6
W Q H G L V H U 3 U X 2 P R U ) U H W W H / $ P R F N Q D E G R R I V O O L K W R R I Z Z Z a U H W Q L : Q R J Q L V X F R I V L U H W W H O V Z H 1 U X R I R H X V V L V L K 7 ´ H U X W X I H K W R W J Q L N R R O ³ G Q D ´ W V D S U X R J Q L U H E P H P H U ³ H K W I R W U D S H U H Z W D K W V U H H W Q X O R Y G H W D F L G H G \ Q D P H K 7 H V R K W G Q D Q R L W D G Q X R I W D H U J D G L D O N Q D % G R R ) \ O U D H G U D Z R W N U R Z R W G H X Q L W Q R F H Y D K G H Z R O O R I W D K W H S R + J Q L Y L * ±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«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

H W W UH ) U PR 2 UX 3 U H V L G H WQ · $ / h w w uh ) u pr 2 ux 3 u h v l g h wq ... ro fod xe vl q vh vh v fv kr r vo q r q sru iwlvs or lhf iul h ... h p uh jqh f\ vuh yfl hv

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: H W W UH ) U PR 2 UX 3 U H V L G H WQ · $ / h w w uh ) u pr 2 ux 3 u h v l g h wq ... ro fod xe vl q vh vh v fv kr r vo q r q sru iwlvs or lhf iul h ... h p uh jqh f\ vuh yfl hv

WQHGLVHU3�UX2�PRU)�UHWWH/�$

����PRF�NQDEGRRIVOOLKWRRI�ZZZ ������� ����������������������������������� � ��a������UHWQL:������

QR�JQLVXFRI�VL�UHWWHOVZH1�UXR�IR�HXVVL�VLK7�´HUXWXI�HKW�RW�JQLNRRO³�GQD�´WVDS�UXR�JQLUHEPHPHU³HKW�IR�WUDS�HUHZ�WDKW�VUHHWQXORY�GHWDFLGHG�\QDP�HK7HVRKW�GQD�QRLWDGQXRI�WDHUJ�D�GLDO�NQD%�GRR)�\OUDHGUDZRW�NURZ�RW�GHXQLWQRF�HYDK�GHZROORI�WDKW

HSR+�JQLYL*�±�UHJQX+�JQLWKJL) WDKW�VL�WOXVHU�HK7���RW�HOED�GQD�\GDHU�VQLDPHU�NQD%�GRR)�VOOLKWRR)�HKWHKW�VL�ZR1���HFQDWVLVVD�JQLNHHV�HPRF�RKZ�OOD�SOHKVLKW�WDKW�HUXVQH�RW�WUDS�UXR�RG�RW�VX�IR�OOD�URI�HPLW

�VGQDS[H�WXE��VHXQLWQRF�\OQR�WRQ�\WLOLEDSDF

HUDKV�RW�VZHQ�JQLWLF[H�HPRV�HYDK�,��GUDJHU�WDKW�Q,ODWLSD&�D�QR�JQLNUDEPH�VL�NQD%�GRR)�HK7���XR\�KWLZHKW�URI�VGQXI�JQLVLDU�IR�WQHWQL�HKW�KWLZ��QJLDSPD&GRR)�HKW�URI�\WLOLFDI�WQHQDPUHS��UHJUDO�D�IR�HVDKFUXSQRLWDFRO�WQHUUXF�UXR�RW�QHHE�HYDK�XR\�IR�\QD0���NQD%HURP�URI�GHHQ�UXR�IR�HUDZD�\UHY�HURIHUHKW�HUD�GQDJQLJQHOODKF�HURP�GQD�HURP�JQLPRFHE�VL�W,���HFDSV�UHYH�HKW�HYUHV�RW�VUHHWQXORY�NQD%�GRR)�HKW�URIHFDSV�GHGZRUF�HKW�QL�VWQHLOF�IR�UHEPXQ�JQLZRUJWDKW�VHFUXRVHU�HKW�QL�GHWLPLO�RVOD�HUD�H:���HOEDOLDYDJQLWHHP�\QD�IR�NFDO�D�RW�HXG�VWQHLOF�HKW�UHIIR�QDF�HZURWFHUL'�HYLWXFH[(�UXR��\OWQDWURSPL�\UHY�GQ$���VPRRUQDF�HKV�WDKW�RV��HWLV�QR�HFLIIR�HWDXTHGD�QD�VGHHQ\OWQHUUXF�VL�HK6���VNVDW�\QDP�UHK�HJDQDP�\OWQHLFLIIHWDKW�GQD�HPRK�PRUI�NURZ�UHK�IR�KFXP�RG�RW�GHFURIGUDR%�NQD%�GRR)�HKW�R6���QRLWDXWLV�GRRJ�D�WRQ�VLVD��GQ$���HJQDKF�D�HNDP�RW�HPLW�HKW�VL�VLKW�WDKW�VOHHI

