Upload
vuongtuong
View
219
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
@ @
كيف تتخلص !؟مـن اإللـحـاد
ا�ؤلف
�د�م�������� �
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
� �
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
���X��WV��U��T��S��R��Q��� � � �P��O��N��X��WV��U��T��S��R��Q��� � � �P��O��N��X��WV��U��T��S��R��Q��� � � �P��O��N��X��WV��U��T��S��R��Q��� � � �P��O��N
��h��g��f��e�� � � � �d��c��b��a�� � �_�� � � � � � � �]��\��[��Z�� � �Y��h��g��f��e�� � � � �d��c��b��a�� � �_�� � � � � � � �]��\��[��Z�� � �Y��h��g��f��e�� � � � �d��c��b��a�� � �_�� � � � � � � �]��\��[��Z�� � �Y��h��g��f��e�� � � � �d��c��b��a�� � �_�� � � � � � � �]��\��[��Z�� � �Y�r� �q��p�� �o�� nm� �l��k� �j� �i�r� �q��p�� �o�� nm� �l��k� �j� �i�r� �q��p�� �o�� nm� �l��k� �j� �i�r� �q��p�� �o�� nm� �l��k� �j� �i������x��w� �v��u� � ts��x��w� �v��u� � ts��x��w� �v��u� � ts��x��w� �v��u� � ts
��h��g��f��e��d���c��b��a�� ��_��~��}�����������|��{���z���y��h��g��f��e��d���c��b��a�� ��_��~��}�����������|��{���z���y��h��g��f��e��d���c��b��a�� ��_��~��}�����������|��{���z���y��h��g��f��e��d���c��b��a�� ��_��~��}�����������|��{���z���y���w��v��u��t��s��r��q��p���o��n��m��l��k��j��i���w��v��u��t��s��r��q��p���o��n��m��l��k��j��i���w��v��u��t��s��r��q��p���o��n��m��l��k��j��i���w��v��u��t��s��r��q��p���o��n��m��l��k��j��i�� ��§��¦��¥���¤£��¢��¡������ �~��}��|{��z��y��x�� ��§��¦��¥���¤£��¢��¡������ �~��}��|{��z��y��x�� ��§��¦��¥���¤£��¢��¡������ �~��}��|{��z��y��x�� ��§��¦��¥���¤£��¢��¡������ �~��}��|{��z��y��x����¶��µ�� � �³�� �²��±��°�� ¯®�� � � � � �¬��«��ª��©����¶��µ�� � �³�� �²��±��°�� ¯®�� � � � � �¬��«��ª��©����¶��µ�� � �³�� �²��±��°�� ¯®�� � � � � �¬��«��ª��©����¶��µ�� � �³�� �²��±��°�� ¯®�� � � � � �¬��«��ª��©��Å� � ÄÃ� �Â� � ÁÀ�� � �¿� �¾� �½� � ¼»� �º��¹��¸��Å� � ÄÃ� �Â� � ÁÀ�� � �¿� �¾� �½� � ¼»� �º��¹��¸��Å� � ÄÃ� �Â� � ÁÀ�� � �¿� �¾� �½� � ¼»� �º��¹��¸��Å� � ÄÃ� �Â� � ÁÀ�� � �¿� �¾� �½� � ¼»� �º��¹��¸
�Æ�Æ�Æ�Æ����Ò��Ñ��Ð��ÏÎ��Í��Ì���ËÊ��É��È��ÇÒ��Ñ��Ð��ÏÎ��Í��Ì���ËÊ��É��È��ÇÒ��Ñ��Ð��ÏÎ��Í��Ì���ËÊ��É��È��ÇÒ��Ñ��Ð��ÏÎ��Í��Ì���ËÊ��É��È��Ç�� ������� �� :��− ���
<ác<ð^Ë}<Ìé×ÓjÖ]<»<äj߉æ<HÌé×ÓjÖ]<äÏ×}<»<�]<í߉<^²<Ù‚j‰]<àÿÚ<Ł ñ^ËÖ]æ<H^ãÏñ^Î�<íÛÓ£]<»<äj߉æ<HíÛÓ£]
<Øã«<^º<ØÃq<àÚ<†‰^¤]æ<HflÑ�æ<êË}<^Ú<î×Â<Ü×ÃèÜ×Ãè<^²<Ù÷‚j‰÷]<àÚ<äÚ†¬<^⁄e^ru< <
� � � < <
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A المقدمة
ib@éÛe@óÜÇë@�a@Þì�‰@óÜÇ@âý�Ûaë@ñý–Ûaë@�@†à§aë@�a@á�†Èië@[êüaë@åßë@éjz•ëZ@ @
,��� ��� �� ����� �������� �� �� �� � �� �� ��� � !"#���$�%&�� '(�")�� �����*
�� +, � -./ �""0 �� 12"3 $�%&�� '(�")� 43 56��� 1�#� 7"8�� -9�:;��<;�� ��=��� >�?�@ !AB C!
>�?�@ E6<F� ��)�� G/ ��8HI J��K�� �L? C � #M�N� �OI�"G�<;��" G�K;P""� Q�� PN�A? ��)�� G/ � �8H/ 2R!
S�K; �� T�8U;� C 1�#V� �? !"#�� !W� P��, �� C�X1�"�� ��I Y,� � ��� , 1��R ��*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
الفصل األول
سم م كل شيءاإلحلاد ي
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A òàîÔÛa@áà�Ží@…b§⁄a@ @
G�ZK��� 1�2�� ,[A\�� � ]3�H '<; C ��1L�� ^<_ .��V� `�#�� !a��b�W�;�� -���Mc�3 >2����� P;�d�� C Z� �Ae [�/ P�f3 >�� �� ���ghi *
�� -12R �� ��j)� 2#3 �I ��k� lI m1�2� G�ZK��� nZ� �� PR�M�� 2#3 �I �ao � � lI � #�� ��p�� �� ,PR�q G�2"�3 �I m1�2� lI ��#� �� lI rK��� �� ,b�: �� G��s/ C t20 +e ��2�2u vwc� >1��) x�#��� �L? ,.�� �� 1�My;�� C t20 +e PR�MA� 2�2u G�2"�3 �I >2�2= z� �
�w{k� `�#�� C t20! ek� `�#�� C ��/ |8 ��� �K6�� ,r� � � .��U3 '<; C b��=k� 1�2�s }
,P"R2��� P��<��3 4 <�� ��~� 2#3 ��<�� ��<K��3� P#8M�� �?��W��34 <�� ��o 2#3 n5; 1�<63 |8 ��� �K6��*
�8j� 1�q�� �L? C� ,� ��� �� -�� !e C P���V� P6�)� ��<_ �LK?�6"�� �/ 7 #V� �� ��2)� �L? lI Y6� � � ��d�2� ,b�,�� ^� ��d�2� P��w�� �/ P
>��)� P����� mL? 1�qI C �M8c �K6� �� .��V� `�#��! S���<� G/ �/ P��w�� �/ P6"�� �/ 7 #V� �� !j0 G/ G�<;�� �M�<� ���,� ���� ��a/ -P�2"�� �ao -$���;� �ao -`�� �� -�263 �I 1��k� mL? �� ��~u �� `�#�� �L? C 2=�� � -Q8"3 �I m��=� P�1�#� n12� G/ G�<;�� �M�<� ���
m� #� �� �?}�*
i1g http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/183374/electron.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
6����d��3 `�#�� �L? C G�<;�� � P6"��� P��w��� 7 #V� ��; EA#� �;k��uk� mL? ��=�P6AN -G�#� ��/ n12� �;k� ;�?� #� ��� C �"�<� �;k� ,
� ����* " F� �L?�`�#�� �L? C G�<;�� ��=� 7 #V �6�<� 2e�_ b2!
Go C -PKpU�� ->1��; -PR1��� C� : �"�N� �� �I 2pAF� G/ G�<;�� �M�<� �� ��L��� P��w��� �2&�� 7 #V�� P6"�� ��=� ��As ,� �"8<� ��)�� �Ma � ?O C
2)/ �V � �� C 2pAV� E?2"�s�!* ��� �M�3 ��s�#� ����� �� �� � a m��)I G/ 1�R �V ,���� ^�� J��j!
T�"N �� �%�� ��K�� �8j�� ,��)�� �Ma �� !�� ��)�� �8j� � ?���K��!
!!!!إنها مفارقة غريبة لكنها حقيقية، وعجيبة لكنها واقعيةإنها مفارقة غريبة لكنها حقيقية، وعجيبة لكنها واقعيةإنها مفارقة غريبة لكنها حقيقية، وعجيبة لكنها واقعيةإنها مفارقة غريبة لكنها حقيقية، وعجيبة لكنها واقعية
>�R P�/ lI G�K_1�� �s�_ ,`�#V� PA��K�� P�<As P��1 !d6� ��)��� ,P8�.��V� `�#�� ��M#63 EA<F_ v"s �, K� ! P6"�� Y��� 1�q�� �L? C�
+e P�1�j�� P���V� P6�)� ��<_� ,��=��� C �� !K� P�1�#V�� 7 #V���� � ?� ,� A �js ;P6"�� �� 7 #V� !"#�� S���<� G�K�� �a�� �? !"#�� Gk
.��V� `�#�� �, � G�K�� Y��� ��1L�� Q�; �� P���V� ��6�)� Q�; �6KB� �2&�� P��w�� �� ��� ]��j�� .��V� ��=��� �L? C >1O !e EKB Y���
P6"��� 7 #V��*
_…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Q��� [Ae .2 ���k� �K�V� ��"� +e�C. S. Lewis :" ��/ xZ� � ���; YM#F_ Y�6:� !a�� ��1O ���� ���;�H� ��Ks 76<�� r�Le ��k� G�e �OI ,
[e G/ !��_ �U� ��2 � .L�� SA)� '��3I !d� �;I ?�p{ .^K�_ G/ 'H/ �OI �K�� ,G2 � P �2V PM��a ���O rM#�N SA)� �"3 �,s �H� �_ Y��� P"��M��
��)�� lI .�|_ Y��� �:)� C 'H/ G/ �M�N/ �� .^K��3 'H/ G/ �M�N/ `, �2pA� G�ek S8N 2=�� � �����3�� ./ �/ � ,��3 ���/ ] e �OI �I ,�ao ��
�K��� C ���/ G/ �M�N/ : G+��� b2#� �K��� b2\�N/ G/ � �23/ �K6� � �p3��3"ghi*
�1�y��1 �}� 2R� ,n��� 7 #� 7�� r� 1}� �� r� b2"F� � .��V� `�#��s 5 e���Richard Dawkins–`�#�� C ��2pAV� J� ��� − G�2"s �� 7 #V�
��"s ��)�� 1�qI C P�1�#V�� P6"��� :" ,P��� %3 ,E6j_ %3 ��""� C G�K��P��8� � ��6� >�<R ��N �� � ,^a �� � %3"g�i*
^,y�� .1�/%�� ��"� +e ,P6:; P���; ��� �? .��)I 1�W � �� G�<;��s G���N �1�eCarl Sagan. g i*
i1g C.S. Lewis ,Surprised by Joy: The Shape of My Early Life. i2gThe universe we observe has precisely the properties we should expect if
there is, at bottom no design, no purpose, no evil and no good, nothing
but blind, pitiless indifference River out of Eden, p.131-132.
i3gVideo Source: The Shores of the Cosmic Ocean [Episode 1£ =
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Y��� P:� �� GOIG/ '8N �¤ �¥ ¦�\; :P#8M�� lI �� !e 2#F� ��)��; ��=��� �L? C 2���� 5e�V� ��k!
���O C � � <�_ !6B �� ,P��8� � P#8M���! §�/ Pwj3 �/ ,7 #V� [R��� � ?� :7 #V� J�#�N� �K6� �; ^� �;k
�� ,>��=�� ^� ��k P6"�� J�#�N� �K6� �� ,��=�� P�1�#� v8c �K6��� ./; � 63� '8N �� !e Gk �"�5s��� PH�A� ��u/ PR2�� 7, �،PMA�¨ ./
P����� P8� P(�1��� ��1�j�3* Y(��%�� Y6�)� b1�j�� `�#�� �L? !a�� ��2)� �K6� � r�O �� � ��� 3�
�+©� Q)� ��aesthetic YR%ak� �/moral Y6"�� �/value-
oriented , ��<;�� �/anthropic ª�k� �/ethical , Y�q�#�� �/ emotional P�1�j�� PK;�KV� P(��%�� P����� P���V� P6�)� ��<_ v"s
mechanical *
= Some part of our being knows this is where we came from. We long to
return. And we can. Because the cosmos is also within us. We're
made of star-stuff. We are a way for the cosmos to know itself. 06
min 04 sec.
_…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A �8j�� !p�<V� ��� !3 ,P"AMV� PR%ak� P6"�� �� «�s2�� !p�<V� ��
�%{/ �¥�#�N� !�y��1 �Z#���� �1 �%(�R r�L3 5 e� :" �2= S#j�� �� «�s2�� ���2�� ^� ��a/ Pc1/ �� P"AMV� PR%ak� P6"�� ��"ghi*
��"� G/ �{k� G�e GI� : �� �%Us §%ak� 7 #� Ps�#� !p�<V� ���, � «�s2�� �/ �¥�#�N�!
}_ �/ ,�A�? P~M� �K6� � Y6�)� .��V� .��)�� `�#�� !a�2s P(�1�y���� >^ak� >1�8#�� mL?� ,4pAjV� 5 e���! g�i*
7 #V�� P�1�#V� �� P��a E(��©� }e/ �8j_ .��)�� `�#�� !a���, �?��"�;� �K6� � �����3�!
�8j_� ,7 #� �� P��� %3 >1�K�� PAU� ��e�� ��� J�j���� �8js 7;�/ %3 P��6y�� ����3�� !e �,A6e�3 P�/ >��3I 43 Y=���3 §�s %s ,P�1�#�
PU6UV� PA6� �%a P�^�K3 ���6#�<� >��3I�! 5 e��� �1�y��1 ��"� :"� ���� Yq�8��� ��/ �Ma J�j���� G�3 n��"���"g i*
i1gIt is pretty hard to defend absolute morals on grounds other than
religious ones* The god Delusion, p.232. i2g What's to prevent us from saying Hitler wasn’t right? I mean that is a
genuinely difficult question.
http://byfaithonline.com/richard-dawkins-the-atheist-evangelist¬ i3g Your belief that rape is wrong is an arbitrary conclusion* From an
interview with Justin Brierley of "unbelievable"
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�����: ;�Ma �;/ �%{/ S���<_ �� `�� C >��=�� ^� P6Ae �M� GkP�1�{ ��6�� �6KB!
+Ks�?^N va �� ��6�_ >1O 2=�_ � �;/, � r�Le ��Ma/ ��/ [y�K_ EH.��V� �A"#3 .��V� G�<;�� �8���<� 7�� �Ma P6AK� .��� ��sI 2=��***
�� G/ +e�m���� QK� C ^<� G/ 1�"�� PW) �A� ®�_ �� G�ZK�, !:¯ EHm�Ma �� 1L�#�� r�O �� r�Le ,E"�<V� �"��M� ��#�� P��e �? .L�� G�<;��
�� ���M� 7 #� �� �M� �� !:� �� �M� S���<� �� ��;�ZK�! Q�1�? b�N °�� �L?� ,E?� ��� >�)� >��1�� �8j_ ��)�� !a���Sam
Harris ����N1 C 2�2©� ��)�� >26�/ 2�/Free Will��"� OI , :" >��1��E?� ��� >�)�"ghi*
Free well is an illusion
�����: C �?� #� ��#; ��� ,�%{/ �?��=� S���<; �� >�)� >��1���?� ��p�� �� �?��� � `��!
F� P���)�� P����� �,cZ�_ Y��� PN�"�� P�}©� mL?� �1�y��1 �, � }# �%(�R 5 e��� :" �p;� v"s r�Le ��I ,.12_ �� tZK_ � PH�1��� >��y��
i1g Free Will. P.5.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
±R�;�,��w;/ 's�"ghi* ��6e�² �K6� � ��3�1 lI .��)�� .��V� `�#�� C G�<;�� ��p�� �LK? 1�, _� G�<;�� 1�, �� ,�_�s�_ 7 #� �/ ,m��=� P��� Ps�#� �/ ,��6R v8c �/
P6"�� E6<�_� �� !e E6<��� ,!Us/ -`�� C ����� !e �#�, �� ��<; ��L��sE,<�;/ E?�<;/ ���dg��f��e�g�i*
���/ ���qk� §���I �8jF� P�\V� PWpA�� mL? C�� �;/ J�#�N� �K6� � [� 4�/ �H1o ��"� ,� � Y, �� �� �%Us ,�MaArthur Allen Leff O��N/PK���k� >2p�V� �������3 ��� P#��:3 G�;�"�� :" G/ ��8H� P"��q 2=�_ �
k� §�� �? `�3� �� !3� "3 ���q³N ��"g i* P6R !e �,#� E6<�_ P���� 9�8u/ ��<_� P��<�� �� G�<;�� Sw� � ?�
��=��� �L? C!
i1g DNA neither cares nor knows. DNA just is. And we dance to its music*
River out Of Eden, p.133.
g�i ���� ,��� �� � :����*
i3g there is today no way of ‘proving’ that napalming babies is bad
Economic Analysis of Law: Some Realism about Nominalism (1974),
p.454.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A âìÜÈÛa@áà�Ží@…b§⁄a@ @
G�K_ �¥ m1��� /28� Y��� >��,#V� PA6©� G´s ��2pAV� 2�/ 1��B ��2 ������e :¦1�a P��/ Y M#F_ %s ,��N�<pV�� Y8��:��� EA#��3 EANF/ v"s �;/ �L?§�M ��!
P"M V� P#c��� ��{/ 2�/ Y? P�2"V� mL?�Logical positivism ���#�� G�"�� �� ��d�� 2"#�� �a��/ C ��y; P���)I P�<As Pe�� Y?�ghi *
�1�#V�� b�A#�� �� ��#3´3 Pe�)� mL? .�� _� ��2�N�� �K6F� � Y��� �?2{1 E�� Ps�#� P�/ >2y3 J1�B Y,s ,>��8V� P<)� P3�:��� �%a �� �,A�
�;�3 ®�N +e ,P<)� P3�:��� �%\3* .L�� QN���� �L?� �& ��� Pe�)� mL? ���M_ G/ P"�� PA��� C_ E�5
Y��� P��k� Q = �� ]<� P �2�� P��k� G/_s ,�?2�� F� 7�� P��k� §� a 'U F� ^� Y8��� ^� !�� !e �, � ¦�µ�!
�K�}e/� 7 �/� ��H/ �_�}a� G�<;�� J1�� ��k� �R�� C ^dK3 �� Y8��:��� Y#8M�� EA#��µ)� , G�3 G�8��M� �p; !,s � <���R �� �Lp;
!e � _�6���e/� � _�#��=� � ����k �U� � Y��� �1�#V�� b�A#�� EA#�Y8��:���?!!
i1g Michael Friedman, Reconsidering Logical Positivism (New York:
Cambridge University Press, 1999) P.xiv.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� G/ 1�8���� EA#�� �� P< K�� EK� G�3I �I � � �6<; ` ���� ��28�N� �;IP"q�? m^�� EA#�� �? �KA�!
?b�A#�� �� 2pAV� m2��� �� P��� �L? !? /2pAV� .12� � k� b�A� !e r�L3 ¦�a/ �;/ «+�=��� P�<A���� §%a
�� ¶�1���� b�A�� J����� G�;�"���Y#8M�� ¶�1���� b�A− �=���8�� Biology −«+�=��� ,��;�<A��� ,Q� �� EA� !d� PR%6� b�A�� ,!
?Y8��:��� EA#�� ����k �U� ¶�1���� b�A� !? �?2{1 �K6� P;�<;�� b�A#�� !e� «+�=��� P�<A���� §%ak� b�A� !?
?µ)� 1�q�� C �� ��8� b�2{ C �A#· �3 2pAV� �;2" F� G/ 2��� .L�� 1�q�� �L? GI
v"s �,"Aw� G/ 2��� PR%6� P6A� ��6���e/; �<��"� �� SN� �_ � ��kP{��*
P #� mL? ]<�/Anathema ?�+A#��� EA#�� �� ?b�A#�� SA�k � ���8� �+6<_ �L? Q�/
QN|� G/ �eLF� �� S:� ��� ��o 2����/ �?� P"M V� P#c��� P�<A���Sir Alfred Jules "Freddie" Ayer !#���3 P�<A��� mL? G/ lI �8 _
!d� PA{k� P;�<;�� b�A#�� G/� ,� ��1�s � ��w� �,A#�� b�A#�� SA�/ �p�E?� ��� Q��"V� mL¥ �8j_ 'M V�� §%ak� ! �� ��o 2����/ �=��_ � ?�
���<As, 23�¸�V� G�"�� �� <¹ �� �,A� ���� C / *
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
,!A"3 �_�s� !8R ];�e P"M V� P#c��� P���q ]8AR Y��� �}K�� >5&� �K� ��V� �� J�ZR�� P3�� ��o 2����/ ���� OINear-death experience � ���#V� �88M� º/� ,� � b�3 1�U���� �/1�* ¦1�= Y�^=Dr Jeremy
George �%(�R -P8:� -�+AK3 §�s/ G/ 2#3 : " 7ya/ ,P8� P&I ��R ]�/1 2"�Y(�1o� Y8�e !e P#=��V Y"��q C �/"ghi*
`�� lI .��V� `�#�� ��� PW) C P"M V� P#c��� QN|� ���"_ G�e �LK? �� � ���� m��=�3 ��|� �K� `���Z��Y��X��W��V��U���T��S�_�� �^� � � �]��\��[����h�� � � � �g��f��e��d��c��b��a��`l��k��j��i�g�i*
���O P���V� ��e�)� �� >2�2u -��3»� P"M V� P#c��� x�#�_ b����s ,�?^� !8R Y(� 8�� 2#3 �� �, V�post-structuralist �%d� EA#�� G/ ���
Y8��:��� µ)� b�"� ��8��� P6R C �, � '"p��� !p�<� x��s ��!d� :PA"�<� P=1�a P""pe � ;��R T�8U;�� ,�3�#�N� G�K�I� ,G�K�� P��"#�!
i1g "I saw a Divine Being. I'm afraid I'm going to have to revise all my
books and opinions"* http://variousenthusiasms.wordpress.com/2009/04/28/did-atheist-
philosopher-see-god-when-he-died-by-william-cash¬ g�i ,P#R���� >1�NP��� :gh¼−¼½*i
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
-�� �� '"p��� �;�K�´3 Q�� Y8��:��� EA#�� �,A� b�"� �+A<� �,Ae�Y8��:��� �, V� ��N P""� � �;/ �;}��� ��� ,�, �, s �, V� ��2N �,���<
�� �� '"p��� P��p�N� �_�L3 �_�O Y8��:����,A� b�R Y��� T��! ghi* G/ r�O lI ��UF� ,¾��3 ¦�� C �Ae Y8��:��� �, V� �U_ P""� mL?� >2?�yV�� Q)� �%a2 F� C ¿"#�� !6#�� �? Y8��:��� EA#�� C Ps�#V� 12j�
S��:���� –PA"#�� P��k�� ¿"#�� !6#�� �� 23� GOI − EA#�� $�N/� ,"#�� ��À28�� �? Y8��:���PA �� G�K� EH P"M V� �+A<FV�� C�#V� ���"�N
����� Y8��:��� EA#�� P��23 mL? ,�_�=123� * �� ��"; P8��:��� P<)� P��k�3 v"s EA<F�� PA"#�� P��k� �s�� .L��s :
?2{���� Q)� �%a2F� C ¿"� !6� G�23 P3�:��� Ppj3 EA<F_ [e� !\�F� %s3 EA<��� P8��:��� P��k� ¸��1� Y"M �� ¿"� QN�_ G��
C�#���P"8N/ PÀ23 A-Priori �/ `�#�� �/ ���8�� !"� C >�"�<�Y(��5���g�i*
Ps�#V� P��k�s Y8��:��� !�2�� v8U � �� ,P8��:��� P��k� �� P"3�N PA"#��P��/ ��À23� P"8<� x��s G�23*
#� ` ;n�O� �L? §�s� !e Q�� P��k� m�=� �� �=� �I Y8��:��� !�2�� 2P��k� *** �� � �"3�N � AR +Ks �I�Q Á)� 12j� ��� ? PR%ak� P6"�� 12j�
i1g http://www.princeton.edu/ ~achaney/tmve/ wiki100k/ docs/ Post -
structuralism.html.
g�i 4#8M�� ��s��a [yK� ��2��V� P�o , �3/��#<� �3� ��2��� ,EA<� b���� 1��, ½Ãà ���3*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
?�+©� Q)� 12j� ��� ?Y ���
5 e��� �1�y��1 Sj#�V� Y ��1�2�� 2pAV� ��"� Richard Dawkins :" �;/ �� P ��1�2�� 2c�� 4� �,"qF/� _�p3 ��k� 'A#"ghi*
Ps�#V� E"��3 �;2� G/ P#c��� P���V� P8��:��� ��e�)� �M�<_ %sP;�<;�� � ��A� P�1�#� v8U_ G/ �� ,PR%ak�!
� ��I S?L� �� Q�; �L?� �w ���Erwin Schrödinger / r;�K� �3 EK�� 1�"� 4� Y8��:��� EA#�� G/��2 � P6"�� �/ PR%ak� P6"�� �� t2p��
P�+©�P ��� P6"�� �/, �� ��%e La� � � rpU � �� �6�<; �=�1/ �,s²2©� !6! g�i*
2R� C � ��a|� 12{g�Äh� iY���� ��<A�� J��e 2pAV� $���_ ^,y�� !=�;Thomas Nagel G�� #3Mind and Cosmos: Why the
Materialist Neo-Darwinian Conception of Nature is
Almost Certainly False P0z >�1 !d6�� ,P���)��� P6A#�� T�N�k� C P:c 1�H/ J��K���
Y8��:��� Y#8M�� S?LV� P���e �� ��<A�A�*
ghi P"R� 5 e��� �1�y��1 �� .5A:;� >��5©� >� R �_�=/ .L�� ��"A��Å�* g�i '������ P#8M�� �3��e C �w;���Nature and the Greeks*
_…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
G�� #�� �� �,W� +e J��K�� >�Ks� :"���� .��V� 1�j��� 1�jR �� !�2� P#8M��"ghi* !!!!ا من حقل املعرفةا من حقل املعرفةا من حقل املعرفةا من حقل املعرفةجدجدجدجد ااااضيقضيقضيقضيق اااالم التجرييب ال يغطي إال جانبلم التجرييب ال يغطي إال جانبلم التجرييب ال يغطي إال جانبلم التجرييب ال يغطي إال جانبفالعفالعفالعفالع
�� ���� ��� ���: ��2�� P6"�� E6<F�� �1�#V�� b�A#�� �� �S� ��)���_�O �� '<�� 7�� v"s PR%6� ��6���e/� ��<N|�!
� ��"�*.�,y�� �� 28� :" P��6u b�K�/ 1�2{I P���²universalist-
absolutist Go�"�� }#� �L� ,�� 1}� � ��_ �? 'c Y8��� �R�� ��� E��K��� G�MA<�� °�A3 � � }#� P��6u b�K�/ 1�2{´3 Y ��� 1�#y�� �L?
Authority l�#_ ��"s :�i����h��g��f��e�����d���c��b�g�i* Æ 6 F� G�MA<�� r�L3 GZ"V� !��\��� �L,s ��~u Q�� ,�;��:�� G�MAN �� �
� �KA�6;e��d������������c��b��a��� ��_��� ��]��\�g igÅi* ،فال يجوز لك أن ت#سمم كل العلوم بدعوى أنها ال تتسق مع فلسفتك المادية اإللحادية
تحذف ما يروق لك اوكأن لك سلطان ،ثم تزعم أن رأيك هو الصواب
!وتقرر فقط ما يصلح لفلسفتك
ghi !:; $����� ,P#8M�� �� .��V� 1�j��� 1�jR �� !�2��� J��e* g�i �� ����� : ��������* g i ���� �� � : ��������* gÅi � ,G+���� EA#��� ��)�� C !(�N1 t%H * t�p8A� �+; 5e�� ,.�,y�� 2#N �3 �� 28�
l�k� P#8M�� ,��N�12���*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A ´ÐÔr½a@áà�í@…b§⁄a@ @
��)�� ��e�)� !e G�u �;�u P{�a �1�#�� PA"�<� QN/ �� b�"� Y��� �1�#V�� ��s�"d�� !e ��5� r�O C �?� ,¶�1���� }� ��,@ Y��� P��K���
!AR 2#3 �c� N +e P{�� ���<As� ����1 §�M; �� x1�#�_* P<;���� >1�d�� 2� �� ��� ��� �� P��23 L ��Révolution française
M;� Y��� b�� ]"AhüÇ,b !8"�<V� �K� `� ,4�"d6A� P0�� ���=k� �K_ ` b�2�I �� � ��28s ,4�"d6A� ��"y��� $|8�� �I >2�%V�� ����� ��� 2� �� !60
���s� G��M;/Antoine-Laurent de Lavoisier ª/ Pd�2)� ��6K��Father of Modern Chemistry È�{ �� ��/� ,4:<e�k� [y�K��
P6<��� b�W; !Ky_ C 2��N� ,PA�K�� ��"3 G�;�R� ,>��V� °�� G�;�R Y(�V� �w�� ��;/ �� ��/� ,Y(�6K��Water – Gas '��q �� b2�F/ .L���
PAj"V�3 $/��� ±Rguillotined C P���� ��� P<;���� >1�d�� 2� ��¼ ���� b��hÃÇÅR .L��� ,>^,y�� ����R n�L � ¸�"�� �� :" lI ¦��B � >1�d�� GI
>�R�8�"* "La République n'a pas besoin de savants ni de
chimistes ; le cours de la justice ne peut être suspendu g1i .
i1g Commenting on this quotation, Denis Duveen, an English expert on
Lavoiser and a collector of his works, wrote that "it is pretty certain
that it was never uttered". For Duveen's evidence, see the following: =
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�"�<� `� P���)I P~3 C 2��� ["d� � À ` P��<�� 7��� ]R��� r�O L �� ,�p3 ���dp3 C �3 �;�2"� �� !e C E?���N �� �I E,A��!
�6N1 ��)�� !{� 4�� E_ '3�<�� Y�s�<�� ��B�� C +e EK)� lI � 2R� ,��)�� �� x1�#�_ Y��� b�A#�� !e E��B J1�� [��= 2pAV� 4���N
Joseph Stalin '3�<�� Y�s�<�� ��B�� Q(1�A#�� «��;/ �� ^dK�� >2y3 b PH�1�A� �2 � 4;��R E��p�3 b�"s ,.��)I �s�23Mendelian genetics;
P�1��a�� �� b�"_ PH�1�A� �2 � 4;��R Gk, P���V� P6�)� �� x1�#�� �L?� >2y3 4���N x1�� r�O !=/ ��� ,4���N [��= �?2��� Y��� P���)��
,PH�1�A� �2 � 4;��R �R 2;�<� `�� ./ G/ }���� S· b�� �? �2 � 4;�3 �=���8�� �+A� �� ^de b�2�I E_ !#���3� ,���2�I���)�� EN P8")� C
P ���<��, �,u/ ��� ��|? ��As�s .��"; Pd�2)� PH�1��� EA� 2(�1Nikolai Vavilov*
�� �;�e �� E���� ��� � �2pA� ��As�s .��"; G�e �� E���� ��� P��K<� >º/ [��= P6�5� Y d F� ` �L? !e G/ �I ,Y�s�<�� ��B�� C P��R
E_ !#���3� ,PH�1�A� �2 � 4;��R EA#_ P6,�3 �A� �8"�� ��"�I �� 4���N C ��As�s ��"���É QM<�/hÇÅÄghi*
= Duveen, Denis I. (February 1954). "Antoine Laurent Lavoisier and the
French Revolution". Journal of Chemical Education 31 (2): 60–65. i1g Loren R. Graham (1993). Science in Russia and the Soviet Union: A Short
History. Cambridge University Press. p. 130*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��_�1�N �:N C �v83 b�#M�� �� ��As�s G���� E_�Saratov
prison C b�_ 1�6U3 S{F/ G/ lI P:�; >�s�� ,!Au �8"�/ �%U#��.f"�� ���:���! ghi*
¦}N�M3 P �2� C ��As�s P<N|� 2#F_ b����St. Petersburg }e/ P�y�KFV� ��8K��K�� 2�/ �� �6N� 'AqF/� ,`�#�� C ��_�8 �� �� © �6�
m��eL� � �2A� ��d�2�g�i* �F� b��� lI ��2pAV� G´s ��"�� PAs�; ��� P ���<�� P����� �� G�
G/ G�2e|�� P�1�j�� P���V� P6�pA� ,E?� ��� P�1��a�� �/ >�)� >��1�� Q�1�? b�N �,uk� 2pAV� r�O 1�0�Sam Harris ��)�� >26�/ 2�/
>�)� >��1�� ����N1 C 2�2©�Free Will��"� OI , :" ��� >�)� >��1��E?�"*
Free well is an illusiong3i .
i1g died imprisoned and suffering from dystrophia (faulty nutrition of muscles,
leading to paralysis), in the Saratov prison* http://www.splendidtable.org/story/how-nikolay-vavilov-the-seed-
collector-who-tried-to-end-famine-died-of-starvation i2g http://biodiversity.ucoz.ru/index/genetic_ resources _of_ leguminous
_plants _in_the_n_i_vavilov _institute _of_ plant _industry /0-10 i3g Free Will. P.5.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
b�R 2"s PH�1�A� �2 � 4;��R �� � �2#3� [��=4���N ��N�N �6c � �U�/P���)�� P#8M�� b�A� �� ^de E��p�3−���5��� −ghi*
�,s EK� Y��� P8")� C 4j�� �p; � ,��� Y�s�<�� ��B�� � e�_ �OI� �;�_ µ_ ��� 2pAV�Mao Zedong �� ` ��k�s �%8�� EA#A� ��2#��� � � de ^w
«��� 4u2�3 �;�_ µ_ ��� b�R 2"s ,>2y3� �?�@ 4�"dV�� �+A#��� >1�d�� �}K�� Ps�"d��Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution:
G�� #�� Y��� +e Ps�"d�� �; ]<� �}K�� Ps�"d�� >1�d�� >�Ks�, +;I�� ���� r�O �� QK#��, 4�"dV� !�R Y? >�K���s E,66<_� �A#s�; 4�"dV� Gk
��)�� �� �S� ��#��©� >L_�N/� 46A#�V��!
P6(�� >1�H C �%8�� 7"8_ G/ xZ�V�sperpetual revolution «�z� �6�<�–x1k� �� P)� �� (�K�� ��=�� P ��1�2�� >�W �� Y? mL?�− �s ��1
'8M_ �;�_ µ_ ��� �A6� r�O�g�i* ��6"� G/ ��#��©� P8Aq� $1�2V� L�%�� m����/ �;�_ µ_ ��� 'Aq/ 2"s �E�� ,�%8�� C Ê���� ���<s ,4N12V�� ��#��©� >L_�Nk P{�a Ee�² ��<A��� E,s +3 4�%V� 2,FMc�� «1��y�� C Ee�pV� ]6RF/� J���
G�� �y_� EW#��Chen Yuen A�F/� G/ 4�"dV� �� SAFq� $1�2V� ]"
i1g hps.elte.hu/~szegedi/cikkek/coldw.doc* i2g Feigon, Lee (2002). Mao: A Reinterpretation. Chicago: Ivan R. Dee*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�%��� b�"� 7�� [���� lI ��8?L���k� G�E,6A#�3 G− C >2�%V� }��� 2"s4�k� �#3 2� �� � � ±A\��� S· �S� P6���ek� Ps�"d�� G/ 4j��−!
>�� ���F�� P�1�� P���j�R�� P�+�=� Ê�s lI Ps�"d�� >1�d�� ��/]Aa�� ,4�%V� «���� �8{/� ;Y j�� �6�:V� C �� !e C Ps�"d�� >1�d��
m2u/ �� �� «1�j_� ,>2����� >ºk� !a��mO��N/ !�R L6A���� �3/ �� �3 * ÆR�4�%V�3 ��;�e PA��V� mL? ��R G/ ����j��� �12ghi*
� ,4�"dV� G�2=� C >5? Ps�"d�� >1�d�� P:�; ];�e� Ë� Á1 P��Ks > �& '8<� ` 4� �;�_ µ_ ��� G/ �eLF�� ,1�p�;�� lI ��^dK��3 r�O ��/ 2R� ,!d�
� >1�d�� ���= G��p� � $� �� G/ m�}a/��R Ps�"d� :" �� G����0 ��L�� � 1�p�; !AR �2� �� �� w�N�� P��,<3 � K6� ,�8��3 �¿� 2A3 4j�� ,E?O�";I �����B
$� �� ��"g�i* ��3 2R� ]R��� r�O C P q��� Pq��� 2(�R 1 ��s .Xie Fuzhi
©�� $1�2V� C L�%��� �3 b�"� .L�� ��V� 7�� S�L#���� J»���#�� �P#8q � �1��/ .�· �� !e � �}�#� ["d� .k� E�L_�Nk «1��y���g i*
i1g http://necrometrics.com/20c5m.htm#Mao*
i2g "People who try to commit suicide — don't attempt to save them! . . .
China is such a populous nation, it is not as if we cannot do without a few people*" MacFarquhar 2006, p. 110*
i3g "Don't say it is wrong of them to beat up bad persons: if in anger they
beat someone to death, then so be it*" =
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
9 �z 4� G�Ks ¶�1���� m�< � �� .L�� S��V�� Í?2V� ������ ��/ ��� ��! "! �#$ %��&' (�# )�*+� ,�� -�.�� /�0 -1� ��R�;�_ µ_ ��� C
b�� J5)� 1���K� «+�=�hǽ¼ :" ¾;��? � 4y_ �� � R��_ 2"�Qin Shi
Huang –���/ �+A#�� �s23 �,�u� E�2R Y { 1��q�}��− �+A#A� ��31�² C ¾;��? � 4y_ �s� 2"� ,4�"dV��ÅÉÄ � `�� ,���/ E? 2�#$ (�# ��� ���&'
)�*+� ,�� /�0 -1� ,¾;��? � 4y_ lI 1��6�N�3 ��8< _ G��"dV� �À/ EK;I ,G�~M¨ EK;I!*
�_ 2"�[#c P(+3 ¾;��? � 4y_ �� ]R�"ghi* �s23 ������3 �;�_ µ_ ��� 2pAV� Á[�K� `ÅÉ r�O !#= !3 ,`�� [�/
Y?�8���� �\�A� �>��2�!
= http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xie_Fuzhi MacFarquhar 2006, p. 125.
i1g During a speech to party cadre in 1958, Mao said he had far outdone
Qin Shi Huang in his policy against intellectuals: "He buried 460
scholars alive; we have buried forty-six thousand scholars alive ...
You [intellectuals] revile us for being Qin Shi Huangs. You are
wrong. We have surpassed Qin Shi Huang a hundredfold* Mao Zedong sixiang wan sui! (1969), p. 195. Referenced in Governing China:
From Revolution to Reform (Second Edition) by Kenneth Lieberthal. W.W.
Norton & Co., 2003. p. 71*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��V� 7�� JL F� 2R�hÃ�� b�� �?2�� 4K3 C �K��hÇÉÉ �L? !e��;�K� ^"B� G�<;�� ��5�a�� P���V� P�<A���� ��)�� EN�3! ghi*
2pAV� EK� >Zs C ����86e P��� G/ � ? �eLF� �� S:� ��� ��3 ��3Pol Pot Y��� 43hÇÃÉ−hÇÃÇ 3 ]��R ��3 ��3 �� ����3� ./ !�"�� ±\u>1�W; .2_ PK6N ["d� G�K� G/ Pya! g�i*
��<N|V�� ��#��©�� $1�2V� §%�I E_ !3 r�L3 ��3 ��3 Y��K� `� � 3 b� 3 P6{�#�� ]��B� ����86e C ��)�� EK� P8"� ���q P6A#���
Phnom Penh C »)� G�KN �� ��N1I E�� G�e� ,9�8u/ P �2� lI 2j�� E��B ����86e �1�R� ,P��� «1�5� C !6#A� ��3�w�� lI ����86e !e [�� ��=� !3 ,P��15A� v"s $� �� È���� 7�� �e����� 1�:u/ «%�R��§%�I� ,SM�� PN1�¤ E���� ���y�<V� §%�I� ,»)� C m�V� �3� � �� ���� ��~� ��� lI P;� :V� P���)�� ��N�<�� mL? ��/� ,$1�2V� S#y�� �¥ �6<� ` P;�<;I t1��e� P8��� ����� C .��86K�� S#y��
i1g MacFarquhar 2006, p. 124. i2g "People who they perceived as intellectuals or even those who had
stereotypical signs of learning, such as glasses, would also be killed".
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khmer_Rouge#Life_under_the_Khmer_
Rouge.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P���86K�� P��K)� ]Us1� ,�Ae `�#�� ]R �1/ PN�R P~3�/� ,!8R �� .��86K��P��� ��2��<� P�/ ]R��� r�O C >2pAV�ghi *
�L? GI G�K� � ��2pAV�� ��)�� 2� �� 4�"dV�� Ps�"dA� 26#�FV� E6<�����3 ��|� � � �#MR� ^K����3 �� EA#��3 �� G�<;��3 ��|� � `�� C �I!
وهكذا قام اإلحلاد فعليوهكذا قام اإلحلاد فعليوهكذا قام اإلحلاد فعليموهكذا قام اإلحلاد فعلي ما بتسميم املثقفني والفتك ما بتسميم املثقفني والفتك ما بتسميم املثقفني والفتك ا بتسميم املثقفني والفتك!!!!
i1g www.paulbogdanor.com/left/cambodia/locard.pdf.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A lìÈ’Ûa@áà�Ží@…b§⁄a@ @
lI �6M_ 2R >1�,"V� J�#y�� ^?�� C� ,>���#� ^� P�%{I ����3 P��N1 J�#y�� G�Oo �� � � de E,6N� ��Z� ` ��L�� >2�%V� !60 S��w�� P��)�� ��a��� G´s ��2�� >��"� ��A{� �� E��3� P���)�� E,��<A�3 P�^y8_ C ��)�� �?�= G�s�#� � ��L�� 1��8s ,��1�,"V� Sj; �� G�K�N >���<V��
P3��,PU��#�� �����2�� mL? �A#s PMA<�� lI >2�%V� 5�"�� �%8�� �#3 C � EK� �� 1�,u +31� ��� N P#U3 G/ �f�� �� ^dK�� ��� Y��� P:� �� �K�
8HI C P6N�� G�K_ ��2pAV� �A#s J�#y�� E6<F� ��)�� G/ �� >��3��3 �À�w�� � �, � G�<;�� �6<� ` Y��� P��6y��C �I Y��� ��2�� C � ����� ,¸�V� G�"��
�2pA� �,6 ÆK Æ��;�3 ®�N +e G! 2pAV� !{� 4� ��3 ��3Pol Pot ER1 Îk� �/h 1�N t���N �/
Saloth Sar ,−2��� 2pAV >1�#�<� >^de �+N/− C EK)� lI !{� 4� P�� { >1�H ^w3 EA0 4K<V� S#y�� �K� ` ����86e P��� �Ay� _ P���j�R��
P���"�� ��� N t%d�� G/ EA#� S#y�� �L? �K� ` �K� ,$|8�� !�� ��hÇÃÉ −hÇÃÇ S#{/ G�K�N �%8�� ��3 ��3 2pAV� �,s EKpN Y����
�,¯1�_ !e }� §%q�� �� ����86e ¶�1�_ C ��� N t%H! �6N1 ��3 ��3 ��3/ 2"s ��½ % P�<A���� ��)�� EN�3 �8#u �� �%a P���V�
EK)� C �?�UR ��� Nghi *
i1g Craig Etcheson, After the Killing Fields (Praeger, 2005), p. 119.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P8< �� mL?��½ % �6N1 PA:<F�P��2�� �_�s� C �ghi* b�� ����86e C P�� ���� ���"�� !a2_ ����hÇÃÇ 2pAV� 1�� [R�_�
���k� ��2�/ ��"�� ��2�/ ]R�s +3�� ����86e ����/ lI �3��?� ��3 ��3* >5=��� >Z��� mL? Y�s �� G2V�� »)� G�KN �� ��3 ��3 }=/
P��� «1�5� C .f"�� !6#A� [���� lI ��"�;��* P���� ��6�� C ^<� .L�� .��V� G�<;��3 �I ��|� ��3 ��3 �K� EAs–
P�o C $�_− �Aa�� !60 �� 7 #� �� P6R �� P�1�#� 7;�/ %3 G�<;I �;�e m5� PA"�<� Pj\u ������ �8j_� P��w��3 tZK� �� ,� � �R�A¨
� �, � �K¤ «�8uI ÐR/ '"B ������ P�+#�N� >��� m�W; P,=� �� x1k��de/!
G�<;�� �L? �? �Ae �8#u G/ P���)�� �����3 ��3 ��3 �@�! P��K)� G/ Y6N��� ����86e ����1 }� ��3 ��3 �A�/ �6K� P��23 C�
�� ¦��B � P���86K�� �3�_��� P��R� �q��� ��A� lI G�A� �� �de/ �,8#u P���V� P���)��Utopia;E& P=�� %s 4R�8�� ��/ , >2(�s %3 E�kg�i *
2"s ,��3 ��3 2pA6A� P;� :V� P���)�� P����� mL? ��Us1 ��L�� ��/�
i1g www.paulbogdanor.com/left/cambodia/locard.pdf. i2g " To keep you is no benefit, to destroy you is no loss".
Children of Cambodia's Killing Fields, Worms from Our Skin. Teeda
Butt Mam. Memoirs compiled by Dith Pran. 1997.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
E, � ���� ��~� J�pM{�3 >2pAV� P���86K�� ���"�� ]��R lI E����R�� ]Us1� ,���/ E,� s� EH ,EÀ2��3 E?1�8R ��p3 E���/� P#N�y�� ��")�
E,A� ��{�{��� §%qI; 2<= C �c�_ G/ �� �6H/ P{�{��� ��"Aq Gk"Bullets are not to be wasted" *
��)�� EN�3 ���/ ���� ��~� �,s �s F� Y��� ��")� mL? ]8p{/� C G�� ��#F_ EN´3 PV�#�� Ps�"d��"P���86K�� !�"�� ��"�" ghi *
��=� 48_ P"�� P;�2� ��N�1� C��Ä PR%6� P��� >}"� [�/ P3��R �s2� >2�%V� �,�2\�N� � �"8q .��86K�� S#y�� �� P6<; G�A�
[<;�A�UNICEF)i g�i* � E�/ �� �8A� �W � .L�� 2pA6A� ���d� ��3 ��3 G�e P6R %3 ��;��
Y#8M�� J�\�;��� ��"8�� !=/ �� «���� G/� ,7 #� �� P��� ��– 1�"_ +eP ��1�2��− `�#�� �L? C >2���� P=���8�� P��w�� �? ���a�� �,R�*
�� ��3 ��3 Ñ�� ,��3 ��3 P��K� T�"NI� ����86K� b� �s ��a� 2#3� �� .��� E�23� P"y V� S(��K�� �2�� P��K<� P��Ò !@ C m�6� �� 7"8_
i1g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_Fields. i2g UNICEF estimated 3 million had been killed*
William Shawcross, The Quality of Mercy: Cambodia, Holocaust, and
Modern Conscience (Touchstone, 1985), pp. 115–116.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
E�2"�� ��A� P8#y�� 4j�� P�1�,�ghi * ,y3 ��6� G/ !8R�(�R2{/ J�R/ ��3 ��3 !�R PAAR 1� �N G�{ ��I �
Son Sen � ���s �� 2�/��p�;� EH ,��A(�� ��, !R�: C !y�3 ���SA"��g�i*
�;�_ µ_ ��� 2pAV� EK� >Zs C 4j�� C� ����86e �� � �2#3�Mao
Zedong G�y¯ $� �� G�e.�,w u C J�pN Ppq�; ]B ^<��; 2R �;k���p� V� 2�/ rA� v"<�!
P��N !e >1�K�� >�?�@ �;�_ µ_ ��� EK� >Zs C 1�p�;�� �8{/ 2"s�� ���q4j�� «1��u C b�g i *
�;�_ µ_ ���� �� .�8�� Q ©� ¶�1�_ C b�� }e/ �;/ �� ��" �� �� j� �� !�R 2"s ,§%q��ÅÄ −ÃÄ !6#��� ���:��� ��N�N S8<3 P6<; G�A�
P�A�\V� ��R�#��� �� Hk� !�R� P��6y�� >��3��� ����2���� .f"��! gÅi*
i1g http://www.edwebproject.org/sideshow/ khmeryears/fall. html* i2g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phnom_Malai* i3g In Shanghai, suicide by jumping from tall buildings became so
commonplace that residents avoided walking on the pavement near
skyscrapers for fear that suicides might land on them Time. March 5,
1956. i4g http://www.hawaii.edu/powerkills/NOTE2.HTM. =
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
� b�� �� ��� � Chǽ¼ b��k� lI �}K�� >5�"�� �;�_ µ_ ��� 'Aq/Great Leap Forward , P��� �� 4j�� !��B lI �&%a �� �2À G�e�
�}e P�� { P��� lI P��1 – � H2B Y��� P3O�K�� PU��#�� P���)�� P���2����"V� P��23 C �, � −, �k� lI �}K�� >5�"�� mL? �K�EW�/ C ]88<_ b� P���
P��8�� ¶�1�_ C PA_�Rdeadliest famine in history *
�� 4�%V� ��� }=/ �� ,P��K)� ��)I S8<3 �}K�� >5�"�� ]Ays 2"s ��o E��e Y�� j�� ���;}�� �L? C !6#�� �� 4;2V�� �+#��� 4�%���
9�1 %3 P����, �� P��� ��2#� ��� SAq� �K�� ,>^8e �(��; '"p�� ¦��;�� �(�<a ���A¨ ,«��V� 1���s P���� $��_ lI ��p�� G/ S#y�� �M�<� ` ,PH1 Q3%63� b�#q %3 �R2� �"s ��,=��� �6d�� m2�� S#y�� �s� ,P6\c
P8< 3 J�8)� ¦��;� ��\;��h½%ghi* �8A� .��)�� �AAB Pp{ �� ��� 1�zI ��� ]R��� ��� ��� E�/�
]6R��_� � ���N 1��k� ���� ,�}K�� >5�"�� «��� [R� ��� �s1 ,��oª�#�� ��"�� E,A� '8M � G� j�� �+#�� 1�{� ,P�k� :" � �c1/ � ]8 V� GI
7"3/ � ��,@ �� �MR"*
P"A Á� §���� m1�K;I� ,E"#�� .��)�� �AAB� >z�"�� P���V� ������ � ��W;�
= Modern China: The Fall and Rise of a Great Power, 1850 to the Present.
Ecco Press. p. 351. i1g Spence, Jonathan (1999). Mao Zedong. Penguin Lives.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
� 43 1���s SAj��� 2�2)� �� F� G/ 9%��� �� �;�_ µ_ ��� SAq 2"s ,�8� �� SAq� ,P��15�� �1���s ���15� G/ 4s�)� �� SAq� ,SAj�� ¦��;I >5�"�� P:�; 4j�� ]Aa�� ,�� !e 1���s PM<8�� ��)� ��N1+� G/ 4 "���
P��:V� �� lI �}K��*
2"s}K�� 4j�� P��� ]H2� �Great Chinese Famine rA?� P��:V� mL? P:�; Ä Y��� 43 Y { G�A�hǽ¼−hÇÉ� !Ap��� ���=
C E&�5�a�� �8A� ¦O�<�� .��)�� .��V�w{ E,R��s �� E?5� bZB � PP_�L�� E�+j3 �� P{�� E��KA� �� P������! ghi*
<_ � �26� 2j"� �;�_ µ_ ��� G�e !? �K� ?�8#u E6t2� ��k� G/ b/ ?�6©� >��1I �� P=1�a ���@ Ee��_ P:�;� ,Ps2j��3
¾;�: = §2 s C ��= .º «+�=� CJinjiang Hotel P �263 ¶�1��3 .�,w u�½ $1��hÇ½Ç � ��/ P��:V� E\U�_ G/ !8R� �;�_ µ_ ��
�6N1 >2pAV� ����K�` P"3�N C �%8�� !{�² �AH ���3 � ¶�1�_ C t2B P��� lI PAAR 1�,u G�U� C �%8�� ��0 G/ �;�u �� 1��"�� �L?� ,4j��
¶�1���� C !d� �& �,W� ` �}e*
G/ �;�_ µ_ ��� 2e/ 2"s ,m��)I �? ��� �� ��1k� ����� �L? S8N���R �� �#8�� 1�j�� +e P6,� ]<� � ���= $� �� ��� PUR :" ��
i1g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Chinese_Famine.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
G/ !Usk�� �2= �ak� [j �� �8y� G/ �� ,S#y�� [j; ��6�"ghi * ^� �� �8�� 4�%� �� !#� Y���� P���)�� P���V� P����� mL? GI ��|_ �� ��3 ��|_ � ��"� �I �?��F_ � P���V� P����� mL? ,�3 tZKF�
G�<;��3*
!3 �� H/ J�8)� G�¨ ���� G/ �;�_ µ_ ��� �s1 2"�P��:V�g�i*
�¤ ��^de b2�/ 2R� ��5 � C J�8� rA6� �� JL#F� �;�_ µ_ ��� G�e�E&� � C J�8)� G�KA6�g i*
%3�4 $�56 � 7(��0 (8�� ��! "! ��� ��9 (�1!
P��K)� ��N�N �� >2y3 S#y�� ' � 2"s �c��� PH1�K� � ��W;�5�"�� [R� lI P��, �� C ��� �Mc�� ,>2pAV� b�� �}K�� >hÇÉ� ]A"�;��
Ì_ .�u �� lI P��2�� PN�(1Liu Shaoqi *
J�8)� �1��<� G/� �%w�� G�¨ � �#�º ���� G/ 2�2©� Q(��� «�M�N�� � AR +e ���3/ G/ 2#3 P��:V� [R�/ �¤ P�+N/��� ��2�� �� Ä P6<; G�A�
;� :V� PU��V� P��5�a�� ���<As� ��)�� EN�3�!*
i1g "When there is not enough to eat, people starve to death. It is better to
let half of the people die so that the other half can eat their fill.
Becker, Jasper (1998). Hungry Ghosts: Mao's Secret Famine i2g Becker, Jasper (1998). Hungry Ghosts: Mao's Secret Famine, p.81. i3g Becker, Jasper (1998). Hungry Ghosts: Mao's Secret Famine, p.93.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�}K�� �;��e�/ P��:63 �;�eLF_ >26#�FV� P���=�� P��:V� mL?�Ukrainian Great Famine 4���N [��= 2pAV� �,8K_1� Y����
Joseph Stalin 2R� ,���e�k� S#y�� S�����t�2�/ ]#R� P��:V� mL? b�� �%ahÇ �,�pc 9�1� �;��e�/ CÅ PN�N S8<3 ���e�/ G�A�
����k� L� F_ � Y��� ��#q�"V� �� P#��:��� 4���N [��=ghi* PN�<�� �,� _� >2pA� ];�e >Z��� rA_ C �;��e�/ G/ PW�%� ��
,Pe�Zu��;$�<6 =�>1� ��?#−�$�@AB�� (+C� ��$CD�� ,;$�<6 �(+C� ��2pAV� '� C 7�� ��2pAV� b��=I �� � ���8� � �=O�6; �L? G�Ks ,E&�d�/!
�� >1��j63 b�R� �;��e�k P=1�a ��2��<� P�/ 4���N �s1 2R� P(�Lw�� ���V�–P��:V� �� H/ J�8)� �� �q ��A� P3��R 1��{−, 2"�3 ��/�
:V� ]B 4#R���� �;��e�/ G�KN Pe�� P��–�A�1� F��# �� ,G��H I*J5 − , ��2_ P��R ����� �s ��,@ G/ 2#3 ���e�k� S#y�� ��OI !=/ �� �L? !e
P;��e�k� P��"A�nationalism Ukrainian S#y�� �e�_ 4���N ��1�s 7 #V�3 P��� Q� t2� �� G/ �2e/ P#6"�� ��N�<�� mL?� ,���e�k�
+;I� P��:6A� ��,#V� P��6u P��� >��3Ig�i*
i1g http://www.unitedhumanrights.org/genocide/ukraine_famine.htm. i2g http://eng.maidanua.org/node/792.
http://www.paulbogdanor.com/left/soviet/famine/ellman1933.pdf.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
� ��N�N 2�/ Y? ���:��� PN�N�S#y�� «�� �� !��#��� C ��)�; S"#_ S#j�� ��� � �#�º �,:(�� 3 ®�_� P"?�� �� P�AK� ^� PN�N ��k
�,8K_��* � C�¼ }6s�;�ÄÄÉ 1�R �6N1 ���e�k� ��V}���� 1�8��� � Y�s�<�� ��B
���~<� ���8�� b�� �;��e�/ P��� ��hÇ * ��� � C��ÄhÄ [��= b��� P6N1 P�j3� ��^a/ �;��e�/ P6K² �1�R
���e�k� S#yA� P�+©� >��3�� PA6#3 4���N, P��:V� rA_ �%a ��, Y���� �,�pc 9�1 � AR +eÅ ���e�/ G�A�ghi*
�� ]N�R Y��� >2���� Y? �;��e�/ �K_ `� ,P���)�� ���:��� ��N�N �8q 4���<s P8")� C ���8�� 1�"�� ,��#q�"V� �� ^de C ���:��� PN�N '
]<��K;�e ��3�1 P ���<��Robert Conquest ����� ���pc G/ lI ]A{� Py���� >��3��� P�f"�� 4���N Ä �%8�� ��p;/ C !�R G�A�g�i*
V ��W#��3 �¿� ¶�1����� Ô� E,6(��=� ��2pAV� ±jR� , ��8_� !��_ � G��5�� ¶�1�_ C >�3�� PpV �I �,W_ G/ �&�q �� P��"� �M�<_ �� ����N�� P ��_�_ +31� ,�eLF� ` +3 ^j8_ �s �e FO �� !#� �K� ,��2pAV� ���K� ��
i1ghttp://www.kyivpost.com/content/kyiv/kyiv-court-accuses-stalin-
leadership-of-organizing-56954.html. i2gConquest, Robert (1991) the Great Terror: A Reassessment, Oxford
University Press.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
� 2u/ ��� m��H/ +s J�8�� �L? C [�|� ���p�� ���3? C ��I P=�) >Z��� mLX1�"A� ª�#��!
�;/ ���"; �� P{%a!d� ��pAMj� �,W_ `" b��e/� ,YR�#�� ^,M��� !�"�� ��"�� ,^3��M�� !�R� ,E=+©�the Killing Fields " !a�� �I
2pA� �,6K� Y��� ��2���G! K��{z��y��x��w��v��u��t���s��r��q��{z��y��x��w��v��u��t���s��r��q��{z��y��x��w��v��u��t���s��r��q��{z��y��x��w��v��u��t���s��r��q
_��~��}���|_��~��}���|_��~��}���|_��~��}���|LMNOP
ghi >�"8�� >1�N : P���gɼi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A @áà�Ží@…b§⁄a´äí†n:½a@ @
��z�� ��L�� !e G�?O/ C >�"�<� PÀ23 �? 4 �2�6A� ��)�� E6<_ [R��V� �� Ð F0 � +3 ¶�1���� °��0� ,��;��� J�p{/ ��;�e� >2pAV� ��2�� �,6K� Y��� ��2�� C G���k� E��p�� 4;��R ] FN 2"s ,���2�� mL? 2e|_ Y���
G�2pA�−!d� >��V�½� 1��N2�� �� P N 2�2©� Y�s�<��hÇÃà ± _ Y����G/ �� :" FB� Y6A#�� ��)�� 7��_ P��2���/ !8ÁR � Á� ��2�� 4"A_ b�P P,="−*
2pA� ��{� ��:63 x1k�3 ��;��2�� J�p{/ 23�#� P��<_ ]��s ,EKpA� Y�/ �;�8� ��d6e §%�I� b2? E_�hÉÇ P< e� 2:<�, !��B E_�
>^8K�� �1��Ku P(�12_�e Shkodër Cathedral Pc����� J�#�Ô� P��R lI Palace of Sports 2#32pAV� ��{� P=�a 1�;/Enver Halil
Hoxha C EKpA� /�;�8�ghi* ,��2��e ��a/ Ps�#� §�<;/ PÒ�5� !8"� � !"�<� C�#� '<; ��)��s
2pAV�s �#N�3 �� !#�N �;´s PMA<�� m2� C G�K_ 4��� �"� 7�� P6N P�/P �� 4 � ^6��%s !(�N1 C� ,Vladimir Lenin P6N���− G�� 2#_ Y����
PN���� P��K)� '(�H� ��–� �"3�N P�s�<�� − , PN�(�� !{� 4� 4 � ��"�!(�N��� rA_ 2�/ C '3�<�� Y s�<�� ��B�� :" ��=1 'pN G�� � A� S·
!e ��¹I� ,>���? %3� b5� !K3 ��2��& P���"� }� r�O ��< � � �p3 E
i1g Wayne C. Thompson (2007). Nordic, Central, and Southeastern Europe.
Stryker-Post Publications.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
4 <��"* � �U�/ ��R� !3 :" �1��R 12{F/ «+�=�� �L? C� ��2�� ��=1 �� PKA� P��´3
�u E& «2; �� PÒ1 %3 Q(� K����~ �K¤ ]R� «º/ C 1��"�� �L? .�·� ,>���K�� 7,� 63�, !Us/ G�e 1� �� E,A� 'AMF; � Æ� �2� �� +Ae�"ghi*
� Î1|V� 1�"� ,��2�� ��=1 b�2�´3 4 � �� Y6N��� 1��"�� �L& �P:�; 5:s �2��;1�/Orlando Figes P3��R G/¼ÄÄÄ ,E,��2�I E_ �?�e
4 � P��N1 S8<3 4 �2�V� �� ���� �����g�i*
i1g Lenin said: "we must precisely now smash the Black Hundreds clergy
most decisively and ruthlessly and put down all resistance with such
brutality that they will not forget it for several decades". He also said: "At this meeting pass a secret resolution of the congress
that the removal of property of value, especially from the very richest
lauras, monasteries, and churches, must be carried out with ruthless
resolution, leaving nothing in doubt, and in the very shortest time. The
greater the number of representatives of the reactionary clergy and the
reactionary bourgeoisie that we succeed in shooting on this occasion,
the better". Source: letters from Lenin. http://www.loc.gov/exhibits/archives/ae2bkhun.html.
i2g Donald Rayfield, Stalin and His Hangmen: The Tyrant and Those Who
Killed for Him. Random House, 2004.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P8")� rA_ C .��)�� J�?1�� 2� �� ��A� FR ��L�� ��2�/ �12FR 2R� P3��"3 >^j"������ S#y�� �� 3/ �� P6<; G�AV�ghi*
4���N [��= 2pAV� ��/Joseph Stalin a ��B�� PN�(1 C 4 � P�A ,� � 4 �2�6A� � �yM3 !R/ �K� EAs Y�s�<�� � �"8Ms ^,y�� Î1|6A� Q83 �1�y��1
Richard Pipes Y��� 43 4���N !�R 2"shÇ Ã −hÇ ¼ P(�� �� �de/ v"s��� !=1 [�/ , b���3 �_�s� !8R� PAAR >��8� ����/ 4���N 2pAV� 12{/
�� 46A<V� ��,Mc�3 ���� !�R� ��"��� E_� ,4;�26#V�� r��H�K�� G�����2=�<V�� Q(� K��� 23�#V� ]�2 F?�g�i*
T�y; ¦�/ G/ Y�K��P��K<#�� ��2pAV� PM3�1 League of Militant
Atheists PM3���� mL?� ,4���N [��= EK� >Zs �%a G�e EU_ ];�e P3��RR� ,�U� 4�%� P�N !�"3 ��6N1 ]��G���k� J�p{/ S�L#_� �3O� ,
]�2?�Å� C Y�s�<�� ��B�� ��� }� P< e� 2:<�� P �� P<N|� [�/ �� >Z���hÇ Ä lIhÇÅh P6N��� '(�H��� S<� ]A�R� , ��o� ["N/ P(��
µeO�H1k� ��2�� ��=1 �� ���� ����� G�8?��� 2R� , �2� !{� b�#�� C PM3����3 P{�� ���1�2��hÇÅÄ lIŽ ��)Ö� ��2_ P�1�� [�/
i1g Stewart-Smith, D. G. The Defeat Of Communism. London: Ludgate
Press Limited, 1964. http://www.hawaii.edu/powerkills/USSR.TAB2A.GIF.
i2g Pipes, Richard (2001). Communism: A History. Modern Library
Chronicles. p. 66.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� $� �� �� F_���2��ghi* �;�_ µ_ ��� 2pAV� b�R 2"s J� ©� C ��/–4j�� Q(1− Y��� 43 ���
hÇÅÇ − hÇý 3 !�"�É Y { EA<� G�A�− 1�w�k� n��_k� Uighurs − , b�� C�hÇÉÅ �%(�R �_�2�2� ��� �; :" QR1� S����*<� T*UF*@V �(�W! X��"*
¦� F ��� G�e �L¥� �c1�#� }�#Æ� G�e� P;�<;�� � Á� 2c [R� �� ! Fe ��1�M_ ��Ma >1�d�� �*
Õ F1 C1 Q6= ��"�James Revee Rusey :" G´s ��×V P8< ��3 Q�� � ��3 ��<� S#y�� ��2�/P;�<;�� PA��#V�3 '� 7;�/ E&"g�i*
G/ 2e|; ��"�� PAs�; ���4 � P8"� �� � � de ^w�� ` z�#V� ��)�� �/�;�_ µ_ ��� �/ 4���N Q�1�? b�N z�#V� 2pAV� �? �,s ,Sam Harris
��"� 2�2©� ��)�� >26�/ 2�/ �3��e C"G+��� P���" the End of Faith ��)�3 :" �K6� �p3 G�K63 >1�M� �� !(�<V� �#3 �� !�R G�K� G/
2"�#� �R%a/ �?�"g i* !�R G/ �<�; J��K�� C Q�1�? b�N 1�"�� !{��<_ P���; PA8 "3 46A<V�
i1g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/League_of_Militant_Atheists. i2g China and Charles Darwin, James Revee Rusey p.456. i3g Some propositions are so dangerous that it may even be ethical to kill
people for believing them. The End of Faith, p.52
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
u�2#8�<� ^� ��/ 23k� lI E,�sghi* !هذا هو اإللحاد حين يحكم
!هذا هو اإللحاد حين تكون له دولة
.هذا هو مصير كل مؤمن في دولة اإللحاد
K��Z��Y��X��W���V���U������ ��T��S��R����Q��P���O��N����M��L��K��Z��Y��X��W���V���U������ ��T��S��R����Q��P���O��N����M��L��K��Z��Y��X��W���V���U������ ��T��S��R����Q��P���O��N����M��L��K��Z��Y��X��W���V���U������ ��T��S��R����Q��P���O��N����M��L��K
��g��f��e��d��c�� � � � � �b��a��� � �_�� � �]��\��[��g��f��e��d��c�� � � � � �b��a��� � �_�� � �]��\��[��g��f��e��d��c�� � � � � �b��a��� � �_�� � �]��\��[��g��f��e��d��c�� � � � � �b��a��� � �_�� � �]��\��[���v��u��t��s��r�����q��p��o��nm��l���k��j��i��h���v��u��t��s��r�����q��p��o��nm��l���k��j��i��h���v��u��t��s��r�����q��p��o��nm��l���k��j��i��h���v��u��t��s��r�����q��p��o��nm��l���k��j��i��h�b��a��� ��_��~��}��|��{��z��y��x��w�b��a��� ��_��~��}��|��{��z��y��x��w�b��a��� ��_��~��}��|��{��z��y��x��w�b��a��� ��_��~��}��|��{��z��y��x��w LMYOP
i1g Harris, S. (2006) the End of Faith, the Free Press, P.129.
g�i ¦�}�� >1�N : P���gÅ−hÄi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
åí†zܽa@áà�Ží@…b§⁄a
�� G�"�� �?2,u Y��� �}K�� ���������# Y��� ��=����2�k�� ,G P���)�� P�5 ��3 P��� �,Ae ];�e G�"�� r�O C �, 3 J�)� 7�1 �1��
��=�A� P���V� P������!* Pu���� � Á6sFascism P ���<�� lI ���M�I CStalinism ��B�� C
P���V� lI Y�s�<��Maoism P�� �� lI 4j�� CNazism ,�;�V/ C � `�#�� �� s �� ]A#= ,P�1�{ P���� ��=����2�/ 2{�� G/ �I Î1|V� �M�<�
PW) P�/ C '"p�A� PA3�R PUR!* P;+A� J��� ��;�e P;�d��� l�k� G���V�#�� G�3�)� GI !3– ,P;+A�
��" �� �p; Y#<�� ��s��a� P��8�� $� =� P���)I ��1�j_ +,6KB��"8��� ,YR�#�� �A{�Survival for the Fittest , $� =k� >��3I�
7;�k�Natural Selection P3��R >��3I P:� �� ];�Ks ,½ % `�#�� G�KN ��=1/ 7 #� %3 P;� � J��� C �%e ]# ,��1��� lI G�R �AH b�5,V�� �� V� ��
� .2 ©� ��d� �� ��23 Q�1�3 vN� C P��8� �c�3 P�N%��� b�R� �P�� e ��,:V>1�U)� P��� �� *
P��� Y�K_ P��� �� PpANk� �� ��;�N�_ P���)�� n1�#V� rA_ ]�Aa�
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
>2�2� -���� �Ae .�8�� Q ©�ghi * .��)�� «���� �� 5e�F; G/ ��; ��"V� �L? C � K�− ��d� ^a� ,.��)��
4���N [��= �? 1�q�� �L? C �R�<;Joseph Stalin � ; 4���N [��= �?%� ��d�� 2(�"�� ,P�%s b/� C�KN/ Jk .1�� P �2� C 2� F� ,Y�s�<�� ��B�� P�2©� P���V� S�e ���q m�6� �� >�� P<��� 4���N ¾A3 4 P�<A����
C� Y��y�� µe1�V� �K���3 �H��� /23� ,2)/� Y �2�� m2"�#� nZs P���)�� EU;� P"�� PA��� b�� C� ,4 A�hÇ�Ç ¿#��� Ee�)� 4���N [��= �8{/
%�Y�s�<�� ��B! g�i*
�/1 2"s ,��=�A� ����1� 4���N ��s�_ �� }ek� �Hk� ��)� G�e Y? P����� Pe�)� G/ �/1� ,�� �� !e�_ ,P�@� ���+:e �8�� 4���N
ihg �1�2;���? G�s ��� ©� .�:V� .��<6 �� 2(�"�� S�eVan Hodzandorf − C ^8K�� 2(�"��
k� PV�#�� J�)�l�− J�)� ��,�;� 2#3 ��"� S�e :" P#8M�� G�;�R J�)� *** 7< ; G/ �× A� �%AR G�×��k� ��I �×;��2_ ��."
James Joll, Europe Since 1870, peguin books 1990 p.164
s ��/ �1�;�31�s r�12��Frederick Vorbernard �?�/ l�k� PV�#�� J�)� ���� = 2���"� S�e 2"s: " �(��; YM#F_� «��A� P#8M�� C ���k� P=�� 12"3 P=����2�/ P=�� J�)�
F�P=���8�� P�� �� �� P�2."
Man in process world .pub .co., New York 1961, p.76* i2g Montefiore 2007, p. 77. Jughashvili's complicity is implied in the memoirs of
Constantine Kandelaki, a Social-Democrat and colleague of Jughashvili in
Batumi at the time.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��<;�� ��=�A� >2���� PAAp��� Pwj��–��1P ��1�� P���)I P− * 4���N !�R !#���3� ,�R�s1 ��2pAV� �� rA_ ����1 '8M�3 4���N b�R�
Y�s�<�� ��B�� C §%q�� �� P���)�� ����"�� }e/ �� P��6� * �����3 4���N 2pAV� b�R �� 2pAV� YK<_��_ G��Leon Trotsky
�Òk� Í©� 2(�R� QN|�� §%q�� �� µe1�V� �K�A� �W � }e/ ���H ����e1�� G���1 !6#�� 4���N !N1/ �� ,Y�s�<��Ramón Mercader
4 � P6:; G���1 4���N � �� ,r<KV�3 m�� � C YK<_��_ ����� .L��� �>�s�K�!
G�� PA(�� �� �8"��3 4���N b�R P"�� PA��� C� E,�2�/� YK<_��_� �#�! ghi*
��K�1 YK<�/ 2pAV� b�2�´3 4���N [��= 2pAV� ��/ � �U�/Alexei
Rykov , � �<(1 G�e� Y�s�<�� ��B�� >26�/ }e/ �� �L? ��K�1 YK<�/�%� �� >Z��� C Y�s�<�� ��BhÇ�Å−hÇ�Ç P6e�² 2#3 ���2�I 4���N 1�R� ,
b�� C P�1�{hÇ ¼g�i*
i1g The murder weapon was a hidden cut-down ice axe, not an ice pick
Many history and reference books have confused the two Robert
Conquest, The Great Terror: A Reassessment, Oxford University Press,
1991, p. 418. i2g http://www.archontology.org/nations/rus/rus_govt1/rykov.php.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�b2�/ 2R 5�/ 7�� ,Y�s�<�� ��B�� >2�%� �� Ð F0 � �� 4���N 2pAV� ��1�a�3 .��K; !d� m�6� §�s1Nicolai Ivanovitch Boukharine
]s�<�� ��2pAV� PA� ���B Q(1� ,G^� ��KA� P�L� ��� P :A� b�#�� 4�k�"���s��3" Pravda , !N1/ 2R� ,}ek� 4���N [A�� lI P��N1 ��1�a�3
�,s ��"� ���2�I �� b��/ !8R 4���N4���<�: "�3�e !?���/ G/ �2��_ �O�V" 'Koba, why do you need me to die?'
+¥�8u �� H/ .f�� 4���N EN� �? �3�e�! �_�s� 2#3 4���N S�K� C P��N��� mL? �� �d F� 2R�! ghi*
b�2�I E_ 7�� b��/ �� `� 4���N �/ �3�e 2� �� ��1�a�3! ��"���� ���K<#� lI ��1�a�3 P=� Y�; E_ �?2#3�! g�i*
� #<_ � +31 ,�_�� §�s1 ��2pAV� �� 4���N E(��= �f; G/ �;�1/ �OI� ���w�I � Á6s ,��R�k�Aagoda YK<s�e�1 lI Rakovsky YK< �<��e lI
Cristinesca YK<��_ !(�\� lIMikhail Tomski [ ��e [� lILev Kamenev [��s� � .1�·�= lI YK<_��_ �,{Grigory
Zinoviev �2= ��M_ P6(�"�� 4���N 2pAV� E,A�R ��L�� ��2pAV� �6#�� §�s�3 �PMA<��� >�"�� m2� C ]p8{/ 4�!
[��s� � .1�·�= ^ak� �L?�Grigory Zinoviev ��R: I b�2�I G
i1g The Unknown Stalin, I.B. Tauris, 2006, chapter 14, p. 296. i2g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nikolai_Bukharin.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��2pAV� �L? S8<3 ���2�I E_ �>��8� ����� b��� C� ;P6��= 4���N §�s1������! ghi*
E��=� !�"� G�e !3 ,m�6� §�s1 ��2pAV� !�"3 Y��K� � 4���N G�e� YK<�=�a�_ !(�\� ��u1�V� �� t2� �� Q�; �?� ,E,A(��� !e� E?���/�
Mikhail Tukhachevsky , §�s1 �,u/ ��� Y�s�<�� �Òk� Í©� 2(�R ��5� .��K; P�f�� Pq��� Q(1 ���´3 ���"��� ��= .L��� ,4���N
Yezhov ,���2��3 P\MA� ];�e �_�s�Z�� PR1� G/ 7�� �8�L#�3 ����R EH, 4��]B T�8c �� P;�KV� P��K<#�� P6KpV� b��/ ��"�� [R� C �_��Ihh �;��hÇ Ã
�R� :"��e �#u/ EA� C I feel I'm dreaming)i"g�i* ���2�´3 ����K� `�, ¦��K�� lI �� 3�� ��=�� �_�""u ��AN1/ OI , ���2�/�
m��"u/* �� P<¹ b�2�I E_ YK<�=�a�_ b�2�I �� >^jR >2� 2#3 �;/ PR1��V�
��6e�² >�UR ��;�e ��L�� 1�8K�� T�8U��! ��N ,P"�� >Zs C���5� .��K; ��q� 2(�R 4���N: �ao ];�e �O��
��"s ?b2#F� G/ !8R YK<�=�a�_ �+Ae:" G�8#d��–YK<�=�a�_ 2j"� − G�e
i1g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grigory_Zinoviev. i2g Stalin: Court of the Red Tsar, page 225.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��"� :I Ps/��� SAM� G�e� ,4���N 's���� P��2A� b��a �;"ghi* ��2pAV� �R�s1 �� 4���N G�e �LK?!
4� 2pAV� !#�� �LK?m��)I '8MF�! S"� 'AMF � �� e ���"2pAV�" �%a � Á6s ,!#s �� !#�� ` �� 4���N ��
$� �� J�R/ >��3I� ,�6©� !�R r K6� S<ps ��)��r�I G�;�"� � �"8q , �A{Ô� ��"8��Survival for the Fittest �I� n2"� � G/ 2pAV �· ��
��)�� E,�� � �,s! د من أعمدة اإللحاد؟د من أعمدة اإللحاد؟د من أعمدة اإللحاد؟د من أعمدة اإللحاد؟لكن لماذا قتل ستالين هذا العدلكن لماذا قتل ستالين هذا العدلكن لماذا قتل ستالين هذا العدلكن لماذا قتل ستالين هذا العد
��� Z��W� �� [*A0 ��: I �I ��2pAV� �� �2#�� �L? !�"� ` 4���N 2pAV� G C G�8���� ,`�#�� !e C Y��y�� ��)��3 ^y8��� C G�8��� ��;�e E�k ��2_ 2R >�M� mL? G/ ��� 4���N G�e� ,P31�k� ��2�� �� �2� }e/ �%���
�� P�s�<�� P�k�,>2�� ��\s V� ��|? 2�/ '8MF� G/ 4���N ����1 >2�% �#R�� rA_ P���)�� ./ Ps�u ��j~�N�3 1��8� G�e �L�� ,� mL? !d� �,WF� 2pA�
���/ ����2�� ���3* �2R �� P���)�� P{����s 4���N �� �8U� b�= Sj� YK<_��_ G�e1�K�_ YK<_��_ ��� +e [R��� G/ 4���<� �· � Y��y�� ��)��3 ^y8���� ,
i1g The snake said he was dedicated to the Motherland and Comrade Stalin.
He asked for clemency.
Stalin: Court of the Red Tsar, page 225
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
� �−>��2�� �S�− ��L�� !e� 4���N 43 Q(��� b�2j�� S8N �L? G�e� ,4��:V� ��2pAV� �� P �� «�z PU"�� ];�e 2"� ,E,A�R, 2��� E,U#3
���/ ��8<�KV�3 Ø������–4���N−, ^�2�3 !:#��� 2��� �a�� �#8���#��`�−YK<_��_−"��)��3 `�#�� ^y8_ 2jR/" * � 7�� b%K�� �L? ��R/
2� C PMA<�� ];�e �� ��|,s ,4���N E,A�R ��L�� ��2pAV�3 Ps/1 EeLa�_$�Nk� �� PM��� �� �31�/ ��2:�� b��� ��;�K_ ` +31 E?2�/ ! �K� EAs
V� ��5�� C �I G��A�¯ >2�%V� ��|?^�2�� SN� �=� ,��)��3 `�#��� � �R�s1 �¥ !:#� G/ ��1/ Y��� 4���N ����6q [R��� P;�d�� PV�#�� J�)�
E,A�R ��L��! ghi* ��L�� G/ ��"; � ;´s ,�pj�� �?1�qI C >1�j�� !AB ���p; ��2 � GOI
i1g When carefully examined the point of conflict between the Stalin and
Trotsky groups turns on the theoretical question of whether Theory
can be built completely in one land, and that a backward one like
Russia, without any help from revolution in other countries. The older
view, still held by Trotsky, maintains that more than Russia must be
won for the revolution it Socialism is to be a complete success. The
newer view, now held by the vast majority of Russian Communists, is
that they can do the whole job alone—if they have no foreign war in
the meantime.
https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/strong-anna-
louise/1925/12/stalin_vs_trotsky.htm.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Pppj�� P���A� J�R/ ��;�e� ,� � � ���)I �de/ ��;�e 4���N [��= E,A�R ��)��3 `�#�� ��� !K� P��6y�� P�Lw��� �� E,���1 26�#_ �� ,��)�
"PAa�2�� �������", ��,8©� !e ��s Y #� �L?� ,�31�/ ��� ±ak�3� �� «º�3 4c1�#V� !e >��3I� ������� P�Lw_� ��2�� !e C ����� ��#uI�
PK<_�Z�� P��W �� SF� �? �L?� ,�K6�Trotskyism �� [��= �,���R Y� ��B�� [< � �,"8M_ ��� G/ �/1� ,� #3 G� ©� �,s �/1� >�R !K3 4���N
23� P���)�� E,��<As v"<F�� Y�s�<��ghi* G�K� !e C ������� !#yF_ G/ rA� P���)�� PK<_�Z�� P�<A�A� � �"8Ms
−Y ��1�2�� .��V� m1�W 63 ��"8�� !=/ �� «�z − V� +s ��"� +e P<e1� ��;�\A3Plekhanov ,P�+�=�� b�A#�� C P ��1�2A� '8M_ �I $�<\�#
]�^� _?R!��! ��9 �`1� ,,a�$ =�b c d*�� � 7���*+ ��R�\� ��9 �� �*J�e1��� �� f.?5 $�<g1!
!!!!فاإلحلاد قد حفر بفلسفته انونة قربا يكفي لدفن العاملفاإلحلاد قد حفر بفلسفته انونة قربا يكفي لدفن العاملفاإلحلاد قد حفر بفلسفته انونة قربا يكفي لدفن العاملفاإلحلاد قد حفر بفلسفته انونة قربا يكفي لدفن العامل
3/ 4���N G�e 2R� ��"_ Y��� PeL�� ��ApA� J�R/� ,��)�� �?�= �� 2# �� YK<_��_ G�� G/ !�/ �L�� ,P��2�� 2��N 2�y� 4� lI ���=�� �L? ^a�_ !�/ ,>2y3 �R��� G�e ��k� �L?� 4 � ^6��%s 2#3 EKpA� !j� G/ «�M�N�
_� >2�%V� EK� ���= [¨ .��; ���u Í#N G�e �Ae `�#�� G/ E,"8M`�#�� C G�K� !e C ������� ��#uI P�<A��!
i1g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trotskyism.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�;�_ µ_ ��� lI � ,��� 4���N [��= � e�_ �OI� Mao Zedong −2pAV� 4j�� Q(1− �6K� >Zs �%a� ,�6©� �� m2"� C m��)I S8<_ 2"s
¶�1���� !e }� b�� }e�e �� j_ E_ 7�� �8�� �� Ð F0 � �� ��3/ 4jA� , �� !�R 2"sÅÄ−ÃÄ P6<; G�A�ghi *
,>2�%V� �� �3 4MpV� J�R/ �;�_ µ_ ��� E,��j�3 b�R � Æ� PA� ��� 2"s !�"� La/ E,s�� C 2pAV� b�W �� E�� 7�� ,>���? %3 ��A� Y�s�<�� ��B
������ P���p63 E�2"��g�i*
s >Z��� rA_ C 2pAV� Y�s�<�� ��B�� ` ,�;�_ µ_ ��� E(��= �� EA<Æ�� [ F{ 2pAV� Y�s�<�� ��B�� ��2� �;/ �� S#yA� 2pAV� Y j�� �R�� ,
t2B ���e� ,>2pAV� 4j�� P��K�� ]s�<�� ��2pAV� 43 2�2u �%a ��y_��a ��K; 43 P���)I P���)I �}e P���; Pe�#�Nikita
Khrushchev � Y�s�<�� ��B�� Q(1 µ_ ��� ��R 2R� ,�;�_ µ_ ���Y�s�<�� ��B�� �� J�)�3 � �(5,�<� ��y_� �;�_ :" 4j�� 2"�_ G/ EÀ �
ÄÄ �; J�� C G�A�� A� 4R�8�� 26j� G/ E,V� P��"g i*
i1g http://www.hawaii.edu/powerkills/NOTE2.HTM. Modern China: The Fall and Rise of a Great Power, 1850 to the
Present. Ecco Press. p. 351. i2g Ion Mihai Pacepa (November 28, 2006). "The Kremlin's Killing Ways". i3g it would not matter if China lost 300 million people in a nuclear war: the
other half of the population would survive to ensure victory". =
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��e�#� C �;�_ µ_ ��� P=� EA<_ ` ¿a�2�� Ù\y�� 2#j�� �� !3 2"s ,��2pAV� ��Q8� �_ µ_ �����=� �; C ��2pAV� >��R �� PH%H ��
P��K)� P j��J ��#� +s E,��2�� � �2,�"P#31k� P3�j�*" Gang of
Four �A=�� ��V� G/ �I! ghi*
��AV� !�"��� P��6y�� >��3�� §�q C .�?�= §�s � �;/ ��" �� ����� �;�_ µ_ ��� 43 P���)I P���� -«��23� ��BP�� �� �;�V/� Y�s�<�� �6©�s ,
E,Ad� � �2pA F� G�e ��� �a�� �8�<_ P:s P���)I ��1 E,e� FB ];�eg�i*
��"� �1�Ks �1�y��1 Richard Weikart :" �/ P ��1�2�� ]p:; 2"�8M�� ��%���_ �N/1 §%ak� G�5� SAR C ,P#� $�Nk� ��s�� ,S"� ��
E(��©� �y3/ G�3 ,E,#� G��#_ ��� E,<�;/ «� R� ,���8_/� �A�& Y6A#��;�e ,PV�#��>1�Ky� PR%a/ PAUs P"")�3 ]"g i*
��1� ��)�� [�Aa 2"s P���R Pe�#� P�/ C .�8�� Q ©� ��� G/ >�Ks m� C G�K� ��2pA6A� 7�� 2#� `� ,P6(�R >�Ks Y? E6<F� ��)��s ,.��)�� `�#�
E?^� E6<F� G/ !8R ��2pAV� * «�5 � .��V� ��)�� �� �R��V� ��s�� �? �L?�7 #V�� P6"��*
= Jasper Becker (2002). The Chinese. Oxford UP. p. 271
i1g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gang_of_Four. i2g Michael Lynch. Mao (Routledge Historical Biographies). Routledge,
2004. p. 230. i3g Richard Weikart, from Darwin to Hitler, p.215.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A a‰bÐîu@áà�Ží@…b§⁄a@ @
g�1��= Ì_ Che Guevara 1928-1967i 2pA� ,�1��= 's��� �/ , ��3�j� J��� 2(�R ,Y � =1/guerrilla leader �8{/ , �_1�{� �6N�
P8#y�� Ps�"d�� C ��6�A� PV�� >1�u* ,�ZN�e �2s �� P3�K�� >1�d�� C ��#��� m1�23 PN�Nk� �_�,u ];ZR�
3� b�2��� §�s !Ky_ �� ���~<� G�e >1�d�� 9�:; 2#firing squads E�2"�� b�W A�*
�<��� P�+N/��� C �6K� `�#�� �� � S8N G/ �1��= }��� PK���k� PNP���}��� �%�K��� E�2_ Y��� –P�1+#�N��− ,`�#�� }� P#6"�� P6W;k��
r�O !=/ ��� P�/ �� J�8y�� T�N�/ C 1�,WA� �1��= >1�{ ��#_ �� ��8���`�#��3 G�K� ./ C PK���k� P���}��� 2c >�?�W�*
8K�� ������� �Hk� P3�K�� >1�d�� 9�: � G�e 2R� ���ps �1��= �� ^ lI ��� EH ,� �#�1O �%ys !ys � K� �w;�K�� lI S?Ls ¦1�� lI >1�d�� ��2j_
�� � ��A� !y��� � �U�/ G�e� ����3, ��� �A� �8"��3 P���8�� ���"�� ]��R� ÆH���2�I Eghi *
�1��:3 P"jA�� P�j�� ];�e �_�� PAq ��#� +31� ,>�<"��� [ #�� Y? �3�8u �AM� C �1��= ��q 2"s ,����H� >2�2y�� ��?��e lI �_�<R S8N
i1g http://www. Theguardian .com/ books/2000/ aug/ 12/cuba
.artsandhumanities.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
� �"��� � #3 2{1� P3� ©� �K���/ >1�R '6� C P�1�\8�� ��=�123 �2� $|8�� ����Hk� �� � �";�� �+R�; ��#s ,E=� V� �+�� G��%��� � � ��#� .L��
4�+N/����* C �3 �Z#� �1��= �N1�� .L�� ÍM8�� 1�{ 2�/� �_��eL� ��"s �<� 3
4�%��� 2�/ G/ [y�e� ,����6�V� ��"� G�e 4�� P3�K�� >1�d�� �� H/ C �;/ 9%��� �� �8"��3 �1��= b�"s ,� � ���� .L�� G�KV�3 ª�K�� Í©� }a/ 2R
�^� �6��I 7�2� G�e�Eutimio GuerraEA�� , �? b�2��� G/ 9%��� � �#�º !�"�� �1��= �� SAMs m^j�"end his life quickly" !#���3�
��"� S�e� ,9%��� $/1 C P�1� �� P"AM�� ¦�a/ EH b��Ô� �1��= 5�R :" 2"� 1�� $2<� �� P"AM3 PAKyV� ]�/ � �� �� �6�k� S;�©� C ¿A� ���
Y�2j�� ±��� �� P"AM�� ]=�a�"ghi* ���R �� 43 ��� ��f�� b�2��� §�s !Ky�3 �1��= �,�u� 2R� :" b�2���
�Ú Q� Â�{���3 ���1.�3 SAM� +;I� ª�K�� S#yA� >1"g�i*
i1g I ended the problem giving him a shot with a .32 pistol in the right side
of the brain, with exit orifice in the right temporal [lobe]. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eutimio_Guerra Anderson, Jon Lee (1997). Che Guevara: A Revolutionary Life. New
York: Grove Press, p.273. i2g "The executions by firing squads are not only a necessity for the people of
Cuba, but also an imposition of the people". =
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
ª�K�� S#y�� �� ��~V� �1��= b2�/ 2R�! ��W;�� �s�e�� �3�e�= ��{� 2"s >�<"�� mL&Jacobo Machover [�|�
"7� V� C Pc1�#�" E��� � .L�� �%©� �;�3 ,(ruthless executioner) ghi* Q�1�����s �2;��1/ E, �� 43�K�� �� ^de }����Armando
Valladares −ª�K�� YR�")� vu� ��� ���y��− Ô��� !=1 �? �1��= G/ , �P?��e" full of hatred a man" �,s�� b2�/ .L�� !=��� G�� ���# P6e�²without trial who executed dozens)i g�i*
^;��;�� �_}�/ $��1�e ª�K�� S_�K��� S��k� 1�"��Carlos
Alberto Montaner ^8<3�1 PA"� rA�6� �1��= G/"a Robespierre
mentality" PAUs �8j_ >�<"�� ��g i*
= Anderson, Jon Lee (1997). Che Guevara: A Revolutionary Life. New
York: Grove Press, p.375. i1g Behind Che Guevara's mask, the cold executioner
Times Online, September 16, 2007. i2g The Legacy of Che Guevara – a PBS online forum with author Jon Lee
Anderson, November 20, 1997. i3g http://www. freedomcollection .org/interviews /carlos _alberto_ montaner
/?vidid=343.
Short interview on Che Guevara with Carlos Alberto Montaner for the
Freedom Collection
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��� !3 �N�� $��1�s �1���/Álvaro Vargas Llosa − vu� ��P=1�� P _%�� �K���/ G�~u C S_�K���− 2#3k G���2¨ �1��= «�8_/ G/
P � >1�MN�3 G�"A#�� E,s 2�"delude themselves by clinging
to a myth" * s �� � �"8M�1�3 -b23 !�"_ P�o �� �de/ �1��= �K� `
"cold-blooded killing machine"g1i . = S"AF��P3�K��� P3�K�� ���k� �� ^de C �1��− EN´3 PK���k�" 1�5=
�;�3�e �" the butcher of La Cabaña * «����� Py���� P��K<#�� P�5 �� 1��6�N� C � ���8� ��88N �1��= G�e� C �,d3 Y��� ��6��� P��� S8<3 >2�2� ��� <� P _%�� �K���/ C ¿a�2��
_%�� J�#y��P! '8N �� !e �� E���� ��� ,r�O !e �� E���� ��� ! �1��= 1�{ !W�N
rA_ !W�N� ,��"jAV�� ��#8"��� ��_^u Y��� �� �� �� � �� �� �8MF_>�R �� ®�/ �� !K3 �¥1�� Y��� P�+N/��� ��e�A� �31 12j� 1�j��*
.��2�� �1��:3 ��;Z"� $|8�� ���´3 EA0 .L�� .1�d�� �1��= !WN� C �Ma/ �? �+��� ,���"��� E#M� ����Hk� !�"� � K� 2��� �1��= �,s ,9��<�� !Us/ P���#V� v8U� ��2��s ,��2�� �� m2#3 S8<3� ,m��)I S8<3 rA_ �����#�
��)�� �� 7�� � H� ��2�� �L? G�e ����, 1}_ � P��w�� G/ 1�"� ��� .�s
i1g http://www.independent.org/newsroom/article.asp?id=1535.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�1��= P��1 �K� ,^"��� b�#q� 2���� !)� �? Q� .�d�� !�R G/� ,PAN��� 9%{�� x�w3 �:� _ P_�R�� PA8 R � � ]A#= >z�"�� P��5�a�� P���)��
�de/ 2<�F�s! GI EH ��� �1��=G�<;�� ��� y� P6"� �I � #� � .��j�R� �(�e� ,�? �L
�p�� .L�� 2���� ¦O�<�� 1�j��� [NÔ� � K� ,P=1� ÐR/ lI ��5�a� 1�j_���� .��V� ��)��!
,��#3k� >�2#�� >�?�@ G�<;��s ,G�<;�� S���<� �� ��)��s� 2R ^"��� �1��= �, � ���� Y��� Pj\y�� ����� G�K_ 2R� ,m� � �� ��/ �����e G�K_
–A� � ���� G�e 4� j� �<(1� P�� Q�; C P�+A� � ����� ª�K�� .5e�V� r 8A�]R���− �0 m2�� 58�3 QAs ,�¥ �"�1 2<� G/ ��1/ Y��� P6"A�� �� ��/
G�<;��ghi* [N� �K�= ]Aa�/ Y��� P���)�� P����� Y? mL?Aa�/� �1��] ����
��� �� P��� C 4V�)� 4<;������ J�8y�� �� �Ad��1�8�� !�"��� �, '"p���?�M\3 �_�� �ao C �<�; �? �Z�� P���#�, >1�H �� ��3�� 2#3 �P{�a
�w;�K��* !�"�� J�<� �� �"��� �� �Ì3 !8"� �w;�K�� S#u G/ �� 48_ 2"s �� A#�� � �31�? �1��= ¦�a� ,E?�%3 C �A#y� G/ �1��= 2��� G�e .L�� �1�8��
�� ���=1 �� P�N 2"s G/ 2#3 �w;�K�� >1�H !ysh� �Z�� 2R� ,43�K��
i1g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agrarian_Reform_Laws_of_Cuba.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
G/ �P��z :">1�d�� !ys/ S#y��"ghi* �� G/ �� 48_ 2"s� � ��:��� .�d�� �� ��j� 2R m�"s P6R C ^"�*
u �M#�� .�d�� �#� �,s [_�K�� Y��� PWpA�� �W� � ^"������~ �� �"� ���_�p3 .�d�� Ø������ ��;�<;´3 Ø������!*
�>�e P��M��� PR2j�� �� !#= ��2e b%N��� «�8uI !#=� ,Pc�����N1 ��R ,G+��� ��{/ �� !{/ 1�©� �� �–EAN� �A� �� �{ − :Û h ��i ��
%5 ,@�� ��� %3�j k6 Ta�j l�j� ���34 S�5 ��Üg�i* �a�� ��2)� C ��R� :Û%3�j k6 Ta�j l�j� T3m� ;`1� ��nB� o*1Ü *
�� J��e C ->1�N ��/ GI !3−>�"8�� >1�N− P#3���V� �c��V� ���� �¥ 4e�<V� x��RI� ���"��� b�#qI� �� !8N C P"� �� !Us �� t2p�_ Y���
��M#��� �L8�� �� $� �� ��� * l�#_ �� ��R: ���LK���J��I��H��G��F���E��D��C��B��A
�� WV� �U��T���S��R��Q��P��O�� � �N��M��Y��X��f��e�� � dc��b��a���`��_^��]��\�� � � �[��Z
i1g" we can't liberate by ourselves a country that does not want to fight".
"This is the history of a failure". http://www.theguardian.com/books/2000/aug/12/cuba.artsandhumaniti
es. i�g ��8�� ���V� J�k� �p{*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��t� � sr��q��p��o� �n�� �m��l��k� � � �i� �h��g��c��b��a���`_��~��}����|��{��z��yx���w�����v��u��n� �m��l��k��j� � �i��h� �g� � � � �f��e��d��w�� � � �v��u��t� �s� �r�� �q� � �p� �o��£� � ¢¡� ����~��}� � �|� �{��z��y� �x
�ª��©� �¨� �§�� �¦��¥� �¤���°�� � �¯�� �®��¬��«��½��¼��»��º���¹��¸���¶��µ��´��³��²��±
¾�ghi* �,8���<� G/ �1��= ��� ` Y��� P���#V� Y? mL?; �1�qI !6B ��k� �Ò��_� �
����j_� ��q�#_� ,� ��2R�#_ �� ,2pA6A� P"?�� P"�5s��� ����{ �,Ae mL?� ,V� 9��K�� �� A#� � �#�º �?��:�s 2c� ¸�1k� n%� 2c� ����Hk� 2c �A<
���V� J�p{/ 4�%���* P)�{ P; !e '?5F�� PAUs !e ��)�� E6<F� �LK?�!
