Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    1/30

    4tm feeufcQprdekvfcul devlstdek aiekrlss

    Fprdc 1, >260 Cfs Zlkfs, EZ

    Hlrrds`fcl Afpdtfcs Pip Lqudty Devlstglet jir >260

    Qfmg F`rfekd, Hlrrds`fcl Afpdtfc Gfefklglet

    www.ZfculDevlstdekAiekrlss.aig

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    2/30

    AIEJD@LEPDFC DEZLQPI^ R^LQLEPFPDIE

    Zfcul Devlstdek iekrlssFprdc >260

    Hlrrds`fcl Afpdtfc Gfefklglet, CCA

    6>6> Fvleul ij tml Fglrdafs, 1r` Jciir

    Elw Tirh, ET 6221:

    Plc? >6>.;4>.;444

    Jfx? >6>.

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    3/30

    Rfkl 6/ Aiejd`letdfc

    Ieal iel ij iur cfrklst ciek pisdtdies

    Pi`fy, wl prlslet f smirtd`lf ie f aigpfey tmft wfs ieal iel ij iur

    jfvirdtl ciek pisdtdies [mft irdkdefccy fttrfatl` us ti tml ippirtuedty ylfrs fki

    Qgfcc nusdelss wdtm elkcdkdncl gfrhlt smfrl wdtm kii` gfefklglet

    [l faqudrl` tml nusdelss ft f ciw R/LRQ, R/PNZ, RLK, lta.

    [l wlrl devlstirs de tml nusdelss jir slvlrfc ylfrs, fe` frl eiw smirt

    Aigpfeys smfrls mfvl fpprladftl` ny 6

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    4/30

    Rfkl >/ Aiejd`letdfc

    NijD Mic`dek Dea. (Efs`fq? NIJD)

    NIJD ds f nrfeamclss iecdel nfeh tmft iplrftls f vfrdlty ij iecdel nfeh

    nrfe`s, deacu`dek Nfeh ij Detlrelt, EltNfeh, Nfeh ] fe` itmlrs

    Cifes frl gf`l vdf nrfe`l` wlnsdtls suam fs fpfrtgletnfeh.aig, vdfrlcftdiesmdps wdtm fjjdedty kriups, afcc aletlrs, fs wlcc fs tmriukm wmiclsfclfe` airrlspie`let amfeelcs

    $1.:ne titfc fsslts, $16>g PNZ, $0;g CPG Elt Deaigl

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    5/30

    Rfkl 1/ Aiejd`letdfc

    Afpdtfcdzftdie

    [l rlaiggle` f smirt pisdtdie de NijD Mic`dek Dea. (NIJD ir tml

    Aigpfey), iel ij tml gist lxplesdvl nfehs de tml \Q NIJD mfs lfrel` devlstirs elfrcy 6:22% de tml pfst < ylfrs, fe` eiw

    trf`ls ft ~0.2x PNZ, jfr mdkmlr tmfe dts nfehdek slatir pllrs

    Devlstirs lxplat rfpd` lfredeks kriwtm8 wl nlcdlvl juturl lfredeks frl cdhlcy tigftlrdfccy `dsfppidet fs detlrlst rftls rdsl

    [l nlcdlvl NIJDs devlstirs frl lxtrfpicftdek rlsucts tmft wdcc nl `djjdauct tifamdlvl kidek jirwfr` fs detlrlst rftls rdsl

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    6/30

    Rfkl 0/ Aiejd`letdfc

    Qtrftlky de f eutsmlcc

    NIJD mfs ei nrfeamls fe` fttrfats `lpisdtirs ny ijjlrdek mdkm detlrlst

    rftls NIJD afe fjjir` mdkm aist ij jue`dek `ul ti dts ciw iplrftdek aists? ei nrfeamls

    fe` ciw lgpciylls / fsslts rftdi (iecy 16> jucc tdgl lgpciylls ft :/12/61)

