HARYANA VIDHAN SABHA

VII SESSION

BULLETIN

Friday, the 4th

November, 2016

(Brief record of the proceedings of the meeting of the Haryana Vidhan

Sabha held on Friday, the 4th November, 2016 from 10.00 A.M. to

6.04 P.M.)

I. OBITUARY REFERENCES

The Chief Minister made references to the deaths of the late:-

1. Shri Dharamvir Yadav, former Minister of Haryana

2. Freedom Fighters of Haryana.

3. Martyrs of Haryana

4. Terrorist Attack in Jammu & Kashmir

5. Others.

and spoke for 5 minutes.

Shri Abhay Singh Chautala, Leader of the Opposition, Spoke for 4

minutes. He made a suggestion and agreed to that, the name of Shri Tayab

Hussain, Brother-in-law of Shri Naseem Ahmed, M.L.A., was also added in

the above-said list.

Smt. Kiran Choudhry, Leader of the Congress Legislature Party,

spoke for 4 minutes. She also demanded that the name of a Ex- Serviceman,

who committed suicide on 1st November, 2016 at Jantar Mantar, New Delhi,

may also be added in the list of martyrs in the obituary references. But the

Leader of the House did not agree with the demand raised by her as he had

committed suicide and it would set a wrong precedent to include the name in

the martyrs list. After heard the views from the both sides, the Speaker

ordered not to include the name of the said Ex-Serviceman in the list of

martyrs.

The Speaker also associated himself with the sentiments expressed in

the House and spoke for a while.

It was decided to send messages of condolence to the bereaved

families.

The House stood in silence for two minutes as a mark of respect to the

memory of the deceased.

2

II. WELCOME TO THE MEMBER OF PARLIAMENT AND

FORMER MEMBERS OF THE HARYANA VIDHAN SABHA

The Parliamentary Affairs Minister, on behalf of the House,

welcomed Shri Dushyant Chautala, Member of Parliament and Shri Durga

Dutt Attri & Dr. Sita Ram, former Members of Haryana Vidhan Sabha, who

were sitting in the V.I.Ps. Gallery to witness the proceedings of the House.

III. ANNOUNCEMENTS

(a) BY THE SPEAKER

PANEL OF CHAIRPERSONS

Under Rule 13(1) of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business

in the Haryana Legislative Assembly, the Speaker nominated the following

members to serve on the Panel of Chairpersons :-

1. Shri Gian Chand Gupta, M.L.A.

2. Smt. Santosh Chauhan Sarwan, M.L.A.

3. Shri Anand Singh Dangi, M.L.A.

4. Shri Zakir Hussain, M.L.A.

(b) BY THE SECRETARY

The Secretary informed the House that the following Bills which were

passed by the Haryana Legislative Assembly during its Sessions held in

March, 2016 and August, 2016 and have since been assented to by the

*President/Governor:-

March Session, 2016

* The Payment of Wages (Haryana Amendment) Bill, 2016

August Session, 2016

1. The Haryana Right to Service (Amendment) Bill, 2016.

2. The Haryana Sports Council Bill, 2016.

3. The Court Fees (Haryana Amendment) Bill, 2016.

4. The Haryana Appropriation (No. 3) Bill, 2016.

5. The Haryana Vishwakarma Skill University Bill, 2016.

6. The Haryana Legislative Assembly (Facilities to Members)

Amendment Bill, 2016.

7. The Haryana State Legislature (Prevention of Disqualification)

Amendment Bill, 2016.

8. The Haryana Law Officers (Engagement) Bill, 2016.

9. The Haryana Development and Regulation of Urban Areas

(Second Amendment) Bill, 2016.

3

10. The Haryana Motor Vehicles Taxation Bill, 2016.

11. University of Health Sciences, Karnal, Bill, 2016.

12. The Haryana Tax on Luxuries (Amendment) Bill, 2016

13. The Haryana Legislative Assembly (Salary, Allowances and

Pension of Members) Amendment Bill, 2016.

