12
ÜBBSBBffl^w^r'r^^—. «Mmfifißmwww-tr- oo o m* AMMRC TR 81-34 AD MECHANISM OF < MONURON-ACCELERATED ^ DICYANDIAMIDE CURE OF RESINS BERNARD R. LaLIBERTE and JOSEPH BORNSTEiN POLYMER RESEARCH DIVISION g|p2 8 19Öt| E ,. n July 1981 s 1 \( Approved for public release; distribution unlimited. ARMY MATERIALS AND MECHANICS RESEARCH CENTER Watertown, Massachusetts 02172 8i 9 28 142 ,

oo AMMRC TR 81-34 AD · »»UiUi: 'W li,«WMIi^T''y^^;>;K»UJ.)HiWi>jl>«i| mmmmmm wmmmß***^*™™1 differences of Monuron (mp 172°C) and Diuron (mp 154°C). Diuron and Monuron

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: oo AMMRC TR 81-34 AD · »»UiUi: 'W li,«WMIi^T''y^^;>;K»UJ.)HiWi>jl>«i| mmmmmm wmmmß***^*™™1 differences of Monuron (mp 172°C) and Diuron (mp 154°C). Diuron and Monuron

■ÜBBSBBffl^w^r'r^^—. ■ «Mmfifißmwww-tr-

oo

o

m* AMMRC TR 81-34 AD

MECHANISM OF

< MONURON-ACCELERATED

^ DICYANDIAMIDE CURE OF

RESINS

BERNARD R. LaLIBERTE and JOSEPH BORNSTEiN

POLYMER RESEARCH DIVISION

g|p2 8 19Öt|

E

■,. n

July 1981

s

1 \(

Approved for public release; distribution unlimited.

ARMY MATERIALS AND MECHANICS RESEARCH CENTER Watertown, Massachusetts 02172

8i 9 28 142

,

Page 2: oo AMMRC TR 81-34 AD · »»UiUi: 'W li,«WMIi^T''y^^;>;K»UJ.)HiWi>jl>«i| mmmmmm wmmmß***^*™™1 differences of Monuron (mp 172°C) and Diuron (mp 154°C). Diuron and Monuron

JW1UJ.J1IWMJIWL-

■-■-■■■■':-■■■->■':■■■

The findings in this report are not to be construed as an official

Department of the Army position, unless so designated by other

authorized documents.

r

Mention of any trade names or manufacturers in this report shall not be construed as advertising nor as an official

indorsement or approval of such products or companies by the united States Government.

DISPOSITION INSTRUCTIONS

Destroy thit report «hen it it no lone/»' needed. Do not return it to the originator.

Page 3: oo AMMRC TR 81-34 AD · »»UiUi: 'W li,«WMIi^T''y^^;>;K»UJ.)HiWi>jl>«i| mmmmmm wmmmß***^*™™1 differences of Monuron (mp 172°C) and Diuron (mp 154°C). Diuron and Monuron

|pp|pt^p,.w»l..».,v.,l,iiiju.,iWJ,,lliWwl^,w,.,,<WLT; <mmmmm ■Bpw Ju.i wwi^"'kjit.iiM.ujmjnmn nnu.mi!!iiji,ii.ii,i!ii...

UNCLASSIFIED SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAGE f*h«n Data Interadj

H ' ^ VAMM1

/ ^

ust

REPORT DOCUMENTATION PAGE I. REPORT NJJMMR

RC-TR-81-34

2. GOVT ACCESSION NO.

4. TITLE fand Submit) AV-A/^if^

, MECHANISM OF MONURON-ACCELERATED DICYANDIAMIDE CURE OF EPOXY RESINS ,

7. AUTHOR«)

Bernard R.jLaLiberte «Hi Joseph|Bornstein

». PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME AND ADDRESS

Army Materials and Mechanics Research Center Watertown, Massachusetts 02172 DRXMR-RP

II. CONTROLLING OFFICE NAME AND AOORESS

U. S. Army Materiel Development and Readiness Command, Alexandria, Virginia 22333

M. MONITORING AGENCY NAME A AOORESyil dlllotonl Irom Controlling Ollirt)

READ INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE COMPLETING FORM

J. RECIPIENT'S CATALOG NUMBER

C\TYPE OF REPORT A PERIOD COVERED

1/ ^ Final -Report■

«■ P<«fO«UW6 ORO. REPORT NUMBER "RIEPOR

t. CONTRACT OR GRANT NUMBERS)

(I 10. PROGRAM ELBMENT. PROJECT, TASK

AREA A WORK ~

)/A Project:/ 1L162105AH84 \MCMS Code: bHUSA "*~ agency Accession: DA OD4815 **'• REPORT DATE

M July t981 RttMB«R-OP^«GES

7 IS. SECURITY CLASS, (ol Ihl, report)

Unclassified IS*. DECLASSIFICATION'DOWNGRADING

SCHEDULE

I«. DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT (ol fhia Report)

Approved for public release; distribution unlimited.

