15
13 神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13

Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

����������������Ì�Ì�Ì�Ì��F'ÎÏÐH���F'ÎÏÐH���F'ÎÏÐH���F'ÎÏÐH�� ����ÉÉÉÉ��%& �����#'�'�#'�!���(�!����"��!����)#���''�"�#������%& �����#'�'�#'�!���(�!����"��!����)#���''�"�#������%& �����#'�'�#'�!���(�!����"��!����)#���''�"�#������%& �����#'�'�#'�!���(�!����"��!����)#���''�"�#����ÊÊÊÊ ����

����

ÑÒ� Ó¤� � ÕÖ� ×Ø� � ÙÆ� ÚÛ� � ÜÒ� ÝÞ� � ßÒ� à �É�ánoâãG?���Ê ����

���� �������� [dy"[dy"[dy"[dy"��������� �ánoâãG?�+[(=!+"�>A>

A������"� 1>9:H�+���l

��GH �"HIkÌ�ÉJv�����Ì��!>[���GÌ��)2U8Ê"�&'ÏÐHKLMN�1e,>8�� (HO4�"�P&'QRH� 9:[¬H

)#N+D'8�� � ������ë�)ST�á��U�"�&'ÏÐ)��Hõ!��� � ���áV£{x@AST�á���yÍ'WXHÏÐ��� � ���áV£{x@AST�á���yÍ'WXHÏÐÉ�Ê��� � ���ST�á���yÍ'WXHÏÐ��� � �9 ���áV£{x@AST�á���yÍ'WXHÏÐÉ�Ê��� ��[�� ��"#2eWXHÎÏÐ�¡�KL1>8&Xg5�� ��HY+[Ì�ZHá6[\"�1e����H���{x�¤]

t"\^&'_�&`,W®ÎÏa�KL1e

2'8bc[á6[\"â&'Qd���)e

f)sE���{x))�"�gêZhil

"HI,jlkl@Am�n%o�xy>p4

3"�2e�¿ �¿HÏaqr)ê��sst1kKL1>8bu[á6[\"â&'���

oH{x"�2eH :�Hp43�KL1WXH(HvHhiH{xHwxHqeysÏa

Hõ!�z{1MU)&'�H+D'8b|[}

"Ì�"�~1>()"â&'���{x"

â1eÏ�1>Ïa��NRS>8�\1e�� ��"#2e��t"ÏÐ@A/��Hõ!"�2e�N!)yMN1>8�

� (=!+)bV��[�ánoâãG?�

H�+�6>��á6��)"1>�H+D'8

� �HY@A� ��ÙÆÚÛ� �Hc�ÑÒÓ¤bu�ÜÒÝÞb|�ÕÖ×Ø*;<1

ßÒà*� �H;<@A�1HBC�1>8������ �������� WXHÎÏÐsEWXHÎÏÐsEWXHÎÏÐsEWXHÎÏÐsE��������YYYY���� ����Ì�����Ì�����Ì�����Ì�ZHZHZHZHá6[ á6[ á6[ á6[ "�2eH"�2eH"�2eH"�2eH

�������"â&'ôl��H�\���"â&'ôl��H�\���"â&'ôl��H�\���"â&'ôl��H�\����ÉÉÉÉWϨ�WϨ�WϨ�WϨ� �������� �9�9�9�9���� ����i�Ci�Ci�Ci�C 9999���� ���� ����������������ÊÊÊÊ������ êYH�zêYH�zêYH�zêYH�z����É�Ê;�[¨� ��� ���"â1��H��^ñ��+ñ?��� =>)��1eô

l��"HIk����xy'hi���1

b� ���)H�+�* ;�"â1���ñ���U()X:�qr)&'hiRH��

�1>8�� ;� H^éT���[� "â&'�U;�H��H>y¨� �� � � �������É�  ����Jv�;��)2U8X# ;�) ;��Dg´e�;E�)2U8Ê"â1�¡eH¢£¤"P'¥¦$H�dH�§@A¥¦$¨ 

Hª©�ɦ�Êo"�2ei�¢£���aÉJ

v�4�)2U8Ê" �� GÌ��&'()�Q1d>8�� ;�[R¨HQd�ª})ly¨� ��� ��4 "â1R¨Hê«"�2e �� GÌ��1>*4[b� �9�(="â&'á6�[ 1>8�� \(+;E[�Z�~[\"MNlmR��� ='úû*¬� =>)��1e4"â1ôl��"HIk���{xhi���1>8�

13

神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13号

Page 2: Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

n�q¬�»�n¤¥¦¯»$% ��( �9* ��+K� 9§ ¨ ����qZ5;�!ëAÄÅbUn;�ÆLqV�� ;�Z5ÆL��2345���ë�b4546WÉ©Ç��_�Pïîï6O�e�!Ñ�

ëAÕ�bU�V�� ÆL�»�n¤¥¦y»$% �( �* ��+K� 9§ ¨ ��:�qZ5;��d345��Û[��éÇ!�FA0��TU789Ç65a!��!þ(R\]�ª-4ûñ�«A.×5xK!

�`!ñû�3h�»A,u4#Ue�k�_

T|5789Ç6p�©ÇA_�!6þ(KO�

�»�bUȾ�d345©Ç6ñ�ÐA�d`

»nPïîï6¬ÍST�`»q�d34Z��

Ò8�­_�`»KO��3h7#KO�V��

b45 J!g÷�b4 �®¯A� bU�V�� eT��b546[ï²³[ïé]b44AbUV��������� »l»l»l»l����n�q��éÇ!��Z57896é°b43�ÈÉAª]_�UL�ÊËRÈñ!Ì�6A_

�e�A ±�_�UL�ì-�TUç!KO

�Vab45��éÇAé-U�ïâºZ�²!³CZ5��R]¼6R3F?5©ÇSTUȾ

�d34PïA_7#ç!�^ST�!KO?5

�� éÇA_�e�6[\!�ïâºZ�²!³C!`÷�UQROPA²´bá�e�Rg

�[J5789� �� Ã! � Z5[\��!þ�R\]A,�UL�5©Ç�FA789Ç�,0

b5µ¶!789!b�6[\��!ól�©�

b4þ(KO�ksk!»�A�é789Ç�

��43�ç!KO�Vah_��5789Ç6

�� éÇ!�FA,0ST43�!Z·�fK��!þ�R\]A,�UL�_×R3!KO

u45��éÇ��_�PïAé-�e��d34789Ç6�Û[Ò8ST�`»A�_�ç

!�Z^STR3V�� bU6u45��éÇ��_�PïA!"_�Ís65��éÇAbU789Ç!�Û[Ò8ST�`»A¸÷_�ç!�b4�é789Ç�

�_�-�ÍsA¹%_�e�ZR3�3h7

#KO�V�

n�q���ëKO�PïîïÑ�ë�d34Z5º��]A»�S²�ÊË6O�k�5W

ÉA5��Ib¼_e��_�V��������� ijijijij����n�qW»�!½E�b4!�çUËR2îZ5��éÇ�!�í!s�d345789Ç65ï�

Ru45g÷¾¿Ã«_��3he�6ó ��

sèSTU�3h�KO�n789Ç����í

îïÑ�!L��d34Z5Ib¼bU!JK�

ü!» ȾZR3VqV�n�q�{5�í!s��_�g÷¾¿Ã«Z5:;<ºZa!÷]Õ789nop�:;<6��

3hVq65ï�R�e�6LkuUV789Ç6

5ï�RuUEZW»�!ÈFbkR3�3�

T�Vbkb5pÀ��2345:;<6���

g÷¾¿Ã«Z���g6ÄÅST43UV;�Z5e!�hR°»E!ÁªAYkb45p�5ï�

R�QAÂ���ÃST�V�� çu�ç5789Ç�5��éÇ!�íAá�e��d34�Û[Ò8ST�`»6O��_

�Ä�ZaLR�KZ�´RkuU�hKO?5

[\`»Asè_�Ä�6ÅÆ�LÇKOuU

nÈ�ÉÊìd% ��9:¨ �9��V°»EKZ5­®y»$% ��( �* ��+»R ��9�¨ ���65ËX�234ÌèbUVqVWÉ!5»��r�S

T5î»�!Ìè�AÍ�_�3^�b4Z5Î

�ϸ;� �9�¨ ���op5��0�ÐÊû÷$W<� ��¨ ��6O�V�WÉ! ��»�Z5789Ç��Û[Ò8ST�`»6O�kghk�ZrTæ�5-�Ís!

ËÉ�b4!v�6R3�3h]¼KëAÄ

ÅbUVÎM55�»�Z5789Ç��Û[Ò

8ST�`»A��k��LUVbkb5���

�5W»���u45789Ç!�Û[Ò8ST

�`»Z��k�sèST5e!©����Ñ

ÒZ-©õ�RuUV�n�qW»�!àX�d345X]ÊÓ�Rç!KZR3�3h3^çO�n��0�ÐÊ$% �(�U»^ ��qVU5]X��Y�T|5�»¸÷!à��b4!g÷�b4MAÚµK#�

k�3h�6�b�5à�Z J!g÷�3��

kR3�ST43�nÎ�Ê`� �9 �qVa!2

14

神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13号

Page 3: Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

eKZ5kR?ÔÕ�R¹%KOuU�3h3M

AST�kçbTR3�VW»�AÖa_�Ö×R

]¼,-633b��3@KZ5789Ç��

�g÷¾¿�×�_�!Z�b3!6ñ+��

CT�V�R25a!�k!ÑÒM�5ab4�í!s!