��=�A� .��)�� 1�j��� P8e��V P;�<;�� P#8M�� ^w_ P���² GI– ��wj3P��y��−��~� � � 7;�� .L�� G� ©� lI ��/ , C �K� ,�8�� �� 4�%V�
` Y��� m��#3�3 G�<;�� ��;�� ¶�1���� PA35� lI Y��y�� ��)�� S?O P��, �� �� P6"��� ,>��V� �� 9���� ���;�� ,Y��y�� ��)�� �,8e��� G/ �M�<�
Í#�� P6"�, ,P:��� P���)�� P���V� P6�)� �� P������ P��)�� P���K���
ihg P��� ,>�"8�� >1�N :g�ÃÄ− �ÃÅi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
3 ¦�a� PAq `�#�� C Y��y�� ��)�� ���R Y��� P��2�� Q(1 �<�A� Q�1� �;�� ��/ C ¦�a G��5�� �� � ���� 4;+HhÇÇh >^,y�� ��6Ae ��"� :" �K_ `
�L? C 1 Æ2"�� � Æ#s�� � s Y��y�� ��)�� P3�� 1�"_ 2"s °)� >2#N �;�%3"��s/ C �� -2A3 1��a� �� ��28s ,m���� � s P3�:��� mL? ���=I C ���� ,�L& �
�� ��2#3 � 3 ]#s� 2"s ,>�K��� mL& G�K� � �;/ � �8H/ P��, �� C � ;/ ^� ,�p; C 4#31/ G/ P""� �<K#_ �� �?� ,>»p�V� `�#�� ��� ��:,�;� .L�� '��M��
OI P6(�� �P�L� G�;�#�� !3 ,�"��� va ]B G�y#� S#y�� �� P(�V� G�"A�� � P��N !e C n�eL_ P6(�� P�L� ��I ,���6��� ��R�M3 E?��3I 2#3 �I �A<��
P��2�� mL? C 28� r;�3"ghi. � 7(+�� 7p�^ TU� /��1� c %!�fq��5 _0�*m1� $�<\� r�� (�1!
���KV� >2�%V� PR�= �#� ]M"N�–���8V� − ,`�#�� ��� P"3 C �3,�8? ]M"N� E F� ��A@ Y��� E,���/ 1�R�� Ý#" ,G��5�� �� !��e -G�R PAq �& G�2
EA<�� ��/ �� �,�=��2� �6 FN� ,P��y��3 �K_ ];�e Y��� ��2�� ]M"N� J�5�k� ]p8{/� ,P��� >�� �U3 �� Y�s�<�� ��B�� rK�_� ,!(�? �.��
#V� ���<� 4<B ����� �I P��y�� �� !6B � Pe�Zu�� ���<� �s1� PyG�<;�� >�?�@ !AB C ��)�� !ys �� �6©� '�_�� ,Ypj�� 4������ E�2�� *
Z��+ ;`1� (+��1� (�31� �s _tu�1� �a�?1� v0 _�*�<� ��R�\� >����$��5�� $(��� ��R�\� %�@9�4 v0 [1��� �� ��V*j!P
i1g th Congress of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A ´àÜ�½a@áà�Ží@…b§⁄a@ @
� ±\u �� � ���� n� ? G�e §�O/ b� P6A<� ��R ��3/� �%���� 46A<V��,6Ae�3 ,G�"A8�� P"M � C C �c��� `�#�� ��M3 46A<V� ��8e/ §��/�
�V� G�"�� �� �� #<��� ,P N�8�� !?/ ��"� J�O/� 4pAjV� !e § �1/� ,¸�_�� C P��� !< ��� t�)� n%?I� x���k� r�? �� !#=�*
9��<�� �;I Q(1Í�s�N�A� G���3�AN '3�<�� �s%N����� �3z Slobodan Milošević *
�Í�s�N�A� G���3�AN � �2pA� G�e �6N1� ,�s�Z��3 � r�O S8<3 »0 `� s� EN��� ��� !=1 ./! ghi*
Í�s�N�A� E F�� 2R� �6N1 P�+©� >��3�� P6��=� P;�<;�� 2c E(��:3 �46A<6A�g�i*
];�e� P��2� QN���� 2��� G�e �;/ �� ± _ Í�s�N�A� b��� Pp(�Y?� P��R : �}K�� �3z'Greater Serbia' �r�O !=/ �� ��1/ !e >��3I
G�"A8�� P"M � C §���k�� �� Hk�� ��ARk�*
i1g There were no clergy at the ceremony because Milosevic was an
avowed atheist* http://www.cbc.ca/news/world/milosevic-buried-in-quiet-ceremony-in-his-
hometown-1.571728* CBC. 18 March 2006. i2g http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/1672414.stm*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
C Pj"�� P��23 ];�e 2R� �� #<_ 4� ¸�V� G�"�� C Í�s�N�A� /23� !?/ 43 P��<��� ��;��)�� rN�&�� P N�8�–>^"� P���)I >�W; − ��"s :
" � ��U� �;�j� !#= 4� G������ 1�q�}�I ��:��K3 ��eL� P N�8�� �%"�N��y�� QA� C"ghi.
Í�s�N�A� �A�/� �83 b�"N �;/ Ppc�� >1�j3 !8©� C !R%"�� P{�s 2· 7�� rN�&�� P N�8�� C� ��Nk�3z P��R� �%u/ �� �}K�� �
G�"A8�� P"M � C 46A<V�* a 2"s !#���3� ���?�WV� ]=� !6B G�K� !e C�1�#u� : G�8�� ��V�
�3z ]u��� gAlbanians Long live Serbia—death toi g�i* �P��"�� >�K��� –�}K�� �3z− G/ Í�s�N�A� G���3�AN 2��� Y���
�8#u C �,d8� >�Ks Y? ��" ��� !Usk� Q ©� �� b�"_ Y,s �?���² C P���)I� !(�8"��� E�k� 43 G��#��� �� ��;��2�� b��R + 3 ,YR�#��������g� �f� �e
��w��vu��t��s��r����q�� po��n��m���l��k��j��i��h
i1ghttp://content.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,983190-2,00.html.
"Bosnia and Herzegovina was illegally proclaimed as an independent
state and recognized. That recognition was like when the Roman.
Emperor Caligula appointed his horse as a Senator". i2g Ramet, Sabrina P. (2006). The Three Yugoslavias: State-Building and
Legitimation, 1918–2005. p. 351.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
z��y���x �ghi* G�<;�� C P_�L�� 1��k� GI EH–P&�� P"A�− Ppj��� G�A�� !d�
�&%a �8�� [ j�3 ��)�� b�"� Y��� 1��k� mL? ,m^�� §�Á#��� Q ©���M�I� E,( P:p3 E,A� ��U"�� r{ �/ >��"�V� P"A)� r{ �/ >�)� r{
b%N�� 2e|� P_�L�� 1��k� mL? ,�A{Ô� ��"8��� Y#8M�� J�\�;��− ��2�� �/� ���6� − P��\<�� 7�� ��= b2#3 �28�� L � ��� 3 >��3�� �� �%Us �,A� �
�ao G�� Q © PR�#�� P" ���� ^�2��������Á��À��� �¿���¾����½��¼��»��º��Ô��Ó��Ò��Ñ��ÐÏ�����Î���Í��Ì��Ë��Ê��É����È��Ç��Æ��Å��Ä��Ã��Âã��â��á��à��ß��Þ��ÝÜ��Û��Ú���Ù��Ø��×Ö��Õ�g�i*
�� ��N1 ��R� − EAN� �A� �� �{ − :Ûp� w��1� �x� �� ,(+�� ,?5 �6 p� ,h�0 v0 _uA�1 p� ,_uA0 v0 h��1 yz# p p� ,(+�� ,9�5� �6�
;���1�5 p6 �{� v0 $��� p� ,$��� v0 �{�Üg i* ��R�−EAN� �A� �� �{− :Û |)�V |� Qz1� }�~5� , �� |>�W! � ��^��W! ���#,?�a�V� Wz5ÜgÅi*
QN|� .L�� ��2��� Y���=�� .��)�� �� ,K�� 43 §���� �6K� � ?�
ghi ����� �� � : ��������* g�i ����� �� � : ��������* g i ��� ,�� !� ��"# �$%� &�'�(!� �)*)��+,--�* gÅi ��� ,�� !� ��"# �$%� &�'�(!� �)*)��,,��*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�8�� 43 P��� PAU��* G/ 2e|;� �s�N�A� lI ��#; P��K)� C �s�N�A� [A�
Ps%N����� P"3�<�� Í�s�� Í�s�<�1�3Borisav Jović G/ }a/ �A#s Í�s�N�A�3 S��M� G�e �× :" �R�� P"; �3z�" *
Republic Ethnically-pureg1i .
!(��/ ��� `�#�� }� 46A<V� G�23/ �& ��#yR� Y��� 1�:V� P��23 ];�Ks ��= �� 1�:V� mL? Ch� !��3/hÇÇ 4� PN12� J��� G���:V� !���
��A�R� �y� 3º C P(�2�3��,Aa�� É� EA<� !�qg�i* � ����)I >��3I 43 §�s � � Z3 ��"� ,��� a >^W� >��3I 43� ���q/ PN12��: N Peter Singer G��< ��3 P#��:3 O��NFk�Princeton university " � ��1�� ��/ ]<� �c1 >����5 a �/ .5;+8u >�� �� �*" g i*
Y? ]R��� r�O C P��8�� � �5? Y��� >15:V� �K� �y� 3º >15� �}K��Srebrenica massacre Í���%� �K_�1 b�:V� 2pAV� �¥ b�R Y���Ratko
Mladić
i1g LeBor, Adam (2004). Milosevic: A Biography. p.138* i2g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Srebrenica_Children_Massacre* http://www.icty.org/x/cases/oric/trans/en/050713ED.htm* i3ghttp://www.lifesitenews.com/news/princeton-professor-singer-and-i-
repeat-i-would-kill-disabled-infants*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
� 7(J@� ��9 d��$C*� �?!��ghiP b�R� ,Í�s�N�A� G���3�AN 2pAV� Í= C ���� = G�e�9��<�� �L?
!�"3¼ÄÄÄ C �y� 3º P �2� v² C Y N�3 EA<�h b�� �� ����hÇǽ �3��� PR�#�� P�j��� �2¥P�+©� >�g�i*
>2�%V� 4��:V� �� P �� PU8R C �5#�� G�6A<V� G�e 2"�* b�� �y� 3º P �2� ��a23 Í���%� �K_�1 b�:V� 2pAV� b�Rh ����
hÇǽ E,Aa�/� ,�� 7�� E,���#_ EH �y� 3º �� ���qk�� ��=��� ���1� �� E,s !6#F� /23� «1�5V�� �%w�� G�¨ C ���y���� ,4e�K<��3 �3L���
P��2�� !3� "��3 �L"���* �;/ 4=� �� 2�/ ��"� � ��{�{1 2#3� �%w�� G�¨ 2�/ lI m���R� 2#3
m�%� �p;� m�p; ]"AM;� �& �� �d©� ]B �?� 2�2u ��23 �#u �>�:s �Ô� Y���� G�K� !e �� �3 ]q��/ Y��� ���2�� �? ��2�� 12j� G�e�
�15V� Í���%� �K_�1 �� = /23 �3L��� !�"�� [R�_ G/ 2#3� ,>1�5w3 P ���dp3 �d©� G�jp��� 7�� ]� �;�3 �?�W�� �? !@� ,>�� �s ±\u ��
��31�? �s� n�8y�� �� 5�R �� ����� b��� 9�8{g i* � �U�/ �eL� �ao -¦�; �5:�² G�e �;/� C �� ��y�� �2�I C ���#�� ��
i1g http://biography.yourdictionary.com/ratko-mladic. i2g http://www.potocarimc.ba/_ba/liste/nestali_a.php* i3g http://www.icty.org/#IIA6.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
-G�K� a� 'cE,A�"� ÍM#�� ��e� ';�, EH ,��V� 1�W�;�3 E&�3 G�3�� ��(23�G�K� �� �K�� P ��y�� �� �R�s1 �� P#31/� �?� 5�"� G/ �Ks* ��5�R !#���3�
C �d©� �� b��e/ �� E,<�;/ ��2=�� «�©�� ÍM#�� >2u� `k� >2u �� ���W� � G�AA<�� ��A@� � ��:s ]R��� G�e� ��3�w�� �2�I SAR 1�; ��"Aq
)� ��2=� OI r�Le E? + 3� ,�� V� >2#3 >�: �� �/ P~=���1�� �?»�/ Y��� �� �R�V� C Í���%� �K_�1 ��2=�� ��,@ 2R E?1�8R ��) Í���%� �K_�1
-PW) C� ,�<� 3 ��A6#�� »0 1�sPR � �2#3 ��3�?� �� ©� ��As��ghi * �¥ b�R Y��� �y� 3º >15� ]� F{ P6��= }e�e Í���%� �K_�1 2pAV�
P;�d�� PV�#�� J�)� L � SK_�F_ P��� >��3Ig�i* b�� C��ļ E�� b�#�� 4�k� ��R Pp3LV� mL& >��#�� ��eL�� C ./
�6©� G�e 2"s ,23k� lI >2p�V� E�k� �1�M_ !W�N �y� 3º >15� G/ >2p�V� .2j��� C G��"�4��:6A�g i*
P:� �� ];�Ks ,�2)/ 4j\y� P_�O >^N �� P�%qI� PpV ];�e mL?A� PR�#�� P�j���� !< ��� t�)� n%?IEÀ2�/ ]B ��#R� ��L�� 46A<6*
�;/ 4� m|M� � .L�� �R����s!d� ��pAMj� �,W_ `" ,YR�#�� ^,M��� !�"�� ��"�� ,^3��M�� !�R� ,E=+©� b��e/�the Killing Fields �I
i1ghttp://www.icty.org/x/cases/krstic/acjug/en/krs-aj040419e.pdf. i2g www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2005/sgsm9993.doc.htm* i3ghttp://www.un.org/press/en/2005/sgsm9993.doc.htm*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��2pA� �,6K� Y��� ��2�� !a�� !K��w� �v��u��t� � �s��r��q
_��~��}���|��{z��y��xLMNO* : وختاما
b�:V� rA? Í�s�N�A� G���3�AN C �A"�#� Chh $1���ÄÄÉ P��3 G�"A8�� 1�5= b�:V� 2pAV� rA? ,m1�p�;� �#8�� �=��� P8AR"Butcher of
the Balkans" .�?� C �A#�� P(� ©� P6KpV� ¸�R �6<� G�e +eg�i* [�� PA:V � �"8q �� j_ E_ .L�� b�:V� 2pAV� rA?Life magazine
C�ÄhÄ `�#�� C 4�1�_��K�2�� /�N/ �� 2���e "The World's Worst Dictators"g3i .
b�� C P��2�� P(� ©� P6KpV� G/ ��K8V� ��KpUV� ����ÄÄà – ./ -b�#3 Í�s�N�A� n%? 2#3 2���− §�"� S?L��� ,Í�s�N�A� G2F_ `
P���=�� ��3�j�� 2pAV� Í�s�N�A� E,A�R ��L�� 46A<V� �� ���� ��~�9����� ¦�1�/ P��"��*
L? ¿<N �%<��s P3��� ���"�� 2(�R �s �Z�� .L�� ]R��� C �Vojislav Šešelj EA#3 ];�e J��� �,8K_1� Y��� E(��©� �� G/
ghi >�"8�� >1�N : P���gɼi* i2ghttp://www.theguardian.com/world/2001/jul/01/warcrimes.balkans* i3g"Power Through Hatred: Slobodan Milosevic". LIFE. 5 December 2010.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
s�N�A� ����� ��8V� �6�23� �,=��3� � ���K<�� ��ghi* G/ [e `�#�� 7< � ��� ,46A<V� 'p3 >2�%V� 1�� b��k� �p� ��
2��� 2pA�`�#�� �s2� Y�K� � �}R ��0 G/ �;�K�´3* �� ,P3�#�� �;�%3 C ��)��� ��2pAV� �� 1Lp; �p; '8N �� !=/ ��
G/ P ���z �, A#; '8N �� !=/ : Í�s�N�A� >�y; >1L3 Y? 2pA� >�y; >1L32�2= Í_�%� �e��1� 2�2= !
C �� 9��� 7�� P;������ P��"��3 .�V� 2pAV� .�� N� P"�� PA��� E,�s�u ��j~�N�� 46A<V� �� sI*
¦�¯� ��"�k� ^d� 7�� Pw���k� P��"��3 .�(�5©� 2pAV� .�� N��%8�� rAÀ� �(�wU��!
i1g”Milošević organized everything. We gathered the volunteers and he
gaves us a special barracks, Bubanj Potok, all our uniforms, arms,
military technology and buses. All our units were always under the
command of the Krajina [Serb army] or [Bosnian] Republika Srpska
Army or the JNA. Of course I don't believe he signed anything, these
were verbal orders. None of our talks was taped and I never took a
paper and pencil when I talked with him. His key people were the
commanders. Nothing could happen on the Serbian side without
Milošević's order or his knowledge”. LeBor, Adam (2004). Milosevic: A Biography. p.191*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
¦L<��� 48wV�� 1���k� �� ��2�/ �;2 �� ,G�K� !e C ����R �,W�N� >�Ks P�/ E\U��� 2y� ./ �!V � ���� Y�K_ �� 4Aq�#��� ���� P�/ P#3��V�
EÀ�w� 1�wj�� J�8y��� ,>O�u �/ P3�?1I �/ >^"� ���2�� mL? ];�e +,�'< �� �� ¦1��3 G�6�À� S��w�� G��"A��� O�y�� *
J�� Y,s ,x1k� �=� �� P6��= �,R��_ � P6��= Y? ��)�� ��������3� ,7 #� �� Q� Y8<; ��/ �& � �"8q §%ak� Gk §%ak� -�� !Ks �� 5(�=*
Q ©�� PR�#�� P" ��� ���23 �6�:V� G�e1/ x�"�N ��)�� ����� ��"8��� Y#8M�� J�\�;�� �� �S� �8jN r�O �K �<� .L��� ,!Usk�
�A{�* mL? 43 ������� .Lw_� ����R lI �6�:V� rK��N ��)�� �����
P��)�� P����� !{/ �? «����s ,����"�� �?� ,�� (�K�� 1�,W�� ��=�A� ��/ b2�� 1�p3 m2 � G�K�N >�W �� mL¥ �8A� �W � .L��� ,Pe�� !K� T�
m2s��1 >��� S· YÀ23* 43�\V�� 4��:V�� O��y�� !e P���"� �� l�/ ��)�� P���"6s �L�� .L��s ,��)�� �� �"�/ �� �8a/ �� EW�/ P6��= 2=�_ %s ,§�M�� «�MR�
�� !e m2 � rK��� m��=� �K �� ��3 ��K�! åí†zܽa@pbä�y@‰bv:ÐÛa@Šöbj×@æhÏ@ÞbÔŽí@bà×ë@L��@Ý×@ê†í@óÜÇ@áà�níëAAA
:المقصود مما سبق أن
,�� !e E6<F� ��)�� �K� `� ,��2�� �%@ C �I � a `�#�� C �K� `�
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�2�� �� 2#8��� P H���� ��)�� �%@ C �I J��a �s� * b%N�� ¶u ��"��� �Ò1 P6_ �3� :Û !e GI� >�8; �H/ �/ ->�8 3 �I P6(�R PKA¤ x1k� C Q� �;I
���8 �� 1�Ho �6s x1k� C - aÜghi*
��"�� !(�N ��<� 2R �K� :" EAs >2�2y�� PÝ6 F<�� mL¥ ��)�� G�e �OI ��pc���� �c�_ Q�/ ,� � ��Lp��� lI P=�)�?�,6,8 F�"
��)�� «�8_/ G/ PAKyV� −� � ��~u G�s�#� � E,8A�/� − �� G�=��� ��1�{ ��^wj�� ������ 43� G� Nk� ��H2� 1�wj�� J�8y�� 43 -Ps�dK3 �3 G��8��
���1 �� ��)�� �Ma -«�1 !e Y#�� J�8y�� ��M��� 7�� ��Lp��� S=�s! :التبشري باإلحلاد
®� ,K�� ^y8���s �2©� ��2pAV� P6N 1�{ ��)��3! �+©�� ^�� ')� C $� �� ��K �Ku� ,�� W3 -��#MR ��M"N�s!
G/ ���� G�<;�� Y 8� ���M�V� .1���k� !:<��� b�#�� Ye�1��� ��2#�NP(1�q >�?�@ ��)�� G/ G�2e|� Go C P�R�� !
.^y8��� �#3�M3 .��)�� ��=�A� ��y� �� �� 2 � b��� m2,y; .L���_���* s ��)�� �A#s � Æ? !60 �8{/ +��2��3 ^y8��� EDogma ��2=� ,>2�2©�
��� P���2�� ��1��5��3 �¿� 2�2©� ��)�� >���P�^y8 G�K� !e C ��� ,
ghi ��A<V� b1�j��h−�½É*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�(+�� _V�� ��(1� $�<\�!* Þ[\�� ��� ��)�� G/ P��"��V� 1�"� +e P#R�� P""� ]p8{/ ; 2pA
G�AN 2��� .1�M���David Sloan �� � �"8q ��)��s: " �+N !e rA6� ,.��"���� ���W; ±\yF_ Y��� J�M"�N�� P��� r�O C +3 ,Y�\�V� ��2��
lI Ps�c��3 2" �� �� P��#�V� �_��R PMAN"ghi* >1�A83 ��w�u�� lI v"s EA#��3 ��w�u�� ��:�_ P��N1 ��2� ��)��s P��1
�¥ G�<;�� PR%�� >�)� m�� * >2�2y�� ���6 FN G�3� � � ��Lp��� S=� r�O !=/ ���!
�1�y��1 2pAV� �3 b�"� �� ��)��3 ®� ,K�� ^y8��� �� Y#R�� ��d6e� 5 e���Richard Dawkins P���)I P(��� �%Ò �� �8= �� '� � .L��
PAÒ ��~<� �?� ,>^de" ��)�� Â�3Atheist Bus Campaign" G2 � C��)Ö� P���� ��{�8�� �� � � ��g�i *
�� 2�5� �� rA_ ��AÒ C 5 e��� �1�y��1 '�;/ 2R�h½ � = [�/ �� ��)Ö� ��2_ ���s� �; !=/ �� Y �ZN�¼ÄÄ ��p;/ J�� Q3�_/
i1g Sloan, D. (2012) Atheism as a Stealth Religion; Hoff-post, Posted
12/14/07.
g J��e �� $�8�R��� ,G+���� EA#��� ��)�� C !(�N1 t%H *.�,y�� 2#N �3 �� 28�i i2g https://www.justgiving.com/atheistbus¬.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�;�M��3ghi * 2��<��� �N�1� �K���/ �� -!e lI ��)��3 ^y8��� ��2� ]A"�;� 2R�
�2 A s� �;�V/�* ��)��3 ^y8��� S:� E_�– ��1��N�� − !��}��� �N�1 �� -!e C
���ZN��g�i * � E? �8{/ 2"� �2= � �:�5� � ���/ ��)��3 ^y8��¥ E�,� !K� �[AV� �L*
���? �;/ �� !Ke ��=�A�� `�#A� �W � 2pAV� G�e �OI� ! �L? !e �O+As ?»� �� �� � � -�Ì3 ^y8���� b+�?��
�P��z r�L3 5 e��� �1�y��1 �Z#�� �3��e C"���� E?�" ��"s :"� � Y(%� �#3 �2= Y(�2� ];/ �O�V ,��yR ?���? �6©� Q�/ ?�"g i*
�2©� ��2pAV� �¥ ��6�� Y��� Ps�M�V� P�^y8��� P���)�� 9���� mL?� S�e ����_ S��{� ^,y�� 2pAV� ]#s� 5 e��� �1�y��1 ±ak�3�
$�1 !K��� PV�#�� ���1��Michael Ruse G�3 ��Z��� lI :" �1�y��1
i1g ibid,. i2g http://www.abc.net.au/news/2008-11-26/atheists-snubbed-in-ad-knock-
back/220036. i3g Colleagues come back at me. Why are you so hostile? Isn't it all just
harmless nonsense? P.281.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P""� PH1�e 5 e���"ghi* !e G/ E�5_ EH ��)��3 �8F_ G�s r<�; �R� _ ];�s ���? -��!
�ao -�c�� C $�1 !K��� ��"�� !3 :" �#u/ Y A#= ���� E?� J��e ,� �2pA� ��e �� !:�3− �� 7�� G�1�5� �2©� ��2pAV� P���� 5 e���
��2�� E,�� G/ ���0 − Î��� 9��3 1�2� l�k� P#��©� P <�� C S��Me �;I , -��� -��j3 :" �� 'Aa � Æ�?'�" �<As P��<� [y�e� �;�e�>^Ma P"g�i*
G/ ,���6,�� G/ G�2��� � E,<�;/ E? Y���� �2©� ��2pAV� PAKy� 1�j#�� P ,e J�AN/ �� � � de [A�¯ � ,.^y8��� .�5��N�� E¥�AN/
7MN���!* 2pAV� ��<A��� S�e �L�� ,J�ANk� �L? E, � �2©� >2�%V� t1� 2R�
=�3 G���= Y Julian Baggini PA� C �F; ���"�Fri Tanke P(�2� ��"� S�e 2"s Y �� �? �� !e �� 2�2y�� E?2"�� �2©� ��2pAV��� :" Pe��
i1g Richard Dawkins is absolute disaster, we are losing this battle, it is just
plain silly and grotesquely immoral to claim that Christianity is simply
a force for evil.
g] �� !;�� ��<A�A� $�1 !K��� P��N1 ��i i2g The god Delusion made me ashamed to be an atheist. Thus, like a first-
year undergraduate, he can happily go around asking loudly, "what
caused god?" as though he had made some momentous philosoohical
discovery Dawkins et al bring us into disrepute.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
>��2� 2�2©� ��)��"ghi* �"�� 2pAV� G/ �� E��s��3 G�2e|� �2©� ��2pAV� G/ Y =�3 G���= 1
��)Ö� PN��<R� P�R�N/ G�23 Í#� G/ �M�<� �! g�i* 1�{ P3�#�� ��\<; C 7�� 2�2©� ��)�� G/ 4� m|M F� � .L�� �R����s
E�_ P3�� P���)I S�e �6s ,�}e P�^y8_ P���� 4��U63 �%"d F� lI �,���_ C � �2,= G���� � P;��5�A_ ����"� lI ,J�_��� �� ��� R lI ,b�W�;�3 P3�#�� ,®� ,K�� E?��)� ���Z�� !3�"� C Pj\y�� E,��%<3 4pUF� �?1�U� �/ ����Z� J�_��� �� Y,� _ � b%s/� ��"(�H�� ���"s� ��"A� lI
:<_ lI ,�?���j�3 E? G���"� � ��p�{ lI ,�2= ��2pA� �� ����"� ! ,����k� Q(��; �,A=/ �� '� F_� 1+�k� �,s �U_ P_�8K #�� PK8y�� �� РFB
��)Ö� ��2� .^y8_ �� ,e �;I* �² b2� 2,©�� 2K�� �L? !e ��1� �� G/ J�#�N� G�K���3 2#� `�
Null* '� � G�e �, 3� G/ E?2�/ >2��� Y _}a/ 2R� �?�a�_ ��:V �,� # F�� PN��3
����/ �� �s S��� �� m��M�I C− P���2�� E,#�1�y� �� §��;�� !=/ ��−* ^<#�� �� P���� -PW�� -P,K;� -P�^y8_ -PwA3 � ��Z� 2�2©� ��)�� 1�{ 2"� �� G�� �� ��&I .��)�� E�� ,e �� ��A#:s ,�8AR �¥�F/ �V �, � >��#��
i1g http://fritanke.no/index.php?page=vis_nyhet&NyhetID=8484.
i�g '3�<�� 12jV�*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�Á���À��È��Ç��Æ��Å��Ä��������Ã��Â�ghi* P ,K�� ��|? ��N1+V P#8q -P:� e ��)�� �� ��Lp��� ®�� �L�!
_ÉIÓìnß@Šßc@æbߌÛa@Š�e@¿@…b§⁄a@‰b’nãa@Ýç@åØÛ@ @E#; ! G�A60 ��)�� P ,e� Æ?3 ^y8��� E��)�� �%p;��3 ��{��� C � �#6q
�� ,>^ak� ��M² lIN !#���3 ®��s ��"� � .L�� b��� : C +e ,�� ���pj�� ��2)�!*
N �� G��5�� �ao C �R��� ��sI ��)��s ,P�1�#V�� P6"�� 7 #� Y��\��6)� ¦1�� $� �� ¦1�,�� − �� �M\3 G��#y� %s «1��y�� C G�;5� ./
�Ma P6AK� 7 #63− ��2)� C +e*
A)� «2_ Y��� ����� �,W_ �����;�^� E*
G��5�� �ao ��s C �,Ae �����k��* EAN� �A� �� �{ �� ��N1 ��R :Û �Z�j ����1� ��i c ��� ��R3@�
]�a`1� ]�@^ ,��@^� yR�1� �� v+� ,G��R1� e@1� �� ��z1� $�@j w��@1, ,G�� ��1�� v0 �.�5� 2V@+ _3# ��a�� �0 �� ���~� h� yj� �0 �� Z���
#��f+ ,*@<� =(! F��Üg�i* EAN� �A� �� �{ �� ��N1 ��R �a�� ��2)� C� :Û 7���# Z�0��5 ��$�5
ihg P��� ,G�R���� >1�N :gŠi* i�g .1L 6A� ,S?Z��� S�Z�� �p{*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
,@qB� y*@1� Tt�9Üghi* �� E¥�"_� �� E,< _ P6A� ��c�s ����� mL? G�K_ G/ 2#8�N/ ��
`�#� �s !p6U_� !q�8��3 ')� �s Q8�A� ���� �R��� ,��)�� P#����Pp6<��!*
�L? b��/ ��)�� P�6 FN 1�,@I �� P8j F� �;��,= ];�e r�O !e !=/ ���3 1} F� ^w�� ^y8���!*
ihg EA<� �p{*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
الفصل الثاني اإلحلاد خيالف بديهيات املنطق وأوليات العقل وألف باء علم
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A قانون فيزيائي ينقض اإللحادقانون فيزيائي ينقض اإللحادقانون فيزيائي ينقض اإللحادقانون فيزيائي ينقض اإللحاد
-�� C >2�%V� �6M� �K� ` .��V� `�#�� P�/ ��8HI �� �de/ P�/ Gk , 2R `�#�� �(5= ��� E?1�B .��V� `�#�� P��23 ��8H� G�e �L�� ,�;�j�� b�5�I �� �
��R� �2= ¦�² �2= b��{� �A� �E, * ¦} ��� ���N 2pAV� Y(��5��� �Z#�Steven Weinberg ]3�d�� G�K�� P��W; 7 6�� G�e �;/ , �de/ ��k ,�k�
G���k� �3 ���; �× Ë6� 2#3/� ,P3O�=ghi * EA#�� v(�p3 ]�2M{� �� ��/ ]�2M{� ¦} ��� ���N �� �F/ �K�
��M�}�� Y(��5��� ��"� ,.��V� EA#�� !a�� G�K� �& 2#� `� ,�<�; Q �� ���uDennis Scaima " ���K� �"�<FV� G�K�� P��W; �� �s��F/ ` ,Ppp{
s P��k� ]6e��_ G/ 2#3 �K�� ,Ppp{ ���e C Y�8��� !3 P8#A�� G/ � � 48_ 2" ],�;� 2R"g�i*
�As ���;/ �Z#� r�L3� ,�%#s ],�;� 2R P8#A��sAntony Flew �%(�R ���#�� G�"�� C ��)�� ��<As :" �� G�<;�� 2�� ��Z��� GI G���"�
�;/� ,P<� �� P�� ��C�Z��3 ��F�N: �2= ¦�² �� G�K�� P��23 ¦O�6; GI� ��2pA6A� P8< ��3 ,P �2�� S�K�� �, � ]#s�� >�Ks ]8H/ EA#�� Gk r�O"g i*
ihg  ,n�1�_ !; ,`�� !a�� `����É*
i2g The Unity of the Universe, N.Y., Doubleday, Dennis William Sciama,
introduction. i3g Henry Margentau, Roy A. Vargesse. Cosmos, Bios, Theos. La Salle Il:
Open Court Publishing, 1992, 241.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
`�#�� P��3 ��"�� �p; � ���5; m2 � �1/� �I � �2pA� 1���/ ��e/ � �L�� .L�� ��)�� Q=�? � K� ,EA#�� b��j_ P��<� mL? G/ �� ,.��V� 2pAV� !#·
��=����2�/ !3�"� C EA#�� 4;��"� �K ��* ���p�� �I � e��? ���<� m����I� !_1�? Q6= «�z �K� ` �L�� C ��)Ö� G�K� � �;/ G�s�#� E�k ,G��5�� P��23 >�Ks �� �¥ G� w�<� Pc�s
��1��V� lI P����� �8j�N �� G��5�� C P��23 �� `��−'���− I PA"� P��� ��#F� �� !_1�?� � e��? 9ZR� 2R� ,�_�O .��V� 7M#V� �?2 �<�� P(�V�3 P(��
¿\��� ��5�� b�,�� �� 26�#� �?� ,G�KA� Y��6K�� ¦O�6 ��3imaginary
time s �� J��,A� �_�?� P"?�V� G��5�� P��23 >�K�* !:;� ��3�? ^<�� 1�"��Sir Herbert Dingle ©� Q(1 P#6
3 PKAV� PKA���´ P�� �� �� � �pp{ G�e �OI PA\��� b�R1k� b�,�� G/ ,�ZA:; !e �s�#� ��d63 r�O �� �2�<�� ,P"8M��� P�� �� C �� 1�8��� %s ,Pc�����
��c���A� 4N1�2�� L�%��� : �? �� P�@�� 43�AMV� ��=��� �2� G�e �OIx G�e�x ����#V� �#3 C P8��N� P8=�� ��+���� �� �2� �& , �p{ �2�
P��� �� ��{� Se�� �2� ,¿� �2�� fe� , Y��� ��Ku�� �� !Ku ./ �/ �2�� }�# N 2e����3 � ;´s ,4c����� ��"� ��x g43�AMV� 4�@�V� �2� i ER1
�?2�� �M�<_ � ��c����� GI ,��+���� YR�3 �s�;� S=�� �p{P3�:���� >}�� 'M V� �� 26�# N� '3�<�� ��dV� C !(�28�� 43 1��a��*
����#� C PA\��� b�R1k� �c� �� �y; .L�� ¿\��� ��5�� G´s EÆH ���� 1�8��� � � e��? ER�3 ¿\��� ER��� �28F�N� �OI Y""� �� lI SA" N� ,�
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��k� S8<V� lI P=�)� �,W�N �?2 � ,Y""�* Y(��5s ��=� �� Q� �����3� ,P(��5s P6e Q� S��<�� 1L©� GOI*
� e�? ¦O�6; P=�L<� � ��W;�− 43�w�� >2�%V� 7�� ��#� 2#� ` !_1�?G�K�� >�y; ^<�_ C �A�*
::::الدليل على أن للكون بدايةالدليل على أن للكون بدايةالدليل على أن للكون بدايةالدليل على أن للكون بداية
��d�� G�;�"�� �? P��23 G��5A�� P��23 G�KA� G/ �� � ���/ }e/ 2�/ P�1��)� �K�� �2A�Second Law of Thermodynamic �L? v<8���
G�;�"��: ��V� �� !"� �N >1��)� G´s Ps�w�� C �a�N ��� J�e n2 � G�e �� ];�s
Ps�w�� �= lI �a�<�� ,J�K�� >1��� P=1� Ps�w�� >1��� P=1� ���#_ 7�� -PW) C� G�K�� C �� !e �� G�;�"�� �L? .f� �LK?� >1��� ���#��N ��
G�KA� .1��)� ��V� t2pN PWpA�� mL? 2 �� G�K�� C �� !eThermal Death of Universe *
��/ G�K�� G�e ��� G/ xZ�V� G�K� � ^j�[R��� G�K�� G�� – ]� ��1����− `� ,��j"�� ª�Z;�� �� !R/ P��� C G�� G�K�� �R���� C �K� ,
A� !j� ��/ Q� �? GOI 2#3 .1��)� ��6 G��5�� �,#� �,@ P�3�H P��23 ��� ,�G�KV��*
�� �H�2� �;/ Y #� �L?� ,ª�Z;k� �� 7;�k� 2)� �� G�K�� �,@ 2"� !3 '3�N -��d� ^�–8 F�«2−*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P��W; Q�� G�;�R �L? P8N� V�3 ! �� !e �� .f� �?�>�:V� ��� >1L�� �� ,!
::::القانون الثاين للديناميكا احلرارية يسقط الوثنيةالقانون الثاين للديناميكا احلرارية يسقط الوثنيةالقانون الثاين للديناميكا احلرارية يسقط الوثنيةالقانون الثاين للديناميكا احلرارية يسقط الوثنية
P�1��)� �K�� �2A� ��d�� G�;�"A� � �U�/ P H� ���<As v"<F_ ��a/ b��� P j�� ��;��2��� P�O�8��� PN�2 &� !d� �}eP�2A"���*
G��5�� G�1�� Pc�s �� P H��� ��;��2�� mL? b�"_ ��− C ^<� ��5�� ��1��cycling − �K� ,4 <�� �� 4�%� P#U3 !e �<�; G��5�� 2#� ��
P H��� Pc���� mL? [< � G�;�"�� �L? , ^<� ��5�� G/ G�;�"�� �L? 1�"� �� PMa P"��M3Linear P�1�� P"��M3 Q��cyclic >1��)� !"� _ G/ !p�<s
�\N/ E<= lI �1�3 E<= �� * ,>�1�8�� Ps�w�� J�<� �� �a�<�� J�K�� >1��� P=1� ��_�_ G/ !p�<�
`��#��� ��5A� P�1�2�� >�K��� [< � G�;�"�� �L? �����3� * !d6� G�;�"�� �L? �8{/�P3Ú }e/ �� P �� P�<A�� EA#�� �,,=��
�e� §%q��;] P j��� P�O�8��� PN�2 &� ��;��2�� Sj; �� P3»��`�#�� C P H��� ��;��2�� �}e mL?� ,P�2A"��� *
s Y#=1 �� .1�� Q�� b��� YMa m���3 ^<� ��5�� G/ 48_ 2"[A\A� *
�����3� b�\ � �� fK � � G�;�R �L?�s P H��� C +e G��5�� P�1�� Pc��/ PR��� P���)�� P H��� C +e ���/ � �A#� -b�2{ C P#8M�� 4;��R �� ��8�
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
���O ! : : : : اإلحلاد مثلاإلحلاد مثلاإلحلاد مثلاإلحلاد مثل ضدضدضدضدوميكن استخدام هذا القانون لتحرير حجج أكرب وميكن استخدام هذا القانون لتحرير حجج أكرب وميكن استخدام هذا القانون لتحرير حجج أكرب وميكن استخدام هذا القانون لتحرير حجج أكرب
3 �� ��� ��t20 ��5 ::::إسقاط التطورإسقاط التطورإسقاط التطورإسقاط التطور - - - - ١١١١ !��� ��5�� G/ �� b�"� 1�M���s P#8M�� G/� ,b2? !��� ��5�� G/ �� ± � G�;�"�� �K� ,«��;Ô� 1�M_ b2&� �� 2�5� �{k� !3 ]R��� �� 2"#��� �� 2�5� !�K_ � P���V�
v<8���� rK�����* !a��2���s Y& ::::إثبات العناية اإللهية والتدخل اإللهي في كل لحظةإثبات العناية اإللهية والتدخل اإللهي في كل لحظةإثبات العناية اإللهية والتدخل اإللهي في كل لحظةإثبات العناية اإللهية والتدخل اإللهي في كل لحظة - - - - ٢٢٢٢
P;�d�� �� �5= 1�A� �� �5= !e C� P;�H !e C− P;�H ��6s !e Y&I !a2_ t20 − >Z��� Y? P;�H ��6���� ,>�)� ]�R��� �I�
m2{1 �K6� Y(�6e !���_ t�2) Ps�K��* �K�� �2�� G�;�R QK� ^<� PA� !a�� t20 Y(�6e !���_ ./�
,��d�� P�1��)� v<8���� b2&� �p; ^<� G�K�� G/ TZy� G�;�"�� �L,s QK� ^<_ >�)�s 2"#���� �� 8�� �p; ^<� PA� C !������ + 3 ,rK�����
PW) !e C Y&I !a2_ P��� C �I t20 � �L?� P#8M�� 4;��R* P&�� P�5#��3 !(�"�� ª�3��� S?LV� � �U�/ [< � �L?�− �� l�#_ +�
G���"�−* -R��� $�<\� -R��� F*���1� -R�� �*����$���.@1 }�.1� �����1� �s6
,F*5�5�1� x1k�� ���+<�� b�R ��3 G+��� G�K� r�L3� − E"V� �_�L3 b�"��m^w�− � x1k�� ���+<�� 'Aa C �K��V� �� r� _ � P""���f��e
�� � �p��o��n�� �m� �l��k��j�� � � � �i��h��g���r� �q
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
y��x��w��v��u��t��s�ghi* 8d[ ::::ول قائلول قائلول قائلول قائللكن قد يقلكن قد يقلكن قد يقلكن قد يق F�� `�#�� P��23 !#���3 ]8d F� ��d�� �K�� �2�� G�;�R
�� 1��6�N�3 PR�q 26<_ PA� !a�� �%������ �K� ,P H��� ���<A��� T�"N ��d�� G�;�"�� [��¯ � +3 PA� !a�� �� 8�� t20 2R �����3� ,¦1��
� �2A�P�1��)� �K�! :الرد
Z�?46 �Gq� ��� :C ª�Z;k� ±" s �_�O m1}� �� �� Q� �� -G�K� �� Q�� � �5©� �L? C ��MU� �p; �� �j"; P�1��6�N� 1}� ��–PA�− >��� !3�"� C
Y=1�a !a2�3 �I PA6©� C ª�Z;k� − �K�� �2�� C 'Aw�� ¦O�6; 1�<K;���d��−*
�# 6� � !#���3 �L? �� -�5= C ª�Z;k� ±"; �Ps��j� t20 G�s �����3� �K� ,ª�Z;k� >��� �p; �:�� PA6©� C G�K�� G/ �V�q ��d�� �K�� �2�� G�;�R
>��M� >�?�@ ª�Z;k� C ±" �� �8j� G/–>�6�<�− G�� �5©� �L? C b�W�;�3¤ �L,s ,� � r� � �� ��5=k� P"3 Y&I !a2�3 � ��R� �=� �� ��Ku�� !#· �
,P;�H ��6s !e �"M � ��R/ 'Aw�� 1�<K;�� Ps��j� «�R� b�W�;� x�Zs� �� � t�2� b2�� ,P��<�� 7��� x1�� �� >�)� 1�,@ PW) L � ª�Z;�� ±"; C� PW) !e C t20 G/ xZ�V� �? .L��� ª�Z;�� >��� �? .L�� QK#��
) ./t20 �+(�� QK#�� r�O ��� x1k� �� G�K� ./ C� PW*
ghi .��/0 12 �� � : ���������*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
mL? ��q ��� >2V� mL? ���q >2#<�� Ps��jV� mL? ^<�_ �K6� ��P6W;k�*
�AAB !,N/� �� ?O J�R/� ��"M � ��R/ !a2���3 ��"�� �8js�* / G�� 2�5� ª�Z;k� !a� P6W;k�� P"AwV�b�W; x1k ::::وقد يقول آخروقد يقول آخروقد يقول آخروقد يقول آخر
�q�3 �� PR�q n� ?� ,Q6y�� �� ���Mc�3� P�3�H PR�q 26�<_ Y,s 9���� >�?�W�� mL? �� t��)� .1��)� ���8���� 1�, ��� !A�� ���8_ n� ?� ,x1k�
r�O lI ���* : الرد
�A#s ª�Z;k� >��� �R���� C .�R Y @ ��/� ,P"AwV� P6W;k� C Y#MR ��/ �P����V� P6W;k� C*
K� ��2�N�� �� �� ±\u 1��j� x1k� �� t2p�; � �p; � ? � P��W V� �� � d�2� +;I� ,'Aw� b�W; ]<�� 9���� b�W; x1k� G/ 1�"�� �� !����_ � ��k 'Aw� b�W; Y? .�W; P,=� �� P_�)� P��W V�� ,P_�)�
8�� ����1I �� ��(�"A_ PR�q J�<�e�3 PMpV� P~� +;I� � �L?� Y(�"A_ � .��1I !����� Â��a b2\�<� +;´s m1�L= }� P3Z�� �� PR�q S<�K� YK� ��8 �� G/ Y #� Q6y�� �� PR�q S<�K� ��2 �� ,P��6Nk� P{�� !d� P��� Ps��? PA"�<�
1�U\�� ��88� �& �s�� �;´s"!s�1�AK��" PR2�� P��� ±(�ja �,s �U�� ,�� !j0 �p3 �=����� �Ì3 2��<� �� �;´s �I� !s�1�AK�� �� >����N��*
�A= �,W� � ?� Pwj3 ]e�_ ��� >��1I %3 ]e�F_ �� P_�)� P��W V� G/ ��? ��|<�� �8j� �����3� ª�Z;k� C >��� �I �& t20 �As �28�� L � P(�"A_ :
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
e P_�)� P��W V� ^<_ �O�V� >��1��� Y���� 12j� �� P;�e P��W � QK� !K ?ª�Z;�� >��� QK� ^<_� P�1��)� �K�� �2A� ��d�� G�;�"�� Y?�
>��1I� Y��� '8<� vM� n� ? G�e �OI �I* '8<� -� j3 �I ��� _ `� �,A{/ C P"Aw� P��W � P_�)� P��W V� GOI
G/ ���"�3 2pAV� 5�R �8j� � ?� ,4"3�N vM�� >��1I� P_�)� P��W V�e ���/ ��#; G/ 23%s ,J�AMV� �� >1��j� �? P����� P��W � b�W; G�K_ [
�_�O ��/ �� 9���� �? P{�� mL? �& ��� .L�� +;I� 9���� b�W; G�K_ � � �I P�1��)� �K�� �2A� ��d�� G�;�"�� fK_ � ±(�ja Y?� >��1��� Y����
!a2�3–Y&I− �,M#� P�5V� mL?� P6<�� mL?* �� PAjpV� G/ E�5� �� �Ma P��)� ��6K�� ��,@/ 2R� P3�Z;A� b�W
-b�� �=�3 r�O �� b5A� �� ���5_ ��/1 C b�W �� ��5=/ �� P3�Z;I >���*
s�& >�1�q ]<�� PR�MA� P{�� P �k� x�Òk� !���� , �� Y? �����3�Z;k� 2�5_ G/ xZ�V�P3�!
ª�Z;�� C >���5�� G�;�R �� '��; P��28�� C �;���S▲:
▲S=q/t1
��q : � � Pj�6V� �/ b�W A� Ps�UV� >1��)� 1�2"�*
�t1 :2"V� G�2"s �/ Â�j��� !8R b�W �� >1��� P=1� 1�q * ��3�Z;� ]AR 2R b�W �� G�e �OI �� 2�2B '3�<�� G�;�"�� �� �M�<;S▲
P8��N, ��� �/S▲ P8=��*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�8j_ P�1��� PR�q b�W �� 2"s �O´sq �� P6<"�� �_�; �8js P8��Nt1 ��8��N, ��3�Z;� ]AR 2R b�W �� G/ ./, PR�q b�W �� S<�e� �� QK#�� t20�
P�1���*
s �& >�1�q ]<�� PR�MA� P{�� P �k� x�Òk� !����*" �� '8M � �L?� �� 3 !���_ ./anabolism*
P#8M�� �� PR�M�� ±�6� .L�� �? !������ G/ Pq�<83 Y #� �� �?� �QK#�� , �� � K6� �� �¤ !������ b�W; C Ê����� ª�Z;�� >��� Y #� �L?�
!��e 4_��3 �� 3 �� �K6�� 7�� Y�K� �V ��6j��* P��)� P��W V� !6�K_ �� ,Y&I !a2_ G�23 �����3�!
ضي ينقض اإللحادضي ينقض اإللحادضي ينقض اإللحادضي ينقض اإللحادقانون رياقانون رياقانون رياقانون ريا
È��2�� �?�"�<� P���� PUR Y���� G/ ��)�� xZ��* P���V� ��1L�� P��; Q�; �� Y? È��2�� >��� ! ÝKyF_ Y��� ��1L�� G/ +3�
.��V� `�#��� x1k� >��� !Ky_ Y���* G/ +3� >��� �%���_ È��2�� 4;��"� �U� P��/ ��~�5© t�2�/ Y?
P(��5s* �L�� mL? ��1 ��%����3 ,�R����� 2��:��� 43 1��� G/ �& Q� Y,s C ^<_
�, � r� _ � P���� ��6��* F� n12F_ G/ !p�<� r_�1O «�6� C ];�s '8N �� �� � ��� 3� �����3� ^w�
2��:���� �R���� 43 9��Z�*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
?�V�� C ��=�� ^� �� 7 #� .��V� r���� Y"�<� [e OI �� EH�U�"� � Y=���8�� r��W; G�e �OI 2��:��� r�O lI r�=��?
��� .��� Y=1��� ¿a�2�� rV��� >��� ��� ] e �O´s− ��"� +e��)�� − P���� � �1�Ho� � �H�2�/ �I n12F_ �As!
��c����� C P���j�� P6"�� �� 2��:��� S���<_ G/ !p�<�� Ä* ��c����� C P���j�� P6"��� ��j_� $�N/� ,���}�� b�A� $�N/ Y?
$�N/� ��K8y����%a �� J��K�� �L? ¦��aI E_ .L�� �_�86K�� �,=* �7 #� ��)Ö� G�e �O´s S�e/ �¤ ��~u /�"_ �As*
s � �pp{ ��)�� G�e �OI�P�2��:��� ��c����� S���<_ �A* !3 P�<As� P6���e/ b�A#� QN���� E�� �� PR%6�b�"_ ��<N|� �,A�P6\c PA"#�� x����� �? }ek� �,���R*
�7 #� ¸����� 2��:�A� G�e �V .��V� `�#�� �� 3/ �� e �� b�A� �1���� ,���}�� �&�/ PA��e*
��=�s ];Z;�� �L? �� ��,�;�� �&%a �� � #M�N� Y��� �_�86K�� P��3�k J��K��� ��)�� Ps�\N �� !�� }e.��V� !Ap���!
قانون قيA@مي ينقض اإللحادقانون قيA@مي ينقض اإللحادقانون قيA@مي ينقض اإللحادقانون قيA@مي ينقض اإللحاد
PA� PjR EK� YK�/ ���� G�;�"�� �L& x�#�; G/ !8R�: G�)�{ ����/ P"3�<�� E�k� C G�e ,G�2?� ��8�� , 23�#�� ���= G�e�
5� �� E?/ Ë�3 ��L�� 4)�j�� ��|? 2�/!=� ,�����K�� EÀ2�/ �� �,@/� ,
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�3 ±3�_ G/ 2#3G�2<�V� ,Py����� C ���"�I ������� , ��#6N ���y_�!q�8��3 , m}a � A� ±R 2R�− EAN� �A� �� �{ � 8;– ��2)� C .L��
Y8 �� �� >���? ª/ �� EA<� � .1�\8�� m��1− EAN� �A� �� �{ − ��R :Û /F�C� p6 (GB� c ,@?�� ,,��� �5� �R*0 , ��j [+��� , ��j ��9� Cj
�(5�0 ,,�G*# ��?# F���� `��# �8� ��� % Q�� %�!�# ,21��# :�� ��j ,Z��#: ���C�� _�� ] ,%!C� v0 y3^�# ,2#>��# , ��� %�!� (~1� �� ��9 �@#
�8� ,21��# : ��j �� ,Z��# :�C�� _�� ] �� ,%!C� v0 y3^�# ,2#>��# ,�8� ��� %�!� (~1� �� ��9 �@# ,21��# : ��j �� ,Z��# : ] ;�
�C�� _�� ,%!C� v0 y3^�# ,21��# : l�j� k6 �q�� ��+ %�� p ,G@1�S�R��B� ,%!$�30� ���j y*a��6 ��5 �9�`�# ,_~5 ���� 2��9� Wy�.u|� W��G�RJ5 ,21��# :,?1 %��|��� �#� ,��4 �6 ,Z�^ :,�G*16 2V�@� ,@# %1 2����# 2!�#
%����� k6 ;��� ��9 �*0� ,��?��#�GRV� �� % ,�G*@0 T^�# ,2@uJ# �@# ,21�^ S(1� : ��j �� �� ,l�1�����# l�!�# ,%����� ���(�� , ��@�j�
%��5�� ,Z��# :,?��4 �� ,��1�^ :��� S(1�# _~31� l`� 2*�� ,Z��# : ���_381� ,%5 ��)�A# ,Z��# :��� ��+ }�0$ ,v8# ,�@# _381� �!� X>��
%�t5 c |�|�|t# ,Z�^� :�C� �� ,Z�^ ? ��5� �� :_0��1� �C# ,Z�^ : v0 ��@3^�#��1�^� ,%5 ��JRu��� %��@�3 |�� ��j :[�s �� ������ �1 _�3� ,Z�^ :p ,
2��9 �9 e �� ���(*0� ,��@�V#Ü*
فليست الحجة في - اآلن انتهت القصة؛ وال يعنينAا تكذيب الملحد لها
صحتها فنحن ال نحتج على الملحد بما ال يؤمن به، وإنما الحجة في
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
، الذي يعنينAا هو تسليمه بصحة القيمة التي - القيمة التي تكمن ورائها
. ترتكز عليها القصة
وتسجيل اإلعجاب بما قام به وتسجيل اإلعجاب بما قام به وتسجيل اإلعجاب بما قام به وتسجيل اإلعجاب بما قام به التمرد على المرأة البغيA، التمرد على المرأة البغيA، التمرد على المرأة البغيA، التمرد على المرأة البغيA، : والقيمة هنا هي
.!!!!جVريج العابدجVريج العابدجVريج العابدجVريج العابد
�?1 23�#�� ���= b��"� G/ !p�<V� �� �8{k � �pp{ ��)�� G�e ��Yw8�� >/�V� ������I!
F; G/ P=12�� Q� 3 !p�<V� ��� Ë��& ��%<�N� �� �����"� �p; !U! �� GI ����)I ��² 23�#�� ���= �3 b�R ��1�M_ ��²� � [Ks ,� ���= �� Ë� F�
?�_� = ���� P{�s 23�#��
�� ��\N� � ���6#�<� ��� � <�/DNA �RNA �1�y��1 ��"� +e �3��e C 5 e���"��;k� 4©�"?
��� ��)�� G/ ��|_ �a�� ];/ r;/ Y #� 23�#�� ���= ��6j3 n1�,8;� GI �E?� È1�s!
#� 23�#�� ���= S���N� �V � �pp{ ��)�� G�e �� � 8���N� �V� ,��6��� 7 [�#��� 7 #� �p;!
Y6� _ � ��pAMj� [�#���� ��6���sL? lI �K6� �� .��V� `�#�� ���)�� 1�qI C �,AAB!
2V� 'p�<� 23�#�� ���= ��_ G�e �O´s� � <� � ;/ Pq�<83 Y #� �L,s �P���� ��� ��)�� G/� ,Y ��1�2�� .��V� ��M�� �� 4Aj��� 2��� P8#�� ,��"Ò
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��+�/ ��fak� �,"8M_! قانون منطقي ينقض اإللحادقانون منطقي ينقض اإللحادقانون منطقي ينقض اإللحادقانون منطقي ينقض اإللحاد
y*�$�j� %�� �t5 c (J@� e�j! � "�N [e 4 ©� �L? ?��/ �M3 ¦1�a EW�� S:� �ao `�� ��=�3
Y,� _ � `���� 1��/ �3� 1�p3� �6R� Q6u� ,P�A�¨ Q���; �3 `��1�:s� ��2#N�*
�L? G/ !� �Î/ �� 4 ©� ��"� Q�/ ,n�a/ S?O ��/ ����N� ,�A8R �5; b/�_2pAV� Ñ�= Pq�31 C : �� ,§+�k� C ]B �sF�� ���� G�KV� � � %a Ya/
��y�k� C �I � � ��L� �� �p; �� ¦1�a >��? �M3 �� �N�/� S�1/ `��� >2�2= �;2� S?O m�a/ G/ EA#� � 4K<V��
�6KB� ,��/ F;� ������ 4;��R 2#3 �?� ,l�k� �_�� �� JZ"_ �/ [A�� EW -��W) �S?�O �,�I!
2pAV� �À/ G�� !� ! ÆN� C �M F"s G��5�A��� C EAs x� F� �� !R� �M ��/� ?!M8A� ��= �O�� ���� �� ,7,�;� �;/ ��2?�yV� �� 2�/ § �2{ �V ;7,�;�
?Pj"�� P6�_ 3 G��W� � E�k r�O G/ �A� ��A8 F= ��� E��M�Y,� _ F�� ,Pj"�� �2<
�&�M3/ J�<�* Ë2<F� `� ��V�3 Y,� _ >�)� PjR G/ !R�� §2j� [Ks?2#3 J�<)� �
m2?�y� !�23 ,P��"�� b��� �#8�� Ppj3 ��,y�N�� v3�� E��K�� Go�"���
_…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
8_� 'A� !���� !�� �?� �/ ,� � �~M� �� b�� !e �#8�� �K � %s �&2 �M3 ¦1�a ��a/ P�2<= 4;��"3 EW�/ `�� n� ? G/ §2j� ��/ �M3 C .L�� Q���; �3 m�W� � �ao `�� n� ? G/ �W� x1k� �,@ �� ^<� .L�� �� ,��/
S:�/� EK�/ ��a/* sl�#_ ��" :���g��f��e��d��c��b��a���`������ � � � �_��~��}��|
�q��p��o��n��m��l���k������j��i��h���x��w���vu���t��s��r��¦¥��¤��£� �¢�� �¡���� �~��}��|� �{��z� � �y��´���³��²��±��°��¯���®��¬��«��ª���©��¨��§��Ã��Â��Á��À��¿���¾��½��¼��»��º��¹��¸¶��µ
�����ghi* ��� s ��V�� ,� �_�� >����� 2pAV� �/1 [Ks ?!��e
قانون أخالقي ينقض اإللحادقانون أخالقي ينقض اإللحادقانون أخالقي ينقض اإللحادقانون أخالقي ينقض اإللحاد
����� ����� � ����� ����� � ����� ����� � ����� ����� � ���� ���� ���� ����::::
6� أخالق مصلحية منفعية أنانية مادية�:V� §%a/ 76<_ Y?� ,– J��3 Y A��#_ Ye J��3 rA���F/– QN|� Y��� PA{k� §%ak� ]<� mL?�
G�R%ak� �&– 4pAj�� ��8;/− G��k�� 1�j#�� !e }� , * , �?mL وهناك النوع الثاني من األخالق وهي تسمى األخالق األصيلة
P"")�� SA��� $�Nk� *¶�1���� }� G�pAjV� �& QN/ Y��� Y?� * !d�
ghi �)� >1�N : P���g½i*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
§%a/ : �c���� EA Á)�� P�� "��� 1�d���� PpU���� P;��k�� �2#��� §2j��'FAF� �< F� ��#� !e�*
jV� 2c �>��8� ®�_ §%ak� mL? �K� Pp3�� ^� Y,s ,Pj\y�� PpA �A6��*
,>��V� 2c Y? !3 !"#�� 2c�* �A"� �/ ��A6� �,A� P ?}�� E�� `��L? � ��� lI �*
P���V� >2(���� � � ]��;� �� �I �%{/ G�K� � $�Nk� C YR%ak� !6#��sPj\u P#� � P�/ �/ ������ �/*
.��� .��)I `�� C m��=� ��}_ �K6� � §%ak� �� «� �� �L? �K�* �� �/ m��=� GI !3 �K�A� �,,=�_ �K6� P3Ú }e/ �? m��=�3 ��Z�
§%q�� �� .��)��! ��2� ,��#3/ PH%H �O .�U� �(�e �? ¸1/ .��� 1�W � �� G�×<;��s 43 �� �,s ,P#8M�� �?��W�� �� .f� �� �A� .f� ,m��2� Y? P#8M��
s P���V�� P���j�R�� �#s��� 1�qI C ��N�1� �K6� ��uk�S<p* ��"�� �� JÚ �? PA{k� §%ak� �� ��2� ./ G´s �����3�
��:FV� .��V� .��)�� ¦O�6 �� �� P���� ^� z� � ��a�I� ,�"�5s��V�3* Y#8M�� b�×W �� C >�wH !d� 1�q�� �L? C §%ak�s , 4;��R �� � ���� !d�
>��V�* �� $/�3 ¶�1���� lI G�<;�� !a� 2R�!(�? Y(28� YR%a/ � * 2"s � ? ���
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
¿� ��"� +e � �2�2= � ��� ]# { Y��� PWpA�� rA_ ��,@ Í�s�:3 �5��3��e C �� �Ò1 :Û L � � �2e/ G�<;�� �� ��,@ Y��� PA{k� §%ak�s
�, � �y; Y��� P#8M�� �� m��� � m1�,@ P��{/ �� l�k� PWpA��Üghi* � 1�{ PWpA�� mL? C�Í��&� Y? P#8M��� 5e�V� �? G�<;�*
���»��º��¹��¸��¶��µ��� �´��³��²��±��°Ã��Â���������Á��À��¿¾���½��¼�g�i*
G�� Ý2"� E? ,>��V� 1�qI C §%ak� 1�,@ !AB G����0 ��L�� G����V�� P���� ^� -§�<;�3 ®�_ �� �2 �"#_ +,� >��V� Gk ,��)�� T�"N� P"��q !,N/
§%ak�e! ñ…b½a@ôì�@bĆ÷î‘@wnäm@åÛ@p†IÔÈm@bàèß@ñ…b½bÏN@ @
�#s ��_� �� ����� ,`�#�� �¥ !a� Y��� l�k� G�<;�� E�R� PA{k� §%ak�s��:V� .��V� `�#�� lI �?�1 -��p3 �K6� � P6W;/ �,Ae >��V� �� >� ����!*
� P��+<�� P�2"V� rA_ �� 2e|�� 1��k� mL? !e GI lI G�<;�� �¥ !a� Y��`�#��!*
��K�� '< �� C �}e Ps�#� >�wH §%ak�s; �,��UaI �K6� � �L��P¯1���� Qe1�� ��6��� P#8M�� 4;��"� ,P��U#�� ���1�� ��6�� �/, �/
P�+�=�� E��e1�� ��6�� *
ghi Í�s�:3 �5� ¿#� ,J�w�� � §��� 43 EAN��* g�i 3�4(!� �� � : �����,+�*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
� C �<�; �� Ý}#F� P#8M��� §%ak� 43 �%�a�� �L? 43 �%�a��P;�<;�� b�A#�� C Ý�|V�� P#8M�� b�A#�� C Ý�|V� 28� 1��e2�� ��"� +e
�� �Ò1 .^<V� J�?���* ��/ P��,<3� n12_ rA#· §%ak� P��<� C �W A� ���B !R�s QK� ^<_
P#8M��3 �& PR%� � §�/ 7 #63 �/ P#8M��* ,s G��5�� C >�wH §%ak�s'Aa ¦��; Y, PA��e �,"Aa ���; �� � � �� Gk
'A¯ +;I� 2y� �� ,�� AR +e �L? !e G�<;�� 1�,@ P��{/ 2e|�* C + 3 ���=� ��uk� 2=�_ P#8M�� `�� ���c�� ��, ��� 1�2_ x1k�s
Q6y��, n�p�_ �?1�23 Q6y��� *P���� P#8q '(�"� mL?* §%ak� `�� C ��/sEK -��u/ �� �,A#�; G/ 2��; � � e� �?� A#s, �� Ee�
-��u/ �23/ �,A#�; ` �K�� �,A#�; G/ �;���� * I n� ? GO–Í�s�:3 ��"� +e− P#8M�� `��� SA"�� `�� G�V��, mL?
��� QK#_ !#���� >��1�� 43 PR%#��`�#��� G�<;�� 43 Y(28V� �R�* ¡3� �� k6 -�� ;SK_1� �OI �G�<;I Ë Æz/� P6��= �� 2jR G�23 �,A#s �;/ ,
2j"�� b2� ��8H� Y��² !e 7#<� � ?* P6��©� ¿"#��� .��V� 1�W V�3 �;/ ���R���� x1/ �� ],�;�� ]#R� , �U�/ b�:V���,8K_1� �;/ �Z#� �, !a2�� �K�
P ��� 2j"�� Ps�#V G�;�"��, �©� J�K_1� �� H/ Q� �� P��� Ps�#�� !? P6� ��= -2j"3 /� b*
'(�")� �� ��/ 5e�� C Q� �� �U; � ?�� , P���V� P#R���� �� ��/
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
>��:V�, �� �� EKp; �K� `�#�� C t2� �� �� EKp; � P"")� C �p sQ� �� !a�� t2�*
�%j� F� Q� G�<;��s ���1�� ��q ��* GI.��V� P#8M�� b�W; C >�wH §%ak� Y,s Ps�#� >�wH� ,P;�� >�wH ,
P6R >�wH�� , PA"� >�wH , §%ak�s � AR +e �A"� Y? !3 >1�c !3 Pp3�� ^� ��,8��{ �� �S� }e/*
���<_ 2R� �1�;�3!s2;��Bernard mandeville §%ak� EA� O��N/.5A:;�� ��: ? .1�U)� 1�M���� �6�:V� b2"�� §%ak� P / ��
J�=/� Pq�<83 : >1�c G�K_ �,A#� !3 �� �* Aاواألخالق والدين هما أقدم األفكار اإلنسانية تر، Aا مع وقد ظهرا سوي
واإلله هو الشرط الوحيد لسمو اإلنسان وحريته وأخالقه واإلله هو الشرط الوحيد لسمو اإلنسان وحريته وأخالقه واإلله هو الشرط الوحيد لسمو اإلنسان وحريته وأخالقه واإلله هو الشرط الوحيد لسمو اإلنسان وحريته وأخالقه ،اإلنسان ....ومبادئه وقيمهومبادئه وقيمهومبادئه وقيمهومبادئه وقيمه
� V�#3 ��R%qI �� PR%� � `�� ;�ao -`�� �� �,�6R 26�<_ PA{k� §%ak�s E?�� ,È1�s �w� ��� lI §%ak� ��p�_ �a�� `�#�� �L? G�23� ,��:V� .��V�
m��=� b2#� m��=�3 |8 ��� �%{/ !p�<� ! >1�U� �/ P�/ P�/ >5e1 Y? !3 ,>��=�� §%ak�� � ��3 +s *��� !3 7
G/ G��� r�L3 �;/ �� ,§%ak� b�5���3 ������ �� �<�; � 6� � ��2pAV� 7��/ �,A6e�3 P���)�� P��W V� v"<F� .12�*
��)�� �" _ P6"e §%ak�s!
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A قانون بديهي ينقض اإللحاد
2�/ 2)/ �V � �pp{ ��)�� G�e ��!
-'<; C ��1L�� ^<_ .��V� `�#�� !a�� �� � ]3�H G�ZK��� 1�2�� ,[A\b�W�;�� -���Mc�3 >2����� P;�d�� C Z� �Ae [�/ P�f3 >�� �� ���*
�� Y��� ��1L�� Q�; Y? r���� ��1O�!Ky .��V� `�#�� �, �* �� ��2)� �8j� 1�q�� �L? C� ,r��� -�� !e C P���V� P6�)� ��<_�
^� ��d�2� P��w�� �/ P6"�� �/ 7 #V� .��V� `�#�� �L? lI Y6� � � ��d�2� ,b�,��>��)� P����� mL? 1�qI C �M8c �K6� ��!
^a �� � �s 2=�� � .��V� `�#��s ***PN�:; �� PN�2R � **** ��Ma �� J��{*
5 e��� �1�y��1 �}� 2R�Richard Dawkins– C ��2pAV� J� ���`�#��− �%(�R r�O �� :"G�K�� ^a �� � %3 ��""� C"ghi*
'8N �� �� ��� 3� : � �� C ��Ma/ ��=� G�<;I [y�K� G/ !p�<� − ���6� 2�− ��=�� J��j��� �M� ��=� � �"8<� � ?O C �"�N� �� �I 2pAs
���� ^�* ��a/ �>�� 1�eF/ :� �� C ��Ma/ ��=� G�<;I [y�K� G/ !p�<�, 2pAs
���� ^� ��=�� J��j��� �M� ��=� � �"8<� � ?O C �"�N� �� �I*
i1g The universe we observe has ... no evil and no good River out of Eden,
p.131-132.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� .L��� � �� C �M� ��=� G�<;I S���N� �V ���� ^� ��=� ��As2pAF� G/ 1 ��R �N�N/!
��)�� �Ma Y #� �L? �K�; � ;k � AR +e �V .��V� `�#�� �L? �� 3/ �� e ��M� ��=� � e1�/��� �� ^� �� ,J��j�� �� � ,� �����3�2�/ 2pAF� �;
�M� �� J��j�� �� ��� �� ^� ��#; � � ;/ xZ�V� � ;k! !!!!لكن هناك ملحدون؛ إذن هناك خير وشر؛ إذن اإللحاد خطألكن هناك ملحدون؛ إذن هناك خير وشر؛ إذن اإللحاد خطألكن هناك ملحدون؛ إذن هناك خير وشر؛ إذن اإللحاد خطألكن هناك ملحدون؛ إذن هناك خير وشر؛ إذن اإللحاد خطأ
G�<;�� �?O C ��)�� �Ma 1��"�N� ��As * � 8� Q� `�#�� �L? G/� �� � '<;�Ma� J��{� �� ^a �3 2=�� `�#�� �L? G/� ��)�� * P�2"V� mL? ���
�V� 2�/ 2)/ �V�� �/ �Ma ��=� � �y�e* � �� C 2pAV� E?2"�s� ��L��� P��w��� �2&�� 7 #V�� P6"�� ��=� ��As –
E�5� +e − 2)/ �V! I G/ 1�R �V ,���� ^�� J��j��� �M�3 ��s�#� ����� �� �� � a m��)
–E�5� +e−! على خطأ اإللحاد، ويصبح الكفر دليال على على خطأ اإللحاد، ويصبح الكفر دليال على على خطأ اإللحاد، ويصبح الكفر دليال على على خطأ اإللحاد، ويصبح الكفر دليال على وهنا يصبح اإللحاد دليالوهنا يصبح اإللحاد دليالوهنا يصبح اإللحاد دليالوهنا يصبح اإللحاد دليال
!!!!سقوط الكفرسقوط الكفرسقوط الكفرسقوط الكفر
P#R�� �, K� P8:�� ,P""� �, K� P8��� PR1��� ��I! S���<� G/ �/ P��w�� �/ P6"�� �/ 7 #V� �� !j0 G/ G�<;�� �M�<� �As
�� ��~uE"�� 2c� E"�� ��a/ -P�2"�� �ao -$���;� �ao -`�� �� -�263 �I � ����−P��+N P�2"�−*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
m��=� P�1�#� n12� G/ G�<;�� �M�<� ��� `�#�� �L? C � -Q8"3 �Im� #� �� �?}� �� `�#�� �L? C 2=��*
6����d��3 `�#�� �L? C G�<;�� � P6"��� P��w��� 7 #V� ��; EA#� �;k -P6AN -G�#� ��/ n12� �;k� ,�?� #� ��� C �"�<� �;k� ��uk� mL? ��=�
� ����* `�#�� �L? C G�<;�� ��=� 7 #V �6�<� 2e�_ b2" F� �L?� !
� �� }e/ 2e�_ b2"���=� !AB �� 7�� m5:�� ,��)�� Ps�\N �2�m �_��2"� Q�; �%a �� ,�?�@ !AB �� m5:��G�<;�� >!
�V� ,��)I P6Ae 7 #� 2�/ n1�/ �� 2�/ 2)/ �V � �pp{ ��)�� G�e �As�Ma �/ J��{ �/ � �/ ^a P6Ae 7 #� 2�/ n1�/!@@@@@ @@ @@ @@ @
æc@Õj�@b¾@…ì–Ô½aZ@ @ [��¯ �,s ,EA� ��3 [�/� !"#�� ����/� 'M V� ��À23 [��¯ ��)��
,���2" F� � �+�A< F�� ,����W; � 4;��R � Ps�#� ER� ,�� @ � '(�"���32�� � � �!AR �K� b�?�/!
_…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
الفصل الثالث !معاجلة جديدة التطور
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A õbÔm‰üa@ÝjÓ@õì’äÛa@òà×bª@ @
��1��� 5�1�y_ �c� G/ L �Charles Darwin �,uk� �3��e" !{/ C «��;k�On the Origin of Species" b�#�� Ch¼½Ç , [R��� ` ��2©��
Pp{ G�y3"P ��1�2��" t2�k� Pwj�� �/"1�M���" ��2©� [R��� � 2R� ,��:�_ -«��2� 1�W V� !8"�<V� C �� ^dK3 EA#�� 5� �Q ��=�����/� 2(�"�
4s�M�� �2�* k ;1�M_ �?2��� 2pAV�s��= ��I x1k� �=� �� �� (�K�� G 1�M_ }� �
"_1��,���H !�23 �� ��8� 'Aa ��I� �� ��)�� v"N 1�M��� v"N �OI �����3�� �2��� ���R P���V� $1�2� ]M"N�*
!R/ G�K� 2R �a�� ��M�� �K� ��2�� �� � ��Ma !Ky� � 1�M���s ; �PN���)� � ��<; ��; !Ky� +e*
«�c�V� !{/ lI ]��A� � Æ� !AR E��� � .L�� ��2©� �L? vN� C �K���y �� �?� − >�)� 1�,@ P��23 ./− )� !8R��"_1�� �� ��2− 1�M_ ./
«��;k�* �jw�� !8R «L:A�� ,«���� !8R !{Ô� ^W ��� E�� G/ l�k�s * �1�N �K�
!{k� �� � "AM;� �� �p s ,2pAV� Y,�y� +3 ��<��–��y �� − 2pA6A� EÁA ÆN �� «�s–��"_1��− 7�� Y8��:���� .2{��� EA#�� �qF/ ¦1�a �"� !{k� Gk
P��<��* �� %e �� 4<6p�V� �� 7�� n12� � � !A"s ��Z��3 ��y �� G/ 4s�M
P�1�M��� P����� �/ P(��y#�� �/ >��V� 1�qI C m^<�_ !p�<� ��2pAV� 1�8e*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
x1k� �� >�)� �/23 [e ��|N 7"8� b��� lI�? 2�# F� � Æ� !e §��_�3P3�=I %3 P��)� ��6K�� �+A�� 4=���8�� �� ��/�3ghi *
�2�� C ��k� ��|<�� G�e �O´s +3 �M"�� lI �AM�; [Ks P3�=I %3 P ��1? m2#3
EA#�� �& 2:N �p8�� ����/ C 1�jR PU"�� G/ !(���� ��� 2R �K� �=���8�� Y6A� ���2:3�3 !,= +;I� �����_ Q� �L?� ,b�� ��O � �3��=
!��? 2��s 2pAV� .5A:;�� rA��� `�� ��3�<) � �"8Ms ,P��)� ��6K���Sir
Fred Hoyle PAa v<3k �+�5;�� P��6� v"s �� ��j)� P{�s G´s , lI !j_ P�hÄ $/ÅÄßÄÄÄ ��:�_ � �Ae G�K�� C ��1L�� �2� G/ ��hÄ
$/¼Äg�i * ���;}�� 1�,@ P�+��� 9�q ��� G/ !��? 2��s �� �<� PWpA�� mL? C�
Y(28�� ��<)� C Ps��jV�3 ,P)� PA\A� EW V� «�; �;/ �� l�k� x1k� P~8��K¤ ���<� ��/ �� ���&� ��
i1g Today as we leave the 20th century, we still face the BIGGEST
PROBLEM that we had when we entered the 20th century : how did life
originate on earth source: Jeffrey Bada, Earth, February 1998, p.40. i2g the chance of obtaining the required set of enzymes for even the
simplest living cell without panspermia was one in 1040,000. Since the
number of atoms in the known universe is infinitesimally tiny by
comparison (1080).
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Is evidently nonsense of a high orderg1i .
�AMj� S��{� ^,u ��M��3 rAs `�� �? �s�#� � �V !��? 2��s� EW#�� 1�:�;��Big Bang >�y; ��c�s C �H�p3/ G/ �I ,� �2pA� G�e�
I ]A#= x1k� �� >�)� >2y3 5�À m��)"greatly shaken" �� ��"� +e�<�;g�i *
PW) ��p�_ 4� !"#�� ��À23 v<3/ G/ �P��z !��? �Z�� 2R� b��/ PAH�� PÀ23 ���e «�23��� E6j��� P"") EA<F_ ��´s >�pA� l�k� 1�,W��
!��? ��"� ,4�k� :"�<V� mL? C E"�<�� ��8� !Ky3 � #3�_ ���P� , G/ G��� ���V� G/ m���� ¦�� �N� lI !j; ,2(�<�� Y6A#�� ./��� P���¨ �� ���3 ��8;
>�6H G�K_ G/ S· b�W;� $�R �� ���B +3 P=���8�� E6j_YeO , 2=�_ ���¥ ^K���� Y K6� ��a/ P�+��� ./"g i *
YK< �^3 2��� ��/David Berlinski Y=���8��� ��c����� `��
i1g The notion that not only the biopolymer but the operating program of a living
cell could be arrived at by chance in a primordial organic soup here on the Earth is evidently nonsense of a high order*Sir Fredrick Hoyle and Chandra
Wickramasinghe, Evolution from Space (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1984), p. 148.
i2ghttp://www.uncommondescent.com/intelligent-design/fred-hoyle-an-
atheist-for-id¬. i3g Hoyle, Fred, Evolution from Space, Omni Lecture, Royal Institution,
London, 12 January 1982; Evolution from Space (1982) pp. 27–28.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��� 4���V� !8R � Á� �s S� Fe �� !e� ��y �� P��<� G/ 2e|s ,^,y�� YK���k��de/ � Y6A� ��a! ghi*
.1�/ � ±\u YK< �^3 2����agnostic �� Ps�� ����1 ��,@ C ���3 2��<6e �A6� �� H/ .��V� �?1�qI C >�)� >�y; ����W; �� S� Fe
P~�5©� �=���8��molecular biology �8����e P#��:3Columbia
University 1�,W�� P�+��� G/ !8R �� !��? 2���� 48_ +e �� 48_� , >�(�q !Ky_ P�+��� �� 12"�� Q�; �? ,P K¤ PAa PAa v<3k Y(��y#��
� ��3ÃÅà >��� �� P��e 9��· 1�j�I 2#3g�i * b� ©� !a�� ^�y_ �� .��B P_���A#� P��W � Y? P K¤ PAa v<3�s �� ,�,�(�@�� PA� ±(�ja �,W_ ^�y��� �L? rs E�� 4�� ,�¥ Â��
��I ¦��p�N �� ^�y�3 PA� b�"_ G/ �K6�; !8R �=��B �� ��#_ � �%{/ ��kv<3/ mL? ,'8<� ^�y_ G�23 �,W_ �� Y?� ,�,W_ G/ GI Y��� !"#�� ��À23
�� !e r�O 2#3 � A?�� �?� A?��! 2=�� '��a �I �?2=�� � P�28� P "�� 'Aa PA6� �? ^�y���s– �;�p8N
l�#_�− r��e Q<;��s [y�e� 4� �L�� ,Francis Crick �.5=
i1ghttps://web.archive.org/web/20080420082802/http://www.slate.com/id/2
189178/entry/2189179/. i2ghttp://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/2024776?uid=3737928&uid=2&
uid=4&sid=21104849695011.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��DNA � >�y; G/ � �2pA� G�e� r��e �Z�� ,5:#V� �� x1k� �� >� �(�"A_ !p�<��3��e r�O !=/ �� �c�� �:
i Life Itself: Its Origin and Nature Ü �,�#8q� ���y; �,<�; >�)� Û) g1i .
>�)� >�y s–��y ��− Y? �A{ Y �2�� '< �� 's� ]pA{ GI Y��� PU"�� � ���2= 2pAV� �� � Aa� �?�;��� GI� ,��2pAV� ����� !e ����� �?2#3 ��
Y,� _ � � �c��s� E���* C � �2�2B� � ��a|��Ç b�� }6<���ÄÄÅ r�O C $��� 2pAV� S�e
�As ���;/ ]R���Antony Garrard Newton Flew ��"� S�e :" GI P6A#�� ��s�y�e��3 P���2V� Y? �� ��=� �� J�:�� >1�HI �dek� �:)�
e +� ^dK3 ��R/ >�pA� «28V� 'A�3 P{�� �:)� rA_� ,Pd�2)� 2R ]!8R �� ��2{1"g�i*
�? �As ���;k � �"8q G�� 7�� �A� P3�=�� E�_ ` .L�� Y�<A��� ��|<��s �� F� G/ !"� %3 ��6� >��� �� !Ky�� .L�� G�KA� [e OI >�)� >�y; G�y3 � G�� � ;I ,>��yV� ��6K��� �H�K��� �� >12"V�� ,P(�w�� �,6KB ��;� e
i1g Crick, F. H. C. and Orgel, L. E., 1973, Icarus, 19, 341. i2g Habermas, Gary R. (9 December 2004), "My Pilgrimage from Atheism
to Theism: An Exclusive Interview with Former British Atheist
Professor Antony Flew".
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
� P�A�¨ P~s ��I �=���3 �� !��#�;PAKyV� �� � ���ghi * 2R >�)� G/ ��|� G�e �<�; ���1�� 5�1�y_ 7�ps" !8R � Á� �:�´3 �,s ¶�F;
'���" «��;k� !{/ �3��e �ao C ���1�2� >^,y�� P6AK�� Y?�The Origin
of Species l�k� �_�#8q C* 2#3� 5:#V� �.5©� ��y�e�DNA ��y�� P)� PA� b� = !KyF� .L��
P~8� Y(28�� ��<)� �/ Ps2j�� ��_ �� ��2)� G�K���3 2#� ` ,�,�(�@� C �&%a �� �� � ���� 2pAV� �8#� G�e Y��� x����� rA_ !e �/ l�k� x1k�
PA"#�� � _�À23* r��e Q<;��s Y ��%�� 1�"�Crick Francis �.5= [y�K�
��DNA ÝL�� '3�N JÚ �? Ps2j��3 v<3 Y�@� 2��� 4_��3 >�y; G/ �e §��� ��K� P��p�N�� ��hÄ $/�ÉÄ � !Ke G�K�� ��1O �2� G/ ��
��:�_hÄ $/¼Ä ��o �3 �� (�K�� 7;�/ G/ �� v<3 Y�@� 4_��3 C �L? ,�e Q<;��s �Z#� P��, �� C� ,�� _�}�� �%(�R r� :" �A< F�� ,[j � !=�e
>�)� >�y; G/ ,'M V� �� -�Ì3 1�RF/ G/ �M�N/ ,G�� � � 9��V� EA#��3
i1g The philosophical question that has not been answered in origin-of-life
studies is this: How can a universe of mindless matter produce beings with intrinsic ends, self-replication capabilities, and 'coded chemistry'? Here we are not dealing with biology, but an entirely different category of problem".
There is a God: How the World's Most Notorious Atheist Changed
His Mind, New York: Harper One, p. 124.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
>5:#�"ghi* ��|N r ?O lI 5�R 2R �;/� 23� E�\; G/ !8R� �K� : ��|? !e Y"3 [e
?'A�� «�23��� !a2��� J�=�3 E,#MR �� E?��)I �� ��2pAV� �+A#�� إجابة هذا السؤال إلى مقالنا التالي بمشيئة اهللا تعالىستبقى
i1g "If a particular amino acid sequence was selected by chance, how rare an
event would this be? "This is an easy exercise in combinatorials. Suppose the chain is about two hundred amino acids long; this is, if anything rather less than the average length of proteins of all types. Since we have just twenty possibilities at each place, the number of possibilities is twenty multiplied by itself some two hundred times. This is conveniently written 20200 and is approximately equal to 10260, that is, a one followed by 260 zeros * " Moreover, we have only considered a polypeptide chain of rather modest length. Had we considered longer ones as well, the figure would have been even more immense. The great majority of sequences can never have been synthesized at all, at any time." pp. 51-52*
"An honest man, armed with all the knowledge available to us now, could only state that in some sense, the origin of life appears at the moment to be almost a miracle, so many are the conditions which would have had to have been satisfied to get it going*" Life Itself: Its Origin and Nature, P.88.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A @bîß��ãbjÛa@òîvycPanspermia@ @
�� E?��)I �� ��A@ ��L�� ��2pAV� �+A#�� �� '3�<�� ��"V� C � H2B ��_ �� -1}� .�8s ,>�)� >�y; PW) 'A�� «�23��� !a2��� J�=�3 E,#MR
?E?��)I �� ��|? Y"3 G/ �V�q �L¥ ��k� G/ �V�q� ,�����<V� !e �� �?�@ Y&�� !a2���
?��)�� ��|? È�<�N� [e ,9�c��� �.5= ��y�e� t2�/ ��k� �R�� CDNA G�"�� �� <¹ C 5:#V�
b� ©� PM��a ��y�e�� ,¸�V�Genome �� Y� �(�e !e PAa !a���� P8e�V� >2"#V� PM��� rA_ ,x1k� �=� P#=�� P3Ú P;�;�"�� P:� V� P��wA
��2pA6A� * P:� � P��w� P8e�� >2"#� ��";�; P ©� PM��\A� L� _ �I ]<� >�)� Gk
�H|V� P�{ �� P��� �Hk� P�js ,���? � "� �� P��� �,A#· �L?� Ps��&� P "V�* �)�s -«�� ���? �� � 'R� b�W 3 ^<_ >= PM��a ���I ]B , ��,@ P
�28�� L � v8U�� 7,� 63! F*����^ F*�*D� Ft���� l`�� ³y F_ Y,s 2"#���� v8U�� C P��� 4;��R
.�|� EK²� 'R� G�;�R 's� E6j� �,66{ 2R 1��V� 1���1 �/ S8M�� 1�;�<s 2R Ñ��� 1�;�N G/ ��"; ¿"#�� $�"�� Q� 3� ,�A=/ �� � F{ .L�� x�w�� P;�"_ b2\�<� Ñ���s �2²� EK²� 'R� Y�@� G�;�R .�|� E6j� �66{
R��V� 2�2p�� P��� �2j��3 �echo location * Pc�s lI >2�%V� �Mc� 2pAV� !,� � Y��� PR%6#�� ���2p��� mL? b��/
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Pc�s ��|? ' ��� 2"s ,�� ��? E?��)I E& ]"3/ G�K� �� J��/� S:�/ �� ��}<;�8��Panspermia }<;�8�����= >�)� G/ E�5_ Pc�s Y? �� lI �
=1�� ��U��� �� x1k�Y! PA"#�� Ps�\<�� 2� lI !j� Y"M �� C�#� !Aa �� !6�y_ Pc���� mL?� !
,PWpA�� 7�� ¿"� x�s ��� ��}<;�8�� G/ EA#; G/ � A� P��28�� C �K� P6(�R C [ j_ �L�� ,§%q�� �� 2��� .2{1 �/ Y6A� 2 N �� !jB `�
P"")� ^� P�(�5�� b�A#��pseudo-science 7��P��<��ghi * }� �eL; �;��� P�\<�� x����� mL? C Y"M V� !A� ���B !8R �K�
�c��A� ����� : ����u 43 YK���k� Y�%��� ��NBen Stein 2pAV� 5 e��� �1�y��1 ^,y��Richard Dawkins ��#;�� ��� G�e �OI +� G/ ��
Fk� P)� PA� !{/ G�K� �+6j_ l� �eO � �s��� �� (�e �#3 !6� ��UFO – Y=1�� ��U��� C P� �� (�e− �� ��� � �;/ 5 e��� 1�"s ,'pN G�� C
2#_ ��I !3 ,r�O � 6�− ���R 2� ��− ��3 >��2=b+�? !
2· ` �L& 43 P��_ P��Ms� P(�"A�3 5 e��� J��= �� S Ë"� G/ �I ����u �%(�R: " �;�� � �? GOI +;I� ,����6� YeL�� E6j��� >�Ks ��8R �� m2 �Z#� �2�2B '��� lI �,�8<; �� x� !" g�i*
PeO �� (�e x�Zs� GI x1k� �� >�)� ��y;/�� �L? , ���� x�Zs
i1g http://www.ideacenter.org/contentmgr/showdetails.php/id/849. i2g http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9M_ZF8r5e7w.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�%<A<_Y,� � � s �LK?� ?PeL�� �� (�K�� rA_ 'Aa .L�� � Æ6* �� S· ����|<��!
x�Zs� S��j� [e EH GI !3 ,Y �2�� J��©� �� S#Æ� G/ �L,e �"N� _� P"M � �de/ Y �2�� J��©� �+�� rA�6�� ,�<�; �� � �A";� ���8�� − ± ��
$2"FV�−x Á1�#V� b2� 2 �<� rA�6�� ,− rA_ �� (�K�� rA_ � � nZ_ ` �� r�L3 �,��R ]8dF_ Y��� ,PU��#�� ���2�� − �de/ Y �2�� J��©� ��U�/ , P;%"�
!<A<���s ,�%"� !p�<� �? .L��� �Aa�23 Y(��%�� !<A<��� ��=� b2#� .23k� '���3 ��"A� >��#�� �/ �3 EA<�A� �s��� Pc�s �MU_ Y(��%��
G�KV�� G��5�� ��2� �� !"�<V� *
��}<;�8�� P:�F/ 1�, _ 4���)� ��Ae C�* ��#<� �3 ��2��� �3/ ��"� :" F� Pc�s YeO E6j �� >�)� �y;/ ,x1k�
�_�O 2� C ��3��= Q� �L?, lI !(�<�� ����� .L�� C�#V� SAMV� ��=1I �? +;I�P�8�� J��= lI � A{�� � Y(�� � !<A<_ ��=1� �� P=1� !
l�Fk� PA#�� ��8HI lI '��M�� C ��c/ G/ �I P"")� C �L¥ 2pAFV� !#s +sPA����� − �� − ,� �c�Zs� ��s�,��� �A#� �� �(��"�� �� �%"#�� 2· � PMN� -PY���− 2#3 �� ���− �%{/ �?��=�3 !
��� �;I ,����5�I �� ��R %3 ��� lI Y �2�� [AK��� �� J��&� � K�2�2©� >2�%V� ��� �s���!" ghi
ihg 4#8M�� ��s��a [yK� ��2��V� P�o ,��#<� �3� ��2��� �3/, EA<� b���� 1�� ,� A�  ɽ*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
PM" �� mL? C � �U�/ ��"�� :" �+A<� �� GI EH 'A� t2� �� � _�M# F�>�)� �/ G�KA� �����N ��k�; �= rA_ 'A� P��W � G/�� Q��� 3 � 4;��R
��"F� [Ks ,P6�� P;�e: IAa�� E? ��L�� ��3�w�� r~��/ G� rA_ PA� C G/� 4;��"��� Q��� �� rA_ fK3 ����R ,�& 4#c�a� Q��� ��� �;2 � ��2=
? >��"ghi* �28� �K�lI �MU� ��)�� G/!8"�� �L? �� ��c��3 EA<��� ; ��k
��2�� !3�"� C P���V� >2����!
����=�� ^� G�K; �� lI PAKy6A� !��_ v"s Y? ��c���� mL? GI r�O �� ��k� 7,�;��!
lI ¦��B� ,P��wA� Py?2� PA6� Y? ��eL�� �L¥ E6j� «�23I PA6� GI EH? P{�a 4;��R mL? ��cZs� ��L�� G/ [y�K; +31 �����3� ,��ak� Y
FN ��c���� ��ËA� ��;�e �� �¤ ^dK3 EW�/ P(�1��� ����5�´3 �� ����� G�¥�:>�K��� rA_ �� *��c���� mL¥ ��"6� �de/� ��/ P(�1� �� >�Ma !"� ; � ;I!
r��e Q<;��s G/ S:#�� ���Francis Crick �� [y�K�DNA �3��e C 1�"�" ���O >�)�Life Itself" � >�y; G/ �� x1k� �� >� �(�"A_ !p�<� 1�"�� !��? 2��s ���� Q�; lI �:A� �,s 2pA� �a�� �;/ +3� ,�
���5�I !60 .L�� ��Ku�� �L? �� 5?�= ¦�¨ ��}<;�8�� Pc�s G/
ihg  '3�<�� 12jV� ÉÉ*
_…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P"�5s���−P �� P_�?� P(�1���−ghi * mL? 2 � ��"_1�� PUR lI !��; G/ � 3 �A0 PM" ��"1�M���" �� �,c�#;�
,��)��3 4�p�AV� ��M��w�� ��}<;�8�� Ps�\N � �8H/ G/ 2#3 ,EA#�� PAj"� ��"_1�� P6e�² ®�_�–1�M���− ��5 _ ��"V� C � AR +e � ;´s �I� ,Ej� �� �� �
¿"#�� �� Y"M V� �� Q� '3�<�� [��\6A� v8U � `� 1�M��� C ���:�; G/ mL? � �A�1 C Ee�pF N� ,!(�"� P��"� n�_ b2� J�3 �� �L? }�#; �K� ,��y ��
"1�M���" ��L�� �� �,A#= �,���/ 1�jR G/ b/ m��"3 .2��/ �W � EA#�� ��R lIG�2�À �!
...فإلى الرحلة مع مقاالتنا القادمة إن شاء اهللا
i1g Crick, F. H. C. and Orgel, L. E., 1973, Icarus, 19, 341.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A ë@‰ìĐnÛaòîÔîÔ§a@„‹a�Ûa@ @
ò߆ÔßZ@ @ G�K_ � 2R ����y �k P��#�� P8< �� P��W; G/ ��2pAV� 2�k ]AR �OI
�P{�a Ppp{, r�%K� ^#� �� 2pAV� G´s ,EK�� P��W; �� 's���_ � ��/� 1�M��� P��W � x�#�_ G/ ��/ ,P��#�� P8< �� >�R 2e|� �/ �A� § Ý2jF� 2R� � ��+�?� PR2� �<�_� m2#"� [���� [�^N �,���N 2pAV� G´s 2"; 7;��3 2pAV� b��/
��3 n�M6� EH ,��2�2u § ��#_� 9�y_1�3 J�j�� � � ��1���� E(��y�� �� -!3 C rKy���3 rA_ r��2"� G�K_ 2R� ,Y6A#�� n���<V 2" ��� [\<����
+K 3 1��)� P��� 1�M��� Pp{! �A� 2"# � �� §�/ Q6� 2pAV� �2� ^dK3 EA#�� ��2� ��:�� ��k� GI
�?� �/ ,�8AR :���B �� -!AB G�� ��)�� ���2"� �6:3 �;+�I! �/�� �2��� ���R 1�M��� Pp{ Y? ���2"V� mL? 2 !
�=� �� P)� �� (�K��s ,P#8���3 m��)I ]M"N/ 1�M��� ]M"N/ �OI ];�s���H !�23 �� 1�M��� ��I� ��8V� 'A� ��I �?12j� x1k� *
76<_ �8�� �� -P�/ $��� -b�R >2"#� ��8� 2"; �? 1�M��� 2" s �L��"��2pAV�"*
� 4�� ¦�1�k�s ,r�O �� � � de �6<; � � ;´s $�w�� Y,�y� � +3 EA#�� ®�¦�1�k� ���_ �� � �1��; �L�� ,$�w�� .�"� �V �I ���F_ �!
®�s '< �� �� ¦�¯ 2R E, � ��j;�� ��p�� G/ ���0 � Æ� �#3 �K�
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��|? ��#� [e �R�� � �� ,�,#R�� � �� e �� ¦�1�k� !a�� �� S(�:#3E?��)I �� >2�%V�, -�� {�3 ��ak�� P ��� 43 E?��)I G�©�#� E�/ [e�
��©�#V� ��, m5:�� �c�63 E,A� 73��s! .1�/%�� 2pAV� G�e '< �� �� ¦��� ������ .L�� PA� �� G/ E,V�
G��;�� !K��� ^,y��Michael John Denton* C >�1��e2�� �� !j� ,^,u ��M��3 P��� ��6e `�� G��;�� !K����
G2 A3 PKAV� PAK�� �� P��)� ��6K��King's College London È��_�>^de ��#��= C �� ©�� P��)� ��6K�� C �p8A�*
.1�/ � 2pA� ±\u �? G��;�� !K���� gagnostici ghi* P�/ C P��W; !#���3 1�M��� G/ PA{���V� t�p3k� �%a �� �� 48_ 2R� !
�,uk� �3��e �c�3 b�"s :"1�M��� : P�/ C P��W;Evolution: A Theory
in Crisis"* G/ �L? �3��e C G��;�� }����P��W; 1�M��� C �,#c� �?���� �8u/ b�#M��3
.L�� ` �U � S<ps, +Ý;I� ` ¶8MF� �%{/ ����� ���aà� �Ae/ ��� > ��"��3! g�i
i1g Denton describes himself as an agnostic, and his book was released by a
secular publishing house.
Evolution in the Antipodes: Charles Darwin and Australia, Tom
Frame, p.291* i2g Denton, M. (1985) Evolution: A Theory in Crisis, Adler & Adler =
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
>�)� ��Ku/ G´s G��;�� S<p8s �A#s ��#_ P ��1�2�� �,�j_ +e Î��3 �� � P#N�u ����� ,PR%6� P""� ���:s�)great divisions( ghi .