    Qiural? NIJD Gfram >260 devlstir prlsletftdie

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    7/30

    Rfkl 1x RL

    Devlstirs mfvl gdstfhlecy fssugl` aurrlet prijdtfndcdty fe` kriwtm ds

    sustfdefncl `lspdtl tml jirwfr` ydlc` de`daftdek itmlrwdsl

    Pmds prlsletftdie wdcc dccustrftl wmy wl nlcdlvl NIJDs aurrlet lfredeks frluesustfdefncl kdvle tml jirwfr` rftl aurvl

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    8/30

    Rfkl :/ Aiejd`letdfc

    NIJDs fsslt ydlc`s frl cdhlcy eit sustfdefncl

    NIJD gfefklglet gf`l sigl fstutl devlstglet `ladsdies `urdek tml

    jdefeadfc ardsds, fcciwdek tml aigpfey ti sustfde vlry fttrfatdvl detlrlstdeaigl `lspdtl f jfccdek rftl levdrieglet

    NIJD mfs ei aigpltdtdvl f`vfetfkl ie tml fsslt sd`l ij dts nfcfeal smllt8gfefklglet wdcc jde` dt `djjdauct ti sustfde ydlc`s wdtm f kriwdek nfcfeal smllt

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    9/30

    Rfkl ;/ Aiejd`letdfc

    [my ds fsslt ydlc` mdkm9 Eierlaurrdek nlts ie GNQ!

    NIJDs fsslt ydlc`s frl jfr mdkmlr tmfe pllrs `ul ti ippirtuedstda nlts ie

    `dstrlssl` GNQ `urdek tml jdefeadfc ardsds NIJDs cife ydlc` fe` itmlr fsslt ydlc`s frl cfrklcy de cdel

    Fs tml slaurdtdls pirtjicdi gfturls fe` riccs ivlr, NIJDs fsslt ydlc` smiuc``lacdel ti f clvlc ie pfr wdtm dts pllrs

    @urdek tml jdefeadfc ardsds, gfefklglet gf`l sigl fstutl ieal-de-f-cdjltdgldevlstglets de `dstrlssl` GNQ, wmdam krlftcy lemfeal` fsslt ydlc`s

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    10/30

    Rfkl =/ Aiejd`letdfc

    NIJDs fsslt ydlc` aigpfrl` ti pllrs

    Fs iutcdel` lfrcdlr, NIJD fe` itmlr detlrelt nfehs mfvl ei f`vfetfkl jrig

    f afpdtfc `lpciyglet plrsplatdvl Fs dts nfcfeal smllt kriws, fe` fs dts mdkm-rlture slaurdtdls pirtjicdi riccs

    ivlr, NIJDs prijdts wdcc jfcc sdkedjdafetcy

    Fsslt ydlc` de cdel wdtm pllrs (fs `ljdel` ny NIJD prixy) wiuc` dgpcy ~>2%`iwesd`l ti CPG LRQ

    Fs NIJDs nfcfeal smllt kriws, fe` dts ippirtuedstda slaurdtdls pirtjicdi riccsivlr, NIJDs fsslt ydlc`s wdcc jfcc acislr ti pllr fvlrfkl

    NIJD [JA \QN JDPN Rllr Fvk.

    Fvlrfkl Qlaurdtdls Tdlc 0.;0% 1.:.>4% 1.1>% >.64%

    Dearlgletfc NIJD ydlc` 6.24% >.0% >. $2.04 $2.>= $2.

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    11/30

    Rfkl 4/ Aiejd`letdfc

    Aigpfrdsie ij NIJD ti Lvlrnfeh Aiejdrgs Zdlw

    Lvlrnfeh ds f sdgdcfr iecdel-iecy nfeh

    Aigpfrdek tml twi jdrgs, NIJDs EDGs frl sdkedjdafetcy lemfeal` ny tmlydlc` ie dts slaurdtdls pirtjicdi

    NIJD LZL^ @djj.

