Upload
rustanfani
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
1/37
Ch ang in g App r oach es t o Reg ion a l
Econ om ic Deve lopm en t :Focus ing on En do g eno u s Fact or s
Rober t J St im sonI m m ed ia te Past P residen t o f RSAI
an dUQ Soc ia l Research Cent re , I ns t i t u t e for Soc ia l Sc ience Research
The Un ivers i t y o f Queens landBr isbane ,Aus t ra l ia
Rog er R St ou ghPres ident o f RSAI
an dSchoo l o f Pub l ic po l i cy
Georg e Mason Un iv ers i t yFa i r fax , VA, US
Finan cia l Deve lopm ent and Reg ion a l Econ om ies RSAI - BCRA
13 -1 4 March , 2008Buenos Ai res , Argen t in a
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
2/37
Th is add r ess p r ov ides.
A n o ver v i e w o f t h e e vo lu t i o n o f t h e o r et i cal e co n o m icdeve lopm en t and po l i cy and p lann ing pa rad igm s as
app roaches to t he s tudy and p r act i ce o f r eg iona l econom icg r o w t h a n d d ev e lo p m e n t .
An em ph asis i s on th e p rocesses o f endogen ous reg ion a lg r o w t h a n d d eve lop m e n t a n d h o w t h o se f act o r s af f e ct i n ge n d o ge n o u s d e velo p m e n t m ig h t b e m o d eled .
A su m m a r y r e ce n t l y w o r k b y t h e au t h o r s t o d eve lo p a n e wf r a m e w o r k t o co n ce p t u a l ize a n d m o d el e n d o g en o u s r e g ion a le co n o m ic g r o w t h a n d d eve lop m e n t .
A d iscu ssio n o f a n ew p lan n in g s t r a t e g y f r a m e w o r k f o rr e g ion a l eco n o m ic d eve lop m e n t t h a t i s f i r m l y e m b e d d ed i nth e p r in c ip les o f endogenous reg iona l g row th andd e velo p m e n t t h a t i s p r o p o se d b ySt i m so n , St o u g h a n d Ro b er t s ( 2 0 0 6 ) Region a l Econom ic Deve lopm ent : Ana lys i s and Plann in g St r a tegy , Spr inger
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
3/37
Reg iona l econom ic deve lopm en t as ap r o d u c t a n d a p r o cess
I t i s t h e p r oduc t o f reg iona l econom ic deve lopm en t :
m e as u re d i n j o b s, w e al t h , i n v e stm e n t , st a n d a rd o f l i v i n g , a n dw o r k i n g co n d it i o n s - w i t h w h i ch p e op l e l iv i n g , w o r k i n g an d i n v est i n gi n r e g io n s t e n d t o b e m o st co n c ern e d
gene ra l l y , inc reases o r im prov em en t s in t hese m easu r es a re equa ted
w i t h e co n o m i c g r o w t h a n d d e v el o pm e n t .
I t i s t h e process o f r eg iona l econom ic dev e lopm en t :
f o r e x a m p le , i n d u s t r y s u p p o r t , in f r a st r u c tu re , la b o r f o r c e or h u m a nca p i t a l d ev e lop m e n t , a n d m a rk e t d e v elo p m e n t
w i th w h i ch r e g ion a l s ci e n t i st s a n d r e g io n a l e co n o m ic d ev e lop m e n tp l a n n ers a n d p ra c t i t i o n e r s t e n d t o b e m o st c on c ern e d .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
4/37
Som e de f i n i t i ons o f r eg iona l econom ic
d e v e l o p me n t
Blakelys (1994) has definition:. a p rocess i n w h i ch l oca l govern m en ts o r com m un i t y basedo rgan i za t i ons a re engaged to st im u la te o r m a in ta inb u s in e ss act i v i t y a n d / o r e m p l o y m e n t . Th e p r i n c ip a l g o al o fl oca l econom ic deve lopm en t i s t o s t im u la te em p loym en to p p o r t u n i t i e s i n se ct o r s t h a t i m p ro v e t h e c om m u n i t y , u si n g
e x i st i n g h u m a n , n a t u r a l an d i n s t i t u t i o n al r e so u rc es (p . x v ) .