«�VURQRG�\QDP�UXR�IR�WURSSXV�HKW�GHHQ�HZ��V\DZODQR�QRLWDPURIQL�HURP�JQLYLHFHU�HE�OOLZ�XR<���XR\�HNLOXR\�WDKW�NVD�GOXRZ�,�GQD�QJLDSPD&�ODWLSD&�HKWHKW�KWLZ�UHQWUDS�QDF�XR\�ZRK�UHGLVQRF�\OOXIUH\DUSVLK7���\WLODHU�D�JQLGOLXE�ZHQ�VLKW�HNDP�RW�NQD%�GRR)

HKW�ZROOD�OOLZ�\WLOLFDI�UHJUDOUXR�QL�ZRUJ�RW�NQD%�GRR)QL�HVRKW�SOHK�RW�\WLOLEDRW�HXQLWQRF�GQD��GHHQRWQL�VHFLYUHV�UXR�GQDS[HVX�QLRM�HVDHO3���HUXWXI�HKWKFDHUWXR�WDHUJ�VLKW�QL

�WURIIH

JQLPRFSX�\QDP�HUD�HUHK7KFLKZ�QL�VWQHYH�\WLQXPPRFHE�OOLZ�NQD%�GRR)�HKW

�JQLWDSLFLWUDS\UDXUEH)�QR�GOHK�VDZ�UHVLDUGQXI�V¶\GQH:�WVULI�HK7�� ����OLUS$�URI�GHOXGHKFV�VL�HQR�UHKWRQD�GQD���

����HWDQRG�OOLZ��\DZKJL+�HHUIHUD&�QR��V¶\GQH:UDGQHODF�UXR\�NUDP�R6���PS����PRUI�VHODV�OOD�IR

�WURIIH�VLKW�QL�QLRM�GQD��HK7�� GQ \WLQXPPR&�VOOLKWRR)�WUHVH'�ODXQQ$�

\QD0������KFUD0�QR��SX�JQLPRF�VL�((%�JQLOOHS6HULI��HFLORS�VWLIRUS�QRQ�VORRKFV�VHVVHQLVXE�ODFROVPDHW�HYDK�OOLZ��NQD%�GRR)�HKW�JQLGXOFQL��VWSHGHQL)�VZRGDK6�VXWFD&�WD�GOHK�HE�OOLZ�W,���JQLWDSLFLWUDSQL�HE�RW�QXI�VL�WL�GQD��PS�����WD�JQLWUDWV��UHWQH&�VWU$Q,���PDHW�HWLURYDI�UXR\�URI�UHHKF�GQD�HFQHLGXD�HKWURI�HOEDOLDYD�HE�OOLZ�[RE�QRLWDQRG�D��QRLWLGGD

�NQD%�GRR)�HKW�URI�VPHWL�JQLWFHOORF�\DGQX6�POD3�QR�NOD:�UHJQX+�HKW�VL�W[H1��

HOSRHS�\UJQXK�\QDP�HKW�IR�VX�VGQLPHU�KFLKZ����OLUS$HK7���PHKW�RW�WXR�KFDHU�RW�GHHQ�UXR�GQD�GOURZ�HKW�QLQL�KFUXK&�QDUHKWX/�GUR/�HKW�WVLUK&�WD�VQLJHE�NODZGQD��NODZ�HIDV��WQDVDHOS�D�VL�W,���PS��WD�HHUIHUD&JQRO$���VJRG�ULHKW�QHYH�GQD�VHLOLPDI�URI�HOED\RMQH

���HJDS�QR�GHXQLWQRF�

Page 2: H W W UH ) U PR 2 UX 3 U H V L G H WQ · $ / h w w uh ) u pr 2 ux 3 u h v l g h wq ... ro fod xe vl q vh vh v fv kr r vo q r q sru iwlvs or lhf iul h ... h p uh jqh f\ vuh yfl hv

RG�RW�OOHZ�IR�DHUD�QD�VD�IR�WKJXRKW�QHWIR�VL�\HOOD9�KWUR1�HK7JQROD�JQLWWHJ�HUD�RKZ�VWQHGLVHU�VVDOF�UHSSX�RW�HOGGLP�KWLZ�VEUXEXV

\QDP�WDKW�WFDI�HKW�HVLXJVLG�VJQLGQXRUUXV�QDEUX�WQDVDHO3���HQLI�WVXMV¶\DGRW�QL�WHHP�VGQH�JQLNDP�\OHUDE�HUD�VWQHGLVHU�\HOOD9�KWUR1

