-
pars.
3
c. 1
ROBA
-
COMMENTARIA
IN ARISTOTELEMG R A E C A
pp3^02.
-]
EDITA COXSILIO ET AUCTORITATE
ACADEMIAE LITTEKARUM REGIAE BORUSSICAE
VOLUMINIS XIII
PARS III PHILOPONI IN ANALYTICA POSTERIORA
CUM ANONYMO IN LIBRUM II.
BEROLINITYPIS ET IMPENSiS GEORGll REIMERI
MCMIX
-
JOANNIS PHILOPONI
JN ARISTOTELIS
ANALYTICA POSTEPJORACOMMENTARIA
CUM ANONYMO IN LIBRUM II
CONSILIO ET AUCTORITATE
ACADEMIAE LITTERARUM REGIAE BORUSSICAE
qCjqoo^
MAXIMILIANUS WATJJKS
BEROLINITYPIS KT IMPENSIS GEORGII REIMERI
MCMIX
-
HaC VOLU minis XIII PARTE III KDITA TOTUM CORPUS
COMMENTARIORUM IN ArISTOTELEM GRAECORUM AD FIN EM
QUEM VOLUIT AcADEMIA BoRUSSICA PERDUCTUM EST.
-
PRAEFATIO
rt ill I'riorum it;i etiam in l^steriorum Analyticoriim
commentariis
Philoponeis alterius libri et condicio, id quod Brandisium ')
lugissc mireris,
ct memoria longe alia est atque prions, nam priraum aliquanto
est brevior;
cum enim Analyticorum Posteriorum liber prior altero tertia fere
parte
maior sit, huius coramentarius vix tertiam illius partem explet.
deinde
nusquam hie Alexandri Aphrodisicnsis, cuius interpretatio
saepissime a
rhilopono in priore libro impugnetur, nusquam xou cpt/voaocfou
aut toij oioa-
jx'iXo'j i, e. Ammonii mentio lit, cuius auctoritas saepe illic
afleratur.
tum multa inveniuntur, quae a Philoponi sermoue, qualis est in
priore libro,
abhorrere videantur''). quod denique ad memoriae fidem attinet,
unius
recentissimi codicis, Vindobonensis pliil. gr. 155, et editionis
Aldinae auctori-
tate Philoponi nomen nititur^), ut eodem vel potius meliore iure
eidem
Philopono Anonymi commentarium tribuas, si quidem huic in
vetustioribus
duobus codicibus, Parisino 1917 et Laurentiano LXXXV 1, nomen
eiuspraefixum est^). neque vero casu videtur accidissc, ut prioris
libri memoria
longe alia sit atque alterius. etenim cum ille plurimis
codicibus con-
servatus sit, huius pauciores reperiuntur, atque in duobus
omnino, Coislini-
ano 160 et Vindobonensi 155, exstant coniuncti. in talibus
codicibus postca
^) tJher die griechischen Ausleger des Aristotelisvhen <
>rgaons (Abliandl. der k. i)r.
Akad. d. W. z. Berlin 1833) p, 293sq. cf. etiam huius vol. 2 p.
VI.-) velut multo saepius in altero libro yoOv et tjo'jv usurpata
videraus. roipo vero post
comparat., (jivToi ye o^? tocjtos a priore libro alicna sunt,
multae praeterea voces in solo
altero libro inveniuntur; exempli causa e magno numero hasce
eligo: d-oX'jTwc, alpETt'CesSat,
a'fvu), Sta(TTj[j.a -/poviy.o'v, Eiorjat;, Jraroprjic/w;,
xaOE^fj?, [).'x%f^xv'jt'j^'U, jjipix0iv, oorjtlv,
TrctXtwoaxEiv, -otpaoEiyijiOTi^eiv, -apaSpoaVj, -ap?,e'j3[;
/povo'J, roor^yilv, a'jvs/i'Cetv, Ta'JTt'Ceiv,
T/vo(3Toc, TUY/c(Viv c. dat., ydipo?. cf. etiam in Ind. verborum
Particip.
3) (juod quidem in saec. XIII cod. Paris. 1848 f. 199^ (cf. vol.
II 1 p. XXI. XXII)
Philoponi nomine inscribitur scholion oit ai ys'^^^ct;
dvcfTiotXtv . . . -A hi lOdi/.^ ztt.vj-zala
non conciuit cum p. 380,4 sq.
*) at ne hunc forte commentariolum aut Philoponi aut e
commentario Philoponeo
excerptum esse putemus, eadem fere obstaut. imprimis sermonis
ratio ut illic iuferiorem
ita hie superiorem aetatem videtur redolere. cf. Brandisii
commentationem 1. c. p. 296.
equidem haec scholia si non omnia at plurima ex Alexandri
commentario deperdito delibata
esse suspicor, cuius nomen prae se ferat scholion e Paris. 1843
et Barocc. 87 (cf. p. XXVI
11. 1) vol. II 1 p. \\I propositiim, (juod jiartim cum Anonymi
p. .^07,27 sq. contrruit.
-
V, PRAEFATIO
Philoponi nomen per librarios a piiore ad alterum librum
translatum esse
60 magis couicias, quod etiam in diiobus illis codicibus, qui
Philoponi in
librum I commentarium una cum Anonymo continent, Parisino 1917
et
Laurentiano LXXXV 1, idem factum esse videmus.
lam codices ipsos perlustremus quibus uterque commentariorum
liber
ad memoriam nostram pervenit'). quorum nullus saeculum XIV
XIII
aetate antecedit. atque prioris libri codices, quattuordecim
numero. in duas/
classes videntur distribuendi esse, quarum discrepantiae saepe
tantae sunt,
ut ueque ad librariorum errores translaticios neque ad
interpolantium libi-
dinem referri possint. alteri classi duo codices recentissimi
adnumerandi
sunt, Hauniensis gr. 209 et Yindobonensis phil. gr. 155, quocum
editio
Aldina^) ita ad verbum congruit, ut si non ex hoc at certe e
codice simillimo
vel gemino eam fluxisse appareat. media inter banc et alteram
classem
intercedunt iragmenta Senensia (saec. XIV) ita, ut, ubi
utriusque classis
raemoria prorsus inter se discrepat, illam sequi soleant. alteri
classi reliquos
codices omnes tribuo, quibus, etsi ipsi quoque multifariam inter
se differunt,
hoc est commune, ut in maioribus discrepantiis secum contra
alteram classem
consentire soleant. quae discrepantiae omnes fere in mantissa
editionis
Aldinae adiectae sunt, ut in praefatione dicitur, in 'variis
exemplaribus',
ut in titulo mantissae legitur, ev kzipm c/.v-qpct'fm
inventae^).
Ex antiquissimis huius classis codicibus duo saeculi XIV,
Laurentianus
LXXXV 1 (R) et Marcianus 225 (U), in hoc commentarlo fide fere
pares,
electi sunt, qui huic editioni tamquam fundamentura
subicerentur. nam
Parisino 1917 (B), qui iis aetate non inferior est, maior est
cum Laurenti-
ano similitude quam cuius varietatem subnotare operae pretium
sit. ex
iis autem, qui aetate his etiam praestare paulo videntur,
Coislinianus 160
madore ita confectus est, ut longe plurima legi non possint, et
Escuria-
lensis
-
PRARFATIO vn
e recentioribus codicibus unum saeculi XV, Vaticanum 247 (V),
adhibui, qui
multo etiam prius (p. 5o, lo) quam in Analyticorum Priorum
coramentario
Philoponeo deficit, horum codicura et mantissae Aldinae (a')
lectiones omnes
subnotavi, ut e silentio semper quae non subnotata sunt cum
textu concinere
concludi possit. e reliquis huius classis libris praeterea quae
notabilia in
schedis meis habui hie illic addidi. quamquam in universum iis,
quae c
codicibus electis notata sunt, huius classis memoriam exhaustam
esse confido.
Alterius classis instar nobis est editio Aldina (a, a'), cuius
varietatem
manilestis typothetarum erroribus exceptis ') totam proposui.
interdum, ut
eius auctoi'itatem, quae re vera plerumque nulla est, contra
alteram classem
Culcirem, fragmentorum 8enensium (S) consensum advocavi. maioris
denique
fragmenti (p. (36, 19 124, 10) varietatem omnem supposui.
8ecuudi libri septem codices innotuerunt'), quorum
antiquissimi
(saec. XIIIXIV) sunt gemelli illi, Parisinus 1972 (F) et
Coisliniauus 157 (E),
atque Coisliniani 160 et (saec. XIV) 167 (C). ex his
Coislinianus 160 iterum
adhiberi non potuit, cum in hoc quoque libro multo maximae
omnium
foliorum partes madore misere alTectae legi nequeant. reliquis
tribus codicibus,
quorum lectiones a textu nostro discrepantes omnes subnotatae
sunt, ita
usus sum, ut, quoad per sententiae et sermonis rationem liceret,
codi-
cum FE memoriam praeferrem, comraendatam tameu aliquo modo
codicis
C auctoritatem, sive sententia sive sermone sive, id quod rarius
accidit,
ipsis illis inter se dissentient! bus, sequi non dubitarem.
recentiorum co-
dicum (saec. XV), Vaticani 1018 (Z) et Mosquensis 313, specimen
proponere
satis habui. his denique codicibus et aetate et fide ac pretio
multo in-
ferior est Vindobonensis 155 (saec. XVI), quocum etiam in hoc
libro ad
verbum consentit editio Aldina (a), eius varietatem plenam
iterum ut in libro
priore subnotavi.
Anonymi commentarii quinque, quod sciam, codices exstant^).
eorum
sunt antiquissimi et praestantissimi, si quidem ita appellare
licet eos, qui
ipsi quoque, imprimis ad finem versus, omni genere mendorum
deformati
sint, Parisinus 1917 et Laurentianus LXXXV 1 propinqua
quadam
cognatione inter se coniuncti. Marcianus 225, qui aetate atque
in libro
') praeterea semper adnotare nolui lemmata in editione Aldiua
plena exhibenita,
ut prima et ultima proximorum lemmatum verba inter se
coiilinuentur.
2) Riccardianum ^'r. 10, de quo v. p. XIII 1, non numero.
3) singula scholia praeterea in Parisino 1843 et Barocciano
87inveniiintur, de
quibus V. p. XI 1 et XXVI 1.
-
vm PRAEFATIO
certe I commentarii Philoponei etiam fide iis par est, hie
aliquantum a
praestantia sua degeneravit ad maximam codicis recentissimi
(saec. XIV)
Oxoniensis Collegii Novi 236 et editionis Aldinae similitudinem,
quorum
est plana consensio. Laurentianus deuique LXXI 15 (saec. XIV),
ubi soli-
turn varietatis modum non excedit, plerumque cum codd. BR facit;
per-saepe autem in tarn diversa abit. ut omnino conferri non
possit. nonnum-
quam quid librario, quid interpreti aut excerptori tribuendum
sit, dubitaveris;
nam sunt quae eo a reliquorum memoria distare videantur, quod
aliter ex
eodem qui illis subest commentario excerpta sunt.
Huius igitur codicis (L) lectiones ita subnotavi, ut quaecunque
aliqua
ratione conferri potuerunt notjirem, reliqua omitterem, ut nihil
umquam e
silentio de consensione eius colligere liceat'). principum
duorum codicum,
Paris. 1917 (B) et Laur. LXXXV 1 (R), varietatem totam proposui;
sed proptermagnam eorum similitudinem litteram B, nisi ipsi inter
se dissentiunt, id
quod raro fit, non addidi. praeterea ultra dignitatem Marciani
(U) varietas
notata est omnis itemque editionis Aldinae (a)^).
f Ad coniecturam confugere in hoc commentariolo saepius quam
vellem
corrupta codicum memoria coactus sum. plurima sane librariorum
menda
facile toUi [Jotueruut, sed doleo non paucos restare locos,
quorum emendatio
desperanda esse videatur.
In codd. BRL commentario Anonymi antecedunt duo prooemia'),
quorumalterum (Schol. p. 240*^ 39 sq.) in Vaticano 1018 f. 448'"
Leonti Magenteno
tribuitur, in Riccard. gr. 10 f. 295'' inscribitur MsTacppotai?
xou Scuiipou pipXtou
tr,; a-ootxTixr^? -f\-rti xaJv uaxepwv dvaXuiixuiv, alterum
(Schol. p. 240^^ 2448)
ut ipsum quoque recentioris aetatis vestigia prae se ferens
Anonymo a
Brandisio") abiudicatur. cuius iudicio eo magis assentior, quod
huic pro-
oemio continuatur interpretatio initii libri II et vix est
credibile idem bis
ab eodem esse tractatum. itaque hoc prooemium infra p. XXVII-XXX
a
commentario ipso seiunctum proponere malui.
') ubi reliqui codd. inter se discrepant, huius conseusum semper
adnotare quam
quicquam silentio committere malui.
-) in lemmatis tamen, quae Ua plena exhibent, ultra initia, quae
sunt in BR,
varietatem lectionum hie quoque notare nolui of. p. VII 1.
^) quam totus R e B pendeat, inde luculenter apparet, quod
initia horum pro-oemiorum, inter quae B spatium reliquit, R
coniuncta habet cf. p. XXIII.
") 1. c.p. 296.
Scr. Berolini
Mense Octobri MCMIX. M. Wallies.
-
SUPIM.KMKNTUM PK\\ KFATloMS.
CONSPECTUS LIIJKOKUM
I COMMKNTARII IN AXALYTICA POSTERIORA PUILoPOiNKI
:
CoiSLiNiAxus 1()0 [H. Omont III I4(> vl'. liiiius vol 2 p.
X\\] honi- Abyciims forma media saec. XIIIXI\ foliorum 655 inscr.
1". 397'' littorispaene evanidis: ToG cpiXo-ovou scvJYr^at; ek ttjv
cit-oosixxix"r]v. !'. 589
^'
subscr. dpiaxoxihrto^ avctXuxi/oJv ucjtspcuv -pniTov. I". 590'
inscr. d^Aaxoxikouz
wrAuxv/.wv uatspojv Ssutepov. Analytica Post, madore magis
magisque ita
confecta sunt, ut phirima, ad linem versus paene omnia legi non
possint. ipse
Parisiis haec enotavi undo codicem Vaticano 247 (V) simillimum
esse apparet:
\}. 1,5. 6 To'jTO 0(7co5t$eios= RUVa- | 5 or) | 8 post v prius
add. ~ais | tiov om. |13 Tcuv ora.
I10 i3a5i3cotj.v post Tot'JTTjV colloc.
|15 inz\
\Ia TipoTotaeuj; aoYXEixai, scd ante
61IG -ocpJocoxEV
I
17 7rpOTC('a(o;|hi ora. | 19 -apsocoxEv | 2,1 t7j{ suporscr. |
xs om. j
at
2.3 c(7:0Ei;ap.Ev to ts ao'flattxov . . . otctX-/.Tr/.6v -/.at
to 7-ooi7.Tt/.6v | 8 ir.i tuj | 'J otoaoxovTe;]
i). 10 T(ov cpapu.ct/.tov oin.|10 i)JA to
|
1'2. 13 to toioutov eIoo; tcuv cuXXoYtSp-tov|13. 14 owv
|i.tCov Tfj? y/j? om.I
15 r][j.rv post eXe'y/o'j? colloc.|IG TiapEotoxE. oto | 17
Diy/iov | eoti cm.
j
18 Tou liabet | 18. 19 dX)^ auToirtaTiov rpOTceaEtuv xat
avay/.atiov | 19 egti ora. | 20 xoi-
a'JTTj dva'yxT) T(Juv Xoytov irop.vovj21 Tpo/,(vrjT&v
I22 p.cxaotioxeiv
j(xy)
|23 tt,; Xoyixfj?
rp-jfYij-aTEia?I
24 TTpo;| 2G lo; j 3,2 laxl om. | 4 TOTitzof; | 5 8o(ttov | 6
aypTjiTov | 8 irpay-
[i-otTEKuv om.I
ci).)M^ 0 OS | 9 'i;'JOEai oio(Tptj3iv I TouToi;] TOTE | 12 ToO
c(Xtj8oO; I -auTT) (post
zpo;)I
13 7.c(VTa'ji)aj 15 ot6a37.otX''a cprjai | otavoTj-tx)j om. | 17
otSa'av-Eiv | 18 flytxai ora.
p. 332,30 cpuatx/jv ou Xsyst | 333,5 r; habet | G toj [j-e'-jou
ev dav-^TiTio ypo'vuj | tout-
E3TIV 8 ypovco post 8 iv dxapiai'to colloc. ] 9 i'vot | IG
dy/ivo'j; 6 toioOto; | 20 6 TtXctTtovcprpiv
I
21 o'j oetTctt | 23 // | 26 arydv to(bv | Eyvtoptisv post 27
a'jvciYioy/' colloc. | 27 cfrEo
/.at Tct OLizid iatt TOiv ctxptuv XO(i.
p. 43S, 19 SeI
21 inoLfw-jf^i | 22 -ctya)Yr| ) ytvii)3xCi,av j 23 yjo'jv | 24
E-eiot) oe
25 fy om,I
26 ETttrEiSei;|27 dXr^flw;
| 431), 1 tiote U I/e-joeI? habet | 5 AiyETai voO;6 ivEpyrj (j.v
xctt xupfio; auTto -povorjaiv | 7 ovto; ovxa | 7. 8 oxav
y^'"'"'/"'" habet i7. 8 ;[ppo;:o;
|8 vE'jarj | ~pd-([).'x~a om. | 9 post xoti d- inc. f. 655'' j
xai tert. om. ] 10 r.pa-
xTixdI11 XEyexai xal
|12 -&if,aai
j13 rapaTiEaotj/i j o-jv j 14 -pi | 'fast oe | 15 jjev alt.
om.