Maleckis (1991) definition:. a com b ina t i on o f qu a l it a t i ve and quan t i t a t i ve f ea tu r es o f a
re g i o n s eco n o m y , w h i ch t h e q u a l i t a t i v e o r s t r u ct u ra l [ a re ]
t h e m ost m ean ing fu lThe qua l it a t i ve a t t r i bu t es i nc lude thety pes o f j obsno t on l y t h e i r num berand l ong - t e rm ands t ru ctu ra l charac te r i s t i cs , such as t h e ab i l i t y t o b r i ng abou tn e w e co n o m i c a ct i v i t y a n d t h e c ap a ci t y t o m a x i m i ze t h eb e n ef i t s w h i ch re m a in s w i t h i n t h e re g io n ( p . 7 ) .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
5/37
Econom ic developm en t t hu s has bo t h aq u an t i t a t i v e an d a q u al i t a t i ve d im en si on
I t i s q u a n t i t a t i v e w i th r espect t o t h e m easu r ed benef i t si t c r eates t h r ou gh :
i n c reasing w ea l th and income leve ls t h e ava i lab i l i t y o f goods and serv i ces
im p ro v i n g f i n a n cia l se cu r i t y and so -on .
I t i s a lso qua l i t a t i ve i n :
cre a t i n g g r e ate r s oci a l/ f i n a n cia l eq u i t y ach iev ing sus ta inab le deve lopm en t cre a t i n g a s p re ad i n t h e r a n g e o f e m p lo y m e n t
g a in i n g im p r o v e m e n t s i n t h e q u a l i t y o f l i f e i n a r eg i o n .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
6/37
Reg iona l econom ic deve lopm en t as a m a t r i x
o f qua l i t a t i ve , quan t i t a t i ve , p r ocess andp r od u ct o u t com es
REGIONAL ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT MATRIX
Regional Economic Process
Policy
PlanningAnalysis
Strategy
Resource application etc.
Regional Economic Product
Employment
WealthInvestment
Infrastructure
Quality of life etc.
Qualitat
ive
Inputs/O
utput
Quan
tita
tiv
e
In
pu
ts/O
utp
ut
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
7/37
St i m so n , St o u g h a n d Ro b er t s ( 2 0 0 6 ) , Regiona l Econ om ic Deve lopm ent : Ana ly s is and Plann ing
S t ra tegy ( Sp r i n g e r ) , g i v e t h i s d e f in i t i o n of r e g io n a leconom i c dev e lopm en t
Re g io n a l eco n o m i c d e v el o p m e n t i s t h e a p p li ca t i o n o feconom ic p r ocesses and r esour ces ava i lab le to a r eg ion t ha t
resu l t i n t he susta inab le developm en t o f , and desi red econom ico u t c o m e s f o r a r e g io n a n d t h a t m e et t h e v a l u e s a n dexpecta t i ons o f bus iness , o f r esiden ts and o f v i s it o r s .
W hi le th i s def in i t i on i s f a r f r om pe r fect , i t does re f l ect ash i f t i n e co n o m i c p r o d u ct a n d p r o ce ss t h i n k i n g .
A balance bet w een t he qua l i t a t i ve and quan t i t a t i ve goal s o feconom ic deve lopm en t p r esen ts a cha l l enge t o t r ad i t i ona lneoclass ical econom ist s and to t h e em erg ing b r eed o feconom ist s w ho recogn i ze tha t r eg ional econom ic deve lopm en tcan occur on a m or e sus t a inab le bas is .
Th is i s no t t o sugges t t ha t neoc lassical th eory id eas shou ld b ed i sm issedfa r f r om i t .Ra the r , t h ey need to evo l ve to accom m oda te t h ose chang ingva lues t ha t socie t y h o lds on expec ted ga ins f rom econom icdeve lopmen t .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
8/37
Evo lv in g pa r ad igm s fo r econom ic po l i cy and
r eg iona l developm en t p l ann ing st r a t egy
Po l i cy f o r econom ic deve lopm en t and reg iona l p lann ings t ra t egy has unde rgone a se r i es o f evo lu t i ona ry s tages du r i ngt h e p e r i o d si n ce W o r l d W a r I I , d r i v e n b y d i f f ere n t p a ra d i g m s o fe co n o m i c t h o u g h t .
Those parad igm s have shaped th e w ay reg ions and l oca lco m m u n i t i e s a n d p e op l e t h i n k a b ou t , a n d p l an f o r , t h e f u t u re .
