Sophia Vol 2 Dunn

7/30/2019 Sophia Vol 2 Dunn

1/15

K^L

D)#&%'5"';"&A7"e%5=$'D.kK

)U$OH[DQGHU6FKPHPDQQ

M5&('$31%5="&A7"&'B%1"';"&A%>"7>>):"%>"97>&"$'57"9:"(71'35&%5="&A7"

RWKHUZRUOGO\H[SHULHQFHRIP\UVW3DVFKD$VD3URWHVWDQWHQTXLUHU

%5&'"&A7"E(&A'$'F"c)%&AN"M"H)>"7FB7(%7517$"%5"&A7")**?T757()9*7"B'&*314"

D7)*"';&75")&&)1A7$"&'"1A3(1A">7(T%17>N"93&"&A7"E(&A'$'F"6)>1A)*"c7)>&"

H)>">'D7&A%5="7*>7"75&%(7*:."/;&7(">&)5$%5=";'("A'3(>"%5")">77D%5=*:"

75$*7>>"1A3(1A">7(T%17N"'57"&A)&"97=)5"%5">'D97("&'57>")5$"75$7$"%5"

7F397()517N"M"1'3*$"5'&"A7*B"93&">77"&A7"D'(5%5="D7)*"&A)&";'**'H7$"

H%&A%5"&A7"1'5&7F&"';"&A)&"*%&3(=:."M5" &A7"7)(*%7>&":7)(>"';"&%)5%&:N"

&A7"#31A)(%>&"';&75"B(717$7$"&)9*7";7**'H>A%B."8%47H%>7N"'3("D%$5%=A&"#31A)(%>&">77D7$"&'"A)T7"7F&75$7$"%&>7*;"%5&'"&A7"9)>47&;3*>"';"D7)&"

)5$"1A77>7")5$"H%57")&" &A7" &)9*7>" %5"&A7"B)(%>A"A)**."/>")"&77&'&)*%5="

6('&7>&)5&N"&A7"*%97()&%5="D'$7()&7"&%)5"aH%57?%5$317$"D7((%D75&]"

M"H%&57>>7$"&A)&"5%=A&"(7D%5$7$"D7"';"&A7"H'($>"';"&")&"&A7"8)>&"

C3BB7(N"HA75"A7"B('D%>7$"&'"$(%54"';"&A7"j;(3%&"';"&A7"T%57k"H%&A"A%>"

$%>1%B*7>"HA75"A7"A)$"1'D7"%5&'"A%>"e%5=$'D"[8347"KK.!Y\."C77%5="&A7"

MR\OOHGERG\RI&KULVWJDWKHUHGWRJHWKHUVRHDUO\LQWKHPRUQLQJRQH

D%=A&"A)T7"&A'3=A&"&A7"e%5=$'D"A)$")*(7)$:"1'D7."

M;"c)&A7("C1AD7D)55"%>"(%=A&N"&A75"&A7"e%5=$'D"A)$"17(&)%5*:"1'D7."

dA75"H7"B():"jGA:"e%5=$'D"1'D7k"97;'(7"(717%T%5="N"!XSO\N"K^.


2/15

K^!

$'"5'&"B():";'("&A7"e%5=$'D"&'"1'D7">'D7&%D7"%5"&A7";3&3(7."Q'("$'"

H7"B():";'("%&"&'"D7(7*:"1'D7">B%(%&3)**:"%5&'"'3("A7)(&>."GA7"e%5=$'D"

%>"5'&">B%(%&3)*b"()&A7(N"%&"A)>"9'$%7>"%5"%&p"C'"H7"B():"jGA:"e%5=$'D"

1'D7k" A7(7N" 5'HN" 3B'5" 3>N" )5$" %5"D)4%5="j&A%>" 9(7)$" &A7" B(71%'3>"

+'$:"';"&A:"&Nk"D)47"3>"'57"H%&A"A%D."GA'3=A"&A7"e%5=$'D"%>"5'&"&A7"1A3(1AN";'("&A7"1A3(1A"A)>">%557(>"%5"%&N"&A7"e%5=$'D"D)47>"

3>"&A7"1A3(1A." M5">B%&7"';"'3("T%>%9*7"%DB7(;71&%'5>N"5'57&A7*7>>N"&A7"

e%5=$'D"(7T7)*>"3>"&'"97"&A7"9'$:"';"&."GA%>">&3$:"7F)D%57>"&A7"

71'5'D%1"%DB*%1)&%'5>"';"HA)&"%&"D7)5>";'("&A7"#31A)(%>&"&'"D)47"&A7"

e%5=$'D"B(7>75&"3>")>"&A7"9'$:"';"&."+71)3>7"&A7"B(7>75&">B)17"

);;'($>"5'"&%D7";'(")5"7FA)3>&%T7">&3$:"';"&A%>"&'B%1N"&A%>">&3$:";'13>7>"

VSHFLFDOO\RQWKHHFRQRPLFVRIWKH.LQJGRPZLWKLQWKHFRQWH[WRI

#31A)(%>&%1"B(7B)()&%'5")5$"#31A)(%>&%1"H'(&A%57>>."

dA75"%&"1'D7>"&'"'3("B(7B)()&%'5"&'"(717%T7N"D'>&*:"H7"&75$"&'"

&A%54")9'3&"%5$%T%$3)*N">B%(%&3)*"$%>1%B*%57>"*%47";)>&%5=N"1'5;7>>%'5N")5$"

B():7(N"HA%*7")&"&A7">)D7"&%D7")145'H*7$=%5="&A)&"5'57"';"3>"%>"(7)**:"

H'(&A:"&'"(717%T7"&A7"9'$:")5$"9*''$"';"&N"93&"9:"&A7"=()17"';"2'$N"

LIRXUKHDUWVDUHULJKWWKH(XFKDULVWLVHIFDFLRXV&"

5'&A%5="&'"$'"H%&A"%5$%T%$3)*N">B%(%&3)*"B(7B)()&%'5."6(7B)()&%'5"%>"*7>>"

)9'3&" HA)&" H7" $'" B(%'(" &'" >"%>"1'(B'()&7N"

9'$%*:N")5$"71'5'D%1."GA3>N"%&"%>";('D"&A%>"9%9*%1)*"B7(>B71&%T7"&A)&"&A%>"

>&3$:")$T)517>"HA)&"%>")"()&A7(">&('5="1*)%D,"M;"'3("&"D)47>"B(7>75&"%5"&A7"1A3(1AN")5$"%>N"&A7(7;'(7N"

)">1)5$)*."

"

M"45'H"&A)&"&A7"*)5=3)=7"';">1)5$)*"%>"9'*$N"B7(A)B>"7T75"';;75>%T7N"

93&"%5"3>%5="&A%>"H'($"M"='"5'";3(&A7("&A)5"&A7"/B'>&*7"6)3*N"HA'">)%$"&A7"

>)D7"&A%5=")9'3&"&A7"&*7"6)3*")>>7(&7$"

&A)&"HA75" &%)5>" =)&A7(" ;'(" " j5'&q&A7"8'($]>"

C3BB7(k"&A7:"7)&N"93&"ji3$=D75&.kO"C'N"&A%>"B(7>75&"&A7>%>"$7T7*'B>"9:"

O""C77"!"


3/15

K^K

7F7=7&%5=" &A%>"B)>>)=7"';"6)3*]>"7B%>&*7" &'"&A7""T%7H"';"&A7"1A3(1A")>"&A7"1'5&%53)&%'5"';"-7>3>]"

D%5%>&(:")5$" 7T%$7517"';"&A7" $)H5%5="';"&A7"e%5=$'D"';"2'$."GA7"

>71'5$">71&%'5"H%**"B(7>75&")">&)5$)($"1*)%D"&A)&"&A7"e%5=$'D"-7>3>"

B(7)1A7$")5$"7D9'$%7$";35$)D75&)**:"%5T'*T7$")"57H"71'5'D%1"'($7(."7KHQDOVHFWLRQXQSDFNVWKHOLWXUJLFDODQGSUDFWLFDOLPSOLFDWLRQVRI

6)3*]>"1'5$7D5)&%'5";'("'3("1'5&7F&"9:"7FB*'(%5="HA)&"%&"D7)5>";'("&A7"

#31A)(%>&"&'"D)47"&A)&"57H"'($7("B(7>75&")D'5="3>.