16 del om.|16. 17 o-jo^v U
|17. 18 eotiv i;:taTTj[jLT; 1 18. 19 -^jyouv Et'at= CEK | 20
zcpt |
22 lemma om. | 24 ^TriaTTjfjir) atjXXoyta[j.ovi om. j 26
yivo(j.vrj | 28 irpo^afvEi | 30 xaiTd ytvo[j.va
| 440,1 yoOv | 2 dXXifj dp/rj om. | 3. 4 dT:ooi$ioc ora. | 5
post fjo-jv inc. f. 655^
6 ouvarj.i; om.|7 post dXryS^aTEpov add. ^xEpov | 9. 10 eit) 6
voO; | 10 eziyivwaxEt | 11 rd
habet| 11. 12 o'jto); i^ dTTOOEict; habet.
-
X SUPPLEMENirM PRAEFATIONIS
l^AKisiNUS 1917 [II. Omout H 162 cf. huius vol. 2 p. XXVII]
oliraMediceus, bombycinus forma minore saec. XIII-XIV inscr. f.
182'' tou
auToO 'fiXoTTOVou cr^"j'r;3i? zk no -puixov -r^ dzoSstxTUTj^
(rjouv sK xo -paJtov
-ojv u3-sp(ov avaXuTixoiv t; xal -siu-coxai add. m. 2). initium
contulit
H. Diels, reliqua ipse contuli:
p. 1.53, 5 -po3,3o(XoOav. 9 xiBv ora. \ 11 Xooictv | 12 o'M \ 13
t'j/Tj | 18 ajy-
-/EiTottI
19 iiii-ii om. 1 '2,1 i-zior] auXXoytap.cov | 2 -potspot; om. )
-ov te 1 xov otavorjxixov
(Aex superscr. m. 2) xat xov ] 5 iv lo | 8 1-1 xtb | 9
oto-ia/ovxE? | 10 xw utrobique | 11 ojo-
-tp 1 1() x6 ora. I 17 Sia xi oocptaxtxol IXEy/ot in mrg. m. 1 |
18 xou om. | 21 osl om, |
22 oioV/ctvI
23 post XoytxT;; add. -darii \ 24 et; ] 26 x6 6p{)6v | 3, -4
to-oi?.
p. 331,1333,29. 1 -/.at voO om. | 2 -/al xf/vr^; y.xX. om. | 5
post yj.xtv inc.
f. 2.56VI
6 oxi om. \ 11 xcd om. ] 17 ,3o6XExcit | 18 v ydp | xuJ
superscr. i 19 vat | 22 xat
om.I
23 ok om. | 24 u-oC'jyt'iu ] xai (ante vaual) | 27 xai [i-iypi
v-at 1 29 laxat | 33 auXXoytaxixrj]
a'j>. superscr. ] 332,1 post imax-^iArj add. w; | 6 xauxo |
8_.aocpia alt. 1. | 12 ij ok \ 13 iau |
15 ej-iv om.I
16 aa'fTJ | 18 o; ora. | 19 xujv om. 1 20 orjXao)] | 22 post
zepiytvofievT] (sic)
inc. f. 2571" | 24 oi~to \ xoOxo om. | 25 voepwv | 27 Scxsov |
333,5 fj om. | 6 jv daxETrxu)
ypovio xoii fXECJO'J 1 11 aTioxptvExat | 12 otTTo | 17
axoyaarjxat | 26 post ccrjalv add, 6 |
29 xeXo? xfj? |rjyrj5U); xoo -pcuxo'j pi^XicJ xt;s d-ooixxix^?
aKo cpiov^s ttii cpiXoTtdvo'J subscr.
CoiSLixiANUS 167 [H. Omont III 147] bombycinus forma media
saec,
XIV'^ foliorum 317 inscr. f 17S^" 'AptaxoxiXou^ avaXuxt/oiv
osuxsptov Txptoxov
V^?X^i "^^i^ otTrooEix(xixr,?), Ixokoc sjxiv cVxotuOaxoj
apitJiOTeXst -pt xoG
ot-oosixxixo'j xal STriaxr^jJiovixou 6i5a?ai auXXo'j'iau-oij ...
xoc oe airXouaxspct xwv
oua/ps3xsp(ov Ttpoxaxxovxat. interpretatio inc, f. 179'' med. r,
SiootaxaXtot xotl y;
ixottlr^ai? xauxa [liv elai xo) uTxoxeifiEvtu xai 05 Xo^fo ixepa
. , . des. f. 256r: xa 63
XoiT:a TTU)^ osi (Arist. p. 89^ 7). sv xai irapovxi PtfiXi'aj
oio(Xo([3tov zpl iTTiaxr^ix-/;^
xoti a::o8ei;aji;. losi "/ap dviZiv Tspl l-taxT^fxyj? oioc xo
xoti X7;v ctTToSsiJiv l-iaxrjjATjV
sivai. Txspl 6e Socr^; (inc, f. 256^) sl-s oia x6 xivi? orsjOcti
xauxov sivoti X7;v
oo;g(v xat XTjV s-t(3X7^arjV. IttsI xotl d'XXoti ouvdasi? xoti
svip^etai EtcJi tt^? "j^^/r/?,
voG;, S[dvoi7, xa/VT] xal ai Xonxoti, Xl^si xyjv ahi'x'j 61'
-?,v xouxoiv ^vxauBoT oux
E[iVTjixoViU3s. xGti cpr^slv oxi Txpo lO'jTtov si'pTjxoti V
xoti? dXXcti; 7rpaY[i.axi'at?,
v |xv xoT; r^Oixou 7rpi xi/vr^? xotl cppovifj(30)S, h 8s xoT?
cpuatxoi? u)s Iv xai-spi 'I'^yji'i T.zrA 6ic(voi'c(c, v 8s xoT;
{xsxd xd cpustxd TXEpl vou xotl oocptotc*,'
Isxi 0 7) otY/ivoia soaxoyiot xal supssi? xou {xsaou rjouv xou
atxt'ou sv daxsuxaj
yp6vu>, rjouv v dxapiaio) xai [^payuxdxoj. oxs ^dp pa)X/]0k
6id x-' xo jxpo; xr^c
asXr^v/j? xo Txpos xov rjXiov otTro^Xs-ov dsl XajxTxpov saxi
[xr^Ssv STiiaxE'j'a'u.svoc
ixrfii [xsXrjSa? (sic) xo oiovoijv suOu; iroir^cisxai xvjv
aTioxpiaiv, oxi utxo tou
-/)Xiou XdjjLTisxai, oGxo; dy/tvou;. cuius commentarii et
prooemium et initium
congruunt cum iis quae ex Escurialensi 0-1-14 f, 1-9 M.
llayduck
Eustratii in Anal. Post. 1. II commentario praeposuit') (vol.
XXI 1 p, VII
sq. cf. etiam Waitz Organ. 1. 48). f. 256''' inscr. 'AvaXuxtxuiv
uaxs'pwv osu-
xepov, 'Ev [j-sv xoj 7xpa)xa> ptBXiui . . , des, f. 317'',
quam codicis partem
ipse Parisiis contuli,
1) Num Philoponea quoque, quae Escurialensis in sequentibus (p.
XXIV) praebet,aut alia praeterea in hac Coisliniani parte
invenirentur, inquirere omisi, quoniam hunc
examinanti mihi ille ex Eustratii commentario postea edito
nondum innotuerat.
-
CONSPECTUS LIRRORUM xi
Parisinus 1913 [U. Umont II 102] oliartaceus sacc. \V folidrum
124iiiscr. ttoot'vvou dXsSotvopiu)? sSrjr,a[; stc to Tzpw-ov tojv
Garirxov avaXuxixfov
Tou dipiSTOTsXou?. ipse codicem inspexi:
]). 1,5 OE.
p. 5, 11 EtVwv 5), 1 TOJTtov. 14 xai alt. om. | IT)
7Tr>0YiYvi!)a-/t | VJ t\'J om. | outio; |2-2 Xtoov
I
ou.aTTav | 23 PouXr^aeiT) | 24 ei] xat u. v. | 24. 25
XEyio-xtvel om. ] 25 tfizi ] 26 -po-j::-
apyouar,;|^ om. I 6,5 post uro add. to-j | 6 oiSaaxaXia xal
Tiaaa om. 1 post yvwaEw; inc.
f. 3rI
9 xaTfjXilEV ^m xd uepixd | 10 ot' om. 1 11 post yvonEw; add.
cpavEpov Se lati
yvibvaiI
axorouvTi]15 post too add. zepl | 20. 21 rprjaEYvwa-^^vov | 23
aTro^cixvjTai | 25 '.fr^-
oiv cptXoao'piov om. | auXXoyiaaoi 1 7,1 ^iyzToii yvwaEco; | 6
Exaaiov oeI hahet | 11 i-ii r.dizTTEpi
I12 ob-A om.
I
13 post CrjTf/Sat add. oo | T-i prius om. | 14 yvwaev | 15
roiou; ]
16 u7:cp$T)IloTiv oXio; | 17. 18 TtpoXaSEtv, om. zpoxEpov ] 19
o] ou | 21 post te del. zpof)>.T,iJ.a
TTpoTtOEtai Ei; d7to5t;iv e vs. I'J illuta | post 'h-r/r] d-
inc. f.3v
|23 post toTc alt. add. -A
24 ante xat add. dXXd | 29 ante C>ov alt. add. to | S, 1 post
(baccJTU)? add. S^ | Cr/ToOaiv
^,[j.Iv, om. xav | 2 eaxi xevo; om. | 3 [J-ev om. 1 4 (jiv om. ]
-poaXa[j.t3dvEa8ai | 6 a^v Ttot' dro5Ei;a); | 12 a'l om. ] 13 laov
| 14 to c t(L corr. | 20 i^eXXovTa | 28 laov | 29 te om.
29. 30 post zETTEpaa.a^vr, inc. f. 4r 31 xai O'j TTEipdToit.
1>. :i;U, 1 333,29 (f. 123v). 2 post aocpi'o; add. eadem quae
U ] 4 uTrdp/ouaat |G Eivai, om. oti | 10 ydp om. | zpaxTct xai] -d
xotl corr. u. v. | 11 xcii om. | 13 7rpaY|J.aTiat; |
17 iSo'jXtjTai (Z)I
18 jaxlv om.|19 oixsi'a
|20 post [jlevtoi add. 51 | 23 U om. | 24 u7roC'JY((uv
xaiI
25 post TaOxa add. Se | 26 post ^^oe- inc. f. 124'' 1 28
d>[:iXEta | 29 eotoi | 30x7);
oo^r);] xat Td e?^; | 332,5 ^ supra inductum (o; | xat om. | 6 d
ex r^ corr. vid. | 8 ao'f ta
alt. 1.I
10 T om.i
12 ivEpYEtat | t?) oe | 14. 15 zyziw ttjv cpOaiv auxr,; | 16
aaceii | 18 o; om. ]
19 xwv om.1ToT?
I
22 zapaYtvouEVT) bis | 25 post vou inc. f. 124^ | optov ex
Epyiov
corr.1333,11 d-oxptvExat | 15 oxo/aaTjrat | 17 axoxdarjxat |
Eiatv om. ] jptoxr^ast \ 23 iQ |
25 Etow;126 i-c^iUoaz^i post 27 ouvaYouY'^ colloc. | 27 xai alt.
post dxptuv colloc. | 29 xeXo;
Tou rpioxou xfj; dzooEtxTtxT,; subscr.
Parisinus 1972 [H. Omont II 173 cf. luiius vol. 2 p. XXVIII]
bom- F
byciniis saec. XIII- XIV et Coislinianus 157 [H. Omont III 145]
mem- E
braneus saec. XIV, codices gemelli, ille f. 32^-390% hie f.
28^-33^
sub eodem titulo eundem in Analyticorum Posteriorum libriim I
commen-
tarium habent atque Coislinianus 167 f. 390^' (331^ inscr.
aoiatoTeXou;
avaXuTixaiv ucjiiptov Ss'jtspov (rubr. E) itemque f. 391^
(332''), inter quos
titiilos exstat prooemiura Philoponi (p. 334,2 336,2). alternant
deindef. 391'" 436 ^' (332'' 3620 textus Aristoteleus et
interpretatio Philoponeainscholia divisa niimeris ascriptis (rubr.
in E), quibus numeri interpretandis
Aristotelis verbis appositi respondent, utrumque codicem
Parisiis contuli. ')
Laurentianus LXXXV 1, qui Oceanus dicitur [Bandini III 237 247
K
1) Partsinis 1843 [IT. Omont II 151 cf. huius vol. 2 p. XWI n.
1] bombycinussaec. XIII f. 158 205 Aualytica Posteriora continet
cum scholiis, inter quae sunt Phi-loponea, velut f. 189v in marg.
rubro xo'j cptXoTrovo-j ascriptum est, ut Ad. Torstrik
testatur,
scholio ItteI hi 7:p6; xauTTjv x/jv {j-daeatv xxX. i. e. p.
241,25 sq. (25 ind Se \ 26 (pT^otv
itavTtovI
27. 28 d; xai o'jxio; ovo(i.dCo'jaiv or.tp ouxo CJov | 28 xat
primum et alt. om. |
242,1. 2 xat orEp d'vDpw-o; xat Td Xoi-d. otd | 2 auxd | 2. 3
xo'jtoj O'jsa; o XY"rat),
f. 191 r scholio rapaotY[J.aTo; hvAt-^ xtX. i. e. p. 269,15 sq.
eadem inveniuntur in
Barocciano 87 chartaceo saec. XVI. cf. vol. II 1 p. XIXXXTI.
-
xii SUPPLEMENTUM PRAEFATIOMS
cf. etiam Imius vol. 2 p. XXI] bombycinus saec. XIV forma
maxima, per-
spicue t nitide scriptus, f. 217' 250\ quae Philoponi in Aoalyt.
Post,
libr. I commentarium continent, a Gull. Rabehl Berolinensi
collata sunt.
T Laurentianus LXXI 31 [Bandini III 16] chartaceus saec. XV
constate foliis 187 male scriptis. f. V, quod inscr. litteris
madore paene evanidis
Too cpiXorovou icTjYr^aic etc: to -pioTov ir^q aTroosixxixTjC,
16^' excerpta con-tinet e Philoponi coramentario, quae inde a f.
17'' Aristotelis verbis, quibus
scholia brevia interraixta sunt, in margine sunt circumscripta,
post verba
TO fjosaOai u-o(p-/iv i. e. p. 305,22 scholia a Philopono
prorsus discrepant,
hue usque codex ab eodem Guil. Rabehl collatus est. uotatione
lectionum
nos iure supersedisse satis ex hisce apparebit:
p. 1,4 post titulum add. lemma -aaa ij.d9Tr)(Jt; | 5 post toOto
add. to pipXt'ov|
5. G 6 Tiept dnohzi^zuii Xoyo?|8 xuiv cm.
|10 v.cti prius' om.
|12 ouSe
|15 tha] out'
|
"2,2 (o; d7t0(?aijiv om.|
2. 3 6 aocptaTtxo;, 6 d-oSEtxTtxo';, 6 5iaAeiCTf/.6; | 5 v io
i
7 ili'jyoii; om.|8 tw
|xd; et w; cpTjOtv om.
|9 Si^daxovtai] -at non liquet
|
10 XE/pT]-
ai)at dXK 711 TwI
[ATjOiic 17 Xo'yos om.|18 toO dtzooEtxTf/.oij om.
|19 to om.
|
r/ov-o;
23 oTt [i.v om.I
23 teXos ouv, post quod add. nescio quid | 24 tk \ 25 cpTjfxi
om. |
3,1 d-09i?t? 28 yvcoOEU)? om.|32 au-ov
|4,1 iV 3 EupEOEio; om. | 3 ob-/. dXr^^tz hi \
ofJTOs 13 ciy-O'jaTEOv om.)15 ^-c [j.a8i^aU)s e; EupESiio; | 16
or] xal rj | 22 ytvofiivr,
om.I
?; TO -d9o;|-poayopEUETCtt
]23 d ydp 29 yvtuacio? om.
|5,1 yvojatv om. | 1. 2 tooto
To'oE to'joe XE'JxoiEpov|2 post atadrjOt; add. (xutyj
|4 xai dXXu); 11 oTt om.
|
11. 12 xai TiiaTOUTCd] .... adij.vos
|13 ?] TTJ;
I
xal otd p/jiopixT]; i- periit | 14 ex] xuiv | xai
15 T)(vu)v periit, ut multa in seq.|19 tyjv om.
|23 PouXtji^eit)
|25 xctl xutuv xai ^o'jr
om.I
T^5tI28 oiov om.
|29 post XEyouaav add. oti
| 6, 1 EvoiapdXXETai | 5 xaXui; ott om. |t) otSaoxaXfa Tiaaa
om.
|7 7,5 om.
|6 Sei om.
|10. 11 6cptXovTa | 11 dXX" IS cprjiJ-i
om.I
21 TO EtI
23 ou S,2 xevo's om.|4 sxaOTo?