IT DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT (ol In* aaairacl en'ered In Block 20. II dlllotonl horn Report)

IB. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES

'• KEY WORDS 'Cenllnwe on rover» aid* II nereiaary ana* Identity by block nmhbot)

Epoxy resins Curing Curing mechanisms Thermal behavior

M. ABSTRACT {Ceriffmie an raver** at** II neceaaary ana) Identify my block mtmbot)

(SEE REVERSE SIDE)

DP i j ANTS 1*73 EOITION OF I NOV •• IS OBSOLETE UNCLASSIFIED

/

SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAGE '*•>••• DM* Eniarod)

**■-""■■"" >~Mr.^ ■ ».-■. - -■- --. ~. -A-- - |||

Page 4: oo AMMRC TR 81-34 AD · »»UiUi: 'W li,«WMIi^T''y^^;>;K»UJ.)HiWi>jl>«i| mmmmmm wmmmß***^*™™1 differences of Monuron (mp 172°C) and Diuron (mp 154°C). Diuron and Monuron

BPST**" ,.'.™.-~.'«npn ' mmmHKß iu*>m<

1%

U£I£2IEU£ _ UCuWiTy CLAM(»lC*TlOW Of TJjjj »*8t(WM« jgi •*—O

Block No. 20

ABSTRACT

A very interesting and practical property of trisubstituted ureas such as Monuron/N-^4-chJqTophenyl)-tI,,N,-dimethylurea, >is the ability of this class of aryl ureas to accelerate the dicyandiamide (Dicy) cure of epoxy resins. Earlier workers had proposed that the in situ formation of diraethylamine from Mouuron was an important factor in explaining the mechanism of the Monuron-accelerated dicyandiamide cure of epoxy resins. The main source of dimethylamine did not appear to us to be that which had been previously described. We have found that the amine is generated by a cyclocondensation reaction between the aryl urea and the resin to form a 2-oxazolidone.

During this study, it was found that the effectiveness with which dimethylamine activates Dicy, especially when compared to other materials such as trimethylamine, made this amine unique. It is postulated that dimethylamine has a strong proclivity to remove a proton from Dicy, thereby creating a highly active nucleophilic species. This enhancement of the nucleophilic nature of the hardening agent (Dicy) would account for the increased reactivity of Dicy toward epoxy resins.

i

Accession For

NTIS GRA&I DTIC TAB Unannounced Justification

D

n

By_ _Distrlbuti on1/

Availability Codes

Avail and/or Special

j\4 3&

UNCLASSIFIED ICCUftlTV CkAMiriCATlfiN fit UNI» PAGtfM»» 0«* t.,„.„tl

-l- ' ■ - '■-'■ i i inmniiaiiflii

Page 5: oo AMMRC TR 81-34 AD · »»UiUi: 'W li,«WMIi^T''y^^;>;K»UJ.)HiWi>jl>«i| mmmmmm wmmmß***^*™™1 differences of Monuron (mp 172°C) and Diuron (mp 154°C). Diuron and Monuron

■ Jl ' '■""""'■ I "»»WIIJIPJIPIP^WWMIIIIIWIIM*^^

i

• a I

INTRODUCTION

The ear j.sr workers, P. N. Son and C. D. Weber,1 reported that the in situ forma- tion of dimethylamine from the aryl urea Monuron, N-(4-chlorophenyl)-N',N'-dimethyl- urea, was an important factor in the mechanism of the Monuron-accelerated dicyandiamide (Dicy) cure of epoxy resins.

A study1 was made to determine the effectiveness of Monuron as an accelerator using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) at a heating rate of 10°C/min and a syn- ergistic effect between Monuron and Dicy was observed. The significance of the reaction between the epoxy resin and Monuron was not considered by these investigators. In search of a low temperature source of dimethylamine, they reported that Monuron and Dicy, when heated at 112°C to 118°C in bis(2-methoxyethy"l)ether (bp 162°C), yielded 35.5% of a linear compound, l-cyano-3-(p-chlorocarbanilino)guanidine. A «examination in our laboratory revealed that the main source of dimethylamine is very likely not this reaction. We were unable to prepare the linear compound at 112°C to 118°C, and at 162°C a cyclic isomer was realized.

Initially, we restricted our effort to find a pathway to dimethylamine to reac- tions in which epoxy-containing compounds were present. It was found that the main source of dimethylamine stems from a low temperature cyclocondensation reaction between the oxirane ring and the aryl urea accelerator2 to form a 2-oxazolidone.* This reac- tion is indicated by the oxirane ring and Monuron below:

o _ n II ^CH3 I I ^CH3

^H-CH2 + HN-C-N ►'VCHCH2N-C = 0 + HN

\/ A. VCH3 .A. ^CH3 0 0

ci

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

The effectiveness of tne trisubstituted ureas as accelerators was illustrated with DSC.2 With a heating rate of 2°C/min, a mixture of Diuron, N-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)- N'.N'-dimethylurea, and tetraglycidyl methylene dianiline (TGMDA) displayed an exotherm at 129°C. The three-component system consisting of Diuron, TGMDA, and Dicy also yielded an exotherm at 129°C. Tn contrast, the two-component TGMDA-Dicy mixture produced an exotherm at 170°C. The examination of the above mixtures made us aware of the thermal relationship between the two- and three-component systems. In other words, the resin- accelerator reaction had activated the Dicy so that cubing occurred at a lower temperature.

