B )J,I1CCepTaUI10HHbIH COBeT )J, 209.002.05 (lOpl1JJ,Ht-IeCKl1e HayKI1)

npn Mfl1MO MI1)J, POCCI1I1

119454, r. Mocxsa, Ilpocnexr Bepaancxoro, JJ,. 76

OT3bIB

odmuuam.aoro onnouenra na nnccepranmoA H)),a e Bo H ,L(uHbI 3uHB)),HeBHbI

na TeMy «Ilpu n un n pe rynapnocrn nepecsrorpa HaJlOr OBO r o

3aKOHo)),aTeJlbCTBa B rocynapcrnax ofituero npasa», npencr annenuyso naCOUCKaHue y q e H OH CTeneHU xaunanara IOpu)),UqeCKU X uayic n o

cneUUaJlbHOCTU 12.00.04 - <puHaHcoBoe npaao;HaJlO rOBOe npaao; 61O)),lKeTHoe npaso

)J,I1CCepTaUJUI Hanl1CaHa Ha axryam.nyro revy. HaJIOrOBOe

3aKOHOJJ,aTeJIbCTBO nOJJ,BepraeTC5I nOCT05lHHbIM 113MeHeHI151M. 3TO CBOHCTBeHHO He

TOJIbKO rocyzrapcrsaa ofiuiero npaaa, HO 11 POCCI1HCKOH <!>eJJ,epau.l1l1 . Ilpn 3TOM

60JIbillOH Bonpoc KaK CJIeJJ,yeT OTHOCI1TbC5I Ha JJ,OKTPI1HaJIbHOM ypoBHe K 3TOH

nOJJ,BI1)K HOCTI1 (LITO crpaxcaer 3JIaCTl1LIHOCTb HaJIoroo6JIo)KeHI151) HaJIOrOBOro

3aKOHOJJ,aTeJIbCTBa. Ha nepasni B3rJI5IJJ" Hel13MeHHOCTb HaJIOrOBOro

3aKOHOJJ,aTeJIbCTBa 03HaLIaeT ero npeJJ,CKa3yeMocTb 11 Y CI1JII1Ba eT onpeJJ,eJIeHHOCTb

npas o aoro nOJIO)KeHI151 HaJIOrOnJIaTeJIbml1Ka. Ho C npyroi! CTOpOH bI, orcyrcraae

c aoes peraennoii peaKUl111 3aKOHOJJ,aTeJI5I na 113MeHeHl1e COUl1aJIbHO-3KOHOMI1LIeCKI1X

n orpefin ocreit B )K113HI1 ofiuiecrna, KOHcepBau.l151 yace HeaJJ,eKBaTHbIX npaaoasrx

npeJJ,nl1CaHI1H necer B ce6e He MeHbilll1H Bp eJJ, . n03TOMY nOI1CK 6aJIaHCa Me)KJJ,y

nOJJ,BI1)KHOCTblO HaJIOrOBOro 3aKOHOJJ,aTeJIbCTBa 11 ero cTa6l1JIbHOCTblO 51BJI5IeTC5I

s e c i.v a aKTyaJIbHOH TeMoH JJ,JI5I nay-more 113yLIeHI151 .

A BTOp pa60TbI I1CnOJIb3yeT orpovusrfi o6beM 3apy6e)KHOH JII1TepaTypbI 11

npaBOBoro per y JIl1p OBa H I151 BonpocoB 113MeHeHI151 HaJIOrOBOro 3aKOHOJJ,aTeJIbCTBa,

LITO JJ,eJIaeT pafiory OLIeHb I1HTepeCHOH JJ,JI5I 113yLIeHI151. BbIBOJJ,bI asropa B ueJIOM

JJ,OCTOBepHbI 11 OTpa)KalOT HayLIHylO HO Bl13HY pe3YJIbTaTOB JJ,I1CCepTaUI10HHOrO

I1CCJIeJJ,OBaHI151, a TaK)Ke I1MelOT aecoraaennyro ueHHOCTb JJ,JI5I HayKI1 11 npaKTI1KI1 .

B LIaCTHOCTI1, asrop aa CTp. 18 JJ,I1CCepTaUI1I1 OTMeLIaeT: «Ilpnnuan

p e r y JI5Ip HOCTI1 nepecxrorpa HaJIOrOBOro 3aKOHOJJ,aTeJIbCTBa KaK CBOHCTBO

HaJIOrOBOH CI1CTeMhI oana-raer CnOC06HOCTh rocyzrapcraeansrx OpraHOB

CBOeBpeMeHHO BHOCI1Th aeofixonnvsre 113MeHeHlUI B I1CTOqHI1KI1 HaJIOrOBOrO npasa

11 cannerenscrnyer 06 3naCTl1qHOCTl1 I1nl1 rl16KOCTl1 HaJIoro06no)l(eHI151».

ABTOp pa60TbI COBepweHHO cnpaBe.nJII1BO apryaeirrnpyer .naHHhIH: npnnrnm

TaKI1MI1 CBOHCTBaMI1 HaJIoro06no)l(eHI151 KaK 3JIaCTl1qHOCTh 11 r116KOcTb.

3naCTl1qHOCTh 11 rl16KOCTb HaJIoro06no)l(eHI151 asrpaacaror no 60nbwoMy CQeTY

a.neKBaTHOCTb npaaosoro peryJIl1pOBaHI151, xorna saxoaonarens OnepaTI1BHO

pearnpyer ua 113MeHeHl1e COU:l1anhHO-3KOHOMI1QeCKI1X OTHOWeHI1H B 06II.J,eCTBe 11

MO.nI1<pI1U:l1pyeT npasonoe perynapoaanne B 06naCTl1 HaJIOr006no)l(eHI151. ITPI1 3TOM

aBTOp na CTp. 23 pa60TbI sepno yxaasrsaer, QTO B I1CCJIe.nOBaHI151X 03CP B

OTHOWeHl111 nparnnma rl16KOCTl1 OTMeQaeTC5I cnertyrouree: HaJIOrOBhle CI1CTeMhI

.nOJI)I(HbI 6bITb .nOCTaTOQHO rl16Kl1Ml1 11 .nI1HaMI1QHhIMI1 .nn51 06eCneQeHI151

COOTBeTCTBI151 pa3Bl1Tl11O TeXHOnOrl1H: 11 6113Heca. Hanorosaa CI1CTeMa .nOJI)I(Ha

6bITb .nOCTaTOQHO .nI1HaMI1QHOH:, QT06hI 06eCneQl1Th <pI1HaHCOBble nOTpe6HOCTl1

npaBI1TeJIhCTBa 11 B TO xce BpeM5I nOCT05lHHO npl1cnOCa6JII1BaThC5I K 113MeH5I1OII.J,I1MC5I

nOTpe6HOCT5IM. 3TO 03HaQaeT, QTO rocyztapcrso .nOJI)I(HO I1MeTb I1HCTpYMeHTbI .nn51

nepecvorpa onpenenennsrx HaJIOrOB I1JII1 ornensusrx 3JIeMeHTOB iopamrsecxoro

COCTaBa nanora no Mepe He06xo.nI1MOCTI1, YQI1ThIBa51 nenpencxasyeaocrs

3KOHOMl1QeCKl1X 11 <pI1HaHCOBbIX npoueccos, B TOM QI1CJIe na rn06aJIhHOM ypoane.

u'I1KnI1QHOCTh 3KOHOMl1QeCKOrO pa3BI1TI151, BhICOKa51 BOnaTl1nbHOCTh

cupsensrx, TOBapHhIX, <pI1HaHCOBbIX PbIHKOB B COBpeMeHHylO anoxy rJI06anl13aU:1111

11 6bICTporo pa3BI1TI151 TeXHOnOrl1H 11 6113HeCa nenaior Hel136e)l(HbIM OnepaTI1BHOe

pearnposanne 3aKOHo.naTen51 B HanorOBOH crpepe na raxne 113MeHeHI151. ECJII1 eure

BO BpeMeH5I Anaxra CMI1Ta MO)l(HO 6bIJ10 nOHI1MaTb onpenenenuocri, nanorosorc

3aKOHo.naTeJIhCTBa KaK ero HeI13MeHHOCTb, TO B nacroatuee BpeM5I Tpe60BaHl1e

orrpenenennocru HaJIOrOBOro 3aKOHa 11 Hel13MeHHOCTl1 B .nnI1TeJIhHOM npovexyrxe

BpeMeHI1 CTaHOB5ITC5I COBepweHHO pa3nl1QHbIMl1 nOH5ITI151MI1.

B uacroaruee BpeM5I 06pa30BaTenbHbIH yposens nanoronnarem.unncoa

noscnr.uo BbICOK, I1H<popMaU:110HHble CI1CTeMbI ztenaror ztocryrmoji CBe.neHI151 06

113MeHeHl1l1 nanorosoro aaxoaonare.u.crna eure zto npl1.naHI151 11M CI1JIhI 3aKOHa.

2

HaJIOrOnJIaTeJIbllI}IKH Hapa60TaJIH npaKTHKH nOCTO~HHOrO MOHHTOpHHra

H3MeHeHHH 3aKOHO,lI,aTeJIbCTBa H ztazce TpaKTOBOK ero npHMeHeHH~, a TaK)I{e

npaBonpHMeHHTeJIbHOH npaKTHKH. B CTpeMHTeJIbHO MeH~lOw.eMC~ MHpe

OTCTaHBaeMbIH aBTopOM npHHUHn perYJI~pHOrO nepecsiorpa HaJIOrOBOro

3aKOHO,lI,aTeJIbCTBa HMeeT see npasa ,lI,eHCTBHTeJIbHO paCCMaTpHBaTbC~B xauecrae

saacaeinuero npmnnma HaJIOrOBOro npaaa,

ABTOp na CTp. 44-45 pa60TbI OTMeqaeT, qTO HCCJIe,lI,OBaHHe orpaxcenna

npHHUHna perYJI~pHOrO nepecMoTpa HaJIOrOBOro 3aKOHO,lI,aTeJIbCTBa B npaBoBoH

,lI,OKTpHHe n03BOJI~eTC,lI,eJIaTb BbIBO,lI, 0 TOM, 4TO ,lI,aHHbIH npHHUHn npH3HaeTC~ KaK

HHOCTpaHHbIMH npaaoaenaxra, TaK H OTe4eCTBeHHbIMH, O,lI,HaKO, cpasuenue

OTeqeCTBeHHOH H sapyfiexcnoii ,lI,OKTPHHbI orpazcaror pa3HHUy nO,lI,XO,lI,OB K ero

H3Y4eHHlO H oueuxe ero 3Ha4eHH~. I1HOCTpaHHbIe y-reusre He npOCTO BKJIlO4alOT

,lI,aHHbIH npHHUHn B cacrevy npHHUHnOB HaJIOrOBOro npasa, HO H CB~3bIBalOT

npHHUHn perYJI~pHOCTH nepeCMOTpa HaJIOrOBOro 3aKOHO,lI,aTeJIbCTBa C

3Q>Q>eKTHBHOCTblO HaJIOrOBOH CHCTeMbI, a TaK)I{e aHaJIH3J1pYlOT MeTO,lI,bI ero

peaJIJ13aUJ1H J1 B03MO)l{HbIe nerarnaasre nOCJIe,lI,CTBH~ OTCYTCTBJ1~

CHCTeMaTH4eCKoro nepecxtorpa HaJIOrOBbIX HOpM. 3apy6e)l{HbIe HCCJIe,lI,OBaTeJIJ1

OTHOC~T YKa3aHHbIH npHHUHn K CHCTeMoo6pa3ylOw.HM npHHUJ1naM.

I1PJ1 :n OM , KaK CnpaBe,lI,JIHBO YKa3bIBaeT aBTOp, J13yqeHJ1e OTe4eCTBeHHOH

npaBOBOH ,lI,OKTPJ1HbI H, B 4aCTHOCTH, HCCJIe,lI,OBaHJ1H, nocasuienm,rx npJ1HUHnaM

HaJIOrOBOro npasa, nOKa3bIBaeT OTCyTcTBHe llIJ1pOKOrO npH3HaHJ1~ npnnunna

perYJI~pHOCTH nepecvorpa HaJIOrOBOro 3aKOHO,lI,aTeJIbCTBa. HeMHOr01.J.J1CJIeHHbIe

pa60TbI OTe4eCTBeHHbIX Y4eHbIX, B KOTOpbIX ynostnaaercs ,lI,aHHbIH npHHUJ1n,

orpaHH4I1BalOTC~ npOCTOH KOHCTaTaUI1eH ero cyw.eCTBOBaHJ1~, OTHOC~ npJ1HUHn

3JIaCTH4HOCTH (nO,lI,BH)I{HOCTH) nanoroofinozceaaa K 4HCJIy opraHH3aUHOHHbIX

npHHUHnOB. B TO »ce BpeM~ B HeKOTopbIX I1CCJIe,lI,OBaHH~XOTMe4aeTC~,4TO B ueJI~X

HaJIOrOBOro perYJIJ1pOBaHH~ 3aKOHO,lI,aTeJIlO CJIe,lI,yeT yqJ1TbIBaTb H3MeHeHH~,

npOHCXO,lI,~w.He B )l{H3HH rocynapcrsa H 06w.eCTBa H npeoxne ncero B

3KOHOMH4eCKOH crpepe. MHorHMH asropann npHHUI1n perYJI~pHOCTH nepecvorpa

HaJIOrOBOro 3aKOHO,lI,aTeJIbCTBa npOTI1BOnOCTaBJI~eTC~ npHHUHny cTa6J1JIbHOCTH:

3

pexoveunyercs COLIeTaTb CI1CTeMaTI1LIeCKI1H nepecsiorp HaJIOrOBbIX HOpM .nJI5I

06eCneLIeHI151 I1X COOTBeTCTBI151 I13MeHeHI151M, npOI1Cxo.n5lw.I1M B perynnpyevstx

I1MI1 npaBOOTHOWeHI151X, C nepaonavu cTa6I1JIbHOCTI1.

TaKI1M 06pa30M, n. 3. Aiinaeaa cnpaBe.nJII1BO CBoeH pafioroii HaLII1HaeT

«fiopsfiy aa npI13HaHJ1e» aroro npI1HUI1na B OTeLIeCTBeHHOH .nOKTpI1He HaJIOrOBOro

npasa. B 3TOM 51BHa51 HayLIHa51 HOBI13Ha ee pa60TbI.

HayLIHa51 HOBI13Ha .nI1CCepTaUI10HHOrO I1CCJIe.nOBaHI151 Bwpa~aeTC5I B

nOJIO~eHI151X, BbIHOCI1MbIX aa 3aw.I1TY.

B LIaCTHOCTI1, aa 3aw.I1TY BbIHOCI1TC5I Te3I1C 0 TOM, LITO peaJIJ13aUJ151 na

npaKTI1Ke npI1HUJ1na pery JI5IpHOCTI1 nepeCMOTpa HaJIOrOBOrO 3aKOHO.naTeJIbCTBa

n03BOJI5IeT OnepaTI1BHO anarrruposa'n. npasonue HOPMbI K I13MeHeHI151M B

3KOHOMI1LIeCKOH cdiepe 11 HaJIOrOBOH nOJII1TI1Ke rocynapcrsa. HanpOTI1B,

I1rHOpI1pOBaHI1e rocynapcrnoxr COCT05lHI151 HaUI10HaJIbHOH 3 KOHOM I1KJ1 J1

OT.neJIbHbIX ee OTpaCJIeH, a raioxe nOJIO~eHI151 HaJIOrOnJIaTeJIbw.J1KOB Mo~eT

npI1BeCTI1 K CHI1~eHJ11O HaJIOrOBbIX .nOXO.nOB 61O.n~eTa, HeraTI1BHO CKa3aTbC5I aa

pe3YJIbTaTI1BHOCTI1 HaJIOrOBOro a.nMI1HI1CTpI1pOBaHI151, HapYWI1Tb 6aJIaHC

ny6JII1LIHbIX 11 LIaCTHbIX I1HTepeCOB.

3TO npennoacenne asropa Hy~.naeTC5I B o.nH03HaLIHoH nonzrepaoce.

K LII1CJIY .nOCTOJ1HCTB pa60TbI MO~HO OTHeCTI1 11 TO , LITO aBTOp OnI1paeTC5I,

KaK yxce 6bIJ10 oTMeLIeHo, aa COJII1.nHbIH MaCCI1B KaK OTeLIeCTBeHHOH, Ta K 11

aapytiexorof JII1TepaTypbI.

Bsrcoxa crenens anpo6aUI1I1 pe3YJIbTaTOB I1CCJIe.nOBaHI151. OCHoBHbIe

pe3YJIbTaTbI .nI1ccepTaUI1I1 ony6JII1KOBaHbI 11 orpaacem.r B HayLIHbIx xcypnanax,

pexoveunoaaunux BAK P<D, a raroxe I13JIaraJII1Cb na HayLIHo-npaKTJ1LIeCKI1X

KOHCpepeHUI151x.

B ueJIOM aBTOp nOJIHO 11 CI1CTeMHO I13YLIJ1JI np06JIeMbI peryJI5IpHOrO

nepecvorpa HaJIOrOBOro 3aKOHo.naTeJIbCTBa B rocy ziapcraax o6w.ero npasa 11

C<pOpMyJII1pOBaJI pxn nOJIO~eHI1H, 06JIa.nalOw.I1X HayLIHoH HOBI13HOH.

4

O)J,HaKO, B pafiore cyuiecrsyror 11 nOJIO)KeHI151, xoropue BbI3bIBalOT

3aMeyaHI151 I1JII1 HY)K)J,alOTC5I B )J,OnOJIHI1TeJIbHOH apryMeHTaUI1I1.

1. Ha CTp. 13 B YI1CJIe nOJIO)KeHI1H, BbIHOCI1MbIX na 3amI1TY, pa60TbI aBTOp

orve-raer, YTO uonxon K epOpMyJII1pOBaHI1lO npe)J,JIO)KeHI1H no nepecvorpy

HaJIOrOBOro 3aKOHO)J,aTeJIbCTBa, KOTOpbIH OrpaHI1YI1BaeT nOJIHOMOYI151 YJIeHOB

napnaereirra no BbI)J,BI1)KeHI1lO 3aKOHO)J,aTeJIbHbIX I1HI1UI1aTI1B B HaJIOrOBOH cdiepe

I1JI11 , no KpaHHeH Mepe, rpefiyer nOJIO)KI1TeJIbHOe 3aKJIlOyeHI1e npaBI1TeJIbCTBa,

CHI1)KaeT KOJII1yeCTBO HaJIOrOBbIX 3aKOHonpoeKTOB, xoropue He I1MelOT

nepCneKTI1B K npI1H5ITI1lO, 11 B ueJIOM, OKa3bIBaeT nOJIO)KI1TeJIbHOe BJII151HI1e ua

cTa6I1JIbHOCTb HaJIOrOBOro 3aKOHO)J,aTeJIbCTBa.

fIpe)J,CTaBJI5IeTC5I cnopnsnr npennoxceane asropa OrpaHI1YI1Tb B03MO)KHOCTb

napnavetrrapnea no CBoeH I1HI1UI1aTI1Be 11 6e3 0)J,06peHI151 I1CnOJIHI1TeJIbHOH BJIaCTI1

BHOCI1Tb nOnpaBKI1 B HaJIOrOBOe 3aKOHO)J,aTeJIbCTBO. fIpe)J,CTaBJI5IeTC5I, YTO

peaJII13aUI151 raxoro npe)J,JIO)KeHI151 asropa MO)KeT npI1BeCTI1 K uapyurenmo

CI1CTeMbI C)J,ep)KeK H npOTHBOBeCOB B CI1CTeMe pa3)J,eJIeHI151 BJIaCTeH. <PaKTHyeCKH B

3TOM CJIyYae 3aKOHO)J,aTeJIbHbIH oprau BJIaCTH JII1WHTC5I B03MO)KHOCTH

perynuposars sonpocsr HaJIoro06JIo)KeHI151 6e3 0)J,06peHH5I I1CnOJIHHTeJIbHOH

BJIaCTI1. Bp5l)J, JIH TaKOH nonxon MO)KeT 6bITb npaBHJIbHbIM. Ilpn 3TOM 60JIhWOe

KOJII1yeCTBO 3aKOHOTBOpyeCKI1X HHHUHaTI1B, xoropue BHOC5IT OT)J,eJIbHhIe YJIeHhI

napnaxienra, HO xoropsre TaK H He CTaHOB5ITC5I 3aKOHaMH, He Bpe)J,51T HaJIOrOBOH

CI1CTeMe, a Ha060pOT C03)J,alOT OCHOBy )J,JI5I )J,I1CKyCCHH 0 nyrax

COBepweHCTBOBaHI151 HaJIOrOBOH CI1CTeMhI.

2. ABTop He aHaJII13I1pyeT B pafiore CneUI1epHKY npaaosoro peryJIHpOBaHI151

I1HBeCTHUI10HHbIX npoexros. B parte crpan, B TOM YI1CJIe 11 B POCCI1I1 cyuiecrsyer

npaBI1JIO «)J,e)J,ywKI1HOH orOBOpKI1», COrJIaCHO KOTOpOMy HaJIOrOBOe

3aKOHO)J,aTeJIbCTBO He MO)KeT MeH5ITbC5I B Xy)J,WylO )J,JI5I I1HBeCTOpa CTOpOHy )J,O

3aBepWeHI151 I1HBeCTI1UI10HHOrO npoexra I1JIH KaKorO-TO )J,JII1TeJIbHOrO nepnona

BpeMeHH.

5

ITpe.uCTaBJI5IeTC5I , q TO pafiory ofiorarnn 6bl ananns COOTHOWeHI151

OTCTal1BaeMOrO aBTOpOM rrpl1HUl1rra peryJI5IpHOCTI1 rrepeCMOTpa HaJIOrOBOrO

3aKOHO.uaTeJIbCTBa 11 pe)KI1Ma «.ue.uYWKI1HOH OrOBOpKI1».

Y«asaa uue 3aMeqaHI151 He BJII151IOT aa rrOJIO)KI1TeJIbHYIO ouenxy

I1CCJIe.uOBaHI151 ,ll.. 3. AH.uaeBoH . ,ll.I1CCepTaUI10HHOe I1CCJIe.uOBaHl1e Aiinaesoii ,ll.I1HbI

31151B.ul1e BHbI ofiorauiaer nayxy HaJIOrOBOro npaaa TeOpeTl1qeCKI1MI1

rr OJIO)K e HI151MI1 , I1CCJIe.uOBaHl1e ofinanaer 51pKO Bblpa)KeHHOH npaxru-recicoil

HarrpaBJIeHHOCTblO 11 MO)KeT 6bITb I1CrrOJIb30BaHO B rrpaBOrrpl1MeHI1TeJIbHOH

nesrensnOCTI1.

ABTope~epaT .uI1CCepTaUI1I1 11 HayqHWe rry6JIl1KaUl1l1 OTpa)KalOT OCHOBHoe

conepacanae nposeneaaoro ero I1CCJIe.uO BaHI151.

Saxmosenue no ouccepmauuonnoii pa6ome. 03BYQeHHble ssuue 3aMeQaHI151 B

ueJIOM He CHI1)KaIOT ueHHOCTI1 rrO JIYQeHHbIX pe3YJIbTaTOB. AKTyaJIbHOCTb TeMbI

I1CCJIe.uOBaHI151 , .uOCTOBepHOCTb 11 060CHOBaHHOCTb rrO JIYQeHHbIX HaYQHbIX

pe3YJIbTaTOB rr03BOJI5IIOT OueHI1Tb .uI1CCepTaUI1IO Aiutaeaoii ,ll..3. KaK

caMOCT05lTeJIbHOe 11 rnytioxoe I1CCJIe.uOBaHl1e 11 3aKOHQeHHYlO HayQHO-

KBaJII1~I1KaUI10HHYIO pafiory, KOTOpa51 OTJII1QaeTC5I HOBI13HOH, a TaK)Ke

TeOpeTI1QeCKOM 11 rrpaKTI1QeCKOH 3HaQI1MOCTblO . Co.uep)KaHl1e .uI1CCe p Ta U I10 HHOH

pa60TbI COOTBeTcTByeT CrreUl1aJIbHOCTI1 12.00.04 « <1>I1HaHc o Bo e npaso;

HaJIOrOBOe npaso; 61O.u)KeTHOe npaso».

B 3aKJIIOQeHl1e MO)KHO OTMeTI1Tb, QTO rro.urOTOBJIeHHOe .uI1CCe p Ta U I10 HHOe

I1CCJIe.uOBa Hl1e «ITpI1HUl1rr peryJI5IpHOCTI1 nepecsrorpa HaJIOrOBOro

3aKOHo.uaTeJIbCTBa B rocynapcrsax ofiuiero npaaa» coornercrayer Tpe6oBaHI151M,

rrpe.ub5lBJI5IeMbIM B A K pep K .uI1CCe p Ta U I151 M aa COI1CKaHl1e YQe HOH CTerreHI1

xaazmnara IOpl1.uI1QeCKI1X nayx, B COOTBeTCTBl111 C ITOJIO)KeHl1eM 0 rrpl1cY)K.ueHI1I1

YQ eH bIX c r e n e n e ii , YTBep)K.ueHHbIM ITocTaHOBJIeHl1eM ITpaBI1TeJIbCTBa P<1> OT 24

CeHT5I6 p 51 2013 rona NQ 842, C 113MeHeHI151MI1 rrOCTaHOBJIeHI151 ITpaBI1TeJIbCTBa pep

OT 2 a srycra 2016 r. NQ748 "0 BHeCeHl111 113MeHeHl1M B ITOJIO)KeHl1e 0

6

npacyxctennn yseasrx creneaeii'', aero aBTOp Aiinaena )],.3. 3aCJlY)l(HBaeT

npncyxnenns y-reaoii crenen» KaH.ll,H.ll,aTa lOpH.ll,HqeCKHX nayx rro CrreUHaJlbHOCTH

12.00.04 - «<l>HHaHcoBoe npaso; HaJlOrOBOe npaso; 61O.ll,)I(eTHOe npaso».

)],.M. llJ,eKHH

O~HUHaJlbHbIM onnonenr:

xaununat lOpH.ll,HqeCKHX nayx, noueirr xarpeztps: ~HHaHcoBoro npasaH)pH.ll,HqeCKOrO 4JaKyJlbTeTa <l>e.ll,epaJlbHOrO rocy~apcTBeHHOrO

06pa30BaTeJlbHOrO Yqpe)l(.ll,eHH5I Bsrcurero TIpo4JeccHOHaJlbHOrO 06pa30BaHH5I

"MOCKOBCKHM rocynapcrscnnuii yHHBepcHTeT HMeHH M.B. Jlovonocoaa» llJ,eKHH)],eHHc MHXaMJlOBHq

119991 , r. Mocxsa, rCTI-I , JIeHHHcKHe ropsr , zt. 1, crpoeane 13 (4-Myqe6HbIM xopnyc), d.schekin@schekin1aw.ru , T. 8 963 618 34 74

llJ,eKHHbIM )],. M . B 2001 r. aaunuuena .ll,HCCepTaUH5I na COHCKaHHe y-renoii

crenenu xaannnara lOpH.ll,HqeCKHX HayK rro reve «H)pH.ll,HqeCKHe npeayvnumr B

HaJlOrOBOM npase», rro CrreUHaJlbHOCTH 12.00.12 - <l>HHaHcoBoe npaso:61O.ll,)I(eTHOe npaso; HaJlOrOBOe npaso; fiamconcxoe npaso; namorno-npaaonoeperynapoaanne; npaaosoe perynapoaanae BbIIIycKa H ofipauiemrs uennstx 6yMar;npasonue OCHOBbI ay.ll,HTOpCKOM ~e5lTeJlbHOCTH.

7