�WQHPQRULYQH�FLPRQRFH

ODFLGHP�IR�UHEPXQ�D��WXF�\DS�D��ERM�IR�VVRO�D�VD�KFXV��VLVLUF�\Q$VJQLYDV�DUW[H�\QD�HYDK�W¶QRG�WVXM�HOSRHS�WDKW�WFDI�HKW�GQD�VOOLE�WXRED�VHNDW�W,��NQDE�GRRI�HKW�RW�HOSRHS�JQLUE�OOLZ��HOEDOLDYD VGQXRS���

�V\DG���URI�QRVUHS�HQR�GHHI�RW������WD�GHXODY��GRRI�IR

63/(+�.1$%�'22)�6//,+722)�:2+

%8/&�(5$&

����PRF�NQDEGRRIVOOLKWRRI�ZZZ ������� ����������������������������������� ��a������UHWQL:���

PHKWQ$�QL�HURW6�HWLOOHWD6�����������

HID&�DLQR. �KFUXK&�VGDRUVVRU&�HGLVQL�GHWDFRO���������[LQHRK3���U'�WV����1��������������PD�����QHHZWHE�\DGVHX7�QR�UHGUR�HFDO3�����PS������QHHZWHE�\DGVUXK7�QR�SX�NFL3�������

UHEPHYR1 UHEPHFH'� \UDXQD-�VGQXRS������� VGQXRS�������������������� VGQXRS��������

\E�GHWDQRG�GRRI�IR�WQXRPD�HKW�IR�QZRGNDHUE�D�V¶HUH+�GHHQ�QL�HVRKW�SOHK�RW�NQD%�GRR)�HKW�RW�\WLQXPPRF�HKW

VODWR7�\OKWQR0

"""ZRQ.�XR<�GL'

VLVDE�\OKWQRP�D�QR�VHLOLPDI�\GHHQ�VWVLVVD��%))��NQD%�GRR)�VOOLKWRR)KFWHUWV�HOSRHS�VSOHK�EXO&�HUD&���PDUJRUS�EXO&�HUD&�VWL�KJXRUKW

GHVDKFUXS�HE�QDF������WD�GHXODY��HJDNFDS�WDHP�$���VUDOORG�GRRI�ULHKW����URI�GHVDKFUXS�HE�QDF������WD�GHXODY��HJDNFDS�\UWQDS�$�������URI

�VLVDE�\OKWQRP�D��QR

HUD�VUXRK�EXO&�HUD&���GHGQHPPRFHU�VL�EXO&�HUD&�URI�QRLWDUWVLJHU�HU3PS��������GQD�KWQRP�KFDH�IR�\DGVHQGH:�WVULI�HKW�QR�PS�������������

�KWQRP�KFDH�IR�\DGVUXK7�GULKW�HKW�QR

�����������������������GDR5�NHHU&�HYD&���������

� �������DQR]LU$��NHHU&�HYD&

�VVHUGGD�JQLOLD0������������[R%�23�����������

�������=$��HHUIHUD&�����

� PRF�NQDEGRRIVOOLKWRRI�ZZZ

71(0(7$76�12,66,0GHHQ�QL�VHLOLPDI�GQD�VODXGLYLGQL�WVLVV$

UHKWR�GQD�QRLWDPURIQL�ODUUHIHU��GRRI�KWLZ�VHFLYUHV�\FQHJUHPH

6527&(5,'�)2�'5$2%�����

WVURKQD3�HQQDH-���WQHGLVHU3QRVWX+�WUHER5��YH5���WQHGLVHU3�HFL9

\HULK6�GLYD'��YH5���\UDWHUFH6WWDO)�HYD'����UHUXVDHU7

\HULK6�GLYD'��YH5���WQHGLVHU3�WVD3RUWHL3L'�PD3���URWFHUL'�HYLWXFH[(

HUXGQHED%�QDOO$���URWFHUL'QLEUX'�DQL*���URWFHUL'VLUUD+�QHUD.���URWFHUL'GQLOJRN6�IIH-���URWFHUL'

RLUR-L'�LQR7���URWLG(�UHWWHOVZH1

6582+�*1,7$5(32

�QR0 �� VHX7 ��� PS��a�PD����������GH:��VUXK7 �� PS��a�PS����������������������LU)�

�VJQLQHYH��VHX7 �� PS��a�PS�������������������VUXK7

EXO&�HUD&PS������a�PS�����������KWQRP�IR�GH:�WV�

QRRQ���������KWQRP��IR�VUXK7�GU� PS���a�

��������HOELGHUFQL�QD�GHYLHFHU�NQD%�GRR)�VOOLKWRR)�HKW�������Q,�VHYLUG�GRRI�GQD�VQRLWDQRG�PRUI�GRRI�IR�VGQXRS

Page 3: H W W UH ) U PR 2 UX 3 U H V L G H WQ · $ / h w w uh ) u pr 2 ux 3 u h v l g h wq ... ro fod xe vl q vh vh v fv kr r vo q r q sru iwlvs or lhf iul h ... h p uh jqh f\ vuh yfl hv

