Evangelista v. Abad-Santos (G.R. No. 31684)

7/27/2019 Evangelista v. Abad-Santos (G.R. No. 31684)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/evangelista-v-abad-santos-gr-no-31684 1/3

!"#$%&' )!*+$#*,-.) !$/ +*0,+, /."#,+, 12345 6 23478 !++&9 :;!<0.$ ;=.#+!

*!%-#>># !$$# "0+.#**#?

!"#" %&" '()*+ ,-./ *0 (12'

345%!367895 :" 5;5<=85%9>8

!"#$%&$''()

• +,#%-."$(&# / 012• 314$%-1 02 +,#%-."$(&#5 6725 01%89$&# :2 ;#,#771 #%< =.1%#7<#

>&$.%?# >@#< A#%&1( B8#C$&#"$(& C#7&%.7( '17 &9. 814C#%DE

3.'.%<#%&) +(&7.""# >@#<FA#%&1( B8"#$4( &1 @. #% $%<G(&7$#" C#7&%.7 '17

&9. 814C#%D5 #%< #& &9. (#4. &$4. $( (.7,$%- #( # 6G<-. 1' &9. 0$&D

01G7& 1' H#%$"#E

0>A+) I.7.$% C.&$&$1%.7( #7. 8#C$&#"$(& C#7&%.7( '17 &9. 814C#%D

+,#%-."$(&# / 012 >@1G& # D.#7 "#&.75 &9.D #4.%<.< &9. >7&$8". 1' 01F

!#7&%.7(9$C &1 $%8"G<. +(&7.""# >@#<FA#%&1( BJ91 J#( #"7.#<D (.7,$%- #(# 6G<-. 1' &9. 0$&D 1' &9. 01G7& 1' H#%$"#E #( #% $%<G(&7$#" C#7&%.72

+(&7.""# #"".-.( &9#& &9. 814C#%D 9#( @..% C#D$%- <$,$<.%<( &1 &9.

C.&$&$1%.7(5 @G& %1& &1 9.72 !.&$&$1%.7( 8"#$4 &9#& >7&$8".( 1' 01F

!#7&%.7(9$C <$< %1& $%<$8#&. &9.$7 &7G. $%&.%& J9$89 $( &9#& +(&7.""# $(

;KL #% $%<G(&7$#" C#7&%.7 #%< J$"" 1%"D @. .%&$&".< &1 MNO (9#7. 1'

C71'$&( 7.#"$?.< @D &9. 814C#%D G%&$" &9. "1#% 1' &9. 814C#%D J9$89 (9.

(.8G7.< J$&9 9.7 C71C.7&D J#( C#$<2

L9. AGC7.4. 01G7& 7G".< &9#& +(&7.""#P( (&#&G( #( $%<G(&7$#" C#7&%.7 J#(

<G"D C71,.< @D &9. .Q9$@$&(5 <18G4.%&( #%< '#8&( C7.(.%&.< #& #%<

.,#"G#&.< @D &9. "1J.7 81G7&2 L9. C.&$&$1%.7( #7. .(&1CC.< '714

8"#$4$%- 1&9.7J$(. @.8#G(. &9.D 9#< #&&.(&.< &1 &9. -.%G$%.%.(( #%<

<G. .Q.8G&$1% 1' &9. <18G4.%&(2 >"(15 +(&7.""# J#( #@". &1 'G"'$"" 9.7

<G&$.( &1 &9. C#7&%.7(9$C .,.% &91G-9 (9. J#( (.7,$%- #( # 6G<-.2

RG7&9.75 9.7 @.$%- # 6G<-. $( %1& # @G($%.(( &9#& 81G"< C1(($@"D 7.(G"& $%

# 81%'"$8& 1' $%&.7.(& J$&9 &9. 814C#%D2 I.%8.5 C.&$&$1%.7( '#$".< &1

.Q.78$(. &9.$7 7$-9& &1 .Q8"G($1% 1% &9. -71G%< &9#& (9. $( J17S$%- #(

TG<-.2

3K0LUV;+W>!!=V0>LVK;) L9. 7$-9& &1 .Q8"G($1% G%<.7 5?@ABC/ (2*1"

;5DE!#>F%<G

! K8&[email protected] X5 YXZ[ ! # 81FC#7&%.7(9$C G%<.7 &9. %#4. 1'