    Cifes

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    12/30

    Rfkl 62/ Aiejd`letdfc

    NIJDs cife pirtjicdi ds kidek ricc deti ciwlr ydlc`

    NIJDs mdstirdafc cife ydlc`s frl suppirtl` ny jiaus ie ougni cifes, wmdam

    ti`fy mfvl jfr ciwlr lxalss ydlc`

    Qiural? NIJD devlstir prlsletftdie Gfram >260 Qiural? Jdefeadfc Pdgls

    Ougni cifes, wmdam jirg tml cfrklst slkglet ij NIJDs cife pdplcdel, frljfadek dearlfsl` aigpltdtdie fe` `lacdedek ydlc`s

    NIJD Cife Rdplcdel

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    13/30

    Rfkl 66/ Aiejd`letdfc

    Fsslt ydlc`s suppirtl` ny lxtle`dek `urftdie

    NIJD mfs nleljdttl` jrig f mukl nlt ie `lacdedek rftls8 dt mfs mlc` fsslts

    wdtm f cieklr `urftdie fe` mdkmlr ydlc` tmfe gist ij dts pllrs

    NIJDs cife pirtjicdi gfturdty ds fe iutcdlr8 NIJDs cdfndcdtdls wdcc rl-prdalrlcftdvlcy qudahcy, nut dts fsslts wdcc tfhl cieklr ti ricc ivlr tmfe dts aigpltdtirs

    NIJD [JA \QN JDPN Rllr Fvk.

    % ij Cifes wdtm ^lgfdedek Gfturdty ir Elxt ^lprdadek @ftl ij?

    1 Gietms =% % 0:% 6%

    5 1 Gietms, 6 Tlfr ;% 1%

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    14/30

    Rfkl 6>/ Aiejd`letdfc

    NIJD gf`l f cfrkl nlt ie `lacdedek rftls

    NIJD mfs iel ij tml cfrklst elkftdvl detlrlst jue`dek kfps fgiek

    puncdacy trf`l` nfehs fe` ds pfrtdaucfrcy vucelrfncl ti rftl smiahs @lpisdts wdcc rl-prdal qudahcy dj rftls rdsl, nut fsslts frl cieklr `urftdie8 tmds wdcc

    arlftl f sdkedjdafet mlf`wde` jir EDGs de tml elfr tlrg

    Lvle fgiek nrfeam-cdkmt nfehs, NIJDs cife niih ds pfrtdaucfrcy piircypisdtdiel` jir f rdsdek rftl levdrieglet

    Qiural? Qtlrel Fkll rlpirt, Gfram >260

    Iecdel Nfeh Iel Tlfr ^ftl Kfp

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    15/30

    Rfkl 61/ Aiejd`letdfc

    NIJDs `lpisdtirs frl clss stdahy

    NIJD mfs f rlcftdvlcy prdal-slesdtdvl fe` clss-stdahy `lpisdt nfsl

    @lpisdt dejciws lxpci`l` fjtlr rlalssdie (eitl ~262)

    Fs girl detlrelt-nfehdek aigpltdtirs frdsl, fe` fs rftls dearlfsl, NIJDs

    rlcftdvl fttrfatdvlelss wlfhles aiesd`lrfncy

    NIJD mfs tfrkltl` f girl prdal-slesdtdvl `lpisdtir nfsl8 tmds mfs nllenleljdadfc `urdek ieal-de-klelrftdie rftl levdrieglet

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    16/30

    Rfkl 60/ Aiejd`letdfc

    Elw aigpltdtdie ds wlfhledek NIJDs pisdtdie NIJDs ijjlrdek ds ue`djjlrletdftl` fe` jfadek aiesd`lrfncl aigpltdtdie?

    Cfrkl cle`lrs? KL Afpdtfc, Fccy Jdefeadfc, ADP, Nfracfys

    \Q iecdel nfehs? Lvlrnfeh, Jdrst Detlrelt Nfeh ij De`dfef

    Iecdel `dvdsdies ij \Q nfehs? Dearl`dnclNfeh (^dvlr Zfccly Nfeh), @irfc @drlat

    Iecdel sunsd`dfrdls ij jirldke nfehs? Zdrtufc Nfeh (Nfeai `l Qfnf`lcc), NFAJcird`f (Krupi Rlccfs)

