,,

rl mi)qqpghg rt(P &mi).>dodoh 3 >A'h N2?> 0159· 'MGP" 51 85 21/22/23- m>dho· 51 87 1 1 ·ggi\-o30MQ?O: www.tbappeal.court.ge; D<!?· <B(').l\o.): tbappeal@court.ge

599 770 100

ooo 'b.~36oo.)m, moo<!?obob l\.).)oo<!?.)GO('). bl\.)S.)MOJ<!?(').b .)Q?8o6ob0 M.)GO'CJ<!? l\.)0aom.)

O.)<!?.)oob 2016 V<!?Ob 22 0.)63MOb o.)Q?.)Vt!3000<!?000b Co.)6Ro6ooob) .)l\<!:?0.

/

b~dao # 330310015720450

b~dao 3e,/1547-1S\J.

22 o~6a~<'>o, 2016 ~n~o

m&o~obob b~~3n~~OO<'l b~b~a~<'>m~M

&~5Bo5nB~ b~d~<'>man~Mb b~bn~om

~<;()8o6ob6<'>~oo~~ b~dBnm~ 3~~~6~ etna<;()n~o etna~<;()M6~M&om:

llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll 0001113905039184

6~0>0~ D~O>~O>D~~dD ( 0>~38%<;()<'l8~MD, 8M8bb[J6[J&[)~O) BMb~a~<'>m~no&o: domna:,5 w~~~.:>ao

Bo<'>~~ ~(')8od,

~3D~~66n&o - b~d~Mmao~(Y}b ao6~0~6 b~dBom~ b~ao5obocY:>(Y}, b~d~cY:>mao~(")b 8m~3~cY:>o a(v)(Y}a~cY:>~o~cY:>~

~~<'>BMB~<;()M6~n&o - 5o5(Y} doaboa3o~o, a~a'CJ5~ aocY:>obo~oao

BM~o6~~~a~DM Bb~MD - 0o(YlcYJ0o J~<;()o0a3o~o ~~<'>a<'la~wM6n~o - 5oJ(Y}~(Y}<t> boa(Y}5oa3o~o

b.:>b.:>80MOJ<!!'<'1b b.:>0.:>8<'1do:J~<'1 J<'1<!!'0oo.:>oo. m~o<!!'obob b.:>.:>30<!!'0G0<'1 b.:>b.:>8.:>Mm<!!'(Y).b U0(>08<'1doo~(Y} J<'1<!!'0000U 2015 V<!!'Ob 23 o.:>6s(V)ob o06Bo6o~om (b.:>d8o NQ1o-71) b.:>Bo30MO .)M Q?0J80EJ(Y).'l30<!!'Q?0 oa b.:>'23~d3<!!'om, M(Y).8 ~M0<!!'Q?O~ob 8b.:>(V)ob Boo<') \).:>M8(Y).Q?o06o<!!'o Q?0 b.:>b.:>80MOJC!?<'1U 0.:>6go6o~om b0d8ob 0Mbo~om 006boC!?30tt>o Q?0030~~<!!' 8oJOGO~~<!!'O~.:>m.:> OMOJC"l(>}C!?oC"l(>).) 00J0M0Q? 0M0U0J80(V)obo OEJC"l Q?0 0C!?(>)0mM<»ob 80~0C!?o b0Mobbom 0M

odC!?OM<Q0 b0123~d3oC!?b 30M0~Q?obmsob, (V)(Y).a 0o<'1M0o JC!?Q?00o3oC!?8.:> g0owo60 006tt>(V)0bo Q?05.:>o0~C!?o .

2.1.4. 2014 V<!!'Ob 12 Q?:JJ:J8~(V)ob U00Q?3<'1J00(Y). a(Y).ab0b~(V)o~ob bo<!!'OOJM'tj<!!'O~Ob m06.:>b80Q?,

0o<'1M0o J<!!'Q?o.:>oso<!!'80 0Q?3(Y).J00 Q?03om J30J06oo(V).:>dob b.:>0Q?3(Y).J00(Y). 8<'18b.:>b~<V>o~obmsob 3<'15<'1M0Mob b.:>bom o0Q?0ob0Q?0 1 180 <!!'0Mo.

2.1.5. 8<'1b0<V>Bo<!!'O 0o(Y).M0o J<!!'Q?O.:>oso<!!'b, 2014 v<!!'ob 16 Q?OJ08~(V)ob 0.:>6eb.:>Q?o~ob U018~d3o<!!'tt>o, ,o6'23<'1M80GOOU m.:>sob'tj'B<!!'O~Ob o.:>6som0MO~Ob o6booo'tjOOb" w.:>a123~a60~o<!!'m0 0.:>w.:>vttsooo<!!'o~om 2014 v<!!'ob 20 o.:>53(V).:>aw0 oo'tjBOMQ?0 wo(V)odo(Y).(V)ob ~'23<!!':J~08<'1b0<!!'0~0.

2.1.6. 2014 VC!?OU 17 Q?OJ08~o(V)b, b0d0M0J30<!!'<'1U oo60(>06 b.:>d8om.:> b.:>8o6obo(V)(Y).a ~003MG0<!!'0 o06Gb0Q?0~0, M<'18<!!'ob 8oboQ?300J0G (>0<'1M(>O J<!!'Q?00030<!!'0 2014 V<!!'Ob 12 Q?OJoa~o(V)b

Q?00J03:Jb b.:>d.:><Y>m30<!!'<'1b bobb<!!'ob b.:>8.:>Mm<!!'ob J(Y).Wodbob 236-o 8'tjb<!!'ob 8:J(Y).MO 6 \) b O:JU0~08ob0Q? GOGD<!!'U0UM(Y).~O O.)M.)~Ob a.)M h.) .')~ Oo uy n~o\1 (\( .. ) ;! ' " noi~l ll J l ,

2.2.1. b.:>b.:>B.:>Mm<!!'<'1a 0068.:>M0 0, M(Y}a b.:>d.:>Mmso<!!'(Y).b 3(Y).5o0 o0 'tj0oob 42-o a~b b o-9 3~5doob m.:>50b80Q?, tt30<!!'0bmsob 0.:>(V).:>6oo(V)o~~<!!'00 b.:>bo<!!'B\Jo'B(Y)., 030(Y).6(Y).8o'tjMO (V)obo~~<!!'OJ:J~ob Q?0 msom88.:>Mm30<!!'<'1~ob (Y).M0.:>6<'1m0 Q?0 8(Y).b.:>8b.:>b'tjMOm.:>0.:>6 'tjJ06(Y).5(Y).Q? 8otto5o~~<!!'o tt>0M0<!!'ob b.:>b08.:>MOJ<!!'(Y). \Jobom b(V)~<!!'o .:>6.:>tt>~.:>'tjM:J~0 oob.:>~.:>8ob.:>Q?

b.:>bo<!!'avo'l3<'1, 036<'15<'180~MO (V)obo~~<!!'OJOU Q?0 0Q?(>0<!!'<'1~M030 msom880M(J)3D<!!'(Y).~Ob

b0bb(V)o~oQ?05. JC"l6booo~Goob Bo-18 8'tjb<!!'ob Bo-7 3~6doob m.:>6.:>b8.:>Q?, 'tjJ06(Y).6(Y).Q? Q?0J030~~C!? .:>5 Q?0o0oo8(V)o~~C!? 3o(V)b 0d3b J(Y).8oo6b~eoob ao~o~ob ~'23~0~0.

b0bOC!?8\)o'8<'1 <'1M005<'1m0 Q?0 8<'1b08b0b'tjMOm0 Boo<') ~J06<'16(Y).Q? 80EJ060~'tj~O tt>o06ob b0b0<!!'8\Jo'8<'1 b0bbMO~OQ?06 060tt>~0~M0~0 0~o0MO~'tjC!?O Q?0 00M.:>6ooMO~'tj~O.:> 0(>M0m30 0Q?08o05ob ~'B<!!'0~0m0 Q?0 doMom0Q? m.:>sob'tj'l3~0~0m.:> oob0bo~ 03M(Y).o'tj~o J(Y).5so5eoob Bo-5 8~bC!?ob Bo-5 3~5doom- ,m.:>sob~'l3~0l)ob0 Q?0 ~b0123Mmb<'10~ob 'tj'l3~0l)0".

tt>oa(Y).0~6oo6~C!?o J<'16booo~GO'tjMo 3(V)o5eooo 0.:>58oJoeo~~~o.:> b000Mm3o~(Y).b bobb~ob b.:>80MmC!?ob b0oM<'1GOb<'1 J<'1Q?Odbob 92-o 8'tjb~oo, (V)(Y).a~ob 3o(V)so~o 6.:>\)o~ob m.:>5.:>b8.:>Q?, 3o(V)b ~'23C!?0~0 0o3b, b.:>8<'1d0~.:>d<'1/0Q?8o6obo(V).:>Go~~o b.:>8.:>(V)m.:>~\).:>M8(Y).o~ob \Jobom 8<'1omb<'13<'1b Q?0 8oo~<'1b ~J05<'16<'1Q? B.:>o.:>MO~~~o b.:>oM(Y).Gob(Y). 8(Y).d80Q?O~ob.:> Q?0 ~J06(Y).6(Y).

