Gilmar Mendes, no STF, atende PSDB e suspende liminarmente posse de Lula como ministro

8/19/2019 Gilmar Mendes, no STF, atende PSDB e suspende liminarmente posse de Lula como ministro

1/34

MEDIDA CAUTELAR EM MANDADO DE SEGURANÇA 34.071 DISTRITO FEDERAL

RELATOR : MIN. GILMAR MENDESIMPTE.(S) :PARTIDO DA SOCIAL DEMOCRACIA BRASILEIRA ADV.(A / S) :FLAVIO HENRIQUE COSTA PEREIRA ADV.(A / S) :GUSTAVO GUILHERME BEZERRA KANFFER IMPDO.(A / S) :PRESIDENTE DA REPÚBLICA PROC.(A / S)(ES) :ADVOGADO-GERAL DA UNIÃO

DECISÃO: Trata-se e !a"a#s e se$%ra"&a '!(etra#s e! )ar*ter)#+et',# (#r (art'#s (#+t')#s ,#+ta#s )#"tra # at# e "#!ea&.# e L%'/I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a (ara # )ar$# e M'"'str# C0e1e a Casa C','+2

O PARTIDO POPULAR SOCIALISTA – PPS '!(etr#% # Ma"a#e Se$%ra"&a C#+et',# 3425652

Q%a"t# a# )a7'!e"t# a a&.#8 s%ste"t#% 9%e #s (art'#s (#+t')#st:! a!(+a +e$'t'!'ae (ara '!(etrar !a"a# e se$%ra"&a e! )ar*ter)#+et',#2

Re+at#% 9%e a a%t#r'ae '!(etraa "#!e#% L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a aS'+,a (ara # )ar$# e C0e1e a Casa C','+8 )#! statuts e M'"'str# eEsta#2 Ar$%!e"t#% 9%e # at# 1#' (rat')a# e! es,'# e 1'"a+'ae8te"# e! ,'sta #s se$%'"tes 1at#s;


2/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

(re,e"t',a # E-Pres'e"te L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a8 "# 7#?## (r#)ess# 5565-25J22J25558 e)+'"#% e s%a

)#!(et:")'a8 (#r e"te"er 9%e # =%/# res(#"s*,e+ (e+a#(era&.# +a,a ?at# @ # )#!(ete"te (ara a(re)'ar #s (e'#s1#r!%+a#s (e+# M'"'st@r'# P7+')# #)2 4

Q%art#; t##s #s set#res a s#)'eae 7ras'+e'ra )#!e&a!a es(e)%+ar a (#ss'7'+'ae e (r's.# # e-Pres'e"te L%'/I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a8 # 9%e @ 1at# (7+')# e "#tr'#

Q%'"t#; #'s 'as a(s J25325J8 a a%t#r'ae )#at#raa"%")'a e e)'e "#!ear # E-Pres'e"te L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a aS'+,a )#!# M'"'str# C0e1e a Casa C','+8 a es+#)ar t#as as

'",est'$a&es )#"tra # E-Pres'e"te L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a(ara # STF #)2 e8

Set#; "esse !es!# 'a8 '"ter)e(ta&.# te+e1"')a a P#+)'aFeera+ re,e+#% '*+#$# e"tre a E)e+e"tss'!a Pres'e"te aRe(7+')a e # e-Pres'e"te L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a2 Nare1er'a $ra,a&.#8 a a%t#r'ae )#at#ra '"1#r!a 9%e 'r* e"tre$ar # #)%!e"t# a# e-(res'e"te L%+a2 Na ,erae8 se trata # (r#)%ra#r a Fa/e"a =#r$e Mess'as8

at%a+!e"te "a s%7)0e1'a e ass%"t#s ?%r')#s a Casa C','+2 Na$ra,a&.#8 a a%t#r'ae )#at#ra @ )+ara a# 1a+ar (ara # e-Pres'e"te L%s I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a; s %sa e! )as# e"e)ess'ae8 9%e @ # TERMO DE POSSE8 t* #)2 >2

A1'r!#% 9%e a Pres'e"te a Re(7+')a te! )#!(et:")'a (ara8 a se% ?%/#8 es)#+0er #s M'"'str#s e Esta#2 N# e"ta"t#8 a "#!ea&.# e! te+a

ter'a s'# (rat')aa e! es,'# e 1'"a+'ae8 "a !e'a e! 9%e 7%s)#%1'"a+'ae ".# (7+')a )#"1er'r (rerr#$at',a e 1#r# a# "#!ea#8'!(e'"# # )%rs# as '",est'$a&es2

Re9%ere% !e'a +'!'"ar (ara s%star #s e1e't#s a "#!ea&.#2 Pe'%(r#,'!e"t# 9%e es)#"st't%a a "#!ea&.#2

O PARTIDO DA SOCIAL DEMOCRACIA RASILEIRA – PSD'!(etr#% # Ma"a# e Se$%ra"&a C#+et',# 342562

Documento assinado digitalmente conforme MP n°2.200-2/2001 de 24/08/2001, que institui a Infraestrutura de Chaves Públicas Brasileira - ICP-Brasil. O

documento pode ser acessado no endereço eletrônico http://www.stf.jus.br/portal/autenticacao/ sob o número 10545213.


3/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

Q%a"t# a# )a7'!e"t# a a&.#8 s%ste"t#% 9%e #s (art'#s (#+t')#st:! a!(+a +e$'t'!'ae (ara '!(etrar !a"a# e se$%ra"&a e! )ar*ter

)#+et',#2 Re+at#% 9%e a a%t#r'ae '!(etraa "#!e#% L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a aS'+,a (ara # )ar$# e C0e1e a Casa C','+8 )#! statuts e M'"'str# eEsta#2 A1'r!#% 9%e a Pres'e"te a Re(7+')a te! )#!(et:")'a (ara8 ase% ?%/#8 es)#+0er #s M'"'str#s e Esta#2 N# e"ta"t#8 a "#!ea&.# e!te+a ter'a s'# (rat')aa e! es,'# e 1'"a+'ae8 "a !e'a e! 9%e

7%s)#% 1'"a+'ae ".# (7+')a )#"1er'r (rerr#$at',a e 1#r# a#"#!ea#8 '!(e'"# # )%rs# as '",est'$a&es2 A+e$#% 9%e # at# aPres'e"te a Re(7+')a ,'#+#% # (r'")('# a !#ra+'ae esta!(a# "#

art2 368 caput 8 a C#"st't%'&.# Feera+8 7e! )#!# #%tr#s (r'")('#s1%"a!e"ta's8 9%e e,e! re$er t#a e 9%a+9%er at','ae aA!'"'stra&.# P7+')a2 S%ste"t#% a'"a 9%e a re1er'a "#!ea&.# #1e"e#s (re)e't#s # ?%'/ "at%ra+ e # e,'# (r#)ess# +e$a+2 A%/ 9%e aPres'e"te a Re(7+')a8 (#r !e'# # at# '!(%$"a#8 (rat')#% )r'!e eres(#"sa7'+'ae (#r ,'#+ar # art2 8 caput e #s '")'s#s II8 IV e VII8 aC#"st't%'&.# Feera+2 S%ste"t#%8 e! s"tese8 9%e # at# '!(etra#


4/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

L - # !a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#+et',# (#e ser'!(etra# (#r;

a (art'# (#+t')# )#! re(rese"ta&.# "# C#"$ress#Na)'#"a+ 7 #r$a"'/a&.# s'"')a+8 e"t'ae e )+asse #% ass#)'a&.#

+e$a+!e"te )#"st't%a e e! 1%")'#"a!e"t# 0* (e+# !e"#s %!a"#8 e! e1esa #s '"teresses e se%s !e!7r#s #% ass#)'a#s>

A!7#s #s (art'#s (#+t')#s '!(etra"tes )#!(r#,a! 9%e t:!re(rese"ta&.# "# )#"$ress# "a)'#"a+2

A (rese"te a&.# testa #s +'!'tes # !a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#+et',#'!(etra# (#r (art'# (#+t')#2O 9%e se te! @ # !a"e?#8 (#r (art'#s (#+t')#s e #(#s'&.#8 e

!a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#"tra at# a C0e1'a # P#er Ee)%t',# 9%e8 e!tese8 ,'#+a a se(ara&.# #s (#eres art2 e (r'")('#s )#"st't%)'#"a's aa!'"'stra&.# (7+')a art2 362

O '"teresse t%te+a# @ e )ar*ter '1%s#8 "a e1'"'&.# # art2 8(ar*$ra1# "')#8 I8 # CDC8 (#r ser tra"s'"','%a+8 '"','s,e+ e e

t't%+ar'ae '"eter!'"aa;

2

H* #'s (#"t#s "aa tr','a's8 '"t'!a!e"te )#"e)ta#s8 a sere!

a(re)'a#s 9%a"t# Y ae9%a&.# a ,'a e+e'ta2 Pr'!e'r#8 se # !a"a# ese$%ra"&a )#+et',# (#e ser %sa# (ara a t%te+a e 're't#s '1%s#s2Se$%"#8 se #s (art'#s (#+t')#s s.# +e$'t'!a#s (ara %sar a a&.# )#! ta+1'"a+'ae2

