. r,~.,,,ts {:/: ftt_.:_ i·f~ f ... '-:; ~,· fl ' r l.c " ._,,( ~ (,,-i'--

-~ ---

"-'·

) !(

l ·: ?

249 248 ·J

250

253

' ,.

I·

.:,

255

t:::. :iL m 1i :b 0 h i f-t.::. 1~

' ' W!f :b 1:::. V)l 7 Q 1 t:" -I! 1 :/ ~

254

I

I

258

·-ii-' ~-:

" 1 i

I

. ;

1 :1

260

I

.i

Z63

. ..• ,,

265

ilL 'H -f JjJ] ml L s {} k ;:c .., L ' L A [:; 3l~ !J'i, (fil fi < l~IJ 0) .:. \,' (l) ;ls 0 0 7 tt iJ> 0 iJ• tilt ;;( G ft H ts:. * 1 0 7:E rm !~ -t ;f; 1 ~ ± iilii 0) 1f- fb t.::. '-\,' .:. 0) 0) 7:E l'.f L 0 15 0) E:l tc rrl.'i -t; c iJ> ;h, i ;/-;. ;I. I L 0 G "'- =\'- ts:. it. j~] ') vt IC ~ 0) :{l r-'f 0) 0 / 0) io tc ts:. _f: tE t .:;>. t 0) El :/ =\'- -"-'. 0) 1) 0) (111 if tk D' t.::. t.::. iJ; .., lj f~ 1:'. tJll. I) -/;> It tr I) *

L 1Jt, ~ tt 0) El 0) B tc t

0 t.::. m :>c. --t: . ti '-ll ; :I: B 11r. ¥ ~E L- A fl) Ii p 0) J: 0 -l fiiJ *' \, ' 0) t.::. ~ ii: ;,f, ~ 8 ~ rr- r-r ' fJ;_ ' t.::. {i'tj p~ - :tf1 IC ;ft L- (/) ' jl~ J: tJ:. 1G ~ '- ~r ' il; * c r;i; t.::. 0) IJ) JZ m'r I) 0 J1 0 ft· c :fir. I) )~ ' 6 c * tc 0) \,' B ,{ I}) ie ft 7J i!'j; ~JF IC s ;/-;. ~ till 7.7' ? c· ~ WL Ii ' '-4 :r;i 0) lf 0) r.111 B ' i'lG f~ l}j, tr. p El L jl)1 -, t.::. rj1 Ii 1fi; ,~, L IC (I,; m ff El ~ -C ? rm .7c ]\?/( tt \, ' < till I) fi G l't:J m y M ~ t.::. tr. iJ; 'L ;I. 0. - ~ B 8 J: -l ~· ·J.t fol 0) "' * fl,'f tc ' ~I:. p;j -C ~!I! 0) IC * L- \,' a . JI] Ji L 0) .., L :t!J 1: tt ~ 0) I di~ ~ fil ' \,' 1) Ul ;h m * 7 ~ ;:, . a ~G * "' [I J: IC ' ti 4 ~ 0) \,' El IE -- ~ (b ts 6 9?:. 1!.:i 'Z" w Ii -C 'L Z!f: ~ D 6 JW m -/J; J: 'b i gg 0 -)] p Ti. 1illi 0) ;I. >t IC 8 l;, (l':J f aq * ? c ¥r- < B IC -l 0 0) 1:ft iW: l!IJ L 1::. 0) ~ )iii -t G J: It * tl:l J: 0) * 7 filt ? J: I) A'o 0 0) ::>" jt, L I@ 1) !le It l:p -r jJJl IC .., it. Ii ~ i i h 0 ~ '- Ll!: t.::. ~ 0) IX; 1::. -t 7J t.::. 0 h 0) ,, .. IA ~ ·

7 rl \ .., !" ' {tf "",' h ~ ¥P- c \, ' * ilx vJ 1t {, 0) 0 c ft 0) 7 L 0) -C c h i f.l ~ F y ' 7J i L ft ~ El 1-? lJ ~ -)] ~ 0) -/;> 0) It 4 0 It ts; ~ ? ~- Q vt 0) tl!l j;rJ jJ~ ·' ~ ' t.::. : I ,, * l < 7 , gg It IC '- * 6 -;- =\'- iJ' Jt: t-1' fJ:. y 0 B 0 t.r. / 0) mt w. 0 Ii ~ B In I*) ~ 0 j;rJ ~ If ~(\ t::. ts:. -ij- 7 L i c..~ L '-01 ·/!Jil 0) I =\'- ©.'. tJ:. ± c 0) t.::. 2! y nq. -l 111 rim < 7J n~1 0) L :fir L 'jJ t.::. 7, Ii 0) IC ' A ' ~ a -C iJ> -t \,' G iJ> 1::. It i0)1 -C /It h fj( t.::. h rt< ;:, r ' h if> :{f c "( G '- 1111 ts:.