But.
m u c h t h i n k i n g o n r e g io n a l eco n o m i c d e v el o p m e n t s t i l l r e m a in sem bedded i n t h e pa rad igm s o f t he 197 0s , because o f aninhe ren t re luc tance o f m any reg ions and l oca l com m un i t i es t o
p ro - act i ve l y em br ace change .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
9/37
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
10/37
Chan g ing f ocus f o r econom ic deve lopm en t
po l icy and p l ann ing s t r a t egy
Focus of Econom ic Policy
Keynsian thought
Postwar - mid 1970s
M onetarism thought
M id 1970s 1990sRationalist thoughtlate 1980s 199 0s
1960 1970 1980 1990 2000
Public
Economic
DevelopmentAgencies
Regulatory
Economic
Development,
M ixed economic
Development
Sustainable
development
Initiatives to
improve
environmental
and overall
quality of lifeto attract highly
skilled workers
and firms
Focus on
Value-adding
strategies.
Incorporating
workforce and
technology
change
Initiatives to
reduce social
disparities by
incorporating
disadvantaged
groups into the
mainstream
economy
Focus of Econom ic Planning Strategy
Com parative Advantage Com petitive Ad vantage
Collaborative Advantage
Master Planning Infrastructure oriented
Goals and
Objectives
Planning
Multi sector
Integrated
Strategic
Planning
Integrated
Strategic
Planning
Structure
PlanningStrategic
Planning
Sustainability
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
11/37
The paper d i scusses a nu m ber o f im po r t an t
i ssues t ha t a r e ev i den t i n t he con t ex t o ft hose evo lu t i ons i n pa r ad igm s
Fi r s t , t her e is a d iscussion o f neo-c lass ica l econom ic th eory asth e bas is o f reg iona l deve lopm en t t heo ry .
Second , t he r e i s a d iscuss ion o f t he evo lu t ion o f econom icpo l i cy f r om Keynes ian t hough t and t he assoc iat ed ma s t e rp lann ing p a ra d ig m s t o mo n e t a r i s m an d econom ic ra t i ona l i smand t he assoc iat ed goa l s and ob j ect i ves an d s t ra t eg i c p lann ingp a ra d i g ms .
Th i r d , t he re i s a d i scuss ion o f t he sh i f t ove r t im e f rom a focuson co m p a ra t i v e a d v a n t a g e t o co m p e t i t i v e a d v a n t a g e an d m o r ere ce n t l y t o t h e n o t i o n o f co l l abo ra t i ve advan t age.
Four t h , t he r e i s a d iscuss ion o f t he p r ocesses o f g loba l i za t ion
and t he em ergence o f conce rn f o r ach iev ing sus ta inab ledeve lopmen t , and t he focus on reg ion a l sel f -h e lp i n t h e p u rs u i to f en d o g e n o u s g ro w t h .
And f i f t h , t he re i s a d i scuss ion o f t he evo lu t i on o f t he newg r o w t h t h e or y .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
12/37
So m e im p l i cat i o n s t o d r aw f r o m t h atd iscuss ion
A t o n e t i m e re g io n s w e re p ro t e ct e d f r o m o u t s i d e co m p e t i t i o n ,a n d t o s o m e ex t e n t t h e ir e co n o m i es w e re ab l e t o b e
m a n i p u la t e d b y n a t i o n al g o v ern m e n t s.
Bu t t ha t i s no l onge r t he case as t h e econom ic ra t i ona l ismp u rs u e d b y m a n y n a t i o n al g o v ern m e n t s le f t m a n y re g i on s t ofend fo r t hem selves.
Reg ions st i l l con t i nue to l ook t o h ighe r l eve l s o f gove rn m en t f o rsuppo r t and r esou r ces t o p rov ide econom ic d i rec t i on andi n v est m e n t t o s t i m u l at e e co n o m i c d e v el o p m e n t .
H ow e v er , u n f o r t u n a t e l y , m a n y re g i o n s f a i l t o u n d e rst a n d t h a tg loba l izat i on has l ef t such gov e rnm en ts l a rge l y devo id o f
pow ers t o app l y econom ic and po l i cy m echan ism s t o enhanceth e com pe t i t i veness o f reg ion econom ies.
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
13/37
Thu s, as st a t ed by St im son , St ough andRo b er t s ( 2 0 0 6 ) .