    6-Tlfr Alrtdjdaftl ij @lpisdts

    Nfeh ^ftl

    6 KL Afpdtfc Nfeh 6.2 Gy l-NFeA ny NFA Jcird`f Nfeh 6.26%1 ZdrtufcNfeh 6.26%0 FciQtfr Nfeh ij Aigglral 6.26%< Aicirf`i Jl`lrfc Qfvdeks Nfeh 6.22%: Pml Rfccf`dfe RrdvftlNfeh 6.22%; Afcdjiredf Jdrst Eftdiefc Nfeh 6.22%= Fccy Nfeh 2.44%4 Migl Qfvdeks Nfeh 2.4=%

    62 @dsaivlr Nfeh 2.4=%66 @irfc @drlat 2.4 L-CIFE 2.40%61 Nfracfys 2.46%60 Rletfkie Jl`lrfc Arl`dt \edie 2.=2%6< \QFF 2.=2%6: fnclNfehdek, f dvdsdie ij Eirtmlfst Nfeh 2.;6%6; Jdrst Detlrelt Nfeh ij De`dfef 2.:

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    17/30

    Rfkl 6224, dt mf` fgiekst tml

    mdkmlst rftls jir A@s fe` sfvdeks faaiuets faair`dek tiwww.nfehrftl.aig

    Pi`fy, euglrius aigpltdtirs mfvl nlaigl girl fkkrlssdvl de tml detlrelt-iecy gfrhlt, wdtm NIJD rfehdek jfr ciwlr tmfe gfey aigpltdek jdrgs

    Aigpltdtdie jrig Itmlr Iecdel Nfehs [dcc Rrlssurl EDGs fe` Kriwtm

    NIJD

    Rri`uat ^fehdek Pip 62 Nfehs (mdkmlst ti ciwlst FRT ie 1/16/60)1-Gietm A@ 61tm FciQtfr, ZdrtufcNfeh, Nfracfys, @dsaivlr, LvlrNfeh:-Gietm A@ >0tm _dies @drlat, @irfc @drlat, FciQtfr, KL Afpdtfc Nfeh, Gy l-NFeA6-Tlfr A@ >e` LvlrNfeh, Nfracfys, dKInfehdek.aig, KL Afpdtfc Nfeh, Qtftl Jfrg Nfeh6-Tlfr Ougni A@ 6;tm Gy L-NFeA, KL Afpdtfc Nfeh, ZdrtufcNfeh, FciQtfr, Migl Qfvdeks Nfeh

    GGF/Qfvdeks >2tm KL Afpdtfc Nfeh, ADP Nfeh, Nfracfys, KL Afpdtfc Nfeh, Qfccdl GflGGF/62H Qfvdeks 61tm KL Afpdtfc Nfeh, Qfccdl Gfl, Rfccf`dfe RrvdftlNfeh, LvlrNfeh, Aicirf`i Jl`lrfc Qfvdeks Nfeh

    GGF/Ougni Qfvdeks eit cdstl` KL Afpdtfc Nfeh, Qfccdl Gfl, Aicirf`i Jl`lrfc Qfvdeks, @dsaivlr Nfeh, JENI @drlat

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    18/30

    Rfkl 6:/ Aiejd`letdfc

    Irkfeda faaiuet kriwtm mfs stfccl`

    NIJD gf`l f sgfcc faqudsdtdie de >261 wmdam dearlfsl` eugnlr ij

    faaiuets F`oustdek jir tmds faqudsdtdie, eugnlr ij faaiuets mfs rlaletcy `lacdel`

    F`oustdek jir f rlalet faqudsdtdie, NIJD mfs eit kriwe elt austiglrs ivlr tmlpfst ylfr

    Faaiuets ft Nlkdeedek >;,;0: 1>,=4= 1>,=11 1>,>;> 11,16> 1,=4= 1>,=11 1>,>;> 11,16> 1 4/12/6> 6>/16/6> 1/12/61 :/12/61 4/12/61 6>/16/61