����PRF�NQDEGRRIVOOLKWRRI�ZZZ ������� ������������������������������������������� ��a�����UHWQL:

VPHW,�HOEDKVLUH3�QR1�VH]LV�HJUDO��VUHSDL'

SDRV�\UGQXD/

VPHW,�GRR)WLXUI�GHQQD&

WDHP��DQXW�GHQQD&VSXRV�GHQQD&

ZHWV���LOLKF�GHQQD&VHRWDPRW�GHFLG�GHQQD&

\OOHM��UHWWXE�WXQDH3HVHHKF��LQRUDFD0

HFXDV�LWWHKJDS6

NOLP�GHUHGZR3GHQQDF�UR�\UG��DWVD3

ODHUHF�WVDINDHU%VQDHE�GHLUIH5

HFL5VHOWWRE�OODPV��OLR�JQLNRR&

SDRV�UD%HXVVLW�WHOLR7HXVVLW�HFD)

VHKVXUE�HWVDSKWRR7WQDURGRH'

RRSPDK6VOHZRW�UHSD3UDHJ�JQLYDK6

HUD�HZ�VPHWL�HUD�HUHK�GHWVL/�����QDF�XR\�I,���IR�GHHQ�QL�V\DZODIR�\QD�IIR�SRUG�HVDHOS���SOHKXR\�I,���%))�HKW�RW�VPHWL�HVHKW

GHHQ�UR�VQRLWVHXT�HYDKHVDHOS��QRLWDPURIQL�ODQRLWLGGD

��������������WD�VX�OODF

HKW�URI�SRK6NQD%�GRR)�VOOLKWRR)

� WVL/�KVL:�����ZRO�\OHPHUW[H�VL�VPHWL�JQLZROORI�HKW�IR�NFRWV�UX2�VPHWL�HVHKW�KWLZ�VHYOHKV�UXR�KVLQHOSHU�SOHK�HVDHO3

UHWWXE�WXQDH3 \OOH-HFLX- NOLP�GHUHGZR3UDJX6 VQDHE�GHLU'

HFXD6�DWVD3 LQRUD�HFLU�UR�DWVD3VHGLV�RWDWRS�GH[R% VHGLV�HFLU�GH[R%

VHLUWHOLR7 SDRV�IR�VUD%��GQD����QUREZHQ��VH]LV���VUHSDL'

WXQDHS��VUHNODZ�HKW�IR�WURSSXV�QL�GHVLDU�VHLQRP�KWLZ�NQD%�GRR)�HKW�URI�GHWFHOORF�HE�OOLZ�\OOHM�GQD�UHWWXE\DOH5³��V¶\WHLFR6�UHFQD&�QDFLUHP$�HKW��\OODQLI�GQ$�� HKW�KWLZ�V$����������OLUS$�QR�GOHK�HE�OOLZ�´HIL/�URIOOLZ�GQD�VPDHW�PURI�OOLZ�VSXRUJ�VXRLUDY��((%�JQLOOHS6NFDUW�HKW�QR�JQLNODZ�UHEPHP�PDHW�D�HYDK�\OODXQLWQRFUHGLVQR&���PD��PS��PRUI�VZRGDK6�VXWFD&�WDVLKW�QL�UHEPHP�PDHW�NQD%�GRR)�D�JQLWURSSXV�KFUDHVHU�UHFQDF�URI�\HQRP�HVLDU�RW�WURIIH�HOLKZKWURZ

HKW�IR�WUDS�D�\OXUW�VL�NQD%�GRR)�HKW�WDKW�HHV�QDF�XR<HWLVEHZ�UXR�WXR�NFHK&���\WLQXPPRF\QD�QR�QRLWDPURIQL�HURP�URI��PRF�NQDEGRRIVOOLKWRRI�

�VWQHYH�HVHKW�IR

URI�JQLQQLJHE�ZHQ�D�HE�OOLZ�WL��JQLUS6�RW�NRRO�HZ�V$QRLWDPURIQL�HURP�JQLUDKV�HE�OOLZ�H:��NQD%�GRR)�HKW�PVDLVXKWQH�UXR�QL�QLRM�OOLZ�XR\�WDKW�HSRK�GQD�XR\�KWLZGHWFHULG�OOD�VL�W,���JQLNDWUHGQX�ZHQ�VLKW�QL�VX�WURSSXV�GQDGQD�«�GHHQ�QL�HVRKW�JQLYUHV�IR�ERM�UHWWHE�D�JQLRG�WD

�QHSSDK�WDKW�HNDP�RW�SOHK�582<�GHHQ�HZ

���HJDS�PRUI��WQRF���UHWWH/�

����� \OUHWUDXT�UXR\�HYLHFH5GDHWVQL�[RE�´Q,³�UXR\�QL�UHWWHOVZHQ�NQD%�GRR)�VOOLKWRR)VUDOORG�IR�VGQDVXRKW�HYDV�VX�SOHK�GQD�[RE�OLDP�UXR\�IR