3=/"%(#2'#/,Q)('"#&422,#&,'"4,0)(#&'"#%&,0"=(/"

67(A)B>N"5'"'&A7("B)>>)=7"';"C1(%B&3(7"A)>"1'5&(%93&7$"D'(7"&'"B%'3>"

DQ[LHW\WKDQZKDWWKH$SRVWOH3DXOZURWHDERXWWKH(XFKDULVWLQKLVUVW

*7&&7("&'"&A7"")5$"$(%54>"i3$=D75&"3B'5"A%D>7*;"[!""1'5>7U37517>"&A'>7"HA'"1'DD357"35H'(&A%*:."

GA7:"H%**"97"1A)>&757$"H%&A"$%>7)>7")5$"B'>>%9*:"7T75"$7)&AN"HA%1A"A7"

%5$%1)&7>"%>")">%=5"';"$%T%57"=()17N">'"&A)&"&A7"35H'(&A:"1'DD35%1)5&"

D):"&3(5")5$"(7B75&")5$"5'&"97"j1'5$7D57$"H%&A"&A7"H'(*$k"[!"N"j*7&")"D)5"7F)D%57"A%D>7*;k"B(%'("

&'""5'&"&'"B)(&)47"35H'(&A%*:"[!""&'">7*;?7F)D%5)&%'5")5$"&A(7)&>"';"

$7)&A")5$"A7**"1'5&(%93&7$"&'"&A7"%5;(7U375&""1'5&%537>"&'$):.P"/;&7(")**N"=%T75"&A7"(%>4>"%5T'*T7$"%5"B)(&)4%5="

';"&A7"9'$:")5$"9*''$"';"&N"%&">77D>"(7)>'5)9*7"7T75";'("&A7"B%'3>"

&'"H)5&"&'"97">);7"()&A7("&A)5">'((:."

GA%>" )5F%7&:" B('9)9*:" 'H7>" D31A" &'" &A7" 1A3(1A" ;)&A7(>]"

%5&7(B(7&)&%'5>"';"&A%>"B)>>)=7."GA7"7F&)5&"%5&7(B(7&)&%'5>"35%T7(>)**:"

;'13>"'5"&A7"577$";'("&A7"%5$%T%$3)*"&%)5"&'")BB(')1A"&A7"13B"';"

&"%5";7)(")5$"&(7D9*%5=."/D9('>%)>&7(">)%$N"j6)3*"&7)1A7>"&A)&"'57"

P""/11'($%5="&'"/,&(M5%",(A-@@#)%"%&'(/-$52(5)$( ",&(A--3&+5"%;&(A-)1+&15"%-)'(!"#$2( 7+-g&4"N"

&A'3=A"B(%7>&>"(7B'(&"&A)&"&A7"D)i'(%&:"';"&A7%("B)(%>A%'57(>"1'DD357"H774*:N"57)(*:")"&A%($"1'DD357"

RQO\RQFHSHUPRQWKRURQPDMRUKROLGD\V,WLVZRUWKQRWLQJWKDWWKHVHJXUHVDUHRQO\

B(%7>&>]" 7>&%D)&7>" )5$" $'" 5'&" )11'35&" ;'(" %5$%T%$3)*"T)(%)&%'5"H%&A%5"1'5=(7=)&%'5>."#*75%"0)4(%>N"

j87)(5%5="/9'3&"E3(>7*T7>,"/"C5)B>A'&"';" &A7"E(&A'$'F"


4/15

K^O

>A'3*$"1'D7"&'"'"

&A)&"&A7"D%5$"H%**"35$7(>&)5$"&A)&"%&"D3>&"(7T7(7"&A7"'57"HA'>7"9'$:"

%&"%>"1'D%5="&'"1'5>3D7.k"C)%5&"-'A5"'>&'DN")"$7T'&7$">&3$75&"

';"&A7"H(%&%5=>"';"6)3*N">)%$"&A)&"97;'(7" &A7"#31A)(%>&"'57">A'3*$"97"

7DB&%7$"';"jB(';)57"*3>&>k"*%47"j&A'>7"';"&A7"9'$:N"';"D'57:N"';")5=7(N"';"D)*%17N")5$">'"'5.k"GA7(7;'(7N"jM5":'3("1'5>1%7517N"HA7(7"5'"'57"%>"

B(7>75&"7F17B&"2'$qi3$=7":'3(>7*;N"7F)D%57":'3(">%5>q"H):N"H%&A")"1*7)5"1'5>1%7517N"&'31A"&A7">)1(7$"

WDEOHDQGSDUWLFLSDWHLQWKHKRO\VDFULFH/LNHZLVH6DLQW$XJXVWLQH

>):>"&A)&"&'"1'DD357"35H'(&A%*:"%>"&'"(717%T7"&A7"9'$:"';"&"j%5"

D'147(:"[)5$\"1'5&7DB&.kZ"

/3=3>&%57]>";'(7(3557(N"&" %5" *%=A&" ';" &A7" @71%)5" B7(>713&%'5." GA'3=A" 5'&"

FRPPHQWLQJ VSHFLFDOO\ RQ WKLV SDVVDJH OLNH WKRVH FKXUFK IDWKHUV

U3'&7$")9'T7N"A7"*%54>"#31A)(%>&%1"35H'(&A%57>>"&'"&A7"B7(>'5)*">%5>"

'57"9(%5=>"&'"&A7")*&)("[%5"A%>"1'5&7F&"&A7">%5"';")B'>&)>:\."GA3>N"%5"

E5"&A7"8)B>7$N"N"&A7"D'>&">A'14%5=">&'(:"&"&'"A7("B)(75&>N")5"%5;)5&"A)$"

B(7T%'3>*:"9775"=%T75"9(7)$"D%F7$"H%&A"&A7"*7;&'T7("H%57"';")"B)=)5"

*%9)&%'5."dA75"&A7"1A%*$"H)>" *)&7("=%T75")*")=(77D75&"&A)&"B7(>'5)*">%5>")(7"HA)&"D)47"'57"35H'(&A:"&'"

1'DD357."M&"%>"35$7(>&)5$)9*7N"=%T75"&A7%("1'5&7F&>N"&A)&"&A7:"H'3*$"

>&(7>>" &A%>" %5$%T%$3)*%>&%1" 35$7(>&)5$%5="';"H'(&A%57>>."&)D75&"VMM"[@'H57(>"2('T7N"M8,"M5&7(T)(>%&:N"!XXX\N"!!K.

^""


5/15

K^P

&'"$7)*"H%&A"&A7"B('9*7D"';")B'>&)>:")5$"&A7"&A(7)&" &A)&"%&"1(7)&7$"&'"

A%>"'H5")3&A'(%&:N">'"A7"A)$"(7)>'5"&'">&(7>>"&A)&"B(%T)&7")B'>&)>:"A)$"

B39*%1"1'5>7U37517>.S"c)1%5="D'(7"&A)5")"*%&&*7"D)(=%5)*"&%)5%&:"

LQDQRIFLDOO\&KULVWLDQHPSLUHLWLVXQGHUVWDQGDEOHZK\RWKHUIDWKHUV

H'3*$"A)T7">&(7>>7$">7*;?7F)D%5)&%'5")5$"%5$%T%$3)*"D'()*"B3(%&:"B(%'("&'"(717%T%5="&A7"9'$:")5$"9*''$"';"&A7"8'($."Q'("H7(7"&A7:"H('5="&'"

$'">'p"M")D"5'&")(=3%5="&A)&"H7">A'3*$"$%>B75>7"H%&A"&A7"B(7(7U3%>%&7>"

';";)>&%5=N"1'5;7>>%'5N"B():7(" )5$" '&A7(">B%(%&3)*"$%>1%B*%57>"B(%'(" &'"

1'DD35%5=."E5*:N"%5">):%5="&A)&N"H7"577$"&'"35$7(>&)5$"&A)&"&A%>"%>"5'&"

HA)&"6)3*"B(%D)(%*:"D7)5&"9:"7)&%5="35H'(&A%*:."

