Kekuasaan Presiden: Suatu Sketsa Komparatif

5/17/2018 Kekuasaan Presiden: Suatu Sketsa Komparatif - slidepdf.com

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kekuasaan-presiden-suatu-sketsa-komparatif 1/3

6

Nbnfyffm Urbylgbm; Yfw Ynbwyf N`cufrfwlj 6

Frljgglm Afclg?

Ybofdfl ybofa rbuohln( ubrolmifmdfm cbmdbmfl nbnfyffm Urbylgbm Lmg`mbylf yfmdfwhfa ubrh

glhfnnfm- Ybhflm nfrbmf ubrfmm|f( urbylgbm kdf cbclhlnl n`cuhbnylwfy nbhbcofdffm gbmdfmhbcofdf#hbcofdf mbdfrf hflmm|f- Urbylgbm glulhla cbhfhl ubclhlafm cc |fmd glhfnnfmybifrf hfmdymd `hba rfn|fw ybalmddf ubrwfmddmdkftfofm hfmdymd nbufgf rfn|fw- Urbylgbm gl

Lmg`mbylf ybhflm ybofdfl nbufhf ubcbrlmwfafm kdf obrwlmgfn ybofdfl nbufhf mbdfrf- Ubrfm dfmgf

urbylgbm lmlhfa |fmd cbmkfglnfm ybdl#ybdl urfnwly ubmdfwrfmm|f cbrufnfm yfhfa yfw yoywfmylwbrubmwlmd gbc`nrfyl-

Gfhfc ubrnbcofmdfmm|f( Urbylgbm Lmg`mbylf cbcum|fl glmfclnfm|f ybmglrl- N`mywlwyl

ybofdfl uf|md anc obrmbdfrf cbmkfgl hfmgfyfm h`dly cbmdfuf glmfclnf wbrybow wbrkfgl-N`mybu urbylgbmylfh crml gfhfc n`mywlwyl urf fcfmgbcbm cbmkfglnfm nbnfyffm urbylgbm

cbmkfgl yfmdfw obyfr- Gfhfc ur`yby ubcofwfm mgfmd#mgfmd( urbylgbm obrubrfm ybofdfl

ubcflm wfcf( glyfculmd hbcofdf hbdlyhfwlj- Ofatf urbylgbm ybhfn ubcofw mgfmd#mgfmdgbmdfm ubrybwkfm GU_ cbconf ibhfa u`hlwln wbrkfglm|f n`ùwfyl- Obmwn n`ùwfyl lw

obrcfifc#cfifc( gfrl urfnwbn ubmcuhfm gf|f nrlwly ufrhbcbm( wlfgfm|f cbnfmlycb iabin

fmg ofhfmiby |fmd kbhfy( wbrcfyn alhfmdm|f jmdyl fyulrfyl gbtfm-

Ufgf {fcfm Urbylgbm Y`bafrw` !@rgb Ofr,( hbdlyhfwlj wlgfn cfcu cbmkfhfmnfm ubrfmm|f ybifrf

cfnylcfh( cfhfa ybnfgfr ifu ywbcubh ubcbrlmwfa- _bj`rcfyl ybofdfl yfw bua`rlf nbcglfm

cbmkmdnlrofhlnnfm wfwfmfm n`mybuwfh |fmd fgf- Fcfmgbcbm RRG 6<72 wbhfa cbmkfglnfm

nbnfyffm urbylgbm9

obrnrfmd( |fmd gbmdfm ybmglrlm|f obrwkfm ubmdfwfm ylywbc urbylgbmylfh-

Gfhfc n`mwbny lmlhfa ubcofafyfm cbmdbmfl n`mywbhfyl nbnfyffm urbylgbm cbmkfgl ubrh

glhfnnfm- Gfhfc nfklfm lml( ubmhly fnfm cbmddfcofrnfm ofdflcfmf glmfclnf n`mybuwfh

gfhfc RRG urf gfm ufyif fcfmgbcbm( ybrwf cbm|fklnfm tfifmf ofr ybuwfr ofdflcfmfcbm|lnful ubrgbofwfm wb`rlwln wbmwfmd ylywbc ubcbrlmwfafm-

U`wrbw Nbnfyffm

Urbylgbm _buohln Lmg`mbylf fgfhfa yfw#yfwm|f `rfmd |fmd cbclculm ybhra ubcbrlmwfafm-7

Afh lml obrfmdnfw gfrl jfnwf n`mybuwfh ofatf urbylgbm cbcum|fl nbtbmfmdfm mwn cbmdfwr

gfm cbhfnyfmfnfm jmdyl bnybnwlj- Mfcm wlgfn obrfrwl nbnfyffm urbylgbm cwhfn wfn wbrofwfy-Ubcofwfyfm `hba ubrfwrfm ubrmgfmd#mgfmdfm fgfhfa nbmlyif|ffm- Ubrm|fwffm ‘cbclculmybhra ubcbrlmwfafm– hbola nfrbmf obyfrm|f kfmdnffm nbnfyffm urbylgbm-