\+,#%-."$(&# / 01] J#( '174.< J$&9 9.7.$% C7$,#&. C.&$&$1%.7(

#( 8#C$&#"$(& C#7&%.7( J$&9 # 81%&7$@G&$1% 1' !Y^5ZNN .#892! 6G%. ^5 YXZZ ! L9. >7&$8".( 1' 81FC#7&%.7(9$C J#( #4.%<.< &1

$%8"G<. +(&7.""# >@#<FA#%&1( #( $%<G(&7$#" C#7&%.7 .%&$&".< &1

MNO2 L9. C71'$&( #%< "1((.( J1G"< @. <$,$<.< #%< <$(&7$@G&.<

#41%- &9. C#7&%.7( $% &9. C71C17&$1% 1' ^NO &1 @. (C"$&

@.&J..% +,#%-."$(&#5 ;#,#71 #%< >&$.%?# >@#< A#%&1(5 J9$".

MNO '17 +(&7.""# >@#< A#%&1(2

! [email protected] Y^5 YX_M! +(&7.""# >@#< A#%&1( '$".< (G$& #-#$%(& &9.

&97.. #"".-$%- &9#& &9. 814C#%D 9#< @..% C#D$%- <$,$<.%<( &1

&9.4 @G& %1& &1 9.72 !"#$%&$''( 7.'G(.< &1 ".& 9.7 .Q#4$%. &9.

C#7&%.7(9$C @11S( #%< 7.'G(.< &1 C#D 9.72! !"#$%&$''( 8"#$4 &9#& &9. >7&$8".( 1' 01FC#7&%.7(9$C <$< %1&

.QC7.(( &9. &7G. $%&.%& 1' &9. #-7..4.%& 1' &9. C#7&$.( J9$89

J#( &9#& BYE C"#$%&$'' J#( %1& #% $%<G(&7$#" C#7&%.7 #%< (9. <$<

%1& $% '#8& 81%&7$@G&. $%<G(&7D &1 &9. C#7&%.7(9$C5 #%< B`E &9#&

9.7 (9#7. 1' MNO J#( &1 @. @#(.< 1% &9. C71'$&( J9$89 4$-9& @.

7.#"$?.< @D &9. C#7&%.7(9$C 1%"D G%&$" 'G"" C#D4.%& 1' &9. "1#%

J9$89 $& 9#< 1@&#$%.< $% [email protected] YXZZ '714 &9.

U.9#@$"$&#&$1% R$%#%8. 017C17#&$1% $% &9. (G4 1' !MN5NNN5 '17

J9$89 &9. C"#$%&$'' 9#< ($-%.< # C714$(17D %1&. #( 81F4#S.7 #%<

417&-#-.< 9.7 C71C.7&D #( (.8G7$&D2

! L9. &7$#" 81G7& 7G".< $% '#,17 1' +(&7.""#5 #%< &9. 01G7& 1'

>CC.#"( #''$74.< &9. TG<-4.%& 1' &9. 81G7& # aG12

788F38 9> ;3 #38>643<G

Y2 b9.&9.7 &9. 7.(C1%<.%& $( #% $%<G(&7$#" C#7&%.7 #( 8"#$4.< @D

9.7 17 4.7."D # C71'$& (9#7.7 .%&$&".< &1 MNO 1' &9. %.& C71'$&(

&9#& 4#D @. 7.#"$?.< @D &9. C#7&%.7(9$C '714 6G%. ^5 YXZZ G%&$"

&9. 417&-#-. "1#% '714 &9. U.9#@$"$&#&$1% R$%#%8. 017C17#&$1%

(9#"" @. 'G""D C#$<5 #( 8"#$4.< @D C.&$&$1%.7(2



!"#$%&' )!*+$#*,-.) !$/ +*0,+, /."#,+, 12345 6 23478 !++&9 :;!<0.$ ;=.#+!

*!%-#>># !$$# "0+.#**#?

#38>6F97>%8 5%< 5#!FH3%98

788F3 ( b9.&9.7 &9. 7.(C1%<.%& $( #% $%<G(&7$#" C#7&%.7 #( 8"#$4.<

@D 9.7 17 4.7."D # C71'$& (9#7.7 .%&$&".< &1 MNO 1' &9. %.& C71'$&( &9#&

4#D @. 7.#"$?.< @D &9. C#7&%.7(9$C '714 6G%. ^5 YXZZ G%&$" &9.

