BU-9-14-Musalmanoun Ki Siasi-O-Milli Zindagi Ke Rahnuma Usool

8/3/2019 BU-9-14-Musalmanoun Ki Siasi-O-Milli Zindagi Ke Rahnuma Usool

1/38


2/38

Zka|tM8gVfZ/Z~IZs

0*

kz{LL%/

~,

TZ

Kz{~zg]

xz wZzg%z7g~YCTazu~V!*{({w heroes) zZxBoV"$F,ZZzgz

LLF,ZCx}.Zz0+} 87,@*X'h+',MV*zu~ZZx/]Zt6gCzg~Zq-5,"$F,Z/pIZs

(cultural 0*kZq-Zz%/ZkpD]]$n )ZkZgY continuity)~[s/ZxgZyZv:Z7 ]#

@*#7g~Q#0(XZkzZxZzgBBQ#0zZzg;6,{gt|tMCtM8gV

LL%/e$x{ZfJ-#x ~zyh+Z%sZzg@*g]z'Z5ZZZZXZzgZq (cultural homogeneity) Zq-~pDq-g

g6,Zk|6,GgxecZ~e{e{VZzgLLoV'Zq-uJ-Qg**ecZkzi

g]~ZkLLzuIa,$zgZ0+6Xc*w )ZDwCtiZ],+w*f[DZggFg}>ZyzZH**Mg!

gzi}xyZZx]Zq-gecZzgz{fZ

Z{Z!zQX DDD VVZP{!*zCzV~Zq-ic*{F,[z

xZzgzu~_.!*CX6,2gzyZgzZgZzgzu~6,

d$

zpyCZzgZyzV!

*bgZ

q-Z

],}ZzgZk %/XyZZkZ],}~LLgZvZzgQk

gwZxc*ZzgZk%/wM8gVHzm,ZzgZi,qXZnq_."ZkZpD

q-gCZzgXgZkZZZq-%/

zZhgTZzg!*/a}gTX )Z[Zkmg]BMVLLgf~LLj+1e$gZiF,-

YEG!]ZtX( xZZ

zuZzZyZ]6,X6,cZIZsZZZzg/zVZzg)oVg_0IG0zZ$zg

Zk**]YDZzgZ%szZ_OgZzgzY(,"gzYY XZyZ]'h+zZ**]~HYYXZq-z{ZF,ZxzWe6,/zVxcDZzgzu}z{CgLpw.e$C~Zx{ZZ~R6,]ZzgZz]!*[DX

lxZZxz:)1(ZZVgzuxZzgZzgiZzg)2(4,Zq )1( ZZxIZhbz)ZzgYyZx

zZYg]~9X:

2

EEFoe^e^] )1(Zke~M8gVtZpIgu-ge

EvnxX]Xe^h]o]vm&e^D m%

v'e

^DD LLZq-Lat!*]!*z{QMy

}X)MyIZkz&:}X(


3/38

t*ZZf)Zg~ZzgCnYX ]D

gzl

g97X(indifference)

c*

W

(ZkZ/Zq-&ic*C6,^gZ[Zks& h: ] DDDD U*77g~Z**ec

(Z#z{/yq}Ziuwzm6,FF*Z~YX)Zkx6, twZzgm(gf{mg6,ZkaZ#7g~Z

Zk&Z~g6,ZkZkyz!*g{*~Zk &6,VZzg]?6,ic*CY!(yZZxbZ6,Zy~bC',ZVI

c*HX!*)!*kxzZZc*/zVg_0IG0zZ$zgzg]aZ 7,Y@*ZzgZk(]zZz]@1YDZzgZ+

YCQb7XZkax[Zi_.ZgzV vYDpi!*yinLq7D!z{bq,t:)Zk!*[aZk.e$~|sZg{HH 1(

Zq-ZKyzu}ZKysC8ZzgZzz%>qZqZKy!*Zzg}.Z{~ZKV

gz7Qy!*C6,X( 2(Zzgo)Zkfs~Zk|szZ#yM:~zu}y**c*pZL

M\**X(3(),!*[Vc*/zVM**xg8)ZkK~

Zg{c*Zsx',Z**x.e$',ZX(4()ZkakH{gZ~X(

] 5(

6(My

~ZzgZF,+

T)

Zgau

gz

$h4->

GIEGX Z(gtyZ+%{

3**X)ZkaTbZq-%{ZLq7YZbZq-)ZK]D6,g7@*X(

ZnZyMJZzZ%zZVZZPx[X

ZkaTb(,~(,~kqwZAVCZzgZk ZPxZgzZgVZAVZzg6,@*z;VZAV

(cement substance) hzZg}c*ac*v)0*GZg~6,@*XZbIZsZPxaTgV~CC]zZgZg**zg~Z

gQyg_0IG0

zZZ2Zg~iXtZ%zZg IZsZPxxgZ]E~zZMZga7LL*~Z**xg!]ZtZv Zka[z{

! (instrument) i}6,Zv%7g~fg=ZzgM!ZzzZZIt#6,!

cZKy]zsg0Tfs~zZ MDc*HZKy]zfc*ZzgfZg:_:F:{0+Zy:x:g8-::o:z:z:W,z]::g]:w:zY>:&:wZzg:x:%sLLZka7g~ZKZq-}.ZtZzgZq-

ZKh})MxzjZ(ZzX tc.e$ZZkazZt*~$+Z*Zzg

3


4/38

Z_OgZzgZKVxZzgZ(,Z:LZzgzg

Zzgtz

/z

y]Z

Ko

]Z

:LkX )1( )Zke~t|7g6ecM8gV$+F,+

2sM\zZ.ZK]zsP{!*xCzVxc*ZzgZK)zZ]ZzgZp]CzV6,Zq-{nc*!(p{mg6,Zkx6,Zkczcz:Zq-tIX

Y',ZVIc

*H}zZZYZzgz$

+Zya

~eZgz{Z~zC6,yzn_./XZzgzu}tZsxZy~qC6,ZKV&zb7z{Zq-{c*C{Zzggc***eLX

ZkVZKVsZq-xZzgz{ZZyZzg

Z3

XLZZy~Zk4,q-sZq-]zsxZzg z{g!Zke~:g6,Zq-zu~.e$Z|sZg{HtZs{Zzggc*!*ZKzVZzggc*2Vg*zm

ZyzCzV6,Y7g~ZKu:

)1(zuZ[Zzg)2(zuMxXZZ|ZY/aZkx m5^m%^]$m!] 6,Zkg]xZ|[?OLLZX)zZgMy~g>ZZ]ZkMe$ m5^m%^]$^ LL

IgFg>ZYMe$T~txZq-aF,KM

yX( zu~ZcZsxZzgZZytzZqizs#0! NDzZgMy~ZZyzZsxZzgzZq]Zz9pZzgZsZpwZEwXZkazZtZq-k,zcXZzgZZyZKyTZ**x

ZsxZk{gYgZZK

y~ZZyzz

grZzg ]m&^$^i]] ~ZsxZzgZ)gzlZ(gQ

]Zte )1( ZzgZq-Zm,~k Eeo]]mVLMMD t ]vFo1Ye!*]Zq-gsZkxVZZyzZsxZq-zu}.c*HZzgZZy!ZZZsx

Zm]HHX Zkx6,ZkcZttZZzgC~|zZYZs}~qZzgZsgc*e$CZZy6,7Zsx6,ZkaZZyZq-!*m|cz)Zzg**\wq70$XZ6g~*~

ZK5]s{gYgzbC6,Z2ZgHYT~ZZyzZUYX ]]e^^ ic*{ic*{sLL

Zkz{Zkcz'h+xY+$g:Zq-tZKyZq-Z+qeZkw~:z

ZX!g6,ZZy:tzg6,tZq-pZk~ZvZzgZkgwZ)XZkqw~Z/pZk

4

ZKLL@*g~M8gV (H.G.WELLS) OZYz? )1(.e$ [!ZZqfs~zZg6,ZZgHZK)zZ]ZzgZp]

ZzzZ/

p[**

~)d"545EEG

EzmZ}>zZ?x(Vp ZyCzV6,@*g~!*gZq-}zZxs!)VzZ{Z!

zZ(g**)X(CALL THE ROSE BY ANY NAME IT WILL SMELL AS SWEET) )1(


5/38

{gz%ZZyZKy!*g}.Zz0+~~=w7Yt

qFF',wC

Z+Z

)Jw

:YC

ptZv\

Sazx)TY+$Zg{zZ^gZzggc*H(Zk

Z)Jw~X)zZgM8gVC ]mk]$^mom]#]]q^ My~zg~Z#

g]QkzVZZyzZsx E]D

Zzg~Czg~Q#0ZZWqwtg;!( zu}tZZyZq-YzpyZzgzZ6,Z, )1( c*HZ"ZZy**xZvZzgZkgwV

T~uz2]:g{VZzgTZAZzgc*VF,+i1ZvXtZKy@Ze$MzZ)h

]ZzgZv+VzZzgZkzZgaYyzw }ZzgZk].z4~@!*y}XMe$My~'h+wc*HsZ,vZLZZZy~FX

]$^]+]$m!]e^# g>ZZ]ZkM`]5a $$miê]qâ]e^]`]òfn]#

6,c*g}[bzU*ZzgbzU*zq O ]#Y@*XZkag>Zu~y{egZi]ZkMe$~zZq]~c*HZq-ZZYZZZzg)LzVZzgzu}ZvYZ!*/ZzgZ!*.EXODZ!*/-cMi@*X

]e^#

]n_]qne]#

]u]un]$]# m5^m% ^]$m!]i]enmp]#]i$]]#

A nnLLZ}ZZyzZ!#M(,ZvZzgZkgw)V(ZzgZvZ(gzXGZvGgzZY+zZX

_M

yT[zZggkZyW~g; Zkgka{g>ZZ]6,XF,KMZgtgIgZVg{Mc*]ZzgzgV6,62z,0*g}~g>ZgUzZgXZ/Zkp}6,gHYt|tMCg>ZMy~zMc*]~p}Mt7g~gIgZy'h+