�VWVRF�HJDWVRS�GQD�JQLWQLUS�QL�UDH\�KFDHV\DZOD�HU¶HZ��HVLU�HKW�QR�JQLKW\UHYH�IR�WVRF�HKW�KWL:�����JQLNDP�IR��VVHQLVXE�RG�RW�V\DZ�WQHLFLIIH�HURP�URI�JQLNRRO\GHHQ�\QDP�VD�SOHK�RW�VX�JQLOEDQH��UHKWUXI�RJ�VUDOORG�UXRGQD�JQLWQLUS�QR�\HQRP�GQHSV�\K:���HOELVVRS�VD�HOSRHSDLY�HHUI�URI�UHWWHOVZHQ�HKW�GQHV�QDF�HZ�QHKZ��HJDWVRS

�HVQHV�GRRJ�HNDP�RW�VPHHV�WVXM�W,��"OLDPHRW�VVHUGGD�OLDPH�GQD�HPDQ�UXR\�OLDPH��R6����

PRF�RRKD\#NQDEGRRIVOOLKWRRI UXR\�GQLI�OO¶XR\�GQD��[RE�´Q,³�UXR\�QL�HQLOQR�UHWWHOVZHQ

��� �VUHKWR�JQLSOHK�RW�VHPRF�WL�QHKZ��VSOHK�WLE�HOWWLO�\UHY(��

QDK7�UHKWD5�OLDP(OLD0��6�8�HKW

PRUI�NFHKF�D�WSHFFD�RUWHL3L'�PD3�GQD�WVURKQD3�HQQDH-HHUIHUD&�WD�V¶\GQH:�IR�URVLYUHSXV�WILKV��GQRP\D5�DWL5

IR�����HUHKZ�����EH)�QR�GOHK�UHVLDUGQXI�D�JQLZROORI���\Z+QLR-���%))�HKW�RW�GHWDQRG�HUHZ�PS������PRUI�VGHHFRUS�HKW�PS������PRUI����OLUS$�QR�UHVLDUGQXI�V¶\GQH:�W[HQ�HKW�URI�VX

Page 4: H W W UH ) U PR 2 UX 3 U H V L G H WQ · $ / h w w uh ) u pr 2 ux 3 u h v l g h wq ... ro fod xe vl q vh vh v fv kr r vo q r q sru iwlvs or lhf iul h ... h p uh jqh f\ vuh yfl hv

��� ��a�����UHWQL:�PRF�NQDEGRRIVOOLKWRRI�ZZZ ������������

���NFD%�JQLNRR/\WLODHU�OOD�WDKW���VHXODY�VXRLFHUS�HVRKW�UHYRFVLGHU�GQD�NFDE�RJ�WVXP�HZ��GUDZURI�RJ�RW�HUD�HZ�I,

��ORUWQRF�ODXWLULSV�VDK�\WLODHU�OOD�WDKW�GQD�VQRLWDGQXRI�ODURP�QR�VHJQLK �� �U-��JQL.�UHKWX/�QLWUD0

�%))�HKW�URI�PHOERUS�D�QHHE�V\DZOD�VDK�HFDSV�KJXRQH�WR1

VWL�PRUI�GHYRP�NQD%�GRR)�VOOLKWRR)�HKW�������\UDXUEH)�Q,D�RW�HFLII2�WVR3�NHHU&�HYD&�GOR�HKW�PRUI�VVRUFD�QRLWDFRO

V¶NQDE�GRRI�HKW�WD�JQLNFDSQ8���D]DO3�DWVL9�DOOH%�WD�HWLV�ZHQWHK&��LUXGQ$�HQQDH-�VUHHWQXORY��WIHO�PRUI��HUD�HPRK�ZHQGQD�WKJLQ.�HQHOL(��UHOHNQX+�\UD0�UHEPHP�GUDRE��WKJLQ.

�VUHJR5�QKR-�UHEPHP�GUDRE

HKW�UDH\�WFD[H�HKW�WXRED�\KFWHNV�HOWWLO�D�V¶HQR\UHY(�����WD�WL�VDK�VXVQHVQRF�HKW�±�GHWDHUF�VDZ�NQD%�GRR)�VOOLKWRR)

HKW�QR�VDZ�RKZ�WXRED�QRLVVXFVLG�HPRV�V¶HUHK7�������GQD�\UD0�WDKW�VL�ZRQN�RG�HZ�WDK:����HHWWLPPRF�ODQLJLUR

QL�NQD%�GRR)�D�URI�GHHQ�D�VDZ�HUHKW�WOHI�H\RW6�UHWOD:RW�VHOUH6�UH\R%�QD1�GHNVD�\HK7���\WLQXPPRF�ULHKW

GHHQ�HKW�WDHUJ�ZRK�HQLPUHWHG�GOXRZ�WDKW�\HYUXV�D�WFXGQRFHKW�IR�QRLWDHUF�HKW�RW�GHO�\HYUXV�WDKW�IR�VWOXVHU�HK7���VDZWDKW�QRLWD]LQDJUR�WLIRUS�QRQ�ODFRO�D�±�NQD%�GRR)�VOOLKWRR)