417&-#-. "1#% '714 &9. U.9#@$"$&#&$1% R$%#%8. 017C17#&$1% (9#"" @. 'G""DC#$<5 #( 8"#$4.< @D C.&$&$1%.7(2! c+A2

H#T17 !1$%& Y) +(&7.""# >@#<FA#%&1( $( &9. $%<G(&7$#" C#7&%.7 #( C71,.<

@D &9. >7&$8".( 1' 01FC#7&%.7(9$C #%< 1&9.7 '#8&17( 81%($(&$%- 1' @1&9

&.(&$41%$#" #%< <18G4.%&#7D .,$<.%8.2

• !.&$&$1%.7( #7-G. &9#& &9. 01G7& 1' >CC.#"( .77.< $% '$%<$%- &9#&

&9. d#4.%<.< >7&$8".( 1' 01FC#7&%.7(9$C5d +Q9$@$& d>d $(

81%8"G($,. .,$<.%8. &9#& 7.(C1%<.%& J#( $% '#8& 4#<. #%

$%<G(&7$#" C#7&%.7 1' +,#%-."$(&# / 012

• V& $( %1& &9. 'G%8&$1% 1' &9. AGC7.4. 01G7& &1 #%#"D?. 17 J.$-9(G89 .,$<.%8. #"" 1,.7 #-#$%5 $&( TG7$(<$8&$1% @.$%- "$4$&.< &1

7.,$.J$%- .7717( 1' "#J &9#& 4$-9& 9#,. @..% 8144$&&.< @D &9.

"1J.7 81G7&2

• L9. "1J.7 81G7& #88.C&.< #%< 7."$.< 4#$%"D 1% &9. .Q9$@$&(

C7.(.%&.< @D 7.(C1%<.%& C71,$%- &9#& (9. $( #% $%<G(&7$#"

C#7&%.7 $% +,#%-."$(&# / 012 @.8#G(. C.&$&$1%.7( 9#,. #<4$&&.<

&9.$7 -.%G$%.%.(( #%< <G. .Q.8G&$1%2 !.&$&$1%.7( #7. ,$7&G#""D

.(&1CC.< '714 #&&.4C&$%- &1 <.&7#8& '714 &9. C71@#&$,. '178.

1' &9. (#$< .Q9$@$&( @.8#G(. &9.D #"" @.#7 &9. $4C7$%& 1' &9.$7

S%1J".<-. #%< 81%(.%&5 #%< &9.7. $( %1 87.<$@". (91J$%- &9#&

&9.D .,.7 C71&.(&.< #-#$%(& 17 1CC1(.< &9.$7 81%&.%&( C7$17 1'

&9. '$"$%- 1' &9.$7 #%(J.7 &1 7.(C1%<.%&P( 814C"#$%&2

H#T17 !1$%& `) +,.% #( 7.(C1%<.%& J#( #%< (&$"" $( # 6G<-. 1' &9. 0$&D

01G7& 1' H#%$"#5 (9. 9#( 7.%<.7.< (.7,$8.( '17 #CC.""#%&( J$&91G& J9$89

&9.D J1G"< %1& 9#,. 9#< &9. J9.7.J$&9#" &1 1C.7#&. &9. @G($%.(( '17

J9$89 #CC.""#%& 814C#%D J#( 17-#%$?.<2

• !.&$&$1%.7( 8"#$4 &9#& 7.(C1%<.%& <$< %1& @$%< 9.7(."' &1

81%&7$@G&. 9.7 $%<G(&7D5 #%< (9. 81G"< %1&5 #%< $% '#8& <$< %1&5

@.8#G(. (9. J#( 1%. 1' &9. TG<-.( 1' &9. 0$&D 01G7& 1' H#%$"#

($%8. YXZ[2 >( (G895 (9. <.,1&.< #"" 9.7 &$4. &1 &9.

C.7'174#%8. 1' &9. <G&$.( 1' 9.7 CG@"$8 1''$8.2 L9$( '#8& C71,.(

@.D1%< C.7#<,.%&G7. &9#& $& J#( %.,.7 81%&.4C"#&.< @.&J..%

&9. C#7&$.(5 '17 (9. 81G"< %1& "#J'G""D 81%&7$@G&. 9.7 'G"" &$4.

#%< $%<G(&7D J9$89 $( &9. 1@"$-#&$1% 1' #% $%<G(&7$#" C#7&%.7CG7(G#%& &1 5?@ABC/ (2*1 1' &9. DA:AC D&I/"

• 5?@ABC/ (2)20 DA:AC D&I/) :D 81%&7#8& 1' C#7&%.7(9$C &J1 17 417.