""' 1) ;/1 1) LU: '? £' ~? fl' 0 ~ ~ -C Jl $ fl c ' 0) 0) 1it b ~ y;:, r: RB P" ... ft vt ;I. ts:. : :riµ , ~ : x~1 r,o ;.;-- ~· II§ mi &:' ;I. 1) 71 ' 7-. YR -f ;h, m tt "' !IT; mi Yt tit 4 t1V- ;:, -/J~ h A. rrr ' . v: -i .., < • L \ n> l 1L~ \ illi ~· "' IC c ~ 1) ;;., fb B r (1'9 c ti~ L- 0 0 ~ t.::. B ;:, I~ 8 t.::. L jfr B y ft c 8 J:i Ji *- fl.Ii fs, t:J " ~ \ '1'.J j t7) \ Ir. .. ts:. ;:. -/)t 7J r ~ * f~ 'M'· ~' '- t 0 fll\ L jlj\ * tr 7-._ tc "? '"( 0) i -)J 1E t1> * ;It -C ;!: )J . !!

~ r:: 4- J'I \o ' ll~ \ ~ ~ 3 t;, c s fb fj: h A 0) jffii ~ -c- 8 il~- L -c -c 0) ~- ;:, c '{, t-o ~ -

269

N "O o t'-- "Reply to Hu Shih" (uQ]f[~-f>'~R::;HJa~l'Piia l:ltl2 I' :,\-'Q:i'KttiJ ~~J!ES'-'=-->-. '( ~-'-l2~~-\1J,;:O\-':,Kl ) l2lfli ~~\-'~~~~"UQM~~~Q•-f>-~~-\J~*!t+lQ •J Q~l;!gt'.' ~~Hll!ll!11:!1'Pffia r~ l21'.:.l-'Q:i'K~Jl2~~~~'>'(J~\-':,~·

(~) kJQ:i;~:!;!' U..Q8Q!;ti?.;;$§.p{:Q~~0 Masao Abe : " Review Article ". The Eastern Buddhist , New Series,

Vol. I, No. 1.

( :::; ) Winston L. King: " Zen and The Death of God", Japanese

Religions, (li£:4Jil~~;(rr~;[rr!f=K:-O!;:~i$;~~~l~) Vol. 5, No. 2.

"Time Transcendence- Acceptance in Zen Buddhism." >J~!;!

~~J:2;i]Q&..;\-'.W,\.!w w+,l:,_ 11' 1'liS~o

c~ ) t-- 11'>- . i:--""' r·.ll--'-~ · '"'' Ht--~ · ~J c*~~~ .;:i ijf:J~g;) .,':;lt'Q~M""~l["

(~ ) -jrr[i)!jj~~' ~$i( 1-.;:i 1 Ji:;° (~ ) t-, 11'), . t--":;--~~.p{~ ~\'.:>!,,!>t'Q,;;;;;;;.,(.J~~o

. No • . 2·.!il'!@~w..i;;t-J:,l(l0 :

{;..) .· ~~ =tl~'-41-.=---··.\H"-;--4 ~t< ,. -!>-"'l;-::::-.t----

4 . ·.~ t1 ~ -4 ';-- \ - ~~~ Q-'i!iiiil~i>\.\L~i"l(l~ =-- ~ i

-fr-2E--JAJ""{/v

4J.1Q J.~..>J...)Plt)~~-K41-1'.R~.fu~-i2~' .>J ©+i411lln:t •· ·*~?J~~V+J{ml~ll!i1 (;($1rr)' ~~;r,i4;J•(HJ!{\~~1'.;.!0 ~!)!'' ::---R'n-l!:::l§ll.i'i,.'.,\-'~R~~)E:;li;ll;;rr

ti\>W!IQ 1 -Jr:f~W~\-' ,'.;,.;.!'t- ~ · -~-"'' 11-""K -'-~!l;l:;l.*s\tl~ I'.;.!'.\:,' >J Q .t--1~ K-'J~J--"'-""-RQ~,'.bl~l'.;.!~~Q~~-'J..J\-'' ~~v j£~w .• ~y.._.:,o >\-'~Qr:f\tl:!±~v' iJ0~*1Q34\:l,'.;,,tJ,'.;,.,Q.l!":t:~&Q° Ct.SR;1!!!~~ Wm *::;'.\~~*-&i.l .il ..... K')

(~) Diamond Sangha, Vol. 7, No. 4. "Zen in the West."

