25

Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

� ������������� �����������������������������! "��#��$��� %��&�'����(*) "�,+�-/.�

02143�57698;:=<?>�@�A78B5 CED�5F3G6IH=CEDKJL8B5NMO8;6PH<78BQ7R�SF3GR�:�TBU�U'UVEWYX?Z[V]\2Z_^2^�Za`Gb2c

d'e4f'g�gGhFgBikjlg'mon2p'qsrat�d'e4uvraw'e4rj�xGtsw'r4y�uvr{z|r4hvhvg�w~}?w'uv��rat�suvq�� uvqsqL���2p2ty�f7� �N���a���2���

�����4�a���/�B�

� w�e4ratq�x�u�w�e4g�w�qLr4��qs����moxB�'u�m�p2m�rawGq�tg�nG���9z=�,�&m�g� 2r4hvu�w'y�eax�w¡�2r��'uvr4¢�r4 �xB�lmoxB�'u�m�p2m£h¤u�¥Br4hvu�f'g'g� ¦q�tsxBu�wG§u�w'y¡iIg't�r4�2n2g�w'rawGqsu�xBh�m�g' 2r4hv�a�Fx�w' |hvu�¥Brog�q�f'rat?moxB�'u�m�p2m¨h¤u�¥Br4hvu�f'g'g� �m�r4q�f'g' 2�©uv�{n2tg�w'r�qsgogB��rat«ª/qLqsu�w'y¬gBiq�tsx�u�w'u�w'y| /xBq�x®­~d'r4��ratsxBh,��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y=m�r4q�f'g' 2�]iIg�t]moxB�'u�m¯p2m°rawGq�tg�nG�=m�g' 2r4h¤�of2x���r��2r4raw�n2tg'n2g��sr4 �qsgxB 2 /tr4�L��q�f'uv��n2tg��'hvram��2�2p'q�n2tr4�'u¤g'p'�±t²r4��p'hvqs�� 2gow'g�qlmox�¥Brluvqle4h¤raxGt�f'gB¢!q�f'r4�sr���m�g�g�q_f'u�w'yom�r4q_f'g� 2�,e4g�m]§n2x�tr]¢�uvq�f��_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y�m�r4q_f'g� 2��iIg't�g�q_f'ratlq�Kn®r4�³gBi�t²r4h�x�qsr4 ´m�g' 2r4hv�a­ � w¦q�f'uv�³¢lg�ts¥N�2¢lr©��p2t�Gr4�~n2tr4��uvg�p'�¢lg�ts¥�u�w¦moxB�'u�m�p2m rawGq�tg'n��o�_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y�x�w' �e4g'mon2x�tr©q�f'r{n®rat«iPg�tsmox�w'e4r©g�ik�sr4�GratsxBh7gBi&q�f'r4�sr{xBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m��¢�uvq�f¡e4g�wG��rawGqsuvg�w2xBh7qsr4e4f2w'uvµKp'r4�liPg�t,��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y¬¶®§Oy�tLx�m·h�xGw'y�p2xBy�r©m�g' 2r4h¤��­�¸,r4eax�p'�sr©g�i�q�f'r©moxBq�p2tr©�2g' 2�gBi�tr4�srax�te4f¦u�w=¶®§Oy�tsx�m¨m�g' 2r4h&��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y~x�w' =q�f'r�e4hvg��sr�e4g�w2w'r4e4qsuvg�w=�®r4q¹¢lr4raw|moxB�'u�m�p2m¨raw�q�t²g�n��|x�w' e4g�wG��rawGqsuvg�w2xBh³¶®§Oy�tsxGmºm�g' 2r4hv�a�lq�f'uv�� 2g�mox�u�w»uv�¬¢lr4hvh¼§O��p'uvqsr4 ½qsg=y'x�p'y�r~q_f'r´n2rat¹iIg�tLmox�w'e4r~g�iEmox���u�m�p2mrawGq�tg�nG�|��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y=m�r4q�f'g' 2�a­=¾?��rat�x¦h�xGty�r�w�p2m��2rat]gBi? /xBq�x��Lr4qs�a�&¢lr�ª¿w' �q�f2x�q¯x�wÀz=����m�g'g�q�f'u�w'ym�r4q�f'g' �n2tg�n2gG�sr4 oqsg�p'���G�¬ÁFx�ÂFratq�¬Ã �sÄ n2rat«iPg�tsm���xB�,¢�r4hvh7xB��g�t,�2r4qsqLrat�q_f2x�woxBhvh/gGq�f'rat�xBhvy�g'tuvq�f2m���p2w' 2rate4g�w'�suv 2ratsx�qsuvg�w7­¬Å�f'uv�]y�raw'ratsxBh�x�w' Àr_Ƭe4uvraw�q�m�r4q�f'g' =u�w���gGh¤�Gr4�¯p'�su�w'y´x�Ç]x�p'�s�su�x�wÀn2tuvg�t?g�w|q�f'ron2x�tLx�m�r_§qsrat�©g�i±q_f'r¬m�g' 2r4h�x�w' =�sr4hvr4e4qsu�w'y=moxB�'u�m¯p2mÉÈ�ÊKËBÌ4ÍPÎaÏ_ÐÑËGÏ�Ð?u�w'�sqsraxB ÀgBi±mox���u�m�p2mÒhvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g' Ón2x�tLx�m�r4qsrat�;x�h�p'r4��­lÔ=r©e4g�wGq�tsxB�sqlq�f'uv�©m�r4q�f'g' ~¢�uvq�f¦n2tr4�'u¤g'p'�Õ¶®§Oy�tsxGm ��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y¬m�r4q_f'g� 2�?qsg�r4�Kn'h�xBu�w|uvqs����p2n2ratuvg�tn2rat¹iIg�tLmox�w'e4r�­

Page 2: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

���������¿����� h�x�w'y�p2x�y�r{m�g' 2r4h¤���¿mox���u�m�p2m rawGq�tg�nG���2��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y

Page 3: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

� ����������� ��������

z=xB�'u�m�p2m raw�q�t²g�n����9z=���©m�g' 2r4hvu�w'y f2x��¯�2r4rawÀ��p'e4e4r4�s�²i p'hvhv� xGn2n'h¤uvr4 �qsg~x ¢�uv 2r¬tsx�w'yGrogBi� 2g'moxBu�w'�a��u�wG§e4h�p' 2u�w'y h�x�w'y�p2x�y�r~m�g' 2r4h¤u�w'y x��¯¢lr4hvh�xB�omox�wG�=g�q�f'rat�w2xBq_p2tsxBh�h�x�w'y'p2xBy�r�q�xB�_¥��¡Ã � � � ���N� ��Ä ­��Ng�t{m�x�w��n2tg��'hvram����2q�f'uv��q�Kn®r©gBikm�g' 2r4hvu�w'y�eax�w��2r©�'uvr4¢�r4 ~x��³moxB�'u�m¯p2m·hvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g' Ó�9z=ÁF�,q�tsx�u�w'u�w'y�iIg't�r4�2n2g'w'rawG§qsu�xBhlm�g� 2r4hv�a�&x�w' Àh¤u�¥Br¡g�q�f'rat]moxB�'u�m¯p2m hvu�¥�r4h¤u�f'g'g� Ym�r4q�f'g� 2�]uv��n2t²g�w'roqsg�gB��rat«ª/qLqsu�w'y~gBilq�tsxBu�w'u�w'y| /xBq�x2­Ô½f'uvh¤r?�sr4��ratLxBh2��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y{m�r4q�f'g' 2�&iPg�t&mox���u�m�p2m�rawGq�tg�nG�¯m�g� 2r4hv��f2x���r��®r4raw¬n2tg'n2g��sr4 �qsg{xB 2 /tr4�s�,q�f'uv�n2tg��'hvram Ã��®� � ���2� �;Ä �¿n2t²r4��uvg�p'�{tr4�_p'h¤qL�© 2g~w'g�qÕm�x�¥Br{uvq?e4hvrax�t©f'gB¢ q�f'r4�Lr¯�_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y~m�r4q�f'g' 2�³e4g�m�n2x�tr¢�uvq�f ��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y¬m�r4q�f'g' 2�liPg�tlg�q_f'rat�q�2n2r4�?gBiktr4h�xBqLr4 ´m�g' 2r4hv�a­

� gB¢lr4��rat4�7q�f'ratr¡f2xB�¯x��®r4raw=y�t²raxBq© 2raxBh�g�i�t²r4�srax�te4f¦u�wÀ��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y|¶2§Oy'tsx�mÒh�x�w'y'p2xBy�r¬m�g' 2r4hv�a�&x�w' uvq�eax�w¦�2r©��f'gB¢³w¡q�f2x�q³moxB�'u�m¯p2m raw�q�t²g�n��¡¶2§Oy'tsx�m�m�g' 2r4hv�ÕxGtr³e4hvg��Lr4h¤�|tr4h�xBqsr4 �qsg�e4g�w��Graw�qsuvg�w2x�h ¶®§Oy�tLx�mm�g' 2r4hv�a­�jlg�w'�Lr4µKp'rawGqshv���2q�f'uv�� 2g�m�xBu�wouv��¢lr4hvh¼§O��p'uvqsr4 ~qsg�y�xGp'y�u�w'y¯q_f'rÕn®rat«iIg'tsmox�w'e4r©gBi&moxB�'u�m�p2m·rawGq�tg�nG���m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y¬m�r4q�f'g� 2�©tr4h�xBqsuv��r©qLgog�q�f'ratl�_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'yoqsr4e4f2w'u¤µ2p'r4�a­

� w�q�f'uv�l¢lg�ts¥N�B¢�r���p2t��r4�¬n2t²r4��uvg�p'�l¢lg�ts¥Eu�w¡moxB�'u�m�p2m�rawGq�tg�nG����m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y¯x�w' ¡e4g�mon2xGtr�q�f'r³n®rat«iPg�t«§mox�w'e4r]gBi��sr4�GratsxBhFgBi&q�f'r4�sr{x�h¤yGg�tuvq�f2m��?¢�uvq�f¡e4g�wG��rawGqsuvg�w2xBhFqsr4e4f2w'uvµKp'r4�?iPg�tl�_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y¬¶®§Oy�tsx�m h�x�w'y'p2xBy�rm�g' 2r4hv�a­{�&�BxBh�p2xBqsu�w'y~q_f'r�n®ratsn'hvr4��uvq�|gBi�raxBe4f|m�r4q�f'g' ´gB��rat?x�h�xGty�row�p2m��®rat?gBi� /xBq�x��sr4qs�a�7¢lrEª¿w' =q�f2xBqq�f'roz=� ��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y=m�r4q�f'g'  n2tg�n®g��sr4 �qsg´p'������ÁFx�ÂFratq� à �LÄ n2rat«iPg�tsm���xB�{¢lr4hvh�xB�{g't©�2r4qsqsrat]q�f2xGw=xBhvhg�q�f'rat]xBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m��¯p2w' 2rat�e4g�w'�Lu¤ 2ratLxBqsuvg�w7­ � w=q�f'uv�om�r4q�f'g' F�&x~Ç]x�p'�s�su�x�w�n2tuvg�t©g'w m�g' 2r4h�n2xGtsx�m�r4qsrat²�©u¤�x�n2n'hvuvr4  xGw'  m�xB��u�m�p2m È�Ê2ËBÌ4ÍPÎaÏ_ÐÑË�Ï_Ðlu�w'�sqsraxB ÀgBi�moxB�'u�m¯p2m¨hvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g' �n2x�tsx�m�r4qLrat?�;xBh�p'r4�¯xGtr{�sr4hvr4e4qsr4 F­Ô½f'uvh¤r¡�su�mon'hvr�x�w' =r_Ƭe4uvrawGqa��q�f'uv�¯m�r4q�f'g' =r4�2f'u��'u¤qL�¬xBhvh&gBi�q�f'r¬�®raf2xa�'uvg�t�]q�f2xBq{f2x���ro�2r4rawÀg��'�srat�Gr4  ���j�f'raw¦x�w' ~Ç©g'g� /m�x�w¡qsg¬�®r{�2raw'r_ª/e4u�xBh�iPg�t�¶®§Oy�tsx�m·��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y|Ã�� Ä ­

� w�q�f'r~tramox�u�w' 2rat�gBi³q_f'u¤�¡�sr4e4qsuvg�w7�,¢lr�n2t²r4�sraw�q¡x�w�u�w�q�t²g� /p'e4qsuvg�w»qsg=moxB�'u�m¯p2m raw�q�t²g�n���m�g� 2r4hvu�w'yx�w' | 2uv�seap'�s�©¢³fG�~�_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y¬z=�$m�g' 2r4h¤�]uv�{w'r4e4r4�s��x�t��­ � w´d'r4e4qLu¤g'w � �N¢�r]u�w�q�t²g� /p'e4r¬¶®§Oy�tLx�m�h�x�w'y'p2xBy�rm�g' 2r4hv�Õx�w' ��_p2momox�tu��4r{n2tr4�'uvg�p'�?¢�g'ts¥�g�w¡��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y�q�f'r4�Lr¯m�g' 2r4hv�a­&Ô=r©hvuv�sq?q�f'r© 2r4�su�tsx��'hvr¯n2t²g�n2ratqLu¤r4�gBil��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y~xBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m��{g��'�srat²��r4 =���=j�f'raw=xGw'  ÇEg�g' /mox�w7­ � w=d'r4e4qsuvg�w � �7¢�r�u�wGq�tg' /p'e4r¬mox���u�m�p2mrawGq�tg�nG�=¶2§Oy'tsx�mÒm�g' 2r4hv��xGw'   2uv�seap'�s��q�f'r4u�t�tr4h�xBqsuvg�w'�_f'u�n�¢�u¤q_f|e4g�wG��raw�qLu¤g'w2xBh�¶®§Oy�tsxGm m�g' 2r4hv�a­ � w�d'r4e_§qsuvg�w��/�l¢lr~�_p2t��r4�Yn2tr4�'uvg�p'��¢lg�ts¥�u�w!��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'yYmoxB�'u�m¯p2mÉrawGq�tg�nG�Ym�g' 2r4h¤�~xGw' Yu�w½d'r4e4qsuvg�w � �l¢lrn2tr4�srawGq�ÁFx�ÂFratq�� ��Ç]x�p'�s�su�x�w¡n2tuvg�tlm�r4q�f'g' F­&Ô=r?e4g�wGq�tsxB�sq,q�f'uv�³m�r4q�f'g' ¡¢�uvq�fo�_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y¬xBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m���iPg�te4g�wG��rawGqsuvg�w2xBh�¶®§Oy�tLx�m m�g� 2r4hv�¬xGw'  ��f'gB¢·q�f2xBq{uvq���xBqLu¤�²ª/r4�¬xBhvh�gBi?eatuvqsratu�x|gBi³j�f'raw�x�w' YÇ©g'g' /mox�w7­ � wd'r4e4qsuvg�w!�2�F¢lron2tr4�srawGq¯t²r4��p'hvqs�{gBi�r4�2n2ratu�m�rawGqs�]e4g�mon2x�tu�w'y=x�w'p2m¯�®rat©gBi³mox���u�m�p2m¨raw�q_tg�nG� xGw' =e4g�wG§��rawGqsuvg�w2xBh7��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y�qsr4e4f2w'uvµKp'r4��g'w¬¶®§Oy�tsxGm h�x�w'y'p2xBy�r©m�g� 2r4hvu�w'y/­"�&u�w2xBhvh¤���Nu�w�d'r4e4qsuvg�w#�]¢lr³ 2uv�seap'�s��g�p2te4g�w'e4h�p'�suvg�w'�a­

$�%&$ ')(�*,+&-/.,- 021�3545687�9:')6<;,=�>?+&1<@jlg�w'�Lu¤ 2rat?q_f'r¯q_xB��¥¡gBi�r4�sqLu�m�xBqsu�w'y�x�n2t²g��2x��'uvhvu¤q�¦ 2u¤�Lq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w!AK�CB/�lgB��rat?x�ª¿w'uvqsr��sr4qDBFEHG½yGu¤�Graw~�Lg�m�rq�tsx�u�w'u�w'y¦ /xBq�x¡�sr4qJILKNMOB�PRQTSUSTS�QVBXWJY'­ � w�q�p'uvqsuv��r4hv���&g'p2t?q�xB��¥ u¤�©qLg¡ª¿w'  x¡ 2uv�sq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w!A2�ZB/�?�su�m�uvh�x�t]qsgq�f'r©ramon'u�tuveaxBh� 2uv�sq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w\[] �CB/�ly�uv��raw��G�¡q�f'r{q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y¡ /xBq�x

[] �ZBN�<K)^V_ �ZBN�`¢³f'ratr ^V_ �ZBN�l 2raw'g�qsr4��q_f'r¯w'p2m¯�®rat�g�ikqsu�m�r4�aB~g'e4eap2t�?u�w#I xGw' ~¢³f'ratr ` u¤�?q�f'r©�su��4r]gBikq_f'rI�­ � w q�f'rr4�'q�tram�r©eaxB�Lr��2¢lr©eax�w¡q�x�¥BrJA2�ZB/�±qsgo�2r{uv 2rawGqsuveaxBh�qsgb[] �ZB/� �K�2p'q?q�f'uv��¢�uvhvh�q¹�2n'uveaxBhvhv�~hvraxB ~qLg¯gB��rat¹ª/qsqsu�w'yoqsgq�f'r]q�tsxBu�w'u�w'y� /xBq�x2­ � w'�sqsraxB F�7uvq?¢lg�p'hv  �®ro�2r4qsqsrat�qsg¬t²r4µKp'u�tr�q�f2xBqJA2�ZB/��moxBqse4f�g�w'hv�¦q�f'g��sr�n2tg�n2rat²qsuvr4�³gBi[] �ZBN�,q�f2xBq�¢lr© 2r4ram qsg¡�2r{�Lu¤y'w'u ª/eaxGw�q©x�w' �q�f2xBq�eax�w��2r�tr4hvu�xG�'h¤�¦r4�sqsu�moxBqLr4 ¡i tg'm q�f'r©q�tsx�u�w'u�w'y¡ /xBq�x2­

Page 4: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

�Ng�t?r4�2x�mon'hvr��Fe4g�w'�Lu¤ 2rat2B�KÒ��� P Q����_�?¢³f'ratr�� P x�w' ����]x�tr¬�,w'y�hvu¤�_f=¢lg�t 2���Fx�w' =hvr4q{q�f'r�q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y /xBq�x�I �®r³q_f'r³hvuv�sqlgBiFe4g�w'�sr4eap'qsuv��r?¢lg�t ¬n2x�u�t²�a��g�t��4Ð�ÏÈ��]Ì4��q�f2xBq,g�e4eap2t,u�w��sg�m�r�h�x�t²y�r�e4g�tsn2p'�lgBi��,w'y�hvu¤�_fqsr4�'qa­lÅ�f�p'���2q�f'r{q_xB��¥�u¤�?r4�sqsu�mox�qsu�w'y¬q�f'rEi t²r4µKp'raw'e4�¦gBi*�,w'y�hvuv��f|�'u¤y'tsx�m��a­ljlg�w'�Lu¤ 2rat©x��'u¤y'tsx�m q�f2xBq� 2g'r4�w'g�q]g�e4eap2tEu�wÀq�f'roq_tsxBu�w'u�w'y~ /xBq�x®�F��x��� ����������,­oÔÀr¬f2x���r [] �� ������������JK��2���2p'q{u�w�q_p'u¤qLu¤�Gr4h¤�À¢�r�¢±xGw�qA2�� ������������������su�w'e4r]q�f'uv�³�'uvy�tsx�m¨f2xB�©Ì4Ë���Î{e4f2x�w'e4r]gBikg'e4eap2tstu�w'y/­,Å�f'uv�³uv�©x�w¡r4�KxGmon'hvr{gBikx�n2tg�n2rat²q¹�gBi [] �ZB/�*q�f2xBq&¢lr� 2g{w'g�q, 2r4ram��suvy�w'u¼ª/eax�wGq�x�w' ¡q�f�p'�& 2g�w'g�q�¢�x�wGq&qsg{mox�qse[f]r4�2xBe4qshv�o¢�uvq�f�AK�CB/�4­ � gB¢lr4��rat4�hvr4qÕp'�©xB�s�_p2m�r©q�f2xBq�¢lr©g��'�Lrat��r{q_f2xBq�q�f'r©¢lg�t  ��!�" g�e4eap2t²�³¢�uvq�f�i t²r4µKp'raw'e4�#�2­� � u�w�q�f'r]q�tsxBu�w'u�w'y¡ /xBq�x2�Ð�$�Î%$�� & '�( [] ����!�")� � �<K & '+* [] ���aP���!�"2�<K,�XS-� � S

¸,r4eax�p'�sr¡gBi�q�f'r�x��2p2w' /x�w'e4r�gBi�q�f'r¡¢lg�t .��!�"7��q�f'uv��uv��n2t²r4��p2mox��'hv� x�w�xBe4eap2tsx�qsror4�sqsu�mox�qsr¬g�i±q_f'u¤�]iOtr_§µ2p'raw'e4�¬x�w' ouvq��Lr4ram���traxB�sg'w2x��'hvr³qsg{t²r4µKp'u�tr�q_f2xBq&g�p2t&�Lr4h¤r4e4qLr4 ¬ 2uv�sq�t²u��2p'qLu¤g'w A2�ZBN����xBqsuv�ª/r4�,q�f'r³x�w2xBhvg�yGg�p'�e4g�w'�sq_tsxBu�w�q & '�( A2����!�")� � �<K & '+* A2���aP/��!�"2�<K0�XS-� � S � � �

z|g�t²r´yGraw'ratsxBhvhv����¢�rÀeax�w½�Lr4h¤r4e4q=x$w'p2m¯�®rat¦gBi¬w'g�w2w'r4y�xBqsuv��r�tsx�w' 2g'm �;xGtu�x��'hvr4�=g�t214Î_È�Í�3�ÏÎ Ì546 KM76 P �ZBN�RQTSUSTS Q�698��ZB/�VY=x�w'  t²r4µKp'u�tr=q_f2xBq¬q_f'r=r4�Kn®r4e4qsr4 ½�BxBh�p'r gBi�raxBe4f�iPraxBq�p2t²r=gB��ratoq_f'r m�g' 2r4hAK�CB/��u¤�r4µ2p2xBhFqsgoq_f2xBqlgBikq_f'r©ramon'u�tuveaxBh� 2uv�sq_tu��2p'qsuvg�w [] �ZB/�;:& < A2�ZBN�=69>¹�ZB/�<K & < [] �ZB/�=69>s�ZB/� Q.?�K � QUSTSTS Q�@ S � � �

Å�f'r©e4g�w'�Lq�tsxBu�wGq�r4�Kn2t²r4�s�sr4 ~u�w r4µKp2xBqLu¤g'w � � �,eax�w��®r{r4�2n2tr4�s�sr4 ¦¢�uvq�f�q¢lg{�_p'e[f�iIraxBq_p2tr4�a�

6;A����aPRQ�� � �<KCB � u¼iD� A KE��!�"� g�q_f'rat¢�uv�sr

iPg�tGF2K � Q � ­Å�f'r¯e4g'w'�sq�tsxBu�wGqs�?y�uv��raw¦u�w r4µKp2xBqLu¤g'w � � �� 2g~w'gGq©y�raw'ratsxBhvhv�|��n2r4e4u¼iP� x¡p2w'uvµKp'r�m�g' 2r4h,A2�ZB/�4�7�2p'q{x��sr4q

gBi�m�g' 2r4hv�IHKJL ­?Å�f'r ��È%M;Ð��23N�ÒÎ9O/ÍPÏË_ÊQP~n2t²u�w'e4u�n'hvr¡�sq�xBqsr4��q�f2xBq?¢�r]��f'g�p'hv =�sr4hvr4e4q©q�f'r�m�g' 2r4h,AK�CB/��E)HRJL¢�uvq�f¦q�f'r�h�x�ty�r4�Lq©raw�q�t²g�n��#S��ZAB��KUT#V < A2�ZBN�2hvg�y,A2�ZB/��ÃW Ä ­ � wGq�p'uvqsuv��r4hv���&m�g� 2r4hv�]¢�uvq�f|f'u¤y'f|raw�q_tg�nG�~x�trm�g�t²rÕp2w'u¼iPg�tsm x�w' ¡e4g�tstr4��n®g�w' ¡qsgoxB�s��p2m�u�w'y�hvr4�s��x��2g'p'q�q_f'r³¢lg�thv F­�Å�f'rÕmox���u�m�p2m·raw�q�t²g�n��om�g' 2r4h7eax�w�2r�u�wGqsratsn2t²r4qsr4  xB�©q�f'rom�g' 2r4h&q�f2xBq{x��s��p2m�r4�©g�w'hv�|q�f'ro¥'w'g;¢�h¤r4 2yGroq�f2xBq?uv�¯tran2tr4�Lraw�qsr4 ����¦q�f'r]iIraxBq_p2tr4� 2ratuv��r4  i tg'm q�f'r©q�tsx�u�w'u�w'y¡ /xBq�x2�2x�w' ~w'gGq�f'u�w'y¬r4hv�sr�­

Å�f'r¬moxB�'u�m¯p2m°rawGq�tg�nG�´n2xGtsxB 2uvy�m f2xB�¯m�x�w��|r4hvr4y�x�wGq¯n2t²g�n2ratqLu¤r4��à � � ��Ä ­�Å�f'r¡moxB�'u�m�p2m°rawGq�tg�nG�m�g' 2r4hFuv�Õp2w'uvµ2p'rox�w' �eax�w��2r]��f'gB¢³w¡qsg¬�®r{x�w�r4�2n2g'w'raw�qsu�xBh�m�g� 2r4h�gBikq_f'r?iIg�tLm

AYX[Z*�CB/��K �\G] r4�2nF� 8&>_^8P+` >a69>s�ZB/�s� � � �

¢³f'ratr \G] K,V < r4�2nF��V 8>_^8P ` >a69>s�ZB/�s�±u¤�©xow'g�tLmoxBhvu��axBqsuvg�w i x�e4qsg�tlx�w' #b/K·� ` P QUSTSTS Q ` 8 ��x�t²r{q�f'r{n2x�tLx�m�r_§qsrat��gBi7q�f'r�m�g� 2r4hP­<�7p2tq�f'ratsm�g�tr���q�f'r�moxB�'u�m�p2m�rawGq�tg�nG�{m�g' 2r4h2uv��xBhv�sg?q�f'r�moxB�'u�m¯p2m�hvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g' ~m�g' 2r4hu�woq_f'r³e4h�xB�s�lgBiFr4�2n2g�w'rawGqsu�xBhFm�g' 2r4hv��yGu¤�Graw�����r4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w|� � �4­ P �&u�w2x�h¤hv���2q_f'r³hvg�yB§Ohvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g' |gBiFq�f'r�q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y*�c+d7egf�e�hjilkmhneoilp�q-egf+d%k=r-s�t+d7eou�vgk=u%f�p�ilw=qxu9qxu7y[z_egwYp�{jile�e}|Yh�egvgp�w�p�q-kmu7f�p�k�~�e�eg�Y{%w=r�p�kDp�d%k�f�e�z_k={9u7s�kmu�wDp�ilwmqxujqxu%y�f�egpg����d7eouvgk=u%f�p�ilw=qxu9qxu7y[eg|Yh�e}vgp�wYp�q-k=u%f�p�k�w=r-p�eoi�u%w�p�e��mw=rx{%e}fg��p�d%eQ�[wY|Yq-�G{%�.eoujp�ilk=hj����k�s9eorjt+qxrxr%u7kYp�~ne+p�d%e��[w�|Yq-��{7�)rxqx��eorxqxd�k�k�s/�[k�sjeor_�wmu7sIp�d7eG�I���[k�sjeor�t+qxrxr�u7kYp�eg|Yq-f�p�qxz�p�d%eGvgk=u%f�p�ilw=qxujp�fGwmile�qxu7vgkmu7f�q-f�p�eoujpg�

Page 5: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

 /xBq�x�u¤�?e4g�w'eax���r]u�w q�f'r¯m�g� 2r4h&n2x�tsx�m�r4qsrat�[b©�/x�w' ~q_f�p'�?uvq³uv�©tr4h�xBqsuv��r4hv�~raxB�L�¬qsg�ª¿w' ´q_f'r{p2w'u¤µ2p'r¬mox���u¼§m�p2m�raw�q_tg�nG����m�xB��u�m�p2m�hvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g'g' ~m�g� 2r4h7p'�su�w'y¯xBhvy�g'tuvq�f2m����_p'e[f�xB�,y�raw'ratsxBhvu��4r4 ¬uvqsratLxBqsuv��r��seax�h¤u�w'y¡Ã � � Äg�tlu�mon2t²g;�Gr4 �u¤qLratsxBqsuv��r©�seax�h¤u�w'y=à � Ä ­