. t oday i t i s m o r e and m or e up t o r eg ions t o dev elopand us e t he i r ow n d ev ices t o com pe te i n t e r na t i ona ll y i no r de r t o su r v i v e .
That i s , a r e l iance on endog enou s p ro cesses i s t yp ica l l y
espoused in r eg iona l econom ic deve lopm en t po l i cy .
To do so r eg ions need f i r s t t o unde r s tand w ha t t hefacto r s a r e t ha t se t t he dy nam ics of t he em er g ing neweconom ic age o f t h e 21st c en t u r y .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
14/37
So, w h a t can w e con clud e so fa r ?.
It is evident that there have emerged a number of keythemes as to what constitutes: r e g ion a l g r o w t h a n d d e velo p m e n t ; an d reg iona l com pe t i t i veness .
Not surprisingly there are differences of views amongregional economic development scholars, and some of those
differences relate to the relative focus given to: t h e ro les o f exogenous fo rces on t he one hand , and t h e ro les o f endogenous pr ocesses and fac to r s on th e
o t h e r h a n d .
But there does now seem to be an almost universalrealization of what Garlick, Taylor and Plumber (2006) referto as the i nst i t u t i ona l em beddedness ofendogenous processes and factors in regional development.
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
15/37
Cont.
Of cour se ex ogenous f a ct o r s d o re m a in i m p o r t a n t t o a r e g io n se co n o m i c p e r f o rm a n ce an d h o w i t d e v e lo p s o v e r t i m e .
B u t . inc reas ing im por t ance i s be ing p laced on endogenous fo rcesas de te rm inan ts o f a r eg ion s com pe t i t i veness.
How eve r , reg iona l econom ic deve lopm en t p o l i cy i n i t i a t i ves now
t e n d t o b e mo r e o r i e n t e d t o w a rd s m e asu re s t h a t : enhance loca l capac i ty an d capab i l i t y f o r a c i t y o r r e g i o n t o d e v e lo p ;
an d
ass is t reg ions t o cope w i th rap id change in an inc reasing lyco m p e t i t i v e g l ob a l e n v i r o n m e n t .
W h i l e e n d og e n o u s g ro w t h t h e o ry m a k e s m e n t i o n o f l eadersh ip ,en t rep reneu rs h i p , and i n st i t u t i ona l f act o r s , l i t t l e system a t i cana lys is has occur r ed to t ho r oug h ly concep tu a l i ze o r , evenm ore , m easu re th e i r ro l es as endogenous fact o rs i n t hedeve lopm en t p rocess .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
16/37
A n ew m o d el o f en d o g e n o u s r e g io n a l
eco n o m i c g r o w t h an d d ev elo p m en t
In a recent series of papers Stimson, Robson, Stoughand Salazar (2003), and Stimson, Stough and Salazar(2003; 2005) have develop a new model framework ofendogenous regional growth and development.
That framework explicitly incorporates:
leadership
entrepreneurship
institutional factorsas i n t e r v en i ng v a r i ab l es that are hypothesized to havea catalytic impact on the regional growth anddevelopment process.
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
17/37
Strong proactive
leadership
Good use and
tapping of
potentialsSustainable
development
Resourceendowments
Marketconditions
M echanisms for
using and tapping
V ision for future
development
Strategy, plans
processes
Fac ilitate institutiona l
change to enhance regional
capacity and cap ability
Effective institutions and
regional infrastructure
A v i r t u o u s ci r cl e f o r su st a i n ab l e
d e v e l o p me n t ( St im son , Stou gh and Sa laza r , 200 5 )
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
18/37
A v i r t uou s ci r c le f o r Sus ta inab le Reg iona l
Deve lopmen t
The ci r cl e i s m a in t a i ned by e f fect i v e l eadersh ip as it i s used tochange and ad j us t i n s t i t u t i ons i n o r de r t o adap t t he st r uc t u r e ,
p rocesses and in f r ast r uc tu re o f a reg iona l econom y in a w ayapp r op r i a t e and n eeded t o : m eet and an t i ci pa te chang ing c i r cum stances
f a ci l it a t e t h e o p t i m a l u se o f i t s r e sou r ce en d o w m e n ts
a ss is t i n d u s t r i e s t o t a p t h e i r f u l l m a r ke t p o te n t i a l .