0.:>Q?0\)EJsooo<!!'o~ob oowoo0Q? 8otto5o~~<!!'o tt>o.:>5ob .:>5.:>tt>~.:>~MO~.:>. 5(Y).M8.:> oooe.:>sb tt>(Y).0.:>wo b0bo.:>mob Q?060\):Jbb, M<'180<!!'0G 006b.:>tt>~3M03b b0bo~8\)o123(Y).b 30~Q?0~~~0~0b, ~J06(Y).6(Y).Q?

3

<t>~d~30~'c:l<!!'· <;,t>~.3~()o8(Y)o~'j<!!' ~5 8bx~3MQ?O~'c:J<!!' . .3o(Y)b oo'c:Jd85~b b~8~MOJ<!!'Q~Mo3o 'Cloba<!!'o~<!!'('}~~. b~JoM('}o~ob a0amb303~ao, 0~a('}o805('}b a('}aa05b~0oob a('}mb('}35ob~ w~ 8o~o~ob 'c:J<z3<!!'0~ob 0~5b('}MGOO<!!'O~ob 0£3000'c:JMO Q?~ MQ~<!!''c:JMO b~8~MOJ<!!'Q~Mo3o 5('}M8Q~o.

b~d~Mm3o<!!'('}b <f>('}o~wo ~wao5ob()M~GO'c:J<!!'o a('}wodbob 208-o a'c:Jb<!!'ob .3oM3Q~o 5~vo<!!'ob m~5~b8~(9, b~bo~8\)o<z3('} ~Q?8o5ob()M~GO'CJ<!!'O ('}M0~5('}b, ~0MQffi30 8obo m~5~8Q?Q~('}~ob

.3o(Y)ob ~5 bb3~ b~bo<!!'avo<s('} a('}b~ab.sb'c:J(Y)ob aoo(Y) b.sab~b'c:JMO~Mo3o a('}3~<!!'D('}~ob

0~6b('}fJGoo<!!'n~ob~b 8oEJo5o~'c:J<!!'O ~o~6ob~m3ob a~b'c:Jbob80o~n<!!'o~ b~bo<!!'avo£3('}. ~a~30 J('}Q?jobob 207-Q 8'c:Jb<!!'ob 8obQQ?30m JO, ffi'c:J ~8 J('}Q?Qobom bb3~ M~8 ~<') ~(Y)ob Q?~Q?oQ50<!!'0, ~w8o5ob()M~(30'c:J(!!>O ('}M0~5('}b 8o6M 8oEJo5o~'c:J<!!'O ~o~~ob ~5~~~~'c:JM[J~Ob~b 0~8('}0EJQ5[)~~ b~o~Mffi3[)<!!'('}b b~8('}o~<!!'~O('} J('}Q?Qobom Q?~Q?o[J50<!!'0 'Qobo.

b~d~fJ0)30<!!'('}h b~8('}rl~<!!'~d('} · J('}Wodbob 1 005-o 8'c:Jb<!!'oh .3oM30<!!'0 5~\)o<!!'oh m05~ba~w. m'c:J b~bo<!!'avo<s(Y} a('}u~ah~b'c:JMO 0~5'b(Y)0bo ~5 'c:Jboao 0~':j<z3Mmbo<!!'o~<!!'('}~om ~(Y)~3o3h m~3ob

. b~Sh~b'c:JMQM~(Y)o3 8('}3~<!!'0('}~~b . bb3~ .3o(Y)m~ 8o8~(Y)m, 8~oo5 b~bo<!!'avo<s('} ~5 oh ('}M0~5('}, fJ('}ao<!!'ooG 8('}b68b~b'c:JfJO 8'c:JO~('}~h, 3~<!!'WO~'CJ<!!'O~ ~~5~~~~'c:JM('}b ~o~5o. 0~6~(Y)~b3ob ~5 'c:Jbooo o~'c:J£3Mmbo<!!'O~<!!'('}~oh Q?M('}b 8Mb~8b~b'c:JMO b~bo<!!'8\)o£3('}bm~5 [JMm~w

U('}<!!'O~~fJ'c:J<!!'~Q? . . ~oo~b a~b'c:Jbh; ' ~8030 a'c:Jb<!!'ob ao-3 5~\)o<!!'ob m~6~b80Q?, <'>Q~~O<!!'OQOMQ{?'c:J<!!'O .3o(Y)ob~cri3oh 'c:JJ~5('}5('} 8bX,~3MQ?[)~Oh, bobb<!!'ob b~8~(Y)m<!!'ob .3~b'c:Jbob0o~~oo 'c:JJ~5('}5('}w 8oGo8oh, ~~.33omob ~('}5obdoo~oh h~bom .3~()o8(Y)('}~ob ~6

o~'CJU3<!!'0<!!'('}~oh bQ<!!'\)QMO<!!'Ob 'c:JJ~5('}5('}Q? 0~8('}l:j[J5[J~Ob, .30()o8M('}~Ob, ~5 0.'l8~b~Mt1>Q~Q~'0

h~8'C)O~<'lQ~Ob h~bom ~Q?8o5ob()M~GO'c:J<!!'O h~bQ?[J<!!'Ob ~(Y)~b\)('}M~Q? Q?~JOUM[J~ob 'Cl[JQ?[)00<:Q 8oEJo5o~'CJ<!!'O ~o~5o ~5~~~~'c:JMQ?O~~ b~bo<!!'avo<s('}h aoo(Y) a('}J3<!!'03oh, 'Qo5~b'Q~(Y)o

. 0~8('}doo~ob, . .3fJ('}d'c:JfJ~6'c:JMOb ('}M0~5('}[J~oh~ Q?~ h~b~8~Mm<!!'('}b ro~5~8Q?[J~(Y}~oh .3o(Y)m~

~fJ.:>~oh 8o'c:Jb[JQ?~3~W·

b~b.:>o~fJm<!!'('}a 0~58~~()~, MM8 b~d~<'1m3[J<!!'('}b b~8('}d~<!!'~d('} J('}Q?[)Jhoro 8omoroo~'c:J<!!'O 5<'lM8ob 0)~30UQ~rJfJo~~b V~M8('}~woo5h ob, M('}8 ~o~5o ~5~~~~'c:JM[)~~b Od3oawo~~M[)~~ 8o'c:Jb[}Q?~3~W ~o~5oh 8o8EJQ5[J~<!!'oh ~M~<!!'ob~, ~o~5oh ~5~~~~'c:JM[J~ob 8(Y}rob('}36oh w~aa~s('}<so<!!'o~ohm3ob b~aa~fJobo~, w~w0o5cgob 0aowo~ob 'c:JJ~5('}5('}~~ w~ h~bo~n O::J('}h .3o(Y)ob a~(Y)o~~o~o()ofJo~O<!!'O o~M[J8('}o~~~ ~a~bm~5, h~o'c:J<!!'Ohba~. M('}8 ~oa~~5o'Cl5'c:J<!!'0 5<'lM8Q~O ~5oJ[J~[J6 fJ~ .3o(Y)b ~o~5oh ~5~~~~'c:JMQ~Ob 8('}rob('}36oh 'CJ<z3(!!'0~~b, ~(Y)

0~5h~~~3fJ~30o a~fJo~~o<!!'ooo(Y)o~o<!!' 0~M0a('}o~o~b . aoh~~~aou~w. a~5('}5awo~o<!!'a~

h~h~8~Mm<!!'<'1h ao~5oJ~ m~3ob'c:J<s<!!'O~~ d8own~ob 'c:JJ~5('}5<'l~ob0 e90 M[J~~o<!!'oo~Gooh

b~<z3'CJd3<!!'D~ob oo<s~bo~ob~b.