Gfhfc n`mywlwyl urf fcfmgbcbm( gfrl 94 ufyfh |fmd fgf( wbrgfufw hbola gfrl ybubrwldf ufyfh |fmdcbmdfwr nbnfyffm urbylgbm- Ubmdfwrfm nbnfyffm urbylgbm |fmd yfmdfw hfy lml cbmlcohnfm

kywljlnfyl hbdfh( ofatf RRG 6<72 yfmdfwhfa cbmlwlnobrfwnfm nbnfyffm bnybnwlj !bqbiwlzb

6Ufubr fnfgbcln cbmdrfl u`wrbw nbnfyffm urbylgbm gfhfc n`mywlwyl urf gfm ufyif fcfmgbcbm-

?Cfafylytf Jfnhwfy Anc RL Ur`drfc Nbnayyfm Ywgl Anc Wfwf Mbdfrf-

9Nbnfyffm glylml gfhfc n`mwbny ubcofwfm ubrfwrfm ubrmgfmd#mgfmdfm-

7Tlrk`m` Ur`gk`gln`r`( Fyfy#Fyfy Anc Wfwf Mbdfrf gl Lmg`mbylf( ibw-: !Kfnfrwf ; Glfm _fn|fw( 6<1<,( ahc- :5-



?

abfz|,- Ofanfm |fmd hbola cbcofw wbribmdfmd( nbwlnf obrhfn ufgf {fcfm @rgb Ofr( afculr

ybcf hbcofdf wbrwlmddl mbdfrf hflmm|f gfm hbcofdf#hbcofdf wlmddl mbdfrf ufgf tfnw lwglfwr gfhfc mgfmd#mgfmd wbrybmglrl- Afm|f hbcofdf nburbylgbmfmhfa |fmd wlgfn glfwr gfhfc

mgfmd#mgfmd wbrybmglrl- Nbwlfgffm ubmdfwrfm ufgf fnalrm|f cbhfalrnfm yfw wfjylr nfyf

cbmdbmfl ofdflcfmf ybafrym|f urbylgbm obrwlmgfn cbm|bhbmddfrfnfm ubcbrlmwfafm- Ufgf

fnalrm|f urbylgbm obrhlmgmd gl ofhln kofa n`mywlwyl |fmd glwfjylrnfmm|f ybmglrl-

Fcfmgbcbm RRG 6<72( gfrl chfl fcfmgbcbm ubrwfcf yfcufl nbbcufw nbcglfm cbhfalrnfm

afrfufm ofr wbrybhbmddfrfm|f wfwf nfyf |fmd hbola obrcfrwfofw- Ofm|fn ulafn obrubmgfufwwbrkfgl ubmdfwfm ylywbc urbylgbmylfh( tfhf kdf ofm|fn |fmd obrubmgfufw ybofhlnm|f ofatf

ubmdfwrfm ubcofwfm mgfmd#mgfmd obryfcf `hba urbylgbm gfm GU_ cbmkfglnfm n`mywlwyl

hbola cbmlwlnobrfwnfm nbnfyffm hbdlhfwlj !hbdlyhfwlzb abfz|,-

Ubmdfwfm hbcofdf nburbylgbmfm glgnmd `hba jfnwf2( ofatf ubclhlafm ybifrf hfmdymd

urbylgbm gfm tfnlh urbylgbm `hba rfn|fw cbmkfglnfm u`ylyl nbhbcofdffm urbylgbm hbola nfw

glofmglmd n`mywlwyl urf fcfmgbcbm- Ybifrf wb`rlwly( fnfm cbmkfglnfm nbnfyffm urbylgbm hbola

obrtloftf( mfcm wbwfu glftfyl- Ybhflm lw( fgfm|f mgfmd#mgfmd wbrybmglrl |fmd cbmdfwrcbnfmlycb ubclhlafm urbylgbm gfm tfnlh urbylgbm( ubmdfwrfm nbhbcofdffm GU_( CU_( GUG(

gfm GU_G( mgfmd#mgfmd ubclhlafm cc( |fmd ybifrf ybgbrafmf gfufw glnfwfnfm ufnbw

mgfmd#mgfmd u`hlwln cbmkfglnfm nbnfyffm urbylgbm wlgfnhfa ybnbrfcfw {fcfm @rgb Ofrgfah- Nbobrfmlfm cbmdmdnfu ybifrf wbrfmd wbmwfmd ofdflcfmf afrym|f urbylgbm glfwr

fgfhfa gfhfc rfmdnf ubmdfwfm ylywbc urbylgbmylfh-

Ubmdfwrfm Ur`drbylj

Fgfm|f nblmdlmfm mwn cbhfnnfm ubrofafm Rmgfmd#Rmgfmd Gfyfr ufgf afnlnfwm|f

cbrufnfm tkg gfrl nblmdlmfm mwn cbhfnnfm ubrofafm u`hlwln gfm nbwfwfmbdfrffm ybifrf

n`mywlwyl`mfh gfm gfcfl-

:

U`wrbw orfc nbnfyffm urbylgbm {fcfm @rgb Hfcf gfm !wbrwfcf,@rgb Ofr |fmd cbmlywf ubrfgfofm anc gfm gbc`nrfyl cbmkfgl hfmgfyfm obrlkwlafg-

Ubmdfwrfm |fmd ubrh fgfhfa nbmlyif|ffm gfhfc gbc`nrfyl- Gfhfc n`mwbny gbclnlfm(

nbnfyffm urbylgbm afryhfa cbmbcnfm obmwn ancm|f |fmd urfnwly( wbmwm|f gfhfc yfwmgfmd#mgfmd-

Gfhfc yfw mgfmd#mgfmd wbmwfmd hbcofdf nburbylgbmfm( j`ny ubry`fhfm wlgfn hfdl afm|fybuwfr fufnfa cbmdfmw urbylgbmylfh( vfyl urbylgbmylfh( fwf ufrhbcbmwbr- Mfcm hbola kfa(

glfwr cbmdbmfl ofdflcfmf ubmdfwrfm hbcofdf nburbylgbmfm gfhfc aomdfmm|f gbmdfm

hbcofdf mbdfrf#hbcofdf mbdfrf hflmm|f-

2Gfufw glhlafw glfmwfrfm|f fgfhfa !f,( nbufhf mbdfrf wlgfn obrwfmddmd kftfo nbufgf ufrhbcbm( cbhflmnfm

hfmdymd obrwfmddmd kftfo nbufgf rfn|fw |fmd cbclhlam|f> Hlafw Klch| Fyyalglvlb( Ubmdfmwfr Lhc Anc Wfwf

Mbdfrf !Klhlg LL,( !Kfnfrwf ; N`mywlwyl Ubry( ?55:, ( afh- 2<- !o,( ubm|ymfm obobrfuf mgfmd#mgfmd gl olgfmd

u`hlwln> Hlafw Yfw|f Frlmfmw`( ‘Hbcofdf Nburbylgbmfm gfhfc Ubryubnwlj Anc Wfwf Mbdfrf–( Cfkfhfa Jldr bglyl QL

!?554,; afh- 74-:Fyrh Afrm( ‘Nbggnfm gfm Nbnfyffm Urbylgbm _buohln Lmg`mbylf Ybobhc gfm Ybygfa Fcfmgbcbm

Rmgfmd#Rmgfmd Gfyfr 6<72(– ynrluyl !Gbu`n( Jfnhwfy Anc Rmlzbrylwfy Lmg`mbylf( ?55?,( afh- 6-



9

_clwm|f ubry`fhfm nbmbdfrffm afrl lml wbmwm|f cbmkfgl ubhbiw fgfm|f j`rchfyl |fmd hbola

rful- Ybkfacfmf urbylgbm cfcu cbcobgfnfm glrlm|f ybofdfl mbdfrftfm gfm u`hlwlyl(aomdfm nbrkf nbhbcofdffmm|f gbmdfm tfnlh urbylgbm( gfm ubrnfrf#ubrnfrf wbnmly hflmm|f

kywr cbmkfgl nbmgfhf wfcf gfhfc bjbnwlzlwfy ubm|bhbmddfrffm ubcbrlmwfafm-

Gfhfc uf|f cbcubrnfw ylywbc urbylgbmylfh( cbmkfgl hbola rdbmw cbcolmifmd cbnfmlycbwbnmly ubm|bhbmddfrffm nbnfyffm glofmglmd ubrgbofwfm wb`rlwln wbmwfmd ylywbc ubcbrlmwfafm

cfmf |fmd glufnfl- Frwlm|f( fuf |fmd ybnfrfmd cbmkfgl hfmgyifub u`hlwln anc Lmg`mbylf

ygfa ybtfkfrm|f glkfhfmnfm gbmdfm ùwlcfh- Ylywbc urbylgbmylfh fgfhfa cbcfmd onfm |fmdwbrofln( mfcm gbmdfm nrbfyl jfnwfh( gfufw cbmkfgl ubg`cfm ubm|bhbmddfrffm mbdfrf mwn

Lmg`mbylf |fmd hbola ofln-

Documents

Kekuasaan Presiden: Suatu Sketsa Komparatif