O e!(re$# # !a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#+et',# (ara a t%te+a e'"teresses '1%s#s ".# @ a)e't# e 1#r!a tra"9%'+a2

A Le' 25J58 9%e


5/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

es(e)1')# a '!(etra&.# e! )ar*ter )#+et',#8 a1'r!a 9%e a a&.# (#e ser!a"e?aa (ara t%te+a e 're't#s )#+et',#s e '"','%a's 0#!#$:"e#s8 ".#

!e")'#"a"# #s 're't#s '1%s#s;

2

De 1#r!a (ara+e+a8 s%r$e a 9%est.# a (#ss'7'+'ae e # (art'#(#+t')# %sar a a&.# e! e1esa e '"teresses 9%e ".# s.# (e)%+'ares a se%s

1'+'a#sF#' essa a ratio 9%e $%'#% # Tr'7%"a+ "# ?%+$a!e"t# # RE J248

Re+2 M'"2 E++e" Gra)'e8 ?%+$a# e! 62525542 O )as# trata,a a(#ss'7'+'ae e %t'+'/a&.# a a&.# )#! # #7?et',# e t%te+ar # '"teresse'"','%a+ 0#!#$:"e# 's(#",e+ '"teresse #s )#"tr'7%'"tes e! ".# ses%7!eter a a%!e"t# "# IPTU2 C#")+%'%-se 9%e a t%te+a # '"teresse'"','%a+ 0#!#$:"e# 's(#",e+ e,er'a ser 1e'ta (e+#s (r(r'#s)#"tr'7%'"tes8 '"','%a+ #% )#+et',a!e"te8 ".# se"# ,'*,e+ a t%te+a (e+a




6/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

a&.# e !a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#+et',# !a"e?aa (#r (art'# (#+t')#2Da9%e+e 1e'ta8 e% !es!# re$'stre' 's)#rW")'a 9%a"t# Y

(#ss'7'+'ae # (art'# (#+t')# '!(etrar se$%ra"&a e! 1a,#r e2

Per)e7# 9%e a a"*+'se 9%e 1'/ a9%e+a 1e'ta 1#' e)ess',a!e"terestr't',a2 Os (art'#s (#+t')#s t:! 1'"a+'aes '"st't%)'#"a's 7e!'1ere"tes as ass#)'a&es e s'"')at#s2 Re(rese"ta! '"teresses as#)'eae8 ".# a(e"as #s se%s !e!7r#s2 Re(rese"ta! at@ !es!#a9%e+es 9%e ".# +0es est'"a! ,#t#2

A 'e'a e 2

Ass'!8 ".# (are)e )#rret# )#"1er'r-+0es # !es!# trata!e"t# a# Ysass#)'a&es e '"')a#s2 E ".# 1#' 'ss# 9%e 1e/ # tet# )#"st't%)'#"a+ e!,'$#r2

C#!# ?* a"#te'8 a e'$:")'a e 9%e # !a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#+et',#se?a '!(etra# )#"sta a(e"as a a+"ea # '")'s# LII # art2 2 N.#)#"sta a a+"ea 8 ta!(#%)# # (r(r'# '")'s#2

A+'*s8 essa '1ere"&a ".# (are)e ter s'# "%")a '$"#raa (#r estaC#rte e! see e )#"tr#+e a7strat#2 Ve?a-se a !a"e'ra )#!# este Tr'7%"a+'"ter(reta # art2 53 a C#"st't%'&.# Feera+8 9%e )%'a #s +e$'t'!a#s(ara ADI e ADC2 E'$e-se (ert'":")'a te!*t')a (ara as e"t'aes(re,'stas "# '")'s# I


7/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

Nessa +'"0a8 "# ?* !e")'#"a# RE J248 a 1%"a!e"ta&.# are+at#ra a1'r!#% 9%e #s (art'#s (#+t')#s (#er'a! !a"e?ar a a&.# e!

e1esa e 9%a's9%er '"teresses '1%s#s2O 1at# @ 9%e # (re)ee"te re%/'% a '!(#rtW")'a a '!(etra&.# a

#re! e !a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#+et',# (#r (art'# (#+t')#8 a#'!(e'r # %s# a a&.# (ara a e1esa e '"teresses '"','%a's0#!#$:"e#s ".# (e)%+'ares a#s 1'+'a#s8 se! 9%e est',esse! )+ar#s #s+'!'tes e e!(re$# # re!@'# "a t%te+a e '"teresses )#+et',#s e '1%s#s2N# )e"*r'# at%a+8 #s )as#s e !a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#+et',# s.# rar#s2

A s%(er,e"'e"te Le' 25J5 (are)e a#tar a +'"0a restr't',a8

+'!'ta"# # #7?et# a a&.# # (art'# Y 2

A +e't%ra restr't',a ,e! se"# )r't')aa )#! e)e+e"tes ar$%!e"t#s2Te#r' Za,as)['8 e! #7ra #%tr'"*r'a8 e1e"e 9%e #s (art'#s (#+t')#st:! +e$'t'!'ae a!(+a (ara !a"e?ar a a&.#8 '"e(e"e"te!e"te e,'")%+a&.# )#! '"teresse e se%s 1'+'a#s2 E ,a' a+@!8 s%ste"ta"# 9%e aa&.# (#e ser !a"e?aa (ara a t%te+a e '"teresses '1%s#s8 +'$a#s Ys1'"a+'aes # (art'#2 Ass'!8 %! (art'# )#! (r#$ra!a ,#+ta# (ara a*rea a!7'e"ta+ (#er* re9%erer a se$%ra"&a )#"tra at# #1e"s',# a# !e'#a!7'e"te2 Tra"s)re,#;


8/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

%! (art'# (#+t')# )%?a 7a"e'ra se?a a (r#te&.# # !e'#a!7'e"te "at%ra+ '!(etre !a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#"tra at# e

a%t#r'ae +es',# a# e9%'+7r'# e)#+$')#2 Te!-se a8 se!,'a8 0'(tese e !a"a# e se$%ra"&a (ara t%te+ar 're't#e "at%re/a tra"s'"','%a+8 se! t't%+ar )ert#8 (erte")e"te at##s8 )#!# asse$%ra # art2 a CF>2 ZAVASCKI8 Te#r'2P!"#$%%" #"&$'". J e2 S.# Pa%+#; RT8 542 (2 3-4

Se$%"# e1e"e Te#r' Za,as)['8 #


9/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

Le' "] 25J55 %!a '"ter(reta&.# )#"1#r!e a C#"st't%'&.#(ara e"te"er 9%e # !a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#+et',# também se

est'"a Y (r#te&.# #s 're't# '1%s#s2O art2 ]8 L8 a C#"st't%'&.# Feera+ ".# 1a/ 9%a+9%er+'!'ta&.#8 e,e"# etra'r-se a "#r!a s%a !*'!ae1et','ae8 e s#rte a a!'t'r 9%e # !a"a# e se$%ra"&a)#+et',# s'r,a ".# s#!e"te Y (r#te&.# #s 're't#s )#+et',#s e'"','%a's 0#!#$:"e#s8 !as '$%a+!e"te a#s '1%s#s2

DA CUNHA8 Le#"ar# =#s@ Car"e'r#2 A fazenda públicaem juízo. 2 e2 S.# Pa%+#; D'a+@t')a8 552 ((2 4J - 4652

Na !es!a +'"0a8 =#s@ A1#"s# a S'+,a a1'r!a # se$%'"te;Pe"sa!#s 9%e a re$ra $era+ (re,a+e)e e! t##s #s )as#s

e! 9%e se re)+a!a # direito subjetivo individual #s ass#)'a#s2^222_ N.# se '"')ara!8 (#r@!8 '"teresses e 9%e! #s (art'#s(#+t')#s (#e! e1e"er (e+# !a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#+et',#2Q%est.# a7erta2 L#$#8 e"te"e!#s 9%e e+es (#e! e1e"er're't# s%7?et',# '"','%a+ e se%s !e!7r#s8 ese 9%e sea!'ta8 )#!# se est* a!'t'"#8 9%e # !a"a# e se$%ra"&a

)#+et',# ta!7@! @ !e'# 0*7'+ (ara a e1esa e 're't# s%7?et',#'"','%a+ e '"te$ra"tes a (arte '"st't%)'#"a+ +e$'t'!aa2

^222_ '"teresses +e$t'!#s8 '1%s#s #% )#+et',#s ^222_ F')a #!a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#+et',# s%?e't# a# re9%'s't# # 're't#+9%'# e )ert#