h~b~8~fJro<!!'('}8 0~58~<')()~, <')('}8 .3o(Y)ob 8~MO~~o<!!'o()oMO~D<!!' 0~M[J8('}[)~~Q? 'c:J6Q?~ od5oh 8oB5[J'c:J<!!'O 8oh 8o8~fJro bobb<!!'obb~8~Mm<!!'[J~Mo3o Q?035oh oo'Q~J306ob 0~5Bo5o~ob

0~a('}0~5~, 3o6~ow~5 ~a03~Mo ~doo ~w~h6'c:JMO~b, M('}a .3o(Y)b w~5~'Cl~'c:J<!!'0 0<1> B~'c:Jwo5o~. fJ~G• ro~3ob 8bfJo3, 0~5~.3ofJ('}~[J~b 8ob 'c:J<z3<!!'[)~[J~Clo ~~Wo06~h - 8oh M[J~~o<!!'oO~Go~h. M~G aoobo~~ ~na~~5o'Cl5'CJ<!!'o a'CJb<!!'oh a0('}MO 3('}aa('}5o50 b, dBown~ob 'c:JJ05('}5('}~~h, ~(Y) 'c:J5w~ OQ<z3~hwob 8b('}<!!'('}(9 J('}5JfJ06'CJ<!!'O h~.3M('}GQh('} m'C) 8~()[)MO~<!!''CJMO 5(Y}(Y)8oh Q?~M~303oh

4

~

CD~<,>gog qo~C<a~<.>q-wg g-w~ '<.>og<aoog g-w~CD<;Y<.'g<.>q<.>q oes8C8qcogCB ~C8~oq<.>qg<.>~

·o~C<.>e,<.>g<.>m oq<.>~q,g<.>~ <.>gomo<.><a <.>g~o8e,<.>om~r o~~-wo~ g-w<;Y 'qo8coqomC<.>~<.>8 q~C8pCfb<.>q <,>mwC~po ~<,' cooqqo~<.>q O~<,'W<.'g qo~U>CD<,'~~<,' <.>m -wRo oqo<;Y<.>gt'<:q<:<;Y<.' m<:~<:Fe,<: <:~-wo~~wco~C <:CD<:QC~CQC8ot'Qg ~C~C8e,<:m Cq,<:8~oqg<:~ coo~Cq<;Y<: qogp<:q coo~Cgo<Jg<:~ q-w~co~<:g<:q<.>q <:m o~ogC~m-wg~<.>~ ~Cog qo~<:qg qoQCm~<:<;YQ g-w<;Y 'coo~8pCfb<:q go <:m~ofbwR<.>gr<:m ~<: o~<:8o<J<:q qo~CQ<:~CF-w~~ o~<:8<:cog q-wc?;)G8<.o<;Y<:p<:q or (IL. -~IoN Cgp<.>q) cooQGgo<Jg<.>~ qo~8g<:o £(; qo~~ SIOZ qoo~G~-wr -wQGop-wg<:~<:q q-wc?;)co~c;-g<.>qc;-q -wo8<:~Ge<.><.>q qoqo~OQCD ·Gq,<:~w<.>co qoQG8R~Ge, qog8Gm o8o~~Gc?;)w<;Yc;-g<:q<:qqo~qqoq co~<:gog qo~o8e,<:om~r o~~wo~ <.>QGgo<Jg<:~ <.>gpo c?;)og<:Q-wg<:~ Gq,<:g-wmqq -w~co~<:g<:q<:q<:go~ ~Gog qw~co~<:g<:q<:q -wp<:~<;>p<:q qoqo~o~w 'q~<:8g<:o S1 qoc?;)~ SIOZ

·q~G8pCS>c;-q qo~G8c;-rc;-oo oqog c;-w-wG~po <;Y<;> <:oo qooC<:<;Y<.>8 qo8~<:gog qo~C~Gm~<:~~ c;-m8<.>q8o~wg<.>~ <.>~-wo~~-wco~G qo~G~G-wgG<;Y<:~ g<: mG<;Yw~q

·g<:coqc;-gc;-RC8f! qoQCwg~<:~~<:co~<:g<:q o~CQC~og8<:F<:m qo~<: w-w<;Ywo£g. oc?;)C~Gwc?;)<:~Q <:m o~C~G~oe,8<.>r<:m qo~c;-~c;-g<:coqc;-coC8r~<: qo~C~S>Cqo8s-w 8<:<;Y '8<:q~G'Xqc:q wGqo q~Ggo~qo~<:8coo '<.>qocoG8rw<: qo~G~S>Cqo8<:w <:m~<:~ 8<:~ 'too~o~<:g z-Gg qo~qCg G-9£Z qoqf!Gm-wr qo~co~<.>gi;>q qo~qqoq <:o~C~GR~<:m <:caCop-wg<:~ Gq,Ggf!<:q qoW>w<;Y<:g<:q qo~qqoq . .

·q<:~Cop-wg<:~ <:QG~<:gGog q-w~m qogS>wR oB<:~G~S>Cqo8<:w o~oe g-w<;Y 'ro<:~~Gc.ot.~c;-q<:qc;-0:>. qogo <:~wo~~wco~G qoo8<.>g~-wS>go <:oo <:qo~CQF<:S> qGroQw~Gq<;Y<:. '<:og~8w.c?;)Gg8Bogg q<:qoQGq<:fbGe, qoqco~fb<.>q qo8~<:gog o~C~Ggo~qo~c;-8w<:~ woqf!Ga:}-wf' wqGO-w~ec;-q qo~co~c;-g<:q qo~qqoq gc;-~m<:~ ·o~G8pCSic;-q o8o~caG~w~<:g<:q qo~G8<:F<:w qo~G],~Gm~<.>0~ <,>m~w~Gq0<: ~<;' gw~ '<;>o~Cge,ogw<: or . OB<:QGgo<Jg<:~ ·gc;-O)o~G8<:F<:w <;>m~SiGqo8c:w<.>~

o~o8e,<:om~r o~~-wo~ wo~Cgo<Jgc;-~ v1~SSlL./<5:>01aN qo~~gCPGw t1 qo~~ · vlOZ qoo~C~-wr <:coGgf!c;-q qo~w~c;-g<.>q qo~qqoq qw~w~<:g<.>q<.>q wp<.>~C:f!i:q qoqo~o~w 'g~coq<:g<.> •

·qo8coqogCmc;-<a qo~Cc;-e,<.>gc;-m o~C~Cgo~qo~<:8w<:~ (<:~G~<:Q U)~Gwgw<:<.>go~<:q~co~<.>g .. qo~-w~oQwR~wg o~GQCpcoGS><:q<.> g<.> qo~G~Goco8og ow<:~GpwG~ 'qo~<:q<:g -w~wp~~<:q 'qowc;-~<.>o o~-w~q<:q~q8G8) coo~o~<:g G~-wGg qo~qrj,g G-9£Z qoq[!G())-wr qo~co~<:gc;-q qo~qqoq q-w~G8co~<:p<.>q 'o~o8e,<:omW>r o~~-wo~ qG8<:t'<:<.>ro <:g~Gc?;)g-w<;Ye,g<.>g<:co qoQgCg<.>Q~<.>eCm qoo8o~we o~C~<.>gogo~r o<;YC~c;-~QgG8 q-w~Qqogog<:q <.>coGgp<:q g<:'l<:goe, q-w~C8co~<:p<:q ·q~G~gGrGm Z:I qo~~ viOl g-w~ 'o~CGg<Jog <:gpo m<:~ogG~mc;-m

·qo8coqo8G~<.><J oW>C~G~~<.>€<.>m<.>~

c;-m;g<.> o~CQG~co~c;-gC<.>~ oe,~C~G~S>C oqog g<:ooo~qg · q-wS>o~gc?;)Gq<.>q <:o8<.>qgG£g-wF oqog<.>Q<.>qGe, qG8Gog <.>rugC '<.>g8Gm o8o~~G~co~<.>gc;-qqo~qqoq <.>ruR~GB 9<:w~<.>gog qo~gw~ 'q~oe '<.>8gCco 'q<:o8gCQG~g-wr qw~co~<.>gc;-q<.>q qgG~roc;-wg~<.>~ woqwCF qo~-wqo0c;-gt'<.>q

qo8coqog<:Q-wg<:~ qogG<J<.>g<:Q o~C~CgCRQgc;-gc;-~ <:~Gq<:S>GB <:co<:.~G~C~G8orQg g<:mo<.>go8 'q'2GmCe, qogf!c;-q o~CQC~rg-wr q8<.>~8wq,<:qg<:~ ~C8 <;Y<.>~q<.>go~ -wg<.>~<;Y-w o~oqwg<.>~G~S>GJ, 'g<.>coq<.>gc;-'qc;-88c;-ro qo~Cwqco<;YSlc;-qC qo08C~ o~GJ,QG<;Yt'gwP oqog 'qo~Gwoo<,>Qwq.,<:q