/"(A7&'(%1)*")5)*:>%>"';"!""H%&A"A'H"D7D97(>"';"&A7"&%)5"1'DD35%&:"&(7)&7$"7)1A"'&A7("

97;'(7N"$3(%5=N")5$");&7("%&."+71)3>7"&A7"D'$7(5"+%9*7"A)>"1A)B&7(>")5$"

T7(>7>"[)5$"5'H"';&75"j>39i71&"A7)$%5=>k\N"%&"%>"7)>:"&'"%>'*)&7"%5$%T%$3)*"

B)>>)=7>";('D"'57")5'&A7(.Y"Q'57&A7*7>>N"!"")&"*7)>&")>"7)(*:")>"1A)B&7("^")5$"1'5&%537>"

%5&'"1A)B&7("!K"[)5$"B('9)9*:"&A('3=A"&A7"(7>&"';"&A7"7B%>&*7\."M5"1A)B&7("

3DXOGHQHVHDWLQJXQZRUWKLO\DVIDLOLQJWRGLVFHUQWKH/RUGVERG\

[!"&%&3&7">'D7A'H"35%&7>"&A7"HA'*7"

1A3(1A"&'"A7(."`7")>4>N"jCA)**"Mq&)47"&A7"D7D97(>"';"&")5$"D)47"

&A7D"D7D97(>"';")"A)(*'&g""1)>7\"HA'">%5>"H%&A")"B('>&%&3&7">%5>"j)=)%5>&"A%>"'H5"9'$:Nk"HA%1A"

LPSOLHVDWUVWJODQFHWKDWVXFKDSHUVRQKDUPVKLPVHOI7UXHDVWKDW

D):"97N">31A")"1'51*3>%'5"D)47>"*%&&*7">75>7"%5"*%=A&"';"6)3*]>"B(7T%'3>"

B'%5&"&A)&">*77B%5="H%&A")"B('>&%&3&7")1&3)**:"A)(D>"&A7"HA'*7"1A3(1AN"

S""-."6)&'3&"+3(5>N"A23+%5)(",&(J%',-3[Q7H"R'(4,"_'3&*7$=7N"KLLK\N"KZ?ZLN"SY?XXN"!OK?ZL.

Y""M")D"%5$79&7$"&'"@)T%$"@)3*&";'("A%>"7D7(=%5="H'(4"'5"A'H"&A7"D)&7(%)*"1'5>&(31&%'5"';"C1(%B&3(7"

>A)B7>"'3("%5&7(B(7&)&%'5>"';"%&."@)T%$"@)3*&N"jGA7">7(&)&%'5N"V)5$7(9%*&N"KLLX\.

X""W5*7>>"'&A7(H%>7"%5$%1)&7$N")**"9%9*%1)*"U3'&)&%'5>")(7";('D"&A7"Qe-V."


6/15

K^Z

7>B71%)**:");&7("A7")>4>"&A7";'**'H%5="(A7&'(%1)*"U37>&%'5N"jE("$'":'3"

5'&"45'H" &A)&":'3("9'$:" %>" &A7" &7DB*7" ';" &A7"`'*:"CB%(%&"HA'"%>" %5"

:'3N"HA'D":'3" A)T7" ;('D"2'$N" )5$":'3")(7"5'&":'3(" 'H5"[!""H%&A"&A7%(">%5=3*)("j:'3k"%DB*:"&A)&"

'3("%5$%T%$3)*"9'$%7>")(7"%5$%T%$3)*"&7DB*7>N"93&"%5"&A7"2(774"&A7":'3"['34"'%$)&7\"%>"B*3()*."GA7"D7)5%5="';"&A%>"T7(>7N"HA%1A"%>"1'5>%>&75&"

H%&A"6)3*]>"B'%5&")9'3&"%5$%T%$3)*">%5>"A)T%5="1'(B'()&7"1'5>7U37517>N"

%>"&A)&"&A7"N"&'"1'((71&"&A%>"

&()5>*)&%'5"[H%&A"&A7">*%=A&*:"D'(7")$T)517$"*7F%1'5"';" &A7"/D7(%1)5"

C'3&A\N" 6)3*]>" B'%5&" %>" &A)&N" j:])**>" 9'$:" %>" &A7" &7DB*7" ';" &A7"`'*:"

CB%(%&qk!L"GA7"9'$:"&A7"j-'A5k"A)(D>"%>"&A7"1A3(1A"9'$:."GA3>N"6)3*"

A)>")*(7)$:"%5&('$317$")"&A7D7"&A)&"A7"D)47>"7FB*%1%&"%5"!""%5&7(7>&%5="

&A)&"&A7"H'($";'("D7D97(>"%>"&A7">)D7"%5"9'&A"1A)B&7("^")5$"!K.\"M5"9'&A"

1)>7>N" 6)3*" $7)*&"H%&A" B()1&%1)*" %>>37>N" B('>&%&3&%'5")5$" ;)1&%'5)*%>D"

[>77"!.!L?!S"v"O.!?!S\N"&A7'*'=%1)**:N"9:">&(7>>%5="&A7"B'%5&"';"711*7>%)*"

35%&:")>"'57"9'$:."M5$77$N"&A%>"%>"A'H"6)3*"$7)*>"H%&A"57)(*:"7T7(:"

B()1&%1)*"1'517(5"';"&A7"&3'3>"(7*)&%'5>A%B"97&H775">&7B>'5")5$">&7BD'&A7(N"

B('B(%7&:"%5"H'(>A%BN")5$"7T75"&A7"(7>3((71&%'5"';"&A7"$7)$.!!"6)3*">77D>"

&'"*'1)&7"&A7">'*3&%'5"&'")**"';"&A7>7"1'517(5>"%5"97%5="35%&7$"&'=7&A7("9:"*'T7"%5"&A7"'57"9'$:"';"&.

M;"&A)&"%>"&(37N"&A75"%&">77D>"%51(7$%9*7"&'"&A%54"&A)&"6)3*"%>">):%5="

B7(>'5)*">%5"D)47>")5"%5$%T%$3)*"35H'(&A:"&'"(717%T7"")(7"&'"$%>17(5"%5"!!.KX"%>"17(&)%5*:"&A7"9'$:"';"&A7"

A%>&'(%1)*"-7>3>N"D)$7"B(7>75&"%5"&A7"9(7)$")5$"H%57"[&A3>"T7(>7>"KO?K^\N"

93&";'("6)3*"&A7"A%>&'(%1)*"9'$:"%>"5'&">7B)()&7";('D"&A7"711*7>%)*"9'$:."

GA7"9'$:"';"&N"HA%1A"&A7""

)*>'"&A7D>7*T7>.!K"E&A7(H%>7N"6)3*]>"1'5$7D5)&%'5"';"&A7""B*3()*.

!!""!""&A)&"&A7"9'$:"&A7""'5*:"&A7"9'$:"';"&A7">)T%5="&N"5'&"5717>>)(%*:"jD:>&%1)**:"B(7>75&k"%5"&A7"


7/15

K^^

97A)T%'(" %5" T7(>7>" !S?K!" D)47>" 5'" >75>7." W5*%47" '>&'DN"

/3=3>&%57N")5$"B%(%&3)*"B(7B)()&%'5."G'">77"

HA)&"A7"1'5$7D5>"H7">A'3*$"7F)D%57"&A%>"B)>>)=7"%5"%&>"75&%(7&:."

Q'H"%5"=%T%5="&A7>7"%5>&(31&%'5>"M"$'"5'&"B()%>7":'3N">%517"

\RXFRPHWRJHWKHUQRWIRUWKHEHWWHUEXWIRUWKHZRUVH)RUUVW

';")**N"HA75":'3"1'D7"&'=7&A7(")>")"1A3(1AN"M"A7)("&A)&"&A7(7")(7"

$%T%>%'5>")D'5=":'3N")5$" %5"B)(&"M"97*%7T7"%&."c'(" &A7(7"D3>&"

)*>'"97";)1&%'5>")D'5=":'3N"&A)&"&A'>7"HA'")(7")BB('T7$"D):"

97"(71'=5%I7$")D'5=":'3."GA7(7;'(7"HA75":'3"1'D7"&'=7&A7("

%5"'57"B*)17N"%&"%>"5'&"&'"7)&"&A7"8'($]>"C3BB7(."c'("%5"7)&%5=N"

7)1A" '57" &)47>" A%>" 'H5" >3BB7(" )A7)$" ';" '&A7(>b" )5$" '57" %>"

A35=(:")5$")5'&A7("%>"$(354."dA)&p"@'":'3"5'&"A)T7"A'3>7>"

&'"7)&")5$"$(%54"%5g"E("$'":'3"$7>B%>7"&A7"1A3(1A"';"2'$")5$"

>A)D7"&A'>7"HA'"A)T7"5'&A%5=g"dA)&">A)**"M">):"&'":'3g"CA)**"

M"B()%>7":'3"%5"&A%>g"M"$'"5'&"B()%>7":'3.