=Zzg6,X g}[~g**yZgZkxZf~@*i{8ZyYZvXZk[ZzZq

It#6,XZqZKK~zgzk~ZZ~]zZg0Mygg}tMXZkZq-gk

~ZZe$Zsxywi0+{0+ZyZZg{ xZk07g~g>Z*7,SXZi0+~ZkF,R6,g~Cc*Yi0+Z],{XZk0/gk~gZuZL}Zzgagq_HXZ[ZF,+RzBZzg(zgc*4i0+Zk0.e$Zp}

ZkgIg~zZggXMy_Dt!*]fdg6ecMyZk

5

)1(zZgzu}ZZ*]Zyfs~M\M\qg`X


6/38

b[7xg6,ZK"CXZK"~

Z1Z[

D

XQC!*

[

Zq-

Zy@*

Zk!*

[p}

K0+@*XQz{!*[f~Z**]c*8w~@*ZzgC`~cZq-zY@*Myg|Zkq[7ZhZMhZzgt7X*VzgZyZZZzg%Zi6,thZ**iw

DgZzggV

Zz!Xq]Z]ZZ] Zzg#V7M@*Zyo9LgV@Zc*]~YCgZzg**iwCgXZyK~z{ZEzZ$+~gZw}bX6,Zv\Zk*~ZKyZi0+Z2Zg9eTpZyaMy~gzZzgD+',ixXZyxZzgZ~.

aMc*]Zkg7,@*ZzggVp}t tq7,CVyZEZzgZ$+~gZwgXZkUZ/g,Z/pg>ZZ]4,zwK~

]jf^ gzZc*]QpMyZq-xZwLLZp MyK~ZZg ]]fg

x:Zk:L{mzZZg4,zw XZ/Zkx7gOzZt=ZK8-g{YCgc*R6,ZkgIg~XZdZzgYF,+g}~X

ZgZq-].h+ ZK@*g (concept of state) gc* qgpMygc*R6,ZyZEzC~ZVg

ZK~Zsgc*~zc*YXZyaC~zZgZkgIg~YCX

Zkg>&V~MhXZ%t!*]Yy

Xp overlapping t

B7p}

t!*]tMZk&{bbMc*]6,Xz~ZsZC~ZwZzgX2V6,tqg]9~ZyHHXzu}z~VzBi0+Z_OgXZzgQ#Zi{~z',Zggpp

K~M

JZxbX~BzZZzgC~ ZxZzgbZyzV~gLZxXMy~z~

Zq-tXtM@*VZ7g~ZKBg*zmHZzgZy]C,H?QZXtik,cM@*VCi0+~agH?

c*ic*{zZZp~-VZsgc*~e$CZzgZkH ?QZkK~Zq-Z*yMT6,tgIgZsxZzgZZy~Ht?~gZq-Z)ZzgY,{M\

|Z]tgc*tz{Zp}ZkgIg_~g}tMDX

Zsgc*2ZZZw ZkZ[MZkgIgMe$6,ZK]m5^m% ^]$m!]i]enmp]#]i$] %6,Xc*:

LLZ}ZZyzZ!ZvZzgZkgw)V( A ]$]#nn ]#M#(,ZzgZvZ(gzZzgYygZv)Cq(GgzZY+

ZkpH!tZq-yZKZZ~w~ zZZvZzgZkgwVZx0*@*ZzgZkag3+gMiZ~

6


7/38

}z7z,Zq-y{ZzgZq-Zsgc*g3+gM

iZ7

ZvZzgZk

g

w

VZ

x0*

XZsx~M

iZ

~ gtZvaCqzu~]qYX)ZDwZ-VZZHC

tZq->{&/ZV&DZg>}M]!

Z!*]ZxVZkgc*:EMD EE%]+%]m^%]on$jDDLLZzgZZyVwZkh}Zq-JZX

(,~\g~XZq-hZz{T6,0*~7l7

z{].Oeg}].OeiM

iZ~BTs eZzgVJ-ezhXZk',@Zq-hZz{Zq-JZXZ[M\nk/Zq-gTz{hZZLJZXZk/Z],{Z0+gz{xQYX

Zkh}ZMiZ~z{ZkZ],}Z0+gTse0*]

/,6,YY'h+MY**ePxZzgZVpk/ wZDwC MC/7YYZkaz{JZ5',!*r~MiZ0*

Z40*-V~qMiZ~!t.e$Zzg$h4->

GIEGXZxV~Zq-i0+

Zq-0*i0+Xz{ZvZzggwVZxZzgZzZ%zZ0*XZ[

C!*]Z#yZvZzgZkgwVZx0*

V

Z

ZyM

iZY

?

VZ

i0+

CR6,ZyZx0*~zg~X~n[Vi0+ZRCi0+ZkF,RZzg(i0+gc*4R6,g}5]tZF,+gX:g~i0+CRZvZzgZkgwVZx0*XZ/VZ

ZzgZyZq-M

iZpUggc*

Zk

5]~Zk ~ZzgZkZ2~ZvZzgZkgwVZx M 2gzM

zi7HYYXt|xZkgIgMe$Zkz:LLZ}ZIZZy!# m5^m% ^]$m!]i]enmp]#

Mc*Zk i] M(,ZvZzgZkgwVXVLL

LLZLM

\ ] F,LL#M

(,JXZkM

LL LLZKgZM#(,Jzs' m M:(,Jc*LLLLZvZzgZkgwXMe$tz enmp]# 7,}X

zVzsZpBaZgX|xttZq-Z],{Xvg~i0+pZ{ZZ~5]0pZ{Zi0+)bmgBb

ZkZ],}Z0+gZ0+gzg6ecX Z/gHYtZsgc*R6,ZkZZzg2ZZZwc*-VvZkiZkMe$CXZka

(sovereignty) gc*K~ctMqSw)ZDw%jxC ?ZzgZsgc*~qShsZv

uzg~iQkfZ" xZVZuz!*CMig~!

7

EMD]uXj^he^o]%mXe^h]eon]pX|LLMMM


8/38

c*(w (Muslim social though) ZCt~Z

zC

~ZzgZF,+!*

]t (Muslim political thought)

qShsZvaXMy~Zk!*]]6,ZZ2yHHXic*{czsZpg-:

LLZ(ZvZZzg7X ]]v]$#mou? Z!*]g>Zl~tZ0+Zi~-Vc*:

LLZzgz{ZL)Z(g(~q-

ag7 Z ]

u]Z%tzgZvqSZwZK{~ig6, fz{gwZvVZ)zZXZkaZv(6,zV~ZkV',ZgZ7(ZkZLZxVJ-aZK!*t]zgYg~c*

TMy~/~{?Z

5454

EEGGEZ[gwZvV ZqSZiz{g>ZYZkMe$jZ:

)Me$95(LLZ)z t ]n]]#]n]]$]o]ZvZzgZ)zgw)V(Zzg?~r#Z%ZyX

8Z%z%Mc*ZvBZzg ]n] ZkMIg~LL

LLZ)zZvZzg ]n]]#]n]]$ gwVBXpMZ#ZkZ)i~ Z)zgw)V(

]o] N*c*7Hc*H: ]n] /~MZ%LLZkZ|[xZZvZzg LLZzgZy?~r#Z%V

Z) ]o] LL ZkgwZ)!*Z]Zzg

zoz{ZvZzgZkgwVZxZ],{Z0+gZ0+g}Mh Zk!*C7XZkaZxVZEg6,tZZwc*

Z,n~t~ EMD EEôn]^DD :

Z)7YT{C

Zv

**ixMgX:My~Z]6,ZZ2ZvZzgZk

gwVZ)ZxbZyHYZkq_Z(,~YZzg(,~pzgCBg>ZZ]

m5^m

% ^]

$m

!]i]en

Me$

~!*,ZIgyc

*H

: LLZ}ZIZZy!#M(,ZvZzgZk mp]#gw)V(X

VtnzVt(,}2g~MZzgZpXZkZwZwaZZ~zZi0+xZgz)bZzg

5]ZvZzgZkgwVZ)Z],}Z0+gZ0+gg Zkzi7XZ%ZkZ],}Z0+ggTDq]ZzgDZK%ZEwhqX~t!*]Zkang;VZIzxxZkZwtDLLZ%~

@*XZq-tc*YLLZvZzg (emphasis) LL4~ic*{izg

ZkgwZ)zZzgzu}t!*]-VYLLZvZzgZk gw)V(M#(,tzuZZ0+ZiZk~@*Ng8-ic*{X

QtZ/g,M{2g~ZgtZp.e$XtZpZkiZk!*]Zqfe (comprehensive) Y

8

!^]ênxX q^]nnoX|VOLUUX]pV]eun EMD

j^h]^]^X]]%ô!


9/38

ZvZzgZkgwVzZZxZyzi7HYnZyZ0+gZ0+gMiZ~qh}VwK~nHH

h}'ZMiZ~z{ZKglZg_.Zq-Z],}Z0+gZ0+gxQYZzgTeZzgguz~gTA6,eYYXZg>ZZ]ZyZpfg)Zq-Z],{c*HZvZzgZkgwVZx

wLLuzZ

vZy

zi7HY

YXZ%ZkZ]

,}Z0

+gZ0+

g Z(gqZLgc*4&)-GZzgZOZgZKZ$+h+MhZLZ2MhX

Zsgc*~gZZkaZq-ZZwg>Zg~yc*H&

] Z(gZ]Z],}~qwpgXz{ZZwt LLZzg)ZIZZy(ZL5]!*btg} )Me$83( Fpen`DXZvZzgZkgwVZxZ],}Z0+gZ0+gzZu{0+Zyc*/z{tZ(gq7z{**{6,*ZkbYc*z{ZxZyZzgvs

ZygTbeZy6,ZK%,XZsxZkq 6c*/z{c* totalitarianism Zzg authoritarianism{0+Zy~Z(gZ]ZgiC/ZYi]7XZsgc*5]`agZxZigzMyixXg>

ZgZkMe$~tZZwZzgZs]tSy

Zk~z{xZZgX0Myz


10/38

Z:vg}VLLZZ~t!*]LLqShZvX!*gZkZw*gzkZc*Zzgt!*]7g@*gZK~%MiZzpUgZzgf)ZgZ)z{g~2giZ(ZkiZq-ZZyzZgHgc*~

6,tc* qShZvXZk0tMhgc*RTZyz ]# ]]$]F]$]#]]$v$]$ ]:

ZgZgZfg)

7g~*tZXZzg~M

`yZ d7**eLVQkc*QyZmMVZkiZp

K2g0*ygZV~g:"No legislation will be done repugnant to the

Quran and the Sunnah."