(g:i) ~~1"1~ r~-l:i-\->J:ltl-lH-Jli'11~->Jl'l!il•11~~"' ~ Q mtmiU (i:)i>{:;ti"-!.o)J;;lj'j:'.Q li'~Q*\llll(-'J-{ii;'iDll~' i\10' ;IJ:1}§@ll..\l:;K1l~~W~\-':, >Z') Nyogen Senzaki and Ruth Strout McCandless, Buddhism

and Zen. Philosophical Library, New Y erk, 1953.

Chang Chen-Chi, The Practice of Zen, Harper & Brothers,

New Y erk, 1959.

Charles Luk (Lu K'uan Yii), Ch'an and Zen Teaching. L

IL III. Rider & Co. London.

ditto, The Secrets of Chinese Meditation.

Holmes Welch, The Practice of Chinese Buddhism 1900-19 -~ '

Harvard Univ. Press, Cambridge, Mass. 1967.

Augustin Hideshi Kishi, Spiritual Consciousness in Zen

from a Thomistic Theological Point of View. Catholic Bishop's

House of Osaka, 67 Nishiyama-cho, Koyaen, Nishinomiya-shi.

~ l\;IH~~lililiii~t!;:1:!-S-@S

Ruth Sasaki ..(Jl--""-.\\-).\l:i' ..... D~;jj£')1JI"' '2~Gr):~-#'->J,il..J\-'~f1P.;.!0 >J>J.\l!1P\-'1l1~1lif.ii~,t

~ ~ &Fm RB ~ ii> w m JIB fr fnJ ~ /' is: mi 0.. =it n ~ d1i j .:,-""' LI ::r ~ tP '= {-E IC tt l" 0 I ~ ~ fiif " " 1 7' :fO " fj fj flfii Q ,-.., Ji( 1'. ~ tP m 'T ~ s;:> 0 .P- * . /j, [g 1111 ;;· 9 0 "Y:. 'ffll i - 7.> fl;; y ~ r; 8 !±I ~ "' . '7 .? * * + ITT1J ~ "--' m ~ * ti ,-.., ii> r 17) ~ 17) * !iii to ~ ,~ * ! jL ., ~ '.'}!: {:, '? '= -1 ;( 13 .... """ ~ " gi A'.'}!: .I 11;~ ~ Q.. "" 71< a.. J1l: *' 17) ~'* 0 t:. 9 '/ 7' ti> * "' ~ *L ~ tc: •tt

tf:jl; JI! tr 11'1 ,.,, l\ w. l'Jt flf.i =- =\" ~ lj)f ;t: .... ;i:,,, frt ·~. Jl{ Jl{ 17) -c "' i:, 1 () °' jJ[ w # tll @ Jj ~ 17) 0 ;f!J !& /v ., '.9E '= \,' p ~ .!ft.·'!' . ~ EfJ jJii lit "}- ~ fl!k {, ,-.., fa ,..._ {:, · H. t. \, 'f 'f i\ c. !:: ..,, ~ H + 1 + : () ? ~!It· .. im . " IT: * li lllJ -:I c >c c_· 9 7 Q E:: 9 ·;; "' < . W{.:n !~ j!; mr AiiU + :fl ')I "' * ::!.. ~ .· tc 1~ - - - jf mr- ~ 17) 1 -)]' 0 tl -t :::. - - ~ c 0 if ::r: * ~ j\; I '= ffll - =it 7' 1 ::r l:t ~ 'rJf: !~ / I if. O!j " "' ~ ]jj - 1& fj 17) " 2P ii /v '-' " 17) ttt " If~·.~ m tl: s j\ - ! \ fa! '= 0 "' t~ * ii'- ?. ®( JG ~ l:l:l 9 .. fi• ~.· * 0 ~ 7fJ * (!) 1rr ~ 1315-32508-4604 © 19GB Chikuma Shobo f.\l :IL