Ô½f'uvhvr³m�g' 2r4hv�&¢�uvq�f�f'u¤y'f�raw�q_tg�nG�©qsraw' �qsgÕ�®r�tsxBq�f'rat�p2w'u¼iIg�tLm�g�tF�_m�g�gGq�f{x�w' �¢lr�mox��©g�w'hv�{e4g�w'�Lq�tsxBu�wn2tg�n®ratqsuvr4��gBi<AK�CB/�,¢lr³e4g�w'�Lu¤ 2rat±�suvy�w'u¼ª/eax�w�q��¿x�moxB�'u�m�p2m rawGq�tg'n��¬m�g� 2r4h7eax�w¡�sqLu¤hvhFgB��rat¹ª/q�q�tsx�u�w'u�w'y¡ /xBq�xr4��raw¡¢�uvq�f¡�_moxBhvh�w'p2m¯�®rat��gBi&e4g�w'�sq_tsxBu�w�qL�a­��/g�t,r4�2x�mon'hvr��/e4g'w'�suv 2rat�e4g�w'�Lq�tsxBu�wGqs�lg�w¡q�f'r?iOtr4µKp'raw'e4�¡gBi&q�f'r¢lg�t �W�����"��$x�w' |q�f'r¬�'uvy�tsx�mÉ\���� W�����"�����x�w'  xB�L��p2m�r�q�f2xBq©q�f'r�¢�g't �W���� "��»g�w'hv�=g'e4eap2t�¯x�iPqsratq�f'r©¢lg�t =\����¦u�w q�f'r{q_tsxBu�w'u�w'y¬ /xBq_x2­&Å�f'raw7�2¢lr©¢�uvhvhkf2x���r& '+* A2���DP{W�����"����"K & '+* [] ���aP]W�����"����<K [] �\����!W�����"��F�x�w' 

A2�\����!W�����"����<K [] �\�����W�����"����¢³f'uve4fou�mon'hvuvr4�DA2���DP{W�����"����<K0�?iPg�t�xBhvh��aP�K�\����­ � w�q�p'uvqsuv��r4hv���N¢lr�¢�x�w�q A2�ZB/�����EiIg't�xBhvh�B E#G!�su�w'e4rxBhvh��'uvy�tsxGm��kf2x���r&�Lg�m�r&e4f2x�w'e4r�gBi2g'e4eap2tstu�w'y/­��7ratg³n2t²g��2x��'uvhvu¤qLu¤r4�&hvraxB ]qsg�u�wGª¿w'uvqsrlhvg��s��u�wEhvg�yB§Ohvg��s��g��� r4e4qsuv��riOp2w'e4qsuvg�w'��xGw' �eax�w�hvraxB Yqsg�n2g'g�ton2rat¹iIg�tLmox�w'e4r�u�wYmoxGw�� xGn2n'h¤uveaxBqLu¤g'w'�a�{Î%$x�$��&¢?f'raw/A2�ZB/��tran2t²r4�sraw�qL�¬xh�x�w'y�p2xByGr³m�g' 2r4h/qsg��2r©p'�sr4 ou�wo�_n2r4r4e4f¬tr4e4gGy�w'uvqsuvg�w7­�Å�f'p'�a�'uvq�uv�l 2r4�su�tsx��'hvr³qLgoÌ��¯Ë�Ë�Í��¬moxB�'u�m�p2m�rawGq�tg�nG�m�g' 2r4hv�a�/g't�x� � ²p'�sq?n2x�tsx�m�r4qLratl�;xBh�p'r4�©x�¢±x���iOtg�m·q�f'r4u�t?moxB�'u�m¯p2m h¤u�¥Br4hvu�f'g'g� =r4�Lqsu�moxBqsr4�a­

� ��� �� ����V���������:��� � !"�D�#�����$� %'& � (%*),+Ô½f'uvh¤r�q�f'ratr=f2xB�~�®r4raw t²r4h�x�qsuv��r4hv�Óhvuvqsqshvr�¢lg�ts¥�u�w$�_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'yYmoxB�'u�m�p2m rawGq�tg�nG�Óm�g� 2r4hv�a�©q_f'ratr=f2xB��2r4raw¡x©y'traxBq& 2raxBh2gBiF¢lg�ts¥Eu�wo��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y�¶®§Oy�tsx�m�h�x�w'y�p2x�y�r³m�g' 2r4hv�a­ �.- È�O��3�È�'ÎI��Ë0/�Î - u¤�lx{n2tg'�2x��'uvh¤uvq� 2uv�sq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w A2�21a��gB��rat�¢lg�t² {�sr4µ2p'raw'e4r4�$1lq�f2xBq�m�g' 2r4hv��f'gB¢�gBiPqsraw]raxBe4f��sr4µ2p'raw'e4r31�g'e4eap2t�lxB��x?�srawGqsraw'e4r�­ÁFx�w'y'p2xBy�rom�g' 2r4h¤�{f2x���r�mox�wG�~x�n2n'hvuveaxBqsuvg�w'�a��u�w'e4h�p' 2u�w2y|��n®r4r4e[f|tr4e4gGy�w'uvqsuvg�w7��mox�e[f'u�w'r�q�tsx�w'�Lh�x�qsuvg�w7�Fx�w' ��n®r4h¤hvu�w'y~e4g'tstr4e4qsuvg�w|à �G� � �a� � �a��Ä ­

�Ng�tlx�¢lg�t ��sr4µ2p'raw'e4r41aK,�aP�56505l�$7 �2¢lr³eax�w r4�Kn2t²r4�s��uvqs�©n2tg��2x��'uvhvuvq¹� � ta�21���xB�� ta�21a� K � t4���aPs�98 � t4��� ��: �aPs�98�50565;8 � ta���<7 : �aP=56505g�$7?>�P��@8 � ta��"���� : �aP=56505g�$7v�

K7BA8PC>_^�P � ta���[> : �aP�50565l�[>�>�P��

¢³f'ratr¦q�f'r~qLg�¥Braw �$7DA�P K "������suvy�w2x�h¤�¡q�f'r¦raw' Óg�iÕq�f'r¦�srawGqsraw'e4r�­ Å�f'r|m�g��sq�¢�uv 2r4h¤�G§¹p'�sr4 ½h�x�w'y'p2xBy�rm�g' 2r4hv�a�2���]iOx�t4��x�tr�¶®§Oy�tsxGm�h�x�w'y�p2xByGr³m�g' 2r4h¤��­ � woxGwo¶®§Oy�tsx�m�m�g' 2r4hP�'¢�r?mox�¥Brlq�f'r³xGn2n2tgB��u�moxBqLu¤g'w�q�f2xBqq�f'rouv 2rawGqsuvq�=gBi±x ¢lg�t | 2ran2raw' 2�og'w'h¤�|g�wÀn2xB�sq{¢lg�t² 2�©q�f2tg�p'y�f q�f'rouv 2raw�qLu¤q�|gBi�q�f'roh�xB�Lq¯¶ T � ¢lg�t 2�a�y�uv�'u�w'y�p'�

� t4�21a�"K7BA8PC>_^8P � ta��� > : �aP�50565l�[>�>�P���E

7DA8PC>_^8P � t����[> : � >�>�P>F>HG?I;>�PKJ �

¢³f'ratr©q_f'r{w'g�q�xBqsuvg�w � A>  2raw'g�qLr4��q�f'r©�sr4µ2p'raw'e4r �[>L56505l��A©x�w' ~¢³f'rat²r � >�IMA � QTSUSTS�QY�9NÕxGtrÕx�h¤h�q�x�¥Braw¡qsgo�®r�sg�m�r© 2u¤�Lqsu�w'y�p'uv��f'r4  �2r4yGu�w2w'u�w'yB§Og�iѧO�srawGqsraw'e4roqLg�¥Braw7­

Å�f'r¬moxB�'u�m¯p2m°hvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g' $r4�sqsu�moxBqsr AYXPO�� �[> : � >�>�P>�>HG?I;>�PKJ �EgBi�q�f'r�n2tg��2x��'uvhvuvqsuvr4� � ta���[> : � >�>�P>�>=G?I;>�PKJ �©gB��rat�sg�m�r¬q�tLxBu�w'u�w'yÀ /xBq�x#I eax�w��2r�eaxBhveap'h�xBqsr4 $���=�Lu�m�n'h¤��e4g�p2wGqsu�w'y f'gB¢ gBiIqLraw=q�f'r¡qsg�¥�raw�� > iIg�hvhvgB¢���q�f'r

Page 6: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

��Ð Ì[ÍPËGÏ�P¡g�t,e4g�wGqsr4�'q/� >�>�P>�>HG I >�P J x�w' � 2uv�'u¤ 2u�w'y|���¡q�f'r©qsg�q_xBhFw�p2m��2rat±gBikqLu�m�r4�³q�f'r{f'uv�sqLg�t�¡g�e4eap2t���FÐa$ Î7$ �AYX9O����[> : � >�>�P>F>HG?I;>�PKJ �"K ^ _ ��� >>�>HG?I;>�PKJ �

^ _ ��� >�>�P>�>HG?I;>�PKJ � K ^ _ ��� >>F>HG?I;>�PKJ �V ' � ^ _ ��� >>�>HG I >�P J � S

� g;¢lr4��rat ��q�f'r©moxB�'u�m¯p2m·hvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g' |r4�sqsu�moxBqsr4�lgBiFq�f'r4�Lr{n2tg��2x��'uvhvuvqsuvr4�³q�2n'u¤eax�h¤hv�¡hvraxB �qsg�gB��rat«ª/qsqsu�w'y/�'x�w' u�w'�sqsraxB �uvq&uv�& 2r4�su�tsx��'hvr�qsg©p'�srl��m�g'g�q�f'r4 ]r4�sqsu�moxBqLr4��gBi/q_f'r4�srl�;xBh�p'r4�a­<�Ng�t�r4�Kx�m�n'h¤r��Bg'w'r��Lu�m�n'h¤r���m�g'g�q�f'u�w'yqsr4e4f2w'uvµKp'r|uv�¬qLg=hvu�w'raxGthv�Óu�wGqsratsn®g�h�xBqsr~q_f'r´moxB�'u�m�p2m hvu�¥�r4h¤u�f'g'g� �r4�sqsu�mox�qsr~gBi©q�f'r|¶2§Oy'tsx�m n2tg'�2x��'uvh¤uvq�AYX9O����[> : � >�>�P>�>=G?I;>�PKJ �,¢�uvq�f~x�w¡r4�Lqsu�moxBqsr©gBi&q�f'r¬�P¶�T � �«§Oy�tsxGm n2t²g��2x��'uvhvu¤q� � ta���[> : � >�>�P>�>=G?I;> � J �©Ã � �2� �a��Ä :

A������[��� > : � >F>�P>�>HG I >�PKJ �<K ` AYX9O����[> : � >�>�P>�>=G?I;>�PKJ ���½� � T ` �<A����������[> : � >F>�P>�>HG I > � J �RQ � ` � S � ���Å�f'rohvgB¢lrat«§Og�t 2ratEr4�sqsu�moxBqLroeax�w��2r¡ 2r_ª¿w'r4  x�w2x�h¤gGy�g�p'�shv���&x�w' �q�f'r¬tr4eap2t�Lu¤g'w=eax�w raw'  ¢�uvq�f�x~p2w'uvy�tLx�mg�t]p2w'u iPg�tsm° 2uv�sq�t²u��2p'qLu¤g'w7­´d'u�w'e4r�q�f'r¡hvg;¢lrat«§Og't 2rat© 2uv�sq�t²u��2p'qLu¤g'w'�¬x�trohvr4�s����n2x�t�sr4hv�|r4�sqsu�mox�qsr4 =iOtg�m q�f'rq�tsx�u�w'u�w'yo /x�q�x2��q_f'r4u�t±u�wGqsratsn®g�h�xBqsuvg�w¡y�raw'ratLxBhvh¤�~t²r4 /p'e4r4��gB��rat¹ª/qsqsu�w'y/­ � h�x�t²y�rÕw'p2m��2rat,gBi�gGq�f'rat,��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'ym�r4q�f'g' 2�liPg�t�¶®§Oy�tsxGm�m�g' 2r4h¤�©f2x���r©�2r4raw|n2tg�n®g��sr4 F�FÎ%$x�$��7à � �®� �®� � �2� � �'� � �®� � W Ä ­

ÔÀrÕn2tr4�Lraw�q�x��2tuvr_i�gB��rat�'uvr4¢Óg�ikn2xB�sq,¢�g'ts¥�u�w¬¶®§Oy�tLx�m m�g� 2r4h7��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'yN­k¾©w'r{�2x��suve©g��'�srat�BxBqsuvg�w�u¤�q�f2xBq�q�f'romoxB�'u�m�p2m hvu�¥�r4h¤u�f'g'g� �r4�sqsu�mox�qsr{gBi�q_f'r¯n2tg��2xG�'u¤hvuvq�~gBi�xGw~¶®§Oy�tsx�m q�f2xBq� 2g�r4�{w'g�q�g�e4eap2t?u�w¦q�f'rq�tsx�u�w'u�w'y� /xBq_x¡u¤�J�4rat²g~x�w' |u¤�©q_f�p'�©qsg'g¡h¤gB¢{�7x�w' |e4g�w'�sr4µ2p'rawGqshv�´q_f'r¯z=Á�n2tg'�2x��'uvh¤uvqsuvr4��gBi�¶®§Oy�tsxGm��©¢�uvq�fw'g�w �4ratg¡e4g�p2wGqs�©x�tr{yGraw'ratsxBhvhv�´qLg�g�f'uvy�f7­©Å�f'uv�³ 2uve4f'g�qsg�m]�´m�g�qsuv�;xBqLr4�³q�f'rEiIgGh¤hvgB¢�u�w'y¡iOtsx�m�r4¢lg�ts¥�iPg�t�r4�G§n2tr4�s�Lu�w'y]��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y{m�r4q�f'g' 2�a�B¢³f'uve4f�eax�w��2r�p'�sr4 �qsg³r4�2n2tr4�s��m�g��sq&r4�'u¤�Lqsu�w'y©��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y©qsr4e4f2w'u¤µ2p'r4�©Ã � � Ä :

A�� �Õ���[> : � >�>�P>�>HG?I;>�PKJ �<K B�����[> : � >�>�P>�>=G?I;>�PKJ � u¼i ^ _ ��� >>�>HG I >�PKJ �[���

� ��� >�>�P>�>HG?I;>�PKJ ��A����{��� > : � >F>�P>�>HG I > � J �Éu¼i ^ _ ��� >>�>HG I >�PKJ �<K,� S � � �

Å�f2xBq]uv�a�&u¼iExGw=¶®§Oy�tsx�m � >>�>HG I >�PKJ g�e4eap2t²�¯u�w�q�f'r¡q�tsx�u�w'u�w'y| /xBq�x®��q_f'r¬r4�sqLu�m�xBqsr ���� > : � >F>�P>�>HG I >�PKJ �Eu¤�¡p'�sr4 ��

q�f'uv�or4�sqLu�m�xBqsr¡u¤��y�raw'ratsxBhvhv�Yx¦ 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qLr4 Y��rat�Lu¤g'w=gBi?q�f'r~moxB�'u�m¯p2m°hvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g' ½r4�sqsu�mox�qsr�­=¾?q�f'rat¢�uv�sr��¢lr{�2xBe4¥ogBÂ|qsgox��seaxBhvr4 ���rat²�suvg�w�gBi�q�f'r¬�P¶�T � �«§Oy�tLx�m� 2uv�sq�t²u��2p'qLu¤g'w A�� �{���[> : � >�>�P>�>=G?I;> � J �4�'¢³f'ratr©q�f'r©hvgB¢lrat«§g�t 2rat� 2u¤�Lq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w!uv�oq�Kn'uveaxBhvhv�Y 2r_ª¿w'r4 $x�w2xBhvg�y�g�p'�Lh¤��qLg´q_f'r~f'u¤y'f'rat«§Og�t 2rat� 2uv�sq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w7­½Å�f'r��LeaxBhvu�w'yiOxBe4qsg�t � ��� >F>�P>�>HG I >�PKJ �,u¤�?e4f'g��sraw¡qsgoxB�s�_p2tr©q�f2xBq�rax�e[f¡e4g�w' 2uvqsuvg�w2x�hF 2uv�sq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w¦��p2m���qsg � ­�Å�f'r{xBhvy�g'tuvq�f2m 2r4�seatu��®r4  �G�¡r4µKp2xBqLu¤g'w � ���,eax�w��®r¯n'h�xBe4r4 |u�w�q�f'uv�liOtsx�m�r4¢�g'ts¥�¢�uvq�f q�f'r?iIgGh¤hvgB¢�u�w'y�tr4h�xBqsuvg�w'�j:

���� > : � >�>�P>F>HG?I;>�PKJ � K A ����� ��� > : � >�>�P>F>HG?I;>�PKJ �� ��� >�>�P>�>HG I >�P J � K � T `

A�� �{���[> : � >�>�P>F>HG?I;> � J � K A����������[> : � >�>�P>F>HG?I;> � J �LS

Å�f'ratrox�tr�q�f2tr4ron2tu�mox�t²�´ 2uv�sqLu�w'e4qLu¤g'w'���®r4q¢�r4raw¦��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y|xBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m��j:?¢³f'r4q�f'rat©x�w|xBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m¨u¤�Ð�O/ÍPÎaÏ ÊKË - ÈGÍPÎ /�g't#�sÈ����;Î /��Ë��³�l¢³f2xBq�q¹�2n2r¦gBi© 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qLu�w'y�uv��x�n2n'hvuvr4 ½qsg=q�f'r�z=Á r4�sqsu�moxBqLr~qsg=eax�h¤eap'h�xBqLr����[> : � >�>�P>�>HG I >�P J �4�/x�w' ~f'gB¢½hvgB¢lrat«§Og�t 2rat, 2uv�sq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w'�{xGtr©e4g�mon2p'qsr4 F­� w�u�w�qsratLn2g�h�xBqsr4 ½m�g' 2r4hv�a�lq�f'r~n2tg'�2x��'uvh¤uvq��r4�sqsu�mox�qsr

����[> : � >�>�P>�>=G?I;>�PKJ ��gBiÕxGwY¶®§Oy�tsx�m � >>�>HG?I;>�PKJ ¢�uvq�f

w'g�w �4ratg�e4g�p2w�ql 2ran®raw' 2�³g�w¡q_f'r{n2tg��2x��'uvhvuvq¹�~x��s�suvy�w'r4 �qsg�q�f'r©e4g�tLtr4��n2g'w' 2u�w'y|�P¶ T � �¹§Oy�tsx�mC� >>�>=G?I;> � J �2xB�u�w¡r4µKp2x�qsuvg�w=� ���4­ � w��2xBe[¥�r4 '§OgB´m�g' 2r4h¤���2q�f'r{n2tg��2xG�'u¤hvuvq��r4�sqsu�moxBqLr³gBi&x�w¬¶®§Oy�tLx�m·¢�uvq�f�w'g�w �4ratg�e4g�p2wGqlu¤� 2r4qsratsm�u�w'r4 �¢?f'u¤hvr©uvy�w'g�t²u�w'y�u�wGiPg�tsm�xBqsuvg�w�i tg'm�hvgB¢�rat¹§Og�t 2rat& 2uv�sq_tu��2p'qsuvg�w'�a­ � wGqsratsn2gGh�x�qsr4 ~m�g' 2r4h¤��u�w'e4h�p' 2r� r4hvu�w'ra¥B§Oz|rate4rat ��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y$à � � Ä xGw' YÔ$uvqsqsrawG§¹¸,r4hvh©��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'yÓà � � Ä �³�2xBe4¥Br4 '§OgB m�g' 2r4hv��u�w'e4h�p' 2r��©xBq����m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y~à � � Ä �/x��'�sgGh�p'qLr© 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qLu�w'y=à � W Ä �2x�w' ��©w'r4�srat¹§ ��r4����m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y¦Ã � � Ä ­

Page 7: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

Å�g� 2r4�seatu��2r�q�f'r] 2u¼Â rat²raw�q�q�2n2r4��g�ik 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsu�w'y/�N¢lr©¢³tuvqsr���� > : � >�>�P>�>HG I >�P J ��xB�

����[> : � >�>�P>�>HG I >�P J �<K ^ _ � � >>�>=G?I;>�PKJ �GT��7��� >>�>HG I >�P J �

^V_ ��� >�>�P>F>HG?I;>�PKJ � ����� � >>�>=G?I;>�PKJ �¢³f'ratr��¿� � >>�>=G?I;>�PKJ ��eax�w¦�2r{�'uvr4¢lr4  x���q�f'r{ 2uv�se4g'p2w�q©u�w�e4g'p2w�q?��n2xBe4rEi tg'm q�f'r{z=ÁÀr4�sqsu�moxBqLr¯x�w' ¦¢³f'ratr����� >>F>HG?I;>�PKJ �?u¤��q�f'r�e4g�w�q_tu��2p'qsuvg�w¦iOtg�mÒhvgB¢lrat«§Og�t 2rat? 2uv�sq_tu��2p'qsuvg�w'�a­~Å�f'r��;xBh�p'r������ >>�>HG I >�PKJ �?uv�2�4ratg�iPg�t�2xBe4¥Br4 '§OgB m�g� 2r4hv�´xGw' Yq�Kn'uveaxBhvhv� � ��� >�>�P>�>HG?I;>�PKJ ��A����{��� > : � >F>�P>�>HG I > � J ��iIg'tou�wGqsratsn2gGh�x�qsr4  m�g' 2r4hv�a­ � w - Ð�O/Î_È�Ï/�Ð Ì �_Ë�3�O/ÍPÐ�O�'�aq�f'rl 2uv�se4g�p2wGq��7��� >>�>HG I >�P J ��u¤�,q�x�¥BrawEqsg©�2r³n2tg'n2g�tqLu¤g'w2xBh�qLg³q�f'rlg�t²u¤yGu�w2x�h2e4g�p2w�q ^V_ ��� >>�>HG I >�P J �4�xB��u�w�r4µKp2x�qsuvg�w�� ����¢³f'ratr�q_f'r� 2uv�se4g'p2w�q&uv�Õ� � T ` �;5 ^ _ ��� >>�>HG I >�P J �4­ � w¡ÈN�_Ì4Ë - 3'ÍPÎ3/�Ð Ì���Ë�3�O/ÍPÐ�O�'���7��� >>�>HG?I;>�PKJ ��u¤�q�x�¥�raw{qLg{�2r³x?e4g�w'�Lq�x�wGqD�� � ­ � woÇEg�g' '§¹Å�p2tu�w'y{ 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsu�w'y/�'q�f'rl 2uv�se4g�p2wGq�uv�,eaxBhveap'h�x�qsr4 �p'�Lu�w'y]q�f'rÇ©g'g' '§¹Å�p2tu�w'yor4�Lqsu�moxBqsroà � � Ä �Kx�q�f'r4g�tr4qsuveaxBhvhv�G§¹m�g�qsuv�;x�qsr4 ~ 2uv�se4g�p2wGq?q�f2xBq�f2xB���2r4raw ��f'gB¢³w¡qsgo�2r{xBe4eap2tLxBqsru�w|w'g�wG§O��n2x�t�Lr{ /xBq�x��suvq�p2xBqsuvg�w'��à � �'� �2�[Ä ­ � �2t²u¤r_il 2r4�seatu�n'qsuvg�w¦gBi&q�f'r¯ÇEg�g' '§¹Å�p2tu�w'y�r4�sqsu�moxBqsr©uv�©y�uv��raw u�wd'r4e4qsuvg�w �/­ � ­ � r4h¤u�w'ra¥�§Oz|rate4rat©��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y¡x�w' ~Ô$uvqsqsrawG§¹¸,r4hvh&��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y¬p'�sr]hvu�w'raxGt? 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qLu�w'y � �©w'r4�srat¹§��r4�=��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y=p'�sr4�¯xG�'�sg�h�p'qsr¡ 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qLu�w'yN��x�w'  �©xBq�����m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y=x�w'  j�f�p2te4fG§¹Ç{x�h¤r¡��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y�à �2�LÄp'�sr�Ç©g'g� '§¹Å�p2tu�w'yo 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsu�w'y/­

Å�f'r�ª¿w2x�h/mox� g�t� 2u¤�Lqsu�w'e4qsuvg�wo�2r4q¢lr4raw���m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y{x�h¤yGg�tuvq�f2m��&uv��f'gB¢�q�f'r�hvgB¢lrat«§Og�t 2rat�n2tg��2x��'uvhvuvq�or4�§qsu�moxBqLr4��x�tr&eaxBhveap'h�xBqsr4 F­�Ô½f'uvhvr±m�g��sq7��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y³m�r4q_f'g� 2�� 2r_ª¿w'r�q�f'r&hvgB¢lrat«§Og�t 2rat�m�g� 2r4h A����{���[> : � >�>�P>�>HG I > � J �x�w2xBhvg�yGg�p'�shv�~qsg�q_f'r�f'uvy�f'rat¹§Og�t 2rat{m�g� 2r4h<A����{��� > : � >F>�P>�>HG I >�PKJ �4�7u�w �©w'r4�Lrat«§ ��r4�|��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y~x¡ 2u¼ÂFratrawGq{x�nG§n2tg�x�e[f u¤�?q�x�¥�raw7­�Å�f'r��P¶�T � �«§Oy�tsxGm�m�g' 2r4h�uv�?e[f'g��Lraw�qsgo�_xBqsuv�iP��e4ratq�xBu�w�e4g'w'�sq�tsxBu�wGqs�? 2ratuv��r4 ¦i tg'm q�f'rq�tsx�u�w'u�w'y¡ /xBq�x2�2w2x�m�r4h¤� &' �� ���� *�� ^ _ ��� >�>�P>F>HG?I;>�PKJ ��A����©���[> : � >F>�P>�>HG I >�PKJ �,K ^ _ ��� >>�>HG I > � J � �Z���

iPg�t�xBhvh��P¶ T � �«§Oy�tsxGm���� >>�>HG?I;> � J ­&Å�f'uv��e4g'w'�sq�tsxBu�wGq�eax�w¡�2r©tran2f2tsx��sr4 ~xB�j:�Å�f'r³r4�2n2r4e4qLr4 ~w�p2m��2rat,gBi�qsu�m�r4�� >>�>HG I > � J g�e4eap2t�?u�w�q�f'r]q�tsxBu�w'u�w'y¡ /xBq�x�y�uv��raw¦q�f'r{m�g� 2r4h<A����{��� > : � >F>�P>�>HG I >�PKJ ��xGw' ~q�f'r�f'u¤�Lqsg�t��i t²r4µKp'raw'e4uvr4�^V_ ��� >�>�P>F>HG?I;>�PKJ �{�_f'g�p'hv �r4µKp2xBhlq�f'r�xBe4q�p2x�h±w'p2m��2rat]gBi³qLu�m�r4�ouvq¯g'e4eap2t�a­ �©w'r4�Lrat«§ ��r4���_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y´eaxGw �®rx�n2n'hvuvr4  tr4eap2t�Lu¤�Gr4h¤�|qsg�h¤gB¢lrat«§Og�t² 2rat� 2uv�sq�t²u��2p'qLu¤g'w'�a�Fu�w¦¢³f'uve[f¦eaxB�Lr{q�f'r�e4g�w'�sq_tsxBu�w�qL�¯�Z���?x�tr�w'g�q���xBqLu¤�²ª/r4 r4�2xBe4qshv��­ � w'�LqsraxB F�Nq�f'r{tuvy�fGq§¹f2x�w' ~�Lu¤ 2r]gBi&q�f'r©e4g�w'�sq�tLxBu�w�qs��x�t²r© 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qLr4 ´¢�u¤q_f�x��'�sg�h�p'qsr] 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qLu�w'yN­

j�f'raw=x�w' �Ç©g'g� /moxGw�Ã�� Ä n2tgB�'uv 2r�x�w r4��qsraw'�Lu¤�Gr¬e4g�m�n2x�tuv�sg�wÀgBi³xBhvh�gBi�q�f'r�¢�uv 2r4h¤�G§¹p'�sr4 !��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'yqsr4e4f2w'uvµKp'r4�a­,Å�f'r4�or4�;x�h�p2x�qsr³rax�e[fox�h¤yGg�tuvq�f2m�g'wox©¢�uv 2r©tsx�w'y�r�gBi¿q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y��sr4qL��q�f2tg'p'y�f�uvqs�&Ê2ÎaÏ Ê - Î�MBÐÑÍ�P]g�wqsr4�sq� /xBq�x2­&Å�f'r�n2ratsn'hvr4�'u¤q� ����� � I�� �lgBi�xom�g' 2r4h�A]g�w¦x�qsr4�sql�sr4qaI��/uv�³q_f'r{tr4e4u�n2tg�eax�h�gBi&q�f'r©y�r4g'm�r4q�tuvex���ratsxByGr�n2tg��2xG�'u¤hvuvq�oq�f2xBq�q�f'r³m�g� 2r4h/xB�L�suvy�w'�&qsg©raxBe4f]¢�g't �u�w�q�f'rlqsr4�sq&�sr4qa­&Å�f'r4��xBhv�sg¯p'�Lr�q_f'r� 2ratuv�;xBqLu¤�Grm�raxB�_p2tr �aÏËBÌ_Ì �ÎjONÍPϹË[ÊQP S � � I � �<K$hvg�y � �,��� � I � �4�'¢³f'uve4f�eax�w��®r©u�wGqsratsn2t²r4qsr4 ~xB��q�f'r{x���ratLxBy�r³w'p2m��2ratlgBi�'uvqs�³w'r4r4 2r4 ¦qsgoe4g' 2r©raxBe[f¡¢lg�t² ¬u�w�q_f'r³qsr4�Lq��sr4q�p'�su�w'y¬q_f'r{m�g� 2r4h�A'­�j�f'raw|Î�Í�È - $�Ã��'� ����Ä xBhv�sgoe4g�w' /p'e4qLr4 r4�2n2ratu�m�rawGqs�?u�wG��r4�sqLu¤y'xBqsu�w'y�f'gB¢½q_f'r{eatg��L�§Oraw�q_tg�nG�ogBi�xoh�x�w'y�p2x�y�r{m�g' 2r4h�uv�³tr4h�xBqLr4 ~qsgouvqs�©n2rat¹iIg�tLmox�w'e4r¢³f'raw�p'�sr4 �u�w�x]��n®r4r4e[f¦tr4e4g�y�w'uvqsuvg�w¡�s�'�sqsram ­kÅ�f'r4�oiPg�p2w' �x{�Lq�tg�w'y�hvu�w'rax�tle4g�tst²r4h�x�qsuvg�w��2r4q¢lr4raw¡q�f'r?q¹¢lgm�r4q�t²u¤e4��¢³f'raw�e4g�m�n2x�tu�w'y�m�g� 2r4hv�?q�f2xBqlg�w'hv�� 2u¼Â rat±u�w ��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y/­