'qgc;-q,og <;YCgoQo~C~ q-wS>o~g~Cq<:q <:~Gy)Cqc;-qgG o~G~Gopqogww qo~G~GJ,po

o~CQGgCRwg<.>~ CD<;Y<.>gog qo~C~Goo~<.><;Y~ c;-ru <;'g8Coo o8o0~G~co0<.>g<.>qqoc?;)qqoq '<.>o~<.><.o~<:(J ·<.>~-w~~C~p<.>qGe, · o<;YCQPCS>C qogC<2ruw<.> qo~G~C~S>GJ, qG8Cog · <.>oogC q<;Yoe 'coogCQw~t

m:>3ob 8<'lmb<'l35oe,b:, <;:Q:> aob:>0Qe,Q~b. :>8 0:>M:J8<'l:Je,:>cn:> <;:Q:>86JOGQe,:, aaod~Qe,:, msom 8b:>Mom:> :>bb5:>-0:>58:>(Y)6oe,ocn, 8<'l\)8ocn:> Rsa5ooocn, \)QMO~<'loocno cn'CJ 5oscnooMo

86J0(3:JO'CJ~Doooocn <;:Q:> odb.3:JM6m:> <;:Q:>bJs5aoocn. :>8:>30 8'C.Jb~ob 8ob:>8o 5:>\)o~ob m:>5:>b8:><;:Q, 0:>M:J8<'l[)e,0oo, M<'l8[J~OG J:>5<'l5ob cn:>5:>b8:><;:Q 'CJ5<;:Q:> <;:Q:><;:Q:>b6'CJM<;:QQb 0:>MJ3Q'CJ~O h:>bob 86JOGOt"'>':::J(!?Ot"'>ot"'>om ~M oood~[Jt"'>:> cg:>cg:>b¢':::JM<;:g[Jb bb30 b:>bob 86JOGOO'CJ~Ooaoom .

b:>d:>Mm30<!!'<'lb b:>8<'ld:>~:>d<'l J<'lWQdbob 408-o 8'C.Jb~ob .3oM3Q~o 5:>\)o~ob m:>5:>b8:>cg, oa .3oM8:>, . M<'l8:J~OG 30~<;:QDO'CJ~o:> :>05:>'\J~:>'C.JM<'lb 'bo:>5o, 'C)5<;:g0 :>~:>cg0o5<'lb ob 8cg0<'l8:>M:J<'lo:>, M<'l8:J~OG o0Mb:JOQO<;:Q:>, M<'l8 0M <;:Q:>8cg0:>MOS<'l :>5:>'b~:>'CJMQoob

B:>s:>~<;:QDO'CJ~Doo~o 0:>M:J8<'l[JO:>.

b:>b08:>Mm~<'la ao'C.Jcnocn0 0cg:>8o:>6ob 'CJCZJ~oo:>m:> D3M<'l.3'CJ~o b:>b:>8:>Mm~<'lb 2009 \)~ob 27 :>.3Mo~ob 0:>w:>\7ssooo~oe,:>'bo (M:>8oaso~o cg:> J<'lbMooao b:>d:>Mm3Q~<'lb \)o5:>:>~8cgo0),

M<'l8Q~'aoG :>~5o'a5'CJ~o:>, M<'l8 0:>58(3b:>cgoo~ob aoaM 8<'lmb<'ls5o~ CZJ'CJ~:>cg

J<'l8.3o5b:>(3o:>b:> <;:Q0 J<'l53Q5Goob <;:g:>M~3QS:>b a<'lMob 'C.)5cg:> os<'lb J<'l5JMQO'CJ~O

8o'bo'b<'loMoso J:>saoMo. b(Y)'CJ~o J<'l8.3o5b:>Goobcnsob (restitutio in integrum) b:>.JoM<'l m:>5bob 'b'C.Jboo (>:>8<'lCD3~0 aood~oe,:, OQ:>ezJQMb<'lb <;:g:>M~3Q30CD (>08<'l\)3Q'CJ~O 'bo05ob e,'CJ5Q?<'l305:Je,:>a. 0bom ao8mbsos:>ao, 'CJ5<;:g0 00<;:g0\)SQ?Qb b080Mcn~o06o <;:g0J80EJ<'lCZJO~Qoob b03ocnbo M<'l(><'lM(3 \)0Mb'CJ~, 0bQ3Q 8<'l8030~ CZJ'CJ~:>cg 'b:>M0~m05 8o80MmQo0oo. 08 b:>Jombob 0:><;:Q0\)S3D00 \):>M8<'l0<;:g0Q5b b0b080Mm~<'lb cgobJMQ(300b <;!? U h

<'loood6'CJMo.

() b..'lb , ':.JO >b:Jt.J(J·>'lo, lll'~ll;l ('ll"•; )t"lllh ll(I;)C•! \}:,(•/ l\•) ll tV JII( "'0.'• l:,l)IJ<' ti d "'':'J('IIl ' I ""',IHJI

cg:>80<;:g:>b6'CJM:Joo~o 86J GDe'CJ a~ae . a<•> (")~, G · ~ 6 U(<).Ub · ,,, c:!~ >h . l:JLI: b• ~ ~ 2014 \)~ob 12 WDJD8e,Mob bo~ClDJM'CJ~Do0, M(V)8~ob 8obacgsom:>G 0(g3(V)J0()ob M<'l8o~oG 0(303<;:Q0 8<'lb0MRo~ob 'CJCZJ~ooaob0 <:g0 o56QM:Jbb bobb~ob b080Mm~ob b008ob 8o8wo50M:J<'loob:>b, \)0M8<'l0<;:Q(>Q5<;:g:> 1 180 ~0Mb. 8(Y}b0MR:J~ob 'CJJ05(Y}5(Y} <;:g0J03Qoob:> <;:g0 8ob 8o8:>Mm bobb~ob b:>80MCD~:JOM030 was5ob <:g0\)saoob (>08<'l, 0(>0 Od'CJ~OO'CJ~O OS(Y} b:>J'CJCD:>Mo 'CJCB~ooooob oCBod6'CJMO <;:Q0Gsobcnsob 8oo80Mm0 :>cgs(Y}J06obmsob. ClQb0o08ob:><;:Q, b:>b:>80MCD~(Y}a <;:Q0<:g0b6'CJMQO'CJ~0<;:g 8ooR5o:> .3oM<;:g0.3oMo 8o'bo'b(Y}oMo3o J0saoMob :>Mb:Je,<'lo:> ez3'CJ~0<:g 'b0M:>~b0 <;:Q0 8(Y}.30b'C.Jbom:> d8:J<;:QQ00b O<'lMob.

'boa~~5o'a5'CJ~ow:>5 0:>8<'l8wo50M:J, b:>bB:>Mm~(Y}a b:>b0MRQ~(Y} a(Y}mb(Y}s5:> a(Y}Gaa'CJ~

5:>\)o~ao ez30DO<'le,(Y)os-b:>80Mm~ooMo30Q? <;:g0b:>o'CJCDQO'CJ~0<;:Q 8ooR6o0 <;:g0 <;:Q00J80l::J(Y}£30~0.

a(Y}.30b'C.Jbooob b<'l~O<;:Q0M'CJ~0<:g <;:Q0:JJObM0CD 8<'lb0MRo~obcnsob 8:>6QM00~'CJMO 'bo05ob :>5:>'b~0'C.)M:J00 1180 (:>m:>b :>b <'lmb8<'l(30) ~:>Mob (Y}<;,'gQ5(Y}oocn.