ØÙ�O� ��éÇ!���Rst�d34Z5� ��234Xæ�V�

�ÚÚÚÚ���� 789Ç©Ç�í!s��b4ÍÄÈ789Ç©Ç�í!s��b4ÍÄÈ789Ç©Ç�í!s��b4ÍÄÈ789Ç©Ç�í!s��b4ÍÄÈ

ÉLM�[!W�Ñ�²³îï,-6AÃÉLM�[!W�Ñ�²³îï,-6AÃÉLM�[!W�Ñ�²³îï,-6AÃÉLM�[!W�Ñ�²³îï,-6AÃ

«bUe©�«bUe©�«bUe©�«bUe©�����

�������� Z�L�Z�L�Z�L�Z�L��

$ØÛ�!789Ç©ÇA«LU789 ;� �:;< ;� 6�íA!sST5W�Ñ��îï,-A«L�ÍÄLM�-�Ís���g÷¾¿

ëAbU�e+5�5���çW�Ñ�!L�AÅpbU65g÷¾¿�d34 ��Z�L5��Z789!ëAÄÅbUÈEKO�Vn��� Üݯ»$% ��( �* �9+;� ��¨ �:��5¸�� ¤¥¦y»$% �� ( * +;� ��¨ ����qV�¸̧̧̧���� ÈF!´Ë���ÈF!´Ë���ÈF!´Ë���ÈF!´Ë�������

n�qÞ�!ßn<qZ$% �9 ( �* �� +àáâKâã(�äAé-5yÖåáôÓ�Ñ~æ

âAË_�Oò�R?5àáâ!åçZî+èÝ

�R :9×é �êë�!æâA bUV�n�q4nÜÝ@ÛqZ5ÜÝì�ì!$ØÛKO�65�"ËÃAé-UVÑ~ÍZ5èÝ �9 R�� ×é5àáâK < AíîS²5yÖåáôÓæâ���5èÝ ��R �9×é5�êëyÖÑ~V�]©�ïðb5<ZîV�]©KÑáãäSTî* �9+è` 9R ��×éñòbUV�n�q;�Z5;�k� <ñò�Ó_�åá�È<!��ó°�s6!Ì��d#�°Aé-5$%

�� ( � * +5WÉÑ~)"�d#ôõö789Çnop�789Ç��3hVq��b789Ç

©Ç!b�Ab5î789ÇZWÉ©ÇAbUV

©ÇȾZ5�÷õRø5Èù´Ë5û�ïðRø5

û���Rø65� åáôÓÂèú¸��5

îôÓïðRø5îôÓZ :dR!��ç{M!�êë�æâbU/û¸]¼!�ó5ü/vR=

�×ýb5�Ek�Ek5a!�±5þ]¼�5K

O�V�

n:q4Z$% ��( �* �+,-�íðKWÉ©ÇA!sbUn� ��íqV� åáôÓÂè!ú¸���d34Z�yÖÑá�áV�]©6!

�©·�©ìA±©���íb5a!ÎZ�µÕ

�Ó_�+PK�a�K#R3��íbUVfU5

�ZÐöKÜÝöµÕ+PÒ8ÃEnop�ÃE�

�3hVq�:Ã!+P� ��ç� bUV�n�q789ÇZ5$% ��( * �+54�5�íZ�w�����±KµÕ+P!�£<a�

�F!��ȼ�R�5WÉ©ÇZÑ~æâ½!

êëKßAò�bU6åáÈùg÷¾¿Ã«

AÍh�UËR��Èñ!+PAá�ULK5W

ÉÑ~)"��ÑR+PA�d!Z 4 !JK÷üZR�5�éµÕ+P!�µÕ�Zñòb

��!ZWÕ�î K#�6WÉ©Ç!ÊË

и.�ÐA�ób5�íA«L��õðAâ,

bUV�

n�q4Z5a!Ý5î( * ��+,-�íðK©Ç�íA!sbUn� � �íqV� � �í!ËlZ5WÉ©ÇZ5åáÈùg÷¾¿Ã«Þ�K

y�����ñ�3!�»Þ�KR3b5�w�

���ç!�b4ÃE �9 ÃKÒ�µÕ+P!�Îa�!��6��STR35fUWÉ©Ço�

�ÃE �: Ã!Ò�µÕ+P� ë6©õ��íb5©ÇȾ���-�í�_�ç!KOuUV�

nqaeK5;�Z5$% ��( * :+5ÍÄÈÉLM�nop�ÍL���3hVq:ò³ �Ã! ���?5� ��í!W�Ñ��ÍL� �Ã� ¾ � ¨²³ � Ã! �KWÉ©Ç�í!îï,-A«L5x�¾¿� �à �¾K ;�����6� ® ���9 ¯²³ ;� �WÉLM�Í!�ð´%W]6 �®¯���g÷;AëbaLbUVR254Z5��7X�àRfK©Ç�Z-�íK5Ñ~)"\¢�A� bRkuUV�

nqWÉ!��Z5c�í!sW�Ñ�L�!þ�Ð5l�í!îï,-!L�!þ�Ð5�

�í!sZ-�Ísk5g÷Ó5KO�V�

8888���� ��»�!Ël��»�!Ël��»�!Ël��»�!Ël����

n�q��c�d34�789Ç©Ç��Z5789Ç6789k�!

15

神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13号

Page 4: Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

b�K�ïâ>�²!³C�©ÇbÊËȾ!

PïA«L���K²�³Cç©Ç!.M�

K#5�ïâ>��³C�789Ç©ÇbU�±

ç©Ç<>©Çb�<�X©Ç<�6��[!

�ÛÓÔ�4d�Z�L�TR3k�5� :Ã!���[!�ÛÓÔ��é�²æ5W�Ñ�!L

��Ñ�!`»ZR�-þ�KO�VfUW�Ñ

�!L�Zx�¾¿� �à �¾!g÷¾¿Ã«o[���^����¸þ(�3�æÑ�!`»6

R�-þ�KO�V�

n�q��l�d34�789Ç©ÇZ²�³C�çRST��w��

�#5ÍÄ�!¨¸�©6p���bM�k!`

»A,0_�ª×A«L�ÍsK5�éÍs��

b4ÍÄ�6`íA_7#�ST4�nÍÄ

� �à �¨q2�æ5�bÃ�nî� �à �¾ �¨5� �Ã! �q�é�bR3V�u45�íîï,-!L�ç-þ�KO�V�

n�q����d34�� 789Ç©Ç��Z5789!#á�[J5é

°ÈÉ!ª]�ÊËRÈñÌ�>��!�3�

�A ±�b5�éÈÉ!þ�^���_�Þ�

Kì-�T5e!ólk�©ÇAé-U�ïâ6

Z5p�!�ï�ÍÍoºZ©Ç�í!�$�`

»���Ò8�»6O��±A�#©Ç�!P

ïîïAw35aTZ��îï�ST43�V7

89>:;<Z�ïâ6��íA«L��`A

�bR36î��K+PAá4p�!�`ñû

>��`»A�é_�6CZ789>:;<K

O�V�u4X©Ç<6©Ç�í¸PïA��R

]¼R��?789!Hï�Í`»>:;<!

°»Aé-��`A¸÷_T|g÷¾¿ó°6

���V�

ñ� ÷��!�<�� ë��ZK6�Kþ�RÍÄ\ !Ñ

Ò6Þ�KO?5789Ç©Ç��Z���!A

dh789�é°µYÈÉ!L�ao>��ª

]!+P��üA0��y���!Ç�6Þ

�KO?5"<Z��ólA��b5©Ç��!

[\UËÐk�+P� ��!�<��?Fè

ST�e�ZR3V�

ø� «23!©ÇȾ!6;�

±��íK#R323>»�A«L�©Ç

ȾZ-þ�Vbkb5WÉÑ~)"!÷õRø

6Z5��!� ¸5þAsh� ±�#J�T5

$$�RÑ~Í!%"R=6��!� �5þ

ç»�Z ±KO�V�

"� +P� !WÕk�g÷¾¿ó°Õ²!&

T�

WÉZ�éµÕ+P!6C < Zñòb < !! ;�6<ñò5þ�d#g÷¾¿Ã«!UL�°bU789 ;� !b�KRSTU!KO�k�4!6;Z`aAc��b4']²æV�'� ;�6«LU+PZ5<!ñò5þ�d#g÷¾¿ó°Õ²!KÈLMao!�5þ(R.

