Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
����� � ������������
� O0M' ��#� A��,X� �d-�k�...
48
�:T" � 56:" ��;�( =��B� �T1>� U�/ �� F�Q4 � (+ ��9!� �:T" �� �M�1� �
����P ��)2 �>6�3��9 �)=� ��
345�� ����Q =-���� �'�� =-��'��V �,� �: 4o# �% 7����Q =-���� 6�U��� 79:6�U��� ����� 6�)��� 7=�� ��� (A B0� 6��0# �)[email protected]
f4O��- �#� O#�#�� =-���� =��Q pqh ^Q 7 �,-� 6�U��� o# �% 7����Q =-���� 6�U��� 7=����Q ��� ����� 6�)��� 7=�� ���
6����)88/G/KEL��MA<</8/KD(
1/���
������ $�&�J 89:�� Vc� D ��� �� � ?f����D )��> +=, �I�b� 1$�c0 $�& $��'�> 89:�� ��Ip> � $�; �KJ �KN � �KJ ?KA�D�JVc� D ��� �% ��5 ��c� �J 89:�� D 5�<� �5�I*� �� � ?6�kX GtJ )��> ������ )� $�& ��k0 1�& +=, $�& 89:�� $�;?� .
5 ?��0 5�<� ���� ML�� ������ )� �� .9*f � 5 �c0 D �AtJ 5�%�% �% ?� $�� �J �&�� �& lK� MK�� � 5��!=� .� %+=, ��k0 ��cJ �����J �J �*�J� 89:�� $�; �K� 14�KJ ?K��0 .�=*� $5 ��(� ?f� 0 �J �% ?� �; $�c"� � $5�J �KJ ��K>
��D�J ��<� 5��!=� 1V*��� ?�6:� �J � *k� $�& �J ��k0 ���% �5 .55 G��� �c,�> /J�L ����G&�BC $�KJ �'�� 1�:����k0 5 ?��0 5��� .�=*� �k��7� +=, $�& ?K�!J�L �KJ �,�> �J �% ?� ��0 ���6� )���J ��k0 D �5�I*� �J 89:�� $�; $�K&
��k0 ��B�� � )���J $�& V*��� $�& �s .�� 189:�� $�& D ��0 ��K� �Kc $5 ��K0 �Ks P� .?� 5�f�J ��4�J ���%�5��; ���� $5�� $D�� ?7[ 1)���J ��k0 PD��; 1.�� $�& PD��; ��k0 �< � ��KA� $�KJ .?K� �,��f Z��*� ?���5 � ���5
���6� P� 5�J�% �55 +=, ��k0 D �*=�L 1��0 �J ��c> �c0 89:�� $�; �� �6'�U� �� � .�=*� D �5�I*� �J � �0 8�t*� $5�J ?��0 5��� �����J ?��'� ?c, D ���� Z C 5 �&��J9:�� 1.�� D ���; ?�5 ��K0 V�K�(> $�Kc"� � ��D�J $�& 1Z��K*� .�K�
��A� ) V% � V% �!�f ?��0 .�=*� �� &5^a�[5) ]��*� � (e_�[5 �K*k' �K% ?� ��k0 5 5�,�� $�&��J9:�� �g% $�J ( �K�+=, ��k0 ��=� GtJ �5�J �� 1��c> 89:�� $�; .�0�J �; /��� �!=, D ���>
�A�, ���6)���: J�# F>�J# E�%��� $%5 ��� 7!.�� J�# F,��Q3� FNQ3� ��,�
"#$�% /)� �� /�� �C.�9 $�% ��; *� #�<� ��!� � :4���-�* +�-�B $��%
����" :��;" 1$-;��, �C��.�9 ���9� /0I��EB 1`���[�)� 1$&� $���% #� #�J�-> # !��� $&��KB 1#�F G 1#5)�4 ��-�&�? �)!�,]X[.
/)� �� +�� v0MG �-<8�� &� /�? #��0�%� /�� /�"!B ��� ��% :�-��� :�� /"!B ���� &�0@� 1�)&�� $-;, ./)� ��� &� :�@<, ��K�� $��%
-P) &� 6&!G &� 1�C.�9)O0�' +�9-5 #� 0� f��K)� f*� $��% 1#������"� 1$����E��� $�%��� �0' :���� +��<� 1#����[ 6� ������
:@�* /��,�� `��u)� /�� $���, &�0@� #�,��;� 6C<l #30M ���,��.��? :���� f*� /���<) +���� -��?t /*� &!��P »:��@<, «# ����B
:0F. � #��%:����A �� �, /"�! �<l �� ��@0� �-<8�� /?# �!,.
#��&-� &� /�? #BC<�l ���� *� #<� /)� ��� �C�.�9 $��%��� �!" f�� 1�&�� �!" &� :��� q��� :��� �� #9�? $�%
/)� ��� +��� :0F. #�&-� ��%1.�&�� �!�" #����� :�0F3� f���
C�� /<u��, � ���, /��? �C�.�9 /)� ���� *� #��lA� 1+���� -��� $���%��" # �C.�9 $&� /� 1�!, �!�� +0 *-��* &� �!9� 6&!G
��< � #�A� /� 1�� /� #�-��� .:��� -�_' /)� ��� $��% ���" &� $$�-��� :���� +��<� �C��.�9&� ���% *� ���u� #)�!��> $�+��� /��?
/� 6C<l *� $�%�!, 1�!, -%�| � � �!" #M3�� &� ��'+0� -�B L��-��, *������ 6C<��l .��� ���) ����� /)� ���� `�*���� ����� $
$�-� :�� +<� #<0�&�0%6� �%�B � ,�� ��; '�+���3� ��� /�?-�Y�v3�� &� �C.�9 ���-" ��*��� �� ��" +�A�&-9 1#%�
+0 *-�* �� �&����4�� ��%1�!�, ������) �<�l ]^[./�� /�"!B ��� �G�!9#�&*�� +0� #)�!> #)� * &� $�% &� #��&*�� f�K)� 1$�
O�A� &� #��[ 6�-0�FB *�0) 6&!G `����J� /�? /<u�, *� #���%.:�� $&-. &�0@� 1�)&�� $-�l0� :@<, ����&
&�`�� $�% :0F�. +0�0FB �-�<8�� #����*&� / 0 * &� -04�/)� �� &� �!"! �C.�9 $�%1O%z' /��9-( 6&!G #��% .:���
:��!�� $�-�� -�u4 ���@0� w�� /F��!B /�� ��&�<�% ��% $�� �
� O0M' ��#� A��,X� �d-�k�...
49 ���������� ����� � ��
#�&*���%-�C.�9 /�4��-' �� .�)� �-? ��0� �% :�!�� /? �)� $�� � #��&*�� ����FB O%��? q�"! �%-�C.�9 #�&*�� /�K0�) &� ��%
/ �7% $&�-3.� 6�-0�FB ���FB O%�? #� /)�-05�l0' $�% .�!�,�08MB >!�- $�%/&�&�� /<u, *� ��I��� �� $-B!0� �? / �)-� w�+�70�d��� :�@<, 6�-�R� #�&-� 1O%z' +�� &� .:�� �, f�K)�
#��&-� #�8? 6&!�G /�� �; B /�9-5) 6&!G #9�? 6�0�7" �, � :��]bc[.
B +��� +�9&����� �����$�%&���l9 :��0F�" O��7��9� 16���@0� �� *���� -��� &���l9 1��� ��79 $����E��� $-;��, &!�� � $���%$�-���
:�!�� B $&��;5) $� ��# O��79� #��-4 `�J &� 6�@0� /�? ����O0' �� / *� #�IK) .:�� /�!� �!34 L��-, �-<8�� =0�� # 0�
/�!� �!34 L��-, `!���)�!? ��" /<u, $�% �& �C�.�9 $&�/<u, *� ��I��� �� O0�' #uE� $�% �-�? #� 0� =�0[MB +��� &� .��)�
&�' /��!� q0�, O,!' =�� 1+� 1Y " 1-3� 1`!> $�%-� � ��% /<u, �!)/�&!P O0' L��-, # 0�1/�9-( &�-� ��I��� �&! *� .��)�
:�7 /<u, *� ��I��� $�% #uE� $�%1����B #����� , /�� *��0) f�� q�0� #��� ,&�? 6�-�P) *� ��I���� ���< � ��08MB $�-� =0��
�� ��� $-� /� *�0) 1�%�-��@( $��% $�-�� 6��u0?-B /��% g*!� � :�� +<� ]e[.
��@0� L��-, ��&�<�% w��� *� ��I���� ��� �& �C�.�9 $�%!?&� -0K)* `� h�-? #���*&� ��, /��9-( -�P) &� $�%-0�� .�)�
6&�u� /��[ +�� &� ./��!� q0�, +�� 1Y �" 1-�3� 1`!�> :*� ��)�:�7 $�&�� !?&� -0K)* g& #��% :��� 1�-�&��? :�!;�� � )�
+0�AB &� Y�-B� �0�!B ��< � �% ��� ?&�? 6��0�-KB U���� -� �%# �-9 !?&� -0K)* g& &� � � .:�� /�� #���-4 �-�) /�? �!�,
�08MB :�� *� ��, /���? q"! /? :@0) /�@�� �� * # �% .�!, ��� ����� 1g& +��� *� ��I��� $�-� 1+�� -� C� $��% /�� �!�"!
