185
" iUftI' '- , ",,' ",2\<£),. .;. - , . . . ,Gli _ '" o• •• II ,'A" ,At, PO,' ttL .. " O'ftE iB-QJ1IJtSftUT8 roB SIDmDE 01' OOaf' OF 'SrLOSOPIY ax 'JlALPII II. '4. ( uat .... lt' ot K1Dae .. _).'b. L. (LaYal UDi •••• '.,) - . '.,. A. v.

McInerny

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

yo

Citation preview

  • " iUftI' '- ~ , ",,' ",2\

  • 1. ror\_ , a.usa ao014.M 1ft: !11aq~i. fl\St8 .. UD4Ufl propoal;tma propter t1nea 1,n alne:rl ",e.

    2. 1\.l81il1ila, lqM118 ~ Y'ir'us ~111e 'J):ti.rretlta. ). 1~rlDo1p1a 8111os1amorUtiper'feot0r11118UI:lt (luo,

    "111e.' 4101,4. OIUl1. at 41014. nullo. 4. :',. ,rooe4enl!,11,.D 4;o.ra8"ratlvla t r o-

    luwrlu. ,. P(811)10 Carll ,11 ,. &oQ,tl1s1~loa.\fl,rtut1.'

    I1Ore118 0011,\"4101" Y8rl'.' .. quett yl:r' .. .. mi.f1ti. eoa (1)udiae.

    . ...

  • 1. ~N.th

    pqe

    1

    ? 1. 2.,.1 8Dl'rovldeaoe 1 I. _. 1.' 'S81 178' IIJ,pO lbl.. II ,. aoueh- aJltt It.s;1atefioe ...................... 26

    III. D.

    ,Aft *fWO, COMm1t1ICAT' '} "hap ...

    I. ~1 1 o. 1. ,.A ttt.,10 " ....................... . I. ...... . a'h1 1Sphe.. ....................... . ,. 4Cr1'\\leal Note

    )9 64

    89 90

    " 99 1'%.. ,~. !.file ftel1g1otll ............... .,........ .105

    Ill. 'a1'_ 8D4tbe A"I\I1'4 1. I. ,.

    1011 of HU4en,lDwarbell . ......... ~ .........

    'ree ~

    'Alf ft8. . I D1UDUTIOII or 1lIDlllBC'f COMMUNICATIOH C ,

    I.

    '114

    115 119 11,

    1

  • lX. Conolutl.S.-J7 137

    IOTIS ................................................ 152 III' ................................. 170-

    - -.

    ..'

  • P' ..... .: .... ','1'4.' , ~ , - ". - .

    A. q.1" ..... 1. p.ae4 ... ' ..... . ......... ' 1 ..... 114 ... .. bli_,. ,4 ..... 1"' ....... , lD - '. ~l~ . ~O.1J_41.1 1

    &11 opl.1 .... ,...M"'l't ..... ~

    AltllouP ,. t. ,Be p..,.. POle ot .184 .. ,. 01'1... .beN i an .1 ... wit ........ wl ......... pau 8Il4 oOD.i4 ...

    '-.'M. lapo._ 0"4 .... ' DO' . ..a 18. 41.'01"108 ot tbe pro'bl.,. a. h&DA,.I ..... 1. 'hla ., .. , ..... , ... beD ,. 4,1 ... 1ple ot I 'Illoaa. (wl'h at 1 .... a 'Dorrowe4 ,,184011) __hi, ,." .. '108 to .he 'bo\lIll' aa4 '.,.'e.. of ao481'11 pt.!,l ... ,.,:.. la 'b ....... ' of _k 'P"\tl.' arKl balt-tl'Uthll _loll MY. t 1_ ,. .... t l"~'l .. t. pbllo.opn,loal .. ta. _ .., ..... 1,- ..,111 .., aM pe, ... ,.,l'b 11.f ,. flO ... .... l'4las tle14.. It II .0 lJ. ao'e4 .. , fRIO. a reao'loa 1 .. , 11' ... , .... 1.'. ,n. pa." tbe t .. th1. Sit "17

    - ,

    ._11 ........ ,. ' . J' .t 1\1_.17. aere 1,a, ho ........ 80 ... .... b1.81"',..'1... .-" ... pllll.'MPhf 1. 81ap17 a tao, .. 4 ,

    l' ott .... 1II1tl , , qlM.'l ... _ A.Qt. R10b the , ...... 1 .... or ,,184 will , .. 1 1ae .... l' 'APawla& hi., he will _ . Oh&11 ___ IO:}l btl _, ...... to. r ...... 10 ,. b1.

    ea11iq. I' 1e tor __ ... 'ha' tlle p 1 .. tor1 '1081 .. '804 1 ....

  • -11 .

    IF 1.111 ... .f P"".'l~ tl\e ..... ,t ,he tol1ow-,

    '- ..,.t Kl .... ...a l\ee fa ...... wha' , ...... pa-ob-1 ...... 1f01I14 ... &4 ......... pllilolO'.... _1 .. t, ... ft. '0 ......... ,. ".f DaDl." ''', wlth "bat .t A. :"'., Wllraa .. la' a ........ \)7 -bleh he ..-14 .......... " Xl .. _tJ86P4 f .... 'h. 11&, ae.e.a1

    ,- ......... ..4 'be tla4lD.1 .f .wa, ,. 0U'I7 .. , 'hl. plAII ......... _Ik ...... ' 1&.4 UpoII, '8 tao, ..... 18 ... .. l ...... t 11._111'1 8&. __ ... -.111_ .. "' ... ,. aplaa' 1'. BIt. let ...... lae. t t '-he pe 'lJl ..,.. of o ..,1D& 011' .... ... a. to ..... ,la" .. .tittloal" , ... 84.

    IIle .. ltlas- of uW.,...a p ..... ' ""II. pe.' a ., 41.,. -. p .. bl....0\W1 ... 1' ,_.,' ... Goula 0: ..... a_ ... __ 18 ........ , .......... f .he. 1a '.10' .. 1 .. 'ltl. _..... '. WfJUlA .. a ........ , &D4 tl'\al'tul .. ft, ., 1'\ 18 'tN'tI,tul ,., tt 001114 pa IM'-' ...... 1. "'" .t .... ,.,..a .. '" .t .... prottl aM .,.oull .. SO Ill.. ftwI.. ... WO\lld .... ,. 1M ltllle4 , ..... _, of al p .... l: wl'k l1Iel4. W .. t .... 08 1t1.-"8-

    , -.

    ... ..Ia.;, ........... aGal wou14 ... b abaD4oatMl . ,'

    ao,." pes.l11111,,, _14 14 la 'e' ' lRl' 1. 110 tOl-.14-a'D1e: -___ 11401111 'JuI' l' ... 14 e.e .. ax _. plWltloal 1-,_1 ., a 408 .... 1 41 .... '.'1... I' eCN14 u. the tOPli . ., 8ft sa llaea ....... , .. , ..... b .t Kl " Jt4 t. work t,M 1 1 .... t1, 1 .... 1le4 toU..-l _, a, . .,.... 1D ,_ '. ' .. ah8e., qU8II'1', ot 'hell.rke,..P41an out-

  • - ill ..

    ,

    ",." . 10.'" .. 1 ... 1oa" 11148 .... , ... t ,_ work .... _____ OIl sa 'M. ....... 'fbla

    la 4eIlleA to ....... -...1 to .8' 11 I1....,.laa 11t-........... , ot , ____ ....... ,lIe4',. p_ ..,.. 4 40 .. , ,..,.. . . . '* of, &l k.~. A' 'hi. POD' we .. '-1111. laaa .. , . , baekwar& ~ at 0tW .011 ...... el .. ,..s to tpo .. ,be ._.... ADA ,., WbeN '8 a , ibUt,,, .f aebl _ 'be aeal .. ,

    Kkrll N ..... 1. )11 ... , ___ '-he We4 , .f ..... . : .... , .. 1. of ,.". ...... Il va ....... ,. _"h .. he other.

    ia ... k ..... te '"' ..... &.1 81,... 'ftfa ,..-10111 .. utlBl .t .-ok .. JIlt ..... ll .h , .... '.'.W 1'. _ha .. , ,' " a1'- ..1 .. Bleil -l .. lI. . ... _H4 'he .. atI '0 ... :. It 1. p".1 .. 1~ '111. b __ .,.att .... whlob 1 ... h0s-t. tlle po l"ttl'" ot .. tat.17 G .... b: ... 1WJ .-1111.-. to. 1t we ea. 11114 .... _.al .... PllDft_ b~ '.be" k ... wod4 ..... e' .. polat at 'acaun-loh wou14 ........ 1 lie .. ., ...... 'i ot _ ... 1 v. t'lMINoh a 1mreaA lathe

    .. " .. ' .t lMl .... o __ i .. " ... a .. 8ha11.......~ la.i.," ' __ What a pePHD

    . - .

    ow. 1. lIIl1.,. .... ,. t". t'18 .vae a.~; hAt &lakel hla _., .. la.as., , ." latl ....... 'loa 1ft _elt a .., , ".l'ewou14 1M) allli_ of :foo4 to. 'h01l8btln w.' he _41. __ ,_ita 10818&117 lab,l. ,..011 .. 1i04. ot oo_loa-t:loa.%' 1:8 J:~.Jfk.p.l'4bl ... ltt ........ ,Wh. ____ 1

    ... .. 101ll 1 ........ ' Ida ....... of esprha1GD.

  • -1 ...

    ,

    Dl. 1I04.0t 00 __ lca.1ea.10b Kl kepa1'4 oaU. bl41reo' 18 ,. tl ' aa4 alai 'lttled', ill tm4 Mm4l11a wha. be ._ .. 1', ... '_MUla .7 .r 1I1 ... 1f t -1_1 ... " 00_1.a-tl ..... ., t-.1 Cl\taut1 .. 1;1 ... ' 884 hct _.,10", 1. w1'" _.-t ..... , WIll.h .1. a1 ..... '.1" ... 1_ ana e"lIP8rat11c.

    It ... ..'el1 .. 14 , ... , .... ,.~t of I:l ... keput4 baa lI_ .... 8".,., .. t1 .. 117 tpe..a (althOUIb eo,' OO_D,.tOI'8

    '. ,., . lip ....n.. .. 1', 'l1aa 1*'1 ... , ...... l 'leu. It 1. _he ... II,b.", ... b Itt.: .. '

    weN tlper ... 4 1 t ...... 4 .. ,.,10 .,0, 10 ... b tl_ \he 0. .......... 41tt ..... ... Ir he 11I ___ to PM'NIl' w,th_the . ,. ....... aDd. tbere a ... _, ... te. . It 1. to. 'bi-....... ,._ we ... , __ '1 ... b ."S-1 __ 1D1 '0 11ene-paN ,_ .81'1".,081'1 p ..... ., ,. hi ..." booke

    . 'c'. 118u..4, ... , Ill.' _ UIiti to04 betoN all el .. "" ,he .. '

    _.h weN .he 41tt10\11'1 wh1." lIItlue1lH4 the IN-l .. ' UC1 e.,. ot .be to11 .. 1_ .'fl"., Aa4..18.e ... r,. oholoe .. tall .... 1"81 .. , 1 t 'le .. 'aurprla_ tha' ou... ....ltloe. 81 _'. wblob ...... , ........ _ 'Dr 'hell' ."'...... sal 1

  • -

    ell' . '._18 tbe alllO.' to 1 la.1e of .. 8.1e.t1rla ft~~lft -'i.4\tM' lDour ddF .oPel.r tollew.a I,. sbA' of 1.1 11-

    ............... ".~ and 1'- 40el aot pJ'O ... 4 ,... 'h~ more_own '0 ua to ,he le.. DO", except 1a ,_ HIlS. 'bat ,1\. M1.to 17 t),Q ale. lqo1ala. to be 110.. lmowa.fte .ery ..... of &lenepar4t. end p elu4a4 thl. ft.'ural. :ppoo., , to!' he ...

    Dot. 80 he thoupt, p ... cm'~t1t a 40etrlaet hi. -Jot" lntent .... to 180.8 'be 11111 anlrtt he o0tl14 oapl11b tht:1 by epee-alatlYe ~1l:t" 1.h he 4iel DOt a l' ... '0 4.0 80. A 4t.,1ao-tlOB 11 oa11e4 to. If . "ell \0 ,..'lt1 OU. 0tII1 laok of 01'4

    Bet ... II 40(1).18.,1 , .. _ta'l .. of tl\tt.ll atteapM4. 0 .. flU8,.ualBe 1)heub' 1 .... , to It,- .tor -,ul debet au-41 .. phllo.. 181, .. 11"8 .. haH .. 1ft ludloc40 81 a,,41.l'lt

    . O1ItHta 1' 1__ qu 1 .4ve"aa.lorua 4.12'1 "'1 .... '.. ftaa. the J)POpa,14eutlo,ott ),7 a 41, "utatl98 all" dlal tical 00;0814-e .. ttoap1aY8 1m Btl.1.&1. m _he ' oblDc of tJ-Uth arut I tb.. 8tu41 of WU*loua ph1lo.o,hara 1. tbe b , .... e of brllll-1Da 'hl. 41al.,.t10 lato pl81. Gtt a at\l41 .baul4 Dot be a , 08.all cr.., ... , 18 top al, 1 )'MPpO J it 1.' DO' aft e1l4 1n 1 ... 1t ( 'he 'houp. ot M1phl1olopl1e. 1. 1m-))o"aa, .. l, 1. 'he 4' .' .. that l' ".tap UI '0 the tNth)

    . ,'

    torett.JmdaJPe OUJ' a4 ...... 1ea. Iaoh 'blue .. baa .. 00.,.lb1lt1.11 to matce,em4 l' ls t1"_ ,bat we ugftl'etul to each ot tile., .".n' no ~lY. U8 fIOre .pro. 'han, trtl'b.' Theretore. &1-thouCh 'hi. MU4, ot li It.pard 1. !lOt ..018.t1t10 'PNND" 'loa ot , ....... l' 1. erde a '0 _ell a pr D~.tlOD. The

  • ..

    Oft'lque8 81ob; MY ealD .. ptet 81\11 .. lDteM'al . , " ' ... 8.0' 1.",*,e4 ,. take the plao. of ,bat "' .... woPltJ ""I" 'he, ..... to .. 1.'. ,_ Kl ke.

    10 lI\teh ,...,.10". ..... M.. n14. al\o\ll4 ".'b 1fU'D. 'h ... d _1 ' ld., ,more 'MD. 18 o,oate.;lJle4 1ft 'h. 8\1" 41""', ' f au(l lD41oa.. that the a"ther ... ..... or thelP1 tro., "le.'ltl0 Yl .,.1Bl.

    The .. , ... , it 1t fall, ' ,..,.. The tip., p .... -

    ..... 1.a pae.al w., ttl. 'Mo., of lll4Sreot e,o_loat-loa, at ~ ..., a_rte. 'a., 'we 1e bJtl.t _, eoap .... hen.ly. ',... of Xl.,. ." t. 11 of b1 ... 'bOd. TIle ti-Dal pap, ooa81c! ,be ,IlIme'. la' 1',*418'1 .. or IDdl .. eo' . a_loatlea,.18 Pea... t.. 401ac 8114 .he 11,,110at1011. \lb.l. haa top h18 weft.

    "0111'. *18 .". .,..1.1 1 ...... ' 18 11erke,aa'" ... hla .. '88"'''' ot,,. .. l.'l ,,,.. .'. h.le 4.tlal't . ot t.1,11 111 ..... of a'blNl'tlltF ... hl_ G aq"eatatim4 'ha' tneoloar 18 . .1M111 .... 'aa4bS. ,.... .. 4oo'.1It.. ,,,1'. 18 Ire.plac

    . .,1.11 b,l. yol1111 __ .l.t.lo --,1 , ad Vb h.. ae.'1 ... ap. pea .. to 4eB7 Ill. 4.mla18. we ... ,,. ... e. 'a' .. 1

    . . --,

    .... , ..-poet ....... lui til .... ee4 lD 'IM1'18 alli .... '1-. , tal"", 11 .. ' 41el-" lit pro bl. 91llpPl.' .

    \

  • ..

    " OJr IIDIll

    .....

    ,

    ,

  • ..

    '., V, ' .... 4,., 1'4.- ... well Gal.ula" '0 la410ate 'bal .... _~cl. to ....... 1,4 ... '.lal, tall .llO~ of_1',. ~ it trcJ1'4a ,.Glrler 'h' '" .... 1\.bla -thlm . Mlr 'ttJU'. real-1*. -- .~/.6 .. * .. 6_.Jt ',., ~~ V~flI' jr_ : ......

    \

    ,.w '" .... 8t 101\ etaD4. to. ocaee.,.1oaa, aDd ,ttl OMte 'be .. -laD .,.. bi.

    "., 'he .. 1' 1M.' .. , .. 'ne hl."o., wbloh haa ao-"'84 '0 'll par.i.til,..'::, ... ,.t lette... AD4, ,et. brOW .. .... 1 & OIl. poD4 ,., be - , tU1el1, aooep' the taot

    ,,'

    ' t. woplMa, 1\6y 1'8.1, .... DS. _ 'b.' tbeH 11 '811 .1 .... ' of 1'181 hi, aD, OMloe. ~. tittl.ttl', lhl'o a oor-

    ,..potl4~q 1ftlNcm of ".fIOR8lltill_, Oft t .. "a4oPI 1t talls '0 hl. '0 a_urel.. .., ',bo ... 'h.. sea., 'Dl,8 WOl'48 toCOft.8,. Vlth tlkl. la"" 1., U8 lou .at a wor4 Bloh .le. p.naps,

    ,

  • ~~--~--~--------------- ----- ~-

    '. I.

    , .al. .xl ..... !'

