1
was a glint of madness in their eyes. And mtp"der etched across their faces. ' Ominous shouts and cries of 'Koi sardar hair Coli se maar dalenge' fol- lowed. We were all shocked into a state of stunned numbness. IIKOI SARDAR Weekly staffer Payal Singh describes the terror of a train journeyo.n November 1. We were a group of 20 Sikhs on our way to Delhi for a wedding. And when we boarded · the De- luxe from Calcutta at 10 am on October 31, ' we had never im- agined that death and destruction were in store for us. rationality, declared that women would be spared. But in what sense were they spared? After all, what can be more torturous for women than seeing male mem- bers of their famil v hacked to death in front of their eyes? The only sardars who were spared were the six with us. And all because of the concern and co-operation of the passengers in our coach. Before the train even halted at Ghaziabad, the hysteric- ul moo hud cuughtu glimpse of the six sardars with us, A fusil- lade of stones followed and the glass windows were smashed to bits. Shutters were hastily put down for proteGtion, The police, we were told. could not control the wild mob and so they just turned their backs and walked away. It was at 12.30 pm that we first heard that Mrs Gandhi had been . shot by her bodyguards and 'was , in hospital. Our instant reaction was one of disbelief. The con- firriled news of Mrs Gandhi's tragic assassination reached us over the radio at about 6.30 pm. And it was only then that we learnt that the two assailants were Sikhs . Every passenger irrespective of his religion was in a state of shocked silence. But not one had anticipated the disaster that awaited us at Ghaziabad . . The train reached Ghaziabad (two hours from Delhi) at 11 am the · next day. That was the beginning ' of two harrowing hours for' us, when we were sus- pended between life and death. A bloodthirsty mob, almost like a pack of hungry wolves hunting for prey, went from coach to coach in search of Sikhs. In a frenzy of madness, the mob, armed with iron rods and knives, brutally dragged out . Sikhs. burnt their turbans , hack- ed them to death and threw them across the tracks. Even the old and feeble were not spared. The barbaric mob, totally devoid of com mittees were formed, to defend the locali ty from outside rs.· At the individual level Sikh families were given shelter by Hindu. Muslim and other non·Sikh neighbours. That is whv in these localities, the casual i- ties' mostly resulted from attacks on individual Sikhs fo und on th e roads, in 11 fow lIppnr lind l1Iiddl" localities houses were identified. attacked and people killed in dacoi· ty- like opera ti ons; in some -o thers. Sikhs could not be saved fr om well· organised, frenzied, large mobs. The worst sufferers of the attacks were the poor in the resettlement colo nie s where the killers and 100- ters carried out the ir operations on November 1. 2 and 3. In these colonies, the mobs were led by the I lll:a I politicians and the criminal elements of the neighbourh ood. Wit· nesses describe how a mob wou'ld go frum house to IlLluse, call alit the names of each person and drag him down to be hit, doused with kerosene, and burnt. Thus, it was not outs iders but some neighbours who led the attacks, killed, and l. _ 1 _ _ oJ ..... '" .............. l lC t" Innt nr hurn . We had a ladies ' compartment and the other passengers in our coach. realising there was more trouble ahead suggested that the sardars in our group occupy it. At first, they were reluctant but we literally. forced them to' stay in- side. It was ironic. Sardars, who were historically known for their valoUr now had to protect them- selves by hiding in a ladies' coin- . parfment or else become· victims of 8 hysterical horde. Two ladies were sent into the 'ladies' com- partment so that they could answer if any questions were asked. The main doors of the coach However.among the poor Sikhs. the worst victims were those who were a little more prosperous as a result of employment in the Gulf countries. For instance in S ultanpuri , the scene of one of the worst carnages of the city, the blocks which were most seriously affected were A-4 and C-4 blocks which hO Il.,c;! Ilw relatively more prosperous among the Sikhs. Th e kind of 'engineered riot' that Delhi witnessed raises a number of political and moral issues: The first and the most important point to remember is that the victims of engineered riots are always sub- stitutable. Th e Sikhs were attacked in these riots by the machinery of terror that has been built up in the c it y. The goondas who did the kill- ing and looting were nol doing so beC<JUse :hey believed in a particular ideology or because they were reli- gious fanatics. They did so