25
On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华华华华华华 华华华 e 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

On the degeneracy between w0 and wa

Yungui Gong

Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech

华中科技大学龚云贵

The 7th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Page 2: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Contents

Motivations: General Property of Scalar Field dynamics

Dark energy parametrizations

The degeneracy between w0 and wa

The consequence of the derived degeneracy

Page 3: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Motivations

General Property of scalar field dynamics scalar field as dark energy: Tracking

solutions

Tracker fields (Steinhardt etal, PRD 1999)

Page 4: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Tracking Solutions

Page 5: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Tracking Solution: General Property

Almost independent of initial conditions Relation

Common Dynamics for scalar fields

Page 6: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Efstathiou Parametrization Dark energy parametrization: capture the main dynamics of scalar field

MNRAS 383, 879 (1999)

Page 7: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

CPL Parametrization

Approximation

E. Linderastro-ph/0210217

Page 8: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

The degeneracy in CPL model

w0 and wa is degenerated

What is the degeneracy? related with ?

Page 9: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Dark Energy Parametrizations (Partial Lists)

Dark energy parametrization: capture the main dynamics of scalar field

Efstathiou 1999, MNRAS 310, 842

CPL, Chevallier & Polarski 2001, IJMPD 10, 213; Linder 2003, PRL 90, 091301

JBP, Jassal, Bagla & Padmanabhan, MNRAS 356, L11

Wetterich 2004, PLB 594, 17

Page 10: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Scalar Field approximation

Cosmological equations

Page 11: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Scalar Field Dynamics

Take the (Slow-roll) approximation

For Thawing scalar field

Scherrer & Sen 2008, PRD 77, 083515

Page 12: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

approximation

Page 13: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Thawing scalar fields

Approximate w(z)

dotted curve

short dash curve

long dash curve

Page 14: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

The degeneracy between and

Relation

0th order approximation

Scherrer and Sen 2008, PRD 78, 067303

Page 15: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

SSLCPL model

Taylor Expansion

Gong etal., Int. J. Mod. Phys. 22 (2013) 1350035, 1301.1224

Page 16: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

The accuracy of the approximation

Page 17: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

SSWCPL model

Take approximation

Page 18: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

The accuracy of the approximation

Page 19: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

The degeneracy

Self-consistency

Page 20: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Flat SSLCPL Results

Page 21: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Flat SSWCPL Results

Page 22: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Flat CPL Results

Page 23: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Comparisons

Page 24: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

Conclusions

The dynamics of scalar fields has some common features

The exists an approximate relation between w and

For thawing models, the dynamics can be approximated by CPL parametrization with degenerated relation between w0 and wa

The reduced degeneracy helps improve the constraint on w(z)

Page 25: On the degeneracy between w 0 and w a Yungui Gong Huazhong Univ of Science and Tech 华中科技大学 龚云贵 The 7 th Aegean Summer School, Paros, Greece, 2013.9.27

THANK YOU!