  • " e.t.'1a(I .'; 1.14ua1 1 .... 4ri.e.. fM' la-,. ear. lle ' .... b a 4.,1".. whe. ill ...... of eal .. t , aD 8..1 __ .e 100 .. 1, .. eaUH, t .. tMD he 1e Be'. arl... ..'a 4,PUBkeD, ,pe .... , 1$0, 1 .. ,l1'.a. 'wAICD tm4 lat.'8 ,be fto tM .... of th .... l.... To be ...... a.MII , " _ .... 'he:" are ,.,-p. _, .aA ~. .. "_ " :V'

    "hat be:, .... Miq .. 4--bS.!. _ eN" to _. Uld tihe ,

    ...... 1, t.o'o. of _. It.l'erlc' ,41,~ ~b,11o.o'P-h1, liD l' 1 1 ...... 1alla pt'eel 1r 'b'_ ... e., 'a 'h..ot,lGa of _oral t

    \\00 Matily aa4 OIl t .... ttl.1 ' lUft08, ... , BOW 'that

    ,tte.olep._.ORr80UG 11' ...... '!'e.'. ot wb1\taH"alled '. 1_ . 81 -.,0.1 < 110.14-.1.... 8,8t....' Yalua,. ill _rae or _lob 11 ......... "JK),al'e4. he -.x,1ete.'181

    ,

    a4n. ... , 'Aa4 all.t~hll ~J, 4,1 .. ot.4'0 .. 114. 'tn. loa1 ot IftOW'wha" l' _ tio' a.oept; ... 1 lou:. 11048 of ex18tcmoe, boW oba.tequa,11tt ,. ao'.ot Ihela41'Y14ual. ae. oaua. 'h18 18 8., out' ooaolualOD, 'bO\lii1 1"1, 1. Dot thoqbt-1 \le:1Bl , 80" 0D1J' eli tbe l1Dei jua'

  • .. It ... '

    'be .... t1\ It A qulok. 'p ..... 1 ot .... of tne.e text. 11111 Hrye \)o'hto Ju.',1t, 1,1 k."., " tau" ,an4 '0 uke oleaHfl tbe ,41atlDotlOli lDyol,,.o4.'

    J , bel 18 e.14 'ltoth.r .ub .... ,tial ct aoo1dat\ul

    \tel' , 8.0 too 18 "n. 110 _1t. ftot oal, or ablolu ,004n ,., .'of' .lbl~ 18 a ...... OUD4UII qu,S.,1 .:,. .. 11.lut tbepe 18a

    ,', ,t 41ft.HIt be" .... 'ile.. '110 d1vl.10n8. !tJo_thlDI~ 1. ,M14'o be, sla.p11, 'luUike .. lta"ltall'lal be1ngJ but; a

    tbl_ 1e 8.14 '0 lte \Ift". q\l14M.attl. ot the accldent,. wblob; eoortleto ,1t_ S.o .. t la, 1-11 the ,.'b.ol~l'. "n or "he '.'ra t beeau r h18wba, tlal t ... , 1\8 18 wb1'. because .. -~.~ i5ltiA4" A ... 4111, a fth.,.' , ... .,1: .. , ~1~ ,*,,~,M'$ ;~ .~ "j ... v..~~ t/f .. "'*~~, :.a'lI'AW p~ii II> '~ j\

    "hloh l'ltro, nt 8,00.ti' lfttrJ ' " , for betore 'b.~ geDerated, ioo, 'b tllap17 was ,_ .'.t "ho elteratloll. G neratieD olm4 qU1,4 , whlotl he lJe;301Be. Wi1,1,'8 e."al18 onll tht,

    , -,

    S.o~~ate. 1,. abeo1u'.1, J.' he 1'1 ,,004 0111, aeoua4.WI qu14 ln vlrt~. ot lila Mm, ._ao1u'.1,. To be 1\. he QU,g,h,t to be 1. 8ometbl. a.olt4eata,l \. hI8 abeoluM '.,.11)1;, and 1e theNtO". belac MO~U;aG,U. qui4.

  • a_",l, Yin"te epollatu 'ltl.18 , Il1b1.0'"., 4101t.r qulae. ~. 1 4UII Q\lld.sollloet in-=:-:S:::~l::.::=-':'': ::u:~,, 'uwm

    Vbi' 1. l' that. ,.tF _ioh flake. s.......to be a'b:.olu'.l, hla 8004 ODlr .. 1.,1 17. ." .... ab.. 18 ab lutel, s004 1a Yip'"e o' .... 'blI18 _1 ..... hi. be cm1, 1ft aD aoc14ental wa,t

    w. apeak ota .h I .".lDS 1. '.'Pa. of all ab801ut.. conal-&eratlO1l, _ . t 18,' we -1 'b.' l' 18 perfeoted 1D It,.lt when It.l.'.b y,n". of . a.1;1&1 1):.18:011'18 ... " Z:10Mllhlas 1a .. 14'0 be 1004.'. be AS 1- aboa14be. with ~.peo'to 80ae-'btDI otl1.. t.. 1 ' If J S .... ,.. .,., be orda'red to flo .. thing 0' ".- t).i_ .. lt 1t he 1. to be go.. Soora" "la:' hla- it t. hl 84 \)7 Goqu1:P1ftC ... o14cm . l ,.rteot1oJl'., Ylptu , wbloh ... t1t'b1.0,. .. '1 .... Be w111 be 14 to be at.801utel, 004. 0 8.4 a\toY. ttut p t.otl.a orbl. aubatantlal

    . bel. _ 1&014111"" 1h. ,."e14 1 pe.'.0'1080t ylrtue.

    0811 OM 18 1.0", all, beeauH ae ls. Ore.tUNa h.a oertain

    .'00..... rollowbe Oft 'help &)) lu'. belaaJ but the), cartOD1,

    ....... ,01u'.,11 C084 11l yl . .-.ot tbat _leh. on the plan. of .,'

    .au. ezll''''',uadera,oocl lD the 11 ke,aar41an n , wl11 tie ,It. bl.tor, or t~dt .04u1 ..... t of .1p't""'. abtl tbe stib que., .... ot tbe. la.. ,1".011 ... 1 to our eD4. It Ibe .,):.,1 talk: la, ,.,' .aln'a,iD8, 'to 1" 01". the

    1.'0 1'. SUI.' 'hla ... t .. e. that we ahould .... 11

  • -6-

    our pot"'1&11'1 "orr .'1". ao tb~l;t .. IIaYDot 01117 be. ~iIt" ~. a- ~: ..... ' .... ~~. ,,. iAllV Wu ~-',_ ~w ~.

    ~h." ar. e18 taPJOOD81 avold eyen a ... 11 popln. ta. beglOD'

    \)~,~t 1t 1. well to

    'leetl',mo.bal,l

    In'o aeo.plete al,8uaie:retaHil:D tba.' whlcn tollow.. ~hat il ....... 14 eD lle, '0 ... uP.. tu41at1notlon or ,8D08 an4 8.18\;6 ... 1. 'thie oreature ., b, 'uegluft.liti w'lt!\ th . llot1on

    'll;. go04 we a bnq.l.'t~l' 11M' .. folloW8, and what toll0.. 18, DO' ...,. .1o~\1 0 14 ... t1'*. 11 kesaard

    )) ... 811"4 no .,.,; ot, .thles, .. : DooM~'rl" prweentatlcm of ho. 1I0ral. ... was ,. be _oqul 4. lIe abhorred \}le flDall,', a.4 au'bo:pl'la.,ltmlaa of Se ." '11&ft8yat tlaat:l.0D . .,JA f'.a .. J6A 41'" l~,A,. ~;I-~, ' .. --... ~t~"vv ~~_J'

    $.017 ot'lreot a._teat1 .. tONlba4. aUGh .. approacb. w. CO oa ... 'fjo 41 -.1; Kl "e ,I't. a14 ." about hulIfUl f act10. aot _ Hoau .. l' 18 . ~.ltloalltlD l' lt. W'1 Mea... 1. will 1. \U1'Mtte. ,. 'UBde.8taD4hll t'beopY ot tM.1I'eot 00_10.tloa.

    .... '

    ....

  • 0 tooll. ~'.' . of' _ , ..... I&l 'loa 1ft ...... .

    It we ... "811.".ll II N, aepllaa1 .. b\mI' 11ke .. 0"1 \be ~k .t Ill ,. .... '1& .... PT'hlq

    wt.alt. UBNallt, aa4 latl'u'.lq ,_ Ycl., ak(\UJ4 t11. t. va,' ODe of P-OIlPOU8

    .. 1'1 ........ \flllob, t.l, that l' DMU tile r.al .'or'.k of th_ht 184 1t 81\4 .... :p ..... 'l, em; 1. 'be lftMr-

    .'1... of atS,.,.. 8'oh M4 exMu.,.' .. al.1 t;;, _.,.,.111"4

    ... pta.rea 'olc,. a.'l.be .... a.'beatlM, aM.oat.lolu.d, troll ',' "8:t kl44 tb __ hti. ot , .. 41Y11\1'" '0 'he inc ot'''e a .... U1. tl,. .Aa a", .... 'i.r~., N hl 1f hd ~.4 8 'h.~. or ,. 87.',", 'MD.sl.tl ~,11; b,. bie ,.,lft, ,. a lal1.,. ' "lat wIllon all , b.1m ... tbeN_

    I "",

    III ..... 1, , .. aw&a117', reall._1 ... "P'U;I:,oah1,tt 'ha' ht.. ooaspl0Uo\lIl1, ab ... , fro. .b. 1,78' , 01' ,at le.,' aD. los waloh cout4 ha...,,,,, 1:8 t lon to hl lf and. th.

  • .1.

    NI~,l', _1.' ........ , hi.. With ""18 .... .pl'10. oa_ ..if,,'; ""bat 'M-ole of Yf.~.ll" phl1o."J:~h1 v.. a fl\D ,10 .. t.pp.1 _lob wou14 ab.'",oi; hta 00_))1 e11 OUI of 1.lt. 1 0._ ... ' .. ' aft4 WOD4 tul ft.~ .t :P\fN aelq

    . AM ,n ... bl b __ ,be _le. . . ,

    /

    !'be ta. of ...... " ... 0r41ms to Hegel, 18 pa4ual17 to ", ' .. ,.lat. tD8 wi_olt t.~, .. llCloa 4 Al'b." "rlwte4 ,. Ji!PO'Y14 ..... 1 Se tel' 'hl\" tne __ lft,tell1pn.o,. :ba4 .,t101 .. ,1, lIl'u.4 .... _.,1.,. OP8l'l ,be 16., 400., 'to SO ",084 tal ll1 6114 DOVO_ a.rip.".. ba4 \WIN. 1ft dolDe th,la, .11 wG'i14 _ ...... lear 884 OOIIPrebeaal'll. ,. -_

    ..... a. to. ul'1 ... '.11 l\pre.u'p .... 'b,G04 ,. aD 0.'>'''' propor1l1 ... a k h ..... l.'.11.1S aa4 1. 'Itt Mlo,w it,_

    ~

    wltb De ,G1"" tOf! 1ftt1lO\l14 Dew the ..... of all 'he oau f

    a.4 tbere oou14 " 'DO tmto ..... .tf.....W. GoulA the.> olio 1110UNl1.

    I .. avo .. bit.' .... , .... t,. 20 1 1.~ t aD4. aa4 :t W11 k plt 1 , . ' till , .. th,.

    Or. .8ae,.1 fAt'. I', -, If'tc. aD.4 lJltu~.l . t u,. 1s ItO' .. '

    Vbat18, bu, 1lM tae, 'ba' l' 1e Dot a. 1. abotl14 lie, ODM ~ 1m _ha,1t 1 1t ,.., tte .. ,haS 1a eo ,. 110\

    ani 'ra.yol" ooatr 'k. a'" 1,- 18 .. I u .... ' \II ,.'

    we a180 AlGopl that 1. ahou14

    Oby1oual,le ,,1 h thl ... 1t a rathe ... lIbi'lou. loal

    aa4 we .. , .. 11 VOD PD.- be pPopoMd to attab 111. 'Wha'

    be , OU. , .... ure .... ol .... ,.hlcb he 1nI1.," ha4 be ..

  • .,.

    4088 '0 1 '1l '" ki. Goa,. . ,".le.8, 'loa'. fQl4. Ie_UiBl-Ie WOQ14 ......... , eaa

    ,

    ..... ", ,,,,,a i.' ,be _01.. TtMtaol., .. bow .... , t ..... 17 \k ...... 'l.l aata ........ lq1'

    ,....'he p ...... t 1'., ... ,....,.. . ftle Whole , .. tal_, ot ....... GoA .. e ... u.'tS lmo.le4~l. of ... _14 .. ke p ... lt1. ... e .. o,em lJook _4,,*. t"e

    Altfto"l\, , ot l1te. ..te ... ,' .... 18 tM S, , &D4 ,. 1'. ,. ... ,. troll lat 1 .. __ . ' .11pe.lor to ... l' 1.

    "t l' -.'4uII9 .:ha. ~~ ... ' .. .., . "'~ ....... u: ....

    r

    1ft '1 .....

    1'. "'11 .. 1 . tllale.'l10al MY.lop .. _ .t ,. .,at '1 ....

    -...

    ", . , 1. IJOtb,lDp _lob &e,.l 1,.1-el ' e. _be ,. .... ,4.W .. power of 'he .... l.e J 1. 1.

    "'~'t ot,.. .. '. J'o., trolla l' 1. lD-,..4. _ '.1 ,,, ',:.'. l.oy14 'the' 01" 0 'he flo,l .. t. whl_ ',.1 4..' IU. """POPs.'

    11.pl va. , .t 'lJ ..... ttl., .01....1. act ,1 a OP .t.1 ..... Sa ... tell awoop, . , 1. 0811' M4 Il,' the .114 of a

    4S,I'laot . -. , 48 aN "011. _._ we PI , .. - 14 to lt ..

    la'. pro .... of 1 .... 1 t lIlI. 41 ":*1*, or o_.p'. o .... poa4.UaI wl'lI'~. 41 .... .1t'.t'b,1.'. kaoWII;.1tor 1.181, ,_ mod 1 ... 11 ie , ....... t .11 our 14 ....

  • .. 10 ..

    "'8.1" . all ftat ... l aJl4 aplrt'ual l1t. :::-.li::~~:-=, .e V:;::1 to:: !!iF.~ WI. i' ...... '.1'1al.. . 1. 00 1'. to tt. 01fll a..l.8 1'3' , ...... ~J , 41_ tln1' '1_ ".... ,he, ,00.1 tl... .t aD eZ'.PD&l ..... 1al of ,.lY .. _ t ... 810h l' .. , ._'ala 1.. '>0.' . aa4 ,be J.o't. ot 11:., &0'1.1t,. 1'. : ,1.',1'.'" B ... 18b:Ra'. ,aD4 18 the -3 ' ot 1'8 ... o,.ra' 1 .... "

    .e ... awaN,fj' ".h. , ..... , 'M 8s..t p.o4\10 1a re-/

    1:1 ... ,1-_ OIl 1'. 'b: . , ....... 0084 la',em'l, , tbe proper ott,' or 1_10. ~. lep1 , .,_ would ... ~ to .M"oe

    ''_It., 4Mltotl88 'NIl .... ala .. 1 1. l" ,am"'aata _. '.'.11.', of ... .Nal ltl all ,. ,. .. 11.,."1 ()QJt 1.1H MGOIIea ."""1,,. aJI4 .. aol" ... Mye '0 do 'with .olfmoe

    .\ . , \1841&, 0 ,.. " ' __ leb 1 .... 1'lt' 1. ae_hlD1

    11 .. , .... be 'u t .... o.b3e.t, tb.' Whlob "0' po.. 11' lMt GaD ,re' t '- ,'1_1 exl., ... e. To regaN 1., ". '6 "." 1. . '. ,.,.1,. '0 a1 .... :r .... , ,be

    --,., .. " '. ot 0lIl" ". -1114'" 0"" 1" ~"' .. :' .~" ...... , .... ,' .'" .. , .. : "-

    lowh " ... Sbe .P"tN.~, .. ot 'hele,el11m .. 'boa be-_",flO.. .',.., ,baa lii, .1.. ."ltoa'loa 'to h18HI7. Kle .. t ." . '. .ook e.,'l~ to ~1. a.peo, ot nepl 18 .81ng 111_11 011 ~ -xta.-ol.. ot the .'h1081 lite. .Ia3\lz,

    ,. ......po.1'1 ... of Ualy l Bl,':o17 arJ.4 tbe oova po.1\10a of . " flUOb. 11 ,.111 be thrown

    ~ 0'. 1.,.11e .. ,ua18111e. 1D 81 th18 fl , M;18hntlallet'.

  • Weba.e ..... _~ t.p& ,l, OllP ... t-hfm oont.ol1'84 wt'h bl.'o., 11 1lO~ ,. 6 .. ,.n. our l.8. w!l'ha .ap. - ........ 00 _ Of'proY148,.0.. Bath..,., we auat Mke thle

    14ea 110" ... 8It4. dAJ":~1Ba" 80 tl1a.t will, be able to ... ,roy 1'.lf OU' 1D, hiB'o.,., ~. p ......

    /

    OJ).~ 1108o,hloal 4."D,,'.rfj,tl(i)ftot tile 410al pea.GB-.1..... .fall '.1DS8 Ul. Ott. at_ of ai.torr.

    , ....1' "_lob' 10:.', ',; bnq8 vlSb I.'. __ e.. 'la\lea, of 11.'0." 1. ,_ .-1.. .'.toa.t J tba' ile.lKel . the lit...,.e. .t ,he ,'J '!la, the blat ., ., ,. we '.' ,: ',."ope. , .. MD' ~ wi 'h .. t,10 .. 1 ,1'00 . '

    " ", . IlalYl ... , t .... ".1 ..... n.1 DO'10n8, ao \181 1 hletol7 ,,111 'ew. , .1 1 ..... 1ob GOYer the tlbol.ot ,_. 4 ... 1 .... : ' t' ,. e realJOB. We... \014 ,.- .... , .'1'." .... 11 .... ,._1 ePA t ey..... but ,.'h...how U8 '1M 'a ... 'i ... -1 _t ...... ' .. 8 ~ .... 1'11&1 ....... ,

    1 ...... 1 hi ... ., "~k .... t.lloaal eoapftt"elcm .0 'tba' ,_ ... 14 la *lGb~ ,....,. 0'- tn-.l1lc"'. aa4 Will _at-

    .. '

    t " .... 1 tl1a. 1 ., let' o. obaD._, wt 91111 be Heft 1. 11 .' ot ,. IC ...

    1l7.re was a ... aoa _lob lo raM _ .. wo.14 aDd.tbat tor tnl .... OD A:r.latoU. 11k' hl,. ,..tbe ODe a.e. ,fI8m 111 oJtOwd of 4 ... 11 11 " S...... eb01ll ,he 1848, ... IDa,.1oa of thl.