because the political bosses, who proVided them protection during no rmai times against the implementation of law, had ordered them to attack a particular group . Mrs Gandhi's death at most pravided a vag ue . were locked from inside. And we waited wlth bated breath. The mob, hell-bent on destruction. was not to 'be deterred. Then it began. They pounded on the heavy metal door for over 15 minutes. The incessatlt pounding was accompanied by threats to set the trai'n on fire. One non-Sikh passenger shifted uncomfortably in his seat and felt that all of them would lose their lives if the door was not opened. But he was stornly ' reprimanded by tho others who declared that under no circumstances would the door be opened. But the mob finally broke open the door. Their violent mutilation of the train had only whetted '. their appetite for more destruc- tion. The . savage mob stormed into our coach. And walked past the ladies' compartment. But before we could even sigh with relief, they turned around and deman- ded that the door of the ladies' compa . rtment be opened, so that they ' could check it. By now our nerves had reached breaking point Yet we Couldn't lose our composure lest they sus- pect that was amiss. . We tried to convince them that there were just women inside but the mob was adamant. And began to bang on the door. They seemed to grow suspicious at the sight of a number of women outside the ladies' compartment atld point- . justification to these criminal ele- ments for wha t they had to do in any case. We feel that it is perfectly within the world view of these politi- cians to engineer s imilar attacks on other groups, be they religious, ethnj c or political. What has hap - pened t0 the Sikhs and in the earlier riots to the Muslims can any day happen to South Indians, Marwaris, leftists, harijans. students or suppor- ters of opposition parti es. The mac hine has been built. It is only matter. of time before it finds new victims. Second, the law and order machinery in the capital of India was deliberately brought to a stand· still for 48 hours, when the police, the administration and the army did not know about the appropriate au· thorities from whom orders could be received. Ordinarily the state con- fronts violence from a section of the people with more violence. Yet, in spite of the tr eme ndolls increase in the coercive ap paratus of the Indian state in recent years, it re- mained silent and passive for three da ys while innocent citizens were ing towards us asked the passengers. "Are these women< travelling could baran eyelid, with us," came the The other passengers have been more The petrified screams of tht' ; two ladies from inside. our plllliB" and the persuasion of the ' othet· passengers finally seemed to COI.l- , vince the mob that there were no . sardars inside. And the mob re- treated. After two hours of ciating agony. we could almost : collapse' with sheer relief. , c. We hoped that conditionsJil : Delhi would be better. But no security arrangements had been made at the station. As a result, there were more than 500 sardars stranded. at the waitirig. room, while the women left the station to make arrangements for them. '1 left the station at 3 pm with the ladies in our group; while the sardars with us-who were the only ones on the train to survive the ghastly disaster-waited · at the station. They removed dead bodies from the train and assisted the injured. By Bp.m, we . were successful in making arrange- ments for them to be taken ouro! the station.. . In a state of stupefied silence, I saw bodies of sardars with rivulets of blood streaming down their faces, being unloaded from the train in which I had travelled. Brutally battered bodies cent Sikhs reached Dolhl ,from other incoming trains. as well .' In· nocent people who pad "(Jone nothing. Except for beiDg Sikhf and travelling towards Delhi OJ] that fateful day. '. < '" being ' systematically killed. since then the state has c1ai insufficient coercive power fo inaction. (Almost all police offi of Delhi accused of colla bora with rioters or of direct participa in the riot have pleaded that could not get reinforcements.) dp.nt ly. the fabulous increase ill size of the. 'law-enforcing force' recent years has diminished, increased, the security of the citi Third, the manner in which autonomy of institutions has i eroded can be witnessed in a ( such as this. Though even relat i low-level officials of the state legally permitted to declare CUI no one dared to do so in Delhi i) first two days of rioting bec their superiors did nol. W at is 'true of thl . and order mach is also tnle 0' public bro<fdc2 systems, worki) ar ms of the state. No.1 only wa an nounc ement of the death oj Gandhi' inordinately delayed ,