The thermal relationship was further investigated with the monofunctional epoxide, phenyl glycidyl ether (PGE). This epoxide was used to magnify the reaction temperature

*UUBERTE, B. R. The Reaction of Diuron *ith Epoxy Croups. Army Materials and Mechanics Research Center, AMMRC TN 79-1, January 1979, and other work by LaLiberte and Bornstein, manuscript in preparation.

J. SON, F. N., and WEBER, C. D. Some Aspects of Monuron-Accelerated Dicyandiamide Cure of Epoxy Resins. J. Applied Polymer Science, v. 17, 1973. p. 1305-1313.

2. UUBERTE. B. R., SACHER, R. E., and BORNSTE1N, J. Acceleration of the hpoxy ResinDicyandiamide Cure Cycle by Trisubstituted Ureas. Army Materials and Mechanics Research Center, AMMRC TR 81-30, June 1981.

Tin—nti 1L ■ -■■■^^m^maäKaalMkaMMmä

Page 6: oo AMMRC TR 81-34 AD · »»UiUi: 'W li,«WMIi^T''y^^;>;K»UJ.)HiWi>jl>«i| mmmmmm wmmmß***^*™™1 differences of Monuron (mp 172°C) and Diuron (mp 154°C). Diuron and Monuron

IHHPIUJJMT -V--"»;«:» i. »»UiUi:'W'li,«WMIi^T''y^^.;>;K»UJ.)HiWi>jl>«i|

mmmmmm wmmmß***^*™™1

differences of Monuron (mp 172°C) and Diuron (mp 154°C). Diuron and Monuron were each intimately mixed with PGE in equimolar amounts to form two-component mixtures. Three- component systems were formulated on the basis of five moles of PGE, one mole of the urea accelerator, and four moles of Dicy. The exothermic reaction temperatures of the two- and three-component systems, recorded (DSC) at 2°C/min, are:

PGE + Diuron: 129°C PGE + Monuron: 148°C PGE + Diuron/Dicy: 128°C PGE + Monuron/Dicy: 130°C

The results from the Diuron-PGE study supported the previously found relationship that the exothermic reaction temperature of the three-component system was about the same as that of the epoxy-aryl urea reaction. Interestingly, the three-component sys- tems have about the same reaction temperature. Thus Monuron at a heating rate of 2°C/min generated dimethylamine in sufficient amounts to activate Dicy so that chemical reaction of the epoxide took place at 130°C.

The above observations prompted further study. Accordingly, the investigation was extended to include a nonchlorinated low-melting aryl urea Nonuron, N-phenyl-N1,N'- dimethylurea (mp 134°C). The reaction temperatures of the aryl ureas were determined with a different epoxy-containing substrate, p-tertiary butylphenyl glycidyl ether (PTBGE). Reaction temperatures were first measured (DSC) at 2°C/min and then at the extremely slow heating rate of 0.5°C/min.

PTBGE

Reaction Temperatures, deg C Heating Rat e per minute

• 2°C 0.5°C

+ Nonuron 161 128 + Nonuron/Dicy - 116 + Diuron 148 116 + Diuron/Dicy - 113 + Monuron 158 118 + Monuron/Dicy - 114

The heating rate of 0.5°C/min produced results that were extremely informative. Regardless of the accelerator, all three-component systems had approximately the same reaction temperature and this fact is an indication that activation of Dicy may be more dependent on the formation of an active species of Dicy rather than the rate at which dimethylamine was generated. Son and Weber's demonstration of the synergistic effect of Monuron and Dicy on the cure temperature was illustrated by comparing the resin - Dicy temperature to that of the three-component system. This comparison is a reality that is well known in the state of the art.

In a search for an active species of Dicy, we attempted to react dimethylamine (bp 6°C) and Dicy at 0°C. For all practical purposes, the infrared analysis and the melting point determination of the treated Dicy indicated that no chemical reaction had taken place. This Dicy was mixed with an epoxy resin and examination of this mixture (DSC) at 2°C/min very surprisingly afforded an exotherm at 150°C. In con- trast, untreated Dicy produced an exotherm with the resin at 179°C. Partial activa- tion may have been realized but further study is indicated.

r i ii^MMili« ---■-■■■ - - iiiiiitiiiMiaiMBii r MJMtfl iüUÄüäi

1

*A«MtMfc

Page 7: oo AMMRC TR 81-34 AD · »»UiUi: 'W li,«WMIi^T''y^^;>;K»UJ.)HiWi>jl>«i| mmmmmm wmmmß***^*™™1 differences of Monuron (mp 172°C) and Diuron (mp 154°C). Diuron and Monuron