LLVZ+yi~7YMyZzgZZ]tMIgc*7pzZtZkiZpF,+DZkMIgZp:

LL#M(,ZvZzgZkgwX i]enmp]# Zv\yMyXZ/M\ZkM7(,_Zk

ptM\ZvM7(,XZzggwZvV


11/38

LLZ}ZZyzZ!#zZKMzZizVMzZi6,Zzg#WzZyMzZi~B?!*Zq-zu}WfeIZvg}xZqwgZVYNZzgZkgJ-:XGz{vZKMzZizVZvgw)V(t-gnpzXVZvaY1XZya

gD Zzg(,ZZXz{v)Z}V(M\vzV!*CZy~Z**XZzgZ/z{DVJ-

M

\pZy0*k=pDtZya}4XZzgZv zZg3zZXZ}ZZyzZ!Z/vg}0*kZMYy1zIZ?**Z~xsZZxZzgQZLK6,D**7,}XZzgYygvg}Zvgw)V(XZ/z{vgZIZ5]~+'?p~7,YpZvZZyvg}4,q-8[c*ZzgZvg}V~[c*Zzgvg}4,q-**Ih+{c*Zzg**ZzgCX

z{vZ~x[zZXtaZvsZzg1ZkXZzgZvY+zZwzZX

g>ZZ]Mc*]2@*8~VZc*Zy

Zi{~zu~ZCZkfXCTfZkg IgMe$~2g~ZzgMZq-Zsgc*c*Zq-ZsZc*Zq-Zs{0*ZvZzgZkgwVZxXZvZzgZkgwVZxZ],{z{Z],{ypZ{pZ{{pZ{7g~IZspZ{Zsgc*z{ZkZ],}

Z0+gzgXZ[ZkZ],}Zq-%/Zzgz{%/~, [gwZvVXVBZi{~~VZk

Z(,~Zq2g~zMZz;Vzu~C%/~wqgVgVo]

Z gVZ[zZZxCMypg3YM\VzWXc*WY/,X Cyw~[gwZvVZzgM\

tg|z{_.!*CCTg}yZzgg~d$u(intellect) t!*]f~gZKy~s=zf;-$ C

Zzg

}~V(sentiments)

7Zk~_.!*

] Zk[Zzg:Z]Zqz;V_.!*]a%/zg~TBZ/_.!*CzZ7wgM:~

gZzgp~q-gaZ7nXORzpDMz~7MnXZq-y}~ (cultural homogenity)

t/g|ZxVZnqfg)aZCX Vt!*]f~gDbzg~Zq-Z)ZzgZq-ZyzV~i}zMytXZ)**xZkgzt Znq

ZzgtgztZ~Zk2g~ZzgMCbz AZ7gZc*YT6,W_XZnqZ],{zWXQk

,[&Zvgw**HT6,ZZyc*HTZv zgww&Z[Zk,z',{7g~z ZkWZkgZkzsZkd$ZzgZk

Ei0+Z0+ZiZk7g}'ZL]zZg~_.[**ZkZzgZkZ],{zWX gztZzgZk**xgZZnq

pDMZfg=:Zngw Vd$ZzgZkyZ}.z{wz{g|Z

11


12/38

ZngwVz~MXt!*]7gC}Zk zg]CXz{)ZDwZq-{m:~

LLp/(CkZKV!M\ZeZKy$zg-V~$zg~w (universal) Zq-$zg~g,ptZKyK

Mzm,ZzgZi,Z+Z/ZkZzgZk}ZZM:~Zq-zu}d$gZyVP.V~

M

XZK

yt

zg]Zk

aZ+,

}Zi{~~!ZgZZ}XZM\z}M\Zzu}Zdg,pzZtxzVt

XZkatZy z!*{{7,DtF,Z7,Czg]X_.!*CzZaZq-Z(%/ixX

X(,~plQ#)d8-zZ?x(V,F,ZZzg{zg]7XzuzV{7,CZzgZynt@*Czg~Z7Zq-5,zg]CXZk!*]zs#a)ZDwt^q(,Z\gZ

LLF,ZCx}.Zz0+}/!pg}0*kZxV8[ ZiHzm,6cZZK+M6,,,X]zZg6,}Zi:geZKZK1R?,XM\V,g~BZi{~a%/~,XM\

ZZxM\o]Z/ WM\ Z[M\ BM\

Zs{~ZyxZg_./g{C%mg XM\Vz{,X0!*9HC

Z[34i XGGik,MVZil**iuF,{Mh+z!*m,h+Z,Y!

M\z{,X!*g}~)ZDw!*gC '.{ EE

W',VpgZ,!ZzZ//Qz:g~x1;-XEZ

Z[Z/ZyzVCzV,Zq-g~Zc*

Zzgz{ZvZzgZk

B

a2g~

MZzg

CgwVZxZ)Xtc*Zq-Z],{ZzgZkZ],}gxy

LLKwZiYV Zq-ZZiZzgHzm,,wZkaZ/LL%/IZbZ(gY 6,i]Z

=ZZn7pZkoBgZt%/ZzXtzg

~$+%zZ7tla@*#[gw ZvV,LL%/Ix6,,gZzggV**XZyzVZzgZyV~GZ#

gZzgtMDZyzo]aZCXZ/F,VV~wz{ZyXZb

0*VV~Z/Z+ZWZb%jxg z{g}XpaZzgZ$+~gzZgz{,[gwZvVXZ/Zkgzbc*tYyQVBZq-ZZkxYCXtgZgxZzXt:sg~RzpDMJ-$

ZkRzpDgMZzg7+MBd$zp Zq-zZF,a{wYg~zg~XzsZzg]k

12


13/38

uzzZzgz',{Z0+ZigVQZnqV~zr5+k,Xzzyeg

zZVc*fn*~zZyVZygxyZq-o9LgZzg7+MMCXtZaZya%/~,la[gwZvVX%z~pZzg~

ZyM

c*]_x@*M

8gV zgZyzZu]Z,X~V"ZTgVZgzZdxzbZ0+6ZXLZKMzZi

Zk6,c*H!C/Z(:**X gVMzZi1tz{Ck7ptZ(,~qgvg}

KZg}ZqwgZVYNvg~g~)VZg]YN XQZ0+Zi~c*Zv\ZzgZkZZaZ4|Z]VYZzg6,1ZKMzZizVVMzZit-gnpXZkn~!*CMzZ$+zV"ZYCX]~zZM

vMZzg6z;V$+zVZq-'Z`ZrVKt~ LLZ})V(!*C m^v]tn^ ~Mg**zqc*LLZk6,ZyIuc*HpBc*Htv**X M

Zy+M~7tZy'Z`Z96ZyU*60HE ]#$un ZtgZI1Bc*H:

LLZvzZg3zZpZoqwzg]XZkMe$6~!*]MZk6,ZyYZv~WX

~ZkgIgp}&]~HXMe$mZy]~zu}qpMc*]7Zzg8~z{

]]$ ZF,+!*]Mqik,W0Xc*:LLZhbYyvg})V, n]#

Z/pt9t0Zv0Z.E z{(ZvgwyCMypgDbecz{t|gVZv pM\

t

V}

hg

wXZ[

n

|]k M\BZkbn,Zq-(,ZZLgL@*V

] gVgwwzbZ0+6XZc*H:LLZzgYy)V(vg}Zvgw ]$n]#

XZyBz{nzZq-QgwB**ecZzgz{t

gVZ[zZZxZzg

M

\V

WzCM

ypgX ZkK~/ZxgZyZv:Ztu{mg6,tc*HZvvg}V~ZZygZtZzgY/,c*Zvg}V~[c*vg}VZZy'+c*Zzgz[ZzgC

b j n]_XZkZ|[~V/Zx

z;VtF,(z&Z0+ZiZkA~fgZZopgpp zg]gVLLgwZvwqw~Z0+Zi:0*XgjZg~f)Zg~!

My~!*]ttgZk6,,!Zkmt

gwZvVU*"${~ZzgZqg$g}agV xXZxVM`!5ESg}ZkagV

13


14/38

~Mì0+{z0*{XgVQM`Z`gpgbgVz@*!*VXg}tZ#!*]gVMZK=Zq-sgbecZLgeZKy:1eZwbecZLLLZZw6,@*eZwbecX$gVt!*]c*7pZ[tgVug$jZZ#!*]tMi!*ygUY

ugUqb

YNX~Z/

xgzZ

e$97

Zk6,Z[7pZ[tgV!*]Z/tMgUaLtnc*YXZ/Zk',@QZLYRZzg

LLIZ ]ivf]^ V ZKyg,tz{YLLZzgZk B ]ji vg}xZqwZg]YN

ZgZuzZkJ-

:XZkMe$6ZzgMc*]901_DXc*:

efjfn$]inf]^ m5^m% ^]$m!]q^

F er ^jfv]Fo^jFn

ek t ]jF]+n]jj]^v]en ^ t ]uF: ô]Fpî]]$joifouj#oio?]5o]]#

I ]$]#mvg%]_n l^v]en ê^]_]

]i$]]#$ t ]$^]+]^v]en]m

J iu

LLZ}ZZyzZ!Z/vg}0*kZMYy 1zXIZ?**Z~xsZZxZzgQ

ZLK6,D**7,}XZkc*:

LLZzgZ/ZIZZy~z/z{M:~7,,Zy*ZzZzgZ/Zy~Zq-/z{zu}6,ic*C6,^gZkzVJ-z{ZvtYXQZ/z{ZvtQ*ZzZyzVZsBZzgw

xGZvZszZVgrXGxZIZZyM:~:?ZLV*Zc*zZzgZvZ(gz)Zk**(@*?6,g3HYX

z(,}Zx:ZzVYyZzg4,Zqg]~*Z

6ZkInHY[VBZi{~LgppaP.e$ZZxg>ZZ]~zZgXVBc*ZzC,ZyK0+_XZq-2g~MzCT6,#@*Xzu~z{

Z[Zk _.!*CCTyZzgd$zpz~MCZZi{~ogppazZxik,_Mc*]~zZgZzgtzVZx.e$ZX

ZZVgzux

tZZ{6,ZZx:HYXZ/}M

Zzg Z(ZkK~ f Zn)!~LL

14


15/38

t9zZy!Z/z{Zx,}|Z]~ j Z1&/gzty"c*ZWYZ;g/

}g;Zzg)zg]7pZ/ZkzZZ(ZZ6,Zkgg7TbZq-t**ecZ,6,ZZx**

**uYZZkZzg)zg~XZzgZt!*]

ZiptM

C

Z/

z{Z(

T!*

g}~

x7t

sc*Zk!*g}~ZkZgZkZt!+BZkgzbZzgn

tzVq,tgzZ!*g}~ !ZzgQLLL Zk!*g}~7g~Yy z)

zg~XZyzV%V/

gQHYZzgZk _.QZZxXzZtZ/Zy5]~Zg~x1YZzgZy

ZVp:g3YY**Z**Z$k5EGYZzg~

Z:qC6,ZZZxYZzg~xtZ:qu}

Xtnxg6,pg}}~M@*Zq-ZZ{} ZzgQz{(,fZq-i!*yhZzgzu}yJ-XZ[zu}i!*yZk~ZDZzgQtZZ{ZVB}~kMvbYCZzgvZk6,feXZt!*](,~Zz)fg)9]q

ZZxXZke~ZxVZq-y\gZXM\Vg}tZq-Z(gg3zZ.Z/Zk6,ZKy

gZ~cZYZkbxZ0+3V]O!*[YXEMD EEFoe^e^]m%v'e^DD gVZgc*:

LLN*a!*]z{ZMyZ[t(,~Zzg(,~\g~!*]gV }

ZgZq-Zk~Z7Hz!*]VVMy~tZkN*aXg!*

]H

!Ztec

Zk

!*]

ZKi

!*y

%

p

Zk8X!*nz{!*]Zk!*];~z{Zq-zZ0HXZkfg)z{XzgJ-YZkZ0+Zi{CpYXZqg$IgA~SZo

Z[ZkK~Zq-!*]'h+^BXik,_Me$ZMe$ )7(T_`Zk~{mg6,ZxVxIII ]]$n]# (,~zs#tc*H

,Me$ZkbzMe$g*Xz{ZkUxZ:]ZzgxzVz)ecp!*]{mg6,

ZxVs[gez{XgKgK!*]YV:Cyaz{!*]ZkZg(,~tgVyg6,7YgXZg~g~


16/38

Zqg$z n tz{Z!*]Tg}$Zx)~ZK7g~7g~i0+HV,XZv\Z7Zx

ZrVgVZqg$yzZgZz-Vq]7g~YyZzgbzsZwKXZkbZYZYwZq-(,ZDZzgZq-(,Zz~Mc*XDZgzVgZzc*Zqg$i0+7V!*g}~QZyq]zyk,~Q

Zy

gz

~

XZ/

Z

xV

s

[!*

] ^^ ZZkC6,JwZzgt71Yt!*]LLZpyZk7g~z ]#o]#n

)Zzg7g~YygzZZzggZXZygZz-Vq]6,bZkyzZXug$~zZW

Zyp>ZzgZyD++XQug

$Q6

, linksZzg gZgHYXtg}gZxg|ZLLZ}ZIZZy!Z/vg}0*kZMZzg)

1zX!*b4,Zqg]~*Z

Z[MZkzu}(,}sMc*]9Zzg01~g}t Z/Zkg~Zo!*zVz/zV4,Zq Mc*',0*YZYqZ%sYZzgtZk]VYz{!*Zq-zu}7,,Zq-}Hgzt!c*:

LLZzgZ/Vz/z{M:~ ]jF]+n]jj]

Zzgly 7,,'ZkptyMyZKyX Zg[CZKyYZVZ/Z9ZYz{

!*Zzg7,,tZr!*]7Z(YX7g~({BZ%sYXQq]Z+g]Z(gMhzV&Z/p(+MVpQXZ`YX{mg6,

Zkg]~{gYVZzgiKZ0+gzVhVg;YmZzg({!*zz{Z!*bywZzgkBg]Z(gYXZkgwt7Zy

~Z

q-&

Z

],Zsx

{g`

Zg

}c*Yc*

Zy

Mi~zV ZZy~YXzZgZkMe$LLZzg ]jF]+n]jj] zZ/zV0c*H:

Z/ZIZZyz/z{M:~7,,XOt!*]^Zy~ZZy7X

ry MZkgIgMc*]ik,_~Zq-7gZyyZ tvgZn ^v]en ^ TFd]Xitzg] Zy*ZzX"Wgzt97ZH

tZyM:nTz{p{XtgzlgKR6,Zzg

c* (,~R6,ZXZ/zVZ%sHZzg RZ{tvtZCZ%sM:~,Z/Zq-h~!*]}pZ{(Z{zu}Zzg**gZWwBZzgzu}h

X ~!*],Zzg**gZnYt"Wgzt_.** Nip the evil in the bud LL zg} ZkaZm,~

ecXO',ZVgHz{Zq-gV Z~gzZZkk~Zq-gZh7,Z/tgZh(,|Zk

16


17/38

HZ0+gMAZ0+gMZ~ZkgZhti ! ^v]en ^ : zZzgZkg9zXOc*H

Z%Zzg}~xg6,tZw**Y@* ]v] ZzgaLL:xZVV6,zZZ#ZzgnHYg; ]qh LL

z{rZNXLL: ek]uFaô]Fp Z[Zkzu~i:

Z/

)r

Zzg*!*

z

(Zq-/

z{z

u}

/z{

6,i

c*C@*Yg;

Zkic*Cz$XZq-tz{/z{V Zzg]Z*Zg:L0g;Zzg"Yg6,ZKic*C6,^Xzu~tZy*ZzgrZZkZ_6,z{g7g;ZkZiuic*CXZyzV

LL:?Zk/z{z

î

]]

$joi

fo qpV!

*g}~g;: Z[tZzhV7g;I ic*Cg;xz%Zk/z{ZHz{Z)W,Zzgvyg9XZZ[Q#',zgMZzgz{

YX ic*CzZ/z{Z6g}z{Zkic*C!*iM

t LLVJ-z{Zv uj#

oio?]5o]]

# Oc*: YXVLLZ%Zv~ZyZ_sZg{IZ

ZyzVhVZXzZ_g|Z%ZvXl^v]en ê^ ~ity:

LLQZ/z{&^Mic*C!*iMYQZy ]_]

Me$Zk{6, ZiuwB*ZZzgZsxX gXtMyZiZzgtz{xVzZ.u7,D

V Zzguq**7,@*tZKyx7YtZvxZ[*Zw e^]_] !*]zZ|1V:

BZZzgdZsZ;BgU:0*XtZgYV?ZkaZ#IZq-&*6,6gHY_.!*]~MZk&6,**gzZic*CYZzgZic*{ic*{!*DyaZYZt{mZox}Z(:Z[wZ

Zk6,Z+

Z_Z+

~YN**o

z**

gzZ

VZzg

ic*C

i%

} ~MCVXOGc*Hic*CzZ&MyyZIZZy~ZZ[}Zk6,ic*C:YZzgwzm

]$]#mvg% Z;B:g^YXMe$My~c*:LLYygzZv\ZszZV I ]_n

@*

X *zrZCZkZMe$~Zq-zZzg~Zwyc*HV5]Zzgi]ZDgzbgg6ecZF,+!*]7gDbecz{H!ZkZyZIg~

LLGxyxZI ]$

^]+] ~ZzgS:LLZZLV ^v]en]m ZZyM:~XZyZIgfg) *ZzgrZc*z

ZKZhHHXtZKyzV}Npl7@*XzV@*@*NCZ[]

ZKyteZy*ZzgrZXZ]ZhHYg; yM:~ZyZq-zu}

17


18/38

g_0IG0Zp]ZZ/V}Z(Z%sYc*}}ZzgZ"$MYZ_."ZzggzbB**?~iZy*ZzXMy~c*:

LLZzgZvZ(gzZk** J ]i$]]#$iugZ~?QyMh?6,g3HY?6,g}.Zz0+~tX

ZyZ

x

ZKywR6,',

Z

g~R6,

ZzgDR6,7

g

ecZzgZv\tDgxecZv4:z\z{y7g~Q#0Zq-zu]^Z(gZyM:}i]Z%]YNZzgt!*]gzZZ(gC

Zq-Vwx0*a

Bi@*g

`! c*)ZDw%jxZLi~yVZq-z

z~MYXQ!*]) (Common Wealth) ZkK~ZyE+{HC

Zy/tYZ

h+Zgnk,$+wY! Zv\Z/ZsxZq-LLz&-GG=ZkR6,ZyZM66,.YNg{!*Mc*]gz~g}tMX

bCzE',ZVZzgZy!*ig@*N~Zx

m5^m% ^]$m!]m5o]m$]n] i] t 5o]m$$n] $

$mjg t e]]e]m^ i^e]e^^h

]$

m5^

m% ^]

$

m!

]]qj

f]

%n]]

$

K

^

5

a]#

]mvg%]u e]$]$$ir$]mjge$e^]$]#i$]h ]i$]]# ]m$^v]nnj^aj

E]vr]lD L $unLLZ}ZZyzZ!?~/z{zu}/z{Zt:ZhZYz{/z{Zy4Zzg:g'zu~gVZtZhZNYz{Zy4VXZzg:?ZLM\Zzg:Zq-zu}',}**xgXZZy',Z**x',ZZzgZk!*i7M)Zv\4,q-(zXZ}ZZyzZ!]yZkaykH{DZzg:I{c*zZzg:?~zu}}XH?