Koi Sardar Hai - Payal Singh Mohanka

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

The first person account titled "Koi Sardar Hai" by Payal Singh Mohanka was published in The Illustrated Weekly of India on December 23, 1984. In this report, Payal Singh throws light on the harrowing train journey that she undertook with her family from Calcutta to New Delhi on November 1, 1984.

Citation preview

Page 1: Koi Sardar Hai - Payal Singh Mohanka

~ere was a glint of madness in • their eyes. And mtp"der etched

across their faces. ' Ominous shouts and cries of 'Koi sardar hair Coli se maar dalenge' fol­lowed. We were all shocked into a state of stunned numbness.

IIKOI SARDAR HAI?~' Weekly staffer Payal Singh describes the terror of a train journeyo.n November 1.

We were a group of 20 Sikhs on our way to Delhi for a wedding. And when we boarded · the De­luxe from Calcutta at 10 am on October 31, ' we had never im­agined that death and destruction were in store for us.

rationality, declared that women would be spared. But in what sense were they spared? After all , what can be more torturous for women than seeing male mem­bers of their famil v hacked to death in front of their eyes?

The only sardars who were spared were the six with us. And all because of the concern and co-operation of the passengers in our coach. Before the train even halted at Ghaziabad, the hysteric­ul moo hud cuughtu glimpse of the six sardars with us, A fusil­lade of stones followed and the glass windows were smashed to bits. Shutters were hastily put down for proteGtion, The police, we were told. could not control the wild mob and so they just turned their backs and walked away.

It was at 12.30 pm that we first heard that Mrs Gandhi had been

. shot by her bodyguards and 'was , in hospital. Our instant reaction

was one of disbelief. The con­firriled news of Mrs Gandhi's tragic assassination reached us over the radio at about 6.30 pm. And it was only then that we learnt that the two assailants were Sikhs . Every passenger irrespective of his religion was in a state of shocked silence. But not one had anticipated the disaster that awaited us at Ghaziabad. .

The train reached Ghaziabad (two hours from Delhi) at 11 am the · next day. That was the beginning 'of two harrowing hours for ' us, when we were sus­pended between life and death. A bloodthirsty mob, almost like a pack of hungry wolves hunting for prey, went from coach to coach in search of Sikhs.

In a frenzy of madness, the mob, armed with iron rods and knives, brutally dragged out

. Sikhs. burnt their turbans, hack­ed them to death and threw them across the tracks. Even the old and feeble were not spared. The barbaric mob, totally devoid of

com mittees were formed, to defend the locali ty from outsiders. · At the individual level Sikh families were given shelter by Hindu. Muslim and other non·S ikh neighbours. That is whv in these locali ties , the casual i­ties' mostly resulted from attacks on individual Sikhs found on the roads, Ilo\vt! v l~r, in 11 fow lIppnr lind l1Iiddl" loca lities houses were identified. attacked and people killed in dacoi· ty- like operations; in some -o thers. Sikhs could not be saved from well· organised, frenzied, large mobs.

The worst sufferers of the attacks were the poor in the resettlement colonies where the killers and 100-

ters carried out their operations on November 1. 2 and 3. In these colonies , the mobs were led by the I lll:a I politicians and the cri minal elements of the neighbourhood. Wit· nesses describe how a mob wou'ld go frum house to IlLluse, call alit the names of each person and drag him down to be hit, doused with kerosene, and burnt. Thus, it was not outsiders but some neighbours who led the attacks, killed, and l. _ 1 _ _ oJ ..... '" .............. l lC t" Innt nr hurn .

We had a ladies ' compartment and the other passengers in our coach. realising there was more trouble ahead suggested that the sardars in our group occupy it. At first, they were reluctant but we literally. forced them to' stay in­side. It was ironic. Sardars, who were historically known for their valoUr now had to protect them­selves by hiding in a ladies' coin- . parfment or else become· victims of 8 hysterical horde. Two ladies were sent into the 'ladies' com­partment so that they could answer if any questions were asked.

The main doors of the coach

However.among the poor Sikhs. the worst victims were those who were a little more prosperous as a result of employment in the Gulf countries. For ins tance in Sultanpuri , the scene of one of the worst carnages of the city, the blocks which were most seriously affected were A-4 and C-4 blocks which hOIl., c;! Ilw relatively more prosperous among the Sikhs.

