......................................................................25
Resumo rationem [23]...................................................................................................26
Contra [24] .....................................................................................................................26
Responsio [25-30] ..........................................................................................................26
948 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Quoad secundum corollarium [31-45] ........................................................
Contra [46-50]..............................................................................................Responsio [51-54] .........................................................................................
Dico aliter [55]..............................................................................................Articulus III. Utrum tale ens compatiatur secum aliquam
NON IDENTITATEM EX NATURA REI .....................................................
Dico duas conclusiones [56-57] ...................................................................Sed contra [58-76].........................................................................................Aliqua distinctio potest concludi [77-82] ....................................................
Contra [83-85]..............................................................................................Articulus IV. Utrum talis distinctio secundum quid suffi-
CIAT AD SCIENTIAM .................................................................................
Quaerenda sunt quattuor [86] ......................................................................
Membrum I. Utrum distinctio talis secundum quid vel non identitatis sal- vet illudprincipium in divinis................................................................
Positio quaestionis [87] .................................................................................Contra [88] ....................................................................................................Solutio quaestionis et divisio videndorum [89] ...........................................Quaesitum 1. De forma istius principii: “Quaecumque uni et eidem sunt ea-
dem inter se sunt eadem”........................................................................
Tres conclusiones [91-93] .............................................................................Quaesitum 2. Quando istudprincipium per se notum valet..........................Corpus quaesiti [94-98] ................................................................................Responsio [99-100] .......................................................................................
Quaesitum 3. Quomodo hoc principium tenet in divinis................................Corpus quaesiti [101-102]............................................................................Membrum III. Utrum salvet medium syllogisticum in divinis ....................
Positio quaestionis [103-104] .......................................................................Duo videnda [105] ........................................................................................Quaesitum 1. Quomodo illud principium teneat in se...................................Duplex ordo terminorum [106-108]............................................................
Sed contra [ 109-110] ....................................................................................
27
28
29
29
30
30
31
33
34
34
34
35
35
3536
36
36
37
37
38
38
38
39
39
39
39
39
40
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 949
Responsio [111-114]............................................................................................... 41
Quaesitum 2. Quomodo illudprincipium teneatin divinis..................................... 41Numquam in divinis tenet forma syllogistica [115-123] ...................................... 41
Membrum IV. Utrum salveturgeneraliter medius syllogisticus per modifi-cationem vel impedimento................................................................................. 43
Modificano est duplex [124-132]............................................................................43
Quaestio praeambula II: Utrum theologia sit de DeoTAMQUAM DE PRIMO SUBIECTO .................................................................. 45
Positio quaestionis [1]..............................................................................................45Contra [2].................................................................................................................45
Respondeo [3] ......................................................................................................... 45Solutio et divisio videndorum [4] ...........................................................................45
Membrum I. Quid sitprimum subiectum in natura et qualiterse habeat............46
Quantum ad primum [5] ........................................................................................ 46
Duplex corollarium [6-8] ........................................................................................46
Quod probo [9-12]..................................................................................................47Sed contra [13-16]...................................................................................................48Corollarium [17-21] ............................................................................................... 48
Sequuntur conclusiones [22-29]............................................................................. 50
Intentio Philosophi [30].........................................................................................51
Dubia et responsiones [31-33]................................................................................ 52Hic est duplex dubium [34-35] .............................................................................. 52
Responsio ad dubia [36-37].....................................................................................53
Tertium dubium [38] ...............................................................................................53Responsio [39-40] ................................................................................................... 53
Membrum IL Quid sitprimum subiectum in scientia...... ..................................... 54
Primum contentum in scientia est prius omnibus contentis in illa scientia[41-50]............................................................................................................. 54
Membrum III. Deus est primum subiectum theologiae.......................................... 56
Positio quaestionis [51-58] ..................................................................................... 56
Tria dubia [59-60]....................................................................................................57
950 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Adrationes [61-63] ................................................................................................. 58
Ideo dico aliter [64-65]............................................................................................58
Quaestio praeambula III: Utrum aliqua scientia ab ista sitDE DeO TAMQUAM DE PRIMO SUBIECTO .................................................. 59
Quaestionem ponit [1] ............................................................................................ 59
Contra [2]................................................................................................................. 59
Respondeo [3-5] ...................................................................................................... 59Pono sex conclusiones.................................................................................................60
Prima conclusio [6-12] ............................................................................................ 60
Secunda conclusio [13-17] ......................................................................................61
Tertia conclusio [18-25] .......................................................................................... 62Quarta conclusio [26-34]........................................................................................ 64
Quinta conclusio [35-37]........................................................................................ 66
Sexta conclusio [38-47] ........................................................................................... 66
Ens potest accipi quadrupliciter................................................................................. 68
Distinguo de ente [48-54]....................................................................................... 68
De ente: quid est?......................................................................................................70
Metaphysica est una vel duplex? [56-59] ................................................................70
Sed hic est dubium [60]...........................................................................................71
Responsio ad dubium [61]...................................................................................... 71
Duplex est metaphysica .............................................................................................72
De ente separato secundum rem et separato secundum rationem [62-66]..........72
Hoc probo [67-68] .................................................................................................. 73
Hoc confirmatur [69-71] ........................................................................................ 73
Forte dices: Haec est quaedam pars metaphysicae [72] .........................................74
Contra [73] ..............................................................................................................74
Forte dices quod est scientia divina [74].................................................................74
Sed contra: duplex est metaphysica [75-78] .......................................................... 75
Quomodo se habet ista scientia de Deo ad theologiam nostram? [79-82]........... 75
Et cum dicitur... [83]............................................................................................... 76
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 951
Duo dubia [84-87] ..................................................................................................76
Responsio [88-90] ...................................................................................................77
Aliterpotest dici [91].............................................................................................. 78
Exemplum [92]........................................................................................................ 79
Quaestio praeambula IV: Utrum theologia nobis revelataa Deo sit scientia proprie dicta............................................................. 81
Quaestionem ponit [1] ............................................................................................81
Contra [2].................................................................................................................81
Solutio [3].................................................................................................................81
Prima quaestio [4].................................................................................................... 81
Contra [5].................................................................................................................82
Secunda quaestio [6] ................................................................................................ 82
Contra [7-9]............................................................................................................. 82
Alius dicit [10-11] ................................................................................................... 83
Responsio [12]..........................................................................................................83
Tres opiniones [13-16].............................................................................................83
Contra [17-23] .........................................................................................................84
Secundo, ad principale [24-25]............................................................................... 85
Item, tertio [26]........................................................................................................85
Responsio ad istas rationes [27-28].........................................................................86
Contra [29-31] ........................................................................................................ 86
Reduco ultimam rationem [32] .............................................................................. 87
Contra [33] ..............................................................................................................87
Probatio [34-41] ......................................................................................................87
Responsio propria [42-44]...................................................................................... 89
Quadruplex genus scientiae...................................................................................... 90
Positio quaestionis [45-50] ..................................................................................... 90
Hoc patet multipliciter [51-57]..............................................................................91
Tria dubia [58-62]................................................................................................... 93
Solutio trium dubiorum [63-66] ............................................................................93
952 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Contra [67] .............................................................................................................. 95Respondeo [68]........................................................................................................95Respondeo aliter [69-71] .........................................................................................95
Quaestio praeambulaV: De scientia practica.....................................97Art. I. Utrum scientia dicaturpractica ab operatione elicita intellectus vel ab
operatione imperata.......................................................................................... 97
Positio quaestionis [1-2].......................................................................................... 97Contra [3-4]............................................................................................................. 97Responsio aliquorum [5-8]......................................................................................98
Operano intellectus quadrupliciter [9-17]............................................................. 98Aliqua veritas et intellectus [18-21]..................................................................... 100
Scientia non dicitur speculativa a veritate [22-25]............................................... 101Conclusio [26]....................................................................................................... 101
Quinque corollaria [27]......................................................................................... 102Primum corollarium [28]...................................................................................... 102Secundum corollarium [29-32] ............................................................................ 102Tertium corollarium [33-34] ................................................................................ 103
Quartum corollarium [35]................................................................................... 103Quintum corollarium [36] ................................................................................... 104
Ad rationes in oppositum [37]............................................................................. 104Contra [38-40] ...................................................................................................... 104
Dico aliter [41-46]................................................................................................. 104Art. IL Utrum scientia practica et speculativa distinguantur per se et primo
ex obiecto vel ex fine....................................................................................... 105Positio quaestionis [47-48] ................................................................................... 105
Contra [49] ........................................................................................................... 106Respondeo [50-51]................................................................................................ 106
Hic sunt tria [52-57] ............................................................................................. 106Dico hic duas conclusiones [58-64]..................................................................... 107Respondeo dupliciter [65-66].............................................................................. 108
Contra [67-68] ...................................................................................................... 108
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 953
Contra [69-80] ........................................................................................................... 109
Contraista [81-86].................................................................................................... Ili
Ad istas rationes ......................................................................................................... 112
Adprimum [87-88]................................................................................................... 112
Ad secundum [89-93]................................................................................................ 113
Ad tertium [94] .......................................................................................................... 114
Dico hic tria [95-97] ................................................................................................. 114