VOOLKWRR)�HKW�QL�UHJQXK�IR�HXVVL�ODFLWLUF�HKW�VVHUGGD�GOXRZ�JQLNURZ�GUDK�IR�SXRUJ�D�GHWVLOQH�VH\RW6�HK7���DHUD

QL�VDZ�WL�GQD�VUREKJLHQ�VOOLKWRR)�GHQUHFQRF�GQD�VXRUHQHJW,���QURE�VDZ�NQD%�GRR)�VOOLKWRR)�HKW�WDKW�PRRU�JQLYLO�ULHKWODQLJLUR�HKW�GHQJLVHG�RKZ��HLOX-��ZDO�QL�UHWKJXDG�ULHKW�VDZ

��GLDV�H\RW6�\UD0���RJRO HKW�IL�HHV�RW�UDH\�D�URI�WL�\UW�OO¶H:³�́WL�WURSSXV�OOLZ�\WLQXPPRF

HOERQ�D�VDZ�NQD%�GRR)�VOOLKWRR)�HKW�JQLQQLJHE�HKW�Q,�����RQ�HUHZ�HUHKW��VDHGL�HOERQ�WVRP�KWLZ�VD�GQD��DHGL

HUHZ�HUHKW��WX%���HPRK�OODF�RW�HFDOS�RQ�GQD�VHFUXRVHUHURWV�D���VQRLWDFRO�HHUKW�WVULI�HK7���SOHK�RW�JQLOOLZ�HOSRHSGOR�HKW�PRUI�VVRUFD�JQLGOLXE�HKW��VWVL[H�UHJQRO�RQ�WDKW�WQRUI

GR5�\E�GHQZR�VL�WDKW�D]DO3�DWVL9�DOOH%�GQD��HFLIIR�WVRSDOOH%�WD�VDZ�NQDE�GRRI�HK7���HHUI�WQHU�HUHZ�\IHGQH=H'DWVL9�DOOH%�WD�VUDH\�ODUHYHV�UHWI$���VUDH\����URI�D]DO3�DWVL9

�\OWQHFHU�OLWQX�S8���WQHU�\DS�RW�QDJHE�NQDE�GRRI�HKWGQD�UH]HHUI��VHYOHKV��NVHG��NQDE�GRRI�HKW�QL�JQLKW\UHYH

NQD%�GRR)�HGL6�WVH:���GHWDQRG�HUHZ��URWDUHJLUIHU

�HYLUG�GRRI�WVULI�HK7���GRRI�GQD�HFLYGD�KWLZ�GHWVLVVDZRQ��VVHO\D%�WD�GOHK�VDZ���VHYOHK6�UX2�NFRW6��´�6�2�6³W$���HHUIHUD&�QL��G5�QRWJQLOUD'�PR7�WD�GHWDFRO��V¶DKVD%WXS�GOXRZ�V¶DKVD%������������PRUI�QRVDHV�\DGLORK�HKW

GQD�VUHSSRKV�HKW�PRUI�VHLUHFRUJ�WFHOORF�RW�WXR�VOHUUDE�\DG�VLKW�R7���GHWFHOORF�VGQXRS�IR�UHEPXQ�HKW�KFWDP�QHKW

�NQD%�GRR)�VOOLKWRR)�HKW�IR�HWDFRYGD�QD�OOLWV�VL�V¶DKVD%\DGRW��NHHZ�D�VUXRK�[LV�QHSR�VDZ�%))�HKW������Q,�����HKW�GHYUHV�WVULI�W,���NHHZ�D�VUXRK����QHSR�VL�\WLOLFDI�HKW

��PRUI�DHUD KW ����RW� KW HQL/�\WQXR&�HKW�RW�KWURQ��VWHHUWV��VHOLP�����VUHYRF�WL�\DGR7���G5�[DPR-�RW�KWXRV�GQDNDH3�HOFDQQL3�RW�KWXRV��G5�HGUH9�RL5�RW����,�HKW�PRUI

�\WL&�QR\QD&�NFDO%�RW�KWURQ�GQDGRR)�HKW�URI�GHNURZ�HYDK�RKZ�VUHHWQXORY�IR�WVLO�HK7�����HUD�\HKW��\DV�RW�WL�HFLIIXV�±�WVLO�RW�VXRUHPXQ�RRW�HUD�NQD%