E,·��_ !d� >2�2©� P ��1�2�� >��� �� ¦��� �� PA� G��;�� [\<F�� �3�y�A���"s 1�M��� t�2� �� P�%#e P)� �� (�K�� 43 Y~�5©� Y ©�:
" 2 Æ# F� ���k� �� «�; !e GI−Y~�5©� ���<V� ��− v8_�� ^�� ��2��� ��2��s��MN�3 * ��~�5©� �5:� 2"s EÆH ��� −���:p�V� G�u ���u − E�2"_ ��
�M��� >��� �� ���k� �+A� E, � �p8� ��L�� ��MN��� �#s ;!��q -�� L � 1 -§�1 �/ Y(�23 �(�e �/ ��/ nZy� 2= �? �(�e 2=�� � ,Y~�5©� ���<V�
�(�3�R�3 �P;1�"� *** 7�+��� _���D� y*1(1� �`� ��9 �1 %�� c �4 (j�� $�?� p���*1� �� ¢��^ y3^, v0 Z�3^ ;� (A�1 ;�z�1� �t�1� �?# �?! / �5�#
£C \�"g�i*
P{%a� ];�e +e ]"3 P ��1�2�� G/ �3��e C G��;�� !K��� ��I Y,� � �� ./ �� >2#3� '(�")�3 ��8� E�� G�� �� P 6� Pc�s ��� ���1�� ]R�
Y"H�_ !��g i * G/ � ? �eLF� �� S:� ��� : G�<;�= SAsPhillip E. Johnson �;1����e P#��:3 G�;�"�� O��N/–YeL�� E6j��� PN12V Y����� Jk�� − G�e =
g ,S_�K�� 1�� ,>�)� E6j_ J��e P�2"� ��Ãi i1g ibid,. i2g Theory in Crisis, p.290-291. i3g Theory in Crisis, p.77.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
J��K� ��(��R �H/ �� ��)�� n�_ � K� ,� �2pA�"1�M��� :P�/ C P��W;"ghi * � �U�/ Y,3 !K���Michael J. Behe YK���k� P��)� ��6K�� `��
)� ��6K�� O��N/� ,�,uk� .�,� P#��:3 P��Lehigh University C 2#3 PAK��3 1�M���� ��)�� �� ��B � K� 1�M�A� � �" �#� � �2pA� G�e ,�;��A< 3
J��K�� Q�; /�R G/"1�M��� :P�/ C P��W;"g�i * ^,y�� �3��e P"�� -PA��� C Y,3 �c� EH :" ��Nk� ���1�� §�2 {
Darwin's Black Box "g i *
�28� +e P��W A� 4(�� V� !8ÁR � Á� Q� 1�M��� �� ��8V� b�:&� GOI– +e�>2�%V� E�5�− � �U�/ �,KA ÁN C 46W� V� !8ÁR � Á� +;I�*
��"�.1�M��� �1���I ¿��� Edward O. Wiley G/ �ao �� ]A{� ��I P��W �� G�y3 «��;k� 1�,@– «���;��speciation – ¿� �� :"2"� ]AÁ� FR mL? PA6#�� −./ :«���;�� − ,�dp3 ')�� ËG/ Æ��KuI �� �? ,«� �� ��KuI� [e ��,@ ,«��;k� G�2#3 �� !)�"gÅi*
i1g Berkeley’s Radical: An Interview with Phillip E. Johnson, Touchstone
Magazine, 2002. i2gThe Evolution of a Skeptic: An Interview with Dr. Michael Behe,
biochemist and author of recent best-seller, Darwin's Black Box, 1996. i3ghttp://www.amazon.com/Darwins-Black-Box-Biochemical-
Challenge/dp/0743290313. i4g Wiley, E.O. (1992) the Evolutionary Species Concept Reconsidered, p.79 =
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P ��1�2�� !{/� P��W �� b��R� 1�M��� >26� Y#8M�� J�\�;�� ��/ PKN%K��>2�2©� P ��1�2���, Y8��:��� EA#�� >�(�� P��<�� 7�� !a2� EAs
.2{��� EA#�� ��, P=���e1/ �� 6� +;I�– P�1���/− �de/ � * b�A�� ^,y�� YK���k� P;�K<�� PH�1���� P�1�M��� �=���8�� `�� ��"�
���s��3 Provine :"J�\�;�� Y#8M�� � !6#� �� ./ �� *%s �? FS\� � ���j� �� �/ ,m2c �� �? ,�,"� �� ,��dKF� �� ,'A¯ �� ,� �2#� �� ,! �KyF�
�� ,! �wy� �� ,��"� �� ,Y�Mj� �� °s�0 �� �� ,�� �� ,�Æs2� �� [�K� *J�\�;�� Y#8M�� � Fb�"� �Ì3"ghi*
� �,�I !{ ��_ Y��� P:� �� Q�; Y?� á4Æ ��1�2� �� Æ2pAV� .^= ���s 1Jerry Fodor
�6N��� ¿_�3 Y �1�V�3 Massimo Piattelli-Palmarini , ��` �2· �23� �� P~M� ���1�� ��N/1, ��Ë {� C ]s�� b�,�� J�\�;�� Y#8M��
+¥��e :"��k� .L�� �Ma/ �s ���1�� What Darwin Got Wrong" *G�e� �¤ �1 �2{ �3 +¥��e ¿� �� :"�L? Q� ��3��e �� ,�� �� �� E6j���
,YeL�� �� �� 'A� *Q� ��/� �� �;2�/ �T1��� C -�� �� r�O *2"� � ��_1� �;/ �� �<p�<V� G/ �c�; �L? L � P��28��; Gk � �/1 Õ�Nk� +s ®�N �"� G�3
= gJ��e P�2"� ��  ,S_�K�� 1�� ,>�)� E6j_Çi
i1g Provine, W.B. (2001) the Origins of Theoretical Population Genetics,
p.199.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
n� ? �Ma �� − +31� �Ma P=12� PA_�R − C P��W; J�\�;�� Y#8M��"ghi *
2{���� .�p���� 2" A� �%3�R �_��� 2 � 7�� � �1�j_ 1�M��� 7"8� �LK?� �� � ��� 3 � � J�ZR�� � A� � �6� � �1�:² � ��: Á� �/ �� �� Q�� C >2�%V� P8�1
� � J�ZR�� b2�! ��;��� � �jj\�� � �2"; P���"�� ���"V� C �� ��u GI x�# N r�O !=/ ���
� b/ 26jN !? �� � EA#�� PAj"63 1�M�A�!
���2�N��� Pc�Zs�� �� 6\��� ��p�� b/ EA#�� ^��#63 v8U N !? [(� EA� lI Pc�s �� SA" s P��(�2��Pseudo-Science?
i1g Fodor, J. & Piattelli Palmarini, M. (2011) What Darwin Got Wrong,
p.15 i  ,S_�K�� 1�� ,>�)� E6j_ J��e P�2"� ��hÄ g*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A åÔn½a@Éä–Ûa@ @
� j�� �/ Y&�� 'A� G/ � ��a|� P��)� ��6K��� �=���8�� �+A#� 48_J�w�� �6<� +e �/ �"�V� �8��� m2{1 �K6� YeL�� E6j����, �8{/ r�L3�
EA#�� �� � ��5=! ghi m�Ma ��8HI P���²� �"�V� � j�� P��/ �� ��2pAV� !#s >�1�, �;/ Y #_
Y6A#�� E��"�A� �c�ag�i * P6 �K F² P6A� PR1� 4<¹ �� �de/ ��,@ � ��a|��peer-reviewed
Y&�� 'A�� �"�V� � j�� �� t2p�_–YeL�� E6j���− ,P)� �� (�K�� C`�#�� C P6A#�� �%:V� }e/ C §�1�k� ��F; 2R�g i *
P#8M�� PA� ����_ 2R�Nature � 3 §%q�� �� �,uk� P6A#�� PA:V�§�1�k� mL? �� ��gÅi *
�?��=� ]�8H/� Y8��:���� .2{��� EA#�� 5� ]Aa� �"�V� � j�� PU"s
ihg >1�8�"�"�V� � j��" >1�8� �� l�/"YeL�� E6j���" ����0�� �� �� w�N� �,s� �o�R �,A{/ Gk �p���� T�p��� >1�Ú �� �,A� S_Z� ��� ,Y8 =k� ^8#�A� PAKyV� g �� .�,y�� �� 28�
 ,S_�K�� 1�� ,>�)� E6j_ J��e P�2"�h�*i i�g ./ :�W F� ,P6A� P��W; �8j_ �M� !8"_ P��W; :"� �M\A� PA3�"�� b�,�Falsifiability
�3�3 �1�e �,uk� b�A#�� ��<As 2 �Karl Popper."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability
i3g http://www.evolutionnews.org/2012/02/intelligent_des056221.html* i4g http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v431/n7005/full/431114a.html*
_…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
>�"3�* ��/ �� �����<V� P6A#��� P{�j�a��� � j�� t�p3/ � �U�/ ]"u 2"s �"�V�–YeL�� E6j���− ,�,"��q P)� �� (�K�� C/23� �+A� t�p3k� C QN�_ �3�\V� PN ��KV� t�p3k ,�"�V� � j�� 2{1%d� :QN/ $%���
Qe/ Douglas Axe− ^8a �=���8�� P~�5©� ��"3�N C P#��= ¦2�}��e− 2,#V� Y=���8�� Biologic Instituteghi *
QN/� ��3�1 G�<e�= Qe1�� Robert J. Marks II − 1�<s��3 PN2 ? SN��)� ��3�,K��� ^,y�� P#��:3 1�A��3 Baylor University −
}�¨ P_���A#V� P�1�M��� gThe Evolutionary Informatics Labi g�i*
�8{/��2� -!e �� ��#��= !��;1�e Cornell University �1��;��N� Stanford University �¿e^3 University of
California, Berkeley ��#6� P3%q ��#_ .��� 3 IDEA gE6j��� YeL�� 1L)�� �� 1�M��� iY��� E�2_ 2{1 �� (�K�� C �"�V� Y&�� � j��
P)�g i * ��W _ ��~&� P<�12��� �� ���� ������� Ee�pV�� lI �K���/ C P;�K�I
i1g www.biologicinstitute.org* i2g www.evoinfo.org* i3ghttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligent_Design_and_Evolution_Awaren
ess_Center*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
EA#_ �"�V� � j�� C $1�2V� P��K)� �6c �?� V� P6A#��ghi * ���5_ P6A� >�R +;I� S<ps P �� ���� 2#� ` �"�V� Y&�� � j��s
b�� !e �?2?��y3 � ���c����Ç��Æ���Å��Ä��Ã��Â��Á���À�Ó��Ò�����������Ñ��Ð��Ï��Î��Í��Ì���ËÊ��É��È�g�i*
P""� !3 2{���� S��:��� �� >��� ���� 'A� C Y&�� G�"_�� 2#� `�8��� !��#V� C PAH�� P=���8�� t�p����������������������g i*
Y?� P��? P"") !{���� !=/ �� 1�M��� 2"; .2� 43 �+AK�� mL¥ b2"�; �O´s ,§�1�k� ���� «L©� ���� �OI� «���� v"N !{k� v"N �OI �;/ ]8H
��2{1 Y&�� G�"_�� x���A� G�K� �� ,Y(��y#�� 1�M�A� G�K� %s ������?2��_ �� !"� [#U� � Y��� �� 6\���� �� ,K*
�� P)� �� (�K�� C �"�V� Y&�� � j�� 2{�� t�p8�� P��23 ];�e 2R� Y,3 !K��� YK���k� P��)� ��6K�� `�� 2�Michael Behe ���R �� H/
.�,� P#��= C �H�p3�3Lehigh University �;��A< 3 C* .^�K8�� T�<�� C Í?2V� 2"#��� �_�N�1� �%a Y,3 2{1 ��
Flagellum Y�(�� �� G�K�� P��wA� 'R2�� .^�K8�� T�<�� �L? G/ [e� ,
ihg !3 G�=gJon. A. Buell i$��� §%ak�� �K��� 5e�� Q(1− 1�� ,>�)� E6j_ ,$�<K_
� ,S_�K�hÉ* i�g P��� ,]Ajs >1�N :g½ i i g P��� ,!6 �� >1�N :g¼¼i
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�As ,�?2�/ 7��a� �/ �a�� G�K� �?2�/ ��= �OI ,2"#��� ¾��3 4_��3 �.5=� �,W_PAK��3 .^�K8�� T�<�� P��W !
1��R �?� ,P"R2�� C Pe�� ��o >�� �2#63 .^�K8�� T�<�� n�p��� 1�_�V� E:�� ,P;�d�� �� �5= [�/ 4#31/ �� �5= C ��e�� m��� QK� �� P�� { G�<;�� �M�<� `� ,P{�8�� �� [�/ P(�� �� 2��� �? T�<A� n�pFV�
Z"� G/ �� �6:p3 1�_�� ¦^3 �1��? �s� .L�� 2)� lI ,�_���e �� JHoward Berg T�<�� G/ 1�8��� lI �1�s1�? P#��:3 �=���8�� `��
Ps2j��3 T�<�� �L? >�y; J�<p3 G�c����� b�R� ,G�K�� C P�o ��e/ .^�K8�� C 2��� lI !j_ P�+���� G/ ��2=�shÄ $/hhÃÄ �Ae G�K�� ��1O G/ ��
�:�_ � �hÄ $/¼Ä >1Oghi * ����V� 2"#��� P��W � �� � .^�K8�� T�<�� C 2"#��� �� ������ «+�=� GI
SC specified complexity �"�V� � j�� �+j3 �� Y?�!
PU� !a�� E�5;I �� PAa !a�� PU� �� Y)� �(�K�� C PAa �A� �� G���e �� E�5;I !a�� 4_��3 ��Codon a�� !a�� >1O �� 4_��3 !
n1��e �� G���equark ����� 2"#_ �� r�O �� �� �A¯ � ,>1O !a��SC�A6e�3 ��=��� P6N ��I ,*
������¨��§��¦��¥� � � � � �¤�� £¢��¡�����~��}��|��{
i1g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a_5FToP_mMY*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
©�ghi* !d� ��N�1� �%a 2"#��� P��� ��a/ P��� P6W;/ Y,3 !K��� 2{1 2R� :
P�o" vA�–�d� − b2��" G�<;�� rAÀ P��� mL? G�23 Y����– bk�� 4 ©�– �_��� 1�s!
�8e�� ���� b2\�<_ ���Ma �� �� P��� mL? 26�#_�� ����� 2�2u G�K� C b2�� �d\�� G/ !"#� %s G�KV�� G��5��3 v8_�_ P��� mL? � �U�/ ,2"#���
M�� �� �a��� ]R� C �/ �5 �� G�K� ^� Y#8–I 2"#_ �L?�P��� �� C�c* P���2�� P��k�� 28K�� 43 ��º� .1�s E�� �� ¦��B P��� mL? � �U�/
¶V�� EW#�� «�\;�* l�k� PWpA�� L � �"�V� � j�� PA��� lI !j; � ? � ;I!
�� 2���R G/ ��"�� PAs�; ���DNA .L�� 4_�}�� �� 3 >��u !6B Y����� T�<�� !KyF� ,Y)� �(�K�� C P��� P��W � !e� vA:��� !����� .^�K8
§��� �,A6B Y��� ����y��� �,8_��_� �,(� 3 C ����� 2"#_ 2���"�� mL? !6B��wA�� �� �s�#; �� !e 2"#_!
G�K�� ���;�3 C G���N �1�e 1�"�Cosmos �� >2��� P��N1 G/ ^,y�� ����V� 2"#��� P��W �SC �I !j_ >�� ��=�3 �&%a �� b5: N ��U��� �� �
� #� !{����� ���B! g�i
ihg P��� ,!p �� >1�N :gh i i2g Cosmos, Video Source*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
?� 8e�e C >��=�V� �?��W�� E"_ C Q��"V� Q�; b2\�<; � �O+As ����� 2"#_ Y? Y)� �(�K�� b� = !a�� >��u !e ]<�/SC ?
�� ¿"#�� $�"�� !�� P=1� Q� 3 �"�V� � j�� �� �%�� �L? Q�/ P��N1?Y=1�� ��U���
†Èi@éäß@ñõï’i@Á−@�ë@éjöbvÇ@ïènäm@ü@åÔn½a@Éä–Ûa@æg@ÝiAA@ @Y)� �(�K�� b� = !a�� ����V� 2"#��� ��/ E,� ��, v<3 4_��3 G´s
�� G�K��hÄÄ b�W 3 PA� >��; C >��y� ��\<; 2=�_ G/ 23� Y �/ �Ò �� ®�� G/ �3������ �L& �K6� .L�� ]R��� C ,P =�Z �� 2���"�� �3��_hÄ
$/h Ä � ? ��� 4_�}�� �L& ^�y��� �� 1��"�� �? v"s �?2�/ ,�ao !�23����V� 2"#��� ®��SC* �� v�� GIDNA ®���A#V� ���d��3 ����V� 2"#��� S;�= lI � �U�/ ��6�
P;�;�"���−Y)� �(�K�� !a�� 4#� G�;�R !6� EW F� − C !j����3 � pc� +e'3�N -��"�*
!"� �� >�� %3 P�o n� ? G�K_ G/ �K6� � r�Le– ��<)� P(��y�)� ��%a �� ]AKy_ .L�� x1Ô� Y(28��G��1�M��� E�5� +e >� − 2��F_
!"#��� >�)� !6B ����A#� ! ?PH�1� >��u ��/ �A6B Y��� !(�&� ®���A#V� EK�� 12j� �? +s
�� v�� �� !��#�� E�5;I v<3/ GI !3DNA �� �� �de/ �� G�K�� C !Aa t2� �/ 7��a� �/ 2��� 4_��3 !M#_ �� ,4_�}�� �� ��~�5=
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
R��� ��A<AN�� v�� !6� �� � �#8_ [R��� .L�� E�5;�� !6� [DNA ,��=� Y)� �(�KA� G�K� �� �����3�*
�� v�� !a�� � �U�/ 2=�_ E�5;�� �L? >��u G/ r�O �� J��k��DNA !e �,W_ G/ ��I ¦12��� �/ ��5�a�� �� 12R !Rk !3�R ^� 2"#_ PU"��s
�,W� � �/ �>�:s ����W V�* ��"� âb�A�� Qe��N £William Stokes Y ��1�2�� `�#�� :" ��
Se��K�� mL? !e �Ô���� ,x1k� Se�e !d� Se��K�� ��1�A� �;»�/�� ��1�A� �,A� �;�W�;�� ,P �k� x�Òk�3 �?�ao �� �� !jp; �As ,4 <
2��� 4_��3"ghi* §%q�� �� Y� �(�e v<3/� [Ks– ��%3�KV�Mycoplasma −
?Pjj\�V� �� _�}�� ��o �� .��0 ŠÐ×@ÝØÛ@�îö‰@‰†–ß@ÝÔÈÛa@ÞbàÇg@åÇ@Ý�bØnÛaë@[ò톕‰ë@òîÜÔÇ@òîšÔÛbÏ
���Ç���Æ��Å�������������Ä��Ã����Â���������Á��À�������¿��������¾��½�g�i*
i1g W. R. Bird, the Origin of Species, p.305*
i�g P��� ,rAV� >1�N :ghÄi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A Ûa�Đ�paŠÐ@ @
����M�� G/ /28� �� G��1�M��� 26�#�Mutations �� !e ^w_ 2R� ���� �ao �(�e lI Y)� �(�K��3 !"� _�! ghi
Y8��:���� Y6A#�� 2{�A� �U� G/ ��I PU��#�� ���2�� mL?, G/ ��I� §�N C !a2_��K�� � �//� ]����PA<V� !A�� [j� � Y=�� G�K� ��
���2�� mL& ���H! ما هي الطفرة؟: لكن بداية
_� �Vt1�: b� ©� '<; C ^w_Genome − �(�K��3 P{�� PH�1��� >��V�Y)� −*
P:�; Y)� �(�K�� C >2�2= [(�@� 1�,@ >��M�� �� S_Z� G/ xZ�V�� [H�K_ ��� ;PH�1��� >��V� C ^w��� �� >1��{ Pjj� �� _��3 ��3
�(�e lI ��p�� PAK��3 Y)� �(�K�� ±(�ja ^w�_ ����M�� �ao* C �� G�=���� E,8�e C G��1�M��� �6N�� .L�� ��1� <�� �? �L??P6A� P""� b/ ¿� ��1� N �L? !? PN�Nk� PAKyV� 7"8_ �K� ,E��Ú�²
�c��� ��p�; �;���! �;/ ��k� P""��� «�z �� ��"� �%a�y; ��N�^��� �� G�<;�
hÄ $/�Ä >2�2= PN�^s P�%N− P)� �� (�K�� �2� [j; ���#� ER1 �?�
i1g http://www.brooklyn.cuny.edu/bc/ahp/BioInfo/MUT/Mut.Definition.html*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
F� Y���k� �� �2=P"A� �23 L � x1− �2�2= 2��� 4_��3 ���K_ G�ghi * G�)�{ G�2�2= G� _��3 �,WF_ ` >2�2= ��%N 1�,@ ��A6� GI !3
E�� _ C !6#A�new protein-new interaction sites �20 ` �� t �8��� §%q�� ��2{1 �/ �� >2�2= S_1 1�,@orders [(��q �/classes �/
S# Fu gphylai g�i* �6N1 ��5=�� �� e �O´s ^w_ ./ P 8� �? .L�� 2��� 4_��3 1�,@ 2{1 �� �
Y)� �(�K�� C Y�@�– >��q ./ P 8�– ��a �� t2p�; �p; ���k�8s.2{���� Y8��:��� ���Z�� �� EA� �� Q�� Y6A�!
G��1�M��� �& ¦��F� [Ks Pu�y&� mL¥ ����M�� >�Ks ];�e �OI �K�–�2©� �P{�a − ?1�M��� C ��{k� !{/ �?1�8���3 P"")� �6A� m2{�; .L�� 2���� �Ì�� G/�, � � t2p�� .L���� G��1�M���>2�2= �� _�}� 2��_ Y? Y��� ����M�� Q, P�@� ����q +;I�
�� ©� �#3 P 3 C–���M_− �?2���R S_�_ C !Aa �& t20 4� ,S��w�� C �� �H|V x�#��� P:�; P =�Z ��! g i
!a�� P =�Z �� 2���"�� �2�I !�� +;I� 2�2= 4_��3 !Ky�� � � ,s
i1g Michael J. Behe, Darwin’s Black Box. i2g ibid,* i3ghttp://www.nature.com/scitable/topicpage/dna-replication-and-causes-
of-mutation-409*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
2�/ s ,�� ©�³u� �� 4_�}�� !�\ P�@��� !�\�s* �� ��M��� t�p3 1�²� Sj� P,e���� P3�3O ];�e 2R� ÁP,e���� FP3�3O ã2 Æ#F_
s ,PN�12�� mL? !dV �P6(%� �P���©�b� Â�� �¥P��,<3 �3 S�%��� �K6�* r�O lI [c/1��� >^j"�� ���� >2�� P��H�K��� ��P#3���V� *�6<� r�O !e
��=k� �� 2�2#�� �8�_� PW�%63 �+A#A�* ,J1�:��� �� 2�2#A� P,e���� P3�3O ]#Ua �����3� �� «�#u´3 �,sLR E_
����� �+A#�� �2�� ,����M�� �2#� >���5� �2= Ppc�� >�Ks� P��; ��!jB G/ �K6� Y��� ����M��ghi*
�;/ 48_ ��=k� 4�%� 2{1 2#3� �./ n� ? Q� �� C ����M�� ËG/ �� ! ,>2�2= 7� F3 'A� P,e���� P3�3O ]��R +s 7 8A� ^w_ ��� �? ����M�� �3
�%d6s ,>��=�V� �� �w{/� ���#V� �� }e/ >2#� Pp =/ ����M�� ]:�;/ Pp =k� �� P���U� P��6� ]:�;/ +e ,���#V�− !6#_ � �?�2�I G����6�
�(�KA� P�O|� Y?� − �, K� , ����; 'A� ` ��2�2= Pp =k� �� * �2��� � �U�/ ��a� F< F� ����M�� G��R �6 _ G/ S· �� �6 _ G�"N ��O
EN�3 ��#_ P��� C ,1�#y�N�� 1�#y�N�� G�"N gAntennapediai g�i* F8� S_�_ >���I ��� �I ]<� Î�<V� mL? 7�� �K� ];�e áGI� >��=�� 7
i1ghttp://www.exploratorium.edu/exhibits/mutant_flies/mutant_flies.html* i�g � ,>�)� E6j_*�� YK<86�� b�A��*� P��_ ,5A�� G�H�;�=* S_�K�� 1�� ,���ao� �<)� ��|�
¼ *
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P8��� §�M3 * , v"s��M���� P3�3O���� �� 2�2= «�; lI P,e��)�� ��B ` ::::اخلالصةاخلالصةاخلالصةاخلالصة
>���w�� P,e�s ��3�3O Pq�<83 ����M�� ]:�;/* �K� P�K_ P�5� 2���� �p; ¦��p; � >1�c ����q–��M_− �� �P?�23
���{ 2�2= 4_��3 7��¦12�� SAM�� ��k� +;I , �+W � � � w_ -Go C �%��e�2���* m1�,@ �� �%Us ^w��� �L? EW _ �� �%Us � �2��� � � w_ 2{�; ` �p;�
>2��� �PA�! >2��� >1�8� C ��k� :Û Šr×c@ü@òîÜ�Žß@òmë†y@paŠÐĐÛaAÜ*
� 6R ��� �A"� ��k� !Ap�3�, P�@� ����A#� SAM�� 2��� 4_��3 ¦��;´s�� !a�� v�� �y � ��2 #s ,>2�2=DNA � v���� �L?� 4_��3 2���3 b�"
>�:s �,@ ����A#� v�� �2j3 �p s ,�(�KA� >2�2= P�@� .�|� 2�2=�� !a��DNA P��A#� ��k�sinformation ��_ ��� G�K� G/ !8R
P =�Z; 2���"�!* A�� ���� !d� P =�Z �� 2���"��s7� #� 7M#_ Ppp{ PA� �� _ Ye Pw
23� SN� � G�K� C �"�<� �p{�,#c�� Q�; C �"�<_ P #� ��#� ��, EH7 #V� �L? !Ky_ Y��� ���)� �,#c�� �6·!
� ����A#V� �5� P;�K�I �� !�� 2=�� � �R���� C�� !a��DNA lI ��23/ >���� PR�q �����R +e� , � �� ��31�; Norbert Wiener µN|� 2�/
����A#V� P��W; :" .k �K6� � ,PR�q �/ >��� ]<� ,����A#� Y? ����A#V�
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
b��k� mL? �6�<� G/ �L¥ �Z#� � .��� S?L�"ghi * !3 P =�Z �� 2���"�� Â��_ ��� ���)� Â��_ �� PA"�<� P��A#V�s
�� P��6:63 �� 5�Z�� E�� .��� �� lI ��p�_ G/ !8R 7 #� Y? C ���)� b� ©� C P =�Z �� 2���"�� �/ PwA��DNA *
V�sP���V� ���;�K� �� PA"�<� P=���8�� EW �� C ����A# * s �� 8� P3�AMV� ����A#V� 12j� �? + Y��� >��y�� � � 2���� .L��� 7 #V�
b� ©� !a�� �?5��_ .�· ? P3�=�� E�_ ` GI .L�� ��|<�� �? �L?m2#3 �� !Ap�� 7 #� %s � �!
s -«�; �� >2�2= P=���3 P 3 ��� �� F�de/ � ? FP8"#�� ,�� P��A#� ��I4_��3 lI >��y�� mL? ��p�_ >��u >1�{ C �,W�N, 4_�}�� �L? .�|� EH
Y)� �(�K�� C �?1�,@ J�AMV� P��A#V� P��, �� C �,W�� Pjj\�� P�@�R2��� v8U�� 7,� 63P!
� �? ����A#� 2��_ �� 1��"�� ���#V� 2���� 12jV� P6K)� �P?�23V� � j��� >12"��� >��1��� >2��� P6AK3 �? .L�� �"�"'A�" ���¨� �§
ª��©�g�i! #3 >��M�� PUR !Ap�3 � 6R �O´s �?23 ��k�s Y6A#�� 2{��� �� � �2 ¦��0 �
�I �,p�� � P��A#V�� P��A#� lI'A�!
i1gNorbert Wiener, Cybernetics, p.132 i  '3�<�� 12jV�¼ g* i�g P��� ,G� �|V� >1�N :ghÅi
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��8V� 2{���� EA#�� SAR �� �"�V� � j�� P��/ ��À23 }e/ }_ � ?� ! !?k �,�����/ P��=�V� �� 6\�A�� ��"#�� C ���K� PM<�<A� !W�N �K�
���?k�!
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A ñ‰ìÐyþa@oãb×@õ†jÛa@¿@ @
>2�2©� P ��1�2�� P��W; b�"_ + 3"1�M���" Evolution P��<� �� P ��1�2�� b��R G´s ,'3�<�� ��"V� C !j����3 �& � c�#_ Y���� ����M��
PKN%K��Darwinism �����)� ��– >�:p�V� �� (�K��fossils − GI� ,�,���/� ��aFk� �:� �� Y w�<_ � 4���W �� �2�I ];�e!
2"��� s Ë�#_ ,b��� Æ2 á#3� h½Ä ����� �� �; P��W; �1�M�� ,���1�2� �� ��o �� (�K�� >�:p�V� Y��� ` � FK_ s��#�P ���1�2� *�K� ]"3 ���:��� 43
����6:V� P� j��� P<(��� ��;��pA� �PËj� �� �!V� *sL 6 G/ ��,@ P��W; ���1�� �+A�� ^s��k� C >^� �� ��/ >12 �� >2�2y�� C ^s��k�
P��"�;�� * �K6V� �� G�eE ã,�_ ��=� !�k� Æb��/ ���1�� G�3 _�,W v3����� >��"�V� ��
]R���, 4� G�e EA� ^s��k� C ����23 �A ãKy_ * C ^s��k� �+A� G/ ��Yw8 � +e �p8��3 ����"� ` ]R��� r�O*
��/ b��� 2"s F�N�]=�\ ��2�/ PA?L� �� ,^s��k� P�º� ��y�e� 2�5V� �, � §��_ � _12R �� �,� j_*
�+Ae Æ���� F�2� ^s��k� P�y�KV� �� ÁR!8 �+A� ^s��k� ���� F9�c� x1�#_ ^s��k� P�y�KV� �� �� �cZ�_ P��W; ���1�� * ËGI Æv6; ^s��k� P�y�KV� Q� ��M6; ��8 �#y�� -!Ky3 ,Y·12_ !3 �Ë;I !Ky� 2R� � P#6�� !j�_
�, 3 �����s *2R � G�K� r�O ��~=��� �;�e Q�; v6 �� .L�� m2:; 43 �� (�K�� P)� b��� * �%d6s 2=�_ F2�2#�� �� ��%N P j�k� �, K� �P�5# �
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
!Ky3 �c�� �� ,Pu�V� !dV�3� 2=�� 2�2#�� �� ���� _ ,>1L�� �K� �� ÆS#j� �� 2�/ '������ �, 3 43� ,�6"�� �6:�_� ���� ��� ��� -v6; ,2���
3 ��2 �� P ��1�2�� xZ�_ +e P=12�� �?1�,@ghi * s% 2=�� �%d� !N%N P=12�� �� ^s��k� � ����� 43 n+Nk�
��(��}��� �/ 43 [���5�� ,1�M��� !3 �,W_ ^s��k� PA��e �6 �� 5�+���� P�@���� �� ��/ -1�,@ �& C !:<�� .1���k� * F_��,W ^s��/ n+Nk� l�k�
!e ���j�� Ps��#V� n+NÔ� b��� *r�Le� F�,WF_ F[���5�� C !:<�� .1���k� Ë!e ���{ [���5�� P)� b��� *�L? v6 �� �?�@ }� !:<�� .1���k� !Ke*
s!:<�� .1���k� � Fb �2"� Ë./ -!�� �� ËG/ S# Fy�� Pc�" V� PM8_�� �� �,U#3 !���63 P�1�M_ PMN�*
�?��=� E�5F� Y��� P��"�;�� ��Kuk� GI * b��� �?�2� Ë!R/ �¤ G�e ��s��#� b��/ ���1�� * ���Mc� �%d� G��1�M���sY� � �#3 ���)� P�2A"��� >1�,yV�
��^w�A� P ��1�2�� C !:<�� ,.1���k� 1�M�e G�j)� C �K���/ P�+y�� 2#3 1�,@ 2�5V� �� ����A#V� PAj�V� ��� r�Og�i*
^� P<K� -P:� 3 ��= >��"�V� ��"A)� 1�,@´3 !�e ��5�� G�3 E�5��s
ihg � ,>�)� E6j_*�� YK<86�� b�A��*� P��_ ,5A�� G�H�;�=*�<)� ��|� S_�K�� 1�� ,���ao�ÂhÄ −hÄÅ*
i2ghttp://www.darwinismrefuted.com/natural_history_2_12.html*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P#R�� F�! ��"� P��W �� ���5��� `��– EK�� ���5s C >�1��e2�� �� !{�)��
P��W �� − Y���N�= ]�/Amit Goswami G/ :" 1�M��� P��W; 1�j;/ 1�j;/ !#�� G�e +e b��� G�A#�� G�� E,s ,G�K�� 5e�� Y? x1k� G/ P��W;
Y(�� � �2� EN�3 G���"� G�"3�<�� G�e �� ,4"3�<�� �� � Q�; G�N1+� �� �� K6�� x1k� ��� n%sk� G�1�� ��1}� ,��"A)�� ��"A)� ��
m�� �<�; ��� b��� G�A#�� P ��1�2�� 1�j;/� ,E,���W 3 r<6��� ��y�e� ./ �/ ^wF���8� �R� �X ��8�� P��W ��X P(�� � �%�2#�3 ����"� G�3 ,�,��o
G�6�5� +e ��k� G/ �� xZ�V� G�Ks ,��s�y�e�� rA_ Se���� bFk� P��W A� �� � �;/ !{�)� �K� 2�2= .1���/ [ye !e C P��W �� ��#R�_ '"p�_ G/
�2= �(��� EN1 SAM�� 2�2= [ye !e GI !3 ,P�8�� '"p�� �1�{� ,�de/ � >2 �I .1���k� [yK�� b2"� �� �Ì3 |8 ��� �� >5=�� �(��2��3 �8� P��W ��
P��W �� ��� >2�2= �(��� Ps�cI*
−G/ Y6N��� �#R�� �� �ao �c�� C ��"��− G�y3 G�� G�6A#� �6©� �2� ��#R��� ��s%a� ,P�1���k� ���:���³A�� ` ,���k� �+A� �� ^8e
�P#R��V� PMN��� ��"A)� ��o ��o �� 7�� �� � ���� P�1���k� ���:��! !�2�� �? �� GOI −P��W �� ��−?
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��?v8U��3 �_�8HI ��|? ���0 .L��"ghi* �& !{�_ Y��� P:� �� Q�; Y?� G�N�_�3 4��eColin Patterson −
�����)� �+A� 1�8e ��−PAq 1�M��� ��� C !6� .L��� , P N ����, EH��R :" C !6#�� �� � ���� ���� 2#3 Y ;/ ]�y�e�� b�� ��O ]W"�N� 2"�
� 2=/ � 1�M���Pq�8��� �� 6� ��N �A� �%�"* ��R� :" ���/ 2=�_ � ,� ���� EK#� '�_/ E#; ���:; G/ �M�<; >2��� >1
���y3"g�i*
i1g Everybody is by now familiar with the fossil gaps. Contrary to a great
number of biologists’ expectations starting with Darwin, the fossil
gaps have never filled up with the thousands upon thousands of
predicted intermediates. The vast majority of the gaps are real; about
this there is no doubt. So what do they signify? What do they prove* Neo-Darwinists, and the majority of biologists, fall into a dogmatic
worldview insisting that the fossil gaps mean nothing. They are sold
on a promissory evolutionism—faithfully believing that eventually the
gaps will fill up* http://www.amitgoswami.org/2014/11/05/darwins-mistake¬
i2g "I fully agree with your comments on the lack of direct illustration of
evolutionary transitions in my book. If I knew of any, fossil or living, I would certainly have included them. . .I will lay it on the line, There is not one such fossil for which one might make a watertight argument."
=
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
PAKy� G/ m^�� G�<��_�3 4��e �c�/ 2"� x����� �� b�"_ 1�M����� ,�de/ � PA������ �qFk�� P�<A��� �6A� �%�� rA� P��W �� ];�e � � �2��� �
2#3 -�� L � ���y3 �2©� [R���* YK< �^3 2��� ^,y�� .1�/%�� 2pAV� ��/David Berlinski G/ �^s
¸��1 b�,�� �� P�1���k� � _�M#V � �"8q 1�M��� −� �?��jj� ��− !p�<� ! G/ 2e|� �� 1�W � �� Ps��a� E?� 1�M���I ,¸��1 Y(�j�
8q� �"� ��� lI ��p�_ G/ >�"8�� 1�"_ ��2 � �;´s �� −1�M��� xZ�� +e− ��´s lI P=�p3½Ä ,P ��5�� ��^w��� �L? G�K_ G/ 23�� ,�¥ .2<= ^w_ [�/ ��U�/ 23�� N��� �� (�K�� 4�%� ��=� �� Y��� P:� ��� ,^w_ !e C PM
��#� �,s�#; 7"8� P��, �� C� PMN��� �� (�K�� mL? �� -.k ��=� � �;/��|<��:?^w��� �L& �=�V� �? � �ghi*
�� �2#�� áG/ Æ��"; ËG/ �+A� ^s��k� 2R ��Awu E,<�;/ -��,:3 P6pA� ��y�e� v3����� >��"�V� 4d��3 C ��o 9��<�� P3�N��� C� G� q/ 1�\j��
P8Aj�� gQ� v"s k�1�:� PA���� �/ 1�\j�� P M�� !3 7�� C 1�\{ 5_1��K�� Y��� ¦��B �,#M"�� lI �(�� P"R1i g�i*
�� �<; ËG/ Æ>12; ^s��k� P��"�;�� � ��#_ -±" � -!{��� C !:<�� =
—Colin Patterson, (Creation Science Foundation, Revised Quote Book,
1990)* i1g http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OMw3OzQfVvI*
i�g ١١٦مؤمن احلسن وآخرين، دار الكاتب ص.جوناثان ويلز، ترمجة د.ويليام دميبسكي ود.تصميم احلياة، د*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
,.1���k� �� lI P�AR ��,©� P��L8V� �s�y�e� * G/ «�c�V� C �� P{%a : P ��1�2�� !�2�� J�� �� Ë�I !�2�� rA� �
m^<�_ !=/ �� P��W �� ]#c� .L�� .1���k�* P��d� �� �\�; G/ �2#�� �6s ^s��k� C >1�8= ����,= �+A#�� �L3 4��
P)� �� (�K�� «� _ ^<��� P6A� P""pe 1�M���* ^,y�� .1�M��� �Z#�.� ? Y= Henry Gee � �1�² !6#� .L���
�6A� �C PA� P#8M�� Nature �U�/� ^s��k� �%a �� 1�M��� Pp{ $�? G/� �3�º �8{/, ��"s :"� F_�s2 >1���k� �� >��,u ,�?�%� �8{/� ��
!p�<V� �A6�� P���² v31 mL? ^s��k� C !N%N P��8"� �� v6; S8N P:�;�* ** �GI La/ P�%N �� ^s��k� ������ ��/ !d� �Ma� ���H�K_� � }�#� Pc�s P6A� PA3�R ,1�8�a%� +;I� �? 2e�_ �� PjR !6B Q�; P6"�� P6A#��
±j"A� Y��� ���_ !8R b� ��"ghi* @ @
i1g Henry Gee, In Search of Deep Time, p.116 i ١٣٥ص. س. م g*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A ðŒãbjà’Ûaë@æb�ã⁄a@´i@�î¦a@éib’nÛa@ @
G�<;�� 43 Y ©� �3�y���� ����M��� ^s��k� �� 1�M��� P��W; b��R ,.5;�86y���A �js P;�d��� l�k� G����<V�� ]"3� P"3�<�� ���"V� C +,s �
��"V� �L? �& ���F; Y���� .5;�86y��� G�<;�� 43 Y ©� �3�y��� P��<�! Y ©� �3�y��� P8<; G/ G��1�M��� E�5� �� JZ"_ .5;�86y��� G�<;�� 43
Ǽ %nZyV� [A<�� ��=�3 �M"� �L?�ghi * ? La|F_ �� G�<;�� 1�M_ �� �q�R !�2e P��A#V� mL����"�� ��
PeZy� -�%N/! ?Y ©� �3�y��� �L? Y #� �O�� �K�
Æ�F; P��28�� C �;�����k� ! Ýj : �� b� ©� G�K��P�2_�AK; QN/ P#31/ Nucleotides v"s Y?�C �G �T �A S = lI ��8 = 2���"�� mL? S_�Z3�
4_��3 ¦��;� ����u YM#_ * ��o �� G�K�� 43�A=�6&� 4_��3 �%d6s�� 2���"��P�2_�AK ��� � �28_ ��� ,P?� �� PR�� 4#� S_Z3 [Mj_ Y���
�L? G´s ��� v"N �/ �ao G�K� 43�A=�6&� C !Aa Y #�³u� �� * QNk�s PA� ���K_ �M�<_ ���)� �#3 �6� ��2 � PwA�� ���� !d� P�2_�AK ��
>2��, � ���� 7 #V� SA" � 2"s ��� �, � v"N ���* ;P k� P��� C ���UR t%H 9�M_ PM<8��� P�2"V� mL?
y_ E�� ��2 #s� G/ *b2\�<F�N P��A#� ^���y�Aa ¦��; ^': ا��� ا�و��
i1ghttp://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2006/10/061013104633.htm*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P"�� -PA��� C–�� 3 ±j\�� 4_��3 − �c�� G/ PA"#�� P?�28��3 Y #� �L? , ,�c��N S_�_ .�3� �c�_ [e EA#�� P��A#V� mL? P6R EA#� ^�y���
P_���A#� P��W � �? ^�y���sKnow How � P��A#V�� P���� P��W � Q�� �3 �2_ �V ^�y���s ,��=�� �? �P?�23 r�O !8R� �;�{� 1��R� `�� �I �,:� �
!Ke ��)�� >�Ks v"<F� ! ���� ��' 3� Q�� SA�/ P"��M����W V� :ا��� ا�� � j� G/ �;�V� ��
?P_�)� ?�;�j�� >2�� �� >��,u mL? ]<�/
�b��a��`��_��^��d���c�ghi! � �� �AK; 2�_G´s �����3� ,� pc�/ +e P�2 /. :ا��� ا���R �31/ 2=�_
��:�_ �3�y_ P=123 ®�N Y(��y� Â��_�½% , ���� .�s r�O �� ��� 3� �3�y��� E�5_G�8<)� C P8< �� mL? La�_ G/ 23�*
G/ '8N �� lI [c/ : .5;�86y�� b� = P8< 3 }e/hÄ % �� b� =G�<;��g�i *
�O´s �����3� � 6R S_Z3DNA 3 Â�� �� G�<;��DNA Â��
ihg P��� ,rAV� >1�N :g i
i2g C. Pellicciari, D. Formenti, e. A. Redi, and M. G. Mandfredi Romanini,
DNA Content Variability in Primates, Journal of Human Evolution
11, p.131-141*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
G´s .5;�86y��hÄ % ��DNA ,G�<;�� 2 � !3�"� �� G�K� �� .5;�86y�� 43 §���� G�K� G/ 23 � �;/ 2:; P���5�� mL? �� P��<V� lI �W �� 2 ��DNA
G�<;��� .5;�86y��hÄ % �� 7;�/ 2pe!Rk�ghi * �de/ .5;�86y��� G�<;�� b� = G/ lI ����2"��� �1�u/ � ��a|� �K�
P��)� ����2"��� �� �W �� �w3� ,E:)� P��; �� � �31�"_, J1�"��� ���2s P8< 3Ǽ % §1�s ��=�3 ��"_ ��3�<)� ];�e 4� ��,@hÄ % E:� C
r�O E& b�"�N� [Ks .5;�86y��� G�<;�� 43 b� ©�? G´s ��� !e �� �K� �3�y�3 ��"��DNA P8< 3 .5;�86y��� G�<;��
Ǽ %!AU� ��R !{k� C ; b�#�� lI ��#� �?�hǼà b�R 4� G�V��G��1�M_ ¿8N 7�2� � 2�/Sibley ]N�K�/ 7�2F� �a���Ahlquist PN�123 Ä−
ÅÄ 4_��3 G�<;�� C >��=�V� rA�3 �,�;1�"�� .5;�86y�� C, G/ �×:� �N����� G�<;�� 43 ��× ©� C �3�y��� P8<;.5;�86y Y?Ǽ*½ % �p8�� �; E_�
PA� CP�1�M_ >^,u n�L;og�i* «�"3 7�u C G�8e��� �3 �1�N� ]N�K�/� ¿8N �p3 ��8;/ ����M_ �K� 1�M��� Pp{ E& ]8d� -!�� .k 4yM#�V� �� !s��R n� ? �� ,x1k�
C ��2=�sE?�w�8� ]N�K�/� ¿8N �p3 *
ihg ٣٢مؤمن احلسن وآخرين، دار الكاتب ص.جوناثان ويلز، ترمجة د.ويليام دميبسكي ود.تصميم احلياة، د. i2g Sibley and Ahlquist, Journal of Molecular Evolution, vol. 26, pp. 99-
121*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
E�2R �;/ �p8�� �L? C ��5V� E_ 2"s� b�hǼÃ, 2#3 � ,�;� 2R �K; `��s �;/2�3� 2R 7�� �� .�8�� b� ©� «��� ��! ghi
�U�/ �� 2�5� �� G�<;�� C 2=�� �hÄÄ !a�� ��y F� 4_��3 [�/DNA PN�1� E6#_ E�� G/ !"#F� %s Ä −ÅÄ �� 4_��3hÄÄ 4_��3 [�/, EH
Ý� F1 Y��� P:� �� rA�e P��6u P:� 3 ¦��� Ʀ !8ÁR �� �×& �«�; �;I ,G��1�M����de/ � Q�2��� ��*
�%a �� ��= �p8�� �L? G/ �W �� ]�AF� �¤��� PAAR P3�� Y?� b�2\�N P3��DNA YMA\��� �/ Y :,���DNA Hybridization, P3�� Y?�
P"R� ^�– G�LA�� .5;�86y��� G�<;�� b� = �� �5= 4\<_ E�� ��� G���y� Ä−ÅÄ QNk� P8<; $�R� G�ZR��3 +& �6 FN EH 4_��3
ihg بدأ العمل يف مشروع اجلينوم البشريHuman Genome Project ومت االنتهاء منه عام ١٩٩٠عام
، ويف أثناء العمل يف املشروع ترك Francis Collinsحتت قيادة عامل البيولوجيا الشهري فرانسيس كوليرت ٢٠٠١لق اإلهلي يف جتلياا البديعه وكيفية تشفري الوظائف احليوية مبنتهى فرانسيس كوليرت اإلحلاد بعد أن تأمل منظومة اخل
.الضبط والدقةhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Genome_Project
.of God The Languageويف مرحلة الحقة وضع فرانسيس كوليرت كتابه لغة اإلله مت االنتهاء من مشروع اجلينوم بعد أن ٢٠٠١يف األخبار عام Gene Myersالعامل الشهري مايرز خرج وقد
ـ افيزيقيـا اليت ختترق العلم وعن مثة خالق البد منوحتدث عن امليت البشري جريدة سان ا ونشرتوجوده حتم : صبيحة ذلك اليوم حتت عنوان San Francisco Chronicle فرنسيسكو كرونيكل
Human Genome Map Has Scientists Talking About the Divine ..!!علماء خريطة اجلينات البشرية يتحدثون عن اخلالق
http://www.sfgate.com/business/article/Human-Genome-Map-Has-Scientists-Talking-About-the-2950445.php
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��P�2_�AK P=��5�V� −, b�R 2R�/Í�1�N 7�2�� �+A#�� 2� Sarich3�Q�; �� P3�:��� Q�; b�2\�N G�V�#�� �¥ b�R Y��� �� _�}��
�2:A� >^d� E,H�p3/ PR�2j� G/ [y�e��s , �¾��8� ��;�8�� -2� lI �,s ^8e, ^dK3 r�O �� !R/ �3�y��� P8<;�ghi *
PU��#�� ���2��� �� ;+d�� C ��= +� �W �� �w3� �À��_ �K_ ` Y���12"3 PR� PAKy6s ;r�O !e �� �W �� �w3 ,�? 2���"�� Â��_ PN�1�
��P�2_�AK ,P��wA� ^<� ��/ >2��R ��1�A� PH%H �� �de/ �?�2� ¾A8� Y���� b� ©� t�p3/ PA� ]�{� 2R�Genome Research P6 �KpV� P6A#��
�� �p8�� �8y� �? .5;�86y��3 Â�� r�L3 G�<;�� b� = P;1�"� G/ PR���V�Í"�� �� -b��e/ C >�3Ig�i *
� !j_ .5;�86y��� G�<;�� 43 J1�"_ P8< 3 PA:V� EA<_ �� E���� �� lIÇÉ % Q��Ǽ % Q� P�2_�AK �� 2���"�� 43 Â�Z�� G�3 �Z#_ ��/ �I
��k� C �� !e* PU"��s"����A#�" +e Y)� �(�K�� C �,W�N Pjj\�� [(�@�� >��y F�
!AR L � � A �js* C �3�y��� P��<� GI EH P�@���� P8eZ��� P�2_�AK �� 2���"�� 43
i1g Sarich et al. 1989. Cladistics 5:3-32* i2g Comparing the human and chimpanzee genomes: Searching for needles
in a haystack
http://genome.cshlp.org/content/15/12/1746.full*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�/ ��8H��3 �×,A� !�2�A� ¦��B � P#8q PÀ23 P)� ��× (�K�� Y� ��! Y(�Lw�� b�&�� P(�Lw�� PA<A<A� P�� P_�×� >1�Ú Y,s, G/ 2��� � +s
��/ �3�y��� G/ G��1�M��� �e12� Y6�� ®��, �%d6s �.5= G/ xZ� � 4_�}�� �%d� �? G�<;�� C PN�¹ �K FN ��×~�5=� P =�Z; 2���R �� G�K�� .L��
�"8�� C ]A3�e ��×~�5=� P\;1 2���R, P(�Lw�� PA<A<�� !6�K_ �� �,���<s Y)� �(�KA� E FN P3�d63 Y� �(�e !e G�KN� �"8�� �� G�<;�� 2��<� ���
�a��, Y��� J�8Nk� P��W � 1�, _� >�)� [R��_� `�#�� �¥ �� 'Aa * �3�y���s $� �� �,s�#� P6�� P(�L� >1�ÚP?�28��3 P(�Lw�� !N%<�� �+�e� �?� ,
�;�3 �2_ �� �;�j�� >2�� �� !��! � �3�y���� ���� � ���/ Q� G�<;�� �� 2�2y�.5;�86y��3 � ! G�2��� E? �K�
P=����2�/ ����2� r�O �� 5eZ��P��A#� P�2(�"� ���2"�� *s �I� P8< ¦�=2��� G�<;�� 43 �3�y���P��wA� P��� �"8q}��e P#��= �_�=/ �p8� ��¦2
University of Cambridgeghi * �U�/ �3�y_ P8<; � �� G�<;��3 Â�� b� ©� ��_+ �� G�2��nematode
� lI !jý %L?� �+�� � G/ Y #� � ý %G�2�2A� '3�M� G�<;�� 2<= ��g�i * ë@òè×bÐÛa@òibi‡ë@æb�ã⁄a@´i@éib’nÛa@òj�ãVP@NE@ @
mL? L\s P)� �� (�K�� 43 b� ©� �3�y_ C S(�:#�� �� 2�5V� ��1/ �OI�
i1g New Scientist, v. 103, 16 August 1984, p. 19* i2g Hürriyet daily, 24 February 2000*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Go C PKpUV�� Py?2V� P��A#V�: @‰dÐÛaë@æb�ã⁄a@´i@éib’nÛa@òj�ãYYA@E@ghi*
!,s ?.5;�86y�� �� 1��A� J�R/ G�<;�� >�:u �¥ v"<; G/ � K6� ,rA_ Y ©� �3�y��� P:�/ �;26��� �� � <�/
?!Ke 1�M��� ?2�5V� 2��_ !?
@óÜÇ@†íŒí@‹ì½a@pbjãë@æb�ã⁄a@´i@éib’nÛa@òj�ãUPAEg�i* �PA� C G�K���/ r�� ��N Scientific American ��P�1�M� >^,y��
}6<�� �2��ÄÄÇ Y6A#�� b2"�A� ]��K�� P<N|� �×,8��#�3 b�"_ Y������ � �& PA:V� �La/��; �<(1�?� �2#�� r�O C �: ��3 �× A#· .L�� �� �what
makes us human؟ ,��� PN�123 ��"V� P8_�e Pd��8�� ]��R�P�� ��DNA �A� 'AMF�� ��× ©� 2�/ CHAR1 -!e C .5;�86y��� G�<;�� ��
¦�=2��� ,�V� G/ ]�y�e��� !� P��DNA C [A�� ¦�=2��� .5;�86y�� 43 !{/ �� v"s 4_2��Rhh¼ �� !j� + 3 >2��R G�<;�� 43 �%�a
lI .5;�86y���h¼ >2��Rg i *
i1g http://www.nature.com /nature /journal/ v420/ n6915/ full/ 420509
a.html. i2g http://seriousfacts.com/50-of-human-dna-is-the-same-as-a-bananas/*
i g جملة Scientific American مؤسسة الكويت للتقدم العلمي تعريب ٢٠٠٩عدد ديسمرب.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P��� C rKyF� �L?�DNA P)� ��× (�K�� 43 56��� �� �_12R�P�A�\V�, G/� �� ��� �;�e �2#� � ��k��P =�Z; 2���"� �����, 7 #� Q��
/ !��� ��L� $�"� �� 9�<6��� ��L� $�"V J�R/ G�<;�� ��L� $�"� G/ � ;2��� !{/ �� �N+����, �p8�� C PpMN mL,s *
Y= .� ? ��"� �L��Henry Gee P#8M�� PA� C Y6A#�� 1�pV�Nature <� �� >^,y�� G��)�� G�<;�� 43 S<; ��=� P�� ��_ �� ��� 3
P�2_�AK �� 2���"�� ��k� G/ �� �2#� ��_�2� ���, ��"s :" C �� !e�k� ��/ �� �_�2� �/ P��K� ��� ��/ G�K_ 2R Y��� PA<V� !A�� [j� � Y=��
Ö� �> Æ2 Áu á� F� �/ �P Æ, Ý= Æ� F� - de C G�<; G��k� ��, �.k 2 �<_ � r�O ��� ��/ �I -$�N/ Y6A�"ghi*
��;��)�� G�<;�� 43 P3��"��� S< �� P��<6s 2���"�� ��_ �� ��� 3� E?� ������V��Ps��a; � lI EA#��3 �s2�� b2� lI PA=��� PN�� P=�� C �p;
Ps��� >�(��g�i* <;/ �+A� ��;�K� G/ �� ���K� G/ E,A� �+A#��� J�×*
�V� P��6� PN�1� ��:63 ��uk�e �� j_ �K6� � G�<;��s� ����
i1g Henry Gee, In Search of Deep Time, New York, The Free Press, 1999,
p.116-117* i2g John R. Durant, "The Myth of Human Evolution", New Universities
Quarterly 35*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��P�2_�AK G�KF_ Y���,�3 Â�� b� ©� �/3 PN�123 �/ P6:6©� E:� PN�12[K�� T�Ma!
�� PN�123 ��8��R �/ �6,s �K6� � G�<;��� �_��� %s �I� ,m^w3 �,�;1�"��!{��_ b2\�<� � Æ� �� b�A; Pj\y�� 2�2B C P6:6©� $�"� �/ �=���
P�(� b�A� �,AKs �8�� [ j_�Pseudo-science G/ EA#��3 �.������Z�� �� 7"8F� 7�� �?�M\��!
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A …ìÔнa@�Ì–Ûa@‰ìĐnÛa@ @
4�%� ��,@ >2�2©� «��;k� P)� �� (�K�� ��r�O C ru � *
1�M��� b��/ PAKy� P"")� mL? �U_Y ��1�2�� �V � �"8q� ^w{ -J�<p8s ,�2� G´s P ��1�2�� �cZ�_ «��;/ Y #� �?1�,@ �� �� P)� �� (�K��Pq�<83
2�2= Y� �(�e!e ��=�A� �,W� P#U3����N *mL? �& PR%� � P""� ��1�M_ r;�K31�M�A� � �Us�1 �/ �! ghi
�, � ^<� �5= ��� ��p�; ` P"")� mL? �K� m���� C �6; � ;/ � # "� �pj��*
2R� ,§%q�� �� �ao Y� �(�e lI Y� �(�e ��B 2{1 E�� EAs�eO `�� EH��©� P#��:3 ���<��3 G�� � G�oAlan H. Linton b�� �ÄÄhb P""�
��"s ��k� �L? :"� F2=�� ./ 1�y � Y6A� � Ë2�Y Æ1�M_ -«�; �� lI -«�; �ao *�EH��©� Y? !Ky�� v<3k� �� ��Ku/ >�)� ,PA"�<V� Y?� �P��d� !dV �L?
«� �� �� ��N�12�� s��5 !©� �Ä – Ä �P"R� F�K6�� F��j)� �� ���+©� �%a h¼ P��N *��%a h½Ä ����� �� §%M;� EA� EH��©� ` Ë:<� á! 1�M_
«�; Y��H�= lI «�; �ao �(���, ��W;�� b�2#;� !�2�� ��� ^w_ «��;k� C !Ky�� v<3k� �� ��Ku/ >�)� ,EH��©� �?��As ÆG�K� ��3�w�<� FG�2"s !�2��
ihg ا ما يزيد علىات احلية، وأضعاف هذه األنواع منقرضة مليون نوع من الكائن ٣يوجد على ظهر األرض حالي
حبسب الداروينية، وأضعاف أضعاف هذه األرقام املفترض أا حلقات وسيطة، حبساب هذه األعداد على زمن
.ظهورها منذ حلظة االنفجار الكبري، فإن الناتج هو كائن حي يظهر للوجود ألول مرة كل بضعة ساعات
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��� 1�M_ �� (�K�� P)� 7R1k� >�2#�� ��%�"ghi* �& !{ ��_ Y��� P:� �� Q�; ];�e mL?��V�� ���k� P�1�M��� $�A�1��
Lynn Margulis �G���N Dorion Sagan b�� C ��eO ���ÄÄ� ��¿�: " á` á�M�<; Æ����R� -!�� -��8� �� «���;�� –>2�2©� «��;k� 1�,@− ����N
G�e C 15= $���3��©� >2#8�� Archipiélago de Colón �/ C Â��R/ ��}�¨ ��}a P3�3O P,e���� �/ C ��3�N��� PN2K�V�" *� F��5� F!�2�� FEN�)�
�� 1�M��� ���"���g�i * ���1�� G�e 2"�Charles Darwin �� [j;� G�"�� P3��R L � �W�
G��5�� ,Y(�� � -!Ky3 ^w�A� �P Æ#Ýq Æ«��;k� ËG/ ^w�_ Y,s ��1�M_� ��,�;� %3 * Ë�I ËG/ ����"� ��"���� �L? �2B 2R P#6:�V� P Ë��k� ��*
s ��� �? m�;2{1 �� !K��^w_ 2����� «� �� �6c, s F>���5 ÁP8<; ��#�� .5A:;�� peppered moths '��w�� �%a >Zs >1�d�� P�� j�� �de/ �K� `
�� F��� -«� _ ��� �6c «�; �#�� �<�; 2R� , Ës�� PH�1��� PN2 &� b�A� � � �� �1�"3/ Æ>^s� EpA�� ��=�=�� ËL�/ C E#M�� �> Æ1 FO� 7 �/ ;4_�}��3 K�� ÆPu�V� ]ËA@
i1g CAlan Linton, Scant Search for the Marker, the Timer Higher
Supplement (April 20.2001) Book Section 29* - ١٥١مؤمن احلسن وآخرين، دار الكاتب ص.جوناثان ويلز، ترمجة د.ويليام دميبسكي ود.تصميم احلياة، د(
١٥٢.( i2g Lynn Margulis and Dorion Sagan, Acquiring Genomes: A Theory of the
Origins of Species, p.32 g١٥٢ص. س.مi *
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Pu�� ¦�=2��� Ë!@ =�=� �� > Æ1 ãL��� ]A@ >1O* �;/ ��k� C �� !e Æ���� ¦��;I ��_�8 �� ��;��)�� P =2V� -!Ky3 - 8e ��
�%a �%w�N� «� ��� ;YH�1��� �K� C !e ���)� L� �N� «� ��� ÐR/ 2� `� á2#� G�K���3 ��j� Á2�5V� �� Á ã w��� �,s *
P��, �� C�` á�M�<� 2�/ 23/ �� áG/ Æ]8d� ¦��;I PH�1��� PN2 &� b�A� -«� � -2���2�2= �%Us �� ¦��;I ��U�k� >2�2©� EW ��� P�2<©� P3�AMV� �� !=/
��j� 1�M��� ^8K��* P��k� !Ks -P:�; lI ^y_ >2��� : -«���;� ./ G�� 7�� �; ` Us ��/ �% ��
��1�M_ ��; G/ ���<V� ^8eghi* �%(�R E?2�/ !(�<�� 2R � ? �K� : ����U6A� ��Ze�8�� P���"� ]<�/
?P��H�©� �� (�K�� C «��;k� ^w_ �� PM<8� P��/ >1�{ P��)� J�R/ �? !3 ,1�M�A� Y�%M{�� b�,�V�3 � �1�M_ Q� �L? ��k� P""� C
PN�K�;�� lIDevolution 1�M��� lI � �Evolution , Y�s ��Ze�8�� P���"� �� :A� Y"sk� ��"�;�� �? t20 �� P��)� ����U6A�Horizontal
Gene Transfer � P���"� �� P��~<V� �� ©� ��"�;� �? �3 ��j"V� -PAa �� .�)� ��UV� 2c ��^�e�8�� -PAa lI C P#(�u P{�a Y?� ,��a/
��^�e�8��, � 4= ��"�;� � .�|� ��a/ P�^�K3 PAa lI P�^�K3 PAa �� P���"V
ihg ١٥٦- ١٥٥مؤمن احلسن وآخرين، دار الكاتب ص.جوناثان ويلز، ترمجة د.ويليام دميبسكي ود.تصميم احلياة، د
.بتصرف
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
!8R �� �,s >��=�� �K_ ` >2�2= P�j� >^ak� mL? J�<�e� lI* P��? P""� �L? lI [U; ; P���"V� �� = S<�K_ Y��� ��^�e�8�� G/ Y?�
P��)� ����UV� 2cg�/ �/P ��a/ �� = i ���j�� !K� PA��� Y? +e !W_�+<��� �,�Ajs� �,�� � P=���8��� P#8M��, ,[A�¨ �(�e lI ��p�_ ��
x�V� Q�; S8<_ Y? +e !W_ �%d� G�<;�� C 4#� x�V P88<V� ��^�e�8��sK� 2���� §���� ,n�A<�� Q�; rA<_� �_��%�� �c���/�6 �,����"� C �
�?2c P�� � �� = !6B Y��� P��)� ����U6A�ghi * �را ��� �� ؟���ذا ه� ا������ و�
�� �%a �� E�_ S��w�� C .�)� ��UV� P���"� Gk3 PpU�� �� ��5=.�)� ��UV� �,A� ��#�� � �p3 PH�1��� >��y�� r�O 2#3 ��Ze�8�� b�"_� ,
>1��:V� P��H�©� ��%� lI 1��8V� 4©� �L? !" 3 P�� V�s , �,8<�K_ Y�����KV� ��3 �� 3 Q�� ^<K_ ��A6� P:�;*
�� -�5= ./ 2"�_ ` Y��� ��%<�� /28_ .�)� ��UV� Y��¯ G/ 2#3� ]���R Y��� P�%<�� �� ��R/ �8j_ �� ,� ��2� �H�K��� C PH�1��� ����u
i1g Bjrkholm, B., I. Nagaev, O.G. Berg, D. Hughes, and D.I. Andersson.
2000. Effects of environment on compensatory mutations to
ameliorate costs of antibiotic resistance. Science 287:1479-1482* على -عهد ناصر للبحوث والعالجمبأخصائي التخدير والعناية املركزة - من مقال للدكتور هشام عزمي (
)منتدى التوحيد
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
����u �� ���5= �2"s� .�)� ��UV�* r�O �� -��d� ^a� :" ���e�1�AK�� 1�"�Chloroquine" !�M� ��UV�
��1%V�Malaria !@� ¸�V� G�"�� �� H%H C 1�"#�� �L? ���M_ E_ �� ; !e ��8��"_ ]p8{/ �� ;+d�� ��Ap3� �>�:s� ,� ���� 4<¹ PAq ���#s 1�"#��
Ê�6A� ��{� �� ��8qk� [R��s ,1�"#�� �L& P���"� �À2� ��1%V� ��%N * ]_�� �>��8� �?2#3� ^w�� ��A�M�� �,A² ]A�� 1�"#A� P���"V� ��%<��
P�%{ �de/ P\<; �K_ ` P���"V� ��%<��s GOI ;1�"#A� P���"�, ���N +;I�>^jR ->Z�� 2,yV�*
P(�3��� x���k� PA� �2{1 2R�The Journal of Infectious
Diseases �1��<e�/ �� >1��j��Oxford Journals �L¥ P{�a PN�1�G/ P:� 3 �, � ]=�a G�y�� : ]H2� ���e�1�AK�� 1�"#� b��"V� ��1%V� !�q
!a�� �� ©� 2�k PA{k� P�@�A� G�2"s ] 6U_ ��1�B� ����q ��.��#�� v6 �� �� P�%{ !R/ Y? P���"V� � � Y��� >��M��s ,��1%V�ghi *
? mL��M���� � t2B�; !a� Q�� �8d� `� «[ : : : : أضف إلى ما سبق أنأضف إلى ما سبق أنأضف إلى ما سبق أنأضف إلى ما سبق أن !a�� >2�2= PH�1� >��� �%d� ]"�Aa ����M�� mL? !d� G/ � �23/DNA ` !3
_��3� 4_��3 43 2��� v31 �R�� 7�� 'ÝA F�P�^�K8�� PA� ��y� C 4 *� � !?�c��� !{� 2� ./ lIg�i*
i1g http://jid.oxfordjournals.org/content/184/6/770.long * (2) Michael J. Behe, Darwin’s Black Box.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
%��, ::::والخالصةوالخالصةوالخالصةوالخالصة� !a�� >2�2= P 3/ PH�1��� PN2 &� ��^w_ �� F_ � !AB G/ !p�<� �����3� ;Y=���8�� 2"#��� �� ,P ©� P��A#V� 2�5_ �� P��e �À2� >2�2= «��;/ 1�,@ �� �%Us !Usk� �p; «� �� 1�M_ ����M��
2�2= [(�@�� >��y� P =�Z �� 2���"�� �� PM8U � PR%6� �(�e C �,W�N >2�2=!
Y(+ �� ���k� EA� PA� ��; 2R�Developmental Biology G/ lI 7,�;�� ���k� �+A� �� P��6� �s nZu� ���"� P�1�M��� :" C ��^w���
Y #� � �L? �K� P~8�� �� [K��� lI .�|_ 2R PH�1��� PN2 &� ����1�,@ �A{k� G/ �28�� ,!{/ �;k�«� −PAKy� ���1��− 7"á8� �PAKy� ^� P��A²"ghi*
-§�8<� ^� -��Z�� C�–+31−� ;��d��3 G�<¹� P(�� �� �de/ �6�= C ���Ku P#��:3 ����|V� 2�/ C `�#�� ��� 1�M��� [A�University of
Chicago ,«��;k� 1�,@ ���o �p8�V� ��|<�� G�e� ��|V� C .1�p ���];�e �OI �� �?��@ 9�� Ps�e EH��©� ����q� PH�1��� PN2 &� ��^w_
^8K�� 1�M���–>2�2©� «��;k� 1�,@− Y? Ppc���� P3�=�� ];�e� :"�"g�i * a��� J1�:��� �� ��"� PAq ��/ 1�M_ 2{1 �� �;5:� �GI �� ��1�8�
i1g Scott F. Gilbert, John M. Opitz, Rudolf A. Raff, Resynthesizing
Evolutionary and Developmental Biology , Developmental Biology
Magazine, Vol173, P.357-372* i2g http://www.sciencemag.org/content/210/4472/883.extract*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Y8��:��� EA#�� 1�qI ¦1�a �,�� F�3 1�M��� PUR G/ Y #� >2"#�� P��/ �� (�e �28_ 2R Pc��e 1�M��� �� !��#��� lI � #s2� �L?� ,P��<�� 7�� .2{���� ]8d��� �� P �j� !W_ �, K� P���V� ��=����2�k� J�p{/ �#8� P:,8�
�,�pj3 b5©� �� �%Us!
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A @ÝØ’Ûa@l‰bÔmòî§a@pbäöbØÛa@¿@ïu‰b¨a@ @
�� �/ x1k� ��� Y�� { �6R G�1�� P�º J�<� G�K63 P��,<�� �� �_� � b�#�� JL©� G�;�R b�2\�N�3 �;�1��Newton's law of
universal gravitation >�R �� ,µK#�� �3Z�� G�;�R 76<F� �� �/O�� ����q SN� �_ G�K�� C 46<= ./ J{�� �� �Ú ! �<K�� +,�A�e J �
+, 3 Ps�<V� �3�� �� *G�;�"�� ± � +eghi * P��#�� P8< �� P��W; b�2\�N�3 �K6��General Relativity ����y �k
. ��� �6:�3 m1��� PW) ��U�� 9��5;� 2{1g�i * P;��}�� Pe�)� ����#� �%a �� � �U�/Brownian motion �M�<;
5©� m���3 |8 ���!(��<�� !a�� ��~�g i * ����W �� mL? b�2\�N�3 �?��WA� v8U V� J�<)�� 'R2�� 2{��� �L?
3 76<�×"P;�;�"�� P�1�#V�" * P8< �� �/ �_� � µK#�� �3Z�� G�;�R C ����<s PW) !e C �, � 2e���� �K6� �,Ae P;��}�� ����#� �/ ����y �k P��#��
�8 �_ �� Pp{ ��8HI�P;�;�R P�1�#� �& P6A� ����W; �,Ae Y? �����3� ,�3!* 1�M��� P��W; lI !"� ; 4� ��/, �& Y��� P3�:��� rA_ rA�6; � � ;´s
"P;�;�"�� P�1�#V�", P6A� P��W; 1�M��� G/ b5:; G/ �M�<; � �����3�!
i1g http://en .wikipedia. org/wiki/Newton%27s _law_of_ universal_ gravitation* i2g http://www.space.com/17661-theory-general-relativity.html* i3g http://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~peres/bmbook.pdf*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
����W �� C P6N�)� P8��:��� ����j�� �_�? !d� 1�M��� !a�� 2=�� %sP6A#�� *
!8R �� ��pAMj� �� �I 1�M��� ��3�/ !a�� �d#; ��" �>�:s– ��q– È53– 5�R" P6A#�� §�1�k� C � P��p<�� L���#��� C b2\�<F_ 2R Ø���/ Y?�
P;�;�"�� P�1�#V� ��O* C x�#� N� � Y��� L���#��� mL? 2�k ��"V� �L? C G��1�M��� �¥ �s2
,E,��ja �=� >L��#_ Y?� �/ :" P)� �� (�KA� Y=1�� !Ky�� �3�y_nZyV� [A<��� 1�M��� �� !�2e!"*
X��3� S��{ �KA�6� �ao �� 2=�� � �;/ Y #_ >L��#��� mL? ;�23 .O �V !�2�� G�2"s ��As ,1�M��� ���� !d� �=�/ ���Ò 46\�3 .1�M��� �����
�3�y��� 46� * P8��� P6A� P:� ]<� P)� �� (�K�� 43 �3�y��� P: F��, P: F� +;I�
P6Ae 7 #V Y�%M{�� [��#���3 P"A#�� P��w� P�%M{�"�3�y_"! ?�3�y��� 2�� �O�� EH
?J1�"_ !�� �3�y��� G/ � � ��/ � Á�� b2\�<F� � `� �;�j�� >2�� �� !�2e �3�y���– 43 �3�y��� C Q�/
2����� '���3 4 �|6A� � ���8� �%�� P)� �� (�K��− ? �� `� �%d� �3�y��� Y #� � ` ?.1�M��� J1�"��� �3�y��� 2 : 'A� C !H+���
!H+�� -b�W 3 ]"Aa P)� �� (�K�� �� P"A Á�������i��h��g��f��e��d���c
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
n��m������l��k��j�ghi* 2��� -'< 3 `�#�� ^N 2�� �� nZyV� [A<�� �3�y��� 2�� `����_� �^
d���c��b��a��`�g�i? PA~Nk� �� �� �� � ���!
9�M�� �3�q ��2©� La/ �� � ���� EA#�� >�(�� ¦1�a G�� �p; � ?�Y�<A���!
,Ppp{ ���1�� P��W; G/ � cZs� �� 7�ps EA#�� >�(�� !a�� ��/ ËG´s �;2�/ �� 2e��� �(��� �� ËG/ �+<�� PeZyV� P¥�y�V� C 4_1���/ Y? P:�;
12B� �� -�%N/ -PeZy�, /� P:�; J1�"_ �� 6� �,Ae �� !H�� P:�; �/P~q�a �,Ae ^j_ 2R� P6(�R!
�3�y�s Y #� � �,s� {/� ��%���� �%�a� �� ��1�<A� �2#V� !K&� ]<�� 4#� '<Æ; �� P66jF� Y? !3 ,nZy� -[AN �� �?1�2p;� �P?�23
��ak� �� �?2�/ >12p �! �& -[A<3 �,�R%� ]8d_ G/ > Ý}# F�� PA6�K� ];�e +,� >1���k� �M�<_ ��
�?2#3 ��= -[Aa �/! S�e ��1�� �<A;GGareth Nelson ^8a ^s��k� [p�V�3 YK���k� ¶�1��A� Y#8M�� ��"� S�e :">�Ks J�?L�� !:<A� .1���k� ��
ihg #;k� >1�NP��� ,b� :g ¼i i�g P��� ,rAV� >1�N :g i
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
!=/ ��j)� �� ¦�� �N� Y8��� PR%#� [A<��−[A� 43 ,«��;k� ,$� =k�� ,�%(�#��� �/ !e �� ,G�e �/ �� �K6� G/ ,G�K� �� ?� �I �E?�
�8a"ghi* �OI�s x1k� �=� �� P)� �� (�K�� �%:N C �;�W; m�8�;%� ]�AFV� �6
PAj� � -����6:V ÁPË)� �� (�K�� [ áj_ �M�<; � Ë;/, -«��;�e -$� =/�r��¤� -S#u� -���{� -S_1� -�%(��� � ���� v8U�� 7,� 63!
43 P"")� P6\U�� §�� � mL?� 2�2y�� 5�+��� �L? 5w� �� r��¤?2��/ nZy� [AN PU"�� ];�e �� P)� �� (�K��
P��� C �I ,4 (�e 43 P3��R PR%� ��8HI �M�<_ �� r;/ r�O lI [c/�� '3�M_ Y?� v"s >2���DNA b��/ r;/ EA#�N v"s �,���N� +¥ Â��
!H+�� -b/�_! �� �+��%� G���1�M��� �MU� ,P��k� G�2"s S8<3� r�O !=/ ��� EN1� 1�M��� ��c�s �� 3 !=/ �� P)� �� (�K�� 43 P=1�� ��¥�y��� C G��2\�<s E,6��5� 2e|� �� EA#�� !a�� G�KA�6� %s ,J�<;k� >�:u
i1g From a presentation by Gareth Nelson in 1969 to the American Museum of
Natural History, quoted in David M. Williams and Maire C. Ebach, "The
Reform of Palaeontology and the Rise of Biogeography- 25 Years after
'Omogeny, Phylogeny, Palaeontology and the Biogenetic Law' (Nelson,
1978)," Journal of Biogeography31 (2004): 709*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�3�y��� �� 6� P��, �� ! �,�2\�<� Y��� mL? �3�y��� P:� �K��� .��B G��1�M��� P��KuI
�Ae �c��� � Ý:�F_ P6\c T�8Mak� 4� �3�y_ C � ���� �� �Ks !,s ,E,���/ �?G�<;�� 4��
1�;�<�� P "_ �3�y_ C � ���� �� �Ks !?Sonar ��� �,�2\�<� Y���?4s�2���
?1�M�� Pp =/� ���)� Pp =/ �3�y_ C � ���� �� �Ks !? �¥�y_ mL? !e !8R G��1�M��� �M"� r�O ��� ,P#8M�� C >��=�� �
��¥�y��� mL? J�p{/ 43 J1�"��� �� -«�; ./ ��=� b2#3 E?^�! P6\U�� P��Ku�� �,W_ � ?� ! -P;�8�� -��1�<� C 1�M��� 1�N [e OI
7,� � ;�(�� �� Q�; lI Y,� � ���8��� C �%�a�� b�� [A�� 1�M�� Pp =�s �,� 3 r�O ��� ���)� Pp =/ �� b��5V� .1�M��� �?1�<�� �,�K�� ���
G�^M�� Y?� ���O P6,V� P��, �� C G���|�! k� �� >2"#� P��6:V ¦��B YK�� �2�� G�^M�� �� Æ>12"�� ËGIP6W; Y���
-�U� !e C �H|_ E<©� �� * v8U�� 7,� 63� �%��K�� G�^M�� �,@ r�O ���<� !Ky3� !"� � ���� G���
J1�"_ PR%����� �31/ : ���2d��� ���)�� 1�M�� C–Ñ���− � :V� [��5���pterosaurs *
J1�"��� �� �%�� �K� ` �3�y��� GOI !
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
?E, 3 P¥�y�� �?��@ °pA; 4� ��a/ -�� (�e C J1�"���3 b5:; �O+As G�<;�� C P��d63 2=�� 1�j3�� G�;�R � �U�/ – �� PN2� 7";/� §�/
§%q��− PR%� � Y0���� ���<V� �� r�O ��� ,T�8Mak� G��� C�T�8Mak� 4#3 G�<;�� 4#�! ghi*
G��A�¨ G�"��q 1�M��� rAN !,s ,n� ? 4#�� �� � ���� [A�� � ? 4#��s?>���K�� Q� 3� v8U��3 P:� �� Q� � P��, �� C !j�
G�e �OI� �� !�� �;/ b5:; EAs J1�"��� �� �%�� Q� � �U�/ � ? �3�y���?��a/ -1�{ C J1�"���
� 1�;�<�� �=��� K_ � �U�/ �0�_ �%�a�� b�� [A� 1�q �� Ñ��� C � �=��� K��� mL¥ ��6�_ �� (�K�� mL? ��� G��)� �� 4s�2�� �� ]�5��
��d63A�� r�O ��� ,P��� -P �0�_ [�%�a�� b�� �g�i * ?P��, �� C P:� �� Q� � !j� §�M�� ���� 1�M��� rAN !,s
E,yA� Ye�y�� ������ � ��8_ ���Porcupine [A�¯ m��_ Y"��sk� �0�_YK���k� E,yA� Ye�y�� ������ �� �%�a�� b�� �! g i*
�?� �ao ��d� :� �2;�8��� FPR%6#�� �2;�8�����6)� >^wj�* [ jF_ � �2�´s
i1g http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC509264/* i2g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_echolocation* i3ghttp://www.thehatchreport.com/information/african-north-american-
porcupines.html*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
G�e���� PA(�� �6cProcyon P832�� PA(�� �6c ��ak�� * ��¥�y��� GOI +, 3 >2�2y�� -���@� _ ÆP:�; á]<� P�1�M_, s ���j�� �H�� á` �2;�8�� Y��
-[AN �� +, 3 ÆPeZyV� nZy�ghi* t���)� mL? !d� 9�M_−P#8M�� C >^de Y?�− |N ��� P;�K�I ���
P�1�M��� ��R%#�� �� >26�#� PË���e P¥�y�V� ���j�� �+��� ! 43 �3�y��� !AB� J�#�N� �� 1�M��� 5:� ]8d_ PM<3 PAd�/ mL,s
P)� �� (�K��! ��8H� >2��R 2=�_ �� ,G�� � �>��� �3�y_ ��=� G��1�M��� 1�"� �>�6s
\��� �I �3�y��� ��:V J1�"��� ��=� �� ¿a�2�� SeZ�� [A�¯ ��2 �� ,46J1�"��� � �#�º G�� � Y=1�� �3�y���!
��"V� P��23 C �, � � H �2B Y��� >L��#��� Y? mL?! rA_ �� �+A� ]<�� ,Pc�Zs� �� 6�� P��pN L���#_ ��I" P�1�#V�
P;�;�"��" P#q�"��* أليس األدق عقليأليس األدق عقليأليس األدق عقليا أنا أنا أنا أنأليس األدق عقلي: @ …ìuìi@ áwÜ�Žãb�@ åÔnßë@ áÄäÜÛ@ ñÁib™@ {ÕÛb�@ A@bèÔÜ�
òÐÜn‚½a@òî§a@pbäöbØÛa@áÄã@óÜÇ@ŠĐî�í@Áîª@{áÜÇ@ë‡@ïÜ×@ïÜ�a…@{æìãbÓë@ñòàØ¡A@ @_ÕÜ�@òĐ�@êˆç@æìØm@æc@lŠÓþaë@|•þa@�îÛc@ @
ihg ١٧٤مؤمن احلسن وآخرين، دار الكاتب ص.جوناثان ويلز، ترمجة د.ويليام دميبسكي ود.تصميم احلياة، د.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
,P6"� P�<As PM��w� �? nZyV� [A<�� �� -!�2e �3�y��� �+��� GI .�(�2�� ��2�N�� PM��w� 76<_Circular Reasoning PwA�� C Y?�
Y #_ :"�A� [R��� �� �� �Ì�� [R�_"* Y=���s1�V� !Ky�� C 4¥�y�� 4 (�e ��=� 7 #� QAs– ¿Ky�� 1�q��
Y(� 8��� − G/ Y�@���� Y0����� &+ 2��� J/ common archetype , mL?PM��w� ; GkJk� �� ������� 2{1 �{k� ���/ �� ��/ , �,s � ? t20
_ P�<As� .�(�� ��2�N��Pc�Zs� PA��* �L,sG�j)� !8R P3�#�� �c� J�3 �� –.5A:;�� !dV� ��"� +e −*
YK���k� P��)� ���5���� P"R2�� ��6K�� `�� 9ZR� 2"s r�O !=/ ����1�e $��Carl Woese b�� C�ÄÄ� Æ��:�� áG/ ���k� EA� �� ËG/ b
nZyV� [A<�� C ËY ��1�2�� Æ/28V�ghi* b�� C S�e��ÄÄÅb G/ :" F1�L= Y? PA��y�� P�1�M��� >�:y�� Æ1�L=
�P# Mj�, �� !Ky��3 b�5���� �� ��_�; r�O� Æ � �;�e E�1 >�pA� .�:ySN� �"g�i*
� �pc�� �28� .L�� ��� GI �? �Ae 1�M��� !ys [AN ��=� ��8HI C �
i1g Carl Woese, "On the Evolution of Cells," Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences USA 99 (2002): 8742-8747* i2g Carl R. Woese, "A New Biology for a New Century," Microbiology and
Molecular Biology Reviews 68 (2004): 173-186 i ١٨٦ص. س.م g*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
PR�H�� ¶�1��_ 2�2B C !ys +e ,>�pA� nZy� YV��«��;k� 1�,W� !ys +e , P�1�M��� ��R%#�� 2�2B C− �%{/ F>��=�� á];�e áGI − >�)� ��Ku/ 43
P6(�"��, ��U�/ !ys� nZyV� YV�#�� [A<�� P?�� ��8HI C– ���=�� G�e GI/ �%{− -!Ky3 �c�� *
áèÜyaŠß@Éîº@¿@‰ìĐnÛa@ñbÇ…@æaìäÇ@ìç@Ý’ÐÛa@óÜÇ@‰aŠ•⁄a@áq@Ý’ÐÛaA@ @
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A ð�ßbØÛa@‰bvÐãa@ @
.}��K�� 1�:�;�Cambrian explosion �3 EÝA<F� 9%M{� �? ³=��� 1�,@ Y #� �?� ,G��1�M��� �#�� P��23 C P)� �� (�K�� SA�k
.}��K��Cambrian Period* 1�,@ P��\j�� �%:<�� PN�1� 2�_ ��EW#� S#u ��;��)�
Ps��#V� g�de/ �� ǽ i%C mL? >Z��� ��>^j" �� �6� x1k�ghi * ³=��V� 1�,W�� �L? GI appearance “at once“ E\U�� �2#�� �L&
� ���� QK#�� �� �? >2��� �P#s� >2�2©� P)� �� (�K��� !e�&� �� Í?2V���M"�V� 1�,W��� ��5�� �� ¦12��� �� P ��1�2�� �U�"_ �¤!*
��"� C �}e >5? .}��K�� 1�:�;� t2�/ 2"s r�L��4�1�M���* ��y�e� .}��K�� 1�:�;�� `�#��"��K��� Walcott" C/ �KN�
Alaska ,���#�� G�"�� ����23 C � K�/ 7�a/ �H�p3� rA_ ]R�w�N� Y���/ �31N��� PA��e ]A6u�¼Ä /P���� [�, '�A� 2R� 12���KN 2��^=
Gerald Schroeder �%(�R «�c�V� �L? �� :" � ��1/ ���O ��K� ��© r� -Í:3 �Us � K� ,�,�N�1�� �����)� �p3 !=/ �� J%M�� �� C S8<�� �/ !
1�M��� P �N §���I, F� 2"s b��� ��/K�� �#�� lI ��#_ ������ ]�y�e� .}��� 15©� � �"��s/ � 4j�� C2;� ���= lI Ps�c��3 2��<��� P�5A:;, 1�{�
.}��K�� 1�:�;� C Pu�# F� PURmº�3 `�#��, !8R �?���aI E_ ����A#V� �K��
i1g http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/evolution/library/03/4/l_034 _ 02 .html*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� K¤ G�K� G/ >��#A� §1�� 1�:�;�� �L? P#8q PyR� �"ghi *
PH�1��� EA� ��?��� PA� �Z#_� Trends in Genetics P�1�M�����"�s 1�M��� �� � ��,�� �� .}��K�� 1�:�;� �S#3 Pjj\�V� :" 2"�
��,@ P)� �� (�K�� !e C ��U�k� � >5,=k�.}��K�� 1�:�;� C �P#s�L? !AB G�K���3 2#� `� ,2"#��� �� 12R ��/ ��� >2��� ��c C 1�:�;�� �
1�M��� P��W;"g�i* G/ '8N �� lI [c/ :` .}��K�� �� /28� !Ky3 ³=��� ,v"s !3 7,�;�
-!Ky3 -³=��� ��U�/S#u �,W_ EAs , .}��K�� �� ��,�;� L � >2�2= P;��� `� ,�L? � �R� 7���]8d� �(��� �./ -!Ku ��"�;� �� �� (�e �� !8R ��
.}��K�� lI �� (�e �� ,.}��K�� �� 2=�� ã./ -!�� �� S#y��� ¦12�V� �� (�KA� �� QK� �� �Ae �L?� �8AM�_ P��W; ���1�� �����g i*
��"3�N .1�M��� 2pAV� �=���8�� `�� 1�"� P8:#�� Pq1��� mL& ���W;�− ����� 1�M�A� J1�pV��− 5A�� G�H�;�=Jonathan Wells 1�M��� >�:u G/
1�:�;� ��y�e� S8<3 §%q�� �� >�:y�� !Ku !6B 2#_ ` P���5V���"s .}��K�� :"b2R >�e S#A� x1/ �� r<�; !�; 2�/ �� ["_ ��2 �
i1g Gerald Schroeder, "Evolution: Rationality vs. Randomness
http://www.geraldschroeder.com/evolution.htm * i2g Trends in Genetics magazine, Volume Feb, 1999* i3ghttp://www.bbc.co.uk/science/earth/earth_timeline /cambrian _explosion*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
x1k� �� >�)� 1�,@ P��23 !d6� v� �L? 7��V� YMa−"8q �� P ��1�2A����O−>�1�� ���#�� va YM\�3 ER ,S#AV� x1/ C ^<�� /23� G��� ,, EH
7��V� va �� ]3ZR� 2R r�L3 G�K_� ,S#AV� [j� � EH >�1�� 4#31k���� >�M\3 7��V� va !8R� ,�a�� �,W_� ,^8K�� .}��K�� 1�:�;�� t20 >2
��;��)�� P)� �� (�K�� ��Ku/ Ps�e* Í(�y� P��6� ��I ;���1�j� +e >�:u ]<� P ��1�2�� ��k� �R�� C
� (�K�� �,W_ �� PA"�<��#8�� �,U#3 �� �PAj� � �>�:s �"ghi* P��6� !3 >�:u 2#_ ` PU"��s" Í(�y�>�H� ��" �;I , �V �(�1 �[{�
,t2� ËGI 1�,W�� ���5�V� ��8��"_ EW#V S#y�� Ps��#V� �28� ��pc�� C �,MM¨ �� b�#�� .2<©� 2=�� !�� �� ��y �� .1�M��� ¦12�V� *
!K3 Pq�<3 1�:�;� .}��K�� !Ky� .2p��� }ek� P��W � 1�M��� >z�#V�*
.}��K�� 1�:�;� !a�� �W �� ]"�R� �OI�N 2{�_ �As!N% P=12�� �� ^s��k� � ����� 43 P�A�\V� P;��)� S#y��, !3 �,W_ ^s��k� PA��e �6 �� 5�+���� P�@���� �� ��/ -1�,@ �& C !:<�� .1���k� *
!Ke P��W �� !��3 GO�_ �}e PAKy� ��I *�U� `��� .1�/%�� 2pAV� P��)� ��6K��!K��� G��;��Michael Denton �#8{/ �� mL? PAKyV�
P��W �� ]"?1/ Y�����"s :"P"")� PAd6�V� ����a� Y? ��Kuk� P��"�;�� ��8��"_ 43 ����6:V� P� j��� �}K��, �'8M _ mL? >2��"�� !Ky3 !��u ��
ihg ،٥٨-٥٧صول ستروبل، كتاب القضية اخلالق.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
!e r�+V� P)� !e� T+;/ �� (�K�� �,�� 3 :>2�2u !V� �:p�A� ����a���e �/ PAAR !V� r�L� ���)�e *�K� �L? QK� �� �8AM�� 1�M��� Y ��1�2��! 2R
�M�<; ^<�_ ����M";�� �:p3 �� !d� ��Ma/ ��2{� �K� P6<�� P��#�� ����M";%� Y� _ !e rA_ ��^<����"ghi *
³=��V� 1�,W��s �� �� ,1�M��� P��W � b�_ 1��� !d6� P)� �� (�KA��?��=�� 1}� P6H 7"8�*
���1�� 5�1�y_ G�e 2R�Charles Darwin ��5�R 1�,@ G/ � ���� n12� Â�� 'A� Y #N .1���k� !:<�� C P(�:s−PA"� PÀ23 mL,s− ��� ,
��"� S�e r�O !=/ :" �� >2�2� «��;/ �>�:s ��,@ �OI -PA(�� �/ 2��� -Q = P��W A� !_�R �L,s ,>2���fatal to the theory , �v8� � e�1�I �� � �{�ja
� PA6� �%a ��^w���Y#8M�� ��"�;�"g�i* 23� P��W �� �� ��� +3�� .}��K�� 1�:�;� ��y�e� ���1�� z�� ���!
���H !�23 2=�� %s³=��� 1�,@ ��I� �YM3 ¦12_ ��I ; −'Aa ��8�− �/ , 5 e��� �1�y��1 ^,y�� .1�M��� 2pAV� PwA3Richard Dawkins :" ` �OI
i1g Denton, M. (1985) Evolution: A Theory in Crisis, p.191* i2g If numerous species, belonging to the same genera or families, have
really started into life all at once, the fact would be fatal to the theory
of descent with slow modification through natural selection* On the Origin of Species, chapter9, p.302
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
>5:#V� ��´s P~M3 P·12_ ��^w_ �K_ gmiraclei" ghi* �2pA� r;�K3 �& PR%� � PA"� P?�23 ��I� � �|� �/�*
X1�"A� 48�� 7��� .}��K�� P8"� C P��:��� PWpA�� 7 #� E��K�� � ;´s ,x1k� �� P)� �� (�K�� «��;/ SA�k ��8V� 'A� �,s �,@ Y����
>Zs !Ku �� x1k� �� �%��e >�)� ¶�1�_ !\� N�Å ]31�R 4�� ,P��N P��<���h �=� �� >�)� ��Ku/ SA�/ ��:�;� v"s 4�"R� �%a C�
k�!6�KV� ��)� �,AKu C �>�:s x1g�i * >^,y�� ��A� �+(�� ���� ���1�� G�e 2"� :" ��5�R 5�"_ � P#8M��
P(�:s"g i* � ���� r�O QK� ]8d� .1���k� 2{��� �? �,s!
`�� b�R 2R� ,!Ke P��W �� T�"N´3 �!�e m2�� .}��K�� 1�:�;� GI 4y_ .�� Y= ]j�� �(�O Y j�� �����)�J. Y. Chen ��N�123 PA"�<�
;.}��K�� P8"� ^s��/ �� C ���1�23 P{�� 1�M��� >�:u G/ P:� 3 ¦�\���R �� 1�, V� �c� :"�� >�:u SAR .}��K�� ������ ��y�e� ��N/1 1�M�
i1g With out gradualness, we are back to a miracle River out of Eden (1995)
p.83 *
i�g طبقا حلساب عامل البيولوجيا األمريكي جوناثان ويلز.
Video source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E10JwiELDo0 i3g Nature takes no sudden leaps On the Origin of Species, p.156*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
J�A"� T��¨ ��� ���1�� >�:u G/ �28� ,S"� ��Darwin’s tree is a
reverse cone shape* �� >�:y�� >2��"s �·12_ 'U_ EH ,P#N Q�; ,�P3�A"� �, K� ���1�� >�:u"ghi*
�©/ .�e �y_ �A� ��/Zhou Qui Gin C ±j\�V� ���8����"s �����)� :"� 1�M_ 2=�� � ��,@ P)� �� (�K�� ,m�;2{1 +s ¦12_ �
�>�:s ! �;2{1 2"�h É P)� �� (�K�� 43 µ(��� «� ��� !d� [A�¨ «�;,@ �2= � �{�a � �1�,@ �>�:s ���"g�i*
�� 4K83 �=���©�� �����)� EA� 2,#� m12{/ �� P{%a ];�e mL?�©/ .�e �y_ � 4y_ .�� Y= !6#�!
@ @
i1g Darwin’s tree is a reverse cone shape. Very unexpectedly, our research
is convincing us that major phyla is starting down below at the
beginning of the Cambrian. The base is wide and gradually narrows.
This is almost turned a different way* http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/news/854288/posts.
i2g Zhou Qui Gin, a senior research fellow at the site, says (translated), “I
do not believe that animals developed gradually from the bottom up. I think the animals suddenly appeared. Among the Chengyiang animals we have found 136 different kinds of animals. And they represent diversity in the level of phyla and classes. So they sudden appearance makes them very special.”
Ibid, *
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
¿@ bß@ ò•ý�Šßþa@Z ،بدون تطور تدريجي نعود إلى المعجزة، بدون تطور تدريجي نعود إلى المعجزة، بدون تطور تدريجي نعود إلى المعجزة، بدون تطور تدريجي نعود إلى المعجزة ! ! ! ! ألم يقل داوكينز ذلكألم يقل داوكينز ذلكألم يقل داوكينز ذلكألم يقل داوكينز ذلك
، أو لنترك ، أو لنترك ، أو لنترك ، أو لنترك - - - - الخلق المباشرالخلق المباشرالخلق المباشرالخلق المباشر––––إذن فلنعترف بالمعجزة إذن فلنعترف بالمعجزة إذن فلنعترف بالمعجزة إذن فلنعترف بالمعجزة ....السجالت العلمية لألبدالسجالت العلمية لألبدالسجالت العلمية لألبدالسجالت العلمية لألبد
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A _‰ìĐnÛa@‰ìèÄi@�bÈÛa@Š��@a‡bß@ @
:اجلزء األول ^,y�� .1�M��� 2pAV� �� � �1��� P�5A:;�� >��5©� >� R ��=/ 4�
5 e��� �1�y��1Richard Dawkins �s�Z��3 5 e��� �2� G/ �R��; �K; `��R 4� Í?2V� :"� _�p3 ��k� 'A#�� 4� �,"qF/ �� P ��1�2�� 2c �;/"ghi*
�S� 5 e��� �1�y��1 `�#�� C ��2pAV� J� ��� S���<� 2)� �L&/ ?P;�<;�� E"�� �� P ��1�2��
?���1�� ��q �� 4A �j� F� � <� � ;/ 2pAV� �L? n12� 2)� �L&/ ��;k� 4©� �?� �8�e �,u/ �� J��e C ��"� �;I !3Selfish Gene G/ :
" �� PR%� � .1�M��� ¸�V� � Y ��1�2�� 1�M��� ,YV�#�� YR%ak� �;Ú�p3 Y�<u�s �6�� �I G�K� � Y ��1�2�� �6�:V�� ,�A�? ��d�/ �I �� F�fascistic
�s �� �PR�#�� P�j���� .� #�� Sj#���"g�i* �P��z �3 �Z#�� 5 e��� �1�y��1 ��I Y,� � .L�� GI�;/ :" S#j�� ��
�2=�� �� «�s2�� �� PR%ak� P6"��2�� ^� ��a/ Pc1/ �� P"AMV"!g i*
ihg ٤٢الذي أجرته قناة اجلزيرة اجنليزي مع ريتشارد داوكيرت دقيقة اللقاء.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PAe8DePq-48* i2g Selfish Gene, p.2, 3* i3g It is pretty hard to defend absolute morals on grounds other than
religious ones.