6)3*" >):>" 5'&A%5=" )9'3&" ;)>&%5=N" 1'5;7>>%'5N" )5$" B():7(" %5" &A%>"

B)>>)=7."GA7">%5>"';"&A7"'">7(%'3>"&A)&"&A7:")1&3)**:"53**%;:"&A7"8'($]>"C3BB7(."

GA'>7"HA'" 1'DD%&" &A%>" >%5" $'" 5'&" j7)&" &A7"8'($]>"C3BB7(k" [!"&."c'("6)3*N"&A7">%5"

WKDWQXOOLHV&RPPXQLRQ DQGPDNHVLWQRWWKH/RUGV6XSSHU LV

71'5'D%1."`7">):>"j&A7(7")(7"$%T%>%'5>")D'5=":'3Nk")5$"971)3>7"';"

HOHPHQWVEXWWKHVDYLQJVLJQLFDQFHRI-HVXVKLPVHOI$ODQ)-RKQVRQ ](A-+%)",%5)'N"7$."2()5&"

_."E>9'(57N"GA7"M.V.6."Q7H"G7>&)D75&""2('T7N"M8,"M5&7(V)(>%&:N"KLLP\N"

-RVHSK$)LW]P\HURQWKHRWKHUKDQGDUJXHVWKDWWKHGLVFHUQPHQWLVLQGLYLGXDOUHHFWLRQXSRQ

'57]>"H'(&A%57>>"&'"B)(&)47."-'>7BA"/."c%&ID:7(N"M%+'"(A-+%)",%5)'L(8(B&R(/+5)'05"%-)(R%",(>)"+-$#4P

"%-)(5)$(A-@@&)"5+2N"7$."d%**%)D"c'FH7**"/*9(%=A&")5$"@)T%$"Q'7*"c(77$D)5N"GA7"/51A'("R)*7"

+%9*7[Q7H"`)T75,"R)*7N"KLLY\N"PP^."M"*)14"c%&ID:7(]>"7FB7(&%>7N"93&"&A%>"%5&7(B(7&)&%'5">77D>"1'D?

B*7&7*:")&"'$$>"H%&A"&A7"B'%5&"';"&A7"B)>>)=7."6)3*"C)DB*7:">77D>"&'"D7"&'"';;7("&A7"97>&"(7)$%5="HA75"

KHVD\V>,@Q3DXOVWKRXJKWWKHERG\RI&KULVWFDQQHYHUEHVHSDUDWHGIURPWKHPHPEHUVZKRE\

2'$]>"=()17")(7"%51'(B'()&7$"%5&'"%&."C'"a$%>17(5%5="&A7"9'$:]"%>"6)3*]>">A'(&A)5$"H):"';"&)*4%5=")9'3&"

)5"%5$%T%$3)*]>")>>7>>D75&"';"&H'"$%>&%5=3%>A)9*7"93&"%5>7B)()9*7"D)&&7(>,"A'H"H7**"'57]>"*%;7"(7*)&7>"

&'"&")5$"A'H"H7**"'57]>"*'T7"&%7>"'57"&'"'&A7(>"HA'N"&A'3=A"D)5:N")(7"'57"9'$:"%5"&.k"-'A5?

VRQLVSDUWO\FRUUHFWVRLV)LW]P\HULQVRIDUDVDQ\DFWRIZRUVKLSLQYROYHVVRPHSHUVRQDOUHHFWLRQ

+3&"%;"H7")(7"&'"&)47"!K.KS">7(%'3>*:N"&A7"jA%>&'(%1)*k"&"1)55'&"97">7B)()&7$";('D"&A7"j711*7>%)*k"

&"%5"6)3*]>"&A7'*'=:."-."6)3*"C)DB*7:N"j!"AT%**7,"

/9%5=$'5N"KLLK\N"XO^.


8/15

K^S

&A7>7"$%T%>%'5>N"&A7(7"%>"5'"#31A)(%>&"A)BB75%5=."dA)&"4%5$>"';"$%T%>%'5>"

)(7"&A7>7"&A)&"H'3*$"53**%;:"&A7"1A3(1A]>"C)1()D75&g"W5*%47"B(7T%'3>"

1A)B&7(>"%5"!""A)T7"5'&A%5="&'"$'"H%&A"HA'"

9)B&%I7$N"HA'" %>" >*77B%5="H%&AN"'("HA'" %>" >3%5="HA'D."_)&A7(N"6)3*"

='7>"'5"&'"B'%5&"'3&"&A)&"j'57"%>"A35=(:")5$")5'&A7("%>"$(354.k"0'$7(5"9%9*%1)*" >1A'*)(>" A)T7" >3(D%>7$" &A)&" )&" &A%>" B'%5&" %5" 1A3(1A" A%>&'(:N"

HA75"&A7"#31A)(%>&"H)>"B)(&"';")"*)(=7("D7)*"&A)&"3>3)**:"&''4"B*)17"%5"

WKHHYHQLQJVLWZDVGLIFXOWIRUSRRUODERUHUVWRPDNHLWWRFKXUFKRQ

WLPH:KHQWKH\QDOO\DUULYHGWKH\IRXQGWKDWWKHZHDOWK\&KULVWLDQV

&A)&"$%$"5'&"A)T7"&'"H'(4"*'5="A'3(>"A)$")*(7)$:"7)&75")**"&A7";''$."

1%B*%57N" 7%&A7(" A7" >):>" 5'&A%5=" )9'3&" %&N" '(" HA)&7T7(" A7"

$%$" >):" &A7" 1A3(1A"$%$" 5'&" $77D" %DB'(&)5&"75'3=A" &'"%51*3$7" %5"&A7"

Q7H"G7>&)D75&."c'("A%DN"&'">):"&A7"1A3(1A"%>"&A7"9'$:"';"&"%>"5'"

D7&)BA'(."M&"H)>"&A7")>175$7$"&"7F&75$7$"%5&'"&A%>"H'(*$"&A('3=A"

A%>"B7'B*7N"HA'D"6)3*"7FB71&7$"&'"7D9'$:"&A7"57H"71'5'D%1"'($7("';"

&]>"e%5=$'DN")"e%5=$'D")*(7)$:"$)H5%5=N"';"HA%1A"&A7"1A3(1A"

H)>"B('';."GA3>N"&A7"1A3(1A"H)>"&'"97")"$%;;7(75&"4%5$"';"1'DD35%&:N"

'57"1A)()1&7(%I7$"9:"71'5'D%1"i3>&%17."G'"1'DD357"35H'(&A%*:"H)>"&'"B)(&)47"%5")"H):"&A)&"T%'*)&7$"&A7"57H"71'5'D:"';"&A7"e%5=$'D"';"2'$."

7"4,3/)&)1+,):,'"4,Z#&&*7"&'"&A7"2)*)&%)5>"[2)*."!.!K\N"6)3*">):>"&A)&"A7"(717%T7$"

&A7"2'>B7*"9:")"$%(71&"(7T7*)&%'5";('D"-7>3>"&N">'"%&"%>">);7"&'">):"

&A)&"HA75"6)3*"7FB71&7$"&A7"'D7&A%5=."GA7"1'D%5="(7%=5"';"2'$"H)>")"1'517B&"

&A)&"B(7$)&7$"&A7"7)(&A*:"D%5%>&(:"';"-7>3>."c'(")"-7H"';"6)3*]>"$):N"

&A7"e%5=$'D"';"2'$"H)>")"D7>>%)5%1"1'517B&"&A)&"%5T'*T7$"D'(7"&A)5"

'T7(&A('H%5="_'D)5"(3*7")5$"(77>&)9*%>A%5=")5"%5$7B75$75&"5)&%'5"';"

M>()7*."M&")*>'"%DB*%7$"&A7"7>&)9*%>AD75&"';")"17(&)%5"4%5$"';">'1%7&:."M5"

!O""C77"2'($'5"@."c77N"/,&(M%+'"(S3%'"0&("-(",&(A-+%)",%5)' N"GA7"Q7H"M5&7(5)&%'5)*","#7($D)5>N"!XYS\N"ZO!?^X."/*>'"C)DB*7:N"XOP."c%&ID:7(N"POP?OZ."