MAÂYbó°5þA�è_�UL�-©cK5

WÉ©Ço�KÑñkd�;Ð!y3+P!�

áZÈ�V�í!sK ;� !y���K��^�Aþ(�ñû_�`»� ;� !:;<!ULÈïª]A¯(��Í_�`»6)*�TUV�

4!��ôÓ!Iä,-a!ÎÈ+K4ZWÉ�í!s6 ; �!�Û[Ò8ST�`»A¸÷_�e�!�u©õÐ6O��b4v�A�L

�V�g÷Ó�d34Z57X!�ólk�5;��d# �® ���9¯5;��d#5�®¯V�ÚÚÚÚ���� �����»�!Ël�»�!Ël�»�!Ël�»�!Ël�

Ñ~)"!/vR=� ;�!g÷K ���Y!»�AbUV�Ñ~)"!/vR=�d34Z5©Ç�!�í

���îï6O�e�A+f�4789�78

9ÇZ©Ç� !Ⱦ�è>�íÈ�R236

A«L43R3k6!jk6ÊË�b5�í!s

6��kZeT��d34ijAË_�bUVÑ

~)"!/vR=Z5Q,!-.Ol6K%"R

=6�R�6Ñ~)"!/0¸»�Z ±�K#

æ5©ÇȾZYsVbkb5$$�RR=Z�

í6 ±K-�í���]¼Rb�bUV;� !g÷Z5LO5��ð�6�ð´%W]Kg÷�

�LR3V�

9999���� ijijijij����

4!789Ç©Ç���! ]^�Z1kST�VWÉ©ÇȾ�í6g÷¾¿Ã«LM�-©

cK÷-©KO�e�A]^²æ5ÃEK�

16

神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13号

Page 5: Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

ë©R�©Ç!s©�!23ç-�KO�V�

� ÎM55ï��b4ç5�5� �» !�h�5ÍL�����W�Ñ�5îï,-A«L�!Z

]6OuUkçbTR3VfU5;�!ë_�g÷Z5LO5��ð�6!´%WKLMW]K

O? ;�!g÷KZR3kVIb+ ;�!g÷Z5åáv0g÷¾¿Ã«LM�-©cRXï!Â

2>ó°5þ�è�ÊËR+P6Xï!�í!

sK�T5:;<�!�;ÓÔAg�U���K

O��Y��V�

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����3333���� 789Ç©Ç789Ç©Ç789Ç©Ç789Ç©Ç�!Pï�!Pï�!Pï�!Pï!"!"!"!"!e©�!e©�!e©�!e©�����

kk�kk�kk�kk�a!Î!°»a!Î!°»a!Î!°»a!Î!°»EEEE������������ ­®y»$%­®y»$%­®y»$%­®y»$% ��������(((( **** ����+;�+;�+;�+;� ���������������� ¨̈̈̈ ����������������

n�qÈF!´Ë�WÉZ5$î.Õ!¬ÕKO� ;nX.ÕZò �q65op!ëAbUÈFKO�V�ñ� ò �¸Xï4Ín4q�!=K5;>6758��9�Ó_�:;nWÉ5;6:;q6<àS

T5WÉ5;6:;6ò �!�`��=Ýç546wh�Å/v� îïZ$>²æ5;Z:;�=Ý�� A«L�e�!K#�ò � !¯IA.��??@bUV;6a!¯I���#�Å/v!� A«L�6!ënWÉ� ëqV�ø� ; 65÷]Õ789A��4789� �� Ã! �����©ÇnWÉ©Çq��u4ÍuU�Å/v� ë�d34 46!"bUe�nWÉ� !sqZW�KO��6;b456ï-¬Í

ºZ-�Ís���#5; :®¯!ÍùënWÉg÷¾¿Ã«qV�n�q��»�n­®¯»$% ��( �* ��+;� ���:¨ ����q!Ël�ñ!WÉ� ë�d34Z55;6:;^;

Ý!�Å/v� îïZ �(AF���_��bnAÈ6�! �(!$>R�AYkq5��7X�àR�KWÉ5;6:;^;!+k� �(A/vb43�e�k�5ëAÄÅbUV�ø!WÉg÷¾¿Ã«�d34Z5WÉ� !

sZ5;!WÉ� ë��@nWÉ5;6:;^;!+k� �(A/v_�o`q�ÍCTUe�k�-�ÍsA¹%_��b5; � ® 999

¯²³AÈ�è`ô!!±�����g÷;!

F�K� b5a!B!WÉg÷¾¿Ã«AÄÅ

bUV�n�qWÉ»�!»lnWÉg÷¾¿Ã«�Ó_�Î×qn5»��$bVëÄÅVq�789Ç©Ç��Z5a!©ÇAé-U.M

65��R]¼6R3F?5PïAÍhîïAw

he�A5a!� �íI��KO�65.M

6whîïZ5O�fK��R��[!îïKO

?5©ÇAé-U.M65�é©Ç�Ô�ÈÉ

�È<��_�ÓÔK5²�[5PïAÍh7#

îïAwhç!KZR3V²�[!Ú�k�Z5

;654��b5ò ��Ô��Å/v!� A«L��`A�_��Z�L�TR3V�� àX�b45WÉ� !sZ56ï-¬Í�Z

�U�æ5aT65;!�`ºZ�Û[Ò8STU`»A¸÷bU�3he�çK#æ5-�Ís

�Z�U�æ5WÉg÷¾¿Ã«�Z]¼6R3

�»�bUV�¸̧̧̧���� CDyCDyCDyCDy»»»»$%$%$%$% �������� (((( ���� **** �9�9�9�9 +;A+;A+;A+;A �::9�::9�::9�::9 ¨̈̈̈::::�������� ����n�qÈF!´Ë�

4n�xEFÒ}jÇVGÆÒ}ÈHAÍu43�Vq!ÍsnÝ\6�7!���!� q��?5;� 6KH�IJºZ J!g÷AXuUe�A6;b45��9®¯n��� �99®¯²³789W].�Ó �9 ®¯q!-�Ís����g÷¾¿Ã«bUÈFKO�n;� !LM÷]ÕKO�;�!ë�d34Z5zK_�VqV�LZop!�?KO�V�ñ� ;�Z5CD�M°»â��b5=�!NO²³���ëLMnYÉLMqAaobUV�ø� YÉLMÔP@�5;� k�é°bU ;�65= !QH�â��_�LOâãAÞ��5= 6#]b43�GRâ�<!Sâ5T¤6!Ⱦno

p�WÉȾ��3hVqAÌ�_�UL�54AU9½R3b©Ç½�_�°»â!Ì�U9nW

ÉÌ�U9q²³CDö789Ç��� �� éÇn�¬Ö©ÇqA«LU�e+546©ÇȾ��_��íR3bPïA!"bUV�"� ;�k� 4�5��éÇ��_�PïZ5WÕ!î2Aá�ÊË6R3e�A� bUV�

17

神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13号

Page 6: Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

'� YÉLMZ5;�¸==!°»[!V^n"<6NO_�e�5W6Þ���b4^�;�b4

:®¯!Íùîï6O�e�A�L5×!b4ÍùhlA� q6%4bUV�X� a!Ý5;� k� = ��b5��5WÉȾ�d# �� éÇn�RÖ©ÇVÞ�6W!QH½!Y06�AIJ��UL�WÉȾ!©Ç

Abb��e�6ó\VqAÍuU654Z©ÇȾ��_��íA!"bUV�n�q��� ��� ��� 46WÉÌ�U9²³WÉü©Ç��_��í²³PïA!"bUe�6Þ�!ÓÔKW�K

O�kskV��� ��� 4 !Ís��u4 ;� !�`ºZ�Û[Ò8ST�`»6¸÷STUkskV�nÎ!���d34ZzK_�Vq�n�q��»�nCD¯»$% ��( :* �+;A

�::9¨ :�q!»l�¬Î� V�RÖ©Ç�d#g÷¾¿Ã«A�

L�V�ñ� �� ��

4Z5CD�M°»â²³WÉ789Ç��b5WÉÌ�U9²³WÉü©Ç�`����[!

îïAwu43U�çkkC�æ5eT�W�b

Uç!�3CÉ�AáR3V�çu�ç54 Z ;� ���b4[\îïAwhç!KZR�546[\îï�W�bUk��3u45õm� ;���!ÓÔK 4!Ís6W��R�ç!KZR3V4 !Ís��u4 ;� �!�`ºZ�Û[Ò8ST�`»6¸÷STU�±

�eT6W��R�B¯6�����gf�V�ø� �� ��nñqWÉÌ�U9²³�¬Ö©Ç��È<Z5Ì�U9²³ �� éÇ��_��í²³Pï6ST�e�����Z�`»A�

é_�e�6K#��_×R3k�5�È<!�

`ºZ�Û[Ò8ST�`»6¸÷STUç!

�3he�6K#æ5W�KO��3he�ZK

#R3VWÉÌ�U9²³�¬Ö©Ç��_��

í²³Pï!!"��?5;� 6°»Aé-��

`A¸÷STUç!�3he�ZK#R3V�nøq�RÖ©Ç�d34�LMÈÉ�234%4bUV^Ìð�3h6

ï¤î��?ÍCT�N��Í��u4p�!