—plpppg^,»^^..-™,,,,,.,™,,,,,,,. J. 1„.JJL1IU ...J.IWPWJ..I-. ■■""•" ""■"

Tertiary amines, such as N,N-dimethylbenzylamine, have been reported by Saunders, Levy, and Serino3 to catalyze Dicy. It is interesting that N,N-dimethylbenzylamine is similar to dimethylamine in that it contains the dimethylamino group and that both these amines are able to activate Dicy. It was found, in contrast, that the diethyl- amino derivatives of the aryl ureas, such as N-phenyl-N',N'-diethylurea and N-(4-chloro- phenyl)-N',N'-diethylurea, demonstrated limited, ability to activate Dicy. It should be pointed out that on the basis of basicity and steric hindrance, it would be expected that the difference in the activation of Dicy by dimethylamine or diethylamine should be marginal. Consequently, dimethylamine was considered to be a unique amine. This belief led to an investigation in which the activating effect of a number of amines was studied. As a result of this work amines may now be arranged in a series according to their decreasing ability to activate Dicy.

HN(CH3)2

\C6H5CH2N(CH3)2\ (C2H5)2NHv ) > Km-C^Ho /(CoHsKN 'fCHO*N /

)2NH (CH3)3N

>0> -J-ClCeH^Nl^

CH3NH2

Nlh

As can be seen, dimethylamine is a better activator than trimethylamine. A fea- sible explanation of the the dominant position of dimethylamine in the activation se- ries may be ascribed to a delicate balance between basicity, nucleophilicity, steric hindrance, and diffusion. On the basis of this activation series, we wish to propose that dimethylamine removes a proton from Dicy, thereby generating a reactive nucleo- philic species. This enhancement of the nucleophilic nature of the hardening agent (Dicy) would account for the increased reactivity of Dicy toward cpoxy resins.

^CH-CH2

\/ 0

0 Nil I C=N-C«N

©I ♦ IIN(CII3)2

Ml,

^:H-CII2NIIC=N-C»N

0 0 Nll2

©',' ♦ IIN(C!I3)2

-\<UI-CH?NHC=N-CiN I I

OH Nll2

!IN(CH3)2

3. SAUNDFRS. T. I., LFVY. M. I.. and SKR1NO. J. J. Polymer Science. A-l, v. 5. 1967. p. 1609-1617.

Mechanism of the Tertiary Aminc Catalyzed IhcvanJiamiJe Ctirr oj k'poxy Resins.

i i u:./'.Li..-MH'-«Bnt::r :r:: . . . . _' ..-'"—Jr: _•^^^r^Li* 1^! "_""■"■-_■ -^jgjgjgj fctOxwWKa«*

Page 8: oo AMMRC TR 81-34 AD · »»UiUi: 'W li,«WMIi^T''y^^;>;K»UJ.)HiWi>jl>«i| mmmmmm wmmmß***^*™™1 differences of Monuron (mp 172°C) and Diuron (mp 154°C). Diuron and Monuron

1^555^Bli-\A\*fl!S5 ■"* *" SS'Sft -; "S^"

It was of interest to determine the relationship between the structure of the trisubstituted ureas and their ability to effect the activation of Dicy. Tetramethyl- urea and 1,3-bis(4-chlorophenyl)urea were found not to possess any accelerative prop- erty. It was observed that 1,1-dimethylurea was not as good an accelerator as the arvl ureas; however, it was found that this compound was definitely more effective than 1,3- dimethylurea. It appears then that for a urea to be a useful accelerator it must con- tain an aryl substitute as well as the gem-dimethyl moiety.

The mechanism proposed above Jailed to take into consideration the ability of dimethylamine to open the epoxy functionality of the substrate to form tertiary amines. This prompted the preparation of two compounds (I and II) from the reactants, phenyl glycidyl ether (PGE), dimethylamine, and 4-chlorophenyl isocyanate as indicated below:

PGE + HN(CH3)2' —C6H5OCH2CHCH2V(CH3)2 I

OH

I + C-

N

0 Cl

—C6H5OCH2CHCH2N(CH3)2

0 I

o=c I

HN

0 ci

ii

Compounds I and II were found to have excellent accelerative properties. The ease with which dimethylamine opened the oxirane ring to form the compound I necessitated the consideration of a second and more general mechanism whereby the proton acceptor dimethylamine was replaced by R-N(CH3)2 in explaining the process of Dicy activation.

^CH-CH2 \/ 0

0 NH I C=N-C«N I NH2

R-N(CH3)2

^H-CH2NHC=N-CiN

0 0 NH2

♦ R-N(CH3)2

-\£H-CH2NHC=N-CiN + I I OH NH2

R-N(CH3)2

UM«**

Page 9: oo AMMRC TR 81-34 AD · »»UiUi: 'W li,«WMIi^T''y^^;>;K»UJ.)HiWi>jl>«i| mmmmmm wmmmß***^*™™1 differences of Monuron (mp 172°C) and Diuron (mp 154°C). Diuron and Monuron

-,^-,.^r.~-~ ^..1,,.^.,,^

Where R is equal to H, the proton acceptor is dimethylamine. R may represent other groups which would be present in substances obtained by the attack of dimethylamine on the epoxy functionality. The foregoing mechanism is now flexible enough to encompass some of the various elements which may contribute to the overall activation of Dicy.