!?&�� -�0K)* #���-4 # M -( -% $�-� �, �0@[B -( � V# &�? $&�!,� qu� /? �!, �0�!B $���" !,�]r[.
/ �)-� ��&�<�% #)���� #���&�� :�-��� :;" $�j/<u�, $��%��" ��% ��!��) ª��M� ��� �C�.�9 $&� *��� �-�<8�� ��� * 1$�
:@�* #<0�&�0% /���&� /<u�, #�30M �-�? #����*&� $�-�� .��)�*�� �!0� g& *� $� /���&� `�� :��7 �, ��I��� $*�9 $�%
��%-� �&�' :�� ��!� �? *� #,�) $�%�34 +�9-( -P) &� ��< � �,��� �!" �� /<u, L��-, #���*&� &� #��)�!B �:��� ���M $��%
4 $!�5�� $�&�� ��M 6��C>� $�&�� ��[) 1`� +�� &� � � #���- 1 Bayesian belief network (Hugin 2000) 2 Markov chain 3Asset management
# �-9 /��l (�%-�C.�9 #��-4)/�� &��? :��� *� /? �)!, &!�>���� # /���? #;"!B �!,]x[.
B �&! &���� 2��4 -��* &� �!9�� 6�@0�y$�-�� #����� `��0���EB �� $�7��"� 6�7��0;KB ���� 0�>� :��08��� :��0I0? ��-��0(
B��-�? #F�� ��&��<�% ���4 .:�� 6�@0� *� ��I���� ��� /�? ��)�/0u, :)! $*�� !�&�?1���" /<u, w� L��-, &� �C�.�9 $&�
-;� `�J -�P) &� $��%-� �&�' .�� %� &�-�� #����*&� �&! �& $&��-�6&�u� &!P +�� $�-� �, /�9-( q0�, -�3� 1`!�> 1+�� :*� �)�
���A�)� /�EAl &��;V -�% /�? :��� ��� ��l) #�&-� /K0�) ./�!�B 1�,�-0R���� ;"!B-<8�� -� #+�-��l0� /�!� +� � � �&�� ��@0� �
B�-0R �&�� �& .� �@% $�F� qB�- &� /�!� -3� `!> �� *� �F� �* #�&-� /� ��&�<�% �)� � �!� #%�y:0F. &� -R
/�!� �� #��-4 ��70 �� /<u, $�% +�7�0� g& *� ��I���� ��� ��%/�4��-' �� .�)� Y " �!) /� $�-� �& � �� � �% ���V 1���V) /��!�
6&��u� � �!� +�� /? �)��� &�-� #�&-� �&! ($��!9 +<l) ��)� :0F�. 12��4 :0F�. 1#"&��4 #84�� O,!' 1+� 1*��)� *� -�� .&�l9 ��70 Y " 1��" �!34 ���FB 1/l)�-B =�� 1/�!� -�@�
# 1=0[MB +�� U��� ��!B/��"0)�< #�&-� $@��� /��!� :�@<, ���� �08MB /�!� /� �!�- $�% �!�) #���*&� �& /�!� L��-, 1�%]{[.
O%z' 70) � &!l? &� #����*&� �-�<8�� #��&-� :;" #��%/)� �� L��-, #8?!B .:�� /�9-( 6&!G �C.�9 �� $�% /�� -9
/0I�EB L��-, �-<8�� #���*&� /�)�4 &� �-�<8�� !�M) �� $��%��-M� -��-� :�� /�4��-' �%]}[./�� #���&!�5�� #)��� #��� &!�P
/0IEB L��-, #���*&� /)�4 ��08MB g& U���� -�� �C.�9 $�% w��@�& :�-���� Y��)�N� ��� �-�:&�-3��.� $`�&���9k�-��� $
*�:4�����- ����% $����; J���0B�#:����� ��� /F����!B]X~ XX[./<u��, #(���� � OK ��� $�-��� #���� ���-5��@� ����" $���% $&�
�� /;"�! $�-� �C.�9 ��-�M� :�-��� /u���M �-�<�& ��� ��%�� w@�& *� ��I���� ��� �& �!�4 ���&!�5�� $ .:��� �-? /��&� �%
g& �0�EB $�% B �!�) +��B &�0F � V $-0(�+��� -��l0� ��0? #�� ,&�? 6�-P) *� ��I��� -� =0[MB �!� :��]X^[ #)��;�*& .
`�� /��&� /� ��&�<�%mIFHRA-WSS �-���& ��� :�;" $*��9 $��@0� �@�& �08MB �B OA� � �, $-;, �� $�%� /0I�EB 1+0
/� ��*!B ���@0� $& -�� �& �� #��&�] � �4��-' /V&���� 6&!G `�� #)��;�*& ��)�-] #��&-� ��-��� &� /�0 &� -;�, �-, �� 4 Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) 5 Integrated Fuzzy Hierarchical Risk Assessment Model For Water
Supply Systems
����� � ������������
� O0M' ��#� A��,X� �d-�k�...
50
/<u, -� # �u �34 :4&� w@�& �08MB $*�9 +�70� $�%d/���&� �& :�� �!�)]Xb Xc[.
/<u, *� 1-04� /%� � `!> &� O�)�� *� ��I��� $�-� +�70� $�%��@0� q��� &� ���� ,&�? �� *� Y�' ��, ��I���� -�u4 $��%1
[[M ��g& /<u, +�� g*! � $�-� #��% ��� *� ��I���� �� �% $��%��� /F���!B �!��"! .���)� /<u��, *� ��I����� /��� :u��@) +�7��0� ����%
g& �� �08MB -5�� ��%�:4&� � )� �% /<u�, 1�0��EB $�% $��% �!0�-(& 1#�! E #uE�-0H :�7 ��&�� *� .:��� ��; $�%
:��7 +��� /8�" $-�� �!�" :���J &� /<u�, /F��!B ���< � 1��%��� ��� #�� ,&�? 6�-P) q�� q0?-B ��< � 1s��) $�% $��%
/� :�!;� ��< � 1�!"! �%-� �&�' #)��&*& #>-�, 6����J�g& DC4-�) T8�A $�%-� �&�' +0� (��34 :�4&� � )� #��%
/�� :�«8� -�( :0F�. *� ��-�� #�') !�8" /�� & 6�u���M ��< � �� (:�8� /�� `!�8F *� ��0��&) q�[� /� & (`!8F ��,�� ]dj
dm[.:�� :0�%� 7��J /? -5�� /�<)1&� .:��� :�0F3� f�� QMu
���§&7� -B<l +� �0��EB 1�� ��� :�-�� /G-� &� �$-�0( :0F3� f�� L��-, &�:��g& . `�� $�-�� $����* $��% $*���
:0F3� f�� ��I��� �&! �%&�-� /�9-( �)� �� -�?� /? /���� � &� �%# $�" .�)-0(1:@A) /��� g& 6�����J� $&!��B -� # �u $�%
g& $-5�� g& .$*�9 =3 -� # �u $�% $�% :�@A) /����$!� $&!�B U��� $�&�� # $-B +��� +�-B����" /�8�" *� /? � ,��
g& /<u, 1�% :�7 *� -5�� #<� .� �@% +�70� $�% /<u, $�% $�%f-) �!" 1+�70� /<u�, +��� *� ��I���� $�-�� #u��� $��%&�79� ��%
:��]Xr[/<u, / 0 * &� =0[MB / 0l0' #�&-� �� . #�<� 1+�70� $�%-�;� *�f-) +� f-) �, #9-F $�%&�79� +0(!0% &�79�h+�� &� /? �!�
#(z� *� .:�� /�9-( &�-� ��I��� �&! O%z' f-�) +�� $�% &�7�9�# /� ��!B +��,�� 7�0) q�� #<09�-( L0M �� �-�&�? #(���
:���M �� q�� #,*! � /A@) #�4-� /�� :u�@) -���? $��%f-) *� -5�� $�%&�79�.�!�) &�,� /��l
�-�<8�� #����*&� /� 0 * &� /��9-( 6&!�G 6�F��3 -�?� &�/<u, &� :@<, ����& `���J� ���" $�% �� �!� 1�C�.�9 $&�
B�/� &�_(-0R /��9-5) &�-�� #��&-� �&!� � �" 6&!G �&!� &� .��)� q0���� ������ �%-�C��.�9 &� :��@<, `�����J� *���� $���% $�
�� �% &� ? &� #<0�&�0% :��!�� #���*&� ��< � �B �)!, � $�� �/� �%-�C.�9 #�&*�� ���K�� q��� #B&!�G �!�, =�0[MB &� /�?