3. b~~3D<::!>~OOM b~Roa<Y>ob b~ez3'CJd3<::!>De,o: b~d~M0>3D<::!>MU am~a~<Y>o 3MMJ'CJM~O'CJ(Y>Ob b~:,3D<::!>:,0o<'l b:,RoacY>ob CB~do~cY>oao <;!?:,

u:,a~cY>m<::!>of><Y>oao b~'lJ'CJd3~of>o:

3.1.1. :>.3Q~056o 8o'C.)CDOCDQOb b0o0MCD3Q~(Y}b b08<'ld0~0d(Y} J<'lQ?Qdbob 992-Q 8'C)b~'bQ, M<'l8~ob cn:>5:>b8:>cg, .3o(Y)o, (Y)(Y}8o~oG bb30 .3oMb 80Mm~b:>\)o500~8cgo0<'l, 005'bM:>bo 06

8

II I

~ I

6

'c;-Qw8oQpc;-o8o<;YQC-wroc;-<awq,c;-q '<;>QWC<;Yc;-gw<arog o<;YC.~c;-o<;YCQc;-g 'o£'<:q<: <:c;-qoc,ywe c;-coc;-QCwgC<;Yc;-Q gc;-·qQCQCwgC<;Yc;-<a <;YC.QpCoQw c;-ro w<;Yc;-gog qogc;-oq, o<;YC.~c;-<;Ywg q<:<aC~C.<;}Croo£'wgc;-ro <;YC.QpCo8C.q {\O<;YO£ 'qQCwo OR,<;>QW~C8roCqg W~CO<;Y<;>gc;-q<:q . q<:qo<;Y8wq,<:qgc;>Q qoQwgCrow qogc;-oq, o<;YC.~c;-<;Ywg ·ru<:~QCroo£'C.wgc;-ru <:QCc,y8wq,<:qog<:<a coog<;YwS, oroc;-~C,S, <;YCog qw~CO<;Y<:gc;-q<:q <;>QC<;YC.<:wq,c;-g<: qog<:oq, 'g<:wq<:g<: 'Cq,<:QW(_YO£ <:8qq<:ro<:8qq ~c;-8c;-<;Yg <:o~C.QCruo£'-wg<:ro '<;>o<;YC.~<:C.roo8orugo <:8C8qcogCe o~C.Cwcooco qoQC<;YC.<:wq,<:g<: qogc;-oq, o<;YC.~c;-<;Ywg •Cq,<:QwgCrow qog<:oq, O<;YC.~<:<;YW8 qQCcoocoC. c,y<: ogwgc;-£' '<:QCc,yC.<:<;Yq,<:g<: qog<:oq, O<;YC.~<;><;YW8 qw8wqcoowg q8pc;-<:QC~S,C, {\(_YO£ ·~kqw<;Yffi qo~gwc,y 'qQC~8pQ.S,<:q

go q8c;-<;Y8wq,<:qgc;-<a 8o~Cgw<;Y 'o~qC.g 81-Cg qoqpCrow£' wP<:~<:Pwg<:q q<aCgo~qo~<:8coo qc;-QC<;YC.c;-wq,c;-g<: qogc;-oq, o<;YC.~c;-<;Ywg ·cooq<:q qoQC<;YC.<:wq,<:g<: og<:o~coc_yc;-g<:q <:ro o~C.<;Y8ogw<a 'OR,QC8C8qcogCR, ~C.<;Y8wq,<:qg<:<a roc;-QqC.q, coogwgc;-£' ruw~wqg qCgpo ~og8wqcowg <:<aC~poGe <;>QC<;YC.c;-wq,<:gc;-oruc;-~C,S, qo8coc;-qogc;-oq, o8o<;YQCgwpc;-<;Y<: 'ru<:gq<:g<:co qo~o~<:g o~C8<;YO£ qo~qC.g C-£1v qoqpCrow£' wP<:~c;-pwgc;-q qw~C8co<;Yc;-p<:q ·c;-QC<;YC.<:wq,<:gc;-qogc;-oq, (o<;YC.~c;-<;Ywg) o<;YC.~c;-o<;YCQ<:g<;><;Y<;> qgC<aro<:Wg<;Y<;>~ qc;-g8wqcowg w~C~<;Y<;>qc;-q 'oec;-8C8qcogCe ~C8~oq<:qg<:Q

·qc;-8oQ<:<awy)C<;Y£ qw~co<;Y<:gc;-q<:q &w~wqg qgC<aro<:Wg<;Y<:~ cooqcoC.£' qoQW{\O<;Y<:g£'c;-q qo8coqogc;-Qwgc;-<a qogC~c;-g<:Q o~C<aCgC.RQg<:g<:<a <:<aCq<:S,CB c;-co<:QC~C.QC8o£'Qg g<:ruoc;-go8 •o<aGroCe qogF<:q o~C.QC<;Y£'gw£' <:<aCc,y8wqsqog<:~ ~C8 c,y<:~q<igo~ 'gc;-wq<:g<: 'q<:8~kru qoQCwqw<;YS,c;-qC. qoQC<;Y8C~ oqog 'qoQCwQ)<:<awq,<:q -qg<:q,og <;YC.goQo<aC~ qwS,o~g~Cq<:q <;>QC<;YC.qc;-qgC OQCQCopqogww qoQC~C.po o~C.QCgCRt.lg<,><a wc,y<:gog qo~C.QCru~<;><;YQ c;-ru <:g8Cru o80<;YQC~W<;Y<;>gc;-q qo~qqoq 'WOQCQc_y<:ggc:<a qoQg<:~C£<: ·z·1·£

·<:rogwPe: <;Y<;> o~o<aru<: q~C.geogw<: 'oe<:8G8qcogGii ~C.gC8wg 'woQCwowog qoQg<:~C£c;-·qo<;YWB q<aCroCe, <;Y<:Qrug<:ru <:m <:q<:QC&>Cgp o<;Yoe8<:£' o8o~Qwq,C<~pg wruC.<;><;Y<:8<:q <;'<;Y<;' <;>ro 'o0or<;>ro<;YO£ qCruQWQCq<;Y<: <:mgC. <:ro COOQW~QC~oqcoc,yS,C,<;>Q

oeCqC. g<: oqc;-<;Yq,g<:<a 'o~C.C~<;><;YQ qwlio c;-ro g<:mOQwC<;Y<:gw.<arog . o8o<;YQC<9C.q<:qgc:q qo~Cqwg qCroQwC0c;-gorugwg<:<a <:rugC. '<:o8~owg<:<a og<:oq, qo8coqo0oe 8<:g~Cgw0 'c;-QCruGgp wgwg<:£'C. qo~Cqwg 'C8Cq<: ·o0oe8c;-£' o8o0Qwq,Cq,og qCmQWQCq0<: <:rogC. qo<;YwB qgc;-oq, •q<aCruCe 0c;-<arugc;-ru c;-ru <:qc;-QCruCgp ~C.QC~Co80wqgc;-<a ;g<:coqc:gc;-'coog0ws, {\O~<;'<;YQ {).OQW~QC~oqeo<;YS,C.c:<a OR,CqC. gc: oqc;-0q,gc;-<a qoQCroCgp qWroc:og . c:rogC. og<:oq, {).00£ gw<;Y •qS,wliroc:q8 c;-o8ogoS,Cro qoQC~qC,g o~C.geogwc: 'woQCQc,yc:gg<:Q qoQgc:~C~c;-

·qqC.qc;-e gCQC<ac: ruc;-~C,0c;-roo~wq W<;'CO<;YC gc;-wqwS,o~g~Cqc;-q OQC00£ qC qo8coqOQW~QC~oqw0fl>C,c:Q

oeCqC. gc: qc;-qo8qc;-0q,gc;-<a ·roc;-8c;-roCqC.og qo~<;>0Q <;>W00£ qoQWQCrogc:gc:co qw~coc,yc:gc;-q<:q c;-ro c;-qoQCwgc;-<a<;Yw qo<;YC.Qc:<;YC.£'w0£ 'qoQCopwgc;-<a wS,o~g~Cqc:q qQC0C.c:wq,<:g<;><;> qgc;-oq, ~C.QCgCiiog roc;-<aCruCe qoQC0qo£'c;-ro roc;-<;Yw~qc;-<;Y<;> qo~Croq<:q o~G;',o8<:0Qqogogroc;-

woqc;-q qoQCwc;-eC.gc;-q o~CQC0w~qc;-gc;-<a gc;-qoQw0goQc:e o~G;',o8<,>0Qqogogm<,>