IV. FIRST REPORT OF THE BUSINESS ADVISORY

COMMITTEE

The Speaker presented the First Report of the Business Advisory

Committee as under:-

“The Committee met at 9.00 A.M. on Friday, the 4th November, 2016

in the Chamber of the Hon’ble Speaker.

The Committee recommends that unless the Speaker otherwise

directs, the Assembly whilst in Session, shall meet on Friday, the

4th November, 2016 at 10.00 A.M. and adjourn after conclusion of Business

entered in the List of Business for the day without question being put.

The Committee, after some discussion, further recommends that the

Business on the 4th November, 2016 be transacted by the Sabha as follows:-

Friday, the 4th November, 2016 1. Obituary References.

(10.00 A.M.) 2. Presentation and adoption of First

Report of the Business Advisory

Committee.

3. Motion under Rule–15 regarding

Non-stop sitting.

4. Motion under Rule-16 regarding

adjournment of the Sabha sine-die.

5. Motion Under Rule-84

6. Any other Business.”

The Parliamentary Affairs Minister moved –

That this House agrees with the recommendations contained in

the First Report of the Business Advisory Committee.

The motion was put and carried.

4

V. MOTION UNDER RULE 15

The Parliamentary Affairs Minister moved-

That the proceedings on the items of Business fixed for today

be exempted at this day’s sitting from the provisions of the Rule

‘Sittings of the Assembly’, indefinitely.

The motion was put and carried.

VI. MOTION UNDER RULE 16

The Parliamentary Affairs Minister moved-

That the Assembly at its rising this day shall stand adjourned

sine die.

The motion was put and carried.

VII. NOTICE OF ADJOURNMENT MOTION

On being enquired by Shri Abhay Singh Chautala and Shri Naseem

Ahmad, M.L.As., the Speaker informed the house that their party’s members

adjournment motion regarding gfj;k.kk izns”k esa vk jgh fdlkuksa dks ikuh dh leL;k

ds lek/kku ds fy, lryqt ;equk fyad ugj (,l-okbZ-,y-) dk fuekZ.k o /kku ,oa cktjs dk

leFkZu ewY; u feyuk o iksiqyj dk jsV vR;f/kd de gks tkuk] iz/kkuea=h Qly chek ;kstuk

ls tcju dVkSrh djuk] ijkyh dh vk jgh leL;k vkSj dbZ bykdksa esa vR;f/kd ikuh ls vkbZ

lse o dbZ bykdksa esa ugjksa ds VwV tkus had been received and the same had been

disallowed due to various reasons but they insisted the Speaker to take up

Adjournment Motion given of by their party’s members first and rest of

Business be taken up after it because the matter of S.Y.L. Canal is a very

important for Haryana State. They demanded discussion on it. The Speaker

asked them that as per decision of the meeting of the Business Advisory

Committee, the discussion will be taken Under Rule 84 only today in which

the Members can also spoke on these issues also. The Speaker further asked

the Parliamentary Affairs Minister to move a Motion Under Rule 84.

VIII. WELCOME TO THE FORMER MINISTER OF HARYANA

AND THE SPEAKER OF THE PUNJAB VIDHAN SABHA AND

THE CHAIRMAN OF THE PUNJAB SUBORDINATE

SERVICES SELECTION BOARD

During the notice of Adjournment Motion:-

(i) The Parliamentary Affairs Minister, on behalf of the House,

welcomed Shri Ran Singh Maan, former Minister of Haryana,

5

who was sitting in the V.I.Ps. Gallery to witness the

proceedings of the House.

(ii) The Parliamentary Affairs Minister, on behalf of the House,

welcomed Shri Charanjeet Singh Atwal, Speaker, Punjab

Vidhan Sabha and Sardar Santa Singh, Chairman, Punjab

Subordinate Services Selection Board, who were sitting in the

V.I.Ps. Gallery to witness the proceedings of the House.

IX. RAISING THE MATTER OF STATEMENT GIVEN BY THE

CHIEF MINISTER, PUNJAB OVER THE S.Y.L.CANAL ISSUE

During the notice of Adjournment Motion, Shri Abhay Singh

Chautala, Leader of the Opposition raised the matter of statement given by

Shri Prakash Singh Badal, Chief Minister, Punjab over the S.Y.L. Canal

issue. He further stated that in his statement, Shri Prakash Singh Badal said

that Haryana would not get a drop of water for the S.Y.L. canal and no

matter what the Supreme Court decision would be in this regard.