]6 post [jlevtoi add. r.dar^i \ 9 ydp om.
|
10 EXdTTou;I
15 Tipo'Taats om.|16 eotIv 19 ovjat'a om.
|20 xd ocpEiXovxa 7rpoXa;xpdvai)at
|
xotvu); om.|
22 -zo'j|26 dXXrjXai? t'aat
|29 te om.
|30 xat ETt 10,4 e't/.TjTtTat om. | 7 et
8 ar]fj.atvot 1 9 post OT,jj.aivt add. [jio'vov | 14 Td om. | 16
Tjij.d; EiOEvat | to om. | 17 7:apr;xv |
18 (rp'ayE) Xacpov o'J S'JvotTov|
post Etosvat add. to Tt egtiv dyvooOvTa Tt arjuatvEt | tov
pro
alt. TOI
20 a/);j.aivot|ETTEtTa 26 aTj[j.atvEt om.
|27 dXXtov habet
|29 'q prius om.
|30 post
xat tert. add. ^v|32 twv om.
|11,1. 2 dpti)[J.rjTtxrj yw[j.ETpt'a | 4 y.ai 12,16 i~-
egtovTE; om.j17 7:poai3dXXu)[jiEv
|19 ydp XdOy)
|20 Xd^orj-Ev
|tov TOtoiJTOv
|23 Ecpotpixoaojj.Ev to
|
25 Tj Toia'jTT] TTdtJaI
28 EtVj] EviI
13,1 ante xpo'Tiouv add. twv | 4 ofov 14,!) yt'vETat om.|
10 ri TE utrobique ] 13 t? C'^Trjatv | 17 7rpoa|3dAXw[JiEv | 18
o'jvd;j.3a | 19 auxov pr. 1. | 20 C^^teIv
aiTovI
21 8I
22 dyaywv tov ooOXov|tov alt. om.
|24. 25 Iotiv o'j saTt TETpdyiovov
j
26 otd(j.TpocI
28 TETpdytovov] TiXEupd;|a^5p
|15, 1 ExdaTT) Ttliv om. | apOij | SC^^I | 2 ij.iyvuat |
3 Xsyu) 8r;om.|4 5* om.
|
yiiTj|7 dpa om.
|7. 8 too evo; TETparrXdata auTovJ IsTt | 11 t'aa
om.I
12 otaipouat|16 yst^
|21 ^^dywv
|xd Ciqto'j;j.ev | 23 xat ou 20,16 oIoe om.
p. 29,15 31,5 d7tooEt;t? om.|8 yvwpt[j.ov alt. 1. | 12 w; eIitov
om. | po.st 3Ttv add.
r;I
13 Td oE'jTEpa TTtaxoupEvrjI
16 XYJi; SeiIeu); xaXstxat|
20 auToiJ|26 xat om.
|28 aO
om.I
32,3 5^|7 post xaTd add. Td
|8 34,3 om. | 4 ';;v 9 cpTjOtv om. | 11 ivAQx-i^ivf^^i
ri
-
CONSPECTUS Lir^RORUM xiii
vcaiI
5 if)[j.a)vI
6 0'jT|8 aOr/jV ora.
|9 7.atc(3/.'J7'Ct
|toj cc^toO ovto;
|10 aitooei^eu);
|13
isTiv om.I
15 r>5, 28 om.p. 24-7,4304. 12 om. | 13 ante lemma add.
a/oXiov si; to | o'j -/.tX. om. | 17 citi o'j (j.ovov
|
31 -/otl dydy-AriI
32 Tiva alt. om.|33 \j.iaow
|305,2. 3 ot'iiouv d'vilpujzo?
|4 6 xot om.
]7 tov
[jLvI
11 post raXiv add. ok\
dXoio'jjjLsvov|12 to ry5o'|/.vov (jiTG(j^c(XXt om.
|13 oiAotoOailat
utrobique|14 (jlv om.
|15 T^jpjj.t'Ct
|15. 16 ^jpEii-fCov
|19. 20 (i.^!Jov Xoirov ^v ttj /^pEi/i'ct
Y^VETOtt TO r^pEij-tCoiJ-ivov. 1)
Fragmenta Senensia, iiidicio llicronyini Vitelli saec. Xl\ , e
bibliotheca S
Seminarii archiepiscop. 8. Francisci [cf. E. Piccolomini De
codd. Pii II
et III deque hibl. eccL cafhedmlis Se/tmsu Hull. Sen. 6, 1899 p.
483,3],
ijuorum unum constat e fol. 4 -f- 1 + 1 quat. + 1 4- 1 quat. 4-
1 quat.,alterum e fol. 1 + i-+ 1, editionis nostrae continent,
ilhul (.scholiis nume-ratis cpa' i. e. (piXo-ovou a' 9pt')')
p. 1 3,2 A7}Xp7.VO(j,evo;
3,16 sli)' 28 ^vwcjeto?5,11 eiTccbv 6,G 7va)ai
-
XIV SUPPLEMENTUM PRAEFATIONIS
172,15173,20
177,16 179,22180,25 185,5186,22 188,6 on i^AiapeX h oU
[j-sv189,7 20191,1.2 lemma
193,30. 31 lemma
194,15 lemma
194,20 lemma
195,5 16 (v. n.)198,625
201,29 202,11203,12 205,9207,1-208,11
208,24210,5
210,21211,14
212,18-216,26
223,1-24224,19 225,27 aTrsipous eivat.
quae omnia contulit Guil. Rabehl. varietatem lectionum p. 66,19
124,10subnotare satis habui, quibus addo haec:
p. 1,13,2 XaiAjSctvofievo;. inscr. ttoavvou dXz^iwopiuiQ xoO
cptXo7:ovou xai Oefxtatiou ')zo'j cpiXoadcpo'j ?Tjrjatc et; to a
[BtpXfov tt;; dTiooeixxtxTi?
|5 post toQto add. to ^t^Xiov
|
7 01T om.
I
12 post O'jTs add. oe|17 TtciXtv ir.ti ou ouvaxov
|2,2 Trpoxipot; om.
|2. 3 xov
T xal Tov y.oa tov | 5 oe post 6 Stoaaxei coUoc. | 6
dTiaTtop-eSa | xai om. | 7 O'jXXo-Yta[j.o\> om.
|8 7:p6; Td; aocpianxd; | 10 xui utrobique | 12 ij (ante 3rou8.)
| 12. 13 to toiouto
eTooc tcuv auXXoyiOfxoJv|13 ^att] thai cpaai
|17 to'j; cptXoaocpou;
|20 ttj dvaYXT) ttj ToiauTTj
|
ou 0i ydpI
21 0i om.|27 tov op86v teIj^ov.
p. 3,16 zl\f 28 Yvioaeu)?. ante 16 tW add. eijtiuv to xaSo'Xou
toutesti to 7rpoxi[AEvov|
21 h. 24 IvvotuJv om.]25 u)|i.oXoYO'jadvai
|27 fXEfCovs;
|28 post d'vEu add. TrjC
p. 5,11 Eijtiov 6,6 f'jwatuii. 11 OE oTi om.|11. 12 post
(ActSirjai? add. otavoTjTixY]
|
19 TTjv om.I
22 post ;:otTjac(fj.Evov add. outoj;|23 pouXr^ftEtr] Tt;
(JiaOeiv
|24 TzdJi; anav
|
X^yw 27 auXXoyt^o'jj.8a] i^ ETiaytoYTj; tcuv xaTd fxEpo;
[>.OL%TiazTai. ex oe to'jtou fz\-f]'JtTciiTOO xaSoXou
auXXoYtuiJ-
-
CONSPKCTl'S r.ll'.itniM^M xv
S post ininkifiCLi add. to'j; vcctXrjv ttjv X'ioiv ind-joyzai
xdi toio'jtco uo'^fafnaxt | xrjv oin.|
9 -poEYvcoaijLEvtov|13 y.cd 15 xaSdXo'j om.
|18 ou (aevtoi
|21 xiva iii euSet'a; ti eJooxa
|
21. 22 -/at EixTiaXtv oin. | 22 [AEvxot j 23 ^;:t/ip/,at os xi;
| 24 o-jvcctciv x^] xcti | 26 ECxt 30yvuipt'Covxa ora.
| 17, 1 x6 0 om. | 4 auxui x6 | ijA'^co ouxto; om. | -5
Y''''"3xovxa 1 8 ifj(JiIvcm.
I
II EYvtupias 0111,|13 ow ora.
|14 ytpl
|xivt (ante i^jij-i-/.)
|15 5td xovi
|18 YUivta; ora.
|
O'joI
19 xat om.|20. 21 iiavxos xptywvo'j oi xpsT; yujviai laat
stai'v.
p. 1{>, 11 21,6 oto;j.E}a 7.TrXcoc. 11. 12 ctXX' [xavSavEt
om. | 13 post ^ add. (jiv |Yj pro alt. r^xot
|14 ante Evor/Exai add. oOx
|15 O'jvt ora.
|Ul zl] rj
\17 x6 alt. om.
|19
xov] TTEpt TOOI
auxov om.I
'20,2 |;.av9avEi|5 post /j add. x?;; | 10 sxaaxov aTiooEtxxixov
| 13
dvxi] atxtovI
14 post d;ro5Ei;io; add. xai | 15 xal om. | 16 [jiv x6 | 20 xtj;
om. | 22 im-
ox^fxat alt. om. j 23 (Stxtoxspov | 24 ouv ora. | 27 r) om. | 28
oxt 30 e/eiv] oxav xr^v xe aWavo[o}jiE8a yivwaxEiv hi 'f)v x6
Tipayijia oxt iv.sho'j airh eoxI xctl jj-tj | 21,2. 3 oxt
T:EnEi'a[XE8a
cm.I
5 Trctvxcov ;:ept auxf^c om. | 6 jiost y.-r'kwi prius add. dXXct
p./) a'j|j.p|jT|XOi: v. n.p. 22,8 23 post 21,5 Iwot'ct; coUoc. | 8
post yip add. xat | 9 ot-ixov | ouxto? r/eiv
om.I
12 oTTtsdE pctXXEtvI
13 xaijxTjv oiovxat x/jv a(xiav|14 xouxo i'XXto; r/Etv
|16 xe om.
|
18 }] om.I
auXXoyiaij-di loxtv|19 o'j x6] o5xo; xat | 20 xat primum ora. |
21 xtvd zotEi i\
;^[AtvI
22 OE habet(23 post xoii add. dX/jSoi;.
p. 23,9 27,11. 9 post EioEvat add. xouxsaxtv sTrtaxaa9at | 10
eittwv yap Et [iev o'jvxal EXEpdc laxt xpoTio; xo5 Int'dxaaSai
uaxspov | 12 o'jv om. ] (XExaXaapavtuv | 14. 15 u)3xe
iXEye] ou
I
16 vuv om.|20 yivu)axo(j.v xouxesxiv oxt laxlv ixitvou atxtov |
23 9Eiopi^at | (j.ev
om.I
x6 TC^pa; xtj; aTtoOEt'^EU);|25 rj primum ora.
|27 ya'p, cpr^at] xat
|24,1 post dXTjduJv add.
x'I
post clvat add. eadem quae a|
ydp] Esxt|
2. 3 o avftpturo; dpa ] 3 ydp om. | 4 ou [j-ev
i; dX7)8(Lv TrpoxotOEtov|5 i~ ak^xid^ TipoxdaEiov SeT Eivat | 7
post xaXtii; add. oe | x6 om. |
8 post ccOdvaxo; add. xat|9 I; om.
|10 oxi d8dvaxo; sivat i} Au//j | OEixai | 12 o'jxoj; |
13 Etvai post TipoxdaEtov colloc.|15 xtvwv ora. | TiepatoOxat |
18 post xaxTjyopoi.uEvov add.
ri (XT] EtvatI
19 xat prius om.|
post xat alt. add. 06 ] 22. 23 e(; x6 d7iooi;at | 24 E-iovxat
|
25,5 post a'JxoTrtaxov add. axtv | 9 TrapaXa[jiPa'vxai | 10 OEt
[at] p.o'vov rpdxEpa Eivai dXXa
xat atxta zo'j\12 xat prius om.
|14 xd 7rapaXa[j.pavo';j.Eva post 13 d[j.Eaa colloc. 1 16
cpT^aiv
cm.I
19 ouvovxot | 24 ucp' Sv auxo ouv oXov dvayvioaxEOv | 26,4 post
ofxEta add. tj | 7 auxou |
12 post ExXsuj^iv add. Xsyovxa; ouxw; | 14 7iaXtvopotJ.r]au)[xv
| oix eaxtv | dXXd xExp-r^ptov
cm.I
15 post x6 add. Se|16 oux Sxt xo \j.ri ov | 18 E-avaXafxpdvet |
19 post ouSe add.
dXTjSrjI
23 post ^TitaxaaOai alt. add. w; (xr) ov, xouxEaxtv | 25 post
a-jp-ixexpo; add. eoxc xfj
TtXEupctI27,2. 3 a6ij.[Xxpov ECxtv EtvatJ ioeiy^ri '(,
xptycoviov. x6 hi drro xf^; ota[x^xpou
XEaadpojv. dXXd x6 dTto xr); otapi^xpo'J daufjifjiExpdv sixt
xiii dTO xtj; TiXEupa; | 3 post orov
add. cpeps e^tteiv|3. 4 x6 ^(jL^aBov xoii dTto xf;; TiXEupd; |
6. 7. 8 6 om.
p. 27,2232,7 (notantur hie quae ab a, a' discrepant). 28,8 (b; |
11 ib; post aixiaxwv
colloc.I
13 ytvovxai|15. 16 06 xaD' sauxd
|
17 xoi; TTpdyfxaatv om. | 18 ou xxX. om. | 26 0, xi |
post ivxau&a add. xat|
xaOxa ora.127 xt -om.
|29,1 xat xd e^tj; om. | 8 zpoxspov | 9 post
dvspyouvxE; add. ei; xd p-sptxd|10 a'jXXoyia,a6v om. | 11 xd
alt. om. | 14 uaxepov \\f\.^ TrpdxEpov
xal uaxEpov aacpdaxepov|23 5e xxX. ora. | 24 al -poxdaEt;\atxtai
| 30, 1 o-jxat [ post ydp add.
xalI4 x6 om.
I
5 [aeoou ora.|
6 Ttpo;|9 xd; dTroSet'SEt; | 14 ti xu/oi om. | 22 post TtdXiv
add.
OE[26 post ouafa add. loxi
|31,2 oxe 8e p.i^xE | 3 auXXoytCwixEaa | 6 Xdyst ] 8 ^axi om.
|
15 -pdxepaI
20 OE-JXEpot|a(xtaxd
|26 saxt hk xol auxfj; 6 TjXto; | 29 auxTjv d:topX^iTov
8X0V fj|xtocpatptovI
32,1. 2 ouxto Elvat habet | 2 xd om. [ 3 x^ om.p. 171,11 6 ydp
26. 13 &Et; om. | Edar] | post ipiotu); add. hk \ 15 [xev ora.
| 17 ydp |
20 eyouat|lyyuxdpto
|22 xd; om.
|23 axfX^Eiv post au}|xdxu>v colloc.
'p. 172,15 173,20. 15 xal xxX. om. | 19 oxav {x^v] xoii hi ahioo
\ 20. 21 yvcopip-ibxEpov8^ x6 otxtov om.
|22 dvopi TrETrXrjOt'axe | 23 ptEv om. | 23. 24 xu xoiixo om. |
24 ouv om. |
post oxi add. Eoxai | 27 dvopl ante 26 Ttavxto; colloc. | 173,3
postahiaxoii add. ovxo; 1
4 x6 xExox^vat atxtov iypidaEio; | iTitihri ye \ 5 xo pr. 1. I
oe om. | 6 xtxox^vat |tpVjaouEv
|oxt
om. ' 7 post o'vxo; add. xat | 8 dSuvaxov ydp xadXou, om.
aixiaxdv , 1156vaaai post xo
-
XVI SUPPLEMENTUM PRAEFATIONIS
prius colloc.I
12 [jlovov|86vota8ai om.
|15. 16 cpafjiv ouv Sxi ouvctjief to al'tiov X^yofisv
|
16 y.oti oi"/] O'ivaTat slvctt (j.rj ovtoc toj atnotToO. ou
-/(ipI
post cti'-riov add. Xe'yoijlev eIvoi|
17 3-iv] O'jvctTat elvai ib;|
ouar^; xabo ;iv -/t xotctvOi|18 Xr^'x^ctTj
|19 e{ Y'^P "^^ aixtov
5'jvc(ij.tI
20 TO aiTiov -oin.
p. 177,16 170,22 (notantur hinc quae ab a, a' discrepant). 17
toOto xtX. oua. | 20 tov
dptaTOTEXrjV|26 t(L
}30 otd to
|178,8_TrjV om.
|
9 pu)T7j8t; 11 auXr^Tpfoa; (v. not.) om.|
11 [xh om.j13 yap
|179,10 d 12 Xoyov om.
j15 Cti U
\17 lemraa habet. !
p. 212, 18 216,26. 24. 25 yj tw dTto^aTixdi? om. | 213,17. 18
i-Alir.oi \ 20. )l antedpiSfxo; add. 6 (v. not.)
j
214,1 TidvTto; om.|8 [j.Et'Cou;
|10 (atv
|31 ofov 215, nXoyou;
om.I
9 Tj diiooi;t; pr. 1.|10 Td
]17 Y^wpifxa -^i^E-zai
\18 eotIv
|auvtet;
]
19 w?|
26 SauTd|
216,2 oTi xatI
oi' -aYU)yrj; (v. not.) | 6 uj:oxt;j.vu)v | 17 auTcov | 21 li
y^P 23 aiai)'rjatoc
om.I
post 26 abOrjToiv notavit haec: oryii-Et'ioaat oi oti 'i^Ta'j%a
[J-r/pt ttoXXou ou-x eotiv
i^riiriaii tou cptXozovou. inti 0 orou q d/.oXo'j9. toO
dptSpLoO. 'iaxi 8s i-/.s.l Ev8a tooe.
I). 223,124. 1 ETTt E/Ei om.
|15 slvat om.
|18 Tidv.
p. 224, 19 225,27 dtiEipou? slvat. 24. 25 ou TTEpt Tuiv Tiapd
cp'jatv estI xaTr^yopttuvdXXd rspt Tu)v xtzTd cpoatv | 26 et 27
laydTO'j | 30 ar^vsliyy^zTai 225, 1 Stj oui. | 5 [jiv om.