'qoQCgCiiwgc;-Q rowgwgc:£'C. (lOQW0goQc;-e woqc;-q qoQCopqogww qocoC8£'w<,> 'qogC8og rowgwgc;-£'C, OR,<;>QC<aqoqC.qc:e {\0~(00<;'8<;'{\ qo~qqoq 'qoQCro08<:Xqg wgwgc:£'G;', qo8CO<:(l000£ o~C.QC0oQo~oQc;-C0 'o£' ruc;-gqc;-gc;-co qo~o~c;-g £-Cg qo~qC.g C-£001 qoqpCrow£' C8c;-g<: ·ogc;-oq, qC qc;-g qw0C.c;-wq,c;-gC.c: c;-o~C.QCro~c;-8. 'qgc;-oq, qQCgCiic;-og woQCroCgpwg o~CQC~oqco0S,C.c;-<a

. I

Zl

-8l ·£-~ ~l-Q) ~~C8pCR>c:~ ~oQC~R>C~o8c:wc:~ ~o~CQC8c:rc:w c:Q)gWQ)c:wg~c:~ ·C~~C8pCf.Oc:~ ~o~Cg C-9Ll ~~o[JCQ)wr C8c:go '8c:<;Y ·~c:8C8w<;Yc:Q) woQC~<;YC: ~o~qCg G-ILl ~o~[JCQ)wr w~C8w<;Y£C:~ ~o~w<;Yc:gc:~ ~o~q~o~ c:Q)gwf!E: o~o~Q)c: gw<;Y · 'c:wocoQ.og gw~co<;Yc:gc:~c:q

·~o8w~oQCQCQ)Cgpwg

WQCopwgc:~c:~ c:goQCQ)o<;YCC: o8c:co o~o~Q)<;> c:ogwf!E: ~r:: or 8r::~r::Qtv~Cm8g

Q)c:8c:Q)CqCog ~ogc: c:Q) QCqc:~Cg, ~oQCWg<;Yr::~ ~ogpr::~ ~o~co<;Yc:gr::q ~o~q~o~ r;:Q)w8o c:g~CQCQ)~r::<;YQ gr::~Q)c:~ ·C~c:Qwc:w ~o8~c:gog w~pr::~Cg, ~o~CQCm~r::~Q ~C:QWQC~<;YC: ~oQ)Cr::<;Yc:8 o~CQCmCQc:~r::Q) c:Q)8c:q8o<;Ywgr::~ or o~Cgg,ogwc: ·cooqr::~ qog~wg c:qcooror::Q) c:Q) og,wgc:~<;YW wQCopwgr::~c:~ r;:Q)Q)c:q8wgr::~ cooQCg o~o8r::co 'OQ.QCQCQ)Ggpwg w<aGopwgr::<ac:~

C:QWC~o~r::gwg wwoog illOQW~Rlwfk<aGg r::g~C~GQ)~r::0<a 8r::~GQ)w<;Y 'gog,r::g OQ.r::<aG~ofbwRgr::<l ~oo8o~wr r::Q)~Co8<;Ywqgr::<l r::<aC8r::rr::Q) ~o~C<aGQ)~r::0<a ·<aGqr::~Gg, ~o8~r::gog

o~og oQ)Cr::<;Yr::8 wQ)Gr::Q) Q)r::~8pCR>r::~ ~r::<aC8r::rr::Q) ~()~CQGQ)~r::<;Y<a gw~ 'r::o~Cgg,ogwr::

og,c:QCgo~gr::<a ·gc:Q)oQC8r::rr::Q) r::Q)~f.OC~o8r::coc:~ G~C~<;Yr::qwg 'gr::coqr::gr:: ·coo<awgGQ)w ~o<;Yr::~ ·(o~r::wCq ~c:wr::) OOSl wr::<;Yo<a r::g[Jo ~CQGgCRwgr::<a woqr::~ ~o<aGop~ogww ~ocoG8rwr:: W<;Yr::gog ~o~o8g,r::oQ)U'A>r o<l<;Ywo~ woQCgo~gr::<l tl-SSlL/Q)Ol<N qo~<aeCrGro tl ~o~~ tlOZ ~oo~C~wr r::coGg[Jr::~ ~o~co<;Yr::gc:~ ~o~q~o~ ~w~co0r::gr::~r::~ wpr::~r::[Jr::~ ~oqo~o<am 'f:'l't ·

·(zt-Sl ·fo·q ~~-Q) ~0.8co~ogGQ)~~ qo~Cc:g,r::gc:Q) o~CQCgo~~o~r::8cor::~ (r::<aC<;Yc:Q . w~CQ)gwr::r::gq~r::~~cpcg~e · S"J.o<awW>oQwR~wg o~CQGpwCR>r::qr:: gc: ~oQG<;YCow8og oQ)c:<aCf!c.oCR> . ·~o~i;>~r::g w~~p~Qr::q_ . 'qowr::<;YC:O o~w<;Yqr::~~q8C8) wo~o~r::g C(;YwCg ~o~q(;hg · C~9£Z ~oqpca,wr qoe:ti>co0r::gr::q qo~q~o~ ~w~C8co<;Yr::pr::~ 'o~o8g,r::9Q)~r o<a<;Ywo~. <tG8r::rc:r::Q) r::g<aG~gw~g;gr::gr::w ~oQgGgr;:_Q~r::rGQ). ~oo8o~wr o<;YC~r::gogo<;Yr O<;YC~c:<;YQgG8 qw~Q~ogogr::~ r::wCg[Jr::~ g<:<ac;-gog, ~w~G8w~r::p~q .. ~<;YCQgCrGQ) (;l ~o~~ tlOZ gw<;Y 'r::o~ogCQQ)r;:Q) G8G~r:: COOQG~r::qr::g qogpr::~ "l:l't.

'(9l-l ·R>·q ~l-Q) cooQwgCQ)w ~o<;Yr::~ (o8wgqcow ~r:: ~r::wr::) 08ll r::<aG0R.r::wq,r::;gr:: ~ogr::o~ O<;YC~c:o<;YGQr::g COW<;Y~of'Cr::Q) Q)r::~C<;Yr::Q)o~w~ Q)wW)<aG<l<;Yr::~r::~ qo~C~~r::qwg q<aGGqC~r::£wg -·

·coo<awgCQ)w ~O<;YC:~ (oqr::cor:: ocor::) 000 01 c:<aG<;YCr::w~c:gr:: ~ogc:()~ o<;YC~r::<;Ywg cow<;Y~orGr::Q) Q)c:~C<;Yc:Q)c.>~w~ Q)w~QC~<;Yc:~r::q ~oW)G~<;Yc:~wg ~QGCqC~c:rwg -

:c:8wqwowg c;-Q) ~r::o~G~wr c:coGg[Jc:q ~Co8r::<;YQ~ogogQ)r:: qw~W<;Yc:gc:~r::~ w[Jr::~r::Pr::~ qo~o~OQW r::w<;Yc:gog cooW)G~~c:~ c:g~o8g,c:oQ)~r

o'2<;Ywo~ ~~r::8<;YGQGco 01 ~o~~ swz: gw<;Y 'r::oW)ogG~Q)c:ffi cooQG~c:~c:g qogpr::~ ·rrt

:r::<aGcoC<ar::qr::O) oCo<y<awOpr::fl>

:~QCQ)gGg, q8r::gg,ogwr:: cooQCQc:gc:Q) r::Q) G~cor::g ~<aGcoocoCog 'coo<aG<yog,8r::Pc:m gr::wQCqworr::~ 8o<;YQC~w<;Yc:gr::~ r::Q) 8o<;Y<awQp~£ ~og[Jr::~ ~<aGg8rqr::Q) r::ro q<aC<aG~~R>Gg, qw~co<;Yc:gc:qr::q ~oo8gr::Qqgo o~G8<;YO£ ~QC<;Yr::o~o r::Q) r::QCgqgr::coG r::Q<;>~C:£ wo8<;>~Grr::c:~

22).

4.1.4. 2015 \)~ob 15 o.:>6s.:>(Y)b, moo~obob b.:>j.'>~.)rl(Y} b.:>b.:>8.)(Y}(J)~(Y}b 8oo(Y) \)o6.:>b.:>b.:>8.:>(Y)m~(Y} bb(!?(Y}80<t>Q 0.:>8(Y}o.:>6o~ oj6.:> 0.:>5Ro5oo.:> 0o(Y}(Y)0o J~cgo.:>oso~ob 8o8.:>(Y)m

bobb~obb.:>b.:>8.:><Y>m~oo<Y>oso wo36ob oo\79300ob m.:>(Y}o.:><t>o (o-1; b.<z3. 23).