-'A5>'5N"KLZ?L^.


9/15

K^Y

477B%5="H%&A"&A7"B('BA7&%1"&()$%&%'5"';"&A7"E*$"G7>&)D75&N">'1%)*")5$"

71'5'D%1"i3>&%17"H'3*$"7>B71%)**:"1A)()1&7(%I7"&A7"Q7H"M>()7*."GA3>"

&A7"B('BA7&"/D'>"1'5$7D57$"&A7"j(7*%=%'3>";7)>&>k")5$"j)>>7D9*%7>k"

';"&A7"jA'3>7"';"M>()7*Nk")5$"%5>&7)$">)%$N"j+3&"*7&"i3>&%17"('**"'5"*%47"

)"(%T7(N" (%=A&7'3>57>>" *%47")"57T7(";)%*%5=">&(7)Dk"[/D'>"Z.K!?KZ\.!P"GA7"$7)&A")5$"(7>3((71&%'5"';"-7>3>"(7U3%(7$"A%>"7)(*%7>&";'**'H7(>"&'"

(77T)*3)&7" &A7%(" 35$7(>&)5$%5=" ';" A'H" &A7"e%5=$'D" ';" 2'$"H'3*$"

97"7>&)9*%>A7$."/>"d'*;A)(&"6)557597(="B'%5&>"'3&N" &A7:"H'3*$"A)T7"

T%7H7$" &A7" (7>3((71&%'5"';"&")>"&A7"97=%55%5="';" &A)&"e%5=$'DN"

ZKLFKLVZK\3DXOFDOOHG-HVXVWKHUVWIUXLWVRIWKRVHZKRKDYHIDOOHQ

)>*77Bk"[!"&%17")5$"(%=A&7'3>57>>"

KDGDOUHDG\EHJXQWRRZIURPWKHVLGHRI&KULVWLQWKLVFDVHEDFNLQWR

A%>"9'$:,"&A7"1A3(1A.

GA3>"&A7"e%5=$'D"';"2'$"H)>"%5$%>>'*39*:"9'35$"3B"H%&A">'1%)*N"

71'5'D%1"i3>&%17"%5"&A7"A7(7")5$"5'H."M5$77$N"&A7"07&A'$%>&"&A7'*'=%)5N"

0."@'3=*)>"0774>N"A)>"B7(>3)>%T7*:">A'H5"&A)&"&A7"75&%(7"A%>&'(:"';"

&A7"E*$"G7>&)D75&"1)5"97"(7)$"%5"&A7'*'=%1)*">'1%'?71'5'D%1"&7(D>N"

)5$"&A)&"&A7">&'(:"';"2'$"[>'"&'">B7)4\"1)5"97"(7)$")>"'57"';"71'5'D%1"

>'*%$)(%&:" H%&A" &A7" B''(." +'&A" 0774>" )5$" &A7" /5)9)B&%>&N" -'A5"`'H)($"R'$7(N"A)T7"A%=A*%=A&7$"D)5:"';"&A7"71'5'D%1"%DB*%1)&%'5>"

';"&A7"2'>B7*"%&>7*;."M")D"A%=A*:"%5$79&7$"&'"&A7D";'("&A7";'**'H%5="

'9>7(T)&%'5>N"HA%1A"A7*B"3>"&'"D)47">75>7"';"6)3*]>"1'5$7D5)&%'5"';"

WKH&RULQWKLDQVEHFDXVHWKH.LQJGRPRI*RG-HVXVSUHDFKHG DQG

KHHPERGLHGZDVYHU\PXFKDERXWHDWLQJSDUWLFXODUO\ZKRDWHDQG

HA'"H75&"A35=(:."M5$77$N"&A'3=A"%&"%>"';&75"'T7(*''47$N"-7>3>]"D%5%>&(:"

7*7T)&7$"71'5'D%1>" )>")" ;35$)D75&)*" %5$%1)&'(" ';" &A7" )$T75&" ';" &A7"

e%5=$'D.!^

!P""c'("HA)&"(7D)%5>"'57"';"&A7"97>&">:5'B>7>"';"&A7"B('BA7&%1"7DBA)>%>"'5">'1%)*"i3>&%17"%5"&A7"E*$"

G7>&)D75&N">77"-'A5"2."2)DD%7N"E-0%)&''(%)(>'+5&0[0%557)B'*%>,"c'(&(7>>N"!XYX\N"S!?!KP.

!Z""d'*;A)(&"6)557597(=N"!2'"&@5"%4(/,&-0-12N"&()5>.N"27';;(7:"d."+('D%*7:N"T'*."K"[2()5$"_)B%$>,"

#7($D)5>N"!XXY\N"OZL.

!^""0."@'3=*)>"0774>N"N-$(",&(S4-)-@%'"L(/,&(=-4"+%)&(-N"!XXP\N"K!?SZ."/*>'"-'A5"`'H)($"R'$7(N"J-$2(7-0%"%4'L(M%;&(7+54"%4&'(


10/15

K^X

GA7"2'>B7*"';"8347"[HA%1AN"%&"%>"%5&7(7>&%5="&'"5'&7N"&()$%&%'5">):>"

H)>"H(%&&75"9:"&A7"BA:>%1%)5?$%>1%B*7"';"6)3*\"(7=3*)(*:")1175&3)&7>"&A7"

WKHPHRISRYHUW\$FFRUGLQJWRWKH0DJQLFDW0DU\WKH7KHRWRNRV

35$7(>&''$"HA)&"H)>"A)BB75%5="&'"A7("U3%&7"'9T%'3>*:""%5"71'5'D%1"

WHUPV6KHPDJQLHVWKH/RUGEHFDXVH+HKDVSXWGRZQWKHPLJKW\IURPWKHLUWKURQHV$QGH[DOWHGWKHORZO\+HKDVOOHGWKHKXQJU\

H%&A"=''$"&A%5=>N"ss"/5$"&A7"(%1A"A7"A)>">75&")H):"7DB&:k"[8347"!.P^N"

ZK?ZO\."GA7"M51)(5)&%'5"';"&A7"d'($"H)>"&'"9(%5="5'&"i3>&")5"%5T7(>%'5"

';">'1%)*"T)*37>"93&")*>'"&A7"T7(:">&(31&3(7>"';">'1%7&:"%&>7*;."GA7"*'H7(N"

*)9'(%5=" 1*)>>7>"H%**" 97" B*)17$" '5" &'B" )&" &A7" 7FB75>7" ';" &A'>7"HA'"

A)T7"D)$7"&A7%("H7)*&A"'3&"';"&A7D."GA%>">'5=">3(7*:"%51*3$7>"-7>3>"

A%D>7*;N"HA'>7"B'T7(&:"8347")*>'" &)47>"B)%5>"&'">&(7>>."dA75"0)(:"

D)$7"A7("H):"&'"&A7"G7DB*7";'("&A7"$7$%1)&%'5"';"A7("C'5N")5$"&'"D)47"

)5"';;7(%5=";'("A7("j1*7)5>%5=k"%5"477B%5="H%&A"&A7"87T%&%1)*"1'$7N">A7"

RIIHUHG WKH VDFULFH IRU SRRU SHRSOH $ SDLU RI WXUWOHGRYHV RU WZR

:'35="B%=7'5>Nk"[8347"K.KP\"HA%1A"87T%&%13>">&)&7>"%>";'("&A'>7"HA'"

)(7"j35)9*7"&'");;'($")"*)D9"[8347"!K.Y\.k"

GA'3=A"'57"D):"'T7(*''4"%&N"-7>3>"$71*)(7$"HA'D"A%>"D%5%>&(:"H)>"

B(%51%B)**:";'(N")5$"%&"H)>"5'&"'5*:";'("3>."/;&7("97%5=" &7DB&7$"%5" &A7"

$7>7(&N"-7>3>"75&7(7$"&A7"B39*%1">BA7(7N"97=%55%5="H%&A"A%>"A'D7&'H5N"

