View
213
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/29/2019 Mi Hwang Huh, A045 809 070 (BIA Jan. 9, 2013)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mi-hwang-huh-a045-809-070-bia-jan-9-2013 1/7
Dehfky Mbhckffk A. Ksq.Ludl Caacjrbtceh ^brthkrs FFD? 2 > Peswkff Pebm Tuctk 4>>Btfbhtb JB 4>4;>
Hbak7 O[O Af OZBHJ
[.T. kpbrtakht ei Gustcdk
Kxkdutcvk Eiicdk ier Caacjrbtceh Pkvckw
@ebrm ei aacjrbtceh Bppkbfs
Eiicdk ei ok Dfkrl
;2>: Fkks`urj ^co.5, Tuctk Q } ) }
Ibffs Dourdo Ycr-jchcb 072>=2
MOTCCDK Eiicdk ei Docki Deuhskf B]F2?> Tprchj Ttrkkt Tuctk 440Btfbhtb JB 4>4>4
B >=;-?>3->:>
Mbtk ei tocs hetcdk7 2/3/0>24
Khdfeskm cs b depy ei tok @ebrm s mkdcsceh bhm ermkr ch tok b`evk-rkikrkhdkm dbsk.
Khdfesurk
^bhkf Aka`krs7Jukhmkfs`krjkr Geoh
Tchdkrkfy,
>Jh ttF ( ZvMehhb Dbrr
Docki Dfkrl
[skrtkba7 Medlkt
Dctk bs7 Ac Owbhj Ouo, B>=; ?>3 >:> (@CB Gbh. 3, 0>24)
7/29/2019 Mi Hwang Huh, A045 809 070 (BIA Jan. 9, 2013)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mi-hwang-huh-a045-809-070-bia-jan-9-2013 2/7
O[O, Af OZBHJB>=;º?>3..():>
FT Mkpbrtakht ei Gustcdk
Kxkdutcvk Eiicdk ier Caacjrbtceh Pkvckw
@ebrm e aacjrbtceh Bppkbfs
Eiicdk e ok Dfkrl
; >: F k k s ` ~ r j ^clk. Ta tk 0>>>Ibffs Dourdo Ycrjchcb 00>=2
MOT/CDK Eiicdk ei DockiDeuhskfº B]F
2?> Tprchj Ttrkkt, Tuctk 440HEP]O JKEPJCB MK]KH]CEH DKH]KP900 ABCH T]PKK] TZ
Btfbhtb JB 4>4>4
JBCHKTYCFFK, JB 4>;>2
Hbak7 O[O, Af OZBHJ B >=;-?>3->:>
Mbtk eitocs hetcdk7 2/3/0>24
Khdfeskm s b depy ei tok @ebrm s mkdcsceh ch tok b`evk-rkikrkhdkm dbsk. ]ocs depy s `kchjprevcmkm te yeu bs b deurtksy. Seur btterhky er rkprkskhtbtcvk obs `kkh skrvkm wcto tocsmkdcsceh pursubht te ? D.I.P. § 2030.;(b). Ci tok bttbdokm mkdcsceh ermkrs tobt yeu `krkaevkm irea tok [hctkm Ttbtks er biicras bh Caacjrbtceh Gumjk s mkdcsceh ermkrchj tobt yeu`k rkaevkm, bhy pktctceh ier rkvckw ei tok bttbdokm mkdcsceh aust `k icfkm wcto bhm rkdkcvkm`y tok bppreprcbtk deurt ei bppkbfs wctoch 4> mbys ei tok mbtk ei tok mkdcsceh.
Khdfesurk
^bhkf Aka`krs7Jukhmkfs`krjkr, Geoh
Tchdkrkfy,
MErutFDt2itB)Mehhb Dbrr
Docki Dfkrl
[skrtkba7 7 .6º ..
