35
Reis. Rev.Esp.Investig.Sociol. ISSN-L: 0210-5233. Nº 167, Julio - Septiembre 2019, pp. 107-124 José Luis Sánchez-Hernández: Universidad de Salamanca | [email protected] Lourdes Moro-Gutiérrez: Universidad de Salamanca | [email protected] Los órdenes de justificación como marco analítico para el estudio de las prácticas económicas alternativas Orders of Worth as an Analytical Framework for Understanding Alternative Economic Practices José Luis Sánchez-Hernández y Lourdes Moro-Gutiérrez doi:10.5477/cis/reis.167.107 Palabras clave Capitalismo Comunidad Órdenes de justificación Prácticas económicas alternativas Sostenibilidad Resumen Este artículo emplea la teoría de los órdenes de justificación para estudiar las prácticas económicas alternativas que cuestionan el capitalismo. Los datos proceden de un cuestionario aplicado a participantes en 55 experiencias de seis ciudades españolas, y del análisis de once casos en Salamanca mediante entrevistas semiestructuradas, observación directa y seguimiento de sus espacios virtuales. Estas iniciativas alternativas construyen comunidades igualitarias, autogestionadas, autónomas y respetuosas con la naturaleza. Sin embargo, para garantizar su funcionamiento interno y satisfacer las exigencias del entorno normativo, deben introducir métodos industriales y comerciales de índole empresarial que son legitimados a través de compromisos con los argumentos domésticos y ecológicos. Key words Capitalism Community Orders of worth Alternative economic practices Sustainability Abstract This article draws upon the theory of orders of worth to study those alternative economic practices that bring into question capitalism. Data from a survey administered to people engaged in 55 alternative experiences located in six Spanish towns are discussed, along with an in-depth analysis of eleven cases from the city of Salamanca, where semi-structured interviews, field observation and the regular monitoring of virtual spaces were used. These alternative initiatives build egalitarian, self-managed and autonomous communities, strongly focused on a respect for nature. However, they are compelled to incorporate market and business practices in order to ensure their internal operation and satisfy the demands from the legal environment. These corporate-like procedures are thus legitimised through compromises with domestic and ecological arguments. Cómo citar Sánchez-Hernández, José Luis y Moro-Gutiérrez, Lourdes (2019). «Los órdenes de justificación como marco analítico para el estudio de las prácticas económicas alternativas». Revista Española de Investigaciones Sociológicas, 167: 107-124. (http://dx.doi.org/10.5477/cis/reis.167.107) La versión en inglés de este artículo puede consultarse en http://reis.cis.es

I) I~. · 2019-01-22 · ves --·~ ~, lotOTE Q ,.: l ~ ~ {E u I c: c: "' I u 2 ~ ~ c: 2-,. i = a ~,~ • c: 'i ~ ": f ~ • , -g -I "' ~ ~i~'J li .;:; g !I'°§ ~ ::,c:: ¥ a -I ~·"

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: I) I~. · 2019-01-22 · ves --·~ ~, lotOTE Q ,.: l ~ ~ {E u I c: c: "' I u 2 ~ ~ c: 2-,. i = a ~,~ • c: 'i ~ ": f ~ • , -g -I "' ~ ~i~'J li .;:; g !I'°§ ~ ::,c:: ¥ a -I ~·"

ves - -·~

~, lotOTE Q ,.:

l ~ ~ {E u I c: c: "' I 2 ~ ~ u :::

~ ! c: 2-,. i = a

~,~ • c: . f ~ 'i ~ ":

• , -g I ~ ~i~'J li - "' .;:; g ! I'°§ ~ ¥ a ~·" --I '"'18 ::,c:: u .E <-.u :; 13 I,• .

I ,,

I) J i

I~. i I .