/<u, &� �, -?t $���7 *� ��I��� �� -.�J $�-<�& �� +�70� $�% 1 Integrated Fault Tree-Bayesian Network Hierarchical Risk
Assessment (IFTBNHRA) 2 Hugin Lite V.7.8
q��� �� /�� #�9-F *� Y�' 1/���[ +��� &� .:��� ��, /��4��-'q0�� /<u, &� +<� $�% ���" $�% �C�.�9 $&� +��� �� �!�q0�� /<u, #9-F 70) �% /u��M $�-� $��; l0' `� 1+�70� $�%
#8G� f�( &�;V q��� &� :@<, `���J���" ��� $&� �&!� $��% :M�G 1+�7�0� /<u�, g*!� � 1*�0) ���� g*!� � `�� #K ��
�� #"-4 :9��&� /<u�, *� #�lA� $�%-�C�.�9 ��, /���&���" /[3 �C.�9 $&�b�/�"!B ��� ��-�;B -;�, �C.�9 �
/� �� &� :�@<, `���J� ��70 /�� 1��% :��!�� q��� &!�> $�� �.�)�,
�#��%69 &'( �#�#��/� e>2 $G�: (� gG> ��� 0lz� �('�
/<u, �%$��" &�$/� �C.�9 �B :�MB :��! ��� ����� &!�>�-0R.�)&�� &�-� #�@�* #��0�0,!0� 1#��0�0, 1#��709 � �!� �+�/�)!(
�B����B!] &� :���� +���� 6�-0R q0���� Q����� 6��� *�&� ���� 6�� OA� .�)!, /�u, T8�A $�%»q0��« �&#��!B /�� 6&!�G -��*
T�-FB �!�)]b[:»-9 =3 U��� -��B *� $&��;5) � ���!�"! q0��� 16��@0�
# �)�!B B Q����B �-]&��] :�08��� -�� *��K -0H #I -0R�6��@0�>!�- /�, ��+��� Q���� 6�� *�&� &� :�� +�� �B /�)!(�6�-0R
!,�«.�; :@<, +�-B q0�� �% # �& +<� $�% -�( � &� ��!�B:@<, *�� $�% :@<, $� /��� #<0�&�0% $�% .�!�) $� �
���/ X�G: (M<� ��/� ���" /<u, &� :@<, �!) -% w��709 /�� /�? �C�.�9 $&�
/<u, ��@0� $�7"� ����4��*�� :@<, 1�&�� #5�@� �C�>� $�# �!,q0�� *� #,�) :@<, �!) +�� . -�* $�%:��:X�O���-9j#<0)�< )�:(#<�709 ��-9 *� &!�P �#�0)��� O��1
OA� #��-4 �%#�L0M *� � �, -B�-� � +�� .:�� /�!� #84�� v3 /�!� &�!�� $-�* O��79� Q��� Q���� q��� �) &�0@� L��-, &�
-AB/�!� q� �%#�!,]b[.^�#(�&!4k:#(�&!4 *� :�� 6&�u� L0�M ��� �� �� O ]�
&� /] O9�->� *��)� ���� -00�B �� /K0�) ��G�J &!��7 ��� $-0(# �!, B Q��� ���� ��] ��� *��� *� #�lA� �-?&��? -� #I -0R
��@0� # �!,/<u, &� ��I��� �&! v��E +0� *� . ��" $�% $&�/� 1�C.�9 &!> ���0�� :�@�*� 1+���) #)��0�� v���E `!�F
3 Erosion 4 Corrosion
� O0M' ��#� A��,X� �d-�k�...
51 ���������� ����� � ��
(6C ��!9) 6�789 (���V ��)&�� &�-�� #(�&!�4 �-�F &� ]b[/�!� �&! &� /�u�� . /�� /��@� 7�0) #�! �E ��!� Y �" *� $��%
# #30M L��-, �& #(�&!�4 .�!�) �%�l �& q0�� �!) +�� ��!B# 84�� #(�&!4 /��� � /� ��!B .�!�) �0@[B #"&�4 #(�&!4 #
�C.�9 &� �)&!4 � �!� -R� &� #84�� #(�&!4/���0�� /�� z�� ���0�!BH2S��B����� #"&���4 #(�&!��4 �%-�C��.�9 &� -��R� &�
/�!� D�->� # 0 *-�* �� 2�4 #(�)&!4 # $& �% .�%� b��<��, -��00�Bd/���!� &� ���; B q0���� +���� :���3[ v3��� $���%
D�3F)� -�_'��!�F )/�!� � )� (#�! E ��! Y " *� $��%PVC .:�� �-3 ��� /�3��& &� �-��* /��!� 1q8�G v���E Y �" *� $��%
�3[ v3� ��, �] &�0@� 6�-00�B1#�ll] ��@u)� �� O B Q���/K0�)&� �, *�K -0H 2-B �� &�!�� #(�&!4 � �G�J �%#!�,�
]b[.c�2-B #(�&!4hg7�& /�!� #5�@<, 1#�,C� ��) /�!� &�!��
��,j2-B :(/�!� ��!��F #(�&!�4 /��!� &� D��3F)�-0H $��% -�_�'# �%�l 2-B � �, /? �!, /�3[) #�.-� 1#�!> $�% .:��� $�
70) /�!� #5�@�, *� &!P ��, ��" O�A� ��%*� #� /��!� &�!��� /�� /��!� :� �[ �� �] +�9& :�� *� 1/�!� &�!�� g7�& *� &!P
%*�� :@<, /8J- +�-B���, /? :�� /�!� +�@�, �%&� �-� $�:��]b[.
�G�<'(��� X�G: (0��" /<u, &� :@<, �!) -% /� ���K�� q�"! /�? �C�.�9 $&�
/� �C.�9 ���-" &� �<l O%��? ��� ����-" �-�) O��7�9� �0��/�!� :09-| # /�I( #<0�&�0% :@<, 1�!, �!,.��&�<�% ��%
O%�? �� �.�[B O��79� *� #,�) �& (#<0�&�0%) $�-<8�� :@<,#�� :��09-| ��� )��]c[/<u��, &� #<0�&���0% :��@<, �!��� . $���%
*�� :@<, /� :u@) �C.�9 `!�F $� q0�� .:�� -B /�? #���%6&�u� 1� �@% :@<, �!) +�� �l :*� �)�
X��� f�� $� �k+�� &� -P) �&! q0�� : $�&�!� � ��, :�@��� f�� � )� /��!� &�!��� &� $�� � #� 6���EB� ��% f��� .�!�,
�� /� $� � �� t!�I) �� �-0� /� /<u, *� �C.�9 :l) 6&!G# *-� /<u, �4�� /� 2�4 # 0 *-�* ��4�� /� 2�4 t!I) /? � ?
��%�!4 �C�.�9 ����-" -0�@ &� #5�9-( $�-� #8 �� �!4 /<u,0 a�% .�!� ��&!�� *� #� 0 *-�* �� t!�I) +1/��!� &� �!�"! $��%
-IJ ��F�� O��79� �� ��K�� q"! -�C�.�9 /�)�� &� �!"! $�%# +�9& :�� *� /� -K 70) �-0� /� /<u, *� �C.�9 :l) .�!,
1 Deformation 2 Cracking 3 Collapse 4 Leakage
/)��7�& # /�!� D�->� 2�4 $�% �!,:l) �%t!I) +�� . +�<� ��%/� :�� -IJ ��K�� &� #���% &� /�? �!�, -�K /��!� D�-�>� 2��4
:4�� � )� #��%����& �� ��, �-�% 6&!G ��� /�7�* 1�%*��+0 * # g7�� :@l) ��K�� q"! �)�!B ���� $�% /"!B�!, ]c[.
/��� #5���@� `� /��8% &� 1�-��0� /��� /<u��, *� �C��.�9 :��l) �&�� #� 0 *-�* �� v3� /� :u@) /�u, #)�� :0F.]b[�-��* .
�/�� �C�.�9 :�l) ���< � 1�,�� # 0 *-�* �� v3� -�* /<u, -( +��� -�5 �&���) �!" /<u, �-0� /��!� ��4�� �C�.�9 &��l9 /�?
/�)/��!� n&��4 �� &��l9 *� O0�� (/��!� ��3[ v3�� ��,-' �0�� �� v3�� 7�0) /<u�, ��4�� /�� #� 0 *-�* �� t!�I) �&! &� .�,��
+00FB � �� # 0 *-�* .:�� � ? ^�-(#5�9m����-" -0�@ &� #�5�9-( :�C�.�9 ���-" -0@ &�
/B -R� &� :�� +<� �( 2�4 # 0l) 6��!�& 1/�!� T? &� $�B *� #,�) 6��!�& 1�-V��� -0R #B�I�!� 6��!�& 1# 0 *-�* $�%
f-" ��4�� /�� ��%�0( /l�& t!I) �,& 1-�C.�9 �4�� #5�9-( ��!�) ��@ �& -�C.�9 /����* L��!B -�C.�9 -0@ ��%
/l�& .�!, ��K�� 1� ��@% #����� ����4&� $�&�� /�? #[>�� &� �%# �<l ��K�� � 7�0) :4&� �!) /�u��) � ?y*� q�8H� (:��� -R
#� ��@0� �&� /�!� �!4 �� 6��EB� &� �!"! �!0� /�? �)!�,/�!� 6��EB� *� /l�& �& # ��IB� -�l0� �% ��� � .���9� ����FB +��-
B #8 �� 1�!"! 6��EB��/�� /�"!B ��� .:��� / 0 * +�� &� &�_(-0R+�� #5�9-( #4-� /? /�� #5�9-( � )� �% #"&��4 ��@" �& ��0��
�!��B 1���0� ��� )� )-��0H/��� ( ���� #��EAl ����uB&� `!���F &!��>#(z� #30M 6�0G!E4 #�J �� �C.�9 /<u, 1�C.�9 $�%
+���? q"! �&��) ��08MB :�� #� ��% +�9-�( -�P) &� *� 1�!�,�� /� � � .:�� �, -P 9-G �% :J��@ :F�� -�(� 1/�)!�) ��!� �
�� %-9 �� )� #8 �!�� 1��,�� §&7�� #9��? *���)� /�� �08MB �&! ?-�l ��# /[3 -% ��� #���*&� �&! �)�!B!,1+��� -� C� .�/���* :�@� &� �% �? :�-� �� /�!� L4 *� #��% # ��" &� �)!�,
��@0� /�� 1��%&� �C.�9 $�% /����* 1#M3�� ���)�& �& ��0��# ��@0� �&� $-�l0� :�-� /�u�� .�!, ��%&� ���@0� $��� $�%
/���* 1g&�� ����& f�5 % &� #� 2�' ��@0� v3� *� �& �% �� � �� ?/���* :�� +<� §&7� $�% ����) ��@0� �&� �& $-B]Xx[.