The god Delusion, p.232*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Ý�8 F� �,u/ 5 e��� G�K� +31 �/ ,4~M¨ G�K; +3�s ;!(�<�; �;��� �K�m��)I �� �%��p�� P ��1�2��� ��)��3:
.1�M_ 1�W � �� �� ./ P�1�#�� 7 #�� P6R ]8dF; G/ �K6� !??Y �1�1��
�0 G/ �K6� !?? ��=�A� P ��1�� P���3 .�8�� Q ©�* �L?� ,��#3k� YH%H .��� v6; ��� P�1�M��� P���A� � �"8q G�<;�� Q�/
.��V� v6 ��P#8M�� C ���� S���< F�s ,� ;��R Y? P#8M�� 4;��", .f_�?P������ P���)� 7,� 63 P=���8�� P���V� P6�)� �A�*
!p�<V� �� Q�/ ���w� �/ ��:�� �ao 2#83 �%"�N�� P���V� P���A� � �"8q �����3� ��aF/ �P�2"�� �ao �!{/ G�<;� G/ �;}��� �I� ,�=���8�� �c��_ �V
?1�M��� 1�, � G/ P6�)� P���V� P�1�M��� P���A� � �"8q �A{k�� �{k� �� Q�/ �� ��
� G�<;�����5e�� � <) ��=��� �L? CP���V� P#8M�� J�; !{k� Y? ��k?2��k�
Y? P���V� P#8M��s 5e�V�R rAs C �I G�<;�� 1�2� �����6��� �, ;��! '8N �� �� ��� 3� �����3� : P#8M�� P�5e�� G�<;�� P�5e�� !² !pN
��k� 'AMFV� �?1�8���3, 1��� Y #� �L?�,G�<;�� G�<;�� 7 Ë�jF� �L3� − ��^8#_ 2� J�?��� 28� 1��e2�� .^<V��� �Ò1− P#8M�� J�<), E���
���� �3�#�N��� P���V� P 6? C v"<�� � �� ��2� ./ �8jF�� ,P=���8
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�/ �6R �/ G�<;�� �"�5s��� t�A� ��2� �? ���5e�� �– .L�� ��1��V�3 v8_��m������ G/ 2pAV� ���0−*
P��, �� C� .1�M��� «��A� ��#�� ��� .��� G��� lI G�<;�� ��p��¶�1���� �3 !a� .L��!
�/ G�<;�� �� ��2)� �8j� b1�j�� .2��:��� .��V� 1�q�� �L? C"PeZyV� P;�<;��" ��1�#u ��p�_� ,È1�s ��w� ��� ��<;�� 1 Æ2 Æ"�� �/"G�<;�� §�"�" �& 7 #� � -Ps�\N lI*
#� +s `�� C E& G�#�� 2� E�2"_ �/ 4H�1��� Ê�V� �/ 4R�#V� P��Ò 7 ?P �1��2�� P����� �6KB .���
Y#8M�� J�\�;�� 2c �>��8� ®�_ !8"�� �L? �� P���² GINatural
Selection �A{Ô� ��"8��� Survival for the Fittest* pj�� P����� Y? P ��1�2�� P����� ];�e �O´s Y? ���6�� ];�e� Pp
G�#�� 2� E�2"_ �/ §�#V� P��Ò >�Ks G�<;�� S���<� �As ]3�d�� !{k� 4R�#V� E"#_ GI !3 ,���#UA�Sterilization– J�:;�� �� E,# �− �?
2��k�� !d�k� .1�M��� !)�* ,.1�M_ �2? �? ���#U��� >5:#��� Ê�V�� 4R�#V� �� ±A\���s
�+N �� P6N� �A{� ��"8��� Y#8M�� J�\�;��! �A�? [���/ 12{/ 4� r�O !=/ ���Adolf Hitler .� �� 2(�R
Nazi m1��R P ��1�2��3 b�wV�� ChÅ ����hÇ E"#�3ÅÄÄ �� J�u [�/
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
-�����_ �� E?���� '��q �� >12"�� ��2"�� 7�� QeI P#u/ �� P���J�×:;�� �� ,��3 43�j� ��;�eP =k� »_ �×631 >^de P3�j� x�� 4� ,
�M�<� ��� ,��=�A� P ��1�2�� P����� �� � ���� 7u+�� G�e 1��"�� �L? 12{/�A�? �3 b�R �� 2"� � G/ 2��� Y ��1��ghi *
® «��� GI !3Å "Action T4" [�/ G�#8N ��%a �A�? !�R .L��5=��� §�#� � ��1�� � ����� G�e ,����3 �g�i *
GIP�/ L? >2;�#V P���²� �� �A�? P���� .��V� 1�qY? P���²;PAu�s ��k ��V� P6�)� 4;��R 2c� 1�M��� 2c ®�_P� ��=��� �� .f_ Y��� *
��"8�� !=/ �� «����� �A{Ô� ��"8��� Y#8M�� J�\�;�� 4;��R 2e|_ �/ ?�A�? �3 b�R �� Pp{
§%q�� �� P�� �� P8"pA� Î1|� �,u/ 2e|� `/n���3 G�o Alan
Bullock Ppj3 b���� �;+�I �� �>��8� ®�_ ,�A�? �,8K_1� Y��� ÕäV� !e G/��"� S�e r�L�� ,��=�A� Y ��1�2�� !Ap���: " G�e ����� �A�? �N�R � G�e� �
�� 4;��R �=� C ["_ Pp<V� G/ ���8M�� J�\�;�A{� ��"8��� ,Y#"g i*
i1g Proctor, Robert N. (1988)
Racial Hygiene: Medicine under the Nazis, p.191* i2g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Action_T4* i3g Bullock wrote that Hitler was a rationalist and materialist, who saw
Christianity as a religion "fit for slaves", and against the natural law of selection and survival of the fittest.
=
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�A�,s G�e �pFR �� ��1�� ,�^ak�� ��k� �A�? [���/ ��� �? �L? * ��"� +eQ;���I �1�y��1 gRichard J. Evansi ghi*
2"��� >1�j�� .� �� �=O�6 3 �A�? G�e P"8M��� Y��� P��+A�] P��W; �&��Y#8M�� J�\�; �A{� v"s ��"8���!
2"� !(�U��� !e� ,�8�� ER !e �s2� Y�K� � �}R P�1�M��� P�<A��� ]# { b2Mj_ P;�<;�� §%ak�� E"��s ,¶�1���� }� G�pAjV� �& QN|� Y���
1�M��� ���2:3/ v<3/ �� �>��8�* ;PA8 �� ��#V� !e E6<F� 1�M���s��"� ��.1�M� Á? Q6= á! James J.
Hill :" � Æ2 FB ����d�� GI_ ��#8 ��"8�� G�;�"���RÔ�"g�i* � � �"8q�!��� Tille �;´s :" �/ �"��� � � P���² ��� 2�2y�� �M� ��
¦��;�� .��2² �/ ���#U�� >2��<� �/ $%s��, �Ma ��|? >2��<� ���P ��12�� P��W �� C .�?�=; ��N�N/ x1�#�� �;k �� ��\�; �?� Y#8M�� J�
P ��1�2�� �?�="g i* =
Alan Bullock; Hitler, a Study in Tyranny; HarperPerennial Edition
1991; p219* i1g Richard J. Evans; the Third Reich at War; Penguin Press; New York
2009, p. 547* i2g Martin, James J. Hill, pp 414* i3g Williams, Raymond. 2000. Social Darwinism. In Herbert Spencer's
Critical Assessment. John Offer*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��3�? ��/ f 8NHerbert Spencer P�+�=�� P ��1�2�� QN|�Social Darwinism −Y #_ P�+�=�� P ��1�2��� : C P ��1�2�� '8M_
���ä� �� !e '"B� P�+�=�� b�A#��−��"� 7_/ ,: " P��R��� !(�N� >�Ks �a2_� Ppj�� �, q��V Ppj�� P�+)� C P��2�� !E,p"A_�; v<3/ x1�#_
�� ��À23Y#8M�� J�\�;, r�Le� P���² �/ ���#U�� >2;�<�P��Ò Ê�V�E,(�"3 �� Â�)��"ghi*
,1�M��� �,p�� Y��� >1�j�� Y? mL?� P���#V� ��IP���V� >2��� ! 2=�� %s !a����`�# .1�M��� .��V� F� �/ G�<;�� 9��F� ���A<, QN|� �/
Ë"��/ �(��8V QN|� �/ �6 �_�R%a/, G/ !p�<�2=�� !a��V���W P���V� P �� !#· �� G�<;��" �;�<;I�"*
E,<�;/ E?�<;/ 2R �� ��<; ��L�� ��|? GI �g��f��e��d�g�i* @
i1g Social Status, p.414-415*
i�g ١٩(: سورة احلشر، اآلية(
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A ‰ìĐnÛa@‰ìèÄi@�bÈÛa@Š��@a‡bß@ @
اجلزء الثاني P�1�M��� P����� G/ [e '3�<�� ��"V� C �;�eO � �}R ���� 2R ��=�A�
¶�1���� }� �& G�<N|� Y��� !(�U��� !e� �8�� ER !e �s2� Y�K�* 1�M��� ����� �6:3 b2Mj_ P;�<;�� §%ak�� E"��s*
G/ 1�M��� ����� 43 �6s :��§�Á# �=���3 !Us/ �3k�k� �� ��N,� �8��s ��/ P8_�� C ��1�M��� EAN! ghi*
�/ �K� Q �R%a/� ��;�;�R � �<N�_ �L?� � ���8� � �8�� 43 .� #�� !j�A �6�:V� !a�� ��<��� ?Y ��1�2��
,P"�� -PA��� C ��<�� �� ��U8�� P�k� ¾����� P:� P�2"V� mL? YM#_ �/?7;�/ � �N� =/ E?1�8����
;��)� ��R/ ��<�� ��a�� � �1}� P ��1�2�� ���2�� mL? �K_ `/ ��
ihg تدعي على العلمناك آالف األحباث اليت ه تفوق اجلنس األبيض على اجلنس األسود مادياا وبيولوجي، ا منها قدمي
Louisوأحباث لويس أجاسي Samuel Morton الشهري صموئيل مورتنأحباث عالم اإلنسـانيـات
Agassiz ولكنهم يتبعون قضية حتمية يف ،الذي كان يقول بأن البيض ليسوا سفاحني حني أبادوا اهلنود احلمر .تطورفهذه هي حتمية ال ،تشكل األعراق
وهو الكتاب الذي ،السبعينـاتا يف أكثر الكتب مبيعBell Curve كتاب قوس اجلرس ظهر وحديثا ـ ألم أضعف عقال ،يتحدث عن أنه ال فائدة من تعليم السود أو حتصينهم من األمراض ا من البيض وأفقر ذهن
.والبد من إنفاق املـال يف أمـور أكثر فائدة
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Bell_Curve
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Human Zoo �8�� �� !R/ P=12e E,� j_�"PMN� P"A�"ghi * � �? P�� #�� mL? �s1 Q�/ >2;�#%� >��8�Y#8M�� J�\�; ����
X��8� �� ��8� ?�_��2:3/ v<3k P;�a� 1�M��� 1�M��� ����� 43 �� � �U�/ :_>/�V� �� !=��� §�� ����� ?� C !=��� G/�
���3 ��/ P8_�� �=>/�V� �� �! s �"8q >/�V�[ j_ �& 1�M��� ��3�k � !"�<� � ���� �� P;��)� PA<A<�� C
!=��� [ j_g�i * M��� t2p��� �� 1��6�N�3 G��1� ¶V� E:� C .�?�= §�s ��=�
1�2"63 !=��� ���j�h�− hÇ % , �e��3 �1�e S�e�Brucca ��"�: I ¶� G ¶� �� ^dK3 [#c/ >/�V�!=��� , r�O '3�M� ��K� >/�V�3 Â�� ¶V� E:ps
%�1�w��3 Â��g i * � P���q S8<3� 1�M��� ��3�/ C >/�V� GI !3 � ��Ma }�#_ �¥ Â�� ¶V
ihg وملن أراد االستزادة" حدائق حيوان البشر"نوقشت هذه املسألة بالتفصيل يف مقال سابق بعنوان :
https://www.popularresistance.org/deep-racism-the-forgotten-history-of-
human-zoos/ i�g املرأة حتت تصنيف تندرجHomo parietalis بينما الرجل حتت تصنيفHomo frontalis
http://www.rae.org/pdf/dsod_apb.pdf Love, R., Darwinism and feminism: “The ‘women question’ in The Life
and Work of Olive Schreinr and Charlotte Perkins Gilman,” in Oldroyd and Langham, Eds., The Wider Domain of Evolutionary Thought, D:Reidel, Holland, pp. 113–131, 1983.
i3g Gould, The Mismeasure of Man, p.105*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�""�>z�#V� >1�U)� �� � * (A real danger to contemporary civilization) g1i .
���1�2� � �"8q >/�V�� �I �Aj_ ��5 V� b�,V, �I]8�� �� P:,8�� ���c ,SAK�� �� !Us/ ]8�� C >/�V�sg�i *
.12; ��M_ �M�<� [e '8N �� �� ��� 33 S��M� G/ .1� 43 >���<V��6�:V� !a�� 4< ©�, ?� ���� � �UR� �� ��8AM� �L? 2#� �/
�� ��2)� 2#� �/">/�V� §�"�" !3 ?P ��1�2�� >�K��� �� ���� �Ma � �=�_�? P#8M�� ��6��� 1�M��� �=� C ["� Yd8�
,P"")� ��1�j3 G�<;� P�1�M��� P����� �? '8N ���s 1�M�� ���8_/ 1 �� ,PR%a/ ��8�/ P�/ ��{� P���� ^� ER ��26�N� G��1�M��� ���� �OI� 9%
1�M��� P�%{ b2#3 � �s�Z�� �L? G�KN �,���N G�<;� C�#V� '< ��.��=��� �5wV� ^<��� PA"�<� P��W 6e !
1�M��� G/ ;r�O lI [c/ ��� 4�%V� >��3� .�W; 1�q´3 P3�w�� P���}���3�P���V� PR�#�� EN, P ��1�2�� P=���8��� ,�L? �� �?'8M��� 2 � 1�M� �L?� ,
i1g Gilmore, D., Misogyny: The Male Malady, University of Pennsylvania
Press, Philadelphia, p. 125, 2001.* i2g an object to be beloved and played with, better than a dog anyhow.
Charles Darwin, The Autobiography of Charles Darwin 1809-1882,
New York pp. 232-233*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�?1�H�� �?1�#u� ��e�#� !{/* Q ©�� !Usk� Q ©� 1}� �%a ��� P���V� P�1�M��� P����� !8N Y�s
7R1k�Favored Race ,§���k� P" _� +,s 23F/ G��V�� G�3�� ]��R P3��RG���� P(�� P���2�� �� J��� ];�e� ,P6<; G�A� G�K63 �p3
�%e ]#=1/ G��A�� G��V�#�� G�3�)�s ,��1��� lI G�R �AH b�5,V�� �� V� �� ���� �_��3/½ % «�5; ��;�e `�#�� G�KN �� b�R 2R� ,��=�A� P�1�M_ P���3 .���
.2 ©� ��d� �� ��23 Q�1�3 vN� P��8� �c�3 ]R��� r�O C P�N%���>1�U)� P��� �� �P�� e ��,:V�ghi *
�� GI !3 �� ���#�� G�"�� C ��,@ Y��� P���=�� ��=����2�k� P��;Nazism Pu�s lIFascism P ���N lIStalinism P���� lI
Maoism � �N� =/ n� ? G/� ,PR�#�� P" ���� ,P�1�M��� P����� lI �2 �N� �,Ae$� =/ �� !Us/!*
7R1k� Q ©� Q=�? �� �� ,�L? � ��� 7���Favored Race �M<� >��<�� '� �� � �< = G/� ,�8A� .1�M��� 1�j��� S8<3 P3�w�� PA"#�� ��
ihg ري اجلنرال فان هودزاندورفكتب القائد النمساوي اVan Hodzandorf ،القائد الكبري يف احلرب
ما تدعونـا إليه علينـا أن ننسى قليال ... احلرب قانون الطبيعة": كتب يقول بعد انتهاء احلرب ،وىلالعاملية األ ".األديـان
James Joll, Europe Since 1870, peguin books 1990 p.164
فقد كتب حد جنراالت احلرب العاملية األوىل أوهو Frederick Vorbernardريدريك فوربرنارد أما ف
من الناحية جديةحاجة أيديولوجية بقدر حاجة األحياء يف الطبيعة للصراع وتعطي نتائج م احلرب" :يقول
".البيولوجية
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
$� =k� P"3 ^,M_�* b�#�� ����23 C��Äh½ P �2� ]A#�u�G�<�^s Ferguson P���3
.1�5� P(}_ S8<3 PK���k�G���6� ¦1�= George Zimmerman �3k�� !�R .L��� �_1�� G����_ J�y�Trivon Martin ��Nk�1�H/ �¤ ,
F3 S8<3 �e^�/ C ��2=2# PU"��� ,YR�#��V� �2��� ���?�W!6y�� ��p;/ �������PK���k�ghi *
5��� >�K�s ,ª�w�� !"#�� ���1 ]B >��=�� YR�#�� !c������ $� =k� P ��1�2�� Ps�"d�� >�MN Q=�? lI ��#� r�O !e ,PW) P�/ C ��#�u%� ��#_�
ª�w�� !"#�� ��* (1 ��{� !=/ �� ����k� �K���/ ];�� [e �»0� r�O ��R/ Q
�,s EKpA� ��N/−���3�/ n�1�3−?!! >5:#63 ����R E��e� !{� 4� �}e P3��R L � ��N/ Q(1 �,6K0 G�e �� G/ 4� C ,��N/ !=1 �3k� ]8A�
G��5�� �� G�R [j;–�� 1�;/����<− ;2�/ �W; r�O ]�AF� G/ G�� � ;k�p;− 46A<V�− QeI b�K��� ��R +e�Malcolm X: �� ��#;" 76�G���/" ��Nk�� �3k� 43 56F; %s ,� �� E��#_ !U�3 *
�� ��N1 ��R− EAN� �A� �� �{− :Û ,(+�� ,?5 �6 p� w��1� �x� �� p� ,h�0 v0 _uA�1 p� ,_uA0 v0 h��1 yz# p p� ,(+�� ,9�5� �6�
i1g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trayvon_Martin*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
;���1�5 p6 �{� v0 $��� p� ,$��� v0 �{�Üghi* ��R�−EAN� �A� �� �{− :Û |)�V |� Qz1� }�~5� , �� |>�W! � ��^��W! ���#?�a�V� Wz5,Üg�i*
�6K� � ?� 7 #�Y�%N�� ��2��, ��2�� r�O .L��� ��= � !q�8�� J1�pE���L� Â�\uk� E��3 G�A� �/! r�O !3�"� C ^,y�� ��}A�� }���− '3�<�� >2p�V� ������� Q(1− 5��o µ ��e G�=John Quincy Adams �� &� 2c �8�� J�� G/
�6)��? G�;�R P#8M��, P#N���� �_�"8M_ G�;�"�� �L&� �2=� "g i*
��j~�N�s $� �� �� PA��e P"8q �,A6e�3 ��1�R ¾���_� ,PR�#�� P" ���� , 7;�k� $� =k� ��–C t2� +e 4�K���k�� ���ZN�− ��� t2p� G�e ��
����<;�� ��=�A� P���V� P���* ��"� �1�Ks �1�y��1 Richard Weikart: " �/ P ��1�2�� ]p:; 2"�
$�Nk� ��s�� ,S"� �� ��N/1 §%ak� G�5� SAR C ,P#8M�� ��%���_3 ,E,#� G��#_ ��� E,<�;/ «� R� ,���8_/� �A�& Y6A#�� E(��©� �y3/ G�
;�e ,PV�#��>1�Ky� PR%a/ PAUs P"")�3 ]"gÅi*
ihg ER1 ,Pppj�� PA<A<��gɬŽhi i�g ��� ,�� !� ��"# �$%� &�'�(!� �)*)��,,��*
i3g Robert Remini, John Quincy Adams (2002)* i4g Richard Weikart, from Darwin to Hitler, p.215*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
sY#8M�� b�W �� C >�wH §%ak� ,.��V� �� 4;��"� �,��UaI �K6� �P��U#�� ���1�� ��6�� �/ P#8M�� � �;�<;I G�<;�� �� !#� Y��� E"��� , ^<_
P#8M�� QK� P�1�M��� P=���8�� P#8M��3 �& PR%� � §�/ 7 #63 �/ P=���8��*
G�<;�� 1�,@ �� ��,@ Y��� PA8 �� P;�<;�� ��#V� !e� G/ !#���3 Y��_ 1��6�N�3 G�<;�� �s�� �L�� ,P ��1�� PAj��3 � P��+N -P�2"63 ��= G�<;��
,��Nk� �� !Us/ �3k� Q ©� G/ �� 2��5�V� P ��1�2�� 9�)I >��3I G/ �/ 2e|� �L?� ,.��� G��� G�<;�� G/ �/ ,.�8�� Q :A� � a ���#U��� 4R�#V�
��<;�� ��=��� >�?�@ !Ap�� �Aj� � 1�M��� G/� ��<;�� 1�,W�� P��{/!* فاإليمان باإلنسان هو توكيد متزايد على أن التطور فاإليمان باإلنسان هو توكيد متزايد على أن التطور فاإليمان باإلنسان هو توكيد متزايد على أن التطور فاإليمان باإلنسان هو توكيد متزايد على أن التطور
....شيء واإلنسان الروح والجسد شيء آخر تماماشيء واإلنسان الروح والجسد شيء آخر تماماشيء واإلنسان الروح والجسد شيء آخر تماماشيء واإلنسان الروح والجسد شيء آخر تماما Í��&� Y? >��V�� P#8M��� 5e�V� �? ��k� P""� C G�<;��s���±��°
���½� �¼� �»� �º� �¹� �¸� �¶� �µ� � � �´� �³� �²¾�ghi*
F��t�1� F�¤�1� _�3�1 �t�� �6� ,%RV� ��^ c � 7��� �1`5 (J@B� �^���%!�t# -1�� _�1�!!!
ihg P��� ,J�5�k� >1�N :g�i*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A ï�⁄a@Õܨa@ @
اجلزء األول
�<6A�� ���je �_�{� �,�p(��e ��p(�1� PM8�� �8y� � �R�A¨ �;2=� áGI !�2�� �S� G�K<s ,�,���8<e �8<�� �,<6A6eBurden of Proof ��
PM3 §�A\V� �L? ËG/ Y� � �� * P6W;/ C �<�; �Ì�� t20 P)� �� (�K�� >2"#V�&%a �� ��;� >2y3 ��� �� �� �"� !�2�� Æ�S� ËG/� Y�; G�2� �"�V� � j�
Y&�� 'A��–G��1�M���− * 4� lI }j�� G��1�M��� ��|? �� � SAM� G/ ���#V� �� �8{/ 2R�
2� �<�E?��,= !e G� � P?� ��%�� ��+���� Y�; CY&�� 'A\A * �K�P"��M�� mL¥ !6#� G/ EA#��3 xZ�� �! ghi*
� }�#� ./ b�W; � j�� �� P�%��"�V� �� ����� áGI 2"#_ �K6� ��M<8_�� 2<�_ �M<8_ E_ �OI �p3 ,b�W �� �L& PN�Nk� P�@� 2#F� � ,s ,
�� P�%� 2"#���"�"�V� � j��"* �� G�K�� �,s ª�,K�� 9�8jV� ;r�O �� ��d6e : �� rAN� ,PA�s
�� PA���� Y60 !��a ��� ,PA��A� ��3�,K�� !{�� Â�{��� �,#� !��#�� �I� !��� �w�� ¦��a �/ ���&� ��a� � 6� ¦�=� ,��3�,K�� �� �� G�K_� P���2��3 9�8jV� !{�_ Y��� Y?� 9�8jV� >2��R� ,PA���� ]RZ��
ihg ٢٢٦مؤمن احلسن وآخرين، دار الكاتب ص.جوناثان ويلز، ترمجة د.ويليام دميبسكي ود.تصميم احلياة، د
.بتصرف
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
ª�,K�� 1��A� � �1�<�* P��� ��s �����3� ,�M<8_ �K6� � 2"#_ �3 b�W; ª�,K�� 9�8jV� � ?
�_ P��/ PA"� xZ�� �/ 9�8jV� �� �"�V� � j�� Y� � .L��� ,�"�V� � j�� 2r�O �� !�2��3 S��MV� �? Ps2j��3 m1�,@!
9�8jV� >2(�s� ���1�<�� ��3�,K�� 7 #� � ���� EA#� 9�8jV� � Æ{ .L��s ,�Á"�� �;�{ �� G/ �� >��8� P��� 9�8jV� ��=� �L�� ,PA���� PN�<��
��y� JÚ Q��� � � ���� �,AKu C P�A�¨ �3�j� n� ? G/ ��:V �! >�? !d� 1�?5�� �#3 2:; ¿"#�� ��2�N�� �� P=12�� Q� 3�
�2e1�k�Orchidaceae �eO ®�s ,!p �� 7d;Fk � ���� P"3�M� >1�{ L\�_ �AM�� 1�8 F� ��8� 'j�A�s ,>�? ��/ ��#� �� m�d;F/ �� J�ZR�� ����² !p ��
C G/ G�� ��dV� �"A���3 b�"s ��a/ �2e1�/ 2 � �,<�; PA6#��3 b�"�� �N/1 .12�! ghi*
P{�� Pp(���� Q�; ��F_ �2e1�k� >�? G/ !R�� !K� >1�HI �dek� GI !3 !p �� 7d;F�3– !p �� 7d;/ G��^sfermions− �L? !e ,v"s �,AKu Q��
32�� �� �W � � ®�8; �(�e Y?� .2p��� �L? E�1� ,��~u m��/ �� Y#� �� ��2e1�k� >�? C �,8V�, ,�� (�K�� �� �?^� �� ��d� Y~3 G��_ C Í#_ ��´s
C � j�� S:� «��� 'A� �q�s G�p8<s ,�,A� G�wM� �� E,A� 7wM_ %s�� !e!
i1g http://www.nhm.ac.uk/nature-online/life/plants-fungi/bee-orchids/*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
3�MV� �,�p(�1� !p �� 7d;k '3�MV� �2e1�k� >�? !Ku Q�/ Pp(��� P"Pjj\�� P�@�3 b�"_ >2"#� P��M � !p �� 7d;/–�"A��� − P��W V� mL? C�
?�"�V� � j�� �� >��8� P��� G/ r�O lI [c/ : La�_ ,���pA� JO�= '�1 %3 Y��� 1�?5�� �#3
J�8� �3 'j�A�� 1�32�� �eO ®�s ,'��A� !�28e � ���� 1�32�� 7d;F/ !Ku G/ G�� 9�"A���"A��� C ��6,� !6K� ��a/ >�?5� S?L�� ,.12�!
� �/ 1�32�� 7d;F/ !Ku Q�; �&� ^3�32�� �,#�� �>�:s �,W_ ��I 1�?5�� mL?�,W_*
?�"�V� Y&�� � j�� �� >��8� �P���� � �2"#_ �L? 2#� �/ G/ °��� : P6R C Â��a Y? 1��R O���� n�1���� �K��� Â��a
P;%"#��!"#_ �/ n12_ 1�?5�� mL? G/ � cZs� �� 7��� ,^32���� P6K)��, wF_ �� Y,s �~u �,�p(�1 �� �,AKu ��/ �� ^�!
��5�� J�<p3 � ��3 +s– �"A��� ��– >�)�3 Â�� E:)�� !Ky��� �R�j��� P{�a J�<�� ,Ps�K�� P6K��3 �Aq 1�8� ¦��;I� ,�,AKu 2A"F�N Y���
>�)� 2<:3 r6N 1�2:3 �, jB� �AM�� 1�8� P8� C ��H1�V� !e vwc� ,]R��� Q�; C G��� P�a ��!
«28FV� EW#�� '��\A� �,88<3 �y¯ !R�#A� ���o Y? ��3�<)� mL? !e���A��N����M��L��K��J��I���H��G��F��E��D��C��B��_�� � �^��]��\��[��Z��Y��X��W��V��U��T�� �S��R��Q��P��O
b��a��`����j��i��h��g��f���e��d��c
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
k �ghi* �����������������������g�i*
�� �P6:< � >2"#V� P���8��� ����W V� ��O �� (�K�� mL? ��,@ 2"s �K� ,P6K)�� ^32���� Y&�� 'A� �� ��8� !�2e ,�28�� L � �#8�� �,U#3
!A"�� �I ��À28�� mL? �32�� � [NÔ� ���º��¹�»�g i* ���1�� 5�1�y_ 7���Charles Darwin Y&�� E6j��� �L& 5�À G�e
¦1�= !�1o §�� ���N ��2 �� ,7N� �� �/ 7< � EH P)� ����W 6A� Í?2V� !8��eGeorge Cambell ¦��5_ C P8:#�� E6j��� P��/ �� b�#3 �_�� !8R
���1�� ��R �2e1�k� >�? :"�� � � de >�K��� mL? �N/1 5? EH ,¿"#3 [j#_��c/� :7u%�_ ��aF/ G��/ C�"gÅi*
�� >2(� P8_�� !{k� C �? P��W � P�/ C 2"#_ 7;�/ G/ r�O lI [c/ ��8j� � � ��:� �2=� �As ,��=��� ���– � ���N 1�:�/ !d�Stonehenge
�ZA:;� J� :3− I C ��Z_ �As�;�j�� ��8H− ;�:)� J�j�;� ��:V Gk
ihg P��� ,>�"8�� >1�N :ghÉÅi*
i�g P��� ,!6 �� >1�N :g¼¼i* i g P��� ,!6 �� >1�N :gÉÉ�i*
i4g "Well, that often comes over me with overwhelming force; but at other
times,’ shaking his head, ‘it seems to go away".
Charles Darwin, quoted in Duke of Argyll, “What Is Science?” Good
Words 26 (1885): 244.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
E6j���� 2"#���3 r��3 +s ,�:)� ��=� ��� �� >2(� P8_�� J�j�;��?�"�V� � j���
�� -12R �� §%q�� �� P��W � �A� � �;/ 2· 'A� G�u C �32�V�� � ?� ,2"#���#�� �� FS·!" �s���V� !�2�� �� F!6#�� –Y&�� 'A�− , �,s
�� S<;k�� �Rk� '��M��2"#��� >�?�@ !Ap! ��K�� �� «�; �L? ,>2��� � �::� ]8d F� 2R !8"�<V� G/ P:p3 P����V� ���� G���s ��e �8y� ��K�� �� «� �� �L?� ,��~u �, � ��#; � PA8"�<� >�:s �q� � G�e GI� ,��~u �, � G���s ��#� � Pc�� >�:s G���s ��e T� � G�e GI�
��#�� ��K�� �� G��� ��!6#�� �� !"#�� ��"�I C G�!* ����é��è���ç��æ��å���ä�� �ã��â��á��à��ß��� � �Þ��Ý��Ü��Û
î������í��ì��ë��ê�ghi* ^� §�q �/ -Ps��#� ^� P���� J�8N/ lI b�K���� -�� C !"#�� �� QAs � EKB �² �L? �GI ,'��� �� ��2�� �?1�qI C >�?�W�� ^<"_ � V P�y�K� ��M#V� mL? ��� PA��V� mL? 2 � �� e �OI� ,!"#�� P�@�� !M#_� ,�de/
'���3 G+��� 2;�#; P#q�<��, ?�� EÝA Ë<F; -PA��� ./ 2 #s ?�3 ��K�� P"31 � <�;/ �� �A\; -2 3 ./ ]B�
?x Á1�#FV� �Aa 2 � !? ��e� ,�s G�K; �� .L�� !8"�<V�3 x Á1�#FV� G�"ÝA# F� 1��K��s !8"�<V� r�O 1
ihg P��� ,�q >1�N :gÅÇ−½hi
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
"ÝA#FN,�ao -!8"�<63 � �U�/ x Á1�#FV� G� � Æ� 4,K��V� 43 2� �� r;I +e �K��� �V� �K�����|¥ !8"�<! ��Ç���Æ��Å�������������Ä��Ã����Â���������Á��À�������¿��������¾��½�ghi*
G���N �1�e .1�/%�� 2pAV� S�e 4��Carl Sagan >^,y�� �����1" !{��_Contact " P��/ PA"� P:� P������ mL? C 2{�� G�eA-Periori
G/ Y?� ,.12� G/ G�� : ��/ 2"#_ 2{1 ��:63 �;�j�� b�5� � ���� n12� !"#��v<3!
EÝA<F� !3 2"#��� 2{1 ��:63 �;�j�� ��=� C !"#�� ���· � �, �� �>��8�!
�K� P������ mL? Y�s ��eO �� E,dp3 �� H/ ��U��� �+A� �� P��6� [y x1k� ¦1�aSETI Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence
!<A<��� Gk� ,Y=1�� ��U��� �� P���R P��k� b�R1k� �� PA��q PA<AN ��U��� �+A� }��� r�O �� ��� 3� ,Ps2j��3 m1�,@ �K6� %s Pc��1 P6R 2�� ���B Y=1�� ��U��� C PR%6� >1�U� ��=� �� � �# "� �%�� �L? G/
� #� !{�����! g�i* − mL,s ,!8"�� �L? �� -�� �� �d#; ` G�� 7�� �p; ��k� �R�� C�
�de/ � P���1−*
ihg P��� ,rAV� >1�N :ghÄi i2g Sagan, Carl. Contact. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1985*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
2?�y�� �K� 2"#��� P:p3 �"F_ P��k� PA"#�� ��KAV� G/ P������ mL? ���Á"�V� �;�j�� �� P��2e b�W ��� *
>1�U� ��=� ���s/ PM<3 P6R �& P��k� b�R1k� �� PA<AN ��:6s ��%a �� PAa !e !a�� Pc��1 P6R ��1�A� PH%H S< ; [Ks ,PR%6�
G�<;��– �� !Ky�� b� ©� A� �� S_Z3 PM8U � P =�Z; >2��R 1�G�<;�� ��%a �� PAa !e !a�� E��"_ �<�/− ?���y#�� lI 2"#��� P6R C
?Ps2j�� lI �2e1�k� >�? �"A_ P��M � 2"#_ S< ; [e 4�%63 � �2"#_ 2u/ � ��� -P� -P��W � !e C 2=�_ ��À28� �K �; [e
>1�U)� P��N1 �� ���V� >1�U� P;�d��� �+� v8a l�k� G/ E�5;� ,PeL��?PR%6�
�� !e r�O 2#3 � #A�3� �,�%�3� � #M�N� GI P=�L<�� P6R ��I! ��W��V��U���T��S�������R��Q��P����������O��N�ghi*
@ @@ @@ @@ @@
ihg P��� ,26² >1�N :gh�i
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A ï�⁄a@Õܨa@ @
اجلزء الثاني P��� -��A6� �� �¥ �� 2{Z� P� PAa P�/ ���M_ 4�– P~�5= �=���3
Molecular biology− �� ��1�AV� ��~� �?^8K_ lI -P=�p3 r;´s , ,�}K�� >�?�"�� P �2� E:p3 PA� �8j_ ^8K��� �� 12"�� �L? 2 � ,���V� ,�,"s��63 >�?�"�� P �2� 2"#_ §��� +31 2"#��� �� ��2#� �,Aa�� 2{�_�
"#�A� ��8� -2{1 b��/ G�K�N �,���N���28�� � Fj��� E6j���� 2!* ��3��8�� 4�%� r���/ 2?�y_ r;´s Y=1�� PA� ��y� lI ]A{� �OI� '< ��� t20� ,PA� lI� �� ���V� ¦��a� ��a2� b�W�;�3 'Aw_� ���_ Y���
��3��8�� mL? 43 b����* ��;o G�K� ��3��8�� 43 '< ��� �L?�– �W)�−�5= !a2_ ��2 #s , �KA= P~
�� lI ]A{� 2R �&�a� P��A#� G�K_ ��3��8�� �2�I }� PA� P�Lw��PWpA�� Q�; C ��ak� ��3��8��*
���5s C >�?�@ P�f�� mL¥ ��3��8�� }� ����A#V� !" � PA� b2\�<_� EK��Quantum Physics Y��6K�� r3�y��� >�?�@ 76<_Quantum
entanglement "� _ �� ��a� t20 %s ,>5:#� P;o P�f3 P��A#V� ! �+A� «�M�N� Y��� >�?�W�� Q�; Y?� ,PA� lI �KA©� ��~�5= �� 2(� �2�
�_�86K�� �(�� C �, � >����N�� �_�86K��liquid crystal
semiconductor with gates and channels mL? b2\�<_ PA� �K�
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
63� �28�� L � >�?�W��G�"_�� 7,� ! ghi* P6A� >�?�@ [@�_ >1�,V�� P6K)� 7,� 63 «�M�N� �_�86K�� ��}� � ? P��W � ¿"#�� $�"�� Q� 3� ,�_�86K�� !a�� P�@� P6,� C P(��5s +e ���y� v8a ]<�� � {� P6K� ¦��; PA� ��y� ��3��3 43 !{�����
>2�%V� xZ��! ��3��8�� 1�8� 2#3 � ;/ E,V� PR1�� �� "��� �� `�� 1���� �� � #��M�
;!?LV� 2"#����#¥��: h − EW ��� >2�2u P(�� � PR�1/ 2"#���� !a�2����– P�%3�2;�� PK8y��
Endoplasmic reticulum – PR�1k�� §�M�� �� PK8y�� mL?� >�� ��� ��U#��� �;�jV� lI PA� !a�� P<(��� !" �� §�q !d�
����� �� �e��/� G�\V��* ::::وتؤدي األروقة إلىوتؤدي األروقة إلىوتؤدي األروقة إلىوتؤدي األروقة إلى
� − >�� �� C .5e�V� >�e�L�� r 3 DNA* − Se�_ �;�j� �� _�}��– �����8����Ribosome −* Å − PR�M�� ¦��;I ��2��– ��12;�e��V�mitochondria –* ½ − Pjj\�V� ��(5©� �;�j�– Y©�= �,=Golgi apparatus − *
i1g http://www.theantiagingdoctor.com /72NewBiology and Trans
formation.htm*
_…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
É − ��3��KV�� P=�)� �� 2(�5��� ���A\V�� ����� �� §�� 'q� �– ����N�<A��Lysosome −*
à − .5e�V� vM\��� ��2��– b�N�Z <��Centriole − ��2_ Y���J�2?k� 1�,@� PA� b�<";�*
¼ − �%w�� G�¨– P�1�j#�� ���:���Vacuole− P6#qk� G5 F� ��>2(�5��*
Ç − .�� �� �6)� ¦��;I �;�j�RNA – P�� ��Nucleolus −* 2{�;� P��<�� 7�� �,�y�K; � � �� Y��� ��U#�� �� �� �� � ���
�,8(�:�! ghi* N � ;´s ,PR�1k�� §�M�� mL? �2�I }� PA� >��; lI � A{� ��� b2Mj
� �2= -Â�a -«�; �� -��3��83 -�(� ./ !8"_ %s ,S;�= !e �� >�� ��3 vB; ��k3 ,PA� P��3 5e�� 5��6��8�� E�5;´3 � ���� S��F_ + polymerase .L��
s ,�� _�}�� � j_ !(�N1 �#� �+(�� !60 �(�K�� �,=��0 Y��� ��8AM�� �6:�� v�� !a�� PA� >��; C >��y� 2=�_ 4_�}�� �� Y)�DNA b�W 3
Y��3��� ^�y���CGTA � Ô6� ^�y��� �L?hÄÄÄ �R��3 2A�½ÄÄ Pp�{� 2A� !K− ��� 1�A� − P��<� C >��=�� �,Aeh ��hÄÄÄ Z6AAV� ��
�<�; �� [�A F�hÄÄ P�� [�/Y&�� 'A� �:�I ��U�� �� PU�� C ,!
i1ghttp://bioserv.fiu.edu/~walterm/FallSpring/review1_fall05
_chap_cell3.htm*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�3 b�"� �;´s PA� >��; lI 5��6��8�� E�5;I !j� 4�� v�� ��DNA F� ��N�<��e��;�8�� ¦�\, k� �K� §�)� lI .�|� +31 ��f�� ����� �L?� ��
F� ���/ 2�}���� [W ���� P�� #3 2# [R��� � ���3− 2�}��� �+�5;I 2=�_ ��PA� >��; !a�� −, �� �� Y8��A�� �5©� ���3 E�5;�� b�"��× DNA �"8��
����A#V� Ps�e ¦��\�N� E�� 7�� �������– FV� >��y− �� � j�� E�� �� 4_�}�/ ��sP -��5=/ P=�� � ��a/�,�Ighi *
��U� G´s ,�2pV� 4_�}�� � j�� P3�AMV� >��y�� �� ��j)� 2#3�RNA � lI >��y�� !6p3 b�"_ ��N��� b��8���– 4_�}�� � j_ G�K�– C
b%3��<��cytoplasm� , �� H/ Cb��8���� lI J�?L�� V� G´s Ps�< PA��q �8<;�, � �����3 F� G�K� �Pc� �L� m�y�A�T� F0 �+(��G��k�� P�+)� �+�5;´3 g�i*
!j_ G/ ��� P��?�= PAKy� �,W_ b��8���� lI 4_�}�� � j_ >��u, �� C P��A#V� PwFAsDNA G���K�� Pw� Y?codon �� G�KFV� ����– P =�Z; 2���R–, )� PwF� 4� C �� PwF� Y? Y �k� �6�Ä ����Ä – Y �/ �Ò «�; −, �;´s Y �k� �6)� Pw� lI G���K�� Pw� P��_ !=k�
P3��R b��8���� C 2=��hÄÄ P�Z��3 ±�¯ �.5=*
Pjj\�V� P�Z�� 2#3� P�@�3 b�"� ��#3k� YH%H �(�e lI >��y�� ��p�_
i1g Friedberg EC (February 2006). "The eureka enzyme: the discovery of
DNA polymerase". Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 7* i2g http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/602542/ transfer -RNA-tRNA*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
76<F�"4_�}��"ghi * !6#_���� !e �� P"3�<�� ��U#��� -!Ky3 ��_�3��A� P¥�yV ���5��
�P~= ��3�?O� -Ee 43 -!(�? �� ��q �� P��k� ���V�� ��:� V� ��§�M , �K� !e -�� n�p�� � ? -PR23 E�� _�*
��uk� �� 2�2#A� P"N� �V� ��e�)� C ���K�� EW ��� ���<� GI !#���3 P Rk� rA_ ��q ��− -b�:<;�3 b�_− ��"#�� S?L� ��k *
r;�e� PA� ��U� �� PU� !e !a�� >2�2y�� Pjj\��� �� r?�; PpAjV P��d� �(�� 3 P6W;k� mL? !e �� ¦�� G/ �K� ,PA"�<� �;�j� b��/
�+Ae �� m�M<; G/ �M�<; �� !e §��� �:�I �& Y)� �(�K��* C� ���V� x�#�� �L?��� ��q�y ��U# � �w3 �;/ P�f3 n12; ;PR1�
P6,� G´s ,PN2 &�� P#8M�� b�A� �� � �2� P6e�ZV� Ps�#V� !e �� �W �� v<3/ 7�� E6j_��U#�� mL? -!Ky3 � _12"� �� ¦1�a ��/ !��e *
�}e ��#��=� >1�8= �;�j�� PR%6� -b�A� �� rA6; �� !K3 �p s � �; %s ,PA� �?��_ Y��� ��;���&� �� 2��� G����? ¦��;I �� 5:#;
G����&�– 4��<;��einsulin �K<�� Ê�V − �� b���� �+���� �%a �� �IP)� �� (�K�� ����W �*
G����&� SeZ3 b���� � 6A� �6s �� � ;´s ,�# j_ 5e���� Õ2 &� �AKu� ����N Y� �(�e !a�� P��� ��A6� �� �+���� G�� m2��_ �� 5:#; r�O
i1g http://www.elmhurst.edu/~chm/vchembook/584proteinsyn .html*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��;��)� �#8e ��%� �2#�� �/ ��Ze�8��e PA� 2��*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
æc@Õj�@bß@Ý×@åß@…ì–Ô½aZ@ @ �,Ae ��1�u�� -!Ky3 � � Y��_ �� ��=�3 ��8��"�V� � j*
?���B� T�81� F*z^ ����t�1� ¦#�� �s�B ;(� p� �/�� !e �U F�����W ,P�1�j�� J1�:�A� �,<�; P6A#�� P��W; �?�}�#As
�,U�� ��#M�<� G/ lI −��A#�� ���−! GI �«��� EA#�� rA�3 b�"�� P�AK_ !6p��� ���q�\V�3 b�"� �,s ;�.�=
-��j_� �� �;k ���q�\V� �<�; �pj� G/ � K6� �L�� ,Y8��:��� !�2��3 E(��>2�2©� '(�")� ��c C �<� 3 *
^<�_� >�)� !{/ ^<�_ C ��1L�� !y���3 �Z#� .��V� EA#�� G�e �OI�� !{k > Áf�� PU"e �"�V� � j��3 EA#�� �"F� G/ �;�V� +s ,PA� 1�,@ ,>�)
���3�H � �2R EA#�� �U�� � �;/ ��y; ^<�_ �M�<� !��K�� .��� !AB ®�� G/ ��"�V� � j�� �� �,���N �� ��� E�N >�)�!
� j�� 9�q G/ �V�q� ,G�"_�� P��� P_���A#� P��W � P)� PA� G/ +3� �"�V� ��23 Ps�#V� �� Y 8� ,s ,!,©� ��� �6A� «����*
F� ��L��3 �+���� �L? G/ °�� �,W G/�"�V� � j�� 1�8�a%� !3�R –P6A� PUR �,s �����3�−p{ 2�2p�� >2���� P"��M��s , Pc�s P�/ P �� Y?
,��UaI S·� ,Y� Y6A� 1�a ���3 ��Z��� �%a� >2�2u EA#�� ±(�j±p���� PA3�w��*
�K� 2�2y�� [N� �s1 �? b��� ��)� S8<3 ���2�3� �"�V� � j��
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
���� ���2"� C �?��WË F� S��� � P���)I P ,�, � ¿\��� rA_ !ys E�1!d� P��?�©� PA~Nk� �� P3�=�� C P���V� ���2"V� : ��� ?>�)� ��y; [e
)� Y? ��� ?�?12j�³=��V� «���;�� t2� [e� ?>� >Zs C P)� �� (�KA� .}��K�� �� P��23Cambrian period �8<; >^j"��� ?� mL? ��,@ [e
?2"#��� P��� P6W;k� 4�1�M��� PAKy� E& ��eO �O´s ,2<_ § Ý�s /28� �� G�y#� E�/ � ���6�
P)� ��%� v<3/ G/ �� ,v<3/ ��%a lI r;�A" � E�´s 2�2y�� PA� 2"#_Pjj\�V� �� _�}�� ��o �� .��B §%q�� ��*
���1 b��R� ;��� ��� GI 4�1�M��� ,'(�"� � -���a �� P6(�R '(�"� �� �"�V� � j�� b��R + 3 ;]3��H � -��+���� ,2{1 � -x��s�
P� -P��W � !K� .�:�I 2{1� PA"� �+A<�� ��À23�* �0(� �J� ��� ���B m���3 EA#��3 �s2�� lI 1�M��� �� �p8V� �L? P��� C
,�"�V� � j�� PUR�1� S��a�?1� �G§ y*@J�1 (�(j FD��� �0(1� l`� �? _�1� S�*t�B�5 _3��A�1� ,@�1� F@8�B �GRV� Tz¨W�1� ,©�� %j� v0 F*<�
F�5�R1� Sp��B� c ����$�� E,�s��{ GI� P���V� >��� G/ n12; �� e GI� , mL?;� ��+�?� �?�^#� �As >��2�� A� 73�_ P���"���� E���2"� Gk E�k� ,r�O E,
���2��� P��28�� L � � AR +e"P���)I P����" G�e GI� ,!�28��3 ��A8"� �� �L��P��/ ]8H/� � ��2R ¶N1/� �P:� ��R/ *
��� ��� � �� ��� ������� ��� � �� ��� ������� ��� � �� ��� ������� ��� � �� ��� ����
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
K��q�� �p��o��n��m��l�� kj��i��h��g�� � � �f��e�� � � �d��c��q���p��o��n��m��l�� kj��i��h��g�� � � �f��e�� � � �d��c��q���p��o��n��m��l�� kj��i��h��g�� � � �f��e�� � � �d��c��q���p��o��n��m��l�� kj��i��h��g�� � � �f��e�� � � �d��c��}��|��{� �z��y� � � � � � �x��w��v��u��t��s��r��}��|��{� �z��y� � � � � � �x��w��v��u��t��s��r��}��|��{� �z��y� � � � � � �x��w��v��u��t��s��r��}��|��{� �z��y� � � � � � �x��w��v��u��t��s��r��o���n��m����� �l��k��j��ih��g��f��ed��c��b���a��`��_��~��o���n��m����� �l��k��j��ih��g��f��ed��c��b���a��`��_��~��o���n��m����� �l��k��j��ih��g��f��ed��c��b���a��`��_��~��o���n��m����� �l��k��j��ih��g��f��ed��c��b���a��`��_��~���{��z��y��x���w��v��u��t��s��r��q��p���{��z��y��x���w��v��u��t��s��r��q��p���{��z��y��x���w��v��u��t��s��r��q��p���{��z��y��x���w��v��u��t��s��r��q��p�����¬� �«� � � � � � �ª��©��¨� �§� �¦�� �¥� �¤�� � �£� � ¢¡� ��� �~� � }|�����¬� �«� � � � � � �ª��©��¨� �§� �¦�� �¥� �¤�� � �£� � ¢¡� ��� �~� � }|�����¬� �«� � � � � � �ª��©��¨� �§� �¦�� �¥� �¤�� � �£� � ¢¡� ��� �~� � }|�����¬� �«� � � � � � �ª��©��¨� �§� �¦�� �¥� �¤�� � �£� � ¢¡� ��� �~� � }|
��³²��±��°��¯��®��³²��±��°��¯��®��³²��±��°��¯��®��³²��±��°��¯��®��»��º��¹��¸¶��µ��� �´��»��º��¹��¸¶��µ��� �´��»��º��¹��¸¶��µ��� �´��»��º��¹��¸¶��µ��� �´������È� �Ç� � � �Æ� �Å��Ä��Ã� �Â�� � �Á� �À�� �¿� �¾��½� �¼������È� �Ç� � � �Æ� �Å��Ä��Ã� �Â�� � �Á� �À�� �¿� �¾��½� �¼������È� �Ç� � � �Æ� �Å��Ä��Ã� �Â�� � �Á� �À�� �¿� �¾��½� �¼������È� �Ç� � � �Æ� �Å��Ä��Ã� �Â�� � �Á� �À�� �¿� �¾��½� �¼
���Ó��Ò��Ñ��Ð��Ï��ÎÍ��Ì��Ë��ÊÉ���Ó��Ò��Ñ��Ð��Ï��ÎÍ��Ì��Ë��ÊÉ���Ó��Ò��Ñ��Ð��Ï��ÎÍ��Ì��Ë��ÊÉ���Ó��Ò��Ñ��Ð��Ï��ÎÍ��Ì��Ë��ÊÉ��F� � E� � D� � C� � B� � A��F� � E� � D� � C� � B� � A��F� � E� � D� � C� � B� � A��F� � E� � D� � C� � B� � A��W���V� �U������� � � � � � �T��S��R��Q��P��ON� �M� �L���KJ� �I� �H� ��G��W���V� �U������� � � � � � �T��S��R��Q��P��ON� �M� �L���KJ� �I� �H� ��G��W���V� �U������� � � � � � �T��S��R��Q��P��ON� �M� �L���KJ� �I� �H� ��G��W���V� �U������� � � � � � �T��S��R��Q��P��ON� �M� �L���KJ� �I� �H� ��G��h� � g� � f� � e� � d� � � � � � c� � b� � a`� � � _� � ^� � ]� � \� � [� � Z� � � � Y� � � X��h� � g� � f� � e� � d� � � � � � c� � b� � a`� � � _� � ^� � ]� � \� � [� � Z� � � � Y� � � X��h� � g� � f� � e� � d� � � � � � c� � b� � a`� � � _� � ^� � ]� � \� � [� � Z� � � � Y� � � X��h� � g� � f� � e� � d� � � � � � c� � b� � a`� � � _� � ^� � ]� � \� � [� � Z� � � � Y� � � X
� � o� � � � n� � m� � lk� � j� � i� � o� � � � n� � m� � lk� � j� � i� � o� � � � n� � m� � lk� � j� � i� � o� � � � n� � m� � lk� � j� � i������������������z� � y� � x� � w� � v� � u� � t� � s� � rq� � p������������������z� � y� � x� � w� � v� � u� � t� � s� � rq� � p������������������z� � y� � x� � w� � v� � u� � t� � s� � rq� � p������������������z� � y� � x� � w� � v� � u� � t� � s� � rq� � p��j����i��h��g��f��e��d����c��b��a��`��_��~��}�������|��{��j����i��h��g��f��e��d����c��b��a��`��_��~��}�������|��{��j����i��h��g��f��e��d����c��b��a��`��_��~��}�������|��{��j����i��h��g��f��e��d����c��b��a��`��_��~��}�������|��{
w��v�����������u��t��s��r��q��p��o���n��m��l��������kw��v�����������u��t��s��r��q��p��o���n��m��l��������kw��v�����������u��t��s��r��q��p��o���n��m��l��������kw��v�����������u��t��s��r��q��p��o���n��m��l��������kL }ÝàäÛa@ñ‰ì�@ZUYMUV{@ @
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
الفصل الرابع تشكيكات امللحدين
_…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A ÞìÜyë@pýØ’ß@ @
لماذا توجد التشكيكات؟لماذا توجد التشكيكات؟لماذا توجد التشكيكات؟لماذا توجد التشكيكات؟
��R ��l�#_:����Ñ����Ð���Ï��Î��Í��Ì��Ë��Ê��É���ÈØ��×��Ö��Õ��Ô��Ó��Ò�ghi*
�R<� Z�^: Û �� [Ks ,r�O �� !#s ��� ,�,A?/ �de�3 �;2�� ]��� 2"� ���?�A#sÜ*
C �� N� ,P6K)� ���a [AK��� C �� N� ,[AK��� �"Aa C �� P N GIN� � Æ� F5(����� ,�,"(�R� P6K)� !#= �� º��� , �§�� Y�a �� �� EA#� +3 �2�
EA#� +3 ��2�N�� �� ���0 � �3�:� !,· �¤* لكن لماذا ال توجد الحجة الحاسمة؟لكن لماذا ال توجد الحجة الحاسمة؟لكن لماذا ال توجد الحجة الحاسمة؟لكن لماذا ال توجد الحجة الحاسمة؟
���R �: I F� �� P;%��� P:)� G��K�� 7��;�� ��#6�=�� $� �� ��� �2=, �,s $� �� ����/� J�<)� T� �� [AK��� !{�3 �!?�=*
[AK��� !{�s�W ��� !"#�� �+�I �� b�"�* �� P��k� C �W ��s ���<�� �W; G�23 �K� ,4"�� 2 G+��� �8j�� �6©� ��
��1��Mc��, [AK��� 7 #� �� P��N��� ��j"� Q� �L?�! ��W) �3� ��V� G/ r�O lI [c/–�� �Ò1 .�©� �3� ��"� +e − G/ +s
SAM� 7�� -4"� �� G�<;�� ��"� ,�� �ao � �2 N �/ m^� ���� ���� .12� +s
ihg P��� ,��a5�� >1�N :g i
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
2#3 m^� ,'3�N -4"� �� -]R� �� Y,� � � rAs C �8<_� 1�2_ ��"#�� �LK?��� 2�* � �&�/ 7<;k �:)� ���� �6#�� ��q ��� �6#�� PAR ]8N�; '(�")�
�?�ao �_��^��]��\��[��Z��Y��X��W���V��U�ghi* �8� ��3 G+��� !WN� �P��<� nZ� 7�� ,G��5�� �ao lI� �28�� L � �
1�8�a�� G2#� �? �L?� 1��¯ G/ SA"A�* ,�� �"s�N §2j3 2,�· .L��� ��Rl�#_ : ���Ó��Ò��� �Ñ��Ð��Ï��Î
�g�i* ,8u !e 12j� �? Q� �� ��? !WN� ��,8y�� ]Aa� ��� ,>�,u� -P
- -X��� SAR � , -P��M3 �I ]#�_1� �� ,>�,y3 �I - de �� ��#� �;/ �� !Us �� !�5�� �� ���×� �Ö� �Õ� �Ô� � �Ó� � �Ò� �Ñ� �Ð��Ï
Ø�g i* Gk �I «�8_/ ��,A� 2= F� ��� �Zs S(�w�� ��#cI C �?�H/ >2?�y6A�
+,Ae G+c �� PA=�� ^;�;2�� �� !=�#�� 1� �2�� S0 G�<;�� ,���C� �B�A
�����G��F��E�������D�gÅi*
ihg P��� ,��a5�� >1�N :ghh½i* i�g P��� ,>2(�V� >1�N :ghhÇi* i g P��� ,�1�y�� >1�N :g Äi* iÅg P��� ,P��"�� >1�N :g�Ä−�hi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��" � �L� ��V� P�� u� �A#s �Ma >5��w��� >�M���3 �6A� �� ���?k� �#8� ,m��?� ��%q��,� ,? Q� '��M�� G/ ��2�� �%a � � 43 «���� t20 � ?
S=����� ��&� ,PpAjV�� ^6U��*
�L¥ ��,8y�� 'A#��s ,SA"�� C m�H/� Q� �� C m�H/ ��,A� G�K� 2R�3 §�j���� b��� ��� ]R��� ��� ,�Hk� ��,8y�� ���5_� �Hk� '6� ���5� ��&�
��K�� lI m1�� ����N �#3 C ��V� �~6M� 2R 7�� ,��;�e1� � �"A#_–��3 � �O��− �Hk� !�2 s ��&� b��"� 7�� r�O �� SA"�� 7"8�� ,�aF/ -����N C �W�A��
��,8y�� �#3 ÍM_�* � ��N1 ��R ,�;2�� C G�<;�� Y"3 �� «���� 7"8��EAN� �A� �� �{ � :
"�$�0 �$�0 f8<�9 ]�@�1� v0 ��V1� ©��!; F�?� %*# 2?� ��«� [@^ ;�#)�$��, ¦*5� v0 e3@^ v0 f8! ��+ )�z*5 F�?� %*# 2?� ���?�� [@^ ;��
�V81� y.�, �$�5�� $��� ��¬�� ©��� S���R1� 2��$ �� F��# l�! C#���� X��� p �*¨ ��?1�9��� �� ]«� �� p6 ��?�� �?�� p� �#l"P �*J�
,@R� x1k� �� G�<;�� Y"3 �� Q� �� �� �+(�R «���� !W<s !
!N%N� S�e 76<F_ S�e �� � _�8�K� C ¦��� �� !8R/ � r�O !=/ ��� Pq�/� ��2A�� ����N���"��,8y�� �� ����" �� -«�z C � ;�e� ,
Y,� _ � -��,8u* ,���Ku�� � ��&� �� ,��,8y�� � Q� �� �� Y"")� «���� G/ �R�����
}e/� �?12"3 �8AR C P,8u >�L= ���M;� >�,u �<�; C ]A�2;� ���*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�de/ � Q� �� ��? �� «�z� ,[AK_ +;I� ��,8u ]<� PU"��s! Q� !j��� �L? C x���N �L�� ,��j�/� -��=%� �/ ���1� -��,8u !3
���3 �� ¿M _ �� P�\N �,A{/ C P,8y�� G/ [e C �K��A� !(�N� Y?�;�eO +e -S;L3 �I ]"A� �� �K� ,'"p��� 4�*
2pAV� �,c�#� Y��� �����qk� �,uk !j��� �L? C x�#; G/ !8R�P��? P""� 1�"; P��28�� C ,ª�#�� : �;/ Y?� �As P#8M�� �3� G�<;�� G�e ��
�3 �#y�,� � #� E,�� ��� P,8y�� �� �M ��d�� !j��� P��� C �;1�R +e! EA@ �� �Ma .��V� `�#�� C 2=�� �� ,�� !e n� FB P���V� ��6�)� Gk ��)�� ��=� b2� �� !�� }e/ P,8y�� G/ �+(�� ��R/ �;�s �L� ,� �� ^a ��
G�<;�� >�?�@ ^<��� �Aj� � �;/�O´s , G/ EA#As P,8u ��=�3 G�<;�� �#u �E?� ��)�� ! P��)�� ,1�q�� �L? ��:�_ � P#8q P"A� F� >��� !"#�� Gk
Y? .��)�� ¦O�6 �� C P6e�)� P<� ��A� �P<�; �P��� ,9��A� Q�� >�+ �����3���a/ �P���� �P��� ³ÝMÆ F� G/ �,F K6� � ,�_ �? Á��1L�� F�q� _ 7�ps ��
� �"s��� b�� �� �s �Ma � Pppj�� ÁP(��5��� 4;��"A�* ��)�� �Ma Y #� $�Nk� C ��,8y�� ��=�s*
���R 7"8� � 7�� ��KKy���� �����qk� �,u/ x�# N -!e ���!(�"�!
...فإلى الرحلة����
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A òîöbíŒîÏ@pübØ‘g@ @
))))A Universe from NothingA Universe from NothingA Universe from NothingA Universe from Nothing(((( كون من ال شيءكون من ال شيءكون من ال شيءكون من ال شيء
V� ��"�2pA : �(��5s ��� �� ��= G�K��$���e Q;�1�� 1�" F� +e �! :الرد
$���e Q;�1�� 2pAV� �?�K�� b�RLawrence M. Krauss 9�M3 J��e"�� � �� G�e" A Universe from Nothing s�� �3��e C xZ
��%�� G/� ,��� �� ��= G�K�� G/ �L?Nothing �? Y"")� m� #63G�K� !e C rA_ �����q�3 1�q� ,G�K�� 12j�*
G�e �� P���qk� mL?� ¦};5��? �;^sWerner Heisenberg Á ����Vk� ���5��� 4"�� b2� /28� [y�K� ^8K�� P8���� /28� �/uncertainty
principle �� Q;�1�� �� ��0���� mL? S8<3 P�12{ Pp3L3 S{k �$���e*
È};5��? ��y�e� .L�� 4"�� b2� /28����8V� �� Y(��5s /28� �?X Y��� Æ# F�� ,G�K�� EKB �2 Pd�2)� ���5��� QNF/ E?/ 2�/� , �� 4"�� b2� /28� ±F Æ�
�;/ :" P� Fº� �R�� 2�2B !p�<� P�1L�� G�� �+<©� 2�/ -]R� C 2���" ,2��� -Go C E<©� P� Fº� �R�� Ps�#� �� G��� ¤ �p s*
� Æ# F� ã2 ;�;�R 4"�� b2� /28� �� �1�{ �� -!Ku .�3 v8_�� �� ,P#8M�� 4;��R �� �? !3 ,2{��� �� � _�12"3 �/ ,� _5,=/ C ��=�V� 1�j"�� �#83 ��Kuk� ��
,��e G�;�R ÁMs PA� Â��a �� 4� ÆN�" F� 4�{�a 2�2B �K6� � G�;�"A� ��"8 P��6equanta –.1O G�� E<=−, ]R��� Q�; C*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
,4"�� b2� /28� �� ��8� -b�2{ C $���e Q;�1�� P���q/ ®�_� P~u%�� 1�"�� /28V� !?�:�� $���e Q;�1�AsNothing �/"b2#��" b5·�
G�KA� ��12j� ���3 *� ��=� Y�; ���"_ 4"�� b2� /28V � �"8q !p�<V� �� �;/ � �;��� ��;�K� E<©� ]R��� Q�; C �– �(��5s !p�<�b2#�� ��8HI �− G/ ��´s ,
�/ 4�{�� Y� 3 b5� G/ !p�<�� ���º ��#_ �/ E<©� G�K� ��#_� �#� +��8HI!
]8dF_ G/ !p�<� �����3�" ��%��nothing "* ]8dF_ G/ !p�<�" b2#��Null " �(��5s�*
�� E�5_ P_� ,e P�<A�� ��8H�� �L? �%a �� QN|_ G/ �� �%Us �L? !K3 `�#�� ��·I �? 1�2�� �L? G/ ]8d_ G/ �� �%Us ,1�� �� b2#�� �L? G/ �&%a
�s ��! �� ./ �� È1���� ��U���s–b2#��− [��¯� ,���5��� QN/ [��¯ /28�
�;�3 b5©� �� �%Us ,m��=�3 b5©� !p�<� �L? !e �� �%Us ,4"�� b2�$���e Q;�1�� �?�K�� E�5� +e G�K�� �L? 12j�!
P��6e ��_���_ P�/ �� �A¯ G/ �K6� � È����� GI !3Quantum
Flactuations–P�1O G�� �+<=− ��0z � �e�,�;� ��k� �L? �8{k �I� , b2� /28V��K�� 4"��*
��2pA� 7 #� %s ,G�KV� 1�qI� G��5�� 1�qI C 2=�� Y��6K�� ���������5��� !a�� G�K�%��� G��%�� ��!
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P ,e b�?�/ �� !"� � � � � P���)�� $���e P���q/ �8j_ �����3� P6w;� ,EA#�� �? �;/ �c�Zs�� ,�p:8_ C �,A� �A#� � K� ,P H��� ��;��2��" �;/
EK � 7eO/" �_����q/ C >��=�V�! ��e /28� J1�0� EA#�� �2p�� �;/ �? $���e Q;�1�� �3 b�R +s– /28�
4"�� b2�− J�#�� G�2pAV� 7 8�� EÆH ��� ,®� ,K�� m��)� ���Z�� !=/ ���_����q/*
L? G/� EA#�� �? m��)I G/ E�5� ª�� 2pA� ®�� ��2 #s �L�� �� 9�M�� � �6A� 2(�<�� �? $���e � :�5� �� �A"� ¦%� [��K_ � A Ý6 F0 � �,���<s �
G�O�� �A6�B � -9�8 3* '8N �� S;�= lI : 'AM V� Q�; �� �3��e C $���e Q;�1�� xZ��
G/ ��)� .��2�� : .��<_ P8��<�� G�K�� PR�q S;�= lI P8=�V� G�K�� PR�q�� G�K��s �����3� ;��j��b2� �!
��<As PMR�N P���qk� mL?��<As �,q�"N G�3 !8R �K� ,� � G/ � � �!(�<�; : G�K�� P�2� G�3 b5:A� $���e Q;�1�� ��2� .L�� ��– ��R�q «�6�
��jA� .��<V�− ?��)�� PpAj� C SjN !q�3 �w� ��� � V�� !e G/ �/ ��w� ��� � V�� G/ r�Le G�2e|� G�6A<V� Q�/ ?!q�3
?È1�s �w�� 1��� G�K�� ��=� G/ E�5; � <�/ �������c��b� � � �a��`��_��^��]��\��[�� � � � � �Z��Y��X
��s��rq��p��o��n�����m��l��k��j��i��h��g���������������f��ed
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
a��`��_��~��}��|��{z��y��x�����w��v��u��t�ghi* ^� �ao �� G�K� �/ S· !Ke §�A\V� ��=��� GI !3 %3 �,s ,b2#��
P�k� P&�� ��L�� �� PA3�"6A� �=� �� 7 #� �� P6R! ?r�O C PAKyV� �� ,x1�� .1�8��� ��=� �? !Ke �;��=�s ��� �? ��R�q !e� �_��� !K3 G�K�� G/ r�O �� � Á !3"P6e PA�"
�?2{�; 4� �I 2=�_ �� �,W_ � ,Y(��5��� �?� #63 ! ^<�_ 1�"� +eP=�V� P��2A� �=�, 3�e*
G/ P"3�<�� >1�8#�� ^<�_� : �W ; 4� �I �_�O C �� 7 #� �� ��= �� G�K�� �,W_� �+<= lI Pp8y�� ��=�V� ��p�_ v"s �,���<s ,m2{�; �/ ��I
?§2j_ !? ,n%sk� ��1� ��� n%sk� � ;�e P""� Y? mL? E#; !K�� G/ P6K�� ���5��� � �6A� 2"s �� ��=� � G�
m2{1 E�� 4� �I �� 7 #� �� �_�O C–����1−* lI ��p�� m2{1 Y��¯ 4�� m2{�� �63 v8_�� !q�3 �w� ��� G�K��s
J�º! ��M#� 2�/ 7"8_ �, K� ��^dKA� Py?2� P6A#�� '(�")� mL? G�K_ 2R
�6s ,P6K�� ���5��� EK�� ���5s 1�W � G´s >��{�V� ��;��K��quanta – !d���U�� ��;�_�s − �,�I �W _ � ��2 �� ,�,�I �W �� 4� �I E<:e �,W_ �
�8�� �:� � .L�� �p<�� !e §��� +31 �L?� ,P=�6e ���_ ��´s!
ihg P��� ,2�2)� >1�N :g�Äi
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��3�? r; ^,y�� Y(��5��� ��"�Nick Herbert :" !#· ��k� �L?^<� �?� ��Aa G/ !\�� G��k� �#3 G�<;��, ��p��=�� lI `�#�� -P ��
E�;��K�� ��×<� lI `�#�� ��p��� ¿K�� G�3�L��, ��� �K�/ �^� ��Aa ]��A� Gk�� 26:�_ ��uk�3 �OI ��<)�k�� 1�:u P���#�� �,�#8M� ��#_� 1�:�
Ps���V��* ��#� ` .L�� rAV� r�O >1�MN/ !d� >1�MN/ !a�� Í#; 'M V� �L¥ � ;I
� Q6A� �_�� C���); k �� �;/S?O lI ��p�� �<6A� G, PAH�¤ P"��M3 �L?� �8y�/ ËG �M�<� �� G�<;��/ áG ��U�� E<= P""� }�¯; k ËG �<6A; �� !e
>��� lI ��p��"ghi*
EW#�� E6j��� �,uk� �3��e C � e��? ���N S�e 2R�the Grand
Design G/ $��<�� !j��� C :" �� �%"�<� ��~u Q� G�K�� G/ >�Ks 2{����–G�<;��− r�Le ]<� �, K� Y6A� ��a� Py?2� �28_ 2R– Y,s
P6A� P""�−"* The idea that the universe does not have a unique
observer-independent history might seem to conflict with
certain facts we know, that might sound like science
fiction, but it isn’t*
i1g Nick Herbert, "How Large is Starlight? A Brief Look at Quantum
Reality," Revision 10, no. 1 (Summer 1987), pp. 31-35*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
� �U�/ ��R� :" .L�� �? ¶�1���� Q�� ,2{��� }� ¶�1���� � j; � Æ� �p;� # j�*"
”We create history by our observation, rather than
history creating us*“
��R� :"�� �� S<ps ¶�1���� 26�#� � Q�� m2{�;��""� C �Ì�� �"* ” The histories that contribute to the Feynman sum
don’t have an independent existence, but depend on what
is being measured. We create history by our observation,
rather than history creating us. The idea that the universe
does not have a unique observer-independent history
might seem to conflict with certain facts we know*"
� ��� �� `�#A� P�\V� P����� mL? , P""� lI ��p�� � `�#�� G/ 1�"_� � � 8 Á� �OI m��=� �� �\��� ,� ��� � ;�?O/ C »� �OI �I >��=��!
G�K� G/ 23%s �����3� lI >1�j�� mL¥ G�K�� »�/ �/ �(�e n� ?u G�K�� !#=� ,� ;�?O/��~ ���?�@� �\<F� �? +;I� ,�_�O C �� P""� P6R �
�A Fe� m��=�3 � ��� �;��=��* �(��5s �LK?� � �A#s ��=��� �L? 5e�� �p; ^j;� ,��6R� m^\<_ 5e��� ,
C 7 #� �/ �_�O C P6R �� �8j_ �� 7��2�_� ,P���V� P�<A��� 1�, _ r�L3� ,�_�O �!AR �K�� ,P�<A��� ���^W _ !e �32�� ��, �!AR� ËG/ n12� �� �;2�� >�)�
F��� -��=� �de/ � .�?�@ .1��� ���c���b��a��`��_��^�����]��\
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
d �ghi* �;2�� >�)�s>�?�@ ÁR��P3�º P & P6R �� ,�""� C� ���P� �O��N
�W��V�����U��T��S����R��Q�g�i * +e ��)� � �1�j�;� Q� �_�O C G�K�� P�2#� 1�j�;��s r�O !=/ ���
G+�� 1�j�;� �? !3 $���e Q;�1�� !\��! G�K�� P�2� G/ EA#_ G/ rA� ,G+�� 1�j�;� �? � ;�e P�2� G/ 2e����
;/ Y #_ ��� ��=�� �? !3 ��=�� ^� � ��1�8��* ����,��=�%�� �� [A�¯ .1�8���� ��= Y��� P�<A��� PM��wV� Y? mL?�
$���e Q;�1�� �,s �R�* ¥��� 7�� �9W�: ;/ Y #_ � G�K�� P�2� ��=�� �? !3 ��=�� ^� �
��1�8�����=�%�� �� [A�¯ .1�8���� ��=���� ,�! ���N $���e Q;�1���–P�<A��� QN�3 �%,=− 43 .1�8���� ��=���
��=��� b2�� * G�K�� PR�q .��<_ P8=�V� G�K�� PR�q G/ �V�q �;/ xZs�sK�� GOI P8��<�� ��<As �Ma � K� ��c��1 �p{ �L?� ,b2#�� .��<� G��*
��2 #s �c��1 ��)� �_�; G´s � ��~3 ��B �~u 9�M� � �~8�� lI [cF/ �OI � �� ¸��1 1�W � �� � �2�2= �#R�� �K� ,.2��[A�¯ ��k� �, ��� F� �~3 n� ,s
!6� �_�; n� ?� Y=1�a !a2_ n� ?�*
ihg P��� ,PH�©� >1�N :g ½i* i�g P��� ,b���� >1�N :gÃi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
���e �Ma/ � ,s ��<As ��Ma $ G/ xZs� �,s ;[#U��� [\<�� C P��� �G�K�� ��=� b2� Y #� P8��<�� P�R�M3 P8=�V� G�K�� PR�q .��<_ !
� G�K�� �K� ��1�8��� �=�a/ 2 Á=�� �� GOI ��=� �� � �?�W�� lI b2#�� ��R� .1�8���� +e P�2#�� ��""� lI ��#N �?2#3� ,�;�p8N �"��a ��y� G/ lI �
G�e���dc��b��a��`�������������_��^]��\����������[��Z��Y��X��j�������������i��h��gf��e�ghi*
!في اآلية هي كلمة معجزة" الكتب"وبالمناسبة كلمة
.��<�_ ��2 #sP8��<�� ��R�M3 P8=�V� G�K�� PR�q, YH%H �M<� ^j� �;´s�N�; P��e� °�� �L?� ,� ���� J��K��e ��#3k�*
the geometry of the universe is flat, like a sheet of
paper g2iP
G�K�� !Ky� P;o�"�� PW�A�� � �U�/"J��e" Pp�{ PW�� �� §�/" sheet
of paper" �N�; ���1�/ Y��� ��#3k� Y(� H Q�� ��#3k� YH%H G�K�� GkPR1�A� � � J��KA� J�R/ �? �����3�*
�3 }a/ �� '3�M_ Y6N��� �N�; �R�� �� G�K�� !Ky� P6A� >5:#� mL,s w�� 7��� G�e �!=1/� [�/ L � PK� !?k v�1��R �� E �� �{ b�� P(+#31
EAN� �A� *
ihg P��� ,��8;k� >1�N :ghÄÅi* i2g http://map.gsfc.nasa.gov/universe/uni_shape.html.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
2e|;� $���e Q;�1�A� ��#; b2#�� G/ 1 ��j_ 4� �Ma/ �;/ Pc��1 P"��M3 +,��; G/ +3� ,G����6�� G�����<�� P8=�� PR�q� P8��N PR�q �� >1�8� 'AMV�
'AM� b2� +,s GOI � ���{ .��<�* ./: �? $���e 2 � 'AMV� b2#�� G/+ghg + i−h = i��{*
C P~u � �? !3 �� � v"s Q� 'AMV� b2#�� G/ 4� C 'AMV� b2#��* G/ 1�j�s �L��+ghg + i−h = i ^� 1�j_ �? 'AMV� b2#�� !d� ��{
E#; ,�p{+ghg + i−h = i � 'AM� b2� Q� �K�� ¸��1 b2� �? ��{�s P~u*
!a2_� !6� n� ? �K� ,�� ��)� �_�;� �~8�� P���#� C !a2� ` !#���8s� ��� ]:�;/ >��1I� P6K�� Y���/ �� �~8� �c��1 «�6:V� �_� �� G .��<� �G�K�� �� '8M � �<�; ��k�� ,��{!
��6K�� �;�p8N �� P��R �� �2� G�K�� ��·I G´s ¿"#�� $�"�� Q� 3��_12R EW�� �_��1I�*
���� G�K�� 7��a� Go !e C ��=��� �L? !e ��� � A� �b��R �� G/ ���� !Ke P���#V�s ,���2#�–#���G�K�� ��=� P� − ���_ ��""� ��~u ]<��, +;I�
�de/ � .�?�@ .1�8��� ��=�* ,��2�� Pp{ �� !�� }e/ $���e Q;�1�� !a2� G/ �U�� '8N �¤�
��<;�� ��=��� P�5e�� �� ��2�� m1 ��R �� Pp{ ���– 2{����– Py��? ��� , G�K�� ��=�– R � >��{�� P6e PA� !d6� .L�� 4� �I �& 7 #� �� �& P6
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
G�<;�� �%a �� �?2{1 E��− 4V�#�� J1 � 26)��* _åäÔ½a@åÇ@æìãbÔÛa@�ÌŽí@Ýç@ @
���N 26��� 2R� ,m1�,@� G�K�� 'A Y�K_ 4;��"�� G/ 2pAV� xZ�� +e ,G�K�� 1�,W� Y�K� P3O�©� G�;�R G/ xZs�s P�2"V� mL? �� � e��?
�e C r�O �c�/EW#�� E6j��� ^ak� �3�ghi * ,��8;k� !(�N� ��AR� _� PV�#�� [pj�� C � e��? ���"_ ��;� 2R�
Ps�dK3 P8#y�� �R��V� �����2_�! 3� �_�O E�5�� �L? T�"N �� �W �� �w G�;�R 12j� C ^K���� ��:63 �
1�,@I� !a2��� P�{ m�M�/ .L�� � Æ�� � R .L�� � Æ� �/ ,P3O�©�?�Hk� lI .�|_ � P3O�©� 4;��R G´s P��k� ��À28�� mL? �� �W �� �w3
��1�A8�� >�e P=���! � �U�/ >�K�� G´s ��1�A8�� �j�� ��1�A3 >�e �� P3O�©� 4;��R � �c/ ��� >�K3 n�<�Ö� !6�� 2,=� !a2_ lI ¦��p N � �U�/ �p s ,¦��2�_ ��
?� �j#��3 �,#s� EH ��1�A8��P3O�©� 4;��R �,W_ v"s � * s �%"�<� ��~u Q� P3O�©� G�;�" Y#8q t2) ®���#� [{� �? +;I�!
��1�A8�� �j� �� vwU_ >�R G�� ��1�A8�� >�e n Ý� F0 �� P3O�©� G�;�R�
i1g Because there is a law such as gravity, the universe can and will create
itself from nothing.
Stephen Hawking and Leonard Mlodinow, The Grand Design, 2010.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P3O�©� G�;�R �H/ �,W�� ��1�A8�� >�e n�p�_ v"s � ?� �,e�B�! =� G/ xZ�� 2pAV� �K� ��1�A8�� >�e 'A Y�K_ P3O�©� 4;��R ��
>�K�� P=���� ��1�A8�� �j��* 'M V�� !"#�� �� ��3�R �de/ +À/ :?��)�� b/ ��2��
>1�N 1�_�� 'A� �� >1�<�� 1�_�� C ¿a�2�� §�Z��� 4;��R !dV�3�* _�V� G´s >1�<�� 1�_�� lI ¿a�2�� §�Z��� 4;��R � �c/ ��� �� � �U�/ 1�
!8R 23�� §�Z��� >1�� �� 23�� ,PR�q YM#� .L�� ��5 8�� �� 23%s ,!6#�1�_�V� ��=� �� r�O * !6#�� ¿a�2�� §�Z��� 4;��R �,W_ S<ps � ?�
1�_�V�! >1��� 1�_�V� 'A Y�K_ ¿a�2�� §�Z��� 4;��R G/ xZ�� � �U�/ 2pAV�
'(�<��� ��5 8��� §�Z��� '��M��� *.��)�� �� ,K�� �;I!*** Q��� [Ae .2 ���k� �K�V� ��"�C.S. Lewis :" C �6©� G�;�R
� = [�/ 2(� � = [��s ,r 8�� C �KA� .L�� ¾A8V� �? �� [j� ��c����� G�;�"�� �L? r� �� F� G/ ��W�;� �� �K� ,G���/ �6©� G�;�"� � �"8q P:� �� G�K_
s�cI �����/ � �2{1 �� � G�;�"�� G/ rc�Zs� S8<3 n2{1 26:�� ��<s P�_�O ��"A_ ��!"
n��)I S8<3 n2{1 26:�� ��N* " laws of nature produce no events: they state the
pattern to which every event - if only it can be induced to
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
happen - must conform, just as the rules of arithmetic
state the pattern to which all transactions with money
must conform - if only you can get hold of any money.
Thus in one sense the laws of Nature cover the whole
field of space and time; in another, what they leave out is
precisely the whole real universe - the incessant torrent
of actual events which makes up true history. That must
come from somewhere else. To think the laws can
produce it is like thinking that you can create real money
by simply doing sums. For every law, in the last resort,
says: If you have A, then you will get B." But first catch
your A: the laws won't do it for you"g1i . PA"�<� P;� e Q� G�;�"��s, >�?�WA� ¸��1 [{�_ �? +;I�!
���+<��� P~8�� EW ��� n%sk�� G�K�� 'A¯ P3O�©� G�;�R G/ x�Zs�s�� P"R2�� >���#V� 7,� 63 �? Py?2V� P(��5��� ]3��d�� ��~V P=�)� ��2)2pA� �I �"AMF� � x�Zs�!
i1g C.S. Lewis, Miracles, p.42.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A æb�ã⁄a@ávyë@æìØÛa@òßb‚™A@ @
(J@B� Z���: �� G/ !"#F� !? !N��� � 3�;L3 E�À ���:V� mL? !e '��a -1��/ C ���� ?PM<3
:الرد
�W�� ,>2N�s �_�N�R� PAq�3 �_��2�N� G/ 2pAV� PAKy� mL¥ �;/m��e P# y3 ��� G/ �K6� P=O�<�� ��M��wV�!
��"; ��2 � !,s: I�(�j ��� ���{��� �#83 � 3� ç�/ rAV� G* Æe� �� S���"�� xZ#� ®�� G/ �K6� !? ,��3��e r�O C : 4�%� rA6� rAV [e
�6:� ¾A8� � .L�� � 3�3 E�À ,�& �� � Y��� P#N�y�� ¸�1k�� >2 sk�rAV� rA6� �¤ 1�A� 1�A� �� 2��� �;��−��k� !dV� �� − P;2sk� ��
¸�1k��? �L? Q�/ ?��I ]��A F� G/ �K6� �/ !R�� [j; �/ !R�� x�Z�� �L? !?
?4;�:V� >�� C � F0 G/ l�k� �� xZ#V� � x�Zs� �? ,P��<V� C �H|� ���äc �/ �Ì�� E:� P��\c G/ x�Zs�s
2pAV� !"� �I ���M�! �;I !3 G�<;Ö� µ)� E:)�3 >}#�� ]<� ,7�� .� #V� E:)�3 +;I�
P;��k�� §2j��� §%ak�e E:� %3 ��uk! §�s �? E?�;�/ 43� ��1�U)� EW�/ ����R/ ��L�� �8�� EW�/ 43 §����s
.��� � .� #�–§%ak� !8;� !6#�� �<�� >��"�� PKÆA� !d�− , G�e ���
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P;��k� !6p3 l�/ x1k�� ���+<�� ];�K� 1�8��� 7;�/ �� G�5� C E:pA�! G/ Y #� �L? !,s ,���V� ��1�A63 ��3��KV� �� E\c/ G��)� GI EH mL& P�2©� P6"�� ��� ?� ? E?/ P6Ae 7 #� ��� ?��3��KV� �� E?/ G��)�
P6AK�� "E?/"? ?^wj�� �(�K��3 E�À �� ����\U� E\U�� �(�K��3 E�À �� !?�
?S<;k� b�W ��� §��� �6:A� !�e �;/ b/ Á���+<�� GI EH k�� Æx1 $�32�� $/1 �� �w{/ PM"; � 12j�– �w{/
���V� ��1�A� ��1�A63 >1L�� G�_��3 �� − Y(��5s !e E�5� r�Le Q�/ ,;�3 �8A� � �"8q `�#��� Big Bang Theory ?
��B ��� Y8<; E:)� � �U�/ �As ��N/ S"H lI �,Ae P<6y�� P��6:V� ]�^w{ Q8u Qe ��:�_− ^j�� x1k� E:�Ä*Ç S#K� Z6� N− *
b�:�k�3 G�K� ��uk� �� EK)� �� b�:�k�3 ]<� PU"�� GOI��"Hk�� G��k��*
N�� ��uk� mL? n�1�I Y? PU"���¥�#�! -�� P6H !? G��� ? G�<;�� �I b�:�k� 43 ��R%#�� mL? S���<�
??G�<;�� �I §1����� n12� �� P6H ! ��2��� P��1� 'A� P6W�� n%sk� P��\c� 4;��"�� n12� �� P6H !?
? G�<;�� �I P�� #3 ^� �+©�� '< ��� P#�23� ���Ò >�1��� G/ n12� �� P6H !? ? G�<;��
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
EKB Y��� P(��5��� P��W V� P��1� n%sk� ��1�2� n12� �� P6H !? ? G�<;�� ^� G�K��
�<;�� G/ �� �+A#�� [A�¯ � GOI �e�1�I G�K�� 5e�� G �=���KN� ��, �(��5s ��d�2���, � �� �k� L �� �*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A òbm@pübØ‘g� �� �� �� �
�(J@B� Z�� : ��;��2��Í��:A= P6pA� �� !" _ P��+<��! :الرد
G2#�� m��e !{/ �L?� ,PA:#�� ���K�/� PpMN �_���R G/ 2pAV� PAKy� �_�,8u���Ã��Â�� � � � � � � � � � � � �Á�� �À��¿¾��½��¼��»��º��¹��¸�� � � � �¶��µ
Ê��É��������È��������Ç��Æ��ÅÄ�ghi* �� H� Í��:A= P6pA� C P�5���� ±j"�� G/ 2pAV� �Ws �L?� ,P����
E,��� C !Ma� �Ma* 4A3�8�� 2 � �;�;/ Y? Y��� ��:A= P6pA� C 1��y� G/ 2pAV� �W� �%d6s Y? G������ 2 � $� s �/ G�;��� 2 � ]����s/ �/ 4" ��� 2 � ��1��y� �/
P6�2"�� P H��� P&�� 2�/ * [\<�� P6R C ¦�� �N�3 P~q�� P�2"V� mL? �� ¦�¯ EH P=�L<���,
7d;k� $2"F� G�e ����23 C ��<;�� �6�:V� G/ xZ�s g1��y� �}K�� bk� i �s�y�e�3 G�<;�� �"�N� 4� .1�eO �6�� lI ��<;�� �6�:V� ��B �� 2#3�
P��15A�* P���)�� ��3��K�� C 2(�N ¦O�<�� ¦�� �N�� �L? G/ Í?2V��!
C 9�M�� �L,s ��k� �R�� C�!,©� P6R *
ihg P��� ,Q;�� >1�N :g Çi*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
A� 5�1 �� �de/ �K_ ` Í��:A= P6pA� C 1��y� G/ ��×"�;�"! ¶�1�_ C 4d��8A� � ��a|� ���;� 2R� ^de P6�2"�� E�%V� C P&��3 5�Z���
J�8�� �L? �� �� G���k�* .�wV� �, ��5_� JO�K�� �,=�,83 �;2A� 5�1 �� �de/ �K_ ` 1��y#s*
�2�� Â�j �� ®�_� P −Í��:A= P6pA� !d� − 1��y� �� ��Lp�A� −�;2��− «�23�� C P��� P�5�1 ±j"3*
r�O !=/ ��� �� rAV� �s1 2"s−.���− G/ Ñ�#�� ���� 4� ]����� �L�� ,���ao n�A� �& 2:N + 3 ,�¥ E�2"�� �q�8_1� E�1 1��y#� 2:<�
�� 4q�y��! >�a���� ��A� �� �2_1�***
K<�/���L\s �� 4q�y�� �*** ]��R� ��I �?�W; 1��y� ]3�{ EH***
m�L\s �L? ��/ghi* 12jV� :���N 9���/ ��* � �U�/ �*�(@1 (AR� �� ¦# d��A@j–��m0− y?5 %!��� ��(�5S�)���\�!AR 2#3 �%j�_ �L? �eL N� , !