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    19/30

    Rfkl 6;/ Aiejd`letdfc

    ^fpd` `lpisdt kriwtm trdkklrl` ny `lacdedek rftls

    NIJD `lpisdt kriwtm mfs nlle `rdvle ny ciw-detlrlst levdrieglet

    tmldr ~6% `lpisdt rftl ds fttrfatdvl wmle aigpltdtirs ijjlr ~2%

    ~262 aidead`dek wdtm 6

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    20/30

    Rfkl 6=/ Aiejd`letdfc

    Jirwfr` aurvl ds eit ciihdek kii` jir NIJD

    Nfsl` ie ti`fys jirwfr` ydlc` aurvl, NIJDs EDGs wdcc cdhlcy rlvlrt nfah ti

    ciek-tlrg eirgfcdzl` prijdtfndcdty de aigdek ylfrs

    NIJD6

    Amfekl '6; Aurvl>

    Fsslt Tdlc % :.6% >.==% 1.42% 3---Nfsl` ie jirwfr` 6-ylfr rftls, NIJD's jue`dek aist wdcc rdsl girl

    Elt Detlrlst Gfrkde 0.26% (6.;:%) >.>;: $2 $1,>;:

    Elt Detlrlst Deaigl $616 ($. Nfsl` ie jirwfr` ydlc` aurvl jir >26;

    1. F`oustl` jir 02% tfx rftl

    Pml jirwfr` ydlc` aurvl ds jcfttledek8 jir f nfeh wdtm f cfrkl elkftdvl rftl kfpfe` ciek `urftdie fsslts cdhl NIJD, tmds dgpcdls f rl`uatdie de prijdtfndcdty

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    21/30

    Rfkl 64/ Aiejd`letdfc

    Ruttdek dt fcc tikltmlr? NIJD EDG kidek ti jfcc

    NIJDs EDGs fe` kriwtm frl eit lvd`leal ij f suplrdir nusdelss

    gi`lc, nut jfatirs rlcftl` ti ti`fys ciw detlrlst rftl levdrieglet Detlrelt nfehs klelrfccy mfvl ciwlr EDGs tmfe tmldr nrdah-fe`-girtfr pllrs

    nlafusl tmly pfy girl jir `lpisdts fe` lfre clss ie fsslts

    NIJD mfs nleljdttl` jrig f elkftdvl rftl kfp fe` tdglcy nlts ie GNQ

    Ie fvlrfkl, detlrelt nfehs mfvl mdkmlr jue`dek aists, fe` girl prdal slesdtdvl `lpisdtirs

    fe` lfre ciwlr ydlc`s ie fsslts rlsuctdek de ciwlr EDGs tmfe tmldr pllrs

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    22/30

    Rfkl >2/ Aiejd`letdfc

    @lacdedek girtkfkl kfde ie sfcl

    Zfst gfoirdty ij NIJDs eie-detlrlst deaigl mfs nlle jrig tml kfde-ie-sfcl

    ij girtkfkl slaurdtdls Qciwdek rljdefeadek fatdvdty wdcc `lprlss girtkfkl sfcls kidek jirwfr`

    \ecdhl gfrqull nrdah-fe`-girtfr nfehs, NIJD lfres cdttcl de tml wfy ij mdkm-gfrkde fe` mdkm-vfcul slrvdal ir jll deaigl