I#$G�: $� ��'(' �G�<'(��� (�� 34�* � /�� :��� +�<� #J�-> ��J *� O0� #<0�&�0% &�� O��79� ��0��
g&���� *���K -0H 6���F��l)� 1�����, $���%-��0H &� .���%� $&��@0� �C.�9 /<u, 1�7K $�% �C.�9 ���-" $�-� #5)�4 $�%
5 Blockage
����� � ������������
� O0M' ��#� A��,X� �d-�k�...
52
8'�2�#:@<, ����& `���J� /u��M &� -R! � �!� X�G: p)�$v)�� ��/�X�G: ���4'( 8�>��� (� �Q) F�)P
:@<, *�� $�
2-B(�&!4 /��!� &�!��� g7�& 1##5�@<,
#� 0 *-�* �� v3�� 1(/��!� -�3� `!>) /�!� ��F�� 1/�!� Y " 1/�!� +�*$���� w�09�-B ��7�0 1(+0 * v3� *� -�C.�9 /8G�9) /�!� =�� 1(�& �!)) -�C.�9 v3�
/�!� O���-9 #(�&!4 �C.�9 ���-" :�-� 1/�!� Y " 1/�!� +�&�) $��B�? :�|�IJ 1#"&��4 O?& O,!' �!) 1
/�!� �&! ($��!9 # %� $�%
�3[ v3� �<, -00�B /8�G�9) /��!� =��� 1(�& �!)) -�C.�9 v3� $��� w09�-B ��70 1/�!� -3� 1/�!� Y " 1/�!� +�(+0 * v3� *� -�C.�9
:@<,#<0�&�0%
f����� �$6��EB� ���FB 1/�!� Y " 1(/<u, +�) /�!� +�# 0 *-�* �� v3� 1
&� #5�9-(-0��������@
���-"
����0�� /���� #���5�9-(6��!�&
�C.�9 :�-� 1/�!� -3� 1/�!� Y " 1/�!� +�(�%&� �� �7K ) /<u, �!) 1
/l�& #5�9-( �� =0�� /l�& $�&��) ���4&� �!) 1/�!� D�->� ���4&� ���FB=��� 1/��!� Y " 1/�!� +� 1(#M3�
6��EB� ���FB 1/�!� -3� 1/�!�*.�!� �%�!4 &�_(-0R�B 1�,�� -�C.�9 v3� *� -B��� # 0 *-�* �� v3� /? #B&!G &�
#�) #J�-> #M3� �� � � �!, O�A� *� #M3�� $��% �� )� #���%f�� g!��'&� 6����EB� 1���%& `���EB� ���� #)!)����-0H #��l<%*
�C.�9 /<u, �� �>�[B &� /<u, /���!4�) ���@0� �&� #M3� $�%# ?-�l 6��EB� ���FB /V-% +0 a�% .�)!,���& 1�!, -�l0�
�C.�9 # -�l0� 70) #M3� $�% ] �!,dp.[
�#�#��/� (� �Q� F�)P $G�: (� �)2) ��� :@<, ��!)� *� w� -% �&! &� �%q0�� #� ��, -?t $�% ��!�B
/? �!�) ��0� �& #��%-� �&�' � �!�/���� /80 :�@<, `���J� �%/� .�!, �* +0�AB �&! -% &� #5��@�� :@<, ��K�� `�� ��! �
q�"! +0���' ����-" :�-�� +0� a�% .�&�� /��!� +�� /�� $���*/B l)# -�C.�9 -0@ &� 6��!�& -�l0� # 0 � � �!� .�!, -�P) &
:��@<, $�-��� ���, /���9-( *���� $���% /��"!B ���� #<0�&���0% $�/� /��� `�" &� 1�u� OA� &� �, /��&� $� �X��, �&� &� .��)�
��� /�� #��-��� ���< � 1`��" +�� &� �!"! � �!� +��B $��%.:�� �, /�9-( -P) &� 70) />!�-
�#�#$G�: � �= g4*�� ��� +�7��0� /<u��,d+0��� #B������J� L����& ����0� $�-��� #��<09�-( #����
/<u�, .:��� �%-0�� 6�����J� *� ��I���� $�� u -�� +�7�0� $��%�, ��� /F�!B 70� $&!�B #>-, /�� 7�0� $&!�B .�)� -��* 6&!�G
:�� �, ��0�]X{[:-(�EF/�)!( /�� � �,�� �-I ����& � /�? $�P(E)≠0
P(F)≠0/3��& �5)� 1d/�# :�� ��� )d(
)F(P)E(P)E/F(P)F/E(P =
1 Bayesian Network (BN)
/<u, 1+�70� /<u, w� -( *� $� h����? �� /? :�� �% j�0[��@ $��%/� �, �E� �% # ��� :u@) `���J� ���B w� -( -% /� �)� .�!,
/��@@( #9��EB -0�� w� -5)�0� -( w� ����FB ��� :0F�. $��% ����� � )� ) ��M d�Bo6&�u� �� $�%»v0MG «»L�8H (« ���
#�!( ��*!B ��) /��!0' #9��EB -0�� w�k�� � �� )� ��KJ ��� ���? .:�� ($�0�!B �C.�9 -�( +0� $�% ���l) ��% L���& �� %�
-( +0� #«8� ����? :�;" � �@% �% :��� /�� :�8� *� &�!��% ��%`!8F ) :�� (��)*-9) ��� 1`!�8F /�� ���� -�( 1:�8� -0�� /�
# �C>� .(�!, � /� �E� �% /� ���? w� L�!B /? (-0�� ) -(�, `�� w� 1�)�m# &��!��) w�� 1+�7�0� /<u�, w� &��!�) .� �!(
/[8J-0H :;" $� #�) #�0[�@ -0@ �0% # F� :�� &�� :9�� ��!B w� &� �� ����' �-, /? $���� �0�% -�( w�� -�(� .��,�� -(
w�� -�( 1(��,�u) �� :�� /� #)��? �0% ��<0' # F�) �,�� /�,��)$*- `���J� `�"o��,�� /��,�� ���� -( w� -(� .:,�� �%�!4
-�( 1(��,�� �� :��� /�� ����? �� V ��� w� # F�)`��" $�&��#>-, `���J�p#>-, `���J� .:��1B��( -� -( w� #����J� -0R -
�& /<u, &� �-I /�:��� #� .��%� /<u�, w�� :4��� *� Y�'#�� ��� �& $�-��� �� *� ��!��B -��( &� #B��%���l $���% /��? #����%
���)&�� f!�8F sA��l :0F�.1�� U����� -�� �!���) ��I������ U��� -� /? �& #B����J� -( &� �% -5�� $�% /�� :��� #� �� ��1
�!�) :9��&�]X}[.
2 Node 3 Link 4 Gaussian Distribution 5 Edge 6 Marginal Probability Table 7 Conditional Probability Table (CPT)
� O0M' ��#� A��,X� �d-�k�...
53 ���������� ����� � ��
�; f!;I w� /<u�, &� #>-�, `C[���� f!�;I 1+�7�0� $��% -0�� � .:��AB# �0 �) #>-, �[�@ -�0�� ��(-% 1�)!,
C$�%-0�� /�AB-�0�� &���[ �,�� /�@��C1��,�� f!�8F -0�� �&! &� 6��C>� �!"B�0�% 1&� #9��.� 6���C>� /�)!(
-0�� �&! A# �& f!;I +�� .�%�) /��&� B/�� ��! /�3��& 6&!�Gh�!�) ��0�
)h(P(AB,C) = P(AC)
/�!�K f�!B #B����J� ��*!B $�%-0�� *� $�1 2, ,... nx x x����� ��!� �[�@ �-9 �G�J *� 1�% #>-�, 6�����J� ��*!B �-.