� w|qsratsm��©gBi±n®ratsn'hvr4��uvq����j�f'raw=xGw'  ÇEg�g' /mox�w´iIg�p2w' Àq�f2xBq �©w'r4�srat«§ ��r4�=��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y´xGw' ´�Bx�tu�xBqsuvg�w'�e4g�w'�suv�sqLraw�qshv�og'p'q�n2rat«iPg�tsm�x�h¤hNg�q�f'rat,xBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m���­�z|g�t²r���n2r4e4u¼ª/eaxBhvhv���Nq�f'r4�on2tr4�srawGq&iPg�p2t�mox�u�w�e4g�w'e4h�p'�suvg�w'�j:

� Å�f'r,i xBe4qLg�tFq_f2xBq�x�ÂFr4e4qs�&n2rat«iPg�tsmoxGw'e4r�q_f'r³m�g��sq�uv��q�f'r�p'�srlgBiFx©m�g' 2u ª/r4 ¡hvgB¢�rat¹§Og�t 2rat� 2u¤�Lq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w'�xB��u�w �©w'r4�srat«§ ��r4�o��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'yN­�Å�f'uv�lu¤�lq�f'r©n2tu�mox�t²�¬traxB�sg'w]iIg't&q�f'r?r4��e4r4hvhvrawGq³n2rat«iPg�tsm�x�w'e4r³g�i�q�f'uv�xBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m�­

Page 8: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

1 3 5 7 9 11 13id

eal a

vera

ge d

isco

unt

original count

trigram, 1MW training

bigram, 1MW training

trigram, 200MW training

bigram, 200MW training

�&uvy�p2tr � : �  2raxBh&x���ratsxByGr© 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�q?iPg�t?¶®§Oy�tsx�m���¢�uvq�f¦y�uv��raw�e4g�p2wGq?u�w¦q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y� /x�q�x�iPg�t � m�uvhvhvu¤g'w=¢lg�t q�tsx�u�w'u�w'y¡�sr4q³x�w'  � ���om�uvhvhvu¤g'w~¢lg�t² �q�tsxBu�w'u�w'yo�sr4qa�N�'u¤y'tsx�m�x�w' ¦q�tuvy�tsxGm m�g� 2r4hv�

� � �'�sgGh�p'qLr¯ 2uv�se4g'p2w�qsu�w'y¦u¤�©�_p2n2ratuvg�t?qsg¡hvu�w'rax�t© 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsu�w'y/­ �/g�t?¶®§Oy�tsx�m��³¢�uvq�f|x�y�uv��raw¦e4g�p2wGq���u�wq�f'roq�tsx�u�w'u�w'y| /xBq�x®��q_f'r4�´eax�h¤eap'h�xBqLr�q�f'r�x���ratLxBy�r� 2uv�se4g�p2wGq¯u�wÀe4g�p2wGq¯�_n2xBe4r �7��� >>�>HG?I;>�PKJ �?iOtg�m q�f'rz Á r4�sqsu�moxBqLr�q�f2xBq&¢lg�p'hv ¡eax�p'�sr�q�f'r?r4�2n2r4e4qsr4 �w�p2m��®rat�g�i¿q�f'r4�sr©¶®§Oy�tsx�m��&u�w¡x©qLr4�sq��sr4q,qsg{�2r?r4µ2p2xBhqsg�q�f'r4u�t³xBe4q_p2xBh�w'p2m¯�®rat¯� xB�s��p2m�u�w'y �l��� >>�>HG I >�P J �,K0���4­�Å�f'uv�?uv 2raxBhkx���ratLxBy�r© 2uv�se4g�p2wGq³uv�? 2uv��n'h�xa�Gr4 u�w �&uvy�p2t²r � iPg�t,e4g�p2wGqs��� �a� iPg�t,q¹¢lg]q�tsxBu�w'u�w'yo�sr4qs�,iPg�tl�'uvy�tsx�m�xGw' ¬q�t²u¤y'tsx�m m�g' 2r4h¤��­,�7tg�m·q�f'uv�y�tsx�n2f7��¢�r��sr4r�¢³f��=x�ª/��r4 = 2uv�se4g'p2w�q�¢lg�ts¥G�©¢lr4h¤hP­¡Ô½f'uvh¤r�Ç©g'g' '§¹Å�p2tu�w'y| 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsu�w'y|u¤��xBe4q�p2xBhvhv��2r4qsqsrat±q�f2x�w~xG�'�sg�h�p'qsr© 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsu�w'y~xBq³n2tr4 2uve4qsu�w'y�q�f'r¡È��aÎ�ÏÈ��Î� 2uv�se4g�p2wGqa�Nuvq³f2xB�?��r4q�qsg¬�®r¯p'�sr4 ¦u�w��p'e[f�x�¢±x��¬x���qsg¬n2tr4 2uve4q?q�f'r©e4g�tst²r4e4q� 2uv�se4g�p2wGqs�³u�w u�w' 2uv�'uv /p2xBh& 2uv�sq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w'�©¢lr4hvhP­

� � wGqsratsn2gGh�x�qsr4 ´m�g' 2r4hv�©g�p'q�n®rat«iIg'tsm��2xBe4¥Br4 '§OgB m�g� 2r4hv�?¢³f'raw¦e4g�w'�suv 2ratu�w'y~n2rat«iPg�tsm�x�w'e4r{g�w ²p'�LqÕ¶®§y�tsx�m���¢�uvq�f!h¤gB¢¨e4g�p2wGqs��u�wYq_f'r~q�tsx�u�w'u�w'y! /xBq�x2­�Å�f'uv��u¤�~�®r4eax�p'�sr|hvgB¢�rat¹§Og�t 2rat¡m�g� 2r4hv�~n2tgB�'uv 2r�;xBh�p2x��'hvr�u�wGiIg�tLmoxBqsuvg�w�iPg�tlr4�sqLu�m�xBqsu�w'yoq�f'r{n2tg'�2x��'uvh¤uvqsuvr4�]gBi*¶®§Oy�tLx�m��l¢�uvq�f�hvgB¢½e4g�p2wGqs�a­

� �  2 2u�w'y¦i t²r4r¬n2x�tsx�m�r4qsrat�©qsg~x�wÀxBhvy�g�tuvq�f2mÒx�w' Àg�n'qsu�m�u��4u�w'y=q�f'r4�sr¬n2xGtsx�m�r4qsrat²�©g�w=f'r4hv '§Og�p'q� /xBq�xeax�w¡u�mon2tgB��r©q�f'r{n®rat«iIg'tsmox�w'e4r]gBikx�w¦xBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m�­

¸lxB�sr4 =g'w~q_f'r4�srog��'�srat²�;xBqsuvg�w'����j�f'raw=xGw'  ÇEg�g' /mox�wÀn2tg�n2gG�srox�w|xBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m°w2x�m�r4 ���Ë0/GÐ �lÎ /�� O/Î4Ì4ÎaÏ �� ÎjP¦Ì ��Ë�Ë�Í���Ð�O�~q_f2xBq�u¤��iIg�p2w' !qsg|g�p'q�n®rat«iIg'tsm xBhvh�g�q�f'rat�m�r4q�f'g' 2�oe4g�w'�Lu¤ 2rat²r4 F­ � qouv�¬x�w�u�w�qLratsn2g�h�xBqLr4 �;xGtu�xBqsuvg�w�g�i �©w'r4�srat¹§ ��r4����m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y�¢�uvq�f~x�w�xGp'y�m�rawGqsr4 ���rat�suvg�w gBi�x��'�sg�h�p'qsr© 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsu�w'y/­ � w'�sqsraxB �gBip'�su�w'y~x��su�w'y�hvro 2uv�se4g�p2wGq �¨iPg�t�xBhvh�¶®§Oy�tsx�m��a�/q_f2tr4r{�sran2xGtsxBqsr] 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qL� � P[� � � �Fx�w' �� A�x�t²r�p'�Lr4 ~iPg�t¶®§Oy�tsx�m���¢�uvq�f�g'w'r©e4g�p2w�q��2q¢�g�e4g�p2w�qL�a�2x�w' ~q�f2t²r4r{g�t�m�g�tr©e4g�p2wGqs�a�/t²r4��n2r4e4qsuv��r4hv��­�Å�f'uv�?uv�Õm�gGqsuv�;xBqsr4 |���q�f'r]g��'�srat�BxBqsuvg�w�q_f2xBqlq�f'r{uv 2raxBh� 2uv�se4g�p2wGq�iPg�tlg�w'r_§Oe4g'p2w�qs�©x�w' �q¢lgB§Oe4g�p2wGqs��uv�?�suvy�w'u¼ª/eax�w�qLh¤�¦��moxBhvhvrat�q�f2x�wq�f'r©uv 2raxBh� 2uv�se4g�p2wGq³gBi�h�xGty�ratle4g�p2wGqs�a�NxB����f'gB¢³w¡u�w#�&uvy�p2t²r � ­

� & � �� � �(� � ����������� �����:��� � & � 4%@),+Ô=r,eax�w]e4g�w'�sq�tsp'e4q�h�x�w'y�p2xByGr±m�g� 2r4hv�&��rat�©�Lu�m�u¤h�x�t�qLg³e4g�wG��rawGqsuvg�w2xBh2¶®§Oy�tsx�m�m�g' 2r4h¤�&¢�u¤q_f'u�w�q�f'r�mox���u�m�p2mrawGq�tg�nG��iOtsx�m�r4¢lg�tL¥/­oÅ�f'r�moxB�'u�m�p2mÒrawGq�tg�nG�´m�g' 2r4hv�� 2r4�seatu��2r4 �u�w�d'r4e4qsuvg�w � ­ � x�tr g�u�wGq¯m�g' 2r4hv� �&qsgeatraxBqLr~q�f'r|e4g�w' 2uvqsuvg�w2xBh? 2uv�sq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w'�|p'�sr4 $u�wYe4g'w���rawGqsuvg�w2xBh©¶®§Oy�tsx�m m�g' 2r4hv��¢�r|p'�sr|q�f'r�iOtsx�m�r4¢�g'ts¥u�w�q_tg� /p'e4r4 |����¸ltgB¢³w|ÎaÍ,È - $Fà ��� Ä ­ � w'�sqsrax� ~gBi�r4�Lqsu�moxBqsu�w'y¬x g�u�wGq� 2uv�sq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w�A2�ZB/�,gB��rat,��x�m�n'h¤r4�JBF�'¢lr

Page 9: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

r4�sqsu�mox�qsr¬x¡e4g�w' 2uvqsuvg�w2xBhl 2uv�sq�t²u��2p'qLu¤g'wbA2��� : B/�?gB��rat?�_x�mon'hvr4�~�ZB�Q����4­ � w'�LqsraxB =gBi�e4g�w'�Lq�tsxBu�wGqs�{xB�{yGu¤�Graw=���r4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w � � �4��¢lr{f2x���r©e4g�w'�Lq�tsxBu�wGqs��gBi&q�f'r?iPg�tsm& <�� � [] �ZB/��A2��� : BN�=69>¹�ZB�Q�����K & <�� � [] �ZB8Q��'�=69>¹�ZB8Q��'� S �Z���

Å�f'uv��eax�w!�2r|u�w�qsratLn2tr4qsr4 Óx���tran'h�xBe4u�w'y AK�CB�Q��'�]u�wYq_f'r g�u�w�q�iIg'tsm�p'h�x�qsuvg�w�¢�uvq�fN[] �CB/��A2��� : B/� ­YÅ�f2xBq¡uv�a�¢lr¬xB�s�_p2m�roq�f2xBq�f'uv�sqsg�t�¦iOtr4µ2p'raw'e4u¤r4� [] �ZB/�©xGtroq�x�¥�raw¦i t²g�m¨q�f'r¡q�tsxBu�w'u�w'y| /xBq�x2��x�w' =¢lrog�w'hv�=r4�sqLu�m�xBqsre4g�w' 2uvqsuvg�w2xBh�n2tg��2x��'uvhvuvqsuvr4�a­Òjlg�w' 2uvqsuvg�w2xBh]z=��m�g' 2r4h¤�¦��f2x�tr=moxGw��!gBi¯q�f'rÀ��x�m�r=n2tg�n®ratqsuvr4�´x��( ¹g�u�wGqm�g' 2r4hv�a�lu�w'e4h�p' 2u�w'y$�2r4u�w'y m�xB��u�m�p2mÉh¤u�¥Br4hvu�f'g'g�  m�g� 2r4hv�a��x�w' Yf2x���r�e4g'mon2p'q�xBqsuvg�w2x�h±xGw' Ón2rat¹iIg�tLmox�w'e4rxB 2�Bx�w�q_xBy�r4�lgB��ratH g�u�w�q�m�g' 2r4hv��u�w¡h�x�w'y�p2xBy�r©m�g' 2r4hvu�w'y|à � �2� � Ä ­ � e4g'w' 2u¤qLu¤g'w2xBhFmoxB�'u�m�p2m rawGq�tg'n��om�g' 2r4hf2xB��q_f'r?iIg�tLm

AYX[Z&��� : B/�<K �\�] �ZBN� r4�Kn�� 8&>_^8P ` >�6j>��CB�Q��'�s� S �Z���

Å�g¡e4g�w'�sq�tsp'e4q{x�m�xB��u�m�p2m¨rawGq�tg�nG�~¶®§Oy�tsx�mÒm�g' 2r4hP�F¢lr�q�x�¥Br2B�K � >F>�P>�>HG I >�PKJ qsg~�®roq�f'rof'uv�sqsg�t�|x�w' �2K,� > qsgo�®r¯q_f'r?iIg�hvhvgB¢�u�w'y¬¢lg�t² F­<�/g�t±raxBe[f���§Oy�tsx�m K � >>�>HG��$>�PKJ ¢�u¤q_f �)K � QTSTSUS�Q�¶¦q�f2x�q�g'e4eap2t�?u�wq�f'r©q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y� /xBq�x2�G¢�r©u�w'e4h�p' 2r¯x�e4g�w'�sq�tsx�u�wGqlq�f2xBq*iIg�t²e4r4��q�f'r?e4g�w' 2uvqsuvg�w2xBhFr4�2n2r4e4q�x�qsuvg�w�gBi�¯x�e4e4g�t 2u�w'yoqsgA]qsg¬�®r©q�f'r{��xGm�r{xB�luvqs��iOtr4µ2p'raw'e4��u�w�q�f'r©q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y¡ /xBq�x®­kÅ�f'r{e4g�tst²r4��n2g�w' 2u�w'y�iIrax�q�p2tr4�/6��B�ZB�Q����lx�tr

6����ZB�Q�����K B � u¼iÕ�ZB8Q��'��K0� >>�>=G?I;>�PKJ raw' 2�³u�w�� gGq�f'rat¢�uv�sr S

d2p2�'�sqsuvq�p'qLu�w'y¡q�f'r4�srEiIrax�q�p2tr4��u�wGqsgor4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w=�Z����x�w' ��su�mon'hvu¼iI�'u�w'y/�7¢lr{x�tstuv��r{xBq�e4g�w'�sq�tsx�u�wGqs�lgBi&q�f'r?iPg�tsm&' ��� ���� *���� ������� G ' ��� ���� *�� J�^�� [] ���>F>�P>�>HG I >�PKJ ��A2��� > : � >F>�P>�>HG I >�PKJ �,KN[] ��B� S ��W��

� w´i xBe4q��7q�f'r�g�w'hv�´�Lg�h�p'qsuvg�w|qsg�q�f'r4�Lr¯e4g'w'�sq�tsxBu�wGqs�©uv� A2��� : B/� K A X9O ��� : B/�4­]jlg�w'�sr4µ2p'raw�qLh¤����q�f'romox���u�m�p2mrawGq�tg�nG�=m�g� 2r4h,uv�ouv 2raw�qsuveaxBhlqsg¦q�f'r�moxB�'u�m�p2m h¤u�¥Br4hvu�f'g'g� ½¶®§Oy�tsx�m°m�g' 2r4h�x�w' �uvq¯¢�u¤hvh��2r��2raw'r_ª/e4u�xBh?qsg��m�g'g�q�f¡q_f'r©r4�sqsu�moxBqsr4��gBikq_f'r{m�g� 2r4h�n2x�tsx�m�r4qLrat�[b/K M ` �VY�­� ramox�ts¥�x��'hv����q_f'r³�sr4q,gBi�m�g' 2r4h¤�ly�uv��raw¡�G�¯r4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w|�Z����¢�u¤q_f¬¶®§Oy�tsxGm�iPraxBq�p2tr4�,u¤�luv 2rawGqsuveaxBh7qsg{q�f'r��sr4qgBikm�g� 2r4hv�l 2r4�seatu��2r4 |����r4µKp2xBqLu¤g'w=� � �4�G¢³f'uve[f¡¢lr³p'�sr4 �qLg{r4�2n2tr4�s�³m�gG�sq�r4�'uv�sqsu�w'yo��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'yoxBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m��iPg�tFe4g'w���rawGqsuvg�w2xBh/¶®§Oy�tLx�m m�g� 2r4hv�a­�Å�g©�sr4rlq�f'uv�a�Gh¤r4q�p'�, 2r_ª¿w'r³x��sr4q&gBi���§Oy'tsx�m�m�g� 2r4hv� AYX�Z���� > : � >F>�P>�>HG��<>�PKJ �iPg�t��)K � QUSTSUS Q_¶¬x��&u�w�r4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w~�Z�G�4�B¢³f'ratr�rax�e[f���§Oy�tsxGm�m�g� 2r4hNg�w'hv��e4g�w�q_xBu�w'�&iPraxBq�p2tr4�&e4g�tLtr4��n2g'w' 2u�w'yqsg¡¢lg�t ~�Lr4µKp'raw'e4r4��p2n|qsg¡h¤raw'yGq�f��|�Fx�w' |¢³f'ratroxBhvh�m�g' 2r4h¤�]��f2x�tr]q�f'r���x�m�ron2x�tLx�m�r4qsrat��sr4qIb©­©Å�f'raw7�qsgo 2r4�Leatu��2r{q_f'r¯moxB�'u�m�p2m raw�q_tg�nG�¬m�g' 2r4h7iIg'tsm u�w�qsratLm���gBi�r4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w�� � �4�'¢lr©q�x�¥�r

�� �[> : � >�>�P>�>=G?I;>�PKJ � K AYX[Zk� �[> : � >�>�P>�>=G?I;>�PKJ �

K r4�2nF� ` ' �� ��� *�� �98 \�] ���>�>�P>�>HG I > � J �\�] ��� >�>�P>�>HG I >�P J � 8 AYX[Zk� �[> : � >�>�P>�>=G?I;> � J �

� ��� > : � >�>�P>�>=G?I;>�PKJ � K\ ] ��� >�>�P>�>HG?I;> � J �\�] ��� >�>�P>�>HG?I;>�PKJ �

A�� �{���[> : � >�>�P>�>=G?I;> � J � K AYX[Zk� �[> : � >�>�P>�>=G?I;> � J � S

Page 10: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

�/g't©x�w��|m�g' 2r4h�gBilq�f'r�iPg�tsm � � � �7¢�r�eax�w e[f'g'g��sr ` � p'�su�w'y~q_f'r¬x��2gB��r�r4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w'�]�sq�x�tqLu�w'y¡iOtg�m¨hvgB¢lrat«§g�t 2rat,m�g' 2r4h¤�,qsg{f'uvy�f'rat«§Og�t² 2rat�qLg©e4g�w'�sq�tsp'e4q�xGw�r4µKp'uv�BxBhvraw�q�r4�2n2g'w'raw�qsu�xBh7m�g' 2r4hI­ � ¸�r4eaxGp'�sr���m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y ` �r4�sqsu�mox�qsr4�{u�w�moxB�'u�m�p2m raw�q�t²g�n��|¶®§Oy�tsx�m°m�g� 2r4hv�ox�w' =�_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y~e4g�wG��rawGqsuvg�w2xBh�¶®§Oy�tsx�m°m�g' 2r4h¤�o�®g�q�fe4g�w'�suv 2rat�q�f'r©��x�m�r©e4h�x��s�³g�i*m�g' 2r4hv�a�2q�f'r4�Lr{q¢lg¯q_xB��¥G�±xGtr©e4hvg��sr4hv�~tr4h�xBqsr4 F­

� ��� �� ����V����& � �� � �(� � ��� ������� & �(%*),+� w»q�f'uv�o�sr4e4qsuvg�w!x�w' Yd'r4e4qsuvg�w � �&¢lr���p2t��r4��n2tr4�'uvg�p'�o¢lg�ts¥|u�w!moxB�'u�m�p2m rawGq�tg'n�� m�g� 2r4h��_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y/­� ratr���¢lr~ 2uv�seap'�L����ËaË0/ ���+3'Ï�Ð�O� /GÐ�Ì���Ë 3NONÍPÐ O ���1 3�����P �¯ÈnM;Ð�� 3�� ÎjONÍPÏË_ÊQPB��x�w'  1[ÈGÍ �_Ë�O®Ì[ÍPÏÈ�Ð�O/Í9Ì���u�w!q�f'riPg�hvh¤gB¢�u�w'y¡�sr4e4qsuvg�w7�N¢lr{n2tr4�srawGq�q�f'r¯Ç]x�p'�s�su�x�w�n2t²u¤g't³m�r4q_f'g� |n2tg�n2gG�sr4 ~���~Á�x�ÂFratq��­ � w� 2r4�seat²u��'u�w'y¦q�f'r4�srm�r4q�f'g' 2�a�&¢lr¡�sg�m�r4qLu�m�r4�¬p'�sr¡q�f'r( ¹gGu�wGqomoxB�'u�m¯p2m°rawGq�tg�nG�|iPg�tsm�p'h�xBqsuvg�w iIg't{�Lu�m�n'h¤uve4uvq��­ � hvh�gBi?q�f'r4�srqsr4e4f2w'uvµKp'r4�{x�n2n'hv�¦r4µKp2xBhvhv�|¢lr4h¤h�qsgoe4g'w' 2u¤qLu¤g'w2xBh&z=�Ym�g' 2r4hv� �7q�f'rox�w2xBhvg�y�g'p'��e4g�w' 2uvqsuvg�w2xBh&z=�!r4µKp2x�qsuvg�w'�eax�w��®r{ 2ratuv��r4 |���~tran'h�xBe4u�w'y#B�¢�uvq�f��ZB�Q����,x�w'  A2�ZBN�,¢�uvq�f [] �CB/��A2��� : B/� ­

�<%&$ H6<6<;� � ."45+?1 @��H+����X6�."1�35+&1<@Ç©g'g' '§¹Å�p2tu�w'y= 2uv�se4g'p2w�qsu�w'y f2x��¯�2r4raw!n2tg�n®g��sr4 ���� Á�x�pYà � Ä x�w'  � g��LrawGiIr4hv ½Ã � Ä x�w' �eax�w �®r���uvr4¢lr4 �xB�q�f'r¬m�xB��u�m�p2mÒrawGq�tg'n��|x�w2xBhvg�y�qsg �©xBq �o��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y�iPg�t?e4g�wG��rawGqsuvg�w2xBh�¶®§Oy�tsxGm m�g' 2r4hv�a­¬Å�f'r4�|g��'�Lrat��rq�f2xBqlq�f'r©mox�t²y�u�w2xBhv��g�i�q�f'r{m�g' 2r4h�AK� � : BN�&��f'g'p'h¤ ~w'gGq±�®r©e4g�w'�sq�tLxBu�w'r4 �qsg¯�®r©r4�KxBe4qLh¤�¡q�f'g��Lr³gBi�q�f'r³ram�n'u�t¹§uveaxBh� 2u¤�Lq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w [] � � : BN�4�/�2p'q?u�w'�sqsraxB |q�x�t²y�r4q��;x�h�p'r4�]��f'g�p'hv =�2r� 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsr4 =xB�?u�w¦e4g�wG��rawGqsuvg�w2xBh�¶®§Oy�tLx�m��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y/­ � w'�sqsrax� �gBike4g'w'�sq�tsxBu�wGqs�³xB��y�uv��raw�����r4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w=� W��4�'q�f'r4��n2tg�n2gG�sr{q�f'r?iPg�hvhvgB¢�u�w'y¬e4g�w'�Lq�tsxBu�wGqs�&' ��� ���� *�� � ������� G ' ��� ���� *�� J�^�� [] ���

>�>�P>�>HG?I;>�PKJ ��A2���[> : � >�>�P>�>HG I >�P J �<K []���� � ;�

¢³f'ratr�[]���� ��B�luv��q�f'r�Ç©g'g� '§¹Å�p2tu�w'y¡r4�sqsu�moxBqsr©g�i�q�f'r©iOtr4µ2p'raw'e4��gBi�'­Å�f'r{Ç©g'g� '§¹Å�p2tu�w'y�r4�sqsu�moxBqLroà � � Ä uv�Õx�q�f'r4g�tr4qsuveaxBhvhv�´m�g�qsuv�;xBqLr4 ´m�r4q�f'g' �iPg�tlr4�Lqsu�moxBqsu�w'y¡q�f'r{x���ratsxBy�r

 2uv�se4g�p2wGq�iPg�t?x�w�r4�Graw�q³�2x��sr4 ~g�w uvqs�³e4g'p2w�q?u�w~q_f'r{q�tsx�u�w'u�w'y¡ /xBq�x2­"�/g't³x�w¡r4�Graw�q?q�f2xBq�g'e4eap2t� ��qsu�m�r4�?u�w` ��x�m�n'h¤r4���2u�woe4g�wGq�tsx��sq�¢�uvq�f�q�f'r©moxB�'u�m¯p2m·hvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g' |r4�sqsu�moxBqsr��W �'q�f'r©Ç©g'g' '§¹Å�p2tu�w'yor4�Lqsu�moxBqsr�g�i�q�f'rr4��rawGqT ��q_tsp'r?i t²r4µKp'raw'e4��uv� ���W ¢³f'rat²r