St r ong leadersh ip m eans a reg ion w i l l : b e p r o a ct i ve i n i n i t i a t i n g r e g i o n a l econ o m i c d eve l o p m e n t s t r a te g y t o
m o n i t o r r e g i o n al p e r f o r m a n ce
set a v i s io n f o r i t s f u t u r e d e ve l op m e n t
i m p l em e n t p r o ce sses an d p l a n s t h a t w i l l f ac il i t a t e i n st i t u t i o n a l ch a n g e .
That , i n t u rn , w i l l enh ance th e capaci t y an d capab i l i t y o f t he reg ion t o :
pos i t i ve l y ad jus t t o chang ing c i r cum stances a t t a i n a g o o d f it w i t h m a r ke t con d i t i o n s
h a r n e ss i t s r e so u r ce en d o w m e n ts
i n o r d er t o m a in t a i n a n d im p r o v e it s com pe t i t i v e pe r f o r m ance a n d t oach ieve susta inab le deve lopm ent as a l earn ing reg ion .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
19/37
A m o d el f or e n d o g en o u s r e g i on a l g r o w t h a n dd e v e l o p m e n t
Stimson, Stough and Salazar (2003; 2005) propose anew model framework.
Operationally, that model may be represented as:
RED = f [RE,M .. m ed iat ed by . . ( L, I , E)]
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
20/37
A n ew m o del f r am ew o r k f o r t h e r eg io n aleconom ic developm en t p r ocess
Quasi-IndependentVariables Intervening Variables Dependent Variable(s)
The dynamic interrelationships that act to createthe catalysis for regional development
(I) Institutions(E) Entrepreneurship(L) Leadership
Resource Endowmentsand
Market Conditions
(RE,M)
OUTCOMEA Region that is:
CompetitiveEntrepreneurial
Sustainable
(RED)
Measure and evaluation change over
time.
Benchmark performance (e.g. Regionalshift component in shift-share analysis)
Direct EffectsIndirect Effects
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
21/37
A m o d el f or e n d o g en o u s r e g i on a l g r o w t h a n ddeve lopm en t , con t .
The ou t com e o f t he r eg iona l econom ic deve lopm en t p rocess
(RED) i s t he deg ree to w h i ch a reg ion has ach ieved com pe t i t i veper f o r m ance , d isp lays en t rep r eneur sh ip , and has ach ievedsus ta inab le deve lopm en t .
Those ou tcom e sta t es a re de f i ned as t he dependen t va r i ab le (s )i n t h e m o d el .
An ou t com e st a te i s concep t ua l i zed as be ing depen den t on a seto f quas i - i ndependen t va r i ab les re la t i ng t o a ci t y o r r eg ion sr e so u r ce en d o w m en t s an d i t s f i t w i t h m a r k et c on d i t i on sw h ich , f o r conven ience is sepa ra t ed in t o i t s tw o com ponen t s( n a m e l y REan d M)
Th a t i s m e d ia t e d t h ro u g h t h e i n t e ra ct i o n b e t w e en l ea d ers h i p( L) a n d i n st i t u t i o n s ( I ) t o f aci l i t a te o r supp resse n t re p re n e u rs h i p ( E) .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
22/37
A m o d el f or e n d o g en o u s r e g i on a l g r o w t h a n ddeve lopm en t , con t .
The new m ode l f r am ew or k p r oposed i nco r po r a tes bo thd i rect and in d i rect e f fect s i n t he i n t e ract i ons be tw eenRE,M ( t h e quas i - i ndependen t va r iab le) an d L, I an d E( t h e in te r v en ing or m ed ia t i ng v a r i ab les) .
A lso , t h e i n t e r act i ons be tw een t he i n t e r v en ing o rm ed ia t i ng v a r i ab les L, I an d Em ay be bo th d i r ect andind i rec t .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
23/37
The dependen t va r i ab le: m easu r ing
en d o g en o u s g r o w t h
Ap p r o a ch b y St i m so n , St o u g h a n d Sa la za r ( 2 0 0 5 )t o m e asu r e t h e RED va r i ab le pe r f o r m ance acro sst he reg i ons o f a st a te o r a na t i on as t he dependen tva r i ab le i n t h e m o d el .
A si m p l e su r roga t e m easu r e o f en d o g en o u s g r o w t hi s p rop osed .