)5$")55'3517$"A%D>7*;N"$71*)(%5="[8347"P.!Y?!X\N

jGA7"CB%(%&"';"&A7"8E_@"%>"3B'5"07N

+71)3>7"`7"A)>")5'%5&7$"07

G'"B(7)1A"&A7"='>B7*"&'"&A7"B''(b

`7"A)>">75&"07"&'"A7)*"&A7"9('475A7)(&7$N

G'"B('1*)%D"*%97(&:"&'"&A7"1)B&%T7>

/5$"(71'T7(:"';">%=A&"&'"&A7"9*%5$N

G'">7&")&"*%97(&:"&A'>7"HA'")(7"'BB(7>>7$b

G'"B('1*)%D"&A7")117B&)9*7":7)("';"&A7"[email protected]

C'D7">77"&A%>"j)117B&)9*7":7)(k")>")"(7;7(7517"&'"&A7"E*$"G7>&)D75&"

-39%*77N")":7)("';"$79&?;'(=%T757>>"&A)&"H)>"B('9)9*:"57T7("'9>7(T7$"

-


11/15

KSL

%5"M>()7*N"93&"5'57&A7*7>>"(7T7)*>"&A7"71'5'D%1"%5&75&%'5>"';"&A7"2'$"

HA'"1'DD)5$7$"%&.!S"+3&"7T75"%;"%&"%>"5'&"&A7"1)>7"&A)&"-7>3>"$71*)(7$"

)"-39%*77N"&A7"B)>>)=7"A)>")"=(7)&"$7)*"&'">):")9'3&"&A7"71'5'D:"';"&A7"

.LQJGRP,QWKHUVWSODFHWKHJRRGQHZVKHSUHDFKHGZDVVSHFLFDOO\

;'("&A7"B''(."GA%>"%>"1'5>%>&75&"H%&A"&A7">'5="';"A%>"0'&A7(."GA7(7;'(7N"%&"%>"%5"&A%>"1'5&7F&"&A)&"H7"D3>&"%5&7(B(7&"&A7">39>7U375&"*%57>"';"&A7"

B('1*)D)&%'5."0'>&"1)B&%T7>")&"&A7"&%D7"H7(7"7%&A7("B'*%&%1)*"B(%>'57(>"

'("%5"$79&'(]>"B(%>'5."M&"%>"'5*:"9:")"D'>&"%51(7$%9*7">7*;?D'**%;:%5="

>&(7&1A" ';" &A7" %D)=%5)&%'5" &A)&" H7" 1'3*$" B'>>%9*:" (7)$" &A%>" *%97(&:"

)5$"B'T7(&:" %5"B3(7*:">B%(%&3)*" &7(D>."GA7"B''(N" &A7"1)B&%T7N")5$" &A7"

'BB(7>>7$")(7N";'("-7>3>N"'57?%5?&A7?>)D7."

Q'&" '5*:"H)>" -7>3>" )" B''("D)5N"HA'" B(7)1A7$" &'" &A7" B''(N"93&"

DOVRKHLQWHQWLRQDOO\LGHQWLHGZLWKWKHPLQKLVSXEOLFPLQLVWU\$VWKH

)$'B&7$"C'5"';")"1)(B75&7("[)11'($%5="&'"0)&&A7H"!O.ZZ")5$"0)(4"^.ON"

HA'"D):"A)T7"9775"D'(7"*%47")">4%**7$"*)9'(7("&A)5")"H''$H'(47(!Y\"

-7>3>"&'*$"B)()9*7>"&A)&"A)$">%&3)&%'5>")5$"1A)()1&7(>"H%&A"HA%1A"&A7"

B''("1'3*$"D'>&"7)>%*:"%$75&%;:."-7>3>"&)*4>")9'3&">'H%5=")5$"A)(T7>&%5="

DQGKHUGLQJRIDZRPDQZKRWXUQVKHUKRXVHXSVLGHGRZQWRQGMXVW

'57"*'>&"1'%5N"';")"97==)("HA'>7"H'35$>"&A7"$'=>"*%147$N"';")"H%$'H"

HA'"1'3*$"5'&"=7&"i3>&%17N")5$"';"D)5"H%&A"D'(7"$79&"&A)5"A7"1'3*$"

7T7("A'B7"&'"(7B):.!X"/**"93&"'57"';"&A7")B'>&*7>"';"-7>3>"D)$7"A%>"*%T%5="9:"&A7">H7)&"';"A%>"9('H"[)5$"&A7"7F17B&%'5N"0)&&A7HN"$%>75;()51A%>7$"

A%D>7*;"&'";'**'H"-7>3>\."d7")*>'"';&75";'13>"'5"A'H"-7>3>"H)>")5"

%&%57()5&"B(7)1A7(N"93&"HA)&"&A)&"(7)**:"D7)5>"%>"&A)&"-7>3>"H)>"A'D7*7>>N"

jc'F7>"A)T7"A'*7>N")5$"9%($>"';"&A7")%("A)T7"57>&>b"93&"&A7"C'5"';"D)5"

A)&A"5'&"HA7(7"&'"*):"A%>"A7)$"[8347"X.ZY\.k"

/5$"&A%>N"-7>3>">)%$N"%>"HA)&"&A7"4%5=$'D"*''4>"*%47."GA7"4%5=$'D"

';"2'$"97*'5=>"&'"&A7"B''("[8347" .KL\."M&"%>"(71'=5%I7$"HA7(7"&A7">%14"

)(7"A7)*7$"[8347"!L.X\")5$"HA7(7"$7D'5>")(7"1)>&"'3&"[8347"!!.KL\."

!S""-l(=75"0'*&D)55N"/,&(F52(-.N"0)(=)(7&"

e'A*[0%557)B'*%>,"c'(&(7>>N"!XXL\N"!!X?KK."R'$7(N"7-0%"%4'(-


12/15

KS!

GA7"e%5=$'D"';"2'$"='7>"HA7(7"-7>3>"='7>."GA3>N"&")$D'5%>A7$"

A%>"$%>1%B*7>"5'&"&'"*''4";'("&A7"e%5=$'D"';"2'$"A7(7")5$"&A7(7"93&"

ZLWKLQWKHP)RULQGHHGWKHNLQJGRPRI*RGLVZLWKLQ\RX /XNH

!S.K!\."GA'3=A"H7"';&75"&)47"&A%>"%5")">B%(%&3)*">75>7N")>"%;"&A7"e%5=$'D"

H7(7"%5"'3("A7)(&>N"&A7"=75%&%T7"B(7B'>%&%'5">A'3*$"D'(7"B('B7(*:"97"(75$7(7$"j%5"&A7"D%$>&"';k"'("j)D'5=.k"GA7"e%5=$'D"';"2'$"%>"5'&"

j%5>%$7k"7)1A"%5$%T%$3)*N"93&"%5"&A7"D%$>&"';"3>N"HA7(7T7("j&H'"'("&A(77"

)(7"=)&A7(7$"[0)&&"!Y.KL\.k"GA7"4%5=$'D"';"2'$"%>")D'5="3>"971)3>7"

-7>3>"%>"H%&A"3>p

7"4,Z#&" B(7>75&" HA7(7T7("

97*%7T7(>"=)&A7("35$7("&"%>")&"&A7"A7)(&"';")5"E(&A'$'F"&A7'*'=%1)*"

35$7(>&)5$%5="';"#31A)(%>&%1"*%&3(=:."M&"%>")*>'"HA:"6)3*">)H"&A7"1A3(1A")>"

)">%=5"';"&A7"$)H5%5="';"&A)&"e%5=$'DN")5$"HA:"A7"7FB71&7$")5"71'5'D%1"

(7'($7(%5="';"&A7"")>"

&'"HA:"A7"H75&">'";)(")>"&'">):"&A)&">A'H%5="7T75"B)>>%T7"1'5&7DB&";'("

WKHSRRUQXOOLHGWKH&RULQWKLDQV(XFKDULVW"7KHDQVZHUWRWKLVTXHVWLRQ

9(%5=>"3>"9)14"&'" &A7"U3'&7";('D"c)&A7("C1AD7D)55"&A)&"'B757$" &A%>"

7>>):N")">&)&7D75&"H'(&A"(7B7)&%5=." jGA7" *%&3(=:"';"&A7"#31A)(%>&Nk"A7"

>)%$N"j%>"&A7"i'3(57:"';"&A7"7517"';"&A7"e%5=$'D"%5"&A7"*%&3(=:."+3&"A7"$%$"35$7(>&)5$"&A)&"&A7"