N.# )#"sta essa e'$:")'a # 's(#s't',# )#"st't%)'#"a+9%e # '"st't%'2 O re9%'s't# )#"sta,a a (r#(#sta '"')'a+ #re!@'#8 !as 1#' +#$# e+'!'"a# "as s%)ess',as rea&es #

tet#2 A a+"ea b # '")2 L # art2 ] 1a+a e! '"teresses e".# e! 're't#s2 Ser* 'ss# s%1')'e"te (ara a1astar # re9%'s't#8sa7'# 9%e ta!7@! "a (r'!e'ra (r#(#sta # '"st't%t# seest'"a,a e+e a (r#te$er 're't# +9%'# e )ert#8 !as "a e1esae interesses e !e!7r#s e ass#)'a#s as e"t'aes re1er'asSe # re9%'s't# # 're't# +9%'# e )ert# 1#r e+'!'"a#8 ".# se)#rrer* # r's)# e (erer-se a (r'")'(a+ )ara)terst')a #'"st't%t#8 9%e @ a )e+er'ae

^222_ 9%a"# #s (art'#s (#+t')#s '!(etrare!-"# "a e1esa




10/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

e interesse coletivo difuso e'$e!-se a# !e"#s a '+e$a+'ae e a+es.# # '"teresse 9%e # 1%"a!e"ta2 DA SILVA8 =#s@ A1#"s#2

Curso de direito constitucional positivo. 2 e2 S.# Pa%+#;Ma+0e'r#s8 5532 ((2 4 42

A+ea"re e M#raes ta!7@! @ e"1*t')# "a !es!a +'"0a;

Os (art'#s (#+t')#s8 ese 9%e re(rese"ta#s "#C#"$ress# Na)'#"a+8 t:! +e$'t'!a&.# a!(+a8 (#e"# (r#te$er9%a's9%er '"teresses )#+et',#s #% '1%s#s +'$a#s Y s#)'eae2

^222_ A"#te-se8 (#r@!8 9%e ".# 1#' esse # e"te"'!e"t# #+e$'s+a#r8 a# esta7e+e)er "# art2 a Le' "] 25J58 9%e #!a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#+et',# (#er* ser '!(etra# (#r(art'# (#+t')# )#! re(rese"ta&.# "# C#"$ress# Na)'#"a+8 "ae1esa e se%s '"teresses +e$t'!#s re+at',#s a se%s'"te$ra"tes #% Y 1'"a+'ae (art'*r'a2

N.# "#s (are)e a !e+0#r s#+%&.# re1%ta!#-as8 '")+%s',e8'")#"st't%)'#"a+2 Ora8 se t## # (#er e!a"a # (#,#8 9%e #eer)e (#r !e'# e re(rese"ta"tes e+e't#s #% 'reta!e"te8 "#s

ter!#s a C#"st't%'&.# CF8 art2 ]8 (ar*$ra1# "')#8 se"#'"'s(e"s*,e+ (ara # eer))'# a )a(a)'ae e+e't#ra+ (ass',aelegibilidade) # a+'sta!e"t# e+e't#ra+ CF8 art2 48 3]8 III8 a ra/.#a e'st:")'a #s (art'#s (#+t')#s @ a (r(r'a subsistncia do!stado "emocr#tico e D're't# e a (reser,a&.# #s 're't#s e$ara"t'as 1%"a!e"ta's CF8 art2 ]8 V )#"sa$ra # (+%ra+'s!#(#+t')# )#!# %! #s 1%"a!e"t#s a Re(7+')a Feerat',a #Bras'+2 Nesta este'ra e ra)'#)"'#8 # +e$'s+a#r )#"st't%'"te

(rete"e 1#rta+e):-+#s )#")ee"#-+0es +e$'t'!a&.# (ara #!a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#+et',#8 (ara a e1esa a (r(r'as#)'eae )#"tra at#s '+e$a's #% a7%s',#s (#r (arte aa%t#r'ae (7+')a2 Cer)ear essa +e$'t'!a&.# s#!e"te (ara se%s(r(r'#s '"teresses #% e se%s 1'+'a#s @ ret'rar #s (art'#s(#+t')#s a )ara)terst')a e esse")'a+'ae e! %! Esta#De!#)r*t')# e D're't# e tra"s1#r!*-+# e! !era ass#)'a&.#(r',aa8 # 9%e8 )erta!e"te8 ".# 1#' a '"te"&.# # +e$'s+a#r)#"st't%'"te2 MORAES8 A+ea"re2 "ireito Constitucional. 32

5




11/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

e2 S.# Pa%+#; At+as S2A28 52 ((2 66

A )#")ret'/a&.# # 's(#s't',# )#"st't%)'#"a+ 9%e (re,: a+e$'t'!'ae # %s# # !a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#+et',# (#r (art'#(#+t')# a'"a @ %!a #7ra e! a"a!e"t#2 Os +'!'tes # art2 a Le'25J5 ser,e! )#!# '"')at',#8 !as )erta!e"te ".# )#!# +'!'te as0'(teses e )a7'!e"t# a a&.#2 Trata"#-se e $ara"t'a )#"st't%)'#"a+8".# (#er'a # +e$'s+a#r restr'"$'r se%s )#"t#r"#s (ara a+@! e se%

s'$"'1')a#2 Nesse se"t'#8 +e)'#"a A+ea"re e M#raes;


12/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

e)ess',a!e"te restr't',a2 C#!# 7e! a"#ta# (#r Te#r' Za,as)['8 - op. cit$ (2 J2

P#r #%tr# +a#8 @ (re)'s# ter )%'a# (ara e,'tar 9%e a a&.# )#"1'ra%!a +e$'t'!'ae %"',ersa+ a#s (art'#s (#+t')#s2 O )r't@r'# a 1'"a+'ae(art'*r'a @ %!a +'!'ta&.# se$%ra e )#rreta2

Mas )re'# 9%e a !e+0#r '"ter(reta&.# a'"a (re)'sa 'r %! (ass#a+@!2 A9%' e,e ser 1e't# %! (ara+e+# )#! # !a"a# e se$%ra"&a

'!(etra# )#"tra es,'#s "# (r#)ess# +e$'s+at',#2A'"a s#7 a C#"st't%'&.# e J6J8 # S%(re!# Tr'7%"a+ Feera+8

"# MS 526 MS 5268 Re+2 M'"2 M#re'ra A+,es8 RT=8 35458e"te"e% a!'ss,e+ a '!(etra&.# e !a"a# e se$%ra"&a )#"tra at#a Mesa a CW!ara #% # Se"a# Feera+8 asse,era"# 9%e8 9%a"# MS 5268 Re+2 M'"2 M#re'ra A+,es8 RT=8 35452

At%a+!e"te8 a ?%r's(r%:")'a # Tr'7%"a+ est* (a)'1')aa "# se"t'#e 9%e MS 42J48 Re+2 M'"2 Car+#s

Ve++#s#8 D= e 2J2554 MS 524DF8 Re+2 M'"2 A+'r Passar'"0#8 RT=8J 46 MS 2J4DF8 Re+2 M'"2 Ce+s# e Me++#8 RDA8 55 MS42J4DF8 Re+2 M'"2 Ce+s# e Me++#8 D= e 22553 MS 423DF8 Re+2M'"2 Ma%r)'# C#rr:a8 D= e 22553 MS 426JDF8 Re+2 M'"2 E++e"Gra)'e8 D= e 22553 MS 423JDF8 Re+2 M'"2 Car+#s Ve++#s#8 D= e225532

Ta!7@! a9%' se a1'$%ra e,'e"te 9%e se )%'a e %!a %t'+'/a&.#es(e)'a+ # !a"a# e se$%ra"&a8 ".# eata!e"te (ara asse$%rar




13/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

're't# +9%'# e )ert# e (ar+a!e"tar8 !as (ara res#+,er (e)%+'ar )#"1+'t#e atr'7%'&es #% 2

E! a!7#s #s )as#s e ,'#+a&.# Y (re!'ssa e ,a+'ae # (r#)ess#+e$'s+at',#8 @ )a7,e+ # !a"a# e se$%ra"&a (ara res$%arar are$%+ar'ae ?%r')#-)#"st't%)'#"a+ # (r#)ess# (#+t')# e e+'7era&.# ea(r#,a&.# e +e's MS 5268 Re+2 M'"2 D@)'# M'ra"a8 D= e 622MS 42J48 Re+2 M'"2 Car+#s Ve++#s#8 D= e 2J25542

E! 4-4-538 1#' )#")e'a +'!'"ar "# MS 325338 Re+2 M'"2 G'+!arMe"es8 (ara s%s(e"er a tra!'ta&.# e (r#?et# e +e' 9%e se )#"s'era,a,'#+a#r e )+*%s%+as (@treas8 %!a ,e/ 9%e8 e"tre #%tr#s ,)'#s e

'")#"st't%)'#"a+'ae 9%e a(rese"ta,a8 '!(+')a,a # trata!e"t# ".#'s#"!')# e"tre (art'#s e (ar+a!e"tares 9%e se e")#"tra,a! e!s't%a&.# ':"t')a2 O P+e"*r'# # S%(re!# Tr'7%"a+8 (#r !a'#r'a e ,#t#s8)#"0e)e% # !a"a# e se$%ra"&a8 )#"1'r!a"# a tra')'#"a+