�� /� �% # :�� ���
)j(∏=
π=n
1iiin21 ))x(x(P)x,...x,x(P
/? P(x1, x2, …xn)�[ f�!B `���J�&� �%-0�� )x( iπ-���[ �8� /�!�K #�? xi.:��
*� $����FB #>-�, `����J� /u���M /�� /�? :��� -�?t /� f*� U��� -� �%-0�� 1+�7�0� /<u�, &� ��%-0�� -���� �!"! 6��C>�
(n�� ���) ��u ���d# /�I( �!�"! 6��C>� # ��B /? #)� * .�!,-( �&! &� 1� ,�� -P) �&! $�%-0�� �� -0�� ���"� �� ��� $�%
/u���M #>-�, 6�����J� L���& U���� -� :�� ��� ��u ���# �� ����)*-9 6��C>� -(� � � .�!, ��!�) ������ 1��,�� �!�"! ��%
���? -0@ DC4-� �& ��u ��� �0a0' &�? ��� f�K)� �% ��%�!4 -�B O0�' /�? 7�0� $&!��B �-�&��? *� &!P +�� $�-� .�!� 1��, ���0� -�B
# ��I��� �!, ]X}[.
I#I#X�G: 8�>��� $�/�6 ���� ����h�f 8� (��@�/ :��;" ���, /����&� g& #��8? ���&!��5�� :��@<, `�����J� /u����M
�<�, &� +�70� /<u, *� ��I��� �� �%-�C.�9X.:��� ��, �&����% #� �%�l ���&!5�� +�� &� /? /)!( *� $��; �l0' `�� 1�!�,
�� � #8? f�( &�;V $�& $*�� 1+�7�0� /<u�, g*!� � 1`� $�%:MG # �0<lB `� #"-4 :9��&� `� #K � !,.�
#8���@ *� #<� /<u�, �&!� &� /�? �-�3 +�7�0� $��% 1:��� /��� +�-�;� ��A�)� :��J +0� *� $� � &� .:��� +<� T8�A $�%
#� �& -� �&�' -% +�70� /<u, w� T�8�A :���J +��� V /�� ��!�B/��� :���J +�� q0?-B *� /? �!�) $� � T�8�A $��%1/<u�, #���%
# �G�J �! � &�0@� �B :�MB 7�0) ��G�J �����) �!,�R&�-�� -0 1 Inference
# ��&��<�% #)&��<�!? L�!B /? #E4�, *� =0[MB +�� &� .�-0(�, #9-F /��� $�-� 1$�� � #� ��I���� *� s4��, +��� /�? �!�,
/3��& =�->k/�# :�� ���]^~[
)k()f(P
)f(P)cf(P)x(D
−=
/?D(x) 1�, #9-F s4�,)cf(P/�� /��!� :@<, `���J� 1¡�4 #(z� /��� w� +�,�� �-,c)/��� ���% /�� �!��- $��%
�%-� �&�' P(f) ��? &� :�@<, �-��@( `����J� ��! � :MB 70) 1/? :�� /<u,)cf(P/3��& =�-> *�m/u��M # !,�
)m())f(P1)(nfc(P)f(P)fc(P
)f(P)fc(P)c/f(P
−+=
/?)fc(P1¡��4 #(z� /��� w� �%�l `���J�c$& -��/�!� w� ����J /? :�� #��% �, :@<, &�V� &�� /�3��& *� �)�o
# /u��M .�!,)nfc(P1¡��4 #(z� /��� w� �%�l `���J�c/�!� $& -� ��l) :@<, &�V� /? :�� #��% *� ��I���� ��� ��)�
/3��&p/�# :�� ���
)o(=)fc(P
)p(=)nfc(P
) /<u�, ��? &� �-�@( `���J�P(f) /�3��& *� 7�0) (�/�� :���# :���
)�(=)P(f)(
!#��%69 C4��� ' ��() $=<�� ��-�;B $�I�� /� /[3 *� #lA� 1O%z' +�� &� /�� ��!� � /�F��3
1���, ����A�)� /��0J�) &� .:���� ���, ����A�)� $�&!�� /<u��, ���% $��" &� ��0�� /�? #�>�9 (�l0() -E) 1����-0 � /[3 �C.�9 $
�!" ��A�)� +����� �% ��!�J $g&�7�( ��% &� $-� !���� $�!" 1=>� +����� �%$GIS �! B �!" �Y " +� &� -�l0
�%-�C.�9 .:�� �!� +�70� /<u, g*! � $�-� /<u�, ���" &� $/� ��-;B �C.�9 &!> 8?#/�6&!G Y " .:�� �, #J�-> �7K
"@O@ ��(F�P�� �:�3Q�c�2��:� 6�R)
ST"@O@ ��(F�P�2��:U�� � 6�R)i
"@O@ ��(F�P�� �:�3Q�c��� ��S7����V
ST"@O@ ��(F�P�����S7����U�� � 6�R) V
"@O@ ST ��(F��PU�� � 6�R) V� S7��� ����i
"@O@ ST ��(F�PU�� �i
����� � ������������
� O0M' ��#� A��,X� �d-�k�...
54
FG:�#+�70� /<u, *� ��I��� �� �C.�9 /<u, :@<, ����& `���J� /u��M `� ���&!5��
�&�) U����� U���W X��Y���
OWO Z��Y ��P��[�
\�0F��)(�P��[� ��: �F]�����
6 $�?*�
�� ����: �� � �P�����A ,�P��(F ^����� �� � U� ���;��
��(�P�O) ��) �P 6 $�� �� ��#��� �: U� �?*�6 $ ��P�?*�
�W��; 6����
U�
"�:
��;
�� 2O� ���": "(@�_ �O `a��� "R0) ": \O:� ��P
�W��; 6���� � ��� L�O! U�
UO07 S:�7 U� ��!
b6��
c��dF�� ��*:�� "�� � ": �P� 2O����0�@�T ��P
6 $�?*�
"R0) L�O!
����:
>�W�� ���!��! � ��� �O ��P�� ����� �P
�� �����A e@�7��O "(@�_ "R0) ��P
"�� "f�����*: ": "WOF �: �����A �P ���: Z��Y ��P
�� �����AOWO ��P
"�� ����+: �����*) � �:��T ���: �����A �P ��*:
����: "R0)
": "WOF �: "&O:� ����: "R0) ���;�� "�@�� ����&
�P�����A ��: �@O�( � 6�� g:���
�� �� ��#��� �:) "R0) ����( ���(F � ���;�� L�O!-
(2O����0�@�T ��P
�� �� ��#��� �: "R0) ��P�����A L�O!�) OWO ��P���P
(2O����0�@�T
"R0) ����( � ���;�� ": 60� ��!
b�� OW� 2�*��&� ����:
"�:
��;
��!����
�����P�U�
���3Q�� S�) ���P"@O@ ��P�P��:a���) �P�3Q�� ,(��P
�3Q�� ��*'�P � `a��� ���$Oh; ,�R�iO@����POfi ��P
�: "T "R0) �O���� �� ��#��� ��PGIS ,j�O� ���a&� ,
L���3 � �� ���P�- ,2���*)��T �: "0��h ,���O���� ��P
"�0)>�W �R�@����P ����� ���! .� O)
"�� "f���� ���� ��P�����A ���: ��*:
6�P� �: ��P�����A "��W �� U� �W��;
":) � ��: � ���"�� " O� 2�O*���*: �����A
�� ��� ": "WOF �: "@O@ �_7 � OWO ��P
"@O@ "�� "� ": 2�3�0; ���k ,cT �_7 �: ��P
"@O@"@O@ � g�O� �_7 �: ��P (��� �_7 �: ��P
����� U����� �: �lO S�O� ": "WOF �:
e��! �O � 6�R)Z��Y ��P
�: �P��[� �@O�( � 6�� g:��� �����
m������F��P�- ��P �� ��#��� �:
c���O�@� ��PPC �NPC
� O0M' ��#� A��,X� �d-�k�...
55 ���������� ����� � ��
��B���� -E) $!? &� �!"! $�%-�C.�9 :��� ���0�� :�@�*����-���!�/�%�Bk���70) `� #M ��[) &� � � .��&�+��� *� $��
*� /0J�)/�!� �%$8'#-��� $�&�� /�? �, ��I��� 70) #�C.�9 +80B� *� 70) #�>�9 ����-0 � /[3 &� .� �@% $-��?/�!� �%Y �" ��� $
8'#+0�� �����-0 � /<u, &� �%-�C.�9 -�� .:�� �, ��I��� +80B� X~ �BXe+0� #�>�9 /<u, &� `��e�BX~:�� `���� v3� .
/[3 �? &� # 0 *-�*j&�0@��'+0� �C�.�9 /<u�, v3�� *� -�B:��.��J # 0 *-�* �� v3�d�� �&�� &�-�� +0� * v3� $-�
*� /�[3 +�� &� /�,_( &� :;" +�� *� ��V ��% ��I���� #�_�" $# �,/� �&�-;, -E) $!? =>� &� /�u�� . ��!�� #4C5 �� ��0��
*� ��I���� ���< � 1�� ��? $-�_'t!I) +0 * �!) ��V ��% _�" $#�#����� &�0�@� =>� +�� /<u, �_� :�� /�,��) �!" /�� 6&!�G
IEB/0/)�4 #8M $�%:�� �!�.
!#�#���� ��'(' ���/ 8� ��� ��� 1`� f�( &� �� /�� #��-��� ���< � /? *�0) �&! $�% �%�-�9 ��%
�!�1��" �)�, $&� `�")X(�� �. . &� :�-�� �� �� �&!� &� *� 1/� 0 * +�� &� �, :uR ��� �!" f�� /� /"!B �� �C.�9 /<u,
/0u, ���" /<u�, #<0�&��0% $*��� *� ��I���� ��� �C�.�9 $&�f-) &�79�SewerCAD v.5.5 ��08MB f��K)� $�-� .:�� �, ��I���
1#<0�&�0% U���� -� �C.�9 /)�-� �0�!B &� ��-�;B � ��" �-�> -��-� 1-P) �&! /[3Lpcddd�k :�� �, /�9-( -P) &�]^X[.