FKXUFKLWVHOIZDVWKHVLWHRIWKH.LQJGRPVSUROHSWLFXQIROGLQJWKDWWKH

e%5=$'D"A)$")*(7)$:"97=35N")5$"&A7"1A3(1A"H)>"&A7"B('';p"GA7"#31A)(%>&"

H)>")";35$)D75&)**:"71'5'D%1";7)>&"971)3>7"%&"H)>"&A7"C)1()D75&"';"&A7"

1A3(1A]>"1'5>&%&3&%'5")>"&A)&"B('*7B>%>N">'D7&A%5="&A)&"H7"7)&")5$"$(%54"

j35&%*"A7"[&A7"8'($"-7>3>\"1'D7>.k

c)&A7("C1AD7D)55"A)>"7DB*':7$"&A7"D%F7$"D7&)BA'(>"';"*%&3(=%1)*"

1:1*7>"1'5>&%&3&%5=")"*%57)("i'3(57:"&'"7FB*)%5"A'H"&A7"e%5=$'D"';"2'$"

D)$7"B(7>75&"%5"&A7">)1()D75&"&A)&"%>"&A7"1A3(1A"971'D7>")5"%5&7=()&%5="

(7;7(7517"B'%5&";'("&A7"*%;7"';"&A7"97*%7T7(N"%5"1'5&()$%>&%51&%'5"&'"&A7"

$%>%5&7=()&%5="(3>A"';"D'$7(5"*%;7")5$"%&>">713*)("25'>&%1%>D"&A)&"H)5&>"

&'">B%(%&3)*%I7"&A7"D)&7(%)*>"9:"HA%1A"H7N")>"D)&7(%)*"97%5=>N"1'5>&(31&"


13/15

KSK

D7)5%5=" ;'(" '3(>7*T7>N" &3(5%5=" &A7D" %5&'" D7(7" >:D9'*>." GA7(7" %>"

)5" )*D'>&" 7B71&)>&%1" %DB*%1)&%'5" %5" C1AD7D)55]>" *%&3(=%'*'=:N" &A)&"

(71'51%*7>"&A7"'&A7(H%>7"$%>B)()&7"D7&)BA'(>"';"*%57)(%&:")5$"1%(13*)(%&:N"

UHPLQLVFHQWRIWKHQHYHUFRPSOHWHG\HWLQQLWHO\VDWLVI\LQJMRXUQH\LQWR

WKHLQQLWH*RGRQHQGVLQ*UHJRU\RI1\VVDVWKHRORJ\KL"c'("c)&A7("C1AD7D)55"&A7"#31A)(%>&%1"j&'")5$";('k"&A)&"1A)()1&7(%I7>"E(&A'$'F"

*%&3(=%1)*" *%;7" *7)$>" 3>" 7T7(D'(7" %5&'" &A7"e%5=$'D"';" 2'$" 971)3>7"

HA75"H7"(717%T7"&A7"#31A)(%>&N"4%>>"&A7"1A)*%17N")5$">&7B")H):";('D"&A7"

SULHVWZHKDYHDOUHDG\LQVWHSSLQJDZD\WDNHQRXUUVWVWHSEDFNWR

&A7"#31A)(%>&")=)%5b"H7"A)T7"97=35"'3("i'3(57:"9)14"%5&'"1'DD35%'5"

H%&A"7)1A"'&A7(."GA7"1A3(1A"$'7>"5'&"*7)$"3>"%5&'")5")*&7(5)&7"(7)*%&:"

&A)&"D)=%1)**:")BB7)(>"%5"&A7"#31A)(%>&N"93&"1)**>")"57H"H'(*$"'($7("

WRKDSSHQLQWKHPLGVWRIXVE\SUHVHQWLQJKLPZKRLVWKHIXOOOPHQW

';" &A)&"e%5=$'D"%5" &A7"#31A)(%>&")>" 3>N" &A7"9'$:"';"&."jGA3>k"

C1AD7D)55">):>N"j&A7"4%5=$'D"';"2'$"%>"&A7"1'5&75&"';"&A7"&%)5"

;)%&AN"&A7"=')*N"&A7"D7)5%5=")5$"&A7"1'5&75&"';"&A7"&%)5"*%;7.kK!"GA7"

e%5=$'D"971'D7>"&A)&"=')*N"D7)5%5=N")5$"1'5&75&"%5)>D31A")>"H7")(7"

(7'($7(7$N"5'&"9:"&A7"A3>&*7")5$"93>&*7"';"'3(";)>&?B)17$N"1'5>3D7(%>&"

>'1%7&:"[HA'>7"A3((%7$"B)17"';&75"477B>"3>"&''"$%>&()1&7$"&'"1'5>%$7("

&A7"577$>"';"%&>"T%1&%D>\"93&"9:"&A7"57H"71'5'D:"';"&A7"e%5=$'D"';"

2'$"B('*7B&%1)**:"%51)(5)&7"%5"'3("711*7>%)*"9'$:."

GA3>N"'(=)5%I%5=" *%;7" )('35$" &A7" #31A)(%>&" %>" )" i'3(57:" %5&'" &A7"

B(7>7517" ';" &A7" e%5=$'D" ';" 2'$" 5'&" '5*:" >:D9'*%1)**:" 93&" )*>'"

)1&3)**:N"971)3>7"%&"%>"'(=)5%I%5="*%;7")('35$"7)1A"'&A7(b"%&"%>")"i'3(57:"

%5&'"1'DD35%'5"H%&A"7)1A"'&A7(."GA'3=A"H7"E(&A'$'F"&75$"&'")$A7(7"

&'" )">75" 35$7(>&)5$%5=" ';" &A7" #31A)(%>&NKK" HA7(79:"

'3("%5$%T%$3)*"9'$%7>")(7"&()5>;'(D7$")11'($%5="&'"&A7"57H"B('&'&:B7"

KL""C77"2(7='(:"Q:>>75N"/,&(:%%1>"

';"d7>&7(5"CB%(%&3)*%&:[Q7H"R'(4,"6)3*%>&N"!XSY\N"B)(."K!X?ZZ.

K!""/*7F)5$7("C1AD7D)55N"/,&(S#4,5+%'"L(!54+5@&)"(-.N"6)3*"e)1A3([&H''$N"

QR,"C&"V*)$%D%(]>N"!XYS\N"PL.

KK""2(7='(:"Q:>>75N"j/5"/$$(7>>>"'5"_7*%=%'3>"M5>&(31&%'5Nk"%5(A,+%'"-0-12(-B7*"/11'($%5="&'"

-RKQ &DOYLQ &ROOHJH KWWSZZZFFHORUJFFHOSHDUVHPRUHIDWKHUVOHVF\ULOBRQBMRKQBBERRN

A&D"[)117>>7$"!X"0)(1A"KL!L\."C77")*>'"N"!XXZ\N"!O!?OK.


14/15

KSO

';"&A7" (7>3((71&7$"&N" &A7"#31A)(%>&%1"&A7'*'=:"';"&A7" )$D%&&7$*:"

1'5&('T7(>%)*" C)%5&"/3=3>&%57" )113()&7*:" $7>1(%97>" '3(" &A7'*'=:" )>"

H7**."j+7"HA)&":'3"1)5">77"['5"&A7")*&)(\Nk"/3=3>&%57">)%$N"j)5$"(717%T7"

HA)&":'3")(7.kKO$XJXVWLQHLGHQWLHGWKH(XFKDULVWZLWKWKHRQHERG\RI

&A7"B7'B*7"(717%T%5=.KP"c'("9'&A"/3=3>&%57")5$"6)3*"&A7"#31A)(%>&"H)>"&A7">)1()D75&"';"&A7"35%&:"';"&A7"1A3(1A."M5"B)(&)4%5="';"&A7"#31A)(%>&%1"

9'$:"';"&N"&A7"CB%(%&"9:"HA'D"j&A7"*'T7"';"2'$"A)>"9775"B'3(7$"

'3&" %5" '3(" A7)(&>" [_'D" Z.Z\Nk" i'%5>" &A7" 711*7>%)*" 9'$:"';" &" &'"

&A7"A7)T75*:"9'$:"';"&"[%&>"`7)$N">7)&7$")&"&A7"(%=A&"A)5$"';"&A7"

c)&A7(\.KZ" M&" %>" 5'"$%;;7(75&"HA75"H7"E(&A'$'F"';;7(" &A7>7"=%;&>" j'5"