?%r's(r%:")'a a C#rte a)er)a # )a7'!e"t# a '!(etra&.# (re,e"t',ae! e1esa # 're't# (7+')# s%7?et',# # (ar+a!e"tar e ".# ses%7!eter a (r#)ess# +e$'s+at',# e',a# e '")#"st't%)'#"a+'ae ,)'#1#r!a+ #% )%?a (r#(#s'&.# a(rese"taa tra$a (r#(#sta te"e"te a a7#+'r)+*%s%+as (@treas a C#"st't%'&.# Feera+2 N# !@r't#8 t#a,'a8 (#r!a'#r'a e ,#t#s8 a C#rte ".# re1ere"#% a (#s'&.# # re+at#r ?%+$a!e"t#1'"a+'/a# e! 52J2532

Esse t'(# e a&.# @ %! !e)a"'s!# e e1esa '"st't%)'#"a+8 %!asa+,a$%ara as (rerr#$at',as as !'"#r'as (ar+a!e"tares )#"tra a7%s#s)#!et'#s (e+a !a'#r'a2

A9%' (#e ser )#"str%a s#+%&.# (ara+e+a2 \ 7e! ,erae 9%e ".#

se est* )%'a"# e (r#)ess# +e$'s+at',#8 !as e at# a!'"'strat',# ee1e't#s )#")ret#s # P#er Ee)%t',#2

Mas8 (e+a '"e'st:")'a e +es.# '!e'ata a 're't#s '"','%a's8 a#(#s'&.# ".# 's(e e a&.# 9%e (#ssa ata)ar '!e'ata!e"te # at#a+e$aa!e"te )#"tr*r'# a# 're't#2

E'ste a (#ss'7'+'ae e t%te+a ,'a a&.# (#(%+ar8 !as essa ,'a ".# @a7erta a#s (art'#s (#+t')#s2 A+@! 'ss#8 # !a"a# e se$%ra"&a @ %!aa&.# 9%e8 a# !e"#s e! re$ra8 t%te+a '"teresses ta!7@! (ass,e's e

3




14/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

sa+,a$%ara e! ,'as #r'"*r'as2A #(#s'&.# te! )+ar# '"teresse e! +e,ar a# ?%')'*r'# at#s

a!'"'strat',#s e e1e't#s )#")ret#s +es',#s a 're't#s '1%s#s2E "#ss# s'ste!a )#"sa$ra a t%te+a e ,'#+a&es a 're't#s '1%s#s

)#!# %! ,a+#r a ser 7%s)a#8 "a (ers(e)t',a # a)ess# Y ?%r's'&.#2N# (rese"te )as#8 est.# e! a(re)'a&.# ,*r'#s !a"a#s e

se$%ra"&a e! )ar*ter )#+et',# '!(etra#s (#r (art'#s (#+t')#s )#!re(rese"ta&.# "# C#"$ress# Na)'#"a+8 ".# '"te$ra"tes a 7ase a+'aa8)#"tra at# a Pres'e"te a Re(7+')a2

L#$#8 trata-se e %!a ,'a e e1esa a #re! '"st't%)'#"a+ 9%e (#e

ser ,a+'a!e"te ese",#+,'a e a)e'ta2Fe'tas essas )#"s'era&es8 te"0# (#r )a7,e's as a&es e !a"a#

e se$%ra"&a2

Pass# a a(re)'ar #s (e'#s +'!'"ares (r#(r'a!e"te 't#s2A (art'r # )as# Nata" D#"a#"8 # STF )#"s#+'#% ?%r's(r%:")'a

"# se"t'# e 9%e a re"")'a a )ar$#s (7+')#s 9%e )#"1ere! (rerr#$at',ae 1#r#8 )#! # ,e+a# #7?et',# e es)a(ar a# ?%+$a!e"t# e! '!'":")'a8)#"1'$%ra es,'# e 1'"a+'ae8 '"a(t# a a1astar a )#!(et:")'a (ara #

?%+$a!e"t# a )a%sa AP 3J8 Re+2 M'"2 C*r!e" L)'a8 Tr'7%"a+ P+e"#8 ?%+$aa e! 252552

A s't%a&.# a9%' e",#+,e # )#"tr*r'#2 A a+e$a&.# @ e 9%e (ess#a 1#'"#!eaa (ara # )ar$# e M'"'str# e Esta# (ara es+#)ar # 1#r# (ara #STF e sa+,a$%arar-se )#"tra e,e"t%a+ a&.# (e"a+ se! a a%t#r'/a&.#(ar+a!e"tar (re,'sta "# art2 8 I8 a CF2

E! est%# ('#"e'r# s#7re # te!a8 V+a'!'r Pass#s e Fre'tase1e"e 9%e # at# e "#!ear (ess#a (ara +0e atr'7%'r 1#r# (r','+e$'a# @"%+#;


15/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

%!a $ra"e 9%a"t'ae e )ar$#s e! )#!'ss.#2 P#r ee!(+#8%! ,erea#r est* se"# '",est'$a# (#r )r'!e e (e#1'+'a e

)#"se$%e "#!ea&.# (ara # )ar$# e se)ret*r'# e Esta#8s%7tra'"#-se a a&.# # (r#!#t#r a )#!ar)a e s%?e'ta"#-sea %!a a&.# "# Tr'7%"a+ e =%st'&a8 #"e # (r#)ess# a"ar* !a's+e"ta!e"te2

E! )as# )#!# # # ee!(+# )'ta#8 @ (re)'s# ,er'1')ar se a1'"a+'ae # at# a!'"'strat',# e "#!ea&.# 1#' et%r(aa8 a1'! e at'"$'r #7?et',# ',ers# # s'!%+a#2 Oete Mea%ar @)+ara a# '/er 9%e # 1'! e '"teresse (7+')# ,'")%+a a at%a&.## a$e"te8 '!(e'"# a '"te"&.# (ess#a+ MEDAUAR8 Oete2

D're't# A!'"'strat',# M#er"#8 62 e2 S.# Pa%+#; RT8 538 (262 Se #s !#t',#s 1#re! a(e"as a(are"tes8 (#r9%e # 1'!ese?a# @ #%tr#8 #)#rrer* es,'# e 1'"a+'ae2 \ # )as#8 (#ree!(+#8 a re!#&.# e %! (#+')'a+ s#7 # ar$%!e"t# e 9%ee+e se "e)ess'ta e! #%tr# !%"')('#8 9%a"#8 "a ,erae8 ##7?et',# @ a1ast*-+# a '",est'$a&.# e eter!'"a# )as#2

He+ L#(es Me're++es8 )#! a )+are/a 9%e !ar)#% s%as#7ras8 e"s'"a 9%e # es,'# e 1'"a+'ae #% e (#er se ,er'1')a

9%a"# a a%t#r'ae8 e!7#ra at%a"# "#s +'!'tes e s%a)#!(et:")'a8 (rat')a # at# (#r !#t',#s #% )#! 1'"s ',ers#s#s #7?et',a#s (e+a +e' #% e'$'#s (e+# '"teresse (7+')#MEIRELLES8 He+ L#(es2 D're't# A!'"'strat',# Bras'+e'r#842 e2 S.# Pa%+#; RT8 8 (2 22 Ce+s# A"t#"'# Ba"e'ra eMe++# e"1at'/a 9%e8 a (r#(s't# # %s# e %! at# (ara a+)a"&ar1'"a+'ae ',ersa a 9%e +0e @ (r(r'a8 )#st%!a se 1a+ar e!es,'# e (#er #% es,'# e 1'"a+'ae> BANDEIRA DE

MELLO8 Ce+s# A"t"'#8 E+e!e"t#s e D're't#A!'"'strat',#2 S.# Pa%+#; RT8 68 (2 462A )#"se9%:")'a essa et%r(a&.# # #7?et',#8 9%e "a

rea+'ae a!'"'strat',a 7ras'+e'ra ".# @ rara8 @ a "%+'ae #at#2 L%)as R#)0a F%rta#8 e 1#r!a #7?et',a8 #7ser,a 9%e8'"e(e"e"te!e"te e 9%a+9%er #%tr# ,)'#8 se # at# 1#'(rat')a# )#"trar'a"# a 1'"a+'ae +e$a+ 9%e ?%st'1')#% a#%t#r$a e )#!(et:")'a (ara a (r*t')a # at#8 e+e @ "%+#FURTADO8 L%)as R#)0a2 C%rs# e D're't# A!'"'strat',#2




16/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

Be+# H#r'/#"te; Fr%!8 5568 (2 3532Para arre!atar8 a Le' a A&.# P#(%+ar8 42668 e J8

a1'r!a 9%e @ "%+# # at# a!'"'strat',# (rat')a# )#! es,'# e1'"a+'ae e "# art'$# 8 (ar*$ra1# "')#8 a+"ea e(+')'ta9%e;

e # es,'# e 1'"a+'ae se ,er'1')a 9%a"# # a$e"te(rat')a # at# ,'sa"# a 1'! ',ers# a9%e+e (re,'st#8 e(+)'ta#% '!(+')'ta!e"te8 "a re$ra e )#!(et:")'a2