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    23/30

    Rfkl >6/ Aiejd`letdfc

    NIJD gfy nl ue`lr-rlslrvdek ERCs

    NIJD privdsdies frl prdal` jir plrjlatdie

    NIJDs ERCs clfvl devlstirs wdtm vlry fsyggltrda rdsh ti tml `iwesd`l

    Mdkm kriwtm nfehs Detlrelt nfehs Gfrqull nfehs

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    24/30

    Rfkl >>/ Aiejd`letdfc

    ^lcftdvl R/PNZ

    NIJD mfs fgiek tml mdkmlst R/PNZ guctdpcls de tml letdrl \.Q. nfehdek

    slatir

    Qiural? AfpdtfcDV

    Mdkm-Kriwtm

    Nfehs R/PNZ

    Detlrelt Nfehs

    R/PNZ

    Gfrqull Nfehs

    R/PNZ

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    25/30

    Rfkl >1/ Aiejd`letdfc

    ^lcftdvl R/LRQ

    NIJD fcsi mfs fgiekst tml mdkmlst vfcuftdies ie f R/LRQ nfsds

    Qiural? AfpdtfcDV

    Mdkm-Kriwtm

    Nfehs R/LRQ

    Detlrelt Nfehs

    R/LRQ

    Gfrqull Nfehs

    R/LRQ

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    26/30

    Rfkl >0/ Aiejd`letdfc

    NIJD R/PNZ vs. ^IPAL

    De ir`lr ti oustdjy vfcuftdie, gfrhlt pfrtdadpfets frl prdadek NIJD ti kriwguctdpcls de sdzl wmdcl gfdetfdedek dts de`ustry-clf`dek prijdtfndcdty

    Qiural? Qtlrel Fkll rlpirt, Gfram >260

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    27/30

    Rfkl >/1r`s ij aurrlet gfrhlt vfcul fttrdnutfncl ti tml ERZ ij juturl cifes, f

    surprdsdekcy mdkm eugnlr

    NIJD fsslt nfsl ds fsyggltrdafccy pisdtdiel` ti tml `iwesd`l

    >22 nfsds pidet dearlfsl de rftls ds f >2% `lacdel de ERZ ij aurrlet cife niih

    Zfcul ivlrwmlcgdekcy fttrdnutl` ti kriwtm

    (@iccfrs de tmi usfe`s , fs ft @lalgnlr 16, >261)Elt

    Rrlslet ZfculRlraletfkl

    Amfekl jrig Nfsl

    ERZ fs fRlraletfklij Fsslts

    \p 122 nfsds pidets$ >:;,>;= (10.=%) ;.=1%

    \p >22 nfsds pidets116,>=0 (64.>%) 4.14%

    \p 622 nfsds pidets1==,2:2 (0= 66.2

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    28/30

    Rfkl >:/ Aiejd`letdfc

    Nfahdek deti NIJD vfcuftdie

    Pi oustdjy NIJDs vfcuftdie, devlstirs mfvl ti gfhl sigl nic` fssugptdies

    ~1x `lpisdt nfsl

    1.

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    29/30

    Rfkl >;/ Aiejd`letdfc

    Aieacusdie

    NIJDs vfcuftdie rlqudrls aietdeul` `lpisdt kriwtm `lspdtl ijjlrdek

    ei `djjlrletdftdie, fe` nldek fncl ti `lpciy tmds kriwdek afpdtfc nfslft de`ustry-clf`dek ydlc`s, `lspdtl mfvdek ei cife siuradek f`vfetfkl

    NIJD ds iel ij tml mdkmlst vfcul` puncdacy trf`l` nfehs de tml \Q

    R/PNZ ij ~0.2x vs. de`ustry pllrs ft mfcj tmft vfcul, nlafusl devlstirs mfvlgdstfhlecy fssugl` NIJDs EDGs fe` `lpisdt kriwtm frl sustfdefncl

    Cdfndcdtdls wdcc jfal mdkmlr aists NIJD mfs iel ij tml cfrklst elkftdvl jue`dek kfps de \Q

    @lpisdts gfy jfal sciwlr kriwtm, ir mdkmlr aists, `ul ti aigpltdtdie

    NIJDs `lpisdts frl clss stdahy, jue`dek aist ndfs ds ti tml upsd`l

    Fsslts frl ivlr-lfredek

    Fsslt ydlc`s suppirtl` ny ippirtuedstda nlts ie sgfcc fsslt nfsl8 fs fsslt nfslkriws, fe` mdkm ydlc` slaurdtdls ricc ivlr, NIJD fsslt rltures wdcc jfal prlssurl

    NIJD prijdtfndcdty ds cdhlcy ti rlvlrt acislr ti de`ustry-pllr clvlcs fs detlrlstrftls rlvlrt, fe` wlcc-jdefeal` aigpltdtirs rlpcdaftl NIJDs ijjlrdeks

