Upload
muri-takura
View
221
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
1/20
1
Dr KurtubiPERTAMINA Head Office, and
Center for Petroleum and Energy Economics Studies (CPEES)Jakarta, Indonesia
Phone: 62-21-471-8570 and 62-21-381-6825E-mail: [email protected] and [email protected]
Presented toThe 26 th Annual Conference of
International Association for Energy Economics (IAEE)Prague, Czech Republic
June 2003
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
2/20
2
Liberalization of Oil Industry in IndonesiaI. The Entry Point: Replacing Pertamina Law No.8/1971 with New Oil and
Gas Law No.22/2001: Mining Rights (Mining Authority) removed fromPertamina (State Oil Company), Natural Monopoly and vertically integrateddismantled, free market and full competition applied.
II. Besides some positive impacts, there will be some negative impacts on:1. the efficiency of petroleum fuels: the cost or price of
petroleum fuels at end users will be more expensivethan that of natural monopolist. Benchmark: market priceat the pump using: Untaxed retail Pump Price (URPP), and
2. the competitive advantage and the efficiency of Indonesian LNG industry will be harmful, i.e, security
of supply for the buyers, cost of money for developingLNG plants and facilities will be more expensive, and finally will hitthe competitiveness of Indonesian LNG .
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
3/20
3
I. BENCMARK OF EFFICIENCY:WHAT IS THE MARKET PRICEOF GASOLINE AT THE PUMP
STATION?:
SURVEY REPORT OFWORLD GASOLINE RETAIL PRICES
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
4/20
4
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
5/20
5
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
6/20
6
25.8% (US$0.30)
25.7% (US$0.30)23.5% (US$0.25)20.8% (US$0.22)24.9% (US$0.25)20.3% (US$0.21)26.1% (US$0.26)25.4% (US$0.24)28.3% (US$0.27)34.7% (US$0.31)25.8% (US$0.23)28.9% (US$0.26)41.3% (US$0.41)35.6% (US$0.26)70.0% (US$0.25)US$0.32US$0.24
74.2%
74.3%76.5%79.2%75.1%79.7%73.9%74.6%71.7%66.3%74.2%71.1%58.7%64.4%30.0%-Negative (Subsidy)
1.19
1.171.061.031.011.011.000.960.950.910.900.901.060.750.36-0.18
1. Norway
2. UK3. Finland4. Netherlands5. Denmark 6. France7. Italy8. Belgium9. Sweden10. Austria11. Germany12. Portugal13. Japan14. Luxembourg15. USAUntaxed Retail Pump Price (Average)Indonesia
Untaxed Retail PumpPrice in % and (US$)
Gasoline TaxComponent(%)
Taxed RetailPump Price(US$/Liter)
Country
Unleaded Gasoline Retail Price, Tax Component and Untaxed Retail Pump Price InOECD Countries, as of November 2000
Source: Fuel Prices and Vehicle Taxation by Gerhard P. Metschies, October 2002, Pertamina and OECD Publications.
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
7/20
7
II. COST OF PETROLEUMFUELS IN INDONESIA :
1. UNDER VERTICALLY INTEGRATED
SYSTEM (NATURAL MONOPOLYWITH BIG SIZE/economy of scale):18 cents (Zero subsidy)
2. UNDER UNBUNDLING SYSTEM(LIBERALIZED SYSTEM with smallersize): 24 cents
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
8/20
8
COMPARISON BETWEEN LIBERALIZED SYSTEM
AND VERTICALLY INTEGRATED SYSTEMOF DOWNSTREAM OIL INDUSTRY IN INDONESIA
Exploration&
ExploitationRefinery End Users
Storage/Wholeseller
Trans-Ports &Distribu
tion
Retail/Pump
Station
Crude Oil:International Price
New systemLaw No.22/2001:UnbundlingWith transactionCosts + Taxes
Old SystemLaw No.8/1971:VerticallyIntegrated System
Cost+
Profit
Cost
LLC LLC LLC LLC : separate limitedliability company
Cost+
Profit
Cost
Cost+
Profit
Cost
Cost+
Profit
PumpMargin
Market
Price= URPP
AverageTotalCost
URPP of Petroleum Fuels >> ATC of Petroleum Fuels24 Cents >> 18 Cents
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
9/20
9
Average Cost of Petroleum Fuels at End Users Throughout Indonesia(US Cent Dollar per Liter)
Fiscal Year Operating Cost(Controlled byPERTAMINA)
Crude Run Costs +Imported PetroleumFuels(Uncontrollable)
Total Cost of Petroleum fuels atend user
1994/19951995/19961996/1997
1997/19981998/199920002001
4.213.813.68
3.232.211.881.73
11.6212.4714.62
13.387.9616.5016.32
15.8316.2818.30
16.6110.1718.3818.05
Declining: The nature of Natural Monopolist
Mostly influencedby World Crude Oil price
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
10/20
10
MONOPOLY WI TH DECREASIN G M ARGI NALCOST: NATURAL M ONOPOLY
QuantityQm Q iQ i Q bepQ bep Q sQ s
P i
P s
Price
P m
P r
P m = Monopoly PriceP r = Zero SubsidyP s = Socially OptimumP i = International Price
LRAC
LRMC
D
International/Singapore Price
MR
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
11/20
11
Empirical Studies on Vertical Integration
Conducted by: Tasneem Chipty (Charles River Associates, Boston)
Vertical Integration, Market Foreclosure, and
Consumer Welfare in the Cable Television Industry
Conclusion:
Vertical integration does not harm, and may actually benefit,
consumers because of the associated efficiency gains
(The American Economic Review, June 2001, Vo. 91, No.3)
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
12/20
12
III.