�`Añû_�`»Z�Û[Ò8ST�ç!�

3h7#KO?546�RÖ©Ç��_�PïA!"bUe���u45;� !�Û[Ò8ST�[\`»6¸÷STU�3h7#KO�V��45

4Z5µÕ+PÒ8�[5��éÇ��_�Pï�ZWÕ!î26ÊËKO��!0uU^[�

ç��34eTA!"bUe�5;� !6ï¤î[!�`6ñûSTR-T|5;� 66ï¤îA�ábU2e6�CT�e�çYk_��54![\ÍsZW�KO���L�!6.�KO�V�� 4Z5;�k�5��éÇ��_�PïZ5WÕ!î2Aá�ÊË6R3e�A� STUe

�5�RÖ©Ç�Ô�©Çb�ð�Z5;�6 =!QH½��_�Y06�AIbJS��UL�

WÉȾ�d34©ÇAbb��l6ó\ST5

4 6eT��_�PïA!"_��5;� 6[\IJ�Abb44�e�6K#R3e�A ±

��3K#U�3��e�k�_��54�v�6�L�T�V�o[A]¼�b45�RÖ©Ç��_�PïA

!"bUe�A]¼�b4;�®¯!g÷¾¿

ë�d34� bUV�n:qWÉ»�!»l�� 5»��$bVëÄÅV�op!]¼k�5� �� Î×AíL5; !ëA_74ÄÅbUV�ñ� �� �� � zK�ø� �� ��nñqÌ�U9²³ ��éÇZ53æTç5�ÑRÈñ����þ(R�ÛÈï6RST�e�

AÞ��_���R��KO?5�È<6eT�

��?+PAá�e����`»Z5[\Þ��

�T�ST5O�3Z[\Þ�6¬ÍST�e�

��?á�T��Z�`»KO?5�È<×�!

`»KZR3�^_�!6.�KO�VÌ�U9

²³ �� éÇAé-U<6eT�`����[!îï�W�bUUL��È<6[\�Z�`

»A�é_�e�6K#RkuU�b4ç5�È

18

神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13号

Page 7: Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

<!�`ºZ�Û[Ò8ST�`»6¸÷ST

Uç!�3he�ZK#R3V46WÉÌ�U9²³WÉü©Ç�d34�í²³PïA!"b

Ue�A]¼�_�5;! 4��_�g÷¾¿Ã«Z]¼6R3VnÎM5°»âZ54!�í!"�d#54!�í6AÍhîï6O�e�Asè_�ç!KZR�5Ib+ 4�2343>k�[\îïA¬Í_7#KO��N�,5bUVq�nøqeT��b5;Z5�Û[Ò8ST�`»A�_�lA6;_�65eT6']K#R3e

�Z[\!�2?KO�V�n"q5»�Z5N��Í��?p�!�`Añ

û_�`»Z�Û[Ò8ST�ç!�b45;!ëA¬Î� _�65[\�©�b.�KZR

3V5»�Z5WÉÌ�U9²³WÉ�¬Ö©Ç

�234 4 6�í²³PïAbRkuUe�A]¼�_� ; ! 4 ��_�g÷¾¿Ã«�d34Z5[\nñq�î\!]¼��?ÄÅbR6

�5�RÖ©Ç��_�PïA!"bUe�A]

¼�_�g÷¾¿Ã«�d34� bUe�Z5

]¼�]3W36O�V�8888���� ¤¥¦y»$%¤¥¦y»$%¤¥¦y»$%¤¥¦y»$% ��������(((( **** ��������+;A+;A+;A+;A �:�9�:�9�:�9�:�9 ¨̈̈̈

����������������n�qÈF!´Ë�ñ� WÉZ5789 ; 654n<� �©T¤^!ªçìë��©T�ÍÇäq��b5L� �!÷]Õ ;�b4ÍCTU789Ç©ÇnÝ\ønøq!WÉ©ÇȾq��b4 4ºZa!�HÆn<q6ÊËRȾAPïbRkuU!ZW�KO�

�6;b45K� 9�úZ ��Ã���#5g÷¾¿;; �: ®¯²³��g÷;!ÍùA«LUÈFKO�Vg÷!6R�_Z5Ý\ønøq

!789Ç©ÇW]5în'q!Ì�ÇäW]5

în'q!6�IJáwb44W]n� �!hm! ��×qKO�V�R25;Z5Ý\ønñqLM²³nXqLM! �LM÷]ÕKO?5WÉ©ÇȾ�Ó_�©Çë²³6�IJáwb44�2-� � !÷]ÕKO�V�ø� �LZop!�2?KO�V�nñq�nLM÷]Õ ;qZ5$% ��(5)n`��!/ 6AH�_�a�ÇäV�`�ª

�xA/ Vq��b4�bÒ�; �9 ®¯nop�WÉÒ�;��3hVq!cdA«L�LMA

¤¥¦¯°�aob5$% �� ( � *5) � �9®¯²³eT��_�( �u!!±���;Æ!ÍùAáæ�»�nop�YÉ»���3hVq6

53eSTUV$% �� ( � *5YÉ»���Í�6,0STUV�nøq;Z5ôõö789Ç��b5�k�6�IJáwb4ÈÉ!�°Aé-U789�b4 4��b54 �Í!�©Tx��T!¬dKO��<��©T�Z �!`��fìA�gh�b43�e�k�5a!e�A`a�p\c²³l

!Ⱦ�d34©Ç_��hbb�AÍ35î7

89ÇZ54��b789Ç©ÇAbUV�c���gh:;Ab43�!Z54KO�k5O�3Z <� �©T�©«!ÇäkV<��©T�©«!ÇäKOT|5a!Çä!

A¨�â<¯V�l��!�gh:;�d#54O�3Z <��©T�©«!Çä6<àb43�5.M

�È<!A¨�â<¯Vî�gh:;!<à

(*+V�n"q4 Z5$% �� ( � *5WÉ©ÇȾ�d345Pï!sAbUV;Z54��b5�iïð�Açu45Pï!sA�Y_��h«LU654Zjk�!B îïA]¼��í!sbUV�n'q� Z5Ì�Çä�!Ì�:;5�n4ÍD<��©T��Çäq>ÝV -��_� ��!6�IJáwb44AÍ35îáwpK�£6

ï<!lV+PA �²³ -k��ábUV�nXq`\n'q!+PAç��5�Z5)²³-AXï�b45m÷Ís�$LMAaobUVR25-Z5�!`��!\ Hï�Ób )k�HïAé9b43Ua�ÇäKO?5«ç©�

�©6! �!`]�;nªçìë��©TÍù×q!4ù;cdë��d3456�IJáwA

é-U65�£6ï<lVK )��_�n;cdë��!.oA]¼�7Ò2�Rb�lVb

43UVîLMZ5)6 ��^�; �9®¯Aå,_�6!� KLM[!V^�R?5�=bUV�"� ��»�n¤¥¦¯»$% �� ( � * +;A �:�9¨ ���qZ54� �! )��_�6�

19

神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13号

Page 8: Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

��)÷!�u6R�5a!�uçbáRkuU

e�6A]¼�b45;!�Û[!Ò8ST�`»A¸÷bUç!�/0_�e�ZK#R36

�b5ëAÄÅbUV�n�qWÉ»�!»l�ëÄÅV�789Ç©ÇAb�bU789Z5©Ç½³C

6©Ç�`�4789Ç�PïAbU�±�7

89Ç�a!� !� AëK#��_×æ5

©Ç½³C��b4PïAëK#���R�

`A�_�e�ZR3V©Ç½³C6©Çb�A

bU789��b4PïîïAwh�hRe�

çR3V�� ©Ç½³C65789Çk�!©Ç��b5�

�R]¼6R�PïîïA-¬ÍbU�±KO

u4ç5a!e�Z5�é©Çb�AbU789

�!ÓÔK5�é7896�_�5���¨ S

TUhiK5é°bUÈÉ!ª]�ÊËRÈñ!

Ì�²³��!��AÍh��`»AW��¸

÷_�e��ZR�R3V�465ôõö789Ç6 ;!b����34ÍuUWÉ©Ç��b45��R]¼R�5Pï

îïA-¬ÍbUe�Açu45Þ6789�

b4�_�ÈñÌ�²³����AÍh��`

»AW��¸÷bUç!�3he�ZK#æ5

Þ��_�-�ÍsA¹%_�ç!KZR3V�ÚÚÚÚ���� ­®¯»$%­®¯»$%­®¯»$%­®¯»$% ����(((( ����**** ::::+pÒìÛ©ß+pÒìÛ©ß+pÒìÛ©ß+pÒìÛ©ß

������������ ¨̈̈̈ ������������n�qÈF!´Ë�

;�65p"ÍA\p@5Èù��?wqbUe�A]¼�b45;� ²³îp"Í�îîb43U ;�65Ö! 4�k� 4���b5Ò};Íù²³g÷¾¿Ã«AÍuUÈFKO�V�

4�� � � ;� \p!Í"�d345�n;� !jr<q6Ò}:;A<àb43UÒ}Çä�

4�� ��÷Í"!\p<�4�� � � 4� Í"�d34Ò}:;A<àb43UÒ}Çä�

n�q;�!ë� n789Ç©Ç���Ó_�ç!o�ZzKq�

;� Z5îÕ!:;��?bb44U789Ç©Ç��b54� 6ù2fUZv���?�ñ�

�R��ín©Ç!�v�R�p"ÍÒ}:;Z

�<bR3�!�ñ��R�l!�íqAbU6

!]¼��?5;� ZW{-ËKO� � �Þ!©ÇABsR�STUe���?g÷AXuU�

b45-�Ís����g÷¾¿;AëbUV�n�qWÉ»�!»l�ëÄÅV�789� �� Ã! � !¹tk�_T|5²���!�È<6789Ç©Ç�Ô�PïAá�e

����`»Z5789Ç6©Ç��Aþ��\

]bUà��b4á�T�Èñ[!`»��g

f�V;� !WÉ©Ç�Ô�PïAá�`»6�Û[Ò8ST�`»��U��3he�ZK#

R3k�5©Ç½6O�4uv!�íAbU6!