��� K ¶ � A8P¶ �� � � � �

x�w' o¢?f'ratr³¶ � u¤�,q�f'r³w'p2m��2rat&g�i m�ram��2rat²��gBi7q�f'r³n2g'n2p'h�x�qsuvg�wo¢�u¤q_f�r4�Kx�e4qshv� �?e4g'p2w�qs��­ �©x�q��©Ã � � Ä ��p'yGy�r4�sqs�x�n2n'hv�'u�w'y¦q�f'uv�{r4�sqLu�m�xBqsr{qLg�raxBe[f g�u�w�q ��§Oy'tsx�m  2u¤�Lq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w7� � K � QUSTSUS Q_¶��7�sran2x�tsxBqLr4h¤��­��¿p2tq�f'ratLm�g�tr��xB�l¶ � eax�w¬�®r©��rat��hvgB¢Óg't<�4ratgEiIg�t*h�x�ty�r �'� �©x�q��³n2tg�n®g��sr4��x{m�r4q�f'g� ¡¢³f'ratr©¶®§Oy�tsx�m���¢�uvq�f�h�x�ty�r?e4g�p2wGqs�x�trow'g�q© 2uv�se4g'p2w�qsr4 �x�w' | 2uv�se4g�p2wGqs�©iPg�t?hvgB¢�e4g�p2wGqs�{x�troxB � sp'�sqsr4 =qLg¬e4g�m�n2raw'��xBqLr�­oÁFx�p=x�w'  � gG�srawGiIr4hv p'�sr]q�f'r �©xBq��©�Bx�tu�xBqsuvg�w gBikÇ©g'g' '§¹Å�p2tu�w'y¡ 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsu�w'y/­

� gB¢lr4��rat4��¢?f'raw�e4g�w'�sq_tsxBu�w'u�w'y�moxGty�u�w2xBhv��gBi�x�m�g� 2r4h�qsg¬Ç©g'g' '§¹Å�p2tu�w'y¡ 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsr4 ´moxGty�u�w2xBhv��gBi&q�f'rq�tsx�u�w'u�w'y= /x�q�x2��q�f'r�e4g�w'�sq_tsxBu�w�qL�¯mox�� w'g|hvg�w'y�rato�®r�e4g�w'�suv�sqsrawGqox�w' Yx|moxB�'u�m¯p2m°rawGq�tg�nG�=m�g' 2r4h³mox��w'g�q�r4�'uv�sqa­ �/g�tlr4�2x�mon'hvr��Nu�w´x�q�tuvy�tLx�m�m�g' 2r4h�e4g'w'�suv 2ratliPraxBq�p2tr4�?q�f2xBq�e4g�w'�sq�tsx�u�w q�f'r©iOtr4µ2p'raw'e4uvr4�©gBi�q�f'r¶®§Oy�tsx�m��/��� � ����� ����"|x�w' )�L�!� ����"|x�w' =xB�s��p2m�r�q�f2x�q³q�f'r�¢lg�t  �L�!�|g'w'h¤�¦iPg�hvhvg;¢��©q�f'r�¢�g't #��� �|u�wq�f'r©q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y¡ /xBq�x®­kÅ�f'raw7�/¢lr©¢�uvhvh�f2x���r©q�f'r]e4g�w'�sq�tsx�u�wGqs�

[] �����"�)���!�7��A2������" : ���"� �L�!�7�<K [] ��� ����� �.���!�)����"2�(gc+d7e�eg�Y{9q-�=w=r-eou%v}e�q-f u7kYp�eg|�w�vgp+wYf�eg|Yh�k=u%elujp�q-wmr���k�s9eor-f�vgw=u9u7kYpQeg|Yh9ile}f�f h9ilk=~%w=~9qxrxq-p�q egf�eg�Y{%w=r�p�k�#geoilkDkmiQkmu7eY�%$ u wYsjs;q-p�q-k=u��z_k=iGp�d7e�eg�Y{jq-�=wmr-eou7vge/p�k d7kmr-s p�d7e�{9ujq-ymilw��R�[k�sjeorQymq-�Yelu ~j�/eg�Y{%w�p�q-kmu'&"(�)��G{%f�pGw�f�f�q-ymu p�d%eDf�wY��e�h9ilk=~%w=~9qxrxq-p �2p�k�wmrxrQt+kmilsjfu7kYp�k�vgvo{ji�i�qxu%y�qxu p�d%eGp�ilw=qxu9qxu7y�sjwYp�wj�+c+djq-f q-f�yYeou7eoilw=rxr-�Ip�d%eGvgw�f�e�t+q-p�d eg|Yq-f�p�qxu%y/f��[k�kYp�djqxu7y�wmr-y�kmi�q-p�d7�[fg��

Page 11: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

x�w'  &' � ( [] ���[>�> � �L�!�/� AK�a� ��" : �[>�> � ���!�7�<K [] ����� �)�L�!�7��A2������" : ��� �)�����7�<K []���� ���L�!� ����"2� S

� w]y�raw'ratLxBhP�B¢�r&¢�u¤hvh/f2x���r []���� �����"� �L�!� � ��"2� �K []���� �a�L�!� � ��"2���su�w'e4r� 2uv�se4g'p2w�qs��iPg�t�¶®§Oy�tLx�m��FgBi/ 2u¼ÂFratrawGqhvraw'y�q�f|x�tr]eaxBhveap'h�xBqsr4 =u�w' 2ran2raw' 2rawGqshv� ��e4g'w'�sr4µKp'rawGqshv���Fq_f'r4�sr{e4g�w'�Lq�tsxBu�wGqs�³¢�u¤hvh��®r¯u�w'e4g�w'�Lu¤�Lqsraw�q�­ � w|n2tsxBe_§qsuve4r��7q�f'ratr�x�tr�w'g¬ 2u�troe4g'w'�sr4µKp'raw'e4r4�©qLg�f2x��'u�w'y¡u�w'e4g�w'�suv�sqsrawGq{e4g'w'�sq�tsxBu�wGqs�a­lÔ½f'uvhvroq�tsxBu�w'u�w'y~xBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m����p'e4f~xB��u¤qLratsxBqsuv��r]�seaxBhvu�w'y�mox���w'g�q�e4g�wG��ratyGr��/xotraxB�Lg�w2x��'hvr¯n2tg'e4r4 /p2tr]u¤�?qsgo�Lqsg�n¡q�tsx�u�w'u�w'y¡g�w'e4r¯n®rat«iPg�t«§mox�w'e4r�g�w��sg�m�r±f'r4hv '§Og�p'ql�sr4q,�sqsg�n'�&u�mon2t²g;�'u�w'y/­ � gB¢�r4�Grat4�Bu�w'e4g�w'�suv�sqsraw'e4�ouv�l�s�2mon'qsg�m�xBqsuvelgBi¿e4g�w'�Lq�tsxBu�wGqs�q�f2xBql¢�uvhvh�h¤rax� ~qsg¬n®g�g't�n2x�tsx�m�r4qsrat,r4�sqsu�moxBqsr4��­

Á�x�poÃ�� Ä e4g'mon2x�tr4��q�f'r�n2rat¹iIg�tLmox�w'e4r�g�i¿Ç©g'g� '§¹Å�p2tu�w'y³ 2uv�se4g'p2w�qsu�w'y?iPg�t7��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y?z=�~¶®§Oy�tsxGm½m�g' 2r4h¤�¢�uvq�f| 2r4hvr4qsr4 Àu�wGqsratsn®g�h�xBqsuvg�w!à � � Ä �Fx¡�Bx�tu�xBqsuvg�w|g�i � r4hvu�w'ra¥B§Oz|rate4rat]��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'yN�7iPg�t?e4g�wG��raw�qLu¤g'w2xBhk¶®§Oy�tLx�mm�g' 2r4hv�a­<�/g't�x � m�u¤hvhvuvg�w�¢�g't {q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y©�Lr4q&gBi/Ô xBhvh/d'q�tr4r4q � g�p2tLw2xBh�qLr4��qa�B 2r4hvr4qsr4 �u�wGqsratsn®g�h�xBqsuvg�w��'uvr4hv 2r4 ¬xn2ratLn'h¤r4�'uvq�{gBi ����� g�w]x��5���2������&¢lg�t² ©qsr4�sq7�sr4qa­�Å�f'r�mox���u�m�p2m$rawGq�tg�nG�Õm�g� 2r4h��'uvr4hv 2r4 ¬xl�shvuvy�fGqshv�©��p2n2ratuvg�tn2ratLn'h¤r4�'uvq� gBi ���2� ��¢³f'ratr¬x�h¤hl¶®§Oy�tsx�m��]q�f2xBq©g'e4eap2tstr4 �g�w'hv�=g�w'e4rou�wÀq�f'roq�tLxBu�w'u�w'y| /xBq_x¡¢�rat²ror4��e4h�p' 2r4 iOtg�m�q_f'r³z=��m�g' 2r4hP­ � gB¢�r4�Grat4�Bh�xBqsrat�tr4�_p'h¤qL�±�G�¬j�f'raw�xGw' �ÇEg�g' /mox�w¦Ã�� Ä �sq�tg�w'yGh¤��u�w' 2uveaxBqsr]q�f2xBq�gGq�f'rat��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y³m�r4q�f'g� 2��iPg�tNe4g�w��Graw�qsuvg�w2x�h�¶®§Oy�tsx�m½m�g� 2r4hv�a�B��p'e4f{x�� m�g� 2u¼ª/r4  �©w'r4�srat«§ ��r4�{��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'yN�a¢lg�p'hv g�p'q�n®rat«iPg�tsm  2r4hvr4qsr4 ¦u�wGqsratsn®g�h�xBqsuvg�w|�G��xom�p'e4f¡h�x�ty�rat�m�x�ty�u�w7­

�<%�� �<.���� 9 ')(�*,+?-�.,- 021�3545687�9� w¡q_f'rli p �R�4��moxB�'u�m�p2m rawGq�tg'n��]iOtsx�m�r4¢lg�ts¥E 2r4��r4hvg�n2r4 |�����©r4h¤h�x � uvr4q�tLx¯xGw' ��©r4hvh�x � uvr4q�tLx¬Ã ��� Ä ��u�w'�sqsrax� gBi�tr4µKp'u�tu�w'y=q_f2xBq©e4g�w'�sq�tLxBu�w�qs�{xGtro��xBqLu¤�²ª/r4 =r4�Kx�e4qshv���kx¦n2raw2xBhvq�|uv��x��s�sg'e4u�x�qsr4 =¢�uvq�f|u�w'r4�2xBe4q{e4g'w'�sq�tsxBu�wGq��xBqLu¤�²i xBe4qLu¤g'w7­��&u�w' 2u�w'y�q�f'r�moxB�'u�m¯p2m£raw�q_tg�nG�{m�g� 2r4hNuv��r4µ2p'u¤�BxBhvraw�qlqsg�ª¿w' 2u�w'y�q�f'r³m�g' 2r4h A2�ZB/����x�qsuv�iI�'u�w'yq�f'r�y�uv��raw|e4g'w'�sq�tsxBu�wGqs�?q�f2xBq©m�u�w'u�m�u �4r4��q�f'r �©p'h¤h��2xBe4¥�§¹Á7r4u��'h�rat� 2uv�sq�x�w'e4r �|�ZA ] ����� � �±iOtg�m q�f'r¬p2w'u¼iIg'tsmm�g' 2r4h ] ����� �¹�ZBN�4­ � w¡iOp �R�4��moxB�'u�m�p2m raw�q_tg�nG����q_f'r©g��� r4e4qsuv��r?i p2w'e4qLu¤g'w�uv�³q_x�¥Braw¡qsgo�2r

�´�ZA� ] ����� � ���� ��o�ZAB� � � ���¢³f'ratr���� 5 ��uv�lx{n2raw2x�h¤q�]iOp2w'e4qsuvg�w¬m�u�w'u�m�u��4r4 �¢³f'raw�e4g�w'�sq�tsx�u�wGqs�lx�trl��xBqsuv�ª/r4 �r4�KxBe4qLh¤�¡x�w' � ]uv�±x?¢lr4uvy�fGq§u�w'y�n2xGtsx�m�r4qsrat ­��©r4hvh�x � uvr4q�tsxoxGw' ��©r4h¤h�x � uvr4q�tsx���p'y�yGr4�sq�xon2raw2xBhvq�¡iOp2w'e4qsuvg�w�gBi&q�f'r?iPg�tsm

���ZAB�<K ��8& >_^�P �� �> � & < A2�ZB/�m6j>s�ZBN��T & < [] �ZB/�m6j>s�ZBN��� � S

Å�f'uv�³n®raw2xBhvq¹��i p2w'e4qsuvg�w¡eaxGw¬�®r³u�wGqsratsn2tr4qsr4 ~x���q_f'r³hvg�y�xGtuvq�f2m�gBi&x¯Ç]x�p'�s�su�x�w� 2uv�sq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w¡¢�u¤q_fo 2u�xBy�g'w2xBhe4gB�;x�t²u�xGw'e4roe4raw�qLratr4 =x�tg�p2w' |q�f'r�q�x�t²y�r4q³e4g'w'�sq�tsxBu�wGq³�BxBh�p'r4�a­�Å�f'ro�;xGtu�x�w'e4r � �> xB�s�sg'e4u�xBqsr4 |¢�uvq�f iIrax�q�p2tr69>²�CB/��eax�w|�2r�r4�sqsu�moxBqLr4 ~iOtg�m q�f'r�ramon'u�tuveaxBh& 2uv�sq�t²u��2p'qLu¤g'w=gBi�69>s�ZB/��u�w|q�f'r�q�tsx�u�w'u�w'y� /xBq_x2­��©r4h¤h�x � u¤r4q_tsxx�w' ��©r4hvh�x � uvr4q�tLx~ 2r4�Leatu��2r´x¦�Bx�tu�x�wGq¯g�i³y�raw'ratsxBhvu��4r4 YuvqsratLxBqsuv��r��seaxBhvu�w'y=q�f2x�q¯eaxGw �®r~p'�sr4 �qsg¦ª¿w' �q�f'rg�n'qsu�mox�h�m�g' 2r4h�p2w' 2rat�q_f'u¤��g��� r4e4qsuv��r©iOp2w'e4qsuvg�w=à � � Ä ­

ÔÀr�eax�w]u�w�qLratsn2tr4q�q�f'uv��xBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m i t²g�m½q_f'r��'uvr4¢³n2gGu�wGq&gBi¿mox���u�m�p2m ȱÊKËBÌ4ÍPÎaÏ_Ð9Ë�Ï�Ðl�9z �Õ� �7r4�sqsu�mox�qsuvg�w7­� w z �©� r4�sqLu�m�xBqsuvg�w7�F¢lroxBqsqLramon'q³qLg¡ª¿w' =q�f'rom�g' 2r4h,A¡¢�uvq�f¦q�f'r¬f'uvy�f'r4�sq�n2g��sqLratuvg�t©n2tg��2x��'uvhvuvq�´yGu¤�Grawq�f'r©q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y¡ /xBq�x I :

x�tylmoxB�� � ta�ZA : I=��K½x�ty�mox��� � t��ZAB� � t4� I : AB��K½x�ty�mox��� à hvg�y � ta�ZAB� ��hvg�y � ta� I : A;� Ä S � ��� �

W

Page 12: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

Å�f'r,z �©� g��� r4e4qsuv��r�iOp2w'e4qsuvg�w�f2xB��q¢lglqsratsm����;x�n2t²u¤g'tFqsratLm - Ë= � ta�CA;��x�w' ¯xlhvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g' ¡qsratsm - Ë= � t[� I : A;� ­Å�f'r,iOp �R�4�{z=�¦g��� r4e4qsuv��r,i p2w'e4qsuvg�w]y�uv��raw]u�w]r4µKp2x�qsuvg�w�� � ����uv��x�w2xBhvg�y�g�p'��qsg?q�f'rlz �Õ� g��� r4e4qsuv��r*i p2w'e4qsuvg�w7­Å�f'rlª¿t²�sq�qsratLm�u�wor4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w¦� � ����raw'e4g�p2tLxBy�r4��q_f'r³m�g' 2r4h�A?qsg�f2xa�Gr±f'uvy�f�rawGq�tg�nG����x�w' �eax�wo�2r?q�f'g�p'y'f�q&gBixB��q�x�¥Gu�w'y³q�f'r�tgGh¤r,gBi¿x?n2tuvg�t� 2uv�sq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w]iOx���g�tu�w'y³m�g�tr�p2w'u¼iPg�tsm�m�g' 2r4hv�a­�Å�f'r,�sr4e4g�w' �qsratsm raw'e4g�p2tsx�y�r4�A?qsg©��x�qsuv�iI��q�f'r�y�uv��rawoe4g'w'�sq�tsxBu�wGqs�a�2Ð�$�Î%$��Gqsg?ª/q�q_f'r�q�tsxBu�w'u�w'y� /xBq�xE¢�r4hvhP­�Å�f'uv�,qsratsm n'h�x��'��x©�Lu�m�u¤h�x�tltgGh¤r?xB�q�f'r]h¤u�¥Br4hvu�f'g'g� �qsratsm u�w~z �©� r4�sqsu�moxBqsuvg�w7­ � gB¢�r4�Grat4�/�2gGq�f�qsratLm��³u�w¦q�f'rEi p �R�4�¦z �!g��� ¹r4e4qsuv��rEi p2w'e4qLu¤g'wx�tr,��rat�© 2u¼ÂFratrawGq�q�f2xGw©q�f'r4u�t�z �Õ� e4g�p2wGqsratsn2x�tqL�a­ � w¯Á�x�ÂFratq�� �FÇ]x�p'�s�su�x�w�n2tuvg�t�m�r4q�f'g' {qsg©�2r, 2uv�seap'�s�sr4 u�w~d'r4e4qsuvg�w � �/x�q_tsxB 2uvqsuvg�w2xBhFz �©� g��� ¹r4e4qsuv��r?iOp2w'e4qsuvg�w¦uv�³p'�sr4 F�7x�w' ~¢lr©e4g�wGq�tsx��sqlq�f'r©q¢�gox�n2n2t²g�xBe4f'r4��u�wq�f2xBql�sr4e4qLu¤g'w7­

Á�x�p�Ã�� Ä e4g�w'�Lq�tsp'e4qsr4 =x�iOp �R�4�´moxB�'u�m�p2m¨raw�q�t²g�n��~¶®§Oy�tLx�m"m�g� 2r4h&r4�'e4h�p' 2u�w'y|xBhvh�¶®§Oy�tsx�m��?¢�uvq�f¦g�w'hv�g�w'r?e4g�p2wGq±p'�Lu�w'y�q�f'r³ /x�q�x]�sr4qs�l 2r4�seatu��2r4 ¦u�w�d'r4e4qsuvg�w �/­ � �G��uvr4hv 2u�w'y�x�n®ratsn'hvr4��uvq��gBi ��� �2­�Å�f'uv��uv���Lh¤uvy�fGqshv�¢lg�t�sr�q�f2x�w�q�f'rÕn®ratsn'hvr4��uvqsuvr4�{xBe4f'uvr4��r4 ~�G�oq�f'r? 2r4h¤r4qLr4 ~u�w�qLratsn2g�h�xBqLu¤g'w�x�w' �ÇEg�g' '§¹Å�p2tu�w'yo 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsr4 �z=�m�g' 2r4hv�a­

�<%�� �<(�3�� 681 �U3545(�+?183 �¾?q�f'rat,m�r4q�f'g' 2��iIg�t&t²r4h�x���u�w'y�e4g�w'�sq�tLxBu�w�qs�&u�w'e4h�p' 2r©¢lg�ts¥©�G� ��r4¢³m�x�w¡Ã � � Ä x�w'  �©f'p' /x�w2n2p2t?à � � Ä ­ � w�q�f'r4�srxBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m��a�'u�w'�sqsraxB ¦gBi��sr4hvr4e4qsu�w'y¡q�f'r{moxB�'u�m¯p2m raw�q�t²g�n��¡m�g� 2r4h7gB��ratlm�g' 2r4hv�DA2�ZBN��q_f2xBql��xBqsuv�iP�¬x��sr4qlgBie4g�w'�sq_tsxBu�w�qL�©r4�KxBe4qLh¤����q�f'r4�¦g�w'hv� tr4µ2p'u�troq�f2xBq©q_f'roy�uv��raw=moxGty�u�w2xBhv�{gBi�A2�ZB/��iOxBhvh�u�w|�sg'm�r¬tsx�w'yGr�xGtg�p2w' q�f'r©q�xGty�r4ql�;xBh�p'r4�a­ ��r4¢³mox�w¡��p'yGy�r4�sqs�³x�e4g�w'�sq�tsx�u�wGq�gBi�q�f'r©iPg�tsm8& >_^8P � > � & < A2�ZBN�=6 > �ZBN��T & < [] �ZBN�=6 > �ZBN��� � � �¢�uvq�f�iPraxBq�p2tr©¢lr4uvy�fGqs� � >�iIg�t,q�f'r©q_xB��¥�gBi�r4�sqsu�mox�qsu�w'y¬n2gB¢lratl��n®r4e4q�tsx2­ �©f'p' /x�w2n2p2t��_p'y�y�r4�sqs�le4g�w'�Lq�tsxBu�wGqs�gBi&q�f'r?iPg�tsm

�> & < AK�CB/�=69>s�ZB/� �� > Q.?8K � QTSUSTS�QY@ S

¸,g�q�f|g�i±q_f'r4�sr¬x�n2n2tg'xBe[f'r4�]eax�w��2ro�'uvr4¢�r4 �xB�]u�w'�Lq�x�w'e4r4��gBi�q�f'r�iOp �R�4� moxB�'u�m�p2mÒrawGq�tg�nG�¦i tsxGm�r4¢lg�ts¥N­� w'�LqsraxB {g�i®xl�_m�g�gGq�f�i p2w'e4qLu¤g'w7�Bq�f'r�n®raw2xBhvq¹���o�ZAB�7uv��q_x�¥Braw?qsg³�®r,�4ratg�u i�A±��xBqsuv�ª/r4��q�f'r�tr4h�xB�'r4 {e4g�w'�Lq�tsxBu�wGqs�x�w' �u�wGª¿w'uvqsr�g�q�f'rat¢�u¤�Lr�­�Å�f'r4�Lr©q¹�2n2r4��gBi*m�r4q�f'g� 2�?f2xa�Gr©��r4q�qsgo�2r�x�n2n'hvuvr4 ´qLgoh�x�w'y�p2xBy�r{m�g� 2r4hvu�w'y/­

� � ���a��+H+�� �a��� �������ÁFx�ÂFratq�~à �sÄ n2tg�n2gG�sr4�³x�n2n'hv�'u�w'y�xoÇ]x�p'�s�su�x�w�n2tuvg�t±g�w¡q�f'r{n2x�tsxGm�r4qsrat�[b$qsg���m�g'g�q�f�mox���u�m�p2m rawGq�tg�nG�m�g' 2r4hv�a­�Å�f'u¤�?qsr4e4f2w'uvµKp'r�f2xB�³�2r4raw|x�n2n'hvuvr4 =n2tr4�'u¤g'p'�shv�~u�w=Ã�� Ä ­ � r4eaxBhvh�q_f2xBq�xomoxB�'u�m¯p2m raw�q�t²g�n���m�g' 2r4huv�oq�f'r�moxB�'u�m¯p2m°hvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g'  m�g' 2r4h�x�m�g�w'y¦q�f'r��sr4q�gBiÕm�g' 2r4hv�oy�uv��raw�����r4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w$� � �4­=¸,� n®rat«iIg'tsm]§u�w'y moxB�'u�m�p2m È¡ÊKË�Ì[ÍPÎ�Ï�Ð9Ë�Ï_Ð{u�w'�sqsrax� �gBiÕmoxB�'u�m�p2m hvu�¥�r4h¤u�f'g'g� $r4�sqLu�m�xBqsuvg�w7�,¢�r¡eax�w�x�n2n'hv�Yx|Ç{xGp'�s�su�x�wn2tuvg�t?e4rawGqsratr4 =x�tg'p2w' �b K 4�¡qsg¡��m�g'g�q�f q�f'r�z=Á�m�g� 2r4h�qsgB¢�x�t ¦q�f'r¯p2w'u¼iPg�tsm m�g� 2r4hP�7q�f'p'�{f'g�n2r_iOp'hvhv�x�m�r4hvuvg�tsx�qsu�w'y¬gB��rat«ª/qLqsu�w'y/­

z|g�t²r{n2tr4e4uv�sr4hv���7¢�r]eax�w¡r4µ2p2xBqsr©ª¿w' 2u�w'y�q�f'r�moxB�'u�m¯p2m rawGq�tg�nG��m�g� 2r4hF¢�u¤q_f¡ª¿w' 2u�w'y´n2x�tLx�m�r4qsrat�[bq�f2xBq�mox���u�m�u��4r�q�f'r©hvg�yB§Ohvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g'  _ ��b��,gBi&q�f'r©q�tsxBu�w'u�w'y¡ /xBq�x I

_ �ab±�<K & < [] �ZB/�®h¤gGy A ] �CB/�LS

� �

Page 13: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

Ô$uvq�foq_f'rÕÇ]x�p'�s�su�x�w¡n2tuvg�t4�'¢³f'uve4fo¢lr?q�x�¥Br�qLg¯f2x���r? 2u�x�y�g�w2xBhNe4g;�Bx�tu�x�w'e4r��'g�p2t,g��� r4e4qsuv��r�i p2w'e4qLu¤g'w �_ ��b��q�f'raw q�x�¥Br4�lq�f'r?iPg�tsm yGu¤�Graw¡u�w r4µKp2x�qsuvg�w � �G� �4�

�_ �ab±� K _ �ab±� � 8& >_^8P hvg�y �� ��� � �> r4�KnF�gT `

�>� � �> � � �a� �

K _ �ab±��T 8& >_^8P ` �>� � �> ��e4g'w'�sq;��b�� Q � �a� �

¢³f'ratr©q_f'r � �> x�tr©q�f'r©�Bx�tu�x�w'e4r4�?gBi&q�f'r{Ç{x�p'�L�su�x�w7­ÔÀr³e4g�wGq�tsx��sq�q�f'uv��g'�� ¹r4e4qLu¤�Gr?i p2w'e4qsuvg�w¡¢�u¤q_f¡q�f'r³g'�� ¹r4e4qLu¤�Gr?i p2w'e4qsuvg�w¡u�w¡r4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w=� � ����iPg�t*i p �R�4��moxB�G§

u�m�p2mÒrawGq�tg�nG��­¬¸,g�q�f´i p2w'e4qsuvg�w'�of2x���roq¢lg¡qsratsm��a��g�w'ro¢³f'uve4f n2t²r_iIrat��m�g' 2r4h¤��q�f2x�q{x�tr¬m�g'tr¬p2w'u¼iIg'tsmx�w' �g�w'ro¢³f'uve4f�n2tr_iPrat�¯m�g' 2r4hv���su�m�uvh�xGt�qsg~q_f'roq�tsxBu�w'u�w'y| /xBq�x2­ � w=q�f'r�ÁFx�ÂFratq� i tsxGm�r4¢lg�ts¥N�Fq�f'roqLratsmq�f2xBq�n2tr_iPrat�³m�g� 2r4hv�?�su�m�uvh�xGt�qsg�q�f'r©q�tsxBu�w'u�w'y¡ /xBq�x]uv�³x�hvg�yB§Ohvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g' =�;x�h�p'r��N¢³f'uvhvr�q�f'r{x�w2xBhvg�y�g'p'��qLratsmu�wÀi p �R�4�Àz � uv�ox~�_p2mÒgBi³�LµKp2x�t²r4 =e4g�w'�sq�tLxBu�w�q�ratstg't�a­�Å�f'r¡��p'uvq�x��'uvhvu¤q��gBi�r4uvq�f'ratEiOp2w'e4qsuvg�w�p'hvqsu�moxBqsr4hv� 2ran2raw' 2�©g'w�q�f'r�x�n2n'hvu¤eax�qsuvg�w7­ � gB¢�r4�Grat4�'iPg�tlh�x�w'y�p2xByGr¯m�g' 2r4hvu�w'y�uvq©f2xB�©�2r4raw iIg'p2w' ~q�f2xBq�h¤u�¥Br4hvu�f'g'g� F��g�tq�f'r© 2ratuv�BxBqsuv��rom�raxB��p2t²r{n2ratsn'hvr4�'u¤q���7uv�³xop'�Lr_i p'h�n®rat«iPg�tsmox�w'e4r�m�r4q�tuve�­