Th e r eg iona l sh i f t o r d i f f e ren t i al sh i f t com ponen td er i v e d f r o m a sh i f t sha r e ana l ysi s o f r eg iona l
em p lo y m en t ch a n g e o v er t im e by su m m i n g t h ereg i ona l o r d i f f e ren t i al em p l oy m en t sh i f t acros s a l li ndu st r y sect o r s st andar d i zed by t he si ze o f t h ereg ion a l labo r f o r ce .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
24/37
Po t en t i al ind ependen t and i n t er v en ing
var iab les
Quas i ind ependen t v ar iab les :
RE= r e so u r ce e n d ow m e n t s
M = m a r k et f i t
I n t er v e n i n g ( o r m e di at i n g ) v a r ia bl es:
L = leadersh ip
E= en t r ep r eneu r s h ip
I = i n s t i t u t i o n s
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
25/37
RE= r e so u r ce en d o w m en t s
a rea si ze o f th e reg ion
c l im a te
t o p o g ra p h y
a g g lo m e ra t i o n o f in d u s t r y k e ysec to rs ( m easu r ed by Loca t ionQu o t i e n t s f o r e m p lo y m e n t i n
indus t ry sec to rs )
popu la t i on s i ze and ra t e o fg r ow t h / d ecl in e
educat ion leve ls ( a de r i vedin d e x o f h u m a n ca p i t a l ) a n d
l i t e racy
pe r cap i t a i ncom e, i ncom ed i st r i b u t i o n , a n d i n co m ed i st r i b u t i o n c h an g e o v er t im e
h o u s in g o w n e rs h ip
i n v e stm e n t i n i n d u s t r i a l a n dco m m e rci a l co n s t r u c t i o n ,b e n ch m a rk e d t o t h e r e g io n sna t iona l sha re vis-a-visi t sna t ion a l sha re o f popu la t i on
i n f r a st r u c t u r e i n v est m e n t ( p ercap i t a ) , such as on r oads ,schoo ls , hosp i t a ls , e tc
i n d u s t r i a l s t r u c tu r e a n d c h an g ein i n d u s t r i a l st r u c tu re( m e as u re d b y a n i n d u st r i a ld i v e r si t y i n d e x )
reg iona l o r gan iza t iona l s lack
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
26/37
M = m ar k e t f i t
basi c econom ic act i v i t y i n m a jo r i n dus t r y sect o rs ( m easu red byLoca t i on Quo t i en ts f o r em p loym en t i n i ndus t r y secto r s )
a ir l i n e co n n e ct i o n s w i t h o t h e r r e g i o n s/ ci t i e s
r o ad f r ei gh t i n / o u t m o vem en t s
vo lum e and v a lue o f expo r t s i n key p r oduc ts and se rv i ces
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
27/37
L = leadersh ip
t h e deg ree o f change / s tab i l i t y i n l oca l po l it i ca l l eade rsh ip
expe r t assessm en t o f l eadersh ip qu a l it y
co rp o ra t e h e ad q u a t e rs l o ca t e d in t h e reg i o n
densi t y o f bu s iness and com m un i t y o rgan i za t i ons pe r 10 ,000popu la t i on
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
28/37
I = i n s t i t u t i o n s
i n st i t u t i o n al t h i ck n e ss ( co rp o ra t e a n d c o m m u n i t y o rg a n i za t i o n sp e r 1 0 , 0 0 0 p o p u l a t i o n )
l ay e r s o f go v er n m en t / g o v er n m e n t f r ag m e n t at i o n
f o rm a l in s t i t u t i o n s o f g o v e rn a n ce , m e asu re d b y n u m b e r o fpub l i c agenc ies pe r 1 0 ,000 popu la t i on
n u m b e r o f h e a d qu a r t e r s o f m a j o r c o rp o ra t i o n s (e .g . Fo r t u n e1 0 0 0 f i r m s)
va lue founda t i on cap i t a l i za t i on pe r 1 0 ,000 popu la t i on
g o v er n m en t f r a g m e n t a t i o n
l e vel o f reg iona l o rg an i za t i ons (n um ber and budge t l eve l )
i ndex o f socia l cap i t a l
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
29/37
E= en t r ep r eneu r sh ip
ch u r n r a t e o r b u s i n ess st a r t - u p r a t e
ven t u r e cap i t a l act i v i t y
co rp o ra t e v e n t u r i n g a ct i v i t y
p a t e n t s i ssu e d p er 1 0 ,0 0 0 w o rk e rs
Loca t i on Quo t i en t o f em p loym en t i n sym bo l i c ana l yst occupa t ions
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
30/37
The m odel
St i m so n , St o u g h a n d Sa la za r ( 2 0 0 5 ) a r g u e t h a t RED i spos it i ve l y re lat ed to RE, M, L, I, and E
Bu t :
t he re a re l ike l y t o be lead and lag ef fect s i n t he sho r t t o
in t e rm ed iat e run , and pe rh aps cyc li ca l ef fect s in t he l ongerr u n .