[
6 oiov to p om.I
7 dro toO C | 8 O'jtio? ouv, om. to'jtou | 12 aEOwv]
[j.piy.u)TE'puiv | 13 fj cp'jstc
om.I
14 ri Td | 15 post to'jtiov add. e( | 18 (bSEiaajAEv | 19. 20
eI'te ut:" %ct(}oXty.u)TEpovhabet
[21 post dvayxTj add. ouv
[22 post ydp add. dv yjv
|23 dpi9(x6v om.
|25 ante, o-j
add. xai|26 ou6e.
U Marcianus 225 [Zanetti p. 118 cf. huius vol. 2 p. XXII] olim
Bessa-rionis, chartaceus foliorum 467 saec. XIV f. 341^^' 448^^
Philoponi in Anal.Post. libr. I commentarium continens collatus est
a Guil. Rabelil.
V Vaticanus 247 [Brandis Die Arist. Handschr. d. Vat. Bihl.
(Abhandl.d. k. pr. Akad. d. W. zu Berl. 1831) p. 53 n. 13 cf. huius
vol. 2 p. XIV. XV]
chartaceus saec. XV f. 1'' 12^' initium commentarii Philoponei
in Anal.Post. libr. I continens (usque ad p. 53,13 l~d [irjos
auXXoYtajxov) collatus
est a Guil. Cronert.
Y " Vaticanus 209 [Brandis 1. c. p. 59 n. 54 cf. huius vol. 2 p.
IX, X]chartaceus saec. XV foliorum 218. f. IBS'", quod inscr.
[(juotvvou aXecavSpio)?TOO '-ptXoTiovou a;(oXixo!l
auosTjfAsicocfsis xxX. (p. 1,24), 218^' cum aliorum,imprimis
Magenteni, scholiis Philoponi in Anal. Post. libr. I
commentarium
continent usque ad p. 120,5 si' 7s osoeixxat. scholia numerantur
pX'. specimen
lectionum suppeditavit Guil. Cronert.
p. 1,53,6 (quibus nihil apposui, concinunt omnia cum Vaticano
1018 Z). 5 posttit. add. lemma -dsa y''"^'^^"^* ("^''^^
(jLaSi^aEU); Z)
|9 post twv add. a-:{kw-^
\10 paoi'aw.aEv
post Ta'JTTjV colloc. ZI
13 ol'jpuYX^"^] T superscr. Z | 14 post toO add. {xrj (om. Z)
|
16 yvwvat d'vE'j TrpoxdoEiov|napEOioxEv
]17. 18 ou ouvktov
|19 TiapEOtuxEv
|2,2 TipOTSpotj
om.I
^OE(;apLEV (d-E0t;au.v Z)|
3. 4 twv piEv djroOEtxTixwv GuXXoYtajMov|
4. 5 tov
Si Tiotpaoioioai om. (habet Z)15 xt; post dv colloc.
|6 xoii ora.
|7 dX;tTrjptov
( r]x Z)I
8 7rapE-/ov Z | 9 oiodaxoutjt | 10 xw utrobique Z |
xE/pTja&at, post (piod add.
Touxou 1 14 0 om.I
15 1T^z om. Z|IG ouSe superscr. Z
|22 po'iXoivxo
|3,3 to zapov,
in. mrg. yp- x6 itpoxstpLEvov Z | 4 xoTrot; | 5 TipoapaXXoufAEv
| 6 post d7ro'5Ei?iv inc. f. 183^.
p. 11J),6 120,5. 7 t5ta; om. | 11 YivwaxEoi^at | 13 r; om. | 16
h xot; om. | 19 /^v |post dXXcov add. oe
|aiTt'wv
|20 yP 1 120,4 ti; recte | 5 dTioSEixTixd^ recte | post
BlSejxzai des. f. 21.SV.
-
CONSPECTUS LIBROIIUM xvri
Vaticanus 1018 [Brandis 1. c. p. ol> n. G cf. huiiis vol. 2
p. XV] Zchartaceus saec. XV-XVI f. 355'-445'" sub codein titulo
atquc Vatif. 209cum Magenteiii et Neophyti scholiis IMiiloponi in
Aiialyt. Post. lihr. Icoramentariiim continet scholiis numeratis
xqo'. post miscellanea deinde
aliorum scholia') f. 449'", quod inscr. drAa-ozilvj;
otva/.oxtx(ov osuTspov, 480^' exstant pv-' scholia, quorum primum
est rept -ou [liaou C^^-ooat. Cr,-Tt OS TTspl TO'j [jL30'j opou i.
6. p. 341,9 sq., ultimum des. in verba xa-t(j-r^ta 7Tpa7(j.aTa xctt
a-oosixta i. e. p. 440,12. praeter initium libri I,
cuius varietatem supra e Guil. Cronert schedis proposui, haec
mihi praesto
erant, quae Torstrikio (1. I) et losepho Heeg Monacensi (I. II)
debeo:
p. 194, 16 19. 16 draxTjv Ttvdt] oo^av -Leuofj[17. 18 tivo;
a^AlofKSiJ.o'j fi'^o^iyrii
\
18. 19 waTTEp 3x1 XTjC ZTzX TOU Siot,
p. 233,21 235,7. 28 oti om. | ante za add. ci'vxa | 29 -aolt
oioevo; ciX'ho'j xa-rjo-pelo&at
I
30 ^XtJetv|234,1 o) rrpw-io
|Stoxt ?.a,upc
-
xvm SUPPLEMENTUM PRAEFATIONIS
^yo'jvI
yvcoptij-WTspat Et3i bis|20 TTOtpi
|22 p.Td draaatj
|25 dXrj&EOXEpcit
|26 d-d5t;tv
|
27 xdc dpyct; fjouv -ci; -pOTCtaeis | 28 Trpopottvet | 29 e^ ydp
| Xoyiopio; recte | 30 -/aTayivJtj.cvaf
101 xalI
440,2 dXXrj dp/T) om. | 3. 4 dTroOti^eoj; xotl om. | 4. 5 eJ
yoijv (jir^Siv dX>.o y^vo;
bisI
6 6 om.|8 post dp/div add. xat r^ jxev ttj; dp/rjS
|9 post q add. recte ;jiv
|
post
dpyfj? add. dv ei't]|
post dv add. dp/rjj10 d-o'ot;iv
|11 id om.
EscuRiALiENSis 0-1-14 [cf. vol. XXI 1 p. V] chartaceus
formamaxima saec. XVI f. !' 9^' initiam auonymi illius in Analyt.
Post. libr. I(usque ad p. 71^25) commentarii a M. Haydack I. c. p.
VIIXVIII editumcontinet, qui exstat etiam iu CEF et Mosq. 313, in
quo p. X 20XVIII 20multa sunt e Philoponi commentario (p. 7,7
26,13) excerpta, qaorumnonnulla integriorem nostris codd. memoriam
videntur servavisse: p. 7,14
(X 28) -/voiV^txsv (7voT[jiv conieci), p. 20,24 (XV 20) ouv,
quod addidi, habet,
p. 24,20 et 23 (XVII 25 et 28) dTroSsixxujv et a::ootxxa v. Add.
et Corr.
EscuRiALiENSis O-III-IO [Miller p. 171 cf. huius vol. 2 p.
XXIV]
bombycinus saec. XIIIXIV post Analyt. Prior, libr. II cum
Philoponicommentario circumscripto') inde a. f. 116'' Analytica
Posteriora continet,
quorum libro I varia scholia ascripta sunt, inter quae sunt
plurima e com-
mentario Philoponeo excerpta; libri II scholia rariora esse Ad.
Torstrik
testatur. e photogrammatis foliorum llGi" 117^ haec noto:f.
116'" med. scholia sic incipiunt: eXouv 6 dptaTotsATj? d-oocT;c([
o-t r^ dTTooeuu ex
rpOEyvtoJij-Evcov xal Trpooij.o^.oyo'juiviov ytvEtcd, otpysiat
drro xoO 7.ai}o},0'j, r^TOt xr,? otoa3y.c(/.ta;
A'xi XT]? (j.a&rjaEO);, a i-.b ayvwapievtuv ((^o\T(xi. ti 0
xovixo, im Ss xal /) duOOsi/CxtxY) ot-oarxaXfa xal [Addrjat;,
Xotrrov d'pct xai ^ dTcoBEtxxixrj ix TrpOEyvtuauEvrj; ytvExat
yvcdacU); '.
'0 dpi3xoxX7)c OeXwv oiodiott -pi d-00Et?(o; o'jx d[;LE3io; 7:1
X(]v xooxO'J 5toa3-/.o;Xtc(v ^/_(opTrj3v,
1) e photogrammatis fol. 102v 103^, quae postea mihi suppeditata
sunt, iiceat hieaddere varietatem lectionum ad vol. XIII 2 p. 387,
1 397,27. 5 /.od t.6-z y.xX. om.
|
7 ipElv, om. cpTjat|11 uXoii
|18 xo-jXdytaxov ypeta
|388,7 ol Se xxX. om. | 10 -/.al primum
om.I
16 lemma om.I20 eI'ttoi
|21 hj^oi
|25 et 26 x6 xdJ
|389,2 oXov
|3 e^ superscr. d
z'y/oi praeterea in mrg.|d'pa om.
j6 oi superscr.
|12 post ixEpo; add. oux
|
14 o3a zxX. om.|
26 xai alt. om.|34 6 oaoi'tu; om.
i390,1 post a'jij.7:Epa3[xa add. l3xtv
|
otd xoij xxX. om.|
3 U'j x6 TO sicI
13 post cpctvEpov add. o'jv|oxt] t
|15 eJ yip] oxt
|19 22 om.
|27 x6
G'jvdyovI
xotxacpaxtxov|391,1. 2 v -pitjxu) c/T^ij.axt dsuXXo'ytaxo? | 9
olov inc. f. 103r | xoO
fiEv 7.xX. om.I
17 o'j om.|18 oxt f^v
|21 ouvaxov
j23 tusx' xxX. om.
|28 txoxe [iev toxe
0I
392,1 post 6' add. ir.l zi \ 4 post oxi add. laxtv | 6 habet |
12 tiL dXir)i}Ei aup.-pd3}jiaxi
xio118 O'J/ xxX. om.
I
22 x6 aofArEpasij-oc x6 p | 26 si oviv] o'j-xoov | ov] oiov | 29
sh xxX.
om.I
393,1 TO a xxX. om.|6 xoOxo om.
|xal om.
|Isxi om.
|9 xod xxX. om.
|12 fj.v et
6^ om.1
14 ? om.|
16 xaxacpaxtxcd xal dro-fotxixal|
22 xiw; om.|23 x^33ap; u. v.
|
32 post -d3c(; add. ouC'jyta;|
3!)4,7 post a add. h | u-dpyov xxX. om. | 14 dlr^Ui |19. 20. rjv
ydp x6 dXr^SE? O'jSevi x6 p | 23 ycVO[jLvai | 24 dXrjSuiv xwv
zpoxd3E(uv ouswv |
25 'Leuoujv ou'SiL'^I
28 0I
29 a\rj%z
-
CONSPECTUS LIBRORUM xix
otXXd TTpcuTOv TTaosotoxe Tot; a-AcJ; cpiovot; v Tal;
-/.aTTjopiat;, Etxa V Ttl) -epi frjj.T,via; xi;
TrpoTctaet;. Iv 0 xot; zpoTEpoi; dvot/.uTtxoi? zepi too aTiXui;
a'jAAoYtaiAoO. elxa ood) /pTj3a[j.vo;
Ip/exai xal EvxaOSa Stoctaxcov xov Xoyov xov TEpi (i::ooi;io;.
ov xai dvayxatov -/i Tiapa-
Souvat (b; xoi; cpiXoao'cpotc 7piQai;-i.ov -/.'A c(vaYxai(ixaxov
ovxa. et Y'^P V-^ ""i a~o5t;t y_pTjaxat,
oux 3v 5uvtj8t) xtjv dXT^9iav xat x6 'I/euOo; otEuxpivfjaat.
toOto y^'p ^sxtv lotov toO xuptio;
cptXoaocpo'j, x6 EUpt'axEiv xov dXrji3fj auXXoYiaaov xat xov
'l^EUofj xal dnooEijat a-jxov. waTiEp
Ydp oux v[ 656; 8iod;a[ xtvd x6 xouocoe xaxaaxE-jdaat TTpotY^d
xi, ( [atj dzXd);y'"'^"''"''-^'
'^^i''
xouTO'j Y'^waiv, o'jxio; xat woe -ettoiV^xev 6 xE/vtxiii. ^ot6a;
xov drXdi; G'j>./.oyi'3!''-'j"'> ^~*
xat Ttept Tou dTtooEtxxixoO (JuXXoYicJ[J.oi) cb;
irpoixotilo'vxa; xat TrpoYtvu'jsxovxot; xov dTiXdi;
a'jXXoYia,a6v xa\ xaSoXo-j: 'Icjxeov o'xi h -oevxt
7:pO(3Xr,ijLaxl ouo xauxa ftEtopEtxai, xo 600|i.vovxat x6
CtjXO'J|j.vov. otov 6 [jiev u;roxi[Jivos opo;, X^y
-
XX SUPPLEMENTUM PRAEFATIONIS
El yeI
27,3 ofov 5 zhon om. | 5 'jpot; | 6 au[i.|j.Tpov rr; TiXeypoi
bis u. v. | 7 post ;j.8' add.vuv 0 V ^3Ttv
I
7 TO TETpctyuivov om.I
9 -oXXa-Xa3t5tCoavo;I
10 O'joeI? c(pii}[j.d;.
Mr) xotrd a'j,aj3s,3rjx6; i. e. p. 28,6 11 /iv. 7 (jl/j xa&'
ccjto eiS^vott j 10 aJTO.T(L I'jvif/a!, TO'JTEan Toi EtOEvat xt
arjpiaivEi vj Ti lanv. d),}.a zoti t(u EtOEvctt oti laxt.
xat axoTiEi OTt vuv cf.7)5tv oTi xal xotrd 060 rpoTToy; o^ov
Etoevat rd d?tio(j.aTa i. e. p. 2S,20 Ua.
"Oxi TO -po'xEpOV 5tTT0V, TO [JtEV TTpOC TjfJtd;, TO 51 TTpO?
TTJV Cp'JStV. XOll -puJTa [J.EV TTJ
cp'jaei XEyovTat xct xotvi xai xaSoXixd, arEp r]u.tv icTiv
uaTEp'z. jrpuita oe xotTd ttjv al'a9T,atv
xat xa&' rj[J.a? Tot fAEpixd. uaTEpa 6e tci; xaboXou .
"AfAESOt Se i. e. p. 30,5 sq. 7 ofXXr) om. | -daa 11 ExaXeoE om.
| 11 dva-ooetxToc|
EOTt om.I
12 oux l6Eri8rj[j.Ev \ 14 et xu/ot om. | 17 oe om. | 21 otov 27
oTt] -dXiv|
27. 28 TO OE o'jafa om. | 28. 29 XEyui
v.i\ om.|
post 29 clixtzo^ sic pergit: to a-j-
SuTToOTaxov o'jai'a. xat auxrj 6|j.oi(o?. to C
-
CONSPECTUS LIBRORUM xxi
notavit, paenc omnia cum U consentiunt, velut p. 333, G
toutsjtiv 8 Xp^vo) om.
MosQUENSis 313 [Matthaei p. 205. 206 cf. vol. II 3 p. XXII] dim
32G,
nunc 455, e monasterio Iberorum, foliorum 435, e duobus constat
codicibus,
quorum posterior bombycinus saec. XV inc. f. 295. ex quo
quattuor foliorumphotogrammata mihi suppetebant. 1'. 345'' inscr.
Tou cpiXorovou ayo/.ict etc
TT.v d7rootxTr/v;v. ^i^'klo'^ a^ov; ^xotto; sailv evxaoOa xo)
apiatoxi/.si Trspl xo'j
ctTToSi'-xxixou v.n\ -iaxyju.ovixo'j otoct'cai auX/.o'j'tcju.o'j
. . . des. f. 373^' in verba
ouxos otYyi'vou;: iiln; xoGi -ptuxou PiJjXioy xr,;
aTroosixxixT,; (cf. p. X. XI. XVIII).
ibidem inscr. otp/T] xou oeuxipo-j pi[3Xiou xr;;
droosixxix-7|s"." 'Kv ab xm rpo'jxto
[BipXuu xTp aTxriOcixxixT^? (p. 334,2) . . . des. f. 394 in
verba t; drJjosir>.; -j-vo'jcjze'.
xa e-icjxr^xa Trpayaaxa xal a-oosixxa (p. 440, 12).
p. 334,2 336,18. 16 droosf^eio;, om. i\ xf, [ 22 avoX'JTixrj |
23 dtva/.-jxizov ] a'jxoil ]335,5 ar.oo-.iU^ui | 6 Ti(xi(oTpov | 7
-/aSoxt y''
-
xxn SUPPLEMENTUM PRAEFATIONIS
add. lb; | xaXelTai] voo'j|j.evT) | 21. 22 TipoaayopeiETat
|xc
-
CONSPECTUS LIBRORUM xxiii
Editionum principuin Aldiuaruni [)Osterior milii iniiotuit, quae
aprotliit Venetiis in Aedihus hucrcduin Aldi Manutii Romani et
AndreaeAsulani Soceri, Mense Decembri MDXXXIIII una cum 'Incerti
authoris'et Eustratii commentariis. ex epistula Aldi Pii Manutii ad
Albertum I'ium
Carpensium principem priori editioni anni MDlllI praemissa, quae
initio
posterioris repetitur, hacc noto:
loa/iiiis Grammatici .... in priora Philosophi resolutoria
commentarios statim post Am-
monium in lihrum de interpreialio?>e (ut par erat, el
libroriim Arislotelis ordo exiyebat) excusos
cura nostra publicare constiiueram. Sed quia, rjuos is ipse
Fhiloponus in resolutoria poste-
riora composuit, paratiores correctioresque haberenlur , ilios
nunc damus, daturi deinceps deo
favente et reliquos. Quoniam vera inter impriinenduin varia
nobis fuere exewplaria, nihil aut
addere, aut dimiiiuere, aut commutare audentcs (temcrarium eiiim
id quidcin) quae varia visa
sunt, asteriscis signanda euravimus, inde operi absoluto
addenda,
quo unicuiqw; pro arbitrio
suo de illis liceret diiudicare. In secundum etiam
rcsolutoriorurn librum duplicem nacti exposi-
iionem, utranque iussimus infortnandam.