� ��qsg¡q�f'r�Ç{x�p'�s�Lu�xGw~n2tuvg�t?m�r4q�f'g' ´p'�sr4 ¦u�w~q_f'r¯ÁFx�ÂFratq��i tLx�m�r4¢lg�ts¥N�'q�f'r¯x�w2x�h¤gGy�g�p'��qsratLm�u�w¡iOp �R�4�z=�$q�f2xBq?iOx���g�t�©m�g�t²r�p2w'u¼iPg�tsmÒm�g' 2r4hv��u¤� �|�ZA ] ����� � �4­�Å�f'r�iPg�tsm�rat�iOp2w'e4qsuvg�w=n®raw2xBhvu��4r4��m�g� 2r4hv��q�f2xBqf2x���r{mox�wG�¡h�xGty�r ` >��BxBh�p'r4�a�N¢³f'uvh¤r]q�f'r{h�xBqLqsrat*i p2w'e4qsuvg�w¦n2raw2xBhvu��4r4�¯m�g� 2r4hv��i x�t�i tg'm p2w'u¼iPg�tsm�­*Ô f'uvhvr�q�f're4g�tst²r4e4q©iOp2w'e4qsuvg�w�qsg´p'�Lr�¢�uvh¤h�xBy'xBu�w= 2ran®raw' Yg�wÀq�f'r�x�n2n'hvu¤eax�qsuvg�w7��¢lr¬xGty�p'r¡q�f2xBq{q_f'roiPg�tsm�ratÕi p2w'e4qLu¤g'wuv�¬yGraw'ratsxBhvhv�Óm�g�t²r~x�n2n2raxBhvu�w'y/­\�/g�t�r4�2x�mon'hvr��?x=m�g' 2r4h³¢�uvq�f!x|�su�w'y�hvr=w'g�w �4ratg ` > n2x�tLx�m�r4qsrat��_f'g�p'hv u�w�q_p'u¤qLu¤�Gr4h¤�$tr4e4r4uv��r´x ��moxBhvh�n2raw2xBhvq����tr4y�xGt 2hvr4�s�ogBi{f'gB¢ iOx�t]iOtg�m p2w'u¼iPg�tsm q�f'uv��m�g' 2r4h�uv�a­�Å�f�p'����¢lrfG�Kn®g�q�f'r4�su��4r{q_f2xBq�q�f'r{Ç]x�p'�s�su�x�w�n2tuvg�t?m�r4q�f'g' �uv�Õn2t²r_iIratsxG�'h¤r]qsg�iOp �R�4��m�xB��u�m�p2m rawGq�tg�nG��­

Å�f'r Ç]x�p'�s�su�x�w$n2tuvg�t�m�r4q�f'g� �xB 2 2��hvu¤qLqshvr=e4g�mon2p'q�x�qsuvg�w!qsg�r4��uv�sqLu�w'y$moxB�'u�m¯p2m rawGq�tg'n���q�tLxBu�w'u�w'yxBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m��a­ d'u�w'e4r¦q�f'r�hvg�y�x�tuvq�f2m°gBi?q�f'r~Ç{x�p'�L�su�x�w�n2tuvg�t�uv�oe4g�w'eax���r��*q�f'r¬g'�� ¹r4e4qLu¤�Gr¡i p2w'e4qsuvg�w�uv�¡�sqsuvhvhe4g�w'eax���r,u�w b x�w' ]u¤q�uv��traxB�sg'w2x��'hv�©raxB�s�©qsglª¿w' ]q�f'r�g'n'qsu�moxBh2m�g� 2r4hP­�Ô=r,eax�w{moxG¥Br�xl�Lu�m�n'h¤r?m�g� 2u¼ª/eaxBqLu¤g'wqsg¦u�m�n2tgB��r4 =uvqsratsxBqLu¤�Gr¬�seax�h¤u�w'y�à � Ä qLg�ª¿w' �q�f'roz �Õ� m�g' 2r4hP­~Å�f'rog�t²u¤yGu�w2x�h±p2n® /xBqsrog�i±rax�e[f ` >�u�w�q�f'uv�xBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m uv�³qsg�q�xG¥Br

` G��FA8PKJ> � ` G��FJ> ��� G�FJ>¢³f'ratr� G��FJ> �_xBqsuv�ª/r4��q�f'r©r4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w

& < [] �CB/�=69>s�ZB/�<K & < A ] ��� � �ZBN�=69>²�CB/�2r4�2n7� � G�FJ> 6��©�ZBN�s� � � ���

x�w' �¢³f'rat²r 6 � �ZBN�<K V > 69>s�ZB/� ­�Ô$uvq�f q�f'r{Ç{x�p'�L�su�x�w�n2tuvg�t4�2r4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w�� � ���,uv�©tran'h�xBe4r4 ~¢�uvq�f& < [] �ZB/�=69>s�ZB/�<K & < A ] ��� � �CB/�=69>s�ZB/�®r4�Kn7� � G��J> 6 � �ZBN�s� � `

G�FJ> ��� G�FJ>� �> S � �a� �

� �³q�f'r�tuvy�fGq§¹f2x�w' ~�Lu¤ 2r�gBi&q�f'uv�?r4µKp2xBqLu¤g'w�uv�©�sq�tuve4qshv�~m�g'w'g�qsg�w'uve{u�w�� G��FJ> �2uvq³uv�{tr4h�xBqsuv��r4hv�¦raxB�s�¡qsg�ª¿w' |uvqs��sg�h�p'qsuvg�w¦p'�su�w'y�x��srax�te4f�xBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m ­&Ô=r© 2ratuv��r]q�f'uv�Õm�g' 2u¼ª/r4 ´p2n® /xBqsr¯tLp'h¤r]u�w�q�f'r{x�n2n®raw' 2uv�¿­

���

Page 14: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

��%&$ ���,= (�. � � +&(�1���45+?6�4�')= 3��,6<; (�1"; � 6�1���= 1835+?6�1"(�>� 45(�- - 6<6�3��"+?1<@� w|d'r4e4qsuvg�w � �7¢lr{hvuv�sqsr4 |iPg�p2t±i xBe4qLg�t�?q�f2xBq?¢�rat²r{iPg�p2w' =�G�~j�f'raw=x�w' =Ç©g'g' /mox�w�qLg¬�suvy�w'u¼ª/eax�wGqshv� x�ÂFr4e4q¶®§Oy�tsx�m¨�_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y~n2rat«iPg�tsmoxGw'e4r�­ � q©uv�{u�wGiPg�tsmoxBqLu¤�Groqsg�xB�s�sr4�s�©q_f'r¬Ç{x�p'�L�su�x�w|n2tuvg�t{m�r4q_f'g� =xBe4e4g�t² 2u�w'yqsgoq_f'r4�sr?iIg'p2tleatuvqsratu�x2­

�&u�t�Lqa�Bq�f'r4�¯n®g�u�w�q,g�p'q�q�f2xBq&q�f'r�m�g' 2u¼ª/r4 ¬hvgB¢lrat«§Og�t 2rat� 2uv�sq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w'�lgBi��©w'r4�srat«§ ��r4�¯�_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y©u¤�,q�f'rn2tu�mox�t²�´traxB�Lg�w¡iPg�t�u¤qL�©��p2n2ratuvg�t²u¤q�=x�m�g'w'y¬e4g�wG��rawGqsuvg�w2xBh&¶®§Oy�tsx�m¨��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y�xBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m��a­ � r4eax�h¤h,q�f2xBqq�f'r4�sr� 2u¤�Lq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w'�¬x�t²roe[f'gG�sraw|qsg���x�qsuv�iI�=moxGty�u�w2xBh�e4g'w'�sq�tsxBu�wGqs�{xB�]y�uv��raw|u�w=r4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w$�Z��� ­ � gB¢lr4��rat4�q�f'uv�©�sr4q?gBi&e4g�w'�sq�tsx�u�wGqs�?uv�oÐF/�Î9O/ÍPÐ ��È - qLgoq�f'r�e4g�tstr4�_n2g�w' 2u�w'y~moxB�'u�m�p2m�rawGq�tg�nG�¡e4g�w'�sq�tsx�u�wGqs��iIg't¯�P¶�T � �«§y�tsxGm��a��x��{y�uv��raw=�G�|r4µKp2x�qsuvg�wÓ� W��4­¬Å�f�p'�a�&mox���u�m�p2mÒrawGq�tg�nG�´¶®§Oy�tLx�m m�g' 2r4hv�of2xa�Gro�su�m�uvh�x�tom�g' 2u¼ª/r4 hvgB¢�rat¹§Og�t 2ratl 2uv�sq�t²u��2p'qLu¤g'w'�{xB�lu�w �©w'r4�srat«§ ��r4�~��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'yN­

� gB¢lr4��rat4�'z �Õ� m�g� 2r4hv�{p2w' 2rat�q�f'r¯Ç]x�p'�s�su�x�w�n2t²u¤g't³w'g¡hvg�w'y�ratl��x�qsuv�iI��q_f'r©z �!e4g�w'�Lq�tsxBu�wGqs��r4�2xBe4qshv��­� w'�LqsraxB F�2q�f'r]e4g�w'�sq�tLxBu�w�qs�lq�f2x�q³x�tr©��x�qsuv�ª/r4 ~f2x���r©q�f'r?iPg�tsm

& < [] �ZB/�m6j>s�ZBN��T ` >� �> K & < A ] �ZB/�=69>s�ZB/� S � � ���

Å�f2xBq?uv�a�7q�f'r]ramon'u�tuveaxBh&r4�Kn®r4e4q�xBqsuvg�w'� V < [] �ZB/�m6 > �ZBN�³x�t²r¯w'gB¢��L 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qLr4 � ��G�~q�f'r�x�m�g�p2wGq ` >�� � �> ­�� � wz=�Y¶®§Oy�tsxGm�m�g' 2r4h¤���¿m�gG�sq ` >kxGtr{n2g��Lu¤qLu¤�Gr�­ ���©p2x�h¤uvq�x�qsuv��r4hv���7q�f'uv�³uv�?r4��raw~m�g'tr© 2r4�su�tsx��'hvr�q�f2x�w�m�r4r4qLu�w'yq�f'r¦q�x�ty�r4qL�or4�Kx�e4qshv����xB�¬ram�n'u�t²u¤eax�h?i tr4µ2p'raw'e4uvr4��qsraw' YqLg �®r´f'uvy�f'rat¡q�f2x�w»q�tsp'r i tr4µ2p'raw'e4uvr4�¡iIg't�r4��rawGqs�¢�uvq�f=w'g'w �4ratg~e4g�p2wGqs�a­ � w2xBhvg�y�g'p'�¯�2raf2x��'uvg�t©uv�¯n2t²g� /p'e4r4 �¢�uvq�f �©w'r4�srat¹§ ��r4�=�_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y~¢³f'raw=xGn2n'h¤uvr4 tr4eap2t�Lu¤�Gr4h¤��qsg{hvgB¢lrat«§Og�t 2rat* 2u¤�Lq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w'�a­ � woq_f'u¤�leaxB�Lr���q�x�t²y�r4q&e4g�p2wGqs��x�t²r� 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsr4 ¬q_f2tg�p'y�foxG�'�sg�h�p'qsr 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsu�w'y/­ �  2ratuv�BxBqsuvg�w¦gBi&r4µKp2xBqLu¤g'w=� � ���,uv�³yGu¤�Graw�u�w�q�f'r{xGn2n2raw' 2uv�¿­

d'r4e4g'w' F�/j�f'raw~xGw' ~Ç©g'g� /moxGw�n2g�u�wGq�g�p'q�q�f2x�q±xG�'�sg�h�p'qsr© 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsu�w'y�uv����p2n2rat²u¤g't�qsg�q�f'r©gGq�f'ratlq�Kn®r4�gBil 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qLu�w'y|e4g�w'�Lu¤ 2rat²r4 F�kxGw' =q�f2xBq{p'�su�w'y|x¡ 2u ÂFratrawGq{ 2uv�se4g'p2w�qEiIg�t?g'w'r_§Oe4g�p2w�qL�¯x�w' =q¢lgB§Oe4g�p2wGqs�©x�w' x��¿x�q¯ 2uv�se4g'p2w�q�q�f'ratrax;iIqsrat]xB��u�w�m�g� 2u¼ª/r4  �©w'r4�srat¹§ ��r4����m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y´n®rat«iPg�tsm���r4��raw��2r4qsqLrat4­~Ô$uvq�fÀq�f'rÇ{xGp'�s�su�x�w�n2tuvg�t4�&q�f'r¡ 2uv�se4g�p2wGq�iPg�t{x�w�¶®§Oy�tsx�m u¤��h¤u�w'rax�t�u�w ` �ox��{eax�w��®r¬�sr4rawÀiOtg�m r4µKp2x�qsuvg�w½� � ��� ­� �¯q_f'r�n2tg'�2x��'uvh¤uvq��xB�s�suvy�w'r4 �qsg |�G�bA ] y�tgB¢��]r4�Kn®g�w'rawGqsu�xBhvh¤��u�w ` � � ` � y'tgB¢��©hvg�y�x�tuvq�f2m�u¤eax�h¤hv�YxB��xiOp2w'e4qsuvg�w|gBilq�f'roq�x�t²y�r4qÕn2t²g��2x��'uvhvu¤q�=g't�e4g�p2wGqa­ � w|g�q�f'rat?¢lg�t 2���Ftg�p'y�f'hv�~�_n2rax�¥Gu�w'y´q_f'r�Ç]x�p'�s�su�x�wÀn2tuvg�tm�r4q�f'g' ~q_tsx�w'�sh�xBqsr4��qsg - Ëm�È�Ï_ÐÑÍ����¯Ð �] 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qLu�w'yN­³Å�f'uv�©uv�Õx�µ2p2xBhvu¤q_xBqsuv��r4hv�´x�n2n®raxBhvu�w'y~m�g� 2r4h�gBi�q�f'r]uv 2raxBhx���ratsxByGr³ 2uv�se4g�p2wGq? 2u¤�_n'h�x���r4 ¦u�w#�&uvy�p2tr � x�w' �uv�Õm�g�tr?r4h¤r4y'x�w�q?q�f2x�w�p'�Lu�w'y�m�p'hvqsu�n'h¤r�¿xBq� 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qL�a­

Å�f'u�t² F��j�f'raw|x�w'  ÇEg�g' /mox�w|tran®g�tq©q�f2x�q³u�wGqsratsn2gGh�x�qsr4  m�g' 2r4hv�¯g'p'q�n2rat«iPg�tsm¨�2xBe4¥Br4 '§OgBÂYm�g' 2r4h¤�]g�w¶®§Oy�tsx�m���¢�uvq�f�hvgB¢�e4g�p2w�qL�a�/xB��hvgB¢lrat«§Og�t 2rat?m�g' 2r4hv�Õn2tgB�'uv 2r{�;x�h�p2xG�'h¤r�u�wGiPg�tsm�xBqsuvg�w¡iPg�tlr4�Lqsu�moxBqsu�w'y¡q�f'r4�srn2tg��2xG�'u¤hvuvqsuvr4�a­ � xGn2n'u¤hv���'q�f'r³Ç]x�p'�s�su�x�w�n2tuvg�t,�2raf2x���r4�&hvu�¥Br©x�w]u�wGqsratsn®g�h�xBqsr4 �m�g' 2r4h/xB��¶®§Oy�tsx�m�n2tg'�2x��'uvh¤uvq�r4�sqsu�mox�qsr4�³ 2ran®raw' =g�w h¤gB¢lrat«§Og�t² 2rat�u�wGiPg�tsmoxBqLu¤g'w7­�Å�f'uv�?iIg�hvhvgB¢��?q�tuv��u�xBhvhv�¦i t²g�m�q_f'r{g��'�srat²�;xBqsuvg�w q�f2xBq?q�f'rn2tg��2xG�'u¤hvuvq� A ] xB�s�Lu¤y'w'��qsg¬x�w�¶®§Oy�tLx�m � 2ran®raw' 2�©g�w�q�f'r{n2xGtsx�m�r4qsrat±�;xBh�p'r4� ` ��� iIg't�xBhvh�¶®§Oy�tsx�m�� � q�f2xBqx�trl��pGÆ¡��r4�&gBi '­ � gB¢lr4��rat4��q�f'r�Ç{x�p'�s�Lu�xGw¯n2t²u¤g't&m�r4q�f'g' ¬p'�sr4�&q�f'rlu�wGiIg'tsmoxBqsuvg�wEiOtg�m�hvgB¢lrat«§Og�t 2rat�m�g' 2r4h¤�u�w x|m�raxGw'u�w'y�i p'hl¢�x���­ �Ng�t{xGw��=¶®§Oy�tsx�m '�&q�f'r�Ç{x�p'�s�Lu�xGw=n2tuvg�t�m�r4q�f'g'  qLraw' 2�¯qLg´xB � sp'�sq ` ��qLg;¢�x�t² 2��4ratg ��¢³f'raw ` �]uv��4ratg/��q�f'roe4g�tLtr4��n2g'w' 2u�w'y iIrax�q�p2tr¬f2xB�{w'g¦r_ÂFr4e4q©g�w¦q�f'r¬m�g' 2r4hP�kxGw' =q�f'r�hvg;¢lrat«§Og't 2rat¶®§Oy�tsx�m�n2t²g��2x��'uvhvu¤q�¡r4�sqsu�moxBqLr�uv��p'�sr4 F­ � w�g�q�f'rat�¢lg�t² 2�a��q�f'r�n2tuvg�tlxB � sp'�sqs��¶®§Oy�tLx�m�n2tg��2x��'uvhvuvqsuvr4�³qLg;¢�x�t² 2�q�f'r©hvgB¢lrat«§Og�t 2rat�n2t²g��2x��'uvhvu¤q��r4�sqLu�m�xBqsr��/xB��u¤�? 2r4�su�tsx��'hvr�­

�&u�w2xBhvhv����j�f'raw½x�w'  ÇEg�g' /mox�w w'g�qsr|q�f2xBq~xB 2 2uvqsuvg�w2x�h¯q_p2w2x��'hvr n2x�tsx�m�r4qsrat��eax�w$u�mon2t²g;�Gr=eap2tstrawGq��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y�m�r4q�f'g' 2�a­ �/g't�q�f'r´Ç]x�p'�s�su�x�w!n2tuvg�t4�lq�f'r|w2xBq�p2tsx�h�iOtr4r|n2x�tsx�m�r4qLrat�¬x�tr¦q�f'r~�Bx�tu�x�w'e4r4� � >­

� � eDvgwmu vgkmujp�ilw�f�p�w���wm{7f�f�q-wmu h9i�q-k=iDkmu���h%w=ilwY�[egp�elilfGt q-p�dIhjileg�Yq-k={%fDt+kmi��/qxu���� ymilw�� f���k�kYp�djqxu%yIt+d7eoile�hji�q-kmilf�d7w=�Ye~�egelu2w=h9hjrxq-egs s;qxile}vgp�r-� qxu h9ilk=~%w=~9qxrxq-p �2f�h%w�vgeY�D�IwYv �Gwm�Iw=u%s�!�egp�k#"%$'&)(�{7f�e[w+*�qxi�q-v djr-egpGh9i�q-k=i[w=u%s-,.w�s9w�f/" 021)(�{7f�egfGw+3+e}p�whji�q-kmi=�%~�k�p�d�ilegf�{jr-p�qxu%y�qxu/rxqxu%e}wmiDs�q-f�vgkm{jujp�qxu%yIt+djq-v dId7wYf+~�e}eou f�d%k=t+u p�kGh�eoi�z_k=il� f�{j~�kmh7p�q-�[w=rxr-�Y��a�

Page 15: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

� w¡q_f'r{�2xB�suve{��rat²�suvg�wog�ikq�f'r{Ç]x�p'�s�su�x�w¡n2tuvg�t�m�r4q�f'g� �q_f2xBql¢�r©u�mon'hvram�rawGqsr4 F�N¢lrÕf2xB ~¶ iOtr4r{n2x�tsxGm�r4qsrat�� �]� � K � QUSTSTS Q�¶��a¢?f'ratr³xBhvh ��§Oy�tsxGm���g�i/q�f'rl��x�m�rlhvraw'y�q�f�¢lratrle4g�w'�Lq�tsxBu�w'r4 �qsg{f2x���r�q_f'r��_x�m�rl�;x�t²u�xGw'e4r� �� ­� �©q�f'r¬Ç]x�p'�s�su�x�wÀn2tuvg�t{m�r4q_f'g� =�_xBqsuv�ª/r4�¯x�h¤h,gBi�q_f'ro 2r4�suv 2ratsxBq�x hvu¤�Lqsr4  �G�=j�f'raw=x�w' �Ç©g'g� /moxGw7�Fuvq

mox��~n2rat¹iIg�tLm�e4g�m�n2r4qsuvqsuv��r4hv�|u�w´¶®§Oy�tLx�m��_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y/­³Å�f'r�r4�2n2ratu�m�rawGqs�©u�w|d'r4e4qsuvg�w��o�_f'g;¢�q�f2xBq?q�f'uv�?u¤�u�w' 2r4r4 |q�f'r©eaxB�sr�­

� � ��� %<��� � % ���=+Å�g{e4g�mon2xGtr³q_f'r³n2rat«iPg�tsm�x�w'e4r³g�i�m�xB��u�m�p2m·raw�q_tg�nG��xGw' oe4g�wG��raw�qLu¤g'w2xBh¿¶®§Oy�tsxGm���m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y�qsr4e4f2w'uvµKp'r4�a�¢lr�tsx�w]r4�Kn®ratu�m�rawGqs��gB��rat&moxGw��©q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y]�sr4q&�su��4r4��p'�su�w'y{�sr4�GratsxBh' 2u ÂFratrawGq&qsr4�'q&e4g�tsn®g�tsx�iPg�t&�2g�q_f¯�'uvy�tLx�mx�w' �q�t²u¤y'tsx�m�m�g' 2r4hv�a­

�<%&$ ')= 3��,6<;,68>?6�@�9¾�i�q�f'r©e4g�wG��rawGqsuvg�w2xBh�¶®§Oy�tLx�m ��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'yoqLr4e[f2w'uvµ2p'r4�a�7¢lr©u�m�n'h¤ram�raw�qsr4  �©xBq �©��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y~à � � Ä �'¢³f'uve[f u¤�n2ratLf2x�n'��q�f'r�m�g��sq¯n®g�n2p'h�x�toxBhvy�g'tuvq�f2m°u�w�n2tLxBe4qsuve4r���x�w' �m�g' 2u ª/r4  �©w'r4�Lrat«§ ��r4����m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y�Ã�� Ä ��¢³f'uve4ff2xB�©�2r4raw¦��f'gB¢³w qsg¬g'p'q�n2rat«iPg�tsm xBhvh�g�q_f'rat�¢�uv 2r4hv�G§¹p'�sr4 =qsr4e4f2w'uvµKp'r4�a­ � w´x� 2 2u¤qLu¤g'w7�7¢�r]u�mon'hvram�raw�qLr4 =q�f'r�;xGtu�xBqsuvg�w¡gBi � r4h¤u�w'ra¥�§Oz|rate4rat?��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'yoy�uv��raw��G�or4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w=� �'��¢?f'ratr³u�w'�sqLraxB ~gBi&x{�Lu�w'yGh¤r ` n2x�tLx�m�r4qsratx¡ 2u¼ÂFratraw�q ` ��uv�{p'�sr4 |iPg�t�raxBe4f|hvr4��r4h&gBi�q_f'r�¶®§Oy�tLx�m"m�g� 2r4hP­oÅ�f'uv�{m�r4q�f'g' = 2g'r4�{w'g�q{n2rat¹iIg�tLmÒn2x�tqsuve_§p'h�x�thv�=¢lr4hvhP���2p'q{uv�op'�sr4 �xB�¯x¦�2xB�sr4hvu�w'r~xBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m iIg�t?r4�2n2gG�suvqsg�t� n2p2tLn2g��sr4��­¬ÔÀr�tr_iPrat©qLg�q�f'r4�sr¡q�f2tr4ru�mon'hvram�rawGq�xBqsuvg�w'�?¢�uvq�f�q_f'r{mow'ram�g�w'uve4��������7���� �����������������������N��x�w' ������������� �2�2tr4��n®r4e4qsuv��r4hv��­

ÔÀr{xBhv�sg¬u�mon'hvram�rawGqsr4 |�sr4��ratLxBhFmoxB�'u�m�p2m raw�q_tg�nG�¬��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y�qsr4e[f2w'uvµ2p'r4�a­ �/g'tlraxBe4f�qsr4e4f2w'uvµKp'r��7xBhvh` �©n2x�tsx�m�r4qsrat�©x�tr{u�w'uvqsu�xBhvu��4r4 �qsg �4ratg�xGw' ´u�mon2t²g;�Gr4 ~uvqsratsxBqLu¤�Gr¯�LeaxBhvu�w'y�uv�{x�n2n'hvuvr4 �qsgoq�tsx�u�w¦q�f'r�m�g' 2r4hI­� qLratsxBqsuv��r,�seaxBhvu�w'y©u¤�&qLratsm�u�w2xBqsr4 �¢³f'rawEq�f'r�n2ratsn'hvr4�'u¤q�]gBi¿x³f'r4hv '§Og�p'q&�Lr4qkw'g?hvg�w'y�rat� 2r4eatraxB�Lr4�&�suvy�w'u¼ª/eax�w�qLh¤��­jlh�p'�sqsrat�r4�2n2x�w'�suvg�w�à �2�LÄ uv�?ramon'hvg;�Gr4 ~qsg¬t²r4 /p'e4r¯e4g'mon2p'q�xBqsuvg�w7­ � w q�f'r{u�mon'hvram�rawGq�xBqLu¤g'w! �"��������#�����$��%F�w'g¡��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y�uv�{n2rat«iPg�tsm�r4 F­o�Pd'u�w'e4r�q�tsx�u�w'u�w'y�uv�©qsratsm�u�w2x�qsr4 |¢³f'raw|n2rat«iPg�tsmoxGw'e4r¯g'w~x¡f'r4h¤ '§Og'p'q{�sr4q©w'ghvg�w'y�ratEu�m�n2tgB��r4�a��w'g|n2tg��2x��'uvhvuvqsuvr4�o¢�uvhvh�e4g�wG��ratyGr¯qLg#�4ratg´xB�©u�wÀq�f'roeaxB�Lr¯¢?f'ratroq�tsx�u�w'u�w'y|uv�{e4g�wGqsu�w'p'r4 qsg¡e4g�wG��raty�raw'e4r�­ ��Å�f'roxBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m& "��'���($�$�����¡uv�¯x�w¦u�mon'hvram�rawGq�xBqsuvg�w|g�i±Ç©g'g' '§¹Å�p2tu�w'y¦ 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qLu�w'yxB�? 2r4�seatu��2r4 Àu�w|d'r4e4qsuvg�w �/­ � ­³Å�f'r�xBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m) �"���*���+���ouv�©x�w¦u�m�n'h¤ram�raw�q�x�qsuvg�w¦gBi�ÁFx�ÂFratq�� �³Ç{xGp'�s�su�x�wn2tuvg�t©m�r4q_f'g� =xB�? 2r4�seatu��2r4 Àu�wÀd'r4e4qsuvg�w � ­ � �©m�rawGqsuvg�w'r4 =rax�thvuvrat4�7q�f'uv�{m�r4q_f'g� =f2xB�©¶|iOtr4ron2x�tsxGm�r4qsrat�� �]�2g�w'r?iPg�tlraxBe4f¡hvr4��r4h�g�ikq�f'r{¶®§Oy�tLx�m�m�g' 2r4hP­

ÔÀrÕp'�sr4 � /x�q�xEi tg'm�iPg�p2t,�sg�p2te4r4�j:*q�f'rÕ¸ltgB¢³w�e4g�tsn2p'����¢?f'u¤e4f�e4g'w�q�x�u�w'�lqsr4�'q,i t²g�m x¯w'p2m��2rat,gBikm�u¤�²§e4r4hvh�x�w'r4g�p'�©�sg�p2t²e4r4�{à ��� Ä �'Ô xBhvh�d'q_tr4r4q � g�p2tLw2xBh��9Ô½d � ��w'r4¢���n2xGn2ratlqsr4�'q{à �G�4Ä ��q_f'r{¸�t²g�xB 2eaxB�sq ��r4¢��¯�P¸ �?�e4g�tsn2p'����¢?f'u¤e4f¡e4g�wGq�xBu�w'�lq�tsx�w'�Leatu�n'qsuvg�w'�lgBi�qsr4hvr4�'u¤�Lu¤g'w~x�w' �tsxB 2uvgow'r4¢��l��f'gB¢��©Ã � � Ä �'x�w' �q�f'r©d'¢�uvqse[f'�2g'x�t �Pd'Ô½¸l�le4g�tsn2p'���/¢³f'uve4f¦e4g�w�q_xBu�w'�³q�tLx�w'�seatu�n'qsuvg�w'�?gBi�qsr4hvran2f'g�w'r�e4g�wG��rat��x�qsuvg�w'�{à ��� Ä ­ � w�raxBe4f�r4�2n2rat²u�m�raw�qa�¢lr{�sr4hvr4e4qsr4 =x�q�tsxBu�w'u�w'y��sr4q�g�i�xoy�uv��raw hvraw'y�q�f i t²g�m�g'w'r{�sg�p2t²e4r��¿x�w' ¦q¢�g¡f'r4h¤ '§Og'p'q©�sr4qs��i tg'm q�f'r{�_x�m�r�sg�p2t²e4r�­¯Å�f'r]ª¿t�Lq{f'r4h¤ '§Og'p'q{�sr4q©¢�xB�©p'�sr4 =qsg¡g�n'qsu�m�u��4r¡q�f'ron2x�tsx�m�r4qsrat�?gBi�raxBe4f¦��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y~xBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m��Î7$ $ �2q�f'r � � n2x�tLx�m�r4qsrat��gBi, �"�$*��+����¯g�t�q�f'r] 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qL� � � g�i�m�g� 2u¼ª/r4  �©w'r4�srat«§ ��r4�~�_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y/­ � x�§tsx�m�r4qsrat�&¢lratrl�sr4hvr4e4qsr4 ¡qsgÕm�u�w'u�m�u��4r©q�f'r?n2ratsn'hvr4�'u¤q�og�i¿q�f'r�f'r4hv '§Og�p'ql�sr4q � � gB¢lr4hvh ���srax�t²e[f�xBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m à � � Ä¢�xB��p'�sr4 �qsgon2rat¹iIg�tLm q�f'uv���srax�t²e[f7­&Å�f'uv�³f'r4hv '§Og�p'q?�sr4q�¢�xB�lxBhv�sg¬p'�sr4 �qsg� 2r4e4uv 2r�¢³f'raw¡qsg�qsratsm�u�w2x�qsr©uvqsrat«§xBqsuv��r?�seaxBhvu�w'y�iIg�t,q�f'r?z=��m�g' 2r4h¤��­�Å�f'r©�Lr4e4g�w' ~f'r4hv '§Og�p'q��sr4q�¢�xB�lp'�sr4 �qsg�r4�;x�h�p2x�qsr©q�f'r?ª¿w2xBhFn2ratLn'h¤r4�'uvq�gBi&raxBe4f¡��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y¬xBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m�­