EXPERIMENTAL

Differential scanning calorimetric experiments were conducted in open aluminum pans on a DuPont 990 thermal analyzer with a 902 DSC plug-in module in a static atmo- sphere. The exothermic reaction temperatures were taken at the apex of the heating curves.

Preparation of Compounds I and II

Phenyl glycidyl ether was reacted with an excess of dimethylamine at 0°C to form compound I, l-phenoxy-3-dimethylamino 2-propanol. Compound I and p-chlorophenyl isocy anate were reacted to yield the carbamate II.* The elemental analysis of the previ- ously unreported carbamate derivative II is shown.

Calcd for: CieH2iClN203; C, 62.07; H, 6.08; Cl, 10.18; N, 8.04% Found: C, 61.90; H, 6.12; Cl 10.38; N, 7.98%.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

Dr. C. A. Byrne kindly prepared compounds I and II for this study.

•The detailed preparation of this material will b? reported by Dr. C. A. Byrne.

Page 10: oo AMMRC TR 81-34 AD · »»UiUi: 'W li,«WMIi^T''y^^;>;K»UJ.)HiWi>jl>«i| mmmmmm wmmmß***^*™™1 differences of Monuron (mp 172°C) and Diuron (mp 154°C). Diuron and Monuron

DISTRIBUTION LIST

No. of Copies

1 Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering, T 2 Pentagon, Washington, D. C. 20301

12 Commander, Defense Technical Information Center, Cameron Station, Building b, 5010 Duke Street, Alexandria, Virginia 22314

1 Metals and Ceramics Information Center, Battelle Columbus Laboratories, 505 King Avenue, Columbus, Ohio 43201

Deputy Chief of Staff, Research, Development, and Acquisition, Headquarters, Department of the Army, Washington, D. C. 20310

1 ATTN: DAMA-ARZ

Commander, Army Research Office, P. 0. Box 12211, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina 27709 1 ATTN: Information Processing Office

Commander, U. S. Army Materiel Development and Readiness Command, 5001 Eisenhower Avenue, Alexandria, Virginia 22333

1 ATTN: DRCLDC

Commander, U. S. Army Materiel Systems Analysis Activity, Aberdeen Proving Ground, Maryland 21005 1 ATTN: DRXSY-MP, H. Cohen

Commander, U. S. Aray Electronics Research and Development ".ommand, Fort Monmouth, New Jersey New Jersey 07703

1 ATTN: DELSD-L 1 DELSD-E

Commander, U. S. Army Missile Command, Redstone Arsenal, Alabama 35809 4 ATTN: DRSMI-TB, Redstone Scientific Information Center 1 Technical Library 1 DRSMI-RLD, Mr. D. Loveless 1 DRSMI-EAM, Mr. H. Dedman

Commander, U. S. Army Armament Research and Development Command, Dover, New Jersey 07801 2 ATTN: Technical Library 1 DRDAR-SCM, J. D. Corrie 1 DRDAR-LCA, Mr. Harry E. Pebly, Jr., PLASTEC, Director 1 Mr. A. M, Anzalone, PLASTEC

Commander, U. S. Army Natick Research and Development Command, Natick, Massachusetts 01760 1 ATTN: Technical Library

Director, U. S. Army Ballistic Research Laboratory, Aberdeen Proving Ground, Maryland 21005 1 ATTN: DRDAR-TSB-S (STINFO)

Commander, U. S. Army Foreign Science and Technology Center, 220 7th Street, N. E., Charlottesville, Virginia 22901

1 ATTN: Military Tech, Mr. Marley

Director, Eustis Directorate, U. S. Army Air Mobility Research and Development Laboratory, Fort Eustis, Virginia 23604

1 AHN: Mr. J. Robinson, DAVDL-E-MOS (AVRADC0M)

Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, D. C. 20375 1 AHN: Dr. J. M. Krafft - Code 5830

Chief of Naval Research, Arlington, Virginia 22217 1 ATTN: Code 471

--...' frju^i

Page 11: oo AMMRC TR 81-34 AD · »»UiUi: 'W li,«WMIi^T''y^^;>;K»UJ.)HiWi>jl>«i| mmmmmm wmmmß***^*™™1 differences of Monuron (mp 172°C) and Diuron (mp 154°C). Diuron and Monuron

wwrmppw 7 <!'JMsl|||H

NO. Of Copies To

Conmander, U. S. Air Force Wright Aeronautical Laboratories, Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio 45433