Quibus in praefatione posterioris editionis haec adduntur:
loannis Grammatici libros in Arislotelis posterioru resolutoria
denuo impi-essuri, dedintus
operam, ut exirent emcndaliores, quam antea fuerant. ilaque ex
doclissimorum hominum lucu-
brationibus mulla, in quibus vera lectio desyderabatur,
casti'javimus.
Mantissa f. 116'' 123'*' inscr. Aioicpopotl, ek xa^ oyrAvKOi;
tccjt^; dnorq-[jLSKoaet?, 5; Iv stspo) upo[Av dvtt*|'pacp(o. ^)
In ScHOLiis a Brandisio a. MDCCCXXXVI editis p. 195251 multa
bsunt ex editione Aldina excerpta, cuius menda uonnulla, plerumque
con-
iectura sublata sunt.
II ANONYMI IN ANALYT. POST. LIBR. II:
Parisinus 1917 [v. supra p. X et Waitz Organ. T 24. 25] in f.
257'' Bexeunte inscr. xou aurou cstXo-ovou elq to Ssuxspov tt,;
aTroSsixTtx^?: Iva -to
OxoTCm TOO rpoxsipLSVOU pipXcou TrapaxoXouOr^Scofiev xotl ttj
-(ptcpfuosi Tocjir^ tou
pr^-ou 7rcx773Xia et spatio relicto in ultimo versu oictXotpojv
6 d^iaxn-i\r,a'(u TY); (ZTcoosixiixTj? . . . dlX ?8tav TTjV Tiept
auTOU oioaaxaXiav iv
Tw rept auTO'j pi,3Xo TuotrjaatjOai : (f. 257^ med. i. e. Leo
Magent. of. p. VIII)(peps (Sauep xotva OsiisXta tt^? tou pr^Tou
cr|Y7]as); irpoXaPcoixsv xtX., quae
verbis iva x~u ax^jTzm . . . ir^ayiekiot. continuari perspexit
Brandis (Schol.
p. 2401' 24. 25; alitor iudicat Waitz 1. c.) Anonymi
commentarius inc.
') tertiuin haec commeutaria edita sunt Venetiis a. MDLVIII.
Versionibus Latinis,quas Fabric. Bibl. Gr. Ill 331 X 646 (ed.
Ilarless) commemorat, adde Conimeniaria inlibros Post. Resol.
Arist. Recens cum Graeco exemplari per Philipp. Theodosium
collata.
Venetiis 1542. 1550.
-
XXIV SUPPLEMENTUM PRAEFATIONIS
f. 259'", initio (f. 259 et 260) scholiis miscellaneis (velut
f.259'' scliolion
vixai'a; nomine inscribitur) in marg. ascriptus. des. f. 272''.
ante Theodori
Ptochoprodromi paraphrasin, quae inc. f. 273^ repetitur illud
Magenteni
prooemium SioiXapwv . . . 7toir^(37.5i}ai. codicem ipse Parisiis
contuli.
R Laurentianus LXXXV 1 [v. supra p. XI. XIIJ inde a f. 251''
Anonymi
commentariuni cum prooemiis Parisini 1917 continet, quocum
omnino
summa est consensio. collatus est a Guil. Rabehl.
U Maecianus 225 [v. supra p. XVI] f. 448^467 Anonymi commen-
tarium continens collatus est a Guil. Rabehl.
OxoNiENSis Collegii Novi 236 [v. supra p. XX] post Philoponeum
in
Aualyt. Post. libr. I Anonymi in libr. II commentarium continens
Tor-
strikii testimonio hie ad verbum cum Aldina congruit.
L Laurentianus LXXI 15 [Bandini III 9. 10] membranaceus in
quarto
saec. XV foliorum 40 in fine mutilus non plus duobus
quaternionibus ex-
scissis testimonio losephi Ileeg Monacensis, a quo f. 21''40^
partim collata
partim descripta sunt; f. l-" 21'' Guil. Rabehl partim contulit
partimdescripsit. f.
1'" iuscr. ezY^r^Si^ ek to Ssuispov xwv uarlpcuv dvaXuiixwy.
AtaXot^djv
6 'X[ASX0-i\r^c h tCo 7rpcu-to ^ipX^'a) "CTj? (ZTroosixTi/rjC .
. . aXX' lO-'av xtjv rspl auxou
oioaaxotXi'otv v x(a Tiapovit Seuxspoj ^i[iKim -oir^a^a&at.
sequitur alterum pro-
oemium ospi oioTisp xoiva OeixsXiot xTj? xo'j p-/jxoui
ezrjriazwi . . . dWa. Xoytuv
TrXsiovov Seixai xaxaaxeuaaxtxibv, quod infra p. XXVIIXXX
proponam. escholiis ipsis, quo magis intellegatur, quod supra p.
VIII dixi, multa solitam
lectionum varietatem excedere, multa prorsus alia esse, haec
eligo:
p. 547,37 V) |J.v] om. 1 post 9 r)E).o|j.v add. ecjrt oe 'fiact
|j.v Ttpo'tEpov to ei laxi xoO
OTt iaxtv. oaa (1. 6) ydp x6 oxi ur.dpyti too xcBoe Ci'ixujv to?
&[j.oXciYO'j,aVov rfirito urroxei'tj.Evov
Xa-j.,3dvi -lEpi o'j CtjTeI. ou -{up CTjTei; t k'axtv, dXX' i
urap'/Et auxui xt v^ fj.T] | 10. 11 ut
omnia lemmata om. | 12 a Cr;Tou;j.v eooeTv d \ 14 i ydp laxt ti
C^ixi^aavTE; /j ,j.y) f^oir^ij.t^
oTi EOTt, TO Ti i(5-i .uExd ToOxo CTjToufJiEV | 15 xai] 5r,Xa07)
TO 1 xouTEOTt om. I xooE roTEpov I
post Ct|XoO[j.v add. TOtouxov | 16 post oxi add. ^-cXEi'rEi ||
p. 54S,21 to piaov Ct;XoO,uv]
CrjTo'jvTE? O'J CrjT0'j!J.v (adde zi) Eaxt xi pisov dXX' auTo to
piaov CtjXo'jij.ev orotov Tt laxtv |
23 v habet|p. 549,9. 10 XEyuj U xi; xoiauxot; CrjTi^aEtc, xi^v
ts xoii oxt xal xoO eI' laxiv, srl
p.Epou; y.od c(-Xio;. dXX' -1 |J.po'j; [j.ev XEyio xt]v tou oxt
CrfXTjatv, oTto'xav CTjXElxat e{ x6
xcixr7opo'j|J.Evov u-dpyEt xui u-oxEi[j.Eva), ofov ei x6
hlzi-.ti-^ vj a'j?EaSo(t UTrdpysi xt) aEXr^vYj.
x6 Y^p xotoijxov t:c(8o; -/.aia'j,u.7:xu)ij.a xotXTjopouiJEVov
xaxd xoO 'j7T07.t;j.vo'j fjyo'jv xf^; oeXtjvt]?,
Xeyoj 6e x6 ixXctTTEiv xctuxTjV Yj a'j^EaSat, xt [Aspo; axi xoiJ
UTioxEtpivou ryxot x^? aEXrjvrj?.
oto -/.at ETTi [jipou; xat (xat deleverim) xt; C/jXTjat; x6
xotouxo'v ecti. xoti -(CLp iv xot; xoio'jxots
xoO oxt Crjxrjpiaat xot; v 7:ocpaoiY!-'.':(C5t CrjXoufjiEvoi;
p.sptxT) ^ C^jxr^at; Yi^^^t- CT/XEtxai Y^p ei'-ep
^ XT)? aEXTjvT;; exXei'Li; |J.po; 3x1 ttjs oeX^vt]; xat t
t)[AEttoat; yj a'j^rjdi; esti Tt Tidao; rj
a6[ji7ixu)|xa c(yxT,c. y.cd y^ip '^'^
-
CONSPECTUS LIl'.ltOKUM xxv
Eraexoei o-i dvctAo'/fot V f/ji)[J.ot; xoj o;o; y.al to'j
Papeo;,r; v oi^Actaiio Xoyto '/ ev xoi-Xaauo
I h i,ixiolm ?, v 7HTptT(o. ei 0 -/otl to otd ri a'j.u.cfiovEl
to o?-j tw ^apEt a'tpoiTO [j.aaeiv
6 C^jTwv, xal o'JTto; to o-jto YvwaExai, oxi oi'i x6e/ecv
dvaAoYiav Iv apii}[J.oi; lv xot; prjOeiai
XoYOi;. -c(Xiv or-ixav C^jXTixctt ^ttI xtj; too oxi otpa
Eaxia^JiJ-cptovEtv to 0;'j v.al xo [iocp'j,
xoOxo (fort, to'xe) C^XEixat otpa esxiv oivctXoYta a'jxuiv v
fjua(AoU /;O'j. p.ai)ovxC oe oxt
a'jacpiovEl TO (i;'J xui papEi iv xoi; prj^Eist Xo-pts, xdxe
rcfXtv CrjXoOiAevxi; 6 Xoyo; xal
7j atxt'a xt;; Tja'fojvtot; a'JX(Lv.
1). 55*2,914. Evaxasiv IvxauiJa Xjei. ivsaxrj Y'ip "' '^'^
''^"^> '^"^^ jt(o>) o opia[j.os
/ci96Xou xai xaTccfotxr/.o; saxtv, r^ auooEt^i; oe (oii)
auXXoYia,aoO, Eial hi auXXoYiaij-oiIv
rptoxu> S'/r^iJ-OLTi. xct&dXou xal xaxacpaTixot, oict t(
Xoitiov 6 6p[a[j.6; o'jx EtJ-atxauxov ttj
d-oOEt'^Ei. '/jV (1. tV^v) oe IvOTaatv ettiXuei oici tou
I;to(Yiv Etxa cjoe izi tivoc tujv
-E'fuxoTwv a'JvaYo9ai cu;j.7TEpc(a[J.cw5ev) Y'^'^
a'ju|3,3Tjxoxaajxo-
OEt'xvjxat. Yj (j'j; xal auxwv TioXXdxi; d-ooixvj;j.V(ov, oxav
ot aixtwOEt; a'jxtwv XoYOt xotvot w3i
xat xalioXtxot.
p. 5y(>,7 post OEOEtYpivov hacc Iiabet: t oe o-jx 3xt xo a
xoO p xaSoXtxibxEoov, otaxi
(AdXXov TO p oixtov xou 0. Xy9/jaxai xal o-V/l to 0. tou p; xal
Et toOto ooi)tr| tu3TE
avxiaxpEcpstv xaijxa -p6; ct'flri'/.oi, ECxai otaXXriXo? 0i?i;.
dXXd [atjv Y; oidXXTjXo; 6t;t; ettI
d-oScixTixou 3'jXXoYtaaoO ytbpav oux e/ei, oj; odOEixxat. Xot-ov
dpa ettI ttXeov e3toi to
a Toii [i.
-
XXVI SUPPLEMENTUM PRAEFATIONIS. CONSPECTUS LIBRORUM
'^XXoj;: 1 0 oux eatt to a xoSoXixwTepov toO p, otaxt [xaXXov
X^yI^^''' ai'^i'^v elvatTO p Toij a, -^TOt TO d'/oXov T^s
[AaxpoptwOEtoc "/ai Old [jiaou auxoij xaxTjYopeioSat to
fj.cc/po^iov
-/aTct 7tc(VT(ov Tuiv 'jTio TO 6; zl O'jv TO a f; xaTot
7:c(VTu>v xaTTjYopelTat Tcijv uTio TO e, loa-ep
or) icai xctTct Tuiv utto to 8, ejovthi xal to: utio to i Tpdv
Tt ev {x^aov xai aiTiov a;iav-a
E/ovTa dXXoTpta (1. dXXo'-ptov) to'j p xat fAT)5[j.iav e/ov
Ttpo? a^TO xoivwviav, oiov to ^, rjzoi
TO Srjpo'v. oi' o'j iJ.iao'j xaxct, in quae ultima folii 40v
verba desinunt scholia')-
EuiTio Aldina (v. supra p. XXIIl) f. 102'' 115'' Anonymi
commen-tarium continet.
1) Etiam in Parisini 1843 f. 199r 201r et Barocciani 87 f. 209v
213r Anonymi
haec scholia reperiuutur: p. 567,27 568,3 568,512 (hoc in
Barocciano solo) 575,20 576,12 576,1821 cf. vol. II 1 p. XXI.
XXII.
-
PROOEMIUM CODD. Bi)RL.
' ]va TM axOTTdl lOU TTpOZSlllivOU PlpXtOU
7i:CipO(XoXou87]a(U}JlV XOtt TYJ "cpi'^wSsi
TCCJiTj tou pr^TO'j aTra'pfsXtcr, cpsps (osirep xotva OsixiXia
tt,? xou pr^xo-j z^r^(r^az(i)c
7rpoXai3(u[x$v xa rspl xmv 5' oiaXsxxixuJv. xiasapa "(ap saxi xa
T:po-7p7xsi[j.va
aXXrjXoic, xi scjxiv, zl I'axiv. oroiov xi 3ti xott oia xi iaxr
xotuixa y-z.o im xr^s
5 xsXsiot; xo'j 6ioc(axo[xvou oioa'JxaXiot?
Trpo-otpaXctixPotvsxoti, oiov si eaxtv vj Xo-i'ixrj
'j'U/Yj xai XI saxt. xouxtov os xuiv xsactapujv
irpolrlXryactxtov 'xuXouGxepot xo t
laxi x7t xo xt iaxt, auvOsxwxspa os xo oiot xi saxt xotl xo
ottoiov xi saxiv. -rj
Yap opou sdxlv tj C'/j'^j^i? Tj Trpoxotasco?. xat sv fj-sv x(o
si' saxi xal xoj xi saxiv
opOs ^axiv 6 C^jXoufASvo;, sv 6s xto ouoTov xi saxi xal xo>
oia xi isxi Trpoxaai?.
10 OIOV Ti Xsyo); xi saxiv r^ ^'^X'^j^"^^ a&a'vaxo?* opo$ 6
C^xo6[xvoc. 6}i.ouo? 8s xal
sv x(o SI E(5xr Ct'jtoujisv 'j'ap st oXto? scjxiv fj ']>uyr^.
sv 6s X(p ozoTov xi laxi
xal T(\i 6ia xt ssxtv ouy opou ssxtv tj Ci'l'^i'itJ'? ^XXa
irpoxaasu)?* CTixo'j[J.Ev -j-ap
iv xouxot? OTTOiov xt saxtv f| 'I'^/V;. xal 6ta xt saxiv fj
'}u*/"/]- xal saxi auvi)xa)-
xspov xou itsv St saxt xo xt saxtv sv y
-
xxvm PROOEMIUM CODD. BRL
ei 8s suvOslc dticpoxspa sI'tto) oti [Bpovxr^ Ian Vccpojv
'j-ocpo? oia Trupo; aTT6a[5sa'V, ouxo?
Arj-STOct ocTib TO'j auvajj-cpoTspou optajioc, to asv iyuiv diio
tTj? uXr^s to oe aizo
xou sloouc, xoti 7;- as-a ^oip tTjV -Xr^^r^v tujv vs'fojv 7)
dsTpaTiT] ETrqi'vEiotf dXX' 7j
5 0^1? oj? oc;i(o[jiati-/ioTp9. o'jcja xr|s dxor^c xctl d/povw;
EVEp^ouaot xt,?d/OTp
TrpoX^apdvEi xa oix-aia- irpcuxov (j-SV -jOip opwijiEV X7]v
dstpaTrr^v, Eib' ouxio?
r dxoT XTj? tXtj-i'^c xa>v VE'fuiv dvxtXotajSdvsxGti. o-jioj?
o /i xal sid xou
6pi(3[i.OU xou OUULO'J- pcOT(l)[JlVOl "(Otp XI iciXl i)U[Jl6?,
CpO(lJ.V 'c3l? TOU TTSpi XCtpOt'ctV
oti'u-otxos' xoil 7ap ETTou-svov laxi X(u Ouix(u y; ;3ic xou
irEpl xotpoiav 7.r|xaxo?.