97A)*;"';")**")5$";'(")**.k"d7")(7"=%T%5="HA)&"H7"A)T7")5$"HA'"H7")(7"

&'"2'$N"5'&"%5$%T%$3)**:N"93&"1'(B'()&7*:N")5$"H7")(7"(717%T%5="j&A7>7"

A'*:"=%;&>k"9)14"&()5>;'(D7$N"%51*3$%5="3>."M5"(717%T%5="9)14"&A7>7"=%;&>"

ERWK WKH RIIHULQJVDQG WKH RQHVPDNLQJ WKH RIIHULQJVZKLFK E\

&A7"B'H7("';"&A7"`'*:"CB%(%&"1)**7$"$'H5"%5" &A7"7B%1*7>%>N"A)T7"9775"

&()5>;'(D7$"%5&'"&"A%D>7*;N"H7")(7"35%&7$"&'"2'$")5$"&'"7)1A"'&A7("

&A('3=A"&A7D."GA%>"B'%5&"';"T%7H"%>"5'&"5717>>)(%*:")&"'$$>"H%&A")"D'(7"

Q:>>)5")5$"77D%5="1'5&()$%1&%'5>N";'("%5"

9'&A"1)>7>"&A7(7"%>"&A7"'3&()=7'3>")5$"7T75">1)5$)*'3>"7FB71&)&%'5"&A)&"

%5"1'5>3D%5="H7"971'D7"HA)&"H7"1'5>3D7,"&A7"9'$:"';"&.

GA7"e%5=$'D"%>"&A7"1'5&75&"';"&A7"1A3(1A"971)3>7"H7"751'35&7("

%&" %5" &A)&" 9'$:." M;"H7" >:>&7D%1)**:" B(7>7(T7" &A7" 71'5'D%1"$%T%>%'5>"

&A)&" 1A)()1&7(%I7" &A%>" ;)**75" H'(*$N" H7" T%'*)&7" &A7" 1'DD35%'5" &A)&"

"%>"5'&"%5&75$7$"&'">3==7>&"&A)&"*''4%5="

&A('3=A"&A%>"j=*)>>"$)(4*:k"&A7"1A3(1A"1'3*$";3**:"(7)*%I7"&A7"e%5=$'D"

';" 2'$." GA'3=A" &A7" 1A3(1A"D):" i'3(57:" %5&'" &A7" $%D75>%'5" ';" &A7"

.LQJGRPLWLVDMRXUQH\RIWVDQGVWDUWV1RQHWKHOHVVWKLVUHFRJQLWLRQ

A)>"%DB*%1)&%'5>";'("A'H"H7"1'517%T7"';"'3("B()1&%17"';"&A7"#31A)(%>&"

KO""/3=3>&%57N"S''&)"%50(!&+@-)'N"7$."+'5%;)17"_)D>7:N"&()5>.N"#$D35$"E.6."`%**N"GA7"d'(4>"';"C)%5&"

/3=3>&%57,"/"G()5>*)&%'5";'("&A7"K!>&">N"KLLS\N"C7(D'5"KSK."

C77")*>'"KKXQ."

KP""dA:"A7"$%$"5'&"(7)1A"&A7">)D7"71'5'D%1"1'51*3>%'5")>"6)3*"%>">'D7&A%5="';")"D:>&7(:N"93&"1)5"

B('9)9*:"97")&&(%93&7$N")=)%5N"&'"&A7"&%D7>"%5"HA%1A"A7"H)>"*%T%5=.

KZ""-."6)&'3&"+3(5>N"jGA7"#31A)(%>&")>"&A7"c'35$)&%'5"';"&%)5"W5%&:"%5"Q'(&A"/;(%1)5"GA7'*'=:Nk"

8#1#'"%)%5)(!"#$%&'"OKN"5'."[KLL!\.


15/15

KSP

)5$"'3(" jH'(&A%57>>k" ['(" j35H'(&A%57>>k\" &'"(717%T7"%&."6)3*"$%$"5'&"

1'5$7D5" &A7" 7"D'>&"';"3>."`7"1'5$7D57$"&A7D";'(")1&%5=")>"%;"&A7"B''("

H7(7"5'&"&A7(7N";'("%=5'(%5="&A7D"1'DB*7&7*:N")5$"&A3>"75>3(%5="&A)&"&A7:"$%$"5'&"A)T7"HA)&"&A7:"577$7$."W5H'(&A:"&%5="

H%&A"&N":7&")**'H%5="'3(">%>&7("'("9('&A7("&'">&)(T7")&"A'D7."M;"'3("

>&7B")H):";('D"&A7"1A)*%17"%>"&A7"97=%55%5="';"'3("57F&">&7B"&'H)($"

%&N" &A75" '3(" B(7B)()&%'5" D3>&" %5T'*T7" 5'&" '5*:" HA)&" H7" $'" 97;'(7"

'" );&7(H)($>." +71)3>7" =''$" &A7'*'=:" %>" *%T7$"

WKHRORJ\OHWPHEULH\VSHDNLQSUDFWLFDOWHUPV(XFKDULVWLFZRUWKLQHVV

(7U3%(7>"'B75%5=" '3(" &)9*7>" &'" &A'>7"HA'" A)T7"5'&A%5=" =''$" &'"7)&."

+'&A")&"A'D7")5$")&"1A3(1A"&A7"#31A)(%>&"%>"5'&")"#31A)(%>&"%;"&A7"B''("

DUHQRWVSHFLFDOO\LQYLWHGWRVKDUHLQWKHDEXQGDQFHRIWKH.LQJGRP

B(7>75&")D'5="3>."#31A)(%>&%1"H'(&A%57>>")*>'"(7U3%(7>"H7"1'5;7>>"'3("

)B)&A:")5$"B():";'("$7*%T7()517";('D"%&N"&A)&"H7")>4"2'$"&'"D)47"3>">77"

&A7"B''(")D'5="3>")5$"&A75"&'")1&"3B'5"&A)&"(7T7*)&%'5."/5$"HA75"H7"

;)>&N"B7(A)B>"H7">A'3*$";)>&"%5"&A7"D'>&")51%75&"H):"(71'DD75$7$"9:"

&A7"B)>&'("';"`7(D)>NK^"HA7(79:"H7"&)47"HA)&"H7"H%**"5'&"7)&")5$">A)(7"

%&"H%&A"&A'>7"HA'";)>&"7T7(:"$):."GA3>N"HA75"%&"1'D7>"&'"#31A)(%>&%1"

H'(&A%57>>N"*7&"3>"A77$"&A7"B('BA7&"M>)%)A"[ZY.^?S\.

M>"&A%>"5'&"&A7";)>&"&A)&"M"A)T7"1A'>75,"

q&'">A)(7":'3("9(7)$"H%&A"&A7"A35=(:N"

/5$"&A)&":'3"9(%5="&'":'3("A'3>7"&A7"B''("HA'")(7"1)>&"'3&b"

dA75":'3">77"&A7"5)47$N"&A)&":'3"1'T7("A%DN"

$QGQRWKLGH\RXUVHOIIURP\RXURZQHVK"

#31A)(%>&%1"B(7B)()&%'5"%>"5'&">%DB*:")"57=)&%T7"$%>1%B*%57"HA7(79:"

H7"A7$=7"9)14"&A7"H'(*$"&'";'13>"'5"&."M&"%>")"B'>%&%T7"$%>1%B*%57"

&A)&"9(%5="3>"%5&'"751'35&7(>"H%&A"&"%5"&A7"*7)>&"';"&A7>7"9:")1&%T7*:"

$%>75;()51A%>%5="'3(>7*T7>"';"'3("'H5"7F17>>"%5"'($7("&'";)T'("&A'>7"

HA'D"&";)T'(>N")5$"&A3>"&'">A'H"&A)&"H7">&)5$"H%&A"&A'>7"HA'D"

&A7"=''$"57H>"';"&A7"e%5=$'D"';"2'$"%>")**")9'3&."

K^""C77"jGA7"6)>&'("';" 7(D)>Nk"%5"/,&(8)"&PB%4&)&(M5",&+'N"7$."/."_'97(&>")5$"-."@'5)*$>'5[/*9)5:N"

E_,"/2#C"C';&H)(7N"!XXY\N"C%D%*%&3$7"V.O.

Documents

Sophia Vol 2 Dunn