C.7(1%( @$%< &9.4(.",.(5 &1 81%&7$@G&. 41%.D5 C71C.7&D5 17

$%<G(&7D &1 # 81441% 'G%<5 J$&9 &9. $%&.%&$1% 1' <$,$<$%- &9.

C71'$&( #41%- &9.4(.",.(2

o L9. #7&$8". <1.( %1& (C.8$'D &9. S$%< 1' $%<G(&7D &9#& #

C#7&%.7 4#D 81%&7$@G&.2 I.%8. (.7,$8.( e (G89 #( &9#&

-$,.% @D #% $%<G(&7$#" C#7&%.7 "$S. 7.(C1%<.%& e 4#D

".-$&$4#&."D @. 81%&7$@G&.< #( C#7& 1' &9. 81441% 'G%<2

• 5?@ABC/ (2*10 DA:AC D&I/) >% $%<G(&7$#" C#7&%.7 8#%%1& .%-#-. $%@G($%.(( '17 9$4(."'5 G%".(( &9. C#7&%.7(9$C .QC7.(("D C.74$&(

9$4 &1 <1 (1f #%< $' 9. (91G"< <1 (15 &9. 8#C$&#"$(& C#7&%.7( 4#D

.$&9.7 .Q8"G<. 9$4 '714 &9. '$74 17 #,#$" &9.4(.",.( 1' &9.

@.%.'$&( J9$89 9. 4#D 9#,. 1@&#$%.< $% ,$1"#&$1% 1' &9$(

C71,$($1%5 J$&9 # 7$-9& &1 <#4#-.( $% .$&9.7 8#(.2Y

o L9#& 7.(C1%<.%& 9#( '#$&9'G""D 814C"$.< J$&9 9.7

1@"$-#&$1% J$&9 7.(C.8& &1 C.&$&$1%.7( $( 8".#7"D (91J%

@D &9. '#8& &9#& $& J#( 1%"D #'&.7 '$"$%- 1' &9. 814C"#$%&

$% &9$( 8#(. #%< &9. #%(J.7 &9.7.&1 #CC.""#%&( .Q.78$(.<

&9.$7 7$-9& 1' .Q8"G($1% @D #"".-$%- $% &9.$7 AGCC".4.%&#"

>%(J.7 <#&.< 6G%. `X5 YX_[ g 17 #'&.7 #71G%< XD.#7(

'714 6G%. ^5 YXZZ g (G@(.aG.%& &1 &9. '$"$%- 1'

<.'.%<#%&(h #%(J.7 &1 &9. 814C"#$%&5 &9#& 9.7.$%

7.(C1%<.%& $( %1& #% $%<G(&7$#" C#7&%.72

J7%56 43#<7D9G 5?@ABC/ (*11 C71,$<.( &9#&)

4 .@ AB CD@ EABFG@HE @IJ@ @IH FKDLABADC JMJACB@ @IH ACEGB@KAJN FJK@CHK HCMJMACM AC OGBACHBB PDK

IAQBHNP BHHRB @D FKHLHC@ JCS TDCPNAT@ DP AC@HKHB@ OH@UHHC @IH ACEGB@KAJN FJK@CHK JCE @IH

FJK@CHKBIAF' JCE @D ACBGKH PJA@IPGN TDQFNAJCTH OS BJAE FJK@CHK UA@I @IAB FKHB@J@ADC9



!"#$%&' )!*+$#*,-.) !$/ +*0,+, /."#,+, 12345 6 23478 !++&9 :;!<0.$ ;=.#+!

*!%-#>># !$$# "0+.#**#?

>%D C#7&%.7 (9#"" 9#,. &9. 7$-9& &1 # '174#" #881G%& #( &1 C#7&%.7(9$C

#''#$7()

BYE V' 9. $( J71%-'G""D .Q8"G<.< '714 &9. C#7&%.7(9$C @G($%.(( 17

C1((.(($1% 1' $&( C71C.7&D @D 9$( 81F C#7&%.7(f

Q Q Q

U.(C1%<.%&5 #( $%<G(&7$#" C#7&%.7 1' &9. 814C#%D 9#( # 7$-9& &1 <.4#%<

'17 '174#" #881G%&$%- #%< &1 7.8.$,. 9.7 (9#7. $% &9. %.& C71'$&2

%> 83K5#593 >K7%7>%8

Documents

Evangelista v. Abad-Santos (G.R. No. 31684)