10 d U -,' i'-u) 'i)u[i6c E3XIV opE^t,- otvxtXu-rjasoic' , d-b
xoti Eioou? 3xtv 6 xoiouxo;6oi3fi6s' tJxoTxbs '(o.p xou
iJu[xou[j.vou dvT'XuTx^aai xbv dotxrjac(vxcf ota
xouxo
-(dp i)u[JlOU|J.0a. 1 OS 7E EITTCO 'OutXOS 3X1 $31? xou TIEpl
X7pOiaV ai'fiClXO? 01
op;iv dvxiXuT:T]3(o;', dirb xou auvafj-cpoxspou 6 xoiouxo;
6piG[x6?, w3X ouv xb xi
3X1 oixxov, 7] dirb xr^? uXr^? t) dub xou sloou?. xcti V xouxoi?
r; upoxsifAEVV]
15 TtSpOt? dT:t).-/j'f OEOJplGt.
'E-E'.OTj ti.Ea9.i>Y/.a[xv xd -Epl xu)V x33dpu)V
Kpo[5Xrj[xdT(ov, 9rj[j.l oTj xou l
3Xt, xou XI 3tl, xou OTToToV XI 3X1 XCtl Old XI 3X1, 'fEpE 07]
dxoXouUu)? XOlt XOV
3xo~bv xou ptpXtou C-//xrj3(uav. 3xo-b? "(dp xou pt[5l>aou
TiEpi 6pt3ii.ou- xouxo
OE, oioxi TTEOt d-ooEicEto? b axoTTOc, 01 o xupi'cu; duooEtqEis
EX xojv xai> auxa
20 xoi? 7:pd7fJio(3tv o-ap/ovxd.y Xo([j-[3dvovT7.i. buo os i3t
xou xai>' auxb oi xpouoi,
w; zwr^zai, Tj OXE v xco opto xb i)-rjxB(iie\/rjv
supL-apotXaiipdvExai (6piCo[Xvoi
^dp XTjV at{JLbx-/;xd 9a[xv xo[lav3iv iv ptvi, xal xb
uTtoxEtp-S^^^v "c^ 3ijxox7jXi, ^r^ixt
07) X7)v prvoe, v x(o bpi3[i.oj aujjL-rypotXotupdvoiAEv), Tj oxe
auxb xb "(evocv xw
bp[3[X( Et3d7xai. waTiEp xuybv bpil^opiEvo'. xb dpx'.bv cpafisv
dpxtov dpi{)fibv
25 Eivat xbv or/a 6iaipou[j.Evov loou -(dp axoTibv e/ovxe? xb
d'pxiovbpi'3a3t)ai
rapEXd[5ou.v xb xou dpxiou "(evoc, xbv dpiOfxov. oioxt ouv
dTroOEixxixTj 7] Tpa^-
[xaxEia, ai 6e xupi'ajc d-oOEicEic x xtov xaO' autb xoTc
7:p7>(ua3iv u7:ap/bvx(ov
XafAl^dvovxat, ouo oe xou xa!)' auxb xpouoi xai Iv Ixaxipw
3ryjxaivo[iV(p bpi3fxou
0b[ii}a, xouxou ydpiv vuv TTEpi opiSfAwv oiaXE^sxai. ypsiworjc
-(dp l3xtv tj
30 bpt3xtx7i Trpb? xr^v d-o8Eiqiv, ou xouxo [lou X-(ovxoc, oxi
xauxbv laxtv bptsixb?
xal d-boEict?. o'jSe -(dp etti ravxcov auvxps/st xouxo- ouo
-(dp, t pouX-/)i)ty|V
OEicai xou xpr(a)Vou xdc xpsi? -((ovt'a? buo opOai? i'sac, xouxo
oid xou 6pi3[xou 8ei-
xvuxai xou xpt-((ovou. ouxo; ouv 3xtv b a/.oirbc xou_pt[3Xiou,
xb irspl bptsixou oia-
XapEiv, ou xaxd Ttpwxov Xb-^ov X7,? -poi>E3Eto? xauxr^c,
cprjii.! 07) xr,? UEpt bptsixou,
35 7:poxEi|j.Evr|C. Iv -(dp xm C' ttj? Msxd xd cf,u3ixd xaxd
Trpdixov Xo-(OV uEpt bptajxaiv
8iaX-(Exat, xat xaxaoa-avaxai oXov xb fA[ikw Iv t^ Trspi
bpi3[Aa)v oioaaxaXi'a.
1 ziTMiu L OTt om. L 4 ytvexai L 5 ojaot om. L 8 of/taaoO xou
om. R irspi-
-/.apoioo itcmque vs. 9 L 10 i'-rjtij.Ev L 11 -/at yip eaxi xw
S'jp.o'j[j.vto axoro; L
12 XuTTO'jacDa L izot|Xv L -cOtxapSto'j L 13 post auvatxcpoTepou
add. saxtv L
14. 15 xal 5)iopia om. L Ifi or) om. R 17 xou utrumque om. L 18
xotvjv LT(I) pipXuo R 21 a'j[j.7:piXo([j.paveTa[ b 22 auvt'Crjaiv L
-/.at to K: to fip L
23 a'j,a7:ptXc(;j.pcvo[j.Ev b ot cm. L 24 ct 25 to scripsi: xov
LR 25 toou ydp L:
7.ai R 30 XeyovTo; (j.O'j L ante op. add. 6 L 31 ante aTroo.
add. i) L
82 5'jalv L 32. 33 OEi;aiij.i 5v otd xoj opiafj-oO L 35 xuJv
L
-
PROOEMIUM CODD. BRL xxix
Tpia ouv TotG-a '^r^-^^. ~zp\ 6picj|i.(ov TrpdJTOv (xsv si
Icjxtv oouti-oG! diroOEi^i^,
dsuTSpov Oo sf 3"*.v rjoia'xh; op'.siiOL), TpiTOv Ttvcuv iiEV
ctatv opo'., xi'vujy 0
OUX l3t. OSUV'jai. ^Otp OTl O'JTS T(OV |'"''1"''-"JT7!t(JUV
"j-SVuiv cialv Optapiol O'JTE TUIV
dxoucov dXXa [x6v(ov xcov uT:o(X>vr]>>u>v. tuiv ukv
-j"zp '(Evv/M-dTiuv ^svos oux s'aTt,
5 y.7i Old toOto O'jok opi3ao;* oi '/ip opisaoi / ;-'""'' "''^'
ot2'9'>P'"V )>7.fi.,3dvov:a'..
tOU 6 dTO|XOU 6pi3aO^ OUX 3TIV, 7:lOr) Ouok 7VOs" Y'ip
d'vf)p(O-0^ C(LX 3Tl
TOO [iXdxtovo; "(ivo;, dW eloo; 3rtv cioi/wtatov ouos ydp xctxd
oia^spovxojvT(o ^621 xai/jYopsitoti 6 d'vDpto-oc dXXd xofrd
ot7'fpovT(ov kij doiDaio. -pl ;j.v
fj'jv tiov -piaiv xouTouv Kpop^vTjjxdtouv otaXi-jEtai iv xui
TrpoxEip-Evro pt,3Xi(i). x^l
10 ~iOT, al irooTdasi? ai'tiai t(ov 3Darpa3[Jidxu>v t3tv,
dyi'i'/.r^ -rjiytvj stxoioj?
X7i i~\ xd xoiv 7:ooxd3(ov aivsi. x^l 3UYxpi'vt xa'jxa osixv-j;
oxt -oxs xal dvxi-
.TTS-ovDoxu); )ri -poc d/vXr^Xa xaOxa xd a'l'xia, toarsp xo
rotr^xixov aixtov x(u
XXixtp airt(i). xo jaIv ^dp -oirjxixov -po-zj^sTxai, oj; xal -1
X(ov Xc/vr^xuiv opoiasv
oTov oixo5o[xo; XTp oixt'ot? Trporj-csixai. xo os xsXr/.ov
aixiov 7:axo/vO'Ji)r* x(o
15 -i'dp "I'dtxd) i-axoXoui)o'J3tv 01 -aiosc. oux dTTSixo? hi
3xi xoG auxo-j zoxe 7roir,xixY,v
x';ti x)axr)v aix-'oiv d-ooioovotr otov xr^ or/iot; -oir^xcxr;
cttxi'a 6 oixo66[xoc, xe/.ixy;
oz oioxt 7'jx/j 3XK73ad SjXiv o_a[5p(ov xtoXuxixov. TOXS 0,
9"/)3l, X'/l uXlXTjV X7l
tsXixT^v 7ixiav ;ov dfjia xo-j 7'jxo'j d-ootoov7i -1 xujv
a'JUL-p7.3p.dx(ov. xoGxci "(dp X7t
7:1 xu)v cpusixoiv opfoasv, (jij37:p ettI xcTjv ooovxcuv, oxi
xo'jc ijiev -or/i3v f, 'iusu
20 ocic, oiov xo'j? ix7:po3i}io'JC, xo'j? Oi djjLp/.sic, oiov
xo'j? Xe^ojxivo'j; x'jvtuoovxac.
;r>v o-3v xr,c xoi^yxr^ cpustxTp o/;a'.o'jp;''7,- uX'.xrjv
piv aix-.'av d-ooioov7i, oxi 01
sa-po3f}ioi 000VX3C xa Soo
7TpOX73Eo')V 131 C"')~'//"l>'-d' C^,X0GaV ^dp 1 XWV OVXOJV
3XtV r, 'yO/V) V.7! XI 33XIV
''\
'i'^'/Ji"''^' '^J^'J^OV xt 3X1 XOtl Old XI 33X1V. El EX73X0V
O'JV, 9731', XO'JXIOV "pO-
-Azti^M- 3X1 C/ir/)Xix6y , xi'c dv ^\^^ xo6x(ov r, oi7'fopd;
pr^xEov xoi'vuv oxt xo
pLV 1 33XIV G-OX3ip3VOU 33X1 !r,Tr;31C, XO OE XI EjXl
X7T-/j70pO'JU.E'vOU, OIOV 0X1
35 dOdvaxoc, orsp 3xi xaxr^Yopoupisvov Trspi x7x-/j-,'opouu3vo'j
-/dp e/ei xr,v ;r(Xr,3iv
TO -(dp dDdvaxov vrf '\^yj\^ x7x/(-j'opTx7t oj? x7{)oXixwx3pov.
xo oe oiaxt
1 xpi'a O'JV L: y.cd -[Art. ycio It 2 ante o>oi add. ot R 3
eWv optiaol yevujv L
10 ai'-ia L xps/ci R lo Xc/vitwv L 14 oixEi'a; LR TtpcrjYEltai
ante ifjC colloc. L
17 a-jxr^ LR 19 ^; cpj3t; post 20 d.a^Xel; colloc. R 20 oicv x.
A. -/.'jvojoovTa; oni. L
21 ;aTiv L 23 -spi^awaaxa scrips! : rapc(a-/.
-
XXX PROOEMIUM CODD. BRL
xi'vr^To; xai auioxiv/j-o;* auioxivrjxo^ ok ou; ctuTTj rpos
eauiTjv emaxpi-
cpousa XGtt voo'jaa auxrj eauxr^v. e^ov ouv x(i Xc'/Octad
oiaxpiasi d-' otX).r]Xu)V
otuxa SiaxpTvat. xouxtov 6s xuiv xeasdptov Suo \iiv ssxiv dT:X5,
xo ei laxt xoti
5 XI saxi, 6'jo ok suvdextoxspa, x6 6ia xt iaxt xal x6 oTroTov
xi ssxt. xott ov l/st
xo xt 5X1 Tcpo? XO SI S3xt, xouxov ijs.1 xov Xo'cov xo oia XL
ia-i -po; xo ottoTov
XI saxi* suvOsxtoxspov Yp "o fxsv xi saxi xou si laxi, xo 6s oia
xi ssxi xot5
OTXOiov XI saxt. xal sv xouxoi? r] Trpoxsitxsv/j -spaioociOu)
Ostopiot.
p. 89^^23. Ta ^r^zo'JUByd S3xiv i'sa xov dpi&ixov.
10 To TTpooi'ixiov Kcpi xiJbv xsaadpojv oiaXs-csxai
-po{5Xr^[i.7'x(ov xosctuxa '(dip,
cp/jSiv, S3XIV a QriTooiizv, oaaTisp ^ivwsxovxs; sirtaxafisOa.
xaXui? 5s ouxto?
s;(pr^aoixo xoti oux scpyj Ix xou svavxiou 'oaonxsp irisxdfisOa,
xocfocuxd isxi xoi
5 Ci'j'oijixsv xouvavxiov -^ap xooauxd ssxtv a Ct)xou[i.ev,
oaausp -(ivtusxovxss ^~i-
axot'fisOa. xsaaapa 8s saxiv a Ci^xoufisv xsaaapa d'pa saxi xal
a "civwcxovxs?
15 S7:i(jxd[jisi)c(. Touxo [asv otjv xoivov Ttov xsaaa'pojv.
oidcpopov os irpuixov fisv xo
xouxcuv xa jisv sivai dTtXouafxspa, xo st saxi xal xo xi iaxi,
xa os auvOsxtoxspa,
xo oTToiov Xt' laxi xal xo ota xt saxt. xal sv jjisv xoTs d-XoTs
d-Xouaxspov xo st
E3XI xou XI saxi, sv 6s xou auv&sxot.; auvOsxouxEpov xo 6id
xt saxt xou oitoiov xt
saxiv. sixa oxi xd [xsv Trspl ouaiSv Troistxcti xrjv {^r^--q(Siv
ds srl xo 7:0X6,
20 oiov XO 1 3X1 xal xo xt 3X1* XO ^o^p 1 S3XIV aoxoOsv C^jxsi
(st) svu'^i'sxaxai xo
TTspl 00 6 XoYo?" xo oh. xt ssxiv auxrjv xtjv xou -pa'^fxaxo?
ou3iav !^r^zzX. xd 8s
'(B XoiTtd ouo xd xai)' aoxo xoi? Tipd"j'[xa3iv uToipyov-a
Eui3xst:xxai, otov o-oiov
Tt -fj ^tiyji, or^XaoY] d&dvaxoc, xal oid xt dOdvaxo?. sSov
6s -po; xauxat? xal d'XX-/j?
STTixpiasto? TTpoasuTTop^aai, 8toxi xouxtov xd ixsv saxi
oiaXsxxtxd xd ok T:u3fiaxixa'.
25 owv xo |j.sv 1 saxt xal xo xi laxi 8iaXxxixd* [xovm ydp
dpxsTxai xm val t) ou*
TO 8e OTTOiov XI xal xo 8id xt Truajxaxixd* ou ^^p dpxsTxat xuj
val r^ oo, dXXd
X6y>v TrXsiovtuv 8rxai xaxasxsuaaxixuiv.
1 Y^P om. L ^TTttOT] R: oto'xt L 2 auTrj R: del L 3 dir'
scripsi: -' LR4 ovjv L fort, y.a.1 (to) 5 aovSeTixioTspa R fort.
OTioto'vSii 5 7 SvXdyov yi TO 1 isTi rpo; to ti iazi, toioOtov to
orolov ti ^oti -po; to 8ta Tt soti L
7 auvScTtxtoTspov R 8 xal R: dXX' L 9 0(p;(jj[j.s!)a oe -/at
Tr^; toj pTjToO ^;t,-yi^aEU); L 12 post ivavTtou add. oti L 13. 14
xouvavxiov ;tiaTd(j.9a oin. L14 e(aiv R 'jpta7.ovT; R 15 |i.v prius
cm. R otd'-iopa R 16 auvSexixduxepa R17 [J.EV om. R d-Xo'j3Tpa R 18
h ok L: -/.al h R auvi}Tf/.u)Xpov Rxo ToO scripsi: touto LR 19 post
rspl add. twv L enr/ei'priaiv L 20 auTo'Si R1 addidi 21 xtjv ouatav
toO -[jdyixiro^ L 22. 23 Oiioiov dda'vaTOv rj 'l^yri xal R23 ;CTt L
TauTa L 23. 24 aXXr^v lirtypiatv R 24 oxt L 25 ofov om. L
fxev om. R t R : ydp L 25 post v] add. xui L 27 Xdyov L Seovxoi
R
-
lOANNIS PHILOPONI IN AUISTOTELIS
ANALYTICA POSTERIORACOMMENTARIA
-
I o A N N ( ir A A i: Z A N A 1* K ii ^ Aldin.r. :{'
iixoAiKAi Aiin^ii\ii;iL'ii;ii i;k tqn vvnoviil>.\AMMQNior rov
i:i\\n:iin- Mi.i \ tin on iain Riiii:TAxi;i>N[M Tit lIlMiTliN
TtiN ViTKI'tiN AN\\niKLiN \ I' 1 XI'OTK A( r:^:.
5 To'jfj xiXo^ iatl tYj? Xo-jIxYjC Kpa^j'tfCtTsrof?, 9/1111 oy;
Xoyo? T:spi
a-oSEi.'c) RV: oi la'-' G ac(i)/j;j.o(-c< a' 7 0 RU 8 postiv
prills add. -c([; V xcov orn. V i> xdiv oni. V 10 oi'
|3o(Oiau)[jLEv] xatEiii TO'!)-u)v dj; 7.7-1 Tuiv (zAAiov oo
-
2 PniLOPONI IN ANALYT. POST. PROOEMIUM
-e[A TTj? Ttov aizXiov cpcovojv Suvocfisto? te xoti
a"/)[xotat7?. zat ettsI cu) Xoy'-oijiou S"^
rJ.tiry^OL c'-'oYj, (u? iv toT; FIp-oTipot^ avotXyxf/oic 8ta
ttXeiovujv aTT=Oct';c([jLcV, to ts
(30'^13T'.X0V Xal "6 Sia/.SXtlXOV XCtl to Ct-OOctXTlXOV, TOV
[J.3V citTCOOElXTlXOV
auXXoYKJfxov iv TO'J-otc 7)uTv Tr^pcxSiom^t, tov ok oi^Xextixov
iv xoT? I ort-
5 xoTc, i'vOot TTfoc av e'j' sxaTSpot Tt; i-r/zior^azf.'