  • .. 11'

    ..

    "1tl08 -114m he ao ... '1M' _I ".-~'. aB4 .fio!.. l~ ... ,~., . ~.A . w ~l. _6. ................. BeA- .'A . Mft'-".~ '. ~~OC.GUI ... :. I.Hlltiq,,' ~ .. ~ V.I!. wW O&~"A.Ut hS_l 111 top we ._, eh.. '.De wOl"klJl18 or tbe 14 a_ -~."., *, ..... ' ........ ii1t;WtA._- . ~Aftt-.- . M6-1 . . t ........ , . ,..f!i(.1:A1ft6.1.1., ~ Vi:;t _~4 ... ~ .... w.~ a,VtiiIit YV~. . ~ fit. Wi'lv .w._ V~. ., alcab 10..... O. 11 14.

  • ~'''.'.'' ~. 't... Xtpl... :"e "I' p.p80 .. 1 OO!P06"". &114. '.lals, , J

    ,be w laot 11 .... 1*1,8108. of eel and. '11,t. lett 1, tne '0',: tt, aDd ... tN't all

    ,

    15M' ...... '111 faoet. w1'h e 4,ltf'1leu1', lot 11t 8Il4thatt 1004 .. 4 1,1 .... 111 .a iaa.,.M1tl e ey... ,., tl'O. "81_ ....... 17, O~ ,11 ooa'aUt .. taoaloula1l1., 'el __ ' vble

    I ... '1... 1. t ,uaat.. ... " ... "'0. __ '.. The tao, 1s -

    0'1 ,1004 .-, 11. 'Wba'M.;r ottered .a an .",1. or a.,., . 1_ 18 be,' '01lJ' r ... h. ODe ., ...... _411, wl t,tt the nltark

    0(\11111., .... ," '1'UlI 1. aeael. we .... ,1.,. :41"14,84 It.''' D

    at1IIl,..'1ea to. Me ,eDl eat.book vea 41 . :t. a. Ii .... t.1.0 ... __ , of airA ))1

    ~., II ...... ..,14.'. , ." .ea ,of, .' 1) coa$1V, Obal"... hu_ u. .'.Doe 1 teelt

    hle.lao ... the'~ ':,ot n."keaaa.4 .

    JUt baa "._'1 .. e4.l:l~ " .. 1'4 8,le.mt Ii pea' 4 1 of ,bitt , .. 'h 1;'.,1. to allllO'" 1) . 18 IN." ooa,rebe.8t,cm of the

    ,

    1'. bttg,lJDl,lDc tiM ..... la, ta.' betm t1;111111.4. It ...to ",1. poml whlob ........ U, ",o"rNa 1a ble OWfl .. tt1DS., 11ktmlq ~be .,...... .atp1ft a at ... vinAOW" whiob rea4 .... ,. pre._, he .. , aM ,., whea _eD,.rei wlt11 pall" or

  • '~lA" ....... Me M t.__ .' ~ 0Itl, ,be alp.... tor .. 1 hw ..,.1. 884,' .... t1 ... pr~l ...... 0. aM al 8. 11"1_'

    q.'" .tt ... _0' 'b. wrt l OU'. otl". aDA ,., , tl;aft4_'al ., ........ , __ cht aa4. Hlq A" one, Ml1.. tl\\'1\ 88y,,4 1. ,be 1108' lB . llft1tto.' aot1.. tmat '-.. 1. & ' . .1\1 pa"," b.1Ui .. 4 ,~.. hl.lias wl.4.11 pre~.t. ,. ~. 8:M'Cu8 ot )) ... 91,4.110 ... 4 ,e bl~. "la40. '.118"81 ta ...... _, pro914 tlae 110.'.... It ... 1 ... 1\\,.1 1.4 .... ott All, ft,,_ ,.,....tU\ pro-Y14_ K.l.iPk __ " ,,1'11 ... 81. ot bla a"'aok on tt ,at

    ot one "h1J1l er, aim orm _e oerM41a: AD 8,x18H.c1al II,:., 1. 1.,. 1111.. fta.t wblo" .. 1 .... r.oa ki.\or, 1e ... 1, Ibe err .. t,. 'If 1OB. __ 1891018-.1. .....urarr ot OOD801ea ....... la. bl44 ... ,... flU ,.

    :. 'h1 ..... 1$M' 110 INCh .,., exl ' D, ........ J ftor .18 till. 1 .11M bl OUft ..... t.loa.

    ~a.al1" l' lt 1 ,.~ .. tor GoA,."t 1. . ..... , lie ,at tor aDJ' e.ll1tlq8:pl,rt'

    . .... _t1aali,'7 .. .... '0D4 '0 ... aao'he., lNtexl. 18 })reel"l1tb.fioppo.lt1J or ttDa11".

    Ile" , 18 .. 'b,eo' ..... ICS 1I8a1'4 0&111 quan'l.tt '41,,1 .. '10, .. 4 .. 11 _." _1." haa _ .. 'ltacl.e ,.pop,.... 1

    . -.

    laolu4e4D 1'_ It oe. DOt aoaleY .... 1~.1 WIlle ... _be ethloalr.. .. _ 1841Yltblal aequu.a bla,.pl l lapoPhnoe _, .. ana ot ,.t _lob. 'PO. aD .'hloalpola' ot .1 , 1. 840;14 '181.1$ _4 ,._. lt OD. 111"'_8 _rull to ua4.r .... Ill.'orr tpo. .. Ylewpou;t ot p~.148Do.. tbe .'hical, 1I0rall t, . _O'D tie ove.l.ilk.A.

    \

  • .. 1,.,

    , Gel" '*-, ,'a10Dot tbe blltop1ealla la, ,.:t.pa Ila _OW' 'e ot the s,aaoat ..... ,. .08861..... ke, b\ tM ' . ,.t ... 'lashe It he (,. :b,l.'ol"l") ... ,.-la. t ... i11IOb .... , .,'t, he w111 '0 0 .. ' .. ' hl. , t ,w1'h "8U ... ,ot the liON pro ... bleil' 1' , aD4 'ill. 18 p~ol .. 1, .hat mak , qUBD'1 'lYe ,-. 4tle14 taotop 1ft Ute .. leo'l ...

    t lIh1ob18 1.~taa., .e tar etb10al 00.111481'.'1011. are OODHrae4, 1. the ' 1)0"_ OBoe _. j>urpoee 1. determlne_, tIl. '0\1'00 _114 .rt.eta are 1n41tt.'pea,.11 Jlar tro. ex-

    I ' plabl. ' .., eYil, Unl .... al l'llato17 oan DeY '.1D. to MGO l1ltlen or go04 8D4 .y11 .a tihe.. _xl., .a ural ,,, .... 81B1m'. 1 t. 1841.16 .. ,1.18

    t wc.14 hl.,oJ7 1. 'h.",81 p-wM .. 004 1. ..' , ' .... I. 18 , 0lMa ' " 11.' e ' '1, .he c, . 'spa"t.'ol*,MoauH He 1.

    ,,~ 081, ..... , MIl 1te. ~Ol,bl. tMa'" 110 1.'laS ' is's.., .a. & ... 1.. It he laaS'1aee bl--.1f

  • . o.latl.e pb11.a.ber4 ... GOd em. 183u.tl 11 It 1. 1B 'he . 80oal,184 ,. d,latl..-1ah 1t

    tft) . the $1' .... , til.' 11ft f:, fA p.,1108Op"10.1 ., .... p, to "tu:_ "8'8 .. 1I1t_[II.

    p ,. '0 .peak of ,.8 ... ',10" whlon 1. 4&8"lDp18.4 , ... 611, _.M. " ... l~ 18 ttl., it .... lie' tm"Ppo the prior .&1 ...... ., tba. aloh _.eo .. e. '~t la. ltle 0_5.''' 011.-_ .. _l.~.\Qt4.r.'8Jkll_ tb

    . eup,..... ... tbiq. lie of tal. 11184. 10n 11 Dev tbel

    a ... be t i t .. bo.' & p(l lbl11tl' aM. a .11lI! _lob 1. ~. . 18 aotual '.ba. OP a.,ua11., J loth~~t t . (lUa,;Cf 1Dvol Y8' 1Il be-00 .. . ........ 1._.' .' .... ' ' .... 1_,1 ... t.OJa ,. lb111t, to aotUill 'IT. 2~.

    I:l k.'...... .,MIl 1. whe.}~.. 'tll8 DAI 7 can 00" into M1Di. -J but 'he .8C " o.tUmot

    .., .' alDM "' 1. &1..,. "la~.4 to It .. 1r. aM .. '.'0 l" .. lt 18 the ... ...... All' . 111'0 be, .. is a 8UJIiDI . ,fl ..., ...... ' ntl , l' .IDJiO't Slltt the" autf' 'or , ,o~\l.l. whloh 1. . "he. " 1-.1. ( .. '-Gal7 , ol.e' po i. b,ll!"" bu' al.o~ tbe A.e.reM p() "blllt7) "-",eal,. 1, lt.8 _0,b1 , ...... t l' 'bee ... _ aotual; to" I " 1h1,.18 _lh,11&t,,4. 1B 'the eo-'l e.,'MII',1;u.t 0 .. _ lB' 1-. p ..... ,1'8018817 '01 eo.~ lato Mlag'.t 1t ,1. Dot DeO ...,..; f,o" 88 171'. 'be 01117' ti\_ t :t4 . ., 00.. l,.t,o 'be MGaU.. the n.Q~8 .., la. t._ eo .. la,,, btl' t 18 ..... 1. _, ao,,,allt, 18 D,O'

    ' .. 08 lt,. Ai ,al. pobtt;" Il tc ,.tot1. top wboa a the .e ., 18 PO lbl

  • .. 1, .. . 1I1stake lle.1D Ill." .. la, -1,. \.

    '18.11'1. 'wlb"l\ ,.'Il Wbl.~\l IT 11 po l))l.. Iu ora:.. to aye14 tiai.,l1 t.o

    -.~_._Ae....A . ~'~ --..... 1. t ...... aA ... ~4__ i.,f.v~r9 W~jv., o&.~~.~~ ..... w~ ." ~~,.",~.. 6" ....

    ,.r7,,",10&'.. alJCU~ ~'U ".-17, .. e bel}). hi_.l.' out . ...,.'1113 two .,..1.. otpo 1-b111.,. laa' of 41800 1ag; t hl. tl ' ,.181tt:' 11. 1~' 81AM' lJl11.' ..... ao' 'be ~lr.41 .. ,"d ot t ...... -17.

    l.erJ .... 1 __ te pa .. :wl1ltf ... 40., Dot b, D.eo l',. All u ... \I1,'l..... a.erl f.o tnebet_ . 884 .. ' ... , B ~ .. 4.1_.4 lJ7 .he ... , peao .... ot 1.' ...... 1 .., oaUI to whl_ Iba. 'b."'" a "OOK . 1,8 ..... IM\I'7. as tllothlq..,er

    . , 00._ ll1to, N, wl.b ...... S. .. , J ... , . 1 ..., DeYfl. 00._ tato Mbli" Bo'h1Da .00._ Deo '817 b, ooal. 1"'0 "_.-16

    te-aa'" 1 . will .. ... '0 a4rIl' t "'0 .. baa .. bl.'oJ')' la80.tar "' . 00.. 1.'0 M;l~ ., 'but 'u 1'.;'8 .. e. ,he .... 11 .. '10D tt hi.'op!oal 1ft the .'.10' DM ,. -the po lbll1t, of " OM l'800a, ". w1 t11l.,. f1rst betJ'o%l,tD.l ."Tb,is be-... In, w1'hin a ltecoa1_ 11 du. \0 relatl 1, t'''e oau Wb!:ob teI'1 . 1t;111&'.1" t~ aD; &b801u\.1" tNe aau as

    pc., 4oe' , ... ,' of allie, t wbe' haa ha,pena4 .8 h8p,...4. but ... , .. t;U toHoOD,clu4e'Uta, tbe llU1Uta-

    _ill" or the paat 'S 1d .. ,loal wi'h ,bat or the ...... aIT' ,,'

    . t'., all. tor 1t ., .88, tl8e oa ... 1.'0' 'bel_. 'It ;he,.., ,1. oODo.1.e4 .8 ae 17, 'Ill. oall U,peD 081, l), .1.0". ot to .. '., *t l' Hie 00 .. S.'o H'. .a, be .. o a.., 1. _._nloh 0_0' be ., .... 1 , _, at 'he t1M or 1'. be-oOllla, tM pe." 001114 bay. ' ..... he .. 1 , thereto" ita 1 11, .,11,1" 18 D.' ' 'l"e 1 __ b1111;, ot the .. 0 .... .,.

  • .. 11-

    11l;81.'. .., 1t 1M e the ,a,a, a.. ..0, ...... " we _ ... "De .... ot _ ru'UN,. ..4 "bU. '..-40. wou14 '"' ',.0,84. &l."II &I'4.fte &'1 "' ... i_loatilon of

    ,

    ,be 48 .... 1' '.fl\,loh ae,e1 lDYOk84. tor _ I .. olag .. .,. .. . ~ 11&17 liDe lDl_ pa.' ~. would, .... '0 t:ol1 tbat. tbl .. o . s.., _,laue. 'B., ..... Ill' 1.~ tn. rut"". ,. '.Ma. .. t

    .... ,.., 18 -- IT, 8!i1l0. 1t .... lD\O __ '., l' 414.0' "..... ....... ., _, .. Oalll!, 1ft.. bJI (.10b. I.. " ... , ...u.',loaJ I '.,11' le ....... 1.b .......... ., 'throup __ t

    " .. ' aloa of 1'_ It_pal' ......... .. ... ,., . It., , . . '.' .f ". p ' WO'fl14 " 1 ... lt7 rmeb _M .PP"_ .. t08

    =~":1". !:!:' t~:"O:-_:: :r:= ,beael... Zf , ... ~ , .r appJ'eh ... 10lll. 0' . '... , la p .... ' ot ".' .M8.1on. ',. epp ..... l .... 1. . ,,' ,..... '4'lIdo 1 .. "' ..... , ... l'

    "_ i ...... ..., '0 _ pbll OJ;MItI, a,. '1&1Jo aad Arlsto,l 8&14, _, _ .... a. tool .ed4_a ,be ....... 17' Aa4 _4 , .t _ ... , 1 ... bo. aa 111&"111,\:, ,. . paep ,

    ., 01 ..... 1\181" lIe,ellaa _, ... 11l1", ,",l.S .,oa4 'won4er. 11 I.,0D4 pbllo, .. _ aa4 __ 11:t 31

    Be pro_l 101\ 1,1 0..-4 18 ,.,la.l to .. 1101 t. ,. .... 1al 11\ pbl1 " "" ,I ... 'iliac Whleh oenbe fIII 1n tb 17 .\la f pee' .hl , he .. reI'. Sa hi. ex-po.,l.loa. 1'18 "IN. th.'" 1. IIUOh 1.8 lDwtm" he Mi4. hl0 ta .... lD. 1 ....... ,.. ft. prOb1 of 0 lt, .. 4 ... '1 .... :, t4 ..... 1II1 ...... tn __ .. 11 asGb

    acre DO", 'ball ,. t .. pa, .... 4e.o' t. l' uke 01 ....

  • .. 19 ..

    .. ..... ti. tberet , pa 0 ,. bt ... tu'.'loa ot ae,81 with-'., ....... ,_ .. , ___ 8a141. __ 11&!lt of the aoboolot

    . 11... OIl VIlloa l). tal.lall, 1) btl .~D4t tnat ot Arl.':G,le.' 1\\111' , ..... , the D." ", 41.t1 ,10..a .. , all, 1ttl .... lf10.I108. \fO\1.14, ofoOUl" oa.P, \18 ta. ~b.,OIl4'bAI .. a , ,. .t .. p ..... , work. aut without

    1 ... , ap.o91"17 81_- II,' 'he 40.'.:1.118 "bloh o ... ers 'hie .".," .. \lUi ... be ,..'ltle4l 1. gol_ 011 to ,be I.i.rke"u."'-

    I

    III ... ..10'1111 ,he 11pltl'oat1oaot . n& .e .... ar7. 11 11' 18 4culttl ..... ,1.8/'" It, \lhe' lre to 41. "1; lsh olearl;, .:11 .... _ur tr08Oo4. 'ortllDa,elT. 'thle lea _lea18 18 1>1 ....... 1 tre4 bl 84,81.,1. of 1eua k1a4, t ...... 1.,. 4(" It, .. eop1alaa;tMtth ... are ex.. 8. or 801u,' """0 be to\l!ld lD o,..,u.... It 1. 'Mealile he tnlaka of poe.i"ill" ,.Oft,.,\18 with OOD-'D' '.0, ,., Il t.papa ... h. "uup' the , .... , '.' 811 ,r. ...... ..,1. po 1,.,18. tMt thl.llUi.' be 80 1.1.,.,.4 ll, 1.' 10110.:1 .",.1. .. _111 4 etloul4 110' be .... a .. ,..1, ... , of _1,1, em elt .utf of an arra.atq

    ..... "' tD..' '. " .. ,-." - -'." .. ,". .' " '. .. ,,' _ <

  • 10.

    :I . ,po. ".' . *1"1.1. t"..... ...1' . &4 ............ 'a

    ,.' Mt_"'O. _ of 'lilt) i.po lbil.. ,hat .10b 0 ... 1 11ft_ao;). 1. alao '0 ~H COllt,

    . ,; .a; . onl, "0 the ....... r,. bu' eD' _iohaa, 01* .. , Dot ... ht the ~ _'lDfj8ll'. 804etlDe4. will all;o be.pose4 to tn. .eo ,...,- which 18 4.f1884 'u' whion o_o:tao. be.))