Thus
REDt = REt - 1 + Mt -1 + ( It - 1 t o It -1 0/ 1 0 ) + Lt - 2 + Et -2 + e
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
31/37
To w a r d s a n e w p a r ad i g m f o r e n d o g en o u sr e g io n a l g r o w t h an d d e v el op m en t p l an n i n g
s t r a t egy
Tr ad i t i ona l m ode ls o f r eg iona l econom ic g r ow th anddeve lopm en t and t r ad i t i ona l m odes o f r eg iona l ana lys is
r em a in im po r t an t and us efu l as m eans o f add r essingreg iona l econom ic change .
Bu t t h e em er g en ce of t h e n ew g r o w t h t h eo r y an d t h e
em phas is now be ing p laced on th e im po r t ance o fendogenous p rocesses i n r eg iona l g r ow t h t h e i nc reas ing concern s ove r sus ta inab i l i t y i n r eg iona l
d e v el o p m e n t s t r a t e g y p l a n n i n g
r e q u ir e d a n e w f r a m ew o r k f o r a p p r o ach i n g r e g i on a leconom ic dev elopm en t p l ann ing st r a tegy f o r m u la t i on .
Tha t h as r esu l t ed i n t h e em er gence o f new i n t eg r a tedapproaches t o reg iona l developm en t p o l i cy and p lann in gs t r a tegy .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
32/37
To w a r d s a n e w p a r ad i g m f o r e n d o g en o u s
r e g io n a l g r o w t h an d d e v el op m en t p l an n i n gst r a t egy , con t .
I n a r g u i n g t h e n e ed f o r a n em er g i n g p a r ad i g m o freg iona l econom ic deve lopm en t p lann in g , and t o assi streg ions to u nder t ake th e p rocesses invo lved in r eg iona leconom ic dev elopm en t s t r a t egy , i t i s im po r t an t :
t o i d en t i f y t h e k e y e l em e n t s f o r r e g io n a l eco n o m i c
d e v el o p m e n t s t r a t e g y b u i l d i n g an d i m p l em e n t a t i o n
p lace t hose in a p rocess t ha t p u l l s toge t her r esour ces ,in f r ast ru ct u r e , socia l cap i t a l , and t echn o logy
t o f aci l i t a t e t h e econom ic dev elopm en t o f a r eg ion i n ady nam ic and g l oba l l y com pe t i t i v e env i r onm en t .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
33/37
Pr ocess fo r a con t em por a ry app r oach
t o r eg iona l econom ic developm en t
Analyse and Appraise Regional
Economic Performance and
Competitiveness using Benchmarks
Establish a Strategic Platform for
Regional Change and Development
Develop and Implement Strategies to Enhance
Industry Cluster Formation and Growth
Building on Regional Core Competencies and
Appraisal of Regional Risk to Create a
Competitive Region
Monitor Regional Performance
and
Competitiveness and Review
Strategy using Benchmarks
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
34/37
Tha t app r oach suggest s t ha t t he i n t en t o f
r eg iona l econom ic developm en t st r a t egym i g h t b e t o .
Es tab l i sh a p la t f o rm fo r change to gu ide the deve lopm en t o f areg ion and to f aci l i t a te i t s com pe t i t i veness i n a g loba le n v i r o n m e n t i n t h e p u rs u i t o f a su s t a in a b l e f u t u re .
Mob i l ize key acto r s o r f aci l i t a to r s and agen ts o f change ,th rou gh pa r t ne rsh ip app roaches encom pass ing s t r a teg i ca l l i ances and par t ne rsh ips be tw een bus iness , m a rk e ts ,g o v er n m e n t an d co m m u n i t y .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
35/37
Th e f r a m ew o r k p r o p o ses t h e f o l l ow i n g .