~ZI}z{ZL%{3? :t!*]Z**IXZzgZv\Z(gzGZv/JwzZ)Zzg(g3zZXg>ZZ]gk!*g}~~W~t!*]n

ZkgIgp}Z/&V~HYZzgMy~{~

VZZzgB0.e$ZZzgZzC~!*' ik,cMXgx{~VZzZtZzgz]

18


19/38

c',ZgppaZzgZ%szZZtzZz]!*[aPZxbX~nHz(,}ZzgbZyz

~gLX~Zk!*].gZ{:0*ZkaYyMy!*]gK7pMy!*VZq-zeXOZ[XzMc*])1121(_gZy~z{bZxzgZMgX

ZybZx0tMhtz{E',ZVg}VxZzgZ7xg6,HZzgY@*pZyzz

Zz]!*wOYDg!z]{Y@*Zzg]zzg]V~YCXZ/Q#0Zq-k$h4->

GIEGX,C!*]kZAVCZzgko~z

q,CXZq

-tCZ

MZzgzu}tZyZ

AV!* hzZ)!{ZzgoXZyzV~Zq-q$zg

Zzg){Zkk$zg~g]~XMyZyMc*]6,gHX~.e$@*NQ#0CC]zZgHYZzgM`ZyMc*]_gX

~VZZZmFV{0+ZVVZzgXVhzZ )oZzg{gppaXqzVzg~z{g}tMgX

zZZY/m, qtM:~Zq-zu}Zt:ZhZ

xg6,My Zzg m ~ZxMDz{s%zV[ZgDXZk

pt7z{Zxs%zVaDX!/Z%t{[~',$3 GEGEZq-qf%ZtCzu~qZk@*,z{#XOMy~Zz9Zx8~bXpVNgZkpZ&

a{mg6,ZgMXZkZgZzgzzh}g~MYCZzgz{ttEyZ!%zV~gV~ic*{CX%zVti0+ZF,+)bZzgF,gSZzgZy~Zy'qgSpZ&Z],{a!*kxzgLZt!*'Zy~ic*{gzZ`0*YCX]k6,L{Dc*^zg]!*g}~ZZZ0+Zi{c*g

ZzgZ/_.7ZkZhZc*HXgKgK!*VZ

Zg}Zy6,Zkb

V

DbZy6

,Z

ZZzg

Z0+Zi ~}bxg6,gVEi0+~t',Zic*{0*YCZ

ZkV{mg6,e{fHHXZktp7tyZ!%zV~7X%zV~t',ZVOZ7[HHZzg

ZkZpZ&aCZc*HX

Z[M

\'h+g,zZ!*z2V~Zq-zu} zZZYZz]g:L0Y@*Zzgz7VI^YCXZ(@*Zq-Ztzk%HHZzgz{',ZHp

zZkeMs@*Z,~YzZtZk',Z!*CYZzgz{O7,}ZzgtO7,**Yk,k,z4

g{!*)0YXtn{ZZR6,YZzg /zV{0+ZVFVZzgXVR6,XOtc*HZzg

19


20/38


21/38

$zg7,YZzgZK(gh}tqgM:L0$XZc*HZ,xgVgppZxzXZkn~ZoZgX

e VQZW,ZzgAcZyZ(gc*H:LLZZy',Z**x',ZXZ#Zv t ]]e]m^

ZZyz[gwZvVZzZhsc*tgKgK!*'ZzgsvgZtDyZkxo9LgppzZq7Zvc*X

ZkF,(BZ[F,9zh+ZzgXZgc*:LLZzg!*i7MNgq7 K $mjg^5a]#

,Zv[~/7,YyZv4,q-Z,v

XZ,

VMy

]~ZLZ,xRdwzRqwZ$

+ **7,} account for 7,}ZzgZywZZyxqzV

Xtq,Z,7g{YNX[:1YXZMe$~Q&ZxzgZMXMyZyZyb!*VzMV~H&Me$~Zzg&zu~Me$~X

pM

e$~z{&!*'M

zgzCXC!*]9 tHYtc*YzZZYtHYA$Zk]qXZi',}**xgnZZyX$+v@*N

ZMe$~Zy&',ZVyMg;XZBc*" m5^m% ^]$m!]]qjf]%n]]$ Zg[@*XZgZ:

y LLZ}ZIZZyy]XpZ{(Z{!*g}~Zq-8!*g}~pZ{(Z{w~',Zw8pZ{(Z{!*g}~w~tgZ8Z#ZZka?ZzgC:ZbpZ{(Z{!*g}~

ZhZ0+Zi ZzgZg8ZkgzHXVLLGykH{DXY ]$e]$]$ ZgZ:

yD7 vgZygptYXyXZ?%?Zzg%Cy!*g}~',ZwZLw~1gZtkH{XZv\

X VZkZzgZk6,wZ7,}

I{~gZzgIH V$ir$] zu~!*] Yg;XanlCZ,-fgppzZVtZq-fztZzgr@*ZkI{~gZky~Hg;?ZyzV]ZkHzz?Zyzz2V~(,ZZmZ(YV?}!*]tMTZy

Z%ng}D~MYXZkZzgI{z:}gz HXZqg$~ZxVt~ZzgSZ/vg}%ZkvgZZkY+ZgZ{vg}D~MYZkyZk6,{7zXZ/*~?ZLy6,{7zZv\My]~vg~6,{7X

ZkSZkZzgZkZ@Ze$tgOZq-{~',]',]MNX

21


22/38

)

mjge$

e^ ZkM

e$~~ZzgMy~!*]: LLZzgZq-zu}:HzX"x~Zk

',Zy**+MZkzE+?XZk!*g}~',~!*]ZkZgZ}VJ-**Zzg;**@*V{~Zkzw:gXZMe$Ig~Zk#(,}h+Z0+Zi~

]mvg%]u]m$^v]nnj^aj yXZgZ: LLH?~ZkI}ZL%{3:Z?**ZgB!Z[Zk~o9LH?]

1KZhZBXZ [z{ZKZf7YXM\VeZkb7z{ZK]7Yz{ZKZzg

Zf~7YXYM\$ZYM\Zk!*g}~!*]gz{XZ/z{zs#npZ/z{7ZK]Zq-

y %{lZL7$XZ/M\ZL)',ZytZzgg|tZR6,!*Z,M\%{l1Vaa3gVX

PZ]YZ]Z%t!*]f~gqptVq,z{X~Z]YZ]XZZzgC~Z@C6,0$+w~aZ$

XZ+g]~zg~ZiZk0ZKZZ_. YXZb#)Zzg9g]qwxa

$Xz{tY+aZq-x%ZzgY$o~)oYku/7Xz{Zi,z{pzu}~Yx}t:YZkosgCX'h+t{0+Zy~M\ZKZzg**eTc*{0+ZyM\dWeagMc*M\9]qac*!*vz)MhX

ZbZk+MZzgZgZ}%ZL]6,**Z/y',Zy**/k,zg]7MYZkg~7X}gVc*Z/M\}g0*g;Zzgz;V)o!*]M\D~ZzgM\ZLZkpZ_."Zz{!*]Cgtg7X'h+

',M

VVzZ.zg])

~Zk',

~ YX !*]ZZZk~ybp{g`LLZzg L ]$]#i$]h$un ]i$]]# Me$My~ZgZ:

)Cqw~(Zv**)Z/YZkg/z(XGZv.e$szZg3zZXY

Zka9F,+gzttz{Zk6

,Zg}ZzgZv[~ gq}ZzgZk/ZzggXz{Zv\.e$s

zZ/JwzZZzgg3zZ0*XqwZyzMc*]~bZyXzZZY

ZzgZq-zu}',}**xgpp

ZA[**ZzgXZ/ZyZpg3YZq- }~ZZZq-zu}Uc*/zV{0+ZVZzgFV

22


23/38

gxyg!ZzgZp]z]{ag9aZMhZy!*[YX

m5^m% ^]$^]$^F$]%FoqFe^$f

M ]$]#nfn ]$]]#]iF9 j^]LLZ}!aZHZq-%ZzgZq-g]ZzgV

ZzgX

V^~H@*

!*Z

q-zu}TyjXGZ

v ;V?~ic*{!*]z{ic*{}.ZF,kZzg

6,gXGZv)(Y+zZ)Zzg(!*XM\c*ZkgIg{~ZsZpZ{z{gc*g]~pZ{{^~ZkzZ]f

Zq-2g~ZzgZkZvZzgZkgwVZx Zzgzu~Zq-Zzg_.!*CC Z],}Z0+gZ0+ggZkzi:z

M8gV%/~,omM\ZgZM\Z[zZZxZzgM\6,gwZZyXZkMy~{~

ZKyZ0Q.e$Z!*'tMgX

)zZZKz

C, Me$ik,_K~t!*]^V[

Mc*Zk m5^m% ^]$^ O m5^m% ^]$m!] Z0+Zi$+wHXZp m5^m% ^]$m!] Zkg>~0*%[a

MXxZz;V[sZIZZyZzgV[Zp

$+wz{-V7$+Zka$+ZkMe$*y ZzgxZKVZq- (universal truth) z{Zq-M|

uZksz{tVc*f[Vg}Vc*VyVc*~|$+|Zzg0*gVc*uZzgCbVX*xZKVgxyzq,uZkMIg

LLZ} m5^m% ^]$^ ~yHHXO[c*H:]$^ Z}!Z[z{zuq,yYgXq ZKy

ZKyzc*eg{7X LL?aZH FZ(7gzVaZzZgZ}.ZZzgV{}.ZXfZvMfZv!Z(7tgzZV{ZzgZzgf[

E]fVQMMD #]]h zZVaZzZZzgXtzf[ZvXZ(7y{Zzg}.ZZzg){Zzg}.Z{sZvnguz\X

]$

p

^

6

g>Z

0~7,

|M

: LLz{)Zv(T?aZHQ?~ )Me$2( $%+-VVzu{Zzgzu Zzg?~

Z[yXtz{ugxZKZq-g~CLL?aZHtuyZX ]$^F :

LLZq-

%ZzgZq-

g]X $]%Fo zu~u: tzuMxZzgzujZfZXvg~hXZvg~gX

].Zvg}lvg~vg~XZvg~i!*3X].Zp?Z~Zq-?MxZzgjZZzX:tzug,xZKZq-zu]

g~6,zXZzgatzq,z{xZKV0 ZX m5^m% ^]$^ ZV[

23


24/38

VZzgXVgsa

ZkZq-(,~Z|sZg{g;Xz{tVZzg XV!*wz{g~aZ{XtZv4:z\sXg};VZz9(,ZZZozyn@*Xz{tLl~MZkz&!*My

Zktg;XZk|Zge7DXV

ZKPS:]CXtxq,zZZzg~Xi!*Vt z{XZb^z>tnzVl].Zg&3EYG

Vt ~tXgZnZzgigzXZk

Zk Fo]= Zq-Tyfetc*X!*]7ZkM\7Y7ZzgsC~g8-

ZzglTM\ZkgZ'Z5:Yy1ZzgZk7gZ@*g]:M\xHXtg~q,g|gsZzgTy

LLZzg qFe^$fj^] aXOc*H:M\p8/FG Nvg~~Zzgvg}\@*?Zq-zu}T

Z/xZKyZq-gDxZKVlZq-DXZzg (boring) CZzgtgZ?zZ (monotony) 7+M

XZgg]CXZkZ%sZzgtzz]~C_gg8-iMm

Z}fztZkmid$Z%s!