Ad dictum Philosophi [98]....................................................................................... 115
Ad rationem primam [99]......................................................................................... 115
Duae responsiones [100-101] .................................................................................. 115
Si autem quaeras [102-103] ...................................................................................... 116
Quaestio praeambula VI: Utrum theologia nobis revelataSIT PRACTICA VEL SPECULATIVA ................................................................. 117
Positio quaestionis [1-3]............................................................................................ 117
Contra [4-5]................................................................................................................ 118
Responsio ad ista [6-7].............................................................................................. 118
Membrum I. Utrum sit unus habitus velplures..................................................... 118
Theologia est unus habitus [8-12] ........................................................................... 118
Membrum II. Utrum habitus theologiae sitpracticus vel speculativus................. 119
Dico hic tres conclusiones [13]................................................................................ 119
Tres conclusiones probo [14-16] ............................................................................. 119
Ad propositum [17-23] ............................................................................................. 120
Sed contra [24-25]..................................................................................................... 122
Responsio tribus rationibus [26-34] ........................................................................ 122
Ad istas rationes [35-39] ........................................................................................... 124
Liber primus Sententiarum........................................................................... 127
Distinctio 1............................................................................................................ 129
Quaestio I. Utrum actus volendi et actus nolendi diffe-rant specie....................................................................................................... 129
Positio quaestionis [1-2]........................................................................................... 129
954 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Quaedam opimo exponitur [3-5]........................................................................ 129
Pro opinione arguitur [6-8] ...................................................................................130
Contra[9-ll] ...................................................................................................... 130Ad principale [12-14] .......................................................................................... 131
Dico aliter [15]..................................................................................................... 131
Ad rationes [16-17] ............................................................................................. 131
Unde differunt isti actus? [18-24]....................................................................... 132
Quaestio II. Utrum in voluntate sit aliquis actus tertiusPRAETER ACTUM VOLENDI ET NOLENDI REALITER DISTINCTUS ABUTROQUE .............................................................................................. 133
Ponit quaestionem [25] ....................................................................................... 133Contra [26] .......................................................................................................... 133
Respondeo: duplex est ordo actuum intellectus [27-29].................................... 133
Probatur ex dictis [30-33] .................................................................................... 134Forte dices quod non est simile [34]................................................................... 135
Istud non valetpropter duo [35-40]................................................................... 136Sequitur corollarium [41-44] .............................................................................. 137
Ad rationem in oppositum [45]........................................................................... 137
Quaestio III. Utrum prima libertas voluntatis consistat inACTU VOLENDI ET NOLENDI....................................................................... 138
Ponit quaestionem [46] ....................................................................................... 138
Contra [47] .......................................................................................................... 138
Duplex est libertas voluntatis [48-49] ...................................................................138
Libertas convenit duobus [50-58]....................................................................... 139
Confirmatur [59]................................................................................................. 141
Patet per Augustinum et Philosophum [60-64]................................................. 141
Ad rationes in contrarium [65]........................................................................... 142
Quaestio IV. Utrum libertas contradictionis primo respiciatACTUM VOLENDI PER MODUM ACTUS VEL PER MODUM OBIECTI ......... 143
Quaestionem ponit [66]...................................................................................... 143
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 955
Contra [67] ................................................................................................................ 143
Quaerit de libertate simpliciter voluntatis [68]..................................................... 143
Est hic una opinio [69] ............................................................................................. 143
Pro ista opinione [70-72] .......................................................................................... 144
Intendo Anseimi [73-74] .......................................................................................... 144
Contra istam opinionem [75-77]............................................................................ 145
Contra conclusionem arguo [78-80] ...................................................................... 145
Dico aliter [81-82]..................................................................................................... 146
Et quando arguitur [83-85] ...................................................................................... 147
Ad secundum dico [86] ............................................................................................ 147
Ad Anselmum [87-90].............................................................................................. 147
Quaestio V. Utrum libertas contradictionis voluntatis re-SPICIAT NECESSARIO ACTUM VOLENDI FINEM......................................... 148
Quaestionem ponit [91]............................................................................................ 148
Contra [92] ................................................................................................................. 148
Responsio [93]............................................................................................................ 148
Est hic una opinio [94] ............................................................................................. 149
Pro ista opinione arguitur [95-97] .......................................................................... 149
Una ratio prò ista opinione [98-99]........................................................................ 150
Intendo Philosophi deficit in tribus [100] ............................................................. 150
Ista opinio deficit in tribus [101-105] ..................................................................... 150
Sed contra [106-127] ................................................................................................ 151
Ideo dico aliter [128-130]......................................................................................... 156
Pono duas conclusiones [131-136] ......................................................................... 156
Ad oppositum [137-143] .......................................................................................... 158
Ad primam [144-145] .................................................................................................159
Quaestio VI. Utrum libertas contradictionis se extendatAD ACTUM VOLENDI ULTIMUM FINEM IN PATRIA ................................... 160
Quaestionem ponit [146] ........................................................................................ 160
Contra [147].............................................................................................................. 160
956 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Respondeo [148] ................................................................................................. 160
Art. 1. Utrum voluntas creata necessitetur ab essentia divina visa per modani agentis................................................................................................... 160
Corpus articuli [149-151]......................................................................................160Respondeo dupliciter [152-154]......................................................................... 161
Art. 2. Utrum voluntas necessitaretur ab essentia divina, visa per modumfinis, licet non per modum agentis................................................................ 162
Corpus articuli [155-162]................................................................................... 162
Contra hoc arguo tripliciter [163] ...................................................................... 163Forte dices... [164]............................................................................................... 163
Responsio [165-170]........................................................................................... 163
Contra [171-172] ................................................................................................ 165
Dico aliter [173-176]........................................................................................... 165
Ad rationes in contrarium [177-179]................................................................. 166
Ad oppositum [180-183] .................................................................................... 167Contra [184]........................................................................................................ 168
Respondeo aliter [185-186] ................................................................................ 168
Contra solutionem [187] ...................................................................................... 169
Responsio [188] ................................................................................................... 169
Sed ista responsio non videtur sufficere [189-192]............................................ 169
Addictum Anseimi [193]................................................................................... 170
Art. 3. Utrum voluntas beata necessitetur ad actum diligendi Deum ex se etnatura sua intrinseca vela principio intrinseco............................................ 170
Una opimo valde probabile [195] ...................................................................... 170
Pro ista opinione arguì tur [196]......................................................................... 171
Pono duas propositiones [197-200].................................................................... 171
Secunda propositio ostensa [201-205]................................................................. 172
Sed contra [206].................................................................................................. 173
Responsio [207-208]........................................................................................... 173
Exemplum de pondere [209-210] ...................................................................... 174
Ad rationes praecedentes [211-212]................................................................... 175
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 957
Quaestio VII. Utrum voluntas creata viatoris eodem actuVELIT FINEM ET ILLUD QUOD EST AD FINEM ......................................... 175
Quaestionem ponit [213] ................................................................................... 175Contra [214]........................................................................................................ 176
Tria videnda [215] ............................................................................................... 176Membrum I. Utrum intellectus eodem actu numero quo apprehendit com-
positionem propositionis apprehendat extremapropositionis........................ 176
Prima operatio intellectus [216] ......................................................................... 176
Probatio [217-223].............................................................................................. 177Ad principale [224-227]...................................................................................... 178Contra conclusionem [228-229]........................................................................ 179Contra ista [230-232].......................................................................................... 179
Siquaeras... [233] ................................................................................................ 180
Respondeo dupliciter [234-239] ......................................................................... 180Arguo contra modum ponendi principaliter [240-244] ................................... 182
Contra istum modum arguo principaliter [245]................................................ 183Intellectus habet tres actus [246]......................................................................... 183
Quod probo [247-249] ....................................................................................... 184Ad rationes [250-258] ......................................................................................... 184
Membrum II. Utrum intellectus eodem actu numero quo assentit conclusioni propter prìncipium eodem actu assentiatprincipio vel alio actu.............. 186
Principium et conclusio possunt intellegi dupliciter [259-263] ........................ 186
Contra conclusionem [264-269]......................................................................... 187Responsio ad haec [270-271] .............................................................................. 189Ad secundam rationem [272] ............................................................................. 189
Contra istam viam arguo [273-277]................................................................... 190Quod sic declaro [278-279] ................................................................................ 191Tunc ad rationes [280-294] ................................................................................. 191Membrum III. Utrum actus volendi finem et illud quod est ad finem sit
idem actus numero ....................................................................................... 195Ratio intellegendi est duplex [295-300] ............................................................. 195Contra [301]........................................................................................................ 196
958 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Quaestio Vili (vel occasionalis). Utrum intellectus in ultimo INSTANTI DISCURSUS SYLLOGISMI QUO INTELLEGIT CON- CLUSIONEM INTELLEGAT ACTU PRAEMISSAS ........................................ 197
Occasione dictorum, quaeritur [302]................................................................. 197
Contra [303]........................................................................................................ 197
Responsio [304] ................................................................................................... 197
Est hic opimo communis [305-313]................................................................... 198Arguo contra istam opinionem [314] ................................................................ 199
Respondetur [315] .............................................................................................. 200Contra [316-320] ................................................................................................ 200
Contra hoc dupliciter [321-322].......................................................................... 201
Ad principale [323] ............................................................................................. 202Ad haec respondetur tripliciter [324]................................................................. 202
Primo [325-326] ................................................................................................... 202
Secundo [327-329]................................................................................................203Tertio [330-332] ....................................................................................................203
Assentire et dissentire sunt contraria [333]..........................................................204
Veritas et falsitas intellectus consistit primo in actu iudicandi [334-335]........ 204
Hoc dicit Philosophus [336]................................................................................ 204
Conclusio non dependet a principio [337-339] ..................................................205
Corollarium [340] .................................................................................................205Contra [341]........................................................................................................ 205
Responsio [342] .................................................................................................... 206