    We ... 1~la 17t)b._, 4,1.,lfto,108. "hlob MV. to 'be la4. if _la '0 ep_. .,l'tt an, .. ' .. :8>t coh...... 111 'M8 IB'''r. a. f1r., 18 'M,"al ...... tlon_b.,t .... the po, lbl. 8114, ~he lapo lltl.. UD4.. 'he po 1"1.,... oars UD4e.-

    .~ Nth the _., .., ..0, _Uti wttlo11., .1"bOui~ Dot Beo ... I

    O&t_&;:'O., .... ot o:our ,eon'-, .,' ,",.' t. Ii ... we ... , agala take oeptloa WlL" Ile.:rkecaaNt top" &41l1\ ot eo, thlD"e wh1eft eOM l11'O N' aM ret ' ".1 4o 80t ooatabl 'he D&:iaU:I

    'iJl.O.8"~7 with aD ab.,.lute ...... 1'7. I' 1 0' , ..... , .s 118._laar4 euga ,tl. 81.pl"UM ,,'hl 0 .... 1.'obelDS ,hat it 1e DOt

    .. 0 ' '., 'tril,be.au .. 1. wa. DO' Deo .... rl1'p .. oont.1D.4 1D - . 1'. oaUH. .,'

    108 4101'ur au, allqul,4 per lnmo a04u. ,.81 1 ooa.. '.. as hoo 8.1uII ,.04 , ... 8,1' 1. po'ea.ta .,t quaft4oq;ue in .. 'u.( ) .' .. 1'0 '_11. ..1 ooati , ... 1.('4 oppcal'.1' ...... a.i0 beo 1D ..... t10-"_._,' _ ....l' .. 0.... 111\14 fl ' r::.:: ~:. . ... ::Ur!:-:.::: ::!~,.=

  • .. 11 ..

    All thiac. 48,.a40. the will of

  • .. 11-

    8 ..... ,. 11 aa ..tlp1. of a betll, aubjeet to lnt.rlnll0 OOD'l ... " theN 1. ~'lD al ppool1Ylt, towaNI Doa.be11li_ Bu' preel.ely .ere 18 an ezaltple ot abttolute ",80 1t,. Is aot aeGe.A,., In, ttl.'8'tplaoe that Soora'M_ be, but BOW tll.the la, l' 18 a.etll.'.17 .. 0 ...... 1 ,bat he lJe patto-8&1 aD4 ~hat he 8.b.ou14 ... -1' 4,1 )8 Howe , 1'1 18 ftot &1) .. lu:,.l, ........ , tba;" aoo .. , PUll, tor he 18 flO ao a ;rtl1l!fJr4 to _ ao'loa ,.. '01 te 0".81 ttl. au. 11 ... lb. tao. tma, 800 .. ' 1. N881D1. l' 1. '1.,,0 lb1. ,bat he' tte he.... 't... .. 841 .'111." JI.,. well the, bDo-'Mt\S. l ....... 1.'.1 .. '. floe,. tpOil ..... q a' '0 tmteoecteDt aa4 8.' Yl08 ..... , l' t.8G' " .e tt, ,he, 1 ..... bo. Dot _AA,., . ___ , Itt >fiMlll'W .' , . '-'-".,'

    0".181181, it we eN bteD\\ OD proylBg tMt ,an ex1lte21tlal ., 18 l 1b1_, .ha ..... we ., will ultl,.".ly.e4uoe

    It lt '0 aD .1D4tt1.r, 1 011011 .tteete preocm l ... 4 1a

    .tt .. ,. are llftO l1y a. p o,~ata.1Dd that be 1s 110 ... ' to 8u8tal h1. , 1a. I'ro. what bas beeD 8a14., it ano,,1.4 be 14 , t;ba"1l18 appp .. _ 18 utan.pp, 0 to,.,,11;1 .... 171'

    ,.'

    ~1 4 OOD'~'l,... It __ 80' ..... 14 the pHS .. D' 8-D4 tutu'liPe, .. 40 ', Mke , ...... 1 to 1;:". pea,_

    if t.8 .... 04 , ,,,., t,,, Ilea t 0 '1 ..... q\\laJlOilOol\1l1qlt ipna Doa tl 1. 14 'q\J04.D .. 81. f ,UtI, et 6. atoo 1.uol' "":. ,"110818 qu1reo'. 41al" I 4u04 8010 t..,. po .... '1"1'ft,'~ n.. u\ _11t.o., taott' 1 11&, lle.t _OIl. . 'a q... .uat .tao.. 1

  • """ ,

    ~

    -I' -the 'Pr._' aa p ..... , 18 .. _je.' '0 ,he .,rlD.olpl. ot .GIlt .... 410'loal 1t ._ot be otbe ilfm'~ ,la.4I V'''''18 let' 1. ,he tuture. aa4 our fl 'l- "0,0.... ftOW ,a.. tuture .tteota 001) .. 1 4 111- ""-lr .a '

    '''_ ftoItae ,.1,1 1+, sbat aa, .tt .. til.ooataiDeeS, 1. 1'. oau" el'her (1) 80 ,bat l' .,111 18 .. 8 fro. l' Wl1D neo' lt" (2) .'0 ,tt., 'ha oau aD bolbUltloa ,. th1. err " b ... oaa .... ~.'_l be 1.,...4 troe .. al1al,D, 1t, or, tlJl&l .. 11'. (') 80 ~_ ~ au .. 18 pu.rel1 1n po' ' aa4 18 80\ &e-'erill A 10 o...tteott orO,G'-l1er. 1n 'fte rl'l' I' .... OOD-t ' ... ,. 18 ... ld.,.: I'i 1. tWO " 'M,t ._ bay. a

    .... lb1a 11&'10*., 1 t . ooQ14 DO_. 0.-.. 1 ., 1'r01l. 'tbe 1'8118111-1"1., .. 41.tl~._t. , ... trpea ot OOIl'tlftgeD07

    ooa4oa1:e10l71.D481t lt ',. two. '1P of oOfl.t1Ilpnor: (a' 'ha' whS)oh.: en8 tor ~h .,8" :part'ollowlaa thelDalta-.'1011 or Da.... Vsuall'Mbt . ... _ .. wl 'b tl "etrlnger. ,pep baIl4, IN' l'oaD happeD 'b.tthts 1.: D()" ... 11 4. (b)_em 1;he iDSlma.loa tstJ'U8'l"ate4, .. b tfMt ls COD-

    . ,_ (e) I,t , blob, 1 "etro O-U which 18 1.11 DO wl ;p,.'etera1r1e' to "be .... t"e to f lection. Ttlis

    . -.

    k11l4 of Goat1 ... ,tolloW8 OIl ,be till.' ~lYl.l .. abo ...

    lb. r will. with whloh ...... _owed 181_itt.pent

    '0 UlY ,004 1 '.DIY 'UIlt"e.l&l 1004; to all 1e r good. we alit ".M-rld .. o\lr.~l '-4 ~bl.,bl4 .. t ..uatlcm .. t it &baol lv: l1de to. ""URe '0 ,p.eooDtalDe4 1ll tbe wtll: 1m ft ,a wbleh will follow fro. 1'_ Are.ll ,l01& or

  • .-. .

    .. 1t.A.teralnatlOB,whloh Cft.BOt be pre(tloted. BtJ,' th ..... 1. aD ., n IION- 41 .. 10OD,10 'ftO, at wOl!'k lnth& .rralra .r_, 'ha\ of etuutoe.

    _.D. ..... 1,11p8 .tt '0 tile ....... PIl to eDloJ' a .014 Me.' aa4 41/ala . ...4 tbeN eDootmtter8 Aloi1tla... who ball ..... 1\111. fl.. 4011... alD.. .he 1 ' 01,.,101 t &001' .... 'wou14 i ,. M1D afoptt.U1&'. 81".u,a\lOD.i'la oe:rtal111r ha4

    baa 110 14.. ,\la', he woul4~ _t Alo1hla4..he:re J 'M. la'ter 11 auDe. of _.'roklbl '.10818'1"" a:ad vaa 8uppoa . ' to MY. let' A'b...'ot-eft!' .t.er 1 ta 4.teat 1 tl,. last .1ectlO1l Itl tfO'U.14 aYe to()lleb ~h.. t ~G' to .... Alolbla4 au"Score"'. 'wou14 DO' be eo .... l,Iloal. H. aOMp'. "he tl , ' ....... ar0Uft4. 8ft4 4.10111$.84 , whe ba4 ateppea 111 "l'el1 tor a paeka8!e of .1 .... t .... -l'b .. , knoWing .he'be:" Soo.nt weN .'111 .bl. e14. 'ot tlbe a,,., .'.pa 11\1'''1'1_ 1 . '0 the ., ... ,.

    '~.l'u.tloa 1 . the .&aspletl an aoc1dental .tteot of

    .. A'.ul!&"~4 ___ ~ft.A __ . A. l'Iitl.A~" ... ,4 il-A ~i' .. fit; .;Al a& -..... A\'II't ... tl.A'ft 'W .. .. v ... w,~,~.~ i\)VV'.'8:V .. Ut. .. ~ .v aw, i:i ___ WJV VAHV.,.. WN W_

    .. '

    ' pora., .. 11.' trOll XUl"hlppe aD4 _ .. t .. 8h1Dl 4r1Dk. but. 'that he. . 14 ., ,..... t1M Noelv. aD unexpected aull, 'hl. he t-.a4 .. DO' .".. ..... of. How aN we to acoOUllttor Bu,ob an aoo14ftlitalooaurrenOfl'l/\rtatotle NldS'b. Thoma. tell

    118 ,bat 800zta 1aher . ar! aool 'a1 O.iUS. ot aD aoo14.0 .. 1 etteot, aa4 tlhllt, 1D orA.r ~ 11e .hll. he au.' liz-at be In-

  • - 15 ..

    a p.. .tt.~o .,.' obaratM .tt~., 11 \IIllt.a. 1)0 the 1ft'. :., .tf.~t, ._ 1, DO'O "'l\hthe ta,ea'lOD.46 I.f . ot, .hat wh10. llappeaa 4 ... totO.'UDe t. or au,on In-f",,, , ocoUPreno _ 1. wo\\14 " tool1ah .0 40 011. thine 18 .N,e. ,., ... 'h tortrult.oua al, 'olf,~nY J aOhth1DC

    lUll', ... or w1'h "EtS .. 8 ot'prob&bl11t, eo that 1, ... 14" fo .. tol.4,eou1(t, Bo1;. tor ..... -4, lc4 Y.' tOOl fOl'tul.oua. 8.1DCe 1'18 ,..Ut.4 pe4 or 11 to 'b. qeDt. _",,14 ...cm pw'.tae4. 0. .vo14.' bad the ageDt DOWll.48

    The .;. " '-.1'1 .1 ...... t to."li,l.\o . "eDt .... ,tat tt,.."that the '. at '" ... kiDS fop aD aDd: ,8CoMl.,.

    ta. Rat M'J~.B. b, tonus. 18 of lntreq\!ent oocu,rr.Doe; ... fUlal1" 'ha,t 1t _. 1'81_04 a ,,004 or 11, '0 "be .gent_ he .ttaotl ot tortu.. are lBca.lov.lable. tor 'he" .re lntlnl te,

    .

    OIl." au ... ptJ'.aeo14eae t 1I1tl . 1\& e" lDd.'."mlnata,eo Cluod iatint_ un! po.auDt.ooSPe. 48a

    s ... bave '.1" ',0 & .. , 'h.la4.tePflla . t ...... t tonu .. , bat.,aa _., anvtltlD." aeol4ea'a'lofUl be .e4uoe4 to a pel' .. oeu 4' . fttu8. 18 0 ... uapl~ .... IOl~ 1)0 the t rn WOUld, be .'. per , oau of Peoelvlll1tl' 481la , ht would 110' hoN .... __ .. .,.., 1t '0. -.0 the .Yel'll we" 8PODJllOUI wt'n :H,,'lv"'1 fl 4011a ''h ... 18 " 'ral .. , au of _be tOP1mlt .... tt .. " 1'_ larMuolbl. to ttl. a~.ntt. 111-'tmtil0Dal .88014 .. ,'1, o,0I1~.lll.4 to It. et'reot.The ert.o,. ot tort ....... ,0w4 ... 00.,rel\ 1oa amt\ thu" r.e to aak.

  • 41tl10111' 'Mde.l.Soai. eot. ,." .. , 81ab' D01l u_, ". DOW \hettetlDlttOB ., to."uee ..a.- how 1, i. a 0 .... help. _aot ., all wbfm M would polllt all ,_ It Moou14 fop-

    .,

    .... ,he eft .. , tfo~, 'be, woul.4 110 18ft1 be .he

    .tt ,. ot tOPluae.

    rfI 18 oODtlas-, 111 'he wOl'14 .. 4; wMt 18. 110 ... there 1. " _ ra410&18peol or eoa'1DpaoJ' _10h le obaDoe or

    f.p'i\m8.'Ho't all eft.01)8 oarl be " ... ia _help caule. an4 be.-caus. of tl118 .aD De.... . re,hflD4 al1 ""11\ .uoh. a 18, -obe" l' w111 e.,. PeA801Ulble POP U8 'heJ!le 11 1U01\ lJ"ratloD-all', 18 .be wol*14 AB4 l' 18 . tbe' we oa1'm.Ot au"mount 1t

    b~ l1houab_. _on. who'h.lDk.be 1\8;8 4cme .0 18, 11erk-~. "~ .... to-o.l. 50 . , .... of ,M.11t,0 .. be tormu-

    1.'.4 beoa" ... 0 holl qauII8xlat.. tor _. Wlt. t1\11 peall-a.'101l, we ..aoba .. tllJl8. ou.'look oahU_ .,0'lon. It. 1 . ItO. ___ nl., _baS toll ... Il ....... ll' tro. what baa geme be-tere, _, .... M 8 .... :" .... tt_ wltha .e .... llt tea. eDt 1i bl1q.

    h .... 'c.....petak of .. au_a we IIflst tl t bUr Wba' "10",8&"'" baa ba4 '0 .. ,a.ou. , ... la'SOD Nt.... '"hOUCh' 8ft4. &0:'1011.

    .."

    ,. ., aa4 k18ttmoe.

    lu.' __ a ... who '.e. eye., 1'" .. ,,'108 Dot '0 tall Oft h,l,. ta08 o,MB ede b7 t ~plu, oyer, '.,ok.aM., 10 tlerk aar4., it! r.a.~1Dg - lnat _.!1'111m .~peO.ulatlv. phl1oloPb)' ha. a tea" o, to. "3eo'.11 .eoul.,1ye phl108.,phI. lowhere 18 bia \

  • .. ..

    ,

    aDtl.1ftMl1ecft)w.lll ao ... p1' .... , tbAD 18 tbe ,i~I~U, tm4 .ven it cae OeD 3\l.,lt7 lUob o,t Wha' be sa,._ 1Jl; oonsider-

    l' .a 411' 084 111., !le,.l,there at111 Nlialf.l,1 a sub ..

    peeul.$1on .. b. Xt\ 18. lt10aDt tb4irt 11e~k.,e;a.rd \\ook $0:0"" 8 al& model, tor Soo",' ' t\IrD84 tX-(nll' the stu ot 810s aDd b\la1,e4 hlll.elfODly 'W1t~~ .f, r4> ri A f.. aut pUr.tbought 18 alto-i;"tfher4 hH, and.ot l1ke 'he abltnot

    , . w_loil .... 1.,4 abs'raot from 1 ,t-eD08,but.rt;nel !l.a rye. " ;Nla'lcm-.B& ft "A 1' .. ,. :.' :. pf"!:

  • -~ 6,vl' olI!~~AA ~,."" ,'oJ~ ~" w ... ~~~~*~ .~# f'~~._

    eo tl\.~ are 'litO: .e41at Ube 41um of abstraot t.hought, ar.~d ,tbe .. 41". of rea11t,. fa'ut pure . thought 18 fft~i"ll (I 'thlrd Mdlu_. quite NCGDl} t11iK10VitPf~4.S)~)\lr.' thou,~ht 1tt;Jlorea orden! 'that) 1. BU.taUt; , Nl~\tlOJl with ttl.t from tmloh l' .b .... o

    1f diffioult, ari.1_ trolt t.h18 IIppe$.l tiC Aristotle 1 ~t 't.h \ll)s.quet1''' ofthe'ena .lta '.#,iot thought" be .. 0 .... a. bltt am'DipO... ~. 80 longer Dowwboth.,. he 1ntenda

    11aa

    ~.'~ot ttb,~, "and then tK'O Oll, ttl Me it l' 'b. tNe of epoculat'l011 a. we 1m4eratarul 1t. We " .. to14, 'tlUi.' allitraot

    t lamor the O()DO'"'. and: te"pop.l,t. whole exlst.-"-

    ential ppe41oa_t of" 1h41Y1dual. 'It 1. ea81 to explain 'h1Jl1;8 1ft ab.tlt.otlo" 8S.mply beoau,fie thougb.t tileD abatra

  • eO.814er _.,n '.',' ....... ': t., oal7 oD3e._1.. 1a to uttmd tM ao'l'011 of trwi8a . Dole.. Me ... apeotall,. he 1. tZ7'1DS to ahow_.t ObpS." .. l 18 DOt .. 1aYltatlon 1;0 apeOl1lat1oa, ., wa, of l1fe. It; will be .... olear lat , 1.fllen we ...

    llerke"aaN'. 01*1' 18 t.r! -..... '1.1 Imewle.4p "hat abetNot 1lhOlijlll' 1. ,be ..... of APlltotl. 1.,. .t to be D.OIl- ld-'181 -.wl ....... " "".'., l.~ U8 OBoe aia.l. lena 8ft .... ,. 11 '

    'OJ! l' 1. '. *14 8, ,'1;e4 thlnc. that the ott3 '1' tfm4 1. 41 ... "1011 of '_Mil twal - t1;OB, le, 1ft .... ' .. 1 .. ' ;; 18:110 .u-S-, " ...... '0 que.'it., or .. , I ,.'bl,,:kaYeto ao,',be k 1,.., ,. "he _ ... ,lye.la8'_ otm;'utt, 18 .0 .. 1.4 hS'a'o.".'c 0'bj .. ,1 .. teD~' 1. tlle .., ent! =t~U::l=e:!II~',-=-~o:,=~"l .". .. .... 'tkt ~ae ,pro.l ot l1f. - or .1M cae I .4, 10 .aau..'.t t'h.~ 18 DO Hal. ..Il1 , aUt .. 4 1. 80 t...o .'hloAl aD ..... "

    II 'hlDklDa .. a4eq .... lust1.u, . tor _0:t1011' It 1. 1a the 11. ..t" ,u , loa that we au., lmder.taa4 .hatEl.rk.