Se ass'! @8 )#"1#r!e e"s'"a!e"t# %"'1#r!e a !e+0#r#%tr'"a8 resta a(e"as sa7er )#!#8 "# )as# )#")ret#8 se)#")+%'r* (e+a e'st:")'a #% ".# e 'ss'!%+a&.#2

E,'e"te!e"te8 # at# se!(re ser* e'ta# )#! 7ase e!(re!'ssas 1a+sas8 a(are"te!e"te ,erae'ras2

A res(#sta est* "a a"*+'se as )'r)%"stW")'as2 P#r ee!(+#8'!a$'"e-se 9%e %! !@')# re"#!a#8 (#rta#r e tt%+#sa)a:!')#s8 se?a )#",'a# (ara ass%!'r a Se)retar'a e Sae# Esta# e 9%e res(#"a8 "# =%'/a# Es(e)'a+ Cr'!'"a+8 (e+#)r'!e e +eses )#r(#ra's +e,es8 e! ,'rt%e e %! s#)#es1er'# e! se% ,'/'"0# e! !e'# a %!a a)a+#raa 's)%ss.#

e! asse!7+e'a e )#"#!"'#2 Ser'a r')%+# '!a$'"ar 9%e a'"')a&.# e se% "#!e ,'sa,a s%7tra'r # =EC a )#!(et:")'a(ara (r#)ess*-+#8 (assa"#-a a# Tr'7%"a+ e =%st'&a2

N# e"ta"t#8 ',ersa ser* a s't%a&.# se a '"')a&.# 1#r 1e'taa %! e"t'sta e",#+,'# e! $ra,es a)%sa&es e est%(r# e(a)'e"tes (ara #)%(ar # )ar$# e !'"'str# #s Tra"s(#rtes8 "#!#!e"t# eat# e! 9%e # Tr'7%"a+ e =%st'&a ?%+$ar* a(e+a&.#)#"tra se"te"&a 9%e # )#"e"#% a 5 a"#s e re)+%s.#2 A #

#7?et',# ser* 1+a$ra"te!e"te # e e,'tar # ?%+$a!e"t# (e+# T= ea !a"%te"&.# a se"te"&a )#"e"atr'a e a s%a ee)%&.#'!e'ata8 tra"s1er'"# # )as# (ara # S%(re!# Tr'7%"a+ Feera+2O at# a!'"'strat',# ser* "%+# (#r e,'e"te es,'# e1'"a+'ae2

A #)#rr:")'a esse t'(# e es,'# e )#"%ta s%?e'tar* aa%t#r'ae a!'"'strat',a8 se?a e+a !e!7r# # P#erLe$'s+at',#8 (re1e't#8 $#,er"a#r8 (res'e"te a Re(7+')a #%#%tra # se$%"# es)a+.# # Ee)%t',#8 a a&.# (#(%+ar e8 a'"a8

J




17/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

a&.# #r'"*r'a e "%+'ae # at#8 ?%"t# )#! a U"'.#8 9%e(#er* ser (r#(#sta "# 1#r# 1eera+ # #!')+'# # a%t#r2

Na ,erae8 as (r*t')as a!'"'strat',as (assa!8 "# Bras'+8(#r %! 1+a$ra"te (r#)ess# e !%a"&a2 Basta ,er a#7r'$at#r'eae at%a+ a tra"s(ar:")'a #s at#sa!'"'strat',#s8 '"'!a$'"*,e+ 0* %as #% tr:s @)aas2 Ass'!8#s a!'"'stra#res8 se?a 9%a+ 1#r # ",e+ #% # P#er e Esta# a9%e (erte"&a!8 e,e! se a)a%te+ar "a )#"%&.# e se%s at#s8(#'s8 e! 7#a 0#ra8 1')#% (ara tr*s # te!(# # 2

O (r'")('# a !#ra+'ae (a%ta 9%a+9%er at# a!'"'strat',#8'")+%s',e a "#!ea&.# e M'"'str# e Esta#8 e !a"e'ra a '!(e'r 9%ese?a! )#"s(%r)a#s #s (re')a#s a 0#"est'ae8 a (r#7'ae e a

7#a-1@ "# trat# a


18/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

222II - a '",est'%ra e! )ar$# #% e!(re$# (7+')# e(e"e

e a(r#,a&.# (r@,'a e! )#")%rs# (7+')# e (r#,as #% e(r#,as e tt%+#s8 e a)#r# )#! a "at%re/a e a )#!(+e'ae #)ar$# #% e!(re$#8 "a 1#r!a (re,'sta e! +e'8 ressa+,aas as"#!ea&es (ara )ar$# e! )#!'ss.# e)+ara# e! +e' e +',re"#!ea&.# e e#"era&.# X>2 $r'1#%-se

P#r s%a ,e/8 # art2 6 a Le' Ma'#r e"%")'a;


19/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

)#"s'eraas t#as as )'r)%"stW")'as8 e,e! )#"s'erar-se (r#'7'as>2ATIENZA8 Ma"%e+ MANERO8 =%a" R%'2 I+)'t#s At(')#s2 e2 Mar';

E't#ra+ Tr#tta8 55J8 (2 E (#r 9%e e,e! ser )#"s'eraas (r#'7'as P#r9%e8 a es(e't# e

s%a a(ar:")'a e +e$a+'ae8 (#r9%e8 a es(e't# e estare!8 Y (r'!e'ra,'sta8 e! )#"1#r!'ae )#! %!a re$ra8 est#a! a ra/.# 9%e a ?%st'1')a8es)a(a! a# (r'")('# e a# '"teresse 9%e +0e @ s%7?a)e"te2 Trata-ses'!(+es!e"te e $ara"t'r )#er:")'a ,a+#rat',a #% ?%st'1')at',a a# s'ste!a

?%r')# e e a(artar8 )#! )+are/a8 's)r')'#"ar'eae e ar7'trar'eae2O !es!# ra)'#)"'# a7ar)a #s tr:s '"st't%t#s 7e! )#"0e)'#s a

"#ssa #%tr'"a; a7%s# e 're't#8 1ra%e Y +e' e es,'# e1'"a+'ae(#er2 T##s s.# '+)'t#s at(')#s e t:! e! )#!%! #s se$%'"tese+e!e"t#s; a e'st:")'a e a&.# 9%e8 prima facie 8 estar'a e!)#"1#r!'ae )#! %!a re$ra ?%r')a a (r#%&.# e %! res%+ta#a"#s# )#!# )#"se9%:")'a8 '"te")'#"a+ #% ".#8 a a&.# 3 # )ar*ter'"?%st'1')a# # res%+ta# a"#s#8 Y +%/ #s (r'")('#s ?%r')#s a(+')*,e'sa# )as# e 4 # esta7e+e)'!e"t# e %!a se$%"a re$ra 9%e +'!'ta # a+)a")ea (r'!e'ra (ara 9%a+'1')ar )#!# (r#'7'#s #s )#!(#rta!e"t#s 9%e a"tesse a(rese"ta,a! tra,est'#s e +e$a+'ae2

Es(e)'1')a!e"te "#s )as#s e es,'# e 1'"a+'ae8 # 9%e se te! @ aa#&.# e %!a )#"%ta 9%e a(are"ta estar e! )#"1#r!'ae )#! %!)erte re$ra 9%e )#"1ere (#er Y a%t#r'ae re$ra e )#!(et:")'a8 !as9%e8 a# 1'!8 )#"%/ a res%+ta#s a7s#+%ta!e"te '")#!(at,e's )#! #es)#(# )#"st't%)'#"a+ esse !a"a!e"t# e8 (#r 'ss#8 @ t'a )#!# '+)'ta2

A(+')a"# essas "#&es a# )as# e! te+a8 te!-se 9%e a Pres'e"te a

Re(7+')a (rat')#% )#"%ta 9%e8 a priori 8 estar'a e! )#"1#r!'ae )#! aatr'7%'&.# 9%e +0e )#"1ere # art2 48 '")'s# I8 a C#"st't%'&.# "#!earM'"'str#s e Esta#2 Mas8 a# 1a/:-+#8 (r#%/'% res%+ta# )#")ret# e t##'")#!(at,e+ )#! a #re! )#"st't%)'#"a+ e! ,'$#r; )#"1er'r a#'",est'$a# 1#r# "# S%(re!# Tr'7%"a+ Feera+2

N.# '!(#rta! #s !#t',#s s%7?et',#s e 9%e! (rat')a # at# '+)'t#2 O,)'#8 # '+)'t#8 te! "at%re/a #7?et',a2 A 7e! '/er8 a )#!(r#,a&.# #s!#t',#s s%7?et',#s 9%e '!(e+'ra! a !a"at*r'a Y (r*t')a8 "# )as# e! te+a8




20/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

)#"1'$%ra e+e!e"t# a !a's a '"')ar a (rese"&a # ,)'# e! 9%est.#8 'st#@8 # es,'# e 1'"a+'ae2

A r'$#r8 ".# )a7e '",est'$ar a9%' # #+#8 a '"te"&.# e 1ra%ar a +e'2N.# est* e! 9%est.# sa7er se a Pres'e"te (rat')#% )r'!e8 )#!%! #% eres(#"sa7'+'ae2 N.# @ 'ss# 9%e se )%'a2