\OUDH�HKW�IR�\QD0���QLDUW�HKW�VOOXS�WDKW�HQLJQH�HKW\UD0�±�\DGRW�%))�HKW�QL�HYLWFD�OOLWV�HUD�VUHHWQXORY

\QDP�QL�GHYUHV�GQD������QL�GUDRE�QR�HPDF�UHOHNQX+HKW�URI�JQLOXGHKFV�VHRG�OOLWV�HKV�±�VQRLWLVRS�HYLWXFH[HGUR/�HKW�WVLUK&�IR�URWVD3��QRVWX+�WUHER5��YH5���%))VDK�GQD������QL�SXRUJ�HKW�GHQLRM�RVOD��KFUXK&�QDUHKWX/

Q,����VHPLW�VXRUHPXQ�VHFLIIR�HYLWXFH[H�HKW�OOD�QL�GHYUHVKWLZ�´WQHY(�VOZR%�\WSP(³�HKW�GHWUDWV�\UUH3�HORUD&�����URI�UHVLDUGQXI�D�VD�HXJDH/�VWU$�QDURQR6�HKW�PRUI�WURSSXVVDZ�PXDEQHVR5�HLKWD&���\DGRW�WL�VULDKF�OOLWV�GQD�%))�HKW

$�WSRG$�VULDKF�RF�\DGRW�GQD�%))�HKW�IR�WQHGLVHU3�PDUJRU3�\OLPD)

VDK�RUWHL3L'�PD3�������HFQLV�URWFHUL'�HYLWXFH[(�����HUD�RKZ�HVRKW�RW�GQD�SOHK�QDF�RKZ�HVRKW�RW�WXR�GHKFDHU�HOSRHS�������RW�HVROF�GHWVLVVD�%))�UDH\�WVD/���GHHQ�QL

Page 5: H W W UH ) U PR 2 UX 3 U H V L G H WQ · $ / h w w uh ) u pr 2 ux 3 u h v l g h wq ... ro fod xe vl q vh vh v fv kr r vo q r q sru iwlvs or lhf iul h ... h p uh jqh f\ vuh yfl hv

����PRF�NQDEGRRIVOOLKWRRI�ZZZ ������� ����������������������������������� ���� ��a�����UHWQL:�

HWDQLGURRF�RW�GQD�VODXGLYLGQL�\GHHQ�RW�WURSSXV�ODLFQDQLI�\FQHJUHPH�GHWLPLO�GQD�GRRI�HGLYRUS�RW�VL�QRLVVL0�UX2�����������QZRUJ�VDK�HVDE�´WQHLOF³�UXR�������HFQL6����HWDQXWURI�VVHO�HKW�RW�GLD�H]LPL[DP�RW�VHFUXRVHU�\WLQXPPRF�KWLZ

�\OWQHLFLIIH�HWDUHSR�RW�VX�URI�GHGZRUF�RRW�KFXP�VL�PRUI�HWDUHSR�ZRQ�HZ�WDKW�HFDSV�HKW�GQD��HOSRHS�������WVRPOD�JQLYUHV

�HWDQXWURI�VVHO�HKW�URI�HUDF�RW�GHGHHQ�HUD�WDKW�VPDUJRUS�HKW�JQLZRKV�HFDSV�GHVRSRUS�HKW�VL�HUHK�GHUXWFL3�����

�HSRK�PHKW�HYLJ�GQD�VUHKWR�SOHK�RW�VX�SOH+�HYDK�RW�VL�HFDSV�VLKW�HVX�RW�HVRSRUS�HZ�\DZ�HK7

� �UHKWDJ�RW�VWQHLOF�URI�DHUD�QRLWSHFH5� �QRLWDPURIQL�ULHKW�JQLUDKV�HOEDWURIPRF�VOHHI�´WQHLOF³�HKW�RV�HFDSV�HWDYLU3� GHWVLVVD�HE�QDF�WQHLOF�UHKWRQD�QRLWDPURIQL�JQLYLJ�VL�WQHLOF�HQR�HOLKZ�WDKW�RV�HFDS6

�VHFUXRVHU�GQD�QRLWDPURIQL�ODQRLWLGGD�KWLZ� �HFQDWVLVVD�ODLFQDQLI�JQLWVHXTHU�QHKZ�URWFHUL'�HYLWXFH[(�HKW�KWLZ�WHHP�RW�WQHLOF�HKW�URI�HFDS6� �VH[RE�GRRI�HURWV�GQD�NFDS�RW�HOED�HE�RW�HFDSV�KJXRQH�GQD�VUHGUR�GRRI�JQLNFDS�URI�DHU$� GHHQ�QL�QHUGOLKF�HGLYRUS�OOLZ�PDUJRUS�VLK7���QHUGOLKF�URI�PDUJRU3�NFD3�NFDQ6�URI�GRRI�HURWV�RW�HFDS6