4.1.5. moo~obob b.:>j.:>~.)rl(Y} b.:>b.:>8.'>(Y)(J)<!:?(Y}b 2015 V<!:?Ob 15 o.:>6s(Y)ob \)o6.:>b.:>b.'>8.)(Y}(J)~(Y}

bbcg(Y}8.:><t>o 8o~oo~~o 006Ro6oo0 b.:>j0(Y)mso~(Y}b 8m030Mo 0(Y)(Y}J~M00~Mob 8oo(Y)

0~b.:>Bos(Y)cg,:, moo~obob b.:>.:>-1[)~.'>(30("} b.:>b.:>8.:>(Y)m~(Y}b b.:>0.:>8(Y}dO[)O(Y} J(Y}~[)00.:>oo.

(J)QO~OUOU b.:>-:>.3[)~0(30("} U0U08.)(Y}(J)~(Y}b b.:>008(Y}d0[)0("} J(Y}~[)(>OOU 2015 \)~ob 23 0063M0U

006Ro6ooom (b0j8o NQ10-71) b0Ro30(Y)o ,:,(') Q?0J808("}£30~Q?.:> oa b.:><z3~d3~om, M(Y}8 ()(Y).)~<:QO~ob 8b0<Y>ob 8oo<Y> \).:>(')8("}(;!?0b5o~o cg.:> b.:>b.:>8.:>(Y)m~(Y}b 006Ro6ooom b.:>j8ob ,:,(Y)booom

· · 0.:>5bo~s.:><t>o w.sasoo~~ 8oJoooo~~oo.:>m.:> o(Y)m(Y}o~o(Y}o.:> .:>aa.:>(Y).:>cg ,:,(Y).:>b.:>J8.:>(Y)obo o8("} CJ:!.'> .:>~o.)m(Y}oob 80~0~0 b0~obbom ,:,(') od~[)(Y}(J:!.'> b.:><z3~d30~b 3.'>M.'>~(J:!Obmsob, (')("}8 ~o(Y}(Y)0o 3~cgo.:>a3o~8.:> B0owo6.:> 0.:>5<t>(Y).:>bo CJ2015.~cb~~o (o-1; b.£3.24-25).

4.1.6. 2014 \)~ob 12 Q?DJ'[}8o(Y)ob b00Q?3MJ.:>6M 8("}8b.:>b~(Y)O()ob bo~'aOJ(Y)~~Ooob m.:>60b8.:>cg, · 0o(Y}(Y)0o J~<Qo.:>a3o~8.:> .:>Q?S(Y}J-:>6 <;.t>.:>som J30J.:>5oo(Y).:>dob b.:>ws(Y)J.:>o(Y) 8M8\}0b~(Y)ooobmsob 3("}5(Y}(Y),:,(:}ob b.:>b~m 0.:>w.:>ob.:>w.:> 1180 ~,:,(Y)o <o-1; b.C(3. 26-29; b.C(3. 31; b.<z3. 30).

4.1.7. (>O(Y}M(>O •. J~CJ:!0.'>030~b 2014 \)~ob 16 CQ[)J[)8o(Y)ob 0.:>6(3b0Q?[)OOb b.:>C(3~d3[)~'b[) ,;06<(3MM8.:>(3oob . m.'>30b~<z3~0oob 0.:>6som.:>(Y)ooob o~booo~oob" <:g.:>8<(3~d5ooo~m.:>

0.:>Q?0V83Doo~o~om 2014 \)~ob 20 o.:>6s(Y).:>8cgo oo~RQ(Y)<:g.:> <:go(Y)ojo(Y}(Y)ob . .

~<B~oo.:>8~bo~oo.:> <o-1; b.<z3. 24-25).

4.1.8. 2014 \)~ob 17 WDJQ8o[j(Y)b b.:>j.:>(Y)mso~(Y}b oo5.:>0.:>5 b.:>j8om.:> b.:>8o5obo(Y)(Y)8 0.:>.:>3MGO~.:>

0.:>5ob.:>cgoo.:>, M(Y}8~ob 8obbwsom.:>o 0o(Y}(Y)0o a~wo.:>oso~o 2014 \)~ob 12 wmoooo(Y)b CJ:!.:>.:>j.:>sob b.:>j.:>Mmso~(Y}b bobb~ob b.:>8.:>Mm~ob J("}wodbob 236-o 8<;Jb~ob 8[)(Y)M[) 5.:>\)o~ob oob.:>o.:>8ob~cg Gocb~b.:>bM(Y}~O o,:,(Y),:,~ob 8.:>Mm<!:?b.:>\)o6.:>.:>~8woo(Y} 6.:>Mooob OM.:>~cgooom (6-1; b.£3. 35-37).

b:,8:,(1)m~o~Moso w:,b:,~~mo~:,:

4.2.1. b.:>.:>3o~.:>GO(Y} b.:>b.:>8.:>(Y)m<!:?(Y} o'bo.:>Moob 0o(Y)so~o o5bo.:>5ooob b.:>b.:>8.:>(Y)m~("}b

CJ:!.'>bJs5oob b.:>j8ob b.:>8.:>(Y)m~ooM03 b.:>JOmboom.:>6 Q?.'>J.'>300M[)OO(J), 8oog5osb, M(Y}8 .30M30~0 o5bo.:>6coob b.:>b.:>8.:>Mm~(Y}8 b.:>8.:>(Y)m~oo(Y)oso ms.:>~b,:,'b(Y)obom b\)(Y}M.'>Q? oo.:>C(3.:>b.:> b.:>j8obm.:>5 <:g.:>J<'>sooMo~~~o c:z3.:>do(Y}oMo3o 0.:>M[)B(Y}ooooo; m.:>sob 8b(Y)o3, .:>.3o~.:>5ooo8.:> b.:>.:>-1o~<'>GO(Y} b.:>Ros.:>Moo 3D(') 0.:><'>j.:>M\78~0b .3oM3Q~o o5bo.:>6ooob b.:>b.:>8.:>(Y)m~(Y}b 8oo(Y) 0.:>Jomoo'<J~O b.:>8.:>Mm~ooMoso cg.:>bJs5ooo, 30(') 8o<;Jmomob <:g.:> 30(') \).:>(Y)8(Y}.:><:g0o5ob obomo .:>(Y)0<;J8o5oooo, (i)(Y}8~oo<t>o CJ2.'>8MQ?5(Y}oom.:>c aob.:>d~ooo~o oj5oo(Y}<:g.'> b.:>j8o'bo <:Q.'><:Q005o~o . <z3.:>doooob

13

I

II

1.(") .......

9l

~~Gwo oes~w~C8mCqg W~CO<.Y~e~~~~ ~~~o<_Y8W(b~~g~g ~og~O(b O<_Y~UA>~<_Ywg ·cooq~~ ~oQC<.Y~~W(b~g~ ogc;-o~co<.Y~e~~ ~m o~~<_Y8ogwg ~~Cmq ~C;Y8W(b~~g~g ~oQwUA>~8wg ~og~O(b O<_Y~~~<_YWH g~mo<_Yqg ~W~CO<.Y~e~~~~ oes8C8qcogCe, ~~QC<jf'gwr ~C8wR gw<_Y ·~8Cg~oog ~m cooQC<_Yoe,8~r~m g~co~~~wgCmw ~oo8~~gC£gwf' ~~o8o(bW£ ~oQGwg~g<_Yw o~~o8~C;YQ~ogogm~ ~QC<_Y~O(bO~g 0C8 w~co<_Y~H~~~~ wo8~~G£~~~ -~~GC;Y~~W(b~g~

~og~O(b o8o<_Y~CgwP~<.Y~ ~wRo o~og8wqcowg coog(bog ~oo8~QoQ~GC;Y ~o~G~G~S,~ o~ofbwR~Gq ~~~W~QC~(?~~Ge, ~~we,wg<_Y~~ C(b~C8(?~fb~~ ~oUA>q~g oUA>~ge,ogw~gG(b 8~0

·~~GC;YQ~ ·~~8q~~Ce, ~oo8<:Q~£G<.Y <:m c;-~o~G~<_Yow ·~~Gm8g<:g <_Y~oQ<:gGg ~8G8~o ~o8co~G8wR ~~GgCRwg~g ~o~CQGO(?~ogww ~ocoG8Pw~ co<_Y<:gog ~og '<:gG8og oe,<:~wUA>QGgg~oq~~<:£ ~o<_YO£ '<:g8Cm o8o<_Y~C~co<_Y~g~~~o~q~oq gw<_Y ·~8Gg~oog wUA>coC;Y~g~~~~ wo8~~G£<:~~