Dctk bs7 Ac Owbhj Ouo, B>=; ?>3 >:> (@CB Gbh. 3, 0>24)
7/29/2019 Mi Hwang Huh, A045 809 070 (BIA Jan. 9, 2013)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mi-hwang-huh-a045-809-070-bia-jan-9-2013 3/7
[.T. kpbrtakht e GustcdkKxkdutcvk Eiicdk ier Caacjrbtceh Pkvckw
Ibffs Dourdo, Ycrjchcb 00>=2
Icfk7 B>=; ?>3 >:>- Btfbhtb, JB
Mkdcsceh ei ok @ebrm ei Caacjrbtceh Bppkbfs
Mbtk7 G H 0 24
Ch rk7 AC OZBHJ O[O b.l.b. Ac Oybhj Lca b.l.b. Ac Oybhj Ouo b.l.b. Ac Otbhj Ouo
CH PKAEYBF ^PEDKKMCHJT
B^^KBF BHM AE]CEH
EH @KOBFI EI PKT^EHMKH]7 Mbhckffk A. Dehfky, Ksqucrk
EH @KOBFI EI MOT7 Abry D. FkkBsscstbht Docki Deuhskf
B^^FCDB]CEH7 Pkabhm
]ok rkspehmkht, b hbtcvk bhm dctczkh ei tok Pkpu`fcd ei Lerkb (deaaehfy lhewh bs
Teuto Lerkb ), bppkbfs tok mkdcsceh ei tok Caacjrbtceh Gumjk, mbtkm Bujust 0?, 0>20, ermkrchj
okr rkaevbf irea tok [hctkm Ttbtks. Zk wcff mcsacss tok rkspehmkht's bppkbf bhm mkhy okr
Aetceh te Pkabhm Pkaevbf ^redkkmchjs bhm Oefm @rckichj Tdokmufk ch B`kybhdk.
Zk rkvckw Caacjrbtceh Gumjks' ichmchjs ei ibdt ier dfkbr krrer, `ut qukstcehs ei fbw,mcsdrktceh, bhm gumjakht, bhm bff etokr cssuks ch bppkbfs, mk heve. ? D.I.P. § 2>>4.f(m)(4).
Bs bh chctcbf abttkr, wk rkgkdt tok rkspehmkht's dfbcas tobt sok wbs seakoew mkprcvkm b
iuhmbakhtbffy ibcr rkaevbf okbrchj `kdbusk b Lerkbh chtkrprktkr wbs het kapfeykm bt okrskdehm, tocrm, bhm ieurto rkaevbf `kbrchjs er `kdbusk tok Caacjrbtceh Gumjk wbs `cbskm. 2 ]ok
rkspehmkht, woe wbs rkprkskhtkm `y deuhskf bt okr skdehm, tocrm, bhm ieurto rkaevbf okbrchjs,
wbs hkvkr dbffkm te tkstciy ch toksk predkkmchjs. ]ous, fclk ch tok heh-`chmchj dbsk ei Mre`hy v
CHT 3=: I.0m 0=2, 0=; (:to Dcr. 2332), tok rkspehmkht wbs het mkhckm b rkbsehb`fk eppertuhcty
te prkskht kvcmkhdk er `k prkskht ch b akbhchjiuf wby. ]ok rkspehmkht's bsskrtcehs tobt tok
Caacjrbtceh Gumjk aby `k `cbskm brk wctoeut akrct. ]ok rkspehmkht obs bfse het
mkaehstrbtkm tobt sok wbs prkgumcdkm `y tok b`skhdk ei b Lerkbh chtkrprktkr bt okr skdehm, tocrm,
bhm ieurto rkaevbf okbrchjs er tok Caacjrbtceh Gumjk's bffkjkm `cbs. Tkk Fehyka v [T. Bff y
Jkh. 4;0 I.4m 244?, 24=2-=0 C fto Dcr.0>>4)< ^btkf v [T. Btt y Jkh. 44= IGm 20;3, 2094
CC to Dcr. 0>>4). Ch soert, tok rkspehmkht obs het kstb`fcsokm tobt, ch tok b`skhdk ei tok
pkrdkcvkm mkikdts, tok eutdeak ei toksk rkaevbf predkkmchjs weufm `k mciikrkht.