  • 8/12/2019 Sahm Adrangi Kerrisdale Capitals Top Equity Investment

    30/30

    Rfkl >= / Aiejd`letdfc

    @dsacfdglr

    Fs ij tml puncdaftdie `ftl ij tmds rlpirt, Hlrrds`fcl Afpdtfc Gfefklglet CCA fe` dts fjjdcdftls (aicclatdvlcy "Hlrrds`fcl"), itmlrs tmft aietrdnutl`

    rlslfram ti tmds rlpirt fe` itmlrs tmft wl mfvl smfrl` iur rlslfram wdtm (aicclatdvlcy, tml Futmirs) mfvl smirt pisdtdies de fe` gfy iwe iptdies ie

    tml stiah ij tml aigpfey aivlrl` mlrlde (NijD Mic`dek Dea.) fe` stfe` ti rlfcdzl kfdes de tml lvlet tmft tml prdal ij tml stiah `larlfsls. Jicciwdek

    puncdaftdie ij tml rlpirt, tml Futmirs gfy trfesfat de tml slaurdtdls ij tml aigpfey aivlrl` mlrlde. Fcc aietlet de tmds rlpirt rlprlslet tml ipdedies ij

    Hlrrds`fcl. Pml Futmirs mfvl intfdel` fcc dejirgftdie mlrlde jrig siurals tmly nlcdlvl ti nl faaurftl fe` rlcdfncl. Miwlvlr, suam dejirgftdie ds

    prlsletl` fs ds, wdtmiut wfrrfety ij fey hde` wmltmlr lxprlss ir dgpcdl`. Pml Futmirs gfhl ei rlprlsletftdie, lxprlss ir dgpcdl`, fs ti tmlfaaurfay, tdglcdelss, ir aigpcltlelss ij fey suam dejirgftdie ir wdtm rlkfr` ti tml rlsucts intfdel` jrig dts usl. Fcc lxprlssdies ij ipdedie frl sunolat

    ti amfekl wdtmiut eitdal, fe` tml Futmirs `i eit ue`lrtfhl ti up`ftl ir suppclglet tmds rlpirt ir fey dejirgftdie aietfdel` mlrlde.

    Pmds `iauglet ds jir dejirgftdiefc purpisls iecy fe` dt ds eit detle`l` fs fe ijjdadfc aiejdrgftdie ij fey trfesfatdie. Fcc gfrhlt prdals, `ftf fe` itmlr

    dejirgftdie frl eit wfrrfetl` fs ti aigpcltlelss ir faaurfay fe` frl sunolat ti amfekl wdtmiut eitdal. Pml dejirgftdie deacu`l` de tmds `iauglet ds

    nfsl` upie slclatl` puncda gfrhlt `ftf fe` rljclats prlvfdcdek aie`dtdies fe` tml Futmirs vdlws fs ij tmds `ftl, fcc ij wmdam frl faair`dekcy sunolat ti

    amfekl. Pml Futmirs ipdedies fe` lstdgftls aiestdtutl f nlst ljjirts ou`kglet fe` smiuc` nl rlkfr`l` fs de`daftdvl, prlcdgdefry fe` jir dccustrftdvl

    purpisls iecy. Fey devlstglet devicvls sunstfetdfc rdshs, deacu`dek, nut eit cdgdtl` ti, prdadek vicftdcdty, def`lquftl cdqud`dty, fe` tml pitletdfc aigpcltl

    ciss ij prdeadpfc. Pmds rlpirts lstdgftl` jue`fgletfc vfcul iecy rlprlslets f nlst ljjirts lstdgftl ij tml pitletdfc jue`fgl etfc vfcuftdie ij f spladjda

    slaurdty, fe` ds eit lxprlssl` fs, ir dgpcdl` fs, fsslssglets ij tml qufcdty ij f slaurdty, f suggfry ij pfst plrjirgfeal, ir fe fatdiefncl devlstglet

    strftlky jir fe devlstir.