Sequitur aliud corollarium [343-345]..................................................................206Circa difficultatem dicam duas conclusiones [346-351] ................................... 206
Responsio ad rationes [352-366]..........................................................................208
Ad propositum [367-368] ....................................................................................211Dico duas conclusiones [369-372]....................................................................... 211
Contra [373-378] ................................................................................................. 212
Responsio [379-381]........................................................................................... 212
Contra [382]..........................................................................................................213
Responsio [383-384].............................................................................................213
Respondeo [385-387]........................................................................................... 213
Quaestio IX. Utrum voluntas eodem actu quo vult finemDELECTETUR IN EO ................................................................................... 214
Solutio [388-390] ..................................................................................................214
Responsio [391-394]........................................................................................... 214
Contra [395-399] ................................................................................................ 215Dicoaliter [400-404]............................................................................................ 216
Quod patet tripliciter [405-408]......................................................................... 217
Quod probo [409-410] ....................................................................................... 218
Distinctio II..................................................................................................... 219
Quaestio I. Utrum in universitate entium sit dare aliquodENS UNIVERSALITER PERFECTUM............................................................ 219
Positio quaestionis [1-4]...................................................................................... 219
Solutio quaestionis [5] ......................................................................................... 219Membrum I. Quid intellegitur nomine universaliterperfecti................................... 220
Primum quid est? [6-8]........................................................................................ 220
Quantum ad secundum [9]................................................................................. 221
Quantum ad tertium [10] ................................................................................... 221
Iste est perfectior conceptus quem de Deo possimus habere in vita ista [11] ...... 222
Conclusio [12]..................................................................................................... 222
Membrum IL Ponit octo conclusiones................................................................. 222
Ponit aliquas conclusiones [13] .......................................................................... 222Prima conclusio [14-17] ....................................................................................... 222
Contra [18-22] .................................................................................................... 223
Responsio [23-28] .................................................................................................223
Secunda conclusio [29-34].................................................................................... 224
Tertia conclusio [35-40]..........................................................................................225
Quarta conclusio [41-46] .......................................................................................226
Quinta conclusio [47-55]........................................................................................227
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 959
960 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Sexta conclusio [56-61] ......................................................................................... 229
Septima conclusio [62] .......................................................................................... 230
Octava conclusio [63] ........................................................................................... 231
Istae rationes videntur non concludere [64-69] ................................................. 231Responsiones ad istas rationes [70-76]............................................................... 232
Contra [77] .......................................................................................................... 233Ad rationes [78-82] ............................................................................................. 233
Ad rationes principales [83-87] .......................................................................... 234
Ad propositum [88] ............................................................................................ 235
Quaestio IL Utrum ex causalitate ultimi finis omnium pos-SIT CONCLUDI SUFFICIENTER CAUSALITAS PRIMI EFFICIENTIS OMNIUM...................................................................................................... 235
Positio quaestionis [89-90]................................................................................... 235
Contra [91-93] ...................................................................................................... 236Responsio et divisio videndorum [94] ............................................................... 236
Membrum I. Utrum sit aliqua continentia extrinseca prior continentiacausali efficientis etfinis [95-100] ............................................................... 237
Membrum IL Utrum causalitasfinis sit prior quoad nos causalitate agentisvel e converso [101-103] ............................................................................... 238
Membrum III. Utrum finis habeat rationem causae secundum quod habet esse obiective in intentione agentis vel secundum quod habet esse realiter extra............................................................................................................. 239
Prima opinio [104-107]....................................................................................... 239
Secunda opimo [108-114] .................................................................................. 239
Membrum IV. UtrumDeus sit causafinalis omnium [115-117] ....................... 241Membrum V. Utrum ex causalitate finis possit concludi causalitas agentis
[118-121] ...................................................................................................... 243
Quidam Doctor contra istam opinionem [122-123].......................................... 244
Ad rationes: quia non concludunt [124-126].................................................... 244
Ista responsio non sufficit [127-129]....................................................................245
Arguoaliter contra istam opinionem [130-135] ............................................... 245Responsio [136] .................................................................................................... 246
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 961
Sedcontra [137-141] ..................................................................................................247
Respondeo [142-143] ............................................................................................... 248
Sed contra [144-148] ................................................................................................ 248
Ideo dico aliter [149] .................................................................................................. 249
Ad propositum [150-156] ........................................................................................ 249
Contra [157]............................................................................................................... 251
Quod dicunt Philosophus et Commentator [158-168] ....................................... 251
Respondeo in oppositum [169-172] ...................................................................... 254
Quaestio III. Utrum ex infinitate motus extensiva possitCONCLUDI INFINITAS VIRTUTIS IN PRIMO MOTORE .............................. 255
Positio quaestionis [173-174] .................................................................................. 255
Responsio [175-177]................................................................................................... 255
Aliquid potest concludi de aliquo dupliciter [178].............................................. 256
Membrum I. Utrum ex infinitate motus possit concludi positive infinitasvirtutis intensiva motoris................................................................................... 256
Primum, comparatur ad quattuor [179] ................................................................ 256
0stendo ex quadruplici via [180].............................................................................. 256
Primus modus ostendendi [181-183]..................................................................... 256
Contra [184]............................................................................................................... 257
Secundus modus ostendendi [185-187] ................................................................. 257
Forte dices [188] ........................................................................................................ 258
Contra [189].................................................................................................................258
Tertius modus ostendendi [190-192] ..................................................................... 258
Quartus modus ostendendi [193] ........................................................................... 259
Respondetur dupliciter [194] ..................................................................................... 259
Prima responsio [195]............................................................................................... 259
Contra [196-197] ........................................................................................................259
Responsio secunda [198] ........................................................................................... 260
Contra [199-207] ........................................................................................................260
Contra sunt instantiae [208] .................................................................................... 262
Prima instantia [209] ..................................................................................................262
962 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Secunda instantia [210-211] ............................................................................... 263
Tertia instantia [212-215] ................................................................................... 263Adista respondet [216-217] ................................................................................. 264Contra [218-221] ..................................................................................................265Responsio ad ista [222-235] ................................................................................ 265Membrum II. Utrum ex infinitate motus intensiva possit concludi negative
virtutemprimi motoris non esse injinitam intensive.................................... 268Videtur quod sic propter tria [236-239]............................................................. 268Ad rationes respondetur [240]............................................................................ 270Contra [241-246] ................................................................................................ 270
Respondetur ab aliis [247].................................................................................. 271Contra [248-251] ................................................................................................ 271Potest dici aliter [252-260]................................................................................... 272
Respondeo [261] ................................................................................................. 274
Per hoc ad secundum [262-263]......................................................................... 274Contra hoc est instantia fortior [264].................................................................. 275
Responsio dupliciter [265-266]............................................................................ 275Adpropositum [267]...........................................................................................276
Estne infinita positive? [268-269]....................................................................... 276Salvatur ibi subiectum velocitatis ? [270-271]..................................................... 277Et si quaeras [272]................................................................................................ 277
Ad argumentum in contrarium [273-275]......................................................... 277
Quaestio IV. Utrum prima causa possit producere extra seALIQUEM EFFECTUM ACTU INFINITUM .................................................. 278
Positio quaestionis [276].......................................................................................278
Contra [277]........................................................................................................ 278Responsio [278-279]............................................................................................. 278Infinitum est triplex [280] .................................................................................... 279
Est hic una opimo negans infinitum [281]...........................................................279Primo probatur: De infinito secundum magnitudinem [282-287] ....................279Secundo. De infinito secundum multitudinem [288-291]................................. 280
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 963
Tertio. De infinito secundum intentionem [292-293] ........................................280
Conclusio [294-295].............................................................................................281Arguo contra conclusionem et contra rationes [296] ........................................281
Arguo contra conclusionem [297-307] .............................................................. 281De infinito secundum multitudinem [308-316]..................................................283
Responsio ad haec [317-319] .............................................................................. 284
Dico aliter [320-324]............................................................................................ 285
Deus potest facere infinitum [325-328] ............................................................. 286
Triplex est quantitas distincta [329-333]..............................................................286
Similiter de magnitudine [334-335].....................................................................287Ad rationes [336-341] .......................................................................................... 287
Adaliud [342-343]................................................................................................289
Adaliud [344-348]..................................... 289
Adaliud [349-351]................................................................................................289
Ad aliam rationem [352-353] ...............................................................................290Adaliud [354-356]................................................................................................291
Ad aliam rationem [357-358] ...............................................................................291
Adaliud [359] .......................................................................................................291Adaliud [360] .......................................................................................................292
Hic sunt duo dubia [361-364] ..............................................................................292
Ratio Augustini [365]........................................................................................... 293
Solutio illius rationis [366-367] ...........................................................................293
Secundum dubium [368] .................................................................................... 293
Responsio ad dubium [369] ................................................................................. 294
Ad primum argumentum [370].......................................................................... 294
Distinctio III (pars I): Quid intellectus noster primo at-TINGIT DE SUBSTANTIA SENSIBILI ........................................................ 295
Positio quaestionis [1]........................................................................................... 295
Quaestio I. Utrum intellectus noster naturaliterhabeat ali-QUEM CONCEPTUM PROPRIUM DE SUBSTANTIA SENSIBILI VEL NON..... 295
964 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Respondeo [4-10] ...................................................................................................... 295
Intellectus habet duplicem conceptum [11-13] ......................................................296
Contra [14-16] ........................................................................................................... 297
Dico aliter [17-19]..................................................................................................... 298
Alius est conceptus proprius [20-22]...................................................................... 299
Forte dices... [23] ....................................................................................................... 300