    "..t ._.... ". .Be lItal.'i - tha.' tile aloal 18 DO., .... 1' .. '

    a lmow'l~, R:t ___ whloh 1 ... la'_ to a tola.g.58 What une. 8.. wor14 bl.".7. 1 'a 4ela, lit tbe ethioal, .ell' ........... k... ~}~-~~ '-1;1:~

    ,1t 18 ao.ooN to ealst __ "

  • .a .... ' !iii. ...

    D't411'1Nl41 .. , _ .... like .xl.' .... would. ..... 1 .. bl. to a ut .... 41.ryH1D 11k. _. low 1. 1" , wl/'b, .he p,o ,4 la ... t1t,

    ~, '. _ " illl la.elm.o" .. , wltb_be ot 1., .... ,}IM. beloqa '0 pa.'leul ...

    , ',-_ be.t I ,Jut &(lo4_oatt..X '-b.1Dk ,tut ,11004. o % ae04 ._au.. I ,.hl_ 'b.,ood. 60

    .. 18 80 411' " .... ,1'108 t... ,)!eobje.'1"8 \t. the 8lJ1). leo,,:v.t1 t... ..t '0&0,,1 .. or 1.'.ftoe. 'It the aatlo1patloa of .. ao'loa 18 '{DO . - '. before 1 had. ".tact.d. lIOU14 It.'he ."tlfdl.-"

    ft. tlIll pe l ..,' Ot"',,18, a latinotloD bet ... 11 , aM; 'loa, 18 to .81 '.')$, ,"0 ~h

    .. of 'tbe po 1'b1." _.41ela'.,H8'04. 11he objeot-l.y.,1m,4 \\0 . 80,.1 .. to ,,,. "ph ... It 'he INb-.teot1.. .BUf; al .. ~.hl,. \)O\mda., the' ... ,,.ar', a, '.,111 :, s08e,.'''--; ., wk .. I:thlu "ba" I 11111 4.0 th1 'M:', t '" "b_ - 18 .0' fe' aD .ro'loa. an4 111 - 1 .-, ... 1', 1\; 18 " 11' 1 '1, 41.'lno" t.OIl .otlonl ' l'ttl'.l t 1tl 18 apo lbl1,l tl 1. .,10h 'he lnt .... , of tl_ ad: 0" ... l.ltf al 4, t,l 1,_elf. 'Ie 41.11l'e.tt.$teue aa401JJ.-otl.'1t,, of tho\\8:h' are OIl'. '''.'0 ".'41 .... lfe4, _eall ..... ellt, ,tm4 " 1",111., ... oiloa". 1., ho14 or 1t.6,

    Aa4 7.' '11. real 1('. 11 flO' toM OO!lt\l.e.s wlth ':118 .X-toraalJ , l' OOll81.,.t he "eolaloft wt~e"b1 0 14eDt1. tt.. hla .. lf vl:tfh .he aoIlMa'ot' illl ~ho.,gb'. KlePllegaar4 111t.Jatr.' 'h18 br ,.U,1_ of _be 1 1,. who p , tn. UD 'WbO ~~," He. ro'bbM. It. tll1.,40 .. the PO.", he Npttt'e4

    ,

    ,be, he baA 80.' u:, ,. '_ .,D4 Nw .. e4 onl, ." t,t,a4 bim _"',ble &0'1011 ... atlU_I.04 OIl. 1.epl'. ottine tao~ that be 00\114, 1 1* -tt ,. 480181011 10.-1:7.64

    fta, ........ 1 'loa 0'''. '.D4 . be 00111\1 4, with -1 .o.ta of 11.'-101'8. 111,e.tlou8, appftoxl. ~';: ... t" ~-:=t r:~l;o a~:;~hl. -:!t ':r':l!t Ga 'M 00& 1'" " 1 _4 tbat lUlt ttll ~ ~t '~'. ,.,1.1.. .',OOBrStP~but;.t:'O 't.he ooDtu.ltm w1 'tb. walon .. An h ... , .. 11118 . J

  • - ,1 ..

    IR '111,. 00& ot1OD, ltl kepap .,,.a ot tbe .'h10al "'* .e ,be .... 1.1' of e, ,Ulllla'e ... 1IM.'6 ale 1.

    *lon',,". lta." 'loa ,1D"" '0 ,he aubJeot aD4 ltd 1ree 1D 'hla b lfl ... 1 .. ot 18 ....... to Hall 'be ,ruth. a'?

    al.rene.tl ... f 1JlwaNll 1 '0 ube .u'b~.tlitl tUDk .... 40 '.1. retleotlO1l. Ia 'hlU,. _ , .he unt 1; lIu' a. eal.,l_'la 'hI. . '.a" ae a l.1,-

    -1rJ& 1" 18 all iawar , .. "~ .... .... ope aubJeotl tr 1801., 4.'

    ,

    ., ... ,.18 .... POD'. 11 k_ca"" .. \1801ate. anoth -30. 'h 18 ',e.'191.0, 18 the "'Ob. A;11 other fleri.1tloDa or tJru'll ... tal ,lt 1 t the 14eb.l', of thought fm4 MUlg. a.,puth 18 8 ... bjeo'1y1t7 .. 4 fN"jeotlvlt" 18 the ~ruth. n. '-e.' app;nAell81oa .f ',. ,:pu$h 18 preo1 .. 1, '''e ... ,1\." .e are 'old .__ obJe lye17 'here 18 no tP\l'h tor exlet1q 1841v14ual8, '., GIll, app ... 1M,llea.10 5"113_0"1,,.11 the 'rut1\ .~.1.'. to. 'MB lD. 1awardD.e , _06tt 'he deola,t Des. of 'be t.uti" leto ... , .... ,1a ,he aubj, 'lyttr ot tbe 1_1.1-4Gal. w. ttD aft 8ft .... OODol,e"et1rJ.lt10D of th. truth aal tt_ obJe l.e ...... l'D:tF be14 taa' 1n aa, approxl .. UloD p.oo., or ,he ... , 1_'. la ......... ?l

    All .t 'h18 w111 MU"j)r-1atna only it we for,., the OOD" 't 1D .1ob l\l,tOUlld. "t8 po.ltlon .,,1 tftOM an artaly . t. of H' ,:1'. approaoh to Ohrlatl 1t, the t1'11sb ot

    epee.la,l.e p'il,1108opbl' bl-l!l"a ,_ tl\tth 1Dto belDe. 'The 'rutll. 1. 8:0t fl t 11 .... aM t~. ua4e:r "41n,, ot it ... lt84

  • ., 1'4.. ltD_ we look tor ,he ... pl.tlow ot 'be ..,...'1&'_1

    ...... lUMllaa . , .. , 810b a1_ 'Olla briac ,be 'ru.th ia'o Mi.'. ,fi11 11 e .... _01... _ba. the _owl" ot noll .. 1."))bf le1 own 0))'.... .utla, l' cm1, 1m it

    ... _,,1 .., IIMtltcull'ltNlltr taDOt j t .. 111-P teo~ 'ruth ,.. tNt'tloa '-7 80.1.4&. J tlba' it l' 1. so'.',h . '0 H llveA arui ,hi. pJ!i.lmarll" lhua , ... the _.'1'11 _'loaM tletlD,l'lOD of .1'\1'b.

    We 40 ItO' 1.'.D4 to 41.0... lCl,en.ga .... f. JlOt10D or t.l.~h

    G.tl1ltW:)b later, b,,' l' .. at 'b. Pta.opt.at tat bi. 4.(1111-'lOB ot tru'h vas to. h1. " "eteD.. of .. t tel thUAft8. '01' 'ble .... ,OD. be 41.0..... .It; 'h.la '1,.'. ...la1ii,ollablp ot Imowl . ~ .. to faith iimd a,rotIuo hili pather })iMrMOOJlOap' 0,' the a\)fJUI*4. We wAll bav. '0 t ... so tll.cul.lon of all tbi. to. 'hepnMnl. ..4 Kleaa t ... w., 18 14 ,_ Nlatlcmahlp . 1M ..... ~1l .... 'loa.fte , ... _ we llaye 01"4 alNa4J 11 us a t.11'17 ao04 110'108 otWha' n k .... r4 UIl4 tooct. by 'hi ... 1.',1011. 0uP 111 ... '1 .. tor 'be .... 11248. of tbla p ..... _ "o1;lea .111 _e , 40 'he e,,1t ... 1a to. 41a,lD-

    tah_ the _"oula'lY. tr . 1_ pr8O'leal aa41how 'bat It 111ft .ale la a 'PI ,-_ leResaaftf .thought proper1J

    "

    tall.. Lb il_ , 1U w111 \18 .. 11 *ow ,bat lb ..... lou. 4.,.. o.f a'b .... otloa wnloboo ttl"" be .,.,oulatl.. oNer 41tt qlll' atloal1y .... "' 40 act 00 '11' ... ,. aD 1-all ... a __ of 1:1 ... . .. ......... rk .... 14 .... ,.0 inAl .. ,-_ '1.,,111 re..... to. the l~lat.l' tel10wlaa etlO1l, the 41e-

  • ,,-

    .... 1 .. of" , .. 48ft.lal &0. 8il4 p18o'lloal 'ruth .b .... we hope ..lq top1lNt. all .Ita. .ItS ... . ~'. hae '0 -Vb thl ... , emA 0' '. 'pe l' wttth en. eM.' ot 1'_ :tho.... We beptl -..... , to __ "th _._ .a. be kep' what .et be M-JeoStHlSa ,be 'h:.' ,.t &len.,aaN.

    vu. K1 epa_ .. t ... 0 ,.De .11la to lat ... nt OD ~he Qecra1a'l aa4. Pl'Aotleal 1 11 ,.,_ : '0 .1e-

    ,. ,

    'a' ., .. , .. , ..-48.t he ,.,.ft., aD 18tlq 1D41yl- .. 1 &1 .. ,. hall a .1 " aa4 thai) "' 1.1. t.b18 that the ,...'1 .. 1 4&tt .... , ... 'I. 1PtJ.1I1,.'1... 08-' ,hi. MeaD ,., 'Il_ : ' .. t4a'lv ....... , bay ' .ea4 o.'.loa' I 18 how I. A. Salt" , ... ,1.'.. .he pa ". 1J.a qu 'l ...

    =:,. ~~,~~ .. .:=l:!t "l.'~:':' ,.- '.t" . ',' . ~~.t ........ '0 .N! ea4. 1...' .... ' .. 1 (1. 4ltte boa 1Ibl4. . ."...1&t''' . l ... ebaNrote f " ... 4) '"

    1'1& t . ,1IIp1, ....... 111 ._ aD ...s. 'ae' .1t. p .. ot1081 1a-,.11 0 41tt fr.. 1&tt.e, but 'b., dltt "eeau .. ,., M 41ff ....... "

    Dlo_.II, fl\lM tMo.lou.al " o,le. Al ta. ' , .',.epeeala" ... ba.' p .. 1m.

    Y lta' , ... .... 148: '_ pao,t,l ... "e .. It., ...... , ': . 'lUI oJt41... m op 1 .... t8aq .. a 1D t1 .... '

    I' 18 aeo .... 17 .e .... pl 'b18 41tteren08,Noau 8t .... 11 ,tt18 tbe proJ)e:r 41tt ... 110._ ,",twe .. the

  • o))J ", ...... th. praot,lea1 In'.llBot wou14 kao.,put,h 10 .a '0.p17 1" to .... oper.e'10 "epeotllat'lYct 1ft,.ll.ot

    , , , ,.. '"

    Ii le. DeO UP7 o\)Jeo,.vlllob. ... )\C. operable ob3.0,. tor ue; tlle 1' 1)10.1 b'ol1eotle lat ,." onl,. 1ft ope;rabl. _Jeot '16 ,

    ,1'ttol1e ta1;t -.lIe 804- of .... 1~4,.ftlt,lOft will al.e. 41tf tor _ .. eoula,lve 0 ,..80.1' blAt l~ know. t.-o It-8 p.l.aolpl J ' p~.o'leal, ao4.1~ oal1.ed compo.i-'lye ttm4ooasl.'. 1a 1718& fo ... to ltIl'tel'.?7 low, al-

    we _ .. y.~ haye ': tl0.1, Do.le"',. of a lIO .. operable , "",..a .,'1 .. 0,. .. \)18 olJJeet ill ,"1 ,.,

    ' .... loal.o ,,~; 18 la, "S.". l'8f .... oe .. tbe .mal ad'h.l

    .. til,' ':'. 8011108'11\4 allq~04. OPCl1Da_r" al0.' arttte" 1) ... 001\0.,--

    tonta 1$ 11,1&. la ..... ,' '. 1M" .... ', ' 'uuc, eat ao\upNo,leaoltlo, et oCtP'lt1.,1a

    ~-.. ..PO " ",14 ..... 111811111. '10 SOD __ . aott\oP41 tR&PJ

    ::0:: .. :-,.:":::: :..i:: ~:.:'!:!:!;t 1."~A.l'J . , nttlfl , qtl04 " ... ,. prae"l-

    .. ~.!l "'.1 -1~". --- _A~~ ." '.' '.1 ..." :~~.B . , ~. '-.v ... ' ID 4 of . ka_r18 ..... a44e" l,.,p1011 of p otloallalow-ldp. Ii.. 08D&OQ.ll&.l.. }ll lf wi '-tl all the a'epe, .eo ...

    , . -,

    ... , to ... ..... , .... 108 ot .. Bora aa4 ,.' pl.'end '0 ~ .. 'Il .. '\t" ;~~ .. ~." '1 ,.1. ... ,.. ~~A,6~~.1.4~.,' .. .,o,fb..a t- ~- .'AftI:.ft: l' .,.1" ' v.,~._ ~. ,. . V 'IlL .~~. ~W ... , ,,~, ~ '. ... ~..,.. w-w-,.

    , ,

    :p~'loal 18 "bla lnt) ".lODI 1' tlleot .rut. 1KHl8 an both

    , ... ""0&1.

  • ." ..

    ope .. b1.:. bu' "or "M .. atlt 18a apeou.latl C0Il814,.ratl,on. _ . " eo\llatl"o bowl ,,-lohbeaPI 01) a DOR-Operable obJeot w111 be 1ft 8'0 wln prflotloal, top l' ..... 1'. to nem. of tbe opl;'er'1,& top 'No~lo1..t1 we have 4:ob,eo\,II04.

    '."l,t -7 aco14enl;al11 .fteot a'ft1on" &., for 1nsteoe, the conal ",'loaot ,.1111 li~r'a11t,. or the Hul.

    ; . ".t .... t~A ex,nae. ot.ll1pl1 .,..',tla'll Jmowleq. a.t1.c~l kl1O'.10 tf~~ bave two '1:P wblob are

    c.o.ulatlv...4", ",: pn,otlcal .,9 oa,. w111, be " 0:.1 .. 1 OD.l,. as to 1t,. . lee" and 18 oa11M

    ra410Itll, p ... '10&1. ."Ml. ls pp.0.1)10.1 bo.h, a, to ita O'bJ.01l &at" 1'. -M_ of .,0001tt.rat,1,oa. anA 18 p,paotloal

    .. :1' 18 'bAt DO_fl_S. _iehll eilQ)l, 8peeulat1.e .10ll 184,18:'11 1Ih ecr41c '0 the tn... d . pees of 6b.,rao.1011.1O

    l'le .:1'41, De.8.rr to .a, tlla' Iter_paN'. tnteR.' 11 . tl lJ'" 1801'.8 ... 1. fit 'lte PNert,toa,l, bU1;l' 18 80_-

    ~A""A~&~.. ,.~&~'.~:.d ~~ . .I- . ":W;~ .f"~~ ~"700."; .... .", ~~ __ 1B.V. ~ . 4.f.~_~

    Ia 'lil ..... , it helps UI WN. 1.n . "lI\Ioh lION t ... orable

    1.' .t ':hIm- 1101114 be, 1_1. it .. ~o.n't}'~.,. to be uDlver. 18 ap;plloa"111t,. -St ... , Ill ,,., be' ... _bered ,hat 1

    speak of tn. Hl1810"8, la1fllloh .. he oJeo,t". ,blatt . -he. :1' ..ak'8 .ela:l at, ,1.p~ol 171pr..11S1oul'. -81 'The ooapl.1ft" 1JJ;p1, ,hat e,en the Malt le(t18 an ~lJ.H'lon.

    .' :-j ~

    "

    ,

  • ..

    ~ r.l1 t'h1:ftk: abo'Qt "'ttl to bii 40De, .,111 v'.1' aooo .. ~1~'~~1~ ~'h6 "~a~ iIP , ... ~l.,;if{; ~ ;;'*~ -ua.,A; "

    '" , 'M'- fte 'k.' _ ..... 18 a &'1'&4a,1J;lon: tr(}m tbe simpl, .lHtC1a~.'l .. 'Ie tbe. "l" .. ot1 1,._ it, would '. ,bat .Ilerke ' : ," , '00 ._ ".Dthl. , e t.....S.ofAl:1 ht. stat ..