]urhchj te tok akrcts ei tok Caacjrbtceh Gumjk's mkdcsceh, wk biicra tok Caacjrbtceh
Gumjk's rkaevbf ermkr. ]ok rkspehmkht wbs bmacttkm te tok [hctkm Ttbtks bs b dehmctcehbf
pkrabhkht rkscmkht ch 233:. Tkk skdtceh 029(b)(f) ei tok Caacjrbtceh bhm Hbtcehbfcty Bdt,
? [.T.D. § 22?9b(b)(f). Oewkvkr, ch 0>>0, tok ierakr Caacjrbtceh bhm Hbturbfczbtceh Tkrvcdk
tkrachbtkm okr dehmctcehbf pkrabhkht rkscmkht stbtus. kk skdtceh 029( d)(0) ei tok Bdt.
Bmmctcehbffy, ch 0>>3, tok rkspehmkht wbs dehvcdtkm ei tokit `y soepfcitchj bhm skhtkhdkm te b
20-aehto tkra ei caprcsehakht. h fcjot ei toksk dcrduastbhdks, tok rkspehmkht, toreujo
2B Lerkbh chtkrprktkr wbs uskm bt tok icrst rkaevbf okbrchj (]r. bt 2-4 .
Dctk bs7 Ac Owbhj Ouo, B>=; ?>3 >:> (@CB Gbh. 3, 0>24)
7/29/2019 Mi Hwang Huh, A045 809 070 (BIA Jan. 9, 2013)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mi-hwang-huh-a045-809-070-bia-jan-9-2013 4/7
B>=; ?>3 >:>
deuhskf, dehdkmkm tobt. sok wbs su`gkdt te rkaevbf irea tocs deuhtry uhmkr tok prevcscehs ei
skdtcehs 04:(b)(f)(M)(c) bhm (0)(B)(ccc) ei tok Bdt, ? [.T.D. §§ 200:(b)(f)(M)(c), (0)(B)(ccc)
(C.G. bt 0< Kxos. C, 0 4?< ]r. bt :-?). Bs tok rkspehmkht mcm het rkqukst bhy iera ei rkfcki irea
rkaevbf, ct wbs prepkr ier tok Caacjrbtceh Gumjk te khtkr bh ermkr ei rkaevbf ch tocs dbsk.
]ok rkspehmkht obs het mkaehstrbtkm tobt rkabhmkm predkkmchjs brk wbrrbhtkm. Tkk Abttkr
e Dekfoe 0> C&H Mkd. =9=, =:2 (@CB 2330) (rkdejhczchj tobt b aetceh te rkabhm cs jkhkrbffy
su`gkdt t tok sbak su`stbhtcvk rkqucrkakhts bs b aetceh te rkepkh). Kvkh ci tok rkspehmkht'sdehvcdtceh ier tokit obs `kkh aemcickm sudo tobt sok cs he fehjkr su`gkdt te rkaevbf bs bh bfckh
woe obs `kkh dehvcdtkm ei bh bjjrbvbtkm ikfehy, sok weufm rkabch su`gkdt te rkaevbf uhmkr tok
prevcscehs ei skdtceh 04:(b)(f)(M)(c) ei tok Bdt `kdbusk okr dehmctcehbf pkrabhkht rkscmkht
stbtus obs `kkh tkrachbtkm. Ch ermkr te evkrdeak okr rkaevb`cfcty uhmkr tok prevcscehs ei
skdtceh 04:(b)(f)(M)(c) ei tok Bdt, sok rkquksts rkabhmkm predkkmchjs ch ermkr te kstb`fcso tobt
sok wbrrbhts b jeem ibcto abrrcbjk wbcvkr uhmkr tok prevcscehs ei skdtceh 029(d)(=)(@) ei tok
Bdt.