Sed contra [24-27]..................................................................................................... 300
Contra ista [28-30].................................................................................................... 301
Ad istas affirmationes [31-42].................................................................................. 301
Ad alias rationes [43-49] ........................................................................................... 303
Quaestio II. Utrum substantia prius intellegatur a nobisQUAM ACCIDENS ............................................................................................. 305
Positio quaestionis [50-52] ....................................................................................... 305
Respondeo [53]............................................................................................................305
Videnda sunt duo [54].............................................................................................. 305
Triplex modus substantiae [55-58] ......................................................................... 305
Quod probo sigillatim [59-67] .................................................................................. 306
Intentio Philosophi et Commentatoris [68-70].................................................... 308
Contra [71-74] ........................................................................................................... 308
Responsio [75-82] ....................................................................................................... 309
Ad primum in oppositum [83] ................................................................................ 311
Quaestio III. Utrum intellectus noster habeat de acciden-TIBUS NATURALITER ALIQUEM CONCEPTUM PROPRIUM ESSEN- TIALEM ............................................................................................................... 311
Positio quaestionis [84-85] ....................................................................................... 311
Contra [86-87].............................................................................................................311
Respondeo [88].......................................................................................................... 312
Probo, primo, de genere; secundo, de specie [89-93]........................................... 312
Quod probo, primo, sic [94-97] .............................................................................. 313
Contra ista [98-105] ................................................................................................. 314
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 965
Responsio ad haec [106-125] ............................................................................. 315
Quaestio IV. Utrum intellectus noster prius natura intel-LEGAT UNIVERSALE QUAM SINGULARE.................................................. 318
Positio quaestionis [126] ..................................................................................... 318
Contra [127-128] ..................................................................................................319Responsio et divisio videndorum [129-130] ..................................................... 319
Membrum I. Quantum ad suppositum .............................................................. 319
Responsio [131-135]............................................................................................. 319
Quid senserint philosophi [136-137]................................................................. 320
Hic modus dicendi non potest stare [138-146] ................................................. 320
Contra hoc tripliciter [147-151] ........................................................................ 322
Ideo dico aliter [152-157]................................................................................... 322
Membrum IL Circa quaesitum............................................................................ 324
Responsio et divisio videndorum [158] .............................................................. 324
Art. 1. Utrum prius intellegatur a nobis magis universale vel minusuniversale.................................................................................................... 324
Primus modus dicendi [159-161] ....................................................................... 324
Secundus modus dicendi [162-165] ................................................................... 325
Respondeo aliter [166-168] ................................................................................ 325
Art. II. Utrum prius intellegatur a nobis universale vel singulare ................ 326
Secunda pars probatur [169-173] ....................................................................... 326Philosophus videtur varie loqui [174-176]......................................................... 327
Distinctio III (Pars II): Utrum trinitas Personarum possitconcludi ex creaturis......................................................................... 329
Quaestionem ponit [1-3] .................................................................................... 329
Contra [4].............................................................................................................. 330
Quattuor sunt videnda [5] .................................................................................. 330
Membrum I. Quid est vestigium ingenerali......................................................... 330
Vestigium dicitur ab investigando [6]................................................................. 330
Membrum II. In quo differt vestigium ab umbra et imagine.............................. 331
966 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Alii dicunt [9]...................................................................................................... 331
Contra [10-11]...................................................................................................... 332Secundus modus dicendi [12]............................................................................. 332
Contra [13-14] ..................................................................................................... 332
Dico aliter [15-19].................................................................................................333Sed in quo differì vestigium? [20-21]................................................................. 334
Membrum III. In qualibet creatura, reperitur vestigium creatoris quantumad essentialia et appropriata ........................................................................ 335
Creatura ducit in notitiam Trinitatis [22] .......................................................... 335Membrum IV. Quomodo reperiatur in creaturis vestigium quantum ad no-
tionalia et propria......................................................................................... 335Duo modi dicendi [23]........................................................................................ 335
Contra [24-28] ...................................................................................................... 335
Secundus modus dicendi [29-30]........................................................................ 337
Contra haec [31-33].............................................................................................. 337Dico aliter [34-35].................................................................................................338Ad rationes in oppositum [36-40] ...................................................................... 338
Ad argomenta in oppositum [41-42] ................................................................... 339
Distinctio IV: Utrum formaliter terminus generationisDIVINAE SIT ESSENTIA VEL RELATIO VEL SUPPOSITUM..................... 341
Quaestionem ponit [1-3] ......................................................................................341Contra omnia ista [4].......................................................................................... 341
Quattuor videnda [5]............................................................................................ 342
Membrum I. Utrum in creaturis per se relatio sitper se terminus mutationis 342
Differentia inter actionem et mutationem [6-8] ................................................ 342
Hoc probo [9-10] ..................................................................................................343Intendo Philosophi [11-12] ................................................................................. 344
Pono duas conclusiones [13-15]......................................................................... 344
Primam conclusionem probo [16] ...................................................................... 344
Forte dices [17]...................................................................................................... 345
Contra haec [18-25]............................................................................................ 345
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 967
Probatio secundae conclusionis [26-29] ............................................................. 346
Contra primam et secundam conclusionem [30-32] ......................................... 348
Ad rationes [33-40] ............................................................................................. 348
Membrum II. Utrum forma substantialis in creaturìs sit per se terminusgenerationis................................................................................................... 349
Opinio Philosophi et Commentatoris [41-42] .................................................. 349
Contra [43-47]...................................................................................................... 350Contra [48] .......................................................................................................... 351
Forte dices... [49] ................................................................................................. 351
Sed contra... [50-51] ........................................................................................... 351
Ad principale [52-57] .......................................................................................... 352Tunc quaero [58-61] ........................................................................................... 353
Tunc arguo [62-70] ............................................................................................... 353
Dicoaliter [71-72]............................................................................................... 355
Istud probo [73-74]............................................................................................... 355
Ad alias rationes [75-81] ..................................................................................... 356Ad aliam rationem [82-83]................................................................................. 357
Ad tertium [84-85]................................................................................................357
Membrum III. Utrum proprietas indivisibilis in creaturìs sit per se princi-pium agendi et etiarn terminus..................................................................... 358
Natura specifica potest considerari dupliciter [86-87]...................................... 358
Opinio Thomae [88-89]...................................................................................... 358
Ratio Scoti [90]..................................................................................................... 359
Contra Thomam et Scotum [91-95].....................................................................359
Ad principale [96-97] .......................................................................................... 360Secundus modus dicendi [98-101] ..................................................................... 360Contra [102-104] ..................................................................................................361
Dico aliter [105-106]............................................................................................ 361
Ad propositum [107-112] .................................................................................... 362
Pro utroque membro arguo [113-114] ............................................................... 363
Ad rationes alterius partis [115-120].................................................................. 363
968 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Ad rationes alterius partis [121-126].................................................................. 364
Membrum IV. An per se terminus generationis divinae sit essentia vel rela-
tio vel suppositum........................................................................................... 365
Duo modi dicendi oppositi [127-128]................................................................ 365
Responsio [129-131]............................................................................................ 366
Contra [132]........................................................................................................ 366
Responsio [133-136]............................................................................................. 366
Distinctio VI: Utrum actuaeis volitio Filii praesuppona-TUR IN Patre eius generationi ......................................................... 369
Positio quaestionis [1-2]...................................................................................... 369
Contra [3]............................................................................................................. 369
Hic est una opinio extrema [4-8]......................................................................... 369
Contra [9]...............................................................................................................370
Secunda opinio [10-11]....................................................................................... 371
Contra hoc [12-14] ............................................................................................. 371
Dico aliter [15-16]............................................................................................... 372
Primo [17] ............................................................................................................ 372
Secundo [18-21] .................................................................................................. 372
Tertio [22-23] ...................................................................................................... 373
Unum dubium [24] ............................................................................................. 374
Responsio [25-27] ............................................................................................... 374
Si non placet [28]................................................................................................. 375
Ad rationes alterius partis [29-34] ...................................................................... 375
Ad aliam rationem [35-36].................................................................................. 376
Ad alias rationes [37-41] ..................................................................................... 377
Secundum dubium [42] ...................................................................................... 378
Respondeo [43].................................................................................................... 378
Distinctio VII: Utrum Filius in divinis possit generareALIUM FILIUM............................................................................................. 379
Positio quaestionis [1-2]...................................................................................... 379
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 969
Contra [3].................................................................................
Solutio quaestionis [4] ..............................................................
Membrum I.Quid sii formale principium generandi essentia vel relatio
Quantum ad primum [5] .........................................................Contra [6-7]..............................................................................
Responsio [8-9] ........................................................................
Pono tres conclusiones [10-13]................................................
Contra [14-15] .........................................................................Responsio [16-20] ....................................................................
Confirmatur [21] ......................................................................
Contra [22-27] ......................................................................... .
Ad ista [28-35] ..........................................................................
Ad ultimum [36-37]..................................................................
Membrum II.Utrum in Deo possent essepluresfilii.................................
Positio quaestionis [38] ............................................................
Contra hoc dupliciter [39-44] .................................................
Deficit in forma [45-51]...........................................................
Ideo dicitur aliter [52-56] .........................................................
Contra haec [57-59]..................................................................
Forte dices [60]..........................................................................
Sed contra [61-62]....................................................................
Ideo dicitur [63-65]...................................................................
Contra haec [66-68]................................................................. .
Ideo dico [69-71] .......................................................................
Membrum III.Utrumpotentiagenerandi cadatsub omnipotentia.......... .
Positio quaestionis [72] ............................................................
Contra [73-74] ..........................................................................
Dico aliter [75-79].....................................................................