    ,

    _'a or 'he '.111 ta.- 1. whl.h the 4181Jttel' 'te of " "esl 'bo _'latN:" ',", .. 4 sbo:, ,t, .0 ..... r to

    leH 11 1, 1. at 'b.l. polat , n. k., pan .. ,. with , aad we c811 h1s ~li' . ot the ab act ',1\01. t P:' 'fMi ., ,. epeoulfl"l 1Dtellee' wltb II l1t,tle

    tal.,a.l".... !hl . ab .... ot~ '1\ou 1),il_.1d, al ... ,. pre n a relatlon ttl _:.1.".0..'" ItAt 1,' exl.ten hera mean . thl.al ~4.ayouJ', we would lift.,. ,tjo IaUA a fe'. eli.tinotlon. beto".uree ; 'One 11 N'.:POD.11blelD. lUl ethlcal manner tor 'ke tl118 he '0.0'.8 to speoulAt.ion t b'A' pJ.'iU,deDC8 1'18,7. DO .ol~.l 1e!l08 aa euoh. lathi. all. ,bat kl.rlc.paM ..... I,ll be 8,q,

    60l1OD1& 111'

    1. .... '1.1 D.w1 ~1~~1 UO .sl$hR.e. or 01111' au.a D(4twl:." .. aD ...... tla1 relation-8blp-. 1.' 08 1 'I .. ~tlal lm;cwle4ie. ,All 8.wl ';~.' .1 4ce,. DO' 11, reute 1, 11 to .X~. " t 1a" , fleo'lioa Of"lDlfa.r4m....18, ..... '1al,ly "11 ... 4.. a.ol1, k~.wl.4&., 1'. 4 __

    '.. all;' e.. t. e'Hatlalli 1rt41tteHD'. That '1.1 _~~.1 ., 1. .."l1t18,111 vela ted to laten.a ,._ Dol .....,he abo,. __ .... t10."" 14eu'lt, whlob,.t,PaO' tbo\\' \ 'Mi. _'weell tkOUllht and Ml1l3; aor l't 81 1", obJectlYell. tat k:rlowl ' r... to .... th exl.'teDt al 1 te object. , It ... _ ~M,\ n'twle4~. has .. relatlcm-8' to tbe bo .. r, -0 18 s .. tl$l17 :1m es18tlag

    iv14tl&l. an' tort.hle .... ell all elaential ,kDOW-11 .... 1.11', .-1.,., to lat ea. ISB;Lz

    ',; ;1 '1

    ,

  • .... --.. .' ".l}irl4f'-

    WOvti,ll, ot att'8.'loll tor en. who ls real11 11.1q, ex1etlng em e , aaok o,111ta,. of In:w.a:r4ne ,.thle '.4ell01 alllp8

    \ -

    11 "8, .. " 'wlth hoo18 of pbl1oe, Wl-t};l .bleh h.e haa other .. wi 11"$.1. 1a 00..... ' pltb18 pea,CMfJt of h1e thought a~, with 'ttl %14, Ill1 elS8 1 oofJ4al7.

    ft.~. 4atf-4iltl tMito.allar1 f-~o~ 'h1ItJreo()p1t,loD 11 ,bat .. --7 .,'01 - 1,. d3eet1Y- a l'Attle anti, make thJ~t Wl110h t ft .. l\'\ifiii 1-- 'f.\~;rA - -~,,- .a~i~A'~~~.;' .~~6_n.t liU'ft"*~"~-" &1,v...o-1 u i, V>1i._ . ~ ~\ii~ m~:~ W~~~ii~ ijjf~ "I~A~ -.v w . . '_;Y~ iit.," '* --ill v' . w- II .

    'vonal17 It 11 a _.11 ohaa"fJ, \rttt it, 81plt1 . , t.bat tne w.1"14baa "fJ_ toO. .. Y.~ RIOI18. ',he ~Olt i.portent tbla" 1 x18t.n.oe .. 4 l' 1. 1D ,." of 1\1* 'hat the value of tll1aal 18 oOIiPU'. 1,1e~kei"r4. 41.t,I'ion ot ,""owle4,. 1e .erta,lDlr 010. thlll lor$ of ~lterl0.. l.l;lewhE);re. 1ft

    .. re,ee'. the1nte':f"pre'1iati,0Il " .t oz. 1811 1& a aur. to. otl'l,.... pr.r.~l:Di.o .erstaD4 It ..... '1 tbe Score'tic .. n ~~t .a,oh~m 11 hl. 0M1 _ttn~", Jl81t,h cre BO'r 1 . ~.N on. 00\1,14 acce-pt 'ble, but 080. al~t!t-1n 1, atter 41.tlllegt~t.~lft1. Xl.rlte ..N 1- eubJectlyl.-. alob he bl 1t 03118 aoo l.a8?

  • --JJ\l '. - o.~ ~;ffl"u-.~l ~A"l.A~ .. '.~ ... 1J . ,.,L ~~ft:~l. ,"''',~~ ,\_~.i'Wn .,'40-

    _baa it 18 "all. &p-,11 tht1 ,a . Dot10ft to :t . 1th. Wh6tl. he 4.:mi 'tJ:1at talt.b 1. &ll7thl., m(~H ~h.1m It w&,0(11f., tmderato04.e " ooat1l1uoaa po.ltl,Dg. ()f a8tlOD~, and thttit IIpeo,ulatloD 8:bo\l' .t11. 'Ntbe ott.ltr~l. '0 make th un-

    ,. '\tls1l &ltd. Noo~,cl1., btlt t;c UJ5~7 antlpa:rtoomJ>8n". But 111 .~, 41ceua.kler:k .&r4. D01l1011 or 1'01'.1,&10:b. until t...coal .PAn .fls .... ,

    xl.~tl,al ,he:,'. aa4 tlutltwl'ti ;jar4 -.0 '.b.18 la"' e ln~c,rNuc ., 4.t181t.1oa of ,ru.tb 18 'opm. ot 8u.bjeotlyltl. OUt" &l1e1,1111 hal Jola,." au' wtmt aU'I~ Mv.'. "'.:en ol,vloul to

    W l11 ao onaow to Ii o0D81uratloaot 'he p.u4ent1al ,lWlg-MD'an4" no,,1oa of praot1oa1 1)1'\1.11., -alnul_ wl'l1 :rho.latla 4,OO'lr1DeIlM. -.klq 1oatSoaM Itl k.g . I'4.~h1. w111 11' the "'~.I .. r1 '~nsl'lon, ~4 pr.pa~ft:tl0A. tor tb,8 Klerk-

    :..>18n 'heo., ottDtl.1Not comIia11, t1GD, wblob w. w111 u'n A_. ~~81 ~.~- ..... -

  • \

    _.t we bay. 'ilua tAP 111; 110rke ' ",: lnd10 .. ' tftat M ... po,l=atcJ1 the a.'lo:c. of p,..tit1oAl 'N~b whlob .. tlD4 80 l\lOl41,.xp IH4 1. th,,. "bought Gt St. ftoua. ft. DaD. 1.'.lgh'blepPolll\1 ~l~, lt ',. the 1:.0 ab.rPtl'loDa we MY" alre., '. 884. 11.tor,11 .et-th.' crl' le of th. 'rw.th .f lluzMa, .. '1, .... ,,)a, hep '1\11 u tate41D' the, He11aD aaDD.r 1a ,. 80 .... _ .. OM ...... 1 .. 4 4oo".tne

    - -

    or PI'. "10 'Il'U' ' ' tG\1D4 1" W'1111aa l ..... l. 10. oaa kaowl.,I11_ .. ttlo. '0 .. 1., our' '1 .. what 1t oua;ht GO "' .. will ......... mt.l11i .... oaamo' _ ao, e 01r'OWlS'_." llt'.left .. e.' aDd will al".7. ..e laa4e-qua'. a,. a ppoxl"' O.A or .. "loa. Wewlll ti.e" _.alD. Wbat ,he -,.110 :000_.. ..1.4 008 .... 111.1 ,."110'81 'Nth.. 8Il4 how' Ilia 400,'.1.. .. hl.. .8 ,. ._ .. eill 'h. ,.. pe.l t1,oa.

  • ., 'c . A. ' ... '

    41 ... , ._l .. ttell \thl011 art OU' otKlerke,aar4' s , 1.1'011.

    1 peo\ll.,l .... , .u". 18 .,.lna4 b, " ocmtol'1l1t7 of 'lu): _d "0 -Wilat 1,., aa4 81aoe 8u,ol\""0 .. 1., OaDDO' be

    ~, 1. aeoe._~y.. .8 ta ... ape.lAlli_lve bablt;ttl (01),0 ... 84 w1tt\ '118 00Dt11\&--,I .. ooat.-.a, . 2 Aa w. ba en, the

    , .

    pb11 ... ptlr' of a&trun. ,tj l' haa e" 'ita ooj ' 'thiD._ ol~ ooa~lqea~f toe.110t 8tu47 tbell i8;,.o.,Ilq8 . t wt

    __ eatra.1i QU the .. 0 ..... ' walch ;1 . aave4 en lnoont.1D-pno,. t~l.o. t. J;1'a.\lcal iatel1eot 18 ooaoerned wltt~ COD-

    t .... _. apeoul.atlveblMlleoi.

    Verua aut6. latwtlleo'.a etlQl aoalplt"r per 'OO8fo.-1 'a' &4 ,.t1 t.1i nottlll. Qu.. qu14e. 'oOJlf ... ili.... .... arl1. lOCUli DOll _01.\, qua. Yoluatate au- DOD flUBt I 4. 801ua lit eo.'lbulquae poe.un' a Dob'!. fleI'1,. 81'1. ala' l11a

  • 8u:sla 'blll aHa .tp .... l .. 1"pq'h w. tled, 'hat 'h ... a" two yl.,uee tthioh p." .. 'tlle p .... '1 1 1.,.118." .. , and pN4eDCe. W ... at ....... b 'the ..... 41tt ,sa 01'4 Dot'. oontu .. ,be .... ot $lie ... wl'h ' r,f", ,hi. '8 aD 0 . , .. t. , ..... '10De4 abo

    AP' In'tblaooaneetloa 1.8 _ IJ)'D0DYlIOUIt w1 tb t,1n$ art , .. " "ltl.. al 1. mll1t..ralib,. A., a yir'ue .11,1 be ".t 1 of ,. tJtlq t. be '',.;It 18 Dot t'n. 1004 of ,'artl.' -1. It wou14l r., btI:t rat"" ,be ~. of 'be olJ.....l.b .1.11 NI.l. t.OfI bl.. 'rime 1 ,i.e aottYl t,. ,_ p s .. al 418 .1't ... ot'the raker .-. 1 . Nl .... t., wM.t .. "... 'e "ba' tlbat _ llak.. 1. ,1004. tfJ t,h1. art 1. like

    ':.,1 yl ,'.l1 1.'4,0 DO' sat'e" aetn tho .. the-.. 'lel.. t8 .1.~.4 4.;p.......'. . __ak.. .. anltra tlO11, '

    t

    1t oa1, hl _ .... tl .. 1 ...... - .tt _1,. 11 4,.. to art 'a ..... 1t 1t 1., .oet ... ttt, 1Ilv.a ,11., 4 OH ft b, the aft1.', it be la'tID'''.'. 4'raw a _.t.l~ aD4, d .... a 1lOD8te. tbAm ..... p.rlorae4 ltta _*.$

    tbe oa. wbo aata 100d .' ,.

    baa a" lute ...... _.I . 'U8 18 IN(ttl b80&US. l' pertecta "

    1\ Si %) '&081', " _._ l' ..... &. 'i,. WON 11 ;1>",4.n" 40 hi,.

  • The ...... t.-

    18 ' .... 1.1 ott .. _ ,.,.. 18 a '_ . 4i!..A~.Afi "'0" .. ~"tA~ 6a, ~Ji.l'I!lJl.ft... ._wac9i'it((j"~" .,Is .. 11 ..... ..,.". ~- 9.""" ' W. . ". '., .~V~ ._ ua4 ... ~. W .. 'J'Jl'.~if;~. ~ "'UV' ..... Dol . '. .... ,1. .. aotloa Wl\&01\ is ltr ... ertt ,. t'be agellt tA\Oh ..., 'ma. 7, .. te ;10 ...... 1Il. &o'clO11. aloll UM , ... p.loua po",l ot- b .. or~ 't1e .... war ...... pw .... 8.- 1 .. 11.&11" Aa4 81a.e la hWllm 8Ot. ,.

    1.,. -~. *108 1. 4t..peal tloa 1a ,be

    : ' . ,lple, ~tmc. pre_,Il!!to... goo4. , wi.

  • 1"'1.'0, fa. 'il." 1" Mea oyerlO(fketl . i_orad or d .. l~ 17 lIeD of , ... , lBtelleo,.al 8,O\'&JIe.I'I dl.t1no_loft 's "th.t be-,.... ,o.l,~' .'. ' _ &.'10.,"1 .. 08 arut Y1rtue. There 1 .. rill Golea . 8 an4 \h.re 1 . ' ,be Yll'tue otpNAeIl.,1 to ocmtu 1; s. ,,,. 18 'Co 00 "0UI!4I er,,'a fOUl' pPe ... ,paPPO 1. 1l0' .. 'ra .. the 1\1.'017 ot 9be ooa,...1 .. , but R'th to ))OlDt

    ~~ . ~., aAl~Il----I ';i!,lj 8- .'.,a, .. ~ .,".-A ,~,. vM9 .~, ~ vV'. r"~ . ., __ .,~ a4, . ~~V9A .... rea.OIl .1'~' " Cl.,. nM \\0

    , "0 btiM1:l eot.. ftllYert1. ,4;er'ln,l tlorl oan ':\)0"8._8.1 ... eoatu81cm.

    " 1. 81,tloe' '. I.IIIiIiI.,ilte' . ._ ....... , ~ AD~ .. ~.: ~' . ~~ '. .

    leo_., . "'t ea. . .. 1a.:11 ... atJMlutft .~ ...... II allu4e. 1tl'" Ga.' alalfttO,.a 410-''- .11b11 .1 1_ ,04 p'.: '18 all .lid e,' ltic.'.'8l "1 ...... 0'. _.'NnWa 18

    r'lCMlIU';n,. Bill 4u14, ~ quU.ter, .'0 . cal.taB 01' ".'.e ....... ,.,._ 1.8 1;0 'Ihl. 01,lalO1l elaplloatloa , '.e ... a~1e 111-.11eotua11, to CtSbaue' '1. olpo\tll._aao.. ,of .,,1* .. '10U8 .. 4 80 judge ,bat we au.' do tbl. or ttU- 1m ROb Nl4 au,.h t bleD.A true lft,.rpre, t1oa ,of 'be 4.118,1'1011 1. t11ft_ p:ru 18 -.lght '""':08 OOllGe"'1ft6 b1HlaB aot. .... f1... It, ,be ... 'lt184 4 11*. ot. partloulaP

    . -U", 'lal 41rt.,.,.. here 'I "b.at .pPlMl;onoe 18 aot. oemoe1"" wl'~t. ,he l1ml'. of 1& .. 11.0'" bu' d.,.dent Q!1 S.lIebblq .... 14. 1.,.11.0., .... 11 1'>.., app.'l te.

    . I

  • : 1 .. ea' 'OIl .petl'., GaD 1M ..... eD, .. conllA that tbe r lAO'.' pnA .... 18 , 0..... 'M Nt. tJ1r8. aot.

    ot " OD Ifhloh Mal" on .... eta, top tl ' we take ooun .. l, WB!I6' tkl 1, we ao~ ,hllol' _.ut

    mw .. tlp:lt '-0 hay. '.1p

  • ,00Di ..ll, S.po l,bl1e

    , ' " .~ .. '.".'.",.,~.:.' .. ' ~,'.'.!.'._'.",' . :.~ . 4I.".1 O.,'.,fD.l>.~.l,~.,.:!., O.'.l,'.OBtOr-.....lJJtalll_,: . w.., wWoWVA u. V.v ,

    ,., 1\0. 801 08 _.era. " .. 11 with the .. 'oozl"lq"'a. ''I 1. tor re .... ' ... ~le. 18 BUall an UDoo.rta1n 801enoe, Ml4 'ilia aot.all wllenltwouldlp,aak of tblJii$. quite 010 '0 there.1a otaotloa. wt eYeD when It.I\\Ul.la~ fieDer.litl bleh -0014 em '0 GOVer eoert.ill area w1tb certltu4e.

    It .WI p .... l'allwa ."lam lD unl".,.. .. ll._ .it lDoer._ .~yarla1J111., .4b\lo ma,lllDo.t1t'''. .at .1quieyell,t 'erlu. d..aoeDte.. , 4 0 400tpUtaa 4. ;"a. l:a .1all. Hoc eua., ftoa .. 'It que ftt. a.... Beque StAb lqua ........ 10D8. Qula oa" ... 1.. ' 111,,'.,,'laIl,ur ,1.f181'18 a041a. tfa4.t,,4101uII ,11e rellDqul ... prudelltlae .al OlIS.aqua.

    1ft ... ,11 " 1. _er aD4. aoI11e" a 'oena1ft t~';h. The ~V"~ .. ~.et .... 1.01 ....... oD17 beot uII1 ... r 18,tO. the

    '.:la, 'ht8 1. ,. M ....... tOH .t OfItWH cmll of tbe prop p.-1 .. 1p1 f __ , 1 ..... 17 a. .. aN \lDl ,..l. of whloh we Wlepe&H_' __ .. I' ... 8114 ,,"on ,aPe ',he 0 .. _ prinoiple

    t .... 1 801....... tmbolpl aN tho,'" ot ...... 1 la., , ~b. mtelleo, l bahl' 10~i perfH'. UI 111 'hi1 "egfD'4 1.

    D;OWll _ .... 1 11 ,'.' . ,pope.prlDcl,pl ot aora1 8018110e ... 41 . .,01"81 .. 8" \1.414 f.o. ,be GO .... PPlDo,lpleal8a whloh l.th ....... "'1 of ' ,11' r, 6) 1'&11',. Conolu-810D8 ~\loe4 tr.oa thea .re 1 pal '''Btl 60001'41 '.' 1

  • o ... l loas _.... 1 8"'1 ..... l rl.l ttla4mil tOW.Nthe pa.,'ealar __ , 'OV8N a l1m1'_ Ythat 1. 1s .. l1mt Whloh aoral .. len .... "0\ .... 1\ bal alrea41 beea 8\1,ftlo1entlJ labON4.

    't.....1111 .. '0 a ooae14eN'lcm of 'be act ot Pf\l4enee, 1\ wG\1l4 "_.,. be 11 t. GOD.lea a rather INr-,.labs 1Bl

  • _."A_A .. l~AhA . .. A9~VW .. ~.~, , _

    ao,., 1e the la".'1cmot' tuumt dlreotl1to applr hie ,. a.tl~oa. Wlth "he app.araDee or th18 l!lMntlcm,

    801.Doe 801.11 15 no 110" aDd. we ar. ilu.ala,'ell' 1n the real. ot .1..... Or.l th18 oon4 polDt, 'hen" Johnot St. ' ..... 18 UDtorlvaa'el, .or1. out w1th ,. loa'

    k~l.b ........ ,; "e' to hla t11'at ,olllewlli,oh waa 80pal 801e,floe lDolu411lt$, pN4.u t kl po. lfl,ltpoB,lJlbl.;, evetl leal .. 0 1.able .... ' ~l.tlG position. Th'!l auli \tlttich exltlt8 .. , .... aop.1 aole.M .~. y1.\ue ,has alread"f) ~oa. degree a ... auI'M. It. ftoaaa, 1'1 .a~14 e_, 18 111"'.78 Quite . 1 .... '.t .01er;l .. __ 4 vl."wtJ a.e _ .. '1))04.1.