2 ATTN: AFWAL/MLSE, E. Morrissey 1 AFWAL/MLC 1 AFWAL/MLLP, D. M. Forney, Jr. 1 AFWAL/MLBC, Stanley Schulman

National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Washington, D. C. 20546 1 ATTN: Mr. B. G. Achhammer 1 Mr. G. C. Deutsch - Code RW

National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville, Alabama 35812

1 ATTN: R. J. Schwinghammer, EH01, Dir, MSP Lab 1 Mr. W. A. Wilson, EH41, Bldg. 4612

1 Ship Research Committee, Maritime Transportation Research Board, National Research Council, 2101 Constitution Ave., N. W., Washington, D. C. 20418

1 Librarian, Materials Sciences Corporation, Blue Bell Campus, Merion Towle House, Blue Bell, Pennsylvania 19422

1 Dr. Clayton May, Lockheed Missiles and Space Company, Inc., Dept. 47-01, Bldg. 150, P. 0. Bex 504, Sunnyvale, California 94088

1 R. W. Hoffman, Hercules, Inc., P. 0. Box 98, Magna, Utah 84044

1 Judy S. Chen, M.C. 73-43, Boeing Commercial Airplane Company, Seattle, Washington 98008

1 Robert Holden, Grumman Aerospace Corporation, Bethpage, New York 11714

1 Dr. David Kaelbe, Rockwell Science Center, 1049 Camino Dos Rios, P. 0. Box 1085, Thousand Oaks, California 91360

1 David Crabtree, Northrop Corporation, Hawthorne, California 90250

1 Don Crozier, Lockheed California Company, B/229, PH2 (Dept. No. 74-71), P. 0. Box 551, Burbank California 91520

1 J. F. Carpenter, McDonnell Douglas Corporation, McDonnell Aircraft Company, P. 0. Box 51 , St. Louis, Missouri 63166

1 Dr. T. Helmlniak, AFWAL/MLBC, Wright-Patterson Air Force Bise, Ohio 45433

1 Dr. R. Van Deusen, AFWAL/MLBP, Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio 45433

1 Dr. Chet Poranski, Naval Research Laboratory, Code 6110, Washington, 0. C. 20375

1 Dr. Anthony Davis, Procurement Executive, Ministry of Defense, Non-Metallic Materials Branch, Waltham Abbey, Essex, England

1 Or. William Moniz, Chemistry Division, Code 6120, Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, D. C. 20375

1 J. M. Mills, Jr., Information Control Office, Union Carbide Corporation, Nuclear Division, Y-12 Plant, Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830

1 Paul Scherer, McDonnell Douglas Corporation, Huntington Beach, California 92646

1 Dr. J. Cernosek, Bell Helicopter Textron, Dept. 80, P. 0. Box 482, Fort Worth, Texas 76101

1 K. Clark, Naval Air Development Center, Warminster, Pennsylvania 18974

1 Charles Bersch, Naval Air Systems Command, Washington, D. C. 20361

Director, Army Materials and Mechanics Research Center, Watertown, Massachusetts 02172 2 ATTN: DRXHR-PL 2 Authors

AU- IUMMMÜ

Page 12: oo AMMRC TR 81-34 AD · »»UiUi: 'W li,«WMIi^T''y^^;>;K»UJ.)HiWi>jl>«i| mmmmmm wmmmß***^*™™1 differences of Monuron (mp 172°C) and Diuron (mp 154°C). Diuron and Monuron

UBEUMWI"* «inmiini. MP ■■■»««> «IHUBWIU.'.W w ■"•»«■» ■ ii i.ijppjiii m

r

i

L

z • *-> o >> at c c o c: in TO c xi x: <n >■(-■«-

o re re re a» o re m *r- c tn C> t- QJ JZ 4-J i. ■»-> "D -r- re *-» at at

is E u s- i- 3«oa> x:x:x:u*ot- o ca in c 3 in o u x: 4-> 2 u re i. LU i—< O S- Q. ■*-> re 3 at rex —• at w> c 3Z<- at E 0) 1- X ifl C >|J= X U. h- ■o W fQ X-* ■oaiatre+J •<-1— o ►— en J- c -C ifl i- u i- X3 C -r l/l £ X QJ d to <-. O u re re o EZ E at E »•— re oix: at to a 3 m <D 3 re reocnC <Df--i-4-> < a* E JZ 4- •i- 4-» o wi- >,X "O _l o X s- '-> O i- m-o in<t- en i.r 4-J- O LÜ a> C« CT> 3 at re c m *r- at at 4-> i«3 o re Z t— ^ >> c c *n m ■!- » re 3 o c ■»-» at i

X uw a) « E aiüj o ID «-" X m r— 2: o i- 1^ in re i- c uoc > E ■>- C l- +J

a. 3 3 re r— re o __J UJ o u QJ U UJ i_-0 E-^+JI- +J4-»3s

Q Z t. 3 i-remuai-t->rereu «t X>

ted

u th

is

ins.

