10/2/12 For firefighter feet, comfort is king

1/3www.firerescue1.com/fire-products/apparel/boots/articles/1284917-For-firefighter-feet-comfort-is-king/

Like 0 TweetTweet 1 0

InterestedinBoots?Getpricing,productinfo&

discountsfromtopcompanies.

*First:

*Last:

*Department:

*Email:

*ZipCode:

Telephone:

Home>F i reProducts>F i reBoots>Forf i ref i ghterf eet ,comfort i ski ng

May10,2012

Forfirefighterfeet,comfortiskingTheleathervsrubberbootdebatelandssquarelyonthesideofleather

BySarahM.SmartFireRescue1Staff

Firefightersoftenhavetothinkontheirfeetduringanemergency,buttheyalsothinkabouttheirfeet.Because,frankly,aretheremanythingsworsethansorefeetonthefireground?

Inthedebateoverwhichbootmaterialissuperior,aprettyclearwinnerhasemerged.

Thorogood,makerofbothrubberandleatherboots,offersalmosttwiceasmanymodelsofleatherstructuralbootasitdoesofrubberstructural(sevenandfour,respectively).Itstoptwosellersarebothleatherstructuralboots,accordingtoJeffBurns,vicepresidentUniform/FireDivisionofWeinbrenner,Thorogood'sparentcompany.

FanbaseFireRescue1Facebookfansalsooverwhelminglypreferleather:Only7percentofrespondentssaidrubberwastheirfirstchoice.

DeputyFireMarshalJonWilliamsofUnionCounty,N.C.,isalsoaCaptainatUnionvilleVolunteerFireDepartment.Hispreferencegoesfurtherthanmaterial:He'sa"hugefan"ofleatherGlobeMagnums.

"Ihavealace­up/zipsetatworkasfiremarshalandatraditionalpull­onleatherformyvolunteerdepartment,"MarshalWilliamssaid,citingthecomfortashisdefiningcriterion.

"Theywearlikeatennisshoe,"hesaid.

Studieshaveshownthatleatherbootshelpreducephysicalinjuriesinfirefighters.

ANIOSHstudystillinprogresshassuggestedthatbecauseleatherbootsareaboutthreepoundslighterthanrubberboots,theyallowmoremobilityinthefeet,ankles,kneesandhips.

Italsosaysthatinalighterboot,thefirefighterhasabettersenseoffootingandasmallerriskofinjurytolowerlimbs.

Sowhydosomefirefightersstillchooserubber?

CostmattersSomeFacebookrespondentssaidrubberbootswereeasiertopullonduringquick­dressdrills.Otherslikedthattheywerenaturallywaterproof,andstillotherssaidtheyweremoredurablethanleather.They'realsoagooddealcheaper.

Thorogood'stwotopsellers,bothofwhichareleatherstructuralboots,costuptotwiceasmuchasrubberboots,Burnssaid.

"Abouttheonlypositivethingaboutrubberisthatit'srelativelyinexpensive,"Burnssaid,addingthatitdoesn'tbreathewellandisheavyanduncomfortable.

Somefirefightersalsobelievethatrubberbootsareeasiertocleanwheninvolvedinahazmatsituation.

"Theprevailingthoughtfromeverybodyisifyougetintoacontaminant,youcouldrinseofftherubberandthrowawaytheleather,"Burnssaid.

ButastudybyW.L.Goreprovedtheopposite.Thecellularstructureofrubberactuallytrapshazardousmaterials,itsaid,whereasleathershedsmostchemicalsbyjustbeinghosedoff.

FireBootsSponsors

GlobeFootGear

LION

Weinbrenner

AllFireBootsSponsors

ConnectwithFireRescue1

FeaturedProducts

StructuralSeries12"Zipper/SpeedLaceBootfromGlobeFootGearGlobeFootGear

LIONTechnicalFootwear

20%OffThePerfectStackw/Code:FIRERESCUE1 SetasHomePage MyProfile Register FR1Email

FR1Mobi l e Apps

TOPEXCLUSIVES

Whyyogaisrightforthefireservice

Moreinformationdoesnotmakeforbetterdecisions

TechrescuePPE:Youroptions

Email Print Comment RSS

ShareShare 0

10/2/12 For firefighter feet, comfort is king

2/3www.firerescue1.com/fire-products/apparel/boots/articles/1284917-For-firefighter-feet-comfort-is-king/

Rubberbootsalsocomewithabitoftradition.Manydepartmentshaveusedrubberbootssincethe1930s.