    1. 4., qulbu8,hlof1' mentia, 1D ttmtwa ... 'ape.,l.. ~.t\t1a., 11l4UAn.1)u,. DOD 1n .... tl __ 1& .... 1. __ " MDeft' allqtl14 1" PIt,l.. .... 1a _tin 801a ratlone. 41o_~q ..... .."l.'lM .. pnolAue so1110.' _\\hloa, 08. ca ., poll_loa

    . l.,lloa'lOJUJ of '~1. a1 ".ta,t.~'.Jl"t would. 8ux-ell be ono.11 to va,,, saalae' .,he staat! "B,loh John baa 'akea.

    'fbe at ... __ _ .at..- 4.18 ,e1fC till. po.ltloa 18 that we M. th. 1 ....... t .. 00 ta1." 1;"1"\ eolm1ce 18 am

    ., tlM,' ... 11 .e ;8U 1. t oan proo.e4 111

  • ... 8 ..

    1\ ".'1481 ..... '".4 .... Mlk UN ot ,De , t 110.81 .01 .... D, .... p'lnC ..... 1 . 1ea tro" 1ts 'he '.1 . , preal

    - .

    of it. ,...t1 .. 1 8,.11-.1 , ..... 1'. prooe4\lre '.,ea4a Oft ,-'.111 .. 8I1al,118 ot .a18 .,11 - -M "Ill ehew. M ... l .olemo. Dol_Sal pI'WS8Doe 1.. ... , .. 410,10ft lJlH"..toP .1\ would iJlpl, .. aalnlD1 wlthla the lttdt. or 1 11.,0. _, ,ft, aohi lq '&0,1011.. Roral "1__ t. ao~ pI\14 0.; ll.u48Uoe- 18 Dot

    - ,

    aoral _aleDO be Dote', howe.er, tut l' 18 of 11t~1. u to 'the 1ntell.ot '0 pupa aoral 1018ft ,top the tPUtt! _hloh oan btl had r'l'OtI ,uoh stulf

    81 l'1.1tl0 .,1\1. 8018,18. e . e' ad 801- :t:-'iuV ... 114 !:;. ':.~ .:~:: ;:.~t:~8J: pert ,; .... 18k11eo ..... 11104 al1,.18 copo.oat yerlabl1 v.~l tat.. tlnSlmtlum opelf.bll.lulI, ou .. (lUAe '.lrt .... .. -

    1. .... 1'''4. whloft ... 14 ...,1.'.1,.~.1 eN' tal .. b.ood 1. aot to be _4 la tl .. 'u.tl .. tt., 1' .. ",1 1 .. 0. GOBald-e.8, 1t ,. DO' 8peoula1)i .... lcmoe 1. , ...... 'h.1J .he ... '11 DO .. 1a .... ,.,. '.'1."11, ' elm ".'l na It 1. e pl*&ot10&1 1 .... _ .a .eh 1. u; '.l toP ';M .... ,. 41 .. 0-

    111 __ aot. _.Nt aN .... taotto . ;'ob. ooaa14.,..4. 'h. first 18 - ",118: wAlah 00 ...... 1, .. lt with the 4ata ot

    -.0 .. 41~t.4. ' ok ..... ' .. ea4. 810h 1. WIU,14 ... 11 , but tor ita_ .a Rob ;'b... 1. aD' ea44.'era1tle4 br tUN. O\lr kao"le'p of our \11t1, __ er.wt 18. specula.tlY. _tIer. 80t

  • ,,,,'1 1 -', ...... '0" 1t4 taOt 00 .. VDd l1ora1 .. 1 .... po,..l,. X1; 1 . 0 .... pr1aolple of ,bas eel ... e. ...4 1 .... p.iaolpleb p ... '1oal .. , .... J Aft "lvAm ~ .~;,.~ iiiO- Wha.- tiM k ... AI1!i.Ift6 it .~ ffft. .... ~W:." a-v- .-.. - _ ....... ~ ___ :.~ .,.~ ~ ......... ,:W ..... v,.... ,,~~.: tIAta

    1. ,. M ..-11_.. 1M ."..lte 411 '. it_l.t towU'd. the ..... 4 ..,ftIl 91n" "" ,,1\18 tat-eIltl... ~'ltle .. ~.1. amtaonll 91.-. t ... la. of oour , pru48ftH. PPa4..... _1. ... '., ....... 1.tI'04\10 ....... sa 41800 .. " WblOh '110 ,..81 ...... 'be,..11101pl f 't. ooa.lulloa.

    tl ' 11&prep l'1 .. tlerl 4f1toa 1IA, ... 1 laW. ." -8. , DGfL of ..... _ 1. CO be 80 -t18 ,. l ... ancl Op ....

    "-

    '1 .... 'The .. 0084 p~ 1.1oa 18 ",",lou1&1' '.'be ,., ,.,004 of ...... tie .. aa4 -... I.. .. . 'tt, 481111 tihle 'bate ... 11 .tad -" . 'waF, .'0. Dtta 0,_ ... he ,PPeM,' ., ll"t4 .... Wbl.h ,. ao'. Oa,." ....... ,". ,lIta

    ., _btl, 1 .......... ,....' .. 1 .. _10" 0: ... 1 , .. t ... I -"14 ... 0 _. P'tIPINe. ob ..... Ia'her

    .. ,.. .. p . ,. I l' 18 aD ... 1... ~b le GOa""" ... ...., up ... apSa it we 'hlak ot ,he .... lu.l ......... 1raao,,, "POpoal.1oa. tO'l' ,MIl plUd.no. we\ll4 H .. ftt17i1tJlt#l&lla.L~&atd.'ntll.

    ,. ta.. ""hla 1. JUt' .. i. alrea4r 14811' 1ft \he ".&Dels1oa'". ,.tl ... ,. __ oad. preat wbloh 1. DO' 1_41., a 1. wou14 "18 "..111atl.e .rUoll.... The .... of ..... 0BtI (prope.t,t 4epea4. OIl ,he 00841'1 .. ot 'he '~'. appe'l'. : l' 00110 .... ,. partloular e.,

  • a__ quall. _Iqul.que, t, tall. tlft18 81 .14etur,. 1fb.e , doea ftC. haye 11l~_11.e.u.1Q.rtl ha.of wba,t he should

    4'0 here and DOW, Iltl4 7.' th1. ls w." he ."'., 3udgm811t OD 1n ' aeoon4, :partlcular pr ll" on whloh hls aot1cm aep81l4 W. w111 reoall that st. ' oall,. th lt\lat,loft 1ft whioh ODe aat . ~lUJ. 1t 1. " tale DO ,_ oan '.11 for DO_ OWl 1 ..... 1'_ -. laftal" ot p08,1"111tl." the "'&1'1,.bl11 t, ot ,n. 81DpillP, 'helaok of ,.talftt, w1 tb ... gar4 ,. ~. ou~oo .. of .. , .. 40' '1M ....... , uk 10ll

    / \

    ,--.... J

    diffloult. We 81apl, _!lO' 'ooa, ... il1'ell,eotualll '0 'M flux, 1ft _lob. ..... , a." J ... 4, .a Ca3.... 1878, be who wou14 poalt 'he ,..f.(1)l011 of 'M p ot10a1 1DY1180' 1. lmOwle4,e 81_ OfR\J1O' 8U.~t 'hl. 4,lttloul".2, In a woJ'4 .. tl101l wouldM 18po8,.lltl. If we tlret ba4 '0 eaau., the 01.0 ...... 0 Sa AD, Sa1Mtlleow.l ......... '''fMloxloall, ..

    , , t".GOa"'.... t,00_14 MV. ,. be '1\\. J we coulet Bot t })1 '118 ,aM tokeD, .. fYalD t'.OIl aotlOft, to,. we would not hay. lBt.lle.wld .... 1,.4. 'Chat 'hi ..... ,. ... 1 ,11)1.. It \h18 1 1.' .... OB \11 ..... pcb' ..... 8"rtmp to tbe reat1.- , 1., bl. reoa11 w1 tit the tlft ... lDe.. whlch!.. 0\11'8 the 8 .. 0 whloh ."en ,h., Yep, wl..- 1184eb tbl ......

    ,,'

    Wha'.~ .. our approaoh, .. to,. OOlle baak '0 _he .... polDt: Dowl, and ao'lon are 81.11 no' "he__ 1shUlg. lmowleagea1_ oaDltO' Not1f},"8 wl'" regard '0 "hi. aotton,. Aa4y.' tMe 60'1011 .. a' be WtIe; thoUtth 1atelleo'uall, we oan ,bave ODlr 011 ..... aua' ,., act with Ott,._l"" ttla' what .e do 1. 1'1'_ 11 11 'he root of the 41tte oe of

  • ......., f!l ... . - ., .. ...

    'pPtlet1oal '..,to. 1,' 4erly 1ts f3er\ltuda not trom Jmo alem., 'bu" tl'omre(l'lfle appe'lte. OUr willa ... t det lne4 to our true .b4lt Wll'~lt we d()11 to be :rlt;ht.

    AD4, ,., 1101114 1t 80' .... ,bat -., we e beeD UP8-

    1.11\ " .1', 8V1010ll1 olrel.,p .. 4e e, we 8&" 11 'e-p.Dd..Il' em .... t1ft.' a. '.tll.,aD! Jet t.;lw;moJtal .,1nu whlo11 reo.t1t7 &p"t1-' ,are4epe.tmt on pl1J4.lloe. 18 '111. no.t 0011' 410.1\10.' Pierbapta 'he 41ttloultl.. of aotion _",e1118 _toaa \8l'hDabl. peat':l... 'o,l't\lt!Atell, th1. 41ttloultl1s 01117 .. ...n'.II8. Appe.'l_ ,18 both ot A.8 'we M" ... ert. 'he em4 1. 4.".,..1,., br 11.t~ an4 is !lot

    ,t OD pw,40noe..t . wb,lc;l\ere d1r.eted, to the end, .wevel-,.I'e DO' 80 4et aNtd 8M .. et be lftY tigate4 '0, ........ I, 18 'he ... U1 __ .f . tiM ,,:,t~th "'Sara to the

    ~.a, ~ '~ ~, ... ~- _~a_>Il __ -t' ft--e: ........ -.. ,.~1U.J. ~.~~ ... .,...,.t . ua . ' ~ W~"."~~I A. 'VJ~_ ~~.~~~v ?r*/-!f~ .. V.1;I-' ~A"-'~.,,-" .",~,." .. ~ .. - " . 18 'be I'Ul& b, Wbleb., .. juG .. or 'hoM 'h1D&8 1fh1ah 81'e top 'he .. 24 a' ...... ot 1'. '.act_,oweN 'he en4, IlOral '11'- : p~ p..u4 ........ 1. 'he .at1\t1'8 or tbe .l'Utb,

    ....

    of "be ail 1' 1 ,ot 'abep ... 'loale,l.lQ&l... Wi_h .... saN 'hoM "hi.C' "blob are t..,be e.4, Yirtue dependa OB ~h. p .... p. of p......... "POlI 'he YleQo1D'b ot prw1enoe. 'hi. 18 ..... '101l 18 eyea 01...... 'rude... 18 '''.l'lt1e4 'b7 1;D..S. "la'eD.lea.r 'he .. 4 W11;ll ,aN '0 1 'e par'lau-1a. Jut, ... , nloh .. 8 ne. 1io be 'he .eooD4 pre.l... Tbe 00&01u.108 of 1' .. 4 .... 1. a 40uble , t.1r.' l' 1 ~udl-

  • and tllu. pr".~,~lpoae tlt,. a:ppetlt.,t S lnt-ention of the end, but tr,t~1 be.t,o" the Mall 01' mONl '''l~tue br conoltA41ng wh,Qt 18 to be done Mre a.4now *' MOl'1l1 .1.t\~. then depend, on :prud,enoe on17 wlttl. Ptl "'Nfjo eleet1on,tb'tt 1.' or tho' thing. whioh

    3 HIlt of th.partle': r circumetano , and, also, but 1n a _dla.e .. ,... 1,D tM 40tlb18: aot of 1'. conolusion.a?

    ttu foregoing enaJf)l ~.to 1M .hat kllj!)wl~se 1. not the ld't,lZ11lte p14;$ot .~'lon* Cu.!' 1l1:nill ar.. a1.p11 Dotable to pa$J) 1;;h. lISiter1a,1 11rA,itllAr 1n a va1 th.' would .lkt& tnt. poa

    .lbl . \ In thetolJ.cwlng .h(l:Pt.~ we will. Ith! that this 11 not

    .. 1.labl11t1 ot In'elleotuallt7 e.s all.ch, 'but ot 01Jr pa,l't,l:Jular

    BOtta ot lD'.lle,ciJu.a.llm,owlettp.lt h been ol"flr.,ed that

    with. It.!e Dot Moau we 11 1ft ,.11 eo tllal 1mowl.qt~ tb8t

    we OaDD(1) haYfJ " aol,enoetfll\ca would be a proximate no~ or COftdtiot" but :ratherbetJ.1118 a~ DOt lntel1ectual enough. 1'op th . lIo.eD:t It 8utt1MI to .how"lif, 1;1.811 Oll,. mode ot

    bowl . f we .iln !leYepactl with oerta1fltr how to a,at tm4 thus aPe '.pellde!!' ,em an.,tit. tor tbe tNtll of aotlOD. But there 1. another' error wi11ck4, altbough 1t is 1,8pllo1t11 refuted 1n

    what .e h e 8814. wou14 to 01},11 top 1I0re ex,pllclt treat. ft' ot ,aot,lon or, 80 to

  • 1 1te.a 84 't _ .110 has 'b n Nt u,pon 1)1 tl11 i'iurth81' dOWD t. roa4 hi. consoielloe "proach.. h1..aa. be re'b\U*l18 to 'v. 811000\1. to the wp.~oh. wt U. ,sa, t~lat the ."'1'1'81) ua bet1ea' 1&,.4 "Dr a 'brokeri shoelace (contini.DOr)

    azul t.b.,t the maD 111 11 18 tl1,8 IUtte.. ~b. lG'Y1te Soal ta illa. m01184 bjc' ,"\lb. chart". tmd..t1m1s .... ral tla.k8 t;a1Da 'water, he put. It '0 the paroned 1m' bit.ttlng lips of the wound.. lUll, who 'ls"8 ' pl1 all4 .ho~t,11 4,1.'. The ","t.h we. an, In\ et exk 1Dator aDdet,la.k oOfttalned 4 .. 411 pollCD. !fow, _.', tile levlte t.el 1mpe:lled to lit .. t,lme ot~o. ""'., .; ;: because he has fioured , , r plDt ot ,', '" trs'" tu_ ant't:1ereb7 ca1;l d hi,. 488')\'

    Pta,11111 he ' .p.ottl.tly.1,. lu. tb18 .... practical

    la'bat t1 .. SUch flaek uWIl117 het,d ... 'ter.. tIle or.1terlon of ,be 'Nth of hi. ao,1on 18 t mteatlcm \f}llerl pldea. it. IS lIe .. aat't well:. 1118 actloa 11ft.' tN.becaua. h,1e .,11.1 reot1-

    ,,'

    fle" an' hehd, 'bl DO _anI acted lna tt'J.cughtleI6 aam:ep. But V~~,' 1strte 3u4pea'of hl.'olT' The me hal ene". th . out~ Gome ooat.aUcta h18 lntetlt101l aDd he 11 e ll-_e-nin,i fool. e.. 1. OOM .... ' la a t.,rse papaaraph, 1.:1.rk.,.,ar4 would .a,. Such an lndlo __ t fl... trom a.ll1Uft4.pa.and~ of praotloal tJ'Ut;b.

  • \"t Q, l' A";"'l:~11' {.l'\tf ~ .. ~ &~ .... ~tI

    pu:r-. j IJ,n4 40_;'1 he 1101. fbe 81)e()ulatlve Ju4imsnt m\tst be .n aot oa'11 111 :relatlon to wbat 11. 1)\%".,1.0 1ft relation to a'.ntion. 0.. t t lrl't.tl'tloft 18 1Ila.diRt.11 I'u.poctl! h,e

    OODcer. ~1na; the water- 1808'* oa'll be referr.a t;f) elttte%' of two nora

    1~o 'l'~,at willon 1. t a thu. 1t 11 tal , termlte .killer 18 not ".'.r. &ut. I'ete:n-et to tt~.1J1tfmt1on ot the 3"ent'h18

    HDUOaft be pf!aotloal,17 tru.. *l:b1a 1.tru. a. well Wh.D ., of 1\11 it tl\;8" .e:re 004 When au,al'\ a 3uCls_n'

    1 ot fl,at.ll" .ooDtra41.cte4 by flvldianoe \fl\1,01\ oantJ:ot be 19nored,,. .

    'tile 'rll'ttl l1e.e 18 pp.e~loalf. tor tbe -30~lt' of am are Dot 10_. Alt4,."

    Ipal .. ' a1fti lu41oaatl. fallu>tt ltad,lo1ult c bene 1:u41c.;t de al10 DOD pept1net a4 malum

    m,'.11eow;. 1p:81 , eloutaao' ad .ius ,perteo .. \1oaeaperutlet l'ec\Ul4u. ee G' osoer rl-.. 'em B lUll GOB'l ; 'lUll; .,841 mal18 per-t In._ .4'teo'uum.