C O

s

Tare at at £ « ai c -r- aiata>&-i*-+jx:i- o *-> D-x: i*- o +J o u re Q. +J at at *r- «f- i- re x: o -a >>■— o

3 *♦- in at 4-j+jai+JOtxi-'- 4J o at i- >— 4-> na x: 4-»aix:x •i- i-4- atoxz-o-MT) re i- O.*J 4-> >i oc+jc at.— at o ■«-

"O m -»J >, at O fl+J k 3X iu > LU C X3 T- X c re"OT3 re re +> ♦>•— •*• Q >0 1 3 .— O i'i-crex:a.m uw

in-.- o. E CT330J+JEO »3U o o t- o a>,c ic r: a; a. ■<- jo at re

<t ■*-> Q- i> re 1-0JV3T3U 'J at <-• u. 4-1 <4- >»3C C tn-r-Oll- O OP r~- u or c -r- at i— 3 c •!■- a x:

U ZD 4- x: 4-J o E > >» o a» *t"a CÜ «I -f- o *-> at at3£rerei-u--£4->E a»

4-> >- _l t- E .— xrre »►-104-m C U 1J CO >,ifl 3 at >> ii L. o re 01 "-• _J en +J •>- u -o x: x: at 0) ■ 3 >> i<- OJ

<_) Q ,—

i*- at *- »— at c c i_t JZ aa >1 an xov E 4-> re 3 o ai c U CM UJ O 0) u O -r- . c •<- •<- CT P E ■--

"O T3 0) u •*- o at i- r- t— "a 3 I- i- -f- c (D r- «t t- rs O. 3 O o E at ai »uc t uai 4* C\J ce <D IA i*- xj x >,HD acx w o ui c: — >» +J •i- o ■<- 4-» -a m re 4J a> _J s- *r re -c ai re c L. at 3 at ai QX cr U HI ro O 4-» "O re at o xj 4-» c c u

m o DO •3" ■^ a» ■<- XTOiA wl ••!- 4) 01 o in ■*-> t_j CO •PEE O u s- a> c >»E> l*- U 4-> < t COX O -r- re l*- a)3~oo«nuicoin

•-- ai l «5 re "o *<- E O -r- -^ -^ E -r- 4-> m >,4-> x: O «n at x: c c w z to DC IX) I- i -o 3

re 3 o z t— O a.- c ai - u+t -f-i-h-3 era« z re VI x: c in re wx O (J U ZJ i/l O CSJ < "O * >» ea 4-»-'~3atcnoj4JO u U QZbJ c cc "Xi in c - o re o t- c 4-> 4-» ■ u X won:

m £ £ O re z ■<- r en E *«- ••*■ re at in re at —i i ^i V c > c % - > -o >» a;

"O «o >- *J 5 Cvj CT»'— ■^- a» at o 3 •— « 4J -i- -o CIlLlfl w <X> c f— at at CX: t--f-Q4JE-'- u r- »0 o o c ■4-J *■' — XJC x: T-H-Q.4J U >QJ3

* G. L 1- u a» 4J C *J -4-1 re re re * •*■* Q. o in CXUJ o o 41 -a <n Oi r- cm» QJ r— in J r- » tO CQ a. ■>-i o at J= at +J Q. • at c ai OJ c: u «3 o «■« u. 0) O LJ U Q.+-» re XUlQlOICC'rOU^

■-- 4-» z o x: a u at O re JZ: at c J5 "O O■■■*- c •- ■*- >> L. L «* a. a. to «-> L. u ■»-» •r- c^Ereo.'—o a» a* x bj at £ c o at c unj o-f flf •»-•.*- w vua: «3 < w ■D ■*- at re yi-r- >>CT>X:Q «3 ID UJ IZD o u -*. £ -c ai at i- x: o o >»x: c Q.-^ X 3 T. <_> -D a < >, u u J- — t*4 x: 4-> o o

c l- 1 u o o >.x: u re 4-t at 1- ai 4-» >> JZ at v re Q.-*-> X U>>X 0) E +-> •— C

! o > — O u o **■ o o E ■*- *» u 4t ai i o U re Q-x: * ■■*-■ *. 3 en < >— < z *J a. i*- at irec\j"04-»re ere

h a co UJ •-• —• üc in u_ ►— "^ m « CO w c t/1 ■-• O *r- i/iQ. 1 in < at JD >» U o uj at o» CT» z t- ^ >> c e 31 -^. X — —

3E O i- i- « Q. 3 3 _i UUU

I ^^

) re at

L. 3 re at i O <-> x: ■*-»

i E at : •<- "o at at re •

•r- X) c ' c E at E : it A o oiC

m •— »n re '

a» u uj

PS >— i. o at z XI < ■•-

x: aa K r*.»— "P «13 r- wf '.. üIMü; H) VI O UJ c a» _J i-

»rt «-» i J u ♦> «t «

■r~ at I c m z to re 3 o z xxa«

00 x

U U3I/I 0> re Z i~' c

«A £ at

o ry < <x ix> in

< -~ CM T> »O >- 4-» CZkVIM so

4-> «J a. i. LU«

o oco — * to CD a.—) o

at flu i. v. < a. at at x uj at

a. </t — X

wwua: <A «0 < t> u-^£

JC JI a: <_»"-> •*- o<

I-. to to ■— to a

at E L.