FirefighterHunterKnightoftheMoodyFireDepartmentinBirmingham,Ala.,saidthefirefighterswithlongertenureinhisdepartmentatfirsthonoredtraditionbystickingtorubberboots.Butnowtheyhavemostlyswitchedtoleather.

Andwhatisthebasisforthis?Newerleatherbootsaremorerigid,providingasimilarrigidsupporttorubber,FirefighterKnightsaid,especiallyforfirefighterswithankleissues.

PlusFirefighterKnightbelievesthecomfortofleatherissuperior.

"Youdon'twanttobesomewherewhereyou'resupposedtoconcentrateonthescenebutyou'refocusedonyourfeethurting,"headded."Ifyou'remorecomfortable,you'remoresafe."

AsFireRescue1'sPPEcolumnistsJeffandGraceStulloutlinedinapreviousarticle,theimportantaspectofchoosingbetweenrubberandleatherfootwearisweighyourorganization'sneedsanddecidewhichcharacteristicsaremoreimportant—weight,comfort/fit,performance,durability,contaminationresistanceandcost.

"Someofthesecharacteristicscanbedeterminedbyunderstandingotherdepartments'experienceswithspecificstylesoffootwearandtherelativeserviceprovidedbythefootwear,"theysaid.

"Aswithanytypeofpersonalprotectiveequipment,itisdifficulttoachieve100percentsatisfactionbetweenallfirefighters.However,itisimportantthatallfirefightersbeaffordedproperfittingfootwearthatprovidesanacceptablelevelofprotectionwithoutcompromisingtheirsafety."

Comments

Thecommentsbelowaremember­generatedanddonotnecessarilyreflecttheopinionsofFrieRescue1.comoritsstaff.

ExpertColumns

RobertAvsec­ProductNews

MoreExpertArticles

TrainingVideos

Firefighterwinterization

MoreTrainingVideos

LatestFireJobs

Firefigter/Paramedic

FirefighterorFirefighter/Paramedic

ProbationaryFirefighter

Firefighter/EngineerassignedtoParamedicDuties

VisittheCareersSection

LION

MoreBootsProducts

FeaturedVideos

Bates­C3

LionTechnicalFootwear­CareandUse

MoreVideos

TopProductArticles

Stationboots:Whattoknowbeforeyoubuy

Ga.departmentreplacesSCBAafterfirefighternear­miss

FR1survey:FirefighterpersonalprotectiveequipmentForfirefighterfeet,comfortisking

MoreTopProductArticles

FeaturedDeals

Win$1,000WorthofFreeGear!fromPublicSafetyManufacturersGroup

MoreBootsDeals

AboutFireRescue1 Advertise ContactUs MemberSupport MyProfile PrivacyPolicy Sitemap

FireRescue1 News&Video PopularProducts PopularTopics Resources InOurNetwork

FireRescue1isrevolutionizingthewaythefireservicecommunityfindsrelevantnews,identifiesimportanttraininginformation,interactsonlineandresearchesproductpurchasesandsuppliers.It'sthemostcomprehensiveandtrustedonlinedestinationforfirefightersandfiredepartmentsworldwide.

ColumnistsFireNewsFireNewsFeedFirePhotosFireVideosFirefighterTipsFlashoverTVLine­of­DutyDeaths

ApparatusFireGlovesFireRadiosFireToolsPPEPreventionProductsRescueEquipmentAllFireProducts

DepartmentManagementFireAttackFire­EMSFirePreventionFirefighterSafetyVolunteerWildlandAllFireTopics

CopyrightInfoFireGamesFirefighterBlogFirefighterJobsFirefighterTrainingFR1SponsorsNewslettersNFPAStandards

BioterrorismFireGrantsParamedicJobsParamedicVideosTacticalEMSVolunteering

FollowUs

Facebook social plugin

CommentPosting as Sarah M. Smart (Change)

Add a comment...

Post to Facebook

10/2/12 For firefighter feet, comfort is king

3/3www.firerescue1.com/fire-products/apparel/boots/articles/1284917-For-firefighter-feet-comfort-is-king/

VisitotherFireRescue1NetworkSites: FireRescue1 Copyright©2012Firerescue1.com.AllRightsReserved.