«�z ��k� �,��� !KyF� ,� ���� �� � H� �� G�K�_ Í��:A= P6pA��
ihg 12jV� :���N 9���/ ��*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P\6u �: _ �� �_��,u �� G�<;��–V�P _���� >/�− �2K;/ «�"�I C − J�y��1�,�V� − �M� C*
n�1�/ lI �=12�<_�–����� ��e1���− 2#_ Y���� P6�2"�� ���N P6{��%q�� �� .�8�� Q ©� �,s�� >1�U� ��/§*
�2K;/ ��"� PjR .��� .L��� Í��:A= P6pA� �� ��d�� 9�A�� ®�� EH–1�,�V� J�y��− Í��:A:3–J�y�� G+��� .�R ��2�V�− G��1�j�� +�/ [e�
P3�� C �3�8¹ G�My�� PA_�"� �� P��, �� C � ��,= 2���_ �K� ,P��28�� C1k�*
n%¥ P6pA6A� Q��� 9�A�� Y,� �� �2K;/ 2� �� �3�8¹ G�My��1k� P3�� C Í��:A=� *
� � ��c�1 n�1�/ lI ��#�� P6 w�� La��� �3�8¹ $/1 Í��:A= «5� ������*
�,W_ �� ,Í��:A© G�K� �� 2u/ �� ����´3 $��<�� 9�A�� /28� � ?� 1��y�–�;2��− �¥ v8_�� 7�� Í��:A= .�w�� �?�&� �,� �� �,=�¥ !K3
�,�3 lI 1��y� m��2_� ,S?L��� �1�%�� ��3�#3 P��wF�s, !a2� G/ �� �;´s7�� �,�3: m2 � ���k�� ����k� �H�K_ ���5�– 2A_ ¦�# ��� t%d��3 �_�5 � 2A_
E(��_− ����k� �� �e^N�* x��#�� mL? !e �s�� OI �+W� � ��R�� Í��:A= !M8�� ["� � ?�
��y� �,WF�� ����������& ��"s �,�""� �� 1 :" J�=/� m�s ��:A= ���s1��y�:
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Á];/–1��y� ��− �M3k� �Aa�� C EMp�� �R�*** �A60 �� t�A� }R Á];/***
�A#� � b2R Â�"� !#; Á];/�*** ?� 7(5� %3+ v0 �2*�5 �^�m0 �� ¢;� ?� 7(5� %�0 �2*� �!�0 �� ¢;��"
B G/ 1�"_� 5��� 1��y� 1�d_ � ?� !?/ Sjs ^� �� n�1�/ !?/ b��� �2K;/ 5�"� � ?� ,2�2y�� J2©� n�1�/2��< C ��� �� Í��:A=
1��y� P �s �� E,�e�#�* T5�R1� ®�@1� c� �3�;O �� �2K;/ J���� �2K;/ 1�U��� ��W) /28_
P6�2"��–P\6u P _����3 ��R%� − Á6d�� �,#�j� G/ �,A� ��2�� P\6u �#A�� !�=�Z�� �,A� �(��� �� ��#� � K� ,� ���� b��� �c�� G�K_ G/� Y��j���,
��:A:3 �2K;/ Ps�#� C ��8� S8N ];�e� �&�� ]pA{/ 2R P\6ys* Pe�#� P��N C ]6� ` �;/ �� �5� �2K;/ ��6��*
T���1� ®�@1� c�: ,�2K;/ �"�2{ >�s� �� 2�2y�� G5)�3 Í��:A= �#y� �p8�� 1�"�� E�y8; �_�/ ��–b%<�� �A� 9�; Y8 ��− G�s�M�� PjR S��{;
P�23k� >�)� �� !j� .L�� EW#�� ±\y�� r�O–P ©�− �� �� 1�N �;k ,P6pAV� ��"_ +e*
�¿� ��� '��q C ^<� Í��:A:3 P6pAV� �� ��#�� 9�A�� /28�� P�\V� P�1�MNk� ��;��)�3–��"�� Q� �� �� «���� ���,y�� P�
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��8�����−; 2���� '��M�� �? P�\V� P�1�MNk� ��;��)� mL? P�1�j� Gk E�y8; �_�/ PA3�"V–b%<�� �A� 9�; Y8 ��−*
��1�p3� P6W� ����?/� P�¨ �� (�e PA��q � �1�,u Í��:A= «1�j�� P6AW�– >�,y��� ��&� 1�p3−, �#� E�y8; �_/ SR��� >2#8�� P�U�� ��� n1
��:A=! >�)� lI ��{��� � � SAM�� E�y8; �_�/ Y"�A�� ��:A= ��� !AR 2#3�
P�23k�–P ©�−, Í��:A© �(�j �� �º C E�y8; �_�/ /28� � ?�, G/ [e�G�<;I nZ� �� ��V�? �G/� ��R ���� ��º ��V� b�� !W� G/ 1 �� s�*
y8; �_�/ «�=ZN�3 �� .��)� 9�A�� /28��G�s�M�� PjR S(�:#� E�, Æ3 +,� ��2N���� G/� E,{�#� S8<3 ��2N���� rA?/ ���� G/ [e� +,�� ��
b��R E,e%,s E, e�<� ]��#_* Í��:A= E�y8; �_�/ EA#F� � ?�3P�23k� >�)� �� ��j)� P�K− P ©�−*
1L�� �K�Í��:A= �� ! P)�s–G�My��− n2,= >�6H [M�"_ G/ �K6�C Á�� $�1� 2#3� ,PW) n�1�/ lI Í��:A= ��#� Py?2� �����w�� }
m12"3 ��c�1 P6�2"�� ���N �%3 P6{��* ¯0 }�.1� ®�@1� ��� P6pAV� lI ��UF� ±; �;/ G�j�\V� G�d��8�� '��s
�º �� ��d�� 9�A�� �L? C ��#� �� ,�� .��)� 9�A�� P��, 3 Y,� _ Y��� �2K;/ ��� PjR >���I� ,�2K;k Í��:A= ��K3 !d� t�2�k� �� ^dK��
���d�� 9�A�� �À��� Y��� >1�j�� �� � ���� [A�� >1�j3*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
@åß@†iü@bäçë[pbÐÓë@ @� P�5�1– Í��:A= !�R !d�� C Â�j� E�%V��P6�2" :الوقفة األولىالوقفة األولىالوقفة األولىالوقفة األولى
�3�8¹ G�MyA�− '(�"� ���3 ���2"�� G+�I � �R%qI Y #_ �, r�O �� 7eO/ E,s�p; �6A#; +e ±j"�� �� .5���� ��j"V� G�6A#�� ^dK3* ÝA<F� E�/ 1�j�s ,���2"�� C ��8w�� xZ�� 2pAV� �K� G�6 ����� P#R��3
m12j� ���2"�� C �@ ��N � �U�/ �L?� ,¶�1���� b�A� ��3 [��3 !,= �L?����2"� P���)IP6"� *
� �=� �(""P? ::::الوقفة الثانيةالوقفة الثانيةالوقفة الثانيةالوقفة الثانية� 1��y� >��8� ]� !? E#; !b��� 7�� ���28#� $� �� �� ^dKs, ,�� H� 1��y� G�K_ G/ b5A� ��
�;�<;I Y�Ks� >�a�� �� �%�23 �;2��3 �_�� G/, �0� �_��,y� S:�<� G/��,A� ��6�� �,A�, 28� �? r�L3�� PAq EN�� �L¥ �6<� ` ��� 7�� 1��y#
m�6�* ��� E2R Y �� ±; Y? Í��:A= P6pA� !? ±; Q ::::الوقفة الثالثةالوقفة الثالثةالوقفة الثالثةالوقفة الثالثة
ª�/? �2= �?�@ �L? .L�� [��p��� Ee Y�K�� ,^W �A� ¦��0 �� � �� ]c�#_
!e C ��8��"_ ��;� Y �� ±; �;/ ��#�� Í��:A= P6pA� ,P6�2"�� ��1�U)� �j; G�e �� OI �3�/ �?����p�� Y��2�� +s �
F� �¤� Ý" V� ��y�e� �� ����B E_ ��� �?12j� Í��:A= P6pA� G/ ]8d C G�83 ���#V� .�Hk� �c�V�×"�8_ G�MAN" y�e� �� ,�e�_ C��5=/ �� �� �
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�%V� !8R ��d�� [�k� C E�2R S_�e �?1 �� P6�2R P��N1� P6pAV�, ���= 2"s���2"�� n�AV� 2�/ lI P;� #� ��:A= G�<� �� P��N��� rA_ghi*
2�2u ^w_ �,s ��= Í��:A= P6pA� G/ 48_ PA{k� �M"�� P;1�"63�P�1�u�� P8")� ���qg�i * � �e !? Y �� ±; �? Í��:A= P6pA� C �1! � ::::الوقفة الرابعةالوقفة الرابعةالوقفة الرابعةالوقفة الرابعة
?�p{ �;�eO +e [��p���s 2�2u �Ma �L? �P?�23 �2= ^8e,� �� ��d�� 9�A���
G�KN �3 ��o .L�� Y �2�� ± �� �+j3 !6B ± �� 9�1 �K� ,�A6e�3 ��²4)� r�O C x1k� �� 7�u «�"{/*
� ]Aa�� [��p��� �,@ G��5�� b��"_ ��� ]R��� �� �K� ± �� C �� H��k� >��8� ]�� ,>^de P H� ���3 G�KV� Ô���� ,Y �2�� C 4)�j�� Â�\u
Þ2� �� P6pAV� �;2�� >��8� �� ���N–1��y�−* �EA<� �p{ C Õ2"�� ��2)� C �1� +e :ÛµbÈm@�a@ÞbÓZ I 2�@� }
2��+� ,,G��$ �0 e �*m1� ,G�1��j�# ,G@9 )�V�+ ;$�30 2@@+� �� ,G*@0 7���t@� %5 Z��� / �� h ��9¯� �� ,°���� ,,±Ü*
$�8� �3� ��R +e� :Ûb%N�� �� E,Ae G��R >�� 9�;� b�o 43 G�e , EHn��� E,s t2�Ü*
ihg 12jV� :�R�3 �q ,��:A= P6pA� J��e* i�g 12jV� :�A�^s �1�u ,G�# e� !3�3 ^q�N/ J��e*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
,y��� ¡5�� (*+��1� �� ����� I�(<� �� (��m1�� '�� �2#��� G/�r�O ]8d F� ¶�1����� ���p;��*
Æ{� +s F� � AM# �2�� ��k� G�<;�� �2� G+��� '6� �� P��/ >1�{ Y�8�� 2� �� ��2�� � � 7;�� .L�� [��p���*
mL? �K_ `� ,����B E_ '3�N Y&I ��� �� �de/ .���<�� ��2�� �K� EAs� �;2A� ��1 �I 1�j�� �2�JO�K�� �, ��5_� ���wM�� �& �8�� P���"�*
�;2�� ]��M�N� r�O ���− �1��y− P��, �� C� �,�I ��^de JL� G/ E�� C E,�R��/–9�; G�s�q−*
?! = Í��:A� Ee�)�� .���<��Í��:A= �? ^,y ::::الوقفة الخامسةالوقفة الخامسةالوقفة الخامسةالوقفة الخامسة?P6pAV� !M3
��:A= P6pA�� P / �O �� � � �eLF� ` .���<�� Ee�)� ��:A=�2�� ^� �ao �� ��:A= P6pA� �K_ EAs ,^dK3 m1�,@ '8<_ ��2� .L�� �
>1�U� ��/ J�p{/ �3* 7�� �K� `� ,n�1�/ b�K� �� PA��q P6(�R �6c G�e Ee�)� ��:A:s
���MN �� �de/ ¶�1���� � � S�K� `� ,P6(�"�� ��/ C* P���V� �� ��<;�� «� �� L" � .L�� �?� �2#�� �,s P6pAV� Í��:A= ��/
P��wV� �;2���* �� P6pAV� ��"_ ����:A= :"
�3k �� 3� ��:A= nZ� `***
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� �M" � `�–P�2a − 1�� !� $� ��*** 76)�� 1�<�� �,s****
Y����� �?�***" �;2�� G�?/� ,G�My�� !�R .L�� �? P6pAV� C Í��:A:s–1��y�− * �.9� p FuJ@B� d��A@j ,�� v0 �uR! ,9�<� d��A@A#P
�O�V �K� �2\�N� b�� ±j"����P�5? ::::الوقفة السادسةالوقفة السادسةالوقفة السادسةالوقفة السادسةA#� !6B� �?L�� '��_� m�8�;�� JL� P�5���� ±j"�� >��y� ����
P���R ����8 � −�= ��� P ,K�� �� G�s�pV� ���� +31 P0z ����8 �� mL? ��?^w_ � �#�º−*
A�� P��+<�� S�K���³ E�2"�� 2,#�� C ��#u/ ��N �%d6s P�5���� ±j"��3e�32�2©� 2,#�� C ������ ��N r�Le� P�5�1 ±jR �� >1�8� �A6*
Á�� � �N�1� YM#_ Y��� PAd�k�3 �¿� E��K�� Go�"��� l�#_ ���R !d� ,}�������c� �b� � � �a� �`� �_��^� �]� �\� �[� � � � � � �Z� �Y� �X
��s��rq��p��o��n�����m��l��k��j��i��h��g���������������f��ed{z��y��x�����w��v��u��t��a��`��_��~��}��|�ghi*
l�#_ ���R�: �������»��º��¹��¸�� �¶��µ� �´��³� �²��Ê���É��È��� � � � � �Ç��Æ��ÅÄ��Ã��Â��Á��À�� �¿��¾��½���¼
ihg P��� ,2�2)� >1�N :g�Äi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��Ù��Ø��×��ÖÕ��Ô��Ó���Ò��Ñ����Ð�� ÏÎ��Í��Ì��ËÛ��Ú�ghi*
!=/ �� G�<;�� «�z 48_ P�5�1 P �� P6pA� Y? Í��:A= P6pA�� �2#��� ')�G+����*
Z�� (�0 (j�! F*R*a�1� %²C�� _±\� ��(1� F8^ �� (9n! FuJ@B� l`�� )���1�� $�3�1�� o*����1�� ,*�1� ����� _�*�<� %1\� ���G# , 7F@u�?� �z+
oV�1� v0� ��t*m1� v0 �8��p� y3�� ��81�� C81��P ±\� [z~1� [3R5 � 7z�� ;���R1� ³�1� c ��#�t1� F8^�_P
E�� C E,Ae �,=��/ ]M"N/ 1��y��−9�; G�s�q − P �<�� ]N1 EH ,3×"E�y8; �_�/" ���N >1�U� ��y; �?2#3� ,4 �|V�3� b%<�� �A� 9�;
�>��8�* � �"P�2 ::::وهنا لمحة هامة تقلب الطاولة على الملحدوهنا لمحة هامة تقلب الطاولة على الملحدوهنا لمحة هامة تقلب الطاولة على الملحدوهنا لمحة هامة تقلب الطاولة على الملحدU� 2pAV�
"P6�2"�� ��1�U)� C �?1�y�;�� 1��y� ��=�" G/ P�2"V� �� �� �<� EH ���d;/ G�e ��k� �6�:V�1�"�� ��8� xZ�� � ? �?� ,�X ���� P��,N� �A,=�,
#3 �K� Ps�\N ./�� P6pAV� 9���/ �f3 � 6R G/ 2 � K6� ���j\u� �� 7 HpAV� J�AN/ Q�; b2\�<; G/ 1�"; OI ,� ���� P<K� P:�; 1�";� 2 �6�:V� G/
��1�eO G�e ��k� ���d� ];�e ��k� �6�:V� C 1��y� G/� �� ,������� �A ,���,y�� �� �sZ��� >��<A� ���d� G�e ��:A=� � �5�1 7d;k� ];�e �����3�
ihg P��� ,>�"8�� >1�N :g�ÉÅi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�A�! _��2"�� 2pAV� �����q/ Ps�\N ��:�_ � ��"� �� !U�3 �K� Y 8� Y��� �
�Ad� PU��� G�?O/ C �I �"_ � PU��� P���)I 1�Ks/ �,A�* !!!!لكن أهم سؤال في هذا المنشور لم يVطرح بعدلكن أهم سؤال في هذا المنشور لم يVطرح بعدلكن أهم سؤال في هذا المنشور لم يVطرح بعدلكن أهم سؤال في هذا المنشور لم يVطرح بعد
�@�A@j FuJ�d? ::::أال وهوأال وهوأال وهوأال وهو(8� �� �A�^s �1�u ��"�Charles Virlleaud G�# e� !3�3 ^q�N/ �3��e C :
"E?56F� �� lI �8�� !{��� ` 4A3�8�� ./1 S<�� G��)� ��− 9���/ }�Í��:A=− E,(�= .L�� EA#�� �%a �� �I¡1��� y3� �� (+�� 7F�#$"*
1 ��R GOI G�y�� J�p{/–4A3�8��− '��� !8R � Á� E,6A� !{/ G/− �L?�PAK��3 Í��:A= P6pA�� Y �2�� ¶�1��A� 2pAV� ��1�j_ [< �−*
?2pA6A� Y"3 �O+s G/ E,V� G+�I� ��2=k E�y8; �_�/ �� P �<�� ��8e1 ��L��− �A� 9�;
b%<��− ����k� �#c 2R −���N >1�U�− lI Í��:A= ��1 ]��B� , $� �� L�� 2"s 2�2= �� x1k� lI G�H�k� ����� ,$� �� �?28#� �� H�
�� G�� �� ����8#� E,)�{� E,(�8;/* P���e �� H� �,�8"�/ Pp6<�� P� )�s*
H�A_� [��p�3 P&�� ��;��2�� �� �?^� ]H�A_ +e Í��:A= P6pA� ]Y&I Y�� �;/ ��pj3 b5:; � A#· �� '8� `� 4��c���*
Q�;/� P)�{ ��j\y� ��1 �� ��:A= P6pA� ����� G/ 2#3�
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�;2��� ��L�� «1�j_� J�_� !e�_ P ~6M�–Í��:A=− P�� ��� Q�;/� ,–�2K;/ −��<��3 >1��/ Q�;/� , –P\6u� 1��y�− ��� � �#� ��|? C �Aw�� E_ ,
$� �� E?28� ]R��� 1�{� !3 ,�� G�� �� P&o E?�L���/ G�3�"�� �;2�� «�8_ ��K�� lI $� �� ��#s E,)�{ G�&|� E,�A#=� 4q�y�� E,����=�s 1��y#�
�� � ���� E�� C E?��2=/ §��/ .L��* l�#_ ��R :��������������µ��´»��º��¹���¸��¶�ghi*
Y" �� 2����� ��� Pppj�� PAV� �� G�^de Y"3 �K�* ��L��� G��� �c���� G�s�pFV� m2<s/ �� P" �� �I � �Z_ !N��� Pd#3 �K_ `�
� ��;�MA FN �3 �5� F� ` �� ��3 ���Ku/��t� �s� �r� �q� �p� �o� �n��a`��_��~��� �}��|��{��z��y��x��w��v���u
e��d��c��b����q� �p��on��m��l��k��j� � �i��h��g��f��¡� � � � � ��� �~� �}� �|� �{� � zy� �x� �w� �v� �u��t� � �s� � �r
¢�g�i* !!!!- - - - اإلسالماإلسالماإلسالماإلسالم- - - - فالحمد هللا على النعمة األولى والخاتمة فالحمد هللا على النعمة األولى والخاتمة فالحمد هللا على النعمة األولى والخاتمة فالحمد هللا على النعمة األولى والخاتمة
ihg P��� ,Q;�� >1�N :ghÇi* i�g P��� ,>�"8�� >1�N :g�h i*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A ÝîöaŠ�g@�i@ƒí‰bmA@ @
G/ 2pAV� E�5� �=���e1/ �� ��¯1�_ ]3�H ^� !(�ºI Y 3 ±jR `� ,� C !(�ºI � 3 �K� �%{/ ��!
::::ل ويقولل ويقولل ويقولل ويقولفهو يتساءفهو يتساءفهو يتساءفهو يتساء
?F�0��V1� SCA� c >� �� y*a��6 _�5 ���� F8�1 ��� ;� (j W� y� !!!!نعمنعمنعمنعم
1��8�o §1�sIpuwer Papyrus G2� [p�� C Ø��pV�� ,.�}�� ]A� S(�j�� �� C ]#R� P6W� ��3��Mc� �eL� !:N �?� ,�2 ��¥
�>��8� �� �� !(�ºI Y 3 ¦��a !8R �,A�* �� P��� ]u�� Y��� P��V� P�1�q�}��� ��� [j_ 1��8�o §�1�/�
$� �� �� - de >�p3 ���/ P~3�/� P8:� P#8q t1��e �,�"pN� Ê����* b2�� �� ���� ��eO ��1�8#�� 2�/�− E��K�� Go�"�� ± � +e− G/ ��eO�,
b2�− ��,��− x1k� ��e�_� Y A� !Ky3 �����* QK#_ �q�"� mL? P8")� rA_ �� P��+<�� S�K�� ���1 Y��� t�2�k�ghi*
b�� C !(�ºI Y 3 �� ��8� !�� n� ?�h�ÄÇ §*b * C ��d�� Q<�1 �3 9��8;�� G����A� PAÒ [j_ Y��� 9��8;�� PA<� ��
i1g Randall Price, The Stones Cry Out, Notes, harvest house publishers,
1997, p.412*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
§ �� ���d�� G�"�� P��� *b * lI ]8?O Y��� P��V� PA6)� PjR YK0 Í" ��� G�# e x1/!(�ºI Y 3 ]"pN�ghi.
�� � V� C �<� Y 3 P��� !d� �� C !(�ºI Y 3 ��=� �� P��/ n� ?� G�1k� �� §� �� 1�� P��6� 1�j_ Y?� ,7MN��� P��V� P��2�� ��
,�A<��� ��;��)�3 �� lI G��5 � >� k6 ]���� _�5 F@*3^ Z��� y.� _��-��� _3�1� [@ v0 � 7)��5P
7�2� G�K� �� G����R E�/ �+y�� lI 46�� �� Í" �� C S�KF� ��Shut G�# e J� =� �� N P"M � EU_ Y���g�i*
P���3 G�"H�� ��N ���2"�� 4��V� G/ �R��; G/ Yw8 � � � ;I EHE,�&ä3 ��,u Y��� t1��K��, 2� �� E,y= P6�5? G��eL� ��N E�/ �/
����V� 28#��!
i1g Paul Backholer, the Exodus Evidence, byfaith books, 2010, p.72* Isreal Finkelstein & Neil Asher Silberman, the Bible Unearthed, chapter2,
Touchstone Rockfeller Center, 2002, p.57* i2g Paul Backholer, the Exodus Evidence, byfaith books, 2010, p.17*
Isreal Finkelstein & Neil Asher Silberman, the Bible Unearthed, chapter2,
Touchstone Rockfeller Center, 2002, p.54*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
_ïuìÛìî׉c@ð…bß@ÝîÛ…@áîçaŠig@bã†î�@…ìuìÛ@Ýç@ @,��b%<�� �A� E?��3I �;2N ��=� �� ��8� .��� !�� E?��3I P#AR ;*
1�2= �� Y�A��^? ±; C ��f� P j)� E?��3I P �2� �/ b��3I �jps�Rk�3 r;�K�� C G��o 28#� C ��p �*
�� 7 3 2R� C G�KV� �L? G+AN �/ �� C �%V� !8R ��#�� G�"�� C S" ��4��V� 2c «�s2�� va �� �5:e �K8� -]R�ghi*
e ���2"�� 4��V� GI !3�3 �8N �~3 P �2� G�6<� ��;�b��3I �j� EN* �� Y8 �� ��=� �� ��/ m��=� �� .��� !�� n� ,s �� �/ G�� !_ P��� �?�
��� ]3 PA<� m�6� .�H/ Í"; �� >1�8� Y?� � ÄÄÄ Í" �� t2p��� ,P N� �1�� Y��� 4��1��� !(�ºI Y 3 43 J�)� �� ���h½Ä b��/ 2#3 P N
��� rAV�6U�� ,� � � 4�6Ae Í" �� �L? �"�� ]3��"g�i* � �u�"; � � ��eZ� G/ !(�ºI Y 3 S#u �� �R��; G/ S#j�� �� �;I EH
P���,�� P#���� Gk r�O� E��1�j�;� �� YKB 1�j�� EN1 � �" � j_ � �� >1�{ �� �_�p � ��d� r�k� C ��� §�s �� �+<�� C � �¤� x1 ��� ]B �
Ck� ]B �� ��V� x1"* â ¦��� ��N�Ä−Å£*
i1g Randall Price, The Stones Cry Out, Chapter5, harvest house publishers,
1997, p.98* i2g Randall Price, The Stones Cry Out, Chapter9, harvest house publishers,
1997, p.167-170*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
_æbàîÜ�@òØܾ@óà�m@óàÄÇ@ñìÓ@†uìm@Ýç@ @ C56 ®��1� ;,��Ebla!
P �2� G/ P��Hk� %3I 9���/ �� ��:� �N� 1�H�� ��}\s J�� �+u C %3I E_� ,E�2"�� `�#�� C �}e ->�"e ���, �� 43 �� �%3� �� Qs� _ ];�e ��1�N P3��K� �MR� 9�� [�/ �� P<¹ �� �de/ .��B P8�K� �� %3I C 1�d#�� Y��� G2V� �6© �%:<3 %3I ]W���� 2"s ,%3I 9����3 ]6 FN P�1+<V�3
/ P�1�� �%��#� �,#� ��=/P�5©� �,A� ]c�s �* $2"V� J��K��3 >��=�V� G2V� �+N/ �� ^de �%:<�� C ��1� 2R�ghi*
Go�"�� �?�eO Y��� b1I P �2�� ,>1�6�� b�2N !d� G2� %3I 9���/ �eL_�G�� #3 J��e �F; 2R� ,E��K��" 1�H�� EA� C >1�H %3I" P �2V� !{��_ YK0
!K���� ];���3 b�u [��_G��5_��* ��6H b��R/ b1I S;�= lI �eL_ %3I 9���/ G/ Í?2V� !3 g�_���u i b�R�
�A�� G�� �2V� � � ,��� ���� �_�eFO G� -J��e C ��eLF_ `� E��K�� Go�"�� C �4��k� ^q�N/ �� +�/ G�:�0 +(�� >2�%V� G�e� ,m^�*
Go�"�� }a/ 2R� E��K�� mL? G/ ±j"��–� ±jR��6H� �� − �,6A#� �� ���R �� Y8 ����r���q����p��o��n������������m��l��kj��i��h��g��f���e
��z��y�����x��wv��ut��s�g�i*
i1g Dr. Laurence B. Brown, Goded, Chapter5, 2007, p.63-64* i�g P��� ,��? >1�N :gÅÇi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�N�; PK���k� ��U��� P��e� ���/ %3I 9���/�NASA �s2�� ��}�¨� t�� ��J.P.L p8�� lI �;1����K3 �A#s b1I 2{1 E_� G2V� rA_ �� � C �
1�jy�� P"M �hÇǼ b�"_ P#A"�� mL? b1´3 P{�a PR%6� P#AR ��y�e� E_� b PH%H lI m�MR !j�� 1���/ P#<_ lI �, � 2����� «��_1� !j� P6\c >26�/ ��
P���� ^� PA�1 P�{�� ����� P �2V� mL?� ,1���/ghi* !(�"�� �� §2{�: ��^��]��\��[��Z���� �Y��X��W���� � � � � �V��U��T���`��_
j��i��h��g��f���e��d��c��b��a �g�i* فما حال الملحد بعد هذه اآليات؟
���Ì� � � ËÊ� �É� �È� �Ç� �Æ�� �Å��Ä� �Ã��Â� �Á�� �À�Ó��Ò�����������Ñ��Ð��Ï��Î��Í�g i*
_ﱉbm@t†y@ïÐäi@⌬@óny@áßþa@ƒí‰bm@åß@å−@bäÐ’×@a‡bß@áq@ @
^,y�� 1�H�� `�� $��� Y?�5� � �"8q, �I �� 1�Ho �� [y�K; ` �p s�Ad��! gÅi*
�2= v<3 �5= ��k� �R�� Y�s t�2�k� �� � �¤ � �2= v<3 �5=� ,G�2F� �2= v<3 �5=� ,7"8� G�2F�¤ � �2= v<3 �5=� ,�8" _ E�� 7"8� � �8" _ E�� �¤ �
ihg 12jV� : b��?k� >2��=� �;���Äļ* i�g P��� ,�:��� >1�N :gÉ−¼i* i g P��� ,]Ajs >1�N :g½ i
i4g The Report: Egypt, 2011, Oxford Business Group, p.230.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
E,�F�� � � �A#F�! ghi* !(�ºI Y 3 ¶�1�_ Â�j\3 >��5�N%� : J��e" Y(��1 1��� ,P����� ��5_ � PU"��
��)��� ��2�� 43" l�k� P#8M�� ,� A� QAq/ ,�� S<� 76AN ,�Äh ]� 2"sP"3�<�� ���"��� ���2_ C J��K�� �� >����N��!
ihg y*a��6 _�5 ´��! µ�8¨5 $����C1 : ]��9" ��(1� e5 _a�� ��+ ,F+��V� Z��! p F*z�1�$�<\��" k��� F�3t1� ,¯�@1 o@ � ,�� [R+ �u@� ,Y�N� c ]��?1� �� $�V��p� 2� (�#
F�5�R1� S���V1� ���(!!P
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A òîÔĐäß@pübØ‘g@ @
Šr×c@ü@ò튒jÛa@ñ�¨a@óÜÇ@òàöbÓ@òîÜÔÈÛa@bänÛ…c@æìØm@æc@Éãb½a@bßA@ @(J@B� Z���: �� ��=� ��8H� ��|V� �,�2"� Y��� P��k� G�K_ G/ �;�V�
?P��8�� >}� �� >26�#� v"s Y? '��� :الرد
PA8R P��/ 4?��3 Y? G+��� �� PA"#�� � ���/ P��28�� CA-Periori �? !3 P��8�� >}�3 �� PR%� � ��k� ¿"#�� G�?}��� ,PA"� ��N�R ]<��
�,A� ��=���� G�2=��� C '3�N* 2pAV� �?��=� �� '�_� ,P"8<� P��/ PA"� 4?�}3 2��� G�<;��s
3 ��|V� �,6<Fs ,��|V��×">�M���" �/"P&�� Pw8j��" ����m� � lk� �j�s��rq��p��o��n�u������t�ghi*
P��k� 5(��w��3 2pAV� �,6<F��instincts * G/ �W A� ]s%�� ��� YK<��y_ b�#; �& QN/ Y��� Pd�2)� ����wA�� EA�
Noam Chomsky � !"#�� G/ �� b�"_e 2��� �� .��0 !3 ��U3 Pp�j P��k� ���2"V� �� ^dK��knowledge is innate *
�� EA� !{/ GI !3 � �"8<� EA<��� G�� ��N�1� �K6� � ��2)� ��;�<A.�8�� !"#�� !a�� � �"8<� P=�< � >�Ms ��=�3, ��U3 Pp�{ Q� �;/�g�i*
ihg P��� ,>�"8�� >1�N :gh ¼i*
i2g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_grammar.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�/ �¥�<�e� E�� �� >}� �� 26�#_ � ,PA8R �/ P��/ 4?��3 rA�6� !"#��s P��k� PA8"�� PA"#�� 4?�}�� mL? ��� ,��=k� }� �,d�1�_P88<�� G�?�3!
f�F� � n��=�� ��=�� ];�s ,b�\ � �� r� � � ��/ ¿8R G�?�3 �,s 2 Á=�� r� GOI �<� 3 �<�;��a��`��_��^��]����\��[��Z�ghi*
� _}\3 2"�� �� ,G�KV�� G��5�� �qF/ ��:�� ,��e ��/ ¿"� !�� �;I'6�/� E�/ �? !3 P��8��*
P��W �� b�A#�� !e b��R� �L? ���Mc� ��As ,P88<�� G�?�3 �� P8��:���� �� P3�� ]M8U;� �� P���#� ]p{ �� G�?Ok� C m1��"�N� ���� G�?}��
È1�s �w� b�A#�� !e �1�j�� P:� 3 � 6�AN! b�A#�� !e b�"_ �A�� G�;�"�� �� ��/ ��e G�?�3 �,s!
� `�#�� �L? G/ '���3 G+��� P��/ �� � �U�/ ��c�� 2�� m��=�� ��=� 2 Á=�� �� `�#�� �L& 23� GOI ,�<� 3 �<�; f�� � `�#��� ,m^w_� �����d��c
j��i��h��gf��e�g�i* >}� '8<� ��/ ¿"� G�?�3 lI � ��� �N� '���3 G+���3 b�"; �p; GOI
P8<�KV� � _�KA� !e '8<�� P��8��* �p; � =1�a �� -!�� .�3 EH?P��8�� � _}a �� ��6���3 G�8��M F�
?P��8�� � _�8<�KV «�j;�� b2#� G��MU� �p; � =1�a �� -!�� .�3
ihg P��� ,1�M�� >1�N :g ½i* i�g P��� ,1�M�� >1�N :g Éi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
?� N��� �3 �;2� �� !e �s�; -!�� .�3 SA";� [R�V� G�� ! $��)� m2{�_ +3 EA<���3 2pAV� b5AF; ��L�� �p;
V�� Y#8M�� S?LV� ���� �;/ �� ,2;�#�� �s�� �?� Q�/ ,�3 ��k� �8?r�Le
^dK3 P��8�� � _}a �� PR�H� ��/ P��k� PA8"�� � ?��3 G/ r�O �� � Á��;�"_I� ��M8c �, � �de/�*
2�/ Y? !3 ,P��k� PA8"�� 4?�}�� C �p _ � � ���/ G/ '8N �� �� � ÁE(�R �ao G�?�3 �? >�8 �� G�?}s �I� ,�de/ � 4?�}�� �� !j� �� �_�L3
�L? C .��V� 2"�� 1�qI ��:�_ Y��� 4?�}�� r�O lI [c/ ,P��k� 4?�}�� b�W�;�3 26�<_� P���� �� PpAj� � §%ak�s ,§%ak� G�?�3 !d� `�#�� �,Ae mL,s ,��:V� .��V� `�#�� �L¥ �� PR%� � �ao -`�� �� �,�6R� �?� #�
b2� �� 4?��3 `�#�� �L? �� Q� -2 N lI -P=�p3 � ;/� ,.��V� S?LV� P���eP���� ^w�� 1��k� mL? ��=� 1}�!
E��K�� Go�"�� ��2\�N� G�?�3 �?� >�� lI >��%�� ��"�;� G�?�3 � �U�/ >��� !e �=� C P:� PWpA�� 7�� �� �� �?� Y&�� !a2��� ��8HI C � � de
#�� b�A� !Ks ,��)�� -��eO �� `�#�� ��I !{�_ �� !e� `�#�� ��#��= !e� `� ��� ,>�)� 1�{ v<3/ �� F� G/ �M�<� � PR%6� -�� e��� -v8c� -P;�"_� ]:�;/� >�)� 1�{ !e ]:�;/ P(��y#�� G/ xZ�� 2pAV� �� �� r�O
P=�L<�� P6R mL? �K_ ` �OI ,G�<;��� ��ZK8��� $�^���, �8"_ ���s P6R ?P=�L<��
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
(J@� �#���� (^ ��� �?1, )���*# c �9 ��¨�! (^ F�¯31� ��!¶� �� _0(��,?1� �*��?*� %�t��� �9 F*33R1� ����5 r�R� (^� ,,?1�P
�:)� ���/ +Ae �?1�K� 2pAV� ��5� � P�\N PM��w� mL? �R���� C�P� Á5AV� PA"#��*
s EK�� `�� C �;/ P"")� Q� 3 �}K�� Ps�#V� �qk� 2=�_� P88<�� 2=�_ 2R �K� ,���Mc�� �� 12"�� P6�� �/ >2��� ��#s/ ���1 �+<©� �8�_ �
���� P#R����, �& G�K� +;I�g��+��� i P=�V� ���2��3 ��#F� +swave
function * �3 �� �L?� Á �� � �� �,uk� ��Vk� ��c������ ���5��� G1�3 QeMax
Born ��/ P6�)�� P88<�� 43 �"���_ �� H/ C �c�Causality and
Determinism G/Y�� _ � EK�� ���5s `�� �s �K�� P88<�� v"<_ P6�)� G���k� �3 ���= �� �� x1�#�� � r�O� ,��+���� �,A² !p��! ghi*
7,� 63 ,����� � Ë\<F� !K��s ,G�;�R %3 G�K�� �L? C ^<� �� 2=�� %s ,> Ë1L�� G�� �� lI >�:ÁV� �� P88<��EK�� r;�K� ����#� !e� � G�;�"� �U
�� ,b1�{ YKN%e 1�qI�_ G/ �M�<_P88<�� �=�����dV� QNF/ �� ��6�* �(5,�<� � e��? ���N ��"�� � P�<A���3�3��e C 1�q�� �L? C 1�2_ Y��:
" b�� Ch�Ãà �� 1�y � �c�3 Q�1�3 ["N/ b�R�hÇ �,�;��I S� P"q�?
ihg 12jV� :^,y�� �3��e � Á� ��d�� !j��� :NATURAL PHILOSOPHY OF CAUSE
AND CHANCE*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P88<��3 G+��� Y? ��"q�&� mL? 2�/� ,�%8�� ��p;/ C , 4;��R b%�3� �1�,u �� `� ,P#8M�� P#8M�� 4;��R 2�/ b%_ S8<3 ["Nk� ��� 7��
K�� ["N �A� v"N 4�©� G�;�R !#�3 P(�12_� P88<�� !#�3� P3O�P�%���!" ghi*
C �I r�O !#�� �� ,P�+d�� 7�� v<�<� �? ��À28�� J1�0 .L�� GIPA"#�� PM<�<�� 1�qI, G+��� $1+� ���� �R�� C �? + 3 $12�� ����R C�
-PW) !e C P88<��3 ���_ %3! 7����+<©� 1�,@ ���� C Y��6K�� JL3L���Quantum
Vacuum Fluctuations,PR�M�� °�� G�;�R [��¯ � �#3 Y�2� +e��2pAV� �� P�(�5�� b�A#�� �=���!
Y��6K�� JL3L���s – �W) �+<©� 1�,@�, È����� !a�� �?����a� EHY�;��K�� − qÖ� �U¯ � � K� ,�_�A� �� C P88<�� G�?}� �U¯ ,Y �5�� 1�
m�ao� ��Ku�� ��/ �L?�! �+<©�s Y�;��K�� È����� C EH �,W�s !8"�<V� �� PR�q xZ"_ G/ �K6�
mL? �K� ,�%��� PW) v8U��3 �,c�ZR�3 ]��R Y��� P6"�� �P#s�� 7u%�_ G��5�� ��2� !a�� .��V� 1�q�� C t2B !8"�<V� �� PR�q x�ZR�� P���<V�
,G�KV��� G��5�� ��As�� �L& G�e �V ��=�V�� §�A\V7 #� �� ��=� x�ZR* sG�K�5�� !j�� 4;��"� �c�a Y��6K�� JL3L��� space time
ihg 12jV� : ,EW#�� E6j��� J��eÅh×� ,Û � e��? ���N Ü*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
continuum G��5��s , PR�M�� x�ZR� �+<©� ���2\�N� .L�� 2#F3 Q�V� �� !j� �P#31k� ��#3k� 2�/ �? !3 G�K "�� ,«��_1� ,x�� ,��q"
���"�5� �/ ��(5� �K6� � !j�� �<; C G�KV� �� !a2 P8< �� 1�"_ +e ,����y �k P��#��!
��2 �� �< �� 2���"3 �< �� �L? !a�� t20 Y��6K�� JL3L���s �L��[A�<� E<©� ,2{��A� P8< ��3 !8"�<� �L? P��)� mL? Y�s ,!8"�<FV� �� PR�q
�� �< �� �� /5:�� � �5= � K���K, � PR�q �%�N� �����3� C §�a t Á2 F0PR�M�� °�� G�;�R; ��j� PW) C ��K�5�� �< �� Gk E<©� rA_ ��
3 b�R Y��� PR�M���RZ�,c�, �����I EH PW)` �u%_C �� ^w�� �< ����K�5�� �!�¯ `� , P;�KV� ��#3k� �� ��5�� !j� � `� ,PR�M�� °�� G�;�R
PH%d��* 1�qI� G�;�"� �U¯ m1�{ �� C Y��6K�� JL3L��� G/ ��2= �� G�;�R fe �M�<� �� >��V� 4;��R �� ��6�� G/ �M�<� �� ,b1�{ YKN%e
PR�M�� °��* s QN/ P6KB� !3 4;��R� 2���R 's� ^<� EK�� r;�K6� P=���6�<3
PM8U �� P��A#� P=�����d� §�M3 ]�8H! !e C �<�12_ E�� �+A� �8{/ �� P"AM� P(��y� EK�� r;�K� G�e ���P0� !d� >^de P6A� -9� � C m�?��@ �� >����N�� E��� ,`�#�� ��#��=
S�K_ Y��� �_�86K�� �&%a ��, P��6K�� >�?�W��3 !6#_ �_�86K�� P0�s� C �, � �;2��N� �� P(��y� PA6#�� ];�e ����!
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
!d� �, � 20 � P�1�{ Pc��1 ����#� 's� ^<� EK�� r;�K� GI !3 �w ���� P���#�Schrödinger equation P��6K�� P��)� [j_ Y���
Y���� ,��5�� �� >26�#V�PKN%K�� ���5��� C ��d�� �_�; G�;�R '3�M_ ��K_* ¦};5��? P���#� n� ? � �U�/Heisenberg equation r;%3 P���#��
����y ��Planck–Einstein equation P��6e ���� [j_ �,Ae�P�A�¨*
r;%3 1�2= §Z¯ G/ !p�<� EK�� r;�K��, v3��U3 .�· �� !Ks�, � 20 �� �?��:�� � Y�;��K�� `�#�� C >�2², ��s��3 |8 ��� �K6��
m��2� C� ¦};5��& 4"�� b2� /28V � �"8q Y�;��K�� `�#��* lI �� EA#�� lI Q� �=�1 P88<�� §�¯ Y�;��K�� `�#�� G/ 2pAV� x�Zs�s
E�;��K�� ���5s, �=�1 +;I� ¾�5�� �� ���8�� P#8q� 2pAV� P#8q lI���l
r���q���p������o��n��m�ghi* �?1 Z���� (J@� Z�R� (^ :�u�@� -*9 ��!��(�� FJ85 w���� �� �?F*@��1�
2pAV� �À/ !PA"#�� � _�A6� G/ Y#_ G/ rA� u QK#_��~ �� .��V� `�#�� ��Ppp{ Y,s � K<; .L��*
� ��K�/ r�L�� �2= Pp=�;>2= �(��; ]M�/� ,Ppp{ ���|8 _� �! -12R �� .��B P6A#�� t�p8��� - 8e PR2�� ��; .��� �R��3 v8_�_ ��k
ihg P��� ,[,K�� >1�N :g½Éi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
!e 2{�_ � ��"� G/ r�O �� E?k� �K� ,�pj�� m���� C ^<; � ;/ ]8d�� ��"� b�K�/ C P"d�� C �%��e ')� � � �L� �(�� �� �R��_� �AAB� r�O*
b�<=k� T�"N 4;��R �� �N� !"#��s–PH%d�� �_�; 4;��R− � 6R 4���,"8M�3 �=�� ���� Ppp{ �(�� �� �*
F� G/ ����y �/ «�M�N�� � _�|8 _ ]R2{ � �U�/� �� �%�2#��� �#3 !a2��R��k� ���f�� C �_�; 4;, �=�� -12R ��� >�,8� � �U�/ �:(��; � -Í?2�
��� PR2�� ��Uv8 � � Q� � ��"� b�K�/ G/ C ��/ P"H � M#� +3� ��1�s� �/ �3�º� ����a�!
ËN|� �<�; EA#��� �%"� `�#�� G/ !�/ �� Q– Æ���<� �A"� S �– �� C�,yV� ��� � P��� �� ���5��� C� ,P��<�� 7�� >2��"�� mL? b�\ _ `� >�
PA"#�� � _�12R ]A@ n%sk� ���5s� P;5��� P�3�H Y? !3 >�V�3 P���a ^�P��#�� PR�H��� �3�q �& b�K�/ YM#_�*
./ P6K�� �� P8< �� 2��_ !d� ��uk � ��"� J�#�N� b2� 7 #� Q�� -rKy_ P��"#6A� m��"�s� ��I !j; ` �� Y #� %s � ��"� P6R C!
�de/ � >z�"�� P��8�� � �#8q Y #� +;I�, �L?� �� !"#�� ¦� F ����K�/ PR�2j�!
�� �Ma b�R1/ >�� �� 2�5_ b�R1/ �� P8N�)� P��� >12"� b2� Y #� %s��I !{��_, � �,66j_ P#8q +;I�� §�s ��� P��A#V� �� 12"�� �L? �I �& ��
F� �� ,��12"� ��:�� r�O���M#� C ��:��� �L? rKy; ���M#� !e Gk–�� P3�<)� ��A6#− '8M���3 Ppp{ ���|8 _� P6AN .��V�*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
G/ r�O lI [c/ mL,s , �+(�� �_�8HI E_ P3�,K�� >�"A� J�A"V� �3�V� G�;�R�_�O EA#�� 9�:; $�N/ Y?� � ���� Pp=�; P(��"�N� P6e�²!
P(��"�N� P6e�² �%a �� P#8M�� �� �+���� P;�K�I �� b�"� EA#��s PA"� P3�:��� C ���3�H !WN P3�,K�� >�"A� J�A"V� �3�V� G/ P�� R �s�_ ,P"8<�P�����EAN ¿"#�� EK)�s �����3� ,!
EW � �;/ P""p3 v8_�� �%"� G�K�� G�3 E�5��s! t�2�Ô� v8U V� r3�y����–P��~� P=1� P(�� 2 � ��V� G�A� !d�− �;26�
"� Pp{ 2e��3 b�W�;�3P88<�� �� PA"#�� � ��2! Y��� t�2�k� ��� ,`�#A� �%"#�� b�W �� �?�W� 2�/ Y? P88<��s
P:�;� S8N 1�qI C 1�2_ �?2{�;!
Z��*1 (J@� �V�� (^ ����� c� :F*@��1� S��(�B� FJ� v0 ���V!�, v0�Z��! �s�B �?1 ,%RV�5 %RV� ·V� p $�j�1� �`� �� FJ� : %�1�� �6 ¡1��� ��
?� 7(�(¸ x����� P��:3� 'M V� P��R�� ��"�� P?��N �� �#y�� [ F"� � ?� §�M� .L�� � Æ� ��#_ � r;/ ��:V J�8A� §1�q ��=� �K F_ ];/ !,s ,PA"#��
? G�� J�8�� ?�6N� ��#_ � r;/ ��:V nO��N/ ��=� �K _ !?
� r;/ ��:V �& 2(�R �/ >�(�M��3 J�e1 ��=� �K _ !??E? � � ��#_ �v0�� y.B� �!
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��8V� ¿"#�� [AK��� ��:�_� b�5��� �� 5�"_� J�AMV� �� 1��j_ �O�V?G�?}�� �3 r�AKF� +3 �� PR%� � �ao -��|N� �ao -x��3 � ����_ !6�0 � .L��
]s�� +3 [AK��� r � v"<F� � n���� ,b�5��� �� r=� F � n5s�"_ }�§�s��� Q�;k� C PAH�V� P��k�!
(J@B� Z��� (^ ���� : �@��u¡1��� $�j�5 �1 �, �@# �� �� |,–%��J3�− ?FV@�¨B� S����(1� c $�j�B� F±¬� �� ��i %16 o*1�
:الرد
�;�p8N '��� ��N 2=�� �"��", �I P{�� Ps�#V� mL? 26�<; `� G�?}3"���8 ��"A�¯ �� , �? 2�k� 2����� '��� G/ C � �#� x1k� !?/ [
"��"!* �� G�28#� � E�k Q� G�×��k� P"3 �� �× s%a�, � ��A#= E�k �K��
G�K�� C ������ SAM��� ��×�2�� C ��e�* EW#�� '��� �×?2 � �?� �� 28#_ x1k� G�×��/ �6:s, �de/ 7��
��R���I ��;��2�� × H��� C;P <e�y�� ��×e� �� ��A#= E, K�4 E?�8<; '��\A�, �P�5 � � � 7;�/ E?�}���� − >^w{ P&o– Subordinationism*
�;�p8N �� ��=�3 G��"F�� G�sZ#� >^wj�� P&�� mL& E���8� �� E, K�! !=� 5� � �Pq�N� �I �8�� �?28� �� b� {k� GI !3: �zy��x��w���v��
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
f��e�����d���c��b��a��`����_��~��}��|��{ �ghi* �+�2R J�#�� G�H�/ �� ���N�,y�� ��"�: Û J�#�� �K� EAs b� {k� ��/
���L� ���28#�, E?2 � �K_ `� �� �de/�:� P#MRÜ* ���ª��©¨��§���¦��¥���������¤��£��¢��¡�����~���}«�g�i*
�I ����� >^dK�� 2 &� P&o ]<�� � v(�N� Y,s ,4�2Rk� J�#�� G�H��e���L� ���28#� �� '���!
G/ �s� 2 &� C P;�M�}�� P��K)� lI «�s�V� ���"��� m�eO �� �L?� :" P8��w�� �� &� >�de G/ Y? �p8�� �� P :A�� �,�I ],�;� Y��� P��#�� P:� ��
��/ 2��� �(�e C P\N�1 >2"� 2"�#_"g i* ���� P&�� �� ���k� mL? G/ ];�1��� �� !#�_ +e �,<�2"_ E�� v"s
4<�2"�� ��� Q�2"_ �� Pp<V� Q(� K��, ��� .2 &� �?O lI §�M�� %s -PWpA� ->2��� � �� � Y��� P&�� mL? G/ �?�2#�A#�� >��<�� �&gÅi*
2��_ C E,���R/� !N��� 43 «�5 �� G�e 2"s �L�� P?��k�" �� ���sI >��8#��3", P3�3��� 2��_ C �" 'A�3 �� ���sI"*
ihg P��� ,��5�� >1�N :g i* i�g P��� ,��8K #�� >1�N :gÉhi* i g 12jV�:− P��N��>1�U)� PjR ,];�1��� ��, 2A� Â�ÄÇ* iÅg 12jV�'3�<��*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�;�j�� ��=� Ps�#63 [AK��� �� � ` �L&�, Y�;� 2����� Ps�#63 �1� +;I�r����*
�� �Ò1 P6_ �3� b%N�� ¶u ��"� :" F� C �@ ��� ��;�e E�/ b� {k� ��8`�#�� 'A� ��/ G�2"�#�, F_ ��/ �/�MV� �5 , G��)� 'A� �/ ��8 �� ]8 _ ��/ �/
r�O ^� �/, �!?�= �,s E¥, 2jR Q = �� E��H�k G�H�k� ��8� 2jR G�e !3 E?2 � P6W#V� 1�8"A� 1�8"��3 4e�V�"ghi*
��;��2�� P"3 �� � s%a� x1k� ��;��� �� C ��8#V� �? �;�p8N ��se��I �� �3�; P?��k� C E,−>��8#��3 �� ���sI− P3�3��� C � , − �� ���sI
'A�3−* '��� 2pA� �K F� G/ !R�� !e ��5� .L�� �K�, P��k�3 b�5��� �K ��
P �2V� �� 3 �3 ��=� �K F� .L��e G�Ks ,'Aa � Æ63 ��s�#� b2� �6� ��:V; E,(+N/ ��#� � �;k!
ihg 12jV�:− ,P6_ �3� ,������� «�6�h¬ ½Ç*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A @ÉÓaë@åß@pübØ‘gŠ•bȽa@´àÜ�½a@ @@ @@ @@ @
ïàÜÈÛa@´àÜ�½a@ÑÜ¥@kj�@bßïàÜÈÛa@´àÜ�½a@ÑÜ¥@kj�@bßïàÜÈÛa@´àÜ�½a@ÑÜ¥@kj�@bßïàÜÈÛa@´àÜ�½a@ÑÜ¥@kj�@bß@@@@ïãbÔnÛaïãbÔnÛaïãbÔnÛaïãbÔnÛa____
:الرد
P�"d� P8\; G�Ad6 F� J�w�� �%3 C G�6A<V�� ��"�*G+s�? ���� :" G�K_ G/ �+A<� �6���e/ G�K_ G/ Y #� �K���/ C �−Y��%�� C �"�<� ��k� �LK? ª�w��−
)� mL?� , ��+�=� � �#c� b%N�� � � P""6�� � ���� � ��R��� � �5 ���R �� *** C� �� !"� � �� 2� ,G�KA<�� .��� SAR C �1%e ��;�NÃÄÄ �_�86e ^8a
���M_ C E, � G�^dK�� n1�u 2"�� EA<�Pentium III"ghi* !d� YK���k� �6�:V� E¥ �\�� 1�8e �+A� E? P�%N�� �+W V� ��N�1�
�* ��2� Sj � !wy�� �1�s1�? P#��= ���a ^,y�� �K�� S8q ���a ^W; Y�%N�� ����A#V� 5e��IIS , C 46A<6A� P;2V� §�")� P6W � Q(1 ��/
�K���/CAIR ,�_�86K�� '(�R� `�� 2Ò/ �6� �,s��/ 46A<V� QA� 4K���k�s.��V� �Ò��� 28� 1��e2�� �N/^*
�?2�� �K���/ C 2=����ÄÄ +e v"s �� �� ���=�? EA<� `�� [�/P��V� >�:&� >1�� ] A�/g�i*
P=����2�k�3 PM8_�� PUR Q� [A\���s−��2��− xZ�� G/ ���0 +eb%N�� C 2=�� %s ,r�O E~A�� 2pAV� ��"��� b2"��� �� � 6� �� *
ihg 12jV� : �5©� ,PK���k� P�1�q�}��� ,��d���hÉ*
i2g http://www.asbar.com/ar/monthly-issues/53.article.htm.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� �Ò1 ��<6A��� �6� O��Nk� ��"� :" ,�s �p; +3 Ê�� � b%N�� GI ���2� b%N�� C �� !e ,E,�#c� 46A<V� �a�_ S8N �;�3 rp6�A� Y��� %s
� ,�;�"_I� !6#��� ,2©�� >���<V�� >�"��� ,��j;��� �2#�� lI lI ��2�� b1�K�� PAU���§%ak"*
G/ G�3�� ���N�� 1�"�� :" �P��%� ��;��2�� �de/ �� b%N�� ��s�y�e�EA#��"* >�_�e� �� P6A#�� T�N�k� C b%N�� §� ��� �dK� r�L��
4d��3� ��1�<s��3�* (�5 Z�nR1� �0 [AW� / �J� �?1!
₣îàÜÇ@æìÐÜ‚nß@å−@a‡b½₣îàÜÇ@æìÐÜ‚nß@å−@a‡b½₣îàÜÇ@æìÐÜ‚nß@å−@a‡b½₣îàÜÇ@æìÐÜ‚nß@å−@a‡b½_b_b_b_b@ @@ @@ @@ @F��(31� c ; PW�%� �? Pq�<83 EA#�� �p8��� ,�?^<�_ Pw3 �?��W��
PU"�� Y? mL? ,��6F� � Æ�� ,�de/ �s2� � Æ63 ���R Y6A#��* �}K�� �K���/ ��#��= �2�I !���� −�1�s1�? P#��= !d�− §���
�P#6�� P3�#�� ��2A� Y6A#�� !��6���ghi* �1�s1�? P#��= �� >1��j�� P6A#�� §�1�k� �2� G�K� G/ YÀ28�� � Á6s
�� }e/ P3�#�� ��2�� ��#��= �� >1��j�� P6A#�� §�1�k� �2�* .1��I [A� �;2 � [A\����, C SM�� S��Ms ,Y�e �/ Y6e [A� Q��
P6A#�� PAj)� !���63 §��_ +31 P6A� PAjp3 ¦�\�� P3�#�� ��#��©�2 � >1���� �K� PV�#�� ��#��©� C SM�� ���R�_� ��@�_ C �: _ E? ��
i1g http://goo.gl/DXnbK6.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��1�,�«28Fs ��jj� >���� �! P��2�� T�"N ¶�1��3 � _�#6�� [A� !���� ��/ P��28� ¶�1���� �K6� � �U�/ C P�2����� P3�k� Ps�"d�� ��,@� , �>�:s P6A#�� 9���� ]A(�U_ 4� PN�8#��
P��<�� 7�� >2(�N ]A@� ª�#�� `�#��! �Ks E�1 �� �I J�k� 2��� � �R���� C� ^w�� ��� V� J�k� �K� EW�
>�N�� EA#3 GZ"�* P�2{��� 2?��y��� P��#�� P3�k� 9���� 43 G�"� Go�"���l�#_ ��R P6A#�� :���l��k��j������i��h��g��f��e
��y��x��w��v��u��t��s��r��q�����p��o��n���m�ghi* "�y� �1�K_ 2R� ,¿"� ��_ Q�� PU��s b%N�� C ^K����s P6Ae ��
>�� 4<¹ P3��R Go�"�� C !"#��* �� 1�j� C �L�� P�%N�� G2V�� �}K�� E{��#�� ];�e P?�5�� b%N
!K� P����� >�?�"��� G��^"��� P8q�R� 'y��� >�8��� Ps�K��� ��2w3 !d�1�� !� 2"#F_ ���@� V� ];�e� ,G���k�� $� =k� , �� G�_�� $� �� ];�e�
e �;2��EA#�� G�"A�� �,A , P:(�1 �>1�� EA#�� G�e�* � Q� �� �3�� � j F� ��wj�� P���2�� >1�2�� [y�K C [" ��"8q
P#s�y��" ,Q6y�� b��/ �×?1�² ��� 1�2_ x1k� G/ �A�/ ��^8�� � , b���� ��� j� �� b�R �×31�/ C rA��� EA� $�N/�I¿e15�� E?��3*
�3��� 1�,yV� [ jV� �=��1�2� G/ [y�e� ]<�� P���U3 Se��K�� �
ihg P��� ,G��6� �o >1�N :ghÇhi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P��(��* 2V�3 2:<V� b�p��� �?� PN12:<V�� �6� 2u���� P�A� b��/ �� PN1 �3��2u���� ���A� ��H � � �� ¸1 J�M�*
��3���� ��V� G�e + 3�G����· �� G2 �� Q�1�3 C ��8�� ];�e� ,�31�/ G�s�#� ��;�K� `� ,P8ya ��c1/ �/ Ls��; �¥ �K� `� Í"��3 T�A\V� 76M��
x���k�3 ��;k� Ee5�� ]8�� Ô6� G�a2�� G�Ks �a�2V� , G�s�#� � ��;�e��1�j� �/ ��c1/ n� ? �K_ EAs Ps�W �� , b��/ 7"A_ ��;��)� ���"3 ];�e�
8���� , �� _ ];�Ks Ps�W �� �/ P��R��� �/ Ypj�� �:)� G�s�#� ��;�K� `� C r�Le �c��� G�e + 3 ,��� N P#U3 !e �3�1�/ !K� PK_���� x���k� L � �3 ���6#� Ypj�� �:)� G�e� ,P~U� �>���� P�%N�� P��2�� ];�e �31�/
��N��� 2,�− EAN� �A� �� �{−«1��y�� ];�e� , �>��U� C �1�jV�� , -P��R !e �P#N�� ��;��N1+8��� , ¦%#A� �31�/ n�A� �,�I ®�� P8�1ghi*
�.��k� 2:<V� P6W� �� ^de �3� � � YK0, EW�/ �,s �K� ` �;2�� G/�� �*
-P��<3 2u��� G�1�? !N1/ ��2 �� �� �I P�2?G�V1�u 1�q�}�, ��aG�V1�u, ������ C � � 2"�" G/ P��<�� ��;�Mu .�B; n�p�_ J1�"#�� Gk
2�/ �,<6A� G/ G��*
ihg 12jV� : 4;+A#�� ��,8u� Y�%N�� !)� �� 3 43�w�V�� ***�* .��c�"�� [N�� **** P8?� P8�K� P;�d�� P#8M��hÇÇ Âh Å*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
sY� b�� ¼Äà b/ 2u��� G�1�? !N1¥2� -P -P8:� P:;���� rA� G�V1�y� ,P�2&� ];�e� -P��N �� >1�8� 3 P6\c� >�R PMN��3 n�p�_ Ps�w�� v(�� «��_1
P(��, ����<�� �2#3 P;2#V� ���K�� �� �2� �, � v"<� P��N !e b�� ��� Fs P6\c PN�p; >2��R §�s J��3k� �� J�3 ����� 7"N�� 4;1 �& �6<
×��h� G�8?1 �K� ,��#� EH �&�� 1�2� $1�s �, � ¦�¯� P��<�� l� P��|V� ��2"��� �"��/ �;�Mu �¥ G� �,e�0, �%� �¥ ��j3Zs �M���?�6ghi*
��5w�� 26² ¶y�� ��"�− �� �Ò1− :" rA���� ,ª�� EA� P�2j�� GI �+Nk� !6B ��5_ �� �×s��w©�� P#8M��� ��c������ �K;�KV�� SM���
7pj��� P3�#�� � ,b��� lIP3�#�� P�k� Y6A#�� 9���� ��N �LK?"g�i* � C ];�1��� ��"� PjR �3��e>1�U)� :"1 �� ��8� �3 S��j�� rA� +3
�P#6�� �31�/ ��8�K� C G�e +3 12"� �� ��#�� G�"�� C S�K��, C 2� ] e� �2� E,j0 � ��×6A� 2 R�6N lI P8q�R �� 2=�<V�"*
��/.^��s f 8N §��<V� ��"s: " 2��� `�� �M�<� �/P8"�� !���� G �3�� �+N� °�A� G/ G�� ��R15�� �� PR1� !A0 G/ Y#8q `�� �M�<� �� ,�
G�� 1�\j�� �� >�\{ ±p�� �/ �:y��/ ./ 12"� �� ,�3�� � �N1� �eL�� G -�%a C b��� ]8� G/ -x�R ./ �<� �� ,J�#�� ��A�/ /28� Y�2�<� G/ G��
k� 2�/ >�(�� !���� G/ S8q�� L � Ps��#V� x��� ��1ä3 Q6À G/ G�� b2"
ihg 12jV� : J��e P�2"�J�w�� �� �M<_ J�#�� Q6u, P;�Vk� PR��<6A�PK;�? 2���* i�g 12jV� :J�w�� �� b%@, ÂÅÄ*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
ª�� S8q"* ]u�� P31�k� ��#��©� GI !3ÉÄÄ ��"� +e J�#�� ����_ �� b��
G�3�� ���N�= * �32���� �K���� �� !"#�� b�0 �� b%N�� C 2=�� %s* ��R1��V� ���
[A\�; + 3 EA#�� ���s�"H b�B Y��� P��N�� ��2�� b2"�_ G/ � ;�� C P8:#���p; *`�#�� ��d� �»0 � ?� YKN �e ��3���Kow Seki C Ñ�� .L��
1�2"� J�<�� ¿��K��� !c����� EA� «23/� �_�; ��Pi 7"3/ � K� C �� �# { � � �y_ [yK� G/ P?��k� �6<3 ! F m�W; C �L? Gk � �º �_���#�
Y#8M�� b�W ��! EA#A� E��s�"H �W _ �LK?*
�N� �;^� + 3 1� �� C � 6Á; � ;Ib%W�� C °"* _xŠ«@åß@Ýç@åØÛ@ @
2����� ��)�3 G��: � ? !����{ ��"� :" $���_ �� �6N b�o � J�p{k PR%ak�� P�q�#��� P<� �� ��=�����3 G��� G��N G�N��=
}e/ ��{�s ];�e GI� �¥ Y�� 2R �<V� �� ,Pc1k� ��;��2�� .2V� �� ,�� N 26² !��M�� g�� �{EAN� �A� i" ghi*
�����e�s Q<;��s ��"�� :" PKN+��� P"<�� P=����2�/ !KyF� b%N��
ihg 12jV� : YV�#�� b�W �� � { >���I ��1�U)� b�2{ **G��: � ? !����{ **P��_: S��y�� ]#Aq P;�d�� P#8M��hÇÇÇ Â�¼Ç*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
,P�+�=��� PN�<�� P��2#��3 PAj�V� ����W;� �3 P{�� PR%ak� m^��#� ��� �Ps�e �8�� ��I ��2� �,s ,PV�� G�K_ G/ �K6� P3O�= b%NÖ� G´s r�Le
� ���3 E?1�8���3�U�/ ���P #� P��R �/ PR�� P��� C �"ghi* �� >z�#V� >1�U)� L" � �� m2 � �;/ �� Y�%N�� `�#�� lI Y8 ��_ �W � �
P�2#��� P�1�#�%��� ���� * ® ��"� * ª*IPK���k� µ _ P#��:3 O��Nk� � s1 :" ��3�u 4#31/ ��M�/
��"6� �+,s b%N�� E,�� �¤ F�3 �c�� G� < F0� ��s/ �;/� �#�� J�AN4�K���k�"g�i*
�G�8��u .� .� ? ��"� :" 46A<V� �� !_1�� �1�u Í= 1�j�;� ���P6AWV� 1�j#�� �<;�s ]Aa� �V �<;�s C"*
�I �×���� �� '�F_ `� P×�%N�� ��2�� �×j� _ ` ��2)� �×j#�� C� ? G�e� ,Y�%N�� EK)� ]B 2A3 n�I Y�%N − P���#<�� P3�#�� PKA6V�−
!s��"�� �3O� ����)� P��8�N�� §�FM�� �MR� Ê���� C !dV� �3 J»F�, +s ��)� ^w_ 7�� ��2)� �s b�R/� ��#N �3 5�5#�� 28� rAV� b���V� �6K� G/
�P6��= x1k� ��#6�� !R/ 1�{�* E�� G�e �� b��k� mL? �e�_ m2,y_ .L�� .��j�R��� �<�� 1��"�N���
ihg 12jV� :�8�� E_�a� ¶�1���� P��×�, �����e�s Q<;��s, P��_ : l�k� P#8M�� 4�/ 2Ò/ 4<�hÇÇ Â � ��� P�ZA� b��?k� 5e��½É*
i�g 12jV� :!(�º� P���� P;+A#�� T�"N, .2,u 26² O��N��,  ��s��� 1��Çh*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
-2"#3 �×,A8R� ,EK FpA� �×,s 4�%N�� ��{� ��� -2��� «���� G�e v"s .��×j�R�� 1�×��� G�e� ,1�,u >2� !e G�V}�� !�� Ps%�(�� ����K)��
%N�� !{� G/ ��� ,�×e�_ !e C >1�3 P�%� vN��� ��_1� 7�� EKpA� G�� �� ����� !a� b�� C 1��� ��o�ÄÄh lIhh C 1��� [�/�Ähh ,
��k P���K�� PAKyV� �/2?� ,��j�� lI ���^=� �e�_ 43 ����5 �� ]A{�� C t�A��� PAKy�� m�V� PAKy�� �%{��V� PAKy� !� E_� ,��"� L � >��
b��5�� P6{�� ��8 MNI* ��ua�� eu@RB� �?1 y<� yuH �C�\�#
� ���"#� G�� !�k� ->1�H �� -P��Ks -P�%NI Y��� �%?Z�� ��5F_ ��»a F6A Á� Y#8M�� EA#��s ,P���V� P;2N� ,��)�� P ,e ���= �� EA#�� ]3�{/� ,
l�k� ���{/ �c� � � �p;�, ��u 7�� �3�j; lI �s ��k� �= F N � � �p;��� *
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A ñŠÏbØÛa@Þë†Ûa@â†Ônm@a‡b½@ @
y*@^ y3^ ��@ ¹8# �9 :Z ��uW� �u5 ����^ ,@�1�PPP ::::المعطياتالمعطياتالمعطياتالمعطيات
h − n� ? ,�Ae Y�%N�� `�#�� Cg½ÄÄ P#��=i n� ? PK���k� >2p�V� ������� Cg½Ã½¼ P#��=*i
� − !(�ºI '� _h %���M���� t�p3k� �� Y��"�� �,Aa� �� '� F_ 4� C ��Ä*ÄÄÄh %���M���� t�p3k� �� Y��"�� �,Aa� ��*
− Y6A#�� �p8�� P;�5� §��_ �1�s1�? P#��= C Y6A#�� �p8�� P;�5��A� ��� �,s +3 P3�#�� ��2�� �� C*
::::النتيجةالنتيجةالنتيجةالنتيجة
�sh¼Ä !3�; >5(�:3 .��À−�� �%ahĽ Pc�V� P N− ���O >Z��� C �s� (�©�3 46A<�>5* $�V�RB� w�(1� : Ý�6 F� � Æ� ,�de/ �s2� �63 ���R Y6A#�� �p8��� !
,@R W� ���9 $�AB �.9� [@t! C#! K �#�9 �º� $�AB ¥��1� �C�6 [@t! p���Õ����Ô��Ó���Ò��Ñ
Ø��×��ÖLghiP
ihg P��� ,��? >1�N :ghhÃi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
F*z�1� _� l`�ghiP ->�%3 �� �s �p; +3 �� ; G/ �R��� .L��s b5 FÀ G/� ,G�6A<� � ;k v"s
-2=� >�3�d� �� �s E? +3 J�w�� v"s; E,s �� $� �� 2#3/ �? G��s�e E�k n%?I G/ 5�5#�� J��K�� �j; ]�� 2"s ,�3��e C �_��o� ,�;�e C �� � N
4V�W��, � 1�©�� EA�W��3 � v<"��� �2#��3 G�K� +�;I��Ó� � ÒÔ�g�i./ ,: EA�W��3 � �2#��3*
l�#_ ��R�: ���R� �Q� �P� �O� �N� �M� � � � �L� �K� �J� �I� �H
S�g i* %s ;�3�"�� mLa/ C ��2� �+K� ; EA�W�� �� PN �2"V� �_�O l�#_ �� m �5 s
EA@� � ���� ��� �� ��I �3�L#3 Sj�* m2�� G�K� � n ��� �G/ lI m^<�_ C Y8q�"�� S?O 2"s r�O !=/ ���
8N ���<sI �3 GZ"� 7Ë�� E�k� n%?� ��8 �`�W_ �/ ,x1k� C ���"� ;��8#�� 43l�#_ :�Ø��×��Ö��Õ����Ô��Ó���Ò��Ñ�gÅi*
ojvÇ@bß@oîÇë@ìÛë@L�ýí†jm@�a@òä�Û@†£@åÛë@Léãì×@¿@�a@òä�@êˆçA@ @
ghi 12jV� :� ,Y���� �� 3 C* ,�K�_ 5e�� ,�"{ 2��a��−� ���3*
i�g P��� ,G� �|V� >1�N :gÅhi* i g P��� ,���#y�� >1�N :g�ļ− �ÄÇi* iÅg P��� ,��? >1�N :ghhÃi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A _“Ça…@ìç@âý�⁄a@Ýç@ @
7f.9 |� W�� �C�\� (J@B� (���� �� � d0�(5 © �� v0 ;�» _�1� y��1� Z�0��FV@�¨B� �C0\� ya��� �G.3!� ,x(��!
J�: F� ���/ �L?�!!! s � #� >�pA� !, 7�� .��V� ��=��� �� !"�<� 7�2"� 2pAV� ?�,8A<� ��
7�� �A� 5�+�_� .��V� 1�q�� ��:�_ P6R >�pA� !?��s� 2pAV� ?�,R�?I
"� +e P6:; �����; ��� � <�/ G���N �1�e 2pAV� 1�Karl Sagan ?��=�A� ������ � �"8q 2pA� !e 1�"� +e� ,��)�3
� �#� x1k� !?/ >��3I C .��� ��KuI %s �����3�! ')�� P6"�� C $� �� rKy��� �de/ � Y�%��� �yA� b%K�� �L? G/ b/
G/� ,§%ak�� 2pAV� Aa�� ����|� � ?� #�� >�)� P6"3 � ��;+�I �;��=� P(��� ��1��Mc� � r� � � �?�
����/ 2�/ 43 2pAV� G��s : ��I3 EA<��� ���=� >�pA� G� �� !"�<� �ao.��V� ��=���− -`�� �� �?� #� 26�<_ �ao− � G�e �� �I� 2"� � G/ �Í���!
��� >�)� G/ ��I� .���; ]8d� EA#�� ®�� �,���N� r�^w� � ��V� G/ ./ -�� .��� >1O [R��_ G/ t20 %s ,§%q�� �� G�<;�� !a�� Pe�)� ��
G/ t20 �� ,>�)� 2"�3�_ ��;�ZK��� [R� ��>�)� SA<3 ���1�� *s +K'AMV� ��j�� 2 � �I [R��_ � >1L�� G´s P�1L�� ���5��� � �6A�, ��V� ��/
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
F_ � ��u/ Y,s >�)�� 1�q�� C ^w .1L�� ./ -�� §%q�� ��* 1 QK#��3 !3�� �s�2_ 2�5� Â�{���3 !�"�� +3�ZK��; ,P3�jV� P"M V� C �
.��V� ���<V� �� ��8<K� 2#� !�"�� �����3� !2pAV� �8#� [Ks! 2pAV� �2� ���H 1�a 2=�� � E,V�!
EA<��� ��I� ,m��)I 1���� >�)� 7 #63 EA<��� ��IP���V� >�W �� Ppj3, �?^� �� ��� 2"� � G/ �� �= �� �����3�!
�>�)� 7 #� �� m� ��N� � ��2"_ ��;��)� �dek � 8?O ��, r�%e ^#� �As ./ -b+�?�r�Le Q� G�<;�� + 3 ,P3�:�N��� ^dV�� >5��w�� ��� 1�2� �,s ,!
-P�2"63 7_/ G�<;��s -P��+N � #� �_�)�7 �P6R m��=��� �P���� !�� }e/� ,>�)� 7 #63 �Z#� �_�O 2pAV� G/ r�O ��, ��� 2"� � �? �����3�!
^�� ')� C $� �� rKy�� m��)I x�#� 4� 2pA� �;/ 2pAV� PAKy�P��w��3� ��=��� 7 #63� P6"��3� ��3 ��|�� ,��2���, 4� §%ak� P"AM63�
��2�� 2"� �! �� 48�<s 2pAV� �,c�#� -P,8u P�/ C G�<;�� '�R� � !���� !6B ��/ ��
�_�O �À����! � 2=�� �� -S?L� �� [\N/ S?L �2� P,8u x�� ��:V v"<�[��\V� S?LV�*
��)��s 7 #� !Ap�� �Aj� �� ��<;�� ��=��� >�?�@ !Ap�� �Aj� ����"_ �� P6"�� J�#�N� �� >�)� 2 � ]8� G/ �� [\N/ �? �L� P��w��
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
-G�<;I �PA� ��� >2���* ��)� G�e ��� � #�7, G�K� �As��2�� 2" � ��� ,P6R� S���< 2pAV�
�%{/ 2" ��* � #� >�pA� G/ ��´s� '0 � ��I� ,Y(��%�� .��V� 1�q�� �� !"�<� 72pA6A
G/� -1�qI C ��1L�� �#3 ^w_ 1�"� �� 2"� .���, �,6<� Y�����#8��">�� SAN"x1k� !?/ >��3I 2"� � G/ �� '0 �� , � �#�, >��3��s
����� ��Ma ]<��?2"� � 7�� �! 4;��"� �U¯ .��� '<; �� �de/ Q� G�<;I �? �� �� G�<;��s
P6:; P���; ��� ,���6��� P#8M��! 6A� ��/ � Á6s �����3�x�#��� � 6� G/ 2pA ��O�3 G�<;Ö�?
5e�V� C G�K� � ��2��3 ��|� � .L��s, 43 �� �� ��� �? +;I���uk�!
�� �� G�<;� �� � �;/ 48�� P��<V� mL? 9�M� E��K�� Go�"��s �L��G�<;I �? !� � �28� �;�e �� �I �?26�<� � ��6R� �s� +;I�!
8� �%a �� �I G�K� � G�<;�� ��s�;�p8N � �����! ���»��º��¹��¸��¶��µ��� �´��³��²��±��°
Ã��Â���������Á��À��¿¾���½��¼�ghi *
ghi 3�4(!� �� � : �����,+�*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��&� Y? P#8M��� 5e�V� �? G�<;��s* �� �� m��#�3� 12"3 `�#�� �L? C m�6N �� G�<;�� 2#�8�����e� �d
g��f�ghi* @bß@ÝÜ−ë@LŠöb¨a@ð…b§⁄a@Õ�äÛa@åÇ@�ýîÜÓ@†ÈnjäÛ@åØÛïßý�g@‰ìÄäß@åß@“Ça…@éi@âìÔmZ@ @
هل يجوز قتل الشيعة؟هل يجوز قتل الشيعة؟هل يجوز قتل الشيعة؟هل يجوز قتل الشيعة؟ - - - - ١١١١
C 2��� ±; 2=�� � �;/ EA<� !e �,s�#� Y��� ��À28�� �� 5� �� J��e ���N1 P N �/ !=�−EAN� �A� �� �{− Y#y�� !�"3 ����!
� Â�\uk� �#3 S� C �%�a� �? !{k� C P#y�� 43� � 3 �%� Y8 �� S Áp{ �¤ 1�"� +e ������ �%� P��23 �? �L? ,EAN� �A� �� �{
43� � 3 §�s � .�A#�� �y���s ,Y�#�� ¿� ^,y�� Y#y�� Y�%N�� �K�V�<�� !?/ Þ¿� �8² E? P#y��s ,�� C P 3/�7 �6�� �K3, 3/ �8² E? P <���7
4#�/ E, � �� ¸1 ¿�� �6�� �K3* C P������ 1��R .1�H b�W 3 ��"���� �� >1�8� �pj�� .�A#�� �y���
P��N1 !60 �6��� ,P�k� PU, � !?|� b�W; ��8=��3 �, � �6�� �� 3 ��P��N*
2N���� .��j�� �y��� �K�–����� G���I m��"_ .L��− ��"���� lI �W � -P��� �� P6(k�3 �� ��N Q� E¥ ��"���� �,s G�K� ��a/ ×3 ��"�gh� i
P#8M�� ��1� �� Q = �� Pj\u, �+R1 �� Y H�� �N2"� � Sp; G/ � A� S·
ghi ���� ,��� �� � :����*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
E,�I J�"�;� E,A� Y d;� �¥�p{/* 2N���� .��j�� �y��� 2(�"� �� �� '8M � �L?�– P#=���� ��28��e
�?^�� P#�V�� P"���� Q6�� P6j#��� − �P;1�"� �pj�� .�A#�� �y���3� .L�� �3 ��2 �#� P <�� !?/�*
��"q�? S8N �?� ,b��� G���I PAKy� �? Õ�<�� .��j�� �y���� � Y��� ����� S8N� ,P�2(�"#�� �� <)� �����¨ S8N� ���)� P ,e
[R��_* لكن هل هذا أيضا يVجيز قتل الشيعي؟لكن هل هذا أيضا يVجيز قتل الشيعي؟لكن هل هذا أيضا يVجيز قتل الشيعي؟لكن هل هذا أيضا يVجيز قتل الشيعي؟
,� A� �� E,A�� � � �� E& G�6A<� P#y�� b��� SA�/ P���K�� «28���E���� ��"q�¥ �� �¥ G�6ÝA<F� �� ���N1+� � P#y��*
(^ �?1ya�^ Z��� :��� �¬� F�*m1� ¦�5�F�R1� y�� )��$ ��J*3�R�� , ?yu�1� �#
FN !�"� .L�� Y#y�� Ý �"s �? � � ±�"F� � !�"� .L�� Y <��e v8U��3 ,v �#uY��� b2�� 1��/ ��/ ,� P ,e �I �,:=|� %s [R��_ � Y��� ������ .��
|? ��d�/� ,P�2(�"#�� �����\V� �%�� Q6� �=���� ���)� �S� �� � �� ��~8� ��<�� �N�*
C .2,V� Í=� G� 8� C !�/ Pe�pe P���=�� P#y�� ��yA� �,W_ `�>2"#�� lI PAj3 ]� � ���� E�1 �� �I §��#�� �� Pppj�� P�A<��
]8��G��c��� E,A�*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
ò•ý¨aZ Y#y��� ,Y#y�� EA<V� b� P��� !d� Y <�� EA<V� b� P��� Ý FN !�"� .L�� b�:V� ª�?1�� �±�"F� � �#u �;�K� Q�� !_�R �;�K� � ��!
��)�e v8U��3 �#u !�"� .L�� Y <�� ���! � P��� �A6y_ � %e���h��g��f���e��d��c
�r��q�����p��o��n��m��l���k��j��i� ghi* ���z b%N��s -Q�; !�R G/ C ->2��� – ��/];�e �− 2c P6��= �?
� P;�<;����T���S��R��Q��P��O��N��M���L��K���J��I
U�g�i* b��� 7�� P��j�� mL? lI !j_ ` P��2�� �2#�� Ee�² + 3, �8j_ 7�ps
Ð F0 � �� lI ��"�� �2� !j� G/ 23� P;�<;�� 2c P6��= P#R����! هل يجوز قتل نصارى العراق والشام ومصر؟هل يجوز قتل نصارى العراق والشام ومصر؟هل يجوز قتل نصارى العراق والشام ومصر؟هل يجوز قتل نصارى العراق والشام ومصر؟ - - - - ٢٢٢٢
2��� ±; 2=�� � ���N1 P N �/ �� J��e C −,@�� %*@0 �� v� − ����Y�L�� !�"3 −b�y��� §��#�� �1�j; ���− ���L�I ��� 7��(�!
s b%N�� ���z x�#��� ��� G/ C ��L���3 Æ?�#6A� ,�s�K�� Y�L�� �/ 2�}e P6��=! 28� �� ��R EAN� �A� �� �{ Y8 �� �� +, � �� ¸1 ��6� �3 �� :Û ��
ghi ���� ,5�*6� �� � :����* g�i ���� ,�78�/� �� � :��+�*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
7��0 e�5� fR� �� (j�� �GH �6� ,F�D� FJa� ®�� / 7�(���� y�^�Üghi * ؟؟؟؟- - - - نصارى الموصلنصارى الموصلنصارى الموصلنصارى الموصل- - - - ينينينينتهجير الذميتهجير الذميتهجير الذميتهجير الذميهل يجوز هل يجوز هل يجوز هل يجوز - - - - ٣٣٣٣
b%N�� P8? Y? vN�k� §��� C P �2�� §����� �� Hk�! P<eO�H1k� ]c�";� b%N�� ���� 23Ô� �%d� , ^:,�3 ��"; [Ks
?4A{k� �%8�� J�p{/ æc@áÜÈm@Ýç@Z@ @
P<eO�H1k� Q(� K�� ]��B 2� �� !3�5� lI �� b%N�� ��a� !8RG������?!! K�� G�e����pj�� C E,?�=� �� 46(�? PN��<"��� P ,?!
���/� �I b%N�� ��= G/ ��� ,x��";%� Pc�#� P<eO�H1k� ];�e�E?2(�"� PN1�¤ P��� E& 9�_/� E,<(� e lI PN��<"��*
G/ S:#�� ��� >��K�� n���M3� P<eO�H1k� P< K�� �3�3 4�� 3 �8;k�P<R�V�, b%N�� ��a� !8R >��8� �� G�e PAq ���pj�� C ��31�?h �����
� � b��/ m�a/ ��p3O G/ 2#3! J��e C�"1�<K <��" >��K�� Q(� e C !6#�<FV� 4<�2"�� 1�8ak ���©�
G�� � ]B ��"� P<R�V�"×�� ��k� 4�� 3 �3�8�� P��; ¼ g¼ P3�q i¿� �� :" �31�? G�e 4�� 3 �8;k� GI� PAq ���pj�� Ch �����, S�e 2R �3��? !8R G�e�
Jk� J��? 2#3 t2�� ,����¯ G�3 >���k� ��N�1� P�R�Nk� �(�N lI ��1�y �
ghi 9��: � ;<�=>*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P����� b�� ��2A"�� ��2"A� QR�"V� �,�I !{� G/ P< K�� �� n���M8��� m2� �c�s rAV� !áR Æ� Á? !Æ8ÁR �� P��V� 1��2�� ¿� Pe���M8��� ,Q(� K�� ¿
�8 = §��/� ��^de �3L�� 4�� 3 �8;k� �a/ � � �� �8R� 4 �|V� 2,Mc�� �%8�� �5�� �� x1/ lI Â�#�� �3 ��6� !{� !AR 2#3� ,��R�� �_��/ EH ��3��e !N1/ 4�� 3 �3�8�� ����a�3 Â�#�� �3 ��6� EA� OI� ,4 N t%H �¥ b�R/�
P��V� �%8�� �(�N lI�s ��"� : �1�j �� n���M3 4�� 3 �s .L�� �c�V��<(� e� �8#u ��2� �� ~6M� �� �o »pAs ,b%<��� G��k�� 2,#�� �� v8"��*
2#3 4�� 3 �8;k� »ps >�� PH%H �R G/ i!g �31�? P N� �3 ��6� ���e/� , ����eI Â�#�� �2(� ���,e%�/� �<(� e EA<�� G/ ��/� ,"ghi*
2#8s E,<(� e G�~u 9%{I lI G���V� ��� �� lI b%N�� ��a� �!�a� ��2#3 ���_� �,��W; � Æ� Ý6 F�� E,<(� e lI PN��<"�� ���� ,�,A6u §
>���k�! �¬��: �8{/� ,`�#�� C ��ARk� 2#N/ �� T�8R/ 1�{ b%N�� !@ C�
`�#�� ��1� Q(1 E, � g ��� $�M3i, H/ � ����H/ �� `�#�� g$����N PA(��i , PAR/ n� ?/ ,b%N�� ��1��� �� Y? +;I �,A� ��Aj� Y��� §�")� mL?�
? PA��#V� mL? 2� Y8Aj�� �/ ��,j�� G�K�� !@ C Í#_ P6A<� -P�(�Me P<eO�H1Ô� �W � b��� lI J�w�� G/ �eLF� �� S:� �� !3 PR�
�� Yp<V� `�#��3 �& PR%� �ª�w* G��: � ? !����{ ��"� :" �31�/ ��2�
ghi 12jV�:− 1�<K <�� J��e,  ��k� �5©��ÅÇ P8pV� P8�K� P#8q*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
mL? P<eO�H1k�� b%N�� /28�� P3�w�� Pp<V� Y,� _ �� �s��w= Y,� _� Y?31�k� �� �?2�|� Y��� P3�=�8 �< �� Â}R� P6A<V� �e�_ ]�� ��� ,
G�;��� 7�� ,ª�1�k� ��B�� C +,s J���� ^� 4���� P<eO�H1k�k� ��U�/ }��� ª1��� ��B%� b+U;�� C P3�#j3 ]p:; Y��� P<eO�H1
b�� ª1��� ��B��hÇÇÅ PMA� ��B�� C �,���U� G/"ghi* ��o �Aa�23 EU� !(�?� E\c [p�� lI vN�k� §��� ��B 2"s
b%N�� P�+N !U�3 §���k�� ��× Hk� �s EK� .L��* � !3�� P��2#_ 2=�_ �P�%N�� P��2�� C �I P, 5 F� Y��� �?2�� Y,s
Ý �� J�p{k Æp µ;���� EA<V� + 3 ,E, 3 +s E,#(�� ��"8MF� G/ P�A�\V� ! +& '0 �� ,µ;���� �+A#�� �2V� 1��N2��3 G��5A F� µ;���� µeO�H1k��
�#�� '8M_Pj\y�� ����k� C 7�� +,* بالجثث في القصاص؟بالجثث في القصاص؟بالجثث في القصاص؟بالجثث في القصاص؟ التمثيلالتمثيلالتمثيلالتمثيلهل يجوز هل يجوز هل يجوز هل يجوز - - - - ٤٤٤٤
Â�jÁR !�R G�e ��� 7�� !d6���3 �d:A� x�#��� �� �P��z 7, � b%N��! ��2)� C� !3 ,EA<� �p{ C ��)�3 �d©�3 !d6��� �� Y, �� ��=�
EA<� T� �� P=�� �3�� 2Ò/ m��1 .L�� �pj��:Û l·?9 2*B� ,q0 ·9 ¼*+�Ü*
�L?��s b2� �� 2�2u �� ]6A� x�#���*
ghi 12jV� :YV�#�� b�W �� � { >���I ��1�U)� b�2{ ,G��: � ? !����{ , P��_: S��y�� ]#Aq P;�d�� P#8M��hÇÇÇ Â�½¼*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
؟؟؟؟- - - - اليزيدياتاليزيدياتاليزيدياتاليزيديات- - - - هل يجوز سبي النساء لمجرد كفرهن هل يجوز سبي النساء لمجرد كفرهن هل يجوز سبي النساء لمجرد كفرهن هل يجوز سبي النساء لمجرد كفرهن - - - - ٥٥٥٥
-J��e ./ C J�LK� �/ «�c�� 2 <3 ��� ��� `� EA<� ���"� � b%e �L? ��s 2#3 ���8N �� ��<; Â�#�� �3 ��6� La/ !,s �I� ,§%q�� �� Y�%NI
��? �s�K��s ,���"�� P��N� Pe�#V� x1/ C �p � Y8<�� ,!�"F� !_�"V�
�����I� �, � ��#�� �/ 46A<V� ��^N�3 �,(�2s E�� 7�� 78<F_ PA_�"V� >�s�K���� �2#A�e����d��c��b��a��`��_��~��}�ghi*
���< �� Y8N P��p3 G�;�R �c� E_ �� –G�� !{�� �? +e− �· � � ,s ,'H��V�� 4;��"�� P���¨ EA<6A� �� �,#MR Y��� ��,#��� �<�; �2#�� /23 �� �I ,
P���\V� C Eu�w��! FB �A�� r�Le� ,G�� J��)� è 78<�� � � 7��� 'H��V�� ��,#�� !e bZ
-�7y3 �;��2�/ � A��� �As «���3 v8U � !{/ �;2 � ��; � � �� è 5(�= ^��3 E,A�, �%d� !d6���e *EA�/ ���!
Z�nR1� ��3� F��G�1� c�: (j�� y� eu@RB� )�@0 �� (+�� /�0 �� F�*�
d0�$ FV*@� T��5 F*�C�6 F*��$ FR�n� F�� �� �� )�@�1� �39? � �/ 2pAV� ����?^� �� Í��� C rp6�, �I��,s ��)� � �"8qm � �·�
�A{� ��"8�� P:p3 � �#� �8�� >��3ISurvival for the Fittest *
ghi P��� ,26² >1�N :gÅi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
� �·�� � [<; P6�� �=� C ["� � Æ� !e� >5:#��� 4R�#V�� Ê�V� � Y#8M�� J�\�;��Natural Selection *
�� ��)�� P?�� �� �� E,�� � ,��)�� �� 1��k� mL? 2#8�<� .L������<As!
¦��K�� !8a1/ C 4�%V� >��3I �K_ ` �L��The Gulag
Archipelago �� 4 � 2pAV� 2� �� .��)I 1 �}� �%a �� �I ,4���N 2pAV.���*
>��3I ]<���½ % ��3 2pAV� 2� �� .��)I 1}63 �I ����86e G�KN �� ��3pol pot *
��V/ YR� Á� .��� Y��R 1}63 �I �,Ae P;�d�� PV�#�� J�)� P��RI ]<���A�? [���/ 2� ��*
�,�pc 9�1 Y��� 4j�� C Ps�"d�� >1�d�� ]<��4�%V� ���� 1}63 �I .��� .��)IMao Zedong*
�� ��1�"�� ¾���_� P���V� SN�KV�� ,���O C P��� ��)�� C J�)�s PR� Á� ��1� ,P���� P ��1�� ����sI �I �,Ae ]<� §���k� ^,M_� ,�8��
P#8q* �1�Ks �1�y��1 ��"�Richard Weikart :"�� �:; 2"� SAR C ��)
� �N/1 §%ak� G�5� ,PA�"��� 4��:V� !K� Y6A#�� $�Nk� �s�� ,S"� ��;�e ,PV�#�� E(��©� �y3/ G�3 ,E,#� G��#_ ��� E,<�;/ «� R� P"")�3 ]
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
>1�Ky� PR%a/ PAUs"ghi*
� �"8q���)Ö� !e «�2�I S· 7R1k� Q ©� �� d�N�3 P��8�� $� =k�M_ ��"A� ��/ P:p3 ��;��)� Â��R/ !a�� �L? '8M_ E_� ,>��"�� P�1�
�A6��: b�� Y�sh¼¼Ç �?2�� Q�1�3 C PV�#�� G��)� P"�2� ]c� Æ�ÅÄÄ
4A{k� G�K<�� �� ±\u* S:#�� ��� !3 �8����e G��� P"�2� G/ b��h¼Ç 4��� EU_ ];�e
�6N1� 43� �� J�8y�� �#3 S;�= lI* −V� §2j� � +31 �6N1 E?��2=/ G/ 4��V� ��2pA Â��R/ !a�� ��;�e �
��)�� EN´3 �31� G�R �� !R/ L �− * Q��� ];�N P �2� C ]~y;F/�St. Louis x�#_ G��� P"�2� �K����3
^dK�� +s 4 8A��� �� .1�M��� Y ��1�2�� b2"��� Se�63 76<F� G�eparade
of evolutionary progress* P"�2� C P<(��� ���2d�� E<R C G�c�#F� >2�2©� � � �� b�5Rk� G�e�
QK;��3 G���* The Primate section of the Bronx Zoo *
��L�� ��|? �� ���p� V� �,u/� �8�� ��;��� ��R/ ��Aa�� ��� E?�
i1g Richard Weikart, from Darwin to Hitler, p.215.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�: 3 �_�/ G�e ��)��Ota Benga . ghi*
�8�� P"3 �� E,q�#_ C PR%a/ ��8�/ P�/ �� ���8_/ ��)�� 1 ��� 2"�* P6:6©� E:� $�R E_ � �U�/ ��)�� !a���Skull Measurement
� ��1�� 7;�k� §���k� P�j�� �6N1 E���3I� � S8<3 PV�#�� J��)� ]��R� ,��A{Ô� ��"8��� PR�#�� P" ���� G�<;Ö� >�W �� mL?*
P��K<#�� ��2pAV� PM3�1 ��,@�League of Militant Atheists �31�/ }� 4 �2�V� �� ���� ��~� ]A�R Y���g�i*
r�O �� E?k� �K� �8�� �� 4�%V� ���� 2��� -G�R C ��)�� ��3/ 2"�C G�<;� !�/ !e ��3/ �;/ � �;�<;I G�K� G/*
� �"8q���)Ö� [ j_ ]B ¦12 _ >/�V�Homo parietalis !=��� + 3 [ j_ ]BHomo frontalisg i*
�� 1��6�N�3 G�2pAV� t2p��� ���j� ¶V� E:� C .�?�= §�s ��=� 1�2"63 !=���h�− hÇ % , G/� r�O '3�M� ��K� >/�V�3 Â�� ¶V� E:ps
i1g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ota_Benga. i2g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/League_of_Militant_Atheists. i3g http://www.rae.org/pdf/dsod_apb.pdf.
Love, R., Darwinism and feminism: “The ‘women question’ in The
Life and Work of Olive Schreinr and Charlotte Perkins Gilman,” in
Oldroyd and Langham, Eds., The Wider Domain of Evolutionary
Thought, D:Reidel, Holland, pp. 113–131, 1983
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
%�1�w��3 Â��ghi * � P���q S8<3� ��)�� ��3�/ C >/�V� GI !3 � ��Ma }�#_ �¥ Â�� ¶V
�""�>z�#V� >1�U)� �� � *A real danger to contemporary
civilizationg�i* ���1�2� � �"8q >/�V���5 V� b�,V �I �Aj_ �, �I]8�� �� P:,8�� ���c ,
K�� �� !Us/ ]8�� C >/�V�sSAg i * �0 �7�*4 X��� p� (J@u5 o*1 ,��f� �� d0�$ c �Ju�� ;`1� (J@B�#
l$�<6P òÃìzÜß@òßbçë@ ñ��cZ �� !e C P��AW� Í��� G/ 1�"� 2R 46A<V� �#3
,«�c�V�3 �� PR%� � �L?� ,�,�I S<F;s ]=�1 !(�<� �� t2p�; �p ��%�I.����� �� >2,#��� ,�de/ � >2y3 �!
�,�""� C ��2� Q�� ,��� �� b%��� �=��F� �� lI �=��� �;2" s�& b%��� �8< � �� Ppj3 b5:; � �p s!
i1g Gould, The Mismeasure of Man, p.105. i2g Gilmore, D., Misogyny: The Male Malady, University of Pennsylvania
Press, Philadelphia, p. 125, 2001. i3g an object to be beloved and played with, better than a dog anyhow.
Charles Darwin, The Autobiography of Charles Darwin 1809-1882,
New York pp. 232-233.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
� ? �p s v"s !j����3 b�"; ����� �� 2pAV� �?O C �"�N� �� �� � ��� 3b%��� �L?*
5e�_ �#y�<� �M��� EA<V�� ,1�8= Y�%�I ���y_ ��=�3 �Z#; �p;�PW�� �� 43�?1�� �� P <�� !?/ ^� C + 3 P <�� !?/ �� �?��� J�?1��
� �6�� C P#���� 1�j;/ 1�q G�23 ���(�M�� [j"_ + 3� ,��MpV� Ô6�P6AK3 ��� 4H�)� J�?1� x�#�_!
��3/ .L�� 2Nk� 1�y3 �� J�"_ � ��� P��2�� �+W ��� !_�"_ + 3�#<�� �8#u [j;�a�� [j �� ^:,�� 7!
�#u 2� ��� P N !?/ ��N ���;��;��= C 2� ��� �2���� G�e� ,�¥r� ��"_ �K���/ : Ý FN G�K_ �/ E,V� ��y_ �� !�R� �� Ë�u �I� !e C r_1�{ � ?
G�K�, n1�W�;�3 � _��(�q G�K�N� ,r3 J�?1�� PW�� �;���! S�0�D� �G§ �0 �s�� �?1?�C�\� v0 FA+ ,� y�� F�fV?�1�
b%N�� Pp{ P��/ �� P�^�K��� ���+©� 1�,@ G/ �1/ �;/! Y8 �� Gk–EAN� �A� �� �{ − 1�,W3 }a/>�dK3 4�^�K��� �ao C
G��5��s , ÆEËA ÆN Æ� Á�á ÆA Æ� FË�� Ë� Æ{ ��" :Û |� | ��� W)� |� |( W+ �� �� | ��� |� ��1� �� ��i �c ���� ���|� ��� �� |C �+| ��� W)� |G |V W� , �F �� � |¶�1� �Z �� | � �f |� �� �� |��W1�W� |� , W£ W� �u |� |� |9 �� |C �� � �\� �� �� |�� W W� �u |� �F�* �� ��1� �� �� W, �G �R1� , �, W� |� �j�|� |+ �,W Wº |���6 W� ��� | W� |p , �, W��W@W� � � |# �, W�� WuW�* ��|1 |�|� ��|� |# , ���� |#
|� �, WG |@�� | �F |��|* ���1� |� �� |� �, WG |@|� | ��|�B �� �jÜ ghi*
ghi .1�\8�� m��1ÉÇ Ä EA<�� ,hÃÃh*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
E��y3 P���/ �3/ m��1 .L�� �a�� ��2)� C� :Û ,)�R1� ,�$� 2¸ v�^ « ¢y*�^ f� l�@�^ ��Ü*
���/ �� �{�� �+e ��� !3–EAN� �A� �� �{− �L� �;/ 1�Z��� �� �;1��"s E?�{� E�%j3 :Û �� �_%{ Ee2�/ �"0 ,E����R �� �_���R� ,E�%{
b%N�� �� G�R�6� ,E?�=� � ��· � Go�"�� G���"� ,E,��{ �� ���{� E?�A�R�s E?�6�"� + �/ ,P���� �� E,<�� §�6� +eÜ*
G��5�� �ao ���%� �� P�^�K��� ���+©� 1�,Ws! W_ ` �;/ ��� ,PR%� T�"N L � b%N�� P�/ ��� lI �@� ��� P��� �,
.�����3 ��,@ �I 4V�#�� J1 ��� '8M_ �p; 7#<_ P�%{I P�AN P�%NIP�+©� rA_ ��:�;/ �� 1+H 2<�_ P�^�K_ P���2#3 ��� !8R �� ��k� �AAs ,!
Z��� �� _�5: P#�2�� Pe}�� 1�j�� ];�e� P��AW� ��� ];�e �� EAW�� �, � �s�� G/ �� ��<; �,���<s ,�,���_� P3�#�� �%8�� S��\�� �}e
46A<V� '�56�� 7#<�� ��1�{ m�y� �¤ E"� � G/� ,�%8���! -ÍM3 �� b%��� �?1�j� +e ];�e ��� - �K_� 46A<V� b��#� -��}=�
<s ,EA@� �� Pp{ �� !��� P�o Y?� G��5�� �ao J�ZR� �� P�%� Y? �,��� Y8 �� �3 }a/−EAN� �A� �� �{ − P�^�K��� ���+©� mL? ��d�/ 1�,@ ��,
�AjF� G/� m�� b5A� G/� Pppj�� �_2"#� EA<V� �M��� G/ �?2 � S·���� ����� !?/ n�8u C �"� � 7�� ,é�#V� S :��� ,m��/ Zw�� �%U
-P��1 ]B !_�"s E,��j3� E�%j3 �P�� ��6s P6� PA?�= * �� ��<;Ps�#��� P�%<��!
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A áènÛ…cë@´îiŠÌÛa@wvy@ÝÔäí@áÜ�½aA@ @
P��M���� PA"#�� r::p3 �"?�_ 4�� J�#�� ��2pAV� 2�/ 1��B 4�V�� >5?�©� ������ mL? �� 2��� �� r;´s P6A#��� P"M V�� P8A#� �"8<�:
4A:;�� 4"A� b%e G�A" _ E�;/* ¿:;I Y"Aa Á �#�� �L? !
��/ �� b2"_ 4� r� �?��2j�3 ª�#�� 2pAV� b�"N P"3�<�� ��1�8#�� PR1� Pm��)I v"<F_ P"M � P:� �/ ¿"� !�� �/ P6A�*
�MU� ,P"M � ��M��w� PA� .�B Y���� PKA,�<V� ��1�8#�� mL?� 2pAV�4� �,��2\�N� � ��1 �& 2· � P6A� P:� C �d#��*
Y? P"3�<�� ��1�8#�� C P"M V� ��M��wV� 2�/�: ]�@tB� y W��» Ft1�~�Irrelevant Conclusion : �1 �? J�AMV�s
�� 5s�"�� �;/ ª�#�� 2pAV� �A#�� �� �K� ,PA"#�� P:)� 2"; �/ P6A#�� P ?}�� �L? r�L3 �;/ �W� EH ,4A:;I 4"Aa b%e �L? G/ P:p3 �A?�:��� J�AMV�
�1 E�2"�3 b�R 2R -��e* 76<_ P"M � PM��w� �� .��B ��1�8#�� mL? � �U�/ ��31� ,*uR! Ft1�~�
Poisoning The Well : [#U�� ��M�� G/ Y #_ �~8�� E6<_ PM��w��� G/ 7�� !8R P:)� S��{ P j\y3 b�"N��d� ,��:� �� �AM : § Ý2jF_ �
����/ E�I ,G�3�w�� G�"A� r� ���"N ��* G�py� ª�#�� 2pAV� G/ �2_ Y��� P"M V� ��M��wV� PA� �� r�O lI ���
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�%p�<V� �� 1}_ Y��� P ��� ��q�"N��� ��1�j��� �� PA6:3 � �"8<� �� !#·� ,m��)I �,Aa�� �8"� Y��� PA"#�� !e b��/ 2{ v(�� ��1�j��� mL?
��<3 m��)� x�#�� ��* لكن في البداية م@ن هم الخلقيون الغربيون؟لكن في البداية م@ن هم الخلقيون الغربيون؟لكن في البداية م@ن هم الخلقيون الغربيون؟لكن في البداية م@ن هم الخلقيون الغربيون؟
��*�@��: E? J�w�� C r�L� ���W V� SA�/� ,'���3 G� �|� ��L�� E?Pp<V� PA:;�� P�(�M�� ��*
�:�� G/ ���0 �� � ���<_� �de/ 7 #63 �/ ,ª�#�� 2pAV� �s�#� � �� �A?�G/ �? ª�#�� 2pAV�:
7p��: 5,�<� � Æ� !e Q�X Aa �? J�w�� C ��)��3 Q�� ,¿:;I �/ Y"5,�<� �� !eX ¿K��� 2pAV� �%d� �Z#� ��2 #s ,��3 7�� ��|� �%d� 1�M���3
!��? 2��s ^,y��Fred Hoyle >2y3 5�À m��)I !#· `�#�� �L& m2{1 G/"greatly shaken" �3��e C ��"� +e"��U��� �� 1�M_" Evolution
from Space , È1�s ���?� G� � x�Zs� �? P(��y#�� x�Zs� G/�is
evidently nonsense of a high order , ��5B b��/ � <� � ? �p sP���"���, P �2�� P:)� >�"3 Y6N1 ��Z�� +;I�!
�w8�� 2pAV� ��p�� ��2 ��obnoxious atheist �<�; [j� +e 5 ��e Q<;��sFrancis Sellers Collins YK���k� �� ©� `��
.�8�� b� ©� «��� ��2�� ,�,uk�Human Genome Project , ��2 � ��3 G+��� lI ��p��.�8�� b� ©� PM�� ��N�1� �R�� ��, �p s
�� �s1� G+��� �p; �s2� EA� b��/��)!
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�7*���: G�e� � �1�#u rM#� 43�w�� 4"A� �� rH20 4� 2pAV� J�AN/ P��d� ��|? 4"A� G/� ,J�w�� C P��<�� �� G��M<V� E? ��2pAV� �dek� P~��� E?� P��d)� E? ��2pAV� G´s ,��k� �R�� C �K� P3�w�� ��#6�:V�
J�w�� C � �1�"��� §%q�� ��! 2R� PR%6#�� P6A#�� PA:V� ��;Scientific American Ì� ��dp3
��k�3 �;�� �In Atheists We Distrust " ��2pAV� C 'd; � �p;" , ��;�K� G/ !8"� �� ��2pAV� 'M� � YK���k� S#y�� SA�/ G/ PA:V� ] 3�
E,(� 3k 46A#� 7��! ghi* 2pAV�s ]N�3 G�M u��A� � �"8q� §%q�� �� P?��K� Pj\u �de/ �?