·~QG~~q<:~wg<:g <:m ~o8<:Q~£G<.Y og~ogpc;-~ '<:~w~~Gq~Ge,UA>Gq OOO<;'(_YO£ 'c;-QGw~g~mo<:~ ~OQG<_Y8wq8 om<:<_YO£ ·~~G~<_YOW 'o8oQ~£ 'oUA>Gq~~

~o<_Yo£ c;-~Cg8co~f'Cog ~GcoGPo~ ~~8<:m coo~q~g o~~QGcoocoog !<:~G<.Y~~W(b~g~ ~og~o(b

o<_Y~~<:<_Ywg ~w8wqcoowg ~8P<: <:~G~fb~ ~<.YO£ ~w<_Ym . ~ofbwH~Gq ~o~gw~ ·~~G~8(?~f6~~ go ~8<:<_Y8w(b<:~gc;-g. o~q~g 8I -Gg ~o~pGmwr wp<;>~<:Pwe~~ ·cooos~ ~o~G<.Y~~w(b<:g<: og<:o~co~c;-gc;-~ <:m o~~~8ogwg 'oe,c;-8G8qcogCe, ~~~8w(b<:~g~<J m~Q~~(b roogwg~P mw~wqg ~Cgpo ~og8wqcowg ~QG~(?oGe, ~QC<_Y~<:w~~g<: om<:~Q;fb "qo8co<:~o,g<:o(b o8o<_Y~Ggwp<:C;Y<: 'mc;-~og<:Q~~Ce, ~o~o~c;-g o~G8~o£ ~o~q~g C'"£It ~o~pGmwr wp~(;;)~pwg~~ qw~G8co<_Y<:P<:q

·~o8co<:qo8C<_Yc;-~ o~~~CQ~~f~m<:g <:m;gc;-o~GQG~co<_Yc;-g~<:g oe,~G~G(;;)fb~ qog 'g<:mo<_Yqg qwfbo~g~Cq<:q <:o8~~gG£gwf' oqog~Q~qGe, qG8Gog ~rug~ '(~g8Gm o8o<_YQG~ro~<:g~qqoUA>qqoq ·. c;-mR~Ge, 'oe,<:8G8qQgCe, ~~QC<_Yf'gwf') ogGH<:gc;-g o~G~G(;;)co0~e~g<:~ <:~m<:m 8~co<_Y~gog qo(;;)gw<_Y '~<.YO£ gw<_Y 'qo~8co ~m q~G~Gq~fbGe. 8o~QG(;;)co<j<;'g~q qwUA>co<j<:g<:q<:q ~oo8g<:Qqgo o~C8(_YO£ ~QG<_Y<:O(bO W~CO<_Y~g~~<;'~ wo8~UA>G£<:<:q qo~o(;;)OQCO 'oe,QG~tv(_YO£ coGq<:

'(£Z: ·fb·~ .. ! I -Q) <:mq~g o~C8(?~fb<:~ ~oQC~fb~~o8<;>coc;-<G g~moQG8<:f'~m o~og 8<:<_Y 'q~8G8w<:><:m ~ogwg<:f' <:mgwPE: o~ogm<: q<:~oQG8<:f'~m ~o~o8e,<:omUA>r og<_Ywog ew<.Y '<:cooco~og gwUA>co<_Y<:g<:q<:q oe,<:~GgoHg<:g UA>~~Gwog G(b<:~w<:co qo~Go(?~ogww qocoG8f'w<: ;8oQGg ·G(b<:~w<:co qoQG8R~Ge, ~og8Cm o8o<_Y~C~co<_Y<:g¢~<:~~o~qqoq . co<_Y~gog ~o~o8e,<:oro~r O~C;Ywog . <:QGgoHg<:g <:gpo ~og<:Qwg<:<rl G(bc;-gwmqq w~co<_Y<:g<:q<:~<:go~ <_YGog ~wcillco<_Y<:g<:~<:~ wP<:(;;)<:[!<:q qo~o~oQco ~<_Y<:8g<:o ~I qo~~ ~IOl gw<_Y ·~o~ogC<Gm<:m coo~G~<:~<:g ~ogp<:q 'oe,<:8G8qwgGe, UA>G8~oq~qg<:~ .

·coo~w~QG~oqco<_Yfb~~g oe,Gq~ g<: coo~GmGgp oq<:<_Y(bg<:g o~~Q<:qwg<:~ 'mwp<_YGf' 'o~<;><_Y~ oqog ~wRo <_Y<: G(bCq<:q g<:<_Yg<:g 'wgwg<:f'~ qwRo <:QGmGgp qoUA>~GgGRgog qog<:o(b

ew<.Y 'q<:~w~~G~(?<:qGe, qQG8e,CJ. <:g<_Ywg o~~ge,ogw<: 'm<:qog~Q<:qGe, ·m<:8<:mGqCJ.og qoUA><:C;YQ ( <:CO<_YO£ \)OQWQGmg<:g<:co ~WUD,CO<_Y<:g<:q<:q <;>ro <;'{\OQGwg<:g<_YW qo<_Y~Q<:C;Y~f'W~£ 'qoCJGopwg<:g)

<:co<_Yo£ qog<:Q<:~Ce, <:~Cm<_Y~~w(b~g<: og<:o(b gw<_Y '~QGwoco~og ~w<_Ym G8<:g<: <:ill ~<:CJGgGRwg<:g mwgwg<:f'~ ~o~o<_YG~UDGq ~OQWUDC~8~~<:g g<: ~o~w<_YgoQ<:£ cooq<:~ ~oQGO(?~ogww ~owG8f'w<: g<: 'q<:gC8og mwgwg<:f'~ Of?.<;'~cgqoq~q<:£ ~O~CO<_Y<;>g<;>~ ~oUA>q~o~ g<: q<:~Gm<j8<:X~g wgwg<:f'G <:mgwPE: o~oQm<: co<_Y<:gog ~o~o£ ~co· '<:~we,owg(_Y<:~ <:~GwgG(;Y<:~ o~GQG(;;)~QGm~<:8<:g

I.D

~

~

I.D

c EO

3. ~3o~~6oor>o 0~m~3obj<s~or>j~o ~(Y)o~6 b~bo~avo<s(Y) r>~vo o.)Q?.)bQ?ob 3~~Q?Dr>j~or>ob.)o.)6;

4. 0~6Ro6or>~ oooa~or>~ 0~b~Ro3(Y)Q?Ob h~J~b~eo(Y) b~Ro3(Y)om, b~d.)(Y)m3o~(Y)b j'bQ6.)obo b~b.)B.)M())~(Y)b ~Q?Bo6obo(Y)~(30j~ b~dBom~ 3.)~.)o~oo (d. mr>o~obo, dBor>o 'bjr>~~~o3o~or>ob d· N232), mr>o~obob b.)~oo~.)GO(Y) b.)b~a.)(Y)())~(Y)b .)Q?Bo6obo(Y).)GOj~ b.)dBom~ 3~~.)oob (d. mr>o~obo, 0(¥) . (Y)(Y)r>.)dodob 0.)8'b. N27.)) Boo3o(Y)r>om. b.),J0U.)(30(Y) b.)Ro3Mob ooo.)6ob 3~<;3?00 21 ((Y)GQ?~O(Y)mo) Q?~D · .)a 3.)Q?ob 0.)0(Y)dO~Dr>.) Q?.) .)~Q?o06.) Q?.)jo3or>o~o0. o0o ovsor>.) 8b.)(Y)ob.)m3ob 0~6Ro6or>ob .)U~ob o.)Q?0(3QBob a(Y)ao6ooQ?.)6.

0.)6Ro6or>ob o.)Q?.)GoBob BMBo66.)Q? om3~0r>.) Q?.)b0r>jmQr>j~o 0.)6Ro6or>ob .)U~ob 8b.)(Y)ob.)m3ob R.)~.)MD~~ jOj.)~(Y)Q? b.)b.)8.)(Y)ro~(Y)oo .)6 b.)d.)(Y)m3o~(Y)b b.)B(Y)d.)~.)d(Y)

b.)o(Y)(Y)eob(Y) J(Y)<:!?odbob 70-78-o Bjb~or>ob aob.)r>.)aob.)Q?;

18