��" *� Y' ��� $&� /���&� s4��, U���� -�� 1*�0) �&! $�%# ��&�<�% #)&�<�!? L�!B �, /��� :;" ��!B w�� -�% $�� �
s0A�lB /�� *��0) /�? +�7�0� /<u�, &� ��I���� �&! $�%-� �&�' *�/��� +�-�;� �!�) #> �& -�* �J�- 1�,�� /�,�� +<� $� �]Xc[:
d���� /�� /�"!B ��� f�( +0�� &� ��� ��5��' &� �!�"! $��% $��% 1����(-u4 6�-��P) *� ��I����� ���� ���u� /��8J- &� ���, ��� /F���!B
/��� $� � q�� -P) /� /? #��% � �@% -B1# ��A�)� .�)!, h�/��� *� w� -% $�-� #�(z�) �% s4��, (��%D(x) /�� �& :���
+05)�0 �� Y�� �&� /��� +0� $-0( s4��, +��� +05)��0 1��%/��� �? $�-� # /u��M $� � !,�)x(D��C� &� /��!� -�� $�-�
-����[ /���� � +�9-( -P) &� :��J1D1(x) D2(x) :���J &� -���[ /��� /� +�9-( -P) &�1D1(x)1D2(x) D3(x) �, /u��M
+05)�0 # $-0( .�!, j�/� *� Y' -���[ ��&� :��)x(D/��� :��J -% $�-� 1$� �
/��� +�-�;� /? :�� #���J $� �§&7� -B�+&��[ )x(D/�K0�) �&.�%�
1 Litter per capita per day
-?t g& *� ��I��� &� *� #��� ,&�? 6���� *� ��I��� 1�, .:��� &��&!4-� #���� :0�%� `��"h/���� /�K0�) f��K)� $�� �
�& +�7�0� /<u�, &� ��I���� �&!� $�& $��%-� �&�' $�-�� /�9-(# ��l) 1-� �&��' -�% f��) ����[ &� 1`��" +��� &� +0� a�% .�%�
�� /� �!�- -( $�-� +�70� /<u, &� /? #)�! � ��% /�� #� &��? 1�&.:�� �, -?t
8'�2�#/��� +�70� /<u, $�%-� �&�' $� � (F�P) ���(�f ;��8'� $�/�;'� $�/�;)/ $�/�
(`��) /�!� +�X~�eXe�X~c~�Xe/�!� Y "���0� :@�*�8'#+80B�) /�!� -3�mm(^^e�^~~^e~^e~>
) /�!� =��m(e/^�x/X)e/b�e/^(e/b≥
�& �!) �& ���9 ����04 /V!?(#8M ) #�-9
�& -��� �%
6��EB� ���FBe�XX~�r^b�XX���4&� ���FBx≤x>
���4&� /l�& =��#M3�=0��) :�-�m/s(X<]e/X�X[e/X>
��� ��? ����FB /�� /"!B �� 1`� *� f�( +�� ����' &� �&!� $��% -����-� ��I�����xe^ ����J 1e~~ w����7)) ���x~$�-��� 1(���G&�
��� /�0[� `�� g*!� � �!0��-u0��? #� F� 1��%^e^ $�-�� ���:MG +��� $�-�� .�� �9-( &�-�� ��I���� �&!� #K � ��� /�? $��%:MG ��� $-� $�-� #�!4 � ���) 1�, ��A�)� #K � �!"! $�%
�� ��A�)� 1�,�� #9��EB ����� �0�!B *� ��I��� �� �%.:9-( f�K)�
!#�#g4*�� $G�: &�)� *� +�7��0� /<u��, $�-��"� g*!�� � 1����K�� $�-��� 1=��0[MB +���� &�
f-) #�&-� /� /"!B �� .�, ��I��� +0(!0% &�79� /��9-( 6&!�G $��%�� ��� �!� /�� 0 * &�yq0���� �&!�� &� :��@<, `�����J� -��� -R $���%
�<�, =���3 +�7�0� /<u, &��4�� 1-u4 6�-P) T8�A h��K�� �.�,/� #5�9-( 1�<, +�� &� " -�( ��� 6��!��& ��0��Blockage "
/� #5�9-( " -�( ��� /�l�& t!�I) �0��Root .:��� ��, ��� ���l) "-��( " $���%Structural" 1"Hydraulical" "P(Failure) /��� 7��0) "
*�� :@<, $�-� q0B-B :@<, `���J� #<0�&�0% :@<, 1$� .�)�, /�9-( -P) &� (��@0� #8? :@<,)
.�!�, ��� g*! � /<u, ���� 1/<u, /0�� $&��F +00FB *� Y' g*!� � &��4��� g*!� � /�8J- � � ��, 1+�70� /<u, g*! � $��%-0�� +0�0FB $�� F /�� /<u, &��4�� g*! � .:�� �%-� �&�'
�� �[�@ /�@����uB&� +�9 /�? :�� #��%-0�� +0� +<� $�%
����� � ������������
� O0M' ��#� A��,X� �d-�k�...
56
�� #�!8F :8� L��& ��� U��� -� �% ���) #B��%��l $�% $��% (�!0����-u0��?������ A��lB0s���&!��5�� .:���� $���%PC NPC *�
D-F ���&!5�� +�-B ] � �@% / 0 * +�� &� ��I��� �&! $�%X}.[g& #8? ���PC /�u� $-� w� ��&� :��6&� #5��@�� $�%
�! *� *� ��I��� �� #5�@�� f�� �� #>-�, `C[���� $&�� � $��% /�? $-�0�� :�I" -�% $�-�� /? :�� /<u, &� -0�� :I" -% $�-�
�� +0�� #>-�, `C[��� #5��@�� $�&��) ��,�� /��,��) �!�" ��% #� /��9-( -�P) &� #>��uB&� ���? w� 1(� ,�� #>-, Y��� .�!�,
w� /� /? #��%-0@ # #;� -( #��&-� ��, #����� , 1�)!�,# �0% /? �!, /[8J /)!( .��,�u) /<u�, &��4�� &� $� *� ��I���� ���
`C[��� /� #>-, $�% :;" 1� � :�� ���? $�% # +00FB �% �!, ./�<) ���&!5�� �&! &� /? $�PC �-�0( &�-�� /�"!B �&! ����1f���
/��% +00FB &� ���&!5�� +�� #��)�!B :�;" ����? $��% =��-> *� ��%��� ����? *� $�����FB +��-��� � :��� �!�"! $��% /�� ��% 6&!��G
:;" #9��EB #� #�%� #� .�)!�, *� �<�l +��� ��J $�-�� ��!�B ���&!5��NPC &� -u4 �� � �FB �� ���&!5�� 1�� &� /? �!�) ��I���
���? �&! # �0�EB sAl �) $�% .�-0( � -u4 �-9 /? #B&!G &� :�8� L���& /<u, /0�� $&��F *
&��4�� g*! � /� $*�0) 1�,�� /�,�� �� 0�>� �%-� �&�' +0� #�!8F /��� �!��u) /<u��, #�� �0[���@ &!��> g*!�� � /��8J- �&� ���)�!B
+�70� /<u, $�%-� �&�' .�!, #>-��, `�����J� `����" n�-A����� 1`��� $���%-� �&�' g*!�� �
/<u�, &� �!�"! T8�A $�%-0�� ��� *� ��I���� ��� �!�"! $��%
��� *� ��%-� �&�' g*! � $�-� .:�� f��( &� /�? �!0���-u0��? $��% ��, ���A�)� �u� #� ��I���� 1��)� ��� +��� .�!�, +0�� ���uB&� ��%
# ��l) �& /<u, &� :@<, ��!)� �!� T8�A $�%-0�� ��%�&� �%-� �&�' g*! � �� +�70� /<u, ���J� ���uB&� ���B���� �0� #�+
0�� +���� �& �%-�/#� :�� .�&� O%z�' +��� &� g*!� � $�-�� ���&!5�� *� �%-� �&�'EMdL��!B g& +��� .:��� ��, ��I����
�7��&�h:��� ��, ��� /F�!B]^^[T�3F $&�7��� g& +��� . +0�AB $�-����� � �, T8�A ���@ &� `���J� / 0l0 s��) $�%
# /��&� &� .�%�-9 ���&!5�� +���+0�� #>-, 6����J� g*! � � � ��� *� ��I���� �� �%-0�� #� f��K)� #B��%��l $�& $��% .�-�0(
���&!5��EM #>-�, 6����J� #��;) ����) 1&�-<B $���FB f�K)� ��# sAl �& #B��%��l ��� `����J� ���&��5� &�-�<B -�% &� .�� ?
#B�����J� ���*!B /� �!�- $�& #� /u���M �!�, ���&!�5�� # #F� �& &��[ +�� /? � ?�����FB `-� ? $�-� �& � .����) / 0l0
:�&�� �!" �%&�-<Bd�$�-�� `���J� ���&�5� +0� #u@) �.�IB -(� #� F� ��,�� wV!? #9�? �J /� =9! &�-<B � ��.�IB +0�� #u�@)
=9! &�-<B � $�-� `���J� ���&�5�wV!? -B4 w� *� *��K $�3 ���&!5�� �,��EM # ����' 1����� h�����FB *� *��KB 6&!�G &�
�# ����' /� ���&!5�� 70) �, +00FB $�%&�-<B / 0l0 ��&]X}[.
1 EM (Estimation-Maximization) Algorithm 2 Lauritzen
FG:H#$�&! /F��3 +�70� /<u, &��4��
� O0M' ��#� A��,X� �d-�k�...