�K���/ Cg�i* <;�� P#��= �p3 S<p3� �< = O�y��� ��M�V� EA<V�s �_� J�R/ �
2pAV� �� YK����g i* � �"8q [ j�� ,��12\V� Y �2� P=1� Q� 3 2pAV� !��# F� !��}�� C�
i1g http://www.scientificamerican.com/article /in -atheists- we -distrust¬
i2g http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/why-do-americans-
still-dislike-atheists/2011/02/18/AFqgnwGF_story_1.html.
i3g http://newsjunkiepost.com/2009/09/19/research-finds-that- atheists-are-
most-hated-and-distrusted-minority¬.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
PAR/ �"��e PA��}�� P6N��� Ps�pjA�ghi* b� F0 �2 ���/ C� P��K)� $1�2V� C Q�12��� �� 2pAV�g�i*
G/ E�5� 4� ,�8�� �� ��Zs�� JLe� 1�� �? ª�#�� 2pAV� �A#�� +sJ�w�� C P6R ��2pA6A�* �6N1 E�� G�;��� C� 2pA� ./ ��"��� ���6e�²�g i*
-Sj � ./ 2pAV� l��� �/ PK���k� ������� 1��N� QN/ 2�/ GI !3 ��§%q��; 2pAV�s ,��;��k G+c �� m2,#� P6R � �� ��=� �K � .L�� Gk
�� !e m2 � rK��� ! �%d� :l�k� >��V� �� �N���� !j��� $�< e1/ P��� 1��N2� � �"8q :" �
C >��,yA� �%?/ G�K� �� ,P����� C .1��I Sj � ./ ��_ 2pA� .k '0P6KpV�"*
Arkansas State Constitution, Article 19 Section 1
i1g http://www.paulopes.com.br/2009/05/ateus-e-usuarios-de-.
drogas-sao-os-mais.html#.VCNTNBYZQQs
i2g http://www.irishtimes.com/premium/loginpage?destination=h.
ttp://www.irishtimes.com/debate/why-must-agnostics-be-obliged-to-
teach-faith-1.616580.
i3g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elder_Pastitsios.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Miscellaneous Provisions
No person who denies the being of a God shall hold
any office in the civil departments of this State, nor be
competent to testify as a witness in any court * ± � � ��1�e t1�; P��� 1��N�� G/ P ��d�� >��V� $��<�� !j��� C
PA?Ô� 2R�s 2pAV�! North Carolina's State Constitution, Article 6 Section 8 "Disqualifications of office. The following persons
shall be disqualified for office: First, any person who
shall deny the being of Almighty God*"
Q� 2pAV� G/ P#31/ >��� ��k� !j��� C �;��A< 3 P��� 1��N� ���� �%?/ P"dA�, Pp31 P<N|� P�/ ��y;I �� '0 %s �A��*
Pennsylvania's State Constitution, Article 1 Section 4
"No person who acknowledges the being of a God
and a future state of rewards and punishments shall, on
account of his religious sentiments, be disqualified to
hold any office or place of trust or profit under this
Commonwealth*"
>��V� $��<�� !j��� � ��1�e t��N P��� 1��N� �A� ± � �� Q�; �?�
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� �N���� !j��� µ _ P���� ,P;�d��P;�d�� >�"�*
��3 G+��� G/ P#3���� >�"��� ��k� !j��� $�<K_ P��� 1��N� 1�"��.1��I Sj � ��_� P"dA� YÀ23 T�*
Õj�@bß@µg@Ñ™c : �b��² 2pAV� G´s �6N1 ��� ,!�M�� P;�U� �� J�w�� C �Pj\u 1�,@ 1�� �� �� b%��� !(�N� C 7��� ,Ps�yK�� §��3 §�p����
V� �A"� !�\V� 1�qI C �I 2pA �< = O�y�� �/ �� *
�7.1��: � P6A#�� ��<N|6A� .O�8�� �/ EA<V� �/ .��,�� �/ Yp<V� �+�;���)�� �? �À�y_� EA#�� �a�_ lI .�|� .L�� GI !3 ,�,:(��; !M8� �� �,AM8�*
Y6A#�� �p8�� '#F� ��)��s ;/ r�O �� ��d� J�R/��2 � � � �;2�� ��y�e�>���Junk DNA s ,��=�A� P���)�� P����� �� 's���� [yK�� G�e !W< �;2��� >�� P�@� %3 >��a !#���3>�)� �2�; �R��� �� P(��y#�� Gk * + 3
>��� �;2�� �5w� ��s�#� 7�� ���R��� �� G�"A�; ��d8� �� 'A¯ ` �� Gk , 48_� ��d�� 1�j��� J�p{/ ���j� � ��a|� P6A#�� t�p3k� ���;� !#���3� !6� �=�_ �� �>��8� ��~<V� �;/ OI >��� �;2�� G�23 G�<;Ö� >�� � �;/
,�� ©�!3 !"�<� 2�2= EA� � ��a|� �,@ C ±j\��[(�@� >��� �;2�� junk DNA �� ©� C EKp��� EA� 76<�Epigenetics , !�� �L?�
�p8��� EA#�� �p; �s2� ��2�� G/ �� ��8�, �p; �s2� ��)�� + 3 PR��IY6A#�� �p8��*
� 7�5� : G�e �;�_ µ_ ��� 2pAV�s ,��2pAV� �� EA#�� �� �Ma/ �� �K� ` b�� J5)� 1���K� «+�=� C � ���� ��R 2R� ,�+A#�� !_�R �;/ � ���� �\��hǽ¼ :
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
"_ 2"� ¾;��? � 4y_ �� � R��Qin Shi Huang – E�2R Y { 1��q�}�����/ �+A#�� �s23 �,�u�− � 4y_ �s� 2"� ,4�"dV�� �+A#A� ��31�² C ¾;��?
ÅÉÄ ] s� 2"s �;/ ��/ ,���/ E?� `��ÅÉ �À/ EK;I ,���/ E?� `�� [�/EK;I ,¾;��? � 4y_ lI 1��6�N�3 ��8< _ G��"dV� G�~M¨ !
[#c P(+3 ¾;��? � 4y_ �� ]R��_ 2"�*" During a speech to party cadre in 1958, Mao said he
had far outdone Qin Shi Huang in his policy against
intellectuals: "He buried 460 scholars alive; we have
buried forty-six thousand scholars alive ... You
[intellectuals] revile us for being Qin Shi Huangs. You
are wrong. We have surpassed Qin Shi Huang a
hundredfold* Mao Zedong sixiang wan sui! (1969), p. 195.
Referenced in Governing China: From Revolution to
Reform (Second Edition) by Kenneth Lieberthal. W.W.
Norton & Co., 2003. p. 71* 4���N G�e 2"s ,mL? ��6��= C ��2pAV� �� � ��23 �;�_ µ_ ��� �K� `�
PH�1��� �2 � b�A� J1�0Mendelian genetics !�R����+A#�� �� ^dK, ��As�s .��"; Pd�2)� PH�1��� EA� 2(�1 E?�,u/ ���Nikolai
VavilovV� G�e ����86e C� , ��3 ��3 2pAPol Pot ±\u ./ !�"�
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��"d� G�K� G/ Pya >1�W; .2_���! "People who they perceived as intellectuals or even
those who had stereotypical signs of learning, such as
glasses, would also be killed* g1i"
)�@�1�� ,@�1� v0 �7�30 yq*�� ��9 $�<\�#eV�.B��P � 7R��� : �z Y�%NI t�^� Y? P�%K�� 4"A� �:� G´s �R���� C
P"M V� ��%{�_� PA"#�� ����2"�� �,���/ C, °��B ]�� �� �,6N� C 7��� b��� lI ª�#�� EN��3Kalām cosmological argument g�i*
'0 � YV�� t�^� Y,s P6A#�� 4"A� �:� ��/ �8�� � � b�0 G/ 2�kª�#�� 2pAV� !#�� +e G�"Aa E�/ ���23*
��3�s PA<AN �� ��#� �;/ ª�#�� 2pAV� PAKy�–���¨− P�� �� ^"p���� ��<���3 �I �=��� G/ �M�<� %s m��)I v"<_ PA"� t1��e PA<AN�
-G��/ C Í#� 7�� �,A6e�3 ��s�"d� Y(+��2�� m��)I ��* �"M � '�k� �K� ,G�3�� G�"Aa �<N|� G/ P:p3 EA#�� �� � ��0 �/ �
�,66#F� %s P:� �� mL? �<� � �? ¸1 �OI*
i1ghttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khmer_Rouge#Life_under_the_Khmer_Ro
uge.
i2g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kal%C4%81m_cosmological_ argument.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�Le 2pAV�s �P��z� �K� �,s mL? m���� C J�–�8�− � ��2\�<� m��)´34A:;�� �� 4�Z\V� SA��s ,43�w�� 4A:;�� 4"A� ��|? ���Z¨!
�� 7�$� :E?k� �?� !#�� P8<; G´s �2= >^"� P8<; 2#_ ��2pAV� �+A � �P;1�"�3!Ke �+A#�� «�6:6*
J��e Y�shÄÄ !3�; 5(��= �� P N– ��hÇÄh lI�ÄÄÄ− S_�K�� 48�Baruch A. Shalev ^� S;�= lI 4�1�/%�� S;�= lI ��2pAV� P8<; G/
��:�_ � 4 �2�V�hÄ*½ % Atheists, agnostics, and free thinkers comprise 10.5%
of total Nobel Prize winners* �� P8< ��s P�1�/%��� 4 �2�V� ^� P��6� �� ��2pAV� � Ajs �� � ;/ ./
��:�_ %ghi* Y? 4"A� �� !3�; >5(�= �� ��5(�)� �+A#�� P8<; G´s 12jV� Q�; C�
ɽ*Å % V� G���� �"�0 ª�#�� 2pAɽ*Å % ���j� �+A#�� �� % ` �OI ,�+A#�� ��
�� ,K�� ���j� 1�Ksk� C 5p���� ��M���� P(+��2�� P6R mL? �K_?P(+��2�� Y? +s .��)��
��3 G� �|� ��8qk� SA�/ G/ 2:; ���Ku P#��= ���=/ ��a/ PN�1� C�
i1g Source: 100 Years of Nobel Prize, Baruch A. Shalev, p.57.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�a�� b����! ghi* V� Yq�#_ GOI F� 5p�� .���F/ Yq�#_ �? Y6A#�� [AV� �� ª�#�� 2pA v"<
mL?� ��)�� �? �L? ,�� ,e m1�"� .L�� ';�� v���� �I !8"� �� b�A#�� !eP"M V� ��:�; Y?!
� 7�5�� : $�:;�K�� P8�K� C−`�#�� C EW�k� P8�KV� − , ["N G/ 2:; P<(��� P��j�� �A� ]y"F; à ,P3�w�� >1�U)� b2"_ 1��j� lI ^y_ �(���
b�A#��3 ±�¯ �?� �8<�� �(��2�� C >1�eLV� >2���� P;��2�� �? b%N��� P#8M��ISLAM: PHYSICS b2"�3� G�2A3 �+N�3 �(��2�� P"3 ±�� + 3
.�w� �/ Y s �/ ª�/!*
GREECE: PHILOSOPHY ROME: ADMINISTRATION ISLAM: PHYSICS THE MIDDLE AGES: MODERN LANGUAGES ITALY: THE FINE ARTS GERMANY: THE ART OF PAINTING
i1g Doctors Say They're Spiritual.
http://www.cbsnews.com/news/doctors-say-theyre-spiritual
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
SPAIN: DISCOVERY ENGLAND: LITERATURE g1i .
y��� _V# :,@�1� �� �C�\�! J��e P,=�� GI !3Selenographia KA�A�$�A�? Q;�?�� Y
Johannes Hevelius b�� ���/ �L��hÉÅà >1�{ �s%� �� �U� G/ 1�REd&� �3 �<)�, �5�1 2#_ >1�j���� 1�j#�� è ��2)� 78��:��� EA#�� PU, �
7MN���, P8��:��� P6A#�� P"��M�� b�2\�N��Scientific Method �,"y3 7_�c����� �"#��ratione Ed&� �3 �Ad6� �L��gAlhasen i r<¤ �?�
N�37N2 ? E* J�K<A�3 r<¤ �?� ���= �A��= �Ad6� �L�� 7<)�� * E:,��� �� [R��� G/ ª�#�� 2pAV� �#s �8�� �� �� ��M3I P���²�
.��)�� �"<; G�#8�� � E�/ P:p3 b�A� �� G�A60!
i1g http://www.loc.gov/loc/walls/jeff1.html#mrr.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A òîÏŠÈß@pübØ‘g@ @
òçì’ß@ÞbÐ�còçì’ß@ÞbÐ�còçì’ß@ÞbÐ�còçì’ß@ÞbÐ�c@ @@ @@ @@ @
�R��)(J@B� Z :?F��m W� Z�V � (1�! �s�B :الرد
��� �� ��2)� −���qk� m�y_− ^� ��=� �� !��− ���qk���p{k�− ^� PAU#� !?�:�_ 2pAV� �À/ �O+As ,−��p{k� ���qk�− ��/ ��
?!6uk�� E�k�� EK�k�� SA�k� ���N� �V � �pp{ n��)I G�e �� EH4R�#� �� 4?�y� ���q/ ��=� ]8;
#�� �L? �� 3/ �� e �� � ;k �� �M� 7 #� ��#_ ��� ,^a �� � �s �28� �As `� 5 e��� �1�y��1 ,��)�3 m1�"� �� �L?� !A�Richard Dawkins– J� ���
`�#�� C ��2pAV�− 4� ��R :" %3 ��""� C G�K�� � %3 ,P��� %3 ,E6j_^a ��"*
The universe we observe has precisely the properties
we should expect if there is, at bottom no design, no
purpose, no evil and no goodg1i P �/ ^�3 ��8_ ];/ [Ks G���"_ +e P��8� ^� ��6� >�<R ];�e �O´s
?���3
i1g River out of Eden, p.131-132.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
!�� }e/ �? 4?�y� ���q/ ��=� �� r���<_� ���� ^�3 r_��8� GI .��)�� 1�j��� Ps�\N ����=�A�!
GI EH �c��1 ��)�� v"<F� m�y��� ��=�Y#_ ] e �� � ! ,1�M_� �8�� Ps2{ �² `�#�� �L? C G�<;�� ��=� PUR ];�e �As
�è�#� 2��� G�<;I �y � �As Ps2j��3, �� J��K� �� � �1�M_ !R/ �(�e ��2��� E�5;I �� !3 PAa PU� 7��! �3 lI �A6e�3 G�K�� ��B �As ê�� P �k� x�Òk� �� !� �� �L?
��o �� �%Us ±j\�� 2��� E�5;I �� F� �As G�K�� �6� ��1�A� !�}���,M<3/� P)� �� (�K�� 7;�/ C 2=�_ Y��� Pjj\�V� �� _�}��� �+�5;��*
!��? 2��s 2 #�� 2pAV� �3 �Z#� �� �L?�Fred Hoyle G/ 1�"� 4��� ��j)� P{�s lI !j_ P� PAa v<3k �+�5;�� P��6� v"shÄ $/
ÅÄßÄÄÄ ��:�_ � �Ae G�K�� C ��1L�� �2� G/ ��hÄ $/¼Ä* Ps��jV�3 �,W� G/ �K6� ,P)� PA\A� EW V� ���;}�� G/ x�Zs� ��� !3 ��/ �� ���&� �� «�; �;/ �c���� �� ,l�k� x1k� P~8� Y(28�� ��<)� C
��<��K¤ �* the chance of obtaining the required set of enzymes
for even the simplest living cell without panspermia was
one in 1040,000. Since the number of atoms in the
known universe is infinitesimally tiny by comparison
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
1080 g1i .
r��e Q<;��s Y ��%�� ��I !{�_ �� Q�; �L?�Crick Francis C�3��e :" �,�#8q� ���y; �,<�; >�)�Life Itself: Its Origin and
Nature"* �� 1 ��R/ r��e �� JÚ �? Ps2j��3 v<3 Y�@� 2��� 4_��3 >�y; G
§��� ��K� P��p�N��hÄ $/�ÉÄ � !Ke G�K�� ��1O �2� G/ �� ��:�_hÄ $/¼Ä v<3 Y�@� 4_��3 C �L? , *��� _�}�� ��o �3 �� (�K�� 7;�/*
�� C� �%(�R r��e Q<;��s �Z#� P��, :" EA#��3 �A< F�� ,[j � !=�e>5:#� >�)� >�y; G/ ,'M V� �� -�Ì3 1�RF/ G/ �M�N/ ,G�� � � 9��V�"*
"If a particular amino acid sequence was selected by
chance, how rare an event would this be؟ "This is an easy exercise in combinatorials. Suppose
the chain is about two hundred amino acids long; this is,
if anything rather less than the average length of proteins
of all types. Since we have just twenty possibilities at
each place, the number of possibilities is twenty
multiplied by itself some two hundred times. This is
i1g Sir Fredrick Hoyle and Chandra Wickramasinghe, Evolution from Space
(New York: Simon & Schuster, 1984), p. 148.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
conveniently written 20200 and is approximately equal
to 10260, that is, a one followed by 260 zeros * "An honest man, armed with all the knowledge
available to us now, could only state that in some sense,
the origin of life appears at the moment to be almost a
miracle, so many are the conditions which would have
had to have been satisfied to get it going." p. 88 À/ ] e �O´sP,8yA� r��q C r<�; �� � �R��{ 2pAV� �, !8R n��)I « Ý��s
�,��q! m�y���� ��� S8N �� Y �� 1�W � �� r8=F/ Y �� n��)I nZ_ G/ 2#3�*
Y��� ����w�� �#3 �s 2=�_ Y�AK_ .1�8�a� `�� C r;k ��=�� ���s ÁK_ �K� �,8���<_ � EK)� ����� �? �L?� �� lI �,6A� ! ��"� �3 S��MFV�
l�#_ �� :���r� � �q��p� �o� �n��m� �l� �k��j� �i� � � �h� � �g��¤��£¢��¡�����~��}���|��{��z��y��x��w��v��u��ts���¹���� �¸��¶��µ´��³��²��� � � � �±��°��¯��®����¬��«��ª���©¨��§��¦��¥
»��º�ghi* EKpV� 2� ];�s –��p{k� ���qk� − E�k�� !6uk�� �{k� �?�,
�� �3�y�V� 2–4?�yV�− �2= P{�a PM<3 >1�{ C !ÁK_ G/ r � J�AMV�� ,�
ihg P��� ,G��6� �o >1�N :gÃi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
2,©�3 rA� �� ���� +31� PA Fe ]<� r�6K� Gk �� lI �3�y�V� �L? EA�P6K)� �� -�� �� �AM�_� Y����� �+��� 2,©�� .��V� Y6A#�� !���µ
��Ä��Ã�� ÂÁ��À��� �¿�� �¾��½��¼��»��º¹��¸��¶��Å����Ç��Æ�ghi*
�%����� �3��e C �1�K�� ��"� :" �� ��L_/ Y A#· S8N 7;�/ .2� Q���� �� EW�/ >12R Y p 6� ` �� G/ �#8q � �1�; Y 8À ` �;/ �/ ,E, ,S?� �¤ �de/ �
-E,�� P8< ��3 P��,�� ^� ��u/ n� ? !W_ G/ Y#8M�� �6s Y#8M�� ��� ,��2²� ���2² §�A\V� E,��� !W� G/"g�i*
2pAV� �À/ Y R2{ EH ! 4����� 'U3 P(�V� �N C ��6� .L�� 43 §�s � ��?�y� 2��� .L��� ,P=���� * PK3�y�� P��<� C 2��� !��#63 $�"_ � >}#��s
P(�V� �3�� ,Y"_��� �32�� ]R��� 2· m�yV� +3�s ,G�<;��e ��LAV� C �_�� P N 2��� !��#� C �%��#V� ��5�a�� v<8��� �L� ,��e12�� C v"<�� J�AN/
�"M � ��8"� ^�� � �� ��8"� ^��� �L? G�23� 2pA6A� >2���� P:)� � K�� ,P,8u �� E"�<_ �� J�ANFk� *
� ��As �+K�� ��=� �� !�� }e/ �? �ao 1�W � �� m�y��� GI EH ��×6K� !e� ,!A� 7 #� � e1�/ �V �M Á��� C �+K�� 1��"�N� ���� ,m�y��� �×;1�j_ �V
�� C .1�#�%�� .��V� `�#�� �L? lI Y6� _ � E?��� mL?!
ihg P��� ,>�"8�� >1�N :g�ÉÇi
i2g Descartes, R., Meditations and Other Metaohysical Writings, p.49.
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�#� ��#; +e �A{/ C m�y����1�q !Aa �? �X 2���"�� �#3 S_�_ C P =�Z �� − !{/ �� >2��� >2��R +31 1�A�PA� >��; C >2��R− ®��� ,
PWs�)� ���V�� ,!6)� � � !(�N�� P~8�� t�A�e G�<;�� ��Ma/ S8<3 �L? ^R�"#���*
��"#�� O��Nk� ��"� +e P&�� P��2#�� P"")� C �K� :" >�W �� �¥ vB � -P��� lI >2����� -���p3 Pq����� E6#��� �� Â� � �� ,>2��� ->^de !8R
P&�� >��1�� [��_ è �2#�� m�=� J�#�N� *�<�� P#"8�� GI è G�K_ 2R ��� �;�� �,Ae >1�j��� >1�j�� ��� lI [U_ 7��� �/ ,�, � 7 � � 7��� �����/ ��
-t��) 7K8; 2R P8��"�� � _�� è �p;� ,�?^w3 ��� �& '"p�� �� EH � 8:#� +3 v8�w; �/ rpU s ��#; �_��s 2#3 � � m� 8<e*"
���=�� �� G�e �� EH� 1���� ^32_ C P×6K� �� G�K_ G/ �;�×V� +s? ?�;�×p8 FN �3 '×�k� �? �L? Q�/ !3!!
)�8���p� �0 %^�W � ,³JV1� �0 k��!� %��J3� %��?+� (�5� �#P ��#s/ ��/ �� 7N�� �;2<� »� ��#s/ �� P6K Á)� �� Ë�= 2R� 2#F_
���?�@ 7N�� PjR� ,EW� - a �� [ �K_ �, K� ,P��<�<� ^�� >�K F� � ��8a��� �32��� J�3 �� �K� ���K)�� �f�� J�3 �� Go�"�� C ��_ ` »��
!:#�FV� �,6K�� P��8�� Q� �� 1�j"3 1��R���* �0 G/ 2pAV �· ���Ì3 P&�� P6K Á)� J�3 C Ë�; 2pAV� Gk Q� �P?�23
-P��<V P��6u >�W; YM#�� 1�"F� 7�� -2� C �� ��#� �� ,EA#�� ¿ Fe `�,8���<�*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
}�G3��� �9s: �8; G/� ,��� �~3 �� J�"��3 QA· G�e !(�º� Y 3 ��8;/ ��J�� $1�s ��:s, EH ]��A� `� m��"; PWs�� ]M"N �~8�� �� ¦1�a �?�
�,�I , Á�� E � Y��1 ��:s ��= EH ,�8= C �,#c�s ��" �� PWs�� 2=�s ��V� ��~8�� �� J�� ^8e �¶u, $1���� ��#s �N��;/ v"�A� �~8�� Ps�� �� QA= EH
m2· EAs ���� �� ��d��3, �A�"s ^8K�� ¶y�� �s E��s* Y8 �� ��"s : ��V� La/ .L�� +;I� ,��V� La�� `� !=��� ' � ]3 Á FÚ J1��
Y����� * Æs Æ: Ý!– Á,@�s �– P6K)� � ! s Y����� 2��� �� ��V� �L? La/ $1���� 2��� G/ ��I �� 7���s�� ��V� ��
� � ]jj�R�s $1���� 2��� !�R ¶y�� �L? GI� ,t1���� lI! ò•ý¨aZ 1�j"3 z�×R P6K Á)� �,s 7�� Y��� 1��k� �� 2pAV� EK F�
1�j"3� ,�×,<�; P��8�� P#8M��Pe�1��� �×��W;* ��s C �"� �� P��8�� Q� �� ��� Q� ,¿ FK�� EKF)�� ,��6y�� J�×#�N
P6K Á)� J�3 C t2p�� G/ 2pA6A� '0 %s �����3� ,>z�"�� �×�12R §�M;�Ì3 P&��* K����»��º���¹����� ��¶��µ ��³��²���±��°�� ��®����¬��«��ª»��º���¹����� ��¶��µ ��³��²���±��°�� ��®����¬��«��ª»��º���¹����� ��¶��µ ��³��²���±��°�� ��®����¬��«��ª»��º���¹����� ��¶��µ ��³��²���±��°�� ��®����¬��«��ªLMNOP
ihg P��� ,G��6� �o >1�N :g i
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
‰bÐØÛa@æc@†zܽa@ïdží@áîÔÛbi@åßûmë@õaŠÔÐÛa@†Çb�m@ïÛìu@bäîܬcë@Lpa�¨a@æìÜÈÐíN@ @
:الرد
��= � A:;/ G/ ��� ,�����2�� mL& � � de G�=��� ��)�� P<�+u �P��z �� YK���k� �6�:V� C ��)�� �� ��2)�� ,�%{/ �?��)´3 b5= 2=�� �
G�dwA� ��2�� P��wA� �8"�<�� ¦�:¤− � � �1��; �L��m��)I �� ±\u �A#F� �* §%ak� P6R �� 2e|_ ,PR%ak� ��= � A:;/ ��s��s r�O ���
-Y��3 ���" �#� �6©� G/� �,�"AM�� �s1 C ��^ F ��<� �8��s ,Y�� ^w3�Y&�� [AK���*
]<� §%ak� mL? G/ �� ,�?� #63 G� �|�� �6©� �," �#� §%ak�sPp31 Y? !3 '��N 2e�_ �L? C� ,>��V� 2c� Pj\y�� PpAjV� 2c �+(�� ®�_
P���� ��6�� 1�qI C �AAB �/ ,.��V� ¦O�6 A� G�<;�� �1 P��p�N� ��* GI !3 �� �_�; >�"�� C G�<;�� 1�jR� � E"��s ,Y6"�� YR%ak� ���5��
K��� 7 #� ���q C !6B Y,s ,`�#�� �L? �� �& 7 #�Y&�� [A* Y&�� [AK��� r�O �s�� G/ �M�<� � 2pAV� 7�ps �L��!
P6"�� P"AM� � �"8<� xZ�� 2pAV� GI EH, �P��1 9�M�� � ���K�/ YM#F� �L�� �Aa�� .�M��� Y���� �L? �� � ��� 3 92�6�� 2"� �� �M�� J��j�� 1�"��
�2A� }ek�� l�k� P:)� �L? C� ,P6"�� P"AM63�* ��+�/ G�K_ G/ ��I P�^� �?^�� ��= � A:;/ � �,���N� �%#s P6W�
��)� 7 #�; P6Ae Gk"^�" �� �?� #� 26�<_ � E"��� P"�5s��� P6Ae
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�,A{/ C >��V� 2c Y? !3 `�#�� �L?* �+�/ G�K_ G/ ��I� ��= � A:;/ �,�2V ��� � �,���N� 7 #� %3 P�^�*
ya�� Z�R� (^ �?1 :? �`� �G@u0 y5��� ]��� Z��! ½�j ��*@A�� y�
2����� �3��e C �� �W�� ��2;5�� 5�5#�� 28� ¶y�� ��"�: Û � ��L�� GI G�2��� � E?� E&+�/ G�A6#� �3�"� G�s�¯ �� ,�3��H G�=�� �� ��3 G� �|�
�w�8� �� ,�� �=� �¥6� !? E,6À �� m�c1 G ��%� ��A � ����� b/, � �L¥ E,s G�"p�<���)�{ G�e GI� !6#�� �� J��d��; ���� � G/ �3 ��2j"� ` 1��e E�k
E,"��a �c1 �3 ��w�3� �� ,E¥1 J��HÜMNO* ��%c� m��e �� SR�# F� �s�K��� ���0 `� �� ��� �� �p8� ` �;k ;
�� �3 ��= .L�� Y&�� G�8�� lI «+�N �6N �OI �,s r�O �� �>��� ,G�AN�V� ������ �A6#s r�L� ,� ��5? �?L�� �A� ��F_ �� ���o �SR�#� �?� m��e ��
�j��i���h��g��f��e��d������c��b�MYO*
���ÃÂ����Á��À��¿��¾��½���������¼��»���º¹�����������¸��¶��µÎ���Í��Ì��Ë��ÊÉ��È��Ç��Æ���Å�����Ä�M�O*
�� � �h��g��f��q��p����o��n��m��l��k����� � �j��� � � � � �i
ihg  ,��2;5�� 2:V� 28� ¶yA� ,2�����Ç*
i�g P��� ,G�R���� >1�N :g� i*
i g P��� ,E?��3I >1�N :gh¼i*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�|��{��z��yx��w��v��u��t���s��r�MNO* ��"� OI �%� ���d� ��2;5�� 1��e2�� J»��: Û �!=1 !a� -G��<3 lI � ^8e
�!=1 G��<8�� !a� + 3 ,G��<8�� !a�� �8#�� �,A� !@� J�� !e�s �KA6� La/� � � J� � � � �/ G��<8�� S��j3 !j_/ 7�� ��~u !#s/ � ��"s �ao
� lI !j� G��<8�� S��{ J�2 63 �O´s ,�p8�� ��<� ¶3�� ,4A=���� b2�� >��8�%�� �# { ��d�� !=�A� �Ku� ,��k� !=��� ��28� .L�� G� ��
�� 7�� �L? !,s �d8�� m1��,�N� �� ��k� !=��� !@� ,�dp3� C �<�/ ��8� �� �? �_L�� �? ��pAjV �I r�O !#�� ` �;I ?�s�KF� G/ �W� � G��<8��
')� S��j3–G��<8�� S��{−��~u*
�rA� �,s ��� x1k� mL? r�Le� �? ��|V�� ,G�3�2 V� E? �� !N1� �����u1I %3 ���� .L�� �? �s�K��� ,!N��� !8N �8�� .L��Ü*
<� PU"�� GI !?� ^� !#�_ �V Y? 2e�� PU"�� +;I� ^� !#s ]��R��_� �A#�_, b/ ,�;2�� C �6<_ �/ >��#N 2�56e Pj\y�� r�pAjV �A#�_�
?�����8#3 � �c1� � � �1�<K;� @ @@ @@ @@ @@
ihg P��� ,1� �� >1�N :g Çi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
òîÛb�ŠÛa@òv§a@ @ÝçÝçÝçÝç@@@@òqa‰ìÛbi@åí†Ûaòqa‰ìÛbi@åí†Ûaòqa‰ìÛbi@åí†Ûaòqa‰ìÛbi@åí†Ûa@_@_@_@_@ @@ @@ @@ @
::::الردالردالردالرد
7"8� �� ,�Aa�� C PH�1�� Pppj�� P3�=�� �#�� 2��� !K�� �#R�_ �I�?!
Y��� P��k� PA"#�� ��À28��� rs ]N� F� Y��� >�M��� Y? P3�=�� mL?� �� ];�s r� 48�� ` ��� ,r� 48_ 7�� ')�3 b5�A�N �?�U�"� �� �º ��
JL#F_���¶��µ��´��³��²±���°��¯��®��¬��«ª��©��¨��§��¦�¿�����¾��½��¼��������»��º��¹¸�MNO*
P:)� rA� b�"F_ 7�� JL#F_ �� r;/ r� 1 �2R ,1� ��� P ©� rA6� .L�� GOI ? P��N���
� 2�/ EAW� ��� r6AW� �� 1� ��� P ©� 'Aa� r"Aa .L�� � �U�/��á��àì��ë��ê��é��èç��æ��å��äã���â�MYO*
_…ŠànÛa@áčÜÏAA@@ @
�H�1� /28� .L�� �? ��2�� GI EH<�K� G+���s ,G+��� Q�� � Q�� S !e C� �3 �� [R�� !e C� PW) !e C P�1�8�a� PA��63 �6� r;+�I� ,YH�1�
ihg P��� ,��º�� >1�N :gh½i*
i�g P��� ,]Ajs >1�N :gÅÉi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
C 2� !?� ,r_2"�� r �� ��{/ �A� Q"_� m��_ �� �%��K�� �%AB r ��m��_ �V?!! .1�{ b/ .�?�= �R� _ P6H !?�?!! b��� �8"F_ lI �LK?�
� r::� 43� r 3 �� !j�� P��"����H� �G� �F��E��D��C� �B�P���O��N��M��L��K���J��I�MNO*
��À28��� >�M��� ê�"V «�8_�� Y8<e !6� Y? P;+��� PU"�� !{/� 2R Y8 �� �3�� ,Y8; G�K� 2R �s�K�� �3� G´s �I� ,rs �� �,N�� Y��� P��k�
1�8�a� �? P��"�� b�� n1�8�a� !{/ r�O !e §�s� ,'A� ��e/ G�K� �(�fA�� $� A� �28� �V Q�����j������i��h�MYO*
s ,n��K� � �1}� n^� ��e �� !#� % �%�� �6A#3 vB ` �¤ !#� �� �� EA#��!
�Ps�#� ]<� �Ì��3 r�s�#� b2�� � ��� Fe �,A� Y 8_ ! ���Æ��ÅÄ��Ã��Â��������������Á���À��¿¾��½��¼��»��º��¹��¸������¶��µ
��������������������M�O* ,P "� P=123 PA";� P��Ms� P;�2=�� Ps�#�� PA"� P6A< F� P �2�� PU"��
�Zs� �� !#� %s �%�23 r @ ��� ,4"A� �%�23 rc �de/ +s ,PÀ28A�
ihg P��� ,!p �� >1�N :ghhhi*
i�g P��� ,§1�M�� >1�N :gÃi*
i g P��� ,Q;�� >1�N :g Çi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
,G� W��� ��c�Zs�� 2���� G�My�� §�N �,s G�My�� � �5� '��q �L,s����1 Sj � �A�� ,����U3 b��ÁR�!
�K;/ 2�/ P ©� !a2� ��� ,P��N1 P:� �A� E"_ ` 2�/ 1� �� !a2� ����;��V� ����;�� T���� ����N� 2#3 P��N��� P:)�*
P��8�� �6� �� ��q/ �?� ,}ek� !j��� b�� �? P��"�� b��� �?� ,�Ae 1}� � n^� ��e� ,r<� 3 �I !wy _ %s ,>Z��� !?k Y�AK��� �A8�� �N
��R OI m��e C G���s P:� mL,s �I� ,n��e :��î������í��ì��ë��ê�MNO* _´�bî’Ûa@áuŠÛ@oÔÜŽ�@kè’Ûa@Ýç@ @
òÐÜn‚½a@æìØÛa@ÊbÔi@¿@†uìm@kè’ÛaL@_ÁÔÏ@´�bî’Ûa@áuŠÛ@ïç@ÝèÏ@ @
::::الردالردالردالرد
Go�"�� !"� `/ Pjj¨ S,y�� G v"s 2=�_ �O�V ��"; 7�� 4q�y�� E=�� C/ �e��/��a?!!
� �U�/�� ���5��� �+A<� 2�/P�2{� J�8N/ ��"_ � >�?�W�� G/ ,b���P#8M�� �+A#� Y(�Z_ Y��� J�8Nk� PA� �� �,��R�*
G�^q G/ b�� !e P�2��:��� ��c����� �+A� �;} F �/ ��,N §�s Pu��s�K���/ C 1�j�I «�R� lI PU�FV� J�8Nk� �� G�K� 2R ��}N ��#F� +s ,
Pu����� ^H��3Butterfly Effect *
ihg P��� ,�q >1�N :g½hi*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�2"#_ 2u/ ��K�� J�8Nk� b�W;�� "�}��� 2{��� �� Y− Y8��:���− �2"#_ 2u/ ��U�/�� b�"� Y8��:��� EA#�� $�N/� ,PÝM� ��c����� 2{1 ��
!{/ �L?� ��+���� >�(�� 'U�� ��c���� !A"_� ,1�j��� !,<_ ��Y8��:��� EA#��*
s PA6#�� rA_ � � � x1Ô� J�,y�� §�Za� PA6� Ps�#� � � % .L�� G� KV� l�#_ �� S� �� �Ae �L?� G�Mu E=1 J�pj�N� �� mZN
�8��*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
òîèÔÏ@pübØ‘g@ @čÔÛa@†î�@Ýrß@ïãbàÜÇ@Éß@aƉaìy@á�¤@Ñîמàčä_ï@ @
���@� �� ��1���� ����"� !e �+A#�� 4�UR ��� 1�2_ Y 6"�� 2N^� � 4� H�:
/;� ��� ��6 P� !)�� E#� 7�� �+A#��� b%<�����a :القضية األولىG�<;�� §�"��!
¶9� �� FJ*z# l`��]��1� ��*��@�1� �± ���� _�1� �a�zV1� �;��<�8s , P��}� P6W;�3 1�2F_ P"��s/ ��� �,Ae ��w <��� $�y�1��� �8��=� �8��;� �� ��2�� mL? r�O ��� ,4 <�� ���� L � � ���� Pq��R�6�� P�+N/1 P;+A�
G�<;�� §�") � �e�,�;� �?�de/� §%q�� �� `�#�� ��� �"s/! ,1��2�� �,�A6�� ,> ���8� YK���k� 1��N2��3 !6#_ ,P"��sk� ��}� P���� P;+A� Y?� ,G��5�� �� G�R [j; �� �de/ L � J��; QA�� Î�u QA� �¥�
}� �2= G���}� �,A?/� ,P"�� P�� � − G�8� G�Ae��� G��<�1�y�� G�jR��YK��; P�L�/ G�2_��� QAKy_− P��� r�O ��� `�#�� ��� �"s�e P� j F� ��}�
§%q�� ��* J%M�� �6:s ,2��� S��q ��}� C P#��©�3 'p�A� ` ¸�V� b�#�� C�
��Ays �� d�N� %3! MNO*
i1g http://today.almasryalyoum.com/article2.aspx?ArticleID=394860.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P;+A� P��� 43 ��= ���#�� G�"�� C �}K�� J��)� �� GI EH�3/ G��A��� P;�d��� l�k� G��V�#�� G�3�)�� ,P;+A� �_�½ % `�#�� G�KN ��
��2��3 P��� J��� ��;�e ��1��� lI G�R �AH �� V�� b�5,V� �_���/�P;+A#��*
P�� �� !d� ���#�� G�"�� C ��,@ Y��� P���=�� ��=����2�k� ��� ,4j�� C P���V�� Y�s�<�� ��B�� C P ���<��� ���M�I C Pu����� �;�V/ C
�,Ae P;+A� ��� C ]����_� ��y; P;+A� ��=����2�/* .� �� J5)�� �;�V/ C ,>2u1 P;+A� Pq��R�6�� P"��M3 EK)� lI !{�
P;%"� Pq��R�6�� P"��M3 ]� J5)� �¥ b�R Y��� >��3�� ��1��R !e�* §�M3 �¥�\�;� E_ ����K� �3 ]��R ª�w�� ���}��� «��V�� P;+A�
�+A#�� 2�����3 7WB ];�e >��3��� >�\<�� ��A6�� ,P6AN* C �& QAs Y 6"�� 2N ��d�/ G�;+A#�� �¥ rp6�� Y��� G�<;�� §�"� ��/ �8�� G/ r��"s ,P�p3 P"�5s��� PUR G�<;�� §�"ps ,Sj; �+A#�� t1��
�R�A¨ G�<;�� G�e �OI v"s �K¤ �L? G���<�� Y? �8�� 43 >���<V�s ,� � 1�W V�3 $� ��s ,PA"� �/ P���� �/ P#8q P""� ]<�� PR%a/ P{�ja v"s ��2�� �� � �<N�_� ,����<�� ^� ru %3� E? ¿"#�� �/ Y#8M�� �/ .��V�
>���<V�3 P8��MV� ��M<8��� ���#U�� �M�<� * ��R%#�� �+A#�� .��V� 1�W V� Y�s P ��1�2�� P����� �?��<_ �8�� 43
�A{� ��"8���Survival for the Fittest Y#8M�� J�\�;��� ,Natural Selection *
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
$�"V � �"8q E,� j_� �8�� E<"_ E�� .��V� 1�q�� C� P6:6©� E:�Skull Measurement ,P3�w�� P;+A#�� E& ]<N/ .L�� b�,�V� �?�
r�6:� E:ps ��"8�� C r"� �����3� r< = ���<�� P=1� �20* E, �� �8�� �� PA��e $� =/ ��Mc� ª�w�� �+A#�� .��V� `�#�� !a���
��;��)� ��R/ C ��a2�� lI G���V�Human Zoo ��"A� E?1�8���37;�/MNO*
�� ��#� � ±\u �? �+A� 1�W 63 G�<;�� §�"� �� t2p�� .L��s� �����O P;+A#�� 7 #��� �K��� �� ¶�1���!
G��� Y��� P3�w�� ¦O+ �� �#3 G�»p�<� �+(�� Y 6"�� ��d�/ G/ PAKyV� �+(�� PR�� ��1�{ G/ –�<;�s� ��w_}��� �;�8N/� �2 ��? !d�− G/ 23� � �#8q� ,
P:�; ���= �����H Gk �+(�� PR�� G�K_½ÄÄ � ,1+#�N�� �� b��½Ä b����2�� 2" �� §�2 { ��*
@ @
i1g http:// query .nytimes .com /gst /abstract .html? res= 9C04E7 D81F 3EE733
A25753C1A96F9C946797D6CF.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
@��Ûa@��Ûa@��Ûa@��Ûa–ÖŠÛaÖŠÛaÖŠÛaÖŠÛa@M@M@M@Mòí…ìjÈÛaòí…ìjÈÛaòí…ìjÈÛaòí…ìjÈÛa@ @@ @@ @@ @�� ��e C �d�2� rA�� P���8#! �"��- :القضية الثانية عند سيد القمني ��
�����3� ,G�K� �& 2#� `� ��2)� �#�� �?��� ���U"�� mL? G/ [e� 46��v"s Y¯1�_ 2#3 �& E��K�� Go�"�� ���o �#3*
$�@1� �� �L?!,©� !AB �� 23� §��� PUR �_�O ¶�1���� !a�� �� �����e: 7p�� : ��U�"� ��� ,.�8�� Q ©� ¶�1�_ C PN�N/ PA��� Y? P���8#��
PA{/ P��3 1�j�* �7*��� : �I ,PR�Ás �� ��8?L� �� P�<As �� P;��� P��8�� ¶�1�_ C 2=�� �
P���=� PÀ23 �_}���� §��� ��=/�* �7.1�� : �(�KV� 1�,W� v"s G�e ¸�V� G�"�� C §��� ����a�– Y��� ����
�8�� !² ]A�– G�<;�� 2= F� �� � ���=�� !WN� G�e §���s �I�* � 7�5� : �� Y�<As �� Y6A� �� .��� �� YR%a/ �� Y �� �;�� 2=�� �
§ Á��� PN1�¤ �� � 6� .��)I Y�%N�� ���,�63–? .L�� J�R/ �Y 8�A�− !AR 2#3 48 N +e*
� 7R��� : �>�:s §��� [R��� ` ��Nk� $�<�I Ps�?�� �/ 28#�� �:U�, C ��,@ Y��� �(�KV�3 28#�� �� ��8� �� w�N� P:�; v"s �K��
¸�V� G�"��* � 7�$�� : ��= P���8#�� ��,�;�� v� ��q �� P���8#A� � �2R�; ¶�1���� ��#� `
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
v"s e -P:� E,�I P=�)� b2#� -PÀ23, �L����R �y�;: " ��M�/ ���%W� 28#�� r<�k P��� �+<��"*
§��� b�,�� G/ �� ��"8q/ �,Ae �;2�� P�N%s� �A{/ C �b�,�� ��8"� PAd�k� �#3 �eL N�:
h − 1/ G�e ëY Á? Æ2Æ3 ��/ P���8#�� G/ ��� �MN, �& ��2�|V� 2u/ �� G�e��,A� 4j��)��
� − �MN1/ ��R : ���<� 2 � �U�/ �? G�;�"A� �U¯ .L�� �� �� �P���8#��*
− 28#�� �� �A� � PAc���� G�q%s/ P�1�,�* Å − m2N P�2a C ��#�� '"0 28#�� G/ ���� >2y3 P���8#�� !:? 2�|�* ½ − �=� � 28� G�23 Qe1�� �1�e ��"�P�+y�� �K���k �MNO*
� 7�5�� :PN�Nk� >5��w�� G/ !:? ��� !; C P8���� Y? G�<;�� C����Z�−��6R �� �− �� ,� ���� ����� '"0 28#��s 1�q�� �L? C� ,
C P8���� lI 7#<� r�O C �?� m2N P�2a C ��#�� '"0 28#�� G/ �23/ m2N �� ��6�� � 28#��� ,��Z��� �;/ ��#� � �%{/ �;k �
§�s �_�8�1� m2N ����/ �� �,""0 P���V� �_�8�1 �,s ,�� �j" � G�e +Ae� !3 ,�A6� C ����}3 �,""0 ��Z��� C P8���� !d� P���V�
i1g http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/410.htm.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�;/ �#y� � 28#��s �L� ,P8���� mL& � �""B �de/ G�e m2<� � �{%aI �de/�%"� 1�qI C n�p�� !3 ,28� ��6�� ` �L� ,m2N S���<�� �8���<�
28#��* �§�<� P��, ��� P��28�� C 28#��s � � J�AMV� 1�2�� lI − � ���� 2<��e − *
�7���� : ��"� P;2V� P��2�� QN|�n�� G�= :" P6�2"�� �K���/ C n�AV� -x�1/ G�KA6� ��;�e ��L��� ����� �"s/ E? P#N�u !��� �� �I .5A:;
CZ<y;�� Ñ1�"* PR%� � P8<; P6R >��#<��s ,�_��#N ���5�s �3 �Z#� �� ��2� rAV� �K�
P���V� P���V� !(�N���3 �&!; �? P���V� >��#<�� �2? +;I� , �L?� ��Z��� ����� 28#A� '"p��� !
� 7���! : -PW) C 28#�� ��#N 28#A� ¦��p; ��2 � ��, {�a �P 2#3 �;/�Za� PW) ./ C �;/ P�+��� >�Ks YV�#�� J�k� C ��,@ P��� �� PpANk� «�
Á©�� !\A� ��#;� Pd�2)� �=��� K��� !e `�#�� f¯ G/ �K6��� �+ �> ,��a/ '��M�� J1�² EAs C�the road warrior ,�A� ¦1�= ��ZN�� �� 6A�
��3�#��� !� �� P6(�R PA8"�<� >1�U� ��;��;��)� �?�� Y���MNO* � 7«�0 : ,G�� P�@��� >�)�� !6#�� P��W � 2"� N �+�� �? P���8#�� 2"� � .L��
� _� F*V*§�1� �*<�# _a�j £–F*a�j F�$�30 −, Y6N��� �,���#_ C� : �/ Pe� �/ P<N|� ���j� [@�V� ]R� �� P #� ����N «�M"�N�
ihg 12jV� :¶�1���� P��×�,  ,�����e�s Q<;��s¼É*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
-±\u ,�� ->�2² -P#� � �/ �2² �=/ ¸�"_ !3�"�* z�#V� G�<;�� �K� P��<� ¾<�<� �� G�� P�@��� P��W V� ¾<�<� >z�#V� S8<3 v"s §���– P��<� z�#� `� P�@��� P��W 6A� z�#� �,s
§��� −* GI !3 � p _��� £�# �� F*V*§�1� F��q�B�� £�1� e5 ;���D� £�V1�,_u*
Á1 Y? P�@��� P��W V�s ��FV� r�O �� '��� +e P(5= >�\N� ,Y�R� §G�� ! Q� §��� � �U�/G�;��#�� �& ¦ Ý���� �,6N�� Y��� >1�j��3 , +31 +;I�
C .�· G�e �� �� >1�j�� rA_ '8M _ ,P;������ P��2�� �;�%3 C + 3 G�e��2�� �+A�� �;2�� P6(/ 'R���* ���� -2?�u ^a r�+V� P G��5�� }� *
�s��w©� }�� ¶�1���� }� �Y Á? Æ2Æ3 ��/ §��� GOI, 'R��� §�"� �� Ø��)��>�1���� C �#�� ���{��� �� >��#�� P{��� �?* â P d��� ��N½−�h £*
P{� �? 28#�� !8R � Á� E,���q J�=�� ��Nk� §�"� �� Ø��)��!:;��* âlI P��N��� Q<s/ É:½£
Y8 �� �K� `� ,G���k� �� � ��2Á3 b%N�� �K� `�−EAN� �A� �� �{− á2Á3 �>��8� P{��� ���= 2"s !N��� �� � �� b%N�� C 'R��� §�"� °�p3*
âý�⁄a@¿@ÕîÓŠÛa@ÖìÔy@ÅÐyZ@ @
h − l�#_ �� ��R: ���p��o���n��ml��k��j��i��h��g��y��x��w��v��u� � �t� �s��r��q��¨��§���¦��¥��¤� �£� �¢� � ¡���~��}��|��{�� � � �z
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
© �MNO* � − l�#_ ��R�: ���d��c��ba��`����_��~��}��|��{
����o� �n� �m� �l� �k� � ji� � � h� �g� � fep �MYO*
�¾G@�� �s�5 �¾GJ?�� �� %��� �� ����� �� $�� � |� %��J3� ���# �¾G*t�� ��� 7C��9 �¾��G�!
− EAN� �A� �� �{ �� ��N1 ��R :Û,9(+� �1��� p: _���� ;(30y�*1�: ���#� ;��#ÜM�O* Å − EAN� �A� �� �{ ��R� :Û 2¸ �� ,G@�j ,?1�� ,?����6 ¹�6
p� ,o3@� �¹¿ %R3@*1� y9�� �¹¿ %u�t*@# l(� 2¸ l��� ��9 �u# ,,?�(�� ,��V@?!,���*0�# ,G3@~� �� ,��u�V@9 ��# ,G3@~� ��ÜM&O *
��Zs ]p8{/� ,� ���×K F�� � �e�A� P�%N�� P��2�� C 'R��� 1�{ �L��'R��� �� � ��K Á� C PA��e P¯1�_MÀO*
ihg P��� ,��< �� >1�N :g Éi*
i�g P��� ,��< �� >1�N :g�½i*
i g EA<� �p{*
iÅg �A� '���*
i½g �� C r�+V� P���*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
b%N�� �� 'R��� �� � �{�� 2u/ ��× �� P;�<;�� ¶�1�_ ��#� ��, Y�K�?�=/ G�_|� PH%H n� ? G/ EA#_ G/P��"�� b�� 4_�� E �� ��2)� ±; C +e
EAN� �A� �� �{ �� ��N1: N − ��¬� ]��?1�� Z��� ]��?1�5 ��i yj ,h ��Á# _�9$� ,� Y − �Gj��!� �G��0�# F�� %1 2��9 yj� � − %*1��� ¡+� �� ¡+ ¥$� (30�MNO*
��5_� ���1�= '��/ �� !=��� GOI4_�� m�=/ �� �,=* 28#���4_�� m�=/ �� m2N �M� .L��*
�A� '��FV� ��2)� C � � �� ¸1 >���? �3/ ��R �L��: Û h� oV� ;`1�� ���� S��� �� 233+� _�� �5� <�� �� y*3� c $�GD� p�1 l(*5 ����
��@¿Ü* ما مصدر الرقيق : ا وهوا هامAنا قد يطرح العلماني تساؤللكن ه
إلى عبد؟وكيف يتحول الحر
ولماذا يتحول األحرار إلى عبيد؟ولماذا يتحول األحرار إلى عبيد؟ولماذا يتحول األحرار إلى عبيد؟ولماذا يتحول األحرار إلى عبيد؟
��#� ���PÒ1 !{�� C �? §��� G/ 4;+A#�� �� ^dK! Á_�"V� �s�K��s ,���"�� P��N� Pe�#V� x1/ C �p � §���s ,!�" F� !
rA� �/ Y8<�� �/ §��� J�3 C �8j_ �����3� !�"F_ �� 78<F_ PA_�"V� >�s�K���
ihg �A� '���*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
46�����%M{��,Ae� 7 #V� Q�; �&* لكن لماذا نقوم باستراقاق النساء؟لكن لماذا نقوم باستراقاق النساء؟لكن لماذا نقوم باستراقاق النساء؟لكن لماذا نقوم باستراقاق النساء؟
�A_�"_ G/ 23� r31�0� rA_�"� ��= .L�� Gk ,PÒ��� J�3 �� � AR +e �L? ,�(����� ^_�N2�� �� �,A� '��_ PÀ23 mL?!
�= Y��� >/�V� ��/� ��rA�R ���3 �� �I �,A_�"_ G/ r� �· %s rA_�"�! !�"F_ � >/�V�s; Î�y�� �� ���qk� �� ��< �� !�R r� 5 F· � b%N�� Gk
PN1+V +;I� 46A<V� P31�pV Pe�#V� P��N lI ��_�� ` ��L�� ��)� J�p{/ ��Pe�#V� P��N C E�/ ��� 1��e E�/ �� E,s��!
/ >/�V�3 b%N�� PÒ1 �6s �� !�"F_ �−46A<V� !�R ��8_ �� P�#c ��k S��w�� C− 78<F_ !3*
78<F_ >/�V�� �����I� �, � ��#�� �/ 46A<V� ��^N�3 �,(�2s E�� 7�� �2#A�!3�"� %3�e����d��c��b��a��`��_��~��}�ghi *
l�#_ ���R °��� :������ ]�<� Tz! ��+ , ,Pe�#V� x1/ C Y #� � � ��I °���2#3 �� :3 �,��º 'AMF_ G�3 �,A� �F� ./��2s ��I� ,!3�"� % : ./
�2#�� �?º/ ®%�� �+A<V�3 �À2�_* F��� (0�^ l`�� ,F9��B� ©� �� p6 _3� �C�\� c (j�� C#!
��B� �3RW! p��j �º� T� ,�G@�^ ��H %�� p6) S$��� �(�1� d*j c S
ghi P��� ,26² >1�N :gÅi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��#�4 Z�8����! ��A" � `� �?�KA�� �;2�� �%3 G�6A<V� ��s 2R� lI ���8N 4A{k� ���KN
4;2V� ��3 lI Pe�#V� P��N ��A" � `� !3 ,!R�� ���"� � �L,s P3�#�� >��5©�b%N�� [ e C �I E,����� E?5� ��2· ` 4;2V� ��|? GI !3 ,4 ���!
�,A�R �· �� >/�V� 78<F_�; ��k � AR +e C r�O ��8_ %s ]A_�R �� 7�����,<� 3 S��w, r�O ��8�� 46A<V� !�R 2��� .L�� �s�K�� �� G�?/ �,�3�"#s
EAN� �A� �� �{ ��� ��N1 ��R r�O !��� ,�<� 3 :"!_�"�� mL? ];�e ��"* ؟؟؟؟لكن هل يجوز نكاح المسبيةلكن هل يجوز نكاح المسبيةلكن هل يجوز نكاح المسبيةلكن هل يجوز نكاح المسبية
®�?� (�0 �± Fj��1� �9 ,�G+�?� ��� ;� ,®�?� (�0 �± F*3RB� �K� ,8<V� 9�K; 2"� T�� �& P=�5��s ,P=�5�� 9�K; 2"� T�� �� [A�� P
�& b2"�� �6s 1��a�� T�* PA_�"� >/��� ��/��=� �2#�� Í= �� rA_�"�� ��,8N E_, mL,s �& Q�
T� �& b2"�� �� 1��a�* P��#�� �qFk� C G�"��� P8<V�� P=�5�� �K�, -!=1 lI P=�5�� !"� _ %s �ao
-§%M3 �I -�,�� 2�2= ,�� -!=1 lI P8<V� !"� _ �� -§%q´3 �I �ao -2"�� 2�2=*
�,8j��� �As ,P=�5A� x�#��� '3�M� P#���� EK� C P8<6A� x�#�����;5�� 2� �A� b�"F� 2�/*
Y#s�y�� ��R :Û ÆP Æ� Á1�Æ á©� F! F= Ë��� ÆS ÆjÆ� á�� � ÆOÁI Æ�, ÁS áj Æwá�� Æ2 á# Æ3 � Æ,Æ~Áq Æ� ËEFH, Æ� F? Æ�
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
á� Á� F� á" F# á�� Æ� FP Æ� Á1�Æ á©� F�á Á� á� ÆL ÁaF/ ÁP Æ�� Æ,Æ á©� Á! á?Æ/ Á á Æ�, �Æ; Ý5�� ã2 Æ� Á�á ÆA Æ� ÆEÁRF/ Æ�Üghi* هل يجوز سبي نساء الكفار المقاتلين اآلن؟هل يجوز سبي نساء الكفار المقاتلين اآلن؟هل يجوز سبي نساء الكفار المقاتلين اآلن؟هل يجوز سبي نساء الكفار المقاتلين اآلن؟وووو
G��s�K��� G�6A<V� �3 b5���� ��< �� Y8N P��p3 G�;�R �c� E_ �� − +eG�� t��� �?− EA<6A� �· � � ,s , �2#�� /23 �� �I ,��,#��� 4;��"�� P���¨
P���\V� C Eu�w��! G�� J��)� è 78<�� � � 7��� 'H��V�� ��,#�� !e bZ FB �A�� * 2R�
�p8� ]B PM" �� mL? � A �js"?��� �? b%N�� !?" * �+A<V� G�8j�w� J��� G���:V� G�e P N�8�� J�� >Zs C�
�O ��� ,�� N�8�� Y8N ]R��� r�O C ��2?�:6A� 46A<V� �+A� 5 F· ` r�2#�� ��<;*
EH �PÒ1 E_2=� !? %s ,�? ��%<3 n�2� PA_�"� C b5�A_ G/ �� EW�/ -9%<3 �A�"_ G/ r� �· ��8#��� 1��2�� rAÀ n��s, ��%N Q� 3 �A_�"_ +;I�
����m��l��k��j��i��h��gf��e��d��c��b����a��`��_��~�n�g�i*
EA�/ ���! هل يحق للملحد أن ينتقد مسألة الرق؟هل يحق للملحد أن ينتقد مسألة الرق؟هل يحق للملحد أن ينتقد مسألة الرق؟هل يحق للملحد أن ينتقد مسألة الرق؟: : : : لكن يبقى السؤاللكن يبقى السؤاللكن يبقى السؤاللكن يبقى السؤال
ghi  ,Sjw�� J�3 ,Y#s�yA� ,bk� J��e�½ * g�i P��� ,>�"8�� >1�N :ghÇÅi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��k� �R�� C ®�� �� S· G/ �A� §��� P��<� 2pAV� 2"� � G/ !8R: IIIIQQQQHHHH ,P�+y�� ��1�e Y? G�� x1k� �=� �� >2pAV� >2���� P��2��
!a��� �6N1 $� �� E<"_ E�� P��2�� mL? � >��N lI3 ��#F� b�W; C ,28��� EN �3A��R1�Songbun, ��Lw�� P6e 2�2B E�� b�W �� �L? S<�� «�;�
m2#3 �� m���k� �+y�� .1�K�� �q��6A� !6#�� P#8q� ��6e� 4_�}��3 S<p�8:;�<�� !a�� ��"8q!
�G�R [j; P3��R L � �3 ��6#� b�W �� �L? G��5�� ��– ��j�;� L �4��1�K��− `� ��2pA� G/ �6<; / �;+A� �m2"�;� �/ ��k� �L? �� ��� �! ghi*
IIIIRRRRHHHH ��e G�;�R ��� P ��1�2�� �� ��z ��� �? §��� �� ��6��� Q�/? �A{Ô� ��"8�� G�;�R �?� �;��=� EK0
IIIISSSSHHHH ? P���V� P6�)� �� ��� �? §��� �� ��6��� Q�/ IIIITTTTHHHH ��8� 2��<� §��� Q�/ �> Y#8M�� J�\�;�� ��– J�\�;� }�
>��N �dek�� ����Rk�– ,� �2pA� 2pAV� G�e �� GOI, � �pp{ ��)�� G�e� §��� >��� ]p8{k ,P6�� PUR P ��1�2�� ];�e�,2pA� !e �2? Q�/
? r�Le IIIIUUUUHHHH §%ak� 7 #� ��� ? �6A� �,A� P ?}�� ]� !?� �?� 8�� 7�� �2pAV? IIIIVVVVHHHH ��2� ,��#3k� PH%H P�%3�_��3 P\M� �;/ �� G�<;Ö� �W � 2pAV�
� <_ [Ks ,� ;��R Y? >��V� 4;��R� m��2� Y? P#8M��G/ �� 7 �M� S���<�
i1g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Songbun
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
m2"� � EH §��� C? IIIIWWWWHHHH Y = 5��_ §%aÔ� 2=�� �– �� ©� C ^�y_– �& Q� GOI ,
.��� 12j�, s; 2pAV� 7 8�� [K �R%a/ � �=O�6?§��� PA6� ��%a �� 2"� � � 1 ©��� �� (��� ;�.1� =���B� �`� ,�¨� �� y3^� �¬�� �81� ¦�3
@1 F^¯B�¡*^� �C�\� F1�$ c ! r�+V� EK Æ�–'R���− �� b�y��� P3��RÉÄÄ b�� L � ,b��h�ÅÄ lI
h¼hh P��%�* ./: !3 ,r�+V� >��N ]B G�e b%N�� C b�y��� �� ¶�1�_ [j;
� P#A"�� Pp3L� C E,p3L3 b�R 4� ��# y�� ��6��=� ¿� 26² P;�a ����;2�� >��N r�+V� !W� ,>^,y��*
r�+V� 2,� C�r��¤ �,6K0 �������� ��#q�"V� �� ];�e* r�O �� 2?�y��� 6� � b%N�� G/�;2�� >��N ��;�K� G/ 'R��� �, C�
Y8 �� G/ �pj�� ��2)� − EAN� �A� �� �{− ��R: Û�� ¥���5 ,?*��W�, 7(30 ��9 �6� F0�t1�� TuR1�� ¼*m3+ ��Ü*
P��M��� �6<��3 EAN� �A� �� �{ �� ��N1 ç�/ GOI 4� 'R�A� G�6K046A<V� �%3!
G/ � ? �eLF� �� S:� ��� ��;�e �� EK) ��A{� 4� $}3� 5MR �� � � �"R1 ��A@� � �"R1 5MR �6�=�s b�y�� �%3 lI 1����� b2R G/ lI ,�%��q
.�� Í= ���K�� ��V� �� E, � SAq� ,����k�� >�U"��� G��k�3
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
§%6�, b%<�� 28� �3� 5#�� b���� b�"s–�� �Ò1− E,<�;/ ��8_�K� G/ E,8��q�� -�����3 E,<�;/ ��2�s ,r�+V� YR�3 E¥ .2�"� 7� P6W�– C P8_�KV��
����� !3�"� m2<� ��V� �� � �wA8� 28#�� �s2� G/ Y? P�%N�� P#����, �L?�� b%N�� C 'R��� §�"� �� .�?�= '���d��c� �b��a��`
q��p��o��n��m��l��kj��i��h����g��f��e�ghi* Í©� �,@ !#���3�§%6#�� .�V�!
� ? ��|<�� �K� : !? P���#�� b%N�� P��� C ��u�� ��L�� 'R�A� P8< ��3 ?�%{/ E, #_ �/ P8_�KV� �� G�{�0
� ͩ� !��6�� �I 1���/ lI ����p��� E,<�;/ ��8_�K� ` $}3� 5MR GI�de/!
2"s�;2�� >��N r�+V� G�e, EW�/ �� r�+V� Í= G�e� �;2�� Ñ�=* b5? 2R� r�+V� b�� ����= 4� Pe�#� C ��wV�h�ÉÄ b*
Ye�A6V� G�MA<�� � �U�/–28#��− b�y��� �� EK� .L�� .1�w�� m�j RY��� ��w_}�� �� ��;� ,�:)�� ];�e �"��s/ '��M_ 2��_ ,]R��� r�O C
P6�5? � E,�5?� b�� 1�3��� P#R�� Ch½Ä¼b* �s�� 2R��j R G�MA<�� �� .1�w�� m P6:? �� b%N�� 1��� ��� G2�
2�2©� �6#�<V�!
ghi P��� ,1� �� >1�N :g i*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
PR%6� ��1�y�� «Z�� 'u C P6W� ��,= r�+6A� G�e� �%3 C,46A<V� Ps%� Í= �I r�+V� Í= Y?�U� Í= �;2�� C �K� `�
P;+d#��! C ���K �� ��6��=� ¿� 26² P;�a ���� r�+V� '� –P#A"�� Pp3L�− ,
��k� �� �?1+#�N� ��� b%N�� 1��� �� ��#�� ª�w�� �6#�<V� /�� �� +312#3 ��� !8R ��*
G/ '8N �� lI [c/ : � �U�/ 'R��� E?>�a�� >��N , �=/ [#c E?�=�s��2)� ± 3 2<�� !AR !8R � �3 +e*
PM6 �� >1�j�� Y? PAKyV� GOI ��� �� ��z�#V� G�?O/ C ]#8M;� Y ,§���§��� Q�� �_�O 2� C*
بن حارثة وأم أيمن بن حارثة وأم أيمن بن حارثة وأم أيمن بن حارثة وأم أيمن وإال فإن بالل بن رباح وعمار بن ياسر وزيد وإال فإن بالل بن رباح وعمار بن ياسر وزيد وإال فإن بالل بن رباح وعمار بن ياسر وزيد وإال فإن بالل بن رباح وعمار بن ياسر وزيد
وكلهم عظماء الصحابة رضي اهللا وكلهم عظماء الصحابة رضي اهللا وكلهم عظماء الصحابة رضي اهللا وكلهم عظماء الصحابة رضي اهللا ،،،،وسمية بنت خياط، كلهم رقيقوسمية بنت خياط، كلهم رقيقوسمية بنت خياط، كلهم رقيقوسمية بنت خياط، كلهم رقيق
....عنهم، وما قلA@ل ر�قهم من قيمتهم شيئاعنهم، وما قلA@ل ر�قهم من قيمتهم شيئاعنهم، وما قلA@ل ر�قهم من قيمتهم شيئاعنهم، وما قلA@ل ر�قهم من قيمتهم شيئا
�� 4#3���� C� 'R��� ,^8K�� �2#�� �+A#��s EW#�� t2pV� E, 6T#�� � �6� �3� l�� F��?0 $�8� �3� l�� ��f� �5�� Z�J?�� )�t0� (���
f3j �5 (*��� ;>31� �R<��4#�/ E, � �� ¸1 � _��N� � �6(/ ,! F*��! F*z^ £�1� y� �?1 �G��� �G���?%0�3!�� _�u�1� ,0�� �9
�? r�O ��"� .L�� � !,=/ �6N1 §��� ����a�s ¶�1����3 $� � G�"�� C � ¸�V�− b��hÇĽ− �(�KV� 1�,W� v"s G�e– Y��� ���� �8�� !² ]A�*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�js +e §�s �� ,��I P=�)� �2= F� �� � ���=�� !WN� G�e §���s �I� A �+, � -!K� Y �5�� ���pV� C �I §��� 43� Y�@��� !6#�� 43*
�*�������9�# o*R���# �3�! �9 �a�?B� )�V��� Z�+ £�1� $�! �8_ �� �%Us �����e�s �� ¶�1�_ � G�s�#� � ���8_/� Y 6"�� � �#8q �K�
G��5�� ��1��� �8�� ����/!
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
kÜĐÛa@…bèu@ @(J@B� Z��� :?[@ $�Gj �C�\� c (j�� y�
:الرد
P�o ��_ EAs ,±; Q�� E,s �L? SAM�� ��,= ;P��28�� C >2��� PW�� �,s"SAM�� ��,=" -��2� ./ C �LK? PW�A�� mL? ��_ `� , -�p{ �/ [#c �/
7��«�c��* �AMj6s �����3�"�,=SAM�� �" � 8� Q�� E,s �� Y 8� ��� ±; �� �
E,���3 v8U � E,s �� Y F3! .ى فهم ينضبط بالفهمما بVني عل: Vكرر/
Á,s 2R� P3�pj�� >^N �� SAM�� ��,= �+A#�� E −E,A� �� G��c1− +3� , Y8 �� �3 ��3 −EAN� �A� �� �{ − C b%N�� 1�y�;�� G�2A8�� �����s ��
x1k� «�"{/* òßbç@pbÐÓë@bäÛ@æŁaëZ@ @
هل كل ما في جهاد الطلب يVنسب لإلسالم؟هل كل ما في جهاد الطلب يVنسب لإلسالم؟هل كل ما في جهاد الطلب يVنسب لإلسالم؟هل كل ما في جهاد الطلب يVنسب لإلسالم؟: : : : أوالأوالأوالأوال
�P?�23 �Ma �L?! P��W A� �8< _ G/ r K6F� � P��W �� [�� F '8M_ !Ks* §��#��� G��<;�ws/ C �5 F#�� 46A<V� �� ���� ��~� >��3I �K_ EAs �I� −
'8M��� − G�<;�� §�"�� Pq��R�6�2�� �; �� � �R%M;� �I−P��W ��−* 4�K���k�e �8�� �� �,A6e�3 ��1�R ¾���_ E�� `�−'8M��� − M;� �I � �R%
Y���� �; C �3k� !=��� �S� �� −P��W ��−!
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
C v������ �/ P��W �� E,s C T��s��� ,�1�� ��/ P��W A� '8M��� P���\6s 2R '8M��� E�� 4�� 4��j#63 � <�� �3 �p s ,P#R��� 1��/ �,Ae �,6,s
P��W �� [��¯ �� �,W�* �� ��N1 2,� L � P��W �� '8M��� [��a 2R�–EAN� �A� �� �{− *
2���� �3 2��a �3 b�R �� r�O �� ��d� J�R/�–� � �� ¸1− !�R 4�6AN/ ����"� G/ �� <0 ` P6�L= Y 3 �� � �N�;� , ,�;�8{ �;�8{ ����"� ��A#:s�6� �3� �s�s E?�º/ ��A�"� G/ m�� = ��/�−� � �� ¸1 − ��R� : � ���
�!=1 !�"� �� .^N/ !�R/ m^N/ ª�p{/ ��* �� �{ Y8 �� �� ���2R 7����R� ��2� EAN� �A� �� �{ Y8 �� �s�s ,��k� �� ���eO� EAN� �A� :Û ,G@1�
e!�� (1�� T�� �¿ �*16 ��5� }6Üghi* 2���� �3 2��a � ,s–� � �� ¸1− P��W �� [��a–� �2,��− � �K�
P��W A� m��,�=� S< F�* P��W A� [��\V� '8M��� �� �ao ��d� :2� �3 P��N/ !�R 4�− �� ¸1
� �− ��R �%=1 : �� ��N1 r�O ¾A3 +As ,Pe�#� C �� �I ��I �– �A� �� �{EAN�− 2� �3 P��Nk ��R :Û�� p6 %16 p Z�^ �� (�5 %�@�^�?Ü* Z�^: 2@^: ��
7�s���� ��9 ��6 �� Z��P Z�^: Û�� p6 %16 p Z�^ �� (�5 %�@�^�?Ü* ��R: �� +s �¿� �?1�K� b��� r�O !8R ]6AN/ �e/ ` �/ ] � 7��g�i*
ghi .1�\8�� �p{* g�i EA<�� .1�\8�� �p{*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
���H ��d� :Y8 �� ��"s ,Pe�#� C �P���"� �2= F� Y��� >/�V�− �A� �� �{EAN�− Ûy!���1 l`� 2��9 ��Üghi*
lI S< F_ �� P��W �� [��� ��"8M_ �,Ae mL,sP��W �� * � �A�� ��"; �p; :"P��W;" ��d6A� ��8��"_, E,�PW ::::بالمناسبةبالمناسبةبالمناسبةبالمناسبة � <_�* �I�
PW�� � #_ �� !6�0 � ��8d�� Y#MR Y �2�� ± ��s"P��W;" 9%M{� C��� ��� S=�s ���a��V�*
هل اإلسالم دين مسالم؟ هل اإلسالم دين مسالم؟ هل اإلسالم دين مسالم؟ هل اإلسالم دين مسالم؟ : : : : ثانياثانياثانياثانيا
�� �_�@� � C G�U�1 §1�q Y�%N�� �K�V� ��"� 2pAV�5 y�? :" −`�<� ��� b%N��− �3 �� !��#�� ��� .�s ,P���a PW�� mL?* !��#�_ 4��
-�� {/ ��� b%<�� ��� [ #�� �� !��#�_ ];�s �8�� �� �� >2y3 P_����� ,���2#�� n�A<�� �� !��#�N� [ #�� �� ��2�� !��#�N ��)� P#8M8s ,�8��
L? �� !��#�� �/ ��2�� �� �R��_ G�s �8�� ��#_ � ];�s P��<V� m− EA� �L?t20 G/ �K6� �− E<�� S?L� �� P�<As �� >�Ks �� P;��� 2=�_ �� ,"� P©�#V� P��6y3[ #�� �� !��#�� � G�<;�� ���U, ^� S?L� �,s �I�
!��K��* @ @@
ghi Y(�< �� �I P�+©� m��1*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
âý�Ûa@ì−@éuìnÜÛ@bã†Çb�í@âý�⁄a@ @1�8#�� Y? mL?� ,Pppj�� >1�8#�� Y? mL?�,A� 's��; Y��� >!"*
�2�/ 2R� ,b�� [�/ P3��R b%N�� >Ú�� C .�8�� Q ©� Ñ�� 2R�>1�U)� �S#3 ��U�� ,�+©�� ^�� EA#��� 1� ��3 G2V� b%N��, G�Ks
��6W�� b%N�� �2� �� ��/1 �V ]3�H -���Mc�3 ��2�� C G�Aa2� $� ����+e�*
G�MA<�� ��s 4� �;I !3 b�� r;%N P �2� ��d�� ���� �+d#��hŠh b P �2� �� 2s� m��=g�;�� i 2s��� Q(1 ��"s ,���M�I EK� ]B n�L;o ];�e Y���
��d�� ���� �+d#�� G�MA<A� :3 ,46A<63 � <� G�MA<�� �À/ �p; ,�1�j; �p; ! � de � #6N � K��� P���� G�6AW� � E�/� ,46A<V� P��2� �� F� �� , G�?�K
�2�/� �GI� ,E, �� §� ��� �� -'� .O !K� �� �L? � #6N 2"� ,EÀ2� �"� EK�����3 � A6y_ G/ �=�; � ;´s �L� ,EK�KA¤ ��1� ��L�� 1� �:��� ��� ,9��<��
4V�W�� � ��K� �� �;�jA\�� �;2A3 ��6KB G/� ,EK�M#3� * 9���� �� ��� �2R EHY8?L�� P �2V�* J�:�N�� P �2� !?/ ��=�� G�MA<��g�;��i m���R 2�/ !N1/� ,
-Í= $/1 �� P N C ./ ,�,<�; P <�� C �%#s �,p�s E_� ,P �2V� mL? lIhÅ h b *
�1s �� [A0� ��i Z�.�� : �+s ,� �pA{ 2 R�6N G+d� �3 2#N ��s 4� �>� � 2 R�6N ���s G�N��a P��� EA<� �3 P8�R m2#3 �� l�_� 2#N G/ G��
28� �3 �6� lI Ps%� ]�o 7�� ,�U� �� ��k� 2 R�6N !?/ !Á8 Æ"s E?�M F P N 5�5#��ÇÇ E, � ��3�;�s ')� >�;� �2#�� �� �3 �,�u� �� � � E,wA3� ×?
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
lI �6�N�� 2s��� P�A� !8"�N�s ,P8�R E¥ �A#s �� �� �Ky�� P�A� 7"A� � �2s���6AW�, +AN lI S�e EH lI m��2� � �3��e 2 R�6N �� �A��� 9f�� ª/ �3 G
¸�R Ú�� �3 � F� lI PU"�� G+A FN ����s ,P�%W�� rA_ C ')�3 ��U"��2 R�6N*
P8�R Í=� $� �� >��,u lI� 2 R�6N !?/ P��Ku lI ¸�"�� �6�N�� *��a´3 êR .L�� !:A:V� �6K� 12{/ P"")� ¸�"�� G�8�N� ��2 �� Í©� ¦
� ?� ,����� 2#3 �?�Aa� ��L�� 46A<V� ¦��aI r�Le� ,2 R�6N �� EA<V� lI m1��R 12{�s ,�%��e EK)� L� �3 ���� ��:s 1��"��3 P�A� ����� �Ma/ �L? S8<3 -P=1 C P �2V� + 3� ,>1��wV�3 4;2V� 46A<V� lI� !����3 Í©�
¯ ` .L�� ��j;��� �2#�� �I E,#<� ` r�O ��I� ,2 R�6N !?/ ��3 �� �M�A� �? �� �� ��)� ��"3´3 P8��MV�� E?��Ku �� E&� _ �� G%���*
2 R�6N !?/ �� ^de �'Aa EAN/�, P�%NI >�� 2 R�6N ]p8{/��}e*
x1k�� P���V� SN�KV� �� §%ak�� ')� ��;� 2"�* يشوه صورة النظرية؟لكن أال يوجد م@ن : ثالثا
;�p{ �8�� ��� C YÀ23 ��/ �L?�! �� E?2�/ rH20 ��2 � �K� .��B ];�e P6W� >1�U� �� ��2¥ �H2 FB G/ r K6� ,P�^�K_ �����
2#_ �%d� �& ��F� ` �� H/� P�� −� �U�/ '8M_ �L?� P;+d#�� >1�U)�− ];�e� , !d� P�%N�� G2V�� �}K�� E{��#�� ];�e� �K���� Ps�"d�� C P#AR Q�2;k� !K� P����� >�?�"��� G��^"��� P8q�R� 'y��� >�8��� Ps�K��� ��2w3
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� G�_�� $� �� ];�e� ,1�� !� 2"#F_ ���@� V� ];�e� ,G���k�� $� =k��� P:(�1 �>1�� EA#�� G�e� ,EA#�� G�"A�� �,Ae �;2−��"8M_ �,Ae mL?�−*
C �K� ,m�,WF_ G/ 2��_ �� � � ¦� F� G/ r K6� E\c «���<� ¶�1����s©� Q�� SA�k� ¶�1���� � �U�/ 7"8�� ,!j��� Y? P��W �� 7"8_ P��, �� ��(5
2��F� �� �,A� 5e�� Y���/ Ý�yF� G,A6e�3 >1�j�� m lI S< F_ Y��� ��(5©� mL¥ ��8�� �? EKÆ)�!
إذن دعنا نتحدث مباشرة عن جهاد الطلب من خالل النص، إذن دعنا نتحدث مباشرة عن جهاد الطلب من خالل النص، إذن دعنا نتحدث مباشرة عن جهاد الطلب من خالل النص، إذن دعنا نتحدث مباشرة عن جهاد الطلب من خالل النص، : : : : رابعارابعارابعارابعا
لماذا يوجد جهاد الطلب؟لماذا يوجد جهاد الطلب؟لماذا يوجد جهاد الطلب؟لماذا يوجد جهاد الطلب؟
G/ Y#_ G/ rA� -§���/ �� ]<� ��2�� Pe�#� $� =/ �/* ->��3´3 �& PR%� � ��2�� Pe�#� - ,M_ �/ YR� Á�*
���� E"_ ` ��2�� Pe�#�� -Q = S8<3 �/ ,>�8�� G�� !=/ �� �� 1��¨favoured race�2² P6:� $�"� �� ,*
���<As �� � ���� QK#�� �� �L?� J��)� �,s��e/ �� ]��R P���)IP ���<��� P�� ��� Pu����e P���=�� ��=����2�k�� PV�#��*
s C� ,2= F� + �/ ,!q�8�� �� P"")� ��2�� Pe�#6P��� �� ]��R -G�K� ./* mL,e 76W F� P��~<� G�23 .�+N ��� G�K� �� !3 ,��2�� S=�� �L?�
�"_�� �� 7"AF_* E,�A_�"� 2#3� ,J�#yA� ����N1 �; � � Y��� ]���M�� !_�"� ��2��s r�O lI ��"�;�� C PA��K�� �,���� J�#y�� rA�� nZ� ����N1 ��j�I 2#3�
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� �,(�"3 �/ ��2�� ��K��* ]���M�� PA_�"� PW) C�–SAM�� ��,=− ]���M�� Í= C ��= �OI
E& x�#��� �· %s P ,e �/ ���q/ �/ ^=/ �/ >/���* �pj�� ��2)� C +Ks :Û 7 *4 ��@��! p 7*��# �� 7CV p� 7f~� p� p� �
7����Ü* �a�� ��2)� C� :Û��12w_ � ,��Aw_ �� ,��Ad� �� ,G�2���� ��A�"_ �� ,����j�� J�p{/ ��Üghi*
لكن لجهاد الطلب لكن لجهاد الطلب لكن لجهاد الطلب لكن لجهاد الطلب ؛؛؛؛جيدجيدجيدجيد هذا كالمهذا كالمهذا كالمهذا كالم ::::قد يقول الملحدقد يقول الملحدقد يقول الملحدقد يقول الملحد: : : : خامساخامساخامساخامسا
؟؟؟؟""""الغنيمةالغنيمةالغنيمةالغنيمة""""مصلحة مادية مصلحة مادية مصلحة مادية مصلحة مادية
,�pj�� �? QK#�� !3 ,� ���� �Ma �L? ,, |�� )[0 �C�\� c Fu*�~1�#;���W�� �jÂ1 y*@�!�EAN� �A� �� �{ �� ��N1 ��R ,: Û �� �� ��~! ¢F����
Fu*�~1� ��3*8*# �� y*3� Ã, ,± ��3�� ��¬� �� ,��j� ¹_.@� ��@A�! [email protected]�, ,��j� ,± ,! Fu*�� ��3*8� / �6�Üg�i*
�S� �,A{/ C P6 w��s GOI; E,�A_�"� C G�6A<V� �¥ ��"�� PwAF3 �, K�* إشكال أخير إشكال أخير إشكال أخير إشكال أخير هنا اتضحت أفرع المسألة بفضل اهللا، لكن يبقى هنا اتضحت أفرع المسألة بفضل اهللا، لكن يبقى هنا اتضحت أفرع المسألة بفضل اهللا، لكن يبقى هنا اتضحت أفرع المسألة بفضل اهللا، لكن يبقى : : : : سادساسادساسادساسادسا
هل يVقتل هؤالء الطواغيت فقط لكفرهم؟هل يVقتل هؤالء الطواغيت فقط لكفرهم؟هل يVقتل هؤالء الطواغيت فقط لكفرهم؟هل يVقتل هؤالء الطواغيت فقط لكفرهم؟: : : : وهووهووهووهو
(�(4 �t� �`� Æ_�" F� ` ]���M��s ,'8N �� >���R 2#_ G/ rA�� �I ��A
ghi 2Òk °�A��� ,.1�\8�� C �A{/ ��2)�* g�i ��2)� ER1 ,EA<� �p{ ½�¼*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
E,�I �&�{� �� E¥�#y� E������ b%N�� P��N1 �=� C ���R� E�k* �V?1� F@5��� c p ]��<� F@5��� c [j� ��6 �C�\� c Z���1��P
��"��� C�� PA3�"� C S=� +;I b%N��)�C � J : : : : ر مرة أخرىر مرة أخرىر مرة أخرىر مرة أخرىأVكرأVكرأVكرأVكر��K�� PA3�"�*
�� G�8?��� �� G�6#�� �� Y �5�� �� G�8j�� �� ��< �� !Æ_�"� � r�L��]���M�� Í= C� 1��e E,Ae E�/*
�� ��N1 >^N ];�e mL?�– EAN� �A� �� �{– ; x1�� !?/ C3�p{ >^N� Æ� !_�"� EAN� �A� �� �{ G�Ks m2#3 �� �� G/ lI ,�31�� �
P�5©�3 m�,R ]B !a2� �/ ,�;��À �/ ,� �� C !a2�– ��� ./ P��N1 �;m2A3 C b%N�� − n�_ �O´s ,E?��2�/ ��31�� �OI �u�=� m���º ���� G�e �L¥�
P��N1 ��e�_� E?�V�N� b%N�� !?/ P31�² 1��K�� r�O C G�e �,W_ b%N�� E,�wA3 �/ ,� ?��3� b%N�� b%�/ ��2?�u �OI E,�%NI ��=1 J�#yA� PpAj�
m1�8a/ ,E,A�R �� � a �L?� ,E,U#3 b%N�� C !a2� G/ 23 %s* 2"s ,!8R �� ��8;k� P N �? SAM�� ��,=� �5 T4�� (��j� ���� (��j
� ,G*@0 ��*@� (��j� $���$ (��j� ����CR1�� C81, ��,= ��2?�= E,Ae ��|F� `� ,SAM�� ��,= !8N C �I �� �� G�; �3 �u�� ¦�¯ `� ,SAq
SAM�� ��,= !8N C �I G�# e ]���q PA_�"63 7N�� * ��}:�V�� ]���M�� �� ����k� ��;��� G�AN�V�� G�8 �� 2?�= 2R�*
� x1k� C �À�· Pc�V� �� P N �, K� � 1�8�a��� �%�3�� 1�� �
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� ��|V�� ,SM�� �� �8� 56�� G+��� P"_�3 C E?� á, Æ{� $� �� ±p�>2"#�� ã.�R G+��� §��{ �I 7"8� %s ,�s�K��*
هل يجوز للملحد أن ينتقد جهاد الطلب؟هل يجوز للملحد أن ينتقد جهاد الطلب؟هل يجوز للملحد أن ينتقد جهاد الطلب؟هل يجوز للملحد أن ينتقد جهاد الطلب؟: : : : سابعاسابعاسابعاسابعا
�A{Ô� ��"8��� ,��"8�� !=/ �� «���� P�<As �� !Ke ��)�� b��RSurvival for the Fittest [R��� � .L�� �6�<V� b�2j��� ,perpetual
conflict* 1��� � �"8<� �"� �? P��6y�� >��3�� 7�� �/ ��,©� 2"� � .L�� 2pAV�s
�_�M#� $|3� ���%{ b2�� m��)I* )� � �"8Ms m��−��)�� 7 #� E,�� G�e ��− P��6y�� >��3�� E(��= ��p�_
§���k� P" _� �A{Ô� ��"8�� !8N C �A� !(�Us lI YR�#�� ^,M����* 4���N 2pAV� !�R ��)�� !8N C�¼ÄÄ �� �%Us ,Y�s�N 2pA� [�/
4 �2�V� �� 4�%V� ����ghi* Y��� ��)�� P��W � !a��� ���qk� §���I ���<�s 7 #V�� P6"��
4�%� >��3I C S8<�� Q8u Qe ¾U6s ,Q8u Qe ¾U� �� EA3� �� !3� "3r6s C ��Ze�8��, ë.��)I 2=�� �� �8��� ��Ze�8�� 43 !c��_*
[� 4�/ �H1o ��"�Arthur Allen Leff ��� P#��:3 G�;�"�� O��N/K���k� >2p�V� �������3P :" !3� "3 ���qk� §�� G/ ��8H� P"��q 2=�_ �
i1g Seumas Milne: The battle for history. The Guardian. 12 September
2002*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
N �� �? `�3� ��³"* there is today no way of ‘proving’ that napalming
babies is badg1i . ��2pAV�� ��)�� �� �S� �? !3 2pA63 Q� ��,©� 2"� � .L�� 2pAV�s*
����y�� �x��w��v��u��t��s��r��q��p��o�� �n��m�~��}��|��{��z�g�i*
l�#_ ���R �� Y ��N >2�%V� �%�5�� 2�/: ���p��o� � �n��m�q�g i*
�s�e !e !�"3 ��8� Y&I ��/ �;/� ! : الرد
IIIIQQQQHHHH � �#� x1k� !?/ !�R �8� ��)�� G/ '��; P��28�� C; Gk p �*<� ¼�$�� ����� ��$�j�1 ;$�B� � \� c fRV! p� �± �����; ��� �8�� �6:s ,
P6R %3 P6:;−G���N �1�e ��R +e− 43� x1k� !?/ 28_ G/ 43 §�s %s , r�5 � b��/ [{��� Q K_ G/−;k ���6#�<V� ��o !�"_ [{��� Q K3 r
��1�M_ §�s �� ,��Ze�8�� 4�%� �, M"_ Y��� P�^�K8��� �I ��Ze�8��� G�<;�� 43
i1g Economic Analysis of Law: Some Realism about Nominalism (1974),
p.454* i�g P��� ,P3���� >1�N :g�Çi* i g P��� ,P3���� >1�N :g�Çi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P=12�� C §�s−! IIIIRRRRHHHH Y #� �L? P,8u 1��K�� ���R G/ 1�8����Ma G/ rAa�� �"_ ];�s ,��)��
� #� >�pA�P���� P6R ��=�A�� 7, ��)�� [< � �L?� * �L? ���"��3 'A#�_ ��,8u 1�Up�N�� 2pA� 2��� 2pA� 2=�� � �;/ 2e|�
�� �%��e � ���)Ix1k� �=�* Y #� �L?� 7�ps ,� �#� �8�� �A� �� ¾8{ .L�� Y&�� [AK��� P6R
F� 2pAV�m��=� P���� G�<;�� P6"3 �"* -�263 �I '"p�_ �� G�<;�� P6R �K� -`�� �� .��V� � V�� ^� �ao, �L?�
� 2�/ 2pAV� Z\As !Ke G�<;�� ��=� 7 #� v"<� �/ ��)�� v"<�! IIIISSSSHHHH P6��K�� P��� �j\3��q� �p��o� � �n��m�ghi, ��
/��Ku�� 7,�;� v"s P,8y�� S��{ �,A6e, !_�"; �p sfight :�s2; ./ ! !�"; Q��kill *
ثم نحن نقاتل م@ن؟ثم نحن نقاتل م@ن؟ثم نحن نقاتل م@ن؟ثم نحن نقاتل م@ن؟P��� !6e/ :���v��u��t��s��r��q��p��o���n��mz��y���x��w�g�i*
,%1��� �� ��+ �� ����H p ��`1�,G# 3�R�*J ��?G���� S���JB� ��F*���1� ��+ f!��(1� y9� )�#¯1� y9 ,G@!��� )pn�� ,©��0��; �s�K��s
ihg P��� ,P3���� >1�N :g�Çi* i�g P��� ,P3���� >1�N :g�Çi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
G/ S· �L? x���Ô� ����8�N�� ����pV� !K� ����3I m��e �� �6�=� .L��G�6A<V� �A_�"�*
���y�� �x��w��v��u��t��s��r��q��p��o�� �n��mz�ghi* IIIITTTTHHHH y��W� C# $�AB� �#�?1� ��� l�V?1 �� �p{ ��2� �� P�o 2=�_ �� ,
!�e b%N�� GI !3 ,�s�e �;k !�"F� �s�K�� G/ 1�"_ «�c�� 7�� �� [#cP;�j��� P������ 7,� � ���N�3 �� ��3 ��|� � .L�� �s�K�� Y�LA�*
Æ?�#6A� x�#��� ��� G/ C ��z b%N�� !3�s�K�� Y�L�� �/ 2 P6��= ,��# u !
28� �� ��R EAN� �A� �� �{ Y8 �� �� +, � �� ¸1 ��6� �3 �� :Û �� 7���0 e�5� fR� �� (j�� �GH �6� ,F�D� FJa� ®�� / 7�(���� y�^Üg�i*
?P ©� Pp(�1 9�_ rA#· � �s�e !�R G/ !� l�#_ ���R /�R� � �U�/:���ÉÈ��Ç� � � � �Æ��Å� �Ä� �Ã� �Â� �Á
�� �������� �� � � ��A���F��E� �D��C��B��W� � VU� � � � �T��S�� � �R��Q��P��O��N�� ML��K� �J�� � � � � �I�� HG��g��f��e��d����c��b��a�������`��_��^��]��\�[��ZY��X
ihg P��� ,P3���� >1�N :g�Çi* i�g �pp{ C .1�\8�� �=�a/*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
���u�����t��������s��r����q��p��o��nm���l������k����j��i��h�ghi* IIIIUUUUHHHH m ��Á3 r� �=/� !3 , Á �<V� �s�K�� �� Í��#��� b%N�� r� �=/�i��
��{��zy��x��w��v��u��t�������s����r��q��p��o��n���m��l��k������j~��}��|�g�i*
IIIIVVVVHHHH �#� �2#_ G�3 n��/ !3 �s�KA� -EA@ ./ �� �P��z b%N�� 7, � ���£��¢�� ¡���~�� �}� �|�� � � � � � �{� �z��y��x
��µ��´���³��²±��°��¯®��¬��«��ª��©¨��§���¦��¥��¤¸��¶�g i*
المدهش أني بعد أن أجبت هذا الزميل بما تقدم وصفني بالمسلم المدهش أني بعد أن أجبت هذا الزميل بما تقدم وصفني بالمسلم المدهش أني بعد أن أجبت هذا الزميل بما تقدم وصفني بالمسلم المدهش أني بعد أن أجبت هذا الزميل بما تقدم وصفني بالمسلم
! ! ! ! - - - - اللطيفاللطيفاللطيفاللطيف- - - - الكيوتالكيوتالكيوتالكيوت
+e ^<���� ��=1� ��/� v8U�� P6R mL?� Go�"��3 Go�"�� �fs �/ ��G���{k� 1�"�!