\ eata!e"te esse (a"# e 1%"# 9%e e,e "#rtear a a"*+'se ee,e"t%a+ es,'# e 1'"a+'ae "a "#!ea&.# e M'"'str# e Esta#2

Nesse )#"tet#8 # ar$%!e"t# # es,'# e 1'"a+'ae @(er1e'ta!e"te a(+')*,e+ (ara e!#"strar a "%+'ae a "#!ea&.# e(ess#a )r'!'"a+!e"te '!(+')aa8 9%a"# (re(#"era a 1'"a+'ae e

)#"1er'r-+0e 1#r# (r','+e$'a#2N# )as# )#")ret#8 a a+e$a&.# @ e 9%e # e-Pres'e"te L%'/ I"*)'#

L%+a a S'+,a ter'a s'# e!(#ssa# ?%sta!e"te (ara es+#)ar # 1#r# (ara #STF e sa+,a$%arar )#"tra e,e"t%a+ a&.# (e"a+ se! a a%t#r'/a&.#(ar+a!e"tar (re,'sta "# art2 8 I8 a CF2

Ha,'a '",est'$a&es e! a"a!e"t#8 9%e 1')ar'a! (ara+'saas (e+a!%a"&a e 1#r#8 %!a e+as 9%e e"se?#% !e'as e 7%s)a e a(ree"s.#)#"tra L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a O(era&.# A+et0e'a8 es#7ra!e"t# aLa,a =at#2 Ha,'a %!a e"")'a (e"e"te e a(re)'a&.#8 a)#!(a"0aa e%! (e'# e e)reta&.# e (r's.# (re,e"t',a )as# Ba")##(2

\ !%'t# )+ar# # t%!%+t# )a%sa# a# (r#$ress# as '",est'$a&es8(e+a !%a"&a e 1#r#2 E


21/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

)#!(et:")'a # Tr'7%"a+ e! )as# e re"")'a e! 1ase e ?%+$a!e"t#8 ".#ser'a "e)ess*r'# ,er'1')ar #s !#t',#s "t'!#s 9%e +e,ara! Y (r*t')a # at#2

A s'!(+es "#!ea&.#8 ass'! )#!# a re"")'a8 e!#"stra!s%1')'e"te!e"te a 1ra%e Y C#"st't%'&.#2

Mas8 "este )as#8 # e+e!e"t# s%7?et',# @ re,e+a# (#r r'9%e/a(r#7atr'a 9%e ".# !ere)e (assar es(er)e7'a2

As '!(etra&es s.# a!(araas e! (r#,as (r#%/'as "# Pr#)ess#55J55J45465558 a 3 Vara Feera+ e C%r't'7a8 "# 9%a+ 1#'eter!'"aa a '"ter)e(ta&.# e ,*r'#s te+e1#"es8 e"tre e+es ter!'"a's%t'+'/a#s (#r L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a2

E! e)'s.# ataa e J238 # ?%'/ a )a%sa +e,a"t#% # s'$'+# as$ra,a&es8 (e+# 9%e ".# 0* 7')e e! %t'+'/a&.# )#!# (r#,a "este(r#)e'!e"t# e2 32

A"tes e (r#$re'r8 @ '"'s(e"s*,e+ a,a+'ar a (#ss'7'+'ae e #'*+#$# e"tre a Pres'e"te a Re(7+')a e L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,atra,a# "a tare # 'a J238 3038 (#er ser '",#)a# (arae!#"stra&.# #s 1at#s2 A ,a+'ae a '"ter)e(ta&.# @ (%7+')a!e"te)#"testaa8 (#r ter s'# rea+'/aa a(s #re! ?%')'a+ (ara a s%s(e"s.##s (r#)e'!e"t#s2

De 1at#8 0#%,e e)'s.# eter!'"a"# a '"terr%(&.# as'"ter)e(ta&es e! J2325J8 Ys 032 A #re! ".# 1#' '!e'ata!e"te)%!(r'a8 # 9%e +e,#% a# es,'# e $ra,a&.# # *%'# !e")'#"a#2

N# !#!e"t#8 ".# @ "e)ess*r'# e!'t'r ?%/# s#7re a +')'t%e a$ra,a&.# e! te+a2 H* )#"1'ss.# s#7re a e'st:")'a e )#"te# a )#",ersa8

s%1')'e"te (ara )#!(r#,ar # 1at#2E! (e+# !e"#s %as #(#rt%"'aes8 a Pres'e"te a Re(7+')a

a!'t'% a )#",ersa8 1a/e"# re1er:")'as a# se% )#"te#2 U!a e+as8 %!a"#ta #1')'a+8 ataa e 9+!'+5$!+6 1 $ *+!," $ 8016 9% 83;


22/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

te+e1#"e!a !a"t'# e"tre # e-(res'e"te L%+a e a (res'e"taD'+!a R#%sse118 se"#8 "# 'a e 0#?e8 ',%+$a#8 '+e$a+!e"te8

(#r e)'s.# a =%st'&a Feera+ # Para"*2A (res'e"ta ass'"ar* # #)%!e"t# a!a"0. 68 e!s#+e"'ae (7+')a e (#sse8 esta"# (rese"te #% ".# # e-(res'e"te L%+a2

A tra"s!'ss.# e )ar$# e"tre # !'"'str# =a9%es da$"er e #e-(res'e"te L%+a 1#' !ar)aa (ara a (r'!a ter&a 1e'ra 2Trata-se e !#!e"t# 'st'"t# a (#sse2

F'"a+!e"te8 )a7e es)+are)er 9%e "# '*+#$# e"tre # e-(res'e"te L%+a e a (res'e"te D'+!a a e(ress.# (ra $e"te ter

e+e s'$"'1')a # $#,er"# ter # ter!# e (#sse8 ass'"a# (e+#(res'e"te L%+a8 (ara e! )as# e s%a a%s:")'a ?* (#er!#s%t'+'/*-+# "a )er'!"'a e a!a"0.2 P#r 'ss#8 # ,er7# ".# @ !as s'! # $#,er"# %sar # re1er'# ter!# e (#sse2

Ass'!8 # '*+#$# 1#' rea+'/a# )#! 7ase "#s (r'")('#sre(%7+')a"#s e e"tr# a estr'ta +e$a+'ae2

Se)retar'a e I!(re"saSe)retar'a e C#!%"')a&.# S#)'a+ a Pres':")'a a Re(7+')a>2

O%tra8 's)%rs# (r#1er'# (e+a Pres'e"te a Re(7+')a (#r #)as'.#a (#sse # !e")'#"a# !'"'str#8 "a !a"0. e 6232

O% se?a8 0* %!a a!'ss.# (ess#a+ a e'st:")'a a )#",ersa e aa%te"t')'ae # )#"te# a $ra,a&.#2

Esta!#s 'a"te e %! )as# e )#"1'ss.# etra?%')'a+8 )#! 1#r&a (ara(r#,ar a )#",ersa e se% )#"te#8 e 1#r!a '"e(e"e"te a'"ter)e(ta&.# te+e1"')a2 A(+')a!-se8 a9%'8 # art2 8 I8 # C'$# C','+

)#!7'"a# )#! # art2 33 # C'$# e Pr#)ess# C','+8 ,'$e"te (#r#)as'.# as e)+ara&es;


23/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

Art2 332 A )#"1'ss.# etra?%')'a+8 1e'ta (#r es)r't# Y (arte#% a 9%e! a re(rese"te8 te! a !es!a e1')*)'a (r#7atr'a a

?%')'a+ 1e'ta a ter)e'r#8 #% )#"t'a e! testa!e"t#8 ser*+',re!e"te a(re)'aa (e+# ?%'/>2

A )#"1'ss.# ".# !ere)er'a '",a+'a&.# (e+# "e# )#! a (r#,a '+)'ta $ra,a&.# se! a%t#r'/a&.#2 A a!'ss.# 1#' es(#"tW"ea8 "a !e'a e!9%e s#7re e+a ".# 0#%,e '"a$a&.# (#r a%t#r'ae2 A '"')'at',a e)#!e"tar a )#",ersa8 a!'t'"# se% )#"te#8 !as )#"testa"# s%a

'"ter(reta&.#8 1#' a (r(r'a a%t#r'ae '!(etraa2 E+a ".# esta,a s#7'"terr#$atr'#2 T#!#% a '"')'at',a e se (r#"%")'ar2

Ass'!8 sa+,# 0'(tese e a"%+a&.# a )#"1'ss.# err# e 1at# #%)#a&.# 0#%,e %!a a!'ss.# 'rre,#$*,e+ #s 1at#s8 9%e t#r"a 'rre+e,a"te9%a+9%er e7ate a)er)a a ,a+'ae as $ra,a&es8 "a 1#r!a # art2 4# CC;

2

U+tra(assa# esse (#"t#8 (ass# a a,a+'ar a (r#,a2\ "#tr'# 9%e # e-Pres'e"te L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a era (ess#a e