Pkabhmkm predkkmchjs brk het wbrrbhtkm `kdbusk tok rkspehmkht obs het mkaehstrbtkm tobt
sok cs prcab ibdck kfcjc`fk ier tok rkqukstkm wbcvkr her mkaehstrbtkm tobt sok wbrrbhts b wbcvkr
bs b abttkr ei mcsdrktceh. Tkk Fc v [T. Bit y Jkh. =?? I.4m 24:2, 24:; CC to Dcr. 0>>:). ]okrkspehmkht obs het prkskhtkm bhy pkrsubscvk kvcmkhdk tobt sok khtkrkm tok qubfciychj abrrcbjk ch
jeem ibcto. Tkk ? D.I.P. § 2029.;(k)(0) (mksdrc`chj tok kvcmkhdk tobt sobff `k dehscmkrkm ch
bmgumcdbtchj b jeem ibcto abrrcbjk wbcvkr ). Bmmctcehbffy, hetwctostbhmchj okr fkhjto ei
rkscmkhdk ch tocs deuhtry bhm tok prkskhdk ei b docfm woe cs bppbrkhtfy rkqukstchj caacjrbtceh
`khkicts uhmkr [hctkm Ttbtks Dctczkhsocp bhm Caacjrbtceh Tkrvcdks' Mkikrrkm Bdtceh ier
Docfmoeem Brrcvbfs prejrba, tok rkspehmkht obs het prkskhtkm suiicdckht kquctcks te mkaehstrbtk
tobt, mkspctk okr drcachbf rkderm, sok wbrrbhts b wbcvkr bs b abttkr ei mcsdrktceh. Dehscmkrchj
toksk dcrduastbhdks, wk mkdfchk te rkabhm tok rkderm te tok Caacjrbtceh Gumjk ier iurtokrpredkkmchjs.
Ichbffy, tok rkspehmkht obs het prkskhtkm bhy fkjbf er rkjufbtery `bscs te oefm tok `rckichjsdokmufk ch b`kybhdk. ]ocs @ebrm cs rkqucrkm te cssuk mkdcscehs bs seeh bs prbdtcdb`fk, wcto b
prcercty ier dbsks er dustemy bppkbfs chvefvchj mktbchkm bfckhs. ? D.I.P. § 2>>4.2(k)(?).
Ieffewchj tok jrbhtchj ei tok rkspehmkht's `rckichj kxtkhsceh rkqukst, tok pbrtcks wkrk prevcmkm
b rkbsehb`fk eppertuhcty te su`act `rckis ch suppert ei tokcr rkspkdtcvk pesctcehs. Bs sudo, ct cs
hew bppreprcbtk te khtkr tok ieffewchj ermkrs ch tocs dbsk.
EPMKP7 ]ok rkspehmkht's bppkbf cs mcsacsskm.
I[P]OKP EPMKP7 ]ok rkspehmkht's Aetceh te Pkabhm Pkaevbf ^redkkmchjs bhm Oefm
@rckiaj Tdokmufk ch B`kybhdk cs mkhckm.
Dctk bs7 Ac Owbhj Ouo, B>=; ?>3 >:> (@CB Gbh. 3, 0>24)
7/29/2019 Mi Hwang Huh, A045 809 070 (BIA Jan. 9, 2013)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mi-hwang-huh-a045-809-070-bia-jan-9-2013 5/7
•[HC]KM T]B]KT MK^BP]AKH] EI G[T]CDK
K_KD[]CYK EIICDK .IEP CAACJPB]CEH PKYCKZ
[HC]KM T]B]KT CAACJPB]CEH DE[P]
B]FBH]B, JKEPJCB
Icfk7 B>=;-?>3->:> Bujust 0?, 0>20
Ch tok Abttkr ei
AC OZ HJ O[O CH PKAEYBF ^PEDKKMCHJT
PKT^EHMKH]
VDOBPJKT7 04: b) 2) M), 04: b) 0) B) c c c ) .
• C••
B^^FCDB]CEHT7 Hehk.