�%(�R �A� ]"A� �L�� :S�*9 %@9 _�C�6 �s6!! � 3 G�6�5� �� >2�%V� ��,8y3 �H�_ !�5�� G/ �28� �K� ��R �� � ��
[<�� P�o P��� mL? G/ ���a��V� �#3ÛP3����:�ÇÜ �� P�o Y�(�� P3��R ]\<;
ihg P��� ,>�"8�� >1�N :ghÇÄ− hÇ i i�g P��� ,P p�6V� >1�N :g¼i i g P��� ,>2(�V� >1�N :g¼i
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� J��e, � ���o� P)�jV�� P����V� ���o Y?�Ô��Ó��� �Ò��Ñ�ghi ���o� ,��_� �^� �]� �\�g�i� EA<A� 9� ©�3 ��k� ���o� ,��Ð� � �Ï� �Î
�Ú��Ù��Ø��×��ÖÕ��Ô��Ó��Ò��Ñ�g i* �3� [{� 2R� ,�3 2�# F� � �a��� [#c ��R �L? G/ 4K<V� .12� ��
�3��e C .�©�Û�i��1� ´����Ü E��3 �3 4A(�"�� :" ,Go�"�� ¿R�; �� E& E,s �V� �� m�2?�� �V 2,#�� b��I �? ��2��� �+K� [<�� P�o ]\<; +;I 4e�
r�O ]\< s ,E&��R �� [K��3"* C !{k��l�#_ ���R 4e�V� Ps�e �� !��#���: ���Ä� �Ã� �Â� �Á
���Ï��Î��Í��Ì��Ë��� �Ê��ÉÈ��Ç��� � �Æ��Å��B��A����R��Q��P��O��N��ML��K��J�������I��HG��F��E��D��C����c��b��a�� � � � � �`��_��^��]��\�[��ZY��X��W��VU��� � �T��S�� �s� �r��� �q� �p��o�� nm� � �l�� � � � �k�� � �j��i��h� �g��f��e��d�� � � ������t
���u�gÅi* : : : : لكن هذا حال الملحدلكن هذا حال الملحدلكن هذا حال الملحدلكن هذا حال الملحد
/− �A���_ ��w�3�� P ���� ��w�3� � � �3�y_ �� «�8_�!
ihg P��� ,>�"8�� >1�N :g�½Éi i�g P��� ,G��s�K�� >1�N :gÉi i g P��� ,���;k� >1�N :gÉhi iÅg P��� ,>�"8�� >1�N :ghÇÄ− hÇ i
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
J− ���a��V� ���R/ «�8_�! ¦ − �pj�� �Hk� n�_ÛFJ*J81� F�R1�� �i��1�Ü, G%s ��"3 'A#����! � − FV� n�_ b�K�k� lI �������� ,P����V�� P)�jV� 1�"� .L�� EKp
P{��! ��{ E,::�� -��a E¥�q�s r�O ^� ��/ ,���s�K�� ��,8u !{/ �? �L?*
عورة الحرة وعورة األمةعورة الحرة وعورة األمةعورة الحرة وعورة األمةعورة الحرة وعورة األمة 1�K_ ��|N ��2pAV� !8R � Á��?� : �0� �<� �0 e5 F^�V! Fu� y�
?F��� :الجواب
����� G/ ��#� � �,s ,�W �� ^jR Ps�"d�� !pc ª�#�� 2pAV� G/ PAKyV�,!{k� C Fe Ë� �,s �,�� �@� �� 2?� �?}K� ��< �� �� 2���"��e*
���I �/ �(��� �e � ����N !��K�� Z<�� �,A� Q� ��|?� * ��"s �� �Ò1 P6_ �3� b%N�� ¶u r�O �eO 2R� :Û 2,� C ����� ËGI
Ë� Fe GI� ,b% Ë<��� >% Ëj�� �A� ��N��� P ���� Gk ;�(��)�e �8:�0 � , ã!R/ Ë�¥�,s l�#_ ��×R ,����K; G�=�� � ®%�� ��<Ý �� �×� Æ2���"�� Æ�,8yF� Ë� F,Æs :
�f��e��d����c��b��a��`��_��^�ghi* Z�^�: Ë� FK Æ� G/ ��23/ �K6� � �L,s ,m�=��� G� Æ< Á)� ��ËeZ�� ����� ��/�
ihg P��� ,1� �� >1�N :gÉÄi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
S·� ,b% Ë<��� >% Ëj�� �A� ��N��� 2,� C �����e ��23 Ë!e Z<_ G/ �,A��WË �� J�3 C ,�WË �� ��** P � Á��� � � �� F �� ZN �? J�:)� �� ��j"V�s
C ����a G�e ��� ,>% Ëj�� C Z�<� G/ G�<;�� �� S· �L&� ,>% Ëj�� �%\3 -G�K� �� �I �A� �AËM� �; �W � �� Z<Ë��� S· +;I �WË �� J�3 C �K�$� �� *
��R :�WË �� C PËA Á#��s ,n�O C PËA Á#�� ^� �L? C PËA Á#��s : C §�s �� ,P ���� ��a����� ��<Ý ��� �(��)� ��<Ý �� 43 �L?Ü*
C �� �Ò1 E"�� �3� ��R�"4#R�V� b%�I" :Û �:#�� lI �W �� E��B ��/�Pp8"�� ��?�y�� >�)�, � P�k� lI ����3I��+©� P�1�8�, ,«1�y�� �� JLKs
��R +;I �;�p8N ��� ? �L? 9�3/� �L? �� b�� ���s :���q��p���o��nr�ghiÜ*
s���<3 ����N >�)� >1�#e P�k� >1�# ,PR�����3 «1�y�� C ±; ��� EAs! 26² �3/ ��R��� �Ò1 b5� �3 :Û >2��� P#8ËM�� Gk ;> Ë�F)�e P�k� GI
Æ!�� �� ,�,�Ë?��� �,�""� �� ¦1�a x1�� [{� 㧠Ý���� ,>2��� P Æ"áA Á��> Ë�F)� 43� �, 3 '���Ë��� ��Ü*
��R EH :Ûl�#_ �� ��R C !?� �� �#3 S?O 2R� :����v� �u�� � �t~��}��|��{� �z��y�� xw� g�i, r�L3 l�#_ �� ��/ +;I �;/ lI; Gk
��#� S3%©� �<8A� G�3 �(��)� ���s '<�A� ��< A� G�c�#�� ��;�e §�<���
ihg P��� ,1� �� >1�N :g Äi* i�g P��� ,J�5�k� >1�N :g½Çi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�?�c�#�� %s �(��� ��/ §�<���Ü* .L�� 2N���� ^<���� �L? �� /}; �p;� PA?� �/ `�� P� ��I �?;'N�s -JO�e ��Zs� �/ !R�� -!c�s l�#_ �� G/ �s Gk
V� ���I x���/ �� §�<��� 'Aq/46A<, 23k� P8j� mL?� * G� H� [A�a� ���P�k�3 �6��p�e >�)�3 �;5�� E��B G/ C b%N�� !?/ ��, ��5�� �� 2)� G/�
>�)�3,§�s �� P�k�3 ��5�� �� 2)�e x�#�e E��p��� C >�)� x�#_ G/�§�s �� P�k�Ü*
�P�k� C !8 � �3 2Ò/ ��R : ,S"� _ PA� ];�e �OI§�s � >�)� EK� �L?�* � ��/ F � Y��� P�k P ���� �, � Ì �,As[ye �� ,>�)�e �=��� G�e �L? ¿
�6� !#s>�1���� �������� C � � �� ¸1 J�M� �3 , 26² ¶y�� ��R�� �W�� b2"V� !�+NI :Û � ? }� �;/ §�1���� �� P_�� 1�H�� P66U3 �?�W��
− ���R C ./ :e� rN/1 Y�y− m��j"� G/ � !K��3 �5©� �� :r,=� Y�ye� ,EA�/ �� �Üghi*
� 26² 1��e2�� ¿� .1�j;k� �� 28� b�y? ª/ ¶y�� �1 �� �W�� !";�� +,Ò1 �%&� ��2�� Y"_, ���R �s � :Û� �6� G/ �� 1��e2�� PAUs ���R �� ��/
ZN ¿� ����� J»� G�e � � �� ¸1�pj3 QAs $/��� , �;/ �pj�� !3�=��� ZN ¿� �¥»� G�eÜMYO*
� � <_ r�O C ����� ¿�*,@0� ���P
ihg J�:)� P��/ :�ļ Í��&� C* i�g J�:)� P��/ :� Ä*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
áuŠÛa@†y@ @_áíŠØÛa@æeŠÔÛa@¿@‰ì׈ß@áuŠÛa@†y@Ýç@ @
P����"���� P��"�� P <�� C � K�� ,�� J��e C Q� E=��� 2�! �Ä� �� « %1� :P#R���� �� ��=1 P#31/ >��,u* �K� ` GI 1L#�� �L?�
��Z��� �/ ,�� F² :!#���3 >/�V� �/ !=��� �Z#� � ?�* �J���� ^� �L?� �s* ¸�"�� lI m��/ �s�� G/ G�� �=��� �31 ��w�<� G�<;�� G/ !{k� !3*
->�� �� �de/ EAN� �A� �� �{ Y8 �� �,#=�1 P�2��w�� >/�V� C �L�� ��1� �?lI �%�/ �,A?/ ->�� !e C ���� �, K� ,2)� �,A� b�"F� �� ��w�<_ G/ C C �P8��1
S;L�� �� �,M���* ��� ,��V� 7�� E=��� �?� �,A� Y���� 2)� P��R´3 Ee�)� b�"� � ?�
P��RI �� H/ J��&� ]��������/ 2)�, Pe�Z� P N mL?�− Y8 �� SU� ��3 P3�pj�� ') 4� EAN� �A� �� �{E=��� �� H/ J�&� ���� 4� 5�+−*
�� P{%a E,V�; ���"G/ � ? :¡*3t�@1 %�� �.9� �j�@1 $�(<� G�e �L�� , �,�6K� G/ �� ,����)� P��8�N�� §�M�� �MR C !dV� J»� 2A3 n� ?
%3 !R/ �1�{ 7�� P#���� P6��= `�#�� �−2A8�� mL¥ 2jR/ P���#<�� 4� �,s b�R/ �3 26²�� �Ò1 J�?��� 28� P�%N�� P#���� −*
1�j�a�3 P�2��w�� >/�V� PjR r�I� : ��N1 G�e + 3 �� EAN� �A� �� �{ �<��=� ����� ->/���3 �OI� �3�p{/� 2:<V� C ��I ]A{� 7�� 2:<V� J�3 !a2_
b%<��� >%j�� �A�, ]��R� ]; ��/ �_}a/� ����/ ]�R� EH : ��N1 �� ��
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�2� ]8{/ ���� �M"� ��e 7�� EAN� �A� �� �{ Y8 �� �=� ���s ,��,Ms � EH , ��~u �6<� ` �;�e ]KN� ,P 6V� lI �,=� � ���*
]��"s ,�,�%e �� >/�V� �=�_ G/ EAN� �A� �� �{ ��N��� ���� 2"s: �s ,r��� �3 5��� ���1 +e ���_ G/ 2��_ �� ��N1 �� n�1F/ �� �8� �I ��
�;5��* �;5�� �� �8� ��/ EA� ��2#3 ,EAN� �A� �� �{ Y8 �� �& ��"s: Û _3�s�
%*�z! ��+Ü* ��#c�s, -b�� ��/ C� -PR�a C �� Ë�� 2R� �3 ]_/]��R� , : ���;5�� �� ��,q �� ��N1* �& ��"s: Û%*���� _�j�Ü* �,A?/ ]3 lI ]8?Ls
2)� �,A� b�R�s ,��6Ms 7�� �,A�q ]#c1�s, ��R� :Û 7F5�! 25�! (�1 2uRW �1,G����1 F��(B� y�� �� e�3� v0Ü*
� �s2? ]<�� ���O C P��� ]<� ��2)� G/ Pj"�� �� 2?�y��* W� =�m1� y5�G�� 2@V�@1 µ�V1� �*��� ,(+ Å^� k6 �G�*z !Us/ P3����s ,
�_�� �� � a EA<V� >��� f�/�* ��= �OI YeL�� ��k� ��� ]3�? �O´s J�� 7�� �¥»� �,M��� 2��_ m/��� �_
�� ���)� 'c/ C �I ��2� P��RI b%N�� P�/ ¶�1�_ C �eLF� ` �L�� ,�,e�_b�©� J�K_1� �� 46A<V� «�� �=5 � �3* EA�/� ��/ ���*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Š½a@Þìy@pübØ‘gñaA@ @g J��e Y�� �� >/�V� ��� ���Ku�� �� ���� C Y���� !{����
Y���M�� §��� �3 5�5#�� 28� ,!" �� [{�� !"#�� [{1 C P��}A�� PA"#�� �� �W��i*
áèÈß@æìØm@óny@b�ìy@ò׊Ƚaë@ñcŠ½aáèÈß@æìØm@óny@b�ìy@ò׊Ƚaë@ñcŠ½aáèÈß@æìØm@óny@b�ìy@ò׊Ƚaë@ñcŠ½aáèÈß@æìØm@óny@b�ìy@ò׊Ƚaë@ñcŠ½aAAAA
�M� C �YM8�� ¦12��� ��)�� �%c 12j� ��&� «�8_�� [;�� �6<��s§2�� � G��º �K� [��� �����, ��� G���M�� ��{ �� b� � G�pM���
]�R�_ �OI G�� �8� _ Y��� Y? l�k� PR2�� ]�;/ Y��� �;O�s ,°"�N� +31 [R�_PR2�� rA_ –�� �W�� Y���M�� 5�5#�� 28� ¶y�� m�eO ��dV� �L?�−*
�YM8�� ¦12��� �� b�"� �,s ��)�� r�Le�, Æ8s�� [�I 2# �8j� .�#�P�1�U� PN12�, � P#=1� b|u Eyp��� �8j����KJ�� �I� �H
N��M��L�MNO* -��� !e C >/�V�� ,�A���� �� -PA��� !e C ��)�� �2,�< F� Y? >/�V�� E?��)I G ��<; 2R >2�%V� ��|? G/ �28� �K� ,��� �/ ^� �¥ ��� F� �3�_ Y?
2R -J�×:�I «�c�� lI >/�V� ��×�/ Ae C� ,�%w�N� «�c�� �/ ����)�� 4E?��)I 2"s �%���V� ^3��q C m2y3 �W�%F; �L?� ,�,�j\u �� >/�V� b�0
-G��� lI 5× F¤ ��<;I �(�e �� >/�V� ]��×B !�* !d� ��2�� C >/�V� + 35�1 �×,��2R/ ]B P ©�� ,$2"F� �(�e� º�, PR%#���
ihg P��� ,����k� >1�N :g¼�i*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��� 43� �, 3 �,���Ò� >/�V� P���1 �p; °A� §�d� !=��� ��� ,PN2"� PR%� !=��N !e �� �,�q��I� �����]��\��[�MNO* Á�� F�� FN Æ1 ��R�− ÆEËA ÆN Æ� Á�á ÆA Æ� FË�� Ë� Æ{ − :Û �, W9 W �f |� �|� |� |� �%�@ ��| �� �, W9 W �f |� �, W9 W �f |�
�� ��| ��ÜMYO* �;/ ª�#�� ��)�� b|u �� �K� �� �s 2· EAs ,b%N�� 9�3 b2M{�
���L¨ ��8(�a ��#s ,>/�V�3 1 Ý�w� �A#·* flõbî‘di@�bî–Ûa@üg@éÛ@Õjí@�ëflõbî‘di@�bî–Ûa@üg@éÛ@Õjí@�ëflõbî‘di@�bî–Ûa@üg@éÛ@Õjí@�ëflõbî‘di@�bî–Ûa@üg@éÛ@Õjí@�ë@@@@ÝrßÝrßÝrßÝrßZZZZ@ @@ @@ @@ @
١ - ���� ����: K�_L �C «��� ���� K�_L ��� ��6��� 2 � P��M��3 !=��� '� 1�,@I
n��<V� Y��3, S�L#��� �� �%Us b%��� ���V� Q��* P��� �L���� $�8� �3�e [A<�� .f��G���"� ��M : n��<��3 J»��
�,8u�* ¦%� !���� �ao �? Y8j�� `|� � .L�� n��<��3 J»�� G�e ��G��:&�� Ppj �� 2#3 4=�5�� 43 �%�*
G/ 2pAV� µ; !? �K� ���1�� 1�"� G�e ,�5 V� b�,V �I �Aj_ � >/�V� G/,]8�� �� P:,8�� ���cI� Ms �� � �"8 SAK�� �� !Us/ ]8�� C >/�V�M�O*
ihg P��� ,��< �� >1�N :g�hi* i�g ���©� �p{ C ��8�k� �pp{� ,.L�Z�� �=�a/*
i3g Charles Darwin, The Autobiography of Charles Darwin 1809-1882,
New York pp. 232-233.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
m��)� � �"8q �;/ 2pAV� µ; !?� r�O '3�M� ��K� >/�V�3 Â�� ¶V� E:�G�<;�� 1�M_ !���� �� ��<�� PA��V� C ®�_ >/�V�� ,%�1�w��3 Â��MNO*
m2U3 ��� m��)� ���Z�� �? 2pAV� m�< � �� .L��! ��/� آ�-,� + � ا�)*( وا��)أةأن ا$�#م ! - ٢ � 0 1*�/.
SeZ�� §���3 !?�= �L? G��#� ��k G��#V� 43 .��<��� 2��� .L��*
��8=���� C ���8��� �� 1�2"� S=�� P8����� >�M���� E<©� C ���8���s .L�� ��,6A� ]��A F� �� ,�2#�� �+e �L?� ,.�M��� ���8��� 1�2"� �� SN� ��
�I 2· �!��#�� *
�� S=�/� ,�,�"A �P"s��� >/�6A� �,�A�/ ��=��� �� ��u/ �� b ��� 2"sQK#��3 QK#��� ,E,N�3 >�R� E?2A© �>����� >/�V� �¥ b5A F� `� ��u/ ��=���*
¢)Æ5 ��B� ��@ W� /� F�V�1�� F0�D� C�� $�GD� Z�j�1� v0 [j��# ���1sP
y9� ��?+�� yj ���f�� y�# v0 F*�3B� �j��, v0 F*�3B� ]��`1� ����B�� yj�1� �G*# ¡5�t�*# �t�� y�#P
�±j� G�K� � ->/��� �/ -!=�3 -EK� !�23 �I, �L? G�K� ��P6K�� -PÒ�3 �I ±j\���*
�_�8=�� C ������ 2����� Q ©��, !=��� �� [A�¯ ^wj�� J�y��s
i1g Gould, The Mismeasure of Man, p.105.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
^wj�� b5As ,�<V� ,^8K�� �� EA<F� G/ �?� ��=� !8"F� G/ ^wjA� �· �� ^8K�� QK� �� E(�{–P6(k� �#3 2 �− C ^8K�� �� ^wj�� b2"�� ��
����,y�� �� ��2)�*
.��<��� GI !3 �6©� 43 ��8=���� ���<_ �O´s ,«� ��� lI �"� 2RP=�5�� �� P"� �� C ¦�5��� Jk� «� _!
�� P��<��� 7�c�_ P�<As �/ P��Ks �/ Pc��1 �/ P6A� ����N �P,= ���/ �� -§�"� C ��ºI� !,=� EA@ �L? G/ �6©� EA#� >/�V�� !=��� 43
§�"� J�<�* �;�My�� P8#� Õ�6�� �� �� � ���� ] e Y ;/ � ? ��"�� PAs�; ���− ]�R�_�
Y,"��� «�5 �� �� � �=��a− �My�� P8#� G/ E,V�P�2��� P ?O PA"� P8#� Y? �; * !=���3 P{�� rA_ �� >/�V�3 P{�� �;�My�� ���M3 !"�<_ r�O ���
� ����! !{/ ���hÅÅh ^8e O��N/ S"� �� !{�� YV�� �;�Mu !M3Grand
Master GM ��N S"A�� �� !j0 ` P8#A�� ¶�1�_ C h >/���MNO* ^8e O��N/ S"A� ��{��� 1�"��� �� ��j)��½ÄÄ C �L? ,PM";
��=���* v"s Y�Ks >/�V� ��/� ÄÄ >^8e >O��N/ S"� �� !jp�� PM";WGM
Woman Grandmaster
i1g http://ratings.fide.com/download.phtml.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� x�#� * P<� �� x���k�� Q� �� EA� O��N/ 4?�e G�1�3 G�6N¦2�}6e P#��:3, ¿"#�� 5�+��� ��� C ����� ���� ��6�N� Y��� �H�p3/ �(��;
�� b�� m�; J��e C ��< ��� ��=��� 43 µ� ��ÄÄ G�� #3" §1�����.�d;k� ¶V�� .1�eL�� ¶V� 43 P��?�©�"*
The truth about male and female brain , the essential
difference � ��R C J��K�� ���² ±\A_ �K6�� *4?�e :" E_ 2R .�d;k� ¶V� GI
m��2�I� �AKy_ .1�eL�� ¶V� !Ky_ E_ + 3 [q�#���� Pe1�yV�3 b�"� ���AN�"�P6W ���� PAAp��� [(�@���3 b"*
The female brain is predominatly hard wired for
empathy, while the male brain is predominatly hard
wired for understanding and building systems 1��e� ��"�4?�e G�1�3 G�6N :" PN� ©� §1����� mL? 1�K;I G/ ru �
}e/ 2#� EA#�� ¶�1�_ C Q�2��� ����²"* �L�� ,�¥ >/�V� ¶FV !8ÁR � P(�y;I� PAAB ��12R �%d� ���5��� PN�1� SAM�_ 43 ���hÃÄ �V�� � ��2N t%H n� ? b�A#�� C !3�; >5(�= �� 4A{��
v"s * @/ +e G/ >2p�V� �������3 b�A#A� P��"�� P~&� ���=/ PN�1� ��,� %
P8< �� G�K_ + 3 ,��< �� �� �=���8�� �+A� ��½ %� ���5��� C % C
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
PN2 &�MNO* �*<� S��(A5� rR5�5 F@��j� ,��u@1 FB�§ F*z^ _� F���1� F��R�1� F*z�#P
.�1 Q�/ >1��e2�� ��"_Alice Rossi I «+�=�� ��V�� �2� ��=��� �� -!e n�AN� ^K�_ 43 P��M��� §����� G��K � �� G/ ,��^,y��
��_� ,J�j�k�� ¶V� b�A�� �=���8�� b�A� �=� C G��"� ��< ��� Q�/.�1 1�K;I �/ Q"M�� ��^w_ �=� C ��R���e }�#� §1����� mL? 1�K;I G/
� ��_� ,���+&� ��8= ��=� *1 �_��o� ¶V� Se�_ C Py?2V� §1����� G/ .� Pq�<83 ��I ,� _�1�,�� � _�12R C� � _���6q� � ���o� � _�����/� � =�5� C �H|_ EA#�� '(�"p3 ��%aI 2#� � §����� rA_ 1�K;I GI ,� �;� e� � _�O YR �§��s
��<;� ��=�e � �;�<;´3 F'6�/ ��%aI � K�� S<ps �2�2�� � _�) � 8eP�ºk�MYO*
P=���8�� P6�)� �=� C ��R� Y? >/�V�� !=��� 43 >���<V� ����² GIP;�<;�� >�M���� , �s2F_ Y��� >/�V� �? ����pV� mL? P:�; Y"")� º���
-'��q lI P=���8�� §1����� 1�K;I �%a �� PN�#���3 -�¿� * ���|N 7"8� �K�b�? �?� : 4< ©� 43 PAH+V� lI ����2�� }�#Æ_ �+(�� �O�V
��< �� �?� 8�_ G/ Yw8 � Y��� PN�Nk� FE"�� Y? ��=��� ÆER G/, $�"V� Y? ��/�
i1g Women in science and engineering, American scientist, 79 p404. i2g Rossi A.S., Gender and Parenthood , Gender and Lifecourse , aldine,
New York.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
? PAUs�� �� ��%a �� EKp; .L�� �=�V�� ��#N Ë!R/ G�K�N ��/ Y #_ !=���3 ��,8u Æ�de/ >/�V� G�K_ Gk -P���² Ë./ GI �>
>/���e! MNO* 1��� Go >1��e2�� ��"_Anne Moir �¥��e C" ¶V� Q =Brain Sex"
� ¿� �: " >�M��� P���¨ lI 1�z´3 �s ]#N �]R� ¶�1���� }� P��8�� �� �6� `Pd�2)� P���V� � _1�U� C G�� t20 +e P=���8�� P#8M��� P;�<;�� , �;I
«1�jF� �� Áy3 �G�� ë!e �s � 2c >/�V�� !=��� �� P#8M�� P��M��� §1����+, 3"MYO*
Z)�R�� �� ��R�g1�: mL& �K �_ ��2)� ª�w�� �,M6 3 >1�U)� �O�V ?? P=���8�� P6�)� 2c ��R��� �O�V ?P6A#�� '(�")��?? �� PpAjV
YK���k� �=���3��d;k� O��N/ �·�_ !;�� 1��e� ��"�G/ :" !H+��� P��"� -12R lI ��/ 2R t�;��� 1�eL�� 43 1�K;I G/ r�O ,>���<V� b2� �� ^8e
v6 �� �� �,��,� PN1�¤ C �6�:V� ��<N|� !e 1��6�N� Y #� §1�����.1�eL��* �¤ P�1�eL�� Q��"V�� J�ANk�3 �,A6� C �<s� �� G/ ��< �� ���
����� T�8��� �� ^dK�� Y #� �����<� '"B C §��a�� P:�; J�~�e��� �_ ��;�p����� ��1�,V�� ��12"�� ��;�p��� C ������ ���/ G�e �O´s ,P�1�eO
i1g Tannen D., you just don’t understand: women and men in conversation .
William Morrow. i2g Moir A., (1992) Brain Sex, chapter 11, Dell publishing New York.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
lI !j_ ��2#63 P��,y�� >1�2�� �� H/ ��\ � P����p���hŠ% '� �� Q�/ P"")� mL? !?�:�; b/ ,�,:(��; E��"_ 2 � r�O G� p�6V� Y���F� G/ t�;��
?1�eLe �,A��#;�"* ��/ Q(���� ,Q6u 4� P#��:3 µ� �� SM�� O��N/ Pu�K� 2Ò/ 1��e2��
µ� �� SMA� PV�#�� P#6:A� '8Nk�s��" :" b�#�� ����23 C �+A#�� !{�_ 2"��Ähh %e ¶� �� >1��j�� P3�,K�� P8j#�� �� py�� C ��s%�a� n� ? G/ lI
2 � ����N ,4< ©� 2"� ,��aZN�� P��� C �/ >���"��e PA"#�� ��q�y �� PN1�¤ �;´s S0 ��2 � !=��� G/ 7 #63 �"M �� !=��� ���y� 43 ���j�;� n� ? G/ ]8H >/�V� G/ 4� C ,P�q�� %3 �,"M 6F� �;´s 1��k� 'M 6� ��2 �� ,'M � %3 S0
�\�_ � �,�q��� P6R C� ,P�q�#3 t�2�k� 'M F� �� 48_ 2"�� ,'M V� �� ��A"� ��2,= �L8_ P �5)� 1�Ksk� �,A� vA<�_ ��2 � >/�V� G/ Pd�2)� ��s�y�e��
!� 2 � ��L8_ �¤ �de/ Pd�2)� Pc����� ����#� 2"�/"MNO* ?�� J�<� ��� P����� P��<��� SAM63 2pAV� ��w� � Æ� .1�/ ��MYO*
...ا���ار/4 �0 ا$�#م - ٣
°� !d� �eLA� G/� b%N�� C ����V� J�3 �� >2�%V� �� t2p�� �� Á�� � � t2p�� ,4d;k� ,��2�� C �C�KV� .���V� ����k� b�W; �� �� � ��
-b�W; 's� ^<� ����� b%N�� E<"�s -�� 3� !��e ,>2��� �P��� Q�� !��K��
ihg  ,7d;F/ b/ �eO ¶V� J��K� Pu�K� 2Ò/ 1��e2�� P�2"�½* i�g J��e �� ��N�8�R�� �#3: � ,7d;/ b/ �eO ¶V� *P��2�� §���� P8�K� ,[�� ��6�*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
"�; >/�V� !6B b%N�� C �%d� �· %s �/ Q8AV� �/ !e�V� ����N �,<�; P¦%#��, ¦��k� 43 ]A" _ ��� �?�,� �s2_ G/ �· ��*
!a2� G/ !8R >/�V� !=��� '�Aq ��� ���2� Y,� _ 7�� �,A� '� � G/ S=* ����k� �� 3 �� >2��� P��� � =�a/ ��� � ��:² � 6K� 1�j� b%N�� C
�:se �� 8�� lI �W �� S· !3 ,� P��)� �%a �� � �� 8�� �%a �� EK)�� !K>2�����!
�<� .L��e G�e �I� �! �=��� ���N ]8dF� �<� -�=� �� P��u *2� �� Y���M�� 5�5#�� 28� ¶y�� ^8#_!
���#�� !A��e �,A#=� P��y�� mL? ^8K_ �� m2,= 2pAV� !6#��G�?Ok� C �"�<� 7�� �,A� b%��� §��3/ E\U_� ��#_ 7�� b5As ,�?���N
^wj_ >���I �,#c�V, !e �LK?� ,� � ]=�a .L�� G�KV� C PR23 �,�1 EH 1�j�� ]6N F1� �&�� §��3k� ]6\U_� �?� 8� �/ �,#c�� �� ]=�a P,8u
�& >�a�<�� >�e�V�* ¦�ak �,6\U_� P,8yA� �=��aI C 7�� � ��j � 2pAV� G�e ��� P��<�
�� �� 'U���S?L��� ���)� Q8� C !=�; È2�2�� >/�6A� !j� G/ 2��� � K��,��q��*
>/�6A� §��� SAq !=/ �� !=��� 2e �� �p3 ���, G��2�� �� r�O C ���Ð F0 � �� !e�yV�� ����5����, Æ� C 7�� 5p�� �;/ n1�k m�K� Fa�d8*
�;/ E,V� �P��_ b%N�� b�W; C b�K�k� ]# F� �� �,#c�� C ]#c��
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�,AA#_� �?2j"� $� �� E,s� �& �W �� ��j� ,�<)� �,=� �� �pj��* ��1��V� !(�<��½�Ä !=��� �� �de/ >/�V� La�_ !(�<V� ���� �¥ P��<�
P����� PA��K�� b%N�� C ��V� P��W 6s ,�,� N� �,#R�� S<p3; G2� �� ��k ^8a -EK��Q���P��O��N��M���L���R�MNO*
...�78دة ا��)أة >,� ا�;:9 -� �78دة ا�)*( - ٤
�L? �,s !=��� >/�V� v��� PMA�¨ P~3 C Í#� �� �6,�� � Y�� EK� n12� ��� ,���K V�� !3 ��u�#V� «��;/ �� �#� �R�#_� ,�� !e C 2pAV�
!{k� C >/�V� G/ �,���N ��<��� �A<�� �� {/� >1�:��� ����/ �� >2#3v8Ue v8U_ %s §�<�� 1�#N/� ,��=��� ��)� P��,= !=��� 2 � �,s !{k��
Z<���* s �,W_ ��� 4_/���3 !=��� >��,u G�e �� P6K)� n12_ �� PMA�\V� P~8��
P6K)� P3��� G�^s PA#�� E&, � 'N� �� �?^� �pj_ G/ S· P#����s � �,#!{k� ��<s 1�8���3 7"8_ �� YwA_ G/*
!=��� >��,u �� [j �� �� >/�V� >��,u� >��,u ��8R b2� ^W; �L?��2)� C +e ,P��"�� S��{ �� .�28�� :Û [+�� v0 ;�(5 $�G4 ��� p
F��^ÜMYO* �¥ 2�# F� �� .�28�� >��,u !8"F_ %s!
ihg P��� ,rAV� >1�N :ghÅi* i�g ���� �3/ m��1*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
>Ú�)� P~8�� �� 2#3 .�28��sE�1�� §�q� E,#AN� E,R��N/�, �H�H/ �8_ Ú��)�s� �1+H�� �1��/�� .�28�� �,s�#� �, �� 7< �� v8U� %s
]R���* !=1 �L,s–.�28��− �%{/ �_��,u �j_ �, .�23 !=1 �#� �6�=� ���
2#3 �� ��� ����k� ��_� �6<_� !=��� P~8� J�R/ >/�V� ];�e �V� ,�ao ����,u ]A8FRb2"_ +e ���Z��� !A#� �?^� �� �K�*
��F_� >/�V� >��,u !8"_ � ?� ,!=��� �� �& v8c/ Y? !(�<� C �%d� >/�V��°��/� v8c/ �,s Y,s «�c��� !(�<6e ,PAK��3 !=��� >��,u*
��=1 >�� >��,u �� ���8R �de/� v8c/ «�c��� C >/�V� >��,ys* �32�� �� �!R �K�!
...��)أة >,� ا�;:9 -� د/� ا�)*(د/� ا - ٥
��Ma 7d;/ ]A� FR �As ,P�2�� C ��k� r�Le�, �PA<_ P�2�� [j; !_�"�� ��PA�"�� !?k, PH1�A� �eL�� x�� �� !R/ x�� �?�*
E?�d;/ ����3 ��V� b�W; �%�a�3 G��H��� � PH1��� Gk; C '� _ � >/�V� Gk -¦� �� b%N�� b�W; 2�� ��*
?>��V� '� �� !A"_ �L? !? �K�
�de �/ !R ��V�3 ��� _ ��� ]_�� >/�V�s ; �Ma* �,A�R �� �¥ !�"F� �,���<s � �26� >/�V� ]A�FR ���, >�� �,A�R �� �6�=� ���
��=1 G�A�"F� E,AKs*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�eL�� P"3�N ��V� P<N|63 PM8_�� ��k� ���2�� ��/; !R/ G�K_ >/�V� P�2s !6p�� !=��� QK#3 ��V� PA(�#�� �c� �� �H|� � �,<�; �%�;� Gk
��"� ��* !j� 7�� >���� �� �2#�� !=��� !a�� Se�� �s�� 2=�� � !{k� C� C E,<s� _ C E,U#3� ��=��� 43 G�K� �� QK#3 ,�Ma !�R lI .2#���
C �=5�� 2�u�s E,R��N/� E&+�/ l�k� C !R� P;�d��*
�j"�� S=�� �,s 26#�� !�"��3 .2#��� ��/�* � � P�2�� EK� �5 F� G/ ��1/ ���� 3� b%N�� ���_ !6� �� �%j( ��V� �
�!�\<s PA#A� m��2"_� �6,s*
Y���M�� 5�5#�� 28� ¶y�� ��"� :Û1 �� P 8� �U_ G/ ��1/ �O´s/ v(�� $R �MN�� v(�)� !{/ �3�s�,#U_ G/ !8, ��� ]M"N� ���? C �,�#c� �I�
b�,sk� �� ��"#�� rs�_ ]8���N�*
J�#�N�� !8R �� 8�� v8c �� 23%s ��"#�� C EN�F_ 1�Ksk� G�M��*
¾<�<� ���IJ�)� ]R� 9%<�� E��B G�<;, E��B ¾<�<� �� �Le �9�8� �;5��� P8 =k�3 >�A� �8AR C!Ü MNO*
�K� � Á5s ,4#A� -�R� ��/ �� �� �<�; �e�B �� v"�A�� E,��� !:#�� 2pAV�� Á5 F��*
ihg l�k� P#8M�� ,Y���M�� §��� �3 5�5#�� 28� ,!" �� [{�� !"#�� [{1 C P��}A�� PA"#��
�Ähh������� � A� �:)� 1�� ,*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Þúb�nÛa@óÔjí@òíbèäÛa@¿ë@Z_pbèj‘@†uìm@a‡b½@ @_pbèj‘@ýi@åí†Ûa@æìØíë@òîÈĐÓ@òÛ…þa@åØm@�@a‡b½@ @
:الرد
r� ��R ���: I?«1�y�� ������ 2�/ Q� �L? G ��|<�� �L? GI !3 � 3�#�N� b2� �� E ��}K�� P�AK��� PU"A�*
SM�� �� �8� �� 56� �3�y�� P8<; ��=� �� �Ae ��2�� b��R! -��/ !Ks P,8y� PA~c ��� P�+��� �s 2�*
�?�W�� ')� nZ�� P,8y�� �=���� �8�� 7�����l��k��j��i����h���g���|��{��z��y��x��w��v��u��ts��r���q��p��o��n��m
¢��¡�����~��}��®��� �¬��«� �ª��� ©¨� �§� �¦��¥��¤�� £»��º���¹�����¸��¶��µ´��³��²�������±��°��¯�ghi*
�3�y�� ./ G�23 EKpV�3 ®�� G/ xZ�V� �� �� G/ ] @ ���, ]s�� +s T� � �? .L�� !"#�� b�2\�N� 7 #� �� 1�8�a�� P��� �� P��N��� 2j"�
r�AK_��������Á��À�������¿��������¾��½����Ç���Æ��Å�������������Ä��Ã����Â�g�i* ��"�� !(�N ��<� G/ G�K63 !,©� �� �L��:
?���#�?1� T� ���� ,RJ�1 oum1�9 ��(1� v0 F*�t^ F1$� (j�! p �s�B s �� �� ,G+��� �� �� ��#� � G+��� �� Q6y��e !�� SAM� .L��
P8< 3 G+���3 �"_ P#q�R P��/ ��=�s ,�?º�3 P���=��� PU"��hÄÄ % �� �L?
ihg P��� ,G��6� �o >1�N :gÃi*
i�g P��� ,rAV� >1�N :ghÄi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�;+�I G�K�� ��1��a�� �;+�I +;I�� ��1��Mc�� G+�I �L?� ,Q6y�� ��=�3 G+��� !d� ,�;k J�"� �� J��H �A� S_Z� � .1��Mc� G+�I*
`�#�� �L? C Y�AK��� n��=�� �8{/ �V ���<V� �L¥ P��k� ];�e �As5�5#�� �3��e C !=� 5� �� ��"� �W;� , �7 #� :����Ä� � ÃÂ� �Á�� �À� � � �¿� �¾
�������������ghi*
� 'M V�� !"#�� �� �8�� 2#3/ �I !8"�� �L? �� P��/ SAM� ����´�¹� �¸��¶� � �µ���Ã� �Â��Á� � �À�� ¿¾� �½��¼� �»� �º
Ï��Î��Í��Ì��Ë���ÊÉ��È��ÇÆ��Å��Ä�g�i*
Ë43 2"s �s ;4 R�6A� �_��o l�#_ ��� G/ 2��� �V PA= Ppc�� �(��"��� ����� ��¥�y�V� �� 2:<s �8#�� 2��� �� ��/ ,��k�� 'A�3 � EA<F�� ��|� Y�
�� PA6K�� �;�p8N �� �?2=�/ �� G�p�� ��Ò1 �� �K� ,m���� �;�wq �� 1}� �I �,#8�� �� ,��6R [#UF_ �� EKpFV� �� 7wM_ � ��¥�y�V� mL? G/ �;�p8N
�¥�F� G/ ��1/ ������q��p��o��n��m��l��k��j��i�� � �h�� �g��¡�����~��}� � �|� �{� �z��y� �x��w� �v� �u� � ts��r
±��°��¯��®����¬��«��ª���©¨��§��¦��¥��¤��£¢���������¶��µ´��³��²»��º���¹�����¸�g i*
ihg P��� ,b�#;k� >1�N :g¼i*
i�g P��� ,>�"8�� >1�N :ghh¼i*
i g P��� ,G��6� �o >1�N :gÃi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
_´ÔîÜÛ@Ý•ìm@ü@òÛ…þa@êˆç@æc@ÙÛ‡@óäÈß@Ýç@åØÛ@ @� 7�3 p !
GI P#6N� ,PA"� P��/ Y? b%N�� P��/ !{/"PA";" P�2{1� ," ��23� j�� S(�:�� 'A�" P��Ms� ," P��/A-Periori" P��2�N�� ,
" C ¦�� �� 46AK�V� �#3 �,�2\�<�P"3�<�� P��k� �� �,�A�, ];�e GI�Pppj��� >2N���� ��N�"�� �#3 �,s"*
�,��6� �� �%Us b%N�� Ppj3 Y "�� EA#�� S=�� P��k� mL? ���o!
���s/ >�"3 �I E,� <�/ ]#M";� ��� ��2pAV� �� ���@� V� §�N ]��R ���PM<�<�� ��N �,���/ E,�#N/ �� Y��� P��k�!
�6 y5�� (^ F1$�� $�+i $�+i ¹1 ,@�� (^� ,� ,*@R�1� p6 %�� ¡3� p �7�*�� ( �u�1� £��m�� y3^ �� � 3WB�� F�(�� ¡�(81� ¢�?5 h� Z�.�� ��1��� ���5�R1�
�i��1�5 ;(J�1�� [*~1�5 �3�\��P
?P�1��Mc� P��/ G+��� P��/ !? �K�
lI ¦��0 � !�� �? .1��Mc�� !�2�� !d� ,!"; ���B �/ !"� �+�IQ6y�� ��=� * �I �%{/ §�<F� �� ,¿"� �!6� �3 'A#�� � P��k� �� «� �� �L,s4;�:V� PA6©!
Y "�� G+��� 43� P�1��Mc�� P��k� 43 G��u�!
J�"� �/ �J��H �A� S_Z� �� !"#�� S:0 ��k�s * ���o C E(�R ��d��� �%Us P��k� ���o �,�A� �� �%Us �?���o ��!
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
b�2\�N�3 P��k� ���o ���o C �W ��3 ��I !j_ G/ !,<� Y "�� G+���sQ� �� ��? �� 1�j�;��� >�M�A� ��";�� �/ !"#�� * 2�_ � ���O C P��k� �K�
��8V� �W �� ��:63 .1��Mc�� G+��� !
lI ��{�A� P��k� C !"#�� �+�I �� 23%s ��:6s �I� ,Y "�� G+��� G+��� 1��Mc� 2�� � �W ��*
P��k� �� E&�"� ��"�I �� E,�2; -�� �� P��"�� b�� 1��K�� b2 � ��� �� "� � �;+�I 2�_ Y������Ç���Æ��Å�������������Ä��Ã����Â���������Á��À�������¿��������¾��½�ghi*
� ,[AK��� �"Aa C �� P <s C �� N� ,P6K)� ���a [AK��� C �� N !#= �� º��� , �§�� Y�a �� �� EA#� +3 �2�N� � Æ� F5(����� ,�,"(�R� P6K)�
EA#� +3 ��2�N�� �� ���0 � �3�:� !,· �¤*
��R �6s: !{�3 �!?�= �,s ,.1��Mc�� G+��� 2�_ ��8V� �W �� P��/ G ����/� J�<)� T� �� [AK���$� ��*
[AK��� T� � !"#��s, k� �� n� ? G�e ��� ��1��Mc� �+A� S=�� �� P�� �!"� �+�I G+��� SAM_ �� �W �� ��:63, J�"� �� �J��H �A� S_�_ ��*
ihg P��� ,rAV� >1�N :ghÄi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A الفصل اخلامس أدلة اإلميان
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
يأيت هذا الفصل كمسك ختام
لكتابنا بعد جولة يف شىت مناحي
اإلحلادي، فما أردنا أن نغلق الفكر
الكتاب بعد التخلية من اإلحلاد إال
بتحلية بشيء من أدلة وجود اخلالق،
وحملات من سرية خري الربية صلى اهللا
عليه وسلم، مث شيء من دالئل نبوته
!صلى اهللا عليه وسلم
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
éãbzj�@ÕÛb¨a@…ìuë@òÛ…c@ @F*@��1� S��(�B� � �� �;�p8N '��� ��=� �� �<�; f�F� � �;��=� G/
2 Á=� F� � � GOI �<� 3: ��a��`��_��^��]����\��[��Z�ghi* � �ت ا���د/� ا��;<��� � V���V و-� ا�� 1}2 G/ ��c��� m^w_ 2�� .
(���e� b2���_�L3 � ë�MU� �6©� �8{/ �L�� , �p8A� G�K�� ¦1�a ¦��\A� P(�� � G��e/ 2pAV� xZs�s ,m��=�� -S8N ��–� �3��= Q� �L? G/ ��, +;I�
��=1IA�!(�<�� ����� .L�� C�#V� SAM6 � !<A<_ ��=1� �� P=1� lIP�8�� J��= lI � A{�� � Y(��!− P �2�� ����/ Pp{ �� ��|V� 2e�_�����c
��i��h��gf��e���dj�g�i* � » �� ��� �M��A<P6 ���#"�� و-� ا@د�� ا$/��� � ا�;<,����3 ��= �� P"s���
Pppj��* b%N�� C P" �� P��<�� �_1�{ C �,W� «��� �3 ��= .L�� 2����� ��2;�
.5��� ��/ .�Ms ��2; �?�, P"�%�� P_�?%�� �%�2#��� ]=�a 2"s �L�� Pp<V�� P���,�� �� E����"� ��s´e G�6� �3 7N��� Y ��e�� ���_ 2� ��
��3 Ps�j�� �_2"� C Y�%N�� 1�y V�, ��,�� ç�#� �,�?�u Y����4p<V�� ,%=��� ���ps .L�� 2�2©� 1�y V� �� SN� �� +3 +,�;��� '< _ G
�2_ t20 ` �OI ��I ��;��2�� «�8_/ !e JL:N P31��V ��º !a P���²� «2j��
ihg P��� ,1�M�� >1�N :g ½i* i�g P��� ,1�M�� >1�N :g Éi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P" �� b%N�� >2"� �� J�"��� ,� 3 4��ak� 4_2"#�� ��Ae G/ ��8HI�� � ��U�/ � �+�� �{k� Pwj�� C �� 2��_ ��P(�, ��, Y��� �� <p���s
F/ ��2�� C 4Aa�2�� ¦��s/ ��"�� Â� � �, � �K� ` 4_2"#�� �� ]Aa�2�2©�*
;+��� P��k� ��� ��5:#� �� �,s��1 ��� ���8 �� ��8H � �U�/ PA" �� P�� ����8;� ���%�� ���o� �? P��N��� Ppj3 EA<��� C .�?�©� 1�#V
Y8 �� §2{, P6_ �3� b%N�� ¶u ��"� ��#(�1 C �� �Ò1"��8 �� ��8H�": Û G�K� G/ ��I >�8 �� Y�2 F6s ,>�8 A� 2��k� T��� Y? >5:#V� ]<� §2{/
2R� ,4A?�©� !,=/ �� �I �L¥ �L? Q8A F� �� 43O�K�� JLe/ �/ 4R��j�� §�"y;� !8R G� Ë�8FV�� P·2a� '�2j�� �K3 ª/ ��d�/ G���k� G�"3�<�� EAN/
,Go�"��3 .2p���� Sw��3 1�8a��� �6"��****2{ EA#� $� �� �� ^de � § 7N��� ,P�8�� P�o %3 }\FV�G��6� �3 E& ��R� �� lI ��= �V: Y AN1/ �� GI*
]8?O� P·2 ���� �eO �V Y8 �� r�Le� ,����� E& �,WF� G/ !8R �R2{ ��6A�lI �3 PR1���R !s�; �3: 7N�� ®/ .L�� $��� �� �? �L?* ,��: �� r�Le�
��1�Ú �+A� �R2{ ��6A� �K3 �3/�� G�s�#� ��� �3 ��= +3 E?}a/ �V � �R2{ � ^� �� ��;��/� ��1�Ú �+A� S=�� �(��"�� �� r�O 2����� }a� ,§��{ �;�3 �
>1�»��3 �R2{ �¥ ��#F� �(��R �3 GZ"_ 2R $� �� ���o �� ��,:V�, [Ks §2{/ �? � Æ� �I ���"� � .L�� ��k� �L? !d63 }a/� ��;��/� �R2j3 �� F� �63
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
E¥Le/ �/ $� ��, �;/ G�6A#� E?� ��d�� G�� ��k� [ j�� ��Üghi* �/(Aا� �BC:و-� أد�� ا� G/ �¥ 2=�_ ` G�KV� }�� G��5�� }� �,Ae P��8��
-G+�I ^w3 �:; �� P��R ��3, �� ¶�1�_ ��#F� �� G�<;I ��2�� 1�qI C ��� ��=�3 G+����*
!=/ �� �I `�#�� ��"� ��1�²� `�#�� ���<As �c�_ `���2A� QN����* PÀ23 PU"e �� ��=� 1�qI C 1�2� �L? � ��� lI �MN1/ L � 'M V��;
Y"����� Î1|V� ��"�ân1�_�A3£ :" ,G�j� %3 G2� ¶�1���� C �2=� 2"�23�#� %3 G2� �23/ 2=�_ ` �K�� ,$1�2� %3 G2�� ,1�jR %3 G2��"
sP��<² P�/ PUR �� ��=� �� Pw8j�� C �,A� $� �� �� �Ms Y��� P��8��u������t��s��rq��p��o��n��m��lk��j�g�i**
�� >��8� ��� +;I� �� ��=� ��� �K� ` E,���R/ �� ��8;k� «�z�, >^,y�� P�5A:;�� P8_�K�� ��"_ �L��â�;�Z<�1/ ��1�e£ ^ak� �¥��e C
"�O�V �� �k� P��8�� 7#<�?" Q� G�<;�� G/homo sapiens
sapiens, �? +;I�homo religiosus �;��� Q� G�<;��s� �%R�� +;I� Y �� G�<;I*
P(��5��� P��k� ��� :G�KA� P"R2�� >���#V�*
ihg ,P6_ �3%� ,���8 �� ���8Hg½à i* i�g P��� ,>�"8�� >1�N :gh ¼i*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@æìØÜÛ@òÔîÓ†Ûa@ñŠíbȽa@ @Fine-tuning of universe
,P#8M��� P(��5��� ]3��d�� ��� P"R� >���#63 ��=��� lI G�K�� �,@ G�K�� !�a� �5= 1�A� 1�A� 1�A� �� �5= 1�2"63 �, � ]3�H !�a� �� Y����
/28� G/ !8R P;�K�� PU8�� PA��� 2 � [R��� �/cosmic egg * � e��? ���N ^,y�� Y(��5��� ��"�Stephen Hawking C �3��e:
" �2= P=�� P�º G�K�� �N�_ P�º GI l�k� P;�d�� C ];�e �� ��/ P=1� lI �G�K�� 1�,@ �� �<�; ��� G�K�� 1��� �5= 1�×A� C G�A� �� �5= �� !R/
!8R/ ��)� �#c� lI !j� G" ghi* P"R2�� >���#V� Q� 3 PWpA�� Q�; C ��,@ P(��5��� ]3��d�� !e�
�%d6s ¦�)� v8U��� : IIIIQQQQHHHH G�ZK��� PA�eElectron mass !d�Ä*� % G��_� �� PA�e ��
Neutron mass > Ë1L�� ���K�� PN�"�� PA�K�� Y? mL?� ,* IIIIRRRRHHHH G�_�}�� PA� Fe ];�e ���Proton � �A� Y? �¤ !"H/3 G�×Ä*� % ,v"s
��;��_�; lI ! Ëp N �;´sNeutrons n�<��� �� 5:#N �����3� , P8< �� ];�e ��� ,.1L�� ¦O�6 �� 1�, N� >�� �� ��� 1�2_ Y��� ��;�ZK���3 �,W_ �As ,G�� �A� Y? �¤ �%AR !R/ G�ZK��� PA�e lI G�_�}�� PA�e 43
��/ ];�e ��� ,> ��"�<� �b�:; �,W_ �As G�� �A� Y? �¤ �%AR P6W;k�
ihg  ,� e��? ���N ,G��5�� ¶�1�_ 5=��h�h*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P)� �� (�K�� ��%a C P�^�y���DNA ؛ �� 26�#_ P�^�y��� P6W;k� Gk ��1O� ,^�y��� P6W;/ C P =�Z �� 2���"�� ! ÝKyF_ Y��� G�3�K�� ��1O G��_
�8j� 7�� G�ZK��� PA�e �� G�_�}�� PA�e G��_ lI ¦��B G�3�K�� G�3�K�� >�"�<� >1O**, Y)� �(�K�� �,W� �� �����3�*
IIIISSSSHHHH G´s 4=�12&� �� G�_1O Ep�A_ ��2 �Ä*à % 4=�12&� PA�e �� Y? PA�K�� mL? ];�e �� ,PR�q lI ��p�_Ä*É % �� �23Ä*Ã% , G�_�}�� G´s
YR�3 ��,@ �V� ,S<ps 4=�12? ��� G�K�� !W�� ,G��_� ��3 Ep�A� �� Y? PR�q lI P� ��p�V� PA� FK�� ];�e ��� ,z� #��Ä*¼ % �� ��23Ä*à % �8{k,
�� lI .�|N .L�� ��k� ,P��wA� ��#�º b�p��� �� ��1�s 4=�12&� ����a 43 G�K� G/ b5A� ER���s ,>�)� �#� !p�<�s ,G�K��Ä*É % �Ä*¼* %
IIIITTTTHHHH 3O�©�� P<q� w���,K�� ��"�� 43 P8< �� Y? Ph :hÄ $/ÅÄ �?� , �K6� � �N�u §�s��3�#�N , ��"��� P��"�� P��� �� ��"�� 43 §���� r�Le
G�<;�� JL� Y��� x1k� G/ � cZs� ��� ,P��wA� ��,� §�s ��U�/ �? ,P3O�©� �� G�<;�� G� G´s ,P��"�� P��� �� ��"��3 �3L:3 ]��R ,P�3O�©� ��"3
� P(�� ���#FN x1k�E:; G�A ! �� �� !#· .L�� ��"�3O�©L¥ P� �� [#U��2�2y, ���"�� :��� ا���ال ا�ن
��"�� ����� C S?��� §1���� �L? G/ �� ? >2�2y�� >�"�� mL¥ P��"�� P��� �� ���M# F� �� �� ,l�Fk� �+<©� 1�,@ T�� �� Q� !!** Y&�� ��2��� �;I
P"(���� P�� #��3* IIIIUUUUHHHH ��"�ân1+:_ Qe��£ Max Tegmark YK���k� ��;�K�� `�� :"
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
3 �A� Y? �¤ [#c/ P<q� w���,K�� ��"�� ];�e �OI×Å % ��:�;� ,v"s P<q� w���,K�� >�"�� ��� �OI P:� �� Q�; �8j�N� ,���K_ 1�s Q6y��
���<� 2 � P�� #3 > Ë2# F� �28_ P#8M�� ]3��H GI ,�A� Y? +� ];�e �OI� ,�� � �����3� ,4=�12&� G�K�� �� G�� �A� Y? �¤ !R/ P�#U�� P ���� �� ��"�� � ��_� �� �+<= G´s �%AR ��R/ ];�e �OI� ,��e 1�8� ��� G�K�� !WN
neutrinos PR%6#�� ���#�<V� >1��w� �� 5:#�N − �s�;�3�<��Supernova − z� #�� !"� _ �� �����3� ���#�<V� ¦1�a >�pA� P�%��
PR%6#��– >�:� FV� b�: ��−" ghi* @@@@IIIIVVVVHHHH ;�e �� P3O�©� ��R] �V G�� �A� Y? �¤ �%AR ��R/� >�� ]R�w�N
P N ��o >�� �� �de/ r�O 2#3 G�K��N Y��� Q6y�� * !3�R ^� v8c �L,s%�=��A� �/ ��5�ax1k�� ���+<�� ��23 G�p8<s ,!!!*
��� �L��â2 ��KN�N �1�;��£ �1�s��N P#��:3 P��W �� ���5��� O��N/ P;�K�� ]3��d�� �� � _�M# F� G/ P"(���� 1�_�k� P��W � QN|V��– P8< �� !d�
G�_�}��� G�ZK��� 43− , �� PA"�< F� �,Ae� 4KN Ps�� �� �,Ae ["_�#8�� �,U#3, >�)� t�2�´3 v"s �6<�� 7R%�_ �<�; ]R��� C�, F ã w_� Ý�/
M# F�7 �%Us YR%���3 �& �6<� �K� ` PA"�<� ��y; Y��� ��M#V� mL? �� ��
i1g space.mit.edu/home/tegmark/multiverse.pdf.
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P;�e P��W � 7�� �/ >�� ��·I P;�K�Ighi* � cZs� ���; � ;/ PWpA� S�� �%d� $/1 !a�� >��=�V� ��1L�� P��1 C
^w{ $�3�, >�K�� E:p3 ^j� �p3 $�32�� $/1 ^8K_ lI P=�p3 � ;´sPc1k�, >^w{ b2R >�e > Ë1L�� E:� ��:�� �� P��)� rA_ C� ** ��1L�� O�V
? Í?2V� E:)� �L¥ > Ë1L�� !a�� >�� �� P��1 C S��; � ;/ � cZs� �OI, >� Fe ^8K�� P=�p3 � ;´s
S#A� E:p3 ^j�� P"3�<�� b2"�� ��:�� �As PWpA�� rA_ C� ^8e b2R >�e P��wA� >^w{ 1�8 F� P8� >1L�� >��; E:� ** ��5 F= .��<� > Ë1L�� >��; E:ps� ��
> Ë1L�� E:� �� �5 F= 4�%3 >�� ** >�� �� C �,Ae >1L�� PA� Fe 2=�_ r�O ���ÇÇ*½ %*
�C v"s >��=�� �,Ae §%6 :واFن ا����ؤل ا��7م S#A� PA�e G�K_ [e�8��� � � 1�8 F� P8�R ? b�×_ È��s Y
!3�"� C >�� �� PA�e 43 G����� �L?� !Ky�� �L¥ .1L�� b�W �� �L? GI t�2p3� G�K�� !Ky�3 �6<� .L�� 2���� b�W �� �? >1L�� !a�� �,6:�
P(��5��� �%������* sk� �L, �K6F� � �� ãj��3 �H�2� J�#�N� F 32_ �;I Y(��y#�� v8� �/ Ps2
Fb�K�I� FS:�� F{ á Á#� �"Aa ���o �32�3 1��6�N�3 �;�p8N �� ���� �L�� ,
i1g http://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/smolin_susskind04/smolin _
susskind.html.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�_12R 2?��u�! P"R2�� >���#V� 7,� 63 ���= Y���� � ;�e C P;�K�� ]3��d�� ��o �LK?�
,� ��� G�5_��� >�)� 1�{ !e ��_ �p3 v8U��� !d6� �, � ]3�H !e� ��K�� ]3�d�� �? ]3��d�� mL? «�1/� �_�O 2p3 >5:#�Cosmological
constant �A� ��{ �� �5= �� !R�3 ��6R ]�A�a� �� .L��h� EH ��{h �A6e�3 G�K�� 1��� 2����� �� P=1� !d� ^dK�� ��� ]3��d�� �� �?^�� ,
d�� G�_�}�� PA�e !d�� ,��V� G�A�� >1L�� E:� !d�� >�� �� E:� !** , ��I ,G�K�� �,@ �� �I� P�� #3 v8c� P"R� >���#� ��2�I �#8��<� G/ 23� 'A� GOI
P�� #3fine tuning of the universe P6AK�� mL?�fine tuning of
the universe �q �� ���5��� lI ]Aa� ��2�� '��q �� Q�� ���5��� '�* �? �L? ��o �6c �� 2pAV� �� �<�; x��� .L�� Y"")� ��Ku��
E# V� �Ku �I 7"8� �� ,� j�� v8c� 'A� P��1 ]8d_ Y��� P��k�� �(��"���8� C �8� �,�U�� PU"�� !?�� �/*
ومن األدلة البيولوجية وجود الخريطة الجينية داخل كل كائن حيومن األدلة البيولوجية وجود الخريطة الجينية داخل كل كائن حيومن األدلة البيولوجية وجود الخريطة الجينية داخل كل كائن حيومن األدلة البيولوجية وجود الخريطة الجينية داخل كل كائن حي
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
òîäî¦a@òĐ튨a@ @ 1�,@ PAU#� !e� �8�� ��R�q !Ks ,PAp�<V� PAU#V� Y? >�)�
v<3/ �� PM<8� >1�{ ��� �� _ G/ �M�<_ ` PR%6#�� E, (�K� !e� E,s1�#� 2pAV� � �"� EH ,Ps2j��3 ��,@ >�)� G/ 2pAV� xZ�� r�O ��� ,>�)� 1�{
1�K_ � >5:#� �,A#© >�)� >�y; Â�s 'U_ 1�"s ��"�� �L? Ps�\<3* 5 e��� �1�y��1 ��"� :" <ps ��y; 2R �,s�#; +e >�)� �� >2��� >�� S
x1k�"ghi* ��y �� P��<��–>�)� 1�,@ − �,���p�N� EA#�� 2e|� P��<� Y? Ps2j��3–
1�M��� J�3 C !8R �� � A �js +e−* !��? 2��s ^,y�� ¿K��� 2pAV� �%d� �Z#�Fred Hoyle �L& m2{1 G/
`�#�� >2y3 5�À m��)I !#· "greatly shaken" �3��e C ��"� +e" �� 1�M_��U���" Evolution from Space, x�Zs� �? P(��y#�� x�Zs� G/�
È1�s ���?� G� �* is evidently nonsense of a high order
G��1�M��� E�5� +e x1k� �� >�)� >�y; ��c�s G/ !��? 2��s 1�"� 2R� ,[\N ¿"� G� = Y? �2R b�� C !��? 2��s bhǼ� �3��e " �� 1�M���
��U��� Evolution from Space " �W �� 2#3 ,YKAV� 2,#6A� >�p6e��R� x1k� �� >�)� ��y � !~U�� �+���� m}��� �� lI: " !Ky3 � #3�_ ���
ihg  76�k� ����<�� �;�{ Š*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P��<V� mL? C E"�<�� ��8� ,��� Y6A#�� ./��� P���¨ �� ���3 ��8; G/ G b�W;� $�R �� ���B +3 P=���8�� ���V� G/ m���� ¦�� �N� lI !j; ,2(�<��
>�6H G�K_ G/ S·YeO E6j_ , �� ^K���� Y K6� ��a/ P�+��� ./ 2=�_�¥"ghi*
�+�5;�� P��6� v"s �� ��j)� P{�s G´s ,!��? 2��s ��3�<) � �"8Ms lI !j_ P� PAa v<3khÄ $/ÅÄßÄÄÄ � �Ae G�K�� C ��1L�� �2� G/ ��
��:�_hÄ $/¼Ä* the chance of obtaining the required set of enzymes
for even the simplest living cell without panspermia was
one in 1040,000. Since the number of atoms in the known
universe is infinitesimally tiny by comparison (1080).
����� !��? 2��s �� �<� PWpA�� mL? C� :" �6��8�� v"s Q� �;/ >�Ks .�)�biopolymer ��� !3 �,W� G/ �K6� ,P)� PA\A� EW V� ���;}��
���&� �� «�; �;/ �c���� �� ,l�k� x1k� P~8� Y(28�� ��<)� C Ps��jV�312R ��/ ��"*
The notion that not only the biopolymer but the
operating program of a living cell could be arrived at by
i1g Hoyle, Fred, Evolution from Space, Omni Lecture, Royal Institution,
London, 12 January 1982; Evolution from Space (1982) pp. 27–28.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
chance in a primordial organic soup here on the Earth is
evidently nonsense of a high orderg1i .
Q<;��s Y ��%�� � �U�/ �,�I !{�_ P:� �� mL? G/ �W A� ]s%�� ��� r��eCrick Francis �3��e C :" �,�#8q� ���y; �,<�; >�)� Life
Itself: Its Origin and Nature" G/ 1 ��R 2"s , Y�@� 2��� 4_��3 >�y; §��� ��K� P��p�N�� �� JÚ �? Ps2j��3 v<3hÄ $/�ÉÄ �2� G/ ��
��:�_ � !Ke G�K�� ��1OhÄ $/¼Ä G/ �� v<3 Y�@� 4_��3 C �L? , �%(�R r��e Q<;��s �Z#� P��, �� C� ,�� _�}�� ��o �3 �� (�K�� 7;�/ :
"�V� EA#��3 �A< F�� ,[j � !=�e �� -�Ì3 1�RF/ G/ �M�N/ ,G�� � � 9�>5:#� >�)� >�y; G/ ,'M V�*"
"If a particular amino acid sequence was selected by
chance, how rare an event would this be؟ "This is an easy exercise in combinatorials. Suppose
the chain is about two hundred amino acids long; this is,
if anything rather less than the average length of proteins
of all types. Since we have just twenty possibilities at
each place, the number of possibilities is twenty
i1g Sir Fredrick Hoyle and Chandra Wickramasinghe, Evolution from
Space (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1984), p. 148.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
multiplied by itself some two hundred times. This is
conveniently written 20200 and is approximately equal to
10260, that is, a one followed by 260 zeros * " Moreover, we have only considered a polypeptide
chain of rather modest length. Had we considered longer
ones as well, the figure would have been even more
immense. The great majority of sequences can never
have been synthesized at all, at any time"g1i .
"An honest man, armed with all the knowledge
available to us now, could only state that in some sense,
the origin of life appears at the moment to be almost a
miracle, so many are the conditions which would have
had to have been satisfied to get it going"g2i . �� P��W � Y? !3 ,S<ps >�� PUR Q� >�)� 1�,@ G/ r�O lI [c/
v8U��� 2"#��� ��=1� ��/, �(�e ��/ �� PA��e P ©� PM��� ��,@ 2"s�(�K�� >��u !6B PM��a Y?�, !e� �?5��_ E�� �� �,=��0 Y��� ����A#V�
�(�K�� �,W� �� �I� P ©� PM���3 76<_ >��u C Y)� �(�K�� 1�,@ !8R
i1g p. 51-52. i2g p. 88.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Y)�* P ©� PM����"b� ©�" �� v�� Y?DNA !e >��; !a�� ��=�V�
n��%a �� PAa* �� >1�8� v���� �L?� ¦����e–J��e− �� PAa >��; !e !a�� 2=��
� ,n2<= ��%a¥¦����K�� �L P�@��� r_���W V PA��e P��3� r_��{���" Y��� 4_�}�� P6e� n�#u «�;� ,r(�U�/ [(�@�� r � G��� r��q P3�,K�� PU8 �� P�º� n2<= >5,=/ EKB Y��� 4;��"��� ,r_%U� �,=��B
C b2�� ¶c ��2#�� ,r3�j�/ C C ��;���&� ��sI ��2#�� ,r8AR � j_ P"��q� P��)� r�(�@� !K� 'R� !j�_ r�O !e S;�= lI ;n�2� [(�@���3 ±�¯ �� !e� ,��k�� ¦��a��� EU&� P6W;/� r�� ���e
n2<© P=���8�� �**¶�I* K�� C 2=���1��M�� ���p3 Â�a !��e !js J��X x�#��� !d� ,
.L��� ��� [�5 � 2�2u Ñ+K;�� b2�� ¦1�¨ 'Aw_ PMA= !6� Y�2�<� !���� >2� �� >2"#� P��W �� ,2R���� ���#�� �s G5\�V� b2�� ¶U� ��pMA�
r���/ C Ñ+K;I !6#� P���2�� PW) b2�� vwU� !_�R T�8? t20 � 7��[�5 ��*
J��K�� C 2=�� � �U�/−¦����K��− P�%�� ��5,:���3 'A#�� !��e !js � j_ P"��q �� .��0 J��K��s ,P~3�k� !d� �}e �q�\V x�#��� PW)
Y��s2�� E<©�G �/IGG 76<� .L��"P#s2V�� ���12V�� >�yV� P8�e" , Y��s2�� E<©� � j_ P"��q�A �/IGA �� !e� ,P{�� b�,V� S��{
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
M� ��W) �I �,��,� �,W_ �� Y��� P��s2�� �+W ��� ���* G��L&� C rA"�� 'U�� C P=���� r ��� /28_ 7�� �20 ¦����K�� �U�/ t�2� P"��q v8U��3 J��K�� [j�� ,SyV� C n�#u� 2#:��� C n2A=�
PR2�� 7,� 63 r�O* J��K��–¦����K��− r � �� !e .�0� E\c*
>1�8#�� °�� ,®���A#� ���² �? J��K�� �L?* ��A#� ���² J��K���,Ae r_���A#� G5¯ ®�*
�1s k6 -�� b�W 3 2=�_ ����A#V� mL? G/ ;"5��_" coding 4�� 5�Z�� rs E��decode P"3�<�� ����A#V� �,W_*
b� ©�� �� v�� �/ DNA Ô6�hÄÄÄ �R��3 2A�½ÄÄ !K� Pp�{ 2A�− ��� 1�A� − P��<� C >��=�� �,Aeh ��hÄÄÄ Z6AAV� ��
F� �<�; �� [�AhÄÄ PA� >��; !a�� P�� [�/* G�A3 �,�#N C §��_ ����A#� !60 $�32�� $/1 E:� C .L�� b� ©��
Pu%s >��Š�:= * Y��31 ^�y_ b�W 3 >��y F� J��K�� �L? !a�� ����A#V� ���C G T A *
P6R��� ����A#V� �c��− PR2��� v8U�� 7,� 63 P��A#� G�A3− , Y��� ¿"� v8c lI P=�p3 P��A#V� mL? !? ,��2R EA� '��a ,� �"�� b2\�<F�N
?�?���p�� �G�;-و �/�Bو� � ������<1ة و-)آ�C و- � ; Gا� �/(Hا� IJوه!
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
'��a �? P ©� PM��� mL? '��a G/ ��"_ 'M V�� !"#�� ��À23 v<3/�2��� ��2R EA� EK�, �2_ P ©� PM��� PwAs ,2��� EAK�� �?��1� G/ ��
P;�;�R �& ��2?/ Y?� � �"8<� >��y� ��2?/ lI !j_ P ©� PM��� G/� �P{�aPA��e*
�3��e C G��;�� !K��� ��"�"P�/ C P��W; 1�M��� " :" P""� E,�; Yek� EA� ��ye .L�� �p �� �� >�)� � A� P~�5©� ���/ F; G [�/ PA� }K
c G�A�[#, YMw� G/ �M�<� �p3 §%6� ��M 6e PA� �28�N �L¥��; !d� >^8e P �2� n1��G2 � �/, �I �,A� 2:; �?� jp�_� PA� �� � 3ZR� �O
>^wj�� ��3��8�� 4�%�, �I � <�;/ 2: N ��3��8�� mL? 2�/ ��a� � � 7 <_ �O'(���� 2"#���� Py?2V� �=��� K��� �� `�� C"ghi*
Ps��&� P "V� P ©� PM��\A� L� _ �I >�)� ���, � "� �� P��� �,A#· �L?��H|V� P�{ �� P��� �Hk� P�js ,���?*
PM��a ���I ]B ,��;�R Y��� ���? �� � 'R� b�W 3 ^<_ >�)�s�28�� L � v8U�� 7,� 63 ��,@ P =!
����A#� >2��R .��B P� PAa >��; !e�Database �� !e !6y_ �+�5;I ¦��;I� «�s�� PpAN/� b�,�� ��U�/� [(�@� �� Y)� �(�K�� �=��0
P��� ����U�� P�� � b�<=/� Pjj\�� �� _��3� P��+e �����– C��� ��1�A� PH%H �� G�K�_ P� PAa !e !a�� ����A#V� >2��R G�<;��−
i1g P.242 Theory in Crisis.
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
e/ Í, _ r;´s E) P0� !e�_ ��2 �� P��N�V� �� P\<; G�A3 P(�� �� �dP;�M�}��*
F*����^ F*�*D� Ft���� l`�� ³y F_ Y,s 2"#���� v8U�� C P��� 4;��R, .�|� EK²� 'R� G�;�R 's� E6j� �,66{ 2R 1��V� 1���1 �/ S8M�� 1�;�<s 2R Ñ��� 1�;�N G/ ��"; ¿"#�� $�"�� Q� 3� ,�A=/ �� � F{ .L�� x�w�� P;�"_ b2\�<� Ñ���s �2²� EK²� 'R� Y�@� G�;�R .�|� E6j� �66{
�2j��3 �R��V� 2�2p�� P���echo location * 5 e��� �1�y��1 2pAV� ��"� :" ���(�M� >�wj� >5,=/ Ís��� !6B
P;�ZK��� ���� �� b5� �,a�¨/� ,>2"#V� >5,=k�3 �#_ Y��� Q<:����?�3 Pq�8UV� ��2{k� �� `�� >��u r�� b5A� +3 P�1�3 P��3 ]��3 2R Ps
echos �pj�� ]R��� C, C P_�{ §���� ��=�V� «�#uI G�"_� P�}� Y,s��P3�AMV� ��?��"ghi*
1�M��� 1�qI C ^<���� �� Ù#�<_ 2"#��� P��� ����W V� mL?* A6� P�1�3� � ���W; PK ² P ©� PM���s ��^�y_ v8U�� P���� ���*
E,s 2R 1�;�<�� E6j6s"�A3�2�� >�?�@" c��1 ����#� C �6,s �� �}�� P,1�;�<�� ¦��;� � �"�� �,Ks E_ �� �,©� E6j_ C 2 Ý< F= 2R E6jV� E,�s �K
,!6#� [e E,�� � �<�; �,©� �ZK�� z� � �,©� .�0� �p3 >2"#� P; G1�"_ �K_���_�/ P6(%V� ��2���� lI P:� �� ��B� ,1����A� �����_ �– !� �Le
ihg  76�k� ����<�� �;�{�*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P��<��3 − ��12R ��2� C v8U��3 � K�� ,2"#� b2\�<V� ��3�<)� b�W;� ,�pj�� �p �� �� P��{�� Pd�2� P;�ZK�� z� � �� ^w{ §�2 {*
YMM\��� EN��� �28�� L �� �¥ 2=�� P ©� PM��� � ? !e� �%{��A� 1������ �,=��0 Y��� >2"#V� P6W;k� !e� �A3�2�� >�?�@ ����#� *** ¦��B !?
?EKpV� ^32���� 5:#V� 'A�� P&�� >12"�� ��8H� Ps�cI lI P�2"V� mL? �M�<� �� �� �� � P#8M�� C >2"#V� ���� C ���&� E6j��� GI
3�#�N� P<N|� �� ���3 �,M3��U3 >��=�� P8e�V� Pc����� ��3�<)� !e� ,�P6W;k� !K� �28�� L �*
!e C !6#_ Y,s P(��y�� Y?� G�;�"3 !6#_� P "� P ©� PM���s4#� �2?� P��w� ���(5= �� P(5=, !6� !e P8R�� ��#� b�W; �,6K0� *
���? !6� P ©� PM��� G/ 2e|� �L?�* �� c y� �?1?�t��5 X�+ (j�� �� �?u� F*�*D� Ft��
¦1�� �� ��<s S��w�� C m12j�� 1��; ��/ �L?– ,����#u� x�#_P qf� ���� ,P��+e ����− 2pAV� 5 e��� ��"� :" >�)� C 2©� ^_�K<��
G�A3 [j; �L?� ,Pp�{ !e C 2��� �Ma �� J�"� �Ma �2#� �� P#R���� C �M� �2#� [#c×? G��<? 4=Å histone H4 "ghi*
GI !3 �2= >1��; �,�8<; Y��� ���)� mL? P��W � !a�� � �U�/ �8"_ ����%�3��, E(�� -E#; lI �s �6M; � ¸1/ `�� C � ;/ 2e�_�*
ihg  76�k� ����<�� �;�{hÃÉ*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P8< �� lI P"R� Pc��1 ����#� !d� Y��� G�5A)� Ps2{ ��"A� ��� E:; ���q/ PN2 ? C P8?L�� EKB Y��� P8?L�� Ì_�;�8s P����� lI �p8��
�� !e G�ZK�I� n1��e !e lI P#8M�� C P)� �� (�K�� §�<;/ �� ^dK��4;��"�� !e � "� � Æ� �?� �/ '��a �� 12{ 'R� 2��� G�;�R C ^<�*
�, � J�ZR�� ��� �� ��)�� 5:#� P;�;�"�� mL?�, �0 �t�1� �A����*������T�8Mak�� G�<;�� C P��d63 2=�� 1�j3�� G�;�"s ,, �� r�O ���
�a��3 � 2�k PR%� � Y0���� ���<V�; � � ? 4#��s 4#�� �� � ���� [A� �0�_ n� ?�� C P��w��� �2&� r�O ��� � 1�M��� rAN !,s >2��� P��,
4"��qA�¨ 4� P:� �� Q� � P��, �� C !j� ? ?F#(81� Sp�² �� �`� o*1�
<�� �=��� K_ � �U�/ �0�_ �%�a�� b�� [A�� 1�;� 1�q �� Ñ��� C �G��)� �� 4s�2�� �� ]�5��, �=��� K��� mL¥ ��6�_ �� (�K�� mL? ���
v8U�� 7,� 63 �0�_ [A�� r�O ��� P��dV���%�a�� b�� �* ���� 1�M��� rAN !,s?P��, �� C P:� �� Q� � !j� §�M��
�m1� )��V1� � 7z�� ¼*H¯! -@�� _���#�� ,G*m@1 _9 �0 XC��p� ��� � �A0 23.W! F0$�� %5�m! %j�� l`� 2R*1� ,_?����� ,G*m@1 _9�m1� )��V1� c 2A���� FV@�Ç £� ¶0 S�m� F�5�t�� ���§ ]��*��� �0 �t�1� FVR@#
m1� oV� F��G�1�� 7��� -@�� ��¯�1� �1s T�� ,r3z1�5 _j��� y?! Y��� EW A� v3�c� 'A\A� � < F� n� ? G/ �� 2eo !�� �?��W�� mL? 2#_ �/
�+�� �8� Q�� P6K�� Y��� 'Aa �,6K0!
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
v² EA�� PAe P6K�� �M<� '��a� EK0 ¿a�� G�;�R n� ,s! �� ^w�� � 'R� $���R �& P ©� PwA���P��� P��d63 v8U *
EK)� �;�j�� 2=�V� '��� �� Q�;k� C ��8� !�� P ©� PM���s«28V�!
Y(��5s 4� �~M� � §�s�� C !�� G�KA� P"R2�� >���#V������À��Ð��Ï��Î��Í��Ì���ËÊ��É��È��Ç��Æ���Å��Ä��Ã��Â��Á
�Ó��Ò�����������Ñ�ghi* : : : : ألدلة القطعية يبقى لنا أن نسألألدلة القطعية يبقى لنا أن نسألألدلة القطعية يبقى لنا أن نسألألدلة القطعية يبقى لنا أن نسألوفي النهاية وبعد هذه اوفي النهاية وبعد هذه اوفي النهاية وبعد هذه اوفي النهاية وبعد هذه ا
؟؟؟؟----سبحانهسبحانهسبحانهسبحانه––––كيف يستدل على ما هو دليل على كل شيء كيف يستدل على ما هو دليل على كل شيء كيف يستدل على ما هو دليل على كل شيء كيف يستدل على ما هو دليل على كل شيء
ihg P��� ,]Ajs >1�N :g½ i
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
áÜ�ë@éîÜÇ@�a@óÜ•@âbãþa@��@ñ��@åß@pb�@ @ S�JB y��� ,,@�� %*@0 �� v� %!�3� yap$ $� c ¡@t�� �� y3^� �¬��
�� v� �t�1� %!f� �� FV �� ,@�� %*@0: µëþa@òzàÜÛa@ @
C -b�� ��/ l�#_ ���R �5; 4� P�26pV� P��N��� b��/ ��: ���~���� � ��}��|
���¡�����ghiE?� EAN� �A� �� �{ Y8 �� lI P#31/ J�R/ EAN/ ,:
�− 2A��a ] 3 P·2a P6��K�� ��=�−�, � �� ¸1− ]6A� 2"s !s�; �3 PR1� P��"� �2,u� ,>�8 �� ��%� �s ��3/� ��1�y8��
PA��q 4 N ��;��/� �R2{ ]e1�/� ,�s*
] − '�2j�� �K3 �3/ E6)� �"�2{ −� � �� ¸1− ��k� b��� C �3 ��o���_ G��; ��;%�� mº EA#� G�e �;k*
�− �3 ¿� �6� �3�/S��q ª−� � �� ¸1 − !e C �#8�� G�e .L����+�/, �_�8; ��{�?1I 2,y��*
$− Y 8���3 � 3�− -PA��� C Y 8��� b�0 G/ !8R P"�� − ,PH1�� �3 2�A� �� �{ Y8 �� ! ËUs .L����= 4� ,�A?/� m2��� �� EAN� �� ��
73�s m�La��*
��|? G+�I G�Ks �{ �R2{ �� 2?�u �2�/ Pd#8�� b��/ �� ��k� b��� CEAN� �A� ��!
ihg P��� ,�H2V� >1�N :gh−�i
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
òîãbrÛa@òzàÜÛa
b�� C½ E?^�� G��M�� EAN� 2N/ � 3� P;� e� Í��R ]#6�=� ,P��:? ��8?Ls ,23Ô� 46A<V�� b%N�� Ps�u ��A{��<� G/ ��1�R� ,J�#�� !(�8R ��
-Í:3 �?�z�p� >1� V� P �2V� �p; ��#F� +s ,!_�"� ��o >�� ����R3×Û§2 � >�5�Ü P3� ©� P,8©� PW��R � 3 ] A�/ >^<#�� PWpA�� mL? C� ,
�� ��N1 PA_�"�� 2,#�� P;�a >1� V� P �26A� P����V� − � �A� �� �{EAN− ���K<� P��<² Pe�#V� �1�js ������ �� �K� ,��,�� P;��� 4e�V� Í© � �
m2 � �� � �2 = �5;�s 4�#U�<V� 4 �|V� m��8� �� ���, Í= S{F/� -9���3 J�5�k� ->�1�3 ]8AR� E,��a ]#A�R�� E?�K<#63 ]�j� >2�2u
E,#� ]��u� E��23/� E¥�AR �5�� E?1�2R, E¥�AR C S���� �� 7"�/�, -[R�� C P;�,V�� .5� ���O G��· 48(�a ����#s wFN 43 ��"�� ����� ^
23� 4 �|V�� 4e�V� �K<#� *
,GB� -1�,y3 >�5w�� mL? 2#3 �;/ !(%R− b�²É P��:?− ��H/ �3 P�+H ¦�a �� ��N1 ����� 2��� P�+�� 2N−EAN� �A� �� �{− mº�s ,�<� 3
-P�1�<3 m�M31� G�6A<V� Y8 �� �3 �6s ,.�8 �� 2:<V� .1��N ��−�{ �� EAN� �A�− ��"s :Û?F��� �� �(�0 �s��Ü* ��R :26² �� ^a .2 �; !�"_ GI
E# F_ GI� ,b� �O !�"_�e�u �� E# F_* b��� C EAN� �A� �� �{ Y8 �� �"Aq�s� ��6�#� PK� lI S?O� ,EAN/� P�+H !<���s ,���d��* ��"� ��R� : � ���
s GO�� 7�� PM � P8� P�+�� �� EK_��EAN� �A� �� �{ �� ��N1 �,* +AsY8 �� lI ��8�e 7�� ��2,:s ,�%#s PK� !?k PM )� �3 � � ��;�− �� �{
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
EAN� �A� − !#�s ,E& b�#M�� �83 �6<� P�+H lI S�K� G/ E,���1�3 �;���<�−A� �� �{EAN� �−*
G�2��� ��;�e PAAR 1�,u L � ��L�� E?� E& PM )� �3 P�+d� �=/� -EA<� !e Ps�u ��j~�N� � �#� J�#�� !(�8R �A� ��8�/� P6A<��*
��"�� 2pA� ®�� EH: ��e�u ]��R G/ 2#3 26² PÒ1 Y? ��/?! òrÛbrÛa@òzàÜÛa
`� Go�"�� P�%83 l�k� PWpA�� L � Í��R ]<�/ ,�3 �,=��_ �� �À2� �K�PwA��� P��j��� C �=�V� ];�e ��/ ��, >1�86A� §��Nk� 2"#_ ];�e�
P��#y��, Go�"�� �3 �?�2p�� �� P{�; rA�� ��R ];�Ks*
S��_� J�5�k� S�5B� Ñ�©� �6� G/ ��|? 2=� ��k� �R�� C �K� �� ��N1 P31�pV !(�8"��−EAN� �A� �� �{ − Pc1�#� �� f�/� G�?/
�L& ��#6<_ � G���"�� P��; �� !(�8"�� G�8�|� ��;�Ks ,.2p��� ��8R� Go�"��� E?2,= ¾��3 �L,s ,��a/ -P��; �� Go�"����£� �¢��¡� � � � � � � � � � ����~��}
¨���§����¦��¥�������¤�ghi*
PA8R Q(1� ,� �?��� � ����u G�e� Õ�2�� ��6� �3 !�q b2R ��2 �� «+N �� m�1L� E���#e� PK� !?/ �A8"�N� PK� b2R ��2 � ,�6�� C $��
26² Go�R−EAN� �A� �� �{− �;O/ �y� 7�� ,m�p<� JL: � %~�[N�K�� − �M"��− �� �{ � � �6<� � Ye ,b��)� 2:<V� lI ��= 4� �A�
ihg P��� ,]Ajs >1�N :g�Éi
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
C ��"s ,P�\<�� P"��M�� mL? �� �� �<�; C �R� �;/ �28� �K� ,��~u EAN��<�; :���u� S8� �I, �8"�� �� �<)� �¿� 7�¯ ��* ��� �;O/ C �R�s ��
lI E?��2� ���R lI ���� ,')� >��,u 2,u� EAN/� �8AR �A� rA6�s Go�"�� �1�; ¦�a �_��� '��q C� b%N�� / EAN/� m2A3 �3 !a2s �q�N �� ,�A?
��3 4;+H �� ��8��R EAN/�� �� ��N�3 ��") ��L�� E?� ,���R ��− �A� �� �{EAN�− P �2V� C 2#3 +s*
�� ���� �<�/ ��;�K� ` E�/ �28s PK� C PwA�� 4q�N/ lI �;2� �OI�s G�~8�¯ ��;�Ks ,Go�"�� �p<� E¥�L:;� C !�q �� Go�"�� G�#6�<� ����
�,AdV ����#� �/ ��#�/ �:��� J�R ��A3�"_ �OI 7�� m�p<� E¥�L:;� T�s�LK?�, 1�jR �/ P:)� ±"; � PA8"��� P8j#�� S8<3 �I E,�%NI �a��� `�P��k�!
�� 2pA� ®�� �L? !e 2#3��"� ���3 �� ���e ��#� � ª :" �2B/ �;/Go�"��"* e S�K� EH6N � ��% � @ ,J�LK�� P6A<� P"��q �� � �: >�e�pV� G/ � � �
.2p�A� P3�:�N� 2A"����! òÈiaŠÛa@òzàÜÛa
�<���� � de >2�%V� � : ?PW��R Y 3 ��=1 !�R E�� �O�V
P�}�� ^a >^N C >2�%V� �?^d� P,8u }e/ ��8��"_ mL?�– �A� �� �{EAN�−*
]8d� .L�� P��28�� C �{ Y8 �� G/ ]8d� G/ � �"8<� �A� PH��)� mL? «�R��� >�8 �� ��=1� ��/ è EAN� �A�; E? PH��)� mL? ��A"; ��L�� >����� Gk
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Q� 3� ,EAN� �A� �� �{ m2� �� �&%a ��= Y��� ��5:#V� ��A"; ��L��P_�8d�� P=1�*
::::قبلهاقبلهاقبلهاقبلهافالذي يثبت وقوع حادثة بني قريظة عليه أن يثبت فالذي يثبت وقوع حادثة بني قريظة عليه أن يثبت فالذي يثبت وقوع حادثة بني قريظة عليه أن يثبت فالذي يثبت وقوع حادثة بني قريظة عليه أن يثبت
IIIIQQQQHHHH ����� ���� ���������� ���� ���������� ���� ���������� ���� �����:::: ��N1 C «�©� >2u �3�= �/1 §2 � ��� �� H/ Y�s ��–EAN� �A� �� �{− � ���{ �_/��� ] pq� �� P6¥ �3Ls ,}j� EAs –
E:)� vN��� '8q − ��� EH ,^#u �� �º EAN� �A� �� �{ �� ��N1 C � �{ �� ��N1 b�"s ,�3�p{/ �� ��;E?� §2 � !?/ �6:3 EAN� �A� ��
, -!=1 [�/ P3��R58 F 4:#��� ,vw_ P�}�� ]�� ��� ��#8u� ��Ae�sghi* IIIIRRRRHHHH ���a� �3k �� �� P �p3 ^y3 �3 G+# �� ]a/ ]8?O�, ��N1 m�28s
-J�H §�s EAN� �A� �� �{ �� �6���� ,��#=1� ��Ae�s §2 � !?/ ����J�d�� ���q/ �� v"<�*
IIIISSSSHHHH Æc��� �A� �� �{ �� ��N1 �5 s >2�2u P�2e �3�p{/� �3�© ] !?/ ��8de ���#s ��#V�3 �¥Ú� ,EAN�– rN+�� � �%�1 ./−*
IIIITTTTHHHH >�\{ �3�p{/� ��}� ]c���– �� ��8��R >����� ��"� +e �,6:�h� Z�C h� C Z�h� ¿j� Y�(�V �<�� 2:<� E:p3 ./ Z�− �� ��N1 �5 s
–�� �{ EAN� �A� − ��"s: Û�� ,R5Ü. ,P#MR �M"s ��#V�3 �P3Ú JÚ EH��"s ,��c �, � ¦�a� :Û��m1� �*!�V� 2*t0W� ¶9� ��, ���8^ k6 �q�� }6�
F0�R1� )��u<�Ü* ./: �s mz�0 .L�� ]R��� C �L?� ��8��R b�y�� ��s E�N
ihg .1�\8�� �p{*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
���3 ��3� P;�d�� JÚ EH ,��� >�#�� G���:�� � J���k� �� P��6�>�\j�� ]#M";�� ,�6�� ���3 ��3� Pd��d�� EH ,$1�s*
-��3Ú t%H -��#63 �{ �8 ��� ,§%6� 7 8� E:p3 >�\{ Ey� Y(�23 ���3 EAN� �A� ����� ��~63 �,u�= ��2�/ 12"_ ���1�q�}�I�* !,s
?n��e �� }j_ rA#· �� v"s 1��� b/ ,��5:#V� mL¥ 2pAV� �À/ EA<F_ IIIIUUUUHHHH �= ��2 ��� ` ,P�+y�� P,©� �� P �2V�3 ]q��/� J�5�k� Ñ�= �
Í= S{F/� ,m2 � �� � �2 = �;�p8N �� �5;�s ,�¥ !8ÁR 46A<6A� �K� -9���3 J�5�k� ->�1�3 �5�� E,��a ]#A�R�� E?�K<#63 ]�j� >2�2u
P;�,V�� .5� ���O G��· 48(�a ����#s ,E,#� ]��u� E��23/� E¥�AR: ���j� �i� �h��g� � �f��e� �d� �c� �b� �a� �`� � �_� �^
s��r��q���p��o��nm��l��k�ghi* IIIIVVVVHHHH �>�� ��_�� �� E�/ EAN� �A� �� �{ Y8 �� }a/ J�5�k� J��? 2#3�
EAN� �A� �� �{ ��"s ,r�O 2#3 P �2V� ��5w� ��� ��a/ :Û p� ,���~� �¬�����~�Üg�i* �� �{ Y8 �� GI !3 ,J�5�k� >�5� 2#3 P �2V� �5� E�� ` !#���3�
2#3 �%#s E,�I 1�N .L�� �? EAN� �A�PK� ��s C ��� N t%d3 �?*
,GB� Y F� �=�_ ,EAN� �A� �� �{ �� ��N�� J�5�k� 1�j� �� H/ �;/ �� Y 3 2N SMa/ �3U �� P3� ©� P,©� C ��;�e� PW��R Y 3 ��À lI ^
ihg P��� ,J�5�k� >1�N :gÇi* i�g .1�\8�� �p{*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
mL,s ����,�� ,EAN� �A� �� �{ �� ��N1 �� 2,#�� �" 3 E?���/� ,P �2V�,1�K�_ �� P{�s �� b�:,A� ��2#�N�� P3� ©� E,�,8= ��p�s� 2,#�� ��U" s
� P �2V��{���z��y��x��w��v��u�ghi �� ��N1 }� ¾A3� ,– �{EAN� �A� �� − ���wy� E?� P�+y�� P,©� C J�5�k� 1�jp3, 2� !N1�s
EÀ1�1O� 46A<V� ��<; PN��) .2 = P(+H%H C PH1�� �3; P,©� C ��;�e E�k2,#�� �"; }a G�A:�<� O�#� �3 2#N� >��8� �3 2#N !N1/� ,P3� ©�,
��� �8a/ C ��,�� ��2=�s– J�#�� ��2pAV� ��pe b��� − G�a�� �=�s ,b��� 2#3 26pV �� G���"�� 46A<V�� b%N�� G�8<�� G�#_���
�A� �� �{ �� ��N1 �}a/� G�3�pj���� ��N1 'AR 2R� ,}�3 EAN�− EAN� �A� �� �{− ��R� �� EH ,�:Mc�s E?12� �wA3 4� :Û¶9� ��Ü ,
Í= ��2_ P6W� ��1 ]��R� ����N �I Y? ��� ,� ��3 46A<V� �3��� 3 +e �� �� G��A� � ���pj�� C G�3�,s E¥�AR �A�"_� J�5�k�*
�� �{ �� ��N1 ��#s ,EW#�� � �� �� �31 � �2��� ��3 lI EAN� �A� ./ b��/ P3� ©� E,�,8= ��s� 2,#A� E,�;�a �� PW��R Y 3 S���_ 2��� ��=�
�� ��N1 E?z�ps ,46A<V� P31�² 2��� b�� −EAN� �A� �� �{− ��8AMs�3 2#N EKB O�#�−� � �� ¸1− E,�;�a C; EKps E, � �%=1 G�e �;k
¥ G� �|� Y��� �,<�; >�1����3A_�"V�� P;�� !�" F� G/ �?� ,�� Q�� ,G !e�������� �#3 �eL_ +e ��=���; !6y� EK)� G/ 1�"_ .1�\8�� P���1 ±; Gk
ihg P��� ,J�5�k� >1�N :ghÄi
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
v"s 4A_�"V� :ÛE,s FE FK�/ �´s : FPÆAÁ_�"FV� Æ!Æ� á" F_ G/Ü *
�� 12w�� Y��s/ ��j~�N� E�s P;��s ,G�<;I �s .1+� � EK)� �L?� ,P;�P#c��� ^_�N2�� C 7�� b�2��� �,�3�"� 76W#��*
C �K� ��k� �R�� � r�O !e �� � �2#3 ����)I �;��� >��3I ��ÇÇ % ��%� � �"8q �8�� �p8��� ^w�� �� ��"3�� GI !3 ,�A{Ô� ��"8��� Y#8M�� J�\�;
�L? E,R�"� �� �3� G�<;�� G�e �� !3 ,.��V� ��)�� QN/ !e �� x1�#���3 �#y� �As P#8M��� � #� E,�� ��� P,8y�� �� �M; P���V� ��6�)� Gk
,� �� ^a �� EA@ �� �Ma .��V� `�#�� C 2=�� �� ,�� !e n� FB +e ,J��K�� P��23 C � A �js P,8y�� G/ �+(�� ��R/ �;�s �L� ��=� b2� �� !�� }e/
G�<;�� >�?�@ ^<��� �Aj� � �;/� ��)��*
�,��R�3 2pAV� �Z�� �� Pp6A�� mL? C �?� c�� Y��� PW��R Y 3 P,8u�, � 8; >�8; G�3 �Z#� G/ � �"8<� ��5As− EAN� �A� �� �{ − ��/ ��
��=12��, �,A"; Y��� ��5:#V� �� ^dK�� �&%a �R� 2"s �\uk� Q�; 26)� �� ,!8R �� � pc�/ +e P_�8d�� P=1� Q� 3� P#R���� mL? ��A"; ��L��
P V��* ò�ßb¨a@òzàÜÛa
Y8 ��� Í��R 43 E(�"�� «���� P:�; G��W� � J�#�� G�e − �A� �� �{EAN�− `� ,b��)� 2:<V� �� �M<� G/ �K6� � `�W�� G/ G�2"�#� ��;�e� ,
���N1 �� b�e/ +As ,>2#83 E, � !��� J�p{/ PjR �K_− �A� �� �{EAN�− '8� ` ,PK� ���3N1 �;�e C ru 7;�/ E?2 � �"� ����, !(�8"�� �/28s
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
����M3 �"_� �,�%NI �A#_ G�2A8�� 7�u �� ��I 2s���_ P3�#��− �A� �� �{EAN�− b�#� ����� b�#�� Y6 FN 7�� ,� �=��s/ �� ��� C G�Aa2� $� �� La/� ,
PK� ��s−ÇP��:? − -1�,u C � P3�#�� >��5©� ]6AN/� ,��s��� b�#3 -PAAR ÁV � �/1���N�3 �� P�� � ��−EAN� �A� �� �{−*
b�#�� �L? C�Ç ^; �� P�1�p��� ��e�)� >�R �#y�<_ b���� �/23 P��:? ����"� G/ G������ �/�s ,]6AN/ Y��� P3�#�� !(�8"�� �?��"_ Y��� G������ b���� Ñ�= �5,�� ,E?1�� �"� C 46A<V� �� �¥ G�U"� P6N�� >�5w3
Pe�#6A��� ��N1 EA�� �}K�� −EAN� �A� �� �{− �� �N�s ,E,e�p�3 Y�%N�� ¶�1���� C ��#� +s ,b���� Í= >�R%V n�8_ �p; n�B� 46A<V�
3×Ûn�8_ >�5�Ü�� ��N1 ��5 3 b���� ]6A� G/ ��� ,−EAN� �A� �� �{− C��s E¥�AR C S���� �� 7"�/� E?��R �1�a� �I ,n�8_ ,E?�%3 !a�� C ��R�
� ��N1 !@� �−EAN� �A� �� �{− ��� ��· EAs n�8_ C � ��K<#� � ���� ���"A�� �� 2�/ E, �*
�_��� '��q C�−EAN� �A� �� �{− Æ#3 Í©� �� ,P �2V� lI La�s P8" Æ#�� '��q EAN� �A� �� �{ �� ��N1 rAN + 3 .����� �M3 $� �� `� P8"
C ������ G�2��� 4"s� V� �� �%=1 �� � H� �#8�s ,1+�� P��L� �I �#� �K� Y8 �� EA#s ,46dA� ��;�e� 1�K�_ �� P{�s−EAN� �A� �� �{− E��y3
Y8 �� }a/� ,1�����3 ���º/� �� E,8�1�s m2�� G+�� �3 P��L� E,�I !N1�s−EAN� �A� �� �{ − E,(+N�3 P��L��� ��N1 º S��j3 Y6 F<s− �� �{
EAN� �A� −*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� ��N1 >�s� 2#3 >2�2� ��� <� P3�pj�� �����−EAN� �A� �� �{ − P��L� �K� 4"s� V� ��|? �+N/ ��s�#� G/−� � �� ¸1− G/ lI ,73�� G�e
Á� F `� ����� ��N1 º ¦−EAN� �A� �� �{−*
��pV �� PpV mL? ];�e °�)�� E# ��3 �A� �AU�_� ,�8 � �� >�;�,u >^<� S����3 >� ��� ��5:#V��*
��"�� 'Ò/ 2pA� ®�� EH: �K� ` �� ���� ,[<�� 2p3 ��;� b%N�� ��; �2��_� �� �� Y8 �� �s Q8 F� .L�� S��q ª/ S#u b%N�� ��� �V �8 �
−�� �{EAN� �A� − lI ��3�p{��= G/ �Pc1k� >�� �, P�p{ ]Ae�s�� ��N1 !N1�s �#R����3 �8; �� }a�s ,P�%©� °�� �2� P#q�"V�− �� �{
EAN� �A�− ,r�L3 �"� ���R �� G�e GI 1��K�� 2,#_� ���,8s ���º ��"Aq/ � ,E, � � de EAN/� Y8 �� �?2#3 'AM;� EH ,EAN� �A� �� �{ �3 }a/ �� ��/1 �V
EAN� �A� �� �{ Á� Áu �G��s�K�� ] F¥ G/ 2#3 �31 P��N1 ¾A8� S��q ª/ S#* ò�…b�Ûa@òzàÜÛa
6)� ��2pAV�3 �2� E��K�� Go�"A� E\U�� C�"d��� C�#V� G Ý�KFV� G/ 7"G/ �� ��� V� �� ��"��� Y8 ��−�{EAN� �A� �� − �^p3 �� EA#�� 7"A_
S?����!
Y8 ��s G%M8�� �?�@ b%e �L?�–EAN� �A� �� �{ − �^p3 '�A� ` �>�� �I S?���� �>2���!
->1�:�3 ¦�¯ G/ S��q �3/ ��1/ 2"s - � C b�y�� lI m�6� G�e� ,Í��"�−EAN� �A� �� �{− P N >�� Y� H�, �� ��N1 EW#�N�s – �A� �� �{
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
EAN�− �� ��3 P �2� �� ��8��R Se��� �5; +As ,�#� mLa/� �A� § ��s ,�R��s !A\�s ,S?���� �^p3 �?� b�y�� P ,e 1�8e 2�/ E,�I ¦�a b�y�� �1�y�
��R� m23 La/� EAN� �A� �� �{ Y8 �� lI !{�� PAs�"�� :Û ,4V�#�� 2N �L?,4V�#�� J1 ��N1 �L? 4V�#A� �PÒ1 �� �d#8� �L?Ü*
����R :?r�L3 r6A� ���
��R :Û ,� �2=�N �a �I �:u �� �:� '8� ` P8"#�� �� E�s�/ 4� EK;I�I� ,Y8 � �I G�2:<� �� !d� ���e ��»� !�N/ >�8 �� E_�\3 �s��/
� 8�e C m2:; �;I� ,P������Ü*
S?���� �^p3 G/ �������� �#3 C ��= 2R� �/�s 2#3 �� PAs�"A� �W; �P3�pN Y8 �� !AW_−EAN� �A� �� �{ − Q6y�� ��, �/1 �^p3 JZR� +AKs
ª/ �� SAq EH ,��R �� ��R� P�f3 PAs�"�� !A\�s ,S:#�� �Ì�� ����� ����{� S��q �3/ L ��; 2R� ,��,�� �� �A� ��s�a � ��f� �3 ��#� G/ S��q!