Zkz&ZzgZ%s~4~UZtg3Y*

*ecX zg:8/FGH6,.yn@*ZzgTty!Zz]Z(

@*azZVZzgVc*VA~(,}%DZzg]z~MDXZyzZqi(,ZY@*X

Zzg (natural) :xZttzz]ZzgtZ%szZqi!*~LL@*?Zq- j^] ZkZq-XZkZq-(,ZZ+{t

zu}TyjXZk**Zsxgz97X]zszZuC:

g8-zC6,ZKV~Zz


25/38

Zk|zZc*HZ/pw~@*ZzgZKyzu}wo7NYpZv!*w~HXz\Vg]zZzg]kX2

gc*Yz\.aC~g6,plZzg]zZg(Q}ZzgZkb*~ZCg)pz{Zv7}YXZvlXz{Y}y0*~!yzZ.}.ZF,kZzgy

)& $'rn^l s3z}asZ!gVLLEMD EEn]#o]]nDD ]zZqzV(fs~c*:

LL7{ZzgCCqw~Zveg**XZz{]~LLaV+C EE]gzgv Zk',@g]t ]~XZ/

+Qtz\7X:Z/vgZZLgBmne

]l

gl

ZzgZk

y

tz{ Z

hb

]if]^o?]]imv^fe]# Zzg ]%Y!*]Czc*ZkZkz{)Zv( ZL LLZ/? )Z>:482(

?[Xik,_Me$Igzc

Z[Zk7g~Me$!*g}~t!*]^ZkzcX Zq-gcZk*ys$~M[ZZYZzg:zZt:ZhZL}D:zg]{:d',}**x:gI{~:pZ{(Z{$+:z[tZs{~!*bZp]^g~Zzg)i~

XZkaZwZkMe$~tMc*z{(,~C~Zq!g]YVC?ZLM\(,KzzXZL

M\Zd&z{Czu}ZXZ/ZLzgc*Zh^zg]6,zgaZg;z{Zy6,zuzVg]{AZzgZyzZZY}qtxq,

ZZkMe$~ZkZ%na Z(g~7tZv\~

^

~

zg

A6,B`

c*H

~(,ZV

~ZdV

~ZzVX z{GZgzu}HZzgZKZzgZkZZYz6,Zq-

ZKy Z~M{@*XZZkMe$~t|y~xZKy**Zq-XZy{Zq-ZzgZy].ZZq-X

Zk!*]ZxV[ZZq~!*,Zpc*:

EEm^]m%

^]$^=]]

$e

$]u]

$]e^]uX] eoFo]roroFoeouFo]

EMD ]Fo]u]$e^j$FpDDLL!M{YGvgZg[Zq-ZzgvgZ!*\Zq-X

Zg!:!Q6,qZzg:Q!

6,

XZzg:g}6

,q

Zzg

: g}6,XCsX

ZkMe$IgzuZcZkZgM\Bxg6,(horizontal) *~ZKVzhVCXZq-Z|

XZ|tZzZk (vertical) ZzgZq-~

ZzZdZXtgVz]XZzg~T

25

EMD]r^]nnoX|VNSPO!vnx]r^f^oX|VUOLO!

]u^m&]vnvX|VNLTM!]uX|TSUNN! EMD


26/38

Dz{ttZzg (isolate) }Zq-zu}Zz{ZzgXtz{ZXt#Vgc*

tz$o-)4GG

GGX Zzgz{#Vgc*Xt#Vz{#V*~xg6,g8-pyZzgzC6,XZsxZk!**a^~tZz]zAzzicZzg_0E0Zyz~Zy9BtDX~Zv\ZK[

M

y~ZzgX~ZxVZLZgZ]zZ] ZsxZb~Zktz**xZZyXqW /Z~

Zzg~ (horizontal) tZsxZkq~Z|zVV6,ZKgXZsx~Z| (vertical)

Zzg~ z{g~}.ZF,Zzg6,g~C6,

Zs{)Zs{e{Zzg**z{tzo{ ZZyC6,X

Qt!*]7gZKyZKl~g$+w7YXz{e',kZ%M~g{g;z{XZZq-o~g!*zV{e{gzV{e{XZ/Z

7 cross z{g7YXtuzz{XZKyxbZzg (barriers) YZy\8-7YXtgz

M;;YDXM`]ZZ@* barriers ]Z|gz{y}!*]0Y@*XZq-pZ{yz~gZg]Tyz}Z0+gvugxy/g**NqZzgZkV~Z/zh+Zu7,YNeZk**Z$k5

EGY~7,}VyzOxgzZkV~geZixYpM`Z/z{7,|z{iZ}BZsxB(,

}(,

}

yB

0+0+J

5K~

i~

9ZY@*ZzgtCyBZq-',@~3**3YZzgZq-',@0*8YaZgyzOx~laZg]Zzg**0*ugLez{~Zg~Zt~aZ',a

ZZyz{7x!*Z]Xtz{ HF,c*C

g}ZzgZs

}(barrier)

ZK

yZ#eZkgz^ ~YX

Zq-@gc*x:zZzg]Zke~Zq-Z!*]~tnzVZkMe$Ig].h+*

Zg{mZX].h+*~ZZZzg@R6,Zq-

aZHbZzg(YA (dilemma) - bXZ[7g~*wZ+i:~Zq-@*

26


27/38

ZzgZkDXfgZZrzZ&]ZF,AnzxgZ~MXzZZ%M~g;ZM\8zn,y6,',ZgZVXpCZzg{g`~tAZY!*zV+V~zZ7Xwu7VJ-Z%M~gzZZzggZe{e{ZyVhzZg7XZkzzt].h+zge$ZzgZtzVC,x~:zu{zZ[!*g:zuMxzjZ!*gX~q7Z7hnXZq-Zm,Zq-Byqh}?Zq-gzByqhn?Zq-Y0*ZzgZq-g:6gzZyuZyZq-g~n?tz{

TM`

*ze

gq

]t

ZK dilemma

Zq-zu]XzZtZkzZkh+zg]DYNZzgZq-@Xzg:ZKhJ}zegXZ/}qU*Cg6,@kBzq7MhHZx!h+tZKZp0YXpZk}ZgZuzgZzg

ZkD+ZguZk!

*zVd

$zZZ

KyZKa o0*GZgZzgkClZzgZ~@*qw**xzgX

zzkBx)4191Y@*8191Y(/LL>Ms=HHZzgz{**xZXZkaZ#~C7V~(7BZzgZLZLZ]gZtgZuZzgZy]

aY,z**Y,g6,Zk**x.@ZZg}ZEw)bi7 YNz{'h+QJZzgZy}ic*{**u

6',kzu~xF,+kB)9391Y@*5491Y(g]~X)ZDw%jxZkLL>Ms=!*g}~C

g~Fgzixhgeg$+:%}Y!

LL>Ms=**Zzgzu~kBxLLZZx{ZzgZk{s/Zz{>Ms= (UNO)4OZk}ic*{**xU*"$ZXZuZLZzgPzu}TZ0+ZiZyZZgzV.hVgDZzggZy7{ZzgZysW,ZZxa:s

(failures) @R6,**xV DD 7gZZZg{ UNO M{Zzg:ZzgHVZy:Lz{7ZKyZKyd$n

X

ZK

zg]tMe$I

g7

g~

g

: m5^m% ^]$^]$^F$]%FoqFe^$f ]$]]#]iF9 j^]

Z[~H%VZzgH?zVX0*ktzZyZLZ#kqwtz{pXw)ZDwC

-V

%

iZ

Zj

y

?XCy?6,f!ZEg(,Zg~zZgZz{tqx

h&ZZrVg}Z0+gaZbXVwg6,1VqwiZg6,Zq-{eZwXz7yZa?x1V~Zzgzm

K^-VaZ[t!*

]inject

iC`NZkg6

,z{^~Vat{0Hz{Xqw

27


28/38

Zq-xZq-i!*y1% FoF] Zt:~[ZzgX zZZz9Zq-xF,+Ze$+Zq-pqx

vV-g8ZEgZy (Territorial Nationalism)ghZz{Zk70*gXZzgg~fzgZZzgzZ:LXl!ypZLszYNZzg

ZkMe$IgZLagzZq-fgBXpzuZ[zzuMxzuZKC6,Zq-I0YNXw)ZDwC

Zq-Vwx0*aBi@*g`!

Z/*tu,ZKgq$X

LZsxZzgLZZy ~tzz]$i+]F]^$^m ^k]]h!$^

]i_n]]#mj]^ ]m^oe

N ]$]#$un n^LLt$+zZZyMX)Z}V(Zy?C/ZZy7-VZsxM)Z)Jw(ZZyZvg}V~Z47ZX@*Z/?ZvZzgZkgwZ)DgZvvg}Zqw)

ZzNZ[(~7}XGZvzZg3zZX t!*]Zq-{m*yZgtMyZF,+

Me$Zzgz{{m*yZZyZzgZsxtXMy~Zz9LLZZyzZsxZzgLLzpZzgZsZpg6,ZEwDXz{yZzgyz{Xt!*

Z,Zm,~~:Call the rose by any name, it will smell as sweet.