�Ng�tlraxBe4f¦ /xBq�x��sg�p2te4r��N¢lr¯tsxGw�r4�2n2ratu�m�rawGqs�¯p'�Lu�w'y�q_tsxBu�w'u�w'y��sr4qs��i tg'm � � �o�srawGqsraw'e4r4�o�Px��®g�p'q � �-�����¢lg�t 2����qsg~x�t²g�p2w'  � ���2�-� �����srawGqsraw'e4r4��� x��2g�p'q � m�uvhvhvu¤g'w�¢�g't 2���4­ � r4h¤ '§Og'p'q{�sr4qs�©¢lratr � � � �����sraw�qLraw'e4r4�a­

�a�

Page 16: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

7

8

9

10

11

100 1000 10000 100000cr

oss-

entr

opy

of te

st d

ata

(bits

/toke

n)training set size (sentences)

Brown 2-,3-gram

SWB 2-gram

SWB 3-gram

WSJ 2-gram

WSJ 3-gram

�&uvy�p2tr � :&j�tg��L�§Oraw�q_tg�nG�{gBi��2xB�sr4hvu�w'r{�_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y¯xBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m g'woqsr4�Lq��sr4q,g;�Grat�m�p'hvqsu�n'h¤r©q_tsxBu�w'u�w'yo�sr4q��Lu �4r4�g�w�¸ltgB¢³w7�2d'¢�uvqse4f��®g�x�t F�7x�w' �Ô x�h¤h�d'q�tr4r4q � g'p2tsw2xBhFe4g�tLn2g�tsx

Ô½f'uvh¤r�q�tsx�u�w'u�w'y!�sr4qs��iPg�t¡h�x�w'y�p2x�y�r m�g' 2r4hv�´mox��Ót²raxBe[f$f'p2w' /tr4 2�|gBi�m�u¤hvhvuvg�w'�=gBi�¢lg�t 2��u�w n2tLxBe4qsuve4r��¢lr~¢lratr=p2w2x��'hvr=qsg�e4g�w'�suv 2rat h�xGty�rat�q�tsxBu�w'u�w'y��sr4qs��q�f2xGw�¢lr| 2u¤   /p'r´qLg e4g�m�n2p'q�xBqsuvg�w2xBh?hvu�m�uvq�xBqsuvg�w'�a­Å�tsxBu�w'u�w'y~moxB�'u�m�p2m¨rawGq�tg�nG�~¶®§Oy�tsx�m m�g� 2r4hv��tr4µKp'u�tr4�{x�y�trax�q� 2raxBh�m�g�t²r{e4g�mon2p'q_xBqsuvg�w�q_f2x�w�q�tLxBu�w'u�w'ye4g�wG��rawGqsuvg�w2xBh³¶®§Oy�tsxGmºm�g' 2r4hv�a­ � w!xB 2 2uvqsuvg�w7��¢?f'rawYe4g'w'�suv 2ratu�w'yYm¯p'hvqsu�n'hvr=n2x�tsx�m�r4qsrat��sr4qsqLu�w'yG�¬u�w!q�f'r� gB¢lr4h¤h��srax�te4f½�PxB��iPg�t]q�f'r � �Òn2x�tsx�m�r4qLrat��u�w "��*���+ �����4�&q�f'r¦u¤qLratsxBqsuv��r��seax�h¤u�w'yYxBhvy�g'tuvq�f2m m�p'�sq¬�®rx�n2n'hvuvr4 |�sran2x�tsxBqLr4h¤��iPg�t,raxBe[f�n2xGtsx�m�r4qsrat,�sr4qLqsu�w'y/­�Å�goq�tsxBu�w�x]�su�w'y�hvr¯m�g� 2r4h�p'�Lu�w'y�m�r4q�f'g' � �"���*���+���©iPg�tx � m�uvhvh¤uvg�w ¢�g't ~q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y¡�sr4q©tr4µ2p'u�t²r4  xGtg�p2w' ~�Lu¤�~f'g'p2t�³g�i�e4g�mon2p'q�xBqLu¤g'w¡g�w~x��N����z � � � rawGqsu�p2m ��e4g�mon2p'qLrat4­�d2p2�'�sq�xGw�qsu�xBhvhv��h�x�ty�rat±q�tsxBu�w'u�w'y¬�Lr4qs�³x�tr?iPraxB�su��'hvr�u¼i*n2x�tLx�m�r4qsratlg'n'qsu�m�u��axBqsuvg�w�uv�©w'g�q�p'�sr4 F­

¾©p2t� /x�q�x��Lr4qs�kxGtrlu¤ 2rawGqsuveaxBh2qsg?q�f'g��Lr±p'�Lr4 ��G�¯j�f'raw¯xGw' �ÇEg�g' /mox�w¡Ã�� Ä x�w' �e4g�w'�sr4µ2p'raw�qLh¤��g�p2t&t²r4��p'hvqs�x�tr� 2u�tr4e4qshv�|e4g�mon2xGtsx��'hvroqsg¡q�f'r¬x�w2x�h¤gGy�g�p'�{tr4��p'hvqs�{n2t²r4�sraw�qLr4  ���|j�f'raw=x�w' =ÇEg�g' /mox�w7­©z|g�t²r¯ 2r4q_xBuvh¤�gBi&g�p2t�m�r4q_f'g� 2g�hvg�yG�¬eax�w��®r©iPg�p2w' ~u�w q�f2xBql¢lg�ts¥N­

�<%�� � =�� .">Z3 �� w �&uvy�p2tr � �2¢lr© 2u¤�_n'h�x���q�f'r]eatg��s�²§Oraw�q�t²g�n���gBikq_f'r¯�2xB�sr4hvu�w'r � r4hvu�w'ra¥B§Oz|rate4ratE��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y¬xBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m�gB��ratx{tLx�w'y�r�gBi7q�tsxBu�w'u�w'y��sr4q��Lu �4r4�lg�w��sr4��ratsxBhNe4g�tsn®g�tsx2­ � w�q�f'r³y'tsx�n2f'�&qsgEiIg�hvhvgB¢{��¢lr� 2uv��n'h�x��¡q�f'r³n2rat¹iIg�tLmox�w'e4rgBi�raxBe4f x�h¤yGg�tuvq�f2m xB��q�f'r¡ 2u ÂFratraw'e4r�g�i±uvqs��eatgG�s�§OrawGq�tg�nG�|g�w=q_f'r¬qsr4�Lq{�sr4qEi tg'm q_f'roeatg��s�²§Oraw�q�t²g�n��|gBiq�f'r��2xB�sr4hvu�w'r´m�r4q_f'g� ½�Pp'�su�w'y|q�f'r¡��x�m�roq_tsxBu�w'u�w'y=�sr4q��4��qsg i x�e4u¤hvuvq�xBqLr���uv��p2xBhvu��axBqsuvg�w7­=�,xBe4f n®g�u�w�q�u�w�q�f'ry�tsxGn2f'�±n2t²r4�sraw�qLr4 ~f'ratrÕt²ran2tr4�srawGqs��x{�Lu�w'yGh¤r]r4�Kn®ratu�m�rawGq �'iPg�t�x�w�xGw2xBhv���suv��g�i q_f'r©�sq�x�w' /x�t² oratstg�t,gBi�q�f'r4�srg��'�srat²�;xBqsuvg�w'��tr_iPrat,qsgoj�f'raw�x�w' �Ç©g'g� /m�x�w~à � Ä ­kÅ�g�y�uv��r{x�tg�p'y�f�uv 2rax]gBi�q�f'r?�sq�xBqLu¤�LqsuveaxBh7ratstg�t*u�wG��g�hv��r4 F�u�w#�&uvy�p2tr4�a�¬x�w'  � �'q�f'r{ 2u¼ÂFratraw'e4r��2r4q¢lr4raw���� ����$������� ��������ox�w' � �"���*��+���omox��¬w'g�q?�2r{�Lu¤y'w'u ª/eaxGw�qa�¢³f'uvhvr�q�f'rl 2u¼ÂFratraw'e4r³�2r4q¢lr4raw�q�f'r4�Lr�q¢lg³xBhvy�g'tuvq�f2m���x�w' oxBhvh2gBi/q�f'rlg�q_f'rat��xBh�m�g��sq�e4ratq�x�u�w'hv��uv��iIg't�xBh�m�gG�sqr4��rat�¡ /xBq�x�n2g�u�wGqa­

� wJ�&uvy�p2tr � �B¢lr&e4g�mon2x�t²r�q�f'rln2rat«iPg�tsmoxGw'e4r�gBi/q�f'r,�;x�t²u¤g'p'��moxB�'u�m�p2m raw�q_tg�nG�³��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y©xBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m��gB��rat�m�p'hvqsu�n'hvr©q�tsxBu�w'u�w'y��sr4q��Lu �4r4�?p'�su�w'y¯Ô�xBhvh¿d'q�tr4r4q � g�p2tsw2x�h¿ /x�q�x2­�Å�f'r³hvr_iPq�y'tsx�n2f�uv�,iIg't��'uvy�tsx�m·m�g' 2r4h¤�x�w' oq_f'rÕtuvy�fGq&y�tsxGn2f�uv��iPg�t�q�t²u¤y'tsx�m m�g� 2r4hv�a­&ÔÀr��sr4r�q�f2x�q �"���������� �������%{u¤�lg�p'q_n2rat«iPg�tsm�r4 ¡����q�f'r�gGq�f'ratxBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m����G�YxÀh�xGty�r´m�x�ty�u�w7�l 2ram�g�w'�Lq�tsxBqsu�w'y�q�f'r´w'r4e4r4�L�suvq¹�!gBi©��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y=iPg�t¡moxB�'u�m¯p2mÉrawGq�tg�nG�m�g' 2r4hv�a­�¾�iFq�f'r³tram�xBu�w'u�w'yoxBhvy�g'tuvq�f2m��a�Gq�f'r³Ç{xGp'�s�su�x�won2tuvg�t,m�r4q�f'g' o�suvy�w'u¼ª/eax�wGqshv�og�p'q�n®rat«iPg�tsm�r4 ¬ÇEg�g' '§Å�p2tu�w'y� 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qLu�w'yN­ÕÅ�f'g�p'y�f~w'gGq³��f'gB¢³w¦f'ratr��N¢�r]�sr4r��su�m�uvh�x�t©�2raf2x��'u¤g't?u�w¦r4�2n2ratu�m�rawGqs�©g�w q�f'r{gGq�f'rat

� �

Page 17: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

-0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

100 1000 10000 100000

diff

in te

st c

ross

-ent

ropy

fro

m b

asel

ine

(bits

/toke

n)

training set size (sentences)

relative performance of algorithms on WSJ corpus, 2-gram

baseline

ME-gauss

ME-disc-katz

ME-no-smooth

-0.4

-0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

100 1000 10000 100000

diff

in te

st c

ross

-ent

ropy

fro

m b

asel

ine

(bits

/toke

n)

training set size (sentences)

relative performance of algorithms on WSJ corpus, 3-gram

baseline

ME-gauss

ME-disc-katz

ME-no-smooth

�&uvy�p2tr � : � rat«iPg�tsmox�w'e4r?tr4h�xBqsuv��r©qsg��2xB�sr4hvu�w'r©gBi��;xGtuvg�p'��moxB�'u�m�p2m·rawGq�tg�nG����m�g'g�q�f'u�w'yoxBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m��lgB��ratm�p'hvqsu�n'h¤r�q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y¡�sr4q��Lu �4r4�?g�w¡q�f'r©Ô�xBhvh�d'q�tr4r4q � g�p2tsw2xBhFe4g'tsn2p'�a�/�'uvy�tsxGm�x�w' ~q_tuvy�tsx�m m�g' 2r4hv�

q�f2tr4r©e4g'tsn2g�tLx2­��� wJ�&uvy�p2tr4�8�³x�w'  � �4¢lr&e4g�mon2x�tr&q_f'r�n2rat¹iIg�tLmox�w'e4r&gBi/moxB�'u�m¯p2m raw�q�t²g�n��?��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y³x�h¤yGg�tuvq�f2m���¢�uvq�f

e4g�wG��rawGqsuvg�w2xBh&¶2§Oy'tsx�m¨��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y~xBhvy�g'tuvq�f2m��©gB��rat��sr4��ratsxBh�e4g�tsn®g�tsx2­�� ¾�ilq�f'roe4g�wG��rawGqsuvg�w2xBh���m�g'g�q�f'u�w'ym�r4q�f'g' 2�a�B¢lrl�sr4rlq�f2xBq �©xBq ���_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y©y�raw'ratsxBhvhv��g�p'q�n2rat¹iIg�tLm���q_f'r±�2x��sr4hvu�w'r©x�w' �q�f2xBq�m�g� 2u¼ª/r4  �©w'r4�srat¹§��r4�©��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y�uv���Lu¤y'w'u ª/eaxGw�qshv���2r4qsqsrat ­�¾�i/q�f'rlmoxB�'u�m�p2m$rawGq�tg'n��©m�r4q�f'g' 2�a��¢�r&�Lr4r�q�f2xBq "��'���($�$�����n2rat¹iIg�tLm���e4g�mon2x�tLx��'hv�ÓqLg �©xBq��=��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y�iPg�t¦�'u¤y'tsx�m m�g' 2r4hv�a�{x�w' ½�Lg�m�r4¢³f2xBq�¢lg�t²�sr¦iIg�t¡q_tuvy�tsx�mm�g' 2r4hv�a�Fq�f'g'p'y�f�uvq© 2g'r4�{�2r4qsqsrat?g'w~h�x�t²y�rat� /x�q�x¡�sr4qs�a­©Å�f'rom�r4q_f'g�  �"���*���+���¬n®rat«iIg'tsm��©x��2g�p'q{x��³¢lr4hvhxB��m�g' 2u¼ª/r4  �©w'r4�Lrat«§ ��r4���_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y/�2x�w' �uv�³�shvuvy�fGqshv�~�2r4qsqLratlgB��ratlm�g��sql /xBq�x]�sr4qL�a­&Å�f�p'���2q�f'r{Ç{xGp'�s�su�x�wn2tuvg�t�m�r4q�f'g' �n2rat«iPg�tsm��oxB��¢lr4hvh�xB�{g�t��®r4qsqsrat]q�f2x�w�xBhvhlg�q�f'rat©¢�u¤ 2r4hv�G§¹p'�sr4 ½xBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m��{iPg�tE��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y¶®§Oy�tsx�m m�g� 2r4hv�a­

Å�g�u�w���r4�Lqsuvy�xBqsr�f'g;¢$q�f'r©hvg�y'x�tuvq�f2m�uve{ 2uv�se4g'p2w�qsu�w'y�gBi�q�f'r{Ç{x�p'�L�su�x�w�n2tuvg�t�e4g�mon2x�tr4��qsg�q�f'r{m�p'h¤qLu�n'hvrx��'�sgGh�p'qLr� 2uv�se4g�p2wGqs��gBiFm�g' 2u ª/r4  �©w'r4�srat«§ ��r4�o��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'yN�B¢�r�e4g�mon2p'qsr4 ¬f'gB¢�e4hvg��sr4hv��q�f'r�r4�2n2r4e4qLr4 �w'p2m]§�2rat?g�i�e4ratq�xBu�w|¶®§Oy�tsx�m��?u�w=x�qsr4�sq?�sr4qÕx�e4e4g�t 2u�w'y�qsg¡raxBe[f|m�g' 2r4h&moxBqse4f'r4 |q�f'r¯xBe4q_p2xBhkw'p2m��2rat?gBi�q_f'g��sr¶®§Oy�tsx�m���u�w q�f'r©qsr4�sql�sr4qa­ � w~n2x�tqLu¤eap'h�x�t �'iIg't�x�h¤hF¶®§Oy�tsxGm���g'e4eap2tstu�w'y �]qsu�m�r4��u�w�x � � �2�-�����?¢lg�t² ¬q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y�sr4q�I°iPg�tl�sg'm�r��'�2¢lr©e4g�mon2p'qsr4 ¦q�f'r{tsxBqsuvgog�ikq�f'r]r4�Kn®r4e4qsr4 ´w'p2m��2rat�gBi&qsu�m�r4�³q_f'r4�sr{¶®§Oy�tsx�m���g�e4eap2tst²r4 u�w~x � �2�-�����®�-�����?¢lg�t �qLr4�sql�sr4q�I � qsg�q�f'r{xBe4q�p2xBhFw'p2m��2rat�gBikqLu�m�r4��q�f'r4�¡g�e4eap2tst²r4 �:V ' ��� ���� *���� ��� G ' ��� ���� *�� J�^ � ^ _ � ��� >�>�P>F>HG?I;>�PKJ ��A2��� > : � >F>�P>�>HG I >�PKJ �V ' �� ��� *�� � ��� G ' ��� ���� *�� J�^ � ^ _ � ��� >>�>HG?I;>�PKJ � S

Å�f'r4�sr¡tsxBqsuvg��{x�t²r¯ 2uv��n'h�x���r4 ÀiIg't ��� �N�¡u�w��&uvy�p2tr �¡iPg�t©�'uvy�tsx�mÒx�w' Àq�tuvy�tsx�mÒm�g� 2r4hv�a­¡Å�f'r¬Ç{xGp'�s�su�x�wn2tuvg�t&xBe4f'uvr4��r4��tsxBqLu¤gG��e4hvg��srat�qLg³q�f'r,uv 2raxBh2�;xBh�p'r�g�i/g�w'rlq�f2x�w{m�g� 2u¼ª/r4  �©w'r4�srat¹§ ��r4�]��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y?iIg't�m�gG�sq �'�¢³f'uve4f�uv�&r4��uv 2raw'e4r?q�f2xBq&q�f'r�Ç{xGp'�s�su�x�w�n2tuvg�t&m�r4q�f'g' �uv����p2n®ratuvg�t&qsg©m�p'hvqsu�n'h¤r �¿xBq� 2uv�se4g�p2wGqs��xBq&n2tr4 2uve4qsu�w'ye4g�tst²r4e4q³x���ratsxBy�r? 2uv�se4g�p2wGqs�a­

ÔÀrÕxBhv�sg�u�wG��r4�sqLu¤y'xBqsr4 ~f'gB¢½q�f'r©w�p2m��®rat�gBi�u�w' 2ran®raw' 2raw�q©�Bx�tu�x�w'e4r�n2x�tsx�m�r4qLrat��p'�sr4 �¢�uvq�f¡q�f'r{Ç]x�p'�§�su�x�w�n2tuvg�tox�ÂFr4e4qs��n2rat«iPg�tsm�x�w'e4r�­ � w�q�f'r¡g�tuvy�u�w2xBhlu�mon'hvram�raw�q_xBqsuvg�w �"���*���+���2�&x� 2u¼ÂFratraw�q � � uv��p'�Lr4 

� e[w=r-f�k�ilwmu eg|Yh�eli�q-�[eoujp�f�{7f�qxu%y� ����������������������u � ymilw��[f " ( (��Nt+d%elile�egw�v d ��� ymilwY��z_egwYp�{jile�q-f�u7kmu #geoilkIk=u9r-� t+d%eouIu7kr-kmu7yYeli ��� ymilwY� z egwYp�{jile�q-f+u7kmu #geoilkj�+c+d9q-f�ilegf�{jr-p�egs�qxu f�q-ymujq��%v}wmujp�r � qxujz_eoi�q-k=i�h�eoi�z kmil�[w=u%vge�� c+d7e�r-w=ilyYeIf�hjqx��egf[qxu p�d%e"!;t+q-p�v�d�~�kYw=ils ymilw=h9d7f�wmile�s�q-f�vo{7f�f�egs�~j��# d7eou wmu7s���k�k�sj�[w=u " $)( �2c+d%e}�2wmile/vgwm{7f�egs�~j� ws�{9hjrxq-vgwYp�e}s2f�egyY��eoujp�kmz�p�eg|�p+qxu p�d7eGvgkmi�ilegf�hnkmu7s;qxu7yIp�ilwmqxujqxu%y/f�egpg�

�a�

Page 18: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

-0.2

-0.15

-0.1

-0.05

0

0.05

0.1

100 1000 10000 100000

diff

in te

st c

ross

-ent

ropy

fro

m b

asel

ine

(bits

/toke

n)

training set size (sentences)

relative performance of algorithms on Broadcast News corpus, 2-gram

baseline

katz

kneser-ney-mod

ME-gauss

ME-disc-katz

-0.25

-0.2

-0.15

-0.1

-0.05

0

0.05

0.1

100 1000 10000 100000

diff

in te

st c

ross

-ent

ropy

fro

m b

asel

ine

(bits

/toke

n)

training set size (sentences)

relative performance of algorithms on Broadcast News corpus, 3-gram

baseline

katz

kneser-ney-mod

ME-gauss

ME-disc-katz

-0.35

-0.3

-0.25

-0.2

-0.15

-0.1

-0.05

0

0.05

0.1

100 1000 10000

diff

in te

st c

ross

-ent

ropy

fro

m b

asel

ine

(bits

/toke

n)

training set size (sentences)

relative performance of algorithms on Brown corpus, 2-gram

baseline

katz

kneser-ney-modME-gauss

ME-disc-katz

-0.35

-0.3

-0.25

-0.2

-0.15

-0.1

-0.05

0

0.05

0.1

100 1000 10000

diff

in te

st c

ross

-ent

ropy

fro

m b

asel

ine

(bits

/toke

n)

training set size (sentences)

relative performance of algorithms on Brown corpus, 3-gram

baseline

katz

kneser-ney-mod

ME-gauss

ME-disc-katz

�&uvy�p2tr ��: � rat«iPg�tsmox�w'e4r{t²r4h�x�qsuv��r�qsg��2x��sr4hvu�w'r�gBi��Bx�tuvg�p'�©��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y�xBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m��³gB��rat�m¯p'hvqsu�n'hvroq�tLxBu�w'u�w'y�sr4q��Lu �4r4�?g�w¡q�f'r{¸ltg'xB 2eaxB�sq ��r4¢��³xGw' ~¸�t²g;¢?w¡e4g�tsn2g'tsx2�2�'uvy�tsx�m¨x�w' �q�tuvy�tLx�m m�g� 2r4hv�

� �

Page 19: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

-0.2

-0.15

-0.1

-0.05

0

0.05

0.1

100 1000 10000 100000

diff

in te

st c

ross

-ent

ropy

fro

m b

asel

ine

(bits

/toke

n)

training set size (sentences)

relative performance of algorithms on Switchboard corpus, 2-gram

baseline

katz

kneser-ney-mod

ME-gauss

ME-disc-katz

-0.25

-0.2

-0.15

-0.1

-0.05

0

0.05

0.1

100 1000 10000 100000

diff

in te

st c

ross

-ent

ropy

fro

m b

asel

ine

(bits

/toke

n)

training set size (sentences)

relative performance of algorithms on Switchboard corpus, 3-gram

baseline

katz

kneser-ney-mod

ME-gauss

ME-disc-katz

-0.25

-0.2

-0.15

-0.1

-0.05

0

0.05

0.1

100 1000 10000 100000

diff

in te

st c

ross

-ent

ropy

fro

m b

asel

ine

(bits

/toke

n)

training set size (sentences)

relative performance of algorithms on WSJ corpus, 2-gram

baseline

katz

kneser-ney-mod

ME-gauss

ME-disc-katz

-0.3

-0.25

-0.2

-0.15

-0.1

-0.05

0

0.05

0.1

100 1000 10000 100000

diff

in te

st c

ross

-ent

ropy

fro

m b

asel

ine

(bits

/toke

n)

training set size (sentences)

relative performance of algorithms on WSJ corpus, 3-gram

baseline

katz

kneser-ney-mod

ME-gauss

ME-disc-katz

�&uvy�p2tr � : � rat«iPg�tsmox�w'e4r{t²r4h�x�qsuv��r�qsg��2x��sr4hvu�w'r�gBi��Bx�tuvg�p'�©��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y�xBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m��³gB��rat�m¯p'hvqsu�n'hvroq�tLxBu�w'u�w'y�sr4q��Lu �4r4�?g�w¡q�f'r{d'¢�u¤qLe[f'�2g�xGt ´x�w' �Ô�xBhvh�d'q�tr4r4q � g�p2tsw2xBhFe4g'tsn2g�tLx2�2�'u¤y'tsx�m¨x�w' �q�tuvy�tsxGm m�g� 2r4hv�

0.9

0.95

1

1.05

1.1

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

expe

cted

cou

nt /

actu

al c

ount

count

ratio of expected to actual counts, 2-gram, 750k words training

kneser-ney-mod

ME-gauss

0.85

0.9

0.95

1

1.05

1.1

1.15

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

expe

cted

cou

nt /

actu

al c

ount

count

ratio of expected to actual counts, 3-gram, 750k words training

kneser-ney-mod

ME-gauss

�&uvy�p2tr��: � xBqsuvgogBi&r4�2n2r4e4qsr4 |w�p2m��2rat�qsgoxBe4q�p2x�h w'p2m��2rat�u�w�qsr4�sql�sr4q�gBi*¶®§Oy�tLx�m��l¢�uvq�f~x�y�uv��raw¡e4g�p2wGq�u�wq�tsx�u�w'u�w'y¡ /xBq�x2�X� � �2�-�����E¢lg�t �Ô xBhvh�d'q_tr4r4q � g�p2tLw2xBhFq�tsx�u�w'u�w'yo�Lr4qa�/�'uvy�tsx�m x�w' ~q�t²u¤y'tsx�m m�g' 2r4h¤�

� �

Page 20: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

-0.2

-0.15

-0.1

-0.05

0

0.05

0.1

100 1000 10000 100000

diff

in te

st c

ross

-ent

ropy

fro

m b

asel

ine

(bits

/toke

n)

training set size (sentences)

relative performance of algorithms on WSJ corpus, 2-gram

baseline

ME-gauss

ME-gauss-1ME-gauss-3n -0.25

-0.2

-0.15

-0.1

-0.05

0

0.05

0.1

100 1000 10000 100000

diff

in te

st c

ross

-ent

ropy

fro

m b

asel

ine

(bits

/toke

n)

training set size (sentences)

relative performance of algorithms on WSJ corpus, 3-gram

baseline

ME-gauss

ME-gauss-1

ME-gauss-3n

�&uvy�p2tr ��: � rat«iPg�tsmox�w'e4r�tr4h�xBqsuv��r�qLg �2x��sr4hvu�w'r|gBi? 2u ÂFratrawGq¬n2x�tLx�m�r4qsratu��axBqLu¤g'w'�¯g�iÕÇ{x�p'�L�su�x�w�n2tuvg�t�gB��ratm�p'hvqsu�n'h¤r�q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y¡�sr4q��Lu �4r4�?g�w¡q�f'r©Ô�xBhvh�d'q�tr4r4q � g�p2tsw2xBhFe4g'tsn2p'�a�/�'uvy�tsxGm�x�w' ~q_tuvy�tsx�m m�g' 2r4hv�

iPg�t©raxBe4fÀh¤r4�Gr4h�gBi�q�f'r�¶2§Oy'tsx�m m�g' 2r4hI­�� Ô=r�xBhv�sg|e4g�w'�suv 2ratr4 Yp'�su�w'y x¦�su�w'y�hvr � g;�Grat{q_f'r¬¢³f'gGh¤r�m�g' 2r4h� �"���*��+���$���a�4��x�w' ¯p'�su�w'y]q�f2tr4r�n2xGtsx�m�r4qsrat²� � � � P4� � � � � ��xGw'  � � � A¡iPg�t�raxBe4f©hvr4��r4h2gBi/q�f'rl¶®§Oy�tsx�m�m�g' 2r4hI�qsg~�®r¬x�n2n'hvuvr4 �qsg ��§Oy'tsx�m��©¢�uvq�f � � � �Fg't � g�t©m�g�tr�e4g�p2wGqs�©u�wÀq�f'r�q�tsxBu�w'u�w'y| /xBq�x2�Ftr4�_n2r4e4qsuv��r4hv��­¬Å�f'u¤�h�xBqsqsrat]n2x�tsx�m�r4qsratu��axBqsuvg�w$� �"���*���+���$�����/��uv�ox�w2xBhvg�y�g'p'�{qsg�q�f'r�n2x�tsxGm�r4qsratu��axBqsuvg�w gBi³m�g� 2u¼ª/r4  �©w'r4�srat¹§��r4�=��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y/­�Å�f'r¬n®rat«iPg�tsmox�w'e4r¡gBi�q�f'r4�sr�q�f2tr4ro�Bx�tu�xBqsuvg�w'��g�w|q_f'r¬Ô x�h¤hld'q�tr4r4q � g�p2tsw2xBh,e4g�tsn2p'�]u¤� 2uv��n'h�x���r4 �u�w!�&u¤y'p2tr �®­´Å�f'r¡�;xGtu�xBqsuvg�w'� "��*���+ ���~x�w'  "�$*��+ ���������´�'u¤r4hv $xBh�m�g��sq]u¤ 2rawGqsuveaxBh³n®rat«iPg�t«§mox�w'e4r���x�w' |q�f'r��;x�t²u�x�qsuvg�w �"���*���+���$����n®rat«iPg�tsm��©�shvuvy�fGqshv�|¢�g't�sr�­� � �{f2x���u�w'y~�Lran2x�tsxBqsr]�;x�t²u�xGw'e4r4�{iPg�traxBe4f ¶®§Oy�tLx�m°h¤r4�Gr4h�hvraxB 2�oqsg|u�mon2tgB��r4 �n2rat«iPg�tsm�x�w'e4r��&q�f'uv�ouv�¬x|p'�sr_iOp'hl 2u¤�Lqsu�w'e4qsuvg�w�qsg=moxG¥Br�­|Ô=r�xBhv�sgu�w��Gr4�sqsuvy�xBqsr4 ~m�x�w���g�q�f'ratln2x�tsx�m�r4qsrat«§Oq��u�w'y��se4f'ram�r4�a�2�2p'q³w'g�w'r©�Lu¤y'w'u ª/eaxGw�qshv��g�p'q_n2rat«iPg�tsm�r4 �q_f'u¤�l�su�mon'hvrqsr4e4f2w'uvµKp'r�­

� �,+� "��+H+����J�� q�f2xB���2r4raw½xGty�p'r4 Yq_f2xBq¬moxB�'u�m�p2m raw�q�t²g�n���m�g' 2r4hv�� 2gYw'g�q¬tr4µ2p'u�tr|��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'yY�2r4eax�p'�Lr´q_f'r4�Yx�trxBh�traxB 2��xB��p2w'u¼iIg'tsm�g�t���m�g'g�q�f�xB�&n2gG�s�su��'hvr³y�uv��raw�q�f'rle4g�w'�sq�tsx�u�wGqs�a­ � gB¢lr4��rat4��m�xB��u�m�p2m�rawGq�tg�nG�{m�g' 2r4h¤�eax�w��®r���uvr4¢lr4 YxB�omoxB�'u�m¯p2m°hvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g' $r4�Kn®g�w'raw�qLu�x�h³m�g' 2r4h¤����x�w' Yf2x���r¡�su�m�uvh�x�ton2tg'n2ratqsuvr4�¬x��¯gGq�f'ratmoxB�'u�m�p2m hvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g' ½m�r4q�f'g' 2�a­ �/g�tEr4�Kx�m�n'h¤r��lxB�]eax�w��2r¡�sr4raw�u�w!�&uvy�p2tr � ��¢³f'raw= /x�q�x¦u¤�on'hvrawGqsu¼i p'hP���m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y¬f2x��³x���mox�h¤hvrat�r_ÂFr4e4qa�/x�w' �¢³f'raw  /xBq�x]uv�³�_n2x�t�sr��2�_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'youv�³r4�s�Lraw�qsu�xBhP­

� w|mox�wG�~q�xB�_¥��?u�w'e4h�p' 2u�w'y=h�x�w'y'p2xBy�rom�g' 2r4h¤u�w'y/��uvq{f2xB�{�®r4raw¦iIg'p2w' ´q_f2xBq©��p2n2rat²u¤g't{n2rat¹iIg�tLmox�w'e4r�eax�w�2r~x�e[f'uvr4��r4 $���=e4g'w'�sq�tsp'e4qsu�w'y=�Grat�=h�x�ty�r~m�g� 2r4hv�´�9�Lg n2xGtsx�m�r4qsrat²��xGtr¬�_n2x�t�sr4hv��r4�sqsu�moxBqsr4 /��x�w' �q�f'raw��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y�q�f'ram ­³Å�f'p'�a�NiPg�t³m�xB��u�m�p2m raw�q�t²g�n��~m�g� 2r4hv�{qLg¬�2roe4g'mon2r4qsuvqsuv��r�¢�uvq�f¦g�q_f'rat�qsr4e4f2w'uvµKp'r4�]u�wq�f'r4�sr© 2g'moxBu�w'�a�N¢�r{w'r4r4 ¦r_ÂFr4e4qsuv��r{moxB�'u�m¯p2m raw�q�t²g�n��¡��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y¬x�h¤yGg�tuvq�f2m��a­

� w$q�f'uv�~¢lg�tL¥/�?¢lr|��f'gB¢�r4 $q�f2x�q´x�Ç{xGp'�s�su�x�w½n2tuvg�t eax�w½�®r p'�sr4 �qsg���m�g'g�q�f$moxB�'u�m�p2m rawGq�tg�nG�¶®§Oy�tsx�m m�g' 2r4hv��qsg x�e[f'uvr4��r=n2rat¹iIg�tLmox�w'e4r~r4µ2p2xBh©qsgÀg�to�_p2n2ratuvg�t¡qsg�q�f2xBq¡gBi¯xBhvh?g�q�f'rat�qsr4e4f2w'u¤µ2p'r4��iPg�t

� c+d7e[kmh7p�q-�[w=r+�=wmi�q-w=u%v}egf� �� (� z kmiGp�d7e ��w={%f�f�q-w=u�hji�q-kmiGz km{ju%sI~j�Ip�d%e !�kmtQeorxr�f�egwmilv�d t+eoileD�[kYf�p�r-�Iqxu2p�d7e�ilw=u%y�e���� (�� ��%(� � (���t+d7eoile� Rq-fGp�d%e�f�q #ge[kmzQp�d7e[p�ilwmqxujqxu%y f�egpg�G��{jr-p�qxhjr-�Yqu7y ~j�� ,vgkmuj��eoilp�fGp�d7e[�=wmi�q-wmu7vgegfGz ilk�� hjilkm~7wm~jqxrxq p �2f�h7wYvgep�k�vgkm{jujpGf�h7wYvgeY�Nwmu7s s;q-f�vgk={9ujp�f�wmileGileor-wYp�q-��eor-�2vgk=u%f�p�w=ujp�qxu2vgk={9ujpGf�h7wYv}e[k=�YeoiDs�q���eoileoujpDp�ilwmqxujqxu7yIf�egpGf�q #gegfg�Dc+d%eDs�q-f�vgkm{jujp�fp�eou7s9e}sIp�k[ymilk=t#t q-p�d s9w�p�w�f�egp�f�q #geGwmu7sIf�d9i�qxuj� t+q-p�d��I�

� c+d7e�ilegwYf�k=uIp�d7wYp�wD�mw=i�q-wYp�q-k=u2t+q-p�dI��kmile�h7wmilwY��egp�eoilf��[w=�[u%k�p�k={%p�hneoi�z_kmil� w��mw=i�q-wYp�q-k=u2t+q-p�d�z egt+eoi+h7wmilw��[egp�eoilf+q-f�s�{%ep�k[f�egw=ilv d eli�ilkmilf+qxuIh%w=ilwY�[e}p�eoi�kmh7p�q-��q #gwYp�q-k=u��� �

Page 21: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y�¶®§Oy�tsx�m m�g� 2r4hv�a��x¦ª/r4hv $¢³f'uve4fYf2xB��x�w�r4�'qsraw'�suv��r=�2g' 2��gBi{xB�s�sg'e4u�xBqsr4 Ót²r4�srax�te4f7­YÅ�f'uv�¡u¤�q�f'r�ª¿t�sq]e4h¤raxGt� 2ram�g�w'�sq_tsxBqsuvg�w|q_f2xBq¯x|moxB�'u�m�p2mÒrawGq�tg�nG�=��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y|m�r4q�f'g'  eax�w��2r~x��{r_ÂFr4e4qsuv��r�xB���m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y�qsr4e4f2w'uvµKp'r4� iIg'tog�q_f'ratoq�2n2r4��gBi¯m�g' 2r4hv�a�©x�w' ½mox�¥Br4�¡uvq~n2g��L�su��'h¤r�qsg�e4g�w'�sq�tLp'e4q�mox���u�m�p2mrawGq�tg�nG�Õm�g� 2r4hv�&u�w]��n2x�t�sr& /x�q�x��Lu¤q_p2xBqsuvg�w'��¢�uvq�f'g�p'q�h¤gG�s��g�i®n®rat«iIg'tsmox�w'e4r�­��¿p2t²q�f'ratsm�g�t²r��auvq&xB 2 2���'u�tq�p2xBhvhv�w'g�e4g�mon2p'q�x�qsuvg�w2xBh7e4g��sqlqsg�q�f'r©moxB�'u�m¯p2m raw�q�t²g�n���q�tLxBu�w'u�w'y¡n2tg�e4r4 /p2t²r�­ � gB¢�r4�Grat4���®r4eax�p'�sr©gBi�q_f'r©h�xGty�rp2w' 2rathv�'u�w'y�e4g�m�n2p'q�xBqsuvg�w2xBh2e4gG�sq�g�i moxB�'u�m�p2m�raw�q�t²g�n���xBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m��a���2p'uvh¤ 2u�w'y¬m�xB��u�m�p2m�rawGq�tg�nG�{m�g' 2r4h¤�iPg�tl��rat��h�xGty�r{ /x�q�x]�sr4qs��uv�?�sqsuvhvh�x�e4f2xBhvh¤raw'yGu�w'y~n2t²g��'hvram�­

Ô½f'uvhvr¬q_f'u¤����m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y=m�r4q_f'g� �eax�w=�®r�r4�Kn2tr4�L�sr4  �Grat�|�su�mon'hv���&¢lr¬��f'gB¢·q�f2xBq©uvqon2g��s�Lr4�s�sr4�oxBhvh�gBiq�f'r© 2r4�su�tsxG�'h¤r]µKp2x�h¤uvqsuvr4�?gBik¶®§Oy�tsxGm �_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y�w'gGqsr4 ��G��j�f'raw�x�w' �Ç©g'g� /moxGw�i tg'm�ramon'u�tuveaxBh&x�w2xBhv�'�suv�a­� w$xB 2 2uvqsuvg�w7�Eu¤q~x�e[f'uvr4��r4��uvqs��r4�'e4r4hvh¤rawGq´n®rat«iPg�tsmox�w'e4r=p'�su�w'y»iIr4¢lrat¡n2x�tsx�m�r4qLrat�¬q_f2x�w!q�f'r|e4g�mon2x�tsxG�'h¤�n2rat¹iIg�tLm�u�w'y�m�g' 2u¼ª/r4 ��©w'r4�srat¹§ ��r4�¦��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y/­

Å�f'r�Ç{xGp'�s�su�x�w�n2tuvg�t&x�w' �q�f'r �©w'r4�srat«§ ��r4�¯m�r4q�f'g� 2�&e4g'w'�suv�sqsrawGqshv�¯g'p'q�n2rat«iPg�tsm g�q�f'rat���m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y©qsr4e4fG§w'uvµKp'r4��­�Å�f'r� 2uv�sqsu�w'e4qsuvg�w¡�2r4q¢lr4raw]q�f'r4�sr�xBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m���x�w' �q�f'rlg�q_f'rat�&uv��q�f'r4u�t&p'�sr�g�i m�g' 2u¼ª/r4 ohvg;¢lrat«§Og't 2rat 2uv�sq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w'��xB�© 2r4�seatu��®r4  u�w=d'r4e4qsuvg�w'� � xGw'  � ­ � ­©Å�f'r4�sr� 2uv�sq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w'�ox�t²r{e4f'g��sraw|qsg¡��xBqLu¤�²iI�¦e4ratq�xBu�wmox�t²y�u�w2xBh�e4g'w'�sq�tsxBu�wGqs�� 2ratuv��r4 �iOtg�m q�f'rlq�tsxBu�w'u�w'y© /xBq�x2­�Å�f'p'�a�Bq�f'r�p'�srlgBi¿mox�t²y�u�w2xBh�e4g'w'�sq�tsxBu�wGqs�&mox��{�2r�xn2gB¢lrat«iOp'h2qsr4e4f2w'u¤µ2p'r?iPg�t& 2r4�suvy�w'u�w'yow'gB��r4h/�_m�g�gGq�f'u�w'y¯xBhvy�g�t²u¤q_f2m��a��¢?f'r4q�f'rat�iPg�t&h�x�w'y'p2xBy�r³m�g' 2r4hvu�w'yog�t�iPg�tg�q�f'rat* 2g�moxBu�w'�a­&�,wGiIg�t²e4u�w'yomoxGty�u�w2xBh2e4g�w'�sq_tsxBu�w�qL�&¢�g'p'h¤ �mox�tL¥{x©�Lu¤y'w'u ª/eaxGw�ql 2ran2x�tq_p2trliOtg�m�q�tsx� 2u¤qLu¤g'w2xBhqsr4e4f2w'uvµKp'r4�©p'�sr4 ~u�w ��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y/­

� w~xB 2 2uvqsuvg�w7�7q_f'r{Ç{x�p'�s�Lu�xGw~n2tuvg�t�uv�{x�µKp2x�h¤uvq�x�qsuv��r4hv�~ 2u¼ÂFratraw�q©n2tuvg�t�q�f2x�w¦f2xB�³�2r4raw|p'�sr4 =n2tr4�'uvg�p'�shv�u�w|¶2§Oy'tsx�m ��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y/­ � �?qsg�p'e4f'r4 ´g'w�u�w|d'r4e4qsuvg�w � ­ � �Nhvu�w'raxGt? 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qLu�w'y�eaxGw´�®rom�g�qsuv�;x�qsr4 ~q�f2t²g�p'y�fx��©u�tuve4f'h¤r4q?g�t�¸,r4q�x�n2tuvg�tlg�w�n2tg'�2x��'uvh¤uvqsuvr4�oà � W�� � � Ä �2�2p'q³uvq³f2xB�?�2r4raw��_f'g;¢?w¡qsgon2rat«iPg�tsm�n®g�g'thv��­�Ô½f'uvhvrx��'�sgGh�p'qLr� 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsu�w'y{�'u¤r4hv 2���2r4qLqsrat�n®rat«iIg'tsmox�w'e4r��Buvq�uv�lp2w'e4h¤raxGt�f'gB¢�qsg©r4hvr4y�x�wGqshv��r4�Kn2tr4�L��q�f'uv��qLr4e[f2w'uvµ2p'rq�f2tg'p'y�f¬x�n2tuvg�t, 2uv�sq�t²u��2p'qLu¤g'w7­ � w¡e4g�w�q_tsxB�sqa�Gq�f'r©Ç{x�p'�s�Lu�xGw¬n2tuvg�t,uv�³x�n2n'hvuvr4 ~qLg ` ��n2xGtsx�m�r4qsrat²��¢³f'uve4f�x�trhvu�w'rax�tlu�w¡hvg�yB§¹n2tg��2xG�'u¤hvuvq���¿xGw' ¬hvraxB 2��qLg¯hvg�y'x�tuvq�f2m�uve© 2uv�se4g�p2wGqsu�w'y/­�Å�f'uv���Lu�m�n'h¤r�n2tuvg�t,��uvr4hv 2�? 2u¤�Le4g�p2w�qLu�w'yq�f2xBqluv�?µKp2xBhvuvq�xBqLu¤�Gr4h¤�|x�w' �µ2p2x�w�qLu¤q_xBqsuv��r4hv���su�m�uvh�x�t�qLgoq�f'r©ramon'u�tuveaxBh�uv 2raxBhP­

��g�qFg'w'h¤�]eax�w©q_f'r�Ç{xGp'�s�su�x�w{n2t²u¤g't&�2r�xGn2n'h¤uvr4 oqLgÕmox���u�m�p2m½rawGq�tg'n��©m�g' 2r4h¤u�w'y/�'�2p'q�uvq&eax�w]xBhv�sg©�2r�x�nG§n'hvuvr4 �u�w�q�f'r³m�g�trly�raw'ratsxBh���Ð�O/Ð��23N� /�Ð �aÎ�Ï 'ÎjO ��Î?n2x�tsxB 2uvy�m à � �'� � � Ä ­�z=xB��u�m�u��4u�w'yorawGq�tg�nG�{uv�,r4µKp'uv�;x�h¤rawGqqsg�ª¿w' 2u�w'y�q�f'r�m�g' 2r4hF¢�uvq�f�q_f'r{��mox�h¤hvr4�sq �©p'hvh��2xBe[¥�§¹Á7r4u��'h�ratE 2u¤�Graty�raw'e4r]i t²g�m q�f'r�p2w'u iPg�tsm  2uv�sq�tu��2p'qsuvg�w7­� w¦m�u�w'u�m¯p2m¨ 2uv��rat²y�raw'e4r¯m�g' 2r4hvu�w'y/�7g�w'r{�Lr4h¤r4e4qL�³q�f'r�m�g' 2r4hF��xBqsuv�iP�'u�w'y¡q�f'r]y�uv��raw�e4g�w'�Lq�tsxBu�wGqs��e4hvg��sr4�sq?qsg�sg�m�ro 2r_i xGp'h¤q� 2uv�sq�t²u��2p'qLu¤g'wbA N��ZBN�4­¬Å�f'r�m�g' 2r4h A N��CB/�?eax�w��2r¬p'�Lr4  qsg¦r4�Kn2t²r4�s�¯n2tuvg�t]¥�w'gB¢�hvr4 2y�r�x��®g�p'qq�f'r© 2g�m�xBu�w7­�z|u�w'u�m¯p2m  2uv��raty�raw'e4r�m�g' 2r4h¤�©f2x���r©q�f'r?iPg�tsm

AYX��±�ZBN�<K �\G] A N��CB/�]r4�Kn�� 8&>_^8P ` > 69>��ZB/�s� S

Å�f'r{x�w2x�h¤�'�suv�?u�w¦d'r4e4qsuvg�w � x�n2n'hvu¤r4�©qLgoq�f'r4�sr{m�g' 2r4hv�³¢�u¤q_f'g�p'q³m�g' 2u¼ª/eaxBqsuvg�w7­z=xB�'u�m�p2m¨raw�q�t²g�n��|m�g' 2r4h¤u�w'y=f2xB��xB 2�;x�wGq�xByGr4�©g;�Grat?e4g�mon2r4qLu�w'y=x�n2n2t²g�xBe4f'r4�©u�wÀqsratsm��©gBi�r4hvr4y�x�w'e4r��

y�raw'ratsx�h¤uvq���Fx�w' =n2rat¹iIg�tLmox�w'e4r��7x�w' ~q�f'roÇ]x�p'�s�su�x�w¦n2tuvg�t?uv�{x¬n®g;¢lrat«iOp'hFqsg'g�h�iIg'tl��m�g'g�q�f'u�w'y�y�raw'ratsx�hFz=�m�g' 2r4hv�a­&Ô½f'r4q�f'ratlq�f'r{Ç]x�p'�s�su�x�w¡n2tuvg�t�n2t²g;�Gr4����p2n®ratuvg�t�qLg¯gGq�f'ratlxBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m��lu�w¡ 2g�mox�u�w'��g�q�f'rat,q�f2x�w�¶®§y�tsxGm m�g� 2r4hvu�w'y¬uv���Lqsuvh¤h�x�w¡g�n2raw ramon'u�tuveaxBhFµ2p'r4�sqsuvg�w7­ � w�¶®§Oy�tsxGm m�g� 2r4hv�a�/w'g�iIraxBq_p2tr4��n2x�tqsu�xBhvhv��gB��rath�x�nraxBe4f�g�q�f'rat4�lx�w' �q�f'uv�¡uv��w'g�q�q�f'r¦eaxB�sr�u�w�yGraw'ratsxBhP­ � w!xB 2 2uvqsuvg�w7��f'gB¢"n2x�tsxGm�r4qsrat����f'g�p'hv $�2r~qLu¤r4 !u�wg�q�f'rat, 2g�m�xBu�w'�±f2x����Gr4q�qsgo�2r?r4�2n'h¤g'tr4 F­�����g�w'r4q�f'r4hvr4�s����g'p2t�t²r4��p'hvqs�³x�w' �x�w2xBhv�'�suv�� ²p'�Lqsu¼iI�oq_f'r³e4f'g�uve4r©gBi�xÇ{xGp'�s�su�x�w¡n2tuvg�t,iPg�t�p'�sr©u�w�¶®§Oy�tsxGm m�g� 2r4hvu�w'y/�/x�w' ��Lq�tg�w'y�hv����p'y�yGr4�sqlu¤qL�±p'�Lr©u�w¡gGq�f'rat,�suvq�p2xBqsuvg�w'�³x���¢lr4hvhI­

� � q-p�d � � y=ilwY�,�[k�sjeor-fg�+t+eDz_km{ju%s p�d%w�p�wIf�qxu7ymr-eI�=wmi�q-w=u%v}e�� z kmi�p�d%e�t+d%k=r-e��[k�s9elr�t+kmi�� egs2�Y{jq-p�e�t+elrxr_� p�d7km{7ymd {7f�qxu%yf�eoh7wmilw�p�e � � z_kmi egwYv�dIr-eg��eor+k=z+p�d7e � � y=ilwY���[k�s9elr+t+k=i���egsIf�rxq-y=djp�r-� ~�egp�p�eli=����kmtQeg�Yeoi=��p�djq-f�h7wmilp�q-p�q-kmujqxu7y q-f�u7kYp�wmhjh9rxq-vgw=~9r eqxu yYelu%eoilw=r_�� W

Page 22: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

� � %<�����9� ��� �J�)��� & � 2��� %,�� �J��+�� ����� ���=+��a�'& �2��� %")� �=% � � �����3% �D ��<) ��V�����T� � ����% � �a��+=+��,�D��� � � ���

� w q�f'uv�³�Lr4e4qsuvg�w7�2¢lr© 2ratuv��r{q_f'r{m�g� 2u¼ª/r4 |e4g�w'�sq_tsxBu�w�qL��y�uv��raw¡u�w�r4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w�� � ���lx�w' �q�f'r�m�g' 2u ª/r4 |p2n2 /xBqLriPg�t?u�mon2tgB��r4 |uvqsratsxBqsuv��r��seax�h¤u�w'y¦y�uv��raw|u�w|r4µ2p2xBqsuvg�wY� ��� �,iPg�t?q�f'roÇ{x�p'�L�su�x�w|n2tuvg�t{m�r4q_f'g� |��p'y�yGr4�sqsr4 =���ÁFx�ÂFratq��­ÀÔ=r~p'�sr�q�f'r�e4g�w' 2uvqsuvg�w2x�h�z=� iIg�tLm¯p'h�xBqLu¤g'w7­b�Ng�tEi p2t²q�f'rat] 2r4q�xBuvhv��x��®g�p'qou�mon2tgB��r4 �uvqsratLxBqsuv��r�seaxBhvu�w'y¡��p'e[f¦xB�³n2tg'gBi�g�ike4g�wG��ratyGraw'e4r��/tr_iPratlqsg~à � Ä ­

Å�g= 2ratuv��r¦q�f'r~m�g' 2u¼ª/r4 Óe4g'w'�sq�tsxBu�wGqs�a�&¢lr�q�xG¥Br�q�f'r~n2x�tqLu�x�h� 2ratuv�;xBqLu¤�Gr4��gBi³q�f'r¦g��� r4e4qsuv��r¡i p2w'e4qLu¤g'wy�uv��raw u�w r4µKp2x�qsuvg�w=� �a� �,¢�uvq�f¦tr4��n®r4e4q³qsg�q�f'r{n2xGtsx�m�r4qsrat²� ` >�x�w' ~�Lr4q�q�f'ram qsg��4ratg/­

�_ ��b��LK & <�� � [] �ZB8Q��'�2hvg�y<A ] ��� : B/��T8& > ^8P ` �>� � �> ��e4g�w'�sqB��b��

K & <�� � [] �ZB8Q��'� & > ` >�6j>s�ZB8Q��'��T & <�� � [] �ZB�Q����®hvg�y & � � r4�2n�� & > ` >�6j>s�ZB8Q�� � �s��T8& >_^�P ` �>� � �> �»e4g�w'�sqa��b��

� �_ ��b��� ` > K & <�� � [] �ZB8Q��'�=69>¹�ZB8Q��'��T & <�� � [] �CB�Q��'� & � �r4�2n�� V > ` >�69>²�CB�Q�� � �s�\G] �ZB/� 69>s�ZB�Q�� � ��T ` >� �>

K & <�� � [] �ZB8Q��'�=69>¹�ZB8Q��'��T & <�� � [] �CB�Q��'� & � � A ] ��� � : B/�m6j>�ZB�Q�� � ��T `>� �>

K & <�� � [] �ZB8Q��'�=69>¹�ZB8Q��'��T & < [] �CB/� &� �A ] ��� � : B/�m6j>s�ZB8Q�� � � &

�[] ��� : B/��T ` >� �>

K & <�� � [] �ZB8Q��'�=69>¹�ZB8Q��'��T & <�� � [] �CB/��A ] ��� : B/�=69>¹�ZB8Q��'��T ` >� �>�&µ2p2xBqsuvg�w=� � ���*iIgGh¤hvgB¢��?�su�mon'hv�¡i t²g�m·q�f'r{h�xB�sq�h¤u�w'r�­

Å�f'r� 2ratuv�;xBqsuvg�w!gBi?q�f'r´m�g' 2u¼ª/r4 Yu�mon2tgB��r4 !uvqsratsxBqsuv��r��LeaxBhvu�w'y�p2n2 /x�qsr~uv�¡u¤ 2rawGqsuveaxBh?qsg=q�f'r�g'tuvy�u�w2xBh 2ratuv�;x�qsuvg�w�r4��e4ran'q]iPg�t?q�f'r�n2tr4�sraw'e4r¡gBi�r4��q_tsx�qsratLm��©iPg�t©q_f'r¬n2tuvg�t4­ � w=rax�e[f|uvqsratLxBqsuvg�w7�&¢lroq�t²�~qsg ª¿w'  K\M �Y> Y©q�f2x�q³moxB�'u�m�u��4r4�³q�f'r©u�w'eatrax��sr{u�w�q_f'r{g��� r4e4qsuv��r?iOp2w'e4qsuvg�w+:

�_ ��b �o�GT� �_ ��b���K & <�� � [] �ZB8Q��'� & > �Y>a69>s�ZB�Q�����T& < [] �ZBN�2hvg�y &

�A ] ��� : BN�2r4�2n¿� & > �Y>�69>²�ZB8Q��'�s��T �

� � �> & > � � ` > �Y> ��� �> �LS

� �³uvq?u¤�©w'g�q?e4hvrax�t³f'gB¢½qLg¬moxB�'u�m�u��4r¯q_f'u¤�?iOp2w'e4qsuvg�w  2u�t²r4e4qshv���7¢�rEª¿w' ´x�w¦x�p'�'u¤hvu�x�t� i p2w'e4qLu¤g'w��¡� o��q�f2xBq¢lr �_È�O=moxB�'u�m�u��4r�q�f2xBq³�®g�p2w' 2�©q�f'uv��iOp2w'e4qsuvg�w iOtg�m��®r4h¤gB¢{­�Ô=r{¢lg�p'hv |hvu�¥Br�q�f'r¯mox���u�m�p2m�g�i��¬� o��qsg�2r]h�x�ty�rat,q�f2x�w �4rat²go¢³f'raw'r4��rat[b$uv�³w'g�qlg�n'qLu�m�xBhP�FÐa$ Î7$ �2¢³f'raw'r4�Grat[bY 2g'r4�Õw'gGq��_xBqsuv�iP�¬q�f'r©e4g'w'�sq�tsxBu�wGqs�lu�wr4µ2p2xBqsuvg�w � � ���4­