�VWFLUWVLG�ORRKFV�HKW�KJXRUKW�GHUHWVLQLPGD�HE�GOXRZ�W,���GRRI�´GQHNHHZ³�KWLZ� KWLZ�JQLUHQWUDS�HUD�H:���VURLQH6�GQXREHPRK�URI�\OODFLILFHSV�HFDSV�VGRRI�´ODLFHS6³

�VGRRI�\UDVVHFHQ�HURWV�RW�HFDSV�NFDO�WXE��PDUJRUS�VLKW�WXR�\UUDF�RW�VSUR&�JQLUD&� �FWH��VWHLG�HHUI�QHWXOJ�URI��VFLWHEDLG�URI�VGRRI�VD�KFXV��VGRRI�KWODHK�ODLFHSV�URI�HFDSV�HJDURW6� �VXQRE�D�VD�VWQHLOF�RW�HYLJ�RW�HYDK�RW�HFLQ�WXE��WVLO�GRRI�QR�WRQ�HUD�WDKW�VPHWL�\DZDHYLJ�URI�HFDS6� �FWH��JQLKWROF��VUHSDL'���QHUGOLKF�URI�\OODFLILFHSV�HUD�WDKW�VPHWL�DUW[H�HKW�URI�HFDS6� HFDSV�HKW�GQD�GRRI�WHS��UH]HHUI�GQD�QL�NODZ�UHJUDO��VGRRI�ODQRVDHV��VPHWL�EXO&�HUD&�URI�HFDSV�ODQRLWLGG$

�FWH��UHEPHFH'��UHEPHYR1��UHERWF2�HNLO��HFQDGQXED�QD�HYDK�HZ�QHKZ�GRRI�HURWV�RW

���GUDZUR)�JQLYR0

Page 6: H W W UH ) U PR 2 UX 3 U H V L G H WQ · $ / h w w uh ) u pr 2 ux 3 u h v l g h wq ... ro fod xe vl q vh vh v fv kr r vo q r q sru iwlvs or lhf iul h ... h p uh jqh f\ vuh yfl hv

���PRF�NQDEGRRIVOOLKWRRI�ZZZ � ������� ����������������������������������������� ��a�����UHWQL:�����

PUR)�HJGHO3�QJLDSPD&�ODWLSD&

, RW�WURIIH�HKW�QL�QJLDSPD&�ODWLSD&�HKW�RW�WILJ�D�KJXRUKW�NQD%�GRR)�VOOLKWRR)�HKW�WURSSXV�OOLZ��DHUD�HFLYUHV�UXR�QLKWLZ�GHHQ�QL�HVRKW�HYUHV�UHWWHE�RW�VD�RV��\WLOLFDI�UHJUDO�D�HULXTFD

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB�V�HPD1

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB�VVHUGG$

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBVVHUGG$�OLDP(BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB�SL]��HWDWV��\WL&

VUDOOR'BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB��IR�PXV�HKW�NQD%�GRR)�VOOLKWRR)�HKW�RW�HJGHOS�\EHUHK�HZ�,�HXODY�WQHODYLXTH�IR�\WUHSRUS�UHKWR�UR�VHLWLUXFHV��GUDF�WLGHUF��NFHKF��KVDF�QL�GLDS�HE�R7

BBBBBBBBBBBBBB�HWD'�BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB�HUXWDQJL6

BBBBBBBBBBBBBB�HWD'��BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB��WILJ�WQLRM�QHKZ��HVXRS6

BBBBBBBBBBBBBB���HXG�HFQDOD%�BBBBBBBBBBBBBB���KWLZHUHK�GLD3

��VZROORI�VD�GLDS�HE�RW�HFQDOD% �HQR�HOFULF \OKWQR0 \OUHWUDX4 \OUDH<BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB��VQRLWFXUWVQL�ODLFHS6BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

� �� �VUHGQLPHU�WQHP\DS�HP�GQHV�HVDHO3

� GHVROFQH�NFHK&� �$6,9���\P�HJUDKF�HVDHO3 �� �&0 � ��UHYRFVL'����� �� BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

�VKWQRPBBBBBB�URI�KWQRP�BBBBBBBBBBBBB��URI�GUDF�\P�HJUDKF�HVDHO3

�GUDF�IR�NFDE�QR�VWLJLG���UR����BBBBBBB���HGRF�\WLUXFH6�BBBBBB�BBBBB��QRLWDULS[(

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBHWD'BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBHUXWDQJL6

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB��IR�\URPHP�UR�URQRK�QL�VL�WILJ�\0

������=$��HHUIHUD&������[R%�23��NQD%�GRR)�VOOLKWRR)���RW�PURI�GHWHOSPRF�VLKW�OLDP�HVDHO3

������=$��NHHU&�HYD&��GDR5�NHHU&�HYD&��(��������VVHUGGD�ODFLV\KS�RW�QUXWHU�U2

\OUDHOF�WQLUS�HVDHO3