379
379
379
379
380
380
381
381
381
382
383
384
386
386
386
386
388
389
390
390
390
390
391
392
392
392
393
393
970 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Adrationes [80-81] ................................................................................................... 394
Distinctio Vili....................................................................................................... 395
Quaestio I. Utrum ens independens subiective ab alio habe-AT ALIQUID COMMUNE UNIVOCUM CUM DEPENDENTIBUS AB IPSO ... 395
Quaestionem ponit [1-2] .......................................................................................... 395
Contra [3]......................................................................................................................395
Responsio et divisio dicendorum [4]...................................................................... 395
Membrum I. Quae sit dijferentia inter univocum et aequivocum........................ 396
Univocum signifìcat unum, aequivocum vero plura [5-6] ................................... 396
Tria corollaria [7-11] ................................................................................................. 396
Membrum II. Quotsuntgradus univocationis....................................................... 398
Quattuor sunt gradus univocationis [12] ............................................................... 398
Primus gradus [12]..................................................................................................... 398
Secundus gradus [13] ................................................................................................. 398
Tertius gradus [14]..................................................................................................... 399
Quartus gradus [15] .................................................................................................. 399
Membrum III. Utrum ens habeat differentias extra suam rationem..................... 401
Opimo quae ponit tria [16] ........................................................................................401
Primum probatur [17-21] ......................................................................................... 401
Secundum probatur [22-23].......................................................................................402
Tertium probatur [24-26] ...........................................................................................402
Contra primum [27-31] ............................................................................................. 403
Forte dices [32].............................................................................................................403
Contra [33-39].............................................................................................................404
Contra secundum [40-44] ..........................................................................................405
Contra tertium [45-47] .............................................................................................. 406
Dico aliter [48-51]....................................................................................................... 406
Ad rationes alterius opinionis [52-57] ..................................................................... 408
Dico aliter [58-62]....................................................................................................... 409
Membrum IV. Ens est univocum substantiae et accidenti secundum rationem........411
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 971
Quoddedaro [63-67]...........................................................................................411
Contra [68-69]......................................................................................................412Respondeo [70].....................................................................................................412
Contra [71-73]......................................................................................................412
Respondeo [74-75]............................................................................................... 413Ad principale [76] ................................................................................................ 413
Quaestio II. Utrum ens habeat aliquid univocum cum aliisENTIBUS AB IPSO DEPENDENTIBUS ......................................................... 414
Quaestionem ponit [77]........................................................................................414Contra [78] ............................................................................................................414
Responsio et divisio videndorum [79] ................................................................. 414Membrum I. Quid intellegiturper univocum [80-84] .....................................415
Membrum II. Utrum Deo et creatume sit aliquid univocum indifferens exparte rei commune utrisque............................................................................416
Quod probo [86] .................................................................................................. 416
Art. 1. Probatio in communi.................................................................................. 416
Prima via [87-89] .................................................................................................. 416
Secundavia [90-93]...............................................................................................417
Tertia via [94-95] .................................................................................................. 418Quarta via [96] ...................................................................................................... 419
Forte dices [97]...................................................................................................... 419Contra [98-101].................................................................................................... 419
Quinta via [102-104] ............................................................................................ 420
Sextavia [105] ....................................................................................................... 421Septimavia [106].................................................................................................. 421
Art. 2. Probatio in speciali [107-110] ....................................................................421
Contra [111-114] ..................................................................................................422Adista [115-130].................................................................................................. 423
Membrum III.Utrum sit aliquid univocum ex parte rei substantiae et accidenti..................426
Quaestionem ponit [131-137]............................................................................. 426
972 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Contra [138]..........................................................................................................427Respondeo [139-148]........................................................................................... 427Triplex est univocum [149-154]........................................................................... 429
Una ratio prò conclusione univocationis [155-157] ........................................... 431Ad rationes alterius partis [158-160]....................................................................432Membrum IY. Utrum aliquid sit univocum Deo et creaturae secundum ra-
tionem.............................................................................................................432Positio quaestionis [161-168] ...............................................................................432
Modus istius opinionis [169-177]........................................................................ 434
Contra istam opinionem [178-183] .....................................................................437Ad principale [184-189]........................................................................................438Respondeo [190-191] ........................................................................................... 439Ad probationes [192-196] .................................................................................... 439Ad secundum principale [197-200]......................................................................440
Ad inconvenientia [201-205]................................................................................441Sed remanent aliqua dubia [206-216].................................................................. 441Posset dici aliter [217-222] ................................................................................. 443
Posset dici ad rationes praecedentes [223-235]....................................................445
Distinctio X: Utrum Spiritus Sanctus procedat a Patre etFilio libere vel naturaliter.............................................................449
Positio quaestionis [1]........................................................................................... 449Contra [2].............................................................................................................. 449
Solutio quaestionis [3] ...........................................................................................449Membrum I. Voluntas nostra est libera respectu actus sui intrinseci .....................450Opinio de libertate voluntatis [4]........................................................................ 450
Rationes prò opinione [5-7] ................................................................................. 450Responsio [8-12]................................................................................................... 450Contra [13-24] .................................................................................................... 451
Dico aliter [25-31].................................................................................................454Ad rationes alterius partis [32-36] ....................................................................... 455Membrum IL Voluntas divina est libera respectu actus sui intrinseci................... 455
Habet duplicem libertatem [37-43]..................................................................... 455
Corollarium [44-46] .............................................................................................457
Contra [47] ........................................................................................................... 457
Respondeo [48-55]................................................................................................457Hic sunt duo dubia [56-57].................................................................................. 459Responsio [58-60] ................................................................................................ 459
Contra [61] ........................................................................................................... 460Dicitur, secundo [62] ............................................................................................ 460
Contra [63] ........................................................................................................... 460Dicoaliter [64-71].................................................................................................460Membrum III. Spiritus Sanctusproducitur libere................................................461Productio Spiritus Sancti [72-73] ........................................................................ 461
Ad rationem [74] .................................................................................................. 462
Distinctio XI: Utrum productio Spiritus Sancti distin-GUATUR A PRODUCTIONE FlLII RATIONE PRINCIPII PRODUC-TIVI VEL ALIUNDE ..................................................................................... 463
Quaestionem ponit [1] ......................................................................................... 463
Contra [2-3]...........................................................................................................463Solutio [4].............................................................................................................. 464
Videnda sunt tria [5] ............................................................................................. 464
Membrum I. Utrum in creaturisprincipium unius rationispossit esseprin-cipium plurium actionum ..............................................................................464
Ponit duas conclusiones [6-8] ...............................................................................464
Instantia [9]........................................................................................................... 465
Contra [10-17]...................................................................................................... 465Forte dices [ 18-22] ................................................................................................467
Contra hoc arguo dupliciter [23-24]....................................................................468
Responsio [25-28] ................................................................................................ 468
Membrum II. Si idem principium tripliciter possit habere diversos modos...........469
Potest intellegi tripliciter [29-39].........................................................................469
Contra istam opinionem [40-43].........................................................................471
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 973
974 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Neutrum est nobilius alio [44]..............................................................................472
Instantia probatur [45-48]....................................................................................472
Sed contra [49-53].................................................................................................473
Contra [54-59]...................................................................................................... 474
Adrationes [60-67] ...............................................................................................475Est hic una difficultas [68-70] ...............................................................................477
Respondeo [71-73]................................................................................................477
Ad argumenta in oppositum [74-76] ................................................................... 478
Distinctio XII: Utrum Spiritus Sanctus prius procedat aPatre quam a Fino................................................................................. 479
Quaestiones ponit [1-2] ........................................................................................479
Solutio [3].............................................................................................................. 479
MembrumI. Utrum in divinis sit aliquis ordo.................................................... 480
Quid est ordo [4] ...................................................................................................480
Est triplex ordo [5-7]............................................................................................. 480Obiectio [8] ...........................................................................................................481
Responsio [9].........................................................................................................481
MembrumII. Utrum in divinis sit ordo alicuiusprioritatis.................................481
Triplex est prioritas [10-12].................................................................................. 481
Hic sunt duo contraria [13-19].............................................................................482
Hoc non potest stare propter duo [20-30] ...........................................................483
Sed contra [31-34].................................................................................................486
Ad istas rationes [35-38] .......................................................................................486
Contra [39-44]...................................................................................................... 487
Ideo dico aliter [45]............................................................................................... 488
Ad rationes [46-47]............................................................................................... 488
Forte dices [48]...................................................................................................... 489
Respondeo [49-52]................................................................................................489
Obiectio et responsio [53-54]...............................................................................490
Responsio non sufficit [55]................................................................................... 490
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 975
Respondeo [56-58]............................................................................................... 491
Membrum III. Utrum Spiritus Sanctuspriusprocedat a Patre quam a Filio.... 492
Actus spirandi dupliciter [59] .............................................................................. 492
Contra [60] ........................................................................................................... 492
Respondeo [61]..................................................................................................... 492
Prima ratio non concludit [62] .............................................................................493
Respondeo [63-66]................................................................................................493
Distinctio XIII: Utrum Pater et Filius spirent SpiritumSanctum naturaliter vel libere..................................................... 495
Positio quaestionum [1] ........................................................................................495Contra [2].............................................................................................................. 495
Responsio ad quaestiones [3] ................................................................................495
Solutio quaestionum [4]........................................................................................495
Membrum I. Quomodo voluntas divina sit libera respectu actus essentialis....... 496
Voluntas divina est libera [5-8] .............................................................................496
Pro ista conclusione arguo [9-12]......................................................................... 497
Contra hoc aliquae difficultates. Prima difficultas [13-15]................................. 498
Secunda difficultas [16-18]................................................................................... 498
Tertia difficultas [19-20] .......................................................................................499
Contra. Ratio non concludit [21-22]...................................................................499
Responsio [23-25] .................................................................................................499
Contra haec [26-29]............................................................................................ 500
Responsio [30-35] ............................................................................................... 501
Secunda difficultas [36] ....................................................................................... 502
Tertia difficultas [37-44] ..................................................................................... 503
Respondeo [45-46].............................................................................................. 504
Ad rationes alterius partis [47-55] ..................................................................... 505Membrum II. Quomodo voluntas sit libera respectu actus notionalis [56].......... 506
Prima conclusio [57-60] ..................................................................................... 506
Secunda conclusio [61-65] ................................................................................. 507
976 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Alia obiectio [66]................................................................................................. 508Respondeo [67-68].............................................................................................. 508Membrum III.