The Impact Liberalization on IndonesianLNG industry
1. LNG Plant could be treated as a profit center, so every body
could enter this market. This will reduce State revenues fromLNG. Under vertically integrated system (old system), LNGplant was not a profit center in order to maximize revenues forboth the State and PSCs who hold risk in their upstreambusiness. In fact, LNG plant does not create any value added,because LNG will be re-gasified in consuming country
2. LNG Marketing is not under one roof because Pertamina willnot be a Mineral Rights holder. No Single Seller anymore: therewill be competition among Indonesian LNG. The possibleconsequence dealing to the security of supply for the buyers,the credibility of Pertamina in the World LNG industry and
Financiers.
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
13/20
13
Indonesian LNG Industry System based on Law No.8/1971Indonesian LNG Industry System based on Law No.8/1971
Gas Gas Field Field Development Development Gas Transmission
Gas Transmission LNG Cargoes LNG Cargoes Receiving Receiving Terimanl Terimanl
PSC PSC PERTAMINA:PERTAMINA:Single Seller.Single Seller.
Project Financing Project Financing Requirement Requirement
Third Parties Third Parties LNG Buyers LNG Buyers
TRUSTEE TRUSTEE PAYING AGENT,PAYING AGENT,
New York New York
Bank Bank Syndicates Syndicates
LNG Plant LNG Plant
Arus Arus Pembayaran Pembayaran LNG:LNG: Arus Arus Investasi Investasi ::Pembentukan Pembentukan Trustee:Trustee:
FOB Price= A
CIF PriceLiquefiction Cost= X
Piping Cost= Y
E & P Cost (PSC)= Z
LNG Revenues = A (X + Y + Z)GOI: 65% - 70%PSC: 30% - 36%
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
14/20
14
5.637 839 1.058 3.738 2002
6.825 837 1.475 4.512 2000
3.856 329 850 2.677 1995
4.048 159 4913.397 1990
3.801- - 3.8011985
2.327 - - 2.327 1980
80 - - 80 1977
Total Taiwan Korea Japan Year
LNG Export (US$ Million)
Note: Export to Korea and Taiwan started in 1986 and 1990 with the value of US$14 million and US$159 million respectively
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
15/20
15
IV.The Future of
Indonesian Oil Industry: Still Optimistic
1. High Potential of Hydrocarbon Resources
2. Long experience with International OilCompanies
3. Initiator of Production Sharing Contracts: havegiven big benefit to the State.
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
16/20
16
HYDROCARBON RESOURCES ININDONESIA
I. BASINS:
II. RESOURCES (1.1.2000) :
III. PROVEN AND POTENTIAL
RESERVES (1.1.2000) :
IV. PRODUCTION (2000) :
60
EXPLORED : 38
NOT YET EXPLORED : 22
14 PRODUCTION
9 DISCOVERED15 NO DISCOVERY
OIL : 77 BILLION BARELS
GAS : 332 TRILLIUN CUBIC FEET (TCF)
OIL : 5,11 + (1,82 + 2,74) = 9,67 BILLION BARELS
GAS : 80,83 + (36,39 + 29,70) = 146,92 TCF
GAS : 2,26 TCF
OIL : 0,48 BILLION BARELS
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
17/20
17
PRODUCTION SHARING CONTRACTORS
A. P A R T I C I P A N T S : 60 OPERATOR S INCLUDING 5 SUPERMAJORS (EXXONMOBIL, CHEVRON TEXACO, BP AMOCO ARCO, TOTALFINA ELF, SHELL) . MAJORS (CONOCO, REPSOL, UNOCAL,SANTA FE, GULF, PREMIER, LASMO, INPEX, JAPEX, DLL.)AND INDEPENDENTS.
B. WORKING AREAS - 160 :PRODUCERS : 57 (12 SUPERMAJORS, 15 MAJORSDAN 30 INDEPENDENTS)
EXPLORATION : 103 (19 SUPERMAJORS, 32 MAJORSDAN 52 INDEPENDENTS)
C. RESERVES (1.1.01) - OIL :
D. PRODUKSI (2000) - OIL :
E. PENDAPATAN (REVENUE)
SUPERMAJORS (70 %), MAJORS(18 %), INDEPENDENTS (12%)- G A S : SUPERMAYORS (80 %), MAYORS(15 %), INDEPENDENTS ( 5%)
SUPERMAJORS (68 %), MAJORS (28 %), INDEPENDENTS ( 4%)- G A S : SUPERMAYORS (82 %), MAYORS (15 %), INDEPENDENTS ( 3%)
(1966 s/d 2000) : GROSS REVENUE : US $ 348,- BILLION (100 %)= COST RECOVERY . : US $ 69,- BILLION ( 20 %)= NET CONTRACTOR SHARE ... .. : US $ 48,- BILLION ( 14 %)= INDONESIA SHARE ... : US $ 231,- BILLION ( 66 %)
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
18/20
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
19/20
8/6/2019 Makalah Kurtubi
20/20
20
Conclusions:1. Applying liberalization and privatization in the oil industrysector in Indonesia will bring some consequences on theefficiency of the industry. It is important to look for thestrategy to implement the program without sacrifice theefficiency.
2. In the long run, petroleum fuel pricing policy in Indonesia,
should be integrated with both primary and final energypricing policies.3. Before applying gasoline tax, it needs to increase price
gradually by considering purchasing power of the people and
market structure.4. In order to avoid any disadvantages, such as in the domestic
petroleum fuels and LNG industries in Indonesia, the NewLaw on Oil and Gas should be opened to be amended.