oi cn X c c x ■■«- — o I- i~ CL 3 3

UJ O O

at < T- 4-> >- _) c ore QJ •- _i

U PJ L

re f— c QJ OJ c in O L QJ _J 1-

UJ at i tJ ca

- 4-> O >, I (/) T3 C XI x: 3 re re re at u -atx:4->i-4->"o -*- a L. t. 3 re at x: = 3inoujz*J jt 3 t. 5. 4-» re I f— at E ai i- sz

>,^ -r- -a at at re 4-» 0 l_ 1- 'rU C -r- oreocE at E 3c

j re re o en t z it_ .,- 4j o «n J O W«T3 m**-in 3 at re c m ■<- at II W 'r j «J 3 OC

in ■— >, OJ *-> O» nrei-cuoc > Or- nj O T- 4-t *r- C -r- ÜUUJS--0 E-—4-»

3 l- re m u 3 m c -a re at at

■r- . o at at at i- 4- 3 X: m Z. 4J CLJZ H- u 4J c re 0.4-: at at J -r- g v re x: 3 H- in O QJ 4-'4->at J o at i- i— 4-t re JZ

LV dt OXT3 4J -» X O C 4-» c n 4-t >, at u re 4-> 3-r-xcre-OT3 re 3 r- O r- I r- C re JZ n'r-a.Ee"O3 0t4-> - ja at re o o i~ -re i— i- at >*- 3 TJ -» i*- x 3 c c

aioxc-r-aii-s -x: 4->OE>>.O 34->atatsrrere&-'

i- E <— x: re >, m 3 T- at >, vi J ■(- U"OJ=X: at at re

It •-—It- QJ 4-» 5. re >, o 't- E 4J D at u o — • c "- i. t- -f- e -a -a at 3.3QOE atat •

r- ^--..- yl V- XJ X >, i -i- O •■- 4-» -O

m m a> c C- >

r i/i ffi at at

r r U T3 (j re -i at re >> in CT >>-c X

o m h r It o.

m our at 4->

>,x: n i- r 4- at 4-> re O re

4-> * re h CT at F r 4->

-i L- 4-* X 01 4-» re re u r re flt c

4J r (- a O 4-> u u <*-. o -o o 4-t at X3

4-» x -n re u Q.4-J

at O u -i r at >

4-" +J

n. in u

S "3 . > a. >, C re

it u at at t.

c •r- Q JZ

1 :

i«- x: 4-1 E at

u o re >, "*- at r- * 4-1 S- r- 01 c e u «J 3 O QJ C •r- CT 4J E •- u ->- o at at c i- u at a. 3 a. c x:

■,- at c in re 3 x: JZ u u at re _ s: in c

m:

o z ex <-* =3 to UM<

CC IX» to s: <— o

at £ ^^~ 4-> < r— CM 0>'

m c x UJ o a. i~ L u oi

o at -a a..-* o ai ou

rexratrec L. ai 3 oi ai QX U4-»T3EreatuQ4-» c c •r- at -r- C x: u «A m *■»- at at ■ 4-».lEous-aic >»E> V

u ■ «t- re I*-- QJ3T3omureOin ifl T3 •<- E O — -f- -r- E '-- ■ i- i "O 3 in>>4-»j=Qmatx: Q.- C li 01 •— U4-» -r- U ¥-

zre-.ijzcmre mjz ■ 3s to +j ■(- 3 atcnat4->o -u IQ o L C*t 4->» z T- c en E •*- -r* re at m

I tJV C > C l- >T3 >,H -» *r- Qt Ot O 3 — "* ■*-* — " r- at at c JC t- •*- a >)£ x: ■<- s- Q.*J c 4-> 4-» re

: o x: a L

re re UJ Z3 O z 3 SI o rs

(J "v. x •r- O <

r- c in • J JZ at 4-» Q. • ai c ai . aw is x i/i ai ai c jorex:atcxit3 0 J L I- 4-t -r- CO :oai cm-oo-r- • r— r— T3 •>- Otre Ur-

JZ at at u x: o o ^ u u m i- •— N - i u o o >>x: u re j<t ii a*j x u >ix »"— OUO*>-uO

! o 5- re a. JZ I ; Z *-> Q-i*- at J re C\J

4-t E ■■- u •— u > at 3 TJ * T- Q. O

at -— IA x oi c u c •<- o u *-* <- E V- •■- >» E re a..— u »Or— -r- -r- r- xenro XJZ C O.'—' SI 4J o o *-> Qj t. at 4-» at E 4-> — c E ■•- si u at

■i- j- 3 en ■o 4-> re c re

:i

. . x u re a «J * u >, * P U p -r- O O

Ot } «(Nj

ili

ii