KENNETH co~. STATE CatrrlOLLEI. CHAIRM:ii',, LEO T. ftCC~~THY~ LIEUTEIAIT GOVERNOR. COfltlSSIOllER JESSE R. HUFF~ DIRECTOR Of FJNANCE. COfltISSIOIER

CLO~ED SESSIOI. •c0tSIDERATIOlt OF POSSIBLE AID PENDllffi llTlGATlOI. THESE !!lTTERS,Wlll BE DISCUSSED 11 A SESSIOll CLOSED TO THE PUBllt. . PURSUAIT ro AT10Rl~Y-CLIENT' PRIVILEGES. (SACRMEIIO IFWSPAPEI &''&Y20 ~;."'\f-110 COUITY MHD Of SUPfRVISORS ( 1968) 26~0 • • 111. 3-58. )• ~

10:00 "·"· - Ch:, THEREAFTER UPOI ADJOUIMEllT OF THE CU!SED SESSfiJI - PUil.JC REt.'T!IG <~i SESSIOI>.

CALENDAR ITEll REFEREICES TO A8 8" DE•TE i~' FD,!!!!· STREAll..IUIG ACT CCALIFORllA GOV£RMEIT COOE SECTIOI 65920 ET SEQ.)

I.

II.

III.

C!.

CZ.

Cl.

C4.

cs.

C6.

ct.

ClO.

cu.

C12.

OIDfl Of •1$1•$$

co.-FIRMTioii OF "INUTts FOR THE REETIIG :OF JUIE 26. 1986 AND SPECIAL MEETING OF ~!!LY 11. 1986..·

REPO~T Gf t:fE EXECUTIVE OFFI(~R.

COllSEIT CALENDAR C01-Cl6. \THE FOLLOWIIG ITEl'S ARE COllSIDERED TO BE llON-CONTROVERSIAL QYOIE WISHllG TO ADDRESS Al IT~ 01 THE COISENT CALENDAR MAY COftE FORWAID.AllD STATE THEIR NARE FOR THE RECORO.

A) ... _, MS. DMt£L 8. *-ill: 8) M'. - .... ,_ nf'lll£: C) M. ,_ .... ElllM.W u"'5rml (l.ESIUS): ~l of u.-~ llwvi-/Cont:i..-t:i-: - in s..t ~in c-.ty ..t t.. in s01- C-t:y .. (sW'tta; NC 4090. NC '1Jl. NC 534!5.)