57 ���������� ����� � ��
/<u, 1/<u, g*! � *� Y'g*! � ��-"� �� �, /K0�) /? /�� :��� /<u, $�-"� *� � �g*! � ��<, &� ��b.:��� ��, ��� ���l)
1$�& $��%-� �&�' $�-�� �<�, +��� &� �, ��� ��l) $�%�G&�l)��� %��G&� ��% ����� *� w� -�/%��� /� �!�- $� *� -� �&�'
��� ���FB ª�M� � $�%��� $-� &� /��� �.:��� �!0���-u0��? $�% ��� ���l) ����� 1`� #"-4 -� �&�' #)�0 $�%-� �&�' �&! &� q0��� :�@<, f��� ��� :�@<, �!�� ��G&� 1�<, +�� &� �,
.:�� />!�-
FG:I#$�&! /F��3 +�70� /<u,g*! � ���
����� � ������������
� O0M' ��#� A��,X� �d-�k�...
58
/<u, *� ��I��� ��g*! � � ���,�-"� # 1-.�J �B ��!B�-0Rq0�� -� �%-� �&�' *� w� -% :�@<, �% #��&-� �& T�8�A $��%
.�!�)/���! � -�3� /�? �!�, �-9 -(� 1-3� -� �&�' �&! &� 1/)!�) " /����� &� -��P) �&!�� -�C��.�9hhm�h�� "&�� &�-����q0���� 1
`���J� /� /�!� #5�9-(pk/kd:�@<, �����& `����J� ��G&� -���-� q�0B-B /� �? :@<, #<0�&�0%�d/mm ��G&�p/od
f!�� /���� &� -�C�.�9 -�3� /? �!, �-9 -(� `�J .:�� �G&�" #�� F�hm� :��@<, 1#��5�9-( q0���� ������& `�����J� 1���,�� ">
-����-� q��0B-B /��� ���? :��@<, #<0�&���0%�p/do1�m/jh�o/k�O%�? /? �!� �%�!4 �G&����� ;"!�B :���J /�� :u�@) #
# .�&�� �u� §&7� $�%-3� /? :9-( /K0�) ��!B -��? #5�9-( -B:@<, .��)&�� $-���? :@<, `���J� �� �uB /� #<0�&�0% $�%
# 70) �%-� �&�' -5�� $�-� -0R��B �!��) QM� =�-> +0�% /� ��!BT8�A � �!� $��%-� �&�' g*!� � *� Y' +0 a�% .�-? #�&-� �&
/�? :��� sA�l 1+�7�0� /<u,m�/mm$�%-�C�.�9 *� ��G&���� :���@<, $�&�� �!0�����-u0��? $����%kd/kk������ ����G&��0% �!�� :@<, /)!( ��!�J +�-��l0� +0� a�% .��)�&$ ���
��!�J +�-���? #�5�9-( /� �!�- �C.�9 /<u, &� �, :uR 1+��� -�� C�� .:�� �!� #(�&!4 O���-9 /� �!�- �, :uR
:@<, �G&� :�@<, *� -��l0� ��, :�uR #<0�&��0% $��% $��%*�� .:�� �!� (-��-� � ��J) $�
T#I#X6V 8� � �/ :M���G :����� ������� 1/<u���, g*!��� � ����J�- f����K)� *� Y���'
O0' # 0� f�K)� $�-� .�-0( &�-� #�&-� �&! `� $�%:MG #K � L��& *� `� ��Bdd��" /<u, �? $�-� ��I���� �C�.�9 $&�
# �!,
)�(n
)PP(100MP
n
1iiestobs
t
∑=
−
−=
)d�(n
)PP(100MP
n
1ii,Festobs
F
∑=
−
−=
)dd(n
)PP(100MP
n
1ii,FNestobs
NF
∑=
−
−=
/]L��& +�� &� MPt1MPFMPNF/��� 1���? $�-��� `��� :���� +05)���0 q��0B-B
$�&�� $�%-�C�.�9 $�-�� :��� +05)��0 1�!�"! $�%-�C.�9
&� :��@<, ����� $�%-�C��.�9 $�-��� :���� +05)���0 :��@<,��� :MG $�% /? � �@% #K �&����" /<u�, �? $&� �C�.�9
# /u��M .�)!,(Pobs)F,i (Pobs)NF,i :�@<, `���J� q0B-B /� /�!� #B��%�l :@<, f��i$�&�� $�%-�C�.�9 $�-� /? :�� f�
:��@<,d�� -I��G :��@<, ����� $�%-�C��.�9 $�-��� ���G&��%�!4 �G&� .�!�(Pest)F,i (Pest)NF,i +0��AB :�@<, `����J� 70)
/�!� $�-� `� L�!B �, �*i/� /? :�� f� /��!� $�-�� q0B-B $��% /3��& &� .� �@% :@<, ��� :@<, $�&���1(Pobs)i/�"!B ���
/�!� &� :@<, �!" f�� �� :@<, �!" /�i��� -IG &��[ 1f�d�� :,�� �%�!4 �G&�(Pest)i��, �* +0�AB :@<, `���J�
q@J -�) `� L�!B /�!� $�-� (�G&�i.:�� f�nL���& +��� &�/�!� �? ���FB B- $�%.:�� /3��& -% �� Lu :MG f�K)� �0�� #K �
O0' $�-� /)�(��" L��& *� ��I��� �� f��� :@<, # 0� :�@<,O0' $�-� $-B��� :�� +�70� /<u, `� �!�F /? :�� +�� #� 0�
O0' :�� 1+�� -� C� �&�� :@<, f�� :@<, # 0� /<u, $�%�0�EB $�-� $-B��� :0�%� *� &��&!4-� ��-0( .:��
�<,kO0' :�� &��!�) 1��� # ��B # 0� :MG $�% �& #K ��# ��l) �� ���) &��!�) +�� &� �, ��� ��l) ��[) *� w� -% .�%�
��� *� #<� :MG $�% L4 :�� #K � sA�l ��, 1&��!��) &�O0' :�� ��70 .:�� �!83 :�� ����J /�!� �? $�-� # 0� $��%
���) /<u, $�%:MG ) (#K ��MPt-���-� (j�/oh$�-�� 1��G&�/�!� ) :�@<, $�&�� $��%MPF(om/kp/��!� $�-�� ��G&� $��%
) :@<, ���MPNF -��-� (�o/op�G&�/�:�� /? � � /�"!B �� �!u�] /� ���,��� ��� ��; B) ��% �!�� U-���� &� `��� ��� $��%
#8F9 L��-, &� (:��.� �@% `!u� ����
FG:!#O0' :�� ��� $�-� `� # 0� :MG $�% #K �
!#!#8� �2'�@ X �4(� ��� �& 1��I��� �&! `� #��;) f�( $��%-� �&�' ��� �� �!� $�%
��" /<u, /� �!�- +�7�0� /<u�, /�� /�F��3 �&!� �C.�9 $&�
0
20
40
60
80
100
0 100 200 300 400���� M4�( �(�>:
~���3�fX��
� O0M' ��#� A��,X� �d-�k�...
59 ���������� ����� � ��
�����& `����J� ����% /�? `�� #�"-4 :�9��&� ���� g*! ��� -�C.�9 -% &� :@<,# 1: *� Y�' &!�P +��� $�-�� .�,��
# �-"� /<u, 1+�70� /<u, g*! � �J�- f�K)� ��!, +��� /�� �� F 1+�7�0� /<u, &� ��u ��� *� ��I��� �� T8�A $�%-0�� �&! &� /?
/[u> /� �!�- /��� -% `���J� `���" *� ��I���� �� -0�� �� $� �) #>-, 6����J�CPT(# /u��M &� .�!, -�% $�-�� ��F� /8J-
�, -?t � �!� *� w�y:@<, &� -R *��� $�% #<0�&��0% $�-()-�C�.�9 -�% �&!� &� 1(��, ���K�� +�70� /<u, #���� $�%
/��� &� q�� /���� �!��) sA�l �& � �� �� /� �!�- $� � -�C.�9 �� /� �!�- :@<, `���J� 1+�70� /<u�, $�-"� *� Y'
sAl # �!, *� ��I��� �� +�70� /<u, &� ��u ��� /8J- +�� &� .��� �����% *� ��I����� ���� -�C��.�9 �� /��� �!���- $�& $���%
# f�K)� 1#>-, 6����J� `��" -% #��;) :@<, `���J� �-0( #� sAl �& -�C.�9 #�(z� *� .�����) /<u�, $��% +�7�0� $��%
,&�? 6�-P) *� ��I��� ��< � ��� �!�" f�� 6&!G &� #�� $��% .:��� ¡�4 � �� w� /� �!�- +��� /�� f��� 6&!�G &� &!�P
��� �!" #� 1�� �� w�� �&! &� #B��%�l $�% 6�-�P) *� ��!�B -� �&�' �� +00FB $�-� ���� ,&�?��-? -' #>-, `���J� `��"
U� ,&�? /? #B&!G &� �� -� C� .�!�) ��I��� �� /� �!�- 70) +�7�0� /<u, 1�,�� /�,��) -� �&�' �� �&! &� =0�� �C>� -P) /��
/��� �%# ¡�E�4� $�@ `���J� -� �&�' �� T8�A $.�%� �<,m��l) /���� &� /? :�� #��%-�C.�9 ���FB � %� $��%
/��9-( &�-�� 1�, sAl :@<, `���J� `����J� ��7�0 -�(� .��)� " :����@<, ��������&h���1""k��h�" 1"o��k�" 1"���o� "
"d���������* ���* �B L�!� 1L�!� 1�? 1�? #804 q0B-B /� " :@<, `���J� 1�!, /�9-( -P) &�d�o ) ��? #�804 -�C�.�9hd
�G&� :�@<, `���J� 1(�k) ��? -�C�.�9do��G&� `����J� 1(:@<,j�� ) L�!� -�C.�9o��G&� :�@<, `���J� (dm
�* -�C.�9) ��j�G&�.:�� (
FG:c#:@<, ����& `���J� /��� -% &� �%-�C.�9 ���FB &��!�)
c#$ ��� ���D /<u, &� :@<, ����& `���J� /u��M ���&!5�� 1/��[ +�� &� $�%
��" /<u�, *� ��I���� �� �C.�9 $&� ��, #�9-F +�7�0� $��%��" /<u, *� #lA� &� �� �-�&�? �C�.�9 $&� /�[3 j$��I��
.�, ��� ��l) ��-;B /<u�, &� ��� �!�u�? �<�l /�� /�"!B �� $��%��" *� 1q��� #�,& *� ��I���� ��� /�? �!� f*� 1�C.�9 $&�
��� =0I8B w�@�& �08MB $�-� ��(-u4 6�-P) �!"! s��) $�%:4��-�* +�� /�� 1+��� -� C� .�!, ��I��� $-;, �; $�% ��0��
$&�!,� / �7% :4���-�* +��� /�� #�-��� ��!� -� 1�!9�� $��%/)� �� +�� L��-, #���*&� $�-� #,& ��K�� 6&-. /�� /"!B �� �%
# U�@J� LuB- � �!� 1=�0[MB +��� &� ��, /���&� `�� �_� .�,/<u, :4��-�* :�-�� ��@0� &� �84 +�� �9& $�-� #,CB $��%
��" .:�� �C.�9 $&� =0[MB +�� &�:@<, q0��� �% *��� $��% #<0�&��0% $�
/<u��, &� �!��"! ����� ���% &!��> /��� ���% �)���, ����� ���� * ��� )� q0�� #��%/8�" *� 2-�B 1#(�&!�4 1O���-9 1#�5�9-( 1#(�&!�4
�� f�� $� �-0H ���&!�5�� q���� &� :�@<, ����& `���J� ��" #���� f�( &�;V � �, /? �, #9-F ��� $&� &! $�% 1*�0) �
:MG 1+�70� /<u, g*! � :�9��&� ���� g*!� � `�� #K �� `��� #��"-4�!��� *� /��F��3 +���� &� +�7��0� /<u��, �-�&���? $�-��� .
f-) :M�G ����) /� /"!B �� .�, ��I��� +0(!0% &�79� :��� 1#K ��O0' `!u� ���� �u�-[B `� # 0��!� ��I���� ��< � 6&!G &� /�u�� .
��� ���FB *�#)�!> #)� * &� �� 1-�l0� &� -B���� :��� ��� 1-�B�0� #��09�-�" /[3 # �F3� 1`� �!0��-u0��? $�-� -B /�� ��!�B
:�� .:9�� :�� $-B��� $�% #"-4 ����)/�:�� `�� *� �� ���l) 1=0[MB $�&! /F��3 $�-� ��? #804 :@<, `���J� � %�
) �?bx�G&� ) L��!� (r~�G&��$�%-�C�.�9 -��?� $�-�� ( /<u��, ����� O��A� ��!��� ��!��" /���u�� /��? :���� /<u��, &� �!��"!
��" # 1��-;B �C.�9 $&� /<u�, .�,�� �� � �!� /8�" *� �)�!B +�70�/�:�� ���" /<u�, $�-� � � �&!� /�[3 �C�.�9 $&�
/�� :08��� /� /"!B �� 1/F��3 /<u�, #)���&*& -�% &� 1+�7�0� $��%#)� * ��� /? � �? $�% $-B/�:�� ��!J &� � �� ���:uR ��,
#� 1����� O��79� �� #��&��? /��9-( &�-�� $-5)*��� �&!� ��)�!B .�!��, ��� O��7��9� #�� -��.�J ���&!��5�� #��"-4 *� &� ��!��B
:�!�� �!�) ��I��� /<u, &� �!"! $�%-�C.�9 #�&*�� $� � O��7��9� �& /<u��, #��&���? �-��<8�� &� ��I����� ���� +0�� a�% ���
/ �)-� ��-�M� �!�� *� �)�� 1w@�& :�-�� �08MB $�% +��� &� #B�0J :4��-�*.�,
10684
308
15
050
100150200250300350
0-20 20-40 40-60 80-100
~��'��
)'��lz� ���=9
(
X�G: 8�>���
����� � ������������
� O0M' ��#� A��,X� �d-�k�...
60
d#����(�� #� f*� �!�4 -�� ��(� @�!) $&��<�% *� /�? �� )�� /)��0��G $��%
����� �C.�9 �� :?-, f-�M ���� ,&�? ��EEA� B��-; /[3 �C.�9 �� :?-, b$� ��,*&� 6���C>� /�? ��-;B
1�����)��� &�-����� N-����' +������ &�����0�4� &� #)��&������.����� ���) o#e2��
1. Grigg, N. S. (2003). Water, wastewater, and stormwater infrastructure management, Lewis Pub., Boca Raton, Florida.
2. Khan, Z., Zayed, T., and Moselhi, O. (2009). “Simulating impact of factors affecting sewer network operational condition.” Proc. of CSCE 2009 Annual General Conference, Montreal, Canada, 285-294.
3. Hahn, M., Palmer, R., and Merrill, M. (1999). “Prioritizing sewer line inspection with an expert system.” Proc. of ASCE, 29th Annual Water Resources Planning and Management Conference, Tempe, Arizona, United States, 1-9.
4. Hahn, M. A., Palmer, R. N., Merrill, S. M., and Lukas, A. B. (2002). “Expert system for prioritizing the inspection of sewers: Knowledge base formulation and evaluation.” J. Water Resources Planning and Management, 128(2), 121-129.
5. Najafi, M., and Kulandaivel, G. (2005). “Pipeline condition prediction using neural network models.” Proc. of Pipeline: Optimizing Pipeline Design, Operations and Maintenance in Today’s Economy, ASCE, Reston, VA., 767-781.
6. Baik, H. S., Jeong, H. S., and Abraham, D. M. (2006). “Estimating transition probabilities in Markov chain-based deterioration models for management of wastewater systems.” J. Water Resources Planning and Management, 132(1), 15-24.
7. Babani, J., Adams, B. J., and Wilson, B. G. (2008). “Integrating hydraulic and environmental performance assessments in asset management of wastewater collection networks.” Proc. of the 11th International Conference on Urban Drainage, Edinburgh, Scotland, UK.
8. Wang, C., Niu, Z., Jia, H., and Zhang, H. (2010). “An assessment model of water pipe condition using Bayesian inference.” J. Zhejiang University-SCIENCE A (Applied Physics & Engineering), 11(7), 495-504.
9. Tavakolifar, H. (2008). “Developing of evaluation and readiness enhancement algorithm for urban water treatment systems against crisis.” MSc. Thesis, School of Civil Engineering, College of Engineering, University of Tehran, Iran. (In Persian)
10. FEMA. (2005). A how to guide to mitigate potential terrorist attacks against buildings, Risk Management Series, FEMA 452, USA.
11. Badali Bavani, E. (2012). “Developing an algorithm for risk management of wastewater treatment plants in crisis situations.” MSc. Thesis, School of Civil Engineering, College of Engineering, University of Tehran, Iran. (In Persian)
12. Asgarian, M. (2012). “An algorithm for assessment of wastewater collection network readiness in crisis situations by multi criteria decision making.” MSc. Thesis, School of Civil Engineering, College of Engineering, University of Tehran, Iran. (In Persian)
13. Roozbahani, A., Zahraie, B., and Tabesh, M. (2013). “Integrated risk assessment of urban water supply systems from source to tap.” J. Stochastic Environmental Research and Risk Assessment, 27(1), 923-944.
14. Roozbahani, A. (2012). “Risk based decision making model for urban water systems.” PhD Thesis, School of
� O0M' ��#� A��,X� �d-�k�...
61 ���������� ����� � ��
Civil Engineering, College of Engineering, University of Tehran, Iran. (In Persian) 15. Heckerman, D. (1996). A tutorial on learning with Bayesian networks, Microsoft Research Advanced
Technology Division, Microsoft Corporation, Redmond, Washington, USA. 16. Nikoo, M. R., and Kerachian, R. (2009). “Evaluating the efficiency of Bayesian networks in river quality
management: Application of the Trading-Ratio System.” J. Water and Wastewater, Vol.19.No.1 (65), 23-33. (In Persian)
17. ASCE. (1994). Existing sewer evaluation and rehabilitation, ASCE 62, New York. 18. Neapolitan, R. E. (2004). Learning Bayesian networks, Prentice Hall, New Jersey, US. 19. HUGIN EXPERT A/S, (2012). Hugin researcher userguide, Version 7.6, Aalborg, Denmark. 20. Kulkarni, R. B., Golabi, K., and Chuang, J. (1986). Analytical techniques for selection of repair-or-replace
options for cast-iron gas piping systems-Phase I, Gas Research Institute, Chicago, Illinois. 21. Management and Planning Organization of Tehran Urban Developing Plans. (2006). “Strategic-structural
plan of Tehran development (Tehran comprehensive plan).” Housing and Urbanization Ministry, Tehran Municipality, Tehran, Iran. (In Persian)
22. Lauritzen, S. L. (1995). “The EM algorithm for graphical association models with missing data.” J. Computational Statistics and Data Analysis, 19(1), 191-201.