Shri Bhupinder Singh Hooda, a Member of the Indian National Congress

Party also supported the views expressed by the Leader of the Opposition.

Shri Abhay Singh Chautala also demanded that this House should pass a

condemnation resolution against Shri Prakash Singh Badal, Chief Minister,

Punjab.

The Chief Minister clarified position in this regard and said that his

government already condemned the statement given by the Chief Minister,

Punjab.

X. NAMING THE MEMBERS OF THE INDIAN NATIONAL LOK

DAL/ADJOURNMENT OF THE SITTING.

Shri Abhay Singh Chautala and his party Members continued insisted

to bring a condemnation resolution against Shri Prakash Singh Badal, Chief

Minister, Punjab. The Speaker requested the Members of the Indian National

Lok Dal to resume their seats but they continued speaking without the

permission of the Chair even they came into the well of the House and

raising the slogans. The Members of the Treasury Benches strongly objected

it. There were heated exchanges between the Health Minister and the

Members of the Indian National Lok Dal. In spite of having been asked by

the Speaker time and again to take their seats but they did not do so.

6

Thereafter, the Speaker named S/Shri Abhay Singh Chautala, Anoop

Dhanak, Balwan Singh Daulatpuria, Kehar Singh, Naseem Ahmad, Om

Parkash Barwa, Parminder Singh Dhull, Pirthi Singh, Rajdeep Singh

Phogat, Ram Chand Kamboj, Ranbir Gangwa, Ravinder Baliala and Ved

Narang and asked them to withdraw themselves from the House. On them

not doing so, the Sergeant-at-Arms was directed to execute the orders.

On finding uproar in the House, the Speaker adjourned the sitting of

the House at 11.22 A.M. for 15 minutes.

The House then adjourned at 11.22 A.M and re-assembled at

11.37 A.M.

When the House re-assembled, the Deputy Speaker was on the Chair

and again adjourned the sitting of the House at 11.37 A.M. for 15 minutes.

The House then adjourned at 11.37 A.M and re-assembled at

11.52 A.M.

XI. RESCINDING THE DECISION OF NAMING OF THE

MEMBERS OF THE INDIAN NATIONAL LOK DAL.

When the House re-assembled, the Speaker rescinded his earlier

decision of naming of the Members of the Indian National Lok Dal and

allowed them to participate in the proceedings of the House.

XII. RAISING THE MATTER REGARDING FACILITES TAKEN

BY SOME MEMBERS OF THE INDIAN NATIONAL LOK

DAL FROM THE PUNJAB GOVERNMENT

Shri Jai Parkash, an independent Member raised the matters regarding

facilities taken by some Members of the Indian National Lok Dal from the

Punjab Government and demanded to pass a Condemnation Resolution

against them also.

XIII. DELETING THE OBJECTIONABLE WORDS FROM THE

PROCEEDINGS OF THE HOUSE

The Speaker ordered that the objectionable words made by Shri

Abhay Singh Chautala, Leader of the Opposition and the Health Minister

Shri Anil Vij be deleted from the proceedings of the House.

7

XIV. CONDEMNATION RESOLUTION AGAINST THE CHIEF

MINISTER, PUNJAB.

On a request made by Shri Abhay Singh Chautala, Leader of the

Opposition and supported by Shri Bhupinder Singh Hooda, a Member from

the Indian National Congress Party and agreed by the House, the

Parliamentary Affairs Minister, with the permission of the Speaker, moved-

“fd ;g lnu Jh izdk”k flag ckny] eq[;ea=h iatkc }kjk ,l-okbZ-,y- ugj ds

ckjs esa tks 1 uoEcj] 2016 dks tks Ck;ku fn;s x;s gSa] mudh Hkjiwj fuank djsA ”

The motion was moved and carried unanimously.

XV. WELCOME TO THE FORMER MEMBERS OF THE

HARYANA VIDHAN SABHA

The Parliamentary Affairs Minister, on behalf of the House,

welcomed Shri Subhash Katyal & Shri Daryao Singh Rajora, former

Members of Haryana Vidhan Sabha, who were sitting in the V.I.Ps. Gallery

to witness the proceedings of the House.

XVI. MOTION UNDER RULE 84

The Speaker informed the House that today’s Special Session is

convened on the occasion of the Golden Jubilee of Haryana Vidhan Sabha. It

is a different Session from other normal Sessions of Haryana Vidhan Sabha

and as per the decision of the Business Advisory Committee, no Questions

Hour, Calling Attention Motion, Adjournment Motion and raising various

matters etc. will be taken up today. He further informed the House that he

had received a motion Under Rule 84 of the Rules of Procedure and conduct

of Business in the Haryana Legislative Assembly on which the House will

take the discussion. He asked the Parliamentary Affairs Minister to move a

motion Under Rule 84.

At 12.01 P.M., The Parliamentary Affairs Minister moved –

“fd gfj;k.kk fo/kku lHkk dh 50oha o’kZxkaB ds volj ij cqyk, x, fo”ks’k l=

ij lHkh fo/kk;d vius&vius fo/kku lHkk {ks+=ksa esa vHkh rd tks fodkl ds dk;Z

gq, gSa ;k tks fodkl ds dk;Z vkxs gksus okys gSa] mu ij vius vius lq>ko nsa

rkfd muds lq>koksa ds vk/kkj ij u;s dk;Zdzeksa dks fdz;kfUor fd;k tk lds

ftlls vkus okys le; esa gfj;k.kk fodkl ds ekeyksa esa vU; jkT;ksa ds fy,

jksy ekWMy cus] ij ppkZ dh tk, A”

and spoke for 25 minutes

8

Smt. Kiran Choudhry, Leader of the Congress Legislature Party,

spoke for 24 minutes.

Shri Abhay Singh Chautala, Leader of the Indian National Lok Dal,

spoke for 45 minutes.

XVII. ADJOURNMENT OF SITTING

The Speaker announced that the House is adjourned for 45 minutes

for Lunch Break.

The House then adjourned at 1.35 P.M and re-assembled at

2.20 P.M.

XVIII. RESUMPTION OF DISCUSSION ON MOTION UNDER

RULE 84

When the House re-assembled, the discussion on motion under Rule

84 was resumed.

Shri Randhir Singh Kaprivas, Shri Subhash Barala and Shri Gian

Chand Gupta, Members from the Treasury Benches, spoke for 10, 19 and 11

minutes respectively.

Shri Parminder Singh Dhull and Shri Naseem Ahmed, Members from

the Indian National Lok Dal, spoke for 10 and 15 minutes respectively.

Shri Bhupinder Singh Hooda and Dr. Raghuvir Singh Kadian,

Members from the Indian National Congress Party, spoke for 23 and 10

minutes respectively.

Shri Tek Chand Sharma, a Member from Bahujan Samaj Party, spoke

for 8 minutes.

Shri Jai Parkash, an independent Member, spoke for 10 minutes.

The Health Minister, The Finance Minister, The Agriculture Minister

and the Minister of State for Social Justice and Empowerment, spoke for 19,

14, 16 and 21 minutes respectively.

The Chief Minister, by way of reply, spoke for 31 minutes.

XIX.WALK OUT

All the Members of the Indian National Congress Party, present in the

House staged a walk out as a protest against not given time to speak to their

some Party’s Members.

9

XX. THANKS BY THE SPEAKER.

Before the House was to adjourn sine die, the Speaker thanked the

Members of the House for their cooperation extended to them for the smooth

conducting of the proceedings of this House. He also thanked the Press

Representatives, Government Officers and the Officers/officials of Haryana

Vidhan Sabha Secretariat for their cooperation extended to them during the

present Session.

The Deputy Speaker occupied the Chair at 12.52 P.M. to 1.35 P.M.

The House then adjourned sine die.

CHANDIGARH SECRETARY

The 4th

November, 2016.