'"teresse e! %as $ra"es '",est'$a&es re+at',as a 1at#s #)#rr'#s "# se%$#,er"#; O(era&.# Ze+#tes e O(era&.# La,a =at#2

E! 42325J8 !e'as #ste"s',as "# W!7't# a O(era&.# La,a =at#

re,e+ara! 9%e # e-Pres'e"te esta,a s#7 '",est'$a&.#2De 1#r!a (ara+e+a8 # e-Pres'e"te era '",est'$a# "%! es9%e!a e

1ra%es8 es,'# e re)%rs#s e +a,a$e! e '"0e'r# "# W!7't# a)##(erat',a Ba")##(2 E! 52325J8 1#' e+e e"%")'a# (e+# M'"'st@r'#P7+')# e S.# Pa%+#2 Na (e&a8 1#' (#st%+aa a e)reta&.# a (r's.#(re,e"t',a2 E! 42325J8 1%"aa "a )#"e.# )#! as '",est'$a&es aO(era&.# La,a =at#8 a ?%/a a 4 Vara Cr'!'"a+ e S.# Pa%+# e)+'"#% a

)#!(et:")'a a res(e)t',a a&.# (e"a+ (ara # =%/# res(#"s*,e+ (#r a9%e+a

3




24/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

O(era&.#8 a 3 Vara Feera+ e C%r't'7a2O% se?a8 (a'ra,a )e"*r'# 9%e '"')a,a 9%e8 "#s (r'!#s

es#7ra!e"t#s8 # e-Pres'e"te (#er'a ser '!(+')a# e! %+ter'#res'",est'$a&es8 (res# (re,e"t',a!e"te e (r#)essa# )r'!'"a+!e"te2

A ass%"&.# e )ar$# e M'"'str# e Esta# ser'a %!a 1#r!a )#")retae #7star essas )#"se9%:")'as2

As )#",ersas '"ter)e(taas )#! a%t#r'/a&.# a 3 Vara Feera+ eC%r't'7a a(#"ta! "# se"t'# e 9%e 1#' esse # (r#(s't# a "#!ea&.#2

E! 2325J8 Ys 08 L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a !a"t@! )#",ersa)#! # )'e"t'sta (#+t')# A+7ert# Car+#s2 Este '/ 9%e a"a+'s#% se% )as# e

9%e a "')a )0a")e e es)a(ar a (r's.# ser'a a ass%"&.# e %!M'"'st@r'#2 Tra"s)re,#;


25/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

@ %! t%)a"#8 1#r!a&.# OPUS DEI e #)a)ete Y 9%atr#8 e"te"e% E+e t* a+'8

e(e"e a )a7e&a e+e8 s "a )a7e&ae+e8 e"te"e% Va' 9%e esse )ara @ !a+%)# e #%sa# s%1')'e"te(ra t#!ar %!a e)'s.# "essa 're&.# V#): %!a )#'sa "a t%a!.# 0#?e Usa )ara+0#

LILS; %0%!!ALBERTO CARLOS; V#): e"te"e% \ a+ar!'sta !es!#8

e"te"e% P#rra8 ,a''")e"'ar # (as se esse )ara 1'/er8 e+e ".# @ %! 0#!e! "a(#+t')a2

LILS; E"t.#8 e'a e% te 1a+ar %!a )#'sa8e% at@8 at@ a)0# 9%e e+e e,e 1a/er(ra ,er # 9%e a)#"te)e222P#r9%e ,e?a8 e%9%er#8 e% t ,',e"# %!a s't%a&.# ea"#r!a+'ae8 #% se?a8 esses )aras (#e!'",est'$ar !'"0a )#"ta "a )asa # )ara+0#8 9%e ".# ,.#e")#"trar %! )e"ta,#2 Esses )aras sa7e! 9%e e%".# te"0# a(arta!e"t#8 esses )aras sa7e! 9%e e% ".# te"0# a

)0*)ara8 esses )aras sa7e! 9%e ".# s e% 1'/ !%'ta(a+estra8 )#!# e% 1%' # !a's 7e! (a$#)#"1ere")'sta # )#!e s@)%+# 2 S e%e # C+'"t#"222E% ".# se' se # St'$+'t/e(#'s8 sa7e A$#ra se # )'a.# )#!e&aa +e,a"tar s%s(e'ta e t%# 'ss#8 e% 9%er# ,er)#!# @ 9%e e+es ,.# (r#,ar 9%e e% te"0# %!a )0*)ara8 )#!# @e+es ,.# (r#,ar 9%e e% te"0# %! a(arta!e"t#2

P#r9%e a+$%@! ,a' ter 9%e (a$ar< (ra !'!ter>2 P#r9%e e% ".# (#ss# ter8 se! (a$ar222ALBERTO CARLOS; \8 !as a# a 1#r!a )#! # (r#)ess# @)#"st't%#8 e+es ?* 1'/era! 'ss#8 e"te"e% V#): ,a' 7#tar ae1esa8 e e+es ,.# '/er8 a"e-se E+e a)a7#% e '/er a #"e$)'# # MARCELO 9%e @ DOMfNIO DO FATO e a)a7#%8,#): e"te"e%

LILS; %0%!!ALBERTO CARLOS; \ a%t#r't*r'a8 a =%st'&a




26/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

Bras'+e'ra @ a +t'!a (e&a e a%t#r'tar's!# as#)'eae 7ras'+e'ra8 e ,#): t* e!7a'# e+a a$#ra8 1#e% O

)ara !#"t#% 'ss#2 E"te"e% N# !e% e"te"er @ 'ss#8 e+e te! a1a)a e # 9%e'?# "a !.#8 '"1e+'/!e"te ' '/er 'ss#8 t* A$#ra8,#): te! %!a )#'sa "a t%a !.# (#rra; ,#):8# PT8 a DILMA2222 Fa/ 'ss# e 1#a-se Va' ter (#rraa V.#)r't')ar E a Ne (#rra222N%!a 7#a8 ,#): res#+,e #%tr#(r#7+e!a8 9%e @ # (r#7+e!a a$#,er"a7'+'ae2P#rra8 ,#): e DILMA8 %! e(e"e # #%tr#8)a)ete

LILS; %0%!!

ALBERTO CARLOS; E% !a"e'8 e% 1'/ # 7a+.# e e"sa'#)#! #s !e%s )+'e"tes2 Ma"e' %! '"1#r!at',# tra7a+0a"#)#! a se$%'"te 0'(tese2 =#$%e'8 @ %!a0'(tese8 a !'"0a )a7e&a !es!#2 V#):;MINISTRO e # PALOCCI "a FAZENDA2 Cara8 "e$# )#!e% a!e +'$ar8 ,a' a)#"te)er 'ss# N.#8 e% 1a+e'8 @ s %!a0'(tese2 A)a7a a )r'se8 a)a7a Pe #!er)a# "# 7#+s#8 e 1a/ # 9%e te!

9%e ser 1e't#8 a)a7#% P#rra8 s # PT te! 'ss#8 te! #s #'s9%ar#s 9%e a)a7a! )#! a )r'se8 )ara+0# P8 ta es(era"# #9%e Q%e arra"?# ,#):s est.# es(era"#

LILS; N.#8 ".# t es(era"# "e"0%! arra"?# ".#2 Pra!'! @ !%'t# '1)'+ essa 0'(tese2 Na ,erae8 ELA =AOFERECEU8 sa7e Mas e% ,#% ter %!a )#",ersa 0#?e8 9%e8e(#'s e% te +'$#2

ALBERTO CARLOS; P#rra8 ".# te!222 #+0a s8 #

art')%+a#r @ ,#):2 V#): te"t#% +* # PMDB8 ,#):te! t#ta+ )re'7'+'ae "a 1re"te # PMDB8 ,#): te! t#ta+)re'7'+'ae "a 1re"te # PT8 t#ta+ )re'7'+'ae "a1re"te e t##s #s (art'#s2 A)a7#%8se"t#% +*8 t* res#+,'# # (r#7+e!a e)re'7'+'ae2 T* res#+,'#2 B#t#% "#ss# a!'$# +* "aFa/e"a8 t* res#+,'# a e)#"#!'a8 a e(e)tat',a (%raE(e)tat',a (%ra E% t 1#ra a9%'8 e% t ,e"# # 9%e @ 'ss#2

LILS; \8 !as "a 0#ra 9%e esse !e% a!'$# 1a/ %! (a(e+

J




27/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

'ss#8 e a '!(re"sa )a' e )a)ete "e+e8 9%e! @ 9%e e1e"eALBERTO CARLOS; F#a-se8 t* t## !%"# 1#'#8 e"te"e%

LILS; P#r9%e e+e ?* 1#'2 E% ,#% )#",ersar e e(#'s a $e"te ,#+taa )#",ersar2 E% te +'$# a!a"0.8ALBERTO CARLOS;V#):s t:! a 1a)a e #9%e'?# "a !.#2 S ,#):s t:! 'ss# "# Bras'+0#?e8 !a's "'"$%@!2 P#rra8 ".# ,a' a(r#,e'tar 'ss# A s%a#%sa'a8 ,#):se!(re 1#' #%sa# )ara+0#