}��su�w'yoq�f'r]u�w'r4µKp2xBhvuvq��hvg�y�B /B T � �'¢lr©y�r4q �_ �ab������T �_ �ab±��� & <�� � [] �ZB8Q��'� & > �Y>�6j>��CB�Q��'� � � T

& < [] �ZBN� &�A ] ��� : BN�2r4�2n¿� & > � > 6 > �ZB�Q����s��T �

� � �> & > � � ` > � > � � �> �HK���� o� S

� �

Page 23: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

d2p2�'�sqsuvq�p'qLu�w'y¡u�w#6 � �ZB�Q�����K,V > 6 > �ZB8Q��'��x�w' |x�n2n'hv��u�w'y � raw'�sraw� �?u�w'r4µKp2xBhvuvq���7¢lr{x�tstuv��r{xBq

��� o�� & <�� � [] �ZB�Q���� & > �Y>a69>��ZB8Q��'� � � T& < [] �CB/� &

�A ] ��� : B/� & > 6 > �ZB8Q��'�6 � �CB�Q��'� r4�Kn�� �Y>a6 � �ZB�Q����s��T �

� � �> & > � � ` > �Y> ��� �> �HK �¬� �� S

Å�x�¥�u�w'y¡q�f'r{n2x�tqLu�x�h¿ 2rat²u¤�BxBqsuv��r�gBi �¬� ��l¢�uvq�f�tr4��n®r4e4q³qLg �Y>¹�®¢�r©yGr4q� �¬� o�� � > K & <�� � [] �ZB8Q��'�=69>¹�ZB�Q�����T & < [] �ZBN� &

�A ] � � : BN�=69>¹�ZB8Q��'�2r4�2n¿� �Y>�6��©�ZB�Q����s��T ` > ���Y>� �> S

�&µ2p2xBqsuvg�w¡� �a� �¿iIg�hvhvgB¢����G�©�sr4qsqsu�w'y?q�f'r4�sr� 2rat²u¤�BxBqsuv��r4�,qsg��4ratg/­ ��g�qsuve4r�q_f2xBq �¡� 4���<K,�?x�w' ]q�f2xBq � �¬� 4�G�<K 4�g�w'hv�|u¼i�b���xBqsuv�ª/r4�]q�f'r�e4g�w'�sq�tsx�u�wGqs�a­ � q?iPg�hvhvgB¢��©q�f2xBq©q�f'romox���u�m�p2m¨gBi �¡� o�?¢�uvhvh��®roh�x�ty�rat?q_f2x�w �4ratg¢³f'raw bYuv�Õw'gGq�g�n'qsu�moxBhP�/x��� 2r4�su�tr4 F­� % �6%<��% � �%@+à �[Ä � ­7ÁFx�ÂFratq���&n2rat²�sg�w2xBhFe4g'mom�p2w'u¤eax�qsuvg�w7� � W�W �2­Ã �;ÄÕ� ­�¸,raty�rat ��d7­ �©r4hvh�x � uvr4q�tsx®��x�w' ��¯­ �©r4hvh�x � uvr4q�tsx®� � � m�xB��u�m�p2mÒrawGq�tg'n��|x�n2n2tg�xBe4f|qsg~w2x�q�p2tsxBh

h�x�w'y�p2x�y�r¯n2tg'e4r4�s�su�w'y/� ���Ë���ÊQ3'ÍPÈ�ÍPÐ9Ë�O/È -�� Ð O N3'Ð�Ì4ÍPÐ�� Ì[�G��g�hP­ ��� �Kw'gN­ � �/n2n7­ � W � � � � W�W5�®­Ã �;Ä d7­��©r4hvh�x � uvr4q�tsx2���¯­ �©r4h¤h�x � u¤r4q_tsx2�7x�w'  � ­7ÁFx�ÂFratq���� � w' /p'e4u�w'y iIraxBq_p2tr4�³g�i*tsxGw' 2g�m ª/r4hv 2�a� ��� � �

�7ÏÈ�O®Ì;$�Ë�O���È�ÍPÍPÎ�Ï�O��IONÈ - P�Ì[Ð ÌÕÈ O /��´È � ��Ð ONÎ���O/ÍPÎ -F- Ð�ÎjO ��Î��B��g�hP­ � W®�Kw'gN­ � � � W�W5�®­Ã � ÄÕ� ­ � xBq�w2x�n2x�tL¥�f'uP���|È%M;Ð��23N�� �O/ÍPÏË_Ê+P��|Ë0/�Î - Ì 1[ËGÏ � È�Í�3'ÏÈ -�� È�O��3�È�'Î��I� �4ÐN3'Ð9Í�P���Î4Ì4Ë - 3'ÍPÐÑË�ON� � f7­ �o­

q�f'r4�Lu¤���¿}?w'uv��rat�suvq��gBi � raw2w'�s�'hv�;x�w'u�x2� � f'uvh�x� 2r4h�n2f'u�x2� �N� � � W�W5�2­Ã �;Ä � ­ � g��srawGiPr4h¤ F� � � moxB�'u�m¯p2mÉrawGq�tg�nG�Yx�n2n2tg�x�e[f�qsg�xB /x�n'qLu¤�Gr~�sq�x�qsuv�sqsuveaxBh?h�xGw'y�p2xBy�r|m�g� 2r4hvu�w'y/�% ��Ë ��Ê+3�ÍPÎ�Ï�� �GÊKÎ_Î � �!�¯È O / � È O�N3'È�'Îa�,��g�hP­ � �2��n2n7­ � �5�" ��� �2� � W�W5�2�$hvg�w'yGrat¡��rat�suvg�w!n2p2�'h¤uv��f'r4 �xB�� �  /x�n'qsuv��r=d'q�x�qsuv�sqsuveaxBh©ÁFx�w'y�p2xByGr~z|g� 2r4hvu�w'y�: � z x���u�m�p2mº�,w�q_tg�nG� � n2n2tg�xBe4f7�% � f7­ �o­�q_f'r4�suv�a�jlg'mon2p'qsrat�d'e4uvraw'e4r��©ran2x�tq�m�raw�qa�2j�xGtsw'r4y�uvr{z|r4hvhvg�w~}?w'uv��rat�suvq���¿Å � jlz=}l§¹j�dG§}W �B§ �a� �®� � n2t4­ � W�W �/­

Ã�� ÄÕ� ­�¸,raty�rat�xGw'  � ­Bz´uvhvhvrat4� � � p'�sq§Ou�wG§Oqsu�m�r�h�x�w'y'p2xBy�r³m�g' 2r4hvu�w'y/�% �u�w#�$�%�&�'��� ��(*)��Bd'raxBqsqshvr���Ô � � � W�W5�2­Ã�� Ä � ­lÁFx�p7� � �  /x�n'qsuv��r¦�sq�xBqLu¤�LqsuveaxBh�h�x�w'y�p2xByGr´m�g' 2r4hvh¤u�w'y/� z�­ d7­&q�f'r4�suv�a� �©ran2xGtq�m�rawGqogBi{�&hvr4e4q�tuveaxBh

�,w'y�u�w'r4ratu�w'y xGw'  j±g�mon2p'qsrat?d'e4uvraw'e4r���z=xB�L��xBe4f�p'�sr4qLqs� � w'�Lqsuvq�p'qsrogBi�Å�r4e4f2w'g�hvg�y�����j�x�m��2tuv 2y�r��7z � �� W W �/­

Ã�� Ä d7­ ��­lj�f'raw½x�w'  � ­lÇ©g'g' /mox�w7� � � w�ramon'u�tuveaxBh]�sq�p' 2�!gBi¯��m�g�g�q_f'u�w'y�qsr4e4f2w'uvµKp'r4�¦iPg�toh�x�w'y'p2xBy�rm�g' 2r4hvu�w'y/�% �ÅFr4e4f7­ � ran7­/Å � § � �;§}W5�2� � x�t�Bx�t ~}?w'u¤�Grat�suvq��� � W�W5�®­

Ã-W Ä ��­ � x��Kw'r4��� � � wGiPg�tsmoxBqLu¤g'w=q�f'r4g't� xGw' ��sq�xBqsuv�sqLu¤eax�h±m�r4e[f2x�w'uve4�a� +�*�NP�Ì4Ð�� Ì ��Î �aÐ9Î$,�Ì4�&��g�hP­ � �5�®��n2n7­� � � � � �®� � W � �2­

à � � Ä � ­��{x�tst²g�e4f�x�w' �o­ � xBqse4hvu¼Â�� ��Ç©raw'ratsx�h¤u��4r4 |uvqsratsxBqLu¤�Gr{�seaxBhvu�w'y�iIg�t�hvg�yB§Ohvu�w'rax�t©m�g' 2r4hv�a�% ���Î-�IO O/È - ÌËg1��´È�Í��'Îj��È�ÍPÐ ��È - �¿ÍPÈ�ÍPÐ Ì[ÍPÐ �4Ì4�'��g�hP­X� � �Kn2n7­ � � ��� � � ���2� � W5� � ­

�2�

Page 24: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

à ���[Ä Á&­ � ­&¸lx�f'hP�"��­ � r4hvu�w'ra¥/��xGw'  � ­&Á&­�z|rate4rat4� � � moxB�'u�m¯p2m°hvu�¥Br4hvu�f'g�g' ½x�n2n2tg�xBe4f|qsg|e4g�wGqsu�w'p'g�p'���n®r4r4e[f|tr4e4gGy�w'uvqsuvg�w7�% �� � � �7ÏÈ�O2Ìj$FË O ��È�ÍPÍPÎ�Ï�O��IONÈ - P�Ì[Ð ÌÕÈ O /#�´È�� ��Ð�O/Î���ONÍPÎ -�- Ð�Î9O �_Îa�G��g�hP­ �N� z � §� �Nw'g/­ � �2n2n7­ � � W � W��®��z=x�t4­ � W5� � ­

à �a�;ÄE� ­���­K¸ltgB¢³w7� � ­¿j±g�e4¥Br��2d7­ � ­��©r4hvh�x � uvr4q�tsx2� ��­ � ­��©r4hvh�x � u¤r4q_tsx2����­ � r4h¤u�w'ra¥N� � ­ �o­/ÁFx�ÂFratq��� � ­7Á&­z|rate4rat4��x�w'  � ­Fd7­ � g'g��s�su�w7� � � �sq�xBqsuv�sqLu¤eax�h�x�n2n2tg�xBe4f¦qsg~moxBe4f'u�w'roq�tsxGw'�sh�xBqsuvg�w7�% ��Ë ��Ê+3�ÍPÈ�ÍPÐ9Ë�ONÈ -� Ð O N3'Ð�Ì4ÍPÐ �4Ì4���Gg�hP­ � �2�/w'g/­ � �/n2n7­���W � � � � p2w7­ � W�W��®­

à �a�;Ä z�­ �?ratsw'uvy�f2x�w7� ��­&j�f�p2t²e[f7��xGw' �Ô ­�Ç{xBhvr�� � � ��n®r4h¤hvu�w'y�e4g�tst²r4e4qsuvg�w�n2tg�y�tLx�m �2xB�Lr4  g�w�x¦w'g�uv�s�e4f2x�w2w'r4h�m�g' 2r4hP�% |u�w���ÏË �%$FËg1©Í���Î'���Ð9Ï_ÍPÎ�Î9O/Í�� ��O/ÍPÎ�Ï�ONÈ�ÍPÐ9Ë�O/È - ��Ë�O;1;$�Ë�O �,Ë���ÊQ3�ÍPÈGÍPÐÑË�ONÈ -�� Ð O N3'Ð�Ì4ÍPÐ �4Ì4�� W W��2�2n2n7­ � � � �2� �2­

à � � Ä ��­ � r4hvu�w'ra¥ÓxGw'  � ­lÁ&­,z´rat²e4rat4� � � w�qLratsn2g�h�xBqLr4 Yr4�sqsu�mox�qsuvg�w�gBi{z=x�tL¥BgB�=�sg�p2te4r|n2x�tsx�m�r4qsrat��iOtg�m��n2xGt�sr{ /x�q�x2�% =u�w ��ÏË �%$�Ëg1¯Í���Î � Ë�Ï ��Ì �'Ë_Ê Ë�O���È�ÍPÍPÎ�Ï�O ��Î���ËmNO/Ð9ÍPÐ9Ë�O~Ð�O���ÏÈ �aÍPÐ �_Îa� � m��sqsrat /x�m �/Å�f'r��r4q�f'rath�x�w' 2�j: ��g�tq�fG§ � g�hvh�x�w' F�/z=x�� � W ���2­

à �a�;ÄE� ­ ��­2¸�t²g;¢?w7��d7­ � ­ �©r4hvh�x � uvr4q�tLx2���¯­ � ­ �©r4h¤h�x � uvr4q�tsx2� � ­2j©­2ÁFxBuP�2x�w'  � ­2Á&­'z|rate4rat4� � � wor4�sqLu�m�xBqsrgBi�x�w¦p2n2n2rat?�2g�p2w' ¦iPg�tlq�f'r©rawGq�tg�nG�¡gBi*�,w'y�hvuv��f7�% ��Ë���ÊQ3'ÍPÈ�ÍPÐ9Ë�O/È - � Ð O N3'Ð�Ì4ÍPÐ �4Ì4����g�hP­ � �2�/w'g/­ � �/n2n7­�2� �N�2�'z=x�t4­ � W�W � ­

à � � Ä Å©­'j©­�¸,r4hvhP� � ­2Ço­�jlhvrax�t���2x�w'  � ­ � ­�Ô$uvqsqsraw7� �7Î;M;Í �,Ë���Ê¿ÏÎ4Ì_Ì[Ð9Ë�O/� � t²raw�qsuve4r � x�h¤hP�2��w'yGh¤r4¢lg'g� �jlhvu¼ÂF�a��]­ � ­�� � W�W��2­

à � � Ä d7­Bz�­��©xBq���� ���&�Lqsu�moxBqsuvg�w]gBi¿n2tg'�2x��'uvh¤uvqsuvr4�,iOtg�m$��n2xGt�srl /xBq�x±iIg'tFq�f'r,h�x�w'y�p2xBy�r�m�g' 2r4h2e4g�mon®g�w'rawGq�gBix��_n2r4r4e4f�tr4e4g�y�w'u��4rat4�% ��� � � �7Ï¹È O2Ìj$7Ë�O � �_Ë�3GÌ[ÍPÐ �4Ì �%�GÊKÎ_Î � �oÈ�O /��¿ÐNONÈ - �lÏ¹Ë ��Î Ì�Ì4Ð�O���B�Gg�hP­ � d2d � § �G� �w'g/­ � �/n2n7­X�N� � �N� � ��z=x�t4­ � W5� �2­

à � � Ä � ­ �©w'r4�srat�x�w'  � ­ ��r4��� � � m�n2tgB��r4  �2xBe4¥�u�w'yB§Og�ÂYiPg�t©m]§Oy�tsxGmÒh�x�w'y�p2xByGr�m�g' 2r4hvu�w'y/�% ¨u�w ��ÏË �7$lËg1Í���Î��� � � ��O/ÍPÎ�Ï�ONÈ�ÍPÐ9Ë�O/È - ��Ë�O;1;$lË O � ��Ë 3�Ì4ÍPÐ�� Ì � ��ÊKÎ_Î�� �=È�O / �¿ÐNO/È - ��ÏË ��Î Ì�Ì4Ð O �� � W W � ����g�hP­ � ��n2n7­� � � � � �N­

à � W Ä�� ­ ��r4����}]­&�&�s�sraw7�lx�w'  � ­ �©w'r4�srat4����¾©w��Lq�tsp'e4q�p2tu�w'y n2t²g��2x��'uvhvu¤�Lqsuve´ 2ran®raw' 2raw'e4r4��u�w��sqsg'e4f2xB�sqsuveh�x�w'y�p2x�y�r¯m�g' 2r4hvu�w'y/�% ��Ë���ÊQ3'ÍPÎaÏ ����Ê2Î�Î�� � �kÈ�O / � È�O N3'È��Î��'��g�hP­ �2�/n2n7­ � � �2� � W W �/­

à � � ÄE� ­�Ç©g'g' F� ��Å�f'r±n®g�n2p'h�xBqsuvg�w�i t²r4µKp'raw'e4uvr4�lgBi¿�_n2r4e4uvr4��x�w' �q�f'r�r4�sqsu�mox�qsuvg�w�gBiFn2g�n2p'h�xBqsuvg�w�n2x�tsx�m�r4qLrat�a�% � Ð9Ë���ÎaÍPÏ_Ð �BÈ��/�Gg�hP­X�N�2�2w'g/­ � x�w' #�/�2n2n7­ �G� � � � �/� � W ��� ­

à �2�[Ä ��­�Ô�­&j�f�p2t²e[f�x�w' �Ô ­ � ­&Ç{xBhvr�� � � e4g'mon2x�tuv�sg�wÀgBi³q_f'r¬raw2f2x�w'e4r4 $Ç©g'g� '§¹Å�p2tu�w'y xGw' � 2r4h¤r4qLr4 r4�sqLu�m�xBqsuvg�w|m�r4q�f'g' 2�?iIg't�r4�sqLu�m�xBqsu�w'y�n2t²g��2x��'uvhvu¤qLu¤r4��gBi��,w'y�hvuv��f=�'uvy�tsx�m��a�% �,Ë���ÊQ3�ÍPÎ�Ï�� ��ÊKÎ_Î�� �!��È�O /� È�O N3'È��Î��2��g�hP­ � �/n2n7­ � W � �/� � W W � ­

à ���;Ä d7­8��­¿j�f'raw7� �o­F¸,r4r_iIratsm�x�w7��x�w'  � ­ � g��srawGiPr4hv F� ���*�;xBh�p2xBqLu¤g'w=m�r4q�tuve4�EiIg�t�h�x�w'y�p2xByGr¬m�g' 2r4h¤���% �u�w� �&��� � � ÏËaÈ / ��È�Ì[Í � Î,�Ì �7Ï¹È O2Ì��aÏ_Ð Ê¿ÍPÐ9Ë�O�È�O /���O /�ÎaÏLÌ4ÍPÈ�O /�Ð�O� � Ë�Ï �aÌ ��Ë_Ê¿� � W�W5�2­

à ���;ÄE� ­�¸ltgB¢³w7�'d7­ �©r4hvh�x � uvr4q�tsx2� �¯­ �©r4hvh�x � uvr4q�tsx®� � ­Gz´rat²e4rat4� � ­ �?xB /xB�a�'x�w' ¬d7­ � g�p2¥Bg���� � � mox���u�m�p2mn®raw2xBhvu �4r4 ¦raw�q_tg�nG�{e4g�w'�sq_tsp'e4qsuvg�w�gBi¿e4g�w' 2uvqsuvg�w2x�h¿hvg�y�§Oh¤u�w'rax�t±h�xGw'y�p2xBy�r³xGw' oq�tsx�w'�Lh�x�qsuvg�wom�g' 2r4hv�±p'�Lu�w'yhvrax�tsw'r4 ¦iPraxBq�p2tr4��x�w' |x�y�raw'ratsx�h¤u��4r4 |e4�suv���ax�t�xBhvy�g�tuvq�f2m�� � wGqsratsw2xBh � ¸,z � ran2g�t²qa� � W�W � ­

à � � Ä � ­�Á�x�p7� � ­ � g��srawGiPr4h¤ F�©x�w' ½d7­ � g�p2¥BgG�a� � �  /x�n'qsuv��r|h�x�w'y�p2xByGr m�g� 2r4hvu�w'yÓp'�su�w'y�q�f'r=mox���u�m�p2mrawGq�tg�nG�´n2t²u�w'e4u�n'hvr��% u�w �lÏË �7$*Ëg1¬Í���Î �&��� � � Ë�Ï �aÌ ��Ë_ÊYË�O�� 3���È�O � È�O N3'È��Î �7Î�� �NONË - Ë=NPB� � W�W � �n2n7­ � �5� ���a� ­

���

Page 25: Jones-Chenjoneschen.org/spigdog/papers/h015j.pdfr4 'uvg p' ?¢ g'ts¥ g w¡ m g gq_f'u w'y q f'r4 Lr¯m g' 2r4hv a&Ô=r©hvuv sq?q f'r© 2r4 su tsx 'hvr¯n2t²g n2rat qLu¤r4 gBil

à ���;Ä d7­ �©r4h¤h�x � uvr4q�tsx{xGw'  �¯­ �©r4hvh�x � u¤r4q_tsx2�/��d'q�x�qsuv�sqsuveaxBh¿m�g� 2r4hvu�w'yo���omoxB�'u�m�p2m rawGq�tg'n����% �p2w2n2p2�'hvuv��f'r4 tran®g�tqa� � W�W � ­

à � � Ä � ­7ÁFx�p7� � ­ � gG�srawGiIr4hv F�Fx�w' |d7­ � g�p2¥Bg��a� �_Å�tuvy�yGrat«§¹�2xB�sr4 ¦h�xGw'y�p2xBy�r�m�g� 2r4hv�j: � moxB�'u�m¯p2m rawGq�tg�nG�x�n2n2t²g�xBe4f7�% =u�w �lÏ¹Ë �7$�Ëg1-��%� ���'� � (���� � n2t ­ � W�W � �Kn2n7­ �¹� � � �¹� � �2­

à � � Ä Ô�­ ��r4¢³moxGw7� ���*��qLraw'�suvg�w=qLg~q�f'r�moxB�'u�m¯p2m raw�q_tg�nG� m�r4q�f'g� F� �� � � �7ÏÈ�O®Ì;$*Ë�O���O�14Ë�ÏY��È�ÍPÐÑË O��'Î�Ë�ÏYPB�2��g�hP­ � Å,§ ��� �Nw'g/­ � �/n2n7­ ��W" W � � � x�w7­ � W5�5�2­

à � � Ä d7­ �©f�p' /xGw2n2p2t4� � � m�r4q�f'g� !gBi{moxB�'u�m�p2m rawGq�tg'n���r4�sqsu�moxBqLu¤g'w�¢�uvq�f!tr4h�xB��r4 $e4g�w'�Lq�tsxBu�wGqs�a�% u�w� ( (����2Ë��NO®Ì �©Ë_Ê �BÐ O®Ì ��O/Ð �aÎaÏLÌ4ÐÑÍ�P � È O�N3'È�'Î��´Ë0/GÎ - Ð O � Ë�Ï �aÌ ��Ë_Ê ��ÏË �%$��'jlraw�qLrat�iPg�t�ÁFxGw'y�p2xBy�r©x�w' d2n®r4r4e[f � t²g�e4r4�s�Lu�w'yN� � g�f2w'� � g'n2¥�u�w'�©}³w'uv��rat�Lu¤q���7¸lxBhvqsu�m�g�tr�� � W�W � ­

à � W Ä �o­ � ­�jE­Bz x�e �©xa�{xGw' ¬Á&­�j©­ � r4qsg/� � � f'uvratsx�te4f'uveaxBh �©u�tuve4f'hvr4q�h�x�w'y�p2xByGr³m�g' 2r4hI� � È�Í�3'Ï¹È - � È�O��3�È;�Î [O��Ð�O/Î_ÎaÏ_Ð�O���G��g�hP­ � �2w'g/­ � �/n2n7­ � � W2� � W�W � ­

à � � ÄÕ� ­ �?xB /xB�������*�sqsu�moxBqsuvg�w gBi�n2tg��2xG�'u¤hvuvqsuvr4�{u�w|q_f'r{h�x�w'y�p2xByGr¯m�g' 2r4h�g�i�q�f'r � ¸�z ��n®r4r4e[f|tr4e4g�y'w'u¤qLu¤g'w�s�'�sqsram �% � � � �7ÏÈ�O2Ìj$�Ë�O � ��Ë�3GÌ4ÍPÐ�� Ì � ��Ê2Î�Î�� �~È O /��7Ð-�O/È - ��ÏË ��Î Ì�Ì4Ð O ��2�Gg�hP­ � d2d � § ��� ��w'gN­��/�Fn2n7­� � W �5� � � � p'y/­ � W5� �/­

à �2�[Ä � ­lÁFx�ÂFratq��x�w' Ó¸?­�d2p2f2m ���_jlh�p'�sqsrat�r4�2n2x�w'�suvg�w'�~x�w' !uvqsratsxBqsuv��r¦�seaxBhvu�w'y�iIg'tomoxB�'u�m¯p2mÉrawGq�tg�nG�h�x�w'y�p2x�y�r~m�g' 2r4h¤���% u�w �|È%M;Ð��23N� �O/ÍPÏË_Ê+P´È O / � È�PBÎ4Ì4Ð9È�O �|ÎaÍ���Ë6/BÌ[� ��­ � x�w'�sg'w x�w'  � ­kd'uvhv��rat4��* 2�a­ �?h�p�¢lrat � eax� 2ram�uve � p2�'hvuv��f'rat��� � W�W � ­

à ���;Ä�� ­ �©p'e4ratsx�x�w' oÔ�­5�7tsx�w'e4uv�a���,Ë���ÊQ3�ÍPÈGÍPÐÑË�ONÈ - �IO/È - P�Ì4Ð�Ì�Ëg1���ÏÎ Ì[Î9O/Í � � È�P��I��ÎaÏ_Ð��_È�O# �O - Ð Ì ���7¸ltgB¢³w}?w'uv��rat�suvq� � tr4�L�a� � t²g;�'uv 2raw'e4r � ­ � ­�� � W5�5�2­

à ���;Ä � ­Nz�­/d'qsratsw7� �_d2n2r4e4u¼ª/eaxBqsuvg�w¦gBi&q�f'r � W�W ��� ���N� f�p2� � r4�BxBh�p2xBqsuvg�w+:�}?w'hvu�m�u¤qLr4 =��g'eax��2p'h�x�t� � � ¸w'r4¢��©�2xB�sr4hvu�w'r��% �u�w ��ÏË �7$�Ëg1{Í���Î � � � � � �GÊKÎ_Î � � ��Î��_Ë=NONÐÑÍPÐ9Ë�O � Ë�Ï ��Ì �'Ë_Ê¿� � W�W5�2�'n2n7­ � �®­

à � � ÄÕ� ­ � p' /w'uve[¥G���-� � p2� ��:&¸lp'�su�w'r4�s�³¸ltg'xB 2eaxB�sq ��r4¢��a�% ¦u�w ��ÏË �%$7Ëg1{Í���Î � �&��� ����Ê2Î�Î�� � �lÎ �_Ë=�O/Ð9ÍPÐÑË�O� Ë�Ï �aÌ ��Ë_Ê7� � W W5�2�2n2n7­ � �G� ­

à ���;Ä � ­FÇEg� 'iOtr4���F��­ � g�hvhvu�mox�w7�&x�w'  � ­7z|e �{x�w'uvr4hP� ��d'Ô � Å�j � ¸l¾ � � � :FÅ�r4hvran2f'g�w'ro��n®r4r4e[f e4g�tsn2p'�©iPg�ttr4�Lrax�te4f�x�w' ~ 2r4��r4hvg�n2m�raw�qa� =u�w ��ÏË �7$�Ëg1 �$� � ���'� ��(���� � W�W � ����gGhI­ � �/n2n7­ �2� � ��� �2­

à � � Ä Ô�­ � tr4�s�a�/¸?­X�&h�x�w2w'rat²���¿d7­/Å�rap2¥Bg�hv��¥G���7x�w' �Ô�­ �&r4qsqsrathvu�w'y/� � 3���ÎaÏ_Ð��_È - �lÎ ��Ð Ê2Î4Ì©Ð O����,j�x�m��2tuv 2y�r}?w'uv��rat�suvq� � tr4�L�a�/j�x�m��2tuv 2y�r�� � W5�5�2­

à � � Ä d7­ �©p'hvh��2xBe4¥/���YO�14Ë�Ï���È�ÍPÐ9Ë�O����Î_Ë�ÏYPoÈ�O / �7ÍPÈ�ÍPÐ�Ì4ÍPÐ �4Ì4��Ô$uvhvr4��� ��r4¢�&g�ts¥N� � W � W2­Ã � � Ä �o­F¸,r4r_iPratsmox�w7� � ­7¸,raty�rat4��x�w'  � ­FÁFx�ÂFratq��� � � m�g' 2r4h&gBilh¤r4�'uveaxBh�x�qsq�tsxBe4qLu¤g'w~x�w' =tran2p'hv�suvg�w7�% ·u�w

�lÏ¹Ë �7$�Ëg1�Í���Î � � � �'z x� /tuv F�/d2n2xBu�w7� � W�W5�2­

���