£1.IZMEnl •· •••-- (MlflLJCMT'): ._,._.1 of - hcreat:iwl 'ier '9r8it: at Lalle T..,_, Pl&cer c-t:y. (s-tta: .. ~525) IAlPHNIFfnT,..,LYDIANIFfnT (~): ~ o~a ~-General LMn­<=-rcial un • .-reel of MJ-.r,... i... located in t:he SAC.--t:o •~-. Co~uq County. (Suett-a; .. ltJJ) . · " IW:If'JZ G.<S ,_. £UCrllC Cll9Mf (UWE): _.,_1 of an ........ nt to ... sur General LNee;- Ri~-f_..., u-. to _.._ t.. ~h of ,.,.,..rg9e1 l..t located in ti. S-wto ltiver. ~ in Shut:&.., T.._ count:iu. t:tle ou.r>.:.r.:..1:oluea ..- Glenn c-.t'ies. (Suettai, 1'tlC 54lt) ,_ ·-.:JLMI» J. MDI,_~ :J. Miii (~): ~l of·a Un-y_. ~l ...,._it: -Prot:ect:ive St:rvct:unt ..,.. 2ecrwet:i-l Us•. ~•l of t:ide <Ind sut.erged land located in the Sacr-to Riv~r. S.C~nto C-.ty. (S-t:t:a: W 21111) :I .-r<T IMYt:s,., Ull>A E. tM9YCS (~): Approval of a ten-yNr Cw.~r•l Perait - Prot:.ctive Strvct:unt .... •.c:.--ti01¥l UH • ..-rc•l of t:ia and s&>a..rged h~· loc•tcd in the $;)(;,,_t:o River. S..C~to,C-.t:r. (s.Mt:t:&; ~ ZlllJ) C2JU!PCE :J. IIaMID --liOloT i.' ~ Aa ~~(LESSEES): Appre>we led-.1ct:ion of eo.billf'd s1,,.1e Limit: I~ eo-r..,. ...,i,._t. General L••MJf­c-t-cial Use. perc•l of t:ide .., 1· II tr,... 1.- located .in Subw• Sl°"9' at: Su'/sun cit:y. Sol- County. ca.-: .. sn1>- · ~ STATE WMTAL QWIWY (MlllUCMf): Approval of a 4t-yw- ...... , ,.,..it: - "-itlic "9MC:r Use. s-"Cd Of tide.., sullrnu!jed J...i located in the '9t:a!~"llher at: s.. Pablo-lt&r. :>o:r- County. ca.-: w 2111,) ftdlMY £JITEllflltlSES .(IW'Pl..lCMr): ......,._. of a ."~YHr General '9rait: - aec:,...t:i-1 Use. parc•l of'sW-rged 1..,.. located int.Me T.._. - ,....,_ ..... Cl ~·CoUnt:y. (Gordon: .. l71l) .. TIE TMEa 9HOIES ~ (..uc::Mr}: T-il•t:ion of llDfic:c-~ial Leete_. approvaii of a U..-it- General ,.,..it: - lec:rwet:i-1, Us•. 44 circul- ,.,-ceh ..W t.. circul.- percels of~ I.- located in Liiii• Ta.-_. T.._ City, PlKer C:-ty. (Gonton; WP ~lS) ST .....:1S YllCNT Q.U8 (~): .......... of a 15-y_. C.-ral ,.,._it - hc:,...ti-l Us•. 12 circul- parcels uf s· II' u..-4 !Mid locat:H in the S- ~in Riwer •t: Tinel., Isl&lld. ~ JMquin c-rty. cc:or.n: .. !>166) -

SUUUTT PM:IFIC MTI&JMl. -· ~: IOCoiCUW Dm. WDA. - 91 .-r; ~ mT: - IPOiCIWP Jim ..am. UCSCllWIP ~ (IWl.JCMl'I): T--.-...t:ion._.,f c.-n.1 L .... - ::-rcialdbe _.. ...,--1 or a 15-r- ........a1 ,._.t'·­a.cr.t:i-1 UM. 12 circuw ..-Ub et se hr,.._. !...S 1~ in Lalre T .... at s..th Laile TllMe, !1 Dorado County. (G.JniM .. 55H)

-1- ..... :-: ..... :."" .,. ,. ..

Page 2: I) I~. · 2019-01-22 · ves --·~ ~, lotOTE Q ,.: l ~ ~ {E u I c: c: "' I u 2 ~ ~ c: 2-,. i = a ~,~ • c: 'i ~ ": f ~ • , -g -I "' ~ ~i~'J li .;:; g !I'°§ ~ ::,c:: ¥ a -I ~·"

I I

l~

CU. CITY OF lN'DIM. IEllCH (""'LJrMO: ~l ef mt-.. d 11t t9·• .-.,_ G.neral ia-it - Public ll!IMCY UM. percel .t tilM'1' ... r+. .... 1.-i 1-tM Mj-.M to tM ~b City lillib'of the City of Illeer'.Jal ...... S.. Di..- c:..nty. (PM; PIC Z"°')

Cl4. -TAlE OF~ - MIZGM STATE(W~SCIM9,(UWE): ~ of ., www aui~ of co-r- ,.mt - Public "9enCY Use on SOWW'ei9ft ,.,.. locat.9d in the Colorallo liwer at v..... rriz-. (Louie; NC 6141) ·