LILS; %0%!!ALBERTO CARLOS; V#): e"te"e O%sa'a8 ,a' +e,ar

(#rraa8 a GLOBO ,a' 7ater8 a00 +*8 )#"1'ss.# e )%+(a2F#a-se8 # 9%e 9%e @ !e+0#r Iss# a8 $a"0ar # ?#$# #% (erer# ?#$#

LILS;


28/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

T)0a%>2

A 0'(tese a ass%"&.# # )ar$# (7+')# (art'% # '"ter+#)%t#r8 ".#e L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a2 A+@! 'ss#8 !es!# 9%e8 # (#"t# e ,'stae L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a8 0#%,esse # #7?et',# e #7str%'r as'",est'$a&es8 ".# ser'a # s%1')'e"te (ara )#"1'$%rar # es,'# e1'"a+'ae2 Ser'a '"'s(e"s*,e+ # )#")%rs# # a$e"te (7+')# res(#"s*,e+(e+# at#8 "# )as#8 a Pres'e"te a Re(7+')a2 E+e!e"t#s s%7se9%e"tes'"')a! esse )#")%rs#2

E! %!a )#",ersa "# 'a 5238 R%' Fa+).#8 Pres'e"te # Part'# #s

Tra7a+0a#res8 (r#(e a# e"t.# M'"'str# C0e1e a Casa C','+8 =a9%esda$"er8 a "#!ea&.# e L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a (ara )ar$# e M'"'str#e Esta#8 (ara '!(e'r s%a (r's.#;


29/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

=AQUES dAGNER; N.#8 te! !'"'str# a =%st'&a2 E+e t*"# !'"'st@r'#2 C+ar#2 E+e t* "# (#st#2

RUI FALCÃO; A+$%!a '"')'at',a ,#):s (re)'sa! t#!ar2P#r9%e t* "a !.# e %!a ?%/a a Q%arta Vara 9%e ".# sa7e9%a"# t#!a e)'s.#8 !as (#e t#!ar e)'s.# 0#?e2 Ns222

=AQUES dAGNER; A08 e+e (e'% a (re,e"t',a # )arae! )'!a # 9%:

RUI FALCÃO; N.#222 ".# te!222 e! )'!a # tr'(+e8 ae"")'a8 e+e @ +#%)#2 Os tr:s (r#!#t#res a9%'8 =a9%es2

=AQUES dAGNER; T* 7#!2 De'a e% 1a/er a+$%!a)#'sa a9%'2

RUI FALCÃO; \8 (#r9%e e+es (#e!8 a ?%/a (#ees(a)0ar a$#ra8 t* Te! #s a,#$a#s t* +* s')8 ta!#)0a!a"# e(%ta#222

=AQUES dAGNER; Fa+#%8 #[2RUI FALCÃO; A #%tra )#'sa @ # se$%'"te; se "#!ear e+e

0#?e8 # 9%e 9%e a)#"te)e =AQUES dAGNER; A ".# se'8 e% t (#r 1#ra2RUI FALCÃO; E"t.#8 )#"s%+ta 'ss# ta!7@!222

=AQUES dAGNER; Mas e+e ?* e)''%RUI FALCÃO; N.#8 !as "s ta!# t## !%"#

(ress'#"#% e+e a9%'2 Fer"a"# Haa8 t## !#,'!e"t#s'"')a+8 t## !%"#2

=AQUES dAGNER; T* 7#!2RUI FALCÃO; T*2

=AQUES dAGNER; E% a)0# 9%e te! 9%e 1')ar )er)a# e!t#r"# # (r@'# e+e e sa'r "a (#rraa8 R%'2

RUI FALCÃO; Te! "aa2 =AQUES dAGNER; N.#8 t%# 7e!8 %@ Mas te! 9%e)er)ar t%#2

RUI FALCÃO; N.#8 e% se'8 !as e"9%a"t# 'ss#222 =AQUES dAGNER; T%# 7e!8 e'a e% 1a+ar a9%'2RUI FALCÃO; A+erta a (res'e"te2 T#!a a e)'s.# e

Esta#-Ma'#r a2 =AQUES dAGNER; Fa+#%8 #[222RUI FALCÃO; E !a"t@! a $e"te '"1#r!a#2 E+e8 t*




30/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

=AQUES dAGNER; T* 7#!>2

At@ e"t.#8 te!#s %!a s%$est.# 1#r!%+aa a# !e!7r# # (r'!e'r#es)a+.# $#,er"a!e"ta+8 se! '"')a&.# e a)#+0'a (#r (arte a C0e1e eG#,er"#2

Mas %as )#",ersas e"tre L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a e a Pres'e"te aRe(7+')a (are)e! e!#"strar 9%e esta ass%!'% # (r#(s't# )#!# se%2

N# 'a 4238 Ys 3058 L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a se '/ ass%sta# )#!a 2 P#r9%e a (art'r e %! ?%'/e I"stW")'a8 t%# (#e a)#"te)er "esse (as2DILMA; E"t.# era t%# '$%a+ # 9%e se!(re 1#'8 @>2

N.# 0* a9%' (e'# e "#!ea&.# (ara # )ar$#8 !as 0* %!a )+ara'"')a&.# a )re"&a e 9%e ser'a )#",e"'e"te ret'rar a a)%sa&.# a 3Vara Feera+ e C%r't'7a a


31/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

ser'a +e"'e"te )#! # e-Pres'e"te2O #7?et',# a Pres'e"te a Re(7+')a e "#!ear L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a

a S'+,a (ara '!(e'r s%a (r's.# @ re,e+a# (e+a )#",ersa se$%'"te8 e!J238 3032 Trata-se e '*+#$# s#7re # ter!# e (#sse8 )#! # se$%'"te)#"te#;

2

A Pres'e"te '/ 9%e e",'ar* # ter!# e (#sse


32/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

e+e> s'$"'1')a


33/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

e",'asse !a"at*r'# )#! (#eres es(e)1')#s2E! "e"0%!a 0'(tese8 a (#sse (#er'a #)#rrer (e+a a(#s'&.#8 (e+a

Pres'e"te8 e s%a ass'"at%ra8 e! ter!# aree!e"te ass'"a# (e+#"#!ea#2

A es(e't# 'ss#8 a Pres'e"te a Re(7+')a e!'t'% "#ta8a)#!(a"0aa e #)%!e"t# '"t't%+a# 8 ass'"a# (e+aa%t#r'ae e!(#ssaa8 !as ".# (e+a a%t#r'ae 9%e * a (#sse8 se! ata(ree")0'a2 O !es!# #)%!e"t# 1#' e'7'# "a )er'!"'a e (#sse8)#!# se"# # #7?et# a )#",ersa e! 9%est.#2 O tet# # #)%!e"t# *)#"ta e 9%e a s%(#sta (#sse ter'a #)#rr'#


34/34

MS 34071 MC / DF

'!(etra#s "# S%(re!# Tr'7%"a+ Feera+ ".# t:! # )#".# e s%s(e"er# trW!'te e a&es (#(%+ares ?* e! )%rs# e! #%tras '"stW")'as #% !es!#

e #7star a (r#(#s't%ra e "#,a e!a"a2 Trata"#-se e 1e't#s e)#!(et:")'a e '"stW")'as 'st'"tas8 '!(#ss,e+ s%a re%"'.#2 Ta!(#%)# a(rese"te a&.# '!(ee a a"*+'se e t%te+a e %r$:")'a e! a&es (#(%+ares8)#"1#r!e 's(e # art2 8 i 8 a Le' 24362

A"te # e(#st#8 $!" + *$+ &*+! 8 (ara s%s(e"er a e1')*)'aa "#!ea&.# e L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a (ara # )ar$# e M'"'str# C0e1ea Casa C','+8 eter!'"a"# a !a"%te"&.# a )#!(et:")'a a ?%st'&a e!

Pr'!e'ra I"stW")'a #s (r#)e'!e"t#s )r'!'"a's e! se% es1a,#r2C#!%"'9%e-se Y 3 Vara Feera+ e C%r't'7a2N#t'1'9%e-se a a%t#r'ae '!(etraa2D:-se )':")'a a# A,#$a#-Gera+ a U"'.#2I")+%a-se L%'/ I"*)'# L%+a a S'+,a "a a%t%a&.#2 C'te-se )#!#

+'t's)#"s#rte (ass',# "e)ess*r'#2A(e"se!-se #s a%t#s #s Ma"a#s e Se$%ra"&a 342565 e 342568

(ara tra!'ta&.# e ?%+$a!e"t# )#"?%"t#2C#! as res(#stas8 :-se ,'sta a# Pr#)%ra#r-Gera+ a Re(7+')a2P%7+'9%e-se2 I"t2Bras+'a8 e !ar e 25J2

M'"'str# GILMAR MENDESRe+at#r

"ocumento assinado digitalmente

Documents

Gilmar Mendes, no STF, atende PSDB e suspende liminarmente posse de Lula como ministro