-0!po(o;o(o3iv. Tva ok ixtj 20
EcoLTrctTtuijiEOa uTto ToJv TTpoaoia/.E-jOijiivcov "/;u.tv,
oiSaaxsi YjfJ-Sc xoti tteoi toQ
ao'iiSTixoGi suXXo'jistxo'j iv toT? locpiSTi/oic iKiy/mc,
(uSTrsp aXs^rj-r^piov
rjaTv cpapa^/ov 7:c(pi)^u)V ettI to a-o'fE'JYSiv Totc
ao'fi!jTt/7!c, to; (zutoc 'f"/;3iv,
EvoyXr^astc, ov Tporov xotl 01 laxpol oioaaxovTczi "ot
or^Xr^tr^pia tojv '^7pij.7'-
10 x(ov oux E-1 TO -/pTj(jOai 7X/.' -1 TO '^su'(eiv. aTjOci; 7ap
u-oX7u.p7vt(o,
OTTsp 01 ToXXol vojxi'Couaiv, m; TiEpl ao'fi(3Tix(ov
au/,Xo"j''(3(i.(ov esti toT?
cciXoao'ioi; Xo'co;* KOiiC'"jvt(ov ^'^P- [xoiXXov, o'j
arouoa^ovTcuv roiv -oiounov 25
auXX0Yl3U.(OV TO ElOOC" oToV zav to UTrSpS/OV TO'J
'J~ip)(0[i.EVOU tXEtCoV EGTf
TO 5e Xct/avov u-pr/st tt,c 77]? to Xa'/avov ap7 ixei^jV tt^c
^r,?. xou-
15 votvTt'ov 5 [xSXXov sXE-f/ou? TT^c TOiauTr^c rzTTatrp iv
ixEivoic vjaTv 'Api-
aroTsXr^? T7p7.oiott)XE* 016-Ep o'jos iirrjEYpa-Tai to pt^Xtov
Ospt ao'fiaTixaiv
auXXo7i3j.tov aXXot Zo'iiaTixot eXey/oi. 6 ^ap Xoyo? toi^
cpiXosocpot?' isTi
ZEpi Toij dtaOosixTixo'j auXXo'ctsixoij oux ic ivoocfov aXX' kz
6yoi'(y.rAmv tz xat so
auTOTri'sTfov TrpoTa'sEwv to Eivai lyovTOC* 010 xat czo'jvaTov
isTi [xet^ttei-
20 sOr^vctt TOV TY] TOiauTYj ava-jXY] tojv Xoyajv ez6[j.evov
oooe "j'otp 7.-X)C
TTElftECjOai ivOO;Ot? OeT T:p05U)Z0'.s (ETEpOXlVr^TOU 77.P
ToGixo) 7.XXa TYjV 7.XTj-
Oe'7.V JJLET70'.(UXEIV aET7. 7.7:O0EtCEfo:, X7.V 7-7VTEs UY]
[jOuXfUVT7l.
"OtI JJLEV O'JV Tc'Xo? TT^? Xo-i'tXY,s 7rp77fl7TE['7s "?)
cJ.KOOEtCtr, OY/^OV -jEYOVc.
TTj^ OS a-oosicc
-
iO
PIIILOPOXI IN ANALYT. POST. PROORMIUM. I 1 [Arist. p. TIM]
Toui xotxo'j. a-o6ct^; xot'vuv iaxt auX/.o7ia[i.o? l-iSTr^uovuo;
iS auTO-iaxoiV
xcti ciUoXo^o'jasvcov aoyjov Xo!u.[j7vouivor. TTCvOTspov ok ~'q
xacsi 23x1 xo
irpoxi'[jLVOV [SipXiov X(ov IV/i-jtizmv i/i--/(i)V. n-i usv
-jOtf. s-cCjOat xoT;
ToTTixoi^ (irit'/.V, ev izst'vou aTrsostQ^asv xoi; ^c/.[>
TriOavoT? i-'-i'uavccjtlsvxc;
5 f>aov xoT^ dvo(7Z7tot; -f.oal^^/.ouuEv. oxi os
irfiorj-i'sixcc. | x(ov IVjcptaxt/fov:}v
kXi'r/tov, OTjXov svxsuOsv. d/rjr^'szo^ '(0.0 T.c/y-zXoj;
z>.: c(-oosi;tv i/si'v/; r^
7TOaY[10tXlO(, XOtl TT^pSIXpOcXXsiV JXSXCUc'u Xa'JXTjV XtoV 1?
drJjOZirlV CUVXlVOU-
(TU)V T:pCtYPL'2t;.
p. 71-1 1 117.37 01073x7X17 x7i -737 [ld\)r^'J^:.
r,0 f'lvwaxEiv -/pr^ oxi 060 xpo-oi u7:7p-/ou3iv iz (ov 1:737
-ji'vExai -(vui-
GIC, UJ^ 9-/)3t X7.1 IIX7X(0V, }i.7l)rj3'.C X7.1 E'3pE3l?' 7]
"(Otp [J.7v07VOVXE; Trap' 20
EXEpou 7ivoj3xotxEv r^ upi3xovxE; aoxot'. 'f/j3iv oov Ev
xoijxoi; o 'AX;av-
2 ^OTi ora. V: ante tyJ colloc. a 4 To;rot; R 5 ya:Tov\'
7 -af,Ea,3o(Xiv V
8 Trpayi^-aTEuov om. V oi o-j ozl Ra': oso; I'Va'^ 9 'hv'jotai
oiizpl^ii-^ V
post TO add. [AT) RFa wjto'j; Ua: to'jto V 10 yEvoi/cvoi R:
yevofxevo-j; Ua
U d^Tt om. V 12 TGCJTT,? RUa: to'j ciXr,.1o'j; V Ta'j-ot V 13
-/dvTci'jaa V15 cfTi^i oioaS/aXta a oiavorjXixT) om. UV IG
;:fvO'J-oxct|iVTj; R 17 izti V
adXet RV oio'ir/eiv V 18 yivExott om. V tojto] toj U 20 veal om.
V
21 -aaa Dili. IT zpoEyvioaaiviov xai irpo'j'irap/ovTtov^ 22
y.cii prius cm. \
23 apct om, V y'''""^' -'"^ *'*' ^ T^P "^'J^''^"''-'"' ^C post
;rXopal
add. TOO Tp(y(ovoj a 27 t;.t'Cove Ra 28 Ian om. V 29 7.al
Tzana
.j-'iS/jai; om. V 30 sfaiv Y 31 vcat' cstj^i l" llXaTiov]
Cratyl. p. -130 A
32 iv. TOJTwv Y h cm. V1*
-
4 PHILOPONI IX ANALYT. POST. I 1 [Aiist. p.Tlnl]
u-svov -aan oioacxaXi'a xct't raca txaOr^sic sx TTpO'j-apy
o6cj"/j;
YivEiai eupiaco)?. oux i'sTt os dXr^Osc* auxog "jOtp
7:7.potx7.ti(bv tjotcpoic
"/juTv Ttapotoroojsi Tov Ttspl S'jpsasajc Xo^ov. aXXu)^ te ttj?
s'jpiastoc -avKuc
5 "pO'Ji-CtpySt 7) C''")"/l'3t?j OJ(JTS TO c'JpsOsv rJjY, (3Tl
TuJV auT0-''cfttOV, Xe^'O -'->
OYj 7^ T(ov xoivcov ivvoiojv r, Tu)V $ ciaOrjCJEfo^
*(iv(oafxo[ivu)v Trptutyj "j'p r;
Tourtov ettiPoXtj xctl oux ^ of/.Xfjov syei to ttistov -p"i
touttov os Zr^xr^rsyz
o'j6c[j.['a Y''v-~^ toiTs 7T7.aa c'jpsatc i'x tivoc xat autrj
irpo'j-^pyouarp
jlVcTOd j'^fl>^-"->?- otc OUX IsTiy OTTEp dro-
~0V. (OSTE X7X(T)? EtTTEy X T p 6 k7 p"/ (J 3 Tj C '^ "J (X>
(j z. la Z . f)7Ua7Sl(UC Sc
30 7Tpoai)r^x TO oiayoTjTtxr] 7:poc dyTiot7aToXT/^ ty^c
7l'(3i}rjTixr,s Y'-'^''^-*"^'
2 tAoi alt. otn. V 3 -apccxottiwv] p. 71 a 17 4 Tjalv oiii. V
post t add.xai a fi /j prius om. a 8 post wcite add. xotl a xat
o'j-tj post 9 yivcTat
colloc. V 9 (o; V 10 post yvwacoj; add. too Ra 11 post ti add.
Tourtuv a12 post [j.ot8/jC!(u; add. Ttciaa yap cpTj3i oioaa/.aXiot
xod -ctjoi jj-aftrjat; UVa 13 postdivTi add. ToO V 14 post i-Xdi;
add. to U\ 7ipooij.oXoyo'jij.'vo'j Ua15 Ix (jLciHTjGEio; j$
'jrjacuc a l(i xat primuin om. V eaxi 0 xai i^ R: tj p.evTOt a17
xa'JTOv V: xajxa etai a oiacespousa V 18 to; V t) alt. om. UV'a
7) tert. om. I V 20 ^^ (jiev yap d7:6 V: o(7:o (jiv yap a'
zpo'iovicra om. a
21 ::p6; a post p.artrjTrjV add. (o; a xaXeixat RUVr voo'jasvr,
a
/j 0 22 rpoaayopE'jExai] -poaayopEoEtat. aro 0 toO [xaDrj-oO to;
xi 7:a9o; tieoi autov yivo-[J.EVOV, ua'&rjai; a' 22 y^ to R 23
ante yviossuj? add. yi'vExat a post
et add. prj V 24 Tiaaa om. \" yvioactij;, om. yivExai \' 24. 25
ttoo-paiTj av a: fort. -poi^aiVEV
-
1M11I,rjT0[>!X7c -laietc.
-|'ivsT7t otjv v 7Tp
-
6 PHILOPONI IN ANALYT. POST. I 1[Aiist. p. 7ia 1. 3. 7. D]
xotXXwTTiC'-Ju.svo; I'-or/o;'- xctl outoi 8k
7r[>oYtva>3x.oucitv on OioJ^Allzxii ih 4^
xaXXtoTTiCeaaat. iv{)6;ji-/)(j.a os Xr^c-at ota to
xataXiuTravciv t(j) v(o iv-
OufjLSiaOai TTjV [iiGtv zpotctaiv. i-l ok xoO
it^pctosri'iJ-ct-o; oO'tu)? ofyStcd r|
TrpoYVojCft?- oiov OL) osi ooiir^vai Ai3/ivr| -/pv^fJ-ctTa- xal
"fip Ilci3i(3Tpc(to;15
5 koL^mv xupc(vvrja3v. loate xotXoK zipr^x'xi utio 'AptatoTsXou;
ott irafja
SiootaxoiXiotxat i:aaa [xoc'Oyj'Jic =/ Kpo'j-ctp/ouir^c -jivsxai
-jVtusso)?.
p. 71a3 AT - 'I'ap ti.aU-/j[i.ati/o!l kov STrtatyiaojy oia
xo-jtou xoij
xpoTtoL) Trepatvovxci.
'loou TTui; ix. xuiv xot^oXou c?.pc7'[j-cVo; stti x7. |j.3pi/7.
xaxTjX&c TTtaxou-
10 [J-svo; oi' oi'jxfov. 'iotvcpov ok xouxo, or^rsiv, oxi
Tr^sa[JCtO/jai: sx
Trpo'j7rap-/o6cj-/iC vtvsxoti Yvtoaswc, xoi? axoTioGa-.v IttI
Travxwv. ai'xcSO
-;or.p [xa{)-/j|j.axixc(t 7:iaxrjiJ.ai, xo'jxiaxiv oil Xoyixai',
8i7. xouxou xou
xpo-ou X7.xopi)o'3vxo;(, xouxiait ot7 xr,c TCpo^vtussojr, uj;
sipr^xaucV. 6[j.ot(uc
ok xo'jxo xal 711 X(i)V aWwv iaxiv tOEiv xe/v(7jv x7i ttEpl xouc
Xo-
15 70 uv, avti xou Sou? auXXo7i(3[xous' ' o-. yj-rj id xe
xaOoXou ixxwv [ispi-
XnJV X7.1 X'i [>3p'-X7. X X(T)V X7i)0>.0'J Ti'CJXO'JlAEVOl
017. auXXo^iafl'^JVTttaXOUV-
X7t x Kpo'jirap/o'jl/js -jViucjewc.
p. 71^7 Ot [xkv Xaixpavovxs; 6k -7p7. quvievxcuv.25
'Avxl XOrj 'XOJV -poaOwXE^OU-EVajv'- el y/p pO'jXo;j.7'.
X7X7(3Z'J7'c5ai oxi
20 r^ >|-j/Y) 7.l)7V7X0C, OEl TTpOXEpOV A7[5tV X XOU
TpoaO'.7X70U.EVO'JCOC "po-
7VtOC5tJ.VOV TO 0X1 VJ '}'J/Tj aUXOXtV/)XOC, XO atJTOXt'vr^TOV
dElXtV/)TOV. 1 0[xr,
0^rjT7t TOUTO, 0r iz aXXcDV xaTaaxcuaCsiv oxi xo auxoxt'vy^xov
c/.Etxtv/^xovso
xal oG'xcuc 7.Troo'.xvuv7t 0x1 r] uyrj aOavaxo?.
p. 7la[) 'Qaauxco; ok xal 01 pr^xopixolaujiTrsiOoutjiv.
25 r,alv 0x1 rjixoiojc xok t(ov cptXoao'fojv aoXXo'i'icJaouxal
01 pr^TOpi-
xol -(tvovTai x jrpo'j'Tr7p7/j'jarp: 7vw3eoj;- tbc yj-p
OEuatj.V, xalto Trapa-
1 IvotaPaXXexai II 2 /iyw V: Ei'prjxcd a aTtoxoO a 4 orov om.
V^
5 xaXu); o'jv, om. wci-e V O-o toO dptaxoTEXou? R: xw apiaxoxEXa
a Gotoa-
a/aXt'a -/al Tioiaa S Arist.: om. RUVa YvtLacu,? Y^stat Y 7. 8
lemma om. RUV
9 {000- 11 iiavTcov 01.1. a xaxriXDsv It:! xot p.epr/.a UH post
yvwacU); aiUI.
cpc(vep6v o 0-1 T^'J-'^' ^^"-^ ''^^' (JxotioOsivY: axoTioOvTi RU
I'J inmriiJ.'xi post
XoYr/.o.i colloc. a r^roi Y at om. Ua post XoYi/al add./al
11
^
ante oici add. ot' a'jxwv -isxoOvxai. Touxeatt a 13yjxot Y post
-poyvwaeiu;
add. xaxopao-jviat a Etprjxat V U 0 x/v(Lv om. R s^xtv om. V15
dv-t xo-j RUV: qyyn a xo'j; om. Y: -epl xo'j; R Ifi
auXXoytafxoO
V
18 post [iiv add. ydip V lU ante dvTi add. I'jvt^vxtov atu>v
om. Va
post TrpiaotctXEYOfxEvcov add. 'fr^atv Ra '20. 21
7:pootYV(a[jivov V: TrpocYvtoaaEvojUa
21 aixivrjTOv RV: dftctvaTOv la 22 0;xat V v.axocsvcEU'iaat a 23
dno-
oetvtvjvott scrips!: d-ootxvj3tv RUa: d-ootxvj-ctt Y 25 cpr,citv
cjtXoao-iiov om. V6;j.ot'co; xot; '.pi).oao-foi? R 25. 26 xott 01
pr.xopiy.oi "yjlloti^iJ-oX R: aoXXoYtafj-Vt Y
26 eSetga.uEv] p. 5,27 S([.
-
I'HlLorONl IN ANAI-YT. POST. I 1 [Arist. p.71a9. 11] ^
eluz aua7Tc['0ou3r xoit -jOtp 6 ll/>aTa)V cfir^atv v KJI
I'ooYta on o'jo :ia
etai TTiaxei,, yj \izv otooiaxot/axY] y; 6s -laTSUTtxY^. xcC
TXpl 7.iT00lXXlxf(.o|xva V lo. 11 Tci /.OL-ci T/jV
cJroo[-/.-(z/> a' 1-4 yvo!;j.v scrips!: yvot-xsv
lihri ante [xr] add. t a |j.c; om. Ua 22 /iyio or^ om. \ Jr,Ti V
23 post
Tof; alt. add. x-i V- 24 auxo V 25 -/.dv V post to?; delevit e(;
V
26. 27 aute xpay. add. 6 V 27 0 6 V 20 ante >ov alt. add. xo
RUa
-
- PHILOPONI IN ANALYT. POST. I 1 [Avist. p. 7111]
Ttoior/jxa OS autoO itva srtC"/)Xr. waaoxoi; xav C"f/ta>jjiV
si totto; xcvo; 4^
(5n, OiOOixevov [xsv sstiv o to-o?, Cr^xouiisvov 03 to si xsvoc.
oj(3T 6
jTOcaai al -f>oxaa'.c, 6i' uiv /axo(a/.cU(zCTat xo
-poJ^X/^ao!, xouXot/iaxov [xsv
Stat 66o, a? sxaary]: u.v xojv xaxa {j-ipo? aTrooEicstuv
TTpioXajj-PotVcCiUod osr
5 ou Totp oFov x auuTzspavott XI [XYj Traauiv x(ov fioxaarswv
*j'^"^^'^^^'j^^V'
7.7:).(o; asvxot c/Troosusco; ao'jvaxov 7.u'^ox3p7C i3f0s
"pos'j'vcocjOoit X7.^ TTpo-
xdastc, uov/)v OS otva-f/.y] xrjv iisiCovot, r^v -7!vxo>c
avc(-fXYj sv xt S'lvott xu)V
xoivaJv o(;t(oij.7'xu)v, (uv /(optc 7.7tooi/i)r|Vai xt
ocouvotxoy. at 6s sXvixxoo?
