24
≤∞∞μ ÂWW wMdA ©¥® …—U˛ …ËWMó|u 55 œ—u w…ËWW ÍWUMU Ë ÂeOUïOU ÂeOUï?OU ÍWWW Í…ËWœdJO? Ë…ËW«bJ} W WOO?d WU ÂWz Í…ËWM“˘œ U…Ë—W? Ë wU?O?? ÍU˛ïï??O??ï? Ë wËËó??}?? ÍW~«Ë— W W?UM}Ä ÊïÇ ËWO?OOÇ Âe?OUïO?U UUz ∫Ëu?…Ë p|—UO?dÄ bWÇ ï Âü…Ë øÈd…œ Ethnicty, Na- Stateò …ËWW wW?†Ë…œ Ë ˚W†Ë…œ øW?O??OÇ …ËWW we??O?Uï??O??U? œ—u?? ÍW??L??}?z UUz ¨ø5Ç w?…ËWW ÍW??U?MU Ë tion Æøw…ËWW Í…ËWMËËe œuU WW ÊU1œ—u wU?O? wW“W? Ë …œ—Uœ Ëu?…Ë Âe?OUï?O?U …ËW?OËËó?}? ÍËË˙W ÂüW ¨—W?ËW??W? ÙU??? ¥∞≠≥∞ ï …ËW???|˙W???Ö…œ Political Doctrine Ë ï????O???????????MO?z Ë —W????W??? W? w1œU????Wz Í…ËWM?O†ï?J} w?WU Ëu????…Ë ÆÙU ¥μ WUÖWz wWW ¨«ËUz˛˘— wUïJ«“ ï …ËW?MM|˙W?~…œ WW?U ÂWz w?U«“…—U??? Ë—…ó?|u Ë —ï???á????Ä ÍW—˘“ Æ ±∑∏π w…—W w˙ï w«b†W—W wU e“W dU œ—u w…ËWW ÍWUMU Ë ÂeOUïOU

nasunalezm w nasnamay galy kurd

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

œ—u ww…ËWWWW ÍWÄUMMUU Ë ÂeOÃUUïOOUU 55 ee“WW ddUÄ ≤∞∞µ ÂWÂWW wMMdAA ©¥® …—UIJ …ËWMMó|uu 56 ≤∞∞µ ÂWÂWW wMMdAA ©¥® …—UIJ …ËWMMó|uu 57 øWOOÇ ÂeOÃUUïOOUU ≤∞∞µ ÂWÂWW wMMdAA ©¥® …—UIJ …ËWMMó|uu 58 È—bb«u? UU W? ? ?  WW«Ë w}? Ä Ë Âe? ? O ? à UUï? ? ? O ? ? ? UU wwœd? ? ?  W? ? ? UM? } Ä Wà W? M O? ? ? ? ? ? …— —˘“ Âï? ? ? O ? ? ? ïï Íô WJJuÇ s}? M M«œ Âe? O ÃUUï? O ? ? UU ïï WWU? O ? O ? «“ ÊUU vv WWU? O OWWUU ı X? ? O ÄWW ñÄ wÂWWW? ? UM}Ä ≤∞∞µ ÂWÂWW wMMdAA ©¥® …—UIJ …ËWMMó|uu

Citation preview

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

55

œ—u� w�…ËW�W� ÍW�UM�U� Ë ÂeO�U�ïO�U�

ÂeO�U�ï?O�U� ÍW�W�W� Í…ËW�œdJO?� Ë…ËW�«bJ}� W� WOO?��d� W�U� ÂWz

Í…ËWM�“˘œ U�…Ë—W?� Ë w�U?O??� ÍU�˛ï�ï??O??�ï?� Ë w�ËËó??}??� ÍW~�«Ë— W�

W?�UM}Ä ÊïÇ ËWO?OOÇ Âe?O�U�ïO?�U� U�Uz ∫Ëu?�…Ë p|—UO?�dÄ b�WÇ ï� Âü…Ë

øÈd�…œ

Ethnicty, Na- Stateò …ËW�W� w�W?†Ë…œ Ë ÊW†Ë…œ øW?O??OÇ …ËW�W�

w�e??O?�U�ï??O??�U?� œ—u??� ÍW??L??}?z U�Uz ¨ø5Ç w?�…ËW�W� ÍW??�U?M�U� Ë tion

Æøw�…ËW�W� Í…ËWM�ËËe� œu�U� W�W� ÊU1œ—u�

w�U?O?� w�W�“W?� Ë …œ—U�œ Ëu?�…Ë Âe?O�U�ï?O?�U� …ËW?O�ËËó?}?� ÍËË˙W�

ÂüW� ¨—W?�ËW??�W?� ÙU???� ¥∞≠≥∞ ï� …ËW???�|˙W???Ö…œ Political Doctrine

Ë ï????O???�????�????�MO?z Ë —W???�?�W???� W?� w1œU????�Wz Í…ËWM?O†ï?J}� w?�W�U� Ëu????�…Ë

ÆÙU� ¥µ W�UÖWz w�W�W� ¨«ËUz˛˘— w�U�ïJ�«“

ï� …ËW?MM|˙W?~�…œ W�W?�U� ÂWz w?�U�«“…—U???� Ë—…ó?|u� Ë —ï???á???�?Ä ÍW�—˘“

Æ ±∑∏π w��…—W� w�˙ï� w�«b†W�—W� w�U�

e�“W� d�U�

œ—u� w�…ËW�W� ÍW�UM�U� Ë ÂeO�U�ïO�U�

56

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

—…œd}� b�«dH�ïÖ ÊU�ï� w�UL†Wz w�u�WK�W� ÊW�ôW� ÂeO�U�ïO�U� wJ�WÇ —U� ÂW�W� ï�

Í…œW??�W� Ë «dM}�—U??�W� Â…œ˛W� Í…œW?� w?�U?�W??O�U�ï?� W?� q|œU� Íœ 5�??�?Öïz w��…—W??� Ë

Æ…Ëu�U�—U�W� WJ�WÇ ÂWz ÊWLÖ…œW� …œ“ï�

w�W?�…Ë«—«“ „…Ë …Ëu�U�—U???�W� ±∏≥∂ w?†U???� W� Íe???OK~?MOz w�U???�“W?� —U???� ÂW??�W?� ï�

ÆwMO�Uz

W� Êï�—ï??� ÍïJ?�«“ W� Æw��…—W??� w�U�ËËó??}??� Í≠ ÊUM|— X?��d??}z ±∏∏≤ w†U??� W�

Ë w�Ë— wJ}?á��dÄ ¨W?�˘— …ËW�W� ∫w�ËË åøWO?OÇ …ËW�W�ò w�U?AO�ËU�W� «œ p|—UMO?LO?�

w�U�U� ÊUO�W�W� 5O�…—W� w�� ËËœ w�U$Wz—…œ WO�ËWM�W� WáO��dÄ ÂWz Ë ¨WO�ËWM�W�

v�…œ …ËW�W� ÊU?M|— Íô W�«ËW?� ÆW�U??�?�?}z w?�U?�W?O�b?�W?�«“…— ÊU?O??A?O?�…ËËœ Ë W??O�—…Ë…œU�

Ͳï�ï?J�U?????� wJ}?�W†U?????� W????� åCommon Memoryò X}?�W� w?�W�ËU?� wJ?|—…Ë…œU�

ËU�b�˛«d?� Ë …—«˛WÄ Ë ÂW??� Ê…ËU??� ÊW???�…œ …ËW� X�W� ÙW???�ï??� w�«b�W?z W??� X}M?|œ ÂW�—W�

Ëu�«Ë w}Ä ÊUM|— Æ5?�…ËW�W� Íd?O� w�«—ï?� ËWz Í«˙W� ‘W�U?�Wz Æs�W?�ËU� w�W?O�—«œïJ�

w�ËuÇï?� w}ÄW� Ë X?}�W� wA???O�U�ï???� v�…œ ËW�W� ÍU�…—W???� „W�…œ—U�œ —W?� „…Ë …ËW�W�

˘—œW� Í≠ ÊUM|— ÍW�U�ËuÇï� ÂWz —UÖ˛˘— ÂüW� Æ…ËW?�|u�…œ Ë vM}�U� UÄË—ËWz W� …ËW�W� ËWz

a W�W�«˛˘— w�W?O?O?�dÄ«— …ËW�W� W?� W�…ËWz …ËW?�W� ï� ÊUM|— ÍW?�UM}Ä ÙU?�—W�W� ¨…ËW?�?�?�

Ædaily plebisite

ÂWz —W??�W� «ËUz˛˘— w~�U?�ËU�W� —˘“ Í—ï??á?�Ä —«u?Ç ËËœd�«— Í…œW?� w?�U?�W�U??�??�W� W�

Ë U?O�U?��—W� W� YL?� w�ï?��Wz «Ë Âï?O?��ï� p�d?}z Ë—WM?KO?Ö X��d?}z Æ…u?O?�Ëu� ÊU�W�W�U�

‹ÆUJ�d�Wz W� s�—b�Wz XJ|bOM}�

Ë X�Ëd?� W?� W?� W?O?O?�W�U?Ñ˘d?� W†W??�ï?� ËWz Natiam …ËW�W� s� w�ËuÇï�W� U�…Ë—W�

Æ…—U�«Ë«œ «bO�…ËW�W� ÍW�UM�U� Í—UO�dÄ w�«Ë…œ—W�W� W� «œËËó}�

∫‘W�«ËWz …Ëu�dÖ …Ëï�…Ë w�…—W� w�WO�U� v� …ËW�W� ï� ÊU�W�UM}Ä ÍW�—˘“

ÆW�W� …ËWM|u�W� Íb�…u�WÄ Spacial w�U�… ≠ Territory ≠±

W�U?�?�Wz w�W�ËU� w?M�?A�W~}� Common understanding Social w�W�üW?�ï?� ≠≤

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

57

ÆX�—W�u�«œ ≠ Ùu�LO� Ë w�ËËó}� Í—…Ë…œU�

Apparatus of Government David „…Ë ≠ ÊW????�u?J� ∫Political w�U????O????� ≠≥

ÆHelo

Lan- ≠ ÊU?�“ ≠≤ ÆTerrotory ≠ „U??� ≠± ∫W�U?�W� 5?��d� …ËW�W� w�U??�W�U??NJ}Ä ≠¥

ÆHistory ≠ ËËó?}� ≠µ Æreligion ≠ 5�Uz ≠¥ ÆCulture ≠ —u�?�W� ≠≥ Æguage

Æw�…ËW�W� ÍW�UM�U� w�œdJ��Ë—œ ï� 7��u}Ä Í—W��U� ‘W�«ËWz Ëu�W�

øWOOÇ ÂeO�U�ïO�U�

ï?� v�U??????� ê?O� «ËW??????� ÊW??????�…œ …ËW?z ï� …˛U??????�U?z w�«Ë…œ—W?�W?� W�W?�U� ÂW?z w?�U�«“…—U??????�

ï� ÊËuÇï� „W� U�…Ë—W� ¨Ë ÊËu�W� „ï� Ê«—ïá�Ä åÂeO�U�ïO�U�ò WJ�WÇ ÂWz w�œd�W�UM}Ä

w�U??O�…œWz W� …Ëu�W?� åÍ“«u?�…ËW�W?� Ë Í—W?Ö…ËW�W� Ë øv?M|œ p}Ä …ËW�W� w?Çò ÍW�W?�W??�

Ëu????�W� W???� …ËW?M�“˘b� Í—ï????O� „W?� 5�«u????�� W�W????L???�…“ —˘“ «b?�˛ï�ï????O???�ï????� Ë w�U???O????�

ÆÍï� W�|d~� ÂeO�U�ïO�U� w�U�W�ËuÇï�

Æ…ËW�œdJO?� „W� …eO?��«dÄ Í—ï~O�U?� Nation sA�W� ∫v†…œ Brubaker —WJ�W� Ëd�

w?†U?????� œW?????� ÆNation is a category of pcactice not a category of analysis

ï� «d?J�U?????�—W?� ¨—WM?KÖ ¨Z|Ëœ ¨”U?????O?� ¨ÊU�u?????� ¨s�u?????� ÊW�ôW?� ±π∏≤≠±∏∏≤ Ê«u?????}�

Æ…Ë«d� «b}� —˘“ Í—UJ�«˙ïÖ ËW�W� ÊËuÇï� p}�WÖ ËWz —W�W� ÂeO�U�ïO�U�

WÖ…—W� s�—b�Wz Æq}�—ï� ÍïJ�«“ W� ÊW�UO� ÍU��ï�U� ÍW�W�}�� w}ÄW� ≠±

Imagined conuni- ∫ Ëu?� p�«œ W?� 5Ç W?� ©≠±π≥∂ w?†U??????� W� Ë w?�b?�W�d??????}?z “

X?�?????????????O??� ÂW?� ties,Reflection on the origin and Spread of. nationalism:

W� X|—b?�…œ«œ W?�U?M}Ä s�d??�??�U�W� Âe??O�U?�ï?O??�U?� ï� s�—b�Wz ÍW??�UM?}Ä «œËËœd�«— ÍW�üU??�

…Ë«d?�UL?}� w�UO?� wJ}†W?�ï� …ËW�W� ∫X}†…œ «b�U?O�W?� …ËWO�˛ï�ï?O�ï?� Ë w�UO?� Í—«u�

…ËW�W� ¨WO�—…Ë—W� Ê…ËU� Ë ÊË«dJ�—U�œ w�U�Wá?O��…dÄ W� …Ë«dJ†U�W� Æ…Ë«dJ†U�W� œu�U�

¨s�U?�U� d????�???�W?� ÊU???� ê?O� gO????�Ëu????â� —˘“ w�W?�…ËW�W?� ÊW�U�W?� WJ�u?Ç …Ë«d???�U????L????}�

58

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

Ë…ËW�W?� s�—b?�Wz Æ7?�????O?�U� „W?� W� ê?O� ÊW�U?�W� Ë X?}�U?� …ËWJ?}Ä ÊU?????O�ËW?????�u????�?†W�

ÙW???ÖW� ªw�W???�WÄUÇ Í—«œW?�U??�—W???� Print Capitalism W� …ËW???�??}??�???�W�…œ Í“«u???�…ËW�W�

¨Ë w�U???L†W?z Ë w��…—W???� Ë Íe???OK?~MOz Ëu???�…Ë w?�U??�W???O?�—W??ÖW?ÇËU� W�U???�“ w�Ëu?� X�Ë—œ