ZkaZZyZq-!*mZsxZkzZ~gXZ[T~tzVq,w~ZZy~Zsx

ZM\e}eBt7zZXpVM\ZMZzgZyF,5HZkMIg~ZyzVZq-zu}!*W.c*HZzgZq-/z{ZZZy6,izg

~.e$Za~F,~LLC/ i+] XLL!i!*y~~aZ ZHLL?C/ZZy7

^!j ZY ^ atY~LLZ4HYX LL LL?ZZy7XzuZ{tpgq6,

LL?C/ZZy7!*]p i+] t@*Na@*XLLZzgZ $^m]m^oe Zt'h+HH:

ZZyvg}V~Z47ZXz{svg~i!*V6,XxZVZZy.e$.e$@*N~Z|[!*,!Zy

LLZ%?MhZsx F]^ ZsxtHYg;:M)yZ)Jw(XZka

X to give up resistance Zzg to surrender Zsxpzz#Zzg#z'ZghutnbXZg~YLL/y.yXc*Ht&EOzMhZsxM

28


29/38

Z)JwX ]i_n]]#mj]^n^ Mc*H:

Z/?ZvZzgQkgwVZ)6,ggvg}ZqwJwaYNZyZzNZ[~7YXvgZZsxtpZ/vgZtw?ZZyMtvgZ(,Z$Zk

]$]# oXMe$Z!x@*ZyZIg6,:LLGZv.e$zZg3zZXtge$~ N $un

YgZZy%vg}ZsxZzgvg~Z)JwZzgvg~n]?6,g3tKg]~Ygz{ZkFg~

zgXZk'h+zs#ZyYZvMMXMIg&Gzs{m

Z[fgZzUVZkM

e$6,

g,XZkU ZkMe$IgK,&&Gzs{mMyiU4,zwZzgZkMe$:jZYz{yvXt[g;XZk!*]a]Z#d8-zZ?xZZzZgfgZZyf~XZ#J-gV

l()~=pgxy$zgX ZsxJw@*Z*c*Y@*bbZj+ZNYCZzgCnK:c*Y@*XZszi!*y6,*0]@*T

Zz{Zk*0hZZ5 w~aZ[@*ZZz{Zk*0 6,ZKYy!*a!zg@*

]ZZ6,*C;aCzM{@*XZ#Zk gZ~Zkw~Zv6,Qk6,gVt]zg6,Zzg

]] Z>]zbZzwZ6,ZZyY/,Y@*A$z{H:z;VZZyZzgZsx $]F]$]#]]$v$]$]#

~Mc*Xp]g{~Z#ZxV=pMA$q]$+wXZ[ZsxjzgzqZX[~"0 GEG

Z#Zq-LL~gc*QVZsx(,k`HXZq]$+sZzgZsxZq-]wZ(g@*`H

z,z,VzgzZ$+rXZ[ZyrT$zZZ+7M**HXl~!*g{{wYg~g;XZkps{gqwt6vZsxI$lXZ[aZzggz~{7ZvtgtZsxJwXZzkzg`7g}7g}\ZZyMXC!*]0

iy~ZyV~ZZyY/,7Y**Ozzg{~ooZq-))g**zqZX

Qlgqw!*$+wXZ[c*[~(,~gwZvVXZ#3`Zzg`zoDbZiyZzg[Z[[~Zzgy[gw

ZvV

.M

@*

XZxDb

[~Zq-

gzX

ZKZK (H!VZzgM\'ZZ[Z+{7Z[M\V7~'Z37MhZp

tz{uMy~0*g}g>Z~ ZzgVZ)JwBM@*:

]mk]$^mom]

# A ]]q]

#]jx B ]]q^

29


30/38

Ltl~V~PvZZyVZzgZ[tDZgzVZZ{z5 EGSMc*ZzgZkZsxJw1c*!*v

Z)tXpZkpt7ZkZ~ZyV0iy~$+wXZZ[Z,vz~MMVZ)Jw]ZZgpLLZZ7q7X

t!*]7gDbZZyZy~t7XZ%vGZ,Xt[g;XRZ[$+zV!*g}~g>Zp!EGMe$99~tzs#:

]]hm%+e^#]n]Fmj$^meFk n ]#ouj ]?]$ ^e$ ]#Fl]$

u

]$

]#

$un LLZzg$+zV)!*t6V(~Z,Zv6,Zzg-My6,

gnpZzgz{ZCwyaDZv\[qaZzggw)V(Nhefg=aXc*gZy

Z4 ya**"Z#"$XZvZyzgZKg~X"Zv.e$n]zZ(,Zg3zZX

tMe$IgZk!*]6,C$+zZ,7X&GzsxZgg}ah+YVZ

Z[fgZZkMe$Ig6,&GzsxZggXZ/ZKgqw6,g,Ckg~xZe$n

ZZyJw7HzZZy

(choice)

XZLZN[ aZLq7ZsxzgZdHXz;V

lZq-gzv`g`Zsx~Z4XVZq-#Zq-zzvg;X~

XZv\z ]$^^]# Zz9g|ZkMe$]ZtXZZyzZyz}XZzgqwZ,ZZCzg~gZzgM`pZ/Ze$tgg,nZx6,MZsx]pzZ

z{T!*g}~)ZDwC fz**gM>aZZ}**ZV!>;BMC

z{gz7TtNg~!tyXtz{ffMCX

Z[Z/ZkgqwtgZkMe$6,'h+g,Zq-!*]g}a(,~ZyZZZzgh+YVZZy$+zVHZ/?ZLlV~ZzgCkz{zZ!*]q7

LLZ/?ZvZzgQkgw)V(Z)6,gg -k:vg}Zqw~7,XzZtt(,~ge$XgZ/xZzgZg6,!*]Yz{tZZy%

Jw7**e

cpVg

e$~Yg

ZL

w 5ZzgCk}zZ7-k:XZkq

z~Z/?Z)6,gg**EVvg}ZqwJwBXZy~ZzgC7,X

]$ Z[fgZgMe$Z!xZv\]6,g;!c*:

LLGZvggXtZkFg~ N ]#

$un ZzgZkg1z{vg}Bt3,',]g;Zzgt

30

31


31/38

ge$}g;ZZZzgx:A$Z/?ZvZzgZkgwZ)Dgvg}ZqwJwaYNvg}

mj]^n^ ZzNZ[~fg{',Z',ZzgC7:N ]$]#$un

bz~Z)|Z%Zk~Zq-ZkC{Z}ZKyZLa:

?:

Zzg}Z(:

ZZ

yw

:}XZkaZigzMyn]aZ)[Xbz~

Z)Z)7XZvZzgZkgwVZxy8ZzgZxF,ubuM\V6,gZzg0*Vgz0+bt

Z)7Xtg]tetqtZvBz

ZZYXz{LL!

*i~!*

i~!*

g!*!*!*

i~!t?ZvB g!tZt?ZvgwVBg!i7,"?Zv!z{7,XZvgzi{ggOXZvg]:pZ73XZkHp?tZvZxuM\V6,g3Zzg0*Vgz0+c*X6~Z

nHtg]eZv[~(,~qXZk6, ]j+ef]jFg g>Z>Me$58~h+"54-> GEEGXXc*:LLH?g~[)Zzg


32/38

Zkz:}Zzggzb6,zMZk t ]jFgief~M\Ck1tZwHDC

M`YVf?J-:I!g~[~! q

*~YVf?zgZZzgZkfzgZ~ZYV@*`Yg;?ZkZ[g>Z>ZMe$~XtZk:L

73 Zzx (climax) ZgtMe$MyaKZwtg>ZZ]~VBp}MgZy

Zkcg*zmH!ZkaCg>%/~*y@*Zk z{g*te g>xMc*]ZkB%1oCV}~qzneZsgc*e$nZyzVCZsxZZy7XZkatnXZq-y%~Zq-yg]$ZzgZq-

yg]bsZq-y%YXy!*\zgZV$ yZzv$Xt{XXZsgc*~

yXZsxZke$CXZ**7,}yyy7XVJ-ZZymz{Zq-!*mz{w~@*Xw~c*7Zk7MhXM`g}0*kM!Zzgfg=7Ttw~ZZyc*7XZ*~y}~zqZzgZsgc*e$CZsxZZy7XZ%My]~gZZx**ZkCZZyX

LLZZyYzpZ[ZwaZ@*ZZyZzgZkH!t

ZkgIgZMe$qTZ[_DX]$^]+]$m!]e^#$$mi^e]q^a]

O ]5a]# e^]`

]`

of

n

]#LL'z{ZZyZv6,ZzgZkgw)V(6,Q

~77,}ZzgZrVHZLZZwZzgZKYVBZvgZ{~Xsv)ZLZZZy~(FXtMe$IgZL*yZgMy`z`Xz{*ytZZpH?Z#tzZHZZyZzg

ZsxZzg~g6,Zq-Zwf~ZMLLZZy!Otz{x&~ZZyYzpZgVXYzpZq-ZkU(x~ZZyZzgZsxe{e{yZXz,ZZy]My~YOyXZZy

T xZ]ZzgZk}!*g}~g>Z0~97,|`zuZgqZZyxZ]ZZy}ZZy!3{5 GGEG]ZzgZZy

32

33


33/38

Z]q6,XpVt9(xH!z{ZZyZzgZsxtXZZk:~t*yMg;'z{X

Xc*t ~z{z7g~gVZkMe$Ig~ygzu}ZkUZkMe$ x (definition) ZZyp

Igzq~Z|ZzgZ!x6,XLLZq-ZbZkZkVwZhbYnZq-]:LLih+ZzgZq-LLih+XZ[gZyzV~HtzZZ?LLih+~ih+Zm]Zpzu}

7Xih+z{ZzgYXZk~LLih+ih+Zm]ZzgzuzVgXih+ZZzg7Xc*Dih+~XZk

]$^]+ Z|XOMe$zq~Mc*:pVLL'z{vc*LLsz{v ]$m

LLsv O ]5a]# XMy~Z|:FXZZZyZrVHXfMe$~Z:

ZZyZzg}ZgpZk ^k]]h!$^

ZZZ

y~F

sz{Zy

V

7gZ

,Zk

Me$Ig

~ yYgX

ZZyZzgmMe$ZkZwzMyZ[MtBZkMe$Z*y

Me$6,h}gt!*]tMC H! content ZzgZ

ZZzZixXc*Z/ZbZEwY YZZzZgyXZgyZsxCy

gzZe$ i zZug$~yX|]Zv0/gwZvVZgc*:

EEeo]FoV^]$]F]$]#]$v$]fEMD ]^]$]mj^]$ûs]fnk^DD

LLZsxC0*!*V6,:ZbZvZZ[7Zzg)V(Zk}ZzggwZzgi**Zzgi2>ZZ**ZzgMZve**Zzggpygzi}gX

ZkZbf t0*vVH?tZgZsxZsx2y! dZzgMe$ik,_gzZZyzZgyH!gZvZzgZkgw)V(6,z{ZZyT~uz2]!*:gX

Mc*Xp LL miê] VLLgd$pgqLLLLC/:,Xuz2]!*`VXx

tzo}ZmZXtZZ ZtLLgXzuZg0Zzgz{ZvZLZZwZzgZKYVX:ZZzZgyZq-LL~ZzgzuZLL~X

VZq-N'h+XLLZZyZp:ke^#ê^^îfkqn]u^]]

e^îme^gZyZpxZZZyzUc*zgZXZq-i!*yZZgZzg

]]e^^ zuZw&c*XZ[Zy~gz

33

EMDvnx]f^pXj^h]m^Xe^heo]o!vnxXj^h]m^Xe^hen^]^]^]^!]!