    .,'

    11 lJrla;8to 11 .t 11 further 4,1tr.,r.mc-e bet ... D pru.4e:nce aDd

    art. '.ork 0'1 o.P't mtt.t be 1004. in iteelf; it 1t 18 not 80 ti~. 0.,,1 tic does Dot .'f "But Pablo t~1.d 80 bllrtl to p6i.nt a &tOod p1.,ot"N.h1. 1a"811,tl01l ... 1rre$l>l'oaohable. it No, art 1. :rAli to 'the pe.'f.eiS,101lotl ,. work 1t 1. t 11 'to be JU4i~pMt 6004.

    outoo.. of p~4.Jlo..l' lo ... 1)!t,l. iDd,l,tfer;ent to the

  • ,...'1 ... 1 ''''Ii ot1'. ".' ... , a ... ,., oall hayeo 1D ,he 14 ~. Ida . b8 t all tDa' .. 1004 _ . )0

    0 .. ,. Pl'1",,8 of &1 k_,,_" be ""oODeile' w1th tbe 4oo".lDe 3"at , to",~' -,.t t;. P0111'i8 wh1ohba.. D_ 01-.4 la ,be p .... "1DI . , would. .... to idloat. tbat be baa r.x1 .. ,.4 ... 18 too'.l em_a, loor... ADd eo he .at. tN, _ we ...... a tbe, ie,ta alle ,\llte _1Sl

    ',. all be '.. 0,. ." .. , ,be r l.. ot the ,r&O'1 1, the "180108te&1 . ""loa or 'be .'bloa1 abaolute. we w111 t'1D4 'bat. be bae tall.. 1.'0 1m ...... ~\l.' &1 . . aye thoM ap1D., ft' _ la.. . .... , 81oqu 11. fh1. oOll.a14,e.rat1oa .111..... &. .~. 1 , _.,.a'o.,lt8P lntotbe 'tl80r, ot 1841"01; 0_1 ... 1011.

    I

    Ia '1'11111 ,. 6ohley.a..cOD .. ., ot order 1D 'h1e tir.' 8114".","10&1., of ... I'_M, of' 'terlcelean, .e are 0 ... I,OU81, I\8llllas til. rlek .f fI, IlPO , .1_ ..... t8l141_ of tll.'oMllt7 of _-. paeu4oDl1lO\l811tel'a'u... Pro. th. to', 1, alab.' lie tb,' .Uba~ Il.ttke,au'd ._ 1D 'he babl' of 4;1 ..... 1 .. pIl11oloph1o$1 ."PObl '11l a reooplubl, ab., o't _.. Tble. ,. tal' trOll -tna 'he ca... Th1s 40ea DO" ... n 'M:t Mba:" ba ... _ 40 - . 1. a tborwgh 41atOJ' .. '.lon ot ,Ilen N'l' .18 ~ lbl. 41 11 the ua4 ...

    We . .., a.'lIla .,. lD. tbe oa ,tbe no.ellst, .. 4 ",c~", 'beare .. strOftI ..... 'lan88 ,"0 the O,Na'l antet.

  • 4' tll,l.pot.', M .... l':~,l' ~;"j o~l .1 ' 'oallu4.,'. the fao"hat al.,"" _4 , tNOh But 1I.'loa ot eth':lo1 .. .. , " ... ' le4 ..... 1.' 8. '0 ".lDa .b1. OU$ we .. at .. t tUBa'.lf, p ............ t. 1 _10ft CaD onlr -- ... . al... 1.,... IN_ 1ft .. 4.,: .. w111 tid 'ha' 'b.." " of .. 4l !\t 1D tar Otlt ,.' .' 1'. 11&b111t1

    ; , .... thetloa,l .... loa alrea47 'been -4e ,or X1el'k.,aard t .. MO., ot 1.".80. eph .... , .bloh is to 1.,. MIl, .,ith 11.e ia, .... b.ti. t .,-. oal 01' Nl1ilou8 .".6011.... Tbe dltteretlOe ." ... D ,n._ 18:"..'..8,.... 1. the polDt ot ,p 'tMmt, 1a-'.i'."'_ It. 1 0' aa. ab.olu'.41tt....... t:htleMr' pol'. out)l tU1i tbe etiihloal 1. 1, tl1l4eX'8,od; 11, U.rk.~ .a a

    , ... 1. 1' lt .. , _ .1 .... ' 1 be 11g.1ou8 lit.. III \tJe wo.k. 1S0 .10h .. bay. \MM. ..te.rlq ill the tore,01JJ& ... 1,.18, 1, is 1D the latt S" ,., Il.rt.part haa been

    ~ Ut'II. erA W.' oOl1el46. 0. .... p t ot bl. tbought

    OIl 'be hl 1 a ."b ... 1211t lf ... w111"00M a .. 8 tnat

    hil 80'lou of bl 1a Ql:.l1'. fa ....... 4 f ... l1 tut. h ... ek... 4 St ...... '. ' llel'kalaaJ'4 tbe .'h1~o.1 18 but. '''.81t10 .. ;1 're OR the --7 to ,be 11&10U81 it OaDftot be

    . -

    o01lP,l.'. 1D lu lt 'becau" l' 844M .... 1 1t to .. t kwh1ch 18 l,.po lb~l. '0. 1.. emUhi.pom,. Xl ke 1.te",lDC'he 1I\fM\eq o, o.f e'bbl0' t ... it. iDabl11', "0 toP. 81.e 811l. _N" PIllaa,.-l" Jileftk" ',,1'4. OJ~I'lO,I.. .thla. to

    t~l'h ll,. ..... '1 ,It. t ..... 10011.'0 " ooaacm good whe .. -8. the la"e. 18 ooaeerDe4 wlt" '118,004 ot the ln41y.14ual.

  • ttat ... ata bl ..... a eNiaI t. 11.J'ke~. i. ,_ t , .. 1\&, lie -ow. , ".1' ...... t. 0' 1_ a "'17 .. ,.,)2 1t&1. ' ,he b4,lYldual -bOY. 'he ,e l ".lell is .. ' ... -.4 tl, .'ldoa," "" tal'h .,.. 1 ... 4. INp-.. 10. '0 the , .... 1 Pd.. .., tal'h ,..14'. '8 the -.leo-1 '0&1 8u.,. .. 1_ ot'~be .... l ." 1., . )it 'ftp.oua" the paea401&TIl.JO ....... 111 '10. &1 .... 81: ... 4 'el1e U8 that

    eM lIO:Pal .bl . 'loa ea11e4 .,. q .... "l ... b;, GMt .,.'1011 ,

    .f: 1. """ __ t .. ,' '~lo ll1a 808 IlOre thaD 111 ... 1t .lJ 'bl. 81\U4.l'1.. 1. __p,n,141141 . 'lDCUlahe4

    18 0&11.4 \lpea '0 .... lf1 hle 4&11 -"' , to ... t tbe Il ... l .... _ aD. : loalrA a .:. Yl of the moral "'all. h~ '!ll. _Bile' .. 8&14 of Ab ...... )6 All .... OaDDOt .. f '0 8. h.. lIoN1 ._le eh aa 4eten4Usg 'be .,.t. o. . .. _ bt.1ta" ...., , hl. 80t1"'1011 1. .OIM-tilt 1'.1 .. __ , ,.taU, , .. lp tllepnara1 OP .. ra1.31 A .... ao' _h O\lt .', 10". top 1\1 ... 1' a. tor loy. ot Goa.- .. hay .... _beD ot a oatesor, to .apr the a 101l.' ~. t !lil .... ea1lal1e aD oppo.l11,cm be-, ........ 1 ";'. -,.._1 .1.' .. ~."

    .. '

    the 0&.. .t . -. _ -1118 .' . ret ....... 1.11 ... 1. __ ,. t ... tul .... ot hle , .,_.t10D.

    A ' 1"."" le ... ,' ............. f , .. , Whioh he ,

    fdMlUl4,..1iO a."", II It '0 alobAb ........ .., ... 18 .14 .a ',. hi. p ,.. _., _.al,1\,. .Aa4 aos-all'1 18

    ; ; .j

    ,

  • 'he "1 .f 004. a\l' 18 1s the 'w111 of 0'04 ... Ab .... "lIB. ........... ...... .~6__ _.'t.A..' .A .AfA . ~ At~ .~. ohiA.pr!:l.t.,lftlr' liAr .. ~.~ .. , ~~ ___ . ~ ....... WW W~ .. ~F Vj;1i ..... .~

    "'.a4,.lo~1 .. ta l'9e&. I' ,. 'be.ill o.t

  • .. J9 ..

    l' 18 b, tal.b -, ... 11 ;. lato &. perloaal l'e:1&t1OWJhlp wl'.. ., l' '8,,',.r_par4 8 DO_laD of ta1'th whiob 18 .:t .p ......... 1.,.,.,1; _N.,bu' hl. 80'10n of th th1oal .. 1 .... &1 .... 1' .... ,...loa. w. ... p ..... \11 GOnG.fIlM with . .,. ... mple of ,Ab .... _loh M br1Dtta for-h emA whiob doe.

    ' aJ)~'i .' GIl wl'h '. tio 'be \lD,lvel' .. l 6pp110ao111., of a 'ellJ)MtlO1l cml7

    w1 .. w.r '011' ... ""1". "or 111 .he '0 'ot ADs-ah... we are '.14, 1\ 18 ,. 4.-....a. ot "1'&11t, wh1cn Goa.tit.,. the MlMa., ,t,'oa.'"

    -...

    , .~~.".'" ~ .. :~j' .~a"'>. : lili&"' . l,ch co.our to _It. II temptatlOll aN

    (1) ' 1 ..... tta,t'ft Dowl' eot ..... blq 1a doubt, (2) 'that __ ide .e lilt e-. \)7 " '.1'1 aM e,) t tibe 'empt ee1... 1Ihi. Dowl. -' at_lf ' Wll.. God 18 1d to tempt a _.1 tie _1, ,btt fir., .0 .tthe.. ..l,t.ria which ... p ..... ,.

    uspa".' 1a ' .. 'a~l~ A_aDa. J praeoept'tum el. =:. '=~tr..=~ '-til:! :!:: :O!=l':;~ ., ,. ... "'.'1.. _It _loa De.81llteade. ba,_/ '

    the _tre.,.,lOll .... DOS, ot oou .... to., G04'. baaetlt. bUt ,,'

    .. 11 '0 toll, the Sra41'.1_141,,181011 otl mtoth.' of "be tl ' tII.1. aa4 *1' .r 'be M0084 1)able. the fl ... , le the '.1'&1 law _lob baa ,,' ... nGe 41 c'1, to 004 wbereal

  • ,_ 1.w Gt tM 0!Ml hble t 0' .,t), ....... 4' !hi. 41 .. 'lDO~1'" 184 1984 trOll ''\lhe tabl ot ,be 'eoalope _loh le _, upoa all ill. la"et ... '. l' coatalm8 the Da 'ura 1 law.'O l' wauU .... thatll:l te :&1'4'.8 aU __ ' tbat the l.w. wh1ob. ... "eo'_ otbe ..... 4. ao' la,te us 1_41.,.1, ... Ood,$118 1D ape .... 'tl Wl')l tala. A .. 18 11&14 to be soo4 mlOt .. aahe

    . are '.ooP4ere. ~t1.1Jt. fm4 pp1Dcl . 1 oJ-deli 1. ,hat of aU

    1U,'.. '0 thewtIl,i._. _ *leb 18 G04j 'be aooolld ord 18 ot ... o ... ,~ '0 aao'hep.f.eftrs. 01"481 1. 'he 'oau,e of

    I

    p t apoD .. 4 4~ o'tfJ4 ' .. ar4 ,n.. fl."" tbe loo4ne". of ,. ..... earl .. nlt,:IraoM4 wlth",,' 41abl.lah1a1 ,he &OOa

    tt_ t1 '. . Doe. tall ..... 'bf~' we ,0IUt 1 __ ... ~ 4ut1 or ,1" .warO'MP 81. _ .. I: GO eIl"'. 01111 em loving' God,

    . a ... 1 hla , t.waNI .'UP . , b., 41H_dient to alll\lJ)erlO.8,e ktll all .lralOlMmtRD, Imd."lll be related to Ill 1t' .... tmAla 8t;lella waF ',M't he .an .' Gall84 sooAt

    ., lleo ... po_,,_ '. 1el y1 ..... , 41ylba. p Clua,. 0 1. '.. . .1 tltu$WJ .It. lllfj,,' e.l. _. "-.,.",,,,",a'11 .lftWN1 . 8 .. tl10_ yip., 41Y1 ........ , 14 '.04 Da'ua :t Nol-pe .. 1teal.' 0 .1 .. at t ,,1_1 .... -41-~. t ...... ;'1J1 .... :.~~ .. ,'ial11.1I. he.b ... ' .... 't". la. 1, . t.'.' . .. I, 1'1;b-' .. o.o .,",u1, ..... at rea 111 , tl.ft4 . 11. .. .' qui .....0.. 1anootmta , 1 ".,1 :re pRlela , .~ po, t .... beau .... b '. tl 1. Il18,1 ... 't.r1-'''. "'81 epto,41vl.o.

    , 004 ...41.'.... .1'11 thl. ',p. of ,re ". ahel lNoh 41.p .... '1oa 1e ,..tl.' as.ftl.Ouloue. 'Ibe further and lION

  • '. 61.

    All 1,&1. 18 o~.p.4 '0 the GOmmon @004; ttl!.. 11 the. t1ret .. priDe!. lDtectloa ot tbe 1 lal .. 'or. 004, aa tbe d1v1Jle 1. 'lye., hit IND.l. ' -'.uattlftll .1aw 1n orae. that opea-

    t~e8 a1 ,be 0,.. to H1 1t. eta.. Ie 18 the OO~.~ft(d~ io

  • '. 61-

    aillon of 'he , oop'. os-a 4801 ... '101l ,., l' 1," 1_4 11l .hl ..... 01" 8O,toa. la,'.". 'hle 41 ..... '1 .. cau ... tu't an aot1oa nlob ,,1,_, _11 41 au_grit, would be 10,14.. 1. not homo!' '

    .. ' "0 . 181 tu.p ,oepta 1, .. 4eoalocl, q;uaDt". a4 ra'loae- '111.'1'1 .. qoam ooat1Ben'. 11l8ltab,111a .ffu.n,'~ ._, __ , ..... all all .......... 1 .. '1 ....

    pez- '., .' 1, tl....atl 8 are . ~ tu. ,ut 101-11 .. , lMMt 1.. a1 _1.141 .. , tuna 1 &4u1\ 1 , aut 8:0&, iloo ,,,14.. auta))11e .56

    .. haa 4,oJl,laloa oyer 1,lte aa44 ... 'h and ., hi. ord,ltlat101l

    "th a1 .... ,. aD' ,_ Ju,.,,,.' '.1. eaJtthlJ eD4. 'fhe.etoN. o.e who kUla all 1:0%100 .. ' '.... at tbe .o1llllSZ4 of God 8lDa

    ~.- .

    .. 110". ,him dee.Ood Who,. exeou,tor he 11.S? 'fhe authorlt, or God ill Rob a oan Wlk 'be ,.,1:181 d1tt oe, for OajeMD tlPa 1

    " ,,' . 1 ".14.. ..MP' .... Mlb1Dtelleotaa ba1tm.'. ". 0,. 11. __ . ""., "'-. ~1.. , .; .:.'. ~ t 101.' .,1,10, '., .qu04 ex .. -..all ............ 1." rl8D' vel BOD

    !=,;.:.~r. oK_a lu'l'lM beolUbU l' 1,8 ~\\1, 01 ... ,btl_ ,he" 1. ao q,. loll here .t . tas 0.1_ .. 8017 u', wt ot i.po.iDa a 41ttel'8Jlt ' .... 11" OIl Sl ..... ,_ !'bat.h1M alas 4 ... 08 p.1va'e .. 'llo.l., 1 _1014_ j ... 4_ em. dlylae l\)1tho..1tl,18 DO'. W ... ,al. ao' , ,4 '11 woul4 be an UDjU 80t of 'h. a..l1" ,,b101l, 'WOld4 'D. tt1a.ltO\lleoaol'u81oa.

    oOilelual88 let l' be d4e4 1n &1,1 hast, that ,he 80taloa ot ,_,-1.01 .al .. ,.pena111m ot the ethioal abeo--1.". 1. nat.1 0Il1, 1a wo.kab, pleudODll1.; ..... 'h.l

    -i

  • l' 11 a.teMe 1D tbelldalll, w~d"ah 1n ttt.I11M ;of 'ad L. 101"1','9 wlto 1I8f 1W1 tely reprde4 aa an auth,orl-"7 1ft 'his .. t' ~l. lhep u4oBJ1lQu,. worlc clo ' to the

    ;L.;I11."-":._. h' or Kl ke, . ' .. 4 111 ... 11. ;l(18rk.,aar4 .etalDed trOll I,~ 'be .. ok ot ... k alid t1D41rc oontra

  • ,-, .. _--... _,._--- -

  • ... 6; ..

    1s Mtm4 up ~ etlll.al lapo.taDoe I ., have.-! The aul'l-tuAe, ~b. publl0 e .. the oono8m of tt.,.118111"a:k,18rk'.gaaN w111 .apb&a


RALF MCINERNYdadun.unav.edu/bitstream/10171/6644/1/04. RALPH MCINERNY...RALF McINERNY ios hombres y, como apunta Santo Tomás, los actos humanos y los actos morales se identifican4

RALF MCINERNYdadun.unav.edu/bitstream/10171/6644/1/04. RALPH MCINERNY...RALF McINERNY ios hombres y, como apunta Santo Tomás, los actos humanos y los actos morales se identifican4

Documents
The Writings of - University of Arizonaaversa/scholastic/Ego Sapientia... · The Writings of CHARLES DE KONINCK Edited and Translated by Ralph McInerny University of Notre Dame Press

The Writings of - University of Arizonaaversa/scholastic/Ego Sapientia... · The Writings of CHARLES DE KONINCK Edited and Translated by Ralph McInerny University of Notre Dame Press

Documents
RALF MCINERNY - dadun.unav.edu...felicidad puede ser cierta en el tiempo pasado, pero jamás en el tiempo presente. La amenaza de la desgracia no debe llevarnos a abandonar la noción

RALF MCINERNY - dadun.unav.edu...felicidad puede ser cierta en el tiempo pasado, pero jamás en el tiempo presente. La amenaza de la desgracia no debe llevarnos a abandonar la noción

Documents
Geleji Katona István politikai metaforái - iti.mta.hu · kapcsolatban.”3 Bloomfield megállapítja Gottlieb Söhngen és Ralph McInerny munkáira hivatkozva, hogy „a metafora

Geleji Katona István politikai metaforái - iti.mta.hu · kapcsolatban.”3 Bloomfield megállapítja Gottlieb Söhngen és Ralph McInerny munkáira hivatkozva, hogy „a metafora

Documents