S?���� ��� ��5� �� P¯1���� ��3 P �2� C b��� lI � ���=�� �^p3��1�<3*
Y8 �� G/ ]8d� �� P¯1���� P������ mL? C !?−EAN� �A� �� �{− QA=?�^p3 �� EA#�� 7"A��
�� 8; >�8; G/ ]8d� �� �,s G/ b/−EAN� �A� �� �{− ��=1� ��/ C�p _ �� Y,� _ � 2?��u �& G/� ,>�8 �������q L � −EAN� �A� �� �{−
? m�"8N ��L�� Q�;/ C >�e�� �_�8; ����3 G/�
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P��A#� :� �,s 2:�N� ,2pA� �,��M� P,8u !e C Í�s ���o� >�8; !(� ëE{ E, K� ,>�?�3 Y6� �EK3! òÈib�Ûa@òzàÜÛa
Y8 �� ��1/ �V–EAN� �A� �� �{− !N1/ ,P8�2)� >�6� �6�#� G/ 2���� �3 2��a >��"3 � �y= G�e�V�–EA<� G/ !8R− �� '��M�� 2<�
2��a Í= �� G�6A<V� JZR� G/ 2#3� ,b��)� ]8�� �� E,# 6�� ,46A<V�Y8 �� E¥ �{ ,�,W�� >%{ ];���−EAN� �A� �� �{− Í= �=� C
2��a ��"s ,2��a : ->�� �� ��;�e 2"� E,A� � AÒ �� e �� G/ 1�"s ?G�AjF� E?� �,W�� 43 ��� >%{ b��� r�O C �� �5;�s ,�#�� >%{ �� H/ E:À
P{���� �_��s �#���*
e�V� �s1 2R�b��)� 2:<V� 46A<V� ��a� G�* ����"� ` P6��= mL?� �< F�� �:)� Ps�c �� $� �� Â��/ ��;�e !3 �%,©� E,�A?�= ���q �¥
E���s�*
�� ��N1 G/ E,V�– �� �{EAN� �A� − !a2N �;/ ��� � C �/1 2R G�e r�L3 }a�s E,N��1 G��"�� G�"A0� G��6�#�� �3�p{/� �? PK� 'u ���6�#� ^� ��#=1� P8�2)�3 1��K�� E?2{ �V �K� �����s �3�p{/
r�O E,A�, s �"� �"�N ������ G/ Go�"�� E?}a�l�#_ ��"s ,�: �¡����¢��±��°��¯��®��¬��«��ª���©��¨��§¦��¥��¤��£
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�À��¿���¾��½��¼��»��º��¹��¸��¶��µ´���³���²�ghi*
�"� ������ ���N1 �� §2{ 2R� ����� b�#�� C 1��k� mL? !e ]H2�� � +e � �U�/ ��8��R � �p�s r�O G�� �� �� !#=� ,�3�p{/� �? �6���� , �>��8�
b�#�� Q�; C }a ��s �?� ,E��K�� Go�"�� }a/ *
��"�� 2pA� ®�� EH :>5:#� ./ !:<� ` Go�"��!
��"�� �ao 2pA� ®��� :�V�q PK� G�6A<V� ��s �O�V �/ G��|� ��;�e EG���3 E,KN� �? ^j ��� �R��� �� �I >^<�� C /�"� ` ª�#�� 2pAV� G/ �28��* òäßbrÛa@òzàÜÛa
�� ��N1 /23 P8�2)� �A{ �� 46A<V� >��� 2#3−EAN� �A� �� �{− �eLF�� b%N�� lI E?��2� ����k�� n�AV� PAN��� C m�� E,���~<63 E?�
,E?����1 >�8 ��3 �� �Z�� E,U#3� ,� ��,= �/ � �º ��I � E, � � de EAN/ 2R�E?��e �� ��AWs P ,K��� «�8_k� �� ��s�a E, K�−� �� !j� +e QR�"V
b���� EW��−5,�<� `� ,X �� ��N1 P��N�3–EAN� �A� �� �{− �I�6�� !?/ �?�H/ �� EAN/ Y��� �}K�� >5:#V� ]H2� �s� �fe− �eL N�
C Pj"���� Pp6A���� ��u GI P���"−*
�� ��N1 !N1/ 2R�–N� �A� �� �{EA− lI �@� FuJ�� È�A�1�Fm3<� �P��N1 ª/ �3 ��#= 2� �� ��: �� EAN/� ,b%N�� lI �,s m��2�
lI S�e� S��q Y8 �� –EAN� �A� �� �{− b�� C ���� ,��#3� ��%N´3Ç
ihg P��� ,����� >1�N :g�Ãi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P��:? Y8 �� m�#;�–EAN� �A� �� �{− �A� �{� ,�s ��� .L�� b��� C>%{ S(�w��*
>� �@� o^��B� ��� �� ��N1 ��N1 P#�A3 ª/ �3 Sq�� b�e/ 2"s–�� �{ EAN� �A� − F� C P��N��� �c�� -' -¦�� �� ,�A� E�a� lI S�e�
�8; G�3 �� �"F� Y8 �� Sq�� �2?/� ,b�y��3 �=��a G/ �W� G�e �;/� Y"3 2R � �G�u +& 4��1�= �EW� �PAw3 m�2?/� ,��^N� P�1�� � � v8"�� C �>�<e� b�e/�
�� ��N1 lI ��� G/ lI Sq�� �5F;−EAN� �A� �� �{−*
�V*j ��0 �@� ��� �? EAN/ 2"s -1��� 2#3 4V�#�� J1 � m�a/� -!��q �� �� ��N1 P��N1 !��� Â�#�� �3 ��6�–EAN� �A� �� �{ − +,�I*
��{� 2#3 ���R �#3� �? EAN/ 2"s ���p8�� rA� .��N �3 1L V� ��/ �� ��N1 P��N1–EAN� �A� �� �{− 2� �� Y�»)� �3 �%#��– �� ¸1
��−*
>*^ ������1� �@� ��R� ,b%N��3 $� �� C ���;� >�8 ��3 �� �Z�� 2"s>^,y�� ����R :��R� ,��2R �� ]A<w� m2 � ] e �� :b���� �#� �� ! EK� !?
F�s ?EKKA� ]8d� G/� 2u���� 9%��� CY8 �� �L? ��#3��* Pj� P ,K�� Â�ps E���; �/1 G/ 2#3 �KA� �� b���� EW� ��\s Í���� �Ò Y��� P6W#��
Y8 �� ��R +e ���1 EHI� �6H´3 ��3� ��%NI �� ��#s ,�"�� ]=1− �� �{EAN� �A� −*
P:)� EAN� �A� �� �{ ����N1 C ��/1� ,G��5�� r�O >��N ��;�e ��|?E,8A�/ >�8 ��3 �� �Z��� E,U#3 �#3��s P6(�"��!
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��"�� ¦O�N 2pA� ®�� EH :2p3 ��;� b%N�� [<��! òÈ�bnÛa@òzàÜÛa
Y8 �� !N1/−EAN� �A� �� �{− �P��N1 $���� rA� �fe lI − �fa��d��− Y6,<�� Ps�L� �3 �� 28� P��N��� !��� G�e� ,b%NÖ� �,s m��2�−
� � �� ¸1− !N1/� ,�¥ 7�1� �,R5�� �?La/ �fe �� P��N��� ](�FR +As , �P��N1 �PA=�� � G�O�3 lI�,s �� ��"� ��# { C �6�� �� �A�� : 4A=�3 �#3�
��2A=−4��R− �:)� lI, -P=�LN C G�O�3 1��a�s ,!=��� �L¥ ��_�As >1��; �� ��N�3 �_�� m2 � �� 4A=1− EAN� �A� �� �{−, lI G%=��� b2R +As
�� ��N1 %3�R P �2V�− EAN� �A� �� �{ − � �) �"A� 2R� �A� %a�� , Y8 �� m Á�Ks ,+¥1��u %�s�− EAN� �A� �� �{− ��R� ,+,�I �W �� :"�� +KA
?�L¥ +e��/ ��." ��R :� 31* s ,�fe G�2j"� ��N��� ��"− �A� �� �{EAN�− :Û�h�4 ³^� _�*< )�V0�5 }��� h �?1Ü*
�Ä(+� Z��#: n�AV� rA� Y #� m�y ?�u GI 26²��−�fe �3 2j"�− 2R ,Y#� 'AM �� r�I Y d#3� r3 �_�� �� r�I �#8� G/ m���� G�O�3 rAV� lI S�e
�� ��N�� 2�2� �s ���R ��R�− EAN� �A� �� �{ − Y8 �� �A� ��� EAs ,− EAN� �A� �� �{ − �2� m�R%� G/ � ��/��*
Y8 �� lI G%=��� ��= ��d�� b��� C�− EAN� �A� �� �{− +& ��"s Y8 ��−EAN� �A� �� �{− :Û�?@�� ;`1� � �¶��−��s�5 − : %5 y�^ h �6F@*@1�− F@*@1� �@! c ¥·9 �@�� yj� �0 �� �� ;�−%1 p�^� ,: �6 _��$
¥·9 É@5 �� É@3*� }�t@��, �#�<�� -�� �G��� k6 _G����Ü*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
lI G%=��� ��#s ,PAA�� rA_ C �A�R� �fe �� ���N�� �� E"�;� 2"s G�O�3 �2= S:#s ,��k�3 �;�}¯ -1�,u 2#3 }� ��:s ,$���� �%3 �� }� �W�;�� �
Y8 �� �?�2� Y��� PAA�� rA_ C �fe !�"63–EAN� �A� �� �{ − ,�%#s ,E,�%N´3 �6�� !?/ EAN/� ,����K� ]6AN/� ,>�=��V� ��? �� G�O�3 EAN�s
�2s� ��=� b%N�� G�6A#�� �6�� !?/ ��, �� �{ �� ��N1 E,s !N1/�!8= �3 O�#� EAN� �A�*
Y8 �� ��/�−EAN� �A� �� �{− 3 G��<3 C ���= �� 83 Q 0 �3 �3� G�O�− P NÉP��:?− ���2:N 1�\j�� �#83 v8U��3 �_�H�2�I� ��A8R �2�� ,
n� ?* �� �de/ P �2V� �� 2#8_ ��# js Py?2� ��a/ >5:#� mL?�¼ÄÄ ,Z� �Ae
�� ��N1 �3 ��/ .L�� 2:<V� �R�� �� ��d�2�� �+�2R �6�� !?/ °s�� 2R� EAN� �A� �� �{/ F� G�s Y 8, )�3 r�O� �? Ë2� Y��� m��2� `�#� �� Ø��
�(� 8� EAN� �A� �� �{ �� ��N1, 2:<V� . �2� 2�/ P6A6AV� >�\j�� !d�43 b��� �#R��� 76<_ 2:<V� .1��N �� 4��1�N I2�� � ">1�6<V�"
��ak�� ">1�" V�"* �� �?�2� Y��� PA8"�� G/ P�� j�� 1+Rk�3 b��� [y�K; �� G�p8N� Y8
�� �de/ L � EAN� �A� �� �{hÅÄÄ ^j�s ,���:A� P��dV� PA8"�� Y? b��P��<�� b�R lI �6�� !?/ �?2,y�� b��� �?2,y; �}e >2�2= >5:#�*
��5:#� �� >5:#� �� E(�R .2{1 .��� !�23 � 8��M� .L�� 2pAV�� K6� >�8 ��3 � G/ Pq�<82{�� ��# j3 ^8K�� ���©� C >1�" V�� >1�6<V� lI
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
b���! ghi* ñŠ‘bÈÛa@òzàÜÛa
�� ��N1 ¾ËA3 ��2#3–EAN� �A� �� �{− j;� P;��k� ��/� ,P��N��� ����#s/� ����R/ C E<�_ �;2�� �� «����� �(%q �/23 P�k�***
�c1��� ,� ���� ���� >��#�� P <�� �� G�U�1 C [K��� Go�"�� !�}=4_��*
P6q�s �� 3� ��"s :Û�j� ]��^� p6 �1s ¥� pÜ* �6�� lI � �O�#� «�����R EH ,m�{��s :Û �� �� �@�1� ,�`� _��0 (�5 }��@! p� �R0 ��6 s��� ��
;¶^� �`� ;(ARu5Ü * �Pya O�#� 7K8s; �� ��N1 §��s J�"3 m1�#y� −EAN� �A� �� �{−*
��R�–�{EAN� �A� �� − � �1��� «����� P:� C :Û (�5 ,9��1� p ��1�`� _��0 (�5 +� p ��1� ,�`� _��0Ü*
l�#_ ���R ��5; G�e�: ���q� �p� � �o� �n� �m� �l� �k
u��t��s��r�g�i* � �� >1�N ��5; r�Le� :���g��f��e��d��c��b��a
������t�� sr���q��p��o��n��m��l� �k��j� �i���h
i1g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H99ycqm9q_I.
i�g P��� ,>2(�V� >1�N :g i*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�v��u�ghi*
�;/ ./ ,«����� P:p3 ]6 FN r�L�� ,�;2�� C ��6,� �� È�s �;�3 � �1�#uI�31 ��"A� $� �� « Ë��*
��{ !(��/ C�hh -�,y3 �_�s� !8R ×? ¦�a–EAN� �A� �� �{− lI !8= F/ } V� lI ��;� EH ,����k�� ���Ô� «��V�e ��2,y�� �� �js ,2���"s :Û �Ê�# ��� }6� ,�¬� Ë�+ k6 �q�� ��� }6� ,,?*@0 �(*G4 ���� ,,?1
�� ,?*@0 X��� �� ��� }6� ,©�� �*!�V� �� ,©�� �a��� �*!�V� 2*t0W��G*# ��R#��! �� ,?*@0 X��� _�?1� ,;(�5 ��9¯!Ü*
��R� ,E& ��w�N�s !A�� ��= C 2R�w�� �"3 lI ¦�a ��{ �a��/ C�: Û ,?5 ��6���+pÜ*
�s ��� .L�� ����� �,y�� C�−��k� �31 − ��R� ,Py(�� ]3 lI !a� :Û ��`¨�! C# p� ,(j�R� ,G*<��� ,Ga�*3�� �3^ ��`¨�� ����9 ,?@3^ ��9 � |�
�1s �0 ,9�º� }6 ,(j�R� �3�1�Ü*
��R� :Û(3�W� �7��� ;¶^ ��`¨�! pÜ*
Â�j"A� $� �� b��/ �<�; x���− � �� � Æ� �L?� ,� � ±�"As P6AW� m2 EAN� �A� �� �{ �"Aa �+e ��−� � a 1�j;k�3 ç�/� ,, ��R EH :Û � 7(30 �6
l(�0 �� ����# ,l(�0 �� e5� )�4 �� �*�(1� ��� �� %*!n� �� e5 �� l �f�Ü*
��R� ,� � �� ¸1 '�2j�� �K3 �3/ 7K8s: � _�,�/� � (�3ä3 n� �2s* ��"s
ihg P��� ,� �� >1�N :gh− i*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
$� �� : -28� �� EAN� �A� �� �{ �� ��N1 }¯ ,¶y�� �L? lI ���W;� m Ë a��"� �?� ,m2 � �� 43� �;2�� >�? �� �_|� G/ 43 ��: � _�,�/� � (�3ä3 n� �2s*
7�MjV� S8)� �? ^\FV� G/ G�6A#� $� �� �K� `� − �A� �� �{EAN�−��1 ��R +e E,6A�/ �K3 �3/ G�Ks , .12� 2#N �3/ ��2)� .− ¸1
� � ��−* �� ��N1 7 H/ EH–EAN� �A� �� �{ − -�K3 ª/ �� J��3k� 2<3 ��/� ,
�K3 ª/ J�3 �I PMpV� ��8�� �� 2:<V� C P����V�*
8)�3 x�V� 2�y� /23�S−EAN� �A� �� �{ − 3/ !N1�s� ¿j� G/ �K3$� ��3*
'3�<�� 2�k� b��� �>��8� S8)� >�s��–EAN� �A� �� �{ − §2j_�� !K3 -��� �� m2 � ��1� ];�e� ,��%N 46A<V� S?�� ,^;�;� P#8N ��;�e� �P;�?�� ^#u �� � ���{ 4H%d3 .��À 2 �*
S8)� >�s� b�� 4 H�� b�� �8{/ �V�–EAN� �A� �� �{ − �K3 �3/ b�R �� ��N1 [yKs ,�:��� >%{ $� ��3 ¿j�–EAN� �A� �� �{− ZN
>�:� ��e� �8"� �� �K3 �3/ ±K s ,rpU� E<8_ EH 4AjV� lI �W;� Py(�� S8)�3 � ���s �� ���� G/ $� ��–EAN� �A� �� �{− ���/ G/ m23 E,�I 1�u�s
Z<�� 7a1/� >�:)� !a� EH ,EK_%{*
�N1 ������ �−EAN� �A� �� �{− ���?5�� P6q�s–�, � �� ¸1 − �? �1�<s -�Ì3 -�Ì3 �? �1�N EH ,]K8s r�O �� Py(�� �,���N� ,]KpUs
�� ��N1 C�_ 7�� ,]6�Ks −EAN� �A� �� �{− C �& ��R �;/ ��}a�s
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
l�k� �c�� C ��6� �;/ P;�d�� C �& ��R� ,]K8s �L? / ��/ ��/ �3 � �R�) �A?]KpUs*
3��� /2 S8)�3 1�U��–EAN� �A� �� �{− 2� !a2F� !#:s ,��V� C ��¥ �<6��+ ��"�� ,�,=� :"���K<� ��6A� GI �� �I ��I �." �/ ��2� �s1 EH
Py(�� ��I ]w{�s ,m���u ]e�B� ["<�� �p; m�83 ± Æ\ Æu� �#8{I��"� ��#6<s: Û�� ,��� ��`1� T� )�(Gm1�� e��(81�� e*3�1� �� ,G*@0
¡*#�1� ,G@1� ,v0�� ¡*#�1�5 _��<�� _�{�� ½ �V�� ,G@1� ,e<�81��v0��Ü* ��k� 's���3 ')� ,���1 ]c�s� ,��H%H >^ak� P6AK�� 1�e�*
����e� �;2�� E,A� ]6A@�s ,��W) C P3�pj�� 43 }� Jf_�EAs ,E,�� G�2"�� �b�� �K� �� ��N1 �s !a� b�� �� ��c/ �� �<�/–
�A� �� �{ EAN�– P �2V� �b�� �K� `� , SjF_ `� ,�s ��� b�� �� EA@/ -J�j63 P�k� ��o ��� �A� n1�3� EAN� !{ E,A�� ,�_�� J�j� �� EW�/
m��� � �� �8p{�* (�5�!
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
ñìjäÛa@Ýöü…@ @ �,L ��C� )M!د �-N0�7� (:O #0 ؛Q,و� � ,< Rا...
::::ومن دالئل النبوةومن دالئل النبوةومن دالئل النبوةومن دالئل النبوة
IQH ?'�("�/@AB" C��< D" E�' F�� ,D$G*" �)*" H<� .�I �/@AB� ; 1��� �$ %@� KI�L� ,9' M$� 760 E�7� N�6� 7< � ,9' M� 760 �OP =�
�)*/� .> ' M$�"�/@B" E�7� F��� O , ��' M� �7$G" �QR . /)*/� 1���S�# TU0�� �/@B �)*L��� ,9' M$� �8VW� �/@B X�GY Z( � 146� ,�
[���°��¯��®��¬��«��ª��©��¨��§��¦��¥�����¤���£��¢��¡�������½��¼��»��º���� �¹�� � �¸��¶��µ��´��³��²��±��Ë���Ê��É��È��Ç��Æ��Å��ÄÃ����Â��Á��À��¿¾
Ô��Ó��Ò� �Ñ� �Ð�� ÏÎ� �Í� �Ì\ghi O �]$^:� _*I 9`�� , ,�/@B9' M$� O 59V��a
��<�� � W� ��w�<� G/ EAN� �A� �� �{ Y8 �� EA#� Go�"�� GI !3� .��,��3�H��G��������F��E��D��CB��A�g�i*
���"� lI P8< ��3 � � 12{ �� �K� ,EAN� �A� �� �{ � �1�L#� G�e GI� ��6pV�–EAN� �A� �� �{− G/ ru�� S;L��e G�K�*
�L���K��J����W��� � � � � � � � � � � � � �V��U��T��S��R��Q�� PO��N��M
ghi 5�*6� �� � : �������+, ����* g�i 5�*6� �� � : ������-b�*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
X�ghi* EK�/ +s.��,�� �� 7�� ��2�/ ��� Go�"��!!
�_�8; !(�� �� lI ����� mL? ];�e ���–EAN� �A� �� �{− [e OIEÀ ,��6� �� �(��"�� «+�=� �� .��,�� b���3 EAN� �A� �� �{ Y8 ��
J1 � 26)�s ,P6#Fq lI P6,��� !" _� � � �s�2_� �(}F_ Y��� ����� �5 _ �>�:s�4V�#��!
IRH �G" cL� H � d��� eR H��> 9`� ;�@L)Y ZY> DY� _B�( ?'�()�� ;$)0 f� e)g Z 6� �"PY �OV:A�� , ,�G/Y ;)O> e)0 . I��/� ;6"h� eL(
�i$)0 �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g Z 6� �"P� ,;$ j f� V=P� ,�>�"� k" ����� H��>�e07� .�G" � WP� eL( � l)^6� .> '�7l/�� �$Y4��"m�= �n��" �>�"� ;Y �op�
�)�� ;$)0 f� e)g ;Y V=> �" ?7� ,�M6" C�`=P$� 3�LI �M@" af� H q��� [ ;Y�LI r ?'�� �`O���J����I��H��G��F��E��D��C��B��A
��������������[��Z��Y��X��W��V��UT������S��R��Q��P��O��N������ ���M��L��K��j�� � �i��h��g��f��e���d��c��ba��`��� �_��^��]��\
�s��r��q��p��o��n��m��lk\g�ia IIIISSSSHHHH V=> Z 6� D$G/L� .> �)�� ;$)0 f� e)gs�!� r �S�# �'�� ,
1�l� f� �'� @Y �/@L� �Q>� :Û , ��� ��� ��� �� ����� ���� �� �! "� #$%�&'(�� �)*+�� , �'� �� ,�! � �(-� .-/)0 �1�� #$� :3)���� �45��Üa
ghi 5�*6� �� � : ������-b�* g�i 5�*6� �� � : �������+, ����*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
� i��t .�L*j�u�> D$Y C�(�6< �S�v� .�I eL( N�6� D" wH$< x/� ���iY�� y7j!��a
IUH ,.�G/�� .�"4� 3��lLY �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g C�� =R ��Mz H@{�Y�S �@��*� H8�� � �/I ,�Y��lL" s�!� 5�4<> K)@< ZL�� Hl6�� 1�%W
�)�� ;$)0 f� e)g Z 6� V=>: Û 6+ 7�� 89:; < &;� # �&�� =� :1� >15 ?�! ���� Üa >9: x@Y eR �M|@Y �|�� } ^AWa
IVH g C�� =R 7@Y 1�/ ~�� eR �<�( r ' @j D �6jPY �)�� ;$)0 f� e))0 f� e)g 1�l� �7�7< H8��� � Mz.�"4� �=2 &�'�(> r �)�� ;$ :
Û �)�$ >@7A� B� CB:�� %D�1A1��Üa �Sl� :1�/ ~��a ş�Ûa@åÇ@ò�ş�Ûa@åÇ@ò�ş�Ûa@åÇ@ò�ş�Ûa@åÇ@ò�kzkzkzkz@ @@ @@ @@ @
��Q!� HG�A$ 146�� ,5�/*� < r �$^W ��S/0 1 $� D0 ��� 0 3�*���Y��� �$� �� C�$/��a
s�!� _)� r � �� ��$Lj . GLW �$� �� C�$/� .> . 6�� 5�"7l� .�I� �M$R �$/� C�$" Hl6W– Z^��!� ��^�− �" �gS= .2�l� 1 l� �/6$Y ,
.> O� ,�l� �)$)� ' l0 `6" �)@� ; Hg W C�$" �O�7%" �$� �� C�$/�[ ��^"!���Ò��Ñ��Ð����Ï��Î�Ù��Ø��×��Ö��Õ��Ô��Ó\ghia
� �� y$� ,���^"!� D" �j GL/� k$Y�6$� O ;$� �� C��$/� �7%/����l� �/0 r ZL� ^��>a
�/� e)0> ����L� } L*" eR C' @g� 5�/� �: W ��$Lj 3�*� . GL��
ghi �"4� �� � : �����+��*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
����l� ����> eR _*� �I� � il8�0 1� �� �$%W � eL( ,�i �� 1� ��[�µ����Ã���Â��Á���À��¿�� ¾½��¼��»��º��¹���¸��¶
Æ�������Å��Ä\ghia ��'�u" �70 r y$8� _ � �$)@� ��l ^� r �� �'��Y .> _$�@� D"�
5�/� k$|$� _I� G� D$Y �" eR s�!� � 3�*�, 3�:W Z�L�Y�[ ��$� X� LW � s�!����L��K��J��IH��G��F��E��D��C��B��A
�N���M\g�ia `� �$8��4$� e�> 70�%L/� 5�/� 3�O}�=> i��" ;�4j �� ;@/�W D" � �`� ,
;�{Y �6$)0 f� �DL"�a X${:� 5�/� ��:Y 7@%� �"760�j ����� ��LW ,�: � ��$)/0 ��$L
�� ,5�/� ��:Y ��]�4< �� u� ���o 1 ( k/�LL� �� u� ���`Y �)//� iY�� �$%L� ��]�4�� �)W �:|LW C�$/� D" ��j ��� ����$)" ;Y � i�S/0 �
[ 5�/*� < r � /"�����«��ª��©���¨��§���¦��¥��¤��£��¢�¬\g ia
.> r ���g ����� 5�/� ��:Y k/�W �" �R� 3�*� �$�AW ZL� ZO ������$*{� s�!� < ��l B r � iM8�W 5�/� ��:Y H�� ,_� HGt e)0a
" �M ����� C`O� _*� �I�( � |W &$Y ��<�' ?S� D" �" �6
ghi T��0!� �� � : ������,�* g�i . 6"h/� �� � : ��������* g i ���� �� � : ��������*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
����� �<�' ��6M� ,��<�7� C`O D$Y H=�7W .�' �O�$�W� �M@��W� �M)l6W� E�{W�� eL( s�� �lgS/� ZO� ��'�@�� ?�{6� ��$L� �<�' �PW �� 1�$">
�0�*Y ���� ZO�+-- ,5Zt HI ��"7 s��� eR K4j � �0�*� r H$"� K*$� �0�*Y ��"7/� �$g�0!,� ZO� ����� �<�7� �PW� ,�V0 �R H$"
} L*" 760� c�� SY �l^6" ZO� � � c^� } L*" F � 1�$">a �*� HG�LW .> 7@Y �M/� _*� D" 5�/� 146� ,�M c��� ����pY _
_�0> �" �6/Y−5Z<�{/� _G*� � ���^l� �" �6"− �)W �)*W� ,� r ���^l� ,�I�� �$@L� s�!� �Mz e)0 7I�W �� D{@LW .> .�' s�!
r s�!� c^� D" �i ��� H�W HY ,�� k{L6j S� s�!� DB�Y r � uW �� 146� ZL� � :%� �$"�*" .> �6nU�� � ;�i6$@"� � i@Y�j �O��" H��� ,�6��6L"
�� D^Y r 5�/� ��u X@|) �l� �'�� �M���0 D$Y �^/� 5�" �"� s� �M$)0 d$@� ZL� �$� �� C�$/� �" �6" ���Q�� iS$ � ;$R �6@^L���- % D"
�� � − �{( c$L� 9`� 7� �`� � :%� ��*" .> �/@j e)0 . �$@� 9> i�7$@Y C� � y$� 5�/� s�!� _)� r− ZL� �/@6� C`� �j�I`A� �l� f�� ,
[ ;j� � 1 l$� �M K{L)j � �/Y��n���v�� � � �u��t� �s�� � � �r��q�� � �p� �ow\ghia
@(/$� :لكن هنا السؤال اهلام� �$O�{/� C`O ���G� .2�l� � n X$I �/@j� �$� �� C�$/� HG�W �l��B� �M�4j� _*� . GW �${$G �$%�
5�/� � �� �70?
ghi �)/� �� � : ������-�*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
ZL� � |� �`� �@6� C`O �6 �� �7� 5�$/@� �@$ ^� .> sU{j X$I �� 6 �6O ��6I �/ �7(�� �" �6" �M6" K)L=� _LG?iSg>
ñìjäÛa@Ýöü…@òÜàØnÛ@…ìÈã:@ @IIIIWWWWHHHH ,S<ps 2A©� C $�<��� 5e��� SA�/� $�<��� 12j� 2A©�
[��f��e��d��c���b���a��`��_��~��}���|��{��zn��m��l���k����j��ih��g\ghi*
�;�p8N �;}¯� ,1� �� J�L� �� ����ZN� E�/ �� @ E?��A= ]:U; +AKs PUR G/ EAN� �A� �� �{ Y8 �� EA� [Ks ,�?^� � ���A= E&28N �;/
?��k� b�"V� C P�2A= $�<��� A� �� �{ Y8 �� EA� [e?`k� [R�� 2A©� �U; G/ EAN� �!! s Y�
��=12 !6� Y,� � Pd��d�� P ���� $�<��� Sj��, §�� Y? `|V� §�)�s �L�� S<ps 2A©�[��d��c���b���a��`��_��~��}���|��{��z
n��m��l� � �k� � � �j� � ih��g��f��e\g�i ,�� ��s�0� �� ����¬�� �¾*�(1� *
IIIIXXXXHHHH b�� 7��hÇÄÄ G/ lI ,P���M� ^� P"6� ¦���/ ��=� >�Ks ];�e b�� !(��/ C G�s�;2 KN�� �+A#�� °��hÇÄÄ �L"_ ,��V� �MN ]B ¦���/
P"6� ��#3/ �� ��{��w��[��g��f��e��d��c��b��a��`���_����~
ghi 5�*6� �� � : ������b�* g�i 5�*6� �� � : ������b�*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
j��i���h\ghi* IIIIYYYYHHHH !?/ m2· �V ��#;� �6N�� E_�� Y8 �� P�{ P"s��� C ��s�{�� J��K��E,8� Fe, [��m� � �l��k��j��i��h��g��f���e��d
o��n\g�i* y; ��<3� b��� lI >�1���� C ��y;�� 2� 26² EN–EAN� �A� �� �{ −
P�}#��3 ** �"M; 26² ,E�k� 7,�y� lI P3�#�� P�Z�� C �1�j �� ��Z� .L�� � �P3��e� P��_ C The KJV Old Testament Hebrew Lexicon
Original Word �+y�� lI 46�� �� :dmxm '3�M�_ Y _%�� 'M ��3� ��"26²" Transliterated Word Machmad Phonetic
Spelling…. makh-mawd' m� #� .L��� �<V� �3 Ë�3 .L�� b��"�� $��Ae1�8�� b��� lI !:;�� C�
!U�_ !#s/ P;�;���3 9���� �? Q� $��Ae�1�8��� ,2Ò/ ./ 26)� �� F� +e $2"�� ¦���1�j �� 1�8�/; �<V� S?L� 7�� ®�� �� $��Ae1�8�� Gk ,
�s �8 _ .L�� 1��)� �L? !8R P��Ò P~? ¿� �<V� �� �5; $2"�� 9�������� <3 2Ò/ b�2"3*
IIIIQQQQPPPPHHHH− b2s ��1�/ J��e C ��=− �2� $2"V� J��K��$�2 &� − [{��3 EAN� �A� �� �{ Y8 ����#;� �6N :Û 43 26² �#8F� ,��#6N� $� �� �À/
ghi � 6� �� � : ������-�* g�i T��0!� �� � : �������,�*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
P ©� C 7�� 26 FB ��6W�� ,$� �� �,@/Ü* â �5©��Ä!js ,h�Ã>�"s ,ÃÄ , ��1�8�h− £*
��¥ C ��=�E;��3 :Û`�#�� O��NF/ 26² �#8F� 4)� r�O C , �,M F�>�,MV� Q6�3− Q6� ���Aj��−Ü* â �5©�� !j��� ��1�8� ���
�?2#3£* IQSH@ ;$)0 f� e)g Z 6�Y ���� � H/W � $� eR N�76M� _LI K�� �"��)��ghia
The Sanskrit text and translation of Verse 5 of
Bhavishya Puran, Prati Sarg Parv III: 3, 3 are given
below. (The boxed area in the Sanskrit text identifies the
word Mahamad or Mohammad).
A malechha (belonging to a foreign country and
speaking foreign language) spiritual teacher will appear
with his companions. His name will be Mahamad...
The translation of Verses 5-27 (Sanskrit text of the
Puranas, Prati Sarg Parv III: 3, 3) is presented below
i1g Bhavishya puran: prati sarg, part lll: 3, 3, 5* PROPHET MUHAMMAD IN HINDU SCRIPTURES. http://www.cyberistan.org/islamic/prophhs.html*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
from the work of Dr. Vidyarthi.
“A malechha (belonging to a foreign country and
speaking foreign language) spiritual teacher will appear
with his companions. His name will be Mahamad. Raja
(Bhoj) after giving this Mahadev Arab (of angelic
disposition) a bath in the 'Panchgavya' and the Ganges
water, (i.e. purging him of all sins) offered him the
presents of his sincere devotion and showing him all
reverence said, 'I make obeisance to thee.' 'O Ye! the
pride of mankind, the dweller in Arabia, Ye have
collected a great force to kill the Devil and you yourself
have been protected from the malechha opponents (idol
worshipers, pagans).' ‘O Ye! the image of the Most Pious
God the biggest Lord, I am a slave to thee, take me as
one lying on thy feet.'
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
ô�ØÛa@ñõìjäÛa@ @[������������������ª��©��¨��§���¦��¥��¤��£��¢��¡�����~��}
���º��¹��¸��¶��µ´��³��²��±�� � � � �°��¯�� ®¬��«���Å��Ä����Ã��Â��ÁÀ��¿������� �¾��½¼�����»��G��F��E��D��CB��A
�L���K���J����I��H\ghi* Y8 �� G�e 2"�EAN� �A� �� �{ b�5,V� 1�j�;�3 �8 ��–b���� − ��K� .L��
� �""B C 2#3/ �� �� �� .L�� � �� �L& ��"R� ��2��� �20� ,�6j EA<�<� � *
C G�6A<V� �,s G�e Y��� >Z��� �%a $����� b���� 43 n1�#V� �2�u� P N PN1�s PAÒ ��R 2R 5���3/ G�e 2"s 4e�V� �� ����k� G�;�#� PK�Éhh
Ý�_#� C b���� �� �N�e 1�j�;�3 ]= Pe�M;/ Pe�– ]V� �p8�� J�R − P NÉhÅ ��N��� G5�/ 2R }� �L? G�e�–EAN� �A� �� �{− 4e�V� 9�s/�*
�C G<ة وSG�- � C T 1/�تU�+ Q/(ن ا��V(>ء ا��G0:
IQH s�!� ej'> r K ) A� ���� .>a C`O H@{�Y� ��@�Y �l^6" x{=> 9> K@�� ZL� ZO� K$/� � � 3�� klW �l^6/��M6" �i ��� �I�@/�g�ia
IIIIRRRRHHHH E,�6�5? 2#3 b���� G/ Í?2�� EW� 2�� C E��K�� Go�"�� 1�"�
ghi ���� �� � : �����+−b�* g�i >K$/� � � 3�� ��@�Y �l^6" x{=*
http://en.wikipediaorg/wiki/extretremes-on-earth
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
m2�� �� [A¯ � �� 2�� �L?� 4 N �U3 C G��� N*
?�� 3/ �s� ��� �K3 '�2j��–� � �� ¸1 − G/ Í��R !?/ �� G�?�A� �� 4 N �U3 C �� �N b���� −Ç ��� N*
�¬� b�� �;�eO +e ]H2� Y��� Pe�#V� mL? 2#3� Pe�M;/ Pe�#V ��#;ÉhÅ PN1���� Ñ�©� �=� C ["_ b���� �K_ ` ��� N �<_ PAq� b, ];�e !3
�PMR�N l���_ G2V� �3/ G�e� ��a/ �A_ >2������� �3L�� Q(� K�� §�0 5��, ���/ 4#<_ !�R �?2�� $2"�� C �;/ ���� 7�� �, � «5�;� EH 4p<V� �� �
P��� �� P�%� mL? ];�e� ��8Aj�� SA{ �?� b���� 2 � Y �� 5�1 $2R/b����*
�¬� ��2� 1�j�;k� C !�/ ±j3 7;�/ 2=�� � b�� lI� �ÉhÉ G�eP���5�� E& $���� b�� P�12 KN�� ���5�;�� `�#�� CÉhÉ lI G�� � A{�� b
b�#��ÉhÇ �"pN b���� G�"p<�� G��� � $����� b�, PA,V� ��,�;� �� '8� `� �R1�� b���� rA� !R�? G�e >Z��� mL? C� ��� N �31/ �I Go�"�� �?�2� Y��� �
��< �� >�R�#�� �6�� �,A�� C� ,� ��2�� � � vR�<�_ �2A3 G2V� 2R� �a�� 2#3 � $��A� P#3�_ �1�{� �� Hk� rA_ C �� � � ]M"N ** �>�:s EH PW"�� t2B
!R�& >�=��V�– ��e ^8#_ 2� �� ¶�1���� J�− Se��� ��LAV� ��� �:,s9%<�� 'y�6�� $���� !!
C EH �U�/ !3�"V�,PN�K#� �, K� PAH�¤ >�?�@ ]H2� � 5���3/ 2:; OI �>�:s [R��� >��"�� �� , -�p; �� �,A�� C Q6w �� T��� , C �5�#N ��
, ��LAV� C Q6w � ��:�N23 �RG�e� �� 4_�p �� 5�B �? !��y�� �Awu
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� �_�=� !�/ ��^y� ��d� ]p;%��o PH%H �?�2� ¾A3 ®!!
��k b���� ���{ C Sj_ $����� b���� 43 ��u�� V� �/23� >�� ���� ���5_ ��u�� V� ]A@� 43 Pe�#V� ]H2� G/ lI b���� ���{ C b�� 2#3 �
b�� $����� b����� b�y�� �%3 !e !3 S<ps Pe�M;/ Q� b���� �ZN�� ���� ��� N �<�3 P6�5&� 2#3 ./ $���� ��Go�"�� �8 _ +e �, P N ��ŠG�e b
123 �; b�� ��1�N �� $���� ��q *@ � ���� !R�? ! P6{�� !��� 7�� � ��8Aj�� SA{ �, � �=ZN�� $1�s*
!R�? �6�N� ��� �"_ ` �� ? mL,e >��8; �� ��2pA� Go�"�� �s2� .L�� �� �R1�� >��2�� ]M"<� �_�LA� C �!!***
,��(�8; ]""B� r�O �� t2B Go�"�� �K� 2#3 �� b��A� 1�j�;� ��/ G�Ks_ 2#3 P����V� E,6(�5?Pe�M;/ C E,�6�5? �� v8U��3 ��� N �<*
�8 Á= 1���I Î1|V� ��"�Edward Gibbon " �8 _ 4� ,]R��� r�O C_ ` ,>��8 �� mL¥ Go�"�� ���R� �, � Æ2#3/ ->��8; P�/ �K�; l�k� �#�� 4 <�� Gk
��,�;�3 GO|_ ];�e !R�? P��K� ����P;������ P�1�q}�"ghi*
ghi �� � l�� ��7j� ����W 7)�/� ,�$j�"��� ��� B�V"� �,�y�� " 9' ;$< �@ B ,*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
@òÜàØnÛ@…ìÈãñìjäÛa@Ýöü…:@ @IIIIQQQQHHHH − �? b%N��s E�2"�� 2,#�� ��8;/ �� >2"� �_2"� C 's��� b%N��
G2� �� E�2"�� 2,#�� ��8;/ �, � >���I� ,]s�p;� Y��� ��;��2�� 1�<V �pj_ G�1�?� Q;��� ������ 7N��� E?��3I� ��?� J��/� ���{� 9�; lI b�o
7<��, ��#� ��|? >2"#s "� Y? >1����� °�A3 2��� J1 � &I J��� >2!:;���, �� >�p� � P&o ��� �� E;�R/ �� �Ad_ ��#_ � Y��� >2"#�� mL?
��a/ P&o �� P&o «�5�;� − J�� �� $2"�� 9���� «�5�;�− P��R P&o ��, l�#_ ��"�: ����u� �t� � �s��r��q� �p� �o��n� �m��l� �k� �j
�}��|��{z��y��x��w��v���f��e��d�����c��ba��`��_���~r��q��p��o��n��m��l��k���j��ih��g�ghi*
e�@W 1���: ���M���LK��J��I��H���G��F�������E����D���C�����B��V��U��T��S���R��Q��P��O��N
\��[��Z���YX��W�g�i* إذن فاإلسالم ليس ديانة كالديانات وإنما هو أصل الديانات
وباألخص اليهودية ،الديانات وتصحيح للخلل الذي أصاب
.والمسيحية في نسختيهما العهد القديم والجديد
ghi �1�y�� >1�N : P���gh i* g�i ��< �� >1�N : P���ghÉ i*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
��� ����������������������א�� � 1��e� ��"�28� J�:² –�� �Ò1 − .L��� ,�N� 3 ����<�� ��U��� `�� b�� !(��/ C C�_�ÄhÅ*
e�@W f� 1�� �"760: ��Z���Y�����X������ � � � � �W��V��U��T��S�����]��\��[����l��k��j��i��h��g�����f��e��d��c����b��a��`��_��^
t��s��r��q��p��o��n��m�ghi*
K���Y�����X�����������W��V��U��T��S���Y�����X�����������W��V��U��T��S���Y�����X�����������W��V��U��T��S���Y�����X�����������W��V��U��T��SL XYه;� وا �;�� : وا�� { ��23 lI �W _ `/�_12R� �� , m2�� !W�� v<3 [e *���5�� �� ���2�3� 1�, �� ]R� lI >1�u��� ,
[j� � ��1�, �� , �%W�� ��q >��� ]R� �?�* �88N C ^K��A� ��"� !W�� 2� P�e C J�AMV� !������, �88N G/ 2: s
J�w��� §��� m��� C �,<�; ��� x1k� G�1��* ��#_� �;�p8N �� >��1I ��N ��88N �� �;2=� ��, �����=/ G/ r�O P��+N
�,<�; ��� 1�2_ � >^de , �1�� GI Y?�P���� ��?��� C 1�2_ �,<�; ���, �A� �? �� ^� ¿� x1k� G�1�� G�K� G/ Y#8q G�;�R ./ �R� � �¤ QAs,
Pc�Z�� PA6©� ���= r�L�� :��]��\��[����Z �* ÁÔÏ@´nÛby@¿@�bä×b�@æìØí@b¸g@ìçë : x1k� G�KN P��� C/ ���1�� P��� C �
��+u� ��3� = �,<�; ���, � G�K��Pc�Z��� PA6©� Y # : !#© �� ��u �� �1�{ !3 �%W�� ]A�a� �V GOI� ��3� =� ��+u ���1�� !#= �/ P e�N x1k�
ghi G�R���� >1�N : P���gŽ−ÅÃi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Q6y�� �=��� .L�� x1k� [j; C P e�N , �)�3 G�<;�� >�� �12K���j �� �L? ¿� E(�2���ak� [j �� ¿� E(�2�� �}��� [, �� r�O C G�K� ��
�� �R� � P#8M�� 4;��"�� �� G�<;�� EA#�* �$ @L� 1�/@L�� K@<�� 7l���[�� � �Z� ���G� .��l� r, r �7< �
" �]$t ;��7( x��6� � �/" . G� �$ @L� 7@Y '�� �" .R ���� HI�/ �)@jD$j� l�� D6*� D" , f� �'��R _ *Y k�� � r ?7� � ;6G� a
ÙÛ‡@òÜrßc@åßZ@ @
�� �q� �pu� �t� �s��r�ghi ,���ä� �ã� �â� � � �á� �à
å�g�i ,�b��a�� �`��_��^� �]� �\��[�g i ,���Y� �X��W_���^��]��\��[��Z�gÅi ,��¦��¥��¤�� �£�� �¢�g½i, eR
2���� �=��$�I ZO� �, �� �)/�� C`O 7@Y�$n�U0: K��������b��a�� ��_��^����b��a�� ��_��^����b��a�� ��_��^����b��a�� ��_��^L
������ � ? K$� L�� _$WU� 7${W ,9>: KW H�� 7" H/LG� .> 7@Y�66$0> ,;$)0 �6)$' y/�� . GW , Z)0 �`@L� .> 7@Y H$)lY 3��u� H$ � �o�
1S�� '�7L"� �@Y�L" N�6�RH=�7LW� K{:W� 7@ W� 1 ^W o , kn " . G$�
ghi >2(�V� >1�N : P���gżi* g�i b�#;k� >1�N : P���g ½i* g i >�"8�� >1�N : P���g�½ i* gÅi Q;�� >1�N : P���gÇÇi* g½i ��< �� >1�N : P���gÇÄi*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�M$)0 �6)$' y/�� , _*j .> k$^L*j �M@n " 7�7W� y/�) ��6�Y� �/" C'�7(� ;O��W�� H�� 1 B i��*$L" .�I 1��4� K�� D" �t� /� N�$l�Y
3��u� H$ � D$� �`O eL(a ��12R §���� 2#3 �,���_1� 7�� �%W�� ¿� � A�� Q6y�� �6�<_� �K6�
!W�� P#3��� �� G�<;�� ��8V� $�"��3 x1k� �=� ¿�, fp � G�� m�^s���U���, P��� ���= r�L��: K����h��g�����f��e��dh��g�����f��e��dh��g�����f��e��dh��g�����f��e��dL °�%;������� S_Z�� ê�"V ��a/ >��
]R����� *���5�� ]R� 7�� !W�� 1�<p;� �6�<�� , ����� � A6e/ 2R G�K s �%��e ���5�� ��lI ���5�� , �,<�; ��� x1k� ��1�� �� PA��e >1�� ./
��3��� ��R� *�?1�<p;�� �%W�� ��2��� '"0 G�1�2�� �L?� , !A�� �U�/ '"0�1�, ���, P��� ���= r�L�: K����t��s��r��q��p��o��n��m�� � �l��k��jt��s��r��q��p��o��n��m�� � �l��k��jt��s��r��q��p��o��n��m�� � �l��k��jt��s��r��q��p��o��n��m�� � �l��k��j L ./:
1�, ��� !A�� C ��88N �U�/ x1k� G�1�� !#= ,>�)� E"�<_ +¥� ,I !A�� C O E,y��#�� $� �� 1�y�;� 1�, �� C� b� ��3 G�23Ô� P��1� ZN*
�,<�; ��� x1� ��3��� ��R� G�1�2�� !e !? ���<�; �K�� '"0 P / G�1�2�� �2#V G/ P3�=�� ? 1�, ��� !A�� SR�#�3 >�"�<V� P8M�� Py#V�
�L? C ��jR , 1�, �� ��q� !A�� ��q �20 .L�� �? OI *�#� �� G�<;�� � �;�;�R �#8q �� -��� �2#63 �,<�; ��� x1k� 1�2_ G/ � 6� �2=�, �+<�� Y�s
�,<�; ��� 1�2_ P��A#� b��=/ >2����� P;�d�� C >�� 4H%H �2#63 �2#63 �,<�; ��� 1�2_ x1k� !#= ��#_� �;�p8N �� ^32_ �K��
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
4#� , �%� G�23k� P��1 ]""B �p3 1�, �� � !A�� SR�#_ �� �K� !jB� �1�� Í��#V�� 2{�"V��, G�8���� G�8�� P��w3 r�L� 1�u/ 2"�� , °�� C�hhhh�
P��� C: K����h� �g� � � � �f� �e��dh� �g� � � � �f� �e��dh� �g� � � � �f� �e��dh� �g� � � � �f� �e��dL 9>: r �]$�� �]$t �*6� H�� H@<
�.PW� �*�� ��7W a f� ��� W> D$l�:� D*(a ���a��`��_��^��]��\��[����Z���Y�����X������� �� ��W��V��U��T��S
��p��o��n��m����l��k��j��i��h��g�����f��e��d��c����bt��s��r��q�ghi*
���اد�أوا� ���
ghi G�R���� >1�N : P���gŽ−ÅÃi*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
@…ìÈãñìjäÛa@Ýöü…@òÜàØnÛ:@ @IIIIQQQQSSSSHHHH 26�<� � �1��N� �U� G/ PK� !?k v�1��R �� E w�� 7��� !=�� [e
?E, ;��R� E?���� G��a��� G���k� � � / !N1�� 1�"� * �1�<��3Marcel A. Boisard G/ PA"�<� PN�1� C :
"Y�%N�� �"��� ������ �� $�Nk�3 >26�<� ��2)� ��2�� G�;�"�� ��{/*" G�A3�; ���_�Napoleonic Code , French civil code 26�< F�
YK��V� �"��� ��* E_� !3 C G�;�"��� ����A� YV�� 12j6e P�%N�� P#����3 ��Z���
b�� L � P6A#�� P��2�� ����|V� �� �2�ghÇ �b i�, �:h − G1�"V� G�;�"�� b�� .�?� C ��2��hÇ �b*�− ��|� b�� C 2"# V� .�?�hÇ Ãb* − ��|�
.�?� C G1�"V� G�;�"��hÇ ¼b*Å− b�� ��2�� ��|V�hÇŽ�M u��3 b*½− G1�"V� G�;�"A� ��2�� �6:V�3 §�")� P8#uhǽhQ�1�83 b*
��|V� mL? �� �12{ 2R��� Y? P��? ��1��R: /− ������ 1�8����� P;1�"V � �#3�1 � �12j� Y�%N���(��* J− � ���L3 P6(�R P�%N�� P#����
��a/ P#�� ./ lI �/ ������� G�;�"�� lI ]�* ¦− "��� P�%{ � Y�%N��P K�k�� P �k� �6©* � − ��U"�� C P�%N�� P#���� !d� P6K²� ��2��
P��2�� �2#��*
IIIIQQQQTTTTHHHH �R �� E w�� 7��� !=1 EA#� [e/ PK� !?k v�1�� ���_�/ ��8©� G ?
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
[�Z��Y\ghi* 1��e2�� ��"�André Cailleux �3��e C"x1k� ���_" :
The mountains, like pegs, have deep roots embedded
in the ground, These roots are deeply embedded in the
ground, thus, a mountain have a shape like peg* FU�1�: �8y_ ��8©� mL? ,x1k� C P"6� ��1�L= rA� Y,s ��_�k�
2_��� �8y� !8©� !Ku G´s r�L�� x1k� C '6#3 >2�¤ 1�L©�* ?F3*A�1� F*j�1�*D� F^(1� l`� ��
IIIIQQQQUUUUHHHH �8 �� [e–EAN� �A� �� �{− / G/ �,A� 7��2��N EH �dK�N ��� Fk�E� ?
Û 4D E�� FD %� G��� G()-+ >+�H; #� IJ9� >-+ 6-D�� >+�H; �1@K�ÌP 1��: �6)�: `]" � �6Y �)� D"> f� 1 �� ��? L � :Í �)MD NO�9� G1P�
F)7�� Q M�D Q MR #9P9(; %(��, S F@T�� GD�H+ =9-� %� 6� �4�� U&1'�%V9�� G(�9-�ÌW 1��: �6)�: DO � �"�? L �: ÍX94�� 6)V��D� Y )Z�� [5Üg�i*
IQVH Z 6� V=>− �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g– \�9Z� ]^��!� U�0� #� ]� \H� %��9_���7%�Y �O7� 1 ^ �M60 f� Zn� _6�� Kj�G� , �g i a
ghi �8 �� >1�N : P���gÃi* g�i �pp{���©� �p{ C ��8�k�* g i �/M$$g r �)*"� 9��: � C���*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
IIIIQQQQWWWWHHHH _�C31� �i��1� ��A06 :C Go�"�� �5; 2"s �P��js b��Rk� EW�/ �P�%3� PwA��� P��j���3 1�8�A� §��Nk� 2"#F_ ];�e�, ��:s�� C Go�" P=1�
J�#�� Se��_ C �,Ad� 2,#F� ` P�%8�� ��, ��"��*>5� �3 SM�� :" ];�e����k�3 Y w���� �5w��� ��2?�yV� [{� C �?�de/ J�#�� P��js, G�e�
�pjs ��= Go�"��� m^� 2 � [#U� ��2V� �"�� .L�� ���y���s !e C �, �� V QN��A� Go�"�� ��=� '< ��� ���<V� Q�; PN�<��� ��j�R�� C >�� �,
Y�%8�� �8��R �� ¦�¯ G/ G�� �;2��� ��2�� �< F0 ��� >��8#���, mL? C �A�/� S�5B� Ñ�©� �6� G/ ��|? �/�s �Ad63 ��_�� G/ ��|? .2B �� PWpA�� Go�"�� Pc1�#� �� f�/� G�?/ �� ��N1 P31�pV !(�8"�� S��_� J�5�k�
.2p��� ��8R� , Go�"�� �L& ��#6<_ � G���"�� P��; �� !(�8"�� G�8�|� ��;�Ks2�2©� ��2�� Pc1�#V E?2,= ¾��3 �L,s ��a/ P��; ��, G�~8�¯ ��;�e E�I EH
m�p<� E¥�L:;� T�s �� Go�"�� G�#6�<� ����s, �:��� J�R ��A3�"_ �OI 7���LK?� �,AdV ����#� �/ ��#��, P6Ae ]#6�=� �L�� �/ �� J�#�� ��s�
P���"V 2���� !8<�� �? �L? G/ ��}���� E,A?/ m�#6<F� �� Go�"A� ��#6<� Go�"�� �L? !d63 .2p���[���§����¦��¥���� � � �¤��£��¢��¡�����~��}
¨\ghi* IIIIQQQQXXXXHHHH [e ��–EAN� �A� �� �{ − G/ �8 ��G�3 >��#�� >��)� C E w�� >��1
N �A� C G���M�? G� 8��
ghi K)%� �� � : �����+b�*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� C P�Aa ¦�3k� ��1��`�#�� C ��q, �=�3 >2= C P���#<�� Y 8_�� ? � � ��q/! P;�N�a �?��@ ��/ PV�#�� ^��#V� C G�� �A� G2� [ jF_� !3
PR%6�! �� EAN� �A� �� �{ ËY8 �� ��N ��2 � ���#V� !�}= ��2� Y�s
��R� P��<�� :�1��/ �� �}a/� *EAN� �A� �� �{ ��"s :Û , �1�� 6��� H-; #�# )'/�� S #9�� *1� Q ��� Q +� 6� @�� Y��@�� Y `Z�� �; #��Üghi*
IIIIQQQQYYYYHHHH .�)" K6Y ���( �> �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g V=> \0 PA� #� ]1�� %� \Y�&R �Z/�� #9/D�)0 "� F)/0 S, H�� �Z/�� Y�&R S Q�H���� L�� �V #9(10�
# Dg�i* IRPH �/( D$0!� ��ug �U� HW�l6� �6j> �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g V=>
���^/� 1��/� �MO <� .PI T j!� Xo C < �, DY� �S�v� �$t 1 l��$/$W :Û. /)*/� �M)W�� �M)I X8� ^� 5�hO�, ZO C`O� ��LL� �O 5�hO�
�ML{gÜg i a
IRQH �'�� ?�7Y �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g C�� =R, i7@ L*" .�I �`O .> k" � i"�/WC�%0 r �, i<� �> D�7) . WP� N�6� .�I� �/� ;IU �O� Mz �)*AW� �
�G*/W �R �`O �O7�4�� .�I 7�� a
IRRH �G" 9> '�@" eR C'�$� ;j> ; �� f� V=> ,[��D��C��B�� �A
ghi �)*" C���* g�i �/M$$g r �)*"� 9��: � C���* g i ,c$%� 3� ��+���*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
H���G��F��E\ghi , i�<�M" �M6" ��= .> 7@Y 7�� �6�7/� eR ;6�7Y � �Wa
IRSH �M���� D$l)" ;LY�g� ���� 7�*/� H=7$� ;j> CV=>��W 7�� D��%l"� [��±��°��¯��®��¬��«��ª���©��¨
²\g�ia IRTH V$= cL� O� �=2 cL� . G$� ���� 7�*/� 1 =' 7@Y ;j> CV=>�
[ �W 7���À��¿���¾��½��¼��»\g ia IRUH i���� Z6u� T � ;j> e�@W f� V=>[ �W 7�� ���W��V��U
��c� �b� �a� �`� �_� �^� �]� � � \[� �Z� �Y� �Xd\gÅia IRVH � /� e6/Lj Dj � l� .PY � /� � 6/L� .> ' M$� .2�l� }7W,
i/L( M� �0�*� �)W r � /� e6/W D" .> . /)@� �Q! � ��:�� /$� �, ; � Y�<> }7L� .> k" ,5�$(> � )z� N� 0 DY� 1�� � 07� K^l*
� W�/ � /� ' M$� e6/W aa/W �/�; �`GW e)0 7�7�� �Mg�( e)0 C 6: [��A��O��N��M��L��K���J��I��H��G��F���E��D���� � � �C��B
�\��[��Z��YX��W��V��U��T��S���R��Q��P \g½ia
ghi �%l� �� � : ��������* g�i cL{� �� � : �����+,�* g i cL{� �� � : �����+,�* gÅi �� � �Y L� : �����+��* g½i ��l � �� � : �������, ���*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
IRWH � .> .2�l� V=> 7$ �l� e)%$�� �{G� e)0 � /$� C�$u/� DY, 7�� .�I[���g��f\ghia IRXH ;j> V=>� – ��$u/� DY� 7$ �− �$�I D$6 Y F� A�D� �'��4� r k/^��
[ SI DG�ß��Þ���� ��� �Ý���� ��Ü��ÛÚ\g�i ,D��=2 D$6 Y F� A� � �> , KMLj� �)�> � 07� !!aa IRYH . �/� �){) H$�" D0 ���G� .2�l� ?7W[��D��C� �B� �A
O��N��M��L��K���J��I����H��G��F��E\g ia ?�Sg� /) }�=A> H8��� D0 �5 j DGW � .R ;)$�" O �/�
ISPH e�@W 1 l�: [�Æ��Å�����Ä��Ã��Â\gÅia � 5�/*� �6O 5�|� D" �M ( �"� �S�!� �'�" ZO aaaZ6 " 5�|{� HM�
5��4${� 5�/)0 760? ��0 r ???���b &Y r �"�@� ;L���j D��L�6�� �: �)�" r ��jannalen derphysic �$Y D" H�> r Db- 5�|{� .> �{g
?'� � ;$)0 e)�LW ��L� '��" y$, ���^Y ��PLW ;$���> �$6Y ;*{j O HY�ML)LGY� �M� � ZL� ��*<!�, � e)0 .��Y yI�" �)0 7��; lY ����6: "
����6� Z �7 W> i���jR ��0> �Q� �@$ ^� D0 9�� � �G{� ;ll(, ��0> �Q>� ���M/�� Z8��4${� ��Mv�� � ���� �${*){� ���6� D$Y k/�� HO`" _$I�W
ghi ��7/� �� � : �����+b�* g�i ��7/� �� � : ������b�* g i y� �� � : ������� −�+�* gÅi �����`� �� � : ������,�*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�$n����"a �/��G� ���� Z��Y �">���� � ,.� I�� �� ���� �4�@/� D/
�� �O> �$G){� �����LI. G� k� W O en�/� .�l� ¡ , 5�6@ ��Lj �� 1 7" �M� ¡ �$ I�Æ��Å� ej G� k� L� 7${W eL� �Expanding
universe �`O �6L�� eL(� . G� �) A= `6", �$Y �" �`O� D" c g>� �)@� ;6 k� W �� �R ���B D0 &$( Zn�/� .�l� r 5��4${� ��4�6" �O> O HY �O>
R �W . G� �� �,' < � ���7Y � G� KY��� T��LI� �W�a ISQH Z)$I � >7 /) �l BBucaillism − 7��" Z/)0 >7 " O�−
.> ��� 7(�� Z/)0 P�^= ;Y 7< � � 9`� 7$( � N7l/� 3�LG� O .2�l� C�/0��-- ��0, �$/)0 H$L*" �`O��; �l B ;j! _LI 7l� >7 /� y{6
�S� ^��>� ��$@$ ^� r �$/)0 _LI aa ����/*� r aa C`O s�!� r �$/)0 �$g �7(�� �)/< �M$� � $� 7< W � ��S�� _LG� �a
ISRH Y V:�� �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g Z 6� P 6L� X$I �.�/�0� ��/0 �'�M� ,�'�Mt . G$� �¢ " .>� ,D$@/<> �M60 f� Zn� ,�$Y4�� �)B� Z)0�
� D �Q>�N�6� ;Y � /� �/" C� � �> �M ~t A�A� e)0 � W /a f� 1 �� 7@g 7��−�)�� ;$)0 f� e)g− £�GY Y>� O ,5��( e)0
e)g f� 1 �� 1�l� ,��:%� KI�L� , A�$Y4�� A�)B� AZ)0� A.�/�0� A�/0��)�� ;$)0 f� :Û a�/P <$ I)-+ 4� ,�HV� bc �� dHH)�J �� eE�Üghia
e)g 7M��!� ,� 6�Y ;*{6 �)�� ;$)0 f� �.�/�@� ,�$l�7%�Y �GY ZY
ghi ,�)*" C���+,��*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�Z)0� �'�M��Y ��)B� .�I 7�� a Z)0 s ~�" � � ��o� ;60 f� Zn� i�7�7t �n�" ,.�6� Y> C��4�
; 1�l� ,Z�7� :C`O �� Gt r D$6"h/� �$"> �� �$)0 �6� :W 7la
Z)0 ; 1�l� :G0 AK� :W �" f�� Z6;6" Z*{j e); f� �1 �� AK@/� �!1 l� �F�7%/� �F'�%� �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g :Û , 'V V \6��f =�gA10 IP$
'V V \6��f�− ;$ ��7 Ag eR ��t>� − ,IA1)Z� [g1i; >15 ��j F)7)�j94k >:J� 6� '�� �� + # D 4D , V :J� �/5 c l#9(��Üghia
ISTH Z 6� K6Y �/B�� H lW�−e)g �)�� ;$)0 f�− Z�/W , �M 1 l$��O Y> :Ûm/5�� �1'� �Üa ��8�0 D$6"h/� �> 1 lW : D0 �> ;6$/� D0 �M*)<> ��
;�/t , ¤KG|� ���7( �M$R q��> �� ,KG � ,���7( �M$R q��> ��a �M K)l� :K�l� ?1�� �/0 �MALP*� ,.4( D" 3��> �(�� � $�I AK�>� �" :
�)�� ;$)0 f� e)g f� 1 �� q� ~� Z��A! K6I �"
K�l� ,�MALP� �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g �Z 6� x~ A� �/)� : qZR q��> :Û F��/^ #$<� ,%);�� 8 @�� �'f� + ]P$� ,Y�� 6'0 lFD #n�:�� �'f� @� # D �g5 <$ o���
G-0� ])-+ "� >-c L :� , A�)(/� ,�� m� Z� �1)� bFV� AL�� IP$� ,�-^� : ��%)'�p4�� bQ 7P �� 6'T�� FV� Q 7P lYH)0 q9(; #� l%) lf�;Üa �` AKG|�g�ia
ISUH �|�>� C A�� =R ; �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g ;�7g �S0>� ;W j H8�' D" ,�Q> ��j /$" D$6"h/� �> 7Lt�� ,�G" r �j /$" Kn�" 7l� ,�G" r � /W �
ghi �I�� C�������++� � �$ G� r ��V^�� ,��,� a� 1��Z/�$M� :D*( C'�6�R* g�i �%� ��<�' e)0> r &�7� �`O � 9��: � C�����b+�� � �)*"� ,�+��-�*
� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�O �760 D/ K�l� ,s�/� �M$)0 : .R ,�� A� "> � �p� ,�G" D" � <�=>�G/Y � "> � �> �V=> �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g f� 1 ��a
f� e)g f� 1 �� �� e6Y ZL� ����� eR ,T ~� �� �� � W> eL( �O )/�0 �)�� ;$)�]$ �{� kn " r �MLW, � $� T��@" �OV�� ,K6�'� ��6O KW�/�
� 9`� V=> �/I ,�G" D0 �<��= �MAW��� Kj�G� ,�G/Y ���� 6� �$(�n r} M� D0 �^6�a
ISVH ,�¢��� D0 �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g Z 6� ?7W D�`� 5�hO D"�� 1�� 7l� ,�6�� HO> �j��� Z)0 DY D$*� ;A ~� �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g Z 6
;<���> }7(v :Û r�-+ Fsj H:� �� L :� �\-/� t�-+ FsH� G� Il-� �)/�� : #$ �� F1:� �1�� ���� 6��; %� IA1��� �OJ #$� ,L91:� %)75 �NV I'�� WL � :
Q��45 6��; u�sv�Üghia ISWH r Zt��6� � " D0 C A�� =R �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g ;W j H8�' D"�s�> �Mt r ��`" � .� I�� ;)/W V= �`O� ,;W��� � � r �� � , Y> 1 l�����O −;60 f� Zn�−: Û 89)�� S �J T'�� G-0� ])-+ "� >-c "� L90� >@P
m@��� �/D� ,G�� wK� ,>-K4�� >�$ u�s ,])� X � ,N��Üg�ia
ISXH �I�@/� s�> f� 1 �� 7l{W ,�7Y � $ �Y�*� � $� r� ,� lW�/�1 l�� ,�M$� D$I��/� HLl" kn� " eR �$�� H@<�: Û#B� U�K� �NVÜa
yj> 1�� :�6O�O �6O�O s�!� e)0 C7� k|�� a D0 �O7(> ���" �/�
ghi �$%� �)*)*���+* g�i � 9��: � C����+��*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�)�� ;$)0 f� e)g f� 1 �� 7� kn "ghia ISYH 5 � D0 �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g C�� =R � 6� e)0 ��7� r ;)�"�
HW�� H<� �/W�= ����O Y> 1 l� ,'S��� 5S � D*(P� D$/)*/� k" Zn�;60 f�: �j7Mt Z07� D/" H<� 1�l� �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g f� 1 �� k"�S�v� :Û� '�� FV� %� �NVÜ*
����O Y> 1 l� : ;LY�gP� ,i�7�7t i��L� H<�� HW�� 1�Ll� �|( �/)�H$l� ,�(��< :; �K)� 9`� ,f� 1 �� �� : � $� HW�� 7� ;jp� ;��6� HO> D" ;jR
��" 7�� ,i�7�7t i��L� !�)�� ;$)0 f� e)g Z 6� 1�l� :Û� '�� >�$Üa ����O Y> 1�� :3�W�� .> N�6� x@Y '�G� a6$ �H$� oR �o e)0 �O �/ : ;jR
i�7�7t �(��< ;Y DG� ,K/� �a
f� e)g Z 6� V=AP� ,;*{j HLl� ,����� e)0 V%� � H$)� D" .�I �/)�1�l� ,�`Y �)�� ;$)0 :Û]A�90�� "� AH/+ q� H�J� ,�/D� "�Ü* i�SY �"> ��
N�6�Y }'�6� :Û� ,64-7� ex`P <$ 6'T�� AFsH� < ]P$ %�H�� �NV H�p)� "� #$�^ `�� bF^�� �Üg�ia
@ITPH D$Y D" k j 5�/� .> ;60 f� Zn� yj> D0 �)*"� 9��: � r K �{���� ;@Y�g>� H<� �8�/�S� 5�O� ;6" Pn W eL( aa� e)0> r &�7( �`O
�%� ��<�'�Y�%� D" �${� wk/< C7Mt ,a
ITQH e)0 �M$7W 7@Y �'�L� D$0 �'�;L6<�; �O'�� − �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g−
ghi C����)*" ��,,�* g�i � 9��: � C����b-+*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
H � D" D*(> Kj�I� � {� e)0 K8V� �{���� C7$Y aa 9`� ZY�%�� ~* AI ��V� ;��� �8 �M$)0 �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g Z 6� c*/Y K aa;l%Y� − e)g
�)�� ;$)0 f�− V� ;60 f� Zn� Z)0 D$0 r8 1�� r K S �-D y�j 5���%)Z)ZK�� a
ITRH ( �7W�� 9`� H<�� &�7 1�l� �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g Z 6� 7M0 e)0−�)�� ;$)0 f� e)g− :Û]-/:; < ���� #$Ü* z '�� ]'�j 4-(� F^��� X 4�
b �]-/:; G�� ���� ]1{a
ITSH ;�7� D$Y ��@^� D" H$)l� �$�GW− �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g− .�I eL(�/O�$�� D$$%� r �o r &�'�(!�� �$lY ;6" el W� ,d$�� ;6" HIP� ,
F76:� ��4� r f� 7 0 DY �Y�< &�7( �O�Mt> � a
ITTH ' @*" DY f� 7 0 &�7( :Û � ]��+� \��T5 �v� 6(� S ���� �'D])-+ t��− G-0� ])-+ "� >-c "� L90�− q|v� ]1@40� <$ Y��L9:�: 8B7��
"� L90� � I)-+Üa f� 1 �� ;60 1�� _$�@� ��� �`O�− ;$)0 f� e)g�)��−: Û \�T5 }�+� q$ ]��+� q$ y@�� #� F/� t�-+ G-7� # D 6(4� �#~�Ü* ��/� DY �Y�< ���B D" �)*" C��� &�7��a
ITUH .> D" ��IP� �� $u A/�Y �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g C�� =R �"> e%A� , ;6" 5���v� �4�@" �� �v ; �G" HO> 97W D/n d��� �$0 D0 C�� =R
���@/��, X)= DY �$"A> HLlY C�� =R ;6"� aa ��<�' e)0> r &�'�(> �M)I� �%�a
ITVH H<�� �M6"� ��$�I 3� � r &�'�(!�� 1�� r 5�07� �Y�<R �"> ��L" e6/$� C7$Y HI!� x�� 9`� ;j> �k$^L*� �, 1�l�− ;$)0 f� e)g
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�)��− :Û�@*10� <Üa ;$� eR ;@�� �/�, �)*" C��� &�7�� a &�7(� C�$�� � W r �^/� 1�4j a
ITWH E`�� D$6(� D$L/��G� ;�7� D$Y e%� c$ *W &�'�(> .R HY N�6� D" ;L/%0� − E���� ��o ��4� r �/I− 3�t���-- �5�" � �]Y D"
�%� ��<�' e)0> r ;$�a
ITXH f� ;/(� 9��: � 1�� : Y> �6�7( _$@t �jV=> .�/$� Y> �6�7(��0!� D0 '�j4� ;60 f� Zn� ����O ZY> D0, ;$)0 f� e)g f� 1 �� .>
1�� �)�� :"�)O �oR ,C7@Y �%$� S� �%$� �)O �oR� ,C7@Y }�*I S� }�*IC7$Y Z*{j 9`�� Dl{6Lf� H$ � r �/O� 6I." � H$7� �`O D" ��0> H$' 9P
?7� �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g Z 6� .> e)0 ;jp� ,f� �R ;/)@� � 9`� Z( �Y ZL� ����I!� ��' .> 7(> � %L� DG� � . G� ��0 X> j ��/L��
����I!� .>� ,D$/)*/� 97�PY �M���� �MB l� ��$� eR� ,. @$^L*� � i��" �MG)" ��7$@� .> �0�*� �$j��a
ITYH �=�� &�7��: D*� 5�< _^:� �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g Z 6� �6$Y�)�� ;$)0 f� e)g Z 6� 1�l�: ÛH)0 �NV �'��, %)1O� %)� ]� �-K� #� "� F@��
%)4-74�� %�Üghia DY D*� 7� e)0 D$/)*/� D$Y ;$� f� c)g> 9`� ��@� Z/ A�� ��0 Z)0
�0�/��−�- ����O− ?�$ug H{B �$%/Y �M)I ;W 0' DO�� .> H<� X$G� ,e)0 �5 6� �lLW �� wZ(� �o . G� .> �R ,_$�0 £ j e( �!
ghi � 9��: � C���bb�+*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
IUPH X� L� � _$OU� k" �o�/ f� 1 ��− �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g− D0?;W 0' � eL( X8�^� r .�$ %� ;Y�| A>� Z"'> ;)<�� ;��{���� , �G" H='�
C�� < '� �� 970 DY �@^" �� < r , A�� Z">;$)0 ��4�� 5�@" ,;0� W>� ej�0� eL( �G" 3�@t r �� 6� ?S� �7/ ��%�� E ��> �Y�� .�I ;j
E �� �7t D" ;6^Y e)0 D���� , �)�� ;$)0 f� e)g 1�� eL( −� ZYPY> Z"Z*{j�−: Û A� H:�5� } i� �� "� S �`s ,H5� |p� �� "� S ��|�� H:�� ,H
/�� �� �� ,89�� 6-)� %)� %� #9kBk �-+ �;� H:��H/D �| ]-Dv� 8 @_ LB <$LB� ��$ ]���9� Q�JÜghia
HY�l" � ,1�/�� ������ ��{G� ;$)0 s�@� 9`� K� � r 9��� �`O HI A� �>� �MLM2� �MIU� .> HY�l" HY ,;W 0' D0 1��6L� .>�¢7$l0 ;{* ! DG
wZ(� Kj�I ;W 0' s��@� H|�! �MIU� eL( ;*{j H ~� D~" K*$ e( ��(�L/�!
هذه كانت حلقة من آالف الحلقات من أدلة نبوته صلى اهللا عليه وسلم
وإذا أكثرت النظر في هذا الباب يحصل لك العلم الضروري
النبوةبكونه صلى اهللا عليه وسلم على أعلى درجات
ghi 9`"U� C���*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
æc@áÜÇa@òíbèäÛa@¿ë@Z@ @$��^Aek� ��=1 GO´3 �I ¦�5�� G/ !=�A� !0 � P< K�� C− ��=1
��2��−, �� $��^Ae�� 26#�3 �I Pp<V� !a2� ��, S<0 � �c��� !3 �p<�26#��� 2#3 �I � *
�� 23��b��/ ��V� ��Z�� �?�K�� P8j� !K3* �� �K� 2=�_ � b%N�31� 28#�� 43 PMN�� �s, ./ >��,y3 ¦��5�� 2"# ��
4A=1, 2�/ �,s !a2�� � �� lI P3�����, �?�q -G�K� ./ C G�K_ >%j���* !3 2"� � b%N�� J1��L -PW) ��/ �� Pq�N���� !a2��� 1�{ !e S:
!"#��* �� J1�0� ,G�,K�� ��s�\N� ^; �� !"#�� 1�0 b%N��s !e b%N 1�{
P�Ú/ �/ ��� ��=1 }� ����N !"#�� �� P����� �(�3L�� �& b2"F_* �p<��e P�� #V� ��uk�3 !"#�� S:� 1�{ !e J1�0 b%N�� � �U�/
EN%M���* ¦��3k� >���R� ���M��e P�(�5�� b�A#��3 �/*
���K<V�e P���V� ��uk�3 !"#�� S:� b%N�� J1�0 r�Le���12\V��!
��s Y��� S:)� ��A� �� �R���;�� !"#�� P��� �? b%N P ,K�� �,c���b�?�k� �#(�3� >�p<���!
�� 2" -1�{ lI J�w�� C P< K�� !@ C P���8#�� ]A{� P:s; 28#�� G�Ks
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
Ë=|�E��M3 �!� �� !3�"� %3 ¸�1�� C G�� ,P6R E,(��2� �K� `�, E,A�"s/ �"� G�e E,8�L#_ �� Ô���N, 2#3 �I ¦�5�� 28#�� �K� `�/ >1�K3 2<�� ��� G
$��#��* G���/ 76#3 G�6A<V� S{/� �8�� 1 ���� b%N�� ��:s– ^8#_ 2� ��
�� �Ò1 QeI b�K���− P{� �1�{� ,��N/ �� �3/ 43 G�R��� %s4s�pV�� P ,K�� �� � �2#3 ��8;k� E��#_ «�8_� Y? >2��� b%N��*
��2 � �L? !e 2#8s ®�� ª�#�� � �%�I C Æ� E�/ 46A<V� �+A� C xZ�� � F�� ,�Í �� �W; �� `�#�� P6R v"<F� 7�� $��^AeI P ,e Ý8y 46A<V� �+A� �
P< K�� ��� ��=1� J�w�� $��^AeI P ,K3 «��¨ JO�e �+�� �,s * P6AKsq�R b%N�� Q���R C �& ��=� � ��� !=1� #3 ��?2��� �KV� �? �L,s , �P8*
P;�,e �K_ ` � �s%a� �;2=�<� C $��^AeI �� �;2 � ��� ��=1 %s* <� ./� Y��V� �/ �?k� ¶u 43 §�s �� ,��� !=1 �? EA<� !Ks -EA
,���N «��� b��/ !K��s ,Y��� � ,>��� P"8q �;2 � QAs4��<¤ P ,e � !K� -EA<� !e !3 ËA�23 [�;�p8N �"��a 43� � 3 PMN�� �� � *
!=/ �� ����"�� T�"NI P���²� ,4�%��� �#3 �N1+� .L�� �KV� �L,s �8a �& ��2,�:V�� �+A#��� 4pAjV� P?��e �� J�8y�� P~y _� P ���� >1�HI
³u�; -��)I >�L= �I �3 9��� � Q3���� »ak� �A�"� G/ 2��� �;�%3 C* �<6s -!,= �� 1��{ ,^8e �Ma m^w3 b%N�� >�� >�M���3 ��A{� ,��""p3
,P��<�� b�R lI �_�8d3 �<�; �� �� mLa/ .L�� ��K�� ��U"��� ,Pppj�� ,PAÒ lI -PAÒ ��� ,P��N lI -P��N ��� ,x�� lI -x�� �� ��p�� � K��
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
& E?�K _� ,E?2{�"� ^w_� ,�A��� �q��3 ^w_ S<p3� � E,s��;�� E*
bäöa†Çc@ŠØß@óÜÇ@b㊖ãaë@bäÛ†jn�m@üë@bäÜàÈn�a@áèÜÛbÏbäöa†Çc@ŠØß@óÜÇ@b㊖ãaë@bäÛ†jn�m@üë@bäÜàÈn�a@áèÜÛbÏbäöa†Çc@ŠØß@óÜÇ@b㊖ãaë@bäÛ†jn�m@üë@bäÜàÈn�a@áèÜÛbÏbäöa†Çc@ŠØß@óÜÇ@b㊖ãaë@bäÛ†jn�m@üë@bäÜàÈn�a@áèÜÛbÏ@ @@ @@ @@ @´ße@áèÜÛa´ße@áèÜÛa´ße@áèÜÛa´ße@áèÜÛa@ @@ @@ @@ @
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
‰bÌ–Ûa@lbj’ÜÛ@ò·b�@ @ P ,e� ,�<�; -EA� S��q �� �0 G/ �� [\N/ m�32_ �V ��)�� P""�
S?LV� �� n^� �� � ���� 4s�e J�#�� ��2pAV�, � G�Mu P�<As �;/ ��8HI��de/!
+e �K� S8)� �;}a/−EAN� �A� �� �{− C ���5_� ����� �dK�N �;´s� ,�}K�� >���� �,W_� ,G��5�� �ao �+A<� �,s !=��� �8j� ��s�e µ6��� ,
�� �|� µ6�� , ���s�e �8j��C +e ,, Y8 �� ç�/ 2R�–EAN� �A� �� �{− P)�j�� �+�k�3 >1��8V�3 P��z; ��= Á� �& ��k–�P��R− ��,8y��� ����� ��
�� !U�3 �I ��_�_ �� Pj#63 �I 28� SAR C P,8u !a2_ %s ,���,y��� ��"s ,P��q� ��–EAN� �A� �� �{− :Û 7��# Z�0��5 ��$�5 y*@1� Tt�9 �
,@qB�PPPÜ ghi* P�� � [#U� �K�� ���O C ���"� Q� G��5�� J�ZR�3 ����� >�R ���5�<s
t2Æ)� �� �P�� � [#c/ �2�/ Q�� ,�& ��2j�V�–�<�� ^w{− t2)�s Áº�_ Á��� m'6#�A� !6� �� S(��w�� ���,�<_� >�K , >�q�a ��/ �� �8 F� La|��
ã!K�� �#�º /�"� �� ±p�� �A"� �+�I �� � ; FN 1�8K�� b�#Ms ãE 1�wj��* sl�k� PA?�A� ��,8y�� �#3 t2)� ���M� ��2 #, SUw�� �K � �;´s �#�º �L�A�� ��2F� G/ lI ���#� �� G��º �K� � , �8AR ^j� ]R��� ��� �?2#3�
P,8u !K� J��� P: �N��e*
ihg ER1 ,EA<� �p{ghhÅi*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
r�O !=/ �� [A<�� 1 ËL�– G��c��� E,A�− «28�� !?/ P<��� � Á�E,8�e P#��M��, P��8<�� ��#� � �V �p8�� J�ZR� �� [A<�� 7��*
�� , /. /} J�p���Ò1− : ÛE?�<��� � :«28 �� − قال أبو قالبهقال أبو قالبهقال أبو قالبهقال أبو قالبه E?�M��� ** � de EKA� ��<8A� �/ Ee�2<�� G/ ��o � �´sG�s�#_ �¤ �Ü*
�� ���> !?/ P���Ò1− : Û «28 �� − قال ابن قدامهقال ابن قدامهقال ابن قدامهقال ابن قدامه G�, � [A<�� G�eE,�%e l� «+�N��� E,8�e C �W ���Ü*
�� �eO 2#3 :Û /?! ��28» ثمان الصابونيثمان الصابونيثمان الصابونيثمان الصابونيوقال أبو عوقال أبو عوقال أبو عوقال أبو ع E��Oo G� Æ{ G���� Æ=� �Ú J�A"�� è � Ë�R� G�O��3 ��� �OI Y��� E,Aq�3/ «+N Ë� �� �,�I �
Æ= �� m2N���� ���M�� $��N��� Ë��Ü* � � �Ò1 − ���R �� −قال الذهبيقال الذهبيقال الذهبيقال الذهبي !"; �� !"� �3� P��_ è: Û G�e�
A3� )� � 3�p{/P Á� G�2��� Ý G��:? Y�+A#�� �� P���, �+A� Y ��0 r�O G�e� �#s�;�Ü * ���"3 Y8?L�� 'A#s :Û�5�#V� P<��� �� �;�, � ��;�eP è �R� 7�� 73�s
E,A(�8�, Â�j �� !���_ �� f��Ü* �CR1� �� Z�R�FP 283��Ò1−: Û �(�<A© �,K0 %s P �� − قال سفيان الثوريقال سفيان الثوريقال سفيان الثوريقال سفيان الثوري �6N �� ** �
è �,"A F�E¥�ARÜ* ���"3 �,A� 'A�� 78?L�� �?�1�/: Û G��� ��Lp��� �L? �� [A<�� P6(/ �de/
�#c J�A"�� G/P �Ma �8y���PsÜ* Ï@òèj’Ûbi@éjÜÓ@ÕÜÈmë@éäîÇ@oËa‹@ðˆÛa@t†§b@énÇb�@¿@ÉuŠí@æc@ČÝÓ@ @
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
,@�1� [@ v0 ¢y3�� ¢]�4 y?1 _�J*8�#: ,r#� � +3 �I !wy _ �À23� rs1�#� v8c��PA"#�� r_� ��� ,4"A� �%�23 rc�Zs� �� !#� %s ,
G�My�� � �5� '��q �L,s ,G� W��� ��c�Zs�� �de/ +s ,PÀ28A� �%�23 r @����1 Sj � �A�� ,����U3 b��ÁR� 2���� G�My�� §�N �,s!
åØÛ@_‰bÌ–Ûa@lbj’Ûa@œÈi@ÞìÔÇ@�bn£@�Ûa@÷ëb�ìÛa@xýÇ@bß@ @ G/ rA� P��28�� C ��,8y��� �� $��N��� G/ S8)� Ya/ EA#_
� ���� �ao �� n�Ky���* ���p6s �L��;$��N��� 2�5_ 4"�� �� �p8�� � ]<� PU"�� Gk
n�Ku, ����k� 43 G���u� $��N� +;I�* P(1�q PA"� x��s �? $��N���s–!d� PA"� ���� : ?EA� C �;/ !?
?�Ma �� � Ae G�K; � �O�V− ?� �/ C�#� 2 N �& Q� !{k� C $��N��� � Y"M �, 1�d� �8j� � 7�� �¥ 9�8� G/ �� 7�� �,8��{ !:¯ S��w�� C �L��
�3 4MpV� �� P��\N* .�8�� !"#�� 1��#_ P �� �j � P��=�� ��,=�_ Y,s n�Ky�� ��/
��1 �& 2· G/ ���0�Y �2�� ± A� �=���� �=���� 2· G/ +s ,� �8AR �~6M� 7�� ��,8u C - 8a �� �p8� G/ ��5A� ry�� S��{ � ?� ,E"N �� �3 �� S?L��
��|? G�u C l�#_ �� ��R �L�� ,�H/ �& 7"8� �� ��5_ 7��: ���t��s
�v���u�ghi*
ghi ���� ,.���{� �� � :����*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
]R��� �� ry�� ��5� 2R�, ��:V P,8y�� ��_Zs P��M��− G/ G�� 7�� ��1 �& Ey:���−�;/ �3 �"F; .L�� !{k�s , :Û@üg@ †jÇ@ kÜÓ@¿@ òèj‘@ ŠÔn�m@ ü
òÇbĐi@ üg@ ÉÐmŠm@ üë@ Lòî–ȶÜ* ^de �� ��#� �;/ l�#_ �� !Us �� �K� ���Ø��×��Ö��Õ��Ô���Ó���Ò��Ñ��Ð��Ï�ghi *
لماذا الشبهة من األساس؟: لكن قد يعرض هنا سؤال وهو
J��©� :�� Y�AK_ .1�8�a� `�� C �p; EKpFV� 2=�� G/ 1�8�a�� P6�_ �l�#_ ��R ,�3�y�FV�� :���c���b����� �a������ �`��_�����~��}��|��{��z��y��x
��q��po��n��m���l���k��j��i��h��g��f��e��ds��r�g�i*
l�#_ ���R ^<�_� :g7 � �OIi :�/: �� ���o %_ , >���"�� �? PwA�� C Y 6���s>�%����*
��= +s lI >��2A� �¥ !N�FV� ����� ���R �� %_ EH -Y8; �� ��N1 ,PAq�3 �%�� � �,8 Fu G�My�� 7"�/ �I ,��K�� �� �A� E? �� L8;� ,2����� +e ,!q�8��3 ������ �� E,AÒ� E,(���� >�A�V� ����� C >2N�s ��+����
l�#_ ��R: ���d��c��b��a`��_���� � � � �~��}��|��{e�g i*
ghi ���� ,}� �� �� � :��-�* g�i ���� ,¥� �� � :��+�* g i ���� ,��@j!� �� � :��+��*
�� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�;�p8N ��R� :���a��`��_��^���]��\� �[��Z��Y��p� �o� � nm� � l� �k� �j� � � i� � hg� �f� � � �e� �d� �c� �b
q�ghi* l�#_ ���R �5; 4� 1��K�� ��R 2R� : �C��B��A�g�i � �26² G/ ,
–EAN� �A� �� �{ − Pp3O P�V� G/ 1�8���3 ,�� Pp3O b� F0� ,�<�; Pp3O ! F0 Ps�\N ��� ,�� �L? G/ �I ,���� �/ �,p3O �� ��u �(�3O !K�� G/� E?����
!q�8�� ��2©�� PM<�<�� �� «�;! x������ b�?�k� mL? !�5� ./ G�My�� Y"A� �� �� ¶< � � ?� 7"8� %s $�%&� mL? !M8� �� �,s �" Æ� �� P �|V� J�A"�� �� ��M<�<���
Fs �� 2 � �� ��= +3 ��|�s ryA� �H/ �8j�� ,���� !8"_ � �p3 �_��o �� EKpx�� E¥�AR C ��LA� P �s ��M<�<�� rA_ �� G�My�� Y"A F� ��*
��� � AR +e $��N���s ,� ���� r�O �� QK#�� �� �,s $��N��� ��/ -Ps�#� -P 83 �& PR%� � ,!"#�� �,��M� P(1�q ��c�Zs� -!jp�3 �� ,P # F�
³q�a .�Ks 3 �� 2R P"3�<�� 1��k� ];�e GI� ,��,8y�� ^d_ �R��� �� -«%q� $��N��� !"� _ 2R� �N��N� 1}� �� �,s !"#�� 2·� $��N��� >2� �� 2�5_ !W_ G/ ��/ ,� �"3�N �;�eO �� S<p3 P©�#V� G�K_ � ?� n�Ku lI �� -PA��� C
�; �� ��~�K � � ��(�� �,8��{ !W�� ,$��N� Y? +e $��N��� ,�¥ ��8~�K� �<
ghi ���� ,��@j!� �� � :���+�* g�i ���� ,�78�/� �� � :���*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
2#3 ��K�� P?��e� P��M�� S�� SA"�� ��"; !(��� G+��� S_��� �� mL,sG+���!
�EA<� ��1 2"s C"�pp{" ��R ,>���? ª/ �� : J�p{/ �� $�; ��= �� �{ Y8 �� m���<s EAN� �A� : EAK�� G/ �;2�/ E@�#�� �� � <�;/ C 2:; �;I
��R ?�3 :Û (^� ?l��(j�Ü* ����R :E#;* ��R :Û���\� ��b ��sÜ * �{ Y8 �� ��2� °�A3 $��N���s Gk ;G+��� ��z Y? EAN� �A� ��
���q � �U� �� �� r8AR �K#� �� �:�5�� ,G+��� �L? J�y� �� �R1|� ,G+���3 �m��{! �s b�W#�N $��N��� , � ��� >2u��¥ 'M �� ��� ,� �%Us , ��
?��"���� P8���� � � ]��;�� ��""² ��+K�N� G+��� !6K�N� �V G�K� +;I ,n�Ky���*
Y,s ��|V� 28#�� ���%�3� PA� �� Y? $��N���� 43 «�z� G�p��� JO�K�� �� §��j�� 48�� 7��� m^� �� �2&� S��q 48�� 7�� !q�8��� ')�
�;�p8N ��R +e ;'s� V� �� ��|V��: �t��s��r��q� ���x��w� �v��u��©��¨������§��¦��¥��¤£��¢��¡�����~��}�����|����{��z��y
ª�ghi*
ghi ���� ,� G6@� �� � :��−��*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
?�C�1� �� �� �?1 � EA<� b���� ��1��R >���? ª/ � :EAN� �A� �� �{ �� ��N1 ��R :
ÛZ��� ��+ ��1)�R�� w��1� Z��� p: |¡@�� W�� ¡@� �`� , �u# ? �� ¡@� �u# ��*4 �1s �� (j���5 2��i y�*@#Ü *
�� P���1 C� :Û ��5 2��i y�*@#%@��Ü *
��a/ -P���1 C� :Û%��*1� ��5 `��R*@# �1s É@5 �s�#Ü* !R� ,��3 L#�N�s $��N��� n��= �O´s ,P��� P��8; E��#_ �,Ae�: ] �o
Â%a�� >1�N /�R�� ,�AN1� ��3–�� 73/ P���1 C +e ¦%� ��/ ��$��N�A�−: ���L��K���J��I��H��G��F��E��D��C��B��A
R��Q��P��O��N��M�ghi * P��� mL? >���R �� �Áde/�: ���Î��Í��Ì�� ËÊ��É��È��Ç��� �Æ
Ï�g�i* $��N� n��= +Ae !R� :Û%1 ��« p h �� ,��Ü* �� ��N1 G�e 2"s −
EAN� �A� �� �{− ��R �� ���1 �OI :Ûp h �� �� %1 ��«Ü * v8_�� $��N��� G/ EA#_ G/ S8)� Ya/ rA�� ��5�� P #� -P � ->Z�3
�_�O�, r#� � +3 !wy;�s ,�_�� �� ->Zs C �3 SjF� ` �� �!R�, ���2�� �� �de/�r�1�3 lI ��:A�� §2 Á{�, Y���� EA#�� r6A#�� � �#s�� rN��N� �� !#=��
ghi ���� ,�S=v� �� � :��−��* g�i ���� ,7�7� �� � :���*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A
�� lI >��2�� C T�\;��; �� ��� Pe�3 �,�s,� � ��wy;��� $��N� S8B�r8AR ^ � P��M�� C $� ��!
نسأل اهللا أن يهدينا وإياك لما اختVلف فيه من الحق بإذنهنسأل اهللا أن يهدينا وإياك لما اختVلف فيه من الحق بإذنهنسأل اهللا أن يهدينا وإياك لما اختVلف فيه من الحق بإذنهنسأل اهللا أن يهدينا وإياك لما اختVلف فيه من الحق بإذنه
�� ��2À G�3 !A�� b�R C -PA� !e ��2� EAN� �A� �� �{ Y8 �� G�e 2R��;O´3 ')� �� �s [AF�a� �V, �� �P{�a ���2�� �L? lI b��k� mL? � =��/ ���
EA#�� PAR� ,����� >�de* ��2� Y�s3/7 ��� �3 ���� 28� �3 P6AN�R�: b/ Py(�� ]��N
4 �|V�: -�� .�3 �� b�R �OI �_%{ ����� EAN� �A� �� �{ �� Y8; G�e!A��? ]��R: �_%{ ���s� !A�� �� b�R �OI G�e :Û y*a�?*�� y*a�¶j ] ,G@1�
�$�30 e5 ,?¸ 2�� $�Gm1�� [*~1� /�0 ©��� S���R1� � �# y*#��6���V@�� %*# ����9 �*#, ��s�5 ¡<� �� %*# -@��� �B }(��; )�m! �� ;(° ��6
¢Ê�b k6 ,*��R�Üghi* ´ße@áèÜÛa@ @
bĆßë…@õbdžÛa@aˆç@óÜÇ@˜ŠybÏA
ghi �)*" c$g*
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A س ا�����ت��
ò߆ԽaNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@U@ @
Ý–ÐÛa@Þëþa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@V@ @
…b§⁄a@áà�Ží@òàîÔÛa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@W@ @
…b§⁄a@áà�Ží@âìÜÈÛa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@ @QT@ @
…b§⁄a@áà�í@´ÐÔr½a@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@RP@ @
…b§⁄a@áà�Ží@lìÈ’Ûa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@RX@ @
…b§⁄a@áà�Ží@´äí†n:½a@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@SX@ @
…b§⁄a@áà�Ží@åí†zܽa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@TS@ @
…b§⁄a@áà�Ží@a‰bÐîu@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@US@ @
…b§⁄a@áà�Ží@´àÜ�½a@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@VQ@ @
åØÛ@Ýç@‰b’nãa@…b§⁄a@¿@Š�e@æbߌÛa@Šßc@_ÉIÓìnß@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@WU@ @
Ý–ÐÛa@ïãbrÛa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@WW@ @
æìãbÓ@ïöbíŒîÏ@œÔäí@…b§⁄a@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@WX@ @
Ý–ÐÛa@sÛbrÛa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@YY@ @
òà×bª@õì’äÛa@ÝjÓ@õbÔm‰üa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QPP@ @
òîvyc@bîß��ãbjÛa@PANSPERMIA@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QPW@ @
‰ìĐnÛa@„‹a�Ûaë@òîÔîÔ§a@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QQR@ @
Éä–Ûa@åÔn½a@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QQX@ @
paŠÐ�Đ�Ûa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QRU@ @
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A ¿@õ†jÛa@oãb×@ñ‰ìÐyþa@ @NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QSQ@ @
éib’nÛa@�î¦a@´i@æb�ã⁄a@ðŒãbjà’Ûaë@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QSW@ @
‰ìĐnÛa@�Ì–Ûa@…ìÔнa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QTV@ @
l‰bÔm@ÝØ’Ûa@ïu‰b¨a@¿@pbäöbØÛa@òî§a@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QUS@ @
‰bvÐãa@ð�ßbØÛa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QVR@ @
a‡bß@Š��@�bÈÛa@‰ìèÄi@_‰ìĐnÛa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QVY@ @
a‡bß@Š��@�bÈÛa@‰ìèÄi@‰ìĐnÛa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QWU@ @
Õܨa@ï�⁄a@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QXR@ @
Õܨa@ï�⁄a@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QXY@ @
Ý–ÐÛa@ÉiaŠÛa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QYX@ @
pýØ’ß@ÞìÜyë@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@QYY@ @
pübØ‘g@òîöbíŒîÏ@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@RPS@ @
òßb‚™@æìØÛa@ávyë@æb�ã⁄aA@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@RQU@ @
pübØ‘g@òbm@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@RQX@ @
ƒí‰bm@�i@ÝîöaŠ�gA@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@RSP@ @
pübØ‘g@òîÔĐäß@ @NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNRSV@ @
pübØ‘g@åß@ÉÓaë@´àÜ�½a@Š•bȽa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@RTX@ @
a‡b½@â†Ônm@Þë†Ûa@ñŠÏbØÛa@ @NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@RUV@ @
Ýç@âý�⁄a@ìç@_“Ça…@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@RUX@ @
áÜ�½a@ÝÔäí@wvy@´îiŠÌÛa@áènÛ…cëA@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@RWU@ @
��� _…b§⁄a@åß@—Ü‚nm@Ñî×A pübØ‘g@òîÏŠÈß@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@RXV@ @
òv§a@òîÛb�ŠÛa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNRYV@ @
pübØ‘g@òîèÔÏ@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@SPP@ @
��Ûa@–ÖŠÛaMòí…ìjÈÛa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@SPS@ @
…bèu@kÜĐÛa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@SQX@ @
pübØ‘g@Þìy@ñaŠ½aA@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@SSW@ @
Ý–ÐÛa@�ßb¨a@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@SUS@ @
òÛ…c@…ìuë@ÕÛb¨a@éãbzj�@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@SUU@ @
ñŠíbȽa@òÔîÓ†Ûa@æìØÜÛ@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@SUX@ @
òĐ튨a@òîäî¦a@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNSVS@ @
pb�@åß@ñ��@��@âbãþa@óÜ•@�a@éîÜÇ@áÜ�ë@ @NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@SWT@ @
Ýöü…@ñìjäÛa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@SYT@ @
ñõìjäÛa@ô�ØÛa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@TPS@ @
�@�c@Šm@µg@Ùi‰@Ñî×@†ß@ÝÄÛa@�@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@@TPW@ @
ò·b�@lbj’ÜÛ@‰bÌ–Ûa@@NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN@TRX@ @