    Pmds iauglet ils eit de fey wfy aiestdtutl fe ijjlr ir sicdadtftdie ij fe ijjlr ti nuy ir slcc fey devlstglet, slaurdty, ir aiggi`dty dsaussl` mlrldeir ij fey ij tml fjjdcdftls ij tml Futmirs. Fcsi, tmds `iauglet `ils eit de fey wfy aiestdtutl fe ijjlr ir sicdadtftdie ij fe ijjlr ti nuy ir slcc fey slaurdty

    de fey ourds`datdie de wmdam suam fe ijjlr wiuc` nl uecfwjuc ue`lr tml slaurdtdls cfws ij suam ourds`datdie. Pi tml nlst ij tml Futmirs fndcdtdls fe`

    nlcdljs, fcc dejirgftdie aietfdel` mlrlde ds faaurftl fe` rlcdfncl. Pml Futmirs rlslrvl tml rdkmts jir tmldr fjjdcdftls, ijjdalrs, fe` lgpciylls ti mic` afsm

    ir `lrdvftdvl pisdtdies de fey aigpfey `dsaussl` de tmds `iauglet ft fey tdgl. Fs ij tml irdkdefc puncdaftdie `ftl ij tmds `iauglet, devlstirs smiuc`

    fssugl tmft tml Futmirs mfvl pisdtdies de jdefeadfc `lrdvftdvls tmft rljlrleal tmds slaurdty fe` stfe` ti pitletdfccy rlfcdzl kfdes de tml lvlet tmft tml

    gfrhlt vfcuftdie ij tml aigpfeys aiggie lqudty ds ciwlr tmfe prdir ti tml irdkdefc puncdaftdie `ftl. Pmlsl fjjdcdftls, ijjdalrs, fe` de`dvd`ufcs smfcc

    mfvl ei incdkftdie ti dejirg fey devlstir fniut tmldr mdstirdafc, aurrlet, fe` juturl trf`dek fatdvdtdls. De f``dtdie, tml Futmirs gfy nleljdt jrig fey

    amfekl de tml vfcuftdie ij fey itmlr aigpfedls, slaurdtdls, ir aiggi`dtdls `dsaussl` de tmds `iauglet. Fefcysts wmi prlpfrl` tmds rlpirt frl

    aigplesftl` nfsl` upie (fgiek itmlr jfatirs) tml ivlrfcc prijdtfndcdty ij tml Futmirs iplrftdies fe` tmldr fjjdcdftls. Pml aigplesftdie struaturl jir

    tml Futmirs fefcysts ds klelrfccy f `lrdvftdvl ij tmldr ljjlatdvlelss de klelrftdek fe` aigguedaftdek elw devlstglet d`lfs f e` tml plrjirgfeal ijrlaiggle`l` strftlkdls jir tml Futmirs. Pmds aiuc` rlprlslet f pitletdfc aiejcdat ij detlrlst de tml stftlglets fe` ipdedies de tml Futmirs `iauglets.

    Pml dejirgftdie aietfdel` de tmds `iauglet gfy deacu`l, ir deairpirftl ny rljlrleal, jirwfr`-ciihdek stftlglets, wmdam wiuc` deacu`l fey stftlglets

    tmft frl eit stftlglets ij mdstirdafc jfat. Fey ir fcc ij tml Futmirs jirwfr`-ciihdek fssugptdies, lxplatftdies, priolatdies, detletdies ir nlcdljs fniut

    juturl lvlets gfy ture iut ti nl wriek. Pmlsl jirwfr`-ciihdek stftlglets afe nl fjjlatl` ny defaaurftl fssugptdies ir ny heiwe ir ueheiwe rdshs,

    uealrtfdetdls fe` itmlr jfatirs, gist ij wmdam frl nlyie` tml Futmirs aietric. Devlstirs smiuc` aie`uat de`lple`let `ul `dcdkleal, wdtm fssdstfeal

    jrig prijlssdiefc jdefeadfc, clkfc fe` tfx lxplrts, ie fcc slaurdtdls, aigpfedls, fe` aiggi`dtdls `dsaussl` de tmds `iauglet fe` `lvlcip f stfe`-fciel

    ou`kglet ij tml rlclvfet gfrhlts prdir ti gfhdek fey devlstglet `ladsdie.