TTpoxa'asic STTciorj oc-sipot (/^i)' sy.7.axov
(''V^i)so')pr,iJt''/ loicti xivs; >.7.ijLpa- i
10 vovxat), sixoxotc 7.6'jv7xov oiirXd); rAar^;. ocTtoostcsa);
X7.c s>,7xxov7C -po-
"j'va)ai)at Trpoxaastc. Trpt/ovx7i [xsvxot sv X7.u fjtst^03i
TTpoxaascJt, Xsya*
or; xou ctc'.waaai, /7t at i/.7xxo'jc ouv7'|i.st. ofov xptrov
suOstuiv uicoxst-
jjLSvwv, xu)V A B 1', E7.y sriro) oxt, etcsI x(xxpa xu)V A B
xifj V daxlv i'a/),
X7t ajX-q\v TTpoxact.; r; kiyjunn. 'o avUpwro; Cov'
|i.-pit/.rja[jisvr| sail orXov oxt x/j [j-st^ovt x'^ Xs^oud'o
'xo Cmov r)0(3ia .
20 waxs xpt7 saxi X7. upo/.7ap7Vsai)at o'fsi/.ovxa xoivojc
tA^t^z aTroost'csto?,
xo 6soo[j.svov, xo C/jfOup-Evov, xo a.ci(x>\xa. oiov (; stti
TCapaostYaaxoc sv
X(o Trp(i)X(p i}copr]u7Xt x(ov Ivjx./.stoou Cr/'o'jvxt srct x/^c
oollstarjC soOsta? 20
TSTispaaasv/jC xptYcjvov t'aoTT/.sopov (j03xy;a7'ji)7i S3xt
osooasvov ukv r; suHsia
Yj TTSTTSpactxEv/j, C'/tO'ju.svov OS xo taor/.EOpov Xpt^OJVOV,
7.;tCOU.7 OS V (>.SV
2b tot's Trpoau/.Xo-|'t(3[j.otc oxt at z% xoG xsvxpou irpoc xyjv
xoG xu/Xou irspt-
csipsiav TtpocjTrtTtxouaat sui}st7t i'aat a>v),r)/,7tc stat
X7l oxt X7. xtu auxco 137
X7t 7./J.r^).ot? S3xtv 1.37, SV Oc X(o a'JaT:Ep7'3a7Tt oxt
xpt'-jOtvov taoTT/.supov
S3Xt xo OTTO XpKOV SuOsioiv t'3tyV KCptS/OlXSVOV. X7t aXOTTSt
CIJ? k7VX7 Xa
Sip-ZjaSVa TTpOStX/jTrXOtt X
-
IMllLol'dNl IN AN.\I,VT. I'OST. I 1 [Arist. p. TPUl] 9
Tt TO i'aov, (uc ev x:^ duvr^OsCa j'V(upi'awv ovkov -couttov. xa
ok ctoxot 4^
Tct'jxct xai v xaTs otXXctt; 7T'.cjT/,ii.a'.s xoti xi/^fai:
sksckov sOp/jdei?. otov iv
[OtTpr/Yj 000[.VOV [liv 3TtV, 1 ~'J/Ot, TO 7T'JpTTlV TOV
aVi>pOJ7T0V, !^r|TO'J|XVOV
6 Tl TO 100C ToO TTUpETOU Tj TO -pOX0tT7f>XTt/OV OtTTlOV XOll
7, Cr.p/Yi T/,? X7-
5 Tax/vt3a)C, 7$iu>aot ok OTi t7. ivctvTi'a t ouatv opDcrc;
'.'ao:; Trotr^jcujtv, -' EuOsia; 30VTai ot/J.r/.otic
15 (xl ul)iai'. 1 77p Ocuo> OTl ill' zij\)z(a; ehiv
c/.XX//.otK ai euDv.oL'., tote
(3tT:'/i7tvoa7i (o; 3Ti nin EoDiia, ' 'j' tu\)ti'x 7p7[j(jy5
3Ttv rJTi; ;
i'aOU TOT^ 'f' 70Trj^ a'/jaElOt; XIT7'..('')3r TO 000aV0V
"j'-(OV C^^TO'J-
tjisvov. ir7'X'v iotv [xev ziTm OTi 7:7VToc- Tpt-j'(ovou 71 060
7:Xup7t T7,; Xoi- -10
TTTp [JLcUOU? ta''v, X7|3ov 0OOU.vOV Tprj'tOVOV. 7V IJ.EVT01
A7pU) TETp7-
20 "I'UJVOV TO A B 1"A X7'( d-^d'^lO TTjV B l^ Ol7'[X-
TpOV X7I TEULtO T7'JT/jV 6t/7 X7T7 TO K a/jfJElOV
X7l E/.TEIV(U X TT)V *,'(OVlOV, TTjC T UTTO I A li
X7l T/jC UTTO B il r 7t1 TO I'j arjIXElOV OUO
'Ji)t7C, T/jV TE A 1"^ X7l Tr,V K Z\, C'J'C'" TTOTEpOV
25 TpiytUVOV E3TI TO A I' A, OTTEp vOv C^("0'J[J.VOV
(Xl' 1 77p OEl'ctO TT^V T A L] X7l Tr,V I, A
iXlOiV 'Jt)Er7V, STjXoV OTl Tpl'i'tOVOV 3ri TO AT A.E10EV7'.
IJLEVTOl yjjTi OTl E3TI TIV7 0E00aEV7 7
[X"/jOTCOTE !^"/)T0'j;J.V7 "j'tVET7t. OlOV E7.V EITTUJ TO
30 00i)eV [AE-'EDo; XlV?,3at, OUOETTOTE E3T71 to [ISYEl^O?
Cr^T06;j.EV0V. X7.V Si'tTOJ 7r7'XtV a'f7lp7V, OUOETTOTE T7'jTrjV
^"/jTO'JUEVOV TTOUO*
Ctsl "('70 7'JT"/j 0E00T71. 6 iJ-EVTOt X'JX/.O; X7l 7'jTO; 7e1
OEOOU-EVO; ESrlv V 60
1 Td> auviTjOei V
oDXiii om. RL'a
ovTuT T(I)'> Toio'JTiov V ccjia OS Ra - xciv V
/.at -iyyoLii om. V S7:a;iai"; V 3 i rJ/oi jaxi RU
4 Tt post TT'jpcTOJ colloc. V 7. 8 TO'JTO O'jvarov om. V -(htzai
do-jvaxov R8 OS V post o'jaai add. ct'JTott V ! r,5otv RV hzio-^
[jivTOt ort V
10 otoo[j,vov Y 11 5oo,a-/r,>- V 12 CTjToy[/-/T| V
TaaapaxatO-.T]Xat; u'l e'JDiat] /.ai id k-f^^ V 15 7:' E'ji)ta'.i
V17 ea-jTot; V, Upr.: za'jTr, a tljj -ote to V 18 ei V (xv om.
UVa
OTl om. V 18. 19 Tol; Xoirot; pr. U 19 eXaxxov V Xa^wv Ra 20
xat
om. Ra 21 xeixvod a ot/a Ta-jTT,v Ra 22 -ujv re RUa 23 xr^; om.
R:
Tojv Ua poyscripsi: j^yo libri 23.24 os'jxepav EyOEia-/
V
24 C^iXtu roxEpov]
fiia-/ 'jlav ofjXov oxi R 25 o'-sp 27 ayo om. RV 29.30 x6 ei
Eaxt |x^yeo;xivEiabai V 31 ocpaipa UV xo-Jxo, sed post Ctjx. V
Ctjxo'jiaevtjV Rl'a
-
10 PHILOPONI IN ANALYT. POST. I 1 [Arist. p. 71^11]
TOt; iTTiTrioo'.?' iv avTot tok arcfiioi? Eypicj/ousy oiuxov
Cv/'^JtJfAiVov, (u;
v Touxd) -(i) Osmpr^aari' ioiv a'fotTpot i-i-o(i) -[xr^\y^^^ r^
Toarj x-j/Xo; iaii'v.
OUOil? O'JV C^ytcl 1 TOOS (3'f7tpa, [ T003 X'j/.//j; V
STTt-iofO, t I06i
}jt-^&o;' xwjxn. "jip x i^? ataiirjssco^ sD.rj-rod.
5 Ta |j.y otjv v rtli^, xa xax7.Xi7:o[jL=va 3xiv iW
1 a-jTo V 2 post e-iv add. oe Ua ai T0ij.7t V 5 Iv fj.ev ouv
tootoi; U6 St'J xeaaape; V rpoyivovxat V 7 |j.ev om. a "J ti iTtv
om. V 11 3Ttv
post rerspcoijivYj colloc. a: eaxai V r^ om. V xo ovoa^ V 14
-/ai om. V
E7XIV om. V 15 -/M ^l V: iny oe a a-opi^aet V 16 rj(A7? Eioevat
a
xo a: om. PiUV 17 wp-oXoyTjijivov U 18 xo prius om. a^ wavtEp 19
dyvooOvxa
oxt ECJxiv om a^ xpctyEXccxiov dojvaxov Ra post Et^svott add.
oxt laxtv dyvooOvxot xi
ar,;j.atvEt la xo alt. U: xov RVa: fort, xov xo 20 xwv om. RUa
21 [xovov UVa
XOtt mrg. U^ 22 xo om. Va 23 i~zA\ a 24 dXXd xo oxt scrips!:
d>X oxt RUa:
dXXot xo xt V 27 dXXojv delevi 29 \ prius om. Va xr^v
-/.axctcpaatv a
7| dTTO'^ctai; V: 7^ x/jv o(;:rj-j;ct5[v i/.rjac'JEiv a: om. R
-de;/; ir.nzf^
-
PHILUI'OM IN ANAI.VT. POST. I 1 [Ari-st.' p. 71^ 1 1. 13. 14.
loj U
tcXci'oS'.v otpaoCst 7rtar"/]ao(K' xoti 'jOip xoti jxooaixr]
xotl ^ctoiAiTpict xal r)!"
apti)[ir(Ttxrj to'jto'.c xs/prjT7.t. to o^ 'ta i'fczpao'ov-a
i::' riyXysj. h>x d'flr,-
Xot? 3X1." [i-OVTj t/fj Y2>[J--tpta TtpOS/jXil.
Aiy(T)s 5' dvotYxaiov -poYtv(u3X3iv X7i t7. $t,?. sipTj/cbs
ot/uj^
5 o' avotYxotiov TTpo-civw^xsiv Tp3rc tookO'j; i-of^sr 9"/)3t
7010 oti tci
asv oxi 3"'. 7:po'j7r'jX7[i[:Javtv 7. vciYxaiov, xa 0 xt xo
/."co|xVov
$UVlVai 0l, X7 0 Ot'tX'iOJ. Z7l S/^X/j Jj 7lXia X XWV
lpr^U.V(UV, OXl
xpta [j-c'v saxtv 7. Sei 7TpoX7[x[':iaval}at 7:73/,'?
m3trja-/)c, ot os tpoiroi, X7i)
oC; OEi xaoxa 7tva>3x3i)7i, 060 eiai'v, xo oxi 3xi X7t to xi
ar^
-
12 PIIILOPONI IN ANALYT. POST. I 1 [Arist. p.71al6. 17]
p. 71*16 Ou '(ap Ofxoiioc touTotv Exctaiov or^Xov rj(jiTv.
S""
To |j.v -,'7p Ssoofxs'vov /i xoti TO OTt lati xotl TO XI
or^ixotivei, to
OS C^l'co'juevov TO Tt arjjx7tvit [xovov, TO Ss otci'to'iot TO
oTi ea-(.
p. 71^17 "Egti 0 j'vcuptCeiv' T(i usv TrpoTspov -j-vcopt CovTot,
twv
5 OS xal (Z[ia Xa[j [5otvovTa ttjV -(^">a'G(; XOlt
[J.0tl)Y;3a)^ OO^OtV e'i'tc ex IT/jT/jacUj; XOtt EOpEaElO?, EX
TTOOEYVtoaplSVtOV T'.VUJV TTO!p77lV(3l)o(l. ItpiV Tj 0
6tC(X)(l)r,V0(l TISpl Upa(OC
15 TCOOTEpOV TtEpl TOtji "(VOipiCElV irpOTtl)TC(l OlOa'cOtl
W> OIV X0tl)oXlXU)TpOU o'vTOC, 60
(U$ 8eI$0[J.EV EITE^IOVTSC. TOU OOV '(VU)[jl'l,et.V o6o 131
TpOTlOt, eU plSV,
OTav TrpoE^voiXOTE? Ti a5i)i>; TOUT(0 Trp0(3pa>.(O[XV
Xr|i)irj^ [AV, XE-j-OtlEOot TOUTOV -j-VtOpt'CsiV St 0 X"/]?)/;
jJlaoX7pryat, ElTOt
20 7Ul)i; T'^V T:pOTp7V O.UT0U "(VuiatV Xa'pOJJJLEV, OOXETt
"CVCUpt'CsiV TO TOtOUTOV
X-(T7t otXXot av7[xijjivY^axaOat. eU \ikv ouv Tpoito? outoc.
osuTspos
OS to; OTav lyovtE; Toti xai)6Xou t))v svvotav aEpixtu Ttvt |
TrpoapaXcojiEv 5^
[lYj TTpoTspov sDsaaa[xi)a, siTa toGto scpapuoacousv tiu xaDoXou
o5 Tf^v
"I'vuxjtv -/o[jiv. otov t Osa'ayiTat tt? t7]v jj-ocj-vr/Ttv
XtOov iXxouaav tov
25 aiSr^pov, i pisv [xtj ei'/j Trpo-,'V(ox>? ott Ttaaa r,
xoiouT/j XtOo? iXxst tov
ator^pov, ou XE^stat o toioGto; "(vajptCsiv OTt piaYvr^Ti; cjTt
XiOoc, dXXa
TTOtuTcu; {xavi)a'vEt, Et EOKopr^cJEt tou otoa'cJxovTOC,
-
1*II1I,()P()NI IN ANAl-YT. I'O.ST. I 1 [Arist. p. Tl-MT] 13
70(lV/j. O'JO OUV TOUKOV OVTOJV Tp'jTTfOV ",'Va>pt(3E(OC
XOtTOt TOV OEOTSpOV tpOTTOV f)^
cp/jdtv 'ApiaxoxiX/jC -jt'vcail^t Tr,v e-jpeaiv, OTctv 11301x01;
Tiai y)zu)oqn'j.ai.
li.-q 7rooE-|V(o3[i3VM; yjjjLiv -pdjKo; ST:t,37'XXovtE;
Tp(uv
7:oos-|V.>3fA2V(ov TTjV -,'V(oaiv ctuTojv ayrjaoixev. oiov
iav Itti iao3Xc>.oGc
;-j Tpr,' I' czkO tTjC xopucf-r,; iitl Tr,v [^ctaiv ttjv B I'
xabstov 10
d'('X'(Mii.zv t/jV A A (liars or/a tsijivcIv ty;v ["rJot'cJtv
xrxi 060 TpiYi)V(ov $
(xva'-fitr^s "(voavov, xojv A B A, A A I', TrpopX'/jil/r]
Y)ji.rv t; C,riTr^aiv Ttorspov ta -,'ivfjava Tpr|'ovc(,
X'Yfo OT) xa x\ BA, A A r, hoL isxtv yj ur|, xouxou
10 XTjV Y'^'fuciiv Eupr^aofisv EcpctpfioCovxE^ auxo dWoi^
xiat xcti)oXix(!>Xpoi; OefopTf]|X7at -posYV(o3[Xvoi;
TjlXlV. TrlOrj "j'Olp 7Tpo'j'V(OU.V, Oil XoJV laOtJXsXmV
xpr,'^i'^\' ^fi *(''>vta Tl'/jv Tr)V ut:o
X(Tjv Xamv ui)t(ov TrEptEyofjivr^v, xotl xyjv [idaiv
XYj BaSEi iCf/jV e'cei xat xo xpr((uvov X(u xpiYcuvfo icjov
laxai xct oc- Xot-at
Yojvr/i xai; Xoi-otis *j'
-
14 PHILOPONI IN ANALYT. POST. I 1 [Arist. p. 71al7]
aUMV Oc(ory/;fic(Tax(o-sp7v sTvoti 5^
tt;v *|'V(ocjiv T^; sGpsasto?, otoxi xctxot [lovov tov oc-jTSpov
toottov x9)s
'(vui[Aatai; r; sup3i? 7ivtai xa Qr^zooiievx toic
ouoXo'/oujiivot; 'iC(p|j.r>C'^v-(ov
/)au)V, y; OS YvuitJt? sttI rXstovwv OstopiiTCti' xcti -^otp
xotl i-t xou Tpo-
5 XSpOU XpOTlOU. OU XOUXO oi r^til, OXt XOIUXOV 3Xl YVWpltJl?
X7t 'jpixou[isv jxt] stooxs? -j'tip
2u)xpax-/iv ouo', av aTravxr^stojiSv aux(i), -,v(opta7i auxov
ouva'asOa. si 6s
20 7:pO7V(oxoxs'"J3t; Y post ciYvoia? add. cpaviv Y 8 iJ.epc'tov
Y:
cpc(Vf,ov Rlia 10 Tj T /) T R Stot prius om. R U TrepiYivcTat
Y12 -/.ai prius om. a h toT Mivwvi] p. 80 I) sq. IrtX-je-cd post
^vteuOev colloc. a:
OtotX'JExat Y 13 CrjTElv