Quomodo sit libera respectu actus includentis utrumque actum.................. 508Missio est manifestatio personae divinae [69-73] .............................................. 508
Diversificantur opiniones [74-75]....................................................................... 510Ad argumenta in oppositum [76]........................................................................ 511Utrum Spiritus Sanctus inchoètur a seipso [77]................................................. 511
Contra [78] .......................................................................................................... 511Responsio [79]..................................................................................................... 511Utrum Spiritus Sanctus mittatur libere a Patre et Filio [80].............................. 512Contra [81] .......................................................................................................... 512
Responsio [82-83] ............................................................................................... 512
Distinctio XVII: De caritate.................................................................... 513Quaestio I. Utrum habitus caritatis sit necessaria ratio
ACCEPTANDI HABENTEM AD VITAM AETERNAM................................... 513Quaestionem ponit [1] ........................................................................................ 513Contra [2]............................................................................................................. 513Solutio [3-4]......................................................................................................... 514
Membrum I. Utrum caritas sit ratio acceptandi habentem ........................................... 514Ratio elicitiva et ratio obiectiva [5-6] ................................................................. 514
Est ergo quaestio [7]............................................................................................ 515Probatur tripliciter [8-11] ................................................................................... 515Contra ista [12-16].............................................................................................. 516Aliaopinio [17-18].............................................................................................. 517Sed contra [19-24]............................................................................................... 517Dico aliter [25-26]............................................................................................... 518Ad rationes primae opinionis [27-35] ................................................................ 519
Ad rationem alterius opinionis [36-39] .............................................................. 520Ad primum in oppositum [40-43] ...................................................................... 521
Membrum II. Utrum habitus caritatis sit necessarius ad salutem viatoris......... 522
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 977
Quaestionem ponit [44]........................................................................................... 522
Contra [45] ................................................................................................................ 522
Responsio [46-47] ..................................................................................................... 523
Quod probatur [48] .................................................................................................. 523
Contra istud arguo [49-54] ..................................................................................... 523
Dico aliter [55]........................................................................................................... 525
Declaro quomodo [56-58]....................................................................................... 525
Hoc probo [59-60] .................................................................................................... 525
Hoc patet quadrupliciter [61-65]............................................................................ 526
Ad oppositum [66] .................................................................................................... 527
Membrum III. Utrum in augmentatione caritatis gradus caritatis praece-dens maneat in adventu sequentisgradus........................................................ 527
Quaestionem ponit [67]........................................................................................... 527
Contra [68] ................................................................................................................. 528
Hic est una opinio [69-78] ....................................................................................... 528
Contra haec [79-90].................................................................................................. 530
Ideo dico aliter [91]................................................................................................... 531
Ad aliam opinionem [92-96] ................................................................................... 532
Per hoc ad probationes [97-104] ............................................................................. 533
Sunt aliqua dubia [105-107]..................................................................................... 534
Quaestio IL Utrum caritas augeatur per essentiam.......................... 535
Quaestionem ponit [108] ........................................................................................ 535
Contra [109]............................................................................................................... 535
Solutio. Tres modi dicendi [111-113] .................................................................... 535
Contra [114-115] ...................................................................................................... 536
Secundus modus dicendi [116-118]....................................................................... 536
Contra [119-124] ...................................................................................................... 536
Tertius modus dicendi [125-127]............................................................................ 537
Declaro tripliciter [128-135]................................................................................... 537
Adrationem [136-138.b]......................................................................................... 539
978 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Quaestio III. Utrum caritas augeatur per additionem velPER SIMPLICEM ACTUATIONEM ................................................................... 540
Quaestionem ponit [139] ......................................................................................... 540
Contra [140]............................................................................................................... 540
Responsio [141] ......................................................................................................... 540
Ad hoc pono tres conclusiones [142] ..................................................................... 541
Probo multipliciter [143-153] ................................................................................. 541
Sed contra [154-158] ................................................................................................ 543
Responsio [159-169]................................................................................................. 543
Adista [170-175]....................................................................................................... 546
Secunda conclusio [176-185]................................................................................... 547
Probo istud [186-190] .............................................................................................. 549
Contra haec [191-192] .............................................................................................. 549
Responsio ad ista [193-196] ..................................................................................... 550
Tertia conclusio [197-204] ....................................................................................... 551
Contra istam conclusionem [205-210]................................................................... 553
Responsio ad ista [211].............................................................................................. 554
Respondeo ad rationes [212-229] ........................................................................... 554
Distinctio XVIII:Utrum donum sit proprium Spiritus Sancti................................. 559
Quaestionem ponit [1] ............................................................................................. 559
Contra [2].................................................................................................................... 559
Solutio [3].................................................................................................................... 560
Membrum l. Quid sit donum.................................................................................. 560
Quantum ad primum [4-8]....................................................................................... 560
Quantum ad secundum [9-12] ................................................................................ 561
Triplex connexio in tribus divinis personis [13-19].............................................. 562
Contra [20-21] ........................................................................................................... 564
Donum est datio irreddibilis [22-27] ..................................................................... 565
Patet ratione et exemplo [28-31] ............................................................................. 566
Contra ista [32-33].................................................................................................... 567
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 979
Responsio ad haec [34-35].................................................................................. 567
Sed contra haec [36]............................................................................................ 568
Respondeo [37-39]............................................................................................... 568
Membrum II. Donumpotest accipi dupliciter: velformaliter velfundamen-taliter [40-43].............................................................................................. 569
Donum sumitur actualiter aut aptitudinaliter [44-46]...................................... 570
Ad rationem in oppositum [47-48] .................................................................... 570
Sed contra [49-51]............................................................................................... 571
Distinctio XIX: Utrum persona divina sit in alia conver-TIBILITER .................................................................................................. 573
Quaestionem ponit [1] ........................................................................................ 573
Contra [2]............................................................................................................ 573
Respondeo [3-12]................................................................................................ 573
Distinctio XX: Utrum divinae Personae sint aequales se-CUNDUM PERFECTIONEM ........................................................................ 577
Quaestionem ponit [1]........................................................................................ 577
Contra [2]............................................................................................................ 577
Respondeo [3] ..................................................................................................... 577
Tria sunt videnda [4] ........................................................................................... 578
Membrum I. Utrum relatio dicat formaliter perfectionem vel non..................... 578
Quidquid est in Deo dicit perfectionem [5-14]................................................. 578
Hoc potest declarari tripliciter [15-22].............................................................. 580
Ad hoc argumentant alii [23-28]........................................................................ 581
Potest declarari tripliciter [29-37]...................................................................... 582
Posset dici ad istas rationes [38-46] .................................................................... 584
Ad rationes alterius opinionis [47-55] ............................................................... 586
Membrum II. Utrum relatio in deo habeatpropriam entitatem....................... 587
In Deo duplex est entitas [56-59]....................................................................... 587
Contra [60-64].................................................................................................... 588
Ideo dico aliter [65-70]....................................................................................... 589
980 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Ad rationes [71-78] ................................................................................................... 591
Membrum III. Utrum relatio in deo habeatpropriam quantitatem entita-tis seu virtutis velperfectionis secundumpropriam infinitatem..................... 592
Relatio in divinis non est formaliter infinita nec formaliter finita [79-85] ....... 593
Contra [86-93]........................................................................................................... 594
Responsio [94]............................................................................................................ 595
Contra [95-98]........................................................................................................... 596
Respondet tertiaeviae [99-102] .............................................................................. 597
Ex quarta via [103-104]............................................................................................. 597
Ad alias rationes [105-116] ...................................................................................... 598
Sed contra [117]......................................................................................................... 600
Responsio [118-121]................................................................................................... 600
Respondetur ad rationes alias [122] ....................................................................... 601
Ad primam rationem [123-124]................................................................................601
Ad secundam rationem [125-127]............................................................................ 602
Ad tertiam rationem [128-130]................................................................................. 602
Sed contra [131-132] ................................................................................................ 603
Ad tertiam rationem principalem [133-134]......................................................... 603
Sed contra [135-138] ................................................................................................ 604
Ad quartam [139-143] ............................................................................................. 604
Distinctio XXI: Utrum haec sit vera: “solus Pater est Deus”.....607
Quaestionem ponit [1] ............................................................................................. 607
Contra [2]..................................................................................................................... 607
Respondeo [3] ............................................................................................................ 607
Membrum I. Quomodo unum relativum includat aliud relativum................... 607
Aliquid includit aliud [4-16]......................................................................................607
Contra utrumque modum arguo [17-23]............................................................... 610
Contra primum et secundum modum [24-25] ..................................................... 611
Pono tres conclusiones [26-32]................................................................................ 611
Contra haec [33-34].................................................................................................. 612
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 981
Membrum IL Quomodo unum relativum excludat aliud relativum................. 612
Status quaestionis [35-37]................................................................................... 612
Contra [38-40] .................................................................................................... 613
Forte dices [41]......................................................................................................613
Contra [42-51].................................................................................................... 613Dubium [52]......................................................................................................... 616
Explanatio [53-55].................................................................................................616
Ad rationes in oppositum [56-59] ...................................................................... 617Ad rationes alterius opinionis [60-63] ................................................................. 618
Ad rationes alterius opinionis [64-65] ............................................................... 618Responsio ad secundum membrum [66-70]...................................................... 618
Distinctio XXII: Utrum nomina dicta de Deo negative seuPRIVATIVE VEL POSITIVE DICANTUR DE IPSO FORMALITER ............ 621
Exponit duo principia [1] ................................................................................... 621
Quaestio I: Utrum nomina dicta de Deo negative seu privative DICANTUR DE IPSO FORMALITER [2] ............................................ 621
Incontrarium [3] ................................................................................................. 621Responsio [4]....................................................................................................... 622
Membrum I. Qualiter ìsta dicantur de creaturis ................................................ 622
Privatio vel negatio [5] ........................................................................................ 622
Ponit duas conclusiones [6] ..................................................................................622
Prima conclusio [7-12]......................................................................................... 622
Contra [13-15]......................................................................................................623Responsio [16-18] ................................................................................................ 624
Secundam conclusionem probo [ 19-27] ............................................................... 624Contra [28-30] .................................................................................................... 626
Respondeo [31-36]............................................................................................. 626
Membrum II. Qualiter ista dicantur de Deo........................................................628
Nulla negatio convenir Deo [37-42] ................................................................... 628
Hic est dubium [43] ............................................................................................. 629
982 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Sed contra haec [44-46].........................................................................................629
Responsio [47-50] .................................................................................................630
Sed contra [51] ...................................................................................................... 631Respondeo [52-54.1] ............................................................................................ 631Dubium [54.2] ...................................................................................................... 631Responsio [54.3-54.8]........................................................................................... 631
Ad rationes in oppositum [54.9-54.10] ............................................................... 632