W??� …ËW?�U??�W�U?M}� Í…ËW�b?M|u??� Ë w?�W??�WÄUÇ Í…œ—U?�œ wMO�ô w?�U??�“ ï� p?†W??� wM?O�«“W�

Ë…ËW�W?� wM�d~?�W� W� «ñ???}???Ö ÊU�—˘“ wJ?}†˘— W�«˛˘— ÍW???�U�˛˘— Ë—U???Ñï???Ö Ë V}???�??� W?�«ËW�

Nation and ≠ w�…ËW�W� ÍdO� Ë…ËW�W�® w�}�� —WMKÖ X��d}z ±π∏≥ w†U� W� U�…Ë—W�

Æ…ËW�U�…œ w� ÂeO�U�ïO�U� ï� Íï?� Í—ïO� Ë ÊËuÇï� «b�UO� W� œdJÄUÇ Í©Nationalism

ÂW� «b�ï?� W� Íï??� Âe?O�U�ï?O?�U� uJ?†W� W?O?O� …ËW�W� w�UM?}�U?ÖUzW� Âe?O�U�ï??O?�U� ËWz Í«˙W�

Âe???O?�U�ï???O????�U� ï� —W?MKÖ Í—ï????O� ÆU???�…œ X?�Ë—œ …ËW�W�W????O???O� v?� Í…ËW�W� W????� ÍW�UM?|u???�

w�W�üW??�ï??� w?�«˙ï?Ö Ë Í—Ëu?�Uz —W??�W� d�U�“ W??� È—b?�…œ«œ X�??O�U�d??O�U??� w�W??O?�—ï??O�W�

g� Modernity ËW�W� Modernity W?� Íb�…u?�WÄ Âe??????O?�U�ï??????O??????�U?� ËWz Í«˙W?� ÆÈËœ…œ

w�W?�?�?O?� W� w�?�?�u?}Ä g�“U?�W?A?OÄ Ë Industrialisation W?O�“U?�W?A??OÄ w�U?$Wz—…œ

ÂWz œd?� X�Ë—œ wJ|—Ëu?�?�W?� ‘W?O?O?�?A?Ö w�bM|u?� w�W?�?�?O?� ¨Ëu�W?� w�?A?Ö w�bM|u?�

W�«ËW???� ÆW�…ËW�W� Í—Ëu???��W???� ËW??�e???O�U�ï???O??�U� Í—Ëu???��W??� «b?�ï??� W� Íï???� ‘…—Ëu??�?�W??�

ÊW†Ë…œ W?� W??O?O?�U?O?� w?J}?á?O?��…d?Ä ∫U?�…œ ÍW?�UM}Ä Íï??� „…Ë —WMKÖ Íô Âe?O�U�ï??O?�U�

U�…Ë—W� ÆvM?}�˛…œ w�ï?�˙U?� wJ|“«u?}??�W� …ËW??�W�W� ©National® —u?�K� Ë ©Political®

Ë ÊW†Ë…œ Í—ËuM?� W?� w?�U?O??� w?�W?O??�—W??� Í—ï??O� W� W??O??O??��d� Âe??O�U?�ï?O??�U� W?�«Ë w}Ä

ÂôW� ¨W�d|œï??� w�W�…œ—U�œ …ËW�W?� —WMKO?Ö ÍôW?� U�…Ë—W� …ËW?�??}?�?�W?�…œ …ËWJ}Ä pOM�??Oz

Æ…ËËœd� w��Ë—œ «u� ËWOO��Ëd� w�W�…œ—U�œ …ËW�W� s}†…œ ©—…œd}� Ë—W�W�d}K�®

W� p}?�d?}� w�?O�ï?� W� W�U?�?�ï?�U?� X�?O�?�—U?� w�U�ËËó?}?� ∫Âï?�?��ï� p�d?}z ≠≤

∫ÍËU�W� Ãd�1W� ÍïJ�«“ W� …Ë«d� ÛUÇ ±ππ∞ w†U� W� W� «b�W�W�}�� W� Ê…b�W� ÍïJ�«“

Nations and Nationlim sinc 1780: Programme. Myth and reality.

È—b�«u?�U� W???� W�«Ë w}?Ä Ë Âe??O?�U�ï???O???�U� w�œd???�W???�UM?}Ä W� W?MO???�???�…— —˘“ Âï???O??�?�ï�

Íô WJ�uÇ s}?M�«œ Âe?O�U�ï?O??�U� ï� W�U?O?O?�«“ ÊU� v� W�U?O�W�U� ı X?�?OÄW� ñÄ w�W�W??�UM}Ä

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

59

ÍôW� ÂüW� Æ…“ï†Uz Ë ÊWL?�…“ wJ|—U� «b�ï� W� Íï� …ËW�W� w�Ëu� X�Ë—œ Í—U?O�dÄ ËWz

Mod- Í—«œd�W� W��…u�WÄ gO�W†Ë…œ w�Ëu� X�Ë—œ Ë W�…ËW�W� Í—WM|—“W�«œ ÊW†Ë…œ ËWz

ÆW�W?†Ë…œ w�U??�W???O�˛ï?�ï�b�U?z U??�WM?� W� ‘…ËW�W?� Ë …Ë«b†W� Í—W???� «ËUz˛˘— W� W???� ernity

…ËW�W� w�Ëu� X�Ë—œ ï� 5� —W?��U� W?�U� ËËó}?� Ë—Ëu��u� ËU?O�«d?Öu� ÂïO?��ï� w�ËuÇï�W�

w�Ëu� X?�Ë—œ w�…œ—W??�W� W�W� ÊU???O�b�…u�WÄ ˙W??� Ë w?�U??O??� Ë Í—Ëu�Uz Í—U??�ï� u?J†W�

ÆNation State. ÆW�…ËW�W� w�W†Ë…œ

Ë w�?�M?�?Oz w�ï?O?�??�MOz Ë Í˛ï�ï?O??�ï?� w�W� ÍU?�?�ï??�U?� ªYO?L?� Íœ w?�ï?��Wz ≠≥

Natin and National- Í—UÑï� Í—W?�Ëu�—W� Ë Ê…b�W� ÍïJ�«“ W� LSE W� ÂeO�U�ïO�U�

Y?L????????� wM?O?�«Ëñ????????}?� Ë ÊËuÇï?� ¨W?�W?�W?�U� ÂW?z w?J?�—W????????� Ë ±π∑∞ w�üU????????� W?� aism

Ë…ËUÇ—W??� ËW?�UM}?Ä ÍW�W?�W??� Í…—U� W� …“«ËU??O?� Ëu?A??}Ä ÍW�«ËWz ÙW??ÖW� w�œd??�œ—Ë«—W�W�

Ë W�ï?� —˘“ uJ†W?� W?O?O� Êd|œï?� w�W�…œ—U?�œ …ËW�W� W�«Ë w}Ä YL?� Æ…ËW�W?� w�Ëu?�?�?�Ë—œ

—˘“ wJ}�U�ï� …ËW�W� v†…œ The ethnic origin of Nations w�UAO�ËU�W� ÍW�W�}��W�

¨X}M|œ p}Ä „W�U~†W?�ï� W?� W� Modernity W� —W� w�U?�WOMO?�?Oz WÄËdÖ ÍËu�ËWJA?}Ä

W�W�U� ÂWz w�U�«“…—U� W� —˘“ Æ…—U�œ …u}Ä w�U?�WOO�UO� WO�—U?�«Ë«œ Ë Í—Ëu��W� ÍW�UM�U�

Ethno Symbol- v�…œ Íï?� W?� ËU� Íï?� YL??� ÂüW� s}�…œ«œ Premodialist W� YL?�

Æic

Ë ÊüË U�…Ë—W� ¨ËW�W� ÊU�Ë«dJ�—U�œ wJ|ËU� W�WJ†W?� W†W�ï?� ËWz YL� Íô …ËW�W�

ÊU�—Ëu�Uz „W� Ë ¨‘W�ËU� w�?A?Ö Í—u�K� ¨„U?� ¨‘W�ËU� ÍËËó?}� ¨‘W?�ËU� ÍW�U�?�Wz

ÂWz 7�…Ë…œ«— —W�W� Í…ËW�W� W� W�W� ÍWJâ?}Ä ‘W� YL� w�ËuÇï�W� Ethnicity W�W�

∫WJâ}Ä ‘W�

Í—…Ëd???O� ≠≥ ÆË«d????�U� Íœ«˛W� ÍW�U????�???�Wz ≠≤ ÆË«d???�U� w?ç???O???�J?}�ï???� wJ?|ËU� ≠±

ÆSolidarity w��—«bO�ï� ≠∂ ÆÊüË ≠µ ÆË«d�U� wJ|—u�K� ≠¥ Æ‘W�ËU� w�ËËó}�

Ë Í—Ëu?��W?� w�W�…ËWM�ËËe� Âe?O�U�ï?O?�U� W?� W�«Ë Í˙…ËU� YL?� Âe?O�U�ï?O?�U� Í…—U�—…œ

wM��«—UÄ Ë w�…ËW�W� w�?}�W� Í…ËWM�A}� Ë w�ï�ï�ïz w�UM}N?��…œW� ï� ÙËW� W�˛ï�ï�b�Uz

60

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

w�…ËW�W� ÍW??�UM�U� gO�W??��U�W� ËW?�UM?�U� Í—U?O?�dÄ «œ…d??}� ÆÊ«œ…œ w�…ËW�W� ÍW??�UM�U�

Êï??� w�U�ï� ÍW??�ËË W� ÍW?�…ËUÇ—W??� ∫Ethnicity øW??O??OÇ W?�U?M�U� U�Uz ¨…ËW??�??}�…œ ‚…“

Ë ¨W??O?O� Ë«—“W??�«œ wJ}�U??L??Oz W� Í«Ëñ� W??� ÍW?�W‡?‡‡� ËWz ÍU�U??�W� ethnikos …Ë«d??O?Ö—…Ë

non- jows non - ¨u�…Ë outsiders œu�U� Foreigners W�U~}� ÍU�U?� wM�}z U�…Ë—W�

wJ†W??� p}??�W??� —W� W� ÊU?�…œ Ë W�U~}� ÍU?�U?� W?� gO�U??�˘— w�U??�…“ W� Ëøchritians

ÊW?�ôW?� ±πµ≥ W� Ë—W?�—«Ëb?�ï?� ÊW?�ôW� ±π¥± w?†U????????� W?� ethnicity ÆW?�«u?�W?� U????????�˘—

Æ…Ëu�U�—U�W� ÊU�e�«Ëbç�…œ

W�UM�U�

Relational …—«b??�b?�…u??�W?Ä Ë ÊËË˙U??� œu???????????????�U?� —U??�œU?� w??J?}??J?�W??Ç W???????????????�U?M??�U?�

ÊU� ”W�ËËœ Ê«u?}� W�W�b�…u�WÄ ËWz W?�UM�U� Æd� ÍËWz ÙWÖW� ”W?�W�U� w�U�W?O�b�…u�WÄW�

ÆÊËuâ�W�W� „W� ÊËu�UO� ÍU�WM� —W�W� U�…œ ÙW�«— d�U�“

ÍU~|— W� W?MO?�U�ï?� w�??}?�˘dÄ ÆpO�U??�?� „W� W?O??OJO?�UM�«œ w?J}�W?�W?� W??�UM�U�

«œ…d??}?� ÍW??à???ç??}� ËW?z ËW�W� vK?ç??}� —˘“ W???�UM�U?� ÆÈËW??�…œ—…œ d� ÍËW?z ÙW??ÖW� Íb?�…u�WÄ

©≤µ® ËW� W?�W� w�…ËW�W� ÍW?�UM�U� Í—U?O�d?Ä WO�…ËW�W� ÍW?�UM�U� ÂWJ� w�U� ÈËW?�…œ

ÂW� —W� Æ…ËW�Ëu?� ‚…“ Ë«b†W� Í—W?� w�U??O?� ï??O?�ï?� w?�W�…œ—U�œ „…Ë «b?O�«Ëœ ÍW?†U?�

w�üW�˛˘— ËUÄË—ËW?z w�U�üË W� Ethinici w�…ËW�W?� ÍW?�U?M�U� w�dÄ ËW??A??}??� «œW�…ËU??�

ô ÊU�…ËWz Í—U??O??�dÄ ÈËW� Ë…d??}� U??O??�U??O??� wÄËd?Ö Æ…ËW?�—«“u?� Ë«b?†W� Í—W??� X�«˙…ËU�

uJ†W� …ËW??�|—“˘b� W??O?O� p}?�W?�W?� w?�…ËW�W� ÍW?�UM?�U� Æø5}?� W??L?}z U?�Uz Ëu� X�Ë—œ

W� W�…ËWz Í…ËW�W� ÍW�UM�U� w�Wà�W� ÆW�«œ Í—UJ�«˙ïÖW� w�«Ë…œ—W�W� Ë Èd�…œ X�Ë—œ

Ë X�—W�u�«œ ¨U?O�«d?Öu� ¨ËËó?}� ¨ÊW?�UO?� ÍU~|— W� ÈdJ� ÍW�U?AO� Èd?�…œ Wç?O�J}�ï?�

„W� W� …ËWM�WJ�ï� w�…ËW�W?� ÍW�UM�U� ÍW�U�UHO?� ÂWz Ëu�W� Èd�U� v†…œ YL?� Æ—u�K�

ÍW�UM}Ä ï?� ÆåW�W�ô …d�ò W‡ Multi dimentional w�…ËW�W� ÍW�UM�U?� WJ�uÇ «bJ†U�

W?� W?�W?�«Ë…œ—W� W�œd??� X�Ë—œ ËWz w�…ËW�W� ÍW??�UM�U� v†…œ YL??� w�…ËW�W� ÍW??�UM�U�

w�«d??O??� W� Ë …ËW??�W�W� …ËW�U??�…œï??� X�—W�u�«œ ËW?�U?�??�Wz Ë Í—…Ë…œU� Ë Ùu??�??L??O??� ËU�W�

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

61

U?�…œ —«œU?ÖUz ï� W?� W�…ËWz w�…ËW?�W� ÍW?�UM�U� w�—Wz s�d?�~�d?Ö Ë X?}�…œ —U�œ W�…ËW�W�

øX�Ëu�U� …u|u�W� Ë XO}�

”U� Æv�W� Ê—u?�K� Ë v�W� XM|u?� v�…œ Ëu�W� XO�…ËW�W� ÍW?�UM�U� ï� —WÖ W�«ËW?�

…—ï??� ı ”W?�W??�U� U�Uz W?� …ËW?�U?�…œ ‚…“ …ËWz Í—U??O?�dÄ W??�UM�U� W?� …ËWMO†ïJ}� Ë Êœd??�

ËËœ 5}?à� 5�«u�…œ W�ï?� øÙW?�ï�W?� …b�W�UÄ b�WÇ øW�W� …ËW�W?�U~?†W�ï?�W?� w�W?O�b�…u�WÄ

©…ËW� ontinuity® ÊËu?��«Ë…œ—W� ∫U?�…œ «dJ�Uz Ë ÊËË— …ËW�W?� ÍW�UM�U� w?�…—W� w†U?�

…ËW�W� wM?�?A�W~}?� W� gO�Ëu?�??�«Ë…œ—W� Ë Diferentiation d� ÍËWz W� …ËW?�œd?�U??O?� Ë

U�U� ËWz ï� gO�U�W�W�W�U� wM�?A�W~}� W� ÊËu��«Ë…œ—W� ÆX}†u�…b†W� ËËó}� w�«ó|—œW�

WÇ—UÄ ÊU?� ÆüUz W�Ëu/ ï� Ë ÊW??Ö…œ w}� Ê…ËW?�W� w�«b�Wz ÍW?�«ËWz U?O?�W� W??� ÍW�U??�W�ËU�

Æp}O�«—ïÖ ÊU� „W�…Ë«d�ï� ¨w�…ËW�W� w�W�ïK�U� ÊU� p}J�“u�

w�U??�W?O??O?�…—W??� …ËUÇ—W?�W� ¨‘W?�ËU� ÍU�U?� w�??}?�W?� ¨—Ëu?��W??� ¨ÙW?�ï??� s� Í«˙W�

s�d?��«u?� “˘—ËW� W� …ËW�œd?�d?ÖUz W�Ëu/ ï� Æs|—b�…œ«œ w�…ËW?�W� ÍW�U?M�U� w�Ëu� X�Ë—œ

Í—W?��U?� Rituals, Symbols W�«ËW?� Æ…ËW�œd?�d?ÖUz w�u?I� Rituals Æ…ËWz ï� W�W�Ëu/

Æw�…ËW�W� ÍW�UM�U� w�œd� X�Ë—œ ï� 5�…—W�

øœ—u� w�…ËW�W� Í…ËWM�ËËe� ÊU� Íœ—u� w�eO�U�ïO�U�

Íœ—u?� w?�e?O�U�ï??O?�U� ÍW�W??�W?� W� ”U?� w�?��«“ w�W?�…u?}?�W?� X|ËW�U0 —W?Ö ˘ñ??�Wz

State 5�W†Ë…œ v� Í…ËW�W� s�d�…—ËWÖ œ—u� ÍWL}z W� s�d~� ËUÇ—W�W� …ËWz v�…œ s�WJ�

Ëu????�U?� ÊW�U?�W� ÆU????O?�Ëœ Ëu????�W?� W� u?J†W� X?�«˙…ËU� w?�üW�˛˘— W?� „W� less Nation

Ëu??�W?� ±∏∑± W� ÍW??�—U??L???�� ËWz Æ…Ëu?�ËW??�WM†W?� v� ÊU??LJ?}??�—U??L???�� W??L???}z U??�??�???}z

œu????�U� Æ„W� …œd????� ÍU????O�U?*WzË Ë…Ë…œd????�ï???� «b?�W†Ë…œ „W� W?� ÍU???O?�U???L?†Wz w?�U???�W?Ç—UÄ

ÍW†U� …œ“UÄ ÂW� ÂüW� ≠ „W� …œd� ÍË«d�WÇ—UÄ WÇ—UÄ ÍUO†U�Oz ±∏∂± W� W� Íb†U��—UÖ

—W??��W??Ñ f�U??� —W??Ö W�W� ÊU??� Unique pO�u?Ä Ë ÊW?L??Ö…œ w?J}�Ëu??�“Wz W??L??}z «b??O�«Ëœ

62

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

ÂWz w�Ëu�“WzW� ‚«d?}� w�U?��œ—u� W?L}z r}†…œ s� Unique WJO�u� «ËUz˛˘— W� w�?}��uÖ

WFO�«Ë Íd�Wz w�W†Ë…œ ÊU�?�œ—u� W� …Ë«œ ÍËË— Í…ËWz Ë 5JO�u� «b�ULO�«Ëœ ÍW†U� ±µ

w�U?M�U????O?M� ÍW????�˘d?Ä «b�ï?????� W� Íï????� ‘W?�Ëu????�“Wz ËW?z —W� de facto kurdish state

ÆÍW�WOO�UO�ïO�ï� U�U�W� Nation - Building W�…ËW�W�

X}OÑï� w�}�W� w�U?�Ë— ‘UÄ 5MO�…œ s�WJ� …ËW�W� Ë ÊW†Ë…œ ÍW�W�W� Íd�W� —WÖ

Í…—U?????�˛ W????� W?�U????O?�«u????�?????O� ÊU?????OM?�d????�?????�Ëu????â?� Ëu� X?�Ë—œ v� w?�W†Ë…œ ±¥ ÈËW?� —W�

U�…Ë—W� Æw�UL?}K� Ëd}�ËW� Íd?}�˛—W?�W� …d��W?� W� uO?� Ë ÊïOK� W�UÖ…œ ÍW?�W�«u�?AO�«œ

„…Ë ÆÂe??O�U??O??�ï??� Ë Âe??O??�?�—U??�W?� Ëu�b�W� W??� ÊüW�˛˘— ÍUÄË—ËW?z w�U??�W??O�—UJ�«˙ï??Ö

Ë«d� Í—U�œ ËË«d�U� w�W†Ë…œ ©µ¥® U?O�W� ±πµ∞ w†U� W� ÆUO�U�ïK�ïJOÇ ËU?O�ö��u�

ÆÊW†Ë…œ ±π≤ W�A�WÖ «œ≤∞∞∞ w†U� W� ÂüW� UO�Ëœ W� Ëu�W�

qOz«d?�Oz Æv�W� w�U?O� Í…ËW�W� Í…ËWz v�W� v�…œ X�Ë—œ ÊW?†Ë…œ «œ…œËË— —U�—˘“

d?????O????�ò @?�W�U?????�W� U?� Ͳ…œ w}?� ÍWJ?†W????� ËW?z ÂüW� W?�W†Ë…œ q?Oz«d?????�????O?z ÆX|u?????� Ë

…ËW�W� ÂüW� ©f�U?��?�® @�W�U?�W� Ͳ…œ v� ÍWJ†W� ËWz ËW?�W†Ë…œ X|u� ¨åf�U?��?�

ÊW†Ë…œ Ë…ËW�W� w?�U?$u?Ö ï� s� Í«˙W� W?�Ëu/ s�d?�?�U� ÆW?�…—ËW?Ö wJ}?à??}?� uJ†W� W??O?O�

ÆWOO� ÊU9W†Ë…œ ÂüW� s�…ËW�W� œ—u� ÍWL}z Æ…b�u� Ë ÊïÄ«˛ ÍW�WOO�ï�—U� …u}�W�

w�Ëu?� p�«œW� Ë W???�???O�d|œï???� ÍW???�˘dÄ w�U???$Wz—…œ «ËUz˛˘— W?� w�…ËW�W� ÍW???�UM?�U�

ÍW�˘dÄ w�U$Wz—…œ œ—u?� ÍWL}z Íô ÆWOO�«d�u1œ Ë ÊËu� w�üËU� Ë w?�…œW� ÍU~†W�ï�

Ë ÊU1…ËW�W?� ÍW?�UM?�U� ï� å„—u� ¨”—U??� Æ»…—W?�ò W?�«Ë W?L??}z ï� …d� ÍËW?z w�œd?�e??�…—

W� UÄË—ËWz W?� Âe?O�U�ï??O?�U� Æ…ËWM?M|uM�U0 «b�U�ï??� w�W??�?�?O??� W� W�U�Ëu??�?��Ë W??� ÊU/Ëu�

ÆÆœdJ}Ä w��…œ ÂW�…œ“ï� Í…œW� w�U�ï�W� œ—u� Íô ÂW�…œ˛W� Í…œW� w�U�WO�U�ï�

W� øp}?�eO�U�ï?O�U� …—ï?� ı g�ËWz ÈdJ� @�d?Ö w�W�W�W�W?� ï� …˛U�Uz v�…œ «œ…d?}�

ÊU� Ethnic W�W� Âe?O�U�ï?O?�U� …—ï?� ËËœ Âe?O�U�ï?O�U?� Ͳï�ïO?�ï?� Ë w�U?O?� w�U?O�…œWz

W?�?�…u�WÄ W??� …ËW?OMO�…œ Ethinc ËU�W� ÊU?�ï?� d�U�“ œ—u?� ÍW?L?}?z s� w�ËuÇï�W� ∫civic

W?�?�…u�W?Ä WJ�uÇ W‡ civic w�?A??ÖW� «ËUz˛˘— W� ÂüW� Socialisation Ë ÊU?�“ Ë —u?�K�W�

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

63

«ËW� W�…ËWz s� Í…ËWMO†ïJ}� Íe?}� Æw�«d�u1œ Ë ÊËu� w�üËU�W� Ë w�…œW� ÍU~†W?�ï�W�

—˘“ w�b�W�…—WÄ Ë œ—u?� w�eO�U�ï?O�U� —W?� W�˘œd� ÊU�—U� W?� ÍW�«—W�?�U� ËWz ±ππ± U�

»…—W�W� ∫„…Ë f�W� w�U�W�W�UO� ï� Reaction „…Ë W� Reactionory Ë íO�W~}�

Ëu?�W�W� U�?�?}z Ëu�U� ±ππ± w�Ëu?�“Wz ÂüW� ÆÆÊœd?� w��W�W?� ¨‰UH�Wz ¨…ËW�«u� ¨Êœd?�

ÍËU� Ë s�…b� ÂW?†W?� W� ÍPositive W� 5�«u�…œ …ËW??O?O?�U?�W?O??O?�ï??�U� ËW?�W?†WÇ Ë @�W�

w�Ëu� ÈdMO?�…œ w�U?�?�œ—u?� W� Í…ËWz WJ�uÇ Æ…ËW�W?� w�W†Ë…œ w�UM�U?OM� w?�Ëu?�“Wz 5}M�

—W??Ö w?�e??O??� …d??� œu???�U� Pluralist X�??O?�—uKÄ w�W?�W~�«Ë˙ W� ÊW†Ë…œ Ë ÊW???�uJ�

Popu- ≠ Ê«u�AO�«œ ≠± ÆÈËW?�…œ—…œ ÊU�ï� ÊU��œ—u� —W�W� s�WJ?� ÊW†Ë…œ Í…eO��«dÄ

governmental ÊU�WO�uJ� Ë Íñ}Ö—U� ÍUÖ“…œ ≠≥ ÆTerritory ≠ „U� ≠≤ Ælation

≠µ ÆInternational erlation ≠ w�Ë…œ Íb�…u�WÄ ≠¥ Æadmiustratie instiution

ÆArmy dJ�W�

ÂeO�U�ïO�U� Ëœ—u� Í—…ó|u�

Ë ÍdJ?O????� w?J}?MO????�Ëu?� „…Ë s|˙W?~� «œ©Text® ‚…œ Í«ËœW� —W?????Ö œ—u????� ÍW????L?????}z

ÊW�U�W?� Æv�«d??�Ëu� Âe??O�U?�ï??O??�U� —W??�W� W??O??O?� ÊU??L??�…œ wH�d??�W??� œu??�U� Ë w?�W??��W??�

w�U??� w�U??�…d?F??O??� W� p|b�W?� Ë v�W� ©±∑∞∑≠±∂µ∞® w�U??� ÍœW?L??�Wz wM?�“u?�W??�

©±µπ∂® W� w�??O�œW� w?�U?�??�—W??� gO�«ËWz g}Ä W?� Ë©±ππ∑≠±∏±∑® w�ï?� Í—œU??�

Æ…ËuO�u� ÍW�UM�…—W�

Ë«œW�W???� Ë«—W??�?K~MO?z w�U??�ï?J�«“ W� W�W?� œ—u??� Í—ï???á??�Ä Ë—…ó?|u� b�WÇ …ËW?�…—U� ÂW�

b???O???�W??� Ë—Ëu?Ä ÊW???�W??� d???O???�Wz Ë w?�…Ë ”U�W???� u???�…Ë ÊW�W�U� ÂW?z wJ�—W???� U???��…—W???�

ÆÊôW�—Wz“ï�

ÍW�W??�W?� —W??�W� d�U�“ —Ëu?Ä ÊW?�W??� d?O??�Wz ÆW� w?�…Ë ”U�W?� d??�~�d??Ö ÊU�Ëu??�W� W�

—Wz …“ï� b???O??�W??� Ë W?�W� wMO??�Ëu?� sA�WJ?O�u??O??�ï???� Ë ÊU??�“ ¨ Íœ—u??� w�e???O�U�ï??O???�U�

—˘“ ËU??O?�—u?� W� œ—u?� w?�W�«ËW�W� w�U??� —W??�W� w�U??�WMO??�Ëu� Ë ”U� ÍW�—˘“ gO�ôW??�

64

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

Í—W?�?}??� W� w�…Ë ”U�W?� ÂüW� Æw�ËËó?}??� ÍU�˛ï�ï?O?�ï?� ÍW?�U?� WM|d?�…œ w�U?�W?MO?�Ëu�

ÆvÇU�—…œ ÂeO�d|œï� X�ïÄ Ë ÂeO�d|œï� w�U�WO�«ËUz˛˘— WO�—ïO�

œu???�U� ¨W???�??�???O�U?�ï??O???�U� uJ?†W� W???O??O?� w�e???O�U�ï???O???�U� œ—u???� ∫v†…œ w�…Ë ”U�W???�

W� p}�eO�U�ïO?�U� ¨œu�U� Íœ—u� w�W†Ë…œ w�Ëu�W� Íï�W� ‘…ËWz WO�…ËW�W� Í…ËWM�ËËe�

«b�U?�W??O�U?�??�W� w�U�ï?� W� W??� v�W� PKK Í…ËWM�Ëe� U??N�W� ¨ÊUJ� w�ï??�W�—W?� Í«Ë«œ

‘W� ‘…ËWz w�U?$Wz—…œ ËWz Í«˙W� Ë ÆËu?� w�ï?�W�—W� W?�…ËWM�Ëe� ÂWz w�…—W?� w�U?Ö˘dÄ

—˘“ w�…Ë ”U?�W??� s� w?�ËuÇï�W?� ¨…œ—u??� w�…ËW?�W� ÍW???�UM�U� w?�Ëu�WÇ—UÄ Ë ÊËu?� ‘W�

‚«d}� Í«Ëœ …ËWz W� s�WJ� Íœ—Ë«—W� Ëœ—u� Í…ËW�W� ÍW�W�W� w�U� —WÖ …Ëu�A�˘— —ËËœ

Æ‚«d}� w�…—W� W� …—U�œ …u}Ä ÊU�…ËW�W� w�UH� d�U�“ œ—u� ÍWL}z W�«Ë r}Ä

ÍUJ�d??�Wz W??� W�W?� p}�b�W9W??��U� ¨…ËW?�œdJO??� ï� s�d~�—…Ë U?J�d??�Wz ÍW�Ëu/ —W??Ö

w�Ëu?� ËüWJ}� W?� W??O???O??��d?� W??� …ËW�«u?� ÍW�ï� Melting pot Æs}†…œ w?}Ä œd??� X�Ë—œ

Æ«œ—u�K� „W� W� UJ�d�Wz ÍW�UO�UO� W�WKKO� ËWz Ëu�W�

ÂWz «ËW???� Í…ËWz ÍW?~�«Ë— W� Êd???Ö…œ Íœ—u???� w�e???O�U�ï???O???�U� W� W?M�…— ÊW� p|b?�W�

Ëu� «ËW?� WO?O� w�W†Ë…œ œ—u?� WJ�uÇ Ë ÆU?�U� Íï�W�—W?� ÍW�W?��W?� …˛U�Uz W?�e?O�U�ïO?�U�

ËW� ˛œ s?� ËW??O?�…Ë ”U�W???� Æœ w�U???�WM?O??�Ëu?� W� W�U?�ËuÇï� ÂWz ÆW???O???O� w?�e??O?�U�ï???O???�U�

Ëu???�W� Ë unigue ≠ 5�U?� ≠ ‚«d???}???� w�U???�???�œ—u???� Íœ—u???� ÍW???L???}z ∫r?}†…œ W�U�Ëu?Çï�

w�UO�…œW?z W� W� s�˛…œ p}�Ëu�“Wz W?� ÊWà�Wz W?L}z ËW�«b?}� ÊU9W†Ë…œ w�Ëu� w�U�W?�—W�

©±µ® ÂW� Í…ËWz ¨©lO?�«Ë Íd?�Wz w�W†Ë…œ ≠ defacto® 5}†…œ w}Ä ÊW??�U?O?� w�?��«“

¨W?�eO�U�ï?O�U� «b�ï?� W� Íï?� Èd�…œ …e?O�?�«eÄ Ë Ê«œ…œËË— ÊU?��œ—u?� W� «bO�«Ëœ ÍW†U?�

Âï� Í…b�…“W�W� ÆUJ� X�Ë—œ Nation - State …ËW�W� w�W†Ë…œ ÈËW�…œ WJ}�eO�U�ïO�U�

ï� ¨…Ëu��W� …ËW�W� Ë ÊW†Ë…œ w�œdJ��Ë—œ Í—ï�Ë«—ï?� w�W�…ËW�bM|u� b�WÇW� r�AÄ W�

ÍWJ�œ w�U?�WÇ—UÄ Í…ËWz v� ÍœW�?}� w�ï?��—W� «b?O�«Ëœ ÍW†U?� b�WÇ ÂW� W�W�«ËW� WL?}z

W??�??}� W??L?}?z ÍW?O?�—Ëu?�?�W?� Ë w?�U?O??� …—«ËW??� ÂWz Ë…ËW??�|d??�??�W?�?� …ËW?L??}zW?� ÊU?�??�œ—u??�

Íœ—u� w�W�U?O� Í—W��W� WMO�…œ ‘W?L}z —W� ¨…—ËWÖ w�U��œ—u?� w�W†Ë…œ ï� w�W�U�WM�

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

65

¨X�«˙…ËU� w�üW�˛˘— Ëu�W?� W� W�Ëu�“Wz W�U� W�Ëu?�“Wz ÂWz Æs�˛…œ UO� W?� ÍW�…œW� ÂW�

w�e??O�U�ï?O??�U� Í…u?}??� ÊU?�W�W� Íœ—u??� w�e?O�U�ï??O?�U� W??O?O� —ËË—…“ —˘“ s� w?�ËuÇï�W�

¨„W�U~†W�ï?� —W� 5�«“…œ „…Ë WJ�uÇ ¨v�� ˙Wá?}� ÍeOK~MOz ÊU� w�U?L†Wz ÊU� w��…—W�

„…Ë Âe?O?�U�ï?O??�U� ÆW�W� Íï?� w?�W?��U� w�ËËó??}?� Ë w�U??O?� Ë Í—Ëu??��W?� wJ}??�˘œË—U�

¨„W�U�˛ï�˘b?�Uz W� U?O?�W� W?O??O� w��d� ÊW??�…œ —W?�W?� w�?�W??� W�W�U� ÂWz w?�U�U�«“ ÍW�—˘“

U�…Ë—W?� ¨«b???O�…ËW?�W� ÍW???�UM?�U� Ë…ËW�W?� Ê«u???}� W?� W???O???OJ?O???�JO?�U�œ wJ?|—…ËW� uJ?†W�

«œ…œËË— ÊU????�???�œ—u????� W� Í…ËW?z …Ë…©±ππ±® w†U????� ‘UÄW� W????� X?}ÇW� œU?� W� ÊU????�…ËWz

¨W?O�…ËW?�W� ÍW?�UM�U� w�œd??�ËW?�Ä Ë≠ Nation Building W�…ËW�W� w�U?M�U?OM� …Ë«b�ËË—

W?�üU?????� ©≤µ≠±∏® Ê«u??????}� w?�W?????�W?� U?????�??????�?????}?z W?????� …Ëu?� X�Ë—œ „W?�…ËW� r?}†…œ s?�

w�?�W� W� Í…ËW� d�U�“ W?O?O�W�«œ—u� ËW?OO�U?�?�œ—u� W?� W�W� Íï� w�W?��U� w�W�W?�UM�U�

ÆX}�W� ‚«d}� ÍW�UM�U� Ë ‚«d}� —W��«—W�

øÈu� ï� ÊU��œ—u�

¨U�…œ X�Ë—œ Chech and Balance Âe?O�«—b?O?� øÂe?O�«—b?O?� ÍW?A?}?� Ë ÊU?�?�œ—u?�

W�W†Ë…œ ≠ Federalism statesò w�???}???�???� Í…d?|u???ÖW� ÊW???�u?J� w�U???�W???à???ç???}?† Ê«u???}�

«œ˘ñ????�Wz ÍU????O�œ W?� ÊW†Ë…œ ©≤µ® Æ…Ë«dJ?ÄUÇ ≤∞∞≤ w?†U???� W?� W????� åÊU???�W????O†«—b????O????�

Íd??}??�˛—W???� Í…u??O� W�U??�…œ „W?�…œ«˙U� W�üË ©≤µ® ÂWz ÆͲ…œ w†«—b???O??� w�W??�??�???O??�W�

Multiculturalism W� U?????O�œ w}?????�˛—W????� ©•πµ® ZM}?Ä Ëœ…ËW� «œW????� W?� Ë ÍË…“—W????�

X�?O†«—b?O?� w�W?�?�?O� d?|˛W� ÊW†Ë…œ ©±π≥® Íï?� W� ÊW†Ë…œ ©≤µ® w�üËU� Æs�˛…œ

¨bMO� ¨U?��W� ¨U?O�«d�?�uz ¨s�Ë…“ —W?� Ê«Ëu�?AO�«œ Í©•¥∞® wKÇ «œW?� W�«ËWz Æs�˛…œ

Æb�� ÆÆUJ�d�Wz ËUO�UL†Wz ¨UO�uO�Wz ¨q�“«—W�

w�U???�W�W?†Ë…œ ©•∑∞® ÍU???�??�W?� «œW???� —…“ö??O?z ÙU??O?�«œ w�U???�…ËWMO?†ïJ}?� Í…d|u???ÖW�

«d?��u?� w�Ëu?�“Wz U�Uz Æs�˛…œ Âe?O†«—b?O?� w�U�U?�WM� W� p?|b�W� —W?�W� ÊUN?O?� ͢ñ?�Wz

w†U� «d?��u� ¨d}?�W� r}†…œ Âï� w†U?�W� ‘W� s� øÈ—œdO~�—…u?}� Íœu� WL?}z ï� Èd�…œ

Ë ÊïOK� ©∑® w�«u�?AO�«œ Í…—U�˛ ÆW��?O†«—bO� «bO�?�«—W� ÂüW� …Ëu� w†«—bH�ï� ±∏¥∏

66

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

w}� ”W??� ≥µ∞[∞∞∞ W?� ¨W�URi Êï??��U?� s�d??�?�u??â� Ë…Ëu�U� p?}Ä Êï?��U??� ©≤∂® W�

¨W�W?� ±[≤≤∏[∂∞∞ w�«u�AO�«œ Íd?}�˛—W� W� W?��—u|“ wMOA�ï��U?� s�d�…—ËWÖ ¨Í˛…œ

•∂≥[π W??� Æw?�U??�˘— Ë ¨w†U???�??Oz ¨w?��…—W??� ¨w?�U??L†Wz ¨W???O??}� w?�…—W??� w�U???�“ —«uÇ

w�«ËWz •π[µ ËW??O�U??�˘— •µ ËW?O??O†U??�??Oz •∂[∂ ËW?O??O??��…—W??� •∏π[µ Ë W?O??O�U??L†Wz

ÆÆÆ…d�

ÊU�…ËUÇ—W�

- Abbas Wali, “The Kurd and the “others”, Fragmented Identity and Framented

Politics” ‘comparatives Studies of South Asia and Middle East, Volxvlll, No2.

- Anthony D. Smith, “the Ethnic origin of Nations” Oxford, DUP. 1986.

- Anthony D. Smith. National Identity, London, Penguin, 1991.

- Bene dict Anderson, “Imagined Communities, reflecton on the origin and

spread of Nationalism, “London, Verso, 1983.

- Eric Hobsbawm, “Nation and Nationalism Since 1780, Cambridye, Cup, 1990.

- Ernest Gillner, “Nation and Nationalism”, Ithaca, Cornell. UP. 1983.

- Amir Hassan Pour: “Nationism & language in kurdistan (san francisico, Meilon

up - 1994).

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

67

©©©©eeee����““““WWWW���� dddd����UUUU����®®®® ÍÍÍÍWWWW����WWWW����WWWW����UUUU���� ————WWWW����WWWW���� ïïïïÖÖÖÖuuuu����HHHHÖÖÖÖ

W� Í…—UMOL?O� ÂWz ï� ÂW�…œ …ËWM�ó|u� ÍWJM� w�UÄu?� w�WA}Ä ∫∫∫∫ssss����ddddÖÖÖÖUUUUzzzz xxxx††††ËËËËbbbb����WWWW���� ÆÆÆÆœœœœ

U��ï?�U� ÍW�W�U� ÂWz Í…—U� W� Íï�ËU� ËïÖu�H?Ö U�…Ë—W� …Ëu���J|— Íd�U� U�?�ï�U� ï�

ÊËË— d�U�“ ï� b�«˛Ë—Ë w?~�d?Ö w�W�U� v†W?�ï?� «œ…—UMO?L?O?� ÂW� «b?O?�?�«—W?� Æs�WJ� d�U?�

W?�W?�W�U� ÆW?�W�W?�U� w�œd?�b�W??�W†Ë…œ W� ÂWJ?� w�W�ËU� ÂW?�…œ “W??� W�W�U� ÂWz Í…ËW?�œd?�

Í…—U� W?� UÄË—ËWz w�U???�W???�???�—ï???O?� Ë…Ë…—…ó|u� Í«˙Ëd???O?� ÊU???O???�W???�W� …ËW�d???Ö w�W?�ô v�

Ë…ËW�W?� ÊU???O????�W????O???}????� ËW�W????�UM?}Ä Í…—U� W?� ÊU???O????�…ËËœ UÄË—ËW?z W� …ËW?�W� Ë w�…ËW?�W�

øs�WJ� w?Çï� …ËW�W� w�Ëu� Ë…ËW�W� ÍW??�UM}Ä 5�«e� v�W?z W�«Ë r}Ä W?O�œ—u??� w�W�«ËW�W�

ÊU/U???�W???�U??� Ë…Ë«d???� ÊË…“ v� ÊU?/U??�W???�U???� s�W???�…œ …ËW� X�W?� W??� s?�WJ�…œ …ËWz—W?�W�

„W�W� Ë Â…œ—W� w�œd?�—U� Í“«u}� s}†…œ w}Ä U?��}z W� Í…“«u}?� ËWz w�U� ¨…ËWM�dÖ—…Ë

ï� W�«Ë r?}Ä ¨˜˘d??� w�U??� wM�??�«—UÄ Ë s�d??Ö—W??��«—W� Íe??}� Ë Êœd??�ï??Öu??�??H??Ö Ë 7A�W??Ö

w�W???�u??$Wz ÍU???�??�???}z W�Ëu/ s?�d??�???�U� ¨W??�???�W??� p|b?�W� W??L???}z w�üË „…Ë w?J}�üË

ÂüW� ¨«b?O??�—u?� ©≤∏∞® Íï?� W� W�W� w�—u??� ©∑∏® œ—u?� W?� ¨W?O?O??�«d?}?� w�U?L?�??A?O�

ÈËW??�U� X�…œ ÊU??LJ}??�?� êO?� W?L??}z X}� W??�W�«b~?�…œ Ë w�«d?�u?1œ ÍW�W?�W??�W� —W??ÖWz

W� …—ËËœ w�«d?�u?1œ ÍW�W?�W?� W� …—ËËœ ‘WM�ËWJ?|— ËWz ¨WM�ËWJJ|—Ë o�«ËW?� Í…u?}?�W�

ï� Æs�˛…œ «b�U?O� W?� s�W?J� ÊU?�ï?� ÍW?�W�˘œË—U?� Íd�b?�W� v�…œ W?L?}z Íœ«“Uz ÍW�W?�W?�

Ë…ËW�W� Ë w�W?�«ËW�W� W� „W�—W� ÍW??�UM}Ä v�…œ …ËW?��U?�W?� ÍW?�W??�U� u?}� WMO??â� Í…ËWz

Í—«u� W?� s�WJ?� W�…Ë…—«“ v?� ÂWz ÍW???�U?M}?Ä ÊU???L????O�«u� W????L????}z —W???ÖW?z s�W?J� w�…ËW?�W�

ËWz W?J�uÇ ¨ÂU???$Wz —˘“ WM�W?~� 5�«u?�Wz W� W�«Ë r?}Ä …ËW??O?�—ï??O?� Í—«u� W� Ë ÊW???�U??O???�

«b�U????�ïJ�«“ W� Ë ¨—W?�ËW???�W� ÙU????� ©¥µ® wA???}Ä œd????� X�U� X?�U�W???� W???� ÍW?�ôW???�W???�

w�W�ïJ�«“ W?� …Ë«œ Í…—…“U?�W?� w��…˙W?� ©ÙUM�d� X��d?O?z® ±∏∏≤ w†U?� W� …ËW�…Ë«d�Ë

Ë Í—ï????O?� wJ}?????�†U????� W?�…Ë«d????�W� …b?�WÇ—W?� w�…ËW�W?� Í—UJ?�Wz ÍW?�W????�W????� w�?�…˙W????�

68

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

”dz ÍW??�UM}Ä ¨ÙW?ÖW� s?� ¨…Ëu�«œ…ËW�W� w�Ëu� ÙW??ÖW� ÂüW� ÈdM|u??�� W?� …ËW?O??O?�W?�?�W?�

w†W??�ï?�® Ær?O� …ËËœd?�«b??}� w�…ËW�W?� ÍW?�UM?}Ä s�d??�?�U� w?}†…œ X�U�W??� W?� ï??O??Ñö~Oz

U?�U� …ËW�W� w�Ëu� wL?�W?� ÍW�UM}?Ä ËWz øWO?OÇ ÊU�W?�W†U�W?� Íb?Oz ©ÙU�W�ËU� w?�UO?�

Æ…ËËb�U*W� ÍW�WO��«— ËËó}� ©…ËW�W� w�Ëu� wL�W�® W�W�UM}Ä ËWz

w�U?O� w†W?�ï� 5�«u�Wz W?L}z W�«Ë …ËWz u?�…Ë W�Wz ©ÙU�W?�ËU� w�UO?� wJ}†W?�ï�®

p}?Ä …ËW�W� W????�W?z ¨X}� „W????O????�—u� ¨X?}� p}?�…—W???� ¨X?}� p|œ—u????� 5?� ÙU�W????� ËU�

wJ}�U?�“ W� …Ëu�U?NJ}Ä w�…—W?� w�—W?� —«uÇ W� …ËW?�W� ©W�√® ÍU?�U�W� …ËW?�W� ÆvM}�U�

wJ?|b???O?�U???�W?� Ë »«œUz ÙW????ÖW� Ë ‘W�ËU?� w�W�ËËó????}????� ¨‘W�ËU� w?J}????�U???� ¨‘W?�ËU�

ÂW� W?� ¨s}†…œ ÊU�W?O�?�—U� W?� W�W�W�«˙Ëd?O� ËWz ÍW�«ËW?â}Ä W?�Wz wÇ—WÖWz ©«b?�W�ËU�

…ËW�W� œ—u??� W�U?�u�u??Ö …Ëu�W� g�—U??�—˘“ ÆX|d�U?�«œ …ËW�W�W� ÊW†Ë…œ w?�Ëu� v�W� W??O??}Ä

U?�U?� X�Ë—œ …ËW�W� ÊW†Ë…œ W?� ÊËW??�—…œ «b?A??O?�U?$Wz W?� ÆW?O?O� w?�W†Ë…œ WJ�uÇ W?O??O�

—W� ¨W�U??�“ …ËW?�W� w�U??�W??O??O??�…—W??� W?�W?†ï??� ÂüW� ¨U??�…œ X�Ë—œ ÊW†Ë…œ …ËW�W� u?J†W�

ÆX}Ç…œ—…œ X�…œ W� w�…ËW�W� «œ X�…œW� w�U�“ gO�W�…ËW�W�

Í…ËWz WL}z ÆU$uÖW� «b?FO�«Ë ÙWÖW� Ëu�UM�U�«œ ÊU�WO��—U� W?���—ïO� W� Í…—ïO� ËWz

Íï?� w�U?� …ËW?OO�Ëu?�U� ÍËË˙W� W?� W�W�W†U?� ËWz wM?��«—UÄ w?�U$Wz W� W?�W� U�?�?}z W?�

¨«d???�…œU???O?Ä w�U???L???}?K� ÍWÇËU?� W� U???N?�W� g�ËW?z wL???�…— w�U????�“W� Ëu� Íœ—u???� w?�U???�“

Ë ÍdO?Ö—U�…œ Ë ÊW?OMOÑï?� W� v�—ËËœ v�Wz X|u� Í…ËW�W� p}?�W� —W?ÖWz s� w�ËuÇï�W�

W� W?���u}Ä …ËW?L}z ÊW�?��W� ‘W�UM�U�W� Ê…—U�W?� d� w�W�…ËW�W� —W�?�«—W� e�u� Ë 5�

Ë Íd???O????Ö—U???�…œ ÍËË˙W� „W?� W???L????}z Íô vA????�W�…œ wÇ 5?�«e� s�W????�Wz W???�U?M�U� w?�U�

w�W�W?�U?M�U� W�W�«ËW� œ—u?� ÍüUz W??L?}z Íô …ËW?�|d?ÖWz X?� —˘“ W?�UM�U� ¨…ËW?�?O?MO?Ñï?�

W� ¨W?O�…ËW�W� w�W�W�UM�U� w?�«“—U� „…Ë Íœ—u� Í…—ËW?Ö w�WO?O�W�U�W?� ¨X}� w�…ËW�W�

W???�UM�U�W?� g�ËWz w�U???� ÍœW???L??�Wz w?M�“u??�W???� „…Ë Í…—ËW???Ö w�…œWz wJ?|—U??�U???� W�«œ

ÊU�…Ëu�d~�W� …ËW�W� W� ÊËu� «b�Wz W� Íï� w�…ËW�W� ÍW�UM?�U� U��}z ÂüW� ÆX|d}�…œ«œ

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

69

Íï??�W�—W??� wJ}�W?†Ë…œ w�…ËU??� Ë ÊU?�…Ëu?�d~�W� …ËW�W?� W� «b�WzW� w�W?�U� …ËW??�?}?MO�…œ

X�ËË X�U�W� Íœ—u� w�eO�U�ïO�U� Í…—U� W� W?OO� XO�…ËW�W� ÍW�UM�U� w�W� Êï� Êï�

…ËW� …u�?�� p}Ä Ë „W� ÍU?O�UL†Wz Ëu?�W� W� W�W� ÊU?LO�U?L†Wz ©w�—UL?��®W� WL?}z W�

w�}�W� ©±∏∂±® w†U� W� W� W�W� ÊU?�UO†U�Oz ©wM�b†U� w†˘œ® W� «œ©±∏∑±®w�U� W�

ÊUL?J}�U�W?� U�U�W?�W�WKKO� ÍËËó?}� W� 5M}?A�� ËUÇ —W?ÖWz ÆX}�œd� X�Ë—œ ÍU?O†U�?Oz

W� W?� p|—UJ�Wz Ë …Ëu�W� ÊU�W�U�U?�MOz ËW�U?O�…œ—W?� Ëu�ËWJA?}Ä Í˙ËU�ËdO� W?� …Ëu�W�

u???�…ËU???� Æ…ËW�˘œd???�Ëx� ÍW�«—UJ?�Wz ËWz ˙W???� W� —ËËœ Ë ˜˘d???� Íœ«“Uz Ë ˜˘d???� w�U???�

w�…ËW�W� wJ}?�W?� …Ëu� œ—u?� Í…—ËW?Ö wJ|b�W?�d?O� W?� ©Íb�W?�?A?�W� Íb?O�U?� U�ôËW?�®

…Ëu� ï?Öu�?H?Ö W� Í«Ëñ� ¨…ËËœd� w�W?�«œ—u� Ë w�W�«ËW�W� Ë…Ëu?� œ—u� w�W?O?O�W�U�W?� …Ëu�

Í…ËWz ï� và}N� v�W� ÊU��œ—u� ©±∏≥∞® w†U� W� Í…ËWz Íï� …Ëu� W� Ëu� g�ËWz —W�

w�W�W�U��U�u� W?� ÍW�«ËW� …Ëu� v�W� Æv�W� ˙W� w�Ëu� ÊU�WOO�U�U� Ë ÊU?�W�—œU� ÙWÖW�

Í…d~�ï?� v?�U?� W?� Íd�W� Íö†Ëb�W�u??� a}?� U�…Ë—W� Æ…ËËb�«—“W?�«œ w?�…ËW�W� Ë ÍdJ�

u?�…Ë W�W� ÊU?L?O�W�U?�W?� v†W?�ï?� W?L?}z Æ…ËËœd?� Íœ—u?� Ëu?�W� w�?}?�W� Í«Ë«œ …Ëu?�?�W�

ôW??� Ëœu??L??�W??� a}??� Ë w�«“—U� w�ôW??��Ëb?�W??� a}??� W??L?}?z ¨s�b�U??��—U??Ö Ë „—U??L??��

UO?�W� W�U�ËuO?�u� …ËW�W� Í—ïO� Í…—U� W� ‘W�«ËW� Ê…—U?�W� ÆW�W� ÊU?LO�«“—U� ÍU?�W�?��

wJ}�UJ†W?� WL?}z W?� œd� w�©b?O�W?� ÙW?ÖW� —ËuÄ ÊW�W?� dO?�Wz Ë w�…Ë w�U�W?�® w�U�

Ë Íœ—W� œW?L?�Wz ¨“W�W� ‰U?�W?� ¨œW?�W?�?� œu?F�W?�®W�Ëu/ ï?� Ê«ËWz g}Ä W�W� ÊU?L?A�d�

ÊU?L?�…ñ?�Ëb�W?� W� ÊËu�W� d?�??�W?� êO� W�U?�WzW??� Ëu�W� ÊU?� ©—W�ËW?� x†Ëb?�W?�U�…Ë—W�

Æ©Íd�)« #U� Ë rOz«b�Ëb�W� x†Ëb�W� Ë“«“W�

ÂWJ�W�� —˘“ œd� Í«Ë ÊW�W�W�U�

d�U� U?��ï�U?� Ë…ËWM�ó|u� ÍWJM� W� w�ï?���…œ w�W?A}Ä ∫∫∫∫wwww$$$$““““————WWWW���� bbbbOOOO????����WWWW((((ËËËËbbbb����WWWW���� ÆÆÆÆœœœœ

ËW� —˘“ x†Ëb?�W??� —ï??�???�œ ÂüW� ÆX|d???Ö…b†W� —˘“ ÍW??�???� Ëu� @�d??Ö w?J}�W�U?� ¨ÂW??�…œ

Ë wMO???�??}� b�WÇ s?� Æœd??� w�U� Ëu�œd??� +U???A??O� X�…œ s� W??� ÍW?�«—U??O??�dÄ Ë wM?O??�??}�

¨Ê©W�U~}� w�U?�“W�® W�U~}� wJ�WÇ w�UM}�—U?�W� ÊU�W�UM}Ä W?� ÂW�W� W�W� rJ|—U?O�dÄ

70

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

—˘“ ÆÆWO?O�U� w�W�…œ—U�œ …ËW�W� W�W� …ËW� Ê˙…ËU� ï� øW?OOÇ W�W� X?�W�W� Ëu� ‘U� vÄ

ï� w�œd?�W?�U?M}Ä W� —W?�u?� qO�W?� ·Ëd?�W?� —ï??�?�œ W�Ëu/ ï� gO�…—W?� w�U?�U?M†W?�ï?� W�

vM?}???�U?� ÍU�U????� …ËW�W� Èu?� Í…œW???� W?� Ë…Ë«d???� X�Ë—œ w?J}????�???� …ËW?�W� ∫v†…œ …ËW?�W�

w�˘— W� ï?� U�…Ë—W� Æ…ËW??��WJ� ÊËË— ï?� ÊU?�…ËW?z W??�U� r}Ä W??�W�ËW??� ‘UÄW� w?�W?�?�U�W�

ËWz ï� …ËWM�WJ?� wÇ W� d?O� œ—u?� u?�…Ë ¨W?�U� vÄ XJ}�W?O�U?z ı W?�UM�U� w�œd?� X�Ë—œ

…ËW�W?� w�U?M}????NJ?}Ä Ë…ËW�W?� …ËW????O�—Ëu�U?z ÍËË—W� U�U?z W�Ëu?/ ï� W�U????�W?� W???� ÍW?�W†U????�

œ—u� Í“«Ë˛—ï� w†˘— øWOO� Í—u�Uz ÍU�WM� W� w���u}Ä p}�W†Ë…œ w�œdJ��Ë—œ U�…Ë—W�

w�Ëu?�“Wz W� WJ�uÇ øW?O?OÇ …Ë…ËU� W� ı Ë ÊüË Í…Ë…—…œ W� ı w�U?L�?A?O� Í“«Ë˛—ï� W�«Ë

«b†U?� Èb�W� W� Æ…uO?MO� w�…—W� Í—Ë…œ w�U?L?�A?O� Í“«Ë˛—ï� ÊW?��U�W� UÄË—ËWz w�U�üË

¨W�W� ÊU?L�…œ W?L?}z uJ†W� ¨X}�W� ÊU?L?�…œ W� W?O?O�«Ë r}Ä s� ÆrO� „ï?� «b�?�U�W� ÙW?ÖW�

¨ÊU�…dFO� W�Ëu/ ï� ÊU/U�W�…œ w�œd�WÑ«— Ë…ËW�œdJO� ï� WOO� ÊU�U�«u�W� Í—W�Ëu� ÂüW�

Í«Ë w�…œ W�«Ë r}Ä W� ÊU/U?�…œd�—W� Í—U�Ë ¨ÊUMO?A}Ä Íb�WÄ ¨Íœ—u� Í—Ëu?��W� ¨»…œWz

b�WÇ U??�??�??}?zU� ÆX|dJ� X?�Ë—œ vÄ w�…ËW�W� Íd??O� ËU?�˛ï�˘b�Uz b�W?Ç Èd??�…œ W??� W�U??O�

…ËW�«œW� s�WLÖ…œ Ë ÂW?� …ËW�«œW� ¨…Ë«d� œ—u� w�U�W�˙ï?� —W�W� w1œU�Wz Í…ËWMO†ïJ}�

¨ÊU�U?~�U1WÄ Ëó}�ï?� Ë w1œU�Wz w�W�ô w�W?��U�W� …ËËœd�d?O� W� ÊUL?O�…ËW�W� w�W�ô WL?}z