34


34/38

^]$]F]$]#]$v$]$ ZZc*ZsxgXZq-i!*yZZg}~} testimony t& ]#!

VZvZq7Zzgt}|]VZvgwZZ ime^g wZsxg ]]e^^ Zk

gXZZzRgy~g6,W_ZkHMU*g!ZkH}zxZ]ZKy~g5+k,V!ZyZgg>Z0~,_`XZZ[Wic*{%6**zu}gZvq6,XtxHtgZZZ/tZZyZzgZ/t7ZZq7X

LLZvZ

|Z[ZwaZ@*tZvH?!*g}~g}Vz(,}(,}%XZq-tpkBKYDXt!*]97ZkF,+aKkBXZkzs#My

X j^ofn]# YXz,kBaMyZb

].z4 LLLL4Zzg4pX 1sXLLywLLOZkpkBXzuZ

$tykB}Xtc*ZZZq-!*]6,Zq-Zzg!*]CgXysz{kBywZvc*aKZgZv$Ts

Zvu**XZ/z{o~nZLE~ZMZg Wz{ywc*Zv7XZZyzV

VfwZzgZ[g6,!4Zzg4p (root) 6~nHZk{

t X to strive for something LL XZm,~~Z-VZZ,pW@{c*Zp~Zq-ZpaZYDXW@{ 4

z{V44ZVX!i!*y~!*~ZpMDZy~ZZp~M\t{Az&!*W.MZq-gVZzgZq-zu}ik,**eTVXIXI~z&DZkZq-zu}zuZXtZLh~?}z{ZLh~?}XtQk

?Lz{Sk?LXtIXZbpZq-zu}tM**X&Gc*ywpZq-zu}O**XOc*W@{t44Zg@Vxg;Xg~ZkZzg,XZm,~~

resistance G struggle !*9X struggle ZkasC'Z~CXZaZk

M@*X against g6, (preposition),

Z[

*~H@*

!Zq-

Z

q-t

zu}

zuZX Vwg6,Zq-gmiHzuZf!/g~utZgZ:xbXtZmBZLbbZzgz{ZLb~

4XZyzVgxyxgXtxc*CR6,Xz{ZLbn}tZLb;Xz{ZLw

V))tZLV^XQZygxy XAYZkt_.Zko~x

34

35


35/38

YXZzZtZ/mBttHHZka].z4ZzgW@{**/k,XZ/7g;tg6,Zk!*]o]

tZLb~47X4Zzgr#ZgZKyz{ZLb]zVa].z4}ZzgZ**xX:Z/qZv6,Zk6,Zkgw|]V6,My6,ZzgZsx6,!ZkZkgZk~Zk&z{Zsxa].z4}}}Zsx;ZZy]x}ZyV}ZsxaYyZzgwagVXz{Zsxxa

}XZ/ZZw~tgZzgZ/t7g; strugglezZZZy7XtpZkgZZyX

Zv

%ZA

$z

%Zi Z[fgZ%ZA$ZzggY]YyXZkaZq-&2!

qg]gf~gXZzgZF,+gzLLW@{ZlXM\Zv**gwV**My**


36/38

ZVNXt%XpZ#ZZ_M\Z!}XZ[M\ZZx active resistance ggzZZk

H!teBZgzV6, j ,Xl~/tc*Y4YX?Z!ZZx7MhZKZf~;B7ZV

] MhXpZkz{zMc*;BwbXMe$**iw:M`ZYi]~YgZy E]vsVUOD $mmFje^$]

X6,Nhhbz{ZMZ[}MhXZzgxXZzgt armed conflict ZkxZEgMy~gz

z{F,+aKVVyw0YT!*g}~g{~z{zMc* X E]fVRMND jgn]j^ ZpM:

MHZ[?6,kBn~X

:tZv&%ZiXZknze$H?Zv +Zv+**Xz{xZv\c*Zkgw

~Vc*Myc*Z!*w****XZkaW@{ZlQW@{ZEX XZLZ0+g}.ZZik,z

c*CR6,ZsxzZZyVZzgzZ)zXQW@{ZEg

T~ZZxZzgzM6,x%ZiX t!*]YyZxVZvgZ{~YyMgizgppZZyZq-ZF,+gZgc*Xt!*]kBCz7CpZ/w~ZZytg6ecl~i0+~z{zM{ywZv%MZzg~Zk~ZK

/yZv\[~uyzZzgzlYVXgV Zgc*:

EMD EE$^lmmv'e^lFof^DDLLT]Zkqw~zZ:ZkZvgZ{~kB

Zzg:Zkw~ZkMgizaZZk]Zq- qt6,zZXZv\g}V]gX

zqW@{Zl@*pZkMy~2wzywZvXt{Zz:0*XZ/pZkZ_z{7g~

VM\z;VqptMgizw~gxg~i0+~z{% MZZyixXZ/t7ZZy7X:ZZyzZkMe$IgjZg}t

MXZ[M\XZ#ZsxZzgZZyzVYNc*ZZg!*uyZzg&!*Xigzi{eZzgi2>ZsxZgy

wVzZZZyw~ZzgZv !*lz!*w~tZZyZgywVZzgZkbc*Zq-,YXZv\Zk'6,7gZZF,

=X

ZZygZ3 ]#m^o]$FFl^o ]i]#em$ m%n]]] P ]#eon ]

e]#m%n]aF:m^]j t i%]o$]e^ ]#en ]$]#mng]$FFl] Q Fn

]#]n R ivnxXj^h]^Xe^h^lmmv'e^! EMD

37


37/38

LLv!H?Zv6,**eTZC+qZvY}MV~Zzgi}~ZzgZvCDgrXz{M\6,

ZyOgz{ZsxMXv:6,ZLZsxZy :OzZv?6,Zy@*ZkZZygZ{Z/?ZZFXGMVZzgi}CqZvD~ZzgZvNg;?gXlZZyzZV~ic*{ZRZ[$+zVX

Zy~ZZq-zg}LLO!*ZrLL{',@ ic*{g]ZtXOXw~ZZy7z{ic*{(,|m|ZLZZyzZsxZgDZzgM8gV6,ZyDX{mg6,z{v}}%ZZyMZt_cDg!:M\kB:LM\#

6,Zg6,ZsxMZgZhzuzV~ic*{X]~zNecZzgg~ge$ic*{ecXZkMe$~

Z0+Zi~ Z4ic*{(,|m|!*'zZV!*g}~g}uiZ}V!M\Zy79/FG? ]i]#em c*:

C**eT?ZsxM?H?ZvZL+zZZyZ:qb]#m^o eT?Z**eT?ZZyM!

LLqZvY}MV~Zzg ]$FFl^o]i}~XZ/vg}w~ZZyZ/?zZr#ZZy

]#e HqZvV7{ZzgZkD!*C$!LLZvCY+zZXZkDCX P on

Z~z{ZLZZyZygwZvV6,ODXOc*:

LL)Z}V!(tM\6,ZyOg m%n]]]tZsxMXa]nM\;B~ZZLZsxZyM\6,OD@*]zZ]~ic*{ic*{zn!

^VZZyZzgZsxQZZq]^~c*Yg;ZzgZkZgtx7g}My~Zqi~wqZsxZzgZZye{e{HHpZkMe$~ZyzVg*(,~pzgCzZHYg;XOMe${~ZsxM8gV6,ZyjZZy6,/

LL)Z} t $i%]o$] m%n]]] :V!(tM\6,ZyOgZsxM:6,

e]#m%n]aF:m^]j Zy:OzZLZsxXLLZv?6,ZyO@*)ZkZy(Zk Q Fn

ZZygZ33c*Z/?)ZLZZsx~(FXZq-z{vMV+M7,JVZy!*]7gZ/?+M%Zsxi!*yZZHc*ZvZy

ZvZkgZ56,Mc*TZ2wZZyXZ[?ZZyJ-VMhZkJ-gqMhXZkaZkvu6,MHZ[c*ZkaMyz{ZZy2wJ-gqXLL@Ze$ZgY]f~ggZ{3b@Ze$ZZgzZzggZ{6,M**@Ze$ZgzXVzVZgZ]F,HYY

g

w Q

e]#

m%

n

]aF:

m^]

jFn : 6,ZLZZyzZsxZyOOZvZyZk

38


38/38

ZZygZ{6,eZwc*Z/?ZZZLZZsx~FXwC4}.!GLVb0

4kZiz{#$+Z]4IGGm%n] V^LLZsxjZW:

e]#m%n]aF: ZzgQ t $i%]o$] ]]~ZZygZ{6,eZ%fZv\Zy Q m^]jFn

g6,HHXZkbLLZsxZzgLLZZyze{e{Zq]

g6,yZy!*bg*zZc*XtZkgIg ]$]#mng]$FFl] Mc*:

Me$XLLZv\MVZzgi}C (concluding) Z!LLZzgZvNg;? R eî ]#en Y+zZX

gXZk~Zq-bNgvg}Zqwvg}g}]g~{~XZkBB4ZIZZyayvg~!**VvgZZgZzgvg}Zq

g~{~Zy"7X6M8gV~ LL)Z}V!(M\g~V $e^n^ MZ0+Zi~c*H:

XZkZgC8ELZZyatZpc*ZZZ#: pXV~gzvZya R eî ]#en

Zph+gzgnpXtMZpZvY}?gXZv\ZZ{Z0+ziZzgZkZZgy

ZgZsx6,eZZzgZvZyV7gZ=X

e^]#oo]]nXo]m$ê^m^l]]vn

Documents

BU-9-14-Musalmanoun Ki Siasi-O-Milli Zindagi Ke Rahnuma Usool