Quaestio II: Utrum nomina dicta de Deo positive dicanturFORMALITER DE IPSO [55] ........................................................................ 633
Contra [56-57]...................................................................................................... 633Quattuor sunt videnda [58-59] .......................................................................... 633Art. 1. Secundum quidsit ensformaliter in aliquo [60] ...................................... 633
Art. 2. Distinguendum est de his quae dicuntur de Deo positive [61].................... 634
Art. 3. Quid sit dicendum circa hoc secundum principia aliorum [62-65] ............634Respondeo [66].................................................................................................... 635
Contra [67-73]...................................................................................................... 635Respondeo [74]..................................................................................................... 636
Contra [75-80] .................................................................................................... 636
Contra [81] ............................................................................................................638Respondeo [82].................................................................................................... 638
Contra hoc dupliciter [83-93] ............................................................................ 638Forte dices [94]...................................................................................................... 640
Contra [95-100].....................................................................................................640
Art. 4. Quid sit dicendum secundum ventatemi 101-118] .................................. 641Respondeo [119-125]........................................................................................... 646
Contra ista [126-133]........................................................................................... 648Responsio [134-141]........................................................................................... 649
Distinctio XXIV............................................................................................. 651
Quaestio I. Utrum unum reperiatur in divinis.................................... 651Quaestionem ponit [1] ........................................................................................ 651
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 983
Contra [2]................................................................................................................... 651
Solutio et divisio videndorum [3] ........................................................................... 651
Membrum I. Quale sit unum quod estprincipium numeri.................................. 652
Duplex est unum [4-9].............................................................................................. 652
Contra ista arguo tripliciter [10-14]....................................................................... 653
Duplex est unitas numeri [15-24] ........................................................................... 654
Ad rationes [25-27] ..................................................................................................... 656
Membrum II. Quale sit unum convertibile cum ente.............................................. 656
Quaestionem ponit [28-32] ..................................................................................... 656
Rationes additivae [33-44]........................................................................................ 657
Contra multipliciter [45-53].................................................................................... 659
Responsio [54-57] ....................................................................................................... 660
Contra [58-64].............................................................................................................661
Ideo dico aliter [65-69]............................................................................................... 662
Pro ista conclusione arguo [70-73] ......................................................................... 663
Ad rationes [74-93] ................................................................................................... 664
Membrum III. Quomodo unum et ens reperiantur in Deo................................... 668
De numero in divinis [94-95] .................................................................................. 668
Quaestio II: Utrum numerus in divinis sit forma absolutavel respectiva [96-97]..................................................................................668
Contra [98] ................................................................................................................ 668
Responsio [99]............................................................................................................ 669
Membrum I. Degenere numeri remoto.................................................................... 669
Numerus est quaedam forma respectiva [100-105].............................................. 669
Arguo tripliciter contra opinionem [106-108] ..................................................... 670
Contra [109-120] ........................................................................................................670
Ideo dico aliter [121-123]......................................................................................... 672
Tunc ad rationes [124-127] ........................................................................................673
Membrum II. Degenere numeri propinquo.............................................................674
Numerus est pluralitas determinata [128-129] ..................................................... 674
984 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Contra [130-133] ...................................................................................................... 675
Quaestio III. Utrum numerus in divinis sit formaliter extraANIMAM ............................................................................................................. 676
In Deo numerus non est formaliter extra animam [134] ..................................... 676
Contra [135]............................................................................................................... 676
Respondeo [136-142] ............................................................................................... 676
Pro ista opinione arguitur [143-152] ..................................................................... 678
Contra [153-157] ........................................................................................................ 679
Contra [158-160] ...................................................................................................... 680
Respondeo [161-165]............................................................................................... 681
Ad rationes alterius partis [166-190]...................................................................... 682
Distinctiones XXV-XXVI: Utrum divinae personae consti-TUANTUR IN ESSE PERSONALI PER ABSOLUTA VEL PER RELATIVA....... 689
Quaestionem ponit [1] ............................................................................................. 689
Contra [2].................................................................................................................... 689
Responsio [3].............................................................................................................. 689
Membrum 1.1Quae ab omnibusfidelibus supponunturper viam rationis............ 690
Diversae rationes a diversis [4-19]........................................................................... 690
Distinctio XXVII: Utrum paternitas et filiatio in divinisSINT RELATIONES REALES VEL RATIONIS TANTUM [1] ....................... 693
Contra [2].................................................................................................................... 693
Solutio [3].................................................................................................................... 693
Membrum I. Utrum istae relationes sint reales in creaturis [4-10] ..................... 693
Responsio [11-15] ....................................................................................................... 695
Ad articulum secundum et tertium [16-20]........................................................... 696
Sed contra [21-23]..................................................................................................... 697
Quantum ad primum [24-26].................................................................................. 697
Hic est dubium [27].................................................................................................. 698
Responsio ad dubium [28]........................................................................................ 698
Contra [29-33].............................................................................................................698
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 985
Contra [34-36]......................................................................................................700
Ideo dico aliter [37-53]......................................................................................... 700
Membrum II. Utrumpaternitas etfiliatio sint relationes reales in Deo............... 702Communis modus dicendi [54-59] ..................................................................... 702Contra [60-68].......................................................................................................703
Distinctio XXVIII: Utrum paternitas et generatio sit ea-DEM NOTIO ................................................................................................. 705
Quaestio I. Utrum paternitas et generatio in divinis sintIDEM FORMALITER VEL DISTINCTA ........................................................ 705
Quaestionem ponit [1] ..........................................................................................705Contra [2].............................................................................................................. 705
Responsio [3].........................................................................................................705Membrum I. Quomodo paternitas et generatio sint in Deo..................................705
Hic sunt tres modi dicendi [4]..............................................................................705
Primus modus dicendi [5-8]................................................................................ 706Secundus modus dicendi [9-12] ........................................................................... 706Tertius modus dicendi [13-14] .............................................................................707
Contra primum modum [15-19].......................................................................... 707Contra secundum modum [20-23]...................................................................... 708Contra tertium modum [24-26]...........................................................................709
Ideo dico aliter [27-59]......................................................................................... 709Rationes contra istas opiniones [60-62]............................................................... 715
Responsio [63-66] .................................................................................................715Membrum IL Utrurn paternitas et generatio in divinis distinguantur [67-69]....... 717
Probationes [70-73] .............................................................................................. 717Membrum III. Quod divinaepersonae non distinguuntur nec constituun-
turformaliter in essentia personali per relationes consequentes [74]..............718
Ad rationes [75-77] ...............................................................................................718
Quaestio II. Utrum Verbum in divinis procedat a Patre perACTUM INTELLECTUS ................................................................................ 719
Quaestionem ponit [78]....................................................................................... 719
986 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Contra [79] ...................................................................................................................719
Responsio et divisio videndorum [80] ..................................................................... 719
MembrumI. Quid sit verbum in nobis.................................................................... 719
Est conceptus actualis emanans ab intellectu [81-91]............................................ 719
Membrum II. Quomodo verbum in nobisprocedatper actum intellectus..........ITI
Intellectus comparatur ad duo: ad subiectum et ad obiectum [92] ..................... 722
Pono tres conclusiones [93-98]..................................................................................722
Sed contra [99-100] .................................................................................................... 724
Respondeo [101-103] ................................................................................................. 724
Secunda conclusio [104-105].....................................................................................725
Tertia conclusio [106-114] .........................................................................................725
Quod si dicatur... [115-126].......................................................................................726
Intendo Augustini [127-132].....................................................................................729
Membrum III. Utrum Verbum divinumprocedat per actum intellectus.............. 730
Intellectus divinus potest comparari tripliciter [133-136].....................................730
Contra [137-138] ........................................................................................................ 731
Contra primum [139-140] .........................................................................................731
Contra secundum [141-147] .....................................................................................732
Contra [148-150] ........................................................................................................ 733
Conclusio [151] ...........................................................................................................734
Ad rationes alterius opinionis [152-154]..................................................................734
Ad argumenta in principio [155-156]...................................................................... 735
Distinctio XXIX: De ratione principii ad extra et intra............737
Quaestiones ponit [1-4] ............................................................................................. 737
Quaestio I. Utrum tres Personae sint unum principium crea-turae.................................................................................................................. 738
Respondeo [5-16] ........................................................................................................738
Quaestio II. Utrum Pater et Filius sint unum principium Spi-ritus Sancti..................................................................................................... 740
Tres personae et principium quo et quod [17-29] .................................................. 740
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 987
Quaestio III. Utrum principium dicatur univoce in DominoDeo de principio ad intra et principio ad extra...................... 745
Principium potest accipi dupliciter [30-34]........................................................ 745
Ad rationem primae quaestionis [35-36]............................................................. 746
Distinctio XXX: Utrum Dei ad creaturam sit aliqua rela-tio realis.................................................................................................. 747
Quaestionem ponit [1]......................................................................................... 747
Contra [2].............................................................................................................. 747
Responsio et divisio videndorum [3]....................................................................747
Membrum I. De modis relationis in generali...........................................................748
Triplex est relatio [4-7] ......................................................................................... 748
Probatio [8-19]...................................................................................................... 749
Membrum II. De modis referendi Deum realiter ad creaturam ........................ 751
Eadem relatione reali tripliciter [20-29]............................................................. 751
Membrum III.Quomodo Deus referatur realiter ad creaturam secundum aliquemillorum modorum......................................................................................... 754
Relatio Dei ad creaturam est duplex [30-36] ....................................................... 754
Pono tres conclusiones. Prima [37-39]................................................................. 756
Secunda conclusio [40-46] ................................................................................... 756
Tertia conclusio [47-54] ........................................................................................757
Contra [55-57]...................................................................................................... 759
Dei ad creaturam non est aliqua relatio realis [58] ............................................ 760
Contra [59-62]...................................................................................................... 760
Alii probant conclusionem per hoc [63-64] ........................................................ 760
Aliter potest probari ista conclusio [65-67] ....... 761
Membrum IV.Quomodo Deus referatur ad creaturam secundum rationem......................... 762
Relationes rationis sunt in Deo [68-70]............................................................... 762
Corollarium [71-72] .............................................................................................762
Ad argumentum in oppositum [73] .................................................................... 763
988 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Contra [74] ............................................................................................................764
Respondeo [75]..................................................................................................... 764
Distinctio XXXI: Utrum identitas similitudo et aequali-TAS PERSONARUM DIVINARUM SINT RELATIONES REALES VELRATIONIS TANTUM ................................................................................... 765
Quaestionem ponit [1-2] ......................................................................................765Contra [3-4]...........................................................................................................765
Responsio et divisio videndorum [5]....................................................................765Membrum I. Defundamentis istarum relationum ingenerali.......................... 766Quaestionem ponit [6-10].................................................................................... 766Membrum II. De conditionibusfundamentorum in speciali................................767
Duplex est relatio [11-12] ..................................................................................... 767Primumpatet [13-16]........................................................................................... 768
Secundum patet [17-25] .......................................................................................768Sed illud non potest stare [26-29]........................................................................ 770Ideo dico aliter [30-33]..........................................................................................771Corollarium [34] ...................................................................................................772Membrum III. De conditionibusfundamentorum in speciali..............................772Istae relationes non sunt reales in creaturis [35-43]............................................. 772