C15. c:cusrt OF SM LUIS CJUSllO; C"LIFCICA ........ OF PMa - ~ (~): AuthorizatiGn of ace~ of ~Y of s.ft° t.¥is.Obhpo !M•eMlll is-• •f .. replac-nt General Pe,.it - Public ~Y Use to the.,.,.. i.ent ,.f ~scanif .:.C,...tion ,_-eel of tide ands~ l..S located in U.. PKific ac.-. S- 4-is-C:;iispo cGUnty. (LippMrdt: .. 160J) . , , ' ,

C16. M.IE9T D. JOIDM llMl SUE JmDM (~): ......,_l of a i>-,_- Gefteral P91'ait -Rect"ffti-1 UH. tide .... nW. gecl 1.... loc.t.t ..0.-.t..- of Walker Laftdi119. ·SAc~to •her. s.c~to Coui~y. (...,.icle: .. ZJn'>

IV. llEGULM CM.Ell'M ItDll 17 - JJ.

17.

11.

19.

20.

21.

22.

21.

24.

25.

WIUBft a. ~LOUD£ MT•.,...(~: DeR;W .. ittiout prejudice., -..ucai:ion for uH of Sblt..._._ property. as set forth in a..ter 1200. Statuti9s of 1tn (M "4): liluthoriu staff counsel ..Uor the Office of the ~Y General to take acti-. -includfog liti.,.tion 1'M7·.ejec:i-.t altd collec:ti- of campensation for -thorii• use of Sta~ tide .,.. sutii1!'ged land• located in tM .... liver ~ ·,.... Slough • ....,. County. (~: HMiy: ,w 2121J) -SEGMI. i.e. ("""-JCM'r): Deny without prejudic• • ., 1111Plication for UH of Sblu--n.d ...,,.litrty in S- F,._isco ..,. Siln Friincisco Count,. (~: W 20041) WllU OF umt l'lle[ZCErEllf (PMTY): -Authorizati- for Eaecution of a......,.~ -of ~bftdi"9 be~ St.te Laftds c-tsaion ,.,.. ..,,._ of lAnd l'lrlr91 1t to facilitata ·~i1d eachan9111. (0.tfield: S IJ75) r.l'Y OF~ HOUSJllG ,_ ~ ~ (Mlf'UCMT): ~al of a .. ,_,..r i'ublic ~' L-H to the City and.-, to act •• l'tllshr l•H- for the - •iont the s.cnii.n~ ~I"'" -terl.ront. S.Cr-1to c-tr. (A. Scott: Hedlr: w 20936) Olllf'a.IA OOIM'1"Ellf W WSilh' (APtlllCMI'): ,._a:dllut of Intenagency "9W1t (LCOJIOI) to .td n pucel of State set.al 1.,.. to be _.,., as ~tr•tion fonat,on behalf of the C-ission bg the Calit0rnia Dapae taent of For.stry. Shaiita County. (R .. se: Pit'; 6lt•) CM. JET. :me. (PHTY): C..Ci. '"'.!iOft of' llofalty OU .<;aJas Contract. Ventura Count,.. (Fre,.: PRC HS. PllC -'JO. P11C 4Z7. PIC 42t. PIC 146f/ OEVllC9 U.S.A •• i.e. (LESSEE): flelpnlval of - saies contracts Mtd,IA9eod•ent o~ Gas S.les Contrcts. State oil f!MIWl '!A• !HMS. Cont~ COsta. ~r-to;, Siln .J!)OlllUih~ •. "..t Sol- countiH. (Gonzalez: l.Sl: E-41S. PIC 714. NC 72'. PllC 2H€1. PllC J7-'l. 'PIC JIM. PRC 64ff) ~ ~CON'MY ('1UIGllOI): Asd.,..nt.,.. ,....._,t of State ail ..t 981 1-•· Hunt.~ INch Field. -Onf'lJe eo.A~. (T-; ~ H. PIC tlO. PIC l_lzt. P11C 16). NC~!!.~ PIC UJ1. LSE HZ. NC MO, NC UJZ. PllC 4ZS. NC HI. ~ UJJ. P11C 42,, P1C MS'. ~.1JJ4, NC 4n6. PllC tM. NC lJH. l.S£ 400, NC "9, P1C 1JJ7, LSE 4o1. NC ,,7, P11C 'i;,40. NC tlt. PIC tn. NC ·1J4S. PIC 4117) .• lllMIT D. 1&11\': IUllEU.·~. Glllll. JIR. (~): ~daartt of, State oil aM 'IH 1-M NC 6'41. Contra £ost&.<Jlld s.cr-to ~i... (T-: PIC "41)