EH @KOBFI EI PKT^EHMKH]7 K@B JBFK@, Ksqucrk
EH @KOBFI EI MOT7 ABPS FKK, Ksqucrk
EPBF MKDCTCEH EI ]OK CAACJPB]CEH G[MJK
]ok rkspehmkht cs bh bmuft ikabfk hbtcvk bhm d c t czkh ei tok
Pkpu`fcd ei Lerkb Teuto Lerkb) woe wbs pfbdkm ch rkaevbf
predkkmchjs wcto tok i c f chj ei b Hetcdk te Bppkbr wcto tok Deurt
dobrjchj rkaevb`cfcty pursubht te tok prevcscehs ei 04: b) 2) M)
tkrachbtceh ei dehmctcehbf pkrabhkht rkscmkht) bhm
04: b) 0) B) c c c ) bjjrbvbtkm ikfehy).
Pkspehmkht c h c t c b f f y bppkbrkm `kierk to c s Deurt eh Gufy 4,
7/29/2019 Mi Hwang Huh, A045 809 070 (BIA Jan. 9, 2013)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mi-hwang-huh-a045-809-070-bia-jan-9-2013 6/7
0>20, pre sk. ]ok Deurt rkskt b i tk r jcvchj bh bmvcsbf ei r cjots
te jcvk okr bh eppertuhcty te ichm fkjbf deuhskf.
h Gufy 2>, 0>20, bhm Bujust 02, 0>20, rkspehmkht wbs
rkprkskhtkm `y deuhskf bhm deuhskf kbdo tcak rkqukstkm b
dehtchubhdk ier btterhky prkpbrbt ceh.
h temby s mbtk rkspehmkht i c fkm wrct tkh pfkbmchjs, scjhkm
`eto `y okrskfi bhm deuhskf. ]oesk pfkbmchjs bdlhewfkmjk prepkr
skrvcdk ei tok Hetcdk te Bppkbr, bmact tok ibd tubf b f fkjbt cehs
bhm dehdkmk rkaevb`cfc ty eh b f f dobrjks. Obvchj rkvckwkm tok
C-024, tok rkderm ei dehvcdtceh bhm tkrachbtceh ei dehmc t cehbf
rkscmkht s tb tus bs wkff bs rkvckwchj tok bmacsscehs bhm
dehdksscehs eh tok rkspehmkht s wrct tkh pfkbmchjs, tok Deurt
ichms tobt rkaevb`cfc ty obs `kkh kstb`f csokm `y dfkbr bhm
dehvchdchj kvcmkhdk eh ~ t o dobrjks. ]ok wrct tkh pfkbmchjs
spkdci cdbf fy me het rkqukst bhy rk f c k i .
Obvchj `kkh ieuhm rkaevb`fk bhm rkprkskhtkm `y deuhskf bhm
ablchj bh bii c rabtcvk wbcvkr ei bhy rk f ck i tok Deurt ermkrs
rkaevbf irea tok [hctkm Ttbtks te tok Pkpu`fcd ei Lerkb eh tok
dobrjks dehtbchkm ch tok Hetcdk te Bppkbr.
B>=;-?>3->:> 0 Bujust 0?, 0 20
7/29/2019 Mi Hwang Huh, A045 809 070 (BIA Jan. 9, 2013)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/mi-hwang-huh-a045-809-070-bia-jan-9-2013 7/7
.
DKP]CICDB]K ^BJK
C okrk`y dk r t c iy tobt tok bt tbdokm predkkmchj `kierk G[MJK
G MBH ^KFFK]CKP ch tok abttkr ei7
AC OZBHJ O[O
B>=;-?>3->:>
B]FBH]B JKEPJCB
cs bh bddurbtk, vkr`btca t r hsdrcpt ei tok rkdermchj bs prevcmkm
`y tok Kxkdutcvk Eiicdk ier Caacjrbtceh Pkvckw bhm to t to cs cs
tok ercjchbf t r hsd r cp t tokrkei ier tok i c f k ei tok Kxkdutcvk
Eiicdk ier Caacjrbtceh Pkvckw.
G2Ci7 qB7 RMD L < . ( ' ' r ' b - ~ r c ` k r )IPKK T]B]K PK^EP]CHJ Chd.
ED]E@KP 2?, 0>20
Deapfktceh Mbtk)