�ü!È+6R3F?5-�ÍsZ%4bR3V

4� 65O�4uv!�íAbU�3uUÈ+A�L��w?���ZR3V�9999���� ijijijij���� �������� eeKxybUÚd!e©�KZ53æTç:

;<zb�Z789Ç©Ç!b�AbU÷]Õ

789k�!g÷¾¿Ã«�d345�Z�`»

Aé-�4��v×R36�b45n¬Î5�K

ëA� b43�ç!çíLqëAÄÅ_�

àX�Ru43�V���������{{{{���� 789Ç©Ç��íbUe����789Ç©Ç��íbUe����789Ç©Ç��íbUe����789Ç©Ç��íbUe����----

�Ís!%s6�Ís!%s6�Ís!%s6�Ís!%s6st�STUÈEst�STUÈEst�STUÈEst�STUÈE������������ Z�L�Z�L�Z�L�Z�L�����Q|y»$% ��( * �+»] �:9�¨ �:��nop�°»Ec��3hVq2�³®}¯»$

% ��( �* �+;� �9:¨ ��nop�°»El��3hVqZ5î¬!789Ç©Ç�Ó_

�Y!LM!°»EKO�V°»EcZ5©ÇA

é-4�íbU~]9��_�g÷¾¿Ã«�

d345°»ElZ5©ÇAÍuU789Ç��

_�g÷¾¿Ã«�d34»�bUV�op5�M!°»EK$�b43�5ÈF!´

ËAV7UÝ5ü°»E!´Ë�»lAV7�V�¸̧̧̧���� ÈF!´ËÈF!´ËÈF!´ËÈF!´Ë����

;Z5µÕK���È!ÃwAH�b43U<KO�65$% �� ( � *k�$% �� ( � *f

20

神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13号

Page 9: Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

K5ñ� �6÷B�<�AïL43U-".!�y5t�6AÞ��_�a�Çä )nop�)ä��3hq�<�b43UVnUb5)ä!ñ7�X©ß©Z �!ñ� �KOuUVq�fU5;Z5~]9KO� 4�5âá~!ÑèbïA:;b43UVR254 Z5a!Ý5<~]9�ÕAì4b5a!÷BäÆ�Q°b43�V�ÎMK5�6÷B�<�A�°bUÝ5)äZ5

� AXï�b45) äAb45$% �� ( : *o�5��ñò!R3 ;��b5Y0²³�0AÍYS²���ç�5;�Ô��èC`WAwdS²5) ä�g÷A��US²URg�6;b45g÷¾¿6A«L�LMnop�YÉLM��3

hVqAaobUV�YÉLMÔP@�5)ä!LM÷]ÕKO� �789Z5;�Q�ñò6RkuUe�A4�_�UL5�789!âP_�®}789Ç��b5< ~]9�ÕA©Ç½�b45; !õÌ �9 (×!Ñèbïð²³��è��!§b!â,6A

«L�� !789Ç©Ç!b�Ab5eTAé

-45®}789ÇZ5<~]9�Õ��b5a!l©ÇbUVeTAé-U <~]9�ÕZ5;!î2Aá�e�R�5®}789Ç��b5$

% ��(k�$% ��(fK!ÑèbïðÆ�²³��è��!ü§bnop�WÉÑèbïð6�

�3hVqA �<n(!J�Ka�bUnop�WÉ� Ís��3hqVR25$% ��(×ÑèbïðÆ���,STU��bï��ð�Z5�W

(@�2-��ZÈ+�!��5�$% ��(�Ób4Z5CÌ-�n�Jq!ULQ�_�e�6

�{RkuU��!\ê6O�V�8888���� Q|y»$%Q|y»$%Q|y»$%Q|y»$% �������� (((( **** ���� ++++»»»»]]]] �:9��:9��:9��:9� ¨̈̈̈�:��:��:��:���������n�q´Ë�

;Z54��b5WÉ� Ís6«�ø�(©�A¸÷_�-�Ís��U��6;b5���

:99®¯6!ÍùA«LUV�5�Z546bUWÉ� ÍsZ-�Ís�R�R3�b4 ; !ëAÄÅbU65W»�Z546WÉ� ÍsAÍuUe��d#v�6O��»�b54!-�Ísó°A�L55»�A�

ºb5g÷; �� ®¯�eT��_���g÷;!Íù3A«L�F�KëA� bUV�n�q»l�ñ� 789Ç©Ç��_��íîï�789Ç©ÇAé-U�ïâºZ�²!³C

Z5�é©Ç��?PïA«L�TUȾ�d3

45©ÇAbU789Ç��b45�Û[55F

�b4Pï_���RîïAwhV�bkb5©Ç��_�PïA!"_�e���

u4Ò8_7#�``»6�<b5Pï6á�T

R3e����-`»�©Ç�`�4Pï_�

e����-`»�Ar��¿b45Ý<!-`

»6����L�T��±�Z5��R]¼6O

�ç!�b45PïA!"K#�V�ø� ~]9� �Ã����B îï�789Ç©Ç��u4�~îï<!«�ø�

(©�Ó_�Ⱦ�d34PïA«L�TU�

±5��R]¼6O��#Z5PïA!"_7#

KO?5aT�çkkC�æ©Ç�`�4Pïb

U�#Z5~]9� � Ã!B îï�W�_��3h7#KO�Vab45~]96ù2ºZv

���?5B îï�W�b4�~îï<�Ó_

�+PA�£<�� bU�±�Z5�é�~î

ï<��b4-�Ísó°AwhV�"� WÉ� Ís!W�Ð�

;!EFOòA4�_�ULKOT|5åáôÓ6�!©Ç���!6õ�KO?5e!�Aã

��b4ç54!â�_�Ñèbïð6-KZ; 6$% �� (�CÌ-���?��6^�bUkghkA�è_�e�Z2�a-#K#R3

�3h7#KO�k�5789Ç©Ç�b4!Ê

ËÐ5.�ÐAc�-þ(Rç!�3CÉ�Aá

R3V�ÎM5Ñèbïð²³��è��!� Z5;WÕ!��Ó!�L!�k5 H)"! @�C

U�Ⱦ>��ÓÔ�Ó_�Ⱦ65«�ø�(

©�Ó_�ȾAL�íIç!KO?5WÉÑè

bïð6A� ST�e���� ; !-`»6WÉ©Ç�`�R3e����-`»A[��

e�6ó�kKO?5WÉ� ÍsZ5W�RÍ

s�3h7#KO�V�'� 4!ù2¸v��

21

神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13号

Page 10: Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

4Z5~]9�b45WÉ©ÇȾ6þ�KR3e�AÖ×�ubáUç!KO?5fU5WÉ

�234Z54Z5;!ÑèbïHï6!�k5)ä>a!ñ7�X©ß©KO���ç@PRÓÔ6O�Rg!È+6O?5WÉ©Ç��b45

¬ð!789Ç©Ç�rb4�?TU�ij_

7#KOuUV�4Z5WÉ� Ís6W�KO�e�A�ubáUç!KO?5ahKR3�b4ç5;!2ªAÑ�_�6bU[KWÉ©Ç�!�`A»�

_7#KOuU!KO?54Z5�R��ç ;!2ªAÑ�_�6_�e�çR�}±�WÉ©

Ç�`�4WÉ� ÍsAÍuUe��d#v

�6O?5-�Ís6%4_�V�ÚÚÚÚ���� ®}¯»$%®}¯»$%®}¯»$%®}¯»$% �������� (((( ���� **** ���� ++++;;;;���� �9:�9:�9:�9: ¨̈̈̈������������n�q´Ë�

;Z5®}789ÇAXï�b45î789Ç6�FAÀÁ¸Â]b4©ÇAbUà�5;çÓÔ_�LMK��a�STUe���? ; 6ÍùAá��T�|ô�S�ST�.�g÷6�

�b5fU5-�� ;!«�ø�(©�6¸÷ST5789²³789Ç��_��]¸�;ç 

(�T5KH�IJAXuU�b45�.�g÷

²³���6!ÍùA«LUV�eT��b5W»�Z5®}789Ç6bU7

89Ç©ÇZþ�KO��b4ëAÄÅbUV�n�q»l�©Ç½!`÷nµÕ+P!�±�Z5���R

`»!?P6CKO�µÕ!`÷!�±6O�q

�!`»�¿6K#�e�6YkSTU±]�

R��²³����Aç��5789Ç©Ç

A_�e�6þ�KO��»�b4RSTU7

89Ç©ÇZ5�ü!È+6R3F?5��[!

W�ÐA¡³�e�ZR3�^_�e�6K#

�V�®}789Ç!©ÇEF!� Z5�`!

ñû>�ñ�3¸��R»��3h789Ç©Ç

��!ól�GuUb�KO�e�A»�K#

�AEèb43��3he�6K#�VfU5

î789Ç!©Çb�!����!� Z5�C

�b45¹C��LRç!K5YkË¢�b4ç

K#�-v-wR��?[*�h�b5789

Ç©Ç!b�65�`!ñû>�ñ�3¸��R

»��3h789Ç©Ç��!ól�GuUç

!KO�e�A»�K#�ç!�Ru42?5©

ǽ!`÷�!`»�¿A_�e�çYkST

Uç!KO��^ST�V�WÉ©ÇZ5©ÇEF!èL����

Gu4RST5;!Ñèbïð6Z5;!µÕ+P�ÓC�ç!KO�65©Çb�!ÊËв³

.�Ð6O��3he�6K#5©Çb�!��

����uUç!�3he�6K#�V�bU6u45WÉ©ÇZþ�Rç!�3he�

6K#�V��������� �������� 789Ç©ÇAL/�789Ç©ÇAL/�789Ç©ÇAL/�789Ç©ÇAL/�°»°»°»°»E²³ÄE²³ÄE²³ÄE²³Ä� �� �� �� �

�!"ª�!"ª�!"ª�!"ª������������� Z�L�Z�L�Z�L�Z�L������ 789Ç©Ç�d34Z5��R]¼6R3F

?eT��í_�!6��[!îï�ST4#

UV� �� £KxybU�»$% � ( �9 * �+K� 9§ ¨ ����nop��(�»��3hVqZ5�y°�b4¤L4e!�AÑ�bU

�3h2î6O�n¥��¦Ê;��9�¨��qV�� ��éÇ�d345§y[Z�í!s!!±ZÊæbçy�R3�3h3^çO�6n¨�©

ó¸4� �¨ �q5¬è!±��b43�e�çÈñKO?5a!ñ�ÐÑÒZ5789Hï

�2-�UËR9t!¬dKO�V�� �í!s��b5û<5QYb4c�íîïÑ

�!L�5lg÷¾¿Ã«�3h �d!y��ÑÒ!©�6ªUST43�V5ï�R�!Z5

:;<5:;<!÷]Õ789nop5:;<²

³:;<!÷]Õ789Af�L4�:;<6�

�3hVq5789Ç6Y��T�n«�¬¸��

:�¨ �:��qV�(�»�234Z5789Ç65ï�Ru45g÷¾¿Ã«_��3he�6

ó ��sèSTUVbkb5�(�»A¬k?�5Î!5ïÂèR3bÑÒM�!©s�d3

4ç­²4ijb5Ï]b4JU3V�� �(�»KsèSTU5789Ç���g÷¾¿Ã«�d34Z5� �!£AÙ±©3U#U

22

神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13号

Page 11: Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

28¬"&¿"­1® =>����"M'

�~m�klHh�"�2e¯¨°+±`'8!

>��WÏ+[R6|é =Xs6>ef)o"M'���{xH²³ü"�2e¯¨�

+9d'8W¯"�1lRHno)1e�~

[\H�Ç}Xé´�"�2eH��y@AU�

RHnoµ�¶+±`'8�°°°°���� ����"M'�~m�klHh�"�2����"M'�~m�klHh�"�2����"M'�~m�klHh�"�2����"M'�~m�klHh�"�2

eeee����� (="�2eW·"{x�¸Å1> � �WÏH&¿+[Ï� =¹��WÏ+�­1® =>8\H>y(H­®¿+D'�º»®Ï¨

� ��� �� �9iÏ] ��:�� ���ÉJv�­®¿Ïa�)2U8Ê*·HÏ�)X6>8�É�Ê� klHh�Hªlü�klHh�)2�0¤]H�êhi"#2e

�!¹klHúû*no)X'8(Hµ"�2

e[­®¿HÏa¼H½¾+búû�ly'

¿�*d =e2>ÉÅƪÈîËÀÁÂ�9����ÃÕ˼� �ÄÅà¹ËÆáÏÐ���9ɪ�ÏÐ��>#�"�Ê����X:Ê8�­®¿Ïa�âÇÈÉHª\Ê]k^Hú

û@AylÈÉHª\�tË"MN1eklH

úû�ly>8����)Ì�ÌHÏ�*Í2j

6>),"Ì�ÌHÀh�Î�÷�1X*Eá

6m��¤Ït"Ï�&'Ðz*D'()��

�=0\Hªlü�\^&`,é´[X2ÉÑ

ÆÒËñl �9�� ���:Ê8!>��GÌ�"cdXke�ÎÏ�[Ó�À�v´X2)2U(

)"X'H[àEs"ô}+D'É­®¿Ïa[

�hiRH��"HIkÔÕ��WÏHef)�TÖX21\Hhi×�THÄúH�Ø�Ù')

2UÚlU�H�Ûü"�g'Ì�+D'sE

ss'ÜÝ"â&'ÚlÏ�*lyE=X2)

2UÞ9[ß})[� =X28�)&'Ê8�ศ� ��á�¯H¨� �9� ��� ��iR¨�º»®ÏHR6¿+W®Î[����H

á6m�klHh��âv1>8((+t9[d

ãX2*��+±`E=>)(ä"ÌE1n

oH-,2Ïa+DäU()�åæ1e#k8ç�É�ÊklHh�Hltè������[Véê1Hëì)��ê1Hëì

�í�&'8��GÌ�*�&'VûRHwîsE\H�~m�[VlRHm�) ='81s1

����"[\=��U&'Àï[X28�(HMU"VlHëì)ðlHëì*�ñ&

'()sEklHh�[òVlRH}ê)hi

É�gêZhil¶GÊXHsó¤]H�êh

iHÐ"M'`,s*no)X'8�(Hµ/�[ò)�&`,�HÉÑÆ˼�

ÃÕ˼� ��Ê)ó)�&`,�HÉôÕõ��öý/÷-/l/D �9 ø�¨ùú¬û^ZHüýþ����Ê"~s=,6�1e2>8­®¿[�����[�H��s�gQ�H�1)X

'lT+[X21����*��GÌ�"�1��VÄKH��HÄ��n =e2')[

2�¹�hlRHú�gþ"}>')[2�

X28!>��Ì�Ì* �� GÌ�"â&'á6�[ &'��[ê���+D6e�g�~

+X2��81>*6e���gQ�"#%'

ÜÝ)2�X28��úVlRHlm�P"�&'

klHh�þ"[�6hiH�^H¤D*�

='*���Z[���ZÌ�ê«"â&

'á6m�H�\�yÍ'hi+DNss'S

��1tXêY"#%'Ï�*xyE=e2'

êZ+D'sE�H�P��XNê1Hhi�

Ås(=E"â&'ÏaH��K�ly>N�

9�m���1>N&'é´[X21�Z+[

¾à�~HâÇ)X'ú�~�[Îaþ[��1

X28\U&')���gQ�H�"cd>

R¨�^��ZHhiÀh"� &'�ûsÐ

zü�¿2¦&()[+,X28�)1eó��

1>8(="�ìt"�b&'¿�)1eÅ

ƪÈîËÀÁÂ��9�� 9�*D'8�VlRH}ê)hi[�gêZ"#2e�

~ü��ù1"k2��HÜÝ"#2eª>X

hiH��£�&'�KX549+D'8)[2

�� �!¸"¿=0�êRHÜÝ+D'1

R¨­®¿H�U)#N"Xk)�hiÀh"

#2e�hlRHÃ#ê��ª &`,rì*

¿2¦1$28Vlðl%Ï9&1Ø�+['

(X�ù+[X2É)�*ú�glcÉ� �+,-+ÊþÉ�./�9��Ê�����ÌÊ8�1>*6e­®¿ÏaHÏx"��&'8�

23

神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13号

Page 12: Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

n�qR25:;<665c�789Ç��_�Pïîï!Ñ�A«L���3h¹%çO?á�V

­®¯»$% �: ( ��* ��+;� ���:¨ �9�Z5��[!�ÛÓÔ�Ó_�Ñ�!L��b

4eTA�LU65ÆL�!­®y»$% �� (:* ��+;� ��¨ ��:�Z5©Ç½6:;<6��b4õPPïîïAwCR3e�k��

È<þbAsèb5ÝV!�Z�`»X��?5

ÎÕ=!�ÛÓÔ�d34®RÑèA«L�`»

A�_��Z3�R3�b45eTAsèbU�V�Ä�[Z5:;<6�d34çPïîï!Ñ�

»���?Ò8_7#��`»A�L�ç!6

O�n«�¬Ê`� ��:�qV]X�RstçS�e�R6�5Pïîï!Ñ�ë6789Çbk

K#R3�_��5789Ç6LMA_�e�!

wdAgh_�k�3hñ�[!st6O?á

�Vbkb5fæZ789Ç���Pïîï!Ñ

�ë6¨ST�e�AÑ4S²U[K5Ö!9

t�b4ijST�7#KO�V�8888���� :;<6���g÷¾¿Ã«�d34:;<6���g÷¾¿Ã«�d34:;<6���g÷¾¿Ã«�d34:;<6���g÷¾¿Ã«�d34����

�(�»!ÈFZ55ï�b45:;<WÕç�Cu43UVbkb5��5���ç5]¼ZWh6ëZÄÅbU�V:;<WÕn!.Õq�

��[ï6ZÄÅSTUUL5:;<6!`»¸

÷�d345�(�»Z¹C�R»�Ab43R3Va!UL5e!st�d34Z5R2^[X

�b4�36Q�V�n�q�{5pÀ�K�CT43U�í!s�Ó_�:;<6k�!g÷¾¿Ã«Z5Q¯6�L�

T4eRkuUVa!]¼Z5��éÇ!��6:;<!`»A°8_�UL!ç!KZR�5:

;<!þ(R�`Ò8Aé-�`»¸789!þ

��ÈÉAª]_�`»Z5�Z��`R3bÈ

ñ[!`»�_×R3�3hç!KO�nUb5

¾¿Ã«ZÄÅbUç!!5ËX�b453>k

�Pï_��hO�4,5bU°»EçO�V`

\­®y»$% �� ( � * �� +»R ��9� ¨ ���n� �£! �n�qq5CDy»$% ��( �* �9+;A �::9¨ :�n� �3! �qqV�n�qeT��b5pÀ�°»E�234ç5�Û[Ò8ST�`»AÌèb5ºZaTA`a�b

45:;<6��_�-�ÍsA�LUç!6O

�Vbkb5aeK�L�TUÈFZ5p�+P

� nÜݯ»$% ��( �* �9+;� ��¨�:��¸¤¥¦y»$% ��( * +;� ��¨ ����5� �Úq5�5�Í<!.Õ�!Pïn®}¯»$% ��( �* �:+»] ���¨ ����qRg5açaç:;<6©Ç½��_�õP

!+P� ë�A�b43�ç!|k?KO

uU�3h3M6O�n�ßÄʲ�»E%Ü©

ª� �� � : �V`\­®¯»$% �� ( � *��+;� ���:¨ ����n� ��3! �! ��»�qçe!e©��é�_���CT�VqV�o[A`a�_��5à�!�e+55F�b

4Z5:;<6k�!-�ÍsëçÄÅST�

�3h!65pÀ�!ÁªKOuU�5CÉ�A

áR3V�n�q�(�»!Dΰ»<! w23KZ5���R]¼!R3PïîïW���?-�Ís[

Ò8ST�`»6¸÷STT|-�Ís6%4

_�e�çO?á���b43�V23@KZó

ST43R365789Ç�d34�Û[Ò8

ST�`»6R3n-�Ís6%4bR3q�ç

kkC�æO�4-�Ís%4!B¯A�L4

3�o[5±?�b�¼u45:;<66�Û[

Ò8ST�`»!6C�R�B¯A�LU�^

ST�V�î w236789Ç:!st2uA²�b

UkghkZ×k�R365e! w23��?5

¿L4:;<665ï�Ru45g÷¾¿Ã«_

�B¯6�-U�Y��T�nR25Ä�[!Ì

è��b4Z5³´µÊp� ��§ �¨ ��5sè��b4Z5¶·¸ÐÊ�Vc ��§ ¨ ��9�qV�U5Dΰ»<! w23��T|5%��

í!sbU-KZ-�Ís%4�fKZ3�

R3�^ST�nîl5¥�Ê`� ��qV3kR��±6���R]¼!R3PïîïW���?

-�Ís[Ò8ST�`»6¸÷ST�U�3�

�!k�d34Z5¹^ó!stKO�VyºÊ`

� � �Z5��Rîï���#5F�b4Pï_�7#»¼A�LU[K5e!�hR�±�2

34©ÇAé-U<66ï<!�ͽT��¾

_�à��R�e�Aõ?R6�PïA!"b

24

神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13号

Page 13: Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

U�#Z5¸÷Ís!¿Ð!H�6y3ç!�b

453CD�nX¸÷�»!»¼�¸÷Ís!ò

\!q.ÓÓÔ���?-�Ís%4!©õÐA

�L�VfU5À�Áµ¸,Â��Ä �� § � ¨����Z5�ñ��ÊËÐ6y�5a!e�6X©Ç<��u4çóÃKO�!�M�]¼A S

æ!"_�5789Çk�!ê(ÄÅRÊËÐ!

�ó¸åæ!bb�6�çkkC�æ5¬(ÆA

9SæÇÜÜÈ ¸!"_�Rg�!�±�F

?-�ÍsA�L��_�V�n:qg÷¾¿Ã«�3hÑÒM�pC!�s�açaç5�í!s��b5g÷¾¿Ã«Aç

u4ÉIe�Zþ(R!kVe!��d3457

89Zr��pó!ç!�b4343��h�

���n@ïÊ`� :��±©qVÑk�5�(�»��?789Ç!5ïþb6�CT5º�:;

<6!`»ç�Z�Rç!�_×R3�_��5

�� éÇ��b4PïAé-��Û[Ò8ST�7#¯I!O�<6�<bR3e��R�V�

_��5��éÇ��ZÊË#�R�çîÓKO�Ve!�hR0­»�Z5�R��ç789�

b4Z�áK#R3ç!KO+hV�bkb5�Ì[Z5�í!s��b4-�Ís

Z¬(%4bR3�^b4kfCR3�#J�

T�6;ç�R�R3VÈ�ɸìd% ��9: ¨�9��Z5g÷¾¿Ã«��u4©Ç��!ñ�ÐAÑÒ_��3hMªpC!�s6st�R

?á��_�Va!ò�Z5�(�»�2-�Í�°»<! w23KO�VeTZ5W{!-�

Ís����g÷¾¿��!ólZûñ!g÷

!Î KO?5îï�ñ�ÐA�U²�e�KZ

R3naTZ=PN�!stKO�q�3h Ë

KO�VfU5��Y!Ï�k�5;Ð!st�

b4bfh�5©Ç½65Pïîï!-¬Í��

����°!H��PïîïA¬Í_�e��

�?+P!6Ck�é-�ÑÒ!H�Ar��

¿b53æTAÂ2_�!6áÓk�3h�Ô�

Õ�2aT6O?5Êæbç��RMÓKR3�

3hç!KO�nÖW×ØÊp� �� § �� ¨ �:�qV�Í�°»<Z5�íîïW�!��=PN�A

�L��fKZó5b43R3VeTA�L�!

KOT|5��íîï!�<Ñ�ÙaT�`�R

3�#!=PN���3h¬d!¬ÚbUÑÒ

©�6O�e��R�k�5Êæbçg÷¾¿Ã

«fK�L�ÊËZR3KO+hVbkb5ae

fKA�L�!Z��_�3^6L��C

T�n¥�Ê`� �5I¼�qVfU5t��L��b4ç789Ç6=PN�fK÷Í_�!

k5:;<6KK#�!k�3h0URstçO

?5ûñ�Z=PN�Z�bahKO�V�KÈ[!ó°Awh©õÐ6O�e�A _

e�pC6Û¶!îï!¬ÍA)_�3h:�

Z5ÜÜaT6U���Z�Rç!KO��b4

çÜÜO�D�×NK¬ð���L�T�Ve�

��éÇ�í!s!�±�-5W{!��ól��_�e�ANÌ_�!Z±�6DkR3V�789Ç©Ç-ñ�ÐANS_�e��d

345��k�YsAÝ_�Ä<ç3�n¶·Ê`

�qVaefKÞßKR3�b4ç5À�Ê`� ��9�Z5�eTfK!789Ç!à«ZáU�­_

�65¬MK5�#�PïA«L�:!X]6½

4m5aT6Í#v×U�±�Z5k�u45W

���ÍoAçU�_©õÐA��S²��3

h:�çO��h��CT�V��_�V��� éÇ!ñ�ÐAÕ>b43��3he�65789!Hâ'`!�h�3�Tk�R3e

��Z.2AË_�+hVbkb5789Z¹

C�RÈñAãb�b4°»â�a _��!5

:;<AØwh�3h�!6O�Va!�Z5Ä

<>°»<�W7��4�6�R�VfU5i�

<!�h�5x��«AØÙ�ÈñAÌ�K#�

C-KçR3V>Z?5789�b4Z5�(�»!5»�6V7U�hR789Ç6�Ub4

#U�!çY�T|5Pï!s��_�ÑÒZM

kb�!JK�L�T�7#KO?5�R��ç

g÷¾¿Ã«!B¯Z�L�7#KO�VO�Z

v�!�è��?ä�RàXA,�7#KO�V�ÚÚÚÚ���� �í!sA�L�ñC�[!ËÉ�í!sA�L�ñC�[!ËÉ�í!sA�L�ñC�[!ËÉ�í!sA�L�ñC�[!ËÉ����n�q�í!s��_�y�[!ÑÒ!<?M�d34Z5eTfKV74#U�e+KO�V

¬M5açaçW�R�í!skghkZ5g!

�h�»�_7#kV�(�»Z5»E�b4ZEhAó b43R3VU5DÎ w23Z5

25

神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13号

Page 14: Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

�ü©ÇȾ�d345©ÇA«L�:!`»�

@AB�T�:!`»Ar��¿b4Pï!

"6��KO�kskA»�_�7#KO�V�

�b43�Ve!�Z5pÀ�KåJU��T4

#U^[�î¬KO?5�y°6��k�EhA

è4_�e��Ru4çS�gæ�6R3��

CT�nç��»µV ��( :* �:+K� ��§�¨ ��9�nop���(�»��3hVq�2345ñ7��r��¿XA']b43��ç^S

T�V@ïÊ`� ::�qV�bkb5eTKZEh6Ou4R3�hRç!5

53è�T|5X©Ç<ZÈ�R»�Aé�T5

���çy�Rõu6«L�T�n«�¬Ê`�q

e��R�V�E�|5;êôÓ!�±K5:;<6ç�6ï

¤îA�áb4N��Í�Éçh�b43��

hRe©�KOT|55F�b4©ÇA«L�:

!`»6[��ç!�b45789Ç�!jè

nS��¬©�3V@ïÊ`� :� �q��u45�í!sA^�_�3hMÓ6O?á�VeTp

CZ5ç��ÇKç¬Î;êôÓ�!=KÍCT

42?5�x��ç%�6�ØL43�Vbkb5

a!�h�»¼SK#R3ÈÉ�d34Z5ëÝ

ç�´ì{�5X©Ç<6È�R»�Aé�T�

©õÐ6O�V�n�q�í!s6íÍ_�ØÙ�Z5789Ç©Ç��íbUe����g÷¾¿Ã«6�L�T

U5��(�»!OP6O�n}î¸`� ��9�5×Dï¬Ê4� ��§ �¨ ���qV�

��(�»�d34Z5̀ ðAJ?���ST

R3`»�Õb��Ób4V7U5ñ�!»E�

b4Ù��KO+hVbkb5e!»�!ÈFZ5

�����2345Çä:65��éÇ!Pï��u4��<!`ðAõ?5a!Ý5îÇäÔÎ

�65@ò���ÆDz³®}¯M°»â!¹�

6K5�é��<!ÈÉ!�]�=Ý6�5ÈÉ

ÓÔ<>Ëó!UL�fu43U<�!`K5�

�<!`ðAË b5fU5îä65��<6e

!`ðA �b4�äbUe�Açu4/ôm

^KO��b4���^õbU�3hç!KO

�VË_��5ÊæbçÈÉ!^��ÊË6Rk

uU!�5`ð�3h5û<K3�|ËjkµÕ

+PnµÕ+PÒ8� �à �¾qAöÓ�� bU�3hç!KO?5ÈF�b4ZkR?�ZR

ç!��CT�V©ÇA�LU789Ç:�çs

t6R3�Z33#Tæ5û<!µÕ+PÒ8�

�pKZ5î\!©Ç6OT|789ÇüýK�

L�TR3�Y��T�V�bkb5ûñ�Z5�� (�»6��� éÇ��u4�í_��-�Ís�R�2aT6O��

�3h½E�b4¬Õ÷#b5�í!s�øT>

_�Ru43U!KO�n� (�»! � �»�ç5��(�»!�<A]¼�v�AsèbUqV��ÌKç5Q|y»$% �� ( * � +»R

��:�¨ ���n`\� ��{q65~]96789Ç©Ç�`�4�~îï<!Ñèbïð6!§

bAa�bUe©��2345-�Ís!%4A

�L43��V�e!�hR»�6O�o[5í��e�Kù�

¾¿ó°AsCT�2aTk�½TU3�3h

X©Ç<!4�ç5×k�R3�Z3�R3V�n�qëÝ!ú1�ñ� û<!��pKZ5`»�¿Afæ789Ç

6Í35aT��4�X©Ç<6Í35bkçX

©Ç<Z�íb4çbR�4çó°Õ²ST�

2aT6O�VX©Ç<Ae!�hR%�ª�S

�bUff�b42�e�ç1fb�R3n×

D¸`� ��qV�ø� PïîïÑ�LM!� »�6OT|5aT

��u4�íb4ç5jk6k�L��T4çX

©Ç<6ó°Awhe�ZR3KO+hV3C|5

��<+P� �ûU¹,�R�V_RCm5P

ïîïÑ�LMAü²S²��3he�Z5X©

Ç<!�í_�e����%�ª!^$�ýÌ

_�e��R�V�bkb53m3mPïîïÑ�LMAao_�

�R��aL_�789Ç�b4ç5`L_�³

C��u4çvQRwd�R�e�Zç��?5

açaçPïîïALMKÑèS²4k�KR

-T|�íbR3�3he�KZ ��éÇ!ô�õZQ#�gRCT4bfhV�"� 789Ç6����ó°Awd_�����Ru43R3e�Ast _�k!�hR3^

çO�n«�¬¸`�qVbkb4�X�b478

26

神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13号

Page 15: Ì Ì Ì ˚˚F’˛ˇ—H - 神奈川県弁護士会...‘!æß 3hˇ»A,u4#Ue kł_ T|5789˙6pł'˙A_˚!6þ(KO˚ »—bU¨¾˝d345'˙6æ‹—A−d‘ »nPïîï6‹˝ST˚‘»q˝d34Z

9Ç6���Ró°Awhe��_7#�_�

�5a!ó°�ZMk5¹C��g!�hR�±

�ó°Awh7#kn v�ó°�Ì3ç!�_

7#R!kq�3he�6st�R?5þ(R�

�ìyZ ±KZR3V�'� U5789Ç�b4ç5©ÇȾ!þ(R

þ?HJZçm+�5�íA«L�ÊËв³.

�ÐA�?¹C�� _�k5X©Ç½6�íb���

���� �ë!ólZ5�XÆLÕÇ4È65789� ��Ã! � ���#ÆLÕ789ÇÇ;�È6bUY[!©Ç�d345ÆLÕ789Ç��bP

ï_�îï6O�e�AÑ�_�V���� ����ë�d34Z5�ÆLÕ789Ç!6I�ëÇg÷¾¿Ã«ÈA¬Î� _�W»

��2345WÉÑ�ë�d34»�_�Ê

ËZR3��STUV��� �Î�Ê`�ç5g÷¾¿!üA��4ñ�ÐAÑÒb�h�_T|5e!M�o��ZR3

��CT��3hI�A�L43�V�:� �Ib+5� (�»Z5g÷¾¿Ã«�?Ñ�!L�!M65��ól�kRuUÑÒM�K

O�e�A �bU�ç#L�VyºÏÊû÷

$W<� ��¨ :�V��� �"»�Z��ñï=>��¨!X��+P��ë²³µÕ+PÒ8AL/��Ì!»E�K

xyb43�V��� ���»�Z5Pï!"�d345�R��çWÉ©ÇȾ!¬Î�d34Z��R]¼Ac

�ç!KO?W��bUç!!5Xï�v�6

O��fKZ3�R3�b45:;<WÕ57

89Ç�çëAÄÅbUV�

Ue�A]¼�aLSTU�#Z789Ç6

ý±�_��95PïbUe���_�ªç©·Z�789Ç6�ª_�Rg5ûÍ!���KçK#

�e�Z3+3+O�n}îÊ`� ����qV�X©Ç<!4�ç+f�Uþ�R\]���

R��ìy�ª-4!à«AS��-�ÊË

6O+hV���

� � ��ÆL�»�Z5:;<WÕ�d34��� éÇ��_�Pï6ST�e���u4:;<

6é-�`»�d34Z5a!��6þ��\

]STUà�çU�ST�Èñ[!`»�_

×R3�_RCm�Û[Ò8ST�`»6R3

�b4ÆLAÄÅbUV�� ��í!s���R]¼6O�ºZv�6R3�3h]¼KÄÅbUç!çO�65W�KZ

��_�V�� �@ï��Ê;� �9�¨ :��. �9Z5aTKç��`»A�é_�ñ7�R6C6:;<

6KO��» _��Z�2�V7�V��� �eT�d34ç5ç�ç�Z~]9!jk��"ñò6OuUkghk6��KOuU�

e+5Ñèbïð>��è���Î!§bA

Ë«bUUL5©Ç� 6³v×U!65þ

KO�VbU6u45789Ç!��K©Ç

� AFè_7#KOuU�3h Ë6O

�V@ïÊ`� :��V��9� �Q|789Ç�4Í�!jè�234Z5X©Ç½6aLSTU�#Z789Ç6LM±

�_�e�6� �Ru43��hKO�V×

D¸`� ��V�

���������������������������������������������������

27

神奈川県弁護士会 専門実務研究13号