W?� ÊËW�…œ—…œ ÊU?�ï� …ËWMO†ïJ� ÊU?�ï� w�U?�W?�˙ï� W� w1œU?�Wz w�W�…u?}� …Ëu�U� —W?ÖWz

w�œd????�W????�«d?�œ ‘UÄ UJ?�—W????�Wz Ë UÄË—ËW?z øs|u????� W� Ë 5?Ç ÊU????�W~�d????Ö W?†U????� ÍW�—˘“

5�Uz W?�«Ë r}Ä U�…Ë—W� Æ…ËW?M�ËuM� ÊU�W??�W�W??Ö w?|u� w�ËËó??}??� ÊU??O�«u� ÊU??O�U??�W??�˙ï??�

W� w?M�œ w�ËW???�W� Í…u???}???� W?�«Ë r}Ä ¨…ËW?�W� w�œdJ?�???�Ë—œ W� wM?O�…œ @�d???Ö wJ?}†˘—

U�Uz øWO?O� ÊU�W�U?M�U� WL}z W?� 5Ç W�U�ï� ËWz ÆW�W� …ËWMO†ïJ}�W� w�?��u}Ä ÊU�?�œ—u�

ÊULO�…ËW�W� w�W�U�W� WL}z U�Uz øWOO� ÊU1—u�Uz ÍWMOâM� WL}z U�Uz øWOO� ÊULM�˛Ëœ WL}z

øWOO�

…Ë…œd?�U??O?� p}� ÍW?Jâ|— ËËœ œd?� Í…ËW�W� w?�U� W?� d�U??� U?�?�ï??�U?� ∫∫∫∫....————WWWW????���� ïïïï????����UUUUzzzz

ÊW†Ë…œ ÍW?�e?O�UM�U?� ÂWz —U?�«Ëœ W�W� Âe?O�UM�U� —U?� ÂW?�W� W�«Ë w?}Ä W?� W�…ËWz g�ËWz

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

71

ÍW???�WJO???ç??O???� W�W�ô d?�U�“ …ËWz ÊU???�…œ X�Ë—œ …ËW�W� g?�©p}???�??�® ÊU???�…œ X�Ë—œ

¨ÊW?�…œ …—ï?O� ÂWz Íd?O~�?A?Ä W?� …ËUM}� Íb�W?�d?O� p}†W?�ï?� ÍËU� w�W?�?�U�W� ¨W�…ËW�W�

¨v�…œ X�Ë—œ d�«Ëœ ÆÊU�…œ X�Ë—œ ÂeO�UM�U� …ËWz W�W?� p}JOM�Oz W�…ËWz Íœ wJ}�W�

Íœ—«b�U????�????� X}?�…œ X|dJ?� Í…ËW�W� ÍW????�UM?}Ä Í…ËW?z ï� W�«Ë r?}Ä r�????A?�W~}?� Í«Ë s�

˜˘d?� Í…œ«d??Oz Ë X�«u?� —W?�W� Í…ËW?z v�W� W�«Ë ¨…ËWMO?�U?M�U?O� Í…ËWz ï� v�W?� w�W�U�

ÊUM}?� ÊËU� Êï??� „…Ë—W� s�W� íO??�??�…ó�ïz Íœ—«b�U??�??� Ë Íb�…u�W?Ä Èb�W� Íb�W??�d??O�

X}�«e� …ËW�W� W� Íï� p}ÄËd?Ö Í…ËWz ï� W�W� w�«“ w�� p|b�W� «b�…ËWz ÙW?ÖW� U�MOz

Ë ÊU�WOO�W�U� …—…u}Ä ı ÊU�…—…u}Ä Æ‘W�ËU� w�� Èb�W�W� ÊœdJ��W� ¨w�«“ w�W�ô W�«Ë

ÂüW� ¨ÊW?� p}M�???Oz u???�…Ë —U??�—˘“ Æ4}?�…œ p}Ä …ËW�W?� …ËW??�W?�W� ÊU??�W???O�«“ …—…u???}Ä ı

wÄËdÖ W� ¨WJ�œ ÍW~†W�ï� W� ÊU�ï� …uO�U�W� ÊU�ï� U�?A}� ¨…ËW�W�U�UO� ÊU�ï� U�A}�

„…Ë—W� ¨W?O??O� ÊU?O�«“ w�W??O�—U?O??�Ë W�«Ë Æ…ËW�˘œd?�W�U??O?� WJ�œ ÍW?�??OMO?�ï??� W� ¨WJ�œ

ÊW?�U� —U?� ÊU�ï?� ï� U?�?A?}� 5� ©U?N?O�«c�® ÂüW� ¨ÊW?� ©UN?�«c� W?�U?�W?�® ∫v†Wz è~O�

ÆËË˙W�}���� w�W�U� p|b�W� …Ë…d}� gO�…Ë w�U�W� W~�…— ÊU�ï� w� W�W�Ëu�W�

Í«Ëœ W� ©Âe??O�U�ï??O?�U�® Ë©sA?�W�U�ï?O??�U�® W� W??�?� W??� Ëu�…ËWz g�ËWz d?� wJ}?�??�

…ËWJ}F?O�«ËW� Íb�…u�WÄ …ËWz W�«Ë r}Ä ¨…ËW�Ëu� —WÖ ÊU?�W�…ËW� ÂeO�UO�ï?� w�ïK� w�U�—

ÊW?�U?�W� «œU????????O?�œ w�U????????�W?ÇËU� ÍW?�—˘“ W?� „W?�…œ«˙U� ÊU????????�W?�…ËW� Í«ËœW?� W????????� Ëu�W?�

ÊU?O�˘d??� w�U?�…—U?� Ëœd?J}Ä w�?�…œ w�U??O?� wM�?O?z ÍW?A?}?� p?}†W?�ï?� …ËW??�UÄË—ËWzW�

Ë w�????�U?z W� W????�…˙W?� …ËWz W�…Ëu????�????A?�W????Ö «b�W?†U????� Èb�W� W?� ÊW�U?�W� Æ…ËW�ï?�ËWJ?}�

ÊU???�W???�???�?�—ï???O� …b�W???�d????O� Íœ wJ?|—U???� …ËËœd???� Í«Ë ‘…ËWz ÆÈdJ?� w�Ë…œ wA?�U???�Uz

Ê…—U?�W?????� ¨…ËWM?†ïJ?� w}?� Ë…ËW�W?J� ”U?� ËW�W?�W?????�W?????� Ë ÊW?�U� ËW?z —W?????� …ËWM?|˙W~?�

w�U??O???� wJ}�U???O??� w�œdJ?�??�Ë—œ ï� Ê«b†ËW?�W� …ËW??�??�W� ÍW???�UM}Ä …ËW?�W� ÍW??�UM?}ÄW�

W� X?}�W�W?~� œ—u???� U???O?�W�W� W????�Wz W~?�…— X}�«Ë —W???ÖW?z ¨ÊW†Ë…œ ÍË«dJ?�—U�œW� g?�ËWz

w�W†Ë…œ W�«ËW�W� ÂW� „W�—W� —W?Ö …—U�œ ¨ÊW� „uâ� Í…ËW�W� W�W?� Ë…ËW�W� b�WÇ «œUO�œ

«b???O???�???�«— W?� U�Uz ¨Èd???�U?� .e�W� w?�Ë…œ Íb�…u�WÄ w?�???�«—W� Æ„W�«—W?� ıW� v�…œ v?�W�

72

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

W� Íï?� ÊW†Ë…œ U�Uz øv�W� w�W†Ë…œ W�W� Í…ËWz w�W?� „W�…ËW�W� W�W?� Ë…ËW�W� Ëu?�W�

ÆX� Èb�W� w�UM?}?N�?�…œW� Ë—u?�?�W� w?M�?�«—UÄ ï� W?�W�WKO?�…Ë Íï?� ÊU� W?$U?�Uz «b�ï?�

…Ëu� W?�«Ë ©XA?M�U????�U� ÍU?�® W� Ëu?� —W????ÖWz ‚«d????}????� W?�Ëu/ ï?� «bJ}?�üË W� Èd????�…œ U?�Uz

ÆX|—e|—U?á� œ—u?� u?�…Ë ï� ÍW?�U?M}Ä «œ«Ë wJ}�W†Ë…œ W� Èd�«u�…œ …ËW?�W� ËËœ wJ}�W†Ë…œ

Ë ÊËu� w�«d?}?� w�UM}Ä ¨Èd~�†W� ”UM}Ä ËËœ «b?�U� „W� W� s�W?� p}Ñ˘d?� Èd?�…œ U�Uz

Íœu�Ë U?O�W� W�W�…ËW�W� Í…ËWz—W�W� œ—u� Í…ËW�W� ÊW?���W� ÆÊËu� w�U��œ—u?� ÍW�UM}Ä

—W???�…—UÇ ÊW†Ë…œ v�W?� s� Í«Ëñ�W� W?�«œWJ�œ w�üË s?�b�WÇ W� u?J†W� W???O??O?� ‚«d??}???� W�

ÆÈd�U�

«b?O�U?�W�ËuÇï� ÍW�—˘“ W� W?� ÂW?�…œ d�U� U?�?�ï?�U?� W� w�ï�?�?�…œ ∫∫∫∫rrrrOOOO????����WWWW���� œœœœ««««————uuuu????���� ÆÆÆÆÂÂÂÂ

œuF�W� u�…Ë wJ}�U�W� d�U?� „U� W� Í…ËWz ÆX}�W� rJ|—UO�dÄ b�WÇ W~�…— «bO†WÖW�

W�U??�Wz W?�??�«— ÆÆ«b?O?†W?ÖW� s� X?}�«“U� w�…ËW�W� w?�?�—ï??O�W� “W�W� ‰U??�W?� ËœW??�W?�??�

Ë—ï?O� WJ�uÇ 5� X�—ï?O� W�U?�Wz ÂüW� Âe?O�U�ï?O�U?� Ë…ËW�W� Í…—U� W� W�W� ÊU�˙…ËU�Ëd?O�

Ê…—U�W?� ÆX}�U� W�?�W�—W� «b�«ËW� W�U?�—W� ÂW?z Ë ¨W�W� Íï� wJ}?�—W� b�WÇ X�—ï?O�

…ËW�W� W??O??O�U??� wJ}??�??� U~†W??�ï??� WJ�uÇ W?�«Ë r}Ä W??O??O�U??� wJ}??�??� …ËW�W� W??� Í…ËW�

ËW� U?�?�??}z u?�U� W?L?}z Æs�…œ X?�Ë—œ sJ}?�?� uJ†W� 5� «b??�U?�Wz W� ËW?O?O�U?� w?J}?�?�

ÊUO�—W?� w†W�ï� …ËW�W� ËU~†W�ï?� WJ�uÇ W�W� ÊU�U~†W�ï� WL?}z U�Uz s�˛…œ «œW�UJAOz

U�…—W??� W?� ÍW�«ËW?z ÆÊd?L??�…œ Èœ p|˛˘— s�…œ X�Ë—œ ï� 5� «b??�U??�Wz W� W�U??�Wz W�W�

©wK?�œU????��œ® Ë w�U????L†W?z Í©—…œd????}�® W�Ëu?/ ï� ÊW????Ö…œ W�U????�????� ËWz Ë Âe????O�U?M�U� w?�U�

w�U� ÊU??�W?O??O�U??N?O??� W?�??��—ï?O?� ÊU?�U??�?�W� W?� …ËËœd?� Í«Ë wÇ U�U?z ÂüW� W?O??O?��…˙W??�

œd????� Í«Ë w?Ç Æs�U????�“ Íe?????OK~?MO?z ÍËu????�W� ¨…ËW?�W????�…œ ÍËËbM?�“ Ë ÊW????�…œ Âe????O?�UM?�U�

p}??�d� êO� «b?J}�U??�W� Ê…b� Âe??O�UM�U�W?� ŒW�U� …bM}?� «bJ}??�…œ—W?�W?� ÊU?�W??O??O�U??��—W�

ÊU?�W?OO�U?L†Wz W�W� W?�W�ËW?� W� ÊU?O?�d� ÊU�W?O?O?��…˙W� øW?O?O� «b�«ËWz ÍW?�UM�U� —W?�W�

—U?�—˘“ øÊ…b� W?�W� ŒW�U� ÊU?�W�U?�“ ÍeOK?~MOz W?� U�…œ «Ë wÇ W?�W� W�W�ËW?� W� ÊU?O?�d�

w�œdJ?�—U�œ W� ÂüW� X?}� ‘«Ë W~�…— Ë …ËW???�??O�d?|œï??�W� …ËWM?O??�??�W?�…œ Âe??O�U?M�U� W??L???}z

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

73

W� U?�?A}?� WL?}z «bJ}�U?�W� X|d?�…œ w��…˙W?� w�˙ï?� W� ”U� «b?�e?O�UM�U� w�«b†W�—W?�

…Ë…©X�˙Uz U�U�® Ë©“bM}Ö® W� d�Oz ÊW�…œ W�O�d|œï� W� ”U� W� ÍW�«ËWz «bO�UNO� w��Uz

…ËW�W??�W� W??�?}�d|œï??� w�…œ—W??� W?� ÊËu?�ËW?�W� p?|— …ËWz —W?�W?� U?�??A?}?� d�«Ëœ ÍW�«ËWz

wMO�}� 5�«Ëœ øWOO��…—W� w�˙ï� Í«Ëœ U� WOO��…—W� w�—ï� g}Ä U�Uz ¨U�…b}Ä X�…œ

¨…ËËœd????� w�U� ©w?�…Ë w�U�W????�® +«e�«Ë W????� v� …ËW?z W~�…— ¨ÂW?J� w�U?� ÈËW???�…œ W????�

s�WJ� Íd?Ö«b?}Ä WL?}z —W?ÖWz U�Uz ÆÍœ—u?� w�e?O�U�ï?O�U� „W� w�U?�?�œ—u?� w�eO�U?�ïO?�U�

Íï� ï� Âe?O�U�ïO�U� øU~†W?�ï� u�…Ë U�U� ÊU?�WA}� Í—UÇËœ Íœ—u?� w�eO�U�ïO?�U� —W�W�

„W�—W�W� U?~†W?�ï??� WJ|e?}� «b??A?O�U??� ÊU?�W?� W� ¨vM� œU?O?M� U~†W?�ï??� v�«u�…œ WJ|e??}�

W?� U??????O?�W?� Êœd??????� ”U?� U?�Uz W?�W?� „W�…ËW?�W?� W� œU?�“ W???????� w�üË W?� ¨X?}M?}???????�…Ë…b†W?�

øW�U~†W�ï� ÂWz w�U�…u†W� ï� WOO� „WOO�d�W� Íœ—u� w�eO�U�ïO�U�

ÊU� w�W�«ËW�W� w�?�W� Í…—U�—…œ ¨«d� ÍW?�U� ËWz …Ëï�W� ÊËË— Âï� ∫∫∫∫eeee����““““WWWW????���� bbbbOOOO????����WWWW���� ÆÆÆÆÂÂÂÂ

s� Æ…Ëu�W� ÊU?�?�œ—u?� W� W�«ËW� p}?�—W� ÆËu?� ÊWO?�ËW?� œu?�U� w�W?�«ËW�W� Í…ËWM�Ëe�

…ËW�œu?� …ËuÇ W� —U� ÂW�W� ¨…œ—u?� ©w�u�Wz s�œW�ôW�® W?� Í…ËW� ÂËu�W� ‘ï�†œ êO�

vHDB?� W?M¹œ ÍœdJ�UÐ e?ž«Ë VOK� W�Ëœ t?�–« Íc�« tK�« b?L?(«® ∫v†…œ œd??� Íd?O??Ö«œ Ë

Æ…ËËœd� …ËW�ï?� w�WO?�ËW�W� Í“«e?O�?FOz …œ—u� W?� Èd�U� …ËW� w†ïJ� êO?� W�Wz ©wÐdF�«

d|˛ œ—u??� W?� …ËW�…ËUJ� «œ…ËWz ÍôW?� …Ëu� „W�…œ«˙W� …Ë…—…œ ÍW?�˘œË—U?� ËWz «b?O?�??�«—W�

…ËW� ÂWM�…— Èb�W� …ËW?A�d� w�W�ôW� ¨…ËW?�W�ôW� W�Wz v�W� w�W†Ë…œ œ—u?� Ë v� W�?�…œ

W??� œd??�W� Êœ—u??� w?�W??O??�U??O??� w�U� ÍËuÇ «b�U??�…e???OK~MO?z ÍôW� d�U�“ X�U?�W??� Ëu�W�

UO�U?L†Wz W� W�W� ÂW?�W� ©—…œd}�® W� rO� «b?�†WÖW� s� Æ…ËW�W�W� —W��«—W� W?OOÇ w�ËuÇï�

b�WÇ® ÍW?�W?�?}�?� w�U?A?O�ËU� W?� W?�W� ÂW?�W� ©W?�?�?O?�® uJ†W� ¨…ËËœd?� Í…ËW�W� w�U�

w�…ËW�W� Í…ËWM�ËËe� W?� ÈdJ� ‘…ËWz w�U� W�«u�…œ …©UO�U?L†Wz Í…ËW�W� ï� p|“«ËW~�U�

W????� s�œW� Ê…—U?�W???� U?�…Ë—W� ÆÆ…Ëu�d?�e???}?�W� d� w?�W�…ËWM?�Ëe� Ëu????�W� W� U????O�U????L†W?z W�

¨Ëu� @?�…— ËËœ W??�…—Ë…œ ÂüW?� ¨w�W�«ËW�W?� w�œdJ?�??�Ë—œ W?� …Ëu�W� w�U???�Wz w?J|—Ë…œ

wJ|—W�W?� Ë«b�UNO?� W� ÊWKKO� s�d�…—ËW?ÖW� œd� w�…—W?� w�W�WKO�W� b�WÇ …ËW?J|—W�W�

74

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

—W� v�W� ÊW?O�ËW?� W� ÊU�«Ëñ� ¨©r�UH?�« WK�« bM� rJ�d�« Ê«® ∫v†…œ œ—u?� ÊU�Wz ËË˙W?�

w�W?�…ËWM�Ëe� Ëu?� X�Ë—œ W???� w�W?�üW??�ï???� w?�W�…œ—U�œ u???�…Ë Âö???�???Oz Æ4?}JA� p?}�

w�U�ï?� ï� …u�˙ï?Ö …ËW?�…œu?�?� w�U�ï?� W� ÍU~†W?�ï?� …Ëu� „W�W?�…—W?� ¨…Ëu?�W� w�…ËW�W�

—ËËœ «b�…˙WM� W� w��…—W� w�˙ï� ÆWOO� w�ËW� w�W�…œ—U�œ ‘W�U�ï� ËWz Æ©XO�UD�«®

—U??� W� ÊW??O�“«Ë˛—ï� ¨Í˛Wz ÈœôW?� ÊW?O??�UD?�Wz ¨œdJ�??�Ë—œ w�ËW??� ÍW??�…—W??� s�œ W�

ÍW???�…—W??� Èœô w?�W�üW???�ï??� Ë w�U???O???� Ë Í—Ëu�Uz w?�˘œË—U� W� W???O???O� 5J�u???� Ͳ…œ

ËW� WJ}�W� w��…˙W?� w�—ï� Æv�…œ X�Ë—œ «œ—U� W� U?O�W� ¨ÈdJ� X�Ë—œ ï� X�…ËW�W�

WOO��d� ©@MOKO� ¨W��O?� ¨è~O� ¨X�U�® ÍW�W��W� ¨v†…œ ”W� —˘“ ÊW�U�W� ¨W�üU�

Æw�UL†Wz w�U�“W� ÂüW� w��…—W� w�˙ï� w�U�U�WM� W� Êœd�dO��W� W�

ÊW�«Ë˛—ï� wM?OÇ ÆœdJ}Ä w�??�…œ …ËU?��«—W??� w�˙ï?� W� w�…ËW?�W� Í…dJO?� w�U??�Wz

ÆÆÊWO�UD�Wz w�«b}� ï� ÆX�Ë—œ

…ËW??�W??�…œ vÄ X�…œ …Ëx†Ëb?�W??� —ï??�??�œ W� ¨ÊU??�W??O??O??�?}?� ï� ”UÄu??� —˘“ ∫∫∫∫dddd����UUUU????????���� ÆÆÆÆÂÂÂÂ

5� b�W�UÄ v�…œ W?L?}z ÆX}�W?� …ËW�W� ÍW?�UM}ÄW� Ê…—U�W?� U?O�W� Ëu�W� ÊU?�U?O?� w�ËuÇï�

ÍW?�W??�UM}Ä ÆÊW?�U?O??� Ë Í˛ï�ï?O?�ï??� w�…œWz Ë Í˛ï�ï?O??�ï?� ÍW?â|d??�?}KOz ÍW?�U?M}ÄW�

∫v†…œ ¨W?O�ËüU�W?� wJ?}?�?� W?� W?O?O� …ËWz w�?�W�W?� W†U�W?� ËU?� ∫v†…œ W?� ©s�—b�Wz®

Íï??� W??� ÂWJ� ©Í—W??�u??� #U??�® W� …˛U??�U?z X��u??�W� s� ¨©w?�U??O??� fO�Ë qO??�??�??�®

©Íb�W??�??A??�W� Íb??O?�U??� U�ôËW??�® ÊW??�??�??O�W� ÆU??�…œ w�U??L?†Wz ÍW�U??��U�u??� w?KO??�??�W�

U� +«e� …ËW?L?â� U�U?OÄ Â…œ…œ ÙËW� ÂW?�…œ X�UÄu?� —˘“ r}?à� ê?O� +«u�U� …ËW�˘bM|u?�?�W�

…ËW�…ËËbM|u?� …ËW?O�e?OK~MOz w�U?�“ ÍW~|— W� ©“W�W� ‰U?�W?�® Ë…Ëu�Ë w�e?O�UM�U� b�WÇ

ÆÂWJ� W?Ñ«— ÊU?�W?�� r?}� w�«Ëœ w1œU?�Wz w�W�…u?}?�W� ÂWJ� Âe?O�UM�U� w�U� ÈËW?�…œ s�

¨ÊW??�…œ Âe??O�UM?�U� Ë…ËW�W� ÍW�W??�W??� Íd?�W??� ÊïÇ »«e??�Wz +«e� …Ëu??�??��u??�W?� U�…Ë—W�

w�—W� W?� W?OO� ÊU�W?�Ëd?O� Ë—UJ�Wz ÊU?�?�œ—u� W� w�U?O?� wJ}�e?O?� êO� s� w�ËuÇï�W�

Ê…—U�W??� ‘U�˛ï�˘b�Uz u??�…Ë ÊW�U�W� ¨W??O?O� ÊU�—ï??O� ¨…ËËœd?�W?� ÊU�d�e�W� ¨ÊUJ� —ï??O�

ÂU?�?�ï�U?� ©qO�W?� ÊW?�W?�® Âï� w†U?�W� ‘W� ¨b?O?�W?(Ëb�W� U?�?�ï?�U?� w�U�W?O?OM�?}�W�

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

75

W?� Í…ËWz ÆÂe?O�UM�U?� ÍW�W?�W?� Í…—U� W� +«“U� wK�W?�u?�W� W� Ë X�?�—ï?O�W� ÂüW� ¨…Ëu�

…ËW�W?� W??� Í…ËW?z ÍW�W???�W??� Æ…Ëu?�d??Ö Í—…Ë W???O???O� Íï???� w�ËuÇï?� vM}???�U� …ËW�W?� v†…œ

ÍW?�UM?�U� ©g�…e?O†U�ï??à?Ö® ∫v†…œ W�W� p?}�ËuÇï� W?�W�ËW??� ÍW�W?�W??� ¨…Ë«d?� X�Ë—œ

ÆÆÆU� v†…œ W�W� Æ…ËW�}M|ËU��…œ ËU�…œ u�W� w�…ËW�W�

¨5Ç…œ Íï� ÊüW�˛˘— W� W?L?}z W?� W?O?O�«Ë …Ë«d?� W?�W�ËW?� ï?� W�W?�…“ ËWz s� Í«Ëñ�W�

…ËW�W?� W??� W???O??O� X?�«— ‘…ËWz ¨ËW�U???O�œ w�œd???� wJ�d???�Wz W� W???�W�ËW???� s� w�ËuÇï?�W�

W?L?}z ÆÊU?�…œ ï� ÍU?�b?Oz UJ�d?�Wz W?� ÍW�«—ËW?Ö …—W� W�üË W� WJ?}?�W� UÄË—ËWz ÆvM}?�U�

W�UM�U� w�œdJ��Ë—œ w†˘—W� Ê…—U�W� ¨ÍW�WJKÄ W� W~?� ÊUÖ…œ vÄ W�W�ËW� W� ÊULOÇ

…ËW�U�«ËU� ÍWÖbM|u� W� v�…œ ¨W�bM|u� w�W��O� s�d�~�dÖ g�—Ëu�Uz Í—U� W� W�«Ë r}Ä

Ùu?� w�W?�«ËW�W� w�?�W� «œU~?†W?�ï?� W� ”W?�W??�U� Í…ËWz ï� Í˙ï~� ÊbM?|u?� w�W?�?�??O?�

ÃU� W� Í…ËWz ï� Ëu�W� ¨WOO� ÊUL?O�…ËW�W� Í“«Ë˛—ï� WL}z ¨Í—Ëu�Uz Í—U� U�ËWz …ËW�|dJ�

Ê…—U�W???� Æœd???� ÊU???O???�???�Ë—œ …œ«“«Ë˛—u?� UÄË—ËWz Æ…ËW?�U???�…œ p}�ËW???Öe???� X}?� Í—U�—u???�

Ë ÊËË˙W� —˘“ w?�??�«—W� w?�ï??� Í—œU???� w�U??� Ë w?�U??� ÍœW???L??�Wz w?M�“u??�W???� gO???�…œW�

g�d� w�� —WÖWz …Ëu��œ ÂW�U�Wz ‚…œ u�…Ë ÊW?�…œ ÂeO�UM�U� ÍW�W�W�W� …˛U�Uz w�«dJ�Uz

Âe??O�U?M�U� ÍW�W??�W??� W?� w†˘— UÄË—ËWz W?� 5�Uz ÆÂW??�…œ ÊU??�??�U?Äu??� —˘“ s}†…œ r}?Ä W�W�

ÆX}� í?O�…“ïÄ Í…ËWz w�U�W?� X}� íO�W~?}� ÍW?�W?†˘— W�W�«ËW� W??L?}?z Íô ÂüW� Æ…Ëu�W�

v�UO?� s� ÙWÖW� X�ËuÇï� ï� W?O�U�Uz g�—˘“ rO� «b?O�…Ë w�U�W� wJ}�ËuÇï?� ÙWÖW� s�

X}�W� ÊU/ËuÇï� Ë«— „W� W� W?OO� ×W� s�U?O� WL}z W?� ÊU�…œ d�ËW�Ä W?L}z w�W�U� …ËWz

pOM�?Oz Ë pOçO?� ÍW�W�W?� ¨ï�Uz „U?� w�U�W?OOMO�?}�W� Ê…—U�W� Æ„W�…œ—U?�œ —W�W�

Ë…—W� w�U??á?�WzW� —˘“ ÂüW� ¨WJO?M�?Oz Íœ—u?� w?�e?O�UM�U� r?}†…œ s� ÂU?�†W?ÖW?� s� v†W�

Ê…—U�W?� Æ…ËUá?�WÇ W?L}z Íô w�…œW?� ÍU~†W?�ï� W?� r}?à� +«u�U� s� Æs�˘˙…œ pO?çO?�

w�W??O�U�u??� „…Ë s?� W�W� ÊU??�U~†W??�ï??� W??L??}z U�Uz ¨œ«—u??� U??�??�ï??�U??� w�U??�…—U??O??�dÄW�

ÆW�U�W� r}†…œ s� ¨W�W� ÊU�U~†W�ï� W� Í…—UO�dÄ ËWz W�W�Ëu�A�WÖW� Ͳï�ïO�ï�

W� pO?��«dÄ „…Ë ı Ë—ï?O� „…Ë ı W�W?O�ËW?� W�…—W?� …ËWM� ÍôW� ∫∫∫∫eeee����““““WWWW????���� bbbbOOOO????����WWWW���� ÆÆÆÆÂÂÂÂ

76

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

Í—Ë…œ U?O�U?L†Wz W?�W� wÇ W?O?O� e?}�W� U?O?�U?��—W� W� ¨…e?}�W� U?O�U?L?†Wz ËUÄË—ËWz Í«ËUz˛˘—

¨W??��U??� W?O??}??� ·u??�WK�W??� ¨…—WK�??O� W??O??}?� Í“U� W??�??�—U??� W?O??}??� w�u??O??� X}�Ëu� U??O�

s�—U?�® œd?� X�—œ «bM�œ W� w?�ËW?� ÍW?�…—W� Ëu?� v� ¨W?�U?�d�U� W?O?}?� X��˛ï�ï?O?�ï?�

w�ËW?� ÍW�…—W?� 5�«e� U� Æb?�� ÆÆÆ Ë w�U?L†WzW� œd?� …ËWO?OMO�ôW� wKO?�MOz W?� …©—W�ï�

ÆW�…Ë«d� ÍW�W�WKKO� ÆÆ«b�UNO� W� …—W�dOÖ«œ ÂW�W� …ËW�«ËWâ}ÄW� ÆW�W�U� eOK~MOz

w�«Ë…“W?� ‘UÄ W� w�W?��U�W� ÊU?�W?O�ËW?� W�W†Ë…œ w�?�d?Ö ∫∫∫∫wwww$$$$““““————WWWW���� bbbb????OOOO????����WWWW((((ËËËËbbbb����WWWW????���� ÆÆÆÆÂÂÂÂ

u?}� W� WJ�uÇ ¨Ëu� X�Ë—œ ï� ÊU?O�Ëu� w�üËU� ÍW?A}?� ¨œdJ}Ä w�?�…œ W?� Í—UL?F?��?Oz

W?� Ëu�…œ ÊU�…ËWz ÍW?A?}??� œd?�…œ d?O?Ö«œ ÊU�d� wJ}�üË W?� Ëu�W� ÊU?�W?A?}?� ÊU�ï?� w�üË

…ËW�Ëu� w?�üËU�W� Íb�…u??}Ä W??�W??�??�W�W??� d�U?�“ ÆU� ÊU� È—œ…œ vÄ w�Ëu?� w�üËU� w�U??�

ÂWz ÊW?†Ë…œ v�…œ W?????� …ËW????�UM?�U� ËU?� W�U� d?�U�“ Ëu?� X�Ë—œ W????�W?????�????�d????Ö …u?|ËW� W?�W�

ÆÊUJ� vÄ w�«d�FOz W� ËW� Ê«b� W�W�UM�U�

¨U??O�U?L†W?z® W�W� sA�W� v?� UÄË—ËWz W� ¨ÂWJ� ÙU??� „W�W� …˛U??�Uz +«u�…œ ∫∫∫∫dddd����UUUU????���� ÆÆÆÆÂÂÂÂ

W?O?O� U��…—W?� u?�…Ë WM|u?� w�U?�Wz —W?�W� UO?�UL†Wz W?� ÂeO�UM?�U� Æ©UO�U?��—W� ËU?��…˙W?�

w�U??L†Wz X?�ËU� Ë p�«œ —W??ÖWz XO� w�U??L†W?z ï� Æv� „U??� Ë Í—ï??��d� w�U??�Wz —W??�W�

W?� W?�W?� s�d?�?�U� ©Ê«b|“ s?�œWM�…“® XO� Íd?Oz«“W?� W�W�«ËW� W?O?O?�«Ë U?��…—W?� W� Æs�W�

W?O?}� W� w�U?L†Wz w�?�?O�UM�U� Í…ËWM�ËËe?� ÆWO?O� gO?��…—W?� ËU?�…œ U��…—W?� wKO?�?�W�

ÆÆW�W�W��O�UO�ï� W�W�ô Ë 5�U�� w��…œ d|˛W� «b�W�…Ëu�ËW�«Ëœ

ÍW�WO�UJAOz ËWz ¨œ«—u� U��ï�U� w�U�W�� —W� …ËWMO|˙W~� W�U� r}Ä ∫∫∫∫VVVVOOOO����WWWW���� ««««““““UUUUzzzz

Æ…ËW�W� wJ�WÇ W� U~†W�ï� wJ�WÇ Í…ËW�œd�UO� ¨Ëu�W� gOM� ÍôW� œd� w�U� ËWz W�

Ë Íb�W9W?��U� w†W?�ï?� U~†W�ï?� ¨X}� U~?†W�ï?� W?O?O� ×W� W�W� …ËW?�W� s� w�ËuÇï� W�

ÍË«—“W�«œ v�…œ W?� Í…ËW� ¨U~†W�ï?� WM�…œ Ë…ËWM�…œï?� «b�U$Wz W?� W� W�W� Íï� ÍU?�WM�

wL�…— ÍË«—“W�«œ «bAO†WÖW� Ë b�� Ë ÆÆÊ«e}� ¨s�œ ÍË«—“W�«œ W�«Ë X}�W� w�W�üW�ï�

w�üËU� «b?�U??$Wz W� Ë X}�W� Í—«b??Oz ÍU?Ö“…œu?�«œ X}�W?� w�U?O?� ÍU?Ö“…œu??�«œ X}�W�

«œ…ËW�W� W� W�U?�� ÂWz W?OO� ×W?� ÂüW� 4}�…œ p}Ä U~†W�ï?� W�U�Wz Ëu?�W� X}�W� ÊËu�

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

77

ÊU??�???�œ—u??� ÍU?~†W??�ï???� W�Ëu/ ï?� X}� „W�…ËW?�W� b�WÇ „W?�U~†W???�ï??� v�…œ ÆÆX?}�W�

…ËW�…Ëu�ï� …ËWJ}?Ä W�U�Wz Ëu�W� W?� ÂüW� ¨W�UO�U?O� wM�œ Ë W?O�—u�Uz ¨ÊUL?�—u� ¨…œ—u�

ÍËU� Ëu� X?�Ë—œ „W�U~†W???�ï??� «b???O??�U???O??� Ë w�W?�üW??�ï??� ÍË«—“W???�«œ Í…u??}?Ç—«uÇ W�

ÆÆW�U��œ—u� ÍU~†W�ï�

s�˛…œ ÊU��œ—u?� W� W� ÍWJ†W� ËWz ÊU��œ—u� ÍU?~†W�ï� r}�UM}� ÍËU� s� ∫∫∫∫dddd����UUUU���� ÆÆÆÆÂÂÂÂ

ËWz U??O�W� Íœ—u??� ÍU~†W??�ï??� r}?à?� —W?ÖWz ÆÆÊU??L??�—u� Ë »…—W??� Ëœ—u?� W� ÊËu?�U� p}Ä

ÆÆͲ…œ ÊU��œ—u�W� W� W�…œ—u�

5}?M�ËU� œ—u???� U�Uz ¨…ËW?M�WJ� ÍU???O???� v�…œ W�W???O�U?JA???Oz ÊU�W???�Wz ∫∫∫∫VVVVOOOO????????????����WWWW????????????���� œœœœ««««““““UUUUzzzz

v�…œ …ËWz W�U~?†W?�ï?� œ—u?� —W?ÖWz ÆÆW??�?O�W� WM�W~?� v�Wz «œW?�W� ¨…ËW�W� ÊU� U?~†W?�ï?�

W????L????}?z …ËWz W�…ËW?�W� —W????ÖW?z Ë v�????O� w?�W�W?� U~†W?????�ï????� W????� ÍW�U????�—W????� ËW?z Ëu????�W�

Ë w�W�üW???�ï??� ¨w�U???O??� ¨w�«d???Öu??� Í—uM� W?� ÂüW� g�œ—u??� W?�W� ÊU??L???�W�U~†W???�ï??�

W� Í…“«u???}???� ËWz Æb??�?� ÆÆËU??O???�—u� W?� ÊU�d??�?�ËWz Ë Í˛…œ «b�«d???}z W� «b?�ï??� ÍË«—“W???�«œ

W� ˜˘d?� w�U� w�U�…b�W?� W� v†W�ï� wL?�u�W� …ËW�Ëu� w�üËU� ÍËU�W� W�W� «œU?��«—W�

d|˛W� «œ…˙…ËU� ËW� s� ¨…ËW�U?�WÑ˘d?� ÊW��?O�W� U�…œ ÊËu� w?�üËU� w�O?��W� ÊUOJ?}�W�

Ê…—U�W????� W�«Ë ‘UJ?�d???�Wz ÆÆ…ËW?�…Ë«ñ???� …ËW�W?� v†W???�ï????� «b???O???�?�…—W???� Í…ËW�W?� ÍËU�

W� ÍËU� v�U?� W�W�ËW?� ÍW�…—W?� ï� W�…ËW�œd?� œ—U� W� È—ï?� rÇ…œ ï� Í«Ë ‘W�W�ËW?�W�

fK~MOz Ë f�—U?� w�U�W?�…œ ï� …ËWMO|˙W~� —W?ÖWz W�«Ë r}Ä ÆÈdM� v� ©w�œd� wJ�d?�Wz®

w�…ËW�W� Í—uM� w�œd�“ËU�W� ï� Ë Í—«œW�U�—W� w�U�—WÇ—…Ë Ë Ê«˙ïÖ W� Êœd� ”U� ï� Ë

Í“«u?}?� ï� d� wJ|—U?� ÊU?�UÄ Ë ÂeO?�U�dá?L?Oz wàJ�W� Ë Íï?� Í…Ë…—…œ ï� Í—«œW�U?�—W?�

vM}*W?�…œ ï� ÊU9WI?O�W� „W� W�U?�Wz Ëu�W� ÆÆœ«“Uz Í˙«“U� Í“«u?}� ï� ¨Íï?� ÊWO�«d?�O�

ÊËu� w?�U???N???O????�W� w�W?�W???�…—W???� Íï???�ï?� Í—«œW�U???�—W????� ÍW???�…—W???� W????� W�…ËWz g?�ËWz

Í—«œW�U?�—W� ÍW�…—W?� W� W~|— …ËW�W� ÂWz w�W�U�W?�…— Í—uM� «bA|u?� W� W�©W�W?�ËW�®

wJ}�…—ËË—…“ W??�W�ËW?� rÇ…œ ï� Í«Ë s� W?�ï� —W� ÆÆÊ«œ«bJ}Ä W?�??}�…œ W?�Wz d?�??Oz Êd?Ö…œ

…“«u}� UO�W� „W� w�W�W� Íï� Í—«œW�U�—W� W� «œW�W�…—W� ËWz Í…u}Ç—«uÇ W� WO�ËËó}�

78

≤∞∞µ ÂW�W� wM�dA� ©¥® …—U�˛ …ËWM�ó|u�

Ë Í—«œW�U??�—W??� ÍW??�…—W??� Ë Í—«œW�U??�—W??� Í—Ëu�Uz W??O??O� 5?J�u??� ÆÆÍW??�W??O?O?J�d??�Wz

ÆÆvMO�W� …ËW�ï�W� W�Wz Í—«œW�U�—W� ÍW�…—W�

ÍW?�W�ËW?� w�U� p†W?� W�U?�U0 Ê«—U?� w�W?O?Ñï?� w�W?O?�W� —W?ÖWz ∫∫∫∫eeee����““““WWWW????���� bbbb????OOOO????����WWWW????���� ÆÆÆÆÂÂÂÂ

øœd�…œ

ÂWz u?�…Ë w�W†Ë…œ ÊU�…œ Ë ÊWO?Ñï� ¨«b?O�…œ—W?�W� WI�U?� WJ�uÇ d}?�W� ∫∫∫∫VVVVOOOO����WWWW���� ««««““““UUUUzzzz

wF??O�W� ÍW??�…—W??� Â…œ—W�W?� ÊËu� o�U??� g�d� Íb�W?Ç Ë gO??�«d??}?� ÍW??O??�U??� W??O??�??�W�

w�…—ËË—…“W� W?�«u�…œ …Ëu� Í“U???�W??A???OÄ w�—ï???� Í…Ë…˛˘— ËW� ¨«œU??O?�œ W� Í—«œW�U???�—W??�

gO?��—U� w�U?�W�…œ w}ÄW?� 5Ç ÊËu� w�UN?O�W� Ë…—W� Í—«œW�U?�—W� ÍW?�…—W� w�ËËó?}�

ÆW?O?�ËW??� W�W†Ë…œ w�Ëu� Ë 5� w�Ëu?� Ë ÊW?O?Ñï?� w�Ëu?� ÂüW� ÆÍï� …ËW?�?O|˙W?~� —W?ÖWz

Â…œ—W�W� o�U??� ÍËu??�W� …ËW�U�ï??� w�W�U�W??�…— wM�?�«—U?Ä ÍËU�W� W�«u??Ö ÊU?�W??O�u?�W??�W�

W�U?Ö—…œ ËW?z «b?O�—«œW�U??�—W?� ÍW?�…—W??� Â…œ—W�W� W?�ïK� ÂW?z w�ËuÇËU�W� Æ«b�—«œW�U??�—W?�

ÆÊËu� w�UNO�W� Ë…—W� …ËW�«d�

s�WJ� d?O�W� œd?�…œ Í—U?� UJ�d?�Wz Í…Ë…—…œ w�…—«“…Ë W� U?�U� ï?�ï?� ï� W?L?}z ∫∫∫∫dddd����UUUU���� ÆÆÆÆÂÂÂÂ

ÛUÇ ÊU?�UÄ Ë«ñ}?Ö U�U� ï�ï?� ÆÆœd�…œ ÊU�©Èu?� w�UN?O� w�«e?O� Ë W�W�ËW?�® ÍU�bO?z W�

W????� ©d???�ô« ÊU????��«® Ë©ËËó????}???� w?�U�ï????�® ÍW�W????�W???� U?�…Ë—W� Ë…ËW�«d?� „W�W????�…“ Ëu�

s�d??��U�W??� Í—«œW�U??�—W?�® ∫v†…œ W?�W� „W�W�u??�W?� ÆÆ…Ëu?�d?Ö—…Ë W??â??O� W� ÍW??�W?�˘d??O�

W??�??}�U?� ËU??�U� ‰ËW??�W� W?�W� !«“W??� W??� v�W� w?��…d??Ö —W??ÖWz Í—«œW�U???�—W??� Æ©W�…—«ËW??�

Ë v�d�…œ …ËW� …ËuÇ—…œ ©≤∞∞¥® w†U?�W� Êï?�~��W� qOzï?�U?� w�}?�?� 5�«Ëœ ¨w�U?NO?�

ÆÆÆvM}J�…œ p}Ä Ë p}� sA�W� UJ�d�Wz ÍW�W�W� WJ�—W� …ËWz ∫v†…œ

Ë…ËW�W� w?�W?O?�UJA??OzW� Ê…—U�W??� U�…Ë—W?� ÆÆ«…ËU� p�—W??�Wz W� w�U??á??�z Í—u??��W??�

W� W??L??}z ¨W?O??O� ‘…ËW�W?� Ëu�W� —W??ÖWz U~†W??�ï??� Ë W?O??O� …ËW�W� 5?}?à� Èd??�U� U~?†W?�ï??�

ÂüW� W�W� U?~†W?�ï?� W�«Ë ©ÊU??�W�W†Ë…œ v� U~†W??�ï?�® ∫v†…œ W�U??�ËbM|u?� Ͳï�ïĢd??��Wz

ÆÆWOO� …ËW�W