The kind of 'engineered riot' that Delhi witnessed raises a number of political and moral issues:

The first and the most important point to remember is that the victims of engineered riots are always sub­stitutable. The Sikhs were attacked in these riots by the machinery of terror that has been built up in the c ity. The goondas who did the kill­ing and looting were nol doing so beC<JUse :hey believed in a particular ideology or because they were reli­gious fanatics. They did so because the political bosses, who proVided them protection during normai times agains t the implementation of law, had ordered them to attack a particular group . Mrs Gandhi's death at most pravided a vague .

were locked from inside. And we waited wlth bated breath. The mob, hell-bent on destruction. was not to 'be deterred. Then it began. They pounded on the heavy metal door for over 15 minutes. The incessatlt pounding was accompanied by threats to set the trai'n on fire. One non-Sikh passenger shifted uncomfortably in his seat and felt that all of them would lose their lives if the door was not opened. But he was stornly ' reprimanded by tho others who declared that under no circumstances would the door be opened.

But the mob finally broke open the door. Their violent mutilation of the train had only whetted

'. their appetite for more destruc­tion.

The . savage mob stormed into our coach. And walked past the ladies' compartment. But before we could even sigh with relief, they turned around and deman­ded that the door of the ladies ' compa.rtment be opened, so that they 'could check it.

By now our nerves had reached breaking point Yet we Couldn't lose our composure lest they sus­pect that ~omething was amiss.

. We tried to convince them that there were just women inside but the mob was adamant. And began to bang on the door. They seemed to grow suspicious at the sight of a number of women outside the ladies' compartment atld point- .

justification to these criminal ele­ments for what they had to do in any case. We feel that it is perfectly within the world view of these politi­cians to engineer similar attacks on other groups, be they religious, ethnj c or political. What has hap­pened t0 the Sikhs and in the earlier riots to the Muslims can any day happen to South Indians, Marwaris, leftists , harijans. students or suppor­ters of opposition parti es . The machine has been built. It is only ~ matter. of time before it finds new victims.

Second, the law and order machinery in the capital of India was deliberately brought to a stand· still for 48 hours, when the police, the administration and the army did not know about the appropriate au· thorities from whom orders cou ld be received. Ordinarily the state con­fronts violence from a section of the people with more violence. Yet, in spite of the tremendolls increase in the coercive apparatus of the Indian state in recent years, it re­mained silent and passive for three days while innocent citizens were

ing towards us asked the oth~x: passengers. "Are these women< travelling alone?"And~·befo~.igl _ could baran eyelid, ~'No; th~Y:8rf!,'. with us," came the quicl(reply~ The other passengers coul.dil~t have been more co-opera~v';~~;H

The petrified screams of tht' ; two ladies from inside. our plllliB" and the persuasion of the ' othet· passengers finally seemed to COI.l- ,

vince the mob that there were no . sardars inside. And the mob re­treated. After two hours of excru~: ciating agony. we could almost : collapse' with sheer relief. , c. ~: ;:

We hoped that conditionsJil: Delhi would be better. But no security arrangements had been made at the station. As a result, there were more than 500 sardars stranded. at the waitirig. room, while the women left the station to make arrangements for them. '1 left the station at 3 pm with the ladies in our group; while the sardars with us-who were the only ones on the train to survive the ghastly disaster-waited · at the station. They removed dead bodies from the train and assisted the injured. By Bp.m, we . were successful in making arrange­ments for them to be taken ouro! the station.. .

In a state of stupefied silence, I saw bodies of sardars with rivulets of blood streaming down their faces, being unloaded from the train in which I had travelled. Brutally battered bodies of~nnp­cent Sikhs reached Dolhl , from other incoming trains. as well.' In· nocent people who pad "(Jone nothing. Except for beiDg Sikhf and travelling towards Delhi OJ]

that fateful day. '. <'"

being ' systematically killed . since then the sta te has c1ai insufficient coercive power fo inaction. (Almost all police offi of Delhi accused of colla bora with rioters or of direct participa in the riot have pleaded that co uld not get reinforcements.) dp.nt ly. the fabulous increase ill size of the. 'law-enforcing force ' recent years has diminished, increased, the security of the citi

Third, the manner in which autonomy of institutions has i eroded can be witnessed in a ( such as this . Though even relati low-level officials of the state legally permitted to declare CUI no one dared to do so in Delhi i) first two days of rioting bec thei r superiors did nol.

Wat is 'true of thl

. and order mach is also tnle 0 '

public bro<fdc2 systems, worki)

arms of the state. No.1 only wa an nouncement of the death oj Gandhi' inordinately delayed,