Aliaopinio [44-51].............................................................................................. 774Responsio [52-56] .................................................................................................775Quod declaratur primo de aequalitate, secundo de aliis [57-70].......................775Tripliciter prò hac opinione [71-81].....................................................................777
Patet responsio ad rationes opinionis [82-88] ..................................................... 779Primum non obstat [89-92].................................................................................. 780Secundum non obstat [93-96] ..............................................................................780Similiter ad rationes alterius partis [97-114] ....................................................... 781Membrum IV. Utrum istae relationes sint reales in Deo...................................... 785
Istae relationes non sunt reales in Deo [115-127] ............................................... 785Respondetur [128] ................................................................................................788
Contra [129-131] ..................................................................................................788
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 989
Ad principale [132-135]....................................................................................... 788
Contraista [136-138]...........................................................................................789
Responsio ad haec [139-148] ............................................................................... 790
Distinctio XXXIII: Utrum relatio originis comparata adESSENTIAM DIVINAM TRANSEAT IN IPSAM REAEITER VEL FOR- MALITER VEL TOTALITER........................................................................ 793
Quaestiones ponit [1] ........................................................................................... 793
Arguo per unicum medium [2].............................................................................793
Contra [3].............................................................................................................. 793
Responsio [4].........................................................................................................793
Membrum I. De entriate relationis in creaturis....................................................794
Relatio in creaturis habet duplicem modum: modum essendi in et mo-dum essendi ad [5-6].....................................................................................794
Pro ista conclusione arguì tur in creaturis [7-10]..................................................794
Contra opinionem arguit [11]..............................................................................795
Forte dices [12]...................................................................................................... 795
Contra [13-18] ...................................................................................................... 795
Dicoaliter [19-22].................................................................................................796
Ad rationes [23-29] ...............................................................................................797
Membrum II. De identitate relationis cum essentia in divinis.............................799
Una opimo exponitur [30-35] ..............................................................................799
Contra istam conclusionem arguo [36-41] ........................................................ 800
Aliaopinio [42-43]................................................................................................801
Contra [44-46]...................................................................................................... 801
Dico aliter [47-50]............................................................................................... 802
Ad argumentum in oppositum [51-52] .............................................................. 803
Ad rationes opinionis primae [53-56]................................................................ 804
Distinctio XXXIV: I. Utrum relatio in Deo sit totaliterEADEM ESSENTIAE DIVINAE II. UTRUM RELATIO SIT TOTALI- TER EADEM PERSONAE CONSTITUTAE III. UTRUM ESSENTIA SIT TOTALITER EADEM PERSONAE ........................................................ 807
990 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Per unicum medium arguo quod sic [1].............................................................. 807Contra [2].............................................................................................................. 807Responsio et divisio ponendorum [3] ................................................................ 807MembrumI. Ponuntur aliqui modi dicendi...................................................... 808Ad primum est unus modus dicendi [4-5].......................................................... 808Probatur quod ita sit [6-7] ................................................................................... 808Contra istam opinionem [8] ............................................................................... 809
Quod probo [9-27].............................................................................................. 809Contra primum:
membra distinctionis includunt contradictionem [28-39] ....................... 813Membrum II. Dicendo, ad quaestiones............................................................... 816Pono tres modos [40-43].......................................................................................816Distinctio personarum secundum quid [44-48] ................................................ 816
Quod ita sit declaro [49-55]................................................................................ 817De effectibus formalibus aliquorum [56-57] ...................................................... 819Arguo prò conclusione [58-63.e] ........................................................................ 819
Quaestio IV seu occasionalis. Utrum essentia divina et re-LATIO DISTINGUANTUR SE IPSIS .............................................................. 821
Positio quaestionis [64] ....................................................................................... 821
Contra [65] .......................................................................................................... 821Responsio. Tria videnda [66]............................................................................... 821Membrum I. Quid sit distingui se ipso ab alio........................................................ 821Positio quaestionis [67-69] ................................................................................. 821
Membrum II. Utrum essentia et relatio se ipsis distinguantur........................... 822Essentia distinguitur a relatione [70-72]............................................................. 822
Quod probo [73-75] ........................................................................................... 822
Accipio tertiam rationem [76-77]....................................................................... 823Contra istud [78-82]........................................................................................... 824
Dico aliter [83-85]............................................................................................... 825Ad rationes [86-89] ............................................................................................. 826Membrum III. Utrum trespersonae distinguantur se ipsis................................. 827
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 991
Tres personae conveniunt secundum rem absolutamet differunt relatione [90] ........................................................................... 827
Arguitur prò ista opinione [91-95]..................................................................... 827Contra opinionem [96-110] ............................................................................... 828
Distinctio XXXV: Utrum futurum contingens sit deter-MINATUM IN RE AD ALTERAM PARTEM CONTRADICTIONIS ............. 833
Contingens et necessarium [1-2]........................................................................ 833
Responsio [3-4] ................................................................................................... 833
Pro ista opinione arguitur [5-10]........................................................................ 834Contra opinionem [11-20]................................................................................. 835Ideo dico aliter [21-25]........................................................................................ 838Probo de ista secunda indeterminatione [26-30] ............................................... 839
Ad rationes alterius opinionis [31-53] ............................................................... 840
Contra [54-55].................................................................................................... 844Responsiones [56-60] .......................................................................................... 844
Distinctio XXXVI: Utrum effectus contingens sit determinate SCIBILIS PER CAUSAS CONTINGENTES .................................. 847
Quaestionem ponit [1-2] .................................................................................... 847
Contra [3]............................................................................................................ 847Responsio et divisio videndorum [4].................................................................. 848Membrum I. Quomodo contingentia sit in rebus................................................ 848
Duplex est contingentia [5-11]........................................................................... 848Secunda contingentia est actuum voluntatis [12-16]......................................... 849Contingentia potest ostendi tripliciter [17-20] ................................................. 850Membrum II. Quomodo effectus contingens sit cognoscibilis per causas con-
tingentes ....................................................................................................... 851Notitia probabilis et certa [21-27] ...................................................................... 851Contra istam conclusionem [28-29]................................................................... 852
Quaero de determinatione [30-35]..................................................................... 853Ideo dico aliter [36]............................................................................................... 854
Pono duas conclusiones [37-43]........................................................................... 854
992 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Secunda conclusio [44-49] .................................................................................. 856
Ad rationes alterius opinionis [50-56] ............................................................... 857
Membrum III.Utrum Deus habeat determinatavi notitiamfuturorum contingentium..... 858
Declarat tripliciter [57] ....................................................................................... 858
Primo [58-59]...................................................................................................... 858
Secundo [60-62] .................................................................................................. 859
Tertio [63-65] ...................................................................................................... 859
Contra ista [66-70].............................................................................................. 860
Responsio [71-85] .................................................................................................861Membrum IV.
Quomodo Deus cognoscat determinate ipsa contingentia............................. 864
Tres modi dicendi [86] ........................................................................................ 864
Primus modus dicendi [87] ................................................................................. 864
Contra [88-91].................................................................................................... 864
Secundus modus dicendi [92]............................................................................. 865
Contra [93-95] .................................................................................................... 865
Tertius modus dicendi [96-97] ........................................................................... 866
Contra [98-107]................................................................................................... 866
Ideo dico aliter [108-109]................................................................................... 868Conclusio [110-112]........................................................................................... 868
Distinctio XXXVIII:Utrum praedestinatio futurorum contingentium im-PONAT NECESSITATEM LIBERO ARBITRIO ............................................ 871
Quaestionem ponit [1]........................................................................................ 871
Contra [2]............................................................................................................. 871
Respondeo [3-5] .................................................................................................. 871
Tria videnda [6] .................................................................................................... 872
Membrum I.Utrum praescientia futurorum sit in se necessaria vel contingens ................ 873
Praescientia futurorum potest considerari dupliciter [7-12] ............................. 873
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 993
Contra [13-16] .................................................................................................... 874
Membrum II. Utrum praescientia sit necessaria respectu liberi arbitrii velsit contingens respectu eius\\7-\7i\............................................................. 875
Membrum III.Utrum praescientia imponat necessitatem libero arbitrio vel non................ 876
Dicitquodnon [18-33]....................................................................................... 876
Distinctio XXXIX:Utrum in Deo sint ideae infinitae..................................................881
Quaestionem ponit [1] ........................................................................................ 881Contra [2]............................................................................................................. 881
Responsio et divisio videndorum [3].................................................................. 881Membrum I.
Aliqui modi dicendi Deus intellegit omnia et singula.................................. 882
Haec videtur esse intendo et auctoritas Augustini [5] ....................................... 882
Triplex modus dicendi [6]................................................................................... 882
Primus modus dicendi [7-10].............................................................................. 882Contra hoc [11-16] ............................................................................................. 883
Contra opinionem arguitur [17-19]................................................................... 885Tertius modus dicendi [20-24] ........................................................................... 885
Sed contra [25-29]............................................................................................... 886Conclusio [30]..................................................................................................... 887Membrum II.
Dicitur ad quaestionem................................................................................ 887
Art. 1. Quomodo idem sub eadem ratione potest esse ratio intellegendipluradistincte [32-36] ........................................................................................... 887
Art. 2. Ad quidponuntur ideae \37-41] .............................................................. 889
Opinio propria [42]............................................................................................. 890Art. 3. Quale esse habeant ideae [43-47] ............................................................. 890
Sed contra [48-51]............................................................................................... 892Solutio [52-55].................................................................................................... 893Esse cognitum vel volitum dicit duo [56-58]..................................................... 894
Ad argumenta [59-67] ........................................................................................ 894
994 5 - INDEX GENERALIS
Distinctio XL:UTRUM PRAEDESTINATIO HABEAT ALIQUAM CAUSAM EX PARTE PRAEDESTINATORUM ......................................................................... 897
Positio quaestionis [1].......................................................................................... 897
Contra [2]............................................................................................................. 897
Respondeo [3] ..................................................................................................... 897
Quattuor modi dicendi [4]................................................................................. 898
Membrum I.Primus modus dicendi depraedestinatione et reprobatone [5-12] .............. 898
Contra istam opinionem [13-19]........................................................................ 899
Membrum II.Praedestinatio et reprobatio habent aliquam causarn.................................. 901
Pro ista opinione arguitur [22-25] ...................................................................... 901
Contra opinionem est Augustinus [26-34].......................................................... 902
Membrum III.Radix distinctionis non venit ex operibus bonis et malis.............................. 906
Tertius modus dicendi [35-41] .............................................................................906
Contra haec sunt omnes rationes Augustini [42-47] ......................................... 908
Ista opimo non videtur rationalis [48-50] .......................................................... 909
Membrum IV.Electio electorum non habet causarn nisi voluntatem eligentis..................... 910
Hic est quartus modus dicendi [51-52] .............................................................. 910
Pro ista opinione arguitur [53-54] ...................................................................... 910
Pro ista opinione videntur Apostolus et Anselmus [55-56]...............................911
Contra istum modum arguo [57-59].................................................................. 911
Contra conclusionem [60-62] ............................................................................ 912
Dicoaliter [63]..................................................................................................... 913
Triplex est voluntarium [64]..................................................................................913
Ad propositum [65-84] .........................................................................................914
Appendix: Partes carentes in textu 919
5 - INDEX GENERALIS 995
Bibliographia........................................................................................................921
I. Fontes et editiones ........................................................................................... 921II. Studia.................................................................................................................925
Indices......................................................................................................................... 929
1. Index codicum manuscriptorum..................................................................... 9312. Index locorum Sacrae Scripturae..................................................................... 9333. Index auctorum et operum citatorum............................................................. 9354. Index nominum personarum .......................................................................... 943
5. Index generalis.................................................................................................. 947