-2-

R ega rd in g Calend~r Item 17: Approved a~ presented wi~h the underscana~ng chac staff would advise the Conmission befo~e init~atin~ litigatio~.

CALENDAR PAGE

rMl'lUTI; Pl.Ge 1766

Page 3: I) I~. · 2019-01-22 · ves --·~ ~, lotOTE Q ,.: l ~ ~ {E u I c: c: "' I u 2 ~ ~ c: 2-,. i = a ~,~ • c: 'i ~ ": f ~ • , -g -I "' ~ ~i~'J li .;:; g !I'°§ ~ ::,c:: ¥ a -I ~·"

ii ....

• =:: :! ~· ~ ;!. u C: < ~ ~ ~ u i: < ~ .. 0 = .. z ~,~ . 'O

~~I~ .. 0

'O 'O ~,~,~ !:! iii 6 0 "' s :; '~ ~- (J c. (J

§ • 5

~ ... 0

I l5 0 ~ :; c

26.

27.

21.

2!1.

30.

31.

JZ.

JJ.

...-on ,..mar WINJll. a.TY t1' _.. C....ucMO: -....st for an Ea...,tion of - oil aM ')Aa lila~fro. the ea...titiM 8itNi"" .... i..-ts of S.Ct:im 7052 of the C&lifornia Public -..-Cea c-. CT.._; w 40497) ~ "'8LlC .a.EJt ~ (~: AwthorizatiDft to Kc~.a Quitcl•i• OHd for ~the,._l lN•• in The c.,sera • ....-Cino Count,. (tto.,1..-wl: Ptic 6191) ...:M. ~TICJm (MlllUCMT): Ace~• of• quitcl•i• dMd ffW • portiiz:t of• 990ther.al leas. locaUd in ttie .,.rudi...,_ - on the -•t sia of Salton S... ~ial C-ty. Cltoa'Jland; PllC UJ7) MEIICllll COUOllJ CDNWW (PIEW • ..__.., .. , .. U.)': Approdl of .. tension of pef-mH:: to Pl"OSPKt for •ine~ls ou.r than oil .,.,. ')ea &M 990~1 ~ ... s- hrrwrdino c-nt,. (PeUa; PllC 6611) . SlftllS PIOfl£aTI£S (MIPl.ICMT): Autt.rization to -.ccept certain pr"OMrtJ i~reat ,,.,, S-is Propel-ties inwolvi"9 portion of .. tiQYitoa 1.-,oon, ~Di~ CountJ. (A. Scott; Fos-; s.g,.1•: W 20?2S.10J) . SMrA CUllM WIU£Y IM10 DDJIJCr (~): Dhcai•r of Sow-ign, ln'-•b in pa.-cal of lllftd nNr the CiullMl ... •i-. 5Mta CJara CountJ. (~alenti; •W 22350) IILW> VIAL (....uawr}: ,.._°"_. **= I rt of ~M Title S.tti, t ""H•nt to alete KCH• --~~ ·~ ~- (Val9Mi-; w 22112) OMUm»,.,, MIE (~: Cesaicln .t eoncun-t Cri..U.l 3uriacHction ower a portion of 14th StrMt:. Olllrl...i. cali'-ia. (Fre,; W 21415)

-J-