I den t i f y , desc r ibe , ana lyze and eva lua t e : core competencies
resource endowments infrastructure competitiveness market intelligence, regional riskt h ro u g h t h e co m b in a t i o n o f q u a l it a t i v e a n d q u an t i t a t i v e m e th o d sencomp assed in :
industry cluster analysis (ICA) multi sector analysis (MSA) (see Roberts and Stimson, 1998).
I d e n t i f y a n d e v a lu a te e co n o m ic p os si b i l i t i e s f o r t h e f u t u re l e ad in g t o t h esta t e m e n t o f st r a te g i c i n t e n t .
Ev a lu ate a l t e rn a t i v e d e v e lo pm e n t f u t u re s o r s ce n ar i o s t h r o u g h t h ep a r t i c ip a t i o n o f s t a k e h o ld e r s w i t h i n t h e r e g ion a n d e x te rn a l t o i t t oencom pass th e assessm en ts o f k ey decis ion -m ake rs con t r o l l i ng cap i ta l ,t r a d e a n d o th e r f l o w s t o t h e r e g io n .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
36/37
Cont.
I m p l em e n t a t i o n p l a n s an d m e ch a n i sm s n ee d t o b e d e v el o p edand pu t i n p lace by app rop r i a t e agenc ies i n t he reg ion .
Prog r ess m ade tow ards ach iev ing t he des ired deve lopm en tf u t u r e n e ed s t o b e m o n it o r e d . Th a t :
r e q u i r e s a g re em e n t o n i n d i c ato r s an d b e n ch m a rk s a g ain st w h i ch t om e as u re an d e v a lu ate r e g io n a l p er f o r m a n ce o v er t im e i n o rd e r t o
assess th e deg ree o f success o f t he s t r a tegy and p rog ress tow ardsa ch ie v em e n t o f t h e s t r a te g i c in t e n t
i n vo lves bu i l d ing enhanced reg iona l i n f ras t r uc tu r e sys tem s a longw i t h s t r e n g t h e n in g ex i s t i n g a n d b u i l d i n g n ew p a r t n e r sh ip s,ne tw ork s and a ll i ances.
I n t h e co n t e m p o ra ry e ra o f t h e g l o b al e co n o m y , i n cre a si n g l yth e pu rsu i t o f r eg iona l econom ic deve lopm en t a l so needs totak e p lace w i th in t he con t ex t o f p r i nc ip les f o r ach iev ing asus ta inab le f u t u r e .
8/3/2019 Presentacion STIMSON 13-3
37/37
St eps i nvo l ved in im p lem en t i ng t he new
f r a m ew o r k f o r r eg i on a l eco n o m i cd ev e lo p m en t p l an n i n g st r a t e g y
12 ACTION PLAN
5 year rolling Plan
Annual Plan
Financial Plan
ACTION PLAN
5 year rolling Plan
Annual Plan
Financial Plan
Establishing
a Platform
for Change
Establishing
a Platform
for Change
Economic
Audit
Analysis
Economic
Audit
Analysis
Economic
Possibilities
Index
Economic
Possibilities
Index
Set (new)
Strategic
Directions
Set (new)
Strategic
Directions
External
Analyses
External
Analyses
STRATEGY
Strategic Intent
Strategic Directions
Strategic Architecture
Economic Drivers
STRATEGY
Strategic Intent
Strategic Directions
Strategic Architecture
Economic Drivers
Indicators &
Benchmarks
Indicators &
Benchmarks
Redefine
Directions
Redefine
Directions
Develop and
Test Alternative
EconomicFutures
Develop and
Test Alternative
Economic
Futures
INDUSTRY
CLUSTERANALYSIS
(ICA)
MULTI
SECTORAL
ANALYSIS
(MSA)
INDUSTRY
CLUSTER
ANALYSIS
(ICA)
MULTI
SECTORAL
ANALYSIS
(MSA)
Agents of Change
BusinessBusiness
MarketsMarkets
GovernmentGovernment
CommunityCommunity
TechnologyTechnologyRegional
InformationSystem
Regional
Information
System
1
3
42 65
10
9
8
7
11
13
14
Review and
Re-